Appendix — Bass v. Nevada Board of Medical Examiners
Supreme Court brief1996
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
1k
EDITOR'S NOTE
THE FOLLOWING PAGES WERE POOR HARD COPY
AT THE TIME OF FILMING. IF AND WHEN A
BETTER COPY CAN BE OBTAINED, A NEW FICHE
WILL BE ISSUED.
-—<~
=
BB-1 689
No.
IN THE
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1996
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.,Petitioner.
-Vvs.-
BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS OF THE
STATE OF NEVADA, THEODORE JACOBS,
M.D., EVA G. SIMMONS, THOMAS J. SCULLY,
M.D., DELMAR E. SNIDER, M.D., IKRAM U.
KHAN, M.D., M. RONALD AVERY, JR., M.D..,
KATHLEEN L. EBNER, H. NAFEES NAGY,
MN.D., AND LEO A. WILNER, BOARD OF THE
NEVADA STATE BOARD OF MEDICAL
EXAMINERS, . Respondents
On Petition for Writ of Certiorari
To The Supreme Court of the State of Nevada
——
a
APPENDIX TO
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
R. PAUL SORENSON
Counsel of Record
513 South Sixth Street
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
(702) 384-9797
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Order Granting Petition for Writ of
Prohibition - Supreme Court of the
State of Nevada
Writ of Prohibition - Supreme Court
of the State of Nevada
Findings of Fact and Conclusions of
Law - District Court, Clark County,
Nevada
Judgment Remanding Matter for
hearing in Las Vegas - District
Court, Clark County, Nevada
Amended Findings of Fact,
Conclusions of Law, and Order--
Before the Board of Medical
Examiners of the State of Nevada
Order Denying Rehearing -
Supreme Court of the State of
Nevada
Order of the Department of Air Force
reinstating Dr. Bass’ medical
credentials ab initio
United States Air Force
Officer Effectiveness Report
Credentials Committee Memo
for Record
Page
la-4a
5a-Ga
7a-12a
13a-14a
15a-24a
25a-26a
27a-28a
29a-36a
37a-38a
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Rescheduling Notice for
Credentials Committee Hearing 39a
Excerpt of Transcript of
Credentials Hearing Committee
containing conclusion of
Committee 40a
Un States Air Force Report
or tain Bass concerning
C) tials 41a-43a
Lett: ‘rom Colonel Pees,
Comruaander concerning Dr. Bass 44a-45a
Report of Adverse Clinical
Privileges from the Department
of the Air Force 46a-48a
Amended Complaint Before the
Board of Medical Examiners 49a-54a
Answer to Amended Complaint .
Before the Board of Medical
Examiner 55a-59a
Brief of Respondent Re:
Legal Issues as Established by
the Hearing's Officer - Board of
Medical Examiners 60a-70a
Excerpt of Brief of the Board
Regarding Legal Issues - Board of
Medical Examiners 71a-72a
ii
ee
a rn aetna
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
Bass’ Petition for Rehearing
before the Supreme Court of
Nevada 73a-85a
iii
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
August 25, 1995
No. 25605
BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS OF
THE STATE OF NEVADA; THEODORE
JACOBS, M.D., EVA G. SIMMONS,
THOMAS J. SCULLY, M.D., DELMAR E.
SNIDER, M.D., IKRAM U. KHAN, M.D.,
M. RONALD AVERY, JR., M.D..,
KATHLEEN L. EBNER, H. NAFEES
NAGY, M.D., AND LEO A. WILNER,
BOARD MEMBERS OF THE NEVADA
STATE BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS,
Petitioners,
vs.
— i Fe
THE EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT)
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA, IN AND FOR )
THE COUNTY OF CLARK, AND THE )
HONORABLE STEPHEN HUFFAKER,
DISTRICT JUDGE,
Respondents,
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D..,
)
)
)
)
)
and )
)
Real Party in Interest. )
)
ORDER GRANTING PETITION FOR WRIT OF
PROHIBITION
la
—
This original petition for a writ of
prohibition challenges an order of the district
court reversing an order of the Board of Medical
Examiners.
On December 14, 1987, petitioner, the
Board of Medical Examiners (Board), filed =
disciplinary complaint against real party in
seiaan tal Harriston Lee Bass. The Board
e disciplinary h to take place
in Reno. Bass thereafter sid a totter to have
venue changed to Las Vegas.
On April 6, 1988, a conference call was
conducted among the parties and the assigned
hearing officer. The Board's counsel stipulated
to a change of venue if Bass would represent
that he needed to have venue in Las Vegas in
order to present his case. Bass would merely
state that Las Vegas was the more convenient
location. The hearing officer granted the motion
to change venue.
On December 26, 1990, the hearing officer
Sua sponte reversed the previous order, and
ordered venue changed back to Reno because
the hearing officer concluded that Bass would
not be calling any witnesses from Las Vegas
other than himself. On May 14, 1991, a
disciplinary hearing was held in Reno. On June
7, 1991, another hearing was held in Reno.
Bass was the only witness who testified on his
behalf. Although Bass again objected to venue,
Bass did not claim that there were specific
witnesses that he would have called if the
hearing had been in Las Vegas. The Board
found Bass guilty of disciplinary violations and
2a
en ee ee ae See ne eh hes Sen deertce rail
oe A ha teed a RaENO Lh tee ABD
Rei BSI AR NE ite dal SIL | ental mk Ait itil ident td
issued a letter of public reprimand. Bass
petitioned the district court for judicial review.
On May 6, 1994, the district court
reversed the decision of the Board and ordered
that the Board conduct a new disciplinary
hearing in Las Vegas. The district court
concluded that the Board acted arbitrarily and
capriciously in changing venue back to Reno,
after stipulating to venue in Las Vegas.
On May 16, 1994, the Board filed in this
court a petition for a writ of prohibition. The
Board contends that: (1) it has the discretion to
set venue wherever it wants, absent a venue
statute or any due process concerns caused by
unavailable witnesses; and (2) NRS 233B.135(3)
limits judicial review to matters that prejudice
the substantial rights of a petitioner, and that
Bass has made no showing of prejudice. Having
reviewed the pleadings, we conclude that the
district court exceeded its jurisdiction in
concluding that the Board acted arbitrarily and
capriciously because Bass was not prejudiced.
See NRS 34.320.
‘Accordingly, we grant this petition. We
direct the clerk of this court to issue a writ of
3a
prohibition directing the district court to vacate
its order granting judicial review.
It is so ORDERED.
cc: Hon. Stephen L. Huffaker, District Judge
Hon. Frankie Sue Del Papa, Attorney
General
Hon. Stewart L. Bell, District Attorney
Page Underwood,
Deputy Attorney General
R. Paul Sorenson
Loretta Bowman, Clerk
4a
kwh swe Ole Se
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
Filed August 25, 1995
No. 25605
BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS OF
THE STATE OF NEVADA; THEODORE
JACOBS, M.D., EVA G. SIMMONS,
THOMAS J. SCULLY, M.D., DELMAR E.
SNIDER, M.D., IKRAM U. KHAN, M.D..,
KATHLEEN L. EBNER, H. NAFEES
NAGY, M.D., AND LEO A. WILNER,
BOARD MEMBERS OF THE NEVADA
STATE BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS,
———_— ee Nee Nee Sere See See eee?
Petitioners,
vs.
THE EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT)
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA, IN AND FOR )
THE COUNTY OF CLARK, AND THE )
HONORABLE STEPHEN HUFFAKER,
DISTRICT JUDGE,
Respondents,
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.,
)
)
)
)
)
and J
)
Real Party in Interest. )
)
WRIT OF PROHIBITION
5a
TO: The Honorable Step?::1 L. Huffaker,
Judge of the Eighth Judicial Dist: ..: Court:
WHEREAS, this Court ha\..g made and
filed its written decision that a writ of prohibition
issue,
NOW, THEREFORE, you are directed to
vacate your Order granting judicial review, in the
case entitled Harriston Lee Bass, Jr., M.D. vs.
Board of Medical Examiners, et al., Case No.
A297956.
WITNESS The Honorables Thomas L.
Steffen, Chief Justice, Cliff Young, Charles E.
Springer, Miriam Shearing and Robert E. Rose,
Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of the
State of Nevada, and attested by my hand and
seal this 25th day of August, 1995.
Supreme Court Clerk
6a
* Spe RS | Pai Re Re lina Linn teas htt ate a
| rie A Cae Maher aol ear ail alt atte ws
cbt a AE K Aa ach Mh Ae BM ie: het Na AB 5 bel: eg
BF IS town 5S
DISTRICT COURT
CLARK COUNTY, NEVADA
FILED MAY 6, 1994
Case No. A 297956
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.
Petitioner,
vs
)
)
)
)
)
BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS )
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA; PATRICK )
DOLAN, Hearing's Officer; THEODORE )
JACOBS, M.D.; EVA G. SIMMONS; )
THOMAS J. SCULLY, M.D.; DELMAR _)
E. SNIDER, M.D., IKRAM U. KHAN, )
M.D.; M. RONALD AVERY, M.D.:; )
KATHLEEN L. EBNER; H. NAFEES )
NAGY, M.D.; LEO A. WILNER, Board __)
Members of the Nevada State Board of )
Medical Examiners, )
)
)
]
Respondents.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF
LAW
Dates of Hearing: 8-24-92 and 4-18-./4
Time of Hearing: 10:00 a.m.
This matter having first come on for
hearing for oral argument upon Petitioner Bass’
Petition for Judicial Review on August 24, 1992
and the Court at that time having initially found
that the issue of venue was not treated properly,
left the issue of venue open, and ordered post-
hearing briefs to be filed, and the Court having
considered those briefs as well as additional
Ja
argument of counsel for Petitioner and
Respondent on April 18, 1994, and good cause
appearing therefor, the Court hereby makes the
following findings of fact:
Findings of Fact
1. On Febru 26, 1988 the Board of
Medical Examiners of the State of Nevada
(hereinafter "Board") issued a Notice of H
in a disciplinary proceeding (No. 9455) against
Harriston Lee Bass, Jr., M.D. (hereinafter "Bass”)
ordering him to appear at a hearing in Reno,
Nevada. [ROA pp. 049 through 052].
