Transcript of Record — Southern R. Co. v. Puckett
Supreme Court brief1917
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
”
STHEE SS TERIE LETS,
ft oes
ee. PINE ENE EIEN ET NETO IE AREA TE LS MLE te ORS DARIEN, Le. acl it A RRORNIN
(24,881)
: SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 1915.
j
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,
v8.
- H. E. PUCKETT.
IN ERROR TO THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF GEORGIA.
“ INDEX.
Original. Print
Transcript of record from the city court of Atlanta............ 1 1
Pe ee NING sic er yaks sa cuanne ateuluuiedoudue ues 1 1
Judge's certificate to bill of exceptions................ 13 6
Clerk’s certificate to bill of CRCOQUII So io ho wdicaus 14 6
DE ish teewcisesh vie rsh beuruncan.shiamaukeoewe ack 15 7
SE ME OR ons in Veo S awa ov ew eects 28 12
Ee Se NU «is ean Veen co ikane case Racenelree 29 13
Ee IM in nh ok wivevivide dcebeadsunwar eaten 33 15
Order overruling petition for removal.................... 36 16
Bill of exceptions pendente lite... 00.0.0... ccc cc coc ec weece 37 17
Te PUNOOD sock cad sdandu inten 38 17
EE sik sh dane yi be i 9Nboab keed deekeas sUene te 38 17
EE a LACUS Macewin hw CREEL AM RELEASE Kee ee 45 20
CU ON sos ccancnbisnes deed aicatent dou 49 22
Bill of exceptions pendente lite... 00.00. cc cece ececccuucee 5 23
PY A COPMBCEUD 35 6i6 css wilcoh pareecdceiee ies 51 23
eT COD 5 is 6k aNS sae ea CR ER EROS cael ecoie ede 52 24
Demurrer to amended petition.................cccccccecce 57 27
\
Jupp & DeTweILeR (INc.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., January 20, 1916,
il INDEX.
Original. Print
Order on demurrer...... ania mene ig etmek Mien ae shelare wes Wk ae 59 28
NO NIE os ioig ConcewaiGd Kae me cas ccdamnsine ame 60 28
ene TY INEGI ii ic ani ecccc niece sawkit enn ad cwe mais 62 29
TnI th SII onda cae wcees Gere anwievediadawees 64 30
Polat arial uot as te, & ai Bracy alia GIN ireor GMOS Aid & viva bi Ralel we Shree 66 31
NIE C1 a he ace Lanne wel Shia kikeame ne caiman thee ce ewae Ke 66 31
NINE ONE oo dic, ck ecole cence ek ee aeeae 67 31
le gi actana 3 ccs winnaar ss rte Ml ling al phar so ais WL 7 33
nt ch ahora iri! 9 ae as Soren ec Witcoreate Swe ker 70 33
Order on motion ....... ARIS TRE ea ORG See 71 33
Pema Waetiows TOF WH WTR... 5 won 5 occ cece ec sdascsccs 73 34
Order denying motion for new trial....................... 79 37
I cre hae alerneie Caw aed 'n dae aceay a unke.s 80 37
Testimony of H. E. Puckett......... eer ee 80 37
Pe Se ee 103 47
rs ee ee 112 51
iE RS aan Gh dana kcndekdw seta 116 53
OI areca. does areca aoe ere recevererduae' 119 54
III cic git ea ma kom ecard cen neees:s 122 56
dns oso aioe. em ware 124 57
ES rig in Glew mene Raube ase daas 128 58
OR 7 RE Pena ey a 130 59
I ached aia cena arua atin Was 132 60
Sl I aaa ex naw ew cena maeincim ees 134 61
Se ora as Cid gu ewe Beaman aioe Wncn a's 140 63
a ian ner ea ween ca weeesc 142 64
A ed rer rc ras trae Grater wie oles 145 66
Rules of Southern Railway Co... ........cccccscccssess 151 68
Judge’s certificate to brief of evidence................ 155 70
Defendant’s Exhibits A, B,C, and D—Photographs... . 156 70
Rule Book, Southern Railway Company (omitted in
RN ane cGe nutes Canes wereikeleeeees eens es 160 71
NG I era rracn cae nde es whew ok wt be bans KEE UEENeS DOS 161 71
ON ikon aia adie nadia Net meenas gemrsialawaises 186 81
See en ene ee eee ee 188 82
Ree ae Run LebGanwe cabelas ees ihedweadanceakenen nea 202 88
eee Gat dhs oo aa Wea a Me ose ewe a os 203 88
Ee RE Tee 205 89
Re OE a aos ca ee ee cee e had acees wccwesiowd 208 4
SI ee eee 209 91
NE OE CN ec ais canine eh an enna tree wed ene ebaeits 210 92
ee Fine eek ehad © <eleicd aciyeene 6 218 95
meeeenge Ber Cramecrint OF record... .. 0.0. ns 2c cence ccceees 220 96
i ah girs Wilts ws exam ell Wwe Sie OAL 222 96
Stipulation to omit parts of record in printing..............+.. 22% 97
IOI a sete DT
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY YS. H. B. PUCKETT. 1
1 State or Georgia,
County of Fulton:
City Court of Atlanta,
No. 23192.
H. E. Puckxerr
vs. ;
SouTHERN Raitway Com PANY,
Be it remembered, That during the March Term, 1914, of the city
court of Atlanta, before the Honorable II. M. Reid, Judge thereof,
there came on to be heard the case of H. E. Puckett against Southern
Railway Company, the same being a suit for personal injuries alleged
to have been sustained by the plaintiff on August 26, 1911, suit hav-
ing originally been brought against Southern Railway Company
and certain individual defendants, to wit: R. L. Cowan, Samuel
Smith and J. N. Biddy, the suit as originally filed embracing two
counts, the first based on the State law. and the second based on the
Act of Congress of 1908, as amended, known as “The Federal Em-
ployers’ Liability Act.” Prior to the trial the first count of the
petition and the three individual defendants in the second count
were stricken by amendment of plaintiff, so that the action when
tried proceeded against Southern Railway Company as sole defend-
ant on the second count of petition based on the said Federal Em-
ployers’ Liability Act.
2 Said case during said term was tried before a jury, and
after evidence was introduced for the plaintiff and defendant
and after argument and charge of the court, the jury at said March
Term, 1914, to wit: on April 7, 1914, rendered a verdict in favor of
the plaintiff and against the defendant Southern Railway Company
for Seven Thousand. Two IIundred and Fifty, ($7,250) Dollars.
The defendant Southern Railway Company thereafter, at the
same term of the court, within the time prescribed by law, filed its
motion for new trial and in connection with said motion for new
trial filed a duly approved brief of the evidence and amendment. to
its motion for new trial, as well as the approved charge of the court,
the grounds of the original motion and the amendment thereto hay-
ing been duly approved and certified by the court. That said mo-
tion for new trial was heard on June 23rd. 1914. and after consider-
ation the court on said date, to wit: June 23. 1914, overruled said
motion for new trial and entered its formal order overruling said
motion and denying a new trial.
To this decision, judgment and order of the court overruling its
motion for new trial the defendant then and there excepted and
now excepts to the same and assigns error thereon. and for specific
assignment of error says that the court erred in overruling the said
1—598
2 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
motion for new trial on each and all of the grounds contained
3 in the original and the amended motion, and Southern Rail-
way Company avers that said motion for new trial should
have been granted on each and all of the grounds contained in the
original motion and the amendment thereto.
Be it further remembered, That before the time for pleading to
the defendant’s declaration, either by law or through a rule of the
court, arrived, it filed its petition and bond for the removal of the
cause to the Circuit Court of the United States (now the District
Court) for the Northern District of Georgia, and that the court, after
considering its petition for removal, passed an order denying the
same, which decision, order and judgment of the court denying
the petition for the removal of the cause to the said United States
Court, Southern Railway Company then and there excepted to and
now excepts to the same and assigns the same as error.
After the order denying its petition for removal was passed, at
the same term of court and within the time required by law South-
ern Railway Company filed its exceptions pendente lite preserving
of record its exceptions to the order of the Court denying its appli-
cation for removal and the errors assigned thereon, and Southern
Railway Company here and now assigns error upon the specifica-
tions contained in said exceptions pendente lite.
t Be it further remembered, That Southern Railway Com-
pany at the first term filed a demurrer to plaintiff's petition
upon various grounds, which demurrer coming on to be heard was
sustained in part and overruled in part, as shown by the order passed
by the court on January 6th, 1912, to which order of the court, in so
far as the same overruled portions of its demurrer, Southern Rail-
way Company then excepted and now excepts to the same and assigns
the same as error.
After the order of January 6th, 1912, overruling its demurrer in
part, was passed, at the same term of the court and within the time
required by law, defendant filed its exceptions pendente lite preserv-
ing in the record its exceptions to the ruling, judgment and order of
the court in so far as said demurrer was overruled: and Southern
Railway Company here and now assigns error upon the specifications
contained in said exceptions pendente lite.
Be it further remembered. That on the 7th dav of June, 19138, the
plaintiff filed two amendments to his petition and on said date South-
ern Railway Company filed a demurrer to such amendments and
to the petition as amended and that upon a consideration of the de-
murrer in question the Court of June 7th, 1913, overruled the
same on each and every ground thereof. to which order, ruling and
judgment of the court in overruling its demurrer to the amendments
filed by the plaintiff and to his petition as amended Southern Rail-
way Company excepted and now excepts to the same and as-
5 signs the same as error; and Southern Railway Company
shows that after the order of the Court overruling its second
demurrer was passed, at the same term of the court at which the
decision was made and the order and judgment entered and within
the time required by law it filed its exceptions pendente lite, pre-
| peers a
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 3
serving of record its exceptions to the order overruling said second
demurrer and the errors assigned thereon, and Southern Railway
Company here and now assigns error upon the specifications con-
tained in said exceptions pendente lite.
Be it further remembered, That during the trial of the case as
aforesaid and after the plaintiff had introduced all of his evidence
Southern Railway Company moved the court for a nonsuit upon the
ground that the plaintiff had failed by his evidence to sustain the
case made by his petition and amendments thereto in the following
particulars:
(1) Because plaintiff had failed to show by his evidence that he
was employed in interstate commerce at the time of his alleged
injuries for which suit was brought:
(2) Because the plaintiff had failed bv his evidence to show that
the defendant was guilty of the acts of negligence charged in the
| petition.
. After considering said motion for a nonsuit the eourt overruled
the same, to which decision. judgment and ruling of the
6 court defendant Southern Railway Company then and there
excepted and now excepts to the same and assigns the same as
nme
error.
Defendant Southern Railway Company, after the overruling of
its nonsuit and at the same term of court and within the time re-
quired by law filed its exceptions pendente lite, preserving of record
its exceptions to the overruling of its motion for nonsuit and the
errors assigned thereon, and Southern Railwav Company here and
now assigns error upon the specifications contained in said ex-
ceptions pendente lite.
Be it further remembered, That during the trial of the ease.
to wit: on the 6th day of April, 1914. plaintiff filed another amend-
ment to his petition, to the allowance of which amendment Southern
Railway Company objected upon the ground that the same did not
in and of itself show and did not. in connection with the allegations
in the original petition and the amendments thereto, show that
plaintiff was engaged in interstate commerce at the time of his al-
leged injuries and was thereby entitled to the henefits of the Act of
Congress of 1908 and the amendment thereto, generally known as
“The Federal Employers’ Liability Act.”
The court over objection allowed said amendment, to which de-
cision and erder Southern Railway Company then and there
7 excepted and now excepts to the same and assigns the same
as error,
After the allowance of said amendment, Southern Railway Com-
pany then renewed its general demurrer. to the declaration as
amended and urged the dismissal of plaintiffs suit upon the eround
that the petition as amended did not by its allegations show that T1.
E. Puckett was engaged in interstate commerce at the time of his
alleged injury, so as to bring him within the purview and entitle him
to the benefits of the Act of Congress of 1908 as amended, generally
known as “The Federal Employers’ Liability Act:” and the court
then and there overruled its demurrer, to which decision and order
a the court overruling its demurrer based upon the ground afore-
BEM com. ope - A , “aR
errr
4 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
said defendant Southern Railway Company then and there ex-
cepted and now excepts to the same and assigns the same as error.
After the allowance of said last-named amendment and the over-
ruling of its demurrer which was renewed to the petition as amended
upon the ground above stated, at the same term of the court and
within the time required by law, Southern Railway Company filed
its exceptions pendente lite. preserving of record its exceptions to
the allowance of said amendment over objection and to the overrul-
ing of its renewed demurrer and the errdrs assigned thereon and it
here and now assigns error upon the specifications contained in said
exceptions pendente lite. Southern Railway Company also
8 preserved in said exceptions pendente lite its exceptions to
the overruling of the demurrer which it renewed to the
petition as amended and here and now assigns error on said ex-
| ceptions pendente lite upon the specifications with respect to the
overruling of said renewed demurrer.
Southern Railway Company specifies the following portions of
the record in said case as material to a clear understanding of the
errors in this bill of exceptions complained of, to wit:
1. The original petition in said case filed November 10, 1911, with
| entry of service thereon ; ;
| 2. The petition and bond for the removal of the case to the Cir-
cuit Court of the United Stete for the Northern District of Georgia,
| filed by Southern Railway Company on December 20, 1911; order of
the court overruling and denving the application for removal of
December 20, 1911, and exceptions pendente lite filed by Southern
Railway Company to such ruling and order on December 20, 1911;
3. Demurrer of Southern Railway Company filed December 29,
1911: order of the court of January 6, 1912, thereon, sustaining
said demurrer in part and overruling it in part; exceptions pendente
lite filed by Southern Railway Company on January 10, 1912,
to order of the court overruling in part its demurrer; |
4. Answer of Southern Railway Company filed December 29,
1911; |
9 5. Amendment of plaintiff to his petition filed June 7,
19138;
6. Demurrer of Southern Railway Company filed June 7, 1913;
order of court of same date overruling said demurrer, and exceptions
pendente lite filed by Southern Railway Company on June 14, |
1913, to order and judgment of the court overruling said demurrer;
7. Amendment of plaintiff filed on June 7, 1913, and allowed on,
June 7, 1913, which was unobjected and unexcepted to;
8. Amendment of plaintiff to his petition filed March 9, 1914, with.
respect to his injuries;
9. Amended answer of Southern Railway Company filed March
9, 1914;
10. Amendment of plaintiff to his petition filed and allowed on
April 6, 1914, over objection of defendant:
11. Exceptions pendente lite filed by defendant Southern Rail-
way Company on April 10, 1914;
12. Verdict of the jury of April 7, 1914, and judgment thereon on
April 9, 1914;
PERSE Se . ential
ee METS LSS TTR CRATING
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT, 5
13. Original motion for new trial filed by Southern Railway
Company on April 10, 1914, together with rule nisi of court thereon
and entry of service upon the same:
10 14, Amended motion for new trial filed by Southern
Railway Company on June 23, 1914. with entry of service
thereon and order of the court allowing the same and sanctioning
and approving the grounds of the original motion for new trial and
the grounds of the amended motion for new trial;
} 15. Approved charge of the court filed on June 23, 1914;
16. Entries of filing, consent of counsel and approval of court
upon the brief of evidence:
17. Order of June 23, 1914, denying and overruling the motion
for new trial.
Southern Railway Company specifies the following oral and
documentary evidence as material to a clear understanding of the
| errors complained of, the same being portions of the brief of evidence
approved by the court as true and correct on June 23. 1914. and filed
| on the same date, which brief of evidence became a part of the
record in the case:
(a) The entire oral evidence of the following evidence of the
following witnesses: TT. FE. Puckett. J. 1. Chappelle, G. W. Lindsay,
I. H. McElroy, W. E. Jackson. H. E. Cochran. J. P. McDonald,
J. N. Biddy, C.F. MeDannell, Samuel Smith. R. T.. Cowan, TT, M.
Gilmer, J. W. Whitaker and C. G. Lee.
(>) The evidence setting forth the rules of the Company
11 which were introduced in evidence contained in the approved
brief of evidence on pages 35 and 36. together with the state-
ment on page 36 of the approved brief of the evidence relative
to the use of rule book by the Court in considering the admissi-
bility of the rules offered in evidence. and the stipulation on the
same page relative to the use in the Appellate Court of said rule hook
of Southern Railway Company. and the identified rule book attached
to the approved brief of evidence.
(ec) The briefed evidence relative to two bills of lading intro-
duced by defendant, which briefed evidence is contained on page
108 of the approved brief of evidence.
(7) The briefed evidence relative to application of H. E. Puckett
to the Southern Railway Company introduced in evidence by the
defendant, which evidence is contained in the approved brief on
page 108.
(¢) Agreed statement in brief of evidence on page 199 relative
to switch list of defendant company introduced in evidence by
plaintiff.
