Appellants Brief — Newton v. Kings County Lighting Co.
Supreme Court brief1922
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
FILBD
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term—1921
' Calendar No. 295
Cuartes D. Newron, as Attorney General of the State
of New York, Atrrep M. Barrett, constituting the
Public Service Commission of the State of New York
for the First District and Harry E. Lewis, as Dis-
trict Attorney of the County of Kings,
Appellants,
against
Kines County Licuting Company,
Appellee.
| BRIEF ON BEHALF OF APPELLANT HARRY
E. LEWIS AS DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF
THE COUNTY OF KINGS.
JOHN P. O'BRIEN, .
Corporation Counsel,
Solicitor for Appellant, Harry E. Lewis,
District Attorney of the County of
Kings,
Municipal Building,
New York.
James A. DonneELLy,
Harry Herrzorr,
of Counsel.
Terry a on
alll all
(18684) Ingle, Inc., 165 William Street, New York.
- iy rt ee, al f ca ok we 1h Vora
eo a
Subject Index.
Pe Stee hese heh whe wba ek Oh AK ew hb ed oko Re 1
Suit instituted by appellee to declare void Chap.
125, Laws 1906, as amended 1916.............. 1
Laws upheld in 212 U. S., 19. Report of Special
Master; confirmed by Judge Hough. Case ad-
vanced, Reference to Consolidated Gas Com-
pany case. Different facts presented.......... 2
I, Judgment should be reversed by reason of judg-
ment entered in State Court .................. 3
History of case in State Court; case dismissed; ap-
peal taken; unclean hands; no subsequent at-
tempt to comply with law..................... 4
Il. No experiment with statute by appellee ....... 5
Statute not complied with; extract from opinion of
EMRE NR URN Ea Na Wh so vk Ak 6400cdeus oni 5)
Conditions imposed by Justice Greenbaum not com-
plied with; Judge Hough had no authority to re-
verse decree of State Court. This Court should
require experimentation with the statutory rate.
EP 14
Reduced rates increase earnings; argument of ap-
pellee anticipated and answered............... 15
No evidence to prove probable results: Lincoln Gas
case (200 U.S.) upholds argument of appellant
IRC OE TES Sai eee ee 16
Suit fails because no practical test of rate......... 19
SEER ein eR TIER CONT ORE eS WY HT. oe
PAGE
III. Statute persistently violated by failure to
furnish quality of gas prescribed .............. 20
Duty imposed to comply with Act; Judge Hands
opinion (267 Fed. Rep., 245) distinguishes this
case from Consolidated Gas case...........00,. 20
Appellee furnished counterfeit gas; it continued to
knowingly violate statute. Quality of gas fur-
nished is necessary factor in determining rate;
proof of poor quality, New uses for gas of re-
Nien GHROS San schaccen eee eee ee eeeeee ?}
Charge equivalent to rate of over $1.38 per M feet.
Might ounces net a pound and 15 candlepower
gas is not a statutory umit. Legislature and
CNS GE Ackndas cee sceseh ckenincicaee cue 3
No resemblance of facts in instant ense and Con-
solidated Gas case. Service and rates interde-
pendent ; ies SE ee A ee so 24
Appellee able to comply with statute; could have |
obtained permission to legally depart from can-
dle power standard; Master's findings of heat-
ing value erroneous, Tleating value gas not more
uniform in quality than candle power gas...... 26
Wisdom of statute solely in provinee of legislature;
not attacked by appellee; not complied with; at-
tempt to comply by other companies in vicinity;
not impossible to comply; reason why prosecu-
tion of appellee futile; this Court ean rebuke de-
Rant attitude of BpMelOO . ciikcc 6c lkas cineeess 27
Ol ie ea
Naw
NS FRSA RS REE ER eS
ie oat
IV. Unreasonable amount of ON TOE och xvniccees: :
Appellee loses one-fifth of gas made: No attempt
to improve despite judicial attack on incompe-
teney. Loss should be eliminated and not con-
doned by higher rates.
management
price; ruling in State Court
Finding of Court be-
low not based on competent evidence; slipshod
should not justify increase in
dia ew oe ee ee ee ee
Effects of high gas leakage serious: appellee dis-
plays unreasonable management: Court below
differed from Master and did not rely upon testi-
mony. Lost gas cost $
Consolidated
ance not ascertainable
Gas
332,25
4 in vear 1919. In
‘ase 4.1 per cent. allowed.
Instant case, Master 11 per cent., Court 15 per
cent. Not justified: basis for Court’s allow-
Reasons for some of avoidable loss; explanations
of witness do not explain; consumers subject
to indirect taxation; conclusions of witnesses not
POU cannwushecvsne cane tieane
supported by f
Miller’s explanation impeaches his own testimony ;
comparison with other companies; fair allow-
ance not to exceed eight per cent...... reer
V. Lack of proof disclosed and gross inefficiency
shown ........
i ee ee ee oe ee we ie
No proof of efficiency, economy or prudence in man-
agement. The main question before the Court.
Plant poorly designed: deplorable results due to
fatuous neglect: appellee has
towards public
eee
«
«
1 responsibility
SSS 2ene ee uenuwas
29
31
33
34
Fee AEDES 81k BRA REI IND Eo oO eS a
iv
PAGE
Purported cost to produce gas; discrepancies in
books; comparison of cost, alternative generator
PAGE s 060 Hi PTIOON PENG, .. nc cceacssessrsss B
Allowance for expense of boiler fuel too high; prae-
tice of appellee condemmed,................... 36
Shortage of tar residual not explained. No credits
oS ere PaPUC EAS ECCRR ANA OH RASS A) OE
No rentals shown for leased property; exeess oi]
used for poor quality gas made; appellee could
have saved $75,903.12 on oil; records of oil used
not conclusive ...... PPT OPE ee OT Ee EERE ETT 38
Appellee’s witness not familiar with the records or
methods used; system of recording cost of labor
is incorrect; no check on materials used. ....... 39
Books not kept according to uniform classification ;
accuracy of charges in doubt; some charges
proved erroneous; no record of renewals pro-
WS an ees ones (iveeavanae eer yay 41
Plant obsolete; expensive operations; greater con-
sumption recorded of poor quality gas......... 42
Refused new consumers; negligence not to be at
expense of consumers; further proof of negli-
gence; current costs reflect) deferred mainte-
Ae ee ee PP COE Cr TTT EET ee TET 43
Testimony of appellee's witness Klumpp shows
plant dirty and inefficient; plant not of balanced
design; mains too small; uses too much boiler
fuel; management requires condemnation...... 45
Finding not supported by evidence; results of op-
eration prove contentions of appellants; plant
inadequate; appellee responsible for high costs;
reasons for assuming huge profits made in past
a 5 Ree Oe re Sper eet Pe eee eee Se
Miller’s testimony is self-contradictory.......... 48
No reward should be bestowed upon negligence... 90
NN ON A iy OLN DI ET ORR RI DT iT BRC ONT ER: ee |
z
VI. Undue haste evident in trial of case [otcantene ie
The record is incomplete ............... dees 51
Extracts from testimony showing appellants did
not have sufficient time to prepare; record is in-
cites ana et ae CU TRE I ee 60
VII. Period too brief for fair test .........._.. i. @&
Year and a half covers abnorma] prices; testimony
as to other periods declined by Master; period
covered January, 1919-—June er 61
Remarkable decline in labor and commodity prices;
rights of consumers to be considered; peak of
high prices passed.................. eevensces fe
Cost of gas in past years: no loss to complainant
because of inventory adjustments; earnings of
past should be considered, average return should
be controlling feature........................ 64
VIII. Statute presumed to be constitutional ....._.. 65
Kates must be plainly unreasonable............. 65
Burden on complainant; must. be sustained by
overwhelming evidence; courts will not act ex-
cept in clearest cases .............. itsseense @&
IX. Books erroneously admitted in evidence ...... 67
Master believed he was bound by decision in recent
Consolidated Gas Co. case: books not kept ae-
cording to uniform classification: transcripts of
other books; opinions of experts not conclusive. 67
Accountant not competent to pass upon engineer-
ing questions ............ See eT eT eee - 68
X. Rate of return .............. Neveawen se dks — |
Eight per cent. not a proper rate; no fixed rule;
utility risks not as great as in average business. 69
ID Fg te Rue er ae a .
vi
PAGE
Courts surely will not rule that utility built partly
out of excess earnings is entitled to high rate of
return; rate varies with risk,................. 70
Gas business sate and stable; monopolistie feat-
ures: cirelumstinees in instant case eall for low
SO Ae GPRM on co waa oa bina a owas ahaa aes id
Table of Cases and Statutes Cited.
Arkansas Rate Cases. In re 187 Fed., 290.......... 1?
Atkinson Ry. Co. v. United States, 253 ULS., 199... 66
Bonbright v. Geary, 210 Ped, 44. ... 6.05 cece cess 1?
Cedar Rapids Gas L. Co. v. City of Cedar Rapids,
Se ic es CER Gt URL Gke SEER GAN Beek kaos 13-15
Carmen v. Fox Film Corp., 269 Fed., 928. .......... 20
Consolidated Gas Co. v. Newton, 267 Fed., 248.
20-92-39-61-67
City of Louisville v. Cumberland Telephone & Tele
graph Co. 225 U. ig SOPs Kalvos Sane be daw a xnee 1]
Chicago, ete. Railway Co. v. Wellman, 148 U.S... 544.13
Commonwealth v. Interstate Pag ouretin tained
(‘o., IST Mass., 436-207 U. Eis avn el tre w aceta aoc l+
Central Hlinois P vee Service Co., P. U. & R.. 1918,
OE BAe gang el nai A Degen UNO A eee Bo Peete 2
Oe, We Baers areal hc es ee aru Ncer ev Cw et es 4
Darnell v. Edwards, 244 U. ae Nae a Sar 10
Des Moines Gas Co. v. Sas Moines, 238 U. S.,
ere ae ka te van ce bea a eeate saa aie cies 10-66
Detroit United Ry. Co. v. Detroit, 248 U. S., 442.2... 66
Fletcher v. Peck, 6 Cranch (star page), 128....... 6
Kings Co, L. Co. v. Lewis, 110 Mise., 204...........
3, 5, 19, 21, 28, 38
Knoxville Water Co. v. Knoxville, 212 U. S., 15.
9, 10, 11, 15, 18, 19, 60
CAMA EI a ee eit
Vii
PAGE
Lincoln Gas & Electrie Co, vy. City of Lincoln, 223
spiheg pager OO ea 13, 66
Lincoln Gas & Eleetrie Co. vy. City of Lincoln, 250
eR GEY SrA Sey wy edu he ete. GP 16
Louisiana R. R. Com. y. Cumberland Tel, Co., 212
ches Mipouy idan errr ee ee On ale 6
Missouri (. BL & Q. Ry. Co., 241 U. 8 me Sa ieee 15
Minnesota Rate Cases, 220 the ORs ca ean 66
Montana W. & S. R. Co. y. Morley, 198 Fed. Rep.,
YO] ee ent aN R RMAC WS We icae cn 4 ox a ae
Municipal Gas Co. v. Public Service Commission, 225
(oll neigh ee ee 14,19
New York Statutes, Chapter 125 of Laws of 1906. .1, 2,7
Chapter 604 of Laws of span EEE OTe Terenas as
Northern Pae. Rv. Co. vy. Nor, Dakota, 236 ite Us
Pr EStreeN es Ciena e arte eee tems 1,15
Palatka Waterworks Co, y. Palatka, 127 Fed. Rep.,
get hap eee g PIECE Yate get ee 66
Penn. R. R. Co. vy. Towers, 245 SBE Se a np 12
Public Serviee Commission Law, See. i PRE ag 70
Railroad Comm'rs. of Louisiana y. Cumberland T.
& T. Co., 212 U. isos Corea TALE Ore a 66
Re-Central Illinois Public Service Com. PLU. R. 1918
<20 a ARPA Rs Fe OR aes ais ADE 17
San Diego L. & T. Co. y. National City, 174 U.S.,
San Diego L. & T. Co. v. Jasper, 189 UL S.. 439. rk ae
Shepard v. Northern Pac. R. Co., 184 Fed. Rep.,
gg SL I ee a ay a a een 66
Sinking Fund Cases, 99 LE Sale anne teen Oe 66
Van Dyck y. Geary, 218 Fed. 111 ; aff. 244 UL S., 49. 11,15
Willeox vy, Cons. Gas Co., 212 U. 8.,.19............
2, 7, 8, 10, 15, 18, 19, 27, 65
Wisconsin R. R. ssi cunensinsn ing CE Lee OR 25
| Young, Jn ok ae ars RRM NTN Seer oe 9, 66
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term—1921
Calendar No. 295
CuarLes D. Newrox, as Attorney General of the State
of New York, ALrrep M. Barrerr, constituting the
Public Service Commission of the State of New York
for the First District and Harry E. Lewis, as Dis-
trict Attorney of the County of Kings,
Appellants,
against
Kixcs County Ligutrxc Company, Appellee.
BRIEF ON BEHALF OF APPELLANT, HARRY
E. LEWIS, AS DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF
THE COUNTY OF KINGS.
Appeal from the Southern District of New York.
Statement.
This is a suit in equity instituted by the above-named
appellee against the appellants herein to have declared
wicoustitutional and void, as to it, Chapter 125 of the
Laws of 1906, as amended by Chapter 604 of the Laws of
1916, upon the ground that the statute is in contravention
of Section 10, Article I of the Constitution of the United
States and the Fourteenth Amendment thereof.
rane NTI NG DE BEI NE ELA LE ERA REY ere mek ot oo nD RAL a
The econstitutionality of Chapter 125 of the Laws of
1906 was upheld by this Court, in Willeor vo Consoli-
dated Gas Company of New York, 212 U.S. 19. The
issues in this case were referred to Gorpoxn AUCHINCLoss,
Esq., as Special Master, whose report was confirmed oy
October 15, 120, by Hon, Cartes M. Houcu, sitting ag
a District Judge.
Appellant's appeal was taken and a motion was made
to advance the argument of the same. This Court ad.
vanced the case for hearing at the October, 1921, Term,
Many of the questions have been thoroughly treated
in the brief filed by us in the Consolidated Gas Company
case, and what we have said with reference to the ques.
tions of burden of proof, abnormal period, earnings of
prior vears, admissibility of the books of aceount jn
evidence and the schedules drawn therefrom, applies
also to this case and we will not attempt to again cover
those points herein, It will be necessary, however, to
add something to what we have said, by reason of dif.
ferent facts which are presented by this case.
POINT I.
The judgment should be reversed and the com-
plaint dismissed by reason of the judgment entered
in the State Court.
The complainant herein commenced an action in the
Supreme Court of the State of New York on July 1,
1916, the date when Chapter 604 of the Laws of 1916
took effect, and sought the same relief and judgment
which it now seeks in this action. The defendants were
the same except that The City of New York was made
a party defendant in the said action, and the District
Attorney was not ineluded as one of the defendants. The
case Was tried before Mr. Justice GREENBAUM and a
judgment was entered on March 29, 1920, dismissing the
complaint (110 Mise., 204). The plaintiff has appealed
from this judgment and the appeal is now pending. The
findings, amonest others, were as follows:
“The substantial observance of the require-
ments of the statute as to candlepower should
have been shown by the plaintiff, and its failure
to do so does not entitle it to favorable considera-
tion of a court of equity.”
The State Court had similar jurisdiction to this Court
over the parties and subject-matter in litigation.
He SN cos
4
The complainant admits that it has made no attempt
to comply with the Law since January 1, 1918, in spite
of the decisién of the Court condemning its practice. In-
stead of mending its ways, as pointed out in that judg.
ment, it commeneed a second action in this Court,
This record is full of instances showing that no effort
has been made to remedy any of the conditions that were
condemned in the prior suit.
It is a well-settled rule that a question which was
raised in a prior suit and passed upon conclusively
settles the question and is not the subject of litigation
in a subsequent action in the same Court or in any other
Court upon the same or a different cause of action (23
Cye, p. 1216).
POINT II.
The complainant has never experimented with
the statute fixing the rate, for 22 candlepower gas,
at 80 cents per thousand cubic feet.
The decision of Justice Greenpavnm (110 Mise., 204)
inthe Supreme Court of the State of New York in which
the complainant in the case at bar was plaintiff, shows
(at p. 248) first, that during the year 1918
“plaintiff continuously furnished gas of a candle-
power below the legal standard of 22 candles and
varying from @ maximum mouthly average of
16.94 candles to a minimum average of 11.18
candles, There was not a single day during the
year 1918 when the plaintiff? furnished gas up to
the standard prescribed by law. There were
many occasions when the gas was found to be
below ten candles.”
The Special Master in the case at bar has found that
for this kind of gas complainant received 95 cents per
thousand cubie feet.
Secondly, Justice Greenpaum required experimenta-
tion with the rate as a condition to re-opening the ease
for the purpose of showing that the statute was con-
fiscatory (see page 250). The complainant could not
make any experimentation with the statutory rate for
the years that the Court had under consideration at the
trial, but only for years of the future, which were the
years 1919 and 1920. The Special Master in the ease at
bar has found (Finding No, 39) that the “taking of tes-
timony in said case [meaning the ease in the Supreme
Court] was coneluded in April, 1919. The opinion of the
Court was handed down January 27th, 1920” (Ree,
p. 38).
