Brief for the United States — United States v. Rider
Supreme Court brief1923
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Page.
RNs ona sseN KS KK KKK a RRSNRREK GK SARKENAN SSRN ERSANS SERS 1
SCN CROUIEUNIE ae ss Gad NAAR cKO A AMASNASA KARAS CARA ARK RE RRM ROK 5
Argument:
I. Is the pay of the claimant, Rider, provided for under the
appropriation made by the act of June 15, 1917 (40 Stat.
180), reading ‘* Pay at $100 per month for enlisted men in
training for officers of the Reserve Corps,” or does the term
‘enlisted men in training,’’ found in said appropriation,
include only the enlisted men of the line of the Army?. . 6
II. The second question is: If Rider’s pay was fixed by the
proviso of the act of June 15, 1917, at $100 per month,
WE SEG BERG WAND BRCINGO Tok osc cwaxdcceencesantasee 13
III. The court below erred in holding that the provision of the
act of June 15, 1917, establishing ‘‘ pay at $100 per month
for enlisted men in training for officers of the Reserve
Corps,’ was extended by the provisions of the acts of July
24, 1917 (40 Stat. 243), and of July 9, 1918 (40 Stat. 485),
RONEE SIU Py RO s'n sx ean ye ee san nAG ASAE ESANS SAR RER 16
AUTHORITIES.
ee AE PON Ay Ree, Oe Us Ces, Mac cc cdin ns cn cuba cksacasuncceccen 3,14
Act of July 16, 1914, $8 Stat. L. 514, 516... ccc cc cceiee nes 3,18
Act of July 3, 1916, 39 Stat. L. 166, sec. 18... won ccc cece cenes 3
ee ee Oe WG, SRS. SP Oy Sa A KCR RRA SAR WAKA R AAT ORES RKA 3,13
Deficiency Appropriation Act of June 15, 1917, 40 Stat. L. 182, 188... . 2,
5, 6, 13, 16
Art of Suly 24, WONT, 40 Btat. 1. 243, DAG. 0c ccc cee ceca 4, 16,17
Act of duly 9, 1018, 40 Stat. L. 845, S40... 6 oo ccc ccccaes 4,6, 16,18
House Report No. 67, 65th Cong.. Ist sess.......... 6.0.2... e eee eee 10
Report of Senate Committee on Appropriations. ...............-.- 10
3270S—23——1 (1)
ao OO a ee a ee ee et ee eet ee
Sn the Supreme Gourt of the United States,
OcToBER ‘TERM, 1922.
THE UNITED STaTes OF AMERICA, APPEL-
lant,
v.
NELSON W. RIDER, APPELLER.
No. 510.
APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS.
BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES.
STATEMENT.
Nelson W. Rider enlisted at Kansas City, Missouri,
on November 22, 1917, for the Aviation Section, Sig-
nal Enlisted Reserve Corps, as a private, first class.
He was called to active duty and directed to proceed
to the School of Military Aeronautics, at Urbana, IIli-
nois. He joined, under such orders, the said school
on February 9, 1918, from which date he was in ac-
tive service in the Aviation Section of the United
States Signal Service Reserve Corps as an enlisted
private, first class. After training and successive
transfers to the various fields, he was assigned to
duty that required him to participate in regular and
frequent flights. His flight duties began at Taylor
es
2
Field, Alabama, on May 15, 1918, and his first
flight was made on May 29, 1918. On September 13,
1918, the plaintiff was discharged from his status as
an enlisted man, in order to allow him to accept a
commission, and on September 14, 1918, he accepted
a commission as second lieutenant in the Air Service
Aeronautics in the Signal Corps, United States Army.
For his service during the period from May 12,
1918, to June 30, 1918, inclusive, Rider received
pay at the rate of $100 per month. For service
during the period from July 1, 1918, to September 30,
1918, Rider received the pay of an enlisted man,
private, first class, at the rate of $33 per month, plus
fifty per centum increase for aviation duty, amount-
ing in all to the sum of $49.50 per month. Rider
sued and made claim for the period from May 12,
1918, to June 30, 1918, for pay at the rate of $106 per
month and fifty per centum increase thereon for said
period, less the amount received by him at the rate
of $100 per month for said period. Rider further
claimed for the period between July 1, 1918, and
September 13, 1918, inclusive, pay at the rate of
$106 per month, plus fifty per centum increase for
flight duty, less the amount which he had received
in pay for said period.
The claim of Rider was based—
1. Upon the Deficiency Appropriation Act of
June 15, 1917 (40 Stat. 182, 188), which Act pro-
vided as follows:
For pay of enlisted men of all grades, in-
cluding recruits, and pay at $100 per month
for enlisted men in training for officers of the
Reserve Corps, $226,882,560.
2. Upon the Act of May 11, 1908 (35 Stat. 109)
which provided:
* * * Privates, first class, of * * *
Signal Corps * * * eighteen dollars.
3. Upon the Act of July 18, 1914 (38 Stat. 514,
516), which Act was the Act that established the
Aviation Section, which was to be a part of the Signal
Corps of the Army, and provides:
That 12 enlisted men at a time shall, in the
discretion of the officer in command of the
Aviation Section, be instructed in the art of
flying, and no enlisted man shall be assigned
to duty as an aerial flyer against his will except
in time of war. Each aviation enlisted man,
while on duty that requires him to participate
regularly and frequently in aerial flights, or
while holding the rating of aviation mechani-
cian, shall receive an increase of 50 per centum
in his pay.
4. The Act of July 3, 1916 (39 Stat. 166), being
known as the National Defense Act. Section 13 of
said Act, pages 174-175, provides for the Signal
Service Corps, and sets forth:
That the Secretary of War shall have au-
thority to cause as many enlisted men of the
Aviation Section to be instructed in the art of
flying as he may deem necessary.
5. Upon the Act of May 18, 1917 (40 Stat. 82),
which provided that—
commencing June 1, 1917, and continuing
until the termination of the emergency, all
i ce
4
enlisted men of the United States in active
service * * * whose base pay is $45 or
more (shall receive) an increase of $6 per
month.
6. Upon the Act of July 24, 1917 (40 Stat. 243),
which Act permanently established and provided for
the organization of the Aviation Section of the Signal
Corps of the Army. Said Act, as relied on, sets out
in section 8 (page 245):
That all officers and enlisted men of the
temporary forces of the Signal Corps, includ-
ing the Aviation Section thereof provided
for herein, shall be in all respects on the same
footing as to pay, allowances, and pensions
as permanent officers and enlisted men of
corresponding grades and length of service
in the Regular Army.
