Transcript of Record — Minerals Separation, Ltd. v. Butte & Superior Mining Co.
Supreme Court brief1919
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
( 26,685 )
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 1918.
No. 599.
‘MINERALS SEPARATION, LIMITED; MINERALS SEPARA-
TION AMERICAN SYNDICATE, LIMITED, AND MIN-
ERALS SEPARATION NORTH AMERICAN CORPORA-
TION, PETITIONERS,
v8.
BUTTE AND SUPERIOR MINING COMPANY, DESIGNATED
AS BUTTE AND SUPERIOR COPPER COMPANY,
LIMITED.
ee
ON PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT.
INDEX
Original. Print.
Caption........cccccccccccvcrecccccccscecccscsssccccseeses a 1
Transcript of record from the District Court of the United
States for the District of Montanad...........seeereeeees i 1
Names and addresses of counsel.......-.-eseereeseerers i 1
Bill of complaint.........ceeeeeeer ee eeeeereeserreeres fi 2
Subpeena and marshal’s returN.......--+eeereeeeereree ix 5
Answer (filed October 28, 1913) ......--eseereeeeereees xii 7
Supplemental answer ......---+eeeeeceeeereeseerercees xxxili 17
Amendment tO answef.s.... cs cee cece cee ernereereerees xiii 21
Answer (filed April 17, 1917) ........seeeeeeereeeeeeees xlix 25
Jupp & Derweizer, (INc.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., Jury 5, 1918.
INDEX.
Notice of motion for leave to file supplemental bill of
Complaint... ccccccccsccscscccsceces $0 Reeneneei~ ees
Supplemental and amended bill of complaint........ eae
Exhibit A—Agreement between Minerals Separation,
Ltd., and Minerals Separation Ameri-
can Syndicate, Ltd., July 8, 1913.....
B—Bill of sale, Minerals Separation Ameri-
can Syndicate, Ltd., to Minerals Sepa-
ration North American Corporation. .
C—Mandate of Supreme Court U. S. in case
No. 46, October term, 1916...........
D—Petition of Ballot to Patent Office......
E—Opinion of court in case of Minerals
Separation vs. Hyde, Bourquin, J.....
Answer to supplemental bill of complaint..............
Exhibit A—Petition by Minerals Separation, by
Ballot, to Patent Office.............-.
Anever to plaintiffs’ amended bill of complaint.........
Exhibit A—Agreement between Butte and Superior
Copper Co., Ltd., and J. M. Hyde,
July B22; WAL ce. cc ccveces wid asacnh o4
Exhibit B—Petition of Minerals Separation to Patent
Opinion, Bourquin, J.........- eee eee eee eeeee ave newowe
Interlocutory Mecree....... eee ee eee rere eee ee ee renrnee
‘Assignment of errors........---+ee+0s igitaels Ae KetadRet
Petition for appeal and allowance..........-.++++ pe
Bond on appeal.........cereeccceeececrcereereeeseeees
Citation and appeal. ..... 00. cec eee cece cree ee eeeneeeees
Preecipe for transcript... 2... eee eee cere eee r eee eeeeeees
Stipulation as to statement of evidence.........++-++++
Order of transmission of physical exhibits...........++:
Order extending time for filing record and docketing case
Stipulation as to settled case, &C.........e eee eee eeees
Offer of record in Hyde case in evidence......... giles
Transcript of record in U. S. District Court for District
of Montana in case of Minerals Separation vs. Hyde...
Bill of complaint..........cceeeeeecereereereeeens
Replication ......cccccsccccevecccscese areteewaere
Agreed factS ......ccccseeeeecee ‘Spbectses ener ore
Testimony of Edward H. Nutter..........- rere re ‘
Testimony of Charles F. Chandler...........--+-+-
Certificate of special examiner............+.+-- ee
Testimony of George Albert Chapman........ epklaek
Testimony of Allen Crawford Howard.........++-++-
Stipulation as to testimony of Giovanni Battista
Zanardo ....... CnbctncwasessUearviegveteoateors?
Testimony of William Henry Ballantyne.........-
George Lockwood Morris......-++.-«-
Allen Crawford Howard (recalled) ..
Original. Print
Ixxii
Ixxiv
Ixxxiv
aevii
exi
cxv
exvili
exxi
exxxii
CXxxv
elxvi
clxxiv
elxxvii
exev
excix
ecix
eexili
ecxvi
eexix
eexxii
eexxvi
ecexxvii
eexxix
1
17
17
27
38
28
amet
INDEX, iii
Original. Print
Testimony of Perey Lot Young.......... Tri Trier -. 484 341
Robert Molesworth Kindersley......... 487 342
Francis Amboor Keating...... TTT -» 490 344
Allen Crawford Howard (recalled).... 495 346
Arthur Weaver Wincey............... 501 349
John Ballot ......... 9Ue e845 0000460008 512 355
Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick Picard...... 528 360
Adoiph Liebmann................ reese 529 362
B.' TOWETE THORNS. oo ccc cvs cicccesccs 714 4AG
Adolph Liebmann (resumed).......... 720 451
ere: GE OOM 5 Foe Che ben re o6 Ghee veO6s 0K0ckas S54 515
Testimony of Charles F. Chandler.................. 855 516
A. Howard Higgins................0.- 925 550
George A. Chapman (recalled)......... 932 553
Patent in suit, 835,120, November 6, 1906............. 949 563
ND. SA cS aha ciV webs evs 00096906404 k050 00% sews 5 569
Be OWNING a vos oduaeesvevasesersdecenrenvces 958 570
Stipulation as to evidence.............ccccceeceuces 982 584
Me Me NE 6d 5 K7805 000000 4085 vow eed dee heeens 983 584
Chapman's report, August 16, 1907.............. 00006 OS4 585
Higgins’ report, January 4, 1911................0000. 989 588
Hyde letter, February 7, 1911.............0...000 -.. 990 588
Froment description... cccccecsscsccvecceccvcccccces 990 589
Translation of Froment description and descriptive
matter on Froment drawings................cc000 996 595
Fryer Hill publication. .......cccsceccccccccccccecces 1006 600
Criley and Everson publication..................00008 1009 601
Statement of profit, Lazard ventures................. 1010 602
Table of material and results, Lazard ventures........ 1011 603
Statement of expenditures in agitation-froth process... 1012 604
Statement of expenditures by American Syndicate in
agitation-froth process............cccccceceeccees 1013 604
Statement of tonnage treated by agitation-froth presses
at Broken Hill, Australia......... 60600600000 600-0 » 1014 605
Statement of profits and royalties on agitation-froth
oo MERE ERTELERRECA ER CERRO ETE TTT eee 1015 606
Table of Sulphide Gospetetion operations with agita-
tion-froth process (small sheet) .................005 1016 606
Table of Sulphide Corporation operations with agita-
tion-froth process (large sheet)...... irvesase dey +. 1016 606
Sulman and Picard report, March 2%, 1908............ 1016 607
Sulman and Picard report, May 5, 1908............... 1027 612
Sulman and Picard report, September 24, 1908........ 1081 614
Sulman and Picard report, November 19, 1903....... +» 1047 ~*~ 626
Sulman and Picard report, March 4, 1904............. 1059 632
Sulman and Picard report, April 19, 1904............. 1068 637
Sulman and Picard report, May 2, 1904............... 1075 641
Sulman and Picard report, May 18, 1904.............. 1077 642
Sulman and Picard report, February 17, 1905......... 1081 644
Sulman and Picard report, Feb-uary 21, 1905......... 1086 647
INDEX.
Original. Print
Higgins’ report, March 2, 1905.....seeeeee eer eeeeere °
Minerals Separation letter, March 3, 1905....«-++-+++>
Sulman and Picard report, March 3, 1905....-6-+eeeeee
Minerals Separation letter, March 6, 1905....6-e0e sees
Higgins’ report, March 16, 1905.....+++++ seweseveeune
Sulman and Picard report, May B, 1905.....+6+- seaase
Cable, Hoover to Hyde, January 18, 1910.....-.eeeeeee
Cable, Hyde to Hoover, January 20, 1910.....-+-+eeeee
Cable, Hoover to Hyde, January 21, 1910.....-++eeeees
Cable, Hyde to Hoover, January 24, 1910.... 0 cece eee
Sulman and Picard report, February 24, 1910...... eee
Letter, Minerals Separation to Hyde, March 2, 1910...
Hyde acceptance, March 3, 1910... ...ceeeee eer eerceee
Nutter report, July 28, 1010....--+++sererrereerrreres
Nutter report, December 3, 5!) eee
Letter, Minerals Separation to Hyde, November 23, 1910
Cable, Minerals Separation to Hyde, December 8, 1910
Cable, Hyde to Minerals Separation, December 9, 1910
Hyde report, January eC!) » On
Copy memorandum re managership of Minerals Separa-
tion American Syndicate, Limited.......--eeeeeeee
Letter, Hyde to Minerals Separation American Syndi-
cate, January 17, 1911....--eeeeerereeresereer ere e®
Letter, Minerals Separation to Hyde, February 1, 1911
Extract from Richards’ ore Uressing.....+eeeeeeeeree
Assignment, Froment to Ballot, November 17, 1903....
Froment Italian patent....-.se-sererrerreereereee
yranslation of Froment Italian patent....eeeeeereees
Photograph, Australian Cattermole plant.....-++++++>
Sulphide Corporation retreatment plant photegraph 1..
Sulphide Corporation retreatment plant photograph 2..
Sulphide Corporation retreatment plant photograph 3..
Sulphide ¢ ‘orporation retreatment plant photograph 4..
United States patents.....--s-erreereererrerr sees
Gabbett, 444,345, January 6, 5 T.:!) eee
Hebron, 474,829, May 17, 1892...---+++eerrrerere’
Robson, 575,669, January 19, 5 |.) eo
Cattermole, 763,259, June 21, bY
Cattermole, 763,260, June 21, 1904......-- oeaneks
Wolf, 787,814, April 18, DT |) ewes
Hoover, 953,746, April 5, 1910.....+-- eetenaen ee °
Hoover, 979,857, December 27, 1910....- ee eee eeees
British patents .....- L eukeviabuwleny ey a6ense inamaes vie
Haynes, 488 of 1860.....--++++++++"
Boulton and Gabbett, 840 of bt.) ee
Sulman et al., 7803 of 1905.....- jeebacse® opewws
Chapman, 17,328 of 1906.....----- cubes aeeee ;
Nutter et al., 23,870 of 1910....---++sererrerrree’
Nutter et al., 23,949 of 1910....---eeererererrree’
Nutter drawing, defendant’s plant (sheet 1)...--++++
ereoreerere
1091
1097
1271
1277
1291
650
653
653
657
710
712
715
717
719
721
739
757
INDEX. Vv
Original. Print
Nutter drawing, defendant's plant (sheet 2)....... «+. 1801 805
Sulman drawing accompanying report, May 3, 1905.... 1302 806
Drawing, Australian model ae een 1303 807
Drawing of 1909 and 1910, agitation- froth plants
SNS ME Vat sh endvaaceceesdiieeviccdonnktédeneuks 1304 808
Drawing of 1909 and. 1910, agitation-froth plants
Se Br esneh oaks vénkenndsaakbes¥edeeseas conecoxs 1305 809
King John’s Court standard plant (sheet 1).......... 1306 810
King John’s Court standard plant (sheet 2).......... 1307 811
King John’s Court standard plant (sheet 3).......... 1308 812
First tracing slide machine (sheet 1)................ 1310 813
First tracing slide machine (sheet 2)................ 1311 814
ey OU vi biiwoknth £6400 ue de 660004 60 cewscinci 1312 815
NE CE Mo cWeua vb cub aedhsadhl dss ddateobka 13138 816
Gabbett advertisements..............0ccccccccecuceee 1314 817
th ion si ksec rides becusa soci, 1314 817
Young, advertisement A..........cc.ccccccsecece 1318 819
Young, advertisement B..............ccccceceeue 1319 820
EE bine WA don be Sha Lbs ibs buanSoesuedeieooeds ck 1323 821
IE OO III. w i.ain sos. 54. sw enceésdusveeciecewe 1337 828
Deposition of Jesse C. Gibson. .........0.0cccccceceee 1344 833
IN eb Vasa ol bon seb cducowdedeevens 1371 847
Deposition of James M. Hyde...............00.00000. 1373 848
Deposition of Eugene A. Byrnes................0c00. 1452 888
ee ia ook veins Sb rivewivccseucucs 1595 955
Order for commission to take depositions............. 1597 956
PE I IN on bod So ud nios cus tives <encnessase 1600 957
Deposition of Henry Livingstone Sulman............ 1602 959
Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard...... 1682 998
°c A, a ee an eee 1710 1012
Herbert Clark Hoover................. 1772 1043
A. Howard Higgins................... 1790 1052
Defendant’s Exhibit Extract from “Treatise on Chem-
istry Applied to the Manufacture of Soap and
WO Es nisavudincebabasdscenddleekeincaxcus 1821 1068
Defendant’s Exhibit Hyde Sketch of Experimental Ma-
SE a vUNW Gk bis ind Whe Oh 0Seh bends barVakendcocda 1822 1069
Defendant’s Exhibit Certified Copy of File-wrapper and
Contents of Patent 788,247.............ccccceccucee 1823 1070
Defendant’s Exhibit Certified Copy of File-wrapper and
Contents of Sulman and Kirkpatrick-Picard Patent
Be EN SD awk oidaCudbuvacnadand vevdeiuisseck joe 1849 1084
Original. Print
Defendant’s Exhibit Certified Copy of File-wrapper
and Contents of Schwarz Patent No. 807,501....... - 1881 1105
Defendant’s Exhibit Certified Copy of File-wrapper
and Contents of Schwarz Patent No. 807,508....... - 1901 1116
Defendant’s Exhibit Certified Copy of File-wrapper :
and Contents of Kirby Patent No. 809,959.......... 1927 3131
Defendant’s Exhibit Certified Copy of File-wrapper
and Contents of Patent in Suit, No. 885,120......... 1974 1156
vi INDEX. !
Original, Print
Defendant's Exhibit: Certified Copy of File-wrapper
and Contents of Kirby Patent No, RBA UBG...csceee. Wl 1178
Bradford patent No, S45Q01...ceceer eer eer eer ereees 2052 1204
Everson patent No, 348,157. ..6006e. eveceeeese eveees 2057 1200
Wagner patent Nov ATBAUIB, .. covccscccessecseveveves 2000 1212
Hockley patent No, 466,703... cece eeeereeeees ececccce 2004 1215 j
Rouse patent No, 460,500... 660 eereeeees PTTTIT TT TLL. 2070 1221
Hebron and Everson patent No. ATLUT4. ccc cerns — 1226
F. KE. Elmore patent No, GW30H0,.. 6c ceeee ree eeeeees 2085 1235
F. EK. Elmore patent No, 676679..... ésewee PTITITT . 2oxp 1239
A. & Elmore patent No, G80TO,...60eeee eee TTT t th 2008 1248
A. & Elmore patent No, 602,048. ...0.055es TTT T it 2006 12435
Stoveken patent No, T2A8Q0....00ccereeeereeeerrrees 2008 1248 \
Delprat patent No, TAR.OTL cc ccccccverevsccscecveres 2108 1258 |
Glogner patent No. TAABRL. cc ccvvcccsccvevcorcers sce ee 1261
Good patent No, TAIMOD,...cccereereeeeererereereeres 2116 126
Delprat patent No, TORR... c6ceece reer ere eeeereees 2122 1269
Kendall patent No, TU10T5. 0.0 ccc cece errr eee ee reese 2126 1272
Potter patent No, TTOUM.....ccer errr rere ee rer eerees 2182 1277
Cattermole patent No. TTT2T8...cecee reer rere eee ees 2136 1280
Cattermole, Sulman and Picard patent No, 777.274.... 2141 1285
Cattermole, Sulman and Picard patent No, TS8,247.... 21438 1287
Sulman and Picard patent No, 1 2146 1289
Schwarz patent 807,501.....6+66> caneveeevesesteaess 2151 1204
Schwarz patent 807,508......+++ sevessevecveosgecess 2155 1207
Kirby patent 800,950...... euseete seugeeseuweceseness 2158 1299
Sulman patent SW14B...... 6c cee eee e ee eeeeeeeeeeees 2168 «1308 i
Sulman, Picard and Ballot patent BBATD. 6. cece eee 2172 1311
Kirby patent 888,626. ......6.cerreeee eee eersereeeees 2176 1314
Sulman, Picard and Ballot patent RID.DAB. ..cevccceres 2181 1319 i
Hyde patent 1,022,085... ...00seeseeeeereeeeer eee eees 2188 1326 ;
English patent to Lake, 12,778, 1902... . ccc cece eeeeee 2104 1332
Colloquy between court and counsel, &C.... 66. e eee eeee ee 13385
Testimony of Maxwell R, Atwater... ...esseseeres acess aaa 1391
Testimony of Henry D. Williams. ...-.eeeerrereeeee eeeee 2350 1412
Colloquy between court and counsel, &C.. 6. eee eee sistees ee 1414
Testimony of John Ballot......+++++ Secsesdeueeecrs evees
Frank R, Wicks.....+-> yeeeesseveseeveeese
Obn Wiser... ccc eee cree eeeee PTTTTT Titi .