2. On March 4, 1988, Petitioner Bass,
through his counsel, filed a Motion for Change of
Place of Hearing from Reno, Nevada to Las
Vegas, Nevada and cited as his reasons: "...
Respondent [Bass] is a resident of the County of
Clark, State of Nevada and the majority of all
witnesses he intends to call for this hearing are
also residents of the County of Clark and that it
would be an extreme economic hardship to
attempt to transport all the parties to Reno,
Nevada."
3. On March 4. 1988 without any
opposition being filed by the Board nor any
hearing granted, the Board issued an Order
denying that Motion. [ROA pp. 064 through
O65].
4. On April 5, 1988, Petitioner Bass
filed a Petition requesting extraordinary relief in
Case No. A265203, Eighth Judicial District
Court, before the Honorable Donald M. Mosely,
District Judge. Judge Mosely indicated some
concerns relative to the Board's refusal to
change venue.
or ean. nde acboein
5. On April 6, 1988 a hearing was held
before Patrick Dolan, Hearings Officer for the
Board wherein the issue of venue was discussed
at length [ROA, Transcript of April 6, 1988, pp.
49 through 67.]
6. That the following was indicated
with regard to venue at that hearing:
"Mr. Lessly: Well, you know, let me
finish.
I guess I've tried to make it as easy as
I possibly can for you, and as I've
indicated to you, by regulation I'm not
required to respond to any of your
motions.
You've made a motion to the board to
remove the venue of this case down to Las
Vegas. I think you're renewing motions
here this morning in front of the hearing
officer. As I understand the regulations,
the hearing officer is required to rule on
motions at the time the hearing begins.
You've renewed your motion, and I'm
perfectly willing for him to rule that we
can move venue in this case to Las Vegas
if you're telling me that it's more
convenient for you and it somehow
impedes the presentation of your defense
to this action, and if being in Reno does
that, then I'm here to stipulate to that.
That's all you have to say is, ‘I need to
go to Las Vegas to present my case," and
I'll stipulate to it and I'll ask Mr. Dolan to
enter the appropriate order and ask the
president to so order.
9a
Mr. Sorenson: I! think that's the
nature of my motion ori , that it is
the place where it should be held, in the
forum most convenient to the parties. It's
as simple as that.
Hearing Officer Dolan: All right. The
motion is granted."
[April 6, 1988, transcript of hearing, Page
63, Lines 18-25 & Page 64, Lines 1-21]
7. That accordingly venue was changed
from Reno to Las Vegas, even though the Board
continued to utilize the services of Reno
Hearing's Officer Patrick Dolan.
8. That the Board has appointed
Hearings Officers in both Las Vegas and Reno,
Nevada.
9. That on October 26, 1990 Hearings
Officer Dolan sua sponte reversed his previous
order granting the change of venue and ordered
that the venue be changed to Reno, Nevada.
[Petitioner's Appendix pp. 127-131]
10. That subsequently, the disciplinary
hearing before Hearings Officer Dolan
concerning Dr. Bass was held in Reno, Nevada
on May 14, 1991.
11. That at the subsequent hearing
before the Board, also held in Reno, on June 7,
1991, counsel for Dr. Bass further objected to
the venue. [ROA, Transcript of June 7, 1991,
page 8].
10a
a a aa eee aw >
lili tet Ale thesia, OR abt A NEB e meena eer okie
pe eee ee ye ee eS eR ee CNET a CE reer Nett coe
Set Ae ALANS Ay edict AP be
Rhett, OR ath WA Wiethbar tele nuitia eh abeanr
12. That the sua sponte decision of the
Board's Hearing's Officer to change the venue
from Las Vegas to Reno, once the Board had
agreed to placing the venue in Las Vegas
[electing to not have a hearing in the first
instance before Judge Mosely], was without
justification, an abuse of discretion, arbitrary
and capricious and in excess of the Board's
jurisdiction.
13. That Dr. Bass was harmed and
prejudiced by a result of the Board's action in
sua sponte reversing the venue Order.
14. That any Finding of Fact which is
more properly a Conclusion of Law herein,
should be so considered.
Based upon the foregoing, Findings of
Fact, the Court hereby makes the following
Conclusions of Law:
Conclusions of Law
1. That the Board has Hearing's
Officers appointed in Las Vegas.
2. That the Board has offices in Las
Vegas, Nevada.
3. That the majority of the population
is in Las Vegas, Nevada.
4. That the action of the Board having
stipulated to the change of venue so that Judge
Mosely did not hear the issue, and then sua
sponte, for no reason, changing the venue back
to Reno from Las Vegas constituted arbitrary
and capricious conduct in excess of the Board's
jurisdiction.
lla
5. That Dr. Bass was harmed and
prejudiced by the Board's action in having to
travel to Reno and further harmed by not being
permitted access to witnesses in Las Vegas.
6. Due to the Board's arbitrary and
capricious conduct in excess of its jurisdiction,
and further due to its abuse of discretion,
pursuant to NRS 233B.1:35(f) this matter should
be remanded for hearin; in Las Vegas, Nevada
and the Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law,
and Order of the Board entered on June 18,
1991 and the Amended Findings of Fact,
Conclusions of Law, and Order entered on
August 6, 1991 are hereby accordingly reversed.
7. That any Conclusion of Law which is
more properly a Finding of Fact herein shall be
so considered.
LET JUDGMENT ENTER ACCORDINGLY.
DATED this 5th day of May, 1994.
DISTRICT JUDGE
R. r n
R. PAUL SORENSON
Nevada Bar No. 002124
513 South Sixth Street
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
Attorney for Petitioner
l2a
i Satine sidint plete abisdi ss
DISTRICT COURT
CLARK COUNTY, NEVADA
FILED MAY 6, 1994
Case No. A 297956
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.
)
)
Petitioner, )
)
vs )
)
i BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS )
2 OF THE STATE OF NEVADA; PATRICK )
DOLAN, Hearing's Officer; THEODORE )
JACOBS, M.D.; EVA G. SIMMONS;
THOMAS J. SCULLY, M.D.; DELMAR
E. SNIDER, M.D., IKRAM U. KHAN,
M.D.; M. RONALD AVERY, M.D.;
KATHLEEN L. EBNER; H. NAFEES
NAGY, M.D.; LEO A. WILNER, Board
Members of the Nevada State Board of
: Medical Examiners,
Respondents.
SS ee
JUDGMENT REMANDING MATTER FOR
HEARING IN LAS VEGAS
Dates of Hearing: 8-24-92 and 4-18-94
i Time of Hearing: 10:00 a.m.
This matter having first come on for
hearing for oral argument upon Petitioner Bass'
Petition for Judicial Review on August 24, 1992
| and the Court at that time having initially found
that the issue of venue was not treated properly,
left the issue of venue open, and ordered post-
l3a
hearing brieis to be filed, and the Court having
considered those briefs as well as additional
argument of counsel for Petitioner and
Respondent on April 18, 1994, and the Court
eniered Findings of Fact and Conclusions
of Law, and based thereupon,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that based
upon this Court's Findings of Fact and
Conclusions of Law that due to the Board's
arbitrary and capricious conduct in excess of its
jurisdiction, and further due to its abuse of
discretion, pursuant to NRS 233B.135(f) this
matter is hereby remanded for hearing in Las
Vegas, Nevada, and the Findings of Fact,
Conclusions of Law, and Order of the Board
entered on June 18, 1991 and the Amended
Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order
entered on August 6, 1991 are hereby reversed
accordingly
DATED this 5th day of May, 1994.
DISTRICT JUDGE
/s/ R. Paul Sorenson
R. PAUL SORENSON
Nevada Bar No. 002124
513 South Sixth Street
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
Attorney for Petitioner
l4a
BEFORE THE BOARD OF MEDICAL
EXAMINERS OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
FILED AUGUST 6, 1991
No. 9455
IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPLAINT
AGAINST
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.,
Ll
AMENDED FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS
OF LAW, AND ORDER
The above-entitled matter came on
regularly for hearing and adjudication on Counts
Two and Four of the Amended Complaint against
Respondent filed January 20, 1988, before the
Nevada State Board of Medical Examiners on
Friday, June 7, 1991, at the offices of the
Nevada State Board of Medical Examiners, 1105
Terminal Way, Suite 300, Reno, Nevada.
Respondent, HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D..,
was present and was represented by legal
counsel, R. Paul Sorenson, Esq.
The Board was constituted by the
following members: Theodore Jacobs, M.D.:;
Kathleen Ebner; Thomas J. Scully, M.D.; M.
Nafees Nagy, M.D.; and Eva G. Simmons. Ikram
U. Khan, M.D. was absent, and the members of
the Investigative Committee of the Board were
excused from the proceedings of the Board and
took no part in the proceedings of the Board
with respect to adjudication of this matter.
15a
It appearing to the satisfaction of the
Board that it had jurisdiction over this matter,
the members of the Board having confirmed that
they had reviewed the pleadings, transcript of
hearing before the hearing officer, exhibits
introduced at hearing, and the report and
recommendation of the hearing officer, the
Board proceeded to make a determination
pursuant to the provisions of NRS 630.352.
The Board having duly considered the
record, the evidence, and law, and
advised in the premises, makes its findings of
fact, conclusions of law, and order as follows:
FINDINGS OF FACT
I.
Respondent is duly licensed by the Board
to practice medicine in the State of Nevada.
II.
That this matter was heard before a
hearing officer, Patrick Dolan, Esq., on May 14,
1991.
Il.
NRS 630.304(1) provides that the Board of
Medical Examiners of the State of Nevada may
initiate proceedings against a physician licensed
in Nevada on the grounds of obtaining,
maintaining or renewing, or attempting to
obtain, maintain or renew, a license to practice
medicine by bribery, fraud, or
16a
z
‘
;
;
q
:
3
misrepresentation, or by any false, misleading,
inaccurate or incomplete statement.
IV.
That Respondent, in his application for
licensure in the State of Nevada for the biennial
license year period of July 1, 1986 to June 30,
1989, answered "no" to the question on the
application asking if Respondent's practice of
medicine had been limited in any other
jurisdiction.
V.