7. On the Act of July 9, 1918 (40 Stat. 845), the
same being the General Appropriation Act for the
support of the Army for the fiscal year ending June
30, 1919. The provision in said Act upon which
Rider relied is set out on page 849, and is headed
“Continuing the Appropriations for the Signal Ser-
vice,” reading as follows:
That funds appropriated by the Act ap-
proved July twenty-fourth, nineteen hundred
and seventeen, for the fiscal year nineteen
hundred and eighteen, entitled ‘““An Act to
authorize the President to increase temporarily
the Signal Corps of the Army and to pur-
chase, maintain, manufacture, repair, and
operate airships and make appropriations
therefor, and for other purposes,” and the
,
5
funds appropriated for the Signal Service of
the Army in the Act approved May twelfth,
nineteen hundred and _ seventeen, entitled,
‘““An Act making appropriations for the sup-
port of the Army for the fiscal year nineteen
hundred and eighteen,’”’ and October sixth,
nineteen hundred and seventeen, for the fiscal
vear nineteen hundred and eighteen and prior
years entitled, “An Act making appropria-
tions to supply urgent deficiencies, and so
forth,”’ are hereby made available until June
thirtieth, nineteen hundred and nineteen.
the Court of Claims entered a judgment in favor
of the claimant, Rider, on May 29, 1922, for the
sum of $326.22. (R. 7.)
The findings of faet and conclusion of Jaw are
set out at pages 4, 5 of the record.
Notice of appeal was then given and the appeal
allowed by the presiding judge.
The offices of the Comptroller General and the
Secretary of War state that the decision in this
case will control the rights of nearly twenty thousand
claimants, involving a possible sum of eight to twelve
million dollars.
QUESTIONS INVOLVED.
The questions involved in this case are threefo!d:
1. Is the pay of the claimant, Rider. being an
enlisted man of the Aviation Section of the Signal
Enlisted Reserve Corps, provided for under the Act
of June 15, 1917 (40 Stat. 188), or does the term
“enlisted men in training,”’ found in said Act, include
only the enlisted men of the line of the Army?
2. If it be held that the said Act of June 15, 1917,
controlled the pay of Rider, does said pay of $100 per
month cover all amounts to which he might have
been entitled, provided said Act had not become a
law, or whether said $100 was merely the base pay of
Rider?
3. Was the pay of $100 per month for enlisted
men in training for officers of the Reserve Corps
appropriated in the Act of June 15, 1917, extended
by the Act of July 9, 1918 (40 Stat. 845), and made
available until June 30, 1919?
ARGUMENT.
I.
Is the pay of the claimant, Rider, provided for
under the appropriation made by the Act of June 15,
1917 (40 Stat. 180), reading ‘‘ Pay at $100 per month
for enlisted men in training for officers of the Reserve
Corps,” or does the term “‘enlisted men in training,”’
found in said appropriation, include only the enlisted
men of the line of the Army?
The Act of June 15, 1917 (40 Stat. 188), is entitled
“An Act making appropriation to supply urgent
military and naval establishments on account of war
expenses for the fiscal year ending June thirtieth,
nineteen hundred and eighteen, and for other
purposes.”
Beginning on page 185 and running to page 201
there are a series of appropriations for the Military
Establishment. In the body of the act these appro-
priations are arranged under different headings.
7
There are a number of different provisions for pay
of enlisted men. ‘The special appropriation which
Rider claims is applicable to his case is set out on
page 188. <A careful reading of this section shows
that the items of appropriations made on pages 1&2,
189, and 190 are all contained under the heading in
the body of the act entitled “Pay of the Army.”
There are herein set out five special appropriations
for the pay of enlisted men and two appropriations
for the pay of retired enlisted men. Said appropri-
ations begin with the heading “Pay of the Army,”
then follows a subheading “ Officers of the Line,” then
“Enlisted men of the Line,” then “Ordnance Depart-
ment,” then “Quartermaster Corps,” then “Signal
Corps,” then “ Medical Department.’”? Under each
of the last three subheadings there is an appropriation
for the pay of enlisted men. Rider claims that he ‘s
entitled to the pay of $100 per month under the
appropriation contained in the second subheading.
This reads:
Enlisted Men of the Line. For pay of en-
listed men of all grades, including recruits,
and pay at $100 per month for enlisted men
in training for officers of the Reserve Corps,
$226,882,560.
It is clear that the only enlisted men in training for
officers that are here given the pay at $100 per month
are the enlisted men of the line. The fifth appro-
priation headed ‘‘Signal Corps” provides for the ps7
of enlisted men and additional pay for length of
service, but there is no designation under said sul-
32708— 23-—2
8
bead for pay at any special rate for enlisted men of
the signal Corps in training for officers.
(on page 187 of the act there is a provision for the
i -fieleney expenses of the office of the Chief Signal
(heer, with the subheading ‘Signal Service of the
\emy,”’ said subheading having two provisos. In the
frst there is set aside for the Aviation Section, for
purchases, the sum of $48,450,000. The second
proviso sets forth:
Provided further, That of the sum last above
mentioned so much thereof as may be neces-
sary shall be available for paying and other-
wise providing for such officers of the Officers’
Reserve Corps of the Aviation Section of the
Signal Corps and such enlisted men of the
Enlisted Reserve Corps of the Aviation Section
of the Signal Corps as may be called into
active service.
It seems clear from the reading of this act and the
sppropriations for the enlisted men that the sole
claim that Rider can make is that his pay shall come
out of the pay provided on page 188 under the sub-
heading “Signal Corps: Pay of enlisted men,”’ or out
o! the pay provided for on page 187 for the officers
xd enlisted men of the Enlisted Reserve Corps of the
Aviation Section of the Signal Corps, which may be
called into active service. These are the sole special
sod particular appropriations, and the only ones in
ssid act of June 15, 1917, for the pay of enlisted men
the Signal Corps or in the Enlisted Reserve Corps
« the Aviation Section of the Signal Corps.
BR cen enna enemas nr enn
9
Rider can not properly claim that the appro; > --
tion under the second subheading “ Enlisted Meo)
the Line,” on page 188 (which alone provides +: ¢
pay at $100 per month for enlisted men in training
for officers of the Reserve Corps), applies to enlisted
men in the Aviation Section of the Signal Enlisted
Reserve Corps. This is clear from the reading of
the act, since the pay provided in the subheading on
page 188 is only the pay for enlisted men of the line.
The line of the Army, at the time, consisted of t}e
Cavalry, Infantry, and Artillery, and neither the
enlisted men in the Signal Corps, nor of any section
of the Signal Enlisted Reserve Corps, were considered
or held, nor were appropriations made for them os
enlisted men of the line. It is clear, therefore, thot
the appropriation made in this act “Pay at $100 pee
month” for enlisted men in training for officers of the
Reserve Corps did not provide any pay for enlisted
men in the Signal Corps or in the Reserve Signuel
Corps. Thus, it ean not be held, as elaimed by Rider,
that by the passage of the Act of June 15, 1017,
which took effect from its passage. this special pay at
#100 per month applied to the enlisted men of *he
Aviation Section of the Signal Reserve Corps 1
training for officers. The enlisted men of the A\/e-
tion Section of the Signal Reserve Corps. such 2s
Rider, at the time of the passage of this Act of June
15, 1917, were receiving as pay the sum of $49.5).
Unless it can clearly be shown that the provision on
which Rider relies was intended to apply to the men
in the Aviation Section of the Signal Reserve Corps
1)
it must be held that it did not. In regard thereto
the only light that can be thrown on the question of
the intent of Congress is of very scant aid. The act
+s originally passed by the House did not contain
the provision for the rate at $100 per month; said
-rovision was inserted at the request of the Army
officers in an amendment inserted by the Senate;
the sole reference to this provision made by or in the
House is in Report No. 67 (65th Cong., Ist. sess.,
fi. R.j, being the conference report.
