Respondents Brief — Layne & Bowler Corp. v. Western Well Works, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1923
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
:
tee Pes DEE AT,
a
Topical Index
ca eh aS 4 6.6.6 & SES
SSS SSO REE DES SEO Sh WE BA A ee Oe we
Misuse by Plaintiff of Detached Phrases from the Van
OE I I 62 cin ck v-deed bien Cock cec.
Layne Patent Found to be of Narrow Seope by Two Differ-
sradlisamarivectteatis. . Tee eT eee ieee,
Decisions of Fifth and Ninth Circuits are in Complete
Harmony as to Validity of Layne Patent...........
Holding of Non-Infringement by Fifth and Ninth Circuits
cis ae Pn ee are
The Layne Invention as Disclosed in the Patent in Suit...
Wedge Mechanism for Centering the Layne Mechanism...
Sg RES ARR eae Gene eas bis |
eS AOSAASRAOCRASADEED DASA LEO RES KO BS
‘unction of Lower Stuffing Box or Packing Gland 41
acking Boxes Abandoned............................
‘his Lower Packing Box an Essential Element of the Layne
Patented Structure
ayne’s Commercial Pump Built Under a Subsequent
Chea Wie eo wins cavevunnoadds seec Ube ote cs
ayne’s Conception Alleged to Have Occurred in Late
Summer of 1902 But Not PRS See ce ta ee
yne is Limited to April 28th, 1903 (His Filing Date) as
His Date of Invention
ii INDEX
I I ie oe eEK ai nin oo wewww ata wade
ee EL NN BOUIN eho 66 6K cca necdeesseensees
Byron Jackson Pump on Sale Before Layne’s Invention. ..
The Pabst Installation a Continuing Act...............
Byron Jackson Defenst Long Known to and Feared by
PEC he cae CAMSECK CS CL sdk bed ae w ene ness
The Layne Patent as Construed by Prior Adjudications. ..
I cc g'S A pak sn eck he de okt S Kes Kanes
ie wank bie banex wah eb eee w ews uss
a Oe an rer reer ener
**Stagnant”’ vs. ‘‘Cireulatory’’ Systems of Lubrication...
bas cise esxaeeiueacd sss es
co ee eee err
Defendants’ Patent to Halstead........................
EEG CELT TCE TET PET eT TT TE
Plaintiff Admits Defendants Employ a Circulatory System
PIG ce i ee eee en ee
The Foregoing Admissions of Fact Binding on Plaintiff. . .
Circulation Has Reference Solely to the Oil Path........
Difference Between Water Circulation as Such and Lubri-
i rE coke aw ha wake vce a eeab ash kean
The Tapered Hub a Fictitious Issue Injected by Plaintiff
Cit ce tahwa wenn dep awew ica ae
Farr err Cer re ee. Tere err ot
Pamiaen OF Bpeed, WE, Bee... once ccs esesccecscvess
Tight Tubes the Rule With Getty and Other Non-Infringers
Lubrication in Defendants’ Structure..................
Lubrication in the Western Well Works Pump..........
Subsequent Lubrication in Western Well Pump..........
The Use of Grease as a Lubricant Not Confined to Western
Wee SU III, icc anadcnanewakcacecus
Circulation Aided by Defendants’ Helical Groove Bearings
The Theory of the Helical Oil Groove...................
ey I ak ns hb anne iada sb ee cereus
‘*Commercial Success’? Has No Place in this Case........
INDEX
Reply to Plaintiff’s Brief..................0.00.......
District Court’s Opinion as to Infringement Not Unas-
coe vtccgp le DELLE Met ee ae 155
Plaintiff’s Mythical Eight Problems.................... 160
The Pit Pump a Popular Rival WOR San ikccicakvacks 161
Adjustment by Wedges.................ccccc0000005,. 163
Protection by Stuffing Boxes.......................... 164
MMMM ANS AON CN RG RITA AL sR oa se Whicker Ww. k care 164
PART ert CoN AC te ee 165
“cnaiong cap ACRE PLCC ENE Aenea 166
‘Gravity Feed’’ oo 167
‘he Lower Stuffing Box 40-41 of Layne Designed to Pre-
BE NE sh \ sVasaencka ivan lee lac. os 171
‘he ‘*Pendent’’ Structure Is No Part of Layne’s Claims in
crt CREOLE | PERE CP COP TC ey eee 173
laintiff’s Liberties in Reconstructing the Claims in Suit. . 176
laintiff’s Misrepresentation and Misuse of the Appellate
pessoa apna, EOE EEE ILO” ODE NERS ae 178
egarding Tapered Hubs and Tight Joints.............. 181
0 ita a, PEELE PEO ee Sr 183
EE Soa hiennes etn pe tee het 185
SEIN rites caneca Vevey, cock) ae a 185
SH SHAS ONS SRR ME SN GNabAAG CNR vAgR Okeke ck og wk 188
iv INDEX
Index to Cases Cited
Page
Adamson vs. Gilliland, 242 U. S. 350................... 154
Advance Corp. vs. Reflex Co., 284 Fed. 117.............. 154
American Soda Fountain Co. vs. Sample, 130 Fed. 145... .32, 46
Atlantic Works vs. Brady, 107 U. S. 102, 27 L. Ed. 440... 51
Automatic Weighing Mach. Co. vs. Pneumatic Seale Corp.,
Me reas Ci aee ial ceca waGvaaenoueen 61, 63
ee Wk A ee, We Ms eo kv kk kh wa dan deeds 159
Blanchard vs. Putnam, 75 U. S. 420, 19 L. Ed. 433........ 150
Burr vs. Duryee, 1 Wall. 531, 17 L. Ed. 650............. 134
California Canneries vs. Dunkley, 247 Fed. 790.......... 88
Christie vs. Seybold, 55 Fed. 69....................... 62
Columbia Motor Car Co. vs. Duerr, 184 Fed. 893......... 188
Concrete Appliance Co. vs. Mienken et al., 267 Fed. 958... 55
Consolidated Ry. Electric Lighting & Equipment Co. vs.
Adams & Westlake Co., 161 Fed. 343............... 52
Curtiss Corp. v. Jamin, 278 Fed. 454.................... 62, 63
Detmold vs. Reeves, 1 Fisher 127....................... 38
Duer vs. Corbin Cabinet Lock Co., 149 U. S. 216........ 152
ens We, Mp, © Pak O06. .... 5... eee kk. 159
Hildreth vs. Mastoris, 254 U. S. 622.................... 155
Hudson vs. Draper, 4 Fisher 256...................... 126
Keystone Bridge Co. vs. Phoenix Iron Co., 95 U.S. 274... 141
Kimball vs. Waters Co., 177 Fed. 239................... 126
Lemley vs. Dobbins, 243 Fed. 391........... een aece 55
Lovell vs. Oriental Co., 231 Fed. 719.................... 34
Lyon Non-Skid Co. vs. Hartford, 247 Fed. 524........... 34, 35
Lyon Non-Skid Co. vs. Hartford, 250 Fed. 1021.......... 35
Magowan vs. New York Belt. & Pack. Co., 141 U. S. 332,
ee SN Aa ele danas av eneerteces, Ceccck 153
Mahn vs. Harwood, 112 U. S. 354...................... 187
McClain v. Ortmayer, 141 U. S. 419, 35 L. Ed. 800........ 153
McCreery, ete. Co. vs. Massachusetts, ete. Co., 195 Fed. 498 63
Merrill vs. Yeomans, 94 U. S. 568...................... 141
Miller vs. Bridgeport Brass Co., 104 U. S. 350............ 187
RN SELMA ASPEN SE RINE EE NITEM I ECO UR EO RISEN Mate EHS re RNA —
INDEX Vv
Page
National Machine Corp. Inc. vs. Benthall Machine Co., Ine.,
sets clacag ea PORTE Oe ae 51, 127
Norton vs. Jensen, 49 Fed. 859......................... 126
Olin vs. Timken, 155 U.S. 155......................... 152
O'Reilly vs. Morse, 15 How. 3.......................... 149
Potts vs. Creager, 155 U.S. 600....................... 152
Raisin Seeder Case, 182 Fed. 59....................... 188
Reed vs. Cutter, 166 Fed. 302.......................... 62
Singer vs. Cramer, 192 U. S. 265; 48 L. ed. 437......... 151, 155
Smith vs. Goodyear Dental Vuleanite, 93 U.S. 495....... 152
Stafford, Inc. vs. Thaddeus Davids Ink Co., 264 Fed. 111.. 35
Sugar Co. vs. Yaryan, 43 Fed. 140.................... 36
Superior Skylight Co. vs. August Kuhnla, 265 Fed. 282.... 34
Twentieth Century Co. vs. Loew Co., 243 Fed. 373........ 62
Underwood vs. Gerber, 149 U. S. 225, 37 L. Ed. 710...... 187
Westinghouse vs. Boyden Power Brake Co., 170 U. S. 537,
18 Sup. Ct. 707, 42 L. KG. 1136.................. 135, 149
PLYER LA em
In the Supreme Court
OF THE
Hnited States
OcrToBerR TreRM, 1922
No. 278
AYNE & BOWLER Corporation,
Petitioner,
vs.
VESTERN WELL Works, INc. (a corporation),
Roraky DriLLinc AND DEVELOPMENT Com-
PANY (a corporation), Stantey M. Hat-
STEAD, P. EK. VAUGHAN and ALLEN W. Ross,
Respondents.
On Writ of Certiorari to the United States Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit.
RESPONDENTS’ BRIEF
STATEMENT.
This is a suit for alleged infringement of Layne
tent No. 821,653, issued May 29th, 1906, on an
plication filed April 28th, 1903, and purporting
to cover new and useful improvements in Well
Mechanism. The suit is based upon claims 9, 13,
and 20 of said patent.
The District Court for the Northern District of
California found said claims valid and infringed.
On appeal, the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Ninth Circuit reversed the decree in so far as
holding that defendants’ construction did not in-
fringe said claims, though at the same time find-
ing the patent valid. In so doing the Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, speaking by Judge
Morrow, in a carefully considered opinion (Record
1121-1148—reported 276 Fed. 465) followed sub-
stantially the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Fifth Circuit.
The case is now before this court on writ of
certiorari.
For convenience the petitioner will be referred to
herein as ‘‘plaintiff’’ and respondents will be re-
ferred to as ‘‘defendants’’.
ADJUDICATIONS OF THE LAYNE PATENT IN SUIT.
This court will be materially assisted in the con-
struction of the Layne patent by what has been
said about it by the various judges before whom
it has come for review in the past. The other
reported Qpinions, to which the Court’s attention
is particularly directed, are all in the Fifth Cir-
cuit, to-wit:
3
The El Campo Case, 195 Fed. 83, C. C. A.
dth Circuit;
The Van Ness Case, 213 Fed. 804, C. C. A.
oth Circuit;
The Getty Case (on Preliminary injunc-
tion), 220 Fed. 918;
The Getty Case (on appeal from Final Hear-
ing), 262 Fed. 141.
In addition to these four Opinions of the Ap-
pellate Court, there is the recent decision in the
Los Angeles District in the American Well &
Prospecting Company case, which case is, for
convenience, referred to as the ‘‘Los Angeles case’’;
the report of the Master who was appointed by the
court to hear the evidence and submit his findings
appearing (R. Pea).
The net result of all these decisions has been
practically to construe the Layne patent to the
level of a mere paper patent, valid only within
very narrow limits. The Getty case supra may
be taken as the leading case on the subject follow-
ing as it does repeated reviews of the same ques-
tion by the same court.
The gist of the Getty case was that the Layne
patent was limited to a stagnant system of lubri-
cation which was not infringed by a pump em-
ploying a circulatory system of lubrication. The
logic and importance of such a distinction will be
manifest in its application to the instant case,
/0%2
The new defenses interposed here on the scope
and validity of the patent must necessarily result
in a further paring down of the claims in question,
rather than any enlargement thereof. These new
defenses are:
(1) Byron Jackson prior invention and sale.
(2) Alvord prior invention.
(3) Eisler patent.
THE CLAIMS IN SUIT.
The claims involved are numbers 9, 13 and 20
(R. 1005) and read as follows:
**9. In well mechanism the combination with
a pump casing, of a rotary pump of a jointed
pump shaft and a closed casing surrounding the
| pump shaft from the pump to the top of the
| well.
| ‘*13. The combination with a pump and its
actuating shaft of a sectional casing therefor
| provided at each end of each section with a fixed
block with bearings for the shaft, the casing
being closed at the top and provided with an
air vent.
‘*20. The combination of a well casing, a
rotary pump therein, and a line shaft for the
pump entirely closed off from the water in the
| well.”’
Having read the El] Campo, Getty and Van Ness
decisions, supra, and Judge Morrow’s opinion in
NOTE—In the Van Ness case, supra, the court found (page 807) that:
‘*The word ‘closed’ in claim 9 seems to mean as much as the words
‘entirely closed’ in claim 20.’’
and proceeded to hold the two claims to be substantially alike.
5
the Western case, the meaning of these claims as
interpreted by the several appellate tribunals will
in a large measure have become apparent to this
court.
We shall, however, in due course point to what
we think is the true meaning of these claims and
show that whatever that meaning is, whether that
given by the Fifth or Ninth Cireuit Judges, that
defendants do not and never did infringe.
MEANING AND SCOPE OF THE CLAIMS IN SUIT.
Throughout the litigation that has been carried
on over the Layne patent the proponents of Layne
have urged upon the various courts the reading
into these claims of functions and elements not
apparent on the face of the claims, nor, indeed,
deducible from the description and drawings of the
patent. Even though the Cireuit Court of Appeals
for the Fifth Cireuit felt disposed to give Layne
credit for accomplishing an important advance in
the art, nevertheless that court in the Yan Ness
case, 213 Fed. 804, in passing upon the
scope and
meaning of claim 13 said:
‘While the Van Ness pump is closed at the
top, it is not contended that the pump has
an air vent such as the patented pump had
and such as the El Campo pump had. One func-
tion of this air vent is to force any water or
spent lubricant remaining in the casing, out of
it, through an aperture in the top, by foreing
air through the air vent into the casing, for
the purpose of substituting clean liquid or oil.
ee ee eee LOD SLD A,
6
It seems clear that the Van Ness pump had
no such member with a corresponding func-
tion as the air vent of the patented pump or
that of the E] Campo pump, and so cannot be
said to infringe claim 13. This, if correct,
would prevent complainant from relying upon
claim 13 in this case, as a ground of recovery.”’
In considering claims 9 and 20 the same court
said:
‘*Giving claim 20 this interpretation, it seems
that it is substantially like claim 9, except in
the omission of the element of jointure or ex-
tensibility of the shaft sections, which adds
nothing to the novelty and patentability of the
device; and that the element common to each
claim, viz., the protective or closed casing sur- |
rounding the pump shaft from the pump to
the top of the well and entirely closing off the
water in the well from the shaft and its bear-
ings, is the only element in any one of the
claims as to which there is persuasive evidence
in the record both as to patentability and in-
fringement. The word ‘closed’ in claim 9 seems
to mean as much as the words ‘entirely closed’
in claim 20. (Italics ours.)
MISUSE BY PLAINTIFF OF DETACHED PHRASES FROM THE
VAN NESS AND GETTY CASES.
The plaintiff in its argument seeks to predicate
conflict between the Fifth and Ninth Circuits and
endeavors to make it appear that the Fifth Circuit
held the Layne patent to be of a fundamental,
generic character and entitled to a broad range of
equivalents, although not infringed by the Getty
device ; whilst the Ninth Circuit, still construing the
patent as valid, held it not infringed by the Western
device; and yet Getty was nearer to Layne than
Western.
The plaintiff always as a premise to its argu-
ments repeats this phrase over and over again:
“The Layne patent . . . did accomplish a revolu-
tion in the well-diilling industry,’’ while failing
to give the full quotation (262 Fed. 141, 143), which
is:
“The Layne patent too nearly resembles the
Crannell patent to be called a pioneer patent,
though it did accomplish a revolution in the
well-drilling industry.”’
The phrase emphasized is what the plaintiff takes
occasion each time to omit. The plaintiff has also
failed to call attention to the Sentence or two fol-
lowing in the € tetty case where the court said:
‘While the substitution of mere mechanical
equivalents for the means adopted by Layne
could not avoid infringement of his patent, it
is also true that the range of equivalents can-
not be enlarged upon the idea that his patent
was a pioneer one in the pump art. Its ad-
vance over Crannell prevented Crannell from
being considered by us an anticipation, and was
enough to show novelty, but it stops there.
The Layne patent must rest, not upon the idea
of closure, which would not be patentable apart
from the method by which it was accomplished,
but upon the means of its accomplishment, as
disclosed by the specifications of his patent.’
(Italies ours.)
8
Plaintiff, likewise, ignores this, from the Van Ness
decision:
‘‘It seems quite clear that the idea of a pro-
tected casing for a pump shaft without re-
strictive interpretation would contain no nov-
elty and would not be patentable, and, if this
element in the patent is given the unrestricted
meaning that its language admits of, it would
destroy the claim.”’
Van Neat
and that in the 4et¢y case the court said:
‘‘it seems that the question of infringement,
like that of novelty, is a close one’’ (R. 809).
And
‘‘Layne’s method of lubrication was to put
the oil in at the top and to permit it to descend
to each of the bearings, and remain stagnant
within the shaft casing until ejected from the
top after it had become spent by air pressure
through an air vent . . . On the other hand,
the oil was confined at the bottom of the well
by use of a packing or stuffing box. Getty
adopted a circulatory system of lubrication.
By it the oil was also introduced from the
top, and descended to the lower bearings by
gravity. However, at the bottom there was
only a partial obstruction to its exist, presented
by a long sleeve bearing. Its passage out from
the shaft casing was automatic and continuous.
so that there was a constant and free flow of
lubricant from the top of the line shaft,
throughout its length, and out through its bot-
tom.”’
We thus see that even conceding all of the con-
tentions of Layne as to the revolutionary char-
acter of his alleged invention and the filling of a
9
long felt want, the court was unable to find infringe-
ment of any of his claims by a structure which
did not effect a complete closure of the shaft-en-
closing casing, but which on the contrary used a
circulatory method of lubrication as distinguished
from Layne’s stagnant system. Although there
was considerably more prior art before the Circuit
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in the pres-
ent case than there was before the Circuit Court
of Appeals for the Fifth Cireuit in the two cases
referred to ante, nevertheless the former resolved
all doubts in favor of Layne and sustained his
patent, but necessarily found non-infringement
thereof.
