Transcript of Record — New York v. New Jersey

Supreme Court brief1921

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 1916.

No. 3, Original.

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, COMPLAIN-

ANTS,

v8.

STATE OF NEW JERSEY AND PASSAIC VALLEY SEWER-

AGE COMMISSIONERS, DEFENDANTS.

VOLUME II.

INDEX.

Original. Print

Testimony of Kenneth Allen (recalled)............... 1428 913

Max L. Berrey (recalled).............. 1463 939

Harry de Berkeley Parsons............. 1621 1047

Kenneth Allen (recalled)............... 1659 1072

Se i IS ors nuns ccwwebevewie 1679 1087

NE ST ys ease taro nec were hich 1682 1090

Max L. Berrey (recalled).............. 1697 1101

SO ee 1704 1106

NS a ee ee ene ae 1746 1142

RN I rs ils vio 00-019 sun Swear oe wa 175 1144

NE le WIN x: asic wa wuseecducees ce 1860 1226

De a is 1878 1241

NIN II wip wiesine winsarieleprcuvackne 2068 1390

Desmond Fitzgerald ..................0. 2234 1507

ee 2367 1597

Charles-Edward Amory Winslow........ 2427 1640

ee SIN ras ccedeunweececenve 247 1678

VOLUME II.

THE Propie ov rue State or New York, Complainants,

vs,

State or New Jersey and Passaic VALLEy SEWERAGE ComMISs-

SIONERS, Defendants.

1428 Supreme Court of the United States, October Term, 1911.

Tue ProrLe or THE State or New York. Complainants,

against

STATE or New Jersey and Passaic VALiey SEWERAGE ComMMIs-

SIONERS, Defendants.

Ciry Hatt, New York Ciry,

January 4th, 1912.—10:30 a. m.

Before James D. Maher, Esq., Commissioner.

Appearances :

Dr. William J. O’Sullivan, Special Counsel for the People of the

State of New York.

Adrian Riker, Esq., of Counsel for the Passaic Valley Sewerage

Commission.

Joseph Coult, Esq., of Counsel for the Passaic Valley Sewerage

Commission.

, Robert H. McCarter, Esq., Special Counsel for the State of New

ersey,

Met pursuant to adjournment.

KENNETH ALLEN, a witness called on behalf of complainants,

recalled for further examination, testitied as follows:

Direct examination (continued) by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Now, taking up the series for 1909, Mr. Allen, these float

observations that you have been testifying to, will you proceed and

state what observations you made?

A. In taking up the previous float observations, I described the

float that we used, made of two tin cans. We found that that was

not entirely satisfactory where the traffic was thick, as in

1429 the East River and the Harlem River. We needed something

more substantial, heavier and larger, so for these ex-

ents we had a float which was approximately a stick of wood

inches square and five feet long, the lower two feet built up to

(913)

.

* he al aaa ‘ alk hi: bein aaa er

914 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

a foot square, and the top foot made somewhat larger than the stick.

I do not remember the size of that. Made of a stick four inches

square and about 5 feet long. At the upper end it was built for 2

feet of a size of 1 foot square, and in the center there was a hole in

which an iron rod was inserted, which served as a flag pole, and also

as a socket for one or two lanterns to carry at night. On the lower

end there were built four plates of plate iron—we used different

sizes—varied from about 18 inches by 2 feet to about 20 inches

square. These served as vanes to be influenced by the current at that

depth below the surface and also to weight the float so that the top

would project only an inch or so above the top of the water. The

object of these floats was to have them strong enough to resist any

ordinary concussion with a boat and to support the lanterns which

we wanted to use at night. Taking up these records, the first one

is No. 46 of November 8th and 9th, 1909. This was started at 11:03

P. M. opposite Mount St. Vincent, on the east side of the Hudson

River.

Mr. Riker: Before the witness uses this blue print, I would like

to ask a few questions in regard to it.

Cross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Mr. Allen, what part did you have in the preparation of the

rint - the positive from which it was taken; I am speaking now of

No. 46? ;

A. Nothing to my recollection, ex pt the supervision of the work,

the drafting which J did not do myself.

Mr. Riker: I object to this witness usiag this blue print for any

urpose as it appears he had nothing to do with the making

1430 of it, and it can neither serve as a memoranda made at the

time to refresh his memory nor can he prove it as an exhibit.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan :

Q. When did you first see that, Mr. Allen?

A. This particular print?

Mr. O'Sullivan: Read my question.

(Question repeated by the stenographer. )

The Witness: This print?

Mr. O'Sullivan: Strike the question out. Sit down, Mr. Allen.

Mr. Riker: I do not think it ought to be stricken out entirely.

He answered, he said yesterday.

Q. Did you see it yesterday?

A. Yes.

Q. Where did you get that print?

A. At the office of the Sewerage Commission.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 915

Q. Did you produce at the hearing yesterday that for the first

time?

A. I did.

Q. When did you see the original from which that print was

made?

A. At the time it was made, in November, 1909.

Q. Was it made under your supervision ?

A. It was.

Q. And were these blue prints made at the instance of the Metro-

politan Sewerage Commission, and have they been in their custody

all the time until yesterday?

A. Yes.

Q. Will you please explain then what you meant when you an-

swered Mr. Riker that you had nothing to do with it?

A. I did not say that. I said I had not seen this particular print

until yesterday.

Q. And where did you see it yesterday?

A. At the offive of the Sewerage Commission.

1431 Q. And it has been in their custody all the time, has it not?

A. Since it was made, yes.

Q. And it was made at their instance, was it not?

A. It was.

Q. Now, what did you have to do with regard to the original

from which that blue print was made for the Metropolitan Sewerage

Commission ?

A. I supervised the drafting, the plotting.

Q. The mechanical work done by the draftsmen, was it done

under ag supervision ?

A. Yes,

Q. Have you got your original minutes or notes in court here to-

day?

1. Of the observations?

Q. Yes.

A. No, I have not.

Q. You did not bring them down today?

A. No, I have not.

2 You had them here yesterday?

0.

Q. What minutes were you using yesterday ’

A. The blue prints and the description in the report.

Q. Made by whom?

A

. By myself.

Q. They were your copy of the report?

A. Yes.

Q. Have you got it in court now?

A. Yes, not with regard to these. There never was a report on

this later series.

Q. What book were you consulting yesterday when you were testi-

fying, Mr. Allen?

A. That was a book containing copies of reports that I made to

916 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

the Sewerage Commission, and included reports on these float ex-

periments prior to 1909.

Q. And on some of the series you submitted reports’?

A. Yes.

Q. Which are already marked in evidence?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, the particular chart that you now have before you, did

you submit a report on that?

A. No.

Q. Describe what you did with Float No. 46, what cbservations

you made?

1432 ~~ gaacauel The question is objected to on the same

und.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Mr. Riker: It is objected to on the ground that the paper before

the witness is not the memoranda in any sense of the word and it

is not an exhibit.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for defendants.

. Q. Describe what you did in the way of observations with Float

0. 46?

A. Float No. 46 was put in opposite Mount St. Vincent on the

east side of the Hudson River November 8th, at 11.03 P. M. and

went down the Hudson to opposite 67th Street, Manhattan, at 3.45

A. M. at slack tide. Then it moved westerly across the river and

at 5.10 A. M. went northward to 110th Street. At 8.25 A. M. it

went westerly for 15 minutes and then southerly to 10.40 A. M.

There it grounded, it was obstructed, and we too it up and it was

replaced again at 10.45 A. M. opposite 71st Street, and it went

southerly to 12.05 P. M. when it grounded on the west shore—it

ran against a wharf or something of that sort and was replaced

‘te there inthe center of the river at 12.07 P .M. opposite 21st

Street, and was taken out at 1.40 P. M.—or it was lost by a tug, at

1.40 P. M. nearly opposite the Battery.

Q. Did yen cause the observations to be plotted upon a map or

ar aa you have described now relative to float No. 46?

Q. Have you got that chart or map?

A. I have a print of it.

Mr. O'Sullivan: I offer the course taken by float No, 46 on Novem-

ber 8 and 9th 1909, as described by this witness, I offer in evidence

- — or chart, and ask that it be marked Complainants’ Exhibit

o 73.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. You have testified that this float did certain things.

1433 Were you there when these observations were made?

A. A of the time.

Q. god much of the oo

A. I saw them start the experiments in the evening, at ni ht,

and then went back. Only a short part of the time. 5 7

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 917

Mr. Riker Fay my hy dt ET

contain anythi is witness knows anythi t, except

papa owe FTE,

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for defendants.

Recerven and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 73.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 73.

Redirect examination by Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. Who was in charge of the observations from the time that

you started ir?

A. This work was done by relays. We started b having three

men, they relayed each other during the twenty-four hours—-we

started having two men, and then we had three men and after that

two men, and now the three that did this—I cannot tell, without

looking at the original notes, and I have not those here. I can find

that though if you want it.

Q. What next did you do relative to float observations?

A. Float No. 47 was set in November 9th, and taken up Novein-

ber 12th, 1909.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Now, before this witness uses his memoranda, I would like to

ask some questions. Did you prepare the original from which the

blue print was made?

A. No, I did not.

Q. Did make the observations which are supposed to be re

corded on blue print?

A. I think none of them.

Mr. Riker: I object to the use of this , as it is not either a

an by him or containing anything that he did him-

1434 The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for d>-

fendants.

The Witness: Well——_

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

The next one?

. The float was set out at 9.52 P. M. opposite Mount St. Vincent

November 9th. just before the beginning of the ebb current. It

a very short distance and then southerly until 2

was lost opposite 155th Street. Another float was set in

M —the

1

>o

a |

i

1

ne

ib

i>

Z

HH

23

. float was found again and reset at 6.45

th Street. and went northerly to just north

i t 8.15 it grounded and was reset on the

at 8.25 A. M. It went northerly to Inwood

on the easterly side, grounded at 10.58 A. M.

was reset near the middle of the river at 8.25 A.

05 P. on the west shore,

q='

Hs

2

Fs

if

f

z

S

Fs

918 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF XEW YORK VS.

and was reset in the middie and then went southerly and grounded

at the west shore at 2.10 P. M. It was taken up and reset in the

at 2.15 it went southerly to ite Pier 15 Manhattan, as

4.15 P.M. Then the current rev and it went northerly to op-

ite West 72nd Street at 9.45 P. M. and southerly to ite St.

Gaap at 4 A. M. then northerly opposite 72nd Street at 9.45 A. M.

=I a my that last was wrong—it went northerly to the Man-

idge, where the current reversed at 8.53 P. M. Thence

southerly to opposite Norton’s Point at 2.20 A. M. thence northeriy

Q. Were you in charge of all these fl-at observations?

A. I was.

A. Did you cause the course of Float No. 47 to be plotted on a

or chart?

. I did.

Q. Have you got that map or chart here?

1435 A. I have the print.

Mr. O'Sullivan: I offer the map or chart showing the course

as described by this witness, taken by float No. 47 on Novem-

ber 9th to November 12th, 1909. I offer that in evidence, and ak

that it he marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 74.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q Mr. Allen, did not you tell me that you had nothing to do

with the matters supposed to be recorded here personally ?

supervision of them.

do you mean by having supervision of them?

. The draftamen doing the work and the observers, they did their

work under my direction.

Q. Well, the observers did the work under your direction, what

Q And when certain supposed data were ‘furnished you, you

’ turned them over to the draftemen, did you not?

Q. That is all you did? i

Mr. Riker: I object to the offer on the ground that it Sas not

been proved by this witnes= to contain any fact.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for defendants.

Received and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 74.

Marked Complainante’ Exhilt No. 74.

Q. Wiss geet Genvetiens SS yes make relative to the floats’

A. Float 5th, 1909. Float No. 48 was put

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 919

Mr. Riker: One moment. You are using a paper to

1436 testify from, are you, Mr. Allen?

The Witness: Yes.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Does that contain any work that you did yourself?

A. That depends a little on just what you mean. It represents

my work to a certain extent, but the drafting on the paper I did

not do myself, no.

Q Not on the original paper?

A. Not that I remember, no.

Mr. Riker: I object to the use oi the paper on the ground that

it is not a memoranda tw refresh the witness’ memory.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Redirect examination by Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q Go on.

A. The float was put in the west channel of the East River

November 15th, 1909, opposite Fast 56th Street at 11 A. M. It went

northerly nearly to the Queensboro Bridge, to abovt 11:30 then it

went southerly to Buttermilk Channe] opposite the south end of

he plotted on a map or chart?

Mr. O’Sullivan : I offer the or chart showing the course taken

by Float No. 48 on November 15th, 1909. as described by this wit-

ness. I offer it in evidence and ask that it be marked Complainant:

Exhibit No. 75.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Were you present during the observations to which you have

testified ?

A. I was not.

Q. How do you know that what you have stated as fact is true?

A. Only from my know of the work of the men who

1437 did the work itself. That work was checked up from time

Mr. O'Sullivan: Have you finished your answer?

ra SS oe The work was checked up from time

to time by visits to the to see whether it was being carried on as

you know that anything that you have stated to be a

y occurred?

A. In no other way than by my knowledge of the men that did

offer on the ground that it is admit.

on the part of this witness.

objection of counsel for defend

Mr. O'Sullivan: Were these men working under your directions’

The Witness: They were.

Mr. O'Sullivan And the draftemen prepared that chart .nder

your direction *

The Witness: Yes.

The Commissioner Note the objection. Received and marked

Complainant<’ Exhibit No. 75.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 75.

Redirect examination By Mr. ('Sullivan

2g. What next observation did you make relative to the floats’

A. Float No. 49, November 16th and 17th, 1909. This war et

out at the mouth of the Fest River at 1.54 P. M.

Mr. Riker The witnes appearing to use a memorandum | would

like to ask in regard to this memorandum

1438 Recros-examination by Mr Riker

Q Did you make the observations supposed to he recorded

from which vou are reading’

’ you make the original from which the blue print wa

. Ri : 1 object to the use of it on the ground that it is not

& memorandum made by the witness that can he used to refresh his

. O'Sullivan

obeervations made by men under your direction”

A. were.

the chart or map that you have before

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.

syieegteat |

ii i :

aaalhietss fi

apiates 43 y8 3

au

23

HEE

SET Pied 73 oe

St

efi; all

ir 5 &

ies hd

oF init if ; . H

ac 7 3s 3 et e

. iy i $4 { Fs

ats

Ha

rt oot roe = 92495

<

972 THE PROFLE OF THE ®TATE OF KEW YORK V8.

Q And you were directed to make these float observations by the

Metropolitan Sewerage Commuismon ”

A. Ye.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker

Q Mr. Allen. when you sy were made by persons in

of the commision, how do you know they

> =

=3¢

*

; x

:

é

Hy

i

:

H

E

:

Fok

A were not able to

out days. but « henever came in they

Q They reported each detail of the observations’

A. Ye.

Q. And you were the proper man to make the report to, were you’

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.

. Riker asked you if that chart contains the same data as

<o<7

fliitnss p>

bs}asiee hy A

Si 8eg hEec es pli as

ann Hees

“7.42

Recrose-examination by Mr. Riker

prepared and con-

of a similar character under similar conditions

Sh pescamdtatae

which has heen offered was

Mr. Allen. | think wou testified in answer to me that

prepare the original yourself from which

?

apie

gy §<oy<o<o< =

417 H

3

he

924 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Were the float observations relative to No. 53 made by men

under your direction?

A. They were.

Q. Did those men report to you?

A. Yes.

Q. Was that chart that has just been offered in evidence and

marked Complainants’ Exhibit No, 77 prepared by a draftsman in

the employ of the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission under your

direction ?

A. It was.

Q. What was your next float observation, Mr. Allen?

A. No. 55, November 29th, and 30th, 1909. This was set in the

East River, opposite East 34th Street in the middle of the stream at

10.55 A. M.

Mr. Riker: Pardon me, Mr. Allen, | observe you are using a pa-

per to —- from. What is the paper that you are testifying

rom

1443 . The Witness: This is a record of the movement of the

oat.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

. Was this prepared in the same manner as the last exhibit?

It was.

. And were the observations made by you personally?

They were not.

Supposed to be recorded hereon?

No

When did you first see this paper you are testifying from?

. This print?

Yes.

. Yesterday.

Mr. Riker: I object to the witness using this paper in evidence

in giving his evidence as it does not appear to be a memorandum

which is competent to refresh his memory, and contains no fact

within his own knowledge. It was not made by him and he never

saw it until yesterday.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for defend-

ants.

POPOPOPOPrS

Redirect-examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Where did you receive that chart you are now using?

A. From the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission.

Q. The original of that chart was prepared by whom—under

whose direction?

A. Under my direction.

Q. When?

A. Very soon after the observations were made. I cannot say

the date when that was made.

PEP rene ae tt Bi SY SENTING Ae ePID MRI OY LOL Ay a TOE ORIEL SRAM —

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 925

Q. Describe the course taken by that float, Mr. Allen?

A. The float was put in the middle of the East River opposite

34th Street. It went southerly to the Lower Bay, south of Swin-

burne Island. At 7.40 P. M. it went northerly to point east of

Hoffman Island, at 11.30 P. M. and then southerly, southeasterly

down the Ambrose Channel, to a point southeast of Romer Light

at 3.43 A. M, and then westerly about 6 miles and at 10.20 A. M.

it was taken up and replaced about a mile and a half west of

Romer Light at 11.06 A. M. It then went southeasterly

1444 and southerly past the Scotland Lightship and was taken

up at 6.30 P. M. several miles southeast of Sandy Hook.

Q. Did you cause the course that you have described as taken by

Float ra > to be plotted on a map or chart?