(f) Four photographs attached to brief of evidence identified in
defendant’s exhibits A, B, C and D,
12 The foregoing evidence is all that is material to a clear
understanding of the errors complained of. The other evi-
dence contained in the brief of evidence relating only to the injuries
claimed to have been received by the plaintiff, 1. EF. Puckett, which
evidence was only material to the ground for motion for new trial
complaining that the verdict was excessive, which ground is not
now insisted upon,
Bereon ‘i sata t : i Brena 7. |
eee —
eae oe
G SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
And now within the time provided by law and within thirty day
of the entry of the order and judgment overruling said motion fo
new trial as amended comes Southern Railway Company and ten
ders this its bill of exceptions and prays that the same may be signe:
and certified as provided by law in order that the errors complaine
of may be considered and corrected by the Court of Appeals.
McDANIEL & BLACK,
Attorneys for Southern Railway Co.,
P. O. Address, Atlanta, Georgia.
13 I do certify that the foregoing bill of exceptions is true
and specifies all of the evidence and specifies all of the recore
material to a clear understanding of the errors complained of; anc
the City Clerk of the city court of Atlanta is hereby ordered to mak
out a complete copy of such parts of the record in said case as ar
in this bill of exceptions specified and certify the same as such ane
cause the same to be transmitted to the Court of Appeals, that th
errors alleged to have been committed may be considered and cor
rected. June 25, 1914.
Hf. M. REID,
Judge City Court of Atlanta,
Due and legal service of the within and foregoing bill of exception
acknowledged. Copy received. All further service waived, Thi
June 25, 1914.
ATKINSON & BORN.
14 (Endorsed:) No. 23192. City Court of Atlanta. TT. E
Puckett vs. Southern Railway Co. Bill) of Exceptions
Filed in office, this the 25 day of June, 1914. Arnold Broyles, Clerk
Geroroia, Fulton County:
I hereby certify, That the foregoing bill of exceptions, hereunt
attached, is the true original bill of exceptions in the case stated
to wit: Southern Railway Company, Plaintiff in error, vs. TH. E
Puckett, Defendant in error, and that a copy hereof has been mad
and filed in this office,
Witness my signature and the seal of Court affixed this the 1é
day of July, 1914.
[ SEAL, | ARNOLD BROYLES,
Clerk Superior Court Fulton County, Georgia,
Ex-Officio Clerk City Court of ‘Atlanta.
15 (Endorsed:) Case No. 5885. Court of Appeals. Octobe
Term, 1914. Southern Railway Co. versus TT. E. Puckett
Bili of Exceptions. Filed in office June 25, 1914. Arnold Broyles
Clerk. Filed in office Jul. 15, 1915. W. E. Talley, D. Clerk.
segs — aaciediniamiaen
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
16 (Petition. )
City Court of Atlanta, January Term, 1912.
No. 23192.
H, E. Puckerr
V.
SourHern Rartway Company et al.
ae
GEORGIA, Fulton County:
To the City Court of Atlanta:
H. E, Puckett brings this his complaint against Southern Rail-
sway Company and R. L. Cowan and Samuel Smith and J. N, Biddy,
and for cause of complaint alleges,
1. That R. L. Cowan is a citizen and resident of said State and
County.
2. That Samuel Smith is a resident and citizen of said State and
County,
3. That J. N. Biddy is a citizen and resident of said State and
County.
4. That said Southern Railway Company is a railroad corporation
operating lines of railroad in and through said county, having an
agent, an office, and doing business in said county,
5. That the said defendants Southern Railway Company, and
R. L. Cowan and Samuel Smith, and J. N. Biddy, have jointly
injured and damaged your petitioner in the sum of Thirty Thou-
sand ($30,000) Dollars for that your petitioner avers:
17 That on the occasion herein referred to, your petitioner
was in the employ of the said Southern Railway Company
in the capacity of ear inspector,
7. That on or about August 26, 1911, at about 10:40) o’cloek
P. M., your petitioner was seriously and permanently injured in
manner and by means as is herein fully set forth,
8. Your petitioner was injured in said State and County,
9. That R. L. Cowan was in the employ of said Southern Rail-
way Company in the capacity of track foreman,
* 10. That Samuel Smith was in the employ of said Southern Rail-
way Company in the capacity of track supervisor,
11. That said J. N. Biddy was in the employ of the said Southern
ailway Company in the capacity of road master,
12. That on the occasion herein referred to, A, P. O’Berry, a
witchman, of the said Southern 1 Wway Company, had heen
aught in a collision between an engine and box car of defendant
ompany in the North Inman yards, and was pinned down be-
ween the box car and end sill of said engine,
13. The box car had been set on fire by the bursting of the oil
ead light and the said O’Berry was in great danger of losing his
ife both by fire from the burning box car, and by being mashed
to death by said box car.
Reem ee HERR OP OITA Te Bem |
8 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
18 14. It was the duty of your petitioner to aid in rescuin;
the said O’Berry from the said wreck as aforesaid, as well as t
assist in clearing away said wreck.
15. That there are a number of tracks in said yards.
16. The track furtherest east is known as the lead track fron
the transfer and is also known as track No. 27.
17. This track was near, that is to say, about 25 yards from wher
the said collision occurred.
18. In order to get some blocks to use in jacking up the box car
to release O’Berry, as well as to clear up the weeck, it became nec
essary for your petitioner to go across the said lead track.
19. After he had gone across the said lead track and had place
the blocks on his shoulders, the blocks being approximately of th
following size, namely, 3 ft. long and 5 inches by 9 inches in thick
ness, and the other one about 3 feet and a half long and 6 inche
by 15 inches in thickness, he started with the blocks up alongsid
i said lead track for the purpose of going around some box car
standing on the said lead track, so as to reach the scene of th
collision and the point where O’Berry was pinned beneath the bo:
car.
20. That lying within one or two feet of the said lead track anc
at about right angles to said track were two old and worn out cros
ties.
21. That within four or five feet of said two cross ties
19 there were three or more clinkers about six inches or eigh
inches in diameter. These clinkers were lying about one o
two feet from the said lead track and on the said road bed,
That it was dark, and your petitioner could not see th
clinkers or cross ties. Grass had grown around the said clinker
and cross ties, also preventing your petitioner from seeing them
23. That when he reached the said clinkers, he stumbled ove
them, which started him, and then he struck in his stumbling th
said two cross ties which threw him heavily to the ground, fallin
with his face to the ground and the two heavy blocks he was carry
ing falling heavily on his back, seriously, dangerously and_ per
manently injuring your petitioner, as herein fully set forth.
24. That it was the duty of the said R. L. Cowan, track foreman
to keep the said track and road bed free from obstruction and o
grass, your petitioner fell over, as aforesaid.
25. That it was the duty of said Samuel Smith, track supervise
to keep the said track and road bed free from obstruction, eras
your petitioner fell over, as aforesaid.
26. That it was the duty of the said J. N. Biddy, road maste
to keep the said track and road bed free from obstruction an
grass and other growth such as your petitioner fell over, as afon
said.
20 27. That said defendant company and R. LL. Cowan an
Samuel Smith, and J. N. Biddy were jointly and ‘concurrent!
negligent in that the said two old cross ties were lying alongsi
said track, as aforesaid.
28. That the said Southern Railway Company and R. L, Cows
eer —
COPY BOUND C
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. BE. PUCKETT. 9
and Samuel Smith and J. N, Biddy were jointly and concurrently
negligent in that the said three large clinkers were on said road
bed as aforesaid.
29. That the said Southern Railway Company and R. L, Cowan
and Samuel Smith and J, N. Biddy were jointly and concurrently
negligent in that the said grass had grown up on said road bed
as aforesaid,
30. That your petitioner did not know that the said obstructions,
namely, three clinkers and two cross ties were on said road bed
as aforesaid,
31. That in and about the premises your petitioner was wholly
free from fault and negligence.
82. That as a consequence of said fall. your petitioner received
serious, dangerous and permanent bodily injuries; that is te say,
his back was injured, the muscles thereof being strained and bruised.
His left kidney was injured and bruised, Te passes blood through
his urine. The small of his back was injured, The spinal
21 column being bruised and wrenched. and his left shoulder
and left hand were sprained and left arm was bruised and
injured. The left sacra illiae joint was injured, twisted. and bruised,
and he received a severe nervous shock. He was confined to his
home for 37 days, :
33. That on account of said injuries your petitioner has suffered
and will continue to suffer so long as he lives great physical pain
and mental anguish on account of said injuries,
34, That at the time of the infliction of said injuries, your peti-
tioner was active, strong, healthy, vigorous, and well. Tle was 36
years of age with an expectancy of 30:32 vears to live in the future,
He was capable of earning $93.67 per month, or other large sum.
Since the infliction of said injuries, he has not been able to earn
any money whatever. lis earning capacity has been permanently
impaired; that is to say, it has been reduced four-fifths of what it
was prior to the infliction of said injuries,
By way of second count, your petitioner respectfully shows:
35. That R. L. Cowan is a citizen and resident of said State and
County.
36. That Samuel Smith is a citizen and resident of said State and
County.
37. That J. N. Biddy is a citizen and resident of said
:22 State and County,
38. That said Southern Railway Company is a railroad
corporation operating lines of railroad in and through said county,
having an agent, an office, and doing business in said County.
39. That the said defendants Southern Railway Company and
R. L. Cowan and Samuel Smith and J. N. Biddy have jointly in-
jured and damaged your petitioner in the sum of Thirty Thousand
($30,000.) Dollars for that your petitioner avers:
40. That on the occasion herein referred to, your petitioner was
in the employ of said Southern Railway Company in the capacity
of car inspector.
41. That on or about August 26, 1911, at about 10:40 o’clock
2—598
ee . aed ~~
are ta neraeree.
10 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
P. M., your petitioner was seriously and permanently injured in
manner and by means as is herein fully set forth.
42. Your petitioner was injured in said State and County.
43. That at the time aforesaid, the said Southern Railway Com-
pany was a common carrier and engaged in interstate commerce.
44, That at the time of the infliction of said injuries, your peti-
tioner was employed by said common carrier and was engaged in in-
terstate commerce.
45. That R. L. Cowan was in the employ of said Southern Rail-
way Company in the capacity of track foreman.
23 46. That Samuel Smith was in the employ of said Southern
Railway Company in the capacity of track supervisor.
47. That said J. N. Biddy was in the employ of the said South-
ern Railway Company in the capacity of road master. j
48. That on the occasion herein referred to A. P. O’Berry, a |
switchman of the said Southern Railway Company, had been caught
in a collision between an engine and box car of defendant company
in the North Inman yards, and was pinned down between the box
car and end sill of said engine.
49. The box car had been set on fire by the bursting of the oil
head light and the said O’Berry was in great danger of losing his
life by fire from the burning box car, and by being mashed to death
by said box car.
50. It was the duty of your petitioner to aid in rescuing the said
O’Berry from the said wreck as aforesaid, as well as to assist in clear-
ing away said track.
51. That there are a number of tracks in said yards.
52. The track furtherest east is known as the “lead track” from
the transfer and is also known as Track No, 27.
53. This track was near; that is to say about 25 vards from where
the said collision occurred.
24 54. In order to get some blocks to use in jacking up the
box car to release O'Berry, as well as to clear up the wreck, it
became necessary for your petitioner to go across the said lead track.
55. After he had gone across the said lead track and had placed
the blocks on his shoulders, the blocks being approximately of the
following size, namely, 3 feet long and 5 inches by 9 inches in
thickness, and the other one about 3 feet and a half long and 6
inches by 15 inches in thickness, he started with the blocks up along-
side the said lead track for the purpose of going around some box#
cars standing on the said lead track, so as to reach the scene of the
collision and the point where O’Berry was pinned beneath the box
car.
56. That lying within one or two feet of the said lead track and
at about right angles to said track were two old and worn out cross
ties.
57. That within four or five feet of said two cross ties, there were
three or more clinkers about 6 inches or 8 inches in diameter. These
clinkers were lying about one or two feet from the said lead track
and on the said road bed.
58. That it was dark, and your petitioner could not see the clinkers
°
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. ll
or cross ties. Grass had grown around the said clinkers and cross
ties, also preventing your petitioner from seeing them.
25 59. That when he reached said clinkers, he stumbled over
them, which started him, and then he struck in his stumbling
the said two cross ties which threw him heavily to the ground, fall-
ing with his face to the ground and the two heavy blocks he was
carrying falling heavily on his back, seriously, dangerously, and
permanently injuring your petitioner, as herein fully set forth.
60. That it was the duty of the said R. L. Cowan, track foreman,
to keep the said track and road hed free from obstruction and of
grass, your petitioner fell over, as aforesaid.
61. That it was the duty of the said Samuel Smith, track super-
visor to keep the said track and road bed free from obstruction,
grass and other growth such as your petitioner fell over, as afore-
said,
62. That it was the duty of the said J. N. Biddy, road master, to
keep the said track and road bed free from obstruction and grass
your petitioner fell over, as aforesaid.
63. That said defendant company and R. L. Cowan and Samuel
Smith and J. N. Biddy were jointly and concurrently negligent in
that the said two old cross ties were lying alongside said track, as
aforesaid.
64. That the said Southern Railway Company and R. 1. Cowan
and Samuel Smith and J. N. Biddy were jointly and concurrently
negligent in that the said three large clinkers were on said
26 road bed, as aforesaid.
65. That the said Southern Railway Company and R. L.
Cowan and Samuel Smith and J. N. Biddy were jointly and con-
currently negligent in that the said grass had grown up on said road
bed, as aforesaid.
66. That your petitioner did not know that the said obstructions.
namely, three clinkers and two cross ties, were on said road bed. as
aforesaid.
67. That in and about the premises your petitioner was wholly
free from fault and negligence.
68. That as a consequence of said fall, your petitioner received
serious, dangerous, and permanent bodily injuries: that is to say,
his hack was injured, the muscles thereof heing strained and bruised.
His left kidney was injured and bruised. THe passed blood through
his urine. The small of his back was injured. The spinal column
being bruised and wrenched, and his left shoulder and left hand
were sprained and left arm was bruised and injured. The left sacra
iliac joint was injured, twisted and bruised, and he received a
severe nervous shock. Te was confined to his home for 37 days.
69. That on account of said injuries your petitioner has suffered
and will continue to suffer so long as he lives, great physieal pain
and mental anguish on account of said injuries.
27 70. That the time of the infliction of said injuries. your
petitioner was active, strong, healthy, vigorous, and well. Tle
was 36 years of age with an expectancy of 30:32 vears to live in the
future. He was capable of earning $93.67 per month, or other large
12 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
sum. Since the infliction of said injuries he has not been able to”
earn any money whatever. Tis earning capacity has been perma-
nently impaired; that is to say, it has been reduced four fifths of |
what it was prior to the infliction of said injuries. |
Wherefore, the premises considered, your petitioner has been in- |
jured and damaged in manner and by means as aforesaid, in the—
sum of Thirty Thousand ($30,000.) Dollars. |
Wherefore, your petitioner prays that process may issue out of.
this Honorable Court directed to the said defendant company and
R. L. Cowan and Samuel Smith and J. N. Biddy, requiring them to—
be and appear at the next term of this Honorable Court then and
there to answer your petitioner’s complaint, and your petitioner will
ever pray. |
f ATKINSON & BORN, |
Petitioner's Attys.
Filed in office this the 10th day of November, 1911. W. W.
Clarke, D. Cl’k.
28 STaTe OF GEORGIA,
County of Fulton:
H. E. Puckerr
vs.
SouTHERN Rainrway Co., R. L. Cowan, Samuet Smita, and J. N.
Binpy.
To the Sheriff or his deputy of said county, Greeting:
The defendants are hereby required, personally or by attorney to
be and appear at the City court of Atlanta, to be held in and for |
said county, on the first Monday in January, 1912, then and there
to answer the plaintiff's complaint, as in default thereof said court
will proceed, as to justice shall appertain.
Witness, The Honorable H. M. Reid, Judge of said Court, this
10th day of November, 1911.
W. W. CLARKE, D. Clk.
Georaia, Fulton County:
Served the defendant Southern Railway Co., a corporation, by
serving E, H. Houseman, its depot agent by leaving a copy of the,
within writ and process with him in person at the office and place
of doing business of said corporation in Fulton county, Ga. This
Nov. 17th, 1911.
J. W. CHAMBERS,
Deputy Sh ff.
Grorata, Fulton County:
I have this dav served the defendant R. L. Cowan, Samuel Smith
and J. N. Biddy each by leaving a copy of the within writ and
29 process at their several place- of residence in this county. This
Nov. 17th, 1911.
J. W. CHAMBERS, D. Sh’ ff.
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS, H. BE. PUCKETT.
(Petition for Removal and Bond.)
GeoraiA, Fulton County:
Your petitioner, the Southern Railway Company, respectfully
shows to this Honorable Court.
1. That it is the defendant in the suit, which is of a civil nature
and now pending; that said suit is brought to recover the sum of
hirty Thousand ($30,000) Dollars, for damages for alleged per-
sonal injuries sustained Aug. 26, 1911, at Atlanta, Ga.
