Transcript of Record — Mine Workers v. Coronado Coal Co.

Supreme Court brief1922

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

s

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,

OCTOBER TERM, 1920.

No. 239.

UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL.,

PLAINTIFFS IN ERROR,

Vs.

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL., DEFENDANTS

IN ERROR.

IN ERROR TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT.

INDEX.

Caption to Transcript from U. 8. Circuit Court of Appeals... Original. Print.

Citation and Waiver of Service.................cccceccccccsecccess 1 1

Writ of Error and Clerk’s Return. .........0....0..ccccecccucccees 2 2

Caption to Transcript from U. 8. District Court................... 4 4

FORE RR AROS, ap eG gor A 5 5

Itemized 1 amages to Hartford Coal Co., et al................... 12 10

NN NES SOLE SU REE RT A 3 “B

Writ of Attachment issued September 1, 1914, and Marshal’s Return. 20 15

Writ of Garnishment issued September 1, 1914, and Marshal’s Return. 22 16

Writ of Attachment issued September 1, 1914, and Marshal’s Return. 24 17

Summons issued September 1, 1914, and Marshal’s Return.......... 2 19

Writ of Attachment issued September 2, 1914, and Marshal’s Return. 33 23

Original. Print.

Writ of Attachment istued September 4, 1914 a4 Maths Return.

Amendment to Complaint...

Summons issued September 16, ‘1914, and Marshal’ 8 Return..

Petition of George Westwood, et al., for Leave to Intervene, ote.

Hearing, October 5, 1914, on Petition of George Westwood, et al.,

EE PERT ELTON CTY TERT CCEL PETE

Hearing, October 17, 1914, on Petition of George Westwood, et al.,

ee ee” POPP TEV ELE ERIE LEE TEL TEEPE

Writ of Attachment issued November 7, 1914, and Marshal's Return.

Writ of Attachment issued November 10, 1914, and Marshal's Return,

Writ of Attachment issued November 11, 1914, and Marshal's Return.

Writ of Attachment issued November 12, 1914, and Marshal's Return.

Summons issued November 16, 1914, and Marshal's Return.........

Writ of Attachment issued November 20, 1914, and Marshal's Return.

Writ of Attachment issued December 1, 1914, and Marshal's Return.

Order, December 3, 1914, releasing certain Funds from Garnishment.

Answer of Sebastian County Bank, as Garnishee................ ;

Answer of Fred Gentry, as Garnishee...........666 66 6c cece

Answer of J. W. McGehee, as Garnishee..................

Answer of Charles E. Osborn, as Garnishee. . . Viper

Answer of German American Bank, as Garnishee..........

Answer of Bank of Clarksville, as Garnishee....................

Answer of First National Bank, as Garnishee....................55

Answer of John R. McBride, as Garnishee.................

Answer of C. C. Calvert, as Garnishee................. Pees Cae

Answer of Huntington State Bank, as Garnishee.................+5

Answer of Branner Coal Company, as Garnishee..................+

Answer of American National Bank, as Garnishee..................

Answer of Midland State Bank, as Garnishee...................065

Answer of Citizens Bank of Coal Hill, as Garnishee..............

Record Entry of the filing of Separate Answers of American National

Bank, ot al., ae Garmighees.........:.ccsccccccsccsvsvcnererees

Record Entry ‘of the filing of Separate Answers of Sebastian C ounty

Bank, ot al., a0 Garnighees......5.. 0 scccsscvcrensrececeeesneees

Answer of Bank of Hartford, as Garnishee,...............55:

Record Entry of the filing of Answer of Bank of Hartford, as

Answer of C. R. Owsley, as Garnishee...........666 665 c cere ern ees

Record Entry of the filing of Answer of C, R. Owsley, as Garnishee,

Answer of Receivers of: Bolen-Darnall Coal Company, as Garnishee.

Record Entry of the filing of Answer of Receivers of Bolen-Darnall

Coal Company, as Garnishee,.........6 6666 ees

Answer of George Henry, as Garnishee..........6 6666666 s eee e es

Record Entry of the filing of Answer of George Henry, as Garnishee,

Stipulation extending Time to or 16, 1915, to file Answer,

Damrver OF Mov, €66..... 00. ccvecsevesvcrrcrvvcvcsnevsevcees

Motion of Defendants to Dismiss...........6 65600000 e erence ees ?

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on United Mine Workers of

EES EL ESAS AE DRO NOT PEPE er OR PERT E TUL TELE

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 340......

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 374.....-

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 560......

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 586......

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1180.....

03

25

26

28

$l

33

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1526.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1530...

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1565.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1810

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1814.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1824....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1912.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 1934

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2053... .

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 2160.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 2316.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union; No, 2766.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 2769.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 2770

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2841

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2880

Record Entry of the filing of Separate Motions to Quash Service of

Summons on United Mine Workers and others...................

Answer of First National Bank of Clarksville, as Garnishee.....

Order, May 22, 1915, sustaining Separate Motions to Quash Service

of Summons on Local Union, No. 560, and others, and overruling

Separate Motions to quash Service of Summons on United Mine

Workers and others and exceptions thereto.................

Demurrer of Defendant, Joe Kervillas, et al., to Complaint. .

Record Entry of the filing of Demurrer of Defendant, Joe Kervillas,

RE EP PEP COLT EE CCRET TOL ICT OPER eTEY 4%

Summons issued May 24, 1915, and Marshal's Return.......... fees

Order of Submission of Demurrer of Joe Kervillas, et al., to

oS ee PPE EL PECL Ie eer eT Ue TPE TT eC PE RET ce

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Fred W. Holt...........

Record Entry of the filing of Motion to Quash Service of Summons

PTT Pre We POe rere TTT TRE ETC Terre

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on United Mine Workers of

ats enh furde c sees Joe Vw TE LY Oo Be TR

Order, June 15, 1915, overruling Motion to Quash Service of Sum-

mons on United Mine Workers of America, and Exceptions (hereto.

Demurrer of Local Union, No, 340, to C omplaint PA rear ee

Order overruling Demurrer of Local Union, No. 340, and Exceptions 8

Demurrer of Local Union, No. 1130, to Complaint. .

Order overruling Demurrer of Local Union, No. 1130, and Excep-

tions thereto. . ;

Demurrer of Local Union, No. 1561, to ¢ Jomplaint.. DPE ee

Order overruling Demurrer of Local Union, No. 1561, and Excep-

ee ere rer rrr Tre rer rey Teer TT TET er

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 560

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 586

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1526

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1530

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1810

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1814

Motion to Qaash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 1842

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 1912.....

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 1934.....

re caca ac tar Las ama Pte aicale Ccahdiaa hs cahetilich arth ARORA ea Rae nei is Mia dil a A a ie da)

6

Original. Print.

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No, 2053.... 157 97

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2110..... 158 08

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2160..... 159 98

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2027..... 160 9%

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2404..... 161 100

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2766 162. «101

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2769 163101

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2770..... 164 102

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2772..... 165 108

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2880..... 166 108

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on Local Union, No. 2841 167.104

Order, June 15, 1915, overruling Separate Motions of Local Union,

No. 560, and others to Quash Service of Summons and Exceptions

RL daktchiawedinescac 168-105

Demurrer of United Mine Workers of America and others to Com-

| SLR RE 173108

Record Entry of the filing of Demurrer of U nited Mine Workers of

America and others to Complaint. ...... 177110

Order, July 6, 1915, sustaining Demurrer of U nited Mine Workers of

America and others to Complaint, and granting Plaintiffs Leave

to file Amended Complaint. . eles LAdbeiceRcanie . 78 Il

Amended Complaint, filed July 6, 1915. in We kdak neha nen 179 «1h

Itemized Damages to Hartford Coal Co., et al...... 193 hI

Notice of Application for Leave to file Second Amended Complaint. 199 126

Order granting Leave to file Second Amended Complaint and Ex-

PEELE ORR Ie EEO COLT CE CE OTEET TERT T 200 «12

Second Amended Complaint, filed July 13, 1915............. .. OB 1277

Itemized Damages to Hartford Coal Co., et al......... 225 144

Demurrer of United Mine Workers of America and ot hers to Second

rs sci nxt ve ws Riedie se kant SBAA WS 230 «148

Demurrer of P. R. Stewart, et al., to Second Amended C omplaint. 234 «151

Order of Submission of Demurrer of United Mine Workers of America

and others to Second Amended Complaint........... 237158

Order allowing Names of Joe Kervillas and other Defendants to be

attached as a part of second Amended Complaint. . ey 238 «(158

Motion to Discharge Attachments and Garnishments served upon

the American National Bank of Fort Smith, Arkansas, and others. 230 154

Sg eer rrerrrr Terri rier aire 244~=«:157

Record Entry of the filing of Motion to Discharge Attachments,

etc., and Intervention of District, No. 21...........66 6666s e ees 247 «159

Order, October 20, 1915, sustaining Demurrers to Second Amended

Coniplaint and dismissing cause, and Exceptions thereto... ... 248 «150

Order, October 25, 1915, discharging Attachments and Garnish-

ments against the American National Bank of Fort Smith, Arkan-

i Ss nvcnshennehadades UhAkbes kd baeebtacteeneay 250 =«1e0

Summons issued September 23, 1916, and Marshal's Return......... 253 «162

Motion to Vacate Decree of District Court, sustaining Demurrers

to Complaint and requiring Defendants to plead within 10 days, 255 162

Mandate of U. 8. Cireuit Court of Appeals and Order, February 7,

1917, entered thereon, vacating Decree of Dismissal of the Dis- ;

trict Court and overruling Demurrers..............6.56050000 6 256 «(1683

Motion of United Mine Workers of America, et al., to Strike out

certain Parts of Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint......... 263 «(168

Original. Print.

Record Entry of the filing of Motion of United Mine Workers of

tiffs’ Second Amended Complaint... .... eee biiecenne) Ge

Record Entry of the filing of Motion of P. R. Stewart, et al., to

Strike out, ete........... “peers web iiee sat ... 0

Third Amended Complaint, filed February 27, 1917... cveces ae

Itemized Damages to Hartford Coal Co., et al .. &

Record Entry of the filing of Third Amended Complaint... , , .. 313

Motion to Amend Caption to Third Amended Complaint... .., 314

Order, February 28, 1917, allowing Amendment to Caption to Third

Amended Complaint.................... RAD AANORES CCN NC RNR G 315

Motion for Leave to Amend Marshal's Return on Summons issued

to Distriet, No. 21, of the United Mine Workers of America...... 316

Order, February 28, 1917, allowing Amend nt to Marshal's Return

on Summons issued to Distriet No. 21, of the United Mine Workers

SMM Ss vos ceevasvessisie4sseencenensvinsetsings cc 317

RLmeebenneveert : - 320

Summons issued February 28, 1917, and Marshal's Return. . .». 982i

Demurrer of United Mine Workers of America, et al., to Third

Amended Complaint.............................. 32%

Amended Complaint...........___ WINV EN SAiex ca beredes te . 828

Motion of Distriet, No. 21, of the United Mine Workers of America,

to Quash Return of Service of Summons... .. . 329

Record Entry of the filing of Motion of Distriet, No. 21, of the

United Mine Workers of America, to Quash Return of Service of

AEE D ASF Vrehtid buss Seenssasinestsssbscisccec cl 3306-212

Motion for Judgment by Default against United Mine Workers of

America, District, No, 21

Motion to Quash Service of Summons on District, No. 21, and Motion

for Judgment by Default against District, No, 21, withdrawn;

Order of Submission of Motion of United Mine Workers of America,

et al., to Strike out certain Parts of Third Amended Complaint, ete, 333-214

Motion of United Mine Workers of America, et al., to Strike out

certain Parts of Third Amended on A as 3344

Motion to Require Plaintiffs to make Complaint more Definite and

Certain

Order, May 10. 1917, overruling Motion of United Mine Workers of

America, et al., to Strike out certain Parts of Third Amended

Complaint and Exceptions thereto................._

Order sustaining in Part and overruling in Part Defendants’ Motion

to require Plaintiffs to make Complaint more Definite and Certain. 348 294

Amendments to Paragraphs 12 and 21 of the Amended Complaint, 349 224

Record Entry of the filing of Amendments to Paragraphs 12 and 21

of the Amended Complaint

Motion to make Complaint and Amendments thereto more Definite

and Certain............... soreesesees O87 @90

Original. Print.

Record Entry of the filing of Motion to make Complaint and Amend-

ments thereto more Definite and Certain.......--..---..-------- 361 231

Order sustaining in Part and overruling in Part Motion to make

Complaint and Amendments thereto more Definite and Certain. 362 2382

Amendment to Paragraph 21 of the Comat... 5 <-< os. Sse os seer « 363 232

Record Entry of the filing of Amendment to Paragraph 21 of the

MARANL. «cs ie .cu<2-c-sesoaeve epee srune neseuaensparnretnarns 372 238

Separate Answer of the United Mine Workers of America........... 73 ©6238

Separate Answer of District, No. 21, of the United Mine Workers

SU MMMMERS. .- . =. - os oe cn cenecswnnecevecnnscnsceceseetesesseners 414 265

Separate Answer of each Cel MIWA ops Wasicin gee > om meee rae 418 268

Separate Answer of Defendants, P. R. Stewart; et al... ...<...--<<-- 419 268

Record Entry of the filing of Answers to Third Amended Complaint. 421 269

Petition filed September 6, 1917, for the Production of certain Docu-

ments and Papers at the Trial of the Case........-..---------++: 423. 270

Amended Petition for the Production of certain Documents and

Papers at the Trial of the Case... ........----+---+++++2seseere 435 278

Answer to Amended Petition for the Production of certain Docu-

ments and Papers et the Trial of the Case.........-..------+++>- 447-286

Exhibit A, Affidavit of Frank J. Hayes as to the Destruction of

all Reports of the International Organizers for the Year 1914.. 453 291

Order of submission of Amended Petition to produce Documents and

Papers at Trial, etc.........-.----00e-eeee cece eer e ent ereretet es 454 291

Order overruling Amended Petition to Produce, ete.......-----.--- 455 292

Petition filed September 20, 1917, to require Defendants to Produce

certain Documents at the Trial..........-.-------+-+-+5+000°° 456 292

Response to Petition to require Defendants to Produce, ete. ....--- 496 =—299

Order of Submission of Motion to Produce..........--.--+-++++++* 468 301

Order requiring Defendants to Produce certain Documents and

Papers at the Trial...........-------2--0eseeecrereer cesses 469 301

Petition filed September 28, 1917, to Produce certain Documents

and Papers at the Trial..........-.---------++-eseerteerreees 472 303

to Petition to Produce certain Documents and Papers... 479 308

Petition filed September 28, 1917, to Produce certain Documents

and Papers at the Trial.............-------+sesseeeereeterstte 481 309

Response to Petition to Produce certain Documents and Papers..... 485 312

Order, September 28, 1917, requiring Defendants to Produce certain

Documents and Papers at the Trial........ ak bce cusaeenen eek 487 313

Order overruling Motion to Postpone Trial.........---..----++:5°> 490 314

Stipulation for Postponement BO A ee eee oy epee yt ara eee ee 491 315

Order, October 1, 1917, granting Continuance........--.--+--+--+°> 492 315

Petition filed October 13, 1917, to Produce certain Expense Accounts,

Papers and Documents at the Trial..........-.-------0+ +0000 01" 493 315

Order, October 13, 1917, requiring Defendants to Produce certain

Documents and Papers.............---2-:0ccseere eee seeseeeneees 505 324

Jury Impaneled; Trial, October 23, So ce ae ha ean gad 508 326

Protest of United Mine Workers of America, et al., against the

Production of certain Documents and Papers........------++---"- 510 = 327

Protest of District, No. 21, of the United Mine Workers of America

against the Production of certain Documents and Papers.....-- 516 0331

Protest of Local Unions against the Production of certain Documents

and Papers....... De Ne poo tlt id at ae care ee eee Ree 518 333

Trial, October 24, 1917.....-.------0-seeeeeree cree rere nrsees sees 520 «334

Trial, October 25, 1917,.......+-:-2secereceessencerseensreeersere” 521 334.

se We : Sane ee mea ane I araree, ee Peace wet pag 9 522 334

pe + ae RA at aA ee highs te ge aOR FRE ARID G8 523 335

Motion of Defendants to produce certain Books and Papers, filed

SORE NE on ado oe en Le eee ole et eae 524 335

Exhibit A, Request of Counsel for Defendants served on Counsel

for Wenmatue to eee, OO... 5 ko oo hac ek os oes 528 338

Order, October 29, 1917, to Produce certain Books, ete............. 530 339

MN, RIN MOINS oo oc ool Fok Sos lok ec eee 531 340

Cees ER Rn oe ee es A ee 532 340

Trial, Oetober’3l, 19017; . ............55..- Re ral ion et eee ee 533 340

ee ae Pe Sie Rm a sie eee 534 340

Sas, Pec NMR ee oN re te i ee ee te 535 346

Response to Defendants’ Motion to Produce certain Books, ete... .. 536 341

PRR Olt) Te MI oe en ee No Se 536 = 341

Stipulation as to Testimony of Ed Parrish and Eva Trannell....__.. 538 342

pg RS Re aa Bele a aed eee WE UME ei yt 539 343

EN PE RED os ooo fs ek Seo ee a 540 «4343

ENSOE IIE PONT Sone lee cache en ee 541 343

ye RR ce: Sa eee it Le eee Rae a teeta ear lee h 542 344

Deen: TUN MET SS el er 543s 344

nL | OMEN Sho nk oa Wa eee Pehl Rees 44 344

eeu; meen ON et. Ce a ee 5453.44

aan PR EE eS oo Re ae Ph AR ee 546345

Nice, ee hes ED ee 1 hae ‘47 345

Defendants’ Motion to Strike out certain Testimony............... 548 346

Motion of Defendants, United Mine Workers of America, et al.,

ie Sperm OME oo Grek me TiN Oa, ee ee 552 348

ule Me Ee NE ne ie dd 553 349

eee SY De Io er A ee Re 554 349

Ms NII PII soe con u's ok ca Poa Seawicdenccocen mse 555349

as or eS es eae Oa ee 556-349

Motion of Defendants, United Mine Workers of America, et al., for

ce gg EE TERED TER SIME BAD OR ple nd hs 557 = 350

Motion of Defendants, P. R. Stewart, et al., for a Directed Verdict. 558-351

Plaintiffs’ Motion to Strike out certain Questions and Answers of

Witness, John P. White

Poe ona Meith ieee bone ee eee 560 352

- ee ead ee er aS Sa eee aT ed 561 352

I oc eo a ee 563 353

MU MUI I oo 5 os Sn's vio bd Coc lnc ccmuds coveecc licens” 564 354

Verdict and Judgment, November 22, 1917......................... 565 354

Motion for Allowance of Interest on OE So ine 568 356

Motion of Plaintiffs to Tax a Reasonable Attorneys’ Fee........... 570 = 357

Motion of Defendants, United Mine Workers, et al., for a Judgment

notwithetanding the Verdict..........................-.....c-. 571 = 358

Motion of Defendants, P. R. Stewart, et al., for a Judgment not-

withstanding the Verdict............................ Seah eet 574 360

Record Entry of the filing of Motions for Judgment notwithstanding

a EEE ESAS RT BOTS tS eee eae er een uti: 576 361

Order continuing Hearing of certain Motions....................... 577-362

Order overruling Motions for Judgment notwithstanding the Verdict. 578 362

Order granting further Stay of SONMIINE c.. So) eo a ae 579 = 363

OS EEE OSE DS NII ee ee BT Bak ho 580 363

Pama she yqltacor awry seis Sis caw ee a Meee teNae ah ee es 580 363

: Original.