A. I did.

Mr. O’Sullivan: I offer the map or chart showing the course as

: described by this witness taken by Float No. 55 on November 29th

7 and 30th, 1909, I offer it in evidence and ask that it be marked

Complainants’ Exhibit No. 78.

: Mr. Riker: I object to the offer on the same grounds as the use

of the paper was objected to.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Received and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 78.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 78.

Q. When did you make the next float observation?

A. Float 56. December 1st to 4th, 1909.

Mr. Riker: You are about to use a paper to testify from?

The Witness: Yes.

Recross-examination by Mr, Riker:

Q. When did you see that paper for the first time?

A. I saw this print yesterday for the first time.

, Q. And the origina! from which it was made, when did you see

| that first?

A. When it was made about the first of the year, 1910.

Q. Have you compared the two?

A. I have not.

Q. And you were asked when next you made a float observation,

did you make the float observations which are supposed to be re-

corded on this paper?

A. Not pineal os

Mr. Riker: I object to the use of the paper by this witness for

aby purpose as it appears not to have been made by him, and it does

hot purport to contain any observations or facts within his own

knowledge.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for

1445 defendants.

aa LCS PMO EET DEA SPN EN BA EERIE ORO ERIS ETN ost

926 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

Redirect examination by Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. Were those float observations made by men under your di-

rection?

A. They were.

Q. Did those men report to you?

‘A. Yes.

Q. Did you occasionally visit the scene of the observations?

A. Yes.

Q. You may proceed.

A. The float was set in December 1st, 1909, just east of Passaic

Light, Newark Bay. It went southerly past Shooter’s Island, and

then easterly down the Kiil von Kull. I will not be able to pick out

all these lines here. I will have to simplify this description a little.

To a point about opposite the west New Brighton, and then back

to about the point of starting for two tides, two tidal periods. In

the third tidal period it went up stream to just below the Central

Railroad of New Jersey Bridge in Newark Bay and then went down

to the mouth of the Kill von Kull. It then went up the stream

once and on the next ebb tide rounded St. George and followed the

shore of Staten Island to a point near Stapleton where it was taken

up at 6.50 A. M. December 3rd. Then it was reset at 7.05 A. M.

and went southerly until 9.55 A. M. opposite Gravesend Bay. It

then went northerly right into Gravesend Bay until 11.05 A. M.

and then reversed and rounded Norton’s Point, and went southerly

until southeasterly of Coney Island, midway between the Ambrose

Channel and the shore when it was taken up at 6.25 P. M. and re

placed at 7.12 P. M. about a mile to the south. It then continued

southerly until 9.30 P. M. when it was about east of Sandy Hook,

and then went northerly about one mile and a half northwest of

the point, where it was taken out at 6.25 P. M. And at 1.30 A. M

the curren’ reversed and it went southeasterly to a point about 8

miles away, when it was taken out at 6.55 A. M., Decem-

ber 4th.

1146 Q. How many tidal cycles did your observations of Float

No. 56 cover?

A. 6% complete tidal cycles.

Q. Did you cause the course that you have just described as

_ ge No. 56 to be plotted on a map or chart?

Q. And was the plotting done by a draftsman in the employ of

~ —— Sewerage Commission under your direction?

. It was.

Mr. O’Sullivan: I offer the course as described by this witness,

the map or chart showing this course taken by Float No. 56 on

December Ist to 4th, 1909 in evidence and ask that it be marked

Complainants’ Exhibit No. 79. ;

Mr. Riker: I object to the offer on the ground that the paper

has not been proved or authenticated as required by law, and it

admittedly contains no fact within the knowledge of this witnes

and does not contain any facts proved in the cause,

dil on ve oA, EGRET aa fet ens SIRE OEE EN Tip ONSITE NT OIC

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 927

The Commission: Note the objection.

Received and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 79.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 79.

Q. Were these obeservatins conducted under your direction?

A. They were.

Q. And were the reported observations reported to you?

A. They were.

Q. And did you cause the course of the observations to be plotted

upon a Exhibit No. 79?

A. id. z ‘

Q. When did you next make any float observations, Mr. Allen?

A. No. 57 December 6th to 8th, 1909. The float was started at

2.15 P. M. December 6th at the Brooklyn Bridge, on the east side

of the East River. It went northerly

Mr. Riker: Excuse me, please, the witness is using a paper

1447 now, I think.

The Witness: Yes.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. The paper that you have before you, Mr. Allen, when did

you see that first?

A. Yesterday.

Q. And the original from which it was taken, have you ever

seen it?

A. Yes.

Q. When?

A. Soon after the observations were made, about two years ago.

Q. What part did you have in the making of the original?

A. Supervising the draftsman.

Q. Did you compare the blue print with the original as it was

when you originally saw it?

A. I did not.

Q. Do you know of your own knowledge whether the blue print

is a correct representation of the original as you saw it after it was

prepared under your supervision?

A. I do not.

Q. Does the paper before you contain a record of any float ob-

servations made by yourself?

A. Not that I know of.

Mr. Riker: I object to the use of the paper by this witness on

the ground that it is not a memorandum made by this witness at

the time, or containing any fact within his own knowledge.

The Commissioner: Note the ebjection of Counsel for defendants.

The Witness: Float No. 57 was started December 6th at 2.15

P. M. on the east side of the East River at the Brooklyn Bridge.

It went northerly, grounded et Sonth Second Street and it was

reset at 2.50 P. it near the middle. It went northerly to Huron

Street, and grounded and was reset at 3.20 P. M. in the middle.

It went northerly up the west Channel and around Blackwell’s Is-

: sytem ne TP AE PRE EE REI DAS HAE LE, STE AE hem AM PRAISE I eee taal

928 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

land, the current turning at 5.20 P. M. It grounded at 6

1448 P. M. east of the south end of Blackwell’s Island and it was

reset at 6.05 P. M. It went southerly through the East

Channel down the river to Governor's Island, where it grounded

twice on the west side and was finally reset at 10.30 P. M. It went

southerly to opposite Stapleton and at 6.30 A. M. it went north-

easterly into Gowanus Bay. At 6.25 A, M. it reversed and went

southwesterly grounding on the Staten Island shore, north of the

Narrows, just north of the Narrows at 11.45 A. M. It was reset

and went southerly until] 1.05 P. M. when it was a short distance

east of a point midway between Hoffman and Swinburne Island.

It then west northerly and again grounded on the east shore of

Staten Island near the Narrows and was reset at 5.15 P. M. in the

Narrows, and went northerly to just east of St. George Ferry. At

7.30 P. M. December 7th it reversed and went southerly and

grounded at Coney Island Point at 11.35 P. M. It was then reset

a short distance west of the point and went southerly and reversed

at 3 A. M. and went northerly to the middle of Gravesend Bay.

At 4.30 A. M. it again went southerly, grounded on Norton’s Point

and was reset at 5.50 and then went southerly and then easterly

opposite the shore of Coney Island, until a short distance west of

Rockaway Point at 10.45 It was reset at 11.10 A. M. and then

went southeasterly to a point about a mile and a half south of Coney

Island Point, and was taken up at 1.40 P. M. December 8th.

Q. Were these observations made by relays of men under your

direction ?

A. They were.

Q. Continuing day and night?

A. Yes.

Q. Did they report these observations to you?

A. They did.

Q. Did you cause the observations as you described the course

vaken by rey No. 57, to be plotted on a chart or map?

A. 1 di

1449 Q. Was this chart or map made under your direction by

draftsmen in the employ of the Metropolitan Sewerage Com-

mission ?

A. It was.

Mr. O’Sullivan: I offer the chart or map showing the course, on

which is plotted the course as described LA witness, taken by

Float No. 57 on December 6th, to 8, 1909, in evidence and ask

that it be marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 80.

Mr. Riker: The offer is objected to on the same grounds as the

last offer, the offer of the last exhibit.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for defendants.

Received and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 80.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 80.

Q. When next did you make a float observation?

A. No. 58, December 9th and 10th, 1909.

Q. What was the date?

SENS GOMES Ree,

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 929

A. December 9th and 10th, 1909. This float was set out at 11.35

A. M. December 9th, a short distance southeast of Robbins Reef

Light.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. arr me, Mr. Allen, you are using a paper again?

A. Yes.

of the same character as the last one?

. Yes,

And prepared in the same manner as the last one’

. Yes.

. None, except as I have stated.

. And when did you see this paper first?

And the original

) the o ,

. Soon after it was made.

Have you compared it with the original?

. I have not.

Mr. Riker: I object to the use of the paper by this witness on the

same grounds as the last paper which was offered as an exhibit.

The Commisioner: Note the objection of counsel for defendants.

1450 Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q.

A

Q.

A

Q. From any facts within your own personal knowledge”

A

Q

Q

A

A

Q

A

Q. Proceed.

A. It was set at 11.35 A. M. December 9th, a short distance south-

east of Robbins Reef. It went southerly at 1 P. M. when it ded,

just north of Fort Wadsworth, and was reset in the middle of the

Narrows at 1.20 P. M. It then went southeasterly until 2.40 P. M.

and then northerly grounding near Fort Hamilton when it was re.

set again near the middle of the Narrows at 4.40 P. M. and went

easterly toward the shore and then skirted the eastern shore of the

Narrows, grounding at Bay Ridge at 6.35 P.M. It was reset at 6.45

P. M. in the middle of the stream, went northerly until 7.35 P. M.

when it was a short distance south of the starting point. It then

went easterly and southerly through the Narrows and at 1.30 A. M.

was east of a point between West Bank Light and Romer Light. It

then went northeasterly, nearly to Fort Hamilton, when the tide

changed at6 A.M. It then went toward Coney Island Point and was

icked up at 9.55 A.M. It was reset at 10.15 northwest of Coney

and Point. It then went southerly until 11 A. M. when it was

taken out a short distance southwest of Coney Island Point.

Q. Were the observations that you have described made by relays

of men during December 9th and 10th, 1909?

. They were.

Q. Did they report their observations to you?

A. They did

Q. Did you cause those observations to be plotted on a map or chart

by ~~ employed by the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission ?

Yes.

Mr. O’Sullivan: I offer the map or chart on which is plotted the

69—3

—

930 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

course taken by Float No. 58 on December 9th and 10th, 1909, in

evidence and ask that it be marked Complainants Exhibit No. 81.

Mr. Riker: The offer is objected to on the same ground as

1451 the last offer, the offer of the last exhibit.

The Commissioner: Note the objection. Reezived and

marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 81.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 81.

Q. When next did you make a float observation?

A. December 14th and 15th, 1909, Float No. 60.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q Mr. Allen, you have got before you again a paper which you

are going to testify from, are you?

. Yes,

Q. And you were asked when did you make these observations.

Were the o — that are supposed to be recorded here your

own personal wor

A. They were not.

Qa ng did not make them, did you?

A. No.

Q. When did you first see the paper you are about to testify from?

A. Yesterda:

Q. Have you seen the original between the time you name and

Q. When?

A. I cannot say when, but I see them every few days.

Q. Can you say that the blue print is a correct reproduction of

any 47 that you have ever seen before?

A. Not from comparison.

Q. Did you —_ any part of the observations which are supposed

to be recorded

A. Not that I remember.

Mr. Riker: I object to the use of the paper on the same grounds

as objection was made to the use of the last paper by the witness.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Were these observations made under your direction’

1452 A. They were.

Q. By relays of men working day and night during the

14th and 15th of December, 1909?

A. Yes.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.

g

:

|

|

-

’

a%

Fe

they had reported to you’

you see the original tracing or plotting shortly after the

id you oxo the axigh ng or plotting ye

&

>Eope

ge re

which this is a copy that you are now using?

ere

<

g

You may proceed?

A. This float was set southwest of Throggs Neck in the wu

East River, December 14th, 1909, at 2.30 P. M. at the time of the

4

if

i

Tf

if

E aE

Lei

ig

in

ae

z

is

=i

é

i

;

33

é

=

¥

;

! the mouth of Manhas-

then it went northerly, grounded on Barker Point.

the middle of the Bay at 3.30 A. M. and went north-

and _— on Barker Point at 4.35 A.M. It was reset

ween

northeasterly past Sands Point, and at a point north of Sands Point,

its motion was a spiral from about 8.30 A. M. until about 1.20 P. M.

then started off in a northeasterly direction and was taken up a

distance southwest of Mattinicock Point at 6.45 [. M. Decem

. Did those relays of men who made these olservations report to

A. They did.

Q. oe en So Aearatioms § be eletind «0 9 exp

or wating course taken float, during

ember 14th and 15th? :

i

52

st

. O'Sullivan: I offer the map or chart showing the course taken

by Float No. 60 on December 14th and 15th, 1909, as described

dew — in evidence and ask that it be marked Complainants’

ibit No. 82.

Mr. Riker: The offer is objected to on the same grounds and for

the same reasons as were offered on the last exhibit.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Received and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 82.

Marker Complainants’ Exhibit No. 82.

See CER CS FED GUND OF Gimme t be exnde fet chee

A. December 16th, 17th and 18th, 1909.

932 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF XEW YORI. V8.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

— Allen, your are using a paper again?

Q

A. Yes.

Q And is this paper of the same character and compared in the

same way as the last paper that you used that was subsequently

offered as an exhibit?

A. It is.

Q. Does it contain any original observations made by you or in

your presence?

A. Not that I remember.

@. And have you compared it with the original of which you

supposed it to be a blue print?

A. I have not.

Mr. Riker: I object to the use of it on the grounds that were

apt ge Se oe used by this witness.

Recross-examination by Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q What number is that float, Mr. Allen?

A. No. 61. This float was started in the Arthur Kill December

16th, at 11.55 A. M. off Elizabethport. It went northerly, a short dis

tance north of the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Bridge, and thence

southerly cane two cycles of tide, each time going to a point

Letween Tuffts Point and Smoking Point on the Arthur

1454 Kill. On returning the second time it passed the starting

point and went to the mouth of Newark Bay, northwest of

Shooter's Leland. It then went a short distance southwesterly, and

easterly and south of the Island and then returned, rounding the

light house off the mouth of the Arthur Kill. It was then taken up

and reset just west of Shooter's Island and went northerly to near

the Central Railroad of New Jersey Bridge across the Nowark ,

It was reset then a short distance to the south and went y

and easterly to the Kill von Kull and grounded at 2 A. M. December

18th, on the north shore of Staten Islend, just east of Port Richmond.

Q. How many tidal cycles did the observations that you have just

described relative to Float No. 61 oceupy?

A. Three and one half complete cycles

Q. Approximately will do, Mr. Allen?

A. I will make sure of that.

(Witness examines data.)

A. were.

Q. Did those men report to you?

A. They did.

Q. Did you cause the reported facts to be plotted on any map #

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.

r. O'Sullivan: I offer the map or chart showing the course testi-

fied to by this witness as having Leen taken by Float No. 61, during

the 16th, to the 18th of December, 1909, in evidence, and ask that

it be marked Complainants’ Exhibit No, 83.

Mr. Riker: The same objection to this as to the last offer.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for the de

fendants.

1455 Received and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 83.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 83.

Q. When were the next observations made on float experiments?

A. Float No. 62, December 20th and 21st, 1909.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q Is this you are alout to testify from of the same character

and in the same way as the last paper that you used?

@ And the blue print iteslf you cow for the fext tine yester-

root

*

ze

=

id you see the original?

. I do not remember the day, but I see the originals every few

id compare this paper with the original?

I did not

Did the originals contain any record of any original observa-

made by you or when you were present?

. Not that T know of.

Fo>ot

>

&

ee i

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Proceed.

It went towards Willett’s Point. It was then taken up and reset a

short distance to the north and went towards City Island until 2 A. M.

and then the current reversed and it grounded off Throggs Neck

and was taken up at 3.10 A. M. and reset off Throggs Neck. From

it westerly grounding near Whitestone Point. It was re-

middle of the stream, and then went westerly and then

directions unti] 10.20 A. M. without going but a short

Received and marked ’ Exhibit No. 84

Complainants’ Exhibit No

Marked Complainants Exbitit No *4

Q. The next one

?

A. Float No. 68, December Zist, 1909.

Recross-examination by Mr Riker

6 When, = Allen. ie it of the same character as the let

one

, feat No. 64.

THE STATE OF PEW JEREEY FT At.

Blackwell

near

eo 2.

taken

map or

having

prepared in the same general way”

That was

Vea.

As the last’

sits +. 3

viptieer-aq het

Recrmexaminavon by Mr Riker

Q You are shout to tetify from « paper agein, Mr. Allen’

> * * & &

Q When next did you direct float observations’

A. December 22nd and 2ird, 1900

Q And dor it contain any record of any oniginal observations by

ee S|

© 3y

are! oe

il }

1 Han

Pa

[sist F

i? aH

= 5i35s iii

i 3 alti tei as

Redirect examination by Mr (’Sulliven

> Reenter

. It wae set out ot 7.20 A. M. December 22nd, 1909, in the

hiatal:

rae it

OF THE STATE OF FEW YORK va.

gull

inet

é fiptiseise-e UGH fee sgh)

its

a

Mr. Riker. You are not going to use thie chart for the purpow

of this testimon

vy’

:

:

$2

x

r

5 E

=

i!

LU

Mr.

:

,

:

THE STATE OF NEW JSEROEY ET AL. 987

Mr. Riker wg yy apes of mad og = Line Laney

The Witnes is 1s the report made Metropolitan .

erage Commission om the work of the float ;

Recrosexamination bv Mr. Riker. ‘

@ And the that yeu are rexding from, what did you

have to do with that?

_ I wrote out the description from the map

©>eore> &

z

fF

E

aff

i

:

j

E

” ever read matter before

before now?

