Transcript of Record — Minerals Separation North American Corp. v. Magma Copper Co.
Supreme Court brief1930
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Vol. I
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1929
No. 71
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION, PETITIONER,
vs.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED APRIL 23, 1929
CERTIORARI GRANTED MAY 20, 1929
(34,160)
(34,160)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1929
No. 71
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION, PETITIONER,
Vs.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT
INDEX
: Page
Record from the district court of the United States, district of
SED Sb 0s.4 0166 004 Leen seus eha rer saUheiseos pNSs bensen bee he een'ys 1
I, SN 6 ayes 000cv navies eve ses ry Pern 520068 2:
Ly 500 tssnedevesa reeves sab oseewe Kosnebeee be viene 5
PEE. secicaaisuade Pps ere aren er yee ery TT eT e sae 16
Order and stipulation re filing of supplemental and amended
IC. OoccGiesi ces tex ve esnebed soo see sbe ks uwae en 24
Supplemental and amended bill of complaint..........-.....06. 26
Answer to supplemental and amended bill of complaint........ 34
Notice, motion, and affidavits re order to inspect defendant’s
mil) at Superior, ATigonA........ccsccccccccccccessccccsoces 42
Order permitting plaintiff to inspect defendant’s mill at Superior,
Ns cise cee eNSshus.e Soba S88 kN MON) bees beekes <5 saaeeeS OF
Order granting leave to file defendant’s interrogatories........ 66
Defendant’s interrogatories and plaintiff’s answers and objec-
tons theretO.....ccccsecccccvcscscscece iiieeenns 4axENSSeR eae 67
Clerk’s docket entry re objections to defendant’s interrogatories. 88
Jupp & DETWEILER (INC.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., SEPTEMBER 20, 1929
INDEX.
Page
Defendant’s motion for further particulars and order thereon.. 89
Plaintiff’s bill of particulars..........-eeeeeeeeeerer eer reeeens 91
Defendant’s notice and motion to amend answer and order
EWETEON 2... cccccccctecccccscccccccccccssccessesessenescces 93
Plaintiff's notice limiting charge of infringement to claims 1 and
2 of patent -in suit...... Shove e Totes bebecdde we devedesensies 96
Notice whder ‘equity ‘Tile 58......... cece eee ee reece eee eee cee 97
Answer to notice under equity rule 58......- pew ide ba wueas eke 100
Stipulation re defendant’s mill operations.......+esceeeeeeeeee 108
Statement of evidence.....--eeeeeeeereceeeerrereseesresereces 107
Appearances of Counsel......-.-seeceesresereesereteretes 107
Motion to amend bill of complaint......--++++essseeeceres 107
Stipulation re copies of patents and publications.......... 109
Colloquy between court and COUNSEL]... cecccevererceccecs 110
Testimony of James Wilding.......-.+++-sseerreerrereres 113
Colloquy between court and COUNBE]. 0. ec ccccee rescence 164
Offers in EVidence.........eeeeerrecesereecreeeseescereres 170
Testimony of Arthur Fay Taggart.....--+-+++-+esseereeres 180
Ralph B. Yerxa.......eeeeeeeceeerersecceces 315
Levi B. Shipley.......---eeeserseeeerreceers 329
Raymond F. Bacon......-.+seeeresererereres 338
Henry W. Nichols.....---+++eeseeeeerereees 372
William S. StevensS.......+e-eeeeeeeeeseeeeee 375
George A. Chapman........-+++serereecreres 377
Arthur H. Higgins........--seeeeeesereeeees 395
‘Lawrence Langner.......-- aererre poe wa oe
Stipulation re New Zealand patent 19,633.....+++-+++e++s 419
Offers in evidence.......-+++se++> egy ere rere re TT ae 420
Testimony of Arthur H. Higgins cussed) cov eethe eee . =
Testimony of George A. Chapman oneniiel .. ina esaeess 551
Colloquy between court and coumsel.....-++++++> echeuwes, ie
Testimony of Arthur F. Taggart (recalled).....--- cvesweee 580
Ralph B. Yerxa (recalled) ....seeeeeeeeeeres 589
Arthur H. Higgins ‘sabia. ohkes ccsacces ae
Stipulation re testimony in prior litigation, etc....----- — —_
Offers in evidence......--eesserrrerrreers Sea neeawus cnc. Se
Colloquy between court ie counsel. ....++++ Seiseeeoe ee a ae
Stipulation re Roberts affidavit......--+++ rie e een eae 616
Opinion, Pedere, J..cccovsevserccorsnservovsrcccorssssonecsee® 617
Interlocutory decree.....-sseesseeeeee évasewes Pe ee 628
Notice of appeadl......scceeceeescecrercrrsceceeeeee® cave eae 630
Assignment of eFrors......-.sseerrererererersseee eee ee 631
Order fixing appeal bond......-+.ssserereeseereserserrsseeees 682
Bond on appeal......c..eeeeeeeeeececercere ERSTE eS Pee 632
Citation and service.........seeeeeeeeeereereeeeeeeeeeseess i oe
Order approving stipulated praecipe.....-..-++eo+eeeereseeeers 635
Stipulated preecipe for transcript of record.......eeseeeeees se OD
Stipulation as -to correctness Of record........sseeeerseereeees 637
Clérk’s certificate. ...... ccc cece cc ccc ccc ccrccccccccecscvensess 638
INDEX. lll
Page
Proceedings in the United States circuit court of appeals, first
SONG SNG5 aly 64s poiveretenncs Skvebo Ob visite CES bore 4S be % OO OoRie ers 639
Opinion, Bingham, J..... eer Tree RPWA Sunn SW Kae Ratue Pan oie ce 639
A. GER i sok be Noi s pasos Sb eobeescede We saeeseee pa see tee in CR
SD MN von nns sxsisiwbees vabbbeds davtessvrdeevieusscss cco, RR
Motion and order extending time, Supreme Court.................. 655
‘Order allowing certiorari..... eee EER dg eT TELE eee ee 659
Stipulation re transcript of record, Supreme Court................ 660
Plaintiff's Exhibits, district court of the United States............ 661
Re Ae OU BO, MND iis 6 cv a vanaan vs bueseevisuccevc, 663
6—Stipulation re statement of mill NS os. 0s kp wen dion es 667
7—Drawing of defendant’s Callow cell or Callow pneunatic
flotation apparatus...... eT RT ere eh ee eee §81
8—Picture of five-ton Callow pneumatic flotation set.......... 683
9—Drawing of five-ton Callow pneumatic flotation set........ 684
Statements re Exhibits 10 and 11........... Sewise sabeceaws - 685
12—Sectional views of pneumatic cell, plaintiff's Boston dem-
MIE Cre briei i bek ie Sse cbdednvnicnsueedce vest 687
13—Elevation of pneumatic cell, plaintiff's Boston demonstra-
RR SIN Venndesauactwritds cued Sev nhw ea Vadose sen esos 689
14—Plan of ball grinding mill classifier and two pneumatic
cells at plaintiff’s Boston demonstration 5s kick os 691
15—Manifest and packing list, Callow cells......... vee sepeeais 693
17—Roberts’ affidavit giving list of reagents used by American
licensees of Minerals Separation North American Corpo-
18—Roberts’ affidavit gives list of American licensees of
Minerals Separation North American Corporation........ 713
19-Roberts’ affidavit giving list of licensees and “tons of ore
SUMO. chou SeeGuave rans cess ews vok oe ol euesw seuss, 721
20—Roberts’ affidavit giving summaries of “tons of ore treated,” vs
“tons ef concentrates produced,” and “licensees reporting
OTN SO isi ie Soe eK incdsSveerecdecisieces TRH
102—Chart 6f velocity tests by Yerxa........... sicvovseresecce WET
103—Chart of velocity tests by Yerxa.............ccccceccceees 728
104—Certified copy file-wrapper and contents of patent in suit,
| ee eee eS Te ee eee 729
-05—Certified copy file-wrapper and contents of patent to John
Ss NOOO, ENOL sD Rrra so b8604 64 65 0 068s ve NGA OSS ie oe 757
106—Patent to John M. Callow, No. 1,124,856.............0000- 845
107—Patent to John M. Callow, No. 1,125,897, of January 19
Ee Re eee OPER ee Cer ee ee S49
108—Patent to John M. Callow, No. 1,141,377, of June 1, 1915.... 853
109—Patext to John M. Callow, No. 1,182,748, of May 9, 1916.... 860
110—Certified copy Canadian patent No. 160,689 to Metals Re-
covery Co., assignee of John M. Callow.................- 864
111—Patent to E. R. Gabbett, No. 444,345, of January 6, 1891.... 882
D—Pleadings, Minerals Separation, Ltd., against Miami Copper
Co., marked “Plaintiff's Exhibit D” for identification.... 887
lv INDEX.
Page
Defendant’s exhibits, district court of the United States............ 921
13—British patent 488 of 1860 to Haynes........ Sthesdivsa ss . &
14—German patent 42 of 1877 to Bessel Bros.....- ert rer 929
15—German patent 39,369 of 1886 to Bessel Bros............. 981
16—U. S. patent 348,157 to Everson.........sereeeereereceees 935
17—British patent 24,144 of 1892 to Sutton.....---+++++esee- . 988
18—British patent 427 of 1894 to Robson & Crowder. ......00. 40
19—British patent 2538 of 1895 to Robson & Crowder........ 944
20—U. S. patent 575,669 to Robson........+++++++ eT eT TT ET 947
21—U. S. patent 703,905 to Elmore....++++eessereereees ae 952
22—U. S. patent 776,145 to Potter......-seeerereeeerrrsreees 955
31—British patent 12,778 of 1902 to Froment......-.-+++++++: 959
32—British patent 26,295 of 1902 to Cattermole........-. imines TE
33—U. 8S. patent 768,259 to Cattermole......cccseeeeeeereneees 965
34—U. S. patent 763,260 to Cattermole..... er rreeyy rt” eee Tr 969
35—U. S. patent 777,273 to Cattermole.....--- re ee ees envs 973
36—British patent 17,109 of 1903 to Cattermore et al........-- 978
87—U. S. patent 777,274 to Cattermole et al........eeeee cree 982
38—U. S. patent 788,247 to Cattermole et al......eeeeeeeeeees 984
40—U. S. patent 793,808 to Suliman & Picard... cesccesesees 988
48—U. S. patent 826,411 to Elmore.....-++--++sserrrrererees 993
53—British patent 7803 of 1905 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot... 9%
54—U. S. patent 835,120 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot.......-.- 1002
65—New Zealand patent 19,633 of 1905 to Sulman, Picard &
Ballot .....00- (etpes vaneuee ese vevateswann pabiasere ess 1008
56—Pages 1815, 1817, 1824, and 1825 of supplement to The New
Zealand Gazette of July 27, 1905......--+- Saas ene vunes -- 1034
57—Title page and page 229, New Zealand Patent Office Jour-
nal, October 31, 1912..... ie kvceeeetewtensetasesses, Se
58—Title page and page 312, New Zealand Patent Office Jour-
nal, December 12, 1912.....+++++++ee+55 paee seeauee» wees 1040
59—U. S. patent 835,143 to Sulman......-++ Pro eer tT TTT ate 1042
60—U. S. patent 835,479 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot.....----- 1045
68—British patent 26,852 of 1908 to Minerals Separation, Ftd.. 1050
70—British patent 28,173 of 1908 to Sulman, Picard & Ballot.. 1058
71—U. S. patent 955,012 to Sulman...esccccccscccccsesescces 1058
72—File-wrapper and contents of U. S. patent 955,012 to
Sulman ...ccscecscccovcesscsovess ve wwe GuekSaeeees esos 1063
%5>—British patent 2359 of 1909 to Greenway, Sulman &
Higgins ......+eeeeeerrrs ete Renee Vea es ery ee
76—British patent 2359 of 1909 to Greenway, Sulman &
Higgins ....eeeeeeeeeees oawaeties <saees Lek ben seestnrres
77—Australian patent 13,947 of 1909 to Sulman, Greenway &
Higgins .....-- Gan Sb ais aes vores’ eo eLeebanaes®
78—The Mining Journal, May 11, 1907, page 623, The Vacuum
Process for Concentration of OreS....--+++eeeeerrereers 1095
79—The Engineering & Mining Journal, May 11, 1907, pages
908 and 909, Vacuum Flotation Process for Concentration. 1096
95—Taggart chart of soluvitities..........-++ pherke aie MbIes eS 1099
108—Miami sorting test blue print.........+eeeeeeeeees cae she:
1079
INDEX. v
Pa
109—Arrangement for sorting test M. S. machine.............. a0
220—-S0rting tents In Oallow Obl... sccsccccccscevcvcssnaccecs 1102
111—Sorting tests on M. S. machine........ beswuwryeskee sscoes Se
112—Chart of velocity tests by Yerxa.........ccccccsccccccccs 1104
CS te SUNOD BURN a.s 650s chess 5846 eee esas op beSe oA es 1105
115—Stevens reports...... nbeeeb sek Chiobhsee dhs hanethuesetnas 1106
120—Sulman and Picard, Higgins, etc., reports 1903-1905; Nutter
ie ana G er are eae PERS OS ODES ESOS SE 1185
123—Standard form of plaintiff's license................00000- 1208
Tab 4)... B.- DUCONE GEE Te CO TROOVOR so ve csc cower vccedesscccese 1219
126—U. S. patent 1,228,188 to Corliss....... 900046444605.0080005 12
127—-U. S. patnet 1,295,817 to Towne & Flinn............cceee. 1223
128—U. &. patent 1,820,886 to Callow.....ccrvcccvcccsccesseces 1231
129—License agreement, dated April 23, 1919, between Metals
Recovery Company and Magma Copper Company, involving
U. 6. patent to. Corian Wo. L2BR RGB i. cc ces sccscvsesuss 1238
130—License agreement, dated August 2, 1915, between Pacific
Metals Recovery Company and Magma Copper Co., involv-
ing U. S. patent of Callow, 1,329,335 (application, serial
rr rr rr rrr rrr Te Terri Tih tee Lhe 1241
131—License agreement, dated May 27, 1921, between Pneumatic
Process Flotation Company and Magma Copper Company,
involving U. S. patent to Towne & Flinn, No. 1,295,817.... 1246
132—File-wrapper and contents of U. 8. patent 1,099,699 to
GYECENWAY ..ccrrccccccccccvcvoees sees eee eben sha <tshanes 1249
Statements re Exhibits 141 and 142...... pvavbeueehedasbaessutens aan
144—(Copper) license agreement, Minerals Separation, Ltd., to
Inspiration Consolidated Copper Company, dated April 10,
BOER. Sa ksineees Sebebaectexees souanhees ss ebsbheceesuceee 1295
145—(Copper) license agreement, Minerals Separation, Ltd., to
‘Anaconda Copper Mining Company, dated February 1,
. Meee e res cebhee Soba bb eRe hee 64050050084005.66 eeseens 1305
146—Special (copper) agreement between “Minerals Separation,
Ltd., and Inspiration Consolidated Copper Company and
Anaconda Copper Mining Company, dated February 1,
| ere eT sennanie Ss KES UA ERAN ES TREATS ceeate 1317
147—Letter, Inspiration Company and Anaconda Company to
Minerals Separation North American Corporation, dated
April 10, 1917; accepted by Minerals Separation North
American Corporation April 10, 1917.........e+++eeeeee 1324
148—(Zinc) license, Minerals Separation North American Cvr-
poration to Anaconda Copper Mining Company, dated
February 14, 1918....... cee eieeeee Sesh eebeees cheese ses 13825
149—Special (zinc) agreement between Minerals Separation
North American Corporation and Anaconda Copper Min-
ing Company, dated February 14, 1918............. cases. De
150—(Copper) license, Minerals Separation North American
Corporation to Utah Copper Company, executed May 10,
ae OS OE SARMNTT 4B, BOOB. oss 5 cider siccves caatewah es 1339
vi INDEX
151—First special copper agreement between Minerals Separa-
tion North American Corporation and Butte & Superior,
Chino, Nevada, Ray, Shasta, and Utah Companies, exe- }
cuted May 10, 1922, as of January 1, 1922.............. 1347
152—Second special copper agreement between Minerals Sepa-
ration North American Corporation and Butte & Superior,
Chino, Nevada, Ray, Shasta, and Utah Companies, exe-
cuted May 10, 1922, as of January 1, 1922.............. 134
153—(Zine) license, Minerals Separation North American Corpo-
ration to Butte & Superior Mining Company, executed
May 10, 1922, as of January 1, 1922.....+...-0-+eeeeeees 1364
154—Special (zinc) agreement between Minerals Separation
North American Corporation and Butte & Superior Min-
ing Company and Shasta Zinc & Copper Company, exe-
cuted May 10, 1922, as of January 1, 1922...........++5.. 1372
155—(Copper) license, Minerals Separation North American
Corporation to Miami Copper Company, executed May 17,
1922, as of January 1, 1922......... eee eee ee eee eeeeeees 1378
156—First special copper agreement, Minerals Separation North
American Corporation to Miami and Tennessee Companies,
executed May 17, 1922, as of January 1, 1922............ 1386
157—Second special copper agreement between Minerals Sepa-
ration North American Corporation and Miami and Ten-
nessee Companies, executed May 17, 1922, as of January
| Oe |: eee et eee 1392
“A” for Iden.—British patent 27,749 of 1913 to Sulman (excluded
by district court)...... ntti eteaeiiaadl ethane antiaine 1404
“B” for Iden.—File-wrapper and contents of bent appli-
cation of Sulman, serial No. 872,470, filed November 16,
1914 (excluded by district court) .....-.e+eeeereeeereee - 140
Stipulation re exhibits, etc., district court of the United States... 1429
SOY ort
BOI? TB ema
1 Re BaF
A > | 7 1 CHARLES tealunc
VOLUME I.
ee
UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS |
FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT. |
OCTOBER TERM, 1927.
