Transcript of Record — Alabama v. United States
Supreme Court brief1929
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(33,475)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITEDSTATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1928.
No. 166
THE STATE OF ALABAMA AND ALABAMA PUBLIC
SERVICK COMMISSION, APPELLANTS,
vs.
THRE UNTPED STATES OF AMERICA, ATLANTIC
COAST LINE RAILROAD COMPANY, SEABOARD
AIR LINE KAILWAY COMPANY, ET AL.
APYRAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF TIE UNITEL STATES
POR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ALABAMA
VOLUME 1
INDEX
(iriginal i*rint
Testimony of JW KRetnet + Be) may
r W. Ailrtiand i7s ns
3 4) ahitl tate au
J PF Pea tton Sah ert)
Jobo Ao Streyer na td
i. «". Amb rans i A)
UE Pireschet fas wr
We HW Mieming naa any
James Ho Rages 57% as
4 0 Darrieh Own un
th £ Levin , MSS | Gi
hatward Ao tt Newt avy 44
A 19) Mtavethat a | OT
12 KO Bates ou WT
T A Posies ne i
James Metiziew trecaliat: (has 71
Jie & lerwegiae Cine), Pinte. Wasuineros, 1) ©) Ocrommm G 12s
u INDEX,
Thomas J. Burks Susoehs
a A ee 6G
Omar Nweidler bisshne tbh the sdnck
K. Gi Cobb
Paigar Moulton
1. F rr
Fr W (jist
J Wo Alldrextge
M fl. Cooper - -
PARI ee
* f Rain
Ro HM Harriss
Wo Hatehinsen
Hage Ignatius
1) A Timohted!
J A Strayer
Bm KR Gartoer
fis Richimoned
MB Lrg
Met” Hh Wits
subg Wiisew
T WH Berens
Jaters Menties i rewaliat:
RA Chadeta
2 PF Saati
Mit” Witenes: ¢ ree liesd:
T AM Pieseies | reeg ile!
Mee” Ho Wilkes + rves tient
PaBibete te ot icbeawe
Progemest repert of Paamioer Artes
Ouvegticvee oa PerBalf of the Alebamme falda
Bettie ¢€ htealeedom
Petithem for rebemring wuel hrief geet ate ument iy mug
pevt thervef
Mothe of defemlants for emuhatgrement of tiaee fer set
‘Wing treme? om apgenet
tier emlerging tine tm which to eetthe the fee vere
M8 tyme he themes
Acbditiema! seftiputative
fresher dhewigmatiog ferred
§ Btathog Fommitton’ i gar imtomg >
terh eo -wetht ate (emmmittoet im peetact ing 1
SMeteteret of jetete tu be tediest wee tel deeignation of
parte of peremnd te te petetest ;
Imeeigmathion by Spertiow ralitveand cwanpankee of ei theomal
guetta of tewwrd te be petatest
Smomiguation by United Statee amt fo Coot of eSTitiona!
partes of rexced te be priptrd..... 6...
1
501
[fol. 445) J. HW. Kernen was thereupon called as a wit-
ness and, having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination:
1 am connected with the Seaboard Air Line Railway
Company, as General Freight Agent, lieadquarters Nor-
folk, Va. 1 have had quite a number of years experience
in connectoin wth traffic matters in the South; with south-
ern lines’ traffic departments nearly twenty-tive years. |
Wish to make a very few comments about certain features
of the case, and especially dealing with the interstate and
itrastate rates in the state of Florida. Just to connect up
the record, Mr. MeConnell was asked by Mr. Perry 1 think
of the Georgia Commission, as to the influence the Georgia
iitrastute seale of fertilizer rates had on the Alabama intra
state seale. During the period of change in Alabama. |
happened to be commercial agent of the Seaboard at Mont-
gomery, Ala. and was over the state pretty generally in
my duties, and | know positively that the State Commission
and the Governor of the state were being urged to adopt
the Georgia Rates; the claim being made that the Alabama
Commission was not taking care of its shippers as well as
the Georgia Commission was; and therefore the seale in
Georgia did have its direct influence on the senle udopted
in Alabama,
The Witness MeConnell was alse asked as to the move
mentoof fertuizer from Savannah, Ga. to South Carolina
destinations in connection with one of his exhibits. By the
Seaboard Air Line Railway, the movement for the season
of 124, January to May inclusive to all stations was 74,000
Plus tons; 3) per cent of this, or something more than 22.
(0 tons went to destinations in South Carolina. From
Montgomery, Ala, via the Seaboard to all stations, we had
a thovernent of in round figures 3,000 tons, and 11 per cent
of this went to stations in Georgia. From Columbus, Ga.,
to all stations, the movement was something over 6.000
[fol. 446] tons, and 30 per cent of this movement went ta
destinations in Alabama. So that there is relatively a
substantial movement to the adjoining states. (Tes. 571
H73.)
502
As stated, I was designated to testify as to the adjust-
ment in Florida, both the intrastate and the interstate ad-
justments to and from Florida, IT hare heard the testi-
ony of previous Witnesses dealing with the general ques
tions amd the justification of the reasonableness of the so
called Royster Seale, new being proposed by the carriers
for general application in the Southern Region, and 1 will
attempt to avoid duplicating of same. However, supple
menting the feostitions that has already been wiven tis ta
the history of the Royster Scale, | would like to state that
I took active part in the several hearings in that case that
is iu the Royster case, finally resulting in the Commission's
report and order in 421.0. G4. | was a witness for the
carriers in Chose cases, with the exception of the first case,
but I was present and worked up the testimony of the Sea
board in all three of the hearings, and | testified in the
last two hearings. It ts my sincere belief that, « xeoept for
eoercion eXercised in connection with the last hearing, we
would taiay have the Royster Seale substantially higher
than the present seale, both for interstate application from
Norfolk te North (Carolina pmritiia amd from Charlestan to
North Carvlina points, and from Wilmington te North
Carolina poimts, on basis of the first senate found reason
able by the Comeyssion an S11 ©. C. 458, and reaffirmed in
SS 1) 0. 190: Lam serry that Mr. Dashiell is not here,
as he wae the wittess for the complainant in that case, and
I think he could verify what T have to say. In the third
beaming the complainant amd the carriers were prepared
te tigke out a cemvineing Shreveport Case, justifying the
(Commission in orndemng a revision in the intrastate rates
applying from Wilmington to North Carolina points, the
complainants having expressed themeelves as being en
tirelv antiefiexd with the leve!l of the rates found reasonable
(fol. 447) by the Commission in its original report, which
wae at that time I believe the same as the North Carolina
intrastate eeale, amd if was the PH pH eee of the complain
ante to so express themeelves in the hearing inthat case. I
utuderstand that the Conmuniesron's first decision in that case,
I think powibly Mr. Gandner has touched upon it, the North
(Carolina scale wax revicem?, and it was apparetit that if
was in the nature of a retaliatory measure, but T think that
has been denied, but it was an odd coimendence that it fol
503
lowed so closely upon the Tnterstate Commerce Commis-
sion having fixed those rates, the rates from Norfolk into
North Carolina, that there was appointed that North Caro-
lina Commission, What was known as the Justice Commis
sion, Which was a commission appointed by the Governor,
and that that commission then reduced the North Carolina
intrastate seale. You spell that Justice, | think it
isa misnomer, In the hearing, this is the third hearing of
the Royster Case, the state of North Carolina was repre-
sented by Ex. Governor Cameron Morrison, then Attorney-
General of the State, that is Nx. Governor now, who was
at that time Attorney-General of the State, and two mem
hers of the North Carolina Corporation Commission were
also present, ] have not read the reeord in that case, the
transeript, but T have recently read the report, and what |
have to say is largely borne out by the Commission's re
port, During the progress of the hearing, the North Caro-
lina representatives Jearned of the attitude of the com
plainants, namely, that the complainants would not further
attack the reasonableness of the rates under Section 1, but
would rely entirely upon Section 3, joining the carriers in
that respect. Mr. Morrison openly stated to complainants
counsel and witness that if they did not change their posi-
tion and urge the Interstate Commerce Commission to adopt
the reduced North Carolina Seale, the North Carolina Farm
interests would boyveott the Norfolk Fertilizer producers.
As a result complainant attempted to withdraw his com
[fel. 448] plaint, as indicated at Page 40 of the Commis
sions report O01 Cl Cl) and on eross-oexamination, that is,
the carriers’ cross-oxamination, of complainant's witness, in
an effert to obtain an admission from complainant's witness
that the original seale of rates established by the Commis
sion was in his opinion reasonably low per se, the only an
swer he would make was that either the removal of the
discrimination by advancing the North Carolina intrastate
rates ar the reduction of the rates from Norfolk would
satisfy his complaint. (Tes. 573-576.)
1 know personally the factx about a threatened hoveott ;
I heard the conversation myself, there was apparently no
secret about it, as if was discussed in the hearing room, |
don't think that part of it was in the transcript of testi.
mony, but ] know it of my knowledge.
504
For the purpose of showing the importance of the fer
tiliver movement to the Southern carriers, Witness Gard-
ner filed Exhibit No. 40, in whieh he meluded the S. A. L.
Railway, and showed for the year 1925 that our fertilizer
tounnuge Was O80,140 net tons and that the fertilier ton
tage Was 4.04 per cent of the total tonnage. In this exhibit
I think Mr. Gardner has made his exhibit overly conserva
tive in that he failed to include the tonnage under the Classi
fication of Chemicals and Bix pelosis es of GU SO fots, or »
per cent of total tonnage, being a total ratio of G54 per
eent of the total tonnage on the Seaboard. Under the Inter
state Commerce Commission's Order of December Ist, 119,
prescribung chissificeation of commodities carried and to be
reported to the Commission, Commodity Group 66 cover
ing chemicals and explosives includes such important fer
tiltzer and fertilizer materials as acid phosphate, mitre cake,
partaasli, fitrate of soda, ets i. athd on the Seabowrd Ade Lane
Railway the majority of the movement under this Classifl
cation consists of acid phosphate and nitrate of soda, and
shecotelel, ate tary epermoen, te pocludedin this statement. [think
fol, 4499) thas will iikewsss apply tar the Najeriys, if not
all the other limes, shownoan this exhitat, There has been
soite stiggestion that the Comemneseion has changed that
classification, bat | don't think ot has so changed it as to
eliminate aend phosphate and nitrate of sada; in fact our
aivhiting department reeentivy adviewd us that those two
articles were still in that classification, and represented the
larger part of the movement umder that classification If
these articles are ineluded, the ratio ta the total tonnage,
eo far as the Seahannd Nir Line Railway is concerted, would
bar th ood ger ererdyt, ttnwte adbof 454 peer ownt (Tes STO 578.)
Chr thee aptrermt teens of the averuwe « consumption af fertiliger
pee gre, ttiels fue fee aad abet the average consump
tron of fertihwer per acre in Southern Territory amd Thay
attomnpeterd through several scurees to aseertain fair and
representative figures on thos question, emloavoring if yer
sitde, fa shaw the actual average applieation of fertilizer
te the « btivatead acry,« ‘eppofiates x” that poor tavern af OTH PATE ol
farm lamds net amder oultivation In an article bw Vir. Wil
liam PD Hart, imlioatel ae Directar of the National Fer
tiliver \ warns tafien, on Rs pert of the Work of the Seal Tn
305
.*
provement Committee’’ of that Association, appearing in
the American Fertilizer Handbook for 1924, and in a
graphic included in this article it shows the average pounds
used per crop acre, arrived at by taking the total consump.
tion of fertilizer sold in each state, divided by the total
aeres of harvested crops in 1922. It seems to me this brings
it down to a fairer average consumption per acre than any
figures | have seen.
Taking Witness Menyies’ Exhibit No. 10, and supple.
menting same with these fisures for 122, it shows an aver
age consumption per acre in North Carolina 265 pounds ;
Virginia ISS ponds ; South Carolina Tso pounds ; Georgia
102 pounds; Florida S34 pounds: Alabama 69 pounds: Mis
sissippi 37 pounds; Louisiana 40 pounds; Tennessee 26
pounds; Kentucky 27 pounds
[fel 490] We are advised hy the State Avricultural De
partment that in the vear 124 with 2.500.000 acres under
cultivation, there were 365.017 tons of fertilizer consumed,
resulting in an average of 202 pounds por acre, Of COUPSe,
this does not mean that some of the crop aeres got this
prortion of fertilizer, sane crop neTes prossitely did not get
auy fertilizer, as one witness was on the stand and testi
fied that he did not Use “any nitrate of soda on his farm:
but this is the nearest actual average that | could tind.
As to whether I] think that getting at the average pounds
used per acre on farm lands in a state is really a fair way
tu determine what it is going to cost the farmer for the use
of fertilizer in’ Florida Well, as ] SUEY, Ll tried the boost
I eould to fitud out some fairl, representative actual aver
age application of fertiliver to the « repoor the aere, amd that
thos apypieation an the harvested crop tmisis is the nearest
Wwe can get down to it ay the general average, | knew, of
eourse, Under same ya wetablos the NS Use an e\VCessive amount
of fertilizer, and force tha Vveuctabloes
“YQ. Mr. Retner, havent vou sufficient acquaintance with
Mlorda te knew that thers are thousands of acres of land
in Flerida that there is ne fertilizer used on at all, and in
that prertian of the state where thy \ perets nad to use fertyhizer,
they ee froma ton te five tons to the nere?
“A. No, that is in connection with the vegetable produc
506
tion, the tomato production on the sea coast and the veg.
etable production in the Manatee section, | of course know
that they use au excessive amount of fertilizer to force the
vegetables"’ (Tes. STON)
1 don’t think there is any question about the vexetable
and citrus production using more than all the balance of
the crops put together, and | know personally of some grow
ers down there that do not use from a ten to 5 tons to the
acre,
{fol. 451) *'Q. So that really we don't get at the true re
sult, we strike an average of all the results, but we don't
get the true result?
“A. Unfortunately, as | say, | tried to get some fairer
average. There is no question about that.”’
I want to make some statement in reward to the list of
articles and the carload minima as proposed under the Rev
ster Seale. Seo far as the Seaboard Air Line ix concerned,
I would like to clear upone pormton which there seems to
be some doubt, amd that is as to the list of commodities and
earload minimum weight to be applhed on same in cannes
tiem with the application of the proposed Royster Seak
Where the Rov ate r Seale is now applicable it covers list of
commeadities as emlmexfied in Note ‘he Exceptions 4, to
Southern Classifleation; and thie list amended eliminating
prices prliater rock and Mhahure Wie filexl tis Witness Menvis =
Fixhibit Ne oS. Under this let, the earload minimum weight
will net anifermiy be 008) pasunds. but will be the mini
mom as specifie! in the descriptive list. It should also Is
utmlerstuem! that this list of articles is not to be taken ax
being crvetalieed for all time to come and that changed con
ditions mav net make it newessarv to add to or take from
this fist, Thies may he true of cottonseed meal, which is now
imelucdes?t im the liet ax taking fertilizer rates It is net un
renectahle to assume that science in the future may fined
other uses for seme of the articles now included in this list
that will make it highly improper te continue the applica
thon of fertilizer rates on «ame
The term ‘fertilizer’ in Florida embraces an extensive
list of articles rated Clase °M."' applying in cents per ton
507
of 2,000 pounds, and applicable to carloads and less than
carload with some few exceptions, Where a carload mini-
mum Weight is specified. [| will here refer to Carriers’ hix-
hibit No. 209, which is a statement showing the present
Florida Classification rules and ratings on articles described
{fol. 452] as fertilizer and fertilizer materials, A number
of the articles embraced in the term fertilizers are also in-
cluded in the list of fertilizer materials. Under the Florida
Classification, fertilizer materials, as listed, are rated 75
per cent of Class M7" in connection with carload minimum
weight of 30,000 pounds. The Class **M"" rating on ferti-
lizer substantially as in effect today, dates back a great
many vears. According to our records this rating was
shown in Florida Classification effective as of December
Ynd, 1840; however, | am not prepared to say that it was
net also in effect sometime prior to that date,
Now, as to the histery of the fertilizer material rating of
75 per cent of Class M, the Classification rating of 75 per
cent of Class Ml ant fertilizer materials in Florida is of a
much more reeent date. The Florida Railroad Commission
by due notice to the lorida carriers, under date of July
87th, 110, called a hearing at its ofiee in Tallahassee, Fla.,
August Tith, 1910, *tte hear and consider whether or not
we, that is, the Commission, ought to make changes im our
Florida Classification No. 3, as follows:
By making fertilizer material; viz,
Brimstone, carbonate of potash, manure salts, verman
sind, Pape petniaee, eurnit, murite af potash, nitrate of
soda, mitre euke, sulphate of potash svivimit and sulphate
of ammoni, one half of M. Class Mi being the then exist-
ing rating accorded fertilizer unde r the Florida Classifi
eation, This hearing was attended by the officials of the
principal tines in) Florida and by representatives of the
(leala Fertilizer Company, Qeala, Fla. and the Southern
Fertilizer Company afl Orlando, Kha The carriers’ repre.
eentatives offered strenuous objections to the drastic re
duction as proposed in the eitation for hearing, and in an
effort to reach some compromise, suggested a basis of 7)
percent of Class Mon connection with earload minimum of
SO,000 pounds, to apply ona lst of fertilizer materials then
fol 455] moving intrastate in North Carolina on basis of
90 per cent of the fertilizer rates, subject toa carload mini-
mum weight of 50,000 pounds. ‘This list being acid phos-
phate, in bulk; sulphate of ammonia; dried blood; bones,
casior pomace, in bags; fish scrap; hardsaltz, in bulk ; hoof
meal, in bags or in bulk; kainit, in bulk; bat, bird or sheep
manure, in bags or in bulk; muriate of potash; sulphate of
potash, rotten slate, nitrate of soda; sylvinit and tankage.