2. Your petitioner further shows that said cause was instituted
nd begun in the city court of Atlanta by the filing of plaintiff’s
etition and the issuance and service of process, the said cause being
turnable to the January, 1912, term, and that the time required
or answering or pleading to the declaration or complaint of the
jlaintiff under the laws of Georgia and the rules of said court has
ot arrived,
3. Your petitioner further shows that this cause being of a civil
fature, as aforesaid, is wholly between citizens of different States:
your petitioner, who was at the time of the commencement
0) of this suit, and still is, a corporate body -corporated under the
laws of Virginia, then and now a resident and citizen of the
tate of Virginia, and a non-resident of the State of Georgia, and
laintiff who was and still is a citizen of Georgia and of the Northern
istrict thereof.
4. Your petitioner further shows that the said declaration or peti-
ion presents a separable controversy as between the plaintiff therein
nd the said Southern Railway Company, your petitioner, distinct
nd separate from the controversy made by the said declaration or
etition between the plaintiff and other defendants, R. L. Cowan.
amuel Smith and J. N. Biddy, for that in the said second count
t is alleged that at the time of the alleged injury complained of the
aid plaintiff and vour petitioner were engaged in interstate com-
erce, which makes an action based and founded on the Employers’
dability Act of Congress, approved April 22, 1908, and amended
April 5, 1910; and vour petitioner therefore by the said second count
s sought to be held liable under the said Act of Congress and the
‘ause of action sought to be set up in the said second count being
vased upon the said Act of Congress presents a cause of action against
your petitioner, whereas under the said Act of Congress aforesaid the
ther defendants joined in the said declaration or petition would not
‘ liable to the said plaintiff under the terms of the said Act of
Congress, Therefore the said declaration or petition, by vir-
31 tue of the said allegations in the said second count, presents
| a controversy which can be wholly determined between your
petitioner and the plaintiff, I. E. Puckett, distinet and separate from
iny cause of action made by the said declaration between the plain-
iff and the other defendants.
5. Your petitioner further shows that the controversy hetween
our petitioner and plaintiff is monetary in character, and the sum
32 and for its complying, in all respects, with the provisions
14 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
or value involved and in controversy therein, exclusive of intere
and costs, exceeds the sum and value of $2,000 and is the sum «
$30,000 as aforesaid.
6. That your petitioner desires to remove this suit before the tri
thereof and to remove same into the next Cireuit Court of the Unit
States, to be held in the Northern District of Georgia: and your pet
tioner hereby brings Illinois Surety Company, of the County ¢
Cook, State of Illinois, as its surety for its entering into the Circu
Court of the United States for the Northern District of Georgia, o
the first day of its next session or before, a copy of the record in sai
suit, and for paying all costs that may be awarded by the said Ci
cuit Court of the United States for the Northern District of Georgi
if said court should hold that this suit was wrongfully and impro
erly removed thereto; and also for its appearing and entering speci
bail in said suit, if special bail was originally required therei
the laws of the United States in the premises, regulating t
removal of causes from the State courts.
7. And your petitioner therefore prays that the said surety an
bond may be accepted; that this suit may be removed into the ney
Circuit Court of the United States, to be held in the Northern Di
trict of Georgia, pursuant to the statutes of the United States i
such cases made and provided, and that no further proceedings ma
be had therein in this court; and your petitioner will ever pray.
8. Your petitioner further shows that its appearance, through i
attorneys, to remove this suit is a special appearance, and does n
waive its objection to the jurisdiction of the court—it being sole
for the purpose of removal to said Circuit Court of the United Stat
for the Northern District of Ga.
McDANTEL ann BLACK ann
ED. NEELY.
Petitioner's Att’ ys.
SraTe OF GEORGIA,
Fulton County:
Personally came before me H. W. Miller, who, being duly swo
deposes and says that he is the Assistant to the President of defen
ant, Southern Railway Company, petitioner in the foregoing pe
tion for removal; that affiant knows the contents of said petitio
having read the same, and said petition is true to his own knowledg
except as to matters therein stated to be alleged upon infof
33 mation and belief, and as to those matters he believes it
be true.
Affiant further says that he is a general officer of the defendan
Southern Railway Company, and is the highest officer of said d
fendant in the State of Georgia and is authorized to verify the fo
going petition.
H. W. MILLER.
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this 19th day of Dee., 1911.
[N. P. SEAL. ] W. C. LANTER,
N. P., Fulton Co., 2
—
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
Bond.
In the City Court of Atlanta, Fulton County, State of Georgia.
H. E. Puckerr
Vv.
SouTHERN Rattway Company et al.
Petition to Remove Cause to the United States Circuit Court for the
Northern District of Georgia from the City Court of Atlanta.
Know all men by these presents, that we, the Southern Railway
Pompany, as principal, and Illinois Surety Company, as surety, are
held and firmly bound unto H. FE. Puckett in the penal sum of One
housand Dollars for the payment whereof, well and truly to be
made unto the said H. E. Puckett, his representatives cue
4 assigns, and all others whom it may concern, we bind @ui-
selves, our heirs, our representatives, successors and assigns,
ointly and severally, by these presents.
Whereas, The Southern Railway Company has filed its petition in
he city court of Atlanta asking for the removal to the Circuit Court
f the United States for the Northern District of Georgia, of a cer-
ain cause therein pending, wherein said H. E. Puckett is plaintiff
nd the Southern Railway Company is defendant:
Now, the conditions of the above obligations are such, that if the
aid Southern Railway Company shall enter into the said Circuit
urt of the United States for the Northern District of Georgia,
foresaid, on the first day of its next session, or before, a copy of
he record in the said suit, and shall well and truly pay all costs that
ay be awarded by said Court, if said Court shall hold that said suit
ras improperly removed thereto, and shall make special bail if origi-
ally required, and shall do and perform all acts required by the
aws of the United States to be done by it in the removal of said suit
s aforesaid, then this obligation to be void; otherwise to remain in
ull force and effect.
In testimony whereof we have hereunto set our hands and affixed
bur seals, this 19th day of Dee., 1911.
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
By Its Att'y, E. R. BLACK. [ SEAL. ]
B5 ILLINOIS SURETY CO., Surety, — sear. ]
By E. A, NEELY, Its General Agent.
Executed, acknowledged and subscribed before me this 19th day of
Dec., 1911.
[N. P. SEAL. ] W. C. LANIER,
N. P., Fulton Co., Ga.
saeemeeeeeneinenibtetiiamaaeaaiatie eee eae -
eciere
16 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
Justification of Surety.
STATE OF GEORGIA,
Fulton County:
In person appeared before me W. C. Lanier, a Notary Public i
and for said county, E. A. Neely, who on oath says that he is a re:
dent of Fulton county and said State; that he is General Agent |
Illinois Surety Company, which Company is worth more than or
thousand dollars (over and above all exceptions and claims ¢
every kind) subject to the foregoing execution.
E. A. NEELY.
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 19th day of Dec. 1911.
W. C. LANIER,
[N. P. SEAL. | N. P., Fulton Co., Ga,
Entry for Minutes.
STATE OF GEORGIA,
Fulton County:
H. E. Pucxert, Plaintiff, :
v.
SouTHeRN Rat~way Company et al., Defendant.
36 The Defendant, the Southern Railway Company, being th
petitioner in the foregoing petition for the removal of. th
cause aforesaid, having within the time provided by law filed it
petition for the removal of this cause to the Cireuit Court of th
United States for the Northern District of Georgia, and havin
at the same time offered its bond in the sum of One Thousand do!
lars, with Illinois Surety Co. good and sufficient surety, pursuan
to the statutes and conditions according to law:
Now, therefore, this Couri does hereby accept and approve sai
bond and accept said position, and does order that the same remat
filed with the Clerk of this Court; and it is ordered that this cause b
not removed for trial to the next Circuit Court of the United State
for the Northern District of Georgia, pursuant to the statutes of th
United States, and that all proceedings of and in this Court be staye
and suspended.
By the Court: The petition for removal is overruled and denie
Dec. 20, 1911.
H. M. REID, Judge.
Filed in office this the 20th Dee., 1911. T. C. Miller, D. Cl’k.
+ auchendas
a\
{
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 17
37 (Exceptions Pendente Lite.)
GEORGIA,
Fulton County:
Be it remembered that on the 20th day of December, 1911, before
his Honor, H. M. Reid, Judge of the City Court of Atlanta, Judge
then and there presiding, there came on to be heard the petition of
the Southern Railway Company for the removal of the above stated
case to the United States Circuit Court for the Northern District
of Georgia, and that the said defendant presented a proper petition
and bond for removal and that upon consideration. the said petition
for removal was by the said Judge overruled and denied, to which rul-
ing, Judgment and order of the court the defendant then and
there excepted and now excepts, and assigns the same as error. This
defendant shows that a proper petition and bond for removal were
presented within the legal limit of time and in accordance with the
statutes of the United States relating thereto and that the petition
for removal should have been granted and the said. cause should have
been ordered removed to the said Circuit Court of the United States
for the Northern District of Ga.
And now within the time allowed by law, comes the defendant
and tenders this its bill of exceptions pendente lite and prays the
same may be certified as true and be ordered to be entered upon the
minutes and be made a part of the record in the said case.
38 McDANIEL & BLACK anp
E. A. NEELY,
Attys for Sou. Rwy. Co.
I do hereby certify that the above and foregoing bill of exceptions
pendente lite is true. It is ordered that the same be entered upon the
minutes and be made a part of the record in the above stated case.
This Dee. 20th, 1911.
H. M. REID,
Judge C.C. A,
Filed in office this the 20th day of Dec. 1911. T. C. Miller,
D. Cl’k.
(Demurrer. )
GEORGIA,
Fulton County:
Now comes the Southern Railway Co.. one of the defendants in
the above stated case, and without waiving its petition for removal
heretofore filed therein, but relying and insisting upon same,
demurs to the plaintiff’s declaration upon the following grounds,
to wit:
1. Because no cause of action is set out therein against this de-
fendant.
2. Because no cause of action is set out in the first count of the
said declaration against this defendant.
38—598
PAGS
18 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
3. Because no cause of action is set out in the second
39 count of the said declaration against this defendant.
4, Because the said declaration is duplicitous, it being ap-
parent therefrom that the plaintiff was an employe of an interstate
railroad being a common carrier and doing an interstate business,
it being alleged in the second count thereof that the plaintiff at
the time of the alleged injury was engaged in interstate commerce,
and that the defendant was a common carrier by railroad, engaged
in interstate commerce, and if the said railroad is liable at all it would
be liable under the Act of Congress approved April 22, 1908, as
amended on April 5th, 1910, upon which said second count. is
based, which said Act supercedes the statutes and laws of the State
of Georgia, upon which the first count is preideated,
5. Defendant demurs to the said declaration upon the ground
that there is a misjoinder of causes of action therein.
The first count sets forth a cause of action based upon the statutes
and laws of the State of Georgia and the second count sets forth a
cause of action based upon the Employers’ Liability Act of Con-
eress, That the two causes of action are inconsistent and incongruous
and not cumulative of each other.
Any cause of action based upon the said Act of Congress being,
exclusive of all other rights of action, either under the
40 common law or under the statutes and laws of the State of
Ga.
6. Defendant demurs to the first count of the said declaration and
moves that the same be stricken on the ground that the Act of
Congress pleaded and relied upon in the second count of said declara-
tion is exclusive.
7. Defendant demurs to the second count of the said declaration
on the ground that the City Court of Atlanta has no jurisdiction
to maintain an action based upon the Employers’ Liability Act. of
Congress; that the said Act of Congress is a law of the United States,
and an action based thereon can be brought only in the inferior
courts of the United States organized and existing under the laws
of the United States.
8 Defendant demurs to the second count of said declaration the
same being based upon the Act of Congress approved April 22.
1908. as amended April 5, 1910, entitled “An Act Relating to the
Liability of Common Carriers by Railroad to their Employees in
certain cases.” for that the said Act of Congress is unconstitutional
and void for the following reasons:
(a) Because the said Act of Congress aforexaid, same having
been approved April 22, 1908, as amended by Act of Apr. 5, 1910,
and pleaded in the said declaration, deals with and legislates upon
a subject which is not within the jurisdiction of the Congres
41 of the United States. Such Acts of Congress undertake to
regulate the relations of master and servant and the Constitu-
tion of the United States under which powers are delegated to Con-
gress and which contain- subjects which Congress shall have the
right to control and upon which it shall legislate does not delegate
the power to legislate in this respect to Congress, and Congress has
no power except those delegated to it by the constitution of the
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 19
United States the passage of said Acts was without authority or
constitutional warrant.
(6) Said Act is further unconstitutional for the reason that it
takes the property of the Southern Railway Company without due
process of law, contrary to the fifth amendment to the Constitution
of the United States, as follows:
“Article V. No person shall be held to answer for a capital or
otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of
a grand jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or
in the militia, when in actual service in time of war or public
danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be
‘twice put in jeopardy for life or limb; nor be compelled in any erimi-
nal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life,
liberty or property without due process of law: nor shall private prop-
erty be taken for public use, without just compensation.”
42 Defendant’s property is taken without due process of
law for the reason that the said Act of Congress in the 3rd, 4th
and 5th sections thereof declares different rules of Jaw and impose-
‘different and greater burdens upon interstate common carriers by
railroad than are imposed on other interstate common carriers, and
that thereby an unreasonable classification is made of interstate com-
‘mon carriers by railroad and the property of this defendant is taken
without due process of law.
(c) Said Act of Congress is further unconstitutional and contrary
to the fifth amendment of the Constitution of the United States,
above quoted, for the reason that the 5th section thereof deprives
it of its property without due process of law in the further particular
that it unreasonably limits, regulates and deprives it of its right
to contract which is a property right and in this way defendant
is deprived by said Act of Congress of its property without due
process of law.
9. Defendant demurs to the second count of the said declara-
tion based upon the said Act of Congress on the ground that there
is a misjoinder of parties defendant, the said Act of Congress giv-
ing no right of action against a co-emplovee of the said plaintiff.
10. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 12, and moves to
strike the same on the ground that the allegations therein con-
43 tained are irrelevant and immaterial,
11. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 13 on the
vround that the allegations therein contained are irrelevant and im-
material.
12. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 14, on the ground
that it is not shown wherein it was the duty of petitioner to rescue
O’Berry, and on the further ground that the allegations as to the
rescuing of the said O’Berry are irrelevant and immaterial,
13. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 34 and moves to
strike therefrom the words: “Ile was capable of earning $93.67
per month, or other large sum.” the said allegation being irrele-
vant and immaterial, and not being based upon the actual earnings
of the petition-.
14. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 48 on the ground
20 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
that the allegation therein contained is a conclusion and is vague,
indefinite and uncertain, it not being shown in what manner the
said Southern Railway Co., was engaged in interstate commerce
at the time of the alleged injury.
15. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 44 on the ground
that the said allegation therein contained is a conclusion; and
further, on the ground that the same is vague, indefinite and
uncertain, it not being sufficiently set forth in what manner the
petition- was engaged in interstate commerce at the time of the
alleged injury.
4 16. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 48 on the
ground that the allegations therein contained are irrelevant
and immaterial.
17. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 49 on the ground
that the allegations therein contained are irrelevant and imma-
terial.
18. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 50 on the ground
that it is not shown how it became the duty of petitioner to rescue
the said O’Berry or assist in clearing away said track, and upon
the further ground that the said allegation is irrelevant and im-
material.
19. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 55, and moves to
strike the words “So as to reach the scene of the collision at the
point where O’Berry was pinned beneath the box car,” said allega-.
tion being irrelevant and immaterial.
20. Defendant specially demurs to paragraph 70 and moves to
strike therefrom: “Ile was capable of earning $93.67 per month or
other large sum,” the said allegation being irrelevant and imma-
terial, and not being an allegation of the petitioner’s actual earn-
ings,
Wherefore the dismissal of said suit is prayed.
45 McDANTIEL & BLACK anp
E, A. NEELY,
Attys for Def’t So. Ry. Co.
Filed in office this the 29th day of Dec., 1911. W. W. Clarke,
D, Cl’k.
(A nswer.)
Grorara, Fulton County:
Now comes the Southern Railway Company, one of the defendants
in the above stated case, and without waiving its petition for re-
moval or its demurrer heretofore filed therein, and makes answer
to the plaintiff’s declaration and says:
First Count.
1. For want of sufficient information defendant is unable to
either admit or deny the allegations of paragraphs 1, 2 and 3.
2. Defendant admits paragraph 4
we
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. et
3. Defendant denies paragraph 5.
4, For want of suflicient information defendant is unable to
ither admit or deny paragraph 6,
5. Defendant denies paragraph 7.
6. For want of suflicient information defendant is unable either
admit or deny paragraphs 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, and 14.