No. 2259.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY,
DEFENDANT, APPELLANT,
Vv.
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION,
PLAINTIFF, APPELLEE.
APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES ©
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MAINE,
FROM INTERLOCUTORY DECREE (PETERS, J.), APRIL 20, 1928. |
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.
VOLUME L
PLEADINGS AND EVIDENCE.
WILLIAM H. DAVIS,
Bee MERTON W. SAGE,
UY OF gR>~_ ALBERT S. WOODMAN,
eG, SEN, WOODMAN, WHITEHOUSE, SKELTON
& THOMPSON,
* 93
For Appellant.
en
Lo
HENRY D. WILLIAMS,
WILLIAM HOUSTON KENYON,
SIDNEY ST. F. THAXTER,
WILLIAMS, RICH & MORSE,
For Appellee.
:
es aammamemmeiaianeneaaas
UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIRST CIRCUIT.
No. 2259. October Term, 1927.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY,
Defendant-A ppellant,
v.
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION,
Plaintiff -A ppellee.
IN THE
District Court of the United States,
For tHe District or Mainz, SoutHern Division.
No. 800.
IN EQUITY.
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION
v.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY.
DOCKET ENTRIES
Jan. 9, 1920 Bill of Complaint filed.
oe) Appearance of Thaxter & Holt for complain-
ant filed.
“ 10, ‘* Subpeena issued returnable Jan. 30, 1921—
10 A. M. ;
— a Subpeena returned executed. Ent. and filing
ret.
“« 29, ‘* App. of Williamson, Burleigh & McLean as
attorneys for defendant filed.
“ 30, ‘* Stipulation extending time for filing answer
filed and allowed.
Mar. 22, “ App. of Woodman & Whitehouse for Magma
Copper Co. filed.
“ 24, ‘* ‘Time for filing answer extended thirty (30)
days. (See stipulation on file.)
__ ON eRe EEN a
46
30, 1921
29,
22, 1923
30,
“eé
6c“
. 28, 1922
ee
‘é
Docket Entries
. 30, 1920. Time for filimg answer extended further pe-
riod of thirty days. (See stipulation on
file.)
Defendant’s motion for bill of particulars
filed.
Stipulation extending time for filing defend-
ant’s answer filed.
Hearing extended to May 11th, 1920 (Tues-
day).
Hearing adjourned to May 26, 1920—9 :30
A. M. by stipulation (filing).
Stipulation extending time for hearing on
defendant’s motion for bill of particulars
adjourned to Friday, July 30; also time for
filing defendant’s answer extended, ete.
(See stipulation on file.)
Hearing Hale, J. on motion for bill of par-
ticulars.
Finding of Court filed.
Defendant’s answer filed.
Order for taking deposition de bene esse of
Leslie Bradford filed. (Hale, J.)
Deposition of Leslie Bradford, witness for
defendant, filed.
Defendant’s motion for leave to take deposi-
tion of Theodore J. Hoover and order
granting same allowed.
Supplemental and amended bill of complaint,
stipulation and order of Court filed.
Defendant’s answer to supplemental and
amended bill of complaint filed.
Hearing on defendant’s motion that case be
set for hearing ordered for March 30, ’23,
10 A. M.
Hearing Peters, J. on motion that case be set
for hearing. Hearing set for June 18, '23,
at 2 P. M. Bangor.
June
iti
“6
30,
16,
“ec
Docket Entries 3
1923. Plaintiff’s motion for leave to inspect and to
sé
‘cé
sé
sé
‘é
sé
sé
6e
take depositions filed.
Hearing on same. Motion granted as per
decree filed.
Stipulation cf agreement as to mill opera-
tions filed by W. & W.
Defendant’s Interrogatories filed with order
of Court regarding same.
Answers and Objections to Interrogatories
filed.
Stipulation re deposition de bene esse of
Theodore J. Hoover filed.
Upon oral presentation by counsel each and
every of plaintiffs’ objections to the inter-
rogatories was sustained, and exceptions
to defendant were allowed in each case.
Defendant’s motion for further particulars
and order, Peters, J., granting same filed.
Defendant’s motion for subpoena to Seth
Gregory and Arthur H. Higgins and order
thereon filed.
Subpoena issued in accordance with order of
Court.
Defendant’s motion for subpoena to Wm. 8.
Stevens and Levi B. Shipley and —
thereon filed.
Subpeena issued in accordance with disié of
Court.
Appearance of Wm. H. Davis for deft.
filed.
Appearance of John F. Neary for deft.
filed.
Appearance of Merton W. Sage for deft.
filed.
Subpena to Wm. S. Stevens returned exe-
cuted.
Subpoena to Seth Gregory returned executed.
4 Docket Entries
June 29, 1923. Subpoena to Arthur Howard Higgins re.
turned executed.
" at aca Stipulation as to introduction of translation
of German Patent filed.
«« 95, ‘© Hearing begun before Peters, J., at Bangor
per stipulation filed.
«6 «666 ~~ fearing continued from day to day to and
including Friday, July 6, 1923.
July 6, ‘‘ Arguments made by both sides. Hearing
closed.
«6 Qounsel to exchange briefs by Sept. 25,
1923.
«= )~©6 Reply briefs to be filed within two weeks
thereafter.
«90, ‘* Stipulation that hearing may be held in
Northern Division filed.
Aug. 3, ‘‘ Order, Peters, J. allowing exhibits to be
withdrawn from the files for the purpose
of having copies made for inclusion in the
printed case filed.
“< «¢ 66 ~~ Order granted upon express condition that
Clerk’s fees for supervision of printing
be paid.
Sept. 22, ‘‘ Stipulation that time be extended regarding
briefs filed.
Feb. 3, 1928. Opinion of the court (Peters, J.) filed. Copy
forwarded Commissioner of Patents.
Apr. 20, ‘‘ Interlocutory decree signed Peters, J. filed.
«66 6 66 Referred to Philip G. Clifford as master to
state the account, etc.
May 15, ‘* Order suspending proceedings before master
filed.
6 66 6 Notice of appeal, acknowledgment Qf serviee .
and order filed.
s¢ 66 66 Assignment of errors filed.
s¢ 66 = 6 Order fixing appeal bond.
“66 © &&@ ~ Gitation to Cireuit Court of Appeals return-
able June 14, 1928, with acknowledgment
of service filed.
May 16, ‘‘ _ Bond on appeal approved Peters, J.
Bill of Complaint 5
Jy roe District Court or tHE Unirep States For THE Dis-
Trict oF Maing, SourHERN Dtvision.
In Eguiry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation and
Minerals Separation, Limited,
Plaintiffs,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
BILL OF COMPLAINT.
The plaintiffs for their bill of complaint allege:
First—That the plaintiff Minerals Separation North
American Corporation is a corporation duly organized and
existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Mary-
land, having its principal office and place of business in the
City of Baltimore, State of Maryland; and that the plaintiff
Minerals Separation, Limited, is a corporation duly organized
and existing under and by virtue of the laws of Great Britain
and an inhabitant of Great Britain, having its principal office
in London, England; and that on information and belief the
defendant Magma Copper Company is a corporation duly
organized and existing under the laws of the State of Maine
and has a regular and established place of business in the City
of Augusta in the State of Maine.
Second.—That this suit is brought under the Patent Laws
of the United States for the infringement of United States
Letters Patent No. 835,120, issued November 6, 1906, and No.
962,678, issued June 28, 1910, both for improvements in ore
concentration.
Third.—That heretofore and before the thirtieth day of
April, 1909, Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirk-
—
6 Bill of Complaint
patrick-Picard and John Ballot, all of London, England, did
invent, and were the original, first and joint inventors of cer.
tain new and useful improvements in ore concentration fully
described in the letters patent hereinafter mentioned, which
invention had not been known or used in the United States
before their invention or discovery thereof, or patented or
described in any printed publication in any country before
their invention or discovery thereof or more than two years
prior to their application for Letters Patent of the United
States hereinafter mentioned, or in public use or on sale in
the United States for more than two years prior to their said
application, and had not been patented in any country foreign
to the United States on an application filed by them or their
legal representatives or assigns more than twelve months
prior to the filing of their said application for Letters Patent
of the United States, and had not been abandoned to the pub-
lic; that the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis
Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot, being as aforesaid the
joint inventors of the said invention, did on the twenty-ninth
day of May, 1905, make due and formal application to the
Commissioner of Patents of the United States for Letters
Patent of the United States therefor, in accordance with the
then existing laws of the United States, and duly complied in
all respects with the conditions and requirements of said laws;
and thereafter, after due proceedings had, on the sixth day
of November, 1906, Letters Patent of the United States num-
bered 835,120, all in due form of the law and bearing date the
day and year last aforesaid, were duly issued and delivered to |
the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpat-
rick-Picard and John Ballot, whereby there was secured to
them, their executors, administrators and assigns, for the term
of seventeen years from the sixth day of November, 1906, the
full and exclusive right of making, using and selling the said
improvements in ore concentration shown, described and
claimed in said letters patent, throughout the United States
and in the territories thereof, which letters patent are now of
record in the United States Patent Office, and which, or a duly
Ld
‘
Bill of Complaint
eertified copy thereof, the plaintiffs will produce as the Court
may direct.
Fourth—That on or about the seventh day of December,
1909, the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirk-
patrick-Picard and John Ballot, by an instrument in writing
duly executed and delivered by them and bearing date the last-
named day, assigned and transferred to the plaintiff, Minerals
Separation, Limited, all right, title and interest in and to the
said invention and Letters Patent No. 835,120, and that the
said instrument in writing was duly recorded in the Patent
Office of the United States on or about the twenty-eighth day
of August, 1911, all of which will more fully appear by the
said instrument in writing with the certificate of the Com-
missioner of Patents ready in court to be produced as the
Court may direct.
Fifth—That heretofore and before the thirtieth day of
April, 1909, Henry Livingstone Sulman, Henry Howard
Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins, all of London, Eng-
land, did invent, and were the original first and jeint inven-
tors of certain new and useful improvements in ore concen-
tration fully described in the letters patent hereinafter men-
tioned, which invention had not been known or used in the
United States before their invention or discovery thereof, or
patented or described in any printed publication in any coun-
try before their invention or discovery thereof or more than
two years prior to their application for Letters Patent of the
United States hereinafter mentioned, or in public use or on
sale in the United States for more than two years prior to
their said application, and had not been patented in any coun-
try foreign to the United States on an application filed by
them or their legal representatives or assigns more than
twelve months prior to the filing of their said application for
Letters Patent of the United States, and had not been aban-
doned to the public; that the said Henry Livingstone Sulman,
Henry Howard Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins, being
as aforesaid the joint inventors of the said invention, did on
—
8 Bill of Complaint
the thirtieth day of April, 1909, make due and formal applica.
tion to the Commissioner of Patents of the United States for
Letters Patent of the United States therefor, in accordance
with the then existing laws of the United States, and duly
complied in all respects with the conditions and requirements
of said laws; and thereafter, after due proceedings had, on
the twenty-eighth day of June, 1910, Letters Patent of the
United States numbered 962,678, all in due form of the law
and bearing date the day and year last aforesaid, were duly
issued and delivered to the said Henry Livingstone Sulman,
Henry Howard Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins,
whereby there was secured to them, their executors, admin-
istrators and assigns, for the term of seventeen years from
the twenty-eighth day of June, 1910, the full and exclusive
right of making, using and selling the said improvements in
ore concentration shown, described and claimed in said letters
patent, throughout the United States and in the territories
thereof, which letters patent are now of record in the United
States Patent Office, and which, or a duly certified copy
thereof, the plaintiffs will produce as the Court may direct.
Siath.—That the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Henry
Howard Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins, by an instru-
ment in writing duly made and executed, assigned and trans-
ferred to the plaintiff, Minerals Separation, Limited, all right,
title and interest in and to the said invention and Letters Pat-
ent No. 962,678, and that the said instrument in writing was
duly recorded in the Patent Office of the United States on or
about the twenty-eighth day of August, 1911, all of which will
more fully appear by the said instrument in writing with the
certificate of the Commissioner of Patents ready in Court to
be produced as the Court may direct.
Seventh—That by an instrument in writing dated the
eighth day of July, 1913, which, or a duly certified copy
thereof, the plaintiffs will produce as the Court may direct,
Minerals Separation, Limited, plaintiff, entered into an agree-
ment of sale and purchase with Minerals Separation Ameri-
Bill of Complaint 9
can Syndicate (1913), Limited, a corporation duly organized
and existing under and by virtue of the laws of Great Britain,
by which Minerals Separation, Limited, agreed to sell and
Minerals Separation American Syndicate (1913), Limited,
agreed to purchase (along with other things) the entire bene-
ficial interest in the said Letters Patent Nos. 835,120 and
962,678, the purchase to be completed on or before the tenth
day of October, 1913: that by mutual arrangement the com-
pletion of the purchase by the assignment of the said Letters
Patent Nos. 835,120 and 962,678 (and others) was deferred
pending the litigation against James M. Hyde, hereinafter
referred to, and other litigation; that by mutual arrange-
ment the completion of the payment of the full consideration
to Minerals Separation, Limited, plaintiff, was deferred until
on or about the sixth day of October, 1916, and thereupon the
entire beneficial interest in said Letters Patent Nos. 835,120
and 962,678 vested in said Minerals Separation American
Syndicate (1913), Limited; that by an instrument in writing
dated the seventh day of December, 1916 (which or a duly
certified copy thereof the plaintiffs will produce as the Court
may direct), Minerals Separation American Syndicate (1913),
Limited, sold, assigned and transferred to Minerals Separa-
tion North American Corporation, plaintiff, all the right, title
and interest in and to said Letters Patent Nos. 835,120 and
962,678 to which it then was, or might thereafter become,
entitled, and all moneys due or to grow due, royalties due or
to grow due, claims and demands and things in action, of Min-
erals Separation American Syndicate (1913), Limited; that
by virtue of the premises the plaintiffs became and now are
the sole owners of said Letters Patent Nos. 835,120 and 962,-
678 and of all of the claims and demands and rights of action
for profits and damages for infringements of said Letters
Patent from the tenth day of October, 1913.
Eighth.—That the said inventions described in said Let-
ters Patent Nos. 835,120 and 962,678 are capable of conjoint
use and have been so used by plaintiffs and their licensees
and have been so used by defendant; and that the said inven-
10 Bill of Complaint
tions are of great value and utility to plaintiffs and to the
public generally and that the plaintiffs have made the said
inventions profitable to themselves and to the public by care-
ful and elaborate tests of said inventions in their application
to a wide variety of ores and by the extensive commercial use
of the said inventions by plaintiffs and their licensees in dif-
ferent parts of the world, including the United States, Austra-
lia, South America, Europe, Africa and Canada; and that the
plaintiffs have granted numerous licenses in the United States
and elsewhere for carrying on the process of ore concentra-
tion constituting such inventions; and that the plaintiffs are
able and willing to supply the entire demand for the use of
said inventions throughout the United States particularly by
granting licenses for the use of same conditioned under pay-
ment of royalties measured by the output of said processes of
concentration and that the plaintiffs will realize and receive
large gains and profits from the said inventions if infringe-
ment by defendant and its confederates shall be prevented.
Ninth.—That in the suit of Minerals Separation, Limited,
and another, against James M. Hyde, for infringement of
said Letters Patent No. 835,120 brought in the District Court
of the United States for the District of Montana on or about
October 9, 1911, and terminated by a mandate of the
Supreme Court of the United States issued on the thirteenth
day of January, 1917, and final decree on mandate entered on
the sixteenth day of April, 1917, claims 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 and 12
of said Letters Patent No. 835,120 were held valid and
infringed and claims 9, 10 and 11 invalid, as appears by the
opinion and mandate of the Supreme Court filed in that case
and final decree of the District Court entered thereon, certi-
fied copies of which are ready to be produced as the Court may
direct.
Tenth—That on the twenty-eighth day of March, 1917,
Minerals Separation, Limited, plaintiff, as the sole assignee,
at law, of the psientees of said Letters Patent » 0. 835,120 for
the whole of the United States and the territories and pos-
sessions thereof, in view of the aforesaid decision and man-
date of the Supreme Court of the United States and under
and pursuant to the laws for such cases made and provided
and without unreasonable neglect or delay, entered its dis-
daimer to so much of the thing patented by claims 9, 10 and
Il of said Letters Patent No. 835,120 as it did not choose to
hold or claim by virtue of said letters patent, all as appears
- by said disclaimer, a certified copy of which is ready here in
court to be produced as the Court may direct; that the proe-
esses recited in claims 9, 10 and 11 of said Letters Patent No.
835,120 as limited by said disclaimer were new and original
inventions of the patentees thereof and a material and sub-
stantial part of the thing patented and definitely distinguish-
able from the parts claimed without right, and that said claims
9,10 and 11 of said Letters Patent No. 835,120 as limited by
said disclaimer are good and valid in law.