Witnes: Vee

Redirect examination by Mr O’Sullivan

you ever read the description given on that volume of

-"

orForore

yvlry

it correspond with your report, did you in any way make

see that it ?

;

i

;

i

|

Mr. O'Sullivan: I will have to withdraw it, Mr. Allen. It is

clear'y worthless.

Ma ratnest: Supposing I make it from the map?

Mr. 0’Sullivan : Make it from the map, yes.

Recromexamination by Mr. Riker.

, You are about to use the blue print, are you, Mr. Allen?

did you see that blue print for the first time?

ere =

tf

938 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

A. Yesterday.

Q. And what did you have to do with the preparation of the orig-

inal from which this blue print was taken?

. I had supervision of the drafting.

When was that drafting done?

. Sodn after the observations were made.

. Have you compared this blue print with the original drafting?

. I have not.

. Did you make any of the observations which are sup to

be recorded on this blue print, or the original from which it was

taken?

A. Not that I remember.

Q. How do you know whether the course of this float which is

supposed to be delineated on this chart is correctly indicated on

the chart?

A. Only by occasional tests of the integrity of the men, and the

work they were doing.

Any test on this particular part of the work that you remem-

r?

A. I do not remember.

Mr. Riker: I object to the use of this blue print on the same

grounds that were urged to the use of the last.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

O>O>rop

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Proceed?

A. This float was started December 27th, at 10 A. M. off College

Point, and went southerly and then westerly down the East River

and between that and the time it was taken out it oscillated back and

forth between Ferry Point and the Brooklyn Bridge. It was taken

out December 30th at 4.30 P. M. near the shore of the Bronx, op

posite North Brother Island.

Q. How many tidal cycles had that float No. 65 been in

1462 the water?

- A. Six and one half—six and one quarter, or six and one

alf.

Q. Was it under observation during all of that time by relays of

men in the employ of the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission?

A. It was.

Q. Did they make their reports to you of their observations?

A. They did.

Q. Did you cause these observations to be plotted on a map oF

chart by a draftsman employed by the Metropolitan Sewerage

mission

A. I did.

Mr. O’Sullivan: I offer the map or chart showing the direction

taken by Float No. 65 on December 27th, to December 30th, both

inclusive, in the year 1909, I offer it in evidence and ask that it be

marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 87.

nee a LP EGE AAP SIE TS

—

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 939

Mr. Riker: The offer is objected to on the same grounds as the

last one. -

The Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for defendants.

Received and marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 87.

Marked Complainants’ Exhibit No. 87.

At Mr. O’Sullivan’s request an adjournment was taken at this

hour to enable him to procure original data which the witness had

failed to produce.

At 12.30 adjourned for noon recess until 2 P. M.

1463 City Hatt, New York, January 4th, 1912.

Afternoon Session, 2 p. m.

KENNETH ALLEN a witness called on behalf of Complainants, re-

called for further examination, testified as follows:

Direct examination (continued) by Mr, O’Sullivan:

Q. Mr. Allen, you were requested at the time of recess to produce

the original tracings from which these blue prints were made; have

you done so?

A. T have.

Q. I now direct your attention to Complainants’ Exhibit No. 32,

being a chart showing the float observations for float No. 1?

A. I have here the original tracings, and the chart. The tracing

of Float No. 1 and Exhibit No. 32, and find that they correspond in

all particulars.

Mr. McCarter: Just one moment. We are inclined to waive proof

that the blue prints are copies of the tracings. I do not think there

is anything in that. That does not admit that the tracings are com-

petent evidence, but we will not ask you to prove that the blue print

isa copy of the tracing. That wouid be simply ridiculous. We are

pretty bad, but we are not as bad as that.

Mr. O'Sullivan: I withdraw this witness just a moment. Mr.

Berrey, will vou take the stand, please?

Max L. Berrey a witness called on behalf of the Complainants, re-

called for further examination, testified as follows:

Direct examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. You have testified in this suit on a previous occasion, have you

not, Mr. Berrey?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. What is your vocation or business?

A. Topographical draftsman.

_ Q. And are you connected with any commission now?

A. T am connected with the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission of

New York as Topographical draftsman.

1464 Q. And how long have you been connected with the

Metropolitan Sewerage Commission as draftsman?

es ECE I POLLEN PET LELINL EDEL NOP LLELEE, SLAP ELIE NIGGER ELE BES 5 SEB. IT NEE DT Ries ea :

tt

940 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VSB.

A. Since February of 1909.

Q. During the months of August, September, October and No-

vember and December of 1909, did you receive direction from any

one to make tracings of float courses?

A. Yes. sir.

Q. From whom?

A. I took directions from Mr. Allen.

Q. Mr. Kenneth Allen?

A. Mr. Kenneth Allen.

(. Who was just on the stand before you took the stand now”

A. Yes, sir.

Q. Have you produced those tracings in court?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Who made those tracings: who drew them, who was the

draftsman?

A. Part of them were made by myself, and some were made by

Mr. John Fox. T believe Mr. Kenneth Allen plotted some; I am

not positive, but I believe so. It is my remembrance.

Q. Where did you get the tracings that you produced here in

court?

A. From the office of the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission.

Q. Are they part of their records?

A. They are.

Q. What do you know in relation to those blue prints, as to when

they were made?

os The blue prints were made during the month of December,

191}.

Q. This past December?

A. Yes.

Q. Were they made from these tracings?

A. Made from the original tracings.

Q. Have you produced them here?

A. Yes, sir.

Mr. O'Sullivan: Your witness.

Cross-examination by Mr. McCarter:

a. “gi of the tracings as you made, are you able to identify?

. T am.

Q. By any signature or initial?

A. T cannot say my signature appears.

1465 Q. What method would you pursue; would you take the

field hooks that were handed to vou as containing the obser-

vations by certain gentlemen who had observed floats that had heen

put in the water at different places and from those entries in hooks

make the tracings?

A. I would.

Q. You did not have anything to do with the observations that

were contained in the field books, did you?

A. No, sir, nothing whatever.

ell aot RTI ROT LEV RS IE HORN ALS RTI EE LISLE TE LP POTENCIES RE ARE

THE STATE Ob NEW JERSEY ET AL. 941

Q. Take the field books, as they were handed to you, you took a

a traced out the different ones as you were directed to do?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. For instance, taking a field book (counsel examines field book )

What method would you pursue? You did not have in this field

book a sketch or map; would you hypothecate lines between the two

given places where the notation appeared?

Mr. Sullivan: You better, Mr. McCarter, let him describe what he

did.

Mr. McCarter: All right, describe what you did.

The Witness: I took the field books, the field notes that were

turned over to me. I looked them over to see whgt part of the har-

bor they covered, the float had covered. I took % ‘coast and geodetic

survey chart—the best, the only authority there is for this sort of

work that I know of—took a piece of tracing paper, laid it over the

geodetic survey chart, then laid my locations, piers, streets, and

buoys, lighthouses, prominent points of the kind, which were noted

in the books by the observer who made the record. In that way |

could plot the different points at which time and distance from ¢er-

tain points they were taken, observed and those points could be plot-

ted on these tracings, and the different points, Sees connecting the

different points.

Q. Interpolated?

A. Yes, to the best of my knowledge.

Q. For instance, having taken the geodetic survey and plotted on

one of those tracing papers, the location, then you undertook

1466 to locate upon that document the points that were not in the

field books, as having been observed?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And you then connected in the course of the float, the given

points by hypothesis or interpolation ?

A. As a rule. Sometimes if there was any great length of time

between the two observations, I might ask the observer about where

e went.

oe And you would take what he said if that was a sufficient length

of time?

A. Ordinarily the observations were taken quite close together,

within a few minutes, so there would be a very short distance be-

tween the points of observation.

Q. Do you know how many of these observations there were?

A. Do you mean on one test or through the whole series?

Q. Through the whole series?

A. I cannot say that now, exactly.

A. Several.

Q. And they would note the result of their tests in these, what I

tall field books, that lie before you here?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. You did not make any observations yourself, I suppose?

A. None at all.

Q. This geodetic survey, is it a federal or a state document?

O4e THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

A. That is a Federal Bureau.

Q. And then the blue prints of course are the regular blue prints

of the tracings, so that if the tracing is right, the blue print neces-

sarily is right, it is not altered in any way at all?

A. That must be correct.

Q. Well, now, taking the blue print, which—we will take Exhibit

No. 32 for instance, as a specimen. This has on it this phrase:

“Total distance covered 4.5 miles in one hour and 55 minutes.

Average velocity 2.3 miles per hour.” Did you make those com-

putations?

A. I did not.

Q Who did that, if you know?

A. I have no personal knowledge, but 1 think Mr. Fox plotted

that particular float record.

Q. That is not one of your records?

A. I had nothing te do with that record.

1467 Q. Can you pick out one that is; I simply want to find

out how you did it personally. This is Complainants’ Ex-

hibit number 73. Did you make any computations on this that

you plotted. This does not seem to have any computations, cor-

ding, for instance, to the phrase “Total distance covered 45

miles in 1 hour and 55 minutes; average velocity 2.3 miles per

hour.”

A. No, I did not do that.

Q. Do you know anything about the method pursued by the

other plotters, to tell us how a computation of that kind, which

I have just read from Exhibit No. 32 was made. Was that com-

puted by the plotters or by the observer?

A. That was computed by the plotter.

Q. In other words after he had plotted on his map the distance

covered by the float in the manner you have indicated, he would

we off the distance and designate below the result, is that

right

A. I believe that is the method, yes.

Q. And do you know how he got at the velocity, or the average

—

A. The average velocity is obtained by the total distance covered,

and you have the total time it took to cover that distance.

Q. Then you would add the times covered, included in the

field book in the particular observation and he would measure the

distance -— it in the manner you have indicated, and by a

simple method ascertain the ave velocity ?

A. I believe that is the don

Cross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Did you make any allowance for the time these floats were

stranded or out of water?

A. Do you mean does that appear?

Q Do you know whether there were allowances made?

a maith ai

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 943

A. In figuring the velocity?

Q. Yes.

A. 1 cannot say.

By Mr. McCarter:

Q. Who is the J. P. F. whose initials appear on so many

1468 of these different exhibits?

A. John P. Fox.

Q. Is he still in the employ of the commission?

A. Not at this time.

Q. But any blue print or tracing containing those initials indi-

cates that Mr. Fox was the man who prepared the tracing?

A. That is my knowledge of the point, yes.

Mr. McCarter: That is all.

Mr. O’Sullivan: That is all, Mr. Berrey. Counsel for Complain-

ants desires to direct the attention of Counsel for the defense to

the fact that these tracings are here now and that he has no power

of retaining them, in case any comparisons are deemed necessary.

Take the stand, Mr. Allen.

KENNETH ALLEN a witness called on behalf of Complainants, re-

called for further examination, testified as follows:

Direct examination (continued) by Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. Mr. Allen, you were requested to produce the original field

note books submitted to you by the observers; have you done so?

A. I have.

Q. And you have them now in court?

A. Yes.

Q. How often were those reports made to you by the men who

were making the observations?

A. As a rule they would turn the book in as soon as they came

in from the field, turn the book in at the office, and then take an-

other book in the field while the first book was left in the office

for plotting the float records.

Q So that they used books alternately in that way?

A. Yes, most of the time. The first period of time when making

the shore records, they might use one Sook several days in succes-

sion. They might use i: a week, and then turn it in.

Q. Some of the float numbers as you testified to them, Mr. Allen,

pane were not alluded to. Take Float No. 20. What became of

t?

A. — No. 20 I believe is in the same sheet as Float No.

1469 Q. What have you in your hand, now, Mr. Allen?

A. I have the float record of numbers 19 and 20.

Mr. O’Sullivan: Complainants’ Exhibit No, 55?

The Witness: Yes.

Q. Is the course of Float No. 20 shown on Complainants’ Ex-

hibit No. 55? .

Pew east SF PTET A GEE! CRG HES I AM OL SR Fe ae

944 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

A. It is.

Q. Describe it.

Mr. McCarter: The same objection.

Mr. Riker: The same objection. The facts ought to appear.

The Commissioner: Note the objections.

A. It was put in the upper East River at 1.20 o’clock a little north

of Stepping Stone Light. For the date, 1 will have to refer to the

note book. It went in a southerly direction, past the Lighthouse,

and it was taken up 7 minutes past 2. No observation in between

the two points. I will look up that date.

Q. Yes.

Mr. McCarter: Please note on the record that Defendant»’ Coum

sel observes that the witness is proposing to use the note books that

were made by the observers, and not by him, as a means of enabling

him to testify. We respectfully contend that he has no right to use

them, no more than counsel or anybody else would have, and evi-

dence based on such use is not legal evidence.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Mr. Riker: I want to interpose the further suggestion that if he

uses them, that the books must be put in evidence.

Mr. O'Sullivan: Complainants’ Counsel desires to state in am

swer to that that as these are public records he has no power to de

other than have the witness stimulate his memory from them,

and if deemed necessary later, I will have copies of them made. |

am not permitted to put them in evidence.

1470 Q. These note books were handed to you by the man whe

— the observations under your direction, that is the fact’

A. Yes.

Q. Consulting the note book in reference to Float No, 20”

A. That was made the same day as No. 19, which was September

3rd, 1908.

Q. And it appears on Complainants’ Exhibit No. 55, ite course?

A. Right.

Q. Now, Floats Nos. 40 to 45?

A. Floats Nos. 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, were none of them plotted.

were in the water a short time and the courses were so im

significant that it did not seem worth while to plot them.

Q. Now, Floats Nos. 50, 51, 52, 54 and 59?

A. No. 50 was destroyed by a ferry boat after it had been in the

water 35 minutes. 51 was lost in a storm and the record was im-

ect. 52 was lost after being in the water two and three quarters

ours, 54, the work had to be stopped on account of a storm, after

being in the water three and one half hours, and No. 59 was stopped

for the same reason after two and one half hours’ observation.

Those records were all so short we considered them as valueless.

Q. That accounte for the whole series reported of float experi-

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 945

Q. What was the rific information sought by those float ex-

periments, conducted oon and under your directions?

A. The most important information that we expected to derive

from them was the possible curve that would be taken by the sewage

or other material drifting in the harbor. Aside from that it gave

an indication of the distance which the tidal flow traversed during

atide. That, of course, only applied to these records that were of

sufficient length to cover practically a full tide.

Q. Did +” of the float experiments cover more than one tide?

A

. Yes.

471 = Q.- Did you make any memoranda at the time of these

vations or su uent to them, relative to the informa-

tion sought and what you uced from these?

A. Yes, those records were taken and studied individually, and

then the result summed up and re rted on in a series of reports

in 1909. I think there are in 1 quite a number, but the later

of these longer night experiments which were made in 1910,

ot been reported on by me in that form.

What reports did you make on the ones in 1908, taking the

of the year, November?

A. The first one was October 26th, 1908, The second were No-

vember 19th, 1908, and February 15th, 1969, and there was also

ot

)

the information sought and how these observations satisfied that

and to what extent?

Mr. McCarter: I object to it as incompetent, irrelevant and im-

material.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of Counsel for Defendants.

A. The object of the work. A series of float observations was

undertaken by the Commission in August for the purpose of se-

curing more definite knowledge regarding the velocity, trend and

duration ef the currents in the waters of the Metropolitan District.

much important information of the kind has been already

I eg | by the Dock Department and by the U. §.

Coast & Geodetic Survey, both of whom have gone to considerable

fons (a) regarding their effect in preventing deposits and (b) re-

arding the amount and directions of the tidal progression of the

60—3

RS I Pe Pe

946 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF XEW YORK VS.

the Harlem River are, however, an exception, as these appear never

to have been accurately observed. But regarding the probable trend

of sewage, which is known to confine i | game © Se od

of the surface, existing information is not so reli , and with

erence to such an important point as the proposed outlet of the

saic Valley Sewer is very deficient.

For these reasons a limited number of float observations—sufficient

to draw definite although very general conclusions as to ihe abuve

questions—was deemed most irable and their cost justified.

e

aun ae would be followed by sewage, has been

of ssest importance, and so the type of Gost Res been exloced wi

=» &

= SESSBEBSTCES SBEPST BASSwP |Bgsees =

Bigg Seeses Ff By

oe

=

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 947

drical air-tight tin can, 5%” in diameter by 5” long, having a short

%” socket on top and an eyelet in the bottom. In the socket an

18” staff was set carrying a small red flag with a serial number. A

#16 gage copper wire attached to the eyelet a

1474 second can at the proper depth—usually 5 feet. is sec-

ond or “sinker” can was 6” in diameter by 14” long, had an

for receiving the wire in the center on top and a %” nozzle,

in the top, closed by a cork, for receiving ballast. The ballast

consisted of water with sufficient sand to nearly submerge the buoy

can and so eliminate the influence of the wind. The cost of these

double floats per hundred was $25.

This type of float proved very satisfactory in the rivers and Upper

Bay. Out of 38 set adrift between August 14 and October 5, 1908,

in the Harlem, East and Hudson Rivers, Newtown Creek and the

Upper Bay about 14 were lost, most of them iy being run down and

cut by the propellers of steamers. In general, however, they were

not easily destroyed.