The statement of the managers on the part of the
House set forth that they agreed to certain amend-
ments of the Senate, among others to
No. 14. Makes the appropriation for pay of
enlisted men of the Army available for pay-
ment at the rate of $100 per month to men in
training for officers of the Reserve Corps, as
proposed by the Senate.
No further comment was made, so far as counsel
has been able to discover, in the House.
The amendment was inserted in the Senate by the
Committee on Appropriations. The sole reference to
this item in the hearings before the Senate is set
forth on pages 89 and 90 of the hearings before a
subcommittee of the Committee on Appropriations
in the following words:
PAY OF MEN WHILE IN TRAINING CAMPS FOR
OFFICERS’ RESERVE CORPS.
Maj. Pierce. There is no language in the
bill that would permit us to pay $100 a month,
or whatever amount is finally authorized, to
_—a— een: hong
11
the candidates for commissions during their
training in camps. It will be necessary to
have a provision to cover that if it is not in-
cluded in this bill.
Senator SmMoor. Do you mean the authori-
zation to pay them $100 a month?
Maj. Prerce. Yes. It can not come out of
the pay of the Army under the wording of the
bill.
Lieut. Brerr. I think we could put in an
item on page 12, line 3, under the heading
“Enlisted men of the line.””. These men are
to be enlisted.
Maj. Prerce. Yes; they are to be enlisted
for a period of three months only.
Lieut. Brerr. That could be put in on page
12, line 3. I can see it will be necessary to
explain. They are not in the essential fea-
tures enlisted men. They are training for
officers. Enlisted men get $30 a month, and
it is proposed to give these men $100 a month.
This would be “including pay at $100 a month
for men training.”’
The CHAIRMAN. “Training for officers in the
Reserve Corps?”
Lieut. Brerr. Yes; in the language that
covers that on page 12, line 2, is where the
wording comes, so that it will read: ‘For pay
of enlisted men, of all grades, including recruits,
and pay at $100 (or whatever amount is
authorized) a month for enlisted men in train-
ing for officers.”’
The CHAIRMAN. “For commissioned officers
in the Reserve Corps ?”’
Lieut. Brerr. That is it; yes.
12
Senator Harpwick. How much have you
to add for that?
Lieut. Brerr. It will not be necessary to
add any.
Maj. Prerce. Have you enough money for
that?
Lieut. Brerr. I think so.
Senator Harpwick. ‘Including pay, at $100
a month for enlisted men in training for offi-
cers of the Reserve Corps?”
Lieut. Brerr. There should be stated the
amount that is to be paid each month, ‘‘at
$100 per month,” or whatever the amount
should be decided upon.
Senator Smoor. “At the rate of $100 a
month?”
Lieut. Brerr. ‘‘At the rate of $100 a
month.”
Maj. Pierce. I think we have covered
everything, Mr. Chairman.
There was no further discussion of the item in the
report to the Senate or in the discussions by the
Senate so far as counsel has been able to discover.
It is clear from the reading of this hearing before
the Senate subcommittee that in the matter of this
item there was no intention to cover the enlisted men
of the Aviation Section of the United States Signal
Service Reserve Corps who might have been in train-
ing for officers. The ordinary private, to whom
Lieutenant Brett refers, saying ‘‘Enlisted men get
$30 a month, and it is proposed to give these men
$100 a month,” was the ordinary private of the line.
Said private received a base pay of $15 and, under the
aed eee NNT NG ral NOE A at a Hie es OTS aeRO ML ERNE thee Saami 2
13
provisions of the act of May 18, 1917, he received an
increase of $15, his total pay thus being $30. The
ordinary private of the line, therefore, in training at
this time for officer in the Reserve Corps, received as
full compensation the sum of $30, and the intent was
that this amount which he received should now be
increased, temporarily, to the sum of $100.
This was purely a temporary measure to meet the
emergency of providing the officers needed for the
line for the vast army of recruited and conscripted
men who were then in training. It was an emergency
and it was felt that the men who were deemed fit and
competent to be trained for officers should, during the
period of their training, receive a special increase over
the pay of the ordinary enlisted men of the line, and
it was this pay and increase which was provided for in
this specific appropriation. The subsequent appro-
priation acts during the course of the war contained
no such provision, the need and the emergency having
ended with the training of the necessary officers for the
line during the course of the year 1917-1918.
Il.
The second question is: If Rider’s pay was fixed
by the proviso of the Act of June 15, 1917, at $100 per
month, what did said sum include?
The court has held that this item in the Act of June
15, 1917, fixed the base pay of an enlisted man in
training for an officer of the Reserve Corps at $100 per
month. If the said sum of $100 per month should,
on and after June 15, 1917, be paid to private enlisted
BAS > Spd DOM me! 4 pena T ee ANS Rag WANS POI A Le Se len PRD ARN tte SURO PS a RS
14
men in the same situation as Rider, is the court
correct in this position, or did not said $100 cover all
amounts to which he would have been entitled pro-
vided said act had not become a law?
If the said $100 set forth in the opinion of the
court was merely the base pay of the plaintiff, then
it took the place of the $18 to which he was entitled
under the Act of May 11, 1908 (35 Stat. 190), and
the provision for pay at $18 was suspended tempo-
rarily and was repealed by implication solely for the
period of time when the Act of June 15, 1917, and
its appropriations remained in force. Such is the
reasoning of the court below. The court held further
that the increase in pay which was to be received
under the provision of the Act of May 18, 1917 (40
Stat. 82), and which was in the case of a private
whose base pay did not exceed $21 per month, that
he “shall receive an increase of $15 per month”’ was
also temporarily repealed by implication by the Act
of June 15, 1917; but the court below held that the
provision of the Act of July 18, 1914 (38 Stat. 516),
of an increase of fifty per centum in the case of the
aviation enlisted men (that he “shall receive an
increase of fifty per centum in his pay,’) was
not repealed by implication by the passage of the
Act of June 15, 1917. It should be noted that
none of these three acts nor any part thereof were
expressly repealed by the Act of June 15, 1917, and
that under the holding of the court the only repeal
or suspension of said act that was made, was by
implication, and that not permanently, but for the
15
life of the Act of June 15, 1917, and the appropriations
carried by it.
Congress clearly did not intend that this $100 per
month was an additional pay to the parties who
would benefit by it. It was, therefore, a new rate
of pay. What, under the acts to which attention
has been called, was the former rate of pay? The
former rate of pay for a private, first class, who was
not engaged in flight was $33 per month; if engaged
in flight duty the private, first class, would receive
an increase of fifty per centum in his pay; and his
rate of pay in these cases would be increased to
$49.50 per month. In either case, whether engaged
m flight duty or not, the pay which the private
received was the amount which he received; it can not
be held, as the court below held, that in the first instance
$33 was his pay, and that in the second instance $49.50
was his pay and something else. In common, ordi-
nary speech, either sum was his pay—was the amount
that he received per month. The acts read “whose
base pay does not exceed $21 per month shall receive
an increase of $15 per month,” and he “shall receive
an increase of fifty per centum in his pay.” And
now Congress sets out in the Act of June 15, 1917,
“Pay at the rate of $100 per month for enlisted
men, ete.” Defendant respectfully submits that it
is a violent wresting of the English language and a
foreed construction of the intent of Congress to
declare that the $100 per month would cover the
$33, but does not cover the $49.50.
