Transcript of Record — Marshall & Co. v. " PRES. ARTHUR"
Supreme Court brief1929
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(33,581)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITEDSTATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1928
No. 272
W. A. MARSHALL & CO. INC, PETITIONER,
es,
STEAMSHIP “PRESIDENT ARTHUR. HER
ENGINES, BOILERS, ETC.
ON WHIT OF CRHTIONARL TO TIE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPRALS Pak THE SHOCOND CLRCUIT
INDEN
Original i’rint
Recon! from the district court of the United States, South
ern New York a 1 1
Miatement vm 1 1
Lited 4 i
Aseader! soxwer a) 3
Cam we on
Ayq@araners of counsel Ww 6
Peetimeny of CW. Sanford . w 6
Liteliant’s Mahitdt 1 Contract between WA Mayr
eheall A Oo and American Valestine Lime, In
Gated February 18 142" ‘ a 14
libellants Eaxhittd 2. Letter from American Dales
tine Tdne In to W A Marshall A Co. dated
Petruars 1, 192% 4 16
litelisnt’s Pahibit 3. 4contract between Wo A Mat
shall A Co amd American Palestine Line Inc.
date? Mareh 4 1025 pa 14
stm &A Derwriaen Cds), Pentre, Wastypneron 1) C Newen im 7, 11S
EP ERR AIRE MIELE FPG EEN OH STE REGIE A REE Sy BN UTC Re Hg SHES ORS
i INDEX
Libellant’s Exhibit 4.-Letter from American ales
tine Line, Ine. to Wo A Marshall &A Co. dated
i an 3k dit gns bank enddatyscete 4) 1s
Chaimant’s Pahibit A--Letter from w a Marshall
& Co Ww American Palestine Line, Im, dated
Pebreary Hi 1S on i ri ws 1s
Claimants Pxhittt B- Trade aoeqtance dated
March 6 1855.. se ; P| iv
Claimant's Exhitit (—-Afidavit of CW Sanfomt
dated (tuber 2 1S : 25 m1)
Chaimant’s Exhibit D-—Afiddasit of George W
Hinckiey, dated (tether 15 105 33 33
Opinion, Thacher, J ' SS x
Pinst deere... + te 3
Nethe of apypoe! me 2
Assignimensts of error Pon os
Bitgulation re trameerige of mword ic »
(Verk’s vertifieate (wmitte? ig printing: 4a
Proeeesfiags in the Unitest States circuit court of apgeals
soumed etrewit we ; 44 ”
t(ydnkm, Mantow, J aa 7m
Ittememting opinics tamd , at ti
Laectoe eee “ x
Clerk » cortifcate icteitied inf prioting? fer)
Order allowing certierari Ree See 7“ - , | *
“ 1
{fols.a & 1]
IN UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, SOUTHERN
DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
W. A. Mansuace & Co., Ixc., Libellant-Appellant,
against
Steamship ‘‘Presipenr Anrnur,’’ Her Engines, Boilers,
ete, Claimant-Appellee
STATEMENT
1925.
May 11, Libel filed. S.S.‘* President Arthur’ arrested.
June 13. Answer filed,
1a26.
May 6. Order entered substituting Lampke & Stein for
Krieger, Stutsky, Rush & Friedman as proctors
for claimant.
Sept. 14. Amended answer filed.
127.
June 3. Trial before Thacher, JJ,
Sept, 13. Opinion rendered directing dismissal of libel.
et, 10, Final decree entered dismissing libel.
Nov. 14. Notice of Appeal, Assigument of Errors and Bond
filexd,
{fol 2] Ix Usiven States Disrmaer Cour?
Line.
To the Honorable the Judges of the District Court of the
United States for the Southern District of New York:
The libel of W. A, Marshall & Co., Inc., against the Steam.
ship ‘* President Arthur,’ her engines, boilers, ete. in a
cause of contract, civil and maritime, alleges upon infor.
mation and behef and respectfully shows to this Honorable
Court as follows:
First, At all times hereinafter mentioned libellant was
and still is a corporation organized and existing under and
] caine ee]
~ie
2
by virtue of the laws of the State of New York, having an
offee and place of business at 17 Battery Place, in the
Borough of Manhattan, City, County and State of New
York, and engaged in the business of supplying coal,
Second. The Steamship ‘President Arthur’’ is now
within this district and within the jurisdiction of this Hon
orable Court.
Third. During the month of March, 1925, at the port of
New York, libelant, upon the request! of the owner of the
Steamship ‘President Arthur,’ or a person authorized by
the owner thereof, furnished to and for the use of said
steainship about 4,150 tons of bunker coal at an agreed
price of $21,173.16, which price was the reasonable market
price for said coal. The said coal was necessary to enable
the steamship to perform her intended voyage.
Fourth. The owner of the steamship ‘President Arthar’’
paid to Lbellant the sam of $11,700.54 on secount of the pur
| fol. 3} chase of saul coal, bout has failed to pear the balance
thereof, and by reason of the premises there is now due and
owing to the libelant from the sand Steamship *' President
Arther’’ the sum of Sa G2. me part of which has been
paid, although the same has been duly demanded, and the
libelant has a lien therefor under and by virtue of the Act
of Congress known as the Merchant Marine Act, approved
June 5, 1920, and also under and by virtue of the General
Maritime Law.
Fifth. All and singular the premises are true and within
the admeralty and maritume jurisdiction of the United
States and of thie Honorable Court
Wherefore libelant prays that process in dae form of
law may is#eue against seid Stoeamelup ‘President Arthur,’
her engones, beslers, tackle, apparel and furniture, and that
all persons having or claiming to have any interest therein
may be cited to appear and answer all and singular the
matters aforesaid, and that this court will be pleased to
award to the libelant ite damages aforesaid with interest
and costs, amd that the said Steamehip ‘' President Arthur,”
her engines, boilers, tackle, apparel and furnitare may be
condemned and sald to pay the same, and that Lbelant may
3
have such other and further relief in the premises as it
may be entitled to receive. 9
George W. Hinckley, Proctor for Libelant. Office
and Post Office address: B-10 Produce Exchange
Building, New York City,
[fol.4) Duly sworn to by Wilbur A. Marshall. Juvat
omitted im pronting.
[fol. 5] Ix Unirep Stares Disrnicr Cours
AMENDED ANSWEK
To the Honorable the Judges of the United States District
Court for the Southera District of New York:
The answer of American Palestine Line, Inc., the claim.
ant of the Steamship ‘*President Arthur,’* to the libel and
complaint of W. A. Marshall & Co. Ine., in an alleged cause
of contract, civil and maritime, respectfully shows;
First. Admits the allegations in Paragraph First and
Second of the libel,
Second. On information and belief admits that in and
during the menth of Mareh, 1925, the libellant furnished to
and for the use of the Steamship President Arthur,”’
bunker coal, which coal was necessary to enable the Steam.
slup to perform her intended voyage, but except as thus
admitted, denies each and every allegation in paragraph
marked 'S"' in said Libel contained.
Thard. On information aud belief admits that the claim
aut paid to Libeliant the sum of $11,714.54, but except as
thus admitted, denies the balance of the allegations in said
paragraph contaiped and expressly alleges that the entire
purchase price of the said coal was paid to the libellant by
claimant by the delivery to it of two trade acceptances en-
dorsed by third parties required by the contract to be given
as complete payment for the said coal and upon the de
livery of said trade acceptances all claims of plaintiff were
paid and extinguished and any maritime lien had or
claimed to be had by plaintifY wax thereupon extinguished
and terminated,
- ———— eres st i
a,
Fourth. Admits the jurisdiction of the United States and
of this Honorable Court, but denies the remaining allega-
(fol. 6] tions in paragraph of the libel numbered Fifth.
Fifth. Further answering and by way of set-off, the
claimant alleges, on information and belief, that heretofore
en or about the Isth day of February, 1925, and the 4th day
of Marvh, 1925, the libellant and claimant entered into two
separate agreements in writing for the purchase by claim
ant of approximately 4,225 gross tons of bituminous coal
to be used as bunker fuel for the Steamship ** President
Arthur.’* And it was further, as a part of said written
contracts, expressly warranted by libellant that said coal
should be approximately Gi. Bethel eoal and [0° Meleroft
coal, and further expressly warranted in writing as follows:
Bethel
** Bethel is Miller Vein coal having the usual character
istics of this seam in the South Fork and Sealp Level dis.
tricts, which it adjoins.
