Transcript of Record — Silver King Coalition Mines Co. v. Conkling Mining Co.
Supreme Court brief1921
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(27,244)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 1920.
No. 158.
SILVER KING COALITION MINES COMPANY, PETITIONER,
v8.
CONKLING MINING COMPANY
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT
INDEX
Origina Print,
Affidavit of Nicholas Treweek in the case of Nicholas Treweek
et al. vx. Silver King Coalition Mines Company et al. in
support of motion for an order to inspect and survey the
wining property of the Silver King Coalition Mines Company. 1 2
Order in the case of Nicholas Treweek ef al. va. Silver King
Coalition Mines Company et al. granting survey, etc., of min-
ing property of Silver King Coalition Mines Company... .. 5 5
a £0 GUNNIEE occeccoscvcvorresvcusteneveneees 6 6
Replication to amended answer...........----cccccscccccsece 25 22
Stipulation in re certain pleadings.............-..+++eeee000% 25 22
/Order, December 16, 1911, granting leave to file amended an-
tt Mcntuawceded beoetevube bee sb O0u sev enoretoworeceen 26 23
Amended answer to amended bill of complaint............... 26 23
of district court, filed November 28, 1916, as to defend-
ant’s motion to reopen the case for the introduction of fur-
NN AU as el ainw signs sue vue daa ween eae : §0 43
& Derwemtre (Inc.), Printers, WASHINGTON, D. C., OcToper 13, 1920.
ii INDEX.
Origina!
Opinion of the district court, filed January 4, 1917, as to de
fendant’s motion to reopen the case and plaintiffs motion for
a decree in accordance with the mandate of the U. 8, cirewit
court of appeals.......ceccec cece cereerrecaeeteeeeeees
Opinion of the district court, filed February 27, 1918, as to
ACCOUNTING 6.6 e ccc cece weer ern nereteeeeeeees - es
Decree of the district court, March 27, 1918.. pecceceoese
Stipulation as to the opinion of the district court, ‘filed ‘Febru
ary 27, 1918, being made a part of the record...... -
Order, April 17, 1918, making opinion filed February 27, 1918,
part of the record in this case.....-.+++-+-+++ neoeuccooees
Statement of CvIdeENCe......-cecereerereccssrssttarnenseneeee
CAPtion coccsccccccccevecsceeessersrrsreserennes
Amended bill of complaint.. sae eceneeend
Amended answer to omental bill of cumptatah.. powenesees
Recital of decree of district court of August 5, 1912......
Recital of opinion of U. 8. circuit court of appeals, Febru
ATY 12, 1916.... 2. eee cece erence eccsreernaees
Defendant’s motion to reopen the case for the introduction
of further testimony........----+-+eeeee onedéenee
Notice of defendant’s motion to reopen case........ —
Affidavit of James Humes in support of motion to re
open the case.
Thomas Kearns in ‘eupgeet of wettee to
R. H. Browne in support of motion to re
open the case. ; :
Interlocutory decree of the district om, Jeuuans 20, 4917
Defendant’s statement as to ore mined from Conkling
CIAIM, Cll. cc cccc cc ccc ccc crcesereeccr ces esrsssesessees
Proceedings, May 14, 1917, defendant granted leave to file
amended statement of account, etc... .-..+e-eeeeee renee
Testimony for defendant........---+eerrcesrenreerewseee
Testimony of Charles P. Brooks.. -
Data of development work Seen | on the ( vonkling
and Arthur claims, 1902, to April, 1916........
Testimony of Thomas L. Walden.....-- +++. +-+eseeee>
Cc. P. Brooks (recalled).......+.«+0+5.
Andrew L. Hurley.........-+sseseeeeee
David Bettla..cccccccccccccevcevesssess
M. J. Dailey (recalled) .........+50006
Letter, Nicholas Treweek ef al. to Silver King
Coalition Mines Company, December 19, 1907..
Priat.
—
—
-
INDEX. Th
Original! Print
letter, Thomas Kearns to Nicholas Treweek et al.
EY Ue ieienaneeebdsseedestnnheneeses 26 174
letter, N. Treweek ef al. to Silver King Coalition
Mines Company, January 6, 1908.............. 26 175
Testimony of C. P. Brooks (recaiied)................ 212 180
Edwin 8S. Maxim............... ‘eoeess 213 181
William Barben............. — Ta 182
tveorge irudeme............... 216 183
Ce Be ccccerescececeen 217 184
et Ap otencsndssemmenosbedien 218 IND
SED |, Heh tet reciaitaeinilebtattenciia tens i 220 186
Excerpt of record showing time of witness ax sta-
See) SEE GP Mndeeteesececesensecenecanae = 187
Testimony of John Forsman......................... 221 187
Stipulation ax to defendant's statement of account. 222 158
Testimony of M. J. Dailey (recatied)................. 222 188
See 2 189
Bart Mahoney.............. reseserees 227 192
En dnencecedheecdesencasa 230 195
Ge. Weedceonewasseceoesee a a4 197
GE Gb GN wecnscaveessoencen 237 200
ND Ce rca csncccunsenmune 41 204
Exhibit 47—Option agreement between DD. P. Robi
fing and Belmont Mining Company and assign
NS Fv cesesccscceseccocsccecetecceccece 242 24
Testimony of J. B. Scholefield....................... 244 206
SD Ge nbecccdccesecseonesenens 2 208
James Toole (recatied)................ “me 210
PE MH meweccceeseceoesesens 251 212
ey Web- Ml nnicncsneunensoneetnnnn 4 214
SD Be icecneccncssceceds one 215
George Holland........ kuulbeeetidbans ot 219
Cornelius J. (Neill (recalled).......... a1 220
Daniel Met'ann (recailed)............. aH 222
©. P. Brooks (recalled) ................ aH 222
Sen ah Bl eneneseeeveseecesse cus 267 225
Se OO Greccncccceccccevececece 269 226
Hl SE idesteuscheteoeceeesesonunss 270 227
WP Ge eecnececcosecccocescecesece 271 227
M. J. Dailey (recaiied)................ 22 228
C. P. Brooks (recalled) ................ 273 229
Certificate of assay of Exhibit 5®................ 275 230
Certificate of assay of Exhibit @0................ 276 231
Certificate of axsay of Exhibit @1................ 276 231
Certificate of assay of Exhibit @2................ 276 222
Certificate of assay of Exhibit @................. 276 22
Testimony of J. I. Scholefield (recalied)............. 2s1 236
(. P. Brooks (recailed)................ Pe) 242
M. J. Dailey (recalied)................ Pant) 243
4. B. Scholefield (recalled)........ -» Bo oH
—_———e CT OE LS NE RE age ta ee a
iv INDEX.
Testimony of M. J. Dailey (recalled).........---+++-
Cornelius J. O'Neill (recalled)
James Humes
John W. Christy ..
Frank Andersen
J. B. Scholefield (recalled)
Thomas Kearn« (recalled)......
David Keith.
Cc. P. Brooks (recalled)
Arthur Meliemald (recalled)
Cornelius J. O'Neill (recalled)
Daniel Met'ann (recalled)
Frank J. Hansen
William F. Dreviin
Frank J. Hansen (reealled)
4. BK. Sehotetield (recalled)
C. . Brooks (reealled)
F. J. Hansen (recalled)
Mining Company and the
American Smetting & Retin
ing Company, Setempher 19
1K o< eee pecs
1S—Contract between the Silver
King Coalition Mines Com
pany and the American
Smelting & Refining Com
pany. June 14, 1907.........
1%—Memorandum agreement, June
14, 1917.. yeudeoete
107--Assignment of contract between
the Silver King Coalition
Mines Company and F. Au
gust Heinze, May 21. 1907,
to Miners Smelting Company,
July 3. 1907
Schedule A Contract between
the Silver King Coalition
Mines Company and F. Au
gust Heinze, May 21, 1907.
Excerpt of minute book of the
board of directors of the Sil
ver King Cealition Mines
ee ee
Entries in assay book of de
RE coceccees oe
Testimony of C. P. Brooks (recallied)........
Testimony of Thomas Kearns (recalled)........ sees
Stipulation as to David Keith (recalled).........
INDEX. v
Original. Print
Testimony for plaintiff...... PPO0CCed cunsoeenersooresoce os UB
Testimony of Frank Anderson....................... aos os)
John (. Whitta...... pecerocevceds ad WIT
oe Ee ee a os
David Hh. Gwilliame.......... Séceve8e i 310
4. HW. Finnegan...... Sevugonneoeee is 311
Harry Stephens...... eeecseneuee a) 313
dein C. Whitta (recalied)............. ot 316
Edward UW. Pradence................ , 373 316
Ff ee veeeeevedes 374 317
Samuel Treweek........ meuceoeovesee 375 318
By De Wovcccucseercerveseecs 37s 320
Jame= Hames... .. witeurresebecne pt) 422
Tem lachinetti...... : eesvocece SI BS as |
Itaniel Met'ann........ sesceeee nes ad S24
4. M. Bidwell........ peeeveoeeses 3M a2
Samuel P. Parker (recatied). peeeoouess ae 43
Witliam J. Lindberg...... peeveesonses at a S34
Mathew Sheriork............. evrsoeers oe; 6
Charles Manguem..................... SWT aa Ty
Wilem A. Howard................... ous OT
Gee De bscccorweusensenciensesssan “rn 0)
SEE Uleccecosseccceccséeesswesnns rR a1
fs ene we 345
Transcript of Taylor's ficures om blackboard... .. 4+ oa)
Testimony of F. J. Hanson Pe weceetoouseensen #21 BOT
Tes*iaony for defendapt in rebuttal..................... 423 Sms
Testimony of Frank Andersen... _. youseteeeroreces 4123 os
Testimony of H. P Taylor.... ses veeuses = STs
Report of Messr«. F.llix and Andersen on Defend
ant’s Exhibits 59. @. G1. 42. and and Plain
tiffs Exhibit 9... .. - 23 es
Testimony of F. J. Hanson 4 Aa
€. P. Brooks (recalled)..............-. Im “in
(. J. O'Neill (recatied)....... peveecees 4126 461
Recital of the filing of defendant's Wrief.................. 1H 1
Summary of defendant'< receipts and disbursements, ete.
(except of defendant’< brief)...... pedeveosedeeseoubns 426 wil
Revital of the filing of plaintiff's brief... .. ywebeowesoros 4 370
Excerpt of plaintiff's brief.............................. 434 371
Recital of the filing of defendant's Septy Orted.......cccces 434 371
Petition of defendant for leave to file an amended account. 425 371
Affidavit of Thomas Marioneaux in suppert of petition
for leave to file an amended account, efe........... i“ 375
Amended account of Silver King Coalition Mines Com-
pany for development work done on Conkling and
SY GE nce. ccrecgacupncorsdenssreecesnas.. 441 376
oven eRe
vi
IN DEX
ahi: A- A@idevtt of J. B. Schetetield te cappert of
defender yetitien fed eave te Ble an amended a
coetoet ov
Exhitatr B—A@idevtt of William Reid ip eappert of
fendant's petition fer leave to Oe an amended «tate
ment of acount. ety
Rerttel «of erder granting Gefendant weve te Hie a
ateeiwded <tatetertt of arent
Recent of preerdiings af the breringe © befe-techatet
petitien for eave te Ble an ateended statement ff
account
A@idavht of W. 1. Itieckeem to eappert of defendant+
petitien for tras ' fil on ameter] = <tatetmetet
af aco, «
€ Opeb tebe of the distri rt. Ged February Zi, 108
ae te acvwtnt ing
Plaintif!s <tatement of amcnnt dar from defendant ov
acoemmnting
Notice «ef defendant « “atement «f amewnt dar jpelate
i on accounting, ot
leefendant'+ stateanetst of mtmeetent hie plaietifl om ae
counting. et«
Defendant's exhibit.
Defendant's Exhiit 1—Map A. <hbewing develqanent
work dome op the Conkiing
and Arther oealas 1 te
April, 1916
Map «beet Ne 1. showing
werk deme on the Conkling
end Arther lates. 18) te
ei"
Maj ha SN 4 showing
werkings below tanmel bec rl
and «teqéng dene on Conk
ting and Arthur claims 1912
te April. 6
‘Map. sheet Ne 4. showing
werking= aterve tantet bewet
chert m= (wnkiieg end Ar
ther claims, 190° te April
. fie
Defendant + Exhibits 5 te 2). inclasive—- Map showing
~_Ttteen! ewtien, Ne ©@ te
tes Ne is behest te
taken threugh the grewnd
a shown te ltefendant’>
Pabieltt 2 (lesking cost. oe
thems 10 feet apert)
> Section Ne @
6—Section No. 1
a
™
Sd
i
4m
IY DEX
7-—Hertien Ne 2
SBection Ne
» -Sectiem No 4
Section Ne. 5
11—-Sertien No 6
id Section Ne 7
13 Section Ne *
14-—-Section Ne. &
in—Section SNe bo
Section Ne 11
1j—Section No 12
1S Section No. 15
1)—Section No 14
)—Section Ne. 15
2+—Sketch map of the Alliance
and werkings from
Defendant » Eabiteit
t tenetee
the mouth te the west end
inlets Exh: 45 Map «of Conkling aim and 8 here
werk wes epg’ in 1900 weet
of the 155-fou tine eseept the
( lomittia rane
“—Ietter. Conkling Mining ( ompeny
te Silver King Coalition Minex«
Companys. Nevember 30 1fu~
*—Fins! summary. subject to elimina
ten of ore net from Conkling
ground
—Extract of ore sales from the Si!
ver King Coalition Mines Com.
pany during the period May 11
17. te March 21. 1906
70—Record of crude ore «ld tn thee
Kearns Keith Mining (compe pean ta)
during May and June. 1907
Defendant's Exhibit *¢. Map «hewing surface of what ix
known as the Belmont Mining
(ompeny’s greand. ete
“6—E.xtract of ore «ales from Silver
King Coalition Mines Company
for October, November. and
December, 1faG
W1—Report of James Humex <uper
imtendent of the Silver King
Coalition Mines Company, for
1914 :, ,
—Repert of James Homes. super
intendent of the Silver King
Coalition Mines Company. for
1915
51S
51s
42g
4t2
46
—
Origteel = Prtat.
Defendant's Exhibit % Paceryt of <bift bowsee ore ex
traction book of the Silver King
Contition Mines Company (page
headed “Alliance Firat (lass.
Jum 1 te Teeomier 31
me, . ————
% Peceret of lft fewer” off os |
traction teedk of the Silver King
(calito Mines (company (page
headed!’ “Neetk Terilie”) : os) ie
.Serfae map of the Silver King
tealttien Mines Company oat +4
Misintif’s Eablet 116 Semmery of cmt anaipele sheet
of Silver King (tition Mines fC ompany fer 1995.. , ae 7
Pisintift’s Exhibit 1 7 Sqmmery of cot analyeie sheet of
Stiver King Coal. © Mines (company for 1914 - a4 as
Stipulation as te tra: script of record ae va
Approval of statement of evidews. ote. ty district Jade... 546 va
Petition for appeal of the Sliver King Conlitien Mines Com
a TAT ve
Assignment of errors on que ft the Sliver King walttion
Mines Company...... el ae
Order allowing apyea!l of the Silver King (oalition ‘Mies Com
SE cccccesesess Tee, "
Supersedeas bond on agpeat - the Silver King ‘ ‘entities Mince
GEE cocccccccocesces - seooceveee 6D rl
(order enlarging time tu file exgnacstys. - seceenponnnonts Ls m2
Stipulation for the tranemiexton of certain original exhibits to
the U. &. cirewit court of appeals... ......- 6-66 occ eee MG cred
Precipe of the Silver King Coalition Mines Company for tran
ee “ae 4
Additional precipe of the Silver King (aatition Mb tees ¢ conmepae try
ey CEE pencuyecseanoewsesnonuerrs rd ord
Amended previpe of the ‘Siwer King Cantithe Siar Campus
Be Gicccccecesvecveeccereeesreccecessersesees Siz m%
Chation on appeal <f the Silver King Cantttion ase Camens
ee GD Ge Gi ecccecescrecceocosecocecosseeoous bre) ca
Clerk's certificate to tranerript................ au4 rod
INDEX TO Ne Some.
lalate aa eed, Te
wn» We PODS IOOOIIP TODS OO CONC COCO SECO OO COSCSOoSes
Precip of the Conkling Mining Company for tramerriga.......
(Ration om ayqeal of the Conkling Mining Company and seveps.
GP SE DI rccccesscccccscnsecesceccecooceossewseecsss.
\ererance of Mr. Eh. Critchiow. Mr Wiltem W. Hay. Mr
Wiltiem J. Kerrette, and Mr William H. King as ome
Methon to mend ap additional parts of the rewwrd and aiidavine
© <appert theres? in couse Neo. Sink beesvevoesoecs reevccees
S558 FRR F
LASERS ULI RRL: PPTL III NS IEEE LYNE LE EEE AIG? | COMES ELEY LORE NRE ER EL
— ~
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 1
a Pleas and proceedings in the United States Circuit Court
of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, at the December Term,
1918, of said Court, before the Honorable Walter H. Sanborn and
the Honorable Kimbrough Stone, Circuit Judges, and the Honorable
James D. Elliott, Distriet Judge.
Attest :
| Seal United States Circuit Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit. |
Kk. E. KOCH,
Clerk of the United States
Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Eighth Circuit.
