Petition for Writ of Mandamus — In re Moretti
Supreme Court brief1996
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(1) Supreme Court, U.8
FILED
$6 249 AUG 1 4 19%
OBR OF THE CLERK
NO.
SUPRME COURT OF
THE UNITED STATES
IN THE PETITION OF SALVATORE MORETTI
PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS
SALVATORE MORETTI,
Petitioner
PETER D. PIZZUTO, J.T.C.
Respondent
Salvatore Moretti
390 Park Street
Hackensack, New Jersey 97601
j , f 7
| i ac
QUESTIONS PRESENTED FOR REVIEW
Has the resvondent, Peter D. Pizzuto,
ge of the New Jersey Tax Court, shown
er disregard for the rule of law by his
usal to conduct a trial in the case of
Cy $4
> @ eo x,
or
> CC
th ot
Se vatore Morerti_v City of Hackensack,
Tax Court Docket No. 9479-95, after
petitioner cured the alleged
"“urisdictiona. defect" in the prior
S:iine of the identical case of Salvatore
Moretts ity of . Tex: Court
Docket No. 8336-93, [appealed to the New
Jersey Supreme Court, No. 41,120].
2 Does the refusal by Judge Peter D.
Pizzuto to hear the case before him amount
to a refusal to take jurisdiction because
the evidence offered proves a cause of
action against the City of Hackensack
sounding in inverse condemnation.
Has the refusal by Judge Peter D.
izzuto to hear the case before him deny
etitioner's federally protected rights
cranted to employment pursuant to the
federal minimum wage law, 29 U.S.C.A.
Sect. 206, applied by N. J. Stat. Ann.
34:1-20, and N. J. Administrative Code
12:56; and made applicabie to apartment
’ managers through I.R.S. Letter Ruling
8639049. |
0 (J
z
ii
II. Questions Presented ii
JUDGE PIZZUTO HAS BEEN PROVIDED 1
950 PAGES OF DETAILED REAL
ESTATE DOCUMENTATION AMPLYING
SETTING FORTH THE TAXATION
RELIEF SOUGHT, AND REPEATED
DENIALS ACT AS INVERSE
CONDEMNATION OF THE REAL
PROPERTY WHILE PERMITTING
SPECULATION IN PROPERTY VALUES.
CONCLUSION
He
4 a ae ts
patina ~
Oe ee ee
ice fi i a a tier oe
THE APPENDIX
1. Transcript of Proceedings
Before the New Jersey Tax
Court, Moretti vy. Hackensack,
Docket No. 9475-95, June 10,
ti to Presiding Judge
of New Jersey Tax Court, Michael
Andrews, July 25, 1996.
4. Moretti to Judge Peter D.
Pizzuto, J.T.C., July 5, 1996
5. Donald Lenner to Judge
Pizzuto, July 10, 1996.
6. Order Dismissing Complaint
with Prejudice, Moretti v.
Hackensack, 8336-93.
7. Petitioner Moretti to Judge
Ackerman, Federal Trial Court,
Moretti v. Hackensack 92-4206,
February 14, 1995.
8. Moretti to Judge Pizzuto,
Case 8336-93, November 4,
1994.
9, Preliminary Income Approach
to Value, November 5, 1994,
iv
=
Ui
25
31
37
tJ ia e
+
qt
(D
a)
a)
O
U1
by’
“<
1 Moretti to Hackensack, in re
Evasive Answers, 8336-93, Novem-
per 4, 1994.
Wi
<
of Hackensack.
i3. Moretti to Judge Pizzuto,
December 31, 1994, 8336-93,
Motion to Impose Restraints
on Collection of Taxes.
14. Moretti to Judge Pizzuto,
January 5, 1995, Notice on
Events from Jan. 1992 to
March 31, 1993
15. Market Data from Hacken-
sack SR1-A Forms, 1991-1994.
6. Motion for Temporary
Restraints on Collection of
Taxes, 9479-95, Renewal of
Prior Motion [8336-93] after
Appearance Before County
Board of Taxation. January
12,1996
17. The Water Bill Overcharg-
Vv
cy
ul
OY
Ul
94
109
433
125
es, March 29, 1996.
18. Marking cf Documents,
Taking of Evidence, 9479-95
Before Tax Court, July 5, 1996
Moretti to Judge Pizzuto.
19. Housing Violations Notice,
Petitioner to Hackensack April
20, i396.
vi
STATEMENT OF BASIS FOR JURISDICTION
The jurisdiction of the United States
Supreme Court to grant this writ is
invoked pursuant to 28 U. S. C. Section
1651(a). Petitioner contends that the
Respondent Judge Peter D. Pizzuto has
twice refused to hear the case before him
[which New Jersey Federal Trial Judge
Harold A. Ackerman claimed presented a
case for speedy relief afforded (App. 29)
in the State tax court system Moretti v.
Hackensack 92-4206(HAA). The federal trial
court refused jurisdiction, requiring this
mandamus to require the state tax court to
proceed expeditiously to conclusion in the
matter before it.
vii
Partition de
1 li 5 lilt is CM ABE: ld SMA tink se” ka el lee ii. bei
LEGAL ARGUMENT
JUDGE PIZZUTO HAS BEEN PROVIDED
950 PAGES OF DETAILED REAL ESTATE
DOCUMENTATION AMPLYING SETTING
FORTH THE TAXATION RELIEF SOUGHT,
AND REPEATED DENIALS ACT AS
INVERSE CONDEMNATION OF THE REAL
PROPERTY WHILE ~ PERMITTING
SPECULATION IN PROPERTY VALUES.
Twice petitioner has appeared ready
for trial before New Jersey Tax Court
Judge Peter D. Pizzuto [App. 1, 10; App.
23). Prior to both trial appearances,
8336-93 and 9479-95, motions had been
filed to invoke temporary restraints on
the collection of taxes by the City of
Hackensack(App. 65, App. 80, App. 94,
App.113). The emergent nature of these
restraints was noted(App. 3), so as to
expedite decision. Judge Pizzuto first
claimed a prior appearance was required
before the county tax board since the
jurisdictional limit of $750,000 was not
met. Upon subsequent appearance January
10, 1996, Judge Pizzuto claimed that he
was required by "custom" to dismiss
because of a lack of evidence cognizable
1
by the court. The judge stated that his
court was not a small claims court (Apr
Judge Pizzuto dismissed the fact that
Petitioner testified at length for four
days before Judge Evers in the New Jersey
Tax Court in 1981 in a prior tax appeal of
taxes on the same property. Subsequently,
Lt3 received hi Juris Doctor
ree. Petitioner published a newsletter
aparz=ment owners for several years,
equiring extensive research in the
subject of housing. The subject matter of
the case before the tax court calls for
multi-disciplinary expertise.
Petitioner claims that the standard
here invoked is discriminatory, in that
the Mason Appraisal (App. 66-74) upon
which Hackensack relied for its real
property assessment, was clearly
deficient. Mason compared the subject
property to high-rise zoned apartments to
achieve his land value. Judge Pizzuto
failed to reach the distinguishing
characteristics of a taking cause of
action by ignoring the description of the
tenancy [ App. 131-139], water overcharges
[App. 126-128], or the distinctive real
2
res
property speculation in residential units,
[App. 109-112].
Judge Pizzuto states in his oral
opinion his bias, "the property in
question is of significant value...And
therefore the complaint must be
dismissed." He does not state the basis
for this opinion, claiming rather that the
municipal assessment is by presumption
correct. Has not that presumption been
challenged? Does not the burden of proof
shift to Hackensack? How has Hackensack
responded?
In a letter to the Bergen County Tax
Board and judge Pizzuto, petitioner
revealed that his single family house was
classed in the 1987 revaluation on the
current Hackensack property record card [
Block 415, Lot 8.b] as a two family
(requiring at minimum two kitchens) ,
thereby resulting in a higher assessment.
The source of this error on the property
record card is alleged to be petitioner
himself. The municipality is being
measured by different standards than
petitioner. Perhaps judge Pizzuto believes
that the tax appeal should be tried by a
small claims court because it's value is
3
ig
“Sa
{)
its
a
Should not
job training so that
estate
ionize
+
tenants unde
-paying
ess statutes.
4s
on
no
provide
in need can keep their apartment-
~
—
oO
disposs
New Jersey does not have un
~ +a
eilstea te base
~ S62 ee
e
ss
summary
those
homes.
wn
TRANSCRIPT OF
TAX
JERSEY
MORETTI v..
COUR’
9475095.
PETER D.
TRANSCRIP’
PIZZUTO
tna comes
appral sers
Courtroc
‘
m t
Wao
+ \ -
with the ru
r7-25. More
LS expert
. }, + a
wel1laqnt wnhl1c
different gs
‘ 4 -~« T _
ri518 Jude
T
-
)
PROCE
IN
CITY OF HACKE
M( \T
iN’ 4
sa)
‘
>
li
7
}
>
ian
A j
y
Lti
: }
:
LCi
+4
{
:
; ‘
it i
Die
I
:
ry,
WY 4
,
‘
V
} }
| J
j
" ;
Yr]
|
a
~~ +
i
.
.%
|
; ,
tee
~
Fa
+ *y
THE
ince
+
~~.
|
*
App. 2
the analysis to support these values.
O. Judge Pizzuto. I think there a
tnree alternatives that have emerged right
now aS to how to proceed...dismiss this
casSe...Or conclude hat Mr. Moretti has
over the course of the years that these
properties have been at issue in this and
I
2
.
2
cr?
b
(
J
su
J
Q
ct
cy
1)
ry
01)
fh Ph
O
mR Oo
a
wy
y ~~
2
z ht
tH
40)
7 et
ct ry’
~~ @
9)
> s
O w
a
te ©
oo, @
hearing his testimony whether a reduction
has been established [or] The third
alternative is to say hat it appears tha
here is some obscurity in the materia
retti has provided t
Hackensack and that in order to assure hi
his day in Court and at the same time t
allow for fairness and adequacy of notic
to percep iets City we ought not to proceed
any further today, case ought not to be
dismissed because perhaps Mr. Moretti did
not totally understand what had to be done
or to this morning but at the same
Hackensack is not prepared to defend
inst his claims and rather what we
rey do on the third alternative is to
schedule a new day to proceed with the
ct
that Mr. Mo
no roms
vi be
3 be -
m
App. 3
case on the condition that Mr. Moretti
provides a summary of his value
contentions, his own appraisal report,
essentially given that he proposes to
testify as his own expert witness, that he
provide an appraisal report to the City of
Hackensack prior to returning.
T24-3. Moretti. The issue I brought forth
was the issue of inverse condemnation and
condemnation practice (involving testimony
by) a real estate appraisal professional
[familiar with the case] --
T24-11. MORETTI. This is an emergency
based on lack of mortgage funds
availability which requires that we have
testimony today and requires that we look
to the fact that this is an emergency in
which I have sought a withholding of tax
payments consented to by the municipality
to afford an opportunity to continue
operation of the building.
T28-9. Moretti. Let me briefly note. I
have been working on illegally parked cars
let 24 for 4 years with the City and
the City hasn't been any more helpful
recently than in the past in that process
of uncovering anything aside from what has
been already set forth to the Tax Court.
To spend another week summarizing lot 24
is not productive. That also applies to
the other 2 assessed parcels and the other
3 lots. So for this particular appeal the
App. 4
City has straight forward standard
appraisai reports based on actual
management, actual assessment of the
larket and cost approaches.
T31-6. Judge Pizzuto. I think what I'm
going to do right now, Mr.‘ Moretti, is
a..ow you cc testify concerning your
qualifications and I'm going to decide
wnetner or not you are capable of giving
an expert opinion in this case. An if I
aecide tnat you're capable of giving an
expert opinion, I will direct that you
prepare a report and come back on another
day and do that. And if I determine after
hearing you testify and be cross-examined
to your qualifications to give an expert
V
~ . } , ! _
Opinion tnat you can't give an expert
eo
Opinion, I will conclude that your case
must fail because you are rot qualified to
testify. So will you please come to the
witness stand and be sworn
T32-17. Moretti. I have owned property in
Hackensack and in New Jersey for over 50
years. I have invested I various types of
housing from the 1950's, '60's, '70's,
‘80's and '90's. I have sold housing nd I
have managed income expense figures in
computing IRS tax forms in computing
assessment analyses for business
establishments such as stores, factories,
apartment buildings, single family houses,
condominiums, vacant land, etc. I have
App. 5
researched deed documentation...I have
evaluated business practices and operates
businesses in many different forms such as
restaurant businesses, such as fact food
businesses, retail businesses. I have
also experience in construction, building
operations, such as the machanicals. As to
code evaluation I have been involved in
testifying in zoning disputes on matters
of factories, funeral parlors, churches,
vacant land, residential land, single
family houses, apartment houses,
hospitals, transportation, construction
practices involving fire, safety, health,
parking. I have involved myself actively
in the mechanicals as far as snow removal,
municipal equipment, trucking, as to
plumbing. I have over a period of 40 years
supervised plumbing, done all plumbing
requires on al emergency basis over a
period of 3 decades.
Contining at t35-2. Moretti. I have
testified before the New Jersey Department
of Transportation on transportation
relating to New Jersey Transit. I hve
prepared reports, all the Apartment Owner
s Association [newsletters] through the
1970's, 1980's, and 1990's. I've attended
meetings, seminars before the Institute of
Continuing Legal Education, the Society of
Real Estate Appraisers, the Society of
Independent Fee Appraisers. I have
‘RUA MMII ai
App. 6
prepared various reports for the law Court
throughout a 40 year period I have
attended hearings, testified before the
-ounty District Courts, Special Civil Part
oi the Superior Court, the Chancery Court,
the Superior Court Law Division and the
New Jersey Appellate Division ané4 prepared
Driefs and appendices for the New Jersey
Supreme Court, the United States Supreme
Ourt, the New York Trial Court in he
Ae : a
the Federal Second Circuit. I
red appeals in the Uni
uae ;
ct
vy
OQ,
09)
ct
07)
ct
(D
”
Court of Appea ror the Federal Circuit
of the Second Circuit and have
participated in Third Circuit - Federal
appeals from the United States District
court for the Third Circuit and on appeal
up to the United States Court of Appeals
in Philadelphia, which encompasses
Philadelphia Pennsylvania, which
encompasses New Jersey, which encompasses
all Third Circuit matters, which also I
believe involves the irgin Islands. I
have done research for at least a period
of 40 years, such research as is available
iin written form] in the Law Courts, and
1s available from the Institute of Real
Estate Management in Chicago, the
Institute of Real Estate Appraisal, which
has its bases in Chicago, Illinois. I have
subscribed to the various journals of the
property management associations, to
App. 7
property appraisal associations, and to
accounting associations. I have done
research in accounting procedures over a
period of 40 years, both handling actual
income/expense analyses and reporting to
government, reporting to federal and state
government agencies, such as the Internal
Revenue Service, the state inspections for
city codes, state code analysis such as
the state inspectors for industrial
property and residential property and
retail and commercial property over a6
period of 40 years, in particular
restaurants, fast food items such as food,
ice cream, sale of frozen items to
retailers, commercial users. I have been
actively involved in preparation for
certification in accounting,
certification in real estate sales,
certification in teacher's licensure for
proprietary establishments. I have
published various newsletters which have
been circulated in the northeast on
housing, inflation, rent control, law
reform, legal decisions, decisions by
Boards of Adjustment and rent
Stabilization board thorough out all
communities in the State of New Jersey, I
have attended at least 50 seminars by the
Society of Real Estate Appraisers...I have
attended universities in Washington, D.C.,
New York City, and New Jersey. I have both
an Associate Def RR’ “and a Bachelor's
Degree. [I have a law degree from New York
Law. School}.
T37-18. Moretti. I have prepared reports
and submitted applications for loans on
various projects over a period of 40 years
for retail, industrial, housing projects.
I've secured .loans for construction,
plumbing, electrical projects for 40
years. I have supervised landscaping
projects for a period of over 40 years as
to landfill, exterior maintenance,
roofing, windows, drive way maintenance,
asphalt repaving, concrete work,
landscaping, fenestration. I have
maintained boilers, both of the low
pressure hot water type, and gas burners
over a period of 40 years. I have
evaluated feasabiliy studies both as far
as the condemnation appraisal practice or
on-going business practice. The issue
between the two, of course, is that in
condemnation appraisal practice one is
foreclosed from certain Options such as
when an on-going business which could go
on for 50 years based on a positive cash
flow is shut down. [In other cases] the
problem concerning condemnation appraisal
is that you have a large number of
business failure and you have high tenant
turnover. You have business management
problems as to excessive hours, inadequate
App. 9
wage per hour, poor working conditions, a
conflict in policy between various forms
of government in which the state seeks to
take over the property for highway usage
or the property is rezoned for different
classifications from 1 to 5 where they
will demolish single family housing and
replace them with factories or retail
businesses or for other Type 4 classes.
T40-20. Moretti. I have attended municipal
hearings on the revision of the zoning
code to allow for the creation of the high
rise district along Prospect and Overlook
streets, the development of zoning and
planning involved in the Center City
Project, and of course the revise master
plan submission of review reports by
planers such as Kren.
T41-15. Moretti. I have been involved in
the educational system in both New Jersey
and New York in grammar schools, high
schools, colleges, law schools, technical
schools, and scientific schools. I've done
about four years of laboratory work in
physics, chemistry, biology, psychology,
and sociology.
