Transcript of Record — Seaboard Air Line Ry. v. United States
Supreme Court brief1920
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(26,834)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
OCTOBER TERM, 1919.
No. 248. |
THE SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY, APPELLANT,
Ux,
THE UNTPRED STATES.
APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS.
INDEX.
Original ‘Print.
Petition and amended pettloniess ces cereccvevcdveteccctanses 1 1
So er eer eee ee eee Tron eT eee eee Tr eee a 3
C0 CR. dso ake hb et band 0Gs ROEROR TRE RNS 5 3
Order of court, entered January 7, YAIR... cccccsccccccenecee 6 3
Findings of fact, conclusion of law, and opinion of the court... 7 4
Oe a a ar reer ey aT 25
EET ETE LER TCL TEETER TE OC re eT eT rr 28 25
OU Ge CIMAG EG GODOEL, GO sn es 6 is cndiws coscarenesavectesss 28 25
eee DU PRIINON as. 5s 50 sy 6 hes Vs Woo 0 kde eRe bo ee 29 25
Jupp & Derweiter, (ENC.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, 1) C.. JUNE 17, 1919.
wees
BALM rang or rN QNigh bas meen SPE SPRAINS SEIN TANIA
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, UNITED STATES, 1
l In the Court of Claims.
No, 240915.
The Skapoarp Air Line Raitpway
vs.
Tur UNITED STaTes.
1. Petition and Amended Petition.
On April 18, 1904 the claimant filed its original petition,
Subsequently, to wit, on February 18, 1917, the claimant, by
leave of court, tiled its amended petition which is as follows:
Amended Petition.
Petitioner, by leave of court, files this its amended petition, and
suys:
l.
Petitioner is a corporation organized under the laws of the State
of Virginia, At the times of the oecurrences hereinafter stated it
operated a system of railways in the States of Virginia, North Caro-
lina, South Carolina and Georgia, It now owns and operates also
railroads which at thore times belonged to other corporations which
have since been merged into it and to whose rights, in the matters
hereinafter stated, it has therefore succeeded, One of said corpora-
tions was the Florida Central and Peninsular Railroad Company
II,
Upon movements of United States troops and freights appurtenant
thereto in the years 1897, 1898, 1899, 1900, 1901, 1902 and
2 1903, petitioner and those corporations to which it has sue-
ceeded, in some cases by an established general practice of the
railway companies of the country, and in other eases by the terms
of a special contract made by a bid and acceptance thereof by an au-
thorized officer of the United States army, was obligated to transport
free of charge all personal baggage of each man of such troops to the
amount of 150 pounds. In makir.z payment for such movements
however, the accounting officer of che United States deducted a num-
her of pounds of freight equal to 150 times the number of men trans-
ported, and withheld the compensation accruing on those amounts of
freight; ignoring the difference between baggage, the property of the
men, and military equipage, stores and supplies, ouish were the
property of the United States.
Te oT , mint ) ? 5) eS
2 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, UNITED STATES,
|
In many of the cases where such deductions were made the men
had only hand baggage, which they carried in the passenger cars,
and no baggayve whatever was included in those weights of freight for
which part payment was made, In other eases, although full facili-
ties were afforded by claimant or said other railroad companies for
separate loading and transporting of the baggage, such as the men
did not keep with them in the passenger cars, this baggage was
loaded by the officers of the army inte freight cars and was mingled
and confused with the freight and not separately weighed, and the
weight of the same cannot now be ascertained, On transactions of
both of these classes, therefore, petitioner is entitled to be reimbursed
the entire amounts deducted. In those cases where the baggage was
separated from freight and weighed separately petitioner is entitled
to recover the acaounts deducted for freight in excess of the
3 weight of baggage actually trensported but classed by the ac-
counting officers as freight. In no case was the average
weight of baggage transported as bigh as 150 pounds per man,
lV,
In said movements large quantities of camp equipage, ammuni-
tion and other military stores and supplies were transported, To
said shipments there were applicable tariffs and classitieations there-
tofore agreed on between petitioner and other railroad companies
within its territory, including petitioner's said predecessors in title,
and duly recognized by the accounting officers of the United States as
fixing the true rates to be paid by the United States; but in many
cases the accounting officers of the army, while recognizing that
compensation was due with respect to the same, treated the same as
of lower classes of freight than to those in whieh they truly helonged
and allowed to petitioner or its said predecessors in title only the
smaller amounts proper to those lower classes.
¥.
The deduetions thus unlawfully made from claimant's due eom-
pensation aggregate twenty-seven thousand dollars: for whieh sum.
therefore, it prays judgment; no part of the same having been paid,
and its claim to the same not having been assigned.
THE SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY,
By BENJ, CARTER, Its Attorney in Fact.
4 District or COLUMBIA, ss:
Before me, Francis L.. Neubeek, a Notary Publie in and for said
District, appeared Benj, Carter, subscriber of the foregoing petition,
who being by me sworn, makes oath and says that the allegations of
PORREAIE 4 ORRIN GRIM MEET H NOM HE IY RON AM SIE ae |
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. UNITED STATES. 8
suid petition are true to the best of his knowledge, information and
belief, ; ive
BENJ. CARTER,
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 5th day of January,
1917,
| SEAL. ] FRANCIS L. NEUBECK,
Notary Public, D.C,
a Il. General Traverse.
Court of Claims.
No. 24915.
Tue Seanoarp Aik Line Raitpway
vs.
The Unrrep Strares.
No demurrer, plea, answer, counterclaim, set-off, claim of damages,
demand, or defense in the premises, having been entered on the part
of the defendants, a general traverse is entered as provided by Rule
34.
ILI. History of Proceedings.
On February 27, 1917 the argument of the case on merits was
begun by Mr, Benjamin Carter for the claimant, and continued hy
Mr, Assistant Attorney General Huston Thompson for the defend-
ants, and further argued by Mr. Benjamin Carter for the claimant.
On February 28, 1917 Mr. Carter conchided his argument for the
claimant and the case was submitted.
On April 9, 1917 the court filed findings of fact and conclusion of
law dismissing petition, with an opinion by Downey, J,
On June 7, 1917 the claimant filed a motion to set aside the judg-
ment of April 9, 1917.
On October 15, 1917 the claimant was allowed. in open
6 court, to withdraw its motion filed June 7, 1917, and granted
leave to file an amended motion and given to Nov. 1, 1917
to file brief in support thereof,
On October 15, 1917 the claimant filed its amended motion to set
aside judgment.
IV. Order of Court on Claimant's Motion.
Entered Jan, 7, 1918,
_ It is ordered by the court That the claimant's motion for a rehear-
ing be and the same is hereby overruled.
The former findings, judgment and opinion are withdrawn and
Presse —— . one , ; . . ‘ , : oo onsie eran S
4 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8, UNITED STATES,
amended findings are this day filed with conclusion of law dismissing
petition, Opinion by Judge Downey,
By Tuk COURT,
7 V. Findings of Fact, Conclusion of Law, and Opinion of the
Court by Downey, J.
Entered January 7, 1018.
This case having been heard by the Court of Claims the court,
upon the evidence, makes the following
Findings of Fact,
I.
The Seaboard Air Line Railway is a corporation formed, as here-
inafter shown, by the consolidation of a corporation of the same
name with another corporation, the Florida Central & Peninsular
Railroad Co.
The Seaboard Air Line Railway was a corporation originally or-
anized under the laws of the State of Virginia, and by duly author-
zed consolidations or mergers with corporations operating railroads
in those States had become a somvalidated corporation under the
laws of the States of Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina,
Georgia and Alabama, At the times of the occurrences hereinafter
stated it operated a system of railways in the States of Virginia,
North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia.
The petitioner, the Seaboard Air Line Railway, a corporation
formed as hereinbefore stated, now owns and operates railroad lines
in the said States and also the railroad lines that, until the eonsoli-
dation herein’ mentioned, belonged to another corporation, the
Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co,
On the 27th day of June, 1908, a com many, described as “the
Seaboard Air Line Railway, a consolidated corporation, organized
and existing under the laws of the States of Virginia, North Caro-
lina, South Carolina, Georgia, and Alabama,” and the Florida Cen-
tral & Peninsular Railroad Co,, described as “a corporation duly
incorporated and operated under and by virtue of the laws of the
States of Florida and Georgia,” entered into an agreement called
“Articles of agreement of merger and consolidation,” prescribing
“the terms and conditions of said merger and eonsolidation and the
mode of carrying the same into effect.”
