Transcript of Record — Rice & Adams Corp. v. Lathrop
Supreme Court brief1929
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Peg a ay tL Mime te
nein GAOT
Eien Se
moe cmap
(33,464)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITEDSTATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1928
No. 155
RICE & ADAMS CORPORATION, PETITIONER,
vs.
HARRY D. LATHROP
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIROUIT
INDEX
Page
Record from the district court of the United States, Western New
p. Seere ees eee re CADSR SATE VERS COD ETO RE ESS Ceetedenteskteyen Sos 1
BOUT OF COUMMIBIRE. 0c cecce ser vececeneecrve scescesstcesieessees 1
Exhibit “A”—Decree, case of Lathrop vs. Bowman Dairy
TI. 6 ydue5eO seen Kb ey SUbs Gan OUR OES RS NatEN CORRES CREO ES 8
Exhibit “B’—Final decree, case of Lathrop vs. Bowman
Bb Ue Tey Tere eer TPT TT LET TTT Leer 12
ene re yer Tees Tee eT eT Tere ee ee hee Te ne 15
Bupplemental ANSWER... cc cceccccevceresvevevesecesecscveecen 28
Tnterromatories tO WeTeMGant. ....0cccvsccececcevsucusvecsvsecs 41
OES BS TEINS so oink cca scaieaccuseeeustsseseccuens 43
Defendant's affidavits on motion for preliminary injunction.... 45
Bae OE By Gy CRI. oo hon oben aws wus nsesecccucceess ° 45
Exhibit “A”—Letter from J. R. H. Potts to Dairy-
ye eo eee Serer eT Sree erry ret Ste ce ete 53
Exhibit “B’—Letter from F. G. Mitchell to J. R. H.
ee ee Te er eae geet ere Tere | ree 55
Jupp & DerweiLer (INc.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., NOVEMBER 28, 1928
od
INDEX
Affidavit of F. E. Prochnon.......- peewseev ese reeseenaeeses
B. A. Bean, Jr.......- pReeweeehee 008 Sereeeetee
Orlando Adams.....++-++++++s Soeedee sa nvesedes
Opinion, Hazer, J., denying motion for preliminary injunction...
Order denying motion for preliminary injunction.....- uéwaeds
Order to show cause..... ceseeesinuehs Ce ERE RS ONDE EREORSCTS ER
Affidavit of Wm. P. Conley.....-+++++ssees SS Ce eee eSSVECECES
Opinion, Hazel, J., denying motion to tramsfer.....vcscccscces
Order denying motion to CraNSTEP. .. os ccesscccccccvevcceccoves
Testimony of Clarence E. THreedy....cceceeseccccccccreeereres
Charles McCowan........sseeereereeerrerrececcees
Richard Guenther. .....+.++eeeeees cebeeeeneae ee °
Walter H. Paulson........-e-seeeeeeecererereers
George BE. McFadyen....+----seseeeeerereerreses
Assignment of patent.....-.seeerereerreeresreerrersr tees
Testimony of Harry D. Lathrop....-+++-+srerrrerreeerste eset
Exhibit 2-D—License to manufacture...-.eeeeererrrsrreres
Exhibit 2-E—License to manufacture. ..+--+seeererereerres
Testimony of George F. McFadyen (recalled) .....-0.eeeeerreee
Jesse A. Holton......seeeeseeeereereerrs ceenanwe
Jackson C. Thyng.....-sssceeeeecvrcsessersrerrs
Frank S. Goodhue.........e-seeecerercerrsereres
Thomas Prain...... SL aeageneS Ck bee eee sast cere
James R. Blair.....----+seeeeree gvegneeeuys veer
Exhibits 16, 18, 19, 20, 21—Bills....--- Ses eee oeeee vey es ewe
Testimony of Robert P. Flaine... ccccvccccscccccsccvssesese ve
Testimony of Orlando Adams.....--+-++-> Perr ye els pes
Minutes of trial.......-++e+eeeeeee c. cpepeaeernsaessekunee®
Testimony of Joshua R. H. Potts... .ccccrcece eedusetbseskee¥y
Defendant’s motion for nonsuit......++. eeceeunne> sveuebSwEess
Testimony of Irving Herriott......+++++erreerereeseresser eee
George Sable......-++- sésvens wrerer ct coeevese
Daniel A. McNamee.....-++++++++ peeeee eseuvees
Kirk K. Wright......--++-++++> shesenennets eenes
Ulrich G. Gressel......-:+eeeeerersereeeercrerees
Samuel H. Tillman......--+-+eerererererrtrrree
Motions to strike out testimony....--++--+++rrrrrerstereeeeees
Correspondence made a part of the record.....-eeeeeeeeeeeeee .
Opinion, Hazel, J., holding patent valid and infringed.........-
Interlocutory decree....+eeseereeeererere So ia wae xe oe ewe ete
Petition for appeal...---+-+rrssesree Diichie ge kee aheoes Oe CEES
Order allowing appeal and staying proceedings....--++-+++++*>
Assignment of errors...-- eseeenees (pena Reber eee oeeS jcaveese
Supersedeas bond for damages and costs on appeal..... ees
Citation on SORE. cc cvcescccersnessenssvecesosssoosounsecrs®
Stipulation as to record on appeal....-seeererseeressreereerets
Stipulation and order re equity rule 75...--+-++++e+e+" aaneeee
Stipulation in regard to physical exhibits.......-.-+. jitweewress
Plaintiff's Exhibit 32—Answer of Bowman Dairy Co., cause No.
—— eas ok ot Rein edke ? 4 ee RETO, ea ae ha boeken Pane SoS REET GT ED, RS Ge GE ROP TIN ORT FT AIO SR
INDEX 1
Page
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 383—Motion to amend answer.......-..++++++ 594
Defendant’s Exhibit 8—Check of Irving Herriott to Harry D.
LAtRTOD «ccrcscvcees VUTTOCC ITC OC Perey Ter 596
Stipulation re transcript of TeECOT.......... cece ee eee ence eee 597
Clerk’s certificate. ...ccccsccccccccccs CPUGND PEW TEE HIER wean ks 598
Exhibits in evidence............+.+. errr rr Terr ri. Pek eae 598
Letters patent No. 745,752..... SiVVOR iene NeeseG Ores. Ke beds» 598
TH BOO EDs pv evesvecereds Ci be nen se eene > 605
WA, Te os vewwovcscevsctees $o6aeve wanes 619
Ts PRE isscvcceteees vevscsenseweteest 625
PG aoe i er dc es dovesrebereeseretes 629
TA OEE 6.65 ve Soho oe Coe eeervererveesesee 641
ee! Tere Ty tie ee 649
8 Reem r rer rrr rete 657
WO. FOTOS sos resvare His EUSA TITS SATE OS 665
errr eee rere: tre eee 673
pe , Seer ere Cee reese re rrr 681
se vba ee Ab SV ou ie ees 1ebeeee 685
By, IE 5S oe 0 RAED: 9 CUPS C OES ITNT OS 699
NI C4 9495.05 Teh 54 60ers gO0 05.564 707
Proceedings in the United States circuit court of appeals, second
COONS oe vceciversss Sa ehe UR STS EES Gus URES TSEIUNEES 6004 EUS NOSS S08 717
Opinion per curiam...........eeeeeeees Loebereseneee PO REbES we ee 717
eee rrr penete bss PRLS V OREO SUN EEAS TES SEN EN SCORE 717
Petition for rehearing........ pUCSCORE NOREEN SERRE SN OE-699 49957 TRE 718
Order denying TeNeaTing.......cccsccccsccccccccevvcccvcesccevcceny 722
Clerk’s certificate...... seuvasie eoceeeceeeeeee (Omitted in printing)
Order allowing certiorarl.....cccccscvccncccesvcscccvenscvccsccese 722
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Larurop,
Plaintiff,
vs. In Equity No.
—O* -D
Rice & Apams Corporation, agi
a Corporation,
Defendant.
Bill of Complaint
To the Honorable Judges of the District Court of
the United States for the Western District
of New York:
Harry D. Lathrop, a resident of the City of
Chicago, County of Cook and State of [linois, in
the Eastern Division of the Northern District of
Illinois, and a citizen of the State of Illinois brings
this bill of complaint against Rice and Adam:
Corporation, a corporation duly organized and
existing under the laws of the State of New York,
having its principal place of business at Buffalo,
New York, and a citizen of the State of New York,
thereupon complains and says :—
First. This is a suit in equity, arising under
the patent laws of the United States, being
brought for infringement of United States Let-
ters Patent to James R. Blair for can washing
machines, granted March 3, 1908, No. 880,713.
2
Bill of Complaint
Second. The plaintiff is informed and believes,
and therefore avers, that on or prior to the 21st
day of December, 1906, James R. Blair, then
residing at Boston in the County of Suffolk and
State of Massachusetts, was the original, first and
sole inventor of certain new and useful improve-
ments in can washing machines, not known or used
by others in this country before his invention
thereof, and not patented or described in any
printed publication in this or any foreign country
before his invention thereof, or more than two
years prior to his application for Letters Patent
of the United States next hereinafter mentioned,
and not in public use or on sale in this country for
more than two years before his said application
and not abandoned by him prior to said applica-
tion, and not patented or caused to be patented by
him or his legal representatives or assigns in any
foreign country upon an application filed more
than twelve months prior to the filing of his appli-
eation in this country, and that being such an
original, first and sole inventor, the said James
R. Blair, on said 21st day of December, 1906, made
application, in due form of law, to the Commis-
sioner of Patents of the United States for Letters
Patent for his said invention and duly swore to
the specification thereof; whereupon such proceed-
ings were had, that on March 3, 1908, Letters
Patent of the United States, No. 880,713, were
duly issued for said invention and on said applica-
tion to said James R. Blair, in conformity with the
requirements of the statute in such cases made
8
Bill of Complaint
and provided, and that said Letters Patent are
good and valid in law and in equity and enforcible
ad such, and the plaintiff herein brings into court
a duly authenticated copy of said Letters Patent
and prays that the same may be taken as part of
this bill.
Third. The said patent, above identified, has
been assigned by mesne assignments or instru-
ments in writing duly and properly recorded in
the United States Patent Office, within three
months from the date thereof to plaintiff herein
who now owns said patent and all rights under it,
including the right to recover for past infringe-
ments.
Fourth, The plaintiff is informed and believes,
and therefore avers, that the defendant herein,
has been, after the issuance of said Letters Patent,
and before the commencement of this suit and
both before and after the acquisition by plaintiff
of said patent and all rights under it, and still is,
within said western district of New York and
more particularly in the City of Buffalo, County
of Erie, and elsewhere in the United States, with-
out license or permission of the plaintiff, and in
infringement of said Letters Patent, making,
using and selling can washing machines embody-
ing the invention claimed in said Letters Patent,
and more particularly in claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11,
12 and 13 thereof, all to the great and irreparable
damage of the plaintiff.
11
12
4
Bill of Complaint
Fifth. The defendant has been duly notified of
said Letters Patent and its infringement thereof
in violation of the plaintiff’s rights thereunder.
Sixth. The plaintiff is informed and belicves,
and therefore avers, that said defendant is pre-
pared and ready to continue said infringement,
and unless it is restrained from so doing, plaintiff
will suffer great and irreparable damage from said
unlawful acts of said defendant, and said defen-
dant has derived and received, and is still deriving
and receiving from said infringing acts, great
gains and profits.
Seventh. Plaintiff further avers that a certain
suit in equity was instituted and prosecuted by
him in the Northern District of Illinois Eastern
Division, said suit being entitled ‘‘ Harry D. Lath-
rop vs. Bowman Dairy Company, in equity No.
2259,’’ and being based upon a bill of complaint,
alleging infringement of the said Blair patent No.
880,713; that said suit was duly prosecuted by
plaintiff to a final decree in said court and was
bitterly contested on behalf of the said Bowman
Dairy Company, defendant therein, and after due
proceedings had, extensive testimony in the form
of depositions being taken by both parties in var-
ious parts of the United States and introduced in
evidence therein, and both parties being repre-
sented by counsel and the court having heard
extensive arguments and considered said evidence
and extensive briefs filed by both parties, did on
the 21st day of January, 1924, enter an interlocu-
5
Bill of Complaint
tory decree, a true and correct certified copy of
said decree being hereunto attached, made a part
hereof and marked Exhibit A; that later and on
the 13th day of May, 1924, said court, entered a
final decree and judgment in said case, a true and
correct certified copy of said final decree and judg-
ment being hereunto attached, made a part hereof
and marked Exhibit B; that the defendant herein,
the said Rice and Adams Corporation, openly and
with the knowledge of plaintiff, conducted the
defense of the said Bowman Dairy Company in
said prior suit and paid all the expenses of such
defense; that the said Rice and Adams Corpora-
tion, defendant herein, openly and with the knowl-
edge of plaintiff, paid the judgment of $736.82
rendered in said final decree; that the said final
decree entered by the District Court of the United
States for the Northern District of Illinois, East-
ern Division, in said suit, in equity No. 2239, thus
became res adjudicata as against the defendant
herein, the said Rice & Adams Corporation;
that the can washing machines so held to infringe
claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 of the said Blair
patent, were manufactured and sold to the said
Bowman Dairy Company by the said Rice &
Adams Corporation, defendant herein; that the
said Rice & Adams Corporation, defendant herein,
is continuing to manufacture and sell machines
in all respects substantially identical with the said
machines so held to infringe the said Blair patent,
and ig also ‘manufacturing and selling certain
other and slightly different machines but involving
13
14
17
18
6
Bill of Complaint
tha same feature of construction, namely the drip
saver, which was held in said prior suit to be the
feature of construction which infringed the said
Blair patent and that said defendant has manu-
factured and sold and is now manufacturing and
selling large quantities of both types of said in-
fringing machines, to the great and irreparable
injury of the plaintiff.
Wherefor the plaintiff prays :—
1. That an account be taken of the profits re-
ceived by defendant, and the damages of plaintiff
in the premises, caused by said defendant. ;
2. That the defendant, its clerks, officers, attor-
neys, agents, servants and workmen may be en-
joined and restrained, both provisionally and per-
petually, by the decree and injunction of this court
from directly or indirectly infringing upon said
patent.
3. That the defendant may be decreed to pay
the cost of this suit, and may be also restrained as
aforesaid during the pendency of this suit.
4. That the plaintiff may have such other and
further relief as the nature of the case may re-
quire.
5. The plaintiff further prays that this honor-
able court issue its writ of subpoena, in due form
of law, according to the law and practice of the
courts, directed to the said Rice & Adams Corpor-
ation, defendant aforesaid, commanding it, at a
7
Bill of Complaint
certain day and under a certain penalty to be
therein specified, to appear before this honorable
court to answer all and singular the matters and
things hereinbefore set forth and complained of,
but not under oath, the answer under oath being
hereby expressly waived, and to stand by and
perform all the orders and decrees of the ccurt
herein.
HARRY D. LATHROP.
JOSHUA R. H. POTTS,
BRAYTON G. RICHARDS,
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
STATE OF ILLINOIS
COUNTY OF COOK, 8%:
On this 14th day of January, 1925, personally
appeared before me, Harry D. Lathrop, the plain-
tiff in the above entitled case, and made oath that
he had read the foregoing bill of complaint sub-
scribed by him, and knows the contents thereof,
and that the same is true of his own knowledge,
except as to the matters therein stated on infor-
ination and belief, and as to those matters he
believes it to be true.
FREDA C. APPLETON,
Notary Public.
19
20
21
8
22 Decree
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
Monday, January 21, A. D. 1924
Present: Honorable George A. Carpenter, Dis-
trict Judge.
23 Harry D. LatHrop,
Plaintiff,
ies In Equity No.
Bowman Datry Company, 2239
a Corporation,
Defendant.
Decree
This cause having come on to be heard, upon the
24 pleadings, proceedings and proofs herein, sub-
mitted on behalf of both parties, and after hearing
counsel for plaintiff and defendant, and after due
proceedings had, it is, upon consideration, ordered,
adjudged, and decreed as follows:
First: That the Letters Patent of the United
States issued to James R. Blair on March 3,
1908 for improvements in CAN WASHING
MACHINES, No. 880,713, are good and valid in
law, particularly as to Claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12
and 13.
9
Decree
Second: That the plaintiff, Harry D. Lathrop,
is the lawful owner of said Letters Patent.
Third: That the defendant, the Bowman Dairy
Company, a corporation, has infringed upon the
said Letters Patent, and particularly upon the
said Claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13, and upon
the exclusive rights of the plaintiff under the
same.
Fourth: That the plaintiff recover of the defend-
ant the profits, gains and advantages which the
said defendant has derived, received or made, by
reason of its said infringement of said claims of
said patent, and that the plaintiff do recover of
the defendant any and all damages which the
plaintiff has sustained, or shall sustain, by reason
of said infringement by the said defendant.
Fifth: It is hereby referred to Charles B. Mor-
rison, as a Master of this Court, who is hereby
appointed, pro hae vice, to check and state the
amount of said gains, profits and advantages and
to assess such damages and to report thereon with
all convenient speed; and the defendant, its direc-
tors, officers, attorneys, servants and workmen,
are hereby directed and required to attend before
said Master from time to time as required, and
to produce before hina such books, papers, vouch-
ers and documents, and to submit such oral exam-
ination as the Master may require.
Siath: That a perpetual injunction issue out of
and under the seal of this Court, directed to the
25
26
27
10
Decree
said defendant, the said Bowman Dairy Company,
its associates, directors, attorneys, clerks, agents,
servants and workmen, enjoining and restraining
them, and each of them, from directly or indirectly
making or causing to be made, using or causing to
be used, or vending to others to be used, in any
manner, any articles, devices, apparatus, or Can
Washing Machines, containing, embodying, or
employing the said inventions or improvements
granted by the said Letters Patents, and particu-
larly claimed in the said Claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11,
12 and 13, or any part or parts of Can Washing
Machines capable of being combined or adapted
to be used in infringement of said claims, or from
infringing upon or violating the said Letters Pat-
ent in any way whatsoever, said injunction not to
apply however to the machines which the Bow-
man Dairy Company now have in actual use until
after final decree.