However, it should be stated this suggested compromise was
not concurred in by one or more of the important Florida
lines.
Following this hearing, and under date of August 19th,
10, the Florida Commission issued its order No, S06, to
become effective on September 6th, 110. Copy of same is
tiled as my Exhibit No, 210.) (Tes. DSU DS.)
(Certain statements were thereupon received in evidence,
and marked **Carriers’ Exhibits Nos, 200 to 219 inclusive
Witness Ketner."’)
The third section of this exhibit has reference to fertil
izer materials, there being several other matters included
in this same hearing covered by the same order. It will
be noted this order included a great number of articles in
addition to the ones referred to in the Commission's clita
tion of hearing and that same preseribed rating of 7 per
cent of M in connection with carload minimum weight of
S000) pounds. This Order was very objectionable to all
of the Florida lines ; however, it was made effective by some
of the lines, same being published under protest,
One of the important Florida lines carned its protest to
the extent of declining to make this order effective and in
letter ackiressed to the Chairman of the Railroad Commis
sion of Florida, under date of September Sra, 1910, set out
fully its reason for so declining and with respect particu
larly to the reduced rating on fertilizer materials, among
other things, called the Commission's attention to the fact
[fol. 454] that its Order No. 306 undertook to make a 2
per cent lower rate on fertilizer ingredients, worth at that
time $50.00 and $60.00 per net ton, that it makes on mixed
fertilizers worth $25.00 per ton, and by its Order, the Com
miasion undertook to say that where $2.00 is a just and
reasonable rate on 30,000 pounds of mixed fertilizers worth
509
$25.00 a ton a just and reasonable rate on the same weight
of nitrate of soda worth $50.00 a ton is only $1.50 per ton.
The rate on materials is not an any-quantity rate; that is
a carload rate, 30,000 pounds. The rate on fertilizer was
an any-quantity rate, with some few exceptions, as my first
exhibit shows, where they specified a carload minimum, |
do not think there is any justifiention for a difference be-
tween the two, because as a matter of fact, even under the
any-quantity basis, the complete fertilizers move in carload
quantities, Assuming that the same rate would be reason
able on fertilizer materials as on a complete fertilizer, then
if we are going to have an any-quantity rating on one and
a carload rating on the other, | think the any-quantity rate
would be higher than the ecarload rate. Of course, the any
quantity rate is the carload or less than carload rate, it im-
cludes both carloads and less than carloads, but I can't see
any justification in making a substantially lower basis of
rates on fertilizer materials than on fertilizer.
“By Mr. Burr:
“Q. Mr. Ketner, it appears not fair to create the impres
sion here that the price of mixed fertilizer at the date you
have mentioned here was $25.00 a ton in Florida.
“A. That was the figure we had at that time, Mr. Burr,
as I stated.’
1 understood it to be the price of fertilizer in Florida;
it was my understanding that that was the price of the eom
plete goods in Florida at that time, that i simply taken
from our records, | have no first hand information on that.
[fol 455) Lam referring now to the protest that was filed
with the Florida Railroad Commission at that time as to
the matters and things that were stated in that protest; we
had objected to putting in the order, and we were simply
giving our reasons for not making the order effective, we
felt that the Florida Railroad Commission was entitled to
our reasons, Attention is also called to the fact that the
whole purpose of the Commission's Order, as was clearly
indicated at the hearing of August 11th, was to build up
and foster interior fertilizer factories at the expense of the
carriers and to the detriment and disadvantage of the port
510
fertilizer manufacturers, and through its rate making
power, Was preferring one section of the state to the preju-
dice and disadvantage of interests in another section of the
state, and its effect was to destroy natural advantages en
joyed by the manufacturers at the ports through an arbi
trary adjustment in rates. It also had the effect of giving
preferential treatment to certain fertilizer materials which
were applied directly to the soil as in commercial fertilizer.
Among such articles are nitrate of soda, cottonseed meal,
acid phosphate, wood ashes, cottonseed hull ashes, kainit,
land plaster, ete. (Tes. 584.587.)
This carrier offered the further reason that the Com
mission's Order 306 included a great many articles that
were not included in the notice of hearing, which was con
trary to the law governing the Railroad Commission,
I don’t know it as a fact that in that hearing, although
the carriers were opposing making rates on these materials,
that it was agreed on one point, that such materials as the
State Chemist of Florida set down as fertitzer materials
would be named in whatever order was written. As | men
tioned, the compromise suggested at that hearing was to
adopt a basis of 75 per cent of Class Moon the list of articles
that took ‘) per cent of the fertilizer rate in the state of
[fol. 445} North Carolina. | know that to be a fact, but
I don’t know it to be a fact, the statement vou bave just
made; | am relying upen the statement of our first Vice
president, and he was at the bearing, he attended the hear
ing. It may possibly be hearsay Information given u-
by our first View presudent, we consider almost first hand
information.
In ackiition to what has been sand, this carrer objected to
the measure ofr the propeoned basis of rates as it would re
sult in lower rates than carrosd on similar commedities in
any other state reached by this carrier and that no other
state through which it operated, with the single exception
of Nerth Carolina, bad attempted to make lower rates on
fertilizer materials than applied to fertilizer. and that in
that «tate, the list of commodities taking rate less than fer
tilizer was very limited.
This carrier continued to refuse to olwerve the Railroad
Commission's Order 306, and after a lapse of something
511
over two years, the Florida Commission issued notice on
September 7th, 1912, calling hearing at Tallahassee, Fla.,
September 18th, 1912, for the purpose of considering and
investigating whether an order should not be entered requir-
ing this carrier to adopt Order No, 306. The notice of this
hearing contained an exact list of the commodities included
in Order 306, thus meeting one of the objections raised by
this carrier against the previous order. At this hearing,
which was finally held on October 2nd, 1912, the defendant
carrier again made strenuous objections to the proposed
action of the Commission; however, under date of October
Sth, 1912. the Florida Commission issued its Order No. 374,
effective November Toth, 1912, which is filed as Carriers’
Exhibit No. 211.
Following receipt of Order No. 374, the defendant carrier
filed an application for an injunetion against the enforce
ment of the Commission's Order, this application being filed
in the Cireuit Court of the Second Judicial Cireuit in Leon
County, Fla.; however, before this injunction preceeding
[fol. 457) was disposed of the defendant carrier, to relieve
itself of the possibility of suffering heavdy penalties on
account of its previous refusal to comply with the Commis-
sien’s Order, published the reduced rating, effective August
6th, WIS. CTes, SS7-590.)
We did not get a permanent injunction against the Order;
we simply minded to save ourselves from being spanked. |
don’t know that the Court would spank us, but we had
other matters up in Florida. We were in court on a good
mans very important matters. They were all withdrawn
from the courts; it was Judge Watts, I think vou will re-
member that Judge Watts was responsible for that com
promise; there were other matters that were pressing ue. It
was good business judgment to accept. The same criticism,
made in 112 ef the 75 per cent of Class M rating on fer
tiliver material, applies with equal force today, and in our
opinion is indefensible,
The only states, as far as | am advised, making a lower
rating on fertilizer material than on fertilizer, other than
the State of Florida, as previously referred to by Mr. Men.
vies, is the State of Georgia, where only two articles,
namely, Kainit and Acid Phosphate in bulk, carload mini
512
mum 40,000 pounds, is rated 10 per cent less than fertilizer
and in the state of North Carolina a restricted list of fer-
tilizer materials are given rating of 90 per cent of the fer-
tilizer rate when such materials are loaded to 90,000 pounds
or more to the car. In North Carolina the larger percent-
age of fertilizer materials move from the port of Wilming-
ton, reaching that port by water, and on the inland move
ment to North Carolina destinations we have for some time
past considered this movement interstate in character and
therefore have not applied the North Carolina intrastate
rating but have apphed the interstate rate, which is the
same as on fertilizer, however.
fol. 455) | don’t think we are applying the intrastate
rates on imported materials tuday te Florida points; |
don’t knew that we have taken detinite action on that, we
are applying it on petroleum products, and it should hike:
wise be applied on imported fertilizer materials, If our
officials in Florida are construing their movement of fertu
liver materials from the ports as interstate traffic, and ap-
plying the interstate rates, they are carrying out my idea
on it.
That is in line with my idea, and we are trying to sus
tain that idea in the Federal Courts now. Continuing my
statement as to the situation in North Carolina, under an
order of the North Carolina Corporation Commission is-
sued in April, 1924, directing the carriers to apply the
intrastate rates on such movements where there wus @
change of ownership at the port, the carriers, to aveid pen
alties, have applied the intrastate rating for ears loaded
to MO pounds or mnore, but have carriad the matter to
the Federa! Court, Eastern District of North Carolina, on
meth appleatron fer interlecutery imygunetion against the
North Carolina Corporation Commission's Order, and that
matter ps terw paorebing Woe had to observe the Nerth Caro
lina Commission's order, or rather the Nerth Carolina
Commission's idea ax to the difference between interstate
and intrastate traffic, beenuse their iden was backed wp by
an order and carried with it serious penalties, whereas the
Interstate Commerce Commission, taking the opposite
view to that of North Carolina Corporation Commission,
had not put ite wleas in the shape of an order, and therefore
we had only one alternative, and that was to obey the
1S
order of the North Carolina Corporation Commission, and
we are exhausting all our reasonable remedies to get the
matter straightened out and some final conclusion reached.
(‘Tes. 590-593.)
{fol. 459] There are only one or two interior fertilizer
plants on the Seaboard Air Line Railway in the State of
Florida, namely, Gainesville aud Orlando, Those interior
plants of course reach the plants at Jacksonville and
‘Tampa, and there are possibly other minor mixing plants.
There is a little mixing done at Tallahassee; there is more
or less mixing now on every farm practically. 1 am not
enough of a fertilizer expert to say whether those home
fixing formulas are valuable or not. Tam speaking of the
Seaboard, | specitied the Seaboard. Both of the plants |
have referred to are of comparatively small eapacity, how-
ever, for the first five months of 1024 January to May,
1924, inclusive—the Seaboard moved out of Jacksonville
409 cars, or U274 net tons of fertilizer material, aud 34
tons from Tampa, which apparently sustains the carriers’
criticism of September, 112 that, with the preferential
rating on fertilizer material, there would likely occur a
movement of certain of these materials for direct applica-
tion to the soil, to the prejudice of comp ete fertilizers pay-
ing the full fertilizer rate from the port factories to in
terior consumers, as it is hardly probable that those two
miner interior plants use the amount of fertilizer material
that | have specified.
As previously stated by Witness Menzies, fertilizer in
Florida ix now rated Class M, any-quantity, with some few
exceptions, Regardless of the fact that fertilizer takes the
sane rate carload or less than carload, the analysis of the
movement over the Seaboard in Florida, so far as we have
been able to make same, indicates that the majority of the
movement is in carload quantities, that is in lots of 15 tons
er more, from one shipper to one consignee on one bill of
lading; for example, the movement via the Seaboard from
Jacksouville, Fla, for the first five months of 1924: we
moved 1309 ears, or 24,152 tons, loaded 15 tons or more
fo the car, whereas, during the same period we only handled
{fol 460] L. CLL. shipments amounting to 5,764 net tons.
The L. CLL. movement represents 19.2 per eent of the total
movement during the 5 months period. The less than car
35—166
54
load shipments were handled in the usual way, through our
forwarding depots, received from drays or trap cars, and
delivered through our depots at destination, placing on the
earriers all of the additional eXpenses of loading and un
lowteling inetdent to less than carload traffie which is con
siderably more expensive than carload trafie where same is
lobed and unloaded by the shipper or receiver, whereas
the compensation to the carrier was on no higher basis than
on the carlond movement. The any quantity rating on
fertiliver is an inheritance of the old days when fertilizer
Was consamed in comparatively small quantities, but is un
fair te the carriers under present conditions.
As pres botany stated by Wittens Menzies, We are propos.
ing the appleation of the socalled Third Royster Seale for
intrastate appheation in the State of Florida on both ferti
beer amd fertiliger material (Tes, 508-495.)
Th view oof the yeoyruphical location of Florida im that
is feettitisule state amd that the lines operating in the
state are, as oAP Posse by the Interstate Commerce Com
risston, gathering or terminal lines, having ne opportunity
ter pebrticrpaate in transtate traffic but wholly dependent upon
trafic ormgitating in aml or terminating in that stale, a
higher level of rates on fertilizer might properly be pre
peed for application in the state of Florida than in the
other Southern States
“Rs Mero Bart
*U) Tt saectris that thes 1» itisula state is rather attri
othe railroad owners, to build mere lines in it at pres
ent, Mr. Retner?
“A. [tis an excellent state, Mr. Burr, and we consider it
aA coring state
“() Therefore, the conditions which son refer to are
tist copenderes! af all sericus when if come te making an
fool $02) snveatinent in railroad Property on Ploruda "’
Ploruia is an exeolient faaier for the reat of the Irnes,
there is ne question abeut that, | haven't denied that. and
I am not offering that as a paetyfieatioon for a higher level
of rates, but neverthelees, Floriuda is a terminal state, the
hmew in Plorda are terminal lines, and they are therefore in
the peeeition of stub lines, thase fines bs mding out from
515
Jacksonville south, where the authorities have repeatedly
recognized that those stub lines, not in a position to par-
ticipate in through traffic might properly be accorded rates
somewhat higher than the general level of rates on the
Trank Lines or the Trunk stem of the system. 1 here re-
fer to Carriers’ Exhibit No. 212.) The statement filed
shows present and proposed local mileage single line rates
on fertilizer and fertilizer material between points in
Florida as compared with the proposed Royster Seale. As
to carload shipments of fertilizer, it will be noted that the
scale proposed by the carriers will result in material re-
ductions in the present seale to and including 140 miles,
with the except.on of 94 to 100 miles, and 111 to 120 miles,
and the block 14] to 150 miles inclusive, where there would
be no change. Beyond 150 miles, the proposed seale will
result in advances.
Ou fertilizer material, now rated 75 per cent of the ferti
liver rate, there would be advances in the proposed scale
with the exception of the first two mileage blocks. In this
connection, it might be well to call attention to the fact that
in the several comparisons filed by previous witnesses,
Where the Royster Seale did not result in reductions, it was
in almest all cases for the longer distances; generally
speaking; distances bevond 150 miles. As has also been
shown by other witnesses, the average movement of corm
plete fertilizer is for distances substantially less than for
Lt miles, whereas, fertilizer materials move for the longer
distances, That is true in Florida; | think that will be
{fol 462) borne out by the traffic or revenue test. In con
sidering the reasonableness of the Royster Seale for the
longer distances, we ask that the Commission bear in mind
the fact that the fertilizer materials, on the average, are
of substantially greater value than complete fertilizers, and
therefore, proportionally higher rates on same would not
be unreasonable.
The Class M mileage scale applicable in’ Florida, exelu
sive of the advances under General Order No. 28 and Ex
Parte 74, and 10) per cent reduction under Docket 104
of July Ist, 1922, has been in effect for a number of vears,
with the exeeption of a reduction effective duly Ist, 1903 of
10 cents per ton for distances up to TQ miles and 3 cents per
ton for distances 71 miles to and including 100 miles.
O16
Now, as to the joint haul rates. The present basis for
joint haul rates under the Florida Commission's Freight
Rule No. 19 is combination of locals less 10 per cent, where
the joint haul is over two independent lines and combina-
tion of locals less 20 per cent where the haul is over three
or more independent lines. (Tes. 595 598.)
ffel 463) Direct examination (continued):
Just before noon adjournment [had referred to Carriers’
Exhibit 213, whieh is statement showing combination of
local mileage rates for varying distances on fertilizer rated
Class M in carload quantities, and fertilizer material rated
75 per cent of Class Moin carload quantities, as compared
with the proposed jennt haul scale. In this statement the
joint hauls are calculated only on basis of two-line hauls or
combination of locals, less 10) per cent, indieated in lines
A and By line © represents the proposed joimt haul scale.