Be it Remembered that heretofore transcripts of record pursuant
to appeals allowed by the District Court of the United States for
the District of Utah were filed in the oflice of the Clerk of the United
States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, in certain
causes wherein the Silver King Coalition Mines Company was
Appellant, and the Conkling Mining Company was Appellee, in
which cause the transcript of record was filed and docketed in said
Cireuit Court of Appeals on June 26, 1918, as No. 5188, and also
wherein the Conkling Mining Company, a corporation, was Ap-
pellant, and the Silver King Coalition Mines Company was Ap-
pellee, in which cause the transcript of record was filed and docketed
on June 27, 1918, as No. 5190. Said transcripts as prepared and
printed under the rules of the United States Cireuit Court of Appeals
for the Eighth Circuit, under the supervision of its Clerk, are in the
words and figures following, to-wit:
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
District of Utah, ss:
At a regular stated term of the District Court of the United
States for the District of Utah, in the Central Division thereof,
begun and held in the Court room in the Federal Building, at Salt
Lake City, on the 8th day of April, in the year of our Lord one
thousand nine hundred and eighteen and the one hundred and
forty-second of the Independence of the United States of America.
Present: Honorable Tillman D. Johnson, United States District
Judge for the District of Utah.
2 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO,
TRANSCRIPT OF THE Recorp.
In Equity.
No. 2125 (307).
CoNKLING Minine Company, a Corporation, Plaintiff,
VS.
Sitver Kine Coarition Mines Company, a Corporation, Defendant.
Affidavit of Nicholas Treweek
in support of a motion for an order to inspect and for a survey,
filed in the Cireuit Court of the United States for the District of
Utah on the Ist day of June, 1908, as follows, to-wit:
In the Cireuit Court of the United States, Eighth Cireuit, in and for
the District of Utah.
Nicuo.as TREWeex and J, Leonarp Buren, Plaintiffs.
vs.
Strver Kine Coarition Mixes Company, a Corporation, and Jou»
M. Davoenerty, Defendants.
Nicholas Treweek, first being duly sworn deposes and says:
That he is if the age of 57 years and for 35 years past has been
and is a resident of Salt Lake City, Utah, and is one of the plaintiffs
in the above entitled action. That he is by profession and oceupa-
tion, a mining engineer and miner, and has had very large experi-
ence in his profession and business in vein, lode or ledge mining for
gold, silver and lead and other metals, and especially in the
2 Uintah Mining District, Summit County, Utah. That he i
now manager of and directing the development work of the
Wabash Mining Company’s mine in said District; and from time
to time in the last thirty years has been the manager of other large
and extensive mining enterprises in other places than said Uintah
Mining District. That the affiant is in charge of matters and things
pertaining to the prosecution of the above entitled action. That he
is one of the owners of the Arthur and Conkling lode mining claims
described in the complaint and the subject matter of the above en
titled action, especially with the surface conditions and to some
extent the underground workings of the same made by the defendant
company or its predecessor in interest of the Alliance Tunnel in 80
far as he has been permitted to examine and observe the same by the
Defendant Company.
That affiant is also and for many years last past has been ac-
quainted with the mining claims of the Defendant Company in sal
mining district adjcining and near by to said Conkling and Arthur
—
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. YS. CONKLING M. CO. 3
mining claims in a general way and to some extent to the under-
ground workings therein in so far as permitted by Defendant Com-
pany to inspect and examine same.
That the portion of the underground workings of said Arthur
and Conkling mining claims that he has been so permitted to in-
spect and examine, afliant is informed and believes is a small portion
of the underground workings of the said Arthur and Conkling min-
ing claims made by the Defendant Company or its predecessors.
That the Alliance Tunnel the afliant is informed and believes is
owned by the Defendant Company and that the Defendant Com-
pany or its predecessors in interest thereof has run same into and
uederneath the surface and at great depth through the said Arthur
and Conkling mining claims and beyond the southwest end line of
the said Conkling claim and into and underneath the surface of
mining claims belonging to Defendant Company the distance of
which affiant does not know. and through said Alliance Tunnel has
mined, and is mifting and intends to mine the ores in dispute in this
action within and underneath the surface of said Arthur and¢ ‘onkling
mining claims; and also through which tunnel Defendant Com-
pahy is mining and intends to mine and is transporting and intends
to transport the ores mined by it from the same ore body or same vein,
lode or ledge lying beneath the surface of said mining claims owned
by the defendant company, but that the defendant company
3 has refused and continues to refuse to the plaintiffs and the
affiant, further entrance inte and upon said Alliance tunnel,
and has excluded and refused atfiant admission thereto and will
hot permit him or any one in the interest of the plaintiff to ap-
proach or inspect any portion of said tunnel that lies within about
135 feet northeasterly back towards the face of the tunnel from the
vertical plane drawn down vertically through the southwest end
line of the said Conkling mining claim. as called for in the field
hotes of the patent survey therefor.
That the Defendant Company claims to be the owner of the
Walker and Walker Extension, Brave Columbia. Constitution, and
Cumberland lode mining claims, and that the vein, lode or ledge
ipon which is deposited said ore hody sone within said Walker
ind Walker Extension, Brave Columbia, Constitution. and Cumber-
and mining claims in such position that the Defendant Company
as extralateral rights thereto, that is, the right to follow same on its
lip into and underneath the surface of said Arthur and Conkling
nining claims, and to own, mine and remove ores therefrom lying
inderneath and within the surface of said Arthur and Conkling
uining claims, and contained within vertical planes drawn down-
‘ard through the exterior boundaries of said Arthur and Conkling
nining claims.
The affiant further says that the issues in the foregoing action is,
there the true apex, strike or dip of said vein, lode, ledge or ore body
neountered by the Defendant Company or its predecessors in said
llliance tunnel and underneath the surface of said Arthur and
onkling mining claims and within vertical planes drawn downward
a GREE LO PIRES ie LEON OR SA GO UREN CN AN
“2
4 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO,
through the exterior boundary of said claims, and the ownership of
said vein, lode, ledge or ore body is to be determined.
That the plaintiff nor afliant cannot from the examination that
he has been permitted to make, determine the true position of the
apex of said alleged vein, lode or ledge or said ore body, nor the true
strike and dip of the same without being given unobstructed access to
every part of said Alliance tunnet, to its ultimate end, and also all
drifts, winzes, upraises, and stopes made from that part of said tunnel
after it passes into said Arthur claim and departs from the Conkling
mining claim and into the ground adjoining and belonging to de-
fendant company and to the faces thereof ;
And also to that end it will be absolutely necessary to exam-
ine and inspect the underground workings within said Walker and
Walker Extension, Brave Columbia, Constitution and Cum-
4 berland mining claims; and also examination and inspection
of the following named tunnels; Hanauer tunnel which runs
generally in a southwesterly direction; the Etna tunnel which runs
generally in a southeasterly direction, but on a higher level and are
connected by a winze;: the Apex tunnel which runs generally ina
southeasterly direction. These tunnels are more or less eross-cuts to |
the general course of the formation through which they are con-
structed and that they or some one of them may or would likely en-
counter said vein, lode or ledge on its dip if such vein, lode or ledge
in faet exists and did apex, strike and dip as claimed by defendant
company. |
The affiant further savs that the veins, lodes or ledges or ore bodies _
in place in the said Arthur and Conkling mining claims, and thoseof
the adjoining and adjacent mining claims of the defendant company
are covered and kept from view by loose earth, gravel and rock, com-
monly called wash, to the depth of so many feet that their apex or
apexes do not come to or reach the surface and therefore cannot be
diseovered or traced on the surface, but must be done wholly from
examination and inspection in underground workings as they exist
in said mining claims of plaintiff and those belonging to defendant
company as hereinbefore set forth.
Affiant further says that all information to be obtained and that
he desires to obtain by examination and inspection of the workings
are intended to and will be used only for the purpose of ascertaining
the extent and condition of said veins, lodes, or ledges or ore bodies
lying underneath the surface and within vertical planes drawn down
through the exterior boundary of said Arthur and Conkling mining
claims, and to establish the rights of the plaintiff in the above en-
titled action.
That all of said inspections and examinations can be made without
injury to defendant company.
That the Conkling vein, lode or ledge, deposit of ore, or ore chan-
nel as disclosed in the said Alliance tunnel, has a slight dip from
the horizontal to the northwesterly from the tunnel level, and 4
corresponding departure upward therefrom, and if it so continues It
would not apex within vertical planes drawn down through the e%
terior boundary of the defendant company’s said Walker and Walker
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. Ys. CONKLING M. CO. 5
Extension, Brave Columbia, Constitution and Cumberland mining
claims or either of them.
And it is also necessary in the premises that in making such
eaminations and inspections to make such surveys of the same as
the plaintiff, or affiant, may think relevant and proper
5 and which will aid in the determination of the is-ue< in said
action.
The affiant attaches to this his affidavit Exhibit (A) and as part
thereto a map showing the approximate relation of the said Arthur
Conkling Mining claims to and with said Walker and Walker Ex-
tension, Brave Columbia, Constitution and Cumberland mining
daims and other mining claims adjoining or adjacent and belong-
ing in part to defendant company, and also the approximate relation
of the said tunnels to said mining claims and the relative position
whieh they bear towards each other and also the position of the vein,
lode, ledge or deposit of ore in dispute in this action and lying
underneath the surface of said Conkling mining claim as herein-
hefore more particularly referred to.
NICHOLAS TREWEEK.
Subscribed and sworn to before me by Nicholas Treweek. this 2nd
day of June, 1908.
[SEAL. | G. A. LAND,
Notary Pu hlie.
Service by copy admitted June 4, 1908.
Attorneys and of Counsel for the Defe ndant,
Silver King Coalition Mines Company.
Filed June 4. 1908
JERROLD R. LETCHER.
Clerk.
(Order Granting Inspection and Survey of Mining Property of Sil-
rer King Coalition Mines Company.)
Made, Filed and Entered in the Cireuit Court of the United States
for the District of Utah on the 30th Day of June, 1908.
NicnoLas TREWeEK and J. Leoxarp Br rcu, Plaintiffs,
vs,
‘iLveR King Coatition Mines COMPANY, a Corporation, and Joux
M. Daveuerry, Defendants.
Motion of the plaintiffs in the above entitled action for surface and
underground inspection and survey coming on regularly to be heard
and all and singular upon the stipulation of the respective parties
said action made im open court.
It is hereby. ordered that the plaintiffs with their experts, agents,
and surveyors be and are hereby given the free and unmol-std right
Bm > « . _ ro : = Reem:
—
6 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.
to enter upon and into the Hanauer tunnel, Etna tunnel and the
Apex tunnel belonging to the defendant company, and also,
6 upon and into the Alliance tunnel which on its course runs
into, underneath and beyond the Arthur and Conkling min-
ing claims described in the complaint from its commencement to its
end, and also, into and upon all drifts, winzes, upraises or st from
all parts thereof after it passes into and departs from said Arther
and Conkling mining claims and into the ground adjoining and
belonging to the defendant company and to the face thereof, and also,
to enter upon the surface and all underground workings of the
Walker and Walker Extension, Brave Columbia, Constitution and
Cumberland lode mining claims belonging to and described in the
defendant company’s answer, and to make such inspection and sur-
vey thereof as to the plaintiff's and their experts and surveyors may
deem important and will illustrate and aid in determining the apex
and dip of the vein, lode or ledge described in the anewer of def
ant as apexing within said last named mining claims belonging t
defendant and to measure and determine the course and strike of |
apex of said vein and dip thereof, and also to measure and deter-
mine the amount and value of the ore that may have been mined
by the defendant company from and underneath the surface of said
Conkling and Arthur lode mining claims and to determine and
measure the dip, strike and apex of the vein or lode upon which said
ore body is deposited; all to be done in such way as to give as little
inconvenience to both parties as circumstance will permit.
Done in open court the 30th day of June, A, D. 1908,
J. A, MARSHALL,
Judge
Filed June 30, 1908.
JERROLD R. LETCHER,
Clerk.
Amended Bill of Complaint.
(Filed in the U. 8S. Circuit Court July 5, 1909.)
In Equity.
No. 307.
ConkKLinc Mixino Company, a Corporation, Complainant,
vs.
Sitver Kine Coarition Mines Company, a Corporation, Defendant.
To the Honorable the Judges of the Circuit Court of the Unitet
States in and for the District of Utah:
The Conkling Mining Company, a corporation organized and
existing under the laws of the State of Utah, and a citizen of the State
of Utah, by leave of this Court first had and obtained, files this, i
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. Ys. CONKLING M. CO. 7
\inended Bill of Complaint, against the Silver King Coalition
; Mines Company, a corporation organized and existing under
the laws of the State of Nevada, and a citizen of the State of
Meads: and thereupon vour orator respectfully represents and
alleges
I.
That on or about the seventeenth day of September, A.D. 1908
Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Burch. the original complainants
herein. caused your orator to be duly Incorporated under the laws
of the State of Utah for the purpose and pursuit of mining
That the capital stock of your orator was paid for upon the in
corporation of said company by a conveyance and transfer te your
orator bw said Nicholas Treweek and J. Leomard Burch of all their
night. tithe and interest (heing an undivided three-fourths) in and
the Conkling Lode Mining Claim, patented ae US. Lot No. 689,
and the Arthur Lode Mining Claim. patented as U.S. Lot No. 690,
situated in the Uintah Mining Distriag. County of Summit and State
@ Viah, and also by an assignment and transfer to vour orator of all
manner of actions and causes of actions, suits, duce. deniatneds, con
inmversies and accounting of every kind and nature whatsoever in
favor of said Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Burch against the
defendant herein.
Il.
That said defendant corporation was organized and incorporated
wider the laws of the State of Nev ada, on or about the month of
May, 1907, to consolidate and take over sundry mining claims and
properties, including the Kearns-Keith Mining Company and the
Silver King Mining Company. respectively corporations. which sand
hamed companies theretofore and for a long time had been en-
gaged in the business of mining in the Mining District where said
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims are situated.
That in and by said consolidation and merger the defendant cor-
poration succeeded to the interest then and theretofore owned by
“id Kearns-Keith Mining Company in and to said Conkling end
Arthur Lode Mining Claims, viz., an undivided one-fourth (1%)
iMterest therein.
That on or about the twenty-second day of September, 190%, said
earns-Keith Mining Company, predecessor in interest and grantor
& the defendant herein, became the owner of said undivided one-
fourth (14) interest in and to said Conkling and Arthur Lode
Mining Claims, and ever since continued to be the owner
thereof until the same was transferred to and merged in the
( nt company as aforesaid, to wit, on or about the twenty-
minth day of May, 1907.
se PEE OO = EE A me rN ee a
enn
« SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.
(II1.}
That during all of the times said Kearns-Keith Mining
was the owner of said undivided onefourth (%) interest in «
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, the said Nicholas Ti
week, as tenant-in-common with said Kearns-Keith Mining Cor
pany, was the ewner of an undivided one-half (1) interest in a
to said mining claims and each of them.
That upon the transfer by said Kearns-Keith Mining Compa
to the defendant as aforesaid, said Treweek continued to be a tenat
in-common with the defendant herein in said mining claims a
each of them, and so continued to be until the transfer to vour orat
as here-hefore alleged.
Vv.
That said J. Leonard Burch since on or about the sixteenth 4
of May, 1906. until the tran-fer to vour orator herein, was @
owner of an undivided one-fourth (-/4) interest in and to «
Conkling and Arthar Lede Mining Claims. That as such own
since said sixteenth day of May. 1906, he was a tenant-in-comme
with said Kearns-Keith Mining Company in said mining cain
and each of them until the time of the transfer by said Kear
Keith Mining Company of its interests therein to the defenda
herein, and since the time of said transfer he was a tenant-in-con
mon with the defendant herein in said claims and each of then
until he transferred his interests to your orator as hereinbefo
alleged.
y
That on or about the twenty-third day of February, 1892 @
United States of America by its letters patent granted to the Ba
Mining Company. a corporation, those certain premises called tt
Conkling Arthur Lode Mining Claims, respectively situated i
the Uintah Mining District, County of Summit, then Territory, ne
State, of Utah. said Conkling Lode Mining Claim being particular!
bounded and described in said patent. to wit. }
“Bounded, described and platted as follows, with magnetic var
tion wen oy degrees at wy minutes —
inning at corner No. 1, a pine our inches squat
marked U. 8. 689 p. 1.
9 Thence first course north twenty-one degrees and nin
minutes west three hundred feet to discovery point six hut
dred feet to corner No. 2, a pine post four inches square
U. 8. 689 p. 2, being also corner No. 4, of Lot No. 191, the Lined
lode claim, and corner No. 2 of Lot No. 580, the Pirate King lod
claim from which U. 8S. mineral monument No. 4 bears nort
thirty-two degrees and fifty-two minutes west nine hundred am
thirty-nine and three tenths feet distant. and a pine tree four imehe
in diameter marked U. 8. 689 P. 2 B. T. bears north thirteen degree
west twenty-eight feet distant.
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. va. « ONKLING M. Co. 9
Thence second course. south “Ixty degrees and forty-five minutes
west one thousand five hundred feet to corner No. 3
Thence third course south twenty-one degrees and nine minutes
east ix hundred feet to corner No. 4
Thence fourth course north sixty degrees and ferty-tive minutes
rast one thousand five hundred feet to corner No. 1. the place of
beginning; said lot No. G89 extending one thousand five hundred
feet in length along said Conkling vein or lode. and containing
Wwenty acres and forty-five hundredths of an acre of land more or
And said Arthur Lode Mining Claim leing particularly bounded
and described in said patent, to wit:
“Bounded, described and platted as follows, with magnetic varia-
hon seventeen degrees and twenty minutes cast.