: ee
PREF Py Hy Ny
6
This discloses that the complainant was required to
experiment with a period of operation subsequent to
“January, 1920." The learned judge of the Court below
has therefore ignored the condition imposed by this dee.
sion and granted equitable relief, notwithstanding that
the question was sfare decisis, This is tantamount toa
reversal of the decree of the Supreme Court of the State
of New York, a court of complete jurisdiction in the
premises, by a court having no authority to reverse de.
erees of the State courts.
Tie practice of the complainant, continuously since
January 1, 191s, of furnishing to its consumers Ulaninat-
ing gas approximately 35 per cent. deficient in. th
standard of quality re quired by law, and selling it for
95 counts per thousand cubic feet, is obviously not ex
pertmenting with the statutory rate.
We urge upon the Court the necessity of requiring
complainaltt to now begin a course of adequate experi
Incntation with the statutory rate, and herewith submit
authorities in support of our position in the premises,
In Lowisiana RR. Com. ve Cumberland Tel. Co, 22
U.S. 426, this Court said:
“We sav this because the evidence shows that
in the case of teiephone companies the general re-
sult of a reduction of rates in some other kinds ot
business does not always follow, namely, that there
would be an increased demand, which could be sup-
plied at a proportionately less cost than the origi-
nal business. Sueh, it is admitted, would be the
‘vase generally in regard to water companies, and
perhaps some others where the rate is a reason
able one. For example, it is said that it would
cost no more, or certainly scareely an appreciable
amount more to haul a train of two ears both tilled
than it would to haul the same train with bot: cars
halt filled, and if the reduction in rates should re-
sult in filling the ears where previously they had
not been half tilled there might be an increased
7
carriage at a cost very little more than before
and probably an inereased profit. So in the Se
of a water company the reduced rate might result
in furnishing more water to consumers already
existing and the increased cost of furnishing the
same would be infinitesimal where there was a
supply sufficiently large to fill the demand. So,
also, in furnishing gas at reduced rates, the re-
duction in the rate would very probably result in
inercased consumption, not only in inereased de-
mands from more consumers, but also an inereased
consumption by consumers already existine and
the increased cost of furnishine thi gas would be
nothing like in proportion to the increase in con-
sumption. In these cases incrersed profits might
be result of decreased rates.”
The rule laid down by this Court is especially ap-
plicable to the appellee beeause it is doing business in
the same city, under practically the same local eondi-
tions, and under the same statute that was attacked in
Wilcox v. Consolidated Gas Co. (212 U. &.. 19). Chap-
ter 604 of the Laws of 1916, which is herein assailed, is
an amendment of Chapter 125 of the Laws of 1906,
which Was passed upon in the Consolidated case. It
night fairly be urged that the decision in the latter case
isan adjudication which positively must be followed in
the Instant case,
In the former case the Court required that an actual
periment be had with the new rate, and it may be ob-
served that ten years elapsed before the Consolidated Gas
Company undertook to assail again in Court the statute
Thich it sought previously to have declared confiseatory.
The Court said:
“The value of real estate and plant is to a
considerable extent matter of opinion, and the
same may be said of personal estate. when not
based upon the actual cost of material and con-
8
struction. Deterioration of the value of the plant,
Wins and pipe. is also, to some extent, batsed Upon
opinion, ALL these matters make questions of
Value somewhat uncertain, while added to this is
an alleged prospecture loss of tHoome Troma re-
duced rate, a matter also of mie Ihe anne ertaiity, doe.
pe willing upou the extent of the reduction of the
probable inercased consumption, and we hare a
probl mas to the character ofa rate whieh is dif.
fie vult fo ansorer without a practical fest from actual
operation of the vate =~ * but where the rate
complained of shows, in any event, a very narrow
line of division between possible confiscation and
proper regulation and based upon the value of
the property found by the Court below, and that
the division depends upon divisions as to value
which differ considerably among the witnesses,
and also upon the results in the future of operat
ing under the rate objeeted to, so that the mate-
rial fact of value is kept very much in doubt, a
Court of equity ought not to interfere by injune-
tion before a tate trial has been made of continn-
ing the business under that rate, and thus elimi-
nating, as far as possible, the doubt arising from
opinions as opposed to facets” (212 UL S.. 42).
And later. in the ssine decision, the Court said:
“The question of how much an increased con-
sumption under a Jess rate will increase the earn
ings of complainant, if at all, at a cost not pro-
portioned to the former cost can he answered ouly
by a practical test. In such a case as this, where
the other data upon whieh the computation of the
rate of return must be based, are from: the evi-
dence so uncertain, and where the margin between
possible confiscation and valid) regulation is so
narrow, Wwe cannot say that there is no fair or
just doubt about the truth of the allegwation that
the rates are insufficient” (212 U.S8., 51).
~~ ea
9
And in conelusion the Court said:
“Upon a careful consideration of the case be-
fore us, we are of the opinion that the complainant
has failed to sustain the burden cast upon it of
showing beyond any just or reasonable doubt that
the acts of the Legislature of the State of New
York are, in fact, confiscatory” (212 U.S. oF).
How closely this Court adheres to this rule requiring
actual experiment is shown in Knoxville Water Company
vr. Knoxville (212 U.S..14). The Court said:
“The case is peculiar. The company has never
observed the ordinance. The suit was begun nine
months after its enactment, and tried considerably
ater © * ©. ty Gile coos there could be no
absolute certainty because the ordinance had
never been put in operation, but evidence of the
years succeeding to the ordinance is relevant and
of great importance, and by a consideration of
such evidence a much greater degree of certainty
be obtained * *) *, The jurisdiction thus in-
voked here, and as has been said to be exercised
only, in the clearest cases. If a company of this
kind chooses to decline to obse mre an ordinance
of this nature and prefers rather to go into Court
with the claim that the ordinance is MnNcOnsItY-
tional, it must be prepared to show to the satis-
faction of the Court. that the ordinance would
necessarily be so coufiscatory in its effect as to vio-
late the Constitution of the United States.”
(Citing ex parte Young, 209 U.S. 123; San
Diego Land & Town Co. v. National City,
V4 U.S., 729, 754:
San Diego L. & T. Co. v. Jasper, 189 U. S.,
439).
“If hereafter it shall appear that the actual
operation of the ordinance that the returns made
10
by it operate as a confiseation of property; nothing |
in this judgment will prevent another application
to the courts of the United States or the courts
of the State of Tennessee” (212 ULS., 19).
To meet the assertion that this rule was laid down
only in exceptional eases, we eall the attention of the
Court to the following cases:
“While we agree with the Court below that it
Was right * we think, in view of the fact
that the attack upon the rate was made before the
advance went into effect, and before actual appliea-
tion of the rates could be demonstrated whether
they were remunerative or not s the
Court should have dismissed the bill) without
prejudice.”
(Des Moines Gas Co. vy. City of Des Moines,
238 U.S., 153).
“The evidence for complainant tending to show
they were non-remunerative, While based upon
actual experience in the operation of the rate, vet
relates to only a brief period when these were ab-
normal * 7 * but it is sufficient for the pres.
ent to show that the experimental period was too
brief, and the decree under review should be so
modified that the dismissal of the bills shall be
Without prejudice to another suit) 7 7 7 i
after a full and fair test they shall be found to be
contiseatory.”
(Darnell vo Edwards, 244 U. S.. 569, 570,
citing Knoxville Water Cov. Knoxville,
and Willcox vy. Consolidated Gas Co.
supra.)
“We are far from saving that the argument for
doing so does not seem to us to have considerable
probability on its side. We do not say that experi
ment may not establish a case in the future that
would require a decision upon the question of con:
1]
stitutional law. But we can express no opinion
upon it now * * *. Tt seems to us that the
nearest approach to justice that can be made at
this time is to follow the precedent of Willcox vy.
Consolidated Gas Co., 212 U. S., 19, as nearly as
may be, and affirm the decree, but without preju-
dice to the right of the railroad company to reopen
the case by appropriate proceedings if. after ade-
quate trial, it thinks it can prove more clearly than
at present the confiseatory character of the rates
for coal.”
Nor. Pacific Ry. v. Nor. Dakota, 236 U. S.,
581.
In this case the test was made under the rates in
question and the case reopened after a year and finally
passed upon by this Court (236 U. S., O85) :
“If thereafter it shall appear that under actual
operations of the plant, under these rates, the
return allowed by such corporation commission
operates as a confiscation of the property of com-
plainant * * * she may at the expiration of
one year again present her evidence to the Court
and obtain appropriate relief on the facts then
presented.”
Van Dyke v. Geary, 218 Fed., 111, aff'd in
244 U.S, 49, citing Anorville Water Co.
v. Knorville (212 U. S., 1).
“When it is remembered what clear evidence
the court requires before it declares legislation
otherwise valid, void on this ground (confiscation)
and when it is considered how speculative every
figure is that we have set down with delusive exact-
ness, we are of the opinion the result is too near
the dividing line not to make actual experiment
necessary.”
City of Louisville v. Cumberland Telephone
€ Telegraph Co., 225 U. S., 430.
12
In Penn. R. R. Co. v. Towers, 245 U. S., 6, this Court
affirmed 126 Md., 59, which refused an injunction and
held:
“and that although the order involved fixed rates
for ten vears, there should be reserved to the col.
pany the right to apply to PLS. CL after reasonable
time for the right to rescission or modification of
the order, if CL PErience demonstrated that the rey-
enue derived under the tariff as established was
not properly compensatory for the services rey.
dered.”
Following the same rule the Court, in Montana W, é
SR. Co. v. Morley, 198 Fed. Rep., 991, held that where
a freight rate had been made for the future and a reason.
able time had passed during which it had been applicable,
the revenue derived therefrom would be regarded in
determining whether it is remunerative or confiscatory,
“We recognize fully the authority and wisdom
of the views of the Supreme Court) 7 7 * “that
a case ought to be a clear one before the Court
ought to be asked to interfere with state legislation
upon the subject of rates in advance of an actual
experience of the practical results of said rates’”
Boubright v. Geary, 210 Ked., 44.
“Where a fair trial for a year of rates of intra-
state business established by a state has demon-
strated that they are not compensatory to a rail-
road it is entitled to an injunetion to restrain their
further enforcement without reference to what
might be their effect if continued.”
In re Arkansas Rate Cases, 187 Fed., 290.
“The ordinance was never put in force. Within
a few days after ft went into effect, this bill was
filed and an injunction pendente lite eranted,” ete.
7s * “The inquiry in cases of this character
is not alone what has complainant theretofore
13
earned but it is what will be the effect of the ordi-
nance reducing the rate upon the future net earn-
ings of the company and it devolves upon com-
plainant to show not that the past rates have not
produced a reasonable return but that the rate pre-
scribed by the ordinance will not in future produce
a reasonable return.”
Lincoln Gas Co. y. Lincoln, 223 U. S., 361.
“As the ordinance was passed in 1906 and had
not yet been enforced, the Supreme Court of the
State dismissed the bill Without prejudice to a rate
suit after it) should have been given a fair test
(144 lowa, 426). The plaintiff, having specially
set-up that the ordinance Violated the contract
Clause of the Constitution (Art, 1, See. 10) and the
Fourteenth Amendment, bring the case here * * mi
But there is nothing of which we ean take notice
in the ease that could warrant us in changing the
result or in saving that the plaintiff did not get
as much as it could expect when leave was reserved
for it to try again.”
Cedar Rapids Gas Co. y. Cedar Rapids, 223
U. S., 666, 670.
“May it not be possible—indeed, does not all
experience suggest the probabilitvy—that a redue-
tion of rates will increase the amount of business
and therefore the earnings? At any rate, must the
Court assume that it has no sueh effect; and ignor-
ing all other considerations, hold as a matter of
law, that a reduction of rates necessarily diminishes
the earnings.”
Chicago, ete., Railway Co. y. Weilman, 143
U. S., 344.
In this case it was shown that, on the very day the act
went into foree, the application for a ticket was made, a
suit begun and within two months a judgment obtained
inthe Trial Court.
14
While we are discussing this point, we may appropri.
ately refer to Commonwealth v. Interstate Consolidated
Railway Company, IST Mass., 486, in Which the Court
said:
“Nothing less than a certainty that the provi-
sien (half rate fare to children) would cause loss
to the railway companies or some of them, would
enable us to hold that the Legislature was power-
less to make the require Be
* = * Was it not possible that the Legisla-
ture to decide * * * that the number who
would ride at the half rate would be nearly, if not
twice as many as at the regular rate and that for
these and other companies would suffer no loss
from earrving children at half the regular fare?”
This case was appealed to this Court and in 207 U.S,
79, Mr. Justice Houmes wrote as follows:
“Tam not prepared to overrule the decision of
the Legislature and of the highest Court of the
State of Massachusetts, that the requirement (half
fare rate) is reasonable under the circumstances
existing there; upon evidence that goes no higher
than this (which was to the effeet that a consider:
able percentage of the passengers carried by the
railroad consisted of school children).
* * * _ 7 * *
It is not enough that a statute goes to the verge
of constitutional power. We must be able to see
clearly that it goes beyond that power.”
The New York Court of Appeals has recently fol:
lowed the same doctrine, and in expressive language
declared (Municipal Gas Co. v. City of Albany, 225 N.Y,
98) :
“On the contrary, through repeated decisions,
there runs the consistent thought, in controversies
of this order, experience is the final test, that the
ee an FT RRL scieiememiniaaitiiiasi |
15
Court must bide their time, and let the Working
of the law deeide.” (Citing Willeor y. Consoli-
dated Gas Co,, 212 U.S., 19; Knoxville Vv. Anor-
rille Water Ca. Zest): S., 1; North. Pacific Ry.
Conv. North Dakota, 216 U. S., 979; Cedar Rapids
Gas Light Company v. City of Cedar Rapids,
225 ULS., 655, 670; Missouri Vv. CO. BL & Q. Ry. Co.,
241 U.S, 583, 540: Darnell Vv. Edivards, 244 VU, S.,
IO4-970; Van Dyke y. Geary, 244. UL S., 39.) “Bills
to annul rates have been dismissed without preju-
dice, While the outcome remained uncertain, Bills
fo annul the same rates haye afterwards been sus-
tained when the vision of results was clarified by
the wisdom that follows the event?” (Northern
Pacific Pr. R. Co. v. North Dakota, 200 U, ou OSD:
Missouri ye C. Be & VY. Ry. Co., 241 U. S., 540).
It is not improbable that the effect of the amended
statutory rate would be to somewhat reduce the earn-
ings of the company during the first Year, but all experi-
ence shows and this Court has recognized jt in many
cases that the probable effect of a reduced rate on such
a commodity as gas would be to ereatly increase the
consumption without a corresponding increase of ex-
peuse, and that in time the increased consumption of
vas, resulting from the reduced rate, would be sufficient
‘omore than overcome the amount of the reduction.
It is notable that, in spite of the competition of the
dectrie light, the consumption of gas is steadily inereas-
ing and the number of new customers may be counted
by thousands,
If it be argued by the complainant that the conditions
under which the company operated since the enactment
of the statute assailed have been such that manifestly
there would have been no difference in the result so far
as the returns upon the value of the property were eon-
cerned, had the company actually obeyed the statute and
tee sai cee 89 Bo
16
put into effect the SO-cent rate, then we respectfully sub.
mit to the Court that there is no evidence in this case to
show such a conclusion, and that such a deduction from
What has been put in evidence in this ease would be purely
conjecture,
The suggestion was made during the trial that the
complainant could show evidence from which it might be
deduced that in all likelihood the results so far as the
percentage of return upon the fair value of the property
of the complainant was concerned, would not have been
changed had the SO-cent rate actually been followed. But
the complainant has brought forward no such evidence
from which a fair conclusion in this matter may be
drawn.
A recent decision was handed down by this Court
in the ease of Lincoln Gas & Electric Light Company
against the City of Lincoln (250 U.S. 266). It will be
recalled that this ease had formerly been up on appeal to
this Court. In the first instance it had not been referred
to a Master and the Court hearing the ease made no
specific findings.
The decree of this Court reversed the decision of the
Court below with directions to refer to a Master with
leave to both parties to take additional evidence. The
Court below followed these instructions and appointed
a Master who reported his findings, both of fact and law,
The Master’s report was confirmed by the District Court,
from which an appeal was again taken to the United
States Supreme Court.
This decision positively confirms the proposition
which we have above asserted that an actual test must be
made of the statutory rate before it may be assailed in
Court. This Court said as follows:
“Pending the hearing upon the Master's report,
and on or about May 1, 1915, complainant, notwith-
standing the injunction pendente lite, put into
17
effect a net rate of #1 per thousand feet for gas,
and has maintained it since,
Upon the streneth of this test, and before the
argument of this the seeond appeal, complainant
presented to us a petition for leave to file a bill of
review in the court. below upon the ground that,
according to the Master's findings, complainant, in
the year 1907, earned so small a return that the
rate ordinance would have been confiseatory upon
the valuation as found by him, but for this addi-
tional findine: Aq] human experience has shown
that inereased consumption follows quickly a re-
duction in the price of commodities, and the eyi-
dence in this case satisfactorily shows that gas is
no exception to the rule’
The petition averred that the experience of
complainant in an actual test of the reduced rate
during a considerable period since May 1, 1915,
showed that the view of the Master was erroneous,
and in fact under actual operating conditions there
Was no increase of consumption,
The application for leave to file a bill of review
will be denied, for the following reasons:
First because the $71 rate was put into effect
pursuant to awritten stipulation made between the
parties in the cause to the effect that the action of
the company in so doing should not be construed as
an acceptance of or compliance with the ordinance
in controversy, and should not he ‘shown in evi-
dence or presented to the court m the above-en-
titled cause, or used in any Way by either party to
influence the action of the court in the disposition
of the case’ Hence defendant was not called upon
to observe the effect of the reduced rate or prepare
to meet inferences drawn therefrom,
Secondly, because complainant miaht have
made a practical test of the ordinance rate before
bringing this suit for an injunction. and certainly
ought to have resorted to thy test long before it did
so. As early as the month of January, 1909. this
court, in two notable rate cases, indicated its riew
of the importance, in any but a very clear case of
ens |
18
subjecting prescribed rates to the test of practical
experience before attacking them in the courts.
