Appendix — Contech Division, SPX Corp. v. National Labor Relations Board
Supreme Court brief1999
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
la
APPENDIX A — OPINION OF THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
DATED DECIDED AND FILED DECEMBER 30, 1998
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
CONTECH DIVISION, SPX
CORPORATION,
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent,
Nos. 97-5099/5247
v.
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS
BOARD,
Respondent/Cross-Petitioner,
INTERNATIONAL UNION,
UNITED AUTOMOBLLE,
AEROSPACE AND
AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA,
UAW,
Intervenor.
On Petition for Review and Cross-Application for Enforcement
of an Order of the National Labor Relations Board.
Nos. 7-CA-39061, 7-RC-20485
Argued: March 13, 1998
Decided and Filed: December 30, 1998
IR NETS 2 RT
Pe Ne on a
ne RO NIA NS TON a: SAE DE LL NR TO TES Ste BN + Rima. ARNEL OT 9 end : fete ei Eis
2a
Appendix A
Before: RYAN, COLE, and GILMAN, Circuit Judges.
COUNSEL
ARGUED: Peter J. Kok, MILLER, JOHNSON, SNELL &
CUMMISKEY, Grand Rapids, Michigan, for Petitioner.
Peter Winkler, NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
APPELLATE COURT BRANCH, Washington, D.C., for
Respondent. Nancy Schiffer, ASSOCIATE GENERAL
COUNSEL, INTERNATIONAL UNION, UAW, Detroit,
Michigan, for Intervenor. ON BRIEF: Peter J. Kok,
MILLER, JOHNSON, SNELL & CUMMISKEY, Grand
Rapids, Michigan, David M. Buday, MILLER, JOHNSON,
SNELL & CUMMISKEY, Kalamazoo, Michigan, for
Petitioner. Peter Winkler, Aileen A. Armstrong, Deborah E.
Shrager, NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
APPELLATE COURT BRANCH, Washington, D.C., for
Respondent. Nancy Schiffer, Jordan Rossen, ASSOCIATE
GENERAL COUNSEL, INTERNATIONAL UNION, UAW,
Detroit, Michigan, for Intervenor.
OPINION
RONALD LEE GILMAN, Circuit Judge. This matter
arises from the efforts of the International Union, United
Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers
of America (“the UAW”) to organize the production and
maintenance employees (“the employees”) of Contech
Division, SPX Corporation in Dowagiac, Michigan. After
setting aside the results of a certification election in which a
majority of the employees voted against UAW representation,
the National Labor Relations Board (“the Board”) ordered a
new election in which the UAW prevailed. The Board
3a
Appendix A
subsequently certified the results of the latter election and
designated the UAW as the exclusive collective-bargaining
representative of the employees.
Upon Contech’s refusal to bargain with the UAW, the
Board charged Contech with a violation of Sections 8(a)(1)
and (5) of the National Labor Relations Act (“the Act”), 29
U.S.C. § 158(a)(1) and (5), and issued an order directing that
Contech bargain on request with the UAW. Contech now
petitions for review of that order, and the Board brings a
cross-application to enforce the same. Contech asserts that
the Board improperly set aside the results of the first election
and also improperly certified the results of the second
election. We are satisfied, however, that substantial evidence
supports each of the Board’s decisions in question.
Accordingly, we DENY Contech’s petition for review and
—* the Board’s cross-application for enforcement of its
order.
I. BACKGROUND
Contech, a parts manufacturer for TRW, Ford Motor
Company, and other automotive suppliers, operates two plants
in Dowagiac, Michigan (“Plant 1” and “Plant 3”) and a plant
in Auburn, Indiana. SPX Corporation, Contech’s parent
company, operates a plant in Muskegon, Michigan.
In November of 1994, the UAW filed a petition for a
Certification of Representative (“the representation petition”)
with the Board, indicating that “a substantial number of [the]
employees wish to be represented for oses of collective
bargaining by [the UAW] and [the UAW] desires to be
certified as representative of the employees.” Pursuant to a
Stipulated Election Agreement, a certification election was
scheduled for January 12, 1995. — pre-election
campaign, Contech engaged in conduct that prompted the
Board to set aside the results of the election. The specific
nature and effect of that conduct, as found by the Board, is set
forth in detail below.
Oe OTN Ese ARR
* on ete EPR. RP Me ee
4a
Appendix A
A. The First Election
On November 17, 1994, three days after the UAW filed the
representation petition, the employees received a letter from
Dwayne Weber, Contech’s Human Resources Manager.
Weber stated in the letter that over two-thirds of the 600
lants that had closed in Michigan over the past two decades
d union work forces.
The employees also received a handout containing a
reprinted newspaper article addressing Ford's removal of
manufacturing dies from an Indiana plant where employees
were on strike. The following statements from the article
were emphasized in the margins of the reprinted pages:
“DIES OWNED BY FORD MOTOR COMPANY," and
"THE DIES WOULD HAVE STAYED AT THE PLANT
ANOTHER FOUR YEARS IF THE STRIKE HAD NOT
OCCURRED.” The handout noted that the UAW was the
union involved in the article. Another Contech handout
contained a reprint of a 1982 letter in which a Contech
customer informed Contech’s general manager that it had
"closed its doors . . . due to union difficulties." On the back
page of both cf the above handouts, the following message
appeared in large print: "SAY NO TO THE POSSIBILI
OF LOST CUSTOMERS, LOST JOBS, LOST PAY, LOST
BENEFITS, AND OTHER TROUBLES--VOTE NO."
In late December, Contech transferred the production of the
MN-12, a Ford part, from Plant 3 in Dowagiac, Michigan to
the plant in Auburn, Indiana. Contech did not provide any
explanation to the employees for making this transfer.
Several days after the UAW filed the representation
petition, Robert Davis, Contech's Director of Sales and
Marketing, met with Gary Mahon, TRW’s Director of
Purchasing. The purpose of the meeting was to negotiate a
renewal of their contract for the manufacture of TRW’s rack-
and-pinion steering housings, the production of which
constituted about 15% of the output of Plant 1 and 90% of
5a
Appendix A
Plant 3. At the meeting, Mahon informed Davis of TRW’s
desire to postpone contract-renewal negotiations “until
Contech’s] union representation issue as well as some
ongstanding quality and delivery issues between [Contech]
and TRW were resolved.”
In a December speech, Contech’s Director of
Manufacturing Joe Barry indicated to the employees that
TRW would not renew its contract with Contech until after
the election. In a separate speech, Brad Farver, Contech’s
Manufacturing er, referred to a letter from TRW to
Contech in which TRW purportedly communicated a concern
about Contech becoming unionized. Farver, however,
declined to elaborate when asked by the employees to explain
why TRW would not want to deal with Contech in the event
that Contech became unionized. Moreover, Contech did not
explain to the employees that product — and delivery
issues were contributing factors in TRW's hesitancy at
entering into a long-term renewal contract.
Also in December, Contech showed its employees a video
depicting strike violence. At that meeting, Barry and Farver
discussed with them the status of the TRW contract-renewal
negotiations. Barry stated that “negotiations had been
suspended ‘until we got some of our problems behind us.””
Farver stated that “TRW had postponed long-term agreements
“until our issues are resolved.’”
During the two weeks preceding the election, Contech
displayed large poster photographs of closed manufacturing
. These posters remained on display until immediately
efore the election. On January 10, 1995, two days before the
election, Contech distributed a handout signed by Weber
explaining that the closed plants pictured in the posters “were
in Michigan and were now closed, that all of the oe
who had worked in those plants were now laid off, many
eee. and that in each instance the laid off employees
been represented by a union.” The handout also provided
that since 1987, there had been a reduction of almost 400
ee eS ee
OE NT Se ON Ek ~
6a
Appendix A
UAW jobs at SPX’s Muskegon, Michigan plant. Moreover,
the handout stated that within that past year, 105 union jobs
were lost when SPX closed its Ravenna, Michigan plant
because of “ineffective operation." Weber’s note concluded:
"A UNION DOES NOT PROVIDE JOB SECURITY." In the
interim, Mark Hunsberger, a Contech Supervisor, stated to “at
least three or four employees individually” that TRW had sent
one of its dies to another company to determine whether that
company could produce the part.
On January 9, 1995, three days before the first election, Al
Zagotta, Contech's President, sent a letter to the employees.
In the letter, Zagotta explained that Contech was in a "very
critical stage in its relationship with certain key customers
a TRW, Ford, and Saginaw." Zagotta's letter continued as
ollows:
I am concerned that if the Dowagiac plant develops
a reputation for not being a dependable
supplier--because of labor problems, a UAW-led
strike, or even the possibility of a strike every time
the contract comes up for renewal--our customers
may become nervous and look elsewhere for another
source for their parts.
On January 10, 1995, two days before the election, Gary
Walker, a Division Manager of Contech, spoke to the
employees. He stated that Contech was "greatly concerned
about the impact the union could eventually have on our
customers like TRW and our ability to compete." He also
referred to what he termed as the “horrendous strike record of
the UAW," “the [hundreds] of closed plants in Michigan and
the hundreds of thousands [of] UAW members who lost their
jobs .. . as a result-of inefficient operation and UAW-led
strikes." Furthermore, Walker shared his observation that "the
UAW is always at the heart of conflict." He also discussed
three unionized SPX plants in Western Michigan that “were
either partially or totally shut down because they were
allegedly no longer competitive.”
Ta
Appendix A
During January 9 and 10, the same two-day period that
Zagotta and Walker made the above statements to the
employees, Jack Fannon, TRW’s Quality Representative,
made a thorough inspection tour of Contech's two Dowagiac
facilities, accompanied by an entourage of Contech managers
and supervisors--all of which was highly visible to the
employees.
Finally, Contech’s supervisors at both Plant 1 and Plant 3,
on all three shifts, regularly discarded UAW literature left in
the respective lunchrooms of the plants. Those supervisors,
however, did not disturb current newspapers, magazines, and
Avon booklets.
An election by secret ballot was conducted on January 12,
1995 (“the first election”). The results of the first election
were as follows: 154 votes in favor of UAW representation,
196 votes against UAW representation, and four challenged
ballots, a number insufficient to affect the results.
The UAW subsequently filed six objections to the first
election. Specifically, the UAW alleged that Contech and its
agents: (1) conducted a “campaign of fear and intimidation
through predictions of violence, strikes, loss of customers and
economic detriment which they insinuated would inevitably
result from a union victory,” (2) made “pro-company
cmnge insignia available to employees, wpe forcing the
employees to make known their pre-election preferences,” (3)
threatened to “go out of business, close the plant or that
customers would remove work if [the UAW] won the
election,” (4) created “the impression of futility by stating that
[Contech] would not bargain in good faith if (the UAW} won
the election,” ©) confiscated “union literature,” and (6)
conducted the election “in an area used by [Contech] to
propagandize employees.”
A Hearing Officer of the Board thereafter conducted a
hearing on UAW’s six objections. In April of 1995, the
Hearing Officer issued a report recommending that the Board
8a
Appendix A
sustain the part of Objection 1 concerning Contech’s
predictions of customer loss as an inevitable result of union
victory, and all of Objections 3 and 5. Contech subsequently
filed exceptions to the Hearing Officer’s report.
In December of 1995, the Board adopted the Hearing
Officer’s recommendations in a Decision and Direction of
Second Election, concluding that “parts of [Contech’s]
speeches, statements, and other communications had a
reasonable tendency to create and reinforce an atmosphere of
fear among the employees that a union victory could result in
loss of work, jobs, and customers, and in-plant closure.” The
Board further found “no objective factual evidence to support
[Contech’s] implication to [the] employees that [its]
—— ‘become nervous’ as a result of the mere presence
of a union.”
In support of its conclusions, the Board found that: (1)
shew Contech normally would have informed the
employees as to why production of a part was leaving Plant 3,
it issued no explanatory communication upon the removal of
the Ford MN-12 production from the plant. In the absence of
such an explanation, the reprinted newspaper article
concerning Ford's removal of dies from the Indiana plant
“took on added significance for the employees,” and would
tend to suggest that the removal of MN-12 production was
related to the UAW’s presence, (2) Hunsberger's statement
that TRW had sent one of its dies to another company “would
have been widely disseminated throughout the unit,” (3) the
comments of Barry and Farver concerning the postponement
of negotiations with TRW, along with Hunsberger's statement
that TRW had sent one of its dies to another company,
“would reasonably lead the employees to conclude that
TRW's relationship with [Contech] was in jeopardy because
of [the UAW], and that the outcome of the first election could
determine whether the TRW contract was renewed,” (4) “in
the context of the statements of Barry, Farver, and
Hunsberger, which gave the employees reason to believe that
TRW and Ford were already retreating from their relationship
9a
Appendix A
with [Contech] because of [the UAW], Walker's statements
in his January 10 s had a reasonable tendency to make
the ———— fearful that a union victory could result in loss
of work for [Contech],” (5) the impression conveyed to the
— by the comments of Barry, Farver, and Hunsberger
was er amplified by Fannon's highly visible quality-
inspection tour (just several days before the election), which
in turn (a) gave additional weight to Zagotta's concern that
Contech’s customers would me nervous about the
UAW’s presence, and (b) provided additional context for
Walker's concern that Contech's relationship with TRW
“would be affected by the outcome of the election,” and (6)
the end-of-campaign statements of Zagotta and Walker
“would reasonably have been understood by [the employees]
as an 7 prediction that work and jobs would be lost if
[the UAW] won the election.”
Finding that these circumstances reasonably tended to
create an impression that a UAW victory would result in harm
to the employees, the Board set aside the results of the first
election and directed that a second election be conducted.
B. The Second Election
Prior to the second election, the employees received a series
of open letters from the UAW. Contech subsequently argued
that these letters misled the employees and thus warranted
setting aside the results of the second election.
In one such letter (“the UAW letter”), the UAW described
Contech’s actions and the Board’s findings regarding the first
election as follows:
The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) has found
that your employer engaged in objectionable conduct
during your union representation election last year when
management blatantly misled you about customer
concerns and loss of jobs. The NLRB report makes it
clear that the company set out from the start of their anti-
union campaign last year until right up to the election to
10a
ORT ae RR
: ' Appendix A
deliberately misconstrue events and customer actions.
It’s also clear that they fully intended and planned to
threaten, intimidate and coerce employees by their
actions. Top management officials were involved in
these unsavory illegal objections against you.
Your employer should allow you to vote this time
without being subjected to company intimidation,
coercion and threats. Out of desperation management
may use tactics similar to those they used last time but
they will probably attempt to be more devious in an
attempt to cover up. If you see tactics that you feel may
be threatening, intimidating and thus illegal, feel free to
call the UAW for assistance and protection.
Lee Hodge, President of UAW Local 1218, then sent the
employees the following letter (“the Hodge letter”):
My wife has worked at Contech for over 20 years. With
that thought in mind, I want to reassure each and every
one of you that I have never, nor will I ever, lie or try to
deceive you concerning the upcoming vote for the UAW.
But, I cannot say the same for your Contech
management. They have spread false rumors of your
on moving, and of losing Ford and TRW work. They
ave threatened and coerced Contech workers during
your last election for the UAW, and _ their
misrepresentation of the facts were [sic] proven by the
National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). The reason
you are allowed to vote again at this time is because the
NLRB felt that Contech workers deserved another vote
because of company lies and distortions during your last
election.
** *
The National Labor Relations Board has found Contech
guilty of giving you untrue information regarding
customer intentions. We have a copy of this NLRB
= at our office, and it can be read by anyone who
wishes.
lla
Appendix A
Phil Dubensky of Ford Motor Company also sent the
following letter to the UAW (“the Ford letter”), dated and
distributed one day before the second election, addressing the
suggestion that Ford would withdraw its business if the UAW
prevailed:
This is pursuant to your inquiry of March 8, 1996
regarding SPX-Contech and the assertion that its Plant
Manager in the past has advised employees that if the
current UAW organizing effort is successful, Ford will
“pull” its business.
Ford’s longstandi i is not to become involved, in
any way, with U organizing efforts that may be
initiated within the supplier community. Furthermore,
the Company’s decision to source product to a particular
supplier, or remove product from a current supplier, is
based on numerous criteria. Removal of a product,
Tre) because employees of a supplier elect to join the
UAW, is definitely not Ford Motor Company’s policy.
Representations to the contrary would be without
foundation.
Finally, UAW’s in-house organizing committee issued a
letter (“the committee letter’), which was posted on
Contech’s bulletin board. It read as follows:
The management HAS the kind of benefits that we would
like to have. Their pension plan is also much better than
ours. . . . [The] management can’t see why we need a
Union. Have you noticed that the supervisors are Not
trying to Talk us out of voting YES this time? They are
the ones that used to be in the position we are in. They
can relate to our fears of having little or nothing after
many years of dedicated service.
