Transcript of Record — Standard Oil Co. v. Marysville
Supreme Court brief1929
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(33,854)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITEDSTATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1928
No. 545
STANDARD OIL COMPANY AND SINCLAIR
REFINING COMPANY, PETETIONERS,
vs,
CITY OF MARYSVILLE, L. N. COLE, AS MAYOR;
R. EK. LONG, ET AL, ETC.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARL TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
OOURT OF APPEALS Pok THE MIGHTH CIROUIT
INDEX
Origine! Print
Proceedings in the United States circuit court of upyoorn ts,
eighth cirowit ‘ wie a 1
Caption , comittied in printing) a
Rewrd frem the district court ef the Dnited States, district
of Kanewe ay Seaeb ie i 1
(Vation and ser hw jomlited jo printing? 1
Amended iii of complaiut tn care No, GN... - 1
Amended til of complaint in case No (tN i mW v
Order comudidating causes and appointing apecial
maecter , ; ; ‘ ie i”
Anewer in case No Giz N : ™ mt)
Anewer in case No GN ie 11 27
Findings of fact avd comctustons of law of special master 34 aS)
Ordinance No, 300 of City of Maryevillk . Sh) BT
Ordinance Ne 237 of City of Marysville ' a7 3
Recommendations of spectal marter sae ow “
F mE owe - a eamaenel
ey diem & leer: tinct, Praatemn, Wasuinotos, DC. Janvany 30, 1920
Re ars
i xD.
Ortginal
Faceytivus of defemlant ta repent of spoctal maater,..- a
Paceptivas of plaintiffs to reqert of syavtal taster 7a
Motion of plaintiffs te cuniri report of spectal master *
Onter of reviver apd striking porthn of repert af
agewial maaster..-. cares : ; P 7s
lector cee Are er ae ve ae ~~
Opdabor: Polterk, J... cake uweund® ; sh si
Petition for appeal and carcher alice bing sae tite ~~
Assignimett wf errurs....--+- f a}
Petad oes appeal... jomittet te prdaniag? “.
Comateasend ota ttetst ef eviticors tw
Capthe ; ‘ 4 jew
Yeetimenmy for pialatifts yea
Teetimeay of FP thane Je went
Makiban A--Map of City wf Marysville
Kaneas : ees
Testimony of C. 1 Wagerct ; Thad
Fabita, BB Pietegraph>s of Ms Lm stua bet
Pragdes (i Tank Vale iu}
Pahibar Co - Mietograye: «t mmatbake vet Pe hg
Pestimany of Hey ( tooe ; | a
A 3 Bexwde ae |
4 OM Peehienes ) eae
3. F. leyer ‘™
Bahita: | ta
Ordinate No SIT of 1D of Marys
ule 145 145
Ordinewe No Ser af City f Maro»
silhe aa ie ri
Teotioewny of & Y Ment 546 ie
Habitats A te & Mesmoremiums ao te ies wa
Teetimesy of Wilthass ¥ Pert ite bee |
A Eheope ieee vied rh)
& 3 Pirwweke yam 140%
4 ot thetthe 141 a
CM Wagwee (fecatiet: lee yes
Pabitete © amt P Prewing eteow bee
Magorterd (Mi tC eeE pn? Safets Valre fot
tect teremial et ear tanks > see
Teatiaones <f 1 HO Peete? a pewe lkewd + wet ict
joe OG tianaliet Te we
taux W ametet Ts 32
Withee FO Pieewes 1 163
um Of lew 10% ”~
‘ 1 Wager 4 cewse Theo & i tie
Tectiamay of he feewkasts yas ae
Testiames of (© F Traveiate pea a»
Vabtitte 1 act t Meweeteodua af te tie we
Toetimomy of ©. ewer 3 an
Pahitet 1 agro se of porte of OH? of
Marpariiie, showing palitond trecke ote a6 7.
INDEX.
Original! Priat
Testimony of ©. bh. Dravetute (recalled)... ., 214 21s
ee. er erer: See rt via 219
A. 4, Beatard.. ..6sssa0> eres Zee 228
BE, GD, Thee. ce nrc rcccsescses 237 pA vd
Hieury (Quinley pps ms} | =
Marry Frankenstein, ........--.- pon | 241
Hierm RKeuffer.. Leeuasbaeaseeas 237 2
Harrys Frapkenstein ¢recalled).., 242 be
M W. Srath es hemeeds nan 242 aM
NE... cc adesaeeeapeiesauns 246 mate |
Pahdbit O) Adidayit of Michael Wehoer aD) aol
Testimeny of James Joseph Love : po 4 21
G Lo Penwiek ¢rewalied)...... 5 2s
Prank King : ; wu 2
% FF Bowwan creeaiied:.... a6 277
James Wo Camiypbel! wer Tri 270
Purther testineny for plaintiffs on peapeatig of cae 200 a2
Testimony of Wo it) Tasker ia% TT TTY 0 ose
Further testimany for defendants : arr oN
Testimony of Pred tb. Arnatrong 275 oN
bahiint Po lerawing shewing heation of
tanks amd surrounding» at Greenleaf
hanna eae wee mare) el
Bahituts. I to No -d*betographs showing pre
sult of fine at Greenleaf, Kansas ; vas pet)
Testimnens of Bart 1) Parvio D7 pt) |
Further testimony for plaintiff. ' vie : ws wa
Testimeans of HR Boehmer at) we
Purther testimeny for defetulant> : : mod ™Hy
Pestimony of Hamilton Perkins Cady ae my
Purtivd fertinnwis fer piniotiff, im retuttal Nis mT)
festimens of Reilie Ko Terrill . ee Sas Te
Testimony of Tp TP Site ‘ oe bt) R27
Further testimens for defendants 419 ws
Testimeny of FP. Tewman + S18 S28
Vis 2. Mitmagemcen ; ps ve mw
1% A lawir , say BOS
Alex Peadeteon ‘ mah ory
Nathan Go Hurgete Mi ine
4 C Patriea ed ry
Nathan G Burgeter crecalled: Bos av
James Wo Campbell , ies uv2
iaey Chime . wy a7h
Purther teetimeany for phabatitts ae nisee
Teetimons of A 3 Brooke : : . eh eat
Pahita: | Ievawlng representing boom thet
of tanks and warehouse ot Greenest
Kanes
iv INDEX.
Testimony of PL. Ring... esehns
A J. Brooks cometied)
H.C. Griffly......-- see eres
Williaa F Parti
Pabitde KK Drawing shewing cresecut
view of mwankeole ated hewtion of Me-
jeenabt Drupies Vewt ot tank of Sinclair
Ht Company, Maryevilie. Ki atina>
Testimony of 1 1 BKerhener
Testimeny of CH Wagner ms
Habitat SB Drawing showing materiale
uwel for growneding dca
Poa thiteit TY terawing slew ing espace!
greweding taywut fer “Hi stallions
tahites t traveling showing detalii of up
Leeting greamdlng des tor
Pabitee V Perewiang = store lag detail af
itek gteanding dew ew
frotimeay of A S Phe dino
Apgvvval of pemetoteed statetwemt of eviderw try dis
triet fretge
Leefermiants’ ptwwtier feet trace riya
Pialutitte pewvige for (rane ryt ;
Cherk’s cortigeate iomittied in printing?
Apewre ret o> af cxeegreeed comitied te printicg!
Argaseret anal suban. rein Ceoggittesd tm porteeticg *
(inden, Yan Velkertargh J
LHieeemibtg opbrbord PRilttyes J
{ werreer
Petition fhe metwartas jommittert in printing *
treet denying tetemering
Motion go stay mandate
iteter efaying toa aehate
Previge fur trecettyt af reword
CBerh's corti ete Committed tes pefeting?
drecket? allow ing cortic¢van
Original Priet
si6 S87
wie oN
mT ot)
37s ome
wl
os
7
“er
“we
wn
wee
aii
aus
ana
aia
ant
Po
te
ae
4“
aan
aan
[Caption omitted]
{fol.1] Citation, in usual form, showing service on Earle
W. Thomas and Thomas F. Doran, filed June 5, 1926,
omitted in printing.
{fol. 2]
IN UNJTED STATES DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF
KANSAS, FIRST DIVISION
No. 652-N. In Equity
Sranpanp Our Comrany, a Corporation, Plaintiff,
vs.
Ture Crry or Manysvirwe, Kansas; Cuances FL Travecore,
Mavor; Leonard Cole, E. G. Filbert, Ed Hall, Paul Kirk-
patrick, Osear Terry, T. J. Austin, and Harry Thomp-
son, Councilmen; Edgar C. Bennett, City Attorney; and
IP. Haves, Marshal, of said City of Marysville, Marshall
County, Kansas, Defendants
Amenpen Bir. or Compiaint—Filed Oct. 11, 1924
This cause being called for hearing at Kansas City, Kan-
sas, on October 6th, 1924, and it having been made to ap.
pear from statements of counsel that the following changes
should be made and errors corrected in the personnel and
names of the parties named as defendants in the original
Bill of Complaint herein, to-wit:
I’. T. Burk, Sr., has been replaced as councilman of the
City of Marysville, Kansas, and the name of Oscar Terry
should be and is hereby substituted therefor.
The name of T. J. Austin should be and the same is
added as a defendant councilman.
[fol. 3) Leave of Court having been first obtained to make
the above substitutions and corrections, plaintiff files this
its Amended Bill of Complaint herein, and alleges ;
I
That the matter in controversy herein exceeds the sum
or value of Three Thousand Dollars, exclusive of interest
and costa,
il
That the cause of action herein set out arises under the
constitution and laws of the United States.
Il
That there is a diversity of citizenship between plaintiff
and each of the defendants 4 hereinafter specifically
shown.
IV
That this action is brought
A. For the purpese of procuring an order and decree of
this court declaring void Ordinance Number Three Hun.
dred fifty of the Ordinances of the City of Marysville, Kan-
«as, for the reasons and upon the grounds that
(1) Tt is in contra ention of the rights of this plaintiff
under the provisions of Section One of the Fourteenth
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States which
provides that
“No state shall make or enforee any law which shall
abridge the privileges or immunities of Citizens of the
United States; ner shall any State deprive any person of
life, liberty, or property, without dne process of law; ner
deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protec:
tion of the laws.”
(2) It is repugnant to the rights of this plaintiff under
the common law and under the constitution and laws of the
State of Kansas;
i3) The action of the defendant city in passing, of at.
tempting tas Pees entice, Ba atal i gifra vires atid waited ord
nance therefore invalid, because of lack of antecedent legis
lative authority conferring upon it power ta pase name
(4) Same is so arbitrary, capricious, Ajecriminatery, un-
rensonable and subversive of private rights as to be a clear
{fol. 4] abuse, inatend of a bona fide exercise of power and
as to deny piaintiff the equal protection of the laws and
Ane process of law scented to it by the provisions af See.
tion One of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitu-
tion of the United States above quoted and to be void under
the Constitution and laws of the State of Kansas;
B. For the purpose of procuring an order and decree
of this court restraining and perpetually enjoining the
defendants and each of them, from enforcing said void
ordinance.
V
That the plaintiff is a corporation duly chartered, organ-
ized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the
state of Indiana, and at all of the times hereinafter men-
tioned was duly licensed and authorized to engage in busi-
ness in Kansas as a foreign corporation, and was and is
“#ooitiven and resident of the State of Indiana and no other
state,
VI
That the defendant, the City of Marysville, Kansas, is
a city of the second class, duly organized and existing under
and by virtue of and subject to the constitution and laws of
the state of Kansas, and is now, and at all of the times
hereinafter set forth, was a resident and citizen of the
state of Kansas and of the First Division of the District
of Kansas, and was not and is not a resident or citizen of
any other state,
Vil
That the individual defendants herein are the duly
elected, qualified and acting officials of the City of Marys.
ville, Kansas, respectively, as set out and shown in the
tithe of this cumse, and that each one of them is a citizen and
resident of the state of Kansas, and of the First Division
of the Distriet of Kansas, and ix not a resident or citizen of
any other state,
Vill
- That plaintiff is now and for more than ten years last
past cas hoon continuously engaged in the business of sell-
ing and storing for «ale and distribution various products
of petroleum, and in the usnal course thereef hax stored
and kept ond is now storing and keeping in tanks con-
4
structed above ground in various towns and cities of the
state of Kansas, including the city of Marysville, Kansas,
large quantities of gasoline and kerosene, to-wit: More than
five hundred gallons in each of such tanks.
{fol. 5] 1X
That said tanks so used by plaintiff as aforesaid, and
each and all of them, are equipped and at all times have
heen constructed, maintained and operated with the most
meadern, efficient and best safety apphances and devices
known and in a prudent, «killful and safe manner,
X
That the storage and keeping of said products in such
tanks so equipped and maintained and operated, adjacent
to railroads and railroad switches within cities and towns,
including the city of Mary «ville, Kansas, is now and for
more than ten years last past has heen a safe, useful con
nt and practice of plaintiff's
luring said period and now is
required by modern methods of commerce, transportation
and habits of life and has been established, maintained and
universally recognized throughout the state of Kansas and
the United States as a necessary and legitimate means of
conducting said business and same in no way infringes
upon, injures OF niversely affects the health, morals, safety
or welfare of indis duals or the public
Xl
venient and necessary incide
said basiness, and has been «
That the plaintiff is now and for more than ten years lant
past has been transacting its said business and in the regu
lar course thereof has maintained and operated a» afore
said tanks of the kind and character aforesaid in the said
city of Mary sville, upon the following described real estate
occupied by plaintef? ander a written lease from the Union
Parifie Railroad Company, the owner thereof, to-wit:
Beginning at a pent that is in the southeast corner of
Lot Twelve, Bleck Forty, (riginal Town of Marveville,
Kansas, thence yerth along east line of said Lot Twelve
Seventy-one feet toa point; thence west at right angles to
initial course forty-four and three-tenths feet to a point
distant eight and five-tenths feet easterly from center line
of west leg of Old Wye Track of Manhattan Branch, at
right angles thereto thence southwesterely parallel to and
distant eight and five-tenths feet from center line of said
Wye Track, seventy-four and five-tenths feet to the south
line of said Block Forty; thence east along said south line
of said Block Forty, seventy-two and two-tenths feet to a
point of beginning.
{fol. 6] XII
That the storage tanks now upon said above described
real estate, or others of somewhat similar character and con
struction have been maintained and operated as aforesaid
upon said premises continuously for more than ten years
prior to the passage of said Ordinance number Three hun.
dred fifty with the knowledge, approval and consent of the
defendant city and without accident, or injury to persons
or property, and that said business and the said use and
maintenance of such tanks during all of said time has been
and is now being carried on in a safe, sanitary and legiti.
tate way.
XIII
That the said tanks and places of business of the plaintiff
aforesaid are located upon a spur or side track of the
Union Pacific Railroad Company outside of the fire limits
established by the mayor and council of the city of Marys-
ville, and in a sparsely occupied section of said city and not
in close proximity to buildings of other persons, firms or
corporations.
XIV
That in July, 1914, the Mayor and council of the city of
Marysville, regularly passed and published Ordinance Two
hundred thirty seven of the Ordinances of the City of
Maryeville, Kansas, and that Section four thereof reads as
follows;
‘Section 4. Tanks may be constructed in the building if
buried at least three feet below the lowest floor thereof, and
isolated tanks constructed for the storage of gasoline, fuel
oil and motor spirits in quantities of 5000 gallons or more,
6
may be constructed above ground at such locations as the
Mayor and City Council may determine. Provided a per-
mit designating the location and manner of construction
must be procured from the Mayor and City Council there-
for, before the construction of such tanks. Provided
further, a permit for the maintenance of isolated tanks
built upon the surface and now located within said city, if
properly safeguarded, will be issued."’
A true and correct copy of said ordinance marked Ex
hibit ‘A’, is attached to the original Bill of Complaint
herein, and asked to be read as a part hereof.
XV
That permits were duly and regularly issued to plaintiff
under and as provided for in said Ordinance number Two
(fol. 7} hundred thirty seven, and that same remained in
force avd effect until the passage of Ordinance Number
Three hundred fifty hereinafter referred to.
XVI
That on to wit, the eighth day of October, 1923, the mayor
and couneil of the defendant city passed and published in-
sofar as they could legally do so Ordinance number Three
hundred fifty of the Ordinances of the City of Marysville,
Kansas, being the ordinance complained of herein. A
true and correct copy of said ordinance, marked Exhibit
“BR, is attached to the original Bill of Complaint, herem
and asked to he read as a part hereof,
XVII
That the provisions of said Ordinance number Three hun
dred fifty are discriminatery and deny to this plaintiff the
equal protection of the laws under said Section One of the
Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United
States in that Section One of said Ordinance required this
plaintiff te bury its said oi! tanks three feet ander yround
while Section three of said ordinance provides:
“Seetion 3. This ordinance shall in no case apply to the
storage of anycrude oil, distillate or fuel oil in containers of
‘
a capacity of 500 gallons or less, but only one such 500 gal-
lon container shall be permitted on each premises, nor, shall
it apply to the storage of gasoline, kerosene or naphtha in
quantities of less than ten gallons, all of which commodities
in the quantities mentioned and permitted by this section
shall be kept and stored in the manner provided by exist-
ing ordinance.”’