LAYNE PATENT FOUND TO BE OF NARROW SCOPE BY TWO
DIFFERENT COURTS OF APPEAL.
The Layne patent, while uniformly held valid
by the courts, has likewise been uniformly held as
being for a narrow invention.
In the El Campo case only claim 13 was in-
fringed; in the Van Ness ease claims 9 and 20
Were infringed because the ‘thrust collar”’ at the
bottom acted as a ‘stuffing box’’ to ‘‘entirely close”
the shaft tubing; while in the Getty, Los Angeles
and Western Well cases there was no infringement,
because they all lacked closure in Layne’s sense and
Operated on a “‘eireulatory”’ system of lubrication
While Layne’s system is “‘stagnant’’.
10
The Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Fifth Cir-
cuit in the case of Layne vs. Getty, 262 Fed. 142,
said:
“The Layne patent must rest, not upon the
idea of closure, which would not be patentable
apart from the method by which it was ac-
complished, but upon the means of its ac-
complishment, as disclosed by the specifications
of his patent.’’
Similarly, the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Ninth Circuit in its decision in the case now brought
here for review, said (R. 1131):
‘‘We have placed some emphasis upon the
fact that all the claims in this patent relate to
one principal operative invention of a well
mechanism, and in that relation they all in a
more or less direct and practical way were de-
signed to co-operate and supplement each other
to the common intent and purpose of being
employed in an operating pump apparatus for
a driven or artesian well; but when we turn to
the analysis of the claims in suit, we find that
the essential elements claimed to have been in-
fringed are limited and narrow and relate only
to the combinations of a rotary pump with an
actuating shaft entirely closed off from the
water in the well by the casing surrounding the
pump shaft.”’
DECISIONS OF FIFTH AND NINTH CIRCUITS ARE IN COMPLETE
HARMONY AS TO VALIDITY OF LAYNE PATENT.
The same court which found infringement in two
eases, but of different claims in each case, found
non-infringement in a third and later case where
11
a different structure was involved and at a time
when the court had acquired greater familiarity
with the scope and meaning of the Layne patent.
The Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cir-
cuit in the instant cause, with the records of all
prior suits before it, found validity and non-in-
fringement in harmony with the findings of the
Fifth Circuit of the Court of Appeals. This is
clearly shown by the following quotation from the
opinion of the court, Western Well Works ys,
Layne & Bowler Corporation, 276 Fed. 470, 472
(R. 1133):
‘In Getty vs. Layne (C. C. A.) 262 Fed. 141,
the court followed its decisions in the previous
cases, determining the question of the validity
of the patent in favor of the plaintiff, but the
court held that the patent was not entitled to
the wide range of equivalents of a pioneer
patent.”’
That this is a correct statement we have only
to note the following from the Circuit Court of
Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in the Getty case,
262 Fed. 143:
“The Layne patent too nearly resembles the
Crannell patent to be called a pioneer, —
Its advance over Crannell prevented Crannell
from being considered by us an anticipation,
and was enough to show novelty, but it stops
there.”’ (Italics ours. )
The Ninth Circuit in the case under considera-
tion gives its stamp of approval to validity of the
Layne patent where it is said (R. 1136) :
™
12
‘*We are of the opinion that there is inven-
tion in the entirely closed casing of the Layne
patent as claimed in claims 9, 13 and 20, par-
ticularly claim 20, functioning as it does in com- |
plete protection to the line shaft from the in-
gress of water and sand and in protecting the
means for lubrication.”
When we come to analyze the prior decisions in
detail, we will see that each court in imparting
validity to the Layne patent, by resolving all doubts
in favor of Layne and not invalidating the par-
ticular claims sued on, did so with regard to the
mechanism disclosed in the drawings and specifica-
tion of the patent in recognition of well recognized
principles of patent law.
HOLDING OF NON-INFRINGEMENT BY FIFTH AND NINTH
CIROUITS ALSO IN HARMONY.
The Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, in
finding non-infringement in the case of Getty vs.
Layne, supra, said, at page 144, after describing
Layne’s method of lubrication already quoted supra,
‘‘We think Getty has accomplished closure
and lubrication by means so functionally differ-
ent from Layne’s disclosure in his patent that
they cannot be said to be mere mechanical
equivalents, but rather distinct methods of at-
taining the same object; the object itself not
being patentable.”’
The Circuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cir-
cuit in finding non-infringement in the instant case
quoted verbatim the above language (page 143)
No. 821,653. PATENTED MAY 29, 1906.
M. E. LAYNE.
WELL MECHANISM.
APPLICATION FILED APR. 28. 1903
4 SHEETS—SHEET 1
Lrwverlor.-
Makin. &.
By ks gon
AL ey
a a
No. 821,653. PATENTED MAY 29, 1906.
M. E. LAYNE.
WELL MECHANISM.
APPLICATION FILED APR. 28. 1903.
4 SHEETS—SHEET 2
Pr
~
SELLLs SILLS. SSLELILE RAS PL
64
UME SSES:
hae, A eberK
CQuav Moamagel)
Posies, aaBTES,
0 a ee
PATENTED MAY 29, 1906.
No. 821,653
M. E. LAYNE.
WELL MECHANISM.
APPLICATION FILED APR. 28, 1903
4 SHEETS-SHELT 3
i Balad REA DEERE BINS. Sa 5 oe |
4
a2.
R-vprovenen se comoreen Soy SV Z
(LVSLLLLSLLLLLLLSDLAL Ah trnse § natneae
Og ES
— 2S
ye
.
'°
Sy,
a
a
on
No. 821,653 PATENTED MAY 29, 1906
M. BE. LAYNE.
WELL MECHANISM.
APPLICATION FILED APK 28, 1903
No. 821,653 PATENTED MAY 29, 1906.
M. E. LAYNE.
WELL MECHANISM.
APPLICATION FILED APR. 28. 1903
4 SHEETS—SHEET 3 4 SHEETS—SHELT 4
| 16
MEN MHARNMOO MARANA ANNAN
iewerlor~. tikdtnesses,’’ Laver lor.
Mahle S Layne Chee, WA sok Makln. Clr gra
7 ’ - a) -\ $
of ha a ean fesciome gels - 4y hick fe CN ti
0 Sittin A sitty-
“OL elok
Qrav Slew -nagt d
se, als PE REMAS HG PEE A
aa ee ee E
13
from the opinion in the Getty case (see R. 1135) and
concluded (R. 1136):
“The difference between the Layne patent
and the Getty mechanism, as it appears in Getty
vs. Layne, supra, is essentially the difference
between the Layne patent and the defendants’
mechanism in this case.’’
The question brought before this court for de-
termination appears to be whether or not the two
Circuit Courts of Appeal referred to have placed
a proper interpretation upon the scope of Layne’s
patent and that this is to be decided not upon the
extent of alleged ‘‘commercial success’’ attained by
plaintiff in later years on a greatly changed struc-
ture, but upon a study of the patent in suit and the
proceedings in the Patent Office leading up to the
granting thereof, together with a consideration of
the prior art.
THE LAYNE INVENTION AS DISCLOSED IN THE PATENT
IN SUIT.
On the opposite page the Layne patent draw-
ings are reproduced direct from the patent, and
in connection therewith the court’s attention is
invited to a consideration of defendant’s model
Exhibit ‘‘B’’ of the Layne patent in suit, which is
admitted to be correct (R. 728).
The patent in suit says:
‘My invention relates to apparatus used for
drawing water from driven or artesian wells,
and particularly to means for adjusting a pump
therein.”’ (Italics ours.)
14
Said ‘‘adjusting’’ means, as will be apparent from
a reading of the patent, are a system of wedges in-
dicated generally at 33 in Fig. 5 and at 62, Fig. 11
of the drawings. The stated objects of the Layne
invention are:
**(1)
(2)
(3)
(7)
(8)
(9)
to provide means by which the piping and
the pump may be all assembled in proper
shape before inserting it into the well;
to provide means by which a pump may
be placed in any desired position in a well,
centered, raised or lowered and fixed in
position by manipulating from the outside
entirely ;
to provide means for adjusting the length
of the piping leading from the pump to
the surface at will and to lower the pump
from time to time without taking it out of
the well;
to provide improved means for centering
and fixing the pump in proper position in
the well casing;
to provide improved means for manipulat-
ing the packing of the pump shaft, and
proper adjustment of the pump in place
by means at the surface of the ground;
to provide for the proper action of a pump
without stopping up the well, so that water
may be either flowed into or pumped out
of the same at pleasure;
to provide a superior mounting for a cen-
trifugal pump in the well, manipulated
from the surface of the ground;
to provide an extensible pump shaft sep-
arately supported at intervals along its
length ;
to provide an automatic centering device
for the pump in the well;
ne RA Na EASES PORATED IRA DR WAIN a NEN 8 IPL EEL
E7EL'E SALNb2 SANAVT
WALSAS AIIM £E-1
Srend opur prnb>) 20 290 40
eSv0I8a uaratd 07 Suvaut
buruaiybr? puv xog Lursynzs —|h
WALSAS PNILVINUIAT
PUVULVIS Hurnoys
JO MAPA paprauuayz
cf
VE
6£
i
|
97
th
SSSI
‘Z¢ edid Wodj paqoafa ping ayi pue ‘pessoa
91 9G [IM UOI}vsJedO ay) ‘fe do}, ay} ze ul &¢
piny Zur nd ey} jo Surysom ayy
YUM aa PUB Uldtey) UBIO SHULIBag
) Ul ABO8lo AUIsvo ayy doay
Ww nO pexI0y aq UB pny
eS JO WO
« ‘2e
‘119M 94) Ul Yidep paitsap eg
AUB PopUuaIxe ST PUB joAZ,T Jo}EM ay) MOLOq
UMOP SPU9IX9 YOIUM ‘Zz edIid vw st [zZ Surseo
dund at MO[APG puR ‘dune
1JUd) ayy
JO 8¢ 4} 0} pokey A € 3eys
eUL ys ef} jo do} > ‘Te deo 0g
yyy AC ‘og XOG Suyjnys B@ YM papraoid
°MOPPVIPLGYW) OF PIUPLIFILA
90S HuvIV02w07
UOPMRVIPEVIBTS WUIPOY
ANAVT *O4Y 22049e7
+
RDRBRBSSLSVESaasasans
L
PANSS AL
ee Otay
COPIES
\
Gi
ian 4
nbr) yzem parry
JPAVQUP DUISDZ
mn 4
bursnz
uPYOIA-27Y,
Duniwquroi
2eP PSISSY OF
(POG br7s3NIS
|_|
\
Va
/
15
(10) to provide for mounting the pump and the
shaft in a closed casing which is open to
operate from the top;
(11) to obviate the necessity of making large
wells for descending into them in order to
arrange the pump, and
(12) to generally improve and cheapen the ap-
paratus used for the above purposes.”’
Inasmuch as the drawings of the Layne patent
are of a piece-meal character and somewhat obscure,
we have assembled the different views in one and
on the opposite sheet will be found a connected view
of Figs. 5,7, 8 and 9, which Layne terms his ‘“‘ap-
proved form’’.
Referring to this illustration it will be noted that
the pump proper indicated at 38 is fixed in the
well casing by a system of ‘“‘wedges 33°’ which
are operated from the top of the well by means
of links (32-31-28) and toggles 34-35 (see
Model ‘‘B’’). The pump has a_ peripheral
discharge pipe for the water and is driven
by a splined and jointed shaft made up of sections 39,
39’ and 39”, which extend up through a casing 20.
The casing is sealed at the bottom and top by stuffing
boxes 40 and 51 respectively and is completely filled
With liquid, which may incidentally serve as a lubri-
cant. This liquid remains stagnant in the tube or
casing 20 and can only be forced out through the pipe
44 by pressure of air introduced through the pipe 52.
(Cut opposite)
The second form of the Layne well mechanism is
shown on the ppesite sheet, being the same as
ht vA 2
REST ey te
16
Layne’s Fig. 10 except that the structure is sectional-
ized throughout, whereas the Layne patent drawings
show the same not in section.
In this modified form the drive shaft is not made
up of sections. It is exposed throughout the greater
portion of its length. The tube ‘60’ which extends
only between the pump bowl 21 and ‘‘block 67”
neither contains nor shows any lubricating means.
To prevent well water rising above the pump bowl
and getting up around the exposed shaft, the pump
bowl 21 itself is surrounded and packed by a water-
tight ‘‘wedge system’’ which prevents water from
rising there-around from the well below. No lubri-
eation whatever has been provided for in this form
of the Layne mechanism.
Prof. Lesley, an eminent, practical engineer of
Stanford University and expert for defendant, says,
in expounding the Layne patent as embodied in the
model Exhibit ‘‘B’’ beginning R. 729:
‘‘The model shows a pump bowl, a shaft sur-
rounded by an enclosing casing, a discharge col-
umn, and a representation of a pump head; the
shaft and its enclosing casing are in sections, the
weight of each section of shafting is borne by a
thrust bearing; .. .
“The thrust bearings or support collars are
numbered 48; the shaft-enclosing casing sections
are numbered 20. In operation the pump would
(691) be driven through a sectional line shaft
from the top, turning the impeller, which is
numbered 38, and by centrifugal force driving
Vata aR alee a
obey 3 “TYP
O71 IAT
of i
Aq p
e eee ‘Bd ib
89 3 ,
ok ZA, a oO
fe eB d b
pt Aap
& bn wl i Ze Z "
o/ - Z
Les wapshs abpay-s
ll ald
LU2SOI NOM YP;
20g Leevyx0d pt0ddns
°F YI 7 9-
gS!
20g BUIyIog “§ of
YUNG.
L9 4991,
ptoddns of
equrt~*
IF -
6£
a ee eee == §
CT 4e2T fo Os]
INALVd ANAWT
JO OF ORT UP
UMNOYS ULOf JO
$ Mate [VUOIPIOS
Ba.
—
— | Peatsep Aue jo _pue suonoes ul
B
se z Saynd & YIM poplaoid eq Avu 1eys
duind « 72 JO do} eyd “p. NeASNyLt ¢ SE OU) UY
, woppnatyro0ds pUAaTOT
NAW] UOt Ss PIVAINT
PI |
Maras y NIM VEEP OU :
»NZ \)
YTV TNE,
17
the water up the discharge column, No. 23, and
delivering it to the surface of the ground.”
Continuing, Prof. Lesley says:
‘A lubricating feature is provided, in that the
shaft-enclosing casing is made substantially
tight against the entrance of water from the
well or from the bowls No. 21, against the en-
trance of water from any point—water or any-
thing that the water might carry with it; means
are provided for tightening this tube, substan-
tially sealing it off, both at the bottom and at
the top. <A stuffing-box,* on which I find no
number, is provided at the bottom; packing is
arranged at the bottom. The stuffing-box is also
provided with a top, and in conjunction means
is provided for tightening the glands of the
stuffing-box, which, of course, cannot be reached
from the surface of the ground; that is the tube
No. 44, which has at its lower end a sprocket
which engages—a sprocket of which there are
three, carrying a sprocket chain—the design ap-
pearing to be if this tube is rotating, all three
stuffing-box bolts would be turned down and
tightened at the same time; the stuffing-box
gland at the top is the ordinary form with only
two bolts. As disclosed in the patent drawings,
there is a pipe No. 52 which is deseribed as an
air vent; the part marked No. 44 is also a tube,
and is provided with a hole into the cham-
ber 47.’’
“Stuffing box: In mach., a contrivance for securing a steam-air—or
water-tight joint when it is required to pass a movable rod out of a vessel
or into it. It consists of a close box cast round the hole through which
the rod passes, in which is laid, around the rod and in contact with it, a
quantity of hemp or india-rubber packing. This packing is lubricated
with oily matter, and a ring is then placed on the top of it and pressed
down by screws, so as to squeeze the packing into every crevice. The
stuffing-box is used in steam-engines, in pumps, on the shaft of a screw
steamer where it passes through the stern, ete.
Century Dict. & Ency.
PEE Ry
18
Prof. Lesley then indicates (R. 730) the stag-
nant system of lubrication employed in Layne, say-
ing (R. 730):
‘‘Tt is stated in the patent specifications that
this whole interior of the shaft casing may be
filled with oil; no water can leak into it; there
is no other place for the oil to leak out. It is
sealed against water at the bottom, it is sealed
against oil leaking out; the lubricant may be
used for such time as is necessary, until it shall
have become spent [692] or worn out, and then
that air pressure may be applied to the air pipe,
52, and the oil forced down and into the hole in
pipe 44 and upward and out one of the openings
that are provided at the top, or that the opera-
tion may be reversed, and air may be forced in
at the top, thus forcing the oil upward and out
of the pipe 52.’’ (Italics ours. )
And on page 731:
‘* As to the lubricating feature, this pump pro-
vides what may be termed a stagnant system of
lubrication; the lubricant introduced by some
means into the tube is held there until it be-
comes spent. There appears no way by whieh
it ean be continuously fed. Jt is simply held as
lubricant might be in the crank case of an auto-
mobile; it is filled up [693] and it wears out or
is burned out, dissipated.’’ (Italics ours.)
The loosely connected sectional feature of Layne’s
driving shaft with thrust collars for supporting the
shaft sections individually act as a further seal to
enhance the stagnant feature of the Layne oiling
system, and prevent ‘‘gravity’’ feed.
aces - a
19
LAYNE IS AN UNDERNEATH FORCE FEED SYSTEM.
1. The bearing blocks or thrust collars 48 for
each shaft section form a complete seal over the
bearing on which it rests, to prevent oil passing
down just as did the thrust collar in Van Ness, rest-
ing upon the long brass bushing and forming a me-
chanical closure (see post herein, page 71). In
Layne each thrust collar or thrust being 48-49’
would form a seal against any downward cir-
culation of oil, even if pressure were applied, be-
cause the more pressure at the top the tighter would
the thrust collars 48 of Layne seat on the bearing
blocks.
2. Lubrication in Layne must be from the
bottom up; i. e., oil must be injected under pressure
through the pipe 44 (Fig. 5), passing downward
and finding its outlet below the lowermost bear-
ing, and then as the pressure of the oil piles up
there below (being prevented from escaping into the
well by the lower stuffing box 40-41) it would work
upward around the shaft 39, slightly lifting the
shaft and the thrust collar 48 and gradually filling
the compartment in the shaft tubing above; simi-
larly passing upward around each shaft section and
its thrust collar until the whole reservoir or cham-
ber formed by the shaft-tubing was filled to the
top; the air vent 52 allowing the displaced air to
escape as the oil rises.
