Prologue — New York v. New Jersey
Supreme Court brief1921
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
-
|
nn? % ahh
eo’ 2uS/
2
| No. @ Original.
In the Supreme Court of the Hnited States
OCTOBER TERM, 1917.
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
Complainants,
vp.
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY AnD PASSAIC VALLEY
SEWERAGE COMMISSIONERS,
Defendants.
On Argument For Injunction
BRIEF ON BEHALF OF THE PEOPLE OF
THE STATE OF NEW YORK.
| MERTON E. LEWIS,
Attorney General of the State
of New York.
WiLuuaM J. O’SULLIVAN,
Special Counsel.
f
DISPATCH PRESS, Inc., NEW YORK
a pon — ’
"= ou ex : LPB RSF ese oe ty PE <enany
|
GIA A eS ol
SUBJECT INDEX.
IIS I is alk a lto7
Mr. F. Child, Counsel for Passaic Valley
Commission, relative to Passaic River.. 3-4
Mr. Edlow Harrison, Chief Engineer, Pas-
saic Valley Sewerage Commission... ... 4
Mayor (. E. Kissam, City of Orange, N. J.,
as to dangers of the experiment........ D
EXCERI’TS FROM TESTIMONY :
Metropolitan Area, New York and New
Jersey, Prof. W. T. Sedgwick.......... 11
New York HUarbor’s Destruction, Prof.
Se GT PUD vavecctevsencveceesees 12
“Sewage Fields,” Extent of, Mr. Desmond
PRED Se ceretcrsrioucn veereeveen 12
Menace to Publie Health, Prof. C. FE. A.
WE wicvedvewsedscvssanedeucooes 12
Pollution by Putreseent Gases, Dr. E.
PEE cervecececevesrereatberenden 13
Sewage and Disease, Prof. O. H. Landreth. 13
lbisease from Sewage, Cases, Prof. W. T.
PE endvesanégaescvewcenvetuses 13-14
Nuisance and Dangers to Health, Mr.
We SEINE caceccovceecesesacce 14-15
Nuisance from Passaic River will be trans
ferred to New York Bay—
Dr. R. Spurr Weston. ....---+--+++:
Prof. W. T. Mamon.....----ceeeeees
Prof. FE. Ellery ....p---- eee cere eee
Dr. D. DD. Jackson. ......-- 6 eee eeeee
Def, Winslow... ccccccccccevcscees 16
Prof. Landreth........-----+-+eeee- 16
Mr. Desmond FitazGerald.........-.-- 16
Mr. Harrison VP. Eddy.......-.----- 16-17
Me 2. B. FiB ce cccccvcvceseeveeeveee 7
Nuisance will be created in New York
Bay—
Mr. J. W. Alword......---000eeeeee 7
Mr. E. Knichling......--.---+-++++ 17-18
Mr. J. J. Powers. ....--- 000 ee ee eeee 18-19
Mr. J. H. Fuertes.......----6+-+0+- 9
Dr. Walter Bensel.......----6-++++ 1”
Landon’s Similar Experiences, Prof. Sedg-
Ge ccccccceversieverseorsrorarseese 20
Irreparable Injury to Property—
Mr. A. Foster Higgins..........---- 21
Captain C. B. Parsons.......----+-- 31-33
Mr. F. B. Dalzell......---- 0 eee eee 23
Mr. A. Sanford........----+eeeeeeee 23
Mr. A. F. Merrell......---+-eeeeee- 23
RESELL Ga US TME TI P EN D P O
iii
PAGE
Bee Ge We Gv ccccvccesccccceces 23-24
See Ge Gee Ws oc cccceccoccces 24-25
eh Wy is Em Oe dccccewcvescecees aa)
eb Ws Gb WEvccccesccesecoeess 25-26
Injury ta Commerce—
Te, GE, Glee WUE. c ccc cecccccecs 26-27
Poet, W. F. Geigwi®. . ccccwccces 27, 20-20
Mr. Desmond FitzGerald. .......... 27-28
FUN, Wc ccncecccnccecceecees 28
Be Ge We Gc co tecccveccscocees 29
Sewage Shouk! he Discharged into New-
ark Bay, Mr. J. J. Powers............. 30
Sanitary Science Prescribes Other Methods—
BS Gy Woo GPU ee coccesccéscevecces 30-31
By Sh Bs Bere cccccccvccevesevce 31-32
See Ge, Gs o cocccvcevcceccese 31-32
Pee, Gt Ge, GOIOER, c ccc ccccccccce 32
Be Ge, Be Weec cv esccccccccceces 32
Bt ae Sb Meacoccccccvccccccouce 338
Pe TR GA Geo cc cccvcceccceccs 33-34
New York and New Jeracy Should Co-op-
erate in the Solution of This Common
Problem—
Prof. W. T. Sedgwick............... 34-35
Bee Ge Wee Eee ccecccccecccesecee 34-35
Mr. Desmond FitzGerald............ 35-36
Vew York Failed to Secure New Jeracy Co-
operation—
Be. BD. Lewte..ccccccccescsvesesess Mi
Prof. O. H. Landreth... .......... 36-37-38
Bie, G. GB, Dee ce ccccccecccesceces 37-38
Metropolitan Sewerage Commisasion’s
Plans—
Mr. D. FitzGerald .........----+--- 40
Admission in Answer That Schedule A of
Complaint Is a True Copy of Chap. 8, L.
BOBS, BH. GV. cccccccccvcccccevecovcseres bd
Art. 11, Chap. 8, L. 1834, N. V.....-.------- xo
Art. 111, Chap. 8, L. 1834, N. ¥.—Decisions
on—
Central R. R. Co. of N. 4. v. Jersey City,
SOD WU. H., BFS... ccc cece cece cceceees 9
(. Ferguson, Respondent, v. P. 8. Ross,
et afl., 156 B. V., G9B.. cc ccccccccess 10
Peo. of the State of N. Y., Respondents,
vy. Central BR. R. of N. J., Appellants,
BE. Gian BEB cccccvccccccscceceeses 9-10
Prayer for Relief...........- 6. +0000 -e00- 40
No. 3 Original.
In the Supreme Court of the United States.
OCTOBER TERM, 1917.
Tue Peor.e or Tue STATE or New York,
Complainants,
r.
THe State or New JERSEY AND Passaic VaLLey
SEWERAGE COM MISSIONERs,
Defendants.
Statement of Fact.
The Passaic Valley Trunk Sewer project, which
the People of the State of New York seek to re
strain, is designed to gather the sewage and trade
wastes from over 103 square miles in the Passaic
Valley, in the State of New Jersey, from 37 munici-
palities and townships, and discharge it in the main
ship channel in the Upper Bay of New York, where
the tidal currents will cause it to surround and
pollute the shores and waterfronts of the City of
New York.
The drainage basin of the Passaic River is over
949 square miles. The evidence based on record in
this suit proves that the Passaic River is the most
polluted body of water on the American Continent.
The conditions in this river became so intolerable
“*
that the legislature of the State of New Jersey oh
dertook to furnish remedial measures as early as
1806, and finally passed Chapter 10 of the Laws of
1907, creating the Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-
mission, with authority to build this immrcose trank
sewer which the People of the State of New York
are seeking to restrain.
In 1908 the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission
applied to the Federal Government for a permit for
a trunk sewer outfall, toe discharge 360 million gal.
lone of this septic filth each day in New York Bay
in the vicinity of Robbins Reef Light, in the main
ship channel, and within a short distance of the
boundary line between the State of New York and
the State of New Jersey.
The applicants for this permit were given hear-
ings before the Harbor Line Board beginning De
cember 9, 1908, and the permit was granted for a
tunnel under Newark Bay, the Bayonne Peninsular
and part of New York's Upper Bay to the main ship
channel.
The complainants’ bill of complaint was filed
October 17, 1908 The hearings before the Harbor
Line Board on the application for the permit began
December 9, 1908.
In January, 1909, and after the granting of the
permit by the Federal Government, the Department
of Justice on behalf of the United States Govern-
ment, moved for permission to intervene as com:
plainant in the suit instituted by the State of New
York against the State of New Jersey and the
Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners. The mo-
tion of intervention was granted on the ample pre-
sentation by the Department of Justice of the un-
satisfactory conditions incident to the issuance of
the trunk sewer permit. On the execution of stipa-
—
lations subsequently, which were framed in the in-
terests of the navigable channels in New York Har-
bor, the Department of Justice withdrew as an
intervenor.
At the hearings before the Harbor Line Board
witnesses for the State of New Jersey and the
Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners testified to
the urgent necessity for cleansing the filthy condi-
tion of the Passaic River by removing this vast
amount of septic waste to New York Bay, where it
will create a permanent and menacing nuisance te
the citizens of the State of New York.
At the hearings before the Harbor Line Board
the only question presented was the obstruction to
navigation.
Mr. Francis Child, counsel for the Passaic Valley
Sewerage Commission, “speaking for the Commis
sion, I have this to say” ( Pages 2908-9, folios 11-12,
vol. 4 of this record) :
“The lamentable conditions of the Passaic
River on account of its filth have been soch and
is such that for the last eleven vears the subject
of some feasible project for the cleansing of the
river has agitated the mind. The Passaic
River is now and has for years little
more than an open sewer, * * * stench
‘
“The question which you are called on to
determine as 1 understand it is whether this
proposed work will be an obstruction to navi-
gation.” (Page 3054, fol. 311, vol. 4.)
“The condition, as you heard it described
here, is terrible, and ought to be abated with
reasonable eclerity. Now to hold as back antil
the Supreme Court of the United States, acting
with reference to the litiga:ion of other ques
tions, should render this decision, would be,
gentiemen, I submit te you, gentlemen, tanta-
mount to a denial of justice.” (Page 3055, fol.
311, vol. 4.
“Now, it may be that at first thenght it will
appear that it would be discourteous to the
United States Supreme Court to anticipate
their action. Now, as against that, I have this
to say: That we were first in the field.” (Page
3055, fol. 312, vol. 4.)
“This whole ter. jtory is building up. It is
thickly populated as are all other territories
around New York City.” (Page 2915. fol. 19,
vol. 4.)
At that hearing before the Harbor Line Board
there were those who made protest against the
3
granting of the permit to the Passaic Valley Sewer.
age Commission for their dangerous experiment.
Among those was Mayor Coleman E. Kissam, repre-
senting the City of Orange, New Jersey, who testi-
fied :
“If New York Harbor is to become so vile in
the course of a reasonable time that it will
cause disease, be offensive, become filled up and
the people will have to stop sewage going inte
New York Harbor, it seems to me very unfair
to us to tap the smaller towns to a point where
it means almost almolute penury in order to
experiment with this sewage disposition system
into deep water which is entirely unnecessary.”
( Page 2033, folios 267-8, vol. 4.)
When the permit was granted to the Passaic
Valley Sewerage Commissioners for the trank sewer
outfall which was to abate the loathesome nuisance
of the Passaic River by transferring it to New
York's Upper Bay, the State of New York created
the New York Bay Pollution Commission to in-
vestigate and report whether our harbor waters
could assimilate the enormous burden of septic filth
which it was contemplated to discharge at Robbins
Keef in New York Bay. This commission was in-
structed to confer with the New Jersey authorities
with a view to cooperation in effort to solve the
sanitary problems involved. Conferences were had
with the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission and
communications were sent to the New Jersey State
Board of Health, but no aid was secured and co
operative solution was rejected.
The New York Bay Pollution Commission made
its report to the Legislature of the State of New
York and recommended the creation of a larger
commission, with greater scope and facilities, to
continue the investigation and to make further
PO ig FAIR AOE OPO oD te tte A ae So OL ete eet ee
EAL NN AMOI OS LL NP WAS IE a
6
effort to secure co-operation from the Passaic Valley
Sewerage Commissioners and the State authorities
of New Jersey in averting a common danger, not
only to the health and property interests of the
citizens of metropolitan New York but of the New
Jersey riparian communities on upper New York
Bay. Thereafter the State of New York created
the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission and di-
rected the City of New York to furnish uppropria-
tions and facilities for extensive scientific investi-
gation of the sanitary problems and dangers in-
volved.
The Metropolitan Sewerage Commission was di-
rected to seck conference and co-operation with the
New Jersey authorities and succeeded in securing
assent for meetings on three occasions. At these
meetings the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commis-
sion’s representatives declined proffers of aid in
joint investigation of the menacing sanitary prob-
lems, and all further efforts to secure co-operation
by the Metropolitan Sewerage Commsision were
frustrated.
Therenpon the State of New York, through its
/+torney General, was forced to institute this suit
in its efforts to protect the health and preserve the
property of its citizens from both pestilence and
destruction.
The Passaic Valley sewerage project contem-
plates the operation and maintenance of a mam-
moth trunk sewer of over twenty-six miles in length,
designed to transport the organic filth and trade
refuse from thirty-seven municipalities and town-
ships in the Passaic Valley watershed, It is pro-
posed to discharge this putrescent menace at the
rate of over 360 millions of gallons per day into
Upper New York Bay, where its septic factors will
ae
a Bn cine = oat rene nem inne
-1
ne
continuously endanger a dense community in the 3
p City of New York with recurring pestilence. :
In the presentation of the evidence comprised in
this record facts have neither been suppressed, ex- 3
ageerated or minimized. These facts were gath- ;
ered, testified to and interpreted by great scientists F
froma many states, primarily in the interests of
sanitary science and progress. A large measure of
original scientific work is embodied in this record,
together with the most complete scientific series of
investigations for the solution of the sanitary ques-
tions presented, The most eminent leaders in
chemistry, bacteriology, sanitation, bio-chemistry,
sanitary engineering and kindred sciences have con-
tributed their knowledge and = services towards
averting the catastrophe. The burden entailed in as-
sembling this evidence is justified by the inealeul-
able injuries inherent in a projeet which imperils
the health and welfare of millions of our citizens
and the commercial pre-eminence of the greatest
port of entry in the United States.
Sh ahi CDMA Ig a NE AAO Ll ON LR EN ELON AREALE AA M3952 2 Oe: Cae ttc a
POINTS.
I.
Quarantine laws are established for
the protection and promotion of the
public health (Gibbons v. Ogden, 9
Wheat., 203).
“Salus populi est suprema lex” (13 Coke 139).
The defendants admit in their answer (page 29,
fol. 51, vol. 1) that that part of the complaint
known as Schedule A is “a true copy of the said
compact or agreement,” entered into by and be-
tween the State of New York and the State of New
Jersey. In the year 1833 this compact or agree-
ment was entered into by and between the afore-
said states through commissioners appointed by
each state respectively. This compact was ratified
by the legislature of the State of New York by
Chapter 8 of the Laws of 1834, passed on February
5, 1834. It was ratified by the legislature of the
State of New Jersey by an act passed February 28,
1834, and was approved by Congress by an act
passed June 28, 1834, constituting Chapter 126 of
the Laws of 1834.
Article III, Chapter 8, Laws of 1834 of New
York, sets forth:
“ARTICLE TiIrp. The State of New York
shall have and enjoy exclusive jurisdiction of
and over all the waters of the Bay of New York,
and of and over all the waters of Hudson River
* * * and of and over the lands covered by
the said waters to the low-water mark on the
westerly or New Jersey side thereof * * *.”
a NE ABE Bh OE AGE te ee A et a TOR, a hee
9
“2. The State of New Jersey shall have the
exclusive jurisdiction of and over the wharves,
docks and improvements made, and to be made,
on the shore of the said State, and of and over
all vessels aground on said shore or fastened to
any such wharf or dock; except that the said
vessel shall be subject to the quarantine or
health laws, and laws in relation to passengers,
of the tate of New York, which now exist or
Which may hereafter be passed.”
Chapter 8 of the Laws of 1834 of the State of New
York was passed on by this high tribunal in 1908,
and the court's ruling, as summarized in the sylla-
bus, is in part as follows:
“Under the agreement of 1833 between the
States of New York and New Jersey, 4 Stat.
708, while exclusive jurisdiction is given to
New York over the waters of the Hudson River
west of the boundary line fixed by the agree.
ment, the land under such waters remained
subject to the sovereignty of New Jersey and
the jurisdiction given to New York over the
waters do not exclude the sovereign power of
New Jersey to tax such land,—nor does an
exercise of that power deprive the owner of the
land of his property without due process of law.
“This Court in construing a compact bet ween
States will hesitate to reach a conclusion differ.
ent from that reached by the highest courts of
both States. 43 Vroom 311 affirmed.”
Central 2. R. Co. of N. J. y. Jersey City,
209 U. 8., 473.
Chapter 8, Laws of 1834 N. Y., had been passed
upon by the Court of Appeals of New York. The
court as summarized in the syllabus held:
“The State has exclusive jurisdiction over
the waters to low water mark on the New Jer-
sey shore, and over ships, vessels and crafts of
--
10
every kind afloat in the bay of New York and
Hudson River south of Spuyten Duyvil Creek
for quarantine or health purposes, the protee-
tion of passengers and property, to secure the
interests of trade and commerce, and to pre-
serve the public peace. It is a qualified and
limited jurisdiction for police and sanitary
purposes and to promote the interests of com-
merce.”
People of the State of New York, Respond-
ents v. Central R. R. of New Jersey,
Appellants, 42 N. Y., 285.
In 1891 this law was again ruled on by the Court
of Appeals of the State of New York and, as sum-
marized in the syllabus, states:
“While by the compact made in 1545 between
the States of New York and New Jersey, the
middle of the North River is declared to be the
boundary between the two states, yet as by it
(Art. 3) exclusive jurisdiction of and over all
waters of the bay of New York and of the Hud-
son River, within certain limits, is given to the
State of New York. That State has jurisdic-
tion to pass a law subjecting persons to lia-
bility for certain acts done in the waters em-
braced in those limits, although within the
boundaries of New Jersey, as so fixed.