The courses of these floats were followed and their paths located

by means of a lene launch (first the Twilight, 46ft. long x 10

ft. beam, and t the Ethelwin, 30 ft. long by 8 ft. 6 in. )

carrying two men besides the observer and with a smal! boat in

tow

tions were made by the observer at frequent intervals, de-

ing somewhat on the velocity of the current, by noting the dis-

tance from the shore, by noting when in line with or opposite some

given pier, street or structure, by bearings to structures whose po-

sitions were known with an azimuth compass, or, if distant, by the

use of the sextant. For the Harlem and East Rivers locations by

streets and distances from shore were most satisfactory. The azi-

muth compass was most convenient and would have been erable

in Most instances except for liability to error due to sluggishness of

the needle and to local attraction. For these reasons long si

were entirely unreliable and even with sights of a few h

eet liable to be too great to be permissible

1475 im so narrow a stream as the Harlem River. The sextant is

more precise but owing to the motion of the boat in the

ing currents the time for observation limits its useful-

the areas of the bay.

path of each float was plotted on a rough tracing of the Coast

most suitable for the purpose, generally on a scale of

, and the velocity between connecting con-

servation points calculated by the times of observation and the scaled

distances. Where the velocities, as compared with those taken im-

, appeared abnormal, this was generally

lack of precision in noting the time where the intervals were

of minute in time might result in a

error in the deduced velocity. In such cases one or more

intermediate observations have disearded so as to elimi-

errors of this nature and secure a more reliable velocity over

q

iv

if

:

d

i

E

af

§

caf

fet jis oe igi! i a i i

ih tt i i ai i:

Pay Hot AH salle i c i} it

: rr i at ii tas a ie a oho i

rl Hee ae aH fig} fe rey

i etl i a He ie Hd dob

Pifeh apie AHF aie

i 1 ae sql stsdataieds3ii2

GRAS eas

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET (1.

that without the

. proved in a wav,

in evidence. T. m-

Ld

to

cone!

cannot be introduced

|

|

|

!

“a7

made, did

some of them were made, but not when

of

uring what the document i

Sewerage Commission ?

itan Sewerage Comumisson

. | observe the witnes readin

when

tade

Metropolitan

observations which vou stated have been

. Riker: The

The Witnes: The Metropoli

present

hem

iker: I wish

which the

conclusions

and

these

Recrosexamination by Mr Riker

vased upon

which vou are reading from is |

you did not make vourself?

ment

me that

theme

— Oo

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF SEW YORK V8.

att;

=

Hee

aT 3

if

HEH

en

TIS el ee

| sit F I is : ' glass

i 4! HHT he if Sec

gNagpet dal fp it3

y risa, FL day y Rises

I geist HE ict ah aah:

A yiel fegfiep Fig

53 eeesee. = ess

f itis “ii it

“| Hun ‘a et ses

Hi! iti § - eat li -as

Neap Tides.

Pvt.

ater Vat

oe

‘PSST SD iw

ve

oo

‘wel

10

05

05

04

04

“0

23 9.0

25 9.0

23 8.0

6.0

55

60

o4

93

02

25

30

3.0

13

17

18

4

20

40

« Interpolated. Racord Incomplete

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 951

IL. On the Jersey Plate.

outlet, the particular object being to determine the velocities near

erosion

the bottom that may produce .

South of the P. RR. Terminal these wore observed 2 ft. from

the surface and about 2 ft. from the bottom, the depth at low water

2

being about 7 ft. The resultant curve was plotted from the

1480 =6work of several days, irrespective of the phase of the moon.

Mid-depth Velocities in Feet per Second

Northeast of the P R. R. Terminal! the observations were taken in

a similar manner and the depth was about the same, but the work

extended over but about «ix hours.

Mid-depth Velocities in Feet per Second.

Ee es, Velowtey. EST vetociey. GET vetcny. AT — Veloomy.

tr lw Pioed car Seck H.W. Pb) car.

1% 0.05 - = 74 0.10 11.0 1.10"

Off Black Tom Island velocities were observed about 3 ft. below

the surface only, the depth at low water being but about 6 ft.

Velocities at a Depth of 2 Ft. in Feet per Second.

fen Veloony rest Velocity, BT SOT veioeity Awl Velocity.

Sack Fw. Ee cor ee Ficed cur

7 0.00 2.50 1.15 7.7 0.00 85 0.80

TTI. At Rockaway Inlet.

Velocities here were taken in the channel between Rockaway

and the Plum Island with the view of obtaining information

ing the discharge from and into Jamaica Bay. Assuming

the average of the velocities at one fifth and four fifths depth

would give the mean velocity in that vertical, observations were

made approximately at these depths. Generally about 9 feet and

%6 feet with the f

Mean Velocity in Channel in Feet per Second.

Pw, Yee pwer Yt 25S, ve Pht Va.

Sock 8. Ww. Eb cor fleck HOW Ficed car.

95 60 3.0 34 7a 0.0 9.0 2.1

1 Record incomplete The maximum velocity probably occurred ister than

eet ie ee Mi de ee ee

952 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATI. OF NEW YORK VS.

1481 From the plotted velocity curves the mean velocity was

found to be 2.22 feet seconds during the ebb, and 1.42 feet

From soundings made by the United States Engineer Corps, in

this case to be but 0.8, that in the vertical taken, the mean cross

sectional velocities for ebb and flood were found 1.78 and 1.14 feet

seconds respectively.

From soundings made by the United States Engineer Corps, in

1908, the area of the cross section at low water, was calculated to be

75,240 square feet. The range of the tide being 4.8 feet. The area

at mean tide was estimated at 88,800 square feet. This is necessarily

a very rough approximation, as elevations on the low lying shore are

not known.

With these factors the discharge during the ebb was found to be

3,729,000,000 cubic feet, and during the flood 2,136,000,000 cubic

feet. Considering the area tributary to Jamaica Bay, it is seen that

the net discharge of 1,593,000.000 cubic feet per tide from Jamaica

Bay cannot be considered in any way normal, but must be due

either to peculiar conditions during the time of observations, to

errors in the assumed cross sectional area, at mean tide, or to both

these causes.

Q. Mr. Allen, did you compare your results with the report of the

Coast Survey of these velocity experiments?

A. The Coast Survey have not data on velocities at those points s0

no comparison was plotted.

Q. Well, as to the tidal motion?

A. No, I did not know of any data that they have that would be

comparable to these.

Q. Did you look at any reports of the Coast Survey at all?

A. Yes, but not with reference to this particular work, experiments

at these four points, but with reference to the general subject, yes.

Q. The general subject of what?

A. Tidal phenomena, currents, velocities.

Q. With what results?

1482 Mr. McCarter: I object to that. The best evidence of the

observations made by the Geodetic Survey is the survey itself.

Comparison can be made by the court if material.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

The Witness: The only data that we could compare, that I think

of were the velocities. The velocities vary very greatly as they will

under various conditions. They agree as nearly as can be expected,

but there was a great variation at different times in all these streams.

_Q Did you conduct a series of bath house experiments with a

view to determining the pollution of the waters?

A. I did, yes. Shall I describe them?

Q. Yes?

A. Those were made with the object of determining whether the

water in the bath houses was directly polluted by effluents from sew-

ers. The first one was made by Mr. John P. Fox on August 12th,

1909. Do you want me to read the details or just surmarize?

Q. You summarize what the results were.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 952

Mr. McCarter: I object to that on the ground that Mr. Fox should

be called and not this witness’ statement as to what Mr. Fox did.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

The Witness: The first experiment was at the 79th Street sewer,

South Brooklyn. It was with reference more particularly to the

bathing beaches in the vicinity of that sewer. There is no batia

house there. It was intended to see if the sewage from the 71-t

Street sewer polluted the bathing beach just south. It was found

that the sewage from the South Brooklyn sewers followed the shore

closely with the ebb current. The flow from one sewer mingling

with that from the next. I have a summary of the matter here.

Q. How many experiments were conducted?

A. There were thirteen bath houses that were investigated.

¥ 1483 Recross-examination by Mr. McCarter:

Q. Did you personally make those investigations?

A. No, I did not.

; Q. They were all made by other gentlemen and reported to you

. and so are giving the results of their reports to you?

A. Yes.

Mr. McCarter: I object as irrelevant, incompetent and imma-

terial— 1 want an objection to each one.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan.

‘ Q. What were they, Mr. Allen?

A. The first experiment was made August 31st, 1909, a dye being

put in at the mouth of the Morris Street sewer during ebb current.

The dve consisted of a compound, what we call special scarlet, with

| a view to seeing whether that polluted the bath house at the Battery.

No result was found. September 2nd a similar experiment was

made with two pounds of special scariet.

September 15th the same experiment was tried from the Board

4 Street sewer on the ebb current, two pounds of special scarlet was

used with no results.

As to the 51st Street bath house, September 2nd. one half a

pound of uranine was placed at the sewer outlet at 50th Street and

followed on the flood with no result. On the same day the experi-

ment was repeated and the diffused dye was found in the bath house.

August 31st it was tried from the 54th Street sewe: on the ebb, one

pound of special scarlet with no result.

On the 30th of August, the previous day, it was tried from the

50th Street sewer outlet on the flood and the bath house was found

| polluted.

| September 7th the experiment was repeated with positive results.

I was mistaken about those two previous cases where I said it was

polluted, it was not, those two previous. It was in this last one only.

— OIRO TARO EI GL LIE A LAA SIREN

954 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V3.

The 82nd Street bath house was experimented with on

1484 August 30th from the sewer at 80th Street. One pound of

special scarlet being placed at the sewer outlet on the flood

without result.

September 4th, the experiment was repeated without result.

per wd 7th, it was repeated again, and the bathhouse was

found polluted, the water in the bath house.

The 97th Street Bathhouse was tried on August 31st one pound

of special scarlet was put in at 96th Street with no result.

mber 9th it was tried with two pounds of uranine from the

108th Street outlet on the ebb, with no result.

On the 16th it was tried with three pounds of special scarlet from

the 96th Street sewer outlet with no result.

On September 21st it was tried again from the same point with

three pounds of special scarlet with no result.

On August 31st, near the 137th Street Bath house, an experi-

ment was made taking one pound of special scarlet at the 158th

Street sewer outlet and found polluted.

The private bath house at 155th Street was found polluted on

August 30th by one pound of special scarlet put in at 158th Street.

That finishes those on the North River.

On the East River the bath house at pier 33 was experimented

with on August 28th, putting one half a pound of ial scarlet

in at Jefferson Street on the ebb without result. It was tried again

on the same day from Rutger’s Slip and found polluted.

The bath house at Collier’s Hook was tried August 28th from

Collier Street with one pound of special scarlet on the ebb, without

result and repeated on the same day without result.

mber 2nd, it was tried again without result.

September 2nd. again, and on September 16th again, and each

time without result.

The Fifth Street bath house on August 30th was experimented

with using two pounds of special scarlet, being put in at the

1485 14th Street sewer on the ebb, the color reaching the bath

house, but it being ladies’ day we were not able to go inside,

so that we could observe it inside.

ber 2nd, one pound of special scarlet was put in at the

Sixth Street sewer without result.

On the same day two pounds was put in at 14th Street without

result.

+ were put in on September 14th at 14th Street with-

out

September 14th, two pounds were put in at 3rd Street without

The 96th Street bath house, on August 31st, a pound of uranine

was put in at 95 Street without result.

September 2nd, one pound of special scarlet was put in at 95th

‘September 9th, one pound of uranine was put in off 95th Street

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 955

Septer: er 18th, four pounds of special scarlet was put in at 95th

Street without result.

Brooklyn, 58th Street, August 27th. One pound of special scarlet

was put in at 49th Street on the ebb without result.

August 27th, one pound of special scarlet was put in at 64th

Street on the flood, it reached the bath honse, but being ladies’ day

was not observed inside.

September 2nd, 64th Street, two pounds of special scarlet were

put on the flood tide, without result.

The Dock Street bath house August 28th, 1 pound of special

scarlet was put in at Main Street on the ebb.

August 31st one pound of uranine put in at Fulton Street on the

flool and the bath house found polluted.

Noble Street, August 31st, 2 pounds of uranine were put in at

Huron Strcet without result.

September 2nd, 2 pounds of uranine were put in at Huron Street

without result.

1486 September 11th, 2 pounds of red and one pound of yel-

low dye were put in at Greenpoint sewer outlet without re-

sult.

Q. Mr. Allen, won’t you describe what you mean by using this

dye and subsequently your expression “found polluted”. Did you

trace the sewage from the sewer outfall into the bath house, into

the bathing establishments?

A. The operation was usually this: the observer took a certain

quantity, one pound, or two pounds of the dye, and put it in the

water at the mouth of the sewer, usually mixed with water, that is,

in a pail, and then — it in.

Q. Right at the outfall?

A. Right at the outlet of the sewer. In one or two cases they

put it down a water closet or through the manholes, and could see

it come out. Then they would go to the bath house and go in and

look at the bathing you know and go up on the roof where they

could watch it, or on the upper gallery where they could watch

and not say anything about their object and wait until they see

whether it comes inside or not.

Q. See what comes in?

A. See the uranine or the dye appear in the water that the men

were bathing in. If it did appear the assumption was that the

sewage also would find its way into the bath house.

Q. And where you saw no results, what does that mean?

A. That means that that experiment failed to give any evidence

of pollution in the bath house.

In other words you did not trace it to the bath house?

A. in those cases, no.

Q. It went in other directions?

A. Yes, usually went outside the bath house, toward the channel

of the river. I think in semething over half the bath houses,

we found it.

Q. Found what?

A. That they were found polluted.

a ao 7 —s a

956 THE PEOPLF OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

Q. I wish you would make that clearer what you mean by found

it polluted?

A. In over half the bath houses evidence of pollution

1487 was shown by these experiments, is that clear?

Q. No, it is not, Mr. Allen. Did you by these experiments

trace sewage from the outfall into the bath house that it entered?

A. We traced the water, the colored water which of course was

mixed with the sewage, coming directly from the sewer outfall inte

the bath house.

Q. Could the colored water have entered without sewage accom-

paniment?

A. I do not see how it could.

Q. Is it that what you mean?

A. Yes.

Q. What investigations did you make relative to dumping cellar

dirt in our harbor waters?

A. I went down to the point where they dumped the cellar dirt,

on the harbor inspections, to see how it was conducted, and whether

much material floated off on the surface. I found that there was

very little that did float on the surface, except sticks—some sticks

of wood, and that was so far outside the Narrows, there was no poe

sibility of its coming up into the Upper Bay.

Q. Does that cover the entire investigations that you made?

A. Formerly they have mixed more or less garbage with the cel-

lar dirt, and we wanted to observe it to see whether thai was mixed

with the cellar dirt and whether that floated off on the surface.

They did not seem to include any garbage with the cellar dirt, or

it was of an insignificant amount. What was left floating was

sticks of wood, and tin cans, nothing of a polluting material.

Q. Did you make any report on drift wood in the harbor?

A. Yes. Looked up the sources of the drift wood and there was

a good deal of that floating from time to time in the different

streams, and it was difficult to trace to its origin, but apparently a

good deal comes from the building operations along the water

front, from the dry docks, where they repair the vessels, and more

or less comes from the refuse dumped in loading the scows. More

or less of that falls overboard, and is carried up and down

1488 the stream by the tide.

Q. What investigations, if any, did you make, concerning

the pollution of New York Harbor from the crews and passengers of

vessels using the harbor waters for navigation?

A. I made inquiry as to the number of vessels the steamship lines

had and the ferries. ‘The number of passengers and crew carried

by boats of different classes, the crews as well and the time that they

were likely to remain on the water and made an estimate of the num-

ber of people whose adjecta went directly into the harbor, Of course

it was very difficult to get a close figure, but it was believed to be

sufficiently close to give a fair idea.

2 ome you make any report of your line of investigation on that

A. Yes, I made a report on that.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY BT AL. 957

. When did you make a report?

This fall. ae

give it more accu ?

"No, f have not it here. 4

I hand you a memorandum to see if it will refresh your recol-

lection any’

A. oe een report?

report

Q

A.

Q Can

A

e

A. To Dr. George A. Soper, the President of the Metropolitan

Sewerage Commission of New York on the pollution of New York

Harbor by the crews and passengers of vessels. Shall I read that?

Q. Yes; state what you reported as the results of your lines of

we ye]

A. classification of vessels is based on that of the United

States Stearnboat Inspecticn Service.

Mr. McCarter: We object to this as not based on information de-

rived by the witness, it is hearsay and also irrelevant and incom-

petent.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Q. Before making the report, Mr. Allen, will you state how

1489 you collected your ?

A. I saw some of the customs officials with regard to the

he, me ears Se oe ¢ wees to o number of the

steamship companies to get some data from the—got a good dea! of

ens eee vessels and the crews from the United

States Boiler Inspection service, Marine Boiler I ion.

Q. Is that part of their official duty to collect this data?

A. Yes, they keep track of all the classes of shipping that enter the

Q. And was it those special matters that you sought these facts in

relation to

A. Yes. I think those points will be made clearer perhaps in

reading this. _

Mr. McCarter: We renew our objection.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

The Witness (continuing): The vessels inspected by them at this

port include, besides all local steam vessels, all AS carryi

ee SO, Stat Cnaeee SRS 6 Shee eae

certain gasolene boats, such as those in oystering. in-

spected in 1910 included—

225 vessels entering and clearing the port for foreign

trade—

450 vessels entering and clearing the port for domestic

1,031 vessels that remain in or about New York Harbor

Total.. 1,712

955 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

To these there should be added all foreign freight vessels, thos

carrying passengers that are inspected elsewhere, all sailing vessels

and gasolene launches.

The total passengers received and delivered by domestic steamers, in

cluding ferries, excursion boats, etc, during 1910 was,

according to the U. 8. Steamboat Inspection Service. . 167,415,471

The number of immigrants was..........-.---+++> 921,094

and the number of emigrants was...........---+++- 320,457

Abow. 1,100 trans-Atlantic and 800 miscellaneous passenger

1490 steamers arrived at the port during the year.

1. Foreign Ocean Passenger Steamers —-Assuming each immigrant

is in the harbor 24 hours and each emigrant 1 hour, that an av

crew per vessel Se ees dat Gat amo in gen 6 age 0 aaa

we have a total of —13,000.

