Transcript of Record — New York v. New Jersey

Supreme Court brief1921

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Comtaapria iesetet = ba bebbeit

No, 3, Original

ANTS

v2

tenA MP TN

INDEX

Mewarapier « repent ef a putt henring

ghem be the New York arte Iie

Theeerd. Deewenber & Tim

ltieqerrt of New Vork Bay ollation (ve

mieeion te Then. Prank Wayland Wie

gies. tervrotnet, March 31, 4

itt map of New York farixe wl

vietwity

eget of New York May Pollation (om

mieten te Hen. Frank Wayland Hig

gins, teerwetner. Aprll a Tie

May eee

May

Map

May

Jew & Trerweee (iec.), Parowrens, Waentweres, 1. C.

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,

OCTOBER TERM, 1916

THE PROCLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK. COMPLAIN

STATE OF NEW JERSEY ANT) PASSAIC VALLEY SEWER

Vr COMMIs=lo NERS. DEFENDANTS

lage

iSereN.

t-pdetnat< Eabhiide TF Mey

* War

o Map

we Map

1) Map peeeceeceseorerenrest

ts dente eetoting to ant quire New 1 te

7G. from New York Bey wed wieteity.

> ttegrem ef bering deview for <ompdling

freed deqerit« der pe

4 ust chert Ye toe

15 OC Weert~ tei beet bem py angte

token at coh “ation dering He... |.

I= Segre «of New Verk May and vietwity

larwer Ving. Wewterty wrdiem.............

larwer Diny. comtral wetiem....

lerwer Vay eaxtetl «<9then

Narre <ertrem peoneoeeessecooeees

i vam Bwll wwtiew.. 2... oo oe cecce eee

Hatters <«tiew .

ee |

Virewhl) Vrbedge te Nterheette ietand.

tost iver eortien.....

Wards tohwedl wertiem. 2. 2. cece ccc cece ces

Harem Hiver, exeterly sectiow...........

Mariem iver, westerly section... .. oeeee

Hates Hivet ctien, Batiety te Sith

GD coe+co+cocevoceeecoceocencoorcoes

Dh eet on ‘Giver avtien, th te lieth

GE co ccceseecoceeocseeroeceeorsces

Hedewm Kinvet ortien 10h treet to

GG FETE ecoccocsececoeneosseces

Hades Kiver «ethen, New York te Tar

GEEEED ere rcccovccesencsseccecocessoes

S—terte ewiating to enter empties, Nan. to

ee ae oor ee

pene ce yous

Bat fie

i

(ompteternts Eabiitt« © ant & Ifegreme of surface current

( uepeletteetet< BF wbeibeit ot Sted eget om Clet axttene te Gee tue.

thew of New York, teewenter 1% 1991. ae

(wrrent eheervatien: weer Kottde~ Mer,

1) —1ewta, «tetemment« of bertertal tewt« ae _.

“tte <etement« of dieotved expen

Geute. Ge. ....+.

w Imta, to ve Geyudite Gram taster tethan.

ye

VOLUME IV.

Tue PeorLe or THE Stare or New York, Complainants,

vs.

Stare or New Jersey and Passaic VALLEY SEWERAGE ComMMIs-

SIONERS, Defendants.

EXHIBITS

CompLAINANTS’ Exnipit No. 1. James D. Maher, Commissioner

Stenographer’s Report of a Public Tearing Given by the New Yorl:

Harbor Line Board, in the Army Building, New York City, Decem-

her 9, 1908, in the Matter of the Application of the Passaie Valley

Sewerage Commission for the Consent of the War Department for

the Construction and Maintenance of a Trunk-outlet Sewer Be-

neath the Waters of Newark and New York Bays.

(2901)

Ex. No. 1——1

Sai ached

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

Index of Speakers.

Messrs. Lebkuecher, pages 60, 85, 137, 230, 297, 303, 313.

Child, 10, 303, 314.

Harrison, 14, 150, 270.

Dean, 43, 86, 137, 138, 141, 150, 162, 214, 229.

Hering, 43, 233, 263, 297, 298, 300.

Dunn, 61.

Eastwood, 71.

Sherrard, 74.

Payne, 85.

McBride, 74.

Heck, 84.

Riker, 86. 105, 136, 138.

Higgins, 113.

Ring, 129.

Darlington, 104.

Miller, 88.

Porter, 97.

Conkling, 120.

Monk, 122.

Colyer, 129.

Parsons, 133, 196.

Landreth, 201.

Jackson, 162.

Ackerman, 229.

Kissam, 263.

Brush, 268.

Sandford, 293, 314.

Schondelmeier, 301.

Soper, 86, 89, 286, 300, 298.

Communications.

City Improvement Association, page 161.

Wallace Downey, page 160.

Atlantie Yacht Club (Bartow S. Weeks), page 159.

Sea Gate Association (Gherardi Davis), page 159.

Borough of Richmond (L. Tribus), page 148.

Calvin Tomkins, page 147.

Data.

U.S. Coast Survey Reports ( Extracts), page 190.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2903

| Stenographer’s report of a public hearing given by the

New York Harbor Line Board in the Army Building,

New York City, December 9, 1908, in the matter of the Applica-

tion of the Passaie V alley Sewerage Commission for the consent

of the War Department to the contruction and maintenance of a

trunk outlet sewer beneath the waters of Newark and New York

bays.

Present:

The New York Harbor Line Board, as follows:

Colonel D. W. Loekwood, Corps of Engineers,

Colonel E. IL. Ruffner, ws

Colonel John G. D. Knight,“ “ 4s

Lieut. Col. S. W. Roessler, “ *

The following gentlemen were also present:

Julius A, Lebruecher, Chairman of and representing the Pas-

saic Valley Sewerage Commission.

Francis Child, Counsel for the Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-

mission.

Edlow W. Harrison, Chief Engineer for the Passaic Valley Sew-

erage Commission.

Maurice B. Dean, Counsel representing the Attorney General of

the State of New York,

Rudolph Hering, Civil and 5 Sanitary Engineer, New York City.

Michael Dunn, Attorney, Paterson, N. J.

Poulteney Bigelow, Journalist, New York City.

Theodore Backers, representing the Attorney General of the State

of New Jersey.

John H. Eastwood, Belleville, N. J.

Morris R. Sherrard, City Engineer, Newark, N. J.

? Dr. Geo. A. Soper, President Metropolitan Sewerage

Comm'n.

Gustave Schwab, New York City.

A. F. MeBride, Mayor of Paterson, N. J,

J. ©. Payne, Secretary and Engineer, Riparian Commission of

New Jersey,

Mr. Heck, Board of Trade, Jersey City, N. J.

Chanler W. Riker, Counsel for the Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-

mission.

A. Foster Higgins, representing the Chamber of Commerce. of

New York City,

B. L. Stowe, representing Jersey City Board of Trade.

Anderson Price, Attorney at Law, New York City,—residing at

Paterson, N. J.

Welding Ring. President, New York Produce Exchange.

te Thomas Darlington, Commissioner of Health, New York

ty

Hugh Gordon Miller, representing the Attorney General of the

United States, in the case,

2904 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

Joseph Coult, Newark, N. J.

Dr. Eugene H. Porter, State Commissioner of Health, New York.

Alfred E. Ommen, representing the West End Association, New

York City.

Alfred R. Conkling, President, Realty League, New York City.

John Monk, New York City.

J. T. Colyer, New York City.

Captain Parsons, Maritime Association, New York City.

Prof. Olin H. Landreth, Sanitary Expert.

Dr. Daniel D. Jackson, Sanitary Expert.

William S. Ackerman, Member, Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-

mission.

Yoleman FE. Kissam, Mayor, representing the City of Orange,

New Jersey.

Dr. George W. Brush, President of the Brooklyn League, Brook-

lyn, New York.

3 Arthur Sandford, Contractor, Newark, N. J.

Dr. C. T. Schondelmeier, representing the Broadway and

Allied Press Trade, Brooklyn, N. Y.

The Chairman: Gentlemen, if you will come to order, I will state

the objects of this hearing.

The hearing is called, subject to the following notice:

“United States Harbor Line Board for Harbor of New York and

Adjacent Waters.

ArMyY BUILDING,

New York Crry, November 14, 1908.

1. Under the Laws of the State of New Jersey, the Passaic Valley

Sewerage Commission propose to intercept the sewage from the dis-

triet now discharging into the Passaic River below the Great Falls

at Paterson and the tributary district which may hereafter discharge

into said river, and convey it beneath the waters of New York and

Newark Bays by means of a trunk outlet sewer ending near Robbins

Reef in Upper New York Bay.

2. Application has been made to the Secretary of War by the

Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission for the consent of the War

Department to the construction and maintenance of such sewer, and

the matter has heen referred to the U. S, Harbor Line Board for the

Harbor of New York and its adjacent waters for a comprehensive

report on this entire subject.

3. The Board will give a Public Hearing on this subject in the

Army Building, No. 39 Whitehall Street, New York City, at 10

a, m. on Wednesday, December 9, 1908, which you are it-

4 vited to attend.

Very respectfully,

D. W. LOCKWOOD,

Colonel, Corps of Engineers, Senior Member of Board.”

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2905

The Chairman: The original papers in this case are ax follows:

“Wasnineton, D. C., Oct. 6, 1908.

Hon. Luke E, Wright, Sec’ty of War.

Dear Sir: I herewith hand you on behalf of my client, the Pas-

saic Valley Sewerage Commissioners, application for consent of your

department to the construction and maintenance of an outlet sewer

beneath the waters of New York and Newark Bay, as fully described

and shown by plans on said application. ‘

As required by the regulations, I have also furnished two extra

copies of the plan annexed to the application and also a copy of

the opinions of Gener’l Henry M. Robert and other consulting En-

gineers on the matter as expressed in an official report mad: by the

Commissioners to the Governor of the State of New Jersey, June

1903.

I shall be pleased to furnish the Department with any other

available data desired in the proper consideration of this applica-

tion.

Respectfully yours,

EDLOW W. HARRISON,

Engineer, Passaic Valley Sewerage

Commission, Jersey City, N. J.”

5 The Chairman: These papers were forwarded to the Har-

hor Line Board by the following endorsement: “War De-

partment, Office of the Chief of Engineers, Washington, October

13, 1908.

1. Respectfully referred to Col. D. W. Lockwood, Corps of En-

gineers, for report by the New York Harbor Line Board,

2. It is the desire of the Chief of Engineers that in considering

this subject the Board give consideration not only to the interests of

navigation, but also to the intere=ts for whose benefit this work is

proposed. In other words, it is desired that the report of the Board

cover the entire subject in comprehensive manner.

3. An expression of opinion is desired as to the practicability of

requiring the builders of thix sewage disposal system to remove by

ging any deposit in navigable waters caused by the projected

works.

FREDERIC V. ABBOT,

Acting Chief of Engineers.”

The Chairman: The application to the Secretary of War, upon

which this hearing is based, is as follows:

To the Honorable Luke E. Wright, Secretary of War of the United

States of America:

_ Respectfully represent the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commis-

sioners acting under authority of Chapter 10 of the Laws of 1907

of the State of New Jersey entitled:

An act to provide for the purification of the waters of the Pas-

2906 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

saic River within the Passaic Valley Sewerage District prohibiting

the discharge of sewage or other polluting matter into said portion

of said river after a fixed date, and authorizing municipalities

6 lying in whole or in part within the Passaic Valley Sewerage

District, from the territory of which sewage or other pol-

luting matter is or may be discharged into said portion of said

river, to enter into contracts with each other and with the Paseaie

Valley Sewerage Commissioners for the intercepting and disposal of

such sewage and other polluting matter, and to provide the necessary

funds therefor.

Propose to intercept the sewage from the district now discharging

into the Passaic River below the Great Falls at Paterson, and the

tributary district which may hereafter discharge into said river,

and by the course of said river and Newark Bay and Kill von Kall

now reaches the Bay of New York; and convey said sewage by means

of a trunk outlet sewer extending from Paterson to a point of dix

charge in the waters of New York Bay East of Robbins Reef ata

depth of not less than 40 ft. below the mean high water in said Bay.

The proposed alignment and grade of said outlet sewer, from the

Westerly side of Newark Bay to the outfall into New York Bay, are

as shown on the map and profile attached, and may be further

described as follows:

The sewer will be in tunnel from a point West of the Western

shore-line of Newark Bay, passing under Newark Bay, the upland

of Bergen Neck, and under New York Bay on a line passing as near

as may be practicable to the Light House on Robbins Reef to a point

where the tunnel intersects the rock contour of the bottom of New

York Bay.

At no point in the line beneath the navigable waters of

7 the United States and outside of the established line for solid

filling, will any part of such permanent structure, when com-

pleted, be less than 35 ft. below mean high water except upon the

reef of rock North of and not more than 500 ft. from Robins Reef

Lighthouse where it is proposed to place a permanent shaft and

shaft-house, rising to a height not more than 20 ft. above mean

high water.

The point designated for said permanent shaft on Robbins Reef

will be preferably where the rock approaches nearest to the surface,

and consequently beyond the limits of safe navigation.

The tunnel will have an inside diameter of 12 ft. At the Eastern

end, where the rock contour is intersected, four or more pipes of

cast iron or reinforced concrete of diameters varying from 6 to 2 ft

will be laid in trenches on the bottom of the Bay to such distances

(within the limits of the State of New Jersey) in any direction a&

may be deemed necessary to procure a quick and free dispersion and

mixture of the sewage with a large volume of Bay water.

The pipes will be provided with proper openings along their

length so that the total volume of sewage discharge may be broken

up in units of volume so small as to be quickly dispersed and di-

luted with a large volume of Bay water.

PG SOLD LEGA LN Ta a AE Re amy ee roeeys v5

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2907

No discharge opening will be less than 40 ft. below mean high

water. :

The discharge of sewage through said sewer at present will be

from a population of about 600,000 people or practically 10% of

the total discharge of sewage into the Bay of New York from

8 the surrounding communities, including the territory to be

served by the proposed sewer. The ultimate capacity of the

sewer is computed to be for a population of 1,650,000 estimated to

be reached in 1940, and it is contemplated will not at that time ex-

ceed the present proportion of 10% of the total sewerage tributary

to New York Bay. It is proposed to subject the sewage to a process

of thorough screening to remove matter carried in suspension, and

also to provide for the sedimentation and removal of sand and

grit, at the pumping station in the Newark Meadows, before allow-

ing the sewage to enter the outfall tunnel.

The undersigned Commissioners respectfully request that the fol-

lowing works may be authorized, approved and permitted se far ax

they come within the jurisdiction and supervision of the War De-

partment:

First. The construction and permanent maintenance of tunnels

under navigable waters of Newark Bay and New York Bay, as shown

by the plans attached.

Second. The construction, laving and permanent maintenance of

four or more outlet pipes of a diameter varying from 6 ft. to 2 ft.

in trenches beneath the navigable waters of New York Bay within

the territory of the State of New Jersey, and not less than 40 ft.

below the mean high water, as shown by the plans attached.

Third. Construction and permanent maintenance of a shart, and

shart-house upon the rock of Robbins Reef not exceeding 100 ft.

square, and not exceeding 20 ft. in height above high water.

9 The site of said shaft to he determined so as not to interfere

with navigation, and not to be inconsistent with the proper

wes of Robbins Reef for lighthouse purposes.

Fourth. The temporary erection and use, during construction, of

such cribs as may be required for construction shafts in the navi-

gable waters of Newark Bay and New York Bay West of Robbins

Reef and outside the established lines for solid filling. The said

construction to be located, built and maintained to the satisfaction

of the United States authorities having supervision of said waters,

and to be removed on the completion of construction.

Fifth. Permission to erect and maintain such temporary plat-

forms, floats or other structures within navigable waters as may be

required for the purpose of sounding and boring to determine the

character of the bottom. The said structures to be located. built

and maintained to the satisfaction of the United States authorities

having supervision of said waters.

All work, in or below navigable waters, both permanent and

2908 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

temporary, to be subject to the approval and supervision of the

United States authority having jurisdiction over the said waters.

( Signed ) J. A. LEBKUECHER,

FRANCIS CHILD,

W.S, A. KERMAN,

Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners.

Attest :

JOHN 8. GIBSON, Clerk.

Dated, Newark, N. J., September 23, 1908.”

10 The Chairman: The Board will listen to the parties in in-

terest. in the following order: First, the applicants, the

Passaic Valley Sewerage Comimission ; Second, others who favor the

project; Third, the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission and the

New York Board of Health: Fourth, the navigation interests, as to

the effect of the work proposed, in possible deposits in the navigable

waters in question: and, Fifth, the Attorney General of the State

of New York, represented by Mr. Dean, attorney at law, on the

subject of pollution,—respresentatives of organizations, and indi-

vidual interests, with regard to the subject of pollution. It is de

sired that any one addressing the Board shall come forward and firt

state their names, and speak distinctly, so that the stenographer can

hear them. It ix also desired that, as far as possible, the various

interests will be represented ly but one <peaker. if that can be done.

