Transcript of Record — New York Central & Hudson River R. Co. v. Tonsellito
Supreme Court brief1917
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(24,907)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1916.
No. 239.
THE NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER RAILROAD
COMPANY, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,
v8.
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, AN INFANT, WHO SUES BY
JAMES TONSELLITO, HIS NEXT FRIEND.
IN ERROR TO THE COURT OF ERRORS AND APPEALS OF THE STATE
OF NEW JERSEY.
INDEX.
Original. Print
DOA IGOT ooo ce ncccccccccccneceeevencecesseccerestsessoecens ° a 1
Transcript of record from the circuit court of Hudson county.. 1 1
Notice of appeal, case of Micaael Tonsellito............... 1 1
Grounds of appeal, case of Michael Tonsellito............. 2 2
Recognizance, case of Michael Tonsellito..............+.6. 8 5
Complaint, case of Michael Tonsellito............0.ee.06. 8 5
Amendment to complaint, case of Michael Tonsellito....... 10 6
Answer, case of Michael Tonsellito............0..csceeeee 11 7
Reply, case of Michael Tonsellito........cc.scceccccccvee 14 8
Judgment, case of Michael ‘Tonsellito...........0..eeeeeee 14 8
Certificate, case of Michael Tonsellito..................4- 15 9
Notice of appeal, case of James Tonsellito................ 16 9
Grounds of appeal, case of James Tonsellito.............. 17 10
Recognizance, case of James Tonsellito................6. 24 13
Complaint, case of James Tonsellito....... Ces vecseedeneas 24 13
Answer, case of James Tonsellito..........cscecscccesces 28 14
Reply, case of James Tonsellito.........ccccrcsoccccscecs 30 15
Judgment, case of James Tonsellito..............ceceeeee 30 15
Jupp & DerweiLer (INc.), PRinTERs, WASHINGTON, D. C., SepTeMBER 28, 1916,
PP SIRS RE
il INDEX.
Original. Print
Certificate, case of James Tonsellito.........-.ecee eee noes 31 16
Stipulation of facts, KC... 6... ccc eee eee eee eee eee e eens 32 16
Testimony of Michael Tonsellito............. ee. cece eeeeee 34 17
Joseph C. Mahlbeck...........ccccesceecess 70 45
Ty FI aa a wren hin oes i cdc Sates weneee 78 51
EEE TD iin oo ain disc cn ct aeccncceewens 86 57
Miest We. GOPMO . oo c Sec cecessdteovccces 96 64
Edward J. Clifford..... nk culo apaigra @eagiopeariiee's 98 66
Geowme FT. BRMAIG..... onc ccccccccscccecccsess 103 69
ED IE. ican dw cceddedeCewesetenmsios,s 105 70
I ONO in. 35k 6 6 xc cece deeeecarcias's 108 is
CN EIN 6s cena cens sd cwanosnase 118 79
Pow. Wes J. APMRB occ inc cecsccccesscs. 121 81
ee Se A WOME 6 on ick oo ccc cacadcnsccdscduns cece 130 87
Testimony of Fred Hemphill ....... 22.22.60. cece eee eeeee 133 89
PE is Ss 5 ins ce can cee wenwnWennaweesé 135 90
Chaties EX. Simerao. ......cccccccccccccvces 137 92
Charles H. McKee (recalled) ............06. 141 95
ey I ao 0 nec ene cin ceae gta ee wesies 144 97
IIE ais 10d va ndatnwctwe Mkeeeawemeee 152 103
George Terwilliger .. . 2... ccccccesccocccces 157 107
Bugeme BP. Krnemer. . ... 2. cscsccesccecees 162 110
ME WEG Tc ior ea cidccvea denne eesasy's 173 118
eee amar 176 120
CCM SN a ok a dcccm cides Sotiwekensemmese'e 179 122
iia cae s sata ddew ne dean 181 123
aE IIE, oe oin nk 5 ack 5 cc ceerees aes 195 133
I Sinan cic wos KucawsGedeeneuss® 196 133
We CR GIO ws on cs ce cencnccccsccccesas 209 142
i NEE IPOUIERONE vas, cic. cecsenbnveaucsee 213 145
Frederick Ohr (recalled) ..........cccccosee 222 152
I NN en a ch ln ie a eee necew oder ap 256 178
Eugene P. Kraemer (recalled).............. 257 179
iI SUI 65S aes sels ene ee euaeiek sho 258 179
PS ts I ic ec Kck ke se bien ceceesb hs 270 188
i cca on Ctnek deketeneecqedieee 275 191
Eugene P. Kraemer (recalled).............. 281 195
Martin F. O’Connor (recalled) .............. 287 200
Michael Tonsellito (recalled)............... 288 200
IN aos wc th URE Sine BESS eK 6 5 sce ceeeds chawes 00 289 200
Testimony of Dr. Louis Poole (recalled) ..............-. or | aa 203
Testimony of Haram A. Robins. ..... 20. scccccesscccccses 298 206
ee ly CINE Oh WN os onic bn a Soci cies cde cweaens oe 303 209
cn aoe Wanetss Wnt cen babeuieneweunecedee 307 221
Exhibit P*—Dr. Poole’s certificate... .........ceccceeeeees - 826 222
D*—<Application of Michael Tonsellito for license
to operate an automobile, &c............... 328 223
SITE ONG CUE OD ok civcvnadndcinceticenviccess 331 225
D*—Statement of Michael Tonsellito............. 331 225
D*—Statement of Michael Tonsellito............. 338 230
D*—Statement of Michael Tomsellito.............. 339 231
INDEX. iii
Original. Print
Pe Pe MN irk aie? oir we abcde bis oe uek coheed 341 232
ee CP NOI os ino ois Ss se dc vbbuccncceccven 347 234
En I Ae EE Ege Bae 348 234
NE can chs kn's Ghr eh seb ancha cece vues 349 234
ey NN aieis'n'd v\w kG dlgw de esd Poke ea cake wnk 350 234
PEE bist eon Sux i Seatobined dawns oc 351 234
PNET nin ncn voovitessbus chbide coi ueeekuc, 352 234
SPE OD AG sted SUM NE Shae d'i:d ah 4d. 46m Od dds Céonks Sk obic cba ae 353 235
ON: MNS 5 6G Wieidiacneve pS dpe ede he G64 6. xbd wea 354 235
NE RNa ail SOC berks pbs 64:4 sais Gao wos oh cRoS Es iw ece de 361 239
EY EM ONE csp opie desknrakabenccked cous. 362 239
NNT MOI eas bun d-via vs daa clecovdinn acura ct 367 242
TO WON as 6. son hy ok x Kee hace venb inscs svarweces 372 245
CRN atens ws diss «ate od < dbvinee c8idantanal 378 245
ee Pe IDA Fs'p is KAW csie-cv'na'cigs'eoe buen tevucscse ioe 380 249
SE Me NO a V5 os dees eves b-oehecdsbeceswacaric, 381 249
enn TO MN da ia x usin s wes in edpkee'eoelehecen enn 382 250
ee I ies otic wiel’s ie 11 Eh kiniekenagasiewiuc ln. 384 251
Clerk's return to writ of error............cccccccccccseces... 385 251
Stipulation as to record to be sent up by clerk of court of
See ee, Dn Sadho PG v sib hao VRE Saas vemos busoeneciccs 386 252
Statement of errors to be relied upon and designation by plain- f
tiff in error of parts of record to be PH I 6 es miosis eaux 389 253
Stipulation as to printing record.................ceccee.00.., é 254
gages
N. Y. C. & H. R, R. R. CO. VS. MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 1
a New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals.
MIcHAEL ToNnsELLITO, an Infant, Who Sues, etc., Plaintiff-Appellee,
Vs.
THe New York CentTrat anp Hupson River RarL~roap CoMPAny,
Defendant-A ppellant.
Action at Law. On Appeal from Hudson Circuit Court.
JAMES TONSELLITO, Plaintiff-A ppellee,
THe New York CenTRA anp Sesatis River RamRoap CoMPANY,
Defendant-Appellant,
Action at Law. On Appeal from Hudson Circuit Court.