The foregoing analysis explodes the ‘ gravity
feed’’ theory of plaintiff and shows better than any-
20
thing else the ‘‘stagnant”’ quality of Layne’s lubri-
cation.
WEDGE MECHANISM FOR CENTERING THE LAYNE
MECHANISM.
Concerning this feature, which we find to be an
emphasized one in the Layne patent, Prof. Lesley
says (R. 731):
‘*Auxiliary devices, in the form of a wedge
mechanism, parts No. 33, with sliding collars,
31 and 28 and connecting rods and toggle links,
are provided, as stated by the patent, to secure
this mechanism within the well. The weight of
the pump bowls, and of the runner, and of the
shafting is supported by the shaft-enclosing
casing sections, 20, in this particular model,
which I should say is substantially correct with
the drawings; the weight of the discharge cas-
ing, or diseharge tube, 23, is also supported by
the tube line.’’
Now if we turn to the patent we see how these
features so tersely described by Prof. Lesley are
emphasized by the patentee.
Thus on page 2 of the patent (R. 1003) begin-
ning line 1, the patentee says:
‘*In order to previously assemble all the parts
and then put the pump into the well and fix it
in position therein, I provide a system of wedges
33, which serve to fix the _— in place and
hold it in the proper vertical position, designed
to be operated by means from the top of the
.
well, avoiding the necessity of a man’s going
into the well in order to fix the pump in place,”’
And lines 28-35, page 2:
“Thus in order to obtain greater power and
fix the wedges more securely in place, it will be
observed that by pulling up on the rod 32, the
toggle links 34 will cause the wedge blocks 35
to press with great power against the wedges
33, and thus fix the pump casing in place
wherever desired.’’
21
And again lines 105-111:
‘The wedge system illustrated for tightening
the pump casing in place may also, if desired,
be used to center it with respect to the casing.
The outlet pipe 23 is also preferably made in
sections to correspond with the sections of the
pump shaft casing.”’ (Italics ours. )
And again lines 120-124 (R. 1003) :
‘‘A series of co-operating wedges 62 may also
be provided, suspended from the platform 61
by means of the screws 64, and the two series
of wedges surround the whole casing.’’
And again page 3 (R. 1004) :
“It will be seen also that the toggle levers
used for actuating the wedges may be used or
not, as desired, since the wedges alone will be
amply sufficient in the apparatus of Figure 1,
as well as in that of Figure 10.”
WEDGES ABANDONED.
As showing how impractical this “‘wedge system’’
is and that no part of the commercial success of
22
the plaintiff-appellee’s pump can be attributed to
this feature of the invention, see Mr. Layne’s testi-
mony on cross-examination (R. 594):
‘‘XQ. For instance, taking Figure 5, the
wedges, 33, which contact with the well casing,
16: Have you ever used those?
‘‘A, At the time of my invention——
‘XQ. Just answer ‘Yes’ or ‘No.’
‘‘A, We have not used a pump that would go
in the bore of a well. Eas
‘‘XQ. Please answer ‘Yes’ or ‘No.’ Have
you used those wedges, 33, for the function
specified in the patent, or at all?
‘A, We have never used the wedges.”’
And as to the means for operating the wedges
Mr. Layne testifies (R. 594):
‘‘XQ. Have you ever used the toggle num-
bers, 34 and 35, which connect with those
wedges ?
‘“‘A. No, sir.
‘‘XQ. Have you ever used the parts repre-
sented by the rods or links, 32, which connect
with the toggles?
“s Be oe.”
And (R. 595) :
“XQ. And, referring to Figure 1, have you
ever used the sliding sleeves, 28, 31, for manipu-
lating those respective links, 32, 297
‘‘A. They all refer to the wedges, which we
have not used. [578]
““XQ. And, likewise, you have not used the
stem members, above 27 and 30, to connect with
those sleeves?
‘“‘A. We have not.”’
The importance of the functions to be performed
by the wedges is repeatedly emphasized in the pre
23
amble to the patent (R. 1002), where Layne says
among his various objects are:
“‘to provide means by which a pump may be
placed in any desired position in a well, cen-
tered, raised or lowered and fixed in position b
manipulating from the outside entirely.”’ . . .
(Italics ours.)
And:
‘“‘to provide improved means for centering and
fixing the pump in proper position in the well
casing.’’
Again Layne says, lines 25-27:
‘“‘to provide improved means for manipulating
the packing of the pump shaft.”’
This refers, of course, to the key rod 44, chain and
sprockets 42, and the lower packing gland or
stuffing box 41.
Again Layne says (beginning line 32, page 1):
‘“‘to provide a superior mounting for a centri-
fugal pump in the well, manipulated from the
surface.’’
That agains refers to the toggles and links, sprock-
ets and chains above mentioned.
The importance of the wedges is again emphasized
in the preamble (line 37)
“to provide an automatic centering device for
the pump in the well.’’
Layne admits, supra, that none of these center-
ing and positioning adjustments have ever been
put into use.
24
These features form no part of the defendants’
structure.
FUNOTION OF LOWER STUFFING BOX OR PACKING
GLAND 41.
The patentee having repeatedly stated that the
form of Fig. 1 is the preferred form bears down on
the importance of the pump shaft casing being
closed both at top and bottom ‘‘to form an atr-
tight chamber’’ and ‘‘water kept out of the casing —
20” (see page 3 (R. 1004), beginning with line
74):
‘‘T consider it of great advantage also to ar-
range the pump shaft in a closed casing with
stuffing box at surface of ground at top of pump,
so that by the use of the packing boxes an air-
tight chamber can be maintained, and water
kept out of the casing 20, or kept filled with
clean liquid, if desired, thereby providing an
efficient lubricating system for all bearings of
the pump.”’
The patentee repeatedly emphasizes that ‘‘the
easing 20 is closed’? and emphasizes the necessity
and functions of the ‘‘stuffing box 50’’ and ‘‘the
packing box 40.’’ Thus on page 2 of the patent
(R. 1003) line 58:
‘‘At the top, the casing 20 is closed and is
provided with a stuffing box 50, closed by the
eap 51, at the top of the shaft 39.’’ (Italics
ours. )
And lines 66-72:
‘‘The casing 20 also contains a tubular rod 44,
which has a bearing in the block 47 on top of
25
is provided with a Square opening which co-
operates with the head of the screw 42, used
for adjusting the cap 41 of the packing box 40
for the pump, and compressing the packing in
place.’’
PACKING BOXES ABANDONED.
This bottom “stuffing box 40” has never been used
commercially by Layne (R. 595) where he testifies:
“XQ. Likewise, referring to Figure Dd, have
you used the stuffing box, 41?
at
No, sir, we never have in that particu-
lar form. We have used a brass or metal sleeve
there, thorough lubricated, which performs the
same function.
“XQ. Then your answer to my question is
you never used the stuffing box, 41?
“*A. No, sir.”
The lubricated ‘metal sleeves’’ referred to by
Witness does not, as the appellate court quite
properly held in the Getty case, perform the func-
tion of the stuffing box 41.
(Note: It is not to be overlooked that the stuffing
box 41 is shown in the patent in addition to the bear-
ing below it. If it were not for the stuffing box,
the oil in the tube would be sucked out around the
bearing, due to the suction in the pump ease. For
that reason the patentee put in the stuffing box 41
to keep in the oil and to exclude the water. By so
doing Layne brings about a condition made essential
in claim 20 where he Says: ‘‘a line shaft for the
pump entirely closed off from the water in the
well.’’)
re ihe Peg PEE aga 8 tes le ao ee eee ee Ld 100 a eM ee ee ee ee ry
The patentee next explains how this lower pack-
ing box is to be operated from the surface, or, as
he says in the preamble, page 1 of the patent, lines
26-27:
‘*to provide improved means for manipulating
the packing of the pump shaft . . . by means
at the surface of the ground.’’
He describes these means beginning with line 3,
page 2 of the patent (R. 1003):
‘In order that this cap 41 may be raised and
lowered evenly, the screw 42 is provided wit!:
a sprocket wheel, and two other screws of a
similar kind are distributed about the cap, as
shown in Figure 6, and connected by means of
the sprocket chain 46, so that by means of the
tubular shaft 44, all three of said screws 42 may
be turned at once to compress the packing in
box 40.”’
Defendants do not use and never have used any
‘stuffing boxes’’ nor their equivalent.
The attempt of one of plaintiff’s experts to find
equivalency between the lower ‘‘stuffing box’’ of
the plaintiff and the open ‘‘drain tubes’”’ or anti-
stuffing boxes of defendants would be amusing if
it were not for the fact that it seems to have been
put forward under the cloak of sincerity.
THIS LOWER PACKING BOX AN ESSENTIAL ELEMENT OF
THE LAYNE PATENTED STRUCTURE.
It was by means of this lower packing box of
Layne whereby he might effectually exclude water
27
from the well, or as Layne says in his
patent (p.
3, lines 77-82—R, 1004) :
. ‘that by the use of the packing boxes an
air-tight chamber ean be maintained, and water
kept out of the casing 20’’ (italics ours),
that Layne differentiated, if at all, from the prior
art, in so far as ‘“‘an enclosed line shaft”’
was con-
cerned,
STUFFING BOXES ANOTHER ABANDONED FEATURE.
This adjustment means ‘for manipulating the
packing of the pump shaft from the sur-
face’? has never been used commercially, it being
utterly impractical (R. 594). See R. 595, where
Layne testifies:
“XQ. And you have never used the adjust-
ing mechanism shown by the sprocket chain,
46, and the sprocket, 42, 42”, 42”, shown in
Figure 6 of the patent ?
“A. All being parts of the packing gland,
Wwe never have used it.’’
EVACUATING THE OIL,
The means (pipe 44) for tightening the lower
packing to make the same air-tight and water-
tight performs also the function of evacuating the
Spent oil in the shaft enclosing tubing or oil
reservoir. Thus says the patentee page 2 (R.
1003) beginning with line 83:
‘This pipe or tubular shaft 44 also serves the
purpose of providing convenient means for
foreing the liquid out of the pump shaft cas-
ORI Bae OO DY OM ONES CE AAO HO og PVE MM an
28
ing. By forcing air in at the top of the casing
20, by means of the pipe 52, the liquid can be
forced down to the bottom of said casing 20, and
by means of the small opening 45, in the bottom
of the tubular shaft 44, the fluid can be forced
out at the top 54, and keep the casing clear in
order to leave the bearings clean therein and
not interfere with the working of the pump, or
by forcing fluid in at the top 54, the operation
will be reversed, and the fluid ejected from
pipe 52.”’
THIS OIL-EVACUATING MEANS ABANDONED.
The pipe 44 with its double function of adjust-
ment for the lower packing and for evacuating by
air the oil reservoir enclosed by the casing 20,
together with the vent pipe 52, has never been used
commercially, being likewise utterly impractical,
although undoubtedly novel with the patentee (R.
595) where Layne testifies:
‘‘XQ. And you have never used the pipe, 44,
which is shown in Figure 5, down to the bottom
of the shaft tubing?
‘‘A. No, sir, we never have.”’
The ‘‘air vent’’ of the patent is the short pipe
52 (see Fig. 7).
Defendants have never used any of these devices.
Layne’s sectional shaft and bearing blocks 48
to carry the shaft sections are commercially im-
practical and never used. The patentee on page
2 of his patent (R. 1003) concerning the sectional,
29
extensible feature with slip joint arrangement of
his shaft says, beginning lines 50-57:
“The weight of the shaft and pump below the
block 47 is carried by the block 48; and from
Figure 8 it will be seen that a similar arrange-
ment is made at the top of the next section of
the shaft casing, where the block 47’ supports
the weight of the section of shaft 39’ by means
of the collar 48’, connected by a pin and key
as before.”’ :
This feature is again emphasized on the same
page, lines 97-104:
“It will be noticed that the weight of the
pump and its shaft is supported at each end of
the sections of the casing by the blocks 47, 47’,
ete. By reason of this arrangement the pump
shaft and the shaft casing can be made in sepa-
rable sections, and consequently the pump may
be inserted at any desired depth and the parts
assembled before putting them into the well.”
Defendants have never used the loose sectional
construction of shaft nor the bearing blocks.
Moreover, this is another abandoned and imprac-
tical feature of Layne.
(See Layne’s testimony (R. 597) ):
“XQ. Now, referring further to the same
drawing, have vou ever used the sectional shaft,
39 and 39’, with loose sliding connections at their
abutting end? In other words, spline the shaft
and giving the sections a limited movement with
relation to one another?
‘A. In our construction we have used in
one or two instances a method of that kind, but
And R. 598 and 599:
doned features nor any equivalent therefor.
30
our general practice is to use the screw and flat
coupling.”’
““XQ. Such a loose coupling method would
not permit of suspending the impeller from the
top, would it?
‘“‘A. No, sir. That was intended for deep
lifts, where the proposition was supposed to
have been carried in different loads.
“XQ. Consequently, this method of impeller
suspension and the shaft coupling have never
been put into use by you?
‘“*A. Only in a few instances,
“XQ. It never has become your commercial
product ?
‘*A, No, sir.
‘““XQ. You have never used the thrust col-
lars, then, 48 and 48’, have you?
‘‘A. Not for thrust purposes, but for the
shaft bearing purposes we have used them ex-
clusively.
“XQ. You have used a single thrust collar,
like 48, in Figure 5, at the bottom of your pump
structure ?
‘“‘A. We have never used the thrust collars
in the two, only in very few instances; we have
only used the collars connecting the shaft by
thread methods.
‘*XQ. And you have done away with the use
of the thrust collars, 48, that we see working on
the bearings?
‘“‘A. So far as contracting the bearings, we
have never used that as a commercial product,
containing the bearings for thrust purposes.”
Defendants have never used any of these aban-
ee ake
DEOL DB ise tt tl SE ett ORE Ne WOLD 6 He Dt Poss
_— Fe eth Lett Nites}
avis nin aa tae!
T
13,467.
2 SHEL
MIP CEs Ble Si ides 4% ae eee mye ais —_ '
PAS STD Sa i Ee ER Mien (RRS: i aes keene sien ie iene .
zg
(ATTORNEY
foal dayne INVENTOR.
o
oe
§ °
¢ -
et
hla &
‘ ze :
p< ms
<2
as % \S
su = %
bad a ewe apolar e eee %
a 2 -
Gf \ iz g = ~ wean nee
Zee cn Yl ai— _'f
se «- CMG |.) Pas
S iy J
ee bo? eee
a =
ae 5
Oe _
Com
fo-) |
: ee eee
z Perro,
or a
5 j
—
a
” y
v.
E rd
Y,
: 4
Zz :
tf.
o wa
ot z
=
od
31
THE ABANDONED FEATURES.
Layne’s structure, stripped of the abandoned
features above, leaves a skeleton differentiated with
difficulty, if at all, from the prior art.
LAYNE’S COMMERCIAL PUMP BUILT UNDER A
SUBSEQUENT PATENT.
It is quite proper to point out that the actual
Layne commercial structure introduced in evidence
by plaintiff as Exhibit 8, but not explained, and
claimed to be its present commercial pump, is not
made according to the patent in suit, but is made
under the later Layne Reissue patent No. 13,467,
dated September 24th, 1912, (see cut on opposite
page). This patent was identified (R. 587-8) as
being one of the patents under which the commercial
pump is marked as patented. Claim 12 thereof
reads as follows:
‘12. In combination, a pump, a drive shaft
therefor, a series of bearings for the shaft, a
shaft casing inclosing the shaft and support-
ing the bearings and preventing access of the
fluid while being pumped to such shaft and
bearings, and a discharge casing inclosing the
shaft casing whereby the fluid from the pump
is carried upward in contact with the exterior
of the shaft casing.”
If we were to substitute this reissue for the patent
in suit we might see some possible basis for the
claim of ‘commercial success” and for the trial
court’s view as to what constituted the Layne
‘‘concept.’’
32
THE LAYNE FILE WRAPPER.
(Defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘D,’’ R. 957.)
The Layne file wrapper is here referred to in
connection with the limitations imposed upon the
Layne patent by the actions in the Patent Office
and as showing what Layne and his attorney con-
sidered Layne’s ‘‘dominant idea’’ in securing his
patent. It was the combined feature of a shaft
enclosing casing, wherein its bearings ‘‘are,’’ to
quote applicant’s attorney, ‘‘completely closed off
from the water in the well’’ with ‘‘the line shaft
supported at various points in the various sections”’ -
and with means for supporting the pump ‘‘at any
desired point in the well.’? The court in the Van
Ness and Getty cases has pointed out that this
latter feature of the adjustable support in the
well means the complicated and discarded system
of wedges.
Several patents were cited against Layne, but
the only ones to which we need to call attention is
the Crannell patent in evidence as defendants’
Exhibit ‘‘G,”’ supra. The Eisler patent, post,
which is here in evidence, was apparently over-
looked by the Patent Office. The fact that Eisler
was not cited weakens rather than strengthens the
presumption that accompanies the issuance of a
patent in favor of its validity. (American Co. vs.
Sample, 130 Fed. 145, 149 (C. C. A. 3rd Cireuit).)
The Layne patent application was filed April
28th, 1903. That is the very earliest date, as we
will see, that Layne can claim as his invention.
33
As originally filed the application contained twenty-
four claims, all of which, except six, were rejected.
Although this rejection was on June 2d, 1903, no
leply was filed thereto until January 30th, 1904,
and considerably subsequent to the issuance of the
Alvord patents and what is significant, it was subse-
quent to the Pabst installation of the Byron Jackson
eneased line shaft pump at Milwaukee.
LAYNE’S AMENDMENT OF JANUARY 30th, 1904.
In this amendment of January 30th, 1904, Layne
amend] — filing several new claims
including ‘pfsent claim 20 in controversy, but did
not accompany this amendment with any Supple-
mental Oath. It is to be presumed as a matter
of law that Layne and his attorney had meanwhile
heeome acquainted with the Alvord patents which
had issned during the year 1903, and applied for
hefore Layne’s application, and had noted that
Alvord showed a shaft tubing but that this shaft
tubing was not “entirely closed off from the water
in the well,’ but had openings in it through
Which water could pass. These Alvord patents be-
ing public decuments, Layne and his attorney were
charged with notice of them and of their contents.