Thomas A, Janney....eseeee eeuevcvere eee
Ralph Augustus COnrads...ccceceeseessees
BEdward W. Engleman.....-eseeseerrrrrers
Ben H. Dosenbach.....ceeeeereereereerees
Samuel P. Sadtler......-eeeereereereereees
Ren H, Dosenbach (recalled) ....+.+++++++>
Samuel P. Sadtler (resumed).....--- geneen
John Warne Phillips....+.-eeeerreeeeeeers
Frank R. Wicks (recalled) ....+.eeeserrees
Arthur Fay Taggart....--seeesereeeeerees
Frederick B. Beach.....seeeseereersereees
INDEX. vii
Original. Print
Testimony of ey Ph ME nekevehccbdcsesdececes 3132 1810
a 1860
deg H. Dosenbach (recalled)... sec ceeeeees 3283 1884
Arthur Fay Taggart.........ccccccecsesss S411 1948
Ben H, Dosenbach (resumed)............. S439 1962
Wilder LD. Bancroft (recalled)........... .. 8476 1981
Frank R. Wicks (recalled) ................ 3831984
Edward W. Engleman................. sees BOHOL 1993
Pe ee ir wakeas ded ddS6tnesdes cess .. 8506 1996
Ralph Augustus Conrads.................. S512 1990
Pe Se Mon odilisubice ce ds0se0isecece 8521 2008
Arthur Fay Taggart (recailed)............ S520 2008
Frank G, Janney (recalled)............. .. S586 20387
ee ee S588 2088
Se. We MN vas coleueseuvedceseeces 3600 2044
Wy as Sn nent sunteetseeatavaddes 3795 2139
David Douglas Punchon,.................. 3849 2165
Rex Sutherland.......... euvewsaveeesionss S3R52 2167
Ty es Mrs netenexevbccacdcvce’e 3855 2169
Ben H. Dosenbach (recalled) TITtririiT 3861 2172
Frank R. Wicks (recalled)................ 3923 22038
James Macdonald Hyde...............005. 847 2215
De: We NDS hadenns nd diecwieconees seca 4618 2251
Ben H. Dosenbach (recalled).............. 4021 2253
John Ballot (recalled) ...........00c0ccees 4026 2255
Be es SI iv 'ncnva0kédseseecaccenct 4042 2268
Ne Ses: SI cesecivesecceesccecests 4092 2288
Maxwell W. Atwater..........cccccceccccs 4126 2306
William Mason Grosvenor................. 4160 2323
ee i a tk 5 0 bbs Kober e ees icudcac 4278 2381
William Mason Grosvenor (resumed)...... 4320 2402
Ira L. Greninger (recalled)............ oo. 4822 2408
William Nichols Rossberg................. 4362 2423
Charles H. Fulton.............. Svesedveser 4387 2435
George A. Chapman (recalled)............ . 4424 2454
Arthur Howard Higgins................... 4458 2471
William Mason Grosvenor (recalled)....... 4538 2511
Arthur Howard Higgins (resumed)........ 4592 2538
James Wilding. . edseccdsereccuacecess GR 2554
Maxwell W. Atwater (vecaiied)....... cones . 4668 2577
Eltoft Wray Wilkinson.................... 4670 2578
Parker C. MclIlhiney............seeceees .. 4681
William Mason Grosvenor (recalled)..... -. 4706
James Wilding (recalled).......... cocccee O790
Arthur Howard Higgins (recalled)......... 4729
Geerwe A. CHAPMRR sc cesciccccccccecccces GUOR
Samuel P. Sadtler (recalled).............. 4785
Frank G, Janney (recalled)............... 4814
Edward W. Englemann (recalled).......... 4828
James Walter Dudgeon..............e.0.. 4834
-EESESEEE:
_—
viii INDEX.
Original. Print
Testimony of Arthur Wellsley Hackwood ,......eseeeeeee 4837 2661
Ren H. Dosenbach (recalled) ......+-+++++- 4845 2664 !
James Walter Dudgeon (recalled)......... 4804 2669 a
Arthur Wellsley Hackwood (recalled) ...... 4860 ©2672 '
Frank R. Wicks... 6... 666 eee cere TTTTITTT T. 4869 2676
Plaintiff's Exhibit 1—Agreement between Butte and Su-
perior Copper Co., LAd., and James
M. Hyde, July 22, 1911....+-+++ 4XSY 2687
2—Agreement between Hyde and Butte
and Superior Copper Co., Ltd., |
October 26, 1911.....66eeees es | 2691
a Atwater to Hyde, Septem-
21, 1911. cevesteceseoe GP 2693
4+ Ment Hyde to Bruse, pears 24,1913 4903 2604
5—Letter, MacKelvie to Bruce, July 2,
WDIB .ccccece i ceneueeehenmanens dO 2695 J
6—TLetter, James M. Hyde to M. W.
Atwater, January 5, 1912........ 4907 2696
7—letter, J. L. Bruce to D, C. Jack-
ling, May 17, 1918.....6.++++00 4910 2698 :
&—Letter, J. M. Hyde to N. B. Mac-
Kelvie, July 15, 1913......++-++- 4911 2698
9—Letter, F. R. Wicks to F. G. Janney,
September 16, 1913.......+-++ ~--. 4028 2706
10—Letter, N. B. MacKelvie to A. H.
Rogers, March 1, 1913; expense
account of J. M. Hyde, January
2D, 1913 ...cercceveceecsscceces 4947 2715
11—Voucher, Butte and Superier Copper
Co. to J. M. Hyde for $601.70.... 4949 2716
12—Check of Butte and Superior ~ pper
Co. to J. M. Hyde for $601 J.... 4950 2717
13—Expense account of J. M. Hy ie and
voucher for $325.65.......++0+++ 4952 2718
18—Paragraph from third annual report
of Butte and Superior Co., read
Defendant's Exhibit 19—Mining World, December 30, 1916,
20—Engineering and Mining Journal,.
December 23, 1916, page 35... 4957 = 2721
21-—Salt Lake Mining Review, Jan-
uary 15, 1917, page 55......-- 4959 2722
22—Mining and Scientific Press, Jan-
uary 6, 1917, page 15.......+. 4960 2723
23— Advertisement, Boston News Bu-
reau, Feb, 21, 1917, page 10 4961 2723
24—Advertisement, New York Com-
mercial, January 15, 1917, '
Defendant's Exhibit
Plaintiff's Exhibit
Plaintiff's Exhibit
Defendant's Exhibit
Plaintiff's Exhibit
Defendant's Exhibit
INDEX.
Original. Print
25—Letter, Williams to Utah Copper
Co,, January 30, 1917.........
26—Record of flotation operations on
the retreatment of vanner con-
GURINOED se scccasvvccececcese
27—Wicks sketch .....ccccccccccces
28—Record of flotation operations on
the treatment of slime vanner
CONS cccececes decvesoescece
20—Revcord of flotation operations on
the retreatment of vanner con-
COMEPROES ccccccces er eescecces
30-——Utah Copper Company, retreat-
ment plant results..... éevseee
31—Utah Copper Company, expert-
ments on low-grade concen-
SNE: dave eeveséevevéntcscees
32—Utah Copper Company, experi-
ments on slime feed.........
33-—No, 1,167,076, T. A. Janney.....
34— No, 1,201,063, T. A. Janney.....
35—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, retreatment plant re-
sults, 9, 1, 14, to 12, 24, '16...
36—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, retreatment plant re-
sults, 12, 25, '16, to 4, 7, 17...
37—Sketch of flotation section No. 3,
Magna plant, by Conrads.....
38—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, statement of copper
losses, 12, 25, "16, to 4, 2, '17...
39—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, 12, 25, "16, to 12, 31, 16
40—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, January report........
41—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, February report.......
42—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, March report..........
43—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, April report....... eene
44—Ray Consolidated Copper Co.,
PNFGGE GONE. vicccvdscevees
45—Sketch of concentrates retreating
plant, Hayden plant, by Engle-
WED cvddevevcesweciseceseve
46—Disclaimer slip ....... wedetuge
47—California Journal of Technology,
November, 1903 .............
4989
4990
4903
4996
4997
4908
5006
HOLS
5016
2752
epee
INDEX.
Original. Print
Defendant's Exhibit 48—Stebbins patent 266,219......... 5053 2765
49—Sullivan patent 306,441....... .. 5056 2768
50—Die Trocknendea Oele, by Andes,
pages 37 and 38..... boivecese | Ge 2772 f
51—Agricola De Re Metallica, illus- ;
tration on page 200.......... 5064 2775 i
52—Phillips photograph 16-3........ 5068 2777 ;
53—Phillips photograph 17-3........ 5069 2778 j
D4—Phillips photograph 1-3........ 5070 2779 :
55—Phillips photograph 2-3........ 5071 2780
56——Phillips photograph 3-3........ 5072 2781
57—Phillips photograph 4-3........ 5073 2782
58—Phillips photograph 8-3........ 5074 2783
59-—Phillips photograph 5-3........ 5075 2784
60—Phillips photograph 16-2........ 5076 2785
61—Phillips photograph 17-2........ 5 2786
62—Phillips photograph 1-2........ 5078 2787 4
63--Phillips photograph 2-2........ 5079 2788 i
64—Phillips photograph 3-2........ 5 27 /
>—Phillips photograph 4-2........ 5081 2790 i
66—Phillips photograph 8-2.......- 5 2791 j
67—Phillips photograph 5-2.......- 5083 2792 i
68—Phillips photograph 16-1........ 5084 2793
69—Phillips photograph 17-1........ 5OR5S 2794 i
70—Phillips photograph 1-1........ 5086 2795
71—Phillips photograph 2-1........ 5087 2796
72—Phillips photograph 3-1........ 5 2797
73—Phillips photograph 4-1........ 5089 2798
74—Phillips photograph 8-1........ 5090 2799 ;
75—Phillips photograph 5-1........ 5091 2800 :
76—Phillips photograph 21-3........ 5002 2801 j
77—Phillips photograph 22-3........ 5 2802
78—Phillips photograph 9-3........ 5 2803
79—Phillips photograph 10-3........ 5095 2804
80—Phillips photograph 11-3........ 5096 2805
81—Phillips photograph 12-3........ 5097 2806
82—Phillips photograph 13-3........ 5098 2807 '
83—Phillips photograph 14-3..... ... 5099 2808
84—-Phillips photograph 21-2........ 5100 2809
85—Phillips photograph 22-2........ 5101 2810
86—Phillips photograph ©2........ 5102 2811
87—Phillips photograph 10-2....... . §108 2812
88—Phillips photograph 11-2........ 5104 2813
89—Phillips photograph 12-2........ 5105 2814
90—Phillips photograph 13-2........ 5106 2815
91—Phillips photograph 14-2... . 5107 2816
92—Phillips photograph 21-1........ 5108 2817
93—Phillips photograph 22-1........ 5100 2818
94—Phillips photograph 9-1........ 5110 2819
95—Phillips photograph 10-1........ 5111 2820
INDEX. xi
Original. Print
Defendant's Exhibit 96—Phillips photograph 11-1....... - §112
97—Phillips photograph 12-1........ 5113
98—Phillips photograph 13-1....... . 6114
99—Phillips photograph 14-1........ 5115
100—Phillips photograph 18-3..... --. 5116
101—Phillips photograph 18-2....... - GHT
102—Phillips photograph 18-1........ 5118
103—Phillips photograph 15-2........ 5119
104—Phillips photograph 19-2........ 5120
105—Phillips photograph 20-2....... - §121
106—Phillips photograph 15-1........ 5122
107—Phillips photograph 19-1........ 5123
108—Phillips photograph 20-1........ 5124
109—Phillips photograph 19-3........ 5125
110-—Phillips photograph 20-3........ 5126
111—Phillips photograph 27-1........ 5127
112—Phillips photograph 27-3........ 5128
113—Phillips photograph 27-2........ 5129
114—Phillips photograph 28-2........ 5130
1145—Phillips photograph 28-1........ 5131
116—Phillips photograph 28.......... 5132
117—Phillips photograph 24.......... 5133
118—Phillips photograph 25.......... 5134
119—Phillips photograph 26.......... 5135
120—-Phillips photograph 29.......... 5136
121—Phillips photograph 30.......... 5137
122—Phillips photograph 31.......... 5138
123—Phillips photograph 82.......... 5138
124—Photograph of Phillips’ bar
mixer apparatus ............ 5139
125—-Corrected copy of Wicks No. 28 5141
126—Taggart diagram No. 8......... 5142
127—-Taggart diagram No. 4......... 5143
128—Taggart diagram No. 5......... 5144
129—Taggart diagram No. 6......... 5145
130—Taggart diagram No. 7......... 5146
131—Beach diagram No. 8......... 5147
132—Beach diagram No. 9......... 5148
133—Beach diagram No, 10......... 5149
134—Beach diagram No. 11......... 5150
135—Beach diagram No. 12......... 5151
136—Beach diagram No. 13......... 5152
137—Beach diagram No. 14......... 5153
139—Beach diagram No. 15......... 5155
140—Beach diagram No. 16......... 5156
141—Taggart diagram No. 1......... 5157
142—Taggart diagram No. 2......... 5158
143—Freundich Kapillarchemie, | fig-
WPS O98 i.c0000000% svevecsecey G00
144—Beach diagram No. 17......... 5160
INDEX.
Original. Print
Defendant’s Exhibit 145—Beach diagram No, 18.........
146—Beach diagram No, 19...... we
147—Beach diagram No, 20.........
148—Beach diagram No, 21.........
149—Ray Consolidated Copper Co., air
machine treating s)ime vanner
CHETIME civccccccedesvevesoecse
150—Ray Consolidated Copper Co., re-
treating vanner concentrate...
151—Ray Consolidated Copper Co., re-
treating slime vanner tails....
152—Ray Consolidated Copper Co.,
sketch flow sheet pyramid air
eee eT ee ee ee
153—Ray Consolidated Copper Co.,
photo pyramid machine.......
154—Ray Consolidated Copper Co.,
table of comparison of results,
eer Oe eee ee ee ee
155—Englemann’s photograph K. & K.
machine, treating 100 tons, Ray
Consolidated Copper Co. .....
156—-Englemann cut of K. & K. ma-
CD bo eewececdenssceseyeres
157—Englemann cut of K. & K. ma-
GED veh iota 9 se Ke a6 6 5% w8d wee
158—Flotation operations ...........
159—Flotation plant record, Jan., 1917
160—Statement of percentages of oils
in various mixtures used in
flotation plant during the
months of January, February,
March, and April, 1917.......
161—Flotation plant record, Feb., 1917
162—Flotation plant record, March,
163—Flotation pyramid machines....
164—-Statement showing percentages
of oils in the various mixtures
used on the three pyramid ma-
chines while running them on
experimental tests............
165—Dosenbach, Butte and Superior
flow sheet, Butte and Superior
plant, April 29, 1917......... ‘
166—V oucher, Butte and Superior Cop-
per Co. to Hyde, month July,
1911, $165.00...........006% oa
167—Same, August, 1911, $155.......
168—Same, September, 1911, $150....
5161
5189
5193
5199
5202
5205
5206
——
INDEX,
Defendant's Exhibit 169—Same, September, 1911, $150....
170—Same, September, 1911, $150....
171—Same, October, 1911, $5,000.....
172—Same, October, 1911, $130......
173—Expense account of J. M. Hyde
and voucher of Butte and Su-
perior Copper Co., $230.15....
174— Voucher, Butte and Superior Cop-
per Co. to J. M. Hyde, month
March, $369.47...............
175—Same, April, $400..............
176—Check, July 8, 1912, $200.......
177—Check, Butte and Superior Cop-
per Co., Ltd., to J. M. Hyde,
November 21, 1912, $602.50;
letter, J. M. Hyde to M. W.
Atwater, October 23, 1912: ex-
pense account of J. M. Hyde,
trip to Washington, leaving
Butte April 17, 1912, $334.05:
expense account of J. M. Hyde,
trip to London, leaving Butte
July 18, 1912, $868.45 ; voucher,
Butte and Superior Copper Co.,
November 21, 1912, to James
iii
*nt
Original. Pg
5208 290
5209 291
5210 292
5211 2:
93
5212 23
4)
5214 206
5215 297
5216 2:
18
5217 2s
M. Hyde, $602.50.............
178—Letter, N. B. MacKelvie to J. L.
Bruce, July 31,1913, and letter,
J. M. Hyde to N.B. MacKelvie,
GUS BO Mew vv ivecccccceecs
182—Drawing of Cataract machine...
183—Drawing of Janney machine....
184—Drawing of square glass jar ma-
GMAND View we Os08 a0 bes eewe vevs
190—Metallurgical and Chemical En-
gineering article by Bancroft. .
191—Chino Copper Co. table, Novem-
ber, 1916, vanner concentrates
192—Ray Consolidated Copper Co.,
1916 vanner concentrates. ....
193—Ray Consolidated Copper Co.,
1916 slime vanner tailings....
194—Butte and Superior Mining Com-
pany, data flotation plant oper-
ations, November, 1916.......
195—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, vanner concentrates, Sep-
tember, 1914, to December 24,
BO Mis CGF Owe SURO be bee Rie
1
5222 292
52 293
5224 294
5225-2
5226 29
6
5227 29
3
5229 29
2
5234. 29
»
5235 29
>
5236 29
5237 29:
5238 29:
cal
xiv
INDEX.
Original. Print
Iefendant’s Exhibit 196—Utah Copper Company, Magna
plant, vanner concentrates,
WOOE WB eas ceccovsveveess oer
197—Utah Copper Company, Magna
PlANE cosccccccccscesesescecs
198—Utah Copper Company, Arthur
plant, slime feed, September 1
to October 31, 1916...........
199—Utah Copper Company, Arthur
DROME cc vccvcvessveseeseovnee
200—Taggart diagram No, 24........
201—Graph chart No, 3, Utah Copper
Oo., Mama Plattt.cccccccccese
202—Graph chart No. 1, Utah Copper
Co., Magna plant............
208-—-Graph chart No. 4, Ray Consoli-
dated Copper Co., Hayden,
APIBONE coccvcvssevccceres eos
204—Graph chart No, 2, Ray Consoli-
dated Copper Co., Hayden,
ROTTER oc ccecceceveveesverse
205—Graph chart No. 2, Chino Copper
Co., Hurley plant.......cccces
206—Graph chart No, 2, Butte and
Superior Mining Co...........
207—Graph chart No. 2, Utah Copper
Co., Magna plant.............
208—-Graph chart No. 1, Butte and Su-
perior Mining Co., Hurley plant
209—Graph chart No. 1, Chino Copper
Co., Hurley plant.............
210—Graph chart No. 3, Ray Consoll-
dated Copper Co., Hayden,
ATIZONA 2... ec eee eee eeeesees
211—Graph chart No. 1, Ray Consoli-
dated Copper Co., Hayden plant
212—Test No. 1, machine No. 1, re-
treatment plant, thirteen cells,
full feed, no circulation; test
performed 9:30 p. m. to 10:30
p. m., April 21, 1917 (not ad-
WUACOE) ccdvcsccvvcevcscvcees
213—Test No. 2, machine No, 1, re-
treatment plant, thirteen cells,
Pall BeOE, GO. ccvccceccvcccces
214—Data compiled from monthly
statements (form No. 62-R)
showing results of operation of
vanner concentrate retreatment
plant during year 1916, di-
5240
5242
5244
5247
5248
5249
5250
5251
5252
5253
5258
5259
5260
5261
2912
2912
2912
2912
2912
2912
2912
2912
2912
2912
2913
INDEX.
XV
Original. Print
vided into 10-day periods;
these figures submitted below
consist of the missing periods
as shown by similar report
compiled April 30, 1917.......
Defendent’s Exhibit 215--Ure's Dictionary of Arts, Manu-
factures, and Mines, pages 330,
331, 332, 335, 353, 354, 355, 356,
Seay WE OU Sadduceeeccexes«
216—No. 10,929 of 1910, to Hoover and
Minerals Separation, Ltd......
217—Drawing of Fryer Hill machine
218—Patent No. 962,678, to Sulman
OF Ge: actetiee redex twnseeder
219—Flow sheet for concentrate flota-
Wee SD vd wan ebuiesoreess
220—-Metallurgical department, 8-hour
test made in retreatment plant,
consisting of two emulsifiers
and thirteen cells, using 323.78
pounds of oil per ton of low-
grade concentrate ; test started
April 29 at 5:45 p. m. and
ended April 30 at 1:45 a. m...
221—Flow sheet for slime flotation
plant, Arthur plant...........