Seventh: That plaintiff do recover of the de-
fendant his costs and disbursements of this suit
to be taxed, and that all further ‘questions be re-
served until the coming in of the Master’s report.
Enter CARPENTER,
District Judge.
Entered, January 21st, 1924.
O. K. as to Form:
ee . 5 ss.8 . ee a “oe ee ee . . 606 0°
. . . . oe . . . . oe .
eee ee eel, eng MENG AR Toth. 4,6. 8 SSS IES SAE Oye 2 Phe SST
o- .
Attorney for Defendant.
11
Decree
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA FOR THE
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF
ILLINOIS, EASTERN DIVISION
I, JOHN H. R. JAMAR, Clerk of the District
Court of the United States of America for the
Northern District of Illinois, do hereby certify the
above and foregoing to be a true and correct copy
of DECRIKE made and entered in said Court on
the 21st day of January, A. D. 1924, as fully as
the same appears of record in my office.
In Testimony Whereof, I have hereunto set my
hand and affixed the seal of said Court at my
office in Chicago, in said District, this 10th day of
January, A. D. 1925.
JOHN H. R. JAMAR,
Clerk.
34
36
12
COPY
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
Harry D, Laturop,
Plaintiff,
vs. In Equity No.
2239.
Bowman Datry Company,
a Corporation,
Defendant.
Final Decree
This cause coming on to be heard and it appear-
ing to the Court that an interlocutory decree was
entered herein on January 21, 1924, holding the
patent to James R. Blair for Can Washing
Machines, No. 880,713, dated March 3, 1908, and
said James R. Blair to be the sole, original and
true inventor of the subject matter thereof, good
and valid in law and infringed by the defendant,
the Bowman Dairy Company, as to Claims 2, 3, 4,
9, 10, 11, 12 and 13, by using the Can washing
Machine manufactured by and purchased from
Rice & Adams Corporation; it further appearing
that the said defendant has used and is now using
three such machines infringing upon said patent,
and it further appearing to the Court that the par-
ties hereto, in order to save the cost of an account-
ing, have agreed upon the sum of Seven Hundred
13
Final Decree
Thirty-Six Dollars and Highty-two Cents as a
total sum to be assessed against the said defend-
ant in lieu of an accounting for damages, profits
and costs, it is ordered, adjudged and decreed that
said defendant pay to the said plaintiff the sum of
Seven Hundred Thirty-Six Dollars and Eighty-
two Cents, and that the plaintiff have execution
therefor.
That the said plaintiff, Harry D. Lathrop is the
lawful owner of said Letters Patent.
That a permanent and perpetual injunction
issue out of and under the seal of this Court
directed to the said defendant, the said Bowman
Dairy Company, its associates, directors, attor-
neys, clerks, agents, servants and workmen, en-
joining and restraining them, and each of them,
from directly or indirectly making or causing to
be made, using or causing to be used, or vending
to others to be used, in any manner, any articles,
devices, apparatus, or Can Washing Machines,
containing, embodying, or employing the said in-
ventions or improvements granted by said Letters
Patent, and particularly claimed in the said Claims
2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13, or any part or parts of
Can Wasning Machines capable of being combined
or adapted to be used in infringement of said
Claims, or from infringing upon or violating the
said Letters Patent in any way whatsoever, except
on the written license of the plaintiff or his
assigns,
Enter CARPENTER,
District Judge.
37
38
39
40
41
14
Final Decree
Entered May 13, 1924.
OK as to Form.
(Signed)
JOSHUA R. H. POTTS,
Attorney for Plaintiff.
(Signed)
MONTGOMERY, HART & SMITH,
Attorneys for Defendant.
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA FOR THE
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
I, JOHN H. R. JAMAR, Clerk of the District
Court of the United States of America for the
Northern District of Illinois, do hereby certify the
above and foregoing to be a true and correct copy
of FINAL DECREE made and entered in said
Court on the 13th day of May, A. D. 1924, as fully
as the same appears of record in my office.
In Testimony Whereof, 1 have hereunto set my
hand and affixed the seal of said Court at my
office in Chicago, in said District, this 10th day of
January, A. D. 1925.
JOHN H. R. JAMAR,
Clerk.
15
Original Answer 43
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT
OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Laturop,
Plaintiff,
against ;
In Equity No.
Rice & Apams Corporation, 793-D, 44
a Corporation,
Defendant.
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
Now comes Rice & Adams Corporation, defend-
ant herein, and in its own behalf makes answer to
the bill of complaint, filed herein, as follows:
The defendant now and at all times hereafter 45
saving and reserving unto itself all and all man-
ner of benefit and advantage by exception, or
otherwise, which can or may be had or taken to
the manifold errors, insufliciencies, uncertainties
and imperfections in said bill of complaint con-
tained, for answer thereto, or to so much and such
parts thereof as this defendant is advised it is
material or necessary for it to make answer unto,
answering, says:
1. The defendant denies each and every alle-
46
48
16
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
gation in said bill of complaint except as herein-
after admitted or specifically answered and
avoided and requires strict proof of each and
every allegation.
2. The defendant is not advised, save by the
bill of complaint, whether the plaintiff is a resi-
dent of the City of Chicago, County of Cook and
State of Illinois, or a citizen of the State of Illi-
nois, or elsewhere, and leaves the plaintiff to the
proof thereof.
3. The defendant admits that it is a corpor-
ation duly organized and existing under the laws
of the State of New York and that it has a prin-
cipal place of business in Buffalo, New York, and
is a citizen of the State of New York.
4. The defendant denies that the facts alleged
in the complaint herein constitute a sufficient cause
of action in equity and alleges that plaintiff has
an adequate remedy at law and that this Court,
as a Court of Equity, has no jurisdiction herein.
5. The defendant admits that Letters Patent of
the United States, Number 880,713, were issued on
the 3rd day of March, 1908, but denies that on or
prior to the 21st day of December, 1906, James R.
Blair, then residing at Boston, in the County of
Suffolk and State of Massachusetts, was the orig-
inal, first and sole inventor of certain or any new
and useful improvements in can washing mach-
ines; and denies that said improvements were not
17
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation 49
known or used by others in this country before
the alleged invention thereof by said James R.
Blair; and were not patented or described in any
printed publication in this or any foreign country
before his alleged invention thereof, or more than
two years prior to his alleged application for Let-
ters Patent of the United States, and were not in
public use or on sale in this country for more than
two years before his alleged application and were
not abandoned by him prior to said application, 50
und were not patented or caused to be patented by
him or his legal representatives or assigns in any
foreign country upon an application filed more
than twelve months prior to the filing of his alleged
application in this country; and denies that said
James R. Blair on the 21st day of December, 1906,
or at any time made application in due form of
law to the Commissioner of Patents of the United
States for Letters Patent on his said alleged in-
vention and duly swore to the specification thereof ;
and denies that said Blair fully or in any respect 51
complied with the law in such cases made and pro-
vided as regards any application to the Commis-
sioner of Patents of the United States for Letters
Patent on his alleged invention, and denies that
proper proceedings were had on his alleged apph-
eation and that Letters Patent No. 880,713 were
duly issued for said alleged invention in conform
ity with the law and Statutes made and provided
in such cases; and denies that said Letters Patent
are good and valid in law and in equity and en-
forceable as such.
52
or
phan
18
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
6. The defendant is not advised, save by the
bill of complaint, whether said alleged patent; has
been assigned by mesne assignments or instru-
ments in writing or otherwise, to plaintiff herein
or to any other person, or whether said alleged
assignments were duly and properly recorded in
the United States Patent Office within three
snonths from the date thereof or at any time, or
whether said plaintiff herein now owns said patent
and all or any rights under it, including the right
to recover for past infringements, and therefore,
denies the same and requires plaintiff to make
strict proof thereof.
7. Defendant denies that it is now or has been
at any time within the Western District of New
York, and particularly in the City of Buffalo, or
elsewhere, making, using or selling can washing
machines embodying the alleged invention claimed
in said Letters Patent, and more particularly in
claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 thereof, and in
safivtanaeeied of said Letters Patent, and denies
that the plaintiff has suffered any damage from
any acts of this defendant.
8. The defendant denies that it was duly noti-
fied of said Letters Patent and of its alleged in-
fringement thereof! prior to the filing of the bill.
9. The defendant denies that it is prepared and
ready to continue the alleged or any infringement
of said Letters Patent or do any illegal act and
denies that plaintiff will suffer great and irrepar-
able or any damage from any acts of this defend-
19
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
ant, and denies that it has derived and received
or is deriving and receiving great, or any gains
and profits from any infringing acts against the
plaintiff or any other party.
10. The defendant admits that a certain suit
in Equity was instituted and prosecuted by plain-
tiff herein in the Northern District of Illinois,
Eastern Division, said suit being entitled ‘‘ Harry
D. Lathrop vs. Bowman Dairy Company, in Equity
No. 2239’? and being based upon a bill of com-
plaint alleging infringement of the said Blair pat-
tent No. 880,713; that the Court did on the 21st day
of January, 1924, enter an interlocutory decree
in said suit in accordance with the copy of
said decree attached to the bill of complaint
marked ‘‘Exhibit A’’; that on the 13th day of
May, 1924, said court entered a final decree
in said case in accordance with the copy of said
decree attached to the bill of complaint herein and
marked ‘‘Exhibit B’’; that the defendant herein
conducted the defense of said Bowman Dairy Com-
pany in said prior suit and paid the expenses of
such defense ; that defendant herein paid the judg-
ment of Seven hundred thirty-six and 82-100
($736.82) Dollars rendered in said final decree,
and that testimony in the form of depositions was
taken by both parties and introduced in evidence
in said suit; but defendant denies that said suit
was, as alleged, duly prosecuted by plaintiff and
was bitterly contested on behalf of said Bowman
Dairy Company, defendant therein; and that due
55
56
57
a |
~o
69
20
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
proceedings were had, both parties being repre-
sented by counsel, and that the Court heard ex-
tensive arguments and considered said evidence
and extensive briefs filed by both parties; and
defendant denies that said final decree entered
in said suit No. 2239 because res adjudicata as
against the defendant herein; and denies that the
can washing machines held in said suit to infringe
claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 of said Blair
patent were manufactured and sold to said Bow-
man Dairy Company by defendant herein; and
denies that defendant is continuing to manufac-
ture and sell machines in all respects substan-
tially identical with said machines so held in said
suit No. 2239 to infringe the said Blair patent;
and denies that defendant is also manufacturing
and selling certain other and slightly different
machines but involving the feature of construction,
namely the drip saver, alleged to have been held
in said prior suit to be the feature of construction
which infringed said Blair patent; and denies that
defendant has manufactured and sold and is now
manufacturing and selling large quantities of both
types of said alleged infringing machines to the
great and irreparable, or any injury of the plain-
tiff; and defendant further denies that the inter-
locutory and final decrees in said prior suit No.
2239 held that ‘‘the drip saver’’ or any particular
feature or features of construction of the alleged
infringing machine infringed the said Blair patent,
but on the contrary defendant asserts that the
decrees in said prior suit held that claims 2, 3, 4,
21
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 of said Blair patent, each of
which claims is for a particular combination of
elements set forth in the claim, was infringed; and
defendant further denies that it has manufactured
and sold or is now manufacturing and selling any
machines in infringement of said Blair patent;
and denies that it has done or is'doing any act to
the injury of the plaintiff or in infringement of
any rights of the plaintiff.
11. Further answering, defendant avers that
said letters Patent No. 880,713, were granted
March 3, 1908, to said James R. Blair, his heirs
and assigns for the term of seventeen years from
the third day of March, 1908, and have expired by
operation of law and are now without force or
effect; that plaintiff herein moved for a prelimin-
ary injunction restraining defendant from the
alleged infringement of said patent pending the
final determination of this suit and that affidavits
in support of and opposing said motion were filed
and the motion was set for hearing; that on Janu-
ary 31, 1925, his Honor, Judge Hazel, heard argu-
ments of counsel for plaintiff and defendant in
support of and against said motion and on the
9th day of February, 1925, rendered a decision
denying said motion for preliminary injunction
and that an order denying said injunction was
entered herein on the 3rd day of March, 1925; that
plaintiff has not appealed from said order deny-
ing said preliminary injunction, and, the patent
having expired as aforesaid, no injuction either
61
62
.
6»
64
65
66
22
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
prelimiary or permanent, can issue herein and
plaintiff has no equitable cause of action but has
an adequate remedy at law and this Court of
Equity is without jurisdiction.
12. Further answering, defendant avers upon
information and belief that the alleged invention
or improvement described and claimed in said Let-
ters Patent No. 880,713 and every material and
substantial part thereof was shown, patented and
described prior to the alleged invention or discov-
ery thereof by said James R, Blair, or more than
two years prior to his application for patent there-
for, in the following specified Letters Patent and
in the following specified publications, to-wit :—
U. S. LETTERS PATENT
70,973 Davison Nov. 19, 1867
193,222 Buell July 17, 1877
291,117 Wicks Jan. 1, 1884
299,185 Von Schade May 27, 1884
338,096 Merkle 1886
345,703 Lafferty 1886
369,424 Baker Sept. 6. 1887
376,546 Pond 1888
393,769 Lorimer 1888
459,337 Strong et al 1891
490,100 Burt Jan. 17, 1893
498,549 Hodgdon May 30, 1893
508,740 Neely Nov. 14, 1893
515,283 Bucklin Feb. 20, 1894
536,785 Griesser 1895
———
23
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
544,880 Bonk et al
546,205 Van Gilder Sept.
547,307 Vollkommer Oct.
549,097 Baker
595,098 Donally Mar.
578,807 Barr et al
582,012 Donally May
618,795 Kellington
613,382 Meinahauser
616,284 Baker et al
616,737 Schuster
616,831 Elliot
625,762 Hayes
641,248 Ten Winkel
643,479 Res Brisal Feb.
648,138 Adams et al Apr.
660,314 Rosedale Oct. 2
663,142 Waring Dee.
676,920 Schreiber June
682,749 Roberts
688,152 Atwood
483,757 Allgood Oct.
505,208 Wayandt Sept.
639,378 Groterjan Dee.
688,740 Kissel et al Dec.
690,563 Cobb Jan.
694,416 Phelan Mar.
700,925 Heurteuax May,
708,738 Schirmer Sept.
721,824 Norkewitz Mar.
724,734 Pindstofte Apr.
736,762 Mitchell Aug.
24
70 Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
745,752 Adams et al Dee. 1, 1903
748,585 Clifford Jan. 5, 1904
755,018 Laible Mar. 22, 1904
762,522 Gillessen June 14, 1904
764,222 Adams et al July 5, 1904
781,692 Stubbs Feb. 7, 1905
784,504 Rubin Mar. 7, 1905
850,199 Wright et al Apr. 16, 1907
821,812 Mather et al 1906
71 864,131 Ilood Aug. 20, 1907
864,132 Hood Aug. 20, 1907
864,133 Hood Aug. 20, 1907
934,404 Hood Sept. 14, 1909
1,110,615 Hick Sept. 15, 1914
and letters patent of the Kingdom of Great Bri-
cain as follows :—
No. 1,738 of 1900 to Gillies
No. 4,993 of 1902 to Cowey
Catalogue 1905 of Dairy Machinery & Construc-
tion Co., Derby, Conn.,
and also by other Letters Patent and publications
at present unknown to this defendant, and which
when known, defendant prays leave to insert herein
by proper amendment.
72
13. Further answering, the defendant avers
4pon information and belief that the alleged in-
vention described and claimed §n ‘said Letters
Patent No. 880,713 and every material and sub-
stantial part thereof, was in public use or on sale
in this country for more than two years prior to
FORMER ep ti egEE PRwY 4
25
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation 73
the application for said Letters Patent, and has
been abandoned.
14. Further answering, the defendant avers
upon informatiion and belief that the alleged in-
vention deseribed and claimed as new by said
Letters Patent and attempted to be patented ther-
by, and every material and substantial part
thereof, did not exhibit any material or substan-
tial variation or change from the devices known a
the art as it existed at the date of the alleged in. /+
vention or discovery thereof by said James R,
Blair, and did not at such date involve any exer-
cise of inventive faculty and did not constitute
subject-matter of invention proper to be secured
by the grant of Letters Patent within the meaning
and intent of the Statutes of the United States re-
lating to patents for inventions, but was an un-
patentable aggregation.
15 And further answering, the defendant avers
upon information and belief that said Letters 75
Patent are invalid, void and of no effect in law for
the following reasons:
(a) Because the alleged invention described
and claimed in said Letters Patent and every
material and substantial part thereof had been in-
vented, produced and used and was known prior
to the alleged invention thereof by said James R.
Blair, to the following named persons, firms and
corporations in and at the following named places,
to-wit:
ASN.0 OR
LAR RP 3 . : =m .
: —— ye ey SNe
SEE AE IRE MIN AES RRR EE © FNRI EEE RSD AE IEE RE CM a ED
, ox PREBLE TUE STREETERS SEN 3
EE WEE ANTN SURE er,
26
76 Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation |
' "Charles S. Adams, Albert J. Rice and O. ?
Adams, of Buffalo, N. Y., at said Buf-
falo, and elsewhere. ‘
R. G. and K. K. Wright of Buffalo, N.
Y., at said Buffalo and elsewhere.
C. H. Hood and H F. Hood & Sons of
Charlestown, Mass., at said Charles-
town, and elsewhere, f
Thomas Sharlow and C. H. Tillson of
77 New York, N Y., at said New York and )
elsewhere.
and by other persons, firms and corporations at
the presvut time unknown to this defendant, but
which when known, defendant prays leave to insert
herein by proper amendment.