Again, in view of the correspondence passing
between the Byron Jackson Iron Works and the
Peden Iron & Steel Co.. evidenced by the letter in-
troduced by plaintiff herein (R. 873), and in view
of certain other correspondence between the parties
34
which plaintiff did not see fit to introduce, and, in
view of Mr. Bowler’s naive letter of November
13th, 1911, to ‘‘Friend Layne” (R.870), it is
reasonably inferred that Layne had wind of the
Pabst installation where there was an enclosed line
shaft primarily designed to close off the shaft bear-
ings from the water in the well.
There was in the Pabst case the very intent and
purpose of closing off the water in the well from the
oil in the shaft casing, as far as practically pos-
sible and by means substantially identical with de-
fendants’ present mode, for in Pabst, as will be
pointed out, the oil passed out from the casing in-
to the well through drawn tubes (R. / 62. ) just
as in defendants’ case. Whatever the presumptions
and inferences are, Layne’s claims, and particularly
claim 20, had their first concept at this time of the
Pabst installation and before Layne’s amendment
of January 30, 1904.
The significance of the foregoing finds its parallel
in the recent case of Superior Skylight Co. vs.
August Kuhnla, Inc., 265 Fed. 282, 284 (quoting
from Lyon Non-Skid Co. vs. Hartford, 247 Fed.
524) wherein Judge Manton said at page 536:
***A series of amendments were filed within
a month in the Fageol application before the
Lyon patent was issued, in an effort to secure
claims broad enough to affect the Lyon patent,
and in this way many, if not all, the claims in
suit were inserted and radically modified. This
may have been brought about by the successful
and extensive use of the Lyon bumper. The
court should not lend its aid to such an effort
of an enterprising patentee. Lovell vs. Oriental
Co., 231 Fed. 719, 146 C. C. A. 3. The Lyon con-
ot
struction and operation was new in Lyon’s work
in 1911, and is covered by his patent in suit.
Lyon gave his valuable invention to the public.
Fageol gave a different type of rigid bar bump-
er which proved to be impracticable and a fail-
ure commercially. It inevitably follows that
Lyon should have full credit for the success and
the protection of the court.’ ”’
To that case we might add the observations of
the Court of Appeals of the 2nd circuit in Stafford,
Ine. vs. Thaddeus Davids Ink Co., 264 Fed. 111,
114:
‘‘As for the rest the plain effort of plaintiff to
‘lick into shape’ some new claims that would
read directly on what a competitor had just put
out, is not attractive, and justly leads any court
to scan closely claims so composed’’ (citing
Lyon, ete., Co. vs. Hartford, (D. C.) 247 Fed.
524, affirmed 250 Fed. 1021, 162 C. C. A. 664).
Reverting to the File Wrapper, Layne’s attorney
argues in his amendment of January 30th, 1904:
‘*The examiner’s attention is first called to
the fact that in applicant’s device the line shaft
and all its bearings are completely closed off
from the water in the well and that the line shaft
is supported at various points in the various
sections, and that either in the device of Figure
) or in the device of Figure 10, the outlet for the
water from the pump is independent of the eas-
ing which surrounds the line shaft, and in case
the pump casing is sealed off completely as in
Figure 10 the discharge may be through the up-
per end of the well casing and still the water
does not come in contact with any of the bear-
ings or the line shaft.’’ (Italics ours.)
ene eee LP MOIR POEL. EL LEI > EG
36
These admissions in the Patent Office should be
regarded as the expressions of a competent expert,
Sugar Co. vs. Yaryan, 43 Fed. 140.
As further emphasizing this ‘‘entirely enclosed’
feature, Layne says:
‘‘It is not supposed that this applicant is the
inventor of the broad idea of using a wedge for
fixing a device at a particular point in the well
casing, but only that he is the originator of the
idea of operating and tightening mechanism for
the pump by means entirely enclosed in the
shaft casing and not exposed to the deleterious
effect of the water being pumped through the
well.’’ (Italics ours.)
(Note: This shows another reason for ‘‘entire
closure’’ in that the tightening means for the lower
gland are not exposed.)
And still not to lose sight of this important
feature he says further:
‘‘Tn fact none of the references show a closed
driving shaft casing which extends from the
top of the well to the pump and being affixed to
the pump in the well casing. These two fea-
tures are necessarily combined because the
essential thing of the invention is the drawing
up of the water from below the pump and dis-
charging it through an outlet which is inde-
pendent from the casing enclosing the bearings,
whereby the bearings are entirely protected
from the flowing water.”’ (Italic ours.)
(Note: ‘Protection from flowing water’’; not
sand, but flowing water. Western Well is not pro-
tected from ‘‘flowing water’’ though it is partially
protected, of course, from sand.)
37
“Entirely”’: If we refer to the lexicographers to
ascertain what Layne meant by the words “‘en-
tirely enclosed’? as used repeatedly in his argu-
ments above, we need but refer to the Standard
Dictionary, which thus defines the word “en-
tirely’’:
‘without diminution, exception or qualifica-
tion; wholly; completely.”’
The reference Crannell is given special con-
sideration; Layne emphasizing that Crannell
“cannot be fixed at any desired point in the well”
and that ‘‘ the lower bearings in the (Crannell)
pump are directly exposed to all the sand and
detritus in the water’? (so is the Western Well
Works for that matter).
As to the Northam patent, which we have in-
troduced simply to show a jointed shaft for a
turbine pump, from all appearances, seems adapt-
able to bored wells, Layne’s attorneys argued be-
fore the Patent Office :
‘It does not appear how the Northam pump
can be held to show an extensible shaft inas-
much as the shaft that belongs to any one of
the pumps is not extensible and the only way
to extend the shaft at all is to put in a new
pump. In other words each one of the pumps
and its shaft is independently supported, but
there is no extensibility of the shaft to any one
of the pumps.”’
(It would appear to be true that the Western Well
Works pump, being supported as it is by the dis-
charge column, is independent of the shaft. Each
POEL EP!
is independently supported and our shaft is no
more extensible than Northam’s.)
We thus see that applicant presented as the
essence of his invention the drawing up of water
from below the pump and discharging it through
an outlet which is independent from the casing
enclosing the bearings, by means of a driving shaft
easing 20 closed by stuffing boxes 40 and 51 anda
separate and independent discharge pipe 23, to
gether with means, such as the wedges 33, for fixing
the pump within the well casing.
After various colloquies extending over a period
of a couple of years, and after the Byron Jackson
unpatented pump had received wide vogue, the
Layne patent issued on May 29th, 1906.
LAYNE A MERE PAPER PATENT.
From the File Wrapper and the surrounding cit
cumstances in connection with this application ani
the fact that the patented structure is uncommer
cial and impractical, it is apparent that the patent
in suit is a mere paper patent at best and must bk
narrowly construed and however construed in the
light of the art and of the proceedings in tht
Patent Office defendants’ structure cannot be hel
to be an infringement.
Plaintiff’s efforts to expand its patent beyo
its true meaning recalls the case of Detmold
Reeves, et al., 1 Fisher 127, 131, where Kane, J
took occasion to say:
39
“But the contract of the public is not with
him who has discovered, but with him who also
makes his discovery usefully known. If he has
discovered much and discloses little—if there
has been revealed to him one of the arcana of
nature, and he communicates to the world only
one or more of its derivative and secondary
truths, he patents no more than he has pro-
claimed. He will not be allowed afterward,
when the extent of his right shall be the subject
of controversy, either by expanding into a
general expression what was limited before
in a particular form, or, by tracing out for us
the line that leads back from consequences to
remote causes, to initiate us, inferentially, into
the radical mystery of his invention, and then
argue that he had described it by implication
from the first, and so claimed ownership of it in
his patent.”’
PRIOR ART.
History of the Small Bore Deep Well Centrifugal
Pumping Mechanism.
Plaintiff would have the court believe that cen-
trifugal pumping mechanism for deep wells of small
bore was unknown prior to the date of Layne’s
alleged invention. With this in view plaintiff in-
troduced a_ self-serving drawing of a pit pump
(plaintiff’s Exhibit 2) and Layne testified, but
without corroboration, that this represented the
general practice prior to his supposed invention.
There is not only ample evidence in the record to
show that small bore wells, and deep well suspended
Pumps were old before Layne, but to show the
“pit pump” is a popular favorite and rival to both
plaintiff and defendants’ pumps today (R. 784-6).
40
British patent No. 24,480 to Mather, dated
January 19th, 1895(R. 1040) (see cut opposite) shows
a deep well of small bore provided with a centrifugal
or rotary pump which is operated by a shaft driven
from the surface of the ground. The specification
states:
‘‘My invention relates to apparatus for
pumping water from well bores so arranged
that the pump can be readily adjusted in posi-
tion and power to suit greater or less depths
of bore.
‘‘For this purpose I extenc down the bore a
pipe which is the delivery pipe of the pump
and in this pipe there is a spindle which is
driven at the top of the well by any suitable
motor, and which works a rotary pump oF
special construction attached to the pipe.’’
British patent No. 2774 to Thomson, dated No-
vember 13th, 1860 (R. 1052) (see cut opposite) also
shows a rotary or centrifugal pump which is adapted
to be inserted in a deep well of small bore. It is
suspended from the top of the well by the discharge
casing A and is driven by a sectional shaft which is
supported in bearings b, d and c. The specification
states:
‘Figure 3 in the accompanying Drawing
shows one of my improved pumps with two
revolving wheels placed in connection with each
other, in such a way that the water discharged
by the lower wheel passes into the suction part
of the upper wheel; by this means I can raise
water or other liquids to any height with the
same speed of revolution of the wheel that
would be required for half the height with one
wheel; and, if necessary, three or more wheels
may be placed in conjunction in a similar man-
OLD EXAMPLES OF PENDENT STRUCTURES FOR BORED WELLS
Patented July 29. 1902.
IVENS, Dec'd.
4K. IVENS. Administrator
PUMP MECHANISM.
Application Aled Apr 90, 1001)
2 Sheets—Sheet 2
. ‘ AN ‘ Ps . - * A ANNA *
2S Sa ESR ARRAN \ x \
RORY, eS FRAY QOH BOY WA .
Lid eG abate tite Peis Tbe chistes
»
TTORNE XS
3 pees
Edmund jHlens
ooo Ul
onan
6688 Re Bi ee ee Sas
Pie Pens
Ce ee
CRANNELL. PATENT
Defendant's Exhibit
R. 1025
“G,"
41
ner with the effect of still further reducing the
necessary speed of rotation.’’
United States Patent No. 705,844 to Ivens, July
29th, 1902 (R. 1058) (see cut opposite) also shows a
small bore deep well pumping mechanism. The
specification states:
‘“‘My present invention is in the nature of an
improved centrifugally-operating pumping
mechanism adapted for use in deep wells and
for lifting water from bayous and lagoons for
irrigating purposes; and it comprehends, ge-
nerically, a casing having a lift-pipe and a dis-
charge-pipe connected thereto, a centrifugally-
operating pump-disk held within the casing, and
a specially-arranged means for passing the
water through the easing in an annular and up-
wardly inclined direction.”’
It is interesting to note that Layne’s patent
nowhere refers to a deep well.
Plaintiff argues that these prior pendent pump
structures fitted in deep wells of small bore failed
to afford adequate protection to the bearings of the
line shaft. Such an argument overlooks the fact
that protecting casings for this purpose are old and
Well known in the same art (see post, for instance,
United States patent No. 425,933 to Crannell, April
15th, 1890, and No. 522,518 to Eisler, July 3rd,
1894),
THE CRANNELL PATENT.
(Defendants’ Exhibit “G.’’)
The Crannell patent, a cut of Figure 3 of which
1s shown on the opposite page, is described with
respect to its pertinent features by Prof. Lesley
as follows (R. 184):
‘*Figure 3, No. 1, shows a shaft-enclosing cas-
ing; No. 2 shows what is termed in the patent
a evlinder which corresponds to the pump bowl
of the patent in suit, No. 21. No. 3 shows what
is called a diaphragm plate forming a closure
between the pump bow! and the shaft-enclosing
casing. No. 4 is termed in the specification an
aperture through which the shaft may pass.
The specification states that the shaft is prop-
erly packed at this point, that is, at the bottom
of the line shaft. No. 5 is the shaft which is
surrounded by the enclosing casing, No. 1. No.
14 is the runner or impeller; in this instance it
is an impeller of the screw type, not of the cen-
trifugal type.”
Concerning Crannell the court in the Getty case
said (262 Fed. 141, 143):
‘‘The Layne patent too nearly resembles the
Crannell patent to be called a pioneer patent.”
And Judge Jack in his opinion has said:
‘“‘The Crannell apparatus, which was not 4
commercial success, provided for a closed cas
ing around the shaft transmitting power to a
rotary pump, but did not provide intermediate
bearings along the line of the shaft. This ab
sence of intermediate bearings is practically the
only difference in principle between the two
mechanisms in so far as claims 9 and 20 are
concerned. It is urged by the defendant that
the adding of intermediate bearings to prevent
the shaft from whipping does not involve i
vention, that it is something that would occur
to anyone skilled in the art, and that, likewise,
the method of oiling by letting the oil run down
from bearing to bearing, would oceur to anyone,
2 ERED FH Oe Sy sen
43
and had always been the method of oiling ver-
tical shafts.
‘“‘The court is much impressed with this ar-
gument. The insertion of additional bearings
to prevent whipping of the shaft where the dis-
tance between bearings is too great, is as simple
and natural a thing to do as the putting in a
fence of extra posts to prevent sagging of a
barbed wire, where the posts of the panels are
too far apart. Were the question a new one,
I should be inclined to hold the patent invalid,
but the same issue was raised and directly
passed on by this court and by the Court of Ap-
peals for this circuit, in the Van Ness case sus-
taining the patent.
‘**Tt is contended by the defendant herein that
the evidence in the Van Ness ease was to the
effect that the Crannell pump would not work,
whereas, by physical demonstration on the trial
of this case, the contrary was shown, and the
court therefore should not feel bound by the rul-
ing in the Van Ness case. The opinion in the
Van Ness case, however, does not appear to have
been based on the evidence that the Crannell
patent would not work.’’ (Italies ours.)
If it is urged that the Crannell patent is merely
a paper patent, that is met by the holding of eur“
Circuit Court of Appeals in Wonder Mfg. Co. vs.
Block, 249 Fed. 748, 750, where Judge Gilbert said:
‘It is contended, also, that the Nathan pat-
ent is without probative value, for the reason
that it is but a paper patent, and that there is
no evidence that the invention has ever been
used. But that fact does not affect its value
as evidence upon the question of infringement.”’
As a consequence one of the patents in that suit
was held void for lack of invention over Nathan
even though Nathan had not been pleaded.
44
THE EISLER PATENT.
The Eisler patent and a model of same are in
evidence, respectively, as defendants’ Exhibits
“FR” and ‘‘X’’; the patent drawing being shown
on the opposite page. Concerning Eisler, Prof.
Lesley says (R. 185-187) :
“This is a model (defendants’ Exhibit ‘X’)
of the Eisler patent as disclosed by the drawing,
particularly with reference to Figures 1 and 4,
and by the specifications which follow on the
succeeding pages. There is provided in this
structure a column construction which, as the
inventor states, is supported by means of four
columns, numbered here 6. To these are fas-
tened an outer casing, No. 7, and an inner cas-
ing, which is numbered, as in the patent, No. 4.
There is provided a shaft, whieh is suitably sup-
ported by bearings, No. 19, No. 23, 18 and 17 in
the bottom. These bearings are carried upon
floors Nos. 9, 10, 11 and 12, and also No. 8. These
floors, as stated by the inventor, are spaced at
suitable intervals around the casing to prop-
erly steady and line the shaft. The shaft is pro-
vided with vertical aljustment by means of set
collars, No. 20 and 22, which may be adjusted in
position, and thereby the shaft raised or low-
ered, and fixed in any desired position, and any
vertical motion prevented; a further set collar
is particularly called attention to at the bottom
—over the bottom bearing—which, as the inven-
tor says, is designed to exclude the sand. Be-
tween the inner casing, No. 4, which fits into
an enclosed shaft and the outer casing, No. 7,
are what are called water passages in what we
would term the water discharge column, which
provides for the passage of water upward as it
is impelled by the runner of the pump. The
water is drawn into the pump through ports in
the side of the outer casing, entering the suc-
(Ho Model.)
S. N. EISLER.
ROTARY PUMP.
No. 622,518.
ewe sses
Aya ily
= Cook.
Patented July 3, 1894.
Suvewror.
SrephewkSi ser.
” Lisanti
Artorney,
EEE ~_
TE PLS STS LET YE Ret ER Rt MERC
tion chamber just below the floor, numbered 11.
It then passes upward through a central port
and by the action of the impeller, which is shown
here as No. 17, is forced out the port, out the
bottom of the shaft-enclosing casing, into the
passage which leads upward. He ealls atten-
tion to the fact that this casing extends above
the outer casing, so that any water that comes
up these passages is spilled over here, and not
into the casing around the shaft. A lubrieat-
ing feature, to which he calls particular atten-
tion, is provided, a pipe not numbered in this
exhibit—I believe the pipe is 26—which has
branch pipes, and they are numbered 27, 28, 29,
and they lead to the various bearings, even to
the bottom-most bearing of the pump. There
are shown in the model and in the patent draw-
ings the intercepting plates No. 31; they are
shown in section here; thev extend inward rad-
ially from the corner of the shaft-enclosing cas-
ing, extended downward, and are designed to
perform a similar function as that of the so-
called diffusion vanes of the more modern tur-
hine pump. The inventor states without them
the water would probably cireulate continuous-
lv in there. It appears that he did not know
the entire theory of the turbine pump when he
made this design. There are provided in this
structure three functions: exclusion of water
and detritus from the shaft, and positioning and
alignment of the bearings for a shaft, and in
this case a means for lubrication which is not, in
itself, the shaft-enclosina casing.” (Italics
ours. )
The fact that the Eisler patent may be a so-called
paper patent does not prevent its being considered
a good reference for everything that it discloses.
(Block vs. Wonder, C. C. A., 9th Cir., 249 F. 748.)
—_
46
Further than that, the Eisler patent is entitled
to additional consideration by reason of the fact
that it was not cited by the Patent Office in con-
nection with the Layne application.
As said by the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Third Circuit in American Soda Fountain Co. ys.
Sample, 1380 Fed. 145, 149:
‘“‘We do not agree with the contention that
the fact that the file wrapper discloses the pat-
ent to have been granted as first applied for,
without any references, adds any force to the
presumption of novelty arising from the grant.
On the contrary, we think the force of that pre-
sumption is much diminished, if not destroyea,
by the lack of any reference by the Examiner to,
or consideration of, the ‘Clark’ patents.”’
