Petition for Writ of Certiorari — James City County v. Environmental Protection Agency

Supreme Court brief1994

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Supreme Court, U.S

¢) FILs oD

932045 JUN 22 19%

NQBNCE ME THE CLERK

IN THE

SUPREME COURT of the UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1993

JAMES CrTy COUNTY, VIRGINIA,

Petitioner,

U. S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AND

U. S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS,

Respondents.

Petition for Writ of Certiorari

to the United States Court of Appeals

for the Fourth Circuit .

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

WILLIAM B. ELLIS FRANK M. MORTON, III

Counsel of Record County Attorney

McSweeney, Burtch & Crump James City County

Post Office Box 1463 101 Mounts Bay Road

11 South Twelfth Street Post Office Box JC

Richmonc, Va. 23212 Williamsburg, Va. 23187

(804) 783-6805 (804) 235-6612

Attomeys for Petitioner James City County, Virginia

SY

> \

'y

)

QUESTIONS PRESENTED

1. Whether the Environmentai Protection Agency. having

long interpreted § 404(c) of the Clean Water Act require

consideration of whether a "practicable" alternative to a project

is or is not available, may ban construction of a public water

supply reservoir without ever considering a final judicial

determination that no "practicable" alternative exists?

2. Whether the Environmental Protection Agency’s finding

that placing fill for the Ware Creek Reservoir would cause

“unacceptable” effects is entitled to undiminished deference

notwithstanding that: (a) the Agency’s original finding was

judicially invalidated as wholly without record support, (b) the

Agency quickly reached the same result on remand without any

important change in the administrative record, and (c) the

Agency’s finding is contradicted by those of other federal and

State agencies sharing simiiar authority under the same statute

to ban Reservoir construction for the same reasons?

TABLE OF CONTENTS

QUESTIONS PRESENIED 2355 66 (3 0%.5 ns

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES. .....65..62 0.68 655055

PRE QR 650856 SSRIS. PDR I

FUT 6 ives Row and CA CARRE

A. Water Supply Planning ........... eet aia

B. Initial Regulatory Proceedings ............

1. The Corps of Engineers ........06.05

2. Virginia’s State Water Control Board ....

D. Regulatory Proceedings on Remand ........

Se Mie hos vac dnvedensankese la

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT ......... 17

I. beta eye songs non etn

Permits EPA to Ignore an Applicant’s Needs

and the Lack of Any Practicable Alternative

Means of Meeting Them, and to Focus Entirely

Oth WOOT PUTTY on ccc ccc ccc ccc cccccccene 17

A. This Is an Important Federal Question ...... 17

B. The Decision Below Conflicts with Prior

Decisions of this Court...............-- 22

1. The Decision Below Failed to Require

EPA to Adhere to Its Long-Standing

pe ee eT eh Pee 22

2. The Decision Below Failed to Require

EPA to Articulate an Adequate Rationale

EES EO are 23

3. The Decision Below Failed to Defer to

EPA’s Long-Standing Policy ........... 24

4. The Decision Below Improperly Granted

Discretion to Ignore Relevant Factors . . . . 25

C. The Decision Below Conflicts with a

Decision of the Court of Appeals for

the Second Circuit .........cccceseceees 26

II. This Court Should Decide Whether Courts

Must Defer to Agency Findings Despite

Obvious Reasons to Doubt Their Analyses ...... 28

a

er : iss 4 * : wow ae,

CONCLUSION oceeerebidecesice Ueebae Shee BU wen 30

ASPERGER, 3.05 bred bill on Sl te

pb bee ewmbae A-1

: ras

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Cases

Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. Wichita

Bd. of Trade, 412 U.S. 800 SU Ba ob i's 5 Si ose 23

Barnard v. Carey, 60 F.Supp. 539 (N.D. Ohio 1945) ..... 29

Bersani v. Environmental Protection Agency, 674

F.Supp. 405 (N.D.N.Y. BPS. 08S A 3 18, 25, 27

Bersani v. Robichaud, 850 F.2d 36 (2d Cir. 1988),

cert. denied 489 U.S. 1089 CSP). 6 9s 5, 25, 27, 29

Burlington Truck Lines, Inc. v. United States,

$7) UB. SOR OO ik estat, wes oy ok Oo 23

Camp v. Pitts, 411 U.S. 138 NUE bdiiccia v oes « « au ot) where 21

Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense

Council, Inc., 467 U.S. 837 as ono oa ba vs 24

Friends of the Earth v. Hintz, 800 F.2d 822 (9th

, 3, EPS oe naa eee 4

General Electric Co. v. Gilbert, 429 U.S. 125 rae 29

James City County v. Environmental Protection

Agency, 758 F. Supp. 348 (E.D. Va. eo ae 12, 29

James City County v. Environmental Protection

Agency, 955 F.2d 254 (4th Cir. 1992) .......... 14, 29

James City County v. Environmental Protection

Agency, 23 Envtl. L. Rep. 20,228 (E.D. Va. 1992) . 15-16

James City County v. Environmental Protection

Agency, 12 F.3d (4th Cir. 1993) ...... 16, 17, 20, 24-26

Louisiana Wildlife Fed’n, Inc. v. York, 761 F.2d

1044 (Sth Cir. 1985S)... ie eo ie eee eis 4

Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n v. State Farm Mut. Auto.

Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29 (1983) .............. 21, 23, 25

Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. v.

Securities & Exch. Comm’n, 606 F.2d

SORE Sais Gale BPFED oa eb ecka idee ee ccececeass 30

Newport Galleria Group v. Deland, 618 F. Supp.

BEEP CE SOUR 6 0 6o a PEERS Rae ssw 25, 28

Secretary of Agric. v. United States, 347 U.S. 645

CAPONE heme dean died Cade wae hee aan e eo 23

Securities and Exch. Comm’n v. Chenery Corp.,

53 US. 296 OG nase cS eae 65S PRAM 24

Statutes

Me a BI i 6k hh EEA i 3

Oe Naa BEM 4h bo odd ovat hudson 3

PALS OA Ss AS A A ee 3

Clean Water Act

Section 401(a), 33 U.S.C. § 1341(a) .......... ...4,9

Section 404(a), 33 U.S.C. § 1344(a) .............. 3

vi

Section 404(b)(1), 33 U.S.C. § 1344(b)(1) ..... 3, 4, 19

Section 404(c), 33 U.S.C. § 1344(c) . 4, 12, 14, 18, 24, 26

National Environmental Policy Act

Section 102, 42 U.S.C. § 4332 .........-5--0eeee 6

Regulatory Materials

Council on Environmental Quality

Forty Most Asked Questions Concerning CEQ’s

NEPA Regulations ..........-++00+eeee00: 6

Environmental Protection Agency, § 404(c) Regulations

Preamble, 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076 (1979) ..... 4, 5, 18, 22

GO Cie WUNO MEMO) cc ccc ccccccccccccces 5, 26

TE ER ieb0 ne tivedocncehedesske 4

Publications and Other Materials

B. Schwartz, Administrative Law § 10.35 (2d ed. 1984) ... 29

*

:

-

.

“~

*s

7

*

,

-

A p

: or

‘ie i he % a fe

. i - S PE nh FN wi Sp ES ane 3 .

ee ee abe ——~* — <a Ga ot nae ee het a ee Be Ae ie ge ee he yn te ee ee ee i

ee Se. de NS Gee oe ae Se ee Oe ee es Se * ae ee | ~ « f ¥

t “y .

IN THE

SUPREME COURT of the UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1993

JAMES CiTy COUNTY, VIRGINIA,

Petitioner,

Vv.

U. S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AND

U. S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS,

Respondents.

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

James City County, Virginia petitions for a writ of certiorari

to review the second judgment of the United States Court of

Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in this case. That decision

reversed the United States District Court for the Eastern

District of Virginia and effectively reinstated the Environmental

Protection Agency’s prohibition of placing fill for construction

of the Ware Creek Reservoir, a municipal reservoir needed as

the principal source of drinking water for the citizens of James

City and New Kent Counties, Virginia.

PRIOR OPINIONS

Decisions of the United States Army Corps of Engineers to

grant a permit to place fill for the Ware Creek Reservoir. dated

July 11, 1988, are in Appendices A and B.

The decision of Virginia’s State Water Control Board

certifying that the Reservoir will comply with all applicable

environmental laws and regulations, dated December 22, 1988,

is in Appendix C.

The original "Final Determination" of the Environmental

Protection Agency ("EPA") to prohibit placement of fill for the

Reservoir, dated July 10, 1989, is in Appendix D.

The decision of the United States District Court for the

Eastern District of Virginia invalidating EPA’s original

prohibition, dated November 6, 1990, is in Appendix E. This

opinion is reported at 758 F. Supp. 348 (E.D. Va. 1990).

The decision of the Fourth Circuit affirming the District

Court but remanding to EPA, dated January 29, 1992, is in

Appendix F. It is reported at 955 F.2d 254 (4th Cir. 1992).

EPA’s "Final Determination On Remand,” which prohibited

the placement of fill for the Reservoir a second time, is dated

March 27, 1992, and is in Appendix G.

The second decision of the District Court invalidating EPA’s

action on remand, dated August 4, 1992, is in Appendix H. It

is reported at 23 Envtl. 1. Rep. 20,228 (E.D. Va. 1992).

The decision of the Fourth Circuit reversing the District

Court, dated December 30, 1993, is in Appendix I. This

opinion is reported at 12 F.3d 1330 (4th Cir. 1993).

The order of the Fourth Circuit denying the Petition of

James City County for Rehearing and Suggestion for Rehearing

In Banc, dated March 25, 1994, is in Appendix J.

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the Fourth Circuit was cutered December

30, 1993. The County’s Petition for Rehearing and Suggestion

for Rehearing In Banc was denied on March 25, 1994. The

2

Court’s jurisdiction is invoked pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1254.

STATUTES AND REGULATIONS INVOLVED

Sections 301(a), 401(a)(1), and 404(a)-(d) of th= Clean

Water Act, also known as the Federal Water Pollution Control

Act, 33 U.S.C. §§ 1311(a), 1341(a)(1) and 1344(a)-(d), are

reproduced in Appendix K.

Regulations promulgated by EPA governing the prohibition

of discharges pursuant to § 404(c) of the Clean Water Act are

published at 40 C.F.R. § 231 (1993), 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076

(1979).

Guidelines promulgated by EPA in conjunction with the

Corps of Engineers pursuant to § 404(b)(1) of the Clean Water

Act governing the issuance of permits for the discharge of

dredged or fill material are published at 40 C.F.R. § 230 (1993),

45 Fed. Reg. 85,336 (1980).

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

This case concerns the second attempt by EPA to override

decisions of the Corps of Engineers and Virginia’s State Water

Control Board ("SWCB") to permit James City County, Virginia

to place fill in constructing the Ware Creek Reservoir. EPA’s

original prohibition was set aside by the District Court,

exercising jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 2201. The

Fourth Circuit affirmed that result. On remand, EPA again

banned the placement of fill. The District Court invalidated

this second prohibition, too. But on December 30, 1993, the

Fourth Circuit reversed and effectively reinstated EPA’s

prohibition. James City County seeks review of that decision.

The Regulatory Program

The Corps is authorized by § 404(a) of the Clean Water Act

(App. K-2) to issue permits for the discharge of fill to waters of

the United States. However, it may only issue a permit if the

state agency responsible for water quality certifies or waives

certification under § 401 (App. K-1) that all applicable laws and

regulations governing water quality will be satisfied. Under

§ 404(c) (App. K-3) EPA may prohibit discharges of particular

materials to specified areas if “the discharge of such materials

into such area will have an unacceptable adverse effect on

municipal water supplies, shellfish beds and fishery areas . . .,

wildlife, or recreational areas."

EPA adopted regulations implementing § 404(c) in 1979.

They require that "[i]n evaluating the unacceptability of such

impacts, consideration should be given to the relevant portions

of the section 404(b)(1) guidelines (40 C.F.R. Part 230)." 40

C.F.R. § 231.2(e), 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076, 58,083 (1979). The

preamble to these regulations provides that the “relevant

portions" of the guidelines include evaluation of whether a

"practicable," less-damaging alternative project is or is not

available to the permit applicant:

[T]hose portions of the guidelines relating to alternative

sites may be considered in evaluating the unacceptability

of the environmental impact. For example, the

Administrator can take into account the fact that the

alternative sites or methods are or are not available, so

that the loss of resources is avoidable or unavoidable.'

44 Fed. Reg. 58,076, 58,078 (1979). To be “available,” an

alternative must be “available to the permit applicant." Final

Determination of the Assistant Administrator for External Affairs

Concerning the Sweedens Swamp Site in Attleboro, Massachusetts

Pursuant to Section 404(c) of the Clean Water Act (May 13, 1986) at

20; Friends of the Earth v. Hintz, 800 F.2d 822, 833-34 (9th Cir. 1986);

Louisiana Wildlife Fed’n, Inc. v. York, 761 F.2d 1044, 1048 (Sth Cir.

1985) (the analysis of alternatives pursuant to the § 404(b)(1)

guidelines must take into account the objectives of the permit

applicant).

SEM Pc TERT

Whether a less-damaging, practicable alternative is available is

to be determined as of the tine the permit applicant “enters the

market" for his proposed activity. Bersani v. Robichaud, 850

F.2d 36, 44 (2d Cir. 1988), cert. denied 489 U.S. 1089 (1989). -

When no such alternative is available, EPA may still ban the

discharge but it must make a greater showing of harm to bear

its burden of proving that the effects are “unacceptable.”

"{W]hen there is no alternative available, and ‘vetoing’ the site

means stopping the project entirely, the loss of the 404(c)

resources may still be so great as to be ‘unacceptable.”* EPA

regulations further provide that “the Administrator will take

into account all information available to him... ." 40 C.F.R.

§ 231.1(a), 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076, 58,083 (1979).

Background

A. Water Supply Planning

James City County is located in Virginia’s low-lying coastal

plain on a peninsula between two tidal, brackish water bodies:

the James River and the York River. It is between two of the

largest metropolitan areas in Virginia, Hampton Roads to the

east and Richmond to the west. The County contains the

originai Jamestown settlement and is adjacent to Williamsburg,

both centers of historic interest and popular tourist areas.

Because of the many attractions of this area, James City

County is the second fastest-growing county in Virginia. It also

is host to growing numbers of tourists each summer. The

7 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076, 58,078 (1979) (emphasis added). "It is

important to recognize that there are circumstances where the impacts

of the project are so significant that even if alternatives are not

available, the discharge may not be permitted. . . .". Memorandum of

Agreement Between the Environmental Protection Agency and the

Department of the Army Concerning the Determination of Mitigation

Under the Clean Water Act Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines (Feb. 6,

1990) at 3 n. 5 (emphasis added).

5

increasing population of residents and tourists, and the limited

freshwater resources of the region present significant problems

for provision of public water supply and fire protection.

In 1979, consultants advised the County that it faced severe

water shortages unless a new, reliable source could be found.

The County and its consultants performed numerous water

supply studies and reviewed others by federal, state, and private

entities. They concluded that construction of a reservoir on

Ware Creek in cooperation with neighboring New Kent County

was the only practicable solution. The Ware Creek Reservoir

would meet the needs of James City and New Kent Counties

through 2030, and its yield could be enhanced to meet the

needs of a larger region by adding facilities to pump water from

nearby streams into the Reservoir during times of high flows.

B. Initial Regulatory Proceedings

1. The Corps of Engineers

After several years of study and coordination with the Corps

and neighboring jurisdictions, the County in 1984 applied to the

Corps’ Norfolk District for a permit to place fill for dam

construction. As required by §102 of the National

Environmental Policy Act ("NEPA"), 42 U.S.C. § 4332, the

Corps examined all potential means of meeting that need. That

included larger, "regional" water supply projects that could not

be implemented by the County alone.? EPA was designated a

> NEPA requires consideration of all reasonable alternatives

to a project regardless of whether they can be implemented by the

permit applicant. Forty Most Asked Questions Concerning CEQ’s

NEPA Regulations, 46 Fed. Reg. 18,026, 18,027 (1981). The Corps did

so in this case:

Every regional alternative discussed, and im fact, every

regional alternative ever identified, was addressed and found

to be engineeringly or economically infeasible,

6

“cooperating agency" in preparing the Final Environmental

Impact Statement ("Final EIS"), which considered every

alternative suggested and analyzed their environmental effects.

On July 11, 1988, the Corps found that the County’s need

for an expanded and more-reliable water supply was

“overpowering” and that constructing the Ware Creek Reservoir

was the only "practicable" means of meeting that need. Record

of Decision (July 11, 1988), App. A-3. The Corps based its

findings on some sixteen water supply studies, including the

Final EIS and other comprehensive assessments of potential

regional water supply solutions. See e.g., Corps, Water Supply

Study: Hampton Roads, Virginia (1984), AR A-52; SWCB,

James Water Supply Plan (March 1988), AR A-25. But of the

29 "regional" projects the Corps investigated, EPA opposed 28

and the last proved impracticable.‘ The Corps’ District

Engineer concluded:

I find that the consequences of not developing a reliable

water supply ... are too dangerous and damaging to

contemplate as an alternative. Given the seven years

which this project has taken to get this far, I am not at

all convinced that James City County could develop

another source of water in time to forestall the

potentially disastrous system failure which the Peninsula

could realistically face by the end of [1999] if this

project were not allowed. Though there has been much

environmentally more damaging, or contrary to the specific

policies of affected State regulatory agencies.