The Board will now hear the applicants in this ca-e.

Mr. Francis Child (Member of the Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-

mission): Gentlemen, the duty of presenting the questions relating

to the engineering features, and matters perchance of most moment.

to you gentlemen, will devolve upon our Chief Engineer who from

long association with the work, has become perfectly familiar with

all its details. Speaking for the Commission. I have this to say:

The lamentable conditions of the Passaic River on account of its

filth, have been such, and is such, that. for the let eleven years the

subject of some feasible project for the cleansing of the River

11 has agitated the public mind. That the Passaic River is now,

and has been for vears past, little more than an open sewer,

cannot be contested by any one, for the very simple reason that i

requires only the olfactory sense of any person visiting that locality

to discover that fact. The «tench arising from the river is

that property lying along its banks, both on the East and Wea

banks, or above, on the North or South banks, has been so seriously

affected that its saleability has been almost destroyed, for factory

urposes and. when used for factory purposes, as I myself have

eard gentlemen at the head of those great manufacturing indus

tries state again and again: that the stench arising from the river,

particularly during the summer months. was so great that their em-

ployves, particularly the female employes—and there are a great

women employed in those various factories—was so seriously af-

fected that many of them had abandoned the locality, and others

GLO PERE EE “tee

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2909

were seriously ill. These facts none can controvert; indeed, I un-

derstand. they are all admitted.

The water of the Passaic River is black; it is black with pollu-

tion. Owing to a peculiarity of the river, which may, or may not be

known to you gentlemen, in its winding course, and in the tidal

effect, a curious phenomenon take= place. The sewage which leaves

the upper waters of the Passaic Valley Sewerage District, that is, at

Paterson, as has been a-certained, occupy eleven days at times, some-

times even more than that, and other times less, before they are

finally discharged from the river. This is owing to an oscillation,

resulting from the winding character of the river, and the

12 _ action of the tidal currents. A little gain ix made each day in

the downward course of the ~ewage. which is only overcome to

a certain extent, perhaps a large extent by the out-going tide, and

then the sewage is driven back, <o that, in this privm we heve sew-

age of eleven days that has been confined there, oscillating backwards

and forwards, and with the limited supply of fre-h water mingling

with it, this great mass ef putrescent matter has been there for a

period of ten or eleven days. Now, these are facts; there is no guess-

work about it; it is the result of experiments. Every measure that

could be suggested, offering any reasonable grounds of relief, has

heen investigated. Every thing, septic tanks, and all the modern

improvements of science have been investigated and every one of

them has been found unavailable. The reason of it is this: That

we have in the Passaic Valley Sewerage District—we have twenty

municipalities; you can see that, in order to establish a -eptic tank

#stem one of two things would he necessary: Either the construc-

tion of a great intercepting or trunk sewer, which would gather the

sewage at any and all placex, and thereafter give the sewage septic

treatment or such other treatment ax research might show to be best.

That ix not feasible for the very simple reason that the ground for

that work cannot be obtained. Individual municipal treatment is

impossible for the same reason. I do not know whether you gentle-

men are familiar or not with the locality embraced within the Pas-

saic Valley Sewerage District, but vou take, for instance, the

13 municipality after municipality that is so closely connected

with the City of Newark, that when you leave the one, here,

you can hardly tell when you enter the other, there, these munici-

palities being, in fact, practically suburbs of the City of Newark,

and so it stands to reason that the only method left for us, the only

thing we can discover after a research of over eleven years, and ex-

amination: and investigations by four successive boards or commis-

sions, aided by the best engineering talent in the country—the only

«lution we can find, gentlemen, ix the solution which is now

wsed to you gentlemen, and which will be explained at length

. I trust, in a most satisfactory manner, by our Engineer, who is

net only a good engineer, but has the advantage—from long asso-

dation, of being perfectly familiar with this territory—with the

tidal action and F matters of great intere=t.

I would now merely call the attention of this Board to the fact

that it is not the intention of the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commis-

2910 THE PROVLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VB.

sion to put into the Bay of New York one more—one additional

drop of ~ewage Evervthing which we propese to handle under this

project ix everything that goes inte the Bay today, and has been

going inte the Bay since a time when the memory of man runneth

net te the contrary, 11 hax always been done. It goes in in the met

offensive form: it gues in after being held back for a period verving

from ten to more days, It ix proposed—we propose to take this

sewage, remove from it all dfluence which i+ eljectionable to the

eve: all that which fleat-,—all that which i« offensive and

14 —s that which will offer any unsightly appearance in the water.

We propose to receive this in a large receptable to lift it

there by puny and send it through a «tof tunnels and then, after

it reaches its outfall, after heing completely «reened and every

thing objectionable removed fron it, nething but liquid —then to

discharge it— net from a twelve foot -ewer——net from a twelve fod

sewer—and vou will «e the plan which vou have before wou dee

not indicate any <uch thing as that— but to di<charge it by means of

as many <eparate pipes as may be necessary—to di<charge tt so that

I think I can speak within reason, that anles—and thir ix

by our own experiment=—unle a person was informed of the fact

a «wer war discharging forty or more feet below the ground,

they would net be consciens of it presence. That i+ all we «oy, and

as we have reason to sav. that this i< the greatest reduction —as far

as we can awertain——that has ever been made in the question of

sewage disposal, We discharge it through as many pipes as may be

necesary, in deep water, distrilated over a large area, after careful

«reening and <dimentation: what more can be dene’ That we

conform te the requirements of the United States statute, of coure,

is known to vou.

1 will new preent te vou Mr. Edlew W. Harrison, and after he

speaks, Mr. Rudolph Hering will he prepared te answer any quer

thons which vou gentlemen mav <agge-t.

Mr. Harri«on: Colonel, and Gentlemen of the Boord, 1 will briefly

state the engineering facts which we find are invelved in this

Es) question, and am prepared at the <ane time to <tate the hase

of our conclusions as to the entire practicability and avail-

ability of the project, and will endeavor to anewer <a) questions a

Passaic Valley, which ix gathered from the towns on either side of

that Valley, commencing with Paterson. at the foot of the Creat

seven Geum 2 clas Gheusand cable tot per ecend, er Oat

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2911

five thousand to six thousand milion gallons a day. Now, into this

Kiver, in the Summer months, with a flow of four hundred million

gallons a day we throw the sewage from a Jrqrulation of «me six

hundred theasand | _—or abeut sixty million gallons, which

is at the rate of a gallons per head per day,—and | think

its night te use the standard of one hundred gallon- e head. which

ix about the water use of the community. We throw sixty

16 —s willion gallons of what | will call «anderd «wage. Standard

«wage, in the ordinary \imerican community —in seme com-

wunities it is stronger and in «ne communities it is weaker than

im other communities, but to take the avegage a» a standard, the sew-

age of the Passaic Valley Sewerage District ik no stronger per unit,

avd no weaker, compared to a similar -tandard, and we are ready to

e it,

M The tide flow of the Passaic is weak during the four months of

the Summer The tidal flow of the Paswic ix peculiar during the

four months of the Winter, or rainy seaen—the rainy months.

The tide, coming in from the narrows of Newark Bay, meets the

fresh water flow of the Kiver from near its mouth; that is, the tidal

priem, so to say, ix filled with the fresh water frou the apper stream

and rises, with the stream, to the <alt water dam below. i

the condition during the rainy month»

In the Summer four month=, the tidal flow of the Ri

practically to the village or City of Pasnic ten or twelve i

dhwe Newark and where the river ix about six feet deep and

hundred to five hundred feet wide. A very «mall <tream. Now,

tiwer ix narrow; the tidal priew ix tall, o ively, to

amount of drainage drained on either side, and the amount of

age coming in.

Now, during the Summer months, with the sixty million

total of sewage coming in, it takes, if a man may state it, from

the Ray—Newark Bay. is accumulation starts

7 main, and commences to accumulate, «0 that at the

dry period, there are <ome eleven days’ sewage i

and an analvsix of the river water shows that that i

That ix, that the Passaic River, at the end of a dr

Market Street, Newark—that is at the Tenneylvania

in Newark, all the way up in its tidal course, to

twelve miles, contains now, in the Sunumer

a bacteriological population than the

efforts were made and the work of construct

was instituted. Now, during that time the

im the river: alone come the Pall rains, when,

r hundred million gallons a day, we

water enough to fill the priem several times over, and as

have, 1 would say, from five thousand to six

rH

ig?

Tt ;

;

!

f

7izta

pTEESttiy

i

4E

z

H

i

>

pf fetll

Nie

HH

:

;

Fa

i

FE

z

a

|

z

i

Bd ATH

Hr wt Hk 7 rt Sqrezeay ePLts ist

+ ait eagle) Han bit Ha 3

5 Sar tee ul igs al Z a

BRTRERHITHAL Tesh aa pin 1 tt

- iit yaad ney T 382.2 Fs Tk pease fs

; gif? i beh Ute oH 4 tiaee ytd #

HG patties Hani aidhiqunats a

ay SH MS Herat Wa eta Bit ats

agit uf fart aie yiniinl Le

bps Hi erths ani a TURE Ae

Te ee iM i

Piet. Wye Poe alii

siedadest i H. tte ard

THE #TATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 291%

ant within their territory, and I do not blame them. I

any sensible man for not wishing to have it. This

territory ix Wuilding up; % thiesly populated, as are all

territories around New York City. In order to take care

« water—thix sewage, our opinion ix that it will require one

acres, and if #% was all taken care of by one plant, which

would be the sensible way, if that way wa* adopted, we

should have to take out of the area of City of Newark,

one thousand acres, Now, Newark has about eleven thou-

In the Southern district of Newark ix the great manu-

commercial city. The meadows at Newark which,

were looked on a= almost valucles, are now very

developments in the Newark Meadows in the wa

interests now amounts to hundreds « Penden |

might say, millions a year, and the future develop-

tremendous in their pow! ilities; they are increasing how

’ to are generally

expected will arveunt to many millions more. And the potenti-

ihe

j2

it

te

i ;

:

se

t

|

a

commercial land of the City of Newark, and, two miles away, is

art of Jersey City, and with Southwest winds, Jersey City

get the benefit of the -prinkling filters, and with Southeast

the City of Newark would get the benefit of the -prinkling

‘and, another ment important point, in my idea is, that you

will not find a «wage diqperal plant anywhere but what the

thes are innumeraide and 1 de, millions of flies, and,

with our present knowledge of sanitary affairs, we know that

eormous quantities of flies would be dangerous in the vicinity of

—, The only City that hax tried that on a large

i in. and Kerlin has fifteen hundred acres of sandy land

sewage diqural plant they do things differently in Ger-

_ Ruffner: Did you say fifteen thousand acres?

” Harrison. Fifteen hundred acres; that ix, one thousand acres

the city, and public lands in the vieinity—the —_ land«

in

but

great hartors of the world, they have not there the

waters we have here: the City of Merlin ix far from the

and there was nothing ele to be done, and even there, no

not a scholar, would be proud of the sewage dis

2914 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE 9F NEW YORK VS.

Now, to cure this evil, this Commission, after a thorough study

and after a number of the brightest of all our engineers have de

termined that the best disposition was the natural, first, disposal,

due to our situation and to our being part of the harbor of New

York, and to the magnificent advantage which this whole metro-

politan district has, with the large tlow of water and plenty of it,

tv take care of this project with safety, we finally decided

22 that the only, best, most economical and also the method

in the line of improvement, future improvement, was to

follow out somewhat the Boston method, somewhat the London

method, somewhat more the Boston method, and with improve

ments,

Now, we propose to take that sewage down to the shore of Newark

Bay, and there pass it through screens and sediment chambers,

settling chambers, and remove from the sewage the heavy grit,

all the floating particles, and, ax vou will perceive by our specifica-

ions which you bave before vou, we do not say just how much will

be removed; we say “all that is necessary or shall be necessary”

shall be removed, so that there will be no danger of an offense aris-

ing in the outlet.

Now, there is no question that we can do that. The City of

Hamburg does it, there, with a population of over one million.

They pass the sewage through a house there, through a house with

settling chambers—over screens—the City of Hamburg passes the

sewage through screens, then out into a settling tank or chamber

eighty feet wide by thirty feet deep, after it passes through this

chamber it passes through six sediment tanks, thence into tow-

boats, for the sediment, and then discharged into the middle of the

river, and the whole river traflic of the City, the ferrvhoat traffic

and general river traflic passes over it; the main ferry station cro-es

the river, and excursion boat traffic with a station right over in

front of the pump house and wharves in front of the pump house,

and the Hamburg-American Line docks, about a mile or two

23 below, are right in the track of this sewer, and you cannot

tell there is any sewer in there at all. The River Elbe—

Col. Ruffner: What is the rise and fall of the tide there?

Mr. Harrison: They have a rise and fall of about eight or ten

feet, the result being that in order to save pumping they made their

sewer so large, with their tide locks, that for feur hours each tide

the sewage flows up inside and filly up this very large sewer, much

larger than ordinary, and they have, from my own knowledge, a

great advantage. in the rise and fall of the tide, over what we have

on our low level—we do not think it a great advantage, but they

do that because it saves pumping, and then the gates open auto

matically, as the tide goes down and the flow goes out, there has been

an accumulation by the intercepting of the flow, causing the sewage

to back up in the sewer, which was made larger for this very purpose,

which results in this sewage being locked into the large main sewer

during the flood tide, so that practically sixteen hours’ stuff has to be

cared for on the ebb. Our project proposes a very large improve

ment over this method, as they have to provide for the accumulation

__

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2915

and have made the sewer larger than ordinary for the purpose ; while

we, however, will not have to hold this tide locked sewage. We im-

prove a great deal, | think, on that; they have a very coarse screen,

and the Hamburg sewage is heavy, is very heavy, it is very strong,

probably twice ax strong as the sewage in the vicinity of New York

or in any of our cities.

24 Now, there has been a great misapprehension as to the

amount of sewage—or a great misunderstanding, at least, as

to the ammount we propose to put into this trunk outlet sewer,

Now, I want to say to the Commission that the people of the Pas-

saie Valley are no different than the people of the City of New York,

and they do not furnish any more sewage per head than the people

of New York; and this mistake may have arisen from the fact that a

figure has heen used in our descriptions, and in all good faith, fixing

the maximum capacity of the sewer at 360,000,000 gallons per day

ultimately ; that is the ultimate capacity of the sewer, built to take

for four or five or six hours, the peak capacity, the peak of the

quantity of stuff which must pass through it; you all realize that at

certain times of the day the flow of the sewage is much greater than

at other times of the day of twenty-four hours, as in every com-

munity the same rule answers; now this figure is fixed as the peak of

the flow, the maximum capacity of the sewer, three hundred and

sixty million gallons; but the average capwaity of discharge to-day

is nearly—the average maximum discharge is only about two-thirds

of that. or two hundred and fifty million gallons, and that is a

capacity or average which we estimate will be effective around 1940;

that. in other words, is the ultimate capacity. That will include,

under the law under which we are acting, the house sewerage, a

certain amount of ground water which cannot possibly be kept out

of the sewer, and not more than ten per cent, of the trade waste, and

when I say trade waste, 1 mean the total effluence from factories,

much of it being clear water; the idea being that the operat-

vz) ing of this sewer in a separate system, which is required in all

communities, at tin.es. the factory waste will be treated, as it

is being treated at the present time and particularly as treated in

other communities, and reduced by this treatment so that ninety per

cent, of the water will pass right into the river, which, of course, will

not injure the river at all. T believe, from our investigation—there

have been investigations made in Paterson, N. J., by Mr. Hazen,

there is no trouble about doing this; there is no difficulty whatever

to do this.

Now, the present discharge is seventy million gallons of sewage;

the maximuin will be two hundred and fifty million gallons, and not

two hundred and fifty million gallons of standard sewage, because

the standard sewage — that will be the sewage from aboutone million

and a half of people and the standard sewage of one and a half mil-

lions people would not be over one and a half millions gallons, and an

additional one hundred millions would be made up of a large

amount of ground water, and it is very necessary that there should

bea large allowance made, because the Eastward slope of the Orange

2916 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

mountains is of gravelly formation and contains enormous quanti-

ties of underground water.