Beginning at Corner No. 1, a pine post four inches square, marked
C8. 690 P. 1. with mound of stones heing alee corner No. 1 of Lot
Xo, 689. the Conkling Lode claim.
» first course, north twenty-one degrees and nine minutes
wet, three hundred feet to discovery point, six lundred feet te
comer No. 2. a pine post four inches square marked US. G0 Pp 2
® mound on stones. being also corner No. 2 of said Lat No. 689.
comer No. 2, of Lot No. S80. the Pirate King Lode Claim. |
comer No. 4, of Lot No. 191, the Lineoln Lode Claim, from whieh
U.& Mineral Monument No. 4 bears north thirty-two degrees and
4wo minutes west nine hundred and thirty-nine and thres-
tenths feet distant: and a pine tree four inches in diameter tnarked
C8. 690 P.2B. T. in mound of stones bears north thirteen degree.
=~ eS
i |
i i,
nee, second course, north seventy-six degrees and fifty-
seven minutes east nine hundred and fifty-one and eight
tenths feet to corner No. 3.
Thence third course south, twenty-one degrees and nine minttes
at one hundred and thirty eight and eight tenths feet intersect
line 2-3. of Lot No. 342, the Pay Rock No. 2. lode claim, at north
degrees and twenty minutes east one hundred and thirty-
our tenths feet from corner No. 3. three hundred feet
line 3-4 of said lot No. 342. at south seventy-two degrees
forty minutes east one hundred and five and three-tenths feet
corner No. 3 six hundred feet to corner No. 4.
course south seventy-six degrees and fifty-sever
- ft o~ —e oe tenths feet to
, the place inning. Expressly exc ing and ex-
these presents all that pastien of the po. herein-
described embraced in said mining claim or survey No, 342.
HM that portion of said Arthur vein or lode, and of all
and ledges, throughout their entire depth, the tops or
which lie inside of such excluded ground ; said Lot No. 690
nine hundred and fifty-one and eight tenths feet in
said Arthur vein or lode, the granted premises in said
ao actes and eighty-two hundredths of an acre of
or less.”
i
eeyret af ge
ea
iH
q
z
:
}
:
SILVER KING COALITION MOO vs. CON KLING WTO
vi
card moning
de for the ores and minerals therem
said aimee, That
vil
STTETEEESS EY Peetatedagese
ta mails Hat i
dale Hi + Ht . dit
wien GieHiG?. EAH
vedi teat WE
Laer Tait
HUeraauitaiia bath
nati it Hirt : + : al
yuna: aH HALE 1 rr ti
ih iieuhil: APEs
LVER KING COALITION MOO Ve CONKLEIXG w. co il
bat upen information and belief alleges the samme to cxeced om value
the cum of one million dollars ($1,000 000.00,
IX.
orater further alleges that «ad grantors of your crater did,
A thie actin. demand from «ad defend-
account to them. as temant=in-cemnecm wrth ot on ened
claus, for eres and munetals by rt and ite eed grantor
Tom said premises and cdispemed of and for ther just and
share of the value thereef, That «sid defemdant COnpanY
refused to give to said grantor: of your crater any ae
counting whatsoever for the ores ot minerals by said defewdant
company extracted and remwed from said premises, oF
to pay to them or either of them their just. or amy, pa por
thon of the value thereedt.
That after the incorporation of your orator. and after veur ore
succeeded to the rights and interests of «wid Nicholas Treweek
J Leemard im and te ssid mining claims. and each of
to-wit, on or the therteeth day of Nowerber, 190%) your
demanded of aid defendant on eecounting as tenet on
in and to said mining claims and for vour orators just
of the value of the ores mined from underneath the «ur-
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Clams between
down vertically through the extener bewnderies of
Claims as herein deseribed. That «aid defendant com-
Lier
cE
j
|
i
your orator into the ron ef either of sad miming clare
manner eccount to or with your orator im the premscs
defendant asserts, pretends and claime= a exclusive in-
Tenant-in-common with vour orater) im a portion of
it hundred and thirty-five and
eard Conk Lode Mining Chom, a« here-
your orater. and to haw exclusive
omnes
tf :
vended curtielly foam the fellewing dona"
rem l
bounded on the southwest by the southwest ond lime of onl
. claim as hereinbefore bownded and described on
feet distant therefrom. and by the pe-
lines of said Conkling Mining Claim a« herenn' fore
: and said defendant has given out on weoch. and other.
exclusive mght te enter om upon sud prem.
(#
ef
H
t
1
=
a Ee
:
$ 7
:
1
;
:
'
:
:
STLYER KING COALITION M. OO. V® COR KLING WOT
12
the Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4. and ale leeouer 1 one
that the howndariee of eaid Conkling Clarm as ceeetibed om th
patent theres! and herein. are oa the 7 wer bemnticberw = thennal
he extent of inebuding the and southweet 15.5 fet of od Cob
ing Cte «2 Rene eae @ al
I
ead mvetlapqang and comfletong Siler Hill Neo 4 and Coeter
he benefit of the defendant and
oratet « tenante-in-commen in seid Conkling Lode Mining (
according to their respective interest theremn ae hereinbefore alleged
That the deserigtion of the beratron of sand Comklong Tok Mining
Claim, « described herein. i+ the <eme and identical desrrpte
as described im the a patented. That in and by a
description in amid patent. the buratien of the bender
ol said Conkling Lede Mining Claim can be readily traced aver
tained and determined upon the grownd, all of which hae, at ahd
the times herein mentioned, been well known to sad Kewrne hetth
siaing Company. ant to tw etna herein, as veur orate verily
believes evet «ince said Comkling Lede Mining Clim oe
XL.
the defendant herein and ity said Kearns hem
wg SS , to said twenty-second dav of Septem
her 1903 the actual time of which your orator has no mean d &
ceriaining), a your orator is informed and believes, did seemth
sstend a certain tunnel called the Alliance Tunnel through a
said Lode Mining Claim from the Northeast
boundary of sad claim to the southwest beundary of <«d elem
dn aay Gm omnes from said Alliance Tamme
“ underneath Ay.
sand i
the southwest corner of said Conkling Lede Mining ¢
Fé
]
2
Fi
i
te
ie
Fr
bei
14 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.
Conkling Lode Mining Claim, to-wit. said Nicholas Treweek and J.
Leonard Burch, became suspicious that there had been secret devel-
opments made in said Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims by
the said Kearns-Keith Mining Company, and thereafter, after said
merger, applied to said defendant for admission to any underground
workings beneath the surface of said Conkling and Arthur Lode
Mining Claims: that said application was refused by the said de
fendant. That thereafter, on or about the month of December,
1907, said Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Burch, as tenantsin-
common with the said defendant in said Conkling Lode Mining
Claim as aforesaid, demanded of said defendant an accounting for
their respective shares of the proceeds of any and all ores taken from
said Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims; that said defendant,
in response to said demand, expressed great surprise at the demand
made upon it as aforesaid, and reminded said Nicholas Treweek and
J. Leonard Burch that the defendant was a co-tenant with them in
the ground they claimed, viz.. the Conkling and Arthur Lode Min-
ing Claims, and also asserted that it had spent a great deal of money
in explorations, and claimed the right to remove and extract suf-
ficient ore, had there been any in the said Conkling and Arthur Lode
Mining Claims, to repay the said defendant for the money expended
in such expiorations, before the said Nicholas Treweek and J. Leon-
ard Burch, as tenants-in-common with said defendant, could set up
any claim for an accounting. That in reference to the demand
made for the privilege of entering the workings for the purpose of
making an examination and survey, the defendant asserted and con-
tended that such demand, so made, was not with the hope of finding
the conditions in reference to the defendant having mined ore in
said Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, as suspected,
16 but charged some ulterior and improper purpose or motive it
said demand and request so made by said Treweek and Bureb.
XIII.
Your orator further alleges that after the secret discovery by said
defendant and its grantor, Kearns-Keith Mining Co., of ore of great
value as aforesaid and within that portion of said Conkling
Mining Claim hereinbefore referred to as the southwest 135.5 feet
thereof, and said Kearns-Keith Mining Company, the predecessor
in interest and grantor of the defendant herein, as aforesaid, pmot
to the incorporation of the defendant, to-wit, in the years 1906
1907, made and caused to be made cunning efforts to purchase the
interest in said mining claims owned by said Treweek and
Burch, representing that said interests were of no special value,
offering to pay for said interest the sum of fifteen thousand dollars
($15,000.00) and no more. That the first suspicion said Treweek
and Burch had of t’ © possibility of there having been undergrou
developments made in said Conkling and Arthur Lode Miming
Claims as aforesaid, arose after the last attempt of said Kearns
Keith Mining Company to purchase their interest in said Conkling
and Arthur Lode Mining Claims for said sum of fifteen tho
| FF P. yr + se SR Te we
is a la BO ge an
—_
SILVER KING COALITION M. Co. VS. CONKLING M. Co. 15
dollars ($15,000.00), and after the purchase of said Custer No. 2
and Silver Hill No. 4 Mining Ciaims, as herein alleged.
XIV.
Your orator further alleges that after failing to purchase the in-
terest of said Treweek and Burch in said Conkling and Arthur Lode
Mining Claims are aforesaid. the defendant's said grantor, Kearns-
Keith Mining Company, did thereafter and during the month of
April, 1907, purchase from the Belmont Mining Company, a corpo-
ration, for a consideration not exceeding one hundred fifty thousand
dollars ($150,000.00), as your orator is informed and believes, the
Custer No. 2 and the Silver Hil] No. 4 Lode Mining Claims, then
wed by the said Belmont Mining Company, and took a convey-
ince for the same in the name of said Thomas Kearns, Trustee, who
ras then the President or Manager of said Kearns-Keith Mining
‘mpany. That upon the incorporation of the defendant herein
tid Thomas Kearns, as Trustee. wrongfully conveyed the said min-
ng claims, and the whole thereof, exclusively to the defendant
rein. That said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 lode mining
claims, Survey No, 4850, were. by Letters Patent dated June
« 2, 1904, granted from the United States of America to the
Belmont Mining Company. That said Patent was based
pon location notices antedating the location of said Conkling lode
ining claim. That as patented, said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill
0. 4 lode mining claims, overlap and include a large area of said
onkling lode mining claim as patented and described in the patent
ereof and herein, including within said overlap all of the area of
id Conkling lode mining claim included within the southwest 135.5
“strip thereof, except only a small area at the northwest corner of
id Conkling lode mining claim as herein described, and particu-
ny included within said overlap, all that portion of said 135.5 foot
np Wherein said ore was discovered and contained as aforesaid.
at during all of the period aforesaid, while the said Treweek
d Burch and the said Kearns-Keith Mining Company were ten-
fs in common as aforesaid in said Arthur and Conkling lode min-
g claims, the said Kearns-Keith Mining Company and said Tre-
ek and Burch were as tenants in common as aforesaid. in the
ual possession of said claims and each of them, to the full extent
darea thereof »s herein specifically described, including said south-
t 135.5 foot strip of said Conkling claim as herein described.
at said purchase from said Belmont Mining Company of said
ster No. 2 and Silver Hil] No. 4, was made as hereinbefore alleged
ile said Kearns-Keith Mining Company and said Treweek and
rch, as tenants-in-common. were in the possession as aforesaid of
Arthur and Conkling claims, including all the aforesaid over-
ping area thereof covered by said Custer No, 2 and Silver Hill
4 lode mining claims. That at and prior to the time of the
thase of said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 mining claims
Moresaid, no ore had been found or developed within the said
ms or either of them as your orator is informed and believes, ex-
16 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO,
cept the aforesaid ore bodies developed prior to said purchase within
raid area overlapping said Conkling mining claim as herein deseribed
and as patented, and as then and during all the times prior thereto
while said Treweck and Burch and said Kearns-Keith Mining Com
pany as tenants in common in said Conkling claim as aforesaid wer
as such tenants in common and not otherwise, in the lawful and
actual possession thereof as part and parcel of said Conkling lode
mining claim.
That until the purchase by the said Kearns-Keith Mining Com-
pany of the said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 lode min-
Is ing claims, neither the said defendant nor its said grantom
held or claimed any right or interest in or to the premise
described in the patent of said Conkling lode mining claim, or in or
to the lodes or veins within the boundary planes thereof as described
in said patent, or in or to the southwest 135.5 foot strip, or in or to
the lodes or veins therein, except the right and interest held by the
said defendant and its grantor, the said Kearns-Keith Mining Com-
pany. as tenant in common with your orator and its predecessors in
title under the patent and grant from the United States of America
of the Conkling mining claim hereinbefore set forth; and after said
purchase neither the said Kearns-Keith Mining Company, nor the
defendant, made any independent claim nor any claim at all ad
verse to your orator, or adverse to the said Treweek and Burch ino
to said premises or any part thereof until on or about the 11th day
of April, 1908.
That in the secret extension of said Alliance Tunnel as hereinbe
fore set forth and continuously during the progress of said work, the
said defendant and its said grantor carried on said work, claiming
to be so operating as tenants in common with your orator and your
orator’s predecessors in title, said Treweek and Burch, and for the
discovery and development of ore within the exterior boundaries &
tended downward vertically of said Conkling mining claim,
claimed of and from its co-tenants, payment and reimbursement out
of the ores developed in said Conkling mining claim for the cost and
expense incurred in said work. That while so carrying on said W
as such tenant in common as aforesaid and while claiming to k
carrying on the same for the development of said properties so
and claimed in common, and while claiming reimbursements, by
reason of said co-tenancy, out of the ores within said Conkling mit
ing claim for the cost and expense of extending said tunnel, the de
fendant’s said grantor, the said Kearns-Keith Mining Compat
secretly discovered said ore body within said 135.5 foot strip,
fraudulently contriving to deprive its co-tenants of their just
any proportion of the value of said ore, and contriving and in
ing to secure to the said defendant's grantors, the benefit of the wh
thereof, the said Kearns-Keith Mining Company secretly and
out informing the orator’s predecessors in title of the discovery ‘
said ores, purchased as aforesaid said Custer No. 2 and Silver
No, 4 mining claims, and thereafter held the same secretly,
after developing the said ground and fully ascertaining the
POE ETRE A OLE VELL EDICT OLE LE Df PTR NW ERI
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. Ys. CONKLING M. Co, 17
of said ore bodies and the value of the ore contained therein,—
19 for the first time made known to your orator’s predecessors in
title that the said Kearns-Keith Mining Company claimed
adversely said 135.5 foot strip, and for the first time. pretended and
claimed that said 135.5 foot strip was not within the boundaries or
planes of said Conkling mining claim.
That said Kearns-Keith Mining Company secured title to said
Custer No, 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 mining claims by reason of its
possession of said premises under its claim thereto as tenant-in-com-
mon and under its claim that the same was part of the Conkling
mining claim, and purchased said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No.
4 mining claims beeause of its knowledge obtained while extending
said tunnel (and while so in possession as tenant in common with
your orator’s predecessors in title) of the valuable ore body within
said 135.5 foot strip—contriving and intending by means of such
adverse claims, to deprive your orator and its predecessors in title
of the ore discovered and partially extracted and sold by the said
Kearns-Keith Mining Company while in possession of said prop-
erty and of said 135.5 foot strip as tenant in common with your
orator’s predecessors in title, the said Treweek and Burch. That
the said pretensions of the said defendant that the boundaries of said
Conkling lode mining claim as deseribed in the patent and herein
are not its true boundaries, but that the southwest 135.5 feet of said
Conkling lode mining claim. as the same is bounded and described
in the patent and herein, should not be included therein when located
upon the ground, constituted the first notice that said Treweek and
Burch, or either of them, ever had that any such claim, pretension
or contention existed, from any source whatsoever, That said ¢laim
and assertion first came to the notice or knowledge of said Treweek
or Burch, or either of them, on or about the 11th day of April,
1908, as your orator is informed and believes.
XV.
Your orator further alleges that under and pursuant to an order
f this Honorable Court, made herein on the thirtieth day of June,
1908, permitting the then complainants herein, Nicholas Treweek
ind J. Leonard Burch, with their experts, agents and surveyors, the
tee and unmolested right to enter upon the aforesaid underground
vorkings for the purpose, among other things, of measuring and
letermining the amount and value of the ore that had been mined
y the said defendant company underneath the surface of said
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, the said Treweek
0 and Burch were able for the first time to. and did, ascertain
the actual facts in respect to said secret underground workings
s aforesaid, underneath the surface boundaries of said Conkling Lode
lining Claim as described in said patent and herein, within planes
tended downward vertically, and of the location of the ore body
ithin said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, and the character and
Ment of the ore body developed therein, and of the importance
2—158
a REE NIT LEAL OTD III IES BAVOIEE TENA © amy omnia sate bait iat
—
18 SILVER KING COALITION M. ©O. VS. CONKLING M. CO.
and great value of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, which is only
valuable for the ores therein contained.
XVI.
Your orator further alleges, upon information and belief, that
the said defendant herein since it succeeded to the interest of said
Kearns-Keith Mining Company in said Conkling Lode Mining
Claim as aforesaid, and the said Kearns-Keith Mining Company
prior thereto and subsequent to its purchase aforesaid, and while
said companies were respectively as aforesaid tenants-in-common
with said Treweek and Burch in said Conkling and Arthur Lode
Mining Claims, and the discovery of ore therein and the extraction
and removal of ore from said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, for the
purpose of taking wrongful and undue advantage of said Treweek
and Burch, as co-tenants as aforesaid, endeavored to purchase their
said three-fourths interest therein for a trifling sum compared with
the actual value as then known exclusively to the said defendant
herein, and its said grantor, the Kearns-Keith Mining Company
XVII.