7. Defendant admits paragraph 15.
6 8. For want of sufficient information defendant is un-
able either to admit or deny the allegations contained in
varagraphs 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26.
9. Defendant denies paragraphs 27, 28, 29,
10. For want of suflicient information defendant is unable either
o admit or deny paragraph 30.
11. Defendant denies paragraphs 31, 32, 33.
12. For want of sufficient information defendant is unable either
o admit or deny paragraph 34.
Second Count.
| 1. For want of sufficient information defendant is unable either
o admit or deny paragraphs 35, 36, 37.
2. Defendant admits paragraph 38.
3. Defendant denies paragraph 39.
4. For want of sufficient information defendant is unable either
o admit or deny paragraphs 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48. 49, 50.
5. Defendant admits paragraph 51,
6. For want of sufficient information defendant is unable either
0 admit or deny paragraphs 52, 53, 54,55, 56. 57. 58. 60, 61, 62.
7. Defendant denies paragraphs 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69.
AT 8. For want of sufficient information defendant is unable
either to admit or deny paragraph 70,
9. For further answer in this behalf. this defendant denies that
t has been guilty of any of the acts of negligence charged in the
id declaration, and denies that it has injured and damaged the
titioner in the sum set forth in said declaration or of any sum
vhatever.
10. For further answer in this behalf. this defendant says that
n the second count of the said declaration it is alleged that the
laintiff and this defendant were engaged in interstate commerce
the time of the alleged injury, which makes a cause of action
ased upon the Employers’ Liability Act of Congress approved April
2, 1908, as amended April 5th. 1910. and this defendant shows
at the said Act of Congress is unconstitutional and void for the fol-
Wing reasons, to wit:
(a) Because the said Act of Congress aforesaid, same having been
pproved April 22, 1908, as amended by Act of April 5th, 1910, and
leaded in the said declaration. deals with and legislates upon a
ubject which is not within the jurisdiction of the Congress of the
‘nited States. Such Act of Congress undertakes to reculate the
elation of master and servant. and the Constitution of the United
tates under which powers are delegated to Congress and which
es . senere ~
SE IN CENTER
22 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
contain- subjects which Congress shall have the right to con:
48 trol and upon which it shall legislate does not delegate the
power to legislate in this respect to Congress, and Congres
has no powers except those delegated to it by the Constitution of
the United States the passage of said Act was without authority or
constitutional warrant. |
(6) Said Act is further unconstitutional for the reason that if
takes the property of the Southern Railway Company without du
process of law, contrary to the fifth amendment to the Constitution
of the United States, as follows:
“Article V. No person shall be held to answer for a capital or
otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indietmens
of a grand jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces
or in the militia, when in actual service in time of war or public
danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be
twice put in jeopardy for life or limb; nor be compelled in any
criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of
life, liberty or property without due process of law; nor shall pri
vate property be taken for public use, without just compensation.’
Defendant’s property is taken without due process of law for the
reason that the said Act of Congress in the 3rd, 4th and Sth sections
thereof declares different rules of law and impose- different and
greater burdens upon interstate common carriers by railroat
49 than are imposed on other interstate common carriers anc
that thereby an unreasonable classification is made of inter
state common carriers by railroad and the property of this defendan
is taken without due process of law.
(ec) Said Act of Congress is further unconstitutional and con
trary to the fifth amendment of the Constitution of the United
States, above quoted, for the reason that the 5th section thereof de.
prives it of its property without due process of law in the further
particular that it unreasonably limits, regulates and deprives it of it
right to contract which is a property right. and in this wav defend
ant is deprived by said Act of Congress of its property without du
process of law.
McDANIEL & BLACK,
E. A. NEELY,
A tt ys for Def't.
Filed in office this the 29th day of Dec. 1911. W. W. Clarke’
D. Cl’k.
(Order on Demurrer.)
The within demurrer coming on to be heard paragraphs 9, 14!
and 15 of the demurrer are sustained,
The names of the defendants other than %e Railway Company
are stricken from the second count and the suit on the sec
50 ond count is dismissed as to the said R. L. Cowan, Samue
Smith and J. N. Biddy.
The plaintiffs shall have 10 days in which to amend the para-
graphs to which special demurrers are sustained, |
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY ys. H. E. PUCKETT. 23
Plaintiff shall have 10 days within which to elect to strike either
unt No. 2 of the declaration or to strike Cowan, Smith and Biddy
is defendants in Count No. 1, otherwise the demurrer is overruled,
This January 6, 1911. (2).
H. M. REID, Judge.
(Exceptions Pendente Lite.)
AEORGIA, Fulton County:
Be it remembered that on the 6th day of January, 1912, there
same on to be heard before His Honor, TH. M. Reid, the demurrer
f the defendant, the Southern Railway Company, to the declara-
ion of the plaintiff in the above stated case and that after argument
the court entered the following order:
“The within demurrer coming on to be heard. paragraphs 9, 14
ind 15 of the demurrer are sustained.
The names of the defendants other than the Railway Company
ire stricken from the second count and the suit on the second count
s dismissed as to the said R. L. Cowan, Samuel Smith and J. N.
Biddy.
The plaintiffs shall have ten days in which to amend paragraphs
to which special demurrers are sustained.
1 Plaintiff shall have ten days within which to elect to strike
Count No. 2 of the declaration or to strike Cowan, Smith and
siddy as defendants in Count No. 1, otherwise the demurrer. is
verruled,
This Jan. 6th, 1912.
H. M. REID. Judge.”
To the ruling, judgement and order of the Court in overruling the
rounds of demurrer not specifically sustained by the foregoing
rder the defendant then and there excepted and now excepts and
ssigns the same as error and for specific assignment of error this
efendant avers that the said demurrer should have been sustained
pon each and every general and special ground thereof,
And now within the time allowed by law comes the defendant
nd files this its bill of exceptions pendente lite and prays that the
une may be certified as true and be ordered to be placed upon the
Minutes and be made a part of the record in the above stated case.
McDANIEL & BLACK anp
E. A. NEELY,
Atty’s for Def't.
I do certify that the foregoing bill of exceptions pendente lite is
ue. It is ordered that the same be entered upon the minutes and
» made a part of the record in the above stated Case,
This January 10th, 1912.
H. M. REID,
Judge C. C.'A,
24 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT,
52 Filed in office this the 10th day of January, 1912. T. C
Miller, D. Cl’k,
(Amended Petition.)
Georaia, Fulton County:
Now comes the plaintiff in the above stated case, and in compli
ance with the order of the court, passed upon the demurrer file:
therein, amends the declaration filed therein, as follows:
First.
By striking count No. 1. |
Second.
By striking paragraphs 35, 36 and 37 in count No. 2.
Third.
By striking Paragraph 39 and substituting in the place thereoj
the following: “That the said defendant, the Southern Railwa
Company has injured and damaged your petitioner in the sum
Thirty Thousand (30,000) Dollars, and that your petitioner avers.
Fourth.
By adding to the second count, paragraph 43a, which is as fol
lows: “That on the occasion herein referred to, the engine and cai
hereinafter referred to, upon which A. P. O’Berry was at work, 2
is herein set out, were engaged in interstate commerce; th
53 the engine with which the said A. P. O'Berry was maki
up freight train, known on the defendant's schedule as Trai
No. 75, whose destination was Birmingham, Alabama, and alj
freight train, known on defendant’s schedule as train No. 87, who;
destination was Chattanooga, Tenn. That the following cars wej
being put in said Train No. 75, at the time of the aforesaid collisiog
The initials and numbers of each of the said cars are herein set otf
as follows, to wit:
Sou. 51009 F. E. Sou. 11985 B. E.
«" 54087 G. BE. “” 18155 «
“ 415703 F. E. L. & N. 4763 B. L.
“ 51754 F. E. Sou. 30680 VL.
“ 183705 G. E. C.& 0. 4819 B. L.
P. L. 517117 B. E. M. & O. 78659 B. F.
N. O. M. & C. 1225 B. B. CR. & P. 3732 B. E.
1. C. 11984 B. E. Sou. 33775 V. L.
Sou. 38527 V. L. “" 11852 B. LL. |
“” 137761 B. E. A. G. 8. 11852 B. L.
« 95669 V. E. Sou. 136613 |
“ 16524 B. E. Sou. 37035 V. L.
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY YS. I. E. PUCKETT. 25
I. C. 34248 B. E. W. C. 17940 B. L.
Sou. 131956 “
Sou. 23936 V. L.
Sou. 132492 B. L.
B. & M. 60437 “
A. & V. 21059 “
A. T. & S. F. 43161 B. L.
Sou. 39243 V. L.
Sou. 12584 B. L.
Sou. 14994 B. L.
ASTROS TEE
' The said train No. 75 was due to leave Atlanta for Birmingham
pat 11:30 P.M. About fifteen of the cars out of the above named list
of cars were coupled to the aforesaid engine at the time of the said
collision,
' By adding to the second count. paragraph 43h, as follows: The
P exact cars coupled to said engine at *he time of the aforesaid col-
; lision, your petitioner is not advised, but the same were cars
p54 which were to be placed by the said engine and crew in the
aforesaid train No. 75,
By adding to the second count, paragraph 43¢, as follows: it
being your petitioner’s duty in obedience to the instructions of the
defendant company to aid and assist in releasing the said A. P.
O’Berry from his perilous position, which is hereinafter referred to,
and also to aid and assist in jacking up the car and thereby releas-
ing said A. P. O’Berry from the danger to which he was exposed,
as is hereby set out, and it was in obedience to the instructions of
the defendant company, your petitioner’s duty to aid and assist the
crew of said switch engine in moving and clearing up said collision
and in moving said interstate cars so as to enable the crew with
which A. P. O’Berry was at work to finish making up said freight
train No. 75, which was an interstate train. as aforesaid,
By adding to the second count paragraph 44a, as follows: That
at the time of the infliction of said injuries upon your petitioner as
is herein set out, your petitioner was engaged in and about the work
and movement of interstate cars, as is hereinbefore set out, and your
petitioner was engaged in interstate commerce as aforesaid. That
the engine and cars referred to at the time Your petitioner was in-
i jured, as hereinafter set out, were engaged in interstate commerce
as aforesaid.
55 By adding to the second count paragraph 47¢, as follows:
That the said defendant company, at the time of the inflic-
tion of the injuries upon your petitioner, as aforesaid, was engaged
in interstate commerce as aforesaid.
Fifth.
By striking paragraphs 45, 46 and 47 from count 2 of said decla-
ration.
Sixth.
By striking the words “the said” in line one of paragraph 60,
) 4598
Eo
26 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. Hl. E. PUCKETT.
Seventh.
By striking the words “the said” in line one of paragraph 61.
Eighth.
By striking the words “the said” in line one of paragraph 62.
Ninth.
By striking paragraph 63 and substituting in the place thereof,
the following:
That the said defendant company was negligent in that the said
old cross ties were lying in manner and place alongside of said track
as aforesaid.
56 Tenth.
By striking paragraph 64, and substituting in the place thereof,
the following: that the said Southern Railway Company was negli-
gent in that said three large clinkers were on said road bed in man-_
ner and place as aforesaid.
Eleventh.
By striking paragraph 65 of said declaration, and substituting in
place thereof, the following: That the said Southern Railway Com-
pany was negligent in that the said grass had grown up on said road
bed, as aforesaid.
Twelfth.
By striking from paragraph 70 of said declaration in lines four
and five, the words “or other large sum.”
Thirteenth.
By striking from the prayer in said declaration, the following
words in the fourth and third lines from bottom of same, namely,
to wit: “R. L. Cowan, and Sam'l Smith and J. N. Biddy.”
Fourteenth.
Plaintiff in obedience to the order passed by this Honorable Court
elects to strike count No, 1 from the declaration filed therein, and
relies upon Count No, 2 as amended.
ATKINSON & BORN,
PI ff’s Att’ ys.
cor
~I
Allowed and ordered filed. This 7th day of June, 1913.
H. M. REID,
Judge C.C. A.
Filed in office this the 7th day of June, 1913. S. T. Conyers,
D. Cl’k.
FP
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. BE. PUCKETT, 27
(Demurrer.)
Georaia, Fulton County:
_ _ Now comes the defendant, by its counsel, McDaniel and Black, and
i shows to the court that heretofore, to wit: on the 10th day of Novem-
: ber, 1911, the original petition in this cause was filed, and that on
) the 380th day of December, 1911, this defendant duly filed its gen-
eral and special demurrer to the original petition as filed, and on
‘the 6th day of January, 1912, said general and special demurrers
_were heard by this court and order of the court duly had and en-
tered thereon. That thereafter, to wit, on the 18th day of January,
1912, this defendant presented to this court its bill of exceptions
pendente lite, excepting to the said order of this court as entered on
the said demurrers of this defendant, and said bill of exceptions
pendente lite were duly signed and certified by this court and filed
on the 18th day of January, 1912: and that thereafter, to wit, on
the 7th day of June, 1913, plaintiff filed in this cause two amend-
“ments to his original petition, which amendments materially change
‘ his cause of action as originally filed: and defendant now and
£58 herein renews his demurrers to the petition as amended and
f
i
to the petition and amendments and for grounds of demurrer
says:
1. That no cause of action is set out in the petition with its amend-
ments.
2. That the petition as amended is filed under the Act of Coneress
of date April 22, 1908, known as the Federal Employers’ Liability
Act, and that the petition and amendment shows that the petition
as amended cannot be maintained under that Act, for the reason
gthat plaintiff was not engaged in interstate commerce at the time
of his alleged injury.
4. Defendant demurs specially to that part of paragraph 4 of the
mendment which is as follows:
“That at the time of the infliction of said injuries upon your peti-
ioner, as is herein set out, your petitioner was enenged in and about
he work and movement of interstate ears as is hereinbefore set out.
nd your petitioner was engaged in interstate commerce as afore-
aid.
That the engine and ears referred to at the time vour petitioner
as injured, as hereinafter set out. were engaged in interstate com-
erce, as aforesaid.” on the ground that said portion of said para-
raph 4 is a mere conclusion and is indefinite and uneertain and
does not show how nor wherein petitioner was eneaged in
9 interstate Commerce, nor what work nor what movement of
interstate cars is referred to. nor how nor wherein he was
ngaged in anv such work or movement, nor how nor wherein he
as at work upon said engine or ears referred to, nor how nor
herein the said engine and cars were engaged in interstate com-
erce.
5. Defendant demurs specially to that portion of paragraph 4 of
he amendment which reads as follows:
28 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
“That the said defendant company, at the time of the infliction
of the injuries upon your petitioner, as aforesaid, was engaged in
interstate commerce as aforesaid.” on the ground that said language
is a mere conclusion of the pleader and sets forth no facts showing
that defendant company was engaged in interstate commerce.
Wherefore, Defendant prays that this its general and special de.
murrers be sustained and said cause be dismissed.
McDANIEL anp BLACK,
Attys for Def't.
Filed in office this the 7th day of June, 1913. S. T. Conyers,
D. Cl’k. |
|
(Order.) |
The foregoing demurrer having been heard, and argument o
counsel had thereon, it is ordered that the demurrer be overruled
upon each and every ground thereof. |
This June 7th, 1913. |
H. M. REID, Judge.
60 (Plaintiff's Amendment.)
GeoraiA, Fulton County:
Now comes the plaintiff in the above stated case, and with leave
of the court first had and obtained, amends the amendment. to the
said deciaration which has heretofore been allowed and filed by add.
ing at the end of Paragraph 43-C of said amendment the followin
to wit:
“Which were instructions given orally to the plaintiff by A. J,
Gilleland, who was Chief Car Inspector of the defendant company
and under whom your petitioner was at work at the time he wa
injured as aforesaid, and whose orders your petitioner was in duty
bound to obey, and the said Gilleland had full authority to give th
said instructions to your petitioner.”
ATKINSON axp BORN,
Petitioner's Att’ ys.
Allowed and ordered filed. This 7th day of June, 1913.
H. M. REID,
Judge C.C. A.
Filed in office this the 7th day of June, 1918. 8S, T. Conyers
D. Cl’k.
61 (Amendment to Par. 32.)
Grorata, Fulton County:
i
The plaintiff now comes and amends his declaration filed i
the above entitled action by adding to paragraph thirty-two thereo!
the following to be designated as “Paragraph 32-A.”
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
And your petitioner further avers that prior to the infliction of the
said injuries he was able to and did in the prosecution of his daily
ork use his legs in a perfectly normal manner, they being of equal
ength and sustaining in equal proportion the weight of his body,
ut that since the infliction of the said injuries and as a consequence
hereof his left leg has been so shortened and the hip joint thereof has
become so out of adjustment as that he is now compelled to place
Imost the entire weight of his body upon his right leg, so that while
standing firmly on his right foot his left will not reach the ground
by one inch and a half or more, that his back and spinal column
ave been twisted and distorted so that he cannot as therebefore stand
in an erect and upright position with both feet on the ground at the
me time, so that vour petitioner is now and henceforth will con-
inue to be a permanent and helpless cripple, and petitioner prays
his amendment be allowed.
ou oT
off ATKINSON anp BORN,
df Atty’s for PI ff.