STATE or Case.
Alexander Simpson, Attorney for Plaintiff-A ppellee,
Vredenburgh, Wall & Carey, Attorneys for Defendant-A ppellant.
Aug. 14,1915. [Stamp illegible. }
1 Notice of Appeal. ‘
(Filed November 13, 1914.) ;
Hudson County Circuit Court. K
Micuaet TonseLuiro, an Infant, Who Sues, ete., Plaintiff-A ppellee, 3
vs. z
New York Cenrrat & Hupson River Rarroap Company, .
Defendant-Appellant. :
On Appeal.
To Alexander Simpson, Ksq., Attorney for Plaintiff-Appellee:
Take Notice: that the defendant appeals from the whole of the a
judgment entered in this cause in the Hudson County Cireuit Court, z
to the Court of Errors and Appeals, in the last resort in all] causes of hi
the State of New Jersey. &
Dated November 11, 1914, Bs
VREDENBURGH, WALL & CAREY, i
Attorneys for Defendant-A ppellant. a
Service is hereby acknowledged of a copy of within notice of ap- 4
peal and consent to the fiiling of the recognizance on appeal, as 4
within time.
ALEX. SIMPSON,
Att’y for P’tiff-Ap-ellee,
1—239
bo
NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
2 Grounds of Appeal.
(Filed February 15, 1915.)
New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals.
MicnHae, Tonseuito, an Infant, Who Sues by James TONSELLITY,
His Next Friend, Plaintiff-Appellee,
vs.
Tun New York Centrat & Hupson River RarLtroap CoMPANY,
Defendant-Appellant.
On Appeal.
Grounds of Appeal.
The above named Defendant-Appellant, the New York Central &
Hudson River Railroad Company, assigns the following grounds of
appeal from the judgment of the Hudson Circuit Court in above
cause:
1. Because the trial court, at the close of the plaintiff's case, re-
fused to grant a nonsuit against the plaintiff, when thereunto moved
by the defendant.
2. Because the trial court, at the close of the whole case, refused
to direct a verdict in favor of defendant and against plaintiff, when
thereunto moved by defendant.
3 Because the trial court refused to find as a matter of law, that,
at the time of plaintiff’s injury, plaintiff and defendant were not
engaged in interstate commerce.
4. Because the jury disregarded the request of the trial court to
return an answer to the following question :
you find, as a matter of fact, the
“Q. At what point do |
3 plaintiff Michael Tonsellito attempted to board the engine,
at the time of the occurrence of the injury complained of?”
but returned instead the following evasive and unintelligible answer:
“And in answer to the question as to where Michael attempted to
board the engine, say that they find that he attempted to board the
engine at the air-pipe”’ ;
and the trial court refused to grant a new trial upon application of
of the defendant because of such failure.
The following questions were admitted :
5. To the witness Edward J. Clifford:
“Q. In these yards where you have had your experience, what is
the condition as to whether the road-bed is level with the ties, or
not, at points near switches and at points where it is customary to get
on and off trains?”
6. To witness Edward J. Clifford:
“Q, Have you ever found any of these yards where you have
——_—
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, PTC. 3
worked, filled in or otherwise, the ground two feet from measure-
ment, from the top of the rail down to the ground?”
7. To the witness George F. Hilliard:
“Q. In those yards, at the time that you worked there, what was
the condition of the road-bed in the yards, with reference to the rail?
Was it even with the ties, or was it down two feet lower than the
ties?”
8. To the witness Charles H. McKee:
“Q. What kind of oil did you have in the store-house?”
4° 9. To the witness John Johnson:
“Q. That was not the question, sir. I asked you if you
know of any other siding of the New York Central that had the
ground two feet below the top of the ties?”
10. To the witness Eugene P. Kraemer:
“Q. Now, Mr. Hartpence has not given you any measurement
since the last trial, to make any measurements between the curved
water-pipe and the switch?”
11. To the witness Kate L. Tully:
“Q. Page 219: Do you remember being asked: ‘What time did
he come out of the ether?’ and your answer: ‘5 P. M.’, at the last
trial?”
12. To the witness Kate L. Tully:
“Q. Then you testify at the last trial, being asked the question by
the court: ‘When was the ether administered? Does your record
show that? Does it show when the ether was administered? A,
Was taken to the operating-room; does not show the exact minute;
shows he came in at 1:20 and he came from the Emergency-room
at 1:20, and he was bathed and undressed by Dr. Fendrick and
taken to the operating-room and operated on by Dr. Fendrick’: did
you so testify at the last trial?”
“A. That could not have been correct.” ;
“Q. Did you so testify?
“A. No, I did not.”
Mr. Hartpence: I object.
“A. I did not testify to anything.”
5 13. To the witness Myles O. Gibson:
“Q. How would the engine get it? It would not go up
itself, would it? On this day?”
14, To the witness Dr. Edward Fendrick:
“Q. Assuming that this boy is in good health, what danger would
there be in performing this operation that Dr. Arlitz speaks of?
15. To the witness Dr. Louis Poole:
“Q. Would this man be able to run an automobile as well as he
is able to walk around on this stump, as you say he is, without any
artificial foot?”
16. To the witness Dr. Louis Poole:
“Q. Always do that when you write figures, first write the figures,
when you are concerned about the time, then look at the clock and
see it is wrong, and change the figure?”
The following questions overruled :
17. To the witness James Tonsellito:
Ss See oe ee
aia ct oe
4 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
“Q, How late did he work that day?”
18. To the witness Martin F. O'Connor:
“Q. You do not do that sort of thing in the railroad service, do
you?’
19. Because the trial court refused to strike out the testimony of
the witness Martin F. O’Connor, relating to the time-card of Michael
Tonsellito, offered in rebuttal by plaintiff.
6 20. The court refused to charge the jury:
1. If the roadbed of the defendants at the place and time of
the accident was similar in construction to the similar types of road-
bed of other standard railroads in th-s locality such as the Lehigh Val-
ley Railroad, The Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad and the
Pennsylvania Railroad companies, and there was no greater distance
from the roadbed itself to the top of the rails at the place and time
of the accident than on such similar types of railroad, then no neg-
ligence can be attributed to defendant because of such distance then
existing at such time and place of the accident.
2. Plaintiff, Micahel Tonsellito’s damages in this case are limited
to legal compensation for his pain and suffering, the testimony being
undisputed that plaintiff was not emancipated at the time of his
alleged injury, and there being no proof in the case of any inter-
ference with plaintiff's earning capacity in the future because of said
injury.
8. Tf the jury believe that the condition of the defendant’s road-
bed at the time and place of the alleged injury to plaintiff, Michael
Tonsellito, occurred (even though defective in the sense of the stat-
ute under which this action is brought, which of course is denied by
defendant) was as plain and obvious to the said plaintiff as to the
defendant and its agents, then plaintiff must be taken to have
assumed the risks of his employment in this respect, and cannot re-
cover against the defendant on that phase of this action.
VREDENBURGH, WALL & CAREY,
Attorneys for Defendant.
7 (Indorsed:) New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals.
Michael Tonsellito, an infant, who sues by James Tonsellito,
his next friend, Plaintiff-Appellee, vs. The New York Central &
Hudson River Railroad Company, Defendant-Appellant. On Ap-
peal. Grounds of Appeal. Vredenburgh, Wall & Carey, Attorneys,
1 Exchange Place, Jersey Citv, N. J. Service of a true copy of
within Grounds of Appeal is acknowledged this 13th day of February
1915, as of legal time. Alex, Simpson, Att’y for PV iff.
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. v
8 Recognizance.
(In Usual Form.)
Complaint.
(Filed Dec. 29, 1913.)
Hudson County Circuit Court.
Micnaer Toxseiuito, an Infant, Who Sues by James TonseLuiro,
His Next Friend, Plaintiff.
vs,
New York CENTRAL aANp Hupsox River Rartroap Company,
Defendant.
Action of Law.