T42-22. Moretti being cross-examined): I
secured experts and interviewed experts
for testimony in he 19780's, 1980's, up to
the present. I interviewed people in real
estate appraisal from the SREA (Society of
Real Estate Appraisers), the IREA and the
App. 10
IFA and other organizations.
796-17. Moretti. £& have attempted to
schedule continuing [education] courses
both in the legal community and the
appraisal community and in addition the
accounting community. ...I work at least
an 85 hour week and I have very little
Spare tie left over to spend with my
family.
T57-6. Moretti. I'm sure at the end of the
Kovatz school they gave a test on real
estate salesperson and I passed.
T60-24. Lenner: [let me ask you a
hypothetical question about the appraisal
of high rise apartments] What information
would you request and how would you go
about preparing an appraisal report for
that client.
T61-3. Moretti. ...age of
construction...the history of the
occupancy, the income range of the
tenants, the employment of the
tenants...are there one year leases, two
year leases, three year leases, what are
the escalator clauses...are there
Saunas...what are the lease concessions on
Such items as parking, pool, what type of
security exists on the premises...the
condition of the rugs...what is the
depreciation of the building components...
T72-7. Judge Pizzuto. Then I shall decide
at this point whether or not Mr. Moretti
, ad App- 11
is qualified to be an expert in this case.
And my conclusion is that I should not
deem Mr. Moretti to have established the
requisite expertise by way of experience
and qualifications to be able to submit to
the Court a credible, cogent, reasoned and
persuasive opinion as to the value of
property. My reasons are that although
Mr. Moretti has some experience in real
estate, although he has legal education
and although he has managed property he
has not demonstrated (sic) and although he
hs some familiarity with appraisal
concepts and terminology he has_ not
demonstrated that he has functioned as a
real estate appraiser other than with
respect to the submission of tax appeals
with respect to his own properti4es. He's
not licensed, he is not--does not possess
designations from any of the appraisal
societies. He has not performed appraisal
assignments for paying clients and has not
testifed on behalf of anyone else.
Moreover, his demeanor during the course
of the entire proceeding this morning,
but in particular during he court of the
voir dire concerning his expertise,
indicates to me that the witness has
difficulty in focus and in analysis and in
cogency. His answers have been lengthy
and disjointed and have not confined
themselves to relevant subject matters and
And
+
Ty
+
the value
no purpose
ue.
~
>
eo)
Lenner
12
that
va
Mr.
onvinced
icant
App.
given.
=
n by
signi
_
_—
pe
,
Q
ert
Q,
ive an ex
to gi
attaching
+
smissed.
correctness
~
e)
t be di
Ss
}
,
(ike
13
F
App.
URT
NEW
{)
—
)
.
~,
v
AX
mi)
2
_—
Ove
~
¢
Aw
~
ye
+
~
“-y
,
J
~
J
Y)
rr
cre
©
mat
tc
h
~
=
;
wy
App. 15
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
July 25, 1996
Michael A. Anderws, P. i ee
25 West Market Street
n, New Jersey 08625
Re.: Salvatore Moretti -v. City Of
Hackensack, No. 9479-9 on
- Bl 418, Lots 22 and 23. Parcel Two
- B1 418, Lot 24, Parcel E
415, Lot 8.b. Motion Return Date
£ ;
June 10, 1996, Berore Juage Peter D
D> ; T 7vT Ras D
Pizzuto, J.T , Real Property
Assessment for 1995 iax rear
-~— ~~ . 4 ’ ~ = .
The above captioned case invoives
appea jled November 8, 1995. The same
le 4 k f Yé t+ }
4
4
4
4
3
x om
fact pattern had been fi
n county tax board in 1991, whi
“~~ - . - : ] ~ ~ .
permittea a slignt qaecreast
App. 16
assessment. Since the case involved
complex matters, the case was then brought
before the United States District Court.
Scott Topolski represented the City of
Hackensack, and stated in his motion to
dismiss the state would provide the relief
requested. Following Topolski's brief in a
written opinion, Judge Harold A. Ackerman,
J.U.S.D.C. held that the state could
provide speedy tax relief. The court
therefore denied granting jurisdiction.
Even before the written opinion was filed
I filed directly with the New Jersey Tax
Court - the motions to dismiss had been
filed while the assessment was over
$750,000 on block 418, lots 22 and 23.
Judge Pizzuto denied jurisdiction - the
City was represented by Donald Lenner,
Esq. I appealed this case, Docket No.
8336-93 to the appellate division, A-4913-
94-T2, and then to the Supreme Court of
New Jersey , Docket No. 41,120, and
finally to the U;. S. Supreme Court, No.
95-1587.
The next case I filed with the Bergen
County Tax Board, involving the same three
parcels. The Board upheld the assessment
of the City of Hackensack by judgment
dated September 13, 1995. I filed with the
N. J. Tax Court, Docket No. 9479-95, and
on June 10, 1996 at a motion hearing,
App. 17
Judge Pizzuto determind that he would not
proceed to trial for the suggested reason
that he refused to accept the testimony of
petitioner as expert testimony. I _ had
submitted a somewhat detailed 950 page
report describing the subject real
property. The state had just made an
inspection of the residential apartments
and had issued a lengthy report on the
housing conditions thereat. I sought to
have this marked as well as the lengthy
appraisal reports I submitted. Judge
Pizzuto refused to mark any exhibit, and
instead insisted that I qualify myself as
an expert. My position was that the
materials provided should be given such
weight as they were entitled, so that we
might reach the merits of the case.
My position is that the New Jersey Tax
Court's failure to reach the merits of
this case due to procedural hurdles s a
denial of due process. The five years of
filings seeking to decrease assessment is
sed on the tripling of assessed value in
~J @
1 Block 415, Lot 8.b is a single
family house which appears on the property
record card of the municipality as a two
family. The city has not even provided an
appraisal report of the subject property,
but insists upon maintaining the property
assessment.
I am providing the transcript of
18
_APp-
his cas
oe
—
in
ngs
.
1
~
d
> ee & cee
Y
&
ana
mice l +
thiWwow
~
L
as
rom which
<
a
-
—
judgmen
I require a
itten
a
~
W
|
settle
~
aiSo
ed above.
-
—
not
Y)
O
'é)
”
App. 19
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
July 5, 1996
Hon. Peter D. Pizzuto, J.T.C.
125 State Street
Room 108
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Re.: Moretti v. City of Hackensack, No.
9479-95; Parcel One - Bl 418, Lots
22 and 23. Parcel Two - Bl 418, Lot
24, Parcel Three, Bl 415, Lot 8.b.
Motion Return Date June 10, 1996
Judge Pizzuto:
a,
1)
9)
Kh
On June 10, 1996 at a motion in the
above captioned matter, I endeavored to
mark for the record documents which had
been delivered to the Tax Court and to the
defendant. Mr. Lenner, on behalf of the
defendant City of Hackensack, refused to
have any documents marked prior to the
motion hearing. At the motion hearing, I
Suggested receiving into evidence the
documents which I had transmitted to the
New Jersey Tax Court, so that a list of
@
App. 20
Said documents would appear of record.
Instead, your Honor proceeded into the
question of whether outside expert
testimony would be offered as to the value
of the property under appeal, and whether
or by whom testimony would be taken.
While the determination at the end of
the motion hearing was couched in terms
relating to several alternatives, it is
not clear whether the court decided to
take additional testimony from parties to
be called by the Court itself or Mr.
Lenner, or whether Mr. Lenner would be
putting on his case.
Since the determination of the Court
ear (1s the court waiting for me to
call an expert witness upon whom I will
rely?), I suggest that Mr. Lenner set
forth in an order what the City of
Hackensack's position is. Should issues
be raised therein which are in dispute, a
hearing may be conducted, or perhaps a
final order should be offered with
opportunity to state plaintiff's position.
Very truly,
(s) Salvatore Moretti, Plaintiff Pro Se
cc: Donald Lenner, Esq. (On Behalf of
City of Hacknsack)
App. 21
DONALD J. LENNER
Attorney At Law
286 Union Street
Hackensack, N 07601
Member N.J. & N.Y. Bars
Tel. (201) 343-6660
Fax (201) 343-2929
July 10, 1996
The Hon. Peter D. Pzzuto, J.T.C.
Tax Court of New Jersey
125 State Street
Hackensack, NJ 07601
RE: SALVATORE MORETTI v. HACKENSACK
Docket No. 009479-95
Block 418, Lots 22 & 23
Block 418, Lot 24
Block 415, Lot 8.b
Dear Judge Pizzuto:
am in receipt of a copy of Mr.
Moretti's letter of July 5, 1996, to Your
Honor. Contrary to the statement in the
firs sentence of the letter's third
paragraph, I believe the Court's decision
was quite clear. The court put forth
I
by
~
han
+
—
O
ather
1cations
re
>
+
22
he method agreed t
qualif
pert
r
a
x
e
5)
o
App.
WF
a
+
—
la’
avin
et
440
YH v Ww CUE UVWUO YD 1 HOD
G& Q & ee ee ae oe ee oe
= * geet a W yw rs d Wi B
Y) O UY) = ’
M Wi > Vv
W . © ~ 1
- Uw yg <2 0 @ >
a r— = — ed = 4
“3 E < iJ TS 4 - rier 4
O O =) hy a ri OW 3 4 © fi,
iJ i aes m4 zs o re © UY)
SC Fuga nM “4 ~ Oo
~4 .
is ONG 4 o = WM oo
4 Bo a m -re4 wv =
ee ) r . f
a o@ae86 2 545
OD ww O co ae oO ¥ M -r Y
Sc ov ie) 5 Qo,7 Oo. Ged Hae
. ‘ 4 | oss
a & O rb) 7 « ie Vv 3s is)
OO,» tH T HO E oa,
“4 ~~ vw @ g® 4 0) * ‘)
cS - © wo >» 5 So 4 = ‘i
e9oegg 2H ow § wv
a7 nN ss O 67) -
ere - Be S006 @ 2 oS
. Se F 2s E Sut kG 8 Oo : hy O
y A. ao Oo,’ ie ri} QO. cs U P oH Ww Ss
0 k < = w 2 WY a3 4 o wv co
eo 3 W = W 5 2 . . wv
“wee ,_.# a co 0 = > v hy
a eo 78s Oe - cd 4 O
G TG = J GS v i) he ro 4J
POHaDGAYM OL au 3 ©
rt O m by 1 we oe, © 4H ry >
Yj yy G4 Y) -r4 O Be. 4 = 4J oe |
: - 3BYT QH U OD QO, ©
1 --4 ae ae vs © bd, |
Br WW O am 6 uy ) G 0) rt n Ww
re} OW S rt © iJ O wv O Q, 40)
3 V Veri . Ss” @ = o4 ” = —
Sb MEO v = o q O OU
v HAnw& = pp E OU 13 Mm AQ A UV
hy i Hon vU Ww TG -c
@ pe D jJ 0) a am | ed by bly i qd
Ov nn H TAH WNW w& Q {
“~ O-d WH CADW PO ~~ oa oS
> FS a i q GT OO UY 2, 1 ™&%
App. 23
Dismissal by Trial Court, N. J. Tax Court,
Feb. 7, 1995
Donald J. Lenner, Esq.
286 Union Street
Hackensack, N. J. (01) 343-6660
Attorney for Defendant
Salvatore Moretti, TAX COURT OF N.J.
Plaintiff DOCKET NO. 008336-93
Vv.
City of Hackensack, ORDER DISMISSING
Defendant COMPLAINT WITH
PREJUDICE
Final Judgment under R, 8:9-1
THIS MATTER being opened to the Court
on the application of Donald J. Lenner,
Esq., attorney for Defendant, and the
Plaintiff having appeared Pro Se, and the
Court having considered the papers filed
and the arguments of counsel for the
Defendant and of the Plaintiff Pro Se, and
it being the finding of the Court that
there was a failure of the Plaintiff to
exhaust his administrative remedies and
meet the jurisdictional requirements of
N.J.S.A. 54:3-21 for a direct appeal to
the Tax Court; that the litigation history
does not excuse the Plaintiff's failure to
timely file a complaint with the Tax Court
for the tax year 1991 or timely file a
App. 24
complaint with either the county board of
taxation or the Tax Court for the tax year
1992; and for good cause shown,
IT IS on this 7th day of February,
1994,
ORDERED THAT the complaint in the
above matter is hereby dismissed with
prejudice.
S Peter D. Pizzuto, Judge
"T ~ a> f i cath ae
App. 25
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
February 14, 1995
Hon. Harold A. Ackerman, J.U. S. D. C.
United States District Court
U. S. Federal Courthouse & Post Office
Building
Newark, New Jersey 07102
re: Salvatore Moretti Vv. City of
Hackensack, et al., Civil Action No. 92-
4206 (HAA)
Dear Judge Ackerman
On June 21, 1993, Your Honor entered
an order dismissing the above captioned
lawsuit. The basis for your dismissal of
the action against the City of Hackensack
was that there were remedies in the state
court system. Your exact words follow:
"Moretti also alleged that the Council
conspired to fix the assessed value
of his property in excess of its actual
value, thereby depriving him of his
ownership rights. This court is barred
from hearing this claim, however, for
lack of subject matter jurisdiction.
App. 26
(Although the factual allegations set
forth in this count refer to unidentified
‘defendants, ' the demand for relief
contained in this names only the City
Council. In either case, however, the
aim must pe dasmissed because this
court iacks subject matter jurisdiction.)
The Tax Injunction Act Oe
provides that:
Jhe district courts shall not
in, suspend or restrain the
ssment, levy or collection of any tax
e a plain, speedy and efficient
y may be had in the court of = such
28 U.S.C. Section 1341. The
ipal purpose of the Act is to limit
ederal court interference with local tax
matters. Hardwick v. Cuomo, 891 F.2d 1097,
1104 (3d Cir. 1989) (git3 Liforni 4
Grace Brethren Church, 457 U.S. 393, 411
\1982)). The United States Supreme Court
has interpreted this statute as
prohibiting federal courts from granting
injunctive relief, see Rosewel) v..
mo WwW
ys cr @
@» F
3
? @m
LaSalle National Bank, 450 U.S. t03,
522 (1981), as well as declaratory
relief, see California v. Grace Brethren
Church, 457 U.S. 393, 408-11 (1982), as
long as there is a "plain, speedy and
27
available
App.
w)
rj
O
4
“A
on
ras
ry
Court and the
Supreme
declined
the
oth
mM
cry
and
Ss
=
-
+
provide
‘
earing
Es
camer
‘So!
pee.
"
5 |
rm
aa
ese
Ace
pal ©
it
have
Mm
Ba Of
Se ee eT
ry
_*
r
~ +
a eh eben
1
Need LADY —
an
—_
.
Wi)
App. 28
determination at which [the taxpayer] may
raise any and all constitutional
objections.'" Hardwick, 891 F. 2d at
aavo. { bi orac reraren, 457 U.S. at
412
New Jersey provides several
remedies which afford the plaintiff an
Opportunity to raise all constitutional
objections to the allegedly wrongful
property assessment. For example,
N.J.S.A. 94:3-21 also provides that if
the assessed value of property exceeds
9750,000. the taxpayer may file a
complaint directly with the tax court.)
If a party is dissatisfied with the county
board's determination, he or she may seek
judicial review of the determination by
iling a complaint in the tax . court.
.J.S.A. 54:51A-1. Thus, New Jersey law
rovides for an administrative
determination, as well as judicial review
of that determination.
A taxpayer, moreover, is not limited
to this review procedure. New Jersey
also has aé_e statute providing for
declaratory judgment actions. See
N.J.S.A. 2A:16-53. See Sipe, 689 F. 2d at
405. Finally, a plaintiff may bring a
Section 1983 action in state court.
See. Peper v. Princeton University Board
of _ Tructees, 77 N.J. 55, 74 (1978) (New
Jersey courts have the jurisdiction to
App. 29
interpret federal statutes and decide
federal Claims) ; see - imber
- ‘ ea ; snc
y Z e J S } , Zz Vv 5
N.J.Super. 273 (Law Div. 1985) (Section
1983 action). New Jersey, therefore,
provides sufficient remedies affording
plaintiff the opportunity to raise any
onstitutional objections to the real
operty tax assessment. See Fai?
Assessment, 454 es at 116-17
(availability of state court Section 1983
action supports withholding of federal
Jurisdiction) ; Long Island Lighting Co.
vy. Town of Brookhaven, 889 F. 2d 428,
622. 426 «Git. 1989) (same) ; Sipte, 689
2d at 405-08 (adequate remedy where state
court has jurisdiction to decide federal
claims). Because New Jersey provides a
plain, complete and adequate remedy, this
court lacks jurisdiction over any claim
regarding the allegedly wrongful]
property value...For all these reasons,
the claims against the City Council will
be dismissed."
m z TT Pine o.cee 4 -
Even before your final written
Aariaes ft ~~ Wackencac] —— eS |
QecC1s1ion, a Ler MaVCLAGCISaACA WY Wid TUS U
Mars apa ee :
urisdiction in the state Tax Court I
7
filed in that court. Hackensack pursued
remedy in that court until the "thirtenth
hour, (November, 1994), when after
2)
conducting discovery for eleven months, it
i
laimed there was no jurisdiction in
. wr ~ -
+ ~~ ~ a e - Ho
. qa ww & ‘ A 4 . o ‘ es
. 1.2) - ~ emrce + + _—- 5 Ay
‘ A ‘ : Aws a oe a» % 4 o a is
.> _ ++ 7. | ra ~~ We ~ ss ~hae tat hh oko anrararA —
A A es » y ad ~ * y wa SAL w \F kh em 4 aah - A Ada
- + ~ . r + “a > a | Ff
’ ¥: , %7 CTY Co ’ ~ ary) » O94 we Lae
me A ‘ L wA A Wil « sed nim WAL Y ; ~ ;
“) 7 ~ =e = & » ~
. ae tae | mo - >} y ¢ ~ a Yammer
a 4 ¥ ri shi - ~ + s+’ * & 4 4% ~ > tin. = .