To ilustrate, assume a joint haul of 4) imiles made ap of 2
miles over two lines, the present fertulger rate is OO4 cents ;
fertilizer material rate 22S cents, and under the proposed
scale Jl4 cents, representing a reduction of {0 ceuts per ton
om fertilver and 14 cents per ton on fertilizer material,
Assume a haul of 4) miles on one line and a haul of 25 miles
em a Cotimeatiny fitse, or through yount hatl af io tiles, the
prrecmartat fertilimer rate is > cents and the fertilhger mate
rial rate tx ZO1 cents, the prroprorscdd rate is 248 cents, repre
senting a redaction of ST cents per ton on fertilizer and 3
cents per ton on fertilizer maternal Assume haul of 75
tritex on one line amd 25 miles on a connecting line, or joint
haul of 1tmiles, present fertilwer rate would be JhS cents
ated the material rate 274 cents, whereas under the proprrsed
pount wale beth would hbeeome JS! cents, representing re
duction SS cents on fertihever and mivance of S cents on
fertsuiver material Kesiuctions on fertihwer would be the
eomeral rule amd on fertilizer material there would be both
reviuetions amd advaners, the advances being largely duc to
the ents reeuy ea tgan tds low bease for prescnt rates on fertiliver
material
Aw tmbieating the effeet of the proposed rates from repre
whrtative fertiliver manufacturing pointe in Florida to
ifol, 464} representative mtrastate destinations in Flor
prise
517
ida, I will here refer to Carriers’ Exhibit No. 214. In this
exhibit we take Tampa, Florida, and Gainesville, Florida,
as representative points of origin, and stations on the At-
lantic Coast Line and Seaboard Air Line Railways as rep-
resentative destinations. The rails of the Atlantie Coast
Line and Seaboard Air Line Railway reach both points of
origin, therefore the distances are figured by the continu-
ous hauls of the respective lines, except at common point
destinations we have used the short line distance via either
the Seaboard or Athantie Coast Line. It will be noted the
proposed rates will result in both increases and reductions,
but where advances occur they will not be material except
for extremely long hauls, and for such hauls it is hardly
probable there will be a movement for reason that those
destinations would more than likely be served by manu-
facturing plants nearer the destinations. For example, on
page 2oof this exhibit we have shown destinations on the
Seaboard between Jacksonville and Chattahoochee River,
that is the line running out due west from Jacksonville, and
present and proposed rates from ‘Tampa, Florida. It is
hardly probable Tampa would expect to supply fertilizer to
this part of the Seaboard as against the extensive produe
thon of fertilizer at Jacksonville, Florida, having an advan
tage in distance of approximately ISO miles. (Tes. 599-601.)
Now, as to the next adjustment, as witness Menzies has
sated, the carriers propose the application of the so-called
Royster seale for single line or joint haul application be.
tween points in Florida and points in adjacent States. For
example, from points in Georgia, such as Albany, Black
shear, Valdosta, and from South Atlantic Ports, namely,
Brunswick, Savannah and Charleston to destinations in
Florida, The general hasis for interstate rates on classes
[fol 465] and commoditics to and from Florida is combi
nation on Jacksonville. Now, when T speak of combination
Palo not meni necessarily full combination of locals between
Jacksonville; either combination ef locals or differential
basis tnade up of proportional rates to and from Jackson
Ville. “This basis has consistently been adhered te, and it
has been established and repeatedly approved by the Inter-
state Commerce Commission in various adjustments and in
our opinion there is full Justification for the continuance of
same. The peninsula of Florida is peculiar to any otber
518
State in the United States, in that the trunk lines in Flor-
ida do not and cannot participate to any extent in the move-
ment of trans State traffic, i.e, traffic originating at or
destined to points in other States passing through the State
of Flonda. We are not proposing combination on Jackson.
ville proper; but TL just wanted the record to show very
clearly that we are departing from the usual basis, and this
is a radical departure, and we still feel that there might be
justification im putting these rates on the usual basis of
combination, or differential basis, except for reasons | will
later explain, - want to show that we are making an un.
usual and unprecedented concession to the State of Florida
aml to the fertilizer interests. Not only that is made with
respect to fertiliver and fertilizer materials, and is based
particularly apen the circumstances and conditions that sur-
round the hamdliog of that particular commodity,
The outbound movement in any volume is almost entirely
litntted te perishables, lumber, naval stores and phosphate
rock, There is but litthy manufacturing in the State, and
the inboumd tompage ts Limited largely to food and clothing
for the inhabitants, together with fertilizer, machinery, ete.
The Florida situation, with its thin population per mile
of rowed, results tn the combition of low traffic density leas
[fel 400) than in any other State cast of the Mississippi
amd Seuth of the Ohio and Potomac Mivers. (Tes, 601-608.)
In support of my statement as to the low traffic density
in the State of Florida as compared with Southern Terri
tery generally, TE will refer to Carriers’ Exhibit No. 215,
“tatement shewtige average tiles operated, revenue ton
thifes amd revenue ton miles per mile of road on Class 1
roads in Seathern Region for vears 1922 and 1923, as com
pared with the traflie density on that portion of the Class 1
roms inthe State of Flarnda. It will be found that the aver
axe traffic denaty on the Florida lines is, in round figures
2 per cent, of the traffie density of Class 1 lines in South
ern Region. The exhilit indicates the source of this infor.
mation, atl epeaks for iteelf. That exhibit covers the two
years, DIZ amd 123. 14 is not available. That ix, of all
Class Tlines. That information ix nsually gotten up by the
HKureaa of Railway Keonomics. Ax an individual line, I
know of course the figures are obtainable.
519
I am sure we have the individual figures, but I mean for
the Class 1 lines of the Class I roads in Southern Territory
as a Whole. [| have not any figures on that. As to those
exhibits, | want to be entirely fair. Since this exhibit was
prepared we have found that in the general averages of the
Class 1 lines in Southern Region, we have included the reve-
nue ton miles of the entire line of the Hlinois Central Rail-
road, Whereas, as a matter of fact, taking 1923 to illustrate,
it shows the average miles operated 4,840.25, whereas, that
part of the Hlinois Central in Southern Region is only 1,676
miles.
I don't think there is any way of determining what their
traffic density is in Southern Territory alone on that line.
The only thing we can do is to take the revenue ton miles
per mile of read, and multiply that by 1,676, to arrive at the
{fol. 467] revenue ton miles, and take that portion of that
total figure included into this general average. On that
basis it would reduce the average revenue per ton mile of
road from 1,411,665 to 1270,000, And the ratio of the aver-
age ton mile per mile of road in Florida to that total figure
would represent 44 or 45 per cent. instead of 39 per cent.
I have previously indicated, That is, the revenue ton mile
per mile of road in Florida would represent about 44 or 45
per cent. of the general average in Southern Region.
I] think it is an acceptable basis, that where the higher
the traffic density the lower the rates can properly be rel-
atively, and it is about the only thing that represents the
density of traffic,
"Q. Now, just to test that idea, and to show the possible
exceptions to at, I netice here that the Atlantie Coast Line
System for 122 has a traffic density of 765,668, whereas,
the Carolina, Clinchfield & Ohio has a traffie density of
R465 021, Now, what would vou say that that would in
dheate, that rates ought to las statostianticalls lower relatiy els
on the Carolina, Clinehfield & Ohio than on the Atlantic
Coast Line?
"4 That is not, of course, a conclusive fivure. 1 think
vou have got to take into consideration somewhat the traffic
moving, Of course, that density on the Carolina, Clinch
field & Ohio represents a large percentage of coal traffic.”’
520
That is true of some of these other lines.
As previously stated, the Interstate Commerce Commis-
sion has established and repeatedly approved the combi-
nation basis of interstate rates in and out of Florida. For
example, in the several fruit: and vegetable adjustments
out of Florida, also in the live stock adjustment, 1, & 5.
Docket Poach, T4 1) CL 419, in the naval stores adjustment,
IL & S. Docket 1900, 87 ECL) CL 740, and in the fertilizer
[fol 408} adjustment from Blackshear, Georgia, Docket
ISSL4 87 LC). 634, and in the brick and clay products ad
justment, Lo & OS Docket ISSO, SS EC) CL 43.) Por ready
reference, LE will call attention toe Carriers’ Exhibits Nos.
oh) and 217, extracts from the several decisions of the In-
terstate Commerce Commission bearing on this question.
Ome of the Commissioners has also apparently recognized
this basis in a tentative repert in LC. C. Docket 14494, on
the class rate adjustment, (Tes, GOO 005,)
We desire it clearly understood the combination basis
heretofore applied is, in our opinion, entirely proper and
reasonable, but for reasons 1 will later give you, we feel
that fertilizer in this instance requires some special treat
ment, ated in departing from the general basis, makes a sub
stantial cenmtmbution to the fertilizer interests, either the
manufacturer or consumer, whoever gets the benefit of rate
realinet retin.
We were not quite satisfied with the extent to which that
lassie Was recognized in the tentative report in 15404; it
only recogniaed it in prineaple, and not in revenue,
The only justitieation for departing from = the general
haste in the ease of fertilizer moving inte Florida from ad
jacent States is that, as we understand it, the purpose of
this investigation t« te arrive at a uniform level of rates
that can be reasonably applied both interstate and intra
state. Fertilweer ia the only commodity manafactured to
any extent in Plorida, and consumed within the borders of
that State. As a matter of fact, by far the larger portion
of fertiioer aed in Florida om manufactured in the borders
af the State There is a movement from these adjacent
States into Florida, bat it ix comparatively an insignificant
movement. TL eaid fertilizer consumed in Florida is largely
ranefaetorsl in that State We are proposing for inter
state application within the State of Florida the single line
521
[fol 469] and joint haul so-called Royster seale. The im-
portant fertilizer manufacturing points in Florida, that is,
important more or less, are ‘Tampa, Lakeland, Orlando,
Gainesville and Jacksonville. ‘There are of course other
minor mixing plants.
Pensacola is an important point from a manufacturing
standpoint, but I don't think they ship much in the diree-
tion of Jacksonville.
There are likewise fertilizer factories at Albany, Val-
dosta, Blackshear, Savannah, Georgia, Charleston, South
Carolina, and Brunswick, Georgia, and possibly other
points in the same general territory, shipping in more or
less volume to consumers in the State of Florida. The
Florida manufacturer having the benefit of the single line
or jomt haul continuous mileage seale under the carriers’
propesed adjustment, the interstate shipper at the points
mentioned would be at a disadvantage on a combination or
differential basis over Jacksonville, and therefore, the only
way that the several manufacturing points can be kept on
a parity, distance considered, is by applying the distance
scale from the adjacent interstate points into Florida—and
this basis will remove any ground for a discrimination com-
plaint and appears to us a reasonable basis considering the
comparatively short hauls between the interstate points of
origin and the Florida State line.
The basis we are proposing from interstate points of
origin in adjacent States and South Atlantic Ports into
Florida will result in material reductions. In support of
this statement Twill call attention to Carriers’ Exhibit No.
21S, showing the present and proposed rates on fertilizer
from Albany and Blackshear, Georgia, as representative
points of production, to destinations on the Seaboard Air
Line Railway and Atlantic Coast Line Railroad in Florida.
[fol 470] The distances in this statement are figured hy
short line workable routes, as indicated. This exhibit
speaks for itself, and shows that we are proposing a basis
of rates that will actually make many reductions in the al-
ready extremely low rates recently established by the Inter-
state Commerce Commission in the Blackshear Case, Docket
514, 87 1. C654.) (Tes, 606.609.)
522
As illustrating the effect of the proposed basis of rates
from Jacksonville, Brunswick, Savannah and Charleston,
to Florida destinations, | here direct attention to Exhibit
No, 219, which shows representative points of destination
on the ALC. L. Railroad and S. A. L. Railway in Florida,
the distances reflecting the short line workable routes as
indicated in the exhibit. It is intended to apply the mile
age scale for the actual distances from the several ports,
and this basis will result in both advances and reductions ;
more substantial reductions being in the rates from Jack
sonville.
Now, at the present time the adjustment from South
Atlantic Ports inte Florida is on a differential basis. That
is, the rates from Jacksonville are on the actual mileacrc,
Savannah, exclusive of the two Zo per cent advanees and
the 10 per cent. reduction Savannah was made $1.00 per
ton over Jacksonville; Brunswick was made the same as
from Savannah; Charleston was made 50 certs over Sa
vannah, or S100 over Jacksonville.
It is a fact as appears from this exhibit that under the
Carriers’ proposal there will be reductions in a great
many of the rates that were established by the Commission
im the se called Blackshear case. That we consider those
rates extremely low, and vet what we are proposing here
will actually result in reductions in a good many of those
rates. The carriers were not at all satistied with the de
cision in the Blackshear case; they filed a) petition for
rehearing in that case, and that is now pending before the
[fel 471] Commission,
I think that these rates that we are propesing are lower
than maximum reasonable rates on fertilizer, My idea
that the fertilizer development in the South has grown
up from the time when we hamdled fertilizer for practically
nething, and as Mr. Burr sand, when we made a charge
for it, a large part of it was rebated, that is the basis for
our present adjustment today, and To candidly think that
we might have reasonably proposed a substantially higher
level of rates than we are proposing here.
As to the reasonableness of the rates per se, Todo not
think the Commission would be justified ino requiring us
fo woeas low as We are proposing voluntarily to wo, 1 don't
523
mean to say these rates will be confiscatory, I think they
will pay us something about the out-of-pocket cost.
As to what is our reason for going lower than we think
would be reasonable: From these interstate points of
origin into Florida, as | explained, our reason for doing it
there is to put the interstate shippers shipping into Florida
on a parity with the intrastate shipper selling from the
sume point of destination.
I think one reason is that the rates we are proposing
bear the stamp of reasonableness of the Interstate Com-
meree Commission; | think that is one of the controlling
reasons, -Toam speaking of the question as a whole. I
understand the question involved is the whole question,
and not any particular situation. | think that is one
reason that influenced us in using the Royster scale.
**By Com, BMastman:
“Q. You think, in view of the Third Royster Case, you
could hardly expect anything higher than that?
“A. Tsay, it bore the stamp of approval by the Com-
Mission.
“Q. But vou are not doing it heeause vou think any con-
{fol. 472] cession ought to be made to either the fertilizer
producing industry or the fertilizer consuming industry?
“AL DT don't think so, sir: T think a somewhat higher
scale would be reasonable to charge for the services in-
volved, to all interests concerned, Now, that is my personal
view, | do not know that others agree with me on that.”’
I really think that fertilizer is one of the commodities
that might be reasonably advanced, You evidently have
in mind the Hoch Smith Resolution. | think fertilizer is
one of the commodities that might be reasonably advanced
and nobody injured, (Tes, GO 612.)
Well, it is mighty hard to tell what the resolution means,
but all Tecan get out of it is in trying to reach some gen-
eral level, and some rates may be too low and others too
high.
It is my view that if in the course of the investigation
the Commission should undertake a redistribution, to use
the language of the resolution, of rates in Southern Ter-
bi
ritery, and an adjustment with the idea of establishing
a better relativity as het ween ditferent commodities, that
fertilizer is certainly not one of the commodities that
should be reduced, but on the contrary, if anything be ad
Vanced, T have no commodity in mind now Which IT think
ought to be reduced.
Now, as to the Value of commercial fertilizer Used in
Florida, in further justifieation of the reasonableness of
the propensed Royster seale inte Florida, it is well recey
hited that Value of the commodity ix one of the elements
to be taken inte consideration in fixing a reasonable rate,
and tnendentally, the fertilizer generally used in the Mlorida
soils represents the highest priced formulae used in South
ern States, ats stated bey Mr. Brantley, of the Black st 3
Manufacturing Companys, Blackshear, Georgia, testified
im that cuse that the Values of the formule used in Florida
(fol 472) were about double those used in Georgia (TR
Mines 1 ard c): in the sine ease Witness Nickerson,
Citpus grower, Tampa, Florida. stated that the cost of
fertilizer used jn the CHTOs groves ranges from S64m) gy,
S401 per wet ten. as colnpared with the average value of
enimercial fertilizer of 828.00 per ton CP. Ro pp. M2, perry
Wher ith Tampa, Florida, ona Dbie Mth itstant, I had oceusian
to leveok Ver number af pean Vottohers emering fer
talizer purchased this sevtasenti, cried the fertilizer for eitrus
culture was on basis of &t6.00 per net ton, and for vegetable
formulae S47.0n) per ton, cash basis. Those Were Wagan
Prices! That was fertilizer hauled from the factors at
Tamipes It Was the f oy I PPTice, factory, (Tes TS oo old }
Ifel 474) Cross examination
I referres] with approval te that feature of the decision
of the Ihterstate (Comimeree (omission in the Blackshear
vase announcing higher rates in Florida than Just north of
Florida, In the Blackshear case the differential, dont line
Over sitivle lite, is SO) cont. peer ton The hitTors link we
are new proposing Varies: at will ray around 4 conte. I
thenk thee Commission erred im the Blackshear case in
adepting any such seale for that territory, and | think the
differential bet Ween the single line and the joint line hinu!
Was lower than it should be referred to the pecuhar
situation in Florida that ios a terminal state, and the
525
trunk lines going down into Florida are stub lines. T think
it reasonable to say | used that situation to uphold my
argument that the rates into and out of Florida should
be on a higher level than elsewhere. | am not able to
state why that principle has not been carried into passenger
rates and express rates, by the carriers. I know nothing
about passenger or express rates; | would have to know
the basis for those rates. [To am not sufficiently familiar
with the basis of the rates.
| referred to the relatively small number of fertilizer
plants in the interior on our line as compared with the
port plants. There is no question but what the port plants
net only on fertilizer, but any other manufacturing indus.
try that gets a large part of its material its raw material
by water, has an advantage to which it is entitled over
an interior manufacturing point,
“YQ. Now, Mr. Ketner, speaking of Florida’s peculiar
situation. Can you cite me to any scope of country in
Florida that is as little productive that is, as barren of
population and where your line of railroad is as expen
sive to maintain as that streteh of country from Jackson
ville to Savannah, Georgia!