The seam is absolutely clean, being free from anY sigh
of slate or bone partings. Bethel is deep mined, contains
no stained or erop coal and is excellent in appearance. It
is soft by nature and does not run lumpy.
The coal analyzes as shipped approximately 165% Vola
tile, 76.25% fixed carbon, G75°% Ash, DAS" Sulphur,
14,650 BTUs and 2250" Fusing Tomperatare of Ash.
Bethel is regarded as a fancy grade of smokeless steam
coal because of its low volatile ard ash content and high
heating Value. It is an extremely het coal and is unexcelled
as a steam producer It makes little or so smoke and
{fol. 7] comes within all smoke ordinance requirements,’
Meleroft
‘Producing Miller vein coal of anusual quality, clean
noes and uniformity. The seam being clean, carrying no
parting of slate or bone, assures aniform quality at all
times,
The coal analyzes as ahippel, approwimately 25.00) of
volatile, 80% ash, 175° Salphur, 14.000 BT. U.'* and
240" Fusing Temperature of Ash.
5
The Volatile matter at 25.00% makes a quick, hot fire
enabling a plant to meet sudden loads and hold the steam
under excessive conditions, Yet the volatile is not suf
ciently high to cause consumption to be high or cause com-
plaint from smoke, It is unsurpassed for bunker fuel.
The sulphur being free from iron, this coal can be forced
under any condition without causing clinker trouble.
In over a year not one report of clinker has been re.
ceived; on the contrary the comment has been frequently
made on its freedom from clinker. This experience is from
over 109,000 tons handled in the past twelve months.’
Sixth. Upon information and belief that the coal! actually
furnished **President Arthur’’ did not analyze as afore.
said, but on the contrary showed a much hicher percentage
of volatile, a much lower percentage of fixed carbon and a
much higher percentage of ash and «vl
much lower number of Britixh Thermal | nits, which ren
dered said coal different from the coal Warranted, and re
quired a much la ‘yer consumption of tons af conl per day,
{fol. 8] making it necessary for the claimant to purchase
additional coal, all to its damage in the sum of Ty n thou.
sand ($1000.00) Dollars, and claimant asks that this sum
be offset against any sum which may be found to be due
libellant.
phur, and a very
Seventh. Further auswering. claimant states on infer
ination and belief that heretofore end on or about the ISth
dav of June, 1025, the Uhellant had in its POSSOCSSION 4 cer-
fain trade acceptance provided in said contract to he de
livered to it in payment for the balance of sand coal and in
the same amount as that mentioned in the libel and for
Which amount libellant secks recovery, Said trade accept
ance bea tage endorsed as provided for in suid eontract by
J. W. Gottlieb, Jacob Wacht and Jacob S. Strahl, the said
libellant then and there elected te treat the said trade ac
ceplance as payment of the sums due it for said coal and en
that day, commenced an action to recover thereon in the
Supreme Court, New York County, against the said J. W,
Gottheb, Jacob Wacht and Jacob S Strahl, which action is
still pending and undetermined, and claimant alleges that
any maritime len Which the libeliant had or could have had
was extinguished or suspended during the pendency of said
action,
All and singular the premises are true.
Wherefore respondent prays that the libel may be dis
missed with costs and for such other and further rehef as
may be just,
Lampke & Stein, Proctors for Respondent. Office
and Post Office address: No. 20 Broadway, Bor
ough of Manhattan, City of New York,
i fol. | Duly sworn to by Joseph A. Gurrin, Jurat omet
ted sm promtong.
(Nere.-The amended answer as filed pursuant to stipu
lation was not verified.)
[fol 1} Is Userep Srates Disruter Count
{ Tithe omitted]
Before Hon. Thos. D. Thacher, District Joige
Case
3, 127
New York, Jane
Arrtakancths oF Cot Neer
lieorge Ww. Hinckley, for Libellant;
Chauneory b. Treadwell, for Rew proride nf
The claims of the bbel and answer are stated
(* W. Sasronn, being duly sworn and examined as a wit
ness for the libellant, testifies
Direct examination by Mr. Hinckley:
Q. In the month of February, 1925, by whom were you
employ el?
A. W. A. Marshall & Company.
Y In what capacity?
iT
7
A. As tide water sales manager,
Q. And in connection with your employment did you
negotiate any contracts of sale between W. A. Marshall &
Company and the American-Palestine Line as owner of the
{fol. 11) steamer ** President Arthur’?
A. I did.
Q. I hand you this contract and ask you if this was one
of the contracts that you negotiated?
A. It was, ves,
Q. You saw this contract signed by the Treasurer of the
Anwrican-Palestine Line?
A. Yes.
It is offered in evidence and marked Libellant’s Exbibit
1 of this date.
Q. I want to eall your attention to one paragraph in this
contract. ** The coal is not to be dumped from the railroad
cars inte barges until the seller receives written notice from
the buyer either that it waives its right to analyze the coal,
or has analyzed it and found it satisfactory and directs its
dumping.’ That provision was arranged between vou and
pursuant to authority was this letter sent to you by the
American Palestine Line (showing witness paper)?
A. Yes, it was.
The letter is offered jin evidences, dated Feb. 19, 1925, to
Marshall, and marked Libellant 's Exhibit 2 of this date.
Y Subsequently to this contract of February 18, Libel
lant’s Exhibit 1, was a further contract negotiated be-
tween You and the American Palestine Line?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. TP hand you a paper and ask you if that is that con-
tract?
A. Yes, sir.
It is offered in evidence and marked Libellant's Exhibit
Sof this date, letter dated March 4, 1925, to the American-
Palestine Line.
{fol 12] Q. And at the time that contract Was signed was
that letter signed by Epstein as General Manager of the
American Palestine Line delivered to yout
A. Yer, sir.
se nae ae a
The letter last referred to, dated March 4, 1925, to Mar-
shall, is offered in evidence and marked Libellant’s Exhibit
4 of this date.
Q. Pursuant to those contracts did W. A. Marshall &
Company actually deliver the coal to the steamship ** Presi-
dent Arthur’’?
A. They did.
@. | hand you herewith certificate of weight and origin
of coal, and ask if the coal as outlined in that certificate of
weight and origin was actually delivered to the ‘* President
Arthur’'?
A. It was.
YY. What was that weight!
A. 4,151 tons and 12 ewt.
Y. And these are the bills of lading of those barges?
A. Yes.
The railroad receipts are offered in evidence and marked
Libellant's Mxhibit 5 of this date.
The bills of lading of the barges are offered in evidetce
ated marked Libellant’s Exhibit 6 of this date.
Y Do you know when the last of the coal was delivered
tlongside the ** President Arthur,’’ within a day or sof
A. About March 6th.
Q. And what year was that?
A. ‘That was 15,
Mr. Hinckley: Mr. Treadwell, will you concede that the
origin of the coal is as stated in these railroad certificates?
{fel 1S) Mr. Treadwell: | won't make any specific con-
cession because | don’t know.
A stipulation is read inte the record as follows;
Claimant consents that the railroad bills of lading and
the certifieates showing daily shipments of coal in question
may be received in evidence as prima facie proof of the
statements in the billa of lading.
Q. | hand you herewith some papers that purport to be
the daily repert of daily «hipments from the Maple Ridge
Coal Company and ask if they show shipments of coal de-
livered to the ** President Arthur’?
A. They do,
SE ER PY SEER Oe ——
,
Q. Are the cars that are checked in lead pencil by num-
ber the cars on which that coal camet
A. Yes.
Q. And is the number 3 as designated on those slips
Bethel coal?
A. Yes.
The slips are offered in evidence and marked Libellant’s
Exhibit 7 of this date.
Q. T hand you certificate from Meleroft Coal certifying
coal by ear numbers, and ask you if those numbers are the
numbers of the cars that were dumped into the lighters
alongside of the ** President Arthur.’
A. They are.
The certificates are offered in evidence and marked Libel-
lant’s Exhibit 8 of this date.