16
IT.
The court below erred in holding that the pro-
vision of the act of June 15, 1917, establishing “ pay at
$100 per month for enlisted men in training for offi-
cers of the Reserve Corps,’’ was extended by the pro-
visions of the act of July 24, 1917 (40 Stat. 243), and
of July 9, 1918 (40 Stat. 485), until June 30, 1919.
The provision of the act of June 15, 1917, estab-
lishing the rate of pay at $100 per month, was clearly
not permanent but temporary legislation on the
subject. It is clear that with the expiration of the
time during which the statute was to be effective
and the appropriations to be available, the temporary
legislation in regard to the rate of pay would expire.
The provision, as to this rate of pay, is not in the
nature of and similar to the frequent provisions
found in appropriation bills, increasing or decreasing
from the time of the going into effect of the act the
pay or allowances of officers or men of the Army or
Navy. In these cases the law specifically sets
out that “ from the passage of this act,”’ or from a date
set out in the act, the increase or decrease shall be-
come and be thereafter effective. That is not the
case here; there is here the appropriation of a lump
sum of $226,882,560. This lump appropriation is
to be used for the purpose of “the pay of enlisted
men of all grades, including recruits, and pay at
$100 per month for enlisted men in training for offi-
cers of the Reserve Corps.”
It is not necessary to argue to the court that with
the expiration of the availability of this appropria-
17
tion the rate of pay at $100 per month would cease.
The second section of the act sets out that the appro-
priations therein were to be available to June 30,
1918. Unless by subsequent legislation the life of
these appropriations was extended, the appropria-
tion which was available to pay the $100 per month
ceased to be available on June 30, 1918, and on that
date pay at said rate came to an end.
The court below held that the appropriations by
later acts were made available until June 30, 1919.
The following are the words of the opinion of the
court as delivered by Judge Hay:
The Government contends that the pro-
vision of the act of June 15, 1917, which estab-
lished the pay of the plaintiff at $100 per
month, expired with the expiration of the
appropriations set forth in the act. We are
of the opinion that this contention is not
tenable because of the provisions of the act
of July 24, 1917, and of the act of July 9, 1918,
which latter act makes available the appro-
priations of the act of July 24, 1917, and of the
appropriations of the act of May 12, 1917,
until June 30, 1919.
It will be first noted that nowhere, either in the
act of July 24, 1917, or in any previous or subsequent
act of Congress, with the exception of the provision
cited in the act of June 15, 1917, is there any mention
of, or reference to, the rate of pay of $100 per month.
The act of July 24, 1917 (40 Stat. 243), is entitled “An
act to authorize the President to increase temporarily
18
the Signal Corps of the Army and to purchase, manu-
facture, maintain, repair, and operate airships, and
to make appropriations therefor, and for other pur-
poses.”” While the act of July 18, 1914 (38 Stat. 514),
is the act which originally created the aviation sec-
tion of the Signal Corps of the Army, yet it is the act
of July 24, 1917, which permanently established and
provided for the organization of the Aviation Section.
Section 9 of the act gives the authority for the
purchase, maintenance, repair, and operation of
airships, and the acquiring and building of aviation
stations with all necessary appurtenances thereof;
for the purchase and manufacture and issuance of
clothing, ete.; for vocational training; for traveling
expenses at home and abroad; for development of
engines, planes, etc.; for the maintenance of manu-
facturing plants; for aviation technical instruction at
schools; and also for the pay of reserve officers, enlisted
men, etc., called into service. To carry the act into
effect, section 10 provides an appropriation of
$640,000,000 ‘‘to be available until June thirtieth,
nineteen hundred eighteen.’’ There is no further or
other appropriation made in and by said act.
The act of July 9, 1918 (40 Stat. 845), is the
general appropriation act for the support of the
Army for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1919. The
portion of the act which is noted by the court in its
reasoning is the following:
Continuing the appropriations for the Signal
Service: That funds appropriated by the Act
approved July twenty-fourth, nineteen hun-
19
dred and seventeen, for the fiscal year nine-
teen hundred and eighteen, entitled ‘An Act
to authorize the President to increase tempo-
rarily the Signal Corps of the Army and to
purchase, maintain, manufacture, repair, and
operate airships, and make appropriations
therefor and for other purposes,” and the
funds appropriated for the Signal Service of
the Army in the Act approved May twelfth,
nineteen hundred and seventeen, entitled ‘“‘An
Act making appropriations for the support of
the Army for the fiscal year nineteen hundred
and eighteen,’ and October sixth, nineteen
hundred and seventeen, for the fiscal year
nineteen hundred and eighteen and _ prior
years entitled, ““An Act making appropria-
tions to supply urgent deficiencies and so
forth,” are hereby made available until June
thirtieth, nineteen hundred and nineteen.
The act of July 24, 1917, has already been noted
and the funds appropriated under that act have
been described. No funds, under said act, provided
for the payment at the rate of $100 per month of
enlisted men in training for officers of the Reserve
Corps. The funds appropriated in the act of May 12,
1917, are set out in 40 Stat., pages 42, 43, and 44.
Nowhere in said act and in the appropriations car-
ried by it—said act having been enacted prior to
June 15, 1917—is there any, even the slightest, ref-
erence to pay at the rate of $100 per month. The
act of October 6, 1917, is a deficiency bill for the
fiscal year ending June 30, 1918. The appropria-
tions of this act which by the act of July 9, 1918,
sactenin en Be
20
were extended and made available until June 30,
1919, are set out in 40 Stat., pages 355, 356. Nowhere
in said act is there any mention of the $100 per
month rate. In other words, the funds appro-
priated by these three acts and which by the act of
July 9, 1918, were made available until June 30,
1918, contained no item in the appropriations for
the payment at the rate of $100 per month. The
appropriation, which provided for that rate, being
the appropriation made in the act of June 15, 1917,
and was not extended by the act of July 9, 1918.
The attention of the court is called specifically to
the fact that this is so, although the appropriations
made for the Signal Service of the Army in the act
of May 12, 1917, enacted one month prior, are ex-
tended until June 30, 1919.
The further attention of the court is drawn to the
fact that the deficiency appropriation bill of October
6, 1917, on page 356, contains appropriations like
but not identical with those made on page 188 in the
act of June 15,1917. The appropriation in the act of
June 15, 1917, the first deficiency bill of this year,
provided :
Enlisted men of the line: For pay of enlisted
men of all grades, including recruits and pay
at $100 per month for enlisted men in training
for officers of the Reserve Corps, $226,882,560.
The like provision in the act of October 6, 1917,
reads:
Enlisted men of the line: For pay of en-
listed men of all grades, including recruits,
$250,000,000.
21
A careful, thorough, and complete reading of each
and all of these statutes clearly discloses the fact
that the court erred in holding that under the pro-
visions of the act of July 24, 1917, or the act of July
9, 1918, the rate of ‘‘pay at $100 per month for
enlisted men in training for officers of the Reserve
Corps,’’ set out in the act of June 15, 1917, by said
acts was extended from June 30, 1918, to June 30,
1919.
James M. Beck,
Solicitor General.