"A. TL don't know of any poor section right now. But
we have got to go through that section to reach Florida.
It is gust one of those difficulties that any pioneer line has
[fol 475] to undergo, is to go through a barren territory
to get to seme territery they think might be productive.”’
That line is not still barren. We are spending consid
erable money in fostering a drainage project in that par-
ticular section, That section has alse vielded us substan
tial revenue in lumber traffic, That has not gone: we still
have some. Not many years age the center of production
of lumber on that line was right in that section. Of course
a great deal of lumber has been taken out of there, but
there is still a substantial movement of lumber out of that
territery, (Tes. 615 618.)
As to what we are doing to avoid 4th section violations
in applying the joint seale versus single seale: The 4th
section problem is one that will be eovered, as T under.
stand, in later proceedings, and we will have to give that
pen ote
f26
consideration at that time. We will no doubt run into many
4th section difficulties in that adjustment, but I] have not
undertaken to testify on that. The majority of these fer-
tilizer manufacturing points in Florida are reached di-
rectly by the respective trunk lines, and we won't have
many joint hauls. Until we have some more figures as to
the actual movement, | could not tell you as to what extent
there is joint-hanl movement, or what relation the joint
haul is te the single line haul. That will very likely come
out in the traffie test. Ofhand, 1 think the joint haul is
substantially less than the single line. My exhibit 215
covers the revenue per ton per mile of road on intrastate
as well as interstate traffie.
The operation of the mileage seale which the carriers
have here submitted would cause advances in charges in
the State of North Carolina on materials no® moving on
hasis of O° of the fertilizer rate, loaded in S0,000 or ex
cess car: that would represent LO increase. Instead of
taking 1. off of those fluures. | would not be willing to
say offhand that under the level which T have submitted,
charges in South Carolina, intrastate, would be advanced ;
I have not examined the exhibits to see that. There would
probably be a general increase in the State of South Caro
[fol 476) lina on fertiliver, | think that would be true
alexo of the State of Georgia; the Georgia rates are very
low, IT will accept vour statement that it would be true
as the whole of the State of Alabama. I was dealing with
intrastate, | think it ix a natoral assumption that it is
true as to all of the State of Mississippi, TI don't know if it
would be true of all of Louisiana east of the Mississippi
River. | would not sav that there would result advances in
interstate rates, one State to another, in many instances,
Beeause, T think seme of the previous witnesses testified
a large part of our interstate adjustment, in fact, that
part of the adjostment moving the preponderance of the
fertilizer tonnage ix now on the Reveter scale, the «scale
the earners are proposing in this procemding. (Tex. Gis
621.)
“Q@ Mr. Ketner, in vour connection with this matter,
has it gone oniv with vour effert to prepare certain testi.
mony for use in this case as affecting Florida, or have you
527
had any part in the determination of the policy which has
been engendered in the determination to propose the Roy-
ster scale?
“A. T have had very little to do with the several con-
ferences and detailed handling of this adjustment. I have
had something to do with the poliey question, as to whether
we would use the Royster scale as a fair basis, and IT have
just gotten into the case in detail in the last week.’’
lam not familiar enough with the operation of the sug
vested rate level in the States of South Carolina, Georgia,
Alabama and Mississippi to agree that there would be gen-
eral advances in all of those States. That result was taken
into account by us, however. We considered what we were
proposing would bring about, aw not unreasonably high
general level, To have not admitted that there would be
general advances in the States named; T did not have any
figures before me, T knew of course in any general level
ling process, there must necessarily be increases and ad
vances. TP did not know definitely, but it was the natural
assumption that there would he except North Carolina,
on fertilizer.
[fol 4771 °*Q. Then, finally, T will put the question this
way, So far as vou were concerned with the pohey of it,
vou did not attempt to estimate the extent to which the
figures that vou songht approval of, would generally ad
Vanee the transportation costs on fertilizer in the South?
‘A. That could only be determined, Mr. Cotterill, by
revenue tests, T think.”*
Idid not think what we were proposing would do violence
to the fertilizer trafie as a whole. It would be a great sur-
prise tome if it vielded ander my figures an increased rev-
enue of about $1,000,000 por vear. Concerning South Car.
olina: The rates prior to the reduction for 1924 by the State
Commission were much higher than the Royster scale, and
the South Carolina Commission at first agreed to apply
the Royster seale. They actually issued a cirenlar on it,
and Tissned a tariff? employing the Royster scale for Seath
Carolina application; the farmers complained of increased
ecarload minimum from 20,0000 to 30,000) pounds, and the
State Commission withdrew their cirenlar. T canceled my
528
tariff, which had net gone into effect. They very readily
accepted the Royster seale as being reasonable then, In
Alabama, the State Commission has made violent redue-
tions within the past year, and every effort was made to
bring about vielent reductions in the State of North Caro-
lima. LE think that it is true when you go to considering any
question of revenue you should take the situation existing
prior to this campaign carried on in the various States,
My recollection of our instructions is that the traffic test
will be predicated both upon the rates we are asking and
those now in effect in South Carolina and Alabama, and
the rates in foree prior toe this reduction.
As to whether that circular mention was issued by the
South Carolina Commission without any formal hearing
or complaint: [tis hard to determine if proceedings before
that Commission are formal or informal. My recollection
is there had been a sc-called formal hearing. To may be in
error there, (Tes, 020-007.)
(Witness excused )
[fol 478) BLOW. Rieriase was thereupon called as a wit
ness and-— been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination:
lam the freight traffie manager of the Florida East
(Coast Railway Company. | desire te make a very brief
statement as to the posithon of the Florida Bast Const
Railway Company in this case.
I understand the Floruda rates are not directly in issue
in this ease, and that the decision of the Commission in this
case will net go to the measure of the Flornda rates. Under
the laws of Florida the State Commission cannot increase
or reduce the rates anti after a puble hearing. It has
been aniversally agrem! that the rates in Florida, on ac
count of the conditions existing im that State, should be on
a somewhat higher basis than the ratee in the States far
ther north. For that reason it has seemed to us that it
would not be appropriste at thie time to offer any sugges
tion as to what the rates in Floruda ought to be It is our
feeling that before making any suggestion ax to the Flonda
529
rates we should first know, what the rates interstate and
intrastate will be in the States farther north. That is our
position, so far as suggesting at this time any intrastate
rates.
Now, in reference to the proposal of the so-called stand-
ard lines in making the rates on fertilizer into Florida inter-
state on a mileage basis, we would like to express our views,
so far as that business would affect the Florida Kast Coast
Railway Company. We have no fertilizer plants located
on the Florida Hast Coast Railway. All of the fertilizer
that we receive is delivered to us on an interchange track
at Jacksonville, We don't serve Jacksonville. Our read
begins at the end of the St. Johns River, We ret into Jack-
sonville on the Terminal Railway Company,
“By Mr. Burr:
[fol 479) **Q. Mr. Kirtland, the Painter Fertilizer Com
pany isin South Jacksonville, is it not?
“AL Practically extinct, Mr. Burr. They do practically
no business now, and TE did not think that their operations
were of sufficient amount to be of any moment in this case.”"
The Florida Bast Coast Railway goes to the north bank
of the St. Johns River, but not into the City of Jacksonville,
We have a terminal in the Cuy of Jacksonville; we oper:
ate over the Jacksonville Terminal Company; part owner
on an operating basis. ‘Phat is, passenger terminal.
We have a freight terminal, the Hast Coast Terminal
Company, butin order wot toomix this railroad up. bam
speaking primarily now to fertilizer, and that comes to us
over the other lines on the joint interchange,
Qur records show that 90 per cent, approximately GO
per cent, of the fertilizer we have originates on the rails of
other lines at) Jacksonville. Transported by those lines
an average of from 3 to Td miles, Now, it is our feeling
that a reasonable rate should be established for the hand
ling oof fertihvzer delivered to us at Jacksonville. The
bulk of the business originates on other lines in Jackson
Ville; pave the transportation charge for delivery to our
line. After having fixed a reasonable rate for the transpor
{ation of that ‘0 percent of the business, we do not feel
34-166
530
that we should be called upon to absorb out of our carnings
the expense of a fertilizer plant located somewhat farther
north. (Tes. 628-631.)
We get our mileage rates from Palm Beach on all of the
business the Seaboard gives us.
We have not been able to bring ourselves to a point where
we can see Why we should be called upon to shrink our earn-
itugs, in order to take the place of a disadvantageous location
on some other line. Now, in the proposal of the so-called
standard lines to establish through rates inferstate to points
[fol 480) on the Mast Coast, itis merely an effort on their
part to go along with the first phrase of ‘ta dead-level of
freight rates’? without regard to those fundamentals that
have heretofore been regarded as of prime importance in
making fremht rates. Tt has generally been understood that
the rates in the South should be on a somewhat different
level from the rates in the Bast, and the rates in the West
should be on a somewhat diferent level from the rates in
the Fast and South, but the fact is that the conditions on
the Florida Mast Coast are so radically different from the
operating conditions on any of the other Southeastern car
riers, We cannet understand why there should be a dead
level of rates. And so far as that is coneerned, our con
ditions are racieally different from what they are on any
other Florida fine. So that being true, it has seemed to
us that the rates prescribaad for the use of the Flonda Fast
Coast Railway Company should be based on the conditions
of the Florida Fast Coast Railway Company, and net in
conformity with some preconceived idea of a dead level
or uniformity of rates based on conditions in some other
section of the ceuntry, and under operating conditions that
do net apply at all to the Florida Mast Coast. The rates
on the Florida Bast Coast on fertilizer and the other lines
are the same.
Those intrastate rates were presertied for our use by
the Florida Railroad Commission. We get the same rates,
whether intra. or interstate,
The rates were preseriband for eur use by the Florida
Commission, and we have alway« applied those same rates
both interstate and intrastate, with «ome certain excep
tions, bat fertilizer was not one of the exceptions, That
was voluntary on our part. Se, «o far as interstate traffie
531
is concerned, | have not sought to distinguish the situation
on the Florida East Coast from that of other roads, because
the rates were the same, and we did not seek to distinguish
it now, We want to have the same rates on interstate as on
|fol. 481] intrastate now.
“YQ. Do you want te have different rates from other
roads!
“A. You mean, do | want our rates to be different from
the so-called standard tines?
“©. Fea.
“ALT do not care what rates they accept. Tam only
speaking now for the Florida Mast Coast."? (Tes. 631-634.)
As | have said, IT do not feel in position yet to recommend
any rates, for the reason that it has been universally agreed
heretofore that the rates in Florida should be on a some-
What higher basis than in States farther north, and we
don't know yet what rates are going to be preseribed for
the States farther north. After that has been determined,
the Florida Commission will then call a hearing, and every
body will be given an opportunity to express themselves
at that time, and we will suggest to them what we consider
a reasonable basis of rates in view of the rates preseribed
for the use of the lines north of Florida. No matter what
was prescribed north of Florida, we would not necessarily
propose something higher in Florida. But we do not feel
that this is the appropriate time to make a specific recom.
mendation, Well, to be perfectly frank, we think the pres.
ent seale of rates prescribed in Florida is fundamentally
on the wrong basis, and what we have in mind when called
upon to suggest a line of rates to suggest some rather fun
damental changes in that basis, Now, for example, it is
our thought that the rates at present preseribed by the
Florida Commission for short distances are too high, and
for long distances, Tom low. And what we have in mind,
suggesting a senile of rates predicated on lower rates for
short distances up to 10 miles, and higher than the present
rates for distances grenter than that.
On G) per cent of our fertilizer, the average haul is 375
miles, and we have always thought it was exceedingly un-
[fol 4s)! yust for the Florida Commission to require us to
532
haul that for a car haul of 10 cents a ton a mile, while you
would haul the fertilizer one way, and the empty car the
other, We think that you, Mr. Burr, will agree that the
rate is too low,
“Hy Com. Mastman :
"YQ. Now, on interstate trafic. Whatever the interstate
rates are, do you join in the proposal of the other carriers
with respect to interstate rates?
“A. DP have undertaken, Vir. Commissioner, to make our
poosition plain in that Thes have suguested the Roy ster
seale intrastate,
“+. Interstate also
A. Well, we want to take it as we come to it. We are
hot prepared at this time to join in asking for the Royster
seale in Florida, for the reason that we would prefer to
wuitandsee, ° ° °
“Q. (Interrupting) Tam net talking about intrastate
lam talking about the rates whieh apply te your interstate
traffic, We have yet that rivist here naw
At this time we are net asking fer any change in our
interstate rates. We don’t think they ought to remain as
they are, but TP said, ot this time we are not asking for any
change, We are going te state aur prosition after the Com
mission decides what would ey fair and reasonable rates in
the Stgtes north of Flargla
Our position is that our rates should be the same, whether
interstate or intrastate. We want the combination hasis on
Jacksonville presers el: amd we want our factors south of
Jacksonville the same as iitrastate
We want the combination on interstate business, We
want our full combination on interstate, and not 10 per cent
less than that combination, as would exrst if rt was handed
to us in intrastate commerce, What To mean to sav, that
we wanted the same rates from that interchange track,
whether it ormginated?d at Jacksonville, Mlackshear, or Al
twany, hewause the transpertation eomditens are exactly the
[fel 485] same with u«, amd we cannot see upon what
grounds we shenuld charge a man at Jacksonville one rate
ami aman at Blackshear another rate, and aman at Albany
another rate, amd the man from Atlanta another rate
I do not know that I understand what you have in your
mind, but I will state this, that it is another one of those
cases where the Coast Line and the Seaboard get into con-
troversy with you and their shippers, and they went there
on the Class P, and made some compromises by reductions
to avoid lawsuits, and when you issued the order, you made
it apply on the East Coast. We applied on intra-, did not
apply on interstate. We went into court; we did not win
on that order, for the reason the Florida Statutes under
which we were proceeding provided that any order of the
Florida Commission shall be considered sufficient for ;:rim».
facie evidence of its reasonableness, and they said we had
not affirmatively proved that it was unreasonable, because
the experts of the Commission and the experts of the Rail-
road disagreed,
They had to accept your order as prima facie evidence of
its reasonableness. They reached the conclosion in that
proceeding that we were making 10 per cent on that traffic,
but it was not, because we were not even paying interest
on our bonds, and nothing on the stock. That order said
that we were making 10 per cent on the lowest class traffic
that we were handling, that paid about 8 cents a car mile,
and the fact was at that time we were not doing anything
better than earning operating expenses on the whole traffic,
including the hugh class traffic. (Tes. 634-639.)
1 did not mean to bring up all of these questions, Mr.
Burr, in answering yours, but [hope that | have made my-
self clear in that our transpertation conditions are identi
calls the siithie, hocnuse the business is all delivered on ohe
track, and ito ois not intended as a device to enhanee our
[fol 484] revenue, but itor intended te represent the true
rate based on transportation conditions.
Is is my contention that we have nothing to do with the
Seaboard or the Coast Line, but that our rates should be
based on our operating conditions, and that our operating
conditions are so dissimilar to those lines that any rate that
might be found reasonable for these roads wonld not neces-
sarily be reasonable rates for our road. That is not to say
that we are necessarily entitled to higher rates than they
are. Tf our operating conditions justify it, vou might make
it}ower, But what | am trying to convey to your mind is
534
that we do net appreve of this dead level of rates, and
uniformity without regard to your operating conditions.
“Q. Well, if we are going to give regard to operating
conditions, you have got to have something to compare
them with. And in Florida you have got comparison right
there. Now, are your operating conditions worse than that
of the Seaboard Air Linet
**A. Yes, sir.
“Q. You have higher traffic density?
“A. Yes sir; and a higher operating cost.
“YQ Amd a higher passenger traffic, haven't vou!
"A. Yes, sir: and it is confined to a class of traffic that
tecessitates a Very high cost for handling, and we do not
have the phosphate rock, lumber and naval stores moving
in heavy volume throughout the vear the same as the Coast
Line amd the Seaboard have.
"Q. Is net your net operating revenue per mile of road
higher than that either of the Coast Line or Seaboard in
Florida!
