Map Too Large For Filming — New York v. New Jersey
Supreme Court brief1921
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
64 Aadah 44 At
7
/ 4 «
Jame Mabey |
; fr ‘hades et }
4
a
Apsoratus For the determinat an of O489): 60
onyger 7 waorter oy the Levy Method
PEOPLE OF STATE OF NEW YORK VS. STATE OF NEW JERSEY. 39%5
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
CoMPLAINANTS,
vs.
STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.
COMPLAINANTS’ EXHIBIT No. 127.
JAMES D. MAHER,
Commissioner.
. . — Perens mw eterna . - ~ i en ee re ae
PLATE I.
P 2 eotooed
Complainants Exhieo.t 127 ( : oe ed | /
‘ —= . —<— ~o / a eo
f ( \ == : NEWARK ] y oe —_ ~. iif “AS er a =.
(Homa om . \ ¥ es. / — SKET CH A\ | XS \ Sy L SS.
Pena ee , a Sse. BELLEVILLE —_ | )) XX . omen By /
| SS a" & / | iq Sy | a... . SKETCH PLAN AND PROF
oad s of e Xs / . f y 7" a ~* BELLEVILLE / —$+— “= ILE
, y : See ~ 7} NUTLEY ACQUACKANONCK NS PROPOSED Hi SN ie enn ne. S ae j } antes
~ PUMP.STA. SCREENS. A¥® SS , \ \\ N a? SS NUTLEY ACO &
Se y ) \\ ‘Ne ‘i ! UACKANONCK
NEW YORK BAY ay bstcn, ? \ DIST Se BAYONNE > Sie wo } Rh / oa % PROPOSED PASSAIC VALLEY
Aj Pi “a ~. ==} |) S a" ~ J is 7~ \
, \ él "de ate PATERSON ' AND (PS XS A —__y _. 4 o- >, DISTRICT SEWER
, ( 7 PASSAIC \ > LIN \ A / \e% , PATERSON y
. SS one ee a Jeo**"Fenge = FASS RSW l= Xy TAKEN FROM a” \ vA PASSAIC \ x AN D CO NNE CTIONS
\ Se a a SSR SEWER ; —. a — J pacenpng
) fF Plan 3; A _ YN POF See i Ge PR SA TAKEN FROM REPORT OF PASSAIC VALLEY
YX DZ Y; i JERSEY CITY . - Plan rt ie —— SEWERAGE COMMISSIONERS
\, 4 y 46 Is v7) Ye lane 2 mies atl SADDLE RIVER “Q aa , SS eee ee 2 _< A __ 1906.
; re MJ) Sac aes -_— ; SADDLE RIVER FEB. 5, 1912
NOTE- This plan not to be scaled caren fae
NOTE- This plan not to be scaled
” ' |
150 NiW YORK BAY = JERSEY “ New BAY Are NEWARK + BELLEVILLE + FRANKLIN -Hexwcavontt PASSAIC fp MERC PATERSO ae ns 1 |
x | FY Ci NEWARK BAY NEWARK | | ACQUACKANONK :
wa = ! ‘ "3 | | | , | a les + BELEVLLE f+ FRANRL He AACKARON PASSAIC + PATERSON _,iee
ore |) Se : Me | | | | 2M onsinary lvl of Weer in Passe Bier eer - i Be | ! | |
L ae 433% . $3! bE 3 ; z§ | | | APA _- 66 —t- : Ne | | | ;
cee 4|\23 &@€ 23 1% | Ha — 1 76 = aa z : z§ | ! ! | tonnes ag ie Gd re er
, = —_——— a — —T H ‘ + 545 1000". - —— 6-6 —trF ' a,
ae “a — - J Sane | nee es . —_ - re Fes ce me 2m Sar ve mae LPP
es ad ed ——s "s 12-0" oF "ti: *& 700 per imo" “T"Pees, rote -— :3 Sie aa ke a a ad ak Fs pret * war : i> Se rat LF
% sage aye \1- 6 - |, S* 380" per 1000. ~e : } & = a4 6) uo atthe - a ? ' hwnd, 8 S45 pr OS SS 6 eS Seen pe canna Rn act FD
i 13-6 a oo” eH ot | gs 370 s ; « ; ee ~S oss 1-6" | ; ; Sor pr 18. at S. 400 per 1000" PR Ss 389 3 Bime
¥ 160 / 4 vot ' >= rs f ' 3-6 “? me i mews lag, = = '& ‘it 90
Z ary Te ty he teat 8 6710 ft. 9550 ff. rom 4 650 ft. HE 10 790 ft : 3 10 750 #. * eo ene 10 850 ft. " 4.500 9 760 {1 a se Rover 380" par’ 1000" Ta : “a 570 &§ “i cieg 5 : Reet
o , owen ; sas Fee: Fo n& 7 6590 ft ie 7610 ft. He 670M 9580 1. BR 4 65041. 10 790 ft : S +e 10 750 4. eteis 7 af jee S00.
—-. oe 7 g { . |S: 380'per 1008" | ee Be $e ft. eer 9 760 tt 6780. He BAT Ht a Je
— 59 . z VS tsi i _ i i es A wo P | aa ; “z 7 : ; joins ee
3 azs fe ae at ' z's ae cee oS ogg Bo z , . . tr . ! 3 ! tt 6
bon 8 ‘ 27 760 ft Be 328 oe BF . z g : : 5 & § ' E 5 F é é <. ; : oe ‘ 42 Z. 2 ' 3 . 3, = “ 5 : a e 7 & ¥ 3 g ; r 7
* Fee 1 f #52) 3 3 5 Pah a8? SEY ae : ManTe ™ cana? : ae 77 e . § ee i Be ae
1 LM toe 1 | FL i re ee ee eae ae ia é ie Forel f is é | af aad 28 OE whe & Tipe
00 0 100 200 300 400 500 500 700 — — | LJ we oe . fs 4 ea a Ce = ae ee * ai us ui € 5% 5
“= : 7 — 3 i. ! - Lsntiandiensdl “ aS ee Se | | i Se 7. = oe sod = a [oe ae see SR HS
1000 1!00
PPorLe OF STATE OF NEW YORK Ve. TATE OF NEW JERERY, Ns
THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW York
COMPLAINANTS
va.
STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.
COMPLAINANTS’ EXHIBITS Nos. 128, 129, 130, 131,
132, 133, and 134.
JAMES D. MAHEK,
Commimswner.
PROPLE OF STATE OF NEW YORK V8. STATE OF NEW JERSEY.
SY97
NORTH METROPOUTAN Guvaer sera ote aan tayjang Gombe ¢ 08
SouTH ° 6 908
NORTH METROPOLITAN SEWER Caged near Chctece and Everett tne.
souTH wn Quincy
pe he env curve moved + =
HOURLY VARIATION IN FLOW OF SEWAGE
IN MASS. METROPOLITAN DISTRICTS AND
ESTIMATED HOURLY VARIATION IN FLOW IN
PASSAIC VALLEY SEWER AT PUMPING STATION
mMerCar Complacnants Eacheort We 128
Soe = baonse 7H har
—e
Fig |
ore oF <T°7R OF SEW YORK Se STATE OF SEW sey. = OO
MAR BORO MASS — rm awemeee BPW INGHAM ENG aver i iveees qoe )
Curve 1s average of all gagngs - ports shown thus
HOURLY VARIATION IN FLOW OF SEWAGE
IN VARIOUS CITIES
433g AiwOs
L9ae Ain ow
| mOISS te > gove3mas NVA! 10¢001 34 ‘40 SAN 3WieadakS
1 | ] 606) ..8 990 % at? Sew
ae C204 CEN @ bets Bhs ewen
WOMTE ATTIW diweewe 15M CRSORDES vw CoIEWH 6214100114
| ee , . ered ee,
SBANDOTVIA
rg s
a
4000
PEOPLE OF STATE OF NEW YORK VS, STATE OF NEW JERSEY.
fa gh nine thle De VRAD IIIS 5 Bin AACN NT i Tt, MOBDME:
32v4uNS MOTIG
’
rf |
a)
ONV's! SYONH2A09 iv
ou
60 a
} -
——— °
I | ©
g } o
m
bet :
1334 AluO4 at
1S | e
Is &
eS doo
aa 1
j } | w"
Bal 4 "
H rai m
™ _y@—+ = 4
> ¢ | | |
\"4 4 H H
4334 ALNIML Le | |
| | | a)
Pcl | | | | m
lo | | | ] a0 | 7
2 | goo1s | | | 9a3 00142
m | ' m
D_} a po iowa 1 \ a
zt 1 | T 3) '
¢ Hy
le | par. | 3
% | | | * 4
2 —_+ a | { - z S
‘ | \ 2
4334 unos ‘a be.
s a Gs !
rr bad | |
| L
LV014d 40 Hidd
|
od | ok 1 =
perwpr Pome)
“7
wrywneyeorrw f- .
1e/ eA) IQSYR TS IMB YOY) Woy
NOISSINWOD 39VHIM3IS NVLITOdOWL3SW 40 SINIWINAdXS
6061 710! 930 OL us! 1d9S
S3Gii ONINdS 40 BWid BH WIN
WIMAS ADTIWA DIVSSYd ‘139 11N0 A3S0d0Nd LY GIAWICRO SINLIDOTIA
Z119- Z- 324
Fig. 4.
| = g L 9 F ’ 2 2 | 0 =
| = | 1] Ten ARS | | a
tt: sani ay eves: | Pa
$ 2 a0} Ps Wola | Ss
; z Ue 62 82 | eee! oe
i ~ Wd IPS-Wd 00S . - .
; 2 Wo [f:2 -W 00:2! Wows Ga22a7%D aNawuMD 8B} NO SIEMYS
: = WY 0¢-6 ayo 13H oy \
ro) “WY CY-Z GNIS! SHONH3ADD W2iVM HOH cereyy 29ND sat wrmidwe | 02
P= "a “161 01 Ate | ice: ise ite
Eig YaAIy WaTdvH pi
; 2 ~ a ae oe S bins w
= Na9AXO aATOSSia 7 > sn sees)
i; 9° | we S ¢ re
j ~ , de em tema oe” Ra a = 3
/ > me ub psemo! ) an ; $ : A = bs
: Z. ferns = a «6§ > & + a
ke 3 i on ee
ee Bee oe els aye —— &— 5 03
/ * sc ae a, 5 >
i = =f “pools 2 eG
2 s s a
3/2 aye <=
— i= a% 2 al =
s | w wv nm -
Md = tS > et — S z = 08
| Se > 2 °
3 = S gee YD eo
“a Lat ~
| Ll | | l | L I L
DISSOLVED OxYGEN
AVERAGE OF CROSS SECTIONS
TAKEN IN AUTUMN oF [9I/
Hudson River Mt St Vincent Oct 13
° : at Mouth Sept. 28
cast eer Throgs Neck Oct 25
Lawrence Point Oct II
Pier 10 Brooklyn Sept 29
Ue Bay Near Rotbins Reef Light Oct. 16
23
. . - 24
isin Bay - §6
Kill Van Kull - #@
| Barrens Sept 26
or at
yon y
4
OS
WEW YORK CITY
aeo
VICINITY
Scare of Munes
*
Baile a 0 va. tks li
PONT trine
I i Ble Da Re eae
eee Vee ee Le
0 4 0 i ai
F t Po 4 wae) AG OSTA TT T 7 ;
: a | :
§ bg * a 3
Z - 2-01 (1 wor) 5 | w
= av 968 (ti Alar) awwrss swam ago wa |
z le s- Aor
z pannria BOMB 9 AONE OL SUINNOA et
S Ava HOA MN GHY Waly NOSONH Lert gp .
< NIDAXO G3ATOSSIO |) || gh’: fp - Fos ¢ |.
‘ Pas Ad . ‘ et s ij a ODT we
TT / x *e | r 3 >
— 1 — a we —& \ —
ve ad | “> Sh oe
: f fri rf z 34° SINJUUND 993 i f
= ied 22 ise ,
5 i f ae. At ad tr ee snk die seaueg - | 02
: cate semen ‘ 7 ros
5 FPGHYSQEIY + ewwep due) ae
1 1 | = | | st L | mi
PEOPLE OF STATE OF NEW YORK Vs. STATE OF NEW JERSEY. 4005
1 Compiarnants’ Exurert No, 135. James D. Maher, Com-
missioner.
In the Supreme Court of the United States, October Term, 1909.
In Equity. No. 6, Original.
Tue Peorie or THe State or New York, Complainants,
vs.
Tue State or New Jersey and Possare Vatcey Sewersce Com-
missioners, Defendants: Tue Uxiten States, Intervenor.
It is hereby stipulated by and between the United States, inter-
venor in the above entitled cause, and the State of New Jersey and
Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners. defendants in said cause,
that the petition of intervention by the United States in said cause
be forthwith dismissed without prejudice.
GEO. W. WICKERSHAM,
Attorney General of the United States.
ROBERT FH. McCARTER.
Special Counsel for State and for Edmund
Wilson, Attorney General of the State
of New Jersey.
CHANDLER W. RIKER,
Solicitors for and of Counsel with
Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners.
2 In the Supreme Court 7> United States, October Term,
1909.
In Equity. No. 6, Original on the Docket for said October Term.
Tre Peorie or THe Stare oy New York, Complainants,
ve.
Tur State or New Jersey and Passarc Vatery Sewrrace Com-
MISSIONERS, Defendants.
Stipulation.
The United States having intervened in the above entitled «nit
with the consent of the court. and it being desired by the United
States and the defendants in the snit to adjust the matters in con-
troversy between them, in the manner and upon the terms and
conditions hereinafter stated, and the State of New Jersey. by an
act of its Legislature. approved on the eighth day of April, nineteen
hundred and ten. havine authorized the defendant. the Passaic
Valley Sewerage Commissioners, to make this adjustment, it is now
stipulated and agreed by. and between the United States and the
1—Ex. 135
re out Uta
H Hi ui niet ate
iF
) = Hi
bt Hen alice
i + Hy i t al ee Ec Ests 2
E Tne alt mite et :
i; Hie all thi He HT
: 3 flirts brie
i sa at
sizes
pale 3.3 EE nRHE uate dei
a
tard in
of 2
feet
THE PROFLE OF THE STATE OF NEW VORK V5.
4006
Pasaic V
Tit
aT a Bee Ti
ae 1 i i Wy i i a i
yes hada ii Ta At rH
oY ily HE A uf . i Hutt et ne
+ hi id diatgeat Bi ies een
| tld ‘ibd rt Hi ie
7 A 33 per 22 oo
at i fate Hale iti? ai be lH
5
‘
2
a
3
E
«
7
:
.
=
-
: ty
tt
3
Sy
Ha
AMERICA,
3
THE UNITED STATES OF
By GEO. W. WICKERSHAM,
senled
Sede ame their
all on the fuurteenth day of April. nineteen hundred and ten.
a
Term,
- Tee
General.
GE COM-
A
PASSAIC VALLEY SEWE
Chairman and President.
vs.
1909.
Tue Stare or New Jeneey and Passa Vatcey Sewenace Cow
In Equity. No. 6, Original.
MISSIONERS,
Tue Peorte or THe State or New Yor«.
By JULIUS A. LERKUECHER,
Unsrrep States, Intervenor.
MissioneRs, Defendants
Secretary and Clerk
In the Supreme Court of the United States, October
JOHN 8&8. GIBSON,
[seat]
Attest -
7
: r 4 ;
~ - ; .
Z
‘ .
;
- .' i
; -
2 ;
. j
: 7 a
~ q , .
- <
7 =
” > -
; - - .
=) —
-- ;
« —_
~
= : 7
- a
= j
oe ,
;
,
r :
° , : ;
;
)
j :
:
* ;
™ : . ,
‘
4010 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
basins where the heavy matter therein shall be taken out as far as
practicable, from which basin or basins the sewage and other matter
shall pass through self-cleansing mechanical screens having clear
openings of not over 4/10 of an inch.
(b) As the sewage comes from the fine screens, it shall also pass
through the sedimentation basins. The sewage after passing through
said grit basin and self-cleansing mechanical screens shall enter
the sedimentation basins or settling tanks consisting of a number of
units, each approximately 225 feet long and 15 feet deep. Each
tank will have a normal capacity of about 1,250,000 gallons, making
an aggregate tank capacity suiticient to meet the requirements as
stated herein. These tanks shall provide a detention period at the
maximum rate of flow of the sewage when the sewer goes into opera-
tion and begins to discharge into the said waters, and until the year
1920, of not less than one hour, with a capacity and provision for
the detention of the average flow of such sewage for not less than
one hour and a half in the year 1920. The main lineal velocities
through said tanks when said sewer begins to discharge, and until
1920 shall not be over 0.5 inch per second for average flow, and
0.75 inch per second for the maximum flov.. In addition
10 to and in connection with these basins scum boards shall be
provided to retain the floating matter, and proper and ade-
quate devices shall be used to remove the retained scum and deposits
from the settling basins; drawings of the general plan of said settling
tanks (sedimentation basins) being herewith attached as Appendix A.
(c) The sewage and waste thus screened and settled is then to
flow into a pump well, from whence it is to be pumped under pres-
sure through the tunnel to a point in the New York Bay near
Robbins Reef light, at which point it is agreed that the matter pass-
ing through the said tunnel shall be dispersed into the waters of the
New York Bay through a series of outlets discharging forty feet or
more beneath the surface of the water at mean low tide. From the
end of the tunnel connections shall be made with four or more dis-
charge pipes extending across the current, spaced about one hun-
dred feet apart, laid in trenches on the bottom of the Bay, and of a
size decreasing in diameter from about six feet to two feet. On the
top of these discharge pipes will be a series of not less than one
hundred and fifty tees of a diameter not exceeding one foot, and
spaced approximately ten feet apart. On each of these vertical tees
shall be placed outlets arranged to discharge horizontally across the
tidal current and the extent of the dispersion area used for this
system of outlet pipes shall cover at least 3.5 acres of the bottom of
the Bay.
Second. The State of New Jersey and the Passaic Valley Sewerage
Commissioners further agree with the United States that in the opera-
tion of said sewer system, provided the permits for its construc-
11 tion referred to in Article V of this instrument have been
granted, at all times the following results shall be secured,
either through compliance with the requirements of the immediately
preceding paragraphs, or through requisite lawful alditional arrange
ments, viz:
6—Ex. 135
ann Sse pear et oo ery ty ‘ “ > on OE,
II 0 ET SES 4 bins Toe 3 ne
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4011
(1) There will be absence in the New York Bay of visible sus-
pended particles coming from the Passaic Valley sewage.
(2) There will be absence of deposits objectionable to the See-
retary of War of the United States in New York Bay coming from
the Passaic Valley sewage.
(3) There will be absence in the New York Bay and its vicimity
of odors due to the putrefaction of organie matters contained in
the Passaic Valley sewage thus discharged.
(4) There will be a practical absence on the surface of New
York Bay of any grease or color due to the discharge of the Passaic
Valley sewage at the dispersion area or elsewhere.
(5) There will be no injury to the public health which will be
occasioned by the discharge from the said sesver into the Bay of
New York in the manner proposed and no public or private nuisance
will be created thereby.
(6) The absence of injurious effect from said sewage discharge,
upon the property of the United States situated in the Harbor of
New York.
(7) The absence of reduction in the dissolved oxygen contents
of the waters of New York Bay, resulting from the discharge of
— Valley sewage, to such an extent as to interfere with major
h life.
Third. The State of New Jersey and said Passaic Valley
12 Sewerage Commissioners further agree with the United States
that so long as said sewer system or any part thereof, is
operated, the United States shall have through such representatives
as may be designated by the Secretary of War at any time for such
purpose, full opportunity to inspect the condition and working of
the sewer system, with a view to determining whether this contract
is in all respects performed, and that the said Passaic Valley Sewerage
Commissioners will render such expert or other assistance as the
United States may desire in the course and in aid of such inspection
and determination.
