Transcript of Record — Austin Nichols & Co. v. The Isla De Panay. Sanchez v. Same. E. Tolibia & Co. v. Same
Supreme Court brief1925
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(29,919, 29,920, 29,921)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1928
_ No. 609
AUSTIN NICHOLS & COMPANY, PETITIONER,
V8.
STEAMSHIP ISLA DE PANAY, HER ENGINES, ETC.,
COMPANIA TRASATLANTICA
No. 610
EUG. SANCHEZ AND JOSE GILDE SAGREDO, COPARTNERS,
TRADING AS E. SANCHEZ & COMPANY, PETITIONERS,
vs,
c STEAMSHIP ISLA DE PANAY, HER ENGINES, ETC..
COMPANIA TRASATLANTICA
No. 611
E. TOLIBIA & COMPANY, PETITIONER,
i vs.
STEAMSHIP ISLA DE PANAY, HER ENGINES, ETC.,
COMPANIA TRASATLANTICA
.
ON WRITS OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
= INDEX
Original Print
Record from U. S. district court for the southern district of
SN PS hk TO ol ks ok Pe ae LS ra ek Cea 1 1
RE ee CPS Nny I ey SoBe erg Crate rater atk oA 1 1
Jupp & DetTweiten (1Nc.), PRINTERS, Wastixcrox, D. C., Fennvary 15, 1924
a
ll INDEX
Original Print
Libel of Austin Nichols & Company.....-..-----+++eeeee ks 2
Pe MPETT POV CTTECTOT TTT Te 7 3
Libel of Sanchez & Company...... 6... cece eee e eee eeeees 18 S
NE cnc kh seth ee che Se ReaGEae 0660RK0066 5666. 000006 2 o
Libel of E. Tolibia & Company...... 2... eeeeee ee eee eeeee 33 14
i cc cedcK Cena Res aths Cus ee cen eedeennagnscdecens 37 15
a cc ck cba nga CaRa kad Cae CR aKD ARSENE EA aD asec decease 49 20
Testimony of J. D. Sagredo.... 2... 0s. eee ee eee eee eee mM 20
Charles A. Thayer.........0-2eseeeeeee a7 3
Fred C. Rodman. .......cccescccccceccs Gt 20
Collin Chivers. ....cccccccccccccccccess 8o 3S
Antonio Richichi........ccccccccccccses oH 46
Robert Forbes. .....ccscccccccccccccces 106 53
Frramic BARRO... cc cccccccccccccecccece 107 BS
Salvatore Noto. ......ccsccccccccsscccs 416 60
Wend B. Pee. cc ccc cc cscccccccccccces 121 63
Walter George Cocks............-se0-0: 134 69
Stipulation as to manner of taking testimony and read-
ing depositions in evidence in other actions......... 139 72
Testimony of Arturo Muslera........++++eee eee ee eens 140 72
Arturo Muslera (recalled)............. 168 S89
Jose Ma. Miquel:........ccseececcecees 171 90
Miguel Corvera...........eseeeeeeeeee 192 103
Emilio Bardecci..........- Tee eee ee - 219 120
Antonio Oliveros. .....cccssscccccceces 240 133
Antonio Oliveros (recalled) .........+.. 27 137
Arturo Muslera (recalled)...........-- 24 141
Interrogatories to Antonio Pastrana............++++ 27 15
Cross-interrogatories to Antonio Pastrana.........++- 286 156
Interrogatories to Jose Montiel and Diego Garcia. . 317 170
Cross-interrogatories to Jose Montiel and Diego Gane. 330 175
Interrogatories to Manuel Samano and Mariano San-
SE ere Te eee eT ets CTT ee oe <hiekens an 374 193
Cross-interrogatories to Manuel Samano and Mariano
ARN none cn ccncecccncceccccccaccaceces «ceases 380 196
Interrogatories to Eduardo Benjumea....... TCT a 208
Cross-interrogatories to Eduardo Benjumea.......... 418 211
Libellants’ Exhibits 1, 2, and 3—Survey reports...... 428 215
Claimant's Exhibit 2—Bill of lading............++.55+ 435 215
Claimant's Exhibit 11—Copy of protest........... eas 219
Claimant’s Exhibit #2—Cargo plan..........seee55: . 48 220
Claimant's Exhibits 13, 14, and 15—Letters........... 449 220
Stipulation as to libel and case of Tolibia & Company.... 452 221
Opinion, Augustus N, Hand, D. J......-.-.+++++ sheuaseis 44 222
Final decree (Austin Nichols & C0.) .....0e cee cere eens 457 223
Final decree (Sanchez & Co.) ... 6... ce eee e eee ees cccccee ©~=6GD 224
Final decree (Tolibia & C0.) ........00eeees in taeekeeeens 461 224
Order consolidating causes... ........ceeeeaes Kpaanis a 225
Sst a Re ae ° = i
INDEX ili
Original Print
Stipulation consolidating causes.................0.00005. 465 226 .
SM NA aw BE Ui 6:5 i645 scabs teseedenteaseagccs 467 226
Ch D see a bb 50d 408 baba «kb dSKcAC dé kn 469 227
mY WU UP UII as css cn scptaccscucececcccccns 475 230
NM IO So bay vcs a oda duu suev cece nvcshavice 477 230
ee Ny nse dw 4 005 bined Kaos buaeencdeevecte 478 230
PO MR, Ms Se vs nua ces ins sho'eansebecneeccevce 480 231
OG SE 5 nn SSixien ae eae ws als 480 231
EE SEERA TE ha es kK GD 08 O5se bd6 854 db'e i s'oe 0a apie DOS 242
SE Ss ENS. 5/00 Swag dds daphne Whabv seabed cuca ve 5 YAS
Order granting petition for writs of certiorari................ 510 244
Bea Pagal ee
REI NIE ag HF sore " ommenesencennonans _ — a . ome _—
1
[fol. 1] UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, SOUTHERN
DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Docket No. 64—312
Austin Nicuots & Company, Libellant,
against .
Steamship “Ista pe Panay,” Her Engines, etc., Claimant
Docket No. 64—306
Eva. Sancnez and Jose Gripe Sacrepo, Copartners, Trading as E.
Sanchez & Company, Libellants,
against
Steamship “Ista pe Panay,” Her Engines, etc., Claimant
Docket No. 84—389
E. Tourpia & Company, Libellant,
against
Steamship “Ista pe Panay,” Her En ines, ete., Cluimant
Pp g
STATEMENT
. Filed libel of E. Sanchez & Company.
[fol. 2]
Dee. 21.
1918.
Filed libel of Austin Nichols & Company.
May
19
May
16.
18.
17.
Filed answer to the libel of Austin Nichols & Company.
1919.
May
1922.
March 18,
27.
Filed answer to libel of E. Sanchez & Company.
Issued Commission to Seville, Spain.
Filed commission and deposition from Seville, Spain.
Sept. 20. Filed libel of E. Tolibia & Company.
“29. Filed stipulation consolidating cases for trial.
Oct. 3. Cause called and tried (A. N. Hand, J.), for libellants,
ie 9°
Nov. 6.
a % Filed final decree.
four witnesses sworn, and three exhibits put in.) For
claimant six witnesses sworn, eleven depositions and
ten exhibits put in.
Argued and submitted.
Filed opinion, libels dismissed,
Filed answer to libel of E. Tolibia & Company.
1—609
ETE RRO T s
2
Dec. 4. Filed order consolidating cases for appeal.
< 5. Filed notice of appeal.
se 5. Filed assignment of errors.
[fol. 3] Ix Unitrep States District Court
+ LIBEL
(Austin Nichols & Company)
‘To the Honorable the Judges of the District Court of the United
States for the Seuthern District of New York:
'The libel and complaint of Austin Nichols & Co., Inc., a corpora-
tion against the Steam#hip “Isla de Panay,” her engines, boilers, ete.,
in a cause of cargo damage, civil and maritime, alleges and respect-
fully shows on information and belief to this Honorable Court as
follows:
First. Your libeUant is a corporation, duly organized, created and
existing under and by virtue of the laws of the State of New York,
with an office and place of business at No. 100 Hudson Street, in the
Borough of Manhattan, City of New York, and is the owner of the
damaged merchandise hereinafter mentioned.
Second. The steamship “Isla De Panay” is now and. will be dur-
ing the pendency of process hereunder, within the Southern District
of New York, and within the jurisdiction of this Honorable Court.
Third. On October 27th. 1917, Rowlett Y Pyman, shipped and
placed on board the steamship ‘Isla De Panay” then lying at the port
{fol. 4] of Cadiz, Spain two hundred and twenty-seven (227) pack-
ages of olives in good order and condition to he carried by the said
steamship “Isla de Panay” as a common earrier from the port of
Cadiz to the port of New York and there to be delivered in like good
order and condition as when shipped io your libellant in accordance
with the terms of bills of lading then and there issued for the said
shipment and in consideration of an agreed freight.
Fourth. Thereafter the said steamship “Isla de Panay” sailed
from the port of Cadiz and arrived at the port of New York in the
month of November, 1917. and there discharged her cargo, but not
in like good order and condition as when shipped but badly damaged.
Fifth. By reason of the premises, your libellant has sustained dam-
age in about the sum of Eleven Thousand ($11,000) Dollars, as
nearly as the same can now be estimated, no part of which has been
paid, although duly demanded.
Sixth. All and singular the premises are true and within the
admiralty and maritime jurisdiction of the United States and of this
Honorabte Court.
3
Wherefore, libellani prays that process in due form of law accord-
ing to the course and practice of this Honorable Court in causes of
[fol. 5] Admiralty and Maritime jurisdiction, issue against the said
steamship “Isla de Panay,” her engines, boilers, ete., and that all
persons having or claiming any interest therein be cited to appear and
answer all and singular the matters aforesaid; that this Honorable
Court be pleased to decree to your libellant its damages, with interest
and costs, and that the steamship “Isla de Panay,” her engines, ete.,
be condemned and sold to satisfy the same, and that your libellant
may have such other and further relief as in law and justice it may
be entitled to receive. °
Harrington, Bingham «& Englar, Proctors for Libellant, No.
64 Wall Street, New York City.
[fol. 6j Jurat showing the foregoing was duly sworn to by E. F.
Bushnell omitted in printing.
[ fol. 7] In United States District Court
ANSWER
To the Honorable the Judges of the District Court of the United
States for the Southern District of New York:
The answer of Compania Trasatlantica, claimant and owner of the
Steamship “Isla de Panay” to the libel and Complaint of Austin,
Nichols & Co., Inc., against the Spanish Steamship “Isla de Panay”
her engines, ete., in a cause of contract and cargo damage, civil and
— alleges and respectfully shows to this Honorable Court as
follows:
First. It denies any knowledge or information sufficient to form a
belief as to the allegations set forth in paragraph marked “First” of
the libel herein.
Second. It admits the allegations set forth in paragraph marked
“Second” of the libel herein.
Third. It admits and alleges that on or about the 6th day of No-
vember, 1917, there were shipped on board the steamship “Isla de
Panay” then at the port of Cadiz Spain and bound for the Port of
New York, 227 casks said to contain olives, the weight and contents
of said casks and their quality, however, being stated to be known to
[fol.8] the claimant, which expressly declined to be responsible
therefor.
It further admits and alleges that it was agreed that the mer-
chandise should be transported for a stipulated freight to the Port
of New York and there be delivered to the order of the libellant sub-
jeet to the conditions and exceptions from liability contained in the
bills of lading issued for said merchandise at Seville, Spain, from
which port said merchandise was shipped; in the first instance.
4
Further answering it denies each and every allegation set forth in
paragraph marked “Third” of the libel herein except as hereinabove
expressly admitted or denied.
Fourth. It admits and alleges that thereafter the steamship “Isla
de Panay” sailed from the Port of Cadiz, Spain and arrived in due
course at the Port of New York in the month of November, 1917,
and that it thereafter delivered at the Port of New York all of the
above mentioned merchandise which it received on board the ship
at Cadiz in pursuance of and in compliance with the terms and con-
ditions of the bills of lading hereinabove referred to.
Futther answering it denies each and every allegation set forth in
paragraph marked “Fourth” of the libel herein except as hereinabove
expressly admitted or denied.
Fifth. It admits and alleges that the libellant has demanded pay-
[fol. 9] ment of its alleged damage and that payment thereof has
been refused but denies that any damage was suffered by the libellant.
Further answering it denies each and every allegation set forth in
paragraph marked “Fifth” of the libel herein except as hereinabove
expressly admitted or denied.
Sixth. It admits the jurisdiction of this Honorable Court but
denies the truth of the premises.
Further answering the libel herein as a first, separate and distinct
defense herein, and re-alleging the denials and allegations herein-
~— pleaded as if they were again set out in full, the claimant al-
leges:
Seventh. I. That the bills of lading for the carriage of the said
merchandise hereinabove referred to contained, among others, the
following provisions, terms and stipulations, subject to which the
carriage was expressly made:
“7 The Company is not responsible for damages or losses caused
by the sea, the winds * * * or any unforseen cause, or o¢-
casioned by juridical acts of any class and nature of the captain,
crew or lightermen, the partics interested in the cargo expressly
renouncing the right to demand any civil responsibility, direct or
subsidiary, which may arise from the laws and especially from Arti-
cles 587, 618 and 620 of the Commercial Code and from Article 21
[fol. 10] of the Penal Code (of Spain). Also not responsible for the
contents, weight and quality of the packages; for damage caused by
other goods; for errors in delivering same caused by insufficient or
illegible marking or for breakage of the articles and fragile con-
tainers. Also not responsible for loss, damage and average caused
to the goods by rats or other rodents.”
“10. The unloading is to be done by the vessel, however, for the
account and risk of the receivers, according to the tariff or custom
of each port, the agent of the vessel being authorized to present the
Declarations at the Customs in accordance with the contents of the
bill of lading.”
oe eS. ee
“11. Delivery must be taken upon the unloading of the goods, the
packages to be exchanged for the bills of lading after the payment
of the freight in case the same has not been paid at the time of load-
ing * * *. Not responsible for misplacement or damage to
goods that have not been received by the interested parties at the
moment of unloading * * *. It is understood that from the
moment the goods have left the deck of the vessel, marine risks,
damages, ete., are for the account of the receivers.”
“18. Even though this bill of lading is not signed by the shipper,
the shipper, by taking this bill of lading, agrees to all the conditions
of same.”
[fol. 11] II. The claimant exercised due diligence to make the
steamship “Isla de Panay” in all respects seaworthy and properly
manned, equipped and supplied for the voyage mentioned in the
libel, and the steamship “Isla de Panay” was in fact in all respects
seaworthy, properly manned, equipped and supplied at the beginning
of such voyage, and the cargo was in every respect properly loaded.
stowed, cared for and delivered.
IL. If there was any loss of or damage to any of the merchandise
referred to in the libel herein, which is not admitted, it was caused
hy one or more of the following causes mentioned in the exemptions
in the above enumerated causes of the bills of lading: (a) the sea;
(b) the winds; (c) unforeseen cause; (d) juridical acts of the captain,
crew or lightermen; (e) damage caused hy other goods; (f) insufli-
cient or illegible marking; (h) breakage of articles; (i) fragile con-
tainers; (j) to other causes excepted by the bills of lading herein-
before referred to from liability for which the steamship “Isla de
Panay” and the claimant, by the conditions and exceptions in the
said bills of lading are expressly excluded,
IV. That if the said alleged damage to the libellant’s merchandise
Was occasioned by the negligence of the claimant’s servants and
employees, which is not admitted, the claimant herein is not respon-
sible therefor, by reason of the clause numbered “7” of the bill of
lading, providing, part. as follows:
Ifol. 12] “The Company is not responsible for damages or losses
caused by * * * juridieial acts of any class and nature of the
captain, crew or lightermen, the parties interested in the cargo
expressly renouncing the right to demand any civil responsibility,
direct or subsidiary, which may arise from the laws and especially
from Articles 587, 618 and 620 of the Commercial Code, and from
Article 21 of the Penal Code (of Spain).”
That Section 618 of the Commercial Code of Spain, its rights under
which the libellant by the aforesaid stipulation has expressly re-
nounced, provides in part as follows:
“The captain shall be civilly liable to the ship owner and the
ship owner to the third partics having contracted with him:
Ist. For ali the damages the ship or her cargo may suffer from
lack of skill or mismanagement.”
AA NERA MG de OK ER LONI thi eee
V. That if any damage was caused to the libellant’s merchandise
by the claimant’s servants and employees, which is not admitted, it
was occasioned by the juridical acts of the captain, crew or lighter-
men of the claimant in which event the steamship “Isla de Panay”
and the claimant are exempt from liability by the stipulation re-
ferred to in the preceding subdivision of this paragraph, which said
stipulation exempts the claimant from liability in any event re-
gardless of whether the acts of the captain, crew or lightermen were
acts of negligence or not and which stipulation is valid and binding
{fol. 13] under the laws of the Kingdom of Spain which govern the
contract of transportation herein referred to; by reason whereof
neither the said vessel nor the claimant is under any circumstances
liable to the libellant for any damage which the libellant’s merehan-
dise may have suffered.
VI. If any of the alleged loss of or damage to the libellant’s goods
occurred after their removal from the steamship “Isla de Panay,”
said vessel and the claimant are not res-onsible therefore by reason
of the stipulations and exemptions of the bills of lading, providing as
follows:
1. The unloading is to be done by the vessel, however, for the
account and risk of the receivers.
2. Delivery must be taken upon the unloading of the goods,
* * * and the Company is not responsible for misplacement or
damage to goods which have not been received by the interested
parties at the moment of unloading.
3. It is understood that from the moment the goods have left
the deck of the vessel, marine risks, damages, etec., are for the account
of the receivers.