(b) Because said alleged invention described
and claimed in said Letters Patent No. 880,713 and
every material and substantial part thereof was
known to and in public use or on sale in this coun-
try for more than two years prior to the applica-
tion of said James R. Blair for said patent, by
the following persons, firms and corporations at
the following named places, to-wit:
78
C. S. Adams, A. J. Rice and Rice &
Adams of Buffalo, N. Y., at said Buf-
falo and elsewhere. J
Thomas Sharlow and C, H. Tilson of New
York, N. Y., at said New York and else-
where,
and by other persons, firms and corporations and
ISR REUSE AC ANA O95 PLEIN SHER ET SY
PIT LEI LEA CRIP ON RES
27
Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
at other places at this time unknown to the defen-
dant, but which when known, defendant prays
leave to insert herein by proper amendment.
(c) Because said James R. Blair surrepti-
tiously or unjustly obtained the pateat for that
which was in fact the invention of another, who
was using reasonable diligence in adapting and
perfecting the same.
16. Further answering, defendant is informed
and believes and therefore avers that said patent
No. 880,713 was and is without value and merit
commercially,
17. Further answering, defendant is informed
and believes, and therefore avers that no proper
notice of the plaintiff’s alleged rights herein has
been given to defendant or to the publie as re-
quired by Section 4900 R.S., by marking machines
or apparatus embodying the alleged invention of
said Letters Patent with the words VE’ ;
and the date of the patent.
e
WHEREFORE, the defendant prays td be
hence dismissed with its reasonable costs and
charges in its behalf most wrongfully sustained.
MITCHELL & STAPLES
Attorneys for Defendant.
CHARLES W. PARKER
Of Counsel.
79
80
81
St
28
Supplemental Answer
IN THE DISTRICT OF THE UNITED STATES
FOR TILE WESTERN DISTRICT OF
NEW YORK
Harry D. Larurop,
Plaintiff,
against In Equity, No.
Rice & Apams Corporation, 793-D.
a Corporation,
Defendant.
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams
Corporation
Now comes Rice & Adams Corporation, defen-
denf herein, and in its own behalf makes supple-
mental answer to the bill of complaint, filed here-
in, as follows :—
The defendant now and at all times hereafter
saving and reserving unto itself all and all manner
of benefit and advantage by exception, or other-
wise, which can or may be had or taken to the
manifold errors, insufficiencies, uncertainties and
imperfections in said bill of complaint contained,
for answer thereto, or to so much and such parts
thereof as this defendant is advised it is material
or necessary for it to make answer unto, answer-
ing, says:
en
29
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
1. The defendant denies each and every ellega-
tion in said bill of complaint except as hereinafter
admitted or specifically answered and avoided and
requires strict proof of each and every allegation.
2. The defendant is not advised, save by the
bill of complaint, whether the plaintiff is a resi-
dent of the City of Chicago, County of Cook and
State of Illinois, or a citizen of the State of Ilin-
ois, or elsewhere, and leaves the plaintiff to the
proof thereof.
3. The defendant admits that it is a corpora-
tion duly organized and existing under the laws
of the State of New York and that it has a prin-
cipal place of business in Buffalo, New York, and
is a citizen of the State of New York.
4. The defendant denies that the facts alleged
in the complaint herein constitute a sufticient
cause of action in equity and alleges that plaintiff
has an adequate remedy at law and that. this
Court, as a Court of Equity, has no jurisdiction
herein.
5. The defendant admits that Letters Patent of
the United States, Number 880,713, were issued on
the 3rd day of March, 1908, but denies that on or
prior to the 21st day of December, 1906, James R.
Blair, then residing at Boston, in the County of
Suffolk and State of Massachusetts, was the orig-
inal first and sole inventor of certain or any new
and useful improvements in can washing mach-
85
86
87
88
89
90
30
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
ines; and denies that said improvements were not
known or used by others in this country before the
alleged invention thereof by said James R. Blair,
and were not patented or described in any printed
publication in this or any foreign country before
his alleged invention thereof, or more than two
years prior to his alleged application for, Letters
Patent of the United States, and were not in pub-
lie use or on sale in this country for more than
two years before his alleged application and were
not abandoned by him prior to said application,
and were not patented or caused to be patented by
him or his ]eval representatives or assigns in any
foreign country upon an application filed more
than twelve months prior to the filing of his alleged
application in this country; and denies that said
James R. Blair on the 21st day of December, 1906,
or at any time made application in due form of
law to the Commissioner of Patents of the United
States for Letters Patent on his said alleged in-
vention and duly swore to the specification there-
of ; and denies that said Blair fully or in any re-
spect complied with the law in such cases made
and provided as regards any application to the
Commissioner of Patents of the United States for
Letters Patent on his alleged invention, and denies
that proper proceedings were had on his alleged
application 1nd that Letters Patent No. 880,713
were duly issued for said alleged invention in con-
formity with the law and statutes made and pro-
vided in such cases; and denies that said Letters
31
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
Patent are good and Valid in law and in equity and
enforceable as such,
6. The defendant is not advised, save by the
bill of complaint, whether said alleged patent has
been assigned by mesne assignments or instru-
ments in writing or otherwise, to plaintiff herein
or to any other person, or whether said alleged
assignments were duly and properly recorded in
the United States Patent Office within three
months from the date thereof or at any time, or
whetuer said plaintiff herein now Owns said patent
and all or any rights under it, including the right
to recover for past infringements, and therefore,
denies the same and requires plaintiff to make
strict proof thereof,
7. Defendant denies that it is now or has been
at any time within the Western District of New
York, and particularly in the City of Buffalo, or
elsewhere, making, using or selling can Washing
machines embodying the alleged invention claimed
in said Letters Patent, and more particularly in
claims 2, 3, 4, &, 10, 11, 12: and 13 thereof, and in
infringement of said Letters Patent, and denies
that the plaintiff has suffered any damage from
any acts of this defendant.
8. The defendant denies that it was duly noti-
fied of said Letters Patent and of its alleged in-
fringement thereof prior to the filing of the bill.
9. The defendant denies that it is prepared and
91
93
4
es
g4
95
96
32
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
ready to contiue the alleged or any infringement
of said Letters Patent or do any illegal act and
denies that plaintiff will suffer great and irrepar-
able or any damage from any acts of this defen-
dant, and denies ‘that it has deriv ed and received
or is deriving and receiving great, or any gains
and profits from any infringing acts against the
plaintiff or any other party.
10. The defendant admits that a certain suit
in equity was instituted and prosecuted by plain-
tiff herein in the Northern District of Illinois,
Eastern Division, said suit being entitled ‘‘Iarry
D. Lathrop vs. Bowman Dairy Company, in
Equity No, 2239’ and being based upon a bill of
complaint alleging infringment of the said Blair
patent No. 880,713; that on the 21st day of Janu-
ary, 1924, an interlocutory decree in said suit was
entered, a copy of which said decree is attached te
the bil’ of complaint herein and marked ‘* Exhibit
A’’; that on the 13th day of May, 1924, a final
decree was entered in said case, a copy of which
said decree is attached to the bill of complaint
herein and marked ‘‘Exhibit B’’; but the defen-
dant denies that the defendant herein conducted
the defense of said Bowman Dairy Company ia
said prior suit; and denies that defendant herein
paid the judgment of Seven hundred thirty-six
and 82-100 ($736.82) Dollars rendered in said final
decree, and denies that said suit was, as alleged,
duly prosecuted by plaintiff to a final decree; and
defendant denies that said final decree entered in
33
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
said suit No. 2239 became res adjudicata as
against the defendant herein and denies that the
can washing machines held in said suit to infringe
claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 of said Blair
patent were manufactured and sold to said Bow-
man Dairy Company by defendant herein; and
denies that defendant is continuing to manufac-
ture and sell machines in all respects substantially
identical with said machines so held in said suit
No. 2239 to infringe the said Blair patent; and
denies that defendant is also manufacturing and
selling certain other and slightly different mach-
ines but involving the feaiure of construction,
namely the drip saver, alleged to have been held in
said prior suit to be the feature of construction
which infringed said Blair patent; and denies that
defendant has manufactured and sold and is now
manufacturing and selling large quantities of both
types of said alleged infringing machines to the
great and irreparable, or any injury of the plain-
tiff; and defendant further denies that it has man-
ufactured and sold or is now manufacturing and
selling any machines in infringement of said Blair
patent ; and denies that it has done or is doing any
act to the injury of the plaintiff or in infringe-
ment of any rights of the plaintiff,
11. Further answering, defendant avers that
said Letters Patent No. 880,713, were granted
March 3, 1908, to said James R, Blair, his heirs
and assigns for the term of seventeen years from
the third day of March, 1908, and have expired by
97
98
34
100 Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
operation of law and are now without force or his,
effect; that plaintiff herein moved for a prelimin-
ary injunction restraining defendant from the
alleged infringement of said patent pending the
final determination of this suit and that the affida-
vits in support of and opposing said motion were }
filed and the motion was set for hearing; that on
January 31, 1925, his Honor, Judge Hazel, beard
arguments of counsel for plaintiff and defendant
in support of and against said motion and on the
Oth day of February, 1925, rendered a decision 4
denying said motion for preliminary injunction
and that an order denying said injunction was
entered herein on the 3rd day of March, 1925; that
plaintiff has not appealed from said order deny-
ing said preliminary injunction, and, the patent
191
having expired as aforesaid, no injunction either
preliminary or permanent, can issue here’n and
plaintiff has ro equitable cause of action but has
an adequate remedy at law and this Court of
102 Equity is without jurisdiction.
12. Further answering, defendant avers upon
information and belief that the alleged invention
or improvement described and claimed in said
Letters Patent No. 880,713 and every material and
substantial part therof was shown, patented and
described prior to the alleged invention or discov-
ery thereof by said James R. Blair, or more than
two years prior to his application for patent
therefor, in the following specified Letters Patent
and in the following specified publications, to-wit: .
U.S. Letters Patent.
35
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation 103
70,973 Davison Nov. 19, 1867
193,222 Buell July 17, 1877
291,117 Wicks Jan. 1, 1884
299,195 Von Schade May 27, 1854
338,096 Merkle 1886
345,703 Lafferty 1886
369,424 Baker Sept. 6, 1887
376,546 Pond 1888
393,769 Lorimer 1888
459,337 Strong et al 18v1 104
490,100 Burt Jan. 17, 1893
496,549 Hodgdon May 30, 1893
308,740 Neely Nov. 14, 1893
515,283 Bucklin Feb. 20, 1894
536,785 Greisser 1895
O44, 880 Bonk et al 1895
046,205 Van Gilder Sept. 10, 18905
047,307 Vollkommer Oct. 1. 1805
549,097 Baker soy
999,998 Donally Mar. 3, 1896
578,807 Barr et al 1897
582,012 Donally May 4, 1897 105
618,795 Kellington 1899
613,382 Meinshauser 1898
616,284 Baker et al 1898
616,737 Schuster 1898
616,831 Elliott 1898
625,762 Ilayes 1899
641,248 Ten Winkel 1900
643,479 Des Brisay Feb. 13 1900
646,138 Adams et al Apr. 24, 1900
660,314 Rosedale Oct. 23, 1900
663,142 Waring Dee. 4, 1900
106
107
108
36
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
676,920
682,749
688,152
483,757
505,208
639,378
688,740
690,563
694,416
700,925
708,738
721,824
724,734
736,762
745,752
748,585
755,018
762,522
764,222
781,692
784,504
850,199
821,812
864,131
864,132
864,133
934,404
1,110,615
940,404
639,378
483,757
505,208
Schreiber
Roberts
Atwood
Allgood
Wayandt
Groterjan
Kissell et al
Cobb
Phelan
Heurteuax
Schirmer
Norkewitz
Pindstofte
Mitchell
Adams et al
Clifford
Laible
Gillessen
Adams et al
Stubbs
Rubin
Wright et al
Mather et al
Hood
Hood
Hood
Hood
Hick
Gibbs
Groterjan
Allgood
Wagandt
June
Oct.
Sept.
Dec.
Dee.
Jan.
Mar.
May
Sept.
Mar.
Apr.
Aug.
Dec.
Jan.
Mar.
June
July
Feb.
Mar.
Apr.
Aug.
Aug. °
Aug. y
Sept.
Sept.
Apr.
Dee.
Oct.
Sept.
Wo
-
—
-
-
Io oe oN
to
14,
1901
1901
1901
1892
1893
1899
1901
1902
1902
1902
1902
1903
1903
1903
1903
1904
1904
1904
1904
1905
1905
1907
1906
1907
1907
1907
1909
1914
1881
1899
1892
1893
37
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
and Letters Patent of the Kingdom of Great
Britain as follows:
No 1,738 of 1900 to Gillies
No. 4,993 of 1902 to Cowey
Catalogue 1905 of Dairy Machinery & Construc-
tion Co., Derby, Conn.,
and also by other Letters Patent and publications
at present unknown to this defendant, and which
when known, defendant prays leave to insert here-
in by proper amendment.
13. Further answering, the defendant avers
upon informatioin and belief that the alleged in-
vention described and claimed in said Letters
Patent No. 880,713 and every material and sub-
stantial part thereof, was in public use or on sale
in this country for more than two years prior to
the application for said Letters Patent, and has
been abandoned.
14. Further answering, the defendant avers
upon information and belief that the alleged in-
vention described and claimed as new by said
Letters Patent and attempted to be patented
thereby and every material and substantial part
thereof, did not exhibit any material or substantia!
variation or change from the devices known in ihe
art as it existed at the date of the alleged inven-
tion or discovery thereof by said James R. Blair,
and did not at such date involve any exercise of
inventive faculty and did not constitute subject-
matter of invention proper to be secured by the
grant of Letters Patent within the meaning and
intent of the Statutes of the United States relat-
109
110
111
119
113
114
38
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
ing to patents for inventions but was an unpatent-
able aggregation.
15. And further answering, the defendant avers
upon information and belief that said Letters
Patent are invalid, void and of no effect in law for
the following reasons:
(a) Because the alleged invention described
and claimed in said Letters Patent and every
material and substantial part thereof had been in-
vented, produced and used and was known prior
to the alleged invention thereof by said James R.
Blair, to the following named persons, firms and
corporations in and at the following named places,
to-wit:
Charles 8S. Adams, Albert J. Rice and O.
Adams, of Buffalo, N. Y., at said Buf-
falo, and elsewhere.
R. G. and K. K. Wright of Buffalo, N. Y.,
at said Buffalo and elsewhere,
C. H. Hood and H. P. Hood & Sons of
Charlestown, Mass., at said Charles-
town and elsewhere.
Thomas Sharlow and C. H. Tillson of
New York, N. Y., at said New York and
elsewhere.
and by other persons, firms and corporations at
the present time unknown to this defendant, but
which when known, defendant prays leave to
insert herein by proper amendment.
(b) Because said alleged invention described
39
Supplemental Answer of Rice & Adams Corporation
and claimed in said Letters Patent No. 880,713
and every material and substantial part thereof
was known to and in public use or on sale in this
country for more than two years prior to the appli-
cation of said James R, Blair for said patent, by
the following persons, firms and corporations at
the following named places, to-wit :—
C.S. Adams, A. J. Rice and Rice & Adams
of Buffalo, N. Y., at said Buffalo and
elsewhere,
Thomas Sharlow and C. H. Tillson of
New York, N. Y., at said N ew York and
elsewhere.
George Sable, Ulrich Gressle, Daniel
McNamee, R. W. J ones, Samuel H.
Tillman, Frank V ine, J. W. Dodds and
Philip Smith, all of the City of Buffalo,
N. Y., at said City of Buffalo, and else-
where,
Ired W. Ilusted, of East Aurora, N, Y.,
at said City of Buffalo, and elsewhere.
and by other persons, firms and corporations and
at other places at this time unknown to the defen-
dant, but which when known, defendant prays
leave to insert herein by proper amendment.
(c) Because said James R. Blair surrepti-
tiously or unjustly obtained the patent for that
which was in fact the invention of another, who
Was using reasonable diligence in adapting and
perfecting the same.
115
116
117
118
119
120
Supplemental Answer to Rice & Adams Corporation
16. Further answering, defendant is informed
and believes and therefore avers that said patent
No. 880,713 was and is without value and merit
commercially.
17. Further answering, defendant is informed
and believes, and therefore avers that no proper
notice of the plaintiff’s alleged rights herein has
been given to defendant or to the public as re-
quired by Section 4900 R.S., by marking machines
or apparatus embodying the alleged invention of
said Letters Patent with the words ‘‘Patented”’
and the date of the patent.
WHEREFORE, the defendant prays to be hence
dismissed with its reasonable costs and charges in
its behalf most wrongfully sustained.
Dated, Buffalo, N. Y., May 1st, 1926.
MITCHELL & STAPLES
Attorneys for Defendant.
CHARLES W. PARKER
Of Counsel.
el AERA RD Hk
41
Interrogatories 12]
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Laturop,
Plaintiff,
against
In Equity No.
Rice & Apams Corporation,
a Corporation,
», >
Defendant. l=:
Interrogatories directed to the defendant to be
answered in conformity with the Provisions oF
rule 58 of the rules of practice for Courts of
Lquity of the United States :—
1. State whether or not you, openly and with the
knowledge of plaintiff, conducted and paid for the
defense of the Bowman Dairy Company in the suit
in the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Divi. aa
sion, entitled Lathrop vs Bowman Dairy Com 1%
pany, in equity No, 2239,
2. State whether or not you conducted and paid
for the defense of the Bowman Dairy Company
in the suit in the Northern District of Tllinois,
Eastern Division, entitled Lathrop vs. Bowman
Dairy Company, in equity No, 2239,
3. State whether or not you, openly and with
the knowledge of plaintiff, paid the judgment of
$736,82, rendered by the court against the Bow-
124
126
42
Interrogatories
man Dairy Company, in the suit in the Northern
District of Illinois, Eastern Division, entitled
Lathrop vs Bowman Dairy Company, in equity
No, 2239.