TT ~ - _ - ~ oo T ~
sf -? Y ‘*— c& A TY
Waa + we ad a SO, + CALL
— <* _—_-..T. - +ho = i oh: ~ Ciimmsa rv a £ -~hpa
him V ANA = * wad we Whe a wo MICA L / 4 sir
~ 4
. + ~ “ —o _- + Ae ~ - + ~ ~ —+ ~~ - ,
) ‘ , } C - ryry erty He Cc a = %
CA. et Au « wWHMuyiiia & LOU ae & Se wLaALS —~ Al.
— “A reciiesc ~ Ho > — —
aw & CArava am we WA AK a aa Am wile —
co -aSaYyrmane wihast ce , HoOnnr - -
A . om mad Will & y\lae a4 ssi ——_
- ~~” 1. —~ - -. — - or > . ~ . -
=_* . 2° .— — “Har 2Sc o> Fam c >
/ aa —— + +" Aw V ee ee ee Se ene | Aor ~~ CE ee a |
. ~ + , lie -
i on a5 =
~ + We ~- +
» . ¥ ¥ io
w A a Av 4 sam WO me
** CAN + *T ~y C Of won > > ~ >
. ~— . i & - ~ —~wssam mtu WA « - AeCKA & A —
. > ~_— ~ Le ) te. . i. " -
- x YT — . ~ ¢ “<é pm | ,
6iGa VS 44D Qarcrn, 4 442 Ad mw WZ Ae
abe ~~ eanneayr » Ory t-te 7 ?
A/W/ad m \A ade head a at A so —~ ai oe — +
— - =
rane ~ Le C+ - . on &
> ; he , » = kk ~ 2 >
-- A » -4* “4 \ a | _— . - — “ + X
App. 31
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
November 4, 1994
Hon. Peter Pizzuto, J.T.C.
125 State street
Room 108
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
re: Salvatore Moretti Vv.
Hackensack, Docket No. 833693; Parc
18, Lots 22 and 23. Parcel
i)
at , p | ba) o oo FR ae ba) _
juagment of the Bergen County Tax Boa
he ot Cc — > Ic } es :
as not been forwarded to you - this is a
~ ro a | 700 ~~ -
direct appea Since the 1992 assessment
~- ro ~ [ f\ /
was over $750,000
- ae : . em
I trust that upon further
Amn) micatione }
~ UnLcations
. . . , ,
i; " > ") +
“ . : i ’ : rar ,
‘ A = a &y CALA km « i Aad iv .
’ + . Ma ’
i ¢ ’ r\¢ » a DAMN YAacacse . < ; , «
. » . y " 4 A *- * . a
+ i. + Ly . Le 7 » Lp AT ’ , .
. > ) K ¢ } \ ;
aa ca » + ine Te | -y AN 4 . ‘
\ . - . “ a & ‘ Aas « Wasa 4 ot 4 . ¥ ai
J "oar n (= 2 5 ale ty "+ >
A * saw & . * ~ ~ CA .
’ ; ‘ s A hae y
i _ + + “2a? san 4 + ee 2 — f — >
— 4 ‘ ° A Aaa a he ra mn . RA ANA os
“y "Soman Ly ~+ ee ,
‘ . . . ~*¥ > a a ~ e
< Ye Y ray ~~ c& ¢ Yr) ? ss
ire —s ad LwWoto. A .’
. 1 mr> .% ry ~ +
a A+ A . , - '
“ ; > “ , «
é ; > 4 '
— ‘ 5 Z ; me be
< ; . ws de ad b
P ‘ _ eo Wa
4 — ~ - 7 ‘
n @OUV, UVLK me
" Ar AnRr --a « ’
» C bd >< ‘
" aC ; . i Se |
» a ‘ff ¥
a&OUV, ’ e
a »
- = 7 ae he = .
C - or
& t
>t
rw)
Cc
K
33
95 Par
App.
_
© |
squir
nsack ac
we
.
»
e |
ack
} J
MOoOmnmMmoaonodqwnowwnooa0oa0onm
= N c . >) . Oo <7" Cc oc
Cc q f
© f¢ ny OH of’ & ee ° ct
~ ~ ~ << ~ {~ ~ ~ co .~ CO
C NAH NONNMN DOM M HAM oO em
~ ~ ™| ~ ~© ~ © a on s)
» J
Om a ew rs Ort NAN ci Ww -
ri
© Cc ee > c>
<
C Cc) ‘ Cc CE) <
. . » WV /
t > >
~ cl ~ & ~ .) -~ & -~ '~ ri Ww ed
t ~e
f , ¥
Li) \ us) \ f J " ) © @) ~ oa ~
fad re mn oO v) J ¥ ; ¢ ; Oo J
App. 34
Deed Information: 387 Park Street,
ckensack, acquired 2/28/85 (Bk. 6902, P.
780). Stabilized Rental Income and
Expenses Park Court Apartments, 391-397
Park St., Hackensack 20 units. Three
\ rooms, one bedroom, one living room, one
kitchen. one bathroom. Heat and hot water
included. Parking included. Stabilized
Income/Expense Statement Income Average
rental income per month collectible is
set at $437.50. Annual rental income
computes to $105,000
Income re ae re ere a he ee $105,000
eed eee ee ar ee 46,175
ARVETEAGADES CCtAIA Ss CeO be hers 300
RRL: & TEMG iwc ai a oa ke ae we 3000
ERRUSOUOCR a oi a ee oe ee a 8970
Repairs & Maintenance.......... 6600
SURDLARE Cakes Cake VET a ee 2000
REAR CAG sus 6 oe eae eee ee 25000
ae pe LRT Te eee Pe eee Oe 7000
OFEICO BROOROGSs si 40 ccna een 7000
Legal & Professional.......... 5000
Total Expenses $64870
Depreciation 11305
Exp. & Deprec....$76175
Net Profit before Local Property Taxes
ei rere 105,000;Exp. & Deprec.
76,175.Before Taxes) Net Profit.28,825
Overall tax rate:10% 28,825/.10 = $288,250
App. 35
(Municipal Real Estate Taxes Charged in
1994 = $26,636.62]
BL0Ge 429, Lets 2s & 29... $23,016.20
PiGCe Gh0, BOE 26. dé ccs bean 3,620.42
$26,636.62
(Net Net under present taxation]:
Net Income before Tx. $28,825
Taxes Charged 26,636.62
App. 36
PARCEL ONE
391-397 PARK STREET
BLOCK 418, LOTS 22 AND 23
CITY OF HACKENSACK
BERGEN COUNTY
NEW JERSEY
PARCEL TWO
387 PARK STREET
BLOCK 418, LOT 24
CITY OF HACKENSACK
BERGEN COUNTY
AS OF: OCTOBER, 1992
SUBMITTED BY:
PROPERTY OWNER -
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
: HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
App. 37
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE
IDENTIFICATION OF SUBJECT
PRUNEMERS bc une wee es 1
oO
'p
4
>
N
CRIPTION OF
POO MONE EED © bk 6b wb 0s 0 bree He we 3
INCOME APPROACH TO
0 —” ra
RE} REQU ST FOR INFORMATION FROM
MATERIALS
it soe SP a a ee 7
LOCK AND LOT LOCATION IN
n
ne
wm td
AS)
(ry
ya
oO
ty
Oo
GF 6 tO KOs RAO KO ae Oe ke E Be bee 9
SURVEY OF BL.418, L. 24 (BEFORE
oY ty gst Dae See Ge Sane SRP a ie. ae
TYPICAL APARTMENT LAYOUT.......... 11
() ert J
’
we
‘
J 4 ~
r .
° Vl LJ Cl)
th
+ 1 ep) oT
mid 4 Ul] <j
—<« a 4
«lL Kl, ol
) hs
. ty) « iA
oa ~ \ s ay
om e bty () ( C)
4
T% > 4 ~
Vv) ’ K—4 ‘ ay ()
r) : a o be ( .
] om ra eq ee
, ' ay or
’ by © ae)
. 4a
— ‘ (™ bday
f r Vl
_ t Q4
+ r> D 1
J \N cs b2, O
. . a y -
‘ ¥ ‘ . Mi, ~ ( "
fj [ ( i) ‘
; ae | C4 b
bq fr) ( ha ‘
iJ 4 S32) 42, - Ly
r ro ( u) .
; \ 4d bead q)
_ rating aA | --4
v4 —4 5 84 —— { =
e- t
Ts 1
a. f+ ) : Y)
\ \
~ ~ Cf ‘ ) Vy)
uv) a n
y > ‘ 7 Ste /
I X 7 ? 4 : eB) **
,
4 ‘ ~4 -
a we t 4 mM on w
a) "4 Ss y {UD .
4 4 PP bt. LJ ¥ ep) {
4 )
r | ** r . A
A f+} ,
rad bay — ° ae)
() {) fa . ) . A }
° °.- = (TS rs {N
\ . — {) U r
rr? } 7s ) {2 4d ‘ (S
,
4 / 4 i ° -_ >| req WV fA T
' 4 y rh a , <a 1) 4
bd lj el, . i" ee
? ry ) y
(¥ . } . ee (N aa)
. . . . . . . ‘ 4 i
‘ ’ 7 A “tt. cL O*
1 ° Y . = T (
mM, p44 VS 4 . b44 , f 4 OY) (N
. . . 4 2 ral } '
pty rq > el, oa Cy
. ° i GF & Bee b4
f ~~ £ c f - 4
. Sing ie ’ a )
cS Ot ) 4 [x] PS tJ
ty < . mr ral vy > » 4
ae 4 : why a i — / A Fi, LD)
by > 4 bay Ly bea ba bY ‘ 4 j (* f { , ]
App. 39
Land: $280,800
Improvement : $486,000
Total: $766,800
TAX = $18,479.88
1992 Tax Assessment of Block
Land: $135,700
Improvement : -
Total: $135,700
TAX = $3,270.37
1992 Hackensack Tax Rate: $2.41 per
$100 Assessed Value 1993 Hackensack Tax
Rate $2.87 per $100 Assessed Value 1994
ackensack Tax Rate: $3.14 per $100
Assessed Value
ZONING R-3B zone
PURPOSE OF APPRAISAL
The purpose of this appraisal is to
estimate the Fair Market Value,
Fair Market Value being defined as
"the highest price estimated in terms of
money which a property will brin if
exposed or sale in the open market,
App. 40
allowine a reasonable time to find a
purchaser who buys with knowledge of all
the uses to which it is adapted and for
which it is capable of being used."
Fair Market Value is further defined
as, “that price in terms of money that a
willine buyer would be justified in
paying to a willing seller, both being
well informed, acting antelligently anc
without compulsion, and normal financing."
» |
It is assumed that title to the
property is good and marketable and fee
simple ownership is to be transferred free
from all encumbrances except for those
specified in the deed of public
interest.
NEIGHBORHOOD DATA:
The area of the subject property is
bordered by commercial, and industrial
41
varia
App.
-
> he a oe A
“wl ali ea
ice
Y
4
O
. ‘
» am
m4 qa)
Os
“rt $4
1 O
(G t)
mo
i)
a’
2
dy -
O N
@
an
ot
48) om |}
4 +
oO #
cS Oo
e >
> i
“G4
}
A
4
/
7
cy ct
cS GC
D ©
ry
ry
J
()
rt
ry)
bi4
val
- 4 4 it 4
‘ vr— r4 a ere
i , 4+ ed
rad
a
apa
195
bul
rtment buildings
8. There is a par
ldings,
wer! =)
. nt ss Ke .
Nad GAiiis
apartments, with one bath in e«
total of 60 rooms Sixty perce
parking (asphalt lot) is provid
tenants on Block 418, Lots 22,
Foundation: Cinder Block
Exterior: Brick Venee,
Roof: Asphalt Shingle
Leaders & Gutters Alumir
Windows. Steel Sliding.
Interior:
Walls. Dry Wall
Heating. Hot Wat ll F
Electrical. BX able
Plumbing. Copper
Floors. Hardwood. Vinyl 2
Kitchen Bath. 4 ft. x 4 ft e?
Floor
Utilities: Gas lect
Sewers Driving Way and rk
Asphalt Off-Site mprov t
Sidewalks, street lights
Each building is 100 feet by
3,000 square feet zach building
stories, the total interior area
square feet 2 There are twee Cy t
apartments, each containing
feet, as fallows
baseme:
i)
m\ TY
~~ Oy Oo VY VY © 0G VY ® e
wn S26 Sh Genet eee
° > 4 £ ° 4 Pa
; Ee Py UO W , mM
7 C ol c oO & ed
" ud . Ad ra) O
Ob 4 4 > CO 4) ‘Tr iJ , 08)
p - 4 T ‘ ra 4 ae:
r O ‘ @) “uw ed wv ¢ J
om ¢€ ed - @ f . i -4
SH oU ag khrtVZ es m4 ~
‘i u 77a MY uy Vv 7 gc © ©) eG +4 mal > “7
ae TG Y) { ri} rt oO by W ry rt .
‘ iJ ( al c > iJ Ww
«+ wun ~ $2 rt
Y) uy UO ee * vw oYEe' w Q Sed
Ww m a | it @) () O 4 4 ar “4 ( Mm
Fi ‘ rod j E 8) | = ) ae | Lb)
uw) ls bt, a VM hy a @® +4 OT W -4 vet
« \Yy ‘ iJ w | og ov ¢ : O w YM UO OG G
as + © © my) i 9,0 4 GS @awnwtetwne @
eee “4 rs i) > g@ FM yy Ss 4
va nM 6 G3 oO wy"? Viw EO
ui) a O “4 4 wt O S W) we) O b4 6)
i ci @© O a) Ania /. An Fe) . Y4
a) 2 ¢ iP ee “8S My
ES aN, m4 = & 1 a O MM ‘ @
in 44 © ; @F #e * © wb
‘ - O E A et . (6 oe > oe EM ay
, wo G - 4) “WH a > As . my oO a J 4
-4 HH © ~ > G GS rt : ae
ss / A} 4 ct 19) f A ‘ C 4 © U _-
“a «4 W wy . o 3S Vn Sh a ‘
ys h4 Or . z2@PMoogcg a. ~~ +
= r GS F gy = 4 Q 4
4 — = 2 0 - . @* )
(“) (N -7 cs UW) = ea ty) 4 9 +8) = wv
Zz 4d gy © nS " bt be SB B
, ’ a F ae) SCS 4) +r ‘A 4 J
i | — ~ G4 a | UY) 3.2 . a e .
iN © rt : O ae | > g¢ @ a) U c ©
cS 1J | ee es mt of 2 ¢
~n ; , ’ Wm rt wr m vs {) iJ “f! = cd O u)
Bpus 0 ~ . £3 c So h ¢ » |
= © © t am o 6 es e ~ Wed ve 1) ry w) ,
{) W) i) bay i) c* ed . ; Te! ) eo} al iJ —
a 4 0 wv V + . o ; + 7 4
{ 4 . a 9 > ay 6 as aed wv O () = O Vv)
© OO 4 ot HOOowDUDBDHH EA BOOBY
_ oe C ‘ » 2
( baa : [C&D QO GB 44 et M VY Aw
45
App.
Y)
Y)
<4
Pi,
WORMCA CI
ed 2 = \ /
TAL ABRINOALA
Th
O*
ri
—
0)
O71
co
2Stabilized Rental Income and Expenses.
Park Court Apartments, 391-397 Park St.,
Hackensack 20 units. Average rental
income per month collectible is set at
$437.50 Annual rental income computes to
$105,000, inclusive of miscellaneous
income
INCOMO 60 as Unk eee ee $105,000
EXP@N@GR:.: « 6 se.aS5 eA ee (Gsa7O
AAVeEYrtiSing,. «0 ss eee ee eee 300
Auto & TRUGK. <\ cease wee Ce eae 3000
INSULANCE «0/05 5 eee eee 8 ee ee 89770
Repairs & Maintenance.......... 6600
Supplies. ...s«rssea sea ap ae eee 2000
UciLitiee ius sss os oe ee ee eee 25000
WAGES . 60s i eo Rs ee ee ee eee Oe 7000
Office Expenses... sis 40 4 aan as 7000
Legal & Professional.......... 5000
Depreciation
$64870
11305
Total Expenses
Exp. & Deprec....$76175
it before Local Property Taxes
LDCOMG 6 sas See 105,000
Exp. & Deprec 1,472
Taxes) Net Profit 28,825
tax rate:
+ 2.57% 5% @ 14.07%
S$ 204,883
App. 47
Note: This approach to value is
$562,000 below the value set by the
Hackensack assessor. This is a _ serious
discrepancy. The cost of services to
maintain the net income received is high.
Management has been above average. Other
properties are having similar cash flow
problems. One such property is 370 Park
Street, Hackensack, (72 units, three
stories, built 1980), Block 415, lots 1
etc. sold for $0 November 20, 1991. Its
1991 assessment was $3,108,000. This sale
was listed in the SR1-A forms at Serial
No. 2208579, Deed Book 7489, p. 916.