Fighth. In case there was any loss of or damage to the cargo
mentioned in the libel, which is not admitted, it was not caused or
[ fol. 14] contributed to in any manner whatsoever by any negligence
on the part of the steamship “Isla de Panay,” her agents, or the
claimant, or its agents and servants, or any one for whom the steam-
ship “Isla de Panay,” or the claimant may have been responsible,
and by reason of the fact that the damage and loss, if any, was
caused within the exceptions of the bills of lading hereinabove set
forth, the said vessel and the claimant are not responsible to the
libellant therefor.
Ninth. The claimant further alleges that it and the steamship
“Tsla de Panay” have performed all and singular the duties and
obligations laid upon them under the bills of lading which constituted
re contracts for the carriage of the goods mentioned in the libel
erein.
Further answering the libel herein and as a second separate and
distinct defense herein, and re-alleging the denials and allegations
hereinabove pleaded as if they were set out in full, the claimant
alleges :
[PRR ewe orraiaiins ad tl Tee Te ee EDR ROLE ACEC IAS NES RANE A Bich Sean mee a
7
I. Under and by the Act of Congress, approved February 13,
1893, entitled “An Act Relating to the navigation of Vessels, ete.,”’
it is provided that if the owner of any vessel transporting merchan-
dise or property to or from any port in the United States of America
shall exercise due diligence to make the said vessel in all respects
[fol. 15] seaworthy and properly manned, equipped and supplied.
neither the vessel, her owner or owners. agent or charterers, shall be-
come or be held responsible for damage or loss resulting from faults
or errors in navigation or in the management of said vessel, nor shall
the vessel, her owner or owners, charterers. agent or master, he held
liable for losses arising from dangers of the sea or other navigable
waters, acts of God or public enemies, or the inherent defect, quality
or vice of the thing carried, or from insufficiency of package or
seizure under legal process, or for loss resulting from any act or
omission of the shipper or owner of the goods, his agent or repre-
sentative. :
II. At the times mentioned in the libel the steamship “Isla de
Panay” was engaged in the transportation of such of the merchan- ‘
dise hereinbefore referred to as was aboard her from ports in the :
Kingdom of Spain to a port in the United States of America, and ‘
the claimant had exercised due diligence to make said vessel in all A
respects seaworthy and properly manned, equipped and supplied, 4
in pursuance of and in accordance with the terms and provisions B
of said act.
III. The damage to and loss of the libellant’s goods, if any, was
due to and caused by causes within the exceptions provided as
above by the said act of February 13, 18938, and was due either
[fol. 16] to a fault or error in navigation or in the management of
the vessel or to the inherent defect, quality or vice of the thing
carried or to the insuflicieney of the containers in which the libel-
lant’s goods were carried or to an act or omission of the shippers
or owners of the goods, their agent or representative, by reason
whereof the steamship “Isla de Panay” and the claimant are ex-
empted from any liability to the libellant in the premises,
Tenth. That the claimant is ignorant of the specific charges of
fault intended to be proved or urged at the trial. and is, therefore.
unable to plead more specifically to the charges, but avers that the
alleged loss, if any, mentioned in the libel was within one or more
of the above quoted exceptions of the bills of lading, to which the
claimant begs leave to refer on the trial, and that the said alleged
loss was thereby to be borne by the owners of the cargo and not by
the vessel nor the claimant.
Eleventh. All and singular the premises are true,
Wherefore, the claimant prays that the libel herein be dismissed
with costs, and for such other and further relief as may be just.
Hunt, Hill & Betts, Proctors for Claimant, Office & P. O.
Address, 120 Broadway, Borough of Manhattan, New
York City.
OOO IMR LOD i OR ABO Cited EP 0d ees ee hee OP eee are! mae n ti Da san "Ty
{fol. 17] Jurat showing the foregoing was duly sworn to by L.
Llanso; omitted in printing.
| fol. 18] Ix Usirep States District Courr
LiBeL
(Sanchez & Company )
To the Honorable the Judges of the District Court of the United
States for the Southern District of New York:
The Libel and Complaint of Eug. Sanchez and Jose Gilde Sag-
redo, copartners trading as E. Sanchez & Co., against the Steam-
ship “Isla de Panay,” her engines, boilers, etc., in a cause of cargo
damage, civil and maritime, alleges and respectfully shows on in-
formation and belief to this Honorable Court as follows:
First. Your libellants are co-partners trading under the firm
name and style of E. Sanchez & Co., with an office and place of
business at No. 155 Front Street, in the Borough of Manhattan,
City of New York, and are the owners of the damaged merchandise
hereinafter mentioned.
Second, The steamship “Isla de Panay” is now within the South-
ern District of New York and within the jurisdiction of this Hon-
orable Court.
Third. On October 27th, 1917, Joseph Y. de Ferry, shipped and
{fol 19] placed on board the steamship “Isla de Panay,” then
lying at the Port of Cadiz, Spain, One hundred (100) packages of
olives in good order and condition to be carried by the said steam-
ship “Isla de Panay,” as a common earrier, from the Port of Spain
to the Port of New York, and there to be delivered to your libel-
lants in like good order and condition as when shipped, in con-
sideration of an agreed freight, and in accordance with the valid
terms of a bill of lading then and there issued.
”
Fourth. Thereafter the said steamship “Isla de Panay,” sailed
from the Port of Cadiz, Spain to the Port of New York in the month
of November, 1917, and made delivery of the cargo as aforesaid,
but not in like good order and condition as when shipped, but
badly damaged.
Fifth. By reason of the premises, your libellants have sustained
damage in about the sum of Eighteen hundred ($1,800.00) Dol-
lars, as nearly as the same can now be estimated, no part of which
has been paid although duly demanded.
Sixth. All and singular the premises are true, and within the Ad-
miralty and Maritime jurisdiction of the United States and of this
Honorable Court.
Wherefore, libellants pray that process in due form of law ac-
cording to the course po practice of this Honorable Court in causes
of Admiralty and Maritime jurisdiction, issue against the said
| fol. 20] steamship “Isla de Panay,” her engines, boilers, ete., and
that all persons having or claiming uny interest therein be cited
to appear and answer all and singular the matters aforesaid: that
this Honorable Court be pleased to deeree to your libellants their
damages, with interest and costs, and that the steamship “Isla de
Panay,” her engines, ete., be condemned and sold to satisfy the
same, and that your libel-ants may have such other and farther
relief as in law and justice they may be entitled to receive.
Harrington, Bigham & Englar, Proctors for Libellants, No.
64 Wall Street, Borough of Manhattan, City of New York.
[fol. 21] Jurat showing the foregoing was duly sworn to by Eu-
gene Sanchez; omitted in printing.
| fol. 22] Ix Unsirep States District Covrr
ANSWER
To the Honorable the Judges of the District Court of the United
States for the Southern District of New York:
The Answer of Compania Trasatlantiea Claimant and Owner of
the Steamship “Isla de Panay,” to the libel and Complaint of Eug.
Sanchez and Jose Gilde Sagredo, co-partners trading as E. Sanchez
« Co., against the Spanish Steamship “Isla de Panay,” her engines,
etc., in a cause of contract and cargo, damage, civil and maritime,
alleges and respectfully shows to this Honorable Court as follows:
First. It denies any knowledge or information suflicient to form
a belief as to the allegations set forth in paragraph marked “First”
of the libel herein.
Second. It admits the allegations set forth in paragraph marked
“Second” of the libel herein.
Third. It admits and alleges that on or about the 6th day of
November, 1917, there were shipped on board the steamship “Isla
de Panay,” then at the Port of Cadiz Spain and bound for the Port
of New York, 100 casks said to contain olives, the weight and con-
| fol. 23] tents of said casks and their quality, however, being stated
to be unknown to the claimant, which expressly declined to be re-
sponsible therefor.
It further admits and alleges that it was agreed that the mer-
chandise should be transported for a stipulated freight to the Port
of New York and there be delivered to the order of the libelants sub-
ject to the conditions and exceptions from liability contained in the
bill of lading issued for said merchandise at Seville, Spain, from
which port said merchandise was shipped, in the first instance.
o YONG 30 RTL tot BPP BD SRE NAME INN IIONON PSL A Sea einai
10
Further answering it denies each and every allegation set forth
in paragraph marked “Third” of the libel herein except as herein-
above expressly admitted or denied.
Fourth. It admits and alleges that thereafter the steamship “Isla
de Panay” sailed from the Port of Cadiz, Spain, and arrived in due
course at the Port of New York in the month of November, 1917,
and that it thereafter delivered at the Port of New York all of the
above mentioned merchandise which it received on board the ship
at Cadiz in pursuance of and in compliance with the terms and con-
ditions of the bill of lading hereinabove referred to.
Further answering it denies each and every allegation set forth
in paragraph marked “Fourth” of the libel herein except as herein-
above expressly admitted or denied.
Fifth. It admits and alleges that the libellants have demanded
[ fol. 24] payment of their alleged damage and that payment thereof
has been refused but denies that any damage was suffered by the
libellants.
Further answering it denies each and every allegation set forth
in paragraph marked “Fifth” of the libel herein exeept as herein-
above expressly admitted or denied.
Sixth. It admits the jurisdiction of this Honorable Court but
denies the truth of the premises.
Further answering the libel herein and as a first, separate and
distinct defense herein, and re-alleging the denials and «!legations
hereinabove pleaded as if they were again set out im full) the claim-
ant alleges:
Seventh. 1. That the bill of lading for the carriage cf the said
merchandise hereinabove referred to contained ameng others, the
following provisions, terms and stipulations, suljeet te which the
carriage was expressly made:
“7. The Company is not responsible for damages or losses caused
by the sea, the winds * * * or any unforeseen cause, or occasioned
by juridical acts of any class and nature of the captain, erew or
lightermen, the parties interested in the cargo expressly renouncing
the right to demand any civil responsibility direet or subsidiary,
ffol. 25] which may arise from the laws and especially from Ar-
ticles 587, 618 and 620 of the Commercial Code and from Article
21 of the Penal Code (of Spain.) Also not responsible for the con-
tents, weights and quality of the packages; for damage caused by
other goods; for errors in delivering same caused by insufficient or
illegible marking or for breakage of the articles and fragile con-
tainers. Also not responsible for loss, damage and average caused
to the goods by rats or other rodents.”
“10. The unloading is to be done by the vessel, however, for
the account and risk of the receivers, according to the tariff or cus-
tom of each port, the agent of the vessel being authorized to present
——— z Bitecdade Fasetunge Settee nite A Rie EP al Iba SANA a Om Mat . a ees
the Declaration at the Customs in accordance with the contents of
the bill of lading.”
“11. Delivery must be taken upon the unloading of the goods.
the packages to be exchanged for the bills of lading after the pay-
ment of the freight in case the same has not been paid at the time
of loading * * *. Not responsible for misplacement or damage
to goods that have not been received by the interested parties at
the moment of unloading * * *, Jt is understood that from the
moment the goods have left the deck of the vessel, marine risks,
damages, ete., are for the account of the receivers.”
“18. Even though this bill of lading is not signed by the shipper,
[fol. 26] the shipper, by taking this bill of lading agrees to all the
conditions of same.”
II. The claimant exercised due diligence to make the steam-
ship “Tsla de Panay” in all respects seaworthy and properly manned,
equipped and supplied for the voyage mentioned in the libel, and
the steamship “Isla de Panay” was in fact in all respects seaworthy,
properly manned, equipped and supplied at the beginning of such
voyage, and the cargo was in every respect properly loaded, stowed,
cared for and delivered.
TIT. If there was any loss of or damage to any of the merchandise
referred to in the libel herein, which is not admitted, it was caused
hy one or more of the following causes mentioned jn the exemp-
tions in the above enumerated clauses of the bill of lading: (a) the
sea; 4b) the winds; (c¢) unforeseen cause: (d) juridical acts of the
captain, crew or lightermen; (e) damage caused by other goods;
(f) insufficient or illegible marking; (h) breakage of the articles.
(i) fragile containers: (j) to other causes excepted by the bill of
lading hereinbefore referred to from liability for which the steam-
ship “Isla de Panay” and the claimant. by the conditions and ex-
ceptions in the said bill of lading are expressly excluded.
IV. That if the said alleged damage to the libellants’ merchandise
was occasioned by the negligence of the claimant’s servants and em-
[ fol. 271 plovees, which is not admitted. the claimant herein is not
responsible therefor, by reason of the clause numbered “7” of the
bill of lading, providing, in part, as follows:
“The Company is not responsible for damages or losses caused
by * * * juridical acts of any class and nature of the captain,
crew or lightermen, the parties interested in the cargo expressly re-
nouncing the right to demand any civil resnonsibilitv, direct or
subsidiary, which may arise from the laws and especially from Ar-
ticles 587, 618 and 620 of the Commercial Code, and from Article
21 of the Penal Code (of Spain) .”
That Section 618 of the Commercial Code of Spain, their rights
under which the libellants by the aforesaid stipulation have ex-
pressly renounced, provides in part as follows:
12
“The captain shall be civilly liable to the ship owner and the
ship owner to the third parties having contracted with him.
Ist. For all the damages the ship or her cargo may suffer from
lack of skill or mismanagement.”
V. That if any damage was caused to the libellants’ merchandise
by the claimant's servants and employees, which is not admitted, ii
was occasioned by the juridical aets of the captain, crew or lighter.
men of the claimant, in which event the Steamship “Isla de Panav”
and the claimant are exempt from liability by the stipulation §re-
|fol. 28] ferred to in the preceding subdivision of this paragraph.
which said stipulation exempts the claimant from liability in any
event regardless of whether the aets of the captain, crew or lighter-
men were acts of negligence or not and which stipulation is valid
and binding under the laws of the Kingdom of Spain which gov-
ern the contract of transportation herein referred to: by reason
whereof neither the said vessel nor the claimant is under any cir-
cumstances liable to the libellants for any damage which the libe'-
lants’ merchandise may have suffered.
VI. If any of the alleged loss of or damage to the libellants’
goods occurred after their removal from the steamship “Isla de
Panay,” said vessel and the claimant are not responsible therefor
by reason of the stipulation and exemptions of the bill of lading.
providing as follows:
1. The unloading is to be done by the vessel, however, for the
account and risk of the receivers.
2. Delivery must be taken upon the unloading of the goods,
* * * and the Company is not responsible for misplacement or
damage to goods which have not been received by the interested
parties at the moment of unloading.
8. It is understood that from the moment the goods have left the
deck of the vessel, marine risks, damages, ete., are for the aceount
of the receivers.
{fol.29] Eighth. In case there was any loss of or damage to the
cargo mentioned in the libel, which is not admitted, it was not caused
or contributed to in any manner whatsoever by any negligence on the
part of the steamship “Isla de Panay.” her agents, or the claimant,
or its agents and servants, or anyone for whom the steamship “Tsla
de Panay.” or the claimant may have been responsible, and by reason
of the fact that the damage and loss, if any, was eansed within the
exceptions of the bill of lading hereinabove set forth, the said vessel
and the claimant are not responsible to the libellants therefor.
Ninth. The claimant further alleges that it and the steamship
“Isla de Panay” have performed all and singular the duties and ob-
ligations laid upon them under the bill of lading which constituted
the contracts for the carriage of the goods mentioned in the libel
herein.
AENEAN AGE EOL He fone) GA il OE nate cs Tit a int le apt ND i, nn i nee
ier nine nat”
"
Further answering the libel herein and as a second separate and
distinet defense herein, and re-alleging the denials and allegations
hereinabove pleaded as if they were again set out in full, the claim-
ant alleges:
I. Under and by the Act of Congress, approved February 13,
1893, entitled, “An Act Relating to the navigation of Vessels, ete.”
it is provided that if the owner of any vessel transporting merchandise
[fol. 30] or property to or from any port in the United States of
America shall exercise due diligence to make the said vessel in all
respects seaworthy and properly manned, equipped and supplied,
neither the vessel, her owner or owners, agent or charterers, shall
become or be held responsible for damage or loss resulting from
faults or errors in navigation or in the management of said vessel,
nor shall the vessel, her owner or owners, charterers, agent or master,
be held liable for losses arising from dangers of the sea or other
navigable waters, acts of God or publie enemies, or the inherent de-
fect, quality or vice of the thing carried, or from insufficiency of
package or seizure under legal process, or for loss resulting from any
aet or omission of the shipper or owner of the goods, his agent or
representative.
II. At the times mentioned in the libel the steamship “Isla de
Panay” was engaged in the transportation of such of the merchandise
hereinbefore referred to as was aboard her from ports in the King-
dom of Spain to a port in the United States of America, and the
claimant had exercised due diligence to make said vessel in all re-
spects seaworthy and properly manned, equipped and supplied, in
oa gd of and in accordance with the terms and provisions of
said Act.
III. The damage to and loss of the libellants’ goods, if any, was
due to and caused by causes within the exceptions provided as above
by the said Act of February 13, 1893, and was due either to a fault
{fol. 31] or error in navigation or in the management of the said
vessel or to the inherent defect, quality or vice of the thing carried
or to the insufficiency of the containers in which the libellants’ goods
were carried or to an act or omission of the shippers or owners of the
goods, their agent or representative, by reason whereof the Steam-
ship “Isla de Panay” and the claimant are exempted from any liabil-
ity to the libellants in the premises.
Tenth. That the claimant is ignorant of the specifie charges of
fault intended to be proved or urged at the trial, and is, therefore,
unable to plead more specifically to the charges, but avers that the
alleged loss, if any, mentioned in the libel was within one or more
of the above quoted exceptions of the bill of lading, to which the
claimant begs leave to refer on the trial, and that the said alleged
loss was thereby to be borne by the owners of the cargo and not by
the vessel nor the claimant. i
Eleventh. All and singular the premises are true,
SEED BRE ISIS LR PRET a EN Ets Rane re
Si acl tS
Sax uus y
TPE GD ETSY ELEM NM o* OP IES ELE BS NEE NC Sie EG REI LPO LEENA ANIL 6 eh a HBR Lee fh Sa ARP AE RN IG BL git tN Pr ete eats Tad elie
14
Wherefore the claimant prays that the libel herein be dismissed
with costs, and for such other and ftrther relief as may be just.