The plaintiff, Michael Tonsellito, an infant, who sues by James
Tonsellito, his next friend. residing at No. 647 5th Street. New
Durham, Hudson County, New Jersey, says that:
1. The defendant above named is now and was at all times here-
inafter mentioned a foreign corporation, and was at all times here-
inafter mentioned engaged in interstate commerce between the
State of New York and the State of New Jersey, at Weehawken.
in the County of Hudson, and the State of New Jersey.
2. The plaintiff, Michael Tonsellito, on the 23d day of June,
1912, was the servant of the defendant, and the said defendant at
that time and at all times during which the plaintiff was in its
service was a common carrier by railroad engaged in commerce
between the State of New York and the State of New Jersey.
9 3. The plaintiff, on the 23d day of June, 1912. while in
the service of the said defendant as a common arrier by
railroad so engaged in interstate commerce, was injured at Wee-
hawken in the County of Hudson aforesaid by reason of the
negligence of the defendant, resulting in whole or in part from the
negligence of its officers, agents and employes, and by reason of
defect and insufficiency, due to the negligence of the defendant in
a certain locomotive, track and roadbed then and there used by the
said defendant in interstate commerce as aforesaid.
4. The negligence of the defendant aforesaid consisted in this:
That it did not use reasonable care to have its roadbed in a safe
condition, but. on the contrary, the roadhed at the place where the
plaintiff was injured was so unskillfully and improperly made and
graded that the said roadbed was below the ties of the railwav track
on which there was a certain locomotive upon which the plaintiff
was engaged, and the plaintiff. who was a minor of the ace of 16
years, had not been vronerly warned and instructed by the de-
fendant of certain hidden dangers connected with the said track
and roadbed, which were not obvious to him by reason of his vouth
©
€ NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
and inexperience, which defect has been before described in the
occurring thereof, which produced a condition which was difficult
and dangerous, although not obvious to a person of the inexperience
and youth of the plaintiff, when mounting upon locomotives at
said place, and the plaintiff while so engaged in the service of the
defendant, attempted to mount the said locomotive, by reason of
the negligence of the defendant aforesaid, and by reason of the
negligence of the defendant ‘aforesaid, and by reason of the
10 further negligence of the person ingplaintiff a reasonable
opportunity to board the same, but started the said locomo-
tive in motion, the plaintiff fell from the locomotive, and by reason *
thereof his left foot was cut and mashed so that he lost the same.
5. The plaintiff by reason of the said accident lost his foot and
suffered great pain and injury.
The plaintiff demands $25,000.00 damages.
ALEX. SIMPSON,
Attorney of Plaintiff.
Amended to Par. 3 of Complaint.
(Allowed on the Trial, May 24, 1914.)
Mr. Simpson: Then T will ask to make this amendment and set
up “that the plaintiff was emploved on a locomotive, which locomo-
tive was a locomotive engaged in moving a train from New Jersey
into the state of New York and that he was emploved on the loco-
motive in preparing that locomotive for the transportation of the
train and also in getting with that locomotive a barrel of oil, which
barrel of oil was to be taken from the state of New Jersev into the
state of New York. and while so eneaged on that locomotive in the
capacity of an extra fireman and in preparing that locomotive to
he attached to the train and in obtainine the harrel of oil to be
taken out of the state of New Jersev he was iniured by the negligence
set up in the complaint.”
The Court: You may have permission to so amend, and the de-
fendant’s answer to naravraph three as originally made will also
remain the answer and be the answer to paraeranh three as amended.
who did not gi
charge of said locomotive,
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 7
Answer.
(Filed January 23, 1914.)
Hudson County Circuit Court.
ICHAEL TONSELLITO, an Infant, Who Sues by JAMEs ToNSELLITO,
His Next Friend, Plaintiff,
vs,
lew YorK CEeNTRAL AND Hupson River Raitroap Company,
Defendant.
Action at Law.
Defendant, a corporation organized and existing under the laws
the State of New York, says that—
1. It denies Paragraph 1 of the Complaint.
2, It denies Paragraph 2 of the Complaint.
3. It admits so much of Paragraph 3 of the Complaint as alleges
it the plaintiff was injured at Weehawken. in the County of
idson, on the 28rd day of June, 1912: but denies all the rest and
nainder of said Paragraph 3 and the allegations contained therein,
L. It denies Paragraph 4 of the Complaint.
. It neither admits nor denies Pa ‘agraph 5 of the Complaint,
having sufficient knowledge thereof to form a belief, but leaves
intiff to his proof thereof.
Second Defense.
. Plaintiff, Michael Tonsellito, contributed to his injury by his
1 negligence, in that he attempted to get upon or aboard a
moving engine at the time of his alleged injury, although
warned not to do so by the servants, agents and emploves of
said defendant, which was an obviously unsafe, improper
dangerous act on the part of plaintiff,
Third Defense.
. Plaintiff, Michael Tonsellito, at the time when and place where
alleged injury occurred, was engaged in the performance of an
which formed no part of his employment, and in the perform-
2 of which he was a mere volunteer, assuming the risks attendant
eupon, to whom the defendant owed no legal duty as alleged in
Complaint.
Third Defense.
, Plaintiff, Michael Tonsellito, was not employed or engaged in
r-state commerce at the time when and place where his said
red injury occurred.
VREDENBURGH, WALL & CAREY,
Attorneys for Defendant.
ENE aN SP
eatethenadeiackeas alien eaee
8 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, V8.
Objection in Point of Law.
Defendant will object, as matter of law, that said complaint is
insufficient and should be stricken out, in that it does not allege or
aver that, at the time when and place where said alleged injury
to plaintiff, Michael Tonsellito, occurred, said plaintiff was engaged
or employed in intercommerce, and_ that therefore said Hudson
County Circuit Court is without jurisdiction to hear and determine
said action.
VREDENBURGH, WALL & CAREY,
Attorneys for Defendant.
13 (Indorsed:) Hudson County Cireuit Court. Michael Ton-
sellito, and infant, who sues by James Tonsellito, his next
friend, Plaintiff, vs. New York Central and Hudson River Railroad
Company, Defendant. Action at Law. Answer. Vredenburgh,
Wall & Carey, Att’ys for Defendant, 1 Exchange Place, Jersey City,
N. J. TI consent to the filing of within Answer as of time, and
hereby acknowledge service of a copy of the same. January 21,
1914. (Signed) Alex. Simpson, Att’y for Pref.
14 Reply.
(Filed January 26, 1914.)
The plaintiff for reply to the special matters set up by the defend-
ant in the above entitled cause in its answer denies the truth of the
matters alleged under the “Second,” “Third,” and “Third” defense,
the defendant having entitled two defenses the “Third Defense.”
The plaintiff also denies the sufficiency in point of law of the
objection in point of law raised by the answer of the defendant.
ALEX. SIMPSON,
Attorney for Plaintiff.
Judgment.
(Entered November 4, 1914.)
This action was tried before Judge Luther A, Campbell, with a
jury at the Hudson Circuit on November 4th, 1914.
he cause having been heard and submitted to the jury, they
returned their verdict as follows: They say that they find for the
plaintiff on occasion of the premises at the sum of six thousand
five hundred dollars ($6,500.).
Whereupon it is adjudged that the plaintiff recover of the defend-
ant the sum of six thousand five hundred dollars ($6,500. ) and his
costs which are taxed at the sum of sixty-nine dollars and sixty-five
cents ($69.65) making in the whole the sum of six thousand five
hundred and sixty-nine dollars and sixty-five cents ($6,569.69).
Judgment entered this November 4th, 1914.
LUTHER A. CAMPBELL, Judge.
ttest :
JOHN F. CROSBY, Clerk.
| MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC.
15 Certificate,
The answer of Luther A. Campbell, Esquire, Judge of the Circuit
Court, holden in and for the County of Hudson, and within named,
the record and proceedings of the plaint whereof mention is within
made with all things touching the same, I send to the Judges of our
Court.of Errors and Appeals, of the last resort of all causes at Tren-
ton, N, J., at the day and year within contained, in a certain appeal
to this writ annexed as within, I am commanded.