Kuoxrille v. Knoxville Water Co., 212 U, S., 1, 16,
1s. Willcox v. Consolidated Gas Co., 212 U. S.,
19,54. When those decisions were announced this
case was pending in the Circuit Court, and shortly
thereajter it was decided adversely to complainant
upon the question of the validity of the rate, the
Knoxville and Willcox cases being cited. 182 Fed.
Rep., 926, 929, Then, if not before, complainant
might have made a practical test of the sufficiency
of the rate, instead of waiting six yearss longer
before doing so, The litigation has been extremely
tedious and burdensome to both sides and it ought
now to be brought to a conclusion upon the record
as it stands.
- * * * a * *
Without going into details, we content ourselves
with announcing our general conclusion that having
regard to the entire period under investigation, we
are unable to say that the Master erred in holding
that the ordinance was not shown to have been con
fiscatory im its effect. It is probable that in the
years 1907 and 1912, the net return was close to the
line, if not below it; but that in the other years ex-
amined it was at least 7 per cent.; and there are too
many doubtful items for us to adjudge, the ordi-
nance void, in the absence of an actual and timely
test.
The decree dismissed the bill, however, so far
as it related to the rate ordinance, without reserva-
tion or qualification. Perhaps it would go without
saying, but in our opinion the decree ought to be
modified so as to permit complainant to make an-
other application to the courts for relief against
the operation of the ordinance hereafter, if it can
show, as a result of its practical test of the dollar
rate since May 1, 1915, or upon evidence respecting
values, costs of operation and the current rates of
return upon capital as they stand at the time of
bringing suit and are likely to continue thereafter,
that the rate ordinance is coufiscatory in its effect
under the new conditions,”
poh IRAE FH SS Cat, he
19
Mr. Justice Greexsavm, in the trial in the State Court
(110 Mise., 204) said:
“This action was commenced before the legis-
lative act here assailed Went into effeet and was not
brought on for trial] until the latter part of 1918,
If the court had before it only the experiences of
the plaintiff during 1916 and a few Years prior
thereto, showing as they do substantial incomes
annually, it would have been justified in dismissing
the bill upon the evidence, for the reason that the
plaintiff had made no practical test by actual
operation under the 80 cent rate (Aunoxville y,
Knoxville Water Co., 212 U. S., 1, 14, 15; Willcox
Vv. Consolidated Gas Co., 212 U. §., 19, 42; Munie-
tpal Gas Co. of City of Albany v. Public Service
Comm'n, 225 N. Y., 89). As matter of fact the
plaintiff has been collecting from its customers
since the commencement of this action at the rate
of 95 cents per thousand eubie feet of gas, pursuant
to an order of the court, the excess of 15 cents
above the legal rate having been deposited with a
trust company pursuant to such order.
The court, however, took proof as to expense of
operations, subsequent to July 1, 1916, and down to
December 31, 1918, to afford the plaintiff an oppor-
tunity to establish that at an 50-cent rate, confisea-
tion would ensue. despite an economical and effi-
cient operation of the works and a largely in-
creased income because of a lower rate (Willcox
Vv. Consolidated Gas Co., supra, at p. 42),
It is obvious, unless the evidence is conclusive
that confiseation is inevitable under the present
law, that it would be mere speculation in the ab-
sence of an actual experimentation to find whether
the inereased business would or would not suffi-
ciently overeome the reduction in priee. Under
such circumstances the plaintiff would not meet the
burden that rests upon it (Willcox v. Consolidated
Gas Co., 212 U.S... 19).”
It is clear, therefore, that the complainant’s suit
ust fail for the reason that it has failed to make a
practical test of the 80c. rate,
Pid PN eguatan ex
Pewee renner tee a se RE LIS snaN sneer Peae EER cana
20
POINT III.
Candle Power.
The defendants assert that complainant is not
entitled to equitable relief, because it has persistently
violated the statute requiring it to furnish gas of
twenty-two candle power.
In the recent case of
Carmen v. Fox Film Corporation, 269 Fed,
92s,
the Court refused to interfere on behalf of an infant
who sought to have certain contracts declared void, which
she alleged had been made during her minority. The
Court said at page 932:
“The maxim that one who comes into equity
must come with clean hands expresses rather a
principle of inaction than one of action. It means
that equity wiil refuse its aid in any mainer to
one secking its active interposition if he has been
guilty either of unlawful or inequitable conduet
respecting the subject matter of the litigation.”
The opinion of Judge Learxep Hanp, in the Consoli-
dated Gas case (267 Fed. Rep., 243), stated that the re
quirement
“must of course be regarded as a duty imposed
upon the plaintiff while it remains upon the stat-
ute book. A persistent and deliberate disregard
of it might, | should think, bring this ease within
that somewhat indefinite rule which turns out o!
a court of equity a suitor who has himself been
unjust in the very matter of which he complains”
Vee 1 a DR ¢ Satee CONS Ear ey
21
The complainant, according to the Court, did not dis-
pute that it has not furnished its consumers with gas
of the quality required by the statute.
It is furnishing a counterfeit gas,
In Nings County Lighting Company v. Lewis et al.
(ante), the case tried recently in the New York Supreme
Court, Mr. Justice GREENBAUM said:
“* * * Moreover, it may well be urged that
if the plaintiff has knowingly violated the law by
selling gas of a standard lower than that fixed
by law, it is not entitled to equitable relief, Ob-
servance of the law is a eardinal principle which
is obligatory upon him Who secks Judgment in
equity.”
The officials of this company “knowingly violated the
law by selling gas of a standard lower than that fixed by
law.”
The quality of the gas manufactured by complainant
sa necessary factor to be considered in connection with
the Income of the company. It has not attempted to
prove or estimate how much the income would have been
increased if it had provided the consumers With candle
wwer gas. It necessarily follows that because of the
nereased purchase of gas, the income would have been
treater than it is alleged to have been, if the company
iad sold 22-candle power gas,
In Kings County Lighting Co. (ante), Judge Green-
uUM Said:
chinese tegete 5 daily tests of gas made by the
legal inspectors established that the average
quality of the gas supplied by the plaintiff dur-
ing 1918 was an average of 13.57 candles instead
of 22 candles, which is the minimum by law. It
follows that the consumer was either compelled to
consume a greater quantity of gas measured by the
re See er ee eens rs
oe
>»)
ratio of 22 to 13.57 at a correspondingly increased
price to him or that he sutfered from the loss of
light in the ratio of 13.57 to 22 for which he paid
the price charged for gas of a 22-candle power
standard,
“How can one foretell how much increased busi-
ness the plaintiff would have had if it had fur.
nished the legal 22-eandle power instead of the
very considerably diminished candle power that it
furnished in 1918?) The use of gas has been large.
ly extended during the past few years for cook.
ine, heating water, house heating and other pur.
poses, A standard quality of gas should insure a
more extensive use of gas. At any rate a fair
test under the law cannot be made except by con-
plianee with the law which fixes the standard of
quality.” * * *°
The Master has found that the complainant has been
charging for gas at the rate of 95 cents per thousand
cubic feet sinee July 1, 1916 (Ree. p. 38). Since Jan-
ary 1, 1919, the monthly average of candle power fur.
nished by complainant has been To. The company is
required by statute to furnish 22 candle power gas &
80 cents per thousand cubic feet. It has restrained put-
lie officials from enforcing the statute for almost four
vears, and ignored the statute after the restraint was of.
Without the sovereign authority of the State, it adopted
its own method of fixing gas quality, of which the Maste
approves, and sold the product it manufactured, not at™
cents per thousand cubie feet, nor even at 95 cents, whic
the Master finds, but at $1.38 per thousand cubic feet
Selling fifteen candle power gas for 95 cents is equivalen!
to selling 22-candle power gas for $1.38. The Cour
below finds, however, that the company is not com
pensated and is entitled to equitable relief. Moreover,
he finds that there has been a sufficient experimentation
= 5 ee NPP SR he See Snore ——_
23
with the statute it has assailed as non-compensatory,
notwithstanding that there has been no effort on the part
of the company to comply with the re quirements of the
statute.
In actual results the discrepancy is even greater
than shown above, because efficient use cannot be made
ofa gas that varies in quality from day to day.
The Master, however, disregards the obyious inequity
and excuses the complainant's default, and its conse-
quent defiance of the regulating power of the State, by
giving full credence to the company’s alleged inability
to get sufficient gas oil.
If Congress passed a law permitting the fixing of
prices per pound of food commodities, and created a
special board to enforce such an act. we feel sure that
the courts would punish those who arbitrarily decided
to sell and did sell 12 ounces of Sugar and eall it a
pound. There would be no defense available to the
dealer that sugar was searce. The analogy herewith
presented is complete with the facts in the case at bar—
l-eandle power gas is not 22-ceandle power gas any more
than 8 or 12 ounces is a pound.
We urge upon the Court to consider the illegality,
and the obvious unfairness of complainant to its eon-
amers, in selling extremely low and variable candle
power gas at a price in excess of that fixed by statute.
The Legislature determined that complainant must give
the consumer 22-candle power gas at 80 cents per thou-
snd cubic feet. The complainant not only failed to
neet the standard but furnished gas of exceedingly in-
terior quality.
The City reported the result of its tests to the com-
jany each day (Ree., pp. 202-3). and no complaint was
*ermade to the City by complainant that said tests were
PBA Me ER Rik i Rn ARE nO
24
not accurate. In addition, the City deducted from the
complainant's bills a proportionate amount to cover the
deficiency in the candle power of the gas furnished,
The tests made by the City of New York are made by
gas testers employed by the Department of Water Sup.
ply, Gas & Electricity of the City of New York. These
men are experts in their line and made daily reports un-
der oath as required by Chapter 735 of the Laws of 1905,
The situation presented in this case bears no re.
semblance to the state of facts passed upon in the Con.
solidated ease hereinbefore referred to. There is no
question in the instant proceeding about the accuracy of
the readings taken or methods used by the official City
gas testers. Their results are uncontroverted,
The testimony shows many violations of the statute,
and the undisputed evidence is that these continued over
a long period (Comp. Ex. 15-17, Ree., p. 1037). The com.
plainant furnished no proof that it had complied with the
statute. It admitted the violations repeatedly con-
plained of and merely offered lame and insufficient ex-
cuses, such as its alleged inability to obtain oil in sufi-
cient quantities to thoroughly enrich the gas.
The Illinois Commission, in re Central Illinois Pub-
lic Service Co., Case No. 7617, reported in P. U. R,
1918, E., pages 357-358, said:
“The petitioner has displayed a lack of effort
and interest in its gas business, and the quality of
the service has been sufficiently bad to discourage
the use of gas, and for these and other reasons,
more fully set forth in this opinion, the company
need not expect consumers to pay a return for poor
service equal to that allowed heretofore in the
order issued in connection with gas utilities that
have been ably managed and developed.”
PENIS SOIR ot PRL LEP LE LIE EE IIE A AL BRAC L OAR
25
The Wisconsin R. R. Commission recently decided
acase reported in P. U. R., January, 1921, said:
“We find:
1. That the gas service furnished by this Com-
pany to these communities is inadequate and un-
satisfactory.
2. That no increase in rates for gas should be
given consideration until the service rendered in
the gas department shall conform in a reasonable
manner to the standards laid down by this Com-
mission.”
Similar findings have been made by other commissions.
Complainant has at all times been in a position to
furnish the gas prescribed by the statute but has re-
fused to do so. It might have made application to the
Public Service Commission for authority to change the
tandard from Candle Power to B. T. U. under certain
enditions; but there is nothing in the reeord to show
that it ever made any such effort.
While we maintain that the heating value is not an
issue in this case, because not mentioned in the statute,
ve say that the heating value of the gas as measured
at the plant of the complainant is not evidence of the
ieating value at the consumers’ premises.
In finding number 11 (Ree., pp. 31-2), the Master
gives a table showing the alleged heating value of the
gas manufactured. He does not state how much more
than 620 British Thermal Units there is normally and un-
woidably contained in gas of 22-candle power. He alto-
gether fails to show that the law requires complainant to
deliver gas of 22-candle power measured at least one mile
‘rom the plant. He has not been informed that there is a
r
very great difference between a gas of 524.07 B. T. U.
OEE DONE HBL SR RO ED RTE RL uk OEE ME Ee we . a
26
ralue tested at the plant and one with 22-candle power (op
say 600 B. T. U.) tested one mile from the plant. He
seemingly does not understand that a manufactured gas
having only 3.08 candle power can have only an exceed.
ingly small heating value. He is not aware that a month.
ly average heating value does not mean anything in jt.
self so far as concerns uniformity of heating value, but
it is demonstrated beyond all question that the gas dur.
ing June, 1920, varied at least as much as 100 per cent,
above the low point in heating value because the candle
power value was around + on June 2nd to 7th inclusive,
While the monthly average was 8.04. Whereas we might
admit that a 22-candle power gas may vary considerably
from day to day in its heat value, although not over 1)
per cent, we know of no gas engineer who would not
swear that as between a 3 or 4-candle power gas and an
S-candle power gas the difference in the heating value
would be in almost direct proportion to the candle power,
We thus see that the complainant has demonstrated, by
its evidence, the fallacy of the opinions loosely expressed
by its experts that heating value gas is more uniform
than a gas measured by its candle power. We positively
dispute the finding of the Master, number 14 (Ree., p. 33),
“the heating value standard tends to increase efficiency
in consumption, by insuring uniformity of quality.” We
deny that the record shows any basis for the conclusion
that up to May 1, 1920, the gas furnished was of uniform
heating quality. He has no means of knowing what heat-
ing value was furnished, No regulatory body has ever
prescribed a test of gas based upon its heating quality
measured at or near the relief holder.
The testimony clearly shows that since 1918 the eom-
plainant has abandoned all efforts to comply with the
statute. The wisdom of this statute is solely within the
province of the Legislature. The constitutionality of
a a as ee ee beereer
27
that part of the statute which prescribes the candle
power to be furnished is not attacked by complain-
ant. Other large companies in this Vicinity have at-
tempted substantially to comply with said statute, and
there is no testimony to controvert the fact that it is
possible to make gas and comply with the requirement
that the Legislature prescribed after due deliberation
and consideration of voluminous evidence relating to this
important part of the service.
In Willcox v. Consolidated Gas Company, 212 U. S.,
19, the penalties for violation of the candle power stat-
ite were held to be unconstitutional, due to their being
amulative, and accordingly it would have been futile to
prosecute this company. The complainant has taken
advantage of this decision, on the assumption that it
could not be punished by the imposition of fines. It can,
however, feel the weight of the law at this time by having
this Court decide that it has taken advantage of its po-
‘ition as a monopoly deliberately to impose upon its
customers. Having come into a court of equity it should
te required to do equity before any relief is granted.
|
J
i
1}
28
POINT IV.
Unaccounted-for Gas.
An unreasonable amount of the unnecessarily ex.
pensive gas made by complainant is subsequently
lost or unaccounted for.
The complainant loses almost one-fifth of its produet
in the distribution process, and, moreover, does not im-
prove its methods notwithstanding one serious judicial
attack made upon this loss over a year ago, Suppose that
any industrial or mereantile plant lost 174, per cent. of
its product before it reached the consumer, Suppose, fur-
ther, it lost 15 per cent. which the Court fixes as a rea-
sonable amount to lose. What would be the result to the
manufacturer?) Seventeen or fifteen per cent. would have
to be added to the price to the consumer in order to
save the concern from bankruptey. Good business prac-
tice does not increase prices to this extent to cover loss,
but seeks to eliminate the loss. Where did the Court be-
low obtain the basis of fact to make the findings? This
eannot be ascertained from the reeord, except from two
loose statements of engineers. These statements explain
nothing. Shall the consumer stand an increase in price
to cover this loss in order to justify the slipshod manage-
ment of the complainant?
The practice of this company was condemned in the
opinion of Mr, Justice Greenbaum, in the prior suit (110
Misc., 204). Tle said:
“It may be assumed that a certain percentage
of this unaecounted-for gas is likely to exist in
every gas factory, however efficiently managed, but
that does not explain whether such a large per
centage of unaccounted-for gas as is here shown
is usual in well-managed gas factories. It was in-
~~ aan aieaiteeitaiaaiaieeaiaael
ey at
29
eumbent upon the plaintiff to establish that its
business was conducted efficiently and with due
regard to proper economies. The expert witness,
however, refrained from giving testimony as to
What the percentage of unaccounted-for gas was
found to be in other gas-making concerns or
whether there is a well-recognized average per-
centage of loss of gas which is unavoidable, nor
was he questioned on these points. The plaintiff
has therefore failed to meet the burden of show-
ing that its percentage of unaccounted-for gus is
not excessive,
The circumstances, too, that in 1916 the ratio
of lost gas was 12.69 per cent, of the entire out-
put, and 1918 the ratio had inereased to 18 per
cent, is an added faet indicating the importance
of showing with some reasonable degree of cer-
tainty whether such an increased loss could not
have been avoided by the exercise of eare and
efficient management. The failure to furnish proof
as to the specifie causes to which the losses were
attributable is a circumstance strongly pointing
to the fact that the loss is exeessive and could
have been largely reduced by careful supervision.”