8 Article I was as follows:
“The capital stock, franchises, railroads, estates, and prop-
erties, real, personal, and mixed, of the said Florida Central & Pen-
insular Railroad Co, shall be, and they are hereby, united, merged
and consolidated with the Seaboard Air Line Railway, and are to be
hereafter owned and controlled as one railroad company.”
Article IT was as follows:
“The name of said company so formed by the merger and consoli-
Rarer cyersrneen mes Mio A mr ri PO ome eRR ET ene NT PEE MRM IEE My Nir ATID ea TAT
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8, UNITED STATES, ”
dation and union of said railroad companies shall be, and is, the
Seaboard Air Line Railway.”
Article IIT prescribed the number of directors of said consolidated
company, their officers, and the names of those who shall act as di-
rectors and officers until the first annual meeting of the stockholders,
Article IV prescribed where the offices of the company should be
located, and Article V prescribed where and when the annual meeting
should be held and procedure thereat,
Article VI provided that the capital stock of said consolidated
company should be $100,000,000, divided into 1,000,000 shares of
$100 each, divided further into 750,000 shares. to be “presently
issued” and 250,000 shares “issuable hereafter,” the 750,000 shares to
be further divided into 250,000 shares of preferred stock and 500,000
shares of common stock,
Article VII provided for the distribution of profits, and Article
VIII provided “the manner of converting the capital stock of each
of said companies into that of the consolidated company,” in which,
as tc the stock of the Florida Central & Peninsular, it is provided ;
“2. To the holders of preferred stock of Florida Central & Penin-
sular Railroad Co, one share of the preferred stock and one share of
the common stock of the consolidated company for each share of the
preferred stock of said Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co.
“To the holders of the common stock of said Florida Central &
Peninsular Railroad Co, one share of the common stock of the con-
eolidated company for cach share of the common stock of said Ilor-
ida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co,
“But in the exchange of stoek, both common and preferred, of the
Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co. for the common and pre-
ferred stock, respectively, of said Seaboard Air Line Railway, no
exchange is to be made for the stock of said Florida Central & Penin-
sular Railroad Co,, either common or preferred, now held and owned
by said Seaboard Air Line Railway,”
Article IX contained authority for the execution of an indenture
of mortgage and Article X was as follows:
“Upon, from, and after the execution of these articles of merger
and consolidation, and the ratification thereof by the stockholders
of the constituent companies and the filing of the same as required
by law, the rights, privileges, and franchises of each of said constit-
vient companies, and all the property, real, personal, and mixed, and
all debts due on every account, as well as stock subseriptions and
other things in action belonging to each of said companies shall be
transferred to and vested in such consolidated company with-
9 out further act or deed as effectually as they were in the former
companies; and all property, rights of way, and every other
interest shall be as effectually the property of the consolidated com-
pany as they were of the former companies; and all rights of eredit-
ors and all liens on the property of said companies shall be preserved
unimpaired; and all debts, liabilities, and dues of said companies
shall thenceforth attach to the consolidated company and be enforce-
able against it to the same extent as if said debts, liabilities, and dues
ad been incurred by it.”
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8. UNITED STATES,
Article XI directed that “The president or other proper officer of
the said consolidated company shall file a counterpart or copy of these
Articles of Agreement of Merger and Consolidation, duly authenti-
cated, with the proper officers in the States of Virginia, North Caro-
lina, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, and Florida.’ The copy
in evidence is certified by the secretary of state of the State of
Florida as—
“a true copy of articles of agreement and consolidation of Sea-
board Air if Railway and Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad
Co, dated June 27, 1905, forming the Seaboard Air Line Railway,
a corporation created by and existing under the laws of the States
of Virginia, North Carolina, and other States, as therem mentioned,
which agreement was duly filed in this office on the 15th day of
August, 1908,"
The said consolidation was made under authority of the statutes
of the State of Georgia and the statutes of the State of Florida.
The Seaboard Air Line Railway, as created under the terms of
said agreement, is the petitioner in this case, and its petition was
filed April 18, 1904.
At the times hereinafter stated movements of United States treans,
with freight belonging to the United States, and baggage of the
troops, eceurred over the line of railroad then operated by said
Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co., all either being wholly
over or terminating on the lines of said company, and none of said
movements were over the lines of railroad then owned by the plain-
tiff herein.
IIT,
All settlements for movements here involved were made by a dis-
bursing quartermaster of the Army, on presentation of the original
bills of lading, on the basis of Weights shown thereon. In eases
Where it appeared by notation on the bill of lading that an amount
of baggage claimed free was carried in carload lots, such cars did
hot appear in the voucher among the items of charge on account of
the particular bill of lading referred to by number, and no myinent
therefor was made. In other cases deduction was made rom the
total weights of certain classes of freights carried, upon the basis of
150 pounds for each officer and enlisted man shown to have beets
transported. All settlements were made with the Florida Central &
Peninsular Railroad Co., the final carrier, and were for the full sium
stated in the vouchers issued therefor, which sums it accepted
10 und retained and gave upon said vouchers its receipt in full
_ therefor, and made no protest. The several movements are
hereinafter referred to by the item number given to them in claim-
ant’s amended request for findings of fact.
Toh hs Rati a saat eisteeh ladedon ERLE aaa Ae oe alee fans eee. |
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8, UNITED STATES,
lV,
Item 1 is in connection with the transportation of 49 officers and
934 men of the Fifth Maryland Volunteer Infantry from Rossville,
Tenn., to Tampa, Fla., with which there was transported, on bill of
lading No. 3, pad June 2, 1898, issued at Rossville, Tenn., by the
Southern Railway Co., 8 cars of stock and 15 cars of wagons,
harness, tentage, company property, and ammunition of 20,000
pounds each, 3 cars of subsistence stores of a total weight of 29,000
pounds, | car of forage of 13,000 pounds, and 1 car of baggage
of 11,000 pounds, The Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad was
paid for the movement on voucher receipted by its treasurer in
full, for said 8 cars of stock, $636. From the total weights of the
other 20 cars there was deducted 147,450 pounds, and it was paid
for 205,550 pounds at 43 cents per hundred, The receipted voucher
upon which payment was made contained, as to this movement, the
notation, “Deduct 983 men, at 150 each, 147,450,"
Item 2 is in connection with the transportation of 46 offieers and
985 men of the Sixty-ninth New York Volunteer Infantry from
Rossville, Tenn., to Tampa, Mla., with which there was transported,
by bill of lading No, 4, dated June 2, 1898, issued at Rossville, Tenn.,
by the Southern Railway Co., 8 cars of stock and 15 ears loaded with
Army wagons containing harness, tentage, ammunition, and com-
pany property, billed at 20,000 pounds each, | car of subsistence
stores of 16,000 pounds, and 1 car of forage of 10,500 pounds, From
the total weights of these 17 cars there was deducted 154,650 pounds
as the baggage allowance for 1,081 men at 150 pounds each, and the
Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad was paid on its receipted
voucher for 171,850 pounds at 43 cents per hundred, The voucher
contained the notation, “Deduct 1,031 men, at 150 each, 154,650,"
lor the 8 cars of stock it was paid $636,
Item 3 is in connection with the transportation of 54 officers and
997 men of the Second New York Volunteer Infantry from Rossville,
Tenn., to Tampa, Fla., with which there was transported, by bill of
lading No, 2, dated July 1, 1898, issued by the Southern Railway Co,
at Rossville, Tenn., 9 cars of stock, 17 cars of Army wagons loaded
with United States property of 20,000 pounds each, 1b ear containing
7,980 pounds of harness and saddles and 5,950 pounds of forage, 1
car company property (baggage), weight 11,500 pounds, 1 car sub-
sistence stores and tentage, weight 12,000 pounds, | car headquarters
and company property (baggage), weight 20,500 pounds, 1 car eom-
pany property and stoves, weight 18,500 pounds, and 1 car subsist-
ence stores and forage, weight 11,500 pounds, On the bill of lading
was the notation, “Deduet 150 Le per passenger for 1,051 pas-
sengers, being 157,650 pounds, Net weight to be paid for 450,280
pounds,” The Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad was paid by
voucher receipted in full for 9 ears of stock, of 20,000 salle each,
$715.50, and for 270,280 pounds net in the other cars at the rate of
43 cents per hundred,
11 Item 4 is in connection with the transportation of 50 offi-
cers and 953 men of the First District of Columbia Volunteer
8 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8. UNITED STATES.