Protest of United Mine Workers of America, et al., against the

Production to certain Documents and Papers overruled and

Exceptions thereto, Recital of............--+-+000sseeeereer ees 581

Testimony for Plaintiffs. ...........-.----6-- seer creer eee eres 582

William Green, Deposition of...........-..---+-00eee seer eres 582

Te Cees error err rrr Creer rey 620

2, Agreement between Operators of the Central Competi-

tive Coal Fields and the United Mine Workers of America,

January 28, 1808...........--. eee cece eect tenner eee es 621

4, Excerpt of Contract between the Union and Operators,

known as the Joint Interstate Agreement for Districts

14, 21 and 25, May 29, 1912, expiring July 31, 1814....... 628

5, Excerpt of Contract entitled, ‘Illinois State Agreement,”

expiring March 31, 1914, District No. 12..........--.---- 630

6, Excerpt of Agreement between Illinois Coal Operators

Association, et al., and the United Mine Workers of

America, District, No. 12, expiring March 31, 1914..... 631

7, Excerpt of Contract between United Mine Workers of

America and Northern Wyoming Coal Operators Associa-

tion for Mines in Wyoming, expiring September 1, 1914. 632

8, Excerpt of Agreement between United Mine Workers of

America and Washington Coal Operators Association,

September 1, 1912...........-----eeeeeeeereesene erste es 633

9, Excerpt of Agreement between Montana Coal Operators

Association and the United Mine Workers of America,

District, No. 27, Montana, October 1, 1912.......-...--- 634

10, Excerpt of Agreement entitled, ‘Joint Interstate

Agreement and Contract for District, No. 14,’’ May 29,

NN Re cata ae ROR CMER EE REES EES ESTEE ORROOS 636

11, Excerpt of Agreement between the Kanawha Coal

Operators and the United Mine Workers of America,

Bale Bh; BOO... 9. oie 5 csc ctv cocsvn sey eentereedasessonets* 637

12, Excerpt of Agreement entitled, “United Mine Workers

of America, District 6, Ohio, for Scale Year, April 1,

1614, to March 31, 1916”... ......-.--- ee eee rere eects 638

13, Excerpt of Agreement between The Vancouver Nanaimo

Coa! Mining Co. and the United Mine Workers of America,

enti WA, WON ssw ca scerneysnavenenexcsanssconsse® 641

14, Excerpt of Agreement between the Pittsburg District

Coal Operators and the United Mine Workers of America,

District, No. 5, for Seale Term, April 1, 1914, to March 31,

ae ae ree nee BERR em Peer en errs sa 642

15, Excerpt of Contract entitled, “Joint Interstate Agree-

ment and Contract for District, No. 21,” May 29, 1912.

16, Excerpt of Contract entitled, “Joint Interstate Agree-

ment and Contract for District, No. 25,” May 29, 1912.

17, Excerpt of Agreement and Scale of Wages between the

Texas and Pacific Coal Co., et al., and the United Mine

Workers of America, District, No. 21, August 1, 1914,

to September 1, 1916.......... (IU Ry per oe ee 646

18, Excerpt of Agreement entitled, ‘‘Northern Agreement

and Constitution, District, No. 22, United Mine Workers

af Aunericn, IO1E.....-..0cncececcerancsscscnsseneceees 647

E

=

£

Print.

391

396

397

398

399

399

400

401

5

S

; Original. Print.

19, Excerpt of Agreement entitled, ‘‘Joint Interstate Agree-

ment and Contracts for Districts 14, 21 and 25,’’ May 29,

at Se et oad: Fes REO RN AED Aas te te Benet ine eee te nae 648 410

20, Agreements between The Block Coal Operators and the

United Mine Workers of America, District, No. 8, April 1,

i i te ee sah alisacach 650 411

21, Michigan Mining Scale, 1912-14, between Michigan

Coal Operators and the United Mine Workers of America,

eee We en I oo en cen bccns 650 411

22, Agreement between Western Kentucky Coal Opérators

Association and the United Mine Workers of America,

District, No. 23, April 1, 1912, Recital of................ 650 412

23, Michigan Mining Scale, 1914-16, between Michigan

Coal Operators and the United Mine Workers of America,

District, No. 24, May 29, 1914, Recital of............... 651 412

24, Agreement between Wesicrn Kentucky Coal Operators

Association and the United Mine Workers of America,

District, No. 23, April 1, 1914, Recital of............... 651 412

25, Book of Seale Agreements between United Mine Work-

ers of America, District, No. 2, and the Bituminous

Operators of Central Pennsylvania, 1899 to 1914, inclusive,

NN EER RE cc BEA. JD Sat ae TaN Em A ie RES Cae Rec OR 651 412

26, Agreement between the Kanawha Coal Operators and

the United Mine Workers of America, April 1. 1910,

i SIRE eR INE ok ose nts COLO Ree eee Se eA SRE 651 412

27, Agreements between The Block Coal Operators and the

United Mine Workers of America, District, No. 8, April

Se Fg ey RS ae eee eae 652 413

28, Contract between the Indiana Bituminous Coal Opera-

tors Association and the United Mine Workers of America,

District, No. 11, May 31, 1912, Excerpt of........... eS

29-A, Proceedings of the 11th, 12th, 13th and 14th Annual

Conventions and the Special Convention of the United

Mine Workers of America, Recital of................... 654 414

29-B to 29-R, inelusive, Proceedings of the Conventions of

the United Mine Workers of America, 1904 to 1916,

PO ION aoa aga a baba sodhc sin deve's ook 655 415

30-A to 30-H, inclusive, Proceedings of the Joint Conferences

of Miners and Operators of the Central Competitive Dis-

tricts, 1901 to 1916, inclusive, Recital of................. 656 415

31-A to 31-X, inclusive, 24 Volumes of the United Mine

Workers’ Journal, April 14, 1892, to April 26, 1917, inelu-

ene I oe pes ok Chis in eae wen ae 656 416

RN I i a ies peeve ieee 660 418

1, Conscitution of the International Union, United Mine

IR EN a os cern nb cee cows 660 418

I Gy I NE oo 5s nos wa ntn dc cwedcpowecevec 694 443

2, Report of the Scale Committee to the Convention of

the International Union, 1912......................... 711 455

3, Miners’ Demands made by the Convention of the United

S| ee ne 714 458

Se ery ey «tt? Sy tS 4g BA RES SOT SERRE

Original. Print.

4, Letter, John P. White, President of the United Mine

Workers of America, to the Representatives of the Opera-

tors and Miners of the Centrai Competitive District,

PONTE, Ge Os Eas RES FOS Ee Rd te rnb 717 = 460

5, Agreement between the Miners and Operators of the

Central Competitive District, March 30, 1912.......... 726 = 466

GREER ne one Are Ra A aR ong 2 ae 745 478

31-Y, 31-Z and 31-AA, 3 Additional Volumes of United Mine

Workers dosumnal, Hadital of «.... 0.65655 006555 cc kaacees cd 745 478

Se ee ee ae ee a 745 479

Letter, President, United Mine Workers of America, to

Honorable Woodrow Wilson, March 3, 1917............... 766 493

Letter, President, to Honorable W. B. Wilson, November 4,

MN caret athe <P WES a Belk De aE AL LEAS Od ae oe 771 «= 496

Circular issued during the Birmingham Strike to Officers and

members of Local Unions, United Mine Workers, for Dis-

eee, T8Gs E Sn sc reset cen crewtepoavees 774 498

Exhibits 31-BB and 31-CC, 2 Volumes of the United Mine

WGEMEW -DCUIRE, TOGIEOL OE 65.55 SoS ice's costa ccctws ses 779 ~=«501

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, October 15, 1914. 785 505

Excerpt of Report of John P. White in the Convention Pro-

ceedings of the United Mine Workers Association, 1914... 786 506

Excerpt of the Report of Secretary and Treasurer Wilson at

the Nationa! Convention of the United Mine Workers of

RE DEMME So ORO. ee te ee et hee ene ee 790 ~=©508

Excerpt of Address by John P. White to the Special Con-

vention of the United Mine Workers of District, No. 21,

DOM I Rc heen ac Cua twhninpreens cons eared nurs 796 = 512

Excerpt of President Lewis’ Report in the Convention Pro-

Semen ter CNG SORE NOUN sks. occas sw decd Ue oe aera 801. 515

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal of October 13, 1910. .806 518

Excerpt of John P. White’s Report in the Proceedings of the

Corvention of the United Mine Workers for the Year, 1912. 810 521

| Excerpt of Journal of the United Mine Workers of America

Se ER RE hes cae eae! rea enter cee a Wor sale sion" 816 524

Excerpt of the Report of John Mitchell in the Convention

Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America for the

Excerpt of the Report of T. L. Lewis in the Convention Pro-

ceedings of the United Mine Workers of America for the

Excerpt of the Report of President Mitchell in the Convention

Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America for

Sa i rae et od ao Seen give be 820 526

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, January 12, 1911. 821 526

Excerpt of the Report of Vice-President Hayes in the Conven-

tion Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America

Nee See mee EE... ha tripe at ds nae dea aeE baa es 825 529

Excerpt of Vice-President, Hayes’ Report in the Convention

Proceedings for the Year, 1914................. 0002 e eee 826 529

Excerpt of the Report of the Committee on Resolutions in

the Convention Proceedings of the United Mine Workers .

of America for the Year, 1914, (Resolution, No. 115)..... 829 531

¢ Original. Print.

Excerpt of the Report of the Committee on Resolutions in

the Convention Proceedings of the United Mine Workers

of America for the Year, 1902, (Resolution, No. 33)....... 838 538

Excerpt of the Convention Proceedings of the United Mine

Workers of America for the Year, 1902, (Report of the

Special Committee on Competitive Scale Districts)..... 843 ODA

Excerpt of the Convention Proceedings of —~» United Mine

Workers of America for the Year, 1902, i: port of the

Special Committee on Organization)..................... 845 512

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Mitchell in the Proceedings of

of the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

PREMISE cGMt COURT oles on eke re ain year oe rt 867 556

Excerpt of Statement by W. S. Bogle in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

POAC a MAE EMO ee co conte. ae se ad ee 868 557

Excerpt of Statement by H. L. Chapmann in the Proceedings

of the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

gt | SERPS Rtn te corn wee here veka hn 869 557

Excerpt of Statements by Messrs. Robbins and Chapman in

the Proceedings of the Joint Conference of Coal operators

and Coal Miners for the Year, 1904....................... *870 558

Excerpt of Statement by W. 8. Bogle in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

ROP GENO FT ee he eee oe ore BN ee ae ee 871 559

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

gk pe f- oqks |: | SSRI Oe pane AUPE etre nN ol UP ere Peg 872 559

Excerpt of Statements by Messrs. Robbins and Bogle in the

Proceedings of the Joint Conference of Coal Operators

and Coal Miners for the Year, 1904........................ 874 561

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Robbins in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

FOR: BOG SORE EGON 335). Re Se oe ee he ne ede hes 875 561

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

RS ORM NO: onde she ered ena a ee 878 563

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Proceedings

yi of the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Coal Miners

: ar Oe SI NINE Ci cota ah poet ce ts oe eee 879 564

Proceedings of the Joint Conference of Coal Operators, and

Coal Miners for the Year, 1904, Recital of................ 880 565

Proceedings of the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and

Coal Miners for the Year, 1904, Excerpt of......... ..... 881 565

Exeerpt of the Convention Proceedings of Miners for the

Year, 1004 -Glesntition. No: 9). ook 884 367

Excerpt of the Convention Proceedings of Miners for the

pe Aare Tier Sion Pape Sion ee Neier eee and yee 886 569

Excerpt of Statement by President Mitchell in the Joint Con-

ference Proceedings of Miners and Operators for the Year,

Excerpt of Statement by W. D. Wilson in the Joint Conference

Proceedings of Miners and Operators for the Year, 1906. 889 571

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Robbins in the Joint Conference

Proceedings of Miners and Operators for the Year, 1906. 890 572

Original. Print.

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Robbins in the Joint Conference

Proceedings of Miners and Operators for the Year, 1906. 891 572

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Penna in the Joint Conference

Proceedings of Miners and Operators for the Year, 1906. 891 572

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Joint Conference

Proceedings of Miners and Operators for the Year, 1906. 893 573

Report of Scale Committee in the Convention Proceedings

ok Wanere for the Year, 1000... ou: 5 nce ccc cceescnccesces 894 574

Resolution, No. 42, adopted at the Convention of Miners

pM OE Es . yiioek vagiagure cde Oreck teseas hee 895 575

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Green in the Proceedings of

the Miners’ Convention for the Year, 1907............... 897 576

Excerpt of the Proceedings of the Miners’ Convention for

C1 RSS SORE RIE ee PO Reo EE Rae Ee ae eT 898 577

Excerpt of Statement by John H. Jones in the Joint Con-

ference Proceedings for the Year, 1908................... 899 578

Excerpt of Statement by Francis Feehan in the Joint Con-

ference Proceedings for the Year, 1908................... 901 579

Excerpt of Address by President Mitchell in the Proceedings

of the Miners’ Convention for the Year, 1908............. 902 580

Except of Statement by Mr. Green in the Proceedings of the

ARE ONE Os wes alwiniy senreudieaee 904 581

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Hagerty in the Proceedings of

the Miners’ Convention of 1909................. cece ee eee 904 «581

Excerpt of Statement by President Lewis in the Proceedings

of the Miners’ Convention of 1909.................002 20005 905 582

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Farley in the Proceedings of

the Miners’ Convention of 1909.................c cece eee eee 906 583

Excerpt of Statement by C. E. Maurer in the Proceedings of

Ce Beet Comrie OF TONG, goo gis wcicnic se See ciccrcee sete’ 907 583

Excerpt of Statement by President Lewis in the Proceedings

a the Joint Convention of 1010. 2. «2... csc cs cccce cece 913 587

Excerpt of Statement by President Lewis in the Proceedings

of the Jot Convention of 1910............cescccccscnvens 914 588

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Green in the Proceedings of

the Jomt Convention of 19010... «0.6... ccc cess grccoceces 915 588

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Maurer in the Proceedings of

Reig demmse ComVemtions OF 1010 onic oc ek cecic ed eccccoensene 916 589

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Penna in the Proceedings of the

nS OMINIREOME OE MONDO ob Siidiee dw, 0 cleice oman swabs aes 918 590

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Proceedings of

the Fort Convention Of 1090: 5 oc... ec 5 epics cece nce ceess 919 591

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1010... 2.0.06 c ieee cee ctseees 920 592

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Maurer in the Proceedings of

ee INA OOO aoe coc Vinlee wats Ke edanedy's 920 592

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Zerbe in the Proceedings of the

ih TCC Me loka pases a neeabhasionee ties 921 593

Excerpt of Statement by Secretary Perry in the Proceedings

of the Joint Convention of 1910.................0.ee eee eeee 923 594

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Proceedings of

ths Jomt Convention of 1900........2. wos. ieasevsvccteseces 924 595

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Green in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1910... 2.0.0.0... 6c e cece eee e ees 925 595

Original. Print.

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal of July 7, 1910..... 926 596

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Hayes in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Miners for the

WI aa Ok secre he tae oe eee oe 928 597

Operators’ Proposition in the Proceedings of the Joint Con-

ference of Coal Operators and Miners for the Year, 1912. 929 598

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Field and Mr. Hayes in the

Proceedings of the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and

dk, | PPR RE ema As pia ria 930 598

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Maurer in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Miners for

Sy MI tt Ute danny cdoh tone were Peden ios 932 600

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Penna in the Proceedings of the

Joint Conference of Coal Operators and Miners for the

MMM ULE or een one: Ee eee ee a 935 602

Excerpt of the Report of E. 8. McCullough in the Proceedings

of the Miners’ Convention of 1910.......................-- 939 605 /

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Lewis in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1912...........0.00.0 0.0.0 cece eee 940 605

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Penna in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1912.....................0.cceeeee 945 608

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Penna in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1912.............0.0 0.0 ccc cece cece 946 608

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Maurer in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1912. .........0.0.0.0.0 000000 cee 951 611

Fxcerpt of Statement by Mr. White in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1912.................cccccsccecves 953 612

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Walker in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1912.................. 0 ccceeeeees 954 613

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Chapman in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention of 1912............. 0.0... ccc cece eee 955 613

Excerpt of the Report of Mr. White in the Proceedings of

the Miners’ Convention of 1912...................0.0.0000e 957 «614

Excerpt of Miners’ Journal, September 26, 1912.............. 958 615

Excerpt of the Report of the Treasurer in the Proceedings

of the Miners’ Convention of 1914...................0.0... 960 616

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Maurer, in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention for the year 1904..................... 961 616

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Maurer in the Proceedings of

the Joint Convention for the year 1904................... 964 618

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Jackson in the Proceedings of the

Miners’ Convention for the year 1914..................... 965 618

Excerpt of Statement by President White in the Proceedings

of the Miners’ Convention of 1914......................... 967 620

Excerpt of Address by President White in the Proceedings of

the Special Convention of United Mine Workers of America,

Pmteack, rer al, tev 18-9014. cee. 969 620

Colloquy between Court and Counsel on Motion to Strike out

certain Testimony in the Record.........................06. 1003-644

Motion to Strike out certain Testimony, denied................ 1014 652

William Green, recalled, Deposition of......................... 1016 653

SSE PSO DRE SR 1019 656

Rummel eeyens aes een cee tlk ‘..... 1081 698

Original. Print.