Q. Mr. Sanford, when you first entered negotiations for
the sale of this coal to the American Palestine Line, what
was said about the time the coal should be paid fort
[fol. 14] AL As T recollect it they wanted to pay for this
coal in thirty days, and—no, our terms were thirty days,
and they wanted a longer period; naturally IT had to put
that up te our Credit Department, and by their wanting a
longer period than thirty days they looked further into
their financial standing and came to the conclusion that
they didn't like the account and w anted to get trade accept-
unees in order to get the money at any time that they
Wanted in fact to discount that paper. When that ques.
lion came up We wanted additional security, as we weren't
satisfied with the eredit of the American-Palestine Line,
Q. The purpose in getting these trade acceptances Was,
was if not, so that Marshall & Company by the use of
these trade aceoptances could obtain the benefit. of the
financing prior to the deferred time of payment arranged
in the contract?
{ Wijeeted to,
Objection sustained.
Q. Did you or did you not know that where bunker coal
is supplied fo a ship on the order of the owner that the
REIL TA ONE ET, ARISE RE PTA: RFS AOE SPR , So a
10
supplier has a lien against the ship for the value of such
coal?
Objected to.
Objection sustained.
Exception.
After argument, the court says be will take the testimony
but will disregard it.
Q. 1 will repeat the question: Were you or were you not
of the opinion that you had a maritime hen for the supply
ing of coal ordered bs the owner for the bunkers of a
vessel?
A. Yes.
{fol. 15] Q. Is it or is it mot a usual custom in the coal
business, where time of geass taetal imoche ferred, for the seller
to draw upon the buyer and for the buyer to accept the
draft and return it to the seller at some deferred time?
Objected to.
Objection sustained,
Except ion.
y Is it or is it not the castom in the coal trade when
supplying bunkers for steamers amd there is to be a de
ferred date of payment, for the seller to receive a draft
which it in turn discounts at the bank pror to the date of
payment?
Ob jeeted to,
Objection sustainesd.
Baception,
Q. Was the requirement made by W. A. Marshall &
Company that this draft should be endorsed by the parties
named in the contract for the purpose of making the draft
more negotiable at the bank?
Same obye ction.
The (Court - 1 will assume it was so and let if stand
A. It was.
(). Was anything ever said during the time of the ne
gotiations for this contract, of at the signing, as to the
—
11
abandonment of any lien or claim that Marshall & Company
might have against a ship for supply of bunkers?
A. No.
{fol. 16] Cross-examined by Mr. Treadwell:
(). You wrote this letter, which ] produce, on the paper
of your attorney Mr. Hinckley, February 16, 1925, did you
not, Mr. Sanford?
A. Yes, | wrote that letter.
It is offered in evidence.
Marked Claimant's Exhibit A of this date.
Q. In that letter you said that the drafts must be en-
dorsed by responsible persons acceptable to you, did you
not!
A. Yes, sir.
() Who were those persons?
A. A party by the name of Wacht, one by the name of
Giottheb, and Jacob S. Strahl.
Q. And they were aceeptable to yout?
A. They were acceptable to me,
. You had them investigated?
A. As far as I know we did; that comes under our Credit
Department; that | know, they were acceptable anyway.
Q. I show you a draft produced by your proctor, dated
March 6, 1925; is that the draft for the amount of which
you are bringing suit here?
(jected to: the papers speak for themselves,
The Court: He may identify it with the transaction.
A. Yes, that is it.
Q. That is the second draft mentioned in these contracts?
A. Yes, sir
Q. And the first draft was paid?
A. Yes, sir,
W. And the second draft Was given———
A. It was a trade acceptance,
[fol 17] The paper referred to is offered in evidence and
marked Cinimant’s Exhibit B oof this date,
———
—,
12
Q. You also made an affidavit!
A. Our attorney, Mr. Hinckley, just mentioned that a
moment ago, didn't he?
Y. Do you remember making an affidavit?
A. No, [ don't remember it.
(. I will show it to you. It is on the office paper of your
proctor here (showing Witness paper).
A. Yes,
Q. You remember it now?
A. Yes.
Y. And when you swore to it you believed it to be true?
A. Yes.
The affidavit referred to is offered in evidence and
marked Claumant’s Exhibit C of this date.
. You said in that affidavit--I quote here the following
sentence from that letter-that is the letter I showed vou
before that the court may observe one of the essential
terms in the offer—and then you quote the part of the letter
about the trade acceptances, and then you say ‘these trade
acceptances to be endorsed by responsible persons accept
able to us.”’ Now, you did believe that was an essential
term of the contract, that the trade acceptances should be
emlorsed by responsible persons!
A. We did that for an additiona! protection; we didn't
beheve that the American-Palestine Line was financially re
sponsible, and we insisted upon these endorsements on
there so that we could discount that paper in case we nooded
te at any time.
{fol 18} Q. Well, you did discount it, didn't vou!
A. I don't think so.
Y You don't?
A. No.
(. And you brought a suit against these endorsers!
A. Yo, air
(). And you made this affidavit in that suit?
A. I don’t know just when that affidavit was made: Mr
Hinckley can tell you that.
Mr. Hinckley: The fact is coneeded and it is also con
coded that the action is pending and undetermined
13
Mr. Treadwell: Yes. 1 offer in evidence affidavit of
George W. Hinckley, proctor for the libellant, in the same
set of papers, It is expressly stated in the affidavit that
payment was to be made by these endorsers, that they
would never have made the contract if the endorsements
had not been there, and that they were not accommodation
endorsers as claimed by the defendant in that aetion. bat
that the endorsements were accepted as payment of the
obligation. It is stated in so many words.
Mr. Hinckley: Objected to; not that I deny that I made
the affidavit, but admissions that ] might make as attorney
in another action T don’t think can be binding as an ad-
mission of the plaintiff as to what he did in this action,
The Court: I will receive it—it is taken subject to the
objection,
The affidavit referred to is offered in evidence and
marked Claimant's Exhibit D of this date.
[fol 19} By Mr. Hinckley:
Q. The purpose in securing these endorsers to these
drafts was in order that you might negotiate it through a
hank more readily than if you did not have it!
A. Yes, we couldn't negotiate the American-Palestine
Line's notes.
Q. So that if necessary you might be in funds prior to
the day ultimately stated for payment?
A. Yes.
Q. And that was the sole purpose of having this draft
endorsed, was it not?
Objected to.
Objection overruled.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was the value of coal as delivered under the
contract?
A. In dollars?
Q. Yes—-how many tons and the rate and the amount?
A, 4151 tons and 12 ewt.; the price was $5.10 alongside
their vessels; the amount was $21,736.16.
Q. And how much of that has been paid?
a AAR SIONS RRR ee ARR RS Aart aroma ENTS tie
ae
14
A. There has $21,173.16 been paid—leaving a balance of
$9,582.62.
Q. Do you wish to correct the amount that has been
paid? I think you stated it as the total amount of the bill;
do you wish to correct itf
A. 1 wish to correct it.
Q. What was the amount paid!
A. The amount actually paid was $11,700.50; the full
amount of the bill was $21,173.16; the balance due is
$9,382.62.
(). Interest would be from what date; what was the time
of the last delivery?
A. The time of the last delivery was March 6, 1925,
Both sides rest.
{fot 0} Livetaanxt’s Fxererr 1
Contract of February 18, 1025
Agreement made at The City of New York, in the State
of New York, this eighteenth dav of Pebroary, 1025,
whereby W. A. Marshall & Company, a New York Corpora
toon, with its principal place of business in The City of
New York, hereinafter called the Seller, agrees ta sell,
avd American Palestine Line, Inc. a corporation organized
under the laws of the State of New York, with its. prim
erpal place of business in the Borough of Manhattan. in
The City of New York, State of New York, ae owner of
the S°S President Arthur, hereinafter called the Buver,
agrees to buy approximately thirty «ix hundred and fifty
(76.50) gross tons of hituminons coal to be used as bunker
fuel for the said SS President Arthur
OK. The coal to be from the Meleoroft and Bethel
ws Mines loon tod at Melerof?, I's . and Halsopple,
OK. Pa, respectively, approximately fifty per cent,
JWG. (50%) of each grade of coal, as per attached
erenlare.
The Baver shall have the right. sf it sa seelewts, to take
samples of the onal while on the raclroad care at Pier Fight
oon, Jersey City, N. 4. The ewal is not to he damped from
the railroad cars into barges until the Seller receives writ
ten notice from the Bayer either that it waives its right to
15
analyze the coal, or has analyzed it and found it satisfac-
tory and directs its dumping.
It is understood that no question as to quality can be
raised by the Buyer after the coal has been dumped into
barges.