That Respondent, in his application for
licensure in the State of Nevada for the biennial
license year period of July 1, 1987 to June 30,
1989, answered "no" to the question on the
application asking if Respondent had had staff
privileges in a hospital denied, suspended,
limited, revoked or not renewed, or whether
Respondent had resigned from a medical staff in
lieu of disciplinary or administrative action.
VI.
That Respondent's application for
registration was prepared and signed by
Respondent on June 8, 1987.
Vil.
That Exhibit F to Respondent's Motion to
Dismiss Action on Ground of Lack of
Jurisdiction and for Other Relief, a part of the
record in this proceeding, indicates that
Respondent's clinical privileges were limited by
17a
the United States Air Force Hospital at Nellis Air
Force Base, Nevada, on November 18, 1986.
Vil.
That the aforesaid Exhibit F indicates that
the limitations imposed upon Respondent's
practice and clinical privileges included the
following: as
A. No in-house specialty call
B. Must operate with a fully
credentialed general surgeon as
first assistant.
C. Must undergo 100 percent
review of all in-patient records and a
50 percent review of all out-patient
records
D. Must establish and maintain
contact with a mental health clinic.
IX
That Respondent acknowledged in his
testimony before the hearing officer that he
answered "no" to questions 4 and 5 on the
application for licensure, which questions read
as follows:
4. Have you been denied a medical
license or surrendered your license to
practice in another jurisdiction or had
your medical license revoked, suspended
or limited in another jurisdiction?
5. Have you had staff privileges in a
18a
niabay tii, inne "
ee. ee ee aks i la
we
hospital denied, suspended, limited,
revoked or not renewed, or have you
resigned from a medical staff in lieu of
disciplinary or administrative action?
x
That Respondent testified before the
hearing officer that he correctly answered the
questions on the basis of his belief that the
actions taken by the United States Air Force
were taken on the basis of military matters, not
medical matters, and based upon his firm
conviction that he would ultimately prevail on
the merits of the military matters.
ee ey
XI
That Respondent acknowledged in his
testimony before the hearing officer that he
executed an affidavit dated January 10, 1988, in
connection with his response to the charges of
the Board, and confirmed stating that "at the
time I filled out the application I believed I was
under no obligation to disclose my private
military affairs and further was under the belief
that I was under the obligation to not disclose
the same as it was a violation of law to do so.”
Paneer Rs ARE cam ean RN 0 A ROOT tei a OS
eae weeny Ek eS eee ee ee eee cae
re
Xi
R re
That Respondent confirmed in his
testimony before the hearing officer with respect
to the actions taken by the United States Air
Force concerning his clinica] privileges and right
to practice that he “was under the obligation to
not disclose the same as it was a violation of law
to do so.”
19a
XI
That Respondent acknowledged in his
testimony before the hearing officer that he had
disclosed the United States Air Force limitations
imposed upon his practice of medicine to
Community Hospital in Clark County, Nevad,a
on December 3, 1986; to Desert Springs Hospital
in Clark County, Nevada, on December 8, 1986;
and the Humana Hospital in Clark County,
Nevada, on November 19, 1987.
XIV
That the aforesaid disclosure to
Community Hospital and Desert Springs
Hospital occurred before June 8, 1987, tie date
of Respondent's execution of his application for
registration with the Board, and the disclosure
to Humana Hospital occurred after June 8,
1987.
xV
That Respondent acknowledged in the
hearing before the hearing officer that he did not
retain legal counsel and commence his efforts to
overturn or reverse the adverse clinical privileges
action taken by the United States Air Force until
after the service upon him upon him of the
initial complaint in this matter by the Board,
and said complaint was filed with the Board on
December 14, 1987.
20a
XVI
That subsequent to the filing of the
complaint against Respondent in this
administrative action on December 14, 1987,
Respondent retained his current legal counsel
and initated an appeal with the United States Air
Force to reverse the decision of the United States
Air Force in limiting his clinical privileges, and a
reversal of that action ab initio was made by the
United States Air Force as a result of such
appeal.
XVII
That the report and recommendation of
the hearing officer comments on the credibility of
Respondent, stating “It is difficult to accord
BASS with a good faith belief that he was under
no duty to report the adverse clinical action on
his application to the BOARD."
XVIII
That if any of the foregoing findings of fact .
is more properly deemed a conclusion of law, it
may be so construed.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I
That the Board has jurisdiction over
Respondent.
2la
II
That the condu.t of Respondent in
selectively disclosing the adverse action by the
United States Air Force to three hospitals, while
not disclosing such matter to the Board, is
further evidence that Respondent was at the
least "misleading, inaccurate, or incomplete" in
his response to questions on his application to
the Board.
Il
That Respondent's disclosure of the action
of the United States Air Force to three hospitals
is inconsistent with his sworn affidavit of
January 10, 1988, stating he was under an
obligation to not disclose the action as it was a
violation of law to do so, and casts great doubt
upon the credibility of Respondent.
IV
That by clear and convincing evidence
Respondent is in violation of the provisions of
NRS 630.304(1) as alleged in Count Two and
Count Four of the amended complaint as he
submitted to the Board "misleading, inaccurate
or incomplete" responses to questions number 4
and 5 on his June 8, 1987 application for
licensure.
V
That if any of the foregoing conclusions of
law is more properly deemed a finding of fact, it
may be so construed.
ORDER
Based upon the foregoing findings of fact
and conclusions of law, and good cause
appearing,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Respondent
shall be administered a public reprimand
pursuant to the provisions of NRS 630.352.
DATED this 3lst day of July, 1991.
NEVADA STATE BOARD
OF MEDICAL
EXAMINERS
By_/s/ Theodore Jacobs, M.D
23a
CERTIFICATION
I hereby certity that the foregoing is a full,
true and correct original AMENDED FINDINGS
OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, AND ORDER
on file and of record in the office of the Board of
Medical Examiners, in the matter of the
Complaint against HARRISTON LEE BASS,
M.D., Respondent, Case No. 9945.
I further certify that Theodore Jacobs,
M.D., is the President of the Board of Medical
Examiners of the State of Nevbada, and that full
force and credit is due to his official acts as
such; that the signature to the foregoing
FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW,
AND ORDER is the genuine signature of the said
Thoedore Jacobs, M.D.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto
set my hand in my official character as
Secretary-Treasurer of the Board of Medical
Examiners of the State of Nevada.
DATED: This 5 day of August, 1991.
/s/ Thomas J. Scully
Thomas J. Scully, M.D.
Secretary-Treasurer
Nevada State Board of
Medical Examiners
24a
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
January 18, 1996
No. 25605
BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS OF
THE STATE OF NEVADA; THEODORE
JACOBS, M.D., EVA G. SIMMONS,
THOMAS J. SCULLY, M.D., DELMAR E.
SNIDER, M.D., IKRAM U. KHAN, M.D.,
M. RONALD AVERY, JR., M.D.,
KATHLEEN L. EBNER, H. NAFEES
NAGY, M.D., AND LEO A. WILNER,
BOARD MEMBERS OF THE NEVADA
STATE BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS,
ee
Petitioners,
Vs.
Neer eee eee
THE EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT)
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA, IN AND FOR )
THE COUNTY OF CLARK, AND THE
HONORABLE STEPHEN HUFFAKER,
DISTRICT JUDGE,
Respondents,
and
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D..,
Real Party in Interest.
Ne eee eee eee eee ee
ORDER DENYING REHEARING
25a
cc:
Rehearing ‘enied. NRAP 40(c).
It is so ORDERED.
Hon. Stephen L. Huffaker, District Judge
Hon. Frankie Sue Del Papa, Attorney
General
Hon. Stewart L. Bell, District Attorney
Page Underwood,
Deputy Attorney General
R. Paul Sorenson
Loretta Bowman, Clerk
26a
iti di
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
Headquarters Tactical Air Command
Langley Air Force Base VA 23665-6001
Dated October 12, 1988
Subject: Medical Credentials - Command
Appeals Committee
To: Harriston L. Bass, Jr.
206¥ East Sahara
Suite A
Las Vegas NV 82104
i‘. I have reviewed your appeal, the medical
facility commander's decision, and the
recommendations of the Command Appeals
Committee.
2. The Command Appeals Committee found,
by majority vote, that there was substantial
evidence to conclude that your surgical practice
was not impaired or substandard. There is
evidence that the chain of command of 554th
Medical Group knew of your incarceration and
that you made appropriate efforts to stay in .
contact with the facility. There is evidence that
you did not jeopardize patient health and safety
when you left the operating room without the
permission of the operating surgeon. The
Command Appeals Committee has
recommended that your appeal be granted and
full reinstatement of your medical credentials ab
initio.
3. After review of the Command Appeals
Committee findings, it is my decision that your
medical credentials be reinstated ab initio.
27a
4. You may appeal my decision to HQ
USAF/SG through HQ USAF/SGPQ. You must
send your written ap via certified mail within
ten (10) duty days of receipt of this notification.
The address is HQ USAF/SGPQ, Bolling AFB,
DC 20337-6188. My decision will remain in
effect during the appeal.
/s/ Robert A. Buethe,
ROBERT A. BUETHE, JR.
Brigadier General, USAF, MC
Command Surgeon
cc: 554th Med Gp/SG
HQ USAF/SGPQ
HQ AFMPC/SGC
R. Paul Sorenson, Esq.
28a
OFFICER EFFECTIVENESS REPORT
June 30, 1986
‘ Ratee Identification Data (Read AFR 36-
10 carefully before filling in any item)
1. Name (Last, First, Middle Initial)
BASS, HARRISTON L.
2. SSN
337-50-6458FV
3. Grade
CPT
4. DAFSC
9416
5. ORGANIZATION, COMMAND, LOCATION
USAF HOSPITAL NELLIS (TAC), NELLIS, AFB,
NV.
6. PAS CODE
NJOTFD5S50
7. PERIOD OF REPORT
From 30 JUN 85 Thru 29 JUN 86
8. NO. DAYS OF SUPERVISION
343
9. REASON FOR REPORT
ANNUAL
ll. JOB DESCRIPTION
1. DUTY TITLE
General Surgeon
29a
2. KEY DUTIES, TASKS AND
responsibilities
Screens, diagnoses and treats general surgery
cases, performs major and/or minor
operations on patients requiring surgery.