XVIII
That the provisions of said Ordinance number Three hun-
dred fifty requiring tanks of the kind and character used by
the plaintiff in the City of Marysville aforesaid to be buried
underneath the ground are arbitrary, unreasonable and im-
possible of performance in that plaintiff's said tanks can-
not be operated and maintained when so buried, and that
the enforcement thereof therefore will result in the absolute
confiscation of plaintiff’. said property.
XIX
That it is more dangerous from the standpoint of the
health and safety of the public to establish, maintain and
operate oil tanks of the kind and for he purposes aforesaid
{fol. 8] under the ground than above ground in the manner
that plaintiff is now maintaining and operating same as
aforesaid in the said city of Marysville and elsewhere.
XX
That said Ordinance number Three hundred fifty herein
complained of and the enforcement of which is herein
sought to be enjoined, prohibits plaintiff from maintaining
and operating oil storage tanks of the kind and character
aforesaid at any point within the corporate limits of the
City of Marysville, Kansas, unless same shall be buried
under the ground as aforesaid. That the said City of
Marysville contains within its corporate limits numerous
tracts of ground that are wholly vacant and used exclusively
for agricultural purposes and each of which is of from one
to ten acres in area. That said ordinance is so arbitrary
and unreasonable in its provisions as to prohibit plaintiff
from using any one of same to establish, maintain and
operate its said business and with said tanks thereon above
ground, although that could be done without any possible
injury or damage to either persons or property.
XX!
Plaintiff respectfully shows that said Ordinance number
Three hundred fifty is so arbitrary and unreasonable, that
it will drive this plaintiff's said business and that of others
engaged in the same business aforesaid, from the city limits
of the City of Marysville, or cause it and them to establish,
maintain and operate oil tanks under the ground in a man
ner less safe than the one now employed by plaintiff a>
aforesaid, and if same is enforced it will result in the con
fixcation of plaintiff's property in violation of the prov!
sions of the Federal Constitution hereinbefore set out and
quoted.
xxl
That the penalties fixed by Section Five of said Ord
nance number Three hundred fifty are unreasonable and
arbitrary in that
‘Any person, firm or corporation violating an
provisions of this eridinance shall upon conviction
judged to pay a fine of $25.00 for each violation, and each
day that any of the commodities herein referred to are
stored in violation of the terms hereof shall constitute a
separate and distinct offense hereunder.”’
{fol. 9} XXIII
That the officers of the City of Marysville, here: named
are threatening and attempting to enforce said ordinance
That they have caused the arrest of an employee of the
plaints? on a warrant charging him with the violation
thereof. That be and other employees and agents of plain
nf are threatened with repeated arrests and fines under
the provisions of said ordinance and the plaintiff has ne
adequate remedy at law. That «aid void ordinance will
le enforced against plaintiff and its officers, agents and em
ployees unless prevented by the equitable order of this
J each and all
qourt restraining and enjoining said city anc
of ite officers and agents from enforcing, or attempting to
enforce, same.
’ of the
be ad
9
Wherefore, plaintiff prays (a) that said ordinance num-
ber Three hundred fifty of the City of Marysville, Kansas,
be declared and decreed by this court to be arbitrary, un-
reasonable, discriminatory, confiscatory of plaintiff's prop-
erty in violation of plaintiff's rights under the constitution
and laws of the United States and the common law, consti-
tution and laws of the state of Kansas, and void; (b) that
the defendants, and each of them, on presentation of this
duly verified bill be restrained from enforcing or attempt-
ing to enforce said ordinance and that this cause be set
down for hearing on the application for temporary injune-
tion at an early date, and that on said hearing, a temporary
injunction be granted, and that on the final hearing herein,
said temporary injunction be made perpetual; (c) that sub-
poena issue out of this Honorable Court directed to each
and all of the defendants, not heretofore served herein, to-
wit: Oskar Terry and T. J. Austin, requiring and com-
manding them, and each of them, to appear in this case on
a day certain and answer the several allegations of this
Amended Bill of Complaint, (unless they shall forthwith
enter their appearance herein), answer under oath being
hereby expressly waived; (d) Plaintiff further prays for
such other and further relef in the premises as to this
Honorable Court may seem equitable and just in the pre-
THI BeS,
Vermillion, Evans, Carey & Lilliston, Attorneys for
Miaintiff, Wichita, Kansas.
Duly sworn to by Earle W. Evans. Jurat omitted in
printing
lfol, 10] Ix Usrren States Disrucr Cour
No, 653-N. In Equity
Sivciam Rerixtixa Company, a Corporation, Plaintiff,
va.
Tee Cory or Manvevirwe, Kansas: Coances FL Travecore,
Mayor; Leonard Cole, kG. Filbert, Kd Hall, Paul Kirk-
patrick, Oscar Terry, T. J. Austin, and Harry Thomp-
son, Councilmen; Edgar C. Bennett, City Attorney ; and
I’. Hayes, Marshal of said City, Defendants
10
Awenpen But or Comriaint Filed Oct, 11, 1924
This cause being called for hearing at Kansas City, Kan.
sas, on October 6th, 1924, and it having been made to ap-
pear from statements of counsel that the following changes
should be made and errors corrected in the personnel and
names of the parties named as defendants in the original
Bill of Complaint herein, to-wit:
P. T. Burk, Sr., has been replaced as councilman of the
city of Marysville, Kansas, and the name of Oscar Terry
should be and is hereby substituted therefor.
The name of Harry Thompson ix erroneously stated in
the original bill of complaint as Henry Thompson, and the
(fol. 11} name of Henry Thompson should be and is cor-
rected to read Harry Thompson.
The name of T. J. Austin should be and the same is
added as a defendant councilman.
The name of P. Haines, erroneously appears in the orig-
inal bill of complaint as Marshal of the City of Marysville,
Kansas. Said name should be and is corrected to read P.
Hayes.
Leave of the Court having heen frst obtained to make
the above substitutions and corrections, plaintiff files this
ite amended bill of complaint herein, and alleges:
That the matter in controversy in this cause exceeds the
eum of Three Thousand ($3,080) Dollars exclusive of
interest and costs.
That the cause of action herom set out arises under the
Constitation and laws of the United States.
lil
That there t» diversity of citirenship between plaintfl
and each of the defendants as heremafter specifically
shown.
IV
That this action t+ bronagh!,
A. For the purperr of procurng an order and decree of
this court declaring void Ordinance No. 350 of the Ord
nances of the City of Maryss ile, Kanaas;
11
(1) As in contravention of the rights of this plaintiff
under the provisions of Section one of the Fourteenth
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, which
provides that:
**No State shall make or enforce any law which shall
abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the
United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of
life, liberty, or property, without due process of law, nor
deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal pro-
tection of the laws.”’
{fol. 12) (2) As repugnant to the rights of this plaintiff
under the common law and under the Constitution and
Laws of the State of Kansas.
(3) As ultra vires the powers of the Mayor and council-
men o” the City of Marysville, Kansas, to pass such ordi-
nance, and therefore void and invalid because of lack of
antecedent legislative authority conferring upon said
Mayor and councilmen power to pass the same.
(4) As so arbitrary, capricious, discriminatory, unrea-
sonable, and subversive of private rights as to be a clear
abuse rather than a bona fide exercise of power, and as to
deny the plaintiff the equal protection of the laws and due
process of law secured to it by the provisions of Section
one of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of
the United States, above quoted, and for the same reasons
void uoder the Constitution and Laws of the State of Kan-
mah.
IB. For the purpose of precuring an order and decree of
this court restraining and permanently enjoining the de-
fendants and each of them from enforcing said void ordi
nahee.
Vv
Miaitifl, Sinclair Rethung Company, is a corporation
duly organized and existing onder the Laws of the State of
Mains, and daly licensed and authorized to engage in busi-
tess in the State of Kansas as a foreign corporation, and
said company now is and was at all times herein mentioned
a citizen and resident of the State of Maine and of no other
State.
12
VI
That the defendant City of Marysville, Kansas, is a city
of the second class, duly organized and existing under and
subject to the Constitution and Laws of the State of Kan-
sas, and therefore is now and at all times hereinafter set
forth has been a resident and citizen of the State of Kan-
sas and of the First Division of the District of Kansas, and
is not and has not been a resident or citizen of any other
State or Federal judicial District.
Vil
That the individual defendants herein are the duly
elected, qualified and acting officers of the City of Marys-
ville, Kansas, respectively, ar set out and shown in the tle
{fol. 13] of this cause; that each of them is a citizen and
resident of the State of Kansas and of the First Division
of the United States District Court for the District of
Kansas, and is not a resident or citizen of any other State.
Vul
Sinclair Refining Company, among other things is now
and has been for many years engaged in the business of
storing gasoline, kerosene, distillate and crude oil in large
steel tanks constructed above ground, and in selling and
distributing said products therefrom in various cities and
towns of Kansas and of the United States including the
City of Marysville, Kansas; that its storage tanks above
ground in Marysville, Kansas, have a capacity of more than
40) gallons cach.
IX
That the said storage tanks se used by plaintiff in Marys.
ville, Kansas, are and each of them is constructed, equipped
and maintained and operated with the most modern, efficient
and best safety appliances and devices known, and said
tanks are operated in a careful, sanitary and safe manner,
x
That the storage of said prodocts in said tanks #0
equipped maintained and operated above groand adjacent
13
to railroads and railroad switches within cities and towns of
the State of Kansas and throughout the United States, in-
eluding the City of Marysville, Kansas, is and for more than
ten years last past has been a safe, useful, convenient and
necessary incident and practice of the business of the plain-
tiffs and of others engaged in the same business,and has been
during said period and now is required by modern methods
of commerce, transportation and habits of life; that said
business has during said period been established, main-
tained and universally recognized throughout the State of
Kansas and the United States as a necessary and legitimate
business, and as conducted by the plaintiff in the City of
Marysville, Kansas, said business in no way infringes upon,
injures or adversely affects the health, morals, safety or
welfare of individuals or of the public.
XI
Plaintiff, Sinclair Refining Company, pursuant to ite well
recognized and established right to carry on the business
of storing said products in storage tanks erected above
ground, on the 28th of November, 1916, purchased from the
(fol. 14] Exchange Bank, of Schmidt and Koester, Lot No.
9, in Block 71 in Marysville, Kansas, which said lot was con-
veyed to plaintiff by said Bank in fee simple by warranty
deed. That at the time of said purchase by plaintiff there
were located upon said Lot No. 9 the steel tanks now owned
and operated by the plaintiff herein for storing said prod-
ucts above mentioned; that said tanks had been constructed
for and used in the storage of said products by plaintiff's
predecessor in title, one J. H. Riepen, who was the im-
mediate predecessor in title of the said Exchange Bank;
that said J. H. Riepen on the 12th day of September, 1910,
was by the Mayor and councilmen of the City of Marysville,
Kansas, granted permission and the right to construct said
oil tanks above ground on said Lot No. 9 in Block 71 above
mentioned, and immediately thereafter erected the oil tanks
now in use by the plaintiff herein; that said tanks were in
use at the time plaintiff purchased Lot No. 9 and have been
in continuous use since their erection by J. H. Riepen to the
present time for the purpose of storing therein and dis-
tributing therefrom oi] and gasoline; that said tanks are
14
two in number, are 10° 6" in diameter and 18’ 7” in height
and each has a capacity of approximately 10,000 gallons.
The tanks are constructed of steel plates 3," in thickness.
These plates are riveted together so as to form a cylindrical
tank. They are built upon a solid concrete foundation,
equipped with man holes and McDonald vents, which allow
the escape of all vapors and gas arising from their contents.
Xi
That the nearest building or structure to said tanks is the
residence of J. 1H. Riepen which is located on the south half
of Block 71 and is approximately 58 feet distance from said
tanks; that said J. H. Riepen occupied said residence int
1910 when he constructed the oil tanks now owned and op
erated by Sinclair Refining Company, and continued to oc
cupy said residence and to operate said storage tanks until
he sold the same; that he has remodeled said residence
sinee said Lot and tanks were sold to the plaintiff; that he
still lives in said residence; that while a number of houses
have been built in that section of the City of Maryeville,
Raneas, shee said tanks were erected, none of them are in
close proximity to or in any Way endangered or affected by
the use and operation of said tanks in plaintiff's business ;
that said tanks are still lo atadan a sparcely netthad section
of the city, on a spar of the Union Pacific Railroad track
devoted almost exclusively to freight and mercantile BeTVIO®.
{fol 15} X1ll
That the storage tanks af the plaintiff in Maryeville,
Kansas, have been in operation with the knowledge, ap
proval ated conwent of the defendant caly, for their present
use and purpose since their erection by J. HM. Riepen, for
more than IS veare prior to the puwsage of Ordinance No.
24) without accident or injury to persona or property, and
the busines. connected with the use thereof has been and
is being carried on in a sanitary, safe and legitimate way;
that in July, 114 the Mayor and councilmen of the City of
Marysville, Kansas, regularly passed and published Ordi.
nance No, X07, Section 4 of which reade as follows:
“Section 4 Tanks may be constructed in the building, if
buried af least three feet below the lowest floor thereof,
15
and isolated tanks, constructed for the storage of gasoline,
fuel oi! and motor spirits in quantities of 5,000 gallons or
more, may be constructed above ground at such locations
as the Mayor and City Council may determine. Provided
a permit designating the locetion and manner of construc-
tion must be procured from the Mayor and City Council
thereof, before the construction of such tanks, Provided
further, a permit for the maintenance of isolated tanks
built upon the surface and now located within said city, if
properly safeguarded, will be issued."’
A true and correct copy of said ordinance, marked Ex-
hibit **A,*’ is attached to the original bill of complaint
herein and asked to be read as a part hereof.
XIV
That the said storage tanks located on Lot 9, Block 71,
in Marveville, Kansas, are outside of the fire limits estab.
lished by the Mayor and councilmen of the City of Marys-
ville, Kansas.
XV
That the provisions of said Ordinance No, 350 requiring
plaintiff to bury its tanks under ground are arbitrary, un-
reasonable and impossible of performance in that said tanks
eannot be buried and that the enforcement of said ordinance
will result in the absolute confiscation of plaintiff's prop-
erty; in an unlawfal and unjust discrimination against
plaintiff, and in a denial to plaintiff of the equal protection
of the laws, and in the deprivation of its property without
duc process of law, in violation of the Fourteenth Amend-
ment to the Constitation of the United States, above quoted,
and of the Constitution and Laws of the State of Kansas.
(fol. 16] XVI
That permits were duly and regularly issued to the plain-
uff under and as provided for in said Ordinance No, 237,
and that the same remains in force and effect until the
passage of Cirdinance No S50 hereinafter referred to.
XVII
That on the Sth day of October, 1923, the Mayor and
councilmen of the defendant City passed and published in
16
so far as they could legally do so, Ordinance No. 350 of the
Ordinances of the City of Marysville, Kansas, being the
ordinance complained of herein. A true and correct copy
of said ordinance, marked Exhibit “B"’ is attached to the
original bill of complaint herein, and asked to be read as
a part hereof. That the provisions of said Ordinance No.
350 are discriminatory and deny to this plaintiff the equal
protection of the laws uuder Section one of the Fourteenth
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, in that
Section one of said ordinance requires this plaintiff to bury
its tanks three feet ander ground, while Section Three of
said ordinance provides that:
“This ordinance shall in no case apply to the storage of
any erude oil, distillate or fuel oil in containers of capacity
of 500 gallons or less, bat only one such 500 gallon con.
tainer shall be permitted on each premises, nor shall it
apply to the storage of gasoline, kerosene or naptha iv
quantities of leas than ten gallons, all of which commodities
in the quantities mentioned and permitted by this section
shall be kept and stored in the manner as how provided by
existing ordinances."
XVIII
That it ia more dangerous from the standpoint of the
health and safety of the public to establish, maintain and
operate oil tanks of the kind and for the purposes aforesaid
under ground than te mamntain and operate them above
ground in the manner in which the plaintiff is now main-
taining and operating the same as aforesaid ip the said
City of Marysville, Kansas, and elsewhere.
XIX
That said Ordinance No. S) herein complained of and
the enforcement of which is berein sought to be enjoined,
prohibsts plaintifl from maintaining and operating all stor.
age tanks of the kind and character aforesaid af any point
within the corporate limits of the City of Marysville, Kan
ifol. 17) sas, unless the same shall be buried under ground
as aforesaid; that said City of Marysville, Kansas, con.
tains within its corporate limits numerous tracts of ground
which are wholly vacant and used exclusively for agri.
17
cultural purposes and each of which is of from one to sixty
acres ip area; that said ordinance is so arbitrary and un-
reasonable in its provisions as to prohibit plaintiff from
using any one of said numerous tracts to establish, main-
tain and operate its said business with its tanks thereon
above ground, although that could be done without any
possible injury or damage to either persons or property.
XX
Plaintiff respectfully shows that said Ordinance No. 350
ix so arbitrary and unreasonable that it will drive this
plaintiff's business and the business of others similarly
engaged from the city limits of the City of Marysville, Kan
eas, or cause it and them to establish, maintain and operate
oil tanks under ground in a manner less safe than that now
omploved by plaintiff as aforesaid, and if said ordinance is
enforeed it will result in confiscation of plaintiff's property
in Violation of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Federal
Constitution, herein above quoted and set out, and in viola-
tion of the Constitution and Laws of the State of Kansas.
XXI
Your petitioner further shows that the penalties fixed
by Section 5 of snid ordinance are unreasonable and arbi-
trary in that they provide that:
“Section 5. Any person, firm or corporation violating
any of the provisions of this ordinance shall upon convie-
tion be adjudged to pay a fine of $25.00 for each such
Violation, and each day that any of the commodities herein
referred to are stored in violation of the terms hereof shall
constitute a separate and distinct offense hereunder.’