Rosert H. Lovett,
Assistant Attorney General.
JOHN G. EwIna,
Attorney.
FEBRUARY, 1923.
duthe Supreme Court of the Gnited States,
OcToOBER TERM, 1922.
Tut UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AP- }
rellant,
+ No. 510.
v.
NELSON W. RIDER, APPELLEE.
APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS,
SUPPLEMENTAL AND REPLY BRIEF FOR THE UNITED
STATES.
The reasoning of the court is that the act of June
15, 1917, 40 Stat. 188, fixed a rate of pay for enlisted
men in training for officers of the Reserve Corps
which, like other rates of pay for enlisted men of the
Army, could be increased by reason of duties per-
formed—such as flying; and that although specifi-
eally applicable only to an appropriation then made
which lapsed with June 30, 1918, vet by reason of
the fact that another and different appropriation was
available for the pay of enlisted men of the Avia-
tion Section of the Signal Enlisted Reserve Corps
which continued available to June 30, 1919, the
authority to pay enlisted men of the Aviation Sec-
tion, Signal Enlisted Reserve Corps, in training for
34338 —23
rorees'oa. Saray Ake WO ACIOE Mie BR _ ee OO AN Le aac ee ee tee ee a
2
officers, at the rate of $100 per month continued to
June 30, 1919.
To get a proper perspective of the question it is
necessary to go back to the events of 1915, the
preparedness parades, ete. It will be recalled that
the War Department, on its own initiative and with-
out legislative authority, organized training camps,
such as at Plattsburg Barracks, N. Y., where civil-
ians were given military training. There being no
statutory authority therefor, persons attending were
required to pay either their own transportation to
and from camp, were required to buy their uniforms,
were required to subsist themselves, and were re-
quired to serve without pay.
Legislative authority for camps of this character
for the military training of civilians was provided in
section 54 of the National Defense Act of June 3,
1916, 39 Stat. 194. Provision was there made for
transportation, uniforms, and subsistence—no pay.
The Army appropriation act of August 29, 1916, for
the fiscal year 1917, 39 Stat. 648, provided funds for
future camps and authorized reimbursement for
transportation and subsistence to persons who had
attended camps ordered by the Secretary of War
prior to the act of June 3, 1916. See 23 Comp.
Dec. 217.
This was the legislative authority for maintaining
training camps for civilians when war was declared
April 6, 1917.
“nlisted men of the Regular Army and of the
National Guard in Federal service were being sent to
a a Ss ETRE tra
SP ee CR Sa ERG Na eet cay
3
training camps for training to become officers and
while there were receiving the pay and allowances of
their grades; civilians received only transportation,
uniforms, and subsistence. Members of the enlisted
reserve corps ordered to active duty for training were
on the same footing as to pay and allowances as en-
listed men of the Regular Army, and in this class was
included the prospective officers of the Air Service,
then known as the Aviation Section, Signal Corps.
When any of these latter were, in the course of their
training, assigned to duty requiring participation in
regular and frequent aerial flights they were entitled
to an increase of 50 per cent of the pay of their grades.
Not so with civilians training under the same con-
ditions of service—they got nothing.
By the Army appropriation act of May 12, 1917, 40
Stat. 69-70, passed after the declaration of war, an
appropriation was made of $3,281,000 for civilian
military training camps: that is, the training camps
authorized by section 54 of the act of June 3, 1916,
and it was provided:
That the Secretary of War is hereby author-
ized out of this appropriation to pay to persons
designated by him for training as officers in
the Army during the period of their training
the sum of not to exceed $100 per month in
addition to the allowances authorized by said
section fifty-four: Provided, That they shall
agree to accept appointment in the Officers’
Reserve Corps in such grade as may be ten-
dered by the Secretary of War.
4
This is the only authority or appropriation for the
payment of $100 per month to civilians attending
training camps. This appropriation for the fiscal
year 1918 was supplemented by the deficiency ap-
propriations of June 15, 1917, 40 Stat. 198, October
6, 1917, id., 364; and July 8, 1918, id., 830, so that
it was only during the fiscal year 1918 that civilians
were authorized to be paid “not to exceed $100 per
month.” The provision under this head for the
fiscal year 1919 will be considered later.
With a view to placing enlisted men in training for
officers on the same footing as to pay as civilians in
training (many or most of the enlisted men were re-
cently from civil life, large numbers in the National
Guard) it was provided in the act of June 15, 1917,
in the appropriation of additional funds for pay of
enlisted men:
For pay of enlisted men of all grades, in-
cluding recruits, and pay at $100 per month
for enlisted men in training for officers of the
Reserve Corps, $226,882,560.
As this was a deficiency appropriation and as the
provision for pay was not permanent law but an
authority limited to the appropriation then made, it
is clear that it did not authorize pay at that rate be-
yond the year for which the appropriation was made.
The training camps for officers to which this appro-
priation and authority applied were established by
War Department Special Regulations No. 49, and
included only training for commissions in the In-
fantry, Cavalry, and Artillery.
5
Training camps or schools for the Aviation Section,
Signal Corps, were not considered by the Depart-
ment as training camps for officers; men who satis-
factorily completed the course of instruction were
recommended by the Chief Signal Officer for com-
mission, Dut the schools and camps were not included
in the training camp plans of the Department as
outlined in Special Regulations No. 49. When,
however, provision was made for pay at the rate of
$100 per month for enlisted men undergoing training
for officers the Chief Signal Officer brought to the
attention of the Secretary of War the disparity that
would exist between the pay of men in training who
might eventually be commissioned in the Aviation
Section, Signal Reserve Corps, and men in training
for commissions in the Infantry, Cavalry, and Ar-
tillery. The Adjutant General brought the matter
to the attention of the Chief of Staff in a memo-
randum, published in full at 26 Comp. Dec. 117,
and the Secretary of War, July 13, 1917, by approval
of the recommendation there made, directed that
enlisted men of the Signal Enlisted Reserve Corps
admitted to Signal Corps Aviation schools would be
considered as designated for training as officers of
the Army, and be placed on the same footing as to
pay and allowances as enlisted men detailed to
training camps for commissions in the Infantry,
Cavalry, and Artillery.
Here it is clear that the purpose was not to secure
& base pay to which was to be added 50 per cent
for flying duty, but a rate of pay for the entire period
6
of training, and that represented a substantial in-
crease over the amount theretofore paid to enlisted
aviation students assigned to flying duty.
It will thus be seen that the sole purpose of the
legislation of June 15, 1917, was to secure uniformity
in the pay of all persons undergoing training to
become officers, whether they were civilians who
came into the service for the training or were enlisted
men detailed for the training; yet it has never been
suggested that a civilian in training should receive
an increase of 50 per cent of the pay fixed by law
when that training included participation in flights.
This is fully discussed at 26 Comp. Dec. 746, which
see. And see also paragraphs 25 to 28, inclusive,
of War Department Special Regulations No. 49,
revised to August 15, 1917.