As for being entitled to claim credit for the com-
mercial development of the small bore deep well
pumping mechanism Layne is hopelessly outclassed.
The testimony of Daniel W. Mead and John W.
Alvord, two civil engineeys of high standing, shows
clearly in what mazner the commercial develop-
ment of this type of pumping mechanism received
its start.
Mr. Mead testified at R. 41-42:
‘*Well, I am obliged to refresh my memory in
regard to the date of a paper that was prepared
by Nicholas Simin, who was a civil engineer, an
engineer of the water works of Moscow, Russia.
He came to this country in 1901
. Mr. Simin read a paper on the water
supply of Moscow, that may be seen in the Pro-
ceedings of the American Waterworks Associa-
47
tion, 1901, pages 33 to 41. In this paper Mr.
Simin described certain centrifugal pumps
which had been installed by a manufacturing
concern, Farcoe, | think it is, of Paris, France,
installed by this company in the Moseow water-
works for raising water from deep wells to the
surface; which consisted, as I recall it, of a
single centrifugal pump, driven at a high rate
of speed, which was sufficient to pump the water
for some considerable distance from below the
surface to the surface.
‘On account of the problem which was con-
tinually before my office at this time of secur-
ing quantities of water from wells of this na-
ture, and the difficulty previously mentioned
due to reciprocating machinery and its con-
stant wear and breakage, the method used in
Moscow appealed to me as of considerable inter-
est. In that connection I wrote to the Byron
Jackson Machine Works, or to Mr. Byron Jack-
son, who had manufactured pumps for me be-
fore, and inquired as to whether he would un-
dertake to manufacture a pump of generally the
same character as— . . . those they used in the
Moscow waterworks.”
(Mr. Mead’s correspondence with Byron Jackson
will shortly be referred to.)
Mr. Alvord likewise gives credit to the article
which appeared in the proceedings of the American
Waterworks Association describing the Moscow
project. His testimony is as follows:
“The matter of the deep well pump was one
which presented itself to my mind during the
summer of 1901. There was obviously a need for
better means for lifting water from deep arte-
sian wells in Northern Illinois, and the region
centering there, and there was no adequate ap-
OPEN G MEN DARDEN re A MAC VATE I GA PT INN 0 PRI VNR TO TARE > esata ar
48
paratus at that time which would lift large
quantities of water economically from such
wells. My attention was first definitely called to
the possibility of such an apparatus by a paper
published [851] in the American Water Works
Convention in the Summer of 1901, in which an
attempt at Moscow, Russia, was the subject of
a paper, and there was deseribed there certain
pumps inserted in wells for this purpose. It
appeared to me, from a study of this paper,
that these pumps were defective and could be
improved upon, and during that vear I revolved
the matter over considerably. In about Febru-
ary, 1902, I was engaged by the President of
the Chicago Clearing & Transfer Co.. having
large property interests southwest of Chieago
and outside of the city limits, beyond the reach
of any ordinary water supply, to investigate
and report to him on the best methods of draw:
ing water from wells in that neighborhood. I
advised Mr. H. H. Porter, the president of the
company, that this was a problem which was
difficult because no appliance was then on the
market which would adequately do this work,
and that it was obviously desirable to invent
and originate some appliance for the purpose.
Mr. Porter encouraged me to look into the mat-
ter further, and on or about April 8th, as dis-
closed by me in former testimony at a former
hearing, my diary shows that I adopted a defin-
ite idea for the purpose, and a day later dis-
closed this same to Prof. Daniel W. Mead, Pro-
fessor of Hydraulic and Sanitary Engineering
of University of Madison, Wisconsin. Some-
time between the 8th of April and the 14th, I
made certain sketches in a note-book in which I
was recording investigations at Clearing for
such a device. The first— There are three
sketches in this note-book, and the first two of
them I identify as being between the 8th and
ioe Soden
49
the 14th of April, 1902, because on the second
page of the note-book I find the date reading as
follows: ‘From Mr. Shire April 7, 1902.’ Mr.
Shire being the [352] Chief Engineer of the
Chicago Clearing & Transfer Co. at that time.
On the page following the second sketch I find
an entry reading as follows : ‘From Lawrence
Machine Company April 17, 1902.’ The first of
these sketches shows a horizontal section of a
deep well with an inclosed shaft in the center,
the shaft being 1 ineh in diameter, the tube sur-
rounding and inclosing the shaft being 17% inch-
es outside diameter, and the well being 584 ineh-
es internal diameter. The apparent purpose of
this drawing was to compute the area available
for the flow of water after inclosing a shaft in
the center of the well. The second sketch, two
pages following in the same note-book, shows
two vertical sections of a shaft and its inclosed
casing. The section on the left shows the shaft
with a coupling, an inclosed casing with the
coupling, a bearing upon which the shaft re-
volves, and a serew device by which such jn-
closed shaft and easing ean be adjusted so as to
be vertical within a well whose walls are not ex-
actly vertical. The drawing on the right also
shows a vertical shaft, an inclosed casing with a
shaft coupling, a casing coupling with interior
screw coupling, and a wooden bearing upon
which the shaft revolves.”
The sketches referred to by Mr. Alvord are in evi-
dence as defendants’ Exhibit A-4. Mr. Alvord is
the patentee of United States Patents Nos. 735,690,
735,691 and 735,692 of August 11th, 1903, to which
reference will be made later.
In all of Mr. Alvord’s patents he refers to the
fact that he is dealing with pumps for deep wells,
100 feet or more in depth, and in each of his patents
he shows a protecting casing for the drive shaft.
50
LAYNE’S CONCEPTION ALLEGED TO HAVE OCCURRED IN LATE
SUMMER OF 1902 BUT NOT PROVEN.
Layne at this time was working in the rice fields
of Texas and perhaps was also familiar with the
Moscow project. The earliest date claimed by
Layne for conception of his alleged invention was
the late summer of 1902, and as to this the showing
is woefully weak. No drawings, models nor sketches
are offered to substantiate this date. Layne’s sole
corroboration is a witness by the name of Woodburn
who testified at R. 861-62 concerning an alleged con-
versation with Layne and some ‘‘pencil marks on
the side of the building’’ made at the time.
Strong suspicion attaches to this testimony for the
reason that Woodburn recalled nothing whatever
about the wedge system which makes up 90% of the
Layne patent and he attributes functions to the shaft
enclosing casing which are not specified in the
patent.
There is nothing in the record showing activity on
Layne’s part from the time of the alleged barn-door
sketch of 1902 until he filed his application on April
28th, 1903.
LAYNE I8 LIMITED TO APRIL 28th, 1903 (His Filing Date)
AS HIS DATE OF INVENTION.
Woodburn seeks to fix the conversation taking
place in 1902 by a recently discovered memorandum
book whose character and existence and custody re
main unexplained.
Paton
Ltd
WIOH SPEED ROTARY POMP
OPP COT 9 Fikee © ’
‘so8
MEARS FOR ALININ
a
(sal Elpace
eo)
o0 wees
51
‘Where the date of use of an alleged antici-
pating device is shown beyond doubt, the bur-
den rests on a subsequent patentee to carry his
invention back to an earlier date, and for that
purpose oral testimony alone is not sufficient.”’
National Machine Corp. Ine. y. Benthall Ma-
chine Co., 241 Fed. 72.
See also the observations of Mr. Justice Bradley
in Atlantic Works v. Brady, 107 U. 8. 102, 27 L. Ed.
440:
‘‘Interested as he is in the result of the suit,
his own testimony cannot be allowed to prevail
against a course of conduct so utterly at vari-
ance with it. It may be true; but we cannot
give it effect against what he himself did, and
did not do, without disregarding the ordinary
laws that govern human conduct. . . . Suffi-
cient appears, however, notwithstanding the
evidence adduced to the contrary, consisting
mostly of the testimony of the complainant
himself, to convince us that Brady derived his
whole idea from the suggestions of General Mc-
Alester;”? .. .
Re: Alvord Patents.
ALVORD PRIOR INVENTIONS.
The deposition of Mr. Alvord, of Chicago, Illi-
nois, is in evidence on the question of prior inven-
tion. (The court, of course, will not confuse this
defense with that of ‘anticipation’ and **prior
publication’’.) Certified copies of the file histories
of Alvord’s three patents (see opposite page), are
in evidence, not for the purpose of showing ‘‘an-
ticipation’? or ‘prior publication,” but “‘prior in-
Re Ri tah OV SERS SPR NIRS TORIES IY ln OE NO RLIE LS BG De na ARIA RRs AWS RN ne Se ai
52
vention’. The grant of a patent raises a presump-
tion that the patentee was the original inventor of
the thing patented and the invention was made
at the time the application was filed, and one claim-
ing priority of invention has the burden of prov-
ing, by evidence which is clear and certain, that the
invention was conceived and reduced to practice
by another prior to the date of application. (Con-
solidated Ry. Electric Lighting & Equipment Co.
v. Adams & Westlake Co., 161 Fed. 343, C. C. A.
7th Circuit.)
The dates of application of the several Alvord
patents are as follows:
Filed Nov. 17, 1902—No. 735,690—Issued Aug.
11, 1903 (R. 930).
Filed Dec. 24, 1902—No. 735,691—Issued Aug.
11, 1903 (R. 935).
Filed Mar. 30, 1903—No. 735,692—Issued Aug.
11, 1903 (R. 944).
The ‘“‘shaft casing’’ of the first patent (see op-
posite page) is number 7 in the drawings; the pat-
ent saying (p. 1, lines 54-63) :
‘The shaft is inclosed in a shaft-tube 7, made
in suitable lengths coupled together and consid-
erably less in diameter than the well-casing, 80
as to leave an annular space 8 between them for
the water to flow up through. At suitable points
in the tube are bearings for the shaft, consist-
ing preferably, of a bushing 9, rigidly secured
in the tube, as by the serew-threads shown, and
slightly tapered internally.’’
53
Moreover, practically all the claims of Alvord,
feature ‘“‘a tube inclosing said shaft’’ (claims 2, 3,
4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12). Thus claim 7 for ex-
ample:
“7. The combination with a well-casing, of
a rotary pump-shaft therein, a tube inclosing
said shaft, bearings in said tube, braces hinged
to said tube, and means for locking said braces,”’
This patent (No. 735,690) has to do with the very
thirg Layne lays such great store on in his patent:
“enclosure,’’ ‘“‘bearings in the tube,”? and ‘“align-
ment. ”’
The second Alvord patent has the protective shaft
tubing 17.
In the third Alvord patent the shaft inclosing
tube is numbered 3; the patentee saying (p. 2, lines
4-6) :
“The rotatable pump-shaft 1 passes down
through the uptake or delivery-pipe 2, being
preferably inelosed in a casing 3.”’
The Alvord defense takes on added interest in
this suit over and against anything appearing in
the prior litigation where Alvord was relied on to
show anticipation; for as Mr. Alvord testified (R.
377) :
“On the 2d of February, 1920, Mr. J. B.
Harmon, whose ecard left with me shows him to
have been sales engineer of the Layne & Bowler
Co. with headquarters at Memphis, Tenn., called
at my office and took up the matter of my pat-
ents in connection with his own company’s op-
eration. Mr. Harmon represented that, in his
opinion, Messrs. Layne & Bowler were develop-
ing their ideas in the Patent Office on or about
the time when I was at work similarly in devel-
oping my ideas. Mr. Harmon inquired what I
would expect to receive for my patents in the
matter and I named him a price of $5,000.
Thereupon he asked me if I would give him a
short option on that amount, and I gave him a
thirty-day option for the purchase of the pat-
ents. Mr. Harmon represented to me that those
patents would be quite valuable to his company;
that they were doing a large business in the sale
of these pumps, amounting, as he said, to some
$3,000,000 per vear, and that the rice industry
could not have been promoted without the use of
the pumps in question and the improvements
which they and I had made. He further stated
that if the Layne & Bowler Co. should own my
patents they could undoubtedly collect royalty
from other companies who were using the same,
and that he could recommend to Mr. Lavne
promptly the purchase of my three patents.
Whereupon I had written out my proposition
in writing, signed it and gave it to him on that
date.’
The letter referred to is in evidence as defend-
ants’ Exhibit ‘‘A12”’ and set out in the record at
R. 655 reads:
“In accordance with our conversation this
afternoon, I would propose to sell the Layne &
Bowler Company all right, title and interest
which I have in the patents relating to deep
well pump shaft alignment and other related
contrivances with reference to vertical centrif-
ugal pump equipment, all for the sum of $500
cash, with the understanding that these patents
be used by your company, being known as the
Alvord patents numbered as per Patent Office;
and the further understanding that this prope
sition is accepted within thirty days from the
a)
date of your offer. I will further support said
patents by competent testimony in court, if
called upon to do so, at the rate of $100 per day
and necessary expenses.”’
This interview and letter of Mr. Harmon (oceur-
ring after defendant’s notice of taking testimony)
taken in connection with Harmon’s interference
with the witness, Classman, and the reluctance of
these men to testify, particular] y Alvord (R. 305-351
ine.), until the option expired March 2, 1920, and
which ordinarily would have carried defendants’
time beyond Rule 47) seem to point their own moral.
Layne’s patent, both as to anticipation and as to
the presence of invention, must be judged upon the
basis of prior knowledge and invention of which
Alvord’s applications are a part.
Concrete Appliance Co. v. Mienken et al., 267
Fed. 958 (C. C. A., 6th Cir.) ;
Lemley v. Dobbins, 243 Fed. 39].
THE BYRON JACKSON DEFENSE.
The Byron Jackson defense and the circumstances
leading up to the Pabst installation are important
in two things:
(1) As illustrating the problem of arranging for
oil lubrication of a shaft in a well and at the same
time keeping the oil from getting into the well; and
(2) its bearing on the question of infringement.
56
Unquestionably if the Layne patent is to be inter-
preted as broadly covering any kind of a line shaft
with a tube around it to protect the bearings from
sand and to afford a means of lubricating the shaft
bearings and without any restriction on the escape
of the oil from the tube into the water in the well,
then the Byron Jackson invention becomes import-
ant in determining the matter of priority. On the
other hand, giving the interpretation to the Layne
patent that every court before which it has come, has
given it by making the lower stuffing box an essen-
tial of the Layne closure means to provide an ‘‘air
tight’? chamber and prevent contamination of the
water by the oil, the Byron Jackson testimony still
remains important and pertinent as showing as
Judge Morrow pointed out, non-infringement by
these defendants.
Byron Jackson, it is to be remembered, was at the
time of Layne’s alleged invention a recognized autb-
ority of national reputation and a large manufac-
turer of pumping machinery. The evidence of his
thought and accomplishments along this line of deep
well pumping is shown by the depositions of Frank
H. Jackson, H. C. Robb and Daniel W. Mead; the
latter a distinguished engineer and Professor of
Hydraulic Engineering in the University of Wis-
consin; also by the correspondence passing between
Byron Jackson and his company on the one hand
and Mr. Mead and the Pabst Brewing Company on
the other.
a7
The purpose for which this. testimony was offered
originally was to show priority of invention and
priority of knowledge of the encased line shaft
problem, although it is true that Byron Jackson
never used ‘‘stuffing boxes”’ in his installations or
other means to keep in the lubricant, because he
says in a letter to Prof. Mead dated June 30th, 1903
(R. 132): .
‘“*T know of no method of retaining the oil in
the bearings and all of the waste oil is there to
pass into the water pumped.”’
And as late as September 5th, 1903, he writes:
- . » “T make no guarantee regarding oil in-
juring the water or making it in any way un-
suitable for the use of the Pabst Brewing Com-
pany.”
ws (See Judge Morrow’s opinion, R. 1146.)
If the court holds as all the other courts have
done that Layne’s invention therefore differs from
Jackson in the interposition of the lower stuffing
box 40-41 of the Layne patent to make an air-tight
oil-tight chamber and the use of mechanical oil
evacuating means, as the tube 44 and vent 52, where-
in and whereby Layne solved the problem of closure
where Jackson failed, then the Jackson defense has
served its purpose in the manner indicated in Judge
Morrow’s opinion (R. 1142-1148, inclusive).
Concerning the testimony on the subject, it is to
be pointed out that the depositions of Jackson and
Robb appear by stipulation of counsel on file, being
58
the same depositions made by these gentlemen in
the Los Angeles suit. The deposition of Mr. Mead
was taken simultaneously with the taking of his
deposition in the Los Angeles suit simply as a mat-
ter of convenience and entitling the deposition in
the respective causes.. There is no privity, nor has
there been at any time any privity between the pres-
ent defendants, or any of them, and any of the de-
fendants in the Los Angeles suit, or other litigation |
respecting this patent. It has merely happened that
in the Los Angeles suit, due to conditions of the _
Court Calendar and the practice in the Southern |
District, that that case came on for hearing and de-
cision first. As a matter of fact, the present suit
was filed before the Los Angeles suit was filed. Un-
der the circumstances your Honors are to view this
Byron Jackson knowledge as a defense entirely new
in the litigation over the Layne patent.
The correspondence passing between Byron Jack-
son, Professor Mead and the Pabst Brewing Com-
pany, supplemented by numerous working drawings, |
is represented by defendants’ Exhibits ‘‘M-1" to |
‘“*M-91"’, inclusive. The development of the en-|
cased line shaft therein is illustrated by the series
of drawings opposite.
For Byron Jackson’s description of drawing No.
1 see his letter to Mead, dated March 31st, 1902 (R.
63) Exhibit M-5.
For Byron Jackson’s description of drawing No.
2 see same letter, Jackson to Mead (R. 62) where
he says:
4 d
WH pete : bs: a
Aligning Spider— ‘fi
xP,
To ol upper bearings
ss
fo ol lower bearings
oe
Actual Pabst installation
Per Byron Jackson Biveprint
June 6, 1905
Exhibit M- 69
For description see leffer Apr £9,/903
R 164-6
em
Fig. 4.
2
Sight feed oiler ot top of
eB this pipe (See specifications) R 146
= _—— Shoft bearing
J Discharge Pipe
|_— Shaft Enclosing Pipe
or ‘Shaft Tubing”
—_— Well Casing
v7 t Oran
“— # Drain. (for escape of o'!
inte well) See specificetions
R 166
oe Stage Pump
_— Suction Casing
:
'
- 3.
-”~
of Fig 2
Pi
G.
y)
Assembled view
a4
-
"3
|— Line Shaft.