A second election by secret ballot was conducted on March
13, 1996 (“the second election”). The results of the second
election were as follows: 184 votes in favor of UAW
ELA See hels
12a
Appendix A
representation, 150 votes against UAW representation, and 16
challenged ballots, a number insufficient to affect the results.
Contech subsequently filed four objections to the second
election, each of which pertained to the foregoing letters.
Specifically, Contech alleged that the UAW, its employees,
agents, and others acting on its behalf: (1) falsely informed
the employees within one day of the second election that
Contech “had made misrepresentations to them that one of its
customers would ‘pull its business’” (2) implied that unless
the UAW “were chosen as the bargaining representative, a
significant customer would remove its business from the
plant,” (3) misrepresented to the employees “the nature of the
dings in the previous objection proceeding,” and (4)
informed the ee that “front line supervisors favored
the UAW, and thereby implied that retaliatory action would
be taken against them if they did not vote in favor of [the
UAW].”
In April of 1996, the Regional Director of the Board (“the
RD”), without conducting a hearing, issued a report
recommending that Contech’s objections be overruled in their
entirety and that a Certification of Representative issue. In
disposing of the first three of Contech’s objections, which
arise from purported misrepresentations contained in the
UAW letter, the Hodge letter, and the Ford letter, the RD
relied primarily upon Midland Nat'l! Life Ins. Co., 263
N.L.R.B. 127 (1982). In Midland, the Board held as follows:
[W]e rule today that we will no longer probe into the
truth or falsity of the parties' campaign statements, and
that we will not set elections aside on the basis of
misleading campaign statements. We will, however,
intervene in cases where a party has used forged
documents which render the voters unable to recognize
propaganda for what it is. Thus, we will set an election
aside not because of the substance of the representation,
but because of the deceptive manner in which it was
made, a manner which renders employees unable to
13a
Appendix A
evaluate the forgery for what it is. . . . [W]e will continue
to protect asainst other campaign conduct, such as
threats, promises, or the like, which interferes with
employee free choice.
Id. at 133 (footnotes omitted). The RD found that under
Midland, the letters in question were not sufficiently
deceptive to warrant Board action.
As to the fourth of Contech’s objections, which was based
upon the committee letter, the RD concluded that Contech
“thas failed to establish that, in fact, its supervisors engaged in
pro-union conduct.” It further stated that the letter would not
reasonably cause employees to “be misled into believing that
[Contech] favored unionization.”
Contech subsequently filed exceptions to the RD’s report.
Upon review of the RD’s report and Contech’s exceptions
thereto, the Board adopted the RD’s findings and
recommendations, and issued the UAW a Certification of
Representative accordingly. In analyzing Contech’s
exception to the RD’s reliance upon Midland, the Board
looked to Van Dorn Plastic Machinery Co. v. NLRB, 736 F.2d
343 (6th Cir. 1984), in which this court held that
misrepresentations may serve as the basis to set aside an
election if they are “so pervasive and the deception so artful
that employees will be unable to separate truth from untruth
and where their right to a free and fair choice will be
affected.” Jd. at 348. The Board then determined that the
present matter “is not a case of pervasive misrepresentation or
artful deception.” At most, the Board found, the UAW “has
mischaracterized the precise rationale for the Board’s decision
to set aside the results of the election.”
C. The Board’s Order
Notwithstanding the Board’s issuance of a Certification of
Representative to the UAW, Contech refused to comply with
the UAW’s requests to meet for eit of eee
e UAW responded by
collective-bargaining agreement.
14a
Appendix A
filing an unfair labor practice charge against Contech in
October of 1996.
The General Counsel of the Board followed up by filing a
complaint against Contech, alleging that Contech’s refusal to
bargain with the UAW constituted a violation of Sections
8(a)(1) and (5) of the Act. In its answer, Contech
acknowledged its refusal to bargain with the UAW, but
attacked the validity of the Board’s certification of the UAW
as the exclusive collective-bargaining representative of the
employees. In November of 1996, the General Counsel filed
a motion for summary judgment. The Board ultimately
granted that motion in a Decision and Order entered on
December 9, 1996. The Board’s order directs that Contech,
among other things, cease and desist from refusing to bargain
with the UAW.
D. The Present Applications
Contech subsequently filed the present petition for review
of the Board’s order. In response, the Board filed a cross-
application for enforcement of the order. In March of 1997,
this court granted UAW’s motion to intervene in the present
matter.
In support of its petition, Contech asserts that the Board
——s (1) set aside the results of the first election and
ordered a second election, (2) overruled Contech’s objections
to the second election, and (3) issued the UAW a Certification
of Representative with respect to the employees. Moreover,
Contech asserts that the Board should have conducted a
hearing with regard to its objections to the second election.
Contech, however, made no request for such a hearing when
filing those objections. Furthermore, Contech did not raise
this contention before the Board. In light of Contech’s failure
to demonstrate the existence of extraordinary circumstances
that would excuse it from not raising the lack of a hearing
before the Board, we shall not consider this contention on
appeal. See 29 U.S.C. 160(e) (“No objection that has not been
15a
Appendix A
urged before the Board, its member, agent, or agency, shall be
considered by the court, unless the failure or neglect to urge
such objection shall be excused because of extraordinary
circumstances.”).
ll. ANALYSIS
A. Standard of Review
We begin by noting that “Congress has vested the Board
with considerable discretion in ———— and regulating
representation elections.” NLRB v. Tennessee Packers, Inc.,
379 F.2d 172, 180 (6th Cir. 1967). In an effort “to assure
employees the greatest freedom of choice in the selection of
their representatives,” the Board strives to conduct
representation elections “in an atmosphere in which
employees are free from pressure, coercion and undue
influence from either the employer or the union.” Jd. When
a party’s pre-election conduct unduly influences the result of
an election, “the Board has set aside such election and ordered
a new one.” /d.
A nat 7 to overturn the results of a representation
election bears “the burden of showing that the election was
not conducted fairly.” NLRB v. Superior Coatings, Inc., 839
F.2d 1178, 1180 (6th Cir. 1988). In order to satisfy its
burden, the wan ape Sap must demonstrate that “unlawful
conduct occurred which interfered with employees’ exercise
of free choice to such an extent that it materially affected the
result of the election.” NLRB v. Shrader’s, Inc., 928 F.2d 194,
196 (6th Cir. 1991). On the other hand, for the Board to set
aside the results of an election, “[i]t is not necessary that
conduct which interferes with the freedom of choice in an
election actually constitute an unfair labor practice.”
Tennessee Packers, 379 F.2d at 181.
Because we afford the Board “broad discretion to determine
whether the circumstances of an election have allowed the
employees to exercise free choice in deciding whether to be
represented by a union,” NLRB v. Duriron Co., 978 F.2d 254,
l6a
Appendix A
256-57 (6th Cir. 1992), “[t]he Board’s findings with respect
to whether an election reflected the ‘free and fair choice’ of
the employees ‘will not be disturbed on appeal where there is
substantial evidence ... to support its conclusions.” NLRB v.
Dickinson Press Inc., 153 F.3d 282, 285 (6th Cir. 1998)
(quoting Mitchellace, Inc. v. NLRB, 90 F.3d 1150, 1155 (6th
Cir. 1996)). The Supreme Court has defined “substantial
evidence” as “such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind
might accept as adequate to support a conclusion.”
Consolidated Edison Co. v. NLRB, 305 U.S. 197, 229 (193 8).
Accordingly, we may not displace the Board’s reasonable
inferences “even though [we] might justifiably have reached
a different conclusion had the matter been before [us] de
novo.” Tony Scott Trucking, Inc. v. NLRB, 821 F.2d 312, 313
(6th Cir. 1987).
B. The First Election
We are satisfied that substantial evidence supports the
Board’s determination that the circumstances surrounding the
first election did not allow the employees to exercise a free
and fair choice in deciding whether to be represented by the
UAW. The Board’s determination was not based on any
single incident, but on the totality of the pertinent
circumstances discussed in Part I.A. above. The Board
concluded that these circumstances “had a _ reasonable
tendency to create and reinforce an atmosphere of fear among
the employees that a union victory could result in loss of
work, jobs, and customers, and in-plant closure” (citing NLRB
v. Gissel —- Co., 395 U.S. 575, 618-19 (1969)), and
ordered a second election accordingly. In light of the broad
discretion afforded the Board “to determine whether the
circumstances of an election have allowed the employees to
exercise free choice in deciding whether to be represented by
a union,” Duriron, 978 F.2d at 256-57, a reversal of its
decision to set aside the results of the first election is
unwarranted.
17a
Appendix A
But Contech argues that the record before the Board was
devoid of any evidence that Contech’s employees were
actually intimidated or misled by its conduct. Such proof,
however, is unnecessary. See Dickinson, 153 F.3d at 286
(“The subjective reactions of employees, like the subjective
intent of the — wrongdoer, are not dispositive. ... Rather,
whether the alleged misconduct was reasonably likely to
interfere with employees’ free choice depends on objective
facts, such as the timing of the allegedly improper act, the
capacity of the actor, and similar prior acts.”) (internal
citation omitted).
Relying primarily upon NLRB v. Pentre Electric, Inc., 998
F.2d 363 (6th Cir.1993), Contech also asserts that the Board
improperly set aside the results of the first election because
the statements of Contech’s representatives were truthful and
entitled to protection under Section 8(c) of the Act, 29 U.S.C.
§ 158(c), which provides as follows:
The expressing of any views, argument, or opinion, or
the dissemination thereof, whether in written, printed,
graphic, or visual form, shall not constitute or be
evidence of an unfair labor practice under any of the
provisions of this subchapter, if such expression contains
no threat of reprisal or force or promise of benefit.
(emphasis added).
Contech posits in its brief that “if the Board’s decision is
affirmed, employers’ free speech will be chilled and they will
be restricted from making objective truthful statements, if
those truthful events can somehow be viewed by the Board or
some other third party as somehow scaring employees.” In
light of the record before us, however, we find Contech’s
concerns to be unfounded, and conclude that its reliance upon
Section 8(c) and Pentre to be misplaced.
In Pentre, the Board petitioned for enforcement of an order
finding that Pentre Electric, Inc. violated Section 8(a)(1) by
“making statements to its employees about the effect that
18a
Appendix A
unionization would have on the oo during the
representation campaign.” 998 F.2d at 365. fn declining to
enforce the order, this court held that the employer’s
statements were permissible under Section 8(c), stating that
“if an employer’s statements fall within the scope of [S]ection
8(c) because they contain no threat of reprisal or promise of
benefit, no basis exists for finding that the employer has
committed an unfair labor practice.” Id. at 368 —s
added). Furthermore, Pentre held that the Board’s burden of
demonstrating that an employer has engaged in an unfair labor
practice encompasses the burden of demonstrating that
‘[S]ection 8(c) does not protect an employer’s predictions of
the consequences of unionization when the employer asserts
[S]ection 8(c) as a defense.” Jd. at 371. Accordingly, the
court held that the Board erroneously determined that an
employer must “produce evidence to corroborate predictions
about the effect of unionization to invoke the protection of
[S]ection 8(c).” /d. at 368.
Unlike Pentre, which involved an alleged unfair labor
practice arising from an employer’s pre-election conduct, the
present matter involves the Board’s broader discretion to set
aside the results of an election. Although the Board
ultimately found Contech to be in violation of Sections
8(a)(1) and (5), those charges arose from Contech’s refusal to
bargain with the UAW after the second election, not from its
conduct during the first election. Because Section 8(c) only
applies to unfair labor practice charges, Contech’s assertion
that it effectively precludes the Board from setting aside the
first election is without merit. The Board may set aside an
election even though an employer’s conduct does not rise to
the level of an unfair labor practice. See Tennessee Packers,
supra, 379 F.2d at 181.
Furthermore, even if we were to apply Section 8(c)’s
language to the election context, we note that the employer’s
expression of its views is protected only “if such expression
contains no threat of reprisal ....”. Where Contech crossed the
line in the present case is not its use of the handouts, posters,
19a
Appendix A
and newspaper articles showing job losses elsewhere that
Contech attributed to union representation, but in the linking
of such literature to its own intimidating conduct in
transferring production of the Ford part to another Contech
plant without explanation, in its timing of the quality-
inspection tour by TRW officials, in its selective removal of
union literature from the plant lunchrooms, and in the
misleading content of certain pre-election statements made by
its own officials. The Board in effect concluded that
Contech’s overall conduct contained the threat of reprisal,
thus denying the employees a free and fair election ice.
Although this is admittedly a close case, where reasonable
minds could reach opposite conclusions on the facts
presented, we cannot say that there is an absence of
substantial evidence to support the Board’s findings. Given
the deference to which the Board is entitled within its area of
expertise, we therefore decline to disturb the Board’s action
in setting aside the first election.
C. The Second Election
Weare also satisfied that substantial evidence supports the
Board’s determination that the circumstances surrounding the
second election allowed the employees to exercise a free and
fair choice in deciding to be represented by the UAW. After
the second election, Contech filed four objections regarding
alleged misrepresentations contained in the letters that the
UAW had disseminated to Contech’s employees. See Part
LB. We agree with the Board’s rationale for rejecting each of
Contech’s objections. See id The Board correctly found that
the alleged UAW misrepresentations were not so egregious as
to justify setting aside the second election. The governing
standard is set forth in Van Dorn Plastic Machinery, Co. v.
NLRB, 736 F.2d 343 (6th Cir. 1984), in which this court
stated as follows:
There may be cases where no forgery can be proved, but
where the ye is sO pervasive and the
deception so art
| that employees will be unable to
20a
Appendix A
separate truth from untruth and where their right to a free
and fair choice will be affected. We agree with the
Board that it should not set aside an election on the basis
of the substance of representations alone, but only on the
deceptive manner in which representations are made.
Id. at 348 (citing Midland, 263 N.L.R.B. at 131).
UAW’s letters do not include the t of pervasive
misrepresentation or artful deception that Van Dorn posited
would inhibit employees’ rights to free and fair choice.
Although several of the UAW letters distributed to Contech’s
employees contained arguably misleading statements, we are
satisfied that the Board properly concluded that the
employees’ right to a free and fair choice was not affected by
their dissemination.
To the extent that the UAW letters might be regarded as
“propaganda,” such is common in almost all representation
elections. The employees were free to evaluate the letters as
such, and Contech was free to respond in kind. If absolute
objectiveness and pristine conduct were required in order to
sustain an election, then virtually none would survive the
rough and tumble of labor-management contentiousness. See
Dickinson, 153 F.3d at 284 (“Although the Board strives to
maintain ‘laboratory conditions’ during representation
elections, such conditions are rare, ‘and elections are not
automatically voided whenever they fall short of
perfection.””) (quoting Duriron, 978 F.2d at 256). Instead, it
is sufficient that the misrepresentations not be “so pervasive
and the deception so artful that employees will be unable to
arate truth from untruth and where their right to a free and
fair choice will be affected.” Van Dorn, 736 F.2d at 348.
Accordingly, we reject Contech’s contention that the UAW
conducted a campaign of deliberate and pervasive
misrepresentations that unlawfully influenced Contech’s
employees.
21a
Appendix A
li. CONCLUSION
Because substantial evidence supports the Board's
decisions to set aside the results of the first election and to
certify the results of the second election, we DENY Contech’s
ape for review and GRANT the Board’s cross-application
or enforcement of its order.
22a
APPENDIX B — DECISION AND DIRECTION OF
SECOND ELECTION OF THE NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS BOARD DATED DECEMBER 19, 1995
Contech Division, SPX Corp. and International Union,
United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural
Implement Workers of America (UAW), AFL-CIO,
Petitioner. Case 7-RC-20485
December 19, 1995
DECISION AND DIRECTION OF SECOND
ELECTION
By MEMBERS BROWNING, COHEN, AND
TRUESDALE
The National Labor Relations Board, by a three-member
panel, has considered objections to an election held January
12, 1995, and the hearing officer’s report recommending
disposition of them. The election was conducted pursuant
to a Stipulated Election Agreement. The tally of ballots
shows 154 for and 196 against the Petitioner, with
4 challenged ballots, an insufficient number to affect the
results.
The Board has reviewed the record in light of the
exceptions and briefs, has adopted the hearing officer’s
findings and recommendations,' and finds that the election
must be set aside and a new election held.
1. Member Cohen finds it unnecessary to pass on the hearing
officer's recommendations regarding Objections 1 ana 3 as he
agrees that Objection 5 should be sustained.