Your orator further alleges upon information and belief, that
said overlapping junior patented claims, to-wit, the Custer No. 2
and Silver Hill No. 4, were purchased as aforesaid without the
knowledge, acquiescence or consent of said Treweek and Burch, or
either of them, for the purpose and with the intention of defrauding
said Treweek and Burch, and your orator, as tenants-in-common
with the said defendant and its grantor, the Kearns-Keith Mining
Company, in said Conkling Lode Mining Claim as aforesaid, out of
their just and proper rights in the premises, and particularly from
that portion of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim wherein the prin-
cipal part and value of said ore, so secretly discovered as aforesaid, is
contained. Also that the attempt on the part of the defendant
herein to describe and locate the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim
so as to exclude the southwest 135.5 feet thereof, as aforesaid, is m
with a like intention and purpose, as your orator is informed
21 and believes. That neither your orator, nor its said grantors,
Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Burch, were ever noti
by said defendant or its grantor, Kearns-Keith Mining Company, 4
it and they were in duty bound to do, of said purchase of said Custer
No, 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Mining Claims, or permitted to partic
pate in said purchase. That ever since said purchase of said Custer
No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Claims as aforesaid, your orator since 1
incorporation has been, and prior thereto said Treweek and Bu
were, and your orator still is, ready, able and willing to pay ¢
contribute to the defendant for its proper share and proportion,
to-wit, three-fourths (34) of the purchase price paid to said Belmont
Mining Company for said claims, or such other or further sum as to
Your Honors may seem meet; and here and now offers to pay the
same as this Honorable Court may direct. That by reason of
NA TNE LN AR AN ee ee UTE —
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. Co. 19
purchase of said claims by said defendant, your orator is, and its
grantors have been, greatly and wrongfully prejudiced as tenants-
incommon as aforesaid with said defendant and its said grantor in
aid Conkling Lode Mining Claim.
XVIII.
And your orator further shows and alleges that the survey of
aid Conkling Lode Mining Claim purports to have been made in
November of the year 1889 by Adolph Jesson, now deceased, then
Deputy United States Mineral Surveyor; that all other persons con-
nected with the making of said survey of said Conkting Lode Mining
Claim are either dead or their whereabouts unknowia, as plaintiff is
informed and believes; that said Conkling Lode Mining Claim is
situated in a rough country, at a high altitude; that the surface is
cwered in part with large trees and thickets of brush and under-
growth; that the yearly snowfall in the winter is very great; that
none of the original marks and boundaries of said Conkling Lode
Mining Claim referred to in said patent are now standing; that the
mnginal place where the respective corners were marked, if marked
ital, is now only a matter of speculation. That the defendant herein
tas upwards of forty (40) miles of underground workings, as
your orator is informed and believes, which have been made by it
and the companies which it succeeded, as hereinbefore alleged, and
thereby its has, and they were enabled to secretly explore and de-
termine the course, strike and dip of the mineral bearing veins and
lodes, including the territory wherein the said Conkling Lode Min-
ing Claim is situated; and with such knowledge and information,
# gained, the said defendant and the said parties to which it suc-
ceeded as aforesaid have, as your grantor is informed and believes,
since secretly discovering said ore deposits, been secretly
2% scheming and designing ways and means, by the methods
hereinbefore alleged and otherwise, to attempt to secure to the
defendant exelusively, the said southwest 135.5 feet of said Conkling
lode Mining Claim, as described in said patent and herein, without
informing your orator, er its predecessors in interest, as tenants-in-
ommon in said Conkling Lode Mining Claim as hereinbefore alleged,
of any of its aforesaid secret acts, doings or intentions, thereby
kaving your orator, at this late date, entirely helpless in the premises
© meet the contentions now made by said defendant in reference to
the boundaries of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim being other
than as described in said patent and herein.
XIX.
And your orator further shows and alleges that the said defend-
ant’s duty, as tenant-in-common with your orator and its said prede-
‘sors in interest in said Conkling Mining claim, was and js to
protect the entire extent and area of said claim, as described in the
patent thereof, and secure, if possible so to do, the entire area thereof,
described in said patent, and not to destroy or defeat the same in
20 |
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO,
any manner or to any extent whatsoever, nor acquire or attempt
to acquire any adverse interests in and to the ground as bounded
and described in said patent and herein, or in or to the minerak
therein contained within planes bounded by the boundaries of said
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, as described in said
patent and herein, extended downward vertically.
That neither the Government of the United States nor any third
party, or party not interested in said Conkling Lode Mining Claim
as patented and described in the patent, does now dispute or con
test, or ever has disputed or contested, to the best of your orators
knowledge, information and belief, the exterior boundaries of said
Conkling Lode Mining Claim as described in the patent and in ths
Amended Bill of Complaint herein.
In Consideration Whereof and forasmuch as your orator has ne
sufficient remedy at law for the wrongs done and threatened to be
done, and that the remedy at law is inadequate and can afford no
protection to your orator against the unlewbal and wrongful clam
and assertions of said defendent, and the waste done and threatened
to be done for the reasons hereinbefore stated, and is only relievable in
a court of equity where matters of this kind are properly cognizable:
and reviewable. |
23 Your orator to the end that it may obtain the relief w
which it is justly entitled in the premises, Prays
Virst: That the defendant show, if it can, why your orator should
not have the relief prayed, and make full disclosure and discovery
of all the matters aforesaid, and, according to the best and utmost of
its remembrance, knowledge, information and belief, full, true, direct
and perfect answer make to the matters hereinbefore stated
charged, but not under oath, answer under oath being expresly
waived.
Second: That the defendant be required to set forth any and every
adverse interest, claim or demand in and to the said above described
premises as herein specifically bounded and described, and to the
ores and minerals therein contained, to the end that the same may be
justly adjudicated and declared null and void as against your orater,
except only as to an undivided one-fourth (%4) interest therein
tenant-in-common with your orator; and that the title and owner
ship of your orator to an undivided three-fourths (44) interest ™
said Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, as specifically here
inltefore described, and to the ores and minerals contained therm
vertically beneath the surface boundaries thereof as hereinbefore
deseribed, be established and confirmed as against any and all claim
of the said defendant, and all cloud thereon forever removed.
Third: That an accounting be taken by and under the directio®
and deeree of this Honorable Court, and the amount, quality
value of the ores and minerals removed by said defendant —
from said premises described as aforesaid be ascertained de
termined ; and that, upon such accounting being had and the value of
such ores ascertained and determined, your orator may be decreed 1
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. Co. 21
le the owner of three-fourths (*4) of the sum so ascertained, and
that the said defendant company be required to pay the same to
vour orator
Fourth: That your honors grant unto your orater your writ of
nyunetion, commanding the said defendant, its servants, agents and
mplovees, and all persons under its authority, direction or control.
wtil the tinal determination of this action, to absolutely desist and
mMrain from entering into or upon any portion of said Conkling and
Anhur Lode Mining Claims as hereinbefore described. or either of
them, and from working in or upon said premises or beneath the
arface thereof, or taking any ores or minerals therefrom at any point
upon or beneath the surface of said premises herein described
4 extended down vertically; or, that vour Honors in lieu of an
injunction as prayed for appoint a receiver pending the final
determination of this action, and that such receiver be empowered
ad authorized to enter into the joint or common possession of said
fokling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, as they are bounded and
teribed in this Amended Bill of Complaint, with the defendant
wmpany, and said receiver and said defendant company continue the
further mining and disposing of the ores now developed and that
my hereafter be found and developed Iving underneath the surface
¢said Conkling and Arthur-Lode Mining Claims, and confined be-
ween the vertical planes drawn down through the exterior bounda-
neof said mining claims as hereinbefore described under such suit-
ile provisions as vour Honors may deem best.
Fifth. That the said defendant be adjudged and decreed to have
jarchased and to hold the said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4
Mining Claims in trust for your orator and said defendant as tenants-
meommon in said Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims. ac-
ing to their respective shares, viz: an undivided three-fourths
‘4) interest for your orater and an undivided one-fourth (4)
Merest for said defendant.
And For Such Other And Further Relief as the equity of the case
may require, and as to vour Honors may seem meet. and for its costs
4suit in this behalf wrongfully expended.
CHARLES ©. DEY «&
A.C. HOPPAUGH,
’ Solicitors for |Complai.|
(Mrep STATES OF AMERICA,
District of Utah,
County of Salt Lake, ss:
J, Leonard Burch, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That he
San officer of the complainant herein, Conkling Mining Company,
wit: the treasurer thereof; that he has read the above and fore-
ang amended bill of complaint, and knows the contents thereof:
the same is true of his own knowledge, except as to matters
in stated on information and belief, and as to those matters he
it to be true.
(Signed ) J. LEONARD BURCH,
22 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.
25 Subscribed and sworn to before me this 29th day of June
[ z _—_ Signed G. W. PARKS
SEAL. (Si ) iW. S,
Notary Public.
My commission expires Jan’y 4, 1910.
Amended bill, filed July 5, 1909.
(Sgd.) JERROLD R. LETCHER,
Clerk.
(Replication to Amended Answer.)
This replicant, Conkling Mining Company, saving and reserving
to itself al! and all manner of advantages of exception which may le
had and taken to the manifold errors, uncertainties and insufficien
cies of the answer of the defendant Silver King Coalition Mines Com
pany, for replication thereunto says that it does and will aver, main
tain, and prove its said bill to be true. certain and sufficient in the
law to be answered unto by the said defendant, and that the answer
of the said defendant is very uncertain, evasive, and insufficient in
law to be replied unto by this replicant; without that, that any other
matter or thing in the said answer contained, material or effectual in
the law to be replied unto, and not herein and hereby well and at-
ficiently replied unto, confessed, or avoided, traversed or denied, is
true; all which matters and things this replicant is ready to aver.
maintain and prove as this honorable Court shall direct and humbly
prays as in and by its said bill it has already prayed.
CHARLES C. DAY,
A. L. HOPPAUGH.
Solicitors for Complainant.
Received copy of above replication this 2nd day of September,
1909
DICKSON, ELLIs, ELLIS &
SCHULDER,
Solicitors for Defendant.
Filed . 2, 1909.
JERROLD R. LETCHER,
Clerk.
(Stipulation In re Certain Pleadings.)
It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between William 1.
King, attorney for complainant herein, and Dickson, Ellis, Eilis 4
Schulder, attorneys for defendant herein. that the said de
26 fendant may file in said cause, the annexed amended answé
that the reply of the complainant to the answer now on file,
shall be treated and considered as the reply to said amended answef,
and that the verification of said reply, as originally filed, shall be
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. Co. 23
treated and considered as the verification of the reply to said amended
answer.
WILLIAM H. KING,
Attorney for Complainant
DICKSON, ELLIS, ELLIS &
SCHULDER,
Attorneys for Defendant.
Dated this —- day of December, 1911.
Filed Dec. 16, 1911.
JEROLD R. LETCHER,
Clerk.
(Order, December 16, 1911, Granting Leave to File Amended An-
awer, etc.)
At this day, on motion of W. H. Dickson, solicitor for defendant,
and pursuant to the stipulation filed herein, it is ordered that de-
fendant have leave to file an amended answer herein and that the
reply of the complainant to the answer now on file be treated and
considered as a reply to said amended answer, and that the veri-
fication to said nal be treated and considered as the verification of
the reply to said amended answer.
(Amended Answer to Arsended Bill of Complaint.)
Comes now the defendant above named, Silver King Coalition
Mines Company, and by leave of the court first had and obtained.
files this its amended answer to the amended Bill of complaint of
complainant above named:
This defendant, now and at all times hereafter, saving to itself all
and all manner of benefit of exception or otherwise that can or may
he had or taken to the many errors. uncertaintics and imperfections
in the said amended bill contained, for answer thereto or to so much
thereof ax this defendant is advised it is material or necessary for it
lo make answer to, answering says:
This defendant admits that on. or about the 17th day of Septem-
her, A. D. 1908, Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Burch, the orig-
inal complainants herein, caused the complainant to be incorpo-
rated under the laws of the State of Utah. and did thereupon
2 convey to said complainant corporation all of their right, title
and interest in and to the Conkling Lode Mining Claim, pat-
ented as U.S. Lot No. 689, and the Arthar Lode Mining Claim, pat-
ented as U. S. Lot No. 690, situated in the Uintah Mining District,
County of Summit, State of Utah. and did also assign and transfer
to said complainant corporation all manner of actions. causes of ac-
tion, suits, demands, controversy and accounting of every kind and
nature whatever in favor of said Treweek and Burch and against the
defendant herein, but as to whether or not the capital stock of said
Pa} SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. Co.
complainant corporation was paid for upon the incorporation of said
company by the conveyance of said above named mining claim, @
any interests therein. and by the assignment mentioned in said com.
t, this defendant has no knowledge or information thereof, and
ves said complainant to make such proof thereof as it may be ad
vised
This defendant admits that it i a corporation, organized and m
corporated under the laws of the State of Newada, on or about the
month of May, 1907, but denice that it was «0 organized for the
of taking over the KearnsKeith Mining Company or the tie
King a anne Company respectively, corporations.
This defendant admits that 1 -uceceded to the interest: theretofore
owned bw said Kearns-Keith Mining Company in and to the Arthar
and Conkling Lede Mining Claims, and that such interest war a
undivided one-fourth interest: therenn.
Admits that on the 22nd day of September, 1903, the sad Kearns
Keith Mining Company was the owner of «ad undivided one-fourth
interest in and to said Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims and
from thence continued to be the owner thereof until «uid Kearns
Kerth Mining Company conveved and transferred said interest to
the defendant above named, which said convevance or transfer wa
made on, to-wit: the Siet day of May A. 1D. 1907, and not on the
2%h day of May, 1907.
That as to whether or net one Nicholas Treweek was the owner
ef an undivided one-half interest in and to each of said Conkling
and Arthur lode Mining Cpiems, during all or any of the times thet
sad Kearns Keith Mining Company was the owner of an
one-fourth interest therem this defendant has neo knowledge or im
formation thereef. and leaves <anl complamn t to make <ach proof
thereof ax it maw be «o advieed: and as to whether the aid
2s Treweek, upon the transfer by «sid KearneKeith Mining
Company to the defendant herein was the owner of an a
divided one-half interest in said mining cGaims and each of them.
and from thence continued to be the owner of such interest in com
mon untt] the transfer bw him te the complamant herem, this de
fendant has no knowledge or information thereof, and leaves said
complainant to make such proof as it mav be advised.
That as to whether or not the «aid J. Leonard Burch was the
owner, on or about the 16th dav of May, 1906, or ever was, at any
other time. the owner of an undivided one-fourth interest In and
said Conkling and Arthur Lede Mining Claims, and that from
thence as such owner he became or was the tenant in common with
of them, antil the transfer bv said KearnsKeith Mining Company
of its interest in and to said claims to the defendant herein. and that
since the time of said tran<fer he ever was a tenant im commen
the defendant herein to «aid claims. or cithe: of them. until he tran
ferred his interest to the complainant herem. this defendant has pe
knowledge or inforination thereof. and therefore leaves «aid com
plainant to make such proof thereof as it may he advised.
This defendant admits that on or about the 23rd day of February,
SILVER KING COALITION M. OO. VS. CONKLING M. oo 25
Bo Minung Company, a anes, those certain prem-
called the Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claim reaper-
«tuated in the Uintah Mining Dictrict, County of Summit.
Utah, and that in said patent ssid Conklin Lede Mining
wularly bounded and described as yn the Sth para
said amended tall of complaint «1 forth. and that im and
of said patent the seid Arthur Lode Mining Cleim ix
parocularly bounded and described as «4 forth om <ard “1h paragraph
said amended complaint, but this defendant alleges that the de-
on and boundaries of said claims as = forth in seid fifth para-
gaph of said amended bill of complaint. are not « true or correct
description of either of said mining claim: as the «ame are hounded
and hirarted upon the ground by the permanent meno-
ments, oljerts and bearing-trees found upon the ground. and alleges
wokling Lode Mining Gaim, U.S Lot Ne. G®0. and
Arthur Lede Mining Claim, U. §. Lot No. G90, as the <ame are
wtually foand upon the grownd, are (artieularly dewribed and
3
gift?
os
?
:
Commencing at corner No. 2. the northeast corner of the
Conkling Claim and the northwest commer of the Artha:
a commen cornet of said Conkling and Arthar Claims. fron
U.S. Mineral Monument No. 4 bears North 32 dee. 52 win.
feet distant, thence from said cormer south G1 deg. 21
1364.5 feet to corner No. 3, the northwest corner of aid
im, thence south 2) deg. 0° min East GOO feet to
, the southwest corner of said Conkling Claim. thence
61 deg 21 min. Bact 1964.5 fret to cormer Neo 1. the eoth
of said Conkling Claw. and alee cormer No. 1 awd the
wathwest corner of said Arthur claim. and thenee north 76 deg.