After its defeat in the State Court, complainant made
no effort to reduce the amount of its unaeccounted-for
gas, so far as the evidence shows.
The loss of gas is a matter of importance, but the
danger to health and to life and limb is of even greater
concern and needs to be particularly considered in a |
rate case from the standpoint of losses from claims and
damages. A company that admits over 10 per eent. of
the gas it sends out is unaccounted for, condemns itself
as negligent and wasteful. The burden is upon it to
prove why such excessive losses should be charged
against the public. Defendants could not in this ease
be charged with the duty of digging thousands of test
holes, making hundreds of thousands of tests on meters,
rexamining a large number of dead service ends. These
RB veces ermine
30
matters are given careful attention by a well-managed
gas company. No reasonably operated gas utility can
be found, other than complainant, with nearly 18 - per
cont. leakage in similar territory to that of the com.
plainant at least so far as our experience goes,
All of the witnesses agreed that this was an excessive
amount and the Master allowed 11 per cent. which was
inereased to 15 per cent. by the District Judge,
The evidence shows how inefficient the manaygement
was,
Chief among the important elements in the costs as
indicated there will be found, by deduction, the cost of
making gas that is lost. The only way to find the cost to
the consumers of this item of expense is by taking the cost
of gas made as shown on page 1 of Exhibit 6 (Ree, p,
1033) (4835) from the cost of gas sold as shown on page
2 (5920) and thus reach the result (.1085). This 10.8ie,
per M. applied to 279,274,156 cubie feet, amounts to a loss
of $32,254 for the vear 1919. We do not say that all of
this loss should be eliminated. We do say, however, that
the 15 per cent. loss allowed by the Court cannot be sub-
stantiated, by the evidence, as the reasonable allovw-
ance, Inthe Consolidated Gas Company ease the learned
judge allowed only 4.1 per cent. for leakage losses. The
Master in the present case allows 11 per cent., which the
Court inereases to 15 ver cent. It is impossible to de-
termine how this conclusion was reached, If the Court
below believed complainant’s territory is different from
that of others, this Court should know how much weight
was given by Judge Hovau to that assumption. It should
also know how much of this allowed loss was figured
from the testimony of Elsman, who swore that gas was
made and blown into the air (after it had been metered)
because there was no place to store it (Ree, p. 809), In
formation should be available to the Court to show the
31
amount figured for leakage losses because of the fact
that the company allowed the gas holder seals to freeze,
unbalanced the holder, and thus allowed a lot of gas to
be lost.
The witness Klumpp, when testifving for appellee on
the matter of leakage, said that some of this might be
attributed to “non-register” meters. That means a meter
has not registered the amount of gas a consumer has
used, It is not due to “sticking valves,” as when valves
cease to operate the meter will not pass gas. He seems to
be unaware of the general practice, covered by Commis-
sions’ rules, that where a meter does not register the
company is allowed to send an estimated bill, and this
excuse that he used for part of the leakage does not hold
good (Ree., p. 362),
He figured the greater proportion of gas unaccounted
for was due to an underestimate of the amount of gas
used for street lighting and paid for by the City of New
York. If that is the case then the gas consumers are be-
ing indirectly taxed for an expense that should be borne
by the people as a whole and not by the gas consumers
asa class (Ree., p. 362).
In making comparisons with other territories the
witness Miller said that the leakage varies in propor-
tion to the number of services (Ree., p. 385), and we
ask the Court to note the testimony of other wit-
nesses to the effect that this particular district has few
services as compared with the number of customers,
due to one service giving connection to several meters
ina large number of apartment buildings. Can you
compare Gloversville, N. Y., with Brooklyn?) Even
Klumpp testified that over ten per cent. unaecounted-for
gas would be excessive, and yet the Master found 11
per cent. was reasonable (Ree., p. 365). Klumpp had
been testifying considerably about the Minneapolis plant
a ee ee = .
in comparison with that of complainant; and it is there.
fore interesting to note that on cross examination he
admitted that the unaccounted-for gas in Minneapolis was
practically nil (Ree., p. 506).
The witness Miller testified that in New York City
a lot of the gas goes directly from the holders to the
consumers, and that in the territory of the complainant
it goes through a long transmission main. He well knew,
having been an expert called in the Consolidated Gag
Company ease, and it is in fact very clearly in that ree.
ord and decision, that gas made for use in the Con-
solidated system goes into a high-pressure transmission
main that is common to all gas companies on the sys.
tem. His lame explanation on page 390 of the Record
impeaches his testimony. The Master thought he saw
some very valuable information in the testimony, but it
is altogether inaccurate and misleading (Ree., pp. 390-1),
This witness, Miller, has long been connected with this
company as an “expert,” and yet his testimony regard-
ing the places where consumers’ meters are set in the
apartment houses was entirely broken down by some
questions directed to him by Counsel Jackson for the de-
fendants (Ree, p. 391). His testimony about the
“gummy” substance depositing in the meters and mak-
ing them “tend to go slowly” is not convincing. The
slowing down of the speed of the valves would have ab-
solutely nothing to do with the registration of the gas
but would merely result in less gas going through per
hour (Ree., pp. 394-5).
Judge Hanp in the case of Consolidated Gas Com-
pany v. Newton (ante) said:
“The average for the whole system over a pe
riod of 13 years during which statistics were given
| — PARLE IEW Sho RAC Gee RR AE, LRM, BIER Ae EN.
33
to the authorities was 5.31 per cent., and unless
there are some disturbing factors, this is a valid
starting point, which the company must accept.
The only disturbing features suggested here are
the poorer quality of coal and oil, and I take
against the plaintiff any doubt which those factors
may raise. I accept the average of 5.31 as a
proper allowance for the system as a whole, at
least ina rate case * * * J shall therefore take
4.1 per cent. as the proper figure for gas unac-
counted for.”
The testimony shows (Defts. Ex. D-1, Ree., p. 1088)
that five companies, located in territory similar to that
of complainant, reported to the Publie Service Commis-
sion for each of the years, 1917, 1918 and 1919, a yearly
percentage of 8 per cent.
The amount allowed by the Court should therefore
be reduced to 8 per cent.
aes Pt
POINT V.
The record in this case discloses a substantial lack
of proof on important facts and gross inefficiency in
the management of complainant’s plant.
Complainant has failed to prove that its business has
been run efficiently, honestly, economically and prudently,
The question resolves itself into whether or not the
complainant, during the period 1919 to June 30, 1920, on
which it relies to prove the statute is contiseatory, pos-
sessed reasonably adequate, modern and efficient plant
equipment. The testimony shows that complainant's
plant is, and has been for many years, poorly designed
and inadequately equipped to produce gas economically,
It is furthermore shown that this deplorable condition
is due to complainant’s wilful or fatuous neglect to pro-
vide for inevitable expansion of those obvious and ordi:
nary improvements in the art of gas manufacture which
substantially deerease the cost of labor and mate.
rials used in the production of gas. It has not looked
ahead in preparing to meet the demands of the public for
good gas at the reasonable price fixed by statute.
The alleged comtiseatory nature of a gas rate cannot
be established by a mere survey of the operating expenses
of the plant for a short period of time; details are re
quired,
In view of the fact that the management and operat:
ing policy of complainant's plant is beyond the control of
the public—purely a function of the executives of the com-
pany—the following questions may be asked:
Can a public utility corporation select any kind of a
plant that it has in mind, operate it according to a system
that has never been sanctioned in the gas industry, and
then come into Court and demand that the publie pay the
bill?
FE oe A ENT MS
35
Can a utility serve only a selected number of cus-
tomers and refuse service to others, thereby increasing
the cost of Operating its property?
Can it in equity defy the laws under which it operates
and charge more than is allowed for a service less than is
prescribed ? ;
All these questions should have been adequately in-
vestigated by the Master before the Acts of the Legis-
lature are set aside and before appellee is permitted to
collect more than the service is reasonably worth,
Complainant’s Exhibit “6” (Ree.. p. 1033) purports
to show the cost of producing and distributing gas for
the year ending December 31, 1919.
The attention of the Court is respectfully directed to
the following comments upon said Exhibit:
Complainant reports using gas oil for raising steam
$073 per gallon. It reports use of gas oil to produce ga
inthe carburetted water gas system at a cost of $.0646 per
vallon. Gas oil is used for both purposes and vet the
cost per gallon of gas oil is different. W hy? Which
price Is correct?
Complainant reports that it used 22,594.80 tons of gen-
erator coal, For purposes of study this should have been
uarrowed down to the number of pounds used per thou-
sand cubic feet of gas sold. Did the complainant use
ay coke for generator fuel? The record is silent on
the point. The recent decision of Judge Haxp in the
case of Consolidated Gas Company v. Newton, et al.
(anfe) is illuminative.
He said at page 248:
“In 1919 the Seaboard Company was selling it
continuously to the plaintiff at six dollars and fifty
cents long ton, delivered alongside.”
and later at page 249:
“Mr. Doane had been for many vears concerned
with the coke market in New York and its environs
PE IDE ELIE RN Pt BELG POEL ABE IEEE ME NEL PB FBO A De NS PR TAI
36
and up to 1915 had made more or less continued
efforts to obtain a market for so much as the com
pany did not use.”
Here we find one New York gas company with eoke
on its hands that it had produced in its coal gas plants,
and which it claimed was going begging at one time:
and in 1919 said gas company was able to secure by-
product coke from the Seaboard Company at six dol.
lars and fifty cents a long ton alongside its plant. Ab
most within hailing distance of said gas company ap.
pellee was paving eight dollars and forty cents a ton
for generator fuel that ts admittedly no better than that
Which the Consolidated Gas Co. alleged it could not sell.
The generator fuel used by appellee was worse for this
purpose than the by-product coke that the Seaboard
Company sold during 1919 at one dollar and cighty-tive
cents a ton less than the complainant paid for its gen-
erator fuel. In 1919, 22,594.80 tons were used. The com
plainant could have saved about $41,800, on this trans
action alone, if the complainant's engineering depart-
ment had been concerned in economizing, rather than
being concerned, which it is, in making the statutory
rate at which it sells gas appear to be confiseatory. Was
the Master justified in reporting that the prices and
amounts paid for and quantities used of generator fuel
were reasonable and necessary?
Boiler Fuel. The testimony shows (Ree., pp. 301, 879)
that two of the five machines were taken down for repairs
in September, 1919, and were not put into use until Jar
uary, 1920, thus leaving only three machines to take care
of the maximum demand, and these remaining three ma-
chines had not been cleaned or repaired since June, 1919,
although the usual practice is to have them cleaned and
repaired after being run for 1,000 gas-making hours.
The allowance for boiler fuel is excessive. Complain-
1 OP NS, TST LS TE eT bes
37
ant’s own witness Klumpp admitted that 18.8 pounds was
high (Ree., p. 353). The testimony of Mr. Merrifield
shows that the reason for the exeessive use of coal was
due to the foul condition of the water-gas machines
(Ree., pp. 845-6) and that this condition could have been
remedied between July and November of 1919; some of
the machines could have been re-checkered, as there was
no necessity of keeping all five machines in use during
that time (Ree., p. 879),
The usual practice in all well-regulated eas plants is
tomake all repairs during the off season, so as to be pre-
pared for the winter demand.
Residuals. In the manufacture of water gas there is
produced a residual oil to the extent of 15 per cent. of
gsoilused. This complainant used, according to Exhibit
“6,” 5,979,887 gallons of gas oil and should therefore have
lad at its disposal 806.383 gallons of tar oil. It used
149.369 gallons under the boilers and charged production
cost at the rate of .064 per gallon. The average selling
price of water gas tar in 1919 was not more than 4 cents
per gailon. To balance this cost of production, there was
acredit for said residual tar, 765,312 eallons at 064 per
vallon. How can the loss of 57,016 gallons of tar be ex-
plained?
Before leaving this matter of residuals, it is pertinent
to inquire what became of the products of gas condensa-
tion, in the form of light oil recovered at the plant or drip
il collected from the mains? The complainant sets up
very boldly, on Exhibit “6” (Ree., p. 1033), the matter of
‘oondensation,” possibly thinking it a good round-sound-
ng word to explain away some of the enormous loss of
9.274,156 eubie feet of gas in 1919. There should be
wailable drip oil from condensation to the extent of
($330 gallons, and at only 5 cents per gallon the revenue
to the company would be $3,916.50 for the vear 1919. Jt
ippears nowhere on Exhibit “6,” as acredit to operations
Oe ee re ee en ee See eee d a
38
or addition to revenues. It is also natural to inguire
where on Exhibit “6” is there shown the rent received
from the Morse Company that leased a large amount of
waterfront property jrom the complainant, As shown by
the opinion of Mr. Justice Greexpaum in this case heard
in the Supreme Court of the State (ante), this land is
leased to the Morse Company and it must be of consider.
able value because it was shown that a certain real es.
tate man got a commission of $2,000 for negotiating the
lease. The complainant in fact valued it at $265,137. In
that case the Court included the leased land in the rate
base so the rentals received are a revenue chargeable into
the gas operations.
Gas Oil. Returning to the recorded operating costs,
the complainant reported for 1919 the use of 3.45 gallons
of gas oil per thousand cubie feet of gas made. The wit-
ness Merrifield, who was put on by defendants at the in-
sistence of counsel for plaintiff (Ree. p. 855), testified
that in his opinion the company lad used close to one
gallon of oil per M. ft. in excess of what should have been
required for the lamentably low quality gas that was pro-
duced (Ree., p. 866). If we assume, to be on the safe
side. that .75 of a gallon was used in excess, the saving
at .0646 per gallon would have been .04845 per M. cubic
feet of gas made, or the amazing sum of $75,905.12 for
the year 1919. One ean well imagine where that 150,000
gallons of “sludge” came from that the company re-
ported as being such a nuisance when it clogged the
machines and the mains at the plant. This was u-
doubtedly caused by the foul machines in use as testi-
fied by Mr. Merrifield. 2
As to the quantity of oil reported used in making
water gas, we propose to show that the records kept by
the complainant are not conclusive. Reference should
be made to the testimony of Albert J. Gounnod, auditor
and assistant secretary to the complainant, who had never
39
worked directly or indirectly on gas accounts until June,
1918, and at that time he was employed by a public ae-
countant (Ree., p. 116). He testified that:
“Well, for the quantity for the year the engi-
neer at the works takes an inventory of the oil on
hand, he examines these tanks, reads the gauges,
takes the inventory at the begininng of the year;
and we receive the bills showing the amount that
was purchased. This amount purchased is de-
livered at our works, and receipt is sent up show-
ing that that amount was received. To the inven-
tory at the beginning of the year we add the pur-
chases during the vear and from that we subtract
the amount of oil as shown by the inventory on the
last day of the year or for the beginning of the first
day of the succeeding year, and that will give us
the amount of oil that was actually used in the
manufacture of gas” (Ree., p. 123.)
Even the witness himself refuted this method later,
as he showed that all the oil purported to have been re-
ceived is not charged to the gas oil account. Some of the
oil is used under the boiler (Ree., p. 126). In criticizing
the method explained above, it may first be said that the
witness knew only ina general way that a referee certified
that the oil delivered was according to the amount shown
on the bill. He had no knowledge of how the engineer
measured the oil in the tanks and in fact did not know,
even approximately, how large the tanks were. We sub-
mit that the mere certificate of some third party to the
effect that certain quantities of oil had been received does
not prove that it was used in the manufacture of gas.
This company reports the loss of very large quantities
oi gas. May it not be that it also loses a great deal of
oil? If that is so, should the consumers be made to stand
the expense? The record shows that the reported use of
gas oil in the vear 1919 was away over what it should have
been in a reasonably well-managed company, and we re-
«+ tesa
£2 OE NEE SAVO PRLS a
40
spectfully suggest that the company must prove to the
satisfaction of the Court that it not only bought the oj
but that it used it legitimately in the production of gas,
Labor. The witness Gounnod testified that he deter.
mines to What account labor is to be charged. He issues
instructions to the men who are to do the work (Ree, p,
145). The witness admitted that it is absolutely impon.
ant to distribute the labor as between operating expens
and capital account, and in view of his statement that he
determines what account the labor is to be charged to we
assert that the system used by complainant is incorree,
because the auditor cannot possibly tell just what kind of
work every man has done each day. There is no prov
in the record that all labor eapital costs are charged to
the proper account and not to operating expenses,
Materials. The plan in use of taking material out ¢
stores and showing this has been done by a receipt giver
by the man who gets the material is no proof that th
material was actually used on the particular job thet
said laborer assigns it to. We claim there should be:
check made of the material taken out of stores, with the
amount estimated to be required when the “extension
and improvement requisition” is made out (Ree., p. 14/),
There is no proof that any kind of check is made. Al
the company does is to inventory the stores and sup
plies each year to see what difference there is betweet
the perpetual inventory and the inspectional inventory,
but this in no way proves that all material charged ott
of stores went correctly to operating expenses or capita
account (Ree., p. 149).
Books of Account. So far as concerns the books then:
selves, the witness admitted that the complainant doe
not include therein certain accounts prescribed by tle
“Uniform System of Accounts,” as, for instance, “Store
and Stable Expense” and “General Amortization.”