23a
Appendix B
The Petitioner filed six objections to the election. The
hearing officer recommended sustaining (1) that part of
Objection 1 alleging Employer predictions of loss of
customer business as an inevitable result of a union victory;
(2) Objection 3 (alleging Employer threats that it would
close the plant and go out of business, or that customers
would remove work from the Employer if the Union won
the election); and (3) Objection 5 (alleging Employer
confiscation of union literature). We agree with the hearing
officer, for the reasons fully set forth in his report, that
Objection 5 should be sustained. We also agree with him,
for the reasons set forth below and in his report, that those
parts of Objections 1 and 3 alleging Employer predictions
of loss of customer business as an inevitable result of a
union victory should be sustained. Accordingly, we direct
that the election be set aside and that a second election be
conducted.?
I. FACTS
The Employer produces automotive parts for TRW,
Ford Motor Company, and other automotive suppliers at
the Employer’s Dowagiac, Michigan plants 1 and 3 involved
in this proceeding.
2. The hearing officer recommended overruling the remaining
objections. We reject the Petitioner’s exception and we adopt the
hearing officer’s recommendation to overrule Objection 6. In the
absence of exceptions, we adopt, pro forma, the hearing officer’s
recommendations to overrule that part of Objection 1 alleging
Employer threats and predictions of strikes and violence if the
Union won the election, and Objections 2 and 4.
24a
Appendix B
On November 17, 1994, 3 days after the Union filed
the representation petition in this case, Employer Human
Resources Manager Dwayne Weber distributed a letter to
employees asserting, among other things, that over two-
thirds of the 600 plants that had closed in Michigan over
the past 2 decades had union work forces.
One of the Employer’s election campaign handouts to
employees contained a reprinted newspaper article
concerning Ford’s removal of their manufacturing dies from
a struck supplier’s plant in Indiana. In the margins of the
reprinted pages, the Employer emphasized two statements
from the article, as follows: “DIES OWNED BY FORD
MOTOR COMPANY,” and “THE DIES WOULD HAVE
STAYED AT THE PLANT ANOTHER FOUR YEARS IF
THE STRIKE HAD NOT OCCURRED.” The Employer
also emphasized in the margin that the union involved in
the article was the UAW — the Petitioner in this case.
Another of the Employer’s campaign handouts to employees
contained a reprint of a 1982 letter from one of the
Employer’s customers to the Employer’s then-general
manager, in which the customer states that it had “closed
its doors . . . due to union difficulties” (emphasis in handout
as distributed by the Employer). On the back page of both
of the above handouts, the Employer printed the following
message, in large print: “SAY NO TO THE POSSIBILITY
OF LOST CUSTOMERS, LOST JOBS, LOST PAY, LOST
BENEFITS, AND OTHER TROUBLES — VOTE NO.”
3. All dates are November 1994 through January 1995 unless
otherwise stated.
ee
25a
Appendix B
Also during the critical period, the Employer showed a
series of videos to the employees, in small group meetings.
One video dealt with strikes and plant closings at plants
where employees were represented by unions, focusing
primarily on the UAW.
Around Christmas, the Employer removed production
of a Ford part (identified as MN-12) from its Dowagiac,
Michigan facility involved in this proceeding, and assigned
production of it to its Auburn, Indiana facility, which is not
involved in this proceeding. The Employer did not, however,
provide the Dowagiac employees with an explanation for
why production of this Ford part was being removed from
the facility. Director of Manufacturing Joe Barry testified
that although he normally would have considered it
important for morale purposes to let the Dowagiac
employees know why production of a part was leaving the
plant, he did not, in this instance, issue any explanatory
communication to the employees, and he offered no reason
at the hearing for not having done so.
The Employer also manufactures rack and pinion
housing castings for TRW at the Dowagiac facility, using
TRW’s manufacturing dies in the process. Manufacture of
this product constitutes about 90 percent of the output of
plant 1 and about 15 percent of the output of plant 3. The
Employer’s 5-year contract with TRW for the manufacture
of this product was scheduled to expire on December 31,
1995, about a year after the scheduled election. A few days
after the Union filed its representation petition on November
14, the Employer and TRW began negotiations for a
successor contract, to continue production of TRW’s
26a
Appendix B
castings. During this first negotiating session, TRW’s
director of purchasing, Gary Mahon, told the Employer’s
director of sales and marketing, Robert Davis, that TRW
wanted to postpone continued contract negotiations until
the Employer’s union representation issue as well as some
longstanding quality and delivery issues between the
Employer and TRW were resoived.
In a December captive audience speech, Manufacturing
Director Barry brought up the subject of TRW’s relationship
with the Employer, telling the employees that TRW would
not sign a contract for production of the castings until after
the election. In a separate captive audience speech,
Manufacturing Manager Brad Farver again raised the
subject of TRW’s attitude toward unionized suppliers,
referring to a letter from TRW to the Employer, and
indicating to the employees that TRW executives did not
want to work in companies that had unions, and telling them
that TRW had communicated a concern to the Employer
about the possibility of the Employer becoming unionized.
Farver, however, declined to elaborate when asked by
employees at this meeting to explain his comments about
why TRW would not want to deal with the Employer if it
became unionized. Nor did the Employer explain to the
employees that product quality and delivery issues were
contributing factors in TRW’s hesitancy at entering into a
long-term renewal contract.
During a series of late December meetings with groups
of employees called to show an antiunion video depicting
strike violence, Barry and Farver each brought up the subject
of the Employer’s above-contract renewal negotiations with
27a
Appendix B
TRW. Barry told the employees that the negotiations had
been suspended “until we got some of our problems behind
us.” Farver told the employees that TRW had postponed
long-term agreements “until our issues are resolved.”
During the 2 weeks immediately preceding the election,
the Employer displayed large poster photographs of closed
manufacturing plants. These posters remained on display
in both plants until just before the election. Then, on January
10, 2 days before the election, the Employer distributed a
handout signed by Human Resources Manager Weber that
explained that all of the plants pictured in the posters were
in Michigan and were now closed, that all of the employees
who had worked in those plants were now laid off, many
permanently, and that in each instance the laid off
employees had been represented by a union. Weber’s memo
went on to state that since 1987, there had been a reduction
of almost 400 unionized (UAW) jobs at the Employer’s
parent company plant in Muskegon, Michigan, and that
within the past year, 105 unionized jobs were lost when the
Employer’s parent company closed the Ravenna, Michigan
plant because of “ineffective operation,” The memo said
that the point was simple: “A UNION DOES NOT
PROVIDE JOB SECURITY.”
In the meantime, about a week or two before the
election, Supervisor Mark Hunsberger told at least three or
four employees individually that the Employer was known
for correcting its mistakes, and that TRW had sent one of
its dies to another company to see if they could produce the
part.
28a
Appendix B
On January 9, 3 days before the election, the Employer’s
president, Al Zagotta, sent a letter to all employees in which
he informed them that the Employer was in a “very critical
stage in its relationship with certain key customers like
TRW, Ford, and Saginaw.” Zagotta’s letter continued:
_I am concerned that if the Dowagiac plant
develops a reputation for not being a dependable
supplier — because of labor problems, a UAW-
led strike, or even the possibility of a strike every
time the contract comes up for renewal — our
customers may become nervous and look
elsewhere for another source for their parts.
There is, however, no objective factual evidence to support
Zagotta’s implication to employees that the Employer’s
customers “become nervous” as a result of the mere
presence of a union.
In a captive audience speech to employees on January
10, 2 days before the election, Division Manager Gary
Walker emphasized that the Employer was “greatly
concerned about the impact the union could eventually have
on our customers like TRW and our ability to compete.”
He also referred to what he termed the “horrendous strike
record of the UAW,” “the 100’s [hundreds] of closed plants
in Michigan and the hundreds of thousands [of] UAW
members who lost their jobs ... as a result of inefficient
operation and UAW-led strikes.” Walker told the employees
that from what he had personally seen, “the UAW is always
at the heart of conflict.” Walker told the employees about
three plants owned by the Employer’s parent company in
29a
Appendix B
Western Michigan (which were also described in Human
Resource Manager Weber’s January 10 memo to employees,
distributed the same day as Walker’s captive audience
speech), which were unionized and either partially or totally
shut down because they were allegedly no longer
competitive.
Also on January 9 and 10, during the same 2-day period
when Zagotta and Walker made their above statements to
the employees, and just a few days before the January 12
election, TRW Quality Representative Jack Fannon made
a very thorough inspection tour of the Employer’s Dowagiac
facility, accompanied by an entourage of Employer
managers and supervisors — all of which was highly visible
to the employees.
II. ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS
The Supreme Court has cautioned that while an
employer may make a prediction to its employees about
the precise effect that it believes that unionization will have
on the company:
[T]he prediction must be carefully phrased
on the basis of objective fact to convey an
employer’s belief as to demonstrably probable
consequences beyond [the employer’s] control
or to convey a management decision already
arrived at to close the plant in case of
unionization. . . . If there is any implication that
an employer may or may not take action solely
on its own initiative for reasons unrelated to
30a
Appendix B
economic necessities and known only to him, the
statement is no longer a reasonable prediction
based on available facts but a threat of retaliation
based on misrepresentation and coercion ....
[A]n employer is free only to tell “what he
reasonably believes will be the likely economic
consequences of unionization that are outside his
control,” and not “threats of economic reprisal
taken solely on his own volition.”
Applying these principles to the facts in this case, we
agree with the hearing officer that parts of the Employer’s
speeches, statements, and other communications had a
reasonable tendency to create and reinforce an atmosphere
of fear among the employees that a union victory could
result in loss of work, jobs, and customers, and in-plant
closure.
Thus, as the hearing officer found, in the absence of an
explanation from the Employer to the employees for the
removal of production of Ford’s MN-12 part, the reprinted
newspaper article distributed to employees about Ford’s
removal of their manufacturing dies from a struck supplier’s
plant in Indiana took on added significance for the
employees, and would tend to suggest to them that the
removal of production of Ford part MN-12 from the
Employer’s Dowagiac facility may have been related to the
presence of the Union.
4. NLRB v. Gissel Packing Co., 395 U.S. 575, 618-619 (1969)
(citations omitted).
3la
Appendix B
As the hearing officer also found, Barry and Farver put
the blame for the postponement of the renewal of the TRW
contract on the presence of the Union and the election. We
also agree with the hearing officer’s finding that given the
nature of Hunsberger’s statement that the Employer’s largest
customer was trying out alternative suppliers, this statement
probably would have been widely disseminated throughout
the unit.
Additionally, the hearing officer found, and again we
agree, that the comments to employees by Barry and Farver
about the postponement of contract renewal negotiations
with TRW, and Hunsberger’s comments to employees about
TRW trying out alternative suppliers, all raised by these
Employer officials in the context of the Employer’s
campaign against the Union, would reasonably lead the
employees to conclude that TRW’s relationship with the
Employer was in jeopardy because of the Union, and that
the outcome of the election could determine whether the
TRW contract was renewed.
As the hearing officer further found, in the context of
the statements of Barry, Farver, and Hunsberger, which gave
the employees reason to believe that TRW and Ford were
already retreating from their relationship with the Employer
because of the Union, Walker’s statements in his January
10 speech had a reasonable tendency to make the employees
fear that a union victory could result in loss of work for the
Employer.
The hearing officer also found that the impression
conveyed to the employees by the comments of Barry,
32a
Appendix B
Farver, and Hunsberger was further amplified —
intentionally or not — by TRW Representative Fannon’s
highly visible quality inspection tour just a few days before
the election, which in turn (1) gave added weight to
Zagotta’s stated concern that the Employer’s customers
would become nervous about the Union’s presence, and (2)
provided additional context for Walker’s expressed concern
about whether the Employer’s relationship with TRW would
be affected by the outcome of the election. Thus, the hearing
officer found that the Employer created an atmosphere in
which Zagotta’s and Walker’s end-of-campaign statements
to employees would reasonably have been understood by
them as an implicit prediction that work and jobs would be
lost if the Union won the election. We agree with the hearing
officer, and we find that the record does not establish that
this prediction is based upon objective facts beyond the
Employer’s control, and that it thus constitutes an
objectionable threat of lost customers, warranting the setting
aside of the election.
As seen, the Employer’s president, Zagotta, told
employees that if the plant developed a reputation for
undependability “because of labor problems, a UAW-led
strike, or even the possibility of a strike . . . our customers
may become nervous and look elsewhere.” The Employer
argues that Zagotta “did not imply that the presence of the
UAW alone would definitively cause Contech’s customers
to become nervous,” but instead only told them that the
customers “may” become nervous, and then only “if” the
plant got a bad reputation because of, inter alia, the
“possibility” of a strike. Thus, argues the Employer, Zagotta
never threatened that adverse consequences would be
33a
Appendix B
deliberately inflicted by the Employer if the Union won the
election. But we find that, under the totality of the campaign
circumstances set forth above, the employees could
reasonably infer from Zagotta’s statements that customers,
or at least work, would be lost if the Union won the election.
The Supreme Court’s closing guidance in NLRB v. Gissel,
supra, is particularly applicable here:
[An employer] can easily make his views known
without engaging in “brinksmanship” when it
becomes all too easy to “overstep and tumble
[over] the brink”... . At the least he can avoid
coercive speech simply by avoiding conscious
overstatements he has reason to believe will
mislead his employees.°
The Employer argues further that Zagotta’s and
Walker’s statements are unobjectionable under NLRB v.
Pentre Electric, 998 F.2d 363 (6th Cir. 1993). We do
not agree, because we find that case substantially
distinguishable from this one.
In a speech to employees about a month before the
election in Pentre, the employer’s president and owner,
Luff, said that specified customers of the employer did not
use union contractors. He told the employees that he
therefore thought that if they chose to be represented by a
union, three of the employer’s current customers would stop
doing business with the employer. He also told them that
he thought the company would not have the same customer
5. Id. at 620 (citation omitted).
34a
Appendix B
base if the employees chose to be represented by a union,
and that he did not know how the company would go about
getting another customer base to replace it. Luff also told
the employees that they would not have the jobs they had
now if they had been represented by a union, and that he
thought that it would be very difficult for them to get work
if they chose to be represented by a union.
Luff also told the employees, however, that he thought
the company could “make it,” that it had been successful
for 6 years and he wanted to keep it that way, and that he
thought it would prosper.
During the week before the election in Pentre, the
employer’s vice-president and co-owner, Meehan, met with
about 10 employees in separate one-on-one conversations.
He told each of them that in the employer’s industry,
electrical contracting, the work that the employer was doing
was traditionally done by open shop companies, and that
the employer was not doing union work and was not
competing against union contractors. Meehan also told them
that almost all of the employer’s large customers were
strictly open shop companies, that it would be difficult for
the employer to keep these particular customers if it became
a union contractor, that if the employer became a union
contractor it would have to establish new customers, and
that he was not prepared to reestablish the company with a
new customer base.
The court found, contrary to the Board, that the
executives’ statements were protected under Section 8(c)
of the Act, and thus not in violation of Section 8(a)(1). The
35a
Appendix B
court noted early in its analysis that “it is often difficult in
practice to distinguish between lawful advocacy and threats
of retaliation.”® The court found, however, that the
executives’ statements in question were nothing more than
predictions about the consequences of the employer’s
unionization, and ihat there was nothing in the record to
show that these predicted consequences were driven by the
employer’s desire to punish its employees for voting in favor
of the union.’ More specifically, while the court recognized
that Section 8(c) does not protect employer predictions
about the effects of unionization if they have a reasonable
tendency to have a coercive effect on the employees, it found
that the reasonable tendency of the statements of the
employer’s executives was not coercive in effect.* In this
regard, the court noted that Luff simply and accurately told
the employees that most of the employer’s customers did
not employ union contractors, that he consequently
predicted that the employer would therefore lose customers
and would have to build a new customer base if the union
won the election — and that he did not intimate that the
employer would close the plant as a result of union animus.
In short, the court found that Luff conveyed nothing more
than his analysis of the likely economic consequences of
unionization of the employer, in light of his knowledge of
the employer’s customers and competitors, and on the basis
of matters outside of his control. The court also noted that
6. 998 F.2d at 369 (citation omitted).
7. Id.
8. Id.
36a
Appendix B
Luff made no threats and did not intersperse his comments
with comments against the union. In fact, as the court
particularly noted, Luff even told the employees that the
company would prosper, and that he and Meehan wanted
to continue the company on its successful course.
There were simply no such words of encouragement
from the Employer or its executives in the case at hand,
and the Employer’s words of discouragement and
predictions of adverse consequences of unionization were,
unlike in Pentre, continuous, pervasive, and clearly far more
extensive than the remarks of Luff and Meehan in Pentre.