Now, after this sewage is pumped up, it is sedimented and passed

through screens, passed through a settling chamber, and then we pro

pose to send it through a twelve foot channel running under this

head, under pressure, the top of the tunnel being thirty feet be-

26 low mean high water; now, when | say not less than thirty feet,

I mean, if it should be determined that we will go some twenty-

eight or thirty feet below mean high water, it will be in the rock bed,

in case you want to dredge where T call the Jersey Flats, the Jersey

City flats, it will be in the rock bed, and hence no interference with

navigation

Col. Ruffner: What will be the depth of the top part of the sewer

below mean high water as it cro-ses the Bay down there?

Mr. Harrison: The top line of the sewer will be below the water

line—will be at an elevation minus fifty feet below; it must be re-

member- that in addition the -ewer is twelve feet, lying on the bed

of the Bay, or if it have a range from twelve to fourteen fect at the

outfall, we might say thirty-six feet below low water———

Col. Knight: Below low water?

Mr. Harrison: Below high water. The plan was based on the

idea that the requirements would not be over thirty feet below high

water in the rock bed in Newark Bay——

Col. Knight: In the Bay?

Mr. Harrison: Yes: in the Bay, and also on the Jersey Flats be

tween Robbins Reef and the Jersey shore; the Pennsylvania dredge is

about twenty-five feet, the foundation for the new Pennsylvania

yards is about twenty-five to thirty feet. Now, we probably will

put that down even lower; the question of whether that tunnel in

place shall be minus fifty feet or minus sixty feet has very little bear-

ing upon the case. We may be able to find the rock and

27 follow it throughout the Bay by going down a few feet more.

What we look for is a way for the tunnel: if the course can

be better had down ten feet below minus fifty, I do not think there

will be involved much more expense for the shaft, allowing us to

keep within the shaft—there will only be required a little more

pressure there with the air: if we have to use air; T don’t expect to

have to use air only for a very shore distance there.

Now, when we bring that out to Robbins Reef, where. in the

vicinity of the light house there ix now about, by our chart, five or six

feet of water at low water, that is nine or ten feet at high water; and

there,—or about there (indicating on map) we ask you for a shaft,

and we ask you for the right to establish a tank or gate house 10

which we can control the flow from the tunnel into the discharge

pipes although it is probably not absolutely necessary that we should

have that; but it would be better for the project, better for the United

States Government, better for all interests that there should be some

thing there where the flow of these pipes could be controlled, and in

order that they could be controlled in the flow; we would then be able

to throw a larger velocity through any one of the pipes or in all

“or , . Nea . . - . ’ Pee e/

Sims oS ned Pag oh BO AR te te el

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2917

them for cleaning out and scouring; also, in case of a repair to a pipe,

we would be able to shut it off there without going into diver work.

You already have an obstruction to navigation on that reef; a

Light House; the Reef was deeded by the State of New Jersey

Is to the United States, during the administration of Governor

McClellan and the United States holds it for light house pur-

wes; the State reserved in the deed the right of reversion if case it

dhould be abandoned for lighthouse purposes and any use for any

ther purpores.

Of course, the Commission acts under authority of the State, and

have the right to the use of any such reversionary interest of the

State or rights of the State in any way. Now, | am well aware, the

Commission is well aware, that probably the question of the location

of this building-——this structure is a small, common structure, archi-

wturally— as it is contemplated to put upon this rock as a shaft

and pump house—we know that the question of its location there

m that reservation does not, | believe lie with the War Department,

wat that the final location would probably lie, we understand, with

the Department of Commerce and Labor and as that Department

requires; but the question of obstruction comes to you; that is the

rason we apply to the War Department,—in regard to the obstrue-

tion, Now, if the Department of Commerce and Labor don't see

it—we think it should be as near the light house as possible,—in

fact, my own opinion is that if we put upa proper kind of a strueture

the upper part of it could be used for light-house purposes instead

ff the small light house there as it is—the light-house there now is

forty feet above high water; but, if the Department of Commerce

{ Labor don’t consider that a proper place to put it, three hundred

ind fifty feet from the light-house we are in the lands of the State

of New Jersey, and, therefore, we ask you for the right to put

% it there on the same reef, about the same height or elevation,

about the same part of the rock—we ask a right to put our

hhaft there.

Now, from this shaft and from this gate-house, which is prae-

tially the end of the tunnel, we propose to extend into the dis-

inbuting ground, a series of perhaps four, we will say, four hundred

four foot pipes; they will be rivetted; they may be rivetted steel,

may be cast iron.—but we are not determined vet what will be the

‘est use. They will. of course, have flexible | vints. They will be

aid in a shallow trench on the bed of the Bay. They will extend

mt toa depth of forty feet where there is water forty feet deep, on

iforty foot paral-el/ line vertically below high water, and there we

ull commence to allow the sewage to go out, and we propose then

® diminish the pipes across the channel, or into the channel, all

"thin the limits of the State of New Jersey, sloping the fall of

the pipes from 40 to 60 or 70 feet, and we propose to have openings

these pipes, in the several pipes, perhaps fifty or sixty openings,

as many as may be necessary, and the pipes, with these open-

ings, will he distributed over as large an area as necessary so that

wery part of this filtered sewage, as it comes out from the pipes,

Mill almost immediately be diluted with a proper proportion of Bay

Ex. No. 1——2

2918 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

water in order that the sewage may be thoroughly dispersed and

that there shall be no offensive conditions arising.

Col. Knight: Do ! understand that those pipes that you say you

will have come down a slope—when you speak about sloping,

30 do you mean that the pipes will slope downward from the

mouth of the tunnel for the length of the pipes, which you

say is to be about 400 feet?

Mr. Harrison: When I spoke of sloping down, I referred to hav-

ing the pipes slope downward toward the bottom of the bay, from

a depth of forty feet to a depth of perhaps seventy feet, depending

on the depth of the water.

Col. Knight: You propose to continue the pipes down to a depth

of seventy feet, on a slope?

Mr. Harrison: They will be put at a depth of forty feet, and sl

downward, with the several openings so distributed as to prc

best results in dispersion.

Now we do not limit ourselves in our specifications as to the prac-

tieal plans; we do not limit ourselves, nor in the contracts whieh

will be made with the municipalities under the law to how much

that area of distribution will be or how many pipes may be necessary

or how many openings may be necessary; we say we will give as

many openings and over ax wide a distributing area so that the

volume of water in the Bay, flowing from forty feet to seventy feet

deep will be sufficient to dilute the sewage as quickly as it comes

and we put it out in small units to mix it at once with the water

of the Bay. There we get the ideal practice. We get a great volume

of water in the New York Bay: the great trouble in all sewage s¥*

tems is the need of mixing quickly the sewage with the diluting

water.—the oxidizing water. Now, in regard to that thing,

31 1 want to give a few figures which are the result of our it-

vestigation and on which we base part of our argument; we

believe and we know that they are correct.

And. first, IT want to remind the Commission that the standard —

of dilution for Chicago was one to twenty; one part of sewage to —

twenty parts of lake water passing through ; that 1s the standard,—

one to twenty, or one unit—or four cubic feet per second of flow

for each one thousand people—the ratio of the diluting water as to

the population for the sewage——

Col. Knight: One moment; is the character of the Chicago sewage

that you are going to refer to now, of the same character as will

come from your effluence there?

Mr. Harrison: Well, leaving out the stock yards sewage, the

character of the Chicago sewage is much stronger, as much of it is

not screened

Col, Knight: That is what I wanted to develop.

Mr. Harrison: Let me say, in regard to the screening proposed, —

from the very best authorities when we have screened sewage and

when we have deposited we have thus reduced its pollution—its

powers of pollution—power of offense so that the oxygen required to

entirely destroy it is fifty-eight per cent of the normal ; that is, if it

takes one hundred per cent. of oxygen—that quantity of oxyget io

ete sg aga MEY ate

VINE LEE A RE EER ERI eS yey 9S art ne “e ——

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2919

destroy the power of pollution of ordinary sewage, screened sewage,

in the way we propose to put it through, as sedimented sewage, it is

about 58 or 58 and a half—fifty-eight and a half per cent. of

32 oxygen will do it; that is, we practically take out about forty

per cent of the putrifying substance. I give that on the

wthority of the English Royal Commission, Hall and Gibson,

wthorities on the subject.

Now, we will say that Chicago is as one to twenty ;—Milwaukee

is one to twenty-six,—in the improvement of the Milwaukee River.

In the English Royal Commission, the result of their experiments

dow, ax applied to American sewage, that it seems to be that the

dilution of one part of sewage with fifty parts of ocean water—

Bay water—salt water—sea water-—one to fifty, with absolutely no

knowledge whatever that anything was being put into the water—

I mean that the sewage may be taken care of with no knowledge

w the senses or to the observation that it was going into the water

tall. 1 only give this as a sort of measure or scale by which to

igure the figures we propose to give further on.

Now, from experiments we have made, only one or two, one

thich 1 happened to have right at my hand last night, an ex-

yriment made at ebb tide at Robbins Reef, in the Summer: we

found at the surface eighty-eight and five-tenths per cent. of the

normal quantity of oxygen in the Bay; that is, that the pollution

frst of the whole of New York, the whole of New York island,

the City of New York, the pollution coming through the Kills

ind mingling with the waters of the Bay had not cut that oxygen

down only eleven and a half per cent. Now the authorities are

ill agreed that water, as long as the oxygen is not cut more than

fifty per cent. the sewage can be put into the river water

% without offence to be taken care of. Of course, I am not

making that as a statement of fact. I do not want to go

wo deep into this thing; I am only stating points upon which we

base things. Now we find—at a point, you asked me in regard

to the constituents of sewage. The speaker is asked for a compre-

hensive view of this. Perhaps I am going further than should be

done. after having stated to vou, and | am willing to prove it,

that the sewage will be liquid; we propose to discharge liquid

ewage into New York Bay; sedimented and screened, and under

ection 1307 of the River and Harbor Law, liquid sewage seems

w be separated from the interdicted articles which are there legis-

lated against being thrown into the bay or into United States waters.

Now, there is a question raised that the sewage of the Passaic

Valley is particularly bad. That there is something in the sewage

of the Passaic Valley. it has been alleged. different from other

ewage: something that will rot timber, and tear out the bottoms

of ships and things of that kind. Now, these are the facts, and

. presumably, because they are so manifest on the Passaic.

Now, the facts are these: The population of the Passaic Valley

#scompared with the population of the rest of the district draining

into New York Bay is ax one to seven and six-tenths.

Col. Knight: One to seven and six-tenths?

2920 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

Mr. Harrison: Yes; to the population of the one, the population

of the other sections in this district is a= one to seven and *ix-tenths,

Now. the manufacturing establishments liable to pollute the

34 streams. | have taken from the United States Census; the

manufacturing establishments which are considered by

«ientilic men——sanitary men—as those of a class which furnish

large amounts of waste or polluting waste such as breweries, «ilk

mills, dyeing establishments, leather tanning industries—I! can give

the whole list if necessarv—any sanitary man would he able t

pick those out at once himself,—-they are in the ratio of one te

sixteen as to number,—that is, for sixteen of such establi<hments

in the territory including Hudson County, Jersey City, Hoboken

and districts draining into New York Bay, direct, to one extallish-

ment on the Passaic. The capitalization is as one to seven; that

is. our establishments are larger. The labor is as one to four, That

ix, we employ somewhat more labor, The value of the product

i< as one to seven: that is, the capitalization and the value of the

product are practically the same—the product and the capitalim

tion; the population, the labor, is a little heavier, we need a little

larger number of laborers to an establishment in the Passaic Valley.

The number of establishments are greater in New York, Brooklyn

and the districts around the Bay, directly draining inte the Bay,

and there ix nothing in that to bear out the idea that there should

be any difference at all in the sewage. Now, those are the figures

the statistics in regard to it.

Now. when we come to an examination of the sewage, amd we

have had hundreds of examinations of the Passaic River, and there

has never been an examination which resulted in finding

30 anything different in Passaic sewage from the ordinary

sewage of American cities, or New York, or the ordinary

communities around here, except this, it is darker and it i+ thicker

because our diluting water is so little. It goes into a stream

very little water. If you take a white boat up the Passaic River

in Summer and you will probably have a black boat when you come

back. but that can be cured by dilution.

Now, the next point in regard to that sewage, we propose, —the

methods we propose are so very far in advance of anything that it

is away and beyond anything that is being done now. You have

this sewage, as the Jersey side of it comes off the Kills now. There

js practically nothing comes down Arthur Kill; the current is dows

the Narrows into New York Bay.

Now, I had an analysis made of the waters of the Newark Bay

on October 23rd of this last year; that was the end of the dry

veriod—the waters of Newark Bay at the Central Railroad draw-

ridge, near Bergen Point, in the channel there, in the swiftest part

of the channel, at ebb tide, towards the end of the ebb: the saniples

were taken and the analysis was made by Professor Stillman

Stevens Institute, and showed Free Ammonia seventy -seven-one

hundredths parts in a million; Albumenoid Ammonia seventy-four-

hundredths parts in a million. The analysis of the Ammonia it

New York Bay as made by the Pollution Commission of |

Ni Liam Pr; i ae ian « Perera em

wan

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2921

others made by the Commission on a New Water Supply for New

York, showed the average of Free Ammonia, commencing at Pier

One and running down in New York Bay s one hundred

% and twenty-nine-thousandths of a million, and of the Albu-

menoid Ammonia, one hundred and forty4threethousandth-

ofa willion, That ix, on October 23rd, of this year, after this dry

period, the result of the accumulation of sewage in the Passaic

River and Newark Bay has made the discharge of waters of and

from Newark Bay into New York Bay contain over ix times a

greater quantity of ammonia and amount of sewage than the nor-

mal waters of New York Bay. That is, the water that is going in

now, from Newark Bay—geing in in the the Summer—not now,

heanse we have had rain.—the water that comes into the Bay in

the end of the Sunmer from the Passaic River into New York Bay

has nearly four, five or six times higher standard than the waters

a New York Bay ax determined by the Pollution Commission, and

wr fiwures, as determined by this Commission, and I must say the

facts since ascertained seem to bear them out. That is, when the

waters of the Passaic River, by way of the Newark Bay, strike New

York Bay, it immediately reduces the conditions of New York Bay,

and the reason for it ix that that four or five or six times higher

dandard of ammonias which is accumulated coming down to the

Bay shows its effect on the normal waters of the Bay, and notwith-

danding this was the condition there through, a simple analysis it

is indicated what an enormous purification is shown, and it shows

that even Iving there in that dry period, and without getting the

lenefit of that dilution which the volume of water in New York

Ray provides, simply from purification, septic tank action, still when

it got through from the Passaic through the Narrows, it ha=

% twice—it has, not twice —it has as much, ammonia per unit

in Newark Bay ax there ix in New York Bay.

Now, that brings me to the condition of New York Bay as we

uke it: We find—the Chicage River +andard—in purifyingtheChi-

cago River canal, the ammonias are due to that admixture, would be

éx hundred and ninety-seventhousandth= part in a million of

Free Ammonia, and one hundred and thirty-ninethousandths parts

ina million of Albumencid Ammonia, that is, fresh, just as it

comes in—of course, Free Ammonia passes into Albumenoid Am-

monia in time. By this Chicago River standard, the Newark Bay

had more free ammonia on October 23rd than the Chicago River

has, purified, That ix, Newark Bay has passed the line of four eubie

feet per thousand. When it goes to the condition of fifty per cent.

free ammonia, it will begin to give out an odor and may become a

nu ance.

Newark Bay, away down to Bergen Point, with the pollution

passing down to New York Bay, in only normally polluted by all

sewage of New York, one-fifth the Lake Michigan standard .—

the standard of the Chicago River: That ix, New York now, taking

the sewage into it of five or six million people could take five or six

times as much sewage, properly diluted, properly spread and prop-

@ly brought into contact with the waters of the Bay, could take

2922 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

five or six times the pollution it now receives before it reaches what

every engineer in the United States —— the proper thing,

to be the best thing, for the City of Chicago, and also pronou

the most capable of taking care of the Chicago River so that

38 there should not be a nuisance arise. There, the point is

this: We propose to put only one day's supply into the Bay.

Each day by itself, that supply can be reduced.—of putrecent mat

ter somewhere around forty percent. No more. Nothing to make

a deposit. A liquid. We propose to deliver it over such an area

that just as soon as it leaves the pipes it immediately comes in con-

tact with a flow, of water in the large prism above, and in regard te

that flow. of the tide in the priem, taking the map ax it <hows thee

(indicating), and allowing the sewage in there to he going out, a

spread out at about an angle of sixty degrees and coming up like

emoke. the water of that prism. moving along at the rate of one and

five-tenths feet per second, which is about the average tidal flow im

New York Bav.—the mean of the tidal flow. the tidal flow in that

prism per second is sixty-three thousand cubic feet per second: that

is, the prism above or across these pipes, flows at the rate of 63.000

cubic feet per second. and the discharge from the pipes.—the alti-

mate discharge, in 1940, our discharge then is two hundred and

twenty-five feet per second,—the present discharge of it if in oper

ation to-day would be one hundred and five cubic feet per second

now, with sixty-three thousand cubic feet of tidal water per second

to receive it.