222—Flow sheet, Butte and Superior
ee
223—Flotation plant operations for
the month of February, 1917..
224—Flow sheet, Butte and Superior
seven-cell test machine.......
ZIG—-DIAGIAN ocisivsccisccevevesces
227—Report showing results of sam-
ples taken from 1 ¢o 5 p. m.,
Sunday, April 29, 1917, at time
of Minerals Separation visit. .
228—Data compiled from original rec-
ords of flotation plant opera-
tions, month of November, 1916,
flotation plant feed...........
229—-Argument of William Houston
Kenyon in Supreme Court U.S.
in Hyde case ..............05.
230—Chino Copper Co., flotation data,
November, 1916 ......... anew
231—Chino -Copper Co., rosin and re-
agents used in vanner concen-
trate, November, 1916 ........
5290
5310
xvi INDEX,
Original. Print
Defendant's Exhibit 232—Assignment, James M. Hyde to
Butte and Superior Copper Co.,
Ltd., of patent No. 1,022,085. .
Plaintiff's Exhibit 233—Letter, Hyde to Ctark, September
We SEE BAUS EEV EEK CERNUS Ces eves
Defendant's Exhibit 234—Certificate of Patent Office that
no disclaimer has been filed to
patent No, 835,120 other than
one filed March 28, 1917......
Defendant's Exhibit 235—Reports Nos. 118, 119, and 120
for April 28 to April 30, in-
UE Sean Ge vntewes debe v eens
Plaintiff's Exhibit 236—Affidavit, dated April 10, 1917,
PRUETT DOH sicccceecceucesccs
237—Diagram No. 1, Dr. Grosvenor, bub-
Ee GUO WEME vecvascvescoeenecs
238—Diagram No, 2, Dr. Grosvenor, bub-
WIS GEAWINED cc ciccscsccccccece
239—Diagram No. 3, Dr. Grosvenor, bub-
Wee MIEN oc cede iwetteasices
240—Diagram No. 4, Dr. Grosvenor, bub-
ble drawings .......ccccccccees
241—Diagram No. 5, Dr. Grosvenor, bub-
ble drawings .............0000.
242—Flow sheet, Anaconda C. M. Co....
243—Flow sheet, Anaconda slime flota-
ee re
244—Anaconda zinc ore concentrator...
245—Flow sheet, Magna mill, Utah Cop-
A Sere ere ee ere
246—Flow sheet, Timber Butte mill....
247—Report flotation oil consumptions
and acid consumptions..........
248—Record of flotation oils...........
249—Comparison annual results, Timber
pe Pare eee err
250—Flow sheet No. 2, copper section,
Timber Butte mill, April, 1917..
Defendant’s Exhibit 251—Experime tal and research de-
partment, determinations on
Magna flotation products for
Butte and Superior litigation.
Plaintiff's Exhibit 252—Report of visit of Minerals Sepa-
ration party, April 29, 1917, test
run 1:00 to 5:00 p. m...........
253—Utah copper samples (statement)..
254—Drawing of Cataract machine.....
255—Table referring to Defendant’s Ex-
hibit 29, retreatment of vanner
concentrates, Mr. Wicks’ evidence,
Q. 25 and Q. 26......cccecccees
5312
S316
5321
5325
5332
5335
5336
5337
5338
5339
5342
5370
2951
2959
Zz
INDEX. xvii
Original, Print
Piatntiff's Exhibit 256—Table referring to Defendant’ Ex.
hibit No. 150, retreatment of van-
her concentrate products, Mr.
Englemann's testimony, (). 82, Q.
' Gey Mr WE caciécsdsdwavences TZ 22
257—Statement of Butte and Superior
) Copper Co, filed in court pursuant
to order of November 15, 191%,
for month of January, 1916..... WTS 200
28-—Same, February, 116............. hOTM 2
250—Same, March, 1916............... HOSS LT
t 200—Same, April, 1916................. TNT wow
261—Same, May, 1916................. nao S001
: 262—Same, June, 1916................. 50% OO
203—Same, July, 1916.,............... aaoo S005
’ 2H4—Same, August, 1916............... TAOS BOOT
205-—Same, September, 116............ DOT nooo
2H5—Same, October, 116.............. An ont
267-—-Same, November, 191€............ MALS SOLS
268-—Same, December, 116............ oo BOWS
269-—Same, January, W17.............. 4s WAT
270-— Same, February, 1917............. NAT no
271—Same, March, 1917............... MASI B021
272—Table of Butte and Superior Min.
ing Company flotation plant re.
sults, calculated from the sworn
statements of the manager to the
Federal court, Butte, Montana., 5436 3022
273-—Same, comparisons made het ween
the results of operation with ex
cess oil with those of operation
with small quantities........... DAaS R022
274— Atwater tabulation estimate of in-
creased revenue to Butte and Su
perior Copper Co, had it followed
wet concentration with flotation
i during period of milling opera-
tions at Basin, Montana, Janu-
ary 1, 1910, to April 30, 1912.... M441 3022
275—Table, comparisons of results at
' Timber Butte and Butte and Su-
perior mills for first quarter of
WOES” Seu dietssceuees Trirorte 448 8022
278—G rosvenor photograph O-1........ D445 8023
279—Grosvenor photograph 0-2........ 5447 3024
280—Grosvenor photograph 0-3........ 5448 8025
281—Grosvenor photograph O-4........ 5449 8026
282—Grosvenor photograph A-1........ 5450 8027
283—Grosvenor Photograph A-2........ 5451 3028
284—Grosvenor photograph A-3........ 5452 8029
—7
Original. Vrint
Ilaintiff’s Exhibit 285-—Grosvenor photograph A-d........ 5458 3080
286-—Grosvenor photograph A-}........ ie bs) SO81
287-—CGrosvenor diagram No, 6, showing
apparatus in which moving pic-
tures were taken .-. 66.66.0006 DAT Sos
2ss—Agreement of July 8, 1915, between
Minerals Separation, Ltd., and
Minerals Separation American
Syndicate (1913), Limited...... DADS ORS
Zs0— Bill of sale from Minerals Separa-
tion American Syndicate 1915,
ltd. to Minerals Separation
North American Corporation.... 5472 SO40
xviii INDEX.
200 Diagram by Welding ........6.05. TASS 3050
201—Abstract of Minerals Separation
MP PTETETERITELEP LEE ASO 3051
202-—Minerals Separation North Amert-
can Corporation license form.... 5518 BOGS
300—Flow sheet Tospiration plant..... noo S079
301—Flow sheet Baden Copper Company,
CBlbe cccccccvesseveccceseeveess na SOSO0
Defendant's Exhibit So2-—Results of an experiment per-
formed in court and testified
to by B. H. Dosenbach, minta-
ture flotation plant .......... 5aa6 3OS81
308—Reports screen analyses run on
samples taken on April 20,
1917, at time Minerals Separa-
Chom vials woccececvsccccesess NST SOR2
304— Assay results of several tests per-
formed by B. H. Dosenbach.. 5542 3082
305—Results of an experiment per-
formed in court and testified
to by B. H. Dosenbach, test
a DE covecsocsedscavecessss 3082
306—Photograph model pyramid ma-
chine (view showing side and
front Of COlIS) .. 6. cece eee eee 546 3083
307—Same (view showing real sludge
CED cc cvevessetccesceesesss GA BOR
308—Same (view showing rear of
cells, drives, &C.)....6.00006. SAD 3085
Plaintiff's Exhibit 300—Department of concentration, table
reagent consumption, pounds per
ton of flotation feed, March, 1917 5551 8085
310—Same, February, 1917............. S562 3085
311—Same, January, 1917............. 5553 3085
312—Department of concentration, cur-
rent mills slime, per cent. copper 5554 3085
INDEX. Xvix
Original. Print
Plaintiff's Exhibit 318—Reagent consumption and sulphide
content of ore, January, 1917.... 5555 3085
314—Same, February, 1917............. 5556 3085
315—Same, March, 1917............... HOG 3085
Defendant's Exhibit 316—Tabulation referring to defend-
ant’s Exhibit 29, retreatment
of vanner concentrates, Mr.
Wicks’ evidence, Q. 25 and
Re OW. eeenecece deesecvevesses SiS 3OS5
Plaintiff's Exhibit 317 ~Assay report Butte and Superior
miniature plant test, Minerals
SINT 0.05 eccccccechess cscs 5561 POND
Plaintiff's Exhibit 318--Assays of Higgins’ tests, Minerals
WIEN. Sek os t0eececascusees G2 JOS5
Seer GUNN wise cncceuscdeenceucsnetecsecsedieégan DG4 JOST
Testimony of Hugh M. Tame...c.ccccccccccccccsccccecce 56 SSS
SG Gh PEs vs cvesmcvascveccdxcacce neo ooo
Cen F, Coe cccecccscecsccececes HTO yen
Order assigning case for foot of February, 1918, session. ..... HaS0 OT
Order for withdrawal of exhibits, &e.. 6.0.00. ccceccceceecuce DOS1 S008
DOT CE CED esccvcvownuscececscccseccecceccetccteece nS? sono
Soe SD BONN. a 600 05ccncsecccsncsdecaueccecacan 5OS4 S000
Order directing filing of opinions and recording decree......... SASS 3100
ee SN Gh. Uebeenwecceheosetsenevecoreveeesééee cvmecas HHS6 8101
Opinion, Hunt, J., concurring............ceccecceccccccccecce HOS 2107
Opinion, Morrow, C. J., coneurring in part and dissenting in
Gow WHURORSAvanedueterteseccacencesedetosesesesedoodeods, neo2 S109
DT MANN EGbAnd toni cent dncdbanbatercadbaleuduie ticks HOOT siz
ST ON GO ss covcccaccsveccesuetecesenceccececss G08 S118
SONI SUNG s Sa deendvnesecevnde sebuesaeceonsboumieu: 5610 3114
Writ of certiorari and return.............00cccc cece eteavveeun 5611 8115
ne ly > aeenernl
BUTTE 4 SUK, MNG. CO, V8. MIN, SEP., LTD, RT AL. 1
a United States Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cireuit,
No, 3081,
Burre axp Surenion Mixixne Comraxy, Designated as Butte and
Superior Copper Company, Limited, a Corporation, Appellant,
Va,
Mixewars Seranation, Limerep, a Corporation; Minenats Serana-
Tios Amenicas Syxoicate, Limerep, a Corporation, and Minerals
Separation North American, a Corporation, Appellees.
Substituted Pursuant to Order Filed Mareh 1%, 1018, for Incorrect
Copy Filed November 10, 1917,
Traxscurr or Recor
Volume 1.
( Pages i to cexxx.)
Upon Appeal from the United States District Court for the District
of Morcina.
Filed Mar, 19, 1918. F. D. Monekton, Clerk.
i (Names and Addresses of) Attorneys of Record.
Mr. Henry D. Williams, New York, N. Y.;
Mr. Lindley M. Garrison, New York, N. Y.;
Mr. William Houston Kenyon, New York, N. Y_;
Mr. Odell W. McConnell, Helena, Montana,
Solicitors and of Counsel for Complainants and Appellees,
Mr. Thomas F. Sheridan, Coleen, Illinois ;
Mr. J. Edgar Bull, New York, N. Y.;
Mr. J. Bruce Kremer, Butte, Montana;
Mr. L.. P. Sanders, Butte, Montana ;
Mr. Alf. C. Kremer, Butte, Montana,
Solicitors and of Counsel for Defendant and Appellant,
2 BUTTE 4 SUPR, MNG. CO. VS. MIN, SRP., LTD, ET AL.
In the District Court of the United States for the District of Montana,
Minenacs Seraration, Limeren; Mixerans Separation Ament-
eax Syxprcate, Laserrep, and Minerals Separation North Ameri-
can Corporation, Plaintiffs,
va.
Berre axo Srernton Mixixnc Company, Formerly Butte and Su-
perior Copper Company, Limited, Defendant.
Be it remembered, Thatwon the 10th day of October, 1915, a Bill
of Complaint was filed herein, which said bill is in the words and
figures as follows, to-wit:
il United States Dietrict Court, District of Montana,
In Equity.
Mixenats Seranatios, Lawerep, Plaintiff,
ve.
Berre & Screnor Correr Company, Liserrep, Defendant,
Bill of ¢ ‘omplaint,
The plaintiff for its Bill of Complaint alleges:
1. That the plaintiff is a corporation duly organized and existing
under and by virtue of the Laws of Great Britain and an inhabitant
of Great Britain, and having its principal office in London, England ;
and that, on information and belief, the defendant is a corporation
duly organized and ex.cting under the Laws of the State of Arizona
has a ilar and established place of business in the City of
Butte, Silver Bow County, State of Montana, where it has commit-ed
acts of infringement hereinafter complained of.
2. t this suit is brought under the patent laws of the
iii United States for the infringement of United States Letters
Patent No, 835,120, issued November 6, 1906, for improve-
ments in Ore Concentration.
3. That on the 29th day of May, 1905, Henry Livingstone Sulman,
Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot, being within
the meaning of the statutes of the United States then in those the
original, first and joint inventors of a certain new and useful process
of ore concentration, and being entitled to a patent thereon under
the provisions of said statutes, duly filed in the United States Patent
Office an epplicetion for Letters Patent for the said invention, and
that on the 6th day of November, 1906, all of the requirements of
the statutes then in force having been duly complied with, the said
Letters Patent of the United States No, 835,120 were duly issued on
said application to the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh
Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot, which Letters Patent,
or a duly certified copy thereof, the plaintiff will produce as this
Court may direct.
4. That on or about the 7th day of December, 1909, the nid
Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and
John Ballot duly assigned to the plaintiff all rights, title and interest
in and to the said invention and Letters Patent, and that the plain-
tiff is now the sole owner of the said invention and Letters Patent,
avd of all right of action, claim and demand for infringement
thereof since said assignment,
5. That the said invention is of great value and utility, and
in that the plaintiff has been to great trouble and expense in
demonstrating the utility thereof and in introducing the same
inte extensive commercial use in the United States and elsewhere,
wand that the plaintiff has granted numerous licenses for cartying on
said process of ore concentration in the United States and elsewhere
and said proces has been and is now being extensively carried on in
the United States and elsewhere and that the plaintiff is able and
willing to supply the entire demand for the use of said invention by
granting licenses for the use of the same conditioned on the payment
of royalties measured by the output of the said process of ore con-
centration,
6. That the defendant has infringed the said Letters Patent since
the plaintiff acquired the same, by installing apparatus for and
carrying on the use of the said process of ore concentration at the
town of Basin, in the County of Jefferson, State of Montana, and at
the City of Butte, Silver Bow County, State of Montana, without the
consent or allowance of the plaintiff, the said process of ore concen-
tration so carried on by the Jefendant embodying the said invention
as claimed in claims 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7,9, 10, 11 and 12 of said Letters
Patent, and that the defendant is carrying on said infringement at
the last named place as a continuing act and threatens to continue
*© to infringe.
7. That the plaintiff and another, on or about October 9, 1911,
brought suit in this Court against James M. Hyde for infringement
of said Letters Patent No, 835,120, and that said suit was fully
v contested on its merits and presented at length to this Court
on the briefs and arguments of counsel and that this Court,
in an opinion filed July 26, 1913, this Court having jurisdiction of
the persons and subject matter in said suit, directed that an inter-
locutory decree be entered adjudging the validity of said Letters
Patent and infringement thereof by the said defendant James M.
Hyde as to the particular claims above charged to be infringed by
the defendant herein, and directing the issuance of an injunction
restraining further infringement, and a reference to a master for
wcertaining profits and damages, and that on or about August 15,
1913, a decree was entered as thus directed by this Court and further
proceedings have been had in accordance therewith, including the
issuance of a permanent injunction restraining further infringement
of said Letters Patent No, 835,120,
8. On information and belief, that the defendant herein confed-
erated with the said James M. Hyde in the acts of infringement com-
plained of in the said suit against the said James M. Hyde and was
an actual defendant therein, and conducted the defense of said suit
wnd paid all the expenses thereof and paid the said James M. Hyde
for his servic » in assisting in the defense of the said suit; that the
BUTTE 4 SUPR, MNG, CO, V8. MIN, SEP., LTD, ET AL, 3
—7
acts decreed in the said suit to be acts of infringement were carried
on under certain Letters Patent issued to said James M. Hyde on
April 2, 1912, No. 1.022.085, and that since the commencement of
said suit the said James M. Hyde assigned to the defendant herein
all of the right, title and interest of the said James M. Hyde
4 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
vi in, to and under his said Letters Patent No. 1,022,085, for,
to and in the County of Silver Bow and State of Montana ;
that the acts decreed in the said suit to be acts of infringement were
carried on in the mill of the defendant herein and by the employees
of the defendant herein and have been continued by the defendant
herein in the identical apparatus used by the said James M. Hyde;
and that this defendant is a joint tort feasor with the said James M.
Hyde in the acts thus decreed to be infringements and is in privity |
with the said James M. Hyde and is bound by the said decree against
the said James M. Hyde.
9. On information and belief, that, prior to the commencement
of the said suit against James M. Hyde, the plaintiff caused the de-
fendant in the present suit to be notified of the rights of the plaintiff
under said Letters Patent No. 835,120, and that the defendant in
this suit was duly advised of the proceedings in said suit as aforesaid,
and, as will appear by the Aiea of this Court, that the permanent
injunction, above referred to, issued pursuant to said decree against
the said James M. Hyde, was directed to the said James M. Hyde,
his confederates and associates, and, with a copy of the said decree
directing the issuance of said injunction, has been served upon the |
defendant in the present suit, but, nevertheless, the defendant has |
continued to infringe the said Letters Patent in defiance of the de-
cree of this Court and of the injunction issued thereon and
vil to its own profit and to the damage of the plaintiff.
The plaintiff therefore prays:
I. For a permanent injunction and a preliminary injunction
pending the determination of this suit, restraining the defendant, its
confederates, associates, oflicers, servants, agents, clerks and work-
men from any installation or use in any manner of the said patented
invention, and particularly claims 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11 and 12
thereof, or any part thereof, in violation of the rights of the plain-
tiff as aforesaid, and from encouraging and inducing others to in-
fringe the said Letters Patent, and from defending other infringers
of said Letters Patent or reimbursing them the expense of defending
against said Letters Patent, in whole or in part, or otherwise aiding
or abetting others to,install or use processes of ore concentration in
infringement of said Letters Patent.
II. For costs and for an accounting of profits and damages, and
that any damages assessed may be tripled.
III. For such other and further relief as the cireumstances of the
case may require.
MINERALS SEPARATION, LTD.,
By S. GREGORY, Director.
0, W. McCONNELL,
Solicitor for Complainant.
HENRY D. WILLIAMS, Of Counsel.