Takes care of inpatients, outpatients and sees
patients on consultation from other
departments. Performs Medical Officer of the
Day duties. Also performs upper endoscopic
examinations and colonoscopy.
Il. PERFORMANCE FACTORS
Specific example of performance required
[ratings:
Not Observed
Far Below Standard
Below Standard
Meets Standard
Above Standard
Well Above Standard]
1. JOB KNOWLEDGE (Depth, currency,
breadth)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Is a well trained general surgeon. Just
finished residency in general surgery and is
current in surgical techniques. Maintains job
knowledge through broad reading and
attending conference downtown.
30a
2. JUDGMENT AND DECISIONS
(Consistent, accurate, effective)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
His assessment of patients’ problems is
consistently sound and logical. Goals are
accurately achieved as manifested by short
recuperation of patients upon which he has
operated.
3 PLAN AND ORGANIZE WORK
(Timely, creative)
| ABOVE STANDARD
Is adjusting to organized workload so as to
have ample time to perform his operations
and be on time to see patients in the clinic.
4. MANAGEMENT OF REOURCES
(Manpower, material, fiscal)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Utilizes equipment at this facility by
performing upper endoscopy and
colonoscopy. Treats all cases within his
capabilities without compromise to quality
care.
5. LEADERSHIP
(Initiative, accept responsibility)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Demonstrates interest in teaching other
providers to perform endoscopy. He gave a
very thorough lecture to the dentists about
wound care and hemorrhage control.
3la
6. ADAPTABILITY TO STRESS
(Stable, flexible, de:xendable)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Displays calmenss and exceptional poise
when confronted with difficult cases. He is
confident in managing stressful cases.
iP ORAL COMMUNICATION
(Clear, concise, confident)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Speaks fluently and gains the confidence of
his patients through detailed explanations of
the procedure to be performed.
8. WRITTEN COMMUNICATION
(Clear, concise, organized)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Pertinent information is well documented in
the patient chart. They are clear, concise and
with diagrams. His line of thought is logical
and he keeps his charts up to date.
9. PROFESSIONAL QUALITIES
(Attitude, dress, cooperation, bearing)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Possesses good military bearing, and is neatly
dressed. He is a volunteer to the Air Force
and has a high regard to military service.
10. HUMAN RELATIONS
(Equal opportunity participation, sensitivity)
WELL ABOVE STANDARD
Consistently fair and impartial and supports
the ideals of equal opportunity. Treats all
patients of all creeds.
32a
IV. ASSIGNMENT RECOMMENDATION
1. STRONGEST QUALIFICATION:
Job Knowledge
2. SUGGESTED JOB (Include AFSC):
Chief, Surgery Services (9416)
3. ORGANIZATION LEVEL
USAF Hospital
4. TIMING
1987
V. EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL
Compare the ratee’s capability to assume
increased responsibility with thet of other
officers whom you know in the same grade.
Indicate your rating by placing an "X” in the
or ana portion of the most appropriate
Rating: Rater
Highest Rating: Addn Rater
Highest Rating: Indorser
VI. RATER COMMENTS
Captain Bass is a well trained general
surgeon. He just finished his residency last
year and volunteered to join the Air Force.
He is current in his surgical skills and
techniques. Despite his being in the Air
Force for only a year, he has been a great
help to this facility as seen by his untiring
efforts to work in the surgical department
and his initiative to impart his knowledge to
other care proviers. He should be promoted
33a
upon eligibility and encouraged to remain in
the Air Force
Name, Grade, BR of SVC, ORGN, COMD.
Location
LEONARD G. SANIDAD, Col, USAF, MC.
USAF Hospital Nellis (TAC)
Nellis Air Force Base, Nevada
Duty Title
Chief, Surgical Clinic
Date
30 Jun 86
SSAN
220-60-7240FV
SIGNATURE
/s/ Leonard G. Sanidad
VII. ADDITIONAL RATER COMMENTS
Concur
Captain Bass is a knowledgeable and capable
physician. His colonoscopy expertise has
significanly broadened our diagnostic
capability. Retain and promote.
34a
Name, Grade, BR of SVC, ORGN, COMD.
Location
JOSEPH J. DAVEY, Col, USAF, MC.
USAF Hospital Nellis (TAC)
Nellis Air Force Base, Nevada
Duty Title
Chief, Hospital Services
Date
30 Jun 86
SSAN
457-66-8254FV
SIGNATURE
Ls/ Joseph Davey
VII INDORSER COMMENTS
Concur
Captain Bass has demonstrated superior
patient care abilities. His adaptation to
military medicine has proceeded well and he
is well versed in his responsibilities of
officership. His handling of surgical cases
and postoperate managment has been
exceptional. His sensitivity and rapport with
patients is likewise excellent. His willingness
to teach other providers is commendable.
Retention and promotion are in the best
interests of the Air Force.
35a
ee
Name, Grade, BR of SVC, ORGN, COMD.
Location
RICHARD C. PEES, Col, USAF, MC.
USAF Hospital Nellis (TAC)
Nellis Air Force Base, Nevada
Duty Title
Commander
Date
180-34-9502FR
SIGNATURE
Ls/ Richard C. Pees
36a
Sf PMLA LATIN SRE LOEE AINE LAL LANA
r aw
_ Guests present:
MEMO FOR RECORD
September 2, 1986
Subject: Review of Clinical Privileges--
Captain Bass
1. On Tuesday, 26 August 1986 at 1630, an
ad hoc group of the Credentials Committee met
in the main conference room to discuss subject
matter. The following individuals were present:
Col Dean Willsey - SGD (Chairperson)
Col Leonard Sanidad - SGNSS
Lt Col Jane Bigelow - SGN
Maj Michael Schiano - SGHSO
Maj Eric Wohlrab - SGF
Maj James Meldrum - SGHL
Cpt John Lewis - SGHM
Cpt Roger Belcourt - SGHG
Lt Col H. B. Nicholson, Jr. - SGA (Recorder)
Maj Deborah Ain - SGHQ
Cpt Everett Jones -SGHMM
Mr Todd Norton - SGJA (Legal Advisor)
2. The objective of this meeting was to gain
consensus on a recommendation to the
Commander regarding Captain (Dr) Bass'
privileges. Major Wohlrab, the investigating
officer for this case, presented his report.
Attendees discussed previous incidents involving
Captain Bass.
3. Consensus of the group was to
recommend to the Commander termination of
37a
privileges for Captain Bass. Mr. Norton will
review the evidence obtained to date with the
medical law consultant at Wilford-Hall USAF
Medical Center.
4. The meeting adjourned at 1605.
/s/ HL. Nicholson, Jr...
H. L. Nicholson, Jr., Lt. Colonel, USAF, MSG
Recorder
38a
i
z
}
a
i
;
4
;
a
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
USAF Hospital Nellis (TAC)
Nellis Air Force Base, NV 89181
Dated: September 12, 1986
Attn of: SGH
Subject: Credentials Hearing Committee
Rescheduling
TO: Lt Col Kessler
Lt Col Premsrirut
Lt Col Bigelow
As requested in the attached letter, the
Credentials Hearing Committee originally
scheduled for 15 Sep 86 has been changed to
1600, 19 Sep 86 in the main conference room.
Ls/Galen S. Wooley
GALEN S. WOOLEY, Colonel, USAF, M.C.
Chief, Hospital Services
1 atch
JAJD Ltr., 10 Sep 86
39a
EXCERPT of
TRANSCRIPT OF CREDENTIALS HEARING
COMMITTEE
September 19, 1986
RECOMMENDATIONS:
It is the unanimous conclusion of ~:is
committee that the credentials of Doctor Bass to
practice medicine at this facility be terminated.
(Page 186)
40a
;
2
4
'
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
USAF Hospital Nellis (TAC)
Nellis Air Force Base NV 89191-5300
Dated: November 18, 1986
Reply to :
Attn of: SGPQ
Subject: Report on Captain Harriston L.
Bass, Jr.,
To: HQ AFMPC/SGPC
According to AFR 168-13, paragraph 8-13,
the following information is submitted:
1. Practitioner affected:
a.
b.
c.
d.
Bass, Harriston L, Jr.
Captain
M.D.
Graduated from Howard University,
Washington, D.C. 1980
e.
f.
&
h.
Home of Record: Chace. Illinois
DOB: 28 Jul 1954
Licensed in state of: Illinois
Date licensed: Illinois - 18 Sep 84
4la
2. Type of action taken: Capt Bass’
credentials were summarily suspended on 4 Aug
86. An investigative officer was appointed and
he submitted his report on 25 Aug 86. A
credentials hearing committee was then
appointed with their report submitted on 29 Sep
86 and validated by the legal advisor on 14 Oct
86. The Credentials Committee met and
submitted their recommendations to the MFC on
2 Oct 86. The Credentials Committee notified
Capt Bass on 20 Oct 86 and on 17 Nov 86 the
MFC informed Capt Bass of his restricted
privileges.
3. Date of final action: 17 Nov 86.
4. Summary of facts: Capt Bass’ credentials
were summarily suspended on 4 Aug 86 as a
result of his being arrested and incarcerated in
the local civilian jail. The arrest was a result of
a domestic altercation. Capt Bass was the only
general surgeon available at USAF Hospital
Nellis for surgical duties and he failed to
properly notify appropriate authorities of his
inability to perform his duties. After a thorough
and exhaustive review of his performance and
practice, restricted privileges were reinstated on
17 Nov 86. The restrictions that apply are:
a. In-house specialty call;
b. Must operate with a fully
credentialied general surgeon as first assistant;
C. 100 percent review of all inpatient
and 50 percent review of all outpatient records;
42a
e
H
4
‘
d. establish and maintain contact with
the mental health clinic;
e. no off-duty employment;
f. complete review of performance and
practice will be reaccomplished in 90 days.
Additionally, AFR 36-2 action was initiated
against Capt Bass on 31 Oct 86 by the Wing
Commander, Colonel Henry M. Hobgood.
/s/ Richard C, Pees
RICHARD C. PEES, Colonel
USAF, MC
Director, Base Medical Services
cc: HQ TAC/SQ
HG AFMSC/SGPC
43a
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
USA: “ospital Nellis (TAC)
Nellis A:. ‘orce Base, NV 89181
Dated December 18, 1986
Subject: Privileges - Capt Harriston L. Bass,
Jr.