Hunt, Hill & Betts, Proctors for Claimant, Office & Post Office
Address 120 Broadway, Borough of Manhattan, New York
City.
|fol. 32] Jurat showing the foregoing was duly sworn to by L.
Llanso; omitted in printing.
[fol. 33 | In Unirep States Districr Court
LIBEL
(Ic. Tolibia & Company )
To the Honorable the Judges of the District Court of the United
States for the Southern District of New York:
The libel and complaint of E. Tolibia & Company, a corporation,
against The Steamship “Isla de Panay,” her engines, boilers, etc.,
in a cause of cargo damage, civil and maritime, alleges and respect-
fully shows on information and belief to this Honorable Court as
follows:
First. Your libellant is a corporation organized under the laws
of the State of New York, having its office and place of business at
No. 24 Renwick Street, in the City of New York, and is the owner
of the damaged merchandise hereinafter mentioned.
Second. The Steamship “Isla de Panay” is now within the South-
ern District of New York and within the jurisdiction of this Honor-
able Court.
Third. On October 27th, 1917, there were shipped on board the
steamship “Isla de Panay” then lying in the port of Cadiz, Spain,
[fol. 84] twenty-seven (27) packages of olives in good order and
condition to be carried by the said steamship “Isla de Panay,” as
a common carrier, from the port of Spain to the port of New York,
and there to be delivered to your libellant in like good order and con-
dition as when shipped, in consideration of an agreed freight, and
in a with the valid terms of a bill of lading then and there
issued.
>
Fourth. Thereafter the said steamship “Isla de Panay,” sailed
from the port of Cadiz, Spain, to the port of New York in the month
of November, 1917, and made delivery of the cargo as aforesaid,
but not in like good order and condition as when shipped, but badly
damaged.
Fifth. By reason of the premises, your libellant has sustained
damage in about the sum of Five hundred ($500.00) Dollars, as
nearly as the same can now be estimated, no part of which has been
paid although duly demanded.
A naan Selah CUA a,
DO INE NGF SRI eR cle ROE te ME A Wh Halle aid SOV A SN Meath Ser
15
Sixth. All and singular the premises are true, and within the
Admiralty and Maritime jurisdiction of the United States and of this
Honorable Court.
Wherefore, libellant prays that proceess in due form of law ac-
cording to the course and practice of this Honorable Court in causes
of Admiralty and Maritime jurisdiction, issue against the said steam-
ship “Isla de Panay,” her engines, boilers, etc. and that all persons
[fol. 85] having or claiming any interest therein be cited to appear
and answer all and singular the matters aforesaid: that this Honor-
able Court be pleased to decree to your libellant its damages, with
interest and costs, and that the steamship “Isla de Panay” her en-
gines, ete., be condemned and sold to satisfy the same and that your
libellant may have such other and further relief as in law and justice
it may be entitled to receive,
Bigham, Englar & Jones, Proctors for Libellant, No. 64 Wall
Strect, Borough of Manhattan, City of New York.
(fol. 36] Jurat showing the foregoing was duly sworn to by T.
Catesby Jones; omitted in printing.
[fol. 37] Ix Unitep Srares District Court
ANSWER
To the Honorable the Judges of the District Court of the United
States for the Southern District of New York:
The Answer of Compania Trasatlantica, Claimant and Owner of
the Steamship “Isla de Panay” to the Libel and Complaint of
KE. Tolibia & Company against the Spanish Steamship “Isla de
Panay,” her engines, ete., in a cause of contract and cargo damage,
civil and maritime, alleges and respectfully shows to this Honor-
able Court as follows:
First. It denies any knowledge or information suflicient to form
a belief as to the allegations set forth in paragraph marked ‘First’
of the libel herein.
Second. It denies the allegations set forth in paragraph marked
“Second” of the libel herein.
Third. It admits and alleges that on or about the 6th day of
November, 1917 there were shipped on board the steamship “Isla de
Panay” then at the port of Cadiz, Spain and bound for the Port of
New York, 27 easks said to contain olives. the weight and contents
of said casks and their quality, however, being stated to be unknown
|fol. 38] to the claimant, which expressly declined to be responsible
therefore.
It further admits and alleges that it was agreed that the merehan-
dise should be transported for a stipulated freight to the port of New
REIMER ENTE he om ar a RAC IIR IS aoe
a OOS, AS SATEEN MO EIDE ANA bh ACIDS ANS LIRA SLD DSO ALP AOE ON Tit 8
16
York and there be delivered to the order of the libellant subject to the
conditions and exceptions from liability contained in the bill of
lading issued for said merchandise at Seville, Spain, from whieh port
said merchandise was shipped, in the first instance.
Further answering it Salas each and every allegation set forth in
paragraph marked “Third” of the libel herein except as herein-
above expressly admitted or denied,
Fourth. It admits and alleges that thereafter the steamship “Isla
de Panay” sailed from the port of Cadiz, Spain and arrived in due
course at the port of New York in the month of November, 1917,
and that it thereafter delivered at the port of New York all of the
above mentioned merchandise which it received on board the ship at
Cadiz in pursuance of and in compliance with the terms and con-
ditions of the bill of lading hereinabove referred to.
Further answering it denies each and every allegation set forth in
paragraph marked “Fourth” of the libel herein except as herein-
above expressly admitted or denied.
Fifth. It admits and alleges that the libellant has demanded pay-
ment of its alleged damage and that payment thereof has been re-
[fol. 39] fused but denies that any damage was suffered by the
libellant.
Further answering it denies each and every allegation set forth in
paragraph marked “Fifth” of the libel herein except as hereinabove
expressly admitted or denied.
Sixth. It admits the jurisdiction of this Ilonorable Court but
denies the truth of the premises.
Further answering the libel herein and as a first, separate and
distinct defence herein, and re-alleging the denials and allegations
hereinabove pleaded as if they were again set out in full, the claim-
ant alleges:
Seventh: I. That the bill of lading for the carriage of the said
merchandise hereinabove referred to contained, among others the
following provisions, terms and stipulations, subject to which the
carriage was expressly made:
“7. The Company is not responsible for damages or losses caused
by the sea, the winds * * * or any unferescen cause, or
oceasioned by juridical acts of any class and nature of the captain,
crew or lightermen, the parties interested in the cargo expressiy re-
nouncing the right to demand any civil responsibility, direct or su-
sidiary, which may arise from the laws and especially from Articles
587, 618 and 620 of the Commercial Code and from Article 21 of
[fol.40] the Penal Code (of Spain). Also not responsible for the
contents, weight and quality of the packages; for damage caused hy
other goods; for errors in delivering same caused by insuflicient or
illegible marking or for breakage of the articles and fragile con-
tainers. Also not responsible for loss, damage and average caused
to the goods by rats or other rodents.”
“10. The unloading is to he done by the vessel, however, for the
account and risk of the receivers, according to the tariff or custom
of each port, the agent of the vessel being authorized to present the
Declaration at the Customs in accordance with the contents of the
bill of lading.”
“11. Delivery must be taken upon the unloading of the goods, the
packages to the exchanged for the bills of lading after the payment
of the freight in case the same has not been paid at the time of
loading * * * Not responsible for misplacement or damage to
goods that have not been received by the interested parties at the
moment of unloading. * * * It is understood that from the
moment the goods have left the deck of the vessel, marine risks, dam-
ages, etc., are for the account of the receivers.”
18. Even though this bill of lading is not signed by the shipper,
the shipper, by taking this bill of lading, agrees to all the conditions
of same.”
[fol.41] 11. The claimant exercised due diligence to make the
steamship “Isla de Panay” in all respects seaworthy and properly
manned, equipped and supplied for the voyage mentioned in the
libel, and the Steamship “Isla de Panay” was in fact in all respects
seaworthy, properly manned, equipped and supplied at the begin-
ning of such voyage, and the eargo was in every respect properly
loaded, stowed, cared for and delivered.
III. If there was any loss of or damage to any of the merchandise
referred to in the libel herein, which is not admitted. it was caused by
one or more of the following causes mentioned in the exemptions in
the above enumerated clauses of the bill of lading: (a) the sea; (b)
the winds; (¢) unforeseen cause: (d) juridical acts of the captain,
crew or lightermen; (e) damage caused by other goods; (f) in-
suflicient or illegible marking: (h) breakage of articles: (i) fragile
containers; (j) to other causes excepted by the bill of lading herein-
lefore referred to from liability for which the Steamship “Isla de
Panay” and the claimant, by the conditions and exceptions in the
said bill of lading are expressly excluded,
IV. That if the said alleged damage to the libellant's merchandise
Was occasioned by the negligence of the claimant's servants and em-
ployees, which is not admitted, the claimant herein js not responsible
therefor, by reason of the clause numbered “7” of the bill of lading,
providing, in part, as follows:
[fol. 42] “The Company is not responsible for damages or losses
eansed by * * * Juridical acts of any class and nature of the
captain, crew or lightermen, the parties interested in the cargo ex-
pressly renouncing the right to demand any civil responsibility,
direct or subsidiary, which may arise from the laws and especially
from Articles 587, 618 and 620 of the Commercial Code, and from
Article 21 of the Penal Code (of Spain) .”
2—609
PACT at Ase ants Seen eee EIEN IRE ERAN MI Gk be hE ARSON PON eit i AIM mA pk RNIN i RSE St LSA aaa ene Nant
18
That Section 618 of the Commercial Code of Spain, its rights under
which the libellant by the aforesaid stipulation has expressly re-
nounced, provides in part as follows:
“The captain shall be civilly liable to the ship owner and the ship
owner to the third parties having contracted with him:
Ist. For all the damages the ship or her cargo may suffer from
lack of skill or mismanagement.”
V. That if any damage was caused to the libellant’s merchandise
by the claimant’s servants and employees, which is not admitted, it
was occasioned by the juridical acts of the captain, crew or lightermen
of the claimant, in which event the Steamship “Isla de Panay” and
the claimant are exempt from liability by the stipulation referred to
in the preceding subdivision of this paragraph, which said stipulation
exempts the claimant from liability in any event regardless of
whether the acts of the captain, crew or lightermen were acts of
| fol. 43] negligence or not and which stipulation is valid and bind-
ing under the laws of the Kingdom of Spain which govern the con-
tract of transportation herein referred to; by reason whereof neither
the said vessel nor the claimant is under any circumstances liable
to the libellant for any damage which the libellant’s merchandise
may have suffered.
VI. If any of the alleged loss of or damage to the libellant’s goods
occurred after their removal from the Steamship ‘Isla de Panay,”
said vessel and the claimant are not responsible therefor by reason of
the stipulations and exemptions of the bills of lading, providing as
follows:
1. The unloading is to be done by the vessel, however, for the
account and risk of fhe receivers.
2. Delivery must be taken upon the unloading of the goods,
* * * and the Company is not responsible for misplacement or
damage to goods which have not been received by the interested
parties at the moment of unloading.
3. It is understood that from the moment the goods have left the
deck of the vessel, marine risks, damages, ete., are for the account of
the receivers.
Eighth. In case there was any loss of or damage to the cargo
mentioned in the libel which is not admitted, it was not caused or con-
{fol. 44] tributed to in any manner whatsoever by any negligence
on the part of the Steamship “Isla de Panay,” her agents, or the
claimant, or its agents and servants, or anyone for whom the Steam-
ship “Isla de Panay,” or the claimant may have been responsible,
and by reason of the fact that the damage and loss, if any, was
caused within the exceptions of the bill of lading hereinabove set
forth, the said vessel and the claimant are not responsible to the
libellant therefor.
Ninth. The claimant further alleges that it and the Steamship
“Isla de Panay” have performed all and singular the duties and
= a — ee <accnememeanneeenees
obligations laid upon them under the bill of lading which constituted
the contract for the carriage of the goods mentioned in the libel
herein,
Further answering the libel herein, and as a second separate and
distinct defence herein, and re-alleging the denials and allegations
hereinabove pleaded as if they were again set out in full, the elaim-
ee |
ant alleges: x
Tenth. Under and by the Act of Congress, approved February 13, p
1893, entitled “An Act Relating to the navigation of Vessels, ete.”, 5
it is provided that if the owner of any vessel transporting merehan- ;
dise or property to or from any port in the United States of America §
shall exercise due diligence to make the said vessel in all respects i.
seaworthy and properly manned, equipped and supplied, neither the *
[fol. 45] vessel, her owner or owners, agent or charterers, shall be- .
come or be held responsible for damage or loss resulting from faults ;
or errors In navigation or in the management of said vessel, nor shall ;
the vessel, her owner or owners. charterers, agent or miaster, be held
liable for losses arising from dangers of the sea or other navigable
waters, acts of God or public enemies, or the inherent defect. quality
or vice of the thing carried, or from insufliciency of package or
seizure under legal process, or for loss resulting from any act or
omission of the shipper or owner of the goods, his agent) or
representative.
Eleventh. At the times mentioned in the libel the Steamship
“Isla de Panay” was engaged in the transportation of such of the
merchandise hereinbefore referred to as was aboard her from ports
in the Kingdom of Spain to a port in the United States of America,
and the claimant had exercised due diligence to make said vessel
in all respects seaworthy and properly manned, equipped and sup-
plied, in pursuance of and in accordance with the terms and provi-
sions of said Act,
MRE LE ONPG N fas? REI EHR Re AO Aika ta
So Ar ee
oF
Twelfth. The damage to and loss of the libellant’s goods, if any,
was due to and caused by causes within the exceptions provided as
above by the said Act of February 13, 1893, and was due either to
a fault or error in navigation or in the management of the said
vessel or to the inherent defect, quality or vice of the thing carried
or to the insufficiency of the containers in which the libellant’s
[fol 46] goods were carried or to an act or omission of the shippers
or owners of the goods, their agent or representative, by reason
whereof the Steamship “Isla de Panay” and the claimant are ex-
empted from any liability to the libellant in the premises,
Further answering the libel herein, and as a third separate and
distinct defence herein, and re-alleging the denials and allegations
hereinabove pleaded as if they were again set out in full, the claim-
ant alleges:
Thirteen. That whatever claim the libellant may have had herein
arose in the month of November, 1917 and therefore such claim
Which is now made the basis of this suit almost five years after it
arose, is a stale claim, and because of the laches of the libellant
herein in not beginning suit on the said claim, the libel herein
should be dismissed.
Fourteenth. That the claimant is ignorant of the specific charges
of fault intended to be proved or urged at the trial, and is, therefore,
unable to plead more specifically to the charges, but avers that the
alleged loss, if any, mentioned in the libel was within one or more
of the above quoted exceptions of the bill of lading, to which the
claimant begs leave to refer on the trial and that the said alleged
loss was thereby to be borne by the owners of the cargo and not by
the vessel nor the claimant.
|fols. 47 & 48] Fifteenth. All and singular the premises are true.
Wherefore, the claimant prays that the libel herein be dismissed
with costs, and for such other and further relief as may be just.
Hunt, Hill & Betts, Proctors for Claimant, Office & Post
Office Address 120 Broadway. Borough of Manhattan, New
York City.
Jurat showing the foregoing was duly sworn to by John W. Cran-
dall; omitted in printing.
{fol. 49] Case.
Unitep States District Court, Souruern Districr or New
YorxK
| Title omitted |
The Claims of the libels and answers are stated.
{[ fol. 50] TESTIMONY FOR THE LIBELANTS
J. D. Sacrepo, being duly sworn and examined as a witness for
the libelant, testifies:
By Mr. Woodruff:
Q. What is your address?
A. 194 Water Street.
Q. And your present occupation ?
A. Importer of olives.
Q. What is the name of your firm?
A. E. Sanchez & Co.
. They are the libelants in one of these actions against the
Steamship Isla de Panay?
A. They are.
Q. Are you a member of that firm?
A. Yes.
PET PK eer ces 4
.
ee
a:
panne + ssieiniaeiiaiitaaes —
21
Q. How long have you been a member?
A. Since 1913.
Q. What are your general duties in connection with the matters
such as are involved in this case?
A. The general run of the business,
Q. Do you remember a consignment of 100 casks of olives to your
firm, IE. Sanchez & Company from Jose y de Terry consigned to this
country in November, 1917?
A. 1 do.
Q. They came by the steamship Isla de Panay of the Spanish
Line?
A. They did.
Q. Where did she dock?
A. At pier 8, East River.
[fol. 51) Q. I show you bill of lading, Claimant’s Exhibit 2, and
ask you if you can identify that?
A. Yes.
Q. What is that bill of lading?
A. What do you mean?
Q. Is that the bill of lading covering the shipment to which you
have testified?
A. It is.
Q, Is that a clean bill of lading, what you call a clean bill of
lading?
Mr. Crandall: I object; it speaks for itself.
Q. Did you at the time you received this bill of lading have your
attention called to the fact that it was a clean bill of lading? Did
you notice whether it was clean or whether it contained notations”
A. It was a clean bill of lading.
Q. After receiving that bill of lading what did you do in connec-
tion with the shipment of olives?
. I accepted the draft.
Q. In payment?
A. In payment of the olives.
Q. Did you do that in the ordinary course of business?
A. I did.
. Are you in the habit of receiving consignments of olives from
Spain? Do you do this from time to time?
A. Absolutely, yes.
Q. Can you give the Court any idea as to how many consignments
of olives of this nature you are in the habit of receiving say in a year?
A, Well, it depends; about once a month.