: ee
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 5
villi Strate or New York,
County of New York, ss:
Seth Gregory, being duly sworn, deposes and says that’ he is a
director of Minerals Separation, Limited, the plaintiff named in the
foregoing Bill of Complaint; that he has read the same and knows
the contents thereof, and that the same is true of his own knowledge,
except as to the matters therein alleged on information and belief.
and as to those matters he believes it to he true: and that he verily
helieves that Henry Livingstone Sulman. Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpat-
rick-Picard and John Ballot were the-true, first. original and joint
inventors of the invention set forth and claimed in the Letters Patent
referred to in the Bill of Complaint.
S. GREGORY,
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 2nd day of October, 19138,
[ SEAL. | GEO, W. SIMERS, Jr..
Notary Public, N.Y. Co.
No. 3529.
Filed: October 10, 1913. Geo. W. Sproule, Clerk.
ix And thereafter on October 15th, 1913, subpeena duly served
on defendant was filed, being as follows, to-wit:
Unirep Spates or AMERICA:
District Court of the United States, District of Montana.
In Equity.
The President of the United States of America to Butte & Superior
Copper Company, Limited, Defendant, Greeting:
You are hereby commanded, That you be and appear in said
District Court of the United States aforesaid. at the Court Room in
Federal Building, Butte, Montana, on the 30th day of October, 1913,
to answer a Bill of Complaint exhibited against you in said Court
by Minerals Separation, Limited, Complainant, who is a citizen of
Great Britain, and having its principal office in London, England,
and to do and receive what the said Court shall have considered in
that behalf. And this you are not to omit, under the penalty of
five thousand dollars,
Witness, the Honorable Geo. M. Bourquin, Judge of the District
Court of the United States for the District of Montana, this 10th
day of October, in the year of our Lord one thousand nine
x hundred and thirteen and of our Independence the 138th.
GEO. W. SPROULE, Clerk,
By C. R. GARLOW,
Deputy Clerk.
LEG PAUSED PIO DD Py ee hae
bo
ee s
6 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
Memorandum Pursuant to Rule 12, Supreme Court U.S.
You are hereby required, to file your answer or other defense in
the Clerk's office of said court on or before the twentieth day after
service, excluding the day hereof; otherwise the bill may be taken
pro confesso.
[Court Seal. | GEO, W. SPROUELE, Clerk,
By C. R. GARLOW,
Deputy Clerk.
O. W. McConnell, Esq.. Solicitor for Complainant, Helena, Mon-
tana.
Henry D. Williams, Esq., of New York City, N. Y., of Counsel.
xi UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
District of Montana:
I hereby certify and return that I received the within Subpena in
Equity together with copy of bill of complaint, on the 13th day of
October, 1913, and that on the same day I served the same on the
Butte Superior Copper Company, Limited, by delivering to and leav-
ing with J. Bruce Kremer, statutory agent for service of Defendant
Company a true copy of said Subpena in Equity, together with a
true copy of bill of complaint, notice, and of affidavits of Joseph C.
Pyle, H. N. Line, Thomas H. Smith, Ernest O. Jacobson, Charles F.
Chandler, Floyd J. Metzger & Henry D. Williams, in said action, at
Butte, Silver Bow County, in said District.
Dated this 13th day of October, 1913.
WILLIAM LINDSAY,
United States Marshal,
By GEORGE A. McKAY, Deputy.
Filed Oct. 15th, 1913. Geo. W. Sproule, Clerk.
xii And thereafter on the 28th day of October, 1913, the
answer of defendant was filed, being as follows, to-wit:
_—
In the District Court of the United States for the District of Mon
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
na,
In Equity.
MINERALS SEPARATION, Limitep, Plaintiff,
Vs.
Butte & Superior Coprer Company, Limitep, Defendant.
Answer.
r . . ed,
The Answer of the Butte and Superior Copper Company, Limra-
Defendant, to the Bill of Complaint of Plaintiff, Minerals Se)
tion, Limited.
self
The defendant now and all times saving and reserving unto san
all and all manner of benefit and advantage of exception whicher-
; or may be had or taken to the errors, uncertainties or other iImto,
fections contained in the bill of complaint herein, for answer he to
or to so much or such parts thereof as it is advised it is materi:
make answer unto, says as follows:
xill I.
in-
This defendant admits that plaintiff is a corporation duly onin
ized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of Great Brijn
and an inhabitant of Great Britain, and has its principal offialy
London, England. Admits that the defendant is a corporation nd
organized and existing under the laws of the State of Arizona, te,
has a regular and established place of business in the City of Bed
Silver Bow County, State of Montana. Denies that it has commee,
acts or any act of infringement at said place, or at any other p or
or at any time, or at all, as alleged in plaintiff's bill of complain
otherwise.
II.
he
Admits that this suit is brought under the patent laws of>rs
United States for the alleged infringement of United States Le;e-
Patent No. 835,120, issued November 6th, 1906, for alleged imprn-
ments in ore concentration; but denies that there has been any
fringement thereof by this defendant.
IIT.
eC,
Denies that on the 29th dav of May, 1905, or at any other tid
Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatriek-Pieard od
John Ballot were, within the meaning of the statutes of the Unat
States then in force, the original or first or joint inventors, or or
either of them was, or that any of them were the original or firs).
joint inventors of a certain new or useful process of orc
a
8 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
xiv _ centration, or were entitled to a patent thereon under the pro-
visions of said statutes, or that they duly filed in the United
States Patent Office an application for Letters Patent of said alleged
invention; denies that on the 6th day of November, 1906, all of the
requirements of the statutes having been duly complied with, the
said Letters Patent of the United States No. 835,120 were duly issued
on said application to the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh
Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot, or either; or any of
them: admits that /a certain alleged patent, being No. 835,120, was
issued to Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-
Picard and John Ballot.
Denies each and every allegation contained in paragraph 3 of
plaintiff's bill of complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted or
denied.
ry.
Denies that it has any knowledge or information as to whether on
or about the 7th day of December, 1909, the said Henry Livingstone
Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Pieard and John Ballot duly or
at all assigned to the plaintiff all right, title and interest in and to said
alleged invention and alleged Letters Patent, or that plaintiff is now
the sole owner of said alleged invention or Letters Patent, or of all
rights of action, or claim, or demand for alleged infringement thereof
since said alleged assignment.
xv ¥.
Defendant denics that said alleged invention is of great value or
utility ; denies that there was or is any invention in the said alleged
patent No, 835,120; denies that it has any knowledge or information
as to whether the plaintiff has been to great trouble or expense in
demonstrating the alleged utility thereof, or in introducing the
same into extensive commercial use in the United States or elsewhere ;
denies that it has anv knowledge or information as to whether the
plaintiff has granted numerous licenses for carrying on said alleged
process of the concentration in the United States or elsewhere ; denies
that said alleged process has been or is now being extensively carried +
on in the United States, or elsewhere; denies that plaintiff has any
patent upon any alleged process, and denies that plaintiff has the
right to grant licenses for the use of said alleged process conditioned
on the payment of royalty measured by the output of said alleged
process of ore concentration, or otherwise, or at all.
Denies each and every allegation contained in paragraph » of
plaintiff's bill of complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted or
denied.
Vi.
Answering the allegations contained in paragraph 6 of plaintiff's
bill of complaint, this defendant denies that it has infringed or is
infringing the said alleged Letters Patent since the plaintiff acquired
the same or any other time, or at all, by installing apparatus
7
cas is OE NG La TONG APO ee ee ae RES eT ee
_7
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 9
xvi for or carrying on the use of said alleged process of ore con-
centration, or in any other manner, or at all, at the town of
Basin, in the County of Jefferson, State of Montana, or at the City
of Butte, Silver Bow County, State of Montana, or at any other place,
or at all, without the consent or allowance of the plaintiff, or at all;
denies that said alleged process of ore concentration alleged to have
been carried on by this defendant embodied the said alleged inven-
tion as claimed in claims one (1), or two (2), or three (3), or five
(9), or six (6), or seven (7), or nine (9), or ten (10), or eleven (11),
or twelve (12), or any other claim of said alleged Letters Patent:
denies that the defendant is carrying on any alleged infringement at
the last named place, or at any other place, or at all, as a continuing
or any act or threatens to continue to use said process or to infringe
or threatens to infringe at all; denies that defendant has ever in-
fringed said alleged patent.
VII.
Answering the allegations contained in paragraph 7 of plaintiff's
bill of complaint, defendant admits that the plaintiff and another,
on or about October 9th, 1911, brought suit in this court ugainst
James M. Hyde for alleged infringement of said Letters Patent No.
835,120, but denies that said suit was fully contested on its merits,
but admits that said suit was presented at length to this Court on
briefs and arguments of counsel; admits that this Court. in an
xvii opinion filed July 26th, 1913, the Court having jurisdiction
of the persons and subject matter in said suit, directed that an
interlocutory deeree be entered adjudging the validity of said Letters
Patent as against James M. Hyde, and infringement thereof by said
James M. Hyde, as to the particular claims herein charged to be the
subject of the alleged infringement by the defendant herein: but
denies that there was an adjudication of the validity of said Letters
Patent as against this defendant, or that this defendant was in any
manner affected by or was in any manner a party to the said alleged
suit above referred to; admits that the above styled Court directed
the issuance of an injunction restraining from alleged further in-
fringement by the said James M. Hyde and a reference to a master for
ascertaining profits and damages to be awarded against the said James
M. Hyde, and admits that on the 15th of August, 1913, a decree was
entered as directed by the said Court and that thereafter, a permanent
injunction restraining the said James M. Hvde from further alleged
infringement of said Letters Patent No. 835,120 was issued by the
above Court. This answering defendant states that thereafter, and
after the entry of said decree, James M. Hyde. the defendant in the
said action above referred to, duly and regularly in compliance with
the laws governing such matters and in compliance with the rules of
this Court and all other Courts having jurisdiction over the said
action, duly and regularly perfeeted an appeal in the ease of
xviii the above-mentioned plaintiff and another against the said
James M. Hyde, and that said appeal was duly and regularly
allowed by a Judge of the Cireuit Court of Appeals, of the Ninth
Circuit, and that said action above referred to is now on appeal, and
—
10 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
that the said cause will shortly be presented to the said Cireuit Court
of Appeals of the Ninth Cireuit for final adjudication and hearing;
and defendant further avers that the said patent in suit by reason of
said appeal to the said Circuit Court of Appeals has not been within
the meaning of the law adjudicated and that the rights of the said
plaintiff above-named and the said James M. Hyde to the use of the
alleged process has not been fully determined and designated by the
Circuit Court of Appeals. :
Further answering the allegations contained in paragraph 7, this
defendant denies each and every allegation contained therein not
hereinbefore specifically admitted or denied.
VIL.
Answering the allegations contained in paragraph 8 of plaintiff's
bill of complaint, this defendant denies that it confederated with the
said James M. Hyde, or any other person, or at all, in the alleged
acts of infringement, or any act of infringement complained of in
the said alleged suit against the said James M. Hyde, or at all; denies
that it was an actual defendant therein, ora defendant therein at all;
denies that it conducted the defense of said suit and denies that it
paid all the expenses thereof, or any of the expenses thereof,
xix except as hereinafter set forth; denies that it paid the said
James M. Hyde for his services in assisting in the defense of
said alleged suit. This defendant avers that the said James M. Hyde
paid the expenses of the defense of the said suit with the exclusive
right in Silver Bow County, Montana, to the process owned by the
said James M. Hyde and covered by United States Patent No. 1,022,-
085, that exclusive right being granted to this defendant herein for
such sum of money as was or is necessary to cover the expenses in-
volved in the defense of the said suit. Denies that the alleged acts
decreed in the said suit referred to to be acts of infringement were
carried on under certain Letters Patent issued to the said James M.
Hyde on April 22nd, 1912, No. 1,022,085, admits that since the com-
mencement of the said suit of the plaintiff and another against
James M. Hyde, the said James M. rlyde assigned to the defendant
herein all of the right, title and interest of the said James M. Hyde
in, to and under his said Letters Patent No. 1,022,085, for, to and in
the County of Silver Bow and State of Montana; denies that any acts
decreed in the said suit to be acts of infringement were carried on
by the said defendant or that any act was carried on by the said de-
fendant; admits that the said James M. Hyde carried on operations
in the mill of the defendant and had working with him certain em-
plovees of the defendant but denies that any act in which the de-
fendant’s employees participated infringed upon the alleged patent
of the plaintiff herein; denies that the defendant herein has
XX continued the use of said alleged process in the identical ap-
paratus or any apparatus used by the said James M. Hyde, or
has continued the use of said process as practised by the said James
M. Hyde at all; denies that this defendant is a joint tort feasor with
the said James M. Hyde in the acts alleged to have been decreed to
—
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, VS. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL. 11
be infringements; denies that this defendant is in privity with the
said James M. Hyde, or any other person or is bound by the said
decree against the said James M. Hyde, or any other person, or is
hound by any decree at all; denies that this defendant is a tort feasor
at all; denies that this defendant is using the alleged process of the
plaintiff above-named or the said alleged process of the said Hyde.
This defendant avers that the flotation process for the concentration
of ore now and heretofore practised and used by it was devised and
developed by its employees; that in the devising and developing of
said process neither defendant nor its employees derived any infor-
mlion or assistance of any kind from the said patent No, 835,120;
that defendant does not and never has practised or used the flotation
process described in said alleged patent of the plaintiffs, nor any flo-
tation process in the mode described in said patent; that the appa-
ratus described in said patent as the instrumentality for practising
the alleged process set forth in said patent is inoperative, impractical
and useless; that no practical, profitable or commercial result can be
obtained from any operations or apparatus described in said
patent.
XXi Further answering the allegations contained in paragraph
8, defendant denies each and every allegation contained in
said paragraph not hereinbefore specifically admitted or denied.
IX.
Answering the allegations contained in paragraph 9, this defend-
ant admits that prior to the commencement of said suit against
James M. Hyde, the plaintiff made claims to the defendant in this
suit that it claimed certain rights under said Letters Patent No,
$35,120, but this defendant denies that the plaintiff in fact had any
riglits under said Letters Patent No. 835,120. This defendant admits
that it was advised of the proceedings in the said suit of Minerals
Separation, Limited, and another, against James M. Hyde; admits
that the above styled Court in said action issued a permanent in-
junction in pursuance of said decree against the said James M. Hyde;
admits that the said injunction and decree was directed to the said
James M. Hyde, his confederates and associates, but denies that this
defendant was at any time or is now a confederate or associate with
the said James M. Hyde, and denies that it was in anywise, or at all,
hound or affected by said decree or said injunction; admits that a
copy of said decree was served upon this defendant: denies that this
defendant has ever infringed the said Letters Patent or has continued
to infringe the said Letters Patent in defiance of the decree
xxii of this Court or of the injunetion issued thereon, to its own
profit or to the damage of the plaintiff, or has it at any
time, or at all, infringed the said Letters Patent: denies that there
was ever a decree of this Court or an injunction of this Court issued
which in any manner affected the above-named defendant in the
use of a flotation process, or otherwise, or at all.
Denies each and every allegation contained in paragraph 9 of
plaintiff's bill of complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted
or denied.
—
12 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO, VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
X.
Denies each and every allegation contained in plaintiff's bill of
complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted or denied.
Further answering plaintiff's bill of complaint, this defendant
further says:
I,
That said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-
Picard and John Ballot were not the original first or true inventors i
of the alleged invention in ore concentration which said Letters
Patent No, 835,120 purport to embrace, or of any material or sub-
stantial part thereof, but that, on the contrary, said alleged inven-
tion and all material and substantial parts thereof had before their
alleged invention been fully and clearly described or claimed in the
following mentioned Letters Patent:
XXill Letters Patent of the United States.
345,951 July 20, 1886.........+: H. Bradford.
348,157 August 24, ISS6......--- C. J. Everson.
444.345 January 6, IS91.....---. E. R. Gabbett.
466.753 January 5, 1892......--- E. A. Hockley.
469.599 February 23, 1892.....-- A. M. Rouse.
471,174 March 22, | a (. B. Hebron and C. J.
Everson.
474,829 May 17, 1892.......---- C. B. Hebron.
575,669 January 19, 1897......-- G. Robson.
653,340 July 10, 1900.......---: F. E. Elmore.
676,679 June 18, 1901.......---- F. E. Elmore.
689,070 December 17, PRPS A. S. Elmore.
692,643 February 4, 1902.......- A. S. Elmore.
729,805 June 2, 1908........-++- J. and L. Stoveken.
735,071 August 4, 1903........-- G. D. Delprat.
736,381 August 18, 1908......--. M. F. R. Glogner.
745,960 December 1, 1908......-+ I. F. Good,
763,259 June 21, 1904........--- A, E. Cattermole.
763,260 June 21, se eect A. E. Cattermole.
768,035 August 23, 1904.......-. G. D. Delprat.
771,075 September 27, 1904....-. C. Kendall.
776.145 November 29, 1904...... C. V. Potter.
777.273 December 13, 1904.....-. A. EF. Cattermole.
777,274 December 13, 1904.....-. A. FE. Cattermole.
H. L. Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard.
787,814 April 18, 1905........-: J.D. Wolf.
788,247 April 25, 1905.......-+-- A. FE. Cattermole.
H. L. Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard.
793,808 July 4, 1905.......-+++- H. L. Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard.
809,959 January 16, 1906......-. E. B. Kirby.
i Stead een sa ica bid
. Pee Pee ta ee ie
a
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG. CO, VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL, 13
XXiV Letters Patent of Great Britain.
; 488 February 23, 1860........ W. Haynes.
840) January 16, 1889....... Boulton and Gabbett.
‘ 12,778 June 4, 1902............ Lake (Froment).
If.
Also that prior to the supposed invention or discovery of the
alleged process patented in said Letters Patent No. 835,120 by said
Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and
John Ballot each and every material and substantial part of said
supposed invention or discovery so patented had been invented and
used by and was known to the following named persons, and was
fully described in applications for Letters Patent of the United
States deposited and filed by said persons in the United States Patent
Oflice prior to the supposed invention or discovery of said alleged
process set forth in said Letters Patent No. 835,120 by said Sulman,
Kirkpatrick-Pieard and Ballot: that said applications were so de-
posited and filed in the United States Patent Office and that Letters
Patent of the United States were granted upon said applications as
set forth below:
Morits F. R. Glogner, a resident of Freiburg, in the Kingdom
of Prussia, German Empire, on January 27, 1903, deposited and
filed in the United States Patent Office his application for Letters
Peient of the United States, and that Letters Patent No. 736,381
Were granted thereon upon August 18, 1903.
Isracl F’. Good, a resident of Allentown, Pennsylvania, on
xxv October 1, 1902, deposited and filed in the United States
Patent Office, his application for Letters Patent of the United
States, and that Letters Patent No. 745,960 were granted thereon
upon December 1, 1903,
Guillaume D. Delprat, a resident of Broken Hill, Australia, on
January 2, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States Patent
Oflice his application for Letters Patent of the United States. and
that Letters Patent No. 768,035 were granted thereon upon August
23, 1904.