2. Foreign Ocean Freight Steamers—_Deducting the foreign pat

from the total foreign steamers, there arrived in the port about

3.384 foreign ocean freight steamers in 1910. Allowing, as an aver-

age, 30 men in the crew and a retention of 8 days in for each

vessel, the average number of crew in New Y each day

3

Inland Passenger Steamers—Information of number of boat,

4

F

2

z

mn

;

Z

i

j

a

i

i

i iH

bei

eit

!

|

t

t

i

i

it

(

38

i

i

2

i

os * aut eee

Sa ofp sf YF

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 959

9. Inland Pleasure Boats and Miscellaneous—There are 185 in-

spected. Assuming 400 boats carrying 3 men, the total is 1,200.

10. Seagoing Ba 217 ‘nam rm | With a crew of 10 men and

15% of the time in harbor, the total is 325.

11. Passenger barges—There are 12 i . Assuming, in

summer, an a crew of 8, the total men in harbor equals 100.

12. Ferries—T are 124 inspected, 10 of these bei “mu-

nicipal”. Those not belonging to the city do not, as a rule, have

wilets. Assuming 20 boats with an average crew of 15 men, the

total is 300.

13. Passengers on Excursion and Ferry Boats—

Rncenasedeseeedsetéesedoeseee 167 415,471

Assume half of these carried in summer............. 83,707,735

Average — A. ere 930,080

Deduct for t carried on ferries (677,400, in 1908—

ep Gi Man vocvesstoeseoesceseooors 730,080

Passengers per day excluding ferries................ 200,000

Assuming average time on water 1!2 hours and that 25% make

use of toilet, the total may be taken as 3,000.

The total population delivering excreta directly to the harbor

during the summer day ma be taken as 27500,

If we assume the insoluble solids given off by 10,000 persons as

556 lbs. (C. M. Tidy), the amount delivered to the harbor day

is 15,290 lbs. or 7.6 tons; and the total solids, estimated at Ibs.,

is 17,188 Ibs. or 8.6 tons.

1492 At 4 P. M. adjourned to January 5th, 1912 at 10:30 A. M.

1493 Supreme Court of the United States, October Term, 1911.

Tae Peorie or THE State or New York, Complainants,

State or New Jexsey and Passaic Vatitey Sewerace

Com MissionerRs, Defendants.

Ciry Hawt, New Yorx Crry,

January 5th, 1912—10:30 A. M.

Before James D. Maher, Esq., Commissioner.

Appearances :

Dr. William J. O'Sullivan, Special Counsel for the Peopie of the

State of New York.

Adrian Riker, Esq., of Counsel for the Passaic Valley Sewerage

Commission.

It, Esq., of Counsel for the Passaic Valley Sewerage

ission.

Robert H. McCarter, Esq., Speciel Counsel for the State of New

fb dR sit STH

! ty H 47 ae iv re IN

; PER Le 3] ah & if! af L

1 Fea +4 HU ee Salen shale

e viii i at i! Hie HES 113 rF

iil 4 Abt ARO ink

EE Mae aa igh ed | HER

btiilg: jt be eis THE 1

HER a earl a

Tinie Ea Ba

4 np eee din il ii :

wu™ Se" =” *

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET al.

material is digested and pases off in selution or in the

ated iecause in dredging operations, usually carned on

depth for navigation, 1 is Ret Customary ww

gurl Letween material formed by recent deposits and that cunstitut-

ing the original bed of the Lay or stream.

following facts, bearing on this question will give, however,

at idea of the extent to which sedimentation takes place.

Dredging Uperations by U. 8. Government.

( Figures for Fiscal Year Ending June 30.)

Mr. Kiker: | will imterpose an objection that the operations of

the | nited States Governinent are imomatema! and irrelevant.

The Cotummsmioner Note the objection.

Q What year’

A. The years 1907 and 1911. (Continuing)

To June 30, 1910 there were dreiged for this channel 52.158.192 cu yds

@ 6 cost of $4,621,135.87 (including the cost cf 4 dredges).

61-8

for interrupting you one moment

reading”

is is report made by me to the Metropolites

a

THE PROFLE OF TRE STATE OF KEW YORK VB.

you are

This

It has come to my attention

1496 Mr. Riker: Pardon me

The Witness:

942

What is it that

by Mr. Riker:

aE:

TEE iH

i nig: w

4 i: é 23

+. He rt

hh PEP i ais

i RH GSH

Hau a

63 x “3s

Fi it fH a

rool ve evel Bl ah]

ya

t a ‘il .

15 it j ria i

33 i! eit +

i * sant i,

ae

ewan

‘atte Hadi

ti ules Hae

Ss

is :

Q

faa o pli

at

a |

He

a

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.

Pune

rH

23

iow

432,459

1908

351,704

The Department of Docks and Ferries las dredged the fol

gee “wy

1907

386,145

Le

~ — lo

=.

skjiivse

jabs. nti

8,993 cu. yde.

7670“ “

. 11,767 “

. Aso *“

concerning Deposits in N. Y. Lower Bay, K. A.

2, 1911.

let for 13,225.

let for 4,200.

average amount for the first three years is

also Memo.

The

Newtown

Wallabout

/11.

**Letter of Nov

***Contract

s

2 bt 282282 as 28

964 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

The price paid for this dredging is naturally high owing to the

congesied traffic in these canals, varying from 30 to 60 cents per

cu. yd. At 40 cents per cu. yd., the annual cost in the recent past

is estimated at $9,400. The expenditure will probably be larger for

the current year.

Very little dredging is done by the Bureau along the water front

except near the De Graw St. outlet where so much original material

has been removed that it is no guide to the sludge deposited.

Mr. A. L. Moulton, General Manager of the New York Dock Co.

says:

Reaween Catherine Ferry and Red Hook Section * * * there

are 16 sewers discharging their contents into water which has very

little movement * * * finally settling to the bottom—filling in

with alarming rapidity the berths at which large steamers are moored

and which we have constantly to dredge to keep sufficient depth of

water for all practical purposes on this account.”

In a report made to the New York Dock Co. by C. C. Hopkins,

Consulting Engineer, it is estimated that from Jan. 1 1905 until

the winter of 1910, dredging at the rate of 120,000 cu. yds. per an-

num at a cost of about 17 cepts per cu. yd. had been necessary in

the slips of this Company, probably half of the material removed

being deposited from sewage.

1499 It is not possible wo obtain a reliable figure for the dredg-

ing that is actually required on account of sewage deposits,

first, because no distinction is made as to the character of mud de

posits removed, and, secondly, because this is only done occasion

ally, at intervals of perhaps several years, when required, and then

often covering different areas; but, aside from the actual expense

of dredging, the inconvenience to shipping in carrying on thes

operations in such congested streams as the Gowanus Canal, Walle

bout channel. Newtown Creek, Harlem and Passaic Rivers, and the

Kill von Kull, is very considerable and indirectly results in a finan-

cial loss.

The following two estimates based upon theoretical considerations,

probably furnish closer limiting values than could be arrived #

with certainty from deductions drawn from dredging operations

Estimated Cost of Dredging Deposits from New York Harbor.

Nore.—These are based upon the populations and sewage flow

of the entire metropolitan district, as estimated for the year 1910,

and upon such assumption as to the amount of solids deposited from

each gallon or cubic foot of sewage and the percentage of moisture

in the dredged material as seem reasonable.

Population of metropolitan district in 1910... 34.2 6,383,000

Dry-weather flow of sewage in 1910.........-- . 796 mgd.

a aR =

Se ee ee ee

wTarvraaeutT.'

ear

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 965

Minimum Estimate.

Solids suspended in sewage.....................005. 125 ppm.

Solids deposited from sewage....................... 50 ppm.

Bi orale Go wlicew aban Waunk owen 85%

20.2

Then by diagram —— attached, the volume of sludge depos-

A203

Se au aead eer abcas bbe med ine so clas 1.7 cu. yds. per mg.

Total volume deposited per annum 796 x 1.7 x 365. .493,900 cu. yds.

Deposits per annum, per 1,000 population.......... 77 cu. yds.*

1500 Maximum Estimate.

If, with the above estimates of population and sewage, we assume

Solids suspended in sewage...................-.000- 200 ppm

I ss 2a aie ee Lao wane a 6,000 x 160 x 960,000 cu. yds.

PD i ee %

20.2

Then, by diagram the volume of sludge

A203

DE isatsiciesntcebivedecuniensiean 5.0 cu, yds. per mg,

Total volume deposited per annum 796 x 5 x 365. . 1,452,700 eu. yds,

Deposits per annum per 1,000 population............ 228 cu. yds.

Taking 160 cu. yds, deposited annually per 1,000 persons as a

reasonable figure and 6 millions as the population connected with

the sewers, the—

Annual volume of sewage deposits in

the harbor ..... baked t4ab ees 6,000 x 160 x 960,000 eu. yds,

If, to this, we add an equal volume as due to detritus added from

street washings and we have a—

Total volume of deposits in harbor per year.... 1,920,000 cu. yds.

The cost of removing these, if estimated at 20 cents per cu. yd.

would be $384,000 per annum, which, capitalized at 415%, represents

asum of $8,533,333.

If to this we add the cost of the Gowanus Flushing Tunnel,

$980,310.76 (plus or minus a sum my sayy on further test of the

pumping plant) as made necessary by the pollution of Gowanus

Canal, we have a gross capital sum amounting to $9,514,144.

ee

*Mr. C. C. Hopkins estimates 367 cu. yds. 90% moisture per

1000 population, but this is based on assumptions of 347 ppm solids

2 suspension, 60% of which are deposited. These facts are derived

from experience in chemical precipitation in England and are not

“rictly applicable, nor do they allow for subsequent digestion, con-

ion and gasification of the deposits,

966 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

b. Losses Due to Impurities in the Water.

Where acids due to certain trade wastes predominate, the cor-

rosion of submerged metallic substances proceeds with increased

rapidity. Mr. J. H. McConnell, Agent, Harlem River Towboat

Line, states* that the acid which occurs in the harbor water eats

the solder off outboard condensers.

It would appear, too, that ordinary sewage is prejudicial

1501 to condensers. For instance, A. J. Hudson, Mechanical

Engineer, in reporting to Commander W. J. Sears, Superin-

tendent of Ferri-s, says, with reference to the Staten Island Ferry

Boats, that within a period of less than 12 months after delivery

of the boats to the Department “it was found necessary to remove

and renew the condenser tubes of each of the boats in their entirety”

at a cost of not less than $17,000 for material alone to which several

thousand dollars should be added for the cost of labor. The harbor

water which leaked through the rubes and so found its way to the

boilers subjected the latter to severe damage as well, although the

extent of this damage to the boiler is difficult to separate from that

due to the fresh water from Staten Island which was itself found to

be deleterious but in Mr. Hudson's opinion it is believed to be

greater than the damage to condensers given above. At presents

more resistent metal is used for the tubes so that it seems possi

that they may last two years or more before renewal,

At the Navy Yard trouble by the pitting and “dezincification” of

condenser tubes has been experienced but although it is believed

_ that this may be accelerated by ammonia, or possibly acids, contained

in the sewage, the chief cause is attributed to “galvanic or electro

chemical action” induced by the salt water.*

The Standard Oil Co.** have not noted any corrosion of con

denser tubes or other metal work on their boats that could be laid

to the pollution of the harbor, but Mr. W. C. Besler, Vice President

and General Manager of the Central R. R. of New Jersey writes**

that “there is more or less corrosion of condenser tubes

1502 other metal work on our boats, partly caused, no doubt, by

the pollution of New York harbor.”

Although the damage done to condensers is more keenly felt than

that experienced in other ways, the corrosion of metals is generally

increased when brought into contact with acid wastes.

Mr. Wm. G. Coxe, President of the Harlem and Hollingsworth

: tion of Wilmington, Del., writes that they have found it

able to use iron rivets on car floats and tug boats that are to ™

main in the vicinity of the sewer outlets in New York harbor, #

= riveta have been found to corrode rapidly under these

ons. *

*Letter of September 18, 1911.

* Latter of = . a ae agg Be. sea U. 8. N., Nov. 18, ”

«“ © OQ. L. Halenbeck, Li t., Nov. 20, 1911.

*** Letter of November 21, it piensa

a = he <

See FtRe FE WESRSEP CSSBQ Se senesnereee ss

11.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 967

At the Williamsburg Power Station of the Transit Development

Co. of Brooklyn, located on the Wallabout Channel at the foot of

Rush Street, the condenser tubes, pumps and piping are corroded

by the water to such an extent, according to Mr. C. E. Rochl, Elee-

trical Engineer of the Company, that the cost of maintenance is in-

creased by probably from $50,000 to $60,000 a year.

Besides corrosion, trouble is caused at this station by deposits

which collect on the tubes of condensers, clogging them and inter-

fering with their proper use. The water of the Wallabout is, at the

above power station, so foul that the screens in the intake tunnel

leading to the condensers have to be regularly raised and cleaned at

intervals of from 4 io 8 hours. In spite of this screening, the con-

denser tubes have to be cleaned about once a week. If practicable,

this would be done oftener, although there are from 5,000 to 8,000

tubs in each of the 8 condensers.

At the Eastern Power Station (at ‘ne foot of Division St.) and

the Central Power Station (Gowanus Canal near 2nd St.) the con-

ditions are said to be much the same, but the results are not felt so

seriously, as jet condensers are employed instead of surface con-

densers at these plants.

The Chief Engineer, Marine Department, N. Y. C. & TI. R. &R. R.

Co., believes that while no serious trouble has been expe-

1503 rienced from this source with the boats of his Company in

general, there has been some difficulty through corrosion of

condenser tubes, pipes and pump fittings in vessels using the water

of Newton Creek.*

The Wheeler Condenser & Engineering Co., who are among the

largest manufacturers of surface condensers, are of the opinion that

“The presence of sewage in the water causes a very rapid deteriora-

tion of the brass tubes used in condensers.” They mention one

power plant in New York where the cost for renewals amounts to

from $50,000 to $70,000 annually. Realizing the in jury caused in

this we’ large sums have been spent by numerous concerns in an

ef. 0 find some more resistant metal as a substitute for brass,

so far, without success.

Aside from the deterioration of metals sewage pollution has becn

d, under certain circumstances, to injure cement mortar and

concrete to a serious extent. This is usually supposed to be due to

the withdrawal of the oxygen by bacteria from sulphates contained

in the sewage, leaving sulphides to form sulphuric acid by combin-

ing with the water. The sulphuric acid is then free to act upon and

disintegrate the cement. The rapid deterioration of the Los Angeles

outfall sewer is a well known case in point.

No such deterioration has been observed by the Department of

s and Ferries on the large amount of sea wall built by them.

Such difficulty as has occurred in the past is attributed to an im-

Proper mixture or to exposure to the open water during construc-

With the dense surfaces secured by moulding massive blocks

- *According to the N. Y., N. H. & H.R. R. Co. this action

increase from year to year in N, Y, harbor. =

968 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

of 25 to 80 tons each on land and placing them with derricks after

setting for about a month in air, no further trouble has been ex-

perienced. Concrete work in the polluted waters of Gowanus

1504 Canal and Newtown Creek has been laid so recently, however,

that opportunity for final deductions has not been afforded.

At the Navy Yard there has been serious deterioration of con-

crete in quay walls and dry docks. Mr. F. R. Harris writes: “We

do not know that such deterioration has ever been proved to result

from polluted water.” In constructing their sea walls in recent years

it has been inundated by the tides, in some Cases, while fresh,

“leaching out some of the concrete and permeating the mass with

salt water.” Between successive layers, therefore, cleavage planes

would form “in which, in spite of cleaning off, there would be a

sediment of salt. It is probable that oil and greasy substance from

sewer pollution helped to define this cleavage plane by settlement

on top of the layer of concrete placed, although this would not ap-

pear so evident, as the surfaces, of course, were carefully washed

off and cleaned before placing concrete on top of them.”

Inquiry of the Central R. R. of New Jersey and of Mr. Fort,

Chief Engineer, Bureau of Sewers, Brooklyn, and of the Standard

Oil Co., fail to bring out evidence that even in the Gowanus Canal

- Newtown Creck has concrete been found to be injured by the pol-

ution.

It is not possible to estimate the gross loss due to the pollution of

the waters of the harbor, but from the few opinions and examples

given, it may safely be assumed to amount to several hundred

thousand dollars a year.

c. Losses due to Gases Liberated from the Polluted Water and

Deposits.

Losses due to liberated gases are incurred by deterioration through

chemical action, by deleterious influence on the health of persons in

the neighborhood and by depreciation in the value of real estate.

Such losses are very difficult to estimate in dollars and cent,

1505 but may be very great. It is well known that white lead

int used on vessels is rapidly discolored by the H.S lib

erated by sewage and sewage sludge during the process of putrefae-

tion. This action is particularly energetic in such waters as those

of Gowanus Canal, the Wallabout Canal and Newton Creek. It oe

- to a less extent in the sewage polluted slips and the Harlem

er.

Losses of this kind have not been observed by the Standard Oil

Co. ¥X or by the Department of Docks and Ferries ' but have been

noticed by the Central R. R. of New Jersey, especially on fresh

— steel car floats lying in the vicinity of Pier 10, N

ver, on which, after a few days, a “black, slimy substance” is in

evidence.

¥XLetter of O. L.| Halenbeck, Lighterage Dept., Nov. 20, 1911.

'Letter of C. W. Staniford, Chief Engineer, November 20, 1911.

wrT@qa tt ¥ oer FF

—

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 969

Mr. H. J. Horn, Ass’t to Pres’t N. Y. N. H. & H. R. R. Co., writes*®

that “there is considerable deterioration in the paint which is applied

to the underbodies of vessels, and as soon as the metal surface is

unprotected by paint it begins to corrode and pitts very rapidly.