é We acknowledge due and legal service of notice of the
62 foregoing amendment, waive copy and all other and further
service of the same.
McDANIEL axnp BLACK,
Attys for Deft.
Amendment allowed. This March 9th, 1914.
" H. M. REID,
ie Judge C.C. A,
o Filed in office this the 9th day of March, 1914. S. T. Conyers,
1D. Clk.
Ay
(Amendment by Defendant.)
TEORGIA, Fulton County:
Now comes the defendant the Southern Railway Company by its
counsel McDaniel and Black and amends its plea in this cause filed,
nd for amendment avers.
7 1. Defendant denies paragraph three of amendment of plaintiff
“filed June 7, 1913.
*, 2. In response to paragraph four of plaintiff's amendment. filed
une 7th, 1913, defendant avers: (1) That at the time A. r,
‘Berry was injured the engine with which he was working had at-
Wtached to it one empty ear which was sent to the repair track, and
ne loaded car whose destination was Eastman, Ga, (2) Defendant
lenies the other allegations of said paragraph four of said amend-
ent.
4 3. Defendant denies all the other allegations contained in
63 paragraphs nine, ten and eleven of said amendment,
j McDANIEL axp BLACK,
i Attys for Def't.
3
ET TT Ls SET LRA
30 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
GaA., Fulton County:
Personally before me a Notary Public in and for said county a
pears W. G. Anderson who being sworn says that he is agent oMff
Southern Ry. Co., and that the foregoing amendment is true ang
that the allegations therein contained were not omitted from they
original answer for the purpose of delay, and that this amendmen
is not now offered for the purpose of delay.
W. G. ANDERSON.
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this 9th day of Mareh, 1913
S. T. CONYERS,
N. P., Fulton Co., Ga.
Filed in office this the 9th day of March, 1914. 8. T. Conyers
D. Cl’k.
64 (Amendirent by Petitioner.)
GeoraiA, Fulton County:
Your petitioner further amends paragraph 43 of his petition by
adding after said paragraph as amended the following:
Your petitioner alleges that on the date of the collision men
tioned in paragraph 45 of the original declaration your petitione:
being then and there in the employment of the defendant company,
in the capacity of inspector of cars in its said yards, his duties r
quired him among other things to inspect cars engaged in interstat
traflic; that at the exact time of said collision and for some time
theretofore he had been engaged in inspecting cars which were t
be incorporated in train No. 75 of the defendant, which was sched,
uled to leave Atlanta that night carrying through freight over th
line of the defendant’s road to Birmingham and other points 1
the State of Alabama; that at the time of the happening of sai
collision he had already inspected twenty or twenty-live of th
‘ars destined to compose said train and these cars had been place
on the track at which the train was to be made up and that h
was then at the instant of said collision engaged in making ou
a record of his said inspection when his work in making out sai
record and in inspecting the remainder of said cars, that is to saj
twelve or fifteen additional cars which were to be incorporated in
train No, 75, was interrupted by the collision aforesaid
69 happening and blocking the track over which the remainde
of said cars were to pass in order for him to inspect them
so that said cars could not pass over said track but were compelle
to be detoured over another track; that in consequence of the in
juries in the petition mentioned sustained in manner and by mean
in his petition stated, he was for the time being wholly disabled am
was unable to complete the inspection of the remainder of th
‘vars destined to and which thereafter did go into said interstat
train No, 75 as aforesaid and that as a consequence of the injuri
sustained as aforesaid not only was he so unable to complete the
— ee
_
| Pee eh a
az
ask of inspecting the said cars in which duty he was specially en-
paged at the time aforesaid, but the departure of the train ‘upon
ts scheduled time was delayed for a space of one hour and other
ong time, thus impeding and interrupting and delaying the said
nterstate train upon its journey, and so your petitioner alleges that
he was thus and in manner aforesaid at the time aforesaid engaged
n interstate commerce.
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 31
ATKINSON anp BORN,
Attys for PVF.
We acknowledge due and legal service of the foregoing amend-
ment, waive copy and all other and further service of the same.
April 6th, 1914,
McDANIEL axp BLACK,
| Att ys for the Def't.
bi Amendment allowed and ordered filed over objection of
deft. April 6th, 1914.
H. M. REID, Judge.
Filed in office this the 6th day of April, 1914. S. T. Conyers,
D. Clk.
(Verdict.)
We the Jury find for the Plaintiff ($7,250.) Seven Thousand Two
Hundred and Fifty Dollars.
This 4/7/1914.
J. M. COCHRAN, Foreman.
(Judgment.)
The jury having found for the plaintiff H. E. Puckett against
ve defendant Southern Railway Company in the sum of Seventy-
ro Hundred Fifty and no/100 ($7,250) Dollars. It is therefore
sidered, ordered and adjudged that the said plaintiff TH. E. Puck-
t, do have and recover of and from the said defendant Southern
ailway Co., the sum of Seventy-two Hundred Fifty and no/100
$7,250) Dollars, together with the costs of suit,
This 9th day of April, 1914.
ATKINSON anv BORN,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
7 (Exceptions Pendente Lite.)
EORGIA, Fulton County:
Be it remembered that the above case was put upon trial at the
arch Term 1914 of the city court of Atlanta, and that during
e progress of said trial, to wit: on April 3, 1914, after the plaintiff
ad introduced all of his evidence and closed his ease, the defendant,
uthern Railway Company, moved for a nonsuit upon the ground
—
we
oe IN CENTER
$2 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
that the plaintiff had failed by his evidence to sustain the case mad
by his petition and the amentment thereto in the following partic
lars:
1. Because the plaintiff had failed to show by his evidence th:
he was employed in interstate commerce at the time of his allege
injury for which suit was brought.
2. Because the plaintiff had failed by his evidence to show thi
the defendant was guilty of the acts of negligence charged in th
petition.
Which motion for nonsuit the court did then, on the 3rd day «
April, 1914, overrule, and such ruling of the court overruling thi
motion for nonsuit Southern Railway Company then excepted {
and now excepts to the same and assigns the same as error, and fi
specific assignment of error defendant says that the court shoul
have sustained its motion and nonsuited the plaintiff’s ca
68 for the reason that plaintiff did not show by his evidence th:
he was employed in interstate commerce at the time of hi
alleged injury and therefore entitled to bring his suit under the Ai
of Congress of 1908 as amended by Act of Congress of 1910, com
monly know as the Iederal Employers’ Liability ct; and for th
further reason that plaintiff did not show by his evidence that th
defendant was guilty of actionable negligence.
Be it further remembered that during the progress of said tri
to wit: on April 6th, 1914, plaintiff, H. FE. Puckett, presented ¢
amendment to his petition, which amendment defendant, Southe
Railway Company, objected to upon the ground that the same di
not in and of itself show and did not in connection with the alleg
tions in the original petition and the amendments thereto show th:
plaintiff was engaged in interstate commerce at the time of h
alleged injuries and thereby entitled to the benefits of the Act :
Congress of 1908 and the amendment thereto generally known
the Federal Employers’ Liability Act. The court overruled t!
defendant’s objection to the said amendment allowing the saw
which ruling and order of the court allowing said amendme
Southern Railway Company then and there excepted to and ne
excepts to the same and assigns the same as error, and for speci
assignment of error the Southern Railway Company says that sa
amendment should have been disallowed for the reaso
69 stated in the objections which Southern Railway Compa
made thereto.
After the allowance of said amendment Southern Railway (
renewed its general demurrer to the declaration as amended a
urged the dismissal of plaintiff's suit upon the ground that the pe
tion as amended did not by its allegations show that the plaint
H. E. Puckett, was engaged in interstate commerce at the time
his alleged injury so as to bring him within the purview and
entitle him to the benefits of the Act of Congress of 1908 as amend
generally known as the Federal Employers’ Liability Aet. T
court overruled defendant’s demurrer to the declaration as amend
which ruling, order and judgment of the court Southern Railw
Company then excepted to and now excepts to the same and assigy
é
SEA OR SNS SR a
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 33
id the same as error, and for specific assignment of error Southern
cy Railway Company says that its demurrer to plaintiff's petition which
was urged after the allowance of his amendment on April 6th, 1914,
ha should have been sustained and that plaintiff's petition should have
yea been dismissed upon all the grounds of such general demurrer, in-
cluding the ground that the allegations of the petition as amended
hag did not show that plaintiff was employed in interstate commerce at
tha the time of his alleged injury.
And now Southern Railway Company, at the same term of court
at which the rulings, judgment and orders complained of
70 Were made, an.’ within the time allowed by law, presents
this its exceptions pendente lite and prays that the same
may be certified, allowed ordered filed and made a part of the record
in the case.
McDANIEL & BLACK,
EDGAR A. NEELY,
Attys for Sou. Ry. Co.
I do certify that the foregoing exceptions pendente lite are true,
the recital of facts therein contained being correct. Such excep-
tions pendente lite are hereby allowed, ordered to be filed and made
a part of the record in the case,
April 10, 1914,
7 H. M. REID,
‘ Judge C. C. A.
di
Kled in office this the 10th day of April, 1914.
D. Cl’k.
S. T. Conyers,
(Motion for New Trial.)
Southern Railway Company, defendant, being dissatisfied with
CB the verdict and judgment in said case, Comes now, at the term at
“which the trial was had and before the adjournment thereof, and
“gwithin thirty days from such trial and within the time allowed by
law, and moves the court for a new trial upon the following grounds,
to wit:
71 1. Because the verdict is contrary to the evidence and
without evidence to support it.
2. Because the verdict is decidedly and strongly against the weight
UBof the evidence.
*@ 3. Because the verdict is contrary to law,
'% 4. Because the verdict is excessive In amount.
Wherefore, movant, Southern Railway Company, prays that
these its grounds for new trial he considered and inquired of by the
qoourt and that said verdict be set aside and a new trial ordered in
McDANTEL axp BLACK,
EDGAR A. NEELY,
Att’ys for Movant, Sou. Ry. Co.
oo ies. aed “*
SE IN CENTER
34 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
The foregoing motion for new trial read and considered. The
grounds thereof are approved.
It is ordered that the plaintiff H. E. Puckett, show cause befor
me on the 9th day of May 1914, why the foregoing motion shoul
not be granted, the verdict rendered set aside and a new tria
ordered.
It is further ordered that this motion for new trial and order shal
operate as a supersedeas and that judgment shall be staved anc
execution shall not be issued until the further order of the cour
vacating such supersedeas and revoking said stay.
Let the said H. E. Puckett or his counsel be served with |
72 copy of this motion and order.
It is further ordered that the movant shall have until th
actual hearing of this motion (whether heard at the date above se
or at a future date thereafter, either in term or vacation) in whic
to prepare, have approved and to file brief of the evidence intre
duced upon the trial of the case. Movant. shall further have th
right to amend its motion for new trial and by amendment to ad
further grounds thereto.
This April 10th, 1914.
H. M. REID,
Judge C. C. A.
Due and legal service of the above and foregoing motion for ne
trial and rule nisi is hereby acknowledged. Copy received. A
other and further service waived.
This April 10, 1914.
ATKINSON anxp BORN,
Attys for H. FE, Puckett.
Due and legal service of the within and foregoing motion for ne
trial and rule nisi is hereby acknowledged. Copy received. A
other and further notice and service waived.
This April 18th, 1914.
ATKINSON axp BORN,
Attys for IT. FE. Puckett.
Filed in office this the 10th day of April, 1914. 8S. T. Conyer
D. Cl’k.
73 (Amended Motion.)
Groraia, Fulton County:
Now comes the defendant and movant, Southern Railway Cor
any, and amends its motion for new trial in this case and mov
that a new trial be granted it upon the following additional ground
1. Because the court erred in the following portion of its char;
to the jury:
“The law directs, gentlemen, that it is your duty, where it can |
done, to so reconcile conflicting evidence, if there be such in t]
case, as all the witnesses will be made to speak the truth and pe
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 35
jury be imputed to none of them. But if there should be any evi-
dence in the case in such irreconcilable conflict that this cannot be
done, you would then believe the evidence most reasonable and most
credible to you, and settle the issues by the greater weight or pre-
ponderance of the evidence.”
Movant contends that this charge was error, because the jury was
instructed by the court in mandatory form as to what evidence they
should believe in event of an irreconcilable conflict in the testimoné,
and in this way were instructed in absolute terms what evidence they
should believe where a conflict existed in the testimony which could
not be reconciled; whereas movant contends that the court could not
commit the jury to any precise and absolute method of
14 solving irreconcilable conflicts in evidence,
2. Because the court erred in the following portion of its
tharge to the jury:
“Tf this plaintiff, gentlemen, at the time as alleged by him was
ngaged in making up, as car inspector, a train that was to go bevond
he limits of the State and carry freight bevond the limits of the
state of Georgia, he would have heen engaged in interstate commerce.
And if you believe he was so engaged and while so engaged there was
p sudden emergency in connection with an injury to Berry (whose
lame is set forth in the petition, another amplovee) that in the dis-
tharge of his duty under the rules and instructions from one in au-
hority he represented the company while in an effort to release
) Berry and in a further effort to clear the track for the movement of
ars that were to go into Train 75 with its other ears, with the present
ntention of returning immediately to the work in which he had just
een engaged, he would still, during that period, be engaged in inter-
ate commerce and have the right to maintain this action and re-
oul if otherwise entitled to recover in the case.”
| Movant contends that this charge of the court was error in that.
ecording to its contention, the fact that Puekett mav have heen en-
aged in interstate commerce prior to the time he entered upon the
| work of rescuing O’Berry in connection with the fact that
5 he intends later to resume duties in connection with interstate
commerce would not be the test of his engagement in inter-
ate commerce at the time of his alleged injury: but as movant
spectfully contends, the work upon which he was engaged at the
me of his alleged injury, independent of his prior engagement and
his future intention, determines whether he was engaged in inter-
ate commerce so as to come within the scope, purview or benefits
the Act of Congress of April 26th, 1908, the same beine “An Act
elating to Liability of Common Carriers by Railroad to their Em-
oyees in Certain Cases.” which as amended by the Acts of Congress
proved April oth, L910. is generally known as “The Federal Em-
overs’ Liability Act”: and movant contends that in giving this
struction to the jury the court:
(a) erroneously construed the said Act of Congress above referred
and erred in holding contrary to movant’s contention that Puckett
is engaged in interstate commerce under the stated conditions: and
(6) gave an erroneous application to the said federal law in
estion ;
}
36 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. I. E. PUCKETT.
(ec) and further erred because he was nor warranted in including
in the instructions above quoted this extract, “and in a further
effort to clear the track for the movement of cars that were
76 to go into Train 75 with its other ars,” the plaintiff having
produced no evidence to support the allegation made in an
amendment to his original petition, in substance, that he was engage¢
in an effort to clear the particular track for the passage of cars to be
put in train 75, and movant having explicitly denied such allegation
2 The court erred in including in that portion of its charge
quoted and excepted to in the second eround of this amended motion
the following language, to wit: ; |
“And in a further effort to clear the track for the movement of car
that were to go into Train 75 with its other cars,”
Movant contends that the submission of this issue was erroneou
in that it was unsupported by any evidence, the allegation in respec
thereto in an amendment of plaintiffs petition having heen ex
pressly denied by defendant. Movant further contends that, i
event this submission to the jury could be justified, it was error 1@
submit only a single alternative, to wit: plaintiff's contention, with”
out at the same time stating and submitting the contrary contention,
which the movant had made by its answer and supported by its evn
dence. P
4. Because the court erred in admitting over objection of movan
the following rules of defendant company in evidence:
“Rule 816. They must not allow lumber, timber, ties, rails, ¢
other freight or material to be piled within ten feet of th
77 track or within seven feet of any side track.
Rule 852. They must not allow lumber, timber, ties, rai
or other freight or material to be piled or placed upon the groun
within ten feet of the main track or seven feet of any side track, any
must see that all such freight or material left near the tracks is §
placed that it cannot fall upon or near them.”
(Rule 816 is addressed to Track Supervisor, and Rule 852 is a
dressed to Track Foreman.)
Movant objected to the admission of these rules upon the grou
that the same showed upon their face, by their context, and by the
conjunction with other rules, that they were not intended to app
to yards, such as the one in which Puckett claimed to have sustain
his injuries, but that their application and requirements are co
fined to the main lines of the company and sidings between te
minals. Movant further objected to the admission of said rules uy
the further ground. that, when considered in connection with Ri
796 addressed to Yard Masters. as follows:
“Rule 796. They must see that their vards are kept in good ord
that links, pins, scrap and other material scattered upon the grou
are promptly collected and stored and that nothing is allowed to
main upon or between the tracks that involves risk to property or |
sons.”
it was apparent that the duty of keeping a yard, such as t
78 in which Puckett sustained his alleged injury. devolved u
an agent of defendant company other than Track Forem
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H, E. PUCKETT. 37
and Track Supervisor, to wit: the Yard Master as against whom no
negligence was charged; and movant respectfully contends that the
objection which it made to the admission in evidence of the two rules
in question should have been sustained and that the court erred in
admitting said rules in evidence.