35, Letter, Franklin Bache to President Woodrow Wilson,

REI Serer re i ieee ies MESES TREO RG ACRE ED 1081 699

36, Letter, W. B. Wilson to Franklin Bache, Recital of..... 1086 702

37, Letter, W. B. Wilson to John P. White, Recital of...... 1086 702

38, Letter to Franklin Bache, March 22, 1914.............. 1109 717

39, Letter from Franklin Bache, May, 1914, Recital of..... 1115. 722

40, Letter to U. 8. Marshal, Western District of Arkansas,

Bay G8) TOC, TROGHA) OF occ cc ceccc crest essebeseseaere 1122 26

41, Letter to John 8. Cameron, May 23, 1914, Recital of.... 1122 726

Defendants’ Exhibit 1, Certified Copy of Certificate of In-

corporation of the Kali-Inla Coal Co. in the State of West

Virginia, September 26, 1898...............--eeeeeeeeeees 1129 731

Defendants’ Exhibit, Certified Copy of Certificate of In-

corporation of the Mammoth Vein Coal Mining Co. in the

State of West Virginia, October 19, 1905................55. 1154 750

Defendants’ Motion to Produce certain Books, etc............... 1162 755

Exhibit A, Request for the Production of certain Books and

Ne Dee ai aN Eco hs cl WEN CER e Kc tlee HIS LENS Hise Daas € 1166 = 757

Testimony for Plaintiffe...............0ccceeeceeeeeceeeseneeees 1173 762

UMMA MAORMO, 5s) oc cee caso e ns dae apes vablanenedae 1173 762

WOMEM eile TORRIINAR:. 5 ais c.ccics pe ccv estes caves es deeureever ses 1179 767

3, Lease between the Cherokee Construction Co. and the

Prairie Creek Coal Co., July 1, 1909..............5005- 1179 767

4, Mortgage with Power of Sale, Mammoth Vein Royalty

Co. to H. C. Parmelee, Trustee, July 3, 1914........... 1219 794

5, Articles of Incorporation of the Mammoth Vein Royalty

Co., of the State of Arkansas, October 15, 1904......... 1233 804

6, Slip of Paper containing Names of Bache-Denman Coal

Co. and Bache & Denman Coal Co.............-56 00055 1240 810

7, Pittsburg Interstate Agreement between the South-

western Coal Operators Association and the United

Mine Workers of America, Districts 14, 21 and 24, July 27,

NE Gh os ek sb Aa DACA Css CR VOL OTR EER HRC ES 1255 820

8, Joint Interstate Agreement between the Southwestern

Coal Operators Association and the United Mine Workers

of America, Districts 14, 21 and 25, August 19, 1904..... 1282 840

Agreement on Scale for District, No. 1.........-..--+++5 1296 850

9, Joint Interstate Agreement between the Southwestern

Coal Operators Asso¢iation and the United Mine Workers

of America, District, No. 21, adopted at Kansas City,

Miteactirh: Deine 16: 1008. 5 cic vs ccieriis 008 in le cok cet eames 1319 867

10, Joint Interstate Agreement between the Southwestern

Coal Operators Association and the United Mine Workers

of Missouri, Kansas and Oklahoma, May 25, 1908...... 1349 889

Contract for District No. 21, of United Mine Workers

of America, adopted at Kansas City, Mo., May 25, 1908. 1363 900

11, Agreement between Mammoth Vein Coal Co., et al.,

and the United Mine Workers of America, August 10,

NEE ye lng dears Am Aahrae Ch ete tains De are we aie arecktestia Ap 1383 914

12, Joint Interstate Agreement between the Southwestern

Interstate Coal Operators Association and the United

Mine Workers of America, District, No. 21, adopted at

Kansas City, Missouri, May 29, 1912............+..+55: 1387 918

Original. Print.

13, Joint Interstate Agreement and Contracts between

the Southwestern Interstate Coal Operators Association

and the United Mine Workers of Missouri, Kansas, Arkan-

sas and Oklahoma, adopted September 19, 1910 1431

Contract between the Southwestern Interstate Coal

Operators Association and the United Mine Workers

of America, District 14, September 19, 1910 1447

Contract between the Southwestern Interstate Coal

Operators Association and the United Mine Workers

of America, District 21, September 19, 1910 1469

Contract between the Southwestern Interstate Coal

Operators Association and the United Mine Workers

of America, District 25, September 19, 1910

14, Certificate of Incorporation of the Coronade Coal Co.,

Recital of

Excerpt of the Report of Vice-President Lewis in the Minutes

of the Annual Convention of the United Mine Workers for

Excerpt of the Report of President Mitchell in the Minutes

of the Annual Convention of the United Mine Workers for

Excerpt of the Report of President Mitchell in the Minutes

of the Annual Convention of the United Mine Workers for

Excerpt of the Report of President Mitchell in the Minutes

of the Annual Convention of the United Mine Workers for

Excerpt of the Report of President Mitchell in the Minutes

of the Annual Convention of the United Mine Workers for

Excerpt of the Report of the Committee on Officers’ Reports,

United Mine Workers Convention of 1907

Excerpt of the Report of the Scale Committee in the Pro-

ceedings of the reconvened Miners’ Convention

Excerpt of the Annual Report of President Lewis in the Con-

vention Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America

Excerpt of the Annual Report of President Lewis in the Con-

vention Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America

Excerpt of the Annual Report of President Lewis in the Con-

vention Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America

Excerpt of Convention Proceedings of the United Mine Work-

ers of America for 1911, (Resolution, No. 110, and Adoption

thereof)

Excerpt of the Annual Report of Vice-President Hayes in the

Convention Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of

America for 1911 1587

Excerpt of the Report of John P. White in the Convention

Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America for

abs ky bees a's hoes b coe h awa eaeen es Ak ae 1589

EEE ORE PI SEED IC RTE IIE NE APES AE TERRI IR Ot BRITE OI OE Ee

Original. Print.

Excerpt of the Report of Frank J, Hayes in the Convention

Proceedings of the United Mine Workers of America for

ee ee Ee eae NAER AACE TREATS EAETS CADET LTO 1590 1062

Excerpt of the Report of the Committee on Rules in the Pro-

ceedings of the Joint Conference of the Miners and Operators

of the Central Competitive Field, 1904............0..00055 1593 1064

Excerpt of the Report of the Credentials Committee in the

Proceedings of the Joint Conference of the Miners and

Operators of the Central Competitive Field, 1904.......... 1504 1065

Excerpt of the Miners’ Proposed Seale. ......... 5.665.000 5005 1595 1066

Excerpt of Statement of John Mitchell in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of the Miners and Operators of the

Central Competitive Field, ST ass cabanas: teckel 1506 1066

Excerpt of Statement of John Mitchell in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of the Miners and Operators of the

Central Competitive Field, 1904........ 6.600 e cece ceees 1598 1068

Exverpt of Statement of John Mitchell in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of the Miners and Operators of the

Central Competitive Field, 1904......... 666.0 cece eens . 1599 1068

Excerpt of Colloquy between Mr, Mitchell and Mr, Chapman

in the Proceedings of the Joint Conference of the Miners

and Operators of the Central Competitive Field, 1904.... 1601 1069

Excerpt of Statement of W. B, Wilson in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of the Miners and Operators of the

Central Competitive Field, 1904........ 660.6660 cc seen 1602 1069

Excerpt of Statement of Mr, Mitchell in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of the Miners and Operators of the

Central Competitive Field, 1904, ...... 66666 creer eee ues 1602 1070

Excerpt of Statement of Mr. Dolan in the Proceedings of the

Joint Conference of the Miners and Operators of the Central

Competitive Field, 1004........6 5.6500 scene een ee ne es .. 1604 107)

Excerpt of the Proceedings of the Scale Committee on Scale

oe PER AA APT eT ETT PELE LOE ee Le 1605 1071

Title Page to the Proceedings of the Joint Interstate Con-

ferences of Miners and Operators of Pennsylvania and

ee EES Re re re ery On 1607 1072

Remarks of Vice-President Lewis in the Proceedings of the

Joint Interstate Conferences of Miners and Operators of

Pennsylvania and other States in 1906............6050008s 1608 1073

Rules adopted at Joint Interstate Conferences of Miners and

Operators of Pennsylvania and other States in 1906....... 1608-a 1074

Excerpt of Argument of President Mitchell in the Proceedings

of the Joint Interstate Conferences of Miners and Operators

of Pennsylvania and other States in 1906............60555> 1609 1074

Excerpt of Argument of Mr, Haskins in the Proceedings of the

Joint Interstate Conferences of Miners and Operators of

Pennsylvania and other States in 1906.............005555 1611 1076

Excerpt of Argument of President Mitchell in the Proceedings

of the Joint Interstate Conferences of Miners and Operators

of Pennsylvania and other States in 1906...........+505+5 1613 1077

Excerpt of the Argument of J. H. Walker in the Proceedings

of the Joint Interstate Conferences of Miners and Operators

of Pennsylvania and other States in 1906...........++0+++ 1617 1079

Original. Print.

Operators of Pennsylvania and other States in 1906........ 1618 1079

SMS Tins Va ceNaeved si cde cor ode c ea ae 1618 1079

Miners and Operators of Pennsylvania and other States

ey OT Ce Oe Oey ee aL IOS: 1619 1080

and Operators of Peansylvania and other States in 1908... 1619 1080

and Operators of Pennsylvania and other States in 1908... 1620 1081

Miners of Pennsylvania and other States................. 1620 108i

and Operators of Pennsylvania and other States in 1914... 1623 1083

and other States in 1914..................... - . 1625 1085

and other States in 1914............0....ccccccccces cee... 1627 1086

NT IN iis iad waiecivacsls see ee 1628 1087

and Operators of Pennsylvania and other States in 1914.... 1629 1087

PMMA RSA Unie bn dedaaain ini iuce tea tie aoe 1630 1088

pow gh, Eig, ROR RMI as 1631 1089

sylvania and other States in 1910................... .. 1636 1092

end other States in 1910....................cc0c00- 0 eee, 1639 1004

Excerpt of Remarks of President White in the Proceedings

of the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Penn-

sylvania and other States in 1910.......................... 1640 1095

and other States in 1010.................cce0s500..5.,,,. 1640 1005

sylvania and other States in 1910........................ 1643 1097

vania and other States in 1910........................... 1643 1097

sylvania and other States in 1910....................... 1645 1098

» “a, et. AB PRLS | pie NT erp eh

LL OLGAILLOOAIEREEL LOLS ONLINE HE PLONE, PID TI: TRE iti

Original. Print.

Excerpt of Remarks of President Lewis in the Proceedings

of the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Penn-

sylvania and other States in 1910....... 05.60 ss sess eeenns 1648 1100

Excerpt of Remarks of President Lewis in the Proceedings

of the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Penn-

sylvania and other States in 1910.........- 66. es ener ee eeees 1649 1101

Title Page to the Proceedings of the Joint Conference of

Miners and Operators of Pennsylvania and other States

RR cece gh ceuy CAD AREESK ADEE 640- KOSHEDVERER ERED STEED 1651 1103

Report of Credentials Committee in the Proceedings of the

Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Pennsylvania

and other Gtates im 1019.........cccerescveecvvrereneees 1652 1108

Excerpt of Remarks of President White in the Proceedings

of the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Penn-

sylvania and other States in 1912, ....... 66. 6c eee rece 1656 1106

Excerpt of Remarks of Vice-President Hayes in the Proceed-

ings of the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of

Pennsylvania and other States in 1912.0... 6.0... 6606 5 1650 1108

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Feehan in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Pennsyl-

vania and other States in 1912....... ; iP eRccusacvesse pee. Bae

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Penna in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Pennsyl-

vania und other States in 1912...............0eceeeee ees 1664 DM

Excerpt of Remarks of Mr. MeDonald in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Pennsyl-

vania and other States in 1912......... 6666 c cece e eee ene 1668 lilt

Excerpt of Statement by President Lewis in the Proceedings

of the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Penn-

sylvania and other States in 112.000.0666. cece reer 1671 1116

Excerpt of Remarks of Mr. McDonald in the Proceedings of

the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of Penn-

sylvania and other States in 1912....... 6.6.66 cece eens 1673 1117

Excerpt of Remarks of Vice-President Hayes in the Proceed-

ings of the Joint Conference of Miners and Operators of

Pennsylvania and other States in 1912... 00.66.66 cece eens 1676 1119

Agreement between United Mine Workers of America and

Miners and Operators of several States, March 30, 1912... 1678 1120

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, September 12, 1907, 1684 1124

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, August 29, 1912... 1688 1127

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, October 3, 1912... 1690 1128

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, February 20, 1913.. 1603 1130

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, September 18, 1913, 1605 1132

Address of John P. White in the Proceedings of the Special

Convention of District 21, May 18, 1914..........655 eee ees 1699 1135

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, February 20, 1913. 1714 1145

Excerpt of the Proceedings of Miners’ Convention of 1907..... 1715 1145

Excerpt of the Proceedings of Miners’ Convention of 1911..... 1716 1146

Excerpt of the Report of President Lewis for the Year 1911. 1717 1147

Oy Ti NOG. ccc cccccvccerccccscvresesvevencessecesecesenecs 1720 1145

Excerpt of Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 32, Proceedings of the Special

Convention of District No. 21, May 18, 1914..........++++: 1724 1151

ae petiudhn pebas dll denne oe ener dv head eee Cum 1738 1160

Original. Print.

MN Ades piausahesedasee vcd id catiéadidy ieckias eee 1755 1171

Me UIA 5 0850-00 600854 745004500) ory y ne hcceasccckceseadeul 1761 1176

a io. 5 6000940060000) tbe Veewnskeewabenicckenaee 1767 1180

BE MERI ol Sv 055 04465 060 vad iddecioatedinniontcecn 1769 1182

ING oh ok one 160544644005 004060 00d cesacaeaieal 1771 1183

Sy IN as ibid uns rhs 90's 0000 endenndcocesaa¥aneeaeean 1789 1196

Roland F. Barnes, Deposition of...........0000000 00000. c cece 1797 1202

EN chi6nis00d9640seeondesdenrdiaeerevdacdacteced 1872 1253

Ewing Thomas, Deposition of... .........0.0.0 000000000 c cece 1882 1261

IIE shiek scdcdvicccsavenstencavevercsataas vee 1909 1280

I II so odo deen caukccececdscevcdseakcsvesvabeaven 1938 1301

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 42, Slip of Paper bearing Address,—C. EB.

Pattie, Box 376, Hartford, Arkansas..................... 1951 1310

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 43, Slip of Paper bearing Addresses,—

H. M. Strope, Frank Sharp, Box 672, Hartford, Arkansas... 1951 1310

Dr, Gnear Bi, Nobili cccccccccusscvcveceaveveecccdvcscecees 1955 1312

Mrs. Mahala Barnes... ... 6.0066 c eee cece 1961 1316

C. H. Langdorf............ Lue¥ dhs eaNeeuaaeavenenanan 1963 1317

William Thomas, Deposition of. . . MTGTITUTTTIT TT Tee Sl

e505 55 vou0n 60.0.500490000%s0400000000000000Tr Cee 2013 1352

Arch Caldwell... ccc ccc cc ecu evucucs 2033 1365

Ellet T, Goddard........ £50 000000 06000440060800000 raN oan

James A, Murray bb55G0 una resT sb enervastsauserted cen 2045 1373

George A, Davis............... bevenevererecertoesesseencedc inet amnMe

J, Curtis Bohannan,............... hsncevescieuasresencecen 2058 1381

William T, White......... sdevauceuencantnsd rir

William Saunders, Deposition of anndesueesestererce buon 2073 13092

W. T. Forrester...........0......5. piuveeeseeed eee te..00ek eee

Mrs, John Degen... .. pha $134 00Ceantbereesseaiceetl 2003 1405

James H. Meeks..... eubivesseevavestenepes vee 2104 1418

Elmer Bohannan., . . . MTTTITC TTC ITTTi Tre

John W. Baker....... Savane cedes beeen aoe ceviny eee

Charley Cheek, Deposition eo icenesseedpectrieessi .oeee 9131 14296

William V. Womack............... 54-95 bKORRD UNO Rade oo OL

William J. Goateher........ seseees 2164 1485

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, July 23, 1014, ..+. 2173 1462

Charles Suttles, Deposition of....... obi ..e. 2174 1468

Mrs. Rhelda Perry, Deposition of............. ..+. 21905 1476

A. W. McGee, Deposition of... .. o's hed one x chaxcedarce Coa

Lee Bishop. . 2 a eean La cots tcast ce ee

James O. Johnson, Deposition of si snd ideaneehiaccier te 2228 1498

Mrs. Preddro Brown............. rue aar sata Reed eee cede 2250 1514

Harry Dunlap...........cccseucseces Sictbesbnns yeeros user 2256 1518

BOE Ms 6 oviviccicioscoas ‘i VE PREECE T ETE Tes 2270 1527

RD ai eh as baa ca5' sia'en ts catue ckeehechanlstecca 2283 1536

arrest bats cs uve t\seesunk ote Cnet cadacnelen 2286 1538

GT oie Fu in-v 1 wretes' gy 3 oh cnr 4 cha ote d cio eens ane 2293 1542

Ce sae Gea eau wa tia eeeaeee passeneneea 2298 1545

David Stanley....... SP aR Pe ip Ape Mee AMAT TEN See” 2306 1551

Melvin Roberts...................... siisnicie a Re xine USE

MN ca hana svg du kaees cis ok swe vies: QUvGN oy en mani 2314 1556

Joseph A. Parrish, Deposition of... ...........0..00000 cc cece eee 2323 1562

Ed Parrish, Stipulation as to.........0.000000 0c c cc cece cee eeey 2335 1571

Mrs. Eva Trannell, Stipulation as to. ..............0 0.000 cee. 2336 1571

Original. Print.

Mrs. Eva Trannell, Testimony of, at former trial, (Ex 45)...... 2338

N. G. Tyler, Deposition of... ..........-... see ce eee cece eee es 2346

ES dtp ar, Nara pta aia pS vig eo 0 ek) Eing 2355

Fameeie A; MaCommalll.«... 6.6... eee c tees eer sceeereeesesees 2361

Mike Doughit, Re-called....... SE SSA Or eearihe ak pe REP ea A eee 2368

Charles L. Reierson, Deposition of.................-.6050 eens 2369

NT Pe ne er erg ais Cos So SS Ws cha OES ema e 2387

6, Letter, H. B. Hill to Rem. U. M. C. Co., June 19, 1914.. 2387

7, Letter, Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge Co.,

to H. B. Hill, Jume 19, 1014. . 2... cece eee c tse ceweece 2388

10, Telegram, H. B. Hill to Remington Arms-Union Metallic

Cartridge Co., June 18, 1914............. 6-0 e eee e eens 2393

11, Telegram, Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

Ce., to H. B. Hill, June 18, 1914..............-..-e eee eee 2394

1, Telegram, Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

Co., ta FH. B: Hill, Fume 10; 1014... = sw cette eee ee 2395

2, Telegren, Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

Co., to H. B. Hill, June 10, 1914.............6-- se eeeeeee 2395

3, Order to the Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

Go. from Ft. T. iill, Jume 10, 1014... oo. 50 so ec cuses 2396

4, Letter, Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge Co.

hes he Dheee, Jee 10, BONA oc oleic vex g ie caweees 2396

5, Order to the Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

Co., from H. B. Hill, June 10, 1914...................-. 2397

8, Order to the Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

Co., from H. B. Till, Fume 17, 1014. .... 0... e cece ee. 2398

9, Order to the Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

Co., from H. B. Hill, June 17, 1914.............2--.--6 2398

Testimony for Defendants... ............2-0ceececer eer ccecncnees 2413

IR ST ara a ee aul s wiaik a 4a RNa 2413

Wastionaeey for Plaintiffs. .. ..... 2... cece cece cence seeeess 2430

RN A oo) Dg De es itn wa elves nc.owe'y an 2430

oe alg Sn kinin Giving Cb shies Nee estig Soh weeps see ease 2435

ee MEMREN WORN oo oi cove ccdeis stevie ses connenneeenes es 2438

Ms MINI UNION 5 oops as a dic cece sevice sawed renccssvactgoeeens 2440

Exhibit 44, Letter to Mr. H. Briggs, April 19, 1914........... 2441

Oe iw tes cues cd peswe pa seanion deed cee 2443

Harry B. Hill, Deposition of...................-.eee cere ees 2448

eS ak wield Sauna bins Cpe ONS 2463

Leo 8. Schell, Deposition of .............. 00. cee ccc ce eee eeeeces 2476

I eee SI oe on Soh PRL At emi aig @ toad big wa AERTS ES 2502

Plaintiff's Exhibit 54, Invoice Atkinson-Williams Hardware

Company, to John Mastell, $176.55, June 10, 1914........ 2504

Invoice Atkinson-Williams Hardware Company, to John

Mastel!, $230.00, June 13, 1914............-. 2.0 - eee ee eee 2505

Invoice Atkinson-Williams Hardware Company, to John

Mastell, $362.94, June 22, 1914. ...... 2.0.0. eee eee eee 2507

Henry Edward Morgan...............--0 eee eeee eens eee een ees 2509

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 55, Check, United Mine Workers of America,