XXTI
Maint further says that the officers of the City of
Marveville, Kansas, hereinbefore named are threatening
am? o'tempting to enforce said ordinance; that they have
cause l the managing agent of this plaintiff to be arrested
ena warrant charging him with violation of Ordinance No.
nants 3)
Is
350; that he is subject to and threatened with continual
arrests and fines; that the plaintiff has no adequate remedy
{fol 18] at law; that said void ordinance will be enforced
against the plaintiff and its officers and agents unless pre-
vented by the equitable order of this court restraining and
enjoining said city and each and all of its said officers and
agents from enforcing or attempting to enforce said void
ordinance.
Wherefore plaintiff prays:
A. That said Ordinance No. 250) of the Ordinances of the
City of Marysville, Kanaas, be declared and decreed by
this court to be arbitrary, unreasonable, discriminatory
and void and confiscatory of the plaintiff's property, and
in violation of the plaintiff's rights under the Constitution
and Laws of the United States and the State of Kansas;
B. That the City of Marysville, Kansas, and Charles F.
Travelute, Mayor; Leonard Cole, E. G. Filbert, Fd. Hall,
Paul Kirkpatrick, Oscar Terry, T. J. Austin, and Harry
Thompson, Councilmen, Fagar (. Bennett, City Attorney;
and Po Haves, Marshal of «aid City, and each of them on
the presentation of this Ar ended Rill of Complaint Tae
temporarily restrained from enforcing of attempting to
onforee said Ordinance No. 2%); that thie canse he set down
for hearing on application for temporary injunction at an
early date; that on said hearing a temporary injunction be
granted, and that on final hearing said temporary injune-
tion shall be made perpetual
C. That sabperna shall isene ont of this Honorable Court
directed to the defendants not heretofore served, to wit:
T J. Austin and Osear Terry, requiring and commanding
them and each of them to appear in this cause on a day cer.
tain, to answer the several allegations of this petition (un
leas they shall forthwith enter their appearance herein),
an«wer under oath being expressly waived.
D. Plaintiff farther prays for such other and further re
lief in the premises ae to this Honerable Court may seem
exqyuitable and just.
Thomas F. Doran, Clayton F Kline, Attorneys for
Plaintiff.
19
Duly sworn to by T. F. Doran. Jurat omitted in print-
ing.
{fol. 19} Ix Unrrep Srares Disrnicr Court
{Title omitted]
Onore ror Consoumatrion anp Rerenence-—Filed
Oct. 6, 1924
Now, on this sixth day of October, 1924, the above en-
titled causes came regularly on for hearing, and it having
heen shown to the Court that there are questions of fact
involved requiring the taking of proofs, and that the issues
of fact and law involved are practically identical in each
case, the Court thereupon finds that said cases should be
consolidated, and that a Master should be appointed herein
to take such proofs and to make findings of fact, conelu-
sions of law and recommend the judgments which should
he entered herein.
Wherefore it is by the Court ordered that Charles Blood
Smith should be and he is hereby appointed Special Master
to take the proofs in said causes and that the same be, and
[fol 20) thew are hereby consolidated; and that the taking
of such proofs shall begin not later than the twentieth dav
of October, 1924, and that the same shall be concluded with
all reasonable speed, and that thereupon the said Master
shall, without delay, make findings of fact and conclusions
of law, and make this report thereon recommending the
judgements to be entered herein.
The taking of such proofs to be held and had within the
jurisdiction of this court, at such times and places as shall
he convenient to the Master and the parties within the
time lumits herem fixed,
John C. Pollock, Judge.
[Poe endorsement omitted]
&
Ix Usrrep States Distraict Court
(No. 652-N)
Axswen—Filed Oct. 11, 1924
Come now the defendants above named, and for their
joint and several answers to the Bill of Complaint, say:
I
1y that the matter in controversy
herein exceeds the sum, or value, of Three Thousand Dol.
lars ($3,000.), exelusive of interest and costs, and file their
wav of answer, because this Court
suit, for that the anid
The defendants det
motion to dismiss by
should not take jurisdiction of this
anit does not really and substantially involve a suit, or con.
troversy, properly within its jurisdiction, for that the al
legations, that the matter in controversy exceed the sum or
of Three Thousand Dollars ($3,000), exclusive of
not truly and in good faith made,
hut on the contrary are falsely and fictitionsly made for
the purpose of imposing on the jurisdiction of this court,
All of which the defendants aver to he true, and plead the
came in bar of the complainant’s said bill and pray jude
ment whether they should answer, and further pray to be
henee dismissed with costs.
value,
interest and costs, are
Further answering:
1!
The defendants admit that the cause of action set out
arixes under the Constitution and laws of the United
States.
Ill
{fol 21} The defendant« admit that there ix a diversity
of citizenship between the plaintiff and each of the defend
ant« herein
IV
wll as brought for the
The defendants admit that the }
decree declaring void
purpose of procuring an order and
.
i aaa fs
21
ordinance No, 350, of the ordinances of the city of Marys-
ville, Kansas, and for the purpose of procuring an order
and decree perpetually enjoining the defendants and each
of them from enforcing said ordinance, and for the reasons
set out in paragraph IV of said Bill of Complaint, but spe-
cifieally deny that said ordinance is in contravention of the
rights of the plaintiff under Section 1 of the Fourteenth
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States; or
that it is repugnant to the rights of the plaintiff, under the
common law and the Constitution and laws of the State of
Kansas; or that the action of the defendant, The City of
Marysville, in passing said ordinance was and is ultra vires ;
or that said ordinance was, or is, invalid because of lack of
antecedent legislative authority conferring power upon said
city to pass the same; or that said ordinance is so arbitrary,
capricious, discriminatory, unreasonable, and subversive of
private rights as to amount to a clear abuse of power and
to deny the plaintiff the equal protection of the laws and
due process of law secured to it by section 1 of the Four.
teenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States;
or that said ordinance is void under the Constitution and
laws of the State of Kansas. The defendants allege that
full authority for the passing of said ordinance No. 350
has been conferred upon them, and exists under sections
14-401, 14-418, 14-421 and 14-439 of the Revised Statutes of
Kansas, 1922, the same having been sections 1704, 1726,
1720 and 1748 of the General Statutes of Kansas for 1915,
Vv
The defendants admit the corporate existence and citizen
ship of the plaintiff, and that at all times mentioned it was
duly licensed and author.zed to engage in business in the
State of Kansas as a foreign corporation, all as set out in
paragraph V of the Bill of Complaint.
VI
The defendants admit that the City of Marysville is a
city of the second class of the State of Kansas, and a resi.
dent and citizen of the State of Kansas, and of the First
Division of the District of Kansas, all as set out in para-
{fol 22) graph VI of the Bill of Complaint.
22
vil
The individual defendants admit that they are the duly
elected, qualified and acting officers of the City of Marys-
ville, as set out and shown in the title of the Bill of Com-
plaint, and admit their residence and citizenship, all as set
out in paragraph VII of the Bill of Complaint.
Vill
The defendants have no knowledge of the plaintiff having
been continuously engaged in the business of selling and
storing for sale and distribution various products of petro
leum in tanks constructed above ground in any other towns
and cities of the State of Kansas, except the City of Mary
ville, but state that, if such be the fact, it is not a matter of
equity entitling plaintiff to the relief prayed for, nor are
the facts as stated sufficient to entitle plaintiff to any rehet
against these defendants; the defendants admit that the
plaintiff has for more than ten years last past been contin
ueusly engaged in the business of selling and stering fer
sale and distribution large quantities of gasoline and hero
sene in tanks constructed above ground in the City of
Marveville, each of which contained more than five hun
dred (400) gallons.
IX
The defendants deny that the tanks so ased by the plain
tiff, and each and all of them, are equipped and constructed,
traintained amd operated with the mast modern, effierent!,
and best safety appliances known, and ina prudent, skillful,
atl safe manner
xX
The defemdant« admit that the sterage and heeping of
pact revbetatey products have been for more than ten vears, and
pew are neefol, convenient and necessary meidents of plain
tiff’s business, and are required by modern methods of
commerce, transportation and habits of life, bat spe iftenlls
deny that the storage amd keeping of sand pradact+ in such
tanks as the plaintiff has, se equipped, maintained, and op
erated adjacent to radroads and railroad switehes within
cit-es, towns, and within the city of Maryeville, Kansas, are
3
the safe, useful, convenient and necessary incidents and
practices of the plaintiff's business, or are required by mod-
ern methods of commerce, transportation and habits of life,
or have been established, maintained, and universally rec-
{fol. 23] ognized throughout the State of Kansas and the
United States, as necessary and legitimate means of con-
ducting said business, and deny that said storage and keep-
ing in no way infringes upon, injures, or adversely affects
the health, morals, safety, or welfare of individuals or the
public in said city of Marysville.
XI
The defendants admit that for more than ten years last
past the plaintiff has been transacting its business in the
regular course and has maintained and operated tanks for
the storage of petroleum products in the city of Marysville
upon the premises described in paragraph XI of said Bill
of Complaint.
Xl
The defendant» admit that the storage tanks now upon
said premises, or others of sunilar character and construe-
tion, have been maintained and operated upon said prem-
ixes continuously fer more than ten years prior to the
passage of ordinance No. 350 of the city of Marysville,
and with the knowledge of the defendant city of Marysville,
but deny that the same was, or is with the approval and
consent of the defendant city, or of the individual defend
ants, The defendants admit that said tanks have been main-
tained and operated as alleged without accident in the city
of Marysville, but deny that they have been maintained and
operated without injury to persons or property, and that
their use and maintenance have been, and are now being car-
ried on in a safe, sanitary, and legitimate way.
NI
The defendant» admit that said tanks and places of busi
ness of the plaintiff are located upon a spur, or sidetrack,
of the Union Pacific Railway Company outside of the fire
limits of the City of Marysville, but deny that said tanks
are located in a sparsely occupied section of said city, and
that they are not in close proximity to buildings of other
persons, firms or corporations, but on the contrary allege
that said tanks of the plaintiff are only 1% blacks distant
from the main business street of the city of Marysville, and
are surrounded on all sides by residences and other build.
ings in such close proximity as to endanger the destruction
of property and loss of life.
XIV
The defendants admit that in July, 1914, the Mayor and
Couneil of the city of Marysville regularly passed and pub-
[fol. 24} lished ordinance No. 237 of the ordinances of the
city of Marysville, and that Section 4, as set out in para
graph XIV of the Bill of Complaint, and exhibit **A"’ at
tached to the Bill of Complaint, are true and correct
copies of said section 4, and of said ordinance respectively.
XV
The defendants admit that permits were issued to the
plaintif® under and as provided for in ordinance No. 2,
hut state tut said permits are void, and are not Voimding on
these defendants, and deny that the same remained in
force and effect until the passage of ordinance No. 350
but admit that the first action taken by these defendant«
with reference thereto was the passage of said ordinance
No. 230. Defendants further state that, if the fact» be as
alleged, they de not state any matter of equity entitling the
plaintiff to relief praved for, nor are the facts as stated sul
ficient to entitle the plaintiff to any relief against there de
fendants.
XVI
The defemlants admit that on October &, 1923, the Mayor
areal Cagnet! of the eity of Maryeville, penned ard published
erdinance No. 33 of the ondinances af the city of Marys
ville, and adiut that exhibit ““B'" of the Bill of Complaint i
a true and correct copy of said ordinance.
XVI
The defendants deny that ordinance No. 350 is diserimi
natory, or denies to the plaintiff the equal protection of the
laws under section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment to the
Constitution of the United States for the reasons set out in
paragraph XVII of the Bill of Complaint, and allege that
the regulation of the keeping and storage of said products
in the quantities and under the conditions provided for in
said ordinance is fair and reasonable for the proper protec-
tion of the health, safety and welfare of the people and the
property of the city of Marysville, in that the keeping and
storing above ground of gasoline, kerosene, naphtha, distil-
late, fuel oi], crude oil, or other inflammable or combustible
liquids in quantities over five hundred (500) gallons is a
menace to the public safety; whereas the keeping and stor-
age above ground of crude oi], distillate, or fuel oil in quan-
tities of five hundred (500) gallons or Jess on one premises,
and of gasoline, kerosene, or naphtha in quantities less than
ten (10) gallons is not a menace to public safety.
(fol, 25] XVIII
The defendants deny that the provisions of ordi-
nance No, 350, require the burying under ground of tanks
of the ‘*kind and character used by the plaintiff’’ in the
city of Marysville, and aliege that said ordinance requires
that all tanks, barrels, and containers, in which are kept or
stored gasoline, kerosene, naphtha, distillate, fuel oil, or
erude oil, or other inflammable or combustible liquid,
should be buried at least three feet under ground, except
as provided in section 3 of said ordinance, and deny that
stich provisions of ordinance No. 350 are arbitrary, unrea-
sonable, and impossible of performance; and deny that
plaintif’s tanks cannot be operated and maintained when
»o buried, and that the enforcement of said erdinance will
result in the absolute confiscation of the plaintiff's prop-
erty, uit state that, if such be the fact, it does not state
any matter of equity entitling plaintiff to the relief prayed
for, ner are seid facts sufficient to entitle plaintiff to any
relief against these defendants.
XIX
Defendants deny that it is more dangerous from the
standpoint of the health and safety of the public to estab-
lish, maintain, and operate tanks for the storage of
petroleum products under ground than above ground.
26
xx
Defendants admit that ordinance No. 350 prohibits the
plaintiff from maintaining and operating tanks for the
storage of petroleum products other than crude oil, distil.
late, or fuel oil, in containers in a capacity of five kundred
(300) gallons or less in storage tanks, unless the same be
buried under ground as provided in said ordinance.
Defendants admit that the City of Marysville [con-
tained} within its corporate limits numerous tracts of land
that are wholly vacant and used exclusively for agricul-
tural purposes, each of which is from one to ten acres in
area, but deny that said ordinance is unreasonable and
arbitrary in prohibiting the plaintiff from using said tracts
otherwise than as provided in said ordinance, and deny
that said ase can be had without possible injury to the per
sons and the property, and further aver that the plaintiff's
tanks are not located on any of said tracts of ground, and
that, if the facts be as alleged, they do not state any matter
of equity entitling the plaintiff to the relief prayed for, ner
are they sufficient to entitle the plai “ff to any relief
against these defendants.
(fol. 36) XXI
The defendants admit that ordinance No, 350 will re
quire the plaintiff to establish, maintain, and operate its
oil tanks under the ground, if it desires to maintain them
within the limits of the city of Marveville, bat denies that
aid tanks are less aafe than the ones now need by said
plaintiff, and denies that said ordinance ix arbitrary and
unreasonable or that it will drive plaintiff's business from
said city limits, or that it will result in the confiscation of
the plaintiff's property in violation of the provisions of the
Federal Constitution as set out in said Bill of Complaint.
XXII
Defendants admit that section 5, of the ondinance No.
RAW, as sot out in paragraph ~) of the Hill of (Complaint, i
true and correct, but denies that the penalties affixed
therein are anreasonable and arbitrary,
27
XXIII
Defendants admit that the officers of the city of Marys-
ville attempted to enforce said ordinance and arrest an
emplovee of the plaintiff on a warrant charging him with
violation thereof, and admit that said ordinance will be
enforced against the plaintiff, its officers, agents and em-
ployees unless prevented by the equitable order of this
Court.
Wherefore having thus made a ful! answer to all the mat-
ters and things contained in the Bill of Complaint, the de-
fendants and each of them, pray that the bill be dismissed,
and fer judgement and costs in its behalf incurred.
John S. Dean, Harry W. Colmery, Edgar C. Ben-
nett, Frank Ho McFarland, Attorneys for the De-
fendants.
In Usrren Starrs Doerucr Covet
(No, 653.N)
Axswerr-—Filed Oct. 11, 1924
Come now the defendants above named, and for their
yoint and several answers to the Bill of Complaint, sav:
{fol 27) I
The defendants deny that the matter in controversy
herein exceeds the sum, or value, of Three Thousand Dol
lars (&1,000.) exclusive of interest and costs, and file their
motion to dismiss by way of answer, because this Court
shonld not take jurisdiction of this suit, for that the said
suit does not really and sabstantially involve a suit, or con-
troversy, properly within its jurisdiction, for that the al.
legations, that the matter in contreversy execeds the sum
er value, of Three Thousand Dollars (43,000), exclusive of
interet and costs, are not truly and in good faith made,
but on the contrary are falsely and fictitiously made for the
purpose of imposing on the jurisdiction of this court. All
of which the defendants aver to be true, and plead the same
28
in bar of the complainant's said hill and pray judgment
whether they should answer, and further pray to be hence
dismissed with costs. pour
Further answering:
Bt
The defendants admit that the cause of action set out
arises under the Constitution and laws of the United
States.
iil
The defendants admit that there is a diversity of citizen
ship between the plaintiff and each of the defendants
herein.