O.K. The price of the coal is $5.10 a gross ton
(.W.S. alongside the said S'S President Arthur,
OK. either at Morse’s Drydock, Brooklyn, or Pier
J.W.G. No. 39 North River, New York City at the op-
tion of the Buyer. Deli, ery [to commence |*
{fol. 21} Feby, 2025 or Feby, 23/25 [and to he com-
pleted within }* at option of buyer,
The Buyer will pay for the said coal as follows:
(1) By delivering to the Seller a trade acceptance drawn
by it in favor of the Seller, dated the date of the delivery
of the coal, due March 10, 15, covering railroad freight
of $2.79 a gross ton, which acceptance is to be endorsed by
Jacob Wacht, Jacob 8. Strahl and Joseph W. Gottlieb.
(2) A trade acceptance drawn by the Buyer in favor
of the Seller, dated on the same day, due May
OK. 8, 1925, covering the balance of the purchase
JLW.G. price, to wit: $2.31 a gross ton, representing
the coal, harbor barge freight and insurance
on coal while in barges, which acceplance is also to be en.
dorsed by the said Jacob Wacht, Jacob S. Strahl and Jo-
sepli W. Gottlieb,
OK. The entire contract between the parties is
C.W.S. stated above and there ix no outside condition,
OK. warranty, agreement or understanding, Cer
JIW.G. tifleate of weights according to R. BR. bill of
lading.
Witness the signatures of the respective parties hereto,
W. A. Marshall & Company, by W. Al Marshall,
President. American Dalestine Line, Ine, by J.
W. Gottheh, Secy,
{fol, 22 In consideration of the execution of the fore.
going contract, and of the delivery of suid coal by the
[* Words amt figures encioned in brackets erased in copy |
16
Seller to the Buyer, and in consideration of One Dollar
($1.00) paid to each of the undersigned, the receipt of
Which is hereby acknowledged, we jointly and severally
agree to endorse the said trade acceptances deseribed in the
foregoing contract between the Seller and the Buyer.
Dated, February 18, 1925.
Jacob S. Strahl, J. W. Gottlieb, Jacob Wacht.
Lintiaanr’s Exnisir 2
Letter Head of American Palestine Line, Ine.
New York, N. Y., February 19, 1925.
W. A. Marshall & Company, 25 Beaver Street, New York
City,
Gentiemen: We refer to our Contract dated February
18, 1925, for the supply of coal aboard the 8. S, President
Arthur.
This coal is to be delis erel alongeide the S.S, President
Arthar, at Moree Dry Dock & Repair Co. Foot of 0th
Street, Brooklyn, N. Y., beginning in the morning, Febru
ary 20th, 1925, and is to be continually delivered as speed
ily an renee bile eo as not to hold up the ates «mshoring thereof,
[fol 23] We waive our right to analyze the coal.
Very truly yours, American Palestine Line, Inc. H.
Epstein, General Manager
he-fa.
wmnameeienn mega oO
Linstaant'’s Eaxvintr 3
Contract of March 4, 1925
Agreement made at the City of New York, in the State
of New York thie fourth day of March, 1925, whereby W
A, Marshal! & Campany, m New York Corporation, with
its principal place of business in the City of New York,
hereinafter called the Seller, agrees to eell, and American
Palestine Line, Ine. a corporation organized under the
laws of the State of New York, with it« principal place of
—
17
business in the Borough of Manhattan, in the City of New
York, State of New York, as Owner of the S. 8. President
Arthur, hereinafter called the Buyer, agrees to buy ap-
proximately five hundred and seventy five (575) gross tons
of Bituminous Coal to be used as bunker fuel for the said
S. S. President Arthur.
The coal is to be from the Melcroft Mine, located at Mel-
eroft, Pa.
The Buyer shall have the right, if it so elects, to take
samples of the coal while in the railroad cars at Pier KMight-
cen, Jerse, City, N. J. The coal is net to he dumped from
the railroad cars into the barges until the Seller receives
written notice from the Buyer either that it waives its
right to analyze the coal, or has aualyzed it and found it
satisfactory and directs its dumping.
(fol. 24) It is understood that no question as to quality
can be raised by the Buyer after the coal has been dumped
into barges,
The price of the coal is $5.10 a gross ton alongside the
said S.S. President Arthur at Pier No. 39, North River,
New York City, delivery beginning tomorrow, March dD,
1925,
The Buyer shall pay for the said coal as follows:
(1) By delivering to the Seller a trade acceptance drawn
by it in favor of the Seller, dated the date of the delivery
of the coal, due Mareh 10, 1925, covering railroad freight
of $2.79 a gross ton, which acceptance is to be endorsed by
Jacob Wacht, Jacob S. St rah! and Joseph Ww, Gottheh,
(2) A trade acceptance drawn by the tuver in favor of
the Seller, dated on the same day, due May 8, 1925, covering
the balance of the purchase price, to wit: $2.31 a gross ton,
representing the coal harbor barge freight and insurance
on coal while in barges, which aceeptance is also to be en-
dorsed by the said Jacob Wacht, Jacob S. Stahl and Joseph
W. Gottlieb.
The entire contract between the parties is stated above
and there is no outside condition, war ranty, agreoment or
understanding. Certifieate of weights according to rail
road bill of lading.
oOo
3~-272
—
ay
18
Witness the signatures of the respective parties hereto.
W. A. Marshall & Company, by W. A. Marshall,
President. American Palestine Line, Ine., by J.
W. Gottlieb.
[fol. 25] In consideration of the execution of the foregoing
contract, and of the delivery of said coal by the Seller to
the Buyer, and in consideration of One Dollar ($1.00) paid
te each of the undersigned, the receipt of which is hereby
acknowledged, we jointly and severally agree to endorse
the said trade acceptance described in the foregoing con-
tract between the Seller and the Buyer, dated March 4, 1925,
J. W. Gottheb, Jacob Wacht, Jacob S. Strabl.
Dated, March 4, 1925.
Lamtizant’s Exuimr 4,
Letterhead of W. A. Marshall & Company
March 4, 1925.
W. A. Marshall & Co, 17 Battery Place, New York City.
tienriemen: We refer to our contract dated March 4,
Ivo, for the supply of coal aboard the S. 8S. President
Arthar.
This coal is to be delivered alongside the S. S. President
Arthur at Pier 239, North River, New York City, on the
morning of March 5, 1925, as per conversation with our
Mr. Sabath, We waive our right to analyze the coal
Yours very traly, American Palestine Line, Inc, by
H. Epstein, General Manager.
{fol. 26) Ciaimast's Fanner A"
Letterhead of W. A. Marshall & Company
X.CWS. February 16, 1925.
American Palestine Line, Inc. 1499 Broadway, New York
City.
Attention of Mr. Epstein
Geetiewrs: We beg to cubmit a price of 85.10 per gross
ton on our Shallmar bunker coal for delivery alongside
19
the 8. 8. ** President Arthur,’’ Morse Dry Dock, Brooklyn,
N. Y., on approximately 3,650 gross tons.
Should we receive this order, we will use the combination
of coals that we are in the habit of using on all of our
steamship business, which would be approximately 50% of
Meleroft coal and about 50% of our Bethel coal. We en-
close a descriptive circular on cach of these coals. We have
had unusually good success with this combination of coals
and feel that you will receive equally good results by
their use.
Regarding terms of payment, we would require a trade
acceptance payable on March 10th for the freight and boat
freight which would amount to $3.04 per gross ton, and an
additional trade acceptance for the balance, amounting to
$2.06 per gross ton; these trade acceptances to be endorsed
by responsible persons acceptable to us. Should this be
acceptable to you, We would need prompt acceptance of this
[fol. 27] order, so that we can start the loading of these
boats. We have all of the coal standing at present. The
second trade acceptance will be payable May Sth,
Yours very truly, W. A. Marshall & Company,
Charles W. Sandford, Manager Tidewater Dept.
CWS/AW.
c. ¢. to Mr. J.C. Meyerhoff, 1 Broadway, New York City.
Craimant’s Exninit *B"
$9, 382.62, New York, March 6th, 1925.
May 8th, 1925, Pay to the order of W. A. Marshall & Com.
pany Nine thousand three hundred and eighty two and
62/100 dollars. Value received and charge the same to ac-
count of
W. A. Marshall & Company. David L. Morrison,
Treas.
To American Palestine Line, Inc. No. 149% Broadway,
New York City, N.Y.