We believe the above conditions are due to the increasing pollution

of the waters of New York harbor.”

Mr. John J. Amory, President of the Gas Engine & Power Co.

and Charles L. Seabury Co. of Morris Heights, has not observed

material damage done to vessels by the polluted water of the har-

borm except by the discoloration of paint. Considerable corrosion

occurs as well, but this “is not of sufficient amount, in our opinion,

to be worthy of any great consideration, at least under present con-

ditions”. The damage done in these ways he has not found to be

“more noticeable in the Harlem than it is in the Hudson or East

Rivers.

It is commonly thought that so long as the waters are not already

saturated with them, gases developed on the bottom with their

1506 corresponding odors will be abosrbed. This is not so, as is evi-

dent from odors that exist at outfalls, such as at Deer Island

in Boston harbor, where there is a large per cent. saturation of dis-

solved oxygen. Large bubbles such as occur in Gowanus Canal and

many other localities rise quickly te the surface without giving time

for alsorption, which is the case of the gradual evolution of

in minute volumes will still be given off in part at the surface with

a freedom depending on the relative pressures of the specific gas in

the water and in the atmosphere. The evolution of such gases as

sulphuretted hydrogen is therefore undesirable whether the overly-

ing water is saturated or not.

The odors accompanying such gases, if not directly injurious to

health, are at least offensive and objectionable. The offensive con-

ditions due to this cause along the Gowanus Canal and Newtown

Creek are acknowledged by all.

The New York Dock Canpeng complains of odors of this kind

due to the discharge of sewage mixed with the water pumped from

Gowanus Canal at and for a quarter of a mile in either direction

from the foot of DeGraw Street, Brooklyn.*

Similar nuisances exist in many localities, such as the vicinity of

slaughter houses, where there is gross pollution of the water or of

the bottom.

In connection with the use of polluted water for condensers, Mr.

Roehl of the Transit Development Co. states: “A rather offensive

odor is at all times noticed from the harbor water when the same is

circulated or the temperature of the same is raised by passing through

the condensers.”**

Nore.—Referring to the effect of gases given off by harbor de-

posits, I was informed hy Lieut. E. H. Tillman, U. 8. N. some oo

ago, that vessels painted white would be badly discolored by lying

XLetter of November 25, 1911.

*Letter of September 22d, 1911.

**Letter of September 28th, 1911.

970 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VB.

1507 in the basin at Baltimore for a single day. The same effect

is seen in steamboats plying in the Passaic River, which ap

pears to have been singed in a fire.

Mr. Oscar F. Lackey, Harbor Engineer of Baltimore, writes ( No-

vember 22d, 1911) that, so far from injuring concrete in Baltimore

harbor, the pollution appears to afford a certain protection by the

thick coating which forms on the surface.

To this may be added the protection to piles and other timber

work submerged in salt water from the teredo afforded by sew

age pollution to which this sea worm is peculiarly sensitive. In

fact it was proposed by an Engineer of the Baltimore & Ohio R. R.

that a certain amount of sewage be discharged continuously inte

Baltimore harbor to provide immunity from this pest, which in the

present condition of the harbor is not found there.

d. Loss Due to Injury to Fisheries.

It is well known that certain fisheries, especially the shad fisheries,

have decreased rapidly in New York harbor during the past 15

years. It is true that the catch of shad was much larger the pat

season than for several years but this is explained by the fact that

the Hudson had been previously stocked with large numbers of

young fry. It is noted, too, that the decline in the shad catch is not

confined to New York harbor, as shown by the following figures:

Pounds of Shad Caught in the United States.*

aD cs veevinn nective 18,075,000

ee ia evade veswens 35,737,000

EME vocdcuabachsénsicroseretors ve 49.787,000

(ast ng Sh ER RRR aM 27 641,000

Interviews have been had with Mr. R. A. Widenmann, Superin-

tendent of Marine Fisheries, and Mr. Wyeth, Engineer of the New

York State Conservation Commission, who have given information

concerning the condition of the fish and shell fis industries about

New York and on November 17th a trip of inspection of the waters

around State Island with reference to pollution of shell fish

1508 was made with Mr. Widenmann, representatives of the New

York and New Jersey State Boards of Health, and others

But I have not been able to secure definite figures of the extent o

value of the catch for successive years.

The following figures, however, give an idea of the importance of

the fisheries to the states of New York and New Jersey* :

*U. S. Census.

Amount. Value. Amount. Value.

Clams—hard ......... 101,000 bu. $223,000 273,000 bu. $318,000

— on 66,000 bu. 54,000 20,000 bu. 11,000

total (including

GD cccces 188,000 bu. 292,000 306,000 bu. 336,000

a 8.173.000 Ibs. 8,200 287,000 los. 1,400

Oysters—market ..... 1,849,000 ba. 2,173,000 920,000 bu. $84,000

a 614,000 bu. 381,000 1,667,000 bu. 485,000

_—_——— 2.463,000 bu. 2,553,000 2,586,000 bu. 1,349,000

Total shell fish...............- $2,853,200 $1,706,400

Geb cocccccocsercecs 260,000 Vos. S27 000 S004 000s 8220000

Total :

ee 76,485,000 Ibe, = 84.504.,000 74827000 Ibe $3,000,000

Men employed......... \) rr rer re ) errr re

Wages and salaries

errr rrr ccceeee 1,177,000 oescoee 744,000

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 971

Amount and Value of Catch for the Year 1908.

The value of the New York fisheries, which are chiefly carried on

in the vicinity of New York harbor, constitute 9% of the total for

the United States, and of the New York fisheries oysters represent

35% of the total in value.

The value of the oyster catch in New Jersey is 45% of that of all

fisheries.

1509 In both states the catch of oysters has decreased sornewhat

Cutag Oe pnt Sw yom. About New York the larger oyster

desirous of protecting their trade by abandoning

Bver, oo Newark Bay A Sor Keil ond tho pe oariee

, Upper Bay, y, Arthur Ki rt itan

fey Ketnetn Pook, Acuboy ond Lemon esesk, dithough paste of Gene

:

F

F?

i

j

roe

i |

HE

rs

il

z3f

tet

HE

ue

3 -

i

Ht

i

972 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF XEW YORK V8.

Conclusions.

From the information given above, which has been collected from

a variety of sources somewhat at random, we may draw the following

conclusions :

1. The pollution of the waters of New York harbor results in an

annual expense for dredging probably amounting to about $200,000,

or, if we include the —— river, Rewesk: bay and Kill von Kull,

(34.2)

to about $350,000 (A214)

2. The impurities contained in the water cause in some cases

rapid deterioration of condenser tubes and other metal sur-

1510 face with which they come in contact and necessitate frequent

cleaning of condenser tubes. re-ulting in a total loss of several

hundred thousand dollars a vear.

%. The loss due to discoloration of paint on vesels and to the

value of real estate on the water front cannot be estimated, but in

certain localities and in total, is very great.

4. The loss due to injury to the shad, oyster, and clam fisheries

io hergp, and, with the limit of pollution reached in the Hudson river

and amaica bay, the losses in the shad fisheries in the former and

in shell fisheries in the latter are liable to be greatly increased within

the next ten years.

(The just referred to is accompanied with a blue print,

marked File No, 202 Acc. No. A203 Volume of Sludge of a given

a eeenineoeepeaemmmaa

By Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. Mr. Allen, di make any studies or observations or investi-

gations relative to pollution of the harbor by garbage and refuse!

Q As the result of your investigations and observations did you

collect that material and submit it as a report to the President of the

a ie eS

A. I did, August 11th, 1911.

Q. Will you now read the report you made to the President of the

. i a a lith, 19117

. Yes, sir.

Recross-examination by Mr. McCarter:

Is the report that you are about to read from made up of data

by you from sources, in the same general way as the date

collected by you on the previous report you just read?

A. Not entirely. In this report there is more that is taken from

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 973

1511 Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q Mr. Allen, do you distinguish in this determination on garbage

and refuse matters, disc directly into the water, do you dis-

tinguish that from matters discharged through sewers’

A. Yes.

Q. This has nothing to do with matters discharged through sewers

then ”

A. No.

Mr. Riker: 1 object to it on the ground that it is irrelevant and

immaterial. Has nothing to do with the discharge a sewer.

The Commissioner: Note the objections of counsel for defendants.

Mr. O'Sullivan: The contention of the Complainants may 1

please the Commissioner, shall be and is and has been that these

waters are now so overburdened by pollution from various sources

tha: this mammoth nuisance which is threatened by the State of

New Jersey would be almost unbearable from the first moment of its

discharge, and for that purpose counsel for Complainants desires

opportunity to show every polluting source that contaminates those

harbor waters to the loss of property, and menace to health also.

Mr. Riker: While it appears from the statement of Counsel for

Complainants that the City of New York is in various ways polluting

no Sacer Sy Se Snag of garbage and refuse and sewage into

the waters of the harbor, and thereby convicting itself of creating a

condition which is injurious to itself, also objectionable, I still per-

sist that this litigation has nothing to do with garbage and refuse us

distingui from sewage.

Mr. O'Sullivan: Counsel for Complainants desires to answer the

comment of Counsel for defendants by stating that the pollution that

will be spread this record as affecting this harbor, not only

comes from the City of New York, but it comes from many cities in

the State of New Jersey, as well as in the State of New York, notabl

cities like Jersey City, Weehawken, Hoboken, Bayonne, wi

1512 the tremendous amount of trade waste that comes from these

= ' we nae nn Fd ay Ng ee So regard as to the

particular source of a given ution act waters are now

overburdened.

Mr. Riker: Now, Mr. Allen, I understood you to say that this

report contains in part material collated and compiled by you from

Mr. Riker: I object to it on the ground that it is hearsay and in-

Commissioner: Note the objection of counsel for Defendants.

Mr. O'Sullivan: State the contents of the apent

The Witness: (Dated August 11th, sot beg to hand you here-

With this m concerning the Pollution of New York Har-

bor by Garbage and Refuse.

Garbage may find its way to the waters of the harbor:

THE PROPLE OF THE STATE OF XEW vORK v6.

974

a aa

NEENY 3

fut ptt teal

alle sh Hig

1: ii He Ha fuerte

eae i

Ht epi ithe Hint Ae i

“PtP Hall 2 eth PEE ifntnbenl

if

4

3

5

ict

i

513

e itt: fa al i a i

eu fa an eh A

1

a

2

!

F

g

E

E

| % eine i lnih 2}

+ bis adit? fail 3 a id j

BT ——E—— — i ———— LL SOT

er

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF KEW YORK VS.

976

Statement to be Appended to Keport on the Pollution of New York

Harbor by Garbage and Refuse, Dated August 11, 1911.

Material Collected by the I t of Street Cleaning in Man

hattan, the Bronx, and yn During the Year 1910.

Ashe Cute (rortage Teas.

Manhatten) 1 95915025 221,408.75 282,390.25 2,408,907 %

662,066.00 143,433.00 113,724.75 919,242.75

Tow). 2,612,244.25 364,921.75 346,064.00 3,373,240

166 2 Disposition of Material from Manhattan, the Brons ab!

Brooklyn During the Year 1910.

Cart home

and the Ber kin

Brome.

At Sem .....-- 11,893 00

Rikers Island ..... «© «sneer 1,774,267 .%

Borough [Development [cscse _spenee 805 385 ©

Barren Island (Garbage)... .. 732,673 .W 113,712.98

Private Dumps .......--- 7 90.255 00

Inland Dump= 215,131.00 133.0

ee 25,035 5 . ;

ee ee 704. 00

Datel. .ccccccccecesess . 2350901.7% 919,230 8

* Te Flastiag Bay end some iniend file No record kept

$. The Amount and Disposition of the Garbage and Refuse fro

Queens are pot

S §.

m3

:

i

:

f

F

5

§

?

THE STATE OF NEW JERARY ET AL.

this

of

wide

east aide

i

HEP ‘

o4o4o< aes

the State of New York’

978 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

hours after low tide—the character of the water improved greatly

and the sewage odor disappeared,

Between 11:50 A. M. and 2:30 P, M, several surface floats con-

sisting of blocks of wood, were set adrift at the outlet, Float No, 2

was carried down by the ebb along the shore, and at 12.03% P. M.

went ashore about 60 ft. north of Mt, St. Vincent dock.

12:15 P. M. A slight current upstream was noticed at the out-

let.

12.50 P. M. Thick scum and feces noted at bathing beach south

of outlet.

12.57 P. M. Float No. 4 was set out from outlet which went

ashore, about 40 ft. to the south, on an ebb current.

1:03 P. M. Slack water occurred near the shore at about this time,

or 1% hours, after low water.

1:07 P. M. Float No. 4 set adrift again at outlet.

1:12 P. M. 60 feet from shore and 10 feet upstream

from outlet.

ao SP “ & 10 feet down stream of S. W. corner of

bathing dock

Bae « « 10 feet down stream from bathing dock,

and 30 feet from shore.

136“ “ “« & 6 get out as before, drifted down stream.

— “« & & 8Y ft, down stream and 40 ft. from shore.

Many grease particles noted at this time.

a * « = opposite outlet and 160 ft. out.

aa « « 495 ft. north of outlet and 150 ft. off

shore.

a oo «“« « 4165 ft. north of outlet and 50 ft. off shore.

68 lengths of 48” pipe were noted on the shore for use in proposed

submerged outlets.

2. Uranine Experiments.

Uranine was dumped in the sewer manhole at Tibbets Brook

by Mr. C. A. Holden, about 7000 ft. above the outlets as follows:

1519

11:06.A.M..... cee 1.0 lb. UDOP. Mh. cvcsvcces 0.5 Ib.

| Sarre re = ie | Biya trtey 0.5 Ib.

BO necccccene Bes ee ncvadeqens 0.5 “

He © ln cvccwcose 0.5 “ see 5“

12:00 M. ....ceeees 0.5 “ SHO csescseces 0.5 “

1B P.M... ccceeee 0.5 “ ie cccewnquns 1.0“

ro 0.5 “ Miptercerer ec 1.0 “

Ce wcccevaven 0.8 “ OD cictecceve 1.0“

The results were observed by Messrs. Gregory, Morse and Barrey

and myself from rowboats near the outlet and toward the end by

Mr. Holden and you.

[parmesan yn soimn rin ee

THE STATE OF SEW JERSEY ET AL, 979

12:31 P.M. The color appeared at outlet, having taken 1 hour 26

minutes in its passage.

12:40" “ The field was as per sketch.

(Here Soak a diagram )

12:57" “ The field was like this

(Here followed a diagram )

1:07 P. M. The west end of the field swept southerly by the current,

1:21" “ The field entering bath house dock as per sketch,

(Sketch was here inserted)

2:15 P.M. Color diffused throughout interior of bathing dock—

very strong at south end.

2:30" “ Color field as per sketch.

; (Sketch was here inserted. )

ond 7 Color field off bot house dock 42 way to Ludlow.

4:00“ “ Followed color detached field about 40’ x 80’ in size

to within about 600 ft. of the Ludlow dock (about 1%

mile from outlet.)

Notes on Float Experiments at Bronx Valley Sewer Outlet Made by

R. B. Morse May 24, 1911.

Tide Ebb—Nearly Low.

Float #1.

Put in at 11:44.

Upstream to 11:48—Position at 11:48, 60’ from shore, 75’ north

of sewer.

Opposite outlet, 75’ out, at 11:51,

11:55—40’ from shore, 300’ south of outlet.

11:59—60’ from shore, 200’ south of outlet.

Swings out to 80’ or 90’ from shore and starts downstream stops

25’ from shore about 450’ south of outlet at 12:02, then starts slowly

south along the shore.

Enter. cove at bathing beach near Mt, St. Vincent Sta. at

1520 12:10 and gets into dead water.

Still in cover at 1:20.

Float #3.

Put in at 1:22.

Moves up stream and out.

At 1:33—170’ from shore and 100’ north of outlet.

Starts downstream.

150’ from shore and opposite outlet at 1:35.

At 1:44 starts to move upstream near shore, it being 50’ from

shore and 200’ below outlet.

Swings out at 1:55, 200’ from shore and 100’ south of outlet.

2:05—50’ from shore and 300’ south of outlet.

Starts upstream near shore.

At 2:20 float is opposite south end of swimming pool north of out-

let, and about 40’ from outer face.

IE PID Beep RE PH WO MN hy OL OAS OS EN FE IR igh:

980 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

At 2:25 float is opposite north end of pool—25’ from outer face,

At 2:35 float strands on short 100’ north of north end of pool.

(This report is accompanied by a map showing location of out

let of Bronx Valley Sewer, May, 1911, and showing the mark | L—

1136—2.)

Q. Mr. Allen, did — make a special line of investigation relative

to ~ de of cellar dirt at Scotland Light?

. I did,

Q. And from the facts that you observed and collected, did you

fashion a report that was submitted to the President of the Metro-

politan Sewerage Commission?

A. I did.

Q On what date?

A. On July 28th, 1911.

Q. Will you now proceed to state what hat report was?

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

& Mr. Allen, is this report a compilation of facts observed by

you

A. Yes.

Q. Does it contain statements made by others?

A. Not with reference to the dumping of cellar dirt excepting as

regards the inspection of boats as they passed through the Narrows.

There the statement was made by the Harbor Inspector as to the

routine of that inspection, but the inspection of the dumping of

the cellar dirt was made by myself.

1520% Q What is it that you designate as cellar dirt?

A. Cellar dirt is the material that is taken from excava-

tions, for new buildings. That sinks to the bottom. It is not dredg-

ings as a rule, but brick and mortar and excavated material.