LUTHER A. CAMPBELL, Judge.
16 Notice of Appeal.
(Filed November 13, 1914.)
Hudson County Circuit Court.
JAMES TONSELLITO, Plaintiff-Appellee,
Vs.
New York Centra, & Hupson River Rartroap ComPAny,
Defendant-Appellant.
On Appeal. }
To Alexander Simpson, Esq., Attorney for Plaintiff-Appellee:
Take Notice: That the defendant appeals from the whole of the
judgment entered in this cause in the Hudson County Circuit Court,
to the Court of Errors and Appeals in the last resort in all causes
of the State of New Jersey.
Dated November 11, 1914.
VREDENBURGH, WALL & CAREY,
Attorneys for Def’t-Appellant.
Service of a copy of within notice of appeal is hereby acknowl-
edged, and consent to the filing of the recognizance on appeal, as
within time.
ALEX, SIMPSON,
Att'y of PU't'ff-Appellee.
19 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
17 Grounds of Appeal.
(Filed February 15, 1915.)
New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals.
James TonseLuiro, Plaintiff-Appellee,
vs.
Tur New York Centrat & Hupson River Rartroap Company,
Defendant-Appellant.
On Appeal,
Grounds of Appeal,
The above named Defendant-Appellant. the New York Central &
Hudson River Railroad Company, assigns the following grounds of
appeal from the judgment of the Hudson Circuit Court in above
cause:
1. Because the trial court, at the close of the plaintiff’s case, re-
fused to grant a nonsuit against the plaintiff, when thereunto moved
by the defendant.
2. Because the trial court, at the close of the whole case, refused
to direct a verdict in favor of defendant and against plaintiff, when
thereunto moved by defendant.
2 Because the trial court refused to find as a matter of law, that,
at the time of plaintiffs injury, plaintiff and defendant were not
engaged in interstate commerce.
4. Because the jury disregarded the request of the trial court to
return an answer to the following question :
“Q. At what point do you find, as a matter of fact, the
18 plaintiff Michael Tonsellito attempted to board the engine, at
the time of the occurrence of the injury complained of?”
but returned instead the following evasive and unintelligible answer:
“And in answer to the question as to where Michael attempted to
board the engine, say that they find that he attempted to board the
engine at the air-pipe” ; |
and the trial court refused to grant a new trial upon application of
the defendant because of such failure.
The following questions were admitted :
5. To the witness Edward J. Clifford:
“Q. In these yards where you have had your experience, what is
the condition as to whether the road-bed is level with the ties, or not,
at points near switches and at points where it is customary to get on
and off trains?”
6. To the witness Edward J. Clifford:
“Q, Have you ever found any of these yards where you have
worked, filled in or otherwise, the ground two feet from measure-
ment, from the top of the rail down to the ground?”
7. To the witness George F. Hilliard:
—
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 11
“Q. In those yards, at the time that you worked there, what was
the condition of the road-bed in the yards, with reference to the rail?
Was it ~—-, with the ties, or was it down two feet lower than the
ties?
19 8. To the witness Charles H. McKee:
“Q. What kind of oil did you have in the store-house?”
9. To the witness John Johnson:
“Q. That was not the question, sir. TI asked you if you knew of
any other siding of the New York Central that had the ground two
feet below the top of the ties?”
10. To the witness Eugene P, Kraemer:
“Q. Now, Mr. Hartpence has not given you any measurement
since the last trial, to make any measurements between the curved
water-pipe and the switch?”
11. To the witness Kate L. Tullv:
“Q. Page 219: Do you remember being asked: ‘What time did
he — out of the ether?’ and your answer: ‘5 P, M..’ at the last
trial ?” '
12. To the witness Kate L. Tully:
“Q. The vou testify at the last trial. being asked the question by
the court: ‘When was the ether administered? Does your record
show that? Does it show when the ether was administered? A.
Was taken to the operating-room ; does not show the exact minute;
shows he came in at 1:20 and he came from the emergency room
at 1:20, and he was bathed and undressed by Dr. Fendrick and
taken to the operating-room and operated on by Dr. Fendrick’; did
vou so testify at the last trial.
“A. That could not have been correct.
“Q. Did you so testify?
“No, I did not.”
20 Mr. Hartpence: T object.
“A. T did not testify to anything.”
13. To the witness Myles O. Gibson:
“Q. How would the engine get it? It would not go up itself,
would it? On this day?”
14. To the witness Dr. Edward Fendrick:
“Q. Assuming that this boy is in good health, what danger -ould
there be in performing this operation that Dr. Arlitz speaks of?
15. To the witness Dr. Louis Poole:
“Q. Would this man be able to run an automobile as well as he
is able to walk around on this stump, as you say he is, without any
artificial foot?”
16. To the witness Dr. Louis Poole:
“Q. Always do that when you write figures, first write the figures,
when you are concerned about the time, then look at the clock and
see it is wrong, and change the figure?”
The following questions were overruled:
17. To the witness James Tonsellito:
“Q. How late did he work that day?”
18. To the witness Martin F. O’Connor:
i
12 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, VS.
> You do not do that sort of thing in the railroad service, do
ou?
19. Because the trial court refused to strike out the testimony of
the witness Martin F. O’Connor, relating to the time-card of Michael
Tonsellito, offered in rebuttal by plaintiff.
21 20. The Court refused to charge the jury:
1. If the roadbed of the defendants at the place and time
of the accident was similar in ‘construction to the similar types of
roadbed of other standard railroads in this locality, such as the
Lehigh Valley Railroad, The Delaware, Lackawanna & Western
Railroad and the Pennsylvania Railroad companies, and there was
nod greater distance from the roadbed itself to the top of the rails at
the place and time of the accident than on such similar types of
railroad, then no negligence can be attributed to defendant beca-se
of such distance then existing at such time and place of the accident.
2 Plaintiff, Michael Tonsellito’s damages in this case are limited
to legal compensation for his pain and suffering, the testimony being
undisputed that plaintiff was not emancipated at the time of his
alleged injury, and there being no proof in the case of any inter-
ference with plaintiff's earning capacity in the future because of said
injury.
3. If the jury believe that the condition of the defendant’s road-
bed at the time and place of the alleged injury to plaintiff, Michael
Tonsellito, occurred (even though defective in the sense of the
statute under which this action is brought, which of course is denied
by defendant) was as plain and obvious to the said plaintiff as to the
defendant and its agents, then plaintiff must be taken to have
assumed the risks of his employment in this respect, and connot
recover against the defendant on that phase of this action.
21. The court charged the jury as follows:
If, however, you find that your verdict should be for Michael, then
you may find for the father * ilo
22 Therefore if, because of these injuries,and which you — are
the result of negligence of the defendant, company, the father
meets with a loss, or is not put in that position or left in that position
where he has the benefit of the son’s services, or, what we commonly
mean, will not have the benefit of the dollar and cent return for that
service, then he is entitled to have at your hands whatever you find
that loss will be.
VREDENBURGH, WALL & CAREY,
Attorneys of Defendant.
23 (Indorsed:) New Jersey Court of Errors and Appeals.
James Tonsellito, Plaintiff-Appellee, vs. The New York Cen-
tral and Hudson River Railroad Company, Defendant-Appellant.
On Appeal. Grounds of Appeal. Vredenburgh, Wall & Carey, At-
tornevs. 1 Exchange Place, Jersey City, N. J. Service of a true copy
of within Grounds of Appeal is acknowledged this 13th day of Feb-
ruary, 1915, as of legal time. Alex. Simpson, Attorney for Plaintiff.
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 13
24 Recognizance.
(In Usual Form.)
Complaint.
(Filed June 9, 1914.)
Hudson County Circuit Court.
JAMES ToNSELLITO, Plaintiff,
vs.
New York Centrat & Hupson River Rartroap CoMPANY,
Defendant.
Action at Law.