Q. If this bill of lading had contained notations would you have
accepted the same in the course of business?
[fol. 52] Objected to as incompetent, irrelevant and immaterial.
Objection sustained.
oxception.
Bs Men
stp sieialil
PLO oe A OTE RAD NN) te RE Ni el a,
22
Q. Have you in the course of your business ever accepted any bill
of lading for consignments of olives containing notations as to in-
sufficient containers?
Same objection.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
A. No.
Q. Did you or any one of your firm to your knowledge have any
knowledge or information as to any defective condition of these con-
tainers when they were received for shipment in Spain?
A. No.
Q. You purchased these goods in the ordinary course of business,
I think vou have testified?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you examine these goods on the dock or on the steamer,
did you examine them at pier 8?
A. On the dock.
Q. Not on the steamer?
A. No.
Q. About how many casks were on the dock when you made your
examination?
A. I don’t quite remember.
Q. A large number or just a few?
A. There were 100 casks in all, and I don’t remember just exactly.
Q. What condition did you find them in, the casks and the con-
tents on the wharf?
A. Well, rather ‘
[fol. 583] Q. Explain in what way they were poor?
A. Casks without brine spoil the olives.
Q. Were the casks broken or how were they”
A. Some of them were broken.
(). Tlow were the heads?
A. Some were in and some were out.
Q. Did you notice the hoops on these casks, any of them?
A. Not exactly.
Q. You don’t remember about that?
A. I don’t remember about that now.
Can you tell us anything more in connection with the condi-
tion of the casks? Will you go a little more into detail.
A. When I found the extent of the damage I put in my claim to
the insurance company.
Q. Have you been in charge of similar shipments of olives before?
A. T have.
Q. What are the containers, these casks, usually made of?
Objected to.
Q. Have you seen any oak casks?
A. Never in my life.
Q. Not since you have been in the business?
_—
25
A. No.
Q. How would these casks compare in size and weight with the
ordinary shipment?
A. Weighing from 1,600 to 1.800 pounds.
Q. Are they the casks that are always used in trans-Atlantic ship-
ments, or do some come in smaller casks?
A. Only in barrels ; 50 gallon barrels; but that is for stuffed olives ;
not green. .
ies 54] Q. But ordinary green olives are always shipped in similar
casks?
A. Yes, in similar casks.
Cross-examined by Mr. Crandall:
Q. Who is this Jose y de Terry?
A. The shipper in Spain.
Q. Do you know him?
A. I do.
Q. How long have you known him?
A. I knew him the last 12 years, myself.
Q. What kind of relations have you had with him?
A. Just as a shipper of olives, an exporter. I have been buying
from him right along.
Q. For 12 years?
A. Yes, on and off, of course.
Q. How long have vou been in the olive business?
A. Since 1907. .
Q. Do you say that in that 15 years you have never seen the olives
come in here in oak casks?
A. No, sir.
Q. How about before that? Do you know what kind of casks had
come in before that?
A. T do not know.
Q. Do you admit that these were bad casks?
A. When they got here, yes.
Q. Do you admit that the casks themselves were weak ?
A. I couldn't tell you, because when T saw them they were all
broken up,
Q. Do you admit that there was bad wood in the casks?
A. T would not say that.
Q. Do you admit that the hoops were weak?
A. T can’t quite remember that.
[fol. 557 Q. What seemed to be the matter with the casks?
A. Well, all the staves were broken : some of them; not all. I had
a shipment of 100 casks. Of course the brine ran out and if brine
runs out olives lose their flavor and color and Are not fit to eat.
2 a you make a close examination of the staves of the casks”
. Yes
Q. Did you look to see whether the wood was good or not?
A. Not as far as I can remember.
_— »
LEAL EME TIE AN EE LIE ALE. ANTLERS EADIE LE IL IEE GIA EBB ALIA LLY AO IED LED I NEN | SEP et OD? 4 RAINE Ree ac Nera ~
Q. Was the wood in the staves new or old? Were they new or old
casks?
A. They were new casks from the appearance of them ; they seemed
to be new.
By the Court:
Q. What was the matter with the casks?
A. These casks when they arrived were all leaking and the hoops
were slack; naturally the staves got lossened and it flies all off then.
Some of them were broken.
Q. Some of what were broken?
A. Some of the casks, staves and hoops.
By Mr. Crandall:
Q. The head has a tendency to come out when the hoop is slack,
doesn’t it?
A. Absolutely.
Q. Did you say “absolutely”?
A. I am not talking about them; they are just hoops.
Q. But when the hoops towards the end come off doesn’t the head
[fol. 56] have a tendency to come off too?
A. Even when the first and second hoop come off the head may
remain if not rough handled.
Mr. Crandall: I move to strike out the latter part of the answer
“if not rough handled.”
Motion denied.
Exception.
QQ. What hoops must come off before the head will come out?
A. The head hoop.
Q. Do you mean the master hoop?
A. I am not an expert. I don’t know what you call the master
100p. c
Q. How about the hoops. Were they rusty?
A. They appeared to be rusty, yes.
Q. What was the condition of the hoops on these casks?
A. They appeared to be rusty. You can’t have a brand new hoop
in a cask when it comes off the seas.
Q. (Repeated.) What was the condition of the hoops on these
casks? Did they appear to be rusted?
A. They appeared to be rusted, yes.
Redirect examination by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. Did you see any casks that were not broken?
A. Yes. ’
Q. What did they look like to you?
A. Pretty good.
Q. Were they as good as the average cask that you get?
A. Oh, yes.
SBE RRC RIM eRe: Lge ty a me . , 2 OEPE TR
25
[fol. 57] Q. Have you ever scen any casks of olives in brine where
the hoops were not rusty?
A. Never.
_—_——
Cuartes A. THayer, being duly sworn and examined as a witness
for the libelant, testifies,
By Mr. Woodruff:
Q. What is your occupation?
A. At the present time I am the Department Manager for Austin
Nichols & Company. In 1917 I managed their olive importing de-
partment.
Q. Do you remember this consignment of the 227 casks of olives
to Austin Nichols received by the Steamer Isla de Panay in Novem-
ber, 1917?
A. Yes, very well.
Q. Did you have charge of the receiving of that consignment for
Austin Nichols?
A. I did.
Q. I show you these two bills of lading, 3 and 4, and ask you if
those are the bills of lading on the shipment to Austin Nichols?
A. Yes, sir, they are.
Q. Does those bills of lading contain any notations as to defective
casks or insufficient containers or anything that would call any one’s
attention to the character or condition of the containers?
Mr. Crandall: My previous objection is renewed, that the bills of
lading speak for themselves.
[fol. 58 | Objection sustained.
Exception.
Q. Are these bills of lading what you in the course of your busi-
ness would call a clean bill of lading or not?
Objected to.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
A. They are.
Q. What do you mean by a clean bill of lading?
A. A clean bill of lading is a bill of lading that a banker will ac-
cept and attach to a draft and on which he will make payment
against a letter of credit, and which indicates that the merchandise
Was in good condition when it was received from the steamship com-
pany. .
Q. If the bill of lading contained any notations as to defective
containers, old insufficient containers, would it be a clean bill of
lading?
( Ibjected to as calling for a conclusion and as immaterial.
Objection sustained.
xception,
26
Q. In the course of your business in connection with a consign-
ment of olives have you ever received any bills of lading containing
notations of the character that I have mentioned?
{fol. 59} Same objection.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
A. Yes, we have.
Q. Have you received many of them, is it an ordinary thing?
A. No, it is an unusual case.
Q. In case you do receive such a bill of lading with notations what
do you do with it?
A. We hold our shippers responsible. They have to stand respon-
sible for the consequences of having shipped goods——
The Court: This is a very strange line of examination.
Q. — received this in the ordinary course of business?
A. Yes.
Q. On the strength of this bill of lading did you accept the ship-
ment?
A. We did.
Q. Did vou pay the shipper for the goods?
A. The money was placed in Seville at the time we made our pur-
chase, and it was made available for his drafts in connection with a
clean bill of lading.
Q. You paid the money in advance on which he could draw for a
clean bill of lading?
A. Yes; in other words a letter of credit was opened.
Q. Under your arrangement would he have been able to draw on
a bill of lading which was not clean?
A. He would not.
Q. You didn’t examine these goods on the dock, did you?
A. Yes, I examined them on the dock.
{fol. 60} Q. Did you see any of them while they were on board
the ship?
A. Yes.
Q. What condition did you find them in? How far were thev
unloaded when you first went on the ship?
A. I should think about one-third of the quantity was left in the
ship when I looked down in the hatchway.
Q. You didn’t go into the hold?
A. No, I didn’t go into the hold, I stood on the railing.
Q. You looked over the coaming of the hatches down into the
hatches? ,
A. Yes, and I saw a number of broken casks of olives and saw the
olives scattered about. and noticed a very strong odor of rotten olives.
Q. They were inside the ship?
A. They were inside the ship.
Q. From your experience wil you express an opinion as to a prob-
able cause for the damage you saw?
pee IER SARL OS a tie ve a TI AE AE SB le NBR IST aS AAO BE esr AA nn NR 1, ahi iE Tt
Objected to as calling for a conclusion and on the ground that 3
counsel has not qualified this man as an expert on stowage. :
Objection sustained. é
Exception. ’
Q. Did you examine these goods on the dock? 4
A. Yes. ,
Q. What condition did you find? 4
A. A great many of the casks were without brine. Some of the
casks were entirely broken and when tendered to us by the Steamship
Company were like bundles of staves and heads. The staves in a
[fol. 61] good many of the casks were cracked and broken which al-
lowed the brine to leak off and on that account the olives had de-
teriorated.
Q. Some of the staves were actually broken? :
. Broken, sappy. 4
rOPoO>
they
Q. You say you established a letter of eredit on these olives?
A. Yes.
Q. The money was paid in advance?
A. I don’t know as you could say that. It was paid after the ship-
ment had been made in exchange for documents.
Q. Who had charge of the paying of the money in Spain? Did
you have an agent in Spain?
A.
Irving National Bank, and they paid it.
[fol. 62] Q. What was his authority in this matter besides that?
A.
and other documents he shall honor the draft of the holder, in this
case Rowlett Pyman & Company.
2. How long have you been buying olives from them?
- Do you claim that these casks were old casks?
. That will depend on what you mean by old.
OPoOro
- In what condition were they?
. Sound; full of brine, and the contents were satisfactory. 7
©
were unusually old or defective or anything of that kind?
A. No, they were the same sort of packages that had been used
right along in importing olives. There was nothing to differentiate
them from other importations.
Q. Is this the size, weight and character of cask usually used in
exportations from Spain and importations into this country, of olives
in bulk?
A.
. No, apparently not.
. This was their first trip?
Did you see any of the casks that were not broken?
Yes. :
Was there anything about the appearance that indicated that ;
Yes, of plain olives.
Cross-examined by Mr. Crandall:
We opened our letter of credit to the correspondent of the
The letter of credit recites that in exchange for a bill of lading
We have done business with them say for 10 years or more.
Had they been used before?
Pig Ape SARE RASA TITEL iNOS De i 0A DREMEL NTN iA 2 BAL SRO RTS AE 4 TSAO RRA URG DOA GATTI ema
A. It looked that way to me.
Q. Good casks?
A. Yes, good casks.
Q. So you don’t claim that the casks were bad?
A. No, I don’t claim that the casks were bad.
Q. How can you tell a new cask from a second hand cask?
A. I consider first the appearance of strength, the appearance of
the hoops and the character of the staves. If a stave shows signs of
rot then it would be an old cask in my opinion.
Q. Would you say these were new or old?
A. I looked at them and picked up pieces of staves that were hang-
ing about, and to that extent formed my opinion regarding them.
[fol. 63] Redirect examination by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. When you answered that you don’t claim these casks were bad
you meant to apply that remark to the casks that were not injured,
did you not?
A. I might say that our claim is that these casks were handled in
a bad way, by bad methods.
Mr. Crandall: I move to strike that out.
Motion granted.
Q. You would not claim that the broken casks were in good con-
dition would you?
A. No, sir.
Q. Do vou mean that broken casks were bad casks?
A. No, I was looking at the easks as they came out of the ship and
on the dock, and I found them in bad condition. I don’t make any
clatm about the casks; but we are making a claim about the manner
in which they were handled.
Q. But you don’t claim that the casks were bad containers?
A. The casks were satisfactory containers. They were the same
casks that we use right along.
By Mr. Crandall:
Q. Of course the casks that were broken naturally were not satis-
factory containers?
A. No.
Q. At the time these drafts were accepted or bills of lading re-
ceived had you any reason to believe that these olives were otherwise
[| fol. 64] than sound and well packed and in sufficient containers?
Objected to on the ground that the bills of lading speak for them-
selves.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
A. I had no reason whatever.
2y
FRED C. RopMan, being duly sworn and examined as a withess for
the libelant, testifies:
Mr. Woodruff: As to the Tolibia claim against the same ship it is
stipulated that the bill of lading in this case was the same as those
issued in the other two cases.
‘Mr. Crandall: I will stipulate tiat the stipulation for value in the
other cases will cover this, provided our clients will consent to it. [f
I can get their consent I will do so.
By Mr. Woodruff:
Q. What is your present occupation ?
A. Cargo surveyor,
Q. Employed where?
A. 56 Beaver Street, New York.
[fol. 65] Q. With whom?
A. Under a retainer of the Insurance Company of North America.
. Where were you in November, 1917?
A. In the employ of Koehler & Kemp.
Is that Koehler, Kemp & Koehler now?
es,
. Who are they?
argo surveyors.
. And your employment in connection with them was to actu-
ally survey cargoes on which claims had been made of damage?
es.
Q. I ask you to examine these documents and tell me what they
are (handing witness papers).
hey consist of one original report and two copies of my
survey report issued in connection with damage to olives on the
steamer Isla de Panay.
Q. Do those reports cover the three consignments in suit here,
Austin Nichols, E. Sanchez & Co. and E. Tolibia & Company?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you make that report yourself?
es,
er
O>O>0
Q. Did you actually survey and inspect the goods yourself?
A. I did.
Q
, Did you go on board the ship when she was at pier 8 East
A. I did.
Q. What state of unloading had been reached when you first went
there?
A. I would have to refer to my notes to tell you.
Q. I think you can refer to your notes and refresh your memory.
A. (Referring to notes) The casks were still in stowage in #1
aoe hold and all but a few had already been removed from the #4
old.
Q. Did you go into all the holds of the ship?
A. I went into the #1 lower hold.
[fol. 66] Q. How about #3?
A. #3 I have no record of.
CERNE
I RI A pa HAM Re OS Rene cecal LA BRIEH Sieh ote Pes ae kace FARE niin ac . . ¥ Dr tr te go> aS
30
Q. Did vou go into #2 or #4?
A. T looked down into #4 and it was practically discharged.
Q. Were the olives and casks still in two tiers in #1 hold when
you went down?
A. Yes, they were stowed two high.
Q. What condition did you find them in, in that hold, #1?
A. T found the casks in more or less damaged condition and the
fruit in them giving off an objectionable odor of decomposition.
Q. Were the casks intact or were they broken?
A. They were broken.
Q. State the nature of the damage as well as you can?
A. In breaking out the crates of lemons and onions and chestnuts,
there were eight packages to a sling; the stevedore had crushed the
casks in the square of the hatches by dropping the sling loads onto
them, and by making the sling loads too Jarge men knocked most
of the hoops loose in the casks in the square of the hatch.
Q. So the casks had the appearance of being crushed in the hold?
A. During discharge, ves.
Q. During discharge of other cargo?
A. Yes.
Q. Weren't they crushed on the upper part of the bilges?
A. Yes.
Q. Where slings had been deposited on them or dragged over
them?
Yes.
Q. Did you see any casks in the hold broken to pieces?
A. Not completely broken up.
Q. Were any olives scattered around in the hold?
A. They were in the #4 hold.
[fol. 67] Q. How did vou see that?
A. In looking down the hatches I saw the loose fruit scattered in
the bottom of the ship.
Q. In any considerable quantity?
A. No.
Q. But here and there olives were scattered round?
A. Yes.
Q. Was there a smell of brine in the various holds?
A. No. I would not attribute the smell to brine; T would attribute
the smell to decomposing olives.
Q. Olives will decompose if robbed of the brine, will they not?
A. Exposed to the air, yes.
Mr. Woodruff: I offer in evidence these reports.
By the Court:
Q. You were telling about things that stevedores have done. You
didn’t see them doing anything, did you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You saw them doing this?
A. T saw them doing it, ves, sir.
Q. Tell me again what you saw them do,
31
A. The after part of the 41 hateh immediately above the olives
was stowed with crates of lemons and crates of onions and crates of
chestnuts. These were taken out about 8 packages to a sling, each
sling load was dragged from the after part of the hatch over to the
square of the hatch, and the gradual loosening of the hoops on the
casks when the sling load was set down heavily resulted in crushing
or depressing the bilges and sides.
(fol. 68] Q. They were dragged from the after to the forward part
of the hatch?
A. They were dragged from the after part out to the square of the
hateh.
Q. And that loosened the hoops?
Yes, sir.
Q. So from your observation there was no trouble with these
articles when the stevedores’ operations began, when the discharging
of the cargo began there was no trouble with the barrels. Is that
your observation ?
A. Yes, that would inelude an examination of all the casks which
were still in the original stowage.
Q. So there was no trouble with the casks or barrels when you
first saw them?
A. When I first saw them they were then discharging the cargo.
By Mr. Woodruff:
Q. Were any of them broken when you first saw them?
A. Yes.
Q. They were in process of being broken?
A, They had already been broken and were in process of con-
tinuing to be broken.
Mr. Woodruff: I offer in evidence the survey reports.