Infantry from Rossville, Tenn., to Tampa, Fla., with which there
was transported, by bill of lading No, 1, dated June 1, 1808, issued at
Rossville, Tenn., by the Southern Railway Co., 7 cars of stock, 15
cars of wagons loaded with tentage and ammunition of 20,000
pounds cach, 1 car of subsistence stores and bacon of 17,000 pounds,
1 car of subsistence stores and hay of 12,000 pounds, 1 car of grain
and bacon of 14,000 pounds, 1 car baggage and company prop-
erty of 18.000 pounds, 1 car of baggage and ammunition of 13,000
pounds, and 1 car of company property and baggage of 14,500
vounds, On the bill of lading was the notation, “Deduct 150 pounds
wggage per passenger for 1,002 passengers, being 150,500) pounds,
making net amount to be paid for 878,200 pounds.” ~The Florida
Central & Peninsular Railroad was paid, on its receipted voucher, for
said 7 cars of stock $556.50, and on account of the freight moved in
the other ears it was paid for 238,200 pounds at 45 cents per huan-
dred.
Item 16 is in connection with the transportation of 1,185 officers
and men of the First South Carolina Regiment from Rossville,
Tenn., to Jacksonville, Fla., with which there was transported, by
bill of lading No. 002, dated July 29, 1898, issued at Rossville, Tenn.,
by the Southern Railway Co., 6 cars of stock, 12 cars of wagons of
20,000 pounds each, 2 cars of tentage of 24,000 pounds each, 2 cars
of subsistence stores of 20,000) pounds each, 1 ear of forage of
20,000 pounds, and 1 car of baggage and hospital stores of 10,000
pounds, The rates indicated on the bill of lading were: Stock, $60
per car; wagons, $40 per car; tentage, $100.80 per car; subsistence
stores, 98 cents per ewt.; forage, $30 per car; and baggage and
hospital stores, 66 cents per ewt. On the face of said bill of lading
was the following notation: “Less baggage allowance of 150 pounds
for each enlisted man and officer (1,185 officers and men). Net
weight, 300,250 pounds.” The Florida Central & Peninsular Rail-
road was = on a voucher receipted in full, 20,250 pounds at 30
cents ag mindred, 20,000 pounds at 15 cents per hundred, 240,000
pounds at 20 cents per hundred, and for 1 car stock at $60, The
voucher upon whieh payment was made showed the deduction 177,-
790 pounds as free fm Sewics for 1,185 officers and men.
The bills of lading in items 1, 2, 3, and 4 contain the notation,
“Special rates as per letters of Col. J. G. C. Lee, Chief Quarter-
master, Department Gulf, dated Camp Geo. H. Thomas, May 30,
and 31, 1898." The letter of May 30 referred to, and referring to
these four movements, stated :
And the rates agreed upon are as follows:
| BEE RED Rp IMP re a CAR thet Pann each, . $12.58
Camp equipage, harness, ete... 2.2.00... per 100 pounds. . 414
Wagons and ambulances. ............. per LOO pounds... 2984
Penn MINS os 6G ners cate ves haved caver per car... 76.57
In his letter of May 31, Colonel Lee said:
Since writing you yesterday the railroad companies have raised
their rates, and I now beg to insert the following rates as to freieht:
‘ we eo . ’ 4 “ HU NAE Ot en A
Naat eA bdey ak att LAE TSU HN IDLE PRR eG WE Ee ' rt ‘ ed warty
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. UNITED STATES, 9
Cs CN i 05a sas aa oss vs oS per 100 pounds... $0.83 4/10
Wagons and ambulances (set up or knocked down)... . : 43
ETT eee per car... 79.50
The passenger rate is as heretofore advised.
12 The weights herein specified are subject to a reduction of
150 pounds per man, which please deduct from total bill of
lading. The enlisted men are, as a matter of course, entitled to carry
their side arms in their train. Please instruet the shipping quarter-
master accordingly.
With reference to the movement referred to in item No. 16 there is
no evidence in the record as to the rate applicable thereto otherwise
than as stated in the bill of lading.
All of these five movements, originating on the Southern Railway,
were over the lines of the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad as
the final carrier, and payment was made to said final carrier for the
service rendered upon vouchers stating the amount to be paid for
each of said movements, which vouchers were reecipted by the treas-
urer of the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co.. as in full and
without protest. Thereafter the Southern Railway Co. commenced
an action in this court against the United States, No. 249134,
wherein it sought to recover on account of alleged unauthorized de-
ductions of baggage in connection with a large number of move-
ments of troops of the United States, among whieh it included the
five movements above referred to as items 1, 2, 3, 4, and 16, in addi-
tion to which allegation, with reference to unauthorized deductions on
account of baggage, it also alleged in its petition in that case, the ap-
plication of erroneous rates in the payments made on account of the
various items of transportation therein ineluded, among which were
the five items hereinbefore referred to. The said five items of trans-
portation for which recovery was sought in that case was the same
transportation as that sought to be recovered in said five items in
this case, evidenced by said bills of lading ‘above enumerated. On
the 8th day of February, 1909, in said case No. 24913.A, the South-
ern Railway Co., whieh was the initial carrier in all of said. fixe
movements, and issued all of said bills of lading aforesaid, was by
this court awarded judgment in the sum of $23,318.53.
It is shown by thefindinfigs of fact in that case that so much of that
judgment as was predicated on the five movements here involved
was on account of determined excessive deductions of personal bag-
gage.
Item 5.
In connection with the transportation of 50 officers and 1.339 men
of the Fifth Ohio Volunteer Infantry from Tampa, Fla., to Fernan-
dina, Fla., there was transported, on bill of lading No, 158, dated,
July 22, 1898, issued at Tampa, Fla. by the Florida Central &
Peninsular Railroad Co., 7 cars of stock, 2 ears of forage, and 13
cars of wagons and ambulances. On said bill of lading, after the
enumeration of the above cars by car number and weight, there was
the follow) tion: “And 13 cars baggage free allowance of 150
wer
Le
10 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8. UNITED STATES.
vounds each for 50 officers, 1,317 enlisted men, and 29 teamsters.”
nasa was made for 7 ears of stock at $19.50 per car, and for said
2 carloads of forage, of 50,000 pounds, as class D freight, at 8 cents
per hundred pounds, and for said 13 cars of wagons, ete., of 260,000
pounds, as sixth-class freight, at 23 cents per hundred pounds. No
payment was made for the 13 cars of baggage.
Item 6.
In connection with the movement of 42 officers and 1,248 men of
the Sixty-ninth New York Volunteer Infantry from ‘Tampa,
13 Fla., to Fernandina, Fla., there was transported, by bill of
lading No, 174, dated July 24, [S0S, issued at Tampa, Fla.,
by the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co.. 7 cars of horses
and mules, 1 car of forage, 13 cars of loaded wagons, and | car of
ammunition, all of 20,000 pounds each. Following the enumera-
tion of said cars by number on said bill of lading there was the fol-
lowing notation: “And 13 ears baggage free allowance of 150 pounds
each for 42 ofticers, 1,225 enlisted men, and 30 teamsters.”
Item 7.
In connection with the movement of 47 officers and 1.234 men of
the Third Regiment Ohio Volunteer Infantry from Tampa, Fla, to
Fernandina, Fla., there was transported, by the Florida Central &
Peninsular Railroad, on bill of lading No,
road at Tampa, Fla., on the 25th of July, L898, 2 cars of forage, 7
cars of stock, and 13 cars of wagons, all of 20,000 pounds each. On
said bill of lading, in addition to said cars, enumerated thereon hy
number, was the notation: “And 13 ears baggage free allowance 150
pounds per man for 47 officers, 1.213 enlisted men. and 21 team-
sters.””
ISO, issued by said rail-
Item 8.