District No. 21, to Cash, $355.68, June 30, 1914..........-- 2515

SH SHSSHSE SOLES OLEATE COAEHMO HE SE OHTOET SHES HEHEHE

CHOCO KCK SSH CoH E HED VEMEERESESSCSHEHRSEHHO OHS

Nee web Re, NL SE EIEN La 2536

pp ce EE EO PLE AREA ERA TITER Del eT oP 2541

Ri is chet agen ag eg hie Nia ad eae 2544

William F. Meeks, Deposition of.............................. 2549

eM tr kOe ee SO ee i On tap 2582

Plaintiff's Exhibit 57, Pay Roll and list of all employees of

the Central Coal and Coke Company for April and July,

ee LS se RR inn ny cana ble gt 2582

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 58, Check-off list turned in by the Secretary

of Local Union, 1526 and 1530 of the United Mine Workers

eI Soc as cos annneeeedeaetace Gu 2583

eM ire GoesSsatepktecuGeis kcidiaeeoeice Es 2591

NG oe 55d Seema shy cabceate leno ee 2593

NS avi ha pick ec aaeti louie us ce 2596

MII Me es iroren pat pacmre potas GGG oe ee 2600

he eh ae ne Ee oO tere: fo 2604

SRE CE eng irre PR men reat namin es, 2608

era og eo, EOI AALS Mele CRORE 2610

TT Teg a oe aA ete 2612

oR abe cele Ce nies spteai ct Mee ER ye 2615

AERO ETS pot yy Stn Pye o 2619

III er kek Doo. OE chen toes oe a 2622

eee es, , SEES ES RE ae NOR it cen 2630

coc nt nT A IIT POG SAND ENR ET I Bir ee: 2634

cn. RISE AE SESE aed pee vant 2640

bo a. STIS VON Menara ee Amey It 2648

ve ERE AR ORE ae ae Ie en ee Ls PRE 2652

ee Peer np re re ee 2654

ccc... RECRRRT RSS CRUISE HIN ree tami te Re ean Be ear 2675

2 BERET aR RES ERE Raat abso nat pt ance een Rebs v8 2679

USE Th, SEERTESRINS kvm ime cable gree Rar aaa 2690

SE RRR BORE SERIE oe cel nc te inion etek 2694

Ie I od oe Fo oe 2696

Letter to Judge Youmans, July 27, 1914...................:.. 2608

1 BRA Saas easel Rai ee Ane ney 2701

I et sr to bac cireyc lo gee te pir anes 2706

cl, ERE ae ctel artes oS ed 2709

ES VAFE i RIES Sess eed ett Gina ( 2713

ire toe ln Nn es a 2714

cn. SASS DISSE SAS rine Seen e helenae Cem arhe s. tae { 2716

Te ook da pi ad odie Ke eri es 2718

nace ng. NESE EATS ee Rea Ie pee ta te SN SE ee it 2720

I i ger SG EP Ba 2 a yh a 2723

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 60, Check of United Mine Workers of

America, District 21, to Hayden Sporting Goods Co.,

PM OR I. 6 os cds nheccenssusaceee’s yess 2725

J. K. Thrasher, Deposition of...................ecec000050055, 2729

M. W. Weston, Deposition of....................cccc05eeeceec. 2739

M. W. Weston, Deposition of, recalled......................... 2751

SN No oe aa EY oie 2753

ne, MONI. ce 2755

i a RRS Sa RO ir bie lcci kt Ma pO el oA 2761

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 61, Relief Map of the Prairie Creek Mine,

No. 4, and its vicinity, Recital of......................... 2761

Original. Print.

Ee caus nc snsccungescsecosescsoestasseetences . 2767 1863

Mack Weston, Deposition of. ........-....5.0500see eter eee eee 2772 1867

W. B. Kissinger, Deposition of... ......... 6-6 +0550 eee ee reer ees 2782 1874

H. H. York, Deposition of................::ees seer e eee ees 2791 1880

Hilbert Stroupe.....:. 0... cece eee eee e teen eee eee ener ee ees 2803 1888

W. C. Harp, Deposition of... ........ 6... 05s ce rere tenes sees 2815 1897

George Simmons, Deposition of .......- 0.0... . +5 +55000ssseees 2822 1902

Howard H. Redner...........:...:ec cece cree ete ee eect eenees 2837 1912

Writing FE. DAMD..... ccc s eck e cece cess sence ee een sees eeengeetiane 2840 1914

Howard H. Redner, recalled.............-.-0:02sseereeeeeeees 2845 1918

OME UIE. ccs esc scce svc cenercreseesenccuererserenaeie 2847 1919

ee ner rrr rere rt ore. 2858 1926

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 99, Stub of Check to Hayden Sporting

Goods Co., $411.19, June 30, 1914........-- 6-662 cee e eee 2861 1928

Amos 8. Johnaon...........0. cc ce cece cece re eee e een ence cnees 2862 1928

John BE. Finney... ...... 0. ccc eevee cece eee e cere eee ener eeecees 2865 1931

a ic cey ke denrtards) «trees ins cyouenepinal 2867 1932

Blobor Denman... ....... 50. ce cece cree nec ee etter seen canes 2871 1935

Edward J. M. Peake............5.:06cceeeee cere net te een ene. 3022 2039

RN ence cies cconecaryarerccsarsneerennenen sever 3026 2042

| dy ONES Ae aA eI In aCe anc Cr 3030 2044

WW, W. Hogam...... 05. c cc cec ccc ct eee e eee eenet eens eeenenecens 3033 2045

Sic ycecincsesvecnacteavecsecnesdcescaerenenes Om 3037 2049

William A. Evans..............00- cece creer rennet nent ee ees 3043 2053

J.G. Peterbaugh........... 0. cece cece e eee e eee t nen een ees 3044 2054

WMD PEMOUG ics ncn sc ces cnc casecescenccrseencseesengerceens 3056 2062

Heber Denman, recalled...............-002s0ssee creer erences 3058 2063

Plaintiffs’ Exhibits.............-.... 0002s eect erent eens 3058 2064

102 Contract of Lease between Cherokee Construction Co.,

et al., and Mammoth Vein Coal Co., June 18, 1906...... 3058 2064

Inventory of Property owned by the Cherokee Construc- |

A UN aan bah nbn ba goed weed ha eR TRON NESS EPP AS 3074 2975

103 Contract between Cherokee Construction Co. and

Mammoth Vein Coal Co., June 26, 1909...........-.+-- 3090 2090

104, Contract of Lease between Mrs. Belle McEachin,

et al., and Missouri Coal Company, May 1, 1907....... 3091 2091

120, Contract of Lease between Mammoth Vein Coal Co.

and Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., March 27, 1911... 3101 2099

121, Contract of Lease between the Kali-Inla Coal Co.

and the Mammoth Vein Coal Co., January 1, 1912..... 3103 2100

123, Contract of Lease between the Kali-Inla Coal Co.,

and the Mammoth Vein Coal Co., November 30, 1910... 3105 2102

122, Assignment of Contract of March 27, 1911, between

Mammoth Vein Coal Co. and Prairie Creek Coal Co.

to Kali-Inla Coal Co............-0:0eeeeeee reer eeeeees 3107 2103

124, Contract of Lease between Denman Coal Co. and

Mammoth Vein Coal Co., October 5, 1910........-.-.--- 3108 2104

108, Contract of Lease between T. W. M. Boone and Wife

and the Prairie Creek Coal Co., January 13, 1903........ 3110 2105

Papers annexed to Exhibit 112......-....-.5+-++2000e 3116 2110

Authority of Sebastian County Coal Co. for the Assign-

ment of Lease between Coronado Coal Co. and Sebas-

tian County Coal Co. to Arkoal Co., October 5, 1909. 3116 2110

Original. Print.

Authority and Agreement of Franklin Bache to the Deed

of the Coronado Coal Co. to the Arkoal Company,

Ne eee cine k san edie ee eae 3117 2110

Acceptance and Agreement by the Sebastian Coal Co.

to the Assignment of Lease from Sebastian Coal Co.

to Franklin Bache, October 5, 1909.................... 3117 2111

Cae Oe, PUN BIE oi he ook ica 3117 2111

112, Contract of Lease between Sebastian County Coal

Co. and Franklin Bache, RET DO ROBT i ee 3120 2112

seen ECL Ee ee OE I ISAS SR PE Bik Bae 3147 2130

125, Contract of Lease between Denman Coal Co. and the

Coronado Coal Co., October 5, 1910..................... 3153 2135

126, Contract of Lease between Denman Coal Co. and the

Coronado Coal Co., March 2 Ua ap gee tp near 3155 2136

127, Contract of Lease between Mammoth Vein Coal Co.

and the Coronado Coal Co., January 3, 1910............. 3157 2138

128, Contract of Lease between Coronado Coal Co. and

the Hartford Coai Co., MU DTU ese 3159 2139

Co., et al., and Mammoth Vein Coal Mining Co., July 10,

Ds diicin cn ba cir ibd SSe Sa ania ge okie Ped ak 3161 2140

ewan EE ee Opa AO Ts Mca 3179 2152

Co. and Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., December 19,

MPS tAiwesimiat Gey neewereedick doice aide eae ee 3181 2154

~

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., May 31, 191i...... 3238 2195

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., December 1, 1912. 3240 2197

134, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Feb. 1, 1914........ 3242 2198

Original. Print.

135, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Aug. 31, 1911...... 3244 2200

136, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Jan. 1, 1911........ 3246 2201

137, Contract of Lease between Mammoth Vein Coal Co.

and the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Mar. 27, 1911... 3248 2203

138, Assignment of Contract of Lease between Mammoth

Vein Coal Co. and the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co.

to Kali-Inla Coal Co., Aug. 2, 1911...................... 8250 2204

139, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Mar. 27, 1911...... 3252 2205

140, Supplements to Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla

Coal Co. and the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., April 15,

ROM Siete ca Ce te er ee aaah aN icp OO, OM

141, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co, and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Feb, 28, 1914....... 3255 2207

142, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Nov. 30, 1913...... 3257 2209

143, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Sept. 30, 1913..... 3259 2210

144, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co, and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Jan. 31, 1914...... 3261 2211

145, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Mar. 31, 1913..... 3262 2213

146, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co, and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Nov. 30, 1913........ 3264 2214

147, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co, and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Dec. 31, 1913........ 3266 2215

148, Contract of Lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Sept. 30, 1913........ 3268 2216

149, Contract of Lease between Hartford Coal Co. and

the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Jan. 1, 1913....... 3270 2218

150, Contract of Lease between Mammoth Vein Coal Co.

and the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Mar. 27, 1911. 3273 2219

151. Agreement between Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co.

and Mammoth Vein Coal Mining Co., July 7, 1914.... 3275 2221

Contract between Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., and

the Mammoth Vein Coal Mining Co., Mar. 23, 1914. 3275 2221

152, Contract between Sebastian County Coal and Mining

Co. and the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Co., Aug. 1913. 3278 2223

153, Contract of lease between Mammoth Vein Coal Mining

Co. and the Hartford Coal Co., June 22, 1914........... 3283 2227

154, Contract of Lease between Franklin Bache and the

Hartford Coal Co., Nov. 20, 1913.............5.00005- 3295 2236

Contract of Lease between Receivers of Bolen-Darnall

Coal Co. and Franklin Bache, Nov. 19, 1913......... 3298 2238

155, Contract of Lease between Denman Coal Co. and

Hartford Coal Co., Dec. 1, 1910.............06 00 eee es 3303 2242

115, Agreement between Mammoth Vein Coal Co. and

Mammoth Vein Coal Mining Co., July 7,°1914......... 3305 2244

Contract between Mammoth Vein Coal Co. and Mammoth

Vein Coal Mining Co., Mar. 23, 1914..............555 3306 2244

116, Contract of lease between Kali-Inla Coal Co. and

Mammoth Vein Coal Co., Feb. 14, 1914..............+++ 3310 2246

Original. Print.

117, Contract of Lease between Denman Coal Co. and the

Mammoth Vein Coal Co., Dec. 5, 1911................. 3313 2248

118, Contract of Lease between Denman Coal Co. and the

Mammoth Vein Coal Co., Oct. 5, 1910................. 3316 2249

119, Contract of Lease between Denman Coal Co, and the

Mammoth Vein Coal Co., Jan. 15, 1914................. 3319 2251

157, Agreement between Receivers for Mammoth Vein

Coal Co., et al., and W. H. Miellmier, Oct. 19, 1917... 3323 2253

Contract of Lease between Receivers of Mammoth Vein

Coal Co., et al. and W. H. Miellmier, June 28, 1917... 3323 2254

PURE a ORD sty vbr k oon ay orale boeiead 89 ¥iaie'4 ab aIb Od 3328 2257

110, Assignment of Contract of Lease between T. W. M.

Boone and Wife, and Prairie Creek Coal Co. to Joseph

DE, Gerba Ot, BD TOG: os oa inns oe cg ienscssce es 3331 2258

111, Deed of Release as to Boone Lease by Cherokee Con-

GUIOTION TI, CORE. Dh: GUM 0 ne co sar nedcseeuedena dens 3336 2260

158, Contract of Lease between Mammoth Vein Coal Co.

and Coronado Coal Co., Jan. 3, 1910.................4. 3341 2263

114, Contract of Lease between Mammoth Vein Royalty

Co. and Mammoth Vein Coal Co., Oct. 1, 1904......... 3342 2264

Contract between Mammoth Vein Coal Co. and Midland

Valley Railroad Co., April 18, 1904.................. 3353 2272

St ER EU ooo a5 oa i sab x Sac yes 404 kale ues 3359 2275

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 158-A, Contract of Lease between Receivers

of Hartford Coal Co. and Roughley-Patterson-White Coal

BONG SR BRS eS acne erie ance Pah hee ce 3360 2276

CR ori a anls g elas d Mtn ses og ve aee ha NS a ee 3368 2280

OS SAN OE PRL EEE EEE PEPE POEL EUR T 3380 2289

be) aaa Rp een ia een ROR ORE en ee 3394 2209

Pe ee a Us os va Sd Raabe a SAW EOU RA RRA SOD 3399 2302

ER Se RT ere WE EEE PRET Tee Ry ee 3402 2304

NR ROR MIU oi ig ksotieeds vA ch poe ave de baadaen 3409 2309

i ree a Nk A ST A tea Rag Slee ean oe 3443 2332

Of By OE Se ee OMY AMT err ner Ener ty 3446 2334

William J. Clinton, Deposition of.................6.00eeeeeues 3464 2347

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit A, Receipt of United States Express Co.

for one case from Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

he MB AOI acks is sie unis Seed ie eae he Caeens yeas « 3467 2349

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit B, Receipt of United States Express Co.

for five cases from Remington Arms-Union Metallic Cart-

ridge Co., June 18, 1014... 50... ei ccn reser eerenonerecees 3467 2349

John J. Morris, Deposition of .... 0.0.6... 60.66 e eee eee eens 3467 2349

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit C, Receipt of American Express Co. for

two cases from Remington-Arms-Union Metallic Cartridge

O.; Beis BE, FORE. is aie eecdcccccns ue sNacevsearereseseacas 3469 2350

Thurman Looper, Deposition of..............5.0060ec eee eens 3469 2350

Excerpts of the Joint Conference Proceedings of the United

Mine Workers of America for 1901................00-00005- 3474 2353

Excerpt of Remarks of Mr. Mitchell...................0055 3474 2354

Excerpt of Remarks of Messrs. Mitchell, Bogle, Purcell

TEN ne ors wa koalas ered ates 0:3. « Rivka cawita oes etre 3475 2354

Excerpts of the Joint Conference Proceedings of the United

Mine Workers of America for 1902................000 0008 3478 2356

Excerpt of Remarks of Mr. Robbins..................-.5+: 3478 2356

Original. Print.

SS NORIO SRT oon Ae AE On AT Oe 3479 2357

Excerpt of Report of Committee on Credentials............ 3480 2358

Excerpt of Remarks of Mr. Mitchell....................... 3481 2358

Excerpt of Remarks of Mr. Lewis..................0.0000- 3481 2359

Excerpt of Colloquy between Messrs. Ryan, Mitchell and

GEG SES ER i Ang Re a en 3483 2360

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Mitchell..................... 3484 2361

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Lewis....................... 3484 2361

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Mitchell..................... 3485 2361

Excerpt of Argument of Mr. Reese....................00.. 3487 2363

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Mitchell..................... 3488 2364

Agreement as to Scale of Wages between Miners and

SL Re i hoe AU) We Lee ee ee 3489 2364

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Mitchell..................... 3490 2365

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Lewis..................... 3492 2366

Excerpt of Statement by Mr. Lewis...................... 3493 2367

Wes aay SUN OMEN Goa sis 5 5 ay Kha A aed ehan gee) aa beeen ese 3494 2368

NI NI oo ora dc 2 vc dha gkieeciow Miainalwa’s calorie ys 3498 2371

172, Decree, March 10, 1915, of the United States District

Court, Western District of Arkansas, in the case of Coro-

nado Coal Company., et al., vs. Sebastian County Coal

I ON i ae cewadet's 3498 2371

173, Deerge, September 4, 1915, of the United States Dis-

trict Court, Western District of Arkansas, in the case

of Coronado Coal Company, et al., vs. Sebastian County

I RR OR Og gs 3504 2375

177, Voucher drawn by A. G. McGraw on the United Mine

Workers of America, Local Union 1565, $2.00, Oct. 2,

178, Voucher drawn by A. G. McGraw on the United Mine

Workers of America, Local Union 1565, $2.00, Oct. 2, 1917. 3512 2380

Excerpt of United Mine Workers Journal, April 16, 1914... ... 3518 2384

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 189, Expense Account of John P. White,

first 2 weeks of April, 1914, Narrative Statement of...... 3520 2385

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 190, Expense Account of James Mullen,

first 2 weeks of April, 1914, Narrative Statement. of..... 3521 2386

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 191, Report of Officers of United Mine

Workers of America for first half of April, Narrative State-

MS ie iahee sass F tskh a ckada oe ka AER eee Eee eae 3524 2388

Excerpt of the Minutes of the Executive Board of the United

Mine Workers of America, May 4, to 8, 1914 at Indianapolis,

NE SPEIRS PRO ey Loerie Ey serene LG, Rent cy RE Sie 3525 2389

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, July 9, 1914........ 3527 2391

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, July 23, 1914....... 3528 2391

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, July 30, 1914...... 3531 2393

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, March 30, 1911.... 3532 2394

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, July 30, 1914....... 3534 2396

Excerpts of United Mine Workers’ Journal, August 6, 1914.... 3540 2399

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, November 19, 1914. 3542 2401

Excerpt of the Minutes of the International Executive Board

of the United Mine Workers’ at Indianapolis, Indiana,

DRC RRN By FCG ino ies soe Seeks wad ae bea eae hee 3548 2405

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, December 3, 1914. 3549 2406

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, November 26, 1914. 3552 2408

Original. Print.