"A. Well, atid not make that comparison before coming
to this hearing, Mero Commissioner, But LT would be very
glad to make that comparison and furnish it to vou in this
case
“Com. Fastman: | will be glad toe have it.’
ffel 485) The Atlantic Coast Line and the Seaboard Air
Line have a very large tonnage of phosphate reek, meowe
bookding material, forest products and naval «teres moving
threnahwut the veur It teves in cars ta practical eapuicity
ef the equgpment. That enables them to have unmform
techanical operating comditions throughout the year, They
are, therefore, mot <a much stubject to fuetuation in operat
itty coms tions, atul costs as a railromd whe hus practically
nene of that class of traffie, Our traffic is composed almost
the front aml vegetable traffic, and the yuan
ertelusively of
senger traffie
Then, within the past two years that has been supple
mented very largely by building materials, For the past
twee years the ereetion of epertrmens? houses and hotels has
practically doubled each vear, and it looks as if it will
tlouble this year over what the total capuicity war last year,
039
Now, it just so happens that our fruit and vegetable traffic
and peak passenger traflic comes along about the same time,
And, I will tell you something that even you probably have
not. “© * * ‘Phat is net true of the Coast Line too, to the
sume extent because their fruit and vegetable traffic comes
later, Oranges possibly are moving out in volume at that
time, but not vegetable traffic. Now, then, here is a develop-
ment that may not have oecurred to you. Our building
operations now are heavier in the winter time than they are
in the summer, due to the fact that during the winter
months the skilled laborers from the far North, in the
Northern territories where it is cold, and there is not much
building operation, they come down there, and they are en-
abled to get the skilled mechanics in larger numbers, and
vet better results out of it, so that it gives the building ma-
terials, and fruit and vegetable traffic, and the passenger
traffic, within a period of about three months. Now, as you
well know, we have to make our estimates, and we have to
be prepared to handle it, the maximum that business that
comes Within two or three months. And a condition might
[fol. 486] develop overnight that would upset every esti-
mite that has been made, and that the growers themselves
cannot tell hardly from week to week just what the move-
ment is going to he the following week, due to cold weather,
which will retard it, and warm weather, whieh will hasten
it, and a little cold weather kills it, and a little rain drowns
it out, Now, that means that we have vet to be equipped
to handle the maximum. Now, what are we up against
right now? While Wwe have had a hiv inerease in earnings
this past wear, we have had a decrease in net earnings.
We had congested conditions, and everyone knows that it is
expensive to operate under congested conditions, where you
have more business than you can reasonably and promptly
handle. Now, as a result of that, we are making large
capital expenditures to double-track the line, to take care
of the peak business of two or three months, and all of that
oyuipment, cars, engines and double track, will be idle for
nine months. Now, do you know of anv railroad in Florida
that operates under any condition even approaching that?
(Tes. 629-644.)
a emennmes
“Q. IL know this too, that the Seaboard Air Line thought
that the business was attractive enough on the Florida East
Coast Railroad to build a railroad down there to divide up
the business with you.
“A. There is a ease, too, where | think they are using
mighty poor judgment, because [ can tell you that they
built 70 miles of railroad there from Okeechobee to West
Palm Beach, where they will never handle a pound of
freight, and never produce a pound of freight, and T don't
understand that to be good judgment.”’
Now the failure to produce these forest products that 1
mentioned that are produced on the Atlantic Coast Line,
makes it very necessary that we haul lumber and the like
down the East Coast in heavy quantities, according to your
own statement upon which you get the long hanl, and
i fol. 487] 12th Section violation on every bit of it.
“Q. That is because you are hauling from Georgia on
an old condemned rate?
“A. Not condemned by the Commission.”’
Jacksonville, geographically is the natural gateway for
the Florida Fast Coast. Lalo not know that vou would eall
| our hauling of coment enormous, but there is a very large
| building operation geing on oon the East Coast, 1 know
| that the coment people say that the biggest per cent of in
crease in consumption of cement in Florida is on the Bast
Coast Railroad. (Tes. 644-645.)
I understand that the bigwest per cent in the South, next
te Nerth Carolina, is in Florada. UT did not know, further,
that they have showed by satistios that the loading on our
line ts heavier than on nN other line in the South, but I
will aceept that. Ldid net know that they showed that the
average loading on our line for practically two vears was
heavier than in any other territery in the country, on
cement, but Twill aceept it, PE think it is true,
“Ry Mr. Teneh:
"O. Mr. Kirtland, vou made the statement twice that it
had been universally agreed that rates to Florida should
be somewhat higher than the rates generally in the Seuth
537
east, I think the Florida Commission would very much
like for you to modify that word universally agreed.
“A. Well, | can quote the Florida Commission as my
authority.
“Mr. Burr: No use to quarrel with him about it, let him
say it.
“The Witness: | will quote the Florida Commission as
good authority; they have stated that repeatedly in their
Annual Reports, and otherwise.
‘By Mr. Burr:
“Q. Have you read the last Annual Report?
‘A. | have not seen it.
“Mr. Burr: Well, | commend it to you.’ (Tes. 646-7.)
(Witness excused.)
[fol. 488) FL AL Bourke was therenpon called as a witness
and, having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination:
lam connected with the Nashville, Chattanooga & St,
Louis Railways; | have had a number of years’ expericnee
in traffic matters, particularly in connection with the traftie
department of that company and | oam familiar with the
mijustment of fertilizer rates in Tennessee,
Inomy testimony Twill deal particularly with that situa-
tion, TP have prepared a series of exhibits, numbered 220
to 235 melusive, which | desire to offer in evidence at this
time.
(The stutetnents were thereupon received in evidence,
and marked ** Respondents’ exhibits Nos. 220 to 233. im
clusive, Witness Burke."*)
The movemnt of fertilizer from manufacturing points
in ‘Tennessee is under speeitic rates with the exception of
rates from Chattanooga to CN, OL & T. Po stations, and
for those the mileage seale is in effect, and with that excep-
tion the fertilizer in ‘Tennessee moves under specific com-
modity rates.
a eeeeeeeeiamneenea
538
We have had no proceedings before the Interstate Com-
merece Commission involving the general level of fertilizer
rates, but when we attempted to increase the rates on fer
tilizer in Tennessee, in line with Ex Parte 74 increases of
1020, the Tennessee Railroad Commission sustained the in
creased rates on fertilizer and a number of other com-
modities, and they set that matter down for hearing at
Nashville, Tennessee, on November ith and 12th, pen,
At the hearing before the Tennessee Commission Mr. T. M.
Henderson, Commissioner of Nashville Traffie Bureau ap
peared on behalf of the Nashville fertilizer shippers, ard
Nashville is the largest fertilizer manufacturing peint in
the State of Tennessee. The average annual movement
from Nashville of fertilizer ts approximately 175,000 tons.
Mr. Menzies’ exhibit shows SOOO) tones, but our investiga
fol. 480} tion developed an actual average movement of
17510) tons, intrastate and interstate
Mr. Henderson appeared before the Tennessee Commis
sion and stated as follows:
“Mr, Commissioners, | am representing the Nashville
shippers ot all of these commendities ts olved in this sus
pension, except the fertilizer shippers, who told me that
they have ne complaint about the Tennessee rates on fer
tilizer. So far as Nashville shippers are concerned, and
no objection to the increase prov tle of course it is made
general, They have ne com] laint about the fertilizer «itu
ation.”
And then he further goes on to say:
“Sometime age | had a conference with one of two of
the fertilmer poople, aml they stated at that time that the
Tennessee fertilizer rates were, they thought, fairly in line
wih other rates on fertilizer, and that they did not oppose
the inerease in those rates Personally, | never made any
examination ef them Thev sand they were satixfied, and
that was all | wanted them to be, so I did net go any
further." (Tes. 647-659.) :
In my exhibits I have umdertaken to show the general
aijustment of the interstate amd intrastate rates in Ten
nesses, as at present in effect, amd as it will be ander the
339
adjustment now proposed by the carriers. IT have shown
on my first exhibit the location of the fertilizer factories
in the State; they are Nashville, Tennessee, Chattanooga,
Tennessee, Knoxville, Memphis and Mount Pleasant, Ten-
nessee,
I will first take up the individual situation of the N.C.
& St. L. Railway, because the Nashville, Chattanooga & St.
Louis Railway operates the greater distance of any line
in Tennessee. Our mileage in Tennessee is 926 miles, and
that is greater than the mileage of any other individual line
in that State.
My Exhibit No, 221 shows the rates from Nashville, Ten-
nessee to Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis Railway
[fol. 490) agency stations. Prior to the fall of 1899, no
specifie commodity rates were provided on fertilizer from
Nashville to N.C. & St. L. Railway stations. In the fall
of 18900 any-<quantity commodity rates were established on
the Class N basis. Class N was the lowest class rate that
we had over our line, Class N applied on earload ship-
ments at that time, of sand, gravel, lime, brick and other
commodities, and we took those Class N rates and applied
them on fertilizer, anyquantity, from Nashville te N.C.
& St. L. stations. Now, rates originally established on this
basis have continued in effeet until this time, to stations
south of Nashville, Tennessee, except that they have been
increased under General Order 28 and Ex Parte 74. and
reduced 10 per cent, under Docket 18203. From stations
west of Nashville, they continued on the basis originally
established on this hasis have continued in effect until this
time, to stations south of Nashville, Tennessee, except that
they have been increased under General Order 2s and hx
Parte 74, and reduced 10 per cent, under Docket 13243.
From stations west of Nashville, they continued on the
basis originally established until April, 1922, when they
were reduced under the 1308 revision.
It will be noted that from this exhibit, that we take ina
number of cases, substantial reductions in our present rates.
For example, to Murfreesboro, Tennessee, from Nashville
there is a substantial movement of fertilizer, and the
present rate is SISO We proposed $1.58. There js a sub
stantial movement from Nashyv ile to Fosters ile, and we re
540
duced the present rate from $2.25 to $1.80; to Tullahoma,
Tennessee, there is also a substantial movement, and the
present rate will be reduced from $2.59 to $2.14. To our
branch line points we have also made reductions, and there
is a movement to these branch line points, On the first page
is shown the Shelbyville Branch. The present rate from
Nashville to Shelbyville, Tennessee, is $2.59; under the pro-
[fol. 491] posed scale the rate to Shelbyville will be $2.03.
On page 2 is shown the Sequatchie Valley Branch. ‘To Jas.
per, Tennessee, on this branch, there is a considerable move
ment, and the rate is reduced from $3.4 to $2.82 per ton.
To Pikeville, Tennessee, there is a larger movement than to
Jasper, that is a point at the end of the branch. There the
rate is reduced from $5.40 per ton to $3.27 per ton.
Now, on our Sparta Branch, and which is a mountain
branch, there is a large movement. For example, to Man.
chester, Tennessee, there is a big movement, and the rate is
reduced from $2.59 to $2.57. Sparta, Tennessee, is practi
cally at the end of the branch, or near the top of the moun-
tain, and there is a substantial movement of fertilizer from
Nashville 4 Sparta, and there the rate is reduced from
S172 tos
Our ae movement from that branch is lumber and
coal, but there ix some sweet potatoes grown, and some to
hacco grown on the Sparta Branch, but I think the fertilizer
must be osed op there mostly for growing corn.
On page 3 is shown our Hantsville Branch. That branch
is a branch which we operate with 20 miles of River trans
fer between Hobbes Island and Guntersville to Albertsville
aml Beas on that branch, seuth of the Tennessee River
there is a sub«tantial movement of fertilizer from Nashville,
and the rate is redneed to those points from £2.42 to €3.27
“Q. Do vou propose to apply straight mileage on that
branch, or are you going to have constructed mileage for
the river crossing?
A. Tt depends, Mr. Commissioner, upon what we get
from 16%. The present proposal i« straight mileage
seale.*’
These rates are figure! ont on straight mileage. To
points on what is known as the Middle Tennessee and Ala
541
bama Branch, abbreviated to read M. T. and A. Branch,
there is a substantial movement of fertilizer, and to Taft,
Tennessee, for example, the rate was reduced from $3.15 to
{ fol, 492] $2.82. To Capshaw, Alabama, the rate is reduced
from $3.15 to $2.93. The next division shown is the W. &
A. Division. That is operated as our Atlanta Division, it
is the Western & Atlantic Railroad, which is leased from the
State of Georgia, and the rates to stations on our Atlanta
Division were originally made in competition with the rates
from Charleston and Savannah to stations in Georgia, and
we have considered those rates on a very low level, There
will be some increases, but the increases, as will be noted,
are not substantial. (Tes, 650-654.)
Now, it will be noted also that there are increased from
Nashville to Chattanooga and Gadsden Group, Huntsville,
and Atlanta, Georgia. Now, these are commonly known
as junction or common points in the South, and the rates
to these points were originally made in line with the rates
from the Ohio River. In fact, Nashville was made a dollar
a ton, and the rates from Louisville, Ohio River Combina-
tion at that time, was recognized at Nashville, and they were
placed on differential basis in line with the Ohio River
Crossings, and that provided very low rates from Nashville
to these Southeastern Common points. Now, subsequent to
the original issuance of these rates, the rates from Ohio
River Crossings were increased, but we made no corres-
ponding increase in the rate from Nashville, so Nashville
has been depressed under the Ohio River Crossings.
Pages 4 and 5 of my exhibit shows the rates from Nash-
ville to N. CL & St. L. stations west of Nashville, Tennessee.
Rates to these stations were reduced under the revision of
Docket 1805, the Mississippi Valley revision which Mr.
Chadwick explained in some detail yesterday.
My Exhibit No, 222, which | offered in connection with
this Mississippi Valley section of my Exhibit 221, shows the
rates on fertilizer from Nashville to West Tennessee, that
would have been in effect had the revision not been made
{fol 492] in 1903, or in other words, the exhibit shows the
modern equivalent of the rates in effect prior to the 1303
revision contrasted with the present rates, and also com.
pared with the rates we are now proposing. It will be
42
noted from this exhibit that we have made some substan-
tial reductions in 1922 in the rates to this territory from
Nashville. And that the proposed rates in a number of
cases do not even equal the rates that were in effect prior
to April, 1922.
The rates that are shown in the first column on that ex-
hibit, being the rates prior to 1. & S. 1508 revision are the
rates that were in effect at the time when Mr. Henderson
made the statement which | quoted a minute age, before
the Tennessee Railroad Commission. And these rates from
Nashville to our other stations that Thave just pointed out,
Where we make these reductions, thes were afso in effect,
My Exhibit No. 225 shows the rates from Nashville to sta
tiots on lines other than the N.C) & St. L. Railway in Ten
nesses, The first three pages cover the situation on the
Louisville & Nashville Railroad. It will be noted that the
changes in the Louisville & Nashville rates are practically
the same as those of the NO. & St. L. Page No. 4 shows
rates from Nashville, Tennessee, to Tennessee Central sta-
tions, In this connection, | desire to call attention to the
fact that the Tennessee Central Railway has notified the
Southern Freight Association that oo was their intention to
apply the short line scale over its line, and that it would not
be their Per prrnee tae ask Fourth Seetion relief in connection
with the seale of rates as finally adopted for application be
tween the various praitits in the Seuthern Territery,
The Tentiwassee Central has» generally beon regarded as a
rather weak line. The Commission has given at Fourth See.
tion relief because of its financial comdition., Tt was covered
by an order in LC. CL Deeket O10), the Murfreeshoro Case,
It appears from page 4 of thos exhibit this proposal will be
{fol 494) a rather sulbetantial reduction in rates on the Ten
fiesases Central Railreond j thon 't know aif that read is get
ting stronger, or whether exeeptions are being made in fer.
tilizer, Pages 5 amd 6 «show the rates from Nashville te
Mobile & Ohio Ratlroad and Hines Central Railroad sta
tiens in West Tennessee, These rates are the result of the
(Commission - decision nh 1a, and represent the Valley re
vision. This was explained by Mr Sheppard and Mr. Chad
wick vesterday.
Page 7 shows the rates from Nashville to N OLE TP.
Railway stations, Tt will be noted that there is not a «ub
543
stantial change propose | in the rates from Nashville to
Cincinnati, New Orleans & Texas Pacific Railway stations.
Pages 8, 9 and 10 show the rates from Nashville to South-
ern Railway stations in East Tennessee. These rates have
been carried on a very low level. They were originally
established the same as from Atlanta, Georgia. Atlanta,
Georgia, to Southern Railway stations is a single line haul,
and the Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis Railway estab-
lished rates from Nashville to Southern Railway stations
for the joint haul the same as published by the Southern
Railway for their single line haul from Atlanta, Georgia.
These rates have heen a matter of complaint for the past
25 years by the Southern Railway. ‘They went so far at one
time as to appeal to the Commission to have their line elimi-
nated as a participating carrier in our tariff. But because
of a change in traffic officials, and the fact that the Southern
Railway entered Nashville at one time with their own line
they leased the Tennessee Central for awhile—we have been
allowed to continue these rates in effect. Now, it is pro
posed to divide these rates along with the others, and it will
be noted that ina number of cases that we are proposing
reductions in the rates which have been objectionable to
the Southern Railway for this long period of years.
My Exhibit No. 254 shows the rates from Chattanooga
to Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis Railway stations.
[fol 495) ‘Phas exhibit is substantially the same as the
Nashville exhibit, and T don’t think it necessary to burden
the record with pointing out the different details,
Exhibit No, 225 shows the rates from Chattanooga, Ten
hessee, to the territory cast of Nashville, Tennessee. It js
similar to the previous exhibit, and compares present rates
on fertilizer with the rates on the proposed scale. (Tes,
648.)
Exhibit No. 226 shows the present rates on fertilizer
compared with the proposed rates from Memphis, Tennes
see, to Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis Railway sta
tions. Conditions here are similar to those at Nashville,
In other words, to stations west of Nashville the rates are
increased? because the present rates in that territory re-
flect the 1S08 revision, To stations south of Nashville the
rates are reduced. T will state, though, for the informa
tion of the Commission, T know of no movement of ferti-
lizer from Memphis to stations on the N.C, & St. L. Rail
“ me
way south of Nashville. So far as my investigation goes,
the movement of fertilizer from Memphis, as far as ‘Ten-
hessee is concerned, is confined to the western portion of the
State.