In connection with the transportation of 46 officers
of the Second New York Volunteer Infantry from Tampa, Fla., to
Fernandina, Fla., there was transported, by the Florida Central &
Peninsular Railroad, by its hill of lading No, 193, issued by it at
Tampa, Fla., under date of July 26, ISOS. 7 ears of stock, 15 cars of
wagons, and 2 cars of forage, all of 20,000 pounds each. — In addition
to said cars enumerated by number on said bill of lading was the
notation: “And 10 cars baggage free allowance for 46 officers, 1,229
enlisted men, and 14 teamsters, 150 pounds each.”
and 1,241 men
Item 9,
In connection with the transportation of 3 officers
the Third Division, Fourth
nandina, Fla., there
Peninsular Railroad, |
Fla., and dated July
and 100 men of
Army Corps, from Tampa. Fla., to Fer-
were transported, by the Florida Central &
rv its bill of lading No. 205, issued at ‘I
‘ampa,
28, 1898, 4 cars of stock, 5 cars of wagon
3, 1 car
PERERA BAT I SS IPR DME SII NII TF EY, a
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. UNITED STATES, 11
of hespital stores, and 1 car of forage. In addition to said cars
enumerated by number on said bill of lading there was given the
number of an additional car with the notation following: “Free
allowance of baggage for 3 officers and 104 enlisted men, 150 pounds
each.”
Item 10.
In connection with the transportation of 47 officers and 933 men
of the First Regiment Ohio Volunteer Infantry from Port Tampa,
Fla., to Fernandina, Fla., there was transported, over the Plant Sys-
tem and the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad, on bill of lading
No, 207, issued at Port Tampa on the 28th of July, 1898, by the
Plant System Railroad, 8 cars of stock, 13 ears of wagons, and
14 1 car of ammunition, of 20,000 pounds each. In addition to
said cars enumerated by number on said bill of lading was the
notation: “And 13 cars baggage free allowance of 150 pounds per
man for 47 officers, 933 enlisted men, and 14 teamsters,”’
Item 11,
In connection with the transportation of 46 officers and 1.260 men
of the One hundred and fifty-seventh Regiment of Indiana Volun-
teer Infantry from Port Tampa, Fla., to Fernandina, Fla, there was
transported by the Plant System Railroad and the Florida Central &
Peninsular Railroad, on bill of lading No. 214, issued at Port Tampa,
July 29, 1898, by the Plant System, 8 cars of stock, 15 cars of wagons,
and 2 cars of forage, all of 20,000 pounds each. In addition to said
cars enumerated by number on said bill of lading was the notation:
“And 10 cars baggage free allowance of 150 pounds per man for 46
officers, 1,246 enlisted men, and 22 teamsters.”’
Item 12.
In connection with the transportation of 31 officers and 759 men of
the Third Regiment Pennsylvania Volunteer Infantry from Port
Tampa, Fla., to Fernandina, Fla., there was transported over the
Plant System and the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad, on bill
of lading No, 221, issued at Port Tampa by the Plant System on July
30, 1898, 8 cars of stock, 12 cars of loaded wagons, 2 cars of forage,
and 1 car of ammunition, all of 20,000 pounds each. In addition to
said cars enumerated by number on said bill of lading there was
noted thereon the following: “And 10 cars baggage free allowance
of 150 pounds per man for 31 officers, 741 enlisted men. and 2
employees,”
With respect to bills of lading 174, 180, 193, 205. 207, 214, and
221, items 6 to 12, inclusive, payment was made on the same basis
and in the same form as shown under item 5 as to bill of lading No.
158, in which case loaded wagons were paid for as sixth-class freight,
As to bills of lading 174, 180, 193. and 205, it was paid for at 23
cents per 100 pounds. As to bills of lading 207, 214, and 221, it was
5 civil
paid for at 25 cents per 100 pounds. One earload on bill of lading
eaeynenaran nt AIR TROT 28
ba ok
12 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8. UNITED STATES.
174 and 1 ecarload on bill of lading 205 were paid for as first-class
freight at 46 cents per LOO pounds. One carload on bill of lading 207
and 2 on bill of lading 221 were paid for as first-class freight at 50
cents per 100 pounds, ALL payments were upon vouchers calling for
the amounts paid and were receipted in full and no protest is shown.
The proper classification of the freights involved in these shipments,
from items 5 te 12, inclusive, is not shown and the proper tariff rate
is not shown, No payment was made for the ears indicated on the
several bills of lading as free allowance of baggage, and no claim
therefor was ever made by the Florida Central & Peninsular Rail-
road Co., or by any other company, before the commencement of this
suit by this plaintiff,
Item 13.
In conneciion with the transportation of S officers and 682 men of
the Third Regiment Cavalry from West Tampa, Fla., to Fer-
15 nandina, Fla. there was transported over the Plant System and
the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad, on bill of lading
No, 234, issued August 1, 1808, at West Tampa by the Plant System,
13 cars of wagons, 50 cars of stock, 5 cars of forage, and 4 cars of regi-
mental and company property, all of 20,000 pounds each. In addi-
tion to said cars enumerated by number, there was upon said bill of
lading the following notation: “And 10 cars baggage free allowance
of 150 pounds per man for 8 officers and 682 enlisted men.” Said
bill of lading called for tariff rates. Settlement was made for 50 cars
of stock, at $19.50 per car; 5 cars of forage, weight 100,000 pounds,
as class D freight, at 8 cents per hundred: 4 cars of regimental and
company property of 80,000 pounds, as class | freight, at 46 cents per
hundred pounds; and 13 cars of wagons of 260,000 pounds, as class 6
freight, at 23 cents per hundred.
Item 14.
In connection with the transportation of 10 officers and 634 men of
the Sixth Regiment United States Cavalry from Tampa, Fla., to
Fernandina, Fla., there was transported, by the Plant System and
the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad. on bill of lading No,
242, issued August 5, 1898, by the Plant System, 46 ears of stock,
© cars of forage of a total weight of 131.935 pounds, and 19 cars of
wagons of 20,000 pounds each, In addition to said cars enumerated
by number on said bill of lading was the notation: “And 14 ears of
haggage free allowance 150 pounds per man or 10 officers, 684 en-
listed men, and 55 civilian employees.” Payment was made to the
Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad for 46 ears of stock, at $19.50
per ear; 5 ears of forage of 131.935 pounds, as Class D freight, at 8
cents per hundred pounds; for 19 cars of wagons of 380,000 pounds,
as class 6 freight, ot 23 cents per hundred pounds. — No pavinent was
made for said 14 cars of baggage and no claim was made therefor,
a eee a ee
o Of
-_
ema — * SS eat = 20 ~*
ae
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY ‘V8. UNITED STATES. 13
ltem 15,
In connection with the transportation of 22 officers and 752 men of
‘Second Regiment of Cavalry from Tampa, Fla., to Fernandina,
1, there was transported, by bill of lading No. 254, issued by the
int System at Tampa, Pla. August 3, 1898, over said Plant Sys-
nand the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad, 34 ears of stock,
cars of wagons of 20,000 pounds each, and 5 cars of forage of a
al weight of 151,016 pounds, In addition to said cars enumerated
number on said bill of lading was the notation: “And 14 cars bag-
ve free allowance of 150 pounds per man for 10 officers, 782 en-
led men, and 35 civilian employees.” For said freight transporta-
n the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co. was paid for 34
sof stock, at $19.50 per car; 15 cars of wagons of 300,000 pounds,
class 6 freight, at 23 cents per hundred pounds; and 5 ears of for-
ep of T51,016 pounds, as class D freight, at 8 cents per hundred
unds, No payment was made for said 14 cars of baggage and no
im was made therefor,
Item 17,
In connection with the transportation of 38 officers and 1,086 men
of the First Florida Regiment of Volunteer Infantry from
Tampa, Fla. to Fernandina, Fla. there was transported by
the Plorida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co., on its bill of
ling No, 150, issued at Tampa on July 21, 1898, 12 cars of loaded
gons of 20,000 pounds each, and 7 cars of stock, In addition to
d cars enumerated by number on said bill of lading was the nota-
ne “13 cars baggage free allowance for 38 officers, 1,062 enlisted
‘ny and 31 teamsters, 150 pounds each.” There was paid the said
prida Central & Peninsular Railroad, for said service, for 12 ears of
gons of 240,000 pounds, as sixth-class fr-ight, at 23 cents per hun-
ad pounds, and for 7 cars of stock at $19.50 per car. No payment
s made for said 13 cars of baggage and no claim was made there-
Item 18,
In connection with the transportation of 9 officers and 220 men,
ruits of the United States Army, from Tampa, Fla.. to Per-
ndina, Fla. there was transported, on bill of lading No. 255
ued August 4, ISYS, by the agent of the Plant System at Tampa,
rarloads of stock, 5 cars of wagons, and 4 carloads of company
yperty, all of 20.000 Ths each. In addition to said ears enumerated
number on said bill, there was the notation “And two cars bag-
ze free allowance for 2 officers, 211 enlisted men. and 9 teamsters,”’
yment was made to the Florida Central and Peninsular Railroad
said freaght transportation for 2 ears of stock at $19.50 per car:
‘ars of wagons of 100,000 pounds, as 6th class freight, at 23 cents
r hundred pounds; and 4 cars of company property of 80,000
unds, as Ist class freight, at 46 cents per hundred pounds. No
D Fee
14 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, UNITED STATES,
payment was made for said 2 cars of baggage and no claim was made
therefor.