Casing.
ra
Intake.
j ( I. Sheft Enclosi
BYRON JACKSON DRAWING N® |-C-75
EXHIBIT M6-R74 - 1068
MARCH 5, 1902
R.111@ AND R649.
i901
MAY 8,
BYRON JACKSON DRAWING.
‘*T herewith inclose an illustration of a small
3 series pump on base, that will give you some
idea of it, but of course it will not give vou anv
idea of size.’’
For Professor Mead’s description of drawing No.
2 opposite (drawing No. 3 being an assembly of the
two views of No. 2) see R. 72 where he says that the
same consists of a
‘series centrifugal pumps at the bottom of the
well, or down in the well, that discharged into
a single discharge pipe, but contained an inner
pipe which in turn enclosed the shaft, the dis-
charge being outside of the inner pipe and in-
side of the outer pipe. Then the bearings were
contained inside of the outer pipe; in fact, as
[ recall it, going clear through and joining the
two pipes together and holding the shaft rigid-
ly in place. The shaft that attached to the driv-
ing head above entered the center pipe and left
it, entered the pump below and separated it
from the discharged water. So that in both
cases there was no contact between the water
discharged by the pump and the shaft.”’
This drawing, it will be observed, is more than a
year prior to Layne’s filing date.
As for drawing No. 4 (Ex. M-69) of the Pabst
actual installation see Pebst proposed agreement
of April 20th, 1903, defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘M-22”
(R. 111) where appears the first written description
of Mr. Jackson’s encased line shaft pump.
‘‘Pump—To be of the Centrifugal Series tvpe
four (4) or more steps, having a capacity of
700 gallons per minute; Revolutions not to ex-
ceed 1500 per minute. The pump shaft to be
encased in a pipe within the discharge pipe.
il
60
Bearings approximately every ten (10) feet
and suitable means provided for oiling same
which will allow no mixture of the oil and
water. Total length from bottom of suction to
discharge at top of well, 200 feet. The pump to
be suspended in the well by the discharge pipe.”
(Italics ours. )
This drawing No. 4, though dated June 8th, 1903,
is exactly deseribed in Byron Jackson’s letter to
Mead of April 29th, 1903, Exhibit ‘‘M-4’’ (R. 164-
166) where Mr. Jackson wrote deseribing the shaft-
ing as enclosed by a jointed tube that was water
and a-tight and in which there were drain pipes
to let out the oil at the bottom, thereby foreshadow-
ing defendants’ structure, saying:
“You will note that the shafting is inclosed
in a 4” pipe and intended to be water and oil
tight, and the oil fed in at the top, letting it find
its way through each bearing and down the
pipe to the pump, where there is arranged suit-
able drain pipes to permit the water to ‘drain
out of the pipe what leaks through the last
bearing of the pump where the waste oil will
also get out and be pumped through the water,
which I presume some people will object to, but
as you know, it is a very homeopathic quantity
and does no harm.’’ (Italies ours.)
_—_—_———_
BYRON JACKSON PUMP ON SALE BEFORE
LAYNE’S INVENTION.
Prior to this, as shown by defendant’s Exhibit
**M-21”’ (letter of Byron Jackson to Mead, April
15, 1903) a bargain had been struck regarding this
pump by an offer to purchase and acceptance of
61
the terms, so that we might well say that the Byron
Jackson pump was ‘‘on sale”’ as early as April 15th,
1903; this being sufficient in itself under the stat-
utes (See. 4920) to effect anticipation of Layne.
This correspondence shows due diligence on the
part of Byron Jackson.
‘And as matter of law we see no difference
between the right of a defendant to show the
time of conception of an unpatented anticipat-
ing device, as also diligence in reducing it to
practice, and the right of a plaintiff to do this
in respect of a patented devices. We conceive
this to be the necessary effect of section 4886
and section 4920, paragraphs second and fourth,
of the Federal Revised Statutes: and these stat-
tory provisions seem to have been substan-
tially complied with in the seared amd third
paragraphs of the answer when pead in con-
nection with the eighth paragraph. [t eannot
be that a patentee ean eseape the defenses either
that he ‘unjustly obtained th. patent for that
which was in fact invented by nother, who was
using reasonable diligence in adapting and per-
feeting the same’ (seeond pair, 4920), or that the
was not the original and first inventor or dis.
coverer of any material and substantial part of
the thing patented’ (fourth par. Td). whether
the anticipating object. is patented or unpat-
ented. The statute makes no distinction in this
regard; it is the fact of prior invention, not the
nature of the right under which the invented
device is held, that the statute treats as a de-
fense. As Judge Colt said in Automatie Weigh-
ing Mach. Co. v. Pneumatic Seale Corp., supra,
166 Fed. at 301, 92 C. C. A, 219 (C. C. A. 1):
‘***No sound reason has been advanced why
the doctrine of diligence should not apply to a
patentee as well as to an inventor who has not
62
secured a patent. On the other hand, any such
distinction in favor of patentees is not in har-
mony with the patent laws.’
‘‘And, when speaking of Mr. Justice Story’s
opinion in Reed v. Cutter, Judge Colt said (166
Fed. 302, 92 C. C. A. 220):
“** According to Reed v. Cutter (Fed. Cas.
No. 11,645), . . . Section 15 of the Act of 1836
(containing in substance pars. 2 and 4, Section
4920) secures to the first inventor the prior
right, provided he uses reasonable diligence in
adapting and perfecting his invention and the
rule applies to all inventors, whether patentees
or otherwise.’ ”’
20th Cent. Co. v. Loew Co., 248 F. 373,
C. C. A., 6th Cir.
THE PABST INSTALLATION A CONTINUING ACT.
‘*Indeed, the whole doctrine of conception, as
differing from reduction to practice, is excel-
lently set forth in Christie v. Seybold, 55 Fed.
69, 76, 5 C. C. A. 33, 40, by the present Chief
Justice when Circuit Judge, in saying that he
who
‘* ‘first conceives, and in a mental sense first
invents, a machine, art, or composition of
matter, may date his patentable invention
back to the time of its conception, if he con-
nects the conception with its reduction to
practice by reasonable diligence on his part,
so that they are substantially one continuous
Sr) ”* (Curtiss Corp. v. Janin, 278 Fed. 454
While the Pabst installation was not completed
until some nine months after Layne filed his ap-
63
plication, it cannot be denied that Byron Jackson
was ahead of Layne as to conception, disclosure and
drawings, assuming, of course, that there is simil-
arity between Layne’s alleged invention and that
of Byron Jackson.
It took Layne but a few days to convey his yet
immature conception to a patent attorney and get
an application for patent on file. Although this fil-
ing date gave Layne a so-called ‘‘constructive re-
duction to practice’’, it ought not to avail him as
against the practical work of Jackson where the de-
vice shown in the Layne patent is impractical and
the features giving it novelty have as Layne admits
been abandoned.
“The reason hitherto successfully urged, for
preferring Janin to Curtiss, is that Janin first
‘reduced to practice’—a phrase of which the
full meaning is alse vital. Reduction to prac-
tice is not merely a matter of construction,
building and trial, but may consist in the dis-
closure of the idea by any kind of description,
pictorial, verbal, or written, which will enable
one skilled in the art to make and use that
which is disclosed. We think a drawing may
possibly be a sufficient reduction to practice,
and an experimental machine insufficient, for
the question is one of degree, and the ultimate
test is always whether the inventor has shown
operative means to that theoretically omnipres-
ent person, the man skilled in the art. Ma-
comber, p. 68. But see Automatic, ete., Co. v.
Pneumatic, ete., Co., 166 Fed. 288; 92 ©. C. A.
206, and McCreery, ete., Co. v. Massachusetts
ete. Co., 195 Fed. 498, 115 C. OC. A. 408.” (Cur-
tiss Corp. v. Janin, supra. )
64
Had Byron Jackson chosen the same course he
could have filed an application on a practical and
worth-while design at least an entire year before
Layne’s filing date. Instead, Byron Jackson pro-
ceeded diligently with his work; always maintain-
ing, justified by subsequent experience, that no man-
ufacturer who knew his business could honestly
guarantee to keep the oil after it has passed the
pump bearings from escaping into the well. Beside
Mr. Jackson was dealing with a customer some two
thousand miles distant and it took time to make his
ideas prevail on that point. (The fact that Layne
took out a patent and showed and claimed such a
means is no proof of its practicability in the light
of experience. )
BYRON JACKSON DEFENSE LONG KNOWN TO AND FEARED
BY PLAINTIFF.
That the Byron Jackson prior invention was for
a long time known to and feared by the plaintiff is
evident from the very significant letter written by
Mr. Bowler to Mr. Layne, dated November 13th,
1911, appearing (R. 870) herein and reading as
follows:
‘*M. E. Layne, Esq., Houston, Texas.
‘Friend Layne: Referring to the copy of
following letter (letter from Mr. Mead of Nov.
7, 1911, to Layne & Bowler Corporation, Los
Angeles, Cal., see R. 869) it occurs to me that I
had better let you get hold of this fellow and
not correspond further with him. He is an old
65
man, having such evidence as this, which I am |
sure the Byron Jackson Company have in their |
possession, it is hard for me to get the right
kind of a deal out of them. If you cannot at-
tend to it at once, let me know and I will en-
deavor to get him straightened out and agree
that it was in the same year the drawing was
made and sent to me, that the sketch was made,
ete.’’ (Italics ours.)
Layne admits receiving this letter (R. 871).
——_ —_——_
THE LAYNE PATENT AS CONSTRUED BY PRIOR
ADJUDICATIONS.
Bearing in mind that the Byron Jackson defense
has never been before any of the courts in the
past being an entirely new defense and that the
Alvord and Eisler defenses, aside from appearing
hever to have been considered, may also be con-
sidered as a new defense this court nevertheless will
be materially assisted in the construction of the
Layne patent by its prior judicial interpretations.
THE EL CAMPO CASE.
The Circuit Court of Appeals which decided the
El Campo case construed this El Campo decision as
follows (213 Fed. 805, Van Ness v. Layne) :
“In the El Campo Case, 195 Fed. 83, 115
C. C. A. 115, the court held the patent valid as
to claim 13, and that that claim had been in-
fringed. As we understand, the validity of
claims 4, 9 and 20 were not passed upon by the
66
court, but were held not to have been infringed.
In the present case we are satisfied that claim
13 is not infringed by the Van Ness pump. The
last clause of claim 13 reads, ‘the casing being
closed at the top and provided with an air vent.’
While the Van Ness pump is closed at the top,
it is not contended that the pump has an air
vent such as the patented pump had and such
as the E] Campo pump had. Dae function of
this air vent is to foree any water or spent
lubricant remaining in the casing, out of it,
through an aperture in the top, by forcing air
through the air vent into the casing, for the
purpose of substituting clean liquid or oil. It
seems clear that the Van Ness pump had no
such member with a corresponding function as |
the air vent of the patented pump or that of
the El Campo pump, and so cannot be said to
infringe claim 13. This, if correct, would pre-
vent complainant from relying upon claim 13
in this case, as a ground of recovery.”’
The foregoing would seem completely to dispose
of the contention of the plaintiff in this case that
the present defendants infringe claim 13. The
court’s analysis of claim 13 obviously excludes the
Western Well Works pump from that claim.
THE VAN NESS CASE.
The Appellate Court in construing the Layne
patent brings out clearly that the features so much
stressed by plaintiff in all the litigation, to-wit, the
‘‘means for supporting the pump and shaft and
casing at any desired point within the well,’’ sim-
ply referred to the ‘‘system of wedges’’ (page
67
806 Van Ness Case). This disposes of any claim
plaintiff may make that Western Well Works has
any “means for supporting the pump and shaft
and casing at any desired point within the well.’
Manifestly, Western Well Works has no ‘‘system
of wedges’’ nor any equivalent therefor,
The court in construing claims 9 and 20 says that
the two claims are substantially one and the same.
Thus at page 807 the court said:
“Giving claim 20 this interpretation (that
is construing the words ‘line shaft’ as referrin
only to the part of the pump shaft which alone
can be enclosed in practice), it seems that it is
substantially like claim 9, except in the omis-
sion of the element of jointure or extensibility
of the shaft sections, which adds nothing to the
novelty and patentability of the device; and that
the element common to each claim, viz., the pro-
tective or closed easing surrounding the ump
shaft from the pump to the top of the well and
entirely closing off the water in the well from
the shaft and its bearings, is the only element
in any one of the claims as to which there is
persuasive evidence in the record both as to pat-
entability and infringement.”’
Continuing, the court Says:
‘*The word ‘closed’ in claim 9 seems to mean
as much as the words ‘entirely closed’ in claim
a **
Continuing, the court says:
‘It seems quite clear that the idea of a pro-
tected casing for a pump shaft without restric-
tive interpretation would contain no novelty
and would not be patentable, and, if this ele-
68
ment in the patent is given the unrestricted
meaning that its language admits of, it would
destroy the claim.”’
The court then proceeds to limit the claim so as
not to destroy it. Against the contentions of the
defendant in that case that the claims be given
the unrestricted generic meaning suggested by the
broad language employed, complainant there ar-
gued that the specifications should be looked to
to interpret the claim and, to use the language of
the court:
. “that it should be held to mean only a
protective casing of the kind and with the funce-
tions set out in the specifications. . . . If so
limited, it would seem that the protective casing
intended to be covered by the claim was one of
the kind described in the specifications and hav-
ing the three functions attributed to it by the
specifications, namely: (1) To exclude water
and detritus from the shaft and its bearings;
(2) to provide a means of lubricating the bear-
ings of each section of the shaft from the top
of the well without removing the apparatus
from it; and (3) to align the bearings and the
shaft so as to prevent lateral displacement in_
the well and keep the shaft in a vertical posi-
tion.”’
In the next paragraph the court says:
‘Giving the claim this significance, it fairly
appears from the record, as we see it, that there
was no protective casing in the prior art of the
kind and with the functions of that of the pat-
ent in suit. It also seems fairly to appear from
the record that such a protective casing as that
set out in the specifications contained novelty
enough to constitute invention.’’
69
The court, therefore, held the claim valid, but
chiefly it appears because in that case there seems
to have been conceded that Layne supplied ‘‘an un-
filled want’’ for apparatus of this sort. Of course,
there is an utter absence of any such showing on
the part of plaintiff that Layne’s patented pump
filled any suclf long-felt want.
Such commercial success as the plaintiff corpora-
tion may have achieved, has been due, no doubt, to
an extensive, and if we may be permitted to use the
expression, uncharitable system of advertising and
intimidation of competitors.
(See Restraining Order of Judge Van Fleet
granted these defendants, R. 28. )
In the Van Ness case the Honorable Judges,
having conceded patentability to Layne, but with-
in very narrow limits, pass on to the question of
infringement, concerning which the eourt says (p.
809) :
- . + ““It seems that the question of infringe-
ment, like that of patentability is a close one,”’
(Italies oyrs.)
In finding equivalency the court Says (p. 809):
‘However, the record shows that protection
against water and sand is afforded by defend-
ant’s casing to all but one of the bearings and
to the shaft in the same “yw as by that of the
patented casing, at least uring the period of
the pump’s operation, and that the protection
afforded by defendant’s casing is different only
in degree from that afforded by the patented
casing. The closure in the patented casing is
70
effected by stuffing boxes as well as by the
presence and downward pressure of the oil be-
tween the bearings and the shaft, which serves
to keep the water from pressing upward into
the shaft casing between the bearings and the
shaft. The closure in defendant’s casing is
effected by the last method only, and without
the use of packing or stuffing boxes.”’
The court attributes the other two functions of
the Layne patent to the defendant and, finally, in
resolving the issue in favor of Layne, chiefly on
the evidence that scemed to be in that case as to
commercial use of the Layne structure, admits its
own difficulties and says (p. 809):
‘We must confess that we are not mechanics
enough to determine with any assurance from
the record the merits of these respective conten-
tions, and it seems that the question of infringe-
ment, like that of patentability, is a close one,”
(Italies ours. )
The court finally saying (p. 810):
‘Comparing the conceded practical benefit
that has been derived from Layne’s patented
pump with the theoretical argument of the de-
fendant, we have come to the conclusion that
the former should prevail, and that claim 20 of
the complainant’s patent should be sustained,
and that the defendant’s apparatus should be
held to infringe it in the one respe:+ of a closed
casing for the pump shaft of the design and
with the triple function attributed to it in the
specifications of Layne’s patent.’’
In the present case there is no concession of any
‘practical benefit’? that has been derived from
Layne’s patented pump. The present testimony
VAN NESS PUMP
(Held to infringe in case of
Van Ness vs Layne 213 Fed 805.)
STUB SHAFT.
aa OOO
BRASS BUSHING.
; i
Impeller.
Reproduction from Plaintiff's Brief Van Ness Case, with following
legend:
COMPLAINANT'S EXHIBIT DRAWING ACTUAL VAN NESS
PUMP (C. E., p. 366).
Note the groove marked X worn by contact between the power
Thrust Bearing and the upper surface of the Brass Bushing,
refuting Van Ness’ testimony that in operation these parts do
not engage (Our brief, p. 47),
. as SU
ee ee
TT vEN Ar:
ede ions
wae ye
deh By SRS
SEPALS ORFS POP EH
Soca”
Pp eO RI
wen
71
shows, aside from the fact that Layne probably
borrowed his ideas from Byron Jackson and Alvord,
that the patentee has discarded ‘‘wedges,’’ ‘‘stuf-
fing boxes,”’ ‘‘air vent,’’ ‘‘oil blow-off means,’’ and
his system of lubrication generally, ‘‘splined slip-
joint shaft,’’ ‘‘thrust collars’’ at the shaft joints,
and practically everything that he may be said to
have ever invented and that no one of these several
Layne ‘‘inventions’’ is now or ever has been used
in practice by anybody.