Cosmo Kendall, a resident of Upper Norwood, Surrey, England,
on July 21, 1908, deposited and filed in the United States Patent
Office his application for Letters Patent of the United States, and
that Letters Patent No. 771,075 were granted thereon upon Septem-
ber 27, 1904.
Charles V. Potter, a resident of Balaclava. Victoria, Australia, on
January 14, 1902, deposited and filed in the United States Patent
Office his application for Letters Patent of the United States, and
that Letters Patent No. 776,145 were granted thereon upon No-
vember 29, 1904.
Arthur E. Cattermole, a resident of Highgate, London, England,
on September 28, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States
Patent Office his application for Letters Patent of the United States,
14 RUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, V8, MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL.
and that Letters Patent No, 777,273 were granted thereon upon
December 13, 1904.
XXVi Arthur E, Cattermole, Henry 1. Sulman and Hugh F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard, all residents of London, England, on
March 29, 1904, deposited and filed in the United States Patent
Office their application for Letters Patent of the United States, and
that Letters Patent No. 777,274 were granted thereon upon Decem-
er 13, 1904.
Arthur E. Cattermole, Henry 1. Sulman and Hugh F. Kirkpat-
rick-Picard, all residents of London, England, on March 29, 1904,
deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office their applica-
tion for Letters Patent of the United States, and that Letters Patent
No. 788,247 were granted thereon upon April 25, 1905,
Henry L. Sulman and Hugh F, Kirkpatrick-Picard, residents of
London, England, on October 5, 1903, deposited and filed in the
United States Patent Office their a yplication for Letters Patent of
the United States, and that Letters Patent No. 793,808 were granted
thereon upon July 4, 1905,
Alfred Schwarz, a resident of New York City, New York, on
April 19, 1905, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office,
his application for Letters Patent of the United States, and that
Letters Patent No, 807,501 were granted thereon upon December 19,
1905,
Alfred Schwarz, a resident of New York City, New York, on May
27, 1904, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office, his
application for Letters Patent of the United States, and that
xxvii Letters Patent No, 807,503 were granted thereon upon De-
cember 19, 1903.
Edmund B. Kirby, a resident of Rossland, Canada, on December
14, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office his
application for Letters Patent of the United States, and that Letters
atent No, 809,959 were granted thereon upon January 16, 1906,
Edmund B. Kirby, a resident of Rossland, Canada, on December
17, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office his
application for Letters Patent of the United States, and that Letters
Patent No, 838,626 were granted thereon upon December 18, 1906.
Also patented or described and contained in other Letters Patent,
the dates, numbers and grantees of which this defendant is not now
able to specify, but prays to be allowed hereafter to add by amend-
ment of this answer or otherwise, if it shall become necessary.
Also illustrated and described in printed publications, the names
and dates of which defendant is not able to specify, but prays to be
allowed hereafter to add to this answer by amendment or otherwise,
if it shall become necessary.
IIT.
This defendant avers that for the purpose of deceiving the public
the description and specification filed by the said patentees in the
Patent Office was in some particulars made to contain more
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, V8, MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 1
xxviii than the whole truth relative to their alleged invention or
discovery and more than is hecessary to produce the desired
effect, and that in other particulars the said description and specifica-
tion was made to contain leas than the whole truth relative to their
alleged invention or discovery,
IV.
This defendant says that the said uitentees, Henry Livingstone
Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-icard and John Ballot and
suid plaintiff herein, Minerals Separation, Limited, have admitted
that the alleged invention, which said Letters Patent No. 825,120
purport to embrace, and each and every material and substantial
part thereof was old and known to others prior to their alleged
Invention and discovery thereof, and have stated that said alleged
invention was the invention of others, and that said patentees made
said admissions and statements in the following described Letters
Patent, and in the applications therefor and proceedings in the
United States Patent Office relating thereto, and also in other patents,
documents and writings:
Letters Patent of the United States.
TH.808 Sulman & Kirkpatrick-Picard, a
103, patented July 4, 1905,
Henry L. Sulman, application filed October 20, 1905, pat-
ented November 6, 1906,
pplication filed October 5,
835,143
XXIX
SSOA7M Sulman Kirkpatrick-Pieard & Ballot, application file]
May 20, 1905, patented November 6, 1906,
Suman, Kirkpatrick-Picard & Ballot, application filed
February 20, 1905, patented February 25, 1908,
STO,9S85
Letters Patent of Great Britain,
17.109 Aupust 6, 1903. Cattermole, Sulman & Kirkpatrick-Picard.
20.419 Sertomber 22. 1903. Sulman & Kirkpatrick-Picard.
5.260 March 13, 1905, Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Pickard & Ballot.
19.709 Septeml er 19, 1905, Sulman.
26,712 December 21, 1905, Sulman.
23.870 October 14. 1910, Minerals
23,949 Octol er 15, 1910, Nutte
Limited.
Kirkpatrick-Picard & Ballot.
Separation, Limited, and Nutter.
r, Hoover and Minerals Separation,
Ws
Defendant, further answering, says, that the plaintiff herein is not
entitled to the relief prayed for in its bill of complaint, without this
that there is any other matter, cause or thing in the said bill of
complaint contained, material or necessary, for this defendant to
16 BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, VS. MEN. SEP, LTD., ET AL.
make answer unto, and not hereinbefore sufficiently answered,
xxx confessed or avoided, traversed or denied, is true; all of which
this defendant is ready to aver, maintain and prove as this
Honorable Court shall direct and prays to be hence dismissed with
its costs in this behalf most wrongfully sustained,
BUTTE AND SUPERIOR COPPER
COMPANY, LIMITED,
By A. B. WOLVIN, Director.
SHERIDAN, WILKINSON & SC TT,
KREMER, SANDERS & KREMER,
Nolicitors for Defendant.
THOMAS F. SHERIDAN,
WALTER A. SC TT,
J. BRUCE KREMER,
of Counsel,
Unrrep States oF AMERICA,
District of Montana, County of Silver Bow, ss:
A. B. Wolvin, being first duly sworn on oath, deposes and says:
That he is a director of Butte and Superior Copper Company, Lim-
ited, the defendant named in the foregoing answer , that he has read
the same and knows the contents thereof, and that the same is true
of his own knowledge, exeept as to the matters therein alleged
xxxi on information and belief, and as to those matters he be-
lieves it to be true. He further states that he makes this
verification for and on behalf of said defendant corporation,
A. B. WOLVIN.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 28th day of October, 1915.
[ NOTARIAL SEAL. | f£, F, OO FLYNN,
Notary Public in and for the State of
Montana, Residing at Butte, Montana.
My commission expires May 16th, 1914.
Unirep Srares or AMERICA,
District of Montana, County of Silver Bow, ss:
J. Bruce Kremer, being first duly sworn on oath, depozes and says:
That he is one of the solicitors for defendant in the above entitled
action; that the solicitors of record for the plaintiff are Henry DP
Williams, Esq., of New York City, New York, who has law offices
in the City of New York, New York, and Odell W. MeConnell, Esq.,
of Helena, Montana, who has law offices in Helena, Montana, and
that for said reason it was impossible for affiant, or any solici-
xxxii_ tor for the defendant, personally to serve upon the said so-
licitors for the plaintiff the foregoing answer, and that on the
98th day of October, 1915, affiant personally served upon the said
plaintiff and its solicitors the foregoing answer by depositing a true
a a
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, V8. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL, 17
copy thereof in the Post Office in the City of Butte, Montana, with
sufficient postage prepaid thereon, said copy of said answer then and
there being enclosed in an envelope and addressed to Odell W. Me-
Connell, Esq., Attorney at Law, Helena, Montana.
J, BRUCE KREMER,
Subseribed and sworn to before me this 28th day of October, 1913,
[ NOTARIAL SEAL. | ki. FL O'FLYNN,
Notary Public in and for the State of Montana.
My commission expires May 16, 1914,
Filed; Oct, 28, 1913. Geo, W. Sproule, Clerk, by Harry H. Wal-
ker, Deputy,
And thereafter on March 27, 1917. the supplemental answer of
defendant was filed, being as follows:
Xxxiii_ In the District Court of the United States for the District of
Montana.
In Equity
MINERALS Separation, Limrrep, Plaintiff,
vs.
Burre AND Superior Mintno Company, Formerly Butte and Su-
perior Copper Company, Limited, Defendant.
Supplemental Answer,
Now comes the defendant above-named, and with leave of court
first had and received, files this, its supplemental answer to the bill of
complaint heretofore filed by the plaintiff and complainant above-
named, and alleges:
I,
That heretofore, to-wit: on the 10th day of October, 1913, the
above-named plaintiff filed its bill in this court against the above-
named defendant; that said complainant in effect charged that the
plaintiff and defendant were both corporations and plaintiff was the
owner and entitled to United States Letters Patent No. 835,120,
issued on November 3rd, 1906, being a patent for improvements in
ore concentration; that on the 29th day of May, 1905, Henry Liv-
ingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John
xxxiv Ballot, being within the meaning of the statutes of the
United States then in force, the original, first and joint in-
ventors of a new and useful process of ore concentration, did duly
file in the United States Patent Office an application for Letters Pat-
ent and that Letters Patent of the United States No. 835,120 were
duly issued on said application to said applicants, and that there-
2—Ree. .
DORE 5 SIGS AN 8 OAS AONE Sd : ”
18 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO, Vs. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL.
after the said patent was duly assigned to the above-named plaintiff,
Plaintiff alleges that the invention is of great value and that the
defendant had infringed said Letters Patent and particularly claims
1.2.3.5. 6.7, 9, 10, [1 and 12, of said patent; plaintiff further
alleging that another suit: was filed by the plaintiff herein and an-
other against James M. Hyde and that the above styled court ren-
dered a decree in favor of the above-named plaintiff and its co-plain-
tiff: that the said Hyde confederated with the defendant in the al-
leged infringement of said patent, plaintiff? herein praying for a
permanent injunction and an injunetion pendente lite and that its
patent be declared valid and for an accounting. Reference is
hereby made to the original bill of coimplaint for a more complete
statement of the contents thereof, said bill of complaint being of the
records and files of this court in the above entitled action,
That on or about the 28th day of October, 1915, the defendant
interposed its answer to the bill of complaint wherein, after
xxxv admitting that the plaintiff is a corporation and that the suit
ix brought under the Patent Laws of the United States, the
defendant denies each and all of the allegations of the complaint,
and particularly the allegations with reference to infringement of
said patent, or any of the claims thereof, the validity of each and
every claim contained in said patent, and any confederation with
the said defendant James M. Hyde.
Further answering said bill the defendant set up as additional de-
fense that Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Vitzalis Kirkpatrick-
Picard and John Ballot were not the original, first and true in-
ventors of the alleged invention in ore concentration, which said
Letters Patent No. 835,120 purport to embrace, or any material or
substantial part thereof, because the same was fully and clearly de-
<eribed or claimed in the list of Letters Patent set forth in paragraph
1 of the affirmative defenses of said answer; and the said defendant
set up as a further and additional defense that each and every ma-
terial part of the supposed invention so claimed to have been pat-
ented and invented by Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis
Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot was known to a great number
of persons and was described in applications for Letters Patent of
the United States deposited by persons in the United States Patent
Office prior to the supposed invention and discovery of the alleged
process set forth in said Letters Patent No. 835,120, as set forth
in paragraph 2 of the affirmative defenses contained in de-
xxxvi fendant’s answer, and the said defendant claimed as an af-
firmative defense that for the purpose of deceiving the public
the description and specifications filed by the patentees in the Patent
Office for said patent were in some particulars made to contain more
than the whole truth relative to their alleged invention and discovery
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG. CO, Vs, MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 19
and more than is necessary to produce the desired effect and that in
other particulars the said description and specifications were made
to contain less than the whole truth relative to their alleged inven-
tion or discovery as set up in paragraph 3 of the affirmative defen:es
of the defendant; and the said defendant set forth as a further ad-
ditional defense that the said patentecs aforesaid have admitted that
the alleged invention, which said Letters Patent No, $35,120 purport
to embrace, and each and every material and substantial part thereof,
was old and known to others prior to said alleged invention and that
said admissions were made in the Letters Patent as set forth in para-
graph 4 of the affirmative defenses of the defendant contained in its
answer, Reference is hereby made to the original answer herein
filed by the defendant for a more complete statement of the contents
thereof, which said answer is of the files and records of this court in
the above entitled action.
IV.
That said issues became joined by the filing of said answer; that
from the date of the filing of said answer the case was and
XXXVIi_ still is at issue; that since the filing of said answer the case of
Minerals Separation and another against James M. Hyde
Was, on appeal from the above styled court, considered by the Cireuit
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and the said Circuit Court of
Appeals in May, 1914, reversed and set aside the decree of the above
styled court in favor of the above-named plaintiff and another and
against James M. Hyde, and did declare the said Patent No, 835,120
and all of the claims thereof invalid and of no force or effect; that
thereafter the said case of the above-named plaintiff and another
versus James M. Hyde reached the Supreme Court of the United
States through a writ of certiorari and was thereafter argued before
the said Supreme Court of the United States and a decision therein
rendered by the Supreme Court of the United States by which de-
cision the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals of the Ninth Cir-
cuit was reversed and set aside except that the said Supreme Court of
the United States declared claims 9, 10 and 11 of said patent No,
835,120 invalid and of no force and effect, and that said decision so
declaring said claims invalid was rendered on the 11th day of De-
cember, 1916, and that the said plaintiff was then and there and on
said date duly advised of the decision and order of the said Supreme
Court of the United States upon the patent aforesaid and did know
that the said Supreme Court of the United States had declared each
and all of said claims 9, 10 and 11 invalid and that said plaintiff
has wholly failed and unreasonably neglected and delayed
Xxxvili the filing of a proper or any disclaimer in writing of the
matters set forth in claims 9, 10 and 11 in the Patent Office
of the United States, and has wholly failed to disclaim in writing
its claim to said claims 9, 10 and 11, or to any or either of them:
that by reason of said unreasonable neglect and delay of the said
plaintiff to disclaim in writing each and all claims to claims 9, 10
and 11, the whole of said patent No, 835,120 had become wholly
PEAR IO”
20 BUTTE & SUPR, MNG. CO, VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
void and invalid and of no force or effect, and plaintiff cannot rely
thereon nor maintain an action in equity under said patent, and
that the plaintiff is now barred by reason of said unreasonable delay
and neglect from any relief of any kind or nature in equity, nor can
plaintiff now be given any assistance in a court of equity for any
alleged invasion of its alleged rights under said patent; nor can
plaintiff maintain an action for injunction or accounting and that
it ix estopped from any further proceedings herein by reason of its
unreasonable delay and neglect to file a proper disclaimer of the
claims held invalid by the Supreme Court of the United States, as
aforesaid, and in accordance with the statutes of the United States
of America in such eases made and provided ; that said defense could
not have been set forth in the original answer herein on file for the
reason that the acts and things herein set forth in connection with
eaid disclaimer were all subsequent to the date of the filing of said
answer and subsequent to the T1th day of December, 1916, the date
upon which the Supreme Court of the United States handed down
‘ts decision in the ease of Minerals Separation and another
xxxix versus James M. Hyde; that said plaintiff has wholly failed
up to this time to file any disclaimer whatsoever in the Patent
Office of the United States as required by law.
wa
sy way of further defense herein defendant alleges that the said
plaintiff is estopped from asserting or claiming that its said alleged
patent, or any claim thereof, is infringed by the use of an amount
of oil exceeding five-tenths of one per cent. on the weight of the ore ~
treated at a given time, for the reason that the said plaintiff ina
judicial proceeding has stated that its invention was not practised
by the use of an amount of oil in excess of five-tenths of one per
cent. on the weight of the ore treated and by the further statements
in a judicial proceeding that its invention was not reached until the
amount of oil reached and fell below five-tenths of one per cent. on
the ore treated: that each of said statements was made in a judicial
proceeding in a court having jurisdiction of the subject matter since
the joinder of issue in this case: that by reason of said: statements
the said plaintiff is now precluded and estopped from asserting in
this court of equity that its invention embraces more than that
described and claimed by it as aforesaid. Defendant alleges that
caid acts immediately last complained of did not occur until after
the joinder of issue herein and the defendant did not become ac-
quainted with the said facts until November, 1916,
x] Wherefore, defendant, having fully answered, prays to be
disinissed hence with its costs.
THOMAS F. SHERIDAN,
J. BRUCE KREMER,
W. A. SCOTT,
THOS. H. SHERIDAN,
L.. P. SANDERS,
ALF. C. KREMER,
Solicitors for Defendant.
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO, VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., PT AL. 21
xli Unrrep Srates or AMERICA,
District of Montana, County of Silver Bow, ss:
J. 1. Bruce, being first duly sworn on oath, deposes and says:
That he is an officer, to-wit: the Manager and also the agemt of
the above-named defendant, and makes this verification in said ¢a-
pacity for and on behalf of the above-named defendant: that he has
read the foregoing supplemental answers, knows the contents thereof,
and that the matters and things therein stated are true to the best of
his knowledge, information and belief, J.L. BRUCK,
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 17th day of Mareh, 1917,
| NOTARIAL SEAL. | C,H. TUOHY,
Notary Public for the State of Montana,
Residing at Butte, Montana.
My commission expires July 7th, 1918,
Kiled: March 27,1917. Geo. W, Sproule, Clerk, by H. H. Walker,
Deputy.
xlii And thereafter on April 17th, 1917, the amendment to
answer of defendant was filed, being as follows:
In the Distriet Court of the United States for the District of Montana,
In Equity.
MINERALS Sevanarion, Limirep, Plaintiff.
V8.
Burre & Superior Mining Company, Formerly Butte & Superior
Copper Company, Limited, Defendant.
Amendment to Answer.
Now comes the defendant. Butte & Superior Mining Company,
and amends its answer in the above entitled suit. in the following
manner, to-wit :
By cancelling the paragraph numbered 1 beginning at Line 20,
page 12, and extending to the bottom of page 15, and substituting
for the cancelled passage the following:
I,
(a) That the supposed invention set forth in said Letters Patent,
No, 835,120, had been patented and had been described in printed
publications prior to the supposed invention thereof by said Sulman,
Kirkpatrick-Picard and Ballot, and had been patented and
xliit_ deseribed in printed publications more than two years prior
to their application for a patent therefor: that said su posed
invention was patented and fully described in each of the fol owing
described patents and publications, each of which patents was
22 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
granted and became a patent and each of with patents and publica-
tions was published as a printed publication more than two years
prior to the application by said Sulman, Picard and Ballot for said
patent No, 835,120:
British patent to William Haynes, No, 485, dated February 25,
1860, sealed August 17, 1860.
United States Patents.
No. Date of patent. Patentee.
SAS LOT i Set. Serre rrr errr. C. J. Everson.
575,669 i / > Pn cc cei ek wane sae ps eee G. Robson.