Letter to Judge Youmans, July 27, 1914.................... 3554 2409

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, November 26, 1914. 3555 2410

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, November 26, 1914. 3558 2412

Plaintiff's Exhibit 193, Indictment returned in the U. 8.

District Court for the Western District of Arkansas...... 3563 2415

Decree of the U. S. District Court for the Western Dis-

trict of Arkansas, May 9, 1914, in the case of Mammoth

Vein Coal Mining Company vs. M. Hunter, et al......... 3564 2416

Letter to Judge Youmans, July 27, 1914.................... 3570 2421

Excerpt of the Proceedings of the Convention of the United

Mine Workers’ National Organization, for 1916............ 3575 2425

Excerpt of the Report of the Committee on Credentials. ... 3575 2425

Excerpt of the Final Report of the Committee on Cre-

oS RR SES MR Ty LOD Gh ROA PEGS HN ORES APE eS 3575 2425

Excerpt of the Complete Report of the Committee on

CRE Seo ei ae iia anenckcns Chen bok oven et 3576 2425

Excerpt of the Report of President White.................. 3576 2426

Excerpt of the Report of the Committee on Officers’ Reports. 3578 2427

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, December 3, 1914.. 3578 2431

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, April 15, 1915...... 3584 2431

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, October 14, 1915... 3586 2433

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, October 7, 1915.... 3587 2433

Excerpt of the Proceedings of the Convention of the United

Mine Workers, District No, 21, September 21, 1915......... 3590 2436

Final Corrected Report of the Credentials Committee. ..... 3590 2436

Excerpt of the Report of President Hanraty............... 3592 2437

Excerpt of the Remarks of Mr. Howard.............. 12+. 3093 2437

Excerpt of the Remarks of Mr. McLaughlin................ 3594 2438

Excerpt of the Remarks of Mr. Covington................. 3595 2439

Excerpt of the Remarks of Mr. Covington................. 3596 2439

Excerpt of the Proceedings of the Convention of the United

Mine Workers of District No. 21, April 18, 1916, Recital of. 3602 2414

Excerpts of Treasurer’s Cash Book of Local Union No. 1565,

PR TR en le ae cn en Pe hay han? welsh nee fe'g 3603 2445

Excerpts of Minute Book of Local Union No. 1526............ 3608 2449

en ss6n- ae gicar cage Galea MARELLA 3613 2453

Excerpt of Minute Book of Local Union No. 1814, of Deming,

MM ing cs Opti aes boy artd HEN EEA KOE CI On eaae 3630 2474

Excerpt of Minute Book of Local Union No. 1842, of Greenwood,

Fe PRE Re Oat OP Ne eT RIE ee SE PA ea a oe SI Ie 3630 2475

Excerpt of Minute Book of Local Union No. 1912, of Hartford,

DE Re Peers ty ile ie eae faite hie naa ake date was 3631 2475

Excerpt of Minute Book of Local Union No. 2769, of Hartford,

MG Se re oe ey ewe needs eta aeane pees 3631 2475

Excerpt of the Minutes of Meeting at Huntington, Arkansas,

WA SUS ie cers tReet ae eevieaicn neato nak. CeF 3632 2466

Excerpt of Minutes of Local Union No. 2494, at Arcole, Arkansas? 3633 2466

Excerpt of the Minutes of the International Executive Board

oS Pia" ARSARSIES CREE Say oh RE RS a a 3634 2467

Excerpt of the Minutes of the International Executive Board

at Philadelphia, November 16 to 21, 1914.................. 3634 2467

Excerpt of the Fifth Semi-Annual Report of Fred W. Holt,

Secretary-Treasurer of District No. 21, United Mine Workers

: Original. Print,

Excerpt of Semi-Annual Report of T. B. Douglas, Secretary-

Treasurer from October 1, 1914, to March 31, 1915........... 3636 2469

Excerpt of Semi-Annual Report of T, B. Douglas, Secretary-

Treasurer from April 1, 1915 to September 20, 1915......... 3639 2471

Excerpt of the Eighth Semi-Annual Report of the United Mine

Workers of America, District No. 21, October 1, 1915 to

Bag TEREST Spat GS to ge ne a 3640 2471

Excerpt of the Ninth Semi-Annual Report of the United Mine

Workers District No, 21, April 16, to September 30, 1916.... 3641 2472

Excerpts of the Criminal Docket U. 8. District Court Western

District of Arkansas, (In Re judgments and .sentences of

ET RE CER RDS eo a ry Cn 3648 2476

Excerpt of the Criminal Docket U. 8. District Court Western

District of Arkansas, (In Re fines)..................000005, 3657 2483

Excerpts of the Criminal Docket U. 8. District Court Western

District of Arkansas, (In Re judgments and sentences of

Sandy Robinson, et al. for contempt)........................ 3663 2487

Plaintiff's Exhibit 159, Bond on Contract between Chicago, :

Rock Island and Pacific Railway Company and Bache-Denman

Coal Company, March 21, 1911...............ccccceeeeeeaes 3667 2490

Contract between Chicago, Rock Island and Pacific Railway

Company and Bache-Denman Coal Company, March. 21,

Te a ee i eas baww'h 09 3668 2491

Plaintiff's Exhibit 40, Letter to U.S. Marshal, Western District

PM BEOU UE, BURG, acccedcceeecuhcrecedsccveseces 3681 2500

Plaintiff's Exhibit 41, Letter to John 8. Cameron.............. 3683 2502

RO EN MOMENI Wi. c.g shad aeen steedectabertheedsarsege 3685 2503

Defendant's Motion for a directed verdict and motion to strike

out certain testimony denied and exceptions thereto, Recital of 3687 2504

Testimony for Defendant’s

eB ee aise dpb eens chee ia

ee ee ds (ua TxA yuk Wa aude a DERE ES

es ce hy rn Win Cn Re Give Ganon ahs una coat

Original. Print.

kd cn vad nde aneaek das Sauna eel 3799 2582

SELES DE OEE PRE EEE PEE hy 3802 2584

ok od od Cute nw hs CHES EKE FRAUD Kaka KEE 3813 2591

BEES CO, FEU PEST Pee PTET ree ree 3814 2592

SEE SEE OEE OTT EEO TTT Sie 3821 2599

Mary Mastell..... LE POE PR eee EEE Ly Ls? 3833 2607

NCTE ER ET RCT EPTRPET TCE TO Terre 3837 2610

SE cls hoe Sek ky Ci Newb wk hGAaee CORALS E ES 3844 2615

NS , cikvc Sob g hna week ad bares saw en Va ake 4s NehE eC aREa Nee 3847 2616

RR Ste coca) Ce re aie es he kw hale Vine Meee 3851 2619

SEITE EETT LTR RTRTR ETT TETUPCRL CEE Cr 3866 2629

Co EY rere ere rere rer ee ore trey” 3875 2635

a eee CLM eek erred 3882 2640

Excerpt of the United Mine Workers’ Jouraal, July 23, 1914. 3893 2648

RN a it wy Nah evn aN DANY KRU SL ORR) aaa ee 3895 2649

Ce eg cok a nis tras. Pare ibck saaeeaine 3900 2653

EPS Ee eee ona ites mys “ae meget 3908 2658

ce civ oia' bh rbaG ka ba Gad ae ORR Roe REE 3913 2

i he. a cay ea hs Sa NTON Eek Oo weed OE 3919 2666

Sd oe oe outa dy gh 6 oe FANDDG TON ROR REET 3927 2671

RS a) es cag be sane Rds +e Rw de aan 3931 2673

EN ee a Se a oh eb SW Ae de Rade RN RAND 3934 2675

CT re EO ot ge RT wey Fe em are 4 or 3945 2682

iter Sl otk at a Ss os saa bara akan Be 3958 2691

Ne de alias hue vabe NW nye cede 3965 2696

TN ee Nae eA aK «5 Naud as eee 3969 2698

I hs ee Fh ean a rk oes be Kan Lh ED eaee kee 3972 2700

a wach bE Kies PRK ESO Rw 3981 2707

EE RR ee er rere ere ey 3987 2711

ERE Le A ey i races URC OEE SD Sa HS gery Sar me 3992 2715

ES EER AL RR Ee TTT EM 3996 2717

ere. ror ha cle eck a Te een Dose akae Rade 3998 2718

TULL. olor ult ies Gah aa GM Os yo ek aon ree 4002 2721

ee er cata Cay hd Sa Ren MSU Rd ER ULAA ME CEES 4004 2722

EN DIS ROLE A DRE ERS Se! AE 4007 2742

SG ES gE RR Oa Er re pe ee 4040 2747

eas phe c ais ab sheuk panes Ald 10h os Caneel 4044 2750

os ong ace bck shoe seared ene hevanes avenee 4048 2753

EE EAST ee MUS RPO Ie cee ni N ern ST ei 4057 2759

tr Pe os baad eae sale eae 4066 2765

EE ES ics o7 rss fun 6h 5 wha babe hE SRR aR aS Oe E OR 4070 2768

Re see a st ay da'e Lidl § pi's'nisce Aokw halen oaks 4087 2780

RN DS a Ne ero ee ots ee 4089 2781

Es oe rs) 5 cuca d gpankatonViadeesa Gakeeee 4098 2787

ee car ya chy kt sak ads knee xk AeA eRe 4100 2788

gd os irk G Ori Cals Va Rha aatOrET SO eAWON A SY ME RIS 4106 2793

a ir LS icdiny i va babies TS ULNA ARR 4108 2794

og I Errore errr errs PEP re Pere 4118 2801

I TCU cho Class eect phan ahasso ean eae ke careek 4125 2805

RN Ri a oye Ne a hn bn bag CAR vam eon ncaa VK Ad ORNS 4127 2807

RA ONL Wine vor shingle wa ak ve ick AW in eo nk nas 4130 2808

os oe Cul Rack an inuise bed Kio Qu beisn ee 4132 2810

Original. Print.

NS SE IRE ASE i ee Ee ied es” 4139

ees Bly shales ns dips de carve Weed tlhe PeeR 4146

TE ora FE as dy alata a nlpcn aie tb wk 9 RAR a aa 4152

eas re ya fat vos i haGdo wah because bee Ree ed Bee 4157

a De aan ache tidy ba OW aE Rents 4161

28, Constitution of the United Mine Workers of America,

RS ORR Pe pee eres ee tonne rae 4161

29, Certified Copy of the Articles of Incorporation of the

Denman Coal Company, State of West Virginia.......... 4104

30, Certified Copy of the Articles of Incorporation of Bache-

Denman Coal Company, State of West Virginia.......... 4109

31, Excerpt of Articles of Incorporation of Hartford Coal

Company, State of Arkansas, June 3, 1907................ 4210

32, Excerpt of Articles of Incorporation of Denman Coal

Company, State of Arkansas, June 3, 1907................ 4211

33, Excerpt of Articles of Incorporation of Mammoth Vein

Coal Mining Company, State of Arkansas, June 3, 1907... 4212

3A, Certified Copy of Articles of Agreement and Incorporation

of the Prairie Creek Coal Mining Company, State of Arkan-

I ee Fore We aban uate thd 4213

35, Certified Copy of Articles of Agreement and Incorpora-

tion of the Mammoth Vein Coal Company, State of Arkan-

CSM cscs Us cc has bead dd at anes ten te tae tt 4218

36, Certified Copy of Articles of Agreement and Incorpora-

tion of the Sebastian County Coal Company, State of

Mins, Mowemned BE, TRB. occ ccc vcvesccvecvecesens 4226

37, Excerpt of Articles of Incorporation of Bache-Denman

Coal Company, State of Arkansas, June 3, 1907........... 4232

38, Excerpt of Articles of Incorporation of Coronado Coal

Company, State of Arkansas, June 3, 1907............... 4232

le ie I Mw op edo nnve reenedereresbansns 4234

Exhibit A, Agreement between Montana Coal Operators’

Association and United Mine Workers of America, District

NE SERIE OTE Ore Pe eee TTT 4240

Exhibit B, Agreement between Montana Coal Operators’

Association and United Mine Workers of America, Dis-

en ONS ne and nauwn ate hie 4284

Exhibit C, Agreement between Montana Coal Operators’

Association and United Mine Workers of America, District

ee ed vexed vee rieevasdeepbareree 4333

as citings aby oui uv bud ad wo vain Pees one 4393

i il oa as cre vys boken aiun ss end ee eaeee ee 4394

Charles E. Jones, Deposition of

Exhibit A, Constitution and By-Laws of the Western Coal

Operators’ Association, Adopted April 1, 1910

Exhibit B, Agreement between United Mine Workers of

America and Washington Coal Operators’ Association,

August 13, 1910

Exhibit C, Agreement between United Mine Workers of

America and Washington Coal Operators’ Association,

August 27, 1912

2813

2818

2822

2826

2829

Original, Print.

Exhibit D, Agreement between United Mine Workers of

America and Washington Coal Operators’ Association,

NED CaN a'cseeas bcs connseneduianeeserbevbesees 4520 3102

IE Se ate eu io Se Nol. eae the b an Te RESTS ee bOaTT Dae 4577 3142

Testimony for Plaintiffs in Rebuttal.............. 600s ceeeeeeenes 4579 3143

ee eee ch bi cua Sulndnga ae CEs OL aees ePE RTE RES 4579 3143

ye Sa ae EO See ree eee te may ea WS 4581 3144

I SS ee os eae pv cdade hoe ENED MON 4582 3145

RS i eS os eee is pawe hea bermeen Dhaba med 4583 3146

NE a ai ars ree nin ibemarev ads shane tees 4584 3146

Excerpt of Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 59, check-off list of the Central

Coal and Coke Company, Mine No. 6, July 15, 1914......... 4585 3147

Excerpt of Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 58, check-off list of Local Union

es i BG MS oi ada ehh ede aa 10g wEFOWs re 8045s KOA) 4586 3148

PRR ee ee wcdle ud vob ees have Mae eel 4586 3148

NOES POPE FEE PCP POE CPP CTE OE Oe PEROT Ee 4592 3152

Plaintiffs’ Exhibit, No. 211, Motion to dismiss Appeal and

Writ of Error, filed in the U. 8. Circuit Court of Appeals. 4601 3158

ics ciciss) vadeder vide Oden dstnean eater nria 4605 3161

NE 2a g san ene be sapen shepaeerveerhewen seueate 4608 3163

William Rush........... jvonsdebpacdectbees baa ceduaceepeonsys 4612 3165

SS EA ELT EET PET PET TT ELEN TE ERY IE cy 4614 3166

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, November 10, 1910... 4615 3167

Excerpt of the United Mine Workers’ Journal, July 22, 1909..... 4616 3168

a Be Fe ON OE ono ore ey ccee e's nuevas thaxevenens 4619 3170

Excerpt of United Mine Workers’ Journal, July 27, 1911 (Official

Se NE N's og ops 80-00 5) Sidad adhe eehnt tes rieeas 4619 3170

RN I at cle ah pin a RR aa DCN EAP TE 4621 3171

212 Affidavit of William Mikel as to Records of Local Union

213, Affidavit of Hugh Miller, as to the Records of Local

nh ds Xe he Ae nee De eae 4622 3172

214, Affidavit of E. W. Abston, as to Records of Local Union

215, Affidavit of Hugh Miller, as to Records of Local Union

No, 2110, having been destroyed by fire.................. 4624 3147

216, Affidavit of W. F. Wallace, as to Records of Local Union

Memorandum Opinion of District Court on Defendants’ Motion

NE ERE POCO EOE ETOP PAPE EE 4632 3179

Motions fcr directed verdict overruled and Defendants’ Excep-

0 ER ae OOP SAE PCR Pen Te ee eer ee F 4643 3187

Motions to strike out certain testimony denied and Defendants’

PN I cok aceu iss fuds dea sseeasaworecveastrebts 4643 3187

Court’s Instructions to the Jury and Exceptions thereto.......... 4644 3188

Instructions to the Jury requested by the Defendants............ 4691 3220

Court’s additional Instructions to the Jury............6 0.606.000: 4707 3232

Court's further Instructions to the Jury... ......6 0.666660 c eee uee 4708 3233

Court's further Instructions to the Jury and Exceptions thereto. 4710 3234

en en OED BEINN oia b's sa's-da pre 08 64 <9H0 poe heme ewas 4713 3237

Certificate of Judge to Bill of Exceptions. ................6600005 4715 3238

Motion for nune pro tune order on Demurrers to Third Amended.

Tee PPP eee eee eee eee eee ee eee eee ee eee eee eee eee eee ee

Original. Print.

Order, February 15, 1918, as of March 17, 1917, overruling Demurrers

co: cence Amended Complaint oi... 5... 6... e ccc ccc ac ccteade nes 4717 3239

Order allowing interest on Judgment.................0..0.0..0005. 4719 3240

Order allowing Attorneys’ Fee................. 0... cece cece neces 4722 3242

ERNE HEREC oc sk ceca sche ch scvevacis cacedecveavoue 4723 3242

IE OE WEEN 6.0 5. W'iv-ciek's vee ac sg cos cdescagetewdscvav ds 4726 3244

EE A avs £00 9 ahh ne bans cau lech nekabaseny uo ORES 4883 3356

Certificate of Authority from U. S. Treasury Department to

The Aetna Accident and Liability Company, ete............... 4891 3362

U. 8. Treasury Department list of companies acceptable as sure-

ee i OI OEE MBO ss oan ceeds xavak ode cheeks che 4895 3365

Rue NR OU REG MN TONMIIN , c. . cc ca wcewoa occ vs ndtecboveepenen 4897 3366

INE INN Cos kc bce ese eh a pcwdicg Soe Such eanee 4904 3373

Petition of Defendants for an Order amending Bill of Exceptions, ete. 4905 3373

Cartoon taken from United Mine Workers’ Journal, of June 11, |

EER AAR EAS Sater at Cae y tepoenh ote ey Ear ONES Cede ene Oi tae es ae 4906 3375

Cartoon taken from United Mine Workers’ Journal, of August 28,

a NC da Ces Vous why Aa woe atl CE OOD MAARTEN 4907 3376

Cartoon taken from United Mine Workers’ Journal, of July 16,

RE Sl ceo Ta eth Od a pavers Seis cua etainee ee ae TEL. 4908 3377

MIN So ales Lek, dy irae Regu uaa wade Shek S 4909 3378

61, Relief Map of the vicinity of Prairie Creek, Sebastian

RI UNMIS) 5 ks 2 6 d'y's os Wore: olavisn ee 0b aid 0 eMac e 4909 3378

62, Photograph of Coronado Tipple, November 19, 1913........ 4910 3379

i eR NE Oo a a ee ee ea yi 4910 3379

63, Photograph of Rock Island Tipple in connection with Mam-

moth Vein Mine No. 1, November 19, 1913................... 4911 3380

ly IRONY BUI osc. o nk cess cae dag eam ede dena ba 4911 3380

64, Photograph of Mammoth Vein No. 6, November 19, 1913... 4912 3381

65, Photograph of Mr. Heber Denman in Mammoth Vein Mine

Pua 2; Seren OO WOU 90, SOUR oc ss hc oh ccios 9 oadcw Rede 4913 3382

Me PINE oh ch 8 een i a ay 4913 3382

66, Photograph of Dallas Mine, November 13, 1913............ 4914 3383

Taep EOIN Nose 2 ia soo sie a peso hehe 4914 3383

67, Photograph of Midland Valley Tipple at Mammoth Vein

wets a, NN EOL EDN. oo sda oo ahs o ydcepeeeseceoees 4915 3384

oe ee SERED ear ee ae MED LEED Elna gt nied 4915 3384

68, Photograph of Prairie Creek Mine*No. 4, November 19,

a RIESE eS PRR NE Siena Ray ee te Oe Coty ee SA 9 he Sah LD Re ane en 4916 3385

i INES ON GS So os cee nals waa sale 4916 3385

76, Photograph of engine and boiler room of Prairie Creek

eee SN te AU ceo sed hc xk cas Shooters 4917 3386

77, Photograph of Boiler Room of Prairie Creek No. 3, July 20,

Pies ain ss peng Sine as oA NES ties aula, da Rake Ramo eeolere oe’ 4918 3387

78, Photograph of Tipple and Mine, Prairie Creek No. 3,

i eS ORES NE en a atte ne PE POD Lenin WORT a 4919 3388

i MOREE MNOS 255.08 acay bad bade cacoknaebs 4919 3388

81, Photograph of Mammoth Vein Mine No. 1 (Midiand Valley

pe og S| NaNO ee ine SrerMane ence priser Te 4920 3389

i NINN TU. Dinas Sib ae wb Fun Ceo OUR aR eee TOS 4920 3389

82, Photograph of Mammoth Vein No. 1, (Midland Valley

UR A Be AONE s «9 a os oc coc Via cba ceed hoe CksS ho aeees 4921 3390

83, Photograph of Mammoth Vein No. 1, July 20, 1914......... 4922 3391

Original. Print.