Eleventh.—That in the suit of Minerals Separation, Lim-
ited, and Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
plaintiffs, and another, against Butte & Superior Mining Com-
pany, designated as Butte & Superior Copper Company, Lim-
ited, brought in the District Court of the United States of the
District of Montana, on or about October 10, 1913, and ter-
minated as to the merits by a mandate of the Supreme Court
of the United States issued on the twenty-fifth day of J une,
1919, and interlocutory decree of the District Court on said
mandate entered on the nineteenth day of July, 1919, claims
l, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 and 12 of said Letters Patent No. 835,120 and
aims 9, 10 and 11 thereof as limited by the aforesaid dis-
‘laimer were held good and valid in law and infringed, as
ippears by the opinion and mandate of the Supreme Court
iled in that case and the interlocutory decree of the District
ourt entered on said mandate and the opinion of the District
ourt on the settlement of said interlocutory decree, certified
opies of which are ready to be produced as the Court may
irect.
Twelfth.—That in the suit of Minerals Separation, Lim-
ed, plaintiff, against Miami Copper Company, for infringe-
Bill of Complaint 11
—
12 Bill of Complaint
ment of Letters Patent Nos. 835,120 and 962,678 and another
letters patent, brought in the District Court of the United
States for the District of Delaware on or about October 10,
1914, and terminated as to the merits by mandates of the
United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
issued on the twenty-seventh day of August, 1917, and inter-
locutory decree of the District Court on said mandates entered
on the eighth day of September, 1917, claims 1 and 12 of said
Letters Patent No. 835,120 and claims 1, 2, 5 and 6 of said
Letters Patent No. 962,678 were held valid and infringed, as
appears by the opinion and mandates of the United States
Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, filed in that
case, and interlocutory decree of the District Court entered
thereon, certified copies of which are ready to be produced as
the Court may direct.
|
Thirteenth—That defendant, well knowing the premises
and the rights secured to the plaintiffs as aforesaid and con-
triving to injure the plaintiffs and to deprive them of the
benefits and advantages from said inventions and letters pat-
ent, did, after the respective dates of the issuance of said let-
ters patent and before commencement of this suit and within
six years prior to commencement of this suit, as the plaintiffs
are informed and believe, without the license or allowance and
against the will of the plaintiffs, and in violation of their
rights and in infringement of the aforesaid Letters Patent
Nos. 835,120 and 962,678 unlawfully and wrongfully in Pinall
County, in the State of Arizona, and elsewhere in the United
States of America, install apparatus for and carry on the use
of the said processes of ore concentration as described in the
specifications and pointed out and claimed in claims 1, 2, 3 and
12 of the aforesaid Letters Patent No. 835,120 and in claims
9, 10 and 11 of said Letters Patent No. 835,120 as limited by
the aforesaid disclaimer, and in claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6,7 and 8
of the aforesaid Letters Patent No. 962,678, and in such
infringement did during certain periods conjointly use in one
process both of said inventions, and during certain other
periods did separately use the invention of said Letters Pat-
ent No. 962,678, all in infringement of the plaintiffs’ rights
Bill of Complaint 13
mder the said letters patent, whereby plaintiffs have been
and still are being greatly damaged and deprived of gains and
profits that they might and otherwise would have obtained
and which have been realized and enjoyed by the said defen-
dant by and through the aforesaid unlawful acts and doings.
Fourteenth—On information and belief, that the said
defendant has made and received profits and advantages from
the infringement of said letters patent as aforesaid, but to
what extent and how much exactly plaintiffs do not know and
pray a discovery thereof.
Fifteenth—That the installation and use of said inven-
tions by the said defendant and its other unlawful acts in dis-
regard and in defiance of the rights of the plaintiffs have the
effect of aiding, encouraging and inducing others so to ven-
ture to infringe said letters patent in disregard of the plain-
tiffs’ rights.
Sixteenth—That the defendant has been repeatedly duly
notified of infringement of said Letters Patent Nos. 835,120
and 962,678, and that such notice was orally repeated and con-
versations entered into relative thereto shortly prior to the
commencement of this suit, and further that defendant has
been fully informed of the rights of plaintiffs in the premises,
not only by reason of the great publicity given to the plain-
tiffs’ rights and the litigations thereon and the general knowl-
edge of the granting of licenses in the United States under
said letters patent, but also by reason of the installation and
extensive use of the said inventions under license in mines
and in places accessible to the defendant and its representa-
tives and with the full knowledge of defendant which has in
fact copied the procedure thus carried on by licensees of the
plaintiffs.
And inasmuch as the plaintiffs cannot have adequate
relief except in this Court and to the end that the defendant
may, if it can, show cause why plaintiffs should not have the
relief herein prayed for and may, but not upon oath (an oath
a. Bil of Complaint
to defendant’s answer being hereby waived) according to its
best knowledge, remembrance, information and belief, full,
true, direct and perfect answer make to all and singular the
premises, and that the said defendant may be compelled to
account for and pay to the plaintiffs the profits thus unlayw-
fully derived or which might have been derived from the vio-
lation of the rights of the plaintiffs aforesaid as well as the
damages therefor, and be restrained from any further viola-
tion of said rights, the plaintiffs pray that your Honors may
grant a writ of injunction restraining defendant, its officers,
associates, servants, agents, attorneys, clerks and workmen
and every person acting for or on behalf of said defendant,
from any installation or use in any manner of the said pat-
ented inventions, or any part thereof, in violation of the
rights of plaintiffs as aforesaid, and from otherwise infring-
ing in any manner directly or indirectly upon the rights of
the plaintiffs aforesaid; and also that your Honors, upon the
entering of a decree for infringement, as above prayed for,
may proceed to assess or cause to be assessed under your
Honors’ direction in addition to the gains and profits to be
accounted for by the defendant, the damages plaintiffs have
sustained by reason of said infringement.
And the plaintiffs pray also for a provisional or prelim-
inary injunction during the pendency of this suit to the same
purport and effect as hereinbefore prayed for in regard to a
perpetual injunction and that the defendant may be decreed
to pay the costs of this suit; and for such further and other
relief as the equity of the case may require and as to your
Honors may seem meet.
May it please your Honors to grant to the plaintiffs a
writ of injunction conformable to the prayer of this bill and
also a writ of subpoena issuing out of and under the seal of
this Honorable Court directed to said defendant, Magma Cop-
per Company, commanding it by a certain day and under a
certain penalty to appear before this Honorable Court, then
and there to answer the plaintiffs and to abide by and per-
Bill of Complaint 15
form such orders and decrees in the premises as to the Court
shall seem meet and be required by the principles of equity
and good conscience.
And the plaintiffs will ever pray, etc.
MINERALS SEPARATION, LIMITED,
By Joun Battor,
Director.
Henry D. Wiis,
Wa. Houston Kenyon,
Lrnviey M. Garrison,
Of Counsel for Plaintiffs.
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN
CORPORATION,
By Joun Batxor,
President.
Solicitor and of Counsel for Plaintiffs.
Stare or New York,
Unrren States or America,
8s
County or New York,
Joun Baxxor, being duly sworn, deposes and says that
he is the President of Minerals Separation North American
Corporation, and a director of Minerals Separation, Limited,
the plaintiffs named in the foregoing bill of complaint, that
he has read the same and knows the contents thereof, and that
the same is true of his own knowledge exvept as to matters
therein alleged to be stated on information and belief and as
to those matters he believes it to be true.
JOHN BALLOT.
Sworn to and subscribed before me this eighth day of
January, 1920.
Harry C. Lewis,
Notary Public, N. Y. County No. 281.
ay
16 Defendant’s Answer
In tHE District Court oF THE Unitep States District op
Marne, SoutHern Drvision.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation and
Minerals Separation, Limited,
Plaintiffs,
Vv.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
In Equity on Lerrers Patent Nos. 835,120 anv 962,678,
DEFENDANT’S ANSWER.
The Magma Copper Company for answer to the plain-
tiffs’ bill of complaint says:
I. The defendant is a corporation organized under the
laws of the State of Maine and has its principal legal office in
Augusta, Maine; the defendant is not informed and therefore
deuies that the plaintiff Minerals Separation North American
Corporation is a corporation organized or existing under the
laws of the State of Maryland, or has its principal office or
place of business in Baltimore, Maryland; and that the plain-
tiff Minerals Separation, Limited, is a corporation organized
or existing under the laws of Great Britain, or is an inhabitant
of Great Britain, or has its principal office in London, Eng-
land, and leaves the plaintiffs to make such proof thereof as
they may be advised.
II. The defendant admits that Letters Patent of the
United States No. 835,120 were issued on November 6, 1906, to
Henry Livingston Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard
and John Ballot, but on information and belief, the defendant
denies that before the thirtieth day of April, 1909, (as alleged
in the bill of complaint) and that before the twenty-ninth day
Defendant’s Answer 17
of May, 1905, or at any other time, Henry Livingstone Sul-
man, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot did
invent or were the original or first or joint inventors of new
and useful improvements in ore concentration described in
said letters patent; and on information and belief, the defend-
ant denies all the other allegations of the third paragraph of
the bill of complaint.
Ill. As to the matters and things alleged in the fourth
paragraph of the bill of complaint, the defendant is not in-
formed, and, therefore, denies the same, demands the pro-
duction at or before the trial ofthe instruments in writing
referred to, and leaves the plaintiffs to make such proof
of said allegations as they may be advised.
IV. The defendant admits that Letters Patent of the
United States No. 962,678 were issued on June 28, 1910, to
Henry Livingston Sulman, Henry Howard Greenway and
Arthur Howard Higgins; but on information and belief, the
defendant denies all the other allegations of the fifth para-
graph of the bill of complaint.
V. As to the matters and things alleged in the sixth and
seventh paragraphs of the bill of complaint, the defendant
is not informed and therefore denies the same, demands the
production at or before the trial of the instruments in writing
referred to, and leaves the plaintiffs to make such proof of
said allegations as they may be advised.
VI. The defendant denies that it has ever used, either
separately or conjointly, the alleged inventions described in
the Letters Patent No. 835,120 and No. 962,678, or either of
them; it admits the value and utility of the alleged invention
described in the said Letters Patent No. 835,120, but it denies
that the alleged invention described in the said Letters Patent
No. 962,678 has any value or utility whatever, the defendant,
not having used either of said inventions, either singly or
conjointly, is not informed as to whether they are capable
of conjoint use and therefore denies that allegation and leaves
—
18 Defendant’s Answer
the plaintiffs to make such proof thereof as they may be
advised, and denies that the plaintiffs have made the alleged
inventions profitable to themselves and to the public by care.
ful and elaborate tests of said alleged inventions in their
application to a wide variety of ores, but, on the contrary, the
defendant alleges that accredited representatives and agents
of the plaintiff, Minerals Separation, Limited, did, on various
occasions, orally and in writing, assert that said inventions
could not be adapted to the ores such as defendant’s ore; and
the defendant is not informed whether the plaintiffs are able
or willing to supply the entire demand for the use of said
alleged inventions throughout the United States, by granting
licenses or otherwise, and it, therefore, denies that allegation
and leaves the plaintiffs to make such proof thereof as they
may be advised, but the defendant denies that plaintiffs are
ready and willing to grant licenses for the use of said alleged
inventions conditioned only upon the payment of royalties
measured by the output of said processes of concentration,
but, on the contrary, avers that the plaintiffs insist upon
restrictive terms and conditions of license which have nothing
to do with the processes of concentration described in the
said patents, which are grossly unfair, and which unlawfully
restrict the commercial freedom of their licensees; and the
defendant further denies that the prevention or continuation
of any act of its will in anywise affect the realization or re-
ceipt of large or any gains or profits from the said inventions
by the plaintiffs.
VII. The defendant is familiar with the published deci-
sions of the Supreme Court in the suit of Minerals Separa-
tion, Limited, and another, against Hyde, and in the suit of
Minerals Separation, Limited, and Minerals Separation North
American Corporation, and another, against Butte & Supe
rior Mining Company, and with the published decision of the ©
Cireuit Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit in the suit of -
Minerals Separation, Limited, against Miami Copper Com-
pany referred to in the ninth, eleventh and twelfth para-
graphs of the bill of complaint, and it admits the existence |
of those suits and that those decisions have been rendered,
Defendant’s Answer 19
and it accepts the decisions of the Supreme Court in the Hyde
ease and the Butte case as authoritative adjudications of the
validity and scope of the agitation froth flotation process
Patent No. 835,120, but it avers that by the force of those
decisions, and by the proceedings conducted on behalf of the
applicants for the said patent in the Patent Office, the plain-
tiffs are estopped to ask for any interpretation of the claims
of said patent or any of them sufficiently broad to include
the pneumatic flotation process used by the defendant, and it
further avers that any such broad interpretation of the claims
of the said patent would render the said claims invalid and
void in view of the prior art which this defendant is ready
to aver, maintain and prove, and the defendant does not accept
as authoritative or binding upon this Court the decision of
the Cireuit Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit in the
Miami case, and particularly with respect to the soluble
frothing agent Patent No. 962,678; the defendant controverts
the decision and avers that the said patent is wholly invalid
and void.
With respect to the allegations of the tenth paragraph
of the bill of complaint, the defendant admits that the plain-
tiffs, Minerals Separation, Limited, filed a paper in the Patent
Office which was called a disclaimer with respect to claims
9,10 and 11 of said Patent No. 835,120, but it avers that
the said alleged disclaimer was not a disclaimer in law or
in fact within the provisions of the statutes in such cases
made and provided, and it avers that the plaintiffs have un-
reasonably neglected and delayed to enter a proper disclaimer
with respect to those claims.
VII. The defendant denies that in Pinall County, in
the State of Arizona, or anywhere else in the United States of
America, it has ever installed apparatus for or carried on the
use of the processes of ore concentration described in the
specifications and pointed out and claimed in claims 423
and 12 of Letters Patent No. 835,120 and in claims 9, 10 and
11 of said patent as limited by the aforesaid alleged dis-
claimer, or in claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the aforesaid
a
20 Defendant’s Answer
Letters Patent No. 962,678, or any of those claims, or of any
part of said processes, either separately or conjointly, but,
on the contrary, it avers that the pneumatic flotation process
employed by it is a process protected by United States Letters
Patent under which the defendant is licensed, which process
is entirely different and distinct from any invention described
or claimed in either of plaintiffs’ patents, No. 835,120 or No.
962,678, and it denies all the other allegations of the thir-
teenth, fourteenth and fifteenth paragraphs of the said bill
of complaint.
IX. The defendant denies that it has been duly notified
of the infringement of said letters patent or either of them
in accordance with the requirements of the revised statutes
of the United States; it has no knowledge of the character
or substance of the alleged oral notice or conversations re-
ferred to in the sixteenth paragraph of the bill of complaint,
and therefore denies the same and leaves the plaintiffs to
make such proof thereof as they may be advised, and it denies
that it is informed of any rights of the plaintiffs, as referred
to in the sixteenth paragraph of the bill of complaint, by
reason of publicity given to the plaintiffs’ alleged rights, or
the alleged litigation thereof, or by the alleged general knowl-
edge of the granting of licenses in the United States under
‘the said letters patent, or by the installation or extensive use
of the alleged inventions under license in mines or places
alleged to be accessible to the defendant or its representatives,
and it denies that it has copied any procedure carried on by
licensees of the plaintiffs.
X. Defendant further answering, on information and
belief, avers that the said Patent No. 962,678 is invalid and
void and of no foree and effect for the following reasons; to
wit,
(a) That the patentees, Sulman, Greenway and Hig-
gins, were not the original and first inventors or discov-
erers of that which is patented by said letters patent,
or any material or substantial part thereof, but that, on
the contrary, prior to the alleged invention or discovery
Defendant’s Answer 21
of said patentees, the things patented by said patent
and all material and substantial parts thereof have been,
1. Patented and published in each of the following
letters patent:
Unrtep States Patents.
No. Date Patentee
703,905 July 1, 1902 Elmore
735,071 Aug. 4, 1903 Delprat
763,260 June 21, 1904 Cattermole
768,035 Aug. 23, 1904 Delprat
776,145 Nov. 29, 1904 Potter
177,273 Dec. 13, 1904 Cattermole
777,274 Dec. 13, 1904 Cattermole
788,247 Apr. 25, 1905 Cattermole, Sulman & Picard
793,808 July 4, 1905 Sulman & Picard
805,382 Nov. 21, 1905 Sanders
826,411 July 17, 1906 Elmore
835,120 Nov. 6, 1906 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
879,985 Feb. 25, 1908 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
British Patents
17109 of 1903 Cattermole
19783 of 1903 Delprat
27132 of 1903 Delprat
17816 of 1904 Elmore
5953 of 1905 Elmore
7803 of 1905 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
15119 of 1905 MacQuisten
26264 of 1908 Lockwood & Samuel
AvusTRALIAN Patents
1935 of 1904 Elmore ;
German PatTENTS
42 of 1877 Bessel
39369 of 1887 Bessel
Also patented or described and contained in other letters
patent, the dates, numbers and grantees of which this defend-
—
22 Defendant’s Answer
ant is not now able to specify, but prays to be allowed here.
after to add by amendment to this answer, or otherwise,
2. Described in the following printed publications:
The Mining Journal (London), May 11, 1907, Page
623;
The Engineering and Mining Journal (New York
City), June 1, 1907, Page 1037;
The Engineer (London), May 10, 1907, Page 469.