Mr. Crandall: I object to the survey reports as not competent
Chey are self serving declarations.
The Court: Objection overruled. They are the memoranda that
the man took at the time.
“xception.
[fol. 69] They are marked respectively exhibits 1, 2 and 3.
Q. How do you aceount for the decomposing of the olives at the
time of discharging?
A. By the fact that the packages, the containers having become
damaged the brine escaped and air entered the olives.
Q. How long before did that happen, do you think? On the
voyage or during the discharge?
A. Possibly during the voyage and during the process of dis-
charge.
The Court: You dou’t know anything about it, do you?
The Witness: I would know just this: having examined olives
over a great many years I had the definite impression as to their
condition, and possibly they may have been without brine.
REET aR NN NR OIO TENE BE Ch er iki RARER ate UE MN eK. WAR AS Rh ae EN HE OEE LS) AY ala cern) lin WA at me OE ee,
< ‘
"i
oem
LOTR IER EP BRED RPS
Kaan
EARL PSE LENA BODEN LAG IPA DA et PALES LI AS RETA Mad nth Pa hd
32
Q. Does it take some time for the decomposing to progress as
far as it had progressed after the discharge?
A. The olives will turn color in a very short while after the brine
has escaped and will decompose very shortly after that; possibly
within a day.
Q. Then it is impossible for you to state whether this decompos-
ing had set in on the voyage or only during discharge?
A. It would be impossible to state definitely.
Q. Did you make this examination alone or was anyone with
you?
A. The examination of the #1 hatch IT had Mr. Collins, one of
the coopers of Austin Nichols with me.
(fol. 70] Q. I have a witness here Mr. Collins Chivers (indicat-
ing). Is that the man you mean?
A. T have always know him as Mr. Collins, yes, sir.
Q. He was with you in the examination of #1 hold?
A. Yes.
Q. Was he with you on the dock?
A. I believe he was on the deck and I went down in the hold.
Q. Did you see any of the casks being actually hoisted out of the
hold on to the dock?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you examine any casks or all of them on the dock after
they were discharged?
A. Generally, on the first examination.
Q. These survey reports which you have made are the result of
your actual survey and the reports are true, are they not?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was there any evidence that the cargo had shifted during the
voyage?
A. I can answer that best by saying that there were probably
only two or three packages left in #4 hold and I examined them
as they were in the original stowage in #1 hold which showed no
evidence in the #1 hold of a shifting of cargo.
Q. Were any of the casks in the hold in any such condition a-
to make it physically impossible in your opinion to hoist them in-
tact from the hold to the dock?
A. There were quite a number which accounted for the loose
olives in the bottom of the ship.
Q. It would be really physically impossible to land the casks
without their actually falng apart?
A. Falling apart sufficiently to lose part of the contents.
{fol. 71] Cross-examined by Mr. Crandall:
Q. What cargo interests did you represent on your survey?
A. The cargo consigned to Austin Nichols and E. Sanchez, anid
later on for EF. Tolibia.
Q. How long have you been a cargo surveyor?
A. Since 1911.
Q. What day did you go down on the boat?
ee eS
A. November 27th.
Q. Where was she lying?
A. At pier 8, East River, the south side of the pier if I remem-
ber rightly.
Q. Do you remember how many between decks she had?
\. One or two. I didn’t go into the construction of the ship.
Q. Where did you go when you went on the ship?
A. I looked in the hatches generally and noticed a few of the
packages in the #4 and what packages were still in stowage in #1.
Q. Where did you go? Did you stay on the upper deck or did
you climb on the ladder and go down into the hold?
A. I went over into the lower hold.
Q. You went over two between decks?
A. If there were two between decks,
(J. How did you get into the lower hold?
A. On the ladder in the square of the hatch.
Q. What are the dimensions of that hatchway ?
A. 1 took no measurements of the ship or no note of the ship’s
construction, so that any dimensions or any answer I might make
as to the construction of the ship would be purely based on memory
or impression.
[fol.72] Q. How many casks were lying in the syuare of the
+1 hatchway?
A. I will have to refer to my notes to tell you.
Q. Well, tell me.
A. (Referring to notes.) As I roughly remember there were
probably six across and four running fore and aft. There were
about 24 on top,
Q. How long were you down in the #1 lower hold?
A. Just long enough to watch them sling out the cargo and notice
generally the crushed stowage and loosened hoops on the casks.
Q. How many sling loads of cargo did you watch them take out?
A. Maybe six or seven,
Q. What kind of cargo were they taking out with the slings?
A. They were taking out cargo in crates that they sling on a
little platform, about 8 erates to a package.
(. What kind of a little platform was that?
A. Just two or three flat boards with ropes at each end. You
generally call that « platform,
Q. Did they put the crates on the top of the platform?
A. "es,
Q. Were the boards in the platform nailed together?
A. I presume they were.
Q. And they slung them out with the crates on top, with the plat-
form below the erates?
A. Yes.
Q. Where were they taking these crates from? Aft of the bar-
rels in the hatchway or forwerd?
A. Aft of the barrels,
5—609
( <tebatnne ORNL T riety Arne Md SS et me Nia te a te laa
34
Q. How did they get those erates from the wings of the ship
vut to the hatchway?
[fol. 73] A. The packages I saw were not stowed in the wings but
were probably stowed aft.
.Q. And they were bringing them directly forward and out into
the square of the hatch?
A. Yes.
Q. How big were those crates? How big a package did they
make?
A. 1% by 1% by 3, at a guess.
Q. Does that mean 3 feet long”
A. 3 feet long and 1%4 by 1%.
Q. How much did they weigh”
A. I don’t know.
2. Approximately?
” They might weigh 50 and 75 pounds per package.
2. How much did these casks of olives weigh apiece?
A. I never had occasion to weigh them, but I should say they
run about 1,500 to 1,700 pounds each.
Q. What was over the casks of olives in the #1 hold in the
square of the hatch?
A. When I examined them nothing was over.
Q. No skids?
A. No.
Q. How wide were the casks of olives?
\. Maybe 3 feet wide at the widest point I should think.
Q. So in bringing those packages of lemons out how many casks
would they touch if there were no skids under them?
A. They might
Q. No; how many would they touch? How many casks would
they bring them over from directly aft to the square of the hateh”
A. 3 or 4.
Q. How long did they allow them to remain on top of the casks?
A. Until the winchman or someone on deck got a signal to take
them up
[ fol. 74) Q. What hoops did they scrape?
A. Generally the bilge or quarter bilge hoop.
Q. Those casks have a curve, have they not? They curve up
from the ends towards the bilge?
A. Right.
Q. They were stowed fore and aft in the hold, weren’t they?
A. Yes.
Q. The crates were drawn forward over the casks, were they’
A. Yes.
Q. Then how, if the crates were drawn forward over the casks
and the casks are higher at the bilge, how can it possibly affect the
hoops enough to loosen them. I should think they would do just
the opposite, move them toward the bilge?
A. Your sling load will only drag on it from over head, will
follow the contour of the barrel, and they will go up and down to
the bilge again until the bilge of the succeeding casks will catch
DEESIDE LEENA RR Re A Pemeacste ue Tamms : romenmes CURRIER ete ae “ — |
35
it and force it up again. That means that your other sling will
drag on the quarter bilge.
Q. Do you think that a package of 50 or 75 pounds was strong
enough to bring any weight on the casks?
The cases are 50 and 75 pounds for one package. There were
S to a sling load, so that would be six or seven hundred pounds,
if not more,
Q. You were 8 to one sling load?
A. Yes,
Q. Do you know anything about the casks?
A. Sufficiently to determine fairly whether they are suflicient
containers or not.
Q. You know a good cask from a bad cask, don’t you?
F . es, J
fol. 75] Q. Isn’t it a fact that a good cask of olives would
stand a weight of 400 pounds on top of it for a small interval of
time?
A. The question of 400 pounds is taking us into a calculation,
and it would be a question of how heavy the impact was.
Q. There couldn’t be much of a direct impact if they were drawn
out of the after hold?
A. You must remember that the weight of the sling load which
we will say was 700 pounds will hit only one of two staves not
1,600 pounds of staves. So that the weight might be only 20 o1
25 pounds, so there could not be any direct impact. That was
only one of the conditions. That accounted for the gradual loosen-
ing of the hoops, but the crushing of the bilge staves was the result
of the sudden drop of the sling load on it.
Q. Do you remember that one of these slings dropped down after
they were hoisting it up?
;, - They were not ropped down, but they were set down sud-
denly.
Q. They were not dropped down?
A. No, they were not dropped down.
©. How many slings were there set down heavily?
A. T saw evidence of 5 or 6.
Q. No; how many did you see that dropped or dropped heavily?
A. I will look at my notes again and will tell you a little more
definitely (refers to notes) ; oh, two or three.
Q. What was the effect of the dropping or the laying of this
sling on this cask?
A. The gradual and continued depressing of the staves.
[fol. 76] Q. How long did it lay on them?
A. It might only rest on them a second, but the impact would
suceeed in forcing the staves each time.
Q. Then your statement is not the result of observation of the
sling, but it is a conclusion?
A. It was a conclusion possibly, but also secing that the staves
were further depressed during the discharge or while IT was there,
Q. Outside of your seeing this sling load rest on the staves for
a fractional part of a second your evidence is a conclusion, is it not?
36
A. Outside of seeing the actual impact’?
Q. Yes, outside of seeing this actual impact, for a fraction of a
second your statement as to the depression of the staves is a con-
clusion ?
A. It is a conclusion based upon the location of the casks.
Redirect-examination by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. You didn’t testify anything about any fraction of a second
of an impact?
Mr. Crandall: Objected to, that he saw this sling on there for «
fraction of a second.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
A. I meant the fraction of a second in getting it too close. That
might be two seconds or a fraction of a minute.
[fol.77] Q. Did you see more than one impact?
A. I saw several; I didn’t tally them.
Q. You saw them hauling these slings, weighing five or six or
seven hundred pounds, consisting of « platform suspended by these
ropes containing 8 or so cases; every sling was dragged from aft on
top of these casks and dropped down before being hoisted?
Mr. Crandall: Objected to; he didn’t say there was any dro iter
down of the sling; he said they let them go down on the cask.
Q. Is my statement correct?
A. At first they dragged them, and then they would sometimes
start them a bit and set them down suddenly, and then start them
up again and take them out of the ship entirely.
Q. Did you see any casks being crushed by this impact?
A. I remember a few.
By the Court:
Q. Impact of what?
A. The sling load of cargo would come down suddenly on the
casks in the square of the hatch before they were finally hoisted out.
7 What would the sling be full of? Would it be just the sling
itself?
A. No, the sling containing the eight packages of lemons or
onions or chestnuts.
{fol.78] By Mr. Woodruff:
Q. How much would it weigh’
A. I should say 75 pounds; only one unit would weigh about
that, and there were about eight units to a sling load.
Mr. Crandall: That would only make between four and six hun-
dred pounds.
i —
37
Q. What would the sling weigh?
A. The sling itself would not probably weigh more than 50
pounds,
Q. Have you ever seen other shipments of olives?
A. Yes, a great many.
Q. Were these in the usual casks that would come from Spatu
for hold olives?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How did their condition compare with the average condition
of casks?
A. Their landed condition ”
Q. No, their condition as you saw them in the hold. 1 mean
the run of the casks?
A. The casks that came out sound in the normal packages?
Q. The usual package in the usual condition ?
A. Yes, the usual package in the usual condition.
Q. What wood were these casks made of, do you remember?
A. I would call them chestnut.
Q. Are most of the casks made of chestnut nowadays?
A. As I remember every olive cask has been made of chestnut
wood.
[fol.79] QQ. Is any oak used for olive casks now?
A. I have never seen an oak cask.
Q. You have seen many casks of olives of this sort and gen
eral character?
A. Yes.
Reeross-examination by Mr. Crandall:
Q. There are no hoops on the bilges of these casks, are there’
A. There were two hoops which are run to the center which are
called bilge hoops out on the quarter.
Q. How many tiers of casks were in the square of the hateh
when you went down?
wo tiers.
Q. Where did you stand when you went down there?
A. I probably stood either on the easks or immediately under
the deck to keep away from the handling of them.
Q. How much space was there for you to stand in’
A. I don’t know; I may have stood in the between decks. 1 don’t
remember just what part of the ship I stood, but I remember being
in close enough proximity to the easks to know what was happening
Q. Did you actually ‘see the bilge depressed after the setting
down of one of these slings?
. Yes.
Q. How many times?
A. Several times: I didn’t tally the impacts,
Q. What would that have to do with the hoops?
A. The dragging of the sling loads would first loosen your hoons:
resting vour sling loads suddenly on the bilge would depress the
Staves.
ee at i a ae i
38
Q. Isn’t that your conclusion ?
A. No, sir.
[fol. 80] Q. Did you see it?
A. I first saw the general condition of loose hoops on the casks
in the square of the hatch, and on succeeding sling loads. When I
saw that I saw the further loosening of the hoops which had already
started.
Objected to, that they had already started.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
Q. The hoops on a great many of the casks were loose through-
out the stowage?
A. I would not say a great many, because the condition when I
saw them applied to the top tiers.
Q. Well, I mean in the top tiers?
Ye Yes. .
Q. A great many were loose?
A. Yes.
CoLttn CuHiIvers, being duly sworn and examined as a witness
for the libelant, testifies:
By Mr. Woodruff:
Q. What is your occupation?
A. Cooper.
Q. Where are you employed?
A. With the Orient Importing Company.
Q. What is their business?
A. The olive business.
Q. They are importers of olives?
A. They are importers of olives.
[fol. 81] Q. How long have you been with them?
A. Since February of the present year.
Q. Where were you employed before that?
A. Before that I was assistant foreman on the White Star Line.
Q. For how many years have you been assistant foreman of the
White Star Line?
A. From October, 1918 until February of this present year.
Q. What was the nature of your duties?
A. Well, it was to see that the goods went on the ship in good
condition.
Q. You are a cooper?
A. Yes.
Q. And you were engaged in coopering for the White Star Line
and are now for the Orient Importing Line?
A. Yes.
Q. Where were you employed in November, 1917?
A. With Austin Nichols.
PINES RR GI caer HORDE TE NON MRE: TIS PREY Homa arena ACUMEN CO REM BN ee |
39
Q. In the capacity of cooper?
A. In the capacity of cooper, yes, coo ring olives.
Q. Did you examine this shipment of 227 casks of olives on pier
8 East River arriving on this steamer?
A. Yes.
Q. Are you the gentleman who is referred to by the preceding
witness as Mr. Collins?
A. Yes. ;
Q. And you are generally known as Mr. Collins, are you not?”
A. Yes.
Q. You examined the olives in his company ?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you go aboard the ship?
A. On one oceasion I went on board the ship. |
Q. Did you go into the hold?
A. No, sir, just on the deck.
[fol. 82] Q. Did you look down into the hold?
A. Oh, yes.
Q. What did you see when you looked down?
A. Well, I couldn’t just mention the holds; I didn't take any
notice—that is, the numbers of the hatches.
Q. You mean which hold it was?
A. Yes, sir, but what I noticed was that the casks generally were
in a bad condition.
Q. In what way?
A. Some of the casks were broken.
Q. How were they broken? In what way? What was the nature
of the break?
A. There were broken staves and so on, broken chimes,
Q. Were they crushed as you saw them?
A. Some of them were somewhat flat on top.
Q. Have you in the course of your experience as cooper made
many examinations of consignments of olives?
A. Oh, yes, yes.
Q. From your experience to what should you attribute the damage
that you noticed in the hold?
Objected to as calling for a conclusion.
Objection sustained.
Exception.
Q. Did you see any of these casks while they were being damaged?
m A. Did I see any of the casks while they were being damaged?
No, sir.
Q. You did not?
A. No, sir.
Q. How long had you been in the employ of Austin Nichols?
A. 14 years.
[fol. 83] Q. Were you engaged as cooper all that time?
A. Cooper and olive man. T was looked upon by those who knew
ie as an expert in olives,
RPA LOMA ANY RIOR CA, ON RRB MOIR NCI RE OR REINA CALEY Pll NLRC MTR
40
Q. What was the condition of the olives in this consignment?
A. Well, the olives, generally speaking—the damaged ones were
in very por condition.
Q. In what way?
A. The olives were dry, twisted, and some of them in my judg-
ment were worth practically nothing.
Q. Were they decomposed?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Had the brine leaked out of the casks?
A. In some cases, yes.
Q. The olives were dry?
A. Yes, the olives were dry.
Q. In the casks?
A. Yes.
. Were any of the casks actually breken so that olives were
scattered around?
A. Well, there were some olives scattered around and | know of
one instance where there was one cast broken; but [ didn’t see it in
the hold. I knew it was rebuilt down in the hatch of the ship by
one of the dock coopers, or two of them.
Q. You mean the broken cask was actually reconstructed and
rebuilt in the hold of the ship?
A. Yes, that is what I mean.
Q. Was it then filled with olives?
A. Well, naturally when a cask falls apart they scatter over every-
thing; whatever they collected of the olives they put them back into
the cask.
Q. So that when they brought this rebuilt cask out of the hold
there were olives in it?
A. Yes.
[fol. ~ Q. Naturally there was not any brine in it?
A. No.
Q. What was the condition of the casks on the dock? Did you
examine them on the dock?
A. Yes, I did. A big number of casks had broken chimes and
broken staves or cracked staves and they were in leaky condition.
Q. You say “broken chimes”. A chime is the top part of the
staves into which the head fits to hold it?
A. Yes, and there is a groove in the chime for the stave to set in.
Q. And the groove in the top over the head and the bulge over
it is called the chime?
A. Yes.
Q. And the head could fall right out?
A. Yes.
By the Court:
Q. Did you find broken chimes?
A. Yes; when a chime breaks the groove that we speak of. it
leaks out through that particular chime.