East 951.8 feet to corner No. 4. the southeast corner of the
Arthur Claim, thence North 21 deg. 69 min. Weet G00 fret to corher
No. 3, the northeast corner of said Arthur Clam. and thence South
deg. 57 min. West 951 feet to «vid corner No 2. the northweat
Tums
a
ay
2
3h
25
2
i
iit
@f said Arthur Claim and the place of commencement of
The line of division between said mining claims
North 21 deg. and 9 min. West from «aid commen corner No
‘sad common corner No 2
This defendant admits beneath the surface and within the
enor boundanes, extended downward vertically, of each of said
miming claims. there is a lode of vein of rock on place, bearing silver,
kad and other valuable minerals, which. on ite course or strike
end: throughout the length of said claims: and admits that «aid
miming claims and each of them are valuable emly for the ores and
manera. therein contained, but thi< defendant alleges that ne part
© Pettion of the top or apex of the said lode or vein of rock m
Hace, fornatel beneath the surface of the «ard moning claims. as above
| , ound anywhere within the exterior howndaries ex-
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. 00.
ward vertically, of ortam other mining claine, owned and jxmsesmed
this defendant. a» heremafter wn thie answer more particularly
and described. which said other claim he northerly from
id Conkling and sad Anhur Mining claim
! denies that ever since the ime wn of te
dcfendant, it has been, of «ill is, of ever wae, mm the powrsnon d
the vein or lode described in the amended complamt herem. «#
within or beneath the boundaries of either the «aid Conkling «
Arthur Lede Mining Claims. or all of any of the ores of miner
heremafter alleged. and denies that te
or has been, since the incorporation of said defendant, work
and
|
ing any vein or lode within the boundares
i Arthur Lode Mining Clarms. extended downward
vertically, or is, or ever has been, extracting any ores or tmineta
therefrom, except that from the vern or bode so apexing ax afcreud
in other mining claine owned by thie defendant it extracted from
t ace of the «aid Conkling Lede Mining Clana ne
to exceed 990 tons of ore, of all grades or classes. And thie detent
ant alleges that the + A all the ore hitherto mvimed ty the &
within the surface beundane: extended downward
vertically, of the «vid Conkling Mining Clann. after deducting there
from the reasemable and necessary cost and expense of mrning am
rr gee te hey ores, dows net exceed the eam of 2094750. Ant
this further alleges that the reasonable and recesaty
cost and expense incurred by it im the discovery and develqment
of all ores hitherto mined of removed by it from within the extene
boundaries, extended downward vertically. or the «sid Conkling
exceeds the cum of 72.500. And thie defendet
i _ at ane time hitherto, mined o &
ahs ores whatever from within the extersar beuwndenes. 6
y, of the «aid Arthar Lode Mining Cham
this defendant deme= that the <ad Kearns Kerth Mining (om
time, wae in powewion of eaid vein of lode «
minerals therein. wrthon or beneath the
id Conkling of the Arthur Loly Woe
ever wae werking of develaping the «am
mineral therefrom «hatever
.
et
Ib reaal
He
iit :
z
[
:
j
e
h
i
I
tf
f
:
Hy
é
;
:
|
a.
SILVER KING COALITION M. OO. VS. CONKLIXG M. Co. 7
said Arthur Lode Mining Claims, except ax hereinbefore ad-
mitted , and denies that the ores <0 extracted by «aid defend-
ant from beneath the earface of «aid Conkling Mining Claim.
heremnbefore admitted. exceed the sum of one million dollars. or
other sam whatever. except $20,017 50. and this defendant al-
mi herennbed one - + that the reasonable and meee
and meurred by it in the diseowery and develop-
all said ores, = heretofore mined by it from within the
ver boundaries extended downward vertically. of the «aid Conk-
exceeds the sum of 872.500. And thie defendant denies
A sad complainant, pret to the commencement
id demand from «aid defendant. that it account to
im commen. with « of «id mining aime. of the
by it and its grantors remmeved from said prem-
dispemed of. or for thew jut and proper share or value
bot admits that «aid complainant sued it. predecessors did
that «aid defendant account to them for ore~ and rinerals
ed by sand defen tant from property and premises
neither said complainant wor any of ite Ptekcrssore in
ever, at any tre. hed any estate. right. tith of intereet what-
And this defendant adwite that after the Meorperation of
inant and after it suceeded to the rights and interests
Nicholas Treweek and J. Leonard Barely in and to the
ling Arthar Mining Claim. it did. on of ahout the
y of November. 1907, demand an accounting by thie de-
val the ores mined by it from ben-ath the «ur-
Conkling Mining Claim.
: endant many hee entirely ignored «aid
tee
;
8
5
rif
il
Alt
Rit
.
:
:
a
Re
i
tt
t
and negh te make anewer thereto. and
to said complainant for the value of the ones
from teneath the «urface of «aid Conkling
has been, obligated to account to <add complain
ite predecessors in interest for any ores mined oF
it from thenenth the surface of the «aid Conkling Ide
any other mining clan then owned. held or
complainant. or any of its predeceors in interest.
admits that it arts, pretend: and claims an
» RA a tenant in common with the complainant
in and to the southwest 125.5 feet of the premise attempted
described in sand complaint as a part and portion
said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, adverse to «aid com.
plainant, and admits that it claim and asserts that it has
exclusive right and ownership of all the ores contained
im. within + estemded downward vertically from
hines deseribed in the tenth paragraph of «aid amended bill of
emplaint. and adits that «uid defendant lee given out in «peech
it hae the exclusive right to enter in aad upon
remove therefrom. without accounting to «aid
tenant in commen with it, ax aforesaid, or ather-
ownetship of the said premise in which said ores
ere
Erprds: ie
es il
:
|
¢ # as
iy
a
28 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.
and minerals are contained; and admits that it asserts that the
boundaries of the said Conkling Mining Claim, as described in said
amended complaint herein, are not the proper boundaries thereof,
to the extent of including the said 135.5 feet, alleged by said com-
plainant to be embraced within the boundaries of said Conkling
Mining Claim; but this defendant denies that any part or portion
of said 135.5 feet, so owned by this defendant as aforesaid. belongs
to or is embraced within the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim,
and denies that the Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining
Claims, mentioned in said tenth paragraph of said complaint, so
far as said 135.5 feet are concerned, overlap or conflict at all with
said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, and this defendant denies that
its claims and pretensions as to the ownership of said 135.5 feet
are false or untrue or unfounded in faet; and denies that by reason
of any of the facts alleged in said amended bill of complaint, said
defendant ought not to be permitted to vary the location or bound-
aries of the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim upon the ground,
as the same are deseribed in said amended bill of complaint, or to
assert an interest adverse to said complainant in and to said 135.5
feet; and denies that said defendant should be held as trustee of
the title of any part or portion of said Custer No. 2 or the Silver
Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims. for the benefit of said complain-
ant, as a tenant in common with said defendant, or otherwise, or
at all.
This defendant denies that the description of the location of said
Conkling Mining Claim, as described in said amended bill, is the
same or identical description, as described in the patent and as pat-
ented, and on the contrary this defendant alleges that the true de-
seription of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, is as appears from
the patent and the field notes, which are a part thereof, and the
return of the surveyor making the said survey of the said Conkling
Lode Mining Claim; that a true and correct description of said
Conkling Lode Mining Claim is as hereinbefore in this answer set
forth; and this defendant denies that in and by the deserip-
33 tion contained in said amended bill of complaint, the loca-
tion of the boundaries of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim
can be readily or at all traced, ascertained or determined upon the
ground, and denies that said or any alleged tracing. from the de-
scription set forth in said amended complaint of said Conkling Lode
Mining Claim, at all or any of the times mentioned in said amended
bill of compalint, was well or at all known to said Kearns Keith
Mining Company, or to this defendant, or to any other person oF
persons whomsoever, and this defendant admits that ever since said
Conkling Mining Claim was patented, the owners of said claim have
never had any disputes or contention over, or disturbance of their
ownership or right of possession of said Conkling Lode Mining
Claim, as the same is located upon the ground: but denies that the
said Conkling Lode Mining Claim is or can be located upon the
ground as the same is described in said amended complaint herein,
and alleges that said Conkling Lode Mining Claim. as the same exists
upon the ground, as determined by the monuments, permanent
POLE LEI SL EOS, RDA TARO Rea Rae at UE POR AE BA) OED
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 29
jects and bearing-trees called for in the filed notes of the survey of said
daim, cm! races the premises and none [others], as the same are de-
stibed hereinbefore in this answer, and do not inelude any part or
portion of said 135.5 feet, claimed by the complaint herein, and that
the said premises as described herein, exclusive of said 135.5 feet,
are the premises had and held hy this defendant and its predecessors
in interest and the other owners of said claim, as tenants in common
with this defendant and its predecessors in interest, without dispute
or contention, and that no contention as to the loeus of said Conk-
ling Lode Mining Claim was ever at any time made or communicated
to this defendant, or any of its predecessors in interest. until the
filing of the complaint in this action and the alleged description
thereof, as set forth in said complaint, and denies that this defend-
ant has been guilty of any wrongful acts or conduct whatever, or
that its grantor and predecessor in interest, Kearns Keith Mining
Company, has been guilty of any wrongful act or conduct what.
ever. And this defendant denies that it or its predecessor in in-
rest, the Kerns Keith Mining Company, or any other person
whomsocver, at any time whatever, either before or after the 22nd
day of September, 1903, extended secretly the Alliance Tunnel,
or any other workings through or underneath the Conkling Lode
Mining Claim, as alleged in said complaint or otherwise, or that
they, or either of them, secretly drove any cross-cut or other
Od working from said Alliance Tunnel. or otherwise, to or
hear the southwest corner of said Conkling Lode Mining
Claim, as the same is described in said patent, or in said amended
complaint.
This defendant admits that the openings underneath the surface
and within the boundary planes of the Conkling Lode Mining Claim,
extended downward vertically, can be entered through the main shaft
of the Silver King Mining Company, and from the levels and drifts
therefrom, or through said Alliance Tunnel, and that said shaft,
drifts, levels and said Alliance Tunnel are under the exclusive con-
ttl and ownership of the defendant, and were under the exclusive
ownership and control of the said Silyer King Mining Company,
with the reserved right in said Thomas Kearns, as alleged in said
amended complaint, until the incorporation of the Kearns Keith
Mining Company. And this defendant denies that in drifting and
extending the cross-cut from said Alliance Tunnel, and prior to the
‘nveyance by said Kearns Keith Mining Company, the said Kearns
Keith Mining Company secretly discovered or explored a large or
ay valuable ore deposit. And denies that this defendant, or its
wid grantor, have made extensive or any stoping, or secretly removed
tom any part or portion of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim ore
of the value of $1,000,000, or any other sum, except the sum of
$20,047.50, as hereinbefore in this answer alleged. And this defend-
int denies that the description of the said Conkling Lode Mining
wim, as asserted and claimed by this defendant herein, is such that
tis within the boundary planes of the said Conkling Lode Mining
‘um, as alleged to be deseribed in the patent thereof, extended
waward vertically, and denies that the 135.5 feet, claimed by said
30 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.
complainant in said amended bill of complaint to be part and pareel
of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim is any part or portion thereof,
or belongs thereto, or that said complainant, or any of its predecessors
in interest, have any estate, right, title or interest in or to any part or
portion of said 125.5 feet, or in or to any part or portion of the ores
or minerals therein contained, vertically beneath the surface thereof,
And this defendant denies that the value of the ores found or dis
covered within the planes extended downward vertically of said
[130.0] foot strip is mot less than the suum of $2,500.00, or of any
greater Value than the sum of $52,681.00, And this defendant
denies that all or any of the underground work or discovery of ore,
or removal of ore, by it, was intentionally or wrongfully or at all
kept secret by this defendant, or its predecessors in interest from said
complainant, or any of its predecessors in interest, Nicholas Treweek
or J, Leonard Burch, or any other person. And this defend
30 ant alleges that as to what suspicions the predecessors in in-
terest of said complainant had, this defendant has no knowl
edge or information thereof, and leaves said complainant to make
proof as it may be advised. And this defendant denies that it re
fused permission to said predecessors in interest of said complainant
to inspect the underground workings beneath the surface of the said
Conkling and Arthur Mining Claims, and this defendant admits
that on or about the month of December, 1907, the said Nicholas
Treweek and J. Leonard Bureh demanded of this defendant an
accounting for the proceeds of any or all ores taken from said
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, but this defendant denies
that this defendant expressed great or any surprise at any demand
which said Treweek or said Burch might make upon it for ores
mined by it from its property, and admits that it Poo eal the said
Treweek and Burch that it had spent a great deal of money in et
ploration and claimed the right to remove and extract suflicient ore
to repay it for the money expended in such explorations before said
Nicholas Treweek and said J. Leonard Burch, or either of them,
would be entitled to have or receive, as tenants in common with said
defendant, any accounting whatever from said defendant.
This defendant denies that the said Kearns Keith Mining Com-
pany at any time after the diseovery of ore, as alleged in the thir-
teenth paragraph of said amended bill of complaint, or otherwise, of
at all, made or caused to be made cunning or any efforts to purchase
the interests in said mining claims owned by said Treweek and said
Burch, or either of them, or that said Kearns Keith Mining Com
pany, or any one on its behalf, represented that said interests were
of no special value, or that they offered to pay for said interests 1
the sum of $15,000 and no more; but this defendant alleges that it 1s
a fact that the interest of said Treweek and said Burch at said time,
and of said complainant, in and to said Conkling and Arthur
Mining Claims, was at said time, and is now of no great value, for
the reason that there has been discovered in and beneath the surface
of said mining claims no ores of any special or great value, and that
the ores which have been discovered therein belong to and are part
and parcel of a vein or lode having its apex in mining ground aD
_—
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. ys. CONKLING M, Co. 31
premises owned, held) and possessed by this defe
incorporation, and prior thereto, by its prede
jereinafter partieularly set forth and alleged, and as to when the
tid Treweek and the said Bureh first lad uny suspicion, as alleged
othe 13th paragraph of said complaint, this defendant has no
noWledge or information, and therefore leaves the said complainant
lo make such proof thereof as it may be advised.
‘i This defendant, ayswering paragraph numbered 14 of said
amended bill of complaint, denies that after any failure what-
ver, at anv time whatever, to purchase any interest of said Treweek
nd Burch, or either of them, in said Conkling and Arthur Lode
ining Claims, as alieged in said amended bill of complaint, or
herwise, or at all, the said Kearns Keith Mining Company did,
wing the month of April, 1907, or at any other time. or at all,
wehase from the Belmont Mining Company, a corporation, for the
nsideration named in said amended complaint, or any other eon-
leration Whatever, the Custer No. 2 and the Silver Hill No. 4 Lode
ining Claims, or either of them. then owned by said Belmont Min-
g Company, or took a conveyance or the same, or either of them,
the name of Thomas Kearns. trustee,
ndant, since its
‘CCSS0rs in interest, as
or any other person whom-
ver, and denies that upon the incorporation of this defendant.
read Thotias Kearns, as trustee. Wrongfully conveyed the said
ning claims, or either of them, exclusively to the defendant
min, and to the contrary this defendant alleges that on or about,
wit: the 6th day of April, 1907, the said Thomas Kearns, individ-
lly, and for and on his own behalf, took and received an assign-
it of an option theretofore viven and granted by the Belmont
wing Company to one D, P. Rohiting, to purchase the said Custer
-2 und the said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims: that
rafter und on or about the LOth day of April, 1907, the said
ous Kearns did offer to the Silver King Mining Company, a
portion, to assign and transfer to it the said option to purchase,
s aforesaid assigned to him, and on, to-wit: the said 10th day of
il, 1907, the said Silver King Mining Company did duly accept
offer of the said Thomas Kearns, and did thereupon pay to the
| Belmont Mining Company, the portion of the conshderetion to
paid to it, pursuant to the terms of said option, and did there-
n direct that the deed from said Belmont Mining Company
ld be taken in the name of said Tuomas Kearns, as trustee for
Silver King Mining Company, to he conveyed by him to the
inee of said Silver King Mining Company; that on to-wit: the
i day of April, 1907, the said Belmont Mining Company did
ute a deed of conveyance to said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No.
Me Mining Claim, conveying the said claims and each of them
the said Thomas Kearns, trustee, and that thereafter and upon
Reorporation and organization of this defendant, and on, to-wit:
~ day of June, 1907, at the request and pursuant to the
‘ment entered into by and between the said Thomas Kearns
and the said Silver King Mining Company, the said
homas Kearns did convey the said Custer No. 2 and the
said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims to this defendant,
32 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M, CO,
and that on said day this defendant did complete the purchase of
said mining claims and each of them, by paying the ialenens of the
purchase price then due thereon to the said Belmont Mining Com-
pany; that at ne time whatever did said Kearns Keith Mining Com-
pany acquire, have, hold or possess any estate, right, title or interest,
of. in or to the said Custer No, 2 and the said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode
Mining Claims, or either of them, or in or to any part or portion d
either of them: that ne part of the purchase price of said mining
claims, or erther of them, was paid or discharged by sai- Keams
Keith Mining Company, or any one on its behalf, but that the title
to said mining claims was purchased and paid for by said Silver King
Mining Company and this defendant, as aforesaid, for the sole ux
and benefit of said Silver King Mining Company and this defendant,
and not otherwise; and this defendant admits that the said Custer
No. 2 and said Silver Hill No, 4 Lode Mining Claims were by letters
patent of the United States, dated June 2nd, 1904, granted to the
Belmont Mining Company, and admits that said patent was haved
upon location notices antedating the location of said Conkling Lode
Mining claim: and this defendant denies that the said Custer No.2
and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims overlap or include any
part or portion of the area of the said Conkling Late Mining Claim,
included within the said 135.5 foot strip thereof, as set forth
de-eribed in said amended complaint, and wrongfully claimed by
said complainant to be part and pareel of the said Conkling Lode
Mining Claim: and denies that anv part or portion of said 135.5 foot
strip is embraced within or described or forms any part or portion
of the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim.