Iv
The defendants admit that the bill is brought for the pur
pose of procuring an order and decree declaring void ordi.
nanees No. 3h, of the ordinances of the ests ef Marveville,
Kanan, and for the prurpese of precuring an onler and
decree perpetually enjoining the defendants and each of
them from enforcing said ordinance, and for the reasons
set out in paragraph IV of said Bill of Complaint, but
specifically deny that said ordinance is in contravention
of the rights af the polars i umdler Section 1 af the Fur
teenth Amendment to the Constitution of th: United
States: or that it is repngnant to the rights of the plaintiff,
utmeder tha congtmert! law atul the Cansatitautan atad laws of
the State of Kansas; or that the action of the defendant,
The City of Marysille, in passing eaid ordinance was and is
ultra vires or that said ordinance Was, of 1s, invalid be
cause of lack of antecedent legislative authority conferring
power upon said city to pars the «ame: or that «aid ord:
nance is ao arbitrary, capricions, discriminatory, unres
ffol. 28) sonable, and auhversive of private rights ax to
amount to a clear abuse of power and to deny the plaintiff
the eqaal protection of the laws and due process of law
eweured to it by section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment
ta the Conatitution of the United States; or that «aid
ordinance is void under the Constintion and laws of the
State aft Kaneas The defeondant« allege that full an
29
thority for the passing of said ordinance No. 350 has been
conferred upon them, and exists under sections 14-401, 14-
418, 14-421 and 14-439 of the Revised Statutes of Kansas,
1923, the same having been sections 1704, 1726, 1729 and
1748 of the General Statutes of Kansas for 1915.
V
The defendants admit the corporate existence and citi-
zenship of the plaintiff, and that at all times mentioned it
was duly licensed and authorized to engage in business in
the State of Kansas as a foreign corporation, all as set
eutin paragraph Voof the Bill of Complaint.
VI
Phe defendants admit that the City of Marysville is a
city of the second class of the State of Kansas, and a resi-
dent and citizen of the State of Kansas, and of the First
Division of the District of Kansas, all as set out in para-
graph VI of the Bill of Complaint.
Vil
The individual defendants admit that they are the duly
elected, qualified and acting officers of the City of Marys-
ville, as set out and shown in the title of the Bill of Com.
plaint, and admit their residence and citizenship, all as set
out in paragraph VII of the Bill of Complaint.
Vill
The defendants have no knowledge of the plaintiff hav-
ing been continnously engaged in the business of selling
and storing for sale and distribution various products of
petrolenm in large steel tanks constructed above ground
and in selling and distributing said products therefrom in
any other towns and cities of the State of Kansas, and of
the United States, except the City of Marvesville but state
that, if such be the fact, it is not a matter of equity en-
titling the plaintiff to the relief praved for, nor are the
facts as stated sufficient to entitle plaintiff to any relief
against these defendants; the defendants admit that plain.
[fol. 29] tiff’s tanks constructed above ground in the City
of Marysville, each have a capacity of more than five hun-
dred (500) gallons.
IX
The defendants deny that the tanks so used by the plain-
tiff and each and all of them, are equipped and constructed,
maintained and operated with the most modern, efficient,
and best safety appliances and devices knewn, and in care-
ful, sanitary, skillful and safe manner.
x
The defendants admit that the storage and keeping of
petroleum products have heen for more than ten years, and
pow are, useful, convenient, and necessary incidents of
plaintiff's btisiness, ami of others engaged in the same
business, and are required by modern methods of com
meree, transportation and habits of life, bat specifically
deny that the storage and keeping of said products in such
tanks as the plaintiff has, +o equipped, maintained and
operated adpacent to railrowds and railroad switches within
cities, towns, and within the city of Marysville, Kansas, are
the safe, useful, convenient, and necessary incidents and
practices of the plaintiff's btsiness, oF are required by
madern methads of commerce, transportation and habits
of life, or have been established, maintained, and armiver
aally recogniaed throughout the State of Kanaas, and the
United States, as necessary and legitimate means of con
ducting said business, and dens that said storage and keep
ing as comductedl hy plaintifY in the City of Marveville, in
no way infringes upon, injures oF adversely affects the
health, morals, safety or welfare of individuals or the pub
lie in said City of Maryeville.
XI
The defendants admit the parchase and ownership of
Lot Nine (9), in Block Seventy one (T1), of the City of
Marysville, and that at the time of said purchase the steel
tanks now owned and operated bs plaintif? were leona ted
thereon, and that said tanks had been constructed and used
by plaintiff's predecessor in tithe ander permission granted
31
by the Mayor and Councilmen of the city of Marysville, all
as set out in paragraph XI of the Bill of Complaint, but
state that said permission was and is void and not binding
on these defendants. Defendants admit that plaintiff's
tanks have been in continuous use since their erection to the
present time, and are of the number, dimensions, capacity,
and construction as set out in paragraph XI of the Bill of
{fol. 30] Complaint, except that defendants have no knowl-
edge as to said tanks being equipped with man-holes and
McDonald vents, admitting that if so equipped, they are
intended to allow the escape of all vapors and gas arising
from their contents, but denying that they do allow such
escape,
XII
The defendants admit that the residence of J, H. Riepen
is located on the South half of Block Seventy-one (71), and
is approximately fifty-cight (58) feet distant from said
tanks, but deny that it is the nearest structure to said tanks:
admit the eceupancy and remodeling of said residence as
alleged, admit that a number of houses have been built in
that section of the City of Marveville since said tanks were
erected, but deny that none of said houses is in close prox-
imity to or in any way endangered or affected by the use
and operation of said tanks in plaintiff's business, and that
said tanks are located in a sparsely settled section of said
city, but on the contrary allege that said tanks are only one
and one-half (1')) blocks distant from the main business
street of the City of Marysville, and are surrounded on all
sides by residences and other buildings in such close prox.
imity as to endanger the destruction of property and the
loss of life
XII
The defendants admit that the storage tanks of the plain.
Uff have been maintained and operated upon said premises
continuously for more than thirteen years prior to the pas.
sage of ordinance No, 350 of the city of Marysville, and
with the knowledge of the defendant city of Marysville, but
deny that the same was, or is with the approval and con.
sent of the defendant city, or of the individual defendants.
The defendants admit that said tanks have been maintained
32
and operated as alleged with! vecident in the city of
Marysville, but deny that they have been maintained and
operated without injury to persons oF property, and that
their use and maintenance have been, and are now being
carried on in a safe, sanitary, and legitimate way. The
defendants admit that in July, 1914, the Mayor and Coun:
cil of the City of Marysville regularly passed and pub-
of the ordinances of the city of
4, as set out in paragraph Xi
A” attached to the
es of anid ain
lished ordinance No. 257
Marysville, and that section
of the Bill of Complaint, and exhibit **
Bill of Complaint, are true and correct coy
tien 4, and of said ordinance, respectively.
{fol 31} XIV
+ the storage tanks on Lot Nine
The defendants wimit that
(9) Black Seventy-one (71). are outside of the fire limits
i Councilmen of the City of
established by the Maver a!
Mars ss ille, Kateas
XV
The defendants deny that the provisions of ordinance No.
r ground of plaintiff's tanks
requires that all tanks, bar
are kept or stored gasoline,
fuel oil, or crude oil, or other
Loegtarel, should be barred, at
L« Loept as pres ded in section
provisions of ar
230 require the burying uataede
and allege that sand ordinance
rela and contamers, in whieh
kerosene, naphtha, distillate
inflammable or owmbustible
least three feet under groun:
3 of ward ordinance, and dens that such
dinance No, 3) are artatrary, unre asonable, and impossible
enforcement of enid ordi
of performanes: amd that the
nanee will reeult im the absolute conflecation of the plain
tiffs property, hut «tate that, if such be the fact, if does not
state anv matter of equity entitling plaintiff to the relief
prayed for, ner are said facts saffierent to entithe plantitf
to any relief against these defemdants, and deny that anid
ordinance 14 an unlawful and unjust diacrimination against
plaintiff or denies it the yual protectin of the laws as
alleged in paragraph XV of the Bill of Complaint
XVI
The clefe mlante petemet that | rmite were saved to the
ave
plaintiff ander and as provided for in ordinance No. 2,
33
but state that said permits are void, and are not binding on
these defendants, and deny that the same remained in force
and effect until the passage of ordinance No, 350, but admit
that the first action taken by these defendants with refer-
ence thereto was the passage of said ordinance No, 350.
Defendants further state that, if the facts be as alleged,
they do not state any matter of equity entitling the plain-
tiff to relief praved for, nor are the facts as stated suf-
ficient to entitle the plaintiff to any relief against these de-
fendants,
XVII
The defendants admit that on October 8, 1925, the Mayor
and Couneil of the city of Marysville, passed and published
ordinance No, 350 of the ordinances of the city of Marys-
ville, and admit that exhibit *B" of the Bill of Complaint
is a true and correct copy of said ordinance. The defend.
ants deny that ordinance No, 350 is discriminatory, or de-
[fol 32) nies to the plaintiff! the equal protection of the
laws under section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment to the
Constitution of the United States for the reasons set out in
paragraph NVIT of the Bill of Complaint, and allege that
the regulation of the keeping and storage of said products
in the quantities and under the conditions provided for in
said ordinance is fair and reasonable for the proper pro
tection of the health, safety, and welfare of the people and
the property of the city of Marysville in that the keeping
and storing above ground of gasoline, kerosene, naphtha,
distillate, fael oil, ernde oil, or other inflammable or com-
bustible liquids in quantities over five hundred (500) gal.
lone is a menace to the public safety; whereas the keeping
and sterage above ground of erude oil, distillate, or fuel oil
in quantities of five hundred (500) gallons or less on one
premises, and of gasoline, kerosene, or naphtha, in quan
tities less than (10) gallons is not a menace to public safety,
XVill
Ik foodants deny that it is more dangerous from the
standpoint of the health and safety of the public to esx.
tablish, maintain and operate tanks for the storage of
petrolonm produets under ground thaf shove ground im the
ne
manner in which said tanks are operated by plaintiff in the
City of Marysville.
XIX
Defendants admit that ordinance No. 350 prohibits the
plaintiff from maintaining and operating tanks for the
storage of petroleum products other than crude oil, distil-
late, or fuel oil, in containers in a capacity of five hundred
(500) gallons or less in storage tanks, unless the same be
buried under ground, as provided in said ordinance.
Defendants admit that the City of Marysville {contained }
within its corporate limits numerous tracts of land that
are wholly vacant and used exclusively for agricultural pur-
poses, each of which is from one to ten acres in area and
that there is one tract of approximately sixty (60) acres,
but deny that said ordinance is unreasonable and arbitrary
in prohibiting the plaintiff from using said tracts other-
wise than as provided in said ordinance, and deny that said
use can be had without possible injury to the persons and
property, and further aver that the plaintiff's tanks are not
located on any of said tracts of ground, and that, if the
facts be as alleged, they do not state any matter of equity
entitling the plaintiff to the relief prayed for, nor are they
{fol. 33] sufficient to entitle the plaintiff to any relief
against these defendants.
XxX
)
The defendants admit that ordinance No, 350 will re-
| quire the plaintiff to establish, maintain, and operate its
oil tanks under the ground, if it desires to maintain them
within the limits of the city of Marysville, but denies that
said tanks are less safe than the ones now used by said
plaintiff, and denies that said ordinance is arbitrary and
unreasonable, or that it will drive plaintiff's business from
said city limits, or that it will result in the confiscation of
the plaintiff’s property in violation of the provisions of the
Federal Constitution and the Constitution and laws of the
State of Kanaas, as «ct out in said Bill of Complaint.
XXI
Defendants admit that section 5 of the ordinance No. 350
as set out in paragraph XXII of the Bill of Complaint, is
35
true and correct, but deny that the penalties affixed therein
are unreasonable and arbitrary.
XXII
Defendants admit that the officers of the City of Marys-
ville attempted to enforce said ordinance and arrest an em-
ployee of the plaintiff on a warrant charging him with
violation thereof, and admit that said ordinance will be
enforced against the plaintiff, its officers, agents, and em-
ployees, unless prevented by the equitable order of this
Court.
Wherefore, having thus made a full answer to all the mat-
ters and things contained in the Bill of Complaint, the de-
fendants, and each of them, pray that the bill be dismissed,
and for judgment and costs in its behalf incurred.
John S. Dean, Harry W. Colmery, Edgar (. Bennett,
Frank H. MeFarland, Attorneys for the Defend.
ants.
Ix Unrrep Srares District Covrr
Fixvines or Fact axnp Concivusions or THe Sprecia Masrer
—Filed Jan. 24, 1925
From the pleadings, the admission of the parties and the
evidence in this ease, the Master makes and finds the fol-
lowing to be the facts:
{ fol. 34) Findings of Fact
I
That the plaintiff, Standard Oil Company, is now, and at
the commencement of this action was, a corporation duly
chartered, organized and existing under and by virtue of
the laws of the State of Indiana, and was then and is now a
citizen of the State of Indiana, duly authorized to engage in
business as a foreign corporation in Kansas.
Il
That the defendants and each of them are now and at the
commencement of this action were residents and citizens of
the State of Kansas and of the First Division of the Dis-
trict of Kansas.
36
Ill
That the defendant, the City of Marysville, Kansas, is
now, and at the time of the commencement of this action
was, a city of the second class of and ander the laws of the
State of Kansas.
IV
That each of the defendants other than the City of
Marysville is now and at the time of the commencement of
this action was a duly elected, qualified and acting officer
of and for the defendant, the City of Marysville, respec
tively, as set forth in the caption or title to this cause.
Vv
That the amount in controversy herein, exclusive of im-
terest and costs, exceeds the scum or value of Three Thou-
sand Dollars ($3,000.00).
Vi
That said plaintill waa, at the tume of the commencement
of this action, and for more than twenty years prior thereto
had been, continuously in possession of the following de
scribed real estate situate in the City of Marysville, State
of Kansas, to-wit:
**Beginning at a pont Uhat is in the south-east corner vl
Lot Twelve, Block Forty, Original Town of Marysville,
Kansas, thence worth along east line of eatd Lat Tweive
seventy one feet to a |} ; thenee west at right angles to
initial course forty four and three-tenths feet to a point
distant eight and five-tenths feet easterly from center line
{fol. 35] of west leg of Old Wye Track of Manhattan
Branch, at right angles thereto; thenee southwesterly par
allel to and distant eight amd five-tenths feet from center
line of said Wye track, seventy foar and five tenths feet to
the south line of said Block Forty; thence east along said
south line of «aid Block Forty seventy two and two-tenths
feet to point of beginning, im Marshall County, Raneas.
Vil
That the real estate occupied by said plaintiff in the City
of Maryeville, Kansas, ix now, and during all the time same
37
has been occupied by said plaintiff as herein set forth, was
owned by the Union Pacific Railroad Company and occupied
as aforesaid by said plaintiff under and by virtue of a lease
of and from said owner.
Vill
That said plaintiff at the time of the commencement of
this action, and for more than twenty years prior thereto,
maintained a storage station upon the real estate herein-
before described for the purpose of there keeping and stor-
ing gasoline, kerosene and other products of petroleum.
IX
That said plaintiff moved upon the real estate herein-
before described in Marysville, Kansas, and there erected
a plant and tanks fer the keeping and storing of gasoline
and kerosene more than twenty years prior to the com-
mencement of this action and with the knowledge and con-
sent of the defendant, the City of Marysville.
xX
That the right or authority of said plaintiff to move upon
said real estate or to erect and maintain there its storage
tanks and use same for the storage of gasoline and kero-
sene was never denied or questioned by the defendant, the
City of Maryeville, until on, to wit the eighth day of Octo-
ber, 1923, although an ineffective attempt was made about
two vears prior to said date to pass an ordinance somewhat
similar in purport to Ordinance No. 350 of the City of
Marysville.
XI
That the City of Marysville, through its Mayor and Coun.
cilmen, on the 8th day of October, 1923, passed and there-
after published and made effective Ordinance No. 350 of
said City, which is in words and figures as follows, to-wit:
fol. 36) Ordinance No, 350
An ordimance regulating the storage of gasoline, kerosene,
naptha, distillate, fnel oil, erude oi|, and other inflamma-
ble and combustible liquids within the city of Marysville,
Kansas, and repealing Ordinance No. 333 and Section 4
of Ordinance No. 237.
Be it ordained by the Mayor and Council of the City of
Maryeville, Kansas:
sesiieeeeeatinemetaniens
38
Section 1. It shall be unlawful for any person, firm or
corporation to keep or store within the corporate limits of
the city of Marysville, Kansas, and gasoline, kerosene, dis
tillate, fuel oil, crude oil, or other inflammable or combusti-
ble liquid otherwise than in tanks, barrels or other con.
tainers which shall be buried at least three feet under
ground.
See. 2. Any person, firm or corporation who shall main-
tain any underground tank-yard shall keep same fenced
securely and shall keep at least six inches of gravel, chat,
cinders or other large aggregate over the said area 80 Occu-
pied by tanks, and shall keep and maintain such tank-yard
in a clean, orderly manner, free from rubbish, weeds, trash
or other inflammable substances.
See. 3. This ordinance shall in no case apply to the stor.
age of any crude oil, distillate or fuel oil in containers of a
capacity of 500 gallons or less, but only one such 500 gallon
container shall be permitted on cach premises, nor, shall it
apply to the storage of gasoline, kerosene or naphtha in
quantities of less than ten gallons, all of which commodities
in the quantities mentioned and permitted by this section
shall be kept and stored in the manner as how pros ided by
existing ordinance.
See. 4. Ordinance No. 355 and Section 4 of Ordinance No.
237 are hereby expressly repealed.