Letter from District Engineer Col. J. J. Thomas to EPA Regional

Administrator James M. Seif (Aug. 29, 1988), Administrative Record

("AR") C-25.

* Record of Decision, App. A-(5); Corps, Analysis of the

Proposed Discharge With Respect to Section 404(b)(1) of the Clean

Water Act (July 11, 1988) ("404(b)(1) Analysis"), App. B- (3-4).

7

hi.

study and more talk devoted to regional solutions over

the past several years, the fact remains that such an

alternative does not currently exist and does not appear

to be even likely in the future.

Record of Decision, App. A-3.

The Corps also considered the environmental effects of the

Reservoir and assisted the County in preparing a Mitigation

Plan to offset them. The Corps determined:

[T]he gross adverse environmental impacts of the

project are substantial, but mitigated to the extent that

they are acceptable.... There is no evidence, and

there are no substantiated statements, to indicate that

this project would cause any adverse cumulative impact

on the Chesapeake Bay. I find that the project would

have a very beneficial impact on municipal water

supplies, a very beneficial impact on both lake and

anadromous fish habitat, a positive impact on

recreational opportunities, and no significant or long

term impact on shellfish beds. The project would have

a mixed impact on wildlife associated with aquatic

ecosystems (three out of seven evaluation species

benefitting from the project).

404(b)(1) Analysis, App. B-11. The Corps specifically found the

Mitigation Plan was most likely to replace 230 acres of the 381

acres of vegetated wetlands potentially affected by the project.

Record of Decision, App. A-10.

The Corps evaluated the effects remaining after mitigation

in light of the lack of any practicable alternative -- local or

"regional." It concluded the Reservoir’s effects were adequately

mitigated and acceptable. 404(b)(1) Analysis, App. B-11. The

Corps therefore proposed to permit the placement of fill for

Reservoir construction.

2. Virginia’s State Water Control Board

The SWCB also considered the effects of the proposed

Reservoir as required by § 401(a) of the Clean Water Act.

App. K-1. Like the Corps, the SWCB evaluated the Reservoir’s

effects in light of the County’s need for water and the absence

of any practicable alternative. On December 22, 1988, it

certified that the Ware Creek Reservoir complied with all

applicable environmental laws, standards and policies. App. C-

1.

3. EPA

EPA chose also to assess the effects of placing fill for the

Reservoir under § 404(c) of the Clean Water Act. App. K-3.

On July 10, 1989, EPA issued its Final Determination

prohibiting the placement of fill for construction of the Ware

Creek Reservoir. EPA said that the “acceptability” of the

project’s effects should be judged in light of whether less-

damaging alternatives are available. But unlike the Corps and

the SWCB, EPA claimed alternatives were practicable, citing

several smaller projects. Final Determination, App. D-73-88.

EPA agreed with the Corps that no larger, "regional" project

was available:

Clearly, the Corps applied regional considerations in its

evaluation of the availability of practicable alternatives

to the Ware Creek proposal as a local water supply

project and factored in its concern that a reservoir on

Ware Creek is a necessary component of a regional

water supply. However, as noted by the Corps and

James City County, within the current institutional

framework, the County does not have the authority to

effect a regional water supply plan. Nor have

institutional arrangements with the state and

neighboring local jurisdictions been made to even

propose such a plan.

‘. App. D-92. Relying on the claim that several smaller

alternatives were practicable, EPA said the adverse effects of

the Ware Creek Reservoir were “unnecessary” and therefore

"unacceptable." App. D-7.

In further contrast to the Corps and the SWCB, EPA did

not consider that the Mitigation Plan might reduce the effects

of the project to an “acceptable” level. Instead, EPA asked

whether the Mitigation Plan would achieve "no net loss” of

wetlands (rather than no “unacceptable adverse effect"). EPA

found the Mitigation Plan "inadequate" because it would not

entirely offset all impacts to wetlands:

The proposed acreage is insufficient to replace the

extent of wetlands that would be lost. [App. D-64.]

= * a

[While the County’s proposed wetland creation efforts

are generally feasible, there is no information suggesting

that the wetland creation effort would produce the

existing cover-types or produce them in their current

proportions or, therefore, that the created wetlands

would exhibit the current range of habitat values. [App.

D-65-66, emphasis added. ]

EPA also did not consider whether the Mitigation Plan

might reduce effects below the “unacceptable” threshold because

it claimed “practicable alternatives" were available:

[I]t would be inappropriate to approve the proposed

project based upon the offered mitigation given EPA’s

finding that there are practicable, less environmentally

damaging alternatives. ... [App. D-61.]

° as *

* App. D-59-60. As EPA’s counsel later admitted, "The

agency’s policy [concerning mitigation], if anything, is no net loss.”

Transcript (July 28, 1992), Court Record ("CR") 72 at 46.

10

[A]ctions to minimize the environmental effects of

permit proposals should follow the sequence: avoid,

minimize and restore, in decreasing order of

preference. . . . EPA believes there are practicable, less

environmentally damaging alternatives to satisfy the

Projected water supply needs of James City County.

Therefore . . . EPA believes the mitigation plan to be

EPA’s Final Determination thus treated the Mitigation Plan as

a commendable -- but ultimately irrelevant — gesture. App. D-

72.

Cc.

JCCI

The County challenged EPA’s action in the District Court

for the

Eastern District of Virginia. There, EPA argued:

EPA has reasonably determined that the “acceptability”

of adverse effects on the environment can best be

evaluated in light of all relevant factors, including

concerns such as the availability of alternatives. ...

Since Congress, in enacting section 404(c), tried to

strike a balance between environmental protection and

economic growth, see, e.g., 1 A Legislative History of

the Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972

(1973) . . . at 816-17, this interpretation of the statute

furthers the legislative intent. Moreover, since this

interpretation of the statute has been EPA policy since

1979, . . . it is entitled to even greater deference than

might be accorded to other kinds of agency

interpretations. ®

6

Summa

Reply Memorandum in Support of Defendants’ Motion for

ty Judgment (Sept. 14, 1990), CR 37 at 2-3.

1]

When asked what role the community’s need for water should

play in that assessment, EPA’s counsel said it would be a very

important factor if no practicable alternative was found:

EPA considers that to be a critical consideration.

[Municipal water supply] is one of the considerations

specified in 404(c) so it is certainly a factor. And EPA

would -- if EPA found there were no alternatives

available at all, in other words, that to veto the project

here meant James City County would not have enough

water, that would be a very difficult decision for EPA to

make.

. e * \

But we don’t have that case here before us. ... EPA is

certainly authorized to say the environmental

consequences are so [adverse] that we are going to veto

this project even though you won’t have enough water.

EPA is authorized to say [that]. But they are also

required to consider the water supply.

Transcript (Sept. 21, 1990), CR 38 at 49-50.

On November 6, 1990, the District Court held that EPA

failed to bear its burden of establishing that practicable

alternatives existed to the Ware Creek Reservoir. EEPA’s

contrary claim was not only unsupported, it was disproved by

the administrative record. 758 F. Supp. at 353, App. E-7-9.

The District Court set aside EPA’s prohibition and directed the

Corps to issue the permit it had previously decided to issue.

The District Court denied EPA’s request for a stay pending

appeal on February 7, 1991, owing to "James City County’s

demonstrated need for a reliable water supply and the

overwhelming public interest inherent therein.” EPA did not

seek a stay from the Court of Appeals. The Corps issued the

permit to James City County on March 1, 1991, and the County

proceeded with preparations for construction.

On appeal to the Fourth Circuit, EPA continued to say that

whether effects are “unacceptable” under § 404(c) must be

12

assessed in light of all relevant information — including whether

practicable alternatives are or are not available:

The statutory term “unacceptable” must certainly

authorize the Agency to consider and balance a wide

variety of pertinent factors, including the scope and

severity of a project’s environmental effects in light of

the benefits to be obtained from it.

Reply Brief for Appellants EPA and Corps of Engineers (May

16, 1991) at 8-9. EPA insisted there were practicable

alternatives, but asked for a remand even if the court concluded

otherwise:

[A] remand is both legally required and essential to

allow the EPA to decide whether the County’s section

404 permit should be vetoed even if the County lacks

alternatives to the Ware Creek Reservoir.’

*- *+ *

[Ajll EPA really seeks here is the opportunity to decide

for itself whether this project’s adverse effects are so

“unacceptable” as to warrant the Agency’s veto even if

the County lacks practicable alternatives.*

Faced at oral argument with the panel’s obvious concern for the

water needs of James City County, EPA’s counsel volunteered

that, if the agency was granted a remand, it would complete it

within sixty days.

On January 29, 1992, the Fourth Circuit agreed with the

Corps, the SWCB and the District Court that the exhaustive

studies in the administrative record established that no

” Brief For Appellants EPA And Corps Of Engineers (April 18,

1991) at 45.

* Reply Brief For Appellants EPA And Corps Of Engineers

(May 16, 1991) at 10.

13

practicable alternative existed. It said the record evidence made

that conclusion "unavoidable" and it refused to permit EPA to

contend otherwise on remand. 955 F.2d at 259-60, App. F-12-

13. Stressing EPA’s voluntary commitment to act within sixty

days, the Fourth Circuit granted EPA’s requested remand. As

the District Court later summed up, "the Court of Appeals gave

the EPA sixty days in which to determine whether, in the

absence of alternatives, the Ware Creek project was

‘unacceptable’ within the meaning of the Ciean Water Act.”

App. H--2.

D. Regulatory Proceedings On Remand

But on remand EPA did not acknowledge the lack of a

practicable alternative to the Ware Creek Reservoir in any way.

Instead, it merely refrained from discussing what EPA

continued to call "the availability of less environmentally

damaging practicable alternatives to the Ware Creek water

supply impoundment... ." Final Determination on Remand

(March 27, 1992), SAR 17 at 47, App. G-72.

Though EPA’s first prohibition said the supposed availability

of alternatives made the Reservoir’s effects unnecessary and

therefore “unacceptable,” its second failed to consider that the

established absence of alternatives might make those effects

necessary and therefore “acceptable” under § 404(c). EPA's

Final Determination on Remand of March 27, 1992 did not

consider James City County’s need for the reservoir, the

absence of any alternative, nor the potential consequences of

failing to build it. Nor did EPA explain its failure to consider

any of these factors.

Nor did EPA’s decision on remand evaluate whether the

effects of the project might be rendered “acceptable” by the

Mitigation Plan. Notwithstanding the established lack of

alternatives, EPA again dismissed the Plan because it would not

14

achieve “no net loss.”

E. JCCll

Back before the District Court, EPA’s counsel was pressed

to explain EPA’s failure to consider these factors. He provided

a response exactly opposite EPA’s prior position:

THE COURT: Do I understand that you take the

position that the lack of any water supply and the effect

upon James City County is something that you can

completely rule out, you don’t “=e to look at that at

all? I take that from your brief -- that’s the reading I

took of it.

MR. CARSON: Your Honor, that’s correct.

Transcript (July 28, 1992), CR 72 at 31. Meanwhile,

environmental groups supporting EPA as amnici curiae attached

to their memorandum portions of a preliminary draft of yet

another “regional” water supply study prepared by consultants

to the City of Newport News. Based on this non-record

material, amici curiae argued that the County’s water needs

could be met by an alternative project.

The District Court set aside EPA’s second prohibition on

August 4, 1992. It did so for two independent reasons. First,

the District Court held that EPA was required to consider but

“completely ignore[d] James City County’s desperate need for

* _ EPA restated the derivation of its "no net loss” policy and said

it was using § 404(c) to implement that policy. App. G-57-59. It then

again found the Plan “inadequate” because, "[t]he proposed acreage

is insufficient to replace the extent of wetlands that would be lost"

(App. G-63, emphasis added) and “there is no information suggesting

that the wetland creation effort would produce the existing cover-types

or produce them in their current proportions or . . . current range of

habitat values." App. G-64 (emphasis added).

15

water." 23 Envtl. L. Rep. at 20,229, App. H-3. The District

Court was unmoved by continuing argument from amici curiae,

based on non-record "evidence," that EPA’s failure to consider

this matter should be excused because yet another “regional”

source was entering the regulatory gauntlet. Second, the

District Court found that "the environmental data in the

administrative record also fail to provide substantial support for

the EPA’s position." This was "primarily because of [EPA’s]

failure to consider the mitigation plan adequately." 23 Envtl. L.

Rep. at 20,229, App. H-4. But EPA also overlooked

uncontradicted evidence that the Ware Creek watershed will be

timbered and developed even if the Reservoir is not constructed

(thus displacing wildlife without mitigation). 23 Envtl. L. Rep.

at 20,229-30, App. H-6.

EPA did not seek a stay of the District Court’s decision and

the Corps accordingly reinstated James City County’s § 404

permit. Preparations for Reservoir construction resumed.

On appeal, EPA’s counsel sought to explain EPA’s policy

regarding alternatives. He said if a practicable alternative

exists, EPA will consider that fact in deciding if the project’s

efiects are "unacceptable." But if no such alternative exists,

EPA will ignore that fact and focus only on matters of water

quality. Reply Brief for Appellants EPA and Corps of

Engineers (Feb. 16, 1993) at 10. The Fourth Circuit

summarized this argument as follows:

The EPA ... asserts that while it may in its sole

discretion consider the need for water, the only

requirement placed on it by Congress is to consider the

project’s potential adverse impacts on the environment.

12 F.3d at 1335, App. I-10.

In its decision of December 30, 1993, the Fourth Circuit

noted that § 404(c) of the Clean Water Act is ambiguous as to

what EPA must consider:

[EPA’s] authority to veto to protect the environment is

16

practically unadorned. It is simply directed to veto

when it finds that the discharge “will have an

adverse effect on municipal water supplies,

shellfish beds and fishery areas ..., wildlife, or

recreational areas."

it said that the only factor clearly and unambiguously identified

for consideration in § 404(c) is water purity. On that basis, the

Fourth Circuit excused EPA from considering any factor other

than water purity and reversed the District Court. 12 F.3d at

1336, App. I-12.

The Fourth Circuit also reversed the District Court’s finding

that EPA’s allegations regarding the effects of the Reservoir

were not adequately supported by the administrative record. It

did not address EPA’s failure to consider the matters cited by

the District Court. Instead, the Court of Appeals cited EPA’s

findings and conclusions and said, "the district court erred in

failing to recognize the deference due the EPA’s

determination." 12 F.3d at 1338, App. I-17-18.

The Petition of James City County for Rehearing and

Suggestion for Rehearing in Banc was denied by the Fourth

Circuit on March 25, 1994. App. J-1.

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT

I. THIS COURT SHOULD DECIDE

WHETHER § 404(c) PERMITS EPA TO

IGNORE AN APPLICANT’S NEEDS AND

THE LACK OF ANY PRACTICABLE

ALTERNATIVE MEANS OF MEETING

THEM, AND TO FOCUS ENTIRELY ON

WATER PURITY.

A. This Is an Important Federal Question.

In the fifteen years since EPA published implementing

regulations, it has pursued the § 404(c) process to completion

17

twelve times. It has blocked a municipal landfill, a flood

control project, three municipal water supply reservoirs, two

recreational impoundments, three agricultural operations, a

shopping mall, and two warehouse complexes. Each of the

last five EPA actions has involved a public water resource

project.

As important as the direct consequences of these completed

§ 404(c) actions are to the communities involved, they are just

"the tip of the iceberg." For each project EPA has blocked with

a completed § 404(c) action, it has blocked many more with

threatened or proposed § 404(c) actions. As with its completed

prohibitions, targets of EPA’s threatened actions often are large

public infrastructure projects undertaken by state and local

governments -- including water resource projects, transportation

improvements such as roads, ports and airports, municipal waste

management facilities, and educational and recreational centers.

Furthermore, EPA claims that “one of the basic functions

of 404(c) is to police the application of the 404(b)(1) guidelines"

by the Corps in its permit decisions. 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076,

58,078 (1979). EPA thus admittedly uses § 404(c) in selected

cases to compel the Corps to apply EPA’s policies to § 404

permitting generally. An excellent example is provided by

EPA’s decision to block construction of the shopping mall in

the Bersani case, thereby compelling the Corps to accept the

EPA policy called “sequencing."” If EPA, as its counsel claims,

‘° Up to EPA’s final § 404(c) action regarding the Attleboro

Mall, the Corps allowed a permit applicant to make its preferred

project the least damaging alternative by performing beneficial

“mitigation.” Bersani v. Environmental Protection Agency, 674 F.Supp.