Fourth. The United States agrees with the State of New Jersey
and the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners that forthwith upon
the filing of this agreement, properly executed, in the office of the
Clerk of the Supreme Court as a stipulation of the parties in the suit,
it will discontinue its intervention in the above entitled suit and
will cause its petition of intervention to be dismissed without preju-
dice, and will not again intervene in said suit.
Fifth. The United States and the State of New Jersey and the
Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners mutually agree that this
contract shall not become effective in any part except the next suc-
ceeding division, unless or until all such permits as would be re-
quisite under the statutes of the United States for the construction,
maintenance or operation of said sewer system without this contract
are actually obtained from the United States, or unless or until such
permits are made conditional upon compliance at all times with all
the terms and requirements of the divisions of this contract
13. numbered first and second, whether or not such permits con-
tain other terms or conditions.
7—Ex. 135
CL a
4012 TRE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.
Sixth. The State of New Jersey and the Passaic Valley Sewerage
Commissioners hereby consent that full compliance at all times with
the terms and requirements of the first and second divisions of this
contract be made express conditions of any permits issued by or on
the part of the United States for construction, maintenance or opera-
tion of said sewer system, and agree with the United States that this
contract shall establish such consent before all officers of the United
States.
Signed in triplicate in the name and on behalf of the United
States by the Attorney General of the United States and in the name
and on behalf of the State of New Jersey by its Attorney General
and in the name and on behalf of the Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-
missioners by their president. and sealed also on behalf of said Pas
saic Valley Sewerage Commissioners with their corporate seal, at
tested by their secretary; all on the — day of Nineteen hun-
dred and ten.
[Endorsed :] Complainants’ Exhibit 135. James D. Maher, Com-
missioner.
Oa a ele wR rem? oi OOG
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4013
1 CompLalxants’ Exutpir No. 136. James D. Maher,
Commissioner.
Board of Estimate and Apportionment.
Report of Col. William M. Black, U. 8. A., and Prof. Earle B. Phelps,
Concerning Location of Sewer Outlets and the Discharge of Sew-
age into New York Harbor.
1911.
2 City or New Yor«x:
Report of Colonel William M. Black, Corps of Engineers, U. S. A.,
and Professor Earle B. Phelps, Concerning the Location of Sewer
Outlets and the Discharge of Sewage into New York Harlor,
Submitted to the Board of Estimate and Apportionment, March
23, 1911.
3 Table of Contents.
Page
SD PED con vasecdsveenerterrevccescevecerereteens 5
Report on Corona Drainage District...................... 99
Report on Flushing Drainage District.............. ....- 115
Report on Jamaica Drainage District...................-- 125
Report on Richmond Drainage District................... 151
Report on Oxygen Content of Sea Water as a Standard for
Measuring Sewage Pollution...............----+e2ee- 185
4 Boarp Or EstTIMATE AND APPORTIONMENT,
City or New York, March 14, 1911.
Hon. William J. Gaynor, Mayor, Chairman of the Board of tstimate
and Apportionment.
Sir: I beg to submit herewith the final report of Colonel William
M. Black and Professor Earle B. Phelps, giving the result of their
investigation as to the location of sewer outlets and the discharge
of sewage into the waters about New York, which was authorized
by resolution adopted by the Board of Estimate and Apportionment
on November 12, 1909.
Five preliminary reports have already been submitted % the
Board, as follows:
1. Drainage of Flushing District, April 22, 1910.
2. Drainage of Corona District, June 17, 1910.
3. Oxygen content as a standard, July 1, 1910.
4. Drainage of Jamaica District, January 12, 1911.
5. Drainage of Richmond District, March 9, 1911.
_The present report gives the general result of their study of the
arculation of the waters in the harbor and the capacity of these
Waters to receive sewage without undue pollution, with recommenda-
1—Ex. 136
ee ee ee ee ee’ LO oR SET DE RLS ST ye
4014 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.
tions as to the standard of purity which should be maintained ip
the different portions of the harbor. These studies are based
the constitution of the water in the different portions of the barber
as the result of the tidal movements and the mixture of sewage bear
ing waters with clean sea water entering the harbor from the sea a
Sandy Hook and from Long Island Sound at Throws Neck, and th
water from the Iludson River, which is already more or less
luted. For the purpose of this investigation and the computations
they have divided the harbor into seven different areas, namely, the
Lower and Upper Bays, the Hudson River, below and above Ninety.
sixth street, the Kast River, below and above Hell Gate, and the
Harlem River.
The degree of pollution and the capacity of the harbor waters
care for additional sewage is expressed in terms of the dissolve
oxygen remaining in the water, and the recommendation in th
final report ix that 70 per cent. of the saturation value of dissolve
oxygen would be a proper standard of purity to be maintained if
possible.
The po po contains a discussion of the renewal of the oxygen
content of water by absorption from the atmosphere and by aeration
through disturbances caused by wind, by passing vessels, and by
tidal currents. It appears to be conclusively shown that the extent
of the nenewal of the normal oxygen content by these agencies ha
been greatly overestimated, and that their effect is so slight as &
be almost negligible. The belief is expressed that were all the sew
age of the City discharged at Throgs Neck or at the Narrows, that
is, at the points of entrance of unpolluted sea water into the harbor,
a safe limit of pollution could be maintained without treatment of
the sewage until the population shall have reached more than 7,000,
000. It is also believed that crude sewage can safely be dischargel
in the vicinity of Riker’s Island or the Narrows for some years &
come, but that at other points partial purification will soon be nece
sary, at least during the summer months, while even with such
sagen purification a proper system of discharge and dispersion will
necessary.
The report gives the results of a series of experiments to deter
mine the practicability of a system of forced aeration following «
short period of septic treatment, the estimated cost of which is given
at $2.00 per million gallons of sewage treated, with the probability
of a material reduction as the result of further experiment. The
suggestions in this and previous reports as to the details of the se
erage plans for different parts of the City must not be considered #
anything more than suggestions, but they appear so reasonable that
it is believed that ¢hey will be found in their general features to
logical and practicable and along lines which will commend them
selves to the several Borough Presidents in the completion of ther
drainage plans.
The amount of work which has been done within the limits o
time and funds which were available is quite remarkable, and thee
results could not have been obtained except for the fact that the
investigations of the United States Coast and Geodetic Survey and
2—Ex. 136
Se IE LPL OF 0 TP RE en PLIES ILO” EL
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4015
of the United States Engineer Corps were fully availed of. In dis-
cussing the question of the pollution of the waters of the harbor and
the necessity for treating sewage discharging into them, the al-ence
of any accepted standard by which the degree of pollution and the
necessity for treatment could be judged, has been a serious handicap.
It may be that the use of the percentage of the saturation value of
dissolved oxygen will furnish a standard which can be generally
accepted. Colonel Black and Professor Phelps have suggested that
70 per cent. of this value would be a proper standard of purity which
the City should endeavor to maintain, bui they admit that this whole
matter is one upon which there is at present much difference of
opinion, and 1 believe that if this question could be submitted to a
committee of especially qualified engineers for a report as to a proper
standard for the harbor waters, the conclusion of such a committee
would be accepted not only by the City of New York, but by other
cities similarly situated, and that a valuable contribution would be
made to the vexed subject of the protection of navigable water from
undue pollution by the sewage of great seacoast cities.
The experiments already referred to may, if continued, produce
results of considerable economic value. vy were started at the
Twenty-sixth Ward sewage disposal plant, in the Borough of Brook-
lyn, and they could be continued at this plant under the supervi<ion
of the President of the Borough of Brooklyn at an expense which
would be small in comparison with the value of the results which
may be attained. An enlargement of this plant will probably be
necessary in the near future, and in planning such enlargement pro-
vision could well be made for experimental work on the lines -ug-
aaA78.8° 2°77 SP TR RTS SS
gested.
I would recommend that the Board int a commission of five
engineers, to consist of Colonel William Mt Black, a representetive to
he designated by the Metropolitan Seweraze Commission, and
5 three others who are generally recognized as authorities in
this particular field of engineering work, and that such com-
mission be instructed to advise the Board of Estimate and Apportion-
ment at a early a date as possible of their conclusions ax to the per-
centage of the saturation value of dissolved oxvgen which the City
should +trive to maintain in the waters of the harber of New York.
1 would also recommend that the President of the Borough of
Brooklyn be requested te continue the investigations inaugurated hy
Colonel Black and Professor Phelps to determine the feasibility of
an economic application of the treatment of sewage by forced aera-
tion, and to advise the Board of the result of such investigations and
ments.
t is further recommended that the Secretary be authorized and
to have five hundred (500) copies of this report printed as
a pamphlet, together with the five preliminary reports as appendices.
Respectfully,
NELSON P. LEWIS,
Chief Engineer.
Sersca, ar 2788 2428 5
aeet2, SVPRCRRTESAS = *
4016 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
6 New York, February 16, 1911.
Mr. Nelson P. Lewis, Chief Engin er, Board of Estimate and Ap
portionment, 277 Broadway, New York City.
Sin: We have the honor to submit the following final report of
the work done under the directions contained in your letters of Oc
tober 11 and November 18 and 20, 1909, and the terms of acc
named in the letter of Colonel Black, dated December 21, 1909,
In brief, the problems laid before us were to determine the mos
advantageous points for sewage discharge for the areas draining into
the Fast River from the districts of Greater New York on Long
I-land to the east of Newtown Creek; for the portion of the Borough
of The Bronx draining into the same waterway; for the drvimage
areas tributary to Jamaica Bay, including Far Rockaway and Coney
Island, and for the Borough of Richmond: and further, to deter
mine the degree of purification, if any, to which the sewage would
have to he sulyjected before discharge in order that the waters in
question should not be polluted unduly thereby.
The solution of the problems involves:
1. The determination of a standard of purity for the harbor water.
2. A study of the circulation of these waters through the variow
parts of the harbor, with a view to determining for each part the
general constitution of the waters in that part during any one tidal
period, what proporticn -f the total volume had come direct from
the unpolluted waters of the sea or Sound and what proporiion from
other parts of the harbor, where, for a greater or less period, they
had been receiving sewage.
3. A study of the capacity of the waters of each part to receive
sewage without undue pollution, including in this a study of the
sources of supply of oxygen.
4. A study of an economical method of partial purification, ap
plicable to the conditions of New York.
5. A study of the terrain of the various districts, of present and
expected population, of the drainage areas from which sewave can
he collected, of the lines along which it can be moved for disposal,
of the volumes of sewage to be provided for, of the available point
for discharge, and finally for each district, of the degree of purifica
tion demanded by the capacity of the portion of the harbor in que
tion to care for the sewage wi undue pollution.
For this work one year’s time and $10,000 were available. It was
found that under these conditions the field work had to be limited
to the determination of the dissolved oxygen in the waters at the
harbor entrances and to the experimental work required to develop
the method of ial purification. In the studies, existing map
had to be used for the terrain and existing data for the circulation
of the waters in the harbor.
The results of our investigations may be briefly summarized #
follows :
(1) The amount of dissolved oxygen in the harbor waters fur
nishes the most satisfactory criterion of the purity of these waters
4—Ex 136
2 i i Peeks
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY FT AL. 4017
We believe that this natural purifying agent should not be
; drawn upon to an extent which will reduce it below 70 per
cent. of the full saturation value. This standard of purity
refers not only to average conditions throughout the harbor and it-
tributaries, but alxo to the average condition within any of the <ub-
areas into which for the purposes of this -tudy we have divided the-e
waters.
(2) We have shown that the circulation of water through these
various sub-areas makes the condition of each dependent to a larze
extent upon the conditions in one or more of the others. We have
determined these complex relationships with a rea-onable degree of
accuracy and in this way have been able to determine the most svit-
able points for sewage discharge and the probable effect of such di--
charge not only upon the area immediately adjacent, but upon the
entire body of water under consideration. If the sewage of the en-
tire drainage area tributary to these waters could be concentrated at
the two entrances, namely, at the Narrows and Throgs Neck, we
etimate that the standard of purity laid down could be maintaine?,
for the present at least, and for the immediate future until “ne i a
continue to exist even after the be ow ok which we have indi-
cated had been established. These are due not to insufficient volumes
of water as compared with the volume of sewage discharged, hut to
the fact that the fullest use of this water cannot be attained under
existing conditions. In studying the sources of oxygen available for
purification we have found that a serious misconception exists of
the importance of reaeration by partially de-aerated waters. We have
determined that this reaeration factor is one that is without material
ificance in the case of the waters of New York Harbor.
(4) We have determined by experiments a practical scale
made both at Brooklyn and at Boston. that a of purification
which will reduce the oxygen requirements of the sewage to one-
third their present value during the summer months, can he ob-
—y Sy of septic treatment followed by forced aera-
hon. cost of such treatment will not exceed all told two dollars
;
int
lons, and further studies will doubtless make it pos-
this cost materially.
Our studies of main drainage schemes are included in four
‘ppendices to this report and summarized in Chapter IV. herein.
ee . ~ LE PRs OTS
THE PROFLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V5.
Ue eal
ae Bu =f vey ie tin 1] ahd
HAncianne : ailiet aul
a unui | PUGE Hane
7 atin ia é Lill mH
i it if Hath iy i: Pill
HF leigh : Ht i a
Hat ; i ilts
Ht in _ildek iia] et ils
ey
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4019
render it i ible to utilize to the point of fullest economy the
—s , W. M. BLACK.
EARLE B. PHELPS.
, Capacity of New York Harbor to Recewe and Reduce Sewage.
By W. M. Black, Colonel, Corps of Engineers, U. 8. A., Member,
American Society of Civil Engineers and Earle B. Phelps, profesor
d Chemical Bielegy, Ma-<achusetts In-titute of Technology; Con-
alting Sanitary Engineer, Aor, American Senety of Civil En-
gineers, February 16, 1911.
1 Contents of Final Report.
Cuarrer L.— PAGE
Study of Circulation of Harber Waters and Their Ca-
pacity to Receive Sewage Without Undue Pollution
Standard of Purity for the Harbor Waters........ 17
Circulation of Waters in New York Harber....... Is
— eae SS = = FF FT
-— a
i y of Harter Water- to Receive Sewage W ith-
out Undue Pollution .............----5-e555- 33
Cuarrer IL.—
Absorption of Atmosphereic Oxygen by Water
Quiescent Water
Discusion of the Problem.................. 39
Theoretical and Experimental............... 0
eile te ela i e ee eee eoen ne 42
SS eT er Tre 49
Salt Water Conditions ..................... fe)
re Se i. ++ osneennenbeneses bd)
Conclusions Regarding Quiescent Water... ... 2
of Currents and Other Disturbing Factors Upon
rate of Aeration |
i ie ee eben commana “ah
Effect of Passing Vewels..................005.. 59
Effect of Tidal Currents............ 66. eee en. ed)
Summary and Conclusions......................... 62
Cuarrer ITL.—
Investigations Inte the Aeration of Sewage:
ORI TIED ay Ge
Aeration of Crude and ~eptic Sewage in Shallow Tanks:
Plan of Investigations. .... yeti taieieienhateninen 4
TILLER AIL 65
IE fancies di inbineadieuniniens 68
THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V*
Aeration of Septic Sewage in a Deep Tank
Plan of Investigations
Results Obtained .
Experiments Upon the Aeration of @ Biclytic Eleent at
, Mase.
Amount of Air apEERS « and aE Effected
ERED cocvceccvoes
11 Cnarter TV.—
Peehas toy Gonge Conventention and Blears
ee ee ee ee eee eee ee eee ee
LAA eee eee eee eee eee ee ee eee
“eee een
e+e ee eee
Fe ef SESE
|
i
&
2
a
ee ee
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.
Dilution ratios and resulting percentages of oxygen
with sewage discharged at the Narrows and Throgs
es Po
Amount of oxygen alsorbed from atrnowphere by
Tea PPP ee eee eee eee eee eee eee
ery ee reer er FF F
Frequency of mixing, by wind, in New York Harbor
Movement of vessels, York Harber..........
Average rate of alworption of oxygen by waters of
BO WOES Pec cccccccceccceccoceccevere
Analyses of Boston sewage........-.- 66-6 essen
Relative stability, etce., crude, septic and aerated
Percentage of improvement by seration...........
Relative ility, erade and aerated sewage.......
Tida! data, isessndessnovedsedededes
Plates and Diagrama.
No. Map of New York Harbor..................++.
No. Mean tidal and velocity curves the Narrows........
No. Mean tidal and velocity curves Forty-second street,
ED DEED cccccococoecctanesoecasecouee
No. Mean tidal and velocity curves Nineteenth «treet,
Dy vsnnsasetcocedananeddekansdaned
No Mean tidal and velocity curves Throgs Neck, Fact
ED sovccrovocevodedoouéneveseeeedonsees
12
Ne. 6. Mean tidal curves New York Harbor............
Ne. 7. Tidal slopes between Sandy Hook and Throgs Neck
Diagram *. oe (pounds) aleerbed at sated depth dur-
_ water during variow: periods, depth 5
Diagram 2. Same for 10foot depth...................-.
Diagram 3. Same for 15-foot depth...................+.
Diagram 4 oan By a eae peesewebesauseeseoonn
Diagram 5. Oxygen (pounds) atmorbed at stated depths dur-
GED GE co cccccccccececcsccese
——e a ae ee ee
402)
4022 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK YS.
Diagram 6. Average rate in pounds eee hour of absorption of
oxygen from atmosphere per million gallons
at stated depths during certain periods...... 4
Diagram 8. Actual hourly rate of absorption of oxygen from
the atmosphere at any time per million gal-
- Gio dc ccccccsctveccsses 5d
Diagram 7. Depths to which wind storms of various veloci-
OP GUND GUID. 6 vvccccscccsesecsvee 57
Diagram 9. Relation between velocity Constant K and ab-
sorption of disolved oxygen by sewage...... 67
Diagram I. App. Apparatus for determining diffusion co-
OPP PEL EC PTEECT EET opp. p. 93
Diagram Il. App. Diffusion co-efficient................. 96
Diagram III. App. Value of K-Range, K—0.000 to 0.001.. 97
Diagram IV. App. Value of K-Range, K=.001 to 0.01.... 98
Map showing drainage lines and points of discharge recom-
mended for Flushing, Corona, Jamaica and Borough of
Db bev aWoo weds ddebs ee cede ticsobrcene 149
13 Chapter I.
I. Standard of Purity for the Harbor Waters.
It is only within recent years that well-founded complaints have
been made about the foulness of the harbor waters. As yet, to the
superficial observer, only small portions of these waters are manifestly
in a condition to be regarded as a nuisance. The condition has
come gradually and with the increase of population. The increase
continues, and it is certain that unless remedial measures are taken
greater and greater portions of the harbor will be reduced to the
conditions of the Gowanus Canal, for example. For years the
capacity of the harbor waters was sufficient to receive and digest
without injury the sewage of the population of the harbor drainage
area. Gradually the volume of sewage poured into them and into
the rivers tributary to them has increased until to-day the -higher
classes of fish have disappeared, bathing in them has become un-
pleasant, if not dangerous, and portions of them in appearance and
smell have more the characteristics of drains than of living waters.