“It appears that the defendants discharged
into the waters of the North River, at a point
about one-fourth of a mile from the Jersey
shore and within the limits specified in the
compact, dredgings from a slip, HELD, that the
State of New York had jurisdiction to enact
the provision and that defendants were liable
to the penalty prescribed for its violation.”
Cornelius Furguson, Respondent v. P. San-
ford Ross, et al., Appellants, 126 N. Y.,
459.
eS ee en ee nee ee
I
Y
;
ul |
The defendants in their answer ( pages 29-30, fol.
ol) admit that the complainants have “police con- {
trol over the said waters for the enforcement of
proper quarantine regulations.” ;
In the exercise of that police power and for the ¢
proper sanitary control of the harbor waters of i
the Port of New York, and for the protection and :
preservation of the publie health, and particularly
for the health, comfort and welfare of citizens resi- F
dent on the ripa of New York's Upper Bay, these 4
complainants pray for injunctive relief against 7
the State of New Jersey and the Passaic Valley
Sewerage Commissioners.
Professor William T. Sedgwick, of the Massa-
chusetts Institute of Technology, a foremost sani-
tarian of our country and a scientist of interna-
tional high repute, describes the area that the
Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission contem-
plates inundating with this river of filth. He
testified ( pages 2256-7, folios 3276-3277, vol. IL):
“The Metropolitan area of New York and
New Jersey is already a vast human aut hill
teeming with one of the greatest commercial
and industrial populations on the face of the
globe. The health, comfort and convenience
of this huge mass of human beings requires
that every practical and reasonable sanitary
safeguard shall be thrown around it. Vast
sums have already been appropriated for its
safe and proper water supplies and much
greater sums will be soon required to pre-
vent its bays and rivers from becoming putri-
fying, nauseating and dangerous bodies of
sewage.”
Professor Earle B. Phelps, an eminent sani-
tarian and bio-chemist who had worked for over a
year and a half in making bacterial determinations
12
and oxygen analyses of our harbor waters to de
termine their capacity to struggle against this flood
of filth, testified (page 1635, folio 2419, vol. IIL):
“This great commercial center of the New
World depends upon the Harbor as the very
heart of its activity. * * * ‘This Harbor
is being destroyed and will, if nothing is done,
reach a condition which is best exemplified in
that of the Passaic River, a black, foul smell-
ing body of water. The Upper Bay will be
destroyed.”
Mr. Desmond FitzGerald, an eminent consulting
and sanitary engineer, of great experience, testi-
fied (page 1575, folio 2335, vol. III):
“For a distance of several miles the sewage
discharged at Robbins Reef will be percept
ible.”
Professor Charles-Edward Amory Winslow, Pro-
fessor of Biology and Consulting Expert on Sani-
tary Science, testified (page 1653, folio 2446, vol.
III):
“The discharge of several million gallons of
sewage at Robbins Reef will undoubtedly pro-
duce an injurious efiect open the health of the
community u.ing the harbor and an effect upon
the health of perscus using vessels in the har-
bor waters * * * fcr when that water is
polluted or infected there is danger of disease.”
And again, page 1652, folio 2444, vol. III:
“The disease bacteria discharged from the
Passaic Valley Sewer will persist for a time in
the harbor and some of them will be carried to
considerable distances so as to increase the
danger.”
Doctor E. Kuichling, a sanitary engineer who
received scientific training in several countries, tes-
tified (page 1322, folio 1975, vol. IT):
“The pollution of the atmosphere in the
warm season from the oscillating fields of sew-
age dne to the continual discharge of the pro-
posed large volume at Robbins Reef Light—
a volume of sewage unusually large being far
greater than any like discharge at any other
outlet.”
The results of such atmospheric pollution was
testified to by Prof. William P. Mason of the Renn-
sacler Polytechnic Institute (page 2002, folios
2912-3, vol. 111) as “lowering the vital resistance
whereby invading pathogenic germs coming from
other sources can secure a firm lodgment in the
holy and induce disease.”
Prof. Olin H. Landreth, a sanitary and consult.
ing engineer of national standing, testified (pages
2052-3, folio 2082, vol. 111) -
“There is a well-established belief among
medical men and sanitarians that the emana-
tions from sewage and from putrefying organie
matter are in general detrimental to health
and induce vomiting, diarrhea, Prost ration,
headache, loss of appetite and a general lower-
ing of health.”
And he adds:
“The river waters and the tidal waters of
New York Harbor are sufficiently polluted so
that they would be a menace to health if used
on our streets” (pages 832-3, folio 1309, vol.
1).
That this sewage menace becomes reality on oc-
casion is evidenced by the testimony of Prof. Will.
iam B. Sedgwick, of the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology (page 2821, folio 4153, vol. IIT):
“Two of my students, in doing work upon
sewage together for investigation, came
Le
down with typhoid fever and careful investiga-
tion seemed to exclude all other known causes
than the sewage upon which they were work-
ing. I therefore was forced to the belief that
they contracted the fever from the sewage. Mr.
Saville, now a partner of Mr. Rudolph Hering,
and Mr. Greeley, now Assistant Chief of the
sewage experiment station in Chicago, are the
two students.”
Prof. Sedgwick adds another case to these two
in the following part of his testimony (page 2809,
folio 4137, vol. IIT):
“One of the lighthouse keepers had an attack
of typhoid fever last year, which was attributed
directly to the sewage coming from the large
sewage fields which gave off a strong stench
of sewage from the Deer Island outlet in Bos-
ton Harbor.”
Mr. Theodore Horton, sanitary engineer, consult-
ing and chief engineer, New York State Depart-
ment of Health, who from 1901 had charge of the
designs and the field work in conjunction with Mr.
Rudolph Hering relative to the Passaic Valley sew-
age problem, testified in relation to the proposed
discharge (page 2305, folio 3354, vol. TIT):
“There will be a nuisance created and there
will be a menace to health. The nuisance will
be more intense in the immediate vicinity of
14
the outfall and will extend to a considerable
distance beyond it and will be carried to quite
distant shores. There will be a nuisance
caused by discoloration * * * offensive
odors, deposits, diminution of the dissolved
oxygen in the water and a menace to health
from infection and a menace to health from the
reduction of the vital resistance resulting from
these offensive odors.”
Dr. Robert Spurr Weston, Sanitary Engineer,
testified (pages 1986-7, folio 2892, vol. I11) -
“The intolerable conditions in the Passaic
River will be transferred to New York's Upper
Bay by the Passaic Valley Tronk Sewer proj-
ect. These intolerable conditions will affect
shipping interests.”
Prof. William P. Mason testified (page 2006,
folio 2919, vol. 111):
“The discharge at Robbins Reef will unduly
damage the bay water. Its pollution, which is
how great, will be made greater, and that pol-
lution growing from all sources will produce a
bay-wide nuisance.”
Prof. Edward Ellery (Professor of Chemistry ),
testified (page 2031, folio 2952, vol. Ill):
“The discharge at Robbins Reef will deplete
the amount of oxygen in the water and that
depletion of oxygen will result in a nuisance
in all the waters into which the sewage is emp-
tied in New York Bay.”
Dr. D. D. Jackson, Sanitary Expert, who had
made complete investigations of all harbors and
tidal waters on the Atlantic seaboard in relation
to sewage discharges, testified (page 2171, folio
3145, vol. IIT):
“There is no question but that the Passaic
Valley Sewer will add materially to the gen-
eral pollation of the harker amd hasten the
time at whieh a general nuieanee will exit.”
Prof. Charlee Edward Amory Winslow, comentt-
ing expert on sanitary eclener, tet ified) (page 1655,
folio 2448, vol, IN):
“The local woleance at Roldins ert will
legin to manifest leelf a* soon a the sewer
ix put inte operation. This and the mere in
direct effect spon the Marker waters will tn
crease progressively with the inereasr in the
amount of sewage discharged”
Prof, Olin H. Landreth, consulting and sanitary
engineer, testified (page 2006, folio 3001, vol. 11h):
“Whereas, now the Passaic Kiver and the
portion of Newark Bay prodace the de
position of sludge on the bottom, and the sludge
nuixance und efavium nuisances are confined
to this tevritery, in fatare they will be tram
ferred to the State of New Vork in the lower
portion of New Vork Bay.”
Mr. Dexmond PitzGierald, an eminent sanitary
engineer, testified (page 1595, folie 2364, vol. 111):
“This sewage passing under the influence of
the winds aud tide would in itself make woi-
sanees in the different parts of the shore.”
After he had previously testified «page 1694, folio
ZAK. vol. Til):
“lt would constitute a nuixance to people
who navigate on the waters and it would be a
nuixance in giving out bad smeti«, It would
be a noisance in lowering the dieselved oxygen
around the shore where before there was suff
cient oxygen to prevent sewage from being a
nuixance.”
Mr. Harrison P. Eddy, consulting engineer and
sanitary expert, testified (page 1472, folio 2186,
vol, THT):
eueas
“The sewage, expecially in the warm season
| of the quan, will have : decom posi
tien to sech an extent that it will hawe be
come putrid and will give rise to highly
offensive odors”
Mr. John 1. Vox, whe bad just concluded ex-
tensive sanitary investigations in various parts of
the United States and in Earopean countries, and
| whe had an extensive knowledge of the conditions
of New York harbor waters, testified (page 1205,
folie INSTA, wal, TT):
| “Rewege discharged at Roltvins Reef will
rise rapidly to the surface of the hay as the
aewage dees from the submerged outlet at Ped-
docks Island, Kosten, and proportionately
large fields will be produced of putrefying sew.
age. * * ow
Mr. dobn W. Alverd of Chicago, the most eminent
sanitary engineer in the Middle West, after months
of carefal stady and investigation of our harbor
waters and of the proposed Passaic Valley dis
charge, swore (page 1893, folio 2772, vol. 111) -
“I have testified that the sewage from the
Passaic Valley sewer will create a nuisance in
the waters of New York Bay.”
After be had previously testified (pages 1879-1880,
folio 2755, vol. 111) :
oe ep emits to eubirnct ene cowage from
the balk of sewage and then predicate
an estimate of the age of the rest of the sewage,
because, as 1 have remarked, the older sew age
always infects the fresher or newer sewage and
infects it with its general characteristics as to
—
tions and had national eminence, testified (pages
1321-22, folios 1974-75, vol. Il}:
“It is thas seen that the sewoge arriving at
Robbins Reef willte * * ° highly septic
and malodorous * * *° to infect and induce
active decomposition in the remaining large
volume of fresher sewage * * °. The liquid
to be discharged at Robbins Kerf will
that would make this intolerable nuisance certain,
he testified (page 1814, folio 2667, vol. Hil):
He testified later (page 2645, folio 2006, vol. 111) :
“1 betiewe that with the treatment that ix de
wribed in Exhibit No. 155, that that eTleent
will be a neiwnee in New Vork Bay and I
would be very mach opposed to having it go
through, © * * Jam a resident of the State
of New Jerecs”
Mr. James I. Poertes, consulting and sanitary
engivert, after several years investigation of New
York Harbor comlitions and sewerage disposal ays
tems in many cities threnghout the United States,
South America and Europe, testified (page 1721,
folie 2544, vol. 111):
“Tn my opinion the contemplated discharge
the Vaseaie Valley tronk sewer owtlet in
‘pret New Vork Iay in the vicinity of Rotting
Keef will have a material effect upon the polla-
tien of the Harbor waters of the Upper May,
° * © te such an extent as to give rise to
hvisances~
lie Walter Bensel, an experienced physician and
sanitary superintendent of the Department of
Health, who had made special stodies and investiga.
tions of New Vork Harbor conditions, testified
(page 2287, folie 3325, vol. 111):
“The Passaic Valley discharge would create
a tremendous offensive condition * * * There
would be so mach material that the amount of
oxygen content in the waters at present would
be unable to produce ordinary decomposition
aml putrefaction would occur to a large
extent.”
Continuing his testimony at page 2288, folio 3226:
“The Passaic Valley discharge added to the
existing couditiens eould produce this nuie
ance. It would produce a nuisance by itself
= 4%
20
wherever it was discharged by leaving decom-
posible materials on the beaches to putrefy.”
The erudite Prof. Sedgwick illustrates the ap-
palling menace threatened by the Passaic Valley
Sewerage Commissioners in citing the experience of
the City of London in 1858 and 1859, when the
River Thames, previously heavily laden with pollu-
tion, became overloaded and caused an intolerable
nuisance (page 2260-61, folios 3283-84, vol. IIT) :
“Stench so foul we may well believe had
never before ascended to pollute this lower air.
Never before at least had a stink risen to the
height of an historic event. * * * For many
weeks the atmosphere of Parliament Commit-
tee Rooms was rendered barely tolerable by the
suspension before every window of blinds sat-
urated with chloride of lime and by the lavish
use of this and other disinfectants. More than
once, in spite of similar precautions, the law
courts were suddenly broken up by an insup-
portable invasion of noxious vapors. The river
lost its accustomed traffic and travelers pressed
for time often made a circuit of many miles
rather than cross one of the city bridges. * * *
Dr. Ord reported to the Privy Council in 1859
that in 1859 (the vear of the worst stench )
steamboat men on the Thames suffered severely
from languor, headache, sore throat, nausea, '
giddiness, mental confusion, ete. In other
words, from symptoms of poisoning. In both
years the presence of sulphureted hydrogen in
the river atmosphere was shown by the rapid
blackening of paper soaked in solutions of lead
and by the discoloration of the paint of
vessels.”
—_—j} — — ee
=
oy -—
‘
SBIR se ro pret tr Cae ree aemecaraee -
21
rrI.
Great commercial and property in-
terests would be irreparably impaired
by the operation and maintenance of the
Passaic Valley trunk sewer.
Mr. A. Foster Higgins, chairman of the Commit-
tee on Harbor and Shipping, Chamber of Com-
merce, City of New York, while representing the
Chamber of Commerce of the City of New York,
testified (page 2959, folio 114, vol. IV):
“I come here with the most intense spirit
on the part of the Chamber in opposition to
this movement. * * * The City of New York
cannot preserve her commerce unless she pre-
serves absolutely her condition of a perfectly
safe port, a safe port for vessels to Visit and
for passengers to land, to carry on their trans-
actions in the City of New York. The com-
merce of the City of New York represents
almost the great bulk of the foreign commerce
of the United States and you can see how very
important a matter it is to all the citizens, not
only to the citizens of the City of New York
but to the whole citizenship of the United
States.”
o * * & * * * ®
Mr. Higgins gave the following among his reasons
for opposition to this project (page 2960, folio 116,
vol. IV):
“This great discharge of sewage should pro-
duce in the atmosphere pollution and sickness
* * * It would be so disastrous to the com-
merce of New York.”
Captain Charles B. Parsons, president Maritime
Association and ship owner, testified (page 2968,
folio 134, vol. IV):
a > ys ee ee be ere end
ORS
o>
-——
“lam here to oppose what New Jerseymen
feel as their interest, yet [am a New Jersey
man myself, but 1 feel, that no man living
along the Passaic Valley can divorce himself
from the best interest of the City of New York
and of its harbor. * * * No man can today
in any way injure this harbor if he is doing
business with the City of New York without
to some extent injuring himself.”
Further on Capt. Parsons adds (page 2969, folios
135-6, vol. IV):
“One of the points which we object to ita
is that it affects the navigable capacity of the
harbor and it obstructs it by filling up the
heads of piers, shoaling the flats which are
used for anchorages. * * * If a vessel paint-
ed white be remaining in some of those waters
she would become lead-colored in a day and
if there two or three days nearly black. * * *
It is not only the outside that it affects but
it stains the inside. It is absolutely unhealthy
for crews of vessels to remain on board while
located in the territories or localities where
it has been so offensive, and this is continually
increasing.”
Mr. F. B. Dalzell, Vice-president of the Maritime
Association of the Port of New York, Director in
the New York Board of Trade and Transportation,
Vice-president of the National Board of Steam
Navigation and President of the Association for
the Protection of Commerce, testified (pages 274-
5, folios 478-80, vol. 1):
“The action of the gases and foreign mat-
ter in the water is very detrimental to the
hulls and sheathing of our boats particularly.
* * * there action destroys our paints and
affect our metals, I mean this sheathing. The
metal that we use on our tugs is copper. * * *
Our paint will be discolored and we have great
23
objections from our employees about sleeping
aboard the tugs at night. * * * The crews
object to the foul air of foul gases. These
putrescent gases affect the paint by turning
it black. I know this of my own knowledge.
My interest in the harbor waters is not senti-
mental or scientific, but purely commercial.
* * * If the water should ever get much
more polluted than it is it would so endanger
the hulls of vessels that it would impair the
efficiency of this port of entry.”
Mr. Arthur Sanford, a contractor, Newark, N. J.,
testified (page 3047, folio 296, vol. IV):
“I don't want this sewage to come down here
and in place of taking the paint off of my
Belleville houses to take the paint off my boats,
* * * and see the immense mass of filth
that it is expected to carry.”
Mr. Azel I’. Merrell, wholesale oyster business,
testified (page 2247, folio 3260, vol. IIT) :
“The sewage that destroyed these oyster beds
came down the Arthur Kill and the Raritan
River. This sewage not only destroyed the
oyster beds but [ noticed its effect on the sides
of vessels or boats. Any light colored paint it
would discolor overnight. The gases rising
from the waters would discolor the paint. The
discoloration would be quite black.”