See. 5. Any person, firm or corporation violating any of
the provisions of this ordinance shall upon conviction be
adjudged to pay a fine of $25.00 for each such violation, and
each day that any of the commodities herein referred to are
stored in vielation of the terms hereof shall constitute a
separate and distinct offense hereunder.
Sec. 6 Any person, firm or corporation now storing any
of the commesdities herein mentioned in a manner otherwise
than that herein provided shall be given until the 10th day
39
of November, 1923, in which to bring themselves within the
provisions hereof and comply herewith.
{fol. 37] See. 7. This ordinance shall be in force and take
effect from and after its publication in the official city
paper.
Passed and approved this 8th day of October, 1923.
C.F. TRAVELUTE, Mayor.
Attest; By S. Clark, City Clerk. (Seal.)
(Published in the Advocate-Democrat Oct, 11, 1923.)
That the Mayor and Councilmen of the City of Marys-
ville, theretofore, on the 13th day of July, 1914, passed and
published ordinance No, 237, which is in words and figures
ax follows, to-wit:
Ordinance No, 237
An Ordinance Providing for the Storage of Gasoline, Fuel,
Motor Spirits Within the City of Marysville
Be it ordained by the Mayor and Councilmen of the City
of Mary aville, Kansas:
Section 1. That it shall be unlawful for any person to
keep or permit to be kept in any building or upon any
premises within the City of Mary seville, Kansas, more than
five gallons of gasoline, fac! oil, or motor spirits, in any
one container, and not to exceed two containers on such
premises,
Sec, 2. Any person desiring to store a large quantity shall
provide a storage tank, which shall be located under ground,
except as hereinafter provided, and shall conform to the
regulations herein contained,
Sec. 3. All tanks locaied under ground shall have the
top of tank at least two feet below the surface of the ground,
and below the level of the lowest pipe in the building to be
supplied. Such tank shall be set ona firm foundation, sur-
rounded by soft earth or sand, well tamped in place, or be
encased in concrete, A permit for all tanks now located un-
derground within said city, if properly safeguarded, will be
issued.
40
Sec. 4. Tanks may be constructed in the building, if buried
at least three feet below the lowest floor thereof, and isolated
tanks, constructed for the storage of gasoline, f vel oi) and
motor spirits, in quantities of 5,000 gallons or more, may be
constructed above ground at such locations as the Mayor
and City Council may determine, Provided, a permit desig-
nating the location and manner of construction must he pro
cured from the Mayor and City Council therefor before the
[fol. 38] construction of such tanks. Provided, further, a
permit for the maintaintenance of isolated tanks built upon
the surface and now located within said city, if properly
safeguarded, will be issued.
See. 5. That any person violating any provision of this
ordinance shall be subject to a fine of not less than five dol.
lars nor more than twenty-five dollars, and be imprisoned
until such fine and costs are paid.
Sec. The word “ person’ in this ordinance shall he cor
sidered to include the owners, occupants, and agents of the
owner or oceupants of premises within said city.
See. 7. That all ordinances or parts of ordinances in con
flict with this ordinance be and the same are hereby re
pealed.
See, 8. This ordinance shall take effeet and be in force
from and after its passage and publication in the official
city paper.
Passed by the Council and approved by the Mayor this
Ith dav of July, A. D., 1914.
Chas, F. Pusch, Mavor
Attest: T. C. Randolph, City Clerk, (Seal)
That Section 4 of «aid Ordinance No 237 was repealed
by Ordinance No. 250, as is shown on the face thereof.
XII
That the real estate and premises upon which both af
said plaintiffs’ storage tanks and business are located in
the City of Marrey ie, Kansas, as aforesaid, are not pow,
and never have been, within the fire limits prescribed by
the City of Marysville.
41
XIII
That upon the rea! estate so occupied by said plaintiff in
the City of Marysville as aforesaid, and as a means of
keeping and storing there gasoline and kerosene, said plain-
tiff now maintains and has continuously maintained for
more than twenty years prior to the commencement of this
action, two steel, horizontal tanks, cach with a capacity of
approximately 17,000 gallons, and each of which rests above
the surface of the grounds on concrete piers eighteen inches
high and extending forty-eight inches into the earth.
{fol, 39] XIV
That in each of said tanks so maintained by said plain-
tiff as aforesaid upon said real estate, said plaintiff keeps
and stores, and for more than twenty vears prior to the
commencement of this action has continuously kept and
stered, gasoline and kerosene in quantities of more than
ten gallons.
XV
That each of said storage tanks so owned and maintained
by said plaintiff in the City of Marysville as aforesaid is
equipped with a two-inch McDonald duplex vent and an
eighteen.inch man-hole vent, as well as an efficient lightning
arrester and grounding device.
XVI
That both of the venting devices with which each of said
plaintiff's said tanks is equipped as aforesaid are in the top
of the tank and they are sufficient to carry off any Vapor
arising from the liquid contents of the tank even when
same is subject fo extreme heat.
XVII
That each of said plaintiff's tanks was, at the time of the
commencement of this action, and for more than twenty
years prior thereto had continuously been, equipped with
the best and most efficient safety devices and were operated
ina careful and efficient manner.
42
XVI
That there has never been any fire, accident or explosion
of any kind or character at or in the tanks or place of busi-
ness of said plaintiff in the city of Marysville.
XIX
That there has never been any fire, accident or explosion
in the city of Marysville, Kansas, of any tank similar in
character to the tanks 80 maintained ax aforesaid by said
plaintiff in said city.
XX
That no complaint was ever made of or fault found with
the construction, equipment or the manner of operation of
said plaintiff's tanks, or either of them.
XXI
That the construction of each of said plaintiff's tanks
and the equipment and manner of operation thereof are
{fol. 40] standard and of the kinds and character generally
employed by said plaintiff in the condoct of its business at
all points other than the eity of Marysville.
XX1l
That said plaintiff bas and maintains more than twelve
thousand tanks sumilar to its tanks in Marysville and dur.
ing the five years last past has had therein and thereof
sixty-six fires and no more.
XXII
In only one of the «ixty-six fires so had during the past
five years n# aforesaid in or about said plaintiff's said tanks
numbering more than twelve thousand, has any such tank
exploded, and in only one inetance (being the same fire)
has the fire from a tank epread to or injared other property
of persons.
XXIV
That the fire at plaintift's place of business in Has », Kan
sas, in November, 191%, 1 the only one that said plaintiff
48
has had within five year. in the maintenance and operation
of more than twelve thousand tanks in which a tank has
exploded, or in which fire from a tank has spread to or in-
jured either the property or person of others.
XXV
That the tank of said plaintiff which exploded during the
fire in Hays, Kansas, November 17, 1910, was equipped with
a two-inch MeDonald duplex vent, but was not equipped
with a manhole vent similar to the manhole vent with which
each of the tanks of said plaintiff at Marysville, Kansas, is
equipped.
XXVI
There is no evidence in this case tending to show that any
tank similar in construction, equipment, and manner of
operation to those maintained by said plaintiff at Marys-
ville. Kansas, as aforesaid, ever exploded or that fire from
any such tank ever spread to or otherwise injured either
the property or the safety of others,
XXVIII
That said storage tanks so maintained and operated by
said plaintiff ax aforesaid in the City of Marysville cannot
be operated if buried as required by the provisions of said
ordinance No. 30,
lfel. 41] XXVIII
That the barying by said plaintif if tanks equal in ca
pacity to those so maintained by it as aforesaid in the City
of Marvyeville as required by said Ordinance No. 350 would
be attended with hagard« which would render the main
tenance and operation thereof underground more danger-
ous to property and persons than the maintenance and oper.
ation of said plaintiff's present tanks above ground,
XXIX
That the above described location of said plaintiff's busi-
ness and tanks in the City of Marveville as aforesaid is in
a sparsely populated portion of said city.
XXX
That there are no changed conditions in the buildings or
improvements around the tanks and premises of said plain-
tiff aforesaid, or in that vicinity, which would warrant or
justify that said tanks should be buried as required by said
Ordinance No. 350.
XXXI
That each of said tanks so operated and maintained by
said plaintiff in the City of Marysville and equipped with
the venting devices aforesaid is safe from the standpoint
of the public safety and does not present a greater fire
hazard than would a frame building or a stock of groceries
in a frame building at the same location.
XXXII
That the dwelling house in Marys: ile situated the closest
to said tanks of said plaintiff ix more than ninety-cight feet
distant.
¥¥XI1
That the dwelling house closest to said tanks and pla e
of business of said plaintiff in the City of Marysville,
Kansas, has been in its present location for more than four.
teen years.
XXXIV
That the above described real estate on which said plain
tiff maintains its eaid storage station is upon the right-of
way of the Union Pacife Railroad Company.
(fol. 42] XXXV
That there are now and daring most of the time that said
plaintiff has maintained ite enid storage «tation in said loca.
tien in the City of Marveville there have been large quanti
ties of cinders used for hallast open the track of the Union
Pacific Railway Company, which i* about twenty feet from
anid plaintiff's said «tation
45
XXXVI
That the action of water upon cinders creates an acid that
corrodes and otherwise injures steel.
XXXVII
That the natural flow and drainage is from the said rail-
road track of the Union Pacific Railway Company upon and
over the property 50 occupied by said plaintiff as aforesaid
in the City of Marysville.
XXXVI
That there are numerous above-ground tanks in the City
of Marysville, Kansas, containing one hundred to five hun-
dred gallons of distillate and fuel oil which are maintained
under the authority of said Ordinance No. 350 above ground
in close proximity to frame residences and business build-
ing.
XXNXIX
That under the provisions of said ordinance No. 350 any
quantity of crude oil less than five hundred gallons may
be stored in tanks above ground in any part of the City of
Marysville.
XL
That crude oil is more dangerous from the standpoint of
public safety than is gasoline or kerosene and presents a
greater hazard.
XLI
That under the provisions of Section One of said Ordi-
nance No. 237 of the City of Marysville, still in force, and
by reference adopted by Ordinance No, 350, not more than
five gallons of gasoline, fuel oil or motor spirits can be
stored or kept above ground in any building or upon any
premises within the City of Marysville in any one container,
and not to exceed two containers may be kept on any one
premises; while under the provisions of Section Three of
said Ordinance No. 250, the quantity of gasoline, kerosene
46
{fol. 43] or naphtha which can be stored or kept above
ground must be and is less than ten gallons.
XL
That under the provisions of Ordinances No, 237 and No.
250 of the City of Marysville, i+ is uniawful for any citizen
of the City of Marysville to keep more than five gallons of
gasoline in the tank of his automobile, and every garage
keeper in Marveville who stores cars the tanks of which con
tain gasoline is guilty of an offense under both of anid ordi-
nances and subject to the penalties thereof,
Xin
That the provisions of Ordinances No. 237 and No, 350
permit and authorize a discrimination particularts in fa
vor of those who desire to keep and store ernde oil, distillate
and fuel oil in quantities less than five hundred gallons
above ground and against those who wish to keep and store
crude oil, distillate and fuel oil in quantities of 501 gallons
or more above ground, and against those who wish to store
and keep ten gallons of gasoline, fuel of] or motor spirits
on their premises in one container above ground, and
agninst those who wish to keep and store ten gallons of
more of gasoline, kerosene or naphtha above ground in the
City of Marysville.
XLIV
That during all the time said plaintiff has occupied the
premises aforesaid in the City of Maryaville, Kansas, it
there transacted its business of keeping and storing and
selling petroleum products and cold therefrom during the
year 1925 pet roleum products aggregating in value the sum
of $10,797.27, and during the year 122, $00 402.51
XLV
That it i more dangerous from the standparnt of pubhe
safety to keep and store gasoline or kerosene in quantities
of ten thousand gallons of more under the ground than it ts
to store the same qquantities thereof above ground
47
XLVI
That the defendant, the City of Marysville, has caused
the arrest of an agent of said plaintiff for the keep-
ing and storing of gasoline and kerosene in said tanks as
aforesaid in alleged violation of said Ordinance No. 350 of
[fol. 44] the City of Marysville, and will, unless enjoined by
decree of this Court, continue to arrest said plaintiff's em-
ployes therefor and thereunder and to endeavor to enforce
the penalties of said ordinance, to-wit, $25.00 per day for
each day that said plaintiff continues to transact its busi-
ness by the use of said storage tanks so placed as aforesaid
above the ground.
XLVII
That the provisions of Sections 1 and 3 of said Ordinance
No. 350 and each and all parts thereof are arbitrary, capri-
cious, discriminatory, unreasonable and subversive of the
rights of said plaintiff herein.
XLVITI
That the plaintiff, Sinclair Refining ¢ ‘ompany, is now, and
at the commencement of this action was, a corporation duly
chartered, organized and existing under and by virtue of
the laws of the State of Maine, and duly licensed to do busi-
ness in the State of Kansas, and was then and is now a citi-
zen of the State of Maine.
XLIX
That the defendant, the City of Marysville, is a municipal
corporation, a city of the second class under the laws of the
State of Kansas, and therefore a citizen and resident of the
State of Kansas, and of the First Division of the United
States District Court for the District of Kansas: that each
of the other defendants ix now and was at the commence-
ment of this action a resident and citizen of the State of
Kansas, and of the First Division of the United States Dis.
trict Court for the District of Kansas, and that each indi-
vidual defendant ix an officer of the City of Marysville,
Kansans, ax respectively designated in the title te this ac-
tion.
48
|
That the amount in controversy herein, exclusive of in-
terest and costs, exceeds the sum and value of Three Thou-
sand Dollars ($3,000.00. )
LI
That the plaintiff, the Sinclair Refining Company, Was
at the time of the commencement of this action and had been
for approximately fourteen years prior thereto, the owner
and in possession of the following-described real estate, sit-
uated in the City of Marysville, Marshall County, Kansas,
{fol. 45) to-wit: Lot number Nine (9) in Block Seventy-one
(71), in said City of Marysville.
LIl
That said plaintiff at the time of the commencement of
this action, and for approximately fourteen ( 14) years prior
thereto, had owned, maintained and operated two storage
tanks on the above-described property, each with a capacity
of approximately twelve thousand (12,000) gallons; that
one of said tanks is used for the storage of gasoline and the
other for the storage of kerosene.
Lill
That each of said tanks ts equipped with proper, suf.
ficient and efficient venting devices, consisting of an im
proved device known as 4 ¥ inch McDonald Duplex Vent and
a manhole eighteen inches in diameter, with an adjustable
cover, which, under pressure, automatically forms a vent
of sufficient capacity to care for all excess vapors which
cannot be taken care of by the McDonald Vent, even under
conditions of extreme heat; that «aid vents were at the time
of the commencement of thi« action, and long prior thereto
were, and are now, kept and maintained in good working
order and condition; that the connections, pipes, cut-offs
and equipment for filling said storage tanks from tank-cars
on adjacent railway tracks, and for removing from said
storage tanks the contents thereof, and for filling distribu-
tion tank wagons, were at the time of the beginning of this
action, had been long prior thereto and now are, generally
49
recognized as approved, efficient, sufficient and safe equip-
ment for the purposes for which they were intended, have
been and are now used; that said storage tanks and all the
equipment connected and used therewith were constructed
and are maintained and operated in first-class condition,
carefully, prudently and safely.
LIV
That said plaintiff's storage tanks have at all times since
their construction been operated carefully, prudently and
safely, without fire, explosion or accident of any kind.
LV
That said tanks were constructed under authority duly
granted by the Mayor and Councilmen of the City of Marvys-
ville, Kansas, and have been maintained and operated with
the full knowledge and consent of said City of Marysville,
without complaint or criticism from said city, its officers or
{fol. 46] agents, and without special regulation, until the
passage of the ordinance herein complained of.
LVI
That each of said plaintiff's storage tanks has a capacity
of more than 500 gallons, and that each since its erection
has at all times been maintained above ground.
LVI
That each of said storage tanks of the plaintiff, Sin-
clair Refining Company, is an upright or vertical tank, and
ix constructed of steel, on a conerete base.
LVIII
That each of said tanks is not so constructed that it can
be buried as required by the provisions of said Ordinance
No. 350.
LIX
That compliance with the requirements of said ordinance
No, 550 would result in almost a total loss of said plaintiif’s
present tanks and equipment, as the same would have to be
disposed of for junk.
+ 545
WD
LX
That the burying of said plaintiff's tanks, or new tanks
of equal capacity, a» required by Ordinance No, 350, would
be attended by hazards which would render the maintenance
and operation of such tanks underground more dangerous
to property and persons than the maintenance and opera:
tion of said plaintiff’s present tanks above ground.
LXI
(a) That the tanks of the Sinclair Refining Company are
located slightly west of the Center of the South Half of
Block 71; north of said tanks a distance of approximately
10 feet is the warehouse of the Sinclair Company, used for
the storage of greases, lubricating oils, and into w hich is
pumped gasoline and kerosene where they are loaded into
the tank wagons, and in the small lean-to on the west side
of «aid warehouse there are housed gusoline engine pumps
for that purpose.
th) Facing west and about midway of the South half
of Block 71, and en the extreme west side thereof, is the
frame residence of J. H. Riepen, which is distant from the
tanks of the Sinclair Company 58 feet. For a number of
vears prior to the erection of said tanks said residence has
(fol, 47} existed at said location and has been occupied con
tinuously by J. H. Rrepen a» his residence up to the present
time. Immediately hack of his residence there are two small
frame out-buildings, 16 feet distant from the Sinclair tanks,
and on the north-east corner of said property is a frame
barn or shed, 27 feet from the Sinclair warehouse, and im
mediately across the alley north from this barn are several
other frame sheds.