From a technical standpoint the most simple measure of the pollu-
tion of any waterway is found in the proportion of dissolved oxygen
contained therein. Pure, living water contains dissolved oxygen to
its saturation value, in an amount which is different for fresh water
and for sea water and which varies with the temperature. The
amount of oxygen found at saturation in fresh water is 6.38 grains
per cubic foot at 32 degrees Fahrenheit and 4.04 grains per cubic
foot at 68 degrees. For sea water the corresponding figures are 5.10
grains and 3.29 grains. Sewage as delivered at the sewer mouth is in
a highly putrescible condition, and the putrefaction is continued
after diffusion in a waterway, robbing the water of its oxygen on -
10—Ex. 136
THE STATE OF NEW “ERSEY ET AL. 4023
the one hand, but on the other reducing the organic materials of
the sewage into stable and innocuous forms. The effect on the water
is practically harmless when not used for domestic purposes, until
this diminution of its oxygen has continued through a considerable
percentage of the saturation volume. For example, probably the
first indication of pollution is the disappearance of major fish life,
for the existence of which 70 per cent. of the saturation volume of
oxygen is necessary. Other forms of fish life can exist until the
limit of 30 per cent. has been reached. When the remaining volume
of dissolved oxygen in a stream falls below 50 per cent., the stream
may at times become turbid and noisome during hot weather, as is
illustrated in the Passaic River, in which in the neighborhood of
the Pennsylvania Railroad bridge on January 19, 1911, the dissolved
oxygen was found to have about 38 per cent. of the saturation value.
When reduced below 30 per cent., the condition of the water is
such as to constitute a nuisance during the summer season. When
any standard is fixed, the amount of sewage which can be poured into
the waters without purification is also fixed, though this amount
will be greater in winter than in summer on account of the slower
rate of putrefaction in cold weather and the greater amount of dis-
solved oxygen found in the water. Therefore, a higher standard
entails greater expense for sewage purification maintenance
14 than a lower. On the other hand, it is practically impossible
to obtain or maintain an even diffusion of sewage through the
waters of any large waterway. The adoption of a high standard
affords greater certainty that no portion of the waterway shall be
polluted to a known degree.
After a careful consideration of the whole question, the writers
recommend that for New York 70 per cent. of the saturation value
he adopted as the standard below which the dissolved oxygen in tts -
harbor waters be not permitted to fall—a standard of which the
maintenance can be made evident by the existence of the major fish
life formerly so abundant here. The calculations of the capacity
of the harbor to receive sewage given hereafter are based on this stand-
ard.
2. Circulation of the Waters in the Harbor.
The sources of the harbor waters are the discharge of the streams
tributary to them, the direct drainage from the shores and the tidal
influx of sea water’through the Sandy Hook and Throgs Neck en-
trances. Originally all of these sources were unpolluted. To-day
the streams are polluted by the drainage from the population along
their shores. The Passaic is polluted to a degree which has caused
an expensive project to be proposed by the State of New Jersey,
under which all of the sewage from the district draining into it is
to be collected and after partial purification, as required by the
United States authorities, is to be discharged into the Upper Bay
near Robbins Reef. This project when carried out will better the
existing conditions under which these polluted waters are now emp-
tied through Newark Bay and the Fill von Kull, purified only by
the comparatively smal] amount of reaeration and sedimentation they
11—Ex. 136
4024 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK YS.
receive in the passage through Newark Bay. Recent observations
made by the United States in a section of the Hudson just above the
northern limit of Greater New York show that during the low water
period, that stream has been polluted to beyond a safe limit before
it reaches the harbor. The direct drainage from the shores is «so
now a source of pollution. The only unpolluted source of supply is
then the sea. Observations made in Ambrose Channel in February,
1910, show that the waters brought in by the flood tide there con-
tain 98 per cent. of the saturation amount of the dissolved oxygen,
Other observations at Throgs Neck entrance from the Sound made in
January, 1910, show that the ebb (westerly) waters there contain
oxygen to 90 per cent. of the saturation value.
Careful observations and analyses of the circulation of the waters
in New York Harbor were made by the U. S. Coast and Geodetic
Survey through a series of years ending in 1886. Subsequent obser-
vations and measurements of the currents in the Harlem have been
made by the Engineer Department, U. 8. Army. From the record
of these observations the following studies have been made.
(Here follow diagrams, of plates 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, marked pages 15
to 21, Complainants’ Exhibit 136.)
12—Ex. 136
EPP HELA LI ELI LEE DOSES LISS BELVO LED ELIC ST I IE ITN Se ETS
PLATE 1
yooy hpueg yo cog woy 49/0
coouasie povoy2 mays Sebi, ILM
WYFIO WLAOTLY
Aagsuar MAN
\ YECAY EWOW# 4ALJO 8 41POM 40UPT
w\ “ o 6 ‘ é 7 s + © 2 wr e
PLATE 2
SACRE
i
Po 20s 43d {24 014 /20/3f
~ oe ~
Li
. i
“E
=a
409-10K1 A Ki "SMOLIOPWY) FY
SPASID ALIIOIIA ONY TWO NOI 2
eee time
DARK PAGE BLEE
SECU BLO H8Lfe BIOY HOUNT
PLATE 3
ve ope |
oye sou
4
S
/
/
Ss 7A“? aa
7
WW ie Per
Of7A ONY 7YOL NYTIW
LEED THRU
m SSMOM BOO hse Bey 18a 7 robe
- on . o ‘ . ‘ , — = ae a .
| ieee te Be nes 7
) 4 102 wae ve SOPeLd megs Meh PRL LOp pw 4 J
’ ed 4 —
— T a eS 7
; | / A
\ Zz IX ie
: 2 +
f
| g | ' ft : t
| > e i ae H t >
. Ss Y? = 1 Fades Few ; of
PIE TIN \ v4 ?
2) % ‘y Ll ‘
) _ , h j
= ——_— !
i , ix ,
: N\ 2 r 78
: A \ iN
e —-— * r
-~ XV ,
7 —_ { i --T 7
a Wary $802 IS ¥4 EY ‘
SIAN ALIOOTIA ONY TWOLL NV IW ¢ :
|
DARK PAGE BL
JOCeq FPR “a ty “eur
]
ae
Vig, | N
| '
} a Or ts
| | TAN | i
t— Pad
ae se Sr
|
AY
CIS
*
AHO AY py eben,
SPAWID ALIPOTIA ONY WOK NOW
-EED THRU
/36-h. je
joy “hay (OP,
ee .
,
~~
—
=
— 7 1
Ke
[toe cat Ee
ne nl ——
|
= ee"
2 oe
lo ae
9910 h) 4-H MOK
SFAMI? T401L NY IW
=
#i-
DARK PAGE Bi
SOM Bema, JO mm IY
POR HK MW
SIASOTS FPO
LEED THRU
Geodetic
of the +» of the Metropol
910
of New York for!
A the water
nted in Ap
current- are the
A fall deeerip-
from the relative
River direct and the other via
|, 8. Coat and
1
at any hour between the points
for 1885 of the |
mages 158-
Harlem and East Rivers, The
currents for each junar hour i* pri
#TATE OF NEW JERSEY ET
result of the «lapes produced by these waves.
0 of the Report
duced on 4
the Hud-en,
tion of these
ooby - these pointe .
em that te yt
=_ No.
wat. the term
ee ae
eae i iia
mann res
= Ge Oe
—— =
Kony 4
shane
river. The shallow and obstr
Bronx Kill« '
£3543 Hee ee
=
pean I
ae aah dies
THE PROFLE OF THE STATE OF KEW YORK Ve
Tame 1.
Sandy Hook —
EE re 23 322.889 000 cubic fon
SR I Sy a ae Besson *- *
Narrows
EE a ee 1278464 UC
il tinneteniatieseendaaanes 13451926144 " *
hast River at Nineteenth «reet—
ns ag IE 4900175476 “ *
bid, A aaea ee 44K sai 257 =" —C*
East Kiver at Throgs Neck—
Plesd....... on RO 4207900000 06 CO
ee CS ee: . © oe
Hudson Kiver at Thirty-ninth «treet—
I ical vac tia res al ae Sond oti ns 62559505 “ °
Se ere 6906 4H78 413 e .
Harlem Kiver at Two Hundred and Six-
teenth treet —
Flood ; PrrTrrrrrriryY secced 227 531 520 = -
See eee 2iso20 * *
Kill von Kall—
ES ae eS 171245362 ° *
_—_-- wee 17. )\oan72 * .
For convenience in the following discussion the waters of the
Kl pper Bay.
©— Headsen Kiver, from Battery to West Ninety-«ixth «treet.
—— — , from Wet Ninety<ixth «treet t Spayte
mayvi
E—RPa= River, from Battery to Hell Cate.
F—Kast Kiver, from Hell Gate to Throgs Neck.
THE eTaTe OF SEW JERERY ET AL. wu
™” Teme 2
growing Chengre in Elevation of Water Beurfece During Flord and Ebb Cur
rent Portede Referr’d to Plane of Been Low Water
a Lower bay — eee Phd o-* 4” a4
be 4 oo o4
Speer bey ..... ———- 8 8—l* 1.7 a9 24
me... 2* eo” 17
C—fheduen River, fron, Rattery to | Phew 20 a4 24
Ninety-steth etree’ .......-. j am... 2.0 oe 20
b—Hedeon Kiver. from Ninety. | Fleet... 24 2.4 24
sixth street to Mpuyten Draywil | Fi. 20 oe 2
£ Leet River, Mattery to Nelli Gate Pieced... eo” 4 4.1
im.... 4.1 eo” eo”
f—Kest Kiver, Het) Gate to Throgs | Fleet. . 4.7 72 45
eee n.. 45 00 47
G Wariem River seeoeeeues EE “2 4 42
em... .. 42 oo 62
An i ection of the map will shew that of the areas named, the
Hodeon Kiwer, the Eat Kiwer from the Battery to Hell Gate, and
the Harlem River are channel. of comparatively regular cross-section
m which the current velocity and direction are comparatively uni-
form from bank to bank: while the areax« of the Lower Bay, the
Upper May and the East River from Hell Gate to Throgs Neck com-
pree clommels with Lave or basins filled and emptied from the chan-
The modification which this difference causes in the circulation of
the waters ix exemplified ax follows When the flood (easterly) cur-
rent begins in the Fast River, opposite Old Ferry Point, the water
level is at 4.26 feet above the mean low water plane and falling.
tide, to the elevation 4.47, i# of water, more or lew pol-
luted. which had flowed out pact Old Ferry Point.
— When the ebb current sets in, the water surface is rising the flow
4028 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.
(about 1,496,222,000¢ cubic feet), gives the measure of the
25 new supply of oxygen provided by one tide through this en-
trance. Before the tide turns again this water has been divided
Letween the East and Harlem Rivers and has entered into its work
in the harbor.
For the Narrows, when the flow to the south, or the ebb, begins,
the water level is at 2.8 feet above the mean low water plane and
falling. While the ebb flow continues the surface falls from 2.8
feet above mean low water to mean low water and then rises to 17
feet above mean low water,
At the end of this tidal period, the entire body of water in the
channel from the Narrows south to the entrance of the Ambrose
Channel and on the shoals at either side to the elevation of 1.7 is of
that derived from other parts of the harbor.
When the flood current sets in, a circulation similar to that at
Throgs Neck takes place. It is estimated that the volume of normal
sea water passing through the Narrows during each flood equals
2.398.800.000 cubie feet.
The estimated volumes of water in the various areas are as follows:
16—Ex, 136
EIS see
4029
ET AL.
JERSEY
s
a
z
&
we
&
<
&
RD
=
<=
&
008'GRe'Z0k 006'989'°S0%
OOD FOR’ LOC’ L OO0G' LOS'SOG'L
OOS LOO'SIG'S OOL'ENT'DIT'S
001'900'ZtR'F L900 FSF
00s'08s'068'S O08 ‘ORS‘068"S
OOO'ZIS'SNE'ZI 00028" 186'LL
OOS‘OOL'LES'LT = -OOLF62 "FOOT
_ “Peo "qqq
yO pue 4B “4z “nd
‘euIN[OA [BIO]
Oze"ee9' OT
OOS EES ELE T
OSO'TEE GEE
SSL LLT' 963
O26 FE6'F
OFS ORE LEC'L
099'°990' 18z 099'990' L8z
000°ZS9'S8F'T O00" E86" LOG
Ose LO EL8'L OF’ COE 072
‘pool “aq
_ ———_——_—- - —
JO pua ye “yz ‘no ‘wstid [epry
yO ouInjo,
OOY FLY FG
GLECOG LES
OOS OOF L6
L68'S880'8FI
OS E8S'OFI
ORE GLE'OSS
OOL'S86'0SS
43 ‘bs
‘vaiBe
(VPLL
‘§ Trav
ooo'zen'set JeAyY Wey
ORG'LOF'LZo'O OCCT testes WOON
SA0IGL 0} 98H [PH ‘JAY IBA
0OL'e9Z'9IT'E ee ayuy eH 0} ‘I9@ATU qeug
CORTE VEGF ee padng uajyéndg oO
q902}8 qIXx}s-AJeUJN ‘Jea;y uUospny
009'89L'6GOL'S ee ee 3300138
qyx}s-Qeujn 0} ‘aay = vwospny
000'068'62L0' LT ee seq aaddy
007 66E' F800 Terre ee ee ee ee seq IMO]
“ay "no
‘OUINJOA “£4 B00'T
jeuuegy
oe
17—Ex. 186
4030 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
27 An exact determination of the amount of water in any one
of the areas at any tidal period derived from the various tribu-
tary areas is manifestly impracticable, but it is possible to make an
analysis based on reasonable assumptions of flow as shown hereafter;
and the reliability of the analysis is susceptible of indirect proof
should the determination of pollution obtained thereby agree with
the chemical analysis of the waters.
Tests for dissolved oxygen in the harbor waters have been made
by the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission at various points, but it
does not appear that any series of tests were made through an entire
cross-section of any of the channels during an entire tidal period.
The results published in the Commission’: report are interesting
and instructive, but they do not give a certain measure of the
average condition of the waters. In September, 1910, under the
direction of the United States authorities, Prof. Earle B, Phelps
made a series of determinations of dissolved oxygen through 4
cross-section of the Hudson, opposite Mount St. Vincent, close to
the northern city limit and covering nearly an entire 12-hour
period. The total number of samples taken was 42, The percent-
age of sea water varied from 40.5 per cent. to 55.5 per cent., with
an average of 42.2 per cent. Dissolved oxygen was found in quanti-
ties varying from 3.6 per cent, to 66.5 per cent. of the saturation
values, with an average of 51.2 per cent. The effect of this pollution
on the harbor capacity for receiving sewage is very apparent in the
figures given later for the capacity of the “Upper Hudson” at ebb,
and “Harlem” at flood periods.
From the figures given in Table No. 3 for the flow and volume
of water in the various areas of the harbor, together with the Coast
and Geodetic Survey determinations of velocities, a study was made
of the probable sources of the waters in each area at the end of the
flood and ebb.*
As an example, the Upper Bay at the end of the ebb is taken.
The ebb flow through the Narrows is known. This water is
drawn from the Upper Bay and the waters tributary to it, and these
again are replaced by those drawn from sources still further up.
The volume in the Upper Bay (channel plus tidal prism volume), at
the beginning of the ebb is 12,656,512,000 cubic feet. The ebb flow
through the Narrows is 13,819,895,144 cubic feet, giving a re
mainder of 1,254,383,144 cubic feet, drawn from the Kill von Kull
and the Hudson and East Rivers. This was proportioned arbi-
trarily among the three as seemed just. The volume in the Upper
Bay at the end of the ebb is 11,981,875,000 cubic feet. This water
is composed entirely of that received from the Kill von Kull, East
and Hudson Rivers. Considering the current velocities, it was
found that the portion received from the East River comprised all
of the water from the Battery to Hell Gate plus a portion of that
in the area from Hell Gate to Throgs Neck. Also, that the portion
received from the Hudson River was equal to all of that in the area
* The writers are indebted to Mr. W. L. Kuehnle for valuable assistance in
this study.
18—Ex. 136
bl ee
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4031
from the Battery to Ninety-sixth street, plus a portion of that in
the area from Ninety-sixth street to Spuyten Duyvil. The same
method was followed for the other areas. For convenience, these
volumes were reduced to percentages and the various volumes were
given a characteristic letter,
Let A and A’ represent the water in the Lower Bay east of line
joining Sandy Hook, West Bank Light and Fort Wadsworth
Light at the end of the flood and ebb, respectively.
28 B and B’ represent the waters in the Upper Bay.
C and C’ represent the waters in the Hudson River from
the Battery to Ninety-sixth street.
D and D’ represent the waters in the Hudson River from Ninety-
sixth street to Spuyten Duyvil.
E and FE’ represent the waters in the East River from the Battery
to Hell Gate.
F and F”’ represent the waters in the East River from Hel] Gate
to Throgs Neck.
G and G’ represent the waters in the Harlem River.
Let K denote the waters received from the Kill von Kull.
L the waters received from the Hudson River above Spuyten
Duyvil.
M the clean waters received from the Sound at one end and the
sea at the other.
Let n denote the tide under consideration, either ebb or flood.
Let n-1 denote the previous tide either floor or ebb,
Let n-2 denote the second previous tide, either ebb or flood.
TABLE 4
As = 11,957,760,800 cu. ft. (M)
BR, = .¢868 A ,.; + 2,398,821,800 cu. ft. (M)
Cy = .0132 A’s-5 + .4384 B’a4
D, = .0697 B’ns+ .7435 C’o-1
E, =.2934 B’s-1
F, =.0410 B’ gy + E’n-1 + .4976 F'n-1+ .6323 Gas
G, = .0094 C’pn-1 + .0365 D’,.4 + .3675 G'n-1
For the end of the ebb
A’, =.6880 By-1 + .1420 Cy: + .2220 E,-; + 113,303,400 cu. ft. (K)
B’, = .8580 Cy4+ .3316 Dos + .7780 Ey4+ 1760 F,-; + 1,676,800,000 cu. ft. (K)
C’n =.2473 C’o-a+ .1§49 D’n-9 + .6684 Dns + .2462 Gos
D’, =. 8088 D’p-s+ .5305 Ge-1 + 766,383,700 cu. ft. (L)
E’, =.4129 Fs
F’,, =.4085 F’ss+ .3945 Fo-1+ 1,496,222,009 cu. ft. (M)
G'g = 0176 Fait .2333 Go-t
19—Ex, 136
4032 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
Taste 5.
For the end of the flood, obtained by substituting the actual
volumes for the percentages of Table 4.
As =11,957.7 million cu.ft. (M)
B, = 10,165.7 million cu. ft. (A’,;) + 2,398.8 million cu. ft. (M)
‘2 =138.1 million cu. ft. (Ag) + 5,252.7 million cu. tt. (B’,-1)
D, =835.2 million cu. ft. (B’,.) + 4,007.3 million cu. ft. (C’,.1)
E, =3,515.6 million cu. ft. (B’s 1)
F, =491.6 million cu. ft. (B’,..) + 3,116.3 million cu. ft. (E’,;) + 3,766.6 million cu. fr.
(F’,-1)+ 128.8 million cu. ft. (G’s-:)
G, =50.6 million cu. ft. (C’s1)+ 177.0 million cu. ft. (D’,..) + 74.8 million cu. ft. (G’,)
29 For the end of the ebb
A’, =8.644.8 million cu. ft. (B,s) + 766.2 million cu. ft. (C,.)+ 780.5 million cu. ft.
(E,-1) + 113.3 million cu. ft. (K)
B’, = 4,624.7 million’ cu. ft. (C, ») + 1,605.9 million cu. ft. (D, 1) + 2,735.1 million cu. ft.
(E,-1) + 1,338 8 millon cu. ft. (F,.)+ 1,676.9 million cu. ft. (K)
C’, =1,332.9 million cu. ft (C’,-2)+ 749.8 million cu. ft. (D’,-2) + 3,236.7 million cu. ft.
(D,-4)+ 71.4 million cu. ft. (Gos)
D’, =3.915.7 million cu. ft. (D ,2)+ 160.4 million cu. ft. (G_1) + 766.4 million cu. ft. (L)
E’, =3,116.3 million cu. ft (F,.)
F’, =3.091 9 million cu. ft. (F’s-2) + 2,980.8 million cu. ft. (F.1) + 1,496.2 million cu. ft. (M)
G’, =133.1 million cu.-ft. (F,-1) + 70.5 million cu. ft. (G,-1)
TaB_e 6.