405, 410 (N.D.N.Y. 1987). EPA contended the least damaging

alternative must be identified prior to consideration of any mitigation,

and called this “sequencing.” EPA blocked construction of the mall

saying an alternative was available to the applicant that -- prior to

consideration of mitigation -- was less damaging. After EPA’s

prohibition was upheld by the Second Circuit, the Corps renounced

18

has indeed decided that the alternatives provisions of the

404(b)(1) guidelines must be applied so that the lack of any

alternative is irrelevant, then that policy is potentially applicable

to every § 404 permit decision.

In many communities across the country, public

infrastructure facilities of the kind at issue in this case simply

cannot be built without placing fill in areas subject to § 404.

And the 404(b)(1) guidelines allow issuance of a permit only for

the single, least-damaging alternative. That means, in such

communities, the Corps and EPA (not state, regional or local

planning departments) determine what water supply is tapped --

if any, what transportation project is built -- if any, what waste

management facility is constructed -- if any, and what

educational and recreational centers are permitted -- if any.

James City County is one example of communities

nationwide with pressing infrastructure requirements. The

evidence in the administrative record is uncontradicted

concerning the County’s need for water. Water levels in its

wells are falling, and water quality is deteriorating as brackish

water enters an overdrawn aquifer. The County has abandoned

several wells already and predictions are that it must soon

abandon more in order to maintain Safe Drinking Water Act

standards. On top of this, the County’s population of residents

and tourists continues to grow. The District Court quite

properly described the County’s water situation as “desperate.”

The immediate, practical consequence of the decision below

for the citizens of James City County is to ban construction of

the water supply finally adjudged to be their only "practicable"

source. According to the Corps, the result could be "too

dangerous and damaging to contemplate" -- a “potentially

disastrous system failure" by the year 2000. Record of Decision,

its policy. It now issues permits only for projects that are the least

damaging prior to consideration of proposed mitigation work.

Memorandum of Agreement between the Environmental Pr otection

Agency and the Department of the Army et cet. (Nov. 15, 1989).

19

App. A-3. The Corps’ finding that the health and safety

(including fire protection) of this community is directly

threatened by EPA’s action is fully supported by the

administrative record.

Even though they contend the consequences of EPA’s

action are irrelevant under § 404(c) and admit that EPA never

considered them, EPA’s counsel and amici curiae found it

necessary to argue -- on the basis of non-record "evidence" --

that no ill effects will occur. The Fourth Circuit felt compelled

to do the same. Referring to the submissions of amici curiae as

"[r]jecord material," it speculated that the City of Newport News

may succeed in licensing and constructing a Black Creek or

King William Reservoir, that the needs of James City County

may thereby be met, and that such a project may produce more

water with less adverse effects.”

The Fourth Circuit's use of this material -- and disregard of

the overwhelming contrary evidence in the record -- was legally

and factually in error. The material was not part of the

administrative record, and EPA expressly disclaimed any

reliance on it.” Judicial review is limited to "the administrative

"12 F.3d at 1334, n. 1, App. I-8-9, n. 1. That EPA, amici

curiae, and the Fourth Circuit each felt it necessary to highlight

supposedly irrelevant, non-record material demonstrates that the

consequences of EPA’s action are actually highly relevant to whether

effects are acceptable or unacceptable.

” EPA’s counsel described the history of these documents as

follows:

[T}hese documents are neither part of the administrative

record in this Section 404(c) proceeding, nor were they relied

upon in any way as a basis for the Remand Determination.

They come before this Court as a part of the judicial record

below, where amici Southern Environmental Law Center

("SELC"), et al., endeavored to make the district court aware

of the realities outside the cocoon woven in litigation.

20

record already in existence, not some new record made initially

in the reviewing court." Camp v. Pitts, 411 U.S. 138, 142 (1973).

Furthermore, “[i}t is well established that an agency’s action

must be upheld, if at all, on the basis articulated by the agency

itself." Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins.

Co., 463 U.S. 29, 50 (1983). This material should have played

no role in the decision below.

The Fourth Circuit also overlooked what the administrative

record does contain regarding its speculations. For example, it

reveals that EPA and other agencies have already nixed a Black

Creek project on multiple occasions.” Regarding Newport

News’ King William Reservoir, the record contains the

following EPA comments: "The purchase of water from

Newport News is legitimately not attractive on a long-term

basis, since it is simply not cost-effective." Final EIS, AR A-31

at 5-11. It shows that, even with the optimistic assumption that

all of its existing wells will remain sound, the County will need

water within just a few years. It thus cannot await the uncertain

conclusion of lengthy licensing and the inevitable litigation

which must be completed before construction of another project

might possibly begin. It also shows that the Ware Creek site

will not remain available as a fallback - it soon will be

timbered, developed, and lost as a potential water supply.

The Fourth Circuit originally ruled that EPA bears the

burden of demonstrating that an alternative is practicable. It

ruled that EPA not only failed to do so, but that the record

proved the opposite. It attempted to close the issue once and

for all. Now -- more than a decade after James City County

"entered the market" for a water source - it has cited

Reply Brief for Appellants EPA and Corps of Engineers (Feb. 16,

1993) at 6.

” _ A reservoir on Black Creek augmented with water pumped

from the Pamunkey River was one of the 28 "regional" projects

investigated by the Corps but rejected by EPA and other agencies.

Record of Decision, App. A-8, A-12.

21

preliminary, non-record materials concerning a new crop of

supposed alternatives. On that basis, it revises history and

suggests that this case is about how -- not whether -- the

County’s water needs will be met. If that is permitted to stand,

then no finding of a lack of alternatives will ever be final.

This case will decide whether the courts will allow EPA to

exercise the tremendous power of § 404(c) irresponsibly and

without any meaningful judicial review. The decision below

held EPA may completely disregard the needs of communities,

their lack of any other practicable means of meeting them, and

the likely consequences of its action. That is a question of

obvious national importance. The unreasonableness of the

Fourth Circuit’s holding is not altered by speculation that this

County may -- or may not -- eventually find another source of

water.

B. The Decision Below Conflicts with Prior Decisions

of this Court.

1. The Decision Below Failed to Require EPA to

Adhere to Its Long-Standing Policy.

EPA’s long-standing policy plainly says EPA “can take into

account the fact that the alternative sites or methods are or are

not available, so that the loss of resources is avoidable or

unavoidable.” 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076, 58,078 (1979). EPA’s

counsel confirmed this policy in JCC I, saying EPA would have

to consider the County’s water supply needs if it found no

practicable alternative to the Ware Creek Reservoir. See page

12, above.

EPA adhered to this policy so long as it was able to

summon a practicable alternative to the project it was reviewing.

But when faced by JCC J with the lack of alternatives in this

case, EPA made an abrupt and unexplained about-face. It did

not consider the County’s need for water and the absence of

alternatives on remand, and did not explain its failure to do so.

This Court has repeatedly held that an administrative

22

agency is bound by its long-standing interpretations of law and

its own regulations unless and until it clearly acknowledges a

change in policy and provides a reasoned explanation for it.

Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. Wichita Bd. of Trade,

412 U.S. 800, 807-08 (1973); Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n v. State

Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29, 41-43 (1983).

The decision below did not require EPA to follow, or to

explain its failure to follow, its long-standing, plainly-stated

policy. It is in conflict with this Court’s settled rule of

administrative law and should be reviewed for that reason.

2. The Decision Below Failed to Require EPA to

Articulate an Adequate Rationale for Its Action.

The only explanation for EPA’s failure to consider the lack

of any practicable alternative to the Ware Creek Reservoir

came post hoc from EPA’s counsel during this litigation. At

that time EPA’s counsel claimed that when no alternative exists,

EPA may ignore that fact. The decision below apparently

accepted that this was the actual basis for EPA’s failure to

consider the lack of alternatives to the Ware Creek Reservoir.

An administrative agency must itself “articulate a satisfactory

explanation for its action including a ‘rational connection

between the facts found and the choice made.” Motor Vehicle

Mfrs. Ass’n, 463 U.S. at 43 quoting Burlington Truck Lines, Inc.

v. United States, 371 U.S. 156, 168 (1962). That connection

cannot be supplied after-the-fact by agency counsel during

litigation. Burlington Truck Lines, 371 U.S. at 169 ("For the

courts to substitute their or counsel's discretion for that of the

Commission is incompatible with the orderly functioning of the

“See also Secretary of Agric. v. United States, 347 U.S. 645, 653-

54 (1954) (Interstate Commerce Commission failed adequately to

explain its departure from prior regulatory practice when it could not

be determined whether the agency simply disregarded facts found or

whether it modified its normal regulatory doctrine).

23

process of judicial review"). If the grounds stated by the agency

are inadequate, “the court is powerless to affirm the

administrative action by substituting what it considers to be a

more adequate or proper basis." Securities and Exch. Comm’n

v. Chenery Corp., 332 U.S. 194, 196 (1947).

Here, EPA articulated no connection at all between an

important fact found (the lack of any practicable alternative to

the Ware Creek Reservoir) and the decision made (to block

Reservoir construction). One cannot know whether EPA

negligently or willfully disregarded the absence of alternatives

or, as EPA’s counsel belatedly claimed, made a conscious policy

decision to ignore the lack of any practicable alternative. By

permitting EPA’s counsel to supply an explanation post hoc, the

decision below conflicts with the foregoing decisions of this

Court.

3. The Decision Below Failed to Defer to EPA’s

Long-Standing Policy.

The Fourth Circuit did not merely allow EPA’s counsel to

provide a new, previously missing policy to explain EPA’s

conduct. It actually accepted and enforced that policy. In so

doing, it displaced the contrary statutory interpretation

announced long ago by EPA itself. In place of the rule stated

in the preamble to EPA’s § 404(c) regulations ("the

Administrator can take into account the fact that the alternative

sites or methods ... are not available"), the Fourth Circuit

substituted one articulated only by EPA’s counsel in litigation

(“while [EPA] may in its sole discretion consider the need for

water, the only requirement placed on it by Congress is to

consider the project’s potential adverse impacts on the

environment"). 12 F.3d at 1335, App. I-10.

This too violates the prior decisions of this Court. In

Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.,

467 U.S. 837 (1984), this Court held that an agency’s properly-

adopted and reasonable interpretation of an ambiguous

statutory provision will not be displaced by a federal court.

24

This rule has been applied extensively when regulated entities

seek to vitiate a regulatory policy. No exception permits an

agency which has failed to follow its policy to disavow it

through counsel in subsequent litigation.

The decision below displaced EPA’s long-standing statutory

interpretation that whether alternatives are or are not available

is relevant to determining if the effects of a project are

acceptabie or "unacceptable." It did not inquire whether that is

a reasonable interpretation. It did not consider that other

courts have found that it is.“ For these reasons as well, the

decision below is contrary to the prior decisions of this Court

and should be reviewed.

4. The Decision Below Improperly Granted EPA

Discretion to Ignore Relevant Factors.

Finally, the policy offered by EPA’s counsel and accepted

by the Fourth Circuit -- that EPA may consider whether

alternatives exist when an alternative is found, but may ignore

the matter when no alternative is found -- also violates prior

decisions of this Court. When a factor is relevant to an

agency’s decision, it is arbitrary and capricious for the agency to

fail to consider it. Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass'n, 463 U.S. at 43.

Agencies have no discretion to consider some relevant factors

and to ignore others, or to consider relevant factors some of the

* Bersani v. Environmental Protection Agency, 674 F.Supp. 405

(N.D.N.Y. 1987), aff'd sub nom Bersani v. Robichaud, 850 F.2d 36 (2d

Cir. 1988) cert. denied 489 U.S. 1089 (1989); Newport Galleria Group

v. Deland, 618 F.Supp. 1179 (D.D.C. 1985).

* Trial courts in negligence actions often follow the rule that

whether a traffic light is red or green when a motorist enters an

intersection is a factor relevant to determining negligence. The

Fourth Circuit’s decision is like permitting the trier of fact to consider

the color of the light if it was red, but not to consider the color of the

light if it was green.

25

time, or when they support an agency’s preordained result.” To

hold otherwise -- as did the Fourth Circuit -- would make a new

principle of administrative law out of an old joke: "Heads, the

agency wins; tails, the permit applicant loses."

The decision below violates fundamental principles of

administrative law long enforced by this Court and should be

reviewed.

C. The Decision Below Conflicts with a Decision of the

Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.

The Fourth Circuit concluded that EPA may consider only

water purity under § 404(c):

Ultimately, however, recognizing the EPA’s expertise

and concentrated concern with environmental matters,

Congress gave the final decision whether to permit a

project to that agency. Its authority to veto to protect

the environment is practically unadorned. It is simply

directed to veto when it finds that the discharge “will

have an unacceptable adverse effect on municipal water

supplies, shellfish beds and fishery areas. . ., wildlife, or

recreational areas." ... This broad grant of power to

the EPA focuses only on the agency’s assigned function

of assuring pure water and is consistent with the

missions assigned to it throughout the Clean Water Act.

’ That is particularly true in this case because EPA’s own

§ 404(c) regulations provide, “In making this determination, the

Administrator will take into account all information available to

him... ." 40 C.F.R. § 231.1(a), 44 Fed. Reg. 58,076, 58,083 (1979).

% James City County has never contended that the absence of

an alternative necessarily entitles it to a permit. Rather, the County

contends the absence of alternatives is a factor supportive of permit

issuance which EPA was required to consider.

26

12 F.3d at 1336, App. I-12. Its decision in this regard conflicts

with the decision of the Second Circuit in Bersani v. Robichaud,

850 F.2d 36 (2d Cir. 1988), cert. denied 489 U.S. 1089 (1989).

In Bersani, the Second Circuit was asked to review EPA’s

prohibition of fill for construction of a shopping mall. EPA’s

Final Determination said:

As a matter of common sense, as well as regulatory ;

practice, the "acceptability" of an adverse effect may }

depend on the extent to which that effect is avoidable. ;

The alternatives provisions, as well as other portions of :

the section 404(b)(1) Guidelines, thus are necessarily é

relevant to a section 404(c) determination.” t

The District Court for the Northern District of New York had

ruled as follows:

The court finds the EPA’s interpretation that the

evoidability of a loss may be considered in corjunction |

with its magnitude in determining whether it is t

“unacceptable” within the meaning of Section 404(c) and E

“significant” within the meaning of the implementing

regulation is reasonable. This interpretation does not

violate the plain language of the statute or the language

of the pertinent regulations. i

Bersani v. Environmental Protection Agency, 674 F.Supp. 405, 415

(N.D.N.Y. 1987). On appeal to the Second Circuit the ft

applicant conceded that EPA may consider whether alternatives i

do or do not exist. But it claimed that determination must be

made as of the time it made its permit application (when it had

* Final Determination of the Administrator for External Affairs

the Sweedens Swamp Site in Attleboro, Massachusetts

Pursuant To Section 404(c) of the Clean Water Act (May 13, 1986),

CR 62 Exhibit 4 at 14 (emphasis added).

27

no alternative) -- not as of the time it “entered the market" for

its project as EPA contended (when it did have an alternative).

The Second Circuit said the existence of alternatives must

be determined as of the date an applicant “enters the market."

It therefore found that EPA’s § 404(c) action was properly

based on the availability of a

alternative. To reach this result, the Second Circuit necessarily

accepted EPA’s contention that factors other than water purity

and the magnitude of environmental effects arc relevant to

assessing whether effects are acceptable or "unacceptable" under

§ 404(c). The Second Circuit relied in part on the reasoning of

Newport Galleria Group v. Deland, 618 F.Supp. 1179, 1182 n. 2

(D.D.C. 1985) ("[I]}t would be extraordinary if Congress granted

the EPA a veto power over the Corps’ permit decisions, but

precluded it from reconsidering those issues the Corps

considered in deciding to grant the permit in the first place").

Il. THIS COURT SHOULD DECIDE

WHETHER COURTS MUST DEFER TO

AGENCY FINDINGS DESPITE OBVIOUS

REASONS TO DOUBT THEIR ANALYSES.

Ordinarily, agency process is given a “presumption of

regularity” and the findings of an agency are entitled to

substantial deference. But there are circumstances in this case

that this Court and various Courts of Appeals have determined

require greater scrutiny of the agency process. The decision

below ignored these “danger signals" and broadly deferred to

EPA’s findings.

First, this case involves joint administration of a single

regulatory program by three agencies, cach with statutory

authority to block permit issuance based on environmental

issues. One agency, EPA, has disagreed extensively with the

other two, the Corps and the SWCB. Both of these found the

Reservoir complied with all applicable environmental

requirements. To the extent a court might defer to EPA’s

28

findings, it would necessarily disregard those of the Corps and

the SWCB.

In such circumstances, this Court has found that federal

courts need not defer to one agency’s findings. General Electric

Co. v. Gilbert, 429 U.S. 125, 144-45 (1976) (where the denial of

benefits for pregnancy disability would be treated as an unlawful

employment practice by the Equal Employment Opportunity

Commission but not by the Wage and Hour Administrator,

court need not defer to EEOC). See also Barnard v. Carey, 60

F.Supp. 539 (N.D. Ohio 1945) (faced with conflicting findings

by two agencies as to whether “Soya Butter” was

“oleomargarine,” court decided the question). According to

Professor Bernard Schwartz, when faced with this situation "the

reviewing court should decide the question for itself” based on

the weight of evidence in the record as a whole. B. Schwartz,

Administrative Law § 10.35 at 664 (2d ed. 1984).