On the face of the trade acceptance appears the follow.
ing:
—— SAORI ONO RA
20
(fol. 28] Accepted—March 6, 1925. Payable at National
City Bank, 57th St. office. American Palestine Line, Ine.,
by James Wacht, Treasurer.
On the reverse side of the trade acceptance appear the
following names in the order given:
Jacob Wacht, Jos. W. Gottlieb, Jacob 8. Strahl, W. A.
Marshall & Co., by David L. Morrison, Treasurer.
Cuamanr’s Exausrr C—Avrimavit or Crances W. Saxprorp
Sureeme Covrr, New Youn Counry
W. A. Manstace & Company, Plaintiff,
against
Josxru W. Gorriana, Jacon 8S. Srxam, and Jacon Wacwr,
Defendants
Affidavit on Motion for Summary Judgment
Srare or New Yorx,
County of New York, as:
Charles W. Sandford, being duly sworn, deposes and
savas:
(fol 29) First. | am Manager of the Tidewst-r Denart
ment of Wo A. Marshal! and Company, the plaintiff in the
abeve entitle! action 'n that capacity | negotiated th
eoutract for the sale of certain coal by plant to Amer
ean Palestine Line, Inc. out of which came the trade a
cetHates here sued wre I jure mally handled, and l am
Persenaily familiar with the matters set forth in this afi
davit, which is made in support of a motion for summary
judgment.
Second. (mn February 16, 1925, 1 wrote a letter to Amer;
can Palestine Line, Ine, offering, on behalf of Wo A. Mar
shall amd Company, to sell a stated quantity of specified
coal at a stated price. A copy of that letter is annexed to
thie affidavit as Exhibit ‘A’ and made a part hereof, Fur.
ther, I quote here the following sentence from that letter
——y
21
that the court may obs: rve one of the essential terms of
the offer:
**Regarding terms of payment, we would require a trade
acceptance payable on March 10th for the freight and boat
freight which would amount to $3.04 per gross ton, and an
additional trade acceptance for the halance, amounting to
$2.06 per gross ton; these trade aceeplances to be endorsed
by responsible persons acceptable to us.’
The Contracts
Third. Shortly after I had sent the letter marked Ex.
hibit **A,*’ American Palestine Line, Ine, accepted the
offer verbally and followed up that acceptance by executing
[fol. 30) a written contract dated February 18, 1925. A
copy of that contract is annexed hereto marked Exhibit
“Band made a part hereof. However, at this point, I
quote for the benefit of the court, four significant parts of
said contract:
(Here follows portions of contract relative to right to
analyze the coal and the terms of payment, Libellant’s Ex-
hibit No. 1 herein.)
Fourth Subsequently, on March 4th, American Pales-
tine Line, Inc, believing it would require more coal than
that eo lled fer in the contract of Febroary 18, 1925, made
a seoetd conract with W. A. Marshall and Company for an
vid tional supply of coal am unting to 575 tons. A copy
of osad contract is annexed hereto, marked Exhibit agi, > Si
ar. ‘ part hereof. This second contract was prac-
tealiy identieal with the first contract except as to dates
and the amount of coal to be delivered. Tt included like-
Wise the provisions quoted above.
(Here follow statements relative to deliveries, )
Trade Acceptances
Tenth. In accordance with the terms of the contracts |
presented to the American Palestine Line, Ine., on behalf
of W. A. Marshall and Co. two trade acceptances for the
balance due on the coal, which were accepted by American
”
a
Palestine Line, Ine, and ender->1 by Messrs. Gottlieh,
Strahl and Waecht, the three individual defendants named
in this action. A copy of the second trade aeceptance is
ifol. 31] bereto annexed, marked Exhibit sta Fa and made
a part hereof. The first trade acceptance was duly paid.
Eleventh, Subsequently, the trade acceptance was pre
sented through the Bank of America.
(Here follows statement that payment was refused and
the draft protested for non payment.)
From the foregoing recital of the facts and from the other
afidasits submitted upon this metion, f ts plain that the
defemdiants ha no defense to this action on the trade ac
ceptanes Phe fact- as established by affidavits and ey
hifats subumitted ar ns follows:
(a) Two contracts for th ie and deliverv by pln ntti?
fo American Palest fo | ,of a total of 4225 tons of
coal te come from Bethel and Meleroft mines,
(b) Spe fe pr sons on said eontracts that the trade
ROCEPT Alier= int ' fit fast } whorl? be endorsed bes
the officer art Vine ‘ Palestine | Bie’, Lei at" . Joseph
W. Gottlieb, Jace) S Strahl and Jacoh Wacht, the individ
nal defendant. in this action.
(fe) FEndorsement~ mad these individual defendants
hes part of the considers nof the sale of said coal ty plain
tiff to American Palewt ne Line, Tne
ffol, 32 The claim that the defendants were accommoda
tion endorsers for the henefit of Wo A. Marshall and Co, is
refuted by the terms of the offer and of the contracts and
by their own signatures upon the contracts, Instead of
heing accommodation endorsers for the henefit of WL A
Marshall and Co., they are in fact straight endorsers, so far
as W. A. Marshall and Co. is concerned, for without the
consideration of such endorsements, the plaintiff wonld
never have sold the coal to American Palestine Line, Ine.
Fourteenth. | am advised be the attorney for W. A. Mar
«hall and Co. that the «oealled defenses in law contained
23
in the amended answer are without any validity. These
defenses are to the effect that there is another action pend-
ing in Admiralty in the United States Distriet Court for
the Southern District of New York against the S.S. Presi-
dent Arthur on the contracts themselves: and that the com.
plaint is defective in failing to make the American Palestine
Line, Ine., a party defendant. 1 am likewise ad\ ised by said
Attorney that an action against the S.S. President Arthur
in the United States Admiralty Court on the maritime con
tracts does net prevent an action in the State Court against
the endorsers on the trade acceptance, and that in an auction
against endorsers it is not necessary to join the principal
obligor.
On the evidence presented in the affidavits submitted in
this motion, it is obvious that there is no real issue of fact
to be tried and that there is no possible defense of which the
defendants could avail themselves upon such a trial. 1,
[fol. 33] therefore, ask that an order be entered by this
court striking ont the amended answer of the defendants
asa sham and a frand and directing the entry of summary
judgment on behalf of W. A. Marshall and Co, for the full
amount demanded.
Charles W. Sanford.
Verified October 2nd, 1925,
Cusimant’s Exnrar D- Arvipaver or Groncr W. HiscKkrry
Sturmer Cover, New Yous Country
WA. Mansnaue & Compan:
against
Josern W. Gorriten, Jacon S. Sriaus, and Jacon Wacur,
Defendants
Stare or New York,
County of New York, as:
George W. Hinckley, heing duly sworn, deposes and SAVS:
First. Tam the attorney for the plaintiff in the above en-
titled action and am making this affidavit in support of the
aT
M
{fol. 34] plaintiff's motion for an order striking out the
amended answer herein and granting summary judgment
to the plaintiff.
B. As to the Charge that the Defendants were Accommoda.
tion Endorsers for the Benefit of W. A. Marshall and Co*,
Plaintiff Herein.
Eleventh. Were the defendants accommodation endorsers
for W. A. Marshall and Co.!) This question of fact is con-
clusively answered by the aflidavit of Mr. Sandford and the
annexed exhibits consisting of the offer to sell the coal and
the two contracts therefor actually signed, These documents
show that W. A. Marshall and Co. offered to sell the coal to
the American-Palestine Line, ine, only on condition that
the trade acceptances to be given in payment would be
signed by three endorsers acceptable to the plaintiff, The
contracts themselves similar in form and for quantities of
coal making up the aggregate, show exactly the lasis upon
which the defendants signed the trade acceptance bere sued
on. They were straight endorsers so far as W. A. Marshall
and ('o. ix concerned. They yuve their endorsements as
part of the consideration moving from American Palestine
Line, Ine, to W. A. Marshall and Co. for the purchase of the
coal in question. The plaintiff's offer shows that the plain
tiff did not rely solely on the credit of the American Pales
tine Line, Inec., and that the endorsement of these individual
defendants was an essential prerequisite for the purchase
of this coal by their corporation. The contract itself demon
strates that these individual defendants understood com
{fol. 5} pletely the signifeance of their endorsements.
(The language of the contract as to terms of payment is
here quoted.)
o . * . a . +
It follows that the allegation of the defendants that they
were accommedation endorsers for the benefit of W. A.