In percentages of the volume in each area in question the formule
become:
For the end of the flood
2 107 (M)
BR, =80 91¢ (A’s-1) 4+ 19.114 (M)
C, =2.57% (A’s-1) + 97.43% (B’e-1)
D, =17.24% (B’,1) + 82.764 (C’,-1)
E, = 100% (B4)
= 6.55% (B’.1) + 41.53% (E’n-1) + $0.202 (F’,.;)+ 1.729 (G’,1)
G, =24.7$% (G'n.1)+ 16.71% (C’n-1) + §8.54% (D's)
For the end of the ebb
A’, =83. 89% (Bas) + 7.45% (Cos) + 7-562 (Ex) + 1. tog (K)
B’, =38 607 (Cys) + 13.40% (D,) + 22.832 (Ens) + 11.177 (Fp-1) + 14.40% (K)
'» =24.72% (C'o2) + 13.92% (Dns) + 60.047 (D.s)+ 1.324 (Ge)
‘n = 80.867 (D’n-4)+ 3.385 (Gus)+ 15.89% (L)
| = 1004 (F,1)
F’, = 40.85 (F’s-2) + 39.38% (Fa-s)+ 19.77% (M)
G’, =65.38¢ (Fas) + 34.627 (Go)
20—Ex. 136
ee i oe Te ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ae
—_
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4033
Capacity of the Harbor Waters to Receive Sewage Without Undue
Pollution.
From the equations given above the composition of the waters
of each of the parts of the harbor can be calculated for any tidal
period. Jamaica Bay is entirely independent, and its capacity is
discussed separately in the special report submitted on the drainage
area tributary to it. The Lower Bay to the west of the channel
leading to the Narrows is also independent. Its waters are changed
with each tide, and the circulation between the Kill von Kull and
the Arthur Kill is but slight.
It may be assumed with safety that the west part of the Lower
Bay has sufficient capacity to receive and care for all «* the sewage
from its drainage area. Our data is insufficient to show with cer-
tainty the conditions in the Arthur Kill, but from the tidal con-
ditions it is evident that its capacity is not large and it is now
30 receiving over 16,000,000 gallons per day from the New Jer-
sey sewer systems discharging into it. VPurther discussion of
this capacity will be found in Chapter IV., in the report on the Bor-
ough of Richmond.
Returning to the other portions of the harbor discussed in the
preceding pages it may be stated that their only source of supply
of unpolluted water is from the sea and Sound—and that the
oxygen of this supply is augmented to any appreciable degree only
through reaeration while in the harbor.
Much misapprehension exists as to the extent to which the harbor
waters renew their oxygen from this source and it is, therefore,
deemed advisable to go jnto this subject somewhat extensively. The
subject has been under investigation for some years by Prof. Phelps,
and his conclusions are embodied in the following chapters. For
present purposes it is sufficient to state that under the most favorable
assumptions the absorption of oxygen from the air (reaeration) in
the waters of New York Harbor will give an increase of 1.9 per
cent. of the saturation value in 24 hours or of 0.475 per cent, in a
six-hour period.
| Our studies have shown that the volume of pure sea water which
enters the harbor limits between the Narrows and Throgs Neck each
twelve hours is 29,135 million gallons, which contain under summer
conditions about 1,946,218 pounds of dissolved oxygen. If this
oxygen were to be reduced to 70 per cent. of the saturation value
by sewage reduction, 583,865 pounds would be so used in the twelve
hours. The total volume of water in New York Harbor within the
limits named is 251,418 million gallons; if this is reduced to 70
per cent. it will in itself absorb.in twelve hours 0.95 per cent. of its
saturation value or 159,550 pounds. This with the amount avail-
able from the pure sea water entering gives a total of 743,415 pounds
of oxygen. This assuming a sewerage production of 100 gallons per
capita per day would care for a population of 7.4 millions.
_The above figures show great possibilities could all of the sewage
discharge be concentrated at the two entrances, and there thoroughly
21—Ex. 136
ee a ee ee EEN RTs yt e-eee tee
4034 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
diffused through the channels. Under existing conditions of dis
charge but little advantage is taken of them since only a small pro
portion of the pure water ever reaches the shores of Manhattan, as is
shown by the equations of tables 4, 5 and 6. These equations indi-
cate, however, that the nearer the sewage is carried to the harbor
entrances, the greater will be the amount that can be cared for with-
out undue pollution of the waters.
The existing population in New York and vicinity, whose sewage
is emptied into the various areas is shown in the following table,
which has been compiled from the best available sources: the sew-
age discharge is computed at 100 gallons per capita per day.
31 TABLE 7.
Estimated
sewage Estimated
Estimated fortwenty- sewage for
Locality. population. fourbours six hours
in million in million
cubic feet. cubic f
Rr TE evcccsarcesrecvsececeseneers 1% 7 WV
SR GE seevecrreetseetcrctvetendtve 367.816 4.9 1.23°
C—Hudson River, Battery to Ninety-sixth
Gerccdecvcrceresseadieutessaveetee 755,992 10.1 2.53
D—Hudson River, Ninety-sixth street to
es DUES cccrveccoccesedecdees 165.260 2.2 ns)
E—East River. Battery to Hell Gate........ 2,212,295 29.6 7.4
F—East River, Hell Gate to Throgs Neck... 246,601 3.3 =
Ge TFG ccc ccccccccvesvesvcoveree 651.098 8.7 2.18
Si cvsvcsdecttedecvcereeweves 4,449,257
* To this will be added the sewage from the Passaic Valley System, when com-
pleted, 4.28 million cubic feet, which, when discharged, will be freed from 20 per
cent. of its putrescible organic contents.
If we assume that the total oxygen of the waters is not to be re-
duced more than 30 per cent., there will be 20.4 pounds of oxygen
available for each million gallons of pure water contained in each
area during any tidal period. Reaeration in 12 hours would in-
crease the oxygen contents by 0.6 pounds per million gallons of the
total volume of water. This would make the following additional
amount of oxygen available for each area for each six-hour period.
Tape 8
11,131.2 million cubic feet = 83,261.4 million gallons = 49,956 pounds oxygel.
12,273.7 million cubic feet = 91.807.3 million gallons = 55,084 pounds oxygen
5,390.8 million cubic feet == 40.223.2 million gallons = 24,19 pounds oxyge..
4,842.5 million cubic feet = 36.221.9 million gallons = 21,733 pounds oxyge®
3,315.9 million cubic feet = 24.802.9 million gallons = 14.882 pounds oxyged.
7,526.1 million cubic feet = 56,270.0 million gallons = 33,822 pounds oxyge
253.0 million cubic feet = 1,492.4 million gallons = 1.135 pounds oxyge®
Qumyamp
Wunnnn
Were it not for the circulation of the waters back and forth be
tween the different areas it would be a simple matter to determine
the amount of sewage the waters of each area could care for without
undue pollution, or the average pollution of these waters under exist-
22—Ex. 126
EB am me GEN WOES a pete > - , ~
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4035
ing conditions with the sewage thoroughly diffused through them.
Inder conditions as they exist, however, it is necessary to com-
pute the dilution through a number of successive tides.
Using the formule in Table 4 and the figures for sewage in Table
7, the amount of sewage received in each area from the various
sources was computed. To this was added the additional amount of
sewage from the various waters, computed by means of the
32 same formule, through successive tides. With the amount of
sewage thus obtained the percentage of dilution for each tide
was obtained. The change in the dilution ratio for each area for
successive tides of the same character was found to be a decreasing
one. These ratios were then plotted and the points joined by a rez-
ular curve. From these curves the ultimate dilution ratio was then
taken. These ratios are given in Table 9.
In considering these dilution ratio=, it must be remembered that
a safe ratio for dilution for one waterway cannot be assumed as safe
for another. It is evident that if the flow of the waterway is in one
direction only, the pollution added at a given point affects only the
waters down stream from that point, whereas in a tidal stream, the
polluted waters may return past the original point of pollution many
times before being finally removed. Again for safety, this ratio
must be a function of the rate of reaeration of the waterway, or of
the time before its waters are further purified by an additional sup-
ply of unpolluted water. Other considerations such as the uses to
which the polluted waters are put and the character of the territory
through which they flow have also weight in determining the safe
ratio.
As shown by studies of Brooklyn sewage, for reduction to a stable
form each million gallons of -ewage will require the consumption of
between 1,500 and 6,000 pounds of oxygen under summer condi-
tions, of which from 500 to 2.000 pounds is taken up in twelve
hours. If we assume an average oxygen consumption of 2,000
pounds per million gallons of sewage and an increase of oxygen
supply of 475 per cent. of saturation value for reaeration in <ix
hours, the oxygen contents may be calculated ; these values are given
in Table 9. They are approximate and for summer conditions only.
4036 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.
Tasiz 9.
Per cent. of oxygen present.
Area. Dilution Without With
Flood.
Raccesttereeorersevesetuedévesteens antaaonn 100 100
i ndecdimdbeotiearbanbebeebedindinniiiies 1 in 120 75.0 75.5
Sl bianitsinbeguminheedddedemuaimemeinmasio lin 4.0 4.4
habemeeebdibeedtedadedsbewanisene lin 58 48.4 48.9
ES ae: lin @& 82.5 53.0
at seisdincdeemninaaacidgaidéwalbudtiieemn & nine 1 in 100 7.1 70.6
EEE SALE Te COME ieee lin ® 38.4° 40.6
Ebb.
inadbentedbesdebennenesetéeonennn 1 in 100 70.1 70.6
iiss iaiteiaescsdiel delbikcceayesidalaceaiecaiia eae lin @& H.0 hHh4
iebdedibesesneessamtboesesanounes lin 57 47.5 47.9
i hindipibintdianiels onineminimeaibinneiainie lin 5% 45 .6° 46.0
thietatinibsemerneeduinebedondoasite 1 in 100 70.1 70.6
ER eI 1 in 150 80.0 80.5
SP idebsiebusnbreeseseaeenenesaeediaen lin © wO.1 0.6
* Largely result of pollution of Hudson above limits of Greater New York.
33 Calculations were then made on the assumption that all the
sewage discharged into the Hudson within the limits of
Greater New York and into the Harlem as well as that discharged
into the Upper Bay from the Passaic Valley sewer is reduced two-
thirds by purification. These computations were made in the same
manner as the foregoing and the results are given in the table be
low, which are also approximate and for summer conditions.
Tasiz 10.
Per cent. of oxygen present.
Area. Dilution Without With
Flood.
OD ccccereccesoreeessrsrrerersensowses ceucunce 100 100
i cucsecevocersereceureentesootaete 1 in 200 85.0 85.5
ederseeesuaveteronedaceveseeoseors lin 80 62.6 63.0
iP saveueneraoeoerreneerensaasoussere lin 80 62.6 63.0
al Sudeudhtorgetabevdutetoeereseness lin 75 0.0 6.5
i epetecouvenceucseerecesereeoerere 1 in 120 75.0 75.5
DP durcoccdenérerceuoseussoeerooresre lin 70 57.2° 57.7
Ebb.
reveredoseceeoreersoesseereseness 1 in 190 4.3 RES
Piepuseeatonspeeseresteorerseseus lin 77 61.1 61.6
uveveeesererceeereceuvesveueseredes lin 8 62.6 63.0
EP wescecewerervecesesesuscoescqreson lin 2 51.7° 52.2
iuereeddebeeuseserenivesceseenencs 1 ip 120 75.0 75.5
PP neswpousoueotecereeutesetoeserons 1 ip 180 83.4 83.9
euducescecerssoreesceresdesecéocens lin 9 6. 67.2
* Result of pollution of Hudson River above limits of Greater New York.
24— Ex. 136
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4037
Computations were next made to show what would result if the
discharge of sewage were made at the two entrances of the harbor,
at the Narrows and near Throgs Neck.
Assuming that the sewage discharged into areas B, C, D, 4% E
and % G is discharged at the Narrows, and that from areas % E,
F and % G at Throgs Neck, computations were made by means of
the same formule and in the same manner as before. The results
for summer conditions are shown in the following table:
A Tapiz 11.
Per cent. of oxygen present.
Ares. Dilution Without With
ratio. reaeration.
Flood.
BD coccrccvcvccrocceesorouscceoanvese eneneere 100 19
DB cevecovcvccscesoesseesesesceosorss 1 in 210 85.8 86.3
DP pcedesecetensserecetureorecessesde 1 in 200 85.0 85.5
D covcccoserescoseoseceveceoroorses . 1 in 140 78.6 79.1
Meweveecenvedceuesseecnescecandeses 1 in 240 87.5 88.0
D cecveccocoecvevceeroevoesooceeoress 1 in 220 86.4 86.9
D eveccceceseccesereereserooncesseus lin 90 6 .7* 67.2
Ebb.
DP ccocececseeececenovesesseeiereres 1 in 210 85.8 86.3
DP ccccccccveecceseosseceeevecoeseres 1 in 240 87.5 aS
Povecceecosccvsoecoressveresedeeees 1 in 130 77.1 77.5
Peecxgevenveceeseneveeveeseourveses lin 72 re .4* 58.9
iw coecececerereseoecerverserersvece 1 in 220 86.4 86.9
Poccoeveesersegescoverscoseroosnce . 1 in 240 87.5 88.0
Pi cccccecesceeveeeevesveresvrvecves 1 in 150 80.0 80.4
Table 11 shows the results of the concentration of the discharge
of the sewage of the entire drainage area of the harbor at the Nar-
rows and at Throgs Neck, with the existing population. Referring
to the computations of available oxygen given on page 34, about
two-thirds of the amount would be available at the Narrows and
one-third at Throgs Neck.
35 Chapter IT.
The Absorption of Atmospheric Oxygen by Water.
Quiescent Water.
Discussion of the Problem.
Atmospheric oxygen is soluble to a limited extent in water, the
maximum amount which can thus be dissolved under any given set
of conditions being known as the “saturation value.” Under the
fairly uniform conditions of with which we have to deal
the saturation value is chiefly a function of temperature. Like
other gases oxygen is practically insoluble in boiling water and the
ee a POR i Re -eRRRaoat me mg eins
ee
4035 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.
solubility increases progressively with decreasing temperature. The
fomponition of the water has al~ some influence, salt water dimoly.
ing oxygen than fre-h water under the <anre conditions, We
may confine cur attention for the present to the behavior of oxygen
in water, pr the laws of diffusion mee solubility which we shall
consider are of general ication to ot such as
and carbon dioxide. ned — —
If a given column of water, containing les oxygen in solution
than it can take up under the existing conditions, is exposed to the
atmosphere, it begins te absorb oxygen. This process proceeds at
a decreasing rate. governed by certain fixed laws until a condition of
saturation is reached. The rate of this al<orption has been the sub-
ject of several investigations. the late-t bet known of which
were made by Adeney, (1) in connection with his investigations
of the pollution of waters by sewage Adeney exposed long tubes of
partially deaerated water, i. ¢. water containing in solution lew
oxygen than would be required to <aturate it, to the
After various interval of time and from various depths specimens
of the water were removed for analysis. In this way, valuable in-
formation was obtained as to the amount of oxygen, and other
gases, almerhed by a column of water under the conditions of the
variable factors are was not shown byw thie work and <erieus mix
use of Adenev's figures has made by others, ax will be pointed
36 be arrived at through a mathematical study of the law it-elf,
coupled with an experimental investigation to determine the
constants involved. This experimental work must be so planned
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4034
beth the theoretical and the experimental portions of the writer's
studies have led te quite different conclusions. it will he necessary to
dewrile our early methods and result~ and al<o certain experiments
undertaken ty the writer later to explain the apparent discrepancies
The physical theory of absorption will first he briefly stated. In
order that there shall he alsorption it is alwavs presupposed that
water contains lex oxygen than ix required to saturate it. Let it
assumed, as an initial condition. that «uch a body of water. hav-
ing a uniform oxygen content throughout its depth.
|
containing 80 per cent. as much oxygen as it can contain, will
start to absorb twice as rapidly as will water at 90 per cent. of satura-
tien. This is the well-known law of rate of solution and is the first
} important
principle known as the law of hvdro-diffusion. Thir principle
shows that any dissolved substance existing in different concentra-
tions at different parts of the solution tends to diffue toward
int of low concentration. In its full quantitative expression the
hyvdro-diffusion, known from t+ discoverer (3) as Fick's law,
rate of diffuxien of anv dissolved sul-tance through
27— Ex. 136
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
—..|
25
©. 105" «© con®
—) & oo oO 779° + —- >
b= mou
HOA) ist | et 2H
+ uy Lill ra} ; i ih
Piiltse i He te dh:
Eels rihiit Histat as i
gar ae : 3s ta i
SBE
Pera te Leah teeta
alee Ait Ht
HUI emir dai
NTA
een iy a f
ait dt HBT THE Milt ‘|
© This metbod is described im the appendix
Valuce of Diffusion Cocficient of Orygen in Distilled Water at
Various Temperatures.
COO OTe
eee eee ee ee ee eee eee eee eee eee eee eee
ee ee ee ee eee ee ee ee ee
"rr eee ee ee eee eee ee eee
ee eee OO ORC eee eer wwe rrrre#
Having utilized the formula in the experimental determination
df Geo exelent, wo may new sovenn the possem and apaly cur ae
culatwons to the practical problem of aleorption. Since the law gov-
ering the course of this absorption hax been formulated, and is seen
to contain factors for the variable conditions to be met with, such
ication may be made with awurance of reasonable accuracy.
ider. first. conditions in quiescent fresh water. Other condition:
be It ix olwious that the rate of abkorption inte a
uit
|
i
ir
:
z
:
H
si
ii
i}
1
ff
ik
z
s e
i+ the time allowed for al ion. This requires no
A third factor ie the initial comtition,
the body of water. the -lower will be the rate of almurytion.
te
Phy
hi
32
1
He
il
f
if
.
4042 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.
iw
TaBLe 12.
ount of Oryuen Absorbed from the Atinosphere by a Quicscont Body of
Fresh Water at 20° ©. During Stated Periods of Time, at Stated Depths
and with Stated Initial Concentration, Expressed in per Cent, of Satura-
tion.
Time in hours.
Initial concentration, — +
per cent. saturation. 1 6 10 12 20
Depth Five Feet.
Sauls piri ie euens eae nw eas er 0.83 2.17 2.80 3.05 3.93 4.45
vueuttyshuws tdueessanaese 0.74 1.9% 2.52 2.74 3.53 4.00
cbtewsavbbaceru ene er eres 0.58 1.52 1.96 2.14 2.74 3.12
Dl eceverewii gen iwathenires 0.42 1.08 1.40 1.52 1.96 2.22
Pr POSEN Tree ys. e 0.25 0.65 0.84 0.92 1.18 1.34
Perry Try Terry te tt 0.08 0.22 0.28 0.31 0.39 0.45
be ccerdacaoegtteenyesbed 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
eae weerersebanetetes ¥e's 0.30 1.05 1.45 1.53 1.97 2.17
eivernerrie rs veseenoeHe 0.27 0.94 1.30 1.38 1.77 1.95
peeseteeseddvereteresoes 0.21 0.74 1.02 1.07 1.38 1.52
OPT TT TT TELL Add ide 0.15 0.52 0.72 0.76 0.98 1.08
parser erwereTmeyN sects 0.09 0.32 0.44 0.46 0.59 0.65
pevereeesrererseereneeee 0.08 0.11 0.18 0.15 0.20 0.22
bee ke eed aN Sed 108 2049 8F9 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Depth Fifteen Feet.
egw eawnetoerEnreneenn® 0.15 0.00 0.87 0.96 1.30 1.45
Dad a tewenked sed Cee t ONS 0.14 0.54 0.7 0.86 HS 1.30
Crtavescedowevenaden ery 0.10 0.42 0.61 0.67 0.9) 1.02
eitedenevese kag etereeris 0.08 0.30 0.44 0.48 0.65 0.72 °
re ee tr 0.04 0.18 0.26 0.29 0.39 0.44
nb eeteerres rawetsaae Res 0.02 0.06 0.09 0.10 0.13 0.15
nd udidedadswsdoneneeees 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Depth Twenty Feet.
eee s uenanodcee hoewbe oe 0.40 0.57 0.6 0.93
weebeareseresnseosutnsee 0.09 0.36 0.51 0.60 0.
shbaseew suisse erereerewe 0.07 0.28 0.40 0.47 0.65
Dn artnk Mae Fae We Te Ae 0.05 0.20 0.28 0.34 O46
a cla aie Ca COONS EER 0.03 0.12 0.17 0.20 0.28
iiesewes ive boereseenwne 0.01 0.04 0.06 0.07 0.09
beewav~ere Keravvaweeesene 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
30—Ex, 136
ass
+ott!
reer
faeee:
i aie
+444
+e bby
+4444
4-4-4
an +
- -
++
het +
eee
peed
TH T
4 wemews ow t 1 4
t ee sees
oa! + L344 + 4 i. s gane8 af
see it +H t ae 7
444 + Tr eta | +t H ,- a8
wt a6 + ry pause tt -
rt he 1 “a tt
> rr a
ry agecse
eee +++
a seus ‘
te
5b 4-4-4-4-4-4-4
}
4-4
-
+
+t444
e
but
+
tet
++ +4 Tytt
Bi
+
titttt
seen
tre
rit
+
i
enue
a
tee
aus
qq sesees
tr Seese_esenase!
it +» r igeae a
r+ 444444 anal
HH seaggecese
4 £4 ttt +
qouquasess!