In the same regulatory context presented by this case, the

Second Circuit was "not thoroughly persuaded" it should defer

to an EPA interpretation of the Section 404(b)(1) guidelines

which conflicted with the Corps’ interpretation. It accordingly

did not do so. Bersani, 850 F.2d at 45. The decision below is

thus in conflict with the decision of the Second Circuit on this

issue as well.

Second, the presumption of regularity ordinarily given to

EPA’s actions has already been conclusively rebutted in this

case. The District Court and the Fourth Circuit have both

invalidated EPA’s claims in this case that a reservoir is not a

“water dependent activity” and that several small water supply

projects are "practicable" and “available” to James City County.

The Fourth Circuit found that EPA ignored "uncontroverted

evidence to the contrary" to reach that result, that "there was

not substantial evidence to support the EPA’s conclusion,” and

that “the record makes this conclusion unavoidable.” 955 F.2d

at 260, App. F-12-13. The District Court more directly called

EPA’s findings "nonsense" and "pure nonsense.” 758 F.Supp. at

352, 353, App. E-8-9.

Despite this -- and despite EPA’s failure even to

29

acknowledge the lack of alternatives it declared -- the Fourth

Circuit granted complete deference to EPA’s findings on

remand. The Fourth Circuit similarly failed to note EPA’s

departure from its consistent and long-standing rule and the

fact that it reachec the same result on remand after less than 60

days’ deliberation.

The D. C. Circuit Court of Appeals has determined that

such facts demand -- not deference -- but "more exacting

scrutiny” of the agency’s findings:

More exacting scrutiny will be particularly useful when

for some reason the presumption of agency regularity

... is rebutted, as where . . . the agency has arrived at

an identical result after remand from a reviewing court

for further explanation of reasons, e.g., Food Marketing

Inst. v. ICC, 587 F.2d 1285, 1289-90 (D.C. Cir. 1978);

accord, Citizens to Preserve Overton Park, supra, 401 U.S.

at 420; or when an agency has departed from its

consistent and longstanding precedents or policies, see

Office of Communication of United Church of Christ v.

CAB, No. 76-1878 (D.C. Cir. Sept. 11, 1978), slip op. at

13; International Union v. NLRB, 459 F.2d 1329, 1341-

42 (D.C. Cir. 1972).

Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. v. Securities & Exch.

Comm'n, 606 F.2d 1031, 1049-50 n.23 (D.C. Cir. 1979). The

decision below is thus in conflict with a decision of the D. C.

Circuit on this point.

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the petition of James City

County for a writ of certiorari should be granted.

Respectfully submitted,

WILLIAM B. ELLIS FRANK M. MORTON, III

Counsel of Record James City County

McSweeney, Burtch & Crump Post Office Box 8784

Post Office Box 1463 101-C Mounts Bay Road

11 South Twelfth Street Williamsburg, Va. 23187

Richmond, Virginia 23212 (804) 253-6612

(804) 783-6805

Counsel for Petitioner James City County, Virginia

June 22, 1994

APPENDIX A

UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

JULY 11, 1988

84-0614-06 RECORD OF DECISION

I have reviewed the Final Environmental Impact Statement

(FEIS) for James City County's proposed water supply reservoir,

and the comments received in response to the October 9, 1987

Public Notice. As part of this review I have also prepared an

analysis pursuant to Section 404(b) (1) of the Clean Water Act,

which is appended to this Record of Decision.

Based on my 404(b) (1) analysis, I find that this project does

comply with the December 24, 1980 Guidelines, with the miti-

gation which is proposed. This is not an easy determination, since

a substantial acreage of special aquatic sites (wetlands) will be

flooded. However, I find that an impressive effort has been made

to avoid, minimize, and compensate for these wetland losses, to

the extent that the net loss has been reduced so as not to cause

a significant degradation to the waters of the United States. I also

find, after considering my Final EIS (and the comments it gen-

erated) as well as the 1984 Water Supply Study, Hampton Roads,

Virginia conducted by Norfolk District and the 1987 James

Water Supply Plan conducted by the Virginia State Water Con-

trol Board, that there are no practicable alternatives which would

be less damaging. The Ware Creek wetlands perform many of the

functions listed in 33 CFR 320.4 (b) (2) and I consider them to

be a valuable public resource. With the reservoir in place, the

remaining wetlands within the Ware Creek watershed will con-

tinue to perform these functions, although some will be per-

formed to a somewhat lesser extent. The wetland creation within

the reservoir will help assure that the reservoir will also be a very

productive aquatic environment, and the wetlands created down-

stream of the dam will help offset the loss of detrital input into

fel

the York River. The breaching of Cranstons Pond dam will re-

connect hundreds of acres of wetlands which have been isolated

from the Yarmouth/Chickahominy/James River system for most

of a century, and, while this will not directly offset the loss to the

York River, both the York and the James flow into the Chesa-

peake Bay. For this reason, and since no commentor has given

any evidence to the contrary, I find that the cumulative impact of

this project to the Chesapeake Bay will not be significant. Based

on my FEIS, I find that there will be a net benefit to navigation;

the slight loss of navigation in Richardson Millpond and Ware

Creek being more than made up for by the creation of the new

reservoir. Navigation can be an important factor in the public

interest review, but in this case it is limited to recreational doat-

ing in a region with many similar opportunities, and is not par-

ticularly important. Energy conservation and development can

also be a very important public interest factor, but I find that the

energy needed to construct and operate this project is not of

significant quantity or concern. (The energy which would be

needed for some of the alternatives, particularly desalinization,

would be much greater and would be of more concern.) With

regard to fish and wildlife, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

(FWS), the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), and the

Virginia Department of Game and Inland Fisheries are all op-

posed to this project. All three contend that the project is not

mitigated on a 1:1 basis for fish and wildlife losses. I concur in

general with their contention, although I note that none of these

agencies has suggested any specific mitigation which would be

needed in order to achieve a 1:1 replacement, and that for cer-

tain species of fish and wildlife the project would substantially

improve habitat. After seven years of discussion this project with

agencies, organizations, and individuals through the NEPA pro-

cess, I find that the mitigation which is currently proposed is all

that can be reasonably expected and is adequate to avoid an

unacceptable wetland functional loss. I note that James City

County is currently negotiating with FWS, the Virginia Depart-

ment of Game and Inland Fisheries, and the Environmental Pro-

Ac2

tection Agency (EPA) to see if additional wetland mitigation

outside of the Ware Creek watershed and outside James City

County would induce them to drop their objections and convince

EPA to cease its consideration of a permit veto. These negotia-

tions are occurring outside the public interest review process,

although if some kind of settlement is achieved, any such addi-

tional mitigation could be made a permit condition, if requested

by the County. As discussed herein, though, I find the mitigation

presently proposed to be adequate to prevent the project from not

being in the public interest.

As stated in 33 CFR 320.4 (m), "Water is an essential resource,

basic to human survival, economic growth, and the natural en-

vironment." I find that the consequences of not developing a

reliable water supply, as outlined in paragraph 2.102 of the FEIS,

are too dangerous and damaging to contemplate as an alternative.

Given the seven years which this project has taken to get this far,

I am not at all convinced that James City County could develop

another source of water in time to forestall the potentially disas-

trous system failure which the Peninsula could realistically face

by the end of the next decade if this project were not allowed.

Though there has been much study and more talk devoted to

regional solutions over the past several years, the fact remains

that such an alternative does not currently exist and does not

appear to be even likely in the future.

I am greatly concerned over the environmental losses which the

EPA, FWS, NMFS, and others have pointed out, and I agree that

not all of these losses will be completely mitigated. I also find,

though, that the mitigation will reduce the net effect of the losses

to the point where they will not significantly degrade the waters

of the United States. Were it not for the overpowering need for

the project and the lack of practicable alternatives, I could not

justify this project as being in the public interest. The need can-

not be overlooked by any responsible party, though, and the

evidence concerning the lack of practicable alternatives is over-

Ac3

whelming. For these reasons I find this project not to be contrary

to the public interest and find that a permit should be issued,

requiring all of the environmental mitigation discussed in the

FEIS which is described as being successful and effective.

The following are comments received from agencies, organiza-

tions, and individuals during the October 9-November 9, 1987

comment period (later extended through November 24).

By letter dated November 23, 1987, Region III of the Environ-

mental Protection Agency (EPA) commented on the FEIS.

EPA's comments are addressed below:

COMMENT: The project would significantly degrade more

that 425 acres of unusually diverse and productive wetlands.

RESPONSE: I concur that the existing wetlands are very pro-

ductive and diverse, and I would much rather see them main-

tained in their present condition if some other feasible and rea-

sonable solution to the water supply problem could be found. The

425 acre figure includes vegetated wetlands as well as shallow

water habitat which may support vegetated shallows. As noted

in the FEIS on pages 5-37 and 5-38, these wetlands are diverse

and productive, but not unique. Other creek/wetland systems in

this area are similarly diverse and productive.

COMMENT: The wetland mitigation plan will not completely

compensate for habitat losses, other wetland functional value

losses, or wetland acreage.

RESPONSE: I recognize that the proposal described in the

FEIS does not constitute 1:1 mitigation of vegetated wetlands in

terms of either habitat or acreage. At a November 19, 1987

meeting between the Corps, the National Marine Fisheries Ser-

vice, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the Environmental

Protection Agency, my staff asked for specific suggestions for

A4

additional wetland mitigation. To date we have received none. By

CEQ regulation (40 CFR 1503.3 (d) EPA and FWS are required

to inform me of any such wetland mitigation which they consider

necessary ("When a cooperating agency with jurisdiction by law

objects to or expresses reservations about the proposal on

grounds of environmental impacts, the agency expressing the

objection or reservation shall specify the mitigation measures it

considers necessary to allow the agency to grant or approve

applicable permit, license, or related requirements or concur-

rences"). EPA was a cooperating agency and has jurisdiction by

law under Section 404(c) of the Clean Water Act. EPA agreed

in 1985, as a cooperating agency, to perform a wetland functional

values assessment for inclusion in the FEIS. EPA never prepared

this analysis. The County has proposed extensive wetland miti-

gation within the reservoir and downstream in Ware Creek. In

addition they have found another site within the County but

outside the Ware Creek watershed (Cranstons Pond) where they

propose a very innovative and appropriate form of mitigation;

turning an existing reservoir back into a wetland. There are no

other wetland mitigation sites within the Ware Creek watershed

and there is a reasonable limit to the geographical area which can

be expected to be searched for additional wetland mitigation

opportunities in the absence of specific suggestions. Thereforc,

I believe a reasonable requirement of mitigation has been reached,

considering the total public interest and in the absence of alternative

water supply solutions. Consequently, I believe that the project is

adequately mitigated and environmentally acceptable.

COMMENT: The project will degrade water quality both

within the reservoir and downstream.

RESPONSE: The FEIS notes that the reservoir will probably

become eutrophic, or at least upper mesotrophic, as are most

other reservoirs in Virginia's Coastal Plain. This has not kept these

reservoirs from being used as water supplies, however, 2nd many

are extensively used for fishing and boating. I know of no evidence

AeS

SS eee eae eT On Se Te Ope ee a

that the project will "degrade" the downstream water quality of

Ware Creek. Reservoirs normally act as efficient sediment and

nutrient traps and this, combined with the guaranteed minimum

release, may actually improve downstream water quality.

COMMENT: The potential cumulative impacts to the Chesa-

peake are "evident".

RESPONSE: Norfolk District asked EPA, in its capacity as a

cooperating agency for the FEIS as well as the lead agency for

the Chesapeake Bay Program, to identify these cumulative im-

pacts and their effects on the Bay so that they could be included

in the FEIS. By letter of December 11, 1985, EPA agreed to do

so and to submit a final report to the District by September 1,

1986. The study has never been performed. The December 11,

1985 letter stated "We appreciate the opportunity you are pro-

viding EPA in this decisionmaking process." EPA was given

every reasonable opportunity to constructively contribute to the

NEPA process as a cooperating agency (40 CFR 1501. 6(b)). By

failing to do so, EPA has substantially reduced the force and sig-

nificance of its objections to this project concerning loss of

wetland functional values and cumulative impacts on the Chesa-

peake Bay. Because of their general expertise in these two areas

I would normally give great weight to their comments, but in this

case I do not find them persuasive. (See "Forty Most Asked

Questions Concerning CEQ's National Environmental Policy Act

Regulations", Federal Register Vol. 46, No. 55, March 23, 1981;

response to question 14d, page 18031.) I find no evidence of any

significant adverse cumulative effect this project would have on

the Chesapeake Bay.

COMMENT: This project would set a precedent of allowing

significant environmental degradation for limited returns. Other

water supply impoundments have been proposed for this area of

Virginia.

RESPONSE: I concur that it is probably not a good policy to

generate only incremental solutions to a regional water supply

problem, and I would prefer to avoid doing so. However, no

practicable regional solution (or solutions) has ever been sug-

gested by any agency, organization, or individual which has been

determined to be environmentally acceptable by EPA, the U.S.

Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS), and the National Marine Fish-

eries Service (NMFS). The Norfolk District has been on

since 1984 (Water Supply Study Hampton Roads Virginia), and

the Virginia Water Control Board as recently as 1987 (James

Water Supply Plan), projecting a regional water supply deficit by

the year 2030 of between 35 and 40 mgd. All agencies with

expertise in this area are in agreement that an additional water

supply is needed. The history of water supply development on the

Peninsula in this century has been one of incremental develop-

ment of surface (direct withdrawal and reservoir construction)

and groundwater resources which are then tied into a regional

network. Since many years of study by sevezal local, State, and

Federal agencies have not identified any acceptable or feasible

long term regional alternative, continuation of incremental devel-

opment appears to be the only practicable solution available.

COMMENT: EPA isconvinced that less damaging alternatives

to the proposal exist but remain unidentified.

RESPONSE: If less damaging alternatives remain unidentified,

it is not for lack of effort. Our 1984 Water Supply Study iden-

tified approximately 29 alternatives to meet the water supply

needs of the Peninsula. EPA supported only one; a pipeline to the

James River above Richmond, which, at the minimum instream

flows recommended by the FWS would have a safe yield of 14

mgd or less. (This assumes that such a pipeline would be hooked

into the existing Newport News water system of reservoirs. By

itself, the pipeline would have no safe yield without somewhere

to store water for use during times when flow in the River is less

than the minimum instream flow). In an independent effort, the

Ac7

Virginia State Water Control Board developed its own list of

regional alternatives for the Peninsula in its 1987 James Water

Supply Plan. EPA has been involved with the Ware Creek EIS

since its initial scoping letter of May 12, 1981 and EPA was a

cooperating agency for the Final EIS. To maintain that a prac-

ticable alternative could he identified with yet another study is not

supported by the record and begs the question why this seven-

year effort, with numerous opportunities for input from EPA (as

well as FWS, NMFS, and other agencies and organizations), has

not succeeded in identifying such an alternative or alternatives.

By letter dated November 24, 1987, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife

Service (FWS) commented on the FEIS. This letter was later

submitted under a December 22, 1987 cover letter from the U.S.

Department of Interior Office of Environmental Project Review.

Since the Department's cover letter primarily summarized and

reiterated the FWS letter, the FWS comments are addressed

below:

COMMENT: The Corps should have evaluated this project

from a regional perspective and not just a local one.

RESPONSE: The FEIS in its very first paragraph placed this

project in a regional perspective, and several alternatives ana-

lyzed were considered as both local and regional alternatives

(e.g.: groundwater, desalinization, James River pipeline, etc.).

COMMENT: Scoping failed to identify, and the FEIS failed to

discuss, multiple source alternatives.

RESPONSE: Scoping may have failed to identify multiple

source alternatives, but they were considered anyway. The FEIS

discusses a Pamunkey/Black Creek alternative, a Pamunkey/

Crump Creek/Ware Creek alternative, and a Pamunkey/Ware

Creek alternative, and it points out that groundwater and the

James River could incrementally produce 10 and 13-14 mgd,

respectively.

COMMENT: The FWS takes exception to the Corps statement

that denial of a Ware Creek reservoir would mean that no accept-

able reservoir sites exist on the Peninsula.

RESPONSE: I find no discrepancy with the conclusion in the

FEIS that denial of this permit implies that no environmentally

acceptable reservoir site exists on the lower Peninsula. FWS, for

instance, has either actively opposed, cr at least not supported,

every water supply reservoir either proposed for construction or

considered as an alternative on the Peninsula since the Little

Creek Reservoir was permitted in 1975. This includes all of the

alternative reservoirs discussed in the Corps Water Supply Study

and this FEIS. The 3 Dam alternative is unacceptable to FWS as

described in the FEIS except with additional (unspecified) miti-

gation. As noted in a response to an EPA comment above, CEQ

regulations require cooperating agencies with jurisdiction by law

to request specific mitigation if they find the proposal lacking.