To: Whom it May Concern
a Captain Bass had his privileges at USAF
Hospital Nellis, Nellis AFB, Nevada, suspended
on 4 August 1986. This action was taken
pending investigation into the charges of
violation of military duties. Procedures as
specified in Air Force regulations were followed.
2. The investigation included a review of
clinical practice, records, documentation,
surgical skills, morbidity/mortality incident
rates and psychiatric evaluation by a civilian
psychiatrist. There were no deficiencies
identified in treatment protocols, documentation,
inappropriate surgical procedures, or abnormal
morbidity/mortality rates. The psychiatric
evaluation likewise did not document any
impairment of judgment or function but did
reveal domestic problems.
3. Restricted privileges were returned to
Captain Bass on 17 November 1986. The
restrictions that were applied included increased
review of medical records, in-house specialty
call, operating with a second general surgeon as
first assistant, and continued counseling for the
domestic problems. These restrictions are to be
re-evaluated at the 90-day point to determine if
44-a
My ct PRIS HIN AS IMT NA TRAE me pop Pee AS RRR a Ai oN
sufficient progress in adapting to the military
environment had been made. Based on that re-
evalaution, the restrictions would then be either
removed, extended or action initiated to separate
C- tain Bass for the best interest of the Air
Force.
/s/ Richard C. Pees
RICHARD C. PEES, Colonel, USAF, MD
Commander
45a
DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE
Headquarters United States Air Force
Rep!v to
Attn of:
Subject:
Action
To:
Bolling. AFB, D.C. 20332
Dated: June 30, 1987
SGPQ |
Report of Adverse Clinical Privileges
Executive Director-Secretary
Federation of State Medical Boards
of the United States, Inc.
2640-B West Freeway, Suite 138
Fort Worth TX 76012-7199
l. Captain Harriston Lee Bass had his
clinical privileges limited by USAF Hospital
Nellis, Nellis AFB NV. In accordance with our
agreement, the following information is provided:
a.
b.
Cc.
Degree: Medical Doctor
University: Howard University
Home of Record: Darien, IL
Date of Birth: 28 Jul 54
State of Licensure: Illinois -
036-064867, 1984; Nevada -
5314, 1985 ;
46a
f. Clinical Privilege Action Taken:
Limited
g. Date of Action: 18 Nov 86
h. Reason for Report: Capt Bass’
clinical privileges were suspended on 4 Aug 86
after he was arrested and incarcerated by local
civilian authorities for a domestic altercation.
His mental state following release was
deteremined by the credentials committee
to be potentially harmful to patient
safety. Following an investigation, the
credentials committee recommended that Capt
Bass's privileges be limited. The hospital
commander agreed with the recommendation.
The limitations imposed included the following:
(1) No in-house specialty call
(2) Must operate with a fully
credentialed general surgeon as first assistant
(3) Must undergo a 100% review of all
inpatient records and a 50% review of all
outpatient records
(4) Must establish and maintain contact
with the mental health clinic.
2. Requests for further information
may be sent to:
HQ USAF/SGPQ (Capt O'Shea)
Bolling AFB DC 20332-6188
(202) 767-2591
Ls/ Robert W. Poel
ROBERT W. POEL,
Colonel, USAF, MC
Chief, Quality Assurance Division
Office of the Surgeon General
cc: ASD/HA
AFMPC/SGCQ
ANG/SG
AFRES/SG
USAFRS/RS
554th Med Gp/SG
48a
BEFORE THE BOARD OF MEDICAL
EXAMINERS OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
Filed: January 20, 1988
Case No. 9455
IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPLAINT
AGAINST
HARRISON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.,
RESPONDENT.
AMENDED COMPLAINT
Pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 630
of the Nevada Revised Statutes, and by virtue of
the authority vested in it by said chapter, the
Board of Medical Examiners of the State of
Nevada, having a reasonable basis to believe that
HARRISON LEE BASS, JR., M.D., (hereinafter
“Respondent") has violated the provisions of said
chapter, hereby issues its formal Amended
Complaint, by and through its secretary, stating
the Board's charges and allegations in that
respect as follows:
I.
That M. Ronald Avery, M.D., Secretary of
the Board of Medical Examiners of the State of
Nevada, pursuant to the instructions of the
Board and on behalf of the Board, hereby makes
and signs this Amended Complaint in his official
capacity as Secretary, and not otherwise.
49a
II.
That Respondent is now, and at all times
alleged herein was, licensed by the Board of
Medical Examiners of the State of Nevada to
practice medicine in the State of Nevada.
COUNT ONE
I.
That NRS 630.301(2) provides that the
Board of Medical Examiners of the State o:
Nevada may initiate disciplinary proceedings
against a physician licensed in Nevada on the
grounds of suspension, revocation, modification
or limitatation of the licensee's license to
practice medicine by another jurisdiction, or the
surrender of the license or discontinuing the
practice of medicine while under investigation by
any licensing authority, a health and care
facility, a branch of the Armed Services of the
United States, an insurance company, an agency
of the Federal Government, or an employer.
Il.,
That Respondent's clinical privileges were
limited by the United States Air Force, a branch
of the Armed Services of the United States, and
an agency of the federal government, at Nellis Air
Force base on November 17, 1986, and the
following restrictions were placed on
Respondent's practice of medicine at Nellis Air
Force Base, Nevada:
50a
A. In-house specialty call.
B. Must operate with a fully
credentialed general surgeon as first assistant.
C. One hundred percent (100%) review
of all in-patient and fifty percent (50%) review of
all out-patient records.
D. Must establish and maintain contact
with the Mental Health Clinic.
E. No off-duty employment.
F. Complete review of performance and
practice to be accomplished in ninety (90) days,
after November 17, 1986.
COUNT TWO
I.
That NRS 630.304(1) provides that the
Board of Medical Examiners of the State of
Nevada may initiate disciplinary proceedings
against a physician licensed in Nevada on the
grounds of obtaining, maintaining or renewing,
or attempting to obtain, maintain or renew, a
license to practice medicine by bribery, fraud or
misrepresentation, or by any false, misleading,
inaccurate or incomplete statement.
II.
That Respondent, in his application for
licensure in the State of Nevada for the July 1,
1987 through June 30, 1989, biennial licensure
period answered "no" to the question on said
5la
application for licensure asking if Respondent's
practice of medicine had been limited in any
other jurisdiction.
III.
That at the time Respondent executed said
application for licensure with the Nevada State
Board of Medical Examiners and forwarded said
application to the Board for licensure,
iKespondent's practice in the United States Air
Foce had been limited as set forth in Count II
above.
IV.
That Respondent's conduct in failing to
disclose the United States Air Force's restriction
on his practice of medicine, constitutes a
violation of NRS 630.304(1) by renewing, or
attempting to renew, a license to practice
medicine by fraud or misrepresentation, or by a
false, misleading, inaccurate or incomplete
statement.
COUNT FOUR
I.
That NRS 630.304(1) provides that the
Board of Medical Examiners of the State of
Nevada may initiate disciplinary proceedings
against a physician licensed in Nevada on the
grounds of obtaining, maintaining or renewing,
or attempting to obtain, maintain or renew, a
license to practice medicine by bribery, fraud or
misrepresentation, or by any false, misleading,
inaccurate or incomplete statement.
52a
Il.
That Respondent, in his application for
licensure in the State of Nevada for the July 1,
1987 through June 30, 1989, biennial licensure
period answered "no" to the question on said
application for licensure asking if Respondent
had had staff privileges in a hospital denied,
suspended, limited, revoked or not renewed, or
whether Respondent had resigned from a
medicai staff in lieu of disciplinary or
administrative action.
Il.
That at the time Respondent executed said
application for licensure with the Nevada State
Board of Medical Examiners and forwarded said
application to the Board for licensure,
Respondent's clinical privileges at United States
Air Force Hospital, Nellis Air Force Base,
Nevada, were suspended on August 4, 1986.
IV. ‘
That Respondent's conduct in failing to
disclose the suspension of clinical privileges at
United States Air Force Hospital, Nellis Air Force
Base, Nevada, constitutes a violation of NRS
630.304(1) by renewing, or attempting to renew,
a license to practice medicine by fraud or
misrepresentation, or by a false, misleading,
inaccurate or incomplete statement.
WHEREFORE, the Secretary of the Nevada
State Board of Medical Examiners requests that
a hearing of this Amended Complaint be had as
53a
provided by law, and that after said hearing, the
Board take such action as may be just and
proper pursuant to Nevada Revis« i Statutes.
Dated this 20th day of January, 1988.
NEVADA STATE BOARD OF
MEDICAL EXAMINERS
BY:
M. RONALD AVERY, M.D.
Secretary-Treasurer
VERIFICATION
Under penalty of perjury, the undersigned
declares that he is the Secretary-Treasurer of the
Nevada State Board of Medical Examiners; that
he knows the contents of the foregoing Amended
Complaint; that the pleading is true of his own
knowledge, except as to those matters stated
upon information and belief, and that as to
those matters, he believes them to be true.
Dated this 20th day of January, 1988.
M. Ronald A M.D.
M. RONALD AVERY, M.D.
54a
BEFORE THE BOARD OF MEDICAL
EXAMINERS OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
Filed: April 5, 1988
Case No. 9455
IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPLAINT
AGAINST
HARRISON LEE BASS, JR., M.D..,
RESPONDENT.
l
ANSWER TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
COMES NOW, Respondent, HARRISTON
LEE BASS, JR., M.D., by and through his
attorney, R. PAUL SORENSON, and in answer to
the Amended Complaint on file herein, admits,
denies and alleges as follows:
FIRST DEFENSE
(COUNT ONE)
3 Respondent admits the allegations
contained in Paragraph I.
2. Respondent denies the allegations
contained in Paragraph II in all parts, and in
further answer to said paragraph, alleges that
the action referred to that was taken on
November 17, 1986 was for administrative
purposes of the United States Air Force only and
was not a limitation or restriction of privileges as
is commonly understood in the civilian medical
community.
55a
SECOND DEFENSE
(COUNT TWO
B Respondent admits the allegations
contained in Paragraphs I and II.