(e) That across the spur tracks, a distance of G2
feet from the Sinclair tanks, are two upright storage
tanks of the Derby Oil Company, east of and in close prox
imity to which i« the warehouse of said Company; that
further east are two upright storage tanks of the Cities
Serview Oi] Company, a distance of 110 feet from the Sin
elair tanks, and immediately north and a few feet distant
ia the warehouse of the Cities Service Company.
51
(d) That along the right-of-way of the Union Pacific
Railroad Company in Block 71, and on the east side of the
spur track, extending north-east and south-west of and
across the alley dividing said Block, there is a coal-shed of
the Bone-MeLucas Lumber Company, 130 feet in length
and 16 feet wide, of wooden construction, the south-west cor-
ner of which is approximately 75 feet from the Sinclair
tanks, about the same distance from the tanks of the Cities
Service Company, and about 60 feet from the tanks of the
Derby Oil Company. In this coal-shed is stored large
quantities of coal.
(ce) In the North Half of Block 71, toward the west and
facing north on Spring Street, is a two-story frame resi-
dence 166 feet from the Sinclair tanks; east of that there is
another frame residence, immediately east of which is the
warehouse and truck-house of the Fenwick Oi! Company,
together with the three storage tanks of that Company
buried underground.
(f) In Block 50, lying directly north of Block 71, the
south half is occupied by four residences, two of which face
south on Spring Street and two east on Sixth Street, to-
gether with three out-buildings, barns, garages, ete.: and
in the north half of Block 50 there are four residences, three
facing north on Walnut Street and one facing east on Sixth
Street, together with five barns, garages and out-buildings.
fg) In Block 51, lving northeast of Block 71, the Union
Pacifie Railroad oceupies a diagonal strip from 6O to 80
feet in width. In addition, the north half of Block 51 con-
tains four residences, two facing north on Walnut Street,
fol. 48] one facing east on Seventh Street and a new house
under construction facing north on Walnut Street, together
with six garages, barns, and out-buildings. The south half
of Block 51 contains, in addition to the railroad right-of
way, a large ice plant in the south-west corner thereof. of
frame construction, 100x42 feet, with an addition of 20.20
feet, each of which is a barn, and in the north-west corner
there sa carpenter shop, and facing east on Seventh Street
is a residence with one ont-building.
(th) In Block 70, Iving east of Block 71, there are two
residences in the north half, and three residences and two
32
barns, garages and out-buildings in the south half, one of
which is in the north-west corner facing west on Sixth
street, and another near the south-west corner facing south
on Oak Street.
(i) In Block 83, lying diagonally across Sixth Street and
south-east of Block 71, is a large frame residence in the
north-west corner, immediately south and a little west of
which, but upon the same lot, there is a large barn; and
there are houses on each lot adjacent to Sixth Street from
Oak to South Streets with the possible exception of one or
two lots in Block 88.
(j) In Block 82, which lies immediately south of Block
71, there is in the north-east corner, facing on Onk Street
a frame residence 99% feet south of the Cities Service
Company's tanks, and a greater distance from the tanks
of the Sinclair Company and west of said residence, fac-
ing north on Oak Street is another frame residence 1054,
feet south of the tanks of the Derby Oi] Company, and a
greater distance from the tanks of the Sinelair Company.
(k) In Block 72, lying west of Block 71, there ix in the
south half thereof a residence facing east on Fifth Street,
4 distance of 200 feet from the Sinclair Company's tanks;
and in the north half of said Black there is a two-story
frame residence facing east on Fifth Street, with two barns
iving west and south of the same.
(1) In Block 49, diagonally north-west of Block 71, on
the south half thereof are four frame residences, two facing
east on Fifth Street and two facing south on Spring Street;
and in the north half of said Block there are four frame
residences, two facing east on Fifth Street and two facing
north on Walnut Street.
(m) That there are six lots in the south half of each
Block. The south half of Block 71 has five occupancies and
{fol. 49] « railroad right-of way: the north half of Block
71 has four occupancies and a railroad right-of-way. The
south half of Block 50 ha« four residences and three out-
buildings, and the north half ha« four residences and five
other atructures. The north half of Block 51 has four resi-
dences, «ix other stroctures and a GO to & foot right-of-
way; and the south half has a @-foot right-of-way, a car-
53
penter shop, a very large ice plant, a residence and two
other structures. The North half of Block 70 has two resi-
dences, and the south half has three residences and two
other structures. In the north half of Block 83 there is
one residence and one barn. In the north half of Block
8&2 there are two residences and in the south half two resi-
dences. In Block 102, lving south of Block 83 there are
four houses, and but one piece of vacant property. In Block
115, south of Block 102, there are four houses. In Block
103, south of Block 82, there are three houses. In Block
103, south of Block 82, there are three houses, and in Block
114 there are three houses. In Block 72 there are two resi-
dences and two barns; and in Block 49 there are eight resi-
dences with out-buildings.
(in) That at Fifth and Oak Streets there is a drop of
seven or eight feet to a lower level, which euts a line diagon-
ally northwest and southeast across Blocks 48, 72 and 82,
which lower level extends westerly and southwesterly a
distance of 150 or 200 feet, is platted, and is suitable for
building purposes, except that the streets need to be cut
through.
(o) That within a radius of 100 feet from the center of
the Sinclair tanks there is one residence, six storage tanks
with a capacity of approximately 75,000 gallons, three
warchouses, large coal-shed, and three out-buildings.
Within a radius of 200 feet there are five residences, the
same six storage tanks and warehouses, seven out-buildings,
harns, ete.. and a 130 foot frame coal-shed. Within a radius
of 400 feet there are seventeen residences, the same stor-
age tanks, warehouses and coal-sheds, a large ice plant, and
11 barns, out-bnildings and other structures: and within a
radius of 0) feet there are 21 residences, the same tanks,
warehouses, coalsheds, ice plant, and a carpenter shop, and
20 barns, garages, out-buildings, and other structures.
LXTI
(a) That the tanks of the Standard Oil Company are lo-
cuted in the southeast corner of the south half of Block 40:
south of said tanks and a distance of ten feet is a frame
[fol. 50) warehouse of the Standard Company where lubri-
cating oils, greases and petroleum products are stored, and
54
to which pipes run from said tanks through which gase
line and kerosene are pumped into tank wagons which are
loaded under a lean-to on the south side of said warehouse ;
that the gasoline pumps for this purpose are located in a
«mal! lean-to on the north side of the warehouse next to the
tanks. North of said tanks, a distance of 27 feet, isa frame
railroad tool-house 14 x 22 feet. West of the tanks and on
the west side of the spur track are frame coal bins 105 feet
long and 12 feet wide, constructed of dry lumber, in which
large quantities of coal are stored, which sheds are 26-27
feet from the Standard tanks. West of said coal-sheds is
a frame residence 93 feet distant from the Standard tanks,
ard immediately west of that residence is a frame garage.
In the southwest corner is a two-story frame residence fac-
ing on Sixth Street, this being one of the best homes in the
city. There are also three other out-buildings on the south
half of Black 40 in the nature of barns, garages, ete.
(hb) In the north half of Block 40, in a northwesterly
direction from the Standard tanks, a hotel property occu:
pies all said north half, except the extreme west and that
extreme east which is taken up by the railroad right of way
The hotel ic a two and one-half story strnetare 40 x SH) feet,
and ja 145 feet from the Standard tanks Southwest of
the hetel and adjacent to the alley, running through the
center of Block 40, is a large combined garage and barn
On the northwest corner there is a residence 22 y 36 facing
west on Sixth Street, in the rear of which, adjacent to the
alley running throngh the center of Block 40, is a com
hined offiee and garage building. This home took first prim
for heautiful homes in a contest in the City of Marveville.
fo) The tanks of the Standard Company are a little les
than two blacks «onth of Rronadway, which i* the main hues
ness street in the City of Maryeville, and approximately
WO) feet south of the edge of the fire limits on the north
aide of Film Street.
id) The senth half of Block 21, lving immediately north
wo” Bleek 40, is almost entirely need hy the ents for storing
machinery, material and tools, bat in the southwest corner
there ix a residence with a barn and two ont-baildings. The
north half of Black 21 faces on Broadway Street, and is oe
cupied by basiness property in the nature of a shoe «tore,
5D
[fol. 51] barber shop, a large clothing store and the city
hall, a cafe and a city store-honse.
(e) Block 22, ving northeast of Block 40, is almost en.
tirely business property. The north half fronts on Broad-
way and is solidly constructed. The south half contains a
studio, a hotel, a large service garage, two small garages,
a residence and a new building under construction which is
305 feet from the Standard tanks.
(f) The north half of Block 39, which hes directly east
of Block 40, has three residences, a large furniture store,
and five garages and out-buildings, together with a railroad
right-of-way occupying a portion of two lots. The south
half of Block 39 has a hotel with garage, a residence 208
feet from the Standard tanks, a cement-block works west
of said residence, and a railroad right-of-way occupying
nhont one third of said south half.
(f) In the north half of Block 52, lving southeast of
Block 40, there are two residences, 100 feet railroad right-
of-way, and in the northwest corner adjacent to Seventh
Street ix a two-story hotel 65 x 40 feet, 160 feet distant
from said tanks.
(h) The nature of the construction in Block 51 is de-
seribed hereinabove, except that a residence in the north-
east corner is @2 feet and 2 inches distant from the Stand.
ard property, and immediately west of said residence there
ix a new house under construction,
(i) In the north half of Block 50, lying southwest of
Block 40, there are four residences, three facing north
en Walnut Street and one east on Sixth Street, and five
harns and garages and other out-buildings; and in the south
half of Block 50 there are four residences facing south on
Spring Street, and two facing east on Sixth Street, and
one barn, one garage and one other out-building.
(j) In the south half of Block 41, lying immediately west
af Block 40, there are three residences facing south on Wal-
nut Street, and four out-buildings in the nature of barns,
garages, ote., and in the north half of Block 41 there are
five residences, four facing north on Elm Street and one
west on Fifth Street, together with two garages or out-
buildings.
(k) In the south half of Block 20, lying northwest of
Block 40, there are five residences facing south on Elm
Street, the nearest of which is 435 feet from the Standard
tanks, and one barn and two other out-buildings; and the
{fol. 52) north half of Block 20, facing on Broadway, is
practically solid business building construction,
(1) In the south half of Block 40 on six lots there are
two residences with out-buildings, the Standard Oil Com-
pany property, coal-bins 105 feet in length, railroad tool-
house, four other structures and a railroad right-of-way ;
in the north half of Block 40 there is a large hotel, a resi-
dence, a doctors’ office building and a large garage and
barn.
(m) Block 39 has four residences, a hotel, a furniture
store and a cement block works, six out-buildings and a
1) foot railroad right-of-way.
(n) The north half of Block 51 has only a vacant strip
40 x 30 feet.
(o} Block 50 has eight residences and cight barns, gar-
ages, ete.
(p) Block 41 has eight residences and six garages, barns,
ete.
iq) The south half of Block 20 has five residences and
three barns, gcarages, etc.
ir} That within a radius of 100 feet from the center af
the Standard Of} Company's tanks there are one residence,
a warehouse, frame tool-house and the large coal bine.
Within 200 feet there are four residences, two hotels, one
warchonse, one tool-house, a cement-block works, the large
coal-bins, amd «ix out-buildings. Within a radius of 4
feet there are nineteen residences, three hotels, warchouse,
tool -hotuse, large ice plant, coment-block factory, three beam -
ness bnildings and twenty harns, garages and other out
boildings. Within a radins of 500 feet there is practically
all the property heretofore described as in Blocks 40, 21,
fo, 32. 51, 50 and 40.
LXIII
That there are no changed conditions in the buildings or
improvements around said tanks, or in their vicinity, which
57
would warrant or justify the requirements of Ordinance
No, 350, that said tanks should be buried.
LXIV
That there are numerous tanks in the City of Marysville,
Kansas, which are, under the provisions of said Ordinance
No, 350, maintained in close proximity to residences and
business buildings, which contain from 100 to 500 gallons of
{fol. 53) distillate and fuel oil, and that said tanks are,
under the authority of said ordinance, maintained above
ground.
LXV
That under the provisions of said Ordinance No. 350 any
quantity of crude oil less than 500 gallons may be stored in
tanks above ground ip any part of the City of Marysville,
and that crude oi) is, as far as fires and explosions are con-
cerned, as hazardous, or more hazardous, than gasoline.
LXVI
That under the provisions of Section 1 of Ordinance No.
207, still in force, and by reference adopted by Ordinance
No. 390, nor more than five gallons of gasoline, fuel oi] or
tnoter syurits can be stored or kept above ground in any
building or upon any premises within the City of Marys.
ville, in one container, and not to exceed two containers
can be kept on such premises; while under the provisions
of Section Sof Ordinance No. 550 the amount of gasoline,
serosene or naphtha which can be stered or kept above
ground must be less than ten gallons,
LXVII
That ander the previsions of Ordinances Nos, 237 and
So0, its unlawful for any citizen of the City of Marys-
ville ta keep more than five gallons of gasoline in the tank
of los automobile, and every garage-keeper in Marysville
who stores cars the tanks of which contain gasoline is
guilty of an offense under both of said ordinances and sub-
ject to the penalties thereunder.
58
LAVIIT
That the provisions of Ordinances Nos, 237 and 300 per-
mit and authorize a discrimination particularly in favor of
those who desire to keep and store crude oil, distillate and
fuel oil in quantities of less than 500 gallons above ground,
and against those who wish to keep and store crude oil,
distillate and fuel oil in quantities of 501 gallons or more
above ground, and against those who wish to store and
keep more than five gallons of gasoline, fuel oi) or motor
spirits on their premises in ote container above ground,
and against those who wish to keep and store ten gallons
or more of gasoline, kerosene oF naphtha above ground in
the City of Marysville.
LXIX
That up until July, 11S, the population of the City of
Marysville was approximately #00, at which time the
{fol. 54) shops and general offices of the St. Jdaseph &
Grand Island Railway Company were removed to Marys
ville from St. Joseph, Missouri, and at the same time
Marysville was made a division point by the Union Pacitic
Railroad Company, and that thereafter the City of Mary®
ville increased very materially in population anti! now it
is over 4200, and since then there has been and is now a
shortage of residences, and building activities beth in resi
dence and business property have been considerable
LXX
That during the samimer of 1928 an extenmen of the
sanitary sewer system of the City of Marysville was made
connecting with the sanitary sewer at the intersection of
Fifth Street, with the alley between Spring and Walnut
Streets, and extending south on Fifth Street one block,
thenee extemling west along the alley through the center
of Blocks 71 and 70 with a lateral running south on Sixth
Street beyond Oak Street. An extension was also made
from Fifth Street cast along the alley from the center of
Blocks 40) and 51, and about one-fourth of the way along
the alley into Block 52. Daring the summer of 1923 and
since that time there has been constructed a brick paving
on Sixth Street from Elm Street south to Jackson Street,
and on Elm Street from Sixth Street east to the city limits
at Sixteenth Street. Numerous other sidewalks have been
constructed and graded in the vicinity of Block 71 and
Block 40,
LXXI
That prior to 1918 Block 49 was a ball park, and it now
contains eight residences and a number of out-buildings.
Some of the residences in the proximity of Block 40 have
heen built in recent years, there being one in 1920, and one
remodeled, both in the south half of Block 40. There is
also a new house under construction in the north half of
Block 51, and two of the houses in Block 50 have been built
recently. The Riepen house in Block 71 has been remod-
eled, and it is reasonable to conclude that with the exten-
sion of the paving on Sixth Street and the construction of
the sanitary sewers built recently more residences will be
built in the immediate vicinity of Block 71. That a great
many of the building sites and locations that are now unoe
enupied by residences are in the southwestern part of Marys-
ville, and, generally speaking, all of the territery imme
diately north and northenst of Block 71 for a distance of
many blocks is built up with residences and there is not
much property vacant for building sites in that direction
{fol 45) LXNXII
That the tanks of the Standard Oil Company are two in
number, cach horizontal, 10° in diameter and 16° in length,
constructed of steel plates 5.16” thick and riveted together
so as to form a cylindrical tank, cach of a capacity of 11,000
vallons, resting on conerete piers IS” high and extending
48” into the earth. Each tank is equipped with a 2” Mac
Donald Duplex Vent and an 18%,” manhole vent, both on
top of the tank, a lhtning arrester or a grounding device
of copper wire, These safety devices are of the best and
most «*etent typ, The Purpose of the venting device js.
to allow automatically the escape of vapor or gas arising
from the contents of the tank and are so constructed that
with increased pressure of vapor or gas from within the
tank the vent is intended to enlarge and allow the escape
of accumulated gas and prevent any injury or danger from
gas pressure. At the bottom of these tanks are pipe con.
nections with valve cut-offs used for the filling of the tanks
from tank cars on the railroad switch and through which
to draw gasoline or kerosene as needed for distribution.