High turnover rate, high cost of
apartment preparation for incoming
tenants, and decreased rental incomes have
been caused by external diseconomies, plus
additional long term irreversible factors.
New construction of apartments in the
neighborhood have been of buildings three
stories and higher. In addition, compara
ble apartment buildings have larger unit
size.
Note that the net profit before taxes
is $28,825, and that the Hackensack local
property tax charged is increasing as
follows resulting in cash flow losses, due
to mortgage financing:
App. 48
Real Property Tax Remaining After Taxes
1992s 08 ess $18,480 $28,825 - $18,400 =
$10,425
1993. .6 << $21,037 $28,825 - $21,037 =
¢ 7,786
1994....-- $23,016 $28,825 - $23,016 =
es
LAND VALUE
offers on this Parcel one (Block 418,
s 22 and 23), and Parcel two (Block
, Lot 24) have failed to approach the
as sessed value set by the Hackensack tax
assessor. The vacant land, iot 24, 38
limited cue to a moratorium on sewer hook
ups - only dry hook ups have been
acceptable.
Petitioner's complaint sets forth
55,000 as the proper assessed value.
REQUESTED INFORMATION
S
w
Petitioner is awaiting receipt of
information requested from the Hackensack
Tax Assessor for Market approach to value.
The Cost Approach to value is dependent
}
be
App. 49
on the obsolescence, depreciation, and
ghest and best use analysis. Such data
has been received to date has not been
a
as
adequate to produce further information at
this time on the three approaches to
value, or reconciliation thereof.
DATE SUBMITTED: NOVEMBER 5, 1994
SUBMITTED BY: SALVATORE MORETTI,
TITIONER
50
App.
,
A
we ae
ss Ve
ATF TORI DP
|
5
rer
rel ny
e) 4
Leet a Ym
TAMNIMD MOR NY
EB ARUGA iL
ard o
C)
fr]
ro
iQ
a
U)
t j
Ss
UY)
fx)
Y)
aa
fx]
fy
~
fa]
leah haan
~ ~~
er ee
TTA, T ONT
Ha
Wad
of
cause
"
App. 51
additional data relating to the operations
of Park Court Apartments, 391-7 Park St.,
Hackensack, enclosed find the expenses
incurred for calendar year 1991-1993.
ms The following qualifying conditions
apply: The N. J. Assessor's Manual upon
which the local property tax is based
incorporates wages for property
maintenance and management. Such wages
require personal services, such personal
services have been insisted upon by
Hackensack in court trials, but no
compensation has been provided by them -
against the law. Twenty rents cannot
compensate for a full time superintendant
or superior on-site management. The
subject property has so many locational,
zoning, and governmental problems that
such intensive labor is required.
When superintendants were hired they have
quit upon seeing the amount of work
involved. Hence, management has performed
the work on a "permanent" basis for over
Six years, with inadequate recompense.
Comprehensive federal wage and hour
controls were enacted by the Fair Labor
Standards Act (FLSA) of 1938 ("the wage-
hour law"). Those wages have been
incorporated into the N. J. Administrative
Code at N.J. Admin. Code Section 12:56-
» bin
ENS QE Saleem
AI e
weyay
way
NAEYC LIEB led
App. 53
includes other forms of compensation such
as fringe benefits..." I.R.S. Publication
337 ©6states at »p. 2 under "who are
employees" that there are common-law
employees and statutory employees" At p.
7, a Similar fact pattern is considered
(motel) in which "the services include
registering guests [short-term and long
term] collecting rents, maintaining rooms
in good condition, making minor repairs,
etc....Major maintenance and repair work
has to be authorized [here, such major
epairs wait for years for eneushs money to
pay for them), or (trailer-courts) "[the
employee] observes regular working hours,
follows a daily routine, and Supplies
whatever equipment is necessary to
maintain the trailer court. He performs
services on a full time basis."
The City of Hackensack has required
any "health violation" visits to i
court-house, one can only analogize th
a
to an employment situation in which the
city acts as the employer, management acts
as the employee. "Health" notices
requiring court appearances included
garbage removal, extermination, rents,
water consumption, maintenance, non-
payment of rent, etc. As a result, the
following three years of expenses should
€ adjusted upward considerably to reflect
Ap, .
54
nigher secretarial costs, legal costs, and
on-call fees. Lumping
‘unpaid retiree living
precluded by the fact
accepted living on-site.
everything under
on-site’ has been
no employee ever
}
Answers to Interrogatories, etc. -3-
CALENDAR 1991
"Te <
NacKensack Water Co....
Bid. BOLL TOS. cccauvces
P.B.Bi& BG. COsiccccsevce
| (Ns. & rr eee
Heating/Refrig. Repair.
Cilano Recyclable Garb.
Vehicle Repair.........
Paint (supplies).......
Paint (labor) ..........
Pest Control. ....sssees
Vehicle Supply.........
SORECOPLOL «2c0< 6 ue bn tus
225
1565
718
(re
4
x
*
>
:
=
3
*
‘
App. 57
CONSIDER ALSO
Real Estate Taxes
Block 418,Lots 22&23..1848
Block 418,Lot 24...... 3270
Management... ..sesesceeee §0
Superintendant........ 400
4. I have examined the fore
incurred and these expenses
in the operation of the sul
house property in the years
as set forth.
)
Answers to Interrogatories,
5 In response to your
respect to additional data re
operations of Park Court Apar
Park St., Hackensack, enclce
expenses incurred for calend
(Note: I have excluded a
expenditures which were requi
great deal of legal work :
2 1989 ¢t 1994 1? lve
i)
Ar ——
Ah, . )
‘ v ‘ A Asada :
vy ‘ . . ;
, + . + ’
~ ~ Vahts—s abe < —_ gue t. . i
. i - A AA - - 4 , ¥ A A " <
, Yé n > , ’ ¢ ~ mB) QO a a
a i. 4 i Yu42 Anu me 2 s
, é a ' . +
, Ass? - - cc
a - Piva . ® ¢ 2 a
—A - pe . . . . . « . 2
‘ta ‘ Gd bs
AWA 4 . . _ SS & ia : a
> c > =
, 1 ‘4 bed by be -
ry x<« eT a 4c . ac
" A LAs da vAw s* eS . f » = he
> VW “+ y y .
3 via é ‘
a Ww hA will 2iGca —
= y — c A
As " 4 . . . . ‘ ~ :
, “ it * '
2
&
‘
3
e
5
;
:
a
3
%
%
}
8
Se
*“*e © *® © © © @ @
@S....
ocksmith.
fice Expens
(Supplies) ..
sw A. Bae = = S
ationery 1
lephone....... 4335.52
ter 10500.00
he water bill was challenged, but the
J Board of Regulatory Commissioner
d the U District Court failed t
duce 1e ill. set
1,000 for 1993 and 1994. Real Estate Ta
n be derived by multiply Assessment
mes municipal tax rate. anaatae cadens
ees were even higher than
CO
Oo rh
,
due
The report which I submitted dated
ember 5, 1994 contains stabilized
penses from five years, 1989-1994, and
such represents more information than
cluded in the three year survey here
longer time
App 60
Ce AO. ee Sane Gagan CBF
App. 61
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646 - 1414
November 14, 1994
Donald J. Lenner, Esq.
286 Union Street
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
re: Salvatore Moretti v. City of
Hackensack, State Tax Court Docket No.
833693; Parcel One - Block 418, Lots 22
and 23. Parcel Two - Block 418, Lot 24.
Dear Mr. Lenner:
On November 30, 1993, I served
interrogatories upon the Hackensack Tax
Assessor, answers to which were due many
months ago. The answers I received were
evasive in every respect, and I note
twenty-one instances where the answers
Simply were non-existent or erroneous, as
follows
1. What is the classification of the
building - [in the assessor's manual]? -
Answer. Apartment Building.
2. What is cost per square foot of the
improvements? - Answer.
\V
None provided.
=
w4 4 re
sa y > by
. 43 ‘
va he oS ei tte wv
oe ee ee oo
, oS o “4 3 & ~~ ©
nH 3 ‘2 5 Ec WO
i) (‘p (i) 4 O 4 Cc) (-
J , 4 - ( s)
peer = 2S 4 eu? e 04 0 es ¢ ee Sy
oe G93 | 222 4 Re a eae ee aad ee 3
by © = cy HH i) 3) om wW O 4 \y Oo, WW O
= ov» & ~~ S 4 GO - : rs : 'é)
i) W) W) O = 3 ed om J > ee Q an © ©
os o wy 2 oO os ( @ ” O y VY O 26 wv m
od lee Bae By ned mH 4 =
Hn ' OF < ce ao & fT O rs © % c
( © N iv Be one O S s ie) O is U ha “r! i)
ef deat? 0) a < ‘ c t4 y ¥ O rte mn
08) oO ed (p O O re Qy -r4 6)
Q, o Bae Gy) GS we} 1, © yw * m v
, ¢ @ @ | Oo : o Me Ds ov - w
) QO, O- sd Q hy od i ~ ad , x
© 3 4J rae) t M4 = 4 rey “a 6S 4 Y) 4J
nm wv 4 Ud UH Q, 2 M 2, » O a 3 0 ,
e < 4 bt ) ‘ : se) M4 6) ° ws b4 a
® aa - - “ ss > 6 ., 8 S rs i] @) ) ms = a a =
a | m pad 2 44 a Y)
Y) oy ry ‘7 “y) co W “~$ n u4 rm O @ J ” 2
y © W 4 we O aa Ss w e & & o %
° tks Uv) z - Eo ‘- J ¥ U i "‘p ef, P Oo ae - e re ’ . ‘o
d o @ Oo a tt 4 yo . @ 4) Q, nv 4 bY
a = , © coy ST Bw 24 Sa me oe O
© . oo ~ @ ° Q H VY A ve 3 re Q, O ~ ood yp
e) 1 WJ € @ * ‘QQ & ri n £208 sv oO
4°) = : ~ m - ct 1 yy oe an a a o YW Ys
me ord r- > in yo 4) ‘ 0)» Or st © +r 1 4 Oo v
at, as tt fe oe ‘ A ~ ay ae Aas.
e rc ‘ ' a 4 , 4 i
4 9 a = a Wa oo e 2 i) E 5 ow W O yo o c - 4, OF
Q ie , om )-a & L ' co.
G ba Q eae fe (Gv w 6: ~ he af i wy 3
Ef Sus ty ° feggg dap bsal cling 45
mw © b ti aN 1 ee uv) ed -~ W) > Be = . © e a ct
LD -rt ft uf) cf @ | i Pa Wi J om =) Y) «<
a > ir 0@s oe a + tee eo ier
cS ~ A> ~~ tes n oO ov YW - Ay oO eo & H
“, od 0 - Sieg WO wo - ers o » Wo “
0 it “oad Yoo oe - . 3 .
O 2 ihe. 340 nt eh a W)
ca 5 i eh “ws Vi) rd << Q c ™N ie)
re) a a rt >
App. 63
13. Same question as to Prince Edward
Court? Answer. Not relevant.
14. What is the locational obsolescence
of subject apartment house under appeal?
Not separated from total depreciation.
15. What is the functional obsolescence
of the subject apartment house under
appeal? Not separated from total
depreciation.
16. What impact have the rent payment
defaults of the tenants at the apartment
house under appeal have on arriving at an
opinion of value by the City of
Hackensack? Answer. None known.
17. What experts will the City of
Hackensack call at trial?
Answer. Not known at this time.
18. What property records cards will the
City of Hackensack rely upon at trial?
Answer. None.
19. Attach real estate appraisal report
if relied upon on the _ subject real
property? Answer. Not known at this time.
20. Show what consideration given for
such factors as:
a. tenants welfare recipients.
b. %¢ tenants arrested on site
c. No. Steel doors broken down on site.
etc.
Answer. No factor.
21. What consideration was given to the
work performed by the on-site office at
cee App. 64
tne suprect apartment house? Answer. Toc
=
&@ question to answer.
he foregoing suggests that you
reconsider the answers thus far provided
Supplement these answers so as to
allow for preparation for trial i
ilure to do so will result in
case Fa
appropriate sanctions being applied[plied
<or before the court
n particular, I require room lay-
outs and measurements of apartments in
apartment buildings in Hackensack, with
rental received showing the. street-
ocation of each apartment. Without this
snformation, hich I have already
requested from the assessor (he did not
ovide it), I will be required to seek
r
he court's permission to secure the
information from whatever sources. are
available.
Very truly,
Certified Mail
No. P 887 136 714
Return Receipt Requested.
App. 65
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
December 20, 1994
Hon. Peter D. Pizzuto, J.T.C.
125 State Street
Room 108
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Re: Salvatore Moretti ¥ City of
Hackensack, Docket No. 8336-93; Parcel One
Block 418, Lots 22 and 23. Parcel Two -
Block 418, Lot 24. Motion Return Date
January 6, 1994
Dear Judge Pizzuto:
Petitioner received a notice of
motion returnable January 6, 1994 from
Donald Lenner on behalf of the City of
Hackensack - the taxing authority - which
by-passes the issues in the case, and
seeks to dismiss on the basis of lack of
Jurisdiction. As noted, this case has
been heard by the Bergen County Board of
Taxation five times (1978, 1979, 1980,
1981, and 1991 [Note -- App. 1. Decision of
Board for Year 1991, Appeaal No. 445)).
ar f : ‘ ene SR
pon creation of the New Jersey iax
‘a. ~+ — a> ~ | -ho .
Court, that court also heard this tax
On October 6, 1981, James W. Mason
submitted a real estate appraisal setting
forth what the court accepted a
opinion of value of $347,500 for 1980[App.
s noteworthy that the
+e ute tal ws é - fae +
firm proviaed tne ampetus for use
od
=
ASSESSMENT HISTORY OF PARK COU
APARTMENT, 391-397 PARK STREET,
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY. 20 UNITS. YEAR
rj
be
LAND IMPROVMENTS NET TAXABLE
}
\O
16 8)
9)
e]
©
iam)
OO
©
Oo
Ul
4
+4
uw
a
Oo
~]
\O
WN)
(J
aa
2
1989 280,800 511,500 792,300
App. 67
The State Tax Court judgement of 1982
froze the assessment at $295,400 unitl
1987:
1984 71,500 223,900 295,400
13,617.94
1985 71,500 223,900 295,400
14,740.46
1986 71,500 223,900 295,400
15,154.02
1987 71,500 223,900 295,400
13,991.60
to Motion to Dismiss by City of Hackensack
The appraisal of $347,500 resulted
in a tax court judgment of $295,400 for
1983 and four subsequent years. But as
soon as that real estate appeal freeze
period passed, the city set an
assessment (increasing $496,900) almost
tripling the value to over $750,000, the
threshhold for direct appeal to the Tax
ae bg Oe
Petitioner filed for a significant
eduction in assessment in 1991 filing his
ax appeal with the Bergen County Tax
oard. The assessment was reduced by only
$25,500. Appeal No. 445 resulted. in a
judgment dated February 20, 1992 leaving
the land ‘assessment at $280,800, but
reducing the improvements from $511,500 to
—a © G U
ri ws 4 ©
, VY)
ve 4 SG
. ~ 8) 9)
a3 6
_ & Ga
< O fast . ©
—s py ran
- ?
qo w%oO wv
se Ee G
ot 68 = fi) iJ
i
£9
@w iJ wv iJ
wo o At iJ
O 2 G O W)
ad UO 4 > b
x “4 @
Q, ”» O W re)
< , —4 te OG =)
~~ ig, O Vv
= 18) ed cat
- ha iJ
: ~ . Uv)
= © y4
‘ ©
0 Ww G w
7 i ; ve
.[7) . 6S O
by C ey et
- Be iv i)
wd oJ efi
oO O =
Ooms x @
~ 8 bAa
-~ 4 O 4
0 = r4 4,
} © ¢£
7 l O ¢
iy f > &5
Cc
~~
rces
ne,
this
>»
filed
ederal
e>
Hackensack Water Company
Ju
ments,
-_
—
he
in
=
i
New
of
depar
ities in
Ccivi
he
.
he municipal
-
*
court
much
per,
Water
r
assessment,
cKensack
instead
as pe
accounting
e
~
superior
in special
S on
mass
,
’
*-_7
-
—
+
se we
nst tne
property
en
Ln
+
anua
,
“eS
sim
-
NV
*
searches,
-
the Ha
ana
_
méereiy
.
yed
t aga
~
Pp
Su
App. 69
region]. Petitioner included the relevant
part of the brief submitted by the City of
Hackensack, along with Judge Ackerman's
opinion dealing with jurisdiction.