FWS has jurisdiction by law under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act

yet made no suggestions for additional wetland mitigation dur-

ing the comment periods for either the Draft or Final EIS.

COMMENT: FWS notes that the project would have substan-

tial adverse impacts, as described in its Habitat Evaluation Pro-

cedures (HEP) analysis (Appendix A to the FEIS). Also, the

Service feels that destruction of the existing Blue Heron rook-

ery should be assumed.

RESPONSE: I do not substantially disagree with the specific

results of the HEP analysis, which was an interagency effort in

which my staff participated. I also recognize that FWS has taken

the position that gains in one habitat cover type cannot be mea-

sured against losses in another habitat cover type. I note, though,

Ad

that the Fish and Wildlife Service Mitigation Policy speaks of

"goals" of no net loss of habitat value, and I think that in most

situations one cannot convert 1200+ acres of mixed habitat cover

types into open water habitat without losing some net habitat

value for at least one cover type. If one refers to Figure 4-5 in the

FEIS and sums the total average annual habitat units (AAHU's)

lost and gained for all cover types, one finds that the 3 dam alter-

native would cause a loss of 754 more AAHU's than the proposed

project. The HEP is only one measure of project impacts, and

some of the proposed mitigation is not reflected in its results (e.g.,

since the HEP does not consider whether a wetland is directly

connected to a downstream estuary, reconnecting the wetlands

above Cranstons Pond to the Yarmouth/Chickahominy estuary

is not given any credit). As stated in the FEIS, approximately 167

acres of wetlands can be counted on to be successfully created

within and downstream of the Site V reservoir and in Cranstons

Pond, and another 128 acres within the Site V reservoir woulc

become vegetated to some extent with wetlands, for a total of 295

acres (167 acres worst case). In addition, breaching the Cranstons

Pond dam would reconnect and enhance the value of between 340

acres (FWS estimate) and 506 acres (County estimate) of up-

stream wetlands which are presently isolated. Using an interme-

diate figure of 230 acres of wetland creation and the lower fig-

ure of 340 acres of wetland enhancement, I find that the 425 acre

wetland loss will be adequately mitigated. We are in basic agree-

ment that relocation of the existing Blue Heron rookery is specu-

lative and should not me expected to occur.

COMMENT: FWS recommends that the 3 dam alternative be

selected, with additiona! mitigation, over the proposed Site V

alternative.

RESPONSE: Selection of the 3 dam alternative would provide

only 65% of the safe yield of the proposed configuration and

would also flood 65% of the wetland acreage. In terms of mil-

lions of gallons of safe yield versus acres of wetlands flooded, the

A-10

two are virtually identical. The Site V alternative would postpone

the onset of mandatory water restrictions and rationing for a

somewhat longer period than the 3 dam alternative, and this is a

legitimate distinction. Site V also has a greater potential for fu-

ture expansion, as discussed later. Further, the 3 Dam alternative

would be acceptable to FWS with additional mitigation. None is

specified in the November 24 letter, although when our respec-

tive staffs met at Norfolk District offices earlier in November, one

of the subjects discussed was how additional mitigation could be

ach:*ved. To date I have received no such suggestions.

COMMENT: Additional alternatives should be investigated

before making a permit decision on this project. The specific

alternatives are enumerated below.

RESPONSE: First, I would point out that FWS recommended

very strongly against two of these alternatives (Chickahominy

and Pamunkey Rivers) in their comments on the Corps Water

Supply Study - Hampton Roads, Virginia. The scope of the analy-

ses which FWS now presents as being "necessary to determine

the relative impacts" exceeds the scope of the entire Ware Creek

EIS anc rivals that of the entire Northside portion of the Corps

Water Supply Study. Given FWS's historic position on these

alternatives, I believe the burden falis cn them to provide some

evidence that they are now in some way both reasonable and

environmentally preferable to Site V.

1. Chickahominy River: After considering the verbal

comments of FWS, NMFS, and EPA staff at the November 19,

1987 meeting and their written comments on the FEIS, I asked

James City County to provide me with clarifying information

relating to the storage capacities of reservoirs of differing eleva-

tions located at Site V, and they are shown on Enclosure 1. In the

course of gathering this information, the elevations of I-64 as it

crosses the various branches of France and Bird Swamps were

determined more exactly than before. At the lowest crossing, the

Acli

road is approximately at elevation 40 msl, or five feet above the

proposed Site V pool elevation of 35 feet. This means that vir-

tually any raising of the reservoir to accommodate a pumpover

from the Chickahominy River would also require raising the

interstate. This is not out of the question, but it does mean that

an entirely new NEPA issue would be raised; on which would

require bringing the Federal Highway Administration into the

process as either a joint lead agency or, at least, a cooperating

agency. A higher reservoir at Site V could, combined with an-

other source such as the Chickahominy River, remain a possible

regional alternative, and James City County may pursue such a

project in cooperation with other Peninsula localities, but it

clearly goes beyond the scope of this EIS, especially with the

additional environmental studies which FWS recommends.

2. Pamunkey River: FWS, EPA, and NMFS have, indi-

vidually and separately, recommended against supplying the

lower Peninsula with Pamunkey River water on at least seven

occasions between 1981 and 1987. EPA has even threatened to

refer any such project to the Council on Environmental Quality.

Now, with a permit application from Hanover County to with-

draw water from the Pamunkey River imminent, FWS (and

NMFS) recommend that this source also be reevaluated as an

alternative for the lower Peninsula. I cannot accept this, absent

some rational explanation from all three agencies of how one

Pamunkey River withdrawal can be environmentally unaccept-

able while two withdrawals merit additional study.

3. Groundwater: As explained in paragraphs 2.104 -

2.108 of the FEIS, approximately 10 mgd of potable groundwa-

ter are believed available in the lower Peninsula area. This figure

is corroborated in the State Water Control Board's 1987 James

Water Supply Plan. A greater quantity could jeopardize the ex-

isting resource. This would be a local alternative for James City

County, but would completely eliminate this as a source for the

additional 30 mgd which would still be needed by the rest of the

Ac12

Peninsula by the year 2030.

4. James River: As discussed in paragraphs 2.141 - 2.143

of the FEIS, a pipeline to the James River above Richmond could

add an increment of 13-14 mgd of safe yield to the lower

Peninsula's existing water supply system. This alternative has

been strongly opposed by the City of Richmond, which has ques-

tioned its legality (see paragraph 2.141 of the FEIS). It is also

discussed in more detail elsewhere in this Record of Decision and

in the 404(b) (1) Analysis.

5. Mandatory Use Restrictions: This is discussed in para-

graphs 2.109 - 2.111 of the FEIS, See also paragraph 2.102 under

the No Action alternatives and Subpart B of the 404 (b) (1)

analysis.

6. Expanded Reservoir Configurations: The 3 Dam alter-

native has only 78% of the capacity and 65% of the safe yield of

the Site V alternative, even though the 3 Dam alternative involves

reservoirs with pool elevations 5 - 15 feet higher than the Site V

alternative. Therefore, raising the pool elevations of the 3 Dam

reservoirs could never achieve the capacity of the yield to be had

by raising the Site V reservoir, which is discussed above. The 3

dam alternative as it is presently proposed would require raising

Route 168Y, but the three reservoirs could be raised to higher

elevations without raising I-64. An investigation would have to

be made to see if the three dams could be raised tc the point

where they would have the capacity to constitute a regional al-

ternative with augmentation from the Chickahominy River before

‘his could be considered an engineeringly feasible alternative.

Had this alternative been raised during the scoping process

(1981-1983) instead of the end of 1987, the extensive informa-

tion the FWS's November 24 letter calls for to determine the en-

vironmental impacts on the Chickahominy River of such a pro-

posal might have been obtained by this time. (Even so, FWS staff

indicated at the November 19, 1987 meeting that any impact on

Ac13

the Chickahominy River wetlands downstream of such an intake

would be considered unacceptable by the Service.) It would be

unreasonable and contrary to the intent of NEPA (40 CFR

1500.5) to call a 1-2 year halt to the decision process now while

this information is gathered, especially with no clear indication

that this would be either a feasible or an environmentally prefer-

able alternative to Site V.

By letter dated November 10, 1987, the National Marine Fish-

eries Service (NMFS) commented on the FEIS. This letter was

later submitted under a brief, November 16, 1987 cover letter

from the U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic and

Atmospheric Administration, which did not include any addi-

tional comments. Also, the NMFS submitted additional com-

ments on November 12. The NMFS comments are addressed

below:

COMMENT: Dissolved oxygen in the release water should

have been discussed.

RESPONSE: The State Water Control Board has dissolved

oxygen standards for different classes of waters in Virginia and

commonly imposes these standards within their 401 Water Qual-

ity Certificate. Conditions of 401 Certificates are made a part of

Corps permits. Whatever standard is imposed will have to be met

by the County.

COMMENT: The wetland mitigation plan is not adequate.

Wetlands created within the reservoir would not perform the

same benefits for the downstream estuary as do the existing

wetlands.

RESPONSE: Approximately 49 acres of tidal fres!:water wet-

lands would be inundated by the proposed project. These would

be mitigated by 27 acres of tidal wetlands created iu borrow sites

downstream of the dam. In his November 25, 1987 letter com-

A-14

menting on the FEIS, Dr. Glenn Kinser of the U.S. Fish and

Wildlife Service stated "The Service believes, however, that this

marsh creation, if successful, will adequately compensate for the

loss of estuarine fizh nursery habitat inundated by the reservoir."

A sizeable portion of .he wetlands to be inundated are located

upstream of the existing Richardsons Millpond dam, so their

contribution to the York River and the Chesapeake Bay is pre-

sumably similar to that of the mitigated wetlands which would be

created within the proposed reservoir. The Cranstons Pond miti-

gation would create additional acres of wetlands with a direct

downstream connection in addition to reconnecting several hun-

dred acres of existing wetlands with the Yarmouth Creek estu-

ary. If directly-connected wetlands are, indeed, more valuable

than those located above a dam, I would expect that the func-

tional values of these hundreds of acres would be substantially

increased. The proposal described in the FEIS does not consti-

tute 1:1 mitigation of vegetated wetlands in terms of acreage or

habitat value. As mentioned above, though, NMFS was asked in

November 1987 for specific suggestions for additional wetland

mitigation. To date they have not done so.

COMMENT: The Cranstons Pond mitigation is not considered

to adequately compensated for the potential anadromous fish

habitat lost due to the implementation of Site V. NMFS believes

that future regulations may require dams such as at Cranstons

Pond to have fish passage devices, anyway. Also, downstream

road improvements should be made immediately.

RESPONSE: The anadromous fish recovery plan NMFS men-

tions may or may not become implemented and it may or may not

cover dams, such as Cranstons Pond, which are not presently

used for any purpose subject to a State or Federal permit and are

not located on a navigable water of the United States. It also

probably will not require improvements in downstream road

crossings which may interfere with fish passage. Enforcement of

specific requirements of any such eventual plan are speculative.

Ac15

If made a part of a Corps permit, restoration of this known, his-

toric anadromous stream would be a certainty and would be

enforceable under the Clean Water Act. Improvement of the

Route 632 culverts would also be made a part of any Corps

permit, although it would not have to be done "immediately". The

Fish and Wildlife Service has recommended that the lake be

drained and planted in stages, and that the dam be left in place

until the lake bottom is fully vegetated. I see no reason to require

the culvert work before then. The Service has also stated, in Dr.

Kinser's letter mentioned above, that ". . . we believe that the

Cranston's Pond breaching will provide adequate compensation

for the blockage of potential river herring spawning habitat at

Ware Creek if the culverts under Route 632 downstream of the

dam are replaced with a bridge, bottomless pipe arch, or larger

culverts set at the appropriate invert."

COMMENT: The presence of downstream shellfish should not

be downplayed simply because the grounds are presently con-

demned.

RESPONSE: I do not consider the shellfish in Ware Creek to

be an insignificant resource, but neither do I consider that they

would be adversely affected by this project, except for possible

temporary impacts due to construction-related turbidity.

COMMENT: Alternatives were dismissed because they would

not satisfy the regional need, although the Ware Creek reservoir

is a local project. The future needs should have been based not

just on safe yields of the existing systems, but on water use re-

strictions. Groundwater, local intergovernmental procedures,

and interbasin transfer should have been discussed more. NMFS

recommends a regional approach to the Peninsula's water sup-

ply problems.

RESPONSE: I find it somewhat inconsistent that in the same

paragraph NMFS first criticizes the FEIS for considering regional

A-16

needs instead of James City County's needs, and yet \ater states

"In short, a Regional solution is needed". The Ware: Creek project

must be viewed as the County's attempt to help solve its own

water supply problem which also constitutes a sizeable part of

and contributes to the overall regional water supply deficit. Safe

yield is a term which may be defined in many ways. Regardless,

conservation and mandatory restrictions are discussed in para-

graphs 2.102 and 2.109-2.111 of the FEIS, and in Subpart B of

the 404 (b) (1) analysis. A deficit projection of 35-40 mgd has

been corroborated by the State Water Control Board's 1987

James Water Supply Plan. Groundwater, local intergovernmental

procedures, and interbasin transfer are discussed in the FEIS in

Section 2 as well as in the response to the NMFS comment 3.09

found on page 5-43 of the FEIS.

COMMENT: NMFS does not recognize HEP as being a valid

procedure for evaluating estuarine fish habitat.

RESPONSE: I do not necessarily disagree with NMFS' criti-

cism of HEP, but it was specifically requested by the U.S. Fish

and Wildlife Service and, presumably, is of use to them. NMFS

offered no alternate methodology which it preferred, as required

by 40 CFR 1503.3 (b). With the FWS in advocate of the HEP

methodology, and EPA an advocate of the Adamus methodol-

ogy (which it agreed, but later failed, to perform), and NMFS an

advocate of no methodology, it was impossible to please all three

cooperating agencies.

COMMENT: Aminimum release equal to 30% of the mean an-

nual flow should be required.

RESPONSE: I know of no justification of a 30% mean annual

flow recommendation other than the Tennant Method. I concur

with the Virginia State Water Control Board (October 30, 1987

letter from Mr. C.E. Easlick to Mr. Charles H. Ellis, III of the

Virginia Council on the Environment) that the Tennant Method

Ac17

is not applicable in tidal situations such as this. Absent a techni-

cally supported rationale for this recommendation, I see no rea-

son to require a higher minimum release.

COMMENT: Both groundwater and the James River pipeline

alternatives would provide as much or more water to the County

than the Ware Creek Reservoir alternative and would be environ-

mentally less damaging.

RESPONSE: This is partly true, but ignores many factors. A

James River pipeline would cost approximately three times what

the Ware Creek alternative would and is strongly opposed by

Richmond area municipalities. If any kind of minimum flows are

imposed on such a withdrawal, as are recommended by all envi-

ronmental agenci¢s, the pipeline would have to be hooked into

a storage system (reservoir (s)) in order to store water during

times when flows are less than the permitted minimums. At

present the only such storage system in existence is owned and

operated by the City of Newport News, and if a James River

pipeline were hooked into this network, it would only increase

the system safe yield by an increment of 13-14 mgd at most. As

noted above, this small contribution toward the 2030 regional

need would merely postpone the regional problem by a few years.

If the pipeline were not hooked into the Newport News system,

James City County would either have to build a reservoir of its

own to store the water for use during times of low flow or else

find another source of water during times of low flow. intuitively,

times of low river flow are also usually times when other surface

water systems are being strained and are generally without any

surplus to sell to any other users. Ten mgd of groundwater is all

that is thought to be safely available in the Peninsula area, and this

will undoubtedly be tapped in ile future to help supply Peninsula

localities. Unless polluted or depleted, the ten mgd of groundwa-

ter will remain available and will not cost substantially more to

develop in another ten years than it would now. As residential

development occurs around the Ware Creek watershed, though,

A-18

the proposed reservoir site may not still be realistically available

in another decade.

COMMENT: Other alternatives should be investigated, or inves-

tigated further, including desalination, additional Chickahominy

River withdrawals, changing the operation of Lake Moomaw in

Alleghany and Bath Counties, and a combined withdrawal from the

Pamunkey River for both Hanover County and James City County.

RESPONSE: Desalination is discussed in the FEIS. NMFS

does not give any reason for studying it further or suggest any

new ways in which it should be studied. Additional Chickahominy

River withdrawals and a combined withdrawal from the

Pamunkey River for both Hanover County and James City

County are discussed above. This is the first time anyone has

suggested that changing the operation of Lake Moomaw, near

the West Virginia border, should be investigated as an alterna-

tive for this project. There is nothing to indicate how this alter-

native might work or any evidence that it might be environmen-

tally preferable to Ware Creek.

By letter dated November 12, 1987, the U.S. Department of

Interior, National Park Service commented on the FEIS. The

Park Service's comments are addressed below:

COMMENT: A portion of Ware Creek is currently listed on the

Nationwide Rivers Inventory. The proposed project would pre-

clude further consideration of Ware Creek as a potential segment

of the National Wild and Scenic Rivers System.