More particularly, and unlike in Pentre, the Employer
here created and reinforced an overall atmosphere of fear
among the employees that a union victory could result not
only in loss of work and customers, but in plant closure
itself. In the midst of all this, and particularly around the
same time that the Employer was warning the employees
that TRW would not renew its long-term production contract
until after the election, the Employer, at Christmas-time,
inexplicably removed production of a Ford part from its
Dowagiac facility. The employer in Pentre engaged in no
such comparable conduct in the context of its warnings
about the possible loss of customers resulting from
unionization. Indeed, the Employer here followed its failure
to explain the removal of production of the Ford part around
Christmas with a display of large poster photographs of
closed manufacturing plants, which it left on display until
just before the election, at which time it then (1) explained
to the employees that these had all been unionized plants,
and (2) told several employees that TRW had already
37a
Appendix B
actually shifted some of its production away from the
Employer. There was no comparable employer conduct in
Pentre.
Thus, unlike in Pentre, it was not until the Employer
had set the stage with the above conduct, statements, and
messages that, only 3 days before the election, President
Zagotta told the employees that the Employer was at a “very
critical stage in its relationship with certain key customers
like TRW, Ford, and Saginaw,” and that the Employer’s
customers “may become nervous and look elsewhere for
another source for their parts” if the Dowagiac plant
developed a reputation for undependability because of,
among other things, “labor problems ... or even the
possibility of a strike.” The full-blown inspection visit from
TRW to Dowagiac in the last remaining days before the
election gave the employees actual notice of the asserted
“nervousness” of one of the Employer’s biggest customers.
Clearly, then, the circumstances addressed by the court
in Pentre are substantially different in scope and intensity
from those created by the Employer here. Unlike in Pentre,
in the final analysis, there is no evidence here that the
Employer’s customers would cease being customers simply
because the Employer was unionized. The Employer’s
asserted belief that its best customers would desert it in the
face of unionization is not, in our view, supported by the
record, and, unlike the court’s assessment of the remarks in
Pentre, does not convey the Employer’s belief as to
demonstrably probable consequences beyond its control.
38a
Appendix B
DIRECTION OF SECOND ELECTION
A second election by secret ballot shall be held among
the employees in the unit found appropriate. The Regional
Director shall direct and supervise the election, subject to
the Board’s Rules and Regulations. Eligible to vote are those
employed during the payroll period ending immediately
before the date of the Notice of Second Election, including
employees who did not work during that period because
they were ill, on vacation, or temporarily laid off. Also
eligible are employees engaged in an economic strike that
began less than 12 months before the election date and who
retained their employee status during the eligibility period
and their replacements. Those in the military services may
vote if they appear in person at the polls. Ineligible to vote
are employees who have quit or been discharged for cause
since the payroll period, striking employees who have been
discharged for cause since the strike began and who have
not been rehired or reinstated before the election date, and
employees engaged in an economic strike that began more
than 12 months before the election date and who have been
permanently replaced. Those eligible shall vote whether
they desire to be represented for collective bargaining by
International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and
Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW),
AFL-CIO.
To ensure that all eligible voters have the opportunity
to be informed of the issues in the exercise of their statutory
right to vote, all parties to the election shall have access to
a list of voters and their addresses that may be used to
communicate with them. Excelsior Underwear, 156 NLRB
39a
Appendix B
1236 (1966); NLRB v. Wyman-Gordon Co., 394 U.S. 759
(1969). Accordingly, it is directed that an eligibility list
containing the full names and addresses of all the eligible
voters must be filed by the Employer with the Regional
Director within 7 days frorn the date of the Notice of Second
Election. North Macon Health Care Facility, 315 NLRB
359 (1994). The Regional Director shall make the list
available to all parties to the election. No extension of time
to file the list shall be granted by the Regional Director
except in extraordinary circumstances. Failure to comply
with this requirement shall be grounds for setting aside the
election if proper objections are filed.
Dated, Washington. D.C. December 19, 1995
Margaret A. Browning, Member
Charles I. Cohen, Member
John C. Truesdale, Member
(SEAL) NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
40a
Appendix B
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS BOARD
Case 7-RC-20485
CONTECH DIVISION, SPX CORPORATION
Employer
and
INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED AUTOMOBILE,
AEROSPACE, AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA (UAW), AFL-CIO
Petitioner
DECISION AND CERTIFICATION
OF REPRESENTATIVE
The National Labor Relations Board, by a three-member
panel, has considered objections to an election held on
March 13, 1996, and the Regional Director’s report
recommending disposition of them. The election was
conducted pursuant to a Decision and Direction of Second
Election. The tally of ballots shows 184 for and 150 against
the Petitioner with 16 challenged ballots, an insufficient
number to affect the results.
The Board has reviewed the Regional Director’s report
in light of the exceptions and brief, has adopted the Regional
4la
Appendix B
Director’s findings' and recommendations, and finds that a
certification of representative should be issued.
1. In finding that the campaign documents circulated by the
Union were at most misrepresentation and therefore did not
constitute objectionable conduct, the Regional Director relied on
Midland National Life Insurance Co., 263 NLRB 127 (1982) and
Riveredge Hospital, 264 NLRB 1094 (1982). The Employer
contends that the Regional Director employed the wrong legal
standard, that the correct legal standard is the one employed by the
Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. The Sixth Circuit has stated that
there may be cases where the misrepresentation is so pervasive
and the deception so artful that the employees will be unable to
separate truth from untruth. Van Dorn Plastics Machinery, Inc.,
736 F.2d 343, 348 (6th Cir. 1984) cert. den. 469 U.S. 1208, 105
S.Ct. 1173 (1985). Thus, in Hub Plastics, Inc., 52 F.3d 608 (1995),
the Sixth Circuit remanded to the Board for reconsideration a case
where the union falsely told employees that the NLRB had made a
final determination that the employer was guilty of unfair labor
practices. The union pointed to the formal charge it had filed with
the NLRB in support of its claim. The Court found that the
substance of the misrepresentation may not have been enough to
void the election, but that the deception may have been artful
enough to affect the employees’ free choice.
Unlike Hub Plastics, there is no such misrepresentation or
deception at issue here. The Union circulated a letter in which it
set forth its version of the Board’s reasons for ordering a second
election. In our view, this is not a case of pervasive
misrepresentation or artful deception. At most, the Union has
mischaracterized the precise rationale for the Board’s decision to
set aside the election.
42a
Appendix B
CERTIFICATION OF REPRESENTATIVE
IT IS CERTIFIED that a majority of the valid ballots
have been case for International Union, United Automobile,
Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America
(UAW), AFL-CIO, and that it is the exclusive collective-
bargaining representative of the employees in the following
appropriate unit:
All production and maintenance employees
employed by the Employer at its facilities located
at 51241 M-51 North, Dowagiac, Michigan, but
excluding all office clerical employees, guards and
supervisors as defined in the Act.
Dated, Washington, D.C., August 5, 1996.
Margaret Browning, Member
Charles I. Cohen, Member
Sarah M. Fox, Member
(SEAL) National Labor Relations Board
43a
Appendix B
UNITED STATE OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS BOARD
SEVENTH REGION
Case No.: GR-7-RC-20485
CONTECH DIVISION, SPX CORPORATION
Employer,
and
INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED AUTOMOBILE,
AEROSPACE AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA (UAW), AFL-CIO
Petitioner,
EMPLOYER’S EXCEPTIONS TO HEARING
OFFICER’S REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS
ON OBJECTIONS
The employer, Contech Division, SPX Corporation
(“Contech”) in accordance with the National Labor
Relations Board Rules and Regulations Section 102.46, by
its attorneys, Miller, Johnson, Snell & Cummiskey, P.L.C.,
excepts to the following findings and rulings of Hearing
Officer, Thomas M. Good, issued on April 17, 1995:
1. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding and
recommendation that “Objections No. 1 and 3 have merit
44a
Appendix B
and I recommend they be sustained.” (Hearing Officer’s
Report and Recommendations on Objections (the “Report”)
p. 15). (A copy of the Report is attached).
2. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding and
recommendation that “The Employer created an atmosphere
where Zagotta’s and Walker’s end of campaign statements
would have been understood as an implicit prediction that
work and jobs would be lost in the event the UAW won the
election.” (Report, p. 12).
3. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding and
recommendation that “Statements made by Zagotta and
Walker were not based upon objective facts beyond the
employer’s control.” (Report, p. 12).
4. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s findings
and recommendation that Zagotta’s and Walker’s statements
constituted an objectionable threat. (Report, p. 12).
5. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding and
recommendation that “Gary Walker’s 25th hour speech by
itself and in this context implicitly threatened employees
with plant closure and had a tendency to interfere with the
Employee’s free choice in the election.” (Report, p. 14).
6. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding and
recommendation that statements made by Walker in his 25th
hour speech were not based upon objective facts and were
not based upon events beyond Contech’s control. (Report,
p. 14).
45a
Appendix B
7. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s following
factual findings:
That “Barry acknowledged that he did not issue
any explanatory communication to employees on
this.” (Report, p. 8).
. That the article “It Can’t Happen Here” tended
to suggest to the employees the loss of the
MN-12 job “may have been related to the
presence of the UAW.” (Report, p. 8).
That Farver “told employees that TRW had
communicated a concern by a letter about the
possibility of a union there.” (Report, p. 9).
That “Farver did not directly dispute the
Statements attributed to him by Murray.”
(Report, p. 10).
That “Barry and Farver put the onus for the
postponement of the LTA on the presence of the
union election.” (Report, p. 10).
That Supervisor Hunsberger made comments
similar to that which he allegedly made to
Tommy Lee Walker to other employees. (Report,
p. 10).
That the comment that Supervisor Hunsberger
allegedly made to Walker “would have been
widely disseminated throughout the unit.”
(Report, p. 10).
46a
Appendix B
. That employees could reasonably concluded that
“the election could determine whether the LTA
was renewed.” (Report, p. 10).
That Zagotta implied that Customers become
nervous simply because of the presence of a
union. (Report, p. 11).
That Jack Fannen’s tour of the plant “was timed
in such a way that its exposure to employees was
maximized.” (Report, p. 11).
. That the underlining in the letter from Scott Die
Casting to Dale Engle was “added for emphasis
in the distribution.” (Report, p. 12).
That Walker’s “statement ‘about the problems
often associated with the union’ was a clear
reference to the plant closings he had just
described and would have a similar impact on
employees as the loser reference in the General
Dynamics poster.” (Report, p. 14).
. That “Walker implicitly identified problems
often associated with the union as the cause for
the loss of profitability, competitiveness and the
resulting loss of jobs.” (Report, p. 14).
. That “Walker’s 25th hour speech left the
impression that unionization and the exercise of
the right to strike was a factor in the decisions to
close plants.” (Report, p. 14).
47a
Appendix B
8. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding and
recommendation that “Objection No. 5 be sustained.”
(Report, p. 19).
9. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding and
recommendation that Contech’s “conduct was neither
isolated nor de minimis.” (Report, p. 19).
10. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding
and recommendation that the supervisor’s required that
individual employees put their names on union literature
they wanted to distribute. (Report, p. 18).
11. Contech excepts to the Hearing Officer’s finding
and recommendation “that it is immaterial that the union
literature was not attended or guarded by employees when
confiscated and disposed of by these supervisors.” (Report,
p. 18).
12. Contech further excepts to the Hearing Officer’s
failure to contain all relevant facts set forth in this record
in his report. Those facts are set forth in the accompanying
brief in support of these exceptions.
13. Contech excepts to the hearing officer’s finding
and recommendation “that the Board direct a second
election.” (Report, p. 19).
WHEREFORE, Contech respectfully requests that this
Board not follow the findings and recommendations of the
Hearing Officer as set forth above and that this Board certify
the results of the election.
48a
Appendix B
Respectfully submitted,
Dated: May 6, 1995 MILLER, JOHNSON, SNELL &
CUMMISKEY, P.L.C.
Attorneys for Employer
By s/ Peter J. Kok
Peter J. Kok (P16121)
And s/ David M. Buday
David M. Buday (P43087)
Business address:
800 Calder Plaza Building
Grand Rapids, MI 49503
(616) 459-8311
. 49a
Appendix B
UNITED STATE OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS BOARD
SEVENTH REGION
Case No.: GR-7-RC-20485
CONTECH DIVISION, SPX CORPORATION
Employer,
and
INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED AUTOMOBILE,
AEROSPACE AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA (UAW), AFL-CIO
Petitioner,
EMPLOYER’S OBJECTIONS TO CONDUCT
AFFECTING THE RESULT OF THE ELECTION
The Employer, Contech Division, SPX Corporation, by
its attorneys, Miller, Johnson, Snell & Cummiskey, P.L.C.
objects to the following conduct by the International Union,
United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement
Workers of America (UAW), AFL-CIO (the “UAW”) which
affected the result of the election held on March 13, 1996:
1. The UAW, its employees, agents and others acting
on its behalf, falsely informed employees that the Company
had made misrepresentations to them to the effect that one
50a
Appendix B
of its customers would “pull its business”. These falsehoods
were spread a day before the election, thereby affording
the employer absolutely no opportunity to respond.
2. The UAW, its employees, agents and others acting
on its behalf, implied to employees that unless the UAW
were chosen as the bargaining representative, a significant
customer would remove its business from the plant.
3. The UAW, its employees, agents and others acting
on its behalf, misrepresented to employees the nature of
the findings in the previous objection proceeding which had
been held in the above-captioned case. The Employer did
not have adequate opportunity to respond.
4. The UAW, its employees, agents and others acting
on its behalf, informed employees that front line supervisors
favored the UAW, and thereby implied that retaliatory
action would be taken against them if they did not vote in
favor of the union.
Dated: March 20, 1996 MILLER, JOHNSON, SNELL
& CUMMISKEY, P.L.C.
Attorneys for Employer
By s/ David M. Buday
David M. Buday (P43087)
Business Address:
425 West Michigan Avenue
Kalamazoo, MI 49007
(616) 343-0282
Sla
Appendix B
MILLER, JOHNSON, SNELL & CUMMISKEY, P.L.C.
ATTORNEYS
800 CALDER PLAZA BUILDING -
250 MONROE AVENUE N.W. «
GRAND RANDS, MICHIGAN 49503
616/459-8311 * FAX: 616/459-6708
* * .
March 27, 1996
VIA HAND DELIVERY
Mr. Chet Byerly
National Labor Relations Board
Region 7 — Resident Office
82 Ionia, N.W.
Room 330
Grand Rapids, MI 49503-3022
Re: SPX-Contech
Dear Mr. Byerly:
In accordance with your written request for additional
information to support the objections the employer filed on
March 20, 1996, we are providing you this letter and the
attached exhibits. Set forth below is an explanation of how
the attached exhibits and the law that governs elections
support Contech’s position that the UAW engaged in
objectionable conduct that requires that the election held
on March 13, 1996 be set aside. This information is being
provided to you solely for the purposes of investigating the
objections that Contech filed.
52a
Appendix B
l. THE EVIDENCE AND LAW THAT SUPPORT
OBJECTIONS NOs. 1 AND 3
The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has repeatedly found
that an election must be set aside where a union
misrepresentation “is so pervasive and the deception so
artful that employees will be unable to separate truth from
untruth and where [employees] right to a free and fair choice
will be affected”. VanDorn Plastic Machinery Co. v. NLRB,
736 F.2d 343, 348 (6th Cir. 1984): See also, Dayton Hudson
Department Store v. NLRB, 987 F.2d 359, 366 (6th Cir.
1993). This is precisely the type of deliberate
miscommunications and deceptions in which the UAW
engaged.
First, the UAW distributed a letter dated February 16,
1996 that contains pervasive and deceptive misinformation
that impacted the employee’s right to a free and fair election.
A copy of that letter is attached as Exhibit 1. The
misrepresentations all involve the UAW’s deliberate
misstatements of why the second election was ordered. In
particular, the UAW made the following misrepresentations:
¢ Asecond election was ordered because “management
blatantly mislead you about customer concerns and
loss of jobs.”
¢ During the entire first campaign, the company “set
out ... to deliberately misconstrue events and
customer actions.”
¢ “(T]hey fully intended and planned to threaten,
intimidate and coerce employees.”
53a
Appendix B
* “Top management officials were involved in these
unsavory illegal objectionable actions against you.”
We have enclosed a copy of the Board’s decision as
Exhibit 2 that resulted in the second election being ordered.
A review of that decision establishes that the above
statements are entirely untrue.
The purpose of the misstatements was to deceive the
employees and to undermine the credibility of management.