Mr. J. William Grifiin, resident of Jersey City,
Superintendent of the Waterworks of the Water
Department of Jersey City since 1906, experience
extensive in public works construction, etc., testi-
fied (page 2873, folios 4226-7, vol. III):
“The discharge of this sewage as proposed
at Robbins Reef Light, in accordance with
these plans, will affect the health and prop-
erty of the citizens of Jersey City.
PCR ERENT ARE OE GT Tat Ty erm egeamanmnent fl
24
“| appeared voluntarily in this case to pro-
test against the discharge. of this sewage into
New York Bay on the ground that it will ere-
ate a nuisance in the waters of the bay which
will seriously affect the business interests, the
property interests and the health of Jersey
City. * * * I know now that the sewage
from these towns creates a nuisance in the
Passaic Valley affecting the health and prop-
erty of the citizens therein and that this nui-
sance is the chief reason why the cities in the
Passaic Valley have joined in a plan to carry
the same out of the valley through the trunk
line sewer proposed by the Passaic Valley
Sewerage Commission. I believe that this pipe
line will simply transfer the nuisance which
exists in the Passaic Valley to the waterfront
of Jersey City and the other municipalities on
New York's upper bay.”
Mr. Griflin, who though an official in the Jersey
City administration, apprehended danger from the
Passaic Valley sewerage project to property and
health in Jersey City, gives the following illumin-
ating answer to a question put by one of the coun-
sel for defendants (page 2875, folio 4229, vol. IIT):
“Q. (By Mr. Riker) Now, if such an effluent
is produced which you say is possible, you
think it nevertheless will be a nuisance if dis-
charged into New York Bay?
“4. I do not, but the only thing I say about
that is that you would not carry it into New
York Bay if you proposed to discharge au
effluent of that character.”
Dr. Robert Spurr Weston, consulting sanitary
engineer, after more than nine months’ investiga-
tion of the Passaic Valley sewerage project and
of the harbor conditions in the Port of New York,
testified (page 1971, folios 2872-3, vol. IIT):
25
“The effect upon shipping from the dis-
charge of the Passaic Valley Sewer at Rob-
bins’ Reef will be that the turbid grease and
other matter would make the waters of the
Upper Bay unpleasant for commerce and
would make excursions on the harbor unpopu-
lar by creating noticeably disagreeable condi-
tions in the largest port of the country, con-
sequently lessening its prestige and depre-
ciating the value of the bay for recreation pur-
poses.”
He also explains as the result of his investigations
how the injuries to ships from sewage is effected,
testifying at page 1951, folio 2847, vol. III:
“The effect on painted wood and metal of
the Passaic Valley sewage: The hydrogen-sul-
phide evolved would cause paints used to coat
wood and iron work to darken in color.”
Mr. R. A. C. Smith, Chairman, Committee on
Harbor and Shipping of the Chamber of Commerce
of the City of New York, Chairman of the New
York and New Jersey Joint Commission on Harbor
Improvement and Pier Extension for New York
arbor, testified (pages 179-180, folios 340-1, vol.
I):
“T have been connected with commercial
business in the City of New York for upwards
of thirty-five years, following trade involving
an enormous amount of shipments to the
South and in addition to that as a ship owner.
* * * I feel that I am qualified in answer-
ing any questions that involve harbor lines,
bulkhead lines and the emptying of the pollu-
tion into our river causing the damage which
it does, and of the deposits that choke up the
channels.”
Mr. Henry R. Towne, President of the Mer-
chants Association of New York, member of the
26
Chamber of Commerce of the City of New York,
Vice-President of the American Society of Me.
chanical Engineers, testified as follows (page 252,
folios 445-6, vol. I):
“There are two phases of this matter bear-
ing on the condition of our harbor, upon the
trade and commerce of the port. * * * The
second is the sanitary phase affecting the
health, comfort and welfare of the people of
this great city. This is the side of the subject
that appeals especially to me for the reason
that for nearly forty years I have been a stu-
dent of sanitary engineering and have followed
the development of that science. * * * One
of the worst factors in the situation is the
fouling of the waters of the harbor which sur-
round and hbisect the greater city. In the
earlier days it was permissible for the city to
discharge its filth into the adjacent water, but
sanitary authorities the world over and one
after another of the great cities have found it
inpermissible and ultimately intolerable to
continue this primitive method and have re-
sorted to other and better methods whereby
the vast amount of filth which must be dis-
posed of * * ®* shall either be carried
elsewhere to some safer and less harmful point
of discharge, or if that be not feasible, shall
then be treated in some way prior to its dis-
charge, so that the effluent * * * shall be
practically relieved of impurities.”
Dr. Robert Spurr Weston’s investigations rel-
ative to the Passaic Valley sewerage project from
the commercial aspect, he testified to as follows
(page 1953, folio 2850, vol. IIT):
“Effect on commerce: If the Passaic Val-
ley project be carried out the sewage field
would extend across the main channel of the
harbor. Incoming and outgoing vessels would
27
pass through this field, * * * creating a
noticeably disagreeable condition in the lar-
gest port of the country. If the polluted har-
hor water were used for washing decks and
in the pantries and galleys of ships, it would
be liable to come into contact with food used
by human beings and thereby become a pos-
sible source of infection.”
Prof. Sedgwick sums up these commercial inter-
ests in his testimony vt page 2257, folio 3277, vol.
III, as follows:
“The port and harbor ef New York are the
most important port and the greatest harbor
of the country and a great center of commence.
Many foreign and other steamship lines bring
and carry unlimited numbers of passengers;
its exports, imports, traffic and trade, foreign
and coast-wise, are of the greatest volume and
magnitude.”
Dr. Weston in his testimony asserts (page 1961,
folio 2860, vol. IIT):
“The Passaic Valley sewage will injure ves-
sels passing through the main channel in the
Upper Bay as occurs now in the Passaic
River.”
Among the injuries to navigation Professor Sedg-
wick asserts the following in his testimony (page
2246, folio 3289, vol. III):
“It will form deposits and will cause shoal-
ing of the channel and blackening of the
shore.”
He adds at page 2269, folio 3297:
“The discharge at Robbins Reef will injure
United States property.”
Mr. Desmond FitzGerald, sanitary and hydraulic
engineer, testifies (page 1539, folio 2281, vol. II):
“We have a large inland community which
proposes to tunnel under their natural outlet,
the Passaic River and Newark Bay, and un-
der the separating land of Bayoune and Jer-
sey City, and discharge their sewage close to
the water boundry between New York and
New Jersey in such a manner as to do a great
injury to the real riparian owners and oceu-
pants of valuable property around the shores.
* * * That discharge will cause a nuis-
ance.”
Prof. Winslow testified «page 1644, folio 2432,
vol. If):
“New York Harbor now receives 900,000,000
gallons of sewage per day from about 6,000,-
000 people. This equals a sewage river 15
miles long, 100 feet wide and 1% feet deep.
This volume of sewage deposits 1,500 tons of
solid material daily. There is now general!
pollution of New York Harbor waters and
very great local pollution in certain areas.”
To this testimony as to present overburdened
condition Mr. Desmond FitzGerald sets forth in
plain language the Passaic Valley project in its
nakedness (page 1541, folios 2285-6, vol. II):
“There is another feature of this tunnel plan
which cannot fail to create alarm. The total
capacity of the tunnel scheme is more than 400
million gallons daily and that it is probable
from the statements of the Passaic Commis-
sioners and their engineers that the full ca-
pacity of the tunnel will be utilized on com-
pletion of the works. * * * There will flow
into the Upper Bay more than 400,000,000 gal-
lons in twenty-four hours. This amount of
filth discharged practically at one spot in the
Upper Bay will create a local and general
nuisance. This amount of sewage concen-
trated in the neighborhood of Robbins Reef
24
will create a local nuisance which in a few
hours under the action of the winds and cur-
rents will be carried to any of the surrounding
shores, thus producing a long series of general
nuisances in every part of the harbor, which
prospectively will increase in intensity as the
sewage becomes less diluted and the dissolved
oxygen in the Upper Bay is carried lower and
lower.”
Mr. John W. Alvord, consulting sanitary engi-
neer, testified (page 1896, folio 2776, vol. III);
“The effluent stipulated for will produce de-
posits in New York Bay of solid matter and
it will produce odors due to the putrefaction
of organic matters; it will also produce grease
and color and it will produce both public and
private nuisance.”
Prof. Sedgwick sets forth in his testimony the
menace to commerce and navigation ( pages 2257-8,
folios 3278-9, vol. IIT):
“The construction and operation of the pro-
posed Passaic Valley Sewer will discharge
large quantities of putrid matter into the waters
of New York Harbor, which matter will oscil-
late back and forth through The Narrows and
through the channels of both upper and lower
New York Bay and will tend, in part, to set-
tle, make deposits and eventually shoal and
obstruct navigation in these waters, clogging
the navigable channels and necessitating the
maintenance of dredges, scows and boats to
remove said deposits, while the dredges, scows
and boats thus required will in themselves ob-
struct navigation. All this will tend to make
the port of New York less serviceable for
commerce and less agreeable and comfortable
to the people through the offensive and un-
pleasant odors and the unsightly appearance
of the water and of the channels, wharves and
7
docks, which will result from the discharge
of the sewage in the manner proposed. The
sewage «0 discharged will injure the hulls of
vessels and their paint, both exterior and in-
terior, inclading war ships and other craft
belonging to the United States Government ; ?
also yachts and pleasure boats.”
Mr. James J. Powers, consulting and construc.
tion engineer, as the result of his stady and in-
vestigation of the Passaic Valley sewerage project,
their plans and their promises, testifies (page 2658,
folio 3805, vol. 111):
“If this effinent, when it ixenes from the
works on Newark Meadows, is an inoffensive,
claritied effluent, incapable of offense, it would
not be necessary to expend seven million dol-
lars in conveying it several miles to Robbins
Reef. If it is inoffensive there can be no ob-
jection whatever to discharging it into the
Newark Bay.”
ow
Sanitary science can abate the nui-
sance in the Passaic Valley without
afflicting a neighboring community.
Mr. John W. Alvord, consulting sanitary engi-
neer, testified (page 1871, folie 2744, wol. IIT):
“The lassaic River and Newark Bay now
constitute what might be well called a natural
sewage dixposal plant by sedimentation, septic
action and tidal dilution, and while this nat-
ural plant is locally obnoxious, its results as
shown by the dissolved oxygen content at the
lower end of Newark Bay are more effective
than the purification caused by the dilution of
the waters of the Hudson Kiver and the tidal
action off the Battery in New York City upon
New York City sewage. No problem of this
character was ever, in my opinion, finally
solved by tranerring it out of its natural
drainage district into the drainage district of
another community where natural conditions
are already insufficient to care for the increas.
ing pollution there existing.”
Dr. George A. Soper, President of the Metropol.
tan Sewerage Commirxion, text itied (page 426, folic
TAR, vol. Ty:
“The conditions in New York Harbor are
net favorable for the disposal of sewage by di-
xesting or asximilation. The constant changing
proportions of sea water and land water are
prejodicial to the existence of a permanent
fauna and flora, and the phenomenon of the
under-run indicated that there was an abswence
of vertical carrents which were needed to carry
an adequate supply of oxygen to the depths.”
Mr. Emil Kuichling, after two years of compre-
hensive investigation of our harbor conditions, and
after studying all available data upon tidal and
other phenomena relating to the Port of New York,
testified (page 1303, folios 1954-5, vol. II):
“Practically the whole of the bottom of
Upper New York Bay is covered with black,
Ulsmelling mud in which particles of sewage
origin are distinguishable. In places these de
posits have been found to obtain te a depth of
over 10 feet. * * * So much
organic matter on the bottom, which is clearly
indicated by the bacterial chemical and micro-
scopical examinations which have been made.
iso pair the quality of the overlying water. The
gases and soluble products of decom position
are absorbed by the water and to maintain the
active process of decomposition oxygen is ab-
stracted from the water. Sewage coutains
much putrescitle organic matter in beth true
and colloidal selution, which is readily oxy-
dized either divectiy in a chemical manner or
indirectly through the action of bacteria which
require a definite supply of oxygen”
Among the efforts to solve a problem that is
exceedingly cosaplicated by the riparian cities in
New Jersey, the following «scheme was formulated
and is testified to by Prof. Olin HL. Landreth, one of
the great sanitary engineering authorities in our
country (page 415, folie 713, vol. Th:
“In dealing with the problems presented te
the New York ay Pollution Commission we
took into general consideration the feasibility
of ocean disposal of sewage, awd in the report
of the Commission we stated that as between
two possible general lines ef remedy it seemed
then that the methed of ocean dixpoxal pow
some advantages that were preferable. It
seemed to be the more feasible and economical
of the two methods, economical for the tay-
payers of New Jersey as well as of New York.”
Mr. L. L. Tribus, a member of the New York Bay
Pollution Commission, testified to an alternate
scheme ( page 317, folio 545, vol. 1):
“| was calied on to work out a plan for the
of Manhattan. 1 prepared the plans
~ peeeeeeaiameemeaieaendmamaes
“The Passaic Valley District hax been in-
is fixed ly.
creasing. It is not a = oa,
The following question put by connsel for the
Pessaic Valley Rewerage Commissioners impels
thenght. It appears on page 2275, folio 3305, vol.
111, and was put to one of the experts who was
called upon by the complainants to aid in invemti-
gating the problem, and is as follows:
“If certain waters were very appropriately
devoted to cesspool purposes, how would the
redaction in disselved oxygen of those waters
be injurious?”
Reveral communities in the Passaic Valley were
anxious to solve their local problem without enter-
ing into the Passaic Valley Sewerage acheme. Mr.
Harrison P. Eddy, consulting sanitary engineer, of
Boston, testified ( page 1394, folie 2074, vol. 11):
“I recently made a report to the State Board
of Health of New Jersey relative to locating a
trickling filter plant for the purification of sew-
age in the township of North Plainfield. Prior
to that I made a report for the cities and towns
of East Orange, Montclair, Glen Ridge and
Bloomfield ; the town of Orange was ineinded.
In this report I outlined a method by means of
which the sewage of these communities could
be purified before it was discharged into any
natural stream of water. These methods were
to be substituted for the necessity of entering
into the Passaic Valley Sewerage project.”
Dr. D. D. Jackson, sanitary expert, testified (page
2171, folio 3145, vol. 111):
“The Sewer Department of New York City in
making extensive examinations into the quality
of the sewage of Manhattan with a view of in-
stalling separate devices for sedimentation and
screening the sewage, which data is now being
collected under my direction.”
Oe IRA Hy SPD A er
SCOR OB Sah ini, ER A II RN NL Ns ey WALES AMATO 5 et De PNB
Any scheme for the relief of New York Harbor
waters will be doomed to hopeless failure if the
Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission is permitted
to operate and maintain its mammoth trunk sewer.
Prof. Sedgwick, after careful study and analysis
of this dangerous sewage situation, testified (page
2PT1, folio 3300, vol. TLL):
“The magnitude of New York City’s problem
and the simplicity of the New Jersey problem
indieate that both should co-operate in study-
ing and solving the whole problem.”
Mr. John W. Alvord, an eminent sanitary au-
thority from the Middle West, after working many
months on this sewage problem and its complica-
tions, testified (page 1903, folio 2786, vol. TIT):
“This problem is inseparable and common as
between the two sovercignties of New York and
New Jersey. I do not see how it can be well
solved without Common co-operation between
these two sovereignties. They are both equally
interested in the preservation of the purity of
the waters of this Harbor. It is a common
property in which they are both interested.
Proper procedure for these two sovereign states
to take on such a question is to agree upon some
plan of just and equitable co-operation which,
if carried out carefully and conscientiously,
will enable both of them to enjoy its advantages
equally.”
Mr. Alvord’s scientific impartiality is disclosed
in his testimony at page 1892, folios 2771-2, vol. IIT:
“I do not look at it from a local or sectional
standpoint. To my mind it is one problem of
sanitation which concerns all the surrounding
communities of this district under considera-
tion, and as such problem I think it should be
treated on broad general advantageous lines
35
Which should not, in my opinion, tax any one
portion of the communities at any excessive
rate over any other portion, * * * In so far as
relates to the ultimate solution of this problem
I do not take into consideration the territorial
jurisdictions of the states of New York and
New Jersey, © * © J recognize the right in
both these sovereign states to obtain a joint
participation in the waters of the hay, but I
recognize that both must use such right with
due regard to the right of each other.”
Prof. Sedgwick, afier a year's investigation of
the entire problem, testified (page 2257, folio 3277.
vol. LIT):
“Instead of adding to the already too ex-
tensive pollutions of New York Bay, the State
of New Jersey ought, in my opinion, to join
hands with the State of New York and set to
work immediately to prevent all further pol-
lution, to the end that these precious bodies
of water shall be reserved forever for the real
comfort, safety, convenience and sanitary wel-
fare of the vast populations which will soon
surround them.”
Mr. Desinond FitzGerald, who had the problem
under investigation and study for two years, tes-
tified (page 1510, folio 2238, vol. IT):
“IT have had a good many opportunities for
examinations of the waters of New York Har-
hor and the Passaic River and examined them
in detail.”
He gives the result in his testimony at page 1538,
folios 2279-80, vol. IL:
“In my opinion all should take an equal
part in some well considered plan devised after
careful thought and acting for the benetit of the
whole.”
PE a OA NO IRD RD GN Mt BPR re ae a
36
At page 1586, folio 2351, vol. IT, he adds:
“What is in my mind is that all the muni-
cipalities should unite and form an intelligent
study of the problem as a whole and that no
part of it should seek to grab any part of the
harbor.”