2. In answer to Paragraph III,
Respondent alleges that at the time he executed
the renewal application for licensure, he was no
longer in the Air Force, having been granted a
general discharge under honorable conditions
and the administrative proceedings that were
referred to in Count I of the Amended Complaint
ceased as they were moot. Respondent further
denies any and all other allegations contained in
Paragraph III.
3. In answer to Paragraph IV,
Respondent denies that he violated NRS
630.304(1) as alleged in that paragraph and in
further answer thereto, alleges that the answers
that he placed on his application for renewal of
medical license were placed there in a good faith
belief by the Respondent that the Air Force
incident was purely an administrative
procedure, for military purposes only, and that
its disclosure was a violation of the Privacy Act,
5S USC 552A and further beyond the jursidiction
of this Board, NRS 630.047(1)(a) and still further
a violation of NRS 179.285.,
THIRD DEFENSE
(COUNT THREE)
Count Three was dismissed pursuant to
an Order entered by Theodore Jacobs, M.D..
56a
3
3
Se Ta ge | Th eke
President of the Nevada State Board of Medical
Examiners on February 26, 1988.
FOURTH DEFENSE
(COUNT FOUR)
he Respondent admits the allegations
contained in Paragraphs I and II.
2. Respondent denies the allegations
contained in Paragraph III.
3. Respondent denies the allegations
contained in Paragraph IV, and in further
answer to said paragraph, realleges Paragraph 3
of the Second Defense as though set forth herein
in its entirety.
FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
The Amended Complaint fails to state a
cause of action upon which relief may be
granted.
SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
{LACK OF SUBSTANTIVE DUE PROCESS)
That the proceedings before this Board
violate the substantive due process requirements
of the Fourteenth Amendment of the United
States Constitution.
THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
(VIOLATION OF NRS 233B. 130)
The action of the Board violates NRS
233B.130 in that the Board neither contacted
nor sought an explanation from Respondent in
57a
the manner pfovided by said statute prior to the
filing of a public complaint.
(VIOLATION OF 5 USC 552A - PRIVACY ACT)
That the Board knew or should have
known that the filing of this public complaint
was a violation of 5 USC 552A - the Privacy Act.
FIFTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
(VIOLATION OF NRS 630.047(1)(a)
That the complaint filed by this Board is
beyond its jurisdiction and a violation of NRS
630.047(1)(a) which provides that the chapter
governing physicians does not apply to a medical
officer in the armed forces in the discharge of
this official duties for which a Nevada license is
not required.
SIXTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
That the Board has failed to establish
complete rules of practice and has failed to
maintain public files as directed by the
Legislature of the State of Nevada; failed to
follow the statutes and regulations that have
been adopted and have arbitrarily and
capriciously punished and damaged the
Respondent.
SEVENTH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
(VIOLATION OF NRS 179.285, ETC.)
That the Board has violated NRS 179.295
and an Order of the Eighth Judicial District
Court in Case No. A252963 sealing the records
of the arrest of Respondent on August 3, 1986,
58a
which order was intended to prevent the release
of information concerning those proceedings and
the events and proceedings relating to the arrest.
That in addition, the Board knew or should have
known that all of the subsequent events they
referred to resulted from the arrest on August 3,
1986, which has been dismissed and sealed.
WHEREFORE, Respondent prays that the
Amended Complaint on file herein be dismissed
with prejudice and he be granted such other and
further relief as previously prayed for and
deemed reasonable in the premises.
Ls/ R. Paul Sorenson
R. PAUL SORENSON
Attorney for Respondent
323 Las Vegas Blvd.So.
Las Vegas, NV 89101
59a
BEFORE THE BOARD OF MEDICAL
EXAMINERS
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
Filed January 30, 1990
Case No. 9455
In the Matter of the Complaint
Against
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.,
Respondent.
mi
OPENING BRIEF OF RESPONDENT RE: LEGAL
ISSUES AS ESTABLISHED BY THE HEARING'S
OFFICER IN HIS REPORT AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
COMES NOW, Respondent, HARRISTON
LEE BASS, JR., M.D., Respondent in the above
entitled action and submits his Opening Brief
Re: Legal Issues as Established by the Hearing's
Officer in his Report and Recommendations and
states as follows:
Introduction
The Hearing's Officer in his Report and
Recommendation dated August 15, 1989 stated
in part as follows:
"Specifically, the parties need to brief and
argue the case-law and statutory authority
for use of the military practice
60a
limitation as the basis for an alleged
violation of N.R.S. 630.301(2); the effect of
the sealing order in the criminal action on a
subsequent application for the privilege to
practice medicine; the effect of the pending
appeal, see Molnar v. State of Nevada Ex
State of Nevada, 105 Nev. Advance Opinion
45 (1989) of the military limitation decision
on appeal by virtue of an order reversing the
limitation ab initio.”
The Hearing's Officer also stated in that Report
and Recommendation that the Opening Brief
was to cover the above legal issue along with any
other issues felt relevant and/or material to the
resolution of this matter.
Respondent has previously submitted
additional legal issues. We have addressed
certain of these issues herein, and have
previously briefed the other issues herein. The
issues that we are going to attempt to re-brief
and brief herein are:
1. Should the Board of Medical
Examiners and Hearing's Officer Dolan be
disqualified from further hearing and
making further determination in this
matter for the reason that they have
prejudged this matter?
2. Were Dr. Bass’ privileges ever
limited by the United States Air Force?
3 Has due process as required by
the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments of
the United States and Nevada
6la
Constitutions been accorded to Respondent
Bass throughout these proceedings,
including, but not limited to: during
investigation of this matter; during peer
review of this matter; commencement of
disciplinary proceedings; filing of a public
complaint; hearings; and appellate rights?
4. Does the Board of Medical
Examiners and the Hearing's Officer have
jurisdiction to proceed in this matter?
This brief is merely submitted to satisfy
the requirements of the Hearing's Officer's
Report and Recommendation and is not a waiver
of any and all rights and objections Respondent
has in this matter.
I.
Th an
Hearing's Officer have
Prejudged the Matter Herein
The prior transcript of the proceedings
before this Hearing's Officer and before the
Board of Medical Examiners (hereinafter referred
to as "Board") reflect hostility on behalf of the
Board to Dr. Bass and a serious prejudgment of
the issues which have already been briefed in
the numerous motions before the Hearing's
Officer and the Board.
The Hearing's Officer lacks the judicial
independence necessary to be an independent
hearing body in this matter as he is under the
direct control of the Board without any rules and
regulations with which to proceed, all in
violation of Nevada law. NRS 233B.050.
62a
"There is, however, authority that a judge
may not try a case in which he has formed
an opinion of the case, before trial, in favor
of one of the parties. A judge is, on this
view, disqualified where he makes
statements in advance of the trial
amounting to a prejudgment of the case.
Where under such circumstances a judge
erroneously denies a change of venue or a
change of judge, the judgment will be
reversed on appeal although there is no
showing of any prejudice in the trial."
46 AmJur 2d 169
(emphasis provided)
See, Haldane v. Haldane. 232 Cal. App. 2d 393,
42 Cal Rptr.; Rugenstein v. Ottenheimer, 152 P.
214 , 78 Or 371 (1915): State ex rel. Barnard v.
f 52 P. 317, 19 Wash. 8
(1898); State v. Espinoza, 754 P.2d 1287 (1988).
The touchstone of all of our judicial
process in the United States is a fair trial in a
fair tribunal. In Withrow v. Larkin, 421 U.S. 35,
46, 95 S.Ct. 1456, 1464 (1976), the Court stated
as follows:
"Concededly, a ‘fair trial in a fair
tribunal is a basic requirement of due
process.’ In re Murchison, 349 U.S.133, 136,
75 S.Ct. 623, 625, 99 L.Ed. 942 (1955). This
applies to administrative agencies which
adjudicate as well as to courts. Gibson v.
Berryhill, 411 U.S. 564, 93 S.Ct. 1689, 1698,
36 L.Ed.2d 488 (1973). Not only is a biased
decisionmaker constitutionally unacceptable
but ‘our system of law has always
63a
ee
endeavored to prevent even the
probability of unfairness.’ In re Murchison,
supra, 349 U.S., at 136, 75 S.Ct., at 625: cf
Tumey v. Ohio, 273 U.S. 510, 532, 47 S.Ct.
437, 444, 71 L.Ed. 749 (1927). In pursuit of
this end, various situations have been
identified in which experience teaches that
the probability of actual bias on the part
of the judge or decisionmaker is too high
to be constitutionally tolerable. Among
these cases are those in which the
adjudicator has a pecuniary interest in the
outcome and in which he has been the target
of personal abuse or criticism from the party
before him."
(emphasis provided)
The Supreme Court has generally authorized
combining the investigative and adjudicative
function as long as the system is properly
designed and works well.
supra 421 U.S. at 49, 95 S.Ct. at 1465 states as
follows:
“More recently we have sustained against
due process objection a system in which a
Social Security examiner has responsibility
for developing the facts and making a
decision as to disability claims, and
observed that the challenge to this
combination of functions 'assumes too
much and would bring down too many
procedures designed, and working well,
for a government structure of great and
growing complexity.'Richardson v. Perales,
402 U.S. 389, 410, 91 S.Ct. 1420, 1432,
28 L.Ed.2d 842 (1971)
The Court did recognize, however, that the
problems associated with combining those
64a
I
functions are substantial. Withrow v. Larkin.
su
pra 421 U.S at 59, 95 S.Ct. at 1466 states as
foll
lows:
"That is not to say that there is
nothing to the argument that those who have
investigated should not then adjudicate. The
issue is substantial, it is not new, and
legislators and others concerned with the
operations of administrative agencies have
given much attention to whether and to what
extent distinctive administrative functions
should be performed by the same persons"
No single answer has been reached. Indeed,
the growth, variety, and complexity of the
administrative processes have made any one
solution highly unlikely."
Reference was also made therein to several
federal cases which found due process violations
in administrative law cases.
"In Texaco, Inc. v. FTC, 118 U.S.
App.D.C. 366, 336 F.2d 754 (1964) vacated
on other grounds, 381 U.S. 739, 85
S.Ct. 1798, 14 L.Ed. 2d 714 (1965), the
court found that a speech made by a
commissioner clearly indicated that he had
already to some extent reached a decision as
to matters pending before that Commission."