The City of Hackensack supported the
water company, and commenced municipal
earings on water consumption at the
wianee real property. These hearings
began in July, 1992 and lasted until
December, 1992. Additional concerns
egistered were excessive fire alarms at
neighboring buildings - 391-397 Park
Street [20 units] and 370 Park Street [72
units). In addition, subsidy recipients at
the two buildings were experiencing many
difficulties, creating high turnover rates
and vacancies. Many evictions occurred at
both buildings, aggravated by municipal
fire drills and the sale of 370 Park
reet back to its prior owner - a law
Turning our attention to the errors
of the Real Estate Appraisal submitted by
James Mason on behalf of th City of
Hackensack, one can readily see the
origin of many municipal
errors.
omparaad f I “tment L
Comparaable Vacant Apartment Land
Sales: Hackensack, N.J. [Note App. 72]
Mason's October 6, 1981 appraisal
-hose for Sale 1 a property at 100 Second
Street. This property (Dawn Manor) is
owned by Edward Swensen, (94 Railroad
Avenue, Hackensack, N. J.), 215 feet by 84
feet, Block 233, lots 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 in
~he 1994 tax books. The assemblage,
presumed comparable to a garden apartment
of 20 units, was used for a 58 unit
puilding of four stories with garages
under the building. Currently, the land is
assessea at $696, the improvements
assessed at $1,429,500, the net taxable at
$2,125,500. Clearly, this property
assemblage should not be used for land to
De used tor two story apartment
auction with no garages. The building
is on a hill in an exclusive area.
Mason then cites assemblage for 125
Lawrence Street, Hackensack, Craig Towers,
which is three stories with 24 garages.
1994 land assessment is $456,000,
Improvements are assessed at $899,700,
th net taxable of $1,355,700. This is
Mason then uses for his land value a
parcel at the corner of Prospect and
Central Avenue, 204,737 square feet. The
sale price in 1977 was $975,000, with 253
App. 71
units built at the site. The building,
however, is an exclusive six stories
building.
Mason then refers to 387 Park Street,
Hackensack, [App. 76] as a sale of vacant
land ‘for a ten unit building, presuming
the property could be used as_ the
adjoining two lots. In fact, this is
Parcel Two, Block 418, lot 24. The
building was purchased for use as a
parking lot, and the variance applied for
was denied due to failure to provide
contiguous parking.
Mason's use of comparable improved
sales suffers also from the defects set
forth above. Sale One concerns 2
Place, Hackensack, N.J., Block 9, lot
The sale is of property situated 30 blocks
from the central business district, near
Route 80. It is adjacent to an attractive
modern building fronting on River Street.
Garages on the first floor distinguish the
property from the subject apartment house
which does not have garages. Mason not
that "Henry Place is a side street [whi
has very little traffic, as opposed to 3
Park Street], and each apartment contains
675 square feet, as opposed to the 391
Park Street's 500 square feet. The
"comparable" was constructed in 1968 (over
~~ -
offace 3 currently assessed at land =
02,400, improvements = 5410,200, net
taxable = $612,600.
A his property is ain the Fairmount
Section, clearly superior to Park Street
The area is predominantly residentia.,
mn one of the most stable
a ections © the ‘City. . tae
apartments each have slide in window air
33 ers. Mason states each unit has
- 4 subject soartunne “heuee in this
ase. There are two two-bedroom
apartments, while all apartments are one-
bedroom apartments at 391-397 Park Street.
The 1994 land assessment is $180,000, the
improvements are assessed at $236,800,
with the net taxable of $416,800. The
building is currently owned by Edmon and
Mariene Anz.
Mason chooses Sale Three as 93 Hobart
reet, [App. 83] Hackensack, Block 81,
t 47, and 48. The current owner is Paul
oS Josephine Tornambe, 423 Taylor Avenue,
outh Hackensack. The building has two
App. 73
garages, unlike the subject property at
391-397 Park Street. As Mason _ states,
"each [apartment] unit has a sleeve air
conditioning unit... with 608 square feet
of area (larger than the subject
property's units).
Mason chooses Sale Four to be 257
Essex Street, Hackensack, Block 127, lot
18, etc. The property is currently owned
by Howard Koval, 419 Essex Street,
Hackensack. The 1994 land assessment is
$265,000, improvement is assessed at
$324,400, with net taxable equal to
$589,600. "The building is elec trically
heated and each apartment contains a
cleeve air conditioning unit. the
”
building was constructed in 1968 and wa
considered to be in good condition at the
time of sale." Note, 10owever, that this
property is located on the hill with a
view of the New York skyline, inclu iding
the Empire State Building. The building
contains five garage - a fact missing from
the Mason appraisal. As Mason states, "the
building is electrically heated and each
apartment contains a sleeve air
conditioning unit. The buildin was
constructed in 1968 and was considered to
be in good condition at the time of sale
By comparison, 391-397 Park epee: the
es
r
subject apartment house, provid
App. 74
has no garages, no sleeve air conditioning
units, and was built a decade before The
subject property lacks a panoramic view of
~he New York skyline.
son's analysis of income anc
I s suspect. For example, he
llocates 946 per year for water, [App. 88]
t the $8,000 per year required in 1992
T 5 a
and thereafter. Utilities are estimated at
$8,160, not the four year $22,480 average
from 1991 1994. Insurance is estimated
‘tc be —§ S853, not the $9,700 actual
insurance cost at. 391-397 Park Street.
Superintendant wages are estimated at
1,500, one-fourth the actual minimum.
Management of $1,780 is estimated by
Mason, about 10% of the actual management.
Based on these low expenses, Mason der .ves
a net income after total expenses of
$42,913. He then capitalizes this into an
=
appraised value of $345,000. in fact,
there is no return on investment at the
subject property, 391-397 Park Street,
with the Hackensack Water Company actually
turning off water and/or threatening shut
off despite payments of $10,000 per year.
CONCLUSION
App. 75
The foregoing analysis should have
provided several important clues as to why
the City of Hackensack and the county of
Bergen have not produced an accurate
assessment of the subject real property.
When provided an Opportunity for four
consecutive years (1978-1981), the county
and city produced an assessment far above
that prayed for - $295,000.
The most important result was that
the tenants were placed in hardship. Their
earnings were not sufficient to pay the
bills (including the tax bill), and the
turn-over rate increased. A 95% vacancy
rate was experienced. Incoming tenants
more often were on subsidy relief, and
such tenants had social problems - they
were often unemployed and failed to secure
employment during their term of occupancy.
Higher maintenance costs were experienced.
Comparing the subject apartment house
to mid-rise construction on Prospect
Street is unfair. It is also unfair to
compare the property to housing in the.
Fairmount section or thirty blocks south,
as did the appraisal by Mason. Garages and
built-in air conditioners along with
construction ten years subséquent to the
Subject property are all clues that the
per unit costs are much too high.
Apr. 76
enant probiems were often
ee problems, rather than
rn oblems alone. When petitioner
assistance for tenants in the
ges did not treat the
t al issues" in the same light
as they would have had a tenant on
P Street been involved. The m
ence of a law on the books (as Judge
rman mentioned) was inadequate
itigants did not have their day in court
e motions to dismiss were granted,
without oral argument, and without consid-
= 1
m
as
(D
ration of issues - based on mere
technical objections. Appeal was not
sta ossible, since testimony of witnesses ana
ross-examination of experts was denied.
Petitioner went to City Hall to
contest his assessment increase when the
assessment tripled, but those conducting
the hearings did not have the knowledge
required to change assessments. Topolski,
the municipal lawyer handling the federai
district court case, assumed that walking
to the nearby county tax board ‘with
one's petition for hearing would provide
automatic relief - this is erroneous. The
problems described, tenants on subsidy in
central city housing, are not readily
App. 77
handled by the mechanics of appraisal
reports. These are legal problems.
Mason's appraisal allocates a grossly
inadequate $30 per week for the on-site
Ssuperintendant. He does not state whether
this complies with federal minimum wage
requirements - petitioner claims it does
not. In fact, superintendants quit when
paid that amount, and those that do not
quit merely live on site until fired.
Mason also selects a 3% management fee
which is inadequate - 5% is an industry
wide standard even for above average
housing. The actual experience of managers
and superintendants on site is missing
from the Mason appraisal. Here
petitioner's appraisal report based on
actual time studies and costs - post
office mailings, gas mileage, etc. proves
that the tax assessment allocates to the
municipality a windfall in the form of
high taxation for services which have not
been received by the subject apartment
house.
We must be concerned with the home
life of Hackensack's apartment dwellers,
particularly those who are being plagued
by medical problems or difficult family
problems, particularly with those who are
victimized by crime. The most recent
Apr. 78
census data state that Hackensack’s crime
s far above that of
& around Hackensack. The
1986-1991 Municipal Uniform Crime
Reports
1986 1988 1991
BOGOTA... reese eens 207 230 246
Littse Ferry...... 429 350 326
South Hackensack 132 150 125
River Edge........ 319 256 274
Hackensack ...... 2418 2468 2453
While Mason speaks of an apartmen
house 30 blocks south of the subject 2
unit apartment house, the neighborhood he
le
selects is just blocks from Little Ferry,
where the crime rate plunges. While Mason
speaks of Prospect Avenue high rises as
providing data from land assemblage for
vacant land appraisal, why does he not
show the different earning characteristics
of those neighborhoods. If he did so, this
would illustrate rent-paying abilities as
definitive of property values. When Mason
lects the Fairmount for his Grand Avenue
property, he neglects to state that this
is the most stable neighborhood = in
Hackensack.
App. 79
The City's assessment is flawed, and
its flaw does not now entitle is to evade
the Tax Court's jurisdiction. If
Hackensack seeks equity, let it give
equity by lowering assessment to that
requested.
Date: December 20, 1994
Submitted by: SAVATORE MORETTI
PETITIONER
SALVATORE MORETTI
290 PARK STREET
CKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601]
(201) 646+1414
Noramr - 4 os
Jecember 31, 1994
_ PA a tT « be rr on
Hon. Peter D. Pizgzzuto, J.T.C
125 State Street
Room i08
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Re Salvatore Moretti v CiE¥ “OF
Hackensack, Docket No. 8336-93; Parcel
One - Block 418, Lots 22 and 23. Parcel
Two Block 418, Lot 24 Motion Return
Date January 6, i995
Continuance on Motion to Impose Restraints
on Collection of Tax by Taxing District.
Oral Argument Requested.
itioner has received various
papers from the taxing district which
appear to represent that the Tax Court
does not have jurisdiction over the
subject matter within. These claims are
made despite the fact that as late as
App. 81
November 8, 1994, Donald Lenner (on
behalf of the taxing district - City of
Hackensack) claimed in in his letter
cpaationed Moretti v. City of Hackensack,
Docket No. 008336-93, | served
interrogatories upon you to be answered by
you. As of this date, I have not yet
received those answers. As I stated in my
message, unless I receive those answers
within one week, I will apply to the Court
for appropriate relief, including seeking
the dismissal of your complaint for
failure to answer interrogatories. The
information contained in your property
appraisal report, submitted to the Court
by letter dated November 4, 1994, is
insufficient." The inference is that the
taxing district wants more information,
better discovery, or different documents,
not that it questions the jurisdiction of
the New Jersey Tax Court. The federal
complaint filed (under the civil rights
Statutes) against the taxing district
adopted the position, echoed by Judge
Ackerman, that petitioner should go to the
State Tax Court for Equitable Relief which
it alone can provide. Petitioner argues
that this is binding upon the parties,
and any filing deadlines are accordingly
tolled.
1) , : ; >< i
; ; .
i - :
-- . ;
; rs >
ON "
GU . ’ !
. j .
Ae j
bds - j
« :
P .s
; ‘- “ * . >
gar App. 83
Petitioner claims that the taxing
district's arguments are self-serving.
Consider the county tax board judgement
dated February 20, 1992 (App. 1). Was
this judgment appealed by filing a series
of complaints alleging federal violations,
to wit violations of 42 U.S.C. Section
1983, etc. What (if any) hourly wages were
paid petitioner to operate his property
sixty hours per week for ten years - was
the compensation below federal minimum
wage guidelines? Petitioner alleges the
property is assessed on the basis of his
unpaid labor, which year after year
remains unpaid because the taxing district
misconstrues the taxing power. Upon an
emergency - water shut-off, the taxing
district claims merely that a health
emergency exists (App. 102), denying
liability for over-assessment, ignoring
years of neighborhood complaints. More
appropriately, this constitutes, for this
thirty-seven year old apartment property,
inadequate cash flow to pay for public
utilities. The four lots under common
ownership are assessed over $1,000,000.
The house (390 Park Street) experienced a
fire some time ago, burning New Jersey Tax
Court, Superior Court, and Supreme Court
volumes. The taxing district knows this,
but ignores this, for self-serving
reasons. The lot known as 387 Park
elt ee ae
App. 85
Board of Taxationt it is possible for a
matter to be heard directly in the Tax
Court and thereby bypass the county board
of taxation. " Note that N.J.S.A. 54:
S1A-7 provides for by-passing the County
Board of Taxation “for correction or
error."
At issue in determining whether the
case at bar passes the jurisdictional
hurdle are the following:
Has the taxing district acceded to
jurisdiction in the Tax Court by
allegations set forth in its federal
defense before Judge Ackerman, said case
Originating in a $9,329.62 (App. 103)
water bill ten times the bill claimed
in Mason's appraisal report
2. Have intervening appeals to the
state appellate division, etc. tolled
the filing of the instant tax appeal in
that issues of fact emerged from these
cases, which facts were not available to
petitioner prior to discovery therein
3. Have the "separate". parcels been
treated as though one parcel, thereby
qualifying under a liberal reading of
the statute for direct appeal to the tax
court?
Ss
i J
= »e 4 fr] 4 7 +/ y) as : J * - )
ve) fa] re ait thither ae. a z ovcg , Ut
> md | , -< / ~
ov xK 4 J OF o © - oD , @230 on C3
Uy b- 47 . L ] > iJ a4 - : ¢ }
\ i | , i ) 44 +> a) iJ iJ J 5
) -4 “
a . Q 4 bay ran} ~~ WY VV , Yd -
. ; oF «1, : 4 » ro ir -* oe 4 t) ad a.
~ bd, ’ f . ca 4 ) : wv 4
” r4 on ~ as ’ }
7 a S < , ) * ‘ cG @ co
l 4 ‘ ; TS iJ c ct ted
- ‘ - ed - ’ / _ »~ Ty
{) ~~ : o al 4 = fils I | ( J!
«< - FA, a4 ro @ ’ . ° VU a Cc
4 , ot rere . 4 | } 4
i - ~~ | TG ~~ O 2) 7” 1 7 L CS q gol ~- 4
j r . - 1 F y ) a) a rt
_s } 4 4 ‘ f f 4 /,
t } J } ° os P
‘ f r< . a+ 4 ¥ ~~ Ff ~+ 4 OD rt o ’ ci roa
d } , as cy +4 4 44 > j a. a/ r4 m
~ Be a + ; > iJ r—4 @ rq , re fy
, i 4, } e 4 iJ ’ 2 e i) i) 1) .
. ‘ x f ‘ v rt r4 le on ie C) . 8
b4u j c . . ‘ ct nh
ae ‘ ‘
I ‘ _ yo ‘ ; t ~ ‘ =) eq 4 “S 'e oF ass
f a » ‘ j f iJ ode { (
*_ ua g : (5 4 > , a. Y) * +4 ) , $y ar
; - 4
‘ +4 ed 4
; . f~< 5 24 44 ope . ‘ *r ( : rt « ©
} (2 r , ‘ ‘eo ( U) } ‘ . [) a P 44
) ‘ TS as « iJ
; i +4 >» bs pda . \ 7 ( — i =
( cd ‘ , . co u , rt " P yam)
-4 - . > “ i ’ s ol 47 8 Ul m4
- (TS 7 < a7 r v) 1 .
J $y & ; Vv UO Wm a )
‘ Cc } and ‘ -
rt “e ' ry) ot ,or oO
s | , i ; | al ct { | ; 3 *- -
- »< ; ~
rx , m4 -« ‘ ‘ 1 f )
a . - UJ ed 1 ] j m4 ef i on oul >< e4 { a | 58) Z
, ~o f f cf
, i i 4 ' i 4 | | | 44 — ed j ; ’
“ , ve) re ‘ ed .
Ul I ‘ 4 j ms / r-4 od 4 ) 8] :
» w no VU IH VOW OBdOe DO tind
, ‘ “ < > < P ‘ < 7
: ; it ip <& « ) < ; 4 | we oe Se a | dm tae"s ,
App. 87 |
of February 16, 1983 (App. 121). In fact,
the defendant lawyer was suspended from
the practice of law by the New Jersey
Supreme Court. Despite this, the taxing
district claimed in its brief, A-3525-82-
T2 (App 123), "Moretti does not have
the knowledge, skill, experience,
training or education to qualify as an
expert." (App. 129-130) The taxing
district alleges that if "pro ses were
allowed to proceed as petitioner
desires, the rules will become
meaningless". If legal malpractice
undercuts the 1978-1981 tax appeals, has
the taxing district corrected this
erroneous perception under the _ facts
within? The answer is that the facts
contradict the city assessment.
The problem posed by legal
malpractice is rendered more acute in that
the three Chancery (equity) court
complaints were filed by the lawyer but
not served upon the defendants Friendship
House (psychiatric halfway house - 387
Park Street, Block 418, Lot 24), Multi-Pak
(garbage compactor factory adjacent to
Block 418, Lots 22 and 23}, and Gutterman-
Musicant-Kreitzman funeral directors
(adjacent to Block 418, Lot 22, and former
owner of lot 24). The Chancery court
treated these three cases as involving the
App. 88
law of nuisance (iApp. 141). The cnancery
court decision assumes that a vacancy rate
of as high as 95% is normal (App 154-10).