After over a year of war, after a year of the draft
act under which practically every able-bodied man
from 18 to 31 was subject to military duty, no
further necessity existed for offering inducements in
the way of pay to civilians to undertake training to
become officers, and the Army appropriation act
of July 9, 1918, 40 Stat. 876, appropriates only
$250,000 for arms and ordnance equipment in con-
nection with training camps; not one cent is appro-
priated for pay for civilians attending training camps,
although such camps were continued to the date of
the armistice, November 11, 1918. Civilians were
admitted, however, only after enlistment and _ re-
ceived no pay over and above their grades as enlisted
men. See Special Regulations No. 49, revised to
=_7
7
January 5, 1918, and amended February 5, 1918,
paragraph 2; and mimeographed regulations of
June 27, 1918.
These regulations contain the contemporaneous
departmental construction of legislation, perhaps
drafted by it; certainly passed at its suggestion.
This was the basis on which the training camps were
organized and conducted and this was the under-
standing of the committee of Congress having the
legislation in charge in making the appropriation
for the fiscal year 1919.
The statutes, regulations, and the decisions of
Comptroller of the Treasury applicable are:
Act of June 3, 1916, 39 Stat. 194-195;
Act of August 29, 1916, 39 Stat. 648:
Act of May 12, 1917, 40 Stat. 69-70;
Act of June 15, 1917, 40 Stat. 188 and 198;
Act of October 6, 1917, 40 Stat. 364;
Act of July 8, 1918, 40 Stat. 830;
Act of July 9, 1918, 40 Stat. 876;
Act of July 11, 1919, 41 Stat. 128;
Act of June 5, 1920, 41 Stat. 974;
23 Comp. Dec. 217;
26 Comp. Dec. 116 and 745;
War Department Special Regulations No.
49, 1st edition, not in library;
War Department Special Regulations No.
49, 2nd edition, in library;
War Department Special Regulations No.
49, 3rd edition, in library;
Mimeograph Regulations June 27, 1918; not
in library.
8
¥
To summarize: It was only by the action of the”
Secretary of War of July 13, 1917, that men of thé ©
Aviation Section, Signal Enlisted Reserve Corps, in
training were brought within the act of June 15, 1917,
see 26 Comp. Dec., 116; the purpose of the act was to 7
equalize the pay of enlisted men and civilians under-
going training during the fiscal year 1918; civilians in —
training for the Air Service could in no circumstances —
be paid more than $100 per month, the only pay pro-
vided by law for them; by reason of the draft act no |
provision was made for pay for either civilians or en-
listed men in training for officers after July 1, 1918;
and as the provision for increased pay for enlisted —
men in training for officers lapsed with June 30, 1918, -
the mere availability of the Aviation appropriation —
beyond that date is not authority for the payment of |
the increased amount in only that one branch of the |
service after that date.
JAMES M. Beck,
Solicitor General.
Rosert H. Loverrt,
Assistant Attorney General.
JoHN G. EwINa,
Attorney.
FEBRUARY, 1923.
APPELLEE'S
BRIEF
IN THE
Supreme Cour of the United States
OcToOBER TERM, 1922.
No. 510.
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
APPELLANT,
Us,
NELSON W. RIDER, APPELLEE.
APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS.
BRIEF FOR THE APPELLEE.
Statement.
The appellee, Nelson W. Rider, was an enlisted man
of the Aviation Section of the Signal Enlisted Reserve
Corps in training for officer of the Reserve Corps, other-
wise called Air Service Cadet, United States Army, dur-
ing the period from February 9, 1918, to September 13,
1918.
He was in training in the aviation ground course at
the School of Military Aeronautics, Urbana, IIl., from
February 9 to April 6, 1918, and at Camp Dick, Texas,
from April 11 to May 9, 1918. He was ordered to Taylor
Field, Alabama, on May 9, 1918, and reported there on
May 12, 1918, From May 12, 1918, to September 13,
9564—1
2
1918, he was on duty requiring regular and frequent
participation in aerial flights at Taylor Field.
From February 9, to June 30, 1918, claimant was paid
$100 per month, with no increase of pay during the
period he was engaged upon flight duty. From July
1 to September 13, 1918, plaintiff was paid $33_ per
month plus 50 per centum increase thereon for flight
duty, or $49.50 per month.
Claimant commenced active duty under his enlistment
in training for commission at the School of Military
Aeronautics, at Urbana, Ill. He pursued the course of
studies at the School of Military Aeronautics from Feb-
ruary 9 to April 6, 1918. The subjects of that course
were: Military Studies, Signalling, Gunnery, Aids to
Flight, Airplanes, Engines, Aerial Observation. All this
was before he was instructed in the art of flying; it was
entirely ground duty.
His flight duty did not begin until he was graduated
from the School of Military Aeronautics. He was some
time after graduation assigned to duty requiring regular
and frequent participation in aerial flights at Taylor
Field, a flying field. He flew almost daily one or more
times in an airplane. It was shown at the trial that flight
duty was performed of a most awesome peril.
ARGUMENT.
The Act of June 15, 1917, 40 Stat., 182, 188, ‘An Act
making appropriations to supply urgent deficiencies in
the appropriations for the military and naval establish-
ments on account of war expenses for the fiseal year end-
ing June 30, 1917, and for other purposes,’ provides:
“For pay of enlisted men of all grades, inelud-
ing recruits, and pay at $100 per month for en-
listed men in training for officers of the Reserve
Corps, $226,882,560,”’
<= PER ORI AIP SET
By section 2 of the above act, the appropriations
therein are made available to June 30, 1918.
3
I.
Act of June 15, 1917, Applies To All Enlisted Men of
the Army in Training for Officers of the Reserve
Corps.
Counsel for the United States now makes the conten-
tion that the language “‘ enlisted men in training for officers
of the Reserve Corps” in the foregoing provision in the Act
of June 15, 1917, includes only the enlisted men of the line
of the army, and that therefore the provision is not ap-
plicable to enlisted men of the Aviation Section in train-
ing for officers of the Reserve Corps.
This contention is made in the face of the fact that
the administrative officers of the Government have con-
strued the provision to apply to aviation enlisted men in
training for officers of the Reserve Corps.
It is made in the face of the fact that the claimant
has already been paid by the Government for the period
he was in training for commission as aviation enlisted
man at $100 per month in accordance with the terms
of his enlistment, during the period that appropriations
were available by the Act of June 15, 1917, for enlisted
men in training for officers of the Reserve Corps.
It is now contended by counsel for the United States
that the provision is limited to enlisted men of the
line because of the sub-heading “PAY OF ENLISTED
MEN OF THE LINE” of the heading “PAY OF THE
ARMY.”
A reading of the committee hearing set out in the Gov-
ernment’s brief shows that the provision was proposed
and aecepted for the purpose of taking care of enlisted
men generally in training for officers of the Reserve
Corps. It was inserted at what was considered a con-
4
venient place in the statute, the language used being
broad enough to cover enlisted men of all branches
in such training. The committee was told that without a
provision of this kind under pay of the army no
enlisted man could be paid any special rate while in
training for a commission. To restrict its application
to enlisted men of the line merely because 0f its juxta-
position to a sub-heading, and that is the only reason
advanced by the Government for such a construction,
would violate not only the language used but the obvious
legislative intent. The contention of Government coun-
sel is contrary to the elementary rule of statutory con-
struction that general words in a statute ‘“‘are to have a
general operation unless the manifest intention of the
legislature affords grounds for qualifying or restraining
them.”