The latter is one of the most important items tol
BA BATA ATONE De a Ra RAD Asa & SAME Ode Theo 2
41
considered by the Court, because the Commission has laid
out this particular amortization account in such a way
that tt ties in with the repair costs which are charged
directly into operating expenses. The Court has been
given absolutely no information about the justice of the
repair accounts and cannot positively tell if they have
been charged with renewals and replacements. If they
have, then the additional sum of one cent per thousand
that the company claims in its operating expense is en-
tirely unnecessary.
The Master appeared to believe this point was not
material, but it was brought to his attention very plainly
by Mr. Chambers, for the defendant Newton (Rec.. pp.
151, 152). The charge for “plant withdrawn from serv-
ice” is arbitrarily made at one cent per thousand feet, al-
though there is no such account presented (Ree., p. 152)
and no proof that any plant retired from service has not
ben charged into repairs and maintenance accounts
(Ree. p. 152). The witness put that charge of $12,872.46
om the books of the company for the year 1919 because
ie was told to do so by the executives of the company
(Rec, p. 153). There is evidence from the complainant
that indicates very clearly the extent to which renewals
ad replacements are charged directly to operating ex-
penses, Gounnod testifying regarding repairs to boilers,
in connection with the expense of $14,329.05 in 1919 as
against $3,895.08 in 1918 and $3,375.27 in 1917 (Ree., p.
20), that “the expense of that is borne within the pe-
tiod where the replacements of boiler tubes was made
necessary” (Ree., p. 221).
Referring further to Gounnod’s testimony, it is per-
ietly evident that there is no real record kept of the
amount of tar produced in making the gas (Ree., p. 158).
ltis furthermore shown by this witness that extensions
aud betterments to the water gas machines in 1919 were
charged to operating expenses, at least in part (Ree., p.
eR
ABSA WR ANREP AO MEATS $B HF i In ——
42
991). Complainant claims that it actually measures
everything that goes into the production of gas, making
check inventories every month, We find, however, that it
estimates the amount of tar made at so much per thov-
sand eubie feet. The Master drew attention to the
smaller pereentage of tar made in 1920 than in 1919, and
the witness Gounnod explained that they found in 1920
this tar Was unusable to the extent of 150,000) gallons
(Ree., p. 228). That being the case, and it being evident
that the 150,000 gallons of “sludge” was not in the tanks
at all but was forcibly extracted from the yard piping,
how is it that the monthly inventory did not reveal this
fact long before the company had it brought to its atten
tion through the choking of the piping system?
General Economy of Plant Operation, — Reflecting
further on the cost of operations is the admitted fact that
the company is operating hand-fired boilers for which it
has to purchase a special kind of coal (Ree., p. 289), It
was admitted by Gounnod that when the automatic
stokers on certain other boilers broke down, the com-
pany had to increase its boiler room force by 18 men
(Ree. p. 229). It naturally follows that by continuing
in use obsolete boilers that do not have stokers attaclied,
this complainant is incurring a greater labor expense
than is neeessary. In regard to the quality of the gas,
we wish to call the attention of the Court to the testi:
mony of Elsman for complainant, particularly at page
203. He shows a great increase in the consumption of gas
although there was practically no inerease in the number
of consumers. This could be caused by two very import-
ant delinquencies on the part of the complainant, one
being the low quality of the gas and the other being the
deficieney of pressure at the consumers’ appliances. In
1915, there were 28,925 consumers who used 765,691 400
feet of gas, or an average of about 26,470 feet, whereas
in 1919 there were 37,884 consumers who used 1,226312-
43
600 fect, or an average of about 32,370 feet (Ree., p. 304).
The evidence is conclusive that the complainant over-
taxed its production plant during the year 1919. It did
not have enough gas to go around, so it refused to take
on new consumers and at the same time it diluted the
gas it sent to those customers it deigned to serve (Ree.,
p. 805). It ts also apparent from this that the cost of
operation was abnormal, You cannot work a plant in
the way indicated and get normal results. It follows
that the negligence of the complainant in keeping up its
plant facilities is not to be charged to the consumers.
It will also be noticed from the testimony that it was
not until the vear 1918 that the company condescended to
try and save some money in its boiler house operations
by putting in a limited number of automatic stokers. It
now has + hand-fired boilers and 2 with automatic stokers
(Ree. p. 806), Further light is thrown upon the excessive
cost of repairs in 1920 by the testimony of Elsman, who
shows that they practically rebuilt three water gas ma-
chines and charged all costs to repair account (Ree.,
p. 307).
As to further negligence in operation the testimony
of Elsman is convincing. He allowed the water in the
holder cups to freeze, which caused an accident to the gas
holder, and a lot of gas was lost (Ree., p. 3808). It is also
reasonable to suppose that this occasioned excessive re-
pairs. Further reasons for the exceedingly bad service
given to the consumers are revealed by Elsman’s testi-
mony as to the neglect of the company to provide sufi-
tient gas storage (Ree., p. 808). The lack of holders also
caused unnecessary production expense as shown by his
vatements. In addition to extra cost to make the gas
they blew into the air a lot of gas that had been made
(Ree., p. 309).
Gas Making Labor. Having given some examples of
the testimony in this case we will again refer to exhibit
44
6 and diseuss further the reported expenses. On the first
page we see the item of “Gas Making Labor.” The testi.
mony shows that it is not really all gas making labor but
includes boiler labor aud a lot of other miscellaneous
labor around the plant. There is also testimony’ that
labor of another sort is ineluded with some of the ma.
terials. We submit that the Court ean form no reasonable
judgment from the evidence as to whether or not the
amount of gas making or other labor is reasonable. Itis
very evident from the testimony, as already abstracted,
that the operation of the water gas machines was exceed.
ingly bad. Gas machines that should be cleaned every
1.000 hours of operation were allowed to run for away
over 5,000 hours without being let down. One might just
as well expect an automobile to run 5 vears without hay.
ine the earbon removed from the eyvlinders. Efficiency
could not possibly exist in a plant operated as this one
was. Repairs. The evidence all. points to the fae!
that repairs account has been inflated away beyoui
all reason by more than one cause. In the first place, a
vood deal of that undertaken in this plant is known to the
industry as deferred maintenance. Some of it is in the
nature of depreciation which should be spread over a
number of years. Other parts of it relate solely to im
provements and betterments that shoud be charged to
capital account.
Concerning the inefficiency of this plant we have the
evidence of J. B. Klumpp, a witness ealled for complai:
ant, who swore that the plant was running at over capa
ity and was very dirty and inefficient. In the next few
words he shows the capacity of the plant had been reduced
25 per cent, because if was in such a dirty condition. (Ret.
p. 336). This witness also testified that althoug!
the capacity of the gas manufacturing apparatus Was
9,600,000 feet per day and the company had been making
as high as 7,000,000 feet per day, the purifying capacity
45
and condenser area was only sufficient for 5,000,000 feet
per day. He also said the transmission main was too
gall and required more steam for operation than should
have been used. He further asserted the gas was go-
ing out on the system at too high a temperature and
caused deposits in the mains (Ree., p. 341). Can it be
yondered at that this complainant reports it is not able to
make gas and sell it at the reasonable price fixed by the
Legislature.
Klumpp is the man who testified at another time that
the complainant could not carry through last winter, and
he seemed to be quite anxious to show why his prog-
nostication had not been fulfilled (Ree., p. 339). It is to
be remembered that the company has been crying “Wolf”
for several years and is still doing business.
The witness Klumpp, claiming to be an expert, was
asked concerning the boiler fuel shown on Exhibit 6,
and stated in reply that 18.8 pounds of “boiler fuel is
high compared to what I would consider good, efficient
operations” (Ree., p. 353). He evidently did not know
what he was talking about because the boiler fuel is away
over 18.8 pounds when the tar is taken into considera-
tion, being in fact over 21 pounds per 1,000 feet of gas
made, This omission by the witness was apparent to
the Master (Ree., pp. 355-6).
The basis for determining whether or not the rate
prescribed by statute is confiscatory must include con-
sideration of the management of the property.
In the Master’s finding, number 4 (Ree., p. 29), he
refers to the capacity of the production plant as it re-
lates to the water gas machines and says that “It is cus-
tomary in efficiently operated companies manufacturing
the same kind of gas as that manufactured by the com-
plainant to estimate actual working capacity as the rated
capacity less the capacity of the largest machines. This is
done because efficient management requires the constant
46
repairing of machines * Tt is on reeord in this
ease that the management failed to let down the ma.
chines once each 600 hours of working effort, but that
it allowed the machines to operate continuously for pe.
riods longer than 5.000 hours without cleaning the
checker bricks, repairing the hot valves, or relining the
generator at the clinkering zone. Under the cireun.
staness it is bevond all dispute that the plant has not
been efficiently operated) or even reasonably — well
managed.
Under finding 7 (Ree. p. 29) the Master reports that
“there has been a steady increase from 1915 to 1920 in
the consumption of gas furnished by the complainant re-
quiring complainant to increase its manufacturing and
distributing facilities ae
We submit that there is not one word in the record
to show that the cemplainant has since 1915 increased
the manufacturing facilities. Even if there were evi
denee to show that additional production units have been
installed, we claim that the testimony of complainant's
own Witnesses is that the production plant is away be-
vond the capacity of the cleaning machinery and the
vard connections, We further assert there has been no
increase in such cleaning and handling facilities, and it
stands to reason that this manufacturing plant is of no
greater capaeity and has no facilities in excess of the
minimum equipment in its production plant. Does it
do any good if you ean make 7 million feet of erude gas
per day but can only treat it at the rate of 5 million feet
per day. If a plant cannot condense the gas that is
produced, so as to remove the unstable elements before
they get out into the distribution system, will it not re
sult in a stoppage of the gas piping and connections be-
tween the machines? The record shows that very thing
happened.
47
Complainant has sufficient production capacity, but
the yard connections, condensers, scrubbers, boilers and
other auxiliary equipment is away below the production
capacity. If complainant had exercised foresight in the
design and selection of its plant equipment, making it
balance one apart with the other, the present situation
would not have been reached. One might just as well say
toa man with an obsolete automobile “IT will fix you up
with a new and more powerful engine, but you must
endeavor to run along during the balance of the vear on
three wheels, because [T cannot get you a new wheel in less
than 18 months.”
The testimony shows that in 1919 the water gas
generator produced more gas than the rest of the equip-
ment could handle, and some of the gas had, therefore,
to be blown into the air.
The complainant alone is responsible for this eondi-
tion, The Courts have invariably ruled that the selec-
tion of plant is solely within the control of the company,
it being unheard of that a regulatory body should sub-
titute its judgment, on the matter of plant design and
capacity, for that of the trained executives of the eom-
pany.
But the courts have never held that gas consumers
nust bear the burden of excessive costs due to incompe-
tent or inefficient management.
The complainant repeatedly asserts that it has been
wable to secure money for extensions. How did it
get, and for what useful end did it dispose of $225,000
that was made available to it “after August, 1919,” as
related by witness Gounnod (Ree. p. 675)? See
Findings of the Master, No. 39 (Ree., p. 38),
in which it is established that. the complainant has
lad Ide. per thousand cubie foot sold since July
11916. Further, the Master in his opinion refers to
®
48
an order of August 7, 1918, permitting plaintiff to with.
draw funds and to further cease from impounding
the Ide. per M. eubie feet. This sum has been ey.
pended for improvements and the total amount had
by the company in excess of the statutory rate is now
approximately $650,000.00, We are confident that if the
stockholders’ property is in jeopardy, they will take ade.
quate steps to protect it, because they are aware ay
enormous amount of new business had been ruthlessy
turned away and that the company refused to sel] any
additional quantities of gas, or of appliances on which
large profits can be made. Conditions for the eon
sumers eannot be any worse than they now are. The
Master reports that since 1915 the sales of gas har:
increased LOO) per cent, (Ree. p. BO). Tle also reports
that the company reduced the price of gas to Goce. per
thousand feet on July 1, 1914 (Ree. pool). At that time,
presumably, it was making huge protits, because it couli
afford to eut the rate for the gas. It should then hav
secured new capital It ought to have laid its plans
build new plant to take care of the greatly increasing
demands. It did not do so. It has only itself to blau
if it is now in a precarious position.
The testimony of Mr. Merrifield) (Ree. pp. 8i25
shows that the Public Service Commission ordered th:
complainant to make additions to its plant in order the
it be in a position to take care of its consumers,
Plant Capacity. Finally in reference to the matter
plant capacity and reasonable production costs we reter
to Miller's testimony that the whole plant needs extent
ing and changing, exeept the water gas generators (Ree,
p. 410). Also, other witnesses testified that they needed
two new water gas generators. Miller also admittel
that all the connections between the gas machines er
49
too small to take care of even the present capacity of the
water gas machines (Ree., p. 405). He then contradicted
jimself by saying that the plant was all right if they had
wailable some extra holder capacity (Ree., pp. 407-8).
He afterwards further contradicted his testimony by
aving the boilers are not nearly sufficient for the pur-
nse (Ree. p. 409).
We cannot see how anyone reading the testimony
anarrive at any other conclusion than that since this
tatute Was enacted there has been a deliberate attempt
yon the part of the management of the company to
anormally and unnecessarily increase its expenses so
gto assist it in striking down the statute.
The Pubhe Service Commission, 2nd District of New
York, said as follows in Breen v. Northern New York
(tilities, Ine., P. U. R., 1921, B. 463:
“The Commission realizes that to a very large
extent the policy of the utility as to whether or not
salaries shall be liberal or otherwise, and the pro-
portion of the earnings which shall be devoted to
various departments of the business, must be left
to the judgment of the directors of the company,
and that such judgment may not be supplanted by
that of the Commission. But unless there is some
limit to the application of this doctrine, and it is
to be held that the Commission can not criticise ex-
penditure on the ground that it is excessive, the
power to regulate rates is greatly circumscribed.”
This reasonable limitation of expenditures must, in
cases of this kind, be imposed by the courts, or else the
power to invalidate legislation, including rates, passes
uevitably from the public authorities into the hands of
tle owners of public utilities.
av
The operation of a public utility is a business withj,
the scope of government. The company’s plant is af
fected by a public use; the company has, in a qualified
sense, taken upon itself a governmental function, and js
therefore, bound in the conduct of its business to scrupn-
lously regard the rights of the public equally with js
own,
We earnestly ask the Court to consider these facts
No reward should be bestowed upon newliwenee. Are the
consumers, With hands tied by the monopolistic charac.
ter of this business, to be bled financially after being in.
conventeneed and imposed Upon hy the foisting on then
of a spurious article?) We have too much faith in ou
courts to believe so.
-
ol
POINT VI.
The record shows that the case was disposed of
with “undue haste”; the appellants having no op-
portunity to prepare their defense.
The complainant had its experts ready to testify after
many months of preparation.
The witnesses who testified for it were interested
witnesses; either employees like Elsman and Gounnod,
or men like Miller, of the Bartlett-Llayward Company,
and Klumpp, of the United Gas Improvement Company,
who are affiliated with it in a business way; while those
called by the defendant were disinterested.
The Master would not accept testimony tending to
show that it was impossible for the Public Service Com-
mission to make an examination of the complainant’s
records und give testimony to protect the gas consumers
and the publie (Ree., p. 901).
The Commission had under its jurisdiction about 100
public utility corporations, and it is manifestly impos-
sible for it to keep in close touch with each one of them,
lue to its limited staff of engineers and accountants.
The record discloses inordinate celerity in disposing
f the case before the Master; it supports a charge that
there Was undue haste—more than “convenient speed”
—in the examination of witnesses, in failure to obtain
exhaustive information of the company’s financial his-
ory and the real facts behind its alleged financial plight.
The result is unfair to the public;
We quote in detail from the testimony of Robert H.
Mitchell, a witness for the defense (Ree., p. 923) to
show lack of opportunity to offer proof in behalf of the
lefense and further, the Master’s misunderstanding of
1 NS
tei
the scope of the issues in the case at bar (we begin g
page 920):
“Q. And vou are acquainted with the plaintiffs
plant there and the business in a general way, ar
you not? A. Yes, | have resided in that same ward
for over twenty vears,
(). And can you state, in reference to this lit.
cation, how long it would take for vou, with sar
two assistants, to make a complete investigating
of the company’s accounts for the purpose of ip.
forming yourself properly upon litigation of this
kind?
Mr. Moran: I object to that.
The Master: Objection sustained.
Mr. Jackson: Exception.
Q. Now, what did you ascertain? Did yon as
certain anything in regard to the repairs of the
plaintiff?
The Master: He has just stated personally
that he has only spenta little part, a small par
of a day, as LT understand it, cousidering this
question, and gave it up. So T don’t suppos
that his testimony could possibly be of any as
sistance to the Court in this case,
- 7 * * * * °
(). What steps do you consider necessary and
proper in analyzing and ascertaining the reason.
ableness or unreasonableness of expenditures, aud
in addition what factors do you take into account
in carrying on any such investigation?
The Master: Do vou object, Mr. Moran?
Mr. Moran: Oh, I don’t see what it has got
to do in the reeord,
The Master: Objection sustained.
Mr. Jackson: Exception.
* - * 7 * 7 ®
(). Have you made a detailed examination of
the charges to repairs made by the company dur
f
53
ing the years 1918 to 1919 and the first six months
of 1920?
The Master: You can answer that.