84, Photograph of Rock Island Dump and Tipple site at Mam-

moth Vein No. 1. (Midland Valley Tracks) July 20, 1914.... 4923 3392

85, Photograph of slope of Mammoth Vein No. 1, July 20, 1914. 4924 3393

86, Photograph of Boiler House Mammoth Vein No. 1, July 20,

RUNG eee eco te ee ie Bie Rens eek EOE TO ei amare Pa 4925 3394

87, Photograph of Mammoth Vein No. 1, (Midland Valley

Tipple) July 20, 1914. . Bt ORR ae BY PME AES ACR ee se ee 4926 3395

97, Photograph of Prairie Creek Mine No. 4, July 19, 1914...... 4927 3396

89, Photograph of Prairie Creek No. 4, Tipple, July 19, 1914.... 4928 3397

90, Photograph of mouth of shaft of Prairie Creek No. 4, Mine,

ONT | NR Aan SARI PWT haa aaa 4929 3398

91, Photograph of Prairie Creek No. 4, July 19, 1914........... 4930 3399

94. Photograph of the smoke of Prairie Creek No. 3. July 20,

TTS lacie tl San ites ge nc eR re Are ee eam lien oh ote ena 4931 3400

92, Photograph of Coronado Mine after the fire, July 20, 1914. 4932 3401

eh EOIN OB OE ks oo cis va ede hoe eb ae teen beeen 4932 3401

| Defendants’ Exhibit 26, Photograph of culvert through which

Mrs. Gooden crawled on night of shooting at Frog Town...... 4933 3402.

Bill of Lading issued by the Midland Valley Railway Company,

July 16, 1914, for car of coal shipped by the Mammoth Vein

Coal Mining Company to McAlester Fuel Company............ 4938-a3406

Order, April 25, 1918, as of February 7, 1918, amending Bill of Excep-

Page.

Proceedings in the U. S. Circuit Court of Appeals.......cceeeer eee ees +. 3412

Appearance of Mr. tc Warrum and Messrs. Covington & Grant

as Counsel for Plaintiffs in Error. .........-.eeeeeeee Pe ere 8412

Appearance of Mr. Alton B. pecker us Counsel for Plaintiffs in

PRO bec cvcsernres Joncas iaunese ee POC TY rere eee ae ore 8412

Appearance of Mr. James B. McDonough as Counsel for Defendants

errr rr perry ree ree Susans paca bien Gi bnmeee oe. 3412

Appearance of Mr. Henry 8S. Drinker, Jr., as Counsel for Defendants

So in sic. cess 5 os eet bagetas Cavete bas erase Veusanny (eedewsOun 3413

Appearance of Mr. Roger B. Hull as Counsel for Defendants in

RO wine aneeeenan Sala cid wai ae oes a soe Ske. tee Rae rere ee .. 384138

Order of Submission..... PEIN PE ORT POR ET Ee rT PPT Core oe. «68418

Submission to third Judge........ cece sees eeecerescees Katie wks even

Opinion, U. 8. Circuit Court of Appeals........ dike kon Re

Nisi Judgment, U. S. Circuit Court of Appeals. .........6.65 Terre Te

Certified Copy of Remittitur of Defendants ‘“ Error filed in Dis-

oy 6, a erry ra Tenis Terie tS ae bs PT Ore ~. 8439

Final Judgment, U. S. Circuit Court of Appeals........... (devas cee eee

Petition of Defendants in Error for allowance of Counsel Fees....... S442

Protest against allowance of Counsel Fees to Counsel for Defend-

ants in Error........ inka eege ke hanee SP Pr rem ee eidewws te ‘ 3448

Reply to Protest by Plaintiffs in Error against adint of Coun-

sel Fees to Counsel for Defendants in Error... ...... eee eee ees sé S444

Order denying Petition of Defendants in Error for diseieies of

Counsel Fees .........006. Sekeh Cree ee kes exwans Kees 64 Saks .. S445

Petition of Plaintiffs in Error for a Rehearing. ........60. cece eeeees S445

Order denying Petition of Plaintiffs in Error for a Rehearing........ 3450

Motion for stay of Mandate........... eer ere y ore senws see hs .. 8450

Order staying Mandate..........0...eeeeee covabde sos Wa Wew es os aoe > ee

Motion for further stay of Mandate... .... 0. cece cece e eee eee eee eeee 3451

Order staying Mandate until February 15, 1920...... 0.660 cee eee eee 3452

Petition for Writ of Error from Supreme Court U. 8. and allowance

thereof ...... ay ee we wake aes wot Pere Pry ee ory ee a Viecwieaes os B42

Assignment of Errors on Writ of Moree from Supreme Court U.S.....0 3458

Cost Bond on Writ of Error from Supreme Court U. S.........-.-066- S459

Supersedeas Bond on Writ of Error from Supreme Court U. S........ BAT

Writ of Error from Supreme Court U. 8S. and Clerk’s Return......... 3478

Citation on Writ of Error from Supreme Court U. 8. and Acceptance

of Service ..... percearcescecscevceeeese 0:00:00 9 000 Ne Ove eee sedegs S474

Clerk’s Certificate to Transcript........ccccecscccecceecscsseens coves 8476

| eoueea

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 839

1280 Monday, October 28, 1917. 2:00 o’clock P. M.

Pursuant to adjournment, Court reconvened at 2:00

o’clock P. M., the parties appearing as before, the following

proceedings were had:

FrankKuin Bacue, resumed the stand.

Cross-Examination (Cont’d.)

By Mr. Covington:

Q. Referring to the clause in the 1903 contract read by

you just before noon, I will ask you if that does not include

all the non-union conditions in existence then, except to the

advance of 12-% per cent? If that is not the only change

in the non-union conditions and the Union conditions.

A. I don’t think that any non-union conditions existed in

the field at that time, all the mines were union, as far as I

know.

Mr. Covington: Your Honor, I am not certain whether

I offered this or not before the roon hour.

The Court: I am not certain either.

Mr. Covington: I desire now to offer it.

The Stenographer:. It has already been identified as Ex-

hibit 7.

Q. Then, passing from the contract of 1903 to 1904, was

there any contract entered into between the operators Asso-

ciation of the southwest and the miners organization?

A. In 1904?

Q. Yes. A. Yes.

Q. Where? A. Pittsburg, Kansas, I think.

Q. Were you representing any of the plaintiff companies

here at that time?

A. I was probably representing the Denman Company at

that time.

1281 Q. You were in that company once, were you?

A. I think I was, Mr. Covington, I am confident of it.

Q. Who was chairman of the conference?

A. I don’t recall.

Q. Were you one of the scale committee? A. I think go.

. Was there anything in the contract in 1904 that was

not in the contract of 1903, with reference to the condition of

work, and the hours of employment and prises to be paid

for labor?

| 54—5154

840 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

_ A. I don’t know whether there was any advance made

in 1904 or not. The contracts from year to year were very

much alike.

Mr. Covington: I would like to have this paper marked

or identified as Exhibit 8.

Q. I hand you Exhibit 8, and I ask you what it is.

A. You want me to read it?

Q. No, I just ask you what it is.

A. District 21 Agreement operators and miners, Pitts-

burg, Kansas, August 10, 1904, from April Ist 1904 to March

31, 1906; Southwest Interstate Coal Operators Association

and United Mine Workers of America for Missouri, Kansas,

Arkansas, Indian Territory and Texas.

._ Was that the contract that you made at Pittsburg in

August, 1904? A. Yes, sir.

Q. Who signed on behalf of the operators association?

A. I will look and see. B. F. Bush, President, S. W.

Kniffin, Secretary.

Q. Who signed on behalf of the miners?

A. Pete Hanraty, Frank J. McGuire, John Lepps, John

Morgan and B. F. Clevenger.

Mr. Covington: I want to offer Exhibit 8 in evidence.

(Exhibit 8 so offered in evidence is in words and figures

following, to-wit :)

1282 ‘Joint Inter-State

Agreement

of

Operators And Miners.

It is hereby agreed between the representatives of the

Southwestern Interstate Coal Operators Association and the

representatives of Districts 14, 21 and 25 of the United Mine

Workers of America, that the existing interstate, District

and Texas agreements be continued without any change or

addition whatever except as follows:

Day wage, yardage, dead and deficient work, to be. reduced

throughout 5.55 per cent, except the day wage scales in Texas

mines, which shall be reduced one-half the above amount.

Interstate and District scales to be signed simultaneously

at Pittsburg, and to expire March 31, 1906.

Inside Day [Wayge] Scale.

Track Layers’ helpers .......+++e+see0% 2.23

Trappers ......cceceeceveesercseeereeees 1.07

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 841

EN MR tips vee aa hed bu cesien oe 2.42

EE Sc seni velWeeia eke neaewetnn 2.42

EERO OTIS Reece mre yarn re her 2.42

a ose u er ibe iba ehh EC GeeeT es 2.42

ccc cee sr euurssunems deed ektadee 2.42

Water haulers and machine haulers........ 2.42

Timbermen where such are employed...... 2.42

Pipe men for compressed air plants........ 2.36

All other inside day labor................. 2.23

Spragging, coupling and greasing when

kk See a rere 1.65

ec eee ee oe ware g 2.64

1283 Shot firers under normal conditions ....... 2.83

Outside Day Wage Scale.

i rR ies baer bcscdndsaxune 2.83

Co hc a vb vces beside aoe 2.60

Blacksmiths’ helpers ..........sssesseees 2.23

EES RRS Pre ne OE 2.30

(Provided that in no case will there be any reduction from

the rate of wages now paid to carpenters of more than 5.55

per cent.)

All other outside day labor not enumerated 1.91.

Provided, that any class of outside day labor now receiv-

ing $2.02-1%4 or more per day shall be reduced 5.55 per cent.

This provision only applies to outside day labor not other-

wise enumerated.

Scale For Engineers.

Engineers, first class, 500 tons and over,

i Cc a Saws ee dcteaine se aenee to's 74.62

Second class, 300 tons to 500 tons, per

RE at pay t ek kd be édcakih 4d Ae 68.95

Third Class, 300 tons or less, per month. . .61.40

Tail rope and slope enginers shall be reduced 5.55 per cent

below present wages.

The minimum rate for tail rope and slope engineers shall

be $2.25 per day, or $58.56 per month; provided, further, that

the maximum rate for tail rope and slope engineers shall be

$2.55 per day or $66.12 per month. Twenty-six days to con-

stitute a [day’s] work. All over-time in excess of nine hours

to be paid for at a proportionate rate per hour.

The tonnage shall be determined by the average for the

month of November, 1902, and based upon mine run coal; but

842 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

in no casé shall any reduction from the present wages be

made.

1284 This scale of wages applies only to mines in operation

at least one year, and in all new mines the wages of

the engineers shall be advanced with the increased tonnage

until the maximum rate is reached; provided, that in no case

shall engineers employed at new mines receive less than $2.25

per day; also that in no case shall engineers, firemen or

pumpers be interferred with or asked to cease work by any

local committee or local union official during the life of this

contract.

The mining prices inside and outside day wage scale (ex-

cept engineers) provided for in this contract is based upon an

eight hour work day.

Rules And Regulations.

Eight hour day.

All classes of day labor are to work full eight hours, and

the going to and coming from the respective working places

it to be done on the day hand’s own time. All company men

shall perform whatever day labor the foreman may direct.

An eight hour day means eight hours’ work in the mines at

the usual working places, exclusive of noon time—which shall

be one half hour—for all classes of inside day labor. This

shall be exclusive of the time required in reaching such work-

peer in the morning and departing from the same at

night.

Drivers shall take their mules to and from the stables,

and the time required in so doing shall not include any part

of the day’s labor; their time beginning when they reach

the change at which they receive empty cars—that is, the

parting drivers at the shaft bottom and the inside drivers at

the parting and [engind] at the same places; but in no case

shall a driver’s time be docked while he is waiting

1285 for such cars at the points named. The inside drivers

at their option, may either walk to and from their

parting or take with them, without compensation, either load-

ed or empty cars to enable them to ride. This provision,

however, shall not prevent the inside drivers from bringing

to and taking from the bottom regular trips, if so directed

by the operators, provided such work is done within the

eight hours.

When the stables are located outside the mine the companies

agree to deliver the mules at the bottom of the shaft in the

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 843

morning and relieve the drivers of the mules at the bottom of

the shaft at night.

When the men go into the mines in the morning they shall

be entitled to two hours’ pay whether or not the mine works

full two hours; but after the first two hours the men shall be

paid for every hour thereafter, by the hour, for each hour’s

work or fractional:part thereof. If for any reason, the regu-

lar work can not be furnished the inside day laborers for a

portion of the first two hours, the operators shall furnish other

than the regular labor for the unexpired time.

Penalties for Loading Impurities.

In order to insure the production of clean, marketable coal,

it is herein provided that if any miner shall load with his coal,

sulphur, bone, slate, blackjack or other impurities, he shall for

the first offense, be notified by the mine foreman; for the sec-

ond offense he may be suspended for one day; for the third

and each subsequent offense occuring in any one month he

may be suspended for three days; provided, that if in any case,

it is shown that a miner maliciously or knowingly loads im-

purities, he shall be subject to discharge. It is further agreed

that if any miner has been suspended and claims that

1286 an injustice has been done him, the matter shall be

taken up for investigation and adjustment in the man-

ner provided in Section Three of this Agreement.

Duties of Pit Committee.

(a) The duties of the pit committee shall be confined to the

adjustment of disputes between the pit boss and any member

of the U. M. W. of A. working in and around the mines, arising

out of this agreement or any District or Sub-District agree-

ment made in connection therewith, when the pit boss and said

miner or mine laborer have failed to agree.

(b) In case of any local trouble arising in any mine

through such failure to agree between the pit boss and any

miner or mine laborer, the pit committee and the pit boss are

' empowered to adjust it, and in the case of their disagreement

it shall be referred to the superintendent of the company and

the district president of the U. M. W. of A., or such person as

he may designate to represent him; and should they fail to

agree it shall be referred to the commissioner of the South-

western Interstate Coal Operators’ Association and the dis-

trict president of the U. M. W. of A. for adjustment; and in all

cases the mines, miners, mine laborers and parties involved

must continue at work pending an investigation and adjust-

844 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS,

ment, until the final decision is reached in the manner above

set forth.

(c) If any day men refuse to continue at work because of

a grievance which has or has not been taken up for adjustment

in the manner provided herein, and such action shall seem

likely to impede the operation of the mine, the pit committee

shall immediately furnish a man or men to take such vacant

place or places at the scale rate, in order that the mine

1287 may continue at work; and it shall be the duty of any

member or members of the United Mine Workers who

may be called upon by the pit boss or pit committee to imme-

diately take the place or places assigned to him or them in

pursuance hereof.

(d) The pit committee, in the discharge of its duties, shall

under no circumstances go around the mine for any | cause

whatever, unless called upon by the pit boss or by a miner or

company man who may have a grievance that he cannot settle

with the boss. Any pit committeeman who shall attempt to

execute any local rule or proceeding in conflict with any pro-

vision of this contract, or any other made in pursuance hereof,

shall be forthwith deposed as committeeman. The foregoing

shall not be construed to prohibit the pit committee from look-

ing after the matter of membership dues and initiations in

any proper manner.

(e) Members of the pit committee employed as day men

shall not leave their places of duty during working hours ex-

cept by permission of the operator, or in cases involving the

stoppage of the mine.

(f) The right to hire and discharge, the management of

the mine and the direction of the working force are vested ex-

clusively in the operator, and the U. M, W. of A. shall not

abridge this right. It is not the intention of this provision

to encourage the discharge of employes or the refusal of em-

ployment to applicants because of personal prejudice or activ-

ity in matters affecting the U. M. W. of A. If any employ

shall be discharged or suspended by the company and it is

claimed that an injustice has been done him, an investigation

to be conducted by the parties and in the manner set forth in

paragraphs ‘‘a’’ and ‘‘b”’ of this section shall be taken

1288 up promptly and if it is proven that an injustice has

been done, the operator shall re-instate said employe

and pay him full compensation for the time he has been sus-

ended and out of employment; provided, if no decision shall

e rendered within five days the case shall be considered

closed, in so far as compensation is concerned, unless said fail-

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL, 845

ure to arrive at a decision within five days is [owning] to delay

upon the part of the operator, in which case a maximum of ten

days’ compensation shall be paid.

Local Demands.

There shall be no demands made locally by either operators

or miners which are in conflict with this agreement, or any

District or Sub-District agreement made prior to September

1, 1904; and there shall be no provision imposed violating the

same. <Any local member, official or committee shutting down

a mine without orders from the District President or District

Executive Board shall be fined in the manner provided for in

the national constitution of the U. M. W. of A., and such addi-

tional [enalties] may be imposed as are now or may be pro-

vided for in the constitutions of the various district organiza-

tions. All such fines are to be collected by the companies and

paid into the district treasury of the U. M. W. of A. Should

any operator violate this agreement, or any provision hereof,

such operator or company shall be fined one hundred dollars

($100.), said fine to be paid into the treasury of the South-

western Interstate Coal Operators’ Association.

Payment of Wages.

The operators agree to pay twice a month, the dates of pay-

ment to be determined by the District joint conventions; and

these payments are to be made at the office nearest to

1289 the mine wherein or at which the employees are em-

ployed; provided, however, that this office shall be lo-

cated not more than two miles from such mine.

Check-Off.

The operators will recognize the Pit Committee in the dis-

charge of their duties, as provided in this agreement, and agree

to check off dues, assessments, fines and initiations from all

miners and mine laborers when desired. In order to protect

the companies the U. M. W. of A. agrees, when the companies

so demand, to furnish a collective and continuqus order author-

izing the companies to make such deductions. The companies

agree to furnish the miners’ local representatives a monthly

statement showing separately the amount of dues, assessments,

fines and initiations calleched. In case any fine is imposed the

propriety of which is questioned, the amount of [wuch] fine

shall be withheld by the operator until the case has been taken

up for adjustment and a decision reached.