Withrow v. Larkin, supra 421 U.S. at 59, 95
S.Ct. at 1466
The United States Supreme Court most
recently discussed the obligations of the state
concerning the authorization and operation of
peer review. Patrick v. Burget, _.-—«aU.S. ___.
108 S.Ct. 1658 (1988). The Court said that
there must be a clear articulation of state
policy and further the Court stated that the peer
65a
review activity must be actively supervised to
make certain that: (1) the decision of the peer
review comported with state policy and (2) any
abuse of that peer review system is corrected.
i.
Dr. Bass' Privileges were Never Limited by the
United States Air Force.
The decision by Brigadier General Robert A.
Buethe, Jr. reinstating Dr. Bass' privileges ab
initio has a plain meaning. Black's Law
Dictionary, Fifth Edition, defines ab initio as
follows:
| "From the beginning; from the first
act; from the inception. A party may be said
to be a trespasser, an estate said to be good,
an agreement or deed said to be void, or a
marriage or act said to be unlawful, ab initio. -
Contrasted in this sense with ex post facto,
or with postea. "
Nevada courts as well as Courts throughout the
United States use the term “ab initio" regularly
and its meaning is unambiguous. It is a
determination that reflects error in this case that
was serious enough in the view of the Air Force
to require this type of correction. The Air Force
in addition, instructed the Federation of State
Medical Boards, the data bank where the Board
obtained its information in the first place, to
delete Dr. Bass' name therefrom.
66a
I.
Dr, Bass Cannot be Required to Advise the
Medical Board of
Errors Made by the United States Air Force
The two remaining charges herein allege
that Dr. Bass failed to tell the Board about the
erroneous orders of alleged limitation by the Air
Force. This just does not state any charge or
make any sense.
Dr. Bass was unaware of anything other
than that he believe he had a contractual
dispute with the Air Force which was resolved.
He became aware of the alleged limitation at the
time he was served with a public complaint by
the Board. He had not been given the
opportunity of being notified of the complaint
nor given an opportunity to explain the facts and
circumstances behind the alleged complaint, in
violation of NRS 233B.127(3). Counsel has
searched for case authority but can find none at
this time wherein anybody has charged a person
with failing to report the error of another. The
Hearing's Officer herein and the attorney for the
Board have previously determined as a matter of
law that in the event Dr. Bass’ clinical privileges
were not limited by the United States Air Force
on November 17, 1986, that there would be no
legal or factual basis with which to proceed.
The following is an excerpt from the
transcript of the hearing before Hearings Officer
Dolan on April 6, 1988 in Reno, Nevada:
“HEARING OFFICER DOLAN:....
67a
He has notice that the charge is that on
November 17, 1986 the United States Air
Force restricted his clinical privileges.
It seems to me that we should establish
with all deliberate speed and with due
process whether or not that is a factual
statement.
If in fact his clinical privileges were not
restricted by the United States Air Force
on November 17, 1986, then it seems to
me it dissolves the entire basis
and legally for the allegations that are
contained in the amended complaint.
Do you agree or disagree, Mr. Lessly?
MR. LESSLY: Agree.
HEARING OFFICER DOLAN:
And the rest of the complaint then flows
from that particular document which simply
Says that at the time on July Ist, 1987 that
Mr. Bass renewed his licensure he answered
no to a question as whether or not his
privileges had ever been restricted during
_— any time preceding the last filing and the
renewal of his application at that time, and
so that if in fact there was no restriction
that occurred on November 17, 1986,
then Counts II and III and IV have no
factual basis insofar as they allege in effect
that he failed to report that restriction on
his clinical practice at the time he renewed
his application. At least that's my
understanding of the nature of the charges
68a
———
that have been alleged against your client.
Mr. Lessty, is that --
MR. LESSLY: That's correct.
HEARINGS OFFICER DOLAN: Is that the
correct factual basis?
MR. LESSLY: That's correct.
(emphasis supplied) (Hearing Trans. p. 17,
Lines 5-25 and p. 18, Lines 1 - 13)
The Hearing's Officer and the Board then
changed their mind after the Air Force issued
their ab initio ruling and decided that Dr. Bass
could be guilty of failing to tell the Board of
something he was unaware of.
This is a violation of the concept of
"law of the case” as announced by the Nevada
Supreme Court. See: LoBue_ v. State
, 92 Nev. 529, 554 P.2d
Department of Highways
258 (1976) and Wickliffe v. Sunrise Hosp., 104
Nev. Adv. Opn. 133, 766 P.2d 1322 (Nev. 1988).
This also constitutes arbitrary,
capricious, and malicious conduct on behalf of
the Board and its members and the Hearing's
Officer as their alter ego in violation of NRS
630.364.
69a
From the beginning of these proceedings,
Dr. Bass has raised the defense that these
proceedings have lacked due process in violation
of the due process clause of the Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendments to the United States
Constitution.
| This issue has been briefed many times in
this proceeding and we would therefore adopt
our prior points and authorities filed herein with
regard to that issue.
Conclusion
There is no factual basis to support the
complaint herein as there is no evidence
whatsoever that Dr. Bass’ privileges or license
were ever limited in any fashion by the Air Force.
The final judgment of the Air Force reflects that
fact unmistakably.
WHEREFORE, Respondent prays that the
above entitled matter be dismissed and sealed.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ R. Paul Sorenson
Attorney for Respondent
323 Las Vegas Blvd. South
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
70a
BEFORE THE BOARD OF MEDICAL
EXAMINERS
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
Filed February 12 1990
Case No. 9455
In the Matter of the Complaint
Against
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D.,
Respondent.
EXCERPT OF
BRIEF OF THE BOARD REGARDING LEGAL
ISSUES
SESSSSSSSSSSSSESSESSSSS
With respect to the hearing officer's
question as to the effect of the reversal of the
military limitation decision on appeal by virtue of
an order reversing the limitation ab initio, such
order has no effect on these proceedings.
Granted, had Respondent had an order reversing
the military decision on appeal ab initio prior to
filling out his application for licensure and
submitting it to the Board for licensure, he
might have an argument that the military order
"ab initio" would entitle him to answer that no
action had been taken with respect to the
Jla
limitation to his practice or limitation of his
hospital privileges.
SSSSeeeeeee+seeseeses
Respectfully submitted this 12th day of
February, 1990.
MOSCHETTI & LESSLY
BY:
Larry D. Lessly
1105 Terminal Way, Ste. 302
Reno, NV 89502
Attorney for the Nevada State
Board of Medic:il Examiners
72a
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
Filed October 2, 1995
No. 25605
BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS OF
THE STATE OF NEVADA; THEODORE
JACOBS, M.D., EVA G. SIMMONS,
THOMAS J. SCULLY, M.D., DELMAR E.
SNIDER, M.D., IKRAM U. KHAN, M.D..
M. RONALD AVERY, JR., M.D..
KATHLEEN L. EBNER, H. NAFEES
NAGY, M.D., AND LEO A. WILNER,
BOARD MEMBERS OF THE NEVADA
STATE BOARD OF MEDICAL EXAMINERS,
i de ed
Petitioners,
vs.
THE EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT)
OF THE STATE OF NEVADA, IN AND FOR )
THE COUNTY OF CLARK, AND THE )
HONORABLE STEPHEN HUFFAKER,
DISTRICT JUDGE,
Respondents,
and
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., M.D..,
Real Party in Interest.
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
HARRISTON LEE BASS, JR., Real Party in
Interest's PETITION FOR REHEARING RE:
ORDER GRANTING PETITION FOR WRIT OF
PROHIBITION
73a
COMES NOW, HARRISTON LEE BASS.
JR., Real Party in Interest, by and through his
attorney, R. PAUL SORENSON, and files his
Petition for Rehearing Re: Order Granting
Petition for Writ of Prohibition entered herein on
August 25, 1995, as follows:
Introduction
This Court entered its Order granting
Petition for Writ of Prohibition on August 25,
1995. The basis for that Order was that Dr.
Bass was not prejudiced by the arbitrary and
capricious act of the Board of Medical
E>aminer's (hereinafter BME) changing venue
fr-m Las Vegas to Reno. The Court overlooked
0. misapprehended Judge Huffaker's ruling.
Judge Huffaker was attempting to afford the
BME an opportunity to correct their obvious
errors. He singled out the conduct which to him
represented an unquestionable abuse of their
power.
This Petition for Rehearing will be
addressed solely to the facts and law this Court
has overlooked or misapprehended. We will
show in this Petition that Judge Huffaker in his
Order only exposed the tip of the iceberg of the
arbitrary and capricious acts the BME
committed in these proceedings in violation of
NRS 233B.135(3) .
Misapprehended or Overlooked Facts
Dr. Bass’ initial answer to the petition for
Writ of Prohibition addressed itself primarily to
the authority of Judge Huffaker to remand the
74a
case to the BME, based solely upon the issue of
venue. Dr. Bass however did point out to the
Court in his Statement of the Case and Facts
that he had been found guilty for a mistake of
the United States Air Force [See pages 2 through
4 of Dr. Bass’ Answer| Dr. Bass believes that
the Court misapprehended or overlooked the
factual basis of the claim against him. A
timeline is necessary to avoid further confusion
concerning this matter.
11/17/86 Nellis Command issues an
12/3/86
order based on an alleged
military violation. The
penalty for that violation makes
it appear that it is a restriction
on Dr. Bass’ medical privileges.
Dr. Bass vehemently disagreed
with the order for the reason
that he believed the same was
based on fraud as well as racial
and professional bias. Dr. Bass,
shortly 2fter this Order, acivised the
USAF that he would not accept the
their proposed punishment and
that he wished to be released from
his contract.
Dr. Bass files an application with
Community Hospital. He responds
to questions concerning medical
restrictions in the affirmative.
He also explains that the
restrictions have no medical basis.
12/8/86 Dr. Bass files an application with
Desert Springs Hospital. He
responds to questions concerning
75a
medical restrictions in the same
manner as to Community Hospital.