Also illustrated or described in other printed publica-
tions, the names and dates of which this defendant is not
now able to specify but prays to be allowed hereafter to add
by amendment to this answer, or otherwise.
3. Known to various persons, the names and addresses
of whom the defendant is not now able to give, but hopes to
be allowed hereafter to add by amendment to this answer.
(b) That the state of the art prior to the alleged
invention or discovery of the said Patent No. 962,678
was such that there was no patentable novelty in the
subject matter described in said patent and claimed in
claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 thereof, which state of the
art the defendant is ready to aver, maintain and prove.
(c) That the patentees Sulman, Greenway and Hig-
gins were not joint inventors of the subject matter al-
leged to be patented by said letters patent or any sub-
stantial or material part thereof.
(d) That the specifications and claims of the said
patent do not constitute a full, clear, concise or exact
description of the alleged invention or of the manner
or process of making, constructing, compounding or
using it in accordance with the statutes in such cases
made and provided, nor do they particularly point out
or distinctly claim the part, improvement or combination
which the inventors claim as their invention or discov-
ery; but on the contrary, said specification, as the de-
fendant avers, was deliberately, and for the purpose of
deceiving the Patent Office and the public, made to con-
tain less than a complete description of the invention
and the said claims for the same purpose were made
to claim more than had been invented by the said inven-
tors either jointly or severally.
Defendant’s Answer 23
XI. The defendant further avers, on information and
belief, that in view of the state of the art prior to the alleged
invention of the said Letters Patent No. 835,120 and No.
962,678 the claims thereof, regardless of their language, to be
sustained as valid must be so construed as not to cover any
rocess of ore concentration heretofore or now carried on by
the defendant.
XII. The defendant further avers, upon information and
belief, that by reason of the acts done by the applicants, the
plaintiffs are now estopped from alleging that the claims
of said Letters Patent No. 835,120 and No. 962,678 or any
of them, can be construed to cover any process of ore con-
centration practiced by the defendant.
XIII. The defendant further answering denies the equity
of the plaintiffs’ bill of complaint and avers that the plain-
tiffs are not entitled to an injunction nor to an account of
profits, nor to damages, nor to any royalty or recovery what-
soever against this defendant, as prayed in the said bill of
complaint.
All of which matters and things, this defendant is ready
to aver, maintain and prove as this Honorable Court shall
direct, and prays that the bill of complaint be dismissed,
and that the defendant shall recover its costs and disburse-
ments in this suit.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY,
(Seal) By (Signed) H. E. Dones,
Secretary.
(Signed) Jonn C. Penni,
(Signed) ‘Weopman & WHITEHOUSE,
Of Counsel.
24 Order
Ix tHe District Court or tHe Untirep States ror rap
District or Marne, Souruern Drvision.
In Egurry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation and Min-
erals Separation, Ltd.
Plaintiffs,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
ORDER.
Upon reading and filing tLe annexed stipulation and sup-
plemental and amended bill of complaint, it is hereby
Orpverep that the bill of complaint herein be dismissed
with respect to Letters Patent No. 835,120, without prejudice,
and that Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
plaintiff, have leave to file said supplemental and amended
bill of complaint, and that the entry and filing of this order
with annexed supplemental and amended bill of complaint
shall constitute the filing of said supplemental and amended
bill of complaint.
The parties having waived the issuance of a writ of sub-
poena the defendant is hereby ordered to file its answer or
other defense to the said supplemental and amended bill of
complaint on or before the twentieth day after filing thereof.
JOHN H. PETERS,
United States District Judge.
34
Stipulation 25
Ix tHe Disrricr Court or THE Unitep STaTES FOR THE
District or Marne, Sournern Drvision.
In Egurry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation and Min-
erals Separation, Ltd.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
STIPULATION.
Ir Is Heresy Strputatep anp Acreep by and between
counsel for the parties to the above-entitled suit that the
bill of complaint herein may be dismissed with respect to
Letters Patent No. 835,120, without prejudice, and that the
supplemental and amended bill of complaint hereto annexed
may be filed in this suit, and that an order in the form hereto
annexed may be entered without further notice to either
side.
Ir 1s Furtuer Sriputarep anp Acreep that the issu-
ance of a writ of subpoena upon the filing of such supple-
mental and amended bill be and the same hereby is waived
and that the defendant file its answer to such supplemental
and amended bill within twenty days from the date of filing
of such supplemental and amended bill.
HENRY D. WILLIAMS,
WM. H. KENYON,
LINDLEY M. GARRISON,
Counsel for Plaintiffs.
PENNIE, DAVIS MARVIN &
EDMONDS,
Counsel for Defendant.
26 Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complamt
In tHe District Court or tHe Unirep States For THe
District or Marne, SoutHern Drvision.
In Eguiry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
SUPPLEMENTAL AND AMENDED BILL OF
COMPLAINT.
Now comes Minerals Separation North American Cor-
poration, the plaintiff above named, and, with leave of
Court first had and received, files this, its supplemental and
amended bill of complaint and alleges by way of amend-
ment and supplement:
That heretofore, to wit, on the ninth day of January,
1920, Minerals Separation North American Corporation
and Minerals Separation, Limited, filed their bill of com-
plaint in this court, alleging the issuance and their owner-
ship of Letters Patent Nos. 835,120 and 962,678 and
infringement by the above-named defendant and praying
for an injunction and accounting of profits and damages;
and that the said defendant filed an answer thereto. Refer-
ence is here made to said bill and answer for a more com-
plete statement of the contents thereof. That thereafter,
pending trial of the issue thereby raised, Minerals Separa-
tion North American Corporation became vested with the
entire right, title and interest in and to the said letters
patent and in and to all right of action, claim and demand
for past infringement thereof, by virtue of an assignment
in writing from Minerals Separation, Limited, as herein-
after more fully recited, and that Minerals Separation,
Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint 27
Limited, thereupon and thereby became divested of all |
right, title and interest in and to the said letters patent
and in and to the cause of complaint herein.
Wuererore, the plaintiff, Minerals Separation North
American Corporation, now and hereby amends and sup-
plements the said bill of complaint filed on the ninth day
of January, 1920, to read as follows, and alleges:
First—That the plaintiff Minerals Separation North
American Corporation is a corporation duly organized and
existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of
Maryland having its principal office and place of business
in the City of Baltimore, State of Maryland; and that on
information and belief the defendant Magma Copper Com-
pany is a corporation duly organized and existing under the
laws of the State of Maine and has a regular and estab-
lished place of business in the City of Augusta in the State
of Maine.
Second.—That this suit is brought under the patent
laws of the United States for the infringement of United
States Letters Patent No. 962,678, issued June 28, 1910, for
improvements in ore concentration.
Third—That heretofore and before the thirtieth day
of April, 1909, Henry Livingstone Sulman, Henry Howard
Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins, all of London,
England, did invent, and were the original first and joint
inventors of, certain new and useful improvements in ore
concentration fully described in the letters patent herein-
after mentioned, which invention had not been known or
used in the United States before their invention or discov-
ery thereof, or patented or described in any printed pub-
lication in any country before their invention or discovery
thereof or more than two years prior to their application
for Letters Patent of the United States hereinafter men-
tioned, or in public use or on sale in the United States for
more than two years prior to their said application, and had
28 Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint
not been patented in any country foreign to the Uniteg
States on an application filed by them or their legal repre.
sentatives or assigns more than twelve months prior to the
filing of their said application for Letters Patent of the
United States, and had not been abandoned to the public;
that the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Henry Howard
Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins, being as aforesaid
the joint inventors of the said invention, did on the thirtieth
day of April, 1909, make due and formal application to the
Commissioner of Patents of the United States for Letters
Patent of the United States therefor, in accordance with
the then existing laws of the United States, and duly com.
plied in all respects with the conditions and requirements
of said laws; and thereafter, after due proceedings had, on
the twenty-eighth day of June, 1910, Letters Patent of the
United States numbered 962,678, all in due form of the law
and bearing date the day and year last aforesaid, were duly
issued and delivered to the said Henry Livingstone Sulman,
Henry Howard Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins,
whereby there was secured to them, their executors, admin-
istrators and assigns, for the term of seventeen years from
the twenty-eighth day of June, 1910, the full and exclusive
right of making, using and selling the said improvements
in ore concentration shown, described and claimed in said
letters patent, throughout the United States, and in the ter-
ritories thereof, which letters patent are now of record in
the United States Patent Office, and which, or a duly certi-
fied copy thereof, the plaintiff will produce as the Court
may direct.
Fourth—That the said Henry Livingstone Sulman,
Henry Howard Greenway and Arthur Howard Higgins, by
an instrument in writing duly made and executed, assigned
and transferred to Minerals Separation, Limited, all right,
title and interest in and to the said invention and Letters
Patent No. 962,678, and that the said instrument in writing
was duly recorded in the Patent Office of the United States
on or about the twenty-eighth day of August, 1911, all of
“ «
Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint 29
which will more fully appear by the said instrument in writ-
ing with the certificate of the Commissioner of Patents
ready in court to be produced as the Court may direct.
Fifth—That the said Minerals Separation, Limited, by
an instrument in writing executed and acknowledged on the
first day of June, 1922, duly sold, assigned and transferred
the whole right, title and interest, together with all right of
-action, claim and demand for past infringement in and to
said Patent No. 962,678, to the plaintiff Minerals Separa-
tion North American Corporation, arid the said instrument
in writing was duly recorded in the Patent Office of the
United States on or about the twenty-first day of June, 1922,
all of which will more fully appear by the said instrument
in writing with the certificate of the Commissioner of Pat-
ents ready in court to be produced as the Court may direct.
Sixth—That the said invention described in said Let-
ters Patent No. 962,678 is of great value and utility to plain-
tiff and to the public generally and that the plaintiff has
made the said invention profitable to itself and to the pub-
lic by careful and elaborate tests of said invention in
its application to a wide variety of ores and by the exten-
sive commercial use of the said invention by plaintiff and
its licensees and that the plaintiff has granted numerous
licenses in the United States and elsewhere for carrying on
the process of ore concentration constituting such inven-
tion; and that the plaintiff is able and willing to supply the
entire demand for the use of said invention throughout the
United States particularly by granting licenses for the use
of same conditioned under payment of royalties measured
by the output of said process of concentration, and that the
plaintiff will realize and receive large gains and profits
from the said invention if infringement by defendant and
its confederates shall be prevented.
Seventh—That in the suit of Minerals Separation,
Limited, plaintiff, against Miami Copper Company, for
infringement of Letters Patent No. 962,678 and two other
ay
30 Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint
letters patent, brought in the District Court of the United
States for the District of Delaware on or about October
10, 1914, and terminated as to the merits by mandates of
the United States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Third
Cireuit issued on the twenty-seventh day of August, 1917,
and interlocutory decree of the District Court on said man.
dates entered on the eighth day of September, 1917, claims |
1, 2, 5 and 6 of said Letters Patent No. 962,678 were held _
valid and infringed, as appears by the opinion and man.’
dates of the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Third Circuit, filed in that case, and interlocutory decree
of the District Court entered thereon, certified copies of
which are ready to be produced as the Court may direct.
Eighth.—That defendant, well knowing the premises and
the rights secured to the plaintiff as aforesaid and contriv-
ing to injure the plaintiff and to deprive it of the benefits
and advantages from said invention and letters patent, did,
after the date of the issuance of said letters patent and
before commencement of this suit and within six years prior
to commencement of this suit, as the plaintiff is informed
and believes, without the license or allowance and against
the will of the plaintiff, and in violation of its rights and
in infringement of the aforesaid Letters Patent No. 962,678,
unlawfully and wrongfully, in Pinall County in the State
of Arizona and elsewhere in the United States of America,
install apparatus for and carry on the use of the said
process of ore concentration as described in the specifica-
tion and pointed out and claimed in claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6,
7 and 8 of the aforesaid Letters Patent No. 962,678, and in
such infringement did use the invention of said Letters Pat-
ent No. 962,678, all in infringement of the plaintiff’s rights
under the said letters patent, whereby plaintiff has been
and still is being greatly damaged and deprived of gains
and profits that it might and otherwise would have obtained
and which have been realized and enjoyed by the said
defendant by and through the aforesaid unlawful acts and
doings.
Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint 31
Ninth.—On information and belief, that the said defend-
ant has made and received profits and advantages from the
infringement of said letters patent as aforesaid, but to what
extent and how much exactly plaintiff does not know and
prays a discovery thereof.
Tenth.—That the installation and use of said invention
by the said defendant and its other unlawful acts in disre-
gard and in defiance of the rights of the plaintiff have the
effect of aiding, encouraging and inducing others so to ven-
ture to infringe said letters patent in disregard of the
plaintiff’s rights
Eleventh.—That the defendant has been repeatedly duly
notified of infringement of said Letters Patent No. 962,678,
and that such notice was orally repeated and conversations
entered into relative thereto shortly prior to the commence-
ment of this suit, and further that defendant has been fully
informed of the rights of plaintiff in the premises, not only
by reason of the great publicity given to the plaintiff’s
rights and the litigations thereon and the general knowl-
edge of the granting of licenses in the United States under
said letters patent, but also by reason of the installation
and extensive use of the said invention under license in
mines and in places accessible to the defendant and its repre-
sentatives and with the full knowledge of defendant which
has in fact copied the procedure thus carried on by licensees
of the plaintiff. ;
AnD inasmuch as the plaintiff cannot have adequate
relief except in this Court and to the end that the defend-
ant may, if it can, show cause why plaintiff should not have
the relief herein prayed for and may, but not upon oath
(an oath to defendant’s answer being hereby waived)
according to its best knowledge, remembrance, informa-
tion and belief, full, true, direct and perfect answer make
to all and singular the premises, ahd that the said defend-
ant may be compelled to account for and pay to the plaintiff
the profits thus unlawfully derived or which might have
—
32 Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint
been derived from the violation of the rights of the plain.
tiff aforesaid as well as the damages therefor, and be
restrained from any further violation of said rights, the
plaintiff prays that your Honors may grant a writ of injunc-
tion restraining defendant, its officers, associates, servants,
agents, attorneys, clerks and workmen and every person
acting for or on behalf of said defendant, from any installa-
tion or use in any manner of the said patented invention, or
any part thereof, in violation of the rights of plaintiff as
aforesaid, and from otherwise infringing in any manner
directly or indirectly upon the rights of the plaintiff afore-
said; and also that your Honors, upon the entering of a
decree for infringement, as above prayed for, may proceed
to assess or cause to be assessed under your Honors direc-
tion in addition to the gains and profits to be accounted for
by the defendant, the damages plaintiff has sustained by
reason of said infringement.
Anp the plaintiff prays also for a provisional or pre-
liminary injunction during the pendency of this suit to the
same purport and effect as hereinbefore prayed for in
regard to a perpetual injunction and that the defendant may
be decreed to pay the costs of this suit; and for such further
and other relief as the equity of the case may require and as
to your Honors may seem meet.
Awnp the plaintiff will ever pray, ete.
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH
AMERICAN CORPORATION,
By Sera Grecory,
President.
Henry D. Wiis,
Won. Houston Kenyon,
Linptey M. Garrison,
of Counsel for Plaintiff.
Sipney Sr. F. THaxter,
Solicitor and of Counsel
for Plaintiff.
Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complamt 33
Srate oF New York,
Usrrep States or AMERICA,
$s
County or New York,
Seta Grecory being duly sworn deposes and says that
he is the President of Minerals Separation North American
Corporation, the plaintiff named in the foregoing bill of
complaint, that he has read the same and knows the con-
tents thereof, and that the same is true of his own knowl-
edge except as to matters therein alleged to be stated on
information and belief, and as to those matters he believes
it to be true.
Seto Grecory.
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 17th day of
July, 1922.
(Seal) F. L. Reqva,
Notary Public, N. Y. County, No. 298.
—
34 Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bil of Complaint
Iy tae Disraict Court or THE Unrrep StaTes For THE
District or Marnz, SourHern Drvisron.
In Equrry on Letrers Patent No. 962,678.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
I
‘DEFENDANT’S ANSWER TO SUPPLEMENTAL AND
AMENDED BILL OF COMPLAINT.
The Magma Copper Company for answer to the plain-
tiff’s supplemental and amended bill of complaint (herein.
after referred to as the bill of complaint) says:
As to the averments contained in the introductory para-
graph of the bill of complaint, the defendant admits that on
or about the ninth day of January, 1920, Minerals Separation
North American Corporation and Minerals Separation, Lim. —
ited, filed a bill of complaint in this court, alleging the issu-
ance and their ownership of Letters Patent Nos. 835,120 and
962,678 and infringement by the defendant and praying for
an injunction and accounting of profits and damages; and
that the said defendant filed an answer thereto. And the
defendant, further answering the aforesaid introductory mat-
ters, avers that in its said answer defendant denies that it has
ever used, either separately or conjointly, the alleged inven-
tions described in the Letters Patent No. 835,120 and No.
962,678, or either of them; and denies that the alleged inven-
tion described in the said Letters Patent No. 962,678 has any
value or utility whatever and further avers that the said Let-
ters Patent No. 962,678 is invalid and void and of no force
_ and effect; that thereafter, pending trial of the issues thereby
Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bill of Complaint 35
raised, the original bill of complaint was, by an order of this
Honorable Court dated August —, 1922, dismissed with
respect to Letters Patent No. 835,120, without prejudice. The
defendant is without knowledge as to the other averments of
the aforesaid introductory paragraph and therefore denies
them and leaves the plaintiff to make such proof thereof as it
may be advised.