One other point T want to make, and then IT am through: The

tidal volume, on the flood, in New York Bay, ix said to be twelve

thousand seven hundred and four million cubic feet, or alwnut five

handred and ninety thousand cubic feet per seeond— in six hours,

twelve thousand, seven hundred and four thousand million

39 cubic feet in six hours, one flood. There has been a com

siderable discussion as to how much of that ix sea water.

Now. the New York Pollution Commission here referred to—thev

say they could not find it—now, I will ask them to look at their

own report. They made a very careful examination and reported

on the subject—that the bacteriological tests at a number of piers.

commencing at pier No. 1, of the Tron Steamboat Company and

going down to the Iron Pier at Coney I-land— they ~tarted, the

Commission started at the last hour of the ebb, on June 11th, pre

sumably a warm day; they took bacteria tests st Pier No. 1,

site Robbins Reef, Liberty Island, Gravesend Bay and in the Nar-

rows. The report of the Board or Commission, in the fir<t document

they state they staved there during the day and came back on the

end of the flood, the last hour of the flood, in the afternoon. They

took the same test of samples. The report of the Commission shows

(Mr. Harrison is here referring piece-meal to the papers).

of the Commission shows that they brought back fourteen

and a half tests (they note the one-half test)—the report of the Com

mi-sion “hows they came back on the flood and they found one-

of the bacteria—just about one-third to one-half the quantity of

—

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2923

bacteria from the samples that they found when they went out on

the ebb.

Now, during that day, they were away when New York Bay was

tide-locked—they went down the last hour of the ebb, before the

food had closed the sewerage in—during the time it was

tide-locked—the sewerage went out, one-sixth of the total

0 sewage in New York Bay, going into the Bay, hearing in it

million of bacteria, the afternoon a warm one, in June, and

the records of the Commission show that the water they took up

«as clear, clear, without stewch, with practically plenty of oxygen

in it: there was, also, a certain amount of Albumenoid Ammonia

and Free Ammonia—(Referring to book—report—in making these

remarks). That ix all there (indicating)—increase in bacteria—

shole afternoon—increase coming back—found only one-half the

iacteria they found in the morning—at the end of the flood—all

we day the bacteria had been pouring into the river and Bay from

the sewers. and nothing gcing out.

What ix the answer? What ix the best answer, with one-half of a

flood tide, at least, coming up? | submit that the tide that comes wu

is ocean water: there is no other change—one-half ocean water—

place no significance in the quantity of bacteria. Now, we will take

the bacteria as so much aniline dye found here, let us suppose that

they went out and placed a certain amount of color in the water,

distributed in New York Bay at the end of the ebb tide, and came

tack, and found one-half, on the end of the flood tide. What is

the fact? The clean ocean water came in up there, dispersing the

color, cleansing the source.

They say their figures there were surface indications: They know

well that under the surface of the water there is double the amount

of salt water at a level of forty feet below the surface of the river,

ay at 39th Street, where, below the surface, and again at 44th Street,

at about 40 feet down, we have found twice as much salt

41 water as at the surface. This water at the surface contains

more of the albumenoid ammonia, more of the factory

waste. more of the fresh water, while below the surface there is less

factory waste and a larger amount of ocean water: fifty per cent. of

that water, at least, which came in on the flood tide into New York

Harbor, is ocean water.

ties, in the suspended impurities, of about one-fifth the standard

thich is accepted by all engineers and all sanitarians throughout

the world as being perfectly safe. That is the standard, day and

night, Winter and Summer. It may in Summer work do somewhat,

but not in Winter. In their report (Referring again to papers) they

2924 THE PROTLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK va.

have shown some that ix that for four or five month= of the

thee waters draining inte New York Harber, and found i

iew York Harter, have ae much ae thirteen-trandredth- of a pan

to the million of ammenia. The standerd which i* «fe rans ap @

high a« «even and threetenth: of a part to the million. Chicage

can go along with sevententh= of a part to the million of free am

mona and « waikance will not arise, In New York Harber

42 the extreme hae heen thirteen-lundredth= part to the milhen

ae wed with the gern condition mmedent to sevententh

to the million of free ammenia in Chicage, and this extreme

New York ix taken from the eurface of the water. Vf vou ell

take all of the «wage in New York out of the pier end sewers, and

take out of it all the matter in saepension. and put it ae oe

form, and bring the sewage right up threngh the water from the

tom, making an adieixture all the wav through, that condition will

net be found. The trouble with New York is they shewld adeqa this

plan, we believe. of <creening and sedimenting of the <ew age putting

only liquid sewage in. and potting it in at the betters. out ef pape

with a number of qpenings, so that the water, coming in cm

tact with the liquid will quickly disperse it. Hf that plan ix hqted

and carried out for the whole city of New York, the Maw will take

care of the sewage of forty of fifty million people. according te the

engineers, whe practically agree on that question.

Col, Knight: The application of your Commission before the

Board new invelves the question of sedimentation”

Mr. Harricon: It does.

Col. Knight: And of screening’

Mr. Harricon: It does.

Col. Knight: There ix nothing before the Teard to shew her

vou 7 to de that, mething te drow what cour interpretetion &

a” «reening a may be necewary” Are you prepared t

give us mere details?

ch Mr. Marricon: 1 will leave that question te Mr. Merme

Col. Ko It will be adequately determined ’

Mr. Narricon: Mr. Dering will anewer vou in vert to that.

Mr, Dean: 1 would like to ask seme question: of the speaker.

and would ack whether vou consider it more convenrent for me te

ask them as each speaker concludes his remuark+”

The Chairman You will be allowed to question them at the end

of the presentation of the petitioners’ case.

THE “TATE OF SEW JERORY ET AL. 2925

River and there were presented to the Conmmission of whieh 1 wae

a wewler, a harmber of plans contemplating the purification of the

evage of the different mranicipalities We doar ener these reports

and plans and propositions very carefully and we came to the

4 conclusion that in our opinion nene of them would an-wer

the puree for the future, ond we could met recommend any

d them. Se, then, the question war, what shall we recomend ”

and. after consultation, we made a new proposition to the State Sew-

erage Commission and: recomended be diqumition of the «wage

df the ewtire Pasnie Valley, in a proper manner, itte New York

Rav near Robbins Reef. where the present Pasaie Valley Sewerage

Commision proposes to discharge the same.

At that time the methods of sewage purification had net dev

w» far as they have developed to-day: im fact. they have net

perfection vet. and | thimnk—having been mveelf three vears age

mn Europe, and this last Summer in Earape, where they are abewd

dom oin this particular branch of engmeering.

We found that net only the expense of the individual purification

chemes would be great. hat we were afraid that a= this population

gen. it would encroach apen the territery which, Lineqnestvomately.

« more or lex offensive according to all metheds that we have te

dev. unless ven previde a free territery around the «me <0 that we

fet that we had to give » positive recommendation, and | mentioned

it

Xow. then. the question was to satisfy ourselves that that was the

fight thing te de, and that it was Letter than any of the other prope-

dtiens that had heen made. 1 had the hener eaain te he com

with thix matter. as one of the engineers of the present commission,

wed had the instructions to revise the entire question as if

G it we a new one, and ae what could be done, That wae

particularly preper in view of the fact that the methods of

erage purification had unfolded and developed, and that the con-

dosion had was better than «even or ten years age. Another study

eu tnade very carefully, and 1 alee examined personally the various

works in the world. Rarepe and here, with seme of whieh Tam con-

neted.—«nd, again, the «ame conclusion wae reached

Foren thee modern methods of «wage purification. which are

mach cheaper than farmer methods and can be controlled better.

and do net require «0 much territery «ct aside for them, have

fgured out more expensive than the present propesition and, in

sidition te thet, they practically <1 aide an area, 1 tolieve, of

shout ome hundred acres. or «amething like that, somewhere in

the Newark Meadows, being the only available territory left for

tewage purification.—set aside that territery. and it will newer be

@ axurance, from our present knowledge. that it will not be objec:

tenable within a certain radius «round the Passaic,

Our provisional thonght was that pesilly a quarter of a square

mile would practically have te be devoted to the project, or

mervation of perhaps more territory, These calculations were

made on the very latest and het experience in Europe. We have

tly a few plants as yet in this country, in operation, on this latest,

THE PROTLE OF THE #T\TE OF SEW YORK V8.

het method. Stall plants too. Earepe hae hed «ome for tx

years, so that we know what it jx quing to do,—know what it Zoe,

and we can, therefore, when we compare the different sewagm,

and differing comditim=. take inte com-detation,

“ can tell pretty nearly what they are going te do im

country, and all that information wa utilized to test

question here for the Paswic Valley Sewerage Commnston,

Therefore. the Bay diqunal was again recommended, and i pew,

would like to «uy here why, and why it ix better than the

.

question is. what does that mean”

Some twenty veare age | was engaged by the City of Chicago &

determine what that City should de with her «wage. Twenty-one

age. Thev wanted te purify it, ond vet that <ulyjert Was ame

hae

: che Michi

gan. that ix. inte the Misisipqi valley. and. therefore, preserve the

and carry it off. « the oxygen in the water will purify tht

sewage and render it, ufter a due time. net at once, let after « doe

<< .

basis the canal was boilt. and it i+ there teo-dar: and, now,

we in that canal? We «e no pollution. We «e that

even though the dilution to-day ie bat two and two-thirds culée fet

th

fi:

i

ia

i

ilt

A

ei

aL

g2a

: |

4"

| it

i!

+ Ff

i

|

fist

TE

THE ©TATE OF SEW JERERY ET AL. 2927

all of the cities got to work and found out how te purify

i «— wewage, and the result wax thet they found it war practically

ipomible or, better, unneceswry. Reports were trade to the

imperial ward of health and the imperial beard of health changed

i» dictum and mew dewre that a certain aneunt of water wrust go

han theme rivers to dilute the «wage of a certain population. It

he thrown away the Chicage standard, and for gouwl reasons.

the «wage must all be «reened and ttled, but nothing more. Now,

di the cities are doing that: Along the Ethe, along the Ader, along

de Khine, and other cities; that ix, they are net all completed the

corks are not all done, bat they are going on im that direction.

This w a+ not an unknown matter to «ae engineers, and, new, every

aagineet that has «tadied this matter and had «me experience im it

could «ay that that wae the way the thing wa geing to go event

ally. and that the imperial German beard of health was executing

emething which was altogether ton expensive and unnecewary at

the time.

or that reas. the «pecifieation for this Passaic Valley Sewerage

Titriet sewer wax made ao that the <ewage shall be «reened and

then it shall he settled, because, the fint Beard. of the fint Commis

dom «aid: “Tf you want to put thie wage inte New York Bay. do

wu want te pat it in like Hoboken, like Jersey City, right alene

the shore, or, how? 1 said, peremally, I do not think that that is

_hecanse it is all one grand metropolis, and [should euppese

that that would he very objectionable, in fact, 1 think every-

" beady would grant that it would be objectionable therefor.

I proposed the methed that vou have been told about, at the

ime Retter than Hoboken diecharges ite «wage: better than Jer-

< Civ dimcharges ite <ewage: better than New York City dix

arves her sewage

Now. here are the chief differences. why I heliewe this ix the beet

edem of «wage diqeral for the territory under consideration. In

the fir place. the «wage has all ite floating matter taken away at

the pumping tation in other words. the sewage is ecteened

Co. Raffner: Won't you please explain that te the Board’

Mr. Hering: 1 was just coming to it: The «reening ix done in a

number of wavs in Europe. We have got about a half-desen differ-

at plants and «cteens. one particularly nice | wax looking at, this

Sommer, heing from two millimeters to an inch. two millimeters is

ther, one <ixteenth of an inch, and experiments have been made a

whew rmneh can he «creened out and as to what cannot he screened

«mt, and von will naturally «e that by «reening vou can get out

dl the coarse. floating matter vou do not wich in evidence, and we

de net need any evidence about it, it «ems to me that the chief

dijertion we all find in the New York <ewage. which is not screened

at we we it coming down, Seating down beth rivers; we sce it,

ad we know it ix sewage, and we don't like it: that ix the reason

for eereening the <ewage in Europe. almost evervwhere. that is the

fom we contract to «Treen it here. « that none of it will float

down the water any more.

The next thing is that we take out the sediment, in order

to prevent this sediment from depositing in the channel and

RP AE A A A AG SERN LED Ae A BP ED BO REE ei lee A

2928 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

filling it up. This was done after a consultation with General Roberts

and General Raymond, of the Army, and no details have been

made as to just how much sedimentation should take place; but

sufficient to satisfy whatever demand the United States Government

may make. Now, that is proper, so that those two things are out.

Then, thirdly, the sewage is not discharged at the shore, like that

of Jersey City, or New York and Brooklyn, but nearly one mile

from shore, and, for that reason, the effect of the New York sewage

going down along the piers, which is taken up by the same thread

of water, and where there is, an accumulation, instead of dispersion,

does not take place —it is out in the middle of the Bay, nearly a

mile from the shore.

The next point is that the sawage is discharged forty feet below

the surface. Now, that is a very important matter—in fresh water,

and, also, in salt water, You can readily see that when the sewage

is discharged down, far below the surface that, as fresh water, it

will rise in =alt water, it will rise up towards the surface if left alone,

and the surface gets quiescent. and it may be apparent there. This

is so in Boston: it is so in many other cities where they discharge

large bodies of sewage in salt water some distance below the surface.

Now, | do not know of any place where it is discharged as much

below the surface as it is intended to be here, nor in the way it is

intended to be, and as it ought te be, but my experience, T will

m1 sav a litt'e experience Thad in Honolulu helped me some-

what in this conclusion. The experience generally in Europe

has, as elsewhere, shown that this sewage will be dispersed as it

rises, the only question is, into how much water shall it go,—how

much sewage into hew much water, and, as a provisional only,

assume, for the case here, the same dilution that T recommended

to Chicago, which is provisional, knowing very well that this is salt

water and Lake Michigan is fresh water, but it gives a foundation,

and T am not certain as to just what is the actual best dilution

because there seems to be no eareful investigation on that subject

as vet. and it is not very simple or easy to make. For that, reason,

IT suggested a number of small outlets —think the number was four

hundred small outlets, to be placed unon this sewer, across the eur-

rent, so that the water, moving into the Hudson, and into the rivers

and Bay and out. would pass those openings and take from eae

one an amount of water just about equal to that which renders the

Chicago Sewage entirely inoffensive. Therefore, it was necessary

to issue the sewage in small amounts in small pipes, across the cur-

rent and, as the report which vou have shows this method has been

adopted by the present commission; it is a dispersion of the sewage

better. T think. we may say, than in any other city in the world

except possibly Hamburg: but that is a very small affair, and Is

not nearly so effective as this. although that is the best that coul

he done there.

In Hamburg. the sewage is sereened and settled the same as here

and is discharged into the Elhe across the current just a

52 is proposed here, with a number of small openings just as 8

proposed here, although there. perhaps, not so thoroughly

ae eee ae ee ee

ARN et AWE = ne wet i % PR Fi nw: P ‘. es

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2929

worked out as may be done in this ease under different and some-

what better conditions. There, what is the result? All of the Ham-

nN

it B burg sewage goes out there; vou don’t see it at the surface; ships go

it B back and forward over the place where, thirty feet down, the sewage

t. B isdischarged, at a depth of thirty feet; all the vessels pass there and

ut B ve no objectionable results in the water and the people are perfectly

le B atistied. The tide there is about six feet, it runs up and it runs

down, but IT don’t know how many, perhaps ten, miles below this

(ity, not more than ten miles below, in the current of the stream,

, B the City of Albany, a large City, with a large population, takes its

a Bvater supply out of the Elbe, into which the sewage of the City

of Hamburg has passed under the conditions described, it takes

y ff its water supply, filters it, and, at the time when the cholera was in

B Hamburg, when the cholera sewage went right into the river, there-

¢ B fore was taken up by the intake of the Albano water works, yet

there were no cases of cholera in Albano excepting those who drank

water In) Hammburg.—one of the most remarkable cases on record

in the world; they drank that water, and they drink that water

wday, and they do not object to it, and they do not think of getting

any other source,

Now, I believe. Mr. Chairman, that that is all I wanted to say

about the method of sewage disposal, which | thoroughly believe

is the best that can be made, and I only wish to say one

8 more thing: I hold the position of consulting engineer to

the Board of Estimate and Apportionment of New York

City and I would not for a moment allow myself to say a word which

would in any way affect the best interosts of New York City, and

[believe that there is no way to dispose of the sewage of our neigh-

bors that is better than the one that has been recommended.