McDANIEL ann BLACK,
Movant's Att ys.
The foregoing amendment to motion for new trial filed by South-
erm Railway Company is hereby allowed. The grounds of said
amended motion, as well as those contained in the original motion,
are hereby approved. The recitals of fact in the original and
amended motion are true and correct.
Il. M. REID,
Judge (.C. A.
Due and legal service of the foregoing amendment to the motion
for new trial is acknowledged. Copy received. All other and fur-
ther service waived. June 23rd, 1914,
ATKINSON axp BORN,
Attys for IT. FE. Puckett.
| Filed in office 23 June, 1914. 8S. T. Conyers, D. Cl’k.
79 (Order Overruling. )
After hearing argument upon the foregoing motion for new trial
pnd the amendment thereto, it is ordered that the same be and is
hereby overruled and said motion denied.
This June 23rd, 1914.
H. M. REID, Judge.
80 (Brief of Evidence.)
IH. E. Peckerr, Plaintiff. Sworn testified :
My name is Tl. FE. Puckett. 1 was engaged on the 26th day of
August, 1911 as car inspector for the Southern Railroad in’ the
North Inman Yards in Fulton County, Georgia. The night T was
hurt I had inspected a part of 75 train to Birmingham. Alabama.
This train consisted of merchandise, sometimes empty cars,—a
through freight train. T was injured that night helping a man,
RWitching up merchandise to go into this train. This engine that
Was switching the merchandise from what they call the transfer. up
there switching the cars to go into train 75, while they were switching
those cars on ahead, they got up there and run into a cut of care.
The cars next to the engine were empty. a few cut of cars and the en-
pine run up into those ears. The switehman was sitting on the end
Fill, and the engine come against the ear and he was caucht under
this car and the car caught afire by the bursting of the headlight, I
ee ee ee eee —
iii Foredin a 06 6829
EA TE SRE rota ELA Te I oat
38 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. BE. PUCKETT.
heard the fuss and began to run up there and I met Walter Lindsay§
and he said that Chappell had killed O’Berry. I went up there an¢
looked at it and I said—Are you all going to let this man die this
way. I had a conversation with them about the man’s condition
Linds; ay was the Yard Conductor. Tle had charge of making up 7)
train. I told Mr. Lindsay—<Are you going to let this mag
81 die? Walt said—Henry vou go over there and get the jacks
vou know where to get them. A jack is a mechanical devie
for lifting cars. He said—You know what kind of jack to get and ge
and get it. I said to Mr. Lindsay—You will have to let me hay
some men to go over there with me, and there were three, one wa
Lee, and I don’t know the other man’s name, and one was a negro
It was a thirty-five ton jack. [showed them where to get it, and I lef
them up there with the jack. I went over to a pile of blocks abou
thirty or forty feet from the jack and picked up two of the bi
blocks. One pine block was six inches by 15 inches, about thre
and a half feet long. The other was oak and was six inches by nin
inches, about three feet long. I put the blocks on my shoulder an
‘an down the outside of track No, 27.
As I was going down the track, | got down in about a car le nth,
and a half of the engine, I struck some clinkers, the first thing thai
started me—I struck those and kind of stumbled and I struck some
old crossties and that shot my foot under one and IT couldn’t pull ig,
out from under it, and it jerked me and threw me right face fore
most and my right foot went that way, and my left was back thi
way, and it made me spring up in my back and the blocks fell righ,
on top of me—across my back. | stumbled around there—I don’
know how—I twisted around there and got one of the block
82 by me, and [ pulled up by the side of this on a car and [T com
to feeling around there and got my lamp and lit it and set 1
on the cross ties. I looked and examined the crossties after I lighted,
my lamp, I looked around there. IT picked up that smallest bloc
and it had a spike in the end of it that stuck out about four inches
and I pulled this block up and I took hold of the spike and TI fol
lowed it around, going on down there, and [ got there and [I mad
them put the jack under the end to get the boy out.
I shined my light around and IT seen that the crossties were ol
wornout crossties. Weeds and grass had growed up over them, an
just hid them. From those crossties to the rail that were in. th
track itself was not over two and a half feet. T walked along ther
three or three and a half feet from the rail. I did not know thos
crossties were there.
Before this injury it had been sometime since IT had had occasiog
to walk along there. [ suppose it had been four or five months
maybe six months. The time that I passed by there. the last tim
before this injury, the pass-way by the side of the track was perfect!
clean. No ties over there at that time.
No. 75 train has from 35 to 38 cars. T had inspected 28 to 2
“ars that were to go into 75 that night. There remained to be ing,
spected and to complete the train something like about 1}
83 or 14 cars. If I had not been hurt it would have been mg;
duty to have inspected the balance of those cars. After I wal
—
: PL i Salas DO GA OLS a RE BM
-_ Rabe a center ee Hic .
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. 1. EL PUCKETT. 839
injured I did not go on and inspect the cars, | got hurt and was not
ible to get up to do any more work that night. I was not physically
ible. C. FE. Smith and George Reynolds inspected the cars that went
into 75 after that. I remained in the yard after 1 was hurt from
he time I got hurt until about 7 0’clock’ the next morning. In the
neantime train No, 75 was made up. They had finished it up. 1
een it when it left. It carried more cars than I had previously in-
pected. They didn’t shove hack up the track. They went and
hoved on to the lead, down that way from the engine, right on to
he main lead, and as quick as they got through pulled right on out.
‘hey were delayed there too long to shove back. TI suppose they
ere delayed something like an hour. When additional cars were
mt into the cars that I had already inspected, they got past the
recked car by pulling back this way, because they couldn't pull
hem north. South is the way they pull them on track 26.
ouldn’t pull them out of the north end on account of the
amaged. Ed. Jackson tried to push a car slowly by
wiped it. Then he pushed out of 26 track.
» Train 75 earries any freight to Anniston—made its first stop at
Anniston for setting off cars, At the time of my injury
bd I was thirty-six years old, My physical condition and health
j were good. T have never had anything, only a little erip,
mething like that sometime, Tam crippled now. T was not crip-
led prior to the time that this injury occurred, It was my left foot
lat was caught. As T stand on my right foot and put my left foot
own I can’t get the heel to the ground, It is short. something is
rawn up there so I can’t get it down unless | get down this Way
indicating). When | raise my right foot up then the other goes
wn. At the time T was injured. my back was straight and my
oulders straight—I stood straight—I don’t stand straight now be-
use I can’t. IT can’t stand straight because my back and leg is
ut.
Before I went to work for the Southern Railroad as car inspector
er there in the Inman Yard, | worked here in the shops. The
st thing that I ever did for the Southern Railroad Was putting
eels in under cars down there. That required heavy lifting.
‘ior to that time IT had farmed. While farming | was engaged in
owing, hoeing, split rails, anything that comes to hand, ditching.
couldn't do half the heavy labor T did while T was engaged in those
her pursuits because I can’t stoop to do any lifting at all. 1 ean't
rk as car inspector. T couldn't do the walking, stooping or lift-
ing. The pain or suffering lasts all the while, never has
quit hurting. It hurts right in this joint, and right back
next to my backbone. Some nights | can sleep and some
chts T can’t sleep at all, Maybe three or four nights that ] don’t
tany rest. When I got hurt somebody come
vas—T stepped back after T got hurt ‘and laid on the grass about
) feet away where they were vetting O'Berry out. and somebody
me and helped me up and got me down about 150 yards to the
tle office. T staid there until 7 o clock the next morning. They
inted to carry me to the hospital and | wouldn't go, I wouldn't
Dil renenremennntenintaeatin
They
car being
and it side-
and helped me where
_ —
~<@ +t) AOA TOD
eet
40 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
agree to it. I told them I wanted to go home as quick as I cou
The next morning | got up and I starts and | would make sometin
ten feet and have to stop. Then I went maybe fifty yards and I ¢
hold of a pine that was probably five and a half feet long, somethi
like as large as my arm and I put the pine pole down and follow
it along. I got to my home on the street car. Dr. Cochran w
first called to attend me after I got hurt. He has been attending
me ever since. [| noticed the limping in that other leg right aft
I got up. I staid in my room 57 days. Thirty-seven days I laid
bed. When | got up I noticed this shoriening of my leg. Th
shortening has increased since that time. Dr, Nicholson examin
me; and Dr, Hancock and Dr. Jarnigan examined me, at the requ
of the railroad company. | am now working in a beer saloon f
J. M. Morris. I quit the railroad work beeause I was n
86 physically able to do the work. 1 can’t stand and work co
stantly at the beer business if they put all the hours on 1
at one time. They divided the time. [| go on at 8:30 in the mor
ing and stay until 12:30 in the afternoon. In the afternoon I don
do anything. Lam at home, From 12:30 to 6:30 in the afternog
I stay at home and get rested and then come back and close up whe
we get ready. Sometimes close up at 9 o'clock, sometimes 10 ¢
10:30 and probably as late as 11 o'clock, but they hardly ever ste
open until 11 o'clock.
When I quit farming I was twenty-six years old. When L le
the farm I came to the Southern shops and got a job. I put whee
in cars, freight and passenger trains, and was paid at that work,
dollar and ten cents a day. | staid there until they raised them
a dollar and thirty-five (1.85) staid there 11 months, and then
quit. I then went out there in the Inman Yards when they fin
started them and helped to build a trestle for old man Lane, a co
tractor. We were building a pine log trestle. We cut timbers, su
work as was necessary and earned two dollars a day. I staid the
a couple of months. I quit and went back to the country and stai
afew days. Then I come back here and went to work at the Sout
ern shops. 1 stayed at the Southern shops something over two yea
My pay was raised when I went back there to $1.85 for repairi
cars, ten hours a day. I staid down there until they sent me oy
here to Inman Yards where ] had been inspecting cars. Th
87 first sent me to the South Inman Yards and I staid over th
awhile known as an extra man, inspecting cars. They se
me from Howell, we say that is the South Inman over to the No
Inman and finally they put me regularly in the North Inman whe
I staid down there—staid down there about a year, and me and «
chief car inspector couldn't get along and [ just quit and went to
Georgia Railroad and staid there 11 months repairing cars and
the Georgia Railroad if my time was thirty days, | got as much
eighty or eighty-five dollars, if I worked on Sundays I got dout
time. After I left the Georgia road I went back to the Southe
under old man A, J. Gilleland and was there up to the time I
injured. I think it was the 9th of April, 1907, that I went 7
there.
nbeon
ov —
COPY BOUND CLC
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. IT. E, PUCKETT, 41
When I was Working as inspector if ] made thirty days, I earned
ninety dollars and 77 cents | think it was, and 3] days would be
ninety-three dollars and some cents, I think that was the scale of
wages. I worked as inspector from the 9th of April, three years, |
think I went there in 1907 on April 9th, and they used me on the
repair track a few days. I remained there from that time about
three years until I was hurt—from the 9th of April to the 26th of
August. During the time | Was employed there I was off 14 days
one time with the grippe, and one time. | think it was about three
days, that C. E. Smith and | went to Jacksonville, Florida,
88 on a pass. I worked Sundays same as any other day. The
car inspector's job is one that you are there all the time.
IT was examined by Dr. Andrews for the railroad. He took X-ray
pictures. Some X-ray pictures were taken at the Grady Tlospital,
I don’t know the gentleman that taken them. Dr. Cochran Was
present. It was done under Dr. Cochran’s supervision, Ile asked
me to have them taken there for him. [am earning now twelve dol-
lars a week. I am not able to work constantly, because | can't stand
sup on my feet long at a time. It hurts so bad that ] give out on it.
I never had any difficulty of that sort before | was injured. In 1911,
the 26th of December | Went into a saloon and tried to work, |
staid there something like a month and T went back home and went
to bed, give out, and | staid there two or three weeks, Ax quick as [
got so T could I went back and tried it again, and | went on that way
until sometime the first of May and IT went home and laid in bed
three weeks, I think it was. I couldn't stand it. My leg gave out
on me, hurt me so bad. Dr. Cochran and Dr, Nicholson came out
there and put a plaster cast on it some time late in June and it staid
there thirty-three days. He told me to go to the country after he
wok it off and I went to the country and staid there until along
about the 17th of December, 1912." In the meantime, I hadn't
earned any money at all, because [couldn't work, and ]
89 couldn't work because | Was injured.
Next vear, from August 1912 to August 1913 I come back
J. M. Morris's T think it Was, about the 17th of December, 1912,
nd went to work for him for $9 a week and | worked there about
hree months and then he give me ten dollars a week for about three
onths, and ever since that time, ever since last May he has given
e 12 dollars a week. If | lay off two or three days on account of
y leg giving out on me. he don't take it out. Just gives it to me.
n the beer saloon I do nothing but draw heer. It is light work that
an do with my arms and shoulders. There js a counter behind
nd one in front of me where I can catch on either one of the
ounters and I make it backward and forward, T don't handle the
egs at all, got a nigger to do that. I don't have to do any heavy
ifting,
I think Dr, Jarnigan only examined me one time. Tim and Dr.
aneock and Dr. Cochran ‘all examined me together
he hospital.
On August 26th. 1911, T was car inspector. — Dr, O'Berry was
orking with Mr. Chappell’s engine. The engine that O'Berry was
6—598
down here at
Fae ol tal KHON TOR
i
working with had run into some other cars over there in the North.
Inman Yards. Mr. O’Berry had been caught between the side sill
and the end sill of the engine. The ear reared up and the side sill
caught him. When I first heard of it I was down in our
90 little old office, writing up my work. We had just finished
the ears in 75, that is those that had been put in on the track,
Had just finished those and had walked inside of the office for check-
ing them off of my little book onto the big book that we had in the
office. and we heard this crash and started over there and met Walt
Lindsay. We were entering in the book the cars, the numbers, the
engine numbers, the conductor, such as that. That was not the ce
sult of my inspection of train 79, not all of it, there were some others
to be inspected. I had to finish it before I would put it all down in
the book. Yes sir, this side of where I got hurt there is a bridge
across the tracks,—runs east and west. The tracks in the North
Inman yard run north and south. This shack that I was in was just
below the bridge above the railroad tracks. The shack I was in was
located north of that bridge about two hundred yards. That was my
office and had been since I had been car inspector out there, for
some two or three years. I had been located within two hundred
yards of the north end of this bridge for two or three years. Both
lead tracks are north of the steel bridge. The cars come off from
those lead tracks on the different switch tracks. From the lead tracks
go out 27 switch tracks which are to hold cars. They start at No. 1
and come back to 27. The engine and cars where O’Beary
91 got hurt was on track 25, maybe 26, | would not be positive
The man failed to throw the switch and let her run back in
there. I don’t know whether it was 25, 26, 23 or 24. He had 25,
96 and 27 all blocked when this happened. The collision occurred
on track 25 I think. Tracks 25. 26 and 27 branch off from the lead
They ran parallel to each other, north and south.
When I heard that O’Beary was hurt I went over there to hel;
him and when I got there, O’Beary was caught and Mr. Lindsay tol
me to go and get some jacks. Those jacks were for the purpose 0
jacking up this car under the engine fo O’Beary could be pulled ou
from between ‘there—then to place the car back on the trucks if 1
could be done, but there was no trucks there to place it back on, noth
ing to place it on—the trucks were too far back. The engine ran u
into the freight car, just telescoped it, pushed it up off the truck
This engine was under the car, O’Beary was caught on the side sil
sitting on the end sill of this engine, when it struck the car will
such force it crushed its sills up except the side sill and the engin
run up and struck it, and telescoped it up on the flag staff.
He was caught between the engine and the side sill of the ear.
went to get the jacks so I could jack the car up, hold it up so O’ Bear
could be pulled out from between the car and the engine—release
from there. I went to get the jacks for him and then the
92 to be placed on its trucks so it could be handled, could plat
it while we were holding it up there. I went to get the ja
to release him. He was fastened in there and I needed the jack so
could jack the car up and pull O’Beary up. In coming to O’Bem
42 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H? E. PUCKETT.
wa
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 43
I had to come to 25 track—a hundred yards from the repair track.
The repair track is where they repair cars, light repairs. East of
track 27, there is a sort of storage yard where there is stored differ-
ent things and things that were used for repairing cars. Twenty-
seven is not a repair track. The repair track was east of 27. I don’t
recollect where they did keep their storage yard. They had a box
ear somewhere over there where they kept bolts, nuts, such as they
might need. They had a special place to pile blocks up that you
have to hold those jacks up. We got this jack before we ever got to
the pile of blocks. The distance between track 27 and the next track
is at least thirty or forty vards. Up above the bridge the space be-
tween track 27 and the track east of it is where you get to the repair,
the transfer comes in then. Ever since I have been there at work T
have not seen between track 27 and track east of it, a lot of old
trestle stuff. South of the bridge they used to keep some between
the repair track and 27. Had old car box set off up there in which
they kept bolts. Right adjacent to the car box, between the car box
and track 27, I have never seen any timbers over there. T didn’t
notice any old timbers of the bridge piled up there if they
93 were there. I could not say whether they have been piled
there ever since the bridge was torn down. I have worked
there every night for two or three years but I didn’t go along up by
there.