1. The defendant is a corporation organized under the
laws of the State of Maine and has its principal legal office in
Augusta, Maine. The defendant is not informed as to the
other allegations of the first and second paragraphs of the
bill of complaint, and therefore denies them and leaves the
plaintiff to make such proof thereof as it may be advised.
2. The defendant admits that Letters Patent of the
United States No. 962,678 were issued on June 28, 1910, to
Henry Tivingstone Sulman, Henry Howard Greenway and
Arthur Howard Higgins; but on information and belief the
defendant denies all other allegations of the third paragraph
of the bill of complaint.
3. The defendant is without knowledge as to the aver-
ments contained in the fourth paragraph of the bill of com-
plaint, and therefore denies them and leaves the plaintiff to
make such proof thereof as it may be advised.
4. As to the matters and things alleged in the fifth para-
graph of the bill of complaint, the defendant is not informed
and, therefore, denies the same, and demands the production
at or before the trial of the instruments in writing referred to
and leaves the plaintiff to make such proof of said matters
and things as it may be advised.
5. The defendant denies that the alleged invention
described in Letters Patent No. 962,678 has any value or util-
ity whatever and denies that the plaintiff has made said
alleged invention profitable to itself and to the public by care-
ful and elaborate tests of said alleged invention in its appli-
cation to a wide variety of ores and by the extensive commer-
ay
36 Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bill of Complaint
cial use of said alleged invention by plaintiff and its licensees;
and the defendant is not informed whether the plaintiff has
granted numerous licenses in the United States and elsewhere
for carrying on the process of ore concentration supposed to
constitute said alleged invention and the defendant is not
informed whether the plaintiff is able and willing to supply
the entire demand for the use of said alleged invention
throughout the United States by granting licenses or other-
wise, and it, therefore, denies those allegations and leaves the
plaintiff to make such proof thereof as it may be advised; but
the defendant denies that plaintiff is ready and willing to
grant licenses for the use of said alleged invention conditioned
only upon the payment of royalties measured by the output
of said process of concentration, but, on the contrary, avers
that the plaintiff insists upon restrictive terms and conditions
of license which have nothing to do with the process of con-
centration described in said patent, which are grossly unfair
and which unlawfully restrict the commercial freedom of its
licensees; and the defendant further denies that the preven-
tion or continuation of any act of it will in any wise affect
the realization or receipt of large or any gains or profits from
said alleged invention by the plaintiff.
6. The defendant is familiar with the published decision
of the Cireuit Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit in the suit
of Minerals Separation, Limited, plaintiff, against Miami
Copper Company, referred to in the seventh paragraph of the
bill of complaint, but the defendant does not accept as authori-
tative or binding upon this Court the decision of the Circuit
Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit (reported in 244 Fed.
Rep. 752); the Court in that case being divided and Judge
Buffington dissenting from the majority opinion rendered by
Judges Woolley and McPherson.
7. The defendant denies that in Pinall County, in the
State of Arizona, or anywhere else in the United States of
_ America, it has ever installed apparatus for or carried on the
use of the said process of ore concentration as described in
Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bill of Complaint 37
the specification and pointed out and claimed in claims 1, 2,
3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of the aforesaid Letters Patent No. 962,678,
or of any of those claims, or of any part of said process; but,
on the contrary, defendant avers that the pneumatic flotation
process employed by it is a process protected by United States
Letters Patents under which the defendant is licensed, which
process is entirely different and distinct from any process
described or claimed in Letters Patent No. 962,678; and the
defendant denies each and every one of the other allegations
of the eighth, ninth and tenth paragraphs of the bill of com-
plaint.
8. The defendant denies that it has been duly notified of
infringement of said Letters Patent No. 962,678 in accordance
with the requirements of the revised statutes of the United
States; it has no knowledge of the character or substance of
the alleged oral notice or conversations referred to in the
eleventh paragraph of the bill of complaint, and therefore
denies the same and leaves the plaintiff to make such proof
thereof as it may be advised; and defendant denies that it is
informed of any rights of the plaintiff, as referred to in the
eleventh paragraph of the bill of complaint, by reason of pub-
licity given to plaintiff’s alleged rights, or the alleged litiga-
tion thereon, or by the alleged general knowledge of the grant-
ing of licenses in the United States under said letters patent,
or by the installation and extensive use of the said alleged
invention under license in mines and in places alleged to be
accessible to the defendant and its representatives and of
which the defendant is alleged to have full knowledge, which
the defendant denies, and the defendant denies that it has
copied any procedure carried on by licensees of the plaintiff.
9. Defendant further answering, on information and
belief, avers that the said Letters Patent No. 962,678 is invalid
and void and of no force and effect for the following reasons,
to wit:
(a) That the patentees, Sulman, Greenway and Hig-
gins, were not the original and first inventors or discover-
ers of that which is patented by said letters patent, or any
38 Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bil of Complaint
material or substantial part thereof, but that, on the con.
trary, prior to the alleged invention or discovery of said
patentees, the things patented by said patent and al]
material and substantial thereof have been,
(1) Patented and published in each of the following
letters patent:
Umsrrep States Patents.
No. Date. Patentee.
703,905 July 1, 1902 Elmore
735,071 <Aug. 4, 1903 Delprat
763,259 June 21, 1904 Cattermole
763,260 June 21, 1904 Cattermole
768,035 Aug. 23, 1904 Delprat
776,145 Nov. 29, 1904 Potter
777,273 Dee. 13, 1904 Cattermole
777,274 Dee. 13, 1904 Cattermole
788,247 Apr. 25, 1905 Cattermole, Sulman & Picard
793,808 July 4, 1905 Sulman & Picard
805,382 Nov. 21,1905 Sanders
807,502 Dec. 19,1905 Schwarz
809,959 Jan. 16,1906 Kirby
826,411 July 17,1906 Elmore
835,120 Nov. 6, 1906 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
835,143 Nov. 6, 1906 Sulman
835,479 Nov. 6, 1906 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
865,194 Sept. 3, 1907 MacQuisten
MacQuisten
879,985 Feb. 25,1908 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
955,012 Apr. 12,1910 Sulman
17,109 of 1903 Cattermole
19,783 of 1903 Delprat
20,419 of 1903 Sulman & Picard
27,132 of 1903 Delprat
17,816 of 1904 Elmore
29,374 of 1904 Sulman & Picard
Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bill of Complaint 39
of 1905 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
5,953 of 1905 Elmore
7,803 of 1905 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
10,475 of 1905 Morgan Crucible Co. (McCourt)
15,119 of 1905 MacQuisten
8,567 of 1907 Chapman
26,264 of 1908 Lockwood & Samuel
2,852 of 1908 Minerals Separation (Higgins)
28,173 of 1908 Sulman & Picard
2,359 of 1909 Greenway, Sulman & Higgins
AvsrraLiaN Patents
1,935 of 1904 Elmore
13,939 of 1904 (New South Wales) Delprat
13,940 of 1904 (New South Wales) Delprat
6,493 of 1904 (South Australia) Delprat
6,494 of 1904 (South Australia) Delprat
4,128 of 1905 MacQuisten
4,655 of 1905 Sulman, Picard & Ballot
5,738 of 1906 Sulman
13,947 of 1909 Sulman, Greenway &
Higgins
15,970 of 1909 Greenway
16,568 of 1909 Minerals Separation
16,601 of 1909 Sulman, Picard
German Patents
42 of 1877 Bessel
39,369 of 1887 Bessel
163,750 (App. filed 1904) Cattermole, Sulman & Picard
226,096 (App. filed 1909) Minerals Separation.
Also patented or described and contained in other letters
patents, the dates, numbers and grantees of which this de-
fendant is not now able to specify, but prays to be allowed
hereafter to add by amendment to this answer, or otherwise.
(2) Described in the following printed publications:
The Mining Journal (Lond
on), May 11, 1907, page
40 Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bill of Complaint
The Engineering & Mining Journal (New York City),
May 11, 1907, pages 908-909.
The Engineering and Mining Journal (New York
City), June 1, 1907, page 1037.
The Engineer (London), May 10, 1907, page 469.
The Engineering & Mining Journal (New York City),
Feb. 16, 1907, pages 317-321.
Also illustrated or described in other printed publica-
tions, the names and dates of which this defendant is not now
able to specify, but prays to be allowed hereafter to add by
amendment to this answer or otherwise.
(2) Known to various persons, the names and
addresses of whom the defendant is not now able to give,
but prays to be allowed hereafter to add by amendment
to this answer or otherwise.
(b) That the state of the art prior to the alleged
invention or discovery of the said Patent No. 962,678 was
such that there was no patentable novelty in the subject
matter described in said patent and claimed in claims 1,
2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 thereof, which state of the art the
defendant is ready to aver, maintain and prove.
(c) That the patentees Sulman, Greenway and Hig-
gins were not joint inventors of the subject matter alleged
to be patented by said Letters Patent No. 962,678 or any
substantial or material part thereof.
(d) That the specification and claims of the said
Letters Patent No. 962,678 do not constitute a full, clear,
concise or exact description of the alleged invention or
of the manner or process of making, constructing, com-
pounding or using it in accordance with the statutes in
such cases made and provided, nor do they particularly
point out or distinctly claim the part, improvement or
combination which the patentees claim as their alleged
invention or discovery; nor does the specification of the
said patent describe the invention claimed in claims 1, 2,
3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 in such full, clear and exact terms as to
enable any one skilled in the art to practice such alleged
invention without making experiments and discoveries of
his own; but on the contrary, said specification, as the
defendant avers, was deliberately, and for the purpose of
ee public, made to contain less than the whole
truth relative to the alleged invention or discovery, or
more than is necessary to produce the desired result, and
Defendant’s Answer to Amended Bill of Complaint 41
the claims of the patent for the same purpose were made
to claim more than had been invented or discovered by
the said patentees either jointly or severally.
(e) That the things alleged to be patented by said
Patent No. 962,678 had been abandoned to the public.
10. The defendant further avers, on information and
belief, that in view of the state of the art prior to the alleged
invention of said Letters Patent No. 962,678 the claims thereof,
regardless of their language, to be sustained as valid must be
so construed as not to cover any process of ore concentration
heretofore or now carried on by the defendant.
11. The defendant further avers, upon information and
belief, that by reason of the acts done by the applicants in the
prosecution before the United States Patent Office of the
application which matured into Letters Patent No. 962,678
the plaintiff is now estopped from alleging that the claims of
said patent, or any of them, can be construed to cover any
process of ore concentration heretofore or now carried on by
the defendant.
12. The defendant further answering denies the equity
of the plaintiff’s bill of complaint and avers that the plaintiff
is not entitled to an injunction nor to an account of profits,
nor to damages, nor to any royalty or recovery whatsoever
against this defendant, nor to any relief whatsoever, as prayed
for in the said bill of complaint.
All of which matters and things this defendant is ready
to aver, maintain and prove as this Honorable Court shall
direct, and the defendant prays that the bill of complaint be
dismissed, and that the defendant shall recover its costs and
disbursements in this suit.
MAGMA COPPER COMPANY,
By H. E. Dopee,
Secretary.
Woopman, Wuitenouss & Lirrieriexp,
Solicitors for Defendant.
Penniz, Davis, Marvin & Epmonps,
Of Counsel for Defendant.
—
42 Notice
‘In tHe District Court or THE Unrrep States For THE
Disraict or Marnz, SourHern Drviston.
In Equrtry on Letters Patent No. 962,678.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
NOTICE.
Penniz, Davis, Marvin & Epmonps, Esqs.,
165 Broadway, New York City.
Asert S. Woopman, Esq.,
Portland, Maine.
Please take notice that on Friday, March 30, 1923, at
10 o’clock in the forenoon, or as soon thereafter as counsel
can be heard, we shall appear before his Honor Judge Hale
and present the motion and annexed affidavits, a copy of
which is handed you herewith.
Henry D. WiuiaMs,
Wma. Houston Kenyon,
LinpLey M. Gagrison,
Of Counsel for Plaintiff.
Swney St. F. THaxter,
Solicitor and of Counsel
for Plaintiff.
Service of the above notice and receipt of copy of the
motion and annexed affidavits is hereby acknowledged this
26th day of March, 1923.
Wriuiam H. Davis.
Motion 43
In tHe District Court or THE Unrrep States FoR THE
District or Marne, Sournern Drvisron.
In Equrry on Lerrers Patent No. 962,678.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
MOTION.
Now comes the plaintiff Minerals Separation North
American Corporation and moves for an order of this
Court directing an inspection of defendant’s mill at Supe
rior, Arizona, by counsel and experts for plaintiff and the
taking of specimens of material of defendant’s process at
various stages thereof, and that the depositions de bene esse
of the general manager, general superintendent, mill super-
intendent, J. Garrett, former mill superintendent, and such
other officers or employees of the defendant as have know]l-
edge of the operations of the defendant during the three
months preceding the commencement of this suit may be
taken by the plaintiff at Superior, Arizona, under the
provisions of Sections 863-867 Revised Statutes, the taking
of such depositions to be begun on or about May 1, 1923,
and for such other and further relief as to the Court may
seem meet.
In connection with this motion plaintiff submits the
annexed affidavits of Henry D. Williams, Alfred A. Cook,
James Wilding and Wm. Houston Kenyon.
Henry D. WriaMs,
Wa. Houston Kenyon,
Liypitzey M. Garrison,
Of Counsel for Plaintif.
Swney Sr. F. Tuaxrer,
Solicitor and of Counsel
for Plaintiff.
cy
44 Affidavit of Henry D. Williams
In tHe Districr Court oF THE Unrrep STaTEs FOR THE
District oF Marne, SoutHern Division.
In Eguiry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
V.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
Arripavit oF Henry D. WituiaMs ror PLAINTIFF.
Strate or New York,
County or New York.
Henry D. Wiiuiams being duly sworn says:
I am of counsel for the plaintiff, and have had charge
of all proceedings in this suit and in all the litigation in
this country involving the same general subject.
This suit was commenced in January, 1920, by the
filing of the bill of complaint on January 9 and the service —
of the subpoena ad respondendum on January 10. Defend.
ant’s time to file its answer or take other action with respect —
to the bill of complaint was extended by stipulation from
time to time, and on or about April 22, 1920, defendant
served notice of motion for a bill of particulars, and there-
after the time for filing defendant’s answer was extended
pending the disposition of said motion. The motion was
heard before his Honor Judge Hale on July 30, 1920, and
was denied. Thereafter there were other extensions by
stipulation and defendant’s answer was filed October 1, 1920.
Thereafter, on November 2, 1920, defendant obtained
an order for the taking of a deposition de bene esse of Leslie
Bradford at Salt Lake City, Utah, and such deposition was
duly taken and filed.
Affidavit of Henry D. Williams 45
More than a year thereafter, on December 30, 1921,
defendant obtained an order for the taking of the deposition
de bene esse of Theodore J. Hoover at New York City, but
a few days later defendant’s counsel notified plaintiff’s
counsel that this deposition would not be taken, and it was
not taken.
The suit as originally commenced included Minerals
Separation, Limited, a British corporation, as one of the
plaintiffs, and was for infringement of Letters Patent No.
835,120 of November 6, 1906, as well as for the patent now
in suit. It was one of six suits against five defendants
brought in this district by these two plaintiffs for infringe-
ment of these two patents. In May, 1922, four of these suits,
the one against Chino Copper Company, the one against
Ray Consolidated Copper Company and the two against the
Nevada Consolidated Copper Company were settled by
agreement and discontinued. At the same time the longer
pending suits then in accounting proceedings, against Butte
& Superior Mining Company and Miami Copper Company,
were settled and discontinued.
In June, 1922, Minerals Separation, Limited, assigned
all its right, title and interest in and right of action, claim
and demand under these patents to the plaintiff Min-
erals Separation North American Corporation, and plaintiff,
being reliably advised that the operations of the defendant
at the time of the commencement of the suit and through
substantially the entire period of infringement and so long as
they were continued after the commencement of the suit,
involved the use of a soluble mineral-frothing agent such as
is described and claimed in Patent No. 962,678, now alone in
suit, and did not include the use of an oily mineral-frothing
agent such as is described and claimed in Patent No.
835,120, a stipulation was entered into that the bill of com-
plaint herein be dismissed with respect to Patent No. 835,120
without prejudice, and that a supplemental and amended bill
of complaint by Minerals Separation North American Cor-
poration as sole plaintiff, charging infringement only of
Patent No. 962,678 should be filed. This stipulation and
—
46 Affidavit of Henry D. Williams
supplemental and amended bill of complaint were filed Sep.
tember 28, 1922, and defendant’s answer to the supple.
mental and amended bill of complaint was filed September
29, 1922.
Late in June, 1922, I was advised that a settlement of
the present suit was in contemplation. On August 1, 1922,
I sailed for Europe on my vacation and returned in the latter
part of September, 1922. Shortly after my return I was
advised that negotiations for settlement of this suit were pro-
ceeding, and finally, early in November, 1922, I received defi.
nite instructions from Alfred A. Cook, Esq., vice-president
and general counsel of the plaintiff, to suspend all work on
the case.
In the latter part of February, 1923, I was advised that
the negotiations for settlement had suddenly terminated and
that preparations for the trial were to be resumed and |
thereupon advised associate counsel and resumed prepara-
tions.
My associate counsel in this suit and in all of the other
suits above referred to involving this subject-matter are Wm.