This defendant denies that at all or any of the times mentioned
in said amended bill of complaint, or while the said Treweek
Bureh and the said Kearns Keith Mining Company were tenat's
in common in said Arthur and Conkling Lode Mining Claims, that
either the said Kearns Keith Mining Company, or the said T
or Burebh were, as tenants in common, as alleged in said a
bill of complaint, or otherwise, or at all, in the actual, construc
tive or any possession whatever of any part or portion of the
125.5 foot strip of the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, a #
forth and alleged in said amended bill of complaint, or otherwise
and deniex that the purchase by the said Thomas Kearns and thi
defendant and said Silver King Mining Company, as herein-
38 before alleged, of said Custer No, 2 and said Silver Hill
No. 4 Lode Mining Claims, or either of them, from said ,
mont Mining Company, was at all made while said Kearns Keith
Mining Company, or said Treweek or said Burch, as tenants @
common of said Arthur and Conkling Lode Mining Claims, or erthe
of them. were in the possession of any part or portion of the
125.5 foot strip, mentioned in said amended complaint, or other
wise, and denies, as it has heretofore denied, that said Kearns
Mining Company and said Treweek and said Burch were tenants
in common of any part or portion of said 125.5 foot strip, or t
any part or portion of eaid 125.5 foot strip ever was, at any time,
part or pareel of the -aid Conkling Lode Mining Claim; 4
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO. 33
defendant denies that at the time of the purchase by said Thomas
Kearns, Trustee, of said Custer No. 2 and said Silver Hill No. 4
Lode Mining Claims, that any ore bodies whatever had been found
or discovered within any part or portion of said 135.5 foot strip,
and alleges that no ore was developed or found within said 135.5
foot strip until long after the purchase of said Custer No. 2 and
Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims, and the conveyance thereof
to this defendant, as hereinbefore alleged, and denies, as it has here-
inbefore denied, that said Kearns Keith Mining Company and said
Treweek and said Bureh ever were, at any time whatever, tenants
in common, the one with the other, in or to any part or portion of
said 135.5 foot strip, or in or to any of the ores or ore bodies therein
contained, and this defendant denies, as it has hereinbefore denied,
that said Kearns Keith Mining Company, ever, at any time whatever,
purchased said Custer No. 2 or said Silver Hill No, 4 Lode Mining
Claim, and admits that neither this defendant, nor any of its grantors,
held or claimed any right or interest in or to any part or portion of
aiid 135.5 foot strip until the purchase and conveyance to this
defendant of the same, as part and parcel of said Custer No. 2 and
Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims, as hereinbefore alleged ; but
this defendant denies that this defendant and its grantors and prede-
cessors in interest did not have any right, tithe or ownership in or
to the lodes or veins in said Conkling Lode Mining Claim, as here-
inbefore in this answer described, and in and to the ores and veins
in said 135.5 foot strip aforesaid, part and parcel of said Custer No.
2 and said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claim; and on the con-
trary this defendant alleges that it and its predecessors in interest,
at all times alleged and claimed that it and its predecessors in inter-
et were the owners of and entitled to all the ore bodies, veins and
lodes in and beneath the surface of the said Conkling Lode
39 Mining Claim and the said Arthur Lode Mining Claim and
said 135.5 foot strip, by reason of its and its predecessors in
interest, ownership of the apex of the veins or lodes in which such
ore bodies are found, as hereinafter in this answer specifically set
forth and alleged. And this defendant denies that either it, or any
of its predecessors in interest, have been, at any time whatever, or
how is. a tenant in common with said plaintiff or any of its prede-
cessors in interest of, in or to any part or portion of said 135.5
foot strip, or any of the ores found or contained therein. And this
defendant admits that said Kearns-Keith Mining Company never
made any independent claim, or any claim whatever, to any part or
portion of said 135.5 foot strip, or any of the ores or minerals
therein contained: but this defendant denies that it and its prede-
cessors in interest made no independent or other claim adverse to
said complainant, or any of its predecessors in interest, in or to said
135.5 foot strip, or any part thereof, until the 11th day of April,
1908, and on the contrary this defendant alleges that it and its prede-
cesors in interest have at all times since procuring the title to said
No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims, as aforesaid,
daimed and asserted title adverse to all the world, in and to said
135.5 foot strip and to all the ores and minerals, veins and lodes
3—158
34 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING MW. OO,
therein contained. And this defendant denies that it has nade any
secret extension whatever of the said Alliance Tunnel, a« set forth
in said amended bill of complaint, or otherwise, and denies that it
or any of its grantors or predecessors in interest, carried on any work
in said Alliance Tunnel, or otherwise, as tenants in commen with
said complainant, or any of its predecessors in tithe or interest, or fer
the discovery or development of any ore within the exterior bow
daries, extended downward vertically, of said Conkling Mining
Claim, or claimed of or from its co-tenants any payment or rem
bursement whatever out of any ores developed in said Conkling
Mining Claim, for the cost or expense incurred in said work: and
this defendant denies that while carrying on any work whetever,
as tenant in common with said complainant, or any of ite predece
sors in interest, or while claiming to be carrying on any work what
ever for the development of any properties held or claimed in com
mon by them, or either of them, or while claiming any reinhune
ment whatever by reason of such co-tenancy, or otherwise, or at all,
out of any ores within said Conkling Mining Claim, for the ect
or expense of extending said tunnel, or otherwise said defendants
grantor, Kearns Keith Mining Company, or any other pet
Ww son or corporation whatever, secretly or at all discovered any
ore body whatever within said 135.5 foot stryp, or fraudulently
or otherwise, contriving to deprive any of its eotenant = of ther
just or any proportion of the value of any ore, of comtriving orm
tending to secure to this defendant's grantors, the benefit of the
whole or any part thereof, the said Kearns-Keith Moning Conary
secretly, without informing said complainant's predecessors in tithe
of the discovery of any ores, or otherwise, or at all, purchased end
Custer No. 2 or said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Cline, or either
of them, or thereafter, or at all, held the same seeretly of otherwne,
or after developing the said ground and fully ascertaiming the «
tent of said ore bodies, or the value of the ore contained therem,
otherwise, or at all, for the first or any time made known to ad
complainant's predecessors in title that the said Kearns Kerth Mining
Company claimed adversely or otherwise, said 185.5 foot strip, of
for the first time, or at all, pretended or claimed that said 155 feet
strip was not within the boundaries or planes of said Conkling Lede
Mining Claim. And on the contrary this defendant alleges thet
no time whatever did said Kearns-Keith Mining Company have any
estate, right, title or interest whatever in or to said 15.5 foot strip,
and that no ore whatever was found or developed in said 135.5 foot
strip, until long after the purchase and conveyance to this defendant
by said ‘Kearns, trustee, of said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill Ne
4 Lode Mining Claim, as hereinbefore alleged. And thie defendant
denies that said Kearns-Keith Mining Company ever, at any time
whatever, secured title to said Custer No. 2 or said Silver Hill Ne
4 Mining Claims. And denies that it ever was In possesion of any
part or portion of the said 135.5 foot strip. And denies that said
Kearns-Keith Mining Company ever made any claims whatever @
said 125.5 foot strip, or any part thereof, as any part or
of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim. And denies that said Kearns
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. Co. 35
Keith Mining Company ever contrived or intended by any adverse
daim or assertion whatever, to deprive said complainant, or its pre-
decewors in tithe, of any ores discovered in or beneath the surface of
aid 135.5 foot strip; and denies that any ore was discovered in said
135.5 foot strip by seid Kearns Keith Mining Company, or by any
aher person or corporation than this defendant, as hereinbefore
wt forth and alleged. And this defendant denies that the claims and
assertions of this defendant that the beuwndaries of said Conkling
Lade Mining Claim, as the same are set forth in swid amendéd bill of
complaint, and in the patent to said Conkling Lode Mining Claim,
without reference to the field notes of the survey of said claim
4! (which form and are a part of said patent) are not its true
boundaries, and that the sad 135.5 foot strip in said amended
complaint mentioned, should not be included in the said Conkling
Lede Mining Claim, when located upon the ground, constituted or
was the first notice that said Treweek and said Burch, or either of
them, ever had that any such claim or assertion existed from any
wuree Whatever, And on the contrary this defendant alleges that
stall times, both said complainant and said Treweek and said Burch
have had full and complete notice that the said 135.5 foot «trip was ne
part or parcel of the said Conkling Lede Mining Claim, as the sume
tas located upon the growed, and never at any tome made any
dam or contention that the said trip was any part or portion of
aid Conkling Lode Mining Claim until just prior te the commence-
ment of this suit
Answering paragraph numbered 15 of said amended bill of com
plaint, thie defendant admits that the «vid Treweek and Burch did
weertain the actual facts and the whole thereof with vect to the
underground works beneath the surface boundaries of the said
Conkling Lode Mining Claim, and the character and extent of the
ote developed therein, and did ascertain the fact to be that no part
or portion of the ores and minerals found and developed in the said
135.5 foot strip belonged to or was beneath any part or portion of the
aid Conkling Lode Mining Claim, and did ascertain the fact that
all of the ores and minerals contained im said 135.5 foot strip, were
outside of and bevond the exterior boundaries of <aid Conkling Lode
Mining Claim.
Answering paragraph numbered 16 of said amended bill of com-
Maint, this defendant denies cach and every allegation therein con-
This defendant admits that the said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill
No. 4 Lode Mining Claims were purchased by this defendant with-
oat the knowledge, acquiescence or consent of said Treweek or Burch,
@ either of them, but denies that such purchase was made for the
Parpese, or with the intention of defrauding said Treweek or Burch,
@ mid complainant in any way whatever, as tencnts in common
with this defendant, or its grantor, the KearnsKeith Mining Com-
pany. or either said Conkling or said Arthut Lode Mining Claims,
@ out of their just or proper rights in the premises, or otherwise, or
Or to any part or portion of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim,
in any ores or minerals whatever, of any value whatever, have
=e 8 ON ee eRe Ser FTE mee
36 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.
been found or discovered. And denies that this defendant
42 has made any attempt whatever to describe or locate the said
Conkling Lode Mining Claim, so as to exclude said 135.5 foot
strip therefrom, or has located or attempted to locate said Conkli
Lode Mining Claim otherwise than in accordance with the
facts, and as said claim appears upon the ground, from the perma
nent monuments, posts, ties and bearing-trees thereof. And this de
fendant denies that it has done, or caused to be done any act o
thing. with any intention or purpose to defraud said complainant,
or any of its grantors or predecessors in interest, in any manner
whatever, and this defendant admits that neither this defendant, nor
said Kearns-Keith Mining Company ever notified the said Treweek
or the said Burch, or said complainant of the purchase by this de
fendant of said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining
Claims, or permitted them, or either of them, to participate in such
purchase ; and denies that either this defendant or any of its grantor:
or predecessors in interest was under any obligation or duty whatever
to notify either the said Burch or said Treweek or said complainant
of any sale or purchase whatever of said Custer No. 2 or said Silver
Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims. That as to whether since the pur
chase of said Custer No. 2 and said Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining
Claims by this defendant, as hereinbefore alleged, said complainant,
since its incorporation, has been, or prior thereto said Treweek a
Burch were, or said complainant now is, ready, able or willing to pay
or contribute *4 of the purchase paid by this defendant for said
aforesaid mining claims, this defendant has no knowledge or infor-
mation thereof, and leaves said complainant to make such proof
thereof as it may be advised.
This defendant denies that by reason of the purchase by this de
fendant of said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining
Claims, said complainant has been, or now is, or either or anv of
its grantors have been, greatly or wrongfully or at all, prejudiced
in any way whatever, as tenants in common of said Conkling Lode
Mining Claim, as hereinbefore described, or otherwise, or at all.
Answering paragraph numbered 18 of said amended bill of com-
plaint, this defendant admits that the survey of the Conkling Lode
Mining Claim was made in the month of November of the vear 1889
hy Adolph Jessen, now deceased, then Deputy United States Mineral
Surveyor, but that as to whether all other persons connected with
the making of said survey of said Conkling Lode Mining Claim,
are dead, or their whereabouts unknown, this defendant has
43 no knowledge or information thereof, and therefore leaves
o said complainant to make such proof thereof as it may be ad-
vised.
This defendant admits that said Conkling Lode Mining Claim #
situated in a rough country, at a high altitude, and that the surface
is covered partly by large trees and brush and undergrowth, and
that the yearly snow-fall in the winter thereat is great, but this de
fendant denies that none of the original marks or boundaries of sai
Conkling Lode Mining Claim, referred to in said patent, is now
standing, and denies that the original place where the respective
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. Co. 37
corners were marked, is now a matter of speculation merely; and to
the contrary thereof this defendant alleges that some of the original
pests and monuments, marking the boundaries of said Conkling
Lode Mining Claim, are now standing in place in their original po-
sition. and that they are the permanent objects referred to in the field
notes of said survey of said Conkling Mining Claim, with the proper
markings thereon, now standing in their original position, and that
certain bearing-trers, identifying and locating the position of the
original monuments of said claim, are now standing, properly
marked. and have been ever since the said survey was made, as afore-
aid, and that the original position upon the ground of <aid Conkling
Lede Mining Claim can be definitely and accurately determined
from the permanent objects, monuments, bearing-trees and other
references found in the field notes of the survey of said claim and
upon the ground where said premises are located; and this defend-
ant denies that it, ur: any of its predecessors in interest, by any means
whatever, have heen secretly, or at all, scheming or designing, by
any Ways or means whatever, or by any methods whatever, except as
hereinhefore in this answer set forth and alleged, to secure to this
defendant exclusively, or at all, the said 135.5 foot strip of ground
hereinbefore mentioned and referred to, and that the only means or
method used by this defendant, or any of its sag epee in Interest
of title, to secure said 135.5 foot strip, was by the purchase by it
from said Belmont Mining Company of the said 135.5 foot strip,
part and parcel of said Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Min-
ing Claims, conveyed to it by said Thomas Kearns, trustee, as afore-
«aid; and this defendant denies that any part or portion of said 155.5
foot strip belongs to, or is part or parcel of, said Conkling Lode Min-
ing Claw, as deseribed in said patent, or otherwise. And this de-
fendant admits, as it has heretofore admitted, that it purchased the
wid Custer No. 2 and Silver Hill No. 4 Lode Mining Claims, enm-
bracing said 135.5 toot strip. without informing said com-
4 piainant, or any of its predecessors in interest: and this de-
fendant denies, as it has heretofore denied, that either said
complainant, or any of its predecessors in interest have been at any
time whatever the tenant in common with this defendant, or any of
its predecessors in interest, of, in or to any part or portion of said
185.5 foot strip, or any of the ores or mine¥als, lodes or veins therein
comtained. And this defendant denies that by reason of any act or
thing done or omitted by this defendant, or any of its predecessors
M mterest, said complainant, or any of its predecessors in interest,
at this late date, or any other date, have been left entirely or at all
pless to meet the contentions now made by said defendant in refer-
ence to the boundaries of the said Conkling Lode Mining Claim: and
m the contrary this defendant alleges that said complainant and its
predecessors in interest have at all times been fully able to ascertain
and determine the true and correct boundaries of said Conkling
Mining Claim, as the same exists upon the ground, and that
said complainant, or any of its predecessors, had gone upon the
found. it or they, at any time since the survey of said Conkling
Mining Claim, in the year 1889, as aforesaid, could and would
>. esanenseetndiiteentetanmentninantatinetmemianneniitia ated
SILVER KING COALITION M. OO. V8. CONKLING M. Co.
ZF in
vapeegtecegert ntnyy ee tennant
cans a
Hith Myiihy
Ht se
Hybigsesae dp iP
geeeiedhe ae pit itis
PCr eee et
ye ee ule aang! tae
ee Osada erate Abia
ti! iit Pca Hi HE bl
pobgesgcbteetytivaics er
i FTO eau a id
area a atae
MLVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING w. co. 39
(lam. lot No. 215, the “Cunvherland” Lode Mining (lain, Lat
Ne. 216, and the “Monroe Doctrine” Lode Mining Claim, Lot No
27
That the «aid Pinyon and Pinven Extension Mining Cleim &
bounced and described as follows tewit
egening at Pot No‘, and running thence on « trac cours
magnet variatem, 17 deg 20 min. Bast. North 57 dew 20 wan
Wet 20 feet to Pot Neo. 2: thence South 82 dee 25 mein Wee
4 feet to Pot No. 3; theme South 4 dee OO min. Eaet
M11 feet to Pot No. 4: themee North Ju deg. 1) win. Bat 28211
feet to Port No. 1, the place of beginning. From Pou No. 1 United
Sates Mineral Monument No. 4 bears south 43 deg 64 min. Wee
19881 feet diwtant
That the «aid Bose Lode Mining Claim ix bownded and de«erited
as follows
” Ieginning ot Pot Ne 1, and ronning themee on « true
rire. magnetic vermtion, 17 deg 20 wn Ket, South 12
+c 4) em. Eaet 207 6 fort to Pot No. 2. thence South 61 dee 24
mm, Weet 1481.1 feet to Pot No 3; thenee North 13 dee 50 rein
Wet 195.7 fort to Poet No 4: thence North dew 0 win. Pact
W412 feet te Pot No. 1, the place of beginning. From Pot No. 1
CS. Mineral Monument No. 4 bears North 59 deg 15 min, Weet
49 fort distant.