4. State whether or not you paid the judgment
of $736.82, rendered by the court against the Bow-
man Dairy Company, in the suit in the Northern
District of Illinois, Eastern Division, entitled
Lathrop vs Bowman Dairy Company, in equity
No. 2239.
5. State whether or not you made and sold to
the Bowman Dairy Company, the three machines
which were held in said suit to infringe the Blair
patent No, 880,713.
6. State whether or not you have been making
and selling other machines like the said three
machines sold by you to the said Bowman Dairy
Company, in the Western District of New York,
and elsewhere in the United States, in the last six
years, and prior to the commencement of this suit.
7. State whether or not you have been making
and selling still other machines, employing a de-
vice or arrangement for saving or preserving milk
or cream, dripping from the cans or other recep-
tacles, preparatory to the washing thereof, in the
Western District of New York, during the past six
years, and prior to the commencement of this suit.
HARRY D. LATHROP.
By Josuvua R. H. Ports
His Attorney.
43
Answer to Plaintiff’s Interrogatories 127
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT
OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Laturop,
Plaintiff.
against In Equity No.
793-D
Rice & Anams Corroration,
a Corporation,
Defendant.
Now comes Orlando Adams, the Treasurer of
the defendant in the above entitled action and
makes answer to plaintiff’s interrogatorics as
follows :—
In answer to the said plaintiff’s interrogatory
numbered 1, defendant states that through its at-
torneys it assisted in the conduct of the defense of
the Bowman Dairy Company in the said suit in the
Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division,
entitled Lathrop against Bowman Dairy Com-
pany, and that it paid its attorneys for the ser-
vices performed in said suit.
In answer to plaintiff’s interrogatory numbered
2, defendant states it has already answered this
interrogatory in its statement in answer to plain-
tiff’s interrogatory numbered 1.
In answer to plaintiff’s interrogatory numbered
3, defendant states that it paid to the attornevs
44
Answer to Plaintiff’s Interrogatories
for the Bowman Dairy Company, the judgment
and costs rendered by the Court against the Bow-
man Dairy Company in the said suit of Lathrop
against said Bowman Dairy Company.
In answer to plaintiff’s interrogatory numbered
4, defendant states that it has already answered
this interrogatory by its answer to interrogatory
numbered 3.
In answer to plaintiff's interrogalory numbered
d, defendant objects to answering the same for the
reason that no specific machines of which the de-
fendant has any knowledge were held by the said
Court to infringe the Blair patent No. 880,713, and
that said defendant has sold many machines to
the Bowman Dairy Company and cannot, there-
fore, answer said interrogatory,
In answer to plaintiff’s interrogatory numbered
6, defendant objects to answering the said inter-
rogatory for the reason set forth in its objection
to the answer to plaintiff’s interrogatory num-
bered 5.
In answer to plaintiff’s interrogatory numbered
7, defendant respectfully objects to answering the
said question for the reason that the said inter-
rogatory of the said plaintiff is incompetent, irre-
levant and immaterial, and that it does not con-
cern the plaintiff in the above entitled action
whether or not the defendant is making and sell-
ing other machines than those which the plaintiff
alleges infringes the said Blair patent No. 880,713.
RICE AND ADAMS CORPORATION,
45
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for 133
Preliminary Injunction
By Ortanpo ADAMs,
Treasurer.
MITCHELL & STAPLES,
Defendant’s Attorneys,
1144 Prudential Bldg.,
Buffalo, N. Y,
134
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT
OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Laturop, 135
Plaintiff,
gainst :
— In Equity No.
Rice & Apams Corporation, { 793-D.
a Corporation,
Defendant.
STATE OF NEW YORK,
COUNTY OF ERIE, ss.
CITY OF BUFFALO.
136
137
138
46
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
Frederick G. Mitchell, being duly sworn, deposes
and says: that he is an attorney and counsellor at
law admitted to practice in all of the Courts of the
State of New York, and in the United States
Courts including the Western District of New
York, and is a member of the firm of Mitchell &
Staples, which said firm is general counsel for the
Rice and Adams Corporation, of Buffalo, N. Y.
That heretofore and sometime in the early part
of the year 1921 an action was commenced by the
above named plaintiff against the Bowman Dairy
Company of Chicago and the Rice and Adams
Corporation, alleging infringement of a patent
known as the Blair patent alleged to be owned by
the plaintiff, and that upon advice of deponent’s
firm a motion was made and granted by the Dis-
trict Court for the Northern District of Illinois,
Kastern Division, setting aside the service of pro-
cess above made upon the Rice and Adams Cor-
poration; that the firm of Montgomery, Hart &
Smith, of Chicago, was attorneys for the Bowman
Dairy Company, and for that reason the motion to
set aside the service of said process was made by
said firm, acting as local counsel for deponent’s
firm; that thereafter the firm of Montgomery,
Hart & Smith appeared as attorneys of record for
their client, the Bowman Dairy Company in said
action and from time to time sought the assistance
of deponent’s firm and of their patent counsel in
Buffalo, Parker & Prochnow.
Deponent further says that the Bowman Dairy
47
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
Company was a customer of the Rice and Adams
Corporation having dealt with them for many
years and purchased many machines from said
Corporation of various descriptions, and that when
said action was commenced by the said Lathrop
against the Bowman Dairy Company, it was deem-
ed advisable and good business policy on the part
of Rice and Adams Corporation, which was ad-
vised by deponent’s firm, to lend every assistance
and to give whatever could be given to assist in
defending the said suit,
Deponent further says that after the testimony
in said Chicago case had been taken and the case
was prepared for argument, Deponent’s firm con-
cluded and so advised the Rice and Adams Cor-
poration that no showing had been made in the
said Lathrop case in Chicago that any one of the
machines sold by the Rice and Adams Corporation
to the Bowman Dairy Company in any manner
infringed the claims of the Blair patent as alleged
in the plaintiff’s complaint in said action, particu-
larly in that the description of the machine alleged
to have infringed the Blair patent was not like or
similar to any machine ever manufactured by the
Rice and Adams Corporation and sold to the Bow-
man Dairy Company, and deponent specifically
asserts that the machine or machines alleged by
said plaintiff in the said Chicago action have never
been seen by deponent, or any member of depon-
ent’s firm, so as to know or to become acquainted
with, in any manner, the character or construction
of the said machine, and that neither deponent nor
139
149
141
142
143
48
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
any member of his firm had any knowledge then
nor has it any knowledge now of the character of
the machine which the said Bowman Dairy Com-
pany was using at the time said action of the said
Lathrop was brought against the Bowman Dairy
Company.
Deponent further says that on the 19th day of
April, 1923, deponent went to Chicago to attend
upon the trial of the said Lathrop action, which
deponent’s firm had been advised had been per-
amptorily set for trial and argument on that day;
that upon reaching the court room, deponent and
the attorney for the Bowman Dairy Company
were informed by Judge Carpenter that the said
Judge did not care to listen to any oral argument
of the case, as it was the custom of patent attor-
neys to take time thereafter and file their briefs
and to say in their briefs practically all that was
said upon the oral argument, .and that he, Judge
Carpenter, preferred to read the briefs, and would
give the plaintiff five days time in which to file
such brief; that the Bowman Dairy Company’s
counsel then stated its brief for the defendant was
ready to file at that time.
Deponent further says that thereupon the par-
ties were directed to file their briefs with the
Judge’s Secretary and that he would dispose of
the case within two weeks after the same was sub-
mitted; that deponent thereupn returned to Buf-
falo without any further knowledge in regard to
said suit than he had learned from the testimony
and other papers which had been filed with the
49
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
Court, until (8) months later, to-wit: on or about
December 10th, 1923, when deponent was advised
by the Bowman Dairy Company’s counsel, Messrs.
Montgmery, Hart & Smith, that Judge Carpenter
had changed his mind with reference to an oral
argument of the case and decided that the same
be orally argued instead upon the submission of
briefs, but neither deponent nor any member of
deponent’s firm desired, nor did either of them
again go to Chicago or take any part whatsoever
in the argument of the said case, and the only
knowledge that deponent has as to what took place
was from third parties and mere hearsay.
Deponent further says that he did not again
hear of the ease until on or about the 12th day of
January, 1924, when deponent was advised that
the District Court of Illinois had decided the case
but had denied to the plaintiff any right of aceount-
ing or injunction and had indicated the desire to
uphold the validity of the patent for the express
purpose of having the same reviewed by the Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals and had advised the attor-
neys before him to take such appeal, Thereafter
deponent was surprised to learn that an interlocu-
tory decree had been entered.
Deponent further says that not until March
26th, 1924, did deponent see or know that an inter-
locutory decree had been entered in the Lathrop
case, at which time deponent first learned of the
terms of said decree,
Deponent further says that when he first learned
146
147
1438
149
150
50
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
that a decision had been rendered by the Court
and sometime in the early part of February, 1924,
that he advised the Rice & Adams Corporation to
cease to manufacture or sell any machine having
the drip pan feature attached, even though it was
deponent’s opinion that the decision in the Tlinois
Lathrop ease did not establish that the Rice &
Adams Corporation was infringing the so-called
Blair patent, the subject of that suit; that the
question of business policy arose as to whether the
Rice & Adams Corporation should protect its cus-
tomers against suits for alleged infringement, and
it was finally determined and deponent advised the
oMicers of said Rice & Adams Corporation that it
should so protect its customers and that if other
suits were to be started against customers in vari-
ous districts of the United States, the cost of de-
fending such suits would be considerable and that
if a settlement could be made which would pre-
vent the commencement of such suits, deponent
advised that some sum be offered Mr. Potts, Lath-
rop’s attorney, to prevent such actions from being
commenced to harass customers of said Rice &
Adams Corporation. Accordingly deponent re-
quested the attorneys for the Bowman Dairy Com-
pany to make overtures to Mr. Potts, to see what
could be done, and on May 6th, 1924, deponent
went to Chicago to see Mr. Potts in regard thereto.
Deponent further says that at said interview
deponent stated plainly to Mr. Potts that if Mr.
Potts would bring an action in the Western Dis-
trict of New York against our client; where the
51
Defendents Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
issues could be squarely met and a full and fair
hearing had, that we would not pay him or his
client a single dollar, but if our customers were
going to be interfered with by starting separate
actions in various districts, wherever a machine
could be found that had been sold by our client,
we would be willing to pay wh:t it would cost us
to defend such customers, an] deponent there-
upon offered said Potts Two thousand two hun-
dred fifty ($2,250.00) Dollars to release the Rice
& Adams Corporation from the chance of such
law suits, and thereafter deporent authorized the
attorneys for the Bowman Dairy Company to in-
crease that sum to Two thousand five hundred
(#2.500.00) Dollars, which was one-half of the
counter offer made by Mr. Potts for such release,
Deponent further says that Mr. Petts declined
the offer and thereafter wrete letters around the
country to the custmers of the Rice & Adams (er-
poration, including many who had never prr-
chased a machine having a drip saver attached,
and threatening suit; a copy of one of such letters
is attached hereto and made a part hereof, and
marked Exhibit ‘*.A’’; that deponent is informed
and verily believes that said Potts or his client
Lathrop also furnished information to various
publications, including the Lactonews, published in
Pennsylvania, which latter is an important adver-
tising medium for maufacturers of milk machinery
that the Riee & Adams Corporation had been de-
feated in an action by the Lathrop-Paulson Com-
pany of Chicago, and that thereupon said Lac-
bed
qo
ve
154
156
52 :
Defendants Affidavits on Motion for
Preliminary Injunction
tonews published such articles and the same was
libellous and was withdrawn by the said Lacto-
news upon notification by deponent of the libellous
character of the publication.
Deponent further says that on August 16, 1924
deponent wrote said Potts a letter, a copy of which
letter is hereto attached and hereby made a part
hereof, and marked Exhibit ‘‘B,’’ notifying said
Potts of the threatening character cf his letters
and of our intention to submit such letters to the
proper authorities for action, if he continued the
campaign which he had started.
Deponent further says that from a careful study
of the proceedings in the Lathrop action in
Chicago, he is of the opinion that the decision of
that Court was made without full consideration of
the case, without a properly prepared argument
and with the express intention of having the case
reviewed by the Circuit Court of Appeals, and that
because the Rice & Adams Corporation was not a
party to said suit at the time of the entry of the
decree, it could not appeal to the Cireuit Court,
and deponent further says that an endeavor on
behalf of the Rice & Adams Corporation to be
permitted to take such appeal, and an application
therefor, was made to Judge Carpenter for that
purpose and was denied by him, so that deponent
asserts that the Rice & Adams Corporation has
never been in position to compel an appeal for the
purpose of reviewing the decision of the District
Court for the Northern District of Illinois, East-
ern Division, and that the action brought and now
53
Exhibit A 157
pending in this Court is the first opportunity that
defendant has had to fully submit the question of
infringement of the so-called Blair patent to a
Court for determination.
FRED’K G. MITCHELL.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 30th day of January, 1925.
C. E. MAYER,
Commissioner of Deeds, 158
in and for the City of Buffalo, N. Y.
EXHIBIT A
July 11, 1924.
Dairymen’s League,
120 West 42nd Street,
New York, New York.
Gentlemen:
I am informed that you are using a number of
CAN WASHING MACHINES purchased from
Rice & Adams Corporation, that are a direct in-
fringement of United States Letters Patent,
granted James R. Blair for CAN WASHING
MACHINES, No. 880,713, dated March 3, 1908,
and owned by my client, Harry D, Lathrop.
You are hereby notified to discontinue the use
of said infringing machines at once and render
an accounting for all of the profits that you have
made by reason of their use, or suit will be insti-
tuted, asking for a preliminary and permanent in-
junction, and an accounting for all profits and
damages.
159
Cee
160
161
162
BIE EAE OL SIEM SEG LS BS FE
54
Exhibit A
If you wish to settle the matter without a suit,
my client is willing to settle for $200.00 per
machine and grant you a license to continue the
use of the infringing machine during its life, with-
out the payment of further royalties.
I am enclosing herewith a copy of the final de-
sree in the case of Harry D. Lathrop vs. Bowman
Dairy Company, in the United States District
Court, Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Divi-
sion, in Equity No. 2239, holding the Blair Pat-
ent valid and infringed by using machines manu-
factured and sold by Rice & Adams Corporation.
This case was bitterly contested and the defendant
must have spent many thousands of dollars in de-
fending this suit.
Your attention is also called to the decree in the
ease of Harry D. Lathrop vs. Davis-Watkins-
Dairymen’s Manufacturing Company, in the
United States District Court, in Equity No, 1166,
holding the said patent valid and infringed, since
which time that company has been operating under
a license from my client.
Awaiting your prompt response as to your in-
tentions in this matter, remain,
Very truly yours,
(Signed) JOSHUA R. H. POTTS.
SA A ee
55
SCHEDULE «BRB»
August 16, 1924,
Mr. Joshua R. I. Potts,
Suite 1500 Burnham Bldg.,
N. W. Corner LaSalle & Randolph Sts.,
(hieago, Ill,
Dear Sir:
Tt has been brought to our attention that you
have written many letters to varius customers of
the Rice & Adams Corporation throughout the
United States, which letters have either been for-
warded to us or copies thereof.
We have given the matter very serious consid-
eration and have reached the conclusion that these
letters are intended to be and are threatening in
their nature and damaging to our clients, Rice &
Adams Corporation. The letters are being sent
to customers of our client who have never pur-
chased a machine of the character you describe
nor have in any way infringed the patent which
yon describe in your letters,
You were thoroughly advised before you wrote
the letters that the customers in question were
not using the machines and in no manner were
affected by the Bowman Dairy Company decision,
Despite this fact, your letters indicate clearly an
attempt to threaten and, if possible, to injure the
business of Rice & Adams Corporation in the in-
terest of a competitive company which you repre-
sent,
We believe that you are violating the Postal
Laws of the United States and other Federal
Laws, and unless you at once refrain from this
164
165
SURAT CTAB He SO iy NR TNR Dern rs a Se ee
56
166 Affidavit Si.
unwarranted and unlawful procedure, we shall be
compelled to present the matter to the proper
oflicers for such action in the premises as they
shall deem advisable.
Yours very truly,
FGN:B.
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
167 WESTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D, LatHrop,
Plaintiff,
vs. eee
Rice & Apams CorPoRaTION, In Equity No
4 793-D
a Corporation,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT
168 STATE OF NEW YORK
oe ss
County of Erie
I, FELIX E. PROCHNOW, being duly sworn,
depose and say that I am 39 years of age and
am a graduate in electrical engineering of the
University of Toronto, and had about two years |
practical experience in mechanical and electrical
engineering before beginning the practice of
patent law in the year 1909, and since that time
have been continuously engaged in such practice
and have prosecuted numerous applications for
57
Affidavit
patents in the United States Patent Office and
Foreign countries; have frequently been called
upon to give my opinion on questions of infringe-
ment and validity of patents, and have acted a*
expert in patent cases.
I have examined the Blair patent in suit, No.