RESPONSE: The portion of Ware Creek currently listed on the

Inventory is "from confluence with York River to Richardson

Mill Pond". The minimum length of a waterway necessary for

continued listing, according to the Park Service, is five miles.

Between 5.1 and 5.2 miles of Ware Creek would be left intact if

A-19

the proposed project were constructed. In their letter, though, the

Park Service notes that the dam "would fall within the 1/4 mile

corridor of the river, and would have a substantial impact on the

undeveloped quality of the stream." There is no explanation as

to why the existing portion of Ware Creek listed on the Inven-

tory does not stop 1/4 mile short of the base of the Richardson

Mill Pond dam, itself a manmade structure impacting the unde-

veloped quality of the stream. Although the Service notes that the

project would affect the scenic quality of the corridor, would

reduce freshwater flows, would alter vegetational patterns,

would "eliminate" anadromous fish habitat, and would have

wetland mitigation areas located within the corridor, I note that

under that category of "Outstandingly Remarkable Values" on

the Inventory list, Ware Creek is not marked under any of the

columns, which are titled Scenic, Recreation, Geologic, Fish,

Wildlife, Historic, Cultural, and Other. Both Ware Creek and the

Poropotank River are included on the Inventory as tributaries to

a stretch of the York River, which is checked under the "Other"

column as "Hydrologic (An extremely unique segment of a

sparsely developed high order tidal river.)" I do not know of any

reason why the five mile segment of Ware Creek downstream of

the proposed dam would not continue to be, and contribute to

this segment of the York River's being, a sparsely developed high

order tidal river. Nevertheless, it is up to the Park Service and not

the Corps to make this determination and there is no requirement

for them to explain their rationale to me. There are 87 waterways

and segments of waterways in Virginia listed on the Inventory

which has existed in final form since 1981. None of these has been

promoted to Wild or Scenic River status. Construction of this

project may, for technical reasons, remove Ware Creek from

further consideration as a Wild or Scenic River, but it will not,

in my opinion, (supported by the Final EIS) significantly dimin-

ish its status as a very attractive, sparsely developed tidal estu-

ary with high values for fish and wildlife habitat. In its August 10,

1980 "Memorandum For Heads of Agencies", the Council on En-

vironmental Quality state that "Where agency action could effec-

A-20

tively foreclose the designation of a wild, scenic, or recreational

river segment, the President has directed the agency to consult

with HCRS" (now the National Park Service), but the Memoran-

dum went on to note that the President's directive does not pro-

hibit such action after the consultation and after "studying, de-

veloping and describing all reasonable alternatives". My staff has

mét with and corresponded with the National Park Service about

this project on several occasions going back to 1983. Alternatives

to the project which would not conflict with Ware Creek's Inven-

tory status have been extensively investigated in the Draft and

Final EIS's and have found to be unreasonable.

COMMENT: The project's most severe impact would be due to

the diminished freshwater flows, causing significant impacts on

the existing tidal freshwater wetlands.

RESPONSE: I do not agree that this is necessarily the most

severe impact, however this will occur. There will be no loss in

wetland acreage due to diminished freshwater flows, though, and

there is no reason to believe that the assemblage of wetland plant

species which will replace the existing species will be any less

valuable.

COMMENT: Mitigativn of anadromous fish habitat in the

Yarmouth Creek watershed (Cranstons Pond) will not make up

for the loss of such habitat in Ware Creek as far as listing on the

Nationwide Rivers Inventory, even though both Ware Creek and

Yarmouth Creek are listed on the Inventory and the mitigation

may allow for future expansion of the Yarmouth Creek Nation-

wide Rivers Inventory segment.

RESPONSE: This is the Park Service's interpretation of Coun-

cil of Environmental Quality guidelines. Since the Park Service

manages the Inventory, it is up to them to make such determina-

tions. I find this to be a rather narrow interpretation, though,

especially given that Ware Creek is only potential habitat for

Ac21

anadromous fish while Yarmouth Creek is a known anadromous

fish stream. This is also inconsistent with an earlier recommen-

dation from the Park Service that "the Corps develop a method

to permanently conserve another stream or river reach similar in

quality and size to the Ware to compensate for the adverse effects

of the project" (July 29, 1983 letter from J. Glenn Eugster (NPS)

to Karen Mayne (FWS)). As a factor in my public interest review,

I believe that this mitigation for anadromous fish habitat will more

than make up for the potential loss.

COMMENT: There is insufficient information in the FEIS for

the Park Service to determine whether the 3 dam alternative

would foreclose further consideration of Ware Creek as a poten-

tial National Wild and Scenic River.

RESPONSE: As noted in the FEIS on pages 5-35 and 5-36, the

Park Service indicated in 1986 that the 3 dam alternative would

cause the delisting of Ware Creek, and in June 1987 they indi-

cated that the 3 dam alternative would not cause delisting. In this

(November 12, 1987) letter the Park Service indicates that they

do not have enough information to make a determination, so I am

uncertain of the Park Service's position on this alternative. Such

vacillation on the part of a Federal commenting agency is very

frustrating. If the Park Service needed more information, they

had several opportunities to ask for it and did not.

By letter dated November 30, 1987, the Commonwealth of

Virginia, acting through the Virginia Council on the Environment

commented on the FEIS. The Council's comments are addressed

below:

COMMENT: The mitigation plan does not completely make up

for the loss of wetlands and the large net wetland loss would,

therefore, work against Virginia's Chesapeake Bay restoration

efforts.

Ac22

RESPONSE: Refer to responses to EPA and NMFS comments

(above) on mitigation. These wetlands perform many functions

and the simple comparison of existing wetland acreage with post-

project wetland acreage overlooks some important factors. The

existing wetlands will not be replaced with shopping centers or

housing developments; the reservoir itself will create over 1200

acres of new fish and wildlife habitat. As the HEP analysis shows,

some existing species will gain habitat from reservoir construc-

tion while other species will lose habitat. In terms of water qual-

ity, the reservoir will act as a very efficient sediment and nutri-

ent trap, similar to that function presently performed by the ex-

isting wetlands. True, the reservoir will also trap most of the

detritus produced by the wetlands created within and upstream

of the reservoir, but those wetlands which currently exist up-

stream of Richardsons Millpond are already cut off from this

detrital contribution. The creation of the new wetlands down-

stream and the breaching of Cranstons Pond will also create

additional detrital contributions. The Cranstons Pond mitigation

will not directly benefit the York River estuary, but both the York

and the James flow into the Chesapeake Bay, so the Bay would

still receive this benefit. If the Commonwealth is convinced that

the project would seriously hinder its ongoing efforts to restore

the water quality of the Chesapeake Bay, it can act through the

State Water Control Board to deny the required 401 Water

Quality Certificate. I do not feel, though, that this project would

be inimical to the goal of restoring a cleaner Chesapeake Bay, for

the reasons stated above.

COMMENT: This project is preferable to the 3 dam alternative,

groundwater, and desalinization in terms of meeting the County's

future water needs.

RESPONSE: Concur.

COMMENT: The project's effects on downstream oyster beds

have been adequately addressed and mitigated.

Ac23

RESPONSE: Concur.

COMMENT: The permit decision should be postponed to al-

low for discussions of interjurisdictional sharing of the project

benefits, more regional wetland mitigation, combination of this

project with other water sources, acquisition of wetland areas for

future protection, and expansion of such recreational opportu-

nities as pedestrian trails.

COMMENT: On March 30, 1987, my predecessor, Colonel

Claude D. Boyd, met with Virginia Secretary of Natural Re-

sources John Daniel and EPA Region III Administrator James

Seif to discuss Virginia's role in regional water supply planning

and development. At that meeting, Secretary Daniel explained

that the State could not take a more active role without direction

and approval by the General Assembly, which has not been forth-

coming. A meeting was held at Norfolk District on November 19,

1987 with the Corps, FWS, EPA, and NMFS to discuss regional

alternatives. I agreed to withhold my decision pending investiga-

tions which I required of James City County into raising of the

normal pool elevation of the reservoir. There was no agreement

among the agencies involved in this November meeting as to

what other additional study was needed or desirable. In the in-

terim, James City County has approached the City of Newport

News about the possibility of an interconnection between this

project and the rest of the existing Newport News water system.

Combining this project with other sources of water remains a

possibility, but it is unreasonable to withhold a decision further

while the extensive informational requirements are met (see, for

instance, the additional information the FWS indicates in its

November 25, 1987 letter would be necessary). I believe that the

reservoir as it is described in the Final EIS will provide recre-

ational opportunities greatly in excess of what is currently avail-

able. Additional items such as pedestrian trails should be dis-

cussed between the County and the State.

A-24

By letter dated December 7, 1987, the Virginia Department of

Game and Inland Fisheries commented on the FEIS. The Depart-

ment notes that it supports the comments contained in the No-

vember 30, 1987 letter from the Virginia Council on the Environ-

ment; finding the environmental impacts of the project unaccept-

abie, asking that a permit be withheld until a regional solution can

be reached, and recommending 1:1 replacement of habitat. I ac-

knowledge the Department's comments, but for the reasons I

have given in my responses to the Council's letter and others, I

cannot concur.

By letter dated November 9, 1987, the Virginia Department of

Transportation comm :nted on the FEIS. The Department indi-

cated that not all of its previous concerns have been completely

addressed and informed me that all work affecting roads and

highways must be coordinated with and approved by the Depart-

ment and/or the Federal Highway Administration. I acknowledge

the Department's comments and I am willing to include this

coordination and approval as a condition of a Corps permit.

By letter dated November 21, 1987, the Chesapeake Bay Foun-

dation commented on the FEIS and included several objections

to the proposed project. Many of their comments were similar or

identical to those of EPA, FWS, and/or NMFS, which are ad-

dressed above. Those which are original or require an additional

response are discussed below.

COMMENT: The Foundation commented on the Draft EIS

that additional discussion should be given to groundwater and

reverse osmosis, but they find the treatment given in the Final EIS

is still inadequate.

RESPONSE: This is why it is so important for comments on a

Draft EIS to be specific. The final EIS did, indeed, expand the

Ac25

discussions of these two alternatives. I find the fact that the

Foundation is still not satisfied to be a reflection of the general-

ized nature of the original comments (page 5-65 of the FEIS).

COMMENT: Combinations of several of the alternatives which

were considered individually should have been investigated.

RESPONSE: Certain combinations were analyzed in the FEIS.

Consideration of every conceivable permutation and combination

of the individual alternatives would be an unreasonable and,

perhaps, impossible task.

COMMENT: There is no mention of wetland acreage currently

surrounding Cranstons Pond which would be lost due to its

breaching.

RESPONSE: There exist only small, isolated pockets of wet-

lands around the perimeter of the Pond, due to its stee,» sides.

Virtually all of the wetlands upstream of the dam to be breached

are upstream of the Pond and would not be adversely affected.

COMMENT: The downstream mitigation areas will become

brackish marshes; not freshwater marshes.

RESPONSE: Concur, assuming the VIMS modelling effort is

accurate. There is no evidence that such areas have lower func-

tional values.

«° MMENT: Ifthe accumulated sediment will be periodically

removed from the headwater impoundments, they will lose much

of their habitat value.

RESPONSE: Vehicular access to these areas several years af-

ter reservoir construction will be excremely difficult or impos-

sible. For this reason, the HEP analysis assumed that these areas

would eventually fill with sediment (over the 50 year planning

A-26

period) but would remain wetlands because of continued upland

drainage and saturated soils.

By letter dated November 23, 1987, the Southern Environmental

Law Center commented on the FEIS. Some of their comments were

similar to those of EPA, FWS, NMFS, and/or the Chesapeake Bay

Foundation, which are addressed above. Those which are original

or require an additional response are discussed below.

COMMENT: The project would significantly degrade the wa-

ters of the United States and, therefore, would be contrary to the

404 (b) (1) Guidelines.

RESPONSE: As explained in my 404 (b) (1) analysis, this

project, with the proposed mitigation complies with these Guide-

lines. I recognize, as indicated by the Center, that FWS has clas-

sified these wetlands as Resource Category I, but this has noth-

ing to do with the Guidelines. Notwithstanding the FWS mitiga-

tion policy, my 404 (b) (1) analysis shows that this project would

adequately mitigate for the lost functional values of these wet-

lands so as not to cause a significant degradation of the waters

of the United States. As discussed in the responses to the Na-

tional Park Service comments, above, the loss of Nationwide

Rivers Inveniory status for Ware Creek (for largely technical

reasons) would not significantly diminish the values which led to

that status.

COMMENT: The 3 dam alternative would be less damaging

and must, therefore, be selected over the Site V alternative.

RESPONSE: The 404 (b) (1) Guidelines (which the Center

references as requiring a less damaging alternative to be selected)

specify that such an alternative be both less damaging as well as

practicable. As stated above, the ratio of the 3 dam's yield to the

acres of wetland flooded is identical to the ratio for the Site V al-

A-27

eS ee eee a

peel tine deer ae

SE RN AST eS ae oe aa

ternative, so as far as wetlands are concerned, the 3 dam alterna-

tive is not less damaging unless the difference in yield can be made

up with another less damaging unless the difference in yield can

be made up with another less damaging alternative. Simply mak-

ing up the difference in yields between these two alternatives with

an increment of groundwater does not make for a realistic com-

parison, considering the remainder of the unmet 2030 regional

need (and it is the regional need that the Center agrees must be

considered). Site V, all safely available groundwater, as well as

an additional 20 mgd source would be needed to meet that re-

gional need. All other alternatives to make up this 20 mgd short-

fall have been shown to be either not practicable or more dam-

aging than Site V. Unless a practicable, acceptable regional al-

ternative or combination of alternatives can be identified to sat-

isfy the entire 40 mgd deficit, it must be assumed that the incre-

ment of additional safe yield necessary to make up the difference

between the 3 dam yield and the Site V yield would have to come

from a source which would be more damaging than Site V.

On November 24 and 25, 1987, James City County submitted its

comments on the FEIS and its views concerning the comments

of the projects opponents. Attached to these submittals were a

groundwater assessment prepared by a consultant to the County,

a feasibility study of reverse osmosis prepared by another con-

sultant to the County, and an update of the county's latest Mas-

ter Water Plan. For the most part I concur with the County's

comments and they are reflective of several of my own, as out-

lined above. For that reason I do not intend to repeat them here.

I find that the County's submittals concerning groundwater and

reverse Osmosis tend to support my own independent findings

that these are not feasible alternatives to the County. I did not

verify them, though, since I did not rely on them in reaching my

own findings. In its comments, the County contends that its

mitigation plan provided 1:1 mitigation for wetland acreage and

functional values which would be lost. For reasons explained in

A-28

my FEIS and elsewhere in this Record, I do not believe that all

of this mitigation will be successful and I did not count on it in

my evaluation. This is a judgement which cannot be verified for

several years, and if the County is correct in its contentions, so

much the better.

Other letters supporting the Site V reservoir project were re-

ceived from several cities (Hampton, Newport News, Norfolk,

Poquoson, Richmond, Suffolk, and Williamsburg), counties

(Charles City, Chesterfield, Gloucester, Hanover, Henrico, King

William, and New Kent), elected officials (State Senator William

E. Fears, Delegate George W. Grayson), organizations

(Appomattox River Water Authority, Hampton Roads Sanitation

District, Hampton Roads Water Quality Agency, James City

Ruritan Club, James River Basin Association, Peninsula Planning

District Commission, Richmond Regional Planning District

Commission, Virginia Peninsula Economic Development Coun-

cil, and Williamsburg Chamber of Commerce), and individuals

and corporations (Royal E. Bowyer, Delmarva Properties, Incor-

porated). Most consisted only of statements of support, and the

remainder either supported my responses to certain of the ad-

verse comments addressed above, or pointed out errors or inac-

curacies in the FEIS of a technical or editorial nature which do

not affect the permit decision. I accept these comments as evi-

dence of considerable public support from not only the areas

which would directly benefit directly from the project, but also

from other municipalities and organizations which have experi-

ence and technical expertise in dealing with water supply issues.

11 July 88 4s/ J. J. Thomas

Date J. J. Thomas

Colonel, U.S. Army

District Engineer

Ac29

APPENDIX B

UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS

JULY 11, 1988

This analysis is made pursuant to the 404 (b) (1) Guidelines (40

CFR 230) as printed in the Wednesday, December 24, 1980

Federal Register.

teristics of the Aquatic Ecosystem: The project would convert

approximately 1217 acres of wetlands, upland forest, and exist-

ing lake habitat into a water supply reservoir. Current patterns

will change and result in the reservoir trapping more sediment and

probably more nutrients than the current system. This will dimin-

ish downstream turbidity somewhat, although the existing wet-

land system normally does a good job of sediment trapping also.

The downstream sections of Ware Creek will become more sa-

line on average, although the range of extremes will not be

changed. The reservoir will probably be upper mesotrophic-to-

eutrophic. The existing benthic community will change and that

part of the reservoir bottom below the photic zone will not sup-

port vegetation. Periodic water level fluctuations within the res-

ervoir will expose some denuded slopes. Existing water levels

fluctuate seasonally (in nontidal areas) and daily (in tidal areas).