Item 1%.
In connection with the transportation of 5 officers and 48 men of
the 15th Company, United States Signal —— from Huntsville,
Ala., to Savannah, Ga., there was transported, over the Southern
Railway and the Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad, by bill of
lading No. 148, issued December 3, 1898, at Huntsville by the South-
ern Railway Co., 3 cars of stock, 2 ears of equipment, of 24,000 Tbs.
each, and 4 cars of wagons, of 20,000 Ibs. each. Said bill of lading,
in addition to said cars enumerated by number thereon, contained
the notation “One baggage ear free for baggage for 5 officers and 48
men,” and the further notation “Agreed rate between Secretary of
War and Southeastern Railway Association.” The Florida Central
& Peninsular Railroad Company was paid for said) transportation,
for 83 cars of stock, at $100 per car; 2 cars of equipment, of 45,000
pounds, as Sth elass freight, at 45 cents per hundred pounds; and for
4 cars of wagons of 80,000 pounds, as 6th class freight, at 35 cents per
hundred pounds. No payment was made for said car of baggage
and no claim was made therefor.
Item 20,
In connection with the transportation of 11 officers and 0 men of
the First Brigade, First Division, First Army Corps, from Knoxville,
Tenn., to Savannah, Ga., there was transported, over the
7 Southern Railway and the Florida Central & Peninsular Rail-
road, by bill of lading No, 28, issued November 28, SOS, at
Knoxville by the Southern Railway, 2 ears of commissary, forage,
and Army equipment of 24,000 Tbs, each: 7 cars of wagons and ambu-
lances of 20,000 Ths. each: and 4 ears of stock. Said bill of lading,
following the notation thereon of two cars of commissary, forage, and
Army equipment, had upon its face the notation “Less 150) pounds
baggage allowed for 101 men.” Payment was made for 1 car of 24.-
000 pounds, as class D freight, at 17 cents per hundred pounds; 1 car
of 24,000 pounds, less 15,150 pounds baggage deduetion, net S850
pounds, as oth class freight, at 45 cents per hundred pounds; 7 ears
of wagons of 140,000 pounds, as 6th class freight, at 35 cents per
hundred pounds; and 4 cars of stock, at $87.00 per car. Upon the
voucher upon which pagoweys for this transportation was made, and
which was receipted by the treasurer of the Florida Central & Pen-
insular Railroad Co., is the notation “Allow 150 pounds each for 101
men, 15,150 free.”
Item 21.
In connection with the transportation of 46 officers and 1,250 men
of the 4th Tennessee Regiment Volunteer Infantry from Knoxville,
Tenn., to Savannah, Ga., there was transported over the Southern
Railway and the Florida Central and Peninsular Railroad, by bill
SOARS ERNNORBAR V MSWIETRR TAS IMATE SPL Te NOR IT RATS atone Patan tc te AIM RTI
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. UNITED STATES, 15
of lading No, 29, issued November 28, 1898, at Knoxville by the
Southern Railway, EL cars of wagons and ambulances of 20,000 Tbs.
each; 7 cars of stock, and 14 cars of equipage, commissary, ete., of
24,000 Ibs, each. Following the notation on said bill of lading of
said 14 cars of equipage, ete., is the notation “Less allowance of 150
equipage, ete., 336,000 pounds less 194,400 pounds, net 141,600
pounds baygaye free each, 1,206 men, 46 officers, 1,230 enlisted men,’
20 civilians, 14400." For said movement there was paid to the
Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co,, upon a voucher duly
receipted in full by it, for 11 cars of wagons of 220,000 sounds
weight, as class 6 freight, at 35 cents per hundred pounds $770; for
14 ears, equipage, ete, 336,000 agony less 194,400 pounds, net 131,-
600 pounds, as fifth-class freight, at 45 cents per hundred pounds,
$637.20; for 7 ears of stock, 168,000 pounds, at $87 per ear, $609;
for car rental on a PL TL. car No, 2180, $16.14. Notation on settle-
ment: “Allow 150 pounds each for 1.206 men, 194,400 free,”
Item 22.
In connection with the transportation of 1,221 officers and men
of the First Ohio Volunteer Infantry from Fernandina, Fla., to
Jacksonville, Fla. there was transported by the Florida Central &
Peninsular Railroad, on its bill of lading No, 22, issued August 27,
SUS, at Fernandina, & cars of stock, 15 ears of wagons, of 20,000
pounds cach, and S cars of company and regimental property, of
24,000 pounds each, Tn addition thereto there was upon the bill of
lading the following notation: “12 cars baggage free for 1,221 men
and officers.” Said bill of lading called for tariff rates, Settlement
for said transportation was made with the Florida Central & Penin-
cular Railroad upon a voucher paid by a disbursing quarter-
IS master of the United States Army, for 8 cars of stock, of 160,-
OOO pounds, at FL per car, less land-grant deduction, $126.67 ;
for 15 cars of wagons, 300,000 pounds, at 13 cents per hundred
pounds, less land-grant reduction, $825; and of §& cars of company
property, 192,000 pounds, at 25 conts per hundred pounds, less oat
grant deduction, $400, A receipt of the treasurer of the Florida
Central & Peninsular Railroad Co. to the voucher for this service is
“in full of the above account and in full of all demands for the serv-
ice stated therein,” and is for the sum of $1,422.36. Why the re-
ceipt is for a larger amount than shown by the settlement to have
heen paid is not shown.
Item 23.
In connection with the transportation of 45 officers and 777 men
of the Thirty-first Michigan Volunteer Regiment from Knoxville,
Tenn., to Savannah, Ga., there was transported over the Southern
Railway, M. & A., Southern Railway, and Florida Central and Pen-
insular Railroad, by bill of lading No, 28, issued January 9, 1899, at
Knoxville, by the Southern Railway Co., 12 cars of equipage and
stores of 24,000 pounds each, 16 cars of wagons and ambulances of
20,000 pounds each, and 7 cars of stock. Following the entry upon
a a ynwoe rs renee moth pan
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8, UNITED STATES,
said bill of said 12 ears of equipage and stores of 24,000 pounds each
is the notation: “Less allowance of 150 pounds baggage for each offi-
cer, soldier, and civilian, total, 1,095, 164,250." Payment for said
transportation was made to the Florida Central & Peninsula- Railroad
Co, for 288,000 pounds, less 164,250 pounds, net 123,750 pounds, as
fifth-class freight, at 45 cents per hundred pounds, $556.87; for 16
cars wagons, 320,000 pounds, as sixth-class freight, at 35 cents per
hundred pounds, $1,120; for 7 cars of stoek, 168,000 pounds, at $87
per car, S500; and for car rental on Keystone car No. 335, $16.
Item 24.
In connection with the transportation of 46. officers and men of
the Seventeenth Company, Signal Corps, from Huntsville, Ala., to
Savannah, Ga., there was transported by the Scuthern Railway and
Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad, on bill of lading No, 289,
issued January 11, ES, at Huntsville by the Southern Railway Co.,
3 cars of stock, 5 cars of wagons of 20,000 pounds each, and 2 ears
of company property of 24,000 pounds each, On said bill of lading
was the notation: “Car S. R. No. $46, baggage free for allowance
of baggage for 46 officers and men, Changing station.” Said bill
of lading provided that the rate should be the agreed rate between
the Secretary of War and the Southeastern Railway Association.
The Florida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co. was paid for said
transportation for 3 cars of stoek at FLO0 per ears 5 cars of wagons,
100,000 pounds, as class 6 freight, at 35 ccnts per hundred pounds ;
and for 48,000 pounds of class 1 freight, at 72 cents per hundred
pounds. No payment was made for said car of baggaye and no claim
Was made therefor,
Item 35.