The plaintiff, James Tousellito, residing at No. 647 5th Street,
New Durham, Hudson County, New Jersey, says that :—
1. He is the father of a minor son named Michael Tonsellito, of
the age of 17 years on the 23rd day of June, 1912, and said Michael
Tonsellito is referred to in paragraph 3 of this complaint,
2. The defendant above named was in June 23, 1912, a foreign
corporation, and was a common carrier by railroad engaged in inter-
state commerce between the State of New York, and the State of New
Jersey, at Weehawken, in the County of Hudson, in the State of New
Jersey, propelling cars, and carrying goods and passengers from one
state to the other.
25 3. The plaintiffs said minor son, on the 23d of June, 1912,
was an employe of the defendant company, and was working
on an engine, firing the engine, raising steam, and preparing the said
engine to be taken out of said State of New Jersey, in interstate com-
merce on that day, to the State of New York, to pull a passenger train
containing passengers to be carried by said defendant on said day
from said State of New Jersey to said State of New York, and also
engaged in getting a barrel of oil to put on the said engine to be taken
on the said engine, by the said defendant, on the said day from the
State of New Jersey to the State of New York.
4. The plaintiff's said son, Michael Tonsellito, on the 23d day of
June, 1912, while in the service of the said defendant as a: common
carrier by railroad (both plaintiff's said son and the said defendant
being so engaged in interstate commerce) was injured, while doing
the things mentioned in paragraph 3 as done by him at Weehawken
in the County of Iludson aforesaid, by reason of the negligence of
the defendant, resulting in whole or in part from the negligence of
its officers, agents and employes, and by reason of defect and in-
sufficiency, due to the negligence of the defendant in a certain loco-
motive, track and roadbed then and there used by the said defendant
in interstate commerce as aforesaid.
5. The negligence of the defendant aforesaid consisted in this :—
That it did not use reasonable care to have its roadbed in a safe
Ree E aE Werke SITE AO me NOS RT MAA EIT Pape Re
ROE Ere ee Bo erET:
- 14 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R, R. CO, VS.
condition, but, on the contrary, the roadbed at the place where
26 the plaintiff’s son was injured was so unskillfully and im-
properly made and graded that the said roadbed, and the
ground adjacent thereto, were not level at a certain place, below the
ties of the railway track, and om the track at said place there was a
certain locomotive upon which the plaintiff's son was engaged, and
the plaintiff’s son, who was a minor of the age of 17 years, had not
been properly warned and instructed by the defendant of certain
hidden dangers connected with the said track and roadbed, produced
by said unlevel condition of said roadbed and ground, which were
not obvious to him by reason of his youth and inexperience, which
produced a condition which was difficult and dangerous (although
not obvious to a person of the inexperience and youth of the plain-
tiff’s son) to persons mounting upon locomotives at said place, and
the plaintiff’s son, while so engaged in the service of the defendant,
necessarily attempted to mount the said locomotive, and by reason
of the negligence of the defendant as aforesaid, and by reason of the
further negligence of the person in charge of the said locomotive,
who did not give the plaintiffs son a reasonable opportunity to board
the same, but started the said locomotive in motion, the plaintiff's
gon fell from and under the said locomotive, and by reason thereof
his right foot was cut and mashed so that he lost the same.
6. The plaintiff's son by reason of the said accident lost his foot.
7. The plaintiff thereby was forced to lay out and expend money
in medical expenses, to wit, the sum of $300.
8. The plaintiff thereby lost the services of his said son
27 from the day of said accident until the date of the within
action, and will be deprived of the services of his said son
during the minority of his said son.
The plaintiff demands $10,000.00.
ALEX. SIMPSON,
Attorney of Plaintiff.
28 Answer.
(Filed June 26, 1914.)
Hudson County Circuit Court.
James Tonsetuito, Plaintiff,
vs.
New York Centrat & Hupson River RatLRoap CoMPANY,
Defendant.
Action at Law.
Defendant, a corporation organized and existing under and by
virtue of the laws of the State of New York, says that—
1. It neither admits nor denies paragraph one of the complaint,
not having sufficient knowledge of the matters set forth therein to
form a belief, and therefore leaves plaintiff to his proof thereof.
9. It admits paragraph two of the complaint.
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 15
ad
It denies paragraph three of the complaint.
It denies paragraph four of the com laint.
It denies paragraph five of the complaint.
It denies paragraph six of the complaint.
. It neither admits nor denies paragraph seven of the complaint,
not having sufficient knowledge of the matters set forth therein to
form a belief, therefore leaves plaintiff to his proof thereof.
29 8. It denies paragraph eight of the complaint,
Second Defense.
Said Michael Tonselllito was contributorially negligent in that he
attempted to board a moving engine at the time he received the in-
jury complained of, by reason of which said injury resulted.
Third Defense.
The risk attendant upon the boarding of said engine by said
Michael Tonsellito, in the manner and under the circumstances as
alleged in the complaint was obvious to said Michael Tonsellito, and
was therefore assumed by him.
VREDENBURGH, WALL & CAREY,
Attorneys for Defendant.
ID OU
30 Reply.
(Filed July 16, 1914.)
The plaintiff for a reply denies all the matters set up by the de-
fendant’s answer under title second defence, ,
ALEX. SIMPSON,
Attorney for Plaintiff.
Judgment.
(Entered November 4, 1914.)
This action was tried before Luther A. Campbell with a jury at the
Hudson Cirenit on November 4th, 1914.
The cause having been heard and submitted to the jury, they re-
turned their verdict as follows: They say that they find for the
plaintiff and against the defendant and they assess the damages of
the plaintiff on occasion of the premises at the sum of one thousand
dollars ($1,000.). :
Whereupon it is adjudged that the plaintiff recover of the defend-
ant the sum of one thousand dollars ($1,000.) and his costs which are
taxed at the sum of fifty dollars and twelve cents ($50.12) making
in the whole the sum of one thousand and fifty dollars and twelve
cents ($1,050.12).
Judgment entered this November 4th, 1914.
LUTHER A. CAMPBELL, Judge.
Attest:
JOHN F. CROSBY, Clerk.
16 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
31 Certificate.
The answer of Luther A, Campbell, Esquire, Judge of the Circuit
Court, holden in and for the County of Hudson, and within named,
the record and proceedings of the plaint whereof mention is within
made with all things touching the same, I send to the Judges of
our Court of Errors and appeals of the last resort of all causes, at
Trenton, N. J., at the day and year within contained, in a certain
appeal to this writ annexed as within I am commanded,
LUTHER A. CAMPBELL, Judge.
$2 Stipulation.
Mr. Simpson: When this case was put off there were certain stipula-
tions made, last time, that you got. I have to get those stipulations
that Mr. Hartpence made, because I have not got the engineer and
he stipulated that I might read the testimony of the engineer, and
also of the superintendent, to show what locomotive number th’s
one was going out immediately after the accident.
Mr. Hartpence: Perhaps we can stipulate the fact without read-
ing it.
Mr. Simpson: I stated what I thought I wanted to stipulate, and
I will see if you will stipulate it or not.
Mr, Hartpence: Is it understood upon the record that the two
cases are being tried together and that the testimony governs both?
I do not think that has been formally placed upon the record.
The Court: With the assent of counsel it may be entered upon
the record that the two cases, one of Michael Tonsellito against
the New York Central & Hudson River Railroad, and the other of
James Tonsellito against the same defendant, will be tried together,
and that the testimony taken will apply to both actions. Is that
consented to, gentlemen?
Mr. Simpson: That is consented to on my part, yes.
Mr, Hartpence: Yes.
Mr, Simpson: That is the stipulation I want to have made,
whether Mr. Hartpence will consent to it or not, that locomotive
number 3791, which is the locomotive which plaintiff was on, in-
mediately before the time he was injured, and which one he was
attempting to board at the time he was injured, was the locomotive
of the Continental Limited, which left Weehawken at 2.25 in the
afternoon of the day upon which the plaintiff was injured, taking
a train from Weehawken, which train was taken by that
33 locomotive on that trip out of the State of New Jersey into
the State of New York; that it left the Granton roundhouse
at about 1:45 in the afternoon, to be attached to the train leaving
Weehawken at 2.35 in the afternoon, and that at the time it left
the roundhouse it had steamed up and was fired; that Albert W.