Q. Where did you get the information as to the place from which

this cellar dirt came?

A. I do not know as I had any information in regard to the source

of it, except from the reports, the published reports of the Harbor

4 +

Is your report that you are about to read based at all on those

reports?

A. No, except as to the source of the material.

Mr. Riker: I object to the reading of the report into the record

upon the ground that it is not a memorandum to refresh this wit-

ness’ memory of facts observed by him. That it is admittedly in

at based upon hearsay, and that as opinion evidence, it has no

oundation of fact proved, upon which it can rest, and that the

witness has not qualified as an expert to testify on the facts.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of Counsel for Defend-

ants. °

fj

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 981

Redirect examination by Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. State the contents of that report?

A, (Dated July 28, 1911,) I ior to report as follows regarding

an inspection of the dumping of cellar dirt off Scotland Light Ves-

sel, made yesterday by courtesy of the Supervisor of the Harbor

on the tug “Cerberus,’

Each tow with its load is noted as it passes out at the Narrows by

one boat of the Supervisor of the Harbor and checked by a second

bout stationed at the dumping ground 4 mi, FE. 8. E. of Scotland

Light vessel. (The same applies to mud scows except that these

are dumped 2 mi. 8. E. by FE, of Seotland Light Vessel.)

The dumping of 10 scows (5 tows) was observed, although it

was so dark in the case of the last 4 that the contents could

1521 not be seen.

The scows contain from 4 to 6 pockets and on the arrival

at the proper location, the tug gives a signal consisting of 4 whistles

and a man on each barge open the gates at the bottom of the pockets,

allowing the load to discharge while under way.

The material consisted of earth and refuse from the tearing down

of buildings. No garbage was seen and both the Supervisor of the

Harbor, Capt. C. McR. Winslow, U. S. N. and Capt. Nelson of the

“Cerberus” claim that this is rigidly excluded.

After dumping the first three scows nothing was left floating but

small sticks, bits of lath, etc., seldom over 2 feet in length. There

were no large boards of timbers. These soon collected and formed a

narrow field on the water surface, such as is frequently seen in the

Upper Bay.

The next three loads were similar in character except that there

were a good many scraps of paper from about 4 inches to 12 inches

on a side and a few tin cans which remained on the surface,

As the tows got out on the ebb current, the dumping usually takes

place at the end of the ebb or beginning of the flood current, which

there appeared to set toward Sandy Hook.

By Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. Mr. Allen, did you make any observations and investigations

one 1 a eaes in the Lower New York Bay?

. I did.

Q. Did you collate the facts observed by you and fashion them

in a report, which you submitted to the President of the Metro-

politan Sewerage Commission?

A. The effects were not observed by me. It was information re-

ceived from others, and reported on August 7th, 1911.

Q. When you say “others” do you mean men in the employ of

the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission ?

A. No, mostly outside.

Q. Were they officials?

A. Yes.

1522 Q. In the Federal or State service?

A. Federal.

982 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

7 a7 yourself gather the figures of facts?

Then

-

: hen you arranged them in the form of a report?

" When did you submit that report, what date?

. August 7th, 1911.

" 1 ask the witness now to read the report that he made on that

Mr. Riker: The reading of the report into the record is objected

to on the ground that by the statement of the witness it appears to be

entirely hearsay, and that all the witness has done is to compile

hearsay evidence which is embraced in this report.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of Counsel for Defendants.

A. (Report dated August 7th, 1911.) I beg to submit the follow-

ing results of an interview with Mr. Balch August 5.

Memorandum Concerning Deposits in New York Lower Bay.

In dredging the Ambrose Channel a large quantity of an offen-

sive brown mud was removed. This covered area indicated on

the attached sketch, but the eastern and western limits were not

located. This varied from 1 to 6 feet in thickness and averaged

about 3 feet in 1905, where it is known from an examination of the

ind that no soft material existed in 1900-1. At this time mussels

and black fish (which feed on them) were plentiful here, while now

they are not found. The quantity of this material removed from the

Ambrose Channei (2,000 feet wide) has been about 114 million

cubic yards in 4 years.

On examination this material is seen to be composed of very fine

yellowish sand filled with black particles which, combined, have &

dark brown appearance.

The material was so offensive that men on the dredges were said

to have been nauseated and Mr. Balch —— # postpone-

1523 ment of the work in that vicinity until cold weather. The

odor was similar to that from sewage and was very strong. A

liar phenomenon was noticed at least once while working in

this material. The dredge was covered with a thin moist greyish

film. What this consisted of was not known, but Mr. Balch sug-

gested that it might have been some form of microscopic mold.

Mr. Balch also mentioned ineeeey that since 1898 deposits

10 feet in thickness had occurred off Red Hook and that considers

ble deposits had occurred between 72nd Street Brooklyn and the

The cost of dredging the Ambrose Channel has been, inde

4% interest about 6 cents per cubic yard. In Coney Is

Channel where the dredges are working at higher stages of the

tide only and can utilize the balance of the time on the Ambros

toe rei nearby, the cost is about 8 cents per cubic yard, but would

be much more if the time during low water were lost.

— — se ere

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 983

(This report is accompanied by a blue print showing the location

of deposits of Organic Matter.)

By Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Mr. Allen, did you make any investigations relative to the sew-

erage at Jamaica, Woodhaven and Richmond Hill?

A. I did, Nevember 16th, 1910.

Q. And did you submit a report based upon the investigations that

= mate of the sewerage of Jamaica, Woodhaven and Richmond

ill?

. 1 did.

To President of the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission?

I did.

On what date?

. November 16th, 1910.

I request this witness to read that report.

2>O>o>

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Mr. Allen, the investigation that you made and which you

say is embodied in this report, is it of original facts observed

1524 by you?

A. It was not so much an inspection as a study of the gen-

eral sewerage question of that district.

Q. And what were the facts which were studied by you in that

connection, where did you get them?

A. Chiefly from the Sewer Bureau of Queens.

Q. Does this report contain any original observations made by you

of facts upon which your report is based?

A. It does not contain observations at all that I know of. The

data used were furnished mostly by the Bureau of Sewers and by

maps.

Q. Then this report is the expression of your opinion on the the

facts furnished to you by someone else?

A. Yes.

Mr. Riker: I object to it in so far as it purports to be a statement of

facts that it is purely hearsay and in so far as it purports to be opin-

ion evidence it is based upon statements which are hearsay, and

therefore has no value as opinion evidence.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of Counsel for Defend-

ants.

Mr. McCarter: The same objection.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Were the facts that you collected from the Bureau of Sewers of

Queens made up of public records in the Department of Sewers of

Queens?

A. oo

Q. And were the maps that you used, were they furnished to you

984 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK V8.

by the borough of Queens, were they maps that were parts of the ree.

ords of the Bureau of Sewers of Queens’

A. They were. f

Q. I ask the witness to state the contents of that report.

Mr. Riker: The objection is renewed on the same grounds.

Mr. McCarter: The same objection.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of Counsel for Defendants.

A. (Report dated November 16th, 1910.) I beg to hand

1525 you herewith the results of a study of the conditions affecting

the design and development of the sewerage of Jamaica,

Woodhaven and Richmond Hill.

In general the conclusions arrived at are that it is desirable to use

the separate system so far as practicable, and that the sewerage from

this area may best be taken care of, until more permanent works are

available, by the present Jamacia disposal plant modified to secure

more efficient and economical results.

The Sewerage of Jamaica, Woodhaven, and Richmond Hill.

1. Existing Conditions.—That part of Queens comprised within

the old corporate limits of the Village of Jamaica is provided with

sewers built on thé separate system under a plan approved June 189%.

The minimum size is 8”.

Areas.

Acres.

Area of Queens Borough draining to Jamaica Bay......... 80,518

Area of dry land in Queens Borough draining to Jamaica

Bc ccccveccctcvesececceceseegunsecsessercscuces 3,328

Area of Jamaica draining to Jamaica Bay............--- 2,311

Area of Jamaica provided with sewerage ..........-+-- 1,900

Area of Woodhaven and Richmond Hill for which sewerage

plans are approved :

ES fn cece cugesnees sees ceeeeeres 893

“ — 40B (exclusive of 40 acres of park)...... 523

as dicvedudvvedacteetecerteerqueds 224

2. Probable Conditions in 1940.

Estimated Population and Sewage, 1940.

Population. eo x .

DN J. c cednuecerebbsedvetorrerrrcce

Woodhaven and Richmond Hill—

GE epcccccesareeses

se Sco cep eeeeees cn084

a as ebeecreveeeuas

*Rep. of R. Hering to Bd. of Est. Jan. 1908.

**Extended to Jamaica.

***Extended to Liberty Ave.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.

985

1526 ~—_ By this time with the effect of the improvements contem-

plated by the Long Island meioaes Compete one Ge ane

ete i Cecdenaemae in Jamaica

Bay, @ density of the above areas approximating 20 to 25

per acre may be expected, diminishing to the south to perhaps

= than 5 per acre, although this density will depend very much

8. Sewerage of Jamacia. The collecting system con to a 24”

trunk sewer running 6 ee ~~ Van

Wyck Ave. at elevation 15.51, a 2’-2” x 3’ 3” trunk sewer extends in

a southerly direction to the Jamaica disposal plant near the Old

conveyed some % mile further to Jamaica Bay. The precise grade

and capacity of this flume are not known.

The ient of the main sewer on Lincoln Ave. is so slight,—less

than 0.1 per 100,—that the estimated velocity when full is not much

over

plan with storm overflows at suitable points. This is a fundamental

matter that requires an early decision in formulating any general

= for the future.

i

!

i

Hy

:

:

4

:

F

2

of

ing tations and pump to the main sum. Such low level

would not, probably, on the combined plan, but the multi-

of pumping plants would not appear economical.

during times of overflow, volumes of crude sewage

1

HL

4

:

;

:

;

F

dt

af

i

af

1

i

f

pir

Ft

.s

986 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF XEW YORK VB.

terference between the two systems would be largely obviated by the

collection of the sanitary onan vo intesnapters placed Stew &

ae pee storm drains to cross over . And the increase

cost of the double system would not be so great as might be expected

as storm drains would not have to extend beyond points to which gut

ter flow could be utilized, the construction of a large part of

1528 the system could be deferred for an indefinite time, while the

main long lines of outfall would have to be built in case the

combined system were adopted as storm overflows.

Without passing hastily upon so important a question, it seems to

me that the advantage of the separate system for Jamaica overweight

those of the combined system.

4. Sewage Disposal for Jamaica. Acsenfiing to he sapest af

Hering of Jan. 1908, already referred to, the Jamaica disposal plant

cost about $108,870 in 1903, handles on an average 1.5 med., reach-

ing during wet periods 2.4 mgd. of sewage from a ion of

19,000 at a yearly cost of $16,000 or $30 per million lons, and has

pagamy SS ag. Of the cost of operation, $1,000 goes for chem-

ica

At this time Mr. Hering was of opinion that the money spent for

chemicals was wasted, that a considerable saving would be effected

the employment of a technical man familiar with sanitary work,

that as good results might be reached by a slight modification in the

plant, but that as soon as practicable the entire lant should be recon-

structed so as to provide septic tanks with eight hours’ storage, ink-

sewers laid at comparatively low elevations for the purpose of con-

veyi the sewage to one or more central ts for treatment, it will

probate be of no advantage to abandon existing plants in a

likely to be recom , :

In view of the fact that no plan conforming to the most desirable

i suggestions made in part by Mr. Hering 3

.1 _ appear worthy of consideration at this time.

st. Increase the lime and — during the summer months

so as to increase the percentage suspended solids and bacteria re

moved from about 67 to 80 or 90. This will cost for chemicals about

necessary to curtail the expense due to increased cost in the summe

when putrefaction is more active and offensive. During such peri

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 987

about one third of the total organic matter or two-thirds of the total

matter and bacteria may be removed.

. Remove a part of the baffles in sedimentation tanks so as to re-

duce the velocity and promote deposition. As operated at present,

The sewage, for instance, might be admitted th a central wall

cutting the present tanks in two when, by reducing the travel by 50%

the time of sedimentation and capacity would remain as at present.

4th. Provide a competent young man to supervise the operation of

the plant, make tests of the results obtained, ete.

5th. Before the capacity of the plant is reached operated under

these more favorable conditions increase its capacity by the addition

of more sedimentation tanks sufficient to last unti! the adopuon of

some more comprehensive scheme.

1530 5. The Sewerage of Woodhaven and Richmond Hill —

The sewerage of Woodhaven and Richmond Hill constitutes

but one general problem. Plans have been approved and contracts

in part advertised covering:

The sewer bureau has adopted the combined system for these

districts for the reasons stated in Art. 3 with reference to Jamaica.

To avoid the multiplication of treatment plants, it is planned to

ary the sewage to the Jamaica plant for this purpose ; and in order

to avoid the carriage of storm water by such an indirect line to its

natural outlet in Jamaica bay and to permit the dry-weather flow

to be treated, storm overflows are to be provided for District

in Scedeker Ave. at Jamaica Ave. in Yarmouth St. at Syosset

% and in Woodhaven Ave. at Ridgewood Ave. The dry weather

swage cut off at the last point is carried in a combi sewer to

Rockaway Road and Freedom Ave. where provision is made for

the drainage of 500 acres from the west and a storm overflow is

tided for District 40B. Continuing on Rockaway Road with a

—A” sewer to Leffert St.. the dry weather flow is diverted into a

¥ sewer which goes to the treatment plant by Rockaway Road,

Panama St. and Stanley Ave., leaving storm water to continue

ie sees Os ay eS SO

sewer.

The obvious reason for intercepting the dry-weather flow so far

above the treatment plant is to permit ite delivery without

431 pumping, leaving the storm water to be carried at the maxi-

mum grade obtainable to the outfall.

6. Provision for Woodhaven and Richmond Hill Sewage for

the Near Future.-—The area lying between Jamaica and the Borough

@ Brooklyn is expected to dev rapidly so that extensions to

the plans already under way are likely to be called for before long

i ne

A th

‘and is assumed

bv duplicating the pre

25.8

18.0

ity of 8.4 mad. to be pre

ape

dant

1920. This ma

year

sewer to

—w

had

rough sedimentation tanks about

Scheme a.

The extimated capacity of sanitary sewers from the area under

of 2 feet per minute and the

outfall flume to Jamaica bay

Eatimate of Cost.

7

10.3 med

to be built from Leffert St. ix 06

ves an additional

would ib

clecit

i al

THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF KEW YORK V8.

ate g? iil ise

-

the

ir

?

2H

De cpety of too re

|

2

i

:

E.

tg? th: Ml 33 .

:

3 a

ie

ai if

| ib iM wi |

:

ri.

lj

Li

|

i

a

aj

OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK v8.

“thy

we

es " :

i Ay

4 ~ 1 >= }

i Bibl

fh onal

Hae PE

ORFs <o<9 24<0

Lian Hl

fe

1

ale

rT

ee {CH <

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL.

eT i a

sHith 1 ait tHE ae HT

ee ! Hin aly 1 LTE fl

ese Ait tae i sii ap

testi aah BHA tie itt

Niet er ii ie b df : ae ine if

tif: rey | Bt i iF ah atl Ht ii

. @ ri

nal fil it i i i hie Usha fey i

on Mo Bete 2 ws 2 Bed

992 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

We passed Manhattan Beach at 4 P. M. and arrived at the Battery

at about 5:25 P. M.

By Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Did you make any observations or inspections of the pollution

of Jamaica Bay and the improvement basins therefor?

A. 1 made a report on November 22nd, 1910, on the probable

llution of the basins which are proposed for the Jamaica Bay

improvement. They are not built yet. They are planned.

Q. And was that report based on observations that you made

of the conditions there and this probable pollution?

A. Partly of conditions there and partly of conditions in similar

bdies of water, particularly Newtown Creek and Gowanus Canal.

Q. When did you make the report?

A. November 22nd, 1910.

Q. I ask the witness to read that report.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Mr. Allen, what are you assuming to be or about to be as the

basis of this report?

A. The Jamaica Bay Improvement Commission planned some

water from’ improvements in Jamaica Bay and those were finally

adopted by the City and the United States Government. That is

th bulkhead line and pierhead line was established by co-operation

between those two bodies. Appropriations have been made to be

gin the work, and the main outlets have been determined on the

north side of the Bay. These plans included running along the

shore certain canals, running up into the city for from half a mile

to two miles in length and it seemed that there might be objection-

able pollution of these canals after being constructed, and it

1538 was to form some conception of what the probable condition

would be that this investigation and report was made.

Q. And this report was upon a project which has not yet been

executed?

A. Yes.

Q. And the data upon which the report is based, outside of this

— of the construction of this work, where did you get the

A. It is largely a matter of opinion.

Q. Largely a matter of opinion based on what facts?

A. Based upon sufficient observations in other bodies of water

such as the Gowanus Canal, the Newtown Creek.

Q. Facts observed by you?

A. Yes.

Q. And known or not known by you to exist in the waters of

Jamaica Bay at that point?

A. They do not exist at the present time.

Q = that it is an opinion upon a hypothesis, is it?

. Yes.

Mr. Riker: I object, one more question.

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 993

Q. How far is this from the point of the proposed idscharge of the

Passaic Valley Sewer?

A. 1 should say from 9 or 10 to 15 miles.

Mr. Riker: I object to it on the ground that it is entirely irrele-

vant to the subject matter of this litigation. I object to the reading

of this report on the ground that a report unless it is authenticated

and offered and admitted as an exhibit cannot be lawfully read

into the record.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of Counsel for Defendants.