In connection with the transportation of 3 officers and 174 enlisted
men of Light Battery A, Second Artillery, from Huntsville, Ala., to
Savannah, Ga., there was transported over the Southern Rail-
19 way to Everett, Ga., and over the S., F, & W. to Savannah,
Ga., on bill of lading No, 308, issued January 17, 1809, at
Huntsville by the Southern Railway Co., 7 cars of stock, 2 cars of
company property of 24,000 pounds each, | car of forage of 20,000
pounds, | car of tents of 24,000 pounds, 3 ears of tent floors of 24,-
000 pounds each, 3 cars of cannons of 24,000 pounds each, 4 cars of
wagons of 20.000 pounds each, and | car of baggage of 20,000
pounds, In addition to the enumeration of said cars by number on
said bill of lading, there is the notation: “Deduct baggage allowance
for 3 officers and 174 men at 150 pounds each.” Said bill of lading
provides for the rate agreed upon between the Secretary of War and
Southeastern Railway Association. The Florida Central & Penin-
sular Railroad Co. was paid for said transportation for 68,000
pounds, “less allowance for 177 men, at 150 pounds each, 26,550,”
41,450 pounds as first-class freight, at 72 cents per hundred, $298.44;
for 24,000 pounds as fifth-class freight, at 45 cents per hundred
pounds, $108; for 72,000 pounds as fourth-class freight, at 55 cents
ROSE TERRI GT SPOT, RIMMED BE IES A OME ES ST RL ELAN EMIS OR AAG, LIE LOLA SENT RESIS ASIN LI
SEABOARD AIR LINE KAILWAY V8, UNITED STATES, 17
er hundred pounds, $396; for 152,000 pounds as sixth-class freight
if 5 cents per hundred pounds, $532; for 140,000 pounds, being 7
vars of stock, at $100 per car, $700; or 20,000 pounds class D freight,
it 17 cents per hundred pounds, $34; and for rental on car No. 713,
B5.45.
V.
Rach bill of lading issued in connection with the movements in-
volved herein was prepared by one of the defendant's quarter-
masters, enumerated the ears involved in the shipment and their con-
ents, and was signed by the agent of the initial carrier, at the point
f origin of the shipment, and was receipted by the defendant's quar-
ertmaster at the point of destination,
Vi.
The bills of lading in the movements referred to as items 5, 6, 7, 8,
110, 11, 12, 18, 14, 15, 17, 18, 20, 21, 22, and 28 called for “tariff
rates.” In items 19, 24, and 25 they ealled for an “agreed rate be-
ween the Secretary of War and Southeastern Railway Association.”
The proper classification of the freights involved in these move-
ments, if otherwise than as used as the basis of the settlement, is not
chown, and proper tariff rates therefore are not shown. The rates
referred to in the Dills of lading in items 19, 24, and 25 as agreed
rates are not shown, The contents of the ears moved with the vari-
vus bodies of troops, for which no payment or claim for payment was
nade, are not shown, otherwise than as described in the bills of lad-
ing as “baggage,” their content weights are not shown, and tariff
wv other applicable rites thereon are not shown.
Vil.
In a resolution adopted at the meeting of the Southeastern Pas-
venger Association, November 15, 1848, referring to the adjustment
of rates with the War Department at the meeting held No-
20) vember 2, net cash rates for passenger movements are agreed
upon as a basis for bids when requested by the Government,
and it ix provided that—
Hach passenger to be allowed 150 pounds of baggage free of charge.
All excess baggage moved with troops on same train or section
thereof to be charged for at the rate of 12 per cent per hundredweight
of the through passage fare for these movements. The term “bag-
gage’ as herein used being understood to mean personal baggage,
lentage, camp equipage, aceoutrements, and rations needed for im-
mediate use of troops, it being understood that rates for live stock,
rannon, heavy ordinance, ambulances, and wagons (set up or knocked
down) shall be obtained from the freight departments and that all
property connected with the movements of troops shall be loaded
and unloaded without expense to the carriers,
Leemntaeds
SEABOARD AIR LINE RALLWAY V8. UNITED STATES,
Conelusion of Law.
Upon the facts found the court concludes as matter of law that
the plartifl is not entitled to recover and that its petition ought to be
and it is distiissed,
Opinion,
Dowsry, Judge, delivered the opinion of the court,
The plainntt sues in this case for alleged underpayment« on cer
tain shipments of freights for the United States in the years DSUs
and ISH, The freight movenent. in question were over the South:
erp Railway and the Florida Central & Poninsular Railroad, some of
therm originating on the former rowd and terminating on the latter,
ad some entirely over the lines of the latter road Tn all eases the
Mlorida Central & Peninsular Railroad Co, was either the sole or the
final carrier, In no ease was the plomtill herein the carrier, Sueh
payments us were made, forall the shipmoute herein invelved, were
nade to the Florida Central & Poenoneuher Raileowd Co. on vouchers
stating the amount due on aecount of each shipment and on whieh
there was poid the full anount thereon shown to be due and whieh
were receipted, in full, by the proper offieer of the Florida Central &
Peninstilar Railroad Coo The elatin ts on aecount of the deduction,
from the various shipments, of cortuin cars or weights, which were
indicated as baggage allowance for the troops of the United States,
In connection With the transportation of which said) freight move
ents ovcurred, of the basis of 150 pounds for each tien transported,
and alse because of alleged misapplication of classifications and rates
in the settlements nade, The bills of lading. in each instanee, were
prepared by the defendant's quartermaster at the point of origin of
the shipment, enumerated the care and the contents thereof involved
in the im ponenr wud were signed, in-eaeh tostunee, by the awent of
the initial carrier, At the point of destination they were recepited
by the proper quartermaster of the defendant,
The first question whieh is presented in this case is upon the right
of the plaintiil to maintain the aetion, ‘The ground fer the objection
assigned is that the plaintiff snes to recover an alleged balanee of a
claim whieh if itever had a legal status belonged to the Florida Cen-
tral & Peninsular Railroud Co,
The undispaited facets are that the Florida corporation, so called
herein for brevity’s sake, engaged ino the movements of troops ane
property of the United States during the period of their movements
during and at the end of the Spanish Amerioan War. That
21 company Woe a railrowd corporation under the laws of Georgia
and Florida, dts lines of road extended from Savannah on
the north to points in Florida,
The Senhora Air Line Railway Wile i railroad corporation orivi-
nally chartered in Virginia, burt hy duly authorized consolidations
or mergers with roads in other States lad beeome a consolidated cor.
poration under the liws of Virginia, North and South Carolina,
SL EE AaL com Mart dll oodles ae . oi e Eee Tie eeritg oO RE BEMIS
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8. UNITED STATES, 19
Georgia, and Alabama. In 1908 the Seaboard company, so “alled
for brevity, as consolidated as last above stated, and the suid Florida
corporation, both acting by and through their respective officers and
by concurrence of their stockholders, entered into an agreement look-
ing to their consolidation into a corporation under the name of the
Seaboard Air Line Railway. and the agreement was carried into
effect. The law of Georgia (see, 2173, Code of Georgia, 1895) ane
thorizes a railroad company which has constructed a railroad in said
State or any other State to make contract with any other railroad
company “that will enable said company to ran their roads in con.
nection with each other and to merge their stocks or to consolidate
with any such company within or without this State, or to lease or
purchase the property of any other such company, and hold, use, and
accupy the same in such manner as they may deem most benefietal to
their interest,”
Section 2812 of the general statutes of the State of Florida eon-
tains a similar provision to that above quoted from the code of
Cieorgia,
The agreement between said two companies provides and declares
that “the eapital stock, franchises, railroads, estates, and properties,
real, personal, and mixed, of the Florida Central & Peninsular Rail-
row Co, shall be, and they are hereby, united. merged, and consoli-
dated with the Seaboard Air Line Railway and are hereafter to be
owned and eontrolled by one railroad company’s that the eonsoli-
dated corporation shall lave preferred and common stock > that the
holders of the preferred stock in the Florida eorporation should. re-
ceive one share of the preferred stock and one share of the conmion
stock of the consolidated company for cach share of preferred stock
in the Florida corporation held by them and one share of the com.
tion stock of the consolidated company for cach share of commen
stock held by them in the Florida eorporation, and that the stock.