The court may take judicial notice of the provision of
the Act of July 9, 1918, 40 Stat., 849, declaring that
after that date ‘‘no person otherwise qualified for serv-
iceascadet . . . inthe aviation service shall be de-
barred from such service by reason of not being equipped
with a college education,” as evidence of the fact that
Air Service Cadets were picked men of very high quali-
fication. They were picked after very exacting physical
examination from college graduates of the country who
volunteered for the risk, hazard and peril of flight duty
during the war.
Congress could not reasonably have intended merely
to allow enlisted men of the infantry, cavalry, and
artillery $100 per month while in training for officers
of the Reserve Corps and deny it to aviation enlisted
men in such training.
Air Service Combatant Arm or Line of the Army.
The line of the army is the fighting portion of the
military service. Wilhelm’s Military Dictionary (1881)
5
p. 280. While years ago the line may have consisted
only of the infantry, cavalry, and artillery, nevertheless,
at least since the beginning of the World War because
of the modern conditions of warfare, the line of the Army
has come to include other arms of the service; notably,
the Air Service. There can be no question that flying
men of the Aviation Section were essentially combatant
forees and operated as fighting men directly employed
in battle. It may be said that the Air Service was the
most hazardous and perilous fighting branch of the
military service, with constant risk and sacrifice of life
not only in combat and battle but at all times.
Under the authority of the Acts of May 18, 1917,
40 Stat., 182; July 24, 1917, 40 Stat., 243: and May
20, 1918, 40 Stat., 556; the President directed the or-
ganization of the Air Service, comprising the aviation
section of the Signal Corps. (See note under heading
Air Service, in Military Laws of the United States,
Annotated, 6th Edition, 1921, p. 391.)
In Changes, Army Regulations, No. 73, War Depart-
ment, June 10, 1918, para. 1575, this appears:
“1575. The Chief of Air Service will be
charged, under direction of the Secretary of
War, with the command of the Air Service,
both staff and line. Ng
There is no statute anywhere so far as counsel can
discover that designates the line of the Army until
the Act of June 4, 1920, 41 Stat., 759, which by See-
tion 2 provides:
“Compesition of the Regular Army.—The
Regular Army of the United States shall consist
of the Infantry, the Cavalry, the Field Artillery,
the Coast Artillery Corps, the Air Service,
the Corps of Engineers, the Signal Corps, which
shall be designated as the combatant arms or
the line of the Army. ay
6
It is clear from the above facts and the reading of
the regulation and law declaratory thereof that aviation
enlisted men were for the whole period of the national
emergency enlisted men of the line.
Section 8, of the Act of July 24, 1917, 40 Stat., 243,
is to be noted which provides:
“That all officers and enlisted men of the tem-
porary forces of the Signal Corps, including the
aviation section thereof provided for herein,
shall be in all respects on the same footing as to
pay, allowances and pensicns as permanent officers
and enlisted men of corresponding grades and
length of service in the Regular Army.”
This Act enacted subsequent to the approval of
the Act of June 15, 1917, confers upon the enlisted man
of the Aviation Section in training for an officer of the
Reserve Corps the same rate of pay as that allowed
enlisted men of the Army likewise engaged, $100 per
month.
I].
Claimant Entitled to 50 Per Cent Increase in His Pay.
The Act of July 18, 1914, 38 Stat., 514, 516, ‘‘An Act
to increase the efficiency of the aviation service of the
Army, and for other purposes,”’ provides:
“That twelve enlisted men at a time shall, in the
discretion of the officer in command of the avia-
tion section, be instructed in the art of flying,
and no enlisted man shall be assigned to duty
as an aerial flyer against his will except in time of
war. Each aviation enlisted man, while on duty
that requires him to participate regularly and fre-
quently in aerial flights, or while holding the rating
of aviation mechanician, shall receive an increase
of 50 per centum in his pay.”’
The above is amplified by the Act of June 3, 1916, 39
Stat. 175.
7
The Act of June 3, 1916, The National Defense Act, by
the second proviso of section 13, provides:
‘That the Secretary of War shall have authorit y
to cause as many enlisted men of the Aviation
Section to be instructed in the art of flying
as he may deem necessary.”
The Army Regulation, Paragraph 1342}, Changes
Army Regulations No. 73, War Department, June 10,
1918, is set forth in plaintiff's petition (Ree., p. 2).
Prior to the Act of July 18, 1914, above, increases were
provided by law for officers of the Signal Corps on
aviation duty. The Act of July 18, 1914, is the first that
enjoined flight duty on enlisted men. It provides, how-
ever, that an aviation enlisted man shall not be required
to perform flight duty against his will, except in time of
war. It is likewise the first act in which increase in pay
for aviation flight duty is provided for enlisted men for
the risk, hazard and peril of that duty.
In brief the Act of July 18, 1914, provides for flying
increase in pay as follows:
Military Aviators.
Rank, pay and allowances of
one grade higher, and in-
crease of 75 per cent in pay.
Junior Military Aviators.
Rank, pay and allowances of
one grade higher, and in
crease of 50 per cent in pay.
Aviation Officers:
Aviation Students.
Increase of .25 per cent in pay.
Flyers.
j Increase of 50 per cent in pay.
Aviation Enlisted Men:
Mechanicians.
Increase of 50 per cent in pay.
Pe. ae
PENT EE
jam
8
Aviation student officers mentioned in the chart,
were instructed in the art of flying together with the
cadets.
It is to be noted that the Act of July 18, 1914, relates
to the Signal Corps of the United States Army, and more
especially to the Aviation Section thereof. It is apparent
that the provision refers to aviation enlisted men apart
from enlisted men of other branches of the Army. It
deals exclusively with officers and enlisted men of the
Aviation Section of the Signal Corps and singles out sol-
diers of that branch of the army for flight duty.
On the other hand, the Act of June 15, 1917, in the
provision for pay at $100 per month, deals with all
enlisted men in training for officer in the Reserve Corps.
It deals with enlisted men generally.
The aviation increase provision of the Act of July 18,
1914, not only deals specifically with aviation enlisted
men exclusive of enlisted men of other branches of the
Army, but it singles out the aviation enlisted men on
duty that requires participation regularly and frequently
in aerial flights.
So the aviation enlisted man on duty that requires
regular and frequent participation in aerial flights
should receive for the risk, hazard and peril of that duty
what the law provides, viz. increase of 50 per centum in
his pay. Congress did not repeal the Act of July 18,
1914, which so provides by the Act of June 15, 1917, in
the provision for pay at $100 per month for enlisted
men in training for officer of the Reserve Corps.
Ruling Case Law, 25 R. C. L., 169, says:
“Repeals by implication are not favored, and
will not be indulged if there is any other reason-
able construction. The presumption is always
against the intention to repeal where express
terms are not used, and the implication, in order
to be operative, must be necessary. A law is
not repealed by a later enactment, if the provi-
"ac
9
sions of the two laws are not irreconcilable nor
necessarily inconsistent, but both may stand and
be operative without repugnance to each other.
Nor can one act be allowed to defeat another, if,
by a fair and reasonable construction, the two
can be made to stand together. Although two
acts ale seemingly contradictory or repugnant,
they are, if possible by a fair and reasonable
interpretation, to be given such a construction
that both may have effect.”