880,713, dated March 3, 1908, and understand the
same. The specification of the patent states that
the invention relates to aparatus for washing milk
and other cans, pails and receptacles of various
types. The claims relied on, to wit, numbers 2, 3,
4,9, 10, 11, 12 and 13, all recite a receptacle wash-
ing apparatus. The drawings and specification of
the patent show and describe a receptacle washing
machine of a type well known vat the date of the
application of the Blair patent and disclosed in
several prior patents, in which the receptacles are
moved in an inverted position, or mouth-down-
ward, one after another over aid past a succession
of devices which discharge fluid into and against
the outer surfaces of the receptacles for washins
or cleaning and_ sterilizing them. Receptacle
washing machines of this type are shown in the
following patents:
498,549 Ifodgdon May, 30, 1893
546,205 Van Gilder Sept. 10, 1895
745,752 Adams & Rice Dee. 1. 1903
(64,222 Adams & Rice July 5, 1904
850,199 Wright & Wright Apr. 16, 1907
864,131 Hood Aug. 20, 1907
864,132 Hood Aug. 20, 1907
169
Wu
173
‘fm
EEE ee
EEE
58
Affidavit
As disclosed in the Blair patent, the receptacles
pass through an open ended, straight hood or
chamber which prevents the escape of the clean-
ing media, and vats are provided beneath the mov-
ing receptacles, a portion of the washing fluid for
the receptacles being taken from these vats and
circulated by pumps so that the washing fluid can
be recirculated and used over and over again to
prevent waste, and to utilize to the maximum the
soap or cleansing medium which is used in the
washing fluid.
The prior patents above mentioned show that
machines of this same type for washing cans or
other receptacles, and including all of these fea-
tures, were known and patented before the appli-
cation for said Blair patent was filed.
The Blair patent, therefore, if it discloses any
novelty, is only for a particular construction of an
old and known type of machine, that is the parti-
cular combinations of parts set forth in the several
claims of the patent. The machine shown and
described in the Blair patent is provided with a
horizontally disposed, endless chain carrier 11
upon which the cans or receptacles are placed and
supported mouth-downward, and which carries
the receptacles through the hood 36 and past: the
fluid discharging or cleaning devices. At the
front end of the machine the endless carrier pro
jects out in advance of the hood 36, and a drip pan
or receptacle 41 is arranged beneath the upper run
of the endless carrier for the purpose of catching
EEE
59
Affidavit
any liquid dripping from the inverted recepta-
cles.
The carrier, adapted to support and carry the
receptacles past the cleansing instrumentalities,
and also the drip receptacle is included in com-
bination with various other features in each one
of the claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 relie
upon. ys
I have read the interlocutory and final decrees
entered in the suit in the United States District
Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Kast-
ern Division, entitled Harry D, Lathrop vs. Bow-
man Dairy Company, in Equity No. 2239, and
also the affidavits filed by plaintiff in support of
his motion for preliminary injunction in the pre-
sent cause, to wit, the aflidavit of Harry D. Lath-
rop subscribed Jan. 14, 1924, and two affidavits
of Joshua R. H. Potts, each subseribed the 28th
day of January, 1925. The statement in the Lath-
rop affidavit:
‘The feature of said machines which were
held to infringe said Blair patent was the drip
saver or the arrangement at the entry end of
the machine whereby the drippings from the
cans or receptacles being washed are saved
uncontaminated by the washing fluid.’’
and the statement on page 9 of the Potts affidavit,
that
‘‘the arangement at the entry end of the mach-
ines for catching and saving the milk or
cream dripping from the cans * * * * was the
175
176
177
178
179
130
69
Affidavit
feature, and the only feature of said machine
which was held to infringe.”’
are not in accord with said decrees. There is no
such holding of infringement in either decree. The
interlocutory decree with reference to infringe-
ment reads:
“That the defendant, the Bowman Dairy
Company, a corporation, has infringed upon
said Letters Patent, and particwarly upon
the said claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13, and j
upon the exclusive right of the plaintiff under
the same.’’
The final decree entered May 13, 1924, reads:
‘it appearing to the Court that an interlo-
cutory decree was entered herein on Jan. 21,
1924, holding the patent to James R. Blair for
ean washing machines No. 880,713, dated
March 3, 1918, and said James R. Blair to be
the sole, original and true inventor of the
subject-matter thereof, good and valid in law
and infringed by the defendant, the Bowman
Dairy Company, as to claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11,
12 and 13 * * * * it further appearing that said
defendant has used and is now using three
such machines infringing upon said patent.’’
There is no claim in the Blair patent broadly
covering a drip pan or receptacle alone or disasso-
ciated from other structural features disclosed in
the patent.
Each of claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11 and 12 specifies
NPIL RE TALS pa NPDES SSS PEE OT RAEN Si,
61
Affidavit 1g1
among other elements, a vat, and) also an endless
carrier.
Claims 2 and 3 specify the endless carrier as
having an operative run supported above the vat
and adapted to receive receptacles supported
mouth-downward thereon.
Claims 4 and 9 specify the endless carrier as
comprising laterally spaced portions or members
whereon the receptacles may be positioned or
supported mouth-downward, or to span the car-
rier.
Claims 10, 11 and 12 specify the endless carrier
comprising laterally spaced members adapted to
receive thereon receptacles to be cleansed, said
endless carrier having an upper horizontal run
projecting beyond said vat at the intake end there-
of.
Claim 13 sets forth (1) a support (2) a carrier
adapted to receive receptacles thereon (3) clean-
ing medium pipes having discharge orifices direct-
ed toward said receptacles positioned thereon (4)
means adapted to receive from the receptacles
when positioned upon the carrier the material
contained in said receptacles and discharged there-
from when said receptacles are positioned upon
said carrier.
Claim 4 specifies a vat having compartments
therein and each of claims 10, 11 and 12 specifies
a vat having a plurality of compartments.
Claim 4 specifies a cleansing fluid circulating
system connected to each compartment.
Claim 9 specifies a vat having a circulating
system including a pump.
182
133
184
62
Affidavit
Each of claims 10, 11 and 12 specifies a circu-
lating system connected to each vat.
Each of Claims 10, 11 and 12 specifies means
for heating the contents of one or more of said
vats.
Each of Claims 9, 10, 11 and 12 specifies opposed
upright discharge pipes having lateral facing dis-
charge openings.
Claims 2 and 3 also specify cleansing medium
pipes within said vat and directed toward the in-
terior of said receptacles.
Still other features are specified in some of the
claims.
I have examined exhibits numbers 4, 5, 6 and 8
filed herein and mentioned in the affidavits of
Joshua R. H. Potts subscribed Jan. 28, 1925, as
being introduced in evidence in the case of Harry
D. Lathrop vs. Bowman Dairy Company, to prove
the character of the alleged infringing machine.
These several exhibits show machines of different
construction in various essentials and are not in
conformity with each other. They do not show,
whether considered collectively or individually,
the combinations of elements set forth in any of
clains 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13, relied upon of
the Blair patent.
None of the exhibits shows an endless carrier
or carrier adapted to receive thereon and carry
the receptacles as set forth in claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10,
11, 12 and 13 of the Blair patent; none of them
- discloses cleansing medium pipes within the vat
and directed toward the interior of the recepta-
REE ents saahbeabirveuees —
REEL AEE NOE IEA Eg eR SEALS BESIDE SIS LIOR, SRS Real PRIS
- . ap pees a OEP LG
PhS REEL IM ENS CLI PITAL ER
PABA NTA NT REE PIP LS REMIND -
63
Affidavit
cles, set forth in claims 2 and 3; none of them dis-
closes the upright opposed discharge pipes having
lateral facing discharge openings, as set forth in
claims 9, 10, 11 and 12, and none of them discloses
other features above stated to form a part of the
claims relied upon.
I am unable to find in any of the exhibits the
construction set forth in any one of the claims 2,
3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 relied upon, and in my
opinion a machine constructed in accordance with
the showing in any one or all of these exhibits
would not infringe any of the claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10,
11, 12 and 13 of the Blair patent.
Iixhibit No. 4 contains a description reading:
“In the R. & A, hydraulic can washer the cans
are fed through the machines by pusher dogs
as shown in the illustration. There are two
pusher bars, one for the cans and one for the
covers, running the entire length of the mach-
ine and to which the ‘dogs’ are fastened. The
pusher bars move forward and back and with
each forward motion of the ‘dogs’ catch the
cans and covers and advance them one posi-
tion.’’
Insofar as the construction of the feeding mech-
anism ean be determined from the exhibits, the
cans are supported mouth-downward on A station-
ary track and are shoved along the track by the
above mentioned reciprocating dogs.
Drip pans or receptacl
. es for catching or saving
milk or other liquids dri
pping from milk cans or
187
188
189
FRET SINCE ROS
Uae Ne Ay
190
191
19
WSU TRON REA RR MTD
6-4
Affidavit
other receptacles were commonly known long be-
fore the application of the Blair patent in suit,
and driyj pans for catching and directing to a de-
sired point the drippings from milk cans or recep-
tacles in can and receptacle washing machines are
disclosed in the following patents:
498,549 Hodgdon May 30, 1893
781,692 Stubbs Feb. 7. 1905
850,199 Wright & Wright Apr. 16, 1907
864,132 Hood Aug. 20, 1907
Devices for catching and saving liquids dripping
from inverted cans and other analogous recepta-
cles are also disclosed in the following patents :—
483,757 Allgood Oct. 4, 1892
505,208 ’ Wayandt Sept. 19, 1893
639,378 Groterjan Dee. 19, 1899
These patents were not cited nor considered in
the Lathrop vs. Bowman Dairy Company suit.
In my opinion, it would not involve invention
or be patentable in view of such patents to pro-
vide a drip pan or receptacle under the carriers,
or at the front ends of the receptacle washing
machines shown in patents to
498,549 Hodgden May 390, 1893
546,205 Van Gilder Sept. 10, 1895
745,752 Adams & Rice Dec. 1, 1903
764,222 Adams & Rice July 5, 1904
850,199 Wright & Wright Apr. 16, 1907
864,132 Hood Aug. 20, 1907
ae ew fee oe
AF EENTIRRD TAT SEER RET Ta EE ORE AO aeT
65
Affidavit
to catch and save the liquid dripping from the
machines when they are placed mouth-downward
in the front end of such machines.
Patent No. 240,404, Gibbs, April 19, 1881, also
not cited nor considered in the Lathrop vs. Bow-
man Dairy Company suit, shows a dish washing
machine comprising a serics of three tanks in
which the dishes are placed and washed one after
another. This patent also discloses at the front
end of this machine in advance of the washing in-
strumentalities, a drip catching device P for eatch-
ing liquid dripping from the receptacle R before
the latter is placed in the first washing tank. The
patent also discloses a similar drip catching de-
vice II at the rear end of the machine beyond the
last washing tank for catching the drippings from
the receptacle R after it has been removed from
the last washing tank. This patent thus shows
the combination in a receptacle washing machine
of a series of washing instrumentalities in which
the receptacles to be cleaned are placed and wash-
ed successively, and devices for catching the drip-
pings from the receptacles to be washed, arranged
in advance of the washing instrumentalities.
In view of the state of the art at the time of the
application of the Blair patent in suit
, as shown
hy the patents above nientioned, the Claims of
the Blair patent relied upon, if valid, are entitled
only to a limited construction, and would not be
infringed by a machine which is not provided with
an endless carrier, or carrier adapted to receive,
support and carry the receptacles and constructed
193
195
196
197
198
66
Affidavit
substantially as disclosed in the Blair patent and
set forth in claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13
thereof.
FELIX EB. PROCHNOW.
Subscribed and sworn to, before me, this 31st
day of January, 1925.
MILDRED J. PITMAN
Notary Public
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF
NEW YORK
Harry D. LatHrop,
Plaintiff,
v8. In Equity No.
Riczs & Apams CorporaTION, 793-D
a Corporation,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ERIE ss
Barton A. Bean, Jr., being duly sworn, deposes
and says that he is an attorney at law and that in
the case of Harry D. Lathrop vs. Bowman Dairy
Company, in the United States District Court for
the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division,
he took a considerable portion of the testimony
~
57
Affidavit
on behalf of the defendant and is familiar with
the trial of that action and made the final argu-
ment in said cause before his Honor, Judge George
A. Carpenter, at Chicago;
That in said case there were substantial de-
fenses of prior invention and of prior use; that all
of the evidence in said cause was submitted in de-
position form and that on or about April 1923
deponent, together with other counsel from Buf-
falo, at the order of his Honor, Judge Carpenter,
proceeded to Chicago to present final argument in
said cause; that a hearing was not had at that
time, the Court stating, substantially, that it could
not give the time for such hearing on that date,
and requesting that the case be submitted on
brief so that it could quickly decide the case; that
the case was submitted on brief but no decision
was rendered at this time, and approximately nine
months later a request was made by Judge Car-
penter that counsel attend and argue the case
before him; that deponent was engaged at such
time on a case at Salt Lake City, Utah, and in
accordance with the Court’s request proceeded to
Chicago, arriving just in time for the argument;
that during the course of the argument Judge Car-
penter seriously questioned the inventive charac-
ter of the patent in suit but would not decide that
the patent was invalid, stating that the case should
be settled by the Court of Appeals, and finally
holding that as the patent was prima facie valid,
he would not disturb that status and urged that
counsel get the case to the Court of Appeals as
199
90
202
203
204
GS
Affidavit
soon as possible; so far as deponent is aware, the
case did not go to the Court of Appeals, but was
settled out of Court subsequent to Judge Carpen-
ter’s holding; that the Judge did not render any
written decision on the case, which written deci-
sion would have been illuminative as to the status
of the patent, and his view of the defenses urged
against the patent;
hat deponent has examined the supplemental
affidavit of Joshua R. H. Potts, subscribed and
sworn to the 28th day of January, A. D. 1925, and
says that he is familiar with plaintiff’s exhibit 4
referred to in said affidavit; that there was no
holding in the Lathrop v Bowman Dairy Company
ease referred to in said affidavit to the effect that
Plaintiff’s exhibit 4 illustrated and described the
machine complained of as being infringed or held
to be infringed in said suit; that in said suit there
were other exhibits introduced in evidence by the
plaintiff, to wit, exhibits Nos. 5, 6 and 8, as show-
ing the alleged infringing structure and that such
exhibits and plaintiff’s exhibit 4 differ and are
inconsistent, and that there was no ruling by the
Court in said Lathrop v Bowman Dairy Company
cuit that any one of these exhibits illustrated
the machine complained of or illustrated any
machine held to be an infringement of the Blair
patent in suit ;
That deponent has read and understands the
affidavit of Harry D. Lathrop filed herein and
says that there was no holding, ruling or decision
by Judge Carpenter in the Lathrop v Bowman
69
Affidavit
Dairy Company case that the feature of the
machines which were held to infringe the said
Blair patent was the ‘‘drip saver’’ or the arrange-
ment at the entry end of said machine whereby
the drippings from the cans or receptacles being
washed are saved uncontaminated by the washing
fluid, as alleged in said Lathrop affidavit, but the
decree in said Lathrop v Bowman Dairy Company
case held that claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 of
said Blair patent were infringed, and each of
these claims sets forth a combination of elements
in which the drip saver is only one feature;
That he has read the final decree entered in said
suit of Lathrop v Bowman Dairy Company and
the statement in said final decree ‘‘it appearing
to the Court that an interlocutory decree was
entered herein on January 21, 1924 holding the
patent to Blair for can washing machine, No.
880,713 * * * infringed by the defendant, the Bow-
man Dairy Company as to claims 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11,
12, 13 by using the can washing machine manufac-
tured and purchased from Rice & Adams Corpora-
tion’’, is not in accordance witld the interlocutory
decree ; that the interlocutory decree contained no
statement whatsoever with reference to the manu-
facture of the infringing machine by Rice & Adams
Corporation; that the final decree was not sub-
mitted to deponent for approval as to form and
that he did not know that the statement with refer-
ence to the manufacture of the machines by the
Rice & Adams Corporation appeared in the decree
until after it was entered, and that such state-
205
206
207
208
209
210
70
Affidavit
ment was not in the interlocutory decree, as alleged
in the final decree;
Further deponent saith not.
BARTON A. BEAN, JR.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 30th
day of January, 1925.
ALICE B. PRITCHARD
Notary Public
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Larurop,
Plaintiff,
vs. In Equity No.
Rice & Apams Corporation, 793-D
a Corporation,
Defendant.
AFFIDAVIT
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ERIE ”
ORLANDO ADAMS, being duly sworn, deposes
and says that he is the affiant whose affidavit sub-
scribed and sworn to the 26th day of January,
1925, was filed in the above entitled suit; that he
has examined the Exhibits numbers 4, 5, 6 and 8,
71
Affidavit
mentioned in the affidavits of Joshua R. H. Potts
filed herein and subscribed the 28th day of Jan-
uary, 1925; that he is familiar with the machines
manufactured and sold by Rice & Adams Corpor-
ation, the defendant in the above entitled cause ;
that since January 21, 1924, the date of the inter-
locutory decree in the suit in the United States
District Court for the Northern District of Illin-
ois, Eastern Division, entitled Harry D. Lathrop
vs. Bowman Dairy Company, in Equity No. 2239,
said Rice & Adams Corporation has not made,
used or sold any machine constructed as shown in
any of said exhibits numbers 4, 5, 6, and 8; that
said Company has never manufactured any can
washing or otlier machine constructed as shown in
the plaintiff’s exhibit No. 8, referred to in said
affidavit of Joshua R. H. Potts; that said exhibits
5 and 6 do not represent the same machine, but ill-
ustrate machines of entirely different construc-
tions, and that exhibit No. 4 illustrates a machine
which is essentially different in construction from
the machines shown in each of the other exhibits
numbers 5 and 6.
ORLANDO ADAMS
Subscribed and sworn to, before me, this 31st
day of January, 1925,
ALICE B. PRITCHARD
Notary Public
211
212
213
214
219
916
72
Opinion Denying Motion for Preliminary
Injunction
DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
WESTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Laturop,
Plaintiff,
against
Rice & Apams CorpPoRATION,
a Corporation,
Defendant.
in
Joshua R. H. Potts, Esq., Chicago, Ill,
for Plaintiff.
Mitchell & Staples, Buffalo, New York,
for Defendant.
Motion for injunction pendente lite.