- - 4
+ + asa
t re ++ an
rt sauaes: TH
: : sent Li
+ ; ett+ $ eet +t
paw + T t + rte
; : — an tt
rote Tt
eens
+
+
+
HF
: +
tert
et eeee
toe tee yet
22 66eee*
e++p e+
teeters
t+ bee
teeter
toe bees
trees
titi
teehee
tetetet
+344-4-44
ees SS.
ee as
tees
o> +
shh bete
ssecuurn
Ssesessse:
Sesseer =
4.
i.
=s
t+
.
t
‘
tr
+
t
rote
ene
Fk mt I36-p. 4A
eb bbe te
b ++ >
‘
sooceses
> Tv
+
peesses ai
te ty ethe
t t
Secesees:
+4 +4 eo
eeaeues!
tiittitr
pe seene:
ee eet
seeegers:
+tetrte
jeasecet
+
-
feet 9 ed nem OD
SOR RT eh 8S pa AEA me NE he P10 AB IA EG Pet ASE Ce ME
PEW AI ROI LD eae! IRE Ad Ta
tet ettttt
_ aeeu abaandeane rr ry
— . r —— eauebeceanenes - - 4 r
ier \eeseeeel seesesse HH tit} H ttt peseat t Soa
ae gaeskeseeas + t . el S3hss: + b+
pas cusnsenses se raed Soease6:
oe rT \ +4 +4444-44 M pee eas 1 +
a +1 4 N 7 t tt TT eet +4 . : tt t as 4 4 +4
aes + Tht et : pssst baa TN seats: .
eeens $0805 66. 0500058 508 . rttttth +4 ‘ ++
{ * os oa) SHAN itt Th ; th ‘
~ +4 ' +t? 7 FT t ~T | 4 +4 +
H ; Ht HAH Lt ease +H 44-444 444
‘ Be + + +t 2 8 bees st + san ‘ $444 4
‘ a Pq a
s S3as8 " a ton see +4 + , +4444 t 4 eae
Ht I Nat HH Ha B TR a
eanese: ana ttt 4 7 a
Rees 44 , +4 4 444 ttt 4 TH
se . eter .
+ a. > + r . +4 i: ae r+ +t 8 al
t es r 4 . + 44 + 44 +t:
7 ee! 4 na : een - a 2 oe 1 s rT Sane " gee ;
+ + +4 ae 7 ‘ s +4 4 as ;
i + tty ++ a begess +7 eo tt -{ s Ch
| 4 + , + b tt ee ++ tet T ttt ® ‘ Ttth
ee + +++ ana & - ~Tr 1 a een
: s tT ane Teh hh an tt ae a
i se + 4 + “4 - =
=o ++ ewes t :
+ +4 + + ' rt tae t eae Susebs tit
tHitt ; : : Ty +4
WH t HT p2esss' 7 4 ]
z of =ee b bth ann |
b 1 Sa, aa ee ee e
t ee at Lia. 4 : + +4 + + > |
+t 2 r HH 4 _
Tt ae a a8
.
uses ae tt ty
UMASS tit H - Ht rr it See seas
- 4+4- + + >
4 5 =
8) HH ttt] 8 e Se ensessens 444 + mbes Seaeei ;
. 7 { =i ‘ wi pte ® = 7 +t + ol
™— ( 7 + 4 +444 444
b+ $4 +4 +++ + t ae ss
. eeeenee shesssesse } 1 r saeeeeee ++ Ty 7 i 4 « :
: . 4 ttt tT epenaue
; = NM ttt a Ht > Ht - ry +r pes ee t an T = ’ - Mt :
tt ; aeene oe nee
Ve +4 - ++ 4+ +444 4 ‘
. = eees eee tt . tt eas na 2 T see
- +++ +444
=e +
ttt Hy rt pees ieee . F +4
: “ +++ - aaee
i 1
eee Hh Ht pea! TTT
: THT re at Tr +
eeq eeaee 4 +t ‘ > at
: Beeeasacnasees Pees eeRhs Peehsenees nes 28 nt tH
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4043
#0 TaBLe 13.
{mount of Orngaen Absorbed from the Atmosphere bu a Quiescent Body of
Preah Water at 20° ©, During Stated Periods of Time, at Stated Depths
and with Stated Initial Concentration, Expressed in Pounds per Million
Gallons.
Time in hours.
Initial concentration, lam — a,
per cent. saturation. 1 6 10 12 20 24
Depth Five Feet.
DR peswrentetcuws reverses 0.636 1.66 2.14 2.34 3.00 3.41
peomeeeteueteneneetends 0.566 1.49 1.93 2.10 2.70 3.06
huveveseecreneredseerese 0.444 1.16 1.5 1.64 2.0 2.39
eed eebteceuedeveevowe 0.322 O.827 1.07 1.16 1.50 1.68
Leeeerensueverroerresess 0.193 0.497 0.643 0.704 0.904 1.03
‘inGearedversrerhecterute 0.064 0.166 0.214 0.254 0.300 0.341
_peeebeeorereonuers serous 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Depth Ten Feet.
Lpusperroeurecersertenees 0.229 O.804 = 1.11 1.17 1.51 1.66
ee eeeeereeredteerndes eer 0.207 0.720 0.995 1.06 1.36 1.49
eepeesgubweroeerverrees 0.16 0.566 0.781 O.820 1.06 1.16
Lembo wendereeveondeenes 0.115 0.398 O.551 0.581 0.750 0.827
cbedeceoneeerwneueenes 0.069 O.2445 6.331 0.252 0.452 0.497
peoveroorerriucvenrerees 0.023 0.080 =60.111 0.12 0.151 0.166
poebereeeesevereestereus 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Depth Fifteen Feet.
Lwtvereeroeresreereerese 0.115 0.459 0.666 0.735 0.996 1.11
‘eu apenewerenenwarbivete 0.107 0.413 O.597 0.65 0.896 0.995
eeeeeneretonvucesborees 0.077 0.322 0.467 0.513 0.696 0.781
Sireveees peeersesouseetees 0.061 0.230 0.2337 0.367 0.497 0.551
bereveverseovererererers 0.051 0.128 0.199 0.222 0.209 0.337
ss pavecressonswerees 0.012 0.046 0.067 0.074 0.100 06.111
seoreeucesweveeevereeeees 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
Depth Twenty Feet.
poueevensdes se ceeeeeves? 0.077 0.306 0.436 0.513 0.712 0.804
ieresevesorvecrsseeseues 0.069 0.276 0.390 0.459 0.648 0.721
guesemeverentoerervers 0.054 0.214 0.306 0.360 0.497 0.566
bveetweourevestousoerses 0.088 0.153 0.214 0.260 0.352 0.308
eueeseeusetdeeceroosooes 0.023 0.092 0.130 0.153 0.214 0.245
Tbesbevudeeorerveverecses 0.008 0.031 0.044 0.051 0.071 0.080
BPvccevsevedorees veceerees) Oe 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
(Here follow diagrams 1, 2, 3, and 4, marked pages 41 to 44, Complainants’
Exhibit 136.)
31—Ex., 136
4044 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.
45 The results of the calculations are given in Tables 12 (per
cent, of saturation) and 13 (pounds per million gallons),
The same information is given graphically in Diagrams 1 to 4.
It is seen that, in quiescent fresh water at least, the rate of absorp-
tion is so low that reaeration in this case cannot play an important
part in self-purification. A ten-foot column of water, for example,
starting at 50 per cent. of saturation, would absorb only enouw
oxygen in 24 hours to bring its average oxygen content up to ol
per cent. The dependence of the rate of absorption upon the initial
condition is also clearly shown. For example, the amount of oxy-
gen which will be absorbed from the atmosphere in one hour by a
ten-foot column of water containing only 10 per cent. of the satu-
ration value of oxygen is nine times as great as is the case with an
initial value of 90 per cent. It should also be noted that the rate of
reaeration is rapid at first and diminishes quickly with time. This
rapid initial absorption involves an initial condition of uniform
mixing in the column of water under consideration. In practice
such a condition seldom obtains, and it is in general the absorption
occurring after the first or later hours that are of practical value.
In a quiescent body of water the average hourly rate after 24 hours
or even longer periods and not the rate during the first hours after
uniform mixing, is the proper value for use. This point, which dis
tinguishes the condition of quiescent water from that of water
having vertical movements, will be referred to again in the discus
sion of the effect of winds and boats.
Application.
A serious misuse has been made of the results reported by Adeney
in that his rates of absorption into fully deaerated water of com-
paratively shallow depths have been used to determine the rate of
reaeration of a natural body of water which in the nature of things
would have much greater depth and would never be permitted to
approach a condition of complete deaeration. For example, a
recent writer has stated (4) “In tidal salt water the results may be,
on the whole, better, for while half fresh water and half salt water
will contain less oxygen when saturated, its powers of reaeration are
almost double fresh water. At 64° F. it will draw from the air 0.62
of a pound per hour per million gallons of its volume, and at in-
creasing rate as the salt increases.
“The basin of New York harbor inside the Narrows, and below
140th Street on the Hudson, and Hell Gate on the East River,
leaving out Kill von Kull, contains, at mean tide, 203,467 million
gallons. At the known rate of absorption of 0.62 pounds per mil-
lion gallons, its hourly reaeration amounts to 126,150 pounds,
enough to destroy the organic matter in the sewage of sixty million
people, at 100 gallons per head per day, provided the sewage is
“) Edlow W. Harrison, Proc. 35th Ann. Meeting, N. J. Sanitary Asen., 1909,
p- 77.
32—Ex. 136
ade - ge Ae CRB eee New ree ener el a ee een cee se
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4045
properly delivered to the water, without reducing the normal
gen.
Passing by for the moment the reference to the effect of dissolved
salts in water upon the rate of reaeration, a question which will be
fully discussed later, it must be pointed out here that the depth and
condition of aeration of the water, essential factors in the rate of
reaeration, have been ignored in the above calculations. Any state-
ment of the magnitude of absorption or reaeration must, to
6 have any weight at all, be limited by considerations of the
three fundamental variables of the problem—time, depth and
initial condition.
It is this same point which is of such predominating influence in
running streams. A stream five feet deep, which is completely
mixed but once in an hour, will abxorb oxygen three times as fast
as would a body of water which is mixed but once in twelve hours.
If our tables showed the facts for 15-minute intervals after mixing,
a condition more nearly that of even sluggish streams, the effect
would be still more striking.
Salt Water Conditions.
Thus far this discussion has referred to fresh water. Actual data
for the determination of the diffusion coefficient in sea water are
lacking. The known facts concerning the physical properties of
«lutions would indicate a slower rate of absorption. On the one
hand the solubility is les, so that smaller concentration gradient«
and consequently less diffusion would necessarily follow even with
the same value of the diffusion coefficient, “a.” Our diffusion law
refers to “per cent. of saturation,” so that with the same value of
“a” the absorption, expressed in this unit, is the same. If the
saturation value be diminished by any cause, the actual amount of
oxygen absorbed is correspondingly decreased. In the second place
diffuxion coefficients in general are decidedly reduced by increased
viscosity of the fluid, so that, judging by analogy, the value of “a”
in salt water would be decreased. All told, the rate of diffusion into
salt water is certainly not greater and is probably much less than
into fresh water. These statements are apparently confirmed by
certain experiments of Adeney's, in which tubes of fresh and salt
water were exposed under similar experimental conditions.
The “Streaming Effect.”
On the other hand, under certain conditions, salt water rently
dissolves atmospheric oxygen more rapidly than fresh. A v and
others have noted that, while in fresh water there is a tendency
toward accumulation of the oxygen near the surface (as would be
indicated by the mathematical formula), in the case of salt water
the oxygen tended to distribute more evenly through the tube. This
has been called the “streaming effect” and was first
noted by Hufner. (5) Adeney found it always present when salt
(5) Ann. Phys. Chem. LX., 1897, 134.
33—Ex. 136
EOS RP 9 rey Oo me ® he ee
4046 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
water was used but most markedly so when a jet of air was intro
duced just below the surface of the water. In the case of fresh
water was no such effect. There was no circulation of the
water uced mechanically by the jet. Adeney found further
that so-called “streaming effect” was due to some unknown
property of the air and that that property was lost after passing
once through water. So that if the same air was passed successively
through the top layer of two tubes of water a streaming would take
place in the first, but only slightly or not at all in the second. It
was concluded that this effect was due to dust particles in the air
acting possibly as electrical condensation points, or to some other
electrical property of the air, such as ionization, which property
way prodyced a downward streaming of the oxygen mole
47 the ionized salts of the water this a in some
It is upon this basis of very rapid ion, as determined quanti-
tatively by Adeney, that Mr. Edlow Harrison’s estimate of 0.62
pounds per hour per million gallons was based.
The logical deduction from Adeney’s investigation was that, owing
investigation of the streaming effect. It was decided to employ @
most sensitive detector of circulating currents, since the evi
on this point was not conclusive. Adeney had used a crystal of
bichromate so into his tube. Under these conditions a thin
layer of a very heavy saturated solution forms on the bottom, and
the contents of the tube would have to be stirred quite vigorously
to remove it. Our test for circulation was the addition of a solution
of methylene blue in the same water as that under investigation.
So delicate was this test that the addition of 1 per cent. of methy-
lene blue to sea water gave the mixture a density sufficiently to
cause it at once to descend to the bottom of a tube of the same water.
This colored mixture was therefore diluted until it would just float
on the surface of the tube. The slightest tendency omued circula-
tion was made manifest at once by streaks of blue water descending.
With tubes of fresh and salt water thus prepared, and others sim-
ilarly prepared with the indicator water on the bottom, Adeney’s e%-
periments were repeated and exactly confirmed. In every case
where he obtained streaming there was a visible streaming of the
blue color. In the case of fresh water and also of salt water, if
JA—Ex. 136
—_
wa
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4047
treated with air that had already passed through one tube of water,
there was no streaming. It was demonstrated that the streaming
of oxygen was only a secondary effect, due to the streaming of
the liquid as a whole. Furthermore, the real source of the stream-
ing now became apparent. It was due to the evaporation ef the
top layer of solution, leaving a slightly denser solution on top which
then descended. Within one hour after turning on the air this
dewent frequently began. No streaming occurs in fresh water, for
dvious reasons. A s other results are also clear in the light
df these experiments, The property which was washed from the
sir by passing through the first tube was its dryness. The air be-
came saturated and evaporation no longer took — A sample of
ach washed air was used in our experiments, but was first passed
through a drying tube. It had regained its streaming properties,
more vigorously than ever before. In this “~~~ the water
eaporated from the first tube was collected in t drying bulb and
weighed. The increased concentration of the top layer of liquid was
then calculated at the instant when streaming began. A solution
was then made up of this strength and colored. When placed
% on the top of the standard salt water it immediately de-
scended to the bottom. In brief, it was shown conclusively
that the so-called streaming effect was due entirely to evaporation
of water from the surface and the consequent increase in the specific
gravity of the a layer of the solution. This layer then descended
w the bottom. In pa no such results would be observed, since
= — layers of an estuary are always somewhat fresher than
Therefore, there is no apparent reason to believe that the reaera-
tion of salt water follows any other laws than those which we have
determined mathematically and experimentally for fresh water.
In the absence of fuller information on the effect of increased
viscosity, upon the diffusion coefficient, it can only be stated that
the rate of reaeration of salt water is less than that of fresh, in pro-
portion to the respective solubilities of oxygen im the two waters,
and stil] less, but to an unknown extent, by reason of the greater
viscosity and consequent small value of the diffusion coefficient.
average Rate in Pounds per Hour at Which a Quiescent Body of One Million
Gallons of Fresh Water in Stated Deptha Will Absorb Oryoen from the
re at 20 Deorces C., at Stated Intervals of Time, After a Con-
Uniform Mixing and With an Initial of
Time in hours.
Depth, feet 6 10 12 20 a
nee netigadeseceneteeons 0.193 0.083 0.0 0.069 0.06 0.043
Seeegeoeoredeooreroooes 069 O41 018A 029 023
neeeeeooeeororoerroees .081 .023 .020 og 015 014
Recovcoveueeecoocooreres 023 O15 013 013 O11 010
—
40448 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF KEW YORK V8.
in suromary Table 14 ix to show the essential facts for
use in our further studies. i+ i+ compiled from Table 13, the 70
per cent, initial condition alone being com=idered Under these con-
ditions the rate of oxygen ab-orption in pounds per million gallons
of water per hour in various depth: of water and during variow
intervels of time are shown. These figures repre-ent our best pres
ent knowledge of the alsorption of oxygen inte quiescent fresh water
and are excessive for qui sea water.
The figures in Table 13 are made the basis of the plot in Diagram
5. This table and the diagram show the total amount of absorp
tion during «tated intervals of time. For the purposes of the el
culation which follows it ix of advantage to have the same dats
expressed in average hourly rate over -tated intervals. rather than
total amount, This form of expresion ix axed in Table 14 ond
in the plot, Diagram 6. A third form of expression is also needed
namely, rate of absorption after any stated interval, as distingui
from average rate during that interval. This form is used in Do
gram 8.
(Tere follow diagrams 5, 6 and 8, marked pages 49, 50, and Si,
Complainants’ Exhibit 136.)
T ? T T bee peeee T t 7373
: t | + i > pa ‘o 7
++} ; ie + ++ }
: 7 Tt + + +4 +44
. : . : 7? 7
: ? ; ++
: - : aha + 2
- a - . + ** ?-
- i. + 4
: : \
: e re e +
ee 33 ? oa Z + Phere ee aee
t so #8808. bee
.. a
+ an . o ?
ee .« “ Te .a >
. —4 ++ b+ e+ 9 ‘ + - b+ 4
base a
pf
ee t ¢
re 4
. he + 7
4 33s) v aa + a >
bt + eee. e4 «es . poe
r« 4 * 4 TT a |
> +4 - > * -
4 . aaa. aan > +
+. +
7 ttree : + ~~
° hte * 7 > *
+~ +eeeeee 1? : > * >
v oe6 ~~ - +
®! * > ~
a Tt . ? 4 . 2¢ ps
i b >
: Peet ws .* . 4 se ++ aes
" : ’ + o eee ee >. Peee ees
— +4 a
> ; aed eeehe aa see oo4- ++
-+ > 4 - 4 ~ > + *
»- oa 3s t +e : Pees eee
ttre a il ** >
: al shes ’ H: ttt beet tetttehe * >
S tere ; soessesstss +343 seass + +? : Ler ?
et ’ ee . 717" . . és beenbee +
| : ; :
.