LXXIII
That the tanks of the Sinclair Refining Company are two
in number, each vertical, 10 6” in diameter and 18’ 7” in
height, constructed of steel plates 3°16” in thickness, riv-
eted together so as to form a cylindrical tank, and each of
a capacity of approximately 12,000 gallons, resting on solid
concrete foundation. Each tank is equipped with a 2” Mac-
Donald Duplex Vent and an 18” manhole vent which is a
cap or cover fitted loosely over the manhole, The purpose
of these vents is to allow automatically the escape of vapor
or gas arising from the contents of the tanks and they are
so constructed that with increased pressure of gas from
within the tanks the vent is enlarged and intended to allow
the escape of accumulated gas and prevent any injury or
damage from gas pressure. At the bottom of the tanks
the pipe connections with valve cut-offs used for the filling
of the tanks from tank-cars on the railroad switch and
through which to draw gasoline or kerosene as needed for
distribation. The said venting devices are appro’ ed and
among the best safety devices and equipment known in
the industry.
LXXIV
That there has never been any fire, accident, or explo
sion of any kind at or in the tanks or place of business of
[fol. 56] either the Standard O}} Company or the Sinclair
Refining Company or at any similar tanks in said City of
Marysville.
LXXV
That under the provisions of said ordinance No, 350,
gasoline, kerosene oF naphtha in the amount of ten gallons,
which must be in two containers of five gallons each, may
be kept or stored in any building or premises, but all quan.
61
tities of gasoline, kerosene or naphtha in excess of ten gal-
lons must be stored in tanks, barrels, or other containers,
buried at least three feet underground. And that under
said ordinance No. 350, five hundred gallons or less of crude
oil, distillate or fuel oil, but only one such container on a
premises may be kept or stored above ground; but all quan-
tities of crude oil, distillate or fuel oil in excess of 500 gal-
lens must be kept or stored in tanks, barrels or other con-
tainers, buried at least three feet under ground; and that
under the provisions of said ordinance it is unlawful to
store more than ten gallons of gasoline or kerosene above
ground, and more than 500 gallons of crude oil, distillate
or fuel oil above ground.
LXXVI
That both the Standard Oil Company and the Sinclair
Refining Company are now, and have been since November
10, 1923, storing gasoline and kerosene in the City of
Marysville in violation of said ordinance No, 350.
LXXVII
That said ordinance No, 350 does not pretend to regu-
late the transportation or use of gasoline and kerosene, but
regulates only the keeping and storing of said products.
LXXVIII
That neither the Standard Oil Company nor the Sinclair
Refining Company operates any automobiles in the City of
Marysville for any purpose other than the transportation
of petroleum products, nor does either of them own, oper-
ate or maintain a garage or garages in said City of Marys-
ville.
LXXIX
That both the Standard Oi! Company and the Sinclair Re-
fining Company store gasoline and kerosene in their tanks
located in the City of Marysville, and do not now, or never
have, stored crude oi] in said tanks, nor is crude oil stored
by anyone in said City of Marysville.
62
{fol. 57] LXXX
That the defendant, the City of Marysville, has caused
the arrest of an agent of each of the plaintiff companies
for the keeping and storing of gasoline and kerosene in
said tanks as aforesaid in alleged violation of said ordi
nance No, 350.
LXXXI
Gasoline and kerosene are highly inflammable and com:
bustible liquids and are dangerous and hazardous. Both
vaporize when coming in contact with the atmosphere and
will ignite when it comes in contact with flame or spark,
and that vapor, mixed in proper proportions with the at-
mosphere, coming in contact with spark or flame will ex
plode with most disastrous results. Gasoline is highly vola-
tile and will flash at ordinary room temperature. Gaso-
line and kerosene can be handled so as to avoid fire and
explosion, and it is generally true that where gasoline and
kerosene are contained in tanks such as those used by
plaintiffs, and equipped in the manner in which they are
equipped, they will burn only at the vent openings in the
tanks and will not explode when heat is applied to them.
And yet, gasoline and kerosene are of such a character that
even when the most modern safety devices are in use a
relaxing of conditions, a careless act or an accident, or
failure in the operation of the safety devices, or the pres-
ence of extreme heat, may result in fires or explosions most
destructive to life and property.
The record shows fires at five storage stations in Kan-
sas: two in 1919, two in 1922, and one in December, 1925.
The McCracken and Greenleaf fires were at tanks of the
Sinclair Company, equipped with MeDonald Duplex Vents
and loose manhole covers, the same or similar to those of
the Company at Marysville, and at McCracken the top of
the vertical gasoline tank was blown out and the kerosene
tank exploded and was lifted off the foundation and thrown
to the ground fifteen feet therefrom.
At Hays, Kansas, in November, 1919, tanks of the Stand.
ard Oil Company containing gasoline and kerosene burned
and exploded. One end of the gasoline tank was blown out
and against an elevator 82 feet away, which it burned com-
pletely, whereas the main part of the tank was hurled in
the opposite direction a distance of 475 feet, breaking off
an eight-inch spruce tree en route and lodging against and
burning up a dwelling house where it struck, and in the
{fol. 58] course of its travel killing nine people, wounding
at least twenty-six more and burning several other houses.
Fires at storage stations have occurred which so heated
up the contents in the storage tanks as to burst open the
seams thereof and let gasoline run out and along the
ground, burning in a flowing flame as it ran, igniting other
property 30 to 60 feet away; and at other fires the flames
have been known to shoot up into the air 50 to 100 feet high
and be swept by the wind and set fire to and burn up prop-
erty 60 to 75 feet distant therefrom.
That the danger of fire to warehouses adjacent to storage
tanks is great owing to the fact that there are kept and
stored therein oils, greases and petroleum products which
are highly combustible, easily ignited and difficult to extin-
guish, and many instances have occurred where warehouses
and storage tanks have become ignited by back-fires from
automobile trucks, sparks from the gasoline engines used
to pump the products to and from the storage tanks, sparks
from static electricity created by the abrasion of metallic
bodies, or otherwise, in which cases tank wagons and
smaller barrels and containers of petroleum products in
the warehouses have exploded. Such fires produce ex-
treme heat around the storage tanks, have broken the con-
nections, or melted off the valves, thus permitting the gaso-
line to flow out of the tanks and burn, adding to the fire
and intensity of the heat, and in those cases should a safety
device fail to operate or should more gas pressure be
formed than the venting devices could relieve, an explosion
would occur.
LXXXII
That distillate and fuel oil are not nearly so dangerous
as gasoline and kerosene.
LXXXIII
That the objections which the plaintiffs make to the stor-
ing of gasoline and kerosene in tanks buried underground
are that the maintenance of sail tanks is very difficult;
should leaks oceur they could not be discovered and the con-
tents might penetrate through the earth, get into sewers,
wells and basements, and contaminate water and cause ex-
plosions; and that such leaks would develop through the
effect of electrolysis and corrosion, eating out the metal
of the tank, vibration and temperatures changing lossen
the seams, and by the tanks being ‘*floated out’’ and break
ing connections. With reference to the above objections
the evidence shows.
{fol. 59} (a) That the conditions which produce elec-
trolysis are not present in the City of Marysville, nor in
Blocks 40 and 71, where the tanks of the plaintiffs are
located.
(b) That the conditions which produce corrosion of metal
underground are the acids in the soil combining with the
oxygen in moisture, and sulphuric acid is a dangerous cor-
rosive; and considering all the acid in the soil at the prop
erty of the Standard Oil Company in Block 40 as sulphuric
acid, it tests 140 to OT] per cent. acid, and that the prop
erty of the Sinclair Company in Block 71 tests 025 per cent.
acid. Although there is more chance of corrosion of metal
underground of the Standard Oil Company property, it
might take a term of years for it to occur.
(e) That ander the conditions existing in and around
Blocks 71 and 40 in the City of Marysville there would be
vibration that might weaken the seams in tanks buried
under ground.
(id) That the evidence «hows that the seams of a tank
under ground might be weakened by temperature changes
to such an extent as to cause the tank to leak. Such tanks
are, however, subject to lexs changes in temperature than
tanks above ground.
(eo) That tanks buried ander three feet of ground in
Block 71 have not floated out during periods of rather
heavy rainfall, and any danger of floating can be overcome
by proper drainage of the surface water by mounding up
the earth, and by weighting, strapping or anchoring down
the tanks.
65
(f) That tanks buried in compliance with Ordinance No.
350 would rest on a level thirteen feet below the level of
the ground; that the only sewers in and around Blocks 71
and 40 are ten and one-half feet below the level of the
ground, and the evidence does not show that there are any
wells anywhere in the vicinity. The soi) in Blocks 71 and
40 is a heavy black gumbo, shading gradually into a com-
pact plastic yellow clay, and tests made thereof by attempt-
ing to force water through the same by exerting a pressure
of fourteen pounds per square inch for two and one-half
hours, showed that only a few small drops of water came
through, and the same test with gasoline, no gasoline came
through.
LXXXIV
That the danger from fire or explosion due to lightning,
which causes a great many fires in oil storage, is less in
underground tanks than in above ground tanks.
{fol 60) LXXXV
That the danger from fire or explosions due to static
electricity is less in underground tanks than in above-
ground tanks.
LXXXVI
That the base rate of insurance on storage tanks of gaso-
line and kerosene underground is fifty per cent. of the base
rate of tanks above ground.
LXXXVII
That the provisions of Ordinances Nos, 237 and 350 are
arbitrary, capricions, discriminatory, unreasonable and
eubwersive of the rights of the plaintiff, The Sinclair Re.
fining Company, herein.
Conclusions of Law
I
That the United States District Court, for the District
of Kansas, First Division, has jurisdiction of the parties
to this action and of the subject-matter thereof.
--§65
(6
Il
That sections numbered one and three of said Ordinance
No. 350 of the defendant, the City of Marysville, Kansas,
and each and every provision thereof, is arbitrary, ca-
pricious, diseriminatory, unreasonable and subversive of
the rights of plaintiff, and void.
Il
That Ordinance No. 350 of the defendant, the City of
Marysville, is arbitrary, capricious, discriminatory, un-
reasonable and subversive of the rights of plaintiffs, and
void.
Recommendations of Special Master
The Special Master recommends that a decree be entered
in said cause in accordance with the foregoing Findings
ef Fact and Conclusions of Law, declaring and decreeing
said Ordinance No, 350 of the City of Marysville, Kansas,
to be arbitrary, unreasonable, discriminatory and contisea
tory of plaintiffs’ property, in violation of plaintiffs’ rights
under the Constitution and laws of the United States and
the common law, the Constitution and laws of the State of
Kansas, and void; that said defendants and each of them
he perpetually enjoined and restrained from enforcing of
attempting to enforce said ordinance, and that said plain.
tiffs have and recover from said defendants their costs in
said anit.
[fol.61] The Special Master further reports that the re-
spective partics presented their several requests for find-
ings of fact and conclusions of law.
Such requests are herewith returned as part of the ree-
ord. Those not included in the foregoing findings of fact
and conclusions of law reached by the Special Master are
denied.
The case was fully presented by reapective counsel, both
in oral arguments and voluminous citations of authorities.
Much time has been consumed in the taking of testimony,
in considering the authorities cited, a* well as in the prepa.
ration of the final report, copies of which were served upon
reapective counsel in the case.
67
Standard Oil Company deposited with the Special Mas-
ter during the hearing the sum of $442.33. Sinclair Re-
fining Company deposited the same amount. The defend-
ant, the City of Marysville deposited $393.86, making a
total of $1,278.52. For such advancement each should re-
ceive credit in the taxation of costs.
The Special Master has expended for costs of reporting
the evidence taken and proceedings had and costs of tran-
script of same the sum of $840.71, which he asks may be
allowed and taxed as costs in the case, vouchers for same
heing returned herewith.
The Special Master has expended for stenographic fees
in the preparation of his report and in making copies of
same for counsel in the case the sum of $44.00, which he
asks may be allowed and taxed as costs in the case.
The Special Master has expended for hotel and inciden-
tal expenses in the hearing of said causes the sum of
$145.00, which he asks may be allowed and taxed as costs
in the ease.
The Special Master charges himself with $248.80, balance
of unused deposit.
Standard Oil Company has paid its witnesses’ per diem,
attendance and mileage, amounting to $188.80, a statement
of which is herewith returned and made a part of this re-
port.
Sinclair Refining Company has paid out for its witnesses
for per diem, attendance and mileage $111.20, statement of
which is herewith returned and made a part of this report.
The City of Marysville has paid out for its witnesses for
per diem, attendance and mileage the sum of $486.25, state-
[fol. 62] ment of which is herewith returned and made a
part of this report.
For which amounts, so paid out by the respective parties,
each should have credit in the taxation of costs.
The «mall model of a MeDonald Duplex Oil Tank Valve,
being plaintiffs’ Exhibit No, 8, and the piece of iron pipe,
being defendants’ Exhibit No. 9, were left in the Federal
Court room at Kansas City, Kansas, for future use.
All of which is respectfully submitted this 24th dav of
January, A. D., 1924,
Charles Blood Smith, Special Master.
68
Ix Unirep States Distsict Covst
Derexvant’s Exceptions To THE Report anp Fixpines oF
Tur Special Masrex—Filed Feb. 13, 1925
Now come the above named defendants and except to the
report and findings of Charles Blood Smith, Esq., Special
Master, filed in this cause on the 24th day of January, 1925,
and for cause of exceptions show:
I
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (Nos.
IX and X) that the plaintiff, the Standard Oil Company,
erected a plant and tanks for keeping and storing gasoline
and kerosene with the knowledge and consent of the de
fendant city, and that said plaintiff's right or authority
to erect and maintain said tanks for said purpose war
never denied or questioned until October 8, 1923, for the
reason that said findings are contrary to and not sup-
ported by the record as shown by the stipulation entered
in the record at Tr. 457; whereas the Special Master ought
to have found, as set out in defendant's request No. 4,
that the records of the City of Marysville do not show that
said city ever granted the Standard Oi] Company any per
mit to so locate or maintain said tanks, and that no action
questioning the right or authority of said plaintiff to main-
tain, or the manner of maintaining said tanks, such as that
contemplated in Ordinace No. 230, was ever taken by the
defendant City until two years prior to its passage, to-wit:
October 8, 1923, at which time ineffectual efforts were
made to regulate by ordinance all keeping and storage of
gasoline within said city (Tr. 457).
(fol, 63} il
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
XIT1) that the tanks of the plaintiff, the Standard Oi) Com.
pany, at Marysville, each have capacity of approximately
17,000 gallons for the reason that said finding is contrary
to and not supported by the evidence as shown by the plain-
tiff's witness, Mr. Wagner, at Tr. 32: and said finding is
in conflict with the Special Master's finding No. LXXII
69
based on the defendant's request No. 16, and said finding
No. XIII should be made to conform therewith.
Ill
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
XVI) that both of the venting devices with which each of
the plaintiff's, the Standard Oi] Company, tanks is equipped
are sufficient to carry off any vapor arising from the liquid
contents of the tanks, even when the same is subject to ex-
treme heat, for the reason that said finding is a conclusion
of fact in conflict with Special Master’s finding No.
LXXXI.
IV
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
XX) that no complaint was ever made of or fault found
with the construction, equipment or the manner of opera-
tion of the plaintiff's, the Standard Oil Company, tanks,
for the reason that said finding is not supported by any
evidence in the record and is contrary to the stipulation
entered at Tr. 457.
V
For that the Special Master erred in finding (No. XX1)
that the construction, equipment and manner of operation
of each of the plaintiff's, The Standard Oil Company, tanks
are standard and of the kinds and character generally em-
ployed by said plaintiff in the conduct of its business at all
points other than the city of Marysville, for the reason
that said finding is based on incompetent, irrelevant and
immaterial testimony which attempts to establish a custom
not binding on these defendants and not within the issues
of the cause, and constituting no equity grounds for equi-
table relief against the defendants, proper and timely ob-
jection to which was made at Tr. 38-9, 228-9.
VI
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (Nos.
XXII, XXII and XXIV) that the plaintiff, the Standard
Oil Company, during the five vears last past has had 66
70
{fol. 64] fires, and no more, at the 12,000 tanks similar to
its tanks in Marysville, and of those the one at Hays, Kan-
sas, November, 1919, is the only one in which a tank ex-
ploded, or in which fire spread to or injured other prop-
erty or persons, for the reason that said findings are based
on incompetent, and irrelevant, and immaterial testimony
not within the issues of the cause, and constituting no
ground for equitable relief, proper and timely objection
to which was made at Tr. 616.
Vil
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
XXV) that the plaintiff's tank, which exploded during the
fire at Hays, Kansas, was not equipped with a manhole
vent similar to the manhole vent with which each of the
tanks of the plaintiff at Marysville, Kansas, ix equipped,
for the reason that said finding is not a fair and complete
statement of the facts, and is misleading, as is shown by
the evidence of the witnesses Love (Tr. 402, 4-5), King (Tr.
428) and Sims (Tr. 558).
vill
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
XXVI) that there is no evidence in this case tending to
show that any tank similar in construction, equipment and
manner of operation to those maintained by said plaintiff
at Marveville, Kansas, ever exploded, or that fire from any
such tank ever spread to or otherwise injured either the
property or the safety of others, for the reason that said
finding is in conflict with Special Master's finding No.
LXXXI. and is not a fair and complete statement of the
facts, and is misleading, as is shown by the evidence of
witnesses Hubbard (Tr. 338), Decker (Tr. 346, 7 and &,
and 255), Quinley (Tr. 359 and 60), Frankenstein (Tr.
262, 3 and 4, 368 and 370), Kenffer (Tr. 372-3, 37h, 378
and Exhibit ‘*1""), Smith (Tr. 383-6), Love (4024.5.7 and
412), King (Tr. 425-9), Armstrong (Tr. 458-9 and 60-1),
Defendant's Exhibit “F’* and 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. Cross 63,
Gamber, 179, Hopkins 156.