469,599 OE MR eae Aa en nar ens reer ae yet \. M. Roure.
Publications.
The Daily Herald Demoerat, published at Leadville, Colorado,
October 80, 1889,
The Engineering and Mining Journal, published at New York
City, N. Y., November 15, 1890,
(b) That said supposed invention was patented and fully de-
scribed in each of the patents end publications set forth in paragraph
(a) hereof and in the following deseribed patents and publications,
each of which patents was granted and became a patent, and cach
of which patents and publications was published as a printed publi-
cation prior to the supposed invention thereof by said man,
Kirkpatrick-Picard and Ballot.
xliv
No. Date of patent. Patentee.
736,381 Aug. 18, 19038) M. F. R. Glogner.
745,960 Dec. 1, 1908 1, FP. Good.
763,259 June 21, 1904 A. KE. Cattermole.
763,260) June 21, 1904 A. FE. Cattermole.
~
\
\
763,749 June 28, 1904 G. A. Goyder and FE. Laughton.
777.273 «Dee. 18, 1904 A. EK. Cattermole.
768,035 Aug. 23, 1904 G. A. Delprat.
777.274. Dee. 13, 1904 A. E. Cattermole, H. L. Sulman and
H. F. Kirkpatrick-Picard.,
784.999 Mar. 14, 1905) G. A. Goyder and EF. | aughton.
776,145 Nov. 29, 1904 C. V. Potter.
TS7,814 Apr. 18, 1905 J.D. Wolf.
788.247) Apr. 25. 1905 TLL. Sulman. HW. Ff. Kirk; atrick-Pieard
and A. E. Cattermole,
=
British patent to Henry Harris Lake, communicated by Aleide
'roment, No. 12.778, of 1902, applied for June 4, 1902, complete
-pecification left March 4, 1903, accepted June 4, 1903, sealed
August 18, 1903.
Italian patent to Aleide Froment, Regro Genle Vole 43, No.
6°,723. Regro Attes. Vol. 156, No. 166, May 20, 1902.
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG. CO. VS. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL.
x4
~~
Publications,
The California Journal of Technology for November, 1903, pub-
lished at Berkeley, California, by the students in the Applied
xlv Science Colleges in the University of California, which con-
tains upon pages 34 to 41 an ‘article by W. F. Copeland,
Drury Butler and James H. Wise, entitled “Experiments on the
Elmore Process of Oil Concentration.”
(c) That said Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Picard and Ballot were not
the original or first inventors or discoverers of any material or sub-
stantial part of the thing patented in and by said patent No, 835,120,
but that said supposed invention and all material and substantial
parts thereof had before their alleged invention thereof been invented
hy the several persons named and referred to in paragraphs (a) and
(4) hereof, and by them patented and described as therein set forth,
and by others who fully and clearly described every material and
substantial part of said supposed invention in applications filed by
them in the United States Patent Office for United States patents and
in Letters Patent granted by the United States, and that the follow-
ing are the names of said parties, the dates of the patents granted
to them, and the dates of filing of the United States patent applica-
tious in those instances where the patents were granted subsequent
to the date of alleged invention by Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Picard and
Ballot. .
xIvi United States Patents.
No. Date of patent. Datentee,
228,004 May 25, 1880........... J. Tunbridge.
345,591 July 20, 1886.........., H. Bradford.
343,118 Nov. 15, 1887.......... Henry J. Wagner.
444,345 Jan. 6, 1891.......... IK. R. Gabbett.
466,703 Jan. 5, 1802.......... I). A. Hockley.
469,599 Feb. 23, 1892.........., \. M. Rouse.
471,174 Mar. 22, 1892.......... C. B. Hebron and C. J. Everson.
474,829 May 17, 1892.......... (. B. Hebron.
521,889 June 26, 1894........... Joseph Wm. Sutton.
653,340 July 10, 1900.......... KF. KE. Elmore.
667,222 Feb. 5, 1001........... John W. Ivery.
676,679 June 18, 1901.......... I’. KE. Elmore.
689,070 Dee. 17, 1901.........., A. S. Elmore.
692,643 Feb. 4, 1902..........A. 8. Elmore.
703,905 July 1, 1902..........A. 8. Elmore.
729,805 June 2, 1908........... J. & L. Stoveken.
735,071 Aug. 4, 1903.......... G. D. Delprat.
763,259 June 21, 1904.........., A. I. Cattermole.
763,859 June 28, 1904........... J. D. Darling.
768,035 Aug. 23, 1904.......... G. D. Delprat.
170,659 Sept. 20, 1904........... T. B. Scammell.
776,145 Nov. 29, 1904.......... C. V. Potter.
sia tall F ee Ren ee
24 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
xlvil
Date of
No. Date of patent. application. Patentee.
787,814 Apr. 18,1905 May 22, 1905 J. D. Wolf of London,
England.
788,247 Apr. 25,1905 Mar. 29, 1904. A. E. Cattermole, H. L.
Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard) —
all of London, Eng-
land.
793,808 July 4,1905 Oct. 5,1908 H. 1. Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard ; of
London, England.
807,502 Dee, 19,1905 May 27,1904 A. Schwartz of New York,
| ee
807,503 Dee, 19,1905 May 27,1904 A. Sehwarz of New York,
ae 2
807,504 Dee. 19,1905 Sept. 21,1904 A. Schwarz of New York,
N. Y.
807,505 Dee. 19,1905 Oct. 14, 1904 A. Schwarz of New York,
N. Y.
807,506 Dee. 19,1905 Nov. 4,1904 A. Schwarz of New York,
i
809,959 Jan. 16,1906 Dee. 14,1908 Edmund B. Kirby for-
merly of Rossland,
British Columbia, now
of St. Louis, Mo.
838,626 Dec. 18,1906 Dec. 17,1903 Edmund B, Kirby, for-
merly of Rossland,
British Columbia, now
of St. Louis, Mo.
(d) That said H. L. Sulman, H. F. Kirkpatrick-Picard and John
Ballot unjustly obtained said patent No. 835,120 for that which was
in fact invented by others who were using reasonable diligence in
adapting and perfecting the same; that said other parties filed in the
United States Patent Office applications for patents fully describing
the supposed invention set forth in said patent No. 835,120 and ob-
tained patents therefor; the names of said other parties, the
xlviii_ dates when they filed said patent applications, the numbers of
the patents so granted, and the dates when said patents were
granted being as follows:
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 25
Date of
No. late of patent. application. atentee,
787,814 Apr. 18,1905 May 22,1903 J. D. Wolf of London,
England.
788,247) Apr. 25,1905 Mar. 29,1904 A. E. Cattermole, H. L.
Sulman and H. F,
Kirkpatrick-Pieard, ali
of London, England.
793,808 July 4,1905 Oct. 5,1903 H. L. Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard, of
London, England.
807,502 Dee. 19, 1905 May 27,1904 A. Sehwarz, New York,
ee
807,503 Dec, 19,1905 May 27,1904 A. Sehwarz, New York,
Se F
Schwarz, New York,
N. Y.
807,505 Dee. 19,1905 Oct. 14,1904 A, Schwarz, New York,
N. Y.
807,506 Dee, 19,1905 Nov. 4.1904 A. Schwarz, New York,
i: #
809,959 Jan. 18,1906 Dee, 14,1903 Edmund B. Kirby, for-
merly of Rossland,
British Columbia, now
of St, Louis, Mo.
838,626 Dee. 18,1906 Dee. 17,1908 Kdmund B. Kirby, for-
merly of Rossland,
British Columbia, now
of St. Louis, Mo.
Filed: April 17,1917. Geo. W. Sproule, Clerk, by I. H. Walker,
Deputy.
807,504 Dee, 19, 1905 Sept. 21, 1004 A,
xlix And thereafter on April 17th, 1917, the answer of de-
fendant was filed, being as follows, to-wit:
In the District Court of the United States for the District of Montana,
In Equity.
MINERALS Sevaration, Limrrep, Plaintiff,
Vs.
Burre & Suverior Correr Company, Defendant.
Answer.
The Answer of Butte and Superior Copper Company, Limited, De-
fendant, to the Bill of Complaint of Plaintiff, Minerals Separation,
Limited.
The defendant now and at all times saving and reserving unto
itself all and all manner of benefit and advantages of exception which
26 RUTTE & SUPR. MNG, CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
can or may be had or taken to the errors, uncertainties or other im-
perfections contained in the bill of complaint herein, for answer:
“hereto, or to so much or such parts thereof as it is advised it is ma-
terial to make answer unto, says as follows:
l I,
This defendant admits that plaintiff is a corporation duly organ-
ized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of Great Britain
and an inhabitant of Great Britain, and has its principal office in
London, England, admits that the defendant is a corporation duly
organized and existing under the laws of the State of Arizona, and
has # regular established place of business in the City of Butte, Silver
Bow County, State of Montana. Denies that it has committed acts
or any act of infringement at said place, or at any place, or at any
time, or at all, as alleged in plaintiff's bill of complaint, or otherwise.
Admits that this suit is brought under the patent laws of the
United States for the alleged infringement of the United States
Letters Patent No. 835,120, issued November 6th, 1906, for alleged
improvements in ore concentration; but denies that there has been
any infringement thereof by this defendant.
IIT.
Denies that on the 29th day of May, 1905, or at any other time,
Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and
John Ballot were, within the meaning of the statutes of the United
States then in force, the original or first or joint inventors, or that
either of them was, or that any of them were the original or first or
joint inventors of a certain new or useful process of ore concentration,
or were entitled to a patent thereon under the provisions of
li said statutes, or that P toe duly filed in the United States Pat-
ent Office an application for Letters Patent of said alleged
invention; denies that on the 6th day of November, 1906, all of the
requirements of the statutes having been duly complied with, the
said Letters Patent of the United States No. 835,120 were duly issued
on said application to the said Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh -
Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot, or either, or any of
them; admits that a certain alleged patent, being No. 835,120, was
issued to Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-
Picard and John Ballot.
Denies each and every allegation contained in paragraph 3 of
=" bill of complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted or
enied.
IV.
Denies that it has any knowledge or information as to whether on
or about the 7th day of December, 1909, the said Henry Livingstone
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, VS. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL. 27
Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John Ballot duly
oreat all assigned to the plaintiff all right, title and interest in and
to said alleged invention and alleged Letters Patent, or that plaintiff
is now the sole owner of said alleged invention or Letters Patent, or
of all rights of action, or claim, or demand for alleged infringement
thereof since said alleged assignment.
¥
Defendant denies that said alleged invention is of great value or
utility; denies that there was or is any invention in the said
lii alleged patent No, 835,120; denies that it has any knowledge
or information as to whether the plaintiff has been to great
trouble or expense in demonstrating the alleged utility thereof, or
in introducing the same into extensive commercial use in the United
States or elsewhere ; denies that it has any knowledge or information
as to whether the plaintiff has granted numerous licenses for carry-
ing on said alleged process of ore concentration in the United States
or clsewhere; denies that said alleged process has been or is now be-
ing extensively carried on in the United States, or elsewhere: denies
that plaintiff has any patent upon any alleged process, and denies
that plaintiff has the right to grant licenses for the use of suid al-
leged process conditioned on the payment of royalty measured by
the output of said alleged process of ore concentration, or otherwise,
or at all.
Denies each and every allegation contained in paragraph 5 of
plaintiff's bill of complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted
or denied,
VI.
Answering the allegations contained in paragraph 6 of plaintiff's
bill of complaint, this defendant denies that it has infringed or is
infringing the said alleged Letters Patent since the plaintiff aequired
the same or at any other time, or at all, by installing apparatus for
or carrying on the use of said alleged process of ore concentration, or
in any other manner, or at all, at the town of Basin, in the County
of Jefferson, State of Montana, or at the City of Butte, Silver
liii Bow County, State of Montana, or at any other place, or at
all, without the consent or allowance of the plaintiff, or at
all; denies that said alleged process of ore concentration alleged to
have been carried on by this defendant embodied the said alleged
invention as claimed in claims one (1) or two (2), or three (3), or
five (5), or six (6), or seven (7), or nine (9), or ten (10), or eleven
(11), or twelve (12), or any other claim of said alleged Letters
Patent ; denies that the defendant is carrying on any alleged infringe-
ment at the last named place, or at any other place, or at all, as a
continuing or any act or threatens to continue to use said process or
to infringe or threatens to infringe at all; denies that defendant has
ever infringed said alleged patent.
28 HUTTE 4 UPR, MNO. CO, VE. MIN, SEP, LTD, BT AL.
VIL
Answering the allegations contained in mragraph 7 of plaintifls
bill of complaint, defendant mdmite that the plaintifl and another,
on or ehout October Mth, 111, brought eait in thix Court againet
James M, Hyde for alleged infringement of said Letters Patent No,
45.120. but denies that suid suit wae fully contested on ite merits,
but admite that anid suit wae presented at length to this Court on
briefs and arguments of counsel; admite that thie Court, in an
opinion filed July 26th, 114, the Court having juriadiction of the
persons and subject matter in said suit, directed that an interloen-
tory decree be entered adjudging the validity of said Letters Patent
as against James M. Hyde, and infringement thereof lw said James
M. Hyde, as to the particular claim herein charged to be
liv the subject of the alleged infringement by the defendant
herein: but denies that there wae an adjudication of the
validity of said Letters Patent as inet thie defendant, or that
this defendant was in any manner affected by or was in any manner
a party to the said alleged suit above referred to; admits that the
above «tvled Court directed the isuance of an injunction restraining
from alleged further infringement by the enid James M. Hyde and a
reference to a taster for ascertaining profits and damages to be
awarded against the «sid James M. Hyde, and admit« that on the
Lith of Auqust, 1913, a decree wae entered ax directed by the said
Court and that thereafter, a permanent injunction restraining the
vaid James M. Hyde from farther alleged infringement of said
Letters Patent No. 835,120 was imued by the above Court, This
answering defendant states that thereafter, and after the entry of
said decree, James M. Hyde, the defendant in the said action above
referred to, duly and regularly in compliance with the laws govern:
ing such matters and in compliance with the rules of this Court and
all other Courts having jurisdiction over the said action, duly and
regularly perfected an appeal in the ease of the above named plaintiff
and another against the said Janes M, Hyde, and that said a ypeal was
dulyand regularly allowed by a Judge of the Cireuit Court of Appeals,
of the Ninth Cireuit, and that aid action above referred to is now on
appeel and that the suid enuse will shortly be presented to the sid
ireuit Court of Appeals of the Ninth Cireuit for final adjudica-
tion and hearing; and defendant further avers that the said
lv tent in suit by reason of said appeal to the said Cireuit
‘ourt of Appeals has not been within the meaning of the
law adjudicated and that the rights of the said plaintiff above-named
and the said James M. Hyde to the use of the a leged process has not
ot fully determined and designated by the Cireuit Court of Ap-
*.
Pe Purther answering the allegations contained in paragraph 7, this
defendant denies each and every allegation contemed tarele not
hereinbefore specifically admitted or denied.
BUTTE 4 SUPR. MNG. CO. V8. MIN. SEP. LTD., BT AL. 20
Vill.
Answering the allegations contained in paragraph 8 of plaintiff's
bill of complaint, this defendant denies that it confederated with the
said James M. Hyde, of any other person, or at all, in the alleged acts
of infringement, or any act of infringement complained of in the
raid alleged suit against the said James M. Hyde, of at all; denies
that it was an actual defendant therein, or a defendant therein at
all; denies that it conducted the defense of «aid suit and denies that
it paid all the expenses thereof, or any of the expenses thereof, except
a hereinafter st forth; denies that it paid the «id James M. Hye
for his services in a-sisting in the defense of «aid alleged suit, This
defendant avers that the said James M. Hyde paid the expenses of
the defense of the aid suit with the exelusive right in Silver Bow
County, Montana, to the proces owned by the said James M.
Iwi Hivde and covered by United States Patent No. 1,022,085,
that exclusive right being granted to thix defendant herein
for such sum of money ax was or ix necewary to cover the expenses
involved in the defense of the suid suit. Denies that the alleged acts
decreed in the said «wit referred to to be acts of infringement were
carried on under certain Letters Patent isued to the said James M.
Hyde on April 22d, 1912, No. 1,022,085; admits that since the com-
meneoment of the wid suit of the plaintiff and another against James
M. Hyde, the «wid Janes M. Hyde assigned to the defendant herein
all of the right, tithe and interest of the «vid Janes M. Iivde in, te
amd under hie said Letters Patent No, 1,022,085, for, to and in the
County of Silver How and State of Montana; denies that any acts
decree! in the swid suit to be acts of infringement were carried on
by the said defendant or that any act was carried on by the said de-
fendant; admits that the said James M, Hyde carried on operations
in the mill of the defendant and had working with him certain em-
ployees of the defendant but denies that any act in which the defend-
ants employers participated infringed upon the alleged patent of
the plaintiff? herein; denies that the defendant herein has continued
the use of said alleged proces: in the identicau apparatus or any
apperstes ised by the said James M. Hyde, or has continued the use
of wid proces as practiool by the said James M. Hyde at all: denies
that this defendant is a joint tort feasor with the suid James M. Hyde
in the acts alleged to have been decreed to be infrin ts; denies
that this defendant is in privity with the «aid James M. Hyde,
vii or any other person or is hound by the said decree against the
said James M. Hyde, or any other person, or is bound by any
decree at all; denies that this defendant is a tort feasor at all: denies
that this defendant is using the alleged process of the plaintiff above-
named or the said alleged process of the said Hyde. is defendant
avers that the flotation process for the concentration of ore now and
heretofore practised and used by it wax devised and developed by its
employees; that in the devising and developing of said process
neither defendant nor its employees derived any information or
assistance of any kind from the said patent No, 835,120; that de-
fendant does not and never has practised or used the flotation process
30 BUTTE 4 SUPR, MNG, CO, VS. MEN, SEP., LTD, ET AL.
devcril ed in «sid alleged patent of the plaintiffs, nor any Metatin
proce s in the mode deseribed in said patent; that the apparatus de-
eeribed in swid patent as the instrumentality for practising the al-
leged process vet forth in said patent is inoperative, im wractical and
useles:; that ne practical, profitable or commercial result can be ob-
tained from ony operations or apparatus described in said patent.
Further an<wermg the allegations contained in paragraph 8, de-
fondant denies each and every allegation contained in aid paragraph
not hereinlefore specifically admitted or denied.
IX.