A. [have not. It is impossible, as I have stated
before, to undertake a thorough analysis along
the lines of proper procedure, which requires not
only analyzing operating expenses, but analyzing
the fixed capital accounts to find out that the items
included in operating expenses are properly
chargeable to operating expense, that they are rea-
sonable and necessary.
Mr. Moran: Just a moment, Mr. Mitchell.
T move to strike out the answer, and I object to
the question.
The Master: I will let him state that he has
not, and that it is impossible to do it within
the day’s time that he spent on the case.
* hal * * - - e
Mr. Jackson: Now, of course, that is limit-
ed—your Honor limits it to the time that he has
spent on the case (at page 926).
Q. Was it possible to do that within the time
that has been available to prepare this case? A.
Absolutely impossible.
Mr. Moran: I object to that.
The Master: Objection sustained. There is
no evidence before the Court as to how much
time there was available to prepare for this
case,
Q. May I ask you, how long it would take to
make such examination?
Mr. Moran: Objected to on all the grounds,
and I ask the Court to admonish the counsel
to cease to take any time of the Court and
counsel in this matter.
The Master: Oh, I will let him state that,
from such an examination as he has made.
ot
A. To properly conduct an examination of the
operating expenses, and correspondingly and con-
currently to carry on investigation of the fixed
capital expenditures for the years 1918 and 1919
and the six months of 1920, would take three en.
gineers approximately four months Working gop.
tinuously,
The Master: You have had just about that
time since this ease was brought (at page 027)
The Witness: Well, your Honor, if T mar
be permitted to state that we have been under
undue pressure, with the limited appropriation
and with fifteen cases pending in the courts
involving gas rate litigations, and in addition
before the Commission—Long Island Railroad
rate case, the Manhattan & Queens Traetion
Corporation——
The Master: Well, [do not think you need
to ¢o.
The Witness: And several other railway
and lighting matters within the city.
The Witness: Tam not discussing the ques.
tion of the rate base. These are elements in-
volving the question of whether operating ex-
penses
Mr. Jackson: TI think, if the Master
please —
The Master: Just a minute. T insist upon
being allowed to ask any question T please,
Mr, Jackson: LT object to the witness being
stopped, either by counsel or the Master, before
he can answer the question,
The Master: Your statement then, when
you said vou have to analyze eapital account,
would be unnecessary in this ease, wouldn't it!
The Witness: Exeept to the extent to find
out and ascertain whether there had been an
inflation in operating expenses and a corre
|
59
sponding deflation in fixed capital, due to the
company charging into operating expenses
items of cost of physical property which were
properly allocatable to the other class (at page
928).
The Master: Well, you could examine that
by looking into your operating expense, you
don’t have to go into capital expense. You
would not object if they charged into capital
expenses operating expenses, would you?
The Witness: Well, your Honor, you do not
find right on the face of the records of the eom-
pany. A value is given showing repairs to an
account. In order to properly analyze that
money value, it is necessary to identify the
property represented by that expenditure, I
which requires i
The Master: Well, T am not going into that. f
The Witness: Which requires going back
through this system of records. This is just a |
general line, following the records right back r
to the original source, consulting the men that
were on the ground when the construction work
was performed, and ascertaining if that par-
ticular work was done and whether it is put
under a name that it should not be put under,
like repairing mains when it is constructing
new mains.
The Master: T am not going into the ques-
tion of whether there has been adequate time
to prepare this case any further (at page
928)
id iad * * * baal @
Mr. Jackson: Ts your Honor going to ex-
clude all other considerations than the fact that
he said it should take four months? Did your
Honor also consider that it would take two
engineers with him, and that there are 18 rate
cases pending, and that there is not any such
force at the command of the Publie Service
Commission? Now, that is what I offer.
56
The Master: I also considered the fact that
he included 1918, which is not pertinent to this
inquiry.
Q. Then T will limit you, I will ask you a ques.
tion within, and limit your considerations to the
vears 1919 and 1920.
The Master: I won't take any further ey.
dence from this witness on this point (at pages
928-929). :
* - . * so a e
Mr. Jackson: You have made an investiga.
tion regarding this plamtiff in regard to its re.
pairs per cubic foot, as stated upon its sched.
ules in evidence.
A. T have examined the schedules,
Q. And what is the result of that, please?
Mr. Moran: Oh, just a moment now.
©. What do vou find in regard to it?
c
Mr. Moran: The exhibits speak for them-
selves.
Mr. Jackson: Oh, they speak part way and
part way they are silent. Now [ would like
to give another opportunity for them to speak
through this witness (at page 930).
- ~~ ~ * ~ *- a
The Witness: I would like to save the time,
if there is a question in vour mind, and counsel
then could proceed with questions along the
line, to give vou what I thought would enlighten
the record on some of these questions. My tes
timony naturally would be as an engineer who
has been identified through all the phases of
examination of capital and operating expend
tures for the Commission, to find out whether
they are properly inecludable, to find out whether
they are deferred repairs or excessive repairs
due to the abnormal conditions that prevailed.
such as occurred in the gas companies in the
o7
last winter—frozen mains and subway con-
struction requiring relocation of mains, and
several other exceptional items that come up.
Now, as the result of that, in all this extensive
work of many hundreds of million dollars
worth of expenditures handled by this Com-
mission, we have collected data showing the re-
pairs per thousand. Some of these companies’
expenditures have been closely analyzed, others
are not. Official reeords filed with the Com-
mission show certain costs per thousand cubie
feet.
Now, differences in those costs have natur-
ally led us to analyze to see what a figure really
means, when you say repairs per thousand,
and likewise investment per thousand eubie
feet. It has led to conclusions which show that
it is unsound to rely on any such data which
does not exactly represent a condition than ean
be used as a basis and taken judicial notice of
and subsequently used in a late proceeding.
Now, if
Mr. Moran: Well, just a moment, now, I
object (at pages 930-931).
* * * * * * *
Now, Mr. Mitchell, your study of this mat-
ter as to the rate per thousand eubie feet, ap-
plied to any item that you have in mind—re-
pairs, say, of the plaintiff—showing for the ex-
penses of either 1919 or 1920, which ever one
you have in mind, and tell us what the result
will be?
The Master: Answer the question.
A. Well, for example, repairs to meters of
this company as shown in the annual reports of
the Commission for the year 1919, were 22,-
900.98. In the year 1918 the repairs were
$11,595.55, or an inerease of approximately 91.5
per cent. in actual dollars. Now, in examining to
find out what is a fair amount for repairs for
meters, when you eleminate it to a specified period
apne
oman
58
of time, necessarily calls for an inquiry into the
fact. ‘Were these meters, meters which were yuo
essarily repaired in that year, or did they inelade
a great number of meters which the company had
deferred repairing due to the peculiar econo).
conditions existing?’ If such a faet exists, it pro.
duced an abnormal figure in this particular vear,
Likewise, the same might be said of any othe
item. Now, if repairs in this particular vear had
increased 15 per cent. the corresponding increas.
in sales might be entirely out of proportion. The
year Goes not represent a normal vear unless it js
examined and found to be. The cents per thoy.
sand cubie feet for repairs is dependent upon ths
condition of equipment at the beginning of th:
particular vear—whether there has been deferred
repairs, whether there has been exceptional mr.
pairs which can be explained away due to the ty
factors, which is increase in labor and material,
and also another factor which is the personal o.
ficieney of the working force at the present tine,
Brietly, T mean te say simply this: You mar
find in a particular vear, considering the plat
operating normally and in a good operating eo
dition and with the company having looked for.
ward with every adequate equipment such as r
serve generating equipment, with capacity o
mains, capable of earrving ten times the amou:
of gasvand in good repair—that the sales may in
erease 30 per eent. and the repairs over the whol
system micht not increase 10 per cent. And thet
would be dependent on studving and seeing whe
the actual conditions are. Likewise, T believe, to
draw an analogous ease, on the question of fixed
capital in the same wayv—and plant (at page 933),
* * * sal * * e
The Witness: Simply as an example. If w
found this particular company at this time wih
per cent. excess generating capacity and wit
equipment maintained in the best operating co:
dition, and correspondingly the rest of the in
vestment in underground system, mains, services
59
meters—with the mains laid out so that they are
adequate to take care of the growth for vears to
eome—which is always the effort of a company, to
try to anticipate future growth—if a condition
like that exists, that there is an investment there
which will be able to take care of the company’s
gas consumers for a number of years with a slight
increase in the investment.
So that, whereas today vou may find as a mat-
ter of fact that the investment is $5 per thousand
eubie feet sold, we will say, inside of the next year
the sales may increase 25 per cent., but due to
the adequacy of the generator equipment and the
adequacy and capacity of the mains for carrying
a given volume of gas within distribution pres-
sures permitted by this Commission, that for the
increase of 25 per cent. in sales there may be 5
per cent. or 10 per cent. or even smaller a cor-
responding increase in the investment. So, as the
ratio is a fluctuating ratio and at one time may
mean nothing, and further taking this company
right under the present conditions that exist to-
day, any figure predicated upon an investment per
thousand cubie feet at this time—and I do not
happen to know offhand what was the sales last
year, or the generator—but vou are, as I under-
stand, from the testimony of previous witnesses,
which has been fairly well substantiated all
through the record—that you are up to the limit
of your rated capacity and almost reaching the
point where it is difficult to maintain the ade-
quacy of your service and reliability of vour serv-
ice, Now, you are about to—and if conditions
permit vou would like to make a big additional
investment in generating plant equipment in the
next vear. What would happen with a growth ex-
penditure of many thousands of dollars to inerease
your generating capacity, perhaps inerease vour
holder capacity, restrenethen vour distribution
network of mains, by making extensions, and
increasing sizes perhaps in certain sections?
A big expenditure like that amounting to a great
60
deal of money, incurred in a particular year and
With a very slight inerease in sales, would be work.
ing an injustice to the company if predicated at
the present time on an investment per thousand
_ ee ** Cat page 934).
Considering the inability of the Public Service Com.
mission to put in serviceable information by reason of
lack of available time to examine into the operations of
the company now or for any other period, the absenee of
any direet evidence from the Attorney General's depart.
ment, and the exclusion by the Master of all evidence re.
lating to operating results prior to L9L9, it is respectfully
submitted that the record is incomplete.
61
VII.
For the purpose of making a fair test of the stat-
ute, the period found is altogether too brief.
The statute should not be declared confiscatory upon
the results obtained in a vear and a half of abnormal
times, When prices had reached their highest level.
The Period to Which the Master Erroneously Confined
the Testimony.
The Master declined to take any testimony as to the
operating expenses, ete., for the years prior to 1919
(Defts. Ex. D23b and D24 for Iden., Ree., pp. 1102-1103).
He was undoubtedly influenced by the opinion of
Judge Haxp in Consolidated Gas Co, vy. Newton, 267 Fed.,
931, who predicted that high prices would remain for
at least five years,
The Master took evidence over a period of eighteen
months, from January 1, 1919, to June 30, 1920.
He said (Finding 28, Ree., p. 36):
“Present prices are so far as can he judged
abnormal and are results of the World War.”
The Period Decided by Judge Hough to be the Proper
Test.
There are several aspects of Judge Hoveu’s decision
of what is the proper period for a test, which make it
impossible to agree with his conelusions.
The Master said (Finding No. 38, Ree., pp. 37-38) :
“The evidence adduced before me affords no
reasonable grounds for expecting that the price
of materials or the wages paid to labor in connec-
62
tion with the production of gas will be redneed
during the last few months of 1920 or during the
vear 1921.”
His report was filed on September 22, 1920, and soon
thereafter a reversal in trade conditions took place which
was unparalleled ino history and beyond the wildes,
dreams of business men in the summer of 1920, when the
peak of prices had been reached.
Since the entry of the decree in the instant case, steel
plants, textile mills, railroads, express companies and
other industries have been readjusting war intlatioy
Wages, cutting War inflation production Costs, and lower
ing War inilation prices. These events are of commoy
knowledge; and they are, therefore, matters of whic)
this Court will take judicial notice,
The rights of gas consumers are as sacred as the
rights of gas producers. Relief is in sight for all pro.
ducers. The peak of high prices las been passed. The
coal used in the manufacture of gas which a few months
ago Was sold tor ten aud twelve dollars a ton has recently
been offered at tive dollars a ton and as low as two dol-
lars aton. Prices of food and clothing are coming down,
This means that the rate of wages will be reduced, as the
purchasing power of the dollar is restored to something
like its pre-war state. Yet, in spite of the general te-
deney downward of all the materials used in the produe-
tion and distribution of gas, the company is asking for
higher rates. Claim is made that it is losing money daily
and that no company liowever strong can sustain such a
loss for a considerable period. No one is inclined to dis
pute this proposition.
In the past it was possible to manufacture and dix
tribute gas for about 45e. per LOOU cu. feet, this left doc
63
to 50 cents to the company to pay overhead expenses and
dividends. In the last few vears the earnings are claimed
tohave fallen short of funds enough to pay dividends. A
reduction in the dividends would affect the profits of the
shareholders; their trustees and directors would preter
that the people should pay a higher price for gas rather
than that the profits should be reduced. The defendants
who are the trustees of the people should be as solicitous
of the interests of the people as the directors are of the
interests Of their shareholders. When the gas corpora-
tion's profits are threatened, the officers of that corpora-
tion have no hesitation in commencing suits to declare the
statute confiscatory,
This company has suffered no loss by reason of the
drop in value of its materials on hand and has not been
subject to any of the troubles which confronted the busi-
uess men of the country in this period of transition back
to the pre-war days.
A survey in the interests of fairness should be made
of the profits made since the law went into effect and
should not be contined to the business of the company
during the past year or so of abnormal times. It should
go back to the time of the enactment of the statute and
should disclose the profits made in the early vears when
it cost only 45e. per thousand eu. feet to produce gas in
order that the earnings of the company may be ascer-
tained for every year from the beginning and so that the
probable profits in the future may be computed. Then
facts will be available from which an opinion may be
drawn concerning the propriety of going to the relief of
the company in the present temporary and disappearing
crisis. The mere fact that the company claims to be los-
ug money is not sufficient to Justify the demand for an
64
increased rate. Tf it should appear after investigation
that the average profits are reasonable then the demand
for the increase will not have a leg to stand on. The stat.
ute should not be declared contiscatory so that the extra
nioney should ro to the shareholders as dividends to in-
crease the value of their shares and to make protits for
speculators in those shares,
As this question has been covered at some length jp
the briefs submitted by the appellants in the Consolidated
Gas case We shall not endeavor to burden the Court with
a repetition of the argument advanced.
65
VIII.
The statute is presumed to be constitutional. The
burden of proof is on the complainant to prove the
contrary beyond a reasonable doubt.
The higher Courts, both State and Federal, have laid
the greatest emphasis upon the quality of proof which
must be adduced by those who assail a statute as uncon-
stitutional. These decisions have a peculiar aptness when
considered in the light of the meagre minimum of testi-
mony presented by complainant.
Tn Willcox v. Consolidated Gas Co., 212, U. S., 19, this
Court said at page 41:
“The rates must be plainly unreasonable to the
extent that their enforcement would be equivalent
to the taking of property for public use without
such compensation as under the circumstances is
just, both to the owner and the public (citing San
Diego Land and Town Co. y. National City, 174
U.S., 739, 757; Same v. Jasper, 189 U, S., 439,
442).
The case must be a clear one before the Courts
ought to be asked to interfere with State legisla-
tion upon the subject of rates, especially before
there has been any experience of the practical re-
sult of such rates. In this ease, the rates have not
been enforeed as yet, because the bill herein was
filed and an injunction obtained restraining their
enforcement before they came into actual opera-
tion.
Upon a careful consideration of the ease before
us, we are of opinion that the complainant has
failed to sustain the burden cast upon it of showing
beyond any just or fair doubt that the acts of the
Legislature of the State of New York are in fact
confiseatory.” (Italics ours.)
Without making extended quotations from the author-
ities, we may state they uphold the following proposi-
tions:
1. The burden of proving that the statute is unconstity.
tional is upon him who asserts it.
2. This burden must be sustained by evidence which
establishes the complainant's case beyond a fair, clear
just, rational or reasonable doubt.
Sad
will not be
est cases,
In the de
Supreme Co
ante, Mr. Ju
“Tt
that in rate eases the burden is on the plaintifi «
establish confiscation beyond doubt.”
B.-<
The judicial power of declaring laws unconstitutional
66
» exercised by this Court except in the clear.
Detroit United Railway v. Detroit, 248 U.S,
442;
Kea rille Bs Ninos rille Wate r ('o., oi2 U. S.,
Ss
Minnesota Rate Cases, 230 U.S., 352, 499;
In re Young, 209 U.S., 123, 165;
Atkinson Ry. Co.v. UL S., 232 ULS., 199, 221;
Lincoln Gas Co. v. Lincoln, 223 U.S., 357;
Des Moines Gas Co. v. Des Moines, 238
U. S., 153, 163;
Railroad Commissioners of Louisiana y,
Cumberland Tel. & Tel. Co., 212 U.S,
oo
wd 5
Shepard vy. Northern Pacific R. R. Co., 1%
Fed. Rep., 165;
Palatka Water Works Co. v. Palatka, 13
Fed. Rep., 161;
Sinking Fund Cases, 99 U. S., 700, 718;
Fletcher v. Peck, 6 Cranch (star page), 125;
Montana Wid S. RL Co. vy. Morley, 198 Fed
Rep., 991.
ision in the ease tried in the New York
urt, Aings County Lighting Co. v. Lewy,
stice GREENBAUM said:
must, however, always be borne in mind
67
IX.