The opinion in the Van Ness case leaves the
character of the Van Ness structure in doubt, but
by referring to the Getty case (262 Fed. 141, 144)
we find that Van Ness used “‘thrust bearings and
a collar to help close the bottom of the shaft cas-
ing.”’ On the opposite page is reproduced a cut of
the Van Ness drawing taken from the brief filed
cn behalf of Layne in the Van Ness case, and which
brief we beg leave to file herewith. In connection
with this drawing the following argument was made
by Layne’s attorney there:
‘‘An examination of this exhibit also makes
clear the falsity of Van Ness’ representations
as to the lower thrust bearing. Van Ness tes-
tified that in actual operation the thrust bear-
ing was drawn up so that it did not rest on the
top of the brass bushing. An examination of
the actual Van Ness pump which has been in
use one season shows that the lower thrust bear-
ing must have contacted with great force upon
the top of the brass bushing, as it has worn its
way down into the top of such brass bushing to
the distance of 7-32 inches. This will be clearly
understood by reference to the drawing of the
actual Van Ness structure, which shows that the
power thrust bearing has worn a deep path in
~]
bo
the top of the brass bushing. See the recess
marked X on the drawing. This corroborates
Wilson’s testimony as opposed to that of Van
Ness, and explains the success of the apparatus
in keeping water out of the casing. It will be
obvious that it would be impossible to get any
more effective seal against water than that se-
cured by the heavy bearing contact between tlic
lower face of the lower thrust bearing and the
upper face of the brass bushing, particularly
when such surfaces are oiled. The witness Van
Ness knew perfectly well that such a contact
would make an absolute seal against water, and
this explains the reason for his testimony to the
effect that in operation the lower thrust bearing
was drawn up so that its lower surface did not
contact with the top of the brass bushing. As
pointed out very clearly by the witness Wads-
worth, this thrust bearing constitutes a much
more effective seal against water than any stuf-
fing box could, and has its counterpart in the
Layne patent, in the thrust bearing 48 which
would serve to keep out the water from the
shaft casing, even though the stuffing box 41
were dispensed with.”’
The decision of the Van Ness case, taken in con-
nection with the foregoing extract from Layne’s
brief and the reproduced drawing, makes it evident
that the court was of the opinion that the Van Ness
lower thrust bearing and collar constituted a seal
for the lower end of the line shaft casing, and, in
view of the holding in the E] Campo case, this seal
is an essential element of claims 9 and 20, which
element was not found in the Getty construction.
Manifestly, it is not found in the Western Well
Works construction.
73
We are further aided in connection with this
matter by reference to Judge Jack’s decision, R.
1007, wherein Judge Jack has said (R. 1001) :
“There is this difference between the Van
Ness and the Getty apparatus. Jn the former
the weight of the shaft is largely sustained by a
thrust bearing near the bottom of the casing, so
that the pressure on the thrust bearing would
tend to make the casing nearer waterproof. In
the Getty apparatus, which rests on the bottom
of the well, there are no thrust bearings, but all
the bearings are of the ordinary kind, so that,
as argued by counsel, more water would pass
into the shaft casing of the Getty pump than in-
to that of the Van Ness pump.” (Italies ours.)
We thus see at the Van Ness stage of the liti-
gation that the court appreciated the mechanical
closure means of Layne that were essential at the
bottom of the shaft tubing, to make anything like
a “closed casing.”” In Layne, as the court says,
“the closure in the patented casing is effected by
stuffing boxes’; and in Van Ness it was effected
by “thrust bearings and a collar to help close the
bottom of the shaft casing.”’ The importance of
“mechanical closure’ is emphasized in the Getty
case as we will see.
THE GETTY CASE.
The Getty case first came before the Cireuit
Court of Appeals (222 Fed. 917) on appeal by the
plaintiff against the refusal of the lower court to
grant a Preliminary Injunction based on the prior
74
adjudication in the Van Ness case; the court say-
ing (p. 98):
‘*A hearing was had upon the motion for a
preliminary injunction, based upon ex parte
affidavits, and the injunction was refused. To
review this order the appellants have brought
the case to this court.
**Claim 20, sustained as valid by this court in
Van Ness v. Layne, 213 Fed. 804, 130 C. C. A.
462, is the only claim of the patent involved in
the present controversy. As before stated, the
hearing before the District Judge was had up-
on mere ex parte affidavits. Appellee denied
that his improvement infringed claim 20 of ap-
pellants’ patent, and it is apparent from an
examination of the contradictory affidavits that
the question of infringement vel non is left in
considerable doubt.”’
The court held that there had not been an abuse
of discretion and denied plaintiff’s motion. This
in itself does not speak a high regard for the Layne
patent in the mind of the Court of Appeals.
In 262 Fed. 141, the case, after final hearing,
comes again before the court for review following
Judge Jack’s decision sustaining the patent and
adjudging infringement against his own better
judgment; the attitude of Judge Jack being indi-
cated by the following excerpt from his opinion
in referring to the argument that there was no
invention over Crannell in interposing intermedi-
ate bearings and oiling by simply letting the oil
run down from bearing to bearing as would occur
to anyone and had always been the method of oil-
ing vertical shafts:
PELL OPTI BOL A SECESSION DEITIES LOL EI OS ESS TE ETM Ee, EEE
Pucey 63
Torust Bearine 3f
Onw Pire SO
BEARING 7S
COUPLING it
Casine 70 ha
Suary CaASine 195!
LAccING 7O a }
Drive SHAFT FIA
Beakine #3 ad
Covuriine FO
4/
20x
Lowe Bearine 62
SF
PUMP CASING 24
PUMP RUNNER 53
Scrtew Pipe 9 —_ *
Pit Caaing 16 —
Coupling #8
Braning #7
Ci03€0 Swart
Casing 20 Saal
Oaive Snare 3D
“4
Oracnanse Pot
Me lati 23
Seaning $7.)
Thrust Seareng .
%
Deanne +7
Pune 27
Suction Merc 2
a of ©
ings. e casing enclosing the
Pp. 6).
Note. Both devices have “a cloved shaft casing” (see casings, 20 and 15), and both devices
have bearings (47° and 43). Supported, protected and jubricated in closed shaft cas-
arings is admittedly a new thing in the art (Brief
RARE SATA RSI
AEB RAPE TST OAPs ARENSON
NEEL SABER AE ME
_
75
‘*The court is much impressed with this argu-
ment. The insertion of additional bearings to
prevent whipping of the shaft where the dis-
tance between bearings is too great, is as simple
and natural a thing to do as the putting in a
fence of extra posts to prevent sagging of a
barbed wire, where the posts of the panels are
too far apart. Were the question a new one,
I should be inclined to hold the patent invalid,
but the same issue was raised and directly
passed on by this Court and by the Court of
Appeals for the circuit, in the Van Ness case
sustaining the patent.’’ (Italies ours.)
On the further question of infringement, Judge
Jack, feeling bound by the ruling of the upper
court in the Van Ness case, says in conclusion:
‘As stated by the court in the Van Ness case,
the questions both as to patentability and in-
fringement are close ones. The evidence on the
first question is practically the same in the case
at bar as in the Van Ness case, and on the sec-
ond question I think there is no substantial dif-
ference in the features of the Van Ness and
Getty pumping apparatus as to which infringe-
ment is claimed.
‘*Following the ruling in the Van Ness case,
specifications numbers 9 and 20 must be held
to be valid and to be infringed by defendant’s
pump.”’
The Court of Appeals, however, took a different
view of the question of infringement and reversed
Judge Jack, holding that Getty did not infringe.
On the opposite page there is reproduced a draw-
ing of the Getty structure taken from the plain-
tiff’s aforesaid brief in the Getty case. The com-
parison they attempted there to show infringement
was, of course, futile.
76
STUFFING BOXES IN LAYNE BOTH TOP AND BOTTOM TO
EFFECT CLOSURE.
The court in its opinion, supra, handed down
since the filing of the Bill of Complaint in this
ease, sustains the Layne patent on admittedly a
‘‘shoestring’’ basis. At page 142 of the Getty case
the court says, in pointing out the alleged advance
of Layne over Crannell:
‘‘Layne solved his problem by the use of a
jointed shaft with intermediate bearings, lubri-
eated from the top to the bottom by gravity,
and protected from the water and sand of the
well by being inclosed in a casing, which ex-
eluded both sand and water from the bearings
and shaft. He accomplished its adjustment to
vertical positions in the well hole by suspending
the shaft, pump and casing from the top of the
well, and by a system of wedges holding the well
mechanism in position when adjusted. The sus-
pending of the well mechanism from the top also
enabled Layne to keep the shaft in alignment
through the added stiffness given by the down-
ward thrust of the weight of the pump and
shaft. This downward thrust also helped to
effect the closure at the lower bearing against
the entrance of sand and water. However, the
specifications of Layne’s patent show that he
relied upon stuffing boxes at the top and bottom
of the shaft to effect the closure, and to prevent
entrance of water and sand, to the detriment of
the shaft and bearings.’’ (Italics ours.)
Then in construing claim 20 (which had previ-
ously been held to be identical with claim 9) the
court says:
‘“‘The twentieth claim of the patent—that
sustained in the case of Van Ness v. Layne,
supra—covered ‘the combination of a well cas-
we
ing, a rotary pump therein, and a line shaft for
the pump entirely closed off from the water in
the well.’ Validity was given this claim by de-
fining a closed shaft to be one having the three
functions of (1) aiding the alignment of the
shaft in the well casing; (2) providing for lubri-
cation of the shaft and bearings; and (3) pro-
tecting the shaft and bearings from water and
sand. The question of adjustment did not enter
into the discussion in that case. The closed
shaft of the claim was restricted, as above
stated, by referring it to the character of in-
closed shaft described in the specifications of the
patent. Jt was only by giving the claim this
restricted meaning, and limiting it to the de-
scription in the specifications, that the claim
could be sustained.’’ (The last sentence itali-
cised is our; the first italies are the court’s.)
Continuing, the court says (p. 143):
‘The Layne patent too nearly resembles the
Crannell patent to be called a pioneer. . . .
Its merit was in adapting the Crannell type of
pump to a narrow and deep well hole, in a way
that has been held by us to exhibit novelty.
While the substitution of mere mechanical
equivalents for the means adopted by Layne
could not avoid infringement of his patent, it is
also true that the range of equivalents cannot
be enlarged upon the idea that his patent was a
pioneer one in the pump art. Its advance over
Crannell prevented Crannell from being consid-
ered by us an anticipation, and was enough to
show novelty, but it stops there.’’ (Italies ours. )
The court then applies the rule of law that a
functional result is not patentable but only the
means of its accomplishment, saying (p. 143) :
“The Layne patent must rest, not upon the
idea of closure, which would not be patentable
PGE 8k he Ne ell een ten > aN th ARS ED I Tle A Dah PT: NESTING REE dt RTE SEL ———
~]
so)
apart from the method by which it was accom-
plished, but upon the means of its accomplish-
ment, as disclosed by the specifications of his
patent. The means which he adopted to accom-
plish adjustment we are not here concerned
with, because the Getty pump has no means of
adjustment up and down in the well.’’ (Italics
ours. )
It is self-evident that the Western Well Works
‘*has no means of adjustment up and down in
the well.”’
——__ -- —
‘““STAGNANT’’ VS. ‘‘CIRCULATORY'’ SYSTEMS OF
LUBRICATION.
The court in the Getty case next passes to the
erux of the case and finds that Layne’s system o:
lubrication is a ‘‘stagnant’’ one, while Getty
adopted a ‘‘circulatory’’ system of lubrication.
“These functional differences between the stag-
nant and circulatory systems of lubrication prevent
their being considered as merely mechanical equiva-
lents.”’
The court says (p. 154):
**Layne’s method of lubrication was to put
the oil in at the top and to permit it to descend
to each of the bearings, and remain stagnant
within the shaft casing until ejected from the
top after it had become spent, by air pressure
through an air vent. When it was ejected, it
was replaced by clean oil from the top again.
On the other hand, the oil was confined at the
bottom of the well by use of a packing or stuff-
ing box. Getty adopted a circulatory system of
lubrication. By it the oil was also introduced
from the top, and descended to the lower bear-
panes Oe SL WR Pr aah ess . . tl
ings by gravity. However, at the bottom there
was only a partial obstruction to its exit, pre-
sented by a long sleeve bearing. Its passage
out from the shaft casing was automatie and
continuous, so that there was a constant and
free flow of lubricant from the top of the line
shaft, throughout its length, and out through
its bottom. This method was claimed to be
necessary to Getty’s device, because wear on
the upper bearing required a continuous supply
of fresh oil for its proper lubrication. These
functional differences between the stagnant and
circulatory systems of lubrication prevent their
being considered as merely mechanical equiva-
lents.”’ (Italies ours. )
In further explanation of this the court points
out (p. 1438):
‘“‘Layne, according to the specifications of
his patent, effected his closure at the top and
bottom of his shaft by the presence of stuffing
boxes, assisted by the effect of a downward
thrust bearing and collar. In practice, Layne
soon abandoned the use of packing boxes, sub-
stituting therefor a long sleeve bearing and re-
taining the collar. The downward thrust of the
weight of the shaft and pump, together with the
downward pressure of the column of oil in the
shaft casing, accomplished his closure. While
the pressure of the column of oil against the out-
ward column of water is now urged by Layne
as important in his means of closure, it is true
that it is not stressed, as such, in the disclosure
of his patent. Principal reliance is there placed
on the use of stuffing boxes.’’
Concerning Getty’s mechanism the court says
(p. 144):
““Getty’s mechanism is free from any such
closure device, either against the flow of oil out-
80
ward or the flow of water inward, except the
long sleeve bearing, without either a collar or
the advantage of the downward pressure from
the suspended apparatus. Getty relies for clos-
ure upon the downward pressure of the oil col-
umn balancing the upward pressure of the water
column. His mechanism prevents him from
availing of packing boxes to effect closure, be-
cause they would equally prevent the exist of
the oil, which is a necessary feature of his cireu-
latory system. The same reason would prevent
his using a thrust bearing with a collar.”’
Finally, the court held that the constructions were
not only functionally different but that the ‘‘ physi-
cal obstructions such as packing boxes and thrust
bearings’? in Layne did not find their mechanical
equivalent in Getty’s partial closure ‘‘effected by
balancing the pressure of the column of water out-
side the shaft casing against the pressure of the
oil inside the casing, without the use of physical
obstruction”’ and therefore held there was no in-
fringement.
THE LOS ANGELES SUIT.
Special Master Helm, in finding that the changed
structure adopted by the defendant, the American
Well & Prospecting Company, subsequent to the
Appellate Court’s decision in the Getty case, was
not an infringement, says in that case (R. 1096) and
following :
‘‘There cannot be said to be any difference in
the method of alignment used by the defendants
in their structure and the method used by
Sl
Layne. The mechanism in both eases is sus-
pended from the top of the well but in the de-
fendants’ pump by reason of a slight support of
the enclosing tubing on the pump neck there is
little tension imposed upon the enclosing tubing.
“The alignment is kept by the use of spiders
in the defendants’ pump and it is also adopted
at intervals in the Layne pump. The use of
spiders was a well known mechanism and it can-
not be held that the defendants have necessarily
adopted that part of the Layne device for the
purpose of creating an alignment and there is
no new discovery on their part by the adoption
thereof.
‘‘With reference to the method of lubrication,
however, there was a considerable difference
| subsequent to January 23rd, 1920, between the
| methods employed by the defendants and by
Layne. Layne’s method of lubrication was to
put the oil in at the top and permit it to de-
scend to each of the shaft bearings and remain
stagnant in the shaft casing until ejected from
the top, after it had become spent, by air pres-
sure through an air vent. When it was ejected
it was replaced by clean oil from the top again.
The oil was confined at the bottom of the tubing
by use of a packing or stuffing box.
“The defendants, however, after J anuary
23rd, 1920, adopted a circulatory system of lu-
brication. The oil was introduced from the top,
passed through a short tube connected to the
casing and descended along the casing to the
shaft bearings by gravity. Before reaching the
extreme lower end of the protecting casing it
assed through between a long eight-inch sleeve
aring (which surrounds the upper end of the
stub and which extends down into the pump
neck), and the outside of the stub shaft. This
long sleeve bearing was bored 1-64 of an inch
larger than the shaft and from the lower end
SH
to
of the long sleeve bearing the oil passed into a
duct in the shaft where there was a passage-
way and thence out through the bottom of the
stub shaft where the unconsumed oil mingled
with the waters of the well. This method was
different from anything that had ever before
been constructed and provided a means of lubri-
cation from the top to the bottom, prevented
stagnation in the oil and made it absolutely
circulatory at all times that the mechanism was
in operation.
‘**The defendants’ mechanism is free from any
closure device either against the flow of oil out-
ward or the flow of water inward, except the
long sleeve bearing. Necessarily the downward
pressure of the column balances the upward
pressure of the water column. There are no
packing boxes in the defendants’ structure as in
the Layne invention to effect closure and it is
absolutely necessary that there should be noth-
ing to prevent the exit of oil which is a neces-
sary feature of the circulatory system. There
is no downward thrust in the defendants’ struc-
ture due to the weight of the apparatus as the
means of closure. One-half pint of oil is plenty
for a ten hours’ run.
“It would appear, therefore, that defendants
accomplished lubrication and closure by means
so fundamentally different from Layne’s clos-
ure in his patent that they cannot be said to be
mere mechanical equivalents. The fact that the
defendants’ structure either in lubrication or
closure are not as complete in effect as that of
Layne is an unimportant factor but the strue-
tures differ so radically that it cannot be said
to be a mere difference in degree.
*‘Layne’s closure is effected by physical ob-
structions such as packing boxes and _ thrust
bearings and by pressure of the oil column while
the defendants’ closure is effected by the col-
“7
TIZM NY3LS3IM
53739NV S07 }
oadeAv |
| j
= r
INAV HLM O}B¥dWOD
SANJWONID 3NI NON
ALLIS
“LWd INAVT
PP AeA AS 1 ay eR sat, OE SRN Ae
—
83
umn of water outside the shaft casing against
the pressure of the oil inside the casing without
the use of physical obstruction. The difference
is one of novelty on the part of the defendants
and not adopted merely to avoid infringement.
‘*The defendants’ structure is suspended from
the top of the well but it does not use thrust
bearings to help close the bottom of the shaft
casing. The differences between the plaintiff’s
structure and the defendants’ structure are with
reference to the lubrication and closure and are
so important that they should not be held to be
mechanical equivalents and not to infringe the
enclosed line shaft lubrication enclosure of the
Layne patent.’’
On the opposite page appears a cut contrasting
the non-infringing structures, that of the present
defendants as well as those of Getty and Los An-
geles, with the patented Layne structure.
THE DEFENDANTS’ STRUCTURE.
The defendants’ structure is illustrated by the
model, Defendants’ Exhibit ‘‘V.’’ This is a true
and correct working model built according to stand-
ard shop practice of the defendants.
Mr. Conant says (R. 668), concerning this model:
“This pump model was built on our standard
forming tools. The hubs were machined with
standard tools, so they would have exactly the
same dimensions as those put out in practice.