>
peeve
>
Stith
++
* -
"
-
--
,
-
+ +
;
*
a .
° Pet peeerr pe
: eeeeeweeeee o4 eee
++ eeee 7 * oo+e
-*
+4
“+ > “+
ro + ++
epee! . . ; |
4 + oe oe oe “++ 4 +? “+?
e -
> pe eeeesers.. a 4444445
ti
+ +++ Se tore
+ +4 44% +++ peeenes
> +4 oS a ae and
+beeeerere + +++
1 Perr. ad shaseese 4
+ 33 Le eee ed
+ +72? Tt : -
! o ++? of
reseees ceeer: eeereeess
abet eee ee et + +7?
+ +o+er 7
oe" +++ ooeee coed
. HAR
aed +e
pene! ‘ —_—- a ae
a aed eee ¢e te
ooo +++" eeeee reer
+ + 4 doe eeetet
++ oT ee
Paes pe ope eeeeee:
--* > ined
+--+ “ i ae
+++ eee eee
+ errr eer
- ’ + ne
pores
++++7 Sieeeeee
pees +++
Tt - toe eee”
++ ‘ o~-
sees cece cones:
a++o+ oe
> > s
> ++
. p4
- a
oo >
> 1.
+ peeee
+ ee
eer > - ree
“- aa eee
~~ .
~ 4
2
>
bes 4
4 “ aa
Z 4 “+ +
“ pees ti
+? 4
4+ 4
4 -
rT?
] 3
ean
eer
-
na r
IE SSsece
so
}oe ee"
-_
. + -~+** > 4
o : eee?
+ . or rrr ere :
eedee oe 3ees .
5 al re
——- ?-
oe eeeee:
z
-+%
b+ Oo *
+ -
, 33 pease - aa
ee oe.) oe +
4 >t 7+? =.
4 + -oeree eo pees -
; " +4
+? . +
= +
+ rs - z
peeeee ee 3]
T Pee oF
pe = ?
pe +
peewee pene: +
Ti pases’ :
pees erpeere errs ce :
po ewes -.
~T pee ee! peer >
+ eet iteeseees feae eee sores oe!
34444444 } oO 08 * 4
teeete “7?
. = eet Loose
- >
> > 333
* -« ys >
>
~* > e 373)
eeee a 3 +
. 2 + —*4
pee os cert Loe eee . 33-24
re tT: 33. $4445 +
* . 33 . tS +
4 err reeem
ree poor ° Peee ©@ poor .
es -* ©eee* 4 i
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4049
jl The Effect of Currents and Other Disturbing Factors upon
the Rate of Absorption.
The discussion of the rate of absorption has thus far been based
upon the assumption that the body of water in question is quiescent.
The effect of departures from this assumption must now be consid-
ered. This brings up the question of currents, in the broad sense of
the word, including eddies, tide and wave action and brief local
disturbances such as are caused by passing vessels, More specifically
it is the vertical components of these currents only that enter the
problem, since these alone induce a vertical circulation. The effect
of wind will be first considered.
52 Effect of Wind.
The wind is generally looked upon as an important factor in the
aeration of water. The very obvious agitation of the surface, pro-
duced by moderate breezes, and the more violent effect of storms,
vould seem at first glance to lend strength to this view. More care-
ful analysis, however, in the light of the theory of aeration which
has heen developed makes it possible to test this hypothesis and de-
termine the manner in which wind action must affect aeration, if
at all, and approximately at least, the extent of such effect.
Since the fundamental law of aeration is one of diffusion, and
irnthermore, since the surface of any body of water is practically
saturated at all times, it must le evident that no mere surface action
ean by itself affect the rate of diffusion. In order to assist the latter
there must be an actual mechanical mixing of the water. If such
mixing oceurs to any given depth by reason of wind action the facts
which have been developed thus far permit the following quantita-
tive analysis to be applied.
It has been seen that a body of water starting with a uniform
initial concentration of oxvgen, B, less than saturation will absorb
oxygen, and that by diffusion a concentration gradient is estab-
lished, from saturation at the surface to the value, B, at some depth
within, This process is continuous, but the rate of absorption is a
constantly decreasing one. Starting with a condition of uniform
mixing the absorption per hour is a maximum at the start and de-
creases steadily, as is shown in Table No. 3, and more strikingly in
Diagram 8.
The immediate effect of wind upon a body of water is to produce
wave action. A definite relation exists between the wind velocity,
the “fetch” of the wind, i. e., the distance, windward, to the shore,
and the size of the wave. The wave in turn sets the water beneath
in motion, each particle moving in an elliptical path, whose minor
axis, depth, is a function of the wave height. An excellent analysis
of the relation between wind velocities, “fetch” and wave height is
given by Gaillard (1).
(1) Professional Paper, Engineer Corps, U. 8. A., No. 31. Wave Action. D. D.
Gaillard, 1904.
37—Ex. 136
= erwin cee
4050 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
Through the relation between wind action and height of wave,
and the secondary relation between height of wave and depth of
the movement of tha water, it would appear that the velocity of
wind would bear some definite relation to the depth of stirring.
This relation is not one that can be deduced upon any of the present
theories of wave action. In all such theories the principal of “con-
tinuity” is a primary assumption. That is, any given plane in the
body of water at rest may, owing to wave action, become distorted
but must remain continuous and unbroken. This mathematical
conception is of course impossible of actual realization and the de
parture from the ideal condition is in fact the measure of the mixing
of the water with which we now have to deal.
The relation between wind velocities and depth of mixing has
been recently demonstrated in an ingenious and thorough manner
by M. F. Sanborn.* The opportunity for such a study was rather
unique. The Charles River Basin iad been made by the construe-
tion of a dam by which the water within was maintained always at
nearly high water mark. A lock in constant service, admitted
54 enough sea water to prevent the complete freshening of the
* Distribution of Sea Water in the Charles River Basin, after Excluding Tidal
Water, M. F. Sanborn, Eng. News, 63, 272.
(Here follows diagram 7, marked page 53, Complainants’ Exhibit
136.)
38—Ex. 136
oe La is ee
(Fe BD Mk ORDA A DAA,
57
be
(36-$. 88
eet i
« + eaee' +44 HH
4 , 4 + +
8 ~ s
8 t 4 + T
4 TTT 1+ +4
tht eeanut 1
J ‘ eee! ba -
4. +p
rl eane ? T
a ~ } t T
s 3 + 444-4 }
' 4 + - + +4
vt s
e ease + u
* eaaahs tT
i ; + . —
sities seueratt aa i
TTT" 4 4 > e
ane + rtTtT a ieee
. tert + ++4 + +
7 ts +e + TTY * 1
SEERA ieneas T ++ tT ttt
7 ee . TT ? TTT t >
a Tr euseeeas feauueu e
a mes Ti ee 4 i Bi
t TT? TTT - -
eeae! st) i i
prhet ; M 4
i nena & rT > T bot e
Da os - euueect i+ : ' ;
het bot ty 7 TT] TTT |
seane Ral’ eueet
+++ ——T ‘
ttt T TT tet ’
TTT aeEees: inase: Tt
ae I I
+-4 + sane! r
ro rtttittth ryt tT
ame 2 aget +t ti
ene tase 5 wi +
Ptrtt str + ttt
‘ t + *
‘ 44.4, Trt t
17 Tp t am jeent { .
ee ee > pt kp beter fe .
ott eeesees 4 it
na : hes seen
- aa +++ +4
-— + + +++
oat eg aegeest + 4 i
-y TT T + TT
44+ 28 1 vas
- . ++eh tt 28 8 44
H - + + +4
17 ttTTIT +++ itt 4
TH + 4 p++ pete ++ +
+-+-* jageeses pee + tt? 4-4 +
4 eesees => bi eee 4
; anes tt ++ =
Ht soaeeues Seuweess
+4 aed Ho + he
-+ 4 oe -e 4
+r ; T 7
Tir + 4 +t +. 4
ce I | me em Bt 4 M
i trth pause L I
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4051
basin and a permanent condition of stratification with regularly
increasing salinity with increasing depth has resulted. Distur-
bances due to wind were therefore easily and quickly recognized by a
study of the salinity after wind storms. The condition of uniform
mixing thus brought about speedily gave way to the stratified condi-
tion normal to the basin and conditions were ready for another test.
Sanborn tested the re=ults, all told, of twenty-one storms, ranging in
wind velocities from five to thirty miles per hour. The direction of
wind was in every case up or down stream with a fetch of one or two
miles. The accompanying plot (Diagram 7), is from Sanborn’s
paper, Stevenson (1) shows that the wave height and consequently
the depth of the movement is proportional to the square root of the
fetch, so that we may assume that depths approximately twice as great
as those found in the Bostcn experiments will be disturbed by wind
storms of corresponding velocities, in New York Harbor. The fol-
lowing values therefore represent the best of our present knowledge
and are probably not far from the truth. Since the total effect of
wind will be shown to amount only to a minor correction to our
figures, approximate values in this case are all that is required.
They are for average conditions over the Bay and are excessive for
the rivers except during wind storms blowing directly up or down
stream.
Tasie 15,
Effect of Wind Producing Vertical Mizing in Water of New York
Harbor.
From results of Sanborn upon Charles River (Boston), corrected
by observations of Stevenson upon relation of fetch and wave height:
Wind velocity. Depth of uniform mixing,
miles per hour. feet.
5 10
10 31
15 42
20 48
A study of the statistics of the United States Weather Bureau,
has shown that during the four summer months, June to Septem-
ber, inclusive, the frequency of wind storms of varying intensities
are as follows:
(1) Quoted by Gaillard, p. 67.
39—Ex. 136
4052 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
TaBLe 16,
Frequency of Wind Storms of Stated Velocities.
(Compiled from Weather Bureau Chart.)
Wind velocity. Average frequency (hours),
miles per hour. June to September.
5 2.7
10 8.7
15 32.6
20 240.6
55 Combining these figures with those of Table 15, the fre
quency with which the water is disturbed to any given depth
is determined. These depths and freauencies have been plotted, a
smooth curve drawn through the points, and the following values
reduced from the curve.
TABLe 17.
Frequency With Which the Waters of New York Harbor Are
Uniformly Mized to Stated Depth by Wind Action.
Depth of mixing Frequency (hours),
(feet). June to September.
12 2.8
20 3.0
30 8.0.
40 24.0
Discussion of the effect of this mixing by wind action will be post-
poned until the added effect of some other causes have been in-
vestigated. The slight breezes which always ruffle the surface have
no material effect upon the result. They keep the surface and a
few inches below in a state of constant admixture. The result is
virtually to decrease the total depth by this amount. Reference to
the figures in Table 13 will show that in depths of 20 feet or over
a change of one foot in depth has but slight effect upon the rate of
absorption.
Effect of Passing Vessels.
The currents produced by the movement of vessels are necessarily
considered in a discussion of this kind. Vessels are commonly be
lieved to exert considerable effect upon the aeration of the water. To
determine this matter quantitatively the following procedure was
adopted. If at any moment of observation, the total number of
‘vessels in motion in the harbor is known, together with their respect-
ive speeds, drafts and breadth of beam (at water line), then the area
40—Ex. 136
a LOLI OA hee CEE RS Me
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4053
disturbed per unit of time will be the sum of the products of the
respective speeds and beams expressed in common units. For ex-
ample, a vessel havin a beam of 40 feet moving at a speed of ten
miles per hour, will disturb a water area of 35,000 square feet per
minute. The total area of water being disturbed in this way at any
unit of time has been determined by averaging the results of a care-
ful observation and classification of the vexseis to be seen at any one
time in the Hudson and East Rivers, between the Lackawanna
Station, Hoboken, the Navy Yard, and Governor's Island. These
observations were made at various hours during the day for a period
of two weeks. The most used waters were purposely selected for
these determinations in order that maximum value might be ob-
tained. For the same reason the hours of heaviest traffic only were
taken and no attempt was made to get night observations. The
results of the inspection and the average speeds and dimensions are
given in Table 18. In this case as in the case of wave action the
sum total of the effect is found to be of minor value, so that ap-
proximate accuracy only is required.
56 Tasie 18.
Statistics of Vessels.
Hudson River and East River Between Lackawanna Station, Navy Yard and
Governor's Island.
Average of Daily Observations at Various Hours for Two Weeks.
Area dis-
Visible at Speed Beam Draft turbed per
Type of vessel. onetime. miles. feet. feet minute
Square feet
Rr 7.5 14 40 12 369.000
TEED cc cc ccccceccccvescccecces 16.9 10 22 12 327.000
Tugs and Tow............-+.-- 6.6 7 wo 12 407.000
seceevecceness 0.23 4 70 pa 20,000
eeccewereersersesees 0.39 7 30 14 7
DEER, 6c ce vecvcccecceecoseqecoccesceseessecscescesers 1,130,000
The total area disturbed calculated us described was found to be
1,130,000 square feet per minute. The total area of waters under
observation is approximately 108,000,000 square feet. The propor-
tion disturbed per minute is therefore 1/105 and the average time
elapsing between successive disturbance of the same point is the
Tecl of this, or 105 minutes. The average draft is twelve feet
80 it may be said that once in 1.75 hours any icular portion
of the water of the Hudson or East River is sti to a depth of 12
feet. Assuming such stirring to represent complete mixing, the data
is now in form for reference to our absorption table. The effect of
vessels amounts toe but a few per vent of the total effect due to all dis
41—Ex. 136
Eee a ee
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
Effect of Tidal Currents.
The third important agency in the mixing of waters like those of
New York Harbor is one whith is least noticeable in its action and
which is con-equently overlooked in general discussions of this sub-
the meeting of fresh and salt water.
When any body of water moves through a cross section which is
changing in area or direction local differences in pressure arise which
cause vertical and horizontal circulation. To a minor extent, move
ment in uniform sections, is, owing to bottom resistance, a process
of rolling rather than one of strict translation. This effect is ag-
gravated by rough bottoms and by high velocities. In extreme cases
“rips” result even where there are considerable depths. Less vigorous
action leads to “boils,” common upon rivers with irregular sandy
bottoms, or in the vicinity of bends.
57 Mixing due to the-e causex is always quite complete through-
out the depth, and owing to the large volumes which pass
during a tidal eyele, this agency, where it ix active at all, ix of impor-
tance in the aeration of tidal waters.
In New York Harbor the waters which flow into the East River
from the Upper Bay, either through the Buttermilk Channel or
around the west side of Governors Island, are visibly subject to this
action. At Hell Gate also there is complete vertical mixing of all
the water passing. It happens that the volume of water in the East
River between Hell Gate and the Battery is approximately equal to
that which enters from each end during a half tidal period of six
lunar hours, so that the average time between mixing of the waters
of this river is about six hours. Some slight additional advantage
is also derived from the relatively narrow cross-section and conse —
— pressure gradients across the current at maximum flow, from
bends and from the influence of Blackwell’s Island. These all
oe ae ee oe Sa the vertical plane so that
‘or these waters an average mixing period of five hours is probably
conservative, and will be assumed.
The waters of the Hudson are jess subject to action of the kind
here described. Its width precludes any material cross-stream pres
sure gradients due to velocity of flow and side resistance and its
uniform depth is not favorable to “boils.” A portion of its flow is
subject to overturning at Governors Island, but the amount is in-
considerable. The second class of tidal effect mentioned, however,
is predominant in the Hudson, namely the effect of under-run. A
careful study throughout the tidal aa as given by the U. S. Coast
and Geodetic Survey (1) shows that at least once during each flood
tide there is a fairly complete commingling of the waters throughout
(1) U. 8. Coast & Geodetic Survey, for 1887, Append. No. 15.
the depth of the stream. This effect is confined to those waters in
42—Ex. 136
te meee - a = . -
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4055
which there is distinct stratification and is probably immaterial be-
low Spuyten Duyvil, as indicated in the salinity table published by
the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission. (2)
Above Spuyten Duyvil, therefore, an average time between mix-
ings of twelve hours may be safely assumed.
That portion of the tidal prism of the bay and tributaries which
passes through the Narrows may similarly be assumed to receive a
thorough mixing at that point, but as this incoming water will be
composed largely of pure sea water, with an oxygen content ap-
proaching saturation the advantage in this case is —
In the main body of the Upper Bay and Lower Hudson the mix-
ing from tidal effect is slight at best and cannot be estimated even
roughly. The effect of tides rising and falling upon sloping shores,
of waves breaking upon those shores, and of minor irregularities in
current leading to eddies and boils is at least small in comparison
with the effect of Hell Gate for example, and the small itional
aeration given to waters as the latter point serves excellently to
indicate the infinitesimal results due to these minor causes.
58 Summary and Conclusion.
These various results may now be summarized and added, as in-
dicated in Table 19. It should be noted in particular that the
effect of boats is the maximum effect found in the river and is
largely excessive for the upper bay. Similarly the wind action is
probably excessive for the Hudson and certainly largely so for the
East River. The values are also all excessive in that fresh water
coefficients of absorption only were available. It has been purposely
intended to give results which shall be maximum values in every
case.
Tastz 19.
Average Rate of Absorption of Atmospheric Orygen in Various Parts of New
York Harbor and Tributary Waters When 70 per Cent. Saturated.
Rate of ab-
Average time between
Body of water. (hours) Pounds
_ An ~ million gallons,
Wind. Boats. Tide. All causes. per hour.
Upper Bay. Middle and
Lewer Hudson:
Depth of 12 feet........ 28 1.7% 1.1 0.045
Depth of 20 feet........ ’ 3.0 0.045
Depth of 30 feet........ 8.0 8.0 0.040
Depth of 40 feet........ 2.0 2.0 0.035
Upper Hudson :
Mean depth 30 feet. 8.0 12 4.8 0.012
East River:
Depth of 12 feet........ 2.8 1.7% 5 0.89 0.048
Depth of 20 feet........ BO cess 5 1.9 0.049
Depth of 30 feet........ 8.0 5 2.3 0.061
(2) Bep. Met. Sew. Comm. of New York, 1910, p. 529, Table IX.
43—Ex. 136
4056 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
The last column of Table 19 ix oltained in the ing manner
The upper twelve feet in the bay is completely mixed in the summer
time on the average of once in 1.1 hours, Obviously the maximum
feat. of such mixing would result from a uniform distribution
of the mixing periods, In asuning such a distribution therefore,
which is the only posible assumption in a general analysis of this
at 20 feet during an &-hour peried the value is found to be 0.61,
and at 40 feet during 24 hours approximately 0.005 pounds per mil-
lion gallons.
bt) In 20-foot depths one million gallons will therefore absorb
altogether 018 pounds per hour plus the amount absorbed
bv twelvetwentieths of one million gallons in the upper twelve feet.
or 0.027, making a total of 0.045 pounds. Similarly in 30 feet there
will he an absorption per million gallons of 0.01 pounds, plus two-
thirds of 0.045 pound, a tetel of 0.040 pound, and in 40 feet 0.005,
rns three-fourths of 0.040 pound, a total of 0.085 pound.
In the Hudson River above Spuvten Dayvil, a mean depth of
20 feet is assumed which an average mixing interval of 2.4 hours
gives a rate of abmorption of 0.019 pound per million gallons. The
treatment of the East River ix the same as that outlined above.
In each case the atmorption in deep lavers is determined as defined
by their degree of quiescence. and to this abecryt ion lw the upper
lavers due to their more frequent period of mixing is added.
special treatment of the 12-foot depths need no longer he considered
all practical purposes the average rate of absorption in the
045, in the East River
of aeration in depths greater than 40 Jeet may safely be disregarded.