Dr. Daniel Lewis, Chairman of the New York
Bay Pollution Commission, Ex-President State
Board of Health for eight years, Commissioner of
State Board of Health for four years, Master
of Art, Doctor of Philosophy, Doctor of Laws,
President Medical Society of New York, and Presi-
dent Metropolitan Sewerage Commission, testified
at pages 638-9, folio 1022, vol. T:
“The law directed us to confer with the New
Jersey authorities who had chaige of the pro-
posed construction of the Passaic Valley Sewer.
* * * We had two or three conferences with
a part of them and we had a conference with
the full commission in Newack. * * * The
records of these meetings were kept by the
secretary, Mr. A. J. Provost.”
Prof. Olin H. Landreth, a member of the New
York Bay Pollution Commission, testified (pages
865-6, folios 1356-7, vol. I):
“Our commission was directed to investigate
the condition of pollution of New York Har-
bor and to recommend what action should be
taken; second, to co operate with similar bodies
from the State of New Jersey with a view to
ascertain whether by co-operation the large
problem of the disposal of the sewage of the
entire Metropolitan District might be solved
in a way to be effective and without conflict
between the two commonwealths. * * *
“There were two or three bodies in the State
of New Jersey that we thought perhaps had
jurisdiction to co-operate with us—the State
a, GR Bea ks
AD AIG Bet OO Pine i POO Ne RE Nei
Board of Health, for one, the State Sewerage
Commission and the Passaic Valley Sewerage
Commission, * * * We rather supposed
they might feel that they had authorization to
deliberate) on questions which affected their
jurisdiction, their territory. We knew that
their duty was approximately to prevent the
pollution of the Passaic River and that that
problem had a great deal to do with our gen-
eral problem, speaking of the problem in gen-
eral, and that the solution of the problem of
the disposal of the sewage in the entire Metro-
politan District regardless of State lines, That
is a problem in itself. [1 stands by itself and
ought to be treated by itself regardless of State
boundaries. We recognized the Passaic Valley
as a part of the Metropolitan District.”
Prof. Landreth testifies to the sequelae of these
conferences (page 869, folio 1362, vol. I):
“No results followed from these conferences.
We hoped that results might fellow and delayed
our work, delayed adopting our final program
of work hoping that we might be able to reach
a Co-operative scheme of investigations by
Which we should be able to concentrate our
activities—our studies—on certain parts of
the harbor, and ask New Jersey to concentrate
theirs on certain other portions, and thus, per-
haps, secure a greater volume of information
than we could be able to do separately, but,
unfortunately, nothing came of the efforts to
co-operate.”
Mr. L. L. Tribus, Sanitary engineer, me nber of
the New York Bay Pollution Commission, testified
(page 312, folio 537, vol. 1):
“The members of the New York Bay Pol-
lution Commission had conferences with Pas-
saic Valley Sewerage Commissioners. Our ob.
ject was to see if some joint action could not
be taken by the states of New York and New
ree
amr
38
Jersey, our two commissions or through a later
commission, or through some board assigned
for the purpose, to see if unity of action look-
ing to a solution of the sewage problem of the
Metropolitan Sewerage District irrespective of
state lines. The New York Pollution Commis-
sion was specially charged to lock into that
phase of the question. Our conterences did
not result in our securing any real information
relative to the plans of the New Jersey project
and we found that it was hopeless to expect
any development along broader lines.”
The comprehensive scope and plan of the inves-
tigations are inferred from Prof. Olin H. Lan-
dreth’s testimony (pages 869-70, folios 1362-3, vol.
“We included the territory in New Jersey
that the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission
had jurisdiction over in the Met repolitan Sew-
er District, because it all lies within the nat-
ural boundarics cf the territory which should
have its sewage f cilities planned harmonious-
ly, planned in common, even if not by a com-
mon single system.
. * * 7 * * * *
“We did not think that even the added difii-
culty arising from the fact that there were
two states was insurmountable. We hoped a
plan might be reached by which in the first
place the question should be studied by the two
together. working harmoniously together, and
as the result ef such studies we hoped to settle
the question as to what would be necessary to
accomplish an harmonious construction or an
harmonious series of construction through all
parts of the district.”
Mr. L. L. Tribus, sanitary engineer and member
of the New York Bay Pollution Commission, de-
scribes this region in his testimony (page 312, folio
538, vol. I):
39
“The district that we call the Metropolitan
Sewerage District is the greatest manufactur-
ing center of the world, the sewage has in it a
great variety of matter other than that classed
ordinarily as sanitary sewage coming from resi-
dential districts. This made the sewage prob-
lem a very complex one.”
Mr. Desmond FitzGerald testified to the work
done by the Metropolitan Sewerage Commission
(page 1587, folio 2352, vol. I1):
“They have begun a serious study of the
present condition in the first place of the har-
bor waters, and in the next place they have
made very extensive surveys and employed a
large number of experts to give them advice
as to the most necessary and practical way to
deal with this great question.”
He also testified (pages 1545-6, folio 2293, vol.
Il):
“A strong reason for not allowing New Jer-
sey to pour this mass of sewage into New York
Harbor near Robbins Reef is because New York
is now planning for the proper disposal of the
sewage of the whole Metropolitan District, and
before any planus can be put into effect the sew-
age will probably be fifty per cent. greater
than in 1910.”
Every available effort has been made by the
complainants to induce the defendants to abstain
from the destructive policy involved in the opera-
tion and maintenance of the Passaic Valley Sewer-
age Commissioners’ trunk sewer. The most emi-
nent scientists have been induced to study and ad-
vise on the far-reaching problems involved. Even
the record in this suit has been compiled until it
is encyclopedic on sanitary engineering science and
is so informative on the impending dangers from
.
this insanitary project that it was hoped that the
defendants would heed the warnings and seek the
co-operation advised by impartial scientists.
This revolting scheme which contemplates inun-
dating the largest industrial population in our
country with septic filth, not only menaces with
pestilence the health and comfort of our citizens
but strikes fatally at the commercial preeminence
of the greatest port of entry on the American Con-
tinent.
For these reasons your Orators pray that the
writ of injunction may issue, and so avert a catas- )
trophe national in its significance.
40
Vv.
It is respectfully submitted that the
prayer of your Orators should be grant-
ed and a writ of injunction issue as
prayed for in the Bill of Complaint.
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
By Merton E. Lewis,
Attorney General.
WILLIAM J. O'SULLIVAN,
Special Counsel.
[4450]
Oihiee Seorewe Com ys
FILED
SEP 24 1917
No. § Original.
jn the Supreme Court of the United States
Ocrown Team, 1917.
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
Complainants,
vs.
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY ann PASSAIC VALLEY
SEWERAGE COMMISSIONERS,
Defendants.
BRIEF AND ARGUMENT ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANTS,
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY AND PASSAIC VALLEY
SEWERAGE COMMISSIONERS.
JOHN W. WESCOTT,
Attorney General of the State
of New Jersey.
ADRIAN RIKER,
Counsel, Passaic Valley
Sewerage Commissioners.
Roment H. MeCawren,
Special Counsel.
Tne Essex Porss, Law Parwrees, Newark N J
a -
a
SUBJECT INDEX
PAGE.
DN GN WEEcccenesveservecsoceceoses 5
History of the Litigation................... x
PUREED hebweneuesuseeceotocéssoccendoca x
PET. skbbruesbbdbsorceseebolaecéesk 9
Analysis, Appendix No. 1................. 96
Issues Raised by the Pleadings.............. 10
Under compact of 1834, Appendix No. 4.... 120
Under allegations of threatened irremedia-
ie NN Nadel dbduencduukGebdcnces 10
ubadebubeasseeebeveedecheWaninces 10
PD Gnbsduntbbiecnéucdasasewds 10
Condition of Passaic River............... 11
Mans for purification of Passaic River. .... 11
Places of discharge of effluent from Passaic
<2 eee 12
Stipulation—Effect of ................... 14
Stipulation, Appendix No. 2.............. 110
Certificate of engineers, Appendix No. 3.... 116
EET Maahevddalntabiencevddsteticnesunwuans 31
Conditions necessary to sustain bill for in-
junction quia timet.................... 31
Legal effect of compact of 1834............ 3
Compact of 1834, Appendix No. 4.......... 120
Legal effect of complainants’ acts......... af
Reply to Brief for Complainants............ 57
EE OT Ub ccrnsenewocsececceceuss 57
Disetssion of points suggested in brief... .. ay
DU Sabcdlceraatersedessnddcocseus, %
ty
: . +305 49,
} een on Ge banned “ead PAGE.
Act of Congress, Jane 24, 1834, 4 Btat., 708... x
Habeork ads. State, 30 N. 4. Law, 28......... a0
Kerdan v. Vasmic Valley Sewerage Commie
sionets, 82 N. 4. Equity, 225 (affirmed 83
Be Go Ge GEO cc ccccscocccccccesoes 13
Hinghamton, City of, ade Morgan, 7 N. E.
Rep. 424 (01. of Appeals of New York)...
rooks ads, Harrison, 20 Ga. SA7........... M4
Kutler v. Rogers, 0 N. 4. Wquity, 487........ a
(rntral Rh. Rh. Co. of N. 4. ade. People, 42 N.Y.
QMS (1870) .......... ppeseconesoosews na
Crutral RR. Ce. v. dereew City, 70 N. 4. Law,
GD ecccscovcccovcevevcescoooccovosees 37,47
Central Rh. BR. of N. 4. derwey City, 2000.
GED ccccccvvcnscoevccccconcecosoeossees ””
Congress, Act of, June 28, 1534, 4 Btatetes, 708 49
In re Devoe Manufactering Co, 108 1. 8. 401) 37
Doviestown ada. Holton, 4 Brewster, 333 (fa) 34
Fergus v. New, 126 NV. 450 (1881)... “
Harrison v. Urooks, 20 Gia. SAT............. a
High on Injonctions, Section 742.......... o =
Holton v. Doylestown, 4 Brewster, 333 (Pa)... 34
Ilineis ads. Missouri, 200 1. #306 (26 T. #.
Ga, GR, Ba, GED o ccccvccccccccccces MOA
Injunctions, High on, Bection 742........... 32
Jerery City ads, Central RK. Ce. 70 N. 7. LL.
ED ecvccsevecvovcenoceecensoeceooeses 33,47
Jersey City ada. Central BR. RR. of N. 4. 208
is es Sb eeeecccnsseeweosooeecoenees 49
Laws of New Jerecy for 1534, page 118... .... 3s
Laws of New Jerecy for 1907, Chapter 10.. .. 11
Laws of New York for 1534, Chapter ®, page ® 38
degre we
Vsrerale oe hO tly Ver
PAGE
No. 3 Original.
3n the Supreme Court of the United States.
(h)venen Team, 19197.
Ss
Tue Peer e oF THE PTATE oF
New Vouk, irief on Behalf of
Complainants, the State of New
Jeracy and Pas
= | mic Valley Sew-
Tue State or New Jemsey| ©1496 Commin
axe assanw Valley Bew- scanners,
FRAGE COMMISSIONERS, Defendants
Defendants. ;
Statement of Fact.
The following fact« are cither admitted by the
complainant, or extablished by its own witnesses,
and are net subject to question:
1. The great public work planned by the de-
femdants ix to be constructed entirely within the
territertal limits of the State of New Jersey.
2. The purpose of the work is to reliewe a con-
dition in the waters of the Passaic River comstitat
ing a public ond private nuisance, which demands
immediate abatement.
10
fu
SRO PY ALOE EDI et WL EAL SNE OIE: IONE LBA Kis’ tb OH
10
20
30
Cs
3. The conditions existing in the Passaic River
result from the discharge of sewage into it from
the municipalities within the Passaic Valley Sew-
erage District.
4. The population within this district at the
time of the closing of the testimony was approxi-
mately seven hundred and fifty thousand.
5. The plans of the defendants contemplate the
intercepting of the sewage of the said municipalities
by a joint trunk intercepting sewer and branches,
the conducting of the sewage to a treatment plant
in the City of Newark on the Newark Meadows ad-
joining Newark Bay, the treatment of the sewage
there and the discharge of the efluent through an
outfall pressure tunnel within a dispersion area
located on the edge of the main ship channel near
Robbins Reef, within the territorial limits of New
Jersey, the nearest point of the dispersion area to
the line dividing the State of New York from the
State of New Jersey being more than one-third of
a mile.
6. The nearest part of any of the upland of the
State of New York to the dispersion area is Staten
Island, which is more than a mile distant.
7. The population of the City of New York
at the close of taking testimony in this case was
about five million.
S. All of the sewage of the City of New York
is discharged, untreated, at the surface of the
waters of New York Harbor, and immediately at
the water's edge.
9. The treatment of the sewage of the Passaic
Valley described in the stipulation, Complainant's
exhibit No. 135 (Appendix No. 2 this Brief), will
result in the removal of more than fifty per cent.
of the solids in the sewage, including all of the
coarse material.
10.) The discharge of the efluent into New York
Bay will be at a depth of forty feet, through at
least one hundred and fifty vents, horizontally in
the direction of the current in the main ship chan-
nel.
11. Asa whole the plan of treatment and dis-
charge into the waters is more perfect and com-
plete than any sewerage system discharging into
harbor waters now in operation in the world.
12. The sewage of the Passaic Valley dis-
charged into the waters of the Passaic River tinds
its way through Newark Bay, thence along the
shores of Staten Island, to the extent of eighty-
four per cent., through the Kill van Kull, into
Upper New York Bay, and to the extent of sixteen
per cent. through the Arthur Kill into Lower New
York Bay.
13. The method of disposal of sewage by the
City of New York is the worst possible, so far as
its effeet on the harbor waters is concerned,
14. In case the methods of treatment described
in the stipulation, Exhibit No. 135 for complainant
(Appendix No. 2 to this Brief), fail to produce the
results guaranteed, further treatment is to be
added, which will produce an effluent, which, when
discharged into the waters of New York Bay, will
result in no nuisance of any kind.
10
20
40
TEE AR TT
_
> Hg DRO AS LTE EERE I BT IT
Pee ae
I.
History of the Litigation.
This suit has been pending from October 17, 1908,
until this time, a period of nearly nine years. The
bill of complaint was filed October 17, 1908, the
United States intervened January 4, 1909, the an-
swer of the defendants was filed January 4, 1909,
replication was filed November &, 1909, the stipu-
lation between the United States and the defend-
ants was filed May 16, 1910, and the intervening
petition of the United States was dismissed with-
out prejudice on that date. The City of New York
applied for leave to intervene December 12, 1910,
Which application was denied December 19, 1910.
20 ‘The order for the appointment of a commissioner
to take testimony was made April 24. 1911. The
time to close the testimony was extended from
time to time until July 1, 1913.) The actual taking
of testimony began on June 26, 1911, and ended
June 27, 1913. The motion to dismiss for want of
prosecution was made and denied November 30,
1913. The time actually used by defendants in
taking testimony was less than six months. The
30 delay in bringing this cause to argument is charge-
able to the complainant.
10
Il.
The Pleadings.
For the convenience of the Court there is append-
ed to this brief, as Appendix No. 1, an analysis of
40 the bill of complaint and the answer and replica-
a:
Sh |
i aR, Ra
9
tion, The substance of the complaint and answer,
stated briefly, is as follows:—
The complaint charges the defendants with plan-
ning and intending to divert the sewage of the
*assaic Valley Sewerage District, then discharg-
ing into the Passaic River, through an intercept-
ing sewer into the waters of New York Bay near
Robbins Reef light, and thereby threatening to 10
injure the complainant.
1. By interfering with contractual rights
claimed by it under the compact betireen New York
and New Jersey, ratified in 1834.
2. By setting up a continuing nuisance in the
waters of New York Bay, achich must cause injury
to the inhabitants of the State of New York, and 20
particularly the City of New York.
The answer admits the design and plan of inter-
cepting the sewage of the Passaic Valley Sewerage
District, carrying it to treatment works on the
Newark Meadows, and discharging an effluent into
the waters of New York Bay near Robbins Reef
light; but denies that the discharge so intended will
be either an infraction of the rights of the com- 30
plainant under the compact in question or will con-
stitute a nuisance, as alleged in the bill of com-
plaint.
The answer further charges that complainant
‘annot be heard in a Court of Equity to urge either
of these claims, because of its own acts of com-
mission which disqualify it on the ground that it
does not come into this Court of Equity with clean
hands. 40
eet = aethipnes oe ng eee peter oe ee a
Ill.
The Issues Raised by the Pleadings.
Is complainant entitled to the injunction prayed
for
1. On the ground that the discharge of the sewer
as planned within the territorial limits of New Jer-
sey into the waters of New York Bay threatens
a. A riolation of rights conferred upon the State
of New York by the compact of 1834.
10
b. An irremediable continuing nuisance affect-
ing the inhabitants of the State of New York in-
juriously.
2. Max complainant any standing in a court of
20 equity to ask the relief prayed for, in view of the
character of its own conduct and acts in’ the
premises?
UPON EACH OF THE ISSUES RAISED, DE-
FENDANTS SUBMIT UNDER THE EVIDENCE
AND THE LAW THE ANSWER MUST BE NO.
IV.
30 The Evidence.
A. The urgent necessity for the purification of
the waters of the Passaic River is admitted by the
allegations of the bill of complaint, the answer,
complainant's brief, and the evidence of every wit-
ness who testified with respect to it. Complain-
ant’s brief, p. 1, says, “The evidence * * * on record
in this suit proves that the Passaic River is the
40 most polluted body of water on the American con-
11 :
'
tinent.” While this statement is extreme and not :
warranted by the evidence, it is nevertheless a fact
that the condition of the river is intolerable and
requires immediate relief. Some of the witnesses
use the term “open sewer,” others “an elongated
septic tank” in describing the river as it now is.