Although the Chancery decision was
affirmed on appeal (App 157), when
petitioner sought to buy out a nuisance -
387 Park Street (App 160 - Motion te
compe. Specific Performance), the court
round "plaintiff has become the owner of
rty in question and there is no
ionger reason for him to seek specifi
performance (App. 162)". That property is
now the vacanct lot (Lot 24) where stood
387 Park Street (App. 171).
The interior of 387 Park Street,
ackensack, is shown at App 72-161 and
aoes not support the Chancery decision
which held that the property was not a
nuisance per. se. Although Friendship
House gathered support (App 185, 186),
after Alster's application for non-
contiguous parking at lot 25 was denied
(App. 182), the property was sold to
deMartino (onwer of lots 24 and 25) for
development as an office building. When
the Appellate Division held that failure
to serve summons and complaint within ten
days did not prohibit the action against
DeMartino in building its office building
(resulting in the survival of the appeal
App. 89
from the zoning board), DeMartino fearing
the removal of the building
sold Lot 24 to petitioner.
The Appellate Division opinion (App
106) in deciding the water company case
found that "plaintiff had extensive corre
spondence with the [Hackensack] Water
Company" prior to filing his complaint on
September 26, 1992, spanning a three year
period (1990-1992) [at issue herein] ." A
high bill investigation was invoked (App
107). After appearing before Judges Van
Tassel (App 110), Eichen (App 109), Murphy
(App 109), and Koblitz (App 111), the
case was dismissed by the trial courts
(App 114). Trying to avert shut-off, the
the Appellate Division denied relief (App
117), despite the fact the water bill
exceeded the fuel oil bill (App 24 and
25). Water was shut off at the apartment
house (App 117).
Consider how the Chancery decision
(oral opinion by Judge Sherwin Lester)
is to be interpreted in view of the
photographs of Multi-Pak (App. 193-199).
Is the taxing district denying that 18
complaints at 111 Passaic Street [App 190]
(adjacent to the funeral parking lot and
25 feet from the subject apartment house)
amount tO a nuisance per se? Is the
App. 90
burning of 111 Passaic Street (App 191)
~~ - | 134 ~ | a ~ + +
ana its demolition (App 201) providentia
oe | ¥
as to the demolition of another
-~— eT AS = 1 - -~ Q D + a %
residential property, 387 Park Street?
aims that nis apartment
ssment should take into account
1eighpornood. When James Mason
t he can derive a value for lana
a er oe
tor Park Court Apartments 391-397 Park
Street, Hackensack (the subject property)
based on the purchase price paid by Quail
Heights of $975,000 for 204,737 squar
feet App 211), 1S Mason acting as an
appraiser or as a lawyer. Is the unstated
premise that Prospect Street - zoned foyr
high ris construction - can be made tc
211 and 212 wi
k Court at App. 2 and
App. 3. Quail Heights is six stories high,
and has ilti-story concrete garage,
while Park Court is two stories high, with
on-street parking for 40% of the tenants.
onsider the photos of a typical apartment
t at Park Court shown at App. 202 -
210 and evaluate how similar those
hotos are to the psychiatri halfway
house (App 172 - 181).
m)
os
App. 91
When viewing the photos depicted at
App. 201-210, consider whether the
Chancery court had jurisdiction when it
claimed the vacancy rate at Park Court was
within normal bounds - a 95% vacancy rate
was testified to. Currently, a high turn-
over rate is being experienced. Note that
the county tax board reduced assessment on
the basis of location obsolescence (App
L)
Given the complex set of facts
addressed within, where cases have been
heard by numerous’- courts (Chancery,
federal trial and appeal courts, state
trial and appeal courts, municipal court,
etc.) and the county tax board has given
negligible reductions due to its
prohibition against providing equity
jurisdiction, does jurisdiction lie within
the Tax Court now? Petitioner claims it
—
does.
The Hackensack City Council passed
Resolution 260 ' (App 102) pertaining to
water thereby binding itself to the
position that $9,329 was due (App 103).
Prior to this resolution, it was not clear
whether the bill was too high, or whether
the meter was defective, or how the water
bill could be higher than the fuel bill.
App. 92
In effect, the City now claims that it can
tax through the taxing power as well as
through its water searcher (Hackensack
Water Company). Since the city regularly
advertises Sheriff's sales of properties
due to delinquent taxes, this places the
city in a conflict position. Consider
from the demolitions addressed within,
whether this lessens residential real
estate values.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Petitioner posed four questions in
his opening remarks. He maintains that
the materials in his extensive 212 page
appendix amply summarizes the need for the
Tax Court imposing restrictions on the
collection of taxes, until the water bill
is paid off. R. 1:1-2 states that "any
rule may be relaxed or dispensed with by
the court in which the action is pending
if adherence to it would result in an
injustice."
In the case at bar, the taxing
district is hopping from forum to forum
claiming lack of jurisdiction wherever it
lands. The result is that an apartment
house of 37 years cannot even pay its
water bill. The land for the _ subject
apartment house was bought for $2.00 "and
App. 93
other consideration." How far does the
"other consideration" go?
Date Submitted: December 31, 1994
Submitted By: SALVATORE MORETTI,
PETITIONER PRO SE
cc: Donald Lenner, Esq. (On Behalf of
the Taxing District)
286 Union Street
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
App. 94
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
January 5, 1995
Hon. Peter D. Pizzuto, J.T.C.
125 State Street
Room 108
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Re: Salvatore Moretti v. Cael = Oe
Hackensack, Docket No. 8336-93;
Parcel One - Block 418, Lots 22 and 23.
Parcel Two - Block 418, Lot 24. Motion
Return Date January 6, 1995.
Continuance on Motion to Impose Restraints
on Collection of Tax by Taxing District.
Oral Argument Requested.
Dear Judge Pizzuto:
Petitioner received a letter in
objection to his December 31, 1994
letter brief stating that the tolling of
time for filing does not apply within.
Others statements may be left to oral
argument, but this matter should be
addressed in advance so as to give the
App. 95
respondent city opportunity to. refute
petitioner's allegations.
Black's Law Dictionary (West
Publishing Co., 1990) defines the verb
toll as meaning "to suspend or _ stop
temporarily, as the statute of limitations
is tolled during the defendant's absence
from the jurisdiction and during the
plaintiff's minority. To bar, defeat, or
take away; thus, to toll the entry means
to deny or take away the right of entry."
The Oxford English Dictionary (1989,
2nd Edition) defines toll as to bar,
defeat, annul, as "The King may toll the
power of the parliament."
Corpus Juris Secundum 1990 Supplement
cites to Phillips v. Sharpestown General
Hospital , App. 1 Dist. 664 S.W. 2d. 162,
165 Petitioner notes in conjunction
therewith that the discovery rule is
discussed in this case, as follows:
"Appellants cite 37 Tex. Jur 2d.
Limitations of Actions, Section 155 in
support of their position. Therein it is
said:
'In a proper case the doctrine of
estoppel may be invoked to prevent
reliance on the statute of limitations.
Thus, in a proper case a defendant may be
:
: App. 96
precluded from relying on the defense of
limitation if the plaintiff's failure to
institute suit within the statutory period
was caused by the defendant's
misrepresentaiton or fraud, or by
negotiations for an amicable settlement
or by some other agreement or conduct that
lulled a creditor into security and
thereby caused him to delay action.
(Emphasis supplied). '
nL SSeS
In the case at bar, petitioner
commenced three lawsuits relating to the
expenses at Park Court Apartments, one
filed with the Bergen County Special Civil
Part of the Superior Court for expedited
settlement, one filed with the Superior
Court, Law Division, and one filed with
the Federal District Court, which included
both the Hackensack Water Company as
defendant and the City of Hackensack as a
taxing district. As noted,
interrogatories answered by the Hackensack
Water Company stated that they did not
perform water searches for the City of
Hackensack. Yet, according to the New
Jersey Lawyers Diary and Manual, the
Hackensack Water Company does perform
water searches.
Numerous questions were asked of the
water company about water consumption at
App. 97
the subject apartment house, and the
spaces provided for "answers" invariably
were filled in "not relevant" or some
other evasive reply. This is fraudulent
concealment of material facts entering
into the assessment of the subject real
property. The Mason appraisal provides, a
water expense of $900, while the
Hackensack Water Company regulated by the
Bureau of Regulatory Commissioners bills
petitioner $9,000. A 1000% increase in
the time period from 1981 to 1991 is
impossible to explain, and prompted the
federal litigation. The City of
Hackensack and the federal court deferred
to the state tax court, wherein this
matter must be addressed. On that basis,
the court time required to proceed in
state and federal court tolled the filing
of the appeal on real property taxes.
I have appended copies of the answers
to interrogatories by the water company in
federal court, as well as copies of the
listing of the water company as water
searcher for Hackensack, contrary to the
answer provided at No. 7, App 62.
This answer is relevant in that the
city relied upon the water’company for the
amount of water due in its municipal trial
App. 98
court, and allowed the water company to
h e water. At trial, th
ved the water company of any
wrong doing, not questioning its water
charged, and refusing all evidence thus
bringing such bills into question. The
trial befor Judge Dinice lasted from
August to December, 1992, and resulting
n petitioner filing his federal appeal.
ty
9
-
ct
i
cc: Donald Lenner, Esq.
286 Union Street
Hackensack, N. J. 07601
rents showing numerous court appearances.
rom January 1992 to March 31, 1993
'T)
a
ate Event
YEAR - 1991 [Summary]
Apr. 24 Hackensack Municipal Court -
Exterminate Animal
Apr. 25 . " "
Various Landlord Tenant Cases, such as:
LT-035513-91,
App.99
LT-036364-91, LT-038538-91, LT-038537-91,
etc. (Price,
Beavers...)
Nov. 20 Fire Alarms - Complainant -
Richard Carucci
YEAR - 1992 [Detail]
Jan. 21 Appeal to Bergen County Tax
Board heard in Hackensack City Council
Chambers, Appeal #445
Appeal of 1991 Taxes. Date Judgment Mailed
February 20, 1992. Land = $280,800.
Improvements = $486,000. Total = $766,800.
Taxing District - Hackensack. Address -
391-395 Park St., Hackensack. Judgement
Code: 14b -
Locational Obsolesence.
Jan 22 Landlord-Tenant Case No. LT-
042052-92 Special Civil Part. Non-payment.
Jan 25 LT-043491-92. LT-Trial Notice
3/12/92
March 2 Warrant of Removal, LT-043491-92
March S LT-043375-92; LT-043373-92; LT-
043374-92
March 12 LT-043491-92; LT-043760-92
March 18 Filed for Collection of Past Due
Rents “,
DC-694531-92; DC-694530-92; DC-694529-92
Apr 1 Trial, LT-044192-92
Apr 9 Trial, LT-044447-92
Apr 20 DC-694530-92
Apr 21 Eviction by Constable - 391-G
Apr 30 Trial, Judge Austin, SC-060945
App. 100
May 14 Carter Trial
June 2 Construction Board of Appeals,
Fire Alarms,Door Closers, Case C-8-S$2
June 23 White v. Moretti. $400
Deduction of $200 Security
June 24 Notice of Water Shut off
placed on Apt. Entry Door By Hackensack
jater Company
ly i LT-046723-92, OSC Judge Simon
July 14 Filed Complaint - Moretti v.
ckensack Water Co.
BER-L-08191-92
July 20 Interlocutory Injunction
Applied for: Hackensack
Water Co. Judge Eichen.
July 22 N. J. v. Moretti. $200 Fine.
Carucci Case
July 27 9 a.m., Judge Eichen.
Hackensack Water Court Hearing
Aug. 7 Motion. Moretti v. Hackensack
Water & Bd. of Regul.Commissioners, BER-L-
8191-92 2nd Motion: Johnson Case 397-F8
YEAR
1992 Detail (cont.)
Aug. 13 Hackensack Water Co., Shut-
Off Water at 4 p.m.to Park Court Apts.,
391-395 Park St., Hackensack
Patricia Farlie Stood By while Water Co.
shut water off. Filed Interlocutory
Injunction with Appellate Division at 4
p.m. Appel. Judge Kestin, 25 Main St.
App. 101
Hackensack
Aug 14 Oral Argument, Howard Kestin,
J.A.D. Appel Div.
Aug 17 Arrested by Hackensack
Municipal Court while addressing Superior
Court Judge Patrick Fitzpatrick upon
receipt of Order by Appellate Judge Kestin
as to notification of tenants receiving
subsidies that water is being shut off.
Placed in Bergen County Jail for three
days.
Aug 19. Landlord Tenant Eviction 397-
D, 1:30 p.m.Municipal Court Hearing 9 a.m.
Aug 26 Municipal Court Hackensack
Appearance. Carucci Case
Sept 2 N.J. v. Moretti (Patricia
Farlie, complainant, water shut-off. (C92-
2940, 2948, 2916)
Sept. 9 Trials in LT-048543-92, 397-I
LT-048541-92, 397-F
LT-048542-92, 391-H
Sept. 11 Moretti v. Hackensack Water
Co., Bd. of Regulatory Commissioners, BER-
L-8191-92. Injunction Applied for by Judge
Edward Van Tassle (Died Subsequently)
Sept. 18 LT-Case. 397-D
Sept. 22 Order to Show Cause Hearing,
397-D
Sept. 30 Filed Special Civil Money
Damages Case
DC-700124-92. 397-B
DC-049272-92. 391-D
App. 102
DC-705906-92. 397-F
Note: Triai Noticte.Moretti v.
sentile.BER-L-9278-92
ct. 2 Went to Hackensack Water Co.
Corporate Offices in Harrington Park, with
check for $2,950 in interim payment for
Water Bill. $11,000 outstanding.
Stic? Hearing. Hackensack Municipal
Court. Judge Dinice
Farlie: 92-2940; 92-2916
Carucci: 92-2449
t. White v. Moretti, 397-C. SC-
4413. Deduction from Security.
Oct. 14 Adjourn Date - Hackensack
Water Company, Mun.Ct.S-42-6599;W-
337637;W337641 - New Docket No's.
66s. 20 Moretti v. Gentile, BER-L-
9278-92. Pre-Trial
VG. 243 DC-700124-92. 397-B. Break in
by police bent door.Motion Hearing
Oct. 28 Municipal Court Hearings
Carucci v. Moretti 26-90
Farlie - 92-3016
Nov. 2 Hackensack Water Co. Case.
3:30 p.m. Mun. Ce.
YEAR
1992 Detail (cont.)
Nov. 4 ° 2 * . ". 3 OE
Municipal Court.
Nov. 6 Hackensack Municipal Cuort
Appearance, 4C Owners.
App. 103
Motion -. 397-B Break-In. Hackensack
Police DC-700124-92. Discovery Motion
Nov. 10 Hospitalized. Acute
Bronchitis. Hackensack Medical
Center.
Nov. 12 Appearrance in Special Civil
Part - Law Div. (Landlord-Tenant Court).
LT-050494-92. 391-E
LT-050496-92. 397-G
LT-050493-92. 391-J
LT-050495-92. 397-H
State of NJ v. Moretti. Water
Case. C92-3016.
Dec 3 Hackensack Municipal Court.
$525 Fine. Jailed in Bergen Count Jail
Dec 4 Moretti v. Zisa, et al. 92-
4206(HAA) Judge Harold Ackerman - Motion
Scheduled in Newark Federal Court.
Dec 12 Moretti v. Hackensack Water
Co. Special Civil Part DC-705907-92. DC-
705907-92. 9AM Trial. Judge Polito
Cancelled by Hackensack River floding into
Bergen County Justice Center Parking lot.
Arraignment 397-D Tenant. Indictment
$1642-92-002
Dec 14 Motion Day - U. S. District
Court Moretti v. Zisa, et. al., 92-4206
(HAA)
Dec. 16 LT-051368-92 1:30 p.m. Rm 103
1993 Event
App. 104
Jan 5 Moretti v. Zisa, et al.
Pretrial Conference Room 479, Federal
District Court, Newark.
Jan 8 Moretti v. Hackensack Water
Co.DC-705907-92 9 am. Rm. 123. Motion
Heard by Judge Polito [Note: Case against
water company filed in Superior Court
(Judge Vaan Tassle), also filed in Special
Civil Part for quick monetary Settle-
ment under account. Also filed in Federal
District Court (92-4206 Harold A.
Ackerman, Judge) Tenant in Apt. 397-D
Hackensack Municipal Hearing.
Jan 11 Pre-Trial Superior Court. 397-
D Tenant.
Jan 15 DC-700124-92 9 am trial. Rm.
320 Break-in and damage to apartment door.
397-D.
DC-705907-92. Trial Rm 320.
Jan 20 Trials all at 1:30 pm - Apts.
397-I, 391-I, 391-J
Jan 25 Motion before Judge Sybil
Moses - Aggrieved Party
Status - R. 3:5-6
Date Event
1993 (cont.)
Jan 27 LT-052324-92 (Eviction) - non-
payment of rent.
Municipal Court Appearance - Hackensack
Jan 29 Judge Sullivan. Motion to
Dismiss 397-D Tenant
’ App. 105
Feb. 1 Pre-Trial - 397-D Tenant
Sullivan
Filed Case, Federal District Court - DC93-
00528 .
Feb. 3 Filed Habeas Corpus Petition.
U.S. District Court
Tenant in 397-D
Feb. 4 LT-000301-93 1:30 p.m. 391-E
LT-000300-93 Rm. 123
Feb. 10 Carucci v. Moretti
92-2449 Municipal Court Trial
Feb. 11 Moretti v. Gentile and Bd. of
Adjustment. Trial
BER-L-009278-92 1:30 p.m.