Houston Kenyon and Lindley M. Garrison, Esqs., and we had
agreed in conference some time prior to last summer that it
was necessary to the proper presentation of this case that
mill-size operations should be conducted in glass-sided pnev-
matic cells in the presence of the Court, so as to avoid the mis-
understandings which would naturally arise and which actu-
ally did arise on the appeal in the Miami suit as to such opera-
tions from demonstrations in miniature apparatus such as
could be used in a court room. We therefore advised the con-
struction of such a mill and recommended that it be located at
Boston so as to be within easy reach of the Judges of the
Court of Appeals, having previously obtained from Judge
Peters an intimation that it would be agreeable to him to go
to Boston to see the demonstration during the trial. I may
add that this mill is a heavy affair which has to be erected on
properly prepared foundations and cannot be moved about
without dismantlement and re-erection.
Affidavit of Henry D. Williams 47
It is my opinion that the demonstrations which we expect
to carry on before the Court and defendant’s representatives
in this Boston demonstration mill will be necessary for the
proper presentation of the facts in issue at the trial.
On February 27, 1923, I received a letter from defendant’s
eounsel suggesting that we arrange for the setting of the case
for trial some time between the first and tenth of May. I
replied by a letter dated and delivered March 1, 1923, a copy
of which is attached hereto. I had been advised, probably
erroneously, that defendant’s mine had resumed operations.
I was also advised that operations of defendant’s mine and
mill had been shut down more than two years ago, and so far
as 1am advised defendant has committed no acts of infringe-
ment for more than two years, although it expects to resume
its infringing acts on April 15th next.
On the same day, March 1, 1923, I received a letter in
reply from defendant’s counsel, a copy of which is hereto
annexed.
I advised Mr. Kenyon as to this correspondence, and he
advised me that there was then some uncertainty as to his
trial engagements, and in the meantime I prepared a state-
ment of information desired as to defendant’s operations
immediately prior to the commencement of the suit such as
we deem necessary in order that our demonstration mill at
Boston should faithfully reproduce these operations.
On March 14, 1923, I sent to defendant’s counsel a letter
of that date, a copy of which is hereto annexed, and with it
the document entitled ‘‘Operations of Mill of Magma Copper
Company during October, November and December, 1919.’’
I have received no letter in reply, but have been advised by
Messrs. Davis and Sage, of counsel for defendant, that the
ore in the bins at the defendant’s mill is not run-of-mine ore
but what has been gathered during exploration operations
during the shut-down, and that serious objection would be
made to using it in any demonstrations as representative of
defendant’s ore; also that the mill expects to resume opera-
tions about the middle of April and that run-of-mine ore can-
—
48 Affidavit of Henry D. Williams
not be supplied until after these operations are resumed; algo
that defendant’s counsel deem an inspection of their mil]
unnecessary (and, of course, it must be of the mill in opera.
tion) and will not consent to delaying the trial for such inspec.
tion; also defendant’s counsel decline to go to the trouble of
supplying the information called for in the statement annexed
to my letter of March 14, 1923, and will only go to the extent
of correcting any errors in a stipulation which we may send
to them as to defendant’s operations. I thereupon said to
them that we would have to take the depositions of such
officers and employees of the defendant as have knowledge of
the operations of the defendant during the three months pre.
ceding the commencement of this suit, and that we would
apply to the Court for an order of inspection and an order for
taking these depositions at Superior, Arizona, at that time.
I deem it necessary in preparation for the trial, and par-
ticularly for the demonstrations that we expect to make at the
Boston mill, that this information be obtained. I reasonably
expected to obtain it by stipulation, since it is the kind of data
that every mill keeps records of for the purpose of keeping
informed as to its operations, and I was quite surprised when
it was refused, as there was a general understanding between
Mr. Davis and myself that a stipulation would be entered into,
Subscribed and sworn to before |
me this 26th day of March, 1923. |
HENRY D. WILLIAMS,
(Seal) F. L. Requa,
Notary Public, New York County No. 298.
Affidavit of Henry D. Williams 49
March 1, 1923.
Panniz, Davis, Marvin & Epmonps, Esgs.,
165 Broadway, New York City.
Attention of Mr. Merton W. Sage.
Dear Sirs:
We are in receipt of your letter of the 26th ultimo with
enclosures as noted, for which we thank you.
We have been instructed to co-operate with you in ob-
taining as early a date as possible for the trial of the suit
of Minerals Separation North American Corporation v.
Magma Copper Company. We will be much pleased to do so,
but hardly think that matters are now sufficiently advanced
for us to agree upon your suggested dates of from the first
to the tenth of May. Indeed one of our associate counsel,
Mr. William H. Kenyon, who will take part in the trial, has
a definite trial engagement for a long trial commencing May
14th and probably consuming the balance of the month of
May.
In our preparations for the trial we will need to use a
considerable amount of defendant’s ore. We understand
that the mine is now in operation and there should therefore
be no difficulty in supplying us with ‘‘run-of-mine ore.’? We
wish to have it dry crushed to the condition in which it would
be supplied to the special grinding machinery of a flotation
section, say not exceeding three-fourths inch cubes. To facili-
tate forwarding we would like a minimum carload, probably
in the neighborhood of thirty tons, packed in bags marked
“Keep Dry,’’ to be shipped as freight and addressed
‘*Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Roxbury, Mass.
Ruggles Street Yard.’’
We also wish a specimen of the flotation agent used by the
defendant, which we understand is X-cake. We would like
twenty-five pounds in a sealed container; also, if the opera-
tions involve the addition of lime, as we understand they do,
ao
50 Affidavit of Henry D. Williams
one hundred pounds of the lime used, in a sealed container
also ten gallons of the fresh water used in the flotation plant
in a sealed container, these smaller samples to be shipped
by express addressed
‘*Frank A. Root,
65 Whitney Street,
Boston, 20,
Mass.’’
When we last appeared before Judge Hale in this cas
the Judge made it perfectly clear that he did not favor ob
taining information as to acts charged to be infringing by
interrogatories, and that he expected counsel to draw up «
proper stipulation. As we have said to your Mr. Davis, wi
are quite willing to meet the Judge’s views in this respect
but before doing so we wish an opportunity for counsel an
experts to visit and examine the defendant’s mill and tak
such specimens as they desire, with duplication of the same
of course, to the defendant’s representatives. We would lik
to arrange for this inspection at the earliest possible date
Will you kindly give these matters consideration an
advise us at your early convenience.
Very truly yours,
(Sgd.) WILLIAMS & PRITCHARD.
Affidavit of Henry D. Williams 5]
(COPY)
Pennie, Davis, Marvin AND Epmonps.
165 Broadway, New York.
March Ist, 1923.
Messrs. Williams & Pritchard,
61 Broadway,
New York City.
Gentlemen :
Replying to your letter of March Ist, 1923, respecting
the trial of the suit of Minerals Separation vy. Magma Cop-
per Company, we beg to advise you that we are prepared to
advance the date of the trial to the latter part of April in
order to acconimodate Mr. Kenyon’s engagement commenc-
ing May 14th. Unless we can agree upon a date for the com-
mencement of the trial, prior to May 15th, we will feel com-
pelled to submit the matter to the Court with the view of
obtaining the earliest date possible for the commencement
of the trial.
Your understanding that the mine of the Magma Copper
Company is now in operation is erroneous, No mining oper-
ations are now being carried on at the Magma mine, nor
Under the circumstances, it appears impossible for us to
supply you with any “‘run-of-mine ore.”? Neither are we in
& position to furnish you samples of X-cake, lime or fresh
water used in the flotation plant, since the plant is not now
in operation and has not been in operation since early in
1921.
Since the flotation plant of the defendant is not now in
operation, no useful purpose could possibly result from a
visit to the Magma mill by plaintiff’s counsel and experts.
Very truly yours,
(Sgd.) MERTON w. SAGE.
—_$<—,
52 Affidavit of Henry D. Williams
March 14th, 1923.
Pennie, Davis, Marvin anp Epmonps, Ese@s.,
165 Broadway,
New York City, New York.
Attention Mr. Merton W. Sage.
Dear Sirs:
I have awaited the final fixing of Mr. Kenyon’s engage-
ments before replying to your letter of the first instant.
On April second he will enter upon a long trial at Wilming-
ton, Delaware, which will probably take three or four weeks,
and he is now and expects to be, up to the commencement
of this trial, actively engaged in preparations for it. Upon
the completion of this trial there will not only be the usual
briefing and argument, but also preparations for another
trial at the same place which Judge Morris has set for May
28th, and which will probably take two weeks. Mr. Kenyon
therefore cannot take up the Magma trial earlier than the
middle of June.
Aside from Mr. Kenyon’s present inescapable obliga-
tions in other work, it will not be possible for plaintiff's
case to be adequately presented at a trial commencing earlier
than June 15th. For the proper presentation thereof it will
be necessary to exhibit to the court a fair representation of
defendant’s operations as carried on at the time of the com-
mencement of the suit, not in miniature apparatus, as was
done at the Miami trial, but in apparatus of sufficient size
to adequately exhibit the operations. We have, therefore, at
considerable expense, constructed in Boston a small demon-
stration mill with glass-sided Callow cells, and in this demon-
stration mill we propose to exhibit to the court operations
with defendant’s ore and defendant’s flotation agents fairly
representing defendant’s operations.
For the operation of this demonstration mill we needs
considerable quantity of defendant’s ore and we have there
fore offered to purchase from the defendant a carload of
Affidavit of Henry D. Williams 53
this ore and to pay the expenses of transporting it from
defendant’s mines to our demonstration mill. We are quite
sure that a reasonable effort to meet us in this regard would
result in the shipment of the ore by the defendant during
the present month. Our information is that defendant’s en.
largement of its plant is practically completed and that its
operations are to be started during the present month.
As to defendant’s flotation agents, you have not met our
request by any statement that it is impossible to supply us
with the specimens required of such material as was used
at the time of the commencement of the suit. We wish of
course to approximate as closely as possible conditions at
that time and should expect you to reasonably co-operate
The two other matters which we insist upon as neces-
sary to the trial are an inspection of defendant’s mill by
our representatives and a precise statement, either by stipu-
lation or deposition, of defendant’s operations at the time
of the commencement of the suit. The inspection can be
arranged to take place promptly after defendant’s mill starts
up. We take it that you are inclined to meet us as to the
stipulation and we therefore send you herewith a memo.
randum of information desired which we have no doubt can
be supplied from the information and records at defendant’s
mill.
Very truly yours, :
(Sgd.) HENRY D. WILLIAMS.
54 Affidavit of Henry D. Williams
Minerats Separation NortH American Corporation,
Vv.
Macma Copper Co.
Operations of Mill of Magma Copper Company during
October, November and December, 1919.
1. Physical character of the ore milled.
2. Mineralogical composition of the ore milled.
3. Average analysis of the ore milled, giving the percent-
age of—
Copper—present as sulphide mineral or minerals, ag
oxidized mineral or minerals and as metal,
if any. ‘
Lime, (Magnesia, Baryta, etc.)
4. The average amount of silver and gold present in the
ore, stated in ounces per ton of ore.
5. Description of apparatus and machinery used in the
mill, with drawings of apparatus and machinery of flotation
plant.
6. Milling flowsheet in detail, showing not only the course
of the ore or ore pulp, but also the following:
(a) The point or points at which fresh water is added
to the ore or ore pulp;
(b) The point or points at which return water is
added to the ore or ore pulp;
Affidavit of Henry D. Williams 55
(c) The tons of ore and tons of water fed to each
class or group of concentrating machines or principal
apparatus per unit of time (minute, hour, day);
(d) The tons of concentrate and accompanying water
discharged from each class or group of concentrating
machines or principal apparatus per unit of time ;
(e) The tons of middlings and accompanying water
discharged from each class or group of concentrating
machines or principal apparatus per unit of time;
(f) The tons of tailings and accompanying water dis-
» charged from each class or group of concentrating ma-
chines or principal apparatus per unit of time ;
(g) The copper assay of the solid products dis-
. charged from each group of concentrating machines or
apparatus;
(h) The point or points at which flotation agents are
added to the ore or ore pulp, naming each agent.
7. If changes were made in flowsheet used during Octo-
ber, November and December, 1919, and in January, 1920,
prior to January 10, 1920, give each flowsheet.
8. The total tonnage of ore milled during such three
months of operations.
9. The tonnage of ore milled in each such month and the
average percentage therein of copper in the sulphide and oxide
form, iron and insoluble or silica. Also the silver and gold
content thereof.
10. The tonnage of concentrates produced in each such
month by the concentrating tables, and the average percentage
therein of copper in sulphide and oxide form, iron and insol-
uble. Also the silver and gold content thereof.
11. The tonnage of feed to the flotation plant in each such
month and the average percentage therein of copper in sul-
phide and oxide form, iron and insoluble. Also the silver and
gold content thereof.
56 Affidavit of Henry D. Wiliams
12. The tonnage of flotation concentrates produced in
each such month and the average percentage therein of cop-
per in sulphide and oxide form, iron and insoluble. Also the
silver and gold content thereof.
13. The tonnage of flotation tailings produced in each
such month and the average percentage therein of copper in
sulphide and oxide form. Also the silver and gold content
thereof.
14. The tonnage of general mill tailings produced in each
such month and the average percentage therein of copper in
sulphide and oxide form. Also the silver and gold content
thereof.
15. The nature and weight of all flotation agents used in
each such month, including such as are of an acid or alkaline
nature.
16. The number, make and rated capacity of the blowers
used in the flotation plant; also speed of operation and
pressure against which they were operated and displacement
per revolution of each blower.
17. Specimen records and reports of daily operations,
including tonnages treated, assays of mill heads, general con-
centrates and general tailings, flotation heads, concentrates
and tailings, tonnages of flotation heads, amount of each
flotation agent used.
18. The specification under which each agent was pur-
chased, and the chemical analysis of the agent purchased.
Affidavit of Alfred A. Cook 57
*
In THE District Court oF THE Unrrep Stares FOR THE
District oF Maine, SoutHern Division.
In Egurry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT OF ALFRED A. COOK FOR PLAINTIFF.
Srarz or New York,
County or New York,
Atrrep A. Coox being duly sworn deposes and says:
I am vice-president and general counsel of Minerals
Separation North American Corporation, the complainant in
the above-entitled suit.
During the late spring of 1922 I adjusted the differences
existing between the Minerals Corporation and Utah Copper
Company, Miami Copper Company, Ray Consolidated Copper
Company, Chino Consolidated Copper Company, Nevada Con-
solidated Copper Company and Butte & Superior’ Mining
Company and all litigation between the Minerals Corporation
and them was discontinued.
I was asked in behalf of the Magma Copper Company
after the aforesaid adjustment had been concluded whether I
would be willing to adjust similarly the differences between
the Magma Copper Company and the Minerals Corporation,
and I said that I would. I left for Europe for my vacation
on June 24, 1922, and was advised shortly before I left that
the Magma Copper Company was giving attention to the situ-
ation, but had not definitely concluded whether it would adjust
or not. I gave the above information to Mr. Henry D. Wil-
—
58 Affidavit of Alfred A. Cook
liams, patent counsel of the Minerals Corporation, and stated
that I doubted very much whether the suit would be tried ip
the fall.
During the latter part of September, 1922, a few days
after I returned from Europe, I was invited by Mr. William
B. Thompson, the controlling owner of the Magma Copper
Company, to confer with him, and I did so. He stated at our
conference that he was shortly leaving for Europe, but would
speak with his associate, Mr. Charles F. Ayer, the president
of the Magma Copper Company, concerning his views and he
asked me to put myself in touch with Mr. Ayer, and I wrote to
Mr. Ayer on September 28, 1922. I met Mr. Ayer during the
middle of October, 1922, and further conferences were had
with him and the counsel for the Magma Copper Company
later in the month and during November, 1922. My confer-
ences with Mr. Ayer continued through December, 1922, and
through January and partly through February, 1923. He and
I sought to determine whether some amicable adjustment
could not be reached as to the matters in difference between
the Minerals Corporation and the Magma Copper Company.
As our negotiations proceeded and as a result of what Mr.
Ayer said to me I felt called upon in November, 1922, to
advise, and did advise Mr. Henry D. Williams, patent coun-
sel for the Corporation, to stop all work in connection with
the preparation for trial of the above-entitled suit.
On February 17, 1923, following a conference with Mr.
Ayer at which I thought we had reached a basis of under.
standing, I received a letter from Mr. Ayer reading as fol-
lows:
‘‘New York, February 17, 1923.
‘Alfred A. Cook,
111 Broadway,
New York, N. Y.
Dear Mr. Cook:
I have requested Messrs. Pennie, Davis, Marvin and
Edmonds, attorneys for the Magma Copper Company,
to have the suit brought against it by the Minerals Sep-
aration Company set down for trial and tried at the ear-
Affidavit of Alfred A. Cook 59
liest possible date. There does not appear to be any other
way of disposing of the litigation except to try the case.
Yours very truly,
Cuarues F, Aver.’’
I acknowledged its receipt as follows:
“February 21, 1923.
‘Charles F. Ayer,
14 Wall Street, City.
Dear Mr. Ayer:
I have your letter of February 17 and note that you
have requested Messrs. Pennie, Davis, Marvin & Edmonds
to have the suit brought against the Magma Copper Com-
pany by Minerals Separation set down for trial and dis-
sed of at the earliest possible date. I have informed
Dr. Gregory of the conclusion which you have reached
and he will in turn advise Messrs. Williams & Pritchard,
the patent counsel for Minerals Separation.