B. The record further discloses that the prob- 10
lem of purifying the Passaic River has been under
consideration by various bodies in the State of
New Jersey from 1896 down to the present time.
The possible solutions are the following :—
a. Separate treatment of the sewage of each
- PES PRET OER PESO ONTO
aye Te eh ES OB ao ie -
municipality and the discharge of the effluents
either into the fresh water streams within the mu-
nicipalities or into the Passaic River.
b. A joint intercepting sewer, conveying all the 20
sewage of the district to a central treatment plant, :
and the discharge of the effluent therefrom either
into Newark Bay, the Kill von Kull, or New York
Bay.
a. Separate local treatment is shown by the
evidence to have been under consideration by the
City of Paterson, the cities of Orange and East Or-
ange, the towns of Montclair and Bloomfield and
the Borough of Glen Ridge. Chapter 10 of the 30
Laws of New Jersey, Session of 1907, a copy of
; which is annexed to the bill of complaint, discloses
that every municipality within the district has the
choice of making disposal of its sewage as might
seem best to it, provided that it shall no longer dis-
charge sewage or other polluting matter into the
waters of the Passaic River after the date fixed by
statute. No compulsion is used on any of the mu-
nicipalities to join in the intercepting sewer 40
10
30
ot ne a ee ee ee ae. - nl relat at a . we o- i
project. It appears, however, by the evidence that
fifteen of the municipalities within the district exe-
cuted the contract for the construction of the sewer,
including the City of Paterson. Record, Vol. 3,
page 2625. The action of these municipalities con-
firms the obvious conclusion that the construction
and operation of individual treatment plants effi-
cient to produce an effluent fit to be discharged into
fresh water streams or into the Passaic River must
be more costly in construction and operation, and
less efficient, than the plan submitted by the Pas-
saie Valley Sewerage Commissioners.
b. There is also to be considered the question
of the place of discharge of the treatment plant to
be located on the Newark Meadows in the City of
Newark. Three possible disposals are suggested:
(1) Into the waters of Newark Bay.
~
(2) Into the Kill van Kull.
(3) Into the waters of New York Bay.
(1) A discharge into Newark Bay would mani-
festly be more economical than either of the others,
but a controiling objection is found in the fact that
the average depth of the waters of Newark Bay is
only six and one-half feet, which renders these
waters most unsuitable for the discharge of any
kind of effluent. It also appears from the testi-
mony that the United States authorities refused to
grant a permit for such a disposal.
(2) The Kill van Kull is subject to all the ob-
jections which are being raised in this suit against
New York Bay, besides additional objections be-
cause of the character, depth and tidal flow of this
body of water as compared with the waters of New
—_
13
York Bay, and because of the necessary proximity
of any discharge point to Staten Island, a part of
the State of New York, which is quite as likely to
raixe objections to this disposal as to the proposed
disposal in the neighborhood of Robbins Reef.
(3) These different disposal points have been
under discussion and adjudication in the case of
Berdan vs. Passaic Valley Sewerage Commission-
ers, 82 N. J. Equity, 235 (affirmed 83 N. J. Equity,
340). In this case an injunction was prayed against
the defendant to prevent the construction of the
outfall tunnel into New York Bay, on the ground
that it would constitute a waste of public money, it
being contended that the effluent which would pro-
duce the results required by the stipulation between
the State of New Jersey and the United States Gov-
ernment could properly, safely and economically
be discharged into the waters of Newark Bay or
the Kill van Kull. The injunction was denied by
Vice Chancellor Backes, and the denial was af.
firmed by the Court of Errors and Appeals for the
reasons given by the Vice Chancellor. The opinion
SAYS:
“It is perfectly obvious, even to the lay mind,
that New York Bay, because of its great depth
and dilution volume, constantly agitated by
strong tides and currents of great velocity, is
possessed of far greater absorbing and digest-
ing capacity and of oxidizing and mineralizing
properties than the shallow and sluggish wi-
ters of Newark Day.”
©. The character of the discharge planned and
intended to be made from the Passaic Valley Sewer
into the waters of New York Bay is not now de-
batable. Whatever doubt may arise from the alle-
10
30
40
ee ee
10
14
gations of the bill of complaint and of the answer
with respect to the character of the proposed dis-
charge has been definitely and finally eliminated by
the stipulation between the United States and the
State of New Jersey and the Passaic Valley Sewer-
age Commissioners after the intervention of the
United States in this suit, by reason of which stipu-
lation the United States applied for and was grant-
ed leave to withdraw its petition of intervention.
This stipulation will be found at different places
in the record of this case:
a. As part of the proceedings in the cause, Rec-
ord, Vol. 1, page 110.
b. Exhibit 135 for complainant, Record, Vol. 5,
page 4005,
«. Exhibits 6 and 7 for defendants, Record, Vol.
5, page 4619.
For the convenience of the Court a copy of the
stipulation is appended to this brief as “Appendix
The second general paragraph of the stipulation
reads as follows:
“Second: The Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-
missioners further agree with the United
States that in the operation of said sewer sys-
tem at all times the following results shall be
secured, either through compliance with the re-
quirements of the immediately preceding para-
graphs, or through requisite lawful additional
arrangements, viz. :
1. There will be absence in the New York
Lay of visible suspended particles coming from
the Passaic Valley sewage.
2. There will be absence of deposits objec-
—
15
tionable to the Secretary of War of the United
States in the New York Bay coming from the
Passaic Valley sewage.
3. There will be absence in the New York
Bay and its vicinity of odors due to the putre-
faction of organic matters contained in the
Passaic Valley sewage thus discharged.
4. There will be a practical abseace on the
surface of New York Bay of any grease or coior
due to the discharge of the Passaic Valley sew-
age at the dispersion area or elsewhere.
5. There will be no injury to the public
health which will be occasioned by the dis-
charge from the said sewer into the Bay of
New York in the manner proposed and no pul-
lie or private nuisance will be created thereby.
6. The absence of injurious effect from said
sewage discharge upon the property of the
United States situated in the harbor of New
York.
7. The absence of reduction in the dissolved
oxygen contents of the waters of New York
Bay, resulting from the discharge of Passaic
Valley sewage, to such an extent as to inter-
fere with major fish life.”
A comparison of the above stipulations with the
matters charged by complainant in its bill of cow-
plaint will demonstrate that the stipulations were
designed to meet the charges of the bill of com-
plaint and to overcome the objections so raised to
the proposed drainage from the Passaic Valley
sewer.
DD. While it is manifest that the legal interpre-
tation of the effect of these stipulations is a matter
for the determination of this ( ‘ourt, and not for that
of expert witnesses, and that no expert testimony
10
Pe WOE SOT OY Tyh £ REN TOY Fr 4
SOLO LDL OEE
10
"0
can establish that a public or private nuisance
was threatenec by the defendants in view of their
stipalation that “There will be no injury to the
public health which will be occasioned by the dis
charge from the said sewer inte the Bay of New
York in the manner proposed, aud no pwblic or pri-
vate neiaance will be created therehy,” WW never-
theless is of interest to note that while substantially
every expert witness for the complainant, crow
examined ax to the effect of the stipulation, was
forced to admit that an effluent producing the guar
anteed results could not he injurious to the waters
of the Ray of New Vork, some of the experts per
sisted in expressing the opinion that a nuisance
would nevertheless be created.
lt ix submited that with respect to what '&
planned and intended by the defendants with ref
erence te the discharge inte New Vork Bay, there
can hardly be conceived a more selewn declaration
of intent than that contained in this stipalation.
It ix made with the United States Government, the
supreme sovereign power having control of the
navigable waters of the Ray of New Vork. It ix
made a condition for the granting of the permit of
the United States authorities, necessary for the
construction and operation of the sewer, and the
further result of its execution was the withdrawal
of the United States ax a party to this litigation.
KE. The prodaction of an effluent by treatment of
the Passaic Valley Rewerags Comminsioners which
when discharged into New Yok Bay near Robbins
Reef will result as guarantesd in the stipulation
ix practicable, either
a. Viv the processes and devices «pecitically de-
—
17
scribed in the first general paragraph of the stipo-
lation; or
hb. By additional treatment and devices, whieh
ate known and cou be applied.
& As might be expected, the experts for the
complainant sey that the efivent required te pro
duce the guaranteed results will not be produced by
the said processes and devices. No one of them, 10
however, is able to point to an efifweat predaced
by the said processes and devices in actual opera-
tien or under conditions similar ax te quawtity of
discharge, volume of water inte which it ix dis.
charged, and diffusion aud dixpersion of discharge.
Record, Vol. 111, 1875. The example most nearly
coinciding with the conditions stated described by
complainant's witnesses jx the discharge from the
Metropoiitan Sewerage Commission's sewer in Dow. 0
tom Harber, at Net or Pedideck’s Island. While
this sewer discharges from only one outlet and
Vertically inte the waters of Bexten May, complain:
ant’s witnesses testify that the results show prac
tically ne nuiseace or objectionable feature of any
kind.
(me expert witness, however, was sworn for the
complainant, whe testified that the discharge of the
eMnent which will be produced bw the specified 3)
processes and devices will net create a nuisance in
New Vork Ray. This witness ix Radelph Hering.
He was asked, Record, Vel 111. pece IGS;
you mean to say that that vou are
the discharge of th.
E
“a
anc for a time—heow long I do net know—thi«
discharge as specified here with only slight ex-
ceptions that woul! ne dew be made in the |
course of developments, will not cause a naix- |
ance, that is, for a certain time, the length of
which I deo net knew.”
Page 2660:
“) | ask you again whether you have
changed your opinion a= to the effect of the
effuent which will be produced at the proposed
pumping station on the Newark Meadows when
discharged inte New York Bay, as to whether
it will or will net for the maximum sewage
intended to he conveyed by this sewer, will re-
sult as specified in the stipulation which ix
Complainant's exhibit Ne. 1257
“A. I dent think that it would cause a
nuisance today, just as I have stated before.
“() That maximum discharge of 300,000,
000 gallons today?
“A. That I am prepared to say today. * * *
“() Well, what I want you to answer, Mr.
Hering, if you will, is whether or not you have
changed your mind ax to the result in New
York Harber of an effluent produced as
10
pre
posed and described in Complainant's exhibit
Ne. 1235, whether it will cause a nuieance in
New Vork Harber?
“A. Not today, ax I have already stated.”
The somewhat arbitrary conclasion of the expert
witnesses of complainant with reference te the efti-
ciency of the processes and devices described in the
stipulation is contradicted -
(1) Dy the inference plainly resulting from the
stipulation itxelf, that the engineers of the United
Mates were of opinion that the said devices and
processes would in fact produce an effluent which
when discharged inte the waters of New York Tay
near Robbins Reef would result ax required by the
stipolation.
(2) By a like inference that the engineers of
the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commissioners be-
liewed that the prescribed procesees and devices
vould produce such an effluent, this opinion ap
pearing wore formally in the certificate of these
engineers, which constitutes exhibit No. 5 for the
defendant in this «uit; omitted by oversight from
the printed record, bat stipulated te be used on
the argument, a copy of which ix for the convenience
of the Court appended as “Appendix 3.~
(3) ty a like inference from the stipulation be-
tween the Unived States and the Bronx Valley § -w-
erage Commietoners of the Mate of New York,
where the same resulix are guaranteed as in the
New Jersey stipulation, ander processes to be
aheted by the Brows Valley Sewerage Commis
siemens, net specifically described, lot guaranteed
to result ina redaction of the putrescibility of the
romx Valley sewage of ten per cent. it being ad-
mitted bey the expert witnesses of the complainant
that the processes and devices described in the
New Jersey stipulation will in fact remove more
than ten per cent. of the putrescible matter from
the sewage of the Passaic Valley.
~ This stipulation ix complainant's exhibit Neo. 177,
Record, Vol. IV. page 4317, and resulted in the
discontinuance of the suit pending between the
United States and the people of the State of New
York and the Browx Valley Sewerage Commis<ion-
ers for an injuwetion against the discharge of the
10
AOL AMER ve) Tos Maas DA oh Ole
10
20
30
pai PEGA NIT EIDE
20
Bronx Valley Sewer into the waters of the Hudson
River.
(4) By the testimony of the expert witnesses of
the defendant. Of these, Wiliiam M. Brown, now
chief engineer of the Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-
missioners, was assistant chief engineer of the
Massachusetts Drainage Board from 1890 until
1895, and chief engineer from 1895 until 1912. His
testimony will be found in the record, Vol. IIL, page
2354 et seq. The sewerage works of which he had
charge provide for the main drainage of about three
hundred square miles of territory surrounding the
City of Boston and involving parts of the city itself,
and includes twenty-five separate municipalities.
The population is approximately one million in-
habitants. His practical experience certainly quali-
fies him to testify as to practical results more fully
than any or all of the theoretical experts sworn on
behalf of the complainant. It is to be noted that his
connection with the Passaic Valley Sewerage Com-
missioners began in 1912, after the approval of the
plans and execution of the stipulation between the
United States and the Passaic Valley Sewerage
Commissioners. He was asked, Record, Vol, TIT,
page 2358:
“Q. In your opinion will or will not the
effluent produced from the works there speci-
fied produce the results which are guaranteed
in the stipulation which you have before you?
“A. I think they will, ves, sir.
“Q. As compared with the effluent, or the
discharge rather, into the Boston Harbor from
the Massachusetts Metropolitan Sewerage Dis-
trict, What in your opinion is the character of
the effluent which will be produced from these
works?
21
“A. I think this effluent will be very much
more clarified as compared with anything we
handle in Massachusetts.”
Asa Henry Phillips, whose testimony will be
found, Record, Vol. III, page 2521 et seq., is the
chief engineer in charge of the sewage treatment
und disposal works of the District of Columbia.
His testimony is particularly valuable and instruc- 10
tive because of its practical character, and because
the results of treatment in the District of Colum-
bia were obtained from a treatment involving only
a fractional part of the processes required for the
Passaic Valley sewerage. He savs, Record, Vol.
IT], page 2323, in answer to the question :
i
;
/
e
:
b
'
:
“Q. What is the discharge from your sewers
into the Potomac River? 20
“A. We have never found the slightest indi-
cation of any result from the discharge of sew-
age at outfall on the shores themselves, that is,
no material can be ascribed to discharge from
the outfall, the shores are clean and entirely
free from any evidence whatever of the sewage
discharge.
“Q. What has been your observation, so far
as the appearance of the water at the point of
outfall, of the different conditions of turbidity 30
and clarity, as you observed them, so far as the
influence of the discharge of sewage is con-
cerned?
“A. The water has been so unaffected by
the discharge that in the great majority of
times it has been very difficult indeed to locate
the discharge at all, even in a boat, I mean
passing over it and searching for particular P
parts; with our upward elbow discharge of
course it makes a slight—the weight of the
water discharging would have a tendency to 40
10
20
30
22
make a slight rounding of the surface, but even
with that we find it very difficult to locate it
in the majority of times. It is free from float-
ing matter, from visible suspended material.
It is not affected in color, and there is abso-
lutely no odor so far as I have ever been able
to determine, even from « boat directly over
the point of discharge.”
The whole testimony of this witness is peculiarly
valuable from the fact that the discharge from the
sewerage system of the District of Columbia nearly
approximates the conditions required by the stipu-
lation in question.
General Henry Martyn Robert (Record, Vol. Il.
2370), for many years chief engineer of the New
York Harbor Line Board, testified that in his
opinion the volume of fresh water brought in by
each tide was more than suflicient to dilute and
disperse the sewage proposed to be discharged from
the Passaic Valley sewer, without treatment.
Samuel L. Gray (Record, Vol TIT, 2385) and
George A. Johnson (Record, Vol TL, 2445), engi-
neers and sanitarians of wide experience, both
agree With these practical witnesses in saving that
the results agreed to be produced by the eMuent
will, in fact, be produced by the processes and de-
vices described in the stipulation.
This conclusion, at least, seems to be fully justi-
fied, namely, that the probabilities are strongly in
favor of the view that the results guaranteed will
be obtained through the processes and devices spe-
cifically described in general paragraph 1 of the
stipulation in question.
b. Whatever may be the result in opreation of the
processes and devices described in general para-
graph 1 of the stipulation in question, it is clear
>
2:
that the treatment so indicated is the minimum
required from the Passaie Valley Sewerage Com-
missioners, and that if it does not produce the re-
sults guaranteed in the second general paragraph
of the stipulation the Commissioners must add the
requisite lawful additional arrangements, The
said second general paragraph of the stipulation
hegins as folows:
SATE CRE RET I NY ENO SA TY 4
10
“?
“The Passaic Valley Sewerage Comimission-
ers further agree with the United States that
in the operation of said sewer system at all q
times the following results shall be secured.
either through compliance with the require-
ments of the immediately preceding para-
graphs, or through requisite lawful additional
arrangements.”
Cross-examination of complainant's experts de- 20
veloped the fact that every one of them in his con-
sideration of the effect of the stipulation assumed
that no further treatment would be given to the
sewage than that specifically described in the stip-
ulation; and upon that assumption they all testified
on direct examination that the results guaranteed
by the Commissioners would not be produced.
Their cross-examination further developed admis-
sions on the part of all of them that there are addi- 30
tional processes known and actually in operation
which, if applied to the sewage at the treatment
works, would certainly produce an effluent of a
character to result when discharged into the waters
of New York Bay as guaranteed in the stipulation.