Gayman, the engineer of the Continental Limited, took that loco-
motive from the Granton roundhouse to Weehawken, and subse-
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETc. 17
quently that it took a train out of the State of New Jersey, leaving
Weehawken at 2.35. That is the stipulation I want to make.
Mr. Hartpence: I have no objection to that, if the court please,
unless it be to the one statement that at the time it left the round.
house it had steam up and was fired. I do not want that to go to
the extent of meaning that it had steam up and was fired at this
trip that is referred to in the rest of the stipulation. I do not think
that it was.
Mr. Simpson: Well, it was stipulated, the last time when this case
was put off, that Gayman, being a difficult witness to reach, I could
read his testimony. If that stipulation is not satisfactory, because
it is important to me and I think that his testimony shows that to
be the fact, I would like to read his testimony, as Mr. Hartpence
stipulated here in open court when the case was adjourned last time,
and I can do that later on by referring to the stipulation which Mr.
Kelley has taken down in shorthand.
The Court: We will see.
Mr. Hartpence: I have no objection.
The Court: The idea is, all of the statement of Mr. Simpson is
agreed to as a stipulation, except that portion which related to this
point, that is, that the locomotive in question had steam up and
was fired at the time it left the roundhouse.
34 _ Mr. Hartpence: No, if you put it that way I have no ob-
jection.
Mr. Simpson: At the time Gayman tock it, it had steam up and
was fired.
The Court: Then suppose you make that correction in the sug-
gestion made by Mr. Simpson, and with that correction the stipula-
tion is then agreed to by counsel for the defendant, and that obviates
and makes unnecessary the reading of the testimony ?
Mr. Hartpence: Yes.
Mr. Simpson: I do not think it makes it unnecessary. Of course,
there may be some little thing that I have slipped up on, that I
will have to look up. I do not waive whatever rights I had under
the stipulation.
Micuart ToNsELLITO, sworn.
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson :
Q. How old are you, Mike?
A. Nineteen.
Q. Where do you live?
A. 647 Bridge Street, New Durham.
Q. Did you ever work for the New York Central and Hudson
River Railroad Company?
A. Yes.
Q. When?
A, On June 23, 1912.
Q. June when?
A. June 23rd, 1912.
2—239
18 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
How long had you been working for them on June 23, 1912?
A year and a half.
On June 23, 1912, were you in the Granton yard?
Yes.
Were you hurt there?
Yes, sir.
Near what switch were you hurt?
. Nearer to the storehouse.
What do you call the switch?
A. Third switch.
35 Q. Now I show you a picture. You saw the Granton yard
and the switch and the track on the day that you were hurt,
didn’t you?
A. Yes.
Q. Is that a true picture of the condition of that track and yard
at the time that you were hurt?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. I show you another picture. Look at that one. Is that also
a true picture or a correct picture of the yard and track and the
place that you were hurt on the day that you were hurt?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Simpson: I offer those two pictures in evidence.
Mr. Hartpence: Can you add any statement as to when the
pictures were actually taken? Then I would have no particular
objection.
Mr. Simpson: They were taken the day they were taken.
Mr. Haripence: I understand that, but I want to know if you
could state what particular time.
Mr. Simpson: I could, but I do not think it is essential.
a Hartpence: I will object and ask for more formal or extended
proof,
Mr. Simpson: Under the case of Temple vs. Clifford, it is simply
necessary to prove that it is a true picture of the facts, that is all.
The Court: Let me see the case. It struck me that that is so.
Mr. Hartpence: I have no objection to the photographs going in
if I can know when they were actually taken, so we might use them
as an actual guide of the actual conditions. It is already in evidence
that the conditions had practically not changed at that time, but I
thought perhaps——
Mr. Simpson: I have no objection to putting it in.
36 Q. When were those pictures taken? Do you remember?
You were down when they were taken with the photographer?
A. About two weeks ago, I think.
Mr. Hartpence: I have no objection to their being admitted.
(Photographs marked Exhibits P-1 and P-2.)
Q. With reference to these pictures, pointing out these pictures,
will you show the place where you were at the time you were hurt?
A. I was—(indicating).
Q. Between ties 1 and 2?
OPOPOoPOoPO
MIVHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 19
A. Yes, Let me have your pencil. Right there, you say?
A. Yes,
Q. Mark that X. You mean those ties or between these ties?
A. Right between these ties.
The Court: Keep your finger where it was,
Q. One, two, three, where was it?
A. Right around the three, somewhere.
Q. You can’t tell anything more definite than that?
A. No.
Q. Is that about the place?
Mr. Simpson: I will mark it. That is marked Exhibit P-2 K,
Mr. Hartpence: That was the first one.
Q. Is that the same?
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as leading.
Q. Show me here about where you say with reference to this water
pipe? re oe
A. There (indicating).
Q. Put your finger there. It won’t bite you.
A. Right there (indicating).
Q. Is that the place?
Mr. Hartpence: I object. It is not the place.
37 Q. Put a pencil on where you say.
The Court: Suppose you rub the other one off.
(Mr. Simpson complies. )
( Witness indicates with pencil. )
Q. About there? All right.
The Court: That is also marked by an X on Exhibit P-1.
(Photograph shown to jury.)
Q. When did you go to work, Michael, for the New York Cen-
tral & Hudson River Railroad, first; how long before you were hurt
did you go to work for them?
A. Oh, about a year and a half.
Q. Who was the man employed you? Who was the man that
employed you?
A. Charlie Hassen.
Q. Charlie who?
. Hassen.
How much were you paid?
Sixteen cents an hour.
What were you hired to do?
. When I went to work it was a wiper.
Wiping?
Yes
What did you wipe?
Wiping engines,
POPO>opop>
SR I
20 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
Q. What part of the engine did you wipe?
A. Wells, and everything.
Q. Wells, and everything?
A. Tanks and
Q. During the first month did you do anything else besides
wiping?
A. Why, I used to be sent down to the machine shop.
Q. Eh?
A. Sent down to the machine shop.
Q. What did you do in the machine shop?
A, Go and get material for the machines that was broken—
fixed.
Q. What else did you do?
A. Why, I used to werk around the roundhouse, clean up.
Q. What work did you do around the roundhouse?
A. Pumping engines.
38 Q. What do you mean by pumping? What was that
pumping?
A. Why, the fire in the engine, and keeping water in the boiler.
Q. Where was the pump?
A. The pump was on the side of the boiler.
Q. What did the pump do when you worked in?
A. Put water in the boiler.
Q. When you say pumping engines do you mean that you pumped
this water into the boilers?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that would keep the steam going, would it?
A. Well, the fire would keep the steam going.
Q. If you don’t have any water you don’t have any steam, would
you?
A. No, wouldn’t have any steam.
Q. How long had you been pumping before this day in June?
A. Oh, about a year.
Q. Had you ever fired engines?
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it on the ground it is leading.
The Court: It is leading, 1 suppose.
Q. What else have you done besides pumping and wiping engines
and wiping headlights? What else had you done with respect to
engines before the day you were hurt?
Mr. Hartpence: I object on the ground that it is immaterial as to
what he did before he was hurt. I think this issue can be narrowed -
down to what he was doing at the time he was injured.
Mr. Simpson: Can’t narrow the issues down any. Mr. Hartpence
says he was a volunteer. He says he was a volunteer and he had no
business to fire, and therefore it becomes essential to me to prove
that he fired many times before this day, and had been seen firing
many times before this day by his boss, to show he was not a volun-
teer.
39 The Court: I so understood.
Mr. Hartpence: I withdraw my objection.
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 21
Q. Go on and tell us, what had you done besides pumping and
wiping, and the other things?
A. Firing engines, too,
Q. How often had you fired before the day that you were hurt?.
A. Oh, I don’t know, about fifty times.
Q. How many?
A. I don’t know, about fifty or a hundred.
The Court: I don’t understand.