Sincerely yours,
Aurrep A, Coox.’’
I appreciate that the conferences which I have had with
Mr. Ayer were privileged and I have avoided on that account
making any reference to what was said. It has seemed to me,
however, proper to call the attention of the Court to the fact
that as a result of negotiations initiated by the defendant,
and which extended from September 28, 1922, to February
17, 1923—a period of approximately five months—patent coun-
sel for complainant was instructed by me to suspend his efforts
to prepare for trial, and that it has been by reason of the
instructions so given that patent counsel has not advanced
with his preparation to the point where it otherwise would
have been. it
ALFRED A. COOK.
Subscribed and sworn to before
me this 26th day of March, 1923.
(Seal) Joun F. Jacoss,
Notary Public, Kings County, No. 38.
Certificate filed in New York County No. 101.
Kings County Reg. No. 3013. New York County Reg.
No. 2026.
ccm
60 Affidavit of James Wilding
In tHe District Court or THE UnrtTEep STATES FOR THE
District oF Marne, SourHern Drvisron.
In Egorry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT OF JAMES WILDING FOR PLAINTIFF.
State or New Yorx, } a
County or New York, *
James Wixpine being duly sworn says:
Tam a metallurgist in the employ of the plaintiff and
have had charge of the erection in Boston by the plaintiff
of an ore concentrating mill with glass-sided pneumatic cells
for the purpose of illustrating to the Court the operations
carried out in the defendant’s mill at Superior, Arizona.
The erection of this mill was commenced in July, 1922, and
the cost of the mill has been in the neighborhood of $10,000.
It includes heavy grinding machinery, classifying apparatus
and pneumatic cells, erected on proper foundations, with
means for handling the material treated and disposing of
the products. It was finished in November of 1922. I was
generally advised before that time that the parties were
engaged in negotiations for the settlement of the suit. In
the latter part of February, 1923, I was instructed by counsel
to proceed with preparations for the trial, and shortly there-
after I went to Boston and tested and operated the mill with
Miami ore, the only ore then available.
Upon being supplied with the necessary information as
to the operations of the defendant and with a sufficient
Affidavit of James Wilding 61
amount of defendant’s ore, I expect to be able in this mill
to carry on operations faithfully reproducing on a smaller
seale, but nevertheless on a mill scale, the operations of
the defendant at Superior, Arizona.
I was requested by plaintiff’s counsel, Mr. Williams, to
give him a statement of the information necessary in order
to assure faithful reproduction of defendant’s operations,
and with Mr. Williams I prepared the series of statements
in the document entitled ‘Operations of Mill of Magma
Copper Company during October, November and December,
1919,” which is annexed to the accompanying affidavit of Mr.
Williams.
For the complete interpretation of the data in connec-
tion with the operations at defendant’s mill, and in order to
assure a reproduction of those operations, it is, in my opinion,
necessary that the defendant’s mill in operation should be
inspected by plaintiff’s counsel and experts, and the mere
fact that the mill has been enlarged or even materially altered
since the commencement of this suit, provided pneumatic
cells are still used, would not militate against the usefulness
of such an inspection and the necessity of such an inspection
in order that I may show to the Court a reproduction of
defendant’s operations and describe to the Court the manner
in which these operations are carried on.
Subscribed and sworn to before
me this 24th day of March, 1923.
JAMES WILDING.
(Seal) F. L. Requa,
Notary Public, N. Y. County, No. 298,
—,
62 Affidavit of Wm. Houston Kenyon
In tHE Unrrep States District Court ror tHe District op
Marne, Soutuern Drviston.
In Egurry.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT FOR PLAINTIFF OF WM. HOUSTON
KENYON.
Strate or New York, { ‘
County or New Yorks, f **°
Wma. Houston Kenyon being duly sworn deposes and
says:
I am of counse! for plaintiff in this case.
I am also of counsel for plaintiff in Victor Talking
Machine Company vs. The Brunswick-Balke-Collender Com-
pany and John Bailey Browning, now pending in the United
States District Court for the District of Delaware and set
for trial there on April 2d, 1923. That case was so set for
trial last November. It involves several counsel and a large
number of witnesses on both sides and several issues, includ-
ing an action between interfering patents and an infringement
counterclaim, and it is anticipated that the trial will occupy
at least three weeks in open court and probably more, and if
more that it will probably have to be continued, owing to
engagements of the Court from April 23d to about May 7th,
and that in any event I will be engaged in May with the prepa-
ration of brief and for oral argument and with the oral argu-
Affidavit of Wm. H ouston Kenyon 63
ment itself in that case, which I anticipate will be continued
to some time in the middle or latter part of May. I have also
an oral argument set for about the first of May in a case
pending in the Southern District of New York entitled
Charles S. Bird v. Sears-Roebuck & Company, which was
tried February 27th to March 1st, inclusive, and set for argu-
ment early in May. I have also a trial, Victor v. The Bruns-
wick-Balke-Collender Company, pending in the District of
Delaware, which is at present fixed for the week of June 4th
and which if tried at that time will require my uninterrupted
attention for at least two weeks preceding in preparation
therefor, and the trial of which will occupy a week.
Under these circumstances it would be exceedingly incon-
venient and so far as I can now see practically impossible
for me to take part in the trial of this case at any time prior
to about the middle of June and to make the preparation for
same that I desire, and would have, to make,
I confirm the statements in the affidavit of Henry D.
Williams as to the agreement at conference of present counsel
in this case, Judge Garrison, Mr. Williams and myself, that
it was necessary to the proper presentation of this case that
mill-size operations should be conducted in glass-sided pneu-
matic cells in the presence of the Court. Mr. Williams and
I conducted the trial in behalf of the plaintiff in the Miami
_ ease, preceding the trial by an inspection of defendant’s mill
at Miami, Arizona. At the trial we were limited to such
demonstrations of the operation of the process as could be
carried on in the court room, and defendant presented dem-
onstrations in miniature apparatus which gave an altogether
wrong impression of the degree and character of the agitation
in pneumatic cells, and we had only small court room appa-
ratus, which were insufficient to correct this wrong impression.
The final result on the appeal was that the Court accepted
these demonstrations in miniature apparatus as representa-
tive of what took place in the defendant’s operations at the
mill. It is, in my opinion, of great importance that we should
be able adequately to show to this Court by such demonstra-
tions as we expect to be able to give at the mill constructed
——
64 Order Permitting Inspection
by the plaintiff in Boston the real nature of the operations 9
defendant’s pneumatic cells.
Subscribed and sworn to be-
fore me this 26th day of
March, 1923.
WM. HOUSTON KENYON,
(Seal) Epwin Secer,
Notary Public for Queens County,
Certificate filed in New York County.
In THe District Court or THE Unrrep States FOR THE
District or Marne, SoutHern Division.
In Equity on Lerrers Patent No. 962,678.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
On motion of the plaintiff and on reading and filing o
affidavits of Henry D. Williams, verified March 26, 192:
Alfred A. Cook, verified March 26, 1923, James Wilding
verified March 24, 1923, and Wm. Houston Kenyon, verifie
March 26, 1923, and on hearing Henry D. Williams, Lindle
M. Garrison and Sidney St. F. Thaxter in support of sai
motion, and William H. Davis, Esq., in opposition therete
and, after due consideration, it is hereby
Orperep, That the plaintiff be permitted to inspect th
defendant’s mill in active operation at Superior, Arizona
represented by counsel and experts, and take specimens 0
material of defendant’s processes at various stages thereol
and it is further
Order Permitting Inspection 65
Onperep, That the plaintiff may take depositions de bene
esse of such officers or employees of the defendant as have
knowledge of the operations of the defendant during the three
months preceding the commencement of this suit; such depo-
sitions to be taken at Superior, Arizona, at the time of the
inspection aforesaid under the provisions of Sections
863-867 Revised Statutes, such inspection to take place at a
time mutually to be agreed upon between counsel and in
default of such agreement and inspection prior to May 7,
1923, apply to this court for further directions in
the premises. The counsel for the plaintiff hold themselves
in readiness to make the said inspection between the fifteenth
of April and the seventh of May, 1923.
Approved as to form:
JOHN A. PETERS,
United States District Judge.
Heyny D. Wittiams,
Linpizy M. Garrison,
’ For Plaintiff.
Wri H. Davis,
For Defendant.
(Sgd. Mar. 30, 1923.)
——
66 © Order Upon Interrogatories
Ls rue District Court or THe Unrrep STarTes IN AND FOR THE
Dusraict or Marz, Sournern Drvision.
Iw Egurry on Lerrers Patent No. 962,678.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation,
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
ORDER UPON INTERROGATORIES.
Upon the application of Messrs. Woodman, Whitehouse
& Littlefield, solicitors for defendant, made pursuant to
Equity Rule 58 it is
Orperep, That the defendant have leave to file the inter.
rogatories hereto annexed and that the same be answered
such officer or agent of the plaintiff, Minerals Separation
North American Corporation, as has knowledge of the facts
inquired of.
This order is without prejudice to the right of said plain
tiff under Equity Rule 58 to present objections to said inter-
rogatories or any of them in the manner prescribed by said
rule, within ten days after service of said interrogatories,
and to defer answers until the objections are determined.
CLARENCE HALE,
District Judge.
May 21, 1923.
Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answens 67
and Objections Thereto
Is roe District Covrr or THe Unrrep Srares ror rue
District or Marne, Sournern Division.
—__—_——
In Equrry on Lerrers Patent No, 962,678.
Minerals Separation North American Corporation, ‘
Plaintiff,
v.
Magma Copper Company,
Defendant.
DEFENDANT’S INTERROGATORIES AND PLAIN-
TIFF’S ANSWERS AND OBJECTIONS
THERETO.
And now comes the defendant in the above entitled cause
and files the following interrogatories under the provisions
of Equity Rule No. 58 for the discovery by the plaintiff of
facts and documents material to its defense of the cause, to
be answered under oath by the president or other duly quali-
fied officer of the plaintiff.
Interrogatory No. 1,
In what capacity, if any, were Henry Livingstone Sul-
man, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard, Arthur Edward
Cattermole, John Ballot, Arthur Howard Higgins, Henry
Greenway, George Albert Chapman, and William
Sidney Stevens employed or retained by (1) Minerals Sepa-
ration, Limited, or its predecessor or predecessors, and by
(2) the plaintiff Minerals Separation North American Corpo-
ration
(a) During the year 1902?
(b) During the year 19031
(ce) During the year 1904?
(d) During the year 19051
(e) During the year 19061
—
68 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers
and Objections Thereto
(f) During the year 1907?
(g) During the year 1908?
(h) During the year 19097
(i) During the year 1910?
(j) From January 1, 1911, to December 31, 19201
(k) With respect to each of said persons, has such em-
ployment or retainer been continuous since the beginning
thereof, and if not, state with respect to whom, and during
what period or periods, the employment was discontinued!
Answer to Interrogatory No. 1.
The plaintiff having been incorporated on the sey-
enth day of December, 1916, and not having in its pos-
session or under its custody or control any document
furnishing the information, is without knowledge as to
the capacity in which the persons named were employed
or retained by Minerals Separation, Limited; or its
predecessor or predecessors during any of the years
enumerated or designated by the letters (a) to (j) inclu-
sive, excepting to the extent that such persons have testi-
fied concerning their said employment or retainers in
suits in which plaintiff was a party. Said suits and the
parties inquired about testifying therein concerning
their employments or retainers are:
Minerals Separation, Limited, Minerals Separation
American Syndicate, Limited, and Minerals Separation
North American Corporation v. Butte & Superior Min
ing Company (the record therein includes the evidence
in full in the prior suit of Minerals Separation, Limited,
and Minerals Separation American Syndicate, Limited,
v. Hyde), in the United States District Court for the
District of Montana. John Ballot, Henry Livingstone
Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard, Arthur
Howard Higgins, George Albert Chapman.
Minerals Separation, Limited, v. Miami Copper
Company, in which by supplemental bill the plaintiff
became a party plaintiff, in the United States District
Court for the District of Delaware. John Ballot, Arthur
_ —
: ae
:
Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers 69
and Objections Thereto
Howard Higgins, George Albert Chapman (See also the
testimony of these witnesses and Messrs. Sulman and
Picard stipulated therein in abbreviated form from the
aforesaid suit against Hyde).
Wolf Mineral Process Corporation v. Minerals Sep-
aration North American Corporation, in the United
States District Court for the District of Maryland.
Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-
Picard and Arthur Edward Cattermole.
With respect to the capacity in which the various
persons named were employed or retained by the plain-
tiff since its incorporation on December 7, 1916, the facts
are as follows:
Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpat-
rick-Picard, Arthur Edward Cattermole, Henry Howard
Greenway and William Sydney Stevens were never em-
ployed or retained by the plaintiff, except that said Sul-
man, Picard and Cattermole were requested by plaintiff
in June, 1922, to take the time necessary to prepare to
testify with respect to the facts upon which they were
to be interrogated in the suit of Wolf Mineral Process
Corporation against Minerals Separation North Ameri-
can Corporation and were called as witnesses therein and
their depositions taken at London under commission in
August and September, 1922, and were compensated for
the time and labor involved in such work. :
With respect to John Ballot, he was president of
the plaintiff corporation from the time of its incorpora-
tion until his death on April 1, 1922.
With respect to Arthur Howard Higgins, he was
employed as chief metallurgist from the inception of the
plaintiff on December 7, 1916, and remained such con-
tinuously to the end of the period inquired of.
With respect to George Albert Chapman, he was
employed by the plaintiff from the time of its incorpora-
tion down to March, 1918, as a metallurgist, and from
the latter date continuously to the end of the period
inquired of as assistant chief engineer.
—
70 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers
and Objections Thereto
Interrogatory No. 2.
Is said Henry Livingstone Sulman the same H. Living-
stone Sulman who presented at a meeting of the Institution
of Mining and Metallurgy, held in London on or about
November 20, 1919, a paper entitled ‘‘A Contribution to the
Study of Flotation,’’ which paper was published in the Bulle-
tin of The Institution of Mining and Metallurgy for Novem-
ber, 1919?
Answer to Interrogatory No. 2.
Yes.
Interrogatory No. 3.
In what capacity, if any, was Theodore J. Hoover em-
ployed by Minerals Separation, Limited, in 1907?
(a) When did that employment begin?
(b) When did that employment terminate?
Answer to Interrogatory No. 3.
In the deposition of Theodore J. Hoover, which has
been stipulated into this case at defendant’s request,
said Hoover testified that in September, 1906, he became
general manager of Minerals Separation, Limited, and
that his employment was from 1906 to 1910 as general
manager and consulting engineer, and for the purposes
of the instant case these statements will not be disputed
It also appears in the testimony of Mr. John Ballot
in the suit against Hyde above referred to that said
employment of Mr. Hoover terminated on the 31st of
December, 1910, and that said Hoover was not thereafter
employed by Minerals Separation, Limited.
Interrogatory No. 4.
(a) Did said Sulman and said Picard, or either of them,
prior to January, 1908, prepare a document or treatise enti-
tled ‘‘The Theory of Concentration Processes Involving Sur-
face Tension’’?
Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers 71
and Objections Thereto
(b) Did said Sulman and said Picard, or either of them,
prior to January, 1908, prepare a document or treatise relat-
ing to the theory of concentration processes involving surface
tension, whatever or however entitled?
(c) If said documents or treatises, or any of them,
referred to under sub-divisions (a) and (b) hereof were so
prepared, did said Sulman and said Picard, or either of them,
deliver an original, or originals, or a copy or copies thereof,
to Minerals Separation, Limited, or any of its officers, and
if so, state what documents or treatises were so delivered and
to whom.
(d) Produce each and every of the documents and trea-
tises referred to under sub-divisions (a) and (b) hereof.
(e) Produce each and every of the notes and memoranda
of research and experiments on surface tension phenomena
in relation to flotation concentration of ores made or written
by, or under the direction of, said Sulman and said Picard,
or either of them.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 4.
With respect to (a), (b), (c) and (d), Theodore J.
Hoover, in a deposition given in a case in which plaintiff
was one of the parties, gave testimony with respect to
this subject-matter and produced a document entitled
as in the interrogatory set forth, concerning which he
testified, which document so produced by him is an
exhibit annexed to said deposition, which latter has been
at defendant’s request stipulated into this case.
With respect to (e) thereof, plaintiff objects on the
ground that the inquiry is too indefinite, too sweeping,
and casts an undue burden upon the plaintiff to ascer-
tain and produce all that the two persons named may
have written upon the subject-matter inquired of.
Interrogatory No. 5.
Did said Sulman and said Picard, or either of them,
or any officer or agent of Minerals Separation, Limited, at
any time during the term of said Hoover’s employment by
——q
72 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answeis
and Objections Thereto
Minerals Separation, Limited, deliver to said Hoover « copy
or copies of the documents or treatises referred to under
Interrogatory No. 4?
(a) If yes, when and by whom was it so deliverec?
Answer to Interrogatory No. 5.
Answered so far as plaintiff is able to do so by
answer to Interrogatory No. 4.
Interrogatory No. 6.
Did said Sulman and said Picard, or either of them,
on or about July 23, 1903, file an application for letters patent
in Great Britain, which application was designated No. 16,285
of 1903, and which application was subsequently abanconed!