Col. Knight: Will vou kindly go a little more into detail as to the

passage of this sewage backwards and forwards with the tide? How

far down stream would it go from your effluent there?

Mr. Hering: It would, naturally, go as far as the water of the

fiver would go during the incoming tide, and then it would go

tack and down as far as it would travel.

Col. Knight: Have you determined any limits in any of the re-

ports you have submitted?

Mr. Hering: No limits of distance, because it don’t seem to us

to be very essential, for this reason: that the sewage is diluted, so

that it is not feasible—I want to state one thing, please, which is a

proof demonstrative—to demonstrate just what I say, some might

ay, oh, that is all very good reasoning, and perhaps a good deal

if theory about it, and in these questions it is well to have a practical

demonstration, so I urged that a practical test be made. The Com-

mission consented, and we procured a barge containing about thirty

thousand gallons of fresh water, and representing sewage, and so

that we could see the same, we put into it enough red aniline

4M = dye to make it blood red, so that vou could see the coloring

plainly, well it was just like blood. Now, we went down

fo the point where it is proposed to discharge this sewage, this side

of Robins Reef, and at a time when the tide met,—that is, I wanted

930 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK YS.

to get there at such a time when the water was as quiet as possible

because then it is very clear, and it seemed to me that when the water

ran from four to five feet per second you would not see it very far

any way, so I wanted the water as quiet as possible. We therefore

discharged this thirty thousand gallons of adulterated water at the

time when the tide went least—the velocity was least, and we found

as follows: We found that when it was discharged ten feet below the

surface, you could very soon see this blood-red water at the surface;

naturally, that could be expected; the fresh water came up; it was

lighter than the salt water. Then we discharged it twenty feet

below the surface and we had to wait some time, and then it came

up, some of it, but very much dispersed and not so vivid. All the

rest of the water we discharged at thirty feet depth and although

we were around there over two hours we never saw anything at the

surface at all, not a thing of this red liquid.

That was a very crude experiment; it was really intended only

to see how it would act, in order to get some practical details, and

so the Commission consented to making that test with the expecta

tion of some day having a test made that might prove it more

thoroughly so as to be able to say that with this Passaic

5D Valley sewage. discharged out of a six inch pipe at a proper

depth, at presumably as nearly as possible the real conditions,

and the quantity, the width of water which was to dilute it would

be about the same as in this project, although the details have not

been studied out, as there has been no opportunity for doing it.

I merely want to say that this proved that this assumption is correct

in practice as well as in theory, although I do want to say that was

theory in a sense, not being actual sewage, but it is not speculation,

because it is not—there is enough evidence given here as to the

practice at Hamburg, Germany, as well as in our own country to

remove that from any charge of speculation whatever.

Col. Knight: Another question, Mr. Hering: As to the proportion

of solid matter in sewage, the proportion vou will remove by screen-

ing; the proportion that will still remain subject to sedimentation?

Mr. Hering: The proportion which can be screened out varies, of

course, with the size of the openings between the pores of the screen.

Now, very elaborate experiments were made in the sewers of Berlin

on the subject of screening and with different size mesh, and it was

found, with the ordinary screen, going down to about a centimetre in

opening—a centimetre is about a half inch, about a half inch open

ing in mesh you can get out more than fifteen per cent. of the

suspended matter, but you get out everything that is larger than

a half inch. The other suspended matter is very smal] and remains

in the water; it is what renders the waters dark, but it 8

56 so small!,—the partices are so smal] that they cannot be seen as

particles, their presence merely serving to darken the water.

More recently, experiments have been made with screens down toa

still smaller size, down to a millimetre in the size of the pores, and,

there, a much larger percentage was taken out, I believe about one

quarter, but the three-quarters remaining in the water corresponds iD

size and effect to what is in the water after a rain, causing the water

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2931

to look brownish; it is so small as to be almost impossible to screen

out with any contrivance of this sort we have been describing; it has

to be filtered out: but that would go through the screen, even down

toa millimeter size of mesh; but there is nothing, that amounts to

anything, in the sewage in a sewage system such as this we con-

template, that is not to take in, after it is completed, any storm water

or any surface water, which is objectionable, all the larger particles,

all that floats, has been taken out———

Col. Knight: You still have not touched the point, Mr. Hering,

you commenced in one particular, but you have not developed it;

wy idea was to get your idea of the proportion of solids to the amount

of sewage,—then the amounts removed by the different stages?

Mr. Hering: This is the figure we usually use; of course, our sew-

we is very much more dilute than that of Europe, and we must

take that Into account. We assume that there is one part of solids

in five thousand parts of water, about, But the solids are very

small: of course, everything that is solid is included in that.

57 But -ewage. vou know, consists of, we will say, organic matter

and mineral matter in about even parts and, together, they

mly amount to about one, that is, to about three or four parts of

water to one part of such matter in the sewage; that is the ordinary

house sewage, in that composition.

Col. Knight: Of that, vou will remove, by screens, then, fifteen

io twenty-five per cent?

Mr. Hering: Yes; and that means, that we would remove one

bundred per cent. of the matter that you would see floating.

Col. Knight: Then, what remains after the sedimentation? That

would also take out a stnall part of the grit that screening had not?

Mr. Hering: That would take out the greater part of the grit that

wreening kad not; that takes out the grit; whatever will deposit.

Now, that is a subject that has not been studied yet very much

Coi. Knight: I noticed you leave it vague.

Mr. Hering: It is left vague because it takes a great deal of study

and expense to find out those details; they simply have not been at-

tacked yet; it was the understanding, of course, of the Commission,

that whatever was necessary to be done would be done. Rough esti-

mates have been made: I cannot tell you just what those rough esti-

mates are, any more, but sufficient, I am quite sure, to cover what-

eer sediment would come in.

Col. Knight: And when the application is made for a per-

58 mit, it includes sedimentation, simply to include things that

may arise and have not been accurately determined yet?

Mr. Hering: This quantity is not accurately determined yet, but

the fact that sedimentation shall be there and the basins shall be

large enough to allow the velocity to be small enough so that matter

of a certain size will deposit—that has all been determined. You

ie aware, perhaps, that the matter carried in suspension by water,

given a certain velocity of the water, if you reduce the velocity, you

cause the suspended matter to be deposited; it is an entirely fixed

ratio.

Col. Knight: Well, the screening station here, the location of the

“932 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

pumping station, is right on the edge of the water? (Referring &

map. )

Mr. Hering: Yes.

Col, Knight: Now, where do you get any sedimentation basins—

(referring to map) where are they to be arranged for between that

point and the point of discharge?

Mr. Hering: It would be arranged above the pumping station—

the screening and gravity basin would be above the pumping sta-

tion

Col. Knight: So, your screens and gravity basins are away down

there (indicating on map)? They are supposed to be there (indi-

cating) before you come to the pumping station?

Mr. Hering: Yes. =ir.

Col. Knight: Now, just whereabout, in this route. where-

59 abouts ix that development—the commercial development

that the City of Newark proposes— the Canal?

Mr. Hering: 1 cannot tell vou that.

Col. Ruffner: | would like to ask you if you propose to do that

small] screening at all before vou reach the pumping station, or only

there?

Mr. Hering: Whatever screening i= necessary and whatever dis

position ix necessary to facilitate the pumping that i= to say. not to

injure the pumps, will, of course, be done at local stations, and all

that, of course, will again be -creened at the pumping station.

Col. Ruffner: That is. vou expect to do screening and sedimenta-

tion in each of those local stations, before you reach the pumping

station, and there also?

Mr. Hering: Yes; the screening and sedimentation at the pump

ing station will, of course, be on account of the pumps.

Col. Knight: It has been determined at Hamburg— that question

of sedimentation-—that question has been practically put in use at

Hamburg?

Mr. Hering: Yes, ir.

Col. Knight: Have you any idea as to the result-?

Mr. Hering: Well. the results are very good. of course. they must

dredge the rivers there; but, there i= no complaint whatever that I

could hear of that the sewage is silting up the channels there.

Col. Knight: But what do they remove? Do you know

60 anything about the proportion removed by sedimentation?

Mr. Hering: I cannot remember. They have a very «mall

settling basin there by screening all the large matter.

Col. Knight: That is all?

Mr. Hering: That is all I know. That is right at the screen.

Right at the screen ; the settling basin is only about as large as this

room (about $0 by 20*) but the system is only for the City of Ham-

burg.—the plant is not very large. That is all. And they get out

everything they think is necessary, and they are entirely satis

with the result=, and the shipping traffie which passes right over the

discharge points makes no complaint, and seems to have cause for

none.

i ae . ios i

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2933

Mr. Dean: Did T understand. Colonel Lockwood, that questions

might be asked after the completed statements?

The Chairman: After each individual, yes.

Mr. Dean: I would like to ask some questions of Mr. Harrison, as

» his statements, and of Mr. Hering, subsequently. I would like to

so into the details of this project——

Mr. Lebkuecher: Mr. Chairman, might we not be first heard

vere? There are here a number of representatives from the Passaic

Valley district, and we want to make a full expression of our case;

nany of them cannot remain here very long, and this questioning

can come later, if you please.

5 The Chairman: 1 think that might be as well—what do

you say, Mr, Dean?

Mr. Dean: It is entirely agreeabie to me, provided the gentlemen

hom I desire to question in order to obtain the details of this proj-

¢ecan be detained to answer those question= subsequently ”

The Chairman: Well, Mr. Lebkuecher, you can arrange that?

Mr. Lebkuecher: | understand Mr. Dean wishe- to question

Messrs, Harrison and Hering, and they will be here after the pre-

entation of our case.

The Chairman: Well, then, you may proceed,

Mr. Dunn: I have been obliged to give this subject considerable

wtention, both as a property owner in the Passaic Valley, as a tax-

waver in the Passaic Valley, and, as a lawyer, protecting our city

if Paterson, as its counsel, from attacks which riparian owners

ielow our city have found it necessary to make against the city in

der to cause it to desist from further discharging the sewage into

ind polluting the waters of the Passaic River. and, in consequence

fthat. 1 have also had occasion to give considerable study to this

abject in connection with the Passaic Valley “ewerage Commission,

thich was first organized in 1896 and, from that time down to the

wesent time, | have been in close touch with all their investigations,

ad know the work that they have been engaged in.

Now, the principal point, is seems to me, in addition to what has

heen stated to your board by the engineers here, to which

2 attention should be called, is this: Why is it necessary that

there should be an improvement of this kind in this Valley?

ind, who is it going to benefit?

Now. in the first place, I want to call your attention to the fact

that in this Valley is represented one-third of the taxable ratables

if the State of New Jersey. I want to call your attention to the fact,

mother important fact, that in this territory is represented one-

third of the population of the whole State of New Jersey; and I want

i) cal] your attention to another fact,—that there is no piece of

#zitory in the State of New Jersey to-day of such future, with such

i promise, with such an outlook for development, that the New-

wk Bay, the property around Newark Bay and the Passaic Valley

if we can only get this relief for which we are now seeking

nsent from your Board. Now, the reason for that follows: The

Pusaie River is an open sewer, and it has been an open sewer, and,

i consequence we must find some relief.

Ex. No. 1——3

=

~~ we OF

295 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

The City of Paterson, located as it is, at the upper end of this im-

provement, at the foot of the Great Falls, and the greater part of

this City, its residential section and its factories, located along the

River, as it winds through the City, is in such a situation to-day that

we almost have to come to you appealing for help, for this reason

The character of our soil and the topography of our ground is such

that there ix no land South of our territory available, and we cannot

go North because that is all up hill; there is no land lyi

63 South of our City as it lies, there is no land South at

available or suitable for sewage disposal work; there is no

land that we own East of the Passaic River, and that is in Bergen

County and in foreign territory.

We have been annoyed for a considerable time by these riparian

owners whose property was being disturbed, whose land was made

unsxalable principally because of the pollution we were discharging

from our factories and sewers into this River, and in 1901 ther

started suit for an injunction against the City; we resisted and de

fended ourselves against the suit—the litigation was prolonged in

consequence of this question, whether Paterson should be responsible

to riparian owners for the damage done to their property or for only

such proportion as was done by the discharge of the factory waste

and pollution through her sewers, the facet being that along the river

there are thirty-seven factories, dye houses, silk mills, locomotive

shops and so forth, giving employment to ten thousand men and

which discharge their sewage directly into the river; so that was the

main question, the main question of discovery before the Courts in

that litigation was as to the proportion of damage, and which ba

just resulted in a decree by Vice-Chancellor Stevens compelling us t

pay a sum amounting in round numbers in damages and costs, te

Thirty thousand dollars; in addition to that we have spent in the

neighborhood of Twenty thousand dollars in protecting and de

fending ourselves; and that injunction is against us, to take effect

by March 26th, 1911, that unless Paterson by that time

64 makes an honest effort in finding a way to dispose of the

sewage by March 26th, 1911, that injunction will issue,

unless the court of equity for good reason believe that such a0

honest effort has been made as in equitable terms may he so

then and in that event the City of Paterson will be liable to the

riparian owners in damages and compensation may be given

relief granted, so that we are now under mandate of the Court of

Chancery to get that sewage out of these waters and cease polluting

these waters by March 26th, 1911.

Now what else is our position The act of legislature which &

tablished the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission, creating it,

which has come before your Board with an application for the best

and only system for purifying this water, under which this applics-

tion is now made to your Board, that act provided that on December

12th, 1912, ali persons polluting the Passaie River from N

Bay up to the Great Falls should cease, and above the Great

the Passaic River or its tributaries, so that we have been inf

by the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission under that act that we

SEG EID DW POLI ED OO MSIF Ng IF BAI 8 Ie . — nee I

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2935

at within these provisions, so that even if the Court of Chancery

dould grant us an indulgence after March 26th, 1911, we would

dill be under the ban of that act, we would still be under the ban

ad both the courts and the sewerage commission, forcing us to get

vet of the river.

In addition to that, following along the banks of this river

6 is some of the most valuable and desirable property any-

wheres in the land is located, convenient for transportation,

for factories, if we could do what the City of Passaic has been able

w do for years, and we have not. Paterson has not been able to get

new industries into the City because we have never had a place

there their people and the factories could discharge their sewage

their efluence without being liable to suits from lower riparian

wwners, <0 that the Passaic people have been able to get in more

right along, and another important plant has just been located

there, to co=t a million and a half and to employ three thousand

hands, But since Paterson has consented to unite with this Passaic

Valley Sewerage Commission, what has happened to us? Right

here, across River Street bridge, right at this point (indicating on

map) there has been projected and is now being built a factory to

give employment to five hundred men, the factory costing Four hun-

dred thousand dollars, but this undertaking was located in our City

vith the precise understanding that we are to be able to get the

eonsent of the Commission——the Passaic Vallev Sewerage Commis-

am that they be permitied to discharge their sewage—their

@uence into the sewers.

Lam speaking of this merely as an example illustrating the great

future there will be for this district once we get a place where objec-

tonable effluence can be discharged into this sewer without doing

harm to the lower riparian owners. Now, why we should not have

this future I cannot understand. There is Newark being permitted

to develop all this territory in here (indicating on map).

% Why, just take New York as it is now and as it has been in

our time, and see how it has developed: You will remember

the time here, fifteen vears ago, vou couid readily buy practically

dl the land vou wanted, the upland here (indicating on map) for

tsong, now the price of land of every kind has gone up so that you

fannot buy it to-day, you can get a lease, or take more than you

vant to put into it, and coming down along Newark Bay here (in-

ing) vou can hardly get dockage.

What is proposed here is to improve the great ‘territory lying

around Newark, available and suitable for such purposes. Here is

Newark, with all her thousands of acres of land here (indicating)

kept undeveloped. Why, I have been informed that at the Clark

Works, the stench from the river is such in warm weather

that they have had to allow their employes to go home, although

they have kept the windows closed on warm days. And at Passaic,

in the filtration works, Mr. Gardiner, of the Water Company, has

wld me that the stench is such in the afternoons that they had to

tse down the works.

Now, then, we ask you if, in view of these facts, in view of the

oo es

I 8 OEE lS

_. me fd US ae, OS... OM B_e_de ee eee, eed

ee ee Ee eee ee

2936 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

fact that here is the city of Paterson obliged to pay Thirty thousand

dollars in damages to those riparian owners because their property

hax been made unsalable, because sickness and ill-health has been

produced in families and children, ax testimony adduced there

proved, because other people down along this shore are complain

ing of this nuisance, can it be said that this great benefit should

be withheld from this great valley?