Answering the allegations contained in paragraph 9, this defend-
ant admits that prior to the commencement of said suit against
James M. Hyde, the plaintiff made claims to the defendant in
Iviii this uit that it claimed certain rights under said Letter:
Patent No, 885.120, but this defendant denies that the plain-
tiff in fact had any rights under said Letters Patent No, 835,120,
This defendant qdmits that it was advised of the proceedings in the
said suit of Minerals Separation, Limited, and another, against
Jame: M. Hyde: admits that the above styled Court in said action
iaved a permanent injunction in pursuance of said deerce against
the «aid James M. Hyde; admits that the said injunction and deerce
was directed to the said James M. Hyde, his confederates and associ-
ates, but denies that this defendart was at any time or is now a
confederate or associate with the said James M. Hyde, and denies
that it was in anywise, or at all, bound or affected by said decree or
said injunction; admits that a copy of said decree was served upon
this defendant: denies that this defendant has cver infringed the
said Letters Patent or has continued to infringe the said Letters
Patent in defiance of the decree of this Court or of the injunetion
jaued thereon, to its own profit or to the damage of the plaintiff, or
has it at any time, or at all infringed the said Letters Patent; denies
that there was ever a deeree ot chis Court or an injunction of this
Court issued which in any manner affected the above-named defend-
ant in the use of a flotation process, or otherwise, or at all,
Denics cach and every allegation contained in paragraph 9 of
plaintiff's bill of complaint not hereinbefore specifically adiitited or
denied.
lix 4
Denies each and every allegation contained in plaintiff's bill of
complaint not hereinbefore specifically admitted or denied.
Further answering plaintiff's bill of complaint, this defendant
further says: ;,
(a) That the supposed invention set forth in said Letters Patent,
No, 835,120, had been patented and had been described in printed
ere wrior to the a ge invention thereof by said Sulman,
Kirkpatrick-Picard and Ballot, and has been patented and described
in printed publications more than two years prior to their application
BUTTE 4 SUPR, MNG, CO, VS, MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL. 31
for a patent therefor; that said supposed invention was patented and
fully described in each of the following described patents and publi-
cations, each of which patents was granted and became a patent and
each of which patents and publications was published as a printed
publication more than two years prior to the a by said
Sulman, Picard and Ballot for said patent No, 835,120.
British patent to William Haynes, No, 488, dated February 23,
1860, sealed August 17, 1860,
United States Patents.
Na, Date of patent,
SI8S.157 Aue. 24, IS8G... 008... xy oe e ek eaten (. J. Everson.
VEO Jam, 19, WOT... ccc cc ccc ee, G. Robson.
40.500 Pel, 23. 1809 \. M. Routse.
WwWmeeeseeoeseeseeseeseceeseseced
Patentee,
Ix Publications,
The Daily Herald Democrat, published at Leadville, Colorado,
October 30, 1889,
The Engineering and Mining Journal, published at New York
City, N. Y., November 15, 1890,
(6) That said supposed invention was patented and fully de-
seribed in each of the patents and publications set forth in ragraph
(a) hereof and in the following described patents and publications,
each of which patents was granted and became a patent, and each of
which patents and publications was published as a printed publica-
tion prior to the supposed invention thereof by said Sulman, Kirk-
patrick-Picard and Ballot.
No, Date of patent. Patentee,
736,381 Aug. 18, 1908..M. F. R. Glogner.
745.960 Dee, 1, 1908. .1. F. Good.
763,259 June 21, 1904. .A. E. Cattermole.
763,260 June 21, 1904. .A. FE. Cattermole.
763,749 June 28, 1904..G. A. Goyder and FE. Laughton,
768,035 Aug. 23, 1904. .G. D. Delprat.
777,278 Dee. 13, 1904. . A. E. Cattermole.
777,274 Dee. 18, 1904.. A. EB. Cattermole, H. L. Sulman and
H. F. Kirkpatrick-Picard.
784,999 Mar. 14, 1905..G. A, Goyder and FE. Laughton.
776,145 Nov. 29, 1904..C. V. Potter.
787,814 Apr. 18, 1905. .J. D. Wolf.
788,247 Apr. 25, 1905... H. L. Sulman, H. F. Kirkpatrick-Picard
and A. E. Cattermole.
Ixi British patent to Henry Harris Lake, communicated by
Aleide Froment, No. 12,778 of 1902, applied for June 4,
102, complete specification left March 4, 1908, accepted June 4,
1903, sealed August 18, 1903.
Italian patent to Alcide Froment, Regro Genle, Vole. 43, No,
63,723. "rere Attes. Vol, 156, No. 166, May 20, 1902.
, Tor _
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
Publications.
The California Journal of Technology for November, 1905, pub-
lished at Berkeley, California, by the students in the Applied Science
College in the University of California, which contains upon pages
84 to 41 an article by W. F. Copeland, Drury Butler and James H.
Wise, entitled “Experiments on the Elmore Process of Oil Concen-
tration.”
(e) That said Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Picard and Ballot were not
the original or first inventors or discoverers of any material or sub-
stantial part of the thing patented in and by said patent No. 835,120,
but that said supposed invention and all material and substantial
parts thereof had before their alleged invention thereof been invented
by the several persons named and referred to in paragraphs (a) and
(b) hereof, and by them patented and described as therein set forth,
and by others who fully and clearly described every material and
substantial part of said supposed invention in applications filed by
them in the United States Patent Office for United States patents
and in Letters Patent granted by the United States, and that the
following are the names of said parties, the dates of the pat-
Ixii ents granted to them, and the dates of filing of the United
States patent applications in those instances where the patents
were granted subsequent to the date of alleged invention by Sulman,
Kirkpatrick-Picard and Ballot ;
United States Patents.
No. Date of patent. Patentee.
228,004 May 25, 1880......... J. Tunbridge.
345,951 July 20, 1886......-- H. Bradford.
373,113 Nov. 15, 1887........ Henry J. Wagner.
444.345 Jan. 6, 1601....-«5: E. R. Gabbett.
466.753 Jan. 5, 180Z........ E. A. Hockley.
469.599 Feb. 23, 1892........ A. M. Rouse.
471.174 Mar. 22, 1602........ C. B. Hebron and C, J. Everson.
474.829 May 17, 1892........ C. B. Hebron.
521,899 June 26, 1894........ Joseph Wm. Sutton.
653,340 July 10, 1900........ F. E. Elmore.
667.222 Feb. 5, 1901........ John W. Ivery.
676.679 June 18, 1901........ F. E. Elmore.
689,070 Dee. 17, 1901.......- A. S. Elmore.
692.643 Feb. 4, 1902........ i A. S. Elmore.
703,905 July 1, 1902........ A. 8. Elmore.
729.805 June 2, 1903......... J. and L. Stoveken.
735,071 Aug. 4, 1908........ G. D. Delprat.
763.259 June 21, 1904........ A. E. Cattermole.
763,859 June 28, 1904........+ J. D. Darling.
768,035 Aug. 23, 1904........ G. D. Delprat.
770,659 + Sept. 20, 1904........+ J. B. Scammell.
776,145 Nov. 29, 1904........ C. V. Potter.
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO, VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 33
Ixili
Date of
No, Date of patent. application. Patentee.
787,814 Apr. 18,1905 May 22,1903 J. D. Wolf. of London,
England.
788,247 Apr. 25,1905 Mar. 29, 1904 A. E. Cattermole, H. L.
Sulman and H. F,
Kirkpatrick-Picard all
of London, England.
793,808 July 4,1905 Oct. 5.1903 H. L. Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard of
London, England.
807,502 Dee. 19,1905 May 27,1904 A. Schwarz of New York,
8
807,503 Dee. 19,1905 May 27,1904 A. Schwarz of New York,
oe $
807,504 Dec. 19,1905 Sept. 21,1904 A. Schwarz of New York,
| ee
807,505 Dee. 19,1905 Oct. 14, 1904 A. Schwarz of New York.
i «
807,506 Dee. 19,1905 Noy. 4.1904 A. Schwarz of New York,
N.Y
509,959 Jan. 16,1906 Dee. 14,1903 Edmund B. Kirby for-
merly of — Rossland,
British Columbia; now
of St. Louis, Mo.
838,626 Dee. 18,1906 Dee. 17,1903 Edmund. B. Kirby for-
merly of Rossland,
British Columbia; now
of St. Louis, Mo.
(¢/) That said H. L. Sulman, H. F. Kirkpatrick-Picard and John
Ballot unjustly obtained said patent No. 835,120 for that which was
in fact invented by others who were using reasonable diligence in
adapting and perfecting the same; that said other parties filed in
the United States Patent Office applications for patents fully
Ixiv describing the supposed invention set forth in. said patent
No. 835,120 and obtained patents therefor: the names of
said other parties, the dates when they filed said patent applications,
the numbers of the patents so granted and the dates when said patents
were granted being as follows:
EMG ER AT III HPL TET IG IT ARR ITD IRE NO LEAP I, a a
«
34 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
Date of
No. Date of patent. application. Patentee.
787,814 Apr. 18,1905 May 22,1903 J. D. Wolfe of London,
England.
788,247) Apr. 25,1905 Mar. 29, 1904 A. kK. Cattermole, H. L.
Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard all
of London, England.
793.808 July 4,1905 Oct. 5, 1908 H. L. Sulman and H. F.
Kirkpatrick-Picard, of
London, England.
$07,502) Dee. 19,1905 May 27, 1904 A. Schwarz, New York,
807,503 Dec. 19,1905 May 27,1904 A. a. New York,
807,504 Dee. 19,1905 Sept. 21, 1904 A. ‘Wasi New York,
807.505 Dee. 19,1905 Oct. 14,1904 A. ‘a New York,
807.506 Dee. 19,1905 Nov. 4.1904 A. elar, New York,
809.959 Jan. 18,1906 Dee. 14,1908 Edmund B. Kirby, for-
merly of — Rossland,
British Columbia; now
of St. Louis, Mo.
838.626 Dee. 18,1906 Dee. 17,1903 Edmund B. Kirby, for-
merly of Rossland,
British Columbia; now
of St. Louis, Mo.
Ixv rt.
Also that prior to the supposed invention or discovery of the al-
leged process patented in said Letters Patent No. $35,120 by said
Henry Livingstone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and
John Ballot each and every material and substantial part of said
supposed invention or discovery so patented had been invented and
used by and was known to the following named persons, and was
fully described in applications for Letters Patent of the United States
deposited and filed by said persons in the United States Patent Office
prior to the supposed invention or discovery of said alleged process
vet forth in said Letters Patent No, 835,120 by said Sulman, Kirk-
patrick-Picard and Ballot; that said applications were so deposited
and filed in the United States Patent Office and that Letters Patent
of the United States were granted upon said applications as set forth
below :
Moritz F. R. Glogner, a resident of Freiburg. in the Kingdom of
Prussia, German Empire, on January 27, 1903, deposited and filed
in the United States -Patent Office his application for Letters Patent
of the United States, and that Letters Patent No, 736,381 were
granted thereon upon Aug. 18, 1905.
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL, 35
Isracl F, Good, a resident of Allentown, Pennsylvania, on October
1, 1902, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office, his
application for Letters Patent of the United States, and that Letters
Patent No. 745,960 were granted thereon upon December 1,
1905,
Ixvi Guillaume D. Delprat, a resident of Broken Hill. Australia,
on January 2, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States
Patent Office his application for Letters Patent of the United States,
and that Letters Patent No. 768,035 were granted thereon upon Au-
guest 23, 1904,
Cosmo Kendall, a resident of Upper Norwood, Surrey, England,
on July 21, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States Patent
Office his application for Letters Patent of the United States. and
that Letters Patent No. 771,075 were granted thereon upon Septem-
ber 27, 1904.
Charles V. Potter, a resident of Balaclava, Victoria. Australia, on
January 14, 1902, deposited and tiled in the United States Patent
Otlice his application for Letters Patent of the United States, and
that Letters Patent No. 776.145 were granted thereon upon Novem-
ber 29, 1904,
Arthur E. Cattermole, a resident of Highgate, London. England,
on September 28, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States Pat-
ent Office his application for Letters Patent of the United States, and
that Letters Patent No, 777,273 were granted thereon upon Dee. 13,
1904.
Arthur E. Cattermole, Henry LL. Sulman and Hugh F. Kirkpat-
rick-Picard, all residents of London, England. on March 29, 1904,
deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office their applica-
tion for Letters Patent of the United States, and that Letters Patent
No. 777,274 were granted thereon upon December 13, 1904,
Ixvii Arthur E. Cattermole, Henry L. Sulman and Hugh F.
Kirkpatrick-Pieard, all residents of London. England, on
March 29, 1904, deposited and filed in the United States Patent
Office their application for Letters Patent of the United States, and
that Letters Patent No. 788.247 were granted thereon upon April 25,
1905,
Henry L. Sulman and Hugh F. Kirkpatrick-Picard, residents of
London, England, on October 5, 1902 deposited and filed in the
United States Patent Office their application for Letters Patent of
the United States, and that Letters Patent No. 793,808 were granted
thereon upon July 4, 1905.
Alfred Schwarz, a resident of New York City, New York, on April
19, 1905, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office, his
application for Letters Patent. of the United States. and that Letters
Patent No. 807,501 were granted thereon upon December 19, 1905.
Alfred Schwarz, a resident of New York City, New York, on May
27, 1904, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office, his
application for Letters Patent of the United States. and that Letters
Patent No, 807.503 were granted thereon upon December 19, 1903.
Edmund B. Kirby, a resident of Rossland. Canada, on December
14, 1903, deposited and filed in the United States Patent Office his
application for Letters Patent of the United States, and that Letters
Patent No. S095 were granted thereon upon January 16,
1906.
Ixviil Edmund B. Kirby, a resident: or Rossland, Canada, on
December 17, 1908, deposited and jiled in the United States
Patent Office his application for Letters Patent of the United States,
and that Letters Patent No, 838,626, were granted thereon upon De-
cember 18, 1906.
Also patented or described and contained in other Letters Patent, 4
the dates, numbers, and grantees of which this defendant is not now
able to specify, but prays to be allowed hereafter to add by amend-
ment of this answer or otherwise, if it shall become necessary,
Also illustrated and described in printed publications, the names
and dates of which defendant is not able to specify, but prays to be
allowed hereafter to add to this answer by amendment or otherwi-e. 4
if it shall become necessary. I
36 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG, CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
IT.
This defendant avers that for the purpose of deceiving the public
the description and specification filed by the said patentees in the
Patent Office was in some particulars made to contain more than
the whole truth relative to their alleged invention or discovery and
more than is necessary to produce the desired effect, and that in
other particulars the said description and specification was made to
contain less than the whole truth relative to their alleged invention
or discovery.
IV.
This defendant says that the said patentees, Henry Living-
Ixix stone Sulman, Hugh Fitzalis Kirkpatrick-Picard and John
Ballot and said plaintiff herein, Minerals Separation, Limite,
have admitted that the alleged invention which said Letters Patent
No. 835,120 purport to embrace, and each and every material and
substantial part thereof, was old and known to others prior to their
alleged invention and discovery thereof, and have stated that said
alleged invention was the invention of others, and that said patentee:
made said admissions and statements in the following deseribed Let-
ters Patent, and in the applications therefor and proceedings in the
United States Patent Office relating thereto, and also in other patents,
documents and writings.
Letters Patent of the United States.
793.808 Sulman & Kirkpatrick-Picard, application filed October 5,
1903, patented July 4, 1905.
835.143 Henry L. Sulman, application filed October 20, 1905, pat-
ented November 6, 1906.
835,479 Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Picard and Ballot, application filed
May 20, 1905, patented November 6, 1906.
879.985 Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Picard & Ballot, application filed
February 20, 1905, patented February 25, 1908.
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 37
Letters Patent of Great Britain.
17,109 August 6, 1903, Cattermole, Sulman & Kirkpatrick-Picard.
Ixx
20,419 September 22, 1903, Sulman & Kirkpatrick-Picard,
9,260 March 13, 1905, Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Picard & Ballot.
19,709 September 19, 1905, Sulman.
26,712 December 21, 1905, Sulman, Kirkpatrick-Picard & Ballot.
23,870 October 14, 1910, Minerals Separation, Limited, and Nut-
ter.
23,949 October 15, 1910, Nutter, Hoover, and Minerals Separa-
tion, Limited,
V.
Defendant, further answering, says that the plaintiff herein is not
entitled to the relief prayed for in its bill of complaint, without this
that there is any other matter, cause, or thing in the said bill of
complaint contained, material or necessary for this defendant. to
make answer unto, and not hereinbefore sufficiently answered, con-
fessed or avoided, traversed or denied, is true; all of which this de-
fendant is ready to aver, maintain and prove as this Honorable
Court shall direct, and prays to be hence dismised with its costs in
this behalf most wrongfully sustained,
THOMAS F. SHERIDAN,
WALTER A. SCOTT,
J. BRUCE KREMER,
Solicitors for Defendant.
xxi UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
District of Montana, County of Silver Bow, ss:
J. 1. Bruce, being first duly sworn on oath, deposes and says:
That he is an officer of the defendant, Butte and Superior Copper
Company, Limited, to-wit: General Manager thereof, and makes
this verification for and on behalf of defendant; that he has read the
same and knows the contents thereof, and that the same is true of
his own knowledge, except as to the matters therein alleged on in-
formation and belief, and as to those matters he believes it to be true.
J. L. BRUCE.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 16th day of April, 1913.
[ NOTARIAL SEAL. | C. kK. TUOHY,
Notary Public in and for the State of
Montana, Residing at Butte, Montana.
My commission expires July 26th, 1915,
Filed: April 17, 1917. Geo. W. Sproule, Clerk, by H. H. Wal-
ker, Deputy.
oT
Ixxii In the District Court of the United States for the District of
Montana.
38 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL.
MINERALS SerParRatioNs, Limitep; MINnerRALs SEPARATION AMERI-
CAN SyNpICATE, Limerep, and Minerals Separation North Ameri-
can Corporation, Plaintiffs,
Vs,
Burre ANp Superior Minin Company, Formerly Butte & Superior
Copper Company, Limited, Defendant.
Please take notice that on April 30th, 1917, at the opening of the
Court we will move on the record and proceedings herein for leave
to file the Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint, copy of
which is annexed hereto.
April 26, 1917.
Yours, ete.,
| ODELL W. McCONNELL,
HENRY D. WILLIAMS,
Solicitor and of Counsel for Plaintiffs.
Ixxiii. To J. Bruce Kremer, Esq.; Walter A. Scott, Esq. ; Thomas
F, Sheridan, Esq., Attorneys and of Counsel for Defendant.
(Copy received Apr. 26, 1917.)
THOMAS F. SHERIDAN,
Of Solicitor- for Defendant.
And thereafter on May Ist, 1917, the supplemental and amended
Lill of complaint of plaintiffs was filed, being as follows, to-wit:
Ixxiv In the District Court of the United States for the District of
Montana.
In Equity.
MINERALS Separation, Limirep; MINERALS SEPARATION AMERICAN
Syxpreatre, Limrrep, and Minerals Separation North American
Corporation, Plaintiffs,
vs.
Burre AND Superior Mixine Company, Formerly Butte and Su-
perior Copper Company, Limited, Defendant.
Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint.