Feb. 17 N. J. v. Moretti. (Carucci
Case) C92-2449 Part II
Feb. 19 Moretti v. Hackensack Water
Co., Oral Argument DC-705907-S2. Also,
Moretti v. Mele, et al., DC625742, Jersey
City
Feb. 22 Ballard v. Moretti, SC-585-93.
Judgement entered against Salvatore
Moretti. Summons and Complaint Filed by
prospective tenant who delivered summons
to wrong address, resulting in entry of
default due to non-appearance. Entered by
Judge Polito.
Feb 24 11 am Municipal Court
Appearance Part III Carucci
case - adjourned. C92-2449
Feb. 26 Appellate Division Motion to
Dismiss. Went to Howard Kestin's (J.A.D.)
Ap;. 106
Court, Michael Rychel considered motion
ar
brought on behalf of 397-D tenant
March 1 9 am Trial before Judge
Sullivan 397-D
97-I Tenant. Eviction Case.
1:30 p.m. 397-D Tenant
appeared before Judge Minuskin
March 8 Moretti v. Zisa, Hackensack
Water Co., et al.,92-4206 (HAA)
Oral Argument in Newark Requested.
March 9 Picked up transcript of
roceedings before the Hackensack
ankataes Court relating to the terminat-
ion of water service at Park Court Apts.,
Arrested with transcript in hands.
Incarcerated all day in Hackensack jail
cell until night.
March 19 Return day of Moretti v.
Hackensack Water Co. case,DC-705907-92.
Adjourned to April 16, 1993
March 31 Appeal of Assessment to the
New Jersey Tax Court,File Today with copy
to Bergen County Tax Board.
April 5 SC-001574-93. Trial before
Judge Polito. 397-J
April 7 Hackensack Municipal Court.
Carucci v. Moretti. 92-2449
April 8 Arraignment of tenant from
397-D. Before Judge Sybil Moses Rm 307
App. 107
Date Event
1993 (cont.)
April 12 Oral Argument. Federal
District Court. Newark. 10 a.m. 92-4206 10
am Addressed both Ackerman and Magistrate
' Chesler.
April 14 LT-002417-93 Tenant in
Apartment 391-E.Room 123. Judge Polito
April 16 Ballard v. Moretti, SC-585~-93.
Motion to set aside Default.
Moretti v. Hackensack Water
Co., DC-705903-92 Judge Koblitz, newly
elevated to judgeship, dismissed the case.
April 19 Motion - Moretti v. Hackensack
Water Co.,DC-705907-92. Judge Polito
Transferred out.
April 21 9 am Hackensack Municipal
Court. Docket No.92-2449
Carucci v. Moretti
April 23 Moretti v. Mele. Proof
Hearing. Hudson County.
Jersey City
April 29 Scheduling Conference. 10:30
a.m. Magistrate Chesler.
May 5 Tenant in Apt 397-D Appearance
Hackensack Municipal. Court. S659173
Carucci Case Dismissed* due to lack of
prosecution
May 10 Motion to Dismiss. Federal
Case. Moretti v. Dinice, et al., 93-528.
Attended Hearings on Motions for oral
argument in Newark Federal Court House
App. 108
May 14 Motion for Reconsideration,
Moretti v. Hackensack Water Co., DC-
705907-93, Judge Koblitz, Moretti v.
Fields & BCBSS, 4327-93. Adjourned
to June 11, 3:30 pm
May 18 Peremptory Trial Date, Ballard
Case, SC-585-93
May 24 Motion to Dismiss Moretti v.
Dinice, et al.,93-528
May -26 397-J - LT-3755-93. Eviction -
landlord tenant case
397-G - LT-3751-93. "
" " +
June 2. LT-3869-93, 397-1. Rent &
Scheduling Conference.
June 10 LT-4151-93 Judge Troast. Rm
314. 397-D
June 11 Motions heard by Judge
Koblitz, former lawyer for tenant in apt.
297-D Moretti v. Hackensack Water Co.,
DC-705907-92 3:30 Moretti v. Fields, 4327-
93.
June 17 Judge Troast, Continuance on
case LT-4151-93, 397-D
: App. 109
MARKET DATA FROM THE Ase OF
HACKENSAACK, N.J.
Source: SR1-A Form in Hackensack 1991-1994
Sales at 281 Park Street [Park Street
Conominiums]
1991 Sales (on condo units)
Unit 5-E. Price: $25,000. Sheriff to
Spencer Savings & Loan 2Unit 3-G. Price:
$35,000. Sheriff to Spencer Savings
(Assessment: L $14,800 + I $73,900 =
$88,700.)
Unit 5-B. Price: $100. Sheriff to Howard
Savings.Deed dated: 9/25/92. SR1-A_ -
2562282 Assessed: L $14,800 + I $73,900 =
$88,700
Unit 5-C. Deed Book 7600. P. 298. Date
2/5/93. Price $100.Assessment Total
$66,500.Sheriff to First Fidelity Bank
Unit Deed Bk 7610, P. 414. 4/16/93.
Price $100. Assessed $14,800 + IS51,700 =
$66,500.
Sheriff to First Fidelity Bank.
Unit Bk 7625, P. 14, Date - 6/25/93.
Sheriff to First Fidelity Bank. Assessed
$66,500. Price $0.
Classification Residence. NU #4.
Serial No. 2902988
Unit 2C Bee F626. Be. 227Ti. S7i8 792.
Sheriff to Spencer Savings.
Assessed $66,500. Price - $100.
Unit 2F Bk. 7627, P. 214. Date - 7/2/93.
App. 110
Sheriff to Lakeview Savings And Loan,
Pric $100. Assessed $64,100.
Serial No. 2903326
Unit 36 Book 7634, P. 257. Spencer
Savings to YAZDI,Assessed $135,400. Price
- $124,000 NU 13 (Bankruptcy)
Unit 4F Bk. 7636. P. 752. Date 9/7/93.
South Bergen Savings to Allford. Price
$32,000. Assessed $64,100.
Not Used (nu) #13. Bankruptcy.
Unit 2F Bk 7649, P. ly 10/29/73.
Assessed $64,100.Price 45,000 Serial No.
2908159. NU #29: "Materially
Gepreciated after assessing date but prior
to sale. Grantor attorney Salvatore L.
Borelli agrees with the
statement. (s) Charles Mason. Mun.
Representative.
Unit SL Book 7658. P. 362. 11/30/93.
Yazdi to Sofla. Serial No. 2910290
Assessed $60,500 Price 35,000. NU - #13.
Unit 4C Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.
to Lamprect. Price $25,000. Deed 12/16/93.
Ser.No. 2913240 Bk. 7669 P. 710
Unit 2L Sheriff to Lakeview Savings
Price $100. Assessed $60,500. NU #13.
Db.7680, p. 190, 2/25/94. Serial No.
2915550
Unit 5B F.D.I.C. Feygin. Db. 7681. P.
823. 3/1/94. Serial No. 2915566. Price
$30,000. Assessed 66,500.
Unit 5J Sheriff to Lakeview Savings. Db.
App. 111
7692 P 577, 2/25/94.Price - $100. Assessed
$59.800. NU #12. Ser#2917972
Unit 2A Sheriff to Lakeview Savings.
Db.7692,P593. Price $100 Assessed $64,500.
Ser. # 2917973
Unit 5D Sheriff to Federal Deposit
Insurance Corp.,Db 7698.P. 768. Date
3/28/94. Price $1. Assessed $66,500.
Serial No. 2919244. NU #13
Unit 2L Deed Book 7701, P 87. 5/26/94.
Price $40,000 Assessed $60,500. Serial
No. 2911846
Unit 5D Deed Book 7703, P.817, 5/24/94.
Price - $24,000. Assessment $66,500.
Serial No. 2921856
Unit 2A Lakeview Savings to Pinter.
Price $31,000. Assessed $64,500. NU #26.
Serial No. 2919754
Unit 5J7 Price $35,000. Assessed $59,800.
Price $35,000. NU #26. Serial No. 2919755
Unit 4B Sheriff Terhune to Lakeview
Savings, Price $100.Price $35,000.
Assessed $66,500. NU - #26. Serial
No. 2919756, Db 7704 P. 346. 3/11/94.2
Unit 3C Spencer Savings to Shearson
Lehman Mtge. Corp.Db. 7704, P. 585.
9/29/93. Price $100. Assess. $66,500.
NU #25. Serial Noo. 2919760
Unit 3C GE Capitol Mtg. Services of
California to Lagharifar,2 Price $34,900.
Assessed $66,500. Serial #3379649
Unit 2E Price - Blank. Db. 7722, P. 384.
6/29/94.Resolution Trust Corp to Joyce
Olivieri, Assessed 65,500 , NU #26. Serial
No. 3379836
Unit 2D Price 29,000. Resolution Trust
Co. to James Olivieri. Assessed $66,500.
Db. 7722. O. 841. 6/13/94. Serial No.
we
me » “Cc cnn sc /69
Book 7581, P. 500. 1/15/93.
Ss 0
Price $100 Assessea 14,60
$73,40C Serial No. 2562543
nal Sales Listed of Note
s Seventy-Two Unit Apartment House
at 370 Park Street, Hackensack, N.J.
Cocoziello to Frank Alster. Deed Book
7489, P. 916. Dated: 11/20/91. Recorded
1/2/92.Block 415 Lot 1 Apartment Use - 4C.
Pric
sea: Land $1,260,000. Imp. =
8,000 Net = $3,108,000
App. 113
SALVATORE MORETTI, PRO SE
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
TAX COURT OF NEW JERSEY
SALVATORE MORETTI, : STATE OF NEW JERSEY
Petitioner: Docket No. 9479-95
Vv. : Further Certification
: in Support of Motion
CITY OF HACKENSACK: For Temporary
Defendant : Restraints on
Taxing District
Block 418, Lots
22, 23, 24, & Block
415, Lot 8.b
To: Donald J. Lenner, Esq.
(On Behalf oof Hackensack Taxing
Authority)
hi Salvatore Moretti, in
Support of temporary restraints being
placed upon the City of Hckensack in the
collection of real estate taxes at the
three parcels subject of this lawsuit,
to wit:
390 Park Street, Hackensack, Block
415, Lot. 8.b. 391-397 Park” Street,
Hackensack, Block 418, Lots 22 and 23,
387 Park St., Hackensack, tlock 418, Lot
24,d0 hereby under oath make this
declaration:?
App. 114
a i am <une property owner of the
ct real property listed above and am
ly familiar with the facts of this
The property located at 391-7 Park
et, Hackensack is occupied by a two
ory bric apartment house containing
wenty one-bedroom apartments; I provide
neat and hot water, and snow removal to
e three lots, lots 22, 23, and 24.
I paid $20,250 to the Hackensack Water
company (now known as United Water New
Jersey) in the past sixteen months. Over
$5,000 1s alleged to be outstanding on the
bill as of December 31, 1995. The judge
who arrested me for failing to pay my
water bill has retained a lawyer who is
suing me for $6,000 in legal expenses TAX
COURT OF NEW JERSEY, SALVATORE 4MORETTI
vs. CITY OF HACKENSACK, Docket No.
9479-95; Further Certification in Support
of Motion For Temporary Restraints on
Taxing District, Block 418, Lots 22, 23,
24, & Block 45, Lot 8.b PG. 2
1/5/95 for defending against the lawsuit
involving Louis Dinice. There have already
been placed lawsuits against me for
bringing frivolous litigation, despite the
obvious excessiveness of the bills I am
being expected to pay. For example, one
" W bh
ge ag,
ry
4)
qt
| App. 115
tenant was arrested on site after being
deprived of water, heat, gas and electric;
when I attempted to defend her case, OVER.
three thousand dollars IN DAMAGES have
ALREADY been assessed against me.
4. It is apparent that the tenants are in
hardship and have requested lower rents.
In order to protest high rents, tenants
have taken the option of causing excessive
damage to the building. For example, all
leases require that tenants not use tools
to disable the plumbing. Nevertheless, I
just entered one apartment where a tenant
revealed that he had a set of tools which
he used to take his plumbing fixtures
apart. When I entered his apartment, he
viewed me fixing the plumbing, and it was
apparent that he had inserted defective
plumbing parts, resulting in a drip.
Trying to stop the "drip" he then turned
on and off the shut off valve repeatedly,
thereby causing a drip which seeped down
to the downstairs apartment, causing the
ceiling to give way. This tenant
complained several months ago that the
rent was too high, and =svacated his
apartment, moving in with someone already
living here at the buiiding.
5. Another tenant in another apartment
experienced a sluggish kitchen Sink's
drain. Instead of depending on me to
fix the clogged drain, he took it upon
App. 116
himself to go into the crawl space and ~°
remove the metal cap from a clean out.
The water from his apartment then drained
directly upon the floor in the crawlspace.
The odor was so great that it attracted
attention. This tenant cooks a great
deal, and obviously uses water which
flushed onto the floor caused a health
hazard. When I discovered what was done,
he had no explanation as to why he thought
he was empowered to do make-shift plumbing
repairs. This tenant subsequenty called me
and requested that I install a pop-up for
his bathroom sink. He had taken upon
himself the authority to install his own
bathroom faucet with a pop-up which he did
not have. I advised him that I installed
only one manufacturer's faucets, and this
was not the supplies I had. I cautioned
this tenant not to do this, but he
persists.
6. I have picked up at least 2,000 beer
and liquor bottles off the lawn areas, and
thrown onto the parking lots. The tenants
I rented to pay their rent better than
other tenants I leased to, but they drink
so excessively and are so careless with
their liquor bottles, it is clear that
they require extra maintenance.
7. I have over the Thanksgiving week
performed four main sewer line clean-outs.
App. 117
I have paid about $160 to clean out the
lines when they clog between the building
and the center of the street. Just one
week's bills would be. $640.00 for main
sewer line clean outs. This group of
tenants has repeatedly caused main sewer
line stoppage; on four successive week-
ends, I entered the laundry room located
in the basement only to discover that
there was over 1500 gallons of water in
the basement, due to main sewer line
clogging. Not only the sewer needed to be
cleaned, but the basement pumped out as
well. I did the pumping out, and I have
"gone through" at least ten pumps pumping
water out - each
App. 118
SALVATORE MORETTI. PRO SE
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
TAX COURT OF NEW
JERSEY
SALVATORE MORETTI. : STATE OF NEW
JERSEY
Petitioner Docket No. 9479-95
v. : Further Certification
in Support of Motion
CITY OF HACKENSACK, : For Temporary
Restraints on Taxing
Defendant ; District, Hackensack.
Block 418. Lots
22, 23. 24, & Block 45.
Lot 8.b
To: Donald J. Lenner, Esq.
(On Behalf of Hackensack Taxing Authority)
286 Union Street
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
I, Salvatore Moretti, in support of temporary restraints
being placed upon the City of Hackensack in the collection of
real estate taxes at the three parcels subject of this lawsuit,
to wit:
390 Park Street, Hackensack, Block 415, Lot 8.b
391-397 Park Street, Hackensack, Block 418, Lots 22 and 23
387 Park St., Hackensack, Block 418, Lot 24,
I, Salvatore Moretti, do hereby under oath make this
declaration:
App. 119
1. lam the property owner of the subject real property listed
above and am fully familiar with the facts of this case.
2. The property located at 391-7 Park Street. Hackensack
is occupied by a two story brick apartment house containing
twenty one-bedroom apartments; I provide heat and hot water.
and snow removal to the three lots, lots 22, 23, and 24.
3. Simultaneous with the move in of the group of tenants
currently occupying Park Court Apartments, .various
maintenance problems resulted thus far covered, such as
plumbing (numerous main sewer back ups) . lawn
maintenance (2000 liquor bottles resulting from late night
partying) . apartment maintenance (tenants replaced locks.
changed plumbing fixtures, etc.), laundry maintenance
(machine breakdowns due to coin shutes filled with pennies.
nickels. and worthless coins), etc.
4. Recently, fluorescent light fixtures mysteriously burned
out, requiring replacing. The fluorescent light fixtures
illuminating the Public Service Gas and Electric Meters
burned out, and required replacement of the fixture itself.
Three new fixtures had to be purchased, despite the fact that
they were recently installed.
5. Toilet seats had been newly installed and were an
expensive component of the rental apartment. These seats
were removed by virtually all of the eighteen tenants rented to
in the last two years, resulting overnight in the disappearance
of $400 of toilet seats and their replacement by cheap toilet
seats.
6. I hired one superintendant who appeared to be ideal for the
job. An apartment was prepared for his occupancy. He said
he was going to occupy the apartment any day, but in fact kept
me waiting for three months before occupying the apartment .
App. 120
Once he did so, he put inlaid linoleum over the ceramic tile in
the bathroom. painted the place cove base in the kitchen an
unusual color. and refused to do any work or pay any rent. |
was required to do all the work of the superintendant. He was
served eviction papers, but given the delays of court procedure
it required seven months for him to move from the date he was
supposed to move in.
6. | While Mr. Donald Lenner, Esq. maintains that it is
possible to detail each and every diseconomy which resulted
from the prior certifications, | do not believe the average
apartment owner has the time or the credentials to do so.
Hence. the form interrogatories are objectionable due to
impossibility of performance.