The UAW describes Contech management as having
intentionally plotted a strategy that it knew was illegal and
with the express and intended purpose of threatening,
intimidating and coercing the employees to vote against the
UAW. Those blatant misrepresentations, if made in different
context may not be objectionable. However, the truth is,
and the employees knew that the Board found that Contech
engaged in objectionable conduct during the first election
and that the Board ordered the second election. By mixing
its misrepresentations with those two facts, the UAW was
able to artfully deceive the employees in such a way that it
was not possible for employees to separate the truth from
untruth.
The UAW’s goal in its act of deception is apparent.
Credibility is a significant issue in any campaign. If
the employees do not believe or trust their employer,
employees are unlikely to vote for their employer.
Understanding that the UAW intentionally and unlawfully
undermined the credibility of Contech management by
deliberately misrepresenting that “top management officials
were involved in unsavory illegal objectionable actions”
54a
Appendix B
and that management “fully intended and planned to
threaten, intimidate and coerce employees”.
The UAW’s deception was pervasive in that the UAW
continued to use this theme throughout the campaign. The
UAW continually notified employees that Contech had
deliberately threatened and misled them in the first election
and that Contech continued to do so during the second
election but only in a more deceptive and underhanded
manner. Under the standards set forth by the Sixth Circuit
Court of Appeals, that conduct by itself is a basis for setting
aside the election.
However, there is additional evidence that the UAW
continued its deliberate campaign of misrepresentations
throughout the entire course of the campaign: A letter the
UAW distributed to the employees from Ford Motor
Company dated March 12, 1996. A copy of which is
attached as Exhibit 3.
As that letter reflects, it was solicited by the UAW.
The letter specifically states that it is written “pursuant to
the [UAW’s] inquiry.”
The inquiry itself is also reflected in the body of the
letter. Specifically, the UAW intentionally misrepresented
to Ford Motor Company that Contech had represented to
its employees that, if the UAW won the election, customers
such as Ford would pull work from Contech. In truth,
Contech made no such representations. Nonetheless, as the
letter states, the UAW misinformed Ford that Contech’s
“plant manager in the past iuas advised employees that if
55a
Appendix B
the current UAW organizing effort is successful, Ford will
‘pull’ its business.”
The UAW distributed that letter to employees on the
day before and/or on the day of the election. Any employee
reading the letter could reasonably conclude that Contech
had represented to employees that if the UAW should win
the election, Ford and other suppliers would pull their work
from Contech. Moreover, as the letter assertively states,
Ford would not pull its work if the UAW won the election.
Thus, the letter inaccurately portrays Contech as lieing to
its employees.
When that misrepresentation is coupled with the
misrepresentations of why the second election was ordered
as set forth above, employees could reasonably be deceived
into concluding that “top management officials [were again]
involved in unsavory, illegal, objectionable actions”; that
once again Contech was “deliberately misconstru[ing]
events and customer actions”; and Contech had again
“intended and planned to threaten, intimidate and coerce
employees.”
Those two communications distributed by the UAW
establish that the theme of its campaign was to misrepresent
the actions of Contech in such a way as to undermine its
credibility. Attached as Exhibit 4 is another piece of UAW
literature that supports that. The UAW did this in a
deceptive, pervasive and artful manner, and as a result, the
UAW was able to impact employees’ fair and free choice.
Under such circumstances, the law requires that the election
be set aside.
56a
Appendix B
Il. THE EVIDENCE AND LAW THAT SUPPORT
OBJECTION NO. 2
The March 12, 1996 letter from Ford Motor Company
is also objectionable because it unlawfully misrepresents
to employees that if the UAW is not voted in at Dowagiac,
Ford will pull its work. Specifically the letter provides in
part:
Removal of product, simply because employees
of a supplier elect to join the UAW is definitely
not Ford Motor Company’s policy.
Representations to the contrary would be without
foundation.
SPX-Contech is, and has been, a supplier to Ford
for housings used in the manufacture of rack and
pinion steering gears and climate control devices.
To ensure no misunderstanding exists, FAO
purchasing will contact management of SPX-
Contech and clearly reiterate Ford’s position as
reflected above.
The nature and tone of the portion of the letter quoted
above is to indicate that Ford is dissatisfied and angry with
Contech. It is angry with Contech because of the
misrepresentations made by the UAW that the plant manger
had advised employees that if the UAW won the election,
Ford would pull its business. The reasonable conclusion to
be reached from a reading of that letter is that if the UAW
did not win, Ford would pull its work from Contech.
a a a ane Te ee
57a
Appendix B
Again, it is important to note that this letter is dated
March 12 — that is one day before the date of the election.
It was distributed on March 12 and/or on the day of the
election. It was impossible for Contech to respond to this
letter. The impact of this letter was significant. It likely
unlawfully persuaded and/or coerced employees to vote in
favor of the UAW. Consequently, the election should be
set aside.
Ill. THE EVIDENCE AND LAW THAT SUPPORT
OBJECTION 4.
In support of ob, ection 4, Contech offers a document,
a copy of which is attached as Exhibit 5. This document
purports to have been prepared by the “In Plant Organizing
Committee”. This document was posted by organizing
committee members on an employee bulletin board. We
believe that if a hearing were convened to which the
employer would be allowed to subpoena witnesses it would
be established that members of the organizing committee
did indeed prepare this document. Through testimony of
subpoenaed witnesses, it would also be established that the
members of the organizing committee are essentially agents
of the union because of the direction and training they
received from the union, and that the union did participate
in the creation and publication of this document.
The portion of the document that is objectionable is
found on the first page where it states:
If you think about it, management can’t see why
we need a union. Have you noticed that the
58a
Appendix B
supervisors are not trying to talk us out of voting
yes this time? They are the ones that used to be
in the position we are in. They can relate to our
fears of having little or nothing after many years
of dedicated service.
The implication is, of course, that the front line
supervisors support the union and the members of the
organizing committee have some inside information about
this. The Board takes a very dim view of cases in which
supervisors support the union. In Si/-Base Company, 290
NLRB 1179 (1988), the Board had this to say:
There are three situations in which a supervisor’s
pro-union conduct may warrant setting aside an
election. The first is when the employer takes
no stand contrary to the supervisor’s pro-union
conduct and employees may be led to believe
the employer favors the union. The second
involves the possibility that the supervisor’s pro-
union conduct could coerce employees into
supporting the union out of fear of future -
retaliation by that supervisor. The third is similar
to the second situation except that instead of
coercion by fear of retaliation, the employees
could be coerced out of a hope of reward by the
supervisor.
Id.
The testimony of company officials will establish that
during the campaign period, supervisors were directed to
Se
59a
Appendix B
maintain a low profile on the union issue. The union seized
upon this fact to represent to employees that the front-line
supervisors supported the union. This representation is
inherently coercive because it Suggests to employees that
unless they follow the wishes of their supervisors by
supporting and voting for the union there would be
retaliation. Under these circumstances, the laboratory
conditions required for a proper election did not exist.
In the event that you require further information or have
any questions about anything contained within this letter,
please contact me.
Sincerely,
MILLER, JOHNSON, SNELL
& CUMMISKEY, P.L.C.
By s/ David M. Buday
David M. Buday
DMB/jad
Enclosure
cc: Kord Kozma
60a
APPENDIX C — REGIONAL DIRECTOR’S REPORT
AND RECOMMENDATION OF THE NATIONAL
LABOR RELATIONS BOARD FOR THE SEVENTH
REGION ON OBJECTIONS TO CONDUCT
AFFECTING THE RESULTS OF THE ELECTION
DATED APRIL 2, 1996
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS BOARD
SEVENTH REGION
CASE NO. GR-7-RC-29485
CONTECH DIVISION, SPX CORPORATION
Employer
and
INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED AUTOMOBILE,
AEROSPACE AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA (UAW), AFL-CIO
Petitioner
REGIONAL DIRECTOR’S REPORT AND
RECOMMENDATION ON OBJECTIONS TO
CONDUCT AFFECTING THE RESULTS
OF THE ELECTION
Upon a Decision and Direction of Second Election dated
December 19, 1995, and mailed by the Board on February
1, 1996, (delay due to the government shutdown) a second
PE ee
6la
Appendix C
election was held in the above-captioned matter on March
13, 1996, among the employees of the Employer in the
following appropriate collective bargaining unit:'
All production and maintenance employees
employed by the Employer at its facilities located
at 51241 M-51 North, Dowagiac, Michigan; BUT
EXCLUDING all other employees, including all
office clerical employees, guards and supervisors
as defined in the Act.
The payroll period for eligibility purposes was the
weekly period ending, S-.iday, February 11, 1996.
Upon the conclusion of the election, a copy of the Tally
of Ballots, indicating the following results, was made
available to each of the parties in accordance with the current
Rules and Regulations of the Board:
1. The petition was filed on November 14, 1994. Pursuant to
a Stipulated Election Agreement executed by the parties and
approved by the undersigned on December 7, 1994, an election
was held on January 12, 1995, which the Petitioner lost. On January
19, 1995, the Petitioner filed Objections To Conduct Affecting the
Results of the Election. The objections raised substantial and
material factual issues, including credibility issues. A hearing was
held on March 9 and 10, 1995. On April 17, 1995, the hearing
officer issued his report and recommendation on objections, finding
that certain of the Employer’s conduct was objectionable and
recommending that the first election be set aside and a second
election held.
62a
Appendix C
Approximate number of eligible voters ................. 345
VIS DIO cccccnsccnesscsensecsisccnnsecnnccrmstnssetermmenmemencnnses 4
Vetes ast Gar FORGED cccccerccecsvecemessccsereseqcemereren 184
Votes cast against participating labor
GHUIIIRRIIIED cccrcccoccscsscenecenscvesevsnsvanesesnenssessesesenees 150
Vals WORES COUIIIG crccccecseesessscsrecevescsnsnsevsesneemennes 334
Chraliemnged BelE OS .cccccsepensecceccscesvcccescsversnsssossoossoessoess 16
Valid votes counted plus challenged ballots ......... 350
The challenged ballots were not determinative of the
ultimate results of the election.
THE OBJECTIONS
On March 20, 1996, the Employer timely filed
Objections To Conduct Affecting the Results of the
Election, a copy of which was served by the Grand Rapids
Resident Office upon the Petitioner on the same date. The
Employer’s objections are attached hereto and marked as
Exhibit 1.
An investigation was conducted under the supervision
of the undersigned and all parties were afforded an
opportunity to present evidence bearing on the objections.
Based thereon, I make the following findings, conclusions
and recommendations.
OBJECTIONS NOS. 1-3:
The Employer claims that the Petitioner, through
several campaign documents, misrepresented why the
second election was being held; falsely informed the
63a
Appendix C
employees that the Employer had misrepresented to the
employees that one of its customers would “pull its
business”; and implied that unless the Petitioner was
selected as their bargaining representative, a significant
customer would remove its business from the plant.
The Employer claims that in the Petitioner’s letter of
February 16, 1996, to employees, which is attached hereto
and marked as Exhibit 2, the Petitioner misrepresented why
the second election was being held. More particularly, the
Employer claims the following as misrepresentations:
(a) A second election was ordered because,
“management blatantly mislead you about
customer concerns and loss of jobs.”
(b) During the entire first campaign, the company,
“set out. . . to deliberately misconstrue events
and customer actions.”
(c) “They fully intended and planned to threaten,
intimidate and coerce employees.”
(d) “Top management officials were involved in
these unsavory illegal objectionable actions
against you.”
The Employer claims that the Petitioner continued to
raise the issue of the Employer’s conduct prior to the first
election and why a second election was held through a
letter dated March 11, 1996, from UAW Local 1218,
President, Les Hodge, and that this letter was a further
64a
Appendix C
misrepresentation as to why the second election was ordered
and the issue of customers “pulling their work” from the
plant. A copy of that letter is attached hereto and marked as
Exhibit 3.
Additionally, the Employer claims that the Petitioner
continued with its objectionable conduct through a March
12, 1996, letter from Ford Motor Company representative
Phil Dubensky to Gerald Banton of the International Union,
UAW Ford Department. A copy of that letter is attached
hereto and marked as Exhibit 4. The Employer claims
that this letter, which was solicited by the Petitioner,
intentionally misrepresents to Ford Motor Company, a
major customer of the Employer, that the Employer had
represented to its employees that, if the Petitioner won the
election, customers such as Ford would pull work out of
the plant. The Employer further claims that the letter
misrepresented to Ford Motor Company that the Employer’s
“.. Plant Manager in the past has advised employees that
if the current UAW [Petitioner] organizing effort is
successful, Ford would ‘pull’ its business.”
The undersigned concludes that under Midland
National Life Insurance Co., 263 NLRB 127 (1982), the
complained of letters do not constitute objectionable
conduct. The Board will no longer consider the truth or
falsity of campaign statements made verbally or in
documentary form. Furthermore, in Riveredge Hospital, 264
NLRB 1094 (1982), the Board stated that it will treat alleged
misrepresentations of Board actions the same as all other
misrepresentations and will refuse to consider the truth or
falsity of such statements. Accordingly, assuming but not
65a
Appendix C
finding that the documents noted herein constitute
misrepresentations, the undersigned finds that no
objectionable conduct was engaged in by the Petitioner.
Accordingly, it is recommended that Objections Nos. 1-3,
be overruled.
Objection No. 4:
In this objection, the Employer claims that an undated
letter from the Petitioner’s in-house organizing committee,
apparently posted on or about March 8, 1996, on a bulletin
board at the plant, shows that front line supervisors favored
the Petitioner and thereby implied that retaliatory action
would be taken against the employees if they did not vote
for the Petitioner. A copy of that letter is attached hereto
and marked as Exhibit 5. The Employer claims that the
following are objectionable statements: “If you think about
it, management can’t see why we need a Union. Have you
noticed that the supervisors are Not trying to Talk us out of
voting Yes this time? They are the ones that used to be in
the position we are in. They can relate to our fears of having
little or nothing after many years of dedicated service.”
In Sil-Base Co., 290 NLRB 1179 (1988), the Board
stated that in cases of supervisory involvement, it would
look to the ability of the supervisor to both reward and
retaliate against employees and the extent of the supervisor’s
prounion conduct. Here the Employer has not indicated that
any specific supervisor was involved in any prounion
conduct. It merely points to the quoted sentences in the
two-page letter and does not describe any specific prounion
conduct by its supervisors. The Petitioner indicates that
66a
Appendix C
there were no supervisors on its in-house organizing
committee and no supervisors were involved in its
organizing campaign. Furthermore, the Employer admits
that it informed its front line supervisors that they were to
keep a low profile during this second election campaign.
Additionally, the Employer concedes that it conducted an .
anti-union campaign prior to the second election wherein it
made it clear that it opposed the Petitioner’s efforts to
organize the employees. This campaign took the form of
employee meetings and various literature.
Based on the evidence, the undersigned concludes that
the Employer has failed to establish that, in fact, its
supervisors engaged in prounion conduct. Moreover, if they
did so engage, the employees would not reasonably be
misled into believing that the Employer favored
unionization. Accordingly, it is recommended that
Objection No. 4 be overruled.
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the Employer’s objections be
overruled in their entirety and that a Certification of
Representative issue.”
2. Under the provisions of Section 102.69 of the Board’s Rules
and Regulations, exceptions to this report may be filed with the
Board in Washington, D. C. Pursuant to Section 102.69(f),
affidavits and other documents which a party has submitted timely
to the Regional Director in support of objections are not a part of
the record unless included in the Regional Director’s Report or
appended to the exceptions or opposition thereto which a party
submits to the Board. Exceptions must be received by the Board in
Washington, D. C. By April 16, 1996.
67a
Appendix C
Dated at Detroit, Michigan, this 2nd day of April, 1996.
(SEAL) /s/William C. Schaub, Jr.
William C. Schaub, Jr.,
Regional Director
National Labor Relations Board
Seventh Region
Patrick V. McNamara
Federal Building
477 Michigan Avenue, Room 300
Detroit, Michigan 48226
Attachment
68a
APPENDIX D — ORDER OF THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
DENYING PETITION FOR REHEARING DATED
AND FILED MARCH 11, 1999
97-5099/5247
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
CONTECH DIVISION, SPX CORPORATION,
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent,
v.
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
Respondent/Cross-Petitioner,
INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED AUTOMOBILE,
AEROSPACE AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA, UAW,
Intervenor.
ORDER
BEFORE: RYAN, COLE, and GILMAN, Circuit
Judges.
The court having received a petition for rehearing en
banc, and the petition having been circulated not only to
the original panel members but also to all other active judges
ee ae
69a
Appendix D
of this court, and no judge of this court having requested a
vote on the suggestion for rehearing en banc, the petition
for rehearing has been referred to the Original panel.
The panel has further reviewed the petition for rehearing
and concludes that the issues raised in the petition were
fully considered upon the ori ginal submission and decision
of the case. Accordingly, the petition is denied.