That the said Zephyr Lode Mining Claim is bownded and de-
wribed ws follows
Beginning at Post No 1. and running thence on « true cour.
magnetic variation, 17 deg 20 min. East, North 67 dee 41 min
Fat 567.8 feet to Post No. 2; thence South 48 deg 23 min. Fact
95 feet to Post No. 3; thence South 60 deg 34 min. Wet 5424
feet to Post No. 4: thence North 46 deg. O1 min. Weet 9245 fot to
Pet Not. the place of beginning From Post No TU & Mineral
Berwwnt No. 4 bears North 49 dee G5 mein. Kat 1272.1 fot dic
lant
That the said Brave Columbia Lode Mining Claim in bended
and dex tibed as follows
Reginning at Pot No. 1. and ranning thence in a tree cour.
magnetic variation, 17 deg 20 min. Past. South 45 dee Of win
Wet 206.9 feet ty Pot No. 2: thence South 45 dee 53 min. Feet
W2A2 feet to Poet No. 3: thence North 45 deg OT min. Fat 200
fet to Pot No. 4; thence North 45 deg 32 min. Weet 1437.1 feet to
Pot No. 1, the place of beginning. From Post No. 1 U. 8 Mineral
No. 4 bears North 89 deg 52 min. Bact 1810.1 feet die
he said Constitution Lede Mining Claim ix bewnded and
as follows
feginning at Pot No 1, and running thence on « true course,
Magnet variation, 17 deg. 20 min East. South 42 dee 55 min
feet to Post No. 2; thence South 46 dew 15 min. Fat
6 feet to Port No. 3; thence North 44 deg. 38 min. Eat 201.2
fet to Post No. 4; thence North 46 deg. 15 min. Weet 1426.6 feet
No. 1, the place of beginning. From Post No.1 U.S Mineral
uli
Hei ¥
2433 in 4
ee a pu
diese | tty Ay ata
: jt Hiss j pet if ii sé egal
ae tifa: That En peat
gS Ey ean ude io Pao H EH
eatin if; ry PH ct TEES ial
LA Hee sein
oa] sae 9 ie ge ipeet ie Hiv Ru
ase, f bee! ext the te AH
rr ngjhac* at uit rt alll;
tt sys we sit} Hit a any
i sreite ase ah We wt ul if HH ej
{3 ‘tei tail Tae ia ‘alin
pat I UE ida at
es
-
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. TS CONKLING Mw. OO. 41
57 feet, where, at ite apex and on ite course of atrike, it crows the
settherly «ide line of the anid Bee Mining Claim, to-wit, at ¢ pont
showt 125 feet easterly of the northwesterly corner of the «nid Bows
Mming Claim, at whieh _ at tte apex and on ite course oF etrike,
a cromes the southerly lune of the «ard Zephwr Mining Claim. and
thence. at ite apex and on ite course of ctrike. it traverses in a weeterly
direction the «aid Zephyr Mining Claim for a distance of about 57
fet. where it cromes the weeterty end line of the «ud Zephwr Mining
Gaim, at which point, at ite apex and on ite coure of atrike, nt
cree the located easterly «ide line of the «ad Brave Colunina Min-
ing Claim. and thence on ite course westerly and at ite apex, pases
to and actrome the weatetly lorated erde line of the «nd Brave Colunibta,
om its course of trike and at ite apex traverees the said
(octitation Mining Claim. ereming beth of the beewted aide lines
thereel. and thence on ite course of atrike and af ite apes travere=
the ‘weberiand Mining Claim, eroing beth of the located
te lee there’. and (ence on ite cours and <rike of ite ayex.
i traeveres the «eid Monier Peectrine Mining Claim, croing
beth of the berated cade limes thenerf
That the loration of the «aid Pinwen and Proven Exteron Min-
ing Claim, and upon which eid patent for «id claim: wae ieewed,
@ doresaid, was made ot lad ween a vein whieh crowed the beeated
ade lines thererd. as was aleo the «ard Brave Colamtnia, the «ad Con-
@itutien. the <ad Cumberland and the «od Monroe Doctrine Mining
That «aid vein dige in a coutherty direction, ond in ite course
downward so far departs from a perpendicular that it passes bey ond
the legal side lines extended downward vertially of cach of said
mining clams. so owned bw thr defendant a: aforesaid. and thener
eating on its dip of course downward. pases inte beneath and
the exterior hewndaries. extended dewnward vertically, of
the «aid (Conkling Mining Claim. wet only ae the «ome © herenthe-
fore im thie anewer deeerihed. bet ale ae the sane i& deveribed om
vad mant’s bill ef complannt berenn
That thie defendant i« the owser, in the poeeeeton and entitled
to the posession. and it and ite predecessor in mnterest. fer
% mere than sewen wears let pact, have been the owners, in
the pemeeson and entitled te the pomerston. threnahent ite
witire depth. of all that portion of <aid ver between the following
Heo: fire. one drawn through the exterly end line of the anid
Ree Mining Claim, extended indefinitely in ite own direction, and
mothe parallel thereto. drawn throuch the pomnt where sad ven.
@ i rex and om its course. erases the northerly «ide line of said
Ree Mining Claim. a aforesaid: and second. between lanes. one
drawn through the lorated westerly ere line of the sad Monroe Doe
tine Mining Claim. extended indefinitely in it< own direction. and
wther parallel thereto, drawn through the pont where «aid ven,
and on its course crosses, as aforesaid. the southerly side
said Zephyr Mining Claim
ores at any time mined or removed by thie de-
its predecessors in interest, from beneath the sur-
:
at
42 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M, CO,
face of the said Conkling Mining Claim, lay in and belonged to,
and were a part of, the said vein or lode so having its top or apex
in the said mining claims of this defendant, as aforesaid, and between
planes, one drawn through the easterly end line of the said Boss
Mining Claim, extended as aforesaid, and another through the
westerly located side line of the said Monroe Doctrine Mining Claim,
extended as aforesaid.
Wherefore, this defendant having fully answered, confessed,
traversed and avoided or denied, all the matters in the said amended
bill of complaint, material to be answered, according to its best
knowledge and belief. humbly prays this Honorable Court to
enter its decree that this defendant be hence dismissed with its
reasonable costs and charges in this behalf most wrongfully sus
tained, and for such other and further relief in the premises as to
this Honorable Court may seem meet and in accordance with equity.
A. C. ELLIS,
A. C. ELLIS, Jr.,
RUSSELL G. SCHULDER,
Solicitors for Defendant.
W.H. DICKSON,
Of Counsel.
SILVER KING COALITION MINES
CO.,
[SEAL. ] By F. J. WESTCOTT,
Sec’y.
50 STATE oF UTAH,
County of Salt Lake, ss:
Frank J. Westcott being first duly sworn, upon his oath, deposes
and says that he is an officer of the defendant corporation above
named, to wit: the secretary thereof; that he has read the above and
foregoing amended answer and knows the contents thereof and that
the same is true of his own knowledge except as to matters therein
stated upon information and belief and as to such matters he believes
it to be true.
FRANK J. WESTCOTT.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 14” day of December,
1911.
ALLIE LEVY, |
[SEAL. ] Notary Pubite.
My commission expires May 27-1913.
Copy-of the above and foregoing amended answer received and
due service admitted this 14 day of December, 1911.
WILLIAM H. KING,
Solicitors for Complainant.
Filed Dec. 16, 1911.
JERROLD R. LETCHER,
Clerk.
SOREN ID ETE 2 SEAR ORR 9 Nee OE ERY eT.
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 43
(Opinion of the District Court, by Judge, Johnson, Filed November
28, 1916, as to Defendant's Motion to Reopen Case for the Intro-
duction of Further Testimony, ete.)
The matter now before the court involves the meaning of the
mandate of the Circuit Court of Appeals in this ease, which reads:
“The decree below must be reversed, and the case must be re-
manded to the trial court for further proceedings consistent with the
views expressed in this opinion, and it is so ordered.
Under this mandate a new trial is not ordered but the court is
ordered to take such “further proceedings consistent with the views
expressed in this opinion” as will dispose of the case.
I am of the opinion that the case now stands where it would have
stood had Judge Marshall announced his deciston in the language
of the opinion of the Cireuit Court of Appeals after the parties had
rested at the conclusion of the trial. In such ease he would
‘have made such order as would have been considered necessary
to bring on the hearing on the accounting, and as the case
now stands the natural procedure would be the making of such an
order at this time.
Under the circumstances above supposed it would have been within
the discretion of Judge Marshall, even after he had announced his
decision, to have opened the case and permitted the introduction of
further evidence upon the part of the defendant, upon application
made and a sufficient showing.
4 Corpus Juris, p. 818 et seq., and cases cited.
38 Cye. p. 1360, and cases cited.
I do not think the mandate of the Circuit Court of Appeals has
taken away the power of the court still to exercise a like discretion.
That question, however, is not now before the court, so far the dis-
cretion of the court has not been appealed to, and I think it would be
an abuse of discretion for the court of its own motion to open the
case for a further hearing on the matters already submitted.
Since the defendant has suggested its desire to present further
«stimony, the order prayed for by plaintiff will be held in abeyance
and the defendant given until and including the 16th day of De-
ember, 1916, in which it may present its application, upon such
thowing as it may deem proper, to reopen the case and introduce
further testimony.
Endorsed: Filed in the District Court on Nov. 28, 1916.
RG ee eH Tae RI MIP AT TNT RR Mp LIME PT ROR Gi IE AS RON OL REBEL
44 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO,
(Opinion of the District Court, by Judge Johnson, Filed January 4,
1917, as to Defendant's Motion to Reopen Case and Plaintiffs
Motion for a Decree in Accordance with the Mandate of the U.S
Circuit Court of Appeals.)
This case is before the court upon the motion of the plaintiff to
enter a decree in accordance with the mandate from the Cireuit
Court of Appeals adjudicating the ownership of the premises and of
the vein of ore in controversy to be in the plaintiff, and for an ae-
counting; and also upon the application of the defendant to re-open
the case and permit the introduction of further evidence by. the
defendant.
Upon a former hearing of plaintiff's motion, this court expressed
the view that it had the same discretion in respect to opening
52 the case and permitting the introduction of further evidence
that it would have had. had this court rendered a decision in
favor of the plaintiff in the first instance.
Since that time, however, attention has been called to the case In
Re Potts, 166 U. S. 263, in which case under conditions entirely
similar to those in the case at bar, the Supreme Court of the United
States declared the rule to be:
“When the merits of a case have been once decided by this court
on appeal, the Circuit Court has no authority, without express leave
of this court, to grant a new trial, a rehearing or a review, or to
permit new defenses on the merits to be introduced by amendment
of the answer.”
It is apparent from the above rule that had the case at bar been
decided and remanded by the Supreme Court of the United States,
this Court would be without authority to do more than enter judg-
ment in accordance with the opinion. and for an accounting. A*
suming that the Cireuit Court of Appeals would, if called upon to aet,
adopt the same rule with respect to its decisions as that announced
by the Supreme Court of the United States, and I think this isa
reasonable assumption, I conclude that the view heretofore expressed,
that this court has a discretion in the matter, was a mistaken one.
The order will, therefore, be that the motion of the defendant be |
denied and the motion of the plaintiff granted.
The form of the decree and order will be considered and deter-
mined at 10 o'clock January 6th, at which time counsel for the
respective parties may present such forms of the decree and order to
be entered as they may deem proper.
Endorsed: Filed in the District Court on January 4, 1917.
IMR eS CAO AEE LEIP ELT NT OR NT ET Pah PER LONE NY AT PL Se TTC
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. YS. CONKLING M. CO. 45
(Op:nion of the District Court, by Judge Johnson, Filed February
27, 1918, ax to Accounting.)
This case is now before the court for its determination upon the
aeounting ordered in the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals in
this eause reported in 230 Federal, 553.
A statement of the facts respecting the title of the common prop-
ety of the parties and the matters out of which this litigation arose
appears in the decision above cited, as well as in the opinion of Judge
Marshall filed herein, and these facts require no re-statement at this
thine.
3 In this opinion I shall contine myself to a statement of the
rules to be applied in stating the account herein, with a brief
discussion of the reasons which have led to the adoption of these
rules,
The record in this matter is voluminous but in many respects un-
atisfactory, and the best that can be hoped for is an approximation
fa true account between the parties.
By reason of the unsatisfactory state of certain of the evidence
counsel for the plaintiff have urged in their briefs the arbitrary
adoption of the rule adopted by Judge Marshall in respect to the
(assification of the ore in the Silver King case. It is te be noted,
however, that counsel have not urged the application of the rule
adopted by Judge Marshall in that ease in respect to the cubical
contents of a ton of ore in place.
There are facts in evidence in this case which were lacking in the
Silver King case. In this case the plaintiff had access to the ore
body and the cavities from which the ore had been removed from
aout the middle of the year 1908 until the date of the former trial
and decision in this court.
After the decision of Judge Marshall in favor of the defendant
the plaintiff did not seek an entrance into the mine or access to the
ore bodies or the stopes until after the case had been reversed by the
Cireuit Court of Appeals. In the Silver King case it appears that
io attempt was made to keep an account of the quantity of ore
_temoved from the mine or its classification, while in this case from
about the first of May, 1909, books were kept in which a daily record
tas made of the cars removed from the mine with a classification of
the ore. Upon the facts in evidence in this ease I do not think the
‘ourt would be justified in arbitrarily adopting the rule of classifiea-
lon applied by Judge Marshall in the Silver King ease,
In this case the defendant has filed four separate accounts which
liffer one from another in respect to certain items contained in the
‘count, and also in the final result. Certain of these changes in the
indy of the accounts have been called to the attention of the court
ind explained as arising from oversight or a change in theory in
rpect to the manner in which the account should be made up.
‘riain other changes have been made in the items of the account
apparently upon the opinion of witnesses called in the ease,
ind respecting these changes no explanation has been made of any
46 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.
mistake upon the part of the defendant company or of any of
a | its officers or agents who made up the accounts. I assume
that each one of these accounts was made up by the defend
ant upon data known to its officers or responsible agents, or from
information received Ly them which they considered reliable, and I
am of the opinion that the data given in these accounts made up in
this way, should have great weight as expressing the best judgment
of the defendant as to the fact, and, unexplained, should not be dis
regarded even though certain witnesses who testified in the case have
given an opinion more favorable to the defendant,
In order to render a true accounting between the parties herein
it is essential to have data upon several matters, namely: volume,
classification, waste, metallic content, of ore, and price. These mat-
ters will be considered in their order.
Volume.
The total cavity mined within the limits of the Conkling ground,
as given by the witness Brooks, is as follows:
1907 50,000 cubie feet
1908 27,120 “ “
1909 104,295 .
1910 29 355 cubic feet
1913 4506 “« *
1914 18,246 “ “
1915 e363“ ™
1916 16410 “ “
These figures are not disputed by the plaintiff and are, in fact,
adopted by it in all of its caleulations in making up what it claims
to be the true account.
In the first and second accounts the defendant has used 9 eubie
feet as representing the volume of a ton of first class cre, and ll
cubic feet as representing the volume of a ton of second class ofe.
In the third and fourth accounts it has used 7.275 cubie feet for first
class ore, and 10.3 cubie feet for second class ore. The figures
in the first and second accounts are adopted from the findings of
Judge Marshall in the Silver King case, except that in that case 12
cubic feet was used as representing the volume of a ton of
class ore. The figures used in the third and fourth accounts are
arrived at from the experiment made by the witness Brooks with
ore samples taken by him from the stopes during the course of
trial.
The witness Taylor made calculations, based upon the data
- furnished by the defendant company with respect to the con-
5d tents of the cavity on the 600 level and the quantity of ore:
taken therefrom, that seem to me to be entitled to greater
weight in the decision of this question than any other evidence offered
in the case, and I shall adopt his conclusions, namely : 6 cubic
for first class ore, 7.62 for second class ore.
Beginning with about the first of May, 1909, the defendant be
LIE LPT OP LOL DOR RELL lo
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO. 47
gan to take ore from the mine at the 500 foot level of the Silver Hill
shaft, and from that time on the ore was pegged showing its classi-
fication and an account kept of the classification of the ore from the
pegging and the number of cars hoisted. The mine continued to be
worked until about June, 1910, and then operations ceased until the
iatter part of 1913. The court would not be justified in disregard-
ing these records and the testimony of the witnesses who were con-
med in keeping them.” The records may not be entirely accurate
wut they more nearly approximate accuracy, I believe, than the
method urged by the plaintiff in its brief. The approximate ac-
curacy at least of these records was assumed in the calculation made
by the witness Taylor upon which has been based the finding of the
cabical contents of a ton of first and second class ore. As used by
the witness Taylor these records gave a fair and reasonable result, as
| believe, with respect to the cubical contents of a ton of first and
«ond class ore, and justifies their adoption in stating the account
uot only for the years 1914, 1915 and 1916 but for the year 1909
ifter the first of May, and for the year 1910,
Classification.
The ratio of first to second class ore for the year 1907 in defend-
ait’ first and second accounts is 1 to 2; in the third and fourth ae-
wants, 1 to 1 1/5. Under the testimony it is uncertain what the
‘tact proportion was of first to second class ore for this year, but from
ill the evidence I am led to the conclusion that as much as one-half
if the ore removed during this year was first class ore.
Por the year 1908 the ratio of first to second class ore, as given by
the defendant in its first and second accounts, is 1 to 2; in its third
ind fourth accounts, 1 to7. The ratio of 1 to 7 presumably is based
tpon the recollection of certain witnesses called at the trial who
uined in the Elephant stope during the year 1908 who testified re-
‘yecting this matter. Necessarily such evidence can have no great
weight. The defendant, in making up its first and second accounts,
presumably as I have said, from the knowledge or recollection of its
®eers and agents, or from information received by it from others
'., Which it believed to be reliable, placed the ratio at 1 to 2.