The total aerial extent of the Ware Creek aquatic ecosystem will

increase by almost 800 acres.

Acuatic Retain: No desancnd or codanaeael species will rat

adversely affected by this project. Finfish habitat will be greatly

expanded and improved (freshwater fish, represented in the U.S.

Fish and Wildlife Service's Habitat Evaluation Procedures (HEP)

Bl

analysis by largemouth bass, would have their habitat increased

by 900 average annual habitat units (AAHU's), while estuarine

fish, represented by juvenile spot, would have their habitat re-

duced by less than one average annual habitat unit). The degree

of eutrophication expected would not have an adverse effect on

fish habitat within the lake, based on other water supply reser-

voirs in the area. Of other wildlife associated with aquatic eco-

systems, the HEP analysis predicted the following: pileated

woodpecker habitat increased by 142 AAHU's, grey squirrel

habitat decreased by 81 AAHU's, American woodcock habitat

decreased by 1141 AAHU's, beaver habitat increased by 316

AAHU's, wood duck habitat decreased by 150 AAHU's, yellow

warbler habitat increased by 3 AAHU's, and red-winged black-

bird habitat decreased by 39 AAHU's. The entire HEP is found

in Appendix A of the Final EIS and is ciiscussed in Section 4 of

that document. Downstream wetland vegetation will experience

a change in species composition, due to higher average salinities.

This is also discussed in Section 4 of the FEIS. Shellfish were not

included in the HEP analysis, but there will be no expected ad-

verse impact on shellfish downstream in Ware Creek except for

possible increased turbidity during construction. The lower parts

of Ware Creek and the adjacent York River are turbid, and the

shellfish which inhabit these areas are presumably adapted to

these conditions.

: i : The

project would flood 381 acres of vegetated wetlands and up to

44 acres of vegetated shallows (the percentage of the shallows

actually vegetated with rooted aquatic vegetation was never

measured). Some of this acreage will be mitigated (see Subpart

H, beiorv). The contribution of these special aquatic sites will for

the most part be lost to the downstream environment with regard

to detrital production and wildlife habitat, although the wetlands

and vegetated shallows upstream of the existing Richardson

Millpond dam are already sequestered in this way. The water

quality functio «s of these special aquatic sites, in terms of sedi-

B-2

ment trapping and nutrient retention, will continue to be per-

formed by the proposed reservoir. The erosion protection pro-

vided by the wetlands will be mostly lost, although sediment will

be trapped within the reservoir, as noted above. Flood protection

is not a significant function in this case, since flooding in this area

is almost entirely tidal flooding, and downstream development is

sparse. Bre2ching the dam at Cranstons Pond will recreate the

direct detrital input connection of the hundreds of acres of wet-

lands currently upstream of that dam, but this will benefit the

Yarmouth/James system and not the Ware/York system.

iba will ll provide a safe yield of 9. 43 million raises per ibdhay

(mgd), which will meet practically all of the County's projected

2030 water supply deficit of 10.6 mgd, and will represent ap-

proximately 1/4 of the region's 2030 deficit of 40 mgd. Water-

related recreation2! opportunities will be enhanced. The reservoir

will be surrounded by a buffer strip in which development would

not be allowed. The aesthetic impact of the reservoir relative to

the existing conditions will vary from individual to individual,

although the number of people visiting the reservoir will probably

greatly exceed the number who visit the existing site. Ware Creek

is presently listed on the Nationwide Rivers Inventory, meaning

that it is a potential candidate for inclusion in the National Wild

and Scenic Rivers System. According to the National Park Ser-

vice, this project would have the effect of removing Ware Creek

from further consideration. Rivers on the Nationwide Rivers

Inventory, of which there are approximately 90 in Virginia, have

no legal status or protection until and unless they become listed

as part of the National Wild and Scenic Rivers System. To date

none of the Inventory waterways in Virginia has ever been el-

evated to the System. There are currently no ongoing efforts to

raise Ware Creek from the Inventory to the System. The

President's directive on Nationwide Inventory waterways does

not prohibit actions which would cause a waterway to be delisted,

provided the action agency has gone through consultation with

B3

the National Park Service and after "studying, developing and

describing all reasonable alternatives". Both have been done in

this case.

Subpart G: Evaluation and Testing: The discharge material will

consist of native material or material which will be chemically and

ph > lly i t ( . )). No t ti is . i j tl . t

3 inimi tse Effects: Many alterna-

tives to this et were cuainenedl in the FEIS, including alter-

native dam configurations within the Ware Creek watershed,

several site alternatives outside the watershed, alternatives in-

volving nonreservoir and nonsurface sources of water, and tech-

nologically innovative alternatives. A guaranteed minimum fresh-

water release will help minimize downstream effects. Preserva-

tion of a buffer strip around the reservoir and adoption of restric-

tive zoning within the watershed will help to minimize adverse

water quality effects of future human development within the

watershed. Breaching the Cranstons Pond dam will mitigate any

adverse effects this project may have on anadromous fish. The

Cranstons Pond will also reestablish a direct connection of hun-

dreds of acres of upstream wetlands to the downstream estuary

as well as create new wetlands in the bottom of that existing

pond. Wetland mitigation within the Ware Creek watershed will

occur both within and downstream of the reservoir by grading

upland areas, constructing small checkdams, and planting areas

with wetland species. The wetland mitigation will not recreate an

equivalent acreage to that lost by flooding the reservoir, however.

Additional minimizing and mitigating measures are described in

Sections 2 and 4 of the FEIS.

Subpart B: Compliance With the Guidelines: Viewed narrowly,

as a reservoir, this project would have to be considered water

dependent. Since the basic purpose is to provide water to the

citizens of James City County, though, and since at least some of

the water currently utilized comes from groundwater, water

supply in general is not dependent on a discharge into waters of

the United States. The "rebuttable presumption" that other alter-

natives exist which do not involve discharges into waters of the

United States has been completely satisfied, though. In every

case, there has been a clear and explicit showing in the FEIS or

the Record of Decision that all other alternatives are either not

practicable or are more environmentally harmful than the pro-

posed discharge/project. Since this project has significant impli-

cations both locally and regionally, both local and regional alter-

natives were investigated in the FEIS. Additionally, in 1984 the

Norfolk District completed an extensive Congressionally-man-

dated study of regional alternatives (Water Supply Study Hamp-

ton Roads Virginia) and in 1987 the Commonwealth of Virginia

completed its own comprehensive study of statewide water sup-

plies and needs, including the James Water Supply Play which

covered the James City County/Peninsula area. It is noteworthy

that the water supply problems in this area have been studied so

extensively and independently at the Local, State, and Federal

levels. Both the FEIS and the Water Supply Study were exten-

sively coordinated with Federal advisory agencies, including the

Environmental Protection Agency, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife

Service, and the National Marine Fisheries Service. The Water

Supply Study determined the 2030 regional deficit as being 40

mgd and, of the three principal regional alternatives given de-

tailed reviews, only the James River pipeline alternative was rated

by the aforementioned Federal agencies as being environmentally

acceptable. However, at the minimum instream flows specified

by these agencies, the yield of this alternative would be reduced

from 40 mgd to 11 mgd, rendering it a non-practicable regional

alternative. The James Water Supply Plan substantiated a re-

gional 2030 deficit projection of 40 mgd (35 mgd with conser-

vation) and identified a similar range of regional alternatives as

the Water Supply Study, but included a 10 mgd increment of

groundwater; the maximum considered safe to avoid significant

degradation of regional groundwater supplies. Since the James

River pipeline alternative could not supply a 30 mgd increment

B5

(under the recommended minimum instream flows), this would

still be a non-practicable regional alternative. These alternatives

were also analyzed in this FEIS, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife

Service recommended a higher set of minimum instream flows for

the James River pipeline alternative, which would raise the safe

yield of this alternative from 11 to 13-14 mgd, but the National

Marine Fisheries Service is still on record as advocating a higher

minimum flow. Even 13-14 mgd is not sufficient to constitute a

practicable regional alternative. No agency, organization, or

individual has ever provided the Corps with any evidence that any

regional alternative(s) would be both practicable and environ-

mentally less damaging than the proposed project. The County

has recently contacted the City of Newport News and offered to

connect the Site V reservoir to a Newport News existing raw

water pipeline which runs nearby. Connecting the Site V reser-

voir to the overall Peninsula water supply system could have a

synergistic, as opposed to additive, effect on the regional safe

yield, since it could allow water throughout the system to be

stored and utilized in a more efficient manner than having mul-

tiple reservoirs operating independently.

With regard to local alternatives, many were discussed in the

Draft and Final EIS's, including reservoirs in other basins in James

City County, other reservoir locations and configurations within

the Ware Creek basin, limiting growth, groundwater, conserva-

tion, purchase from other raw or treated water suppliers, desalin-

ization, and wastewater reuse. The James River pipeline alterna-

tive mentioned above could provide sufficient water so as to

constitute a local alternative if the County could arrange to uti-

lize Newport News’ system of reservoirs to store the water from

the pipeline for use during times of low river flows (an arrange-

ment which, without Newport News' assistance and approval,

would be impossible to achieve). In response to this FEIS the City

sion strongly opposed the pipeline alternative. In addition to

stating that the FWS's analysis of this alternative (Appendix D of

B6

the FEIS) significantly underestimated both the project's costs

and Richmond's water demands, and overlooked Richmond's

legal rights to 645 cfs of river flow as a separate item when fig-

uring minimum flow requirements, the City and the Commission

maintain that diverting James River water from above Richmond

to the Peninsula would be an illegal interbasin transfer. Construc-

tion costs would be 3-4 times greater than the Ware Creek alter-

native and James City County would have to obtain agreements

from the other political jurisdictions along the pipeline route.

Even if the potentially significant legal barriers to this alternative

are disregarded, the need for a complex contractual arrangement

with Newport News, the strength of Richmond-area opposition,

and the extra cost combine to make this an impracticable local

alternative, although it has possible technical feasibility. Of the

other out-of-basin reservoir sites, all would either involve signifi-

cant adverse environmental impacts or are much too small to

supply the water needed to fulfill the basic project need. The FEIS

cites case law (see page 2-36) restricting a municipality's ability

to limit growth by limiting water hookups. Virginia is one of a

number of states which adhere to a legal interpretation known as

the Dillion Rule, which means, in essence, that the power to enact

laws and ordinances must be expressly granted or implied by

statute (See County Board v. Brown, 229 Va. 341, 329 S.E. 2d

468 (1985); Tabler v. Fairfax County, 221 Va. 200, 269 S.E. 2d

358 (1980). Municipalities cannot, therefore, adopt and enforce

local ordinances not already provided for by state law. James City

County has adopted a watershed protective zoning ordinance to

control the type of growth, but such zoning is allowed by stat-

ute or charter. Further restrictions on growth within the County

must be within the constraints of the Diilion Rule. Limiting

growth, then, is not a practicable alternative because it is not

available to the applicant. Also, given the population projections

for the entire region, it is likely that if growth could be limited in

James City County it would merely be shifted (along with the

problem) to adjacent counties or cities. Groundwater is an alter-

native to this project in that it is estimated that its safe yield can

B7

be increased by approximately 10 mgd (compared to this project's

yield of 9.4 mgd). If the County existed in a vacuum, groundwa-

ter would be considered to be an environmentally preferable

alternative. However, since it has been well documented that the

region will require an additional 35-40 mgd by the year 2030, for

James City County to utilize ail of the safely available remaining

groundwater resources would simply foist the problem onto the

other Peninsula localities. As stated in the FEIS, if Ware Creek

is considered environmentally unacceptable as a reservoir site,

there is no other site on the Peninsula which could be considered

acceptable (based on comments from EPA, FWS, and NMFS

received over the last decade). It appears likely that both Ware

Creek and groundwater will be needed to meet the region's needs,

as well as another 15-20 mgd source or sources. Groundwater

might be considered a practicable alternative to this project in a

shortsighted sense only; it could not be considered a prudent al-

ternative or one which would be less environmentally damaging

in the long term. Conservation has been estimated in the James

Water Supply Plan (defined as "conservation oriented plumbing

codes, leak detection, and educational programs") to reduce the

region's 2030 demand from 40 to 35 mgd and James City

County's 2030 demand from 16.86 to 16.49 mgd. (Note that the

State's independent projections are different from, but quite close

to James City County's 2030 publicly supplied demand estimate

of 18.6 mgd). In the James Water Supply Plan, Virginia's conser-

vation policy regarding further water restrictions is stated as:

"[R ]estrictions in water use and rationing should not be made part

of a regular conservation program. These measures, which are

usually implemented during emergencies, should be used as

contingent measures in order to provide some reliability during

drought. In other words, water supply planning should leave

room for further reduction during emergency cases." Conserva-

tion cannot be considered a practicable alternative because it will

not satisfy the basic project purpose of providing for the future

water deficit. Obviously, since the entire region will experience

a water deficit, it would not be practicable to purchase the addi-

BS

tional water the County will need from another Peninsula local-

ity. Wastewater reuse, as discussed in the FEIS, is so strongly

opposed by the Virginia State Health Department as being unsafe

that it cannot be considered a practicable alternative. Desaliniza-

tion was considered as a regional and a local alternative in the

FEIS, the Water Supply Study, and the James Water Supply Pian.

While the technology of desalinization has been proven in other

areas of the country, particularly Florida, no large-scale test has

ever been performed in Virginia. (The City of Suffolk is complet-

ing testing of a small-scale electrodialysis reversal (EDR) desalin-

ization plant under an experimental authorization from the State.)

Commenting on a 1986 reverse osmosis (RO) study prepared by

EPA for Gloucester County, Virginia, the Virginia State Depart-

ment of Health found "The report is clearly neither independent

nor unbiased", "The wide range of uncertainties associated with

the RO proposals are all but ignored", and "Along these lines we

would suggest that insufficient data is currently available to rec-

ommend any further consideration of RO at this time." (Decem-

ber 4, 1986 letter from Eric H. Bartsch, P.E., Director of Water

Programs, Depzttment of Health to Charles Ellis, Virginia Coun-

cilon the Environment). In a November 26, 1986 letter from Ri-

chard N. Burton, Executive Director of the Virginia Water Con-

trol Board to Richard V. Pepino EPA Region III, commenting

on the same report, Mr. Burton states "In your report (ES-9), the

EPA indicates a number of actions that must be undertaken by the

State. Except for setting NPDES effluent limitations, the State

does not have the authority to undertake these actions and I am

not aware of any federal regulations which require them." An

attached staff analysis states "We believe that EPA at the outset

is objecting to this particular prospective reservoir, and upon that

premise starts with unproven assertions which are later "justified"

by reference to the assertion. They then compound the error by

requiring the VWCB to prove them wrong with costly studies

and work." Since the two State regulatory agencies which would

be charged with permitting any such project find so many prob-

lems with anything but a small, experimental desalinization

B-9

project, desalinization cannot be considered to be an alternative

presently available to the applicant. Extrapolating from costs

contained in the aforementioned EPA RO study, such a system

to provide an amount of potable water equivalent to the Ware

Creek reservoir would cost 1.5-3 times as much in construction

costs and approximately twice as much in operating costs as the

proposed reservoir. (Figures derived from pages 2-12, 2-45, and

2-46 of FEIS.) Also, as noted in the FEIS, important questions

remain unanswered concerning the environmental effects of brine

disposal and large withdrawals of brackish groundwater. These

factors combine to indicate that desalinization is not a practicable

alternative to the Ware Creek project at this time. The only other

alternative suggested is the 3 dam alternative. This would pro-

vide only 65% of the safe yield of the proposed reservoir and

would incur 65% of the wetland and vegetated shallows impacts.

The ratio of impacts to special aquatic sites is identical to the ratio

of the safe yields and this alternative would leave the County and

the region with another 3.3 mgd to make up somewhere. Years

of intensive study by the Peninsula localities, the State of Virginia,

and the Federal Government have not identified a regional alter-

native (or combination of alternatives) which would be practi-

cable and environmentally less damaging than Ware Creek, so it

must be assumed that the additional 3.3 mgd needed to make up

the difference in yields between the 3 dam alternative and the Site

V alternative would come from 4 source with greater adverse

impacts than Site V. Therefore, the 3 dam alternative cannot be

considered less environmentally harmful than the proposed

project when seen from anything but a shortsighted view.