ENTERED BY ORDER OF
THE COURT
s/ Leonard Green
Leonard Green, Clerk
70a
APPENDIX E — HEARING OFFICER’S REPORT
AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE NATIONAL
LABOR RELATIONS BOARD FOR THE SEVENTH
REGION ON OBJECTIONS DATED APRIL 17, 1995
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS BOARD
SEVENTH REGION
Case No. GR-7-RC-20485
CONTECH DIVISION, SPX CORPORATION
Employer
and
INTERNATIONAL UNION, UNITED AUTOMOBILE,
AEROSPACE AND AGRICULTURAL IMPLEMENT
WORKERS OF AMERICA (UAW), AFL-CIO
Petitioner
HEARING OFFICER’S REPORT
AND RECOMMENDATIONS ON OBJECTIONS
Upon a petition filed on November 14, 1994, and
pursuant to a Stipulated Election Agreement executed by
the parties and approved by the Regional Director for
Region Seven on December 7, 1994, an election by secret
ballot was conducted on Thursday, January 12, 1995, among
the employees of the Employer in the following appropriate
unit:
Tla
Appendix E
All production and maintenance employees
employed by the Employer at its facilities located
at 51241 M-51 North, Dowagiac, Michigan; BUT
EXCLUDING all other employees, including all
office clerical employees, guards and supervisors
as defined in the Act.
The payroll period for eligibility purposes was the
bi-weekly period ending Sunday, November 27, 1994.
Upon conclusion of the count of ballots, a copy of the
Tally of Ballots, indicating the following results, was made
available to each of the parties in accordance with the current
Rules and Regulations of the Board:
Approximate number of eligible voters........... 366
NESTE Se - eae CR 2
Votes cast for Petitioner ..................ccccccocessesess 154
Votes cast against participating labor
i 196
| Te 350
Challenged Ballots .........0cececcccesesseveresereeverereseceeceses 4
Valid votes counted plus challenged
TSR CS cae ea 354
The challenged ballots were insufficient in number to
affect the results of the election. A majority of valid votes
cast plus challenged ballots was not cast for the Petitioner. '
1. A switch of 24 votes, or 6.8% of the votes counted plus
challenged ballots, would have resulted in a majority for the
Petitioner.
72a
Appendix E
On January 19, 1995, the Petitioner timely filed
Objections to Conduct Affecting the Results of the Election,
a copy of which was served on the Employer by the Board’s
Grand Rapids Resident Office on January 20, 1995.
Following a preliminary investigation, a Report and Notice
of Hearing on Objections was issued on February 9, 1995,
by the Regional Director. Therein he concluded that the
Petitioner’s six (6) enumerated Objections raised substantial
and material issues of fact including credibility issues, and
that these issues could best be resolved by a hearing. The
Objections are here set forth verbatim:
“During the course of the Union’s organizing drive, the
employer and his agents...
1. Conducted a campaign of fear and intimidation
through predictions of violence, strikes, loss of customers
and economic detriment which they insinuated would
inevitably result from a union victory.
2. Made pro-company campaign insignia available to
employees, thereby forcing the employees to make known
their pre-election preferences.
3. Threatened to go out of business, close the plant or
that customers would remove work if the union won the
election.
4. Created the impression of futility by stating that the
employer would not bargain in good faith if the union won
the election.
ERD, om: ~
RAM Z tem t-6P\je Dela
73a
Appendix E
5. Confiscated union literature.
6. In addition, the election was conducted in an area
used by the employer to propagandize employees.”
On March 9 and 10, 1995, at Cassopolis, Michigan, a
hearing in this matter was held before the undersigned
Hearing Officer, conducted according to the Board’s Rules
and Regulations, Series 8, as amended. The Petitioner and
Employer were each afforded full opportunity to be heard,
to introduce evidence, to call, examine and cross-examine .
witnesses, and to argue orally. The findings of fact and
credibility resolutions which follow are based upon my
consideration of the entire record? and upon my observation
of the testimony and demeanor of the witnesses.
BACKGROUND
The Employer operates two adjacent plants, designated
as plants #1 and #3, in Dowagiac, Michigan, where it
produces automotive rack and pinion housings and other
automotive parts for TRW, Ford Motor Company, and other
automotive suppliers. The precise number of employees
working at each plant is not clear from the record, but it is
clear that plant #3 is the larger of the two. Contech has two
other plants in Indiana. The Employer’s parent Corporation,
SPX (Sealed Power) operates other plants in Muskegon,
Michigan.
2. Accordingly, any failure to completely detail all conflicts
in evidence does not mean conflicting evidence was not considered.
Bishop and Malco, Inc. d/b/a Walker’s, 159 NLRB 1159 (1966).
e AO ae ~
74a
Appendix E
Objection No. 1 and 3
These two objections will be considered together,
because the alleged threats to go out of business, close the
plant, or that customers would remove work if the union
won (Objection #3) are related to and comprehended by
the broader language of Objection #1: “Conducted a
campaign of fear and intimidation through predictions of
violence, strikes, loss of customers and economic detriment
which they insinuated would inevitably result from a Union
victory.” At issue is whether elements of the Employer’s
campaign individually, in combination with each other, or
the campaign in toto, predicted or threatened consequences
of unionization in a way that interfered with the election.
First, however, I will deal with three instances of alleged
interference by supervisors or representatives of
management in one-on-one conversations with employees.
Alleged Spoken Threats by Supervisors
The first of these is only arguably but not clearly
encompassed by a very broad reading of Objection No. 1,
in that it involves a threat of unspecified reprisal to an
individual employee during the campaign. Nonetheless, it
was litigated without objection from the Employer. Plant
#1 production technician Loisa Murray testified that in
December, 1994, Die Cast Manger Patrick Harding tried to
show her some Employer campaign literature describing
employee complaints and unfair labor practice charges
against the UAW. He indicated that he thought something
in there was funny. Murray refused to look. She then said
their conversation “went back and forth a couple of times,”
75a
Appendix E
and then Harding became angry and said, “I’ll remember
that.” Murray could not recall what had been said
immediately before Harding’s statement that he would
“remember that.” She said that Harding later paid an unusual
visit to her work area, looking over her machine and parts.
Supervisor Harding recalled the encounter differently.
While distributing some of the Employer’s campaign
literature to employees, he found Murray reading some other
material and commented. “Oh I see you’re reading that.”
Murray, apparently perceiving an implied insult in this,
responded, “Yeah, I’m capable of doing that.” Harding
rejoined, “That’s good,” and asked her to keep the literature
off the work station if she was going to retain it. Murray
said she would. Harding denied becoming angry with her,
and denied saying that he would “remember that.”
Both Murray’s and Harding’s description of their
conversation struck me, for the most part, as credible, and
it seems likely that they were describing different parts of
the same conversation. To the extent that Murray’s and
Harding’s testimony conflicts on whether he told her he
would, “remember that,” I credit Murray. However, due to
the lack of immediate context for this statement in Murray’s
account, it is not possible to identify what it was Harding
said he would remember. If the comment followed Murray’s
assertion that she was capable of reading the campaign
literature, it would be a completely innocuous statement.
Without immediate context it is not possible to gauge
whether the statement would tend to interfere with the
election.
76a
Appendix E
Employee Shirley Stroud testified that for about six
months ending in December, 1994, group leader George
Avery was Acting Foreman while regular Foreman Mark
Hunsberger served as Acting Director of Manufacturing.
Stroud testified that Avery told her that if the Union got in,
the company would have to find other suppliers to fall back
on, and that the employees would have to go on strike to
get a signed contract. Avery was not called as a witness.
However, the record does not reveal when this conversation
took place, whether it was before or after the petition, or
before or after Avery’s assignment as Acting Foreman ended
in December, 1994. Also, the Petitioner who seeks to have
this statement attributed to the Employer has not clearly
established Avery’s agency or supervisory status. Aside
from the “Acting Foreman” designation, and witness Danny
Truelove’s statement that Avery spent more time doing
paperwork in the office during this period, there is no
evidence in the record that Avery possessed or exercised
statutory supervisory authority during this period. The
burden of establishing an individual’s supervisory status
rests with the party asserting it, in this case the Petitioner.
Gold Shield Security and Investigations, Inc., 306 NLRB
20, 21 (1992). Petitioner has not met this burden. For these
reasons I find the record does not support a conclusion that
Avery’s conduct was objectionable.
Employee Sheila Lott testified, at first, that after the
petition was filed she approached plant #3 Manager of
Manufacturing Mark Hunsberger and asked his opinion of
the Union. She stated that Hunsberger told her that if the
union got in, both plants would close. However, later in
her testimony she was emphatic that this conversation took
77a
Appendix E
place before the filing of the petition on November 14, 1994,
Accordingly, it took place before the critical period.
Moreover, Lott indicated that she told no one of this
conversation until after the election.
Employee Kevin Whiteoak testified about a
conversation initiated by Manufacturing and Engineering
Manager Paul Brancaleon, in which Brancaleon questioned
him about why he was supporting a union at Contech.
During the conversation, Brancaleon allegedly cautioned
him to be careful of what he was doing, because 400 jobs
hung in the balance. Whiteoak said that Brancaleon added
that the company’s largest customer, TRW, had pulled work
out of union shops before, giving Latrobe Die Casting
(“Latrobe”) as an example. Whiteoak said that he believed
this conversation took place after the petition was filed. He
told three to four other employees about it.
Paul Brancaleon testified about the same conversation.
He recalled that it took place on the afternoon of October
25, 1994, after he returned to the plant from an annual
manager’s meeting in Kalamazoo. He stated that when he
returned to the shop that night he received his first report
of union activity from other management personnel. They
told him that there had been a union meeting the preceding
weekend and that Whiteoak had been there. Brancaleon
acknowledged that he then called Whiteoak into his office
and questioned him about the Union meeting. He further
acknowledged that he told Whiteoak that Latrobe was a
union shop that had been purchased by a company called
Pace, which subsequently had lost some of TRW’s work
to Contech. He added that TRW had some very bad
78a
Appendix E
experiences with TRW in the past. He said that he did not
recall saying that 400 jobs were at stake in the union matter.
I credit Whiteoak’s account that Brancaleon said that
Whiteoak should think about what he was doing, because
400 jobs could hang in the balance, a statement that
obviously made an impression on Whiteoak. However, in
all other respects, due to his general demeanor, the detail
of his testimony and his greater ability to recall detail, I
credit Brancaleon’s account of this conversation as the more
complete and accurate. Because Brancaleon was able to link
this conversation in time with the date of the October 25,
1994 manager’s meeting, I find that was the date on which
the conversation took place. Accordingly, this exchange
occurred prior to the November 14, 1994 filing of the
petition and outside of the critical period. Therefore, this
conversation, standing alone, cannot be the basis for an
Objection. Data Technology Corp., 281 NLRB 1005, 1007
(1985). It may be considered only if it provides meaning
and dimension to post-petition conduct. Dresser Industries,
242 NLRB 74 (1979). Turner Shoe Company, Inc, 249
NLRB 144 ftn.2 (1980).
THE EMPLOYER’S CAMPAIGN
The Employer’s campaign comprised four elements:
posters depicting closed plants, printed literature mailed or
distributed to employees or posted in the plant, video
presentations, and speeches by management officials.
79a
Appendix E
The posters
During the last two weeks of the campaign the
Employer displayed large poster photographs of closed
manufacturing plants in both Plant #1 and #3. The posters
remained on display until just before the election. An
Employer campaign distribution diced January 10, 1995, is
signed by Human Resources Manager Dwayne Weber. It
explains that the plants pictured in the posters are all in
Michigan, that all are closed, that the employees who
worked there are all laid off, “many permanently,” and that
in each case the employees were represented by a union.
The memo goes on to state, “Within Sealed Power, there
are over 400 fewer union jobs since June of 1987. Most of
those were UAW jobs in Muskegon. Within the past year,
105 union jobs were eliminated when Sealed Power closed
the Ravenna plant due to that plant’s ineffective operation.
The point to all this is simple. A UNION DOES NOT
PROVIDE JOB SECURITY.” (Emphasis in original.)
Campaign literature
The Employer distributed, mailed or posted about thirty
pieces of literature to the unit employees during the
campaign. Although the parties could not stipulate that each
piece of literature was distributed “throughout the unit,”
testimony was received that in addition to supervisors
hand-distributing the employer’s literature, some were
placed in stacks in the lunchroom for employees to pick
up. Plant #3 employee Shirley Stroud testified that there
were “at least a hundred” pieces of Employer campaign
literature posted on the stockroom wall in her plant, which
80a
Appendix E
is a conservative estimate of the number of printed pages
submitted as the Employer’s campaign material in Joint
Exhibit 1. Neither party advanced evidence or argument
that any of the Employer’s campaign literature should be
discounted for lack of full distribution. In the absence of
such evidence or argument, and on the basis of the parties’
stipulation and the testimony received concerning the
Employer’s methods of distribution, I find that each of the
documents in Joint Exhibit 1 were mailed, distributed, or
posted in such a way that at least a majority of bargaining
unit employees were exposed to each of them.
I have not considered any of the undated material unless
its text clearly indicates it was posted or distributed during
the critical period’. Joint Exhibits 1-(a), (b) and (s) are all
dated outside the critical period, and they have also been
excluded from consideration.
The videos
In addition to its campaign literature and posters, during
the critical period the Employer showed three videos to the
employees, each in a series of small group meetings. These
have been made part of the record. Joint Exhibit 6(a) is a
film titled “Union Watch” which deals with strikes and plant
3. Campaign literature that contains an admonition to “vote
no” or a reference to the January 12 election date was clearly
distributed or posted after the petition was filed and before the
election. Before the petition was filed, the election date and whether
there was to be an election at all was not known. The undated
campaign distributions containing no such references are: Joint
Exhibits. 1-(d), (g), (k), (p), (v), (bb) and (cc).
8la
Appendix E
closings at plants where employees are represented by
unions, focusing primarily on the UAW. Joint Exhibit 6(b),
the “Guardian” video, shows television news reports
concerning a 1986 strike and picket line violence at
Guardian Industries’ plant in Carlton, Michigan. The same
video contains a CBS News feature on the UAW’s
unsuccessful attempt to organize a Nissan plant in Smyrna,
Tennessee. This video was shown to employees shortly
before the December holiday shutdown, at a series of
meetings conducted by Director of Manufacturing Joe
Barry. The third video was presented to the bargaining unit
employees on Tuesday, January 10, 1995, at the end of the
Company’s campaign. It is Joint Exhibit 6(c), the “25th hour
video,” a reference to the prohibition against captive
audience presentations to employees during the 24 hours
before the opening of the polls, enunciated by the Board in
Peerless Plywood Co., 107 NLRB 427 (1953). At the same
meeting where the 25th hour video was shown, employees
heard speeches by Contech’s Division President Gary
Walker, and a former general manager of the plant, Dale
Engel.
Alleged predictions of strikes and violence
The major themes of the Employer’s campaign appeared
almost immediately after the petition was filed. It’s
November 17, 1994 distribution is a letter from Human
Resources Manager Dwayne Weber asserting that over
two-thirds of the 600 plants that closed in Michigan in the
last two decades had union workforces, that the UAW has
called over 1,000 strikes, averaging 94 days in length and
idling 870,000 of its members during a recent 12-year
period.
82a
Appendix E
Two of the campaign distributions, Joint Exhibits 1(1)
and (m) deal exclusively with the UAW-Caterpillar strike
in Peoria, Illinois. Both are two-sided three page documents
with large, red-ink blotches, perhaps intended to be
evocative of blood stains, printed on the front and back
pages. The first contains excerpted and highlighted portions
of newspaper articles describing the UAW-Caterpillar
negotiations and strike in Peoria, Illinois. On its last page
it asks, “Are these the kinds of results that you want here at
CONTECH?” The second contains excerpts of a complaint
filed in Illinois state court alleging threats and physical
violence by UAW agents at Caterpillar and portions of
unfair labor practice charges filed by employees against the
UAW in the same dispute. It states on its last page, “Now
its up to you to decide if this is the kind of representation
you want here at Contech.”
Joint Exhibit 1(q) is a 12-page pamphlet containing
newspaper headlines, articles and photographs depicting the
1986 UAW strike at Guardian Industries. There is a
removable 1-page insert containing a chronology of the
strike. The headlines of the reprinted articles say: “Workers
Walk Out at Guardian,” “Guardian Advertising for
Workers,” “Truck Windshield Hit by Gunshot,” “Tear Gas
Used at Guardian,” “Glass Plant Strike Explodes Into
Violence.” The final page contains a disclaimer in large
print: “We are not saying that a strike would necessarily
happen here ... but you deserve to know the facts about
the U.A.W.”