Marshal! amd t‘o, ie faleo smd known to them to dae false.
25
Under such conditions, I submit that the interests of jus-
tice and the dignity of this court require the granting of the
relief here sought.
George W. Hinckley.
Verified October 15th, 1925,
Ix Ustrep Sraves District Court
[ Title omitted]
In Admiralty
Optxion-—SNept. 13, 1928
Libel in rem to recover agreed price of bunker coal fur.
[ fol. $6] nished to the Steamship ** President Arthur.’’
In March, 1925, the American-Palestine Line, as owner
of the S'S “President Arthur,”’ entered into two written
agreements with the libellant for the sale of approximately
3,225 gross tons of coal, as each agreement recites *‘to be
used as bunker fuel for the said S/S ‘President Arthur,’ ”’
Each agreement contains the following provisions with ref-
erence to the payment of the purchase price:
“The Buyer shall pay for the said coal as follows;
(1) By delivering to the Seller a trade acceptance drawn
by it in favor of the Seller, dated the date of the delivery
of the coal, due Mareh 19, 1925, covering railroad freight at
279 a gross ton, which aceeplance is to be endorsed by
Jacob Wachit, Jacob S. Strahl and Joseph W. Gottlieb.
(2) A trade acceptance drawn by the Buyer in favor of
the Seller, dated on the same day, due May &, 1925, covering
the balance of the purchase price, to wit: $2.31 a gross ton,
representing the coal, harbor barge freight and insurance
on coal while in barges, which acceptance is also to be en-
dorsed by the said Jacob Wacht, Jacob S. Strahl and Joseph
W. Gottlieb."
The entire contract between the partion is stated above
and there is te outside condition, warranty, agreement,
_
26
or understanding. Certifieate of weights according to rail
road bill of lading.
Witness the signatures of the respective parties hereto.”’
{fol 37] On each of the said agreements, below the signa
tures of the parties and above the signatures of the persotis
named as endorsers of the acceptances to be given by the
Purchaser, there appears the following:
‘*In consideration of the execution of the foregoing con.
tract, and the delivery of said coal by the Seller to the
Buyer, and in consideration of One Dollar ($1.00) paid to
each of the undersigned, the reeeipt of which is hereby ac
knowledged, we jointly and severally agree to endorse the
said trade acceptance described in the foregoing contract
between the Seller and the Buyer.”
The libellant delivered 4,151 tons and 12 ewt. to the ves
sel. The purchase price, at $5.10 per ton, nimounted to
$21,726.16. Trade acceptances in this amount were given
and received under the agreements, These have not been
paid exept to the extent of 811,700.50. For the halance of
SO 8 82, with interest from March 6, 1025, the lhellant
claims a maritime lien against the vessel,
George Wright Hinkley, Proctor for Libellant (J) Mark
ham Marshall and George Wright Hinkley of Counsel);
Lampke & Stein, Proctors for Claimant American Pal
estine Line, Inc. (Chauncey Eo Treadwell of Counsel)
Traces, D. J. (after stating the facts as above}:
The rule is settled that when a note of a third party os
taken at the time of the creation of a debt, as upon a sale
(fol. 38] of goods, the presumption ix that it was taken
in payment
Atlas S. S. Ca. v. Columbian Land Co, 1 Fed, 358 (€,
CA. 2od);
N.Y. @€ Cuba S. S. Co, v. Texas Co. 282 Fed, 221.¢¢
C, A., 2nd);
Hall v. Stevens, IGN. YH
There is no need for such presumption in this ease be-
cause the agreement expressly required payment coinci-
dentally with the delivery of the coal by delivery of trade
acceptances bearing three endorsements. The agreement
which the parties made is conclusive, and if there were evi-
dence of intention contrary to its terms this could not be
considered. But there was no such evidence. In the face
of the agreements no maritime lien could arise, because the
coal was to be paid for on delivery. Even if a lien had
arisen it certainly could not survive payment in the form
the parties expressly contracted for, namely, the delivery
of the acceptance. It is entirely clear, I think, that the
libellant did net reiv on the credit of the ship.
The libellant having no lien, its suit fails and the com.
plaint will he dismissed with costs,
(Sed.) Phomas D. Thacher, U.S. D. J.
September 13th, 1927.
(fol. 38a} so Is Unsirep Srares District Court
{ Title omitted ]
Finat Droner—-Oct. 10, 1927
This cause having duly come on to be heard in its reg-
ular order on June 3, 1927, upon the pleadings and proofs
and having been argued and submitted by the advocates
for the respective parties and the court, after due delibera.-
tion, having rendered ite decision dismissing the libel
herein, with costs, and claimant's costs having been duly
taxed in the sum of $37.90,
Now, on motion of Lampke & Stein, proctors for the
claimant, it is
Ordered, adjudged and decreed that the libel herein he
and the same hereby is dismissed with costs and that the
[fol 38h) claimant Lawrence S. Greenbaum, Reeeiver-in
Kquity of the American Palestine Line, Inc., recover of
the libelant W. A. Marshall & Co. Ine., and its stipulators
for casts, the sum of S37.), costs as taxed, which sum shall
hear interest until paid and that the claimant have judg.
ment against the said libelant therefor and it is further
—
28
Ordered, adjudged, and decreed that unless an appeal be
taken from this decree within the time limited by the rules
and practice of this court, that the stipulators for costs on
the part of said libelant cause the engagement of their stip-
ulations to be performed within ten days or to show cause
within four days thereafter why execution should not issue
against them to enforce satisfaction of this decree.
T. D. Thacher, U.S. D. J.
Get ree eee oe
{fol 39) Is Usrrep Strares Disruucr Count
{Tithe omitted!
Norice or Arrra..
Sims: Please take notice that W. A. Marshall & Co. Inc,
the libellant herein, hereby appeals to the Circuit Court of
Appeals for the Second Circuit, from the Decree of the
District Court in this cause, entered the ith day of Oc
tober, 1927, and from each and every part thereof,
Dated November 11, 1927.
Yours, ete. George Wright Hinckley, Proctor for
Libellant, 50 Broadway, Manhattan, New York
City.
To Alexander Gilchrist, Fag, Clerk of United States Dis
trict Court, Southern District of New York; Lamphke &
Stein, Reqs, Proctors for Claimant, 29 Broadway, Manhat
tan, New York City.
{fol. 40} Is Usrren Straten Deermecr Court
{Tithe omitted]
Asstaxwesxt or Beacon
W. A. Marshall & Co, Inc, the bbellant-appellant,
aAseignhes ae erfrere in the District Court
1. The finding and decision that libellant had taken the
note of a third party.
pak Ok . Soe
29
2. The finding and decision that the provision of the
contracts requiring delivery by buyer of its trade accept-
ances bearing three indorsements, was conclusive proof of
intention that such acceptances were taken in absolute pay-
ment.
3. The finding and decision that there was no evidence
that buyer's trade acceptances bearing three indorsements
were not taken in absolute payment.
4. The decision that evidence was not admissible that
buyer's acceptances bearing three indorsements were not
taken in absolute payment.
5. The finding and decision that no maritime lien could
arise in the face of the agreements of the parties,
[fol.41] 6. The finding and decision that even if a mari-
time hen had arisen it could not have survived the taking
by the seller of buyer's acceptances bearing three indorse-
ments,
7. The finding and decision that it was « niirely clear that
libelant did not rely on the credit of the ship.
8. The decision that claimant was entitled to a decree dis
missing the libel.
%. The failure of the District Court to find and decide
that libellant was entitled to a decree for the full amount
claimed with interest and costs.
George Wright Hinckley, Proctor for Libellant Ap
pellant. Office and Post Office address: No. 50
Broadway, Manhattan, New York City
{fol. 42 Ix Usiren States Distrrer Covi
[Tithe omitted]
Srirvnation xe Thanscrirt or Rroonp
It ir herely etipmlatedd and agreed t] at they foregoine is n
true transcript of the record of the said District Court in
the above entitled matter nes agreed on bw the partic s.
Dated December 1, 1925.
George Wright Hinckley, Proctor for [ibe Nant.
Lampke & Stein, Proctors for Claimant.
en
30
[fol. 45] Clerk's certificate to foregoing transeript omitted
in printing.
{fol 44] Is Userep Svares Crevrr Counr or Arrrars ror
tHe Seoonp Cinevir, Ocronen Tram, 1027
No, 233
Argued March 14, 1028.) Decided April, 1s
W. A. Mansitats. & Co, Inc, Libelant Appellant,
v.