From track 27 back the other way I would go, but the other way T
did not. From 27 west I worked. IT never worked from 27 east. I
never inspected east of track 27. We had a fellow named Baker in
day time who inspected east of track 27. There was an inspector of
the cars on tracks east of 27 at night. Didn’t have anybody then be-
cause no cars were loaded there at night. There were no cars in-
spected at night east of track 27 unless there was an accident, some-
thing like that. If we had an accident we had to go, no difference
where it was.
This collision in which O’Berry was hurt was some 50 or 75 yards
north of the bridge. They had a certain place up there for keeping
everything. They piled all the blocks up in a place, and then they
had the jacks up in a place, cleaned the yard up, when they quit
every night. I come across those jacks before we got to the blocks
and I told those boys to take the jack and that I will get the blocks.
I can’t tell whether that photograph marked Exhibit “A” of the
yard and tracks is a correct: photograph.
When I left this engine and the car in that collision I had
94 to come back south across track 26 and along 27 to go and get
those blocks. We kept up between the two lead tracks, up
between 24 and 25, run up there even where we thought the blocks
were and crawled up between the other cars, jumped between the cars
on the coupling. I had to cross 27 after we passed the bridge. Then
I got out where this space was between track 27 and the next track
east of it—run right straight across the vard, right east. The dis-
tance between track 27 and the next track east of it at the point where
I got those blocks is some thirty or forty vards. I didn’t know that
the space between those two tracks at that point on that side of the
Sin She
.
44 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
bridge has been a storage yard for old timbers that came out of |
bridge. Never known of it being a storage yard at all. T have sé
a few pieces of timber up there above the bridge. These blocks tl
I got were something like 50 vards south of the bridge. There w
no timbers pred up on that side that I seen at all. I do not kn
that some are piled up there right now. They kept the blocks sou
of the bridge about fifty yards stacked on the ground between tri
27 and the next track on the east, right close to the repair tracks,
didn’t know exactly where they were. I knew that they kept th
piled up somewhere. I did not know where the blocks were. 1 4
hunting forthem. I couldn’t say positively why T went th
95 for them. I happened to run right across them the f
thing. I knew there were some blocks over there at so
place, I didn’t know particularly where they were, but I knew tl
they were about the repair track. I could not say that this pict
marked “B” is a correct representation of the situation there as to t
space east of track 27 and between track 27 and the first track e
of it. I could not say that space has not only been used as a stor:
yard there for years, but the grass has grown up in between the pi
of lumber there. I couldn't say what was in there at all. T ne
did see but very few pieces of timber there because it was low a
there used to stand a pond of water south and east of the tres
They had cleaned it all up four or five months before the accide
At that time I saw a few pieces of timber south of the bridge. Ne
had been a pile of timber in there. I never seen it. When TI ,
these blocks and put them on my back and started back to wh
O’Beary was, I was walking along the east side of track 27. I vy
running as hard as I could. [ had my lantern with me and whil
was running along there | stepped on some clinkers. [ stumbl
against those after I got nearly to O’Beary, just below the bridge.
mean by that north of the bridge. That is where T stumped my t
I was still on the east side of the track. I stumped my toe agai
some ¢clinkers, Some two or three, [ suppose, were large on
96 That started me to stumbling and in shooting this foot une
the tie, jamming it up under there, it twisted and threw 1
right face foremost. What T stumbled on was the clinkers, that w
what first started me. [T never would have fell if T hadn’t struck t
crossties. I first stumbled against the clinkers in four or five feet
where I struck the cross ties which threw me face foremost. I
running as hard as [| could run. T hit the clinkers and that ma
me stumble some. T was running as fast as | could and hit t
clinkers and that made me stumble and three or four feet from t
clinkers were the crossties. When I struck the crossties, that thr
me face foremost. When Tam running as fast as T can, with a le
like that, I could not go far in a leap. Something like three feet
about as far as T could step. T stumbled over the clinkers a
jumped three feet, then my foot hit the crosstie and then T stumb
and fell right face foremost. T hit the crossties. The end of it m
have been something like three and a half feet from the rail. I
not say whether the space between the end of the crossties and
rail was perfectly clean. The rail comes over here and the cross
or
.
project out a piece. Weeds and grass was all I seen until T hit this
tie.
I do not know whether or not the ears which were attached to the
engine that was pulling the cars when O Berry was hurt were going
into train 75,
7 Lee was with me. Tle went to get the jack. He was not
with me when IT stumbled. Neither of the others were with
ne, the other three men toted the jack and I toted the blocks. The
ther three men at the time | stumbled were ahead of me somewhere.
had two of those blocks. Lee and a couple of other fellows had
he jack. The jack is made out of cast iron, some solid material.
t was thirty-five ton jack, It weighed a couple of hundred pounds,
hree men had it. They went directly in front of me. The three
en got hold of this jack. There was a handle on each side and
wo of them caught hold of the handle and one man at the end over
here, and went down the tracks. When I fel] down my lantern went
ut. When it dropped it put the light out. | pulled myself up by
he side of the box car. T eaught, I don’t know how, but pulled up
w the box car and T felt around there and got my lantern and struck
match and T shined the light around there. I did not call any-
body. O' Beary was hollering and begging us to get him out and J
ust reached around and got the smaller block and followed it down
here, and they put the jack on it. After I lit my lantern I got the
lock up to where O’Beary was hurt. the leneth of the engine and
bout half length of the box car. about forty-five feet to where
Beary was injured. Then I just stepped out about ten feet and laid
down on the grass and staved there a couple of hours. This
grass that Tam talking about was west of where the accident
happened, over next to the other lead. about 10 or 11. feet.
hen I went hack to the shack when somebody come and helped me
ip. I spent the night at the shack, until 7 o'clock the next morning.
hen I went to the street ear and went home, From the shack where
spent the night to the street car was four or five hundred vards,
From the end of the old ties to the end of the ties under the
ail was not a space of over two feet, You put the blocks down for a
oundation for your jack. then you set your jack on top of it and
ack the car up.
These cars that were attached to the engine where O’Beary was
ing gotten out. blocked the track they were on. This car caught
te when the collision occurred. Tt hursted the headlight and that
hrowed the oil up there and it caught fire,
I staid there until Mr. O'Beary got released. | laid down there
nd watched them get him out. As to whether they were trying
oput the car on the track with the jack and block, they couldn't
lo anything with it because it Was in such a shape that all they could
lo was to let it down hack on the trucks that were knocked away
ack under it. As to whether all they had to do was te jack the ear
Pp, get O’Beary out and then let it settle down on the tracks—if it
hadn't heen torn up se bad we could lave pushed the trucks
) back so as to handle it. Tt broke the sills so they couldn't do
that and had to let it go like it was. It was prized up for the
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. o
oO
46 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS, H. E. PUCKETT.
purpose of releasing O’ Bearv—to get O’Beary out. Tf we had push
forward with O’Beary on the engine where he was jammed in wi
the other car, or pulled the car from the engine, it would have kil
him. If the engine had backed back in the other direction from t
car it would have killed him. So it was absolutely necessary
jack up this car to release O’Beary. After O’Beary was releas
the car was allowed to settle back on the trueks—had to becat
there was no other place to put the trucks. I didn’t see an engi
go down to the other end of this cut where O’Beary’s engine was aj
hitch to it. It come in at the south end and T was at the nor
end of the bunch of cars. 1 couldn't see the engine up there but
could see the cut of cars as they were pulled out from down the
As quick as they got O’Beary out, they backed the engine out a
then let the car down. That was all that we could do, because:
couldn’t get the truck back. We had to get O’Beary out before t
wreckage could be removed at all. T did all T could to save O’ Bear
life. The first thing on my mind was to try to get O’ Beary out,
that was necessary to remove the wreckage. In case of a wreck or @
lision by which the tracks are obstructed, or the life of an employe
imperiled, all the employees that learn about it try to do
100 best we can to clean it up and to remove everything at a
time. That applies to all the employees. If I didn’t do th
and the officials found it out they would run me off. They got ¢
fire put out on that occasion, As soon as we got to O'Beary we k
two men toting water out of the tender and one up in the car dashi
the water over it until we could get him out. We dashed water on
before we had stopped and let it down—kept dashing water on it un
we got him out. A. J. Gilleland, Chief Car Inspector had given
instructions to help in clearing the track, in the vard there at
Southern road. They were in writing and oral. Every few days
bulletin would come out there and say go to all such accidents a
everything of that kind and assist the best way we could.
bulletin that T am talking about it not this particular one at
there are several. IT have read this one many a time. That a
don’t cover all of it at all. That is one of the bulletins. It)
not the one T have reference to at all. T cannot tell how mat
bulletins I ever received. I received them every few days fr
the time IT went there until the time IT got hurt. T received }
structions every few days. Every time the Chief Car Inspeq
‘ame down there and heard that anything had happened up in {
yard, he would sav—Now look here hovs. you look after that busine
Then there would be a bulletin about it. THe would say th
101 people are supposed to tell vou and vou go and look after a
kind of an accident. If vou hear of anvthing of the kind
want vou boys to look after it. Where any accident happened. ap
sonal injury, anything of that kind, if we heard about. we were
go right to it. T had written instructions and oral instruetions
assist the injured and help to remove the wreck. Mr, Gilleland:
not there that night.
—_ SARNIA NL EMI ILLES EISEN IPRA OLE EP EFT TR WAGE LATOR DAS RRs
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 47
H. E. Puckert, plaintiff, recalled, testified:
I worked for the Railroad Company as car inspector the last
ime about three years, from the 9th of April until the 26th of
ugust. Six other car inspectors were on duty there with me at
ight. Neither I nor any of the other ear Inspectors with my
nowledge, during the time | was employed there as car inspector
er took out or put in any cross ties out of the track. I had nothing
do with the maintenance of way. The tracks there were repaired
uring the time I was there, under Mr. Smith’s direction. He was
rack Supervisor. THe hada gang of men there in the north Inman
fard and in the south Inman Yard for the purpose of maintaining
ie track and keeping it in order, Those men who worked there in
ie yard taken out all worn out ties, made the track perfectly safe
ut in switches and frogs. Asx to the old ties. he Was supposed to have
taken them out and burned them. — ] have seen them do it. I
02. have seen the men around there taking them out and burning
them. I have never seen an inspector of the cars engaved in
mat business at all during the -vhole time | Was there.
I weigh about 151. At the time | was hurt I weighed from [SO
Sv. I weighed when I entered the company’s service the lust
me on April 24th, 1908, about 179,
That is my application. That is Iny signature. I never answered
ese questions—A ve 32, weight 165. | didn’t answer that part at
l, I never signed that. All | signed was right here. (Indicating),
e never asked me that question at all, Mr. Manley went and got
at and fixed it up himself. He didn’t ask me as to my weight and
never answered 165 pounds. This was filled in before I signed it.
signed the questions down there myself. That is not my handwrit-
g (Indicating). 1 didn’t have anything to do with that other part
er here. I don’t remember whether I onve mv height as five feet.
ninches. That is my height. | guess T gave my age as thirty-two,
can’t say positively, That was my correct age. I didn’t tell them
at I weighed 165.
Plaintiff introduced in evidence sclograph of TH. E. Puckett’s
lvis, which is attached, marked plaintiff's Exhibit No. 1.
8 J. L. CHArren.e, sworn for defendant, testified :
I am working now for the Southern Railway Company as
rd foreman of the switchmen. A yard foreman has charge of
rd crews engaged in switching. It is the same thing as the freight
nductor except vou are in charge of switeh engines. | was at
tk on August 26th, 1911, the night Mr. O'Berry was hurt. The
mber of the engine I was at work with was 1714. In that vard
ere are the lead tracks, one runs out from the lower end of the
rd, the Inman yard, there are tracks numbered up to 20, that run
tfrom it, and there are also tracks that run up to the hump, the
mp tracks run up a hill in the yard and the tracks run off from
e hump, and there are what are known as house tracks. “Switeh
cks from 21 to 27 inclusive are connected with the lead, 21 js
st of 27. The tracks out there facing south, run from ZI to 27
| the tracks out there run north and south. There is about 12 or
48 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
14 feet between 27 and 26 and between 25 and 26, five or six f
or probably eight feet, something like that. They are paired
between platforms. Built a platform between 27 and 26 and th
is one between 25 and 24 and there is a platform between 25 and
and one between 21 and 20. The platforms are used for tra
ferring freight in loading and unloading cars. Track 25 is e
of track 27. Photograph marked “A” is a correct pict
104 of the situation out there, generally, as it existed at the ti
Mr. O’Berry was hurt, we will say August 26th, 1911. 7
tracks were all the same. Between tracks 27 and 25 around |
bridge, north and south of the bridge, there are old drawhea
timber and such stuff, It is used for putting old timber there. A
south of it there is a car inspector's shanty with tools and all kir
of materials, drawheads, knuckles, bolts and everything like tl
that is used in repairing a car. Between track 27 and 28 south
the bridge the distance is about forty or fifty feet as well as | ¢
guess at it, | don’t know the exact distance. North of the bridge, t
distance between those two tracks would be about sixty or sever
feet. The tracks flare out after leaving the platform. Thad be
at work in the yard prior to August 26th, L911, in this local
around this bridge, as a switchman, since November 1910. 1 start
to working on the house November [3th, TOPO. as a switch:
The condition of the vards between tracks and between rails—
tween 27 and 26 out there, was in fairly good shape. Between
and 28 it was piled up with timbers, such stuff as that. That
what I said was used for storage. On the night that Mr. O'Bes
got caught between my engine and some other cars, he was caug
on track 26. That was north of the bridge about a hundred, a hy
dred and twenty-five or a hundred and thirty feet. That is a gue
I don’t know the distance, but it is something like th
105 = My crew had been engaged prior to that collision in’ swite
ing all cars that were marked to come out of the house tra
Those cars go everywhere—go into trains and anything else that
there from up from six o'clock in the evening until about. ten.
My crew that night had done no work at all on train 75, or
switched cars out for the train took them out of the house. We h
switched cars to track 23. At the time of the collision in which }
O’Berry was hurt, we had finished our work on those cars about |
or fifteen minutes before the collision occurred. The cars 1 |
attached to my engine at the time of this collision were South
18774; Southern 34960. Southern 13774 was empty and 5f
was loaded. These are the only ears | had attached to my eng
at the time. I was shoving them in on track 26 to pick up a
to kick in on track 21. None of those cars, neither the two the
was shoving in there nor the one that T was going to pick up
kick were to go into train 75. My engine was moving south at
time of the collision. It was headed south. Those two cars attac
to the engine were in front of it. We were pushing them. A
ear was directly in front of the engine. The cars that we v
shoving ahead with our engine collided with other cars on track
When they collided with these cars on track 26, O'’Berry was
a ‘ ; i dso a a
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. 49
the front foot board of engine 1714. That was a switch
106 engine. It had no cow-catcher on it—just a footboard. A
couple of boards about three feet long and about a foot wide
on each side of the front of the engine for the boys to stand on.
O’Berry was riding on the engine on the right side at the front of
the engine on the footboard. When the collision occurred the engine
run partly into the car immediately in front of it and the sill on
the side and the end of the car was up around the boiler—sort of
telescoped the car, went into it. The head of the boiler was right
about the end of the car. The car in front of the engine was lifted
up off its trucks. The trucks were knocked back mighty nigh the
middle of the car. Mr. O’Berry was pinned in between the car
and the sill. He was between the two. | was there when an order
was given for anybody to go after jacks. When it first happened
I hollered for somebody to go after jacks, to the caboose of 75 and
I heard other hands holler also. 1 don’t remember that | gave Mr.
Puckett any orders to get any jack. | merely hollered, “Get some
jacks.” That was before anybody got there except those right there
at the time. IT wanted the jacks to jack up the ear so we could vet
p0'Berry out from under it. | guess T was there at the time Mr.
Puckett got hurt. I didn’t see him get hurt. I didn’t know
anything about it until the next morning, T think it was. | left the
collision after we got Mr. O’Berry away from there, went to
107 ~—s the shop and got another engine, | don't remember how long
it was. I was there when the car was pulled off the engine,
They just come in at the upper end of track 26, another engine
come down there, and picked up the two ears and pulled them off
the engine. I don’t know what the condition of the track was at
the time this photograph “A” was taken. 1 don’t know who took
this. I never saw anybody at work out there hetween the tracks,
lining them up, fixing the erossties, | work at nieht. | never
saw men working on the track under a foreman. | don't remember
who was the track foreman on that section embracing this vard,
I didn’t see the section foreman: his work was during the dav and
I was at work at night. The track supervisor was Smith, | believe.