When asked why they exeluded the application of
additional processes they made various excuses,
Some of them professed not to understand the
meaning of the phrase “through requisite lawful 40
24
widitional arrangements,” claiming that they did
not know whet might or might not be lawful, but in
the end convicting themselves of a willful refusal to
accept the natural, reasonable and common mean-
ing of common English words. Others professed
to believe that the guaranteed results would not be
produced because om their opinion it could not be
determined whether objectionable conditions exist-
ing in the waters of New York Bay could in fact be
identified with the sewage discharged from = the
Passaic Valley sewer. Others professed to believe
that the additional treatment would not be given
because of the cost of such treatment, but were
unable to suggest any other plan of disposal of the
sewage of the district at a less cost. One of them
went so far as to say that the stipulation would not
be carried into effect for the reason that the City
of New York was not a party to it, and could not
insist upon its terms. Of the above suggestions it
is perhaps worth while to consider briefly the fol-
lowing:
(1) That the State of New Jersey and the Pas-
saic Valley Sewerage Commissioners will be un-
willing to apply additional treatment because of
the cost of such treatment.
2) Because the United States will not enforce
the stipulation.
(1) The foundation of the first suggestion is
an assumption that the State of New Jersey has
no real interest in the condition of the waters of
New York Bay; or, to put it in another way, that
New York Bay is practically admitted by New
Jersey to be the property of the State of New
York, and that the designation of it as “My Bay”
2
or “Our Bay” used by some of the witnesses for
the complainant, has a real foundation in fact.
It seems plain enough to require no argument
that the interests of the State of New Jersey in
the Bay of New York do not differ in kind and
hardly in degree from those of the State of New
York. The shore line of New Jersey on the lay
is seven miles as compared with thirteen miles for
the State of New York. The land under water to
the middle of the Bay is the territory of the State
of New Jersey. The development of the lands of
New Jersey bordering the Bay is ax important to
that State as the development of the New York
lands is to that State. Any condition created in
the waters of New York Bay which tends to in-
jue the future development of the surrounding
territory is of as much importance to the State of
New Jersey as to the State of New York. As a
matter of fact, it is bevond doubt that the inhabit-
ants of New Jersey make more actual use of New
York Bay than the inhabitants of the State of
New York.
it is added by some of the witnesses that in their
opinion the cost of the additional treatment will
be prohibitive. The use of the term “prohibitive,”
however, is found to be only relative, and is meant
to indicate that in their opinion some other methods
of disposal of the sewage of the Passaic Valley
could be adopted which would be less costiy; but
When examined as to what these other disposals
might be, are found to be unable to suggest any
which would be in any way efficient to produce the
desired result.
(2) As to the second reason suggested for the
non-performance of the stipulation, it may be said
10
20
30
10
20
that the considerations which induced the Attorney
General of the United States to intervene in this
litigation and in like manner to institute an inde-
pendent suit in this court against the State of
New York and the Bronx Valley Sewerage Com-
missioners, are unquestionably sufficiently potent
to insure prompt action on the part of the United
States in case the stipulation is violated by the
State of New Jersey or the Passaic Valley Sewer-
age Commissioners, certainly if conditions even
approximating those predieted by some of com-
plainani’s witnesses shall appear; and against any
action by the United States arising in this man-
ner the State of New Jersey and the Passaic Val-
ley Sewerage Commissioners would be without de-
fense. The permit to operate the sewer is ex-
pressiy conditioned upon the performance of the
stipulation. Failure to perform would be followed
by the withdrawal of the permit, and this in turn
would necessarily be followed by an injunction
against further operation of the sewer. No equity
could be urged in favor of the defendants in view
of the fact that the stipulation was executed be-
fore the sewer was in fact constructed or begun.
To insure the detection of even a partial failure to
perform the stipulation the third general para-
graph thereof covers visitatorial powers upon the
United Staies and its representatives, to inspect
and examine the operation of the sewer.
It is therefore submitted that the suggestions
under discussion are not worthy of serious con-
sideration. Lrietly summarizing the foregoing
discussion we submit:
1 |
(1) THAT THE AGREEMENT WITH THE
UNITED STATES GUARANTEES THAT NO
NUISANCE WILL BE PRODUCED BY THE
DISCHARGE OF THE EFFLUENT INTO THE
WATERS OF NEW YORK BAY.
(2) THAT THE STIPULATION IS CAP-
ABLE OF EXECUTION BY THE PASSAIC
VALLEY SEWERAGE COMMISSIONERS.
(3) THAT ITS EXECUTION IS ASSURED
BOTH BY THE INTERESTS OF THE STATE
OF NEW JERSEY AND BY THE CONTROL
OVER IT BY THE UNITED STATER.
F. Some facts appear in the evidence which bear
upon the practical interpretation by the States
of New York and New Jersey of the scope and
effect of the compact of 1854.
Charles A. Van Kuren, Chief Engineer of Jer-
sey City, Record, Vol. 111, page 2604 et seq., testi-
fies to the practice of Jersey City in constructing
sewers emptying into the waters of New York
Bay without request for any permit from the State
of New York or any claim on the part of the State
of New York of jurisdiction over such discharge.
Thomas H. McCann, a civil engineer having had
experience with the sewers of Hoboken, Record,
Vol. ILL, page 2608, testifies that New York City or
State never asserted the right to control the dis-
charge into New York Bay on the New Jersey side
within a period of practically forty-three years.
Jolin Payne, secretary and engineer of the State
Board of Riparian Commissioners of New Jersey,
Record, Vol. III, page 2612, testified to the con-
trol by the State of New Jersey over the lands
under water in New York Bay, including grants
10
20
to the United States, the fixing of lines of solid
filling, the granting of the fee of the lands under
water to private individuals and corporations, and
the filling of the lands to the lines of solid filling
fixed by the Riparian Commissioners; that ne per-
mit or approval was ever asked or received from
the State of New York, that ne remonstrances
from the State of New York or any municipal body
in that State have ever been made.
This practice, extending over a great many years,
indicates a practical interpretation of the legal
effect of the compact of 1834, which accords with
the effect of the decisions cited in this brief in the
discussion of the legal aspects of the case.
(3) COMPLAINANT HAS NO STANDING
IN THIS COURT TO ASK OR RECEIVE
EQUITABLE RELIEF FOR THE REASON
THAT IT DOES NOT COME INTO THIS
COURT WITH CLEAN HANDS.
Three commissions appointed by the State of
New York, the first in 1903, have busied them-
selves for more than ten years and expended more
than one hundred and thirty-five thousand dollars
in accumulating data, scientific and otherwise, re-
lating to the waters of New York Harbor, includ-
ing therein the Hudson River, the East River, the
Harlem River, Upper New York Bay, Lower New
York Bay, New Town Creek, Jamaica Bay, Graves
end Bay, the Gowanus Canal, the Kill von Kull,
the Arthur Kill, Newark Bay and the Passaic
River. The whole of this matter, including the
reports of each of the Commissioners, for the most
part immaterial, irrelevant and inadmissible, has
been emptied bodily into this case, resulting in
what counsel for the complainant terms an “En-
cyclopaedic Record,” but which we humbly sub-
mit is a record remarkable only in extent, bewilder-
ing in detail, and for the most part valueless in
determining the issues in this cause. The record
in fact is inexcusably loaded down with complain-
ant’s expert scientific determinations of the salinity
of the waters of New York Harbor, their bacterial
content, determinations of the amount of free oxy-
gen in the waters, the presence and chemical prop-
erties of the muds in the Harbor, the directions
and continuance of currents in the water, and
various other observations, all of which undoubt-
edly have an interest, if net a value, in scientific
libraries, but de pot in fact help in any wey to
the determination of the issues in this cause. This
scientific data is in fact only a translation into
technical terms of the results of the admitted acts
of the complainant, which Professor Winslow, the
witness for the complainant, Record, Vol. LL, page
1644, says resulis as follows:
“New York Harbor now receives nine hun-
dred million gallons of sewage per day from
about six million people. This equals a sew-
age river thirteen miles long, one hundred feet
wide and eighteen feet deep. This volume of
sewage deposits fifteen hundred tons of solid
material daily. There is now general pollu.
tion of New York Harbor waters. and very
great local pollution in certain areas.”
It further appears from the testimony of com-
plainant’s witness, Record, Vol. III, page 1767,
that of the sewage entering New York Harbor
ninety per cent. is contributed by the City of New
10
20
10
vO
York. It is further testified by complainaat’s wit-
nemes, Record, Vel. 11, pages 1550, 1620, that the
City of New Vork is discharging thix vast 4nantity
of sewage without treatment of any kind, even
rough screening, at the most objectionable points
porsible for its discharge, the only excuse for which
ix the saving of the cost of a proper discharge. The
textimeny ix, Record, Vol. 11, page 1209, that all
of the sewage ix discharged at a point not lower
than low water in the Harber, in part inte the
slips, in port at the pier heads, in some cases di.
rectly ander piers axed for recreation purposes in
the summer time, at points either adjoining or
near to free public hathing extablishments, at others
near oyeter beds, from which oysters are taken for
food, and that the result of this course of procedure
be the City of New York has rendered bathing in
the waters of New York Bay, the Hodson, Rast and
Harlem Rivers, not only revolting, but dangerows,
hae contaminated the oveter beds of the Harber te
such an extent that most of them have been aban
doned, has rendered the major edible fieh unfit for
conmmption, se that the “erudite” Professor
Sedgwick, Record, Vol. 111, page 2256, is compelled
to say:
“That it ix not only a disgusting, but a dan-
gerous condition, when Manhattan Ixland or
Staten Island or Coney Island ix in fact, ax
hax often been said, ‘A bedy of land surreand.
ed by sewage”
Testimony (xs cited wader Part V of this brief
given by complainant's wi inesses of the results of
professional investigation of the conditions of the
waters of the Madson River, New Vork Kay, the
Kast River, the Harlem River, the Gowanus Canal
awd New fown Creek, which discloses such revolt.
ing conditions created by the City of New Vork ax
to be aheeet anheliewatle, All of the conditions
predicted as likely to result from the discharge of
Passaic Valley sewage at Robbins Keef being terti-
fied to as existing in the most exaggerated form in
the waters immediately surrounding all the shores
of the greater city of New York. 11 can be confident
Iv stated that the complainant's own record in this
vase establishes beyond question that the City of
New Vork hae swintained for many years and is
new maintaining «a public and private nuisence
within the waters of New Vork May, which extends
its influence inte the waters within the territorial
limits of the Ptate of New Jersey, With a lrtle
alteration we adept the language ef complain: ut's
wrief in this case, fond on page 40, and aay :
“This revelling prectiee (echeme) which
‘ tes) inendates (imendating) the
ny population in our
with septic filth, not only menaces with
lence the health and of our cVigens bat
strikes fatally at the commercial
of the greatest port of entry on American
continent.”
Vv.
The Law.
(1) COMPLAINANT 18 NOT ENTITLED TO
AN INJUNCTION AGAINST THE DEFUND.
ANTS UNDER THE DECISIONS OF THE
COURTS, AND IN VIEW OF THE PROOrs \s
TO THE CTLARACTER OF THE ACTS INTUND.
ED RY THE DEFENDANTS WHICH ARE
FOUGHT TO BE EXJOLNED.
(2) COMPLAINANT 18 NOT ENTITLED TH
AN INJUNCTION AGAINST THE DEPENT
ANTS UNDER THE COMPACT OF Ist, EE
TWEEN THE ®TATES OF NEW YORK AND
NEW JERSEY.
10) (3) COMPLAINANT 18 NOT ENTITLED To
AN INJUNCTION. AGAINST THE DEFEND.
ANTS BECAUSE OF THE CHARACTER OF
ITs OWN ADMITTED ACTS IN THE PREM
IXES.
4) THE PREMIT ITED To THE DE
PENDANT. THE PASSAIC VALLEY SEWER
AGE COMMISMIONERS, GY THE UNITED
STATEX GOVERNMENT Is THE EXERCIAE
20 or A SUPERIOR SOVEREIGN giGHrT,
WHICH Is NOT SURIRCT TO ATTACK BY
THE COMPLAINANT.
(1) Upon bills te enjoin acts alleged to threat
en irremedialle damage to complainants, the law
requires the following comditions to be shown
(High on Ia jenctions, Section 742):
30 “Where the injery complained of ix net per
«a fuixenee, bot wey or may fet become se
according to circumstances, and when it ix
uneertain, indefinite er contingent, or pre
ductive of only possible injary, equity will met
interfere.”
In Wolcott wa, Welliek, 11 N. 4. Bq. D4 C2.
the Court save:
“If the euieanece ix admitted of if the eree-
40 tien contemplated must from ite character
neceoerily be a noice to the ~~
and his legal remedy is net adequate, the Court
will enjoin it.”
Newark Aqeedect Raard =. Passaic GN. 4.
iq. 908 (02).
ta Verges vs Cita of Hivwhewten, 7 NE.
Rep C24 (Cert of Appeals of New Vert
it was held that an injunction should mot be granted 10
against the const rection of a sewer by a city where
the injery complained of ix that in the course of
teoer three vears the sewage dixcharged therefrom
jute the river may he se imereased as to be depesited
apen lew grewnd belonging te the petitioner, Iving
aleng the rivet, and so poisening and infecting the
air, Pinch, 4, save:
“The findings plainly disco two character. 20
isties of the apprehended danger. Ut ix not im-
minent and it ix whelly contingent and not
inevitable, Neo imuediate danger exiets, It ix
found to be posible within one of two rears,
bet wet certain te occur sooner than in three
years”
In Roth wa The Village of La Grang, t2
NE. Rep. 77 ep. Conrt of TL
on Will brought by an owner of land to enjoin the 30
construction of a sewer by the village, threatening
injory te Wie lewd, Craig, 4. mare:
“The real question in the case, then, iss hether
the evidence ix suflicient to extablish a noie
auee, Tf the evidence of the complainant was
considered alewe it might be regarded as suf.
ficient to sustain the bill, bet a large namher of
Vines were intredeced! of behalf of the
defemlania, whe testify there ix no smell or 40
34
stench arising from the sewer. There is, there-
fore, so much conflict in the evidence that we
are unable to hold the allegations of the bill
proven by such clear and satisfactory evidence
as is required in a case of this character where
a nuisance has not been established by a judg-
ment in an action at law. * * * It will be
observed, however, that this bill was brought
before the sewer was completed, and at the
time of the trial it may not have been in opera-
tion long enough to determine fully whether it
would result in a nuisance or not. Under such
circumstances we think the bill should have
been dismissed without prejudice.”
In Butler vs. Rogers, 9 Nd. Equity, AST, it was
held that the Court ought not to interfere in cases
of nuisance where the injury apprehended is of a
character to justify conflicting opinions whether the
injury in fact will ever be realized.
In Harrison vs. Brooks, 20 Ga., 537, the Court
held that injunctions to restrain nuisances will only
he granted in cases of absolute necessity, in which
the evil to be prevented is not only possible, but
certain and inevitable.
In Holton vs. Doylestoin, 4 Brewster, 833 (Pa.),
it was held that if the injury be doubtful or con-
tingent, or if the matter complained of is not ipso
facto a nuisance or will become such in operation,
an injunction will not be granted, and it lies upon
the plaintiff to establish his case upon satisfactory
proof, which does not consist of the opinions of wit-
nesses. To the same effect is Pfingst vs. Senn, 2
NS. W., 358 (Ky.).
We submit that the case of VWissouri vs. [1linois,
200 US. (26. US. Sup. Ct. Rep. 268) is controlling
in this litigation. It is as to matters of law as well
35
as matters of fact on all fours with the present con-
troversy. The suit in that case was brought by the
State of Missouri to restrain the discharge of the
sewage of Chicago through an artificial channel into
the Des Plaines River in the State of Hlinois. That
river empties into the Ilinois River, and the lat-
ter empties into the Mississippi River at a point
about forty-three miles above the City of St. Louis,
Missouri. It was alleged in the bill that the result
of the threatened discharge would be to send fifteen
hundred tons of poisonous filth daily into the Mis-
sissippi, to deposit great quantities of the same
upon the bed of the last-named river belonging to
the plaintiff, and so to poison the water of that
river, upon which various of the plaintiff's cities,
towns and inhabitants depended, as to make it unfit
for drinking, agricultural or manufacturing pur-
poses. It is to be noted that the Chicago drainage
canal diverts the sewage of the City of Chicago from
its natural point of discharge and transfers it into
an entirely distinet watershed, discharging it into
fresh waters used by the municipalities of Missouri
for drinking purposes as well as other uses,
The injunction was denied. Justice Holmes, de-
livering the opinion, says:
“Before this court ought to intervene the
case should be of serious magnitude, clearly
and fully proved, and the principle to be ap-
plied should be one which the Court is pre-
pared deliberately to maintain against all con-
siderations on the other side. See Kans, vs.
Colo, 185 UL 8., 125; 46 L. Ed., 888; 22 Sup.
Ct. Rep., 552.
“As to the principle to be laid down, the eau-
tion necessary is manifest. It is a question of
the first magnitude whether the destiny of the
10
30
nee |
RET?
TERA RY Ty
POR,
PEST Te de ee
36
great rivers is to be the sewers of the cities
along their banks, or to be protected against
everything which threatens their purity. To
decide the whole matter at one blow by an
irrevocable fiat would be at least premature.”
Applying the principles of law laid down in the
cases cited to the proofs in this case, it will be found
that no one of the requirements of the cases is made
by the proofs in this case. The creation of a nuis-
ance is not admitted, but is in fact denied. The
works contemplated will not from their character
necessarily be a nuisance to the complainant, but
on the contrary, upon the admission of its own wit-
nesses, can be operated so as to produce no nuis-
ance, When there is added the undisputed fact that
the stipulation between the United States and de-
fendants in this cause, if carried into effect, as the
witnesses for the complainant testify it can in fact
be carrjed into effect, will result in conditions in no
way harmful to the complainant, no basis is estab-
lished for the granting of the injunction prayed for
by the complainant.