12/18/86 Dr. Bass has a discussion with
the Commander who issued the
11/17/86 Order and Dr. Bass
receives from him a letter
explaining that this Order was
for military environment
adaption purposes only and was
not intended to reflect upon.
his conduct as a doctor. During
this discussion and during many
other discussions, Dr. Bass was
advised that military matters of
this nature were subject to the
Privacy Act. Dr. Bass realized he
did not have any restrictions or
limitations on his medical license
as are commonly understood. He
further believed that the USAF had
corrected the original misnomer
5/28/87 Effective date of discharge of Bass.
6/8/87
Dr. Bass files his application for
renewal of his medical license with
the BME and responds in the
negative to questions concerning
restrictions on his medical license
and privileges.
11/19/87 Dr. Bass files application with
Humana Hospital Sunrise and
responds in the negative to
questions concerning restrictions
on his medical license and
privileges. [an addendum was
76a
submitted to respond to a direct
question about the incident at
Nellis which came about by means
of medical community gossip.]
12/14/87 BME files a public complaint
1/12/88
against Dr. Bass concerning his
answers on the renewal application.
This was filed without any
investigation and further without
seeking any explanation from Dr.
Bass concerning his answers.
Dr. Bass files a Motion to Dismiss
[basis: violation of the Privacy Act,
S USC 552A as well as illegal and
malicious acts of persons unknown
to Bass at the time of filing his
motion.]
10/20/88 Brig. Gen. Buethe, Jr., Command
Surgeon, USAF, issued a decision
after reviewing the Command
Appeals Committee findings to
reinstate Bass' medical credentials
ab initio thereby voiding the Order
of 11/17/86
10/27/88 Bass files a supplement to his
Motion to Dismiss based on the
decision of Brig. Gen. Buethe, Jr.
1/22/89 Board denied Motion to Dismiss
8/6/91
Counts Two and Four
Board finds Bass guilty of Counts
Two and Four. However, in its
findings, deleted any reference to
77a
"false" statement as the Board
recognized that Dr. Bass' answers
were true. The Board felt that
the correct answer required an
additional explanation even though
their form did not call for the same
and unless specific questions were
addressed, a complete answer was
impossible.
Dr. Bass was charged by the BME in
Counts 2 and 4 as follows:
"Count Two. ..
IV. That Respondent's conduct in
failing to disclose the United States Air
Force's restriction on his practice
of medicine, constitutes a violation of
NRS 630.304(1) by renewing, or
attempting to renew, a license to practice
medicine by fraud or misrepresentation,
or by a false, misleading, inaccurate or
incomplete statement.:
Count Four
IV. That Respondent's conduct in
failing to disclose the suspension of
clinical privileges at United States
Air force Hospital, Nellis Air Force Base,
Nevada, constitutes a violation of NRS
630.304(1) by renewing,or attempting to
renew, a license to practice medicine
by fraud or misrepresentation, or by a
false, misleading,inaccurate or incomplete
statement." [emphasis provided]
Dr. Bass answered these counts of the
complaint as follows:
78
"SECOND DEFENSE (Count Two)
"3. In answer to Paragraph IV,
Respondent denies that
he violated NRS 630.304(1) as alleged in
that paragraph and in further answer
thereto, alleges that the answers that he
placed on his application for renewal of
medical license were placed there in a
good faith belief by the Respondent that
the Air Force incident was purely an
administrative procedure, for military
purposes only, and that its disclosure was
a violation of the Privacy Act, 5
USC 552A and further beyond the
jurisdiction of this Board, NRS
630.047(1){a)!. . .[{footnote added]
FOURTH DEFENSE (Count Four)
3. Respondent denies the allegations
contained in Paragraph IV, and in further
answer to said paragraph, realleges
Paragraph 3 of the Second Defense as
though set forth herein in its entirety."
The following is the violation that Dr. Bass
was found to be guilty of by the BME:
"That by clear and convincing evidence
Respondent is in violation of the
provisions of NRS 630.304(1) as alleged in
INRS 630.047(1)(a):
1. This chapter does not apply to:
(a) A medical officer of the armed services or a
medical officer of any division or department of the United
States in the discharge of his official duties for which a
license is not required;. .. ." [emphasis provided]
79a
Count Two and Count Four of the
amended complaint as he
submitted to the Board ‘misleading,
inaccurate or incomplete"
responses to questions number 4 and 5 on
his June 8, 1987 application for
licensure.” [emphasis provided]
[Record on Appeal, filed with Eighth
Judicial District Court, page 333, in Petition for
Judicial Review action before Judge Huffaker)
Misapprehended or Overlooked Legal
Authorities
Dr. Bass clearly told the BME that he did
not believe he had any restrictions on his
medical license or privileges on June 8, 1987
when he filed his application for renewal of his
medical license. He reaffirmed that position
when he filed his answer to the complaint. He
also clearly told the BME that the information
that they received from the USAF was the result
of fraud as well as malicious and illegal acts of
unknown persons [this is one of the usual basis
for setting aside fraudulent judgments.]
It is now also clear that the BME
recognized that Dr. Bass' answer was correct as
they deleted the words "fraud, misrepresentation
and false" from the charge when they entered
their findings. They relied instead on the words
“misleading, incorrect or incomplete." The
questions called for yes or no responses. An
explanation was only required if the question
was answered yes. Dr. Bass had arrived at his
opinion concerning his medical privileges long
80a
——— ey
before he filed his renewal application on June
8, 1987. No one had any knowledge that the
matter was going to be made public before June
30, 1987 when the USAF filed their mistaken
report with the Federation.
It would seem basic that the charges
against Dr. Bass should have been immediately
dismissed as a result of the Order of the United
States Air Force dated October 20, 1988.
Instead, the BME continued their arbitrary,
capricious and biased course of conduct and
found Dr. Bass guilty of a charge over which
they had no jurisdiction and upon which there
was no evidence of any violation.
"MS. SIMMONS: It would seem to me that
even if all that were true and reasonable, the
appropriate response to the question still
should have been "Yes", but with the
explanation of all of these other things that
happened, and the admission that the Air
Force made a mistake, and all that."
[Adjudication Hearing, June 7, 1991, ROA
Transcript 6, page 27, lines 15-19]
It is clear from reading the above reasoning of
the BME that they were requiring Dr. Bass to be
omniscient on June 8, 1987 concerning the
mistake the USAF was going to make on June
30, 1987 after he filed his Application for
Renewal; and that the USAF did not admit
making until October 20, 1988.
NRS 233B.135(3) provides:
The court shall not substitute its
judgment for that of the agency as to the
weight of evidence on a question of fact. The
8la
court may remand or affirm the final decision
or set it aside in whole or in part if
substantial rights of the petitioner have been
prejudiced because the final decision of the
agency is:
(a) In violation of constitutional
or statutory provisions;
{b) ‘In excess of statuory authority
of the agency:
(c) Made upon unlawful
procedure;
(d) Affected by other error of law:
(e) Clearly erroeneous in view of
the reliable, probativeand substantial
evidence on the whole record; or
() Arbitrarily or capricious or
characterized by abuse of discretion.
The decision of the BME was in excess of
its statutory authority and in direct violation of
NRS 630.047(1)(a). The only evidence in front of
the BME confirmed that this matter was military
and not medical. The plain meaning of NRS
630.047(1)(a) specifically prohibits the BME from
getting involved in military matters.
Besides the fact there is no evidence to
Support the charges of which Dr. Bass was
found guilty, the BME had apparent difficulty
understanding the meaning of the term "ab
initio." The case that appears closest on point
is United States v. Allen, 27 M.J. 234 [CMA
1988}. In that case, the accused was convicted
of making a false statement concerning his
marital status. His wife had obtained a divorce
in some fraudulent manner and the state court
who signed the Decree subsequently entered an
82a
order voiding the divorce ab initio. The accused
had signed his statements between the time of
the fraudulently obtained divorce decree and the
revocation of the same. The appellate court held
that it was a violation of the full faith and credit
provision of the United States Constitution
[Article IV, Section 1] and 28 USCA § 1738 to fail
to give full effect to the revocation [ab initio]
provisions of the Decree. The appellate court in
overruling the trial court's decision stated:
"He [the trial judge] surprisingly refused to
credit that portion of the revocation decree
that voids the earlier divorce decree ab initio.
He categorically asserted this decree could
not nullify the ‘action of an individual during
the period when North Carolina recognized
the parties as divorced.’ No authority.federal,
state or military was cited for this legal
conclusion."
Dr. Bass is here faced with the same
dilemma. The BME accepted the initial order of
the USAF, however, refused to give the
subsequent revocation order its true legal effect.
The initial order was corrected by the USAF on
10/20/88. The full faith and credit provisions of
the United States Constitution requires that
Nevada recognize the final determination of the
USAF--not prior orders. These charges must be
dismissed forthwith to prevent any further
prejudice.
The BME has been guilty of other
violations of NRS 233B.135(3). These are set
forth in Dr. Bass Points and Authorities in
support of his Petition for Judicial Review and
83a
included as Exhibit 11 in Dr. Bass' Appendix in
this action.
As indicated above, venue was just the tip
of the iceberg. The heart of the iceberg was
mere, Spgs Bass guilty of an offense for telling
e truth.
CONCLUSION
Although this Writ proceeding was
directed to the issue of venue, it is not only
appropriate but necessary that Dr. Bass point
out to this Court that he has been convicted of
telling the truth. That is not an offense under
Nevada law.
This Court in examining the venue issue
exclusively, determined that Dr. Bass was not
prejudiced by having the hearing in Reno. Even
Judge Huffaker had determined the prejudice to
be slight. However, what this Court is
overlooking is the concommitant effect of all the
arbitrary, capricious and biased conduct in the
proceedings toward Dr. Bass with the venue
issue being the tip of a massive iceberg.
The extreme delay in considering the very
simple issue of ab initio is enough for this
Court to step in and give Dr. Bass the relief he
deserved back in October of 1988.
Substantial justice dictates that this Court
grant the rehearing and dismiss the proceedings
against Dr. Bass on the entire record--not just
84a
venue. Alternatively, Dr. Bass would request
remand of the entire matter to Judge Huffaker
for further consideration of the entire record.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/R. Paul Sorenson
R. PAUL SORENSON
Nevada Bar No. 002124
513 South Sixth Street
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
Attorney for
Harriston Lee Bass, Jr., M.D.
Real Party in Interest
Se ey en
85a
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.