Now, then, another point that | think probably it would

not be improper for me to make adversion to.

I understand that there are some people in the State of New York

who entertain the opinion that they ought to object to this improve

ment—who have entertained the notion that this improvement

ought to be objected to; just why, Ido net know. We are neighbor

and we should be neighborly, but there is an impression among cer-

tain men that they always ought to be appearing ax objectors to any

improvement going on.

Now, it seems to me that they ought not to take New York City.

Brooklyn,—Greater New York as a pattern and come before thi

Board, representing the Federal Government, and make an ol jection

to an improvement which means so much to the public health of all

of our State, and which means so much to the industrial develop

ment of the territory there when they stand right here discharging

raw sewage and street sewage right into the waters of the Bay.

But they say, “Oh, well, you ceded to the State of New York, the

right to exercise dominion over the waters of this Bay and the waters

of New York Harbor, and, therefore, New York people, and thee

who are responsible, are entering complaint, and you must come

consult them before you can build an improvement of that kind in

the Bay”. Now, in a word, to an-wer these objections, let me simply

say this: I have given considerable study, careful study and investi-

gation to those suggestions, and, in the first place, I say that

6s the position which the State of New York takes upon the

question of nuisance is settled ly the cas2 of the State of Mis

souri against the State of Illinois in the case of the Chicago Drainage

Canal. The Supreme Court of the United States has just rendered a

decision and has said to the State of Missouri, “so long as you

your cities continue to pollute the waters of the Missi=-ippi River,

you do not stand in court with clean hands and until such time #

you can prove that the evil of which you are complaining is pre

duced alone by the Chicago Drainage Canal, you have no standing in

equity.”

Now, where does the State of New York stand, in equity, wid

clean, or dirty, hands, in making an application against New Jersey.

for an injunction against the State of New Jersey, because it may

happen to pollute the waters of the Bay, according to our engineers

not in a lifetime, not in the lifetime of any of us and not in centurie

with the present growth of population, will the Bay be incapable of

taking care of the sewage from the population, as stated by Mr.

Hering, and which all engineers have conceded is correct. So that,

they will say to the State of New York that it ix premature in tryig

67

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2937

to have the Supreme Court of the United State= imagine there is a

nuixance there, of which they cannot alduce any proof,

The City of Newark applied for an injunction against the City of

Passaic, in 1SS2:they wanted to build a sewer =ystem in ISS2Z, and the

City of Newark was getting its water supply there and she very prop-

erly thought that when the City of Passaic, with sewerage from a

population of thirty thousand, would render the water unfit by

a9 pollution. Now, what did she do? She went into the Court

of Chancery and asked the court of chancery to grant an in-

junction, but the Court said, “no; that is not a principle of equity to

enter at) injunction in the ease until such time as you prove the

nuisance, until the injury is shown, we will held off our hands and

f after such a time if it is found they are committing a nuisance

there and do not abate it or modify it so that it ceases to be a nui-

ance. then the Court may act.” So that the same principle invoked

by the New Jersey court is applicalile to the case here.

Just a word more: In saving that this great amount of money

should he applied—the City of Paterson, in order not to he tied fast

to any proposals of this very Commission and their very able engi-

neers —there was a feeling among our people that the cost of our

apportionment of over Two million dollars was very heavy, consid-

ting that our total ratables at that time were fifty-eight thousand,

aithongh mere new, being some ninety-two thousand.—that appor-

tionment was made also seven vears ago, and it was simply submitted

to our people as a basis to work on, and the feeling was that every

efort should he made to secure the very best results for the amount

involved. and so we had Mr. Allen Hazen make a study and investi-

ettion of this whole subject and recommend to that City what was

in his judgment, what was the most feasible, economical and prae-

tieal and effective plan to adopt, and he recommended—he had

studied the whole subject. both in this country and abroad,

70 and he said that the plan which seemed to him as the one best

plan was to erect a rock dam, across the river, in Dundee

County and there install a sewage disposal plant, and he recom-

mended that we immediately buy there five hundred acres of land

and clear it up, right over the river here (indicating on may) South

of this line, right in that (indicating) territory there which might

he used for a disposal works. But there was no law in the State of

New Jersey that permitted the City of Paterson or any other munic-

ipality to do this or allowed them to go out of their own territory

and erect a disposal works. So, we went to the Legislature ia the fol-

lowing Winter, and we presented to them the matter in full. includ-

ing all of the recommendations, and the Legislature passed a law

thus far: “We will grant to Paterson, or any municipality in New

Jersey, permission to build a separate sewage disposal plant provided

there he no objection on the part of the authorities in the territory

in which the work is to be performed or from other persons having

aright there at present.”

We subsequently consulted with the authorities in Dundee

County, and they said: “No, you cannot put up any out-house on our

ground : we won't let you destroy a lot of land here”,—and Mr. Hazen

2938 THE PROFLE GF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

says the smell, in his experience, would affect the value of land

within a considerable radius of the disposal works, and so, as I say,

we cannot build a separate dispoxal work on our own lands. and we

we cannot get land on which to build it, and so we ssid, let us gow

the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission and say “We want

71 to join you, join with vou and our other sister ietpalite

here in trying to develop the resources of this territory and

protecting the public health,” and I subunit to vou, gentlemen that

view of the great benefit that is coming frem it. in protecting the

public health, developing property. improving the condition of ach

4 proportion of the population of the State and therehy inerem

ing taxes and building up t commerce of the country. and in viet

of the evidence that navigation is not likely to be interfered with by

the i ement, that vou will net withhold vour approval.

Mr. Lebkuecher: 1 underciand fully that it is net necoary to

lain to these gentlemen or this Reard that a nuisance exists in the

ic Valley ——

The Chairman: It is within the personal knowledge of moa of

the members of the Board ——

Mr. Lebkuecher: Rut I would like to have Mr. East wood, being

the representative of one of the Boards of Trade along the River

Mir. Rastwood: Mr. Chairman and Members of the Roard, | am

neither an engineer nor a lawyer, but a plain business man, a fet

dent of the Township of Belleville on the hanks of the Vinee

River.—horn and raised up there. I can remember when the Po

«aie River was one of the most beautiful stream in this country,

perfect in every respect, its waters of the utrnest purity, drank ty the

citizens of Jersey City and Newark. Some veare age loth of there

large corporations were compelled te discontinue the use a

the Passic Valley. We are now losing « certain amount of ou

population along the hanks of this river. Our manufactaring iter

ets are at a standstill, that is, as “ar a* any increase in 1

fought out for many years. +I believe T am one of t

adopted or advocated, rather, the trank sewer. A number

SOO OE en _ ~ oe

a A

Or ee ee ee Se Ee,

THE *TATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2939

have heen lost to the people of Passaic Valley by securing proper

legielation and by ascertaining the question - ag to the

people up to a paint where such a thing is possible.

1 wast «av that J, with great pleasure listened to the gen-

730s Hleman whe «poke lat; it wae an eloquent moment to have

Paterson come before thix Board and advocate the adoption

of this trumk sewer and the granting of the application t your

Board to deposit this sewage in New York Bay ; it is a great pleasure

wevery gentleman who has been interested in this project <ince rts

Now, in our little town, right ahowe the City of Newark, North

of that City, we are in a terrible condition, Not only has property

depreciated in value. taut it has had a tendency to drive people away

fram the River, for we cannet keep our property in proper comd:-

fen. Anvone visiting that tewn will notice the condition of the

hwuwes there: there ix not a house there (day in respectable con-

dition as far as paint ix concerned: it makes no difference if vou

paint the heuse= three or four times a vear, the gases arixing from

that river take the color out of the paint right away, so that every

house there looks ax theagh it had not had « touch of paint for

twenty vears, T merely tate that te show the condition of the

mosphere. That is why wo are here tolay, on behalf of the

Roard of Trade. of the first ditrict of the Passaic Valley Sewerage

Commission. axking for thix application and for relief, and we think

that under the circumstances, that while the City of New York and

the City of Brooklyn are placing their sewerage in this Bay, that

the State of New Jersey ought to have. if it does net, the same mght

in this Bav.—it <heuld have an equal privilege.—if they are putting

thc incubus inte the Raw im its raw «tate, we should have the right

here applied for. ax if it be met granted it will work the prac-

74 tieal destruction of eur community,

Mr. Sherrard: Mr. Chairman, and Members of the Beard,

lonly want to «peak of this question from the standpoint of the City

of Newark. that city, a* vour Beard knows, is already committed

w the large «heme of a deep water harber and deck improvements

on Newark Ray, and we know that with the crowded conditions of

the New York Tlarbor will lving this portion of the City of Newark

very much to the front, and alse all of Newark Bay. and it seem to

w as we have looked at this project—I think the Chairman asked

® to ite location—the location ix about four thousand feet to the

South of where the tunne! and sewer pumping station: t located on

this map (indicating).

Now, the proposition of coare screening and the provision for

edimentation, on this large project, would. in my judgment, relieve

the Passaic River and Newark Ray of a good deal of the present

Seat Ah tee Cae 0 ee hen, Go mmienel bad

paint alone, as has heen shown by Mr. Harrison. this continual hold-

ing hack of the flow of the river causing a deposit in the Ray. ix «

detriment to navigation. std the pumping out of this portion of the

dodge in the «ewer will to that extent be an improvement in the

2940 THE PROPLE OF THE *TATE OF NEW YORK Va.

condition of navigation in that vicinity—of Newark and of Ne

York Harbor.

Mr. Lebkuecher: The Mayor of Paterson ix here and will hand a

a paper, which he would like to form a part of the record of thi

Mr. MeBiride: Mr. Chairman, and Gentlemen: | do oa

reo propose te take up your time, but 1 would like to present the

. for your record;

(Mr. MeBride here presented the following paper):

“The City of Paterson, in the vear 1868, hegan the contruction

of sewers discharging inte the Pae<aie Kiver. Thi< action was takes

under the autherity of an act of the Legislature of the State of New

Jersey entitled “An A\ct te Nwtherize the Con-truction of Sewers and

Drains in the City of Paterem.” approved February 26, 1868,

At that time. the only methed of sewage diepexal in use in the

country was that adepted tw thi< City. namely. the discharge d

sewage inte ronning water, Such action wae taken in good faith

with the belief that thix City had a leual rial «0 te de. and that it

was the het and only method wherely the public health and pable

interest~ could he <ubser ed.

With the advance of time. of sanitary knowledge. and increase

population. it was found by the City of Paterson in consequent

thereof. that <uch dixcharge of «wage inte a river of the ize of the

Pasaic. was inevitably the cause of a public nuisance. From the

nuisance the City of Paterson. through it- di<charge of «uch sewage,

has it<elf suffered more than any of its neighbers.

As long age as the vear 1894 the attention of thix City was called

to the then existing conditions of nuixance. bw the local Board

76 of Health. Thie City was then called upon te defend itelf

against the charge. that it was the chief cause of the pollution

of the Pasaic River. This the City denied. and denies now.

Tn our opinion, the chief <ufferer from our own pollution is the

City of Paterson iteelf, and net our neighbors below. We firmlr

believe that the Passaic River has sufficient volume and diluting

capacity te care for the sewage of Paterom alone. without couing

a unquestionably depreciated the value of property contig

“The initial step taken by those realizing these condition

o~ — 2 Re Eee -

ers & = a ee ee i i al

bt |

THE *TATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2941

into any river, stream, lake or pond. This, the City of Paterson,

through it official representative-, strongly opposed, and as a means

of preventing the passage of suels an act. which would be mest inim-

val to the interests of the City, proposed in lieu thereof, that inas-

woch ax practically all the communities bordering upon the Passaic

River were lly guilty. that they should combine and unite their

interests. and jointly act in such a way a= to remove such nuisance

and purify «sid river. Official representatives of this City, there-

fore. were Texponsible for the preparation, the passage and the «ign-

ing of the bill, passed by the Legidature February 26, 1896, and

agned bw our respected fellowtown-man, Governor Griggs.

Purmant to thie Act, Governor Griggs appointed, on April 21,

1806, as a commission. our late rexpected fellow-townsman, Dr. Elias

1. Marsh. and Dr, 1. C. 1. Herold and William T. Hunt, Eaq., of

Newark: a better selection than which, from any standpoint, could

not peomitly have been made.

This Commision reported. on February 26, 1897. said report, in

brief being that the interests of the various municipalities horder-

ing on the Paseaic River below the Great Falls, were identical, and

that it was to the interest of each and every one of these municipal:-

tie to unite with the others in a manner, namely. a joint

7 ottrunmk «ewer, to diepese of their sewage and prevent the exist

ing nuisance by the discharge of <aid <ewage into tidal water-.

Thix investigation has heen continued ap to April 1998. In the

work have heen engaged the most eminent engineers known to the

profexion im thie country. The mere mention of their names i«

ample proof of the previous -tatement. namely:

Col. George EF. Waring.

Alphonse Feeley,

Charles EF. A. Jacobson,

Rodelph Hering.

Jame~ Owen.

Colin R. Wise,

Robert M. Watson,

William Ferguson.

1.4. R. Crome,

William M. Brown,

Gen. Henry M. Roberts, U.S. A.

Lient. Col. C. W. Raymond, U.S. A.

9 _ The work of two of these gentlemen was done entirely

in the intere-t« of the City of Paterson: one. Mr. Gray, being

engaged and paid by an organization of the citizens of Paterson,

ic ek ie AAAS tart A Ae AO Ci AA BC re GS CBE ARTE nal at inate De at att IP Oe

2942 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

desiring the good of the City; the other, Mr. Hazen, being engaged

and paid by the City officially.

All of these engineers mentioned, who have studied the problem

and become acquainted with the conditions and requirements in the

Passaic Valley, have agreed

(1) That a public nuisance existed.

(2) That such nuisance should be abated.

(3) That it was to the interests, economically and from a prac

tical point of view, to each and every municipality bordering upon

the Passaic River below the Great Falls, to unite and work jointly

to accomplish the abatement of this nuisance.

The question presented to the City of Paterson is purely a bus-

ness one. The law of March 18, 1907. forbids this City to discharge

its sewage, unpurified, into the Passaic River, after December 12,

1912.) By an agreement, made through its official representatives,

with the Court of Chancery, since contirmed by an opinion of said

Court, the City of Paterson has been ordered to cease such pollution

on March 26, 1911.

The City is therefore hound in honor, in law, and by the man-

dates of the Court of Chancery, to cease polluting, by its sewage,

the Passaic River, on March 26, 1911.

The proposition, therefore, before the City, was whether

80 this result could best be accomplished by uniting with the

other municipalities bordering on the Passaic River below the

Great Falls, or by the building of a local sewage disposal system

by the City itself.

As has already been stated, the eminent engineers who have given

this matter their consideration and study, the universal opinion

has been that the most economical and best way to accomplish the

desired results was by union or by united efforts. All these en-

gineers, except Mr. Gray and Mr. Hazen, have considered the in-

terests of the District as a whole, and not the =pecial interests of the

City of Paterson. Mr. Gray and Mr. Hazen considered the inter-

ests of the City of Paterson alone, as distinct from those of the

District, and reported on the advisability and the cost of local dis

posal systems.

Mr. Gray estimated the cost of a local disposal system for Pater-

son, at $2,670,185, such system being for the disposal of 25 million

gallons of sewage daily.

The report of the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners, under

date of April 20, 1908, gives a capacity for the carrying away of the

sewage of Paterson to the amount of 63,952,300 gallons per day,

at an estimated cost to Paterson of $2,008 425.28,

Mr. Hazen (in whom this City has the greatest confidence, both

as a man and as an engineer) was employed solely in the interests of

this City. and gives an estimate of the cost of a sewage disposal

plant at $3,028,190. In his report he advises as follows:

81 “In view of all the facts and circumstances as I have found

them, and upon the supposition that a full, just and lawful

arrangement with the other municipalities upon the Passaic River

is reached, acceptable to the Legislature and to the Governor, I

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2943

believe that the interest of Paterson will be best served by joining

with other municipalities in the construction of a trunk sewer to

take the sewage from the entire district requiring sewage disposal

facilities in the Lower Passaic Valley to a point of adequate sea-

water dilution in New York or in Newark Bay near the Kill von

Kull.

“I believe that this arrangement will be substantially better for

Paterson than the separate local purification of her sewage.”

Both the scientific and the economic side of this question have

been most thoroughly studied, considered and approved by a Com-

mittee of the Taxpayers’ Association of this City,—an Association

without any motive except the preservation and advancement of the

interests of the City, composed of citizens whose only incentive is

dvie pride and whose only object is the interests of the City in

which they were born or lived.