Steamship Puesioent Anrucn, Her Engines, foilers, etc.
Claimant. Appellee
Appeal from the District Court of the United States for
the Southern District of New York
Before Manton, L. Hand, and Augustus No Hand, Cireuit
Judges
Orinion
Appeal from the District Court for the Southern District
of New York. Libel filed by W. A. Marshall & Co. Inc. te
enforee a maritime len against the stean ship President Ar
ther for coal supplied. Deeroe for claimant; libelant ap
peale, Affirmed.
Gieorge Wright Hinckley, of New York City, for appel
lant.
Lampke & Stein, of New York ("sty iChauncey FE. Tread
well, of New York City, of counsel), for at pearl be
Saul S. Mvers, John Mo Woolsey, and Joseph Ko Guerin
all of New York City, amici curiae
Mastos, Circu:t Judge.
In March, 1925, appellant supplied bunker coal to the
President Arthar and seeks to enforce a lien for a halance
unpaid It ia net denied that the coal was mtapeyeiend, beat it
ic contended by the appellee that the coal was supplied pur
suant to written contract providing for parment on delis
—
31
ery by giv ing a trade acceptance indorsed by three individ-
nals, and it is asserted that by reason thereof no maritime
lien exists against the vessel. The contract provided:
**The buyer will pay for the said coal as follows:
**(1) By delivering to the seller a > acceptance drawn
by it in favor of the seller, dated the date of the de livery
of the coal, due March 10, 1925, cove ring railroad freight
of $2.79 a gross ton, which acceptance is to be indorsed by
Jacob Wacht, Jacob 8S. Strahl, and Joseph W. Gottlieb,
“(2) A trade acceptance drawn by the buyer in favor of
the seller, dated on the same day, due May &, 192), covering
the halance of the purchase price, to wit, $2.31 % gross ton,
representing the coal, harbor barge freight ‘and insurance
on coal while in barges, whichAeceptance is algo to be in-
dorsed by the aaid Jacob Wacht, Jacob 8. Strahl, and Jo-
seph W. Gottheb.
“The entire contract between the parties is stated above,
and there is no outside condition. warranty, agreement, or
understanding.’
After the signature on the contract, it is provided :
‘In consideration of the execution of the foregoing con-
tract, amd of the delivery of said coal by the seller to the
buyer, and in consideration of one dollar ($1.00) paid to
each of the — ‘rsigned, the rece ipt of which is here ‘hy ae-
knowledged, ¢ jointly and severally agree to indorse the
said trade acceptances described in the foregoing contract
between the seller and the buver.*’
Qn February 15, 1925, the appellant's sales manager
testified that they looked inte the financial standing of the
owners of the vessel and came to the conclusion that the y
did mat hke the secon nt ae wanted to get trade aecep lances
[fol 45] in order ‘to get the money at any time they
Wanted in fact to pt that paper.’’ And he said,
“We were nat satisfied with the eredit of the American.
Palestine Line.’ He wrote appellee on February 16th that
thes wanted track seceptiances to be indorsed by three re-
plable to them He testified further
that they did not consider the Palestine Line financial! Vv re
sprotmstele per eaetis Maus
sponsible, nnd insisted pean the mdorsement so thisat thes
could discount the paper ‘in case we need it at any time”?
—,
oo
It is significant that the agreement provides that the in-
dorsements were made by these individuals as part of the
consideration of the sale of the coal, and it was sworn in an
affidavit that, without the consideration of such indorse-
ments, the appellant would never have sold the coal to the
American Palestine Line. There was ‘*no outside condi-
tion, Warranty, agreement or understanding."’ Thus it,
appears that the crediLof the ship was nutaceepted by the | +
appellant, but, by the contract of the parties, trade accept
ances with three indorsers were insisted upon, and every-
thing for which the appellant had contracted was given in
payment, Cash was not contracted for, but payment other
than cash was accepted. It was, ax said by Chief Justice
Taney in Phelps vo The Camilla, Taney 400, Fed. Cas. No.
LOTS (Mad. ISS):
“If the parts does nat choose to rely on the contract which
the maritime law implies in such cases, but takes an express
written contract, he must rely on the contract he makes for
himself, and cannot, pen a change of cireumstances, resort
to the securities upon whieh, in the absence of any special
agreement, the law prosumes that he rehed; and if he takes
a note or till of exchange, or anv other personal engage
ment far the prs 8 Ths rit af thes shelst, hie ts presumed to rely an
this personal security, and to waive his hen Wless he stipu
latex that the linbility of the vesee? shall still continue."’
This rule has not been departed from by authoritative
decisions, See Segrist vo Crabtree, 121 U.S. 287, 9S. Ct
687, 33 L. Fab. 125; MeMurrav v. Brown, 92 U.S. 257, 28
I. Bd. %21: N. ¥. & Cuba 8S. 8S. Co. v. Texas Co. (C. C. A.)
o>? FOP. Atlan SS Co. vo Columbian Land Co, (2C. C |
A.) 102 F, 238 |
The Merchant Marine Act of 120 1446 UL SLC) ALS 974;
Comp. St. ¢ 8146' (ppp) provides that:
**Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent the
furnisher of repairs, «npples, towage, ase of dry dock or
marine rulway, or other neocsaries, Sena aera creiil
from wait mg hia right tog fen, oryn the enee ofa pre erred
mortgage fen, to the preferred status of sach hen, at any
time, by agreement or otherwiee,"’
Te sappert a tien, the act provides "it shall not be neces
anty tea nllege or prave
Nothing in the act bare proof that whatever was furnished
was furnished on the mer+ credit of the owner or third party
and in no sense upon the credit of the ship. Ely v. Murray
(C, C, A,) 200 F, 368. A lien does not exist where the sup-
plies are furnished on the mere credit of the owner. The
Cora P. White (D. C.) 243° FO 46. were is marked dis-
tinction between the effect of taking a note for an obligation
which already existed, and agrctme nh a contract which re-
ferred to an obligation hereafter to aftse, Mat the payment
of that obligation must be made by promissory note. The
trade acceptance, assuming a default in payment, permitted
the appellant to sue the indorsers. This it did.
The maritime lien is not to be given a broad legal inter
. ge .
pretation, nor is it to be extended by constryetion analogy,
or inference, Osaka Shosen Kaisha v. Pacific Export Lum.
ber Co, 260 U.S. 490, 45 8. Ct. 172, 67 L. Bd. 364; Piedmont
Coal Co. v. Seaboard Fisheries Co., 254 U.S. 1, 12, 41 8.
(1.1,65 L. Ed. 97. Where parties agree to an express con-
tract as to payment, the contract becomes extinguished by
full performance and so it is impossible that either party
should have any claim against the other arising out of the
contract, No lien can exist in faver of the materialman
when he receives in payment Tat forwtich he stipulated
when the contract was made.
In The Bird of Paradise, 5 Wall. 545, 18 L. Ed. 662. re-
ferred to by appellant, a lien was asserted for freight,
That lien differs from a maritime lien for repairs be-
cause a ship is bound to the carge until delivery or tender
of deliv ery and equalls is the cargo bound to the ship for
the payment of freight. The freight contract provided that
it should be paid in Liverpool on unloading and right de.
livery of the cargo. Construing the clauses of the hill of
lading together, it was clear that the charterer was not
obliged to pay the freight until tender of delivery. While
the charterer did give the first acceptance, he failed in busi
ness, and the acceptance was dishonored before the arrival
of the ship, and he never gave or tendered the second ac
ceptance mentioned in the charter party. It was held that
{fol. 46) the lien remained. The court stated that the
freight lien ‘stands upon the same ground with the lien of
the carrier on Jand, and arises from the right of the ship
owner to retain the possession of the goods until the freight
5-272
34
is paid, and is lost by an unconditional delivery to the con-
signee.’ And that the freight lien ‘‘may be modified, or
it may excluded, or displaced by direct words, or by the in-
sertion of some stipulation wholly incompatible or irrecon-
eilable with the existence of such a right."’ Requiring the
appellee to procure indorsements of three separate indi.
viduals was such a stipulation as is referred to in the lan-
guage quoted, and the appellant relied solely upon the in-
dorsements and not on the maritime lien, for it refused to
sell until it had the agreed indorsements.
Decree affirmed.