2) The location of the proposed outlet in New
Yerk Bay is concededly about one-half mile west of
the boundary lines between the States of New York
and New Jersey. As we shall see, and as is well
known to the Court, the settlement of that boun-
dary line was a matter of agreement between the
two states in 1833, owing to the fact that there were
no means of locating this boundary line, Joint
Commissioners were appointed in New York and
New Jersey respectively, the latter pursuant. to
joint resolution approved February 14, 1888, and
found in the Pamphlet Laws of New Jersey for that
3T
Year on page doz, authorizing the Governor of New
Jersey :
“To appoint three Commissioners with pow-
er on the part of the State to meet any authori-
ties of the State of New York, and with them
locate and mark out by reference to permanent
landmarks, monuments or buoys, the boundary
line between the two states in lands under
water in the Hudson River, New York Bay,
Kill von Kull Sound and Arthur Kill or Staten
Island Sound.”
Pursuant to this authority it-is admitted that the
line was fixed as portrayed upon Defendant's Ex-
hibit No. 4, Record, p. 4619. The line is a heavy
black line running generally north and south from
a point designated on the map as K. or A. A. to J.
(Record, p. 2613.)
Inasmuch as the complainant, both in its bill of
complaint and its brief, relies upon some alleged
peculiar rights that the State of New York claimed
by it in the locus in quo, it is necessary that we
briefly narrate the facts touching this boundary
line.
Owing to the descriptions that were contained in
the Grants by the Crown to the Provinces now
known as New York and New Jersey respectively,
disputes arose almost immediately after the organi-
zation of the Government of the United States un-
der the present Constitution as to the exact boun-
dary line between the two states. The history of
these disputes appears in several of the cases here-
after referred to, notably Central RB. R. Co, y. Jer-
sey City, 70 N.S. 1, 81, and In re Deroe Manufae-
turing Co, in this Court, 108 US8., 401. The diiter-
ences had become so acute that an original bill was
10
30
40
aa
38
filed in this Court by the State of New Jersey
against the State of New York in 1828, secking an
adjudication. This led to the appointment of Com-
missioners in both states, pursuant to legislative
authority passed therein, who, after full considera-
tion, joined in an agreement or treaty which subse-
quently received the sanction of the Legislatures of
the respective states, and of Congress, See Laws
of New York for U834, chap. 8, p. 85 lacs of New
Jersey for 1834, p. 118; Aet of Congress, June 2%,
1834, 4 Statutes, 70%.
A copy of this compact is attached to the bill of
complaint herein, and for convenience is appended
to this brief as “Appendix 4.° The significant pro-
visions are Articles First and Third, reading as
follows:
“Article first. The boundary line between
the two States of New York and New Jersey,
from a point in the middle of Hudson River
opposite the point on the west shore thereof,
in the forty-first degree of north latitude, as
heretofore ascertained and marked, to the main
sea, shall be the middle of the said river, of the
ay of New York, of the waters between Staten
Island and New Jersey, and of Raritan Bay, to
the main sea, except as hereinafter otherwise
particularly mentioned.
“Article third. The State of New York
shall have and enjoy exclusive jurisdiction of
and over all the waters of the Bay of New York, |
and of and over all the waters of Hudson River
lving west of Manhattan Island and to the
south of the mouth of Spuyten Duyvel Creek,
and of and over the lands covered by the said
waters to the low-water mark on the westerly
or New Jersey side thereof; subject to the fol-
lowing rights of property and of jurisdiction of
the State of New Jersey, that is to say: |
39
(1) The State of New Jersey shall have
the exclusive right of property in and to the
land under water lying west of the middle of
the Bay of New York and west of the middle
of that part of the Iludson River which lies be-
tween Manhattan Island and New Jersey.
(2) The State of New Jersey shall have
the exclusive jurisdiction of and over the
wharves, docks and improvements made, and
to be made, on the shore of the said State, and
of and over all vessels aground on said shore
or fastened to any such wharf or dock; except
that the said vessels shall be subject to the
quarantine or health laws and laws in relation
to passengers, of the State of New York, which
now exist or which may hereafter be passed.
(3) The State of New Jersey shall have the
exclusive right of regulating the fisheries on
the westerly side of the middle of the said
waters, provided that the navigation be not
obstructed or hindered.”
This agreement, having received the highest pos-
sible sanction, has been construed by the highest
courts of both of the contracting states, and by this
Court, and any confusion arising from its phraseol-
ogy has been entirely cleared away by these deci-
sions, to which we shall briefly refer. The earliest
of these decisions is Ntate v. Babcock, 30 N. Jd. 1.,
29, decided in 1862, the opinion of which, having
been written by Justice Elmer, is entitled to con-
siderable weight, ax he was one of the New Jersey
Commissioners who negotiated and signed the
treaty. There an indictment was found in the New
York courts for obstructing the Hudson River by a
nuisance west of the boundary line established by
the treaty. Justice Elmer, speaking of the treaty,
SAYS:
10
20
30
2A. ET IRIN INA BI RELI TRE IRI ERG NT I Oe I 4
warner
Ssevever"s
10
20
30
40
40
“Although for some purposes, New Jersey is
bounded by the middle of the Iludson River,
and the State owns the land under the water
to that extent, exclusive jurisdiction, not only
over the water, but over the land to the low
water line on the New Jersey shore, is in plain
and unmistakable language, granted to, or
rather acknowledged to belong to the State of
New York. There is no reason to doubt that
the tribunals-of that State, which have a com-
mon interest in preventing all obstrtietions to
the navigation of the waters surrounding their
most important city, will not only punish all
crimes against our citizens or their own, while
in or upon those waters, but will also ade-
quately punish all interference with the navi-
gation. The case does not materially differ
from a line between two states on the land
which happens to be the scene of a busy popu-
lation, where a manufactory near to that line,
in one State, may be a nuisance to the citizens
of the other, whose redress will have to be ob-
tained from the tribunals of the State in which
the nuisance is situate.”
He adds:
“When the Commissioners of New Jersey
and New York again met, in 1833, and it was
found that those of the latter State appeared
to be desirous of arranging the dispute upon
fair and liberal terms, but deemed it indispen-
sable that their great commercial emporium
should have the exclusive control of the police
on the surrounding waters, and full power to
establish such quarantine regulations as should
he found necessary, the Commissioners of this
State deemed it wise to secure the exclusive
property in the soil to the middle of the river,
amd exclusive jurisdiction over the wharves,
docks and other improvements made or to be
made on the Jersey shore, and of the vessels
41
fastened thereto and the right to regulate the
adjacen’ fisheries, leaving to New York, which
was thought to be quite as much a burthen as
a privilege, the exclusice jurisdiction orer the
offences in or upon the waters or the land cov-
ered by the water outside of the low water
mark.”
The question next arose in New York, in the
case of People vy. Central R. RB. Co, of N. d., 42%.
Y. 283 (1870), where a decision of importance was
rendered reversing the lower court.
The action was commenced by the Attorney Gen-
eral of New York, to abate as nuisances certain
wharves, piers, and other structures placed by the
defendant Railroad Company in the Harbor of
New York, and extending into the Hudson River
about a mile from the New Jersey shore, all of
which structures were confessedly west of the
boundary line as established by the treaty, It was
claimed by the Attorney General, and by the court
below, that the effect of the treaty was to bestow
upon New York State the vight to entertain juris-
diction ef the action, and the lower court directed
the removal of the structures and the abatement
of the alleged nuisance created thereby. The
opinion says:
“The cause of action set forth in the com-
plaint is clearly one of equitable cognizance ;
and as the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court
is coextensive with the boundaries of the State,
it clearly had jurisdiction of stich cause of ac-
tion, if the place where the nuisances com-
plained of were erected and existed iras with
in the territorial limits of the State.”
10
42
It then proceeds, after showing that the pro-
priety of the decision below depended upon the
agreement or treaty between the States, critically
to examine the agreement, and reached the con-
clusion that the New York courts had no jurisdic-
tion or rights in the premises. The whole opinion
is important, but for brevity we quote the follow-
ing:
“Whatever doubt may have existed before
upon the subject immediately upon the adop-
tien and ratification of this convention or ;
treaty, the sovereiguty and jurisdiction of the
respective States extended and attached to that
portion of the said river and other waters as-
signed to each State respectively by said article
up to the line of the boundary therein fixed and
established. * * *
“The right of absolute sovereignty, which in-
cludes all the powers of government, all the
authority, executive, judicial and legislative,
which the several States possess and exercise,
subject to the constitutional supremacy of the
national government, doubtless belongs to New
Jersey, over the domain and territory of said
State. This right of governmental control may
doubtless be moditied by compact between the
States. And this brings us te the inquiry, how
far, if at all, the State of New Jersey had made
a binding prevision by treaty for the cession
and extinguishment of any of her territorial
or governmental rights to the State of New
York, over the waters or land referred to in
said treaty. * * *
“It is quite apparent, I think, that they well
and wisely considered that the necessities of
the case, the welfare of these States, the exi-
43
gencies of the commerce, and the interests of
the city and port of New York in particular,
in whose prosperity, as the commercial me-
tropolis of the country, New Jersey had, in a
large degree, a common interest, required that
there should be a unity of control over said
waters, and a single aud exclusive juris¢dic-
tion exercised over them by one of the said
States. And this control or jurisdiction, in
the language used in that treaty or agreement,
was very properly conceded to this State in the
following Article:
“Article 3. “The State of New York shall
have and enjoy exclusive jurisdiction of and
over all the waters of the Bay of New Yerk,
and of and over all the waters of Hudson River
lying west of Manhattan Island and to the
south of the mouth of Spuyten Duyvil Creek,
and of and over the lands covered by said
waters to low water mark on the westerly or
New Jersey side thereof, subject to the follow-
ing rights of property and of jurisdiction of
the State of New Jersey.” This provision in
the treaty most clearly and distinetly gives and
grants to and vests in the State of New York,
full, complete and undoubted control, gorera-
ment and jurisdiction of and over all the waters
therein mentioned. Such was the clear intent
and purpose of this provision; and, se far as
it was essential to the proper exercise of such
jurisdiction, it gives a control also of and over
the land covered by such waters. It doubtless
was designed in the clause of said provision in
these words: ‘Of and over the lands covered
by the said waters to low water mark,’ to dis-
embarrass the jurisdiction so conferred over
the said water, from all pretense of right to
interfere therewith arising from the legal
maxim, that the owner of the soil owned all
10
Tee OR perm iotew
44
above it, cajex ext solam ext waque ad coclam
ho that the jurisdiction over the water showkd
be absolute and unquestioned for all practical
purposes.
“Lt clearly could net have been the intention
in these words to recede to New Vork what
had just been relinquished in respect te the
boundary between the two States in the first
article or to wollify the force of such article:
for it declares expressly that the right« ever
the water so granted were subject te the right.
of property and of jurisdiction of the State of
New Jersey, following :
“Firs, That the State of New Jersey shall
have the exclusive right of property in and te
the land under the water lying west of the
middie of the Bay of New York, and west of
the middle of that part of Hudson River which
lies between Manhattan Island and New Jer-
“ey.
“Second, That the State of New Jersey
shall have exclusive jurisdiction of and over
the wharves, decks and improvements made
and te be made on the shore of seid State, and
of and over all vessels aground on said shore,
or fastened to any such wharf or dock, except
that the said vessels shall be subject te the
quarantine or health laws in relation to pas
sengers of the State of New York, which now
exist or which may hereafter be passed.
“Third, The State of New Jersey shall have
the exclusive right of regulating the fisheries
on the westerly side of the micdle of nail
waters, provided that the navigat.en he net ob-
structed or hindered,
“These provisions clearly show that it was
net the intention of New Jersey, in giving
—
5
jurisdiction to New York over the waters of .
such State, to relinquish any of the important
rights of property which were acquired by or
conceded im the first article of the said .
iwatr, * * *
“It was this very claim and the legal rights
and consequences resulting from it, if allowed,
which New Jersey had long resisted. This was 10 ;
in legal effect renounced and abandoned by
thix State in the first article of said treaty;
awd New Jersey ax a sovereign, independent,
coequal state, acquired thereby, if «he did not
before poses, all the rights of proprictorship
in said river and bay west of the center thereof
possessed by this State cast of the same center
for © © ©
“The remaining articles of said agreement,
all fairly considered, condace to the same con- 20
| struction, and confirm the view that the Juris
diction conferred woo this State over the
waters of said river and bay wax a qualified
and limited jurisdiction conferred for police
| and sanitary purposes, and to promote the
interests of commerce in the wee and nariga-
tion of said waters, and wan not desiqned to
confer or create control over the lands or do-
mains of New Jersey, or to give to this State
any right te interfere with her complete po- 30
litical or governmental jurisdiction as a sev-
° ereign State of and over her own soil, and its
appurtenances, and of and over every descrip:
tien of property of any appreciable value with-
in her territorial limit«.”
The result was that the judgment of the lower
| court was reversed and the complaint ordered to be
; slixinissed.
In Perqueon V. Row, 126 N.Y. 450 (1801), the
Court of Appeals gave unanimous approval to the
case of People ©. Central RB. RB. Co., supra, There
an action was commenced by an officer called the
Shere Inepector, appointed by the Governor of New
York porsnant to express legislative authority in
an act te prevent deposits of a certain character in
the North or East Rivers, or in the Bay of New
York “within the jurisdiction of the Btate of New
York.” The deposit in question had admittedly
heen made by the defendant in the waters of the
River on the New Jersey side opposite the City of
New York. The court sustained the jurisdiction,
saving :
“By the compact entered inte between New
York and New Jersey, the particulars
of whieh are set forth in the opinion in that
case, the middie of the North River wax de-
claved to be the bowndary between the two
states; but by the third article exclusive juris
diction of and over all the waters of the Bay
of New Vork and of the Hudson River lying
west of Manhattan Island and to the south of
Spayten Duyvil creek, and of and over the
lands covered by said waters to low-water
mark on the New Jersey side thereof, was
ceded to the State of New York, reserving to
the State of New Jersey jurisdiction of
wharves, docks and piers on the Jersey here.
The purpose of vesting exclusive jurisdiction
over these waters, in the State of New York,
was to promote the interests of commerce ond
navigation, which would, as supposed. be bewt
vobserved by giving to this State the exclusive
control and redulation of the waters of the bay
and harbor of New York.”
The subject received comprehensive and intelli-
gent comideration by the New Jersey courts in
Crntral 8. of Nd. we. devecy City, 70 N. dL.
“1. The opinion of the Supreme Court there re
porte! was affirmed by the Court of Errors and
Appeals for the reasons given by Justice Garrison
in the Supreme Court, 72 N. 4. Law, 311. It is
difieunlt to make any sati«factory excerpts from
thix able opinion, which «howl! be read in toto.
Ilere the Central Railread Company of New
Aevees (the seme company that was defendant in
the caxe of People ¥. Ccutral 2. 2. Co., 42 N. Y.
283. evpray sought te excape taxation apen lands
owned twoit bet tving ander the water« of the
Iiucdses Hiver in Jersew City, and lerated, of course,
west of the hewndary line, The effect of thin de-
rete
] The acreement of 1835 between the com-
mixieners representing the States of New Jer
“y and New York, having heen confirmed by
the legishature of those states, respret tively, ane
approved bw the congress of the United Btates,
extablished the boundary line between this
Miate and the State of New York in the middle
of the Haden iver and of the as of New
York
2 The swereignty of the State of New
Jersey is coextensive with the territorial limits
thes extablisherl, subject only te such excep
tions and te such extraterritorial jurisdiction
ax was by the «wid agreement conceded to the
State of New Vork.
3%. The word “jurisdiction” ix not used in
article 3 of thie agreement in the sense of
severcignty.
10
20
*”
10
20
40
RNS <he » D4
48
After a full review and consideration of the
treaty, as well as the New York decisions referred
to, the opinion concludes :
“From these considerations, the conclusions
reached are that the agreement of 1833. he-
tween the commissioners representing — the
states of New Jersey and New York, having
been confirmed by their respective legislatures
and approved by the congress of the United
States, established the boundary line between
this State and the State of New York in the
middle of the Hudson River and of the Bay
of New York, and that the sovereignty of the
State of New Jersey is coextensive with the
territorial limits thus established, subject only
to such extra-territorial jurisdiction of a jurt-
dical character as was Ww the said compact
conceded to the State of New York, from which
it results that the sovereign power of taxation
over all the teritory thus defined resides in the
State of New Jersey.”
The decision, therefore, sustained the taxability
of the lands by the authorities of New Jersey, hold
ing that the sovereign right of taxation undoubt-
edly existed in that State of the lands lying west of
the boundary line. Upon this particular point the
opinion says:
“The question is one of first impression, be-
ing entirely distinct from the right to exercise
civil or criminal jurisdiction which has hither-
to been the only aspect in which the compact
has been presented for judicial consideration.