It is agreed that the miners may employ a Check-Weighman

to see that coal is properly weighed and a correct record made

846 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

thereof, and when such Check-Weighman is employed the com-

panies shall furnish him a check number, and he shall credit

to his number such portion of ‘each miner’s coal as he may be

authorized to do by the local union. It is understood that the

above provision shall not affect the arrangements now exist-

ing at any mine where a check number is issued in the name

of the local union, and dues, assessments, fines and initiations

collected by this method.

Measurements.

It is agreed that measurements of entries, brushing

room turning and deadwork shall be made semi-month-

1290 ry and payment in full shall be made for such work in

, the same manner as that in which other work is paid

or.

Equal Turn.

The operator shall see that an equal turn is offered each

miner and that he be given a fair chance to obtain the same.

The Check-Weighman shall keep a turn bulletin for the turn-

keeper’s guidance. The drivers shall be subject to whomever

_ a manager shall designate as turn-keeper in pursuance

ereof.

Deaths and Funerals.

In the event of an instantaneous death by accident in the

mine, the miners and underground em loyees shall have the

privilege of discontinuing work for the remainder of that

day; but work at the option of the operator, shall be resumed

the day following and continue thereafter. In case the op-

erator elects to operate the mine on the day of the funeral of

the deceased, as above, or where death has resulted from an

accident in the mine, individual miners and underground em-

ployes may, at their option, absent themselves from work for

the purpose of attending such funeral, but not otherwise. And

whether attending such funeral or not, each member of the

U. M. W. of A. employed at the mine at which the deceased

member was employed, shall contribute fifty (50) cents and the

operator twenty-five ($25) dollars for the benefit of the fam-

ily of the deceased or his legal representatives, to be collect-

ed through the office of the company. In the event that the

mines are thrown idle on account of the miners’ or other em-

ployes’ failure to report for work in the time intervening be-

tween the time of the accident and the funeral, or on the day

of the funeral, then the company shall not be call

1291 upon for the payment of the twenty-five ($25) dollars

above referred to.

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 847

Except in cases of fatal accidents, as above, the mine

shall in no case be thrown idle because of any death or funeral;

but in the case of the death of any employe of the company

or member of his family, any individual miner may, at his op-

tion, absent himself from work for the purpose of attending

such funeral, but not otherwise.

Doctor.

No deduction shall be made for doctors unless such deduc-

tion is authorized by the individual employe.

Condition of the Mine.

Yhe company shall keep the mine in as dry condition a»

practicable, by keeping the water off the road and out of the

working places. hen a miner has to leave his working place

on account of water, through the neglect of the company, they

shall employ said miner doing company work when practic-

able, and provided that said miner is competent to do such

work, or he shall be given another working place until such

water is taken out of the place.

Provisions for Injured.

The operators shall keep sufficient blankets, oil, bandages,

ete., and provide suitable ambulance or conveyance, readily

available at each mine to properly convey injured persons to

their homes after an accident.

Powder.

The price of powder shall be $2.00 per keg during the term

of this contract.

1906 Joint Convention.

It is agreed that the Southwestern Interstate Coal Operators

Association and the representatives of the United Mine

1292 Workers of America shall meet in the city of Indianap-

olis, Indiana, on the 25th day of January, 1906, at 10

o’clock a, m.

Appendix.

Harnessing Mules.

In regard to taking the mules into the mine where the mules

are kept on top of slope opening, the mules are to be taken

to and from the tipple to the mouth of the slope. In shaft

openings the [mueles] are to be taken down and up the shaft

by the company, either by the drivers on the company’s time,

of by the company employing a man to do so; and it may em-

ploy any man, or number of men, it chooses, to do this work,

848 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

Where mules are kept in the mine, if the mules are _har-

nessed by the company, the driver must be at the pit bottom,

or the parting where he commences work, ready to begin at

starting time. If the driver harnesses the mules, he does so

on the company’s time.

Penalties for Loading Impurities.

The interpretation of, or the construction to be placed upon,

that paragraph relative to penalties for loading impurities in

the agreement between the U. M. W. of A., and the Southwest-

ern Interstate Coal Operators’ Association, entered into at

Pittsburg, Kansas, July 27th, 1903, having been referred to the

undersigned, is ruled upon as follows. The paragraph reads:

‘¢Tn order to insure the production of clean, marketable coal,

it is hereby provided that if any miner shall load with his coal,

sulphur, bone slate blackjack or other impurities, he shall,

for the first offense, be notified by the mine foreman; for the

second offense he may be suspended for one day; for the third

and each subsequent offense occurring in any one month he

may be suspended for three days; provided, that if in

1293 any case it is shown that a miner maliciously or know-

ingly loads impurities, he shall be subject to discharge.”’

The question is upon what constitutes ‘‘one month’’ with-

in the meaning and the intent of this contract.

It was clearly intended by the pzrties to this contract

that if it became necessary to insure the prodrction of clean

coal, the penalties provided in this agreement should be and

could be inflicted. It is also clear that if the operation of

this agreement is to be limited and confined to each calen-

dar month for the period it is in effect, the penalties can

not be inflicted as contemplated by the parties to the agree-

ment, and the offender must be allowed to go unpunished.

For example, suppose a miner is notified on the first, or

any subsequent day of the calendar month that he has load-

ed dirty coal—that is the extent of his punishment for that

offense; and, suppose, he is notified on the first, or any sub-

sequent day of the calendar month following, that he has

loaded dirty coal, that is the limit of his punishment for the

second offense, notwithstanding the second offense may

have been committed on consecutive days, that is to say, on

the last day of one calendar month and the first day of the

calendar month following.

Again, the first offense may be committed on any day subse-

quent to the first day of the month; the second offense on

3 8 Ne EO NGI LE SORIANO nr aes a wiser

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 849

any day subsequent to the first offense, and the third of-

fense on the first day of the succeeding month, or any sub-

sequent day, and the offender go practically unscathed, be-

cause no penalty [othe] than that provided for the second

offense could be inflicted. Again, if the second offense oc-

curred on the last day of any calendar month on

1294 which the first offense occurred, the offense is con-

doned, because of the application, as lawyers would

say, of the ‘Statute of Limitations’’ interfering to save the

offender from the infliction of the punishment provided as

just and necessary to the consummation of the intent and

purpose of the contract—the ‘‘insurance of the production

of clean, marketable coal’.’

Now, in my judgment, that could not have been the in-

tent and purpose of the parties to this agreement, because

they clearly intended that the penalty should be inflicted if

the offenses were committed within the specified time, ‘‘one

month’’, i. e., thirty days. Nor would this impose any hard-

ships on the miner, or give the operator any undue advant-

age.

The ruling is, therefore, that ‘‘one month”’ in this agree-

ment, means thirty days.

If either of the district presidents disagree with this rul-

ing, they will please submit their reasons therefor in writ-

ing.

BENNETT BROWN,

Commissioner.

Copies sent to and endorsed by—George Colville, District

President No. 25.

George Richardson, District President No. 14.

Pete Hanraty District President No. 21.

Thomas M. King, Vice President District No. 21.

Pittsburg, Kansas, August 19, 1904.

A difference of opinion having arisen in regard to wheth-

er or not the brushing question in the northern part of

Kansas is to be taken up and adjusted by the President of

District 14 and the Operators’ Commissioner, the repre-

sentatives of the Miners and the representatives of

1295 the Operators agree to refer the matter to T. L.

_ Lewis, National Vice President of the U. M. W. of A.,

and W. C. Perry, Vice President at Large for the South-

Western Interstate Coal Operators’ Association for settle

ment.

850 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

Executed at Pittsburg, Kansas, this 19th day of August,

1904.

In behalf of the Southw estern Interstate Coal Operators’

Association.

B. F. BUSH, President.

: S. W. KNIFFIN, Secretary.

In behalf of the Miners:

J. G. RICHARDSON,

President District 14.

PETE HANRATY,

President District 21.

GEO. COLVILLE,

President District 25.

ROBERT GILMOUR,

Secretary Joint Convention.

T. L. LEWIS,

National Vice President.

District Agreement

Adopted August 19, 1904.

Southwestern Inter-State Coal Operators Association.

and

The United Mine Workers of America.

District Number 21.

1296 District Agreement.

Seale of District No. 1.

Prices for Mining in Indian Territory.

Coalgate, Edwardsville, Brewerville, Baker, Krebs

No. 11, No. 5 and No. 7 Buck No. 6, Harts-

horne, Haileyville, Gowen, Wilburton, Lu-

tie, Turkey Creek and Witteville, per ton for

mine run coal, $ 72

Alderson, Krebs No. 8, Carbon, Bache, Dow,

. Craig, per ton for mine run coal 77-Y%

Lehizh, for screened coal 90

Bolen-Darnall, McAlester mines, per ton hand-

picked, coal, 1.00 <

=

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 851

Samples, McAlester, mines, per ton hand-pocked

coal,

The mining price at Midway shall be eighty cents per ton

mine run coal. Coal mined in entries and air courses, the

price shall be seventy-four cents per ton mine run. The

price per ton at Midway shall cover all bottom taken up and

the removal of top bony.

All yardage, entry and dead work at Midway, also the in-

side and outside day wage scale, to be reduced 5.55 per cent.

Sutter and Witteville No. 4.

The mining price at Sutter, Indian Territory, and Mine

No. 4, Witteville, shall be ninety-five cents per ton for coal

screened over the standard diamond top screen of follow-

ing dimensions: Width, six feet; length, twelve feet; space

between bars to be 14% inch.

All entry, yardage and dead work to be reduced 5.55 per

cent under existing prices.

All refuse matter thrown into gob shall not be loaded

1297 unless same shall be paid for. Rate of payment on

such work to be agreed on by the company’s repre-

sentative and the pit committee. All coal shall be loaded

the same as run mine coal in the Pittsburg Agreement,

namely, every precaution shall be used to prevent the load-

ing of dirt. The rule adopted by the Pittsburg Conference

for the loading of impurities shall not apply to Sutter and

Witteville No. 4 to impurities passed through the screen but

to impurities passed over the screen, except where a miner

does not use due caution or maliciously loads impurities.

The price of mining low vein coal at Turkey Creek shall

be $1.00 per ton mine run. The conditions relating to min-

ing coal at present to remain unchanged.

Prices on yardage and dead work shall be reduced 5.55

per cent. Room cross cuts will be paid the same as air

courses where they are cut.

For taking up bottom at the Coalgate Company’s mine,

the following prices shall be paid: Where prevailin

height is required, seven cents per inch for each inch whe

coal is less than four feet in thickness. This does not in

clude all bottom, but only that representing the differen

between the actua! thickness of the coal and four feet.

The price for yardage and dead work at No. 7 Krebs

shall be as follows:

852 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

Where coal is three feet eight inches and under, same

rates will be paid as No. 8 Krebs. Where coal is over three

feet eight inches, same price will be paid as at No. 11 Krebs.

Seale of prices on cross-bars, dirt and deficient narrow

work in room necks at the mines on Atoka track, excepting

Midway.

1298 Setting cross-bars, 31 cents, eight-foot bar. Loading

dirt in cars, 26 cents per car. Air course yardage in

rooms turned off the entry where top will not alle w widen-

ing out. Where bottom is required to be taken up, entry

prices shall be paid. One-half room turning price to be paid

for widening out. Measurements to begin at entry and end

at point of widening out.

Prices on clod at Bolen-Darnell and Samples’ mines:

From September 1st to October 1st the price shall be five

cents per inch for all clod coming over the coal.

During the month of October the superintendent and pit

committee shall take the average thickness of the clod. The

price to be paid per inch shall be based on the average at

9 cents per inch for clod over four inches in thickness.

The superintendent and mine committee shall, on the 1st

of —” determine what day in the month averages shall

be taken.

The decision cf superintendent and mine committee shall

be final and binding for the term of this contract. This ap-

plies to clod coming from top of coal only.

All break-throughs in the Indian Territory shall be driv-

en from six to eight feet wide, and paid for at the rate of

$1.70 per yard. Measurement to be made from lower rib.

Seale of prices governing yardage at mines of the Great

Western Coal and Coke Company, at Wilburton, I. T.

For loading dirt and rock where same can not be gobbed,

28 cents per car.

For entry work where brushing is not required, $2.13 per

yard.

Where brushing is required it shall be paid for at the rate

of 47 cents for eight (8) inches or 6 cents per inch.

1299 Air courses shall be paid for at the rate of $1.70 per

yard.

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 853

Bottom brushing shall be paid for at the rate of 53 cents

per yard, where it is taken up, for turning rooms.

The price of setting cross-bars shall be 26 cents per bar,

under same conditions which have existed during the past

year.

The price of soda powder at Krebs shall be $2.00 per

keg.

All coal in the Indian Territory under two feet ten inches

on the 77-1/2 cents rate be declared deficient.

At Witteville the price for entry shall be $2.55 per yard,

brushing included; for air course, $1.70 per yard.

All coal under four feet in height in the Indian Territory

where bottom brushing has not been paid for in rooms, it

shall be paid for at 2-1/4 cents per inch per yard to make

the required height; and in Arkansas the same price and

prevailing conditions shall apply to digging bottom in

rooms. This shall not apply to mines of Dallas Coal Com-

pany nor the Central and Coke Coal Company mines at

Hartford. This question at Central Coal and Coke Com-

pany mines at Hartford is left to the commissioner of the

Operators’ association and the President of District No.

21, they select a third party if they can not agree.

The price for turning rooms in scale district 1 is $5.31.

Machine Scale for Indian Territory.

Loaders for chain ‘machines are to receive 45 cents per

ton in all classes of working places.

Runners are to receive 5 cents per ton.

Helpers are to reecive 41/2 cents per ton.

Loaders are to do ail work now done by pick miners

1300 except cutting of coal; this includes taking up of the

same amount of bottom under same conditions as ap-

plies to pick miners and furnish their own powder.

Day wage scale for loading after chain machines shall be

$2.42. No loader will be employed on the day wage scale

where it is practicable to employ them on tonnage rate.

Day Wage Scale.

_ The fire boss shall receive $2.87 per day and shall be sub-

ject to discharge by the management of the mine without

appeal; if competent, shall be given other work.

854 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS. |

The fire runner shall receive not less than $2.42 where

such is employed.

Auxiliary electric hoist operators:

Per day.

For boys, $1.89

Electric slope engineers, 2.42

Motormen 2.42

Pump men 2.42

Head machinist 2.93

Machinist 2.60

‘*Boys’’ means those of maximum age of 19 years.

Day wages for [digginc] coal, 2.66

Machine runners 2.83

Machine helpers 2.60

Shaft sinkers, 2.87

When any employe shall be requested to fill the place of

another employe, as specified herein, he shall receive the

wage of the employe whose place he takes, plus 26 cents; pro-

vided, further, that it is not compulsory on any man who

may not wish to take such place.

1301 The scale for Henryetta is referred to the District Pres-

ident and Operators’ Commissioner for adjustment.

Seale of District No. 2.

The price for mine run coal per ton shall be, $ 62

For screened coal per ton, 90

The operators are to have the option of paying on a screened

coal or mine run basis. When the coal is mined on a screened

coal basis the screens used shall be not more than six feet wide

have bars not more than sixteen feet long and a 1-'% inch

space between the bars.

Ouita.

For hand-picked coal, free from slack, slate, sulphur, bony

and blackjack, the price shall be as follows:

From the first of September to the first March, $1.22

From the first of March to the 31st of August, 1.07

Spadra.

For screened coal per ton, from the first of September to

the first of March, 1.02

Lact ibeeaitcniaieablaaleahtahdion

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 855

From the first of March to the 31st of August, 92

For all coal under three feet in height, for each three inches

less of coal, shall be 5 cents per ton additional to above prices.

The price for narrow work shall be as follows:

20 feet gob entries or air courses per yard, $1.06

20 feet gob entries or air courses per yard, 1.18

16 feet gob entries or air courses per yard, 1.42

12 feet gob entries or air courses per yard, 1.65

8 feet entries or air courses per yard, 1.89

Paris.

For mining hand-picked or forked coal free from slate,

1302 slack and other impurities, $1.05 per ton shall be paid.

Where draw slate or rock comes with coal the following

prices shall be adopted:

For all over one inch and under five inches, five cents per

ton extra; over five inches and less than ten inches, 9 cents

per ton extra; over ten inches and less than fifteen inches, 14

cents per ton extra; over fifteen inches and less than twenty

inches, 19 cents per ton extra.

The price to be paid for screened coal at McCurtain to be

determined by test.

The brushing price at Bonanza, Jenny Lind, All brushing

16 inches, per yard, $1.06.

and over 16 inches 7 cents for each inch extra.

The company shall have the right to do all brushing by shift

work at $2.42 per day when desired.

All cross-cuts in rooms shall be, per yard, 1.06

All room turning shall be, per yard, 1.06

Russellville.

Ten cents per ton less than the price paid at Ouita.

Entry, Yardage, Ete.

Entry, yardage and deficient work will be reduced 5.55 per

cent. The same rules and customs defining deficient work in

District 21 shall be in force during the life of this agreement.

55—5154

856 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

Coal Hill and Denning shall be $1.32 for eighteen inches of

brushing. Where the company requires more than eighteen

inches to be brushed, they agree to pay eight cents per inch for

each additional inch over the eighteen inches.

Draw slate in air courses will be paid as follows:

For three inches or over, 24 cents.

1303 For six inches or over, 47 cents.

For nine inches or over, 71 cents.

For twelve inches or over, 94 cents per yard.

All coal in Arkansas two feet ten inches and less in height

shall be considered deficient work, except where special price

has been made.

Scale of prices to be paid for draw slate and rock at Bache

& Denman’s mines at Burma and Montreal No. 2:

Over four inches and up to eight inches, 53 cents per yard.

Over eight inches and up to 12 inches, 79 cents per yard.

Over twelve inches, to be settled locally. Brushing entries to

be $1.33 per yerd.

Where bottom 1s taken up in rooms and room necks it shall

be paid 53 cents per yard. This applies to Bache & Denman’s

mines at Burma only. —

All break-throughs in Arkansas, when required to cut

through, to be paid at the present rate, less 5.55 per cent.

Pick Mining at McCurtain.

Mine No. 2: Company to pay Arkansas mine run price un-

til installs standard Arkansas screen, when there may be a

test run, to determine proportion of lump as compared to av-

erage Arkansas coal. Test shall be run the first twenty-one

days after Company goes on lump coal basis, [nunder] condi-

tions prescribed by the Commissioner representing the op-

erators and the President of District 21, representing the min-

ers. These two, if unable to agree on result, may call in a

third party, the decision of any two to be final. The company,

after such test, remain on lump basis at the rate so agreed

upon. While running on mine run basis any miner persisting

in making an unreasonable amount of slack under con-

1304 ditions prevailing at Mine No. 2, after being cautioned

by pit boss, may be discharged.

Mine No. 3: Scale of District 2, with waiver of right to

lump coal basis, unti] development shall have sufficiently pro-

Sd ab Bite eraty

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 857

gressed to show characteristics of coal to be equal to average

Arkansas Coal. This determination to be made by Com-

missioner representing operators and President of District 21,

representing miners, and to be settled by calling in third par-

ty in event of disagreement.