The patent in suit expires next month. This
action against the defendant corporation, charging
infringement, was brought last month. The patent
was held valid and infringed in an action against
a customer of defendant in the District Court of
Illinois on January 21st, 1924, It is true that
defendant here was in privity therewith and ordin-
arily in the circumstances a preliminary injunction
would not be denied in another suit against the
manufacturer of the infringing device, but in the
present case, the plaintiff has delayed enforcing
his rights against the manufacturer, the vendor,
until within a very short time of the expiration
of his patent, and the suggestion in opposition
73
Opinion Denying Motion for Preliminary Injunctior.
that the restraining order is intended to be used
by plaintiff for advertising its machine is not with-
out force. Defendant satisfactorily shows that it
has not made or sold any can washing machines
embodying a drip saving device since the decree
in the Illinois case was announced. On a motion
for preliminary injunction pendente lite, the court
is required to consider the position of the parties
and the injury or benefit which, as said in West-
inghouse Air Brake Co. vs. Carpenter, 32 Fed.
484, may result to either from the granting or the
refusal of the injunction. I do not think that
injury will result to complainant by refusal to
grant the injunction at this time. Infringement
has ceased and the responsibility of the defendant
is unquestioned, and the recovery of damages, I
think, is sufficient protection for past infringe-
ments. See also Rousso vs. Barber, 276 Fed, 552.
And furthermore, the alleged infringement of the
claims relied on is strongly denied, and other pat-
ents not before the court in the Illinois case are
urged as anticipatory, but as to the denial of in-
fringement and reading of other prior patents, I
express no conclusion.
For the reasons stated, the motion for prelim-
inary injunction is denied.
DATED February 9, 1925,
JOHN R. HAZEL,
D. J.
217
219
220
221
7A
Order Denying Motion for Preliminary
Injunction
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR THE WESTERN DIS-
TRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Laruropr,
Plaintiff,
= In Equity No.
tice & ADAMS CORPORATION, 793-D
a Corporation,
Defendant.
The above cause having come on to be heard on
the 21st day of January, 1925, on motion of the
plaintiff for a preliminary injunction in accord-
ance with the prayer of the bill of complaint
herein, and upon aflidavits and exhibits filed by
the plaintiff and the defendant, and Joshua R. HH.
Potts, attorney for the plaintiff, having been heard
in favor of said motion, and Charles J. Staples
and Charles W. Parker, of counsel for the defend-
ant appearing specially, having been heard in
opposition thereto, and the Court having fully
considered the same.
Now, on motion of Mitchell & Staples, attor-
neys appearing specially herein, it is hereby
Ordered that the plaintiff’s motion for a pre-
liminary injunction be and it hereby s denied.
Dated, Buffalo, N. Y., March 8rd, 1925.
JOUN R. HAZEL,
District Judge.
es
fo
Affidavits and order to show cause why 223
cause should not be transferred
from Equity to Law Side of
Court, and extending
time to answer
Harry D, Laruropr, )
Plaintiff,
against In Equity No.
Rice & Apams Corporation, 793-D.
a Corporation, . 924
Defendant.
On reading and filing the affidavit ef Wm. P.
Conley, verified on the 4th day of March, 1925,
from which it appears that the plaintiff’s metion
for a temporary injunction hercin has been denied
and that the plaintiff has an adequate remedy at
law for damages, and that the defendant’s time to
answer or otherwise plead herein will expire on
the 11th day of March, 1925, and on the bill of
complaint and affidavits read on the motion for a 225
temporary injunction, and on all the papers filed
and proceedings heretofore had herein.
Now, on motion of Mitchell & Staples, appear-
ing specially herein, it is hereby
Ordered, that the plaintiff show cause before
this Court on the 17th day of March, 1925, at 10
o’clock in the forenoon, or as soon thereafter as
counsel can be heard, why an order should not be
made herein transferring this cause from the
equity side of the Court to the law side thereof,
and for such other, further or different relief as
226
227
nr
"3
Affidavits and Order to Show Cause
to the Court shall seem proper and competent to
grant in the premises, and it is further
Ordered, that the defendant’s time to answer
or otherwise plead or move herein, be and it is
hereby extended until the hearing and determina-
tion of this motion, and it is further
Ordered, that service of this order by mail on
Joshua R. H. Potts, Esq., Solicitor of the plaintiff,
on or before the 7th day of March, 1925, addressed
to him at 160 N. LaSalle St., Chicago, Hl, shall
be deemed sufficient service thereof.
Dated, Buffalo, N. Y., March 5th, 1925.
JOHN R. HAZEL,
District Judge.
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR THE WESTERN DIS-
TRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D. LatHrop,
Plaintiff,
against In Equity No.
Rice & ApaMs CorRpPorRaTION, 793-D.
a Corporation,
Defendant.
State of New York sz
County of Erie ss.
City of Buffalo
Wm. P. Conley, being duly sworn, deposes and
77
Affidavits and Order to Show Cause
says: that he is a member of the firm of Mitchell
& Staples, attorneys at-law, of Buffalo, N. Y., who
have heretofore appeared specially in the above
entitled action on behalf of the defendant therein;
that the complainant’s bill herein was filed on the
21st day of January, 1925, and was served with
an Equity Subpoena on the said defendant on that
day.
Deponent further says that a motion for a tem-
porary injunction herein was filed on the 23rd day
of January, 1925, returnable on the 26th day of
January, 1925; that said motion came on to be
heard on January 31st, 1925, and deponent’s said
firm appeared specially for the said defendant in
opposition to said motion, and that thereafter said
motion was denied, and that an order of this Court
denying complainant’s said motion for a tempor-
ary injunction was made and filed on the 3rd day
of March, 1925,
Deponent further says, on information and
belief, that the patent for the infringement of
which said suit was brought has already expired,
or is about to expire.
Deponent further says that on the 31st day of
January, 1925, the complainant’s attorney exe-
cuted a written consent to an extension of thirty
days for defendant to answer or otherwise plead
herein, and that an order has been made herein
extending defendant's time to answer or otherwise
plead herein to the 13th day of March, 1925.
Deponent, further says that the plaintiff has no
grounds for invoking the equitable jurisdiction of
229
230
231
232
233
284
78
Affidavits and Order to Show Cause
this Court; the motion for an injunction having
been denied and the Court having held in effect,
among other things, that if tho plaintiff has any
cause of action herein, he has an adequate remedy
at law for damages.
Deponent further says that the defendant de-
sires to have this case transferred to the law side
of the Court, and fears that its time to answer or
otherwise plead herein; may expire before a hear-
ing and determination can be had on a motion for
that purpose, and that the filing of an answer
before the determination of such motion might
be deemed a waiver of its objection to the equita-
ble jurisdiction of the Court herein, and, there-
fore, prays that the filing of an answer may be
deferred until the hearing and determination of
such motion. |
Deponent further says that no other application
has been made for the relief herein sought.
WM. P. CONLEY.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 4th day of March, 1925.
M. A. SULLIVAN,
Commissioner of Deeds
in and for the City of Buffalo, N. Y.
r
79
Opinion of District Court Denying
Motion to Transfer Cause
DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
WESTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry D, Laturop,
Plaintiff,
vs.
Rice & Apams Corporation,
a Corporation,
Defendant.
Joshua R. IL, Potts, Chicago, Illinois, for
Plaintiff,
Mitchell & Staples, Buffalo, New York,
for Defendant.
Ifazel, District Judge — This is a motion to
transfer the above entitled action to the law side
of the court. It is an action to restrain infringe-
ment of a patent owned by plaintiff, and a pre-
liminary injunction was demanded, but upon hear-
ing the motion it was ruled that since the patent
would expire within a short time, and as it was
denied that defendant sold the infringing wash-
ing machines, an injunction pendente lite should
be denied. There had been a prior decree in the
District Court of Illinois in an action against a
customer of defendant wherein the patent in suit
was held valid and infringed and it appeared that
defendant here was in privity therewith. In the
circumstances plaintiff had a right, at the time
235
to
co
D
240
80
Opinion of District Court Denying Motion to Transfer
this action was instituted, to commence in equity
and to assert that right to an injunction existed.
The cases cited by defendant on the point that an
adequate remedy at law existed at such time and
a remedy at law only existed, are not strictly in
point. As said in W. W. Sly Mfg. Co. vs. Cent.
Iron Works, 201, Fed. 683:
“Tf, however, facts existed when suit
was commenced which might, in any view,
sustain an injunction, the question is not
then one of jurisdiction, but one of dis-
cretion in the exercise vf jurisdiction.”
Moreover, the bill, seeks to recover an accounting
for profits and damages and accordingly the in-
junction was not the only equitable relief sought.
Clark vs. Wooster, 119 U. S. 322; Tompkin vs.
International Paper Co. 183 Fed. 773; Standard
Fashion Co. vs. Magrane Houston Co., 259 Fed.
793; Bradner Adjustable Hanger Co. vs, Water-
bury Button Co., 106 Fed. 735. And in Kittle vs.
DeGraaf, et al.,.30 Fed. 689, Judge Cox substan-
tially said that the fact that the patent in that
case expired three weeks after the commencement
of the action, standing alone, would not be suffi-
cient ground to deny equity jurisdiction; that as
the allegations of the bill entitled complainant to
equitable relief at the time the action was brought,
though only for a short period and on narrow
grounds, the cause should not be dismissed. There
are many adjudications that uphold this view. I
must therefore hold that the relief sought in the
bill was grantable and it was only denied by the
81
Order Denying Motion to Transfer Cause from Equity to
Law Side of Court
court in the exercise of its discretion, and the re-
quested transference to the law side under Equity
Rule 22 must be denied.
Dated, May 2, 1925.
JOHN R. HAZEL,
District Judge.
Order denying motion to transfer cause
from Equity to Law Side of Court
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT
OF NEW YORK
Harry D. Larurop,
Plaintiff,
against In Equity No.
Rice & Apams Corporation, 793-D.
a Corporation, ‘
Defendant.
A motion having been made in this ease to trans-
fer said cause from the equity to the law side
thereof, returnable on the 17th day of March,
1925, and after hearing counsel for the plaintiff
and the defendant and due consideration having
been had thereon
Now, on motion of Joshua R. H. Potts, attorney
for the plaintiff,
It Is Hereby Ordered that the said motion of
the said defendant to transfer said cause from
241
242
243
244
245
246
Clarence Edward Threedy
equity to the law side of the court be and the same
is hereby denied.
Dated, October 13, 1925.
JOHN R. HAZEL,
District Judge.
Filed October 13, 1925.
Plaintiff’s Depositions de bene esse
CLARENCE EDWARD THREEDY
Clarence Edward Threedy, being produced as &
witness in behalf of plaintiff, after being first
duly sworn in response to interrogatories of
counsel, testified, as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Richards:
Q. 1. State your name, age, residence and occu-
pation, please.
A. Clarence Edward Threedy; 30 years old;
residence 1240 Lill Avenue, Chicago, Illinois; pat-
ent specification writer.
Q. 2. Where are you now employed?
A. Victor J. Evans & Company.
Q. 3. Chieago?
A. Chicago.
Q. 4. Wherd were you employed in 19211
A. With Joshua R. H. Potts, Chicago.
Q. 5. I will ask you to state whether or not at
about the last mentioned date, you paid a visit to
a plant of the Bowman Dairy Company in Chicago
83
Clarence Edward Threedy
A. Yes.
Q. 6. When was it that that visit was paid?
A. About April 29, 1921,
Q. 7. And as near as you can state, where was
that plant located?
A. On the South Side—some place on Went-
worth Avenue, I believe.
Q. 8. Chicago, Illinois?
A. Chicago, Illinois.
Q. 9. And please state whether or not you saw
a milk can washing machine in operation there on
that date. Please answer t):it yes or no.
A. Yes. .
Q. 10. Can you describe that machine that you
saw there on that day briefly?
A. Yes, sir, briefly.
Q. 11. Please do so.
A. The machine was constructed to receive a
can in inverted, position at one end which consti-
tuted the receiving end of the machine, and was
intermittently removed in inverted position along
the machine to an end of the machine known as the
discharge end of the machine. The can passed
over a drip pan which received milk drippings
from the can draining therefrom because of its in-
verted position. This drip pan was positioned
under the machine adjacent the track-way over
which the can was intermittently moved. The
drip pan had an inclined bottom at its lowest point
from whickgthe milk drippings were drained from
the can to’a’can under the machine, for the pur-
pose,
247
218
219
250
251
84
Clarence Edward Threedy
Q. 12. Do you think you would recognize a cut
or picture of that machine if you saw one?
A. Yes, sir.
(. 13. I hand you a cut or picture of a machine
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit No.
By Mr. Staples: There are no exhibits in
yet if you please. I wish you would not refer
to any exhibits until offered.
By Mr. Richards: Now marked) for identi-
fication, Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 5, and ask you
to state whether or not you recognize the
same.
By Mr, Staples: I ask that you have these
exhibits marked in their order to avoid confu-
sion. I would like to get your identification
for the exhibits.
A. I do.
By Mr. Richards: Counsel for plaintiff re-
grets that he is unable to accommodate coun-
sel for defendant in this regard, inasmuch as
it is deemed advisable both for the conve-
nience of the court and the parties hereto to
have the exhibits which are introduced in evi-
dence in this case, and which are the same as
the exhibits which were introduced in evi-
dence in the case entitled ‘‘Lathrop v. Bow-
man Dairy Company, in Equity No. 2239, in
the United States District Court, for the
Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Divi-
sion,’’ similarly numbered in both cases.
By Mr. Staples: Defendant objects to any
85
Clarence Edward Threedy
irregular method of proof or the numbering
of any exhibits contrary to fact, and calls the
court’s attention that in the irregular num-
bering offered, there is an obvious attempt at
the outset to make reference to litigation
which is not this litigation, and which I am
advised has been settled.
Q. 14. What does that cut represent?
By Mr. Staples: Has this been offered in
evidence?
By Mr. Richards: Not yet.
A. This cut represents a can washing machine
substantially similar to the one J viewed at the
Bowman Dairy Company’s plant at Chicago.
By Mr. Staples: This is objected to and the
court is requested to strike out the evidence
insofar as it is a conclusion, and I call the
witness’ attention that we do not wish any
comparisons. It is improper, and a similar-
ity is not a description, and therefore we ask
you tq confine yourself to testimony of exact
observations.
By Mr. Richards: Theremarks of counsel
for defendant are objected to as constituting
argument with the witness, and an attempt to
dictate to and control the aetion of the wit-
ness.
By Mr. Richards: The cut identified by the
witness is offered in evidence as Plaintiff’s
Exhibit No. 5.
By Mr. Staples: May I ask one prelimin-
ary question?
253
254
255
86
256 Clarence Edward Threedy
By Mr. Richards: Just a minute.
Ly Myr, Potts: You haven’t made your
objection yet.
Py Mr, Staples: Objected to as incompe-
ten‘, immaterial 2-4 evidently from the tes-
timony of the witness a mere similarity and
not a picture of the machine at the Bowman
Dairy Company, and for the further reason
that this exhibit appears to be a sheet from a
OoT mutiliated catalogue and no connection in the
evidence is given between this advertising
picture and the machine attempted to be de-
seribed by the witness.
By Mr. Richards: The connection will ap-
pear later.
By Mr. Staples: That is objected to as
unnecessary comment by counsel. The best
evidence will be tha connecting link.
By Mr. Potts: Mr. Staples wants to make
all the comments.
258 By Mr. Staples: That is voluntary com-
ment by learned counsel, Mr. Potis.
Q. 15. I also hand you four leaves from a cata-
logue of the Rice & Adams Corporation, Buffalo,
New York, marked for identification, Plaintiff’s
Exhibit No. 6, and ask you to state what that is.
By Mr. Staples: That is objected to on the
ground that it is incompetent, immaterial, and
in that it is a statement in the question of an
assumed fact by counsel, which is not in evi-
dence.
A, This cut illustrates a can washing machine,
87
Clarence Edward Threedy 259
Q 16. And how does; that can washing machine
illustrated in that cut.
By Mr. Staples: That is objected to.
By Mr. Richards: Just a moment! compare
with or differ from the machine which you
Saw, as you State, in operation in the plant of
the Bowman Dairy Company, Chicago, Illin-
ois, on the occasion you have mentioned.
By Mr. Staples: That is objected to as
totally incompetent, immaterial and impro- 260
per, for the reason that in the question itself
it, states as facts, things which have not been
established in the evidence. Further, it calls
for conclusions, and the opinion of the witness
who has not been shown to be an expert, and
further it asked for a comparison with the
machine which the witness said he could
describe before the machine has been de-
scribed, and in order to make it clear to the
court and counsel, we will have no objections
to the fullest description of accurate observa- 261
tion of the witness, but we do object to having
comparisons of pictures not taken by the wit-
ness, and calling for the judgment and opinion
of the witness, a thing that is particularly the
province of the court, and I would like to have
it understood, instead of repeating this, that
all questions of comparisons and conclusions
and similarities, are objected to as incompe-
tent and immaterial, and merely a waste of
time for the consideration of what the truth
is in reference to a particular machine,
262
263
264
88
Clarence Edward Threedy
By Mr. Richa rds: In order to save time, it
may be considered and understood that the
same objection is offered to each and every
question asked by counsel for plaintiff, and
each and every witness taken into the case.
By. Mr. Staples: And all questions calling
for conclusions are under the same objection,
I understand.
A. The machine illustrated in this cut does not
disclose so far as I can determine, a drain pan
serving to catch the milk drippings from the in-
verted cans, which was included as a part of the
machine that I viewed at the Bowman Dairy Com-
pany, Chicago.
Q.17. The cut you refer to is the cut on the page
marked ‘‘Form 233’’, is that correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 18. I direct your attention also to the cut on
the page marked ‘Form 234’? and ask you to
answer the same question with respect to that cut.