{fol 496] My Exhibit No. 227 compares the present rates
from Memphis, Tennessee, to points on lines other than
the NO CL & St. Loin the Western section of Tennessee, with
the rates on the proposed seale. There are a number of
increases in these rates because the present rates, as ex
plained before, reflect the Memphis Southwestern revision
or 1508 revision. That 1 & S. 1908) readjustment was
primarily a Fourth Section realignment of the rates.
My Exhibit 228 compares the rates from Knoxville, Ten
hessee, toa territery cast of Nashville with the rates on the
proposed basis. ‘There is, so my investigation develops, a
substantial movement of fertilizer from Atlanta, Georgia,
to Tennessee points, expecially on the line of the N.C. &
St. L. Railway, and for that reason T have shown in my kx
hiit No. 220 the present and proposed rates on fertilizer
from Atlanta to N.C) & St. L. Railway stations, When the
fertilizer factories Were originally established at Nashville,
in order to assist them in establishing their products to the
Southeast and cotton sections, the N.C. & St. L. Railway
established a low line of rates te Georgia destinations,
which were made in line with the rates from South Atlantic
Ports te the same destinations, which were, as has been
testified bere, on a very low level) After we had estab
lished these rates from Nashville southbound in order to
pacify the Atlanta shippers, or manufacturers of fertilizer,
we established northbeand to N.C. & St. L. Railway sta
tiens from Atlanta practically the same scale that we used
in publishing rates from Nashville to Georgian destinations
These rates we have always considered are on a Vers low
level, and it well be noted thatin a number of CUMS substan
tial reductions are made in the present rates,
On the first page of the exhibit will be noted that the
rates from Atlanta te statiens intertnediate to Chattanooga
{fol 497] and Nashville, that the Nashville rate is not ex
cowed. Now, prior te the revistan of the Commission in
the Murfreeshors Case, we had higher rates to these in
termediate points than to Nashville Nashville being a de
pressed point, located on the Camberland River, Under
the Commission's decision in Docket 0100, and the Fourth
7"
545
Section order issued in connection with the Murfreesboro
case, Fourth Section Order 7566, we were denied relief at
Nashville against these intermediate points, so in order to
escape the violation we reduced the rates to intermediate
points, so as te not exceed Nashville. This reduction was
made along about 1922, and while it will be noted that the
proposed rates do not substantially increase the existing
rates from Atlanta.
My Exhibit No. 280 compares the proposed rates on fer-
tilizer with the rates on coal from Clifty, Tennessee, to
stations on the N.C. & St. L. Railway intermediate to
Clifty, Tennessee, and Memplis, Tennessee, It also shows
the per car revenue on coal as contrasted with the per car
revenue on fertilizer, the latter on the basis of the pro
posed scale. Tt will be neted that in practically every in
stance that we receive a greater revenue on coal than we
would under the proposed fertilizer scale, that is, dm this
local traffic on the N.C. & St. Lo Railway in Tennessee.
That is revenue per car.
Taking the Nashville distances to Tennessee destina
tions, | would not say that coal moves substantially greater
distances than fertilizer. Nashville, Tennessee, ships ferti
lizer all up the Southern Railway, as far as Bristol, Tennes.
see. Tt has shipped all over Western Tennessee. The
weighted average haul, in my opinion, would be slightly
over 100 miles; that is, the weighted average haul in this
territory,
We do handle coal ever our Hines to Georgia points
which would be substantially longer hauls. When we be.
gin to get up inte the long hauls, the per car carnings begin
to be greater on fertilizer, because of the competition that
| fol. 408] we meet there on coal. In other words, the
Western Kentucky — the rates on coal from Western Ken
tucky mines on the Louisville & Nashville, and the Hlinois
Central, We have te meet that competitive condition in
West Tennessee, and that reduces, or holds down the rates
on coal in that territory. (Tes, 658.662.)
Exhibit No. 231 compares the rates and car earnings on
crushed stone with the rates and per car earnings on the
proposed scale on fertilizers. Tt will be noted that the per
ear earnings on stone is only slightly less than the per car
earnings on the proposed scale on fertilizer, Now, this
35—— 106
546
crushed stone is worth about $1.50 f, o. b. the quarries. It
is used in Tennessee for road-building purposes, and these
rates have been reviewed by the Tennessee Commission
and have not been condemned, 1 could not say that they
have been specifically approved, but they have never con.
demned the measure of these rates on crushed stone. Now,
this is not pulverized limestone, to which Mr. Orr called
attention this morning with Mr. Drescher. This is stone
known as crushed stone, and is used for road-buildipg pur
poses in Tennessee,
Exhibit No, 232 compares the per car earnings on cement
from Nashville, Tennessee, to Nashville, Chattanooga &
St. Louis Railway stations, with the per car earnings on
fertilizer. In filing this exhibit | wish to call your attention
to the fact that the rates [ show here on cement from Nash
ville are the present rates. The carriers are proposing
revised rates on cement, and also the shippers have a scale
which they are proposing on cement, and in order to re
move any question, | have used the present rates under
which cement is moving at the present time.
My Exhibit No. 233 is similar to 252 and shows the rates
on cement and per car earnings compared with fertilizer,
from Richards City, Tennessee. Richards City is a large
cement producing port on eur line, and ships to stations on
{fol 499] the N.C. & St. L. Railway.
Nashville, Tennessee is quite a large milling point, and
there is a very considerable quantity of mill products
shipped from that point; four and wheat,
I have investigated through our superintendents the
question of using cars that have been loaded with fertilizer,
and it appears to be universally reported that cars once
loaded with fertilizer caunet be loaded with any other com
meadity that woukl absorh odor within approximately 0
days. That is a car had been loaded with fertilizer, and
were loaded with four within 90 days, that the flour or
fot would absorb the ador of the fertilizer, and for that
reason the cara once loaded with fertilizer cannot agnin
be used until the odor has heen eliminated, This oder, so
I am advieed, remains in the ear after it has been cleaned
out, and jt is the judgement of our superintendents that at
least $0) days is required to rid a ear of this odor,
That i« the report I get from our superintendents, that
they must be very careful to see that no commodities loaded
547
in sacks or burlap is placed in a car that has been loaded
with fertilizer until the sulphuric acid that might have
accumulated in the eracks has evaporated, that the sul-
phurie acid Jeaks out of the fetilizer, that is, from the bur-
lap or cotton bag. There is no free sulphuric acid in the
fertilizer; | understand there is sulphuric acid used in mak-
ing acid phosphate. The sulphuric acid is used with the
phosphate rock to make acid phosphate.
**By Mr. Cotterill:
“Q. Well, was it your impression that the acid phosphate
possesses those qualities which Mr. Gwathmey assumed
were possessed by acid?
‘A. This is the drainage out of the acid phosphate that
is loaded into the car, Mr. Cotterill.
“Q. Drainage of what?
{fol. 500) ** A. The acid, so 1 am advised by our superin-
tendents.
*Q. Mr. Burke, acid phosphate is a dry material; there
is no drainage from acid phosphate. 1] think perhaps there
is a confusion there of some sort.”’ (Tes. 662-065.)
To clear that point, T had an understanding from our
operating people, that they recognize that when a car has
been loaded with fertilizer, that it cannot safely be used
thereafter for the shipment of flour, and meal, and things
of that sort, in sacks, for approximately 90 days.
With respect to this matter of minimum weight, and the
inclusion of various articles in the fertilizer list as pro-
posed, the statement made by Mr. Ketner in regard to that
matter, coincides exactly with our view. That is, we do not
wish to commit ourselves to a continuous application of the
specific list indefinitely, In other words, conditions may
change, and the carriers may want to add some more com.
modities to the fertilizer list, or some of the commodities
should be climinated from the list. T have particularly in
mind the jfem of cottonseed meal, and as to minimum
weights, if is onr view that the classifieation minimum
should be used in connection with the fertilizer list. (Tes,
666-067.)
548
Cross-eXxamination :
We have not as yet fully Sma the rates that will
be applied to Tennessee River Landings. There is a move-
ment to the landings on the Tennessee River, but until we
have had an opportunity to confer or correspond with the
boat lines, we would ask not to put in that statement. Be-
tween now and the next hearing we will prebably have sutf-
ficient time for determining the measure of such rates as
we suggest. | will say, that it had been the intention to
include in the traffic test the movement to the River
Landings.
“Q. Tn respect to this matter of the subsequent use of
ears in which fertilizer has once been loaded, did your in.
{fol. S01) formant make distinction whatsoever as between
the different articles which are loosely called fertilizer?
Take, for instance let us take nitrate of seda, kainit, acid
phosphate, a considerable variety of articles in the list, con
stituling a large paart of the total tonnage have no odor at
all, have they f
“A. tam net an expert on this odor busimess. | gave
you the souree of my information, Mr, Cotterill, that that is
the report T obtained from my superintendents on investi
xution.”’
1 am net familiar with the loading of evanimid fertilizer
material, As far as you know, it does not put any odor in
a car.
Judging by the tonnage statements as [ have seen, the
principal movement in my territory is commercial fertilizer
and acid phosphate. | would judge that those are the fer
tilizers which our operating people have dealt with, from
the information IT have obtained from the tonnage state
ments, (Tes. 667.670.)
“Ry Mr. Cotterill:
“Y Mr. Burke, what do you understand commercial fer
tilizer to be, ax distinguished from the things that I was
enumerating?
“A. Twas going by the billing: what is billed as complete
fertilizer, and what is billed as acid phosphate, and so on."’
549
Complete fertilizer is nothing in the world but a mixture
of one or the other, or maybe two or three of the articles
that 1 described; put together in a hopper, and mixed up.
1 would not be in a position myself to testify that it is
only as to tankage, and in rare instances of fish scraps, that
there is any odor at all in the movement of fertilizer not of
my personal knowledge.
Taking Exhibit 231 here, where I compare crushed stone
with fertilizer, the earnings per car: It is, generally, a fact
that we load that crushed stone in epen top equipment,
**@. That is around 22 tons dead weight to the car there,
of crushed stone, is it not?
{fol. 502] ** A. I don’t know what the dead weight is, Mr.
Orr, in that."’
We have got 45 tons of stone going in there, but as to
whether, in our fertilizer, we have got about 18 ton ear, I
couldn't tell vou; IT don’t know. (Tes. 670-672.)
(Witness excused.)
J. 0. Ginn was thereupon called as a witness and, having
been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direet examination:
My name is J. O. Gill, and Tam employed by the Gulf
Mobile & Northern Railway Company, with headquarters
at Mobile, Alabama, as freight traffie manager, which posi-
tion T have held since 1922, having been connected with the
properties prior thereto in the traffic department in various
capacities, Prior to coming with these companies | was
with the general freight ofiee of the Hinois Central at Mem-
phis. The Birmingham & Northwestern, and the Gulf, Mo-
bile & Northern Railway Companies are here seeking au-
thority to meet the rates at the junction points, and to
establish, publish and maintain rates to local stations on
these lines 50 cents per ton higher than the rates suggested
or established for trunk line application.
1 wonld like to offer at this time a series of seven Ex-
hibits, subject to any objection, of course.
550
(The statements were thereupon received in evidence and
marked ** Respondents’ Exhibits Nos. 234 to 240, inelu-
sive, Witness Gill.’’)
Exhibit 254 is a blue print showing the physical and
geographic location of these lines and the territory served,
as well as truak line connections. The Birmingham &
Northwestern Railway Company extends from Jackson,
Tennessee, in a generally northerly direction, is 49 miles
long, and is in competition with strong trunk lines at Jack-
sen, Bells, and Dyersburg. The territory traversed by this
[fol SUS] line was without railroad transportation. The
necessity for such transportation was recognized by the
business interests, a company organized and the railroad
built in order to serve this local territory. This line is
largely dependent upon the local traffic to make its operat-
ing expenses. The Gulf, Mobile & Northern constructed in
sections, as lumber roads, but I was dealing here with the
Birmingham & Northwestern.
The Galf, Mobile & Northern extends from Mobile, Ala
hama, to Jackson, Tennessee, in a general nertherly diree
tion, through the States of Alabama, Mississippi, and Ten-
nessee, and traverses a very sparsely settled country, which
is generally poorly developed. It competes with strong
trank lines at Mobile, Laurel, New Albany, Ackerman,
Meridian, Newton, Houston, Middleton, Tennessee, and
Jackson, Tennessee, This line and predecessor companies
were built primarily for the purpose of tapping the virgin
forests which have been and are being rapidly denuded.
Exhibit No. 255 is a list of junetion points reached by
the Birmingham & Northwestern Railway, and the Gulf,
Mobile & Northern Railroad, arranged in alphabetical and
geographical order, each road shown separately, The ex
hibit also shows lines other than these lines, which reach
the said junetion points. There is a junction point at ap-
proximately an average of every 50 miles.
The Interstate Commerce Commission, apon namerous
occasions, as well as the State Railroad Commissions of
Alabame, Mississippi and Tennessee, as [ shall point out
specifically Inter on, recognize the necessity for relief in
connection with rates to and from stations on these lines.
The Birmingham & Northern, and Gulf, Mobile & North.
ern, as a rule, do not make the rates at the junction points.
551
That is, they have not in the past. It may be that under a
mileage scheme of rates these lines would make the rates
from certain Ohio River Crossings to certain junctions, but
| fol. 504] they are here seeking authority to participate in
rates at the junction points made by trunk line applications
in cases where these lines do not make the mileage; be-
cause, as we will show a little later, they are not in a posi-
tion financially to operate rates on trunk line basis.
Exhibit 236 is a statement of rates showing the mileages,
present rates, rates proposed for trunk line application, as
well as rates proposed for these lines, reflecting 50 cents
per ton higher than proposed for trunk line application
from Ohio River Crossings, Memphis, New Orleans, and
certain typical Southeastern points.
Exhibit No. 237 is a statement showing the average reve-
nue per ton mile on fertilizer, as well as per car mile and
per car, also revenue per ton mile, per car mile, and per
ear, and basis proposed rates on fertilizer. The average
revenue on all traffic for the vear ending 1924, on the Gulf,
Mobile & Northern Railroad was 13 mills, the average reve-
nue derived from proposed rates on fertilizer would be
14.8 mills. (Tes. 672-6.)
In some respects it is true that the use of the Third
Royster Seale would in many cases produce higher than
our present rates, than if no arbitrary of 50 cents were
added to the rates that were revised under Docket 1303,
or from Ohio River Crossings, also for local application
on our line. In view of that fact, we think there is a neces-
sity for adding of the 50-cent arbitrary. The present rates
are not exactly satisfactory to us from the Ohio River Cros-
sings, and from the Southeast those rates are higher. Not
in all cases, but the rates from Atlanta to Bay Springs, for
instance, $4.95, the Royster scale would make $4.95. We
did not think we could get enough out of that rate to really
pay us, and therefore we are asking for something over
the seale in these rates. We are asking for something
more than we have now got. The rate is on combination
lfol. 505] from many Southeastern points. These are
merely shown as typical. I might state at that particular
point, that we have found it necessary to file a general
Fourth Section application under Docket 1303, because of
our financial situation, and that has been heard.
i a) |
It has been, and is the desire of these lines to operate
rates strictly on Fourth Section principles where possible
or consistent, but our situation prevents such peculiar cir-
cUlustanecs as to make special treatment as to Fourth Sec-
tion relief necessary. It has been estimated that 62 per
cent. of the voting population of the State of Mississippi,
in which state there are situated 397 miles of the Gulf, Mo-
bile & Northern Railroad, exist within a radius of 15 miles
each side of this line. The following counties in Missis
sippi are dependent, or practically so, upon the Gulf, Mo
bile & Northern Railroad for transportation facilities:
George, Perry, Greene, Jasper, Neshoba, Winston, Ponto
tor, and Tippa. Vopulations of these counties are:
lieorge County 504
(ireene County 10,430
Perry County 8,08]
Jasper County 18,508
Neshoha County 19,503
Winston Counts Is,139
Pontotoe County 15419
In ackdition to these counties the Gulf, Mobile & er a
Railrouwd serves to a very large extent the following coun
Thea: Jones, Newton, Choctaw, Webster, Chickasaw, and
Union Counties, making a total of 14 counties in the State
of Mississipqe eather solely dependent or largely dependent
upon the Gulf, Molale & Northern Railroad for railroad
transportation. Thus, it is seen that, although the country
te ut this tre poorly chev eloped from an agricultural and
tmlustrial wtatedpaarnt, aside from products of the forest,
thie tiulf, Molbule A Northern Ratlroad i* obligated to serve
an vopertant territory, the des eloprent of which aly vous
eanneot be carr forward without efficient railroad trans
fol 4) pertation, Praducts of the forest comprise an
average of approximately 65 per cent. of the tonnage of
thie line Forests are becoming very rapidly cut out, the
lumber manufactured and shipped Consejuently, unless
this territory can be developasd, this line views with alarm
the situatron im whieh ot will be when thie lumber is gone,
unless vast dev eloproent« arte made These Titnes have n
development department, and are doing everything consist
ent to develop the territory, but at heat the progress is slow
and without money nothing can be done. These lines find
it necessary to develop through traffic for reasons which
have been shown, and this can be done only by efficient
operation. The importance of prompt movement of traffic
is of course recognized, Consequently, unless this service
is performed, the development of this territory cannot go
forward, Anticipating the loss in revenue from forest prod-
vets, these lines realize the necessity of competing with
the strong trank lines for other traffic. This traffie cannot
be secured without efficient service. These lines, as will be
pointed out, contemplate improvements that will permit
them to adequately serve the public, compete for traffic, and
carry out a development program, but which cannot be
done without relief. It is of course understood by all con-
cerned, ineluding shippers and receivers, that the differen-
tial will acerue solely to these lines.