His given name was Sam—I am not <ure that is it. I don’t know
who the track foreman was. Durine the entire time T was at wotk
in this yard T never saw men repairing the track at night. never
had occasion, as T was up on the house at night. T have seen them
down in the North Inman tracks, taken up by the section men,
The yard is not cleaned up by the section foremen, they repair the
tracks, take out the crossties, things like that and carry the crossties
off which they take out—remove those. This track 27 was on the
outside of the track next to that open space that T mentioned as
being about forty or fifty feet wide, Ontside of that track was used
at that time for the storage and piling of old material, Old
108 ties, old scraps, anything of that sort, and it Was used for the
piling of stuff on the outside. between there and number 28,
Mr. O’Berry was alive when T went. to jack up the car. He
didn’t die at all. T could not have possibly have moved this ear
with O’Berry as we was there. without killing him: ] don't suppose
7—598
50 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
we could, we didn’t try it. Therefore, the first thing I had on my
mind was to get O’Berry out. Not to move the car but to jack the
car up. When T was first asked the question I said to get O’Berry
out. We had to get him out before we could move the car. We
didn’t jack it up for the car to be moved, but to get O’ Berry out
We had to jack the car up to get O’Berry out, had to do that so
the engine could be moved from under the car. In jacking the ear
up we had to move the car but we had jacked the car up so we could
get O’Berry out. The jacking up had nothing to do with the mov.
ing of it. Couldn’t use it until you put the pair of trucks under it,
We didn’t lower the car on to the trucks and then move the car
The trucks were left where they were knocked under the car. We
jacked it up only to get O’Berry out. |
I can’t say how many ears I had handled in working with train
70 that night, about 12 or 14, something like that. I did not
handle any cars after this accident, going into 75 that night. |
could not tell how many cars went into 75 after the accident
109 [| didn’t place them in the train. The cars that I switched
into train 75 had been switched in before this accident oe
curred. | didn’t switch any more to go into train 75, They were
all switched before the accident occurred, all that I had switched
in—all that T had anything to do with. Whether any more wa
switched into 75 [ don’t know anything about that. I had switched
all the cars out of the house for that train, before the accident. |
am not prepared to say that the only cars that went into 75 wer
my cars that | had switched in there that night. 1 don’t know any:
thing about 75 at all except [ switched cars in there before the acc:
dent. The two cars that were involved in this wreck, the one the
engine bursted into, one of them was empty and the other wa
loaded. IT don’t know anything about two other cars. Two car
that hit in the collision T had hold of, I went in there to pick y
one. | don't know where that car was going. [t was simply a car
on that switch in the vard. It had a destination but that car had
been dropped in there to go to the shop or some other place. |
don’t know whether it was loaded or empty. We send loaded car
to the shop. We went in on track 26, it was filled with cars—I went
in there to pick up one. Train 87 ran from Atlanta to Chattanooga
I did not put any cars with my engine in 87 that night. I switched
other cars to destination besides train 75. | switched ears to any
destination on the tracks at the house, different destination
110 I could not say that IT had any ear going to Chattanooga tha
night, unless I looked at the house list. 1 could tell by look
ing at the house list. I don’t know where the house list is. I have
seen it. It is a loose slip, cardboard system. (Ianding witnes
some paper.) It is a list like that. The clerk at the transfer got i
up. I don’t know who was the clerk at that time. That is th
original list | switeh by. As to those two cars that were involve
in that wreck, one of them was empty, a flat car, brought in the var
and dropped on the empty track. The loaded one. | forget no
where it went to. It had merchandise in it. The list would no
show what the car was loaded with. The number of that loaded ea
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY Ys, H. E. PUCKETT, 51
was Southern 34960. I had no means of knowing the destination of
that car—it was just a set-back car, Now, the list shows Eastman,
but the list seems to be changed. | only know from this list. That
is car 54960 in one hand writing and the balance of the memo-
randuin is the change that | speak of. It looks to me like about
the same handwriting as the balance of the list. It looked like it
had been written over, | don’t know that it had been changed. J]
don’t know whether it was changed or not. I don’t know who did
that writing. J think probably the same clerk that did the other,
% there has been a change in it I don't know who made it, nor
when, nor for what purpose,
111 J only had two cars ahead of my engine. When ] got
against the other cars on the track,
I could not tell vou where those other
know. I intended to shove this engine and the two cars in on that
track where O' Berry was hurt. to pick up one on that track so I could
come out on the lead track. On the oceasion of the collision, which
occurred by a misunderstanding of the signal. I went in there with
two cars and the engine and was going to pick up a ear on twenty-six
and kick it in on track 21 so as to clear the lead. 1 don’t remember
where the one that I intended to kick up was destined to. ] don't
know whether 87 went out that night. It goes out every night |
fhink except Saturday night. 1 think, as well as T remember, that
twas Saturday night that this occurred, 87 didn’t go out. If any
rain went out to Chattanooga that night. it: was probably eighty-
ive,
This is a memorandum that was furnished me by whieh to switch
ars (looking at list), A memorandum furnished the “witching in
eference to switching, it refers to Cars that are tugged, supposed to
etageed. Car tag 135,727. A. W. & P. seems to have some change
made on it. B. & O. No, — and A. B. & A. 183158 appear to have
een changed too. After a list is originally made up, for the hand-
ing of cars, those cars are changed from where
intended to vo to somewhere else,
they were ahead of mine.
cars were going. I don’t
they were originally
I Suppose so, as there are
12 changes in the list. from one road to the other. The bill of
lading for this Southern 2 1960 will show where it Was going,
I put in on track 22 twelve or fourteen cars destined to go in to
)». 75 leavine there would have about 35 or 58 cars. You ean
nd the destination on the bill of lading, | suppose there is a bill of
ding for a shipment. where a car is loaded, wherever jf ix. An
upty car would have no bill of lading,
G. W. Lixpsay, sworn. for defendant, testified :
Tam in the employ of the Southern R;
in its employ August 26th, 1911, the
the yard. 1 was conductor of <witch-engine. In the North In-
in vards there are a large number of switch tracks that connect
tha lead. Cars are placed on those different tr:
nt them for different points in the yard
ins out there and do different
lh the condition of the yard out
—=
lilway Company now and
time that O'Berry was hurt
wks, as you may
. and we make up our
things like that, 1] am familiar
at that point and was at the time
=
52 SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H, E. PUCKETT.
O’Berry was hurt. The North Inman Yard, with reference to the
special portion immediately north of and immediately south of the
bridge—the Old Sweat road bridge, as to cleanliness was in fairly
good shape. 1 was in the yard at the time of this collision in whieh
Mr. O’Berry was injured. I was sitting on the end sill of
113. my engine somewhere, may be ten or twelve cars on the same
track the engine was when we had the collision. After the
collision, I stepped out from the footboard of the engine, gave the
engineer a signal and made the remark—Come let us go up wher
that trouble is, as | heard it. I gave my engineer a signal to come
ahead, so we could go up there, 7 went right up to it. I only seer
one man when | got there that was working out of the crew of the
fireman and the engineer of the engine that had the collision—anjé
Mr. Lee, a switchman, he had done gone up and got some blocks~
he was up there at the time [ got there, and the engmeer and the fire
man, I can’t say that I remember the very instant that Mr. Pucket
‘ame up there. Everybody, the vard men come over that way.
didn’t notice any certain person, couldn't say as to any certain perso
coming up there at any certain time. I don’t remember that I gaw
any orders to Mr. Puckett to get any jacks. I might have said—
SJovs, go and get some jacks, something like that. IT don’t think
addressed any certain person personally. The purpose of gettin
those jacks was to raise the car. | wanted to raise the car to g
Mr. O’Berry out from under the car. The rip track is in a kind ¢
south direction from where the accident happened, east of track 27
Same people eall it the repair track, some the shop track, some tl
rip track, whatever you want to call it. It is a track where w
114 ~~ earry crippled cars. That is a track that is immediately eas
of track 27. | rode right down on the front of my engine t
the place of collision. After Mr. O’Berry was released, I took hi
to the hospital with my engine As soon as | got up there with m
engine | made arrangements to take him to the hospital with m
engine. I had to back my engine back up north. T sent it back up
I gave orders to my switchman to take the engine around and tak
a caboose—run the engine up by the side next to where the accide
was, with the cab. So when we got him out there wouldn't be an
delay in getting him to tewn. | just brought him te town with m
engine and the cab and I come with it. T couldn’t say the exa
time I got back to North Inman Yards—something like 11:30 ¢
11:50, somewhere along there, | couldn't say the exact minute.
At the time of the collision, Mr. Chappel had finished his wo
with reference to train 75 according to our rule that we were work
ing by. He had a red signal in front of the car. Tle never put th
signal there until he got his stuff ready. He put that signal the
15 minutes before the accident occurred. T was going to work th
I was going after the balance of the stuff for train 75 when I stop
to take O'Berry to the hospital. When the collision oceurred Ty
stopped, as T had begun to clear track 23 and it was blocked
115 account of the accident. IT didn’t get back on 23. T just te
my engine immediately to carry O’Berry to the hospital.
At the time the balance of the train was made up—when I pull
—— ee
mp TAs OFLIIAICT OTA
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. B. PUCKETT. 53
ut on the transfer when I came back. they were making the move-
nent down at the North Inman block ollice—got the stuff out of the
uth end of the transfer and taken it out — North Inman. An-
ther switch engine was making the movement down on that track
here after’ [ come from the hospital. I couldn't say whether any-
hing was left there after those cars had been pulled by the engine
ut of track 26, because I didn’t work it and I don’t know what time
he track was cleared. 1 suppose my memory is very clear as to what
happened when I first came up there where the wreck occurred that
ight. I remember as well as any ordinary man would do in regard
it. I remember that Mr. Puckett was up there; L don’t remem-
r paying any particular attention, nor would you if you had come
p there that night. IT wasn’t paying any attention to Mr. Puckett
here at all. My business was about something else, and my mind
ras not on Mr. Puckett at that time. So Mr. Puckett’s presence
here made no particular impression on my mind.
16 I. H. McEroy, sworn for defendant, testified:
[am in the railroad business working for the Southern Rail-
avay as yard conductor. 1 was at work in North Inman the night of
August 26th, 1911, when O’Berry was hurt. working then as night
ard master. 1 was there that night. There are two lead tracks in
hat yard at that point in North Inman. Twenty-seven tracks run
ut from those lead tracks at that end of the vard, on the two leads.
hat yard at that time was clean, kept clean all the while. There
ad been no special reason there for its having been cleaned up
hortly prior to this that I know of. Track 27 from track 28 above
he bridge was fifty or sixty feet | suppose, along the bridge, may
ave been further. They converged as they went under the bridge
nd got a little wider apart as they weni north. That space between
hose tracks was used for nothing particularly, just a vaeant place in
here. I do not know that anything was stored in there. The rip
racks were from 28 over to 31, 1 believe—2S8. 29. 20 and 31—four
ip tracks. They were used for repairing cars. The bolts, nuts and
hings kept in relation to track- 27 and 28 for the purpose of repair-
ng cars were kept in a rack on the side of 28 there where they keep
the material and stuff. That is between 27 and 28.
This night at the time the collision in whieh Mr. O’Berry was
injured occurred, IT was at the extreme end of the South
Inman vard at the time he was hurt. 1 heard of it and came
on up there. When I got there Mr. O'Berry had been re-
ased, they had taken him away. Mr. Lindsay was not there then.
le had taken Mr, O'Berry to the hospital. 1 finished making up
ain 75 that night. I handled it myself. As to the movement |
tade—I just went back up the other — of the vard and got my
ngine and took the cars out and worked on the transfer of South
nman down on the vard main line and let train 73 pick them up
f of the main line.
I started my work south of where the collision occurred, Brought
e cars to the south end. shoved them down on the vard main line
f South Inman and 75 picked them up right off of the yard main
9E IN CENTER
Bd SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT.
line. I completed train 75 about 12 o'clock if L remember right,
did not see Mr. Puckett that night. | got these cars down south ang
proceeded down that way until I got them on the main line and tly
train 75 come up and they were delivered there. 1 did not come y
the scene right where the collision occurred. | went around oj
another track.
I don’t know who inspected the cars that T saw put in 75. They
were three other inspectors in North Inman, I don’t know what thei
names were. [| don’t know who was the man inspecting the cay
going into 75 that night. I don’t know who handled them. —Pucke
was a car inspector under me, of the North Inman Yard, |
118 have been in the railroad business about eight years. Befon
I went into the railroad business T was farming. [worked oy
a farm until [ was 17 vears old. I had to tight grass a good dee!
As to how long it would take grass to grow over a few crossties an
cover them up, it is according to the weather. In rainy weathe
raining all the time, it would take but a few days. [ should say fiy
or six days. The size of ordinary cross ties is about six inches thi¢
and about eight inches across the face, across the top. It would tak
a month for grass growing up enough to cover crossties. Or, it mig
be more depending on how rich the land was and the state of th
season.
I don’t know who was the track foreman who had charge of the
work in that yard. | was working at night, I never seen the trac
foreman. It was no part of the duty of the yard master to take th
crossties off the track. It was not a part of the duty of the var
master to dispose of the ties—that was the duty of the track forema
to do that.
Mr. Smith was the road supervisor at that time, I think. M
Biddy was road master at that time. I don’t remember who wa
the track foreman who had the job of looking after that work in the
yard. I have seen the track foreman repairing the yard from tim
to time, the tracks in it. [f this wreck hadn't occurred, th
119 = most convenient way of moving the last cut of cars, the ea
that would go into 75, would have been right out on the trad
where the wreck happened. The happening of the wreck made |
necessary to detour the cars around over another track. bringing thed
out another way. That is the way the train was made up. Tif
leaving time of 75 was 11:35. It left somewhere about 12 0’ clock
I don't recall exactly. My recollection is that it left about a he!
hour late. That was due to this trouble in the yard.
A clinker is cinders where vou clean out one of the engine’s fir
box—burnt coal. All the engines in Atlanta burn coal—all that
know anything about. They don’t burn any oil here.
W.E. Jackson, sworn for the defendant testified :
I am not working for the Southern Railroad now. Tam farmin
T was working for the Southern Railroad in Aneust 1911 at the tin
that Mr. O’Berry got hurt. LT was yard foreman of a switeh engin
I had nothing to do with making up train 75 that night. The ce
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS. H. E. PUCKETT. yo
sion occurred on track 26. At the time the collision occurred, |
ad a cut of cars on the hump, coming with a cut over the hump.
he hump is south of the bridge. 1 didn’t go down to the scene oi
he collision until IT went down there to remove the damaged car.
fhe yard master ordered me down there. | went down there to
remove the damaged car from the engine. I saw the engine
20 and the car where they were together, To releiving the situa-
tion, I coupled to the car, pulled it off the engine, pulled it
pto the south end of the transfer and put it on track 31. 1 had a
erailment and worked there until | was releived. Day come and
ey relieved me there. 1 had a derailment two hundred vards from
Bhere I first got hold of the car, | had pulled it off the engine and
Bas carrying it down the track. The engine had telescoped up under
We car. T come from the south end of the transfer—south of the
int of collision, There was only one car on that track when T went
gown there after that car. The rest of them had been taken out be-
re] got there. I hitched to that ear and moved it off of the
gine—got it out from there. It rolled before it derailed about
enty car lengths—I don’t know just the distance, must have been
mewhere between 200 yards, probably. 1 don’t’ know whether
ain ¢ had left on its trip that night or not. at the time I pulled
e engine and car apart.
(Showing witness a picture “A",) | recognize the location of that
idge there with reference to the tracks. From the top of the
il to the end of the ecrossties, | judge it to be two feet, mavbe a
tle better. Those crossties are all uniform length and the track is
uniform standard evage track. All of the yard track, the main
tracks, the switch track, are all standard guage and they have
1 about the same size crossties—crossties are nearly the same
size. They vary in thickness but all of the same length. |
nt know anything about the accident at all, T only taken the car
the engine. The engine was removed by some one, but I don’t
iow who. 7 don’t know who did that. They turn large clinkers
tof those engines in the clinker pit. The clinker pit is near the
und house. The place 1 call the clinker pit is where they specially
and take the clinkers out of the engines. The size that usually
mes out of them varies from that spittoon down there to a marble.
Ihave been engaged in farming only a month. | never farmed
fore then. T have not had any grass in mv crop vet,
This clinker pit from where this collision occurred was not over a
ndred yards, hardly so far. The clinker pit is situated southeast
m where the accident happened, The rip tracks are between track
and the clinker pit. The clinker pit is on a track on the outside
the rip track right next to the coal chute. That is where the
nkers are taken out, where the place is specially fixed for cleaning
fires,
I didn't have anything to do with
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.