Senneterre en . . . atl
41
By Mr. Woodruff:
Q. You say you have seen many shipments of olives in casks?
A. Yes, I have been at them for years.
Q. Have you ever seen any shipments that were in worse con-
dition than this?
A. Well, I would not say; I might have seen one, I would not
just say. I have seen them as bad, but at that particular time I
believe that was as bad as I had seen for a good while before that;
but I have seen others, I believe, as bad.
[fol. 85] Q. Were these casks of the usual size and weight that is
used in the Trans-Atlantic shipments, in your experience?
A, Yes, sir, just the same.
Q. What wood were they made of?
A. Well, I believe those were chestnut.
Q. Is chestnut the usual material used in olive casks?
A. I think previous to the war, I am sure previous to the war they
were all oak,
Q. How about since the war?
A. Since the war I believe.they had gone back to the oak again.
Q. You think they are oak at the present time?
A. Yes; what I have been handling lately.
Q. Have you handled any chestnut casks since the war?
A. I was out of the olive business for three years; during that time
I don’t know. There were no olives came in where I was working
during that space of time and I couldn’t tell just what they were
made of. Of course I was in touch on and off with the olive busi-
ness; that is I took care of olives for several firms through the city
during the time I was working for the White Star Line.
Q. Do you mean attending to their recuperation, refitting and re-
conditioning?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You say these casks were the regular size?
A. Yes.
; they were about 4 by 4-and weighed sixteen or seventeen
hundred pounds?
A. Well, they generally weighed from sixteen hundred to eighteen
hundred pounds; in exceptional times they weigh a little more.
Se 86] Q. Did you see any casks actually being hoisted off the
ship?
A. Do you mean in discharging?
Q. Yes.
A. Well, not that I saw.
Q. I mean did you in this particular shipment see any of them
being actually hoisted off?
A. No no, I did not. I didn’t see any being hoisted off that I
remember.
Q. But you did see them in the hold and on the dock?
A. Yes, I saw them in the hold. Of course when the packages
fame on the dock I didn’t notice the discharging of the ship. My
business was to take care of the goods.
42
Q. From your experience in handling and inspecting these ship-
ments to what possible causes would you attribute the damage to these
olives?
Objected to as calling for a conclusion.
The Court: I think that is pretty vague, but he may answer the
question though it is just a matter of argument.
Exception.
A. Well, I have seen the barrels being loaded on the ships, and
the taking of the barrels off the dock in the draft; sometimes they
bang against the side of the ship, doing considerable damage along
these lines. Of course a cooper’s business is to tally those articles
right into the hatch if any of them are damaged—lI have seen the
chimes being broken by the draft going on up into the ship and bang-
[fol. 87] ing against the side of the ship and breaking the chimes.
I have seen that done repeatedly and I have had to send men into
the hatch to see that they are re-coopered.
Q. How about discharging olives?
A. In discharging olives the same thing can occur.
Mr. Crandall: I move to strike all this out.
Motion granted.
Exception.
Cross-examined by Mr. Crandall :
How long have you been a cooper?
. I have been a cooper for 18 years.
. Why did they bring the olives in in chestnut casks during the
war?
A. From what I have understood of the oak it was very scarce dur-
ing the time of the war.
Q. What kind of wood is best to make a cask out of?
A. Oak.
Q. What is the matter with chestnut casks?
A. Well, so far as putting in chestnut generally the wood saps. It
gets saturated and it don’t hold; it is not as good and water-tight
as oak.
Q. Olives are all packed in brine?
A. Yes.
Q. A salty liquid?
A. Yes.
Q. What do the chestnut staves do to the brine?
A. I don’t think it does anything; I don’t catch just what you
[fol. 88] mean. Do you mean does it damage the brine?
UE eee 2s AIL FOOTSIE TATA Ne 9 = . 7 — . , «it
Q. During the war they brought these olives in in chestnut casks?
A. Yes.
Q. Before that time they brought them in in oak casks?
A. Oak.
Q. Are you a cooper?
A. Yes.
-Q.
A
Q
43
Q. No, do they soak up the brine?
A. Naturally, providing the wood is new.
Q. What happens to the staves when they soak up the brine?
A. Well, they get more water-tight. So far as the wood being
saturated with the brine would have nothing
Q. Sup-osing the staves are not new?
A. They are saturated generally with the liquid.
Q. Doesn’t it make them brittle?
A. Well, no.
Q. Are chestnut staves as good for such purposes as oak staves
A. The oak would be better.
Q. Why are the chestnut staves not the best?
A. Oak is understood by everybody in the business as the prin-
cipal material that they use in making barrels, casks.
Q. Why is it that the chestnut staves are not as good for olive
casks?
A. Well, they don’t hold as good ; that is, they are not water tight
to the same extent as the oak is.
Q. Isn’t chestnut a much softer wood than oak?
A. Yes
Q. And much more brittle?
A. Providing it would be dried out.
Q. There is much more chance of damage being sustained to a
cask made of chestnut than when they are made of oak?
A. I think the chances would be very slight.
Q. If chestnut wood is not as good for casks as oak why wouldn’t
they suffer damage?
A. If I were to give you my opinion about why the olives do get
[fol. 89] damaged it is through breakages and leaks. Even with
chestnut it would not leak to that extent and damage the olives. It
is easier to break chestnut than to break oak. Oak is a strong
material. You know that, and it would stand more abuse than the
-chestnut_generally_ speaking. _Chestnut-would_not-stand_the same
abuse as oak would.
Do you recommend chestnut as a better wood for casks,
especially these large casks?
A. No, sir, I would not.
Redirect examination by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. Do you mean to say that chestnut is in you opinion an im-
proper wood?
Objected to as cross examination of his own witness.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
Q. You heard Mr. Rodman testify that chestnut was the wood
generally used at the present time, that he has not seen any oak
for a number of years. Is he mistaken.
A. Well, before the war it was generally oak that was used.
ee ee Baa gl RANA SC BARO ES, ee
44
Q. When did you leave Austin Nichols?
A. In 1918, in October, 1918.
Q. That was during the war, was it not?
A. That was during the war.
Q. Then you went with the White Star Line?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you have anything to do with the receipt of consignments
of olives in casks while you were with that line?
A. No, sir.
{fol. 90] Q. How long were you with the White Star Line?
A. Three years.
Q. Then you went with the Orient Importing business in 1921?
A. Yes, this present year, 1922.
Q. Up to February, 1922 you have had nothing to do with olives
in casks?
A. Excepting doing a little job on the side.
Q. But I mean as a general employment?
A. As a general employment.
Q. Is chestnut as strong a wood as oak?
A. No.
Q. Is a chestnut cask as strong as an oak cask?
A. No, sir.
Mr. Woodruff: Will you agree that a Port Warden’s testimony
will be substantially the same as that of this witness?
Mr. Crandall: I place no reliance on the Port Warden’s testi-
mony, and I cannot stipulate anything.
Mr. Woodruff: Then perhaps before reaching the end of the
case T will take his testimony.
Recross examination by Mr. Crandall:
Q. Were any of these hoops on these casks rusted through?
A. Well, they generally do rust, from the brine ; even when in
sound condition they rust.
Q. Were any of these staves that you saw broken, soggy or satu-
rated with brine?
[fol.91] A. They would all be, naturally; they would be in touch
with the brine and would be saturated of course.
Q. These were not good casks, were they, as a matter of fact?
Objected to as calling for a conclusion.
The Court: You had better ask him to describe the condition
of the casks.
Q. Will you describe the condition of the casks?
A. Well, there were some of them with the hoops rotten; that is,
the iron was in a rotten condition and some of them were broken
staves; some of them had broken chimes.
Q. What was the condition of the wood in the staves?
A. Well, they were cracked or broken from being either—from
bad usage, to my mind.
SRY tay PRS CR OR Eon PRE R eh Of x05 maiz ; wre sete Longpep tee Sra Ee Y _—
45
Mr. Crandall: I did not ask what your opinion was as to the usage,
and I move to strike that out.
Motion granted.
Q. What was the condition of the wood in the staves?
A. Well, in order for a stave to be broken it would have to get
bad usage. You understand that.
Mr. Crandall: I move to strike out the answer.
Motion granted.
[fol.92] Q. What was the condition of the wood in these staves?
A. Do you mean the broken staves”
Q. The broken staves or any of the other staves in these casks.
Was it in good condition or bad condition ?
A. Well, with the staves that were broken, they were broken.
The rest of the cask might have been in good condition.
Q. How about the broken staves? Was that wood in good or bad
condition ?
A. Of course when it was broken it was in bad condition.
By the Court:
Q. Do you mean rotten?
A. Oh, no; now I see what he means. The wood was absolutely
sound, only broken.
By Mr. Crandall:
Q. Do you think these were sufficient containers for olives; made
out of chestnut?
Objected to.
Objection overruled.
Exception.
___A. They would have held-the olives all right if they had been
treated right.
Mr. Crandall: I move to strike out the answer.
Q. Just forget this question of treatment, and tell me whether
[fol. 93] those casks were or were not sufficient containers for olives,
made out of chestnut wood?
A. When they were made, of course they were sufficient to hold
the olives. Of course they were.
Q. How could they be sufficient if the staves got loose?
A. Well, they couldn’t get loose without bad handling.
Mr. Crandall: I move to strike out the latter part of the answer.
Motion denied.
Exception.
Recess till 2.10 P. M.
Fee = MAE ROTI Tact sae RE ot eas
46
Met pursuant to adjournment at 2.10 P. M.
Present as before.
Mr. Woodruff: I have no other witnesses present. I cannot i
cate the Port Warden, but his testimony would be only cumulative
except for the’ bills of lading and reserving the right to put in
certain part of the depositions, that will be our case.
The Court: Do you wish to offer those depositions?
Mr. Crandall: 1 am going to offer the depositions.
Mr. Woodruff: Then I will not offer them. The Port Warde
[fol. 94] says he was there in the employ of the Steamship Compan
and examined the casks in the hold, but I do not think he went int
the hold.
Mr. Crandall: The Port Warden is supposed to give a certificat
for good stowage.
Mr. Woodruff: Perhaps 1 may be permitted to call him in re
buttal.
Mr. Crandall: I offer in evidence the deposition of Captain Artur
Musera, Jose Ma Miquel, Miguel Corvera, Emilo Bardecci, Antoni
Oliveros; also the depositions taken in Seville, Spain, with the es
hibits attached thereto.
TESTIMONY FOR THE CLAIMANT
Antonio Ricuicul, being duly sworn and examined as a witne:
for the claimant, testifies:
By Mr. Crandall:
What is your business.
. Stevedore foreman and longshoreman.
. Are you in business for yourself?
No, sir.
. For whom are you working?
. At the present time I don’t work for nobody. My firm is or
of business.
[fol. 95] Q. How long have you been a stevedore”
A. About twelve years.
Q. Who were you working for in November, 1917”
A. Dominic Pace, stevedore.
Q. Was that in November, 1917?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you have anything to do with the unloading of the Stean
ship Isla de Panay belonging to the Spanish Line in Novembe
1917 in New York?
A. Yes.
Q. What were you doing on that steamer?
A. I was attending two hatches, #1 and #2.
Q. What did you have to do with those hatches?
A. To tell the men how to get the cargo out.
>rOPOPO
47
. Where were you standing when the cargo was being unloaded ?
A. I was going down from one hatch to another.
2. Were you in the lower hold?
A. I was in the lower hold, yes, sir.
Q. Were you at all in the between-decks?
Q. Were you in the upper and lower between-decks, both?
A. Yes.
Q. Were you there on the dock when these casks were being un-
loaded ?
A. Yes.
Q. Alongside of the ship and on the dock?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you remember these shipments of olives on this steamer?
A. Yes.
Q. What kind of containers were they in?
A. They were in casks.
Q. Were they big or little casks?
A. They were about 5 feet 9 in length, and about 12 feet round.
[fol. 96] Q. Were they five feet 9 inches long?
A. Something like that.
Q. How wide were they from one bilge to the other?
A. About 4 feet.
Q. Did you look at these casks when you were unloading them
from the steamer?
A. Certainly.
Q. Tell me what you observed as to the condition of these casks;
that is, the wooden staves and the heads and the hoops, et cetera.
A. Well I could see that to sling them up we had to roll them into
the square of the hatch because they won't stand by dragging out with
the fall, because they were pretty weak and rotten. As soon as you
would touch them they would be open, those hoops. We rolled
some of them you know. By rolling them in ¢ are—of the——
hatch the hoops would get loose and bursted and some had to be
opened in the hold of the ship too, so that we could sling them up
4s we usually would sling them. we would get them on the dock
and roll them into place; and while rolling them some of them
couldn’t stand it and they would be wide open.
By the Court:
Q. Do you mean the barrels. the casks?
A. Yes, and while rolling the hoops bursted and the heads fell
down and the whole business would go down.
- Before you began to discharge, when you first saw these casks
in the hold, what condition were they in then, before you began to
[fol. 97] roll them?
A. They looked good stowed, but on handling them it was danger-
ous, because they were rotten.
48
By Mr. Crandall:
Q. What hoops came off from the casks when you started to roll
or handle them?
A. Well, sometimes we would get two hoops in these chimes, and
sometimes the middle ones on the bilge.
Q. Was there any other way to get these casks away from the
wings of the ship to the square of the hatch, into the square of the
hatch, besides rolling them?
A. No, sir, any other way would be worse.
Q. How did vou roll those casks over to the square of the hateh-
way?
A. We had a skid and would roll them on the skid, so we could
sling them in the square of the hatch.
Q. What kind of a skid did you use?
A. We had a cable on each edge; there were about two—one
about 4 feet long and the other about 16 feet.
Q. Where did you lay these skids?
A. We would shift them; every time we had to get a cask we
would shift them because they would not be all in one place; we
would shift them so that when we rolled them they would he in the
square of the hatch.
Q. Did you place the skids underneath the casks and roll the casks
on the skids?
A. Yes.
Q. How thick were the skids?
A. The skids were about 4 inches thick.
{fol. 98] Q. How wide?
A. About 6 or 7 feet wide; about 6 feet wide.
Q. Do you mean one piece of board or several pieces of board
nailed together?
A. No; several pieces of board nailed together.
By the Court:
Q. What you did was to place these in some part of the hold, these
skids, 2 rfl the casks on top of them?
es.
By Mr. Crandall:
Q. Had any of the casks that were in the hold broken out of the
stowage?
. No, sir.
How did you get the casks out of the hold?
Put a rope sling around the two ends and we hove them up.
How many casks would you take in a sling?
One at a time.
~ you use any hooks or clamps in getting these casks out?
svO
. How did you get the casks away from the side of the ship”
The ones that looked good and strong, we would roll them;
the others we would land them on the truck and would truck them
POPOorero>
=
49
so that they would be fixed and then put them where they would
belong.
Q. _— would you put these casks on the truck? On end or
on the bilges?
A. The only way to put them is put them on the head,
Q. Where the heads were out would you or would you not put
in new heads before the easks were taken off and put on the dock?
[fol.99] A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who did that?
A. The cooper.
Q. How did you get casks off from the trucks?
A. We would lay a skid down on the floor and then we had a
bag full of corks so that we would not drop the casks.
Q. Did you hear Mr. Rodman, the surveyor, testify here this
morning?
A. I heard him but I couldn’t catch every word very well,
Q. Did you hear what he said?
A. Yes,
Q. Did you see him on board this ship?
o No, sir.
Were you down in the #1 hold?
A. I was down in the #1 and #2; in the holds and on the
deck of the ship and on the dock, wherever I was needed.
Q. Did you hear him testify that the men would raise these
slings and drop them down on the barrels in the square of the hatch?
‘A. T heard him say that.
Q. Is that true or is it not true?
A. No, sir, it ain’t true.
Q. What kind of merchandise did you have stowed in the #1
hold aft of the casks?
- There were some barrels of wine and some chestnuts and other
stulf,
Q. How did you get that stuff from the other part of the hold
over these barrels and into the square of the hatch?
A. Well, like the chestnuts we had to sling them on a platform
sling, and that would be slung in the square of the hatch, because
we could never drag a platform sling from underneath the hatch.
(fol. 100] Q. Where would you leave that platform? In the
square of the hatch?
A. Yes,
Q. How would you get the cases on the platform?
A. Pass them from where they are stowed to the platform.
Q. You would pass them from hand to hand?
A. Yes, :
Q. By men?
A. Yes,
Q. Did you drag any cases across the barrels in the square of the
hatch?
A. No, sir.
4—609
— ae . 1) Re Sh RT
Oo er qans erm . ~ ‘
50
‘ Q Did you have anything over the barrels in the square of the
hatch, any skids or anything?
A. If there was a case there so that we had to drag the stuff on
top of it, we always took a skid, but there was no dragging on top
of the casks at all.
Q. Did your method of unloading these casks of olives differ in
any way from the usual and customary way of unloading olives
from other steamers?
Objected to.
—. How long have you been unloading olives at the port of
New York?
A. At that time I had worked about two years.
Q. For what companies did you work?
A. The same company.
Q. How many different steamship lines did you unload for’
A. Just that single line.
Q. What line?
A. The Spanish Line.
Q. Did you ever see olives unloaded any differently from the
ones you unloaded in this case?
A. I saw it, but I didn’t work with that.
a wu Q. Do you understand the question?
. Yes
Q. Did you ever see them unloaded any differently?
A. Oh no, no sir.
Q. Did you notice whether the bilges of these casks touched the
floor of the hold, or whether they were off from the floor of the hold
of the vessel?
A. They were off.
Q. How were the bungs? Were they up or down?
A. They were right on top.
Q. Were there any empty spaces in the hold around these casks
when the vessel arrived?