There remains only the discussion of minor tributaries. Of these
the Harlem ix of the greate-t interest. This rapid flowing stream
undoubtedly more thoroughly mixed throughout its course and
throughout most of the tidal evele, then any other body of water
dealt with here. The relatively «mall volume of water passing
through the Harlem makes it of minor consequence. Of the other
hodies of water tributary to the Bay there is none that is as fever
ably affected either by wind or tide or vessels ex are the Hudson and
44— Ex. 136
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.
Chapter IIL.
Investigations Upon the Aeration of Sewage.
RHE Ho
mint |
! + Hpi
Fe ae i
ivy erie) HEE ih
Hine
Hil,
Bi eat t
Ht RRR Tie
stream, will
3eaze
4058 THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK ve
Series 1 —Aeration of Crude and Septic Sewage in Shallow Tanks
Plan of Investigation.
The purpose of these experiments was to determine, first, whether
the stalality of raw or septicised sewage could be increased by forved
aeration, and, secondly. under what conditions, with what volumes
of air and at what cet the maximum economic efficiency of such a
process could be attwined. For thie pu arrangements were
made at the sewage disposal works in East New York for
pumping directly from the outfall sewer a continuous flow of sewage
sufficient for these mvestigations. This sewage was fir pumped to
an elevated supply tank from which it flowed by independent lines
to a septic tank and te an aerating tank. The sewage from the «ptic
tank overflowed to a second aerating tank. we were thus en-
61 abled to aerate both the crude sewage and the septic sewage.
Dunng a portion of this period of investigation aeration of
the septic tank cfhaent was accomplished by pumping compressed air
of better distribution of this air a fine mesh cop gauze was ~ |: lered
around the air pipe so that the between the pipe itself and this
guaze became virtually an air her. During the second period
of the investigation in addition to the arrangement just deecribed,
,
=
ons ae Se gueney tHe ee os © Genel epwane. The aerat
tank used with the crude sewage was constructed in 1
same way at the beginning. The total capacity of the septic
3,200 gallons; of the i i ;
Li
i
F
:
ee Ee i
Shst23 ere te HTT: '
iE: ADIL THE At fait 5
ie eee el beset 33 i
tail adits icra ifs
Leu aae et tae
Aen dei Hh
lj ett aE aT hue
Hi i i tt nie -
3 i ee z egiseicye ae
fein sl At ill fy it i
= TSE 3 af HiT
| Hila He ila eatin
IE
4060 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
In which O is the amount of oxygen present in unit volume, C
the amount of organic matter oxidizable, t the time allowed for the
reaction to proceed, and K a constant determined by the character
of the organic matter and in turn defining the oxidizability of that
organic matter. Integrating
O’
log ———_ = K Ct
O
O’ being the initial and O the final amount of oxygen present.
The constant K defines mathematicallly the rapidity with which
the oxygen is used in a mixture of water and sewage. It depends
upon the character of the sewage matter and the concentration of
that material in the sewage and is independent of the extent of dilu-
tion or character of diluting water. A value of K = .0030 would
indicate a sewage which in 25 per cent admixture with water would
reduce the oxygen content of the mixture 50 per cent. in four hours.
Similarly for K = .0020 the reduction in a 25 per cent. admixture
in' four hours would be 37.5 per’ cent. and with K = .0015, 28.5
per cent. These figures are tabulated in column A below to serve
as a standard for interpreting the results of our experimental work.
In column B a set of figures are given which show the percentage
of sewage of given K value which could be discharged into a stream
under the condition that the oxygen of that stream shall not be re-
duced more than 20 per cent. in six hours.
(Here follows diagram 9, marked page 63, Complainants’ Ex-
hibit 136.)
apn ery £ : EEG PREIS ee gyno wo SERGE RYE rete Am mer mEINE rennet ene . om — wee SE
a rAes Ne Poe, PAG a Pt tH aR te RG I ERIN aT dt
I T TT
bb hat ete et tt
ba 4 he es et ey 14
Leete
penoeeses eee
q
a
s
+ +
+4 +3 +++
+4 tatty " + euenees peeve
t t iT} . ; ttiatrtttitrr
7 + i | + ~+oo-e7+ 4
+++ + +++ + ttt tt
{tr + ttith + Whit +
+ bie tithe + + a oes:
+ + 4
1S OSS s SaeeReEet Tyg BSS Seseees
+tt pepeat ++ t e444 n te
eteigg isis satis 4- + ttt pose
‘ +44
rt i et
Stith) +tit+t 4 sassesgees
ee tei4e +++44 . ee a +
eesesansees sesbacetes sssceeses
+444 398s saeeEs, Senet +
setts, Ths $4444) +
tt ed bated tte tee 444t ‘
See ececneenen cbeteaseces? pepe auc
a PSE RSOS 8: 19 5G5 CERS. SeRes BOs
4 > t ++he +-+++4 > i +4 en ane el
e ++ 6 SVSSSSe. -
ttt tr+ SH 4 iS eas
++ jeans + > J.
+ Hie esses apeese a
eee
++ pases itt shots etl ty +4
tt “TT + tts ttt ttl te +
T easase: panes +++ .
4+ $44344-44444444 ++
+4 +t OR SGRs CROSS SCeeE TSE PESS PRS Ds @ a
ft ® +-H4 ++ th eeusceecssecece: rote Se SS). Sapce
nee 3 $4444 SRE Be! 4
sesseoececenes ccesetsccscccesssee: ith Tot
; Toh sa Bwees Senna! sean Ht .
4 it i °
-- tT +e H
+ — + ++
H aap dete ee oe + 4 ae bs
pee ToT +4 7 ret
ae + tt +> +
+ eaees seus
- +++ + vt +
$ Sees oe sueaeuse secses +3 + HIt yt
2
2 + sessseqst +t > +44 ++ oe
+ +44 ttt te + owe
4+ Saeenes eens +? 4y os 4
ppene ent ioe
t eansgeeRes t senensi
T
+ >
s +
+
++ 4
44-44 t ;
+—4 + +t
t 4 t 4 4 t
pes a +4 tT t T
t
tt Cott as ttt
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4061
K A B
0030 50.0% 5%
.0020 37.5% 8%
0015 28.5% 11%
.0010 20.0% 16%
A—Reducetion in dissolved oxygen which would result at the end
of four hours in a 25 per cent. admixture of sewage in water.
B—Maximum concentration of sewage permissible if the oxyge:
shall not be reduced more than 20 per cent. in approximately a half
tidal period of six hours.
The relationship is shown more fully in Diagram 9.
Results Obtained.
Chemical Analyses.—Samples were collected daily throughout
most of the period covered by the work. During the latter part of
the period they were collected every other day. Composite samples,
preserved with chloroform, were analyzed weekly. The results are
given in Table 20 in the form of monthly averages. For compuri-
son an average analysis of Boston sewage is given.
TABLE 20.
Monthly Averages of Sewage Analyses Made on Samples Collected Daily at
East New York, Before and After Experimental Treatment, and Average
tnalysixs of Boston Sewage. ss
Suspended solids. Oxygen consumed. Nitrogen as organic.
A A.
ae a i saints we it
Month. Free
Total. Vol. Fixed. Total. Dis. Susp. amm, Total. Dis. Susp.
Crude Sewage.
—=
a 73 48 25 90 71 19 38 29 22 7
rarer 52 38 14 73 61 12 57 14 10 4
5 ns oat 53 35 18 71 63 ba 53 14 10 4
eee 71 46 25 76 60 16 46 16 12 4
ee 92 61 31 tt 58 6 40 16 12 4
*September ... 113 86 2 76 65 11 46 28 22 6
Average :
Ist Series... 68 A+ 24 75 63 12 46 18 14 4
Grand Av.. 75 52 23 76 63 13 46 20 15 5
Crude Sewage Aerated.
Oe davwtewws 7s 47 31 68 51 17 39 23 19 4
NE iat ole aie 5 34 20 53 42 11 33 16 1h 3
eee 101 57 44 56 46 10 83 15 12 3
_. Sarrer 56 34 22 5h 46 9 H 15 12 3
ee Ot 65 29 57 47 10 34 15 12 3
Average... 76 47 29 58 47 11 35 17 13 4
* Second series of experiments begun.
4062 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
65 Suspended solids. Oxygenconsumed. Nitrogen as organic.
—-—_—_ —_, ——__ nd — —
Month. | ” "Pree ie
Total. Vol. Fixed. Total. Dis. Susp. amm. Total. Dis. Susp,
Septic Sewage Aerated.
er be 3 38 16 57 38 19 24 21 17 +
BY wecvevers vA 23 11 2 » 12 H 16 11 5
BD socsdvers oS 34 24 56 40 16 27 17 15 2
MT cxsvenevs 5 26 28 5 41 15 27 16 12 4
August ...... 42 31 11 42 38 4 26 14 11 3
*September ... 72 51 21 49 46 3 24 25 20 Pt)
Average
Ist Series... 49 26 23 53 39 14 26 17 13 4
Grand Av.. 51 32 19 52 41 11 25 18 14 4
Boston Sewage
Sept.-Dec. .... 185 130 55 66 27 33 , aos ae Fh ee
* Second series of experiments begun.
The high nitrogen values indicate « sewage much stronger than
the average and possibly containing nitrogenous manufacturing
wastes, such as brewery waste. The low su-pended solids on the
other hand indicate a considerable deposit in the outfall sewer.
Censidering the strength of this sewage its stability is high. The
sewage of Boston is fully as putrescible as this sewage, measured in
verms of oxygen absorption from water, but in chemical compos-
tion it is much weaker, This bears out the indication of some rei-
tively stable manufacturing waste. It would appear that we ure
dealing with a sewage which, although strong according to ont
analytical results, is not more decomposable than an averaze city
sewage. Improvement by aeration would, therefore, be relatively
more difficult.
The analyses of the crude sewage after aeration and of the same
sewage after having passed the septic tank and the aeration tank
are also given in Table 20. No changes are noted other than those
which can be ascribed to the action of the tanks thenmelves.
Relative Stability.—The relative stability results as determined by
the methylene blue test are giver ii: Table 21.
5O—Ex., 136
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4065
68 Taste 21.
Relative Stability, Dissolved Orygen and Putrescibility Results and Other Data.
Series I.
Putrescibility
Air., Time Relative coefficient
eu. of stability K
ft. con- dilution %. dilution %.
Sewage Period. per tact, -— ~ ._ -—-———_ Dis.
gal. hours. 15 20 25 30 35 5 25 oxygen.
a 1 “a0 snl 80 66 53 45... 0029 =. 0085 1.9
Crude, Aerated 1 -20 1.4 9 96 77 6 61 .0020 = .On20 2.3
eee 2 rap mae 5 € 2a . 0054 0060 2.8
Crude, Aerated 2 09 1.4 .. .. 74463 52 .0023 .0Ou 1.1
ae 3 _ 8% 70m .. . 0059" §=.0040*% 1.2
Septic, Aerated 3 360«—2..8 9 % 79 61 48 .0O2T* .0U26* 34
re 4 82 68 60 sa .0028 0026 2.7
Septic, Aerated 4 67 5.6 .. .. 6 56 4 .0017 0023 .37
a 5 _ _ 46H... .- 0038 .0036 3.1
Septic, Aerated 5 7 6.6 .. .» 7% 70 68 .0014 = .0021 1.2
a 6 ove ee 7 @ @ .. «- 0076 .0104 2.5
Septic, Aerated 6 23 2.8 .. .. 8 80 6 .0O18 § .0054 22
* These dilutions are 10 and 50 instead of 5 and 25.
Period 1—March 25 to May 17.
Period 2—May 18 to August 19.
Period 3—March 25 to April 21.
Period 4—April 22 to May 12.
Period 5—May 13 to June 26,
Period 6—June 27 to August 19.
Baffle screens used during Periods 1, 2, 5 and 6.
The raw sewage shows a constantly decreasing stability as is al-
ways the case during this season of the year. Direct aeration at the
rate of .20 cubic feet of air per gallon of sewage increases the stability
by about 45 per cent. in a 25 per cent. mixture, and 53 per cent. in
a 30 per cent. mixture. During the second period the rate of appli-
cation of air was decreased to 09. and the increased stability for this
period in a 25 per cent. mixture was 72 per cent. It is possible that
still less quantities of air would give results approximately as good,
but upon the basis of this work it is evident that no greater quantities
than 90,000 cubic feet per million gallons will be required.
The septic sewage results must be considered in four separate
periods. During period “3” the rate of application was .26 cubic
feet per gallon, and the increased stability over the raw sewage for the
corresponding period was 32 per cent. in a 25 per cent. mixture;
during the fourth period the time of contact with the air increased
from 2.8 to 5.6 hours, the other conditions remaining the same ex-
cept that now the rate of application of air was .67 cubic feet per
gallon. The stability in 25 per cent. mixture was increased only
13 per cent. During the fifth period screens were installed similar
to those already in use with the crude sewage, the rate of application
and time of contact remaining the same, which resulted in an in-
creased stability of 62 per cent., calculated on the crude sewage for
51—Ex., 136
ceed a sie ieee eee
4064 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
this period. During the sixth period the air was diminished
67 to 0.23 cubic feet per gallon, and the time of contact to 24
hours, with a resulting improvement in stability at 25 per
cent. dilution of 89 per cent., the highest value recorded during these
studies. A part of this improvement is doubtless due to the decreased
stability of the sewage itself already noted, and the same stxtement
may be made in regard to the second period of the raw sewage ex-
periment, in which decreasing the amount of applied air did not
materially affect the zesult. The results of these last periods are
approaching summer conditions and it is doubtless true that with
the coming of warm weather and the consequent lessened stability
of the crude sewage, high percentages of improvement are more
readily obtained, As it is summer conditions that really limit any
dilution process of sewage disposal, these warm weather result« have
the greatest significance in this present study.
Putrescibility Coefficient.—The results obtained by the putreseibil-
ity coefficient are, when suitably interpreted, the most satisfactory
basis for determining the results of the work of this character. In
Curve B, Diagram 9, the maximum permissible concentration of
sewage in a body of water is given for all values of the coefficient
under the condition that the dissolved oxygen shall not be reduc
by more than 20 per cent. in six hours. For purposes of comparison
any other value might have been selected. Measured by this prac
tical test the percentage improvements in the sewage under treat
ment as shown by the data of Table 21 were as follows:
Taste 22.
Percentage Improvement in Condition of Sewage Brought About by Aeration,
as Measured ty Concentration of Sewage Required to Reduce the Gayo
Content of Water 20 per Cent. in Six Hours.
Summary.
Improvement,
Period. per cent.
DO Gavenesaeerrertedacaceuceces €ovéeeetesseuareeeers 45
© evcceseccoernscoseneceusceroesecroeseeseervecéese 136
D sccevsecseuvevececseevscervedederseeveds téeveeves 118
OD eveserseveerectetvceseeneeveceesreeseneacesaeeess 65
DP revexvutveveeretrsvressweveveseesereeveerereeotyes 177
© cecvoreccvsrevewerwevensvercovevoeeseeveeronceoes 320
Full discussion of these results will be reserved for a later place.
Series I1.—Aeration of Septic Sewage in a Deep Tank.
Our investigations up to this time had shown that a satisfactory
partial oxidation of crude sewage could be accomplished under the
conditions prevailing in the experiments. The volume of air re
quired relative to the sewage flow was considerable, however, and the
cost of such treatment seemed unnecessarily high. Examinations
of the air leaving the aeration tank showed conclusively that the
oxygen content was far from being exhausted. In fact, the air was
52—Ex. 136
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4065
practically of normal composition upon leaving the tank as far as
we could learn from fmm mer analysis, In other words, the actual
amount of oxygen absorbed from this considerable volume of air
was infinitesimal. It seemed therefore that the same body of air
might to good advantage be used to treat a larger volume of
68 sewage at a consequent decreased cost of pumping. This re-
sult could only be obtained by increasing the depth of the
tank. In two tanks of unequal depth through each of which sew-
age is flowing at a stated velocity and into each of which a stated
volume of air is passing, the sewage in that tank having the greater
depth will obviously receive exactly the same treatment as that in the
smaller tank, but the relation of cir volume to sewage will be in-
versely as the depths.
Plan of Investigation.
To test the efficiency of this proceedure, a tank twenty-one feet in
depth to the water line was built out of two-foot lengths of 24-inch
Vitrified sewer pipe set up in a vertical stack. Through the central
axis of this stack a three-quarter-inch iron pipe passed from top to
bottom and upon this pipe circular discs of No. 12 expanded metal
lathing were placed at one-foot vertical intervals. Sewage was ad-
mitted to this stack through a two-inch pipe at the bottom, this pipe
coming from the overflow in the septic tank used in our previous
experiments, The sewage overtiowed from a pipe at the top of the
dack. Compressed air was pumped through the three-quarter-ineh
iron pipe mentioned and was distributed at the bottom of the stack
through one-cighth-inch holes spaced two inches on centers upon
four cross arms 90 degree apart, extending from the center to a
point near the periphery. Compressed air was supplied by the com-
presor used in the previous experiments, The capacity of the air
compressor was determined under the working conditions by in-
serting a pressure air meter in the line and calibrating the pump by
revolutions. Subsequently the rate was controlled by pumping as
nearly as possible at a fixed number of revolutions and wasting the
desired amount through a by-pass which was metered. The actual
amount of air used was then taken as the difference between the
original pump rate at the given speed and the amount of air meas-
ured in the waste line. The experimental portion of this work was
divided into two periods:
During the first, a four-hour ee of septic treatfnent and a one-
hour period of aeration were allowed. The rate of flow of sewage
through the tank during this period was 486 gallons per hour and
of air about 110 cubic feet, so that air was being applied at the rate
of approximately 0.23 cubic feet per gallon.
During the second period, the rate of flow throughout the sys
tem was reduced one-half, so that the time of ic treatment was
made eight hours and of aeration two hours. volume of air
was decreased proportionately, so that the net effect of this change
Was to increase the time of treatment only.
53—Ex. 1346
4066 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V3.
Results Obtained.
These experiments were controlled by the same chemical texts as
were made in the first series. They extended from September 10 to
September 23, in the first period, and from September 23 to October
6 in the second period. As the sole purpose of this series of experi-
ments was to determine whether results comparable with those ob-
tained in Series 1. could be obtained in the deeper tank at a corre-
spondingly le=« volume of air relative to sewage, it was not continued
longer than was necessary to demonstrate the facts. The average
results of each period as measured by the two methods already de
scribed are summarized below.
406
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.
rr Ho ROO ~ 2s wb
oo qunn’ 6an0' 2s ry ow Bt ease eeee eee eee en as epna
zs 9 e100" tloo Lb a ts ** 1 eZ 0 1 eee ee eee eee eee eee ee opides per Bey
or wooo: eou0 ve eo @ e - wets Tenet etna eee nee arene een e es apna
‘vl ‘ ow ss oe cs Us
‘eeBize = ~ ed “Sa noy ~aorred
peajossy] —"yuee sad GorynyTp “gaea sed wornytp ‘youjuoo sed joey POO oSemog
JUSTO ‘Sayyquas eared oom, = aqne “aTV
arytqrosedy nd
‘Tl #®He8
‘PIP 40YIO PWO eIPREAY ArQuerdsgRd PUY KIDATO PIA/080K) “AUNAOIS 91N019N
WS FMV o &
ets
Hip ipl
Fr
HT ihe
Pyetuiatnilt
Ht atti
Wi He He Fa
RETO
a init fle af
Hall
ja Hu Hin
Baty casprieiecty at2tia ye fi i
fi; es if uit iit: HUN ue ie
ii} ih 2 HIGH THT Fil :
i)
ba Ri} ype: abit Ane F Hf; il,
ad - Th 3 77344 att f
tt | it uy fi i
ite? HERE AHH ii aes
sat feat 4 ete Het iil
te i Ther HE
: r i Tee ath ip i i
of all coeficients obtained
v coefficient only were obtained im thie
during the period, Octoher 1 to December 31, 1910, were
experiments putrescitility coefficients were ob-
order to determine thorough!