Complainant’s books of account, erroneously ad-
mitted in evidence over defendants’ objections and
exceptions, are not prima facie proof of their con-
tents.
In admitting the books in evidence the Master felt he
was bound by the decision of Judge Haxp in the Consoli-
dated Gas ease (ante), whieh Was based on the ides that
the books had been kept in accordance with the Uniform
System of Accounts.
‘He said (p. 39), “the hooks * * * have been kept in
conformity with said rules and regulations with one ex-
ception,” :
The appellants pointed out many other respects in
which the accounts differed with those prescribed by the
Public Service Commission,
* * Sl
The books admitted are transcripts of other hooks,
records and papers, many of which were not proven or
even produced,
The witness for complainant admitted that complain-
aut does not keep an account required by the Uniform
System of Accounts, and the Master said( Ree., p. 39):
“Complainant company does not keep an ac-
count entitled ‘General Amortiziation—Gas’ which
is an account required by the Public Service Com-
mission * * #9
Even if all the figures and computations that are on
the books of the complainant are correct and exact, the
distribution of these figures from the vouchers still re-
Mains a matter open to discussion between experts who
re sincere in their views as to the proper distribution
it them.
The fact that accountants have found the computa-
ions, meaning by that the additions, subtractions, divi-
we"
68
sions, and multiplications entered on the various ae.
counts, to be correct, is no proot that the accounts them.
selves have not been sophisticated by a wrong distribu.
tion of the amounts of the vouchers, or that the cost of
gas has not been sophisticated by a subsequent incorrect
distribution of these accounts.
It is not possible for a mere neeountant, familiar only
with figures, and unfamilar with the practical processes
of was making, to authoritatively determine the distribu.
tion of vouchers to accounts, Mor, assuming these voucl.
ersers to have been properly distributed, to determine the
proper accounts, which should go to operating Cost, aud
which should go to capital or investment account,
As this question has been discussed fully in the briefs
filed by the appellants in the Consolidated case we wil
not attempt to do so once more,
69
X.
Rate of Return.
The Court erred in its finding that 8 per cent. was
aproper rate of return.
It is well recognized both by the companies in rate
regulation cases and by the financial community in ordi-
nary commercial transactions, that what is a fair return
upon in investment is not a fixed rule. It depends
great part upon the character of the enterprise. Thus,
business men consider a railroad stock earning a certain
rite is Worth par, while they would demand a much
jigher return upon the par value of the so-called indus-
vies. The risk assumed and the likelihood that the prop-
ety would continue to earn an adequate profit are always
wntrolling factors of such valuation. This faet is im-
wortant in the present ease,
| Utility corporations of all kinds are not subject to the
ame risk a8 is the average business for the reason that
tey are, practically speaking, free trom competition and
uder proper regulation are in fact guaranteed a rea-
vuable return,
Itis no reply to assert that a person could not organ-
weanew gas company ona 6 per cent. basis. We are not
wiling with new companies just starting out in a small
(ity or endeavoring to compete in a large city.
We are dealing with a company whose rates eannot
learbitrarily reduced below a minimum of profit, and the
yroperty has and always will have a value which it would
wt possess if thrown on a serap heap.
Although the Court may consider that the company
Senittlo’ to earn some return on even that portion of its
ant which has been built up out of profits, vet surely the
Court would not consider so high a return Just upon capi-
70
tal thus accumulated as upon capital direetly contributed
by stockholders, ‘This is more likely to be the opinion of
the Court if it find, as it surely will, first, that the com.
pany has paid good dividends for over twenty years;
and, second, that if the gas companies had undertaken to
divide much larger profits than they did they probably
would have attracted so much publie attention as long ago
as to have precipitated urgent demands for a reduction in
the price of gas.
Section 72 of the Public Service Commissions Law of
the State of New York reads in part as follows:
conn with due regard, among other things,
toa reasonable arerage return Upon capital actu:
ally expended and to the necessity of making reser-
vations out of income for surplus and contin
gencies.”
A gas company does not usually exhibit to the public
too exorbitant prolits on its actual investment. by its
stockholders. Can it then conceal from the public these
profits by putting them in the plant and vet expect the
Court to allow it as high a return on the investment as
if the cost of the property had been paid for direetly by
the stockholders?
In general it will be acknowledged by business men
that any addition to 6 per cent. interest or profit on
moneys invested is because of more than ordinary risks
in business. When the percentage on interest or div:
dend on any given investment drops below 6 per cent. the
reduction of interest rates is due to the unusual satety
of the investment.
The question of the risks of the business is the con:
trolling factor in the determination of the percentage of
divisible profit which may be expected from gas works.
Notwithstanding the fact that accidents and_ explo
sions have occurred in other large cities there was pro
v1
duced no evidence showing any extraordinary danger or
quy relatively heavy loss on the part of the complainant,
which goes to show that gas making on the average when
properly conducted is one of the safest and most stable of
businesses,
The monopolistic feature of public service corpora-
tions, especially in the present case, where a duplication
of gas piping would result in an intolerably increased
burden upon the City streets, is another important fea-
ture to be considered as tending to increase the sec urity
of the investment of the complainant company,
This Court has held that public service corporations,
asa matter of law, are not entitled to any fixed rate of
return. What is a reasonable rate must depend upon the
creumstances of each ease.
The complainant has paid good dividends since its
start, and in addition it has built a considerable portion
of its plant out of its earnings. These facts will nat-
urally lead the Court to recognize as reasonable a lower
rate of return than if the plant had been entirely con-
structed out of stock and bond issues.
ae
-~]
to
CONCLUSION.
The judgment should be reversed, the bill of
complaint dismissed, and judgment rendered in
favor of the appellanis, with costs.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHN P. OOBRIEN,
Corporation Counsel,
Solicitor for Appellant, Harry E. Lewis,
District Attorney of the County of Kings,
Municipal Building,
New York.
James A. DoNNELLY,
Harry Herrzorr,
of Counsel.
[3027]
a
Suprel
CHARLES
New Y;
Commi’
and H!
SINGS CO
ILBER W
the bill of
¢ndered in
‘>
sel,
seWis,
f Kings,
. Building,
New York,
\ a aot
> ~,
ee Oe me |
' OCT 4 199]
upreme Court of the United States Z
?- .
October Term, 1921
No. 295
HARLES D. NEWTON, as Attorney-General of the State of
New York; LEWIS NIXON, constituting the Public Service
Commission of the State of New York, for the First District :
and HARRY E. LEWIS, as District Attorney of Kings County,
; Appellants.
against
NGS COUNTY LIGHTING COMPANY,
Respondent.
fF ON BEHALF OF APPELLANT NEWTON, AS ATTORNEY-
GENERAL OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
CHARLES D. NEWTON,
Attorney-General
of the State of New York
Capitol, Albany, N. Y.
WILBER W. CHAMBERS,
Solicitor for
Appellant Attorney-General :
Capitol, Albany, N. Y.
BER W. CHAMBERs,
RES E. BUCHNER,
of Counsel
INDEX TO POINTS
Prior adjudieation requires a dismissal of the bill of com
plaint
Il.
The burden of proof is on the respondent to establish
hevond a reasonable doubt the unconstitutionality af the
statute In que Thon
Respondent should experiment with the rate fixed by tle
statute ‘ re it ds wassatled as CoOmscatery
IV.
Respondent came inte this court. of equity admitting that
it had vielated the Jaw assailed and with the fact
established that it had persistently, flagrantly and
the said daw im that it) had = net
nvitmers the quality of gas specified in
the aeto it question For that reasen alone the bill of
mplaint should have been dismissed
deliberately Vie
supplied toy its
The consumer slonld net be charged with the unreasonable,
excessive and mwarranted Loss ot vas allowed hey the court
nd matster as “oumaeceounted for owas
VI.
The “fair value of respondent's property was fixed by
stipulation between the parties at S3.300.000. This sam
could not property be augmented by the master for the
future needs of the companys
VIL.
The statute in question should mot he declared contis« ators
merely upeu the financial returns obtained im one or two
abnormal years disregarding protits in all prior years
Writ,
here is such a nonioinder of parties defendant as to make
a determination of the contise atery character of the 1t6
statuie impossible of determination in this action. .
LX.
The respondent did not) sustain) the burden of proving
that the statute im question was contiscatery. The hooks
f the company and tabulations compiled from them were
Improperly admitted and did not mect the requirements
of proof cast upon the respondent Bras
a
The proof discloses that the respondent's plant was net
operated ino an efficient and economical manner and that
gross ineflicioney and mismanagement added ert atly to the
proper cost of making and distributine its gas
PAGE
OF
Reece creer cts ee eco chee |
Phe court and
--
-_-
XT.
master erred in not deducting Mahy improper
items from: respondent’s alleged operating: costs
NIt.
Resersible crrors were committed in) the admission
exclusion of evidence
Conelusien
SUBJECT INDEX
Abnormal pertod, valueless in rate making ot. 51. 54, 37
An-wers. defendants
Auditing: expense
Baill of complaint
Books underdying lata
Books and eee rd. loss of
Pooks= ret capable of being checked by regulating be
Reaks, accuracy of
Books. improperly admitted
British Thermal Units. order of POS. C. relating t
British Thermal Unit-. refusal ote submit: te ord
‘ee. a “90
Barden of proof : ; !
Candle power, Wegation non complianes
(an le power, © miplaint alleges ne chat of abverdieiies
Candie power, Court) findings of violation
Candle power, Qagrant Violations 2a
Candle power, higher at works than Where required
tested
andle power,
andle power,
andle power,
~--
andle power,
Capital, ne los
City of New \
(itv of New
Coal shortages
Dectston and ft
how tested
no allegation in complaint of uaplnanes
plaintul violated statute (TTS) The
quality detined by statute
sts of :
ork. loss of rates te
ork, necessary party
ndings, State court action
Decree appealed) trom ;
wo Years... beret ; ; 4. 6,
rroin not admitting books and tabulations of
Dividends, pric
Error of miuaste
respon tent i
Error of maste
Evidence, earn
n evidence
rin refusing te call witnesses
Ings under statutory rate
Excess, moneys collected over statutory: rate
Fair value
and
bindings tasters on candle power...
Findings -- waste rate base
Findings State court action
bindings unclean liand-s ; a
Findings, weight to be given findings of miatstet and
Court
t; ol ONES Use
PAu
M0
Mil
PAGE
Improper items not deducted ratkiedl was eee ee om
Inefliciency of operations 2... ..0..66..+54556- AIP Sa
Inefhic lene of plant Lee ke a aOR ee ee aa fear 7s
Interest on funded debt. . WA ly Fe oN eee REE ee sn 66
Issues In the case ... ‘A rar eik Miktie Se KAS kOe 2, °
Judgment prior yo RS ere ee ora : se ws ‘
Non joinder at partie Roa» ESA, Pa Say eR ERE Te : 67
Oil, amount necessary to produce 22 candle power wee 27
Oil, amount used im making gas .... 2... .066 20-22. .e eee 2¢
Oil shortages ........ 2c cee eee wen eee ot a : - s1
Operations. ~heuld not he tested hy one year .. ; 53
Period te he considered . cece ca ne Oo Oe, SI, 6s. Ga
Plant inadequate ee ‘ : ‘ 78
Preliminary statement ni eae ha 3 Roe > 3
Prior adjudication, ete. ........ el eee 4 rau
Prior earnings : " ADE ae Y: ak : 6
Prior State court: action, ete... Ht ee Cee a
Prior State court action, same parties a) ee v ”
Profits. pr ior Vears : : ; = : : ’ Se oe
Rate base. elements and ‘judicial determination. ....... . he
Rate base, 1816 .. es ape vce ee aE 5 a
Rate base, 1917 : eee ae ; Phe e on
Rate of return ca o Pe kak oa Xa ee. oe
late, respondent never ope fated unger. .....5... ee Ape) |
Rate, respondent w ithout autherity collected in’ excess of
statutory bie sess ~- ty oe he Si. 30
Referee. to control return of excess tunds ’ wee
Rate base, stipulation im re * RT GS aee tie a Ce
Repairs excessive charges for re ee ek Teter ate
Res adjudicata ; malar pe Peale na escheat
Similarity ob orssues : sae ae oR 8 : hontai a ace. Ae S
BIANCA BTUIOR ss os eee a seen hes oe s
ge rt et ae ae eee ee ee 2 ee s9
Spectal master : : ee AEN Ot a Th as ee : 3
Stipulation of rate DARE 2... ocean. eeeores. “ae fi
Geet TIE SOBR. 5a 5 aks bcc Soe hee etek : : Owras SS
Summary operating costs, TT T9200 .. Rr aise KR 02,
Tar. war gas (loss)... Sere s8 en ee eC oe ere Le?
Tests, candle power by city not challenged ....0........ 23, 30
Trial, State court) action OMA ares £ ktets Rare gern ey 5A: 5
Peactuunted TOF Was... wc ea ens es 36. 38, 41,43. 44
Unaceounted for gas, abnormal Oe OO et A ere a Ae 3s
LeaCOOnniOd TOF PAS, BECRRSING 2. ki escent bees 84. 89
Unaccounted for gas. largest in metropolitan district eex 37,40
Unaccounted for gras, loss ins street = aig eee ee
Unclean hands ......... eet a B12: Si. SS. Se. Ss, «68
Uneollectible bill- oP es ty er eae eek k ccare'as 6-0
Uniform system oof accounts, not “approv: al of accounts by
consumers EK a toe wea acerere Sie Wickes kas 74
Uniform system of accounts, not co anplied Wee Na st os 10, @2
Uniform system of accounts, probative force oo. .......... 73
Violation of statute ek eet eer ee a ree ; 34
Violation of statute, master’s findings of ................ 9
Violation of statute no effort to stop respondent admits
in complacit ra nthig AS iL SK SR ale CR Mas kik ke SR eee
Violation of statute, collecting: excess of statutory rate ee
Water stock
Royle v. St. Louis R. R. Co., 222 Fed. Rep. 539. ...
Bronx Gas & Elec. Co. ve City of New York, 195 App. Diy.
054, 556- 187 N. ¥. Supp. 2.......
Carmen vo Fox Film Co., 269 Fed. Rep. 928
Chapter 125 of the Laws of 106 Ae 8:;
Chapter 604 of the Laws of 1916 ., 4.7, 8.45.33
Chapter T3360 of the Laws of 1905 ; «a | 8
Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Ro R. Co. v. Tompkins. 176
G.. BS. 26%
City of Knoxville vo Knoxville Water Co.. 212 U.S. 1 7:
"
Consolidated Gas Co. vi Newton, et al. 267) Fed. Rep. 231,
243 <n . ee ee
Darnell vo. Edwards, 244 U.S. 564 :
Des Moines Gas Co. vo Des Moines. 238 Ul oS. 155. 1620 14
Ex Parte Young, 209 UL oS. 123, 165
Greater New York Charter, City of N.Y. (see. 522
Hewsev vo Queens Borough Gas and Elec. Co. 47) Mix
Rep 360 . .
Kings County Lighting Co. vo Lewis. et al. Dl) Mise. 204
Lineoln Gas & El. Co. ve City of Lincoln, 250 US) 258 019
Lincoln Gas & El. Co. v. City of Lincoln, 223 U.S. 349
Marble Co. v. Ripley, 1 Wall. 338, 357° (10 L. Ed. 955
Medicine Co. v. Wood, 108 U. S. 218, 227 (2 Supt. 346
27 L. Ed. 706)
Michigan Pipe Co. et alive Freemont Diteh Pipe Line &
Reservoir Co., TLD Fed. 284. 287 :
Missouri v. Chicago B. & Q. Ro Co. 241 U.S. 533
Municipal Gas Co. v. P.S. C., 225 N. ¥. 88, 91 1
People ex rel. New York Railways Co. vy. P. S. C., 223 N.Y
or
37; Re
Pomeroy on Equity Jurisprudence, Srd ed. 37.
vo. ¢°. “ye te ‘ : ul,
Public Service Commissions Law, Sec. 72... ;
Public Service Commissions Law, Sees. 66. 67 28. 66, 74
Railroad Comm. v. Cumberland Tel. Co.. 212, 414, 426
Re Maintowoea Gas Co... 1 Wis. ROR. Rep. S32
San Diego Land & Town Co. v. National City, 174 U.S. 759
risyi
Same v. Jasper, ISO UL S. 439, 442
Sinking Fund Cases, 4 US. Ta0, 71s
Southern Pacitie ROR. Co. ve UL S.. 168 U,
Steenerson v. Great Northern Ry. Co.. 7
-.)
i~
Transportation Corporations Law, Sees. 63. 65
Trustees of Saratoga Springs v. Saratoga Gas Co. 122 App.
ivy. 203 (N.Y. : :
Washington ete., Packet Co. vi Sickles, 24 How. Pro 333
Williamsburg Co. Sav. Bk. ve Solon. 36 N.Y... 465
Willeox v. Consolidated Gas Co., 212 U.S. 19.013, 17, 18, 26,
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
Cuartes D. Newrox, as Attorney-
General of the State of New
York: Lewis Nixox, constitut-
ine the Publie Service Comimits-
‘ : : wre i October Term,
sion of the State of New York, 121. Ne. 295
° oa - . B ef CH) he-
for the First) District; and Sctd at tenvice
Ilanny KH. Lewis, District Attor- D. Newton, a=
ee ‘ Attorney - Gen-
nev ol ings ( ounty, eral of the
: State of New
Appellants, eck
Kixes Country Ligutrixng Conm-
PANY, Ri sponds ul,
Brict on Be haly of A ppe lant. Newton.