A. Why this cut illustrates a can washing mach-
ine in which there is included as a part of the
machine, a drip pan serving to catch the milk
drippings from inverted cans. The drip pan is
similar to that one that was incorporated as a part
of the machine that I viewed at the Bowman Dairy
Company’s plant at Chicago.
By Mr. Staples: May I have the same re-
quest for all of the answers given by the wit-
ness, to wit, that comparisons and similarities
in statements of that kind, may be stricken
out without repeating the request made to
Clarence Edward Threedy
strike out the evidence?
By Mr. Potts: I understood that was
already in there.
By Mr. Staples: If it is, all right. It is
understood that I am objecting to all com-
parisons and similarities.
By Mr. Richards: You may consider that
such objection and such motion is introduced
as to each and every question.
By Mr. Staples: With the request that it
be struck out when it is answered.
By Mr. Richards: And that also.
Q. 19. Did you examine that machine and did
you notice whether or not it contained a manufac-
turer’s name plate, and if so, what did you ob-
serve in this regard?
By Mr. Staples: That is objected to as in-
competent and immaterial.
By Mr. Potts: I understand we have that
objection in all of' them.
By Mr. Staples: That is leading. He asks
him to describe it and then he goes on and
asks for particular things. It is objected to
as leading.
A. Why the machine that I viewed at the Bow-
man Dairy Company’s plant on the day I men-
tioned, included a name plate which was fixed to
the machine in some manner, on the north side of
the machine. The name plate included as a part
thereof, the wording, ‘‘Rice & Adams, Buffalo.’’
Q. 20 You stated, I believe, that when you saw
265
266
267
268
269
270
90
Clarence Edward Threedy
this machine it was in actual operation. What
was it doing?
A. The machine in operation was intermittently
moving cans from the receiving end toward the
discharge end of the machine, the cans being in
inverted position and a number of sprays were
directed toward the cans for cleansing the cans,
; ete.
Q. 21. And what, if anything, was this drip pan
which you have referred to, doing?
A. The drip pan that I referred to, was catch-
ing the milk drippings from the cans, as they
passed through the machine from the receiving
end to the discharge end.
Q. 22. And can you give us some idea as to the
quantity of the milk drippings the drip pan was
thus collecting? :
A. I didn’t quite get the question.
By Mr. Staples: That is objected to in add-
ition to the other objections as being immater-
ial, and no foundation that observation was
made about any quantities, and has nothing
to do with an infringement suit.
(Reporter reads question.)
A. There was a fairly good size stream passing
through the drain pipe of the drip pan, and if I
recall correctly, I think the can was approximately
one-half full with milk that had been caught from
drippings from cans passing through the machine
in inverted position.
Q. 23. And how, if you recall, were these milk
cans introduced into the machine?
91
Clarence Edward Threedy
A. Well, the milk cans, after the milk had been
emptied therefrom into a vat, were placed on wliat
you might term a platform, which moving mech-
anism engaged the can in its inverted position and
passed it through the machine.
Q. 24 I gather from your answer that it was
placed thereon by a man. Is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. 25. Was anything said on this occasion as to
the quantity of milk which was being saved, and
if so, what?
By Mr. Staples: This question is objected
to, it calling for a conversation, and as lead-
ing in suggesting that there was a conversa-
tion. It is incompetent, immaterial and high-
ly improper I think at this time of the case,
and not binding upon the defendant in any
way, and immaterial to the issue, and second-
ary proof at best, it not appearing that the
person who talked is available, and it not
offering any opportunity for cross-examina-
tion.
By Mr. Potts: If counsel wants to we will
subpoena all the officers of the Bowman Dairy
Company.
By Mr. Staples: It is immaterial what your
conversations were. It is rediculous to call
for conversations when the witness is here to
swear to what he himself saw and heard.
A. Yes. I was informed by a man at the plant
that the quantity of milk saved amounted to
approximately fifty pounds a day.
271
272
273
274
276
toe ‘
ee o
92
Clarence Edward Threedy
Q. 26. Who was the man who gave you this
information?
A. He was one of the workmen who was hand-
ling the milk cans, discharging the milk into a vat
and placing the cans on the machine to be moved
therefrom.
Q. 27. Referring now to Plaintiff’s Exhibit No.
5 which you have indentified, this consists of a
single sheet of glazed paper having cuts and illus-
trations on opposite sides thereof, the cut and
illustration on one side being marked ‘‘Form
179’ and the cut and illustration on the other side
being marked ‘‘Form 180’’, Is that correct?
A. Yes.
By Mr. Richards: The Exihibit No. 5, in-
cluding the cuts and description on both sides
thereof, is offered in evidence.
By Mr. Staples: You have offered that
before.
By Mr. Richards: Oh, yes.
By Mr. Staples: Well, if it is already in,
you are just merely referring to it more defin-
itely?
By Mr. Richards: That is all.
Q. 28. The exhibit which you have identified as
Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 6, consists of two sheets of
paper insecurely fastened together so that they
may become accidently easily separated, but con-
sisting of one sheet marked on one side ‘‘Form
235’’ and on the other side ‘‘ Form 236’’, and the
other sheet marked on one side ‘‘Form 233’’ and
|
93
Clarence Edward Threedy
the other side ‘‘ Form 234’’. Is that correct?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Richards: The exhibit identified by
the witness as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 6 is
offered in evidence including the cuts and
printed matter thereon.
By Mr. Staples: It is understood that the
same objection is offered to this exhibit as No.
5.
By Mr. Potts: I think that has been agreed
as applying to everything. It saves repeat-
ing it.
By Mr. Richards: That is all.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Staples:
XQ. 1. What is your work at the present time?
A. Patent specification writer.
XQ. 2. You have been engaged in patent work
since you were how old?
A. I can tell you better in years than how old.
XQ. 3. Well any way?
A. Seven years approximately.
XQ. 4. And in 1921 I understand you were in
Mr. Potts’ office here in Chicago?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 5. Were you admitted to the bar at that
time?
A. No. sir. |
XQ. 6. Are you admitted to the bar at the pres-
ent time?
277
278
279
280
281
282
94
Clarence Edward Threedy
A. No. sir.
«2. 7. Yon were employed by Mr. Potts in 1921,
and what were vou doing at that time, in 1921?
A. I was doing patent specification writing and
patent oflice drawings, as well as attending law
school.
XQ. 8. You had experience in patent office
drawings at that time?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 9. You were called in at different times to
observe facts in patent litigations by Mr. Potts
while you were working for Mr. Potts, the plain-
tiff in this case, and you had
By Mr. Potts: I am not the plaintiff in this
case.
By Mr. Staples: Oh no, not the plaintiff,
the attorney for the plaintiff—the handsome
Mr. Joshua Potts right in this room that we
refer to.
A. Mr. Potts in this room, yes.
XQ. 10 You were doing drawing work at that
time—making blue prints? ?
A. No, not making blue prints.
XQ. 11. What kind of drawings were you mak-
ing?
A. Patent Office drawings.
XQ. 12. Are those accurate drawings, or rather
careless drawings?
A. Accurate drawings.
XQ. 13. Had you any training in any kind of
accurate drawings at a!l?
A. Yes, sir, I had.
a
95
Clarence Edward Threedy
XQ. 14. And your reading such law as you have
read in patent office matters, has led you to see
the importance of accuracy in Patent Office draw-
ings? You realize that an inaccurate drawing has
very little weight in patent matters?
A. With certain exceptions, probably,
XQ. 15. Inaceuracies in those drawings are mis-
fortunes, are they not?
By Mr. Potts: This ling of cross-examina-
ation is objected to as not being cross-exam-
ination at all, but merely a lecture to the wit-
ness,
XQ. 16. You do not understand that I am lec-
turing you, do you?
A. You might be.
XQ. 17. You do not then understand me. I
want to see what your qualifications are in making
observations in 1921.
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 18. And you had had sufficient experience
at that time to make accurate measurements—
what other methods are there to get accuracies in
machine drawings besides a rule?
A. There are many other methods of doing that.
Close observation of the machine is one,
XQ. 19. Picture of the machine is another?
A. Yes, might be,
XQ. 20. And you cannot tell accurately about
the dimensions of any machine unless you measure
it?
A. No, not exactly,
XQ. 21. You cannot tell the substance of any
283
284
285
286
287
288
Clarence Edward Threedy
machine unless you take particular notice of the
parts thereof, to see that it is built of this kind of
iron, ete.?
A. Yes, to a certain extent.
XQ. 22. Now in 1921 was the first time you had
ever gone to the Bowman Dairy Company?
A. Yes, sir, the first time.
XQ. 23. How many times have you ever been in
the Bowman Dairy in your life.
A. First time as I said.
XQ. 24. Never been there since?
A. No, sir.
XQ. 25. Prior to that time had you ever seen &
can washing machine in the Bowman Dairy?
A. No, sir, not in the Bowman Dairy.
XQ. 26. That is the first time you had seen the
machine that you tried to describe here?
A. That particular machine, yes.
XQ. 27. How long were you in the Bowman
Dairy?
A. Somewheres between an hour and a half.
XQ. 28. Did you go with Mr. Potts, the lawyer
in this case and Mr. Richards? He is the lawyer
who has just been asking the questions of you.
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 29. Mr. Richards is associated with Mr.
Potts here in the patent law? '
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 30. You knew why you were going to the
Bowman Dairy, did you not?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 31. You knew you were going there to make
97
Clarence Edward Threedy 289
+ observations of a machine for a law suit?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 32. You knew you were, going to be called
upon to make a description of the machine when
you got back?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 33. Therefore, you were particularly
anxious to see and know definitely about that
machine, were yon not?
A. I was more particular to be accurate about 290
the machine.
XQ. 34 They probably told you things about
what you would see before you got there, didn’t
they?
A. Not that I recall.
XQ. 35. Didn’t they tell you about points that
they were complaining about?
A. I don’t recall.
XQ. 36. Would it be your best belief, going
down there with Mr. Potts the patent lawyer and
his counsel, Mr, Richards, as you did, and knowing
that there was a patent case on and you knew you
were going to be there a short time when you
went?
A. Well, I can’t say that.
XQ. 37. You may have a short time at the Bow-
man Dairy?
A. I can’t say that.
XQ. 38. Is it your best belief that they told yow
this machine was defective or that it Was an in-
fringement on account of this or that or the other
thing?
291
— —_——
292 Clarence Edward Threedy
A. They might have told me it was an infringe- ¢
ment.
XQ. 39. They might have talked about infringe-
ments?
A. I said they might have.
XQ. 40. Do you remember their saying anything
about a Lathrop-Paulson machine?
A. Undoubtedly they did.
XQ. 41. Didn’t they?
993 A. Well they wouldn’t take me out blindly as 1
though I was going to prison or something like
that. Certainly they did.
XQ. 42. Have you ever seen the Lathrop
machine?
A. I can’t say so, no.
XQ. 43 At the time you went there, you were
not fitted to make a comparison between the mach-
ine you were about to see and had'not seen, and
the machine you supposed it was infringing?
A. I believe I saw cuts of the Lathrop-Paulson
machine.
XQ. 44. So prior to this examination at the Bow-
man Dairy, your knowledge of the Lathrop-Paul-
son machine you think was an infringement, was
derived from cuts and pictures?
294
A. From drawings, I would say, rather than
cuts and pictures—patent office drawings.
XQ. 45. Had you had your attention called to
any particular feature of the patent drawings of
the Lathrop machine before you went to the Bow-
man Dairy?
99
Clarence Edward Threedy
A. I think they took the matter up, pointing
out the drain pan.
XQ. 46. That was the main thing, wasn’t it—
the drain pan?
A. That is one part of it.
XQ. 47. That is the outstanding feature, isn’t
it?
A. Yes, the outstanding feature.
XQ. 48. And as you think back over years that
have intervened, it is the milk pan or some kind
of a drain pan that was an outstanding feature?
A. The incorporation of a drain pan for the pur-
pose of catching the drippings of milk; to save the
drippings of milk.
By Mr. Staples: That is what I say.
By Mr. Potts: Let the witness answer his
question. I object to counsel interrupting.
By Mr. Staples: You haven't anything more
to say?
Witness: Not now, no.
XQ. 49. Were Attorney Potts and his associate
present all the time you were observing this mach-
ine?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 50. Was this conversation that you have
been telling about going on at the time you were
observing this machine?
A. Not at the time we were observing the mach-
ine.
XQ. 51. Was there anyone else present at the
time you were observing the machine?
A. Yes, there was.
295
296
297
100
298 Clarence Edward Threedy
XQ. 52. Did you have any difficulty in getting
into the plant of the Bowman Dairy?
A. No, sir.
XQ. 53. Perfectly courteous in inviting you in
there?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 54. What time of day was it?
A. I think it was in the morning, if I am not
mistaken. Quite certain it was in the morning.
299 XQ. 55. While you were observing the machine, }
did you talk with Mr. Potts and his associate
about parts of the machine?
A. Undoubtedly we did.
XQ. 56. Did you or did you not?
A. I wouldn’t say.
XQ. 67. You are not quite clear as to what took
place there?
A. Yes, sir, I am.
XQ. 68. Was the machine working all the while
you were there?
800 A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 69. Was it light? f
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 70. Could ‘you take a picture of the mach-
ine?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 71. Did you take a picture of the machine?
A. I didn’t. Not a photographic picture if that
is what you refer to.
XQ. 72. Yes.
A. No, sir.
101
Clarence Edward Threedy 301
: . XQ. 73. Such a picture would have given the
appearance of the machine, would it not?
A. Undoubtedly, it would.
XQ. 74. Did you make any measurements what-
ever?
A. Not measurements, no. .
XQ. 75. Any notes?
-A. No, sir.
XQ. 76. Now did you make any drawing of it?
A. No, sir, not out there. 309
XQ. 77. Did you make any drawing afterwards?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 78. An accurate drawing?
A. Substantially an accurate.
By Mr. Staples: No, not ‘‘substantially’’.
By Mr. Potts: I object to counsel telling
the witness what language he should use in
answer to the question.
XQ. 79. You used the word ‘‘substantially”’ in
your direct testimony a number of times. What
do you mean by ‘‘substantially’’? 3038
A. A near resemblance.
XQ. 80. Accurate?
A. No, you can’t say accurate.
XQ. 81. When you describe a machine and
describe it ‘‘substantially’’, do you have any re-
ference to what substance the machine is made of ?
A. Substantially, yes.
XQ. 82. Has your description made any refer-
ence thus far to the substance of the machine?
A. I haven’t made any statement to that effect.
aa es
304
305
306
“7
If it is wood or steel, it is substantially wood or
steel.
XQ. 83. Have you used the word substantially
102
lurence Edward Threedy
I’y Mr. Potts: 1 object to counsel asking
the witness as to what he said. He knows
what the witness has said. He has been here
to object to every question.
By Mr. Staples: 1 think the comments un-
ealled for. I am trying to find out, what the
witness means by a particular word and say- }
ing
By Mr. Richards: Just a minute
By Mr. Staples: I haven’t asked the ques-
tion
By Mr. Richards: Just a minute
By Mr. Staples: I haven’t completed my
question, and I don’t want two or three coun-
sels interrupting. I want to ask the witness
the meaning of his testimony and he is will-
ing to give it to me if counsel will permit.
By Mr. Richards: Just a minute
By Mr. Staples: 1 am going to complete my
question if I may. Do you mean when you say
substantially different as you have used it in
your testimony, that that has reference to
and modifies your description as to the mater-
jal substance the machines were made of?
You understand what I mean?
A. No, I don’t get the substance of the question
you ask me.
XQ. 84. Now I told you, you have used the word
substantially like or su!stantially similar, and said
103
Clyrence Edward Threedy 307
substantially several times, and I don’t know just
what you mean and I am trying to find out just
what you do mean. When you Say it is substan-
tially like it, you said you did not mean exactly
like it.
A. No, I didn’t.
XQ. 85. You didn’t mean that.
A. I didn’t say that. I mean by substantially
that if the principal thing you refer to is wood, it
is substantially wood, not iron or six inches.
XQ. 86. Have you given any testimony as to
iron, wood or six inches thus far?
A. Iam.
By Mr. Staples: Let the question be asked
By Mr. Potts: Let the witness answer his
question. I object to that. Every time this
witness starts to answer a question, counsel
interrupts him before he gets half way through
with his answer.
308
By Mr. Staples: Will the stenographer
please read the last question asked by Mr. 399
Staples?
XQ. 87. I refer you to the first exhibit that was
shown you, which the plaintiff, for his own pur-
poses, has numbered Exhibrt'5 and refer to Figure
385 thereof, and ask you this question: Were you
not asked on the direct examination, whether that
showed the machine that you saw at the Bowman
Dairy, and did you not answer, ‘‘It is substantially
the same machine’’ or words to that effect? Yes
or no?
A. Well I can’t answer two questions by yes or
, SSuEnEeeEeaeeen
=
104
810 Clarence Edward Threedy
no. You ask two questions in one, and I can’t
answer that.
XQ. 88. Did you, when this Exhibit No, 5 was
shown to you, say in referring to it, that the mach-
ine was substantially like the one you saw at the
Bowman Dairy, or not?
A. Yes and no.
XQ. 89. They do or
By Mr. Potts: The witness may answer the
question in any way he likes. 5
By Mr. Staples: Mr. Potts made that re-
mark.
XQ. 90. Did you get the question I just asked?
A. To have a perfect understanding, suppose
you ask me the question again?
XQ. 91. Have you, in reference to Plaintiff’s
first exhibit which is numbered No. 5, described
the cut on that exhibit as substantially like the
machine you saw at the Bowman Dairy?
A. I don’t know as I described this cut.
312 XQ. 92. Did you or did you not?
A. I said that this machine was substantially
the same as that I viewed at the Bowman Dairy
plant at Chicago.
XQ. 93. And is that true—that last statement?