holders in the Seaboard company should receive share for share,
whether of preferred or common stock, held in the Seabowrd come
July,
Provision is made for the issue hy the consolidated company of its
own capital stock in amount exceeding that necessary to take up the
shares of stock issued and outstanding by said two companies, and
leo for the issue by the consolidated company of bonds to the
amount of F100,000,000, to be secured by a mortaage or deed of trust
upon the propertios of the consolidated company,
It ix aleo provided in the agreement that upon the ratification of
the same by the stockholders of the constituent companies the rights,
privileges, and franehises of cach of the constituent companies and
all the property, real. personal, and mixel, and all debts due on
every account as well as stock sabseriptions and other things in
action belonging to cach of said companies, shall be transferred to
and vested in the consolidated company without further act. or
deed,
While the agreement speaks of a merger and consolidation,
the name by whieh the transaction is called is not determina.
tive, The power given by statute was to merge or to consolidate or
the purchase of one road by the other, The effeet of what was ac-
——— . oe
Paris) aver
22
20 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8, UNITED STATES.
complished by the agreement and the manifest intention of the
parties to the agreement was the creation of a corporation—a legal
entity distinet from either of the corporations entering into the agree-
ment, The contract between them speaks of the two “former” com-
puinies and of the new or consolidated corporation,
We have no doult that a new corporation was formed, to whieh
was transferred and assigned the franchises, rights, and properties
of each of the former companies,
Yazoo & Mississippi Ry. Co, v. Adams, [80 02S. 1, 18; Railroad
Co. v. Georgia, 98 US. 859,
In legal effect the transaction is not different from a purchase by
the new corporation of the railroads and properties of the two
former companies, so far as the right to collect the debts or claims
of either of the former companies is concerned, Nor would there
he any difficulty in the new company suing for the recovery of debts
due the former companies in the absence of a statute such as seetion
S477 of the Revised Statutes, That statute forbids assignments of
claims against the United States,
Seetion SAT7 of the Revised Statutes las been construed often by
this court and by the Supreme Court, One of the latest expressions
of the Supreme Court on that question is found in’ National Bank of
Conmmeree v. Downie, 218 US. 345, 5595. That ease reviews a num
her of former decisions, Quoting from Spolford v. Kirk, 47 UL 8.,
184, 488, it approves the following language in that case referring
to section SAT7T: “Tt would seem to he tnpossible to use language
more comprehensive than this, Tt embraces alike legal and equitable
asigntents. Tt ineludes powers of attorney, orders, or other authori.
ties for receiving payment of any such claims, or any part or share
thereof, Tt strikes at every derivative interest, in) whatever form
acquired, and ineapacitates every claimant upen the Government
from creating an interest in the claim of any other than himself.”
In Spotford vy. Kirk an attempt was nude by one of the parties to
make a distinetion between the validity of an assignment as between
the parties and the validity of an assignment so far as the United
States were concerned. The eourt said (mp. 490): "We ean not sav,
when the statute declares all transfers and assignments of the whole
of a claim, or any part or interest therein, and all orders, powers of
attorney, or other authority for receiving payment of the claim, or
ony part thereof, shall be absolutely null and void, that they are only
partially mull and void: that they are valid and effective as between
the parties thereto and only invalid when set up against the Govern-
ment,
In St. Paul & Duluth RoR, Co, v. United States, 112 UL 8. 782,
736, it ery tee that a voluntary transfer by mortgage for the secur
ity of adebt had been made and that there had been a foreclosure of
the mortgage consummated by judicial sale, and it was held that the
transfer was within the prohibition of section S477 of the Revised
Statutes, In the opinion by Mr. Justice Matthews it was said: “If
the statute does not apply to such cases, it would be difficult to
25 draw a line of exclusion which leaves any place for the opera-
tion of the prohibition.”
It ix true that in construing this statute the Supreme Court has
AeA en Ladies Ae aaa : retin, pT
SEABOARD AIR LINE KAILWAY V8, UNITED STATES, 21
held that a transfer by operation of law does not come within the
inhibition of that statute. Erwin v. United States, 97 U. S., 382,
37,
In Goodman v. Niblaek, 102 UL S., 556, it was held that « velun-
tary assignment for the benefit of his ereditors made by an jaselvent
debtor of all his effects is not different from an assignment in bank-
ruptey and is not within the inhibition of the statute.
In Bailey et al. v. United States, LOO UL S., 452, it appeared that a
ower of attorney had been given by the plaintiff and payment had
oan made to the person holding the duly executed power of attorney.
The plaintiff pen the United States and sought a recovery upon the
ground that the payment to the person holding his power of attorney
was unauthorized because the power of attorney was itself void under
the influence of section 3477. Tt was held that the plaintiff eould not
recover, and was said (p. 440): “But if the protection of claimants
was at all in the mind of Congress when passing the acts of 1846
and 1853, it is quite certain that the courts should not, to the injury
of the Government, extend that protection to those that elected not
to avail themselves of the provisions of those statutes.” The yee
tiff having given a power of attorney, and it being unrevoked, and
payment having been made thereunder by the Government, the
court would not allow the plaintiff to question the propriety of the
puvinent,
n Price vy, Forrest, 173 U.8., 410, it was held that an order made
by a judicial tribunal having jurisdiction of the parties appointing
a receiver of a claim against the Government and ordering the elaim-
wnt to assign the same to such receiver, to be held subjeet to the order
of the court for the benetit of those entitled thereto, can not be re-
gurded as prohibited by section S477, The court in that case reeog-
nized the rule announced in United States v. Gillis, 05 UL S.. 407:
Erwin v. United States, supra; Goodman vo Niblaek, supra, and St,
Paul & Duluth R. RCo. v. United States, supra,
Manifestly the transfer of the properties and assets of the Florida
railroad to the new corporation was not a transfer by operation of
law, The agreement between the two corporations under whieh a
third and distinet organization and corporation arose was entirely
Voluntary on the art of each of them. The termes and conditions
upon which the Florida corporation made the transfer of its assets
are fully set forth in the agreement between the two companies, and
it was only because of said agreement that any transfer was or could
he made,
The facts show that the claims now sought to be enforeed by the
Seaboard Air Line company were claims which are alleged to have
aceruied to the Florida corporation in the years [898 and 1899, Part
of a claim how asserted was for transportation which originated on
the Southern Railway, ane it appears that that company brought suit
and recovered judgment. The items which are involved in this suit
concerning the Southern Railway Co.'s transportation were within
the purview of the suit brought by the Southern Railway Co.. but
Were not included in its said suit. is claimed that the Florida com.
puny cun now maintain the suit for those items beenuse if wats
—
BERBERS
22 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY Vs, UNITED STATES,
24 the terminal carrier with whom settlement should have been
made, As to all of the items of claim, settlements were made
with the Florida company during said years or shortly thereafter.
Those settlements are sought to be impeached upon the ground that
payments made by the Government on account of transportation. of
troops and property were incorreet in that the Government officials
made deductions on account of baggage when, as it is alleged, the
amount of baggage for which deduetions should have been made was
greatly below the weights upon which settlements were made, In
other words, that the Government was not paying the Florida com-
pany for property transported and which should have been paid for,
and on the contrary has treated as baggage large shipments which
were not properly baggage. The Florida company reecived the
vouchers issued in pursuance of the settlements made by the ac:
counting officers, Tt does not appear that the Florida company made
any objection to the settlements, and certainly the Florida company
never brought any action in this or any other court to correct. the
alleged errors, The consolidated company, which is the plaintiff
in this suit, was not organized until June, 1905, some four years
after the alleged errors had been made against the Florida company.
This action was brought in this court in April, 1904, and it seeks
to recover on account of the alleged errors in. settlements made by
the accounting officers with the Florida company.