The tubes were reamed with our shop reamers,
those which are used in standard practice. If
there is any difference in fit between any of
them now it would be due to putting them on
—— eo EO
84
and taking them off, which would make them
slightly looser by that means; there has been
no other change.”’
—_
DEFENDANTS’ PATENT TO HALSTEAD.
Defendants operate under their own patent No.
1,228,770, dated June 5th, 1917, in evidence as De-
fendants’ Exhibit ‘‘W’’ (R. 1109). For testimony,
see Lesley (R. 738).
Prof. Lesley has already characterized the lubri-
cating feature of Layne as ‘‘a stagnant system of
lubrication”’’ (R. 731) ‘‘the lubricant introduced by
some means into the tube is held there until it be
comes spent. There appears no way by which it
can be continuously fed. It is simply held as lubri-
cant might be in the crank case of an automobile;
it is filled up and it wears out or is burned out, dis-
sipated.”’
Mr. Doble confirms Prof. Lesley and the Halstead
patent when, on direct examination, he quotes from
the Halstead patent (page 2, commencing with line
53, R. 840-1):
“Tt is of course well known that clear water
is an excellent lubricant but the tendency of the
shaft to corrode renders its use objectionable
when used alone. The use of oil alone is highly
objectionable as it contaminates the water to
such a degree as to become a nuisance when fed
from the top or bottom, and requires a more or
less complicated system of pipes when fed
directly to each bearing, besides adding consid-
erable to the expense of operating. I obviate
a aia eat all hc 2)
S. M. HALSTEAD.
PUMP MECHANISM. :
APPLICATION FILED DEC. 20, 1915. 1
1,228,770. Patented June 5, 1917.
2 SHEETS—SHEET 1. :
li
ene ae PS
<SSAAS NANA « 5.
S
yY 2
SISISISSETTIMAIMTTTTEES A,
“7
34s
/5 ee
{EWS
WN
~ome:
FIGURE |
AWA WAAL,
NNN
UNI (NT
adie
WA) AS 24
24-Nos-N INo2 SN
NSN RS22 | 7
aa. SV ‘S N sa:
28% SRS 3 28:
2i-§ SY AS 8_-/9
INVEN ToR
OF oye
YIN. Cia ct, é
MIMI UATTETT I I
Hi
s pos ag
ron mai? ay as ik ST Mt Ne AGI Ay Tere . . : a pn
85
these objectionable features by using an oil
emulsion as a lubricant as above described,
thereby providing a cheap lubricating medium,
preventing corrosion of the shaft, not contami-
nating the water delivered and, on account of
the constant flow of water through the bearings,
providing an efficient cooling system for said
hearings.
‘It will be readily seen, of course, that since
the conduits are connected to the well proper by
channel 27 and auxiliary conduits 28, the water
in said conduits will be drained to the level of
the water in the well when the pump is in opera-
tion, and consequently there will always be a
movement of the water into said conduits, down
the shaft, through the bearings and out through
auxiliary conduits 28. The draining of conduits
8, 8a, ete., in this manner also conduces to
economy by obviating the necessity of providing
a stuffing-box at the top bearing.’’
And continuing Doble’s cross-examination (R.
841-2);
“XQ. You found present in this Plaintiff’s
Exhibit 4 the function of the drain tubes with
respect to the matter that vou first read begin-
ning on page 2 of the Halstead patent, lines 63
to 65?
“‘A, Yes.
‘‘Q. You found that function present?
‘‘A. Yes, I found that the elements as set
forth in that part of the patent are in this Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 4.’’
This version of the operation of defendants’ struc-
ture was adopted by the Circuit Court of Appeals
and to some extent by the District Court, although
the latter injected some qualifications therein not in
any way supported by the evidence.
S6
The Court of Appeals on this phase of the case
said (R. 1142):
‘*Does the lubricating oil introduced into the
defendants’ shaft casing pass down through the
bearings, and after being used and spent, finally
pass out at the bottom of the shaft into the well
proper through a channel or auxiliary conduit
constructed for that purpose? If it does, then it
is not the same mechanical device for lubrica-
tion claimed and specified in the plaintiff’s pat-
ent. The plaintiff’s device does not have any
outlet for the used and spent oil to pass out into
the well, and as we understand the mechanical
construction of plaintiff’s pump, it was devised,
in part at least, for the specific purpose of avoid-
ing that objection.’’ (R. Vol. 3, p. 1142.) ...
‘‘The defendants’ pump is substantially the
Jackson mechanism with respect to the dis-
charge of used or spent oil from the bottom
shaft into the water of the well, and is there-
fore not an infringement of plaintiff’s patent
for an entirely closed casing for the line shaft.”
(R. Vol. 3, p. 1148.)
Inferentially, at least, inasmuch as Mr. Doble
found the functions and elements of the drain tubes
set forth in that part of the patent which he had
first read to be present in Plaintiff’s Exhibit ‘‘4,”’
the additional functions of drainage and circulation
of the lubricating medium (referring to lines 70 to .
103, supra) were also present.
‘**Tt will be observed that channel 27 is
placed a short distance above the lower end of
bearing 17. This is done so that the lubricating
emulsion will traverse the greater portion of the
bearing before draining away. That portion
of the bearing below channel 27 will not be
lubricated, because the upward pressure of the
87
water being raised will tend to force a smal]
amount of water in the direction of the arrow
upward through the bearing, until the channel,
27, is reached, where it will be drained away
through auxiliary conduits, 28.’ ”’
And continuing, Mr. Doble says (R. 830) that
the Anderson pump, Plaintiff’s Exhibit ——" a
substantially the same mode of operation, saying:
‘Referring to Plaintiff’s Exhibit 4 I find the
channel, 27, which is shown in the patent draw-
ing, being placed between the ends of the lower
bearing, or the bearing immediately above the
pump bowl, and from that chamber 1 find the
two conduits, 28, and on examining the shaft of
this pump and its bearings, it shows clearly that
where the shaft went through the upper bear-
ing it was protected from grease, and the lower
part from this point down shows the corrosive
action of the water being forced through the
bearing. Now, in pumping under high pressure.
the water is forced up through this bearing into
chamber 23, and is then short-cireuited back into
the well, where there is low pressure through
the channel] 28,”
And, on cross-examination, Mr. Doble reads into
the record the additional functions of the drain
tubes specified by the Halstead patent (beginning
with line 70 down to line 103, inclusive, of page 2):
‘**Tt is of course well known that clear water
is an excellent lubricant but the tendency of the
shaft to corrode renders its use objectionable
when used alone. The use of oil alone is highly
objectionable as it contaminates the water to
such a degree as to become a nuisance when fed
from the top or bottom, and requires a more or
less complicated system of pipes when fed
directly to each bearing, besides adding consid-
ROR SAS eer SSRI a CRI RIM A EE ES her RA a Os SENN IR EARS, ER erie ond ——
88
erable to the expense of operating. I obviate
these objectionable features by using an oil
emulsion as a lubricant as above described,
thereby providing a cheap lubricating medium,
preventing corrosion of the shaft, not contami-
nating the water delivered and, on account of
the constant flow of water through the bearings,
providing an efficient cooling system for said
bearings.’ ”’
As said in California Canneries v. Dunkley, 247
Fed. 790, 794:
‘*They cannot offer this testimony as true to
prove a material and relevant fact for one pur-
pose, and discredit it for another purpose. If
it is true for one purpose, it is true for any
purpose.”’
The defendants’ pump is described by the witness
Conant, Engineer for the Western Well Works, Inc.,
beginning (R. 664).
The defendants’ structure, as shown both by the
model Exhibit ‘‘V’’ and the Halstead patent, may
generally be said to embrace a pump which has a
shaft to operate the impeller, which shaft turns
in bearings which are carried by the discharge
column of the pump. Between the discharge col-
umn and the impeller shaft, which latter is con-
centric with the discharge column, and between the
successive bearings, there are interposed sections of
pipe surrounding the line shaft and which enclos-
ing pipe or tubing, with the discharge column, forms
a conduit for the water discharge. This shaft tub-
ing of the defendants is like Layne in only one
particular, and in that particular it is exactly like
89
numerous structures and patents in the prior art:
that is, it affords a protection against sand and
gravel carried by the water against cutting out the
bearings. The similarity between Layne and the
defendants ends there.
The problem in that regard was not new with
Layne; for prior patentees like Crannell, Eisler,
Ivens, Alvord and others used a tubing around the
shaft to protect the bearings from wear. The only
difference between them and Layne was in the de-
gree of the enclosure effected by their tubing around
the shaft. Except Eisler they afforded a protection
merely against the abrasion of sand and gravel but
did not exclude water from the interior of the tub-
ing. Neither do defendants exclude water, while
Layne does. Eisler had the Layne problem of ex-
clusion of water although he does not show a stuffing
box. The added function of stuffing boxes provided
by Layne was the exclusion of the water, so that
a clear undiluted body of oil could be retained in
the Layne shaft enclosing tubing, and his shaft bear-
ings would run in a flood of oil. Again we see the
pertinency of Professor Lesley’s automobile crank-
case comparison.
In Halstead the rigid connection of all the shaft
sections together and carrying its entire weight and
the weight of the pump impeller on the surface is
in marked contrast to the loose telescoping struc-
ture of the plaintiff’s patent where the pump shaft
is in sections each with its collar 47 or 48, each sec-
tion carrying its own load; the slip joint connections
90
of Layne being in no ways the equivalent of the
rigid connected shaft of defendants.
Again, it is to be noted that the Joose disconnected
shaft tubings of defendants are dependent entirely
for their support on the bearings which are carried
by the discharge column, and that the shaft tubing
may be entirely dispensed with and the pump would
still function although it would leave the bearings
exposed to the discharging water. This, again, is
in marked contrast to the Layne patented strue-
ture where the shaft-enclosing tubing is connected
as a rigid structure and the whole pump and its
assembly is dependent for support on the Layne
shaft tubing. Remove Layne’s shaft tubing and the
pump falls apart.
Again, defendants, effect their lubrication on an
entirely different principle from Layne, and, in
fact, from the prior art for that matter. Halstead
as seen above discovered that by using a loosely
jointed tubing around his line shaft, with each sec-
tion shorter than the distance between each bearing
so that a limited amount of vertical play of each
section was permissible, and with the lower end of
the shaft tubing in direct communication with the
water in the well through ducts or channels which
communicated with the interior of the tubing and
the outside of the well eliminating stuffing boxes,
and employing a gravity feed of his lubricant, that
this oil would travel downward from bearing to
bearing and eventually find its outlet into the well
through the drain tubes. Inasmuch as these pumps
are usually submerged so that the water would
back up through the drain tubes and enter the tub-
ing a lubricant could be used known as an emulsi-
fying oil whieh is readily miscible with water; this
emulsion forming a good lubricant in itself.
91
Furthermore, it was found that by making the
sections surrounding the tube with loose slip joints
adapted to seat merely by friction on hubs, formed
above and below the bearings (the tube sections
being as above stated each shorter than the distance
between the bearings so that a limited lengthwise
play of each section between the bearings is per-
missible, and more or less water would leak in at
each of these joints formed between the telescop-
ing ends of the tube sections with the bearing
hubs), that this entering water mixing with the
emulsifying oil, would further aid lubrication and
reduce the quantity of lubricant necessary.
The testimony shows further that where operat-
ing under high heads or considerable water pres-
sure, due to the lift, a difficulty was met with by
reason of the water entering the tube and flowing
upward in the tube and out at the top, rather than
downward and out at the drain tubes. So in order
to maintain circulation downward rather than up-
ward and to permit the proper infeed of lubricant
which is necessary for most effective lubrication,
the defendants, early in their operations, provided
the shaft bearings with helical grooves delivering
downward, so that the shaft, which, in operation,
is rotated at the high speed of some 1100 to 1200
———
Pees
92
revolutions per minute produces, as experience
shows the phenomenal condition of a force feed
acting after the manner of a multi-stage pump to
create a downward pressure and a forced de-
livery down of oil and water or any other liquid
or viscid substance in the tubing; these accumu-
lating pressures serving to carry downward the
emulsion as well as the original heavy greases
emploved around the bearing when the pumps are
first installed and finally ejecting the same from
the drain tubes into the well.
The action which will be more fully explained
later, of these helically grooved bearings with the
open drain tubes is evidenced by a bottle of a
brownish liquid identified as Exhibit ‘* Y-10’’ and
representing a mixture of emulsifying oil and an
analine dye fed in at the top of one of defendants’
pumps and after mixture with the water in the
tubing being caught by Professor Lesley when dis-
charged at the drain tubes. This exhibit was gath-
ered by Professor Lesley in one of many tests
that he made to determine within the range of
physical possibilities just exactly what the action
was particularly as concerns lubrication in_ the
defendants’ pump. These tests, as well as the com-
mon sense of the thing, show conclusively that the
defendants’ pump works on a circulatory svstem of
lubrication and is as foreign to the stagnant, crank-
case system of defendants as is a stream of pure
running water to a cesspool.
Layne has been judicially determined to be
limited to a ‘‘stagnant’”’ system of lubrication and,
93
therefore, should not be held to embrace defendants’
system which is admitted to be ““circulatory.”’
THE ANDERSON PUMP.
There is also in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit
“4” a mutilated section of the so-called Anderson
pump, an original installation of the defendants.
The history of this mutilated section since it was
installed in the well by the defendants is so sur-
rounded with mystery and so much suspicion at-
tached to the so-called “tests”? which it was sub-
jected to in the year and a quarter it was in plain-
tiff’s possession, following its removal from the
Well, that its present condition ean in no wise be
taken as an indication of operating conditions which
these pumps are designed to meet and fulfill.
Whether the pump was tampered with or not of
course is not known but that it is not in the condi-
tion it was in in the well seems to be certain.
However, even in its present condition and with
the white lead around the joints of the tubing har-
dened and dried by exposure to the atmosphere, it
clearly shows the “‘drain tubes” through which ‘cir-
culation”? takes place.
Indeed, the ‘‘cireulation” of the lubricant in the
Western Well Works construction is so evident,
and the system so manifestly a ‘circulatory one”
that the plaintiff admits the very method of lubrica-
tion contended for by defendants.
94
PLAINTIFF ADMITS DEFENDANTS EMPLOY A CIRCULATORY
SYSTEM OF LUBRICATION.
Mr. Layne in describing the lubrication of de-
fendants’ pump, as evidenced by the Anderson
pump, says (R. 573):
‘‘In the first place, the tube that surrounds
the shafting that enters the bearing is con-
tinuous from the pump neck to the top of the
well, which makes connection with pump head.
A 3-inch pipe connects up through the discharge
T into the pump head proper, so that the water,
as it is being pumped from the well by the pump
discharges up through the casing member here,
and outside of the shaft casing. The lubricant,
as it is applied, works its way down through
the shaft casing, and—
‘“‘Mr. TowNsenp.—Now, your Honor, he
never has seen one of these pumps in operation,
and so he can’t tell how it is lubricated.
‘“‘The Court.—Well, he agrees with your
statement, anyhow. . . .
‘‘The Court.—He is stating precisely what
you stated in your opening. Proceed with the
answer.
“A. The lubricant is then admitted into the
well through the drain port or vent in the pump
neck—’”’ (Italies ours.)
In order to emphasize how the oil traverses the
several bearings in the Western Well Works struc-
ture gravitating downward until it finally escapes
from the tube into the well Mr. Layne further says
(R. 575):
“‘Therefore, we claim that every part of the
Halstead structure, or the Western Well Works
structure, every pipe, the enclosing casing, per-
forms the same function as our enclosing casing,
the bearings perform the same function, the
ref etd ok Pa Vf ee Et tent ae ’ = 4
95
lubricating performs the same function; the
shaft-protecting casing shuts out the sand as it
is being pumped through here, so that the
lubricant can gravitate or work its way down
through the shaft casing, and as it works down
it both lubricates and protects in every way
every bearing throughout the entire line of
shafting. One drop of oil admitted at the sur-
face, or a dozen drops of oil, lubricate each
bearing as it passes from one to the aw, ..
And (R. 582):
‘the only difference being that they provide a
duct by which the lubricant, when it reaches the
top of the pump, can pass into the well in place
of the lubricant as it works through our shaft-
enclosing casing passing in the pump portion
and is carried out directly with the water being
pumped.” . . .
And again this (R. 583):
“Mr. Lyon.—Q. From your examination of
this Anderson pump, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 4, was
that a free circulation down at the bottom out
from the shaft-enclosing casing ?
“A. It is free after it comes in contact with
the ports, but preceding the [568] entry of the
oil at the port opening the oil is retarded at each
shaft-bearing.”’ (Italics ours. )
And finally we have this in Plaintiff’s so-called
Opening Brief (page 103):
‘Lubricant, with the exception of the hard
grease packed in the shaft casing by defendants
at the time of installing the structure, is fed
into the top of the shaft-enclosing casing at
12 and passes or circulates down the casing
through each intermediate bearing and through
the lowest bearing into the chamber 97 from
CLR RRL eee HDA MEN: 1G REE MSTA DO EI SRM PNR > ODLD ELATED ALLEL RA ADI oa
ke
96
which it overflows and passes through the con-
duits 28 into the well.’’ (Italies ours.)
The figures have reference to the Halstead Patent
drawings; the chamber 27 and conduits 28 also
being shown in the cross sectional cut of the An-
derson pump which appears opposite said page
103 of Plaintiff’s Opening Brief.
So inconsistent are plaintiff’s counsel that after
conceding defendants’ lubricating system to be
circulatory, page 103, say at page 135 of their
Opening Brief:
‘“‘With said heavy grease in the casing, on
the shaft and in the spiral grooves of the bear-
ings and thus being found after years of use,
it is obvious that even the lighter, emulsifying
oil could not flow freely through defendants’
shaft-enclosing casing.’’ (Italics theirs.)
Of course, the word ‘‘freely’’ may be said to save
the day and not to constitute a retraction of the
previous admission.
THE FOREGOING ADMISSIONS OF FACT BINDING
ON PLAINTIFF.
Even in the face of the above admissions and
weight of evidence and the teachings of the Layne
Patent the trial judge committed the fundamental
error of comparing the defendants’ structure not
with the Layne patent but with what appears to
be the mode of operation of Layne in his com-
mercial structure, and finds in effect that both
97
systems are circulatory or that both systems may be
stagnant; the trial court saying (R. 894):
“It is also earnestly insisted by defendants
that the two systems are differentiated by the
fact that their lubricating system is circulatory,
while that of the plaintiff is static. In one or
two of the decisions cited
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.