A. It is absolutely true.
XQ. 94. And the use that you made of substan-
tially in reference to the testimony I have just
shown you on this cut, is the use you wish to be
understood by substantially?
A. That is the word I wish to use.
XQ. 95. Is there a milk saving device or drip
311
105
Clarence Edward Threedy 313
. pan of any kind or nature on that Exhibit 5.?
A. Yes, there is.
By Mr. Richards: The witness is instructed
that when Mr. Staples stands before him in
that dramatic attitude, and shakes his fist in
his face and shoves the exhibits in his face,
Mr. Staples does not mean to be discourteous
or attack him in any way, but it is simply his
way of being emphatic and that witness need
} not pay any attention. 314
By Mr. Staples: The Honorable Court
upon reading comments of counsel, will see
how humorous the same are in fact.
XQ. 96. On Exhibit 5, Figure 386, did you or
did you not decribe that as substantially the same
as the Bowman Dairy machine? Yes or no?
A. Yes,
XQ. 97. On the second exhibit which was refer-
red to by the plaintiff for his convenience as
Exhibit No, 6 in describing the so-cailed machine
of the Bowman Dairy, did you have reference to 315
the four pages of that exhibit in describing them
as substantially the same as the machine you saw
in the Bowman Dairy?
A. Not to the four pages, no.
XQ. 98. Did you have any reference whatever
in your testimony to Figure 613?
A. No, sir, not to Figure 613.
XQ. 99. Or to anything on the page to which
Figure 613 refers?
A. Only to identify that page as part of the
preceding page.
- —
316
317
318
108
Clarence Edward Threedy ; we
XQ. 100. You don’t know of your own know-
ledge, anything about this Page 235?
A. No.
XQ. 101. And did you, in your testimony, have
any reference to the page on which Form 236
appears, and that is the one on which plaintiff’s
Exhibit No. 6 appears?
A. No, sir.
XQ. 102. You did have reference, did you not, to
the page in which Form 233 appears?
A. I did.
XQ. 103. And you did describe the machine in
the Figure 545 as substantially like the machine
you saw in the Bowman Dairy?
A. I did not.
XQ. 104. Did you have reference in your testi-
mony to any thing on Page 233%
A. I did.
XQ. 105. To what did you refer in your direct-
examination?
A. The illustration of Figure 545.
XQ. 106. That is just what I asked you. You
misunderstood me here.
A. I probably: did.
XQ. 107. Then I understand now, that in your
direct examination you did refer to Figure 545
and did define that as substantially like the mach-
ine you saw in the Bowman Dairy?
A. No, sir.
XQ. 108. You did not? Is that substantially
unlike it?
A. Substantially unlike it.
107
Clarence Edward Threedy
XQ. 109. And Figure 534 is substantially like
or unlike?
A. Substantially like a can I saw out there, but
otherwise not.
XQ. 110. I notice in this 434—On the machine
you saw out there, was there a dog or wasn’t there
a dog?
A. I didn’t pay particular attention whether it
was a dog or pawl.
XQ. 111. Did you see any continuous endless
chain in the machine you saw out there?
A. I didn’t pay particular attention.
XQ. 112. Did you pay particular attention to
the mechanism of the machine other than you have
described it today?
A. That depends on what mechanism you have
reference to.
XQ. 113. As to the way the cans were carried
through the machine?
A. No, I didn’t pay any attention to that.
XQ. 114. Now did you make a cut—drawing?
A. Yes, I made a drawing.
XQ. 115. Have you that here?
A. I have not.
XQ. 116. How long after you made that draw-
ing, how long was it after you saw the machin
itself? ¥
A. That I made the drawing?
XQ. 117. Yes.
A. The same day.
XQ. 118. And in that drawing, did you embody
320
321
“3
108
322 Clarence Edward Threedy
as accurately as you could, all of the observations
you made on that day in 1921?
A. Substantially so.
XQ. 119. And that is your memory—well, I will
withdraw that. You haven’t that drawing?
A. No, sir.
XQ. 120. From your own memoranda, the draw-
ing that you made at that time, your memory of
the exact details would be refreshed, would they
not?
323 A. They, would, yes.
XQ. 121. These exhibits 5 and 6, were first seen
by you, when?
A. Those exhibits were first seen by me the
same time I made the drawing and after I had
been at the Bowman Dairy Company.
XQ. 122. Was the drawing which you made of
the machine in the Bowman Dairy, substantially
like Figure 545?
A. No, sir.
324 XQ. 123. Was there anything in it substantially
like Figure 434?
A. There might have been a bar which would
indicate a supporting bar for the can or the driv-
ing mechanism.
XQ. 124. Can you recall now whether you made
notice of what the driving mechanism was?
A. No, I can’t.
XQ. 125. Then you would not be able to swear
at this time that your description as you remember
it, would show anything either substantially like
or unlike, or either approach Figure 434 and may-
a
109
Clarence Edward Threedy
be the can illustrate 1 there, but nothing more than
where the can set?
A. On a bar.
XQ. 126. But you are not sure about that?
A. No, I am not sure about the bar.
XQ. 127. In referring to Exhibit, No. 5, Figure
386, did the drawing that you made correspond
substantially with that?
A. No, sir.
XQ. 128. It was substantially different?
A. Substantially different, yes, correct.
XQ. 129. Would you recognize the drawing that
you made at the present time?
A. I believe I would be able to.
XQ. 130. I show you a drawing. Is that exactly
like the drawing you made the day you went in
the Bowman Dairy and, examined the machine?
A. You say exactly?
XQ. 131. Exactly?
A. That is similar to the one I made.
XQ; 132. Is it exactly or not, or can’t you tell?
A. Yes, it is the exact reproduction of a draw-
ing I made the day I visited the Bowman Dairy.
XQ. 133. Is that as complete as you made it?
A. That I can’t recall. It may have extended a
little further.
By Mr. Staples: Mark for identification on
the back of that if you please, Defendant’s
Uxhibit No. 1 for identification.
XQ. 134. Does that show all that you remember
325
326
327
110
Clarence Edward Threedy
of th machine you say you saw in the Bowman
Dairy?
A. Well, that doesn’t show all that I remember,
because the drawing does not illustrate all that I
remember.
XQ. 135. Does it show all you remember in re-
ference to a drip pan?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 136. Does it show all that you remember in
the mechanism connected with the drip pan?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 137. Does it show what you observed in the
machine actually to exist in reference to the
guides?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 138. Does it show all that you remember
as to the method of movement?
A. The drawing does not show any method,
By Mr. Richards: The drawing identified
By Mr. Staples: Wait, I am not through.
By Mr. Richards: You are through with the
drawing. It isn’t
By Mr. Staples: I am not through with the
drawing. Because you objected and I cross-
examined after you got through with these
things, please let me complete with the wit-
ness. Then you can have him on direct.
By Mr. Richards: Are you through now—
are you sure you're through?
By Mr. Staples: Well, I am not through,
no.
By Mr. Richards: The drawing identified
111
Clerence Edward Threedy
by the witness is offered in evidence, and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 8.
By Mr. Staples: The defendant objects to
the plaintiff’s interrupting and violently de-
manding the right to interrupt at the cross-
examination, and objects to his offering any
evidence in exhibits out of their order while
he is cross-examining the witness, and asks
to have the comment of the attorney Richards
disregarded.
XQ. 139. (Witness i¢ shown drawing) Do you
recognize in that drawing the machine you saw in
the Bowman Dairy?
A. One end of the machine; more or less a dia-
grammatical illustration.
By Mr. Staples: Mark Defendant's Exhibit
No. 2 for identification.
By Mr. Richards: The drawing identified
by the witness is offered in evidence as Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit)No. 8-a.
By Mr. Staples: The same objection.
XQ. 140. I show you a cut, Mr. Threedy. Assum-
ing that this section A-B is a washing device—
can washing device, and that this C is a drip pan,
and that D is a drain; that the cans illustrated are
in the forepart of the washing machine. In your
opinion is that substantially what you saw there
except that the drip pan slants in a different di-
rection?
331
332
333
Vv —
112
334 Clarence Edward Threedy
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Richards: Objection is taken to the
examination of the witness as to his opinions,
and further objection is made to the question
and answer as to this exhibit, as not being
proper cross-examination, and motion is here-
by made to strike both the question and
answer from the record.
By Mr. Richards: Counsel for defendant
is formally requested on the record to permit
the Notary to mark the two exhibits which
were identified by this witness and offered in
evidence by the plaintiff, with the Notary in-
dicated, in this record.
By Mr. Staples: Defendant says that he
will welcome at the proper time and place the
admission of all exhibits presented by the
plaintiff.
By Mr. Richards: Counsel for plaintiff
wishes this record to show that counsel for
336 defendant has taken physical possession of
the exhibits in question, and refuses to permit
Notary to mark them as requested.
XQ. 141. Witness, I am showing you a drawing.
Do you recognize what that describes roughly?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 142. Substantially does it in any respect
represent what you saw at the Bowman Dairy?
A. Substantially with reference to the drain
pan it does.
XQ. 143. Does it?
A. Yes, sir.
335
118
Clarence Edward Threedy
By Mr. Staples: That is plaintiff’s
By Mr. Richards: Not the plaintiff’s if you
please.
By Mr. Staples: Defendant’s Exhibit No.
4 for identification, and defendant states that
he will have this exhibit and all others which
have been referred to this witness in court,
for the purpose of such action of consent or
objection as plaintiff wishes to make thereon.
XQ. 144. Do you recognize that?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 145. What is it?
A. That is a can washing machine having a drip
pan attached thereto at one end, apparently for
catching the milk drippings from the can in an
inverted position, as it passes through the mach-
ine.
XQ. 146. Now, Mr. Witness, look carefully.
Does that not illustrate and show just exacily
what you saw at the Bowman Dairy?
A. Substantially what I saw out there.
XQ. 147. And does it not represent everything?
A. In substance, yes.
XQ. 148. And I show you another cut. Does
not that cut show everything just exactly as it was
and as you observed it?
A. In substance, it does, yes.
By Mr. Staples: Plaintiff’s Exhibit for
identification
By Mr. Richards: Not plaintiff’s
337
338
339
840
341
342
114
Clarence Edward Threedy
By Mr. Staples: I beg your parden De-
fendant’s Exhibit No. 5.
XQ. 149. Now, Mr. Witness, you have noticed
in each of these exhibits that I have been showing
you, 1 to 5, differences, have you not?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 150. There hasn’t been a description in any
of them of the can washing mechanism and the
means of conveying the cans through the machine?
A. Just a slight illustration of a pawl and a
dog in one of them.
XQ. 151. But there hasn’t been a representation
in any of the pictures you have yet ~een in this
entire testimony of any continuous endless chain
carrier, has there?
A. No.
XQ. 152. And the substance of each drip pan
or can or milk saver has been, hasn’t it, a can de-
vice in front of the milk washing machine, so
positioned as to get the drippings that come down
by gravity into some receptacle below the cans?
A. You say in front of it? The can in front of
the drip pan id that what you say?
XQ. 153. That is substantially correct, is it not?
A. Substantially correct, yes
XQ. 154. Now you were asked about the quan-
tity of milk saved. You haven’t any accurate
knowledge of it beyond, as you say, a fairly good-
sized stream?
A. Yes.
XQ. 155. You didn’t make measurements?
115
Ciurence Edward Threedy
A. Not personally,
XQ. 156. All there is to that, is that milk that
drained out of the cans as far as you could see, by
gravity, went down through the drain pan and
into the pot below. It that correct?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 157. That is all there was to it?
A. Yes, sir.
XQ. 158. You have seen drains of various kinds
before in connection with other machines?
A. Probably have.
XQ. 159. Nothing strange or peculiar about the
drain you saw there?
By Mr. Richards: This line of cross-exam-
ination is objected to as improper cross-exam-
ination,
XQ. 160. Was there anything new or peculiar
that you saw in that machine?
A. Noy sir.
XQ. 161. Just as common observation, were you
brought up on a farm?
A. No, sir.
XQ 162 Did you have anything to do with a
farm?
A. Not in a general way.
XQ 163. Did you ever see anyone wash any milk
cans?
A. Yes.
XQ. 164. Did you ever see anyone wash milk
cans that didn’t turn them bottom side up?
A. Maybe or maybe not,
343
345
346
347
348
116
Clarence Edward Threedy
XQ. 165. Is there any way of draining a milk
ean except by turning it upside down?
A. No, sir.
Re-Direct Examination by Mr. Richards.
RDQ 1. You spoke in your cross-examination
of having made a drawing of this machine which
you saw in the plant of the Bowman Dairy Com-
pany on the occasion indicated. Please state if
you know, what has become of that drawing.
A. I don’t know.
RDQ. 2. Have you any idea?
A. No, sir, I haven’t.
RDQ. 3. Have you heard it discussed recently?
A. Yes, sir, I have.
RDQ. 4. In what connection?
By Mr. Staples: That is incompetent and
immaterial.
A. That the drawing has been lost.
RDQ. 5. I hand you the five exhibits that you
identified before Mr. Staples and ask you to state
which, if any of them, correctly represent that
drawing that you made on that occasion.
A. There are two of them here that represent
the drawing that I made—those two there.
By Mr. Richards: The witness picked out
Defendant’s Exhibit No. 1, Defendant’s Exhi-
bit No. 2, and Defendants Exhibit No. 5.
By Mr. Staples: You mean Defendant’s
Exhibits for identification?
By Mr. Richards: Yes.
RDQ. 6. And as I understand you then, Defen-
117
Clarence Edward Threedy
dant’s Exhibits 1 and 2 substantially correctly ill-
ustrate the machine which you saw in operation in
the plant of the Bowman Dairy Company, Chica-
go, Illinois, in April, 1921. Is that correct?
By Mr. Staples: Now wait a minute! That
is objected to on the ground that it is leading,
and on the ground that the question cannot be
answered because it asks for both whether it
is substantially the same or exactly the same,
and there is a difference, which is the differ-
ence in this law suit perhaps.
By Mr. Richards: The question is of course
leading, and purposely so, but it is thought
legitimately so under the circumstances pre-
sented here.
A. Yes, sir.
RDQ. 7. Referring now to Plaintiff’s Exhibit
No. 5, please refer to the machine illustrated on the
side thereof, marked Form 179, aad state wherein
that cut differs from the machine which you thus
saw in operation in the Bowman Dairy plant.
A. Well, this machine illustrated in this cut
apparently has means for moving cans through
what appears to be a housing, and this illustra-
tion here differs from the machine that I saw at
the Bowman Dairy. Company’s plant at Chicago,
by not having incorporated as a part thereof, the
means for catching and carrying away the milk
drippings from the can in inverted position.
RDQ. 8. As I understand you, otherwise this
machine is substantially the same as you saw on
that occasion?
350
351
352
353
118
Clarence Edward Threedy
A. { would say so, yes.
RDQ. 9. Now answer the same question with
reference to the machine illustrated on the other
side of said exhibit, irj the cut marked Form 180.
A. The machine illustrated in this cut also has
mechanism for intermittently moving cans through
the machine. ‘This machine is provided with a
drip or drainage pan which serves to catch the
milk drippings from the cans in inverted positions,
and is substantially similar to that one that I ob-
served at the Bowman Dairy’s plant at Chicago.
RDQ, 10. Then I take it that this cut correctly
illustrates the machine that you saw on that occa-
sion?
By Mr. Staples: That is objected to as lead-
ing. He said substantially and the witness
has already answered.
By Mr. Potts: Substantially is correct.
By Mr. Staples: Mr. Potts has added from
the side lines' further testimony.
A. It is substantially correct.
RDQ. 11. I also note the same distinction in
Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 6, namely that the cut in
the illustration marked Form No 233 does not
disclose a drip saver and the illustration in the cut
marked Form 234 does disclose a drip saver. Do
you draw the same distinction here?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Richards: That is all.
Re-Cross Examin:tion By Mr. Staples:
RXQ. 1. Now, Mr. Witness. in making your an-
119
Clarence Edward Threedy
swers in reference to your exhibits—these exhi-
bits that have been referred to you—whether they
are substantially correct or not substantially
correct depends whether you see in the picture or
in the cut, a milk saving device—that is the sub-
stance of it, isn’t it?
A. No, sir.
RXQ. 2. What other substance is there in, con-
nection with the milk washing machine?
A. If it is a substantial resemblance of the
machine that I have observed ati the Bowman
Dairy’s plant.
RXQ. 3. In what particulars?
A. In the particular with the arrangement of
cans which) appear to be intermittently moved
through the can washing machine over a drip or
drainage pan at one end of the machine.
RXQ. 4. Did your answers depend upon the
nature of the mechanism—whether it was a con-
tinuous chain or not?
A. No, they did not.
RXQ. 5. They didn’t have anything to do with
the mechanism?
A. None.
RXQ. 6. Did they have anything to do with the
cans being inverted?
A. Yes.
RXQ. 7. Then you came to your answer by see-
ing cans inverted, and if there wasn’t the milk
saving device as in Figure 386, then you said that
wasn’t substantially, but there isn’t any milk sav-
ing device in 386, and therefore you say it.
855
356
357
358
360
120
Clarence Edward Threedy
A. Yes.
RXQ. 8. In Figure 386, were there other facts
in that figure that led you to the conclusion that it
was substantially different?
A. What is the question?
RXQ. 9. The question is, is 386 substantially
like or substantially different?
A. It is substantially different.
RXQ. 10. Now you come to that conclusion that
it is substantially different, because there was
lacking what?
A. A milk drain or pan.
RXQ. 11. And that is the whole thing on that
figure?
A. In one respect.
RXQ. 12. Now on Figure 385, I think you said
that was substantially like?
A. Yes.
RXQ. 13. The reason you gave that testimony
was that in this picture you detect a drip pan, was
is not?
A. That is one of the points.
RXQ. 14. The essent
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.