This is an appeal by the abeve named appel-
lants from a deeree of the United States District
Court. for the Southern District of New York
(Hon. Charles M. Tough, sitting as District
Judge presiding), entered in the office of the elerk
of said court on the 19th day of October, 1920, ad-
indging chapter 125 of the Laws of 1206 and
chapter GOF of the Laws of 1916 of the State of
New York, confiscatory and unconstitutional, and
depriving the respondent of its property, without
due process of law, contrary to the Fourteenth
Amendment of the Constitution of the United
States: and furthermore, restraining and enmjott-
ing the appellants, public officials of the State of
New York, from enforcing the provisions of the
aforesaid laws of the State of New York.
2
The laws herein referred to provided, among
other things, that the respondent company shall
not charge or receive for was manufactured, fur.
nished or sold by it in certain portions of the City
of New York to private consumers, a sum in ey.
cess of SO cents per thousand enbie fect,
ISSUES IN THE CASE
The issues in this case were, by order dated
July 31, 1920, made by Hon. John C. Knox, Dis.
trict Judwe of the United States District Court,
Southern Distriet of New York, referred to Gor.
don Auchineloss, hse., to take proot respecting
the Issues and to find and report the facts with
his conclusions and recommendations. (Pp. 24,
4s |
This being a suit to enjoin the enforcement of
a State law as uneonstitutional, the findings of
the master are not entitled to the weight and con-
sideration usually aecorded to them ino equity
suits, sinee the validity of the aetion of a. sov-
ercien legislative body is involved. It i the duty
of the court in cases of this character to vive its
own full consideration to the facets as well as the
law, regardless of what took place in the courts
below,
(ily of Nnoavill ve Nuorville Wate:
(‘o., 212 U. S..1.
In the case of the Consolidated Gas Co, v. New-
fon etal, 267 Fed. Rep. 251, the court recognized
that this rule obtained. Judee Learned Hand
sald (p. 259):
‘Tn these enses the conclusivencss of the
Ioaster’s report dees not obtain (Nnoreill
Wain Conv, Niesrille, supray.?
3
And again in a supplemental opinion said (p.
O74):
In the case at bar the reference was not
on consent— though without objection
aud it Was only advisory in any case. In
suca Cases * the report has no legal sanction,
and no further weight than sueh as attaches
to it by reason of the fact that it may em-
wody the researches and conclusions of an
intelligent master. ??
The order referring the issues to a special mas
erin the instant case was similar te the order of
reference in the case of the ( ‘onsolidated Gas ('u,
vy. Newton et al.
The trial of the case before the special master
began on the 3rd day of August, 1920, and was
completed on the 3rd day of September, 1920,
The master filed his report and opinion on the
“ud day of September, 1920. The said report
and opinion Was moved for confirmation before
lon. Charles M. Hough, sittine as United States
District Judge, Southern District of New York.
Thereafter and on or about the 13th day of Octo-
her, L920, Judge Hough filed an opinion confirm.
ag the report of the special master herein (pp.
i) and thereafter a decree Was filed in the
ofice of the clerk of the United States District
vourt, for the Southern District of New York, as
doresaid, from whieh this appeal is taken (pp.
idl),
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
This action was begun by the service of a
ubpoena on the appellants on the first day of
Jane, 1920, and the filing of a bill of complaint
4
to have declared unconstitutional and void as to
the respondent, chapter G4 of the laws of 1916,
upon the ground that the rate of So cents per
thousand cubie feet at which was shall be “Up.
plied to private coustumers in the City of New
York in the $0th and Sist wards thercot
Borough of Brooklyn, is comfiscatory, and that
the appellants, public offielals should be yo.
strained from in any way enforcing or attempting
to enforee the said statute.
There was no allegation that the requirement
In the statute as to quality and eandle-power of
gas served was unconstitutional Cp. 1-11),
The answers of the appellants denied all th
material allegations of the complaint. and allewed
that the respondent has not furutshed to its coy.
sumers gas of a candle power having the <tandard
of illumination provided by the statute (chapter
Ino oof the laws of 1906) known as 22. cand!
power (pp. 14-25),
The respondent serves about 40.000 individual
consumers in the Borongh of Brooklyn, City of
New York, and furnishes eas for stroet Helitin
’
= —! bhi
to about 3.600 street lamps maintained by the City
of New York,
The territory served hy the respondent com-
pany has a present population of about 250,004,
The statute which the respondent seeks to have
declared unconstitutional and void) (chapter 60!
of the laws of 1916) went into effect on July 1.
116.
Just prior to the time when the statute went
into effect and on or about June 22, 1916, respond
ent started an action in the Supreme Court of
the State of New York to have the said statute
5
declared unconstitutional and restraining the
public officials from enforcing the provisions of
the said statute. The defendants in that action
were the Attorney-General of the State of New
York, the Public Service Commission of the State
of New York for the First District, and the City
of New York. All filed answers denying the
waterial allegations of the complaint. On
August 2, 1916, an order was made and filed in
that action in the county clerk’s office of the City
of New York granting the company a temporary
injunction and allowing it to charge 95 cents per
thousand cubic feet for gas supplied to private
couswiners from the time the act went into effect,
July 1, 1916. This injunction order required
respondent to deposit with a trust company the
difference between the statutory rate of 80 cents
and 9) cents thus allowed. Approximately $610,-
(0 has thus been deposited and no part of this
money has been returned to the consumers.
The issues in that ease were tried before Mr.
Justice Greenbaum at a Special Term of the Su-
preme Court and an exhaustive and painstaking
trial was had. The trial was begun in October,
WMS, and coneluded in’ April, 1919. The court
handed down an opinion on January 27, 1920
(M0 Mise. 204, Record, pp. 1151-1178) and there-
after a motion was made on February 6, 1920, by
the plaintiff to reopen the case. This motion was
denied by an order of March 29, 1920. The deci-
sion of the court contained 111 findines of fact
id 20 conclusions of law (pp. 1130-1149),
In the State court action the court found upon
competent evidence that in the vear 1916, at an
2
shes: a
6
SO-cent rate, plaintiff had an income of $153.
STS.01, or a littl: over 5 per cent upon the rate
base found by the Court of $3,041,259; that in
the vear 1917 plaintiff had a net income of ap-
ward of $152,953.91, which upon the rate base as
found by the Court of $3,100,000 would give a
return of between 3 per cent and 6 per cent, and
that if plaintiff were charged with a substantial
sum for unaccounted for leakage, this revenue
would be correspondingly increased; and that in
the vear 1918S the plaintiff had some profit, and
with the elimination of objectionable items the
income would have been approximately $100,000,
The court further found, that so far as the year
1L9IS was concerned, the operations of plaintiff
show improvidence; that there was no satisfac
tory proof offered as to the actual amount of coal
used; that plaintiff failed to explain the increase
in wages of its employees for that year, and the
increase in the number of its employees and the
hiring of extra help; that its stable expenses were
excessive; that the promotion expenses were ex-
cessive; that the items for office supplies and
expenses were excessive; that a great many items
were not satisfactorily explained as necessary
and reasonable operating expenses; that the loss
in unaccounted for gas was not properly proven;
that the gas furnished by plaintiff to its con-
sumers was of a very low candle power and below
the standard required by law; that plaintiff has
not proven beyond a rational doubt that the 80
cent rate would or could not give a fair return
during the year 1918; that plaintiff came into
court of equity with unclean hands by furnishing
to its consumers in the vear 1918 gas of a candle
7
power of 13.57 instead of 22 candle power, and
thai tue portion of the fiscal year which was as
abnormal as was the vear 1918 lacked the value
of a uormal year, in determining the future (pp.
1130-1178).
Judgment was entered in the office of the clerk
of the county of New York dismissing the com-
plaint upon the merits, and denying the motion
made by the plaintiff to reopen the case. Plain-
tiff appealed from this order but said appeal has
not been heard by the Appellate Division, First
Departinent (pp. 1149-1150).
The appellants in the instant case excepted to
substantially all of the findings of the master,
aid filed assignments of errors covering sub-
stantially all of the conclusions and findings in
Judge Hough’s opinion confirming the report and
opinion of the special master and in the final de-
cree from which this appeal is taken (pp. 54-65,
80-92),
The respondent has never operated under the
statutory rate complained of. The preliminary
injunction in the State court action allowed it to
charge 95 per cent per thousand cubic feet from
the date When the statute was to have taken effect.
POINT I
Prior adjudication requires a dismissal of the Dill of
complaint.
The action begun by the respondent in the Su-
preme Court of the State of New York to lave
declared unconstitutional chapter 604 of the laws
of 1916, sought the same relief as the action in
this court.
The defendants were the predecessor in office
8
of the present appellant Attorney-General of the
State of New York, the predecessor in office of
the present appellant Lewis Nixon, constituting
the Public Service Commission of the State af
New York, for the First) Distriet: the City of
New York was made a party defendant in said
aetion in the State court while in this action the
District Attorney of Kings County was made a
party defendant. The Corporation Counsel of
the City of New York represented the District
Attorney of Wings County in this action.
The issues raised by the pleadings are sub.
stantially the same. The decision of Mr. Justice
Greenbaum contained = the following findings.
among others:
The plaintiff? has come inte equity with
unclean hands in that it has conceded that
the candle power of gas furnished to its
consumers in TTS was 13.57 candle power
instead of 22 candle power as preseribed by
chapter 125 of the laws of 1906, as amended
by chapter GO4 of the laws of 1916." (Oth
Conclusion of Law, p. 1148.)
Again:
The substantial observance of the re-
quirements of the statute as to the candle
power should have been shown by the plain-
tit, and tts failure to do so does not entith
to the favorable consideration of a court
ot equity ee (p. 1177).
Does this decision of the State courts have any
effect?) That court had co-ordinate Jurisdiction
with the United States Courts over the parties
and subject-matter here litigated. Sines July 1,
1916, the respondent has at all times violated the
9
statute in question, The pleadings in this case
allege a continuance of the violation. (Com-
plaint, paragraphs NV and NNI, pp. 6,7, 9.) Its
general manager says no attempt has been made
io comply with the regulations contained in the
law since January 1, 1918 (pp. 315-323).
The master during the examination of this wit-
Hess said:
The plaintiff has admitted it never has
during this period —I- think it has admitted
that during this period i has not produced
yes of a candle power required by the stat-
ute”? (p. 316),
Can respondent have and entertain a complete
disregard for all statutes and laws, and when its
conduct las been judicially condemned by a court
of competent jurisdiction, is such judgment a
nullity and entirely invalid and inoperative, made
so by its own determination and decision? It was
decided that the respondent was not entitled to
equitable relict because of its failure to observe
the conditions of the statute, and to conduct itself
in that reasonably blameless manner which the
rules of equity have prescribed as a condition pre-
vedent to the coming in by a suitor. Having been
defeated in one court of equity it has prepared a
weW Dill, alleging that at all times it das continued
the same course of conduct, which, the previous
iudament declared, prevented relief being given
it May a corporation be so obdurate as to turn
defeat into victory? And shall it, by pleading
amd proof of its continuing obstinacy, lay a
foundation for a second action in another court
of equity, giving no heed to the decision of a court
having full jurisdiction?
3
10
The rule that a prior adjudication ts conclusive
ix so Well seithed that citation of wlithority js
ditnest unnecessary. Tt is to the eflect that a
fact or question Which was im issue in a former
suit and was there judicially passed upon and
determined hy ncourt of colnpetent Jurisdiction,
is couelusivels settled Hy the judgment LhETrein se
faras concerns the party te that action, and por.
sons in privity with them, and eannot be litigated
Ino auy future action between such parties or
privies in the same court or in any other court
of coneurrent jurisdiction upon the same or a
different cause of aetion.
Missourt Vv. Chicane Bd i; ta,
241 ©. S533 (Rate Case) anid eases
etted hw Mr. Chief Justice White iN
the opinion of the Court,
Williamsburg Sacuwg Bank vo Solon.
6 N.Y... 405;
Southern Pacific RoR. Cony. CLS,
los U.S. 1.
In the case last cited, Judge Tarkan at p. 4s.
said:
‘STs this position consistent with the set-
ted rule of law as to the conclusiveness, le-
tween parties and their privies, of the final
detorratnation by a court of competent juris:
diction oof inatters put im issue hy the
pleadings?
"The imertanee of this question, inde-
pendently of the magnitude of the interests
to Le affected Dy our decision, and of the
earnest contention of learned counsel, justi-
fis a referenes ta some of the adjudged
cases, showing the grounds upon which this
salutary rifle rests.
“The general principle announeed in
1]
numerous eases is that a right, question or
fact distinctly put in issue and directly de-
termined by a court of competent jurisdie-
tion, as a ground of recovery, cannot be dis-
puted Ina subsequent suit between the same
parties or their privies; and even if the
second suit is fora differs ut cause of action,
the reght, question or fact once so deter-
mined must, as between the same parties or
thie i) pre Vt ts hie faken as conclusively estab-
lished, so long as the judgment in the first
ult remains unmodified. This general rule
is demanded by the very object for which
civil courts have been established, which is
te secure the peace and repose of soclety by
the setthment of matters capable of judicial
deteriumuation. Its enforcement is essential
te the iusintenanee of social order; for the
vid of judicial tribumals would not be in-
vohod for the vindication of rights of person
aud property, if as between parties and
thelr privies, conelusiveness did not attend
the judgements of such tribunals in’ respect
ofallmatters properly put in issue and actu-
ally determined by them.’’
It was judicially determined that the respond-
met Was not entitled to equitable relief because it
lad flagrantly violated the very law which it
sought to have declared unconstitutional and
void. After such oa judicial determination
squarely denying it relief in a court of equity,
cal) the respondent seck the equitable aid of a
court ef concurrent jurisdiction, admitting its
continued disregard of the law it seeks to have
leclared void as it did in its complaint? (pp. 6, 7,
‘) Can it hope to have this second court over-
ride and disregard the adjudication of the Su-
i
iy
i
q
12
preme Court of the State of New York, and fur.
thermore, overlook the time-honored equity
mmaximeef tt clean hands? all for the purpose of
eranting rellef to a deliberate and flagrant vio-
later of the law of a sovereign State? We do wot
beliewe that this court will countenance such prae-
tice, The right to equity relief was direciiy ** put
in issue and directly determined by a court ot
competent jurisdiction.” “Phe very eouditions
Which led the first court to deny relief were ad-
tiiited: te exist in the cotplaiat to the second
judicial tribunal Paraphrasing the language of
the court im Washington, ete., Packet Cae, y,
Sickles, 24 How... 353, limits must) be
upon the faculties for litigation.
A right adjudged by a court: of competent
jurisdic tien under definite ¢ onditions suelias pre-
Vailed in the action in the Supreme Court of the
State of New York should he received In evidence
‘ons irrefragable truth ‘* and should be oa enar-
inipased
autee of the future cfieiency and binding opera-
tien of a judgment.
It is true that the judgment of the Supreme
Court of the State of New York passed upon the
coifiseatory mature of the statute for the vears
O16. W917 and WS as set Porth in the opiiton of
Ju othe learned Jmdee failed to
Judee Plough. |
tuke into consideration that the judgement alse
provided that the respondent had vielated the
law assailed. in that. for the vear TIPS. it fur
nished to its consamers a gas of 1.07 candle
power instead of 22 candle power as provided hy
statute and that a substantial observance of the
statute should have been shown by the respond:
ent. and having failed to do so it was not entitled
13
to equitable relief. That the same failure to ob-
serve the law prevailed in the instant case. The
record shows that the average candle power for
the six months of P90 was 15.99, and for the vear
Wi9 was TG100 Crespondent’s exhibits 15, 17,
y, 1050).
We respectfully submit) that the respondent's
right to equitable relief, so long as the conditious
which moved the State court to deny relief re-
mained the same, was res adjudicata,
In other words, it ts the law hetween tho parties
that farhare hy respondent to furnish eas to
its constimers of the statutory quality, prevents
it from obtaining relief upon a claim that the
rate af retarn is inadequate,
The fact was establivhed in this aetion that if
lid net furnish sueh eas to its consumers, hence
the earrt below erred in not holding the State
court judement was a bar,
The prior determination required a disiiissnl
at the Dill of complaint,
POINT II
The burden ef proof is on the respendent te establish
teyond a rezsonable doubt the uncerstitntionslity of the
statute in question.
Ii ix new settled by an abundance of authority
that the Durden of proof in suits broneht to have
aerate statute declared coutiseatory, is on the
party assailing the statute to establish its con-
tentions bevond a just or fair doubt.
In the case of Walloon vy. Consolidated Gas Com-
pow, 22 US. 19, the eourt said (p>. 41):
' Pe rates must he plainky un-
nsonnble to the extent that ther enforee
|
Mm
14
ment would be equivalent to the taking of
property for public use without: such com,
pensation as under the eireumstiunces is just
hoth to the owner and to the public. There
must be a fair return upon the reasonable
value of the property at the time itis being
used lor the publie. Sais Divide Land d
Town (Company V. Natioual Culy, Lid U,, a
739, coc; Same Vv. Jus pr r, ISO UL S., 459, 442,
hs ; 7 1 hie Ctlye nist bea clear ope
before the courts ought to be asked to inter:
fere with state legislation upon the subject
of rat
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.