With respect to the right last mentioned,
namely, that of administering jurisprudence
over the territory declared by the compact of
eve
SP ARR SPARE BONE BSAA ITD AE Re hed oh ae SO EA OS
49
1833 to be within the boundaries of the State
of New Jersey, it was held by this court, in the
case of Slate v. Babcock, 1 Vroom 29, that an
indictment for a nuisance by placing wrecks in
the Hudson River below low water mark on
the New Jersey shore would not lie in’ this
State, upon the ground that by the compact in
question exclusive jurisdiction over offences
in or upon the said waters or the Jand under 16
them resided in the State of New Yerk. Later,
the Court of Appeals of the State of New York,
in the case of People vy. Central Raijroad of
New Jersey, 42 N.Y. 285, held that the courts t
of New York had no jurisdiction to abate by
injunction nuisances extending out into the
bay or river from the New Jersey shore, upon
the ground that by the compact in question the
jurisdiction conferred upon New York over the
waters of the bay and river was a qualified and 20
limited jurisdiction for police and sanitary
purposes, or to protect the interests of com- .
merce, and was not designed to give to New :
York any right to interfere with the complete §
political or governmental jurisdiction of New ;
Jersey as a sorercign State over her own soil ¢
and its appurtenances, and of and over every $
description of property within her territorial f
‘ limits, which ruling was followed by the seme '
court in 1891, in the case of Ferguson v. Ross, 30 :
126 N.Y. 459."
R
| This case was brought by writ of error to this
court, and the judgment of the New Jersey courts
sustaining the tax was here affirmed. Central PR.
r R. of N. J. rv. Jersey City, 209 U.S, 473. The
opinion of Mr. Justice Holmes ably and succinetly
analyzes the significout portions of the treaty :s
follows: 40
Sere Stes.
)
ee
ee eS ~we _
“By Article I the boundary line between
the two States from a point above the land in
dispute is to be the middle of the Hudson River,
of the Bay of New York, of the water between
Staten Island and New Jersey, ete., ‘except
as hereinafter otherwise particularly men-
tioned. By Article Il New York retains its
present jurisdiction over Bedlow’s and Ellis
10 Islands, and exclusive jurisdiction over certain
other islands in the waters mentioned. By
Article 111 New York is te have ‘exclusive
jurisdiction of and over all the waters of the
Bay of New York and of and over all the
waters of the Hudson River lying west of Man-
hattan Island and to the south ‘of the above
mentioned point, and of and over the land
covered by the said waters to the low water |
mark on the westerly or New Jersey side there- |
20 of, subject to the following rights of property
and jurisdiction of the State of New Jersey,
that is to say: 1. The State of New Jersey
shall have the exclusive right of property in
and to the land under water lying west of the
middle of the Bay of New York, and west of
the middle of that part of the Hudson River
which lies between Manhattan Island and New
Jersey. 2. New Jersey is to have exclusive
jurisdiction over wharves, docks and impreve-
30 ments made or to be made on its shore and
over vessels aground or fastened there, subject
to the quarantine and passenger laws of New
York. 3. New Jersey is to have the exelu-
sive right of regulating the fisheries on the
west of the middle of said waters, providing
that navigation be not obstructed or hindered.”
He adds:
40 “Thus the land which has been taxed is on
De ee weg 4
OTE A ALIN eect A Oi IE
51
the New Jersey side of the boundary line but
under the ‘exclusive jurisdiction’ of New York,
subject to the exclusive right of property in
New Jersey and the limited jurisdiction and
authority conferred by the paragraphs sum-
med up. The question is which of these pro-
Visions governs the right to tax. It appears
to us plain on the face of the agreement that
the dominant fact is the establishment of the
houndary line. The boundary line is the line
of sovereignty, and the establishment of it is
not satisfied but is contradicted by the sug-
gestion that the agreement simply gives the
ownership of the land under water on the New
Jersey side to that State as a private owner
of land lying within the State of New York.
On the contrary, the provision as to exclusive
right of property in’ the compact between
States ix to be taken primarily to refer to ulti-
mate sovereign rights, in pursuance of the set-
tlement of the territorial limits, which was
declared to be one purpose of the agreement,
and ix not to be confined to the assertion and
recognition of a private claim, which, for all
that appears, may have been inconsistent with
titles already acerued and which would lose
significance the moment that New Jersey sold
the land. We repeat that boundary means
sovereignty, since in modern times sovereignty
ix mainly territorial, unless a different mean-
ing clearly appears.
It is said that a different meaning does ap-
pear in the Article (IIT) that gives New York
exclusive jurisdiction over this land as wel) as
the water above it. But we agree with the
state courts that have been called on to con-
strue that part of the agreement that the pirr-
pose was to promote the interests of commerce
and nerigation, not to take hack the ser-
10
20
30
40
AEP LLG ORE EE MONIT CRN NIT Fy
10
30
40
at aap
52
ereignty that otherwise was the consequence
of Article 1. This is the view of the New York
as well as of the New Jersey court of errors
and appeals, and it would be a strange result
if this court should be driven to a different
conclusion from that reached by both the par
ties concerned. Ferguson v. Ross, 126 a. Be
159, 463; People v. Central R. R. C0., 42 Ae
283. This opinion is confirmed by the judg-
ment delivered by one of the commissioners in
State v. Babcock, 1 Vr. 2%. Again, as was
pointed out by the state court, the often ex-
pressed purpose of the appointment of the
commissioner and of the agreement to settle
the territorial limits and jurisdiction must
mean by territorial limits sovereignty, and by
jurisdiction something less. It is suggested
that jurisdiction is used in a broader sense
in the second article, and that may be true se
far as concerns Bedlow’s and Ellis Islands.
But the provision there is that New York shall
retain its ‘present’ jurisdiction over them, and
would seem on its face simply to be intended
to preserve the status quo ante, whatever it
may be.
Throughout nearly all the articles of the
agreement, other than those in controversy,
the word jurisdiction obviously is used in a
more limited sense. The word has occurred in
other cases where a river was a boundary. and
in the Virginia Compact was held to mean,
primarily at least, Jurisdictio authority to
apply the law to the acts of men, Wedding v.
Meyler, 192 U. 8. 574, 584. Whether in the
case at bar some power of police regulation
also was conferred upon New York, as held in
Ferguson v. Ross, need not be decided now.
That New Jersey retained the sovereignty.
however, seems to be assumed in Article TI
aie ceeeeeeiees -
2) giving ber exclusive jurisdiction over
wharves, docks and improvements, made and
‘to be made” on the shore. This does not grant
the right to make such improvements, but ax-
sumes it to exist. But the right would need
the permission of New York, except on the
hypothesis that New Jersey had sovereign
power over the place.”
° 10
XThe use of tidal waters for the disposal of
has been exhaustively discussed and determine
@ sovereign right by the Court of Errors and
of New Jersey.
Sayre vs. llewark, 60 J. J. Equity, 561.
socus iH quo.
Taking the conclusion of this ceart in the above
case that the jurisdiction granted to the State of 20
New York by the compact in question was a limited
one, the purpose of which was to promote the in-
terests of commerce and navigation as conclusive
in this case, we submit that the bill of complaint
and the evidence fail to disclose any attempt on
the part of New York State to make regulations
for the promotion of the interests of commerce and
navigation, or any acts on the part of the defend-
ants in violation of such regulations, or injurious
to the interests in question.
The provisions of Section 75 of the Public Health
Law, annexed to the bill of complaint as “Schedule
1)” Record, page 23, obviously has no application
in this suit, as by its own terms it applies only to
the waters of the State of New York. It reads as
follows:
ROLE RE ne
30
“No person, corporation or municipality,
shall place or cause to be placed, or discharge 40
1...
Te
10
a
or cause to be discharged into any of the
waters of this State, unless the same shall have
been permitted by the State Commissioner of
Health, any sewage, garbage, offal, dead ani-
mal, dead fish, dead bird or part thereof, or
any decomposable or putrescible matter of any
kind or any substance, chemical or otherwise,
containing the same in quantities injurious to
the public health, or any refuse or waste mat-
ter, either solid or liquid, in quantities in-
jurious to the public health, from any shop,
factory, mill or industrial establishment; un-
less express permission to do se shall have been
first given in writing by the State Commix
sioner of Health as provided in this article,
except as hereinafter provided”
If any attempt to regulate commerce and naviga-
tion had in fact been made by the State of New
York applicable to the waters of the Bay of New
York, they must of necessity in a Court of Equity
he subject to examination asx to their reasonable
ness, fairness and uniformity. It must alse appear
that the complainant has in fact executed such
regulations impartially throughout the waters of
the Bay of New York, and does net permit prac-
tires to exist within its own sovereignty which it
attempts to prevent within the severeignty of the
State of New Jersey under the limited jurisdiction
conferred by the compact. That naturally leads
to the following considerations :
(3) THE MAXIM THAT “HE WIlO COMES
INTO A COURT OF EQUITY MUST COME
WITH CLEAN HANDS” IS FUNDAMENTAL
AND AXIOMATIC, AND WAS APPLIED BY
MR. JUSTICE HOLMES IN MISSOURI VS.
~-
oe
ILLINOIS, 200 C8. 296,18 THE POLLOWING
LANGUAGE:
“If we are to judge by what the plaintiff
itself permits, the discharge of sewage into the
Mississippi by cities and towns is to be ex-
pected. We believe that the practice of dix
charging inte the river is general along its
banks, except where the levees of Louisiana
have led to a different course. The argument
for the plaintiff asserts it to be proper within
certain limits. These are facts to be consid-
ered. Even in cases between individuals, some
consideration is given toe the practical course
of events. In the black country of England
parties would not be expected to stand upon
extreme rights. Af, Helen's Smelting Co. vs.
Tipping, 1 HW. OL. Cas. G42. Bee Boston Fer-
rule Co. vs. Hille, 159 Mass. 147, 150, 20 L. R.
A. 844,34 N. B85. Where, as bere, the plain-
tiff hax sovereign powers, and deliberately per-
mits discharges similar to those of which it
complains, it »ot only offers a standard to
which the defendant has the right to appeal,
but, as some of those discharges are above the
intake of St. Louis, it warrants the defendant
in demanding the strictest proof that the
plaintiff's own conduct does not produce the
result, or at least so conduce to it, that courts
should not be curious to apportion the blame.”
The case at bar discloses in an exaggerated form
every feature referred to by the learned justice in
the above opinion as precluding any relief to the
plaintiff therein. Judged by what New York itself
permits, the discharge of sewage into Upper New
York Bay ix to be expected. Not only is this true
of New York Bay, but it is true of all the harbors
10
os
t ORR HEE Se rw ee +
im the civilized world, ax will appear from an ex-
amination of the testimony in this case with rela-
tion to various barbers examined by the witpesses,
The complainant in the case at bar has sovereign
powers, and deliberately permits dicharges more
objectionable than these of which it complains,
and thereby offers a standard to which the defend.
ants have a right te appeal. It ix safe to say that
over fifty per cent. of the voluminous record in this
case consists of textumeny as to the effect of the
discharge of sewage bw New Vork City inte the
waters surrounding it. For Wustrations of the
character of this testimony we refer the court
the following: Record, Vel. U1, pages 120%, 1490,
1310, 1551, 1620, 1672, 1687 «ft weq.; Record, Vel
111, page 2007,
The effect of the sewage discharged bw the City
of New York inte the Upper Ray on fish, Record,
Vel. 1, 459-460; on shell fish, Record, Vol. LIL, page
1969; on bathing, Record, Vol. 111, page 2290.
The evidence referred to eill disclose comdid cms
created by the City of New Vork of the sume kind,
hut te a greater degree, than is charged in the bill
of complaint, ax likely te result from the acts of
the defendants: and if the sewage of the Passaic
Valley were in fact to be discharged inte New York
ay near Robbins Reef, without treatment of any
kind, the result, excepting possibly at the im
wediate point of discharge, woul! net be percep
title in any way within the limit« of the Soate of
New Vork: and it ix very doubtful whether the
effects at the immediate point of discharge would
extend bevend the territerial Limits of the State of
New Jersey.
oe
V. Reply to Brief for Complainants.
Statement of Fact.
Disregarding the namber of incidental mistakes
im the alleged statement of fact, such as, for ex-
ample, the sumber of municipalities in the Passa
Valley District, which ix twenty instead of thirty.
«ix, and the law under which the Pawwic Valley 10
Sewerage Commix<ion was constituted a corpora.
tien was 19605 inxtead of 1907, there are two mat.
ters of considerable importance the correction of
which is necessary to prevent misunderstanding on
the part of the court.
The first ix that “in January, 1909, and after the
granting of the permit by the Federal Government,
the Department of Justice, on behalf of the United
States Government, moved for permission to in- 2)
tervene as complainant in the «it now before the
court.” The chronelegy of the proceedings at the
beginning of this brief will indicate that the inter-
vention by the United States was by order made
on January 4, 1909. No permit was executed until
after the filing of the stipulation between the
United States and the defendants, which appears
as “exhibit No. 155 for the complainants” (a copy
of which is appended to this brief). Reference to 39
this stipulation will «how that it was approved
on behalf of the State of New Jersey on April 14,
1910. The permit itself will be found immediately
following page 4619 of the record, volume V; de
fendants’ exhibits 6 and 7, September 22, 1911.
It is accordingly net a fact that the intervention
by the United States was after the granting of the
permit by the Federal Government.
The statement in the brief immediately following 40
—
—_
that abowe criticized, viz: “The motion of interven.
tien was granted on the ample presentation by the
Department of Justice of the unxatixfactory condi
ties incident to the imuance of the trunk sewer
permit,” ix alxe unfounded and might create a mix
understanding of the situation.
It ix possible that complainants’ counsel have
JQ *etfased the application of the City of New York
for leave to intervene in this suit, ax attempted
under date of December 12, 1910, denied by this
court wader date of December 19, 1910, whieh mo
tien wax made after the execation of the stipula
tien, but before the actual ixenance of the permit.
The inference whieh might be drawn from the
mixstatement in complainants’ brief ix that the
Department of Justice was in fact dissatixtied with
the terms upon which the permit was granted, the
fact being that the stipulation provided that bo
permit should be granted except apm the terms of
the stipulation, and that the Department of Jus
tice was entively satified and withdrew its peti
tien of intervention in this can.
The second material misstatement of fact ap
pears in a number of versions, a typical one being
found on the sixth page of the brief ax follows:
“The Passaic Valley Sewerage project con
templates the operation and maintenance of a
mammoth trunk sewer of ever twenty-six miles
in length, designed te tram<pert the organic
filth and trade refuse from thirty-seven muni-
cipalities aed townshipe in the Passaic Valley
watershed. It ix proposed to discharge thix
putrescent menace at the rate of over 300
millions of gallon« per day into Upper New
York Bay.”
This statement invelves one of the important
beues in the cause, and ix not supported by the
testimony of any of the witnesses, either for com-
plainants« or the defendants
I. COMPLAINANTS COUNSEL SAYS
“QUARANTINE LAWS ARE ESTABLISHED
POR THE PROTECTION AND PROMOTION
OF THE PUBLIC HEALTH.”
This statement ix not subject to dixpute, but in-
asmuch as no quarantine laws are invelved in thix
controversy, nowe being alleged in the pleadings or
shown by the evidence, it may, therefore, be disre-
garded. The dixewssion of the effect of the com-
pect, ratified in 184 between the Mtates of New
York and New Jersey, has already been anticipated
and fully met in this brief, All of the cases cited
in the complainants brief are cited more fully and
discussed at length in this brief.
i. THE QUOTATIONS FROM THE TESTI.
MONY INCLUDED UNDER POINT L AS WELL
A® POINTS 11 AND Il, MAY PROPERLY BE
CONSIDERED TOGETHER.
It will be found upon an examination of the
quotations of evidence which follow in this brief
that all of the Witnesses whose testimony ix quoted
from in complainants’ brief have axsumed in their
direct evidence that the terms of the stipulation
between the United States and the State of New
Jersey and the Passaic Valley Sewerage Commis
sioners would not be complied with by the defend-
ants herein, and that their testimony ix, in fact,
upon direct examination confined entirely to
10
ose ee +
10
20
30
60
opinion evidence based upon an assumption that
nothing more than the processes and devices pre-
seribed in detail in the stipulation would be done
to purify the Passaic Valley sewage so as to pro-
duce an effluent which would result as guaranteed
in the stipulation, An examination of the testi-
mony of these withesses on cross-examination will
disclose the fact that every one of them admitted
that processes could be applied to the Passaic Val-
ley sewage which would result in an effluent of a
character to produce the results guaranteed in the
stipulation, and thet tf the guaranteed results were
in fact produced wo injury of any kind would result
to the water of the Upper Bay.
While it would be desirable to quote substan-
tially the whole of the cross examination of the wit-
nesses for the complainants, whose testimony is
referred to in complainants’ brief, it would result
in making this brief too voluminous, and we, there-
fore, content ourselves with extracts only,
It is to be noted that the witnesses in question are
practically all of the expert witnesses produced
and sworn on behalf of the complainants. Taking
them in order we submit the following citations
from the testimony :
Professor William T. Sedgwick, Vol. III, p. 2269,
fol. 3297:
Q. Now, I ask you again that if the ef-
fluent discharged into New York Bay produces
the guaranteed results, do you mean to say
that you think there will be any injury to the
property of the United States in the harbor
of New York?
amewpans ARCO Ht AER AA A AE IRA AY RE NBN EN AE At OR PIE DAES
61
A. No, logically speaking. Paragraph 6
seems to cover all that point.
(). That seems to exclude the injuries which
you testified to?
A. But I do not believe that the means pro-
posed will produce the results guaranteed.
(). Well, by that you refer to the sedimen-
tation and screening processes? 10
A. Yes,
(2. And you do not have in mind any requi-
site additional arrangements?
A. 1 do not understand.
(). [Tsay have you in mind the agreement
on the part of the Passaie Valley Seweraze
Commissioners to adopt other requisite law-
ful additional arrangements? 20 :
A. IT have noted that provision and I have i
no doubt that additional arrangements could /
be made which would do away with all my :
sanitary objections. Whether these would be fe
lawful or not. Tam unable to state. i
Professor Earl B. Phelps, Vol. 2. page 1638, fol. :
2434: 3
Q. Now, Prof. Phelps, assuming that the 30
legal intent of the instrument is that the Pas-
stie Valley Sewerage Commissioners agree to
produce the results in the effluent which «are
specified in the stipulations, either through ‘he
me
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.