Said Committee, after their investigation and study, reported as

follows:

“We recommend that Paterson join with the City of Newark and

other municipalities in an effort to secure the disposal of sewage

by discharging it into the sea without treatment, other than screen-

ing.

The Special Committee appointed by me, the function of

% which was to advise the officials of Paterson upon the subject

of the most economical, the most scientific and the best

method for the disposition of the sewage of Paterson, after a most

thorough and exhaustive study of the work already done, and after

personal investigation of the subject sufficient to satisfy themselves

of the justice and right of their conclusions, reported in part as

follows :

“That we have fully investigated the subject of sewage disposal

and are unable to find any system of local disposal that would be

applicable to the City of Paterson, and that, owing to the date set

by the Court of Chancery, namely, March 26th, 1911, limiting the

time of our use of the river as a sewer, it is necessary that we take

ome action without further delay.

“Therefore we are of the opinion, that in order to comply with

the order of the Court of Chancery and of the General Sewerage

Act of 1907, pertaining to the discharge of the sewage of the Passaic

Valley Sewerage District, limiting our period for the discharge of

sewage into the river, that this City should enter into a contract with

the other municipalities of the Passaic Valley Sewerage District,

and with the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners, with the

understanding that the City may withdraw if the cost of the pro-

posed trunk sewer exceeds the present estimate of $12,200,000.00,

rine our share for the securing of working plans, estimates and

ids,

“We therefore recommend, that the Mayor and Board of

8 Finance be authorized to sign such contract as proposed by

the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission, and that this City

pay its share for the preparation of working plans and estimates

2944 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8,

and the securing of bids, leaving, however, the ultimate question

of the joining in the trunk sewer plan to future developments,”

The Board of Finance, acting upon the above recommendation,

resolved unanimously to enter into a contract with the Passaic

Valley Sewerage Commission and the other municipalities inter.

ested, for joint action in the disposition of their sewage.

The City of Paterson is therefore of the opinion that its best

interests can only be subserved by union with the other municipal:

ities of the Passaic Valley and the joint discharge of their sewage

into tidal waters.

At the present time, the sewage of Paterson is discharged above

the Dundee Dam and above the tidal waters of the Passaic River.

This sewage is carried down and is now discharged through the

Lower Passaic River, Newark Bay and the Kill von Kull, into New

York Bay.

The joint action of the various municipalities contemplated does

not increase this discharge of sewage but simply provides for the

collection of such sewage as will, under existing conditions, inevita-

bly be so discharged, and its discharge at another point in New

York Bay.

The interests of our City demand, in our opinion, a joint system

of sewage disposal for the Passaie Valley.”

Mr. Lebkuecher: Now, gentlemen, | do not think it is necessary

for us to call any more. perhaps, of the people who are here at your

invitation——

84 Col. Knight: There is one thing,—these gentlemen who

have been called might be requested to remain until oppor

tunity has been given for such questions as the opposition may wish

to ask.

Mr. Lebkuecher: I will arrange for that,—I have already asked

them to remain.

Mr. Heck, ef the Jersey City Board of Trade, would like to addres

the Board in behalf of the application,

Mr. Heck: I only wish to say that, on behalf of the Board of

Trade of Jersey City, and not only do | appear as a member of that

Board, but as one of its Board of Directors, a few, a dozen or more,

of whom are here—that that Board has carefully considered the

plans of the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission and are in hearty

accord with all that the Commission has determined and are sup-

porting it fully; that we know the present conditions, that has ll

hecp said and that is about all to be said; we could only reiterate

what has already been said. We think it is an improvement, that

would affect Jersey City materially, as well as Newark Bay. A good

portion of our City is bounded by Newark Bay,—the upper portion,

by the Newark Bay and the Hackensack; it would also be an ir

provement to Jersey City flats and Bayonne Neck, and we think this

matter of sedimentation and sewage in the Passaic Valley and New-

arn bay ought to be aone and as speedily as possible.

I am the representative, also, of owners of land in the lower por

tion of Jersey City, in the neighborhood of this project and now i

= -_, —_2 =e G&G fe? >

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2945

the way, will have to be applied to personally for privileges,

6 and I can say, personally, as representing eighteen or twenty

acres, that we will in no way interfere with the project but

hail it, and we thoroughly advocate the adoption, or, at least, the

wnsent of your Board to the privileges now sought for.

Mr. Payne: | am here, representing the Riparian Commission of

the State of New Jersey, simply in answer to the invitation of this

Board, and I have nothing to say in addition to what has been so

ably said.

The Riparian Commission is intrusted with the improvement and

ale of its riparian lands, and anything that would enhance or raise

their value is, of course, in line with their duties, and they feel sure

that the Commission in the direction of this important work, are

itending to it properly, and [ have nothing further to add.

Mr. Lebkuecher: I do not think it is necessary to call anv more

idvecates after the presentation that has already been made: there

sonly one thing T would like to add, and that is,— when this proj-

at of discharging the Passaic Vallev sewage into New York Bay

ms first brought forward by the engineers employed by the Passaic

Valley Commissioners, we, as commissioners were uncertain as to

whether that was the proper thing to do, and we were told by the

agineers and assured that it would cause no pollution whatever.

The question also came up, advanced by other people in the State,

iid the Legislature passed an Act that we should first find out, and

get the best information possible as to whether there would

% be any injury in New York Bay. by reason of this discharge,

if discharged as proposed, after screening and sedimentation,

In pursuance of that Resolution of the Legislature, the Commis-

dners got the opinion of a number of experts from the Army Board,

nd we have here (( handing the Chairman a paper) our report,

aving the opinion of General Henry M. Robert, Lieut. Col. C. W.

Raymond, and C. 8. Greene Jr., Civil Engineer, and T would like to

abmit it as accompanying our application,

If there are any questions to be asked, these gentlemen are ready

o be interrogated.

Mr. Dean: The State Commissioner of Health, Dr. Porter is here,

ind says he will have to catch a train back to Albany—

The Chairman: Dr. Soper was going to address the Board—

Dr. Soper: Mr. Chairman, if you will hear those who are down on

programme when their names are called, they can make their

rmarks—the questions might come afterwards—otherwise a num-

ler of people here | know want to go out of town and it is impos-

ible for them to come back, and they will not have an opportunity

o be heard.

Mr. Dean: It is absolutely necessary for me to ask certain ques-

tons, to cross-examine, some of these witnesses for the reason that

they have not given certain details it is necessary to have in order to

understand the nature of their application entirely—

sv Mr. Riker: IT do not think there should be a eross-examina-

tion of our witnesses; there is a litigation pending between

the State of New York and the State of New Jersey, before the Su-

2948 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Ys.

preme Court of the United ©<.es, and I understand that the gentle.

man who is on his feet represents the State of New York, and I do

not think that the witnesses on behalf of the State of New Jersey, if

he so terms them, should be subjected to a cross-examination, and |

think nothing should be asked of those witnesses except what is

actually germane to the subject-matter before this Commission, |

do not think there should be a fishing excursion for evidence against

the State of New Jersey.

Mr. Dean: Mr. Chairman, I am not on a fishing expedition; I

want to find out what is going to become of this sewage. I wish to

find out what the specifications of this Commission consist of? As

the representative of the State of New York I believe we have the

right to find out whether this sewage ix going to interfere with the

navigation of this harbor. It is true that the United States Gov-

ernment has the primary right over the navigable waters of this

State, but the law is well-settled that the State of New York. or anv

State in which are navigable waters, has a secondary right, and that

is what we wish to invoke, and it is for that purpose that I want to

bring definitely to a head just what this screening chamber, this

gravity chamber is to consist of,—wihat is the size of the dispersion

area, and the size of the solid matter in suspension, and how

SS it will affect navigation with reference to the largest of the

big ships which enter this harbor, representing investments

of millions of dollars, and, consequently, the ecommerce of this State

and City.

The Chairman: You only want the engineers?

Mr. Dean: Yes, sir.

Dr. Soper: Every one of these men (referring to names on list)

may go out before Mr. Dean, or one of your Board has put questions

to the engineers with regard to this matter.

Mr. Miller: I have no especial status here, except as I represent

the Department of Justice, and I did not wish to interrupt the presen

tation of the case by the proponents, in order to ask certain questions

as to the bearing of the application with reference to that Depart-

ment, and I am perfectly willing to wait and suit the convenience of

this Board. I want to know, on behalf of the Department of Jus

tice what effect this will have upon commerce and navigation, and,

of course, that can be brought out iy other methods. 1 do not want

to ask any questions, and I therefore hope that the gentleman rep-

resenting the State of New York will bring out such information a

desired, of course, subject tc the right of New Jersey to answer or not.

The Chairman: Mr. Miller, this Board has been deputed to hold

this hearing, and they are men who have had experience in this sort

of work for a good many years. I think the mind of the Board is

pretty well made up as to what information they want. We want

the information covered by the endorsement of the Chief of

89 Engineers in sending this matter to us. I do not like the

idea of bringing in technical matters, if it can be avoided—

What is the sense of the Board? Shall we give Mr. Dean an op-

portunity to proceed to cross question the witnesses——

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2947

Col. Knight: I do not like the word cross question or cross-ex-

unine; | should prefer the word “question.”

(The sense of the Board—after a moment's discussion. )

The Chairman: You may proceed, Mr. Dean, to question the

geakers who have made their presentation.

Mr. Dean: | would really prefer to let the other speakers get

through, and then ask such questions as | may

The Chairman: Then that may be done.

Dr. Soper: Mr. Harrison has made the chief remarks of a tech-

nical nature, and described what was intended by the Passaic Valley

sewerage Commissioners.

I will not attempt to reply to many of the statements which he

wade, although I am very strongly tempted to do so. I am sure

that some of the fallacies which have been fallen into and stated by

Mr. Harrison, will appeal to others who will speak here before your

Col. Knight: But, Dr. Soper, please do not give us anything by in-

direction: If you have anything to criticize or to comment upon in

aperson’s statement, if he has made, in your opinion, an error, please

refer to that error directly.

w) Dr, Soper: 1 would call attention, as one error, to the fact

‘that the disposition of sewage in the New York Bay, and its

dict, has been largely based upon the observed effects of the dis-

weal of sewage into fresh water, and to state that the effects, particu-

arly with regard to sedimentation of solid matters in salt water and

in fresh water, are quite different.

Ihave an exhibit here to offer in that connection. Sewage sludge

has boen mixed with fresh water in one bottle and an equal quantity

df sewage sludge with salt water in another; the bottles have been

illowed to stand, in this case, one hour; the clearer bottle shows the

diect in salt water, where the sewage sludge is deposited much more

mpidly than in fresh (Referring to photograph of exhibits men-

toned). In this case (referring to separate photograph) the exhibit

dows the effect of three hours’ standing.

Col. Knight: Have you any volumetric determination as to the

mount of dispersion?

Dr. Soper: None has been reached.

Col. Knight: This is merely a question of experience?

Dr. Soper: A question of experience.

Attention is called also to the fact that the specific arrangement

for sreening and settling and discharging the sewage are not given

in the report, and have not been given by any of the gentlemen who

tave spoken here this morning.

You are requested to form an opinion on the statement that the

necessary works will be constructed. The Metropolitan

Sewerage Commiseion has requested of the Passaic Valley

Commissioners informatien on this point and has been no

nore able to get it than your Board has this morning.

The rest of my remarks, for the sake of accuracy, and to econo-

hve time, will be read; and are:

‘The Metropolitan Sewerage Commission is an official body

tl he

2948 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.

created by the State of New York to investigate and report on means

for permanently protecting and improving the sanitary condition of

the waters of New York harbor and vicinity. Its report is to be

made by May, 1910 (Do you hear me, Mr. Harrison) ?

The present hearing is not a suitable occasion for extended diseus

sion of the sanitary aspects of the Passaic Valley sewer, but this com

mission desires to make a few remarks upon the possible injurie

which may result to navigation if the Passaie Valley project w cr

ried out,

Although possessing certain novel features, the Passaie Valley

project is not altogether new. Nearly thirteen vears ago legislation

was secured in New Jersey looking to a general system of sewerage

for the sanitary improvement of the Passaic Valley, and this projet

has been urged in some form ever since. For the last seven year,

at least, it has been proposed to collect all the sewage of the Passaic

Valley district and discharge it without purification into New York

harbor. The question whether injury would be done to the harker

if the Passaic Valley sewer was allowed to discharge crude sewage

into these waters has been the subject of several invests

92 tions. In 1903 the Passaic Valley Commission was required

by the New Jersey legislature to investigate whether the pro

posed outfall was likely to cause a nuisance to persons or property

within the State of New York. On that occasion favorable reports

were secured from a number of prominent engineers and, with the

advice of the Attorney General and Governor of New Jersey the

project was allowed to proceed.

Earlier than this the Harbor Line Board made an inquiry a t

whether the discharge of the sewage would injure navigation. M

that time it was proposed to discharge the sewage of the Passaic Val

ley into Newark Bay at a point about twenty-two hundred feet above

the bridge of the Central Railroad of New Jersey. The Board &

amined this project and made an adverse report upon it under date

of May 28, 1897. The Board summarized its opinion in the follow

ing words: “It is easy to see that it will require only a few years te

make the proposed sewer system not only a public nuisance buts

serious obstruction to the navigable waters adjacent to the harber of

New York.”

In 1903 the Legislature of the State of New York created the New

Yark Bay Pollution Commission to investigate the threatened pollu-

tion of the waters of New York Bay and vicinity. One of the recom

mendations of the Pollution Commission ix especially worthy of a

tention at this hearing. The Pollution Commission pret

against the execution of the plan to discharge the crude sewage of the

Passaic Valley into New York bay and advised the Governor of New

York that in the event of the Passaic Valley Commissioners

93 pressing the construction of their works, action be brought im

the Supreme Court of the United States against the State of

New Jersey and the Passaic Valley District Sewerage Commissione™.

So far as the proposed plan for diffusing the Passaic Valley s%

age through the tidal waters can be comprehended, it gives inad-

equate assurance that the sewage will be immediately diffused and

_. & me =F

i ae ee | | i

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2949

ligersed. Diffusion and dispersion are phenomena which, as re-

ited t» the discharge of sewage into harbor waters, are not «ufli-

cently understood to be within the range of exact engineering con-

wi, Experience shows that the discharge of large volumes of

erage into a natural body of water generally produces evil conse-

quences in the vicinity and that the extent of these evils increases

wore rapidly than the quantity of sewage.

The Passaic Valley scheme bears a certain resemblance to works

thich carry the sewage of Boston and its neighboring municipal-

tie into Boston harbur, and it ix understood that the experience

d Boston has guided the Passaic Valley Commissioners in making

‘wir plans, Tlaving visited Boston and seen the outfalle in that

venity the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission has no hesitancy

nexpresing the opinion that the conditions in Boston harbor

dual not he duplicated in New York hay.

Freedom from evil effects connot be urged on the ground that

mt and large solid particles will be removed before the sewage is

ieharged. The amount of harm which might result would not

be confined to the channels near the sewer outfall. In places

4 remote from the mouths of sewers the bottom of New York

harbor ix already covered with accumulations of fine black

material which it has been impossible to distinguish from sewaye

‘udge. The United States Government has removed thousands of

abie yards of this material from Ambrose Channel.

The evil results which would follow the deposit of ~ewage matters

athe channels would not be restricted to the mere cost of dredg-

uo The interference which vessels might experience from the

peence of dredging machines should also be considered. In this

wanection it should be remembered that the proposed outfall works

wuld be located in the land-locked part of ¢ Teter on the edge

tthe main ship channel, and consequently in the direct path of

tel bound in and out of New York, Newark Bay, the Kill van

and close to the path of the Municipal ferry between Man-

wwttan and Staten Islands.

The need of affording adequate sewerage facilities for the rapidly

owing municipalities in the vicinity of New York City, and the

wpertance of keeping the river tributaries clean are fully recog-

wed lw the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission, But the practice

fanitating inland municipalities at the expense of the harbor is

avise, There ix a limit to the quantity of filth which these waters

nil tolerate and which the public will consent to have floating about.

igation has shown that portions of the harbor already receive

maze in excess of their capacity to assimilate in a harmless and

inoffensive manner. It is the opinion of the Metropolitan

Sewerage Commission that the discharge of sewage into these

_ Waters should be restricted to such municipalities and dis-

Mets adjacent to the buy as cannot otherwise dispose of their sewage

at prohibitive cost.

present project of the Passaic Valley Commissioners is not

te only practicable way of handling the sewage of the Passaic Val-

Ex. No, 1——4

A —aineeeatarm saree eer =

2950 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OY NEW YORK V8.

ley. It is feasible to purify the sewage of the twenty or more mo.

nicipalities concerned by public works constructed for that purpos.