There is no evidence whatever that this project would: (1) cause

or contribute to violations of any State water quality standards

(a 401 Water Quality Certificate must be issued or waived by the

Virginia State Water Control Board), (2) violate any toxic efflu-

ent standard, (3) jeopardize any threatened or endangered spe-

cies, or (4) affect any marine sanctuaries. With the extensive

mitigation proposed, including avoidance (a rigorous analysis of

B-10

<M

a

1) Saher

Seater seerien: GAR ANTE SC ao Gc ate ioe ete eee ;

5 LET g Pete a ¢ . Ne P ink ae - is p> -

ee eS AER De eee PN TCS TIE ESE ek me ee pee

srnemeceie teat

Ss FAY baer

Kah ail Reales SiN Le tae a ts obit aia ea teh) ate

ee Ae Ba ee ee as

a sf Minds Pe eames

eS a eek tah Sg

alternatives), measures to minimize impacts (watershed protec-

tive zoning, minimum flow release, and maintenance of a buffer

strip), and compensation (wetland creation, restoration of an

anadromous fisixery, and recreation of a direct connection of

hundreds of acres of wetlands on the Cranstons Pond watershed

to the downstream estuary), the project should not cause or

contribute to a significant degradation of the waters of the United

States. It should be noted here that the project would create 1217

acres of waters of the United States where only 425 acres pres-

ently exist, and would result in a net loss of less than 50 average

annual habitat units of fish and wildlife habitat (see Figure 4-5 of

the FEIS). The net loss of special aquatic site (wetland) acreage

must be weighed against the wetland functional values which

would be created by the project (fish and wildlife habitat, sedi-

ment and nutrient trapping, desynchronization of flooding, and

improvement of the detrital contribution of the hundreds of acres

of isolated wetlands presently upstream of Cranston's Pond).

James City County is currently pursuing negotiations with EPA

Region III, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and the Virginia

Department of Game and Inland Fisheries to commit up to

$600,000 toward additional wetland creation and preservation.

These negotiations are going on outside the Corps permit pro-

cess and may or may not achieve results.

Based on the information contained in this document, the FEIS,

and my Record of Decision, I find that there are no practicable

alternatives to this project which are less environmentally dam-

aging than the proposed project. I find that the gross adverse

environmental impacts of the project are substantial, but miti-

gated to the extent that they are acceptable. (If the aforemen-

tioned mitigation negotiations between the County and the other

environmental agencies are fruitful, such mitigation could be

made a condition of a Corps permit (at the request of the

County), but based on this 404(b) (1) analysis and my Record of

Decision, I believe that the currently proposed mitigation is ac-

ceptable and adequate to prevent a significant degradation of the

B-11

waters of the United States.) There is no evidence, and there are

no substantiated statements, to indicate that this project would

cause any adverse cumulative impact on the Chesapeake Bay. I

find that the project would have a very beneficial impact on

municipal water supplies, a very beneficial impact on both lake

and anadromous fish habitat, a positive impact on recreational

opportunities, and no significant or long term impact on shellfish

beds. The project would have a mixed impact on wildlife asso-

ciated with aquatic ecosystems (three out of seven evaluation

species benefiting from the project). I find that, with the impo-

sition of the minimizing and compensation measures outlined

above, this project complies with these Guidelines.

11 July 88 G/ J.J. Thomas

Date J. J. Thomas

Colonel, U.S. Army

District Engineer

B-12

Sas BR ire re Seg oe EN YE eT Eee Oe ae ae ee et eee

APPENDIX C

COMMONWEALTH of VIRGINIA

STATE WATER CONTROL BOARD

2111 Hamilton Street

CERTIFICATION NO. 84-0614

401 CERTIFICATION ISSUED TO

James City County

101 Mounts Bay Road

Williamsburg, Virginia 23185

PURSUANT TO SECTION 401 OF THE

CLEAN WATER ACT (33USC SECTION 1341)

The State Water Control Board hereby certifies, subject to the

special conditions listed herein, that the proposed construction

of James City County's water suppiv reservoir on Ware Creek in

James City County, Virginia, as specified in the application sub-

mitted to the Board on June 14, 1984, and updated information

on July 28, 1988, and other correspondence or communications

supplied to the Board by the applicant, will comply with (1) the

Virginia Water Quality Standards which became effective on July

20, 1970 and which are, as amended, in full force and effect under

Section 303(a) of Public Law 95-217; (2) other applicable limi-

tations, standards, regulations, and requirements in accordance

with the State Water Control Law (Title 62.1-44.2 through 62.1-

44.34 of the Code of Virginia (1950), as amended). The Board

further certifies that there are no other applicable promulgated

effluent limitations or other limitations under Sections 301, 302,

and 303 and there is not an applicable standard under Sections

306 or 307 of Public Law 95-217 presently in effect.

The applicant shall immediately notify the Board of any modifi-

cation of this project and shall demonstrate in a written statement

to the Board that said modification will not violate any conditions

C1

of this Certification. If such demonstration cannot be made, the

applicant shall apply to the Board for a modification of this Cer-

tification.

This Certification, after proper hearing, is subject to revocation

for failure to comply with the conditions herein. It is issued in

accordance with the plans for the project and certifies that the

applicant and the project contractor shall not violate the Water

Quality Standards to accomplish the project. Any violation of the

Water Quality Standards will be subject to abatement and con-

trol under the State Water Control Law.

This Certification is valid providing the applicant complies with

the following Special Conditions, which are made a part of this

Certification.

SPECIAL CONDITIONS

1. That all work shall be done in such a manner as to minimize

sedimentation of State Waters.

2. That the Ware Creek water supply reservoir shall be

designed with the following general features:

Dam Length 1,450 feet

Crest Width 40 feet

Dam Base Width 300 feet

Upstream/Downstream Dam Slopes 3 horizontal: 1 vertical

Crest Elevation +48 feet MSL

Upstream Drainage Area 17.4 square miles

Normal Pool Elevation +35 feet MSL

Storage Capacity 6,355 MG

Average Depth 16 feet

Gross Yieid i0.1 MGD

Minimum Downstream Release 0.4 MGD

Seepage Loss Through Dam 0.3 MGD

Safe Yield 9.4 MGD

C2

. That the County shall submit a Water Management/Conserva-

tion Plan for approval by the State Water Control Board at least

90 days prior to commencement of construction. The plan must

include water quality monitoring and a phased conservation

strategy including mandatory measures designed to reduce water

consumption to essential human needs when conditions warrant

such action. The Water Conservation Plan shall be based on the

specific conditions noted in items 4,5,6 and 7 below.

. That when the average runoff from the watershed for the

period of the preceding 30 consecutive days is equal to, or

greater than, the total of the quantity withdrawn for water

supply plus 1.6 MGD the minimum release through the prin-

cipal spillway should be equivalent to at least 1.6 MGD.

. That when the average runoff from the watershed for the period

of the preceding 30 consecutive days is less than the toial of the

quantity withdrawn for water supply plus 1.6 MGD the mini-

mum release through the principal spillway shall be 0.8 MGD.

. That when the release through the principal spillway has been

reduced to 0.8 MGD and reservoir storage has been reduced

below normal pool, the minimum release through the princi-

pal spillway shall remain at 0.8 MGD until the reservoir stor-

age has recovered to normal pool elevation. When the res-

ervoir has recovered to normal pool elevation, condition

number four (4) or number five (5) above will prevail.

. That the Water Management/Conservation Plan as required

in condition number 3 shall be designed so that the initial

mandatory water conservation measures go into effect when

the spillway release flows fail below 0.8 MGD and shall be

phased to full implementation and enforcement when the

release flows are at least 0.4 MGD. However, this shall not

preclude the implementation of voluntary measures when

release flows are greater than 0.8 MGD.

Tne, CO oon) COE ee ee eo Oe aden Bitar toe, ; : 7 ' pata 3c: =

8. That the County shail submit for approval by the State Wa-

ter Control Board at least 90 days prior to commencement

of construction the following: :

a) Aplan designed to document and monitor the down-

stream wetlands changes which may result from the

reservoir operation and

b) Aplan to monitor the development of created wet-

lands associated with the mitigation plan for this

project.

These plans shall be operaticnal prior to modification of the

natural flow pattern in Ware Creek.

9. That the County shall submit a Wetlands Preservation Plan

which would be a supplement to the Wetlands Mitigation

Plan contained in the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)

dated September, 1987. The Wetlands Preservation Plan

shall be submitted for approval by the State Water Control

Board's Executive Director 90 days prior to commencement

of construction.

10. That the data generated from the above monitoring program

shall be submitted to the Virginia Water Control Board for

review and comment semi-annually.

11. That all denuded areas associated with the project's construc-

tion shall be provided with adequate ground cover or seed-

ing upon completion of the project to arrest soil erosion.

Further, phased seeding should be employed, as practicable,

to minimize sedimentation during construction.

12. That the procedures set fourth in the Virginia Erosion and

Sediment Control Handbook, Second Edition, 1980 should

be followed.

13. That any excavated of fill material stored on site should ei-

ther be contained or be located in such a manner as to pre-

vent any discharge into State water's.

14. That all construction and installation associated with the

project shall be accomplished in such a manner that construc-

tion material or waste material shall not be discharged into

State waters.

15. That the State Water Control Board's Permits Program,

Office of Water Resources Management, Richmond Office,

be notified when construction begins so that the staff will be

aware of progress and inspections of the project may be

made.

By: s/ Richard N. Burton Date: 12/22/88

Richard N. Burton

Executive Director

State Water Control Board

C5

APPENDIX D

FINAL DETERMINATION OF THE

U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY'S

ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR WATER

PURSUANT TO SECTION 404(C) OF THE CLEAN

WATER ACT CONCERNING THE PROPOSED WARE

CREEK WATER SUPPLY IMPOUNDMENT JAMES

CITY COUNTY, VIRGINIA

|

TABLE OF CONTENTS

| Page

I. Introduction D-3

}

| II. Project Description and Background D-8

| A. Project Description D-8

| B. Project History D-11

C. EPA Headquarters Actions D-12

| III. Description of Project Site D-15

| A. Site Description D-19

| B. Wildlife D-26

| IV. Adverse Impacts of Proposed Project D-41

| A. Impacts to Wildlife D-42

B. Impacts to Recreational and Commercial

Fisheries D-53

C. Impacts to Recreation D-54

D. Cumuiative Impacts D-55

| E. Chesapeake Bay Agreements D-58

| V. Mitigation D-60

| A. The Mitigation Plan D-61

a B. Analysis of the Plan D-64

C. Discussion D-72

VI. Alternatives D-73

A. James City County's Water Supply Needs D-73

B. James River Pipeline D-75

C. Groundwater D-76

D. Three Dam Alternative D-79

E. Water Use and Conservation D-83

F. Discussion D-85

VII. Conclusions and Findings D-88

; D-2

I. INTRODUCTION

Section 404(c) of the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. Section

1251 et seq.) provides that, if the Administrator of the U.S.

Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) determines, after no-

tice and opportunity for public comment, that unacceptable ad-

verse effects on municipal water supplies, shellfish beds, fishery

areas (including spawning and breeding areas), wildlife, or rec-

reational areas would result from the discharge of dredged or fill

material, he may exercise his authority to withdraw or prohibit

the specification, or deny, restrict or withdraw the use for speci-

fication, of any defined area as a disposal site for dredged or fill

material, Before making such a determination, the Administra-

tor must consult with the Chief of the Army Corps of Engineers

(Corps), the property owner(s), and the applicant where there has

been an application for a Section 404 permit. The procedures for

implementation of Section 404(c) are set forth in the Code of

Federal Regulations, 40 CFR Part 231.

EPA's regulations for implementing Section 404(c) establish

procedures to be foliowed in exercising the Administrator's au-

thority pursuant to that Section. Three major milestones in the

process are: 1) the Regional Administrator's proposed decision

to withdraw, deny, restrict or prohibit the use of a site (Proposed

Determination); 2) the Regional Administrator's recommenda-

tion to the Administrator to withdraw, deny, restrict or prohibit

the use of a site (Recommended Determination); and 3) the

Administrator's final decision to affirm, modify, or rescind the

Regional Recommendation (Final Determination). The Admin-

istrator has delegated the authority to make final decisions under

Section 404(c) to the Assistant Administrator for Water, wiio is

EPA's national Clean Water Act Section 404 program manager.

This Final Determination concerns the proposed placement

of dredged or fill material for the purpose of creating a local water

supply impoundment on Ware Creek in the County of James City,

D-3

DBR uit NORA SE egg spas + Fae oe eRe _

Virginia that would supply water to James City County residents.

Figure 1 shows the location of the proposed project on a regional

scale. Figure 2 shows the location at the proposed impoundment

relative to James City County.

EPA Region III's Regional Administrator has recommended that

EPA prohibit or deny specification or use of described waters of the

United States, including wetlands, as a disposal site for dredged or

fill material in connection with the construction of any water supply

impoundment in the subject area of James City County. Region III's

finding that the discharge of materials in connection with the above

described activities would have an unacceptable adverse effect on

wildlife, fishing areas and recreational areas. In addition, the Regional

Administrator expressed his belief that several promising environ-

mentally superior, economically feasible alternatives should be more

thoroughly investigated.

This Final Determination is based on consideration of the

record developed by EPA and by the Corps in this case, includ-

ing public comment submitted in response to the Regional Pro-

posed Determination, comment received at the public hearing

and comment from other Federal and state agencies. This Final

Determination also reflects comment and information received

during EPA Headquarters’ consultation pursuant to Section

231.6 of the Clean Water Act Section 404(c) regulations.

The administrative record contains references to the need for,

and potential use of the proposed Ware Creek impoundment as,

a regional water supply for the Lower James River/York River

Peninsula.’ However, the project as proposed is a local water

1 The Lower James River/York River Peninsula is comprised of the

Cities of Newport News, Hampton, Poquoson and Williamsburg as

well as James City County and York County. This area corresponds

to the northside Hampton Roads area or region for which the local,

state and Federal regional water supply studies have been conducted.

D4

Wee ngtan, 0.C.

FIGURE 1. Location of Ware Creek project on a regional

scale

D-5

NEW KENT COUNTY

CMARLES CITY COUNTY

FIGURE 2. Location of Ware Creek project relative to

James City County.

D-6

a eee

peg

supply for James City County. The analysis in the record regard-

associated environmental impacts, and mitigation is focused on

the local water supply project. Any future evaluations of regional

water supply proposals would require different environmental

regional alternatives, appropriate multijurisdictional endorse-

ment, and cther factors. Therefore, this Final Determination is

based solely on an evaluation of the proposed local Ware Creek/

James City County water supply project.

The Section 404(c) regulations authorize the prohibition or

other restriction of fill at sites where "unacceptable adverse ef-

fects on municipal water s shellfish beds and fishery ar-

eas (including spawning and ing areas), wildlife, or recre-

ation areas" are found to occur. As described in detail below, it

is the finding of this Final Determination that the proposed Ware

Creek/James City County water supply impoundment would

result in the destruction and loss of a diverse wetland habitat that

. For the purposes of this Section 404(c) Final Determination, "effects

on wildlife" include impacts to ecosystem integrity, nutrient pathways,

and all other life requisites of animal, including fish, species.

D-7

mended Determination and restricts the designation of the sub-

ject waters of the United States as discharge sites for dredged or

fill material expressly for the puxpose of establishing a local water

supply for James City County and as such prohibits the placement

of fill for that purpose. This Final Determination does not pertain

to other types of filling activities or to proposed filling activities

in other waters of the United States within the Ware Creek wa-

tershed. Other proposals involving the discharge of dredged or

fill material on the waters of the United States at issue will be

evaluated on their merits withia the Corps of Engineers’ Section

404 regulatory prograin.

II. PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND BACKGROUND

This Final Determination concerns waters of the United

States affected by the local water supply impoundment proposed

by James City County, Virginia and activities proposed as miti-

gation for associated adverse environmental impacts. Review of

the Recommended Determination submitted by Region III and

the administrative record pertaining to this case indicates that

EPA Region III's\Recommended Determination accurately re-

flects background events leading to consideration of the Recom-

mended Determination. The following sections of the Recom-

mended Determination are hereby adopted as part of this Final

Determination: Sections III], PROJECT DESCRIPTION (pages

5-6); Section IV, PROJECT HISTORY (pages 6-9); and Section

VI.C, MITIGATION (pages 41-42). Below are summary de-

scriptions of the proposed project, mitigation plan and project

history based on the Recommended Determination and admin-

istrative record, and of EPA Headquarters actions subsequent to

the Recommended Determination.

A. PROJECT DESCRIPTION

1. The Water Supply Impoundment

D-8

This Section 404(c) action addresses the proposed placement

of dredged or fill material in the waters of the United States, as

described in the Recommended Determination. James City

County, Virginia proposes to discharge dredged and/or fill ma-

terial into the Ware Creek basin to construct an earthen dam to

impound water for a 1,217 acre water supply reservoir. The dam

would be constructed on a northwest-southeast axis across Ware

Creek and France Swamp (Figures 1 and 3). The proposed res-

ervoir would be located along the border of James City and New

Kent Counties. The dam would be 1,450 feet long, 40 feet wide

at the crest and 300 feet wide at the base, with a crest elevation

of +48 feet mean sea level. The reservoir would have an average

depth of 16 feet. Capacity of the reservoir would be 6,355 mil-

lion gallons at a normal pool elevation of +35 feet mean sea level.

The project would provide a safe yield’ of 9.4 million gallons per

day (mgd).

Construction of the impoundment would result in inundation of

425 acres of waters of the United States and 792 acres of primarily

forested

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Petition for Writ of Certiorari — James City County v. Environmental Protection Agency · 513 U.S. 823 | Frix