{fol. 47] Ix Usrren States Cascurr Count or Arrmais
No, 233
October Term, 1927
Argued March 14, 1928. Decided April 9, 1928
{Tithe omitted]
Disses tine Opinion
L. Hawn, Cirenit Jadge (dissenting): There are two
questions at issue first, whether the acceptances were a
payment; if not, whether their receipt by the libelant was a
‘waiver’ (of) ‘his righttealien ° ° ° by agreement
or otherwise."’ If the claimant had not been a party to the
acceptances, it may be assumed that they would have been
apayment. Atlas SS. Co. v. Colombian Land Co., 102 F.
ma CC AL 2) N.Y. & Caba SS. Co, v. Texas Co., 282 Fr.
271 (CC. A. 2); Hall v. Stewens, 116 N. ¥. 01, 22 N. E.
374,5 LR. A. Sm. If, on the other hand, it had agreed
only to deliver its note, and had done so, the note would
not have heen a payment. The doctrine that a note, in the
absence of an agreement to that effect, is not payment, is
not limited to eases where it is given upon a pre-existing
debt, bat equally applies when the only promise is to de-
liver it. The Bind of Paradise, 5 Wall, 545, 18 L. Ed. 662;
Reed v. Van Ostrand, 1 Wend. (N. Y¥.) 424, 19 Am. Dee.
529; Combe v. Bateman, 10 Barb. (N. Y.) 573. Lagieally, it
a
35
is true, the promise is performed when the note is delivered,
but the law looks to the essence, wil is the payment of
the money, of which the note is only another promise, When
the buyer is to deliver the note of another person he has
never agreed to pay at all, but if he joins in the paper, the
presence of other obligors does not affect his primary obli-
gation. As he still remains liable, he has never paid.
The question of ‘‘waiver’’ is more difficult. Under the
maritime law, the cases were in great conflict as to what
security taken at the time forbade the inference that the
buyer meant to rely on the ship. The strongest case for
the claimant is a bottemry bond, and this was held to
‘*waive’’ the lien. The Ann C. Pratt, Fed. Cas. No. 409, af-
firmed sub nom. Carrington v. The Ann C. Pratt, 18 How.
63, 15 L. Ed. 267. It would seem that a mortgage was
equally strong evidence of the same intent, but the decisions
are at variance. In The A. R. Dunlap, Fed. Cas. No. 513,
The D. B. Steelman (D. C.) 48 FP. 580, The Thomas Morgan
(PD. C.) 123 F. 781, The Cimbria (D. C.) 214 F. 128, and
The Fairhope (D. C.) 235 F. 1007, the lien survived such a
mortgage, but not in The Lucille (D. C.) 208 F. 434, and
The Yankton (D. C.) 7 F. (2d) 384.
Other kinds of security have also an equivocal effect. The
Cirenit Court of Appeals for the Fifth Cirenit held that a
wharfinger’s lien was not waived by taking a surety bend
in advance (EF) Amigo, 285 F. 868), an’ une
lien was not waived bv retaining title to ‘oe wmehinery
installed (Ricou v. Fairbanks, Morse & Co. 1C. C. A.j 11
F. (2d) 10%). The Pearl (D. ©.) 189 F. 540 and The E-270
[fol. 48] (D.C.) 16 F. (2d) 1005, are in accord with the last
case, The acceptance of an unindorsed note of the owner is
not a ‘‘waiver.’’ The Kimball, 3 Wall. 37, 18 L. Ed. 50:
The Bird of Paradise, 5 Wall. 545, 18 L. Ed. 662, supra,
Judge Brown held the same of the note of a third person in
The James T. Easton (D. C.) 49 F. 656, and Judge Betts
in The Active, Fed. Cas. No. 34. In Moore vy. Newbury,
Fed. Cas. No, 9772, and The Theodore Perry, Fed. Cas.
No. 13879, the same was held av to indorsed paper, taken,
however, after the goods had been sold. Justice Miller on
the other hand held flatly the contrary at Circuit (Taylor v.
Commonwealth, Fed. Cas. No. 13787). even though the note
we i “a t ee teheered. On the facts it is hard to see
how sue he tee. ouht have been reached. In Phelps
v. The Camilla, Fed. Cas. No. 11073, Chief Justice Taney at
Cireuit decided that when the sellers took notes of the ship’s
agent, they showed that they meant to rely upon them and
not upon the ship, and he added obiter that the taking of a
note wonld have ~ lease oe: way
Mechanics’ liens are not released by a reservation of
title (Chie. & Alton R. R. Co. v. Union Rolling Mill Co.,
109 U. S. 702, 3S. Ct. 594, 27 L. Ed. 1081; Leschen, ete.,
Co. v. Mayflower, ete., Co., 173 F. 855, 35 L. R. A. [N.8.] 1
[C. C. A. 8]; Hooven, ete., Co. v. Featherstone, 111 F. 81,
95 (C. C. A. 8}), nor by taking other security (Smith v.
Butts, 72 Miss. 269, 16 So, 242; Hinchman v. Lybrand, 14
Serg. & R. [Pa.] 32; Phelps Lumber Co. v. MeDonough Mfg.
Co., 202 F. 445 [C.C. A.9]) Perhaps this is because such
liens are favored. unlike m: citime liens or those of vendors.
Cor . ' ' M 5ST ; Williams v.
Roberts, 5 Ohio, 35; Gr din v. Blanchar, 17 Cal. 70.
It must be confessed, therefore, that the decisions are
confused and thet om anthority the case might go either
way. Before if! | ©:e ques.ion was whether the seller had
shown that he had taken the credit of the ship and not that
of the owner, though prima facie he succeeded if the ship
were in a forcien port, The statute has, however, changed
the burden (Piedmont Coal Co. v. Seaboard Fisheries Co.,
234 U.S. 1, 12, 41 8. Ct. 1, 65 L. Ed. 97), because it estab-
lishes the lien whenever the goods are ordered by any of the
specified persons, Why should "es pot want some
}. aur ty he arden tom! te tebe the note in sub-
at” tithes for “! leon?
The claimant must show just that; he must affirmatively
prove, there being no agreement and no estoppel, that the
parties could not have intended hoth eeenritiee to etand to-
ethos ‘an find no warrant for so strong a conclusion.
Marve, if the libelant still had the burden, this evidence
would not show positively enough that he had given credit
to the ship. But he has not got to do that any longer; the
hoot is on the other leg, and the claimant must show that the
lien was released, for that, in substance, appears to me to
be the equivalent of ‘‘waived"’ under these circumstances.
POOR COPY
_ 37
The proof falls far shi :t of that. Courts may still look
jealously at maritime liens, but the statute has accom-
plished something and that in their favor. If it has not
even gone so far as meets the libelant’s needs here, I
should think it had done nothing at all. 1 think that the
decree should be reversed.
ee
(fol.49] In Unrrep Srares Cmevrr Covrr or APPEALs,
Seconp Cimourr
W. A. Marsuatt & Company, Iwe., Libellant-Appellant,
v.
Sreamsuir ‘*Preswent Anruvn,’’ American Pacestine
Lixe, Claimant-Appellee
Appeal from the District Court of the United States for
the Southern District of New York
Decner-—-Filed April 16, 1928
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of record
from the District Court of the United States for the South-
ern District of New York and was argued by counsel,
On consideration whereof it is now hereby ordered, ad-
judged, and decreed that the decree of said District Court
be, and it hereby is, affirmed, with costé.
It is further ordered that a Mandate issue to the said
District Court in accordance with this decree.
M.T.M. L. H.
[File endorsement omitted. ]
ee
(fol. 50] Clerk's certificate to foregoing transcript omitted
in printing.
38
{fol.51}) Supreme Covet or rar Unirep States
Oxvex Attowine Ceerionant— Filed October 15, 1928
The petition herein for a writ of certiorari to the United
States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit is
granted. And it is further ordered that the duly certified
copy of the transcript of the proceedings below which ac-
companied the petition shall be treated as though filed in
response to such writ.
Endorsed on cover: File No. 35,581. U.S. Cireuit Court
of Appeals, Second Circuit. Term No. 272. W. A. Mar-
shall & Co., Inc., petitioner, vs. Steamship *' President Ar-
thur,’’ her engines, boilers, ete. Petition for writ of cer-
tiorari and exhibit thereto. Filed July 14th, 1928. File No.
33,581.
(4215)
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.