The cost of constructing and operating works to purify the sewage

of the whole Passaic Valley would not be materially greater than

the cost of constructing and operating the works under the plan

posed, with their grit chambers, screens, pumping station and

tunnel under Newark Bay, the Bayonne Veninsula and New

York bay. If such purifying works were built a harmless and in

offensive effluent could be discharged into Newark bay in place of

discharging the raw <ewage as now proposed in a more or less putre

fying condition into New York bay.

It is the opinion of the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission that

the discharge of sewage in the manner and in the quantities pro

posed by the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners would be det

rimental to the interests of navigation and that this project should

be opposed by all who desire to see New York harbor maintained in

a clean and unobstructed condition.

Mr. Dean: Dr. Porter, the State Conwnissioner of Health—

Col. Knight: Before Dr. Porter speaks,—Mr. Soper, you

96 spoke of some parts of New York bay being already polluted

to the limit—have you those in mind?

Dr. Soper: | am speaking of Gowanus Canal and Newtown Creek.

Col. Knight: You would not consider those as exemplifying the

general condition of affairs around New York Harbor’

Dr. Soper: The general condition, no.

Col. Knight: A special case?

Dr. Soper: Yes.

Col. Knight: And, in the case of Gowanus, do you notice any

reptible difference in the condition there as you go from the

head of the Canal down to the mouth of it?

oe There is no very material difference until you get #

the Bay.

Col. Knight: But you will admit that at the Bay the relative

a of trouble—if I may so call it—is very materially te

’

Dr. Soper: It is reduced, but it is difficult to say whether mate

rially or not.

Col. Knight: But vou are able to determine that?

Dr. Soper: Contrary to what has been said this morning, there

are no standard sewerages. ;

Col. Knight: Then how are you going to pass on the question

of pollution, if you have no standards?

Dr. Soper: To fix the sanitary standards of the harbor

97 for all time, is too much to do, or what the tide will do o

the water permit; it is not necessary to-day to call

outright falsifier-——

Col. Knight: We are not talking about calling people names.

When you say there are no standards,—what do you propose, your

self, your Board, to be governed by; where does the limit of pollu

tion rest? You say it has been reached in certain localities in New

York Harbor, and then you say there is no standard?

rermae £ gf" © 7 Ea

i

re T FT =

THE STATE OF XEW JERSEY ET AL. 2951

Dr. Soper: To answer vou directly, we will include the Passaic

River ax one case in which the sense of the public of its odor has

etablixhed a standard.

Col. Knight: Then your standard js that of the nose?

Dr. Soper: Of the nose, and of the eyes, and of the public health

and of other considerations——

Col. Knight: But nothing definite?

Dr. Soper: This Metropolitan Sewerage Commission that exists

wday and which I represent as one of its members, has for one

d its undertakings to come as near extablishing a standard—a sani-

ry standard for New York bay as is practical——

Col. Knight: But you do ‘not admit that anything exists to-day

wa standard?

Dr. Soper: Not that can be stated in mathematical terms: no.

Col. Knight: Well, that can be used, practically, for de-

% termining whether the discharge of this sewage will pollute

the waters of New York Bay?

Dr. Soper: We believe that the condition of the waters in Boston

Harbor could be instanced as a good criterion.

Col. Knight: How are you going to apply the conditions of Bos-

wn harber, practically, to New York harbor?

Dr. Soper: Boston harbor—there ix a project 1 here which

ems likely to produce the same conditions as in on, OF worse,

and we object to those conditions; we think that that is a practical

pplication.

Col. Knight: You think that by developing or appropriating the

baton methods, ever or both, is going in the wrong direction?

Dr. Soper: We do.

Col. Knight: But you have no standard or standards to measure

Ww, as to whether that is wrong or right?

Dr. Soper: Not as yet.

Dr. Porter: My main object in appearing before you this after-

won is to state to vou what the policy of New York, so far as the

Sate Department of Health is concerned, is, regarding the pollution

the streams and of the waters of our State.

I believe that the discharge of raw sewage into the waters of this,

any other, State indicates a defective civilization.

I believe that the progress of science has been such and the

% progress of our health experience has been such that we are

ne longer justified in polluting deliberately and with full

inowledge of the consequences that may result, the waters of New

York harbor or of any other harbor or of any other waters, where it

‘posible to purify this sewage before it ix introduced into those

taters, and | withhold permission whenever it is asked of the De-

jartment. and have taken steps to prevent or remove such con-

(Reading:) “In appearing here to-day in opposition to this Pas-

we Valley project, | wish to be clearly understood as in no way

Gtending to oppose, nor obstruct, any great and needed sanitary

maure. On the contrary, I am here to oppose only the execution

4 project that may not carry with it the fullest assurance that the

2052 THE PROTLE OF THE ©TATE OF SEW YORK ve.

benefits to be secured will be realized in a manner that will not

mee to olyectionalle conditions whether from > ~~

poet «, offen<ve oder and appearance, of injury to

“nn

Ih approaching then the question at isue—the pollution

tida waters of New York bay—I believe that it will be both

?

i

i

si

H

He .

question invelved with respect to the needs of the entire

tefore dating any conclusions of giving a decen in any

coe. The need of this « Ne Viewpoint ond reservation

decom em to be parti ¥ ived at thie time in view

ne ae ee 0 ge ee es ee ee ne

extent tof prevent ton upon the waters

0 oharher, Furthermore, the ae of thie whole

you know, hae been eutrusted bw the State of New York

an Investigating Beard, which har teen studying thir 7

some time and which it is expected will, within a

time, report the necesery information that will enable not aly

vour Board. bat others entrusted with corresponding duties, te cm

vider intelligently and act «afely in regard to it.

To give a derision in advance of euch knowledge would, in my

manen, certainly be a step in the wrong direction.

The importance of any evil consequences that might arise from

the propewed diecharge of sewage from the Pasaic Valley Diane

mto New York Bay can hardly be overestimated. They would

affect net alone the people of New York City but the cities and cm

munities along the New Jerey <here ae well, They would invele

net only the comfort, health and life of thee communities, tat

BH

J

—~~ oo 2. ey interested and wishes to appear

to ay to vou for couperation in conserving ite policy in pre

"The pelicy of + hh om oly A adi inetvation

icy

hen, T totiowe, ~~~ ’ — ni

this time fairly well under-toed throughout the State

101 expressed, this policy ix in opperition to the farther

tion of the waters of the State, whether inland or tid

all case where such pollution may appreciably affect the purity d

these waters In accordance with it, the State Department of Health

THE TATE OF SEW JERERY EF aL. 2953

it

i

:

i

iF

if

t

3

ined Lower few Yack Kav on viemity of Keldans Reef

As to what methods will Le used to purify this vast amount

Fie

2% :

i

[err

rf

He

iif

& 5

:

ei

:

424

a

:

i

Hl

ever, tt would appear they recommend. and we are ac-

cordingly led to believe that it i= the intention of New

jeres authorities to previde. only a partial purification of this ——

wume of sewage. According to these engineers, it ix proposed to

eatroct wom the Newark endow ¢ gpl or esltanatition dumm

set and iy Gcaeaneh aiaiee Ie cateall at tie ame oe

gewet wlids and te provide at the outlet near Rottins Keef some

to mtles from «bere. and at edge of the main channel. a «vetem of

aultple outlets -ultmerged seme forty feet below the surface, dis

thated over what they term a dispersion area

There would seem to be litthe doula that th this method of

oupared with the present methed im vogue in New You where

orage i diet without <ettlement of «reening wt pier and

takhead lines near the surface of the water ix relatively superior,

iiged from the sandpeint of methods As to the absolute effi-

aney of the method. under the conditions which it is proposed to

deharge this ewage. it is net «o clear, One thing we are certain

dent, and that is the madequacy of the present method of dixposal

a New York City, which i¢ apparent to any careful oleerver who

mperts the condition of sewage pollution alomy the shores of Man-

tttan and for a considerable distance above and below the city.

hm true that the proposed volume of sewage from the Pas<aic Val-

© trunk «wer mav be «mall compared with present of future vol-

me of sewage from (ireater New York—perhape only ten per

mt —iut have we sufficient knowledge at thix time to he assured

that this volume of sewage discharged with only clanfication

% within the limited 4 sersion atea proposed will not become

m any way object tema

Viewing this phe mn bread y. and in the light of what we do

ee ee ee. Bae ee ee

—

i ee eee ee

method of dixpomal such a= that pore ‘for the Passaic Valley Dis

The experience and succe==ful practice in both this country

thread fully hear out thie statement. And, if this he «o, it

wuld wem that such methods of purification might better have

or at least proposed. as an alternative proposition.

therefore, that in view of what I have said, that it is

would urge it upon vou, Gul pon gh Sn ot

aetul consideration to thix project, and judge it not only in the

more restricted question of the «lting up of the harbor

:

3

bee

ii

?

>

af

rfl

F

24333!

TET tl fo i Witees ee aite

eigaan Li ; Hi + ' AL at

P “it } tid. a5] = 22 : 5 why ean . |

eee bine ql aL akin ee

Bi sit Hs iit i ; BHaaRRH

! lene Hite | bjigaieyts

7 : Hf Hi FE aL siethe EEE bs bere

= {: 4 ‘| est = : t= 4 #87 4 Foy: > 425s : AS

rai eel at aH

HE TE nib |

a Hinds s eestebeyeP herr i

THE #TATE OF NEW JER®RY ET AL. 2955

fom the Treaeury Department on that question relative to some-

tung along that lime——

Mr. Kiker. May I b# allowed to interrupt for a moment? Does

dw Beard propose to hear argument’ We did not understand that

the Koord would hear leyal argument——-

The (hairman We will leave that out—-

ir, Darlington We will leave that out, bat, let me say that, on

eowont of having juriediction, the Department of Health of the

City of New York would certainly exercixe the jurisdiction

™ «of the City of New York <hould they attempt to commence

to build: it ix not « cove of waiting, a one gentlemen «poke

ds being the practice in equity, until we could prove the existence

da Ditance ——

Col. Knight: 1 de not understand that any permit from the War

ment would prevent vou from commencing to aet-——-

i Darlington Tf 1 wnder-tand correctly, the Harbor Line Board

not created to give permission for encroochment= upon the

wwther but te prevent encroachment-——

The Chairman: The question of jurisdiction i« not now before

TR eeecrer rF 2s TS

OE ov: we would mat pox upen the question of juri=diction ; this hear-

my & te ascettain and report concerning the matters set forth in the

pf wderement of the Chief of Engineers on the application—

. Dr. Darlington: I <inuply wich to «tate, then, in regard to some

¢ the arguments that have been raised.—I would like to say that

thy eupervicion, which ix ve-ted in the City of New York, over the

ater of the harbor, would be exercised.

I would like to aek thie question, which they might anewer at

ome future time: ax to whe ix to supervise this <edimentation and

coning” Will ther permit officials of the State of New York to

aperviee these ceration=? Can the officers of the City of New York

@ that it i* properly done?

The Chairman That ix a fair question for you to settle with them.

Dr. Darlington And, also, if it be true that the paint comes

off the howe along the line of the Paemic River. what are

we to aume bat that after it reaches the Bay it will do the

ame to the vessels

Col. Knight: 1 certainiy will, if it ix in the same condition

Dr. Darlington: It ie not claimed that they intend to purify it,

wt ill. ax the ergument< «ew to he wery thick, bw the engineers,

the have not heen able to say or determme definitely anything

feat ito thie <come to be largely an experiment, why do not

they let the first «ewer of thie kind, as proposed by the State of New

key run down and empty opposite Long Branch, Asbury Park,

tome of the other New Jersey resorts, and see whether, in front

@ their own lands. it does any damage or harm?

At a genera) proposition. -ewage is unsanitary, and the pollution

4 water bw sewage ix unsanitary, and if it is intended to increase

t pollution of the water in New York Harbor by means of this new

rage «veterm from New Jersey towns, a heavy burden of proof

™ upen the persons whe propose this increase of pollution, to

tow that it will do no harm.

re ee ee ee, ee eee

PN Sit SPR STARR PO ON REEL IN A

2956 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.

I desire to submit that the burden of proof does not rest upon the

City of New York, but upon the State of New Jersey, and that if

there is any question of doubt in the minds 6f this Board, any doubt

whatsoever, they are not at liberty to simply pass judgment upon it,

but that they must decide upon the side of safety. This is a general

principle in all public health work.

The time has passed when it is necessary to show that

108 a condition produces pestilence in order to be a nuisance

and require correction. The standards of hygiene and of

publie decency are continually becoming higher. What was per

mitted twenty years ago is not to be tolerated to-day, and what is

tolerated to-day will, in all probability. not be permissible twenty

vears hence. The fact. therefore, even of noxious and disagreeable

odors must be taken into consideration, under the laws of the State

of New York. Nay. more. there is larga flotsam in the water, and

even to-day driftwood which is polluted by excrementatious material

is being carried into the houses of tenements,—people pick up this

fire-wood, covered with excrementatious matter and take it home.

We believe we have traced many cases of typhoid fever to the condi-

tion of the flotsam in New York bay.

The’ Metropolitan Sewage Commission was created to formulate

a policy of sewage disposal for the whole metropolitan district, and,

in due course, that will be done. Tow can we ever create better

conditions if we allow these things to come in here now, as proposed

by this application? The Metropolitan Sewerage Commission has

already registered its opinion against the Passaic Valley project.

and has enunciated the principle that large volumes of raw sewage

from municipalities not on the shores of the harbor should not be

discharged into these waters. It has come to my knowledge that

the Commission has knowledge of many facts bearing directly upon

the sanitary side of the question which at present they evi-

109 dently do not feel at liberty to put forward: Therefore, |

think it will be better to let this application wait until some

of those questions are settled.

Not only must we think of the condition when these great works

are first put into operation with six hundred thousand people con-

tributing sewage, but what will occur, let us say, in 1940, (and we

must also take into consideration the suspended material which

comes from streets and roads of that kind, which, on account of the

streets not being paved in those country districts, come under the

New York City standard) and subsequently, when the waste of one

million, six hundred thousand people would probably be flowing

out at that point.

The persistence with which these people, who are interested, en-

deavor to carry out their project, means that the people of the State

of New Jersey do not care whether the harbor of New York be clean

or otherwise.

The one reason above all others, it seems to me. why New York

to-day is a great commercial center, is because of its efficient quaran-

tine. If it were not for that, we would not have the commerce we

enjoy. Let any great plague or pestilential disease become epidemic

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 2957

in the City of New York through laxity of its health officials or the

ie

if § quarantine and I ask you, what would become of the. commerce

it Where? Why is it that New Orleans, with its splendid geographical

wsition at the mouth of a great river, over which freight may be

catied at a minimum: expense, is not the greatest commercial cen-

ter? Simply because of its history in the past with its rela-

110 tion to yellow fever. That is why I am here to-day. We

are very jealous of health and quarantine regulations as it

affects our commerce, and unless it can be proven absolutely that

no nuisance whatever will be created in any way, shape or manner,

the burden of proof resting upon the people who endeavor to build

this work, we do not believe that they should be at liberty to under-

take the work, and that you gentlemen, and all others in authority,

should take the safe position, and prevent it.

Col. Knight: When that sewer was proposed to be built above New-

ark, at Passaic, the court did not take that position?

Dr. Darlington: I do not know with regard to that case.

Col. Knight: There the court said that they could not bring «

ait to prevent the nuisance, but you must prove the existence of a

nuisance, which you are going to prevent.

Dr. Darlington: We prevent nuisances before they are created

in this City: we prove that the conditions would create the nuisance,

and prevent its creation.

Col. Roessler: You represent the Health Department of the City

of New York?

Dr. Darlington: TI do.

Col. Roessler: The gentleman who preceded you referred to a

State law which aimed to prevent the pollution of all streams

t @ navigable and non-navigable; that applies, of course, to New York

Harbor?

- # ill Dr. Darlington: Yes, sir.

Col. Roessler: It applies to Newtown Creek, that we all

know to be polluted ?

Dr. Darlington: Yes.

Col. Roessler: Has anything been done to abate the nuisance

there, under that law?

Dr. Darlington: Yes; things have been investigated looking

towards the abatement of conditions there, by the Department of

Health of New York City: we will not permit slaughter houses to

dump biood or refuse; we make them keep out. We are endeavor-

ing to correct that condition, but we are waiting until we can have

the report of the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission, which is to

be rendered in 1910. We have corrected many of the evils, but we

‘annot correct them unless we can stop sewers of thi

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — New York v. New Jersey · 256 U.S. 296 | Frix