Results bw the
wre §=PDuring
tained at a great many dilutions in
the significance of this text The average
S7— Ex. 138
THE PROFLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.
whieh by Diagram 1 gives an improvement of 10 per cent., as mens
ured by the dilution of these «ewages which will reduce 20 per cent.
of the oxygen of the water in «x hours.
This poor showing i« evidently due to difficulty i
conditions extabliched im the tank which
72 for ewer « year. During the month: of N ie
cember when improvement was mest dificult in Brooklyn,
the average results of the Boston texts made at 5 per cent. dilutions
Conclusions.
Amount of Air Required ana Improvement Effected.
The amount of oxygen necesery to give significant result. has
heen determined regardless of cont or considerations. In the
case of the crude sewage it was found that a rate of application of
110 thon<end cubic feet per million gallons gave an excess of die
solved oxveen im the sewage which indicated that ne further ad-
vantage would be obtained bw increasing the air «apply. In the case
of the septic sewage an equal rate of application gave no euch ev
dence of exces and an effort was made to add the air at a sufficiently
high rate to show some excess. This effort wae only partially sue
cessful and in ne case wae the excessive oxygen in thik effluent #
great as in the raw sewage effluent. For this reason also the time of
contact was doubled without anv appreniable results in the exces of
oxygen. It was soon di<cowored that it war usele-* to te get
any noticeatle excess in this septic «wage and that even at the lower
rates the «tatality of the <eptic sewage was increased and at the higher
rates of ay dication was fully equal to that of the aerated crude sew-
age A yeix of the air leaving the liquid alo showed thet the
abmerption of oxygen from this air war very little indeed «0 that #
SRE. 18
1 FO REPO a! - -
om
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4071
obtained during the firt period of treatment indicates a dix
etvantage in favor of shorter ported wf moptle Mine ait © Again
found h the capacity of the air compres
machinery and meters to reduce the wir ow to whet war strony
iodiccted a
economy in ait since only a shallow h was available, but the
all thie work taken together enal conclusions to be drawn
not indicated in any «ingle serie. Period 6 of Series I,
ma low tank with an air con-urp-
of 0.23 cubic feet per gallon and a contact veriond of 2.8
tank «pace,
_ other conditions being equal.
- 3
if
5
2.
4
application of short period septic action, and by aerating in a deep
tank and that an air consumption a may mpd 0.1 cubic feet
these conditions, This
the harber waters the maximum amount of -ewage which ean be die
posed of in the harbor is increased two to three fold by this treatment.
tl?
1
it
H
"
13
H
j
:
:
ic designed with special reference to this
is to reduce the sludge to a mini-
maximum liquifaction in the tank, Reeult«
the tenk will soon be published in another place.
he stated that the «lodge problem will at least be not greater
can bw dewien of tanks be very
dexirable. The amount of finely divided «aepended
the tank will discharge ix controlled by the design.
which should be discharged under any given local
conditions can only he determined by local studies, It will be found
advantageous to discharge a maximum quantity a- determined bw
stream flow and dilution in any cae. The remainder will have to
Po with by methed« now in vogue. most likely by removal
}
i
i
i
:
=
ef
x
a2
rit
leh
i
2
Cost of Aeration.
The relative costs of low presure air compression by means of
compression and rotary blowers has not heen gone into in detail,
would seem to he some advantage in the use of deep tanks and
pressures, up to possibly thirty feet. On the other hand for
pressures, up to five or six feet, the blower type of air pump
4072 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK YS.
A blower of this type having a capacity of fifty thousand cubic
feet of air per hour under a five-foot head of water requires about
25 K. W. of current, net.
At the rates of aeration which we have finally adopted, this blower
would care for a sewage flow of half a million gallons per hour. At
a cost of 4 cents per K. W. hour these costs for current alone would
be two dollars ($2) per million gallons. This refers to small elec-
trically operated plants at sewer outfalls. For larger installations,
the cost of power would not exceed one-half this amount. We esti-
mate the total cost of installation of plant in the neighborhood of
two thousand dollars ($2,000) per million gallons daily capacity,
or about one twenty-fifth the cost of sprinkling filters after deducting
land costs. Labor charges should be exceedingly low.
It should further be noted that under conditions in which such
a process might be necessary and suflicient, the necessity for
74 its use would arise only during the summer season, of per-
haps four months each vear. If winter conditions demand
treatment at all then the summer conditions would not be met by
aeration, since the variations we have noted between summer and
winter sewaves are greater than the improvements obtained.
Under certain local conditions also less perfect results than have
been obtained here might be ample. The merits and possibilities
of this process have only been barely indicated in this investigation
and a fruitful field has been opened up for future investigation.
75 Chapter IV.
Studies for Sewage Disposal from Certain Districts,
Flushing Drainage District.*--This district is bounded on the
south by the ridge near Hillside road. which forms the divide of
the watershed to north and south: on the west by Flushing Bay
and the high land west of Flushing Creek: on the north by the
Sound and on the east by Little Neck Bay and the low lands ex-
tending from the head of that bay to the ridge first mentioned.
The total area is 14,923 acres, and the estimated future population
on a basis of 50 persons per acre for the towns and 25 persons per
acre for suburban districts, is 423,425. For the purpose of deter-
mining possible points of discharge a trunk sewer system had to be
designed, on the separate system for the unsewered parts and with
storm water overflows where the combined system is now installed.
This system as designed serves all of the district and is adequate
to the needs of the estimated future population. A water consump-
tion of 125 gallons per capita per day was assumed and an allow-
ance of .003 cubic feet per second per acre was made for ground
water flow, based on the practice of the Borough Engineer of Brook-
lyn. Further assumptions made were as follows: that of the total
* See map showing Drainage Districts of Jamaica, Corona, Flushing and West-
chester following p. 148. The writers are indebted to Mr. E. F. Robinson for
valuable assistance in the Drainage District Studies.
60—Ex, 136
an RIS OT fh * AO RY sere, ‘ > . . -
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4073
flow per 24 hours, half would pass in eight hours; that the maxi-
mum velocity with sewer 0.8 full should not exceed 7.5 feet per
second; and that the minimum velocity with sewer 0.2 full should
not be less than 1.50 feet per second.
It was found that the drainage from the entire area could be
brought to a point in the East River east of Powells Cove and then
discharged, and that five-sevenths of the area could be drained by
a high level gravity system to the point of discharge, with a low
level gravity system for the remainder, discharging into the high
level system by pumping. Possible sites for purification works were
found should such prove necessary. Details of the recommenda-
tions made are given in the special report rendered March 20, 1910.
Corona Drainage District.*—This district comprises the territory
between the Flushing District on the east, the dividing ridge on the
south, the Borough of Brooklyn and Newtown Creek on the west
and the East River on the north. Its area is 14,535 acres and the
estimated future population on the basis described for the Flushing
District is 628,200. This includes an area of 756 acres with an
estimated future population of 37,800 for which the natural drain-
age is through the sewers of Brooklyn. Another portion containing
1,290 acres with an estimated future population of 64,500 along the
water front from Astoria south and west to Newtown Creek and lying
below the 20-foot contour, is now drained into Newtown Creek and
the East River. Eventually its sewers will have to be intercepted
and discharged by pumping into the main system.
For the remainder of the district a gravity system of trunk sewers
has been designed by which all of the sewage is carried to and dis-
charged into deep water of the East River from a point approxi-
mately to the southeast of Berrians Island.
76 Should purification works become necessary, these can be
located on Rikers Island, to which the system can be pro-
longed,
The sewers were designed on the same assumptions as those for
the Flushing District. Provision for storm water overflows has been
made at points where the proposed interceptors receive the discharge
of existing combined systems, and at two points along Flushing
Bay and one point near the head of Newtown Creek. While the
sewers were designed for sanitary and ground water flow only, they
are of capacity sufficient for the estimated future population and
until the present population shall have increased greatly they can
be utilized for storm water flow.
There is now a sewage purification plant at Elmhurst, which is
capable of caring for the sewage of the district tributary to it for
the present and if improved can be utilized for the increasing popu-
lation for some years and thus render unnecessary the immediate
‘onstruction of a portion of the projected system.
Full details of the system as projected are given in the special
report dated May 24, 1910.
61—Ex, 136
4074 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Vs.
Jamaica Drainage District.*—This district comprises the areas
draining naturally into Jamaica Bay as well as Coney Island, Rock-
away Beach and a small area near the head of Little Neck Bay, within
the limits of Greater New York, but cut off by a ridge from the
Flushing District system. In general it is bounded on the north
by the ridge which forms the southern limit of the Corona and
Flushing Districts, on the east by Nassau County, on the south by
Jamaica Bay and on the west by Gravesend Bay.
The estimates for future population were made as in the other
districts. Inasmuch as it is expected that the portion of the district
contiguous to Jamaica Bay, for which a population of 50 per acre
has been assumed, will be developed chiefly for manufacturing and
commercial purposes, a water consumption of 100 instead of 125
gallons per day has been allowed, which gives an equivalent popu-
lation of 40 per acre with a water consumption of 125 gallons per
day. In the cases of Coney Island and Rockaway Beach, the perma-
nent population is small in comparison with the number of daily
visitors throughout the summer months. For Coney Island a max-
imum population of 500,000, with an average daily water con-
sumption of 15 gallons per capita, has been assumed, and it is
further assumed that the total run-off will take place in 12 hours.
These assumptions when reduced to terms corresponding to those
used for other districts would give a permanent population of 70
per acre with a daily per capita water consumption of 125 gallons,
Similar assumptions for the Rockaway section give an equivalent
permanent population of 50 per acre, with a daily water consump-
tion of 125 gallons. Other assumptions as to population, water con-
sumption, ground water run-off and ratio of maximurin to average
discharge are the same as for the FlushingDistrict.
The total area in the Jamaica District is 48,916 acres. The total
estimated future population is 1,561,495.
Jamaica Bay is a land-locked tidal basin of slight depth, in which
the entire tidal prism is filled and emptied during each tida! period.
Partial purification of the sewage discharged into it will be re-
77 quired, but even with such purification, to secure an adequate
degree of diffusion there must be several points of discharge.
For the portion of the Jamaica Bay drainage area of the Borough of
Queens, the system as projected gathers all of the sewage by gravity
at two main concentration points, one at the present Twenty-sixth
Ward Pumping Station, and one on Cornell Creek, from which it
will be discharged through iron force mains into Fishkill and Broad
Channels, respectively. When under the proposed project for im-
provement of Jamaica Bay, a thirty-foot channel has been formed
along the north side of the Bay as far as these discharge mains,
they must terminate in that channel, and it will then be essential
to provide the most efficient means of diffusion practicable on dis
charge in order to avoid the formation of local nuisances, Storm
* See map showing Drainage Districts of Jamaica, Corona, Flushing and West-
chester, following p. 148.
62—Ex. 136
PR ! of as nf e Perey OOS OL SS See. - . — pee
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4075
water overflows are provided whenever existing sewers of the com-
bined system are intercepted.
The eastern section of the Borough of Brooklyn comprised in
the Jamaica District already had approved plans for sewerage, and
the project had to be formed with due regard to these plans. The
project contemplates the collection of the sewage by gravity at three
points where it is lifted to a higher level and conveyed by gravity
to proposed purification works in Riches Point Meadow, and then
lifted and discharged into Rockaway Inlet, the ebb currents from
which pass seaward, without touching the bathing beaches of Coney
Island or Rockaway Beach.
The western sections in the Borough of Brooklyn are already pro-
vided with approved projects partly carried out. In the complete
project only a few additions were required,
Two distinct systems of dixposal are practicable for the Coney
Island sewage. One is to force the sewage north to the concentra-
tion point established for the sections to the north and thence to
lead and discharge it into the Narrows. through the interceptor
already constructed. The second is to discharge it to the south by
pumping into the sea, not less than 2,000 feet from shore, and at
a point from which currents do not lead to the beach. The latter
plan is recommended, since the inadvisability of increasing the
pollution of the harbor in any cause where it can be avoided is
manifest.
The Little Neck Bay section is of a limited area, It is proposed
to concentrate the sewage from it at the head of Little Neck Bay
and after purification to discharge it into the bay.
The Rockaway section is low and flat. It is proposed to collect
the sewage from it at three points, and after coarse screening and
sedimentation with liquefaction for a short period in hydrolvtie
tanks. to discharge it into the sea at least 1,000 feet from the shore
line, from which there is no probability of its being brought back
to any appreciable degree.
Disposal in Jamaica Bay.—As stated earlier, Jamaica Bay is a
land-locked tidal basin, of which the tidal prism is filled and
emptied during each tidal period through Rockaway Inlet. After
passing the fanshaped bar between Rockaway Point and Coney
Island, outside the outer extremity of the inlet, the inlet has a deep
channel of ample width which extends as far east as Barren Island.
There this main channel is divided into several minor channels,
One follows the north shore of Rockaway Point, others pass north-
east between the islands of the bay, and the most westerly follows
generally the west shore of the bay. These channels are
78 formed and maintained by the tidal currents. But there is
no current circulation between the heads of the channels
along the north side of the bey other than such as may be produced
temporarily by wind action, Excepting as moved by the winds, the
waters on ihe north and east shores are quiescent. Under such con-
ditions it is evidently necessary that the sewers be extended into the
channels as in the project.
63—Ex, 136
a
4076 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
The total flow through Rockaway Inlet as determined by the ob-
servations of the Engineer Department, U.S. Army, is for flood
4,550,000,000 cubic feet. This is the measure of the tidal prism,
From the map of the bay the portion of the tidal prism tributary
to each channel was determined and from this the mean velocities
of flow in the channels calculated. Assuming the sewage discharge
through each of the outlets on the basis as calculated for the project
and beginning with pure water in the bay, the amount of partially
polluted water due to the discharge at the close of an ebb tide and
remaining in the channel at the beginning of the flood period was
determined and the ratio of sewage to pure water obtained. It is
evident that this ratio ix at first too large, since at first no previous
pollution is assumed. By continuing the process the ratio grows
smaller by decreasing decrements unti! the decrement practically
vanishes and the ratio then represents the true proportions of the
average admixture of sewage and sea water which result from the
discharge of the assumed volume of sewage. While the dilution
figure fairly represents an average condition, the pollution in the
immediate vicinity of the sewer outlet will be much greater even
with the best process for diffusion possible, and to avoid local nui-
sance, it will be necessary to have the dilution ratio large. We be
lieve that this figure should not be lower than 1 part sewage to 117
parts sea water at 63 degrees Fahrenheit.
The sewage discharged into Rockaway Inlet from Riches Point
Meadow, if considered alone, would have an ultimate dilution, de-
termined as indicated, of one part in 2,670, but when considered
together with the discharge into other portions of the bay the aver-
age ultimate dilution is 1 in 209. The discharge into Big Fishkill
Channel! will have an average ultimate dilution of 1 in 75. That
discharged into Broad Channel will have an average ultimate dilu-
tion of 1 in 95, These figures are based upon an assumption of
thorough diffusion. At periods of slack water the percentage of
pollution will be much greater.
The dilution ratio of 1 in 117 was adopted as necessary in view
of the volume of oxygen absorbed by sewage under summer con-
ditions (1,950 pounds per million gallons in 12 hours), the avail-
able supply in the tidal basin, and the consideration that under the
worst conditions this supply must never be reduced below 50 per
cent. of the saturation value, which would make an average reduc-
tion to 75 per cent. of saturation value a standard with a small
margin of safety.
Complete purification before discharge is evidenily never neces
sary under the conditions prevailing in Jamaica Bay with sewage
concentrated and discharged under the project outlined in this re
port. During the winter season even partial purification will prob-
ably be unnecessary. Therefore, we recommend for this district
purification by aeration as described in this report as being
79 most economical and advantageous. Even this treatment
will probably be unnecessary until the proposed drainage
64—Ex. 136
GOOLE IVES EELS NE SE ee —
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 4077
system shall have been developed to at least one-half of its ultimate
capacity.
Details of the project are given in the special report dated Novem-
ber 18, 1910.
Borough of Richmond Drainage District.*—This district includes
all of Staten Island with an area of 36,623 acres, shaped roughly in
triangular form with its vertex to the south and its greatest length
from the vertex to near the centre of the base at the outer end of he
Kill von Kull, on a line running northeast and southwest. It is
bounded on the north by the Kill von Kull and the Upper Bay; on
the east by the Narrows and the Lower Bay; on the south by the
Lower Bay and on the west by the Arthur Kill. The total length of
coast line is 36 miles, of which 18 miles border on the two Kills
and 5 miles on the Upper Bay. Both Kills are now polluted by
sewage from the cities of New Jersey to an extent which probably
makes further discharge of sewage into them inadmissible. Tidal
and current data are meagre, but the following discussion of the
circulation in the Arthur Kill, based on the best information ob-
tainable, confirms this opinion. An examination of the tidal curve
of the current charts in Appendix No. 9 of the report for 1886 of
the U. S. Coast and Geodetic Survey shows that the tide has risen
to 1.51 above mean low water at the beginning of the flood currents
and that the plane of the water rises to high water (+4.1) and falls
to an elevation of +2.35 before the current begins to run ebb.
It is estimated that the amount of water in the Arthur Kill below
the low water plane is about 1,973.5 million cubic feet ; that the tidal
area is about 123.34 million square feet; and that the ebb and flood
flow through the cross-section at Elizabethport is 319.0 million cubic
feet.
Taste 24, SHow1ne Data ror ARTHUR KILL.
Maximum Total
Ele- or Tidal volume
vation mini- Elevation Tidal prism at end of
Area. at mum at area. volume, period,
begin- eleva- end of million _ million million
ningof tion. period. sq. ft. sq. ft. eu. ft.
P-Arthur Kill Flood +1.5 4.1 2.35 123.34 289.9 2,263.4
- * “ Ebb +2.35 0.0 1.50 123.34 185.0 2,158.5
Let M = clean water from the Lower Bay
Let K = water received from the Kill von Kull or Newark Bay
Let n = tide under consideration, flood or ebb
n-1 = the previous tide, ebb or flood
Then P, = 2,263.4 million cu. ft. = 1,839.5 million cu. ft. (P’ 1) + 423.9 mil-
lion cu. ft. (M) =§ 28% (P’ 0.1) + 18.72% (M)
= .8522 P’ .1 + 423 9 million cu. ft. (M)
P’, = 2,158.5 million cu. ft. = 839.5 million cu. ft. (P«1) + 319.0 million
cu. ft. (K) = 85.22% (Pos) + 14.78% (K) = .8128 Po + 31.80
million cu. ft. (K)
"See map of Richmond Drainage District folloming p. 182.
65—Ex. 136
eee
4078 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.
SO Under present conditions it ix estimated that the amount
of sewage emptied into Arthur Kill amounts to 18.5 milhion
gallons in 24 hours or 0.623 million cubic feet in 6 hours. Using
this value in the above formule we get the following approximate
figures for summer conditions:
Per cent. of oxygen present,
=
Seana: «i ——
Area. Dilution Without With
ratio. reaeration. reaeration,
PP hxc re sews eheed Uae ares DEeeEtOESTTE 1 in 127 76.5 86.9
P sevccveucedccosnvvecewersevaawree 1 in 105 71.5 720
If the sewage from the Borough of Richmond be added to the
sewage now discharged into the Kill from New Jersey, the figures
will be as follows:
Per cent. of oxygen present.
Area. Dilution Without With
ratio. reaeration. reaeration,
nck e Seaeddu tee rereeekverdse news se 1 in 98 69.4 69.9
FF sccdeenerdteretieravends civenr ints 1 in 76 00.6 61.1
The waters of the Upper Bay are so intimately connected by cir-
culation with the waters of the Hudson and East Rivers that no in-
creased pollution there is permissible. The Lower Bay, however,
has its tidal prism filled and emptied in each tidal period from and
into the waters of the ocean and has a capacity for sewage reduction
greater than is necess
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.