7. Based upon the profile of the tenancy and operating
difficulties of the apartment house. it is understandable that the
Bergen County Tax Board concluded that the reason for
lowering the assessment was that the land was surrounded by
external diseconomies. I believe that the income-expense
analysis contained in the detailed cost of operating the
building must be considered in arriving at true value - taxable
value. I require additional time to prepare for my April 15,
1996 taxes filings. I therefore request that the court stay the
imposing of taxes due February 1, 1996 based upon the 700-
pages of materials relating to the property thus far produced,
which have been heavily dependent upon income-expense
analysis.
6. The foregoing statements made by me are true. I am
aware that if any of the foregoing statements made by me are
willfully false, 1 am subject to punishment.
Date: January 12, 1996
App. 121.
SALVATORE MORETTI, PRO SE
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
TAX COURT OF NEW JERSEY
SALVATORE MORETTI,: STATE OF NEW JERSEY
Petitioner: Docket No. 9479-95
Vv. : Further Certification
: in Support of Motion
CITY OF HACKENSACK: For Temporary
: Restraints on Taxing
Defendant : District, Hackensack,
Block 418, Lots 22,
23, 24, & Block 45, Lot 8.b
To: Donald J. Lenner, Esq.
(On Behalf of Hackensack)
z; Salvatore Moretti, in support of
temporary restraints being placed upon
the City of Hackensack in the collection
of real estate taxes at the three
parcels subject of this lawsuit, to wit:
390 Park Street, Hackensack, Block
415, Lot 8.b
391-397 Park Street, Hackensack,
Block 418, Lots 22 and 23 387 Park St.,
Hackensack, Block 418, Lot 24,do hereby
under oath make this declaration:
> I am the property owner of the
subject real property listed above and am
fully familiar with the facts of this
case.
App. 122
a: The property located at 391-7 Park
treet, Hackensack is occupied by a two
story brick apartment house containine
twenty one-bedroom apartments; I provide
heat and hot water, and snow removal to
he three lots, lots 22, 23, and 24.
By notice dated February 15, 1996,
lerk of the U. S.. Court of Appeals
he Third Circuit has forwarded to me
ication of the order filed by the
awarding $8,496.09 to Robert
who was employed to defend Louis
e. The "trial" in that case never
occurred, the case was dismissed without
scheduling of a hearing, and the only
reason for the award was that Zimmerer
alleged he read papers submitted to the
court by other parties. The order speaks
for itself as to the nature of the
services provided by the city. Dinice
apparently precipitated my arrest in my
own home when I tried to collect rent from
B. Freeman. Dinice himself found Freeman
to be guilty of uttering false statements
about Hackensack officials. Freeman had
just emerged from Bergen County jail when
she filed complaints which were "believed"
by the city. I enclose the award for
legal fees for your reference. It is
apparent that the assessment of Block 418,
lot 8.b must be lowered accordingly, due
to the intereference with rent collections
oO
=~
th ct WwW ct
Co
my ©
re
* ie
cs: -tF
Ky
ct
JN O
te
3
- 3
(D
Ky
(D
K
C
ty
j
Q
(
es App. 123
at that address.
4. Recently tenants called the fire
department due to the sounding of the
smoke alarms. I received a notice from the
fire department which found the alarm
system was not operating, and shut down
the system in both buildings. The system
remained shut down for one week. I enclose
the fire alarm notice for your reference.
In order to correct the defective smoke
and fire alarms, I personally inspected
the smoke alarms at _ the site, and
nineteen defective smoke alarms had to be
removed. The problems found were many.
Several were unplugged. Several were
rewired so as not to sound. The rest were
clearly installed from other locations
after good smoke alarms were stolen from
this location. I found two defective
smoke alarms next to each other. I found
that some alarms did not sound, some
alarms sounded all the time, some alarms
had not parts inside of them, the wiring
having been removed - clearly indicating
tampering. I did this work for a period
of eighteen hours, and the work occurred
over a period of a week. Along with the
purposeful dismantling of the fire alarm
system, when I attempted to repair it, the
tenants called the fire department,
thereby further interfering with work on
site. To further create a fire emergency,
Cia
wd
J
wy
-<
*
© .
-
Q
“AH
’
q@
/ ort
fal
J
iJ
Ww
‘ OF
,
ge +
Vv
iJ
Aman *
etti\.2¢ ae
s
vy tetah
a me
a
‘
a
e
App. 125
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
March 29, 1996
Kent R. Papsun
Bureau of Customer Assistance
N.J. Board of Public Utilities
Two Gateway Center
Newark, New Jersey 07102
United Water New Jersey
P. O. Box 23398
Newark, N. J. 07197-0001
Hackensack Water Company
190 Moore Street
Hackensack, N. J. 07601
Judges Gerson/Jeffrey
Office of Administrative Law
185 Washington Street
Newark, N.J. 07101
Judge Peter D. Pizzuto, J.T.C.
125 State Street
6Room 108
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
U
)
)
]
J
2
fo
fy
|
©]
i
4
tr]
fy
'¢
in
()
ity
bo
Hackensack Water to Answer
—_ ; a or ne © | ry 2 D oS 2D »y fe c
og.Acct #05-480-18900-2. Add. 2¢--5
ark.St., Hackensack, NJ.
Dear Judges Gerson, Jeffrey, Pizzuto, Mr
Papsun, Ms. Peretz, Hackensack Ta>
~-Oliector, et al
t am disputing the water bil, as
mackensack Water Co., now known as United
Water N J cO., has been advises On
1/31/96 I received a statement of account
trom the Hackensack Water Company,
reflecting payment Of $21,250.00. This
matches the payments I made as per my
1/9/96. I enclose an additional payment of
$1,000.00 resulting in a nineteen month
total of $22,500 as follows:
09/6/94 1. 0455-006389, $1,000.00 to
Hackensack Water Co. 09/6/94 2. 0455-
006390, $1,000.00 to Hackensack Water Co.
9/6/94 3. 0455-006391, $500.00 to
Hackensack Water Co. 9/6/94 4. 0455-
006392, $1,000.00 to Hackensack Water Co.
9/15/94 1. 0455-006478, $1,000.00 to
Hackensack Water Co. 9/15/94 2. 0455-
006479, $ 500.00 to Hackensack Water Co.
10/14/94 1.0455-006797, $1,000.00 to
Hackensack Water Co. 10/14/94 2.0455-
006798, $500.00 to Hackensack Water Co.
11/10/94 1.0455-007157, $1,000.00 to
Hackensack Water Co. 11/10/94 2.0455-
007158,
12/7/94 1.
Hackensack
12/7/94 2.
Hackensack
12/31/94 1.
Hackensack
3/14/95 1.
Hackensack
3/14/95 2.
Hackensack
3/14/94 3.
Hackensack
§/15/395 i.
Hackensack
5/15/95 2.
Hackensack
6/8/95 1.
United Water Co.,
Hackensack
7/47/98 2.
Water Co.,
Hackensack
7/7/95 2.
Water Co.,
Hackensack
8/7/95 1.
Water Co.,
Hackensack
me
Water Co.,
Hackensack
App.
0455-907466,
Water Co.
0455-007467.
Water Co.
0455-007711.
Water Co.
0455-008560.
Water Co.
0455-008343.
Water Co.
0455-008561.
Water Co.
0455-009406.
Water Co.
0455-009407.
Water Co.
0455-009715.
aka
127
$500.00 to Hackensack Water Co.
$1,000.00 to
$500.00 to
$1,000.00 to
$1,000.00 to
$800.00 to
$200.00 to
$1,000.00 to
$1,000.00 to
$1,000.00 to
Water Company.
0455-009948.
aka
Water Co.
0455-009099.
aka
Water Co.
0455-010144.
aka
Water Co.
0455-009949.
aka
Water Co.
$500.00 to
$500.00 to
$500.00 to
$500.00 to
United
United
United
United
App. 129
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
July 5, 1996
Hon. Peter D. Pizzuto, J.T.C.
125 State Street
Room 108
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Re.: Moretti v. City of Hackensack, No.
9479-95; Parcel One - Bl 418, Lots
22 and 23. Parcel Two - Bl 418, Lot
24, Parcel Three, Bl 415, Lot 8.b.
Motion Return Date June 10, 1996
Dear Judge Pizzuto:
On June 10, 1996 at a motion in the
above captioned matter, Il endeavored to
mark for the record documents which had
been delivered to the Tax Court and to the
defendant. Mr. Lenner, on behalf of the
defendant City of Hackensack, refused to
have any documents marked prior to the
motion hearing. At the motion hearing, I
suggested receiving into evidence the
documents which I had transmitted to the
New Jersey Tax Court, so that a list of
salc aocuments would appear of record
=nsteac, your Honor proceeded inte the
guestion of whetner outside expert
csestimony would be offered as tc the value
f the property under appeal, and whether
or by whom testimony would be taken.
While the determination at the end of
the motion hearing was couched in terms
l co to several alternatives, it
ass =
se Aw ss bone = is
- . . be . be “
not clear whether che court gaeciaea to
take additional testimony from parties to
ed b the Court itself or Mr.
L or whether Mr. Lenner would be
putting on his case.
nce the determination of the Court
ear (is the court waiting for me to
call an expert witness upon whom I will
rely?), I suggest that Mr. Lenner set
forth in an order what the City of
Hackensack's position is. Should issues
be raised therein which are in dispute, a
hearing may be conducted, or perhaps a
final order should be offered with
opportunity to state plaintiff's position.
Very truly,
(s) Salvatore Moretti, Plaintiff Pro Se
cc: Donald Lenner, Esq. (On Behalf of
City of Hacknsack)
App. 131
SALVATORE MORETTI
390 PARK STREET
HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY 07601
(201) 646-1414
April 20, 1996
Larry Manning
Bureau of Housing Maintenance
& Inspections
Dept. of Community Affairs
Hackensack City Hall
65 Central Avenue
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
re: Notices Delivered to management of
Park Court Apartments, 391-397 Park st.,
Hackensack, NJ 07601, Unregistered Cars
parked & Smoke Detectors
Dear Mr. Manning:
In reply to your notices as to cars
parked without registration at Park Court
Apartments, more particularly described
as Block 418, Lot 24, I have placed on
notice the various tenants of the
building with regard to the cars subject
of the notice. As of this date, I am
awaiting responses as to who owns the
subject vahicles.
As to the interior smoke alarms and
the dismantling of the fire alarm system,
that has been placed back in service
App. 132
new smoke detectors were
, Suggesting an excessive number
smoke detectors were malfunctioning
tO)6U tampering - removing of smoke
ectors, pulling wires out of the smoke
detectors, placing in service non-
functionng smoke detectors, selling the
operational smoke detectors in place of
malfunctioning smoke detectors, and so
forth.
That is also referenced in the enclosed
notice of leashold violations excerpted
for you in the following:
ay
Ph tS th
”
(2,0 Fb’
9)
dBm ££
1 ct
fm
yoril 19, 1996
re: Notice to Cease Leasehold Violations
at Park Court Apartments, Apt. Park
Street, Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Dear TENANTS NAMED INDIVIDUALLY
This is a NOTICE TO CEASE LEASHOLD
VIOLATIONS. You are currently a
residential tenant residing at the above
noted apartment at 391-397 Park Street,
Hackensack, New Jersey. Your lease is a
written lease. Your monthly rent is due
on or before the first of each month.
This notice commands that you cease the
violations complained of oor be evicted
from the rented premises.
Notices Delivered to management of Park
App. 133
Court Apartments, 391-397 Park st.,
Hackensack, NJ 07601 -Unregistered cars
parked and smoke detectors, 4/20/96 - 2 -
The leashold violations complained
of which have been committed by you and
the other occupants of Apartment 39
Park Street, Hackensack, New Jersey are
listed as follows. Cease these
violations.
4. Cease removing smoke alarms from your
apartment ceiling. All apartmnts were
rented with operating smoke alarms, and
they should be left operation for your
safety, and in accord with the fire laws.
If smoking sets off the smoke alarm, turn
your exhaust fan on. All exhaust fans
were in operating condition when your
apartmnt was rented to you.
Notice to Cease Leasehold Violations at
Park Court Apartments, 391-7 Park Street,
Hackensack, New Jersey 07601, 4/19/96. p.
2
S. Cease interfering with the fire alarm
system at Park Court Apartments, by
removing the electric components of the
smoke alarms installed in the common
areas, by inserting defective smoke
alarms in the common areas, by removing
properly functioning smoke alarms from
App. 134
2 eas, Dy installing smoke
arms wnich do not sound in the common
im ¢
mw © ¢t
reas even in the presence of smoke, and
Dy installing smoke alarms which
constantly sound in the common areas even
ner there is no smoke present. The
forgoing acts cause the loss of fire
protection to the other tenants, ana
in@rease fire insurance rates.
6. Cease using the grounds of Park Court
Apartments to dispose of garbage by
discarding beer and liquor bottles, and
other garbage on the lawns, driveways,
walkways, and the front sidewalks,
instead of using the 2 three cubic yard
containers provided at the rear of Park
Court Apartments. This practice results
in flats, such as when the glass breaks
and vehicle tires pass over broken glass.
This practice results in an unsightly
appearance in the front lawn areas when
bottles are tossed in the bushes, or in
the rear areas when bottles are tossed
behind the fencing.
13. Cease performing all manner of
improper make-shift remdedies including
the following: parking in fire lanes,
and doing repairs in vehicles improperly
parked so as to block the use of the
driveways. Cease leaving the vehicles so
parked for many hours on end. Cease
stringing electric wires from the
apartment house into the vehicles
App. 135
improperly parked outside so as to
perform make-shift repairs. Cease
stringing electric wires in your
apartment to the outside windows so that
others can perform make shift repairs,
leaving the vehicle parked illegally and
blocking the fire lanes for hours on end.
Cease putting up make-shift electric
wiring in your apartment, putting up blue
painter's drop cloths which are then
strung aS room dividers so that extra
beds can be placed in the living room.
Notices Delivered to management of Park
Court Apartments, 391-397 Park st.,
Hackensack, NJ 07601 -Unregistered cars
parked and smoke detectors, 4/20/96 - 3 -
14. Cease causing unregistered cars to
be parked in the perking areas of Park
Court Apartment. If you wish to park a
car in our parking areas, you are
required to write the license plate
number of the car on a piece of paper,
and present this to the management
office, with your name and apartment
number on the notice, along with the date
and the make of the car.
15. Cease stringing elctric lighs on the
ceilings which result in make shift
electric repairs. This increases fire
hazard. Also cease making changes by
App. 136
installing barrirs in your rooms without
the prior approval of management; such
barriers include wooden barriers as well
as barriers in which curtains are erected
dividing rooms.
16. The management of Park Court
Apartment has received - notice of
violation dated March 7, 1996 from the
City of Hackensack as follows: "you are
-hereby notified that an inspection has
been made by this department on March :
i996 of the following premises...listed
as Block 418, Lots 22 and 23 in
Hackensack and ...the following
conditions were found to exist: Remove
all abandoned vehicles parked in parking
areas which are contrary to "Vehicles and
Property" of the Code of the City of
Hackensack. Incorporated within this
notice was notice dated November 30,
1995, listing unregistered, abandoned,
Stripped and dismantled motor vehicles on
Block 418, lot 24, also known as 387 Park
Street, Hackensack - the lot to the south
of the two apartment buildings. General
ordinance of Hackensack Ord. #1-74, Ch.
104, Sections 104-1 and 104-2 prohibit
the parking, storing or otherwise placing
of the above mentioned unregistered and
abandoned vehicles. The vehciles listed
were as follows:
- Blue 2-door GMC panel truck having flat
tires and no registration.
- Black 4-door Chevrolet Malibu with
missing rear rim and tires, flat front
-App. 137
tires and bearing. invalid Registration
ABN-1565 |
- Black 4-door Oldsmoblie bearing no
registration with flat tires.
- Black 4-door Lumina Chevrolet with
missing front rims and tires and no
registration.
- 2-door Omega Oldsmobile having invalid
Registration FY-605C.
_ White 4-door Aries with missing front
rims and tires having invalid N. Y.
registration E-65-OYK.
- Black 4-door Datsun with missing rear
rim and tire with no registration.
- 4-door Maxima Toyora having no
registration.
The notice from Hackensack states
that all containers filled with oil, all
automobile parts consisting of rims,
tires, transmissions, car doors and all
other automobile parts abandonee and/or
stores on these propertes are to be
removed. This property is presently
located in a residential zone and cannot
be maintained as an automobile junk yard.
Additional cars listed for removal
and or towing away by the City of
Hackensack are as follows:
Notices Delivered to management of Park
Court Apartments, 391-397 Park st.,
App. 138
ck, NO 07601 -Unregistered cars
1 anc smoke detectors, ¢/20/96 - @ -
- Four door Black Chrysler bearing flat
tires with no registration.
~ Four door Chevrolet Station Wagon with
considerable body damage bearing invalid
N. J. registration CH-230S.
our door red Honda Accord having no
*ry
gistration
- Four door gold Datsun 280 ZK with flat
tires and no registration.
i7. The management of Park Court
Apartments, 391-397 Park Street,
Hackensack, has received notice of
hazardous conditions dated April 2, 1996
as follows:
- Remove extension cords inside of
apartments.
- Repair or replace battery operated
smoke detectors inside of apartments.
- Light fixtrues inside of apartments
that are improerly wired must be removed
or wired properly.
Please correct the above listed code
violations inside of your apartment.
Failure to do so may result in your
eviction.
18. The management of Park Court
Apartments has received notice dated
March 5, 1996 from the Fre Department of
the City of Hackensack that "the smoke
alarm system must be repaired and back in
service within forty eight hours." Upon
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.