*” — Considering this fact, together with the evidence given in the
_, fase by witnesses called by the defendant as well az those who
‘‘stified for the plaintiff, I have reached the conclusion that the ratio
1 to 2 is probably approximately correct.
As already intimated, the ratio of first class to second class ore for
n_ 1909 and 1910 and the years 1913, 1914. 1915 and 1916,
based upon the classification shown by the shift boss books
evidence in the case.
Waste.
No waste is claimed by the defendant for the year 1907. In its
ust and second accounts the defendant gives the percentage of waste
*"none” for the year 1908. In the third and fourth accounts,
48 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M,. CO,
14.3%. I do not believe the uncertain recollection of witnese
called in the case ought to outweigh the best judgment of the de
fendant at the time it made up its first and second accounts,
sumably from information secured, as already suggested. This ix
especially true for this year in view of the testimony of the witness
with respect to the appearance of the ore in the stope. No waste will
be allowed for the year 1908,
For the vears 1909 and 1910, and the years 1913, 1914, 1925 and
1916, an allowance of one-seventh for waste, under all of the facts
in the case, probably more nearly approximates an average of the
waste than any other percentage, and for each of these years one
seventh will be allowed for waste, where the matter of waste become
important.
Metallic Content of Ore and Price.
In all of the accounts filed by the defendant it has assumed the
metallic content of the entire ore body that is to be accounted for im
this action to be the same as the metallic content of the K-K ship
ment, and in the first three accounts the price allowed for the metal-
lic content of the entire body of ore was the same as the price te
ceived on the K-K shipment.
The plaintiff, on the other hand, has ignored, except incidentally,
the metallic content of the ores and adopted as a basis of the value:
of the ores the highest monthly averages of prices received by the
defendant during any month of each of the several years covered by
the account. This method was used by Judge Marshall in the Sil.
ver King case, Judge Marshall in that case saying: ‘There is not
liable evidence as to when the ores from this stope were marketed.”
In the case at bar it, I believe, sufficiently a rs that the ores re
moved by the defendant from the Conkling ground were mat-
57 keted in due course and within probably thirty days from the
time the ore was taken from the stopes, except the K-K ship
ments. *
The evidence shows that the K-K shipments were taken from the
Elephant stope, but from a consideration of all the testimony in the
case, as well as the lack of testimony upon certain essential matters,
I am not satisfied that these shipments represent the value of all the
ores taken from the Conkling ground. There is a remarkable dearth
of testimony respecting the assay value of the ores taken during the
period of nine years while the mine was operated, and in view of |
fact that the defendant mixed the ores taken from the ©
ground with other ores mined by it, upon the principle applicable @
the case of a confusion of goods, the metallic content of the ore taken
should be determined from the average metallic content of all the
ore shipped by it from year to year during the period of this #&
counting, or, as a practical matter in making up the account, diste
garding the metallic content, the prices allowed for the ore in que
tion should be based upon the yearly average prices received by @
defendant for all the ores shipped by it, with the limitations herei
after mentioned.
sige
rag tenes a. iS ORO Tae | ——
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. Co. 49
Applying the general rules above given in detail, the account for
the several years will be made up as follows:
1907.
The returns on the K-K shipments as shown by the books of said
company in evidence.
The tonnage of the K-K shipment reduced to its volume in cubic
feet and deducted from the 50,000 cubic feet of excavation mined
during this year.
The tonnage and classification of the balance of said excavation
determined upon the data heretofore given, and the price thereof
fixed by taking an average of the prices received by the defendant
for all of its ores shipped for the months of June, July, August, Sep-
ember, October, November and December.
1908. a.
To be calculated from the data heretofore given, the value of the
ore to be determined by the average of the prices received by the de-
fendant for its ores during this year.
1909 and 1910.
The time beginning with May, 1909, or the date when ore first
began to be hoisted from the 500 foot level of the Silver Hill
8 = shaft until the operations ceased in 1910, will be treated as
one period, and the ratio of first to second class determined
by the ratio of first and second class ore as shown by the records kept
by the shift bosses and others. in evidence in the case.
It is claimed in argument by the plaintiff that the Alliance cars,
that is the cars used in hauling these ores, were larger in size than
the cars used upon the Silver King side. This is true, but there is no
certainty, under the evidence, that any considerably greater weight
of ore was hauied in them than was hauled in the smaller Silver King
‘ar. But the controlling consideration in this matter of the weight
cars is that in the calculation made by the witness Taylor upon
rhich the cubical content of a ton of first and second class ore is de-
mined, the difference in the weight of the cars, if any, Was not
into consideration, and if the result of his calculations with-
out this matter being considered gives the cubical content of a ton
and second class ore in place, it seems to follow that the dif-
ce in weight in the cars, if any, ought to be disregarded in other
The weight of the cars to be used in this calculation will be the
ts of cars given by the witness Daly for this period, namely :
21 — for first class, 1,650 pounds for second class. From
‘hese » together with the cubical contents of a ton of ore as
found by the witness Taylor, may be determined the quantity of the
pace excavated during the years 1909, 1910, occupied by the ores
4—158
50 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.
removed of which an account was kept; edd to this quantity one
seventh for waste anid deduct from the total cavity left by the ore re.
moved during the years 1909 and 1910 leaves the cavity of the ore
removed during the first four months of the year 1909 and of which
no record was kept. Assuming the ratio of first and second class ore
during this last mentioned period to be the same as that during the
period from May 1909 to June 1910, the amount of first and second
class ore contained in this cavity may be determined from the data
given; the price for the year 1909, to be the average price for the
year as above indicated, and the price of the ores mined during the
year 1910 to be the average of the price received by the defendant for
ores during the first six months of said year.
1913.
The data for stating the account for the year 1913 is unsatisfac-
torv. The cavity for that year, furnished by the witness Brooks, was
4.505 eubie feet. The ore, as given by the shift boss books, leave
such a large proportion of this space to be occupied by waste
a as to seem unreasonable. Undoubtedly there is a mistake a
to the volume of the cavity for this year, or the quantity of
ore removed. The basis for calculation must, therefore, be more or
less a surmise. As an approximation I have concluded to use the
following: The ratio of to second class as shown by the shift
boss books; percentage of waste one-seventh ; volume of cavity 4,505
cubie feet. With this data and that heretofore given, the quantity
and class of ore to be determined, and the price to be an average of
the prices of the ores sold by the defendant company during the
months of November and December, 1913, and January, 1914—it
being probable that some of this ore was marketed in the early part
of the year 1914.
1914, 1915, and 1916.
The amount of first and second class ore as shown by the shift
Loss books, the weights of the cars to be the same as those used by
the witness Taylor in making his calculations; the price of the ore
for the year 1914 to be the average price of all the ores sold by the
defendant during that vear; the price for the year 1915 to be de
termined in the same manner; the price for 1916 to be the average
price oe months during which the ore of that year wes mined and
rately, disa when treated as a unit, as was done by the witnes
calculations.
Taylor in his
The value of all slimes accounted for, to be included in the
count.
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO. 51
Interest.
Interest at the legal rate should be allowed on yearly balances to
date of decree,
The defendant is entitled to credits as charges against the value
of the ore accounted for, as above indicated, as follows: mining
charges $4.50, sampling $0.221, tramming $0.20, milling $1.10, per
ton; the reasonable expense of all development or dead work done
within the limits of the Conkling ground, except in respect to the
Alliance tunnel and branch tunnels therefrom as hereinafter stated.
For such development or dead work and raises, the allowance will be
the value claimed by the defendant in its account, except in those
cases where witnesses called by the defendant have given a smaller
sum as a reasonable value.
0 The driving of the Alliance tunnel was prosecuted by the
P in interest of the defendant for the purpose of
developing the country lying to the west. of which country the
Conkling ground was only a part. After having discovered the ore
body in the Elephant stope the defendant acquired what is known as
the Belmont property and made use of the Alliance Tunnel during
the years from 1907 to 1916 for the development of the Belmont
property and the removal of the ores discovered therein, as well as
the removal of the ores found in-the Conkling ground. As I view
it, it would be unjust to charge all the expense of running this tunnel
to the Conkling property, as it would be inequitable not to charge
ay of this expense to the Conkling ground. It may be true that
at the present time this tunnel does not add any value to the Conk-
ling property. For aught that appears in the record ractically al!
d the ore in the Conkling ground has been removed, and tunnels
upon a worked-out mine never have any substantial value. The
value of this tunnel to the Conkling property must be considered as
of the time when the ore was discovered, rather than now when the
oe has all been removed. On the other hand, this same tunnel
has been used for nine years by the defendant in connection with its
ownership of the Belmont property. Considered from the stand-
pint of what was equitable and right at the time that the ore bodies
i those properties were first discovered and before they had been
mmoved, and considered in the light of the fact that the defendant
has made use of this tunnel in the removal of the ore from its Bel-
ont property, I have reached the conclusion that one-half of the
st of running the Alliance tunnel and tunnels branching there-
within the limits of the Conkling ground, except the McKay
Teseut, should be charged against the common fund. In this con-
tection, however, it may be said that a part of the tunnel, in its
progress through the Conkling ground, runs outside of and beyond
he north line of the Conkling claim. At the trial of this cause the
t stood upon its legal rights with respect to that part of the
tunnel run outside of the north line of the Conkling claim, and
that part of the tunnel should be exciuded in making up this credit.
defendant, in its account of the cost of this work, used the
ON ERS OE SP TPO Oh,
2 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. V8. CONKLING M. CO.
figures $15.38, $26.186 and $54.073 which give to the accoum a
air of accuracy to which it is not entitled. Facer figures ave
upon the estimate made by the witness Walden, which, at best, can
wale be ealled rough estimates As, under the evidence, only
61 timated values are possible, round numbers will be used is
making up the account, namely: $15.00, $25.00, and $50.0,
will be used as approximations to the actual cost in running the
tunnel.
Had the fi res used in the account of the defendant been based
upon the t and records of the Kearns-Keith Company, | should
see peatate to adopt them, and it is somewhat remarkable that in
I do not believe the evidence | «ffucient) to justify the court &
require the defendant io account for these ores at price higher thes
t looking
orable to the defendant in the marketing of its ores,
nothing in the evidence that would justify a finding that 1
entered into in bad faith or for ior purposes.
Interest should be allowed at the legal rate upon yearly balance
mining operations. ial evidence im t
of the nature and extent of such use or of its reasonable
do not think a pro rata part of an interest charge
of the defendant's improvements a legitimate basis for «
tion of the value of such use. That item of the defendan
of
a
ili
iy ite
i
ci
Ci
4
Fhe
tH
5%
te rf
- —
|
ge
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. 00. 33
(Decree of the District Court, March 27, 191%.)
This cause came on to be further heard at this term upon the
eeownt of the defendant, and the testimony and proofs presented
lw the parties in support of the same and in oppesition therete and
ex argued by Counsel and thereupon. apen consideration theneef
ht was Ordered, Adjudged and Decreed as follows, to-wit
That there is due from defendant, Silver King Coalition Mine
Company, to the plaintiff, the Conkling Mining Company, upon an
secounting for the ores. ‘ninerals and minetal-earing rock bw the
aid defendant and its grantor and predecessor in interest: Kearn--
Keith Mining Company, taken from the land amd prenise ot ted
in common ty the plaintiff and defendan|, the sum of Five Hundred
Forty-two Thousand Two Hundred and Twenty Two and & 100
Dollars, (#542.222.55). and
It was Further Ordered. Adjudged and Deereed that the plantiff
do have and recover from the said defendant, the said sam of Five
Hundred Forty Two Thousend, Two Handred Twenty two ated
1 100 Dollars (8042.222.58) so found duc ae aforesaid, together
with plaintiffs cost hevern tawed at the sum off Ihtlars (# )
vith wterest upon the full amount thereof from the firt dav of
March. 1918, at the rate of 8% per annum, and that plaintiff have
ercutor therefor.
Dated March 27, 1915.
TILLMAN D. JOHNSON,
Dratrict Judq
Endorsed. Filed in the District Court on March 27, 1915
(Stipulation as to Opinion of District Court, Filed February Zi.
1918, Being Made a Part of the Record)
It is hereby stipulated in the above entithed cause that thee cqentevets
df the Court heretafore filed herein, on the 27th day of February,
1915, containing the Court's finding. m reqect te verhuaneee
& cdamification, waste, metallic contents of one, prices, ete, shall
hecome and be deemed to be « part of the record in this cane,
and that an order may be entered by the Court accordingls
PIERCE, CRITCHLOW &
BARRETTE &
WwW. W. RAY,
Solicitors for (omplanant
W. H. DICKSON.
T. MARICONEAUX.,
A. C. ELLIS,
R. G. LUCAS,
Solicitors for Defendant.
Dated: April 16, 1918.
Endorsed: Filed in the District Court op April 17, 1915.
= sf: re.
Hee ond GEES cp teal
27 Z 4 ‘ 4 . my iF dai
13! 3:4; s 7242p? 3 aH if Bertie:
ese aitegees 3 2 ait 7 eae He ee
alia $y WE fa Ray “li
RE vg de pha - gly
aS hail ; j i ; 4 is acy Aue fe
=} PH 32 Z ii ; 3 {Hii Bari
' es He ‘i ~ : Ti - =3 figs : itty
2 it i am Lit ‘eae Ue ee Le
st ati, aH a} ae! eS
et hs a sl in
SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLIXG M. CO. 55
whatsoever in favor of said Nicholas Treweek and J. Leemard Burch
against the defendant herein
That said defendant corporation was organized and incotporated
under the laws of the State of Nevada. on or about the month of
May. 1907 to consolidate and take over sundry mining clains and
pryerte. including the Kearns-Keith Mining Company and the
“iver King Mining Company, respectively corporations, which ssid
at-hated companies theretofore and for a long time had heen en-
gaged in the business of mining in the Mining District where said
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims are situated.
Ill
That im and by said consolidation and merger the defendant
eaperation succeeded to the interest then and theretofore owned
w sed KearnsKeith Mining Company in and to said Conkling
ad Arthur Lode Mining Claims, viz., an undivided omefourth (1%)
mtetest therein
That on or about the twenty-second day of September, 1903. said
hearne Kerth Mining Company, predecessor in interest and grantor
of the defendant herein, became the owner of «aid undivided
© «wmeftourth (%) interest in and to said Conkling and Arthur
Lode Mining Claims, and ever since continued to be the
owner thereof until the same was transferred to and merged in the
‘ company a aforesaid, to-wit, on or about the twenty-
wmth day of May, 1907
H1.
That during all of the times said Kearne-Keith Mining Com-
pany war the owner of said undivided oneftourth (%) interest
ad Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claim, the said Nicholas
Treweek. ax tenant-in-common with said Kearns Keith Mining Com-
pany. wae the owner of an undivided one-half (45) interest mm and
ed mining claims and each of therm.
mmen with the defendant herein m said mining claims and
th of them. and so continued to be until the transfer to vour
IV.
‘
That said J. Leonard Burch since on or about the sixteenth day
May. 1906, until the transfer to your orator herein. was the
wuer «of an undivided one-fourth (%) interest in and to said
z and Arthur Lode Mining Claims. That a such owner
“ar said sixteenth day of May, 1906, he was a tenant-in-common
——_< « - ee owe oe
56 SILVER KING COALITION M. CO. VS. CONKLING M. CO.
with said Kearns-Keith Mining Company in said mining claims
and each of them until the time of the transfer by said Kearns
Keith Mining Company of its interests therein to the defendant
herein, and since the time of said transfer he was a tenant-in-common
with the defendant herein in said claims and each of them, until he
transferred his interest to your orator as hereinbefore alleged.
V.
That on or about the twenty-third day of February, 1892, the
United States of America by its letters patent granted to the Boss
Mining Company, a corporation, those certain premises called the
Conkling and Arthur Lode Mining Claims, respectively situated in
the Uintah Mining District, County of Summit, then territory, now
State of Utah, said Conkling Lode Mining Claim being particularly
bounded and deseribed in said patent, to-wit:
“Bounded, described and platted as follows, with magnetic varia
tion seventeen degrees and twenty minutes east.
(iH Beginning at Corner No. 1, a pine post four inches square
marked U.S. 689 P. T. .
Thence first course north twenty-one degrees and nine minutes
west three hundred feet to discovery point six hundred feet to corner
No. 2, a pine post four inches square marked U. 8. 589 P. 2, being
also corner No. 4, of Lot No. 191, the Lineoln lode claim, and corner
No. 2 of Lot No. 580, the Pirate King Lode claim from which U. §.
mineral monument No. 4 bears north thirty-two degrees and fifty-
two minutes west nine hundred and thirty-nine and three-tenths
feet distant, and a pine tree four inches in diameter marked U. S$.
689 P. 2 B. T. bears north thirteen degrees west twenty-eight feet
distant.
Thence second course, south sixty degrees and forty-five minutes
west one thousand five hundred feet to corner No. 3.
Thence third course south twenty-one degrees and nine minutes
east six hundred feet to corner No. 4.
Thence fourth course north sixty degrees and forty-five minutes
east one thousand five hundred feet to corner No. 1, the place of be
ginning; said Lot 689 extending one thousand five hundred feet in
length along said Conkling vein or lode, and containing twenty sere:
and forty-five hundredths of an acre of land more or less.”
and said Arthur Lode Mining Claim being particularly bounded
and described in said patent, to-wit:
“Bounded, described and platted as follows, with magnetic varia
tion seventeen degrees and twenty minutes east,
Beginning at corner No. 1 a pine post four inches square marked _
U. S. 690 P. 1, with mound of stones being also corner No. 1 of |
Lot No. 689, th
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.