Q. Fifty times, you say?
A. About fifty or a hundred.
The Court: Michael, try and talk as slowly and distinctly as you
can, because otherwise what you say will be of no value to the jury,
because it will be unable to understand it and hear you. Try and
keep that in mind.
Q. Now on the day that you were hurt what were you doing in the
morning?
A, Well, in the morning I went to work at half past four and we
started in to clean up the office and after that. why, I went on the
headlight job.
Q. On the headlight job? Was a man named Ohr around there
in the morning?
A. Yes.
Q. About noon time or twelve o’clock ?
A. Yes.
Q. What was Ohr?
A. Hostler.
Q. What did Ohr do with reference to you, if anything, about
twelve o'clock?
A, Well, IT was supposed to do whatever he told me unless IT was
on the extra
Mr. Hartpence: I object.
The Court: That may be stricken out. You were asked another
question.
Question repeated,
40 A. Fire an engine.
Q. Ohr fired it or what?
A. I fired engine.
Q. What happened before you fired the engine? What was said
to you by Ohr, or what happened?
A. He says, “Come up and be my fireman: | got to get some steam
up for me,”
Q. Did he say anything else to you or anything besides, “Come
up and be his fireman?”
Yes, told me to get a hook and shovel.
What was the hook?
. Hook up the fire,
Did you get a hook?
Yes, sir.
POPO>
22 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
Q. What did you do with it?
\. I put it on the engine.
Q. Did you get a shovel?
A. Yes.
Q. What did you do with that?
A. I put it on the engine.
Q. What did you do?
A. Then ] got up and fired the engine.
Q. Did you get on the engine?
A. Yes.
Q. How did you get on the engine?
A. I went up the steps and got in the cab.
Q. Where was the engine when you got up on it?
A. Oh, right at the tool shed.
Q. Was Ohr on the engine or did he get on after you?
A. He was on the engine.
Then as soon as you got on the engine you say you put a hook
and shovel on, what did you do?
A. I started to get some steam up.
Q. How did you start?
A. Put some coal on, and then I hooked her up and put some
water in the——
Q. In the boiler?
A. In the boiler.
Q. Then what was the effect of that, when you put some coal on
and hooked it up and put some water in the boiler, what did that
do to the engine?
A. That gave it more steam.
Q. Then what did Ohr do?
A. He started in to drive down to the first switch.
41 Q. Into the first switch?
A. Yes.
Q. What side of the cab were you on when he started to drive up
into the first switch?
A. Well, I was down firing the engine in the middle of it.
Q. In the middle of the engine?
A. Yes.
Q. What happened then when he got to the first switch?
A. Then I got out and threw it: we went down to the second
switch.
Q. What was the switch that you threw, the first switch?
A. That was number one switch.
Q. Number one. Then what did vou do after vou threw number
one switch? Did you go back?
Then he kept right down to the machine shop.
Well, did you come to another switch?
Yes.
What did you do when vou got to the other switch?
. Threw that switch.
. Did you get back on the engine?
Yes.
©
>PO>OPoP
g i
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 23
Q. Was the engine moving when you got back on it the second 1
time? ;
A. No, sir.
Q. He stopped it, did he?
A. Yes.
Q. And it stopped until you got on?
A. Yes.
Q. Now then when you got to the third switch, what did you do?
’ A. I got off and threw that switch.
Q. Then what did you do?
A. When I was coming back I wax going to get on the engine
Q. Wait a minute. How far back of the third switch were you
going to get on the engine? Tow far back did vou have to go to get
on the engine.
Mr. Hartpence: I object.
Q. How far did you go? About how far back of the third switch
did you go?
A. Back near to that pipe there.
Q. Between the pipe and the switch?
A. Between the pipe and the switch.
Q. At the point where you marked on the picture?
A. Yes.
42 Q. Why did you go back that far to get on? Where was
the cab?
A. That was the cab.
Q. Where the cab was. How was the ground at this water pipe
and at the point where vou tried to get on the engine; was the ground
level with the ties, or was it down lower here?
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as leading.
A. Down lower.
Mr. Simpson: I asked him whether it was level or whether it was
lower. That certainly is not leading.
Mr. Hartpence: The first part of the question, the condition of the
ground, and then was it level or lower.
The Court: It is really directing the attention of the witness to
the testimony, that is all.
Q. What was the condition of the ground at this point where you
have marked, with reference to height? What was it?
A. Well, it was kind of low.
Q. Do you know how much lower it was than the ties: a foot or
two feet?
A. About two feet.
The Court: The top of the ties?
Q. That is from the top of the ties?
A. About two feet.
Q. When you say two feet do you mean two feet down to the solid.
ground?
A. Yes.
NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
Q. Where did you step from to get on the engine? Was it this
point that you have described as two feet down fromr the ties or was it
some other point?
A. It was there where I marked it there.
Q. Was it beyond—was it down here at the ground or up on the
ties?
24
A. Well, I was about in the middle there.
43 Q. In the middle here; you mean of the ties?
A. Yes, where I marked.
Q. I know you are in the middle where you marked, but I want to
know where you were, actually on the ground here, or were you up
on the ties? Were you down all the two feet?
A. I was there.
Q. Where the two feet is?
A. Yes.
Q. When you tried to get on the locomotive from the point you
were in what happened?
A. Just as I was going to get on he starts off and he throws me.
Q. Where did you go?
A. My foot got run over.
Q. Where did your foot go, under the wheels?
A. Under the wheels.
Q. How did you start to get on from this place; did you lift your
foot up to get on?
A. Yes.
Q. How was it, hard or easy? How was it to reach the step?
A. It was hard.
Q. Why was it hard?
A. Because it was too high.
Q. The step was too high?
A. Yes.
Q. From where you stood?
A. Yes.
Q.
Were you able to reach it or were vou able to get your foot on
Mr. Simpson: Your honor, these men are grinning and laughing
at the witness and distracting the attention of the jury from the
examination. Whether they are trying to make fun of the testimony
T don’t know, but I cannot certainly——
The Court: T did not notice it, Mr. Simpson, but this will apply to
all persons in the court room, whether interested in this case or not,
that no demonstration of any character is to be made. If it continues,
I, of course, will have to take such steps as are necessary to stop it.
44 Q. Well, Michael, after this that you have described, what
happened to you? Were you taken away or what?
A. Yes, a couple of men picked me up and brought me to the
machine shop, up near the storehouse.
Q. What was the condition of your foot?
—,
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 25
It was crushed.
. Where were you taken from there?
. To the North Hudson Hospital.
How long were you in the North Hudson Hospital ?
About ten weeks, I guess, nine or ten weeks.
. When you came out of the North Hudson Hospital, where were
you taken?
A. At home.
Q. How long were you at home? If you don’t know, say you
don’t know.
A. I don’t know.
Q. When they got through with you at the Hospital did you have
any foot?
A. No, sir.
Q. How high up had they taken off your foot?
A. At the ankle.
Q. You have been examined by Dr. Arlitz since that time?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Going back to the time when you went to work, who was the
man that you say you saw when you first went to work?
A. I saw Mr. Howard.
Q. Hansen, was it?
A. No; Hansen was the foreman.
Q. Who was the man that you saw when you got your employ-
ment?
A. Saw Mr. Hassen.
Q. Mr. Hasser?
A. Yes.
Q. Who was the man immediately above you? Who was your
boss?
A. Mr. Hassen.
Q. Hassen? Was Hassen working there at the time you were
hurt?
A. No, sir.
Q. Who was your boss at the time you were hurt?
A. Mr. O’Connor.
45 Q. Well now, what was O'Connor? What was his position
there?
A. General foreman.
Q. What did he tell you when he came there that vou were to do?
A. Extra man.
Q. Did he tell you what you were to do with reference to other
people around the shop?
A. Yes; do anything they told me.
Q. Do anything that they told you?
A. Yes.
Q. So, for a period of about—when did Mr. O’Connor come there?
How long before you were hurt?