Now comes the plaintiffs above named, and, with leave of Court
fir-t had and received, file this their Supplemental and Amended
Bill of Complaint and allege by way of Supplement and Amendment:
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG. CO. V8, MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL. 39
1. That heretofore, to-wit, on the 10th day of October, 1913,
Ixxv the plaintiff Minerals Separation, Limited, filed its bill in this
court, alleging the issue and its ownership, of Letters Patent
$39,120 and infringement by the above named defendant, and the
suit of said plaintifY and another against James M, Hyde and par-
ticipation therein by the defendant here and the conduct of the de-
fendant here so as to he estopped thereby, and praying for an in-
junction and accounting of profits and damages, and that said de-
fendant filed an Answer and Amended Answers thereto, Reference
is here made to said Bill and Answers for a more complete statement
of the contents thereof,
2. That the plaintiff, Minerals Separation Ameriean Svndicate,
Limited, is a corporation duly organized and existing under and by
virtue of the laws of Great Britain and having its principal offiee in
London, England, and that the plaintif!, Minerals Separation North
American Corporation, is a corporation duly organized and existing
under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Maryland having its
principal office and place of business in the Continental Building in
the City of Baltimore in the State of Maryland.
8’. That by an instrument in writing dated the tenth day of Octo-
her, 1910, (which, or a duly certified copy thereof, the plaintiffs
will produce as the Court may direct) Minerals Separation, Limited,
plaintiff, granted to Minerals Separation American Syndicate
Limited, plaintiff (together with other things) the sole and exclusive
right, license, power and authority to apply, use and exercise in the
United States of America, the invention and process of said Letters
Patent No. 835,120 for the term of two years, with the privi-
Ixxvi_ lege of extension for a further period of one year; that said
privilege of extension was exercised, and that said exclusive
license expired by affluxion of time on the tenth day of October,
1913; that by an instrument in writing dated the eighth day of July,
1913 (which, or a duly certified copy thereof, the plaintiffs will pro-
duce as the Court may direct, and a copy of which is annexed hereto
as Exhibit A), Minerals Separation Limited, plaintiff, entered into
an agreement of sale and purchase with Minerals Separation Ameri-
can Syndieate (1913) Limited, a corporation duly organized and
existing under and by virtue of the laws of Great Britain, hy which
Minerals Separation, Limited, agreed to sell and Minerals Separation
American Syndicate (1913) Limited agreed to purchase (along with
other things) the entire beneficial interest in the said Letters Patent
$35,120, the purchase to be completed on or before the tenth day of
October, 1913; that by mutual arrangement the completion of the
purchase by the assignment of the said Letters Patent 835.120 (and
others) was deferred pending the litigation against James M, Hyde
and other litigation; that by mutual arrangement the completion of
the payment of the full’ consideration to Minerals Separation,
Limited, plaintiff, was deferred until on or about the sixth day of
October, 1916, and thereupon the entire beneficial interest in ‘said
Letters Patent 835,120 vested in said Minerals Separation American
Syndicate (1913) Limited; that by an instrument in writing dated
the 7th day of December, 1916 (which, or a duly certified copy
thereof the plaintiffs will produce as the Court may direct, and
De RRM RY BENE A RII CENTERS LS PMO BY SEINE NER SE: Ly ARNT A TR NTRS OER Th IES
40 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
Ixxvii a copy of which is annexed hereto as exhibit B) Minerals
Separation American Syndicate (1913) Limited sold, as-
signed and transferred to Minerals Separation North American Cor-
oration, plaintiff, all the right, title and interest in and to said
etters Patent 835,120 to which it then was, or might thereafter be-
come entitled, und all moneys due and to grow due, royalties due
and to grow due, claims and demands and things in action, of Min-
erals Separation American Syndicate (1913) Limited; that ‘by
virtue of the premises the plaintiffs became and now are the sole
owners of said Letters Patent 835,120 and of all claims and demands
and rights of action for profits and damages for infringements of said
Letters Patent from the date of issue thereof.
4. That in the suit of Minerals Separation, Limited, and another
against James M. Hyde, referred to in paragraph 7 of the Bill of
Complaint, the Circuit Court of Appeals of the Ninth Circuit in May,
1914. entered its decree reversing the decree of this Court; that
thereafter on the 13th day of January, 1917, the Supreme Court of
the United States issued its Mandate reversing the decree of the
Cireuit Court of Appeals of the Ninth Circuit and modifying and
affirming the decree of this Court and directing the entry of a decree
holding claims 1, 2. 3,5, 6, 7, and 12 of said Letters Patent 835,120
valid and infringed and claims 9, 10, and 11 invalid, as appears by
said Mandate on file in this Court, a copy of whieh is annexed hereto
as Exhibit C.
5. That on the 28th day of March, 1917, Minerals Separation,
Limited, plaintiff, as the sole assignee of the patentees of said
Ixxviii Letters Patent 835,120 for the whole of the United States
and the territories and possessions thereof, in view of the
aforesaid decision and Mandate of the Supreme Court of the United
States, and under and pursuant to the laws for such case made and
provided, and without unreasonable neglect or delay, entered its
disclaimer or so much of the thing patented by claims 9, 10 and 11
of said Letters Patent 835.120 as it did not choose to hold or claim by
virtue of said Letters Patent, all as appears by said disclaimer a
certified copy of which is ready here in Court to be produced as the
ee direct, and a copy of which is hereto annexed as Ex-
iibit D.
6. That on the 16th day of April, 1917, plaintiffs there waiving
accounting and filing proof of said disclaimer and not asking for
costs, a final decree was entered in said suit of Minerals Separation,
Limited, and another, against James M. Hyde, decreeing the validity
of claims 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 and 12 of said Letters Patent 835,120, and
infringement thereof by defendant, and a perpetual injunction, as
appears by the said decree on file in this court, a certified copy of
which is ready to be produced as the court may direct, and a copy
of which is annexed hereto as exhibit EF.
7. That the processes recited in claims 9, 10 and 11 of said Letters
Patent 835,120 as limited by said disclaimer were new and original
inventions of the patentees thereof, and that said claims 9, 10 and 11
of said Letters Patent, 835,120 as limited by said disclaimer are good
and valid, and that the Butte and Superior Mining Company, de-
fendant, subsequent to the issue of said Letters Patent 835,120 and
BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO. VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL. 41
prior to the filing of the Bill of Complaint herein and with-
out the license and allowance of the plaintiffs or either of
them, employed processes of concentrating powdered ores em-
hodying and containing said invention or inventions in infringe-
ment of said claims 9, 10 and 11 of said Letters Patent 835,120 as
limited by said disclaimer, as well as the invention or inventions of
claims 1, 2, 8, 5, 6, 7 and 12 of said Letters Patent, and continues
v0 to do, and has encouraged and induced others so to infringe.
And plaintiffs allege by way of amendment to and in substitution
of paragraph 8 of the Bill of Complaint :
8. On information and belief, that prior to the beginning of the
acts of infringement complained of in said suit of Minerals Separa-
tion, Limited, and another, against James M. Hyde, the Butte and
Superior Mining Company, defendant here, invited. said James M,.
Hyde to test the applicability of flotation to the ores of the Butte and
Superior Mining Company ; that thereafter Butte and Superior Min-
ing Company investigated through its own attorneys and counsel the
matter of infringement of the patents of Minerals Separation, Lim-
ited, by such application, and thereafter entered into an agreement
with said James M. Hyde whereby Hyde was to give his knowledge
and time to working out such application of flotation to the ores of the
Butte and Superior Mining Company and was to superintend the eree-
tion and operation of a plant to that end and was to be paid expenses
and to have a large additional payment if the enterprise succeeded, and
that it was further agreed between said Butte and Superior Mining
Company and said Hyde that said Butte and Superior Mining
Ixxx Company would defend said Hyde and hold him harmless in
case he should be sued by Minerals Separation, Limited, for
infringement by reason of the ercetion and operation of such plant
for said Butte and Superior Mining Company ; that the acts of said
Hyde complained of in said suit of Minerals Separation, Limited,
and another against James M. Hyde as the acts of infringement there,
consisted in the operation of the plant so erected and operated by
said Hyde for the said Butte and Superior Mining Company ; that
said acts of infringement by Hyde were conducted in the mill of the
said Butte and Superior Mining Company, with apparatus and ingre-
dients belonging to the said Company, upon the ore of said Company,
and for the benefit and advantage of the said company ; that the said
acts of infringement by Hyde were conducted by the employees of
the Butte and Superior Mining Company under the superintendence
of Hyde and that in those operations Hyde was himself an employee
of the said company ; that the Butte and Superior Mining Company
conducted and controlled the defense from the beginning to the end
of said suit of Minerals Separation, Limited. and another, against
James M. Hyde, and paid al! the expenses thereof and paid the said
James M. Hyde for his expenses in assisting in the defense of said
suit; that subsequent to the beginning of the said suit of Minerals
Separation, Limited, and another, against Hyde the latter applied
for and subsequently obtained a patent No. 1,022,085 for certain
features involved in the said operations in the mill of Butte and
Superior Mining Company charged as the act of infringement
Ixxix
42 BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, V8. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL.
Ixaxi there, but said patent was granted and issued for what was
not the invention of said Hyde or any invention over the art
and the application for said patent was an after thought and a sham
and a device to aid in the defense of said suit; that long subsequently
and after the said suit was argued at final hearing in this court the
said Hyde granted to said Butte and Superior Mining Company an
exclusive license under said patent for the County of Silver Bow, State
of Montana, for and in consideration of said company's paying all
the expenses of the defense of said suit and holding Hyde harmless
therein, but said license was without value and said consideration was
paid for nothing and the transaction was an after thought and a sham
and a device to avoid the legal effect of the actual relation of Butte
and Superior Mining Company to the defense of said surt; that the
process introduced by said Iyde into the Butte and Superior Mining
Company's plant was continued in use by the raid company, the de-
fendant here, by and through other employees and under other st
erintendence and in other plants; that to the extent that the said
Lyde was concerned in the said operations deereed in said Iivde suit
to be an infringement of said Letters Patent 835,120 this defendant
was the master and the principal and was a joint tort feasor with said
Hyde; that the defendant here conducted the defense of Hyde in said
suit against Hyde for its own protection here and with the knowl-
edge of the plaintiffs and has had its day in court, in so far as concerns
the issues there raised and determined, and is hound by the said final
decree entered against the said James M. Hyde in said case on April
16th, 1917, to that extent, that is to say, to the extent that the
Ixxxii_ Letters Patent in suit No, 835,120 are valid as to claims 1, 2, 3,
5. 6, 7 and 12, and were infringed by the acts and operations
there complained of.
And plaintiffs allege by way of further Supplement:
9 That the aforesaid final decree entered on April 16th, 1917, in
eaid suit of Minerals Separation, Limited, against James M. Hyde ts
final and determinative against the defendant here as to the issue of
validity of claims 1, 2,3, 5, 6,7 and 12 of said Letters Patent 835,120,
and as to the issue of infringement of said claims by the acts and
operations there complained of.
The plaintiffs therefore pray :
I. For a permanent injunction and an injunction pendente lite
restraining the defendant, its confederates, associates, officers, serv-
ants, agents, clerks and workmen from any installation or use in any
manner of the said patented invention and particularly claims 1, 2,
3.5, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11 and 12 thereof, or any part thereof, in violation
of the rights of the plaintiffs as aforesaid, and from encouraging ane
inducing others to infringe the said Letters Patent, and from de-
fending other infringers of said Letters Patent or reimbursing them
the expense of defending against said Letters Patent, in whole or in
part, or otherwise aiding or abetting others to install or use processes
of ore concentration in infringement of said Letters Patent.
II. For an accounting of profits and damages and that any dam-
ages assessed may be tripled.
BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO. V8. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL. 43
lil. For such other and further relief as the circumstances of the
case may require,
MINERALS SEPARATION, LTD..
By JOHN BALLOT, Chairman.
IXNAiii MINERALS SEPARATION AMERICAN
SYNDICATE, LTD,
By JOHN BALLOT, Chairman.
MINERALS SEPARATION NORTH
AMERICAN CORPORATION,
By JOHN BALLOT, President,
HENRY D. WILLIAMS,
WM. HOUSTON KENYON,
Of Counse 1.
ODELL W. McCONNELL,
Nolicitor and of Counael,
Unrrep Srares of AMERICA,
State of Montana,
County of Silver Bow, ss:
John Ballot, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
That he is Chairman of the Board of Directors of Minerals Separa-
tion, Limited, one of the plaintiffs named in the foregoing Supple-
mental and Amended Bill of Complaint, and that he is Chairman of
Minerals Separation American Syndicate, Limited, another one of the
said plaintiffs, and that he is also President of Minerals Separation
North American Corporation, the third other plaintiff named in the
foregoing Supplemental and Amended Bill of Complaint; that he has
read the same, and knqws the contents thereof, and that the same is
true of his own knowledge, exeept as to the matters therein
Ixxxiv alleged on information and belief, and as to those matters
he believes it to be true.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 26th day of April, 1917.
[| NOTARIAL SEAL. | JOHN G. BAILEY,
A Notary Public in and for the State of
Montana, Residing at Butte, Montana.
My commission expires 12-10-1917,
Exuinrr “A,
Agreement of July 8, 1918, Between Minerals Separation, Limited,
and Minerals Separation American Syndicate (1913), Limited.
An agreement made the eighth day of July, One Thousand Nine
Hundred and Thirteen between Minerals Separation Limited having
its registered office at 62 London Wall in the City of London (here-
inafter called the company) of the one part and Minerals Separation
14 BUTTE & SUPR, MNG, CO, VS. MIN. 8EP., LTD., ET AL.
American Syndicate (1915) Limited having its registered office at
6? London Wall aforesaid (hereinafter called the Syndicate) of the
other part.
Whereas the Syndicate was incorporated on the twenty-
Ixxxy seventh day of June One Thousand Nine Hundred and
thirteen under the Companies (Consolidation) Act 1908
with a nominal capital of Two hundred and fifty thousand pounds
divided into One hundred and twenty-five thousand A shares of One
pound each and ‘Two hundred and fifty thousand B shares of Ten
shillings each ; and whereas by Chiuse 2 of the Articles of Association
of the Syndicate it is provided that the Svndicate shall enter into the
Agreement thereim referred to being this Agreement now it is hereby
agreed as follows:
1. The Company shall sell and the Syndicate shall purchase :
First, The letters patent and rights mentioned in the schedule
hereto but subject to certain licenses granted by the company the
dates of which and the names of the licensees mentioned therein are
as follows:
(A) Twenty-fifth June One thousand nine hundred and twelve,
The Cuba Copper Company.
(1B) Nineteenth November, One thousand nine hundred and
twelve. Britannia Mining and Smelting Company, Limited, as mod-
ified by letter dated seventeenth December One thousand nine hun-
dred and twelve from the Company to the said Britannia Mining and
Smelting Company Limited.
(C) Sixteenth January One thousand nine hundred and thirteen
the Silverton Mines Limited and Robert Insinger.
(D) Twenty-seventh February One thousand nine hundred and
thirteen the Ducktown Sulphur & Copper and Tron Company Lim-
ited.
|XXXVI (E) Tenth April One thousand nine hundred and thir-
teen The Inspiration Consolidated Copper Company.
(F) Seventh May One thousand nine tee and thirteen The
Elm Orlu Mining Company.
(44) Seventh May One thousand nine hundred and thirteen The
Colusa Parrot Mining and Smelting Company.
(IL) Thirteenth May One thousand nine hundred and thirteen
Witliam B. MeDonald and Louis 8. Nobel.
Secondly. The benefit and rights of the Company of and under
the said licenses and of any other licenses that may be granted prior
to the completion of the purchase and Thirdly :—the exclusive right
<o far as the company can confer the same to apply for and obtain
in the Republic of Cuba and the Philippine Islands patents in con-
nection with any of the inventions comprised in the letters patent
and applications mentioned in the schedule hereto and generally in
connection with processes and apparatus for separating different pul-
verulent materials by oil selection gaseous flotation or other surface
tension phenomena.
2 Part of the consideration for the said sale shall be the sum of
Ninety three thousand seven hundred and fifty pounds which shall
be paid and satisfied by the allotment to the company or its nominee
BUTTE & SUPR, MNO. CO, VS. MIN, SEP., LTD., ET AL. 45
or Hominees of One hundred and eighty seven thousand five hundred
fully paid B shares of Ten shillings each in the Capital of the Syn-
dicate.
As the residue of the consideration for the said sale the Syndi-
cate shall indemnify the Company against all liability and obliga-
tions of the Company under or in respect of any of the li-
IXAXVii censes granted by them and particulars of which are set
out in Clause 1 hereof and shall also indewnify the Com-
pany against all liability and obligations of the Company under or
in respect of all costs and charges already or hereafter to be ineurred
by the Company in connection with applying for and taking out
patents in the said Republic of Cuba and the Syndicate shall further
indemnify the Company against the liabilities of the Company under
a letter dated second day of March One thousand nine hundred and
ten from the company to one James M. Hyde and against all sums
whieh the Company may have been ordered and may be ordered to
pay to the said James M. Hyde in connection with certain litigation
pending between the company and the said James M. Hyde in the
United States of America and against the costs, charges and expenses
of the Company in coniection with the said litigation and the Syndi-
cate shall at once repay to the Company all disbursements already
made by the Company on account thereof or in connection therewith,
The Syndicate shall be entitled to receive all damages and any other
profits or benefits which may be derived from or in connection with
the said litigation.
The purchase shall be completed on or before the tenth day of
October One thousand nine hundred and thirteen at the registered
office of the Syndieate when One hundred and thirty seven thousand
liv: hundred fully paid B shares of Ten shillings each in the Capital
of the Svndieate part of the said One hundred and eighty seven thou-
sand five hundred fully paid B shares shali be allotted the Company
or its nominees and the Company and all other necessary
IXxxviii parties if any shall at the expense of the Syndicate, execute
and do all assurances and things for vesting in the Syndi-
cate or as it shall direct the premises mentioned in the schedule hereto
and giving to the Syndicate the full benefit ef (his Agreement as shall
be reasonably required. As to fifty thousand fully paid B shares of
Ten shillings each in the Capital of the Syndicate the balance of the
said One hundred and eighty seven thousand five hundred B shares
the same shai! be allotted to the Company or its nominees at the rate
of Two shares for every one “A” share of one pound each in the
initial capital of the Syndicate part of the last twenty five thousand
A shares in such capital which shall be hereafter allotted that is to
sav when one of such “A” shares shall be allotted there shall be al-
lotted to the company or its nominees Two of such fully paid “B”
shares. No new shares in the Capital of the Syndicate shall be cre-
ated or issues until the whole of the shares in the initial capital of
the Syndicate shall have been allotted,
5. The Company shall with all convenient speed and at cost price
communicate to the Syndicate or its assigns all improvements, addi-
tions and new discoveries which it shall make or acquire or be inter-
es diet oe IIS #08 PTE ee eee ee
ie iat
46 BUTTE & SUPR. MNG. CO, VS. MIN. SEP., LTD., ET AL.
ested in either alone or jointly with others in con
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.