A. No, sir.
Cross-examined by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. Did you say there were empty casks in the ship when the
~ arrived?
. Empty casks?
Q. Yes.
A. No, sir.
Q. Do yeu ever drag any cargo over other cargo when you are
ees it, cargo from the wings or away from the square of the
te
A. If it is like bag stuff we will drag it, but other stuff that is
liable to dump we never sling it way in. We always take them out
of the square.
Q. These cases of chestnuts. You would not drag those over the
other cargo?
-
51
A. They can’t be on account of the sealing on the plat-
form and that platform will be catching some place.
- Have you ever seen that done?
A. Well, i don’t have to see it, because I know it.
Q. You have seen it done, where they drag these platform slings
over other cargo, it does catch once in awhile?
A. Well, yes, I have seen that.
[fol. 102} Q How much would you say these casks weighed?
A. About three quarters of a ton.
Q. Should you think they were as high as 5 feet 9 inches, around
about 6 feet? Are they as tall as I am?
A. No, about 4 feet.
>s How much did these barrels of wine weigh? How large were
t
=, wel, they were small barrels, like a 20 gallon or 50 gallon
Q. Would t roll those casks over or would t them from
hand to hand?” Pena
A. They would roll them over the platform.
Q. You say your platform was under the square of the hatch.
You had barrels of wine clear away from them. How did you get
them -from the platform ?
A. There were no casks in where the wing was, because the wine
was in the hold, alongside of them.
Q You had to lift the barrels of wine up on to the casks, didn’t
you!
A. Well, we had them like clear up to the deck, and we let them
down there on the skid.
2. _ had your platform in the square of the hatch?
. Yes.
Q. And over at the side, you had to lift the casks of wine up
the of olives to get them over onto this platform, didn't
Q. How about the barrels of wine that were on top of the olives?
were forward of that.
Q. Were there any barrels of wine stowed on the casks of olives?
Q. Those that were off at the side would roll over to get the
on the platform? _ —
52
Q. Are you prepared to say t th at w “hen you first saw these casks of
olives in the hold ne of them were broken?
no
A. None of them were broken, but you could see the shape they
were in.
Q. What shape «were ihey in?
A. Why, so that if you would touch them—you would not want
to touch them.
. Did they look perfectly sound before you would touch them?
. No, some were leaking down below.
. How did they look on top?
Rotten.
, eg they broken down or crushed in?
O.
. How could you tell they were rotten?
. Well, they were damp and rusty.
. a they were not broken?
)
There were no signs of any damage on top? Do you remember
there were two men that have sworn that there was?
A. No, sir, what was broken was broken while we were working,
because you could hardly move one of them without dragging it.
{fol. 104] Q. You said you were afraid to touch them. What made
you afraid to touch them?
A. Because they were badly leaking.
Q. yg they show no signs of breakage at all on top?
A.
Q. Any hoops off?
A. Not till you touched them, as soon as you would touch them you
would get them off.
Q. But the hoops were all on until you touched them?
A. That is right.
Q. You are not prepared to say that Rodman was not in the hold
and you did not see him?
A. He may have been there; I can say that I didn’t see him.
Q. Did you notice particularly whether the bungs were on top?
A. They were all on top.
Q. You looked at them all?
A. Yes, you could see.
Q. If they had been half a dozen casks with the bungs a little one
side, would you have noticed it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. About how much do these platform slings weigh? You said
they were 6 feet wide and 4 inches thick?
A. It ain’t solid; the platform ain’t solid; it is two boards this
way and empty in the middle.
Q. Then it is not all 4 inches thick?
A. No.
Q. You mean there are two pieces of 4 inch board one at each
end and then boards across it?
A. No. We have got two boards on each side, one on top of the
other, a couple of pieces across.
OPOPOPOProre
Rene Se na ipEC TORR te rep Sena grades iy he
PT Peds — |
Q. Then it would rest on the two 4 inch pieces?
A. Yes.
(foi. 105] Q. How much would that weigh? Would it weigh 100
pounds?
A. No, no.
Q. 50?
A. Well, about 50.
Q. What should you say was the weight of one of these slings
that contained cases of chestnuts, or whatever you did swing when
it was ready to hoist out?
A. Oh, about 400 ponnds.
Q. You say you put this platform under the hatch and then would
bring the other goods and put them on the sling and then hoist the
sling up?
A. Yes.
Q. And then the sling would be lowered down again and you
would proceed?
A. Yes.
Redirect examination by Mr. Crandall:
Q. When you rolled wine barrels from the wings of the ship over
to the square of the hatch did you roll them over the olive barrels
or over skids on top of the olive casks?
A. They couldn’t be rolled on top of the olive barrels because
they would be going between them and the work would be three
times more than what it should be.
Q. How did you get the mover there?
A. We had good solid boards; if there were a couple we used
to put boards on top; when there were like a dozen or so we would
put the skid.
Q. Was it easier to roll one barrel on a board or skid than over
the tops of the olive casks?
. Yes,
Q. What was the length of one of these olive casks from one end
to the other end?
A. It must have been 5 feet or a little over 5 feet.
fol. 106] Roperr Forses, being duly sworn and examined as a
witness for the claimant, testified :
By Mr. Crandall:
Do you understand the Spanish language?
Yes, sir.
Where were you born?
In Spain.
Do you speak Spanish?
A little bit.
. What do you mean by that?
eed manera . wr PA 8 RI LOH NRTA 7 I CO
PPO>O>o
A. Enough to be understood.
Q. Do you speak Spanish fluently?
A. Yes
Q
. Have you ever acted as interpreter?
A. I have.
Q. Have you ever acted as interpreter for the firm of Bigham,
Engler & Jones?
A. Yes, I have.
Q. On numerous occasions?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. I show you three bills of lading which have been introduced
in evidence, Claimant’s Exhibits 2, 3 and 4, and I also show you
three other documents and ask you to state whether or not these
bills of lading in English are a correct translation from the Spanish
into the English, and whether you checked up the English transla-
tion Fg if it corresponded with the Spanish original?
A. Yes.
Q. Is that a correct translation?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Crandall: I offer in evidence the three translations of the bills
of lading. —
They are marked respectively Exhibits A, B and C.
[{fol. 107] Q. I also refer to a protest filed in this case, Claimant's
Exhibit 11, and ask you to state whether or not you made an
English translation of that protest?
A. I have.
Q. Is this the document, is this the English transalation of the
-/; (indicating) ?
a. es,
Mr. Crandall: I offer it in evidence.
It is marked Exhibit D.
Q. Did you see the guarantees attached to the commission in this
ae , appear in Spanish?
. Yes
Q. Have you translated those three guarantees?
A. T have.
Q. Are these your translations (indicating) ?
A. Yes, sir, they are.
The translations of the guarantees are offered in evidence.
They are marked Exhibits E, F and G.
No cross examination.
gs ;
Frank anno, being duly sworn and examined as a Witness for
the claimant, testifies:
By Mr. Crandall:
Q. What is your business?
A. Stevedore foreman.
[fol. 108] Q. Are you in business for yourself?
A. I have been for myself for the last 4 years.
Q. How long have you been a stevedore ?
A. Pretty near 12 years.
Q. Did you have anything to do with the unloading of the steam-
ship Isla de Panay in November, 1917?
. I was the foreman.
. Who employed you?
. Dominic Pace.
. What holds did you have charge of?
#3 and #4.
- Did you unload many olive cargoes before this?
es.
How often on other boats?
. Well, about 20 years before that.
. Did you unload olives during that time?
. Some on the Italian Line.
. How did you get the casks into the square of the hatch; the
ones that were stowed in the wings?
A. We used to use a skid, first we would take them out of the
square of the hatch and would land a skid on the square of the hatch,
2 by 10, 13 feet and then we used to roll them on top of the skid.
We would swing on a circle and raise up on them when they were
in the square of the hatch.
Q. Did you remove any of the cargo from the square of the hatch
before you started rolling any from the wings?
A. Yes, we would take it all off and then we would land it on the
skid.
Q. Were you down in #1 and #2 holds also?
A. Well, I used to take a look there once in awhile.
Q. Did they have all the cargo out of the square of the hatch in
|fol. 109] #1 and #2 before they started rolling the cargo from
the side?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you look at the casks down in #3 and #4 holds and also
in the other holds?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did they look like? Tell me about the hoops and staves
and everything.
A. A barrel they used to stow——
Q. How did the barrels look?
A. They looked very bad; the hoops were all rusted.
Q. How bad were the hoops?
A. You couldn’t touch them. If you touched them with your
finger nai] it would burst the hoops.
OFOrOPoOporo>
a a I en na 2
56
Q. How were the staves?
A. They were rotten altogether.
Q. How were the heads?
A. The heads were all right, but the hoops would break off and
then the head would come out.
Q. When would the hoops break off?
A. As soon as they would ' eak off then the heads would come too.
Q. When would the hoops break?
A. When we used to move them, to roll them on the skid, then
they used to break.
Q. When the hoops broke what happened?
A. The hoops would come off and the olives would go all over the
hatches, and then we used to head them up and set them on the
dock and land them on the truck and take them to the cooper.
Q. The casks that had the head out you would put on the truck?
A. Yes; they were about a foot and a half high.
[fol.110] Q. How would you get them off from the 4-wheeled
truck?
A. We had a kind of skids and we would have a couple of bags of
saw dust on the bottom te put them on.
Q. And the other casks (hat you didn’t take away on trucks what
would you do with them?
A. We used to land them on the dock and would roll them on the
dock to put them in a certain place, and when we used to roll them
the hoops would break and the heads would come off and then we
would head them up and would leave them there till the cooper
would fix them up.
Q. The coopers were on the dock?
A. The coopers were on the dock.
Q. How did you get them out of the hold?
A. With rope slings.
Q. Did you use any hooks to get them out of the hold?
A. No, because we would break them open if we did that. The
staves were not strong enough to hold 1600 or 1700 pounds.
Q. Did you ever see any slings of merchandise being thrown down
on top of the casks in the square of the #1 hatch?
A. Oh no, sir; that can’t be done.
Q. Did you ever drag any of your cargo in packages across the
barrels into the square of the hatch?
A. You can’t drag anything on top of the barrels; you would
break it. We used to handle them one by one; three men on each
side and two men on the square of the hatch, and then we would
make up the draft on top of the skid in the square of the hatch.
We had a 2 by 10, 13; that means 2 inch board and 10 inch wide
and 13 feet long.
[fol.111] Q. AWhen you had these drafts of cases would you have
a little platform underneath them? |
A. We had a little platform to take out the onions, about 4 or 5 |
feet long and 3 feet wide and would make a draft up there.
Q. Why did you have a platform?
A. To take out onions.
i i at at ov SPN I HERES RE MDa Ie RTD eS
Q. Could one man handle one of the big casks?
A. Oh, my God, how could they handle it.
Q. How much do they weigh?
A. About 1600 or-1700 pounds,
Q. Can you use a hand truck to take a cask away from the ship?
A, No.
Q. What is the usual way of getting them away from the ship?
A. You have got to have ‘a 4-wheeled truck, or else land them on
the dock and roll them.
Q. When you roll any casks that you thought would not stand
the rolling?
A. No, when we saw they were not good enough we would land
them on the 4-wheeled truck and bring them to the cooper,
Cross-examined by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. All of those casks that you did roll did not stand rolling, did
they? They broke?
A. No, they didn’t stand rolling; they broke.
Q. If you had put them on the 4-wheeled truck they would not
have broken ?
A, No, because when we saw their condition we would land them
on the 4-wheeled truck.
fol. 112] Q. But some you didn’t land on the 4-wheeled truck and
rolled them away and they broke?
A. Yes.
Q. There were quite a number of casks that did break while roll-
ing on the dock?
A, Yes,
Q. You say you unloaded the square of the hatch. Do you mean
to say that you got right to the floor of the hold?
A. No, no; one tier. We did take one tier off first and then we
landed our skid.
Q. Just so you could get into the hold?
A. Yes,
Q. Then your skid resting in the square of the hatch would raise
the cask that was on it?
A. Yes.
Q. You mean to say that. if you had casks or eases of onions off
in the wings or fore and aft of the square of the hatch that you would
bother to put up skids to carry them to the square of ‘the hatch
and put them on this platform?
A. We usually keep the skid on the square of the hatch, and at
the same time get a couple of planks and lay them tier by tier and
we used to drag some; when we had a chance to pass them hand
hand we would pass them hand by hand, three men on each
side.
Q. Frequently you would drag them?
A. No, because they would turn them over and we would have to
drag them again.
Q. But you could drag these barrels across these skids?
a AERO CUMIN IR BS BA Se A ARCA RO RR ea A sts oo OE
58
A. Oh, my God, how could I do it? I am not a machine haul-
ing stevedore.
Q. Did you roll them?
A. Yes, but before that we would put a couple of planks.
{fol. 113] Q. You never dragged them?
A. No, sir.
Q. Where would the men stand while rolling them?
A. If a man rolls a barrel he has got to stand on the casks; he
can’t stand on the end.
Q. You have testified that the hoops were so rusted that they
would break if you touched them with a finger nail, that the staves
were altogether rotten?
A. Yes.
Q. How did they get those casks inside the ship in that condition?
A. Well, they used to get them into the ship and would put any-
thing on the ship.
Q. They couldn’t get the casks out of the ship and you say they
would skid all right. How did they get them into the ship and
stowed?
A. They used to put a sling on and put them in the ship; but
before they travelled from the other side it would be kind of damp
in the hold and they would rust from the other side coming to this
side.
Q. Do you think they handled them any better on the other side
than you do here?
A. Pretty near the same.
Q. Those casks couldn’t have been in the condition that you found
them when they were laid down?
A. Maybe they were kind of better.
Q. They must have been much better?
A. Well, some wasn’t; they were rusted altogether, as far as I
could see. ;
Q. But all of them didn’t break?
A. Oh, of course not.
Q. All of the hoops didn’t break?
A. All of the hoops didn’t break, of course all did not break.
{fol.114] Q. Was the wood rotten?
A. The wood was rotten ; it was rotten before, because I think those
barrels had been in this country and then they sent them on the
other side and filled them up again.
Q. Then you think they were rotten on the other side?
A. Yes, they would be put on the ship and it would be during
war, and that would cost a lot of money——
Q. And if you had been careful in taking them out of the ship
they would have been all right?
A. We would take care of them pretty good.
Q. Who employed you?
A. Dominic Pace.
Q. Is he a general stevedore here in New York?
A. Yes.
Q. Did he work for any other line than the Spanish Line?
Oe TT Sen ee ee eae nepete Eatin ere " —— " —
a ee et et eT |
59
A. Oh, I think so.
Q. Have you ever worked for any other line?
A. Yes.
Q. Since you have been working with him?
A. When I chucked my job on the Spanish Line then I went in
business for myself.
Q. But while you were with Mr. Pace did you work on any other
ship than ships of the Spanish Line? ta
A. All on the Spanish Line.
Q. Do you know that Mr. Pace did any work for any other line
than the Spanish Line?
A. Yes, at Pier 25, North River, Ansaldo, the Italian Line.
Q. But you yourself never worked for any other ship than the
Spanish ships while you were with him. Did you use any hooks on
any of these casks, any of the good ones?
O.
Q. Did you try to?
No, sir.
(fol. 115] Redirect examination by Mr. Crandall:
Q. Do you remember seeing Mr. Redman who was here this
morning, that surveyor?
A. I don’t think
Did you see him here in Court this morning?
Yes, I saw him in Court this morning.
- Was he on board that ship?
. I don’t think I saw him on the ship or on the dock.
You never saw him on the ship?
. Provided he didn’t change his face.
. Do you have men down in the hold of your boat when you are
unloading it? |
A. No, nobody is allowed to go in the hold of the ship.
Q. Did you allow anybody down in the ship when you were dis-
charging?
A. No, it is not allowed, and I never allow anybody to go in the
hold of the ship, because if anything happens the foreman at the
hatch gets the blame for it.
OPOPOPO
Recross-examination by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. You never let the surveyor for an insurance company go into
the hold of the ship?
A. He is not allowed to go. He is only allowed to go by the hatch
and look down in the hold.
He can go on the ship?
A. Oh, yes, I can’t stop them from doing that, but if he wants to
go in the hold I will stop him, or else I will stop the gang altogether.
You don’t want a Surveyor to see your work. Is that it?
A. Oh, yes, I do; but if anything is broken or anybody got killed
I would get all the blame for it.
60
[fol. 116] Q. You are not prepared to swear that Mr. Rodman
didn’t go in the hold?
A. I didn’t see him at all.
Q. But he might have gone in, might he not, and you not have
seen him?
A. I didn’t see him no place.
SatvaToreE Noto, being duly sworn and examined as a witness for
the Claimant, testifies through the interpreter Connie Mantia, who is
also sworn :
By Mr. Crandall:
. What is your business?
. Foreman.
Foreman of what?
Stevedores.
Do you work for yourself?
No.
Who do you work for?
Do you mean now?
Yes.
The Prince Line.
How long have you been a stevedore?
. 15 years.
. Do you remember unloading the steamer Isla de Panay in
New York in November, 1917?
A. Yes.
Q. Who were you employed by at that time?
A. Dominic Pace.
Q. What did you have to do on the Isla de Panay?
A. I was head foreman.
Q. What hatch did you go down into?
A. All of them.
{fol.117] Q. Where else did you stand beside being in the hatches?
A. Well, I was standing on the dock and then again upon the
hatches.
Q. Do you remember these shipments of casks of olives from Spain
on that trip?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you look at those casks when they were in the hold, and
when they were on the dock?
A. Yes.
, >, Tell me what you noticed about those casks. A. How did they
ook?
A. They were very bad.
Q. Tell me all about them. Describe how they looked.
A. The hoops were all in bad condition. Some of them were
broken, and the staves of the casks were rotten.