Company may work on yardage basis during development.

The prices for yardage at mine No. 2 and mine No. 3, shall

be as follows: '

Entries, per yard, $2.13

[Aair] courses, per yard, 2.13

Crossecuts, per yard, 1.59

Room turning, 3.19

The Pittsburg Agreement shall cover all entry room turn-

ing and deficient work at Russellville, and the company shall

pay 85 cents per yard for first cut in rooms for actual meas-

urement.

McCurtain Punching Machine Seale.

Cutting in rooms and [rokm] break-throughs shall be 12-4

cents per ton mine run to be divided three-fifths to cutter and

two-fifths to helper.

Cutting in entries and all other narrow work except room

break-throughs shall be sixteen and one-half cents, divided

three-fifths and two-fifths as above. No yardage.

Loaders in rooms (including room break-throughs) shall re-

ceive forty cents per ton mine run; loaders to furnish powder

and do all work ordinarily done by pick miners in rooms, ex-

cept cutting.

1305 Loaders in entries and all other narrow work (except

room break-throughs) shall receive forty-five cents per

ton. No yardage. Loaders to furnish powder and do all

work ordinarily done by pick miners in entry work, except

cutting.

Seale of District No. 3.

Texas.

Section 1. That the price for mining coal on the screened

coal basis be as follows:

. For Thurber, from the 1st of September, 1904, to the 31st

of January, 1905, $1.15 per ton of 2000 pounds. From Febru-

ary 1 to August 31, 1905, $1.17-%% per ton.

For Rock Creek, from September 1, 1904, to January 31,

1905, $1.17-14 per ton; from February 1, to August 31, 1905,

$1.20 per ton.

SECTS Nag RETR che 1 RESALE LS Le ler ee PARASITE

858 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

Strawn, from September 1, 1904, to August 31, 1905, $1.25

per ton.

Bridgeport, from September 1, 1904, to August 31, 1905,

$1.40 per ton.

Prices to continue on same rates until end of contract period,

Screens.

The screens to be six feet wide, fourteen feet long, diamond

shape bars with one inch space; grooved rests to be placed not

more than two feet apart. This is to apply to Thurber,

Strawn and Rock Creek. Bridgeport screens to remain as

heretofore.

Entry Driving and Brushing.

Section 2. For Thurber, Strawn and Rock Creek, [heighth|]

to be four and one-half (4-%%) feet above the rail; for Bridge-

port four (4) feet above the rail; for Thurber and

1306 Strawn, the width between walls to be eight (8) feet.

Brushing six feet (6) wide at the top. Tock Creek, as

required at the discretion of the management, but in no case

shall it be higher or wider than the above. At Bridgeport the

width between walls to be six (6) feet, brushing to be four and

one-half (4-14) feet wide at the top.

The price to be $1.22 per yard.

1. The price on back brushing shall be 97 cents per yard

at Thurber, Strawn and Rock Creek, and $1.12 per yard at

Bridgeport., Brushing to be taken so that six and one-half (6-

Y%) feet shall be above the rail, and four and one-half (4-14)

feet wide at the top, in Thurber, Strawn and Rock Creek. At

Bridgeport brushing to be taken six (6) feet above the rail

and three and one-half (3-14) feet wide at the top.

2. The brushing in rooms at Thurber, Strawn and Rock

Creek shall be four and one-half (4-14) feet above the rail;

at Bridgeport, four (4) feet above the rail. This height to

apply nine feet from the face of coal.

3. For straights, the price shall be 24¢ per yard at Thur-

ber, Strawn and Rock Creek. Bridgeport to be exempt.

4. The switch room to be the fourth within the face of

entry.

5. Room turning as follows: Cribs, 73¢ each; brushing

to be the same width, height and price as entry work.

6. All rails, ties, timber and other material to be delivered

by the company at the switch room of each place.

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL, 859

7. All dead and deficient work to be left for local settle-

ment. '

Inside Day Wage Scale.

Section 3 Per day.

1307 Track layers, $2.33

Timber men, 2.33

Ventilators, 2.33

And miners when taken from face, 2.33

Drivers, 2.19

Cagers, 2.19

Motormen, 2.28

[ Watern] bailers, 2.19

Trappers, 1,02

Greasers and spraggers, maximum, 1,

@reasers and spraggers, minimum, 1.

Pushers, Maximum, 2.

Pushers, minimum, 1.94

Sinkers, 2.43

Shift leaders, 2.67

Mule feeders, per month $43.75 to $48.61.

Outside Day Wage Scale.

Section 4,

Blacksmiths, Thurber, Rock Creek and Strawn, 2.55

[Hlacksmith] helpers, Thurber, Rock Creek and

Strawn, 1.85

Blacksmiths at Bridgeport 2.19

Firemen, 1.94

Dumpers, 1.75

Car trimmers, 1.75

Slate men, 1.85

1308 Slate pickers, $1.22 to $1.46

Engineers, first class, $68.06

Engineers, second class, 63.20

Engineers, third class, 58.34

_For engineers, a (qorking] month to consist of twenty-

six (26) working days of nine (9) hours per day, and all

time worked in excess of this to be considered over-time and

paid for proportionately.

Machine Mining Seale.

The price for loading after machine shall be 65¢ per ton,

where company does the room brushing and 77¢ per ton

Where loader does room brushing, the loader to take care of

his place, to do his own timbering, ete., in the same man-

ner as a pick miner, to keep the face clear from the machine,

860 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

and leave not less than three feet space between the face

and the props otherwise necessary.

Machine runner, per day, $2.58

Machine helper, 2.19

Powder.

Section 6. The price of powder shall be $2.00 per keg of

25 pounds.

Pay Days.

Section 7. The pay days to be on the first and third Sat-

urdays in each month, The full statement to be issued to

employes on the third Saturday only, which shall cover all

operations up to the first of each current month. On the

first Saturday, employes shall be required to give a receipt

for pay received,

Section 8. Any miner or mine laborer desiring to leave

the service of the company shall give notice to the

1309 superintendent or general manager and shall receive

his money in full not later than five (5) days from the

date of such notice.

Strawn.

Agreement arrived at October 19, 1903, between the op-

erators of Strawn and the U. M. W. of A. in reference to

the development of new mines.

For developing a new mine, when worked by the day, the

price shall be $2.67 per day, company to furnish powder and

tools.

Entries, when driven by yard, 8 feet wide, $2.43 per yard.

Entries, when driven by yard, 10 feet wide, $2.67 per yard.

[Entties,] when driven by yard, 16 to 18 feet wide, $1.94

per yard, and miners to get coal.

Dimensions of brushing to be same in regard to height

and width as specified in contract.

When three shifts are worked by day work, it is under-

stood that the men shall not be docked for any reasonable

time taken to eat dinner, but it shall be so arranged that the

men shall eat alternately so as not to stop operations unless

by request of the men, they stop all operations for a half

hour for the purpose of eating, then one-half hour shall be

docked from their wages.

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL, 861

The price of mining coal at the mines of the Mount Ma-

rion Coal Mining Company, Strawn, shall be $1.25 per ton

until March 31st, 1906, inclusive.

The question of prices for mining coal at the Mt. Marion

Coal Mining Company’s mine at Strawn, shall be taken up

and adjusted by the Operators’ Commissioner and the Pres-

ident of District 21 whenever it becomes necessary,

General ‘Conditions.

1310 There shall be two pay days a month and the opera-

tors shall issue to each employe a statement of his ac-

count, which the employe may retain, The dates of pay days

shall be arranged between the respective companies and

their employees.

Where air courses are [diven] in chute or platform work,

that is, where the coal isin a greater pitch than twenty de-

grees shall be considered as air courses, and it shall be paid

for at the regular district price, provided such air course or

breakthrough is cut or sheared before being shot.

The company shall put in all batteries, wing boards and

platforms in all chute work in District No. 21.

The miners shall load their own coal in pitching veins in

this district at the regular scale price.

No person employed under ground shall use an inferior

grade of lard oil, and the use of any other except lard oil is

prohibited. Rope riders in mine slopes are excepted,

The taking up of bottom for stub switches for

chute rooms will be done by the miner, and pay-

ment for same is referred to Local Union and mine of-

ficials for adjustment. In the event of their failure to

agree, general resolutions to govern.

Where coal is screened before being weighed it shall be

dumped on flat sheets and passed over the sereen specified

in the Pittsburg Agreement, and there shall be no obstruc-

tion on said screen,

When an employe leaves the employment of a company he

shall receive all money due him within three days from the

date of notice. Settlements must be asked for between the

hours of 8 a, m. and 6 p. m., on day settlement is due.

All company men shall receive an equal share of all

1311 work when competent to do such work.

The gas men shall place marks at last inside break-

through, showing clearly whether there is any standing gas

862

in working place. Should there be standing gas, he shall

— gas mark at toom neck in addition to mark at inside

reak-through; but should working place be clear, he shall

oye marks so indicating this at coal face. No miner shall

e permitted to brush out gas.

Miners shall have the right to send out their dull tools on

top of loaded cars, and the company shall deliver same to

blacksmith shop for sharpening, and no man be allowed to

carry tools up or down shaft. In slopes the company shall

deliver the same to parting at bottom. The company shall

not be responsible for tools.

And under-ground employe not on hand to go down to work

at the hour for commencing work, shall not be entitled to go

below except at the convenience of the company.

When an employe is sick or injured he shall be given a

cage at once. When a cage load of men come to the bot-

tom of the shaft who have been prevented from working by

reason of falls or other things over which they have no con-

trol, they shall be given a cage at once. For the accommoda-

tion of individual employes less than a cage load who have

been prevented from working as above, cage will be run

mid-forenoon, noon and mid-afternoon of each working day.

Provided, however, that the foregoing shall not be permit-

ted to enable men to leave their work for other than the

reasons stated above.

The sinking of slopes and driving narrow work through

faults shall be left to Local Union and .mine management

for adjustment. All double-shift places to be paid

1312 twenty-six cents per yard extra.

All wet entries, rooms, slopes, slope air courses and

all other work connected with the slopes shall be left to Lo-

cal Union and superintendent or manager for agreement of

price.

Frozen or seamy coal, struck top or bottom, shall be de-

ficient work, and shall be paid for extra, the same to be de-

termined by mine committee and pit boss. If they fail to

agree the miner shall be given an average place in the mine.

There shall be no deduction for school purposes except

authorized by the individuals.

For the health and safety of the miners’ lives, air courses

shall be kept up with the entries as near as possible, and

cross cuts shall be driven every forty feet; where gas ex-

UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 863

ists they shall be driven every thirty feet. No room shall

be turned inside the last cross cut.

Scale price for blacksmithing miners’ tools and machine

mine tools:

Three-fourths of one per cent on gross earnings for black-

smithing of miners’ tools, and three-eighths of one per cent

on gross earnings for machine coal loaders’ tools.

All sharpening and repairs of tools shall be done as

promptly as possible.

The District President of the United Mine Workers of

America, the Commissioner of the Southwestern Interstate

Operators’ Association and the State Mine Inspector shall

be a committee of three to determine at what places shot-

firers shall be employed in Arkansas.

The present conditions in regard to double and single

work shall prevail.

1313 Any employe absenting himself from work two days

and not reporting for work on the morning of the

third day, shall forfeit his right to his working place, unless

excused by mine foreman, but shall be given another place

on turn; provided, however, this shall not apply in case of

sickness.

Where a fall oceurs in any working place, the company

shall make preparations to clean up same within four hours

from time of notice; failing to do so the miner or miners

affected shall clean up same, company paying at the rate of

$2.42 per shift.

Price for moving all draw slate and rock exceeding two

inches in. thickness, two and one-half cents per inch per

running yard for each five feet in width, and all over and

above to be paid accordingly. This applies to all mines ex-

cept where there is a special contract.

Where rooms are driven up narrow on account of bad top,

the yardage shall be same as that in air course, measure.

ments to be made from the entry; and when room is widened

out one-half room turning shall be paid. Where bottom is

taken up entry yardage shall be paid. This does not apply

in rooms that have been widened out, then narrowed up and

re-necked, but in these cases the prices now in effect shall

prevail, less 5.55 per cent.

When a car leaves working place it is in charge of the

company and average weight shall be paid for broken cars,

864 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

Such cars shall be reported by the man that dumps the coal.

The company shall keep all cars in good repair.

All coal four feet and over where it comes down to under

a thickness of three feet four inches, shall be declared de-

ficient work. This applies te Arkansas and the In-

1314 dian Territory

Where cars are delivered at working face all timber

and rails shall be delivered there.

Where powder is taken into the mine in kegs it shall be

delivered to the working place; otherwise it shall be handled

according to the methods in vogue at the various mines.

Where miners at Coal Hill, No. 18 Jenny Lind, and Den-

ning, Arkansas, have been pushing cars both ways, the com-

pany shall assist the miner one way when necessary; and

all miners in the Indian Territory who have been pushing

their cars both ways, nall receive for all coal pushed over

200 feet, five cents ton extra. The conditions that prevail at

Lehigh apply to all mines on the Atoka Track in regard to

lowering cars down to the switch.

All questions that have been left to the President of the

United Mine Workers of America, District 21, and Com-

missioner of the Southwestern Interstate Coal Operators’

Association, or to arbitration, shall become a part f this

contract and be binding upon both parties when tle same

have both been decided and agreed upon by the said Presi-

dent and Commissioner, or by arbitration: and the opera-

tors shall furnish the District Secretary of the U. M. W. of

4., and also post at the mines the prices to be paid on and

after September 1, 1904, based hereon.

Color shall be no bar to employment.

Powder.

The price of powder shall be $2 per keg during the term

of this contract.

In behalf of the Southwestern Interstate Coal Operators’

Association.

B. F. BUSH, President.

1315 S. W. KNIFFEN,

Sectrary.

PETE HANRATY,

FRANK J. McGUIRE,

T. H. LEPPS,

; JOHN MORGAN,

B, F. CLEVENGER.

In behalf of the miners;

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 865

Appendix.

The President of District 21 and the commissioner of the

Southwestern Interstate Coal Operators’ Association, having

under consideration the question of payment for double shift-

ing places, agreee that whenever the company requires a dou-

ble shift to be worked in one place, it shall be paid at the rate

of 26¢ per yard extra.

The wage for all pump men under ground is $2.56 per eight

hour day. For pump men above ground, $2.02-14, except men

receiving $2.00 or over per day for eight hours last year, the

advance will be 12-14 per cent.

It is agreed between the representatives of the Miners and

the representatives of the Operators, on making of the scale,

that wherever a reduction applied on work is less than one-

half of le, the present price remain unchanged.

Special provision applicable to Texas alone.

Check-offs.

Section 6. The operators will recognize the pit committee

in the discharge of their duties, as provided in this agree-

ment, and agree to check off dues, assessments, fines and

initiations from all miners and mine laborers when desired.

In order to protect the companies, the United Mine

1316 Workers of America agree, when the companies so de-

mand, to furnish _a collective and continuous order

authorizing the companies to make such deductions. The

companies agree to furnish the miners’ local representatives

a monthly statement showing separately the amount of dues,

assessments, fines and initiations collected. In case any fine

is imposed the propriety of which is questioned, the amount

of such fine shall be withheld by the operator until the case

has been taken up for adjustment and a decision rendered.

It is agreed that the miners may employ a check weighman

to see that coal is properly weighed and a correct record

made thereof; and when such check weighman is employed

the companies shall furnish him a check number, and he shall

credit to his [mumbe] such portion of each miner’s coal as he

may be authorized to do by the local union. It is also under-

stood that the local union may have a number in order to

collect dues, assessments, fines and initiations from the miners

and mine laborers, and the local union shall notify the com-

pany by giving the names in writing of the person or persons

866 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

~ agua to collect such union money from the company

office.

The dues and assessments to be deducted on the first work-

ing day of each month or on the first day that employes com-

menced work.’’

1317 Q. Mr. Covington: These exhibits I am now offering,

we can consider as read in evidence, in order to shorten

the time greatly.

The Court: Yes, proceed, we will consider it as read.

Q. When did the miners and operators next meet?

A. 1906, I think.

Q. Were you in that conference? A. I think so.

Q. Where was it held? A. Pittsburg, Arkansas City.

. How were [theye]conventions composed—I mean by

that, how was the membership of the convention made up on

both sides, operators and miners?

A. The representatives of the various coal companies who

were members of the operators association represented the

operators, and the miners were represented by their officers

and delegates, I think, I am not positive of it; delegates from

the various locals.

Q. Were you in the 1904 convention as representative of

@ some of the plaintiffs?

= <A. Yes, and also in 1913 and ’04, both, I think I chiefly

represent other mines that are not plaintiff, that belonged

tc the Midland Valley Railroad.

Q. In 1906 did you represent the plaintiffs, in the 1906 con-

ference? <A. All the plaintiffs that were operated at that

time I did.

Q. Do you recall the names of the particular plaintiffs that

were operating at that time?

A. The Mammoth Vein. Coal Company,—I would be sure

of, and I think the Denman Company. I won’t be certain as

to what other ones, because I don’t remember which ones

were started by that time.

1318 Q. At the time of making the 1904-1906 contract,

were you then conversant with the competitive con-

ditions that you related here in your direct examination last

Friday and Saturday?

A. In a general way I was, but not to the same extent

that I afterwards became, of course.

Q. Did you have any more information in regard to that

particular matter than you had in 1903?

A. In 1904, you mean?

Q. No, in 1904 and 1906.

CORONADO COAL COMPANY, ET AL. 867

A. Yes, sir, I have no doubt that my information in-

creased from year to year.

Q. To what extent?

A. Oh, I cannot say. The more coal we sold and the

more coal we mined, the more we learned about the competi-

tion.

Mr. Covington: I would like to ask that this paper be

marked as an Exhibit.

(Paper was marked by the stenographer as Exhibit 9.)

Q. I hand you defendants Exhibit 9, and will ask you

what it is.

A. Joint interstate agreement contract for District 21

of operators and miners, adopted at Kansas City, Missouri,

June 16, 1906, for period ending March 31, 1908; South

west Interstate Coal Operators Association and United

Mine Workers District 21.

(. Were you in the conference that concurred in the

adoption of that contract, were you, as a representative of

the companies you have named? A. I think so.

Mr. Covington: I wish to offer in evidence Exhibit 9.

The Court: It will be received.

(Exhibit 9 so offered in evidence is in words and figures

following, to-wit:)

1319 Defendants’ Exhibit No. 9.

Joint Interstate Agreement of Operators and Miners

Adopted at Kansas City? Mo.? June 16, 1906

for the Period Closing March 31, 1908.

General Cenditions.

Section 1. All classes of day labor are to work full eigh

[house], and the going to and coming from the respectiv

working places is to be done on the day hand’s own time

All company men shall perform whatever day labor th

foreman may direct. An eight-hour means eight hours

work in the mines at the usual working places, exclusive o

noon time—which shall be one-half hour—for all classes o

inside day labor. This shall be exclusive of the time requir

ed in reaching such working places in the morning and de

parting from the same at night.

Drivers shall take their mules to and from the stables an

the time required in so doing shall not include any part o

the day’s labor; their time beginning when they reach th

868 UNITED MINE WORKERS OF AMERICA, ET AL., VS.

change at which they receive empty cars—that is, the part-

ing drivers at the shaft botto

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.