The average revenne per ton mile on the Gulf, Mobile &
Northern Railroad for the vear ending December 31st,
194, was 12 mills, whereas the average revenue on ferti-
lizer, proposed, will vield 14.8 mills. Exhibit 237 is a state-
ment showing present rates, revenue per ton mile, per car
mile and per car, as well as revenue per ton per mile, per
ear mile and per car, basis proposed rates on fertilizer.
This statement is representative of the situation.
The Interstate Commerce Commission has heretofore
granted these lines relief in view of the unusual circum.
stances. By application bearing the Interstate Commerce
lfol. SOT] Commission's No. 448, conditions peculiar to
these lines were set forth and conditions have not changed
te Warrant a strict olwervanee of the Fourth Section, but
certain other additional conditions and circumstances now
exist that make relief necessary. These circumstances are
net only indicated herein, but have been recognized by the
Commission on numerous occasions in which relief has been
granted. To illustrate: Fourth Seetion Orders 2531, 2754,
'To6, S866, 4500, To26, S845, and S805. Fourth Seetion
Order 2501 eranted Birmingham & Northwestern Railway
permission to establish from and to Jackson, Bells, and
Dyersburg, Tennessee, the same rates as were currently in
effect from and to these points via other lines in cases
where the rates from and to Jackson, Bells, and Dyersburg
were lower than the rates currently in effect from and to
intermediate points. (Tes. 676-680.)
554
This Order also authorized the Birmingham & North-
western Railway to establish and maintain rates from and
to local stations bearing reasonable relation to the rates
from and to Jackson, Bells and Dyersburg,
Fourth Section Order 2766 granted the Birmingham &
Northwestern Railway permission to maintain $1.55 per
net ton on coal from Louisville & Nashville Railroad Ken
tucky mines to Dyersburg, Tennessee, and to establish a
rate of $1.75 per ton from the same points to intermediate
points on the Birmingham & Northwestern Railway with
out observing the long-and-short-haul provisions of the
Fourth Section,
Fourth Section Order 2754 granted the Gulf, Mobile &
Northern Railroad permission to maintain rates from Gulf,
Mobile & Northern Railroad stations to Ohio River Cross
mgs and Memphis, Tennessee, when via the gateways of
Montgomery, Birmingham and Chattanooga the same as in
effect via the direct lines to Ohio River Crossings and Mem.
phis amd to exceed these rates to intermediate points the
sume as the rates from the gateways of Montgomery, Bir
minghbam aml Chattanooya to intermediate pots exceed
[fol SOS) the rates to Ohio River Crossings. This Fourth
Section Order also granted the Gulf, Mobile & Northern
Railroad authority to meet the rates of the strong trunk
lines from our junctions to Ohio River Crossings, and to
maintain rates to intermediate points between said june.
tions higher than the rates from sand junctions.
Fourth Seetion Grder 400) granted the Dirmingham &
Northwestern Railway peerdiinsien ter treet fates of the
lilimeis Central Railroad, amd the Lanisville & Nashville
Railrownd from Diy. rsburyg and Hall», DPettiossen, to Cyire,
Hiner, on lumber via Jackson and Molule & Ohio Rail
road, and to maintain bigher rates from intermediite points
provider! that the rates from said intermedate pomts did
net exeem? more than 3 cents per 100 pounds the rates con
currently in effeet from Dyersburg and Bell«, Tennessee,
Fourth Seetian Order 7026 granted the Lirmingham &€
Northwestern Railway and the Gulf, Motule & Northern
Railway permission to meet the rates of their competitors
at junction points on class and commeadity rates to and
from Haltimere and related points, Ohio and Mississippi
River Crossings, and related points, and Southern Atlantic
555
and Gulf Ports and related points, and to maintain higher
rates to their intermediate local points on basis of lowest
combination provided that the components applicable be-
tween points on the complainants’ lines used in making
such combination should not be increased.
Fourth Section Order No, S834 granted these lines au-
thority to meet the rates established at the junction points
and to charge higher rates at local or intermediate points.
In Memphis Freight Bureau Case, decided July 19th,
1913, reported in 27 LC. ©. S07, the Commission employed
the following language :
‘The Commission in Stiritz vo N.O. Mo& ©. RR. Com-
pany, 22.00. ©. O78, held that since this was a compara-
[fol. 509) tively new line, poorly equipped, and lacking the
density of trafic of the older competing lines, it was justi-
fied in charging higher rates.”*
The Commission, in’ Fourth Section Violation of the
Southeastern lines, reported in SOE CG) CL 161, after refer-
ehnee toa revenue check made ly interested carriers, pointed
out that a strict application of the long and short-haul
clause would result in a deficit to a number of lines, inelud-
ing these lines.
In S20. CL) CL 78, the Commission made the following
statement as to such short or weak lines:
“Ht is earnestly represented that these several short
roads imfersecting the main lines are not in a position to
observe at their local statrons the same scale of rates that
ix observed by their trunk line connections. The Com-
Mission has net had an opportunity to investigate the con-
ditions exsisting on each of these several short roads. We
are of the opinion that they shond be authorized te con
tinne to meet at their junction points the rates which are
established at such points by their trunk line connections,
and to continue for two vears higher rates to intermediate
local stations, provided that the present short roads and
the rates of the trunk line junction points on which rates
to said intermediate points are made are not inereased,”’
More recently, in Docket I449, reported in SO 1. C.,
the Commission, upon hearing and determination realized
the situation confronting petitioners’ lines and granted
certain special relief (Fourth Section Order 8843).
In 1. & S. Docket ISS85, pertaining to brick anel clay prod
ucts, the Commission authorized for application upon
petitioners” lines rates a differential of 3 cents per 100
pounds higher than for trunk lines (Fourth Section Order
S85).
[fol. 510) Commissioner Eastman, in his tentative report,
Southeastern Class Rate Investigation, Docket 1404,
recommended special treatment for account of petitioners’
lines, realizing financial conditions and among other things
said:
“Certain financially weak carriers of fair size and
numerous so-called short) lines seek special treatment.
The weak lines are these: Birmingham & Northwestern
Railway; Gulf, Mobile & Northern Railroad.
**There seems no doult but that most of these weak lines
and shert lines find it hard te keep the wolf from the door.’
(Tes. 680-684.)
The State Commissions of Alabama, Mississippi and Ten
nesser, have also in the prast and de now recognize these
lines as requiring special treatment and they have been,
are permitted, and do now maintain higher intrastate rates
than applicable over trunk lines. This is mentioned merely
to illustrate that these lines, account of location, financial
amd physical conditions, traflie cs neitv, amd nature of
trafic, cannet afford to operate rates in effect on strong
trunk lines.
Exhilkt No. JOS is a comparative statement showing
average miles operated, gross revenue per mile of road,
ZTOSS CA petises por mile of road, freight traffic density, tiert
ton miles per mile of read, for the Gulf, Mobile & Northern
Railroad, Alabama & Vieksbure Railway, Mlinois Central
Railroad, amd New Orleans & Northeastern Railroad. for
the perm]? of 1910 te 197), inelosive, and the «ame informa
then for the Giulf, Mobile & Northern Railroad for 192° and
Mot, This exhilat further and clearly portray« the weak
fhes« of the tiulf, Mobile é Northern Railrond a* compared
with certam of its connections and competitors, and we
believe will fully justify the Commisx«ion in granting the
557
authority to us to publivh and maintain higher rates than
strong trunk lines. It will be seen that the gross revenue
[fol. 511) per mile of road on the Gulf, Mobile & Northern
Railroad was substantially one-third of the gross revenue
on the Alabama & Vicksburg Railroad and Hlinois Central
Railroad, and approximately one-fourth of that of the New
Orleans & Northeastern Railroad and this is substantially
true as to freight traflic density.
{fol. 511) Exhibit No, 239 is a statement showing con-
densed comparative income account for the years 1914
to 1924, inclusive. This statement shows a deficit for the
years 1914, 1915, 1916, and 1919. While it is true that this
statements shows a surplus for the years 1917, 1918, 1920,
W21, 1922, 1925 and 1924, this company has never paid a
dividend, exeept a total of 7'4 per cent. on its preferred
stock only.
There is at this time $22.75 per share due preferred
stockholders in) accumulated dividends. The preferred
stock is an exchange for old New Orleans, Mobile & Chi-
cago Railroad first mortgage bonds, so really the preferred
stockholders are the former bond owners, who have re-
ceived only the dividends mentioned. All surplus, except
the inconsequential dividends mentioned, is put back into
the property for HOCOSSATS additions, bettlerments, locomo-
tives, equipment, ete, Since this line came out of receiver-
ship January Ist, 117, it has expended for additions, bet-
lerments and extensions approximately — $6,708,573.90.
There are no bonds outstanding against the property, there-
fore no interest of consequence charged to income. Thus
the financial disability or difficulty is emphasized. This
company’s financial difficulty has been of long duration,
having gone through two receiverships. While conditions
for 125 and 1924 were more favorable, enabling the prop:
erty by efficent operation and ceonomical management to
pay a portion of its dividends under abnormal traffie con-
ditions, business moving freely throughout the COUNTY as a
whole, the fact remains that this property has a very heavy
maintenance expense. To illustrate, in the next five vears
fol. S12] contemplated maintenance of equipment and
roadway expenditures are in amount $11,319,200,00, or #2,.
ZH per vear which ix the lowest the management
feels should be expended in the imterest of efficient oper-
ation and economical management, that it may adequately
serve the public dependent upon it. During the year 1924
our maintenance expenditures were approximately $1,963,-
127.00, making a difference of $800,713.00 per year for the
next five years, Which must be raised from earnings,
Our Company tiled returns with the Commission under
the Recapture Clause of the Transportation Act of 1920;
these returns have been filed for the last four months of
1920, for the years 1921, 1922, 1923, and will be filed for the
year 1924. There is filed herewith as Exhibit No. 240 copy
of the returns already filed and a copy of the returns that
will be filed for the year 1924. These returns do not show
that our Company earned the 3°, return on investment
permitted by the Transportation Act before recapture, The
rate of return for four months 1920 was 3 per cent.; 1921,
4 per cent.; 1922, 0.2 per cent. ; 1923, 3.4 per cent.; and 1924,
4.5 per cent; or an average rate for this period of 2.4 per
cent,
These returns were based on our investment as repre.
sented by the hooks of the Company. However, we have
received our tentative valuation from the valuation seetion
of the Commission, and this valuation based on 1914 prices
properly equated in aceordance with recent decisions of the
Interstate Commerce Commission do not differ materially
from our book figures, (Tes, 684-88.)
Cross examination
By M Fe Moore :
ata Mr Ciill, you do not shaw the proposed rates from
Gulfport, Mississippi, or Mobile, Alabama, to stations on
your tine, Do vou propose to apply from those points the
Royster seale plus 30 cents per ton?
[fol SIR} tA What you asking to de, Mr. Moore, is
to apply the seale that is adepted on fertilizer for trunk
line applieation, prltis Mt conta t’’
That may he something higher or something else than
the Rawster Seale. Wherever [have used rates here, [have
used the Royster scale,
559
I don’t know what per cent. of our fertilizer traffic is in-
trastate. The intrastate must be greater, because of the
proximity and the low rates we have. However, there is a
very substantial movement, for example, from Nashville,
Birmingham and Memphis to our stations. The intrastate
movements are, as a rule, short distance movements.
I should judge our average would be less than 100 miles.
These proposed rates would bring about some very material
increases in our intrastate rates. In most cases it would
bring about increases in our present rates, anyway, with-
out the 50 cents that we propose in the Tnterstate, as well
as the intrastate,
During the past five vears, there has been a very substan.
tial increase in the net earnings of our road. We are not
new approximating the 5%, per cent. We have made im-
provements. We realize the necessity for further improve-
ments, You will observe from my Exhibit 240 that we have
filed in this record copies of the returns made to the Inter-
state Commerce Commission under the capitalization
clause, The average of that, | believe. I can give vou the
average in just a second —the average for the period, 5
years, Was 2.4 per cent,
Page 4, 1919, shows one-half of one per cent.
For 1025 it appears to be S$1,.502,000,00, and for 1924,
$1,465,000,00, That shows a very substantial improvement
ever 1979, that is true, That shows a very substantial im-
provement. (Tes, 688.690.)
“Q. Now, then, Mr. Gill, referring to your statement
about the disposition of the timber supply along vour road.
[fol. S14] Ina hearing conducted in Mobile recently on your
Fourth Section application, didn’t vou file an exhibit: show
ing the per cent. of forest products reflected in vour total
tonnage for a period of something like 10 or 12 vears?
A. 1 did: ves, sir: and the average was the figure that I
mentioned at this particular hearing.”’
Tadon’t knew how mach difference there was between the
average of the first half of that period, and the average of
the latter half ef that period; it was very small, but [ am
not sure about it. There has been a very substantial in-
crease in the movement of tonnage over your road, now only
of forest products, but every other commodity. We would
560
like to see it continue, but there is uo possibility of it eon-
tinning, that is why we are developing through traffic.
Wherever there has been timber cut out and plants aban-
doned, in many cases new ones have not been established;
for instance, Lhave in mind a place there at Rose, | do not
know whether you know where it is, just north of Tate
Springs, two tremendous plants that were in operation
there, and there is nothing there today but skeletons. There
is hot anything shipped from there except a little waste
Wood that goes inte these reduction plants, Despite the
cutting out of the timber and abandonment of plants, our
tunber, forest products, continue to increase; they are eut-
ting out new faster than they ever did. As to how the rates
from, say New Orleans, to stations on our road on fertilizer
are now divided: T have net the basis in my mind, even. We
have various arraugements with our conbections, that are
based om certain reciprocal yrraugements. TP will say, for
your information, however, that any relief accorded us in
fertilizer rates is te acerue solely to us; if that is what you
have in omind. Ef 50 cents per ten is allowed to our line
over the rates that may be established by the Commission,
that SO cents will accrue to our line, and wherever rates to
thay are accorded us we will get the relief. (Tes CMG )
(Witness exeused. )
{fol D1 a. KF. Das TeeN Wiis thereupon daly sWorh ds «a
Witness and testified as follows:
Direct examination:
(Statement:) My name ix J. FL Dalton, and Tam General
Prewht Agent of the Norfolk Southern Railroad
I have had about twenty off vears’ rihiltewd eX perience,
approximately sixteen of which as been with the traffie de
partment of the Norfolk Southern Railroad. Of the six
teen Yours connected with the Norfolk Southern Railroad,
I have been a general officer of the traMfe department for
approximately fourteen vears
The Norfolk Southern Railroad's interest iy this in enti
gation lies very largely in the movement of fertilizers
within the «tates of Virginia and North Carolina, both in
561
trastate and interstate. Of the total mileage of the Norfolk-
Southern Railroad, that is 932 miles, all of same is located
within the state of North Carolina, with the exception of 115
miles, which is located in the State of Virginia, and which
mileage is very largely made up of branch lines.
Mr. Menzies, 1 believe, in his testimony in dealing with
the North Carolina, or the Carolina, rate situation, covered
in a general way the history of the rate adjustment within
the state of North Carolina, beginning with about 1891 up
to the present time, as has been well covered by the Com-
mission's report in the third Royster case, 50 1. C. C., the
present cates, or rather the basic scale of rates, within that
State, is a result of the findings of the special commission
appointed by the governor in the early part of 1914, I think,
to conduct an investigation dealing with the reasonable-
ness of rates passed by an Act of the legislature of the
{fol. 516] State of North Carolina. As a result of its ex-
tensive hearings and consideration the special commission
made a report of its findings to the governor, and those
findings were promulgated as the Justice freight rate
scales, and which included fertilizers.
That scale promulgated by the governor became effective
on October 15, 1914, and provided for a mileage scale, single.
and joint line, the latter being 20 cents per ton at that time
higher than the single-line seale. This seale—or those
seales, rather, were applicable to all trunk lines of 75 miles
or more in length, and which included the lines of the Nor-
folk-Southern Railroad within the State of North Carolina.
Under the law the State regulatory authorities of North
Carolina could not assume jurisdiction in so far as lowering
or raising the rates of the State of North Carolina until at
the expiration of six months subsequent to the promulga.
tion or the effectiveness of the rates. Soon after the State
Corporation Commission assumed custody of the rate situa.
tion within the State of North Carolina, the Norfolk-South-
ern Railroad made representations to the governor of North
Carolina—I should have said of the State Commission
that the rates were unreasonable and sought to increase the
rates previously prescribed and known as the Justice scale,
(Tes. 700-702.)