Another Employer handout is titled “A Flashback in
Time, or Job Security Union Style” (Joint Exhibit 1(x)).
83a
Appendix E
Flashback is a 12-page pamphlet containing more
newspaper articles about strikes and lockouts, most in the
local Southwest Michigan area.
The most voluminous Employer handout of the
campaign, Joint Exhibit 1(v), has 27 pages of newspaper
articles and photographs describing protracted and faltering
strikes, plant closings, permanent replacement of strikers,
picket line violence, and shootings. It’s cover page
proclaims, “The UAW says ... ‘IT CAN’T HAPPEN
HERE!!’” The implication of the title, of course, is that
the Employer takes the opposite view, that strikes and
violence can happen here. On the upper left comer of the
back page, in much smaller print, appears the same
disclaimer used at the end of the Guardian handout.
The Guardian video presentation shows local news
coverage of a picket line confrontation between local police
using tear gas and striking employees, followed by assaults
on replacement workers’ cars and persons by strikers.
The Employer’s campaign associated the UAW and
unions in general with strikes and picket line violence, but
the literature and videos fall short of suggesting that a strike
would be inevitable at Contech. The disclaimers in the
printed literature, plus the absence of threats that there
would be regressive bargaining lead me to conclude that
the Employer did not make such a prediction or threat.
Agri-International Inc. 271 NLRB 925, 926 (1984).
84a
Appendix E
Alleged threats/predictions that customers would remove
work:
¢ Ford’s MN-12 part
Quality Control employee Shirley Stroud testified that
shortly before or after the holiday shutdown, a Ford part,
rack & pinion #MN-12, which had been produced at plant
#3 ceased production and left the plant, with no explanation
from management. Director of Manufacturing Joe Barry
testified that production of part MN-12 came to Dowagiac
about a year ago from the company’s Auburn, Indiana plant.
It was moved to Dowagiac to make room for some other
work in Auburn. Barry said that he had made a commitment
to Ford to return production of MN-12 to Auburn before
the end of 1994, and that the removal of MN-12 from
Dowagiac was done to fulfill that commitment. Under
cross-examination, Barry acknowledged that “normally,”
he would have considered it important for morale purposes
to let the Dowagiac employees know why production of a
part was leaving their plant. However, consistent with
Stroud’s testimony that there was no explanation, Barry
acknowledged that he did not issue any explanatory
communication to employees on this. No reason was offered
for Barry’s failure to explain the removal of MN-12.
In the Employer’s “Jt Can't Happen Here!!” pamphlet
there is a reprinted newspaper article titled “DIES
REMOVED,” concerning Ford’s removal of their dies from
a struck supplier’s plant in South Bend, Indiana. The
article’s print is very small and difficult to read. But Contech
has excerpted some of its text in larger print at the margins
85a
Appendix E
(“quote-outs”) to emphasize two statements from the article:
“DIES OWNED BY FORD MOTOR COMPANY,” and
“... THE DIES WOULD HAVE STAYED AT THE
PLANT ANOTHER FOUR YEARS IF THE STRIKE HAD
NOT OCCURRED.” Another quote-out indicates that the
union involved is the UAW.
In the absence of an explanation from Contech
management as to the reasons for the loss of MN-12, I find
that this article, as reproduced in the Employer’s campaign
literature, takes on added significance and would tend to
suggest to employees that the loss of MN-12 from their plant
may have been related to the presence of the UAW.
* The long-term agreement with TRW
Rack & pinion housing castings for Contech’s customer
TRW represent about 90% of the output from plant #1, and
about 15% of plant #3’s work. Contech uses TRW’s dies
for manufacturing its castings. At the time of the filing of
the petition Contech and TRW were just completing the
fourth year of their five-year long term supply agreement
(LTA), which expires on 12/31/95. Contech’s Director of
Sales and Marketing, Robert Davis, testified that within a
few days after the petition was filed he had a meeting with
TRW’s Director of Purchasing Gary Mahon to begin
negotiations for a successor LTA. Early in their meeting
Davis told Mahon that Contech had been formally petitioned
for a union vote. He testified that during the meeting Mahon
said TRW wanted to postpone LTA negotiations until the
union issues, along with some long standing quality and
delivery issues between Contech and TRW, were resolved.
86a
Appendix E
A November 18, 1994 memo from Davis to Division
Manager Gary Walker about his meeting with Mahon
indicates that TRW’s decision to postpone was due to
“issues at Dowagiac relative to the union” alone, and did
not mention that quality and delivery issues were
contributing factors. The explanation that TRW was holding
off LTA negotiations because of the union vote was
confirmed in Davis’ monthly activity report to Walker two
weeks later.
Plant #3 employee Shirley Stroud testified that in
December, at a captive audience presentation in the
conference room, Director of Manufacturing Joe Barry told
employees that TRW wouldn’t sign an LTA with Contech
until after the election.
Employee Loisa Murray, who works in plant #1,
testified without contradiction that Manufacturing Manager
Brad Farver brought up the subject of TRW’s attitude
toward union suppliers in a captive audience speech to
employees, and that he referred to a letter from TRW to
Contech on the subject. Ms. Murray said that Farver
indicated that TRW top executives didn’t want to work in
companies that had unions. Murray three times qualified
this part of her recollection with “more or less,” making it
difficult to differentiate her recollection of Farver’s
statement from her subjective interpretation of what he said.
Murray was clear, however, that after Farver’s statement
about TRW, employees in the meeting asked Farver to
explain his comments why TRW would not want to deal
with a unionized Contech, and that Farver did not elaborate.
I do conclude from Murray’s account that Farver told
87a
Appendix E
employees that TRW had communicated a concern to
Contech by letter about the possibility of a union there. I
also conclude that this was a different group meeting of
employees from the one that Shirley Stroud described,
although it was possibly in the same series of meetings,
and that it was again the company representative who
brought up the subject of TRW’s relationship with Contech
as it introduced the Guardian video.
Joe Barry testified that at one of his late-December
meetings with groups of employees, at which he showed
the Guardian Glass video, he told employees that the LTA
negotiations with TRW had been suspended “until we got
some of our problems behind us.” He didn’t recall how the
subject came up, and said that an employee might have
asked about it. Manufacturing Manager Brad Farver testified
that he was present for this series of meetings and that as
part of his introduction to the video he told employees “to
clarify rumors that have been floating around the shop floor
that TRW has postponed long term agreements until our
issues are resolved.” Asked about what Joe Barry had said,
Farver testified that Barry brought up the subject of the
quality and delivery issues with TRW as part of his
introduction to the video, and that he referred to rumors on
the shop floor, and then confirmed that LTA negotiations
had been postponed “based on those issues.” Farver did not
directly dispute the statements attributed to him by Murray.
I credit Farver’s account only in that it confirms that
he and Barry brought up the status of LTA negotiations as
part of the introduction to the video. I specifically discredit
his claim that Barry digressed to a discussion of quality
88a
Appendix E
and delivery issues while introducing the video. In the
context of a meeting called for the purpose of watching an
anti-union video depicting strike violence, I accept Stroud’s
and Murray’s credited recollection of their statements as
the more accurate. Accordingly, I conclude that Barry and
Farver put the onus for the postponement of the LTA on
the presence of the Union and the election.
¢ The rumored loss of a TRW part production
Plant #3 production employee Tommy Lee Walker
testified credibly without contradiction that within one to
two weeks before the election he saw supervisor Mark
Hunsberger stop and talked to employees on the line, one
after the other. He said that each conversation lasted a few
minutes. When Hunsberger got to Walker’s line, he told
Walker that the company was known for correcting its
mistakes. Then Hunsberger told him the TRW had sent one
of its dies to another company to see if they could run the
part. There is no record evidence whether Hunsberger’s
report was accurate.
Based upor Walier’s direct observation that
Hunsberger had stopped io talk to 2 or 3 other employees
on the line for about the same length of time before reaching
his machine, and based further upon Walker’s account that
Hunsberger’s comments were unsolicited, I find that it is
reasonable to infer that Hunsberger made similar comments
to other employees during this series of conversations. Even
if he spoke to no more than Walker and the 2-3 other
employees directly observed by this witness, given the
nature of his comment that the Contech’s largest customer
89a
Appendix E
was trying out alternative suppliers, I find it probable that
this report would have been widely disseminated throughout
the unit.
The Barry-Farver comments about the postponement
of LTA negotiations and Hunsberger’s comments about
TRW’s trying out alternative suppliers were raised in the
context of the Employer’s anti-union campaign: Barry’s and
Farver’s came at meetings called to watch a campaign video,
Hunsberger’s while he was talking about the company’s
ability to correct its mistakes. I find that by these statement
in their context, employees would reasonably conclude that
TRW’s relationship with Contech was in jeopardy because
of the union, and that the election could determine whether
the LTA was renewed.
* Late campaign statements by Zagotta and Walker
A January 9, 1995, campaign letter on SPX letterhead
to employees from President Al Zagotta informed
employees that “(your) plant is at a very critical stage in its
relationship with certain key customers like TRW, Ford and
Saginaw. ... 1 am concerned that if the Dowagiac plant
develops a reputation for not being a dependable supplier
— because of labor problems, a UAW-led strike, or even
the possibility of a strike every time the contract comes up
for renewal — our customers may become nervous and look
elsewhere for another source for their parts.” The record
provides no objective factual support for Zagotta’s
implication that customers “become nervous” as a result of
the mere presence of a union. The objective facts were that
there were other reasons for the Ford NM-12 rack & pinion
90a
Appendix E
part leaving Dowagiac, and TRW had additional reasons‘
other than the union drive for delaying renegotiation of the
LTA.
in his 25th hour speech to the employees on January
10, 1995, Division Manager Gary Walker emphasized that
he was “greatly concerned about the impact the union could
eventually have on our customers like TRW and our ability
to compete.” Considering only the immediate context of
his speech, this statement would not tend to interfere with
the election. But in the already-described larger context of
the campaign in which employees have been led by Barry,
Farver and Hunsberger’s conduct to believe that TRW and
Ford were already retreating from their relationship with
Contech because of the union, the statement tended to
reinforce fear that a vote for the union could result in loss
of work for Contech.
¢ TRW’s pre-election visit to the plant
TRW’s quality representative, Jack Fannon, visited both
Plant #1 and #3 on January 9, and 10, 1995, and toured
and inspected the production areas thoroughly. He was
accompanied by an entourage of Contech managers and
supervisors. The tour was highly visible throughout the
plant. According to the agenda Contech prepared for his
visit, Joint Exhibit 4(00), the Plant #3 tour lasted two hours
on the afternoon of January 9, from 1:45 p.m. to 3:45 p.m.
4. Division Manager Gary Walker testified that TRW’s
concerns about the union did not supersede the long-standing
concerns TRW had about quality of parts.
9la
Appendix E
Plant #3, the larger of the two plants, has a shift change at
2:30 p.m., according to employee Danny Truelove, so
Fannon’s tour spanned both first and second shifts and was
timed in such a way that its exposure to employees was
maximized. The Plant #1 tour lasted an hour on the morning
of January 10. He was still in the plant when Gary Walker
delivered his series of 25th hour speeches.
The impression conveyed to employees by Barry’s,
Farver’s and Hunsberger’s comments described above could
only have been further amplified by the January 9 and 10
plant visit by Jack Fannon. From Barry’s testimony it is
not clear who was responsible for the timing of this visit. I
think it is immaterial whether the timing of this visit was
first suggested by TRW or by Contech. Whether intentional
or not, Contech allowed the visit during the last two days
of the campaign, a time when its potential to affect the
election would have been greatest. It followed and gave
added weight to Zagotta’s stated concern that customers
would “become nervous.” It coincided with Gary Walker’s
25th hour speech and provided additional context for his
stated concern about the TRW-Contech relationship and
how it would be affected by the election.
I find that the Barry-Farver statements to the effect that
TRW was holding up the LTA pending the election results,
Barry’s failure to explain the disappearance of MN-12, and
Hunsberger’s statements that TRW had pulled a part out of
the plant, the Employer created an atmosphere where
Zagotta’s and Walker’s end-of-campaign statements would
have been understood as an implicit prediction that
work and jobs would be lost in the event the UAW won the
92a
Appendix E
election. The record does not show that this prediction is
based upon objective facts beyond the Employer’s control,
and as such constitutes an objectionable threat. Blaser Tool
& Mold Co. 196 NLRB 374 (1972).
¢ Alleged threats to go out of business or close the plant
As noted above, the Employer sought to associate
unions with plant closings from its keynote distribution on
November 17, 1994, to its videos, handouts, to tne
photographs of closed plants as explained by Dwayne
Weber’s January 10, 1995, letter.
The “Flashback” handout contains a full-size
reproduction of a 1982 letter to then-General Manager of
the Employer’s plant, Dale Engel. It is from William
Milford, the president of Scott Die Casting, Inc. The first
sentence of the typed letter states: “Scott Die Casting, Inc.,
an aluminum die casting and machining operation, in
Carlisle Ohio closed its doors last week due to union
difficulties.” In somewhat irregular and uneven lines, the
words “Scott Die Casting, Inc.” and “Carlisle, Ohio closed
its doors last week due to union difficulties,” are
underscored. The words “union difficulties” are triple-
underscored. The irregularity of the lines gives the clear
and immediate impression that they are not original to the
letter, but were added for emphasis in the distribution. This
page is back-to-back with a reproduced notice of a public
Auction for the Scott Die Casting equipment. This letter
was also shown with the underscoring in close-up in the
25th hour video presentation to employees. On the back
page of both and Flashback, and “JT CAN’T HAPPEN
De ape gnnaeatte ea aaa a oe ON Tee
SA See ae
93a
Appendix E
HERE?” in large print the Employer has printed this message:
“SAY NO TO THE POSSIBILITY OF LOST
CUSTOMERS, LOST JOBS, LOST PAY, LOST
BENEFITS AND OTHER TROUBLES — VOTE NO.”
The association of the UAW with plant closings and
loss of jobs was brought home by Division Manager Gary
Walker during his 25th hour speech to the employees. He
reviewed the points the Employer emphasized in the
campaign: “We feei we have accurately presented life in
the UAW by giving you the facts ...” He cites “the
horrendous strike record of the UAW”, “the 100’s of closed
plants in Michigan and the hundreds of thousands UAW
members who lost their jobs . . . as a result of inefficient
operation and UAW-led strikes.” Then Walker talked about
the years he has known the UAW and his “experience” with
them:
“From what I have personally seen, the UAW is
always at the heart of conflict ... Let me tell
you my personal experience with the UAW and
why I am so opposed to a union at this plant. I
also want to tell you because J don’t want you to
believe the union's campaign propaganda’ that
the UAW'’s relationship is so wonderful with
Sealed Power.” (Emphasis supplied.)
5. The UAW’s campaign literature included several
newspaper articles and letters from Muskegon-area UAW locals
describing a constructive and harmonious relationship between the
UAW and management at other Sealed Power plants.
94a
Appendix E
Walker then described three Sealed Power plants in
West Michigan where unions had represented employees:
“When I first joined Sealed Power in 1971, UAW
Local 637 was on strike in Muskegon. Right after
the strike, due to the fact the company wasn’t
competitive, the company closed the piston
operation and bought the parts on the outside.
We were so inefficient we could buy parts
cheaper from outside suppliers. That strike
issue was simply one of cost and not being
competitive. As sad as it was, Sealed Power was
forced to make a business decision in order to
save the rest of the company.”
“Another business decision was made in 1987
when the company announced the closing of the
Sealed Power Muskegon Machining operation.
400 UAW members ... lost their jobs. Those
jobs were lost due to the fact that we were no
longer competitive. .. .
“At the Sealed Power Ravenna facility near
Muskegon, another unionized plant with a
different union, the issue was once again the
profitability of the business. The company and
union reached an impasse during negotiations —
the union called a strike in May, 1993... . Once
the strike was over, the Union agreed to a
contract that froze wages and dropped retiree
medical benefits. .. . Only four months later, in
February 1994, the Ravenna plant closed costing
95a
Appendix E
105 people their jobs. Because of these facts and
because of what I have personally seen, 1 don’t
feel we need the problems often associated with
a union in our plant at Dowagiac.” (Emphasis
added.)