(a) If so, produce a true, correct and complete epy of
the specifications and claims, if any, and the drawings, if
any, of such abandoned application, and each and every of —
the letters and correspondence to and from the British ?atent
Office in connection therewith.
(b) If said application was filed, was it filed with the
knowledge and consent of Minerals Separation, Limited, its
predecessor or predecessors?
(c) If said application was filed, produce each anc every
of the correspondence and reports from said Sulmm and
said Picard, or either of them, or their associates, rlating
to pep: 88 with, and the practice of, the severa proc-
esses, and each of them, described therein?
(d) Produce the letter of July 27th, 1903, from G. Vautin
(signed C. V.) to Sulman and Picard (addressed Dez §. &
P.) re Gas Lifting Process; the letter of H. K. Picari to ¢.
Vautin of August 7th, 1903, referring to Froment’s auticipa-
tion of Gas Lifting Process; and the letter of August 4th,
1903, from C. Vautin, referred to in the first line of tie said
letter of August 7th, 1903, from said Picard to said 7autin
Answer to Interrogatory No. 6.
Plaintiff having been incorporated on Decemler 7th,
1916, and not having any document giving the irforma
tion inquired of other than the document prodiced in
Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers 73
and Objections Thereto
connection with this answer, has no knowledge relative
to this subject-matter other than appears in such docu-
ment and in the testimony of William H. Ballantyne in
the suit against Hyde above referred to and the testi-
mony of Sulman, Picard and Ballantyne in the suit of
Wolf Mineral Process Corporation above referred to.
It has in its possession and annexes hereto a certified
copy of the abandoned British application No. 16,285,
filed July 23, 1903, of said Sulman and Picard.
Interrogatory No. 7.
Did Minerals Separation, Limited, ever acquire any
right, title and interest in, to or under British Patent No.
12,778 of 1902 to Alcide Froment?
(a) If so, what was the extent of such right, title and
interest and when was it acquired?
(b) Did Minerals Separation, Limited, bring suit for
infringement of said British Patent No. 12,778 of 1902
against the Ore Concentration Company (1905), Limited, in
the High Court of Justice in England, and if so
(1) State when that suit was brought and when and
how it was terminated.
(2) Describe the process which was alleged in said suit
to be an infringement.
(3) Produce a copy of the writ and statement of claim
and the particulars of breaches filed or delivered by the
plaintiff in such case.
(c) Did Minerals Separation, Limited, its predecessor
or predecessors, bring any other suit or suits for infringe-
ment of said British Patent No. 12,778 of 1902, and if so,
state when such suit or suits were brought, the defendant
or defendants in such suits, describe the processes alleged to
infringe in each such suit, and state when and how such suits
were terminated.
(d) Did Minerals Separation, Limited, its predecessor
or predecessors, maintain the said British Patent N 0. 12,778
of 1902 in force for the full term for which the same was
granted by payment of the annual renewal fees?
—
74 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers
and Objections Thereto
Answer to Interrogatory No. 7.
Plaintiff having been incorporated on December
7th, 1916, and not. having any documents giving the
information, has no knowledge in the respects inquired
of excepting as appears in the testimony of John Ballot
and William H. Ballantyne in the suit against Hyde
above referred to, and the testimony of Henry L. Sul-
man and William H. Ballantyne in the suit of Wolf
Mineral Process Corporation above referred to, and also
excepting such information as may be derived from the
published reports of opinions of the British Courts in
the case referred to.
Interrogatory No. 8.
Did Minerals Separation, Limited, its predecessor or
predecessors, or John Ballot, receive from Alcide Froment
during the year 1903, or the year 1904, a certain written
description, instructions and drawings relating to the con-
centration of minerals?
(a) If so, state when, and produce the original of such
description, instructions and drawings.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 8.
Plaintiff having been incorporated on December 7th,
1916, and not having any documents giving the informa-
tion, has no information in the respect inquired of
excepting as appears in the testimony of H. F. K. Picard,
John Ballot and W. H. Ballantyne in the suit against
Hyde above referred to. The documents requested were
in evidence therein, and in the suits against Butte &
Superior Mining Company and Miami Copper Company,
as Complainants’ Exhibit Froment Description, together
with a translation thereof, Complainants’ Exhibit Fro-
ment Plan and Complainants’ Exhibit Drawing A, and
these documents are in the custody of plaintiff’s counsel
Henry D. Williams, Esq., and will be produced for in-
spection.
2 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers 79
and Objections Thereto
Interrogatory No. 9.
Produce each and every of the correspondence and docu-
ments passing between Minerals Separation, Limited, its
predecessor or predecessors, or its or their agents, and Alcide
Froment, his agent or agents, during the years 1903, 1904,
and 1905.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 9.
Plaintiff having been incorporated on December 7th,
1916, and not having any of the correspondence or docu-
ments which it is requested to produce, can refer only
to the evidence above referred to and to the assignment
from Alcide Froment to John Ballot which was in evi-
dence in the suits against Hyde, Butte & Superior Mining
Company, and Miami Copper Company as Complain-
ants’ Exhibit Assignment Froment to Ballot, November
17th, 1903. This document is in the custody of plaintiff’s
counsel Henry D. Williams, Hsq., and will be produced
for inspection.
Interrogatory No. 10.
Produce each and every of the correspondence and
reports from said Sulman and said Picard, or either of them,
. or their associates, relating to experiments with and the prac-
tice of the several processes, and each of them, described
in letters patent of the United States, No. 793,808, granted
to said Sulman and said Picard, and described in British
patent No. 20,419 of 1903 and in the respective applications
therefor.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 10.
Plaintiff cannot produce what is called for as it does
not possess the same or have the same under its custody
or control.
Interrogatory No. 11.
Produce the three letters from said Sulman and said
Picard to John Ballot, Chairman, Minerals Separation,
—
76 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers
and Objections Thereto
Limited, dated respectively July 14th, 1903, July 27th, 1903,
and August 11th, 1903, referred to in a certain letter from
the same parties to the same addressee dated September 24th,
1903.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 11.
Plaintiff cannot produce what is called for as it does
not possess the same or have the same under its custody
or control.
Interrogatory No. 12.
Produce the original of each and every of the following
reports and documents:
(a) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated March 25,
1903,
(b) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated May 5, 1903,
(c) Sulman ¢ Picard to John Ballot, dated September
24, 1903,
(d) Sulman é Picard to John Ballot, dated November
19, 1903,
(e) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated March 4,
1904,
(f) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated April 19,
1904,
(g) Sulman é Picard to John Ballot, dated May 2, 1904,
(h) Sulman & Picard to Messrs. The Minerals Separa-
tion, Limited, dated May 18, 1904,
(i) Sulman & Picard to Messrs. Minerals Separation,
Limited, dated February 17, 1905,
(j) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated February
21, 1905.
(k) The report of Mr. Higgins, presumably bearing date
of February 20, 1905, referred to in the Sulman & Picard
Report, dated February 21, 1905.
(1) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated March 3,
1905
,
(m) The report of A. Howard Higgins, of March 2, 1905,
together with curve diagrams, referred to in said Sulman &
Picard Report, dated March 3, 1905.
Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers 77
and Objections Thereto
(n) The report of A. Howard Higgins, of March 16,
1905, entitled ‘‘ Further Report on Conditions of Granulation,
March 16, 1905. Influence of the Percentage of Oil,’’ and all
correspondence between Minerals Separation, Limited, or its
officers, and the said Higgins, or said Sulman and said Picard,
or either of them, relating to said report,
(0) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated May 3, 1905,
(p) Sulman & Picard to John Ballot, dated May 16, 1902.
(q) The report or paper addressed to ‘‘The Board of
Directors, Minerals Separation, Limited,’’ dated December
3, 1910, by Edward H. Nutter.
Note.—state what relations, if any, existed between said
Nutter and Minerals Separation, Limited, during the year
1910, and what relations, if any, exist between the plaintiff
and said Nutter at the present time.
(r) Each and every of the reports of George A. Chap-
man to C. F. Courtney and each and every of the reports of
said Chapman or said Courtney to Minerals Separation,
Limited, or to any of its officers during each of the years
1904 to 1908, inclusive, relating to the Cattermole process,
or the process of United States Letters Patent No. 835,120,
or to modifications of either of said processes, and all corre-
spondence between said parties and Minerals Separation,
Limited, or any of its officers, relating to said reports or said
processes. :
Note.—State what relations, if any, existed between said
Chapman and said Courtney and Minerals Separation,
Limited, or its officers, during each of the years from 1904
to 1909, inclusive.
(s) Each and every of the reports of said Chapman and
said Higgins to Minerals Separation, Limited, or any of its
officers during the years 1908 and 1909 relating to the proc-
esses of Letters Patent of the United States Nos. 835,120 and
962,678, or modifications of either of said processes, and all
correspondence between said parties relating to said reports
or said processes.
—
78 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers
and Objections Thereto
Answer to Interrogatory No. 12.
Plaintiff having been incorporated on December 7,
1916, and not having any documents giving the infor-
mation, has no knowledge in the respect inquired of
excepting as follows: the documents called for, or copies
thereof, were in evidence in the suits against Hyde, Butte
& Superior Mining Company and Miami Copper Com-
pany above referred to in respect to (a) to (j) inclusive,
(1), (m) (excepting the curve diagrams), (n) (the report
referred to and two letters of Minerals Separation,
Limited, dated March 3 and March 6, 1905, but no other
letters of the correspondence referred to, if any such
existed), (0), (q) (with respect to the note, Edward H.
Nutter in the suit against Hyde above referred to gave
testimony with regard to the relations inquired of
between himself and Minerals Separation, Limited. Said
Nutter at the present time is chief engineer of the plain-
tiff), (r) (only the report of George A. Chapman to
Theodore J. Hoover, Manager of Minerals Separation,
Limited, dated August 16, 1907; with respect to the
note, said Chapman and John Ballot in the suit against
Hyde above referred to testified as to relations between
said Chapman and C. F. Courtney and Minerals Separa-
tion, Limited, during a part of the period inquired of).
With respect to (s), this part of the interrogatory
is objected to as an attempt on the part of the defendant
to obtain from the plaintiff information in respect of
evidence or testimony which plaintiff may use in support
of plaintiff’s case, and as not a legitimate use of inter-
rogatories to obtain discovery to which defendant is
entitled.
Interrogatory No, 12.
Produce the note book given Mr. John Ballot by said
Arthur Edward Cattermole during 1902 or 1903, which note
book contained an exposition of the Cattermole process, being
a résumé of notes from Mr. Cattermole’s note books.
| Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers 79
and Objections Thereto
Answer to Interrogaiory No. 13.
In the suit above referred to of Wolf Mineral Proc-
ess Corporation against plaintiff, Arthur Edward Catter-
mole testified that he had given to Mr. John Ballot a
note book such as is called for and such note book is in
evidence therein and is in the custody of Henry D.
Williams, Esq., counsel for the plaintiff, and will be pro-
duced for inspection.
Interrogatory No, 14.
Produce the note book of said George Albert Chapman
entitled or relating to ‘‘ Australian Ore Concentration Syndi-
cate-Results of Experimental Work’’ and ‘‘Work on the
Scammel Oil Process Commenced February 9, 1903.’’
Answer to Interrogatory No. 14.
In the suit above referred to of Wolf Mineral Proc-
ess Corporation against the plaintiff a laboratory note
book of Messrs. Sulman & Picard, entitled as stated in
the interrogatory, is in evidence and is in the custody of
Henry D. Williams, Esq., counsel for the plaintiff, and
will be produced for the inspection of defendant. Plain-
tiff has no knov'ledge of any other note book so entitled.
Interrogatory No, 15.
Is said Henry Livingstone Sulman the same Henry Liv-
ingstone Sulman named or described in Letters Patent of
Great Britain No. 27,749 of 1913, and Letters Patent of Aus-
tralia No. 12,416 of 1914, relating to the concentration of
ores?
Answer to Interrogatory No. 15.
Since plaintiff was incorporated on December 7,
1916, and has no documents giving the information, it
has no knowledge, but upon information and belief
answers Yes.
—
80 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers
and Objections Thereto
Interrogatory No. 16.
Produce a duly certified copy of the file wrapper and con.
tents of application for Letters Patent of the United States,
Serial No. 872,470, referred to as ‘‘ Aqueous Extract of Oil”
in the bill of sale to plaintiff from Minerals Separation
American Syndicate (1913), Limited.
Note.—In lieu of a duly certified copy, give defendant's
counsel an order and power addressed to the Commissioner
of Patents to inspect and make copies of the file wrapper and
contents of said application.
(a) If said application was filed in the name of Henry
Livingstone Sulman, is he the same Henry Livingstone Sul-
man hereinbefore inquired about and one of the joint pat-
entees of the patent in syit No. 962,678?
Answer to Interrogatory No. 16.
Plaintiff objects to this interrogatory upon the
ground that the defendant is not entitled to the doeu-
ment requested and that the contents of the same are
immaterial and irrelevant to any issue herein, but plain-
tiff will give defendant’s counsel the order and power
requested.
With respect to (a) the answer is Yes.
Interrogatory No. 17.
Is said Arthur Howard Higgins the same Arthur Howard
Higgins named or described in Letters Patent of Great
Britain No. 26,852 of 1908?
(a) If so, when did said Higgins next prior to December
10, 1908, leave England for Australia and when did he next
thereafter arrive in England?
(b) Produce the original communication from said Hig-
gins upon which the provisional specification of British Pat-
ent No. 26,852 of 1908 was based.
(c) Produce each and every communication relating to
the subject matter of British Patent No. 26,852 of 1908, and .
to the subject matter of the patent in suit No. 962,678,
between said Higgins and (1) Minerals Separation, Limited,
(2) said Sulman, and (3) said Greenway.
Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers 81
and Objections Thereto
Answer to Interrogatory No. 17.
Since plaintiff was incurporated on December 7,
1916, and has no documents giving the information, it
has no knowledge, but upon information and belief
answers Yes as to the first paragraph of said interroga-
tory.
With respect to (a), since plaintiff was incorporated
on December 7, 1916, and has no documents giving the
information, it has no knowledge and is without infor-
mation except as has appeared in the testimony in the
suits above referred to.
With respect to (b) and (c), this part of the inter-
rogatory is objected to as an attempt on the part of the
defendant to obtain from the plaintiff information in
respect of evidence or testimony which plaintiff may use
in support of plaintiff’s case, and as not a legitimate use
of interrogatories to obtain discovery to which defend-
ant is entitled.
Interrogatory No. 18.
Is said Henry Livingstone Sulman the same Henry Liv-
ingstone Sulman who obtained Letters Patent of the United
States No. 955,012, dated April 12, 1910, and (with said
Picard) Letters Patent of Great Britain No. 28,173 of 1908?
(a) Did Minerals Separation, Limited, obtain German
Patent No. 226,096 for an invention substantially correspond-
ing with the supposed invention of said United States Letters
Patent No. 955,012 and British Patent No. 28,173 of 1908?
Answer to Interrogatory No. 18.
Since plaintiff was incorporated on December 7,
1916, and has no documents giving the information, it
has no knowledge, but upon information and belief
answers Yes as to the first paragraph of the interroga-
tory.
With respect to (a), since plaintiff was incorporated
on December 7, 1916, and has no documents giving the
information, it has no other or further knowledge than
can be obtained from a copy of said German patent, and
—ay
82 Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’s Answers
and Objections Thereto
furthermore said interrogatory is objectionable as call-
ing upon the plaintiff to make a comparison or a deter.
mination with respect to different documents which it is
not the right of the defendant to require plaintiff to
make.
Interrogatory No. 19.
Did said Sulman, or said Higgins, or said Greenway or
Minerals Separation, Limited, make application for patent
in Germany for any of the supposed inventions described in
British Patents Nos. 26,852 of 1908, 28,173 of 1908, and 2,359
of 1909? ee |
(a) If so, what Letters Patent of Germany were granted
on any such applications?
(b) With respect to each and every such application so
filed in Germany and upon which no patent was granted,
produce a true, correct and complete copy of the specifica-
tions and claims, if any, and the drawings, if any, of the
application, and each and every of the letters and corre
spondence to and from the German Patent Office in connec
tion therewith.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 19.
Since plaintiff was incorporated on December 7,
1916, and has no documents giving the information, and
has no such documents as are called for in this inter-
rogatory, it therefore cannot produce the same or give
the information asked for.
Interrogatory No. 20.
Were said Sulman or said Greenway, or either of them,
in Australia (1) during 1908, and (2) during 1909, and if 0,
give the precise dates when either or both (1) left England
and arrived in Australia and (2) left Australia and arrived
in England.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 20.
Since plaintiff was incorporated on December /,
1916, and has no documents giving the information, it
Defendant’s Interrogatories and Plaintiff’’s Answers 83
and Objections Thereto
Interrogatory No, 21.
Produce each and every report and communication, not
already called for herein, relating to any and all work in
British Patents No. 26,852 of 1908; No, 28,173 of 1908, and
No. 2,359 of 1909, made by, under the direction of, or to said
Sulman, said Greenway, said Higgins, said Stevens and Min-
erals Separation, Limited, including the following reports to
Minerals Separation, Limited:
(1) Tests using carbolic acid, dated 11-12-08 (including
laboratory reports dated 8-12-08 ; 9-12-08) ;
(2) Further tests using carbolic acid, dated 11-12-08
(including laboratory reports entitled ‘Results of Tests o
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.