36— 166
GeO NARS D RIN WIE SE SL AE: Leet E TE ATR TS OARS PULA RF
The same rates do not apply interstate. The rates inter-
state are those fixed by the Commission in the third Royster
case, and in the second and third cases, certainly the third
Royster case, the Norfolk Southern Railroad attempted to
prevail upon the Interstate Commeree Commission to grant
it a seale of rates approximately ten per cent. higher than
what the Commission fixed for the other three defendants in
fol. DIT] the Royster case. However Commissioner Hall,
in the third ease, 50 1. C. CL, ealled attention in his dissent-
ing report to the inadequacy of the Commission in promul.
gating rates in the third Royster ease while not fixing the
differential adjustment for the lines of the Norfolk-South-
ern,
I have referred to interstate, having in mind the rates
from Norfolk into North Carolina, and which scale also
now applies interstate within the State of North Carolina,
amd from Charlesten, South Carolina inte the State of
North Carolina. Our intra state rates now are higher than
our interstate rates, They are for distances, single-line for
OS miles, and under, and for joint-hauls all distances higher,
With the permission of the Commissioner at this point
I would like te introduce a series of exhibits, which T have
prepared, dealing with the issues im this case. The first
exhibit has been pambered 241, which | anderstand was the
next number following the close of the hearing in Atlhinta
in April, 241 to 276 inclusive.
(There being no objection, the documents referred to were
thereupon reeeived in evidence, and marked ** Respondents’
Exhibits 241 to 276, inclusive, witness Dalton.’’)
The exhibit 241 is a map outlining the territory served
by the Norfolk Southern Railroad. On this map TP have im
dicated by a reference mark star the location of fertilizer
plants of one description or another on the lines of the
Norfolk Southern Railroad. Tt will be observed that the
plants are ina number of cases a very short distance apart,
The exhibit 242 ix a «tatement «showing the points as well
{fol SIS} as the character of fertilizer plants located on the
lines of the Norfolk Southern Railroad,
Exhibit 243 is a statement of the present rates on ferti
licer earlead single line application as now effective be.
_—
563
tween points in North Carolina intrastate as well as be-
tween points in Virginia intrastate, and also the seale as
effective interstate between points in North Carolina or
Virginia, or vice versa. However that scale does not apply
to or from Norfolk, Virginia, because the Royster scale as
prescribed by the Commission is applicable from that point.
It would, however, apply from a point such as Elizabeth
City or Hertford, North Carolina, located immediately
south of the Virginia-North Carolina state line, on a ship-
ment destined to a point in Virginia. (Tes. 702-705.)
That scale was not prescribed by the Commission, and
it is very proper to state that the movement under that
scale is not very great. However, it would apply on such
shipments as might be handled from those North Carolina
factories to points on our line in Virginia. The scale would
not apply from Suffolk. There are specific rates from Suf-
folk, Virginia, to destinations on the line of the Norfolk-
Southern Railroad, which, for some distance, I think up to
about 90 or 100 miles, where the rates exceed the Royster
scale, applicable from Norfolk, and for distances over 00
miles, my recollection is that the scale is about the same as
the Royster scale.
The exhibit 244 is a comparison of the rates intrastate in
North Carolina as effective prior to the Justice scale, viz.
October 13, 1914, which scale has been plussed the two gen-
[fol. 519) eral increases and minnsed the ten per cent. re-
duction, as contrasted with the proposed scale for single-
line application of the Norfolk-Southern Railroad.
That is different from the seale which the other carriers
are proposing. That scale is universally ten per cent.
higher than the scale proposed by the other trunk lines. It
will be noted that in some cases the old scale as shown in
the first column of the exhibit 244, which was in effect from
189] to 1914, plus these increases, and ten per cent. redue-
tion, in some cases, is the same, and in others under. and
still in other cases over the scale which we are proposing.
Exhibit 245 is the old North Carolina intrastate seale
effective prior to the Justice seale plus the two general in-
creases and the ten per cent. reduction, as compared with
the present North Carolina intrastate joint seale, and the
proposed joint scale of the Norfolk-Southern. There it will
be noted that the old scales, or rather the old basis, shown
eee Dey eS re to tate
64
under column A, which, prior to October 15, 1914, was the
local mileage seale of each line, subject to 25 per cent, stat-
utory deduction of the State. In other words, there were
no joint-line mileage seales, but the looal seale of each line
less 25 per eent. was used in making joint-haul rates between
trunk lines 75 miles or more in length. That basis is con
trasted with the existing joint seale and that which we are
proposing in this case for jeint-haul application,
Exhibit 246 ix excerpts from transeript of testimony in
1 CO. Doeket 7573, which LT believe is the third Royster
case, OTC OC) Mer. Calloway, as referred to in this exhibit,
Was the attorney fur the Lines defendant to the case other
{fol S20) than the Norfolk Southern, Mr, Womble, as men
tioted im the exhibit, is the rate expert of the North Caro
lina Commission, amd Mr. Travis at that time was Chairman
of the North Carolina State Corporation Commission,
Pixhibit 247 is a cepy of rate authority No. 125 ef April
12, 121, of the Virginia State Corporation Commission
dealing with the intrastate rates of the Norfolk Southern
Railroad. It will there be observed that the Virginia Com
ttixsion authormad, after prtabeloesation af He Wspriper matioes,
but without a public bearing, a seale of rates for the Nor
folk Seuthers Railroad generally higher than the seale now
prepromseddt for wttigghe Lite aagegrdnc ation over the hinnes of the
Norfolk Southern We are prt enprerne tig that seale for both
tutrastate and interstate appleation: pros ulead We can se
cure that seale, it our purpose to apply it universally, As
haw already Vaarorty stated all litters of the Norfolk Southern
are leeated in the States of Virginia amd North Carolina,
and the two State Commissions have authorized the Nor
folk Southern Railroad te charge generally a higher level
of rates than the Ray ater acale In the traffic test which
the carriers heave brevet Making, ve ued eur porerpersand monte :
Ihave an exhitat whieh PT will deal with later touching upon
thst
Exhilat 248 is a comparison of the present jomt-hanl
acales beet Ween ports ny North Carolina and the poreepmemend
joint hanl seales of the Norfolk Seuthern Ra: road The
joint haul seale was made as much higher tha. the proprrmed
single tine seale of the Nerfolk Southern as he HRoveter
jyont hoe eonte ia higher than the Roveter single line scale
565
Exhibit 249 is a comparison of the present rates of the
Norfolk-Southern intrastate North Carolina single-line
[fol. S21] with the proposed joint scale.
Exhibit 250 is a statement showing the proposed rates of
the Norfolk-Southern Railroad as contrasted with the 6th
class rates from Norfolk, Virginia, to North Carolina points
for corresponding distances, and the percentage which the
proposed rates bear te the Sixth class rates from Norfolk,
Virginia, to the destinations indicated in the exhibit.
The Southern Railway provides for Sixth class rate on
fertilizers in the absence of specific commodity rates. The
exhibit shows that the rates in many cases are as low as 3o
per cent that is the prope od commodity rates are as low
as 34 per cent. of the going Sixth class rates. (Tes, 70
TUS.)
As to how we arrive at our joint scale: after making the
single line seale ten per cent. higher than the Koyster single
line seale, TE then found the ditference existing in the present
Royster single dine and Royster joint seale, and added that
difference to our proposed single line senle,
Exhibit 291 is similar to Exhibit 250, except it deals with
the intrastate rates in Virginia.
And exhibit 252 is the same as exhibit 260, exeept that
it compares the North Carolina itrastate sixth class rates
with the proposed rates on fertilizer, and shows the per
centage of such proposed rates to the existing sixth class
rates
Bexhibit 298 is a cOmpRErisen of the rates as effective from
Norfolk, Virginia, te stations on the Chesapeake & Ohio
Railway as compared with the proposed Norfolk Southern
seale,
fol S22) The exhibat shows both the C. & O. intrastate and
interstate senlers,
Exhibit 264 is a comparison of the proposed Norfolk
Southern single dine seale with the rates from Norfolk,
Virginia, to stations on the Pennevivania Railroad, and
single dine haul, both interstate and intrastate.
In connection with that exhibit it will develop upen in
vestigation that in January, February, and March = the
Pennsvivania Railroad handled to local stations on its line
between 2700 and 2800 cars of fertilizer, and that the balk
of same moved from Norfolk, Virginia, Baltimore, Mary
land, Salisbury, Marvland, Princess Anne and Crisfield,
Maryland, and some from Eastern cities.
Exhibit 255 is a comparison of the rates between Pennsyl-
vania Ratlroad Stations, N. Yo 8S. & N. division, both intra-
state and interstate, compared with the scales as proposed
bey the Norfolk Southern.
Exhibit 256 is a comparison of the rates proposed by the
Norfolk Southern with the rates from Baltimore, Mary
land, to stations on the Pennsyivania Railroad, both repre
senting stnuleline hauls. Baltimore, as is well known, ts a
very large and important shipping point for fertilizer.
That exhibit consists of two pages.
Exhibut 257 is similar to 250, except it makes the compari
son with the rates on fertilizer from Baltimore and to sta
tions on the Baltimore & thio.
Bixtulat oS os sumilar to 24), exeept it makes the compari
son with the rates from Haltimere to stations on the West
ert Mars land.
jfel S25) Pixhibit 23% is a comparicon of the proposed
rates with these applioable for single line applreation be
tween stations on the New York, New Haven & Hartford
Railroad, My investugation with the New Haven road de
veloped that there is some movement under the rates of the
New Haven road, but we were anable to get any statistics
as to the volume of it,
Bxhilat 200 is a comparison of the Norfolk Southern’s
propermed seale with that applientle an CC. FPO AL territory
tieder the three different none basis,
In our study of thie came we bueve hoon anxious to develop
as far nu porno toler the CHa which rofluenced and deter
tmithad the comsumption of fertilizers within the states of
Virginia ami Nerth Carolina, and in onder to arrive at
some definite ules god secure same complete and fall infor
tation of a peste character as near as possible, we
sought te obtain same from the United States Department
of Agneniture, as well as the Department of Agneniture
amd lmmigratioen of Virginia, amd the North Carolina De
partrooent of Agneuitore
Fixhitat 262 eontaine letters from the United States De
partment of Agriculture, Bareau of Soils, expressing views
as to the cauees which lead to the consemption of fertilizer ;
the original of that letter | believe ie attached to the set of
567
exhibits handed to the Commissioner. This exhibit also
contains a letter from Commissioner Koiner of the Depart-
ment of Agriculture and Imaigration of Virginia, and also
letter from the North Caroiina Department of Agriculture.
After securing that information we undertook to develop
information relating to the acreage, production, and mar-
ket values as well as the consumption of fertilizer, and we
were forced te reach the conclusion that there is quite a
fol. S24] cor-elation between farm values and production
crops and the consumption of fertilizer.
Asis well known the chief industries of North Carolina,
I think, és eotten and tobacco, and in Virginia, and om Vor.
ginia, possibly tobacco, ‘There is not as much cotton grown
in the State of Virginia, in faet not anything like as much
us is produced in the State of North Carolina.
On this exhibit | have also indicated the freight rates as
in effect during the months of March and April of the vears
indicated for certain representative distances.
Exhibit 262 shows the acreage, production, and the farm
price as of December Ist, cotton and tobacco, for the State
of Virginia. (Tes, 708-712.)
Eahibit 263 shows separately the same information as to
eatton and late tobacco for the State of North Carolina.
Exhibit 204 is a statement separately of Virginia and
North Carolina of cotton, showing the acreage, production,
consmimption of fertilizer, and the rates on fertilizer for
representative distances.
The porpose of these exhibits is to show that there isa
very close relation on the farm values of cotton and tobacco
and the comsumption of fertilizer. For example, it will be
noted that, taking the state of North Carolina as shown on
Pixhubut Jod, that the farm price of cotton December 1, 19,
was So.2 per pound, whieh was materially higher than the
price of colton fer any previotis Vvear, As a result of that
the vear of 1920 there was a material increase im the con
sumption of fertiizer, The price obtained from cotton, or
rather the priee an the farm of Docember 1, 10, and dur
(fol S25) img that period had a laumper crop, the price of
cotton fumbled from 25.2 in W198 te 14.5 per pound mn 1920,
The following vear, 121, the priee of cotton was somewhat
better than im 10, but the movement ef fertilizer which
took place in the spring was materially less, having dropped
E68
in 1920 from 1,221,796 tons to 695,000, Now, in 1921 the
price Was better than 1920, and there developed an increase
in the fertilizer consumption of 1922. Going a step further
it will be observed from the same exhibit that in the year
of 1822 the price of cotton was 24.5 per pound a» compared
with the previous year of 164, so there again it appears
that the fertilizer consumption went from 856,000 tons mn
MA the fertilizer consumption in 1922-—went from 436,
(A) toms, on round figures, to LOSD000 in 1925. What tam
tring to prove by these exhiluts in other words, is what the
Departrsent of Agriculture of North Carolina told us in
one sentence that when the farmers are hard up they buy
little, amd when they are prosperous they buy liberally, and
that their prosperity and liberality seems to depend very
largely upon the prices obtained for these chief crop,
vi Ks Mr. Roberts;
“@. That doen't fit as far as Virginia is concerned in
MAES and P22, does it!
“A. Probably be a littl better on tobacco in Virginia,
Which ta the priumcial erep, more so than eottom is ou Vir
Kitua.”*
The consumption of fertilizer does net depend upon the
particular acreage, That fertilizer consumption means a
tetal consumption for the state as used on all crops. |
thunk ¢& os guteralls recognizes) that cotton and tohacea are
the chef erepe or the chief itedaetes of the State, and in
Virgina, | supqemee from an agricultural standypaunt, that
tolwers ts Phere is materially less cotton grown in Vir
ifel $26) ginia than tela, haewever the fertilizer con
sumption ie that consumption for all kinds of crops, and
fet tecwssartiy cetton and tolkaooe However, it does not
show that with the tremd of the farm priees, that the oon
sumption has generally gune along with it) This acreage,
though, dees refer to the aereage, bot mot the ConeUmMyp tien
of fertiliger, whieh os the total ommeutpioon of the State
Finhilat 29 te a simular estat. tent, showing woparately
by states the same infortnation as to leaf tohacce
Pishitat 24) ie statement separately by states, showing
the combined acreage of cotton and feaf tobacco, That 1»,
taking the total acreage of cotton and tobacee in Virginia
amd combaning them,
569
Exhibit 267 is statement of combined cotton and leaf to-
bacco for the states of Virginia and North Carolina; the
farm price, the production, and the freight rates for rep-
resentative distances in North Carolina and Virginia intra-
state, and also from Norfolk to various points in North
Carolina for representative hauls.
Now Exhibit 268 is a similar statement to 264, except that
it deals with the acreage and production of hay for the
states of Virginia and North Carolina separately,
Exhibit 2609 is a similar statement for corn,
It will be noted that fram exhibits JOS and 269 that the
consumption geperally of fertilizer followed more nearly
the trend of the prices of cotten and tobaceo than it did
corn and hay.
Exhibit 270 is a statement showing the movement of fer.
tiliver locally between stations where the entire transporta-
tien took place on the line of the Norfolk Southern for the
[fol S27} months of March and April, 25. ‘Phose months,
hased upon 1924, represented about OS per cent. of the total
fertilizer movement for the vear D424. That is, that the
fertilizer for cotten and tolmcecs generally tukes place dur.
ing the early part of the vear, and that has a great deal to
do with the tonnage handled. Now we have taken the ab
stracts covering each carload shipment, and rerated it on
basis of our proposed single line scale, and it shows an in
crease in revenue of 2G. Now it will be recalled that we
are proposing a scale ten per cent. lugher than the single
line Royveter seale, but the reason wha this inerease in rev
enue is net as much as ten per cent. is due to the fact, as
has already been indicated, that within the State of North
Carolina we have generally seales of rates that are higher
than the Ros ster scale, on the Norfolk Southern.
In other words for single line appleation for 4 miles
and under our present scale os higher than the Rovster
single line seule, and at TG miles our present scale single
line is the same as the Roveter single dine senate. About 90
pereent of the TYS7 ears of this total of 2124 shown on this
exhibit moved for distances (> miles and under. The aver
age haul is approxdanately OS miles, and by reference to
eshibit 241 at will be observed there that the lines of the
Norfolk Southern Railroad have quite a number of fertil
ver establishments on them, (Tes, 712-716.)
570
Now exhibit 271 is a statement showing the movement
of fertilizer segregated by the three different xroups as
outlined in commection with the general traffie test, sep.
arated as between North Carolina intrastate, North Care
lina interstate, and North Carolina interterritorially, That
ffel SYS] cowers shipments coming from = poimts north of
the Obie River or west of the Mississipepe and moving vie
Atlanta or Paint Rock gateways, or the Virginia Cities, re
rated on the basis of the Rovster seate. The movement,
however, is infimetessimaltiy stall Dt alse shows the move
tent in eommection with the short lines intrastate and in
terstate. Tt might be said, that un se far as this interstate
tevertient is comeermed, that it as generally a mevement
from Norfolk, Virginia, You will recall, Mr. Con
stoner, that tn ote of the Bars ster cases, that referenee was
tide te the fact that a vers substantial and large volume
of the fertalorer peremtconel wut thst prornt Wits sbirpoprencl ttile
the state af North Carglina, Now the statement, however,
reflects totiiawe where the Norfolk Seuthern Railroad is
the debvering carrer, as well as, of course, its
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.