The following from Black on Interpretation of Laws,
p. 116, is quoted with approval by this court in Rodgers
vs. the United States, 185 U. S., 83:
“As a corollary from the doctrine that im-
plied repeals are not favored, it has come to be
an established rule in the construction of sta-
tutes that a subsequent act, treating a subject
in general terms and not expressly contradicting
the provisions of a prior special statute, is not
to be considered as intended to affect the more
particular and specific provisions of the earlier
act, unless it is absolutely necessary so to con-
strue it in order to give its words any meaning
at all.”
In its nature the aviation increase provision can not
operate alone, and the provision for pay is the very
thing in harmony with its operation and indeed necessary
for its computation. (See 25 Comp., Dec. 63.)
Thus it is clear that the provision for flying risk
increase in pay of aviation enlisted men of the Act of
July 18, 1914, is not repealed by the provision of the
Act of June 15, 1917, for pay at $100 per month for
enlisted men in training for officers of the Reserve Corps.
Pay of Aviation Enlisted Men at $100 per Mowrit
Extended to June 30, 1919
On the day following June 30. 1418S. whole chee
was in the performance of his duties. while tll om tran
ing for a commission, without any change in the mature
of his duties, while in the performance of aerial flights
in an airplane, and without any change whatsoever
except the change on the pay roll, his pay was cut
to $33 per month.
After June 30, 1918, he received pay at $33 per month.
Also he has been paid 50 per cent increase therein as
aviation enlisted man on flight duty.
The Act of June 15, 1917, above, prescribes the pay
of an enlisted man in training for commission in the
Officers Reserve Corps at $100 per month.
Claimant relies upon the Act of June 15, 1917, in
so far as its prescribes pay at $100 per month to en-
listed men in training for commission and upon the
Act of July 24, 1917, in sections 8, 9 and 10 as supple-
mental:
“Sec. 9. That during the existing emergency
authority is given the President, through the
War Department, for the purchase . . . of
airships. . . . And also to pay and other-
wise provide for . . . such enlisted men
of the Enlisted Reserve Corps of the Aviation
Section of the Signal Corps as may be called
into active service and such enlisted men as may
be enlisted in the Aviation Section of the Signal
Corps under the provisions of section 2 of the
act to increase temporarily the military estab-
lishment of the United States, approved May
eighteenth, nineteen hundred and seventeen, or
any subsequent act temporarily increasing the
commissioned or enlisted personnel of the Avia-
tion Section of the Signal Corps. . . .: Pro-
vided, That hereafter all . . . enlisted men
1]
* the Aviation Section of the Signal Corps
stall be paid by Quartermaster disbursing officers
‘rem funds transferred to their credit from Signal
‘orp. appropriations.
“See. 10. ‘That for the purpose of carrying this
act into effect the sum of $640,000,000 is hereby
appropriated out of any funds in the Treasury not
otherwise appropriated, to be available ‘until
June thirtieth, nineteen hundred and eighteen.”
Claimant insists that the rate of pay at $100 per
month prescribed in the Act of June 15, 1917, is au-
thorized for the then existing emergency by the Act of
July 24, 1917, for pay of aviation enlisted men in train-
ing for commission. By the provisions of sections 8, 9,
and 10 of the latter act, his rate of pay at $100 per
month prescribed by the Act of June 15, 1917. was drawn
and transferred into the Act of July 24, 1917, and was
payable from the appropriations therein.
Section 8 of the latter is again to be noted, which
provides:
“That all officers and enlisted men of the
temporary forees of the Signal Corps, including
the aviation section thereof provided for herein,
shall be in all respects on the same footing as
to pay, allowances and pensions as permanent
officers and enlisted men of corresponding grades
and length of service in the Regular Army.”
The provision for pay in section 9 of the same act, while
general as to rates, is specifie as to aviation enlisted
men. The provision for pay at $100 per month in the
Act of June 15, 1917, while specific as to rate, is general
as to enlisted men of all branches. The more specific
therefore is that giving authority during the existing
emergency to pay and otherwise provide for aviation
enlisted men. As a matter of elementary law, it is there-
fore supplemental in respect to the rate of pay at $100
12
per month prescribed by the Act of June 15, 1917, which
merges into the authority to pay the existing rates of
pay. Section 9 of the Act of July 24, 1917, also provides
that thereafter aviation enlisted men be paid out of Sig-
nal Corps appropriations. Hence aviation enlisted men
should receive the rate of pay prescribed for service in
training for commission out of Signal Corps appropria-
tions as long as the authority to pay and provide for them
by the Act of July 24, 1917, continued, which was for and
during the existing emergency.
The Act of July 9, 1918, 40 Stat., 845, already referred
to in regard to qualifications of the cadet of the Air
Service, is again to be noted. It is entitled ‘‘An Act
making appropriations for the support of the Army
for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1919.’ and on p.
849 and 850, provides:
“Continuing the Appropriations for the Signal
Service.—That funds appropriated by the act
approved July twenty-fourth, nineteen hundred
and seventeen, for the fiscal year nineteen hundred
and eighteen, entitled ‘An Act to authorize the
President to increase temporarily the Signal
Corps of the Army . . . and make ap-
propriations therefor and for other purposes,’
and the funds appropriated for the Signal Serv-
ice of the Army in the Act of May twelfth, nine-
teen hundred and seventeen entitled ‘An Act
making appropriations for the support of the
Army for the fiseal year nineteen hundred and
eighteen, . . . are hereby made available
until June thirtieth, nineteen hundred and nine-
teen.”
The Act of May 12, 1917, 40 Stat., 40, 42, referred
to in the above together with the Act of July 24, 1917,
provides:
“That of the sum ($10,800,000) last above
mentioned so much thereof as may be necessary
will be available for paying and otherwise provid-
13
ing for such officers of the Officers Reserve
Corps of the Aviation Section of the Signal Corps
and such enlisted men of the Enlisted Reserve
Corps of the Aviation Section of the Signal Corps
as may be called into active service.”
See also Joint Resolution of July 8, 1918, 39 Stat., 843,
Chap., 140, by which all appropriations for the support
of the Army in effect June 30, 1918, are extended to
July 9, 1918.
The claimant continued to perform the duty of
Air Service Cadet after June 30, 1918. He has received
base pay to that date at the rate of $100 per month;
and after that date at the rate of $33 per month. Con-
gress continued Signal Service appropriations by the
Act of July 9, 1918, to June 30, 1919, and thereby ex-
tended the basic rate of $100 per month for aviation
enlisted men in training for commissions. No other
rate had been established for this class of enlisted men,
and it does not appear that there was any intention
°n the pait of Congress to repeal the provision fixing
the pay of enlisted men in training for officers of the
Reserve Corps. Despite this fact, et the very height of
the war period, the base pay of the claimant was re-
duced by the administrative officers from $100 to $33
per month. As the Court of Claims well says: “It is
hardly possible to conceive that Congress would at the
height of the emergency, while the war was going
on, reduce the pay which had been held forth as an
inducement to the young men of the country to enter
into training for officers in the Reserve Corps.”’
HENRY W. DRISCOLL,
Attorney for Appellee.
HARVEY D. JACOB,
RICHARD P. WHITELEY,
Of Counsel.
February, 1923.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.