The impact of this speech is analogous to a campaign
poster used by an employer to show a correlation between
employees selecting a union, exercising their right to strike
and subsequent plant closing in General Dynamics
Corporation, 250 NLRB 719 (1980). There the employer
displayed a poster showing that the IUE had lost eleven
representation elections at General Dynamics plants, and
had won 3. It showed that there had been two strikes
and two plant closings. The poster concluded with an
exhortation: “Don’t vote for a Loser.” The Board held that
the “loser” reference could be interpreted as a reference to
the IUE’s association with the plant closings. “The message
conveyed to the employees through this poster was that the
Employer had closed two out of its three plants where the
(UE) won representation elections, and that the same thing
could happen at Camden.” (p.720). By comparison, Gary
Walker’s 25th hour speech gave three examples of Sealed
Power plants represented by unions, all three of which had
been closed or lost jobs, two following strikes. His statement
about the “problems often associated with a union” was a
clear reference to the plant closings he had just described
and would have had a similar impact on empioyees as the
“loser” reference in General Dynamics’ poster. General
Dynamics in its speeches to employees pointed out that there
are plants where the company and union have a successful
bargaining relationship, and stated affirmatively that the
96a
Appendix E
Camden plant would not be closed merely because a union
won an election. The Board held that this was not enough
to dispel the effect of the implicit threats in the rest of their
campaign. Contech’s disclaimers were weaker and fewer
than those found in General Dynamics. Walker’s only
disclaimer in this speech was that he was not saying a strike
would “automatically” occur if the VAW won the election.
The second example of union shops closing made no
mention of a strike. What all three examples had in common
was that the employees were represented by a union, and
Sealed Power closed plants or removed work.
Walker’s speech went beyond merely showing that a
union presence does not necessarily prevent plant closing
or loss of jobs, a point that had been stated in some of the
company’s campaign literature up to this point. These
comments were expressly offered to tell employees
something about Sealed Power’s “relationships” with
unions: that the relationships were marked by strikes
followed by “business decisions” to close plants, even
where the union had agreed to concessions. The speech
makes no effort to correlate the possible economic
consequences of unionization and the closing of plants.
Walker implicitly identified “the problems often associated
with a union” as the cause for the loss of profitability,
competitiveness and the resulting loss of jobs. An employer
who implies the possibility of job loss through unionization
must do so carefully “on the basis of objective fact to
convey an employer’s belief as to demonstrably probably
consequences beyond his control.” N.L.R.B. v. Gissel
Packing Co., Inc. et al., 395 U.S. 575 (1969). The Court
observed in that case that, “employees, who are particularly
Fe ees
97a
Appendix E
sensitive to rumors of plant closings, take such hints as
coercive threats rather than honest forecasts.” (Id. at
619-620). Walker’s 25th hour speech left the impression
that unionization and the exercise of the right to strike was
a factor in the decisions to close plants, and so failed to
meet this test. Diner 's Drive-In, Inc., 280 NLRB 971 (1986).
Walker’s speech must be evaluated in the context of
the Employer’s campaign which constantly provided
examples of plants closing where employees were
represented by unions. His speech was followed by a video
with a close-up of the Scott Die Casting “union difficulties”
letter. As detailed above, the Employer’s management at
high levels conducted its campaign at the “brink” of
overstating the objective facts linking unionization with the
dire consequences of closed plants and lost customers.
Turner Shoe Company, Inc., 249 NLRB 144, 146 (1980).
Unlike cases where other employers have spoken of their
“experiences” with unions, Walker gave no assurances that
Contech was not anti-union. Cf. Atlantic Forest Products,
Inc., 282 NLRB 855 (1987). I find that Gary Walker’s 25th
hour speech by itself and in this context implicitly
threatened employees with plant closure and had a tendency
to interfere with employee’s free choice in the election.
General Dynamics Corporation, supra. Harrison Steel
Castings Company, 262 NLRB 450, (1982).
On the basis of the record, including the above
credibility resolutions and findings of fact, I conclude that
Objections Nos. | and 3 have merit and I recommend that
they be sustained.
98a
Appendix E
Objection No. 2
The Petitioner presented one witness, Kevin Whiteoak,
who testified on this Objection. During the two weeks prior
to the election, Whiteoak said, supervisors in the shop wore
green, corduroy baseball style caps displaying the
crossed-out initials of the UAW. At first, only the
supervisors wore these caps, but then he heard a rumor that
employees could obtain the caps for the asking at the
personnel office. Bargaining unit employee Danny Truelove
testified that he asked supervisor Steve Nunez for a hat,
and received one. Truelove then decorated the hat with
pro-union buttons.
An employer who asks employees whether they will
wear anti-union campaign paraphernalia during the
critical period may interfere with an election. In certain
circumstances, this can be a coercive form of interrogation,
since employees may be thereby forced to declare
themselves on the issue of union representation. Lott’s
Electric Co., 293 NLRB 297 (1989), Horwath & Co., d/b/a
Gonzales Packing Co., 304 NLRB 805 (1991). However,
merely making these materials available to employee who
request them is not objectionable. Farah Manufacturing
Co., 204 NLRB 173, 175 (1973).
There is no evidence here that the Employer went
beyond merely making these caps available to employees
who came forward to ask for them. Indeed, the record is
void of evidence that supervisors or agents of the Employer
affirmatively let it be known that employees could ask for
the hats. The Petitioner has offered no evidence that any
99a
Appendix E
supervisor or Employer agent solicited employees to wear
hats or other anti-union campaign paraphernalia. Under
these circumstances, the Employer’s conduct is not
objectionable, and so I recommend that this Objection be
overruled.
OBJECTION No. 4
Testimony evidence in support of this Objection came
from bargaining unit employee Al Groth, a member of the
’ UAW in-plant organizing committee. He testified that on
the Monday before the election third shift die cast supervisor
James Rank initiated a conversation with him about the
upcoming election. He recalled Rank stating that it appeared
that the election would be close, to which Groth replied
that the Union was in pretty good shape. Under direct
examination Groth testified that Rank then said that if the
Union did win, the company would not honor the election
or negotiate a contract with the union. Under direct and
cross examination, Groth stated that this conversation was
preceded by a discussion® between him and an unidentified
co-worker about the significance of the posters and
photographs of closed plants displayed in the plant by the
Employer. Groth said that the earlier conversation caused
him to be upset or irate that the Employer’s campaign
6. From transcript p. 82, In. 24 to p. 83 In. 18, it is not clear
when Groth is describing his conversation with Rank and when he
is describing an earlier conversation with another employee. (See
Attorney Kok’s cross-examination of Groth at p. 92.) Accordingly,
the statement at p. 83, In. 4-5, “. . . he was saying that the company
would move because of the Union,” has not been clearly attributed
to Rank or any other Employer agent.
100a
Appendix E
literature had “insinuated” or “implied” that unions were
to blame for plant closings. Under cross-examination Groth
acknowledged that Rank might have said only that there
was no guarantee that the union would get anything in
negotiations.
In his testimony, supervisor James Rank recalled this
conversation occurring on the morning of the election. His
account of the preliminary discussion is consistent with
Groth’s. However, he denied saying that the Employer
would not bargain in good faith, or that the Union would
never get a contract. Instead he maintained that he had said
everything would have to be negotiated and there was no
guarantee that the company and union would agree on
bargaining points.
To the extent that Groth’s and Rank’s testimony
conflicts on this issue, I credit Rank, whose testimony was
both more clear and more consistent. I find, relying upon
Rank’s testimony and Groth’s acknowledgment under
cross-examination, that in this conversation Rank did not
say the company would refuse to honor bargaining in good
faith, or that it would refuse to negotiate a contract with the
Union if it won the election.
I conclude that the Petitioner has failed to adequately
support this Objection with evidence, and accordingly, I
recommend that it be overruled.
OBJECTION No. 5
The Contech Employee handbook (Employer’s Exhibit
2) contains the shop rules that were in effect during the
10la
Appendix E
critical period. Among the rules is a ban on “unauthorized
distribution of literature except during nonworking hours
(unpaid time or scheduled breaks) in nonworking areas as
is protected by the National Labor Relations Act.” (p.64).
This facially valid rule would permit the distribution of
union campaign literature in the lunchroom of each plant.
The first and second shifts each have an employee whose
job it is to daily cleanup the lunchrooms in both plants.
The job descriptions of both supervisors and production
employees, as well as the shop rules, require that they
promote plant-wide housekeeping. Some supervisors
regularly take their lunch and breaks in the lunchroom, along
with production employees. The Employer has allowed
employees to leave newspapers, magazines, a Bible, and
Avon catalogs on lunchroom tables for other employees to
read.
The Employer posted or hand-distributed about thirty
pieces of literature to the employees in the bargaining unit
during the campaign. The usual means of distribution was
for the supervisors to give it to employees at their
workstations. The Union, on the other hand, distributed its
campaign literature at its off-site meetings, but some
employees would then bring the union’s literature to work
and leave it on the lunch room tables in stacks or in single
sheets, for other employees to find and read.
Plant #1 third shift employee Al Groth testified that on
at least two occasions he witnessed supervisor Jim Rank
pick up union literature from the lunch room tables and
throw it in the trash. One of these occasions was in
December, 1994, about a week before the holiday shutdown,
102a
Appendix E
clearly within the critical period. On other occasions he
observed that union literature left in the break room
disappeared after Rank had been there.
Rank acknowledged that it was his practice to clear the
lunchroom of campaign literature when he went to the
lunchroom for his coffee, something that he did up to twice
each shift. He didn’t keep count of the number of times he
did this, and could not estimate it. If it was “unattended,”
he said, he put it in the garbage. He recalled once asking
some employees seated at a table with some of these papers
if the literature was theirs, or if they were reading it. When
they said no, he threw it away. Rank’s explanation was that
he was indiscriminate, gathering up both the union’s and
the company’s campaign literature. However, he did not
dispose of the Avon booklets or magazines, even though
they were also left on the lunchroom tables by employees,
because employees’ names appeared on those items, he said.
Two plant #3 employees, Shirley Stroud and Roddy
Green, testified that they saw first shift supervisor Ila
Aurand throw out union literature. Green recalled that about
a week before the election, he saw Aurand pick up a stack
of 25-30 pieces of union literature and put them in the trash.
Stroud testified that during the week preceding the election,
she and co-worker Barb Singleton were seated at a lunch
room table during a break, and that Aurand was seated at
the opposite end of the same table. Stroud took a piece of
union literature out of her folder, showed it to Singleton,
and then pushed it across the table to the other side, leaving
it for someone else to find and read. When Aurand finished
her break, she picked up the literature Stroud had placed
there, and threw it away.
103a
Appendix E
Supervisor Ila Aurand indicated that because this piece
of literature had been left on the table, and no one was
reading it when she finished her break, she regarded it as
“litter” and threw it away with her coffee cup and napkin.
Aurand stated that anytime she found “unattended”
campaign literature in the lunchroom, she threw it away.
Like James Rank, she did not disturb the Avon booklets or
magazines. Aurand also ignored newspapers left in the
lunchroom by employees, unless their tattered appearance
indicated they were old.
Plant #3 production technician Danny Truelove testified
that in December, 1994, he was working during the second
shift. While in the breakroom, he saw second shift die cast
supervisor Jim Humphrie cleaning up the tables. Humphrie
put magazines on an end table, but the union literature that
was laid out on the tables he gathered up and threw in the
trash barrel.
Supervisor Jim Humphrie testified that this instance was
the only time during the campaign that he disposed of
campaign material found in the lunchroom. Other times he
left the literature on the tables, but this time, he said the
table was “a mess” with “all kind of papers, candy
wrappers, everything on the table.” The campaign literature,
comprising 15-20 pieces of company and union
distributions, was scattered on tables throughout the
lunchroom. Humphrie cleared the table and threw out the
campaign literature. Danny Truelove was called again to
rebut Humphrie’s account that the lunchroom was
exceptionally messy when he cleared the tables. He added
that as Humphrie went through the lunchroom, he placed
104a
Appendix E
magazines on an end table, but that the threw out the union
campaign literature.
Truelove also testified without contradiction that two
days before the election another supervisor, die cast foreman
Mark Hunsberger, picked up a single piece of union
literature after Truelove placed it on the table, and then left
the lunchroom with it.
The incidents described involve four different
supervisors of the Employer, at both plants, and on all three
shifts. Two of those supervisors, Aurand and Rank, admitted
that during breaks they cleared campaign literature from
the lunchroom routinely. It is immaterial that the union
literature was not attended or guarded by employees when
confiscated and disposed of by these supervisors. The
Employer’s distribution rule imposes no such condition, and
this test was not applied to the other reading matter. As
indicated by Shirley Stroud, leaving copies of literature on
lunchroom tables, whether in stacks or single sheets, was a
means of forwarding it to other employees who would come
to the lunchroom later. Current newspapers, magazines and
Avon booklets were not disturbed, indicating that the
supervisors understood this. The supervisors’ explanations
for their conduct are not credible. Rank and Aurand tried to
distinguish the campaign literature from lunchroom
magazines on the basis that the latter had the names of
employees on them. Aside from the coercive effect of
requiring individual employees to put their names on union
literature they want to distribute, this seems too fine a
distinction from supervisors who did not differentiate
current campaign literature from candy wrappers, used
coffee cups and napkins.
105a
Anpendix E
Discriminatory confiscation of union campaign
literature during the critical period by Employer agents can
constitute election interference. It conveys that the
Employer will not tolerate lawful distribution of union
literature, while simultaneously permitting other types of
literature to remain. Jennie-O Foods, Inc., 301 NLRB 305,
338 (1991); See also Vemco, Inc., 304 NLRB 911, 927
(1991). In its closing argument at the hearing, the Employer
cited Genessee Merchants Bank & Trust Co., 206 NLRB
274, 275 at ftn. 10, an 8(a)(1) case, to support its claim that
its supervisors were merely cleaning up litter. The footnote
cited states, “Respondent can prevent the distribution of
literature which occurs in such a manner as to cause litter.
Erie Marine, Inc., 192 NLRB No. 119.” Both Genessee and
Erie involve unfair labor practice 8(a)(1) issues, and not
the more restrictive test of objectionable conduct interfering
with the “laboratory conditions” of a representation election.
Dal-Tex Optical Co., 137 NLRB 1782, 1787 (1962).
Moreover, Erie concerned the maintenance and enforcement
of a written no-distribution rule expressly aimed at curbing
litter.
The Employer’s conduct here was neither isolated nor
de minimus. There is no evidence that Employer corrected,
disavowed, or minimized the impact of this conduct during
the campaign. Cf. United States Aviex Co. 279 NLRB 826
(1986).
I recommend that this Objection be sustained.
OBJECTION NO. 6
The Petitioner argues that, because the polling took
place in the plant #1 conference room, the same room where
106a
Appendix E
the Employer had conducted its captive audience meetings
and where it had shown its campaign videos, the atmosphere
of the election was tainted. There is no dispute that the
conference room selected by the Board Agent for the polling
area was where the Employer conducted its meetings. The
parties stipulated that the Union’s organizer expressed to
the Board agent an objection to the selection of the
conference room on grounds consistent with this objection.
The Union’s witness, Kevin Whiteoak, testified that on
the day of the election, all campaign material had been
removed and that only the Board’s official election notices
remained posted. There is no evidence or claim that the
secrecy of ballots was compromised or that supervisors were
present in the voting area while the polls were open. The
Tally of Ballots reveals there was a 97% turnout. Under
these circumstances I find that it is too speculative to
conclude that the location of the voting area in the
conference room could have affected the results of the
election.
I recommend that this Objection be overruled.
SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS
I recommend’ that Petitioner’s Objections Nos. 2, 4 and
6 be overruled. I further Recommend that Objections Nos.
1, 3 and 5 be sustained and that the Board direct a second
election.
7. Under the provisions of Sec. 102.69 of the Board’s Rules
and Regulations, exceptions to this report may be filed with the
Board in Washington, D.C. Exceptions must be received by the
Board in Washington by May 1, 1995.
107a
Appendix E
Dated at Grand Rapids, Michigan, this 17th day of
April, 1995.
s/ Thomas M. Good
Thomas M. Good, Hearing Officer
National Labor Relations Board
Room 330, 82 Ionia N.W.
Grand Rapids, Michigan 49503
108a
APPENDIX F — EXCERPTS FROM TRIAL
TRANSCRIPT OF ROBERT DAVIS
[Commencing at page 263]
* * ad
Q Who specifically called you?
A Gary Mahon, their director of purchasing for North
America.
Q And when did he call you to do that?
A Roughly, November time frame.
Q And did he request that you meet with him face to face?
A Yes.
Q And where was that meeting scheduled?
A At his office in Sterling Heights, Michigan.
Q I assume you attended the meeting.
A Yes.
Q And who was there?
A Myself and Gary Mahon.
Q Could you tell us what the discussion was?
109a
Appendix F
A The discussion started off, before we got involved with
the LTA, I had informed him that we had been formally
petitioned for a union vote. That’s the first information I
had given him in regards to the union situation.
Q And then what happened?
A He had told me that in, in view of the current situations,
within the context that he would like to postpone our
long-term agreement negotiations until our issues in
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.