Mr. McCarter: The same objection.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

A. (Report dated November 22, 1910.) 1 beg to report as fol-

lows concerning the possible pollution of the basins as at

1539 present proposed by the Dept. of Docks and Ferries in con-

nection with the contemplated Jamaica Bay Improvement.

In general the conclusions reached are that fouling of these basins

is not likely to be extreme or to cause a septic condition of the water,

unless from local conditions which cannot at this time be foreseen.

That much filth will find its way to these waters is, however, certain,

and the most feasible way to ameliorate the situation would appear

to be by widening, shortening, and reducing the depth of the upper

part, of each basin.

Report of the Pollution of the Jamaica Bay Improvement Basins.

1. Typical Basin Assumed.—According to the plan of the Jamaica

Bay Improvement Commission, as modified by the Department of

Docks and Ferries, there are to be long basins 300 or more feet in

width running inland from the pierhead line at Sheepshead Bay,

Dead Horse Inlet, Island creek, Paerdegat Creek, Fresh creek, Spring

creek, Hawtree creek, Bergen creek, Cornell creek, Head of Bay, Nig-

ger Bar and Motts point. For the general purpose of discussion, a

typical basin having the mean dimensions of the six extending north

from Jamaica Bay beginning with that at Paerdegat creek in the

above list has been assumed. Such a typical basin would have the

following elements:

Tributary drainage area...................... 5,250 acres

Length of “i 2» SIE TEER eee og 25,000 ft.

b ee sekns enc s es 6,900 ft.

Width aad I ee 370 ft.

Depth of basin at mean low water............... 18 ft.

- «+ «8 a 22.5 ft.

Contents of basin at mean low water............ 46 m. cu. ft.

‘ 7 ae es ne eter ns _& Bedi

NAST Sit eae aaa 11.5

Based on the above data there result the following deductions

63—3

IEE DP 9S A NETL AM RE LURREON E PTLAITN SAVE C IT P MERIT ILE AOS POMP:

994 HE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VB.

1540 1. The tidal prism amounts to 25% of the entire contents

of the basin at M. L. W. In other words 50% of the low water

volume of the basin enters during the two flood tides each day.

2. If the harbor water acted as a piston, it would advance but one-

fifth the length of the basin, or 1,380 ft. from the mouth, at each

high tide and then recede.

3, The mean velocity due to the tide at the mouth of the basin

would be about 4.2 feet per minute—much too small to effect any

scouring action.

If the motion of the water were due to the tides only, there would

be no | pg of the stagnant water at the upper end of the basin

toward the bay. Any resultant motion in this irection will be due

to the inflow of land water. A rough estimate of this is as follows:

*Mean daily volume of rain falling on the area

draining to the basin throughout an ordinary

YOAT .cccccnccecsccccscsccessaesecseseeess 2,350,000 cu. ft.

Run-off assumed at 50% of rainfall daily......... 1,175,000 “ “

Run-off reaching head of basin by gutters and

drains, assumed as 8/10 of the whole.........-- 940,000 “ “

From this there follows:

1. The mean daily inflow of land water amounts to about 2% of

the low water contents of the basin.

9. If the land water acted as a piston, it would force the basin»

water about 140 ft. farther down stream each day at low tide.

3 It would take at this rate 49 days to replenish the entire basin —

with land water.

Nor would the flushing due to severe storms be a factor of very

great importance. If we assume a downpour of 2 inches in 6 hours,

the run-off would be but about 4,000,000 cu. ft. or less than 9% of

the L. W. contents of the basin.

2. General Considerations.—While there would be an in-

1541 flow of some 52% of new water to the t ical basin from the

tidal action and from run-off from rainfall, the greater part |

of the basin would be dependent on the diffusion of the new sup —

plies and on the absorption of oxygen from the —— to pre

serve it in good conditon. Diffusion up stream woul be retarded '

by the comparatively narrow width of the basin as compared with

its length, but by currents set up by the wind, by vessels and other |

encies, it is probable that there would be found some admixture |

of harbor water well up toward its upper end. aa

It is impossible to predict the actual degree of pollution. This

will depend on the number and kind of vessels using the basin,

the number of men employed on them, the street dirt brought in by

rains, the wastes admitted from factories and those (dead animals,

*) deliberately thrown into the water.

y an arbitrary assumption, but one that seems reasonable, as #

* Based on a mean Feed rainfall of 44.7”—Record covering 61

years prior to 1896—Public Water Supplies—Turneaure &

p. 45.

its

kT

BS & SF «a

SBE SEERSSERR sc

to

Ss

61

el

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY EY AL. 995

the well oxygenated water admitted and, to a certain extent diffused,

each day, we may secure a rough conception of the admissible pollu-

tion. 1 have assumed that 900,000 cu. ft, land water plus 25% of

23,000,000 cu. ft. harbor water equals 6,650,000 cu, ft. per day or

77 cu. ft. see. might be counted on for the disposal of sanitary sew-

age. If 25% should be considered too high or too low, the general

arguinent would remain the same.

t has been stated that from 25 to 30 dilutions will render Mil-

waukee’s sewage inoffensive. At that rate the typical basin might

dispose of 266,000 to 222,000 cu. ft. or from 2 to 1.7 Mgd. of sewage

per day, equivalent, at 125 | em per cap, to that from a population

of from 16 to 1342 thousand persons.

*Mr. Rudolph Hering mentions a diluiton of 3 cu. ft. sec.

1542 ag satisfactory for the sewage of 1,000 persons. At that rate

the basin would take the sewaye from a population of 25%

thousand.

Mr, F. P. Stearns** states that 5 cu. ft, sec, will dispose of the

sewage from 1,000 persons without offense. At that rate, 104% thou-

sand might drain to the basin.

These estimates of course presuppose proper dispersion of the im-

purities discharged into the basin.

3. Preventive measures desirable.-—It hardly seems probable that

with the diversion of domestic wastes from the land, with the inter-

ception of gross impurities by sand catchers in storm drains and

with ordinary efficient policing, the amount of the impurities reach-

ing the basin would approach in amount the least of the above figures,

equivalent to the sewerage of over 10,000 persons. Nevertheless it

is quite possible that the condition of some of the basins as planned

would become objectionably foul at points of maximum pollution

during periods of drovght.. As already mentioned, the extent of

such focal or temporary nuisances cannot be foretold, but it would

be well to minimize the degree of pollution as far as practicable.

The most obvious of these means would be:

a. Flushing the basin by pumping to or from its head,

b. Flushing the basin at low water by discharge through a lock.

c. Flushing the basin by intermittent discharge from a reservoir.

d. Promoting diffusion by adopting a different form of basin—

wider and shorter—similar to the Atlantic, Pacific and Erie Basins.

e. Promoting diffusion by a relative increase of the tidal prism

near the upper end.

ushing by pumping—would be effective. but costly. It

1543 is a method that could be easily adopted if the necessity de-

veloped, but could at least be referred for some years,

Flushing by the sudden release of the tital prism through a lock

need not be considered on account of the interference with naviga-

tion and the great cost.

Flushing from a storage reservoir may also be dismissed as the

construction of such a reservoir would be costly and would require

*Engineering Record, March 10, 1888.

**Rep. Mass. State Board of Health, 1890.

eae sng ~ TELA PROS gs EMBL ITLL CS I Hk a IER! PNT OR ES <BR

a

996 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK YS.

land that would otherwise be available for purposes of manufacture

or commerce.

The adoption of a wide, open basin would permit of a more gen-

eral movement of the water due to the influences the tides and wind,

but would not provide for any permanent current, especially in

places far from a direct line between storm water outlets nd the

entrance to the basin. It would involve a radical departure from

the plans already formulated, would be less economical of space and

robably less desirable in the solution of transportation problems.

t would also involve a longer carriage for storm water on flat terri-

tory. Bui without adopting any such extreme alteration in desi

it might still be possible to effect am improvement by shortening

and widening the basin.

Provision for a relative increase for the tidal prism may be had

without any radical change in the proposed plan except a diminu-

tion of the depth at the upper end. If, for instance, the depth at low

water were reduced to 12 feet, the volume would be increased

4.5==37142% instead of 25% with a depth of 15 ft. and the two

12

daily tides would bring in 75% instead of 50% of the low water

volume to aid in dilution. This would not be necessary at the lower

end, where there would be in any case a free admixture of harber

water, and as the larger vessels would presumably dock near

the bay, any reduction in depth would be inadmissible. But,

1544 if, say, the upper half of the basin were reduced in —< as

indicated, there would follow not only a much more effective

dilution of this part from the harbor water, but the progression of

land water toward the bay would be correspondingly increased and

the depth would be sufficient for light draught coasting vessels, tugs,

lighters, and scows.

4. Conclusions.—Without full knowledge of the necessities of

navigation and land transportation as well as of future conditions

as to pollution, I do not feel that final recommendations can be

made, but would suggest as follows:

1. That before commitment to any plan, the design of the basin

be reviewed to ascertain to what extent they may be shortened and

widened and their upper ends reduced in depth, having due regard to ‘

economy of construction, the ultimate demands of commerce and of

storm drainage.

2. That in any plan adopted, the possible future desirability of

flushing by pumping be borne in mind.

In the studies involved in preparing the above report, I have been

assisted by Mr. D. M. Belcher.

(The report is accompanied by a map showing “Jamaica Bay

Division Location of Disposal Plant, on Jo Co’s Marsh, and showing

mark I N-1061-III, dated Dee. 1, 1910.)

By Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. Mr, Allen, is Jamaica Bay a part of the waters of New York

Harbor? A. It is.

wa

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 997

Mr. Riker: Have you finished with that?

Mr. O’Sullivan: Yes, sir.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Mr. Allen, have you from your own observations and your

own knowledge observed the facts which would justify you in saying

that the discharge of sewage at Robbins Keef at a depth of 40 feet

would enter in any way or affect in any way Jamaica Bay?

1545 A. Not appreciably. .

Q. Will it at all from anything that you know?

A. I think it would to a very slight degree.

Q. In what way?

A. The water passing out of the Narrows would probably pass

down and go into Jamaica Bay on the return tide.

Q. Have you traced any such float, has any float observation or

other fact within your knowledge indicated such a conclusion?

A. No.

Mr. Riker: I renew my objection to this report on the ground

that it is irrelevant.

The Commissioner: Note the objection.

Redirect examination by Mr. O'Sullivan:

Q. Did you make any observations under the direction of the

Metropolitan Sewerage Commission on the sewerage of Jamacia Bay

Division, —— trip over the line of interceptors?

A. I did.

Q. And from the facts alleged, did vou submit a report to the

Metropolitan Sewerage Commission ?

A. I did.

Q. In the discharge of your duties?

A. I did submit a report.

Q. And on that one topic?

A. On the sewerage of Jamaica Bay, ves. There was only one,

an inspection.

Q. When was that?

A. January 25th, 1911,

Q. I ask the witness to state the contents of that report.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. What is this report based on so far as the data is concerned?

A. On a trip made over the line of the proposed interceptors near

the shore of Jamaica Bay.

Q. the report deal with the expected results of the inter-

ceptors?

A. It deals particularly with the practicability of constructing the

interceptors and the cost.

Q. Is it or is it not a report on the method on the part of

one of the municipal corporations of the Complainants to

femove its own pollution from Jamaica Bay?

ee Para Peat bre anal

cw

998 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VB.

A. Yes, it has to do with that subject.

Q. Has it been done?

A. No.

Mr. Riker: I object to the report going into the record on the

ground that it is a statement of opinion upon a hypothesis merely,

and upon no facts, and that it is immaterial and irrelevant to this

suit by reason first, of the location of the plant, the proposed loca-

tion of the plant, and second by reason of the subject matter of the

investigation, and I object to it further on the ground that the report

cannot be read into record until it has been properly authenticated

and offered and admitted as an exhibit.

Mr. McCarter: The same objection.

The Commissioner: Note the objection of Counsel for Defendants.

Jamaica Bay Division Memorandum of Inspection Trip Over Lines

of Interceptors.

Jan. 25, 1911.

Started with Mr, D. M. Belcher in automobile from Flatbush Ave.

Station and went through Flatbush, noting the state of development,

to Shellbank Creek Disposal Plant. At this plant there was no ap

iable odor, possibly due to an excess of lime and chlorine used.

e sewage is weak and effluent clear. The general condition of the

place was clean. Sludge is pum at intervals of several weeks, in

winter, to adjoining beds and when dry is used for filling. More or

less surface water is admitted by catch basins to the sewers. The se®-

age is received and the effluent passes to Shellbank Creek through

24” pipes.

About 11% med. are ordinarily pumped and this is not greatly

1547 increased in summer.

From this point the route lay by Kings Highway, Eat

New York and Old South Road and Rockaway Road to Far Rock-

away. At the several streams crossed by Rockaway Road, measure

ments were made of the width and depth, as follows:

h Water surface

Stream. Width. about low below bridge

tide. floor.

Hassock Creek ......----- 33’ , of 8’

WOVGTS 00... ccc cece ceeee 36’ 3’ Fy’

Hook Creek ......-.----- 50’ 11’ 9

Hook Creek Branch .......- 115’ 3’ vy

Mott Creek .......--++0+: 63’ 5’ y

This information, although approximate only, is valuable as de

termining the necessity and number of siphons that will be required

After lunch at Far Rockaway, Norton’s Creek was inspected and &

of 15% feet noted. A drawbridge about 110 feet long spans

the creek. The necessity of this is not apparent, as there can be 00

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 999

ovens of ipeing Sateen this and the railway bridge 200 or 300

ft. to the south.

The return trip was by way of Lawrence, Woodmere, Valley

Stream, Springland, Jamaica, Richmond Hill, Woodside, Eastern

Boulevard, Bedford Ave. and Williamsburg Bridge to Astor Square,

arriving about 3:40. The topography and development along the

route were especially noted.

Redirect examination by Mr. O’Sullivan:

Q. Did you make in the discharge of vour duties as Engineer for

the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission, did you make any studies of

-. prospective relative development of the area tributary to Jamaica

y?

A. I did.

Q. With a view to determining what facts?

A. Determining the capacity required for the disposal of the

swace from that district; the capacity of the sewers and of the

disposal plant and also the character of the disposal that would

be most suitable, That wae made on August 3rd, 1911.

1548 Q. Were these facts collected and your computations made

after you had acquired knowledge through observation of the

polluted condition of Jamaica Bay?

A. They were

Q. Did this report deal with the prospective added pollution that

an increase in the population through development would discharge

into that bay?

A. It did, but that was rather secondary. The principal object

of the report was to form a conception of the probable increase in

population with a view of the proposed collection and disposal of the

sewage. The whole subject, rather than the pollution of the waters.

It was more for the construction of the sewers and the disposal plants.

It wax largely a matter of forecast ax to population and diet iiution.

Q. And dealing with the possible capacity of the waters of Jamaica

Bay to stand the added pollution?

A. It had not directly very much connection with that, the report.

Q. What did the consider chiefly?

A. It dealt principally with the prospective development depend-

ing largely on the Long Island Railroad Improvement and the pro-

posed Jamaica Bay Im t, which would increase the density

of population, which of course would have a bearing on the pollution

of the bay, but the immediate object was the design of a system for

collecting and disposing of the sewage.

Q You made the report yourself?

. I did.

. The language of the report is your language?

Yes.

Q And the facts observed are the facts that vou fashioned in that

report?

. Yes.

“Q 1 ask the witness to give that report on the record.

o>

—

>

1000 THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK VS.

Recross-examination by Mr. Riker:

Q. Mr. Allen, the data on which this report is based and which

are stated in the report did you collect them personally?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. From what sources?

1549 A. I got opinions from various individuals, some in a pri-

vate capacity and some public officials as to the savhabte'ds de-

velopment of that territory and the population statistics are based

largely upon census returns. modified in tl in the future by the opinions

of those gentlemen.

Q. And were these opinions and data directed to some prospective

work in the work of sewage interception or disposal?

Q Se en ot Caw gues you mean?

es

A. Upon the facts that are purported to be embraced in this

. are the opinions of some gentlemen and some things obtained.

Q. From the censns reports?

A. Yes.

Q. ea! your own opinion on these opinions?

es

Mr. Riker: I object to reading this ny into the record for the

same reasons that were offered as to the report, and also for the

further reason that this appears to be merely an opinion upon an

opinion

Mr. McCarter: The same objection.

The Commissioner Note the objections.

The Witness: If vou will allow me to ea a word. When you say

my opinion is hased on their opinion. Their opi i

to to with the future fieures that I adopted.

my opinion on the opinion received from these men. T had to form

my own conclusions as to the combined opinion of the different

authorities that T consulted.

(Report dated August 3rd. 1911.) I heg to report as follows re-

garding the proposed scheme for the improvernent of Jamaica ae

and the probable development of the adjacent territory upon whi

A for the future sewerage of this district ultimately depend.

1550 Proposed Plan.

The plan which has been proposed by the City and agreed to, #0

far as it is concerned, by the War pany whey

and maintaining a channel from the ocean through Rockaway inlet

and around the shores of the bay. From this channel basins or canals

for the accommodation of shipping would extend inland for varying

distances. These basins the pi

finally established by the

proved by the Secretary’ of ar, May 1, 1911, are shown on draw-

ae ge 149—TIII.

plan includes the construction of bulkheads and piers and the

RENIN ae eye

THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ET AL. 1001

_ in of marsh and other low lands behind bulkhead walls.

aggregate, exclusive of the islands of the bay, some 8,500

that — &: reclaimed. The population tributary to the bay,

ated by the Jamaica Bay Commission for the year 1950, follows:

Ward. Density. Population.

cadens ndgicwiris 74 420.000

i cceces

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — New York v. New Jersey · 256 U.S. 296 | Frix