71
IX
For that the Special Master erred in finding (Nos.
XXVIII, XLV and LX) that the burying of the tanks of
either of the plaintiffs is more dangerous to property and
persons than the maintenance and operation of said tanks
above ground, for the reason that said finding is a mere
conclusion of fact which invades and usurps the judgment
and discretion of the Mayor and Council of the City of
Marysville, and is in conflict with the Special Master’s
(fol. 65] findings Nos. LXI, LXII, LXIX, LXX, LXXI,
LXXXI. LXXXIII, LXXXIV, LXXXV and LXXXVI,
and having given this finding further erred in declining
to find, as set out in the defendant's request No. 39, that
there is a substantial conflict of opinion as to whether stor-
age above ground or under ground is more hazardous to
public safety, and that all testimony to the effect that
above ground storage is less hazardous is based on gen-
eral conditions and not on conditions existing at and
around blocks 40 and 71 in the city of Marysville, whereas
the testimony that underground storage is less hazardous
is based both on general conditions and conditions in and
around blocks 40 and 71 in the City of Marysville, and
that there is a fair difference of opinion as to whether
storage of gasoline and kerosene above ground or under
ground is more hazardous to the public safety, all as
shown by the testimony of the witnesses Cross (Tr. 51, 2, 4
and 57), Boehmer (Tr. 92, 169), Hopkins (Tr. 141), Gam.
ber (Tr. 174), Lewis (Tr. 229), Campbell (Tr. 196), Cady
(Tr. 535-6), Simpson (Tr. 576, 7, 8, and 9, 585, 6, and 7),
Henderson (Tr. 620), Burgster, (Tr. 630), Patrick (Tr.
647, 8 and 9), and findings Nos, LXXXI, LXXXIII,
LXXXIV, LXXXV.
x
For that the said Special Master erred in finding No.
XXIX) that the plaintiff's, the Standard Oil Company,
tanks are located in a sparsely populated portion of the
City of Marysville, for the reason that said finding is in
conflict with Special Master's finding- Nos. LXII, LXIX,
LXX and LXXI.
~
to
x!
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (Nos.
XXX and LXIII) that there are no changed conditions in
the buildings or improvements around the tanks and prem-
ises of either of said plaintiffs, or in that vicinity, which
would warrant or justify that said tanks be buried as re-
quired by Ordinance No, 350, for the reason that said find-
ings are in conflict with the Special Master's findings Nos.
LXI, LXU, LXIX, LXX and LXXI.
XI
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No,
XXX1) that each of the tanks of the plaintiff, the Standard
Oil Company, are so operated and maintained and equipped
with venting devices as to be safe from the standpoint of
ifol. 66] the public safety, for the reason that said find
ing is a mere conclusion of fact and in conflict with the
Special! Master's finding No. LXXXI, and the further find.
ing that said tanks do not present a greater fire hazard
than would a frame building or a stock of groceries in a
frame building at the same focation, for the reason that
said finding is hased on incompetent, irrelevenat and im
tnaterial testimony not tending to prove any issues in the
cause, and constituting no eypuity, proper and timely objec
tion to which was made at Tr. 178, 198, 201; and ts argu
mentative, and,
Having given said finding No. XXXI, the said Special
Master erred in declining to give defendant's request No
ITB, that the city council may make reasonable classifica.
tions of private property and business for the purpose of
regulating them in the interest of public safety, and the
classification putting frame buildings and frame business
structures in one class, and storage of gasoline and kero-
sone and petroleum products in another, is a proper classifi
cation, and that the evidence does not show, and therefore,
there ix no presumption, that proper regulations have pot
heen made of frame baildings and business structures
the interest of public safety.
XIII
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No
XXXII) that the dwelling house closest to the plaintil's
73
the Standard Oi] Company, tanks, is more than 98 feet
distant, for the reason that said finding is contrary to and
not supported by the evidence, as is shown by the testi-
mony of the witness Bowman (Tr. 272) and finding No.
LXIU, and for the further reason that said finding is not
a fair and complete statement of the facts and is mislead-
ing, as is shown by finding of the Special Master No, LXIL
XIV
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
XNXV) that large quantities of cinders have been and are
now used for ballast upon the tracks of the Union Pacific
Railway Company, which is 20 feet from the plaintiff's,
the Standard Oi] Company, station, for the reason that
said finding is not a clear, accurate and complete state-
mon! of the facts, as is shown by the testimony of the wit-
nesses Brooks (Tr, 80), Bowman (Tr. 438), and in declin-
ing to find, as set out in defendant's request No, 32, that
the ballast on the spur track in block 40 is of cinder and
Sherman Hill gravel, and that although water passing over
cinders produces a corrosive acid, yet pipes buried on this
(fol. 67) right-of-way for at least 11 years show that there
is little danger of corrosion to a tank buried on the prop-
erty of the Standard Oil Company but what can be pro-
tected agaist (Tarvin 464-0 and Defendant's Exhibit 9).
XV
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
NANVIL) that the natural tlow and drainage is from the
rotlroad tracks of the Union Pacific Railway Company
apen and over the property occupied by the plaintiff, the
Standard Oh! Company, for the reason that there is no tes
hamensy an the record to support sal finding.
XVI
bor that the said Special Master erred in finding (Nos.
NL and LXV) that erude oil is more dangerous from the
stam.pomnt of public safety than is gasoline or kerosene,
and presents a greater hazard, for the reason that said
finding is mere surplusage and not within the issues as
shown by Special Master's finding No. LXXIX, and is so
74
general in its nature as to be clearly erroneous, as shown
by the testimony of the witnesses Cross (Tr. 54, 5 and 6),
Cady (Tr. 550, 3, 4, and 5, 50-1), Simpson (Tr. 574),
Patrick (Tr. 649), Boehmer (Tr. 99 and 6, 483, 692), Hop-
kins (Tr. 144, 149).
xvi
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (Nos.
XLI and LXVI) that under Ordinance 237 not more than
five gallons of gasoline, fuel oil or motor spirits can be
stored or kept above ground in any building or upon any
premises in any one container, and not to exceed [Wo con-
tainers to a premise, whereas under Ordinance No. 390,
the quantity of said commodities which can be stored or
kept is less than ten gallons, for the reason that said find-
ing does not prove or tend to prove any of the issues in
this cause, and if there be any conflict, the provisions of
Ordinance No. 350 will govern.
XVill
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (Nos.
XLII and LXVII) that ander the provisions of Ordinance
No, 237 and No, 350 it is unlawful for any citizen of Marys-
ville to keep more than five gallons of gasoline in the tank
of his automobile, and that every garece keeper in Mars.
ville, whe stores cats the tanks of which contain gasoline,
ix guilty of an offense under the ordinance, for the reason
that «aid finding is an erroneous interpretation of said ordi
{fol. GS] nanee, and does not prove or tend to prove any
of the issues in this cause, a i« shown by the Special Mas-
ter’s findings Nos. LXXVII and LXNXVIII, and for the
further reason that said finding ix also based on incompe-
tent, irrelevant and immaterial testimony not tending to
prove any of the iaanes in the cause, and constituting ne
equity or ground for equitable relief, proper and timely
objection to which was made at Tr. 28, 134, 136,
XIX
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
XLII) that the provisions of Ordinances Nos, 237 and
350) permit and authorize a discrimination in favor of those
75
who keep and store crud) oil, distillate, and fuel oil in quan-
tities of less than five hundred gallons above ground and
against those who wsh to keep and store the same commod-
ities in quantities of five hundred gallons or more above
ground; and against those who wish to store and keep ten
gallons of gasoline, fuel oil, or motor spirits on their prem-
ises in One container above ground; and against those who
wish to keep and store ten gallons or more of gasoline,
kerosene, or naphtha above ground in the City of Marys-
ville, for the reason that said finding is an erroneous inter-
pretation of said ordinances and not within the issues in
this cause; Whereas, the Special Master ought to have
granted the finding as set out in defendant's Request No.
43, that Ordinance No. 350 makes a reasonable classifica-
tion as between gasoline and kerosene on the one hand, and
fuel of and distillate on the other; and a reasonable elassi-
fication as between the keeping and storing of ten gallons
or tess of gasoline or kerosene on the one hand and quan-
tities in exeess of ten gallons on the other; and a reason-
able classification as between the keeping and storing of five
hundred gallons of fuel oil and distillate on the one hand
and quantities in excess of five hundred gallons of said
products on the other hand; and said ordinance applies
equally to all persons, firms, or corporations who keep and
store like amounts of gasoline and kerosene in the one case,
and like amounts of distillate and fuel oil on the other and
is net discriminatory and does not deny to either of the
PaintiiYs the equal protection of the law: all of which is
shown by Special Master's findings No. LXXXI to
LANXVI, both inclusive, LX, LXIL, LXIEX. and LXX,
defendant's exhibits F, 1, 2.3, 4, and 5, and the testimony
of the witness, Cross, (Tr. 55 6).
aa
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (Nos,
NLVIT and LANXVI1), that Sections 1 and 3 of Ordinance
[fol 69] Ne. 350, and each and all parts thereof are arbi-
trars, capricious, discriminatory, unreasonable and sub-
Versive of the rights of the plaintiff for the reason that
said finding is a conclusion of fact hased on erroneous find-
ings of fact, ix not supported by the evidence, is not a fair
76
and reasonable conclusion from the findings made by the
Special Master herein, and constitutes an invasion and
usurpation of the diseretion of the Mayor of and City Coun-
cil of the City of Marysville.
XXI
For that the said Specialy Master erred in finding (No.
LIT) that each of the tanks of the plaintiff, The Sinclair
Refining Company, is equipped with sufficient venting de-
vices fo care for all excess vapors even under conditions
of extreme heat, and that said vents are maintained in good
working order and condition and that the connections,
pipes, cut-offs and equipment for filling and emptying said
storage tanks and tank wagons are sufficient and safe equip-
ment and that all of said equipment is maintained and op-
erated in a first class, careful, prudent, and safe manner,
and that the said plaintiff's storage tanks have been op-
erated carefully, prudently, and safely ; for the reason that
said finding is not supported by any evidence and is con-
trary to the evidence as shown by the testimony of the wit-
nesses, Travelute, (Tr. 243 5-6), Fenwick, (Tr. 350), and
defendant's Exhibits A and B, and for the further rea-
son that said finding is in conflict with Special Master's
*inding No. LXXXI, and the testimony of the witness,
Hubbard, (Tr. 338), Decker, (Tr. 345, 7 and &, and 355),
Quinley, (Tr. 359 and 60), Frankenstein, (Tr. 362, 3 and 4,
268 and 370), Keuffer (Tr. 372-3, 375, 378 and Exhibit
1"), Smith (Tr. 383-6), Love (402-4-5-7 and 412), King
(Tr. 425-9), Armstrong, (Tr. 458-9 and 60-1).
XXII
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
LVI) that the tanks of The Sinclair Refining Company were
constructed under authority duly granted by the mayor and
councilmen of the City of Marysville for the reason that
said finding is not a fair, accurate, and complete statement
of the facts as shown by the petition of The Sinclair Re-
fining Company filed herein; Whereas, the Special Mas-
ter ought to have found, as set out in defendant's Request
No. 6, that said tanks were constructed under authority
granted to one J. H. Riepen, on September 12, 1910, as
shown by piaintiff’s Exhibit D.
77
{fol. 70) XXIII
For that the said Special Master refused to give that
part of defendants’ Request No. 15 that ‘‘citizens have
assigned as a reason for not building in the vicinity of
Block 71 their fear of the danger of the explosion of oil
tanks,’’ which finding should have been given as is shown
by the testimony of the witness, Travelute, (Tr. 255-6).
XXIV
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to give
that part of the defendant's Request No. 27, which states
that ‘tand there have been instances when tanks containing
the same products and equipped in the same or similar man-
ner have burned and, or exploded, causing death and
serious destruction of property,’’ which finding is sup-
ported by Special Master's finding No. LXXXI, and the
testimony of the witnesses, Travelute, (Tr. 243-5-6), Fen-
wick, (Tr. 330), and defendant's Exhibits A and B, and for
the further reason that said finding is in conflict with Spe-
cial Master's finding No. LXXX1I, and the testimony of the
witnesses, Hubbard, (Tr. 338), Decker, (Tr. 345, 7 and 8
and 355), Quinley (Tr. 359 and 60), Frankenstein (Tr. 362,
3 and 4, 368 and 370), Keuffer (Tr. 372-3, 375, 378 and Ex-
hibit **1''), Smith (Tr. 383-6), Love (402-4-5-7 and 412),
King (Tr. 425-9), Armstrong, (Tr. 458-9 and 60-1).
XXV
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to
find (No. LXXXIII, (b) ) with reference to the acids found
in Blocks 40 and 71 in the City of Marysville, as set out in
defendant's Request No. 30, b, that, ‘‘in each case it is very
doubtful that the acid found is sulphuric acid,” as shown
by the testimony of the witness, Cady (Tr. 511-12), and
further erred in finding that it might take a term of years
for corrosion to occur under ground at the Standard Oil
property; Whereas, the said Special Master ought to have
found that it would take a term of years for corrosion to
even start and that there would be no difficulty in pro-
tecting against it, as shown by the testimony of the wit-
nesses, Cady, (Tr. 513-4-5.6-7), Patrick, (Tr. 646-7).
XXVI
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
LXXXIII (c)) that under the conditions in and around
Blocks 71 and 40, in the City of Marysville **there would be
{fol. 71} vibration that might weaken the seams in tanks
buried under ground ;"’ Whereas, the Special Master ough!
to have found, as requested in defendant's Request No. 30
(c), that ‘*it is very doubtful whether under the conditiens
existing in and around Blocks 71 and 40, in the City of
Marysville, there would be vibration sufficient to weaken
the seams in tanks buried under ground and any leakages
from such cause is a very remote possibility, as shown by
the testimony of the witnesses, Brooks (Tr. 812, 890), Cady,
(Tr. 521), Simpson, (Tr. 594). :
XXVIl
For that the said Special Master erred in finding (No.
LXXXITE (d) ) that “the evidence shows that the seams
of a tank under ground might he weakened by temperature
changes to such an extent as to cause the tank to lean’;
Whereas, the Master ought to have found, as set out in de-
fendant’s Request No. 30 id), that the probability that the
seams of a tank under ground beng weakened by tempera.
ture to such an extent as to cause leaks is very remote, a5
shown by the testimony of the witnesses, Boehmer (Tr.
1045-6, amd 454), Fenwick (Tr. 310), Cady, (Tr. 519-20),
and Simpson (Tr. 575 6-7-8, and 9).
XXVIII
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to find,
(No. LXXXIII (f) ) ae @ pert of the finding that the tests
made showing that a few drops of water and no gasoline
came through samples of coil taken from Blocks 71 and 40,
that anid soil is so nearly imperviows as to make it quite
improbable that any leaks «o «mall as not to be discovered
would seep through the soil ina lateral direction, but rather
would come up throagh the loose soil in which the tanks are
buried and dissipate in the air and that owing to the fact
that «aid tanks are lower than the sewer level and the na
ture of the construction of the sewers that the possibility
79
of any gasoline getting into the sewers is too remote to
present any serious danger; as shown by the testimony
of the witresses, Cady (Tr. 507-10, 527-8), Brooks (Tr. 85-
6), and Bowman (Tr. 286-7).
XXIX
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to
find as set out in defendant's Request No. 28 that the stor-
age of gasoline in quantities of ten thousand gallons in a
tank in a residential district is very hazardous, as shown
by the testimony of witness, Cross (Tr. 62).
{fol. 72] XXX
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to find,
as set out in defendant’s request No. 33 ‘That there is no
cinder ballast on the spur track in Block 40,’’ as is shown
by the testimony of the witness Bowman (Tr. 437-8).
XXXI
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to find,
as set out in defendant's Request No. 36, that a large per-
centage of fires at storage stations originate in or about
warehouses caused by back-fires of the motors in the tank-
wagons, sparks from gasoline, pumping engines, and other
causes, resulting from fire, create extreme heat around stor-
age tanks, and as the heat increases the amount of vapor
from the contents of the tank increases, and as the vapor
increases the greater the pressure becomes, and the greater
the pressure the more danger there is of an explosion and
that this danger from communicated fire is almost entirely
eliminated in the tanks buried under ground on account of
the protection of the covering of three feet of earth as
shown by the testimony of the witness Boehmer (Tr. 100,
484.5, 429.4), Wagner (Tr. 166-7), Cady, (Tr. 535), Simp-
son (Tr. 575-6), Cross (Tr. 660-1.2), Tasker (Tr. 452-3-4),
Defendant's Exhibit, “*F,°' 1, 2, 3. 4,5,) Hopkins (Tr. 155).
XXXII
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to find,
as set out in defendant's Request No. 37, that, owing to
80
the fact that there ia more evaporation in above ground
tanks than under ground tanks and owing to the breathing
process of the tanks above ground due to temperature
changes there is more danger of having an explosive mix-
ture in the tanks, as shown by the testimony of the wit-
nesses, Boehmer (Tr. 97-5, 100), Cady (Tr. 518-9, 520-1,
552), Simpson (Tr. 577-8-9, 580, 596), Patrick (Tr. 648).
XXXII
For that the said Special Master erred in refusing to
find, as set out in defendant's Request No. 38, that there is
much less danger to the public safety from an explosion in
a storage tank buried three f
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.