If under the circumstances stated the status of the Seaboard com-
pany in this ease is not that of an assignee of a claim, it is difficult
to define its status. That assignment was not by operation of law
but was the case of a voluntary transfer of claims against the United
States before their allowance in’ direct: opposition to the statute,
One of the mischiefs sought to be prevented by said statute finds
illustration in the ease at bar, because it appears that the Florida
company brought no action, although more than ample time therefor
had elapsed, and that a new corporation which acquired its assets
is seeking to enforce claims the settlement of which, so far as the ree-
ord shows, were acquiesced in by the Florida company. One of the
mnischiefs which the act was intended to remedy was, as stated in
Goodman v. Niblaek, 102 UL S., 556, 560, "That. by a transfer of
such a claim against the Goverment to one or more persons not
originally interested in it, the way might be conveniently opened to
such improper influences in presenting the claim: before the depart-
ments, the courts, or the Congress, as desperate cases, when the re-
ward is contingent on success, so often suggests.” Certainly where
a claim is transferred by mortgage, which is subsequently foreclosed,
the purchaser does not acquire a right to maintain an action against
the United States by virtue of that assignment. St. Paul & Duluth
RR. Co. supra. That being true, how ean we say that a voluntary
transfer by a corporation of all its assets to another corporation is
not an assignment within said section? “We can not say, when the
statute declares all transfers and assignments of the whole of a claim.
or any part or interest therein, * * * shall be absolutely mull
and void, that they are only partially null and void.” Spofford vy,
Kirk, 97 ULS., 484, 490.
4
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. UNITED STATES, 23
The plaintiff insists that in order to question its right to maintain
the action the defendants should have pleaded in abatement,
) and that having failed to so plead or to file any plea the de-
fendants should not now be heard to say that there was an as-
miment of the claim. The rules of the court preseribe that in the
ent the defendants do not plead within 60 days after suit is brought
d notice thereof a general traverse of the petition shall be treated as
ed and the case proceed.
The plaintiff relies upon the familiar rule that at common law a
ea in bar is a waiver of matter which should be pleaded in abate-
ent,
There are several reasons why the rule invoked by plaintiff should
t be applied here, The Court of Claims is not bound by special
le of pleading. District of Columbia y. Barnes, 197 UL S8., 146,
4.
This court, in Labadie’s case, 31 C. Cls., 436, considered the ques-
m whether a special plea could be filed after the lapse of the 60 days
lowed by the statute for the defendants to plead, answer, or demur,
less the time were extended by order of the court, and hold that it
is a matter of discretion with the court to allow a plea to be subse-
ently filed,
But if it were conceded that there is an order of pleading in this
urt the principle urged by plaintiff would not be applicable, beeause
e matter of assigninent could be pleaded in bar as well as in abate-
ent, Seetion 159 of the judicial code preseribes what a petition
all contain and require the averment that no assignment or trans-
r Of the claim has been made. Section 3477 of the Revised Statutes
rbids the assignment of a claim against the United States. The
tition in this ease docs not in terms negative an ussigninent of
msfer of the claim, but in general terms avers a merger of the
© corporations and the succession by plaintiff to the rights of the
orida corporation, We have no doubt that the general traverse
whes the question of an assignment. In view of the positive terms
the statute, it would be the duiy of the court to take notiee of the
et of an assignment or transfer of the claim sued upon, whether
ought to its attention by the defendants or not.
The language of the court in National Bank of Commerce v.
mnie, 218 UL S., 345, 356, is apposite: “The present cases are not
‘ignments which by operation of law created an interest in the
‘ignor’s claims against the United States, They are clean-cut cases
a voluntary transfer of claims against the United States before
cir allowance, in direet opposition to the statute. If any regard
itever is to be had to the intention of Congress, as manifested by
words—too clear, we think, to need construction—we must hold
cha transfer to be absolutely null and void, and not in itself puss-
¥ to the appellants any interest, present or remote, legal or equi-
dle, in the claims transferred,”
The conclusions reached upon the question discussed nece
termines the right of this plaintiff to maintain. this
quires an adverse judgment,
In our former opinion in this case while announcing the
sssarily
action and
views
PRM ioc
24 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V5, UNITED STATES,
above suggested as to the right of the plaintiff to maintain the action
we went further and discussed the ease as presented by the findings
of fact. We called attention to the fact that a stipulation which had
been made in a number of cases similar to the one at bar (exeept the
question of assigninent), and upon which the other cases had
26 been tried, had been withdrawn by the Assistant Attorney
General in this case, who declined to be bound by it. We
recognized the rule stated by Judge Howry in the case of Jones &
Laughlin v. United States, 43 C. Cls., 178, but we also called atten-
tion to the fact that the plaintiff had not asked a continuance of the
case when the stipulation was withdrawn, That the withdrawal of
the stipulation upon which, up to that time, the plaintiff had relied
might be a ground of surprise, which would authorize a continuance
in order to enable the parties to supply by proof what they thought
was proved by the stipulation, we have no doubt, Plaintiff now by a
motion for a rehearing asks leave of the court to supply the requisite
proof. Some proof has been taken in other cases of a similar kind to
this, but that proof was not brought into this case norwas itconsidered
by the court in the original hearing. Some affidavits are filed with
plaintiff's motion for a rehearing, some of which are to the effect that
the settlements which were made and which the plaintiff seeks to
question, were made by the accounting officers taking the bills of lad-
ing with the notations thereon and treating them as accurate expo-
nents of the facts instead of taking the bills presented by the railroad
companies themselves. Though the suit was brought in April, 1904,
and was not presented to this court for decision until Mareh, 1917,
nearly 13 years, we might afford the plaintiff an opportunity of tak-
ing additional proof because largely of the surprise to whieh it was
probably put by the withdrawal of said stipulation which affected
some but not all of the questions involved in the case. But we are
met by the fact that in our opinion plaintiff can not maintain the
action because of section 3477 above discussed. And section 165 of
the Judicial Code provides: “When it appears to the court in any case
that the facets set forth in the petition of the claimant do not furnish
any ground for relief, it shall not authorize the taking of any. testi-
mony therein.” Tlolding to the view we do upon the right of the
plaintiff to maintain the action we do not feel justified in putting the
parties to the expense of taking additional testimony which ean not
affect the result.
The findings of fact show the case as it was presented on the former
hearing, and our former opinion in the case will be withdrawn and
this opinion substituted therefor.
For the reasons stated the motion for a rehearing will be overruled.
And it is so ordered.
Hay, Judge; Barney, Judge: Booth, Judge, and Campbell, Chief
Justice, concur.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. UNITED &TATES, 25
27 Vi, Judgment of the Court.
At a Court of Claims held in the City of Washington on the
Seventh day of January, A. D., 1918, judgment was ordered to be en-
tered as follows:
The Court, upon due consideration of the premises find in favor
of the defendants, and do order, adjudge, and decree that the Sea-
hoard Air Line Railway, as aforesaid, shall not have and recover
any sum in this action of and from the defendents, the United
States; and, that claimant’s petition be and it hereby is dismissed.
By Tue COURT.
28 VIL. History of Proceedings After Entry of Judgment.
On March 7, 1918 the claimant filed a motion in relation to find-
ings of fact.
On the same day claimant filed a motion to extend the time for
moving amendments of findings of fact to and including April 10,
1918,
On March 11, 1918 both of these motions were overruled by the
court,
On March 13, 1918 claimant was granted, in open court, leave to
tile motion to amend findings.
On May 9, 1918 the claimant filed a renewed moton in relation to
findings of fact. This motion was overruled by the court on May 27,
1918,
VIII. Note of Claimant's Application for Appeal with Metion for
Restriction of Transcript,
On August 15, 1918 the claimant filed an application for appeal
to the Supreme Court. Incorporated in said application for appeal
was a motion to omit from the record on appeal paragraphs I to VII,
inclusive, of the findings of fact. On October 21, 1918 the court or-
dered that the appeal be allowed. .
29 Court of Claims.
No. 24915.
THE SEABOARD Ark Line Rattpway
Vs.
Tur Unrrep Srares.
I, Saml. A. Putman, Chief Clerk Court of Claims. certify that the
foregoing are true transcripts of the pleadings in the above-entitled
cause; of the findings of fact and conclusion of law and opinion of
3—248
PPR ETAL IE Sry Fe
>
26 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8. UNITED STATES.
the court by Downey, J.: of the judgment of the court; and of the
note of, and allowance of, an appeal to the Supreme Court of the
United States.
fe oe
ore
In testimony whereof T have hereunto set my hand and aftixed the
seal of said Court at Washington City this oth day of November,
A. D., 1918. °
[ Seal Court of Claims. |
SPL rag "
Pa
2p RI DEIR S58
SAML. A. PUTMAN,
Chief Clerk Court of Claims.
endorsed on cover: File No. 26.834. Court of Claims. Term No,
248. The Seaboard Air Line Railway, appellant, vs. The United
States. Filed November 25th, 1918.) File No. 26,834.
OAR 5
RR
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.