LPOPOPOrOPore
Bs Seals PEE EET AOE LR Re tet dele SERMON ADR NB Nt ere ems ————— |
61
Q. When you say the hoops were in bad condition describe a little
more fully what you mean. In what respect were they in bad con-
dition?
A. Well, I mean that the wood was not the same as all the other
casks that we had been handling.
Q. I mean the hoops.
A. They were rusty; the-hoops were rusty,
Q. Will you tell me what happened to the barrels or casks wlien
you were taking them out of the ship?
A. Do you want to know the manner in which we took them off?
Q. No, what happened to them when you took them off?
A. When we handled them to put them on the skids, so as to roll
them down to the hatch, some of the hoops would break, because they
were rotten.
Q. How did you get these casks into the square of the hatch?
(fol. 118] A. We used skids to roll them, and we used to roll them
on to the square of the hatch so that we could sling them right
off.
Q. How did you sling them out of the ship?
A. With a sling.
Q. you use any hooks, or clamps on these casks?
A. No.
Q. When you started to roll these casks in the hold you say the
hoops went off, some of them?
A. Yes, every now and then one of the hoops would crack and
break right off.
Q. What happened when the hoops would break?
A. When this would happen then we would take the casks and put
it on a 4-wheeled truck.
Q. oo any of the heads get out of the casks down in the hold?
A. No.
Q. What casks did you put on the 4-wheeled trucks?
A. When one of those heads would come off
Q. Did I understand you to say that no heads came out down in
the hold?
A. No, they didn’t come off.
Q. What casks did you put on the 4-wheeled trucks?
A. Those whose heads would come off.
Q. When did the heads come off?
A. When we would take off the top tier, when we would see the
bottom tier some of the heads would be crushed then, the heads of
the casks on the bottom tier,
Q. When did the ends of these casks come out?
Mr. Crandall: He doesn’t understand you.
[fol.119] A. The heads never would come off, only the hoops
would come off. :
Q. When would the hoops come off?
A. One or two; as soon as you would touch them they would come
off.
62
Q. What casks did you put on the 4-wheeled truck?
A. Those casks whose hoops came off, because we were afraid that
when the hoops came off by rolling them over to the dock the heads
might come off too.
i Did you drag any cases of merchandise over the tops of the
casks into the square of the hatch?
A. No, we did not.
Q. Did you take any of these slings of boxes and lift them up and
~~ — them down on top of the casks in the square of the hatch?
. No.
Q. Do you remember that Mr. Rodman who was here this morn-
ing, that surveyor
A. No.
Q. You saw him in Court this morning, didn’t you?
A. Oh yes, I saw him. but I don’t know him.
Q. Was he down in the ship when you were discharging that
cargo?
A. No.
Q. Did you allow men to go down into the hold when you were
discharging your cargo?
0.
Q. Did you ever roll wine barrels across the top of the casks of
olives?
A. No.
Q. How did you get the wine barrels over to the square of the
hatch?
A. We would put some planks and roll the barrels on the planks.
Q. Did you have any lemons on board this ship at that time?
. sO.
ffol. 120] Q. When you took that cargo in cases, and took it out of
the vessel and there were any casks in the square of the hatch how
would you get this cargo in the cases over to the square of the hatch?
A. We would place a platform in the square of the hatch and the
men would pass by hand the cases and place them on the platform.
Q. Is there any way to get those casks away from the wings of the
ship over to the square of the hatch except by rolling them?
. Which ones do you mean?
. Casks of olives? ‘
. No, you would have to roll them.
naa would be no other way?
oO.
Cross-examined by Woodruff :
Did you see any casks broken in the hold?
0.
a you see any hoops broken in the hold?
0.
>PO>o>
Were any staves or heads broken?
0.
When would they first break and begin to snill olives?
. In handling them from the tiers in the hold some of the hoops
would break.
>OPOPrOro
ORIN Ie SINE CRT CORNY RR-A RILEY I: Mowry Perse tenn |
OPO PO SINS vy ‘ ns
a"
63
. Would the casks break while handling in the hold?
. No, they would slacken.
. Did any olives leak out in the hold?
No, the brine would.
The brine would, but no olives?
0.
. Was that true of the casks in the whole tier of the hold. the
121] bottom tier, that there were no broken casks?
. No, not the barrels; hoops.
a no olives leaked out in the hold?
0.
. What cargo was on the ship besides these casks of olives?
. Onions, barrels of wine and onions.
Were there any drums of oil, essential oii, metal barrels?
. No, small casks of wine.
=
LO>O>POro
>PO>rOro>:
Noex P. Pitcuer, being duly sworn and examined as a witness
for the Claimant, testifies:
By Mr. Crandall:
Q. What is your business?
A. Inspector of cargoes, and cargo surveyor.
0 you hold a master’s certificate?
A. I hold a British extra master’s certificate issued by the British
Board of Trade.
Q. Were you ever master of vessels?
A. For 8 years master of steamers trading principally between
New York and the Far East.
Q. How long did you go to sea before you were on shore?
A. 25 years.
Q. What companies in New York have you acted as surveyor for?
A. The Cunard Line, the Anchor Line, the Hawaiian American
Line, the United American, Hamburg American Lines, Lloyd, Sa-
[fol. 122] baudo, Kerr Line, Oriental Line, Garcia & Diaz, Jose
Taya’s Sons, Booth Line, the Blue Funnel Line, and quite a number
of others.
Q. When you were at sea what trades were you engaged in?
A. When I was in sailing ships we were trading principally be-
tween Great Britain and India and Australia. in steam trading prin-
cipally between New York and the Far East, China and Japan.
Q. What kind of barrel cargo, if any, have you carried?
A. Barrels of oil from New York, petroleum, lubricating oils and
inward would be bean oil, cocoanut oil in hogs-heads and pipes, wood
oil, essential oils,
Q. What experience, if any, have you had with olives from the
Mediterranean to this port?
A. I have inspected a number of cargoes containing olives in
brine from Spain; I say a number, probably several hundred during
the past years, both on the Anchor Line steamships, and Garcia &
Diaz ships.
— om = . . - r met caer FLY LIT NTR RET LPNS AR Ge Cre
Bam URN Se - .
64
Q. Where did you inspect it from?
A. In the port of New York at various ‘piers; 1 saw them in the
vessel in stow during discharge and on the pier whilst waitin +
delivery.
Q. I want to put a hypothetical question to you. 1 want you to
assume the following facts as true: Assume that the steamer Isla de
Panay was a vessel of 3484 gross and 2087 net tons. That «he had
a lower hold and upper and lower tween decks. That she had four
holds or compartments, No. 1—59 ft. in length and 29 ft. in width
No. 2—62 ft. in length and 41 ft. in width, No. 3-14 ft. in length
fol. 123] with 8 ft. of allowance for fan or tunnel rece-« and 40 ft
in width, No. 4—72 ft. in length with 26 ft. of allowance for the fan
or tunnel recess and 39 ft. in width.
That the distance from the floor of the hold to the tween deck«
was 13 ft. That the distance from the top of the fan to the lower
tween decks was 5 ft. That the bilges of the vessel were cleaned out
and whitewashed before any cargo was loaded.
That most of the casks of olives which are referred to in thee
actions were stowed in lower hold« Nos. 1. 2, 3 and 4.) That the
casks measured approximately 5 ft. in length and 4 ft. in diameter
at the bilge and each weighed approximately 750 kilos.
That cargo battens were laid around the side of the «hip on her
beams. That in holds Nos. 1 and 2 dunnage wood wa< placed between
the casks and stanchions; that the casks of olives in hold« Nos. 1 and
2 extended across the ship from one side to the other and that in
holds Nos. 3 and 4 they were stowed on either side of the shaft
tunnel which had a wooden covering: that all casks were stowed with
their bungs up and their bilges free; that no cargo was stowed below
the casks in the lower hold; that there was a clearance of between |
and 2 inches between the bilges of the casks in the first tier in the
four holds and the floor. which clearance was obtained by placin
wedges or quoins 4 or 5 feet long and 4 or 5 inches wide at the end:
of the casks; that at the end of each cask on each side a small quoin
was placed: that in holds 3 and 4 dunnage wood was put between
{fol. 124] the casks and the shaft tunnel: that after the first tier of
casks in the lower holds was laid a second tier was stowed on top of
the first tier one on four or bilge and cuntline with wedges hetween
the casks; that between the casks nearest to the skin of the shin
small cargo was stowed if there was any room. or if there was not
sufficient room for cargo dunnage wood was laid; that there were neo
empty spaces around the casks of olives in the lower holds; that om
top of the second tier of olives small barels of wine, eases of wine am!
cases of chestnuts were stowed; that all empty spaces around the
olive casks in the four holds were completely filled with other carro
or dunnage wood; that the wine barrels were about 1 to 1/6 of the
size of the olive casks; that the casks of olives oceupied a heicht in the
hold of approximately 9 ft.; that in the space on top of the fan or
tunnel recess, at the after end of the No. 4 hold, 1 tier of olives in
casks was stowed, being qoined and chocked in the manner prei-
ously stated; that some bags of chestnuts were stowed on top of the
olives on the fan; that the space forward of the olives stowed on the
a ee > nee ” SO ES Be Op ge =
fan was comedy filled with cargo; that the tween deck hatches
were covered and that in the square of the hatchways Nos. 1, 2 and 3
in the upper tween decks, one tier of olive casks were stowed; that
the casks in the said tween week hatchwava were quoined and dun-
naged in the same manner as those in the lower holds: that above the
eases of olives in the tween deck hatchways bags and cases of chest-
[fol. 125] nuts were stowed, and that the at the sides of the
casks of olives was filled with chestnuts and that there were no empty
ces either forward or aft of the olives in the tween deck hatchways.
That all casks, whether in the lower holds, on the tunnel recess or
fan in hold No. 4, or in the square of the Nos. 1, 2 and 3 hatchways,
were stowed bung up and bilge free.
Q. What is your opinion as to whether or not the stowage of the
casks of olives as I have stated to you was the usual and customary
method of stowing olives in the transatlantic trade, and whether or
not such stowage was proper?
Mr. Woodruff: Objected to as being incompetent and irrelevant,
Leing somewhat outside of the ease. There is no custom as to the stow.
age pleaded in this ease, and there has heen no imue raised by the
testimony of the libellant as to the actual disposition of these casks
in the hold of the ship.
The Court: What is the claim of stowage’?
Mr. Woodruff: That the easke were damaged while in the care
and custody and on being delivered by the ship.
Mr. Crandall: I am prepared to show proper stowage.
The Court: He may answer the question.
Mr. Woodruff excepts.
A. Such stowage as you deseribe was customary and ’
[fol. 126] Q. Assuming that these casks were 4 feet in diameter,
what can vou say as to the possibility of any undue pressure being
placed upon the two tiers in the lower hold?
A. re could not be: if there were only a 4-foot clearaner over
the uper tier and a part of that space was filled in with onions whieh
is in itself light, there would be no undue pressure on the olives
Q. Have you any objection to stowing casks on top of a tunnel
recess?
A. None whatever.
Q. Have you any objection to stowing casks in the square of the
upper between decks hatchways provided the cupty spaces around
them were filled in?
A. None at all.
Q. Is there any method of discharging or handling casks of olives
at this when they get off from the vewel and are landed along-
‘ide, other than rolling them in to their place on the pier?
A. No, when the cask is mised up they are rolled into a position
m the pier where they are to await delivery.
. Is there any way that you know of getting casks into the «quare
f the hatchway other than rolling them from the wings of the ship
© the square of the hatchway?
A. T have always seen them rolled into the hatchway.
5—609
Pir _—— ae ~~ ll
66
Q. What, if anything, can you tell us with regard to the use of
chestnut wood for olive casks?
Objected to on the ground that no foundation has been laid for
the question.
{fol. 127] Q. Are you familiar with the advantages or disadvan-
tages of oak, chestnut, and other woods for olive casks?
A. Yes.
Q. What experience have you had with regard to observing dif-
ferent kinds of wood for olives?
A. During the past six years in the Port of New York I have
examined many thousands of casks, both of oak and chestnut wood
and have gone to a considerable amount of trouble in making
special surveys and reports to steamship companies concerning the
examination. In 1919 the chestnut wood casks were coming in
in such condition from Spain and Italy with olives alone that we
brought the attention in circular form to different ship owners and
showed them as comparison the result of chestnut wood as com-
pared with oak.
Q. Based upon your own observation?
A. Absolutely, on special surveys, under my own observation.
Q. Based upon your own observation of the containers in which
olives came in, will you tell us what are the relative merits of oak
and chestnut for olive containers?
A. My experience of oak containers has been that the results are
good. The containers come here in fair condition and their con-
tents are usually intact. With chestnut wood we invariably have
some heavy leakage, whether it is the olive in brine or whether it
is oil. The olives in brine, or the brine itself, causes the chestnut
wood—which is softer than oak and more britthe—to become
soggy. When it gets soggy and saturated the staves erack and
[fol. 128] when they are cracked you can see the saturation of the
staves right through the staves. Also in carrying olives one must
always consider the contents, and that the hoops will rust. When
the hoops gets so rusted through the edge of the containers they
burst and then the staves open; even though the heads do not come
out the leakage of brine sales place; I would say that the chestnut
wood containers would not compare with the oak containers for the
carrying of oil or brine or any similar commodity.
Q. How long have the chestnut containers been used for olives?
A. From experience I cannot say what was used before the war
because I was at sea until 1916; but my experience on the Spanish
coast, where I was for six months, showed me that it was the cus-
tom in Spain to import oak in staves from this country and from
Great Britain to make these containers. Since the war as a result
of war conditions, and not being able to get the imported wood,
they made ‘hem of chestnut. That applies to the olive oil also.
Q. Did you hear the testimony this morning of Mr. Rodman
abont a slings damaging the casks in the square of the hatch?
A. Yea.
67
Q. Assuming that that testimony is true what effect would such
a sling have upon a cask which was a good strong container for
olives?
A. I don’t think it would have much effect on the containers
unless they were to do it continuously for some period of time;
but I would expect to see an effect upon the containers of the
onions, if they were onions, because the containers of onions are
[fol. 129] brittle wood and the sides or ends would burst.
Q. Tfow large are these ordinarily large casks in which olives are
’ carried?
A. Olive casks?
es,
A. They measure about 5 feet in length, 4-feet from bilge to
bilge.
Q. How much do they weigh?
A. About three-quarters of a ton.
Cross-examined by Mr. Woodruff:
Q. Do you think no precautions are necessary with good strong
onk casks of olives, hitting them with cargo as has been testified
would not have any effect? You said no damage would be done
by hitting these casks with cargo?
A. If as described by Mr. Rodman where they were not dumped
down on them and there would be a pressure brought to bear for a
short time, it would not have any material effect upon good sound
containers. It would have, if you dropped 8 packages down the
hatchway on top of them. It would break them.
Q. Are they using any oak casks now?
A. T couldn't tell you what they are using, because today I
leave the ships ig the hands of my two assistants. One ship dis-
charging olives in brine at present in Brooklyn, we have, but I
have not seen her.
Q. As a matter of fact you have not personally known of any
oak casks since they began to manufacture chestnut casks owing to
war conditions?
A. That I cannot say; some are oak and some are chestnut I
[fol. 180] believe. IT have never made an examination to see which
is which. In July we had a ship in Brooklyn on which the asks
were reported to me as being oak and chestnut, one of the Ybarra
Line steamers.
Q. You think they use oak and chestnut indiscriminately now,
do you?
A. They use oak and chestnut, both.
Q. Assuming that the casks were of chestnut in the average con-
dition of shipments during the war, would it be likely that any
effect of 4-feet of Super-stowage of small barrels or casks of wine
and cases of chestnuts, considering how they would have to be put
into the ship by being rolled or wheeled or carried over the casks
to stow them, and having to be carried over the casks to get them
. “ So ELH I 6G Pi ag MUN ALE IRR Ve RI WLI ST emt
Mr esr PO eRLOR FO J y wey , .
68
out—would there be any likelihood of their doing damage to these
casks of olives.
A. No, sir, not if these casks had come on board intact and had
been stowed intact with only 4-feet moving room, with wine or
other light commodity such as onions, I think they were perfectly
justified in stowing them over the olives.
Q. If it appears from this testimony that these casks when they
arrived at Seville were in a leaky condition, some of them were re-
coopered and made tight so as to show that there was no leaking
while loading these casks onto the river steamer and transporting
them down the river and bringing them alongside of the Isla de
Panay and stowing them in the hold, and that there was no leak-
age, would you reasonably expect that they would arrive intact
{fol. 131] with that method of stowage’
A. We might expect them to arrive intact under those conditions.
Q. Your answer would be yes or no to that question?
A. One would reasonably ex them to.
Q. That was my question. Your answer would be yes, would it
t?
A. Well, I would not know—I would say yes, I say you might
expect them, but when you get to your port of destination.
Q. Would they come apart?
A. If they had been re-coopered and came on board in apparent
good condition you would expect them to be discharged in good
condition.
Q. If they were re-coopered so that they survived all this han-
dling with no leakage apparently, you would reasonably expect them
to arrive at their destination in good condition, would you not?
A. What do you mean by “good condition”? I have never yet
seen or known of any consignment of olives in brine making her
dise without heavy leakage of brine.
Q. t is, heavy leakage of brine; not of the olives?
A. Heavy leakage of brine.
Q. Except for this heavy leakage of brine you would reasonably
expect, or would expect, that the olives under the conditions men-
tioned in my previous question would arrive in reasonable condi-
tion?
A. I would expect the containers to arrive intact.
Q. Assuming that on the voyage there was a great quantity of
[fol. 132] leakage so that the brine was pumped out of the bilges
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.