A. T think about a year.
Q. Well, for a period of a year before vou were hurt, what did you
do with reference to what other people told you?
OPorep
26 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
_ Mr. Hartpence: I object, on the ground as to what he did with
respect to other people, unless those other people are designated in
some way as being people who could bind this defendant——
Mr. Simpson: The insturctions of the defendant were to do what
other people told him in the shop. I may not be able to name what
other people, but if the immediate superior tells me, it seems to me
it is relevant what he said.
The Court: Of course the answer to that previous question was a
very general one, and I do not imagine for a moment that you are
directing your question to that point, nor does he intend to indicate
gome person who was of a lesser position than he. Undoubtedly you
did not intend that. I think he is entitled to know a little more
specifically at least who the persons were about the shop whose orders
he was to take or was directed to take.
Q. Who did Mr. O’Connor tell you to obey? You say he
46 told you to do what other people told you. Who did he name
when he told you to do what other people told you?
A. Machinists.
Q. And who else?
A. Boiler makers and all them things.
Q. Who were the hostlers there?
A. Fred Ohr.
Q. Is he the only hostler?
A. Yes. ‘
Q. Did Mr. O’Connor tell you anything about Freddie Ohr, about
doing what Freddie Ohr told you to do?
A. Yes.
Q. What did he tell you? What did Mr. O’Connor tell vou about
Freddie Ohr.
A. He says, If he needs any help, why, I should go with him.
Q. Needs any help, go with him?
A. Yes.
Q. Before the day that you were hurt had Freddie Ohr ever called
you before?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many times?
A. Oh, about a hundred times.
Q. A hundred times? A. What had he told you to do during
those times?
A. Well, fire the engine, get some steam up.
Q. Fire the engine and get steam up? What did Freddie Ohr
do with these engines? Where did he take them?
A. Sometimes we used to go down for coal and water, and he used
to take them’ in and out of the house. .
Q. Take them out of the house ; is that the place where they waited
for the engineer, where they took them?
A. Yes.
Q. Where were you going with this engine where you were on with
Ohr? Where was the — going that you were pumping up the
fire and putting steam on
A. We were going for a barrel of oil.
to
-1
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC,
Q. Where were you going?
A. Storehouse. : :
Q. Where was the storehouse with reference to this third switch?
Was it on this track?
. Yes, sir,
Q. Was this the storehouse track?
A. Yes, sir.
47 Q. You did not actually get up to the storehouse before
you were hurt, did you?
A. No, sir.
Q. Now when you got on this engine before you fired it up what
was the condition of it as. to steam; was the steam low or was the
steam high?
A. It was +4 ge
Q. What did you do with it, what did you do to keep it high?
Put coal on?
A. Put coal and water.
Q. And pump water to keep the steam up?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Had you ever done that before?
A. Yes.
Q. Now when you came back from the third switch did you
do anything with your hands at all?
. Yes, sir.
What did you do?
. Grabbed hold of the railing.
Which railing
Oh, on the tank.
The locomotive?
. On the tank, yes.
On the tank?
Yes,
What was that, a rod?
Yes.
Was it near the step?
That was above the step.
=" the step; you reached that with your hand?
es.
Which hand?
With the——
The Court: He don’t answer the question.
A. On the left hand.
Q. The left hand grabbed it? Now you say that Mr. Ohr started
the engine the time it went over your foot. Was it going fast or slow?
. Well, it was going about four miles or five miles an hour.
— It wasn’t going any faster than a man could walk?
0.
It was going very slowly?
Yes.
POPOPOPOPO>O>oODop
POPO>
ena
28 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
48 By the Court:
Q. Which side of the locomotive were you getting on, Mr. Michael?
A. On the engineer’s side.
Q. On the engineer’s side?
A. Yes.
By Mr. Simpson:
Q. Why did you choose the engineer’s side to get on? |
Mr. Hartpence: I object, on the ground that why he chose that
is not material.
The Court: I do not think it is.
Q. Was the engineer’s side the same side as the switch?
A. Yes, sir.
Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpense:
Q. Michael, had you ever gotten on and off an engine of that
same kind as 3791 before that day?
Yes, sir.
Where?
In the roundhouse.
In the roundhouse?
And outside the roundhouse.
Whereabouts outside the roundhouse?
By the tool shop.
How near is the tool shop to the roundhouse?
About two hundred feet or three hundred feet.
How far?
About three hundred feet.
I can’t hear you?
. About three hundred feet.
. Well, did you ever gei on or off such an engine when it was
moving?
A. Did I ever got off?
The Court: On or off such an engine when it was moving.
A. No, sir.
Q. You never did?
A. No, sir.
Q. Always got on or off when it was standing still; is that right?
A. Yes, sir.
DPOPOPOPOroPror
49 Q. Did you ever get on or off such an engine anywhere
except in the roundhouse and by the tool shop before this
occurrence?
A. We used to get a ride home at night down to the coal pocket;
got off down there.
' Q. How far is that from the roundhouse?
. A. About a mile.
Q. You could jump off then, couldn’t you, while the engine was
moving?
A. No, sir, it stops at the coal pocket.
—
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 29
Q. You got off then?
. Yes, sir.
Q. Was the tool house anywhere near the place where you were
hurt?
A. No, sir.
Q. Was the machine shop anywhere near where you were hurt?
A. Which machine shop?
Q. The one that you referred to when you said you sometimes
went to the machine shop from the roundhouse?
A. Well, that is about a half a mile.
Q. Which way, south or north?
A. South.
Q. When you would go down to the machine shop would you
ride on an engine or would you walk?
. Well, we used to have a hand car and have to push it down,
Oh, you would go down on the handcar?
Yes.
You sometimes walked, didn’t you?
. Yes, sometimes we walked.
. Sometimes rode on the hand car?
. We walked or pushed it down.
What say?
. We pushed it down.
Pushed the car?
Yes.
Q. What tracks would you take to go down to the machine shop
when you would go?
A. It was a track that leads from the storehouse down to the ma-
chine shop.
Q. This same track on which the engine was standing, or on
which the engine was when you were hurt; is that right? —
A. Yes, sir.
50 Q. So you have been up and down that track before,
hadn’t you, the day you were hurt?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. bo had worked there, you say, about a year and a half.
A. Yes.
Q. —before you were hurt. Had you ever ridden on an engine
around on that storehouse track before the day you were hurt?
A. Not on that track.
Q. Not on that track?
A. Not on that track.
Q. Where was Ohr, the engine man, when you got off the engine
there at the switch at which you were hurt? :
A. He was up in the cab.
Q. Well, did you have to pass-him in order to get off the engine?
A. He was sitting up on the side of the cab and I go down the
steps.
Q. Where had you been sitting?
A. Well, I was on the fireman’s side.
Q. On the left hand side?
POPO>OPOPoOD
30 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Well, he didn’t tell you to get off and throw that switch, did
he?
A. Well, I knew it had to be thrown.
The Court: No; you are not asked that. Listen to the question.
(Question repeated.)
A. No. ’
_Q. Was the engine standing still or moving when you got off?
A. Standing still.
Q. It had stopped, had it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was the engine anything like the engine which is shown in
this Exhibit P-17
A. The tanks are different on it, that is all.
Q. How about the engine part, was that about the same?
A. Yes.
Q. But the tank is a little different?
A. Yes.
Q. In what way was it different?
A. Well, longer and different.
51 Q. In the back part of the tank it is not square; was it
like this one?
A. Was square like this one.
Q. Cut off; is that about right?
A. Yes, sir..
Q. What is this place over here, Michael, where this engine is
standing?
A. That is the ashpit.
Q. That is the ashpit?
A. Yes.
Q. Are there tracks running along there?
A. Yes.
Q. Well, right beneath the engine here, what is that sort of a bank
there?
A. Big bank.
Q. It is a fill—filled off with cinders?
A. Yes, that was filling it up. Th-s is all coal (indicating).
Q. Over here at the point where you say you were at the time
you were hurt, which you have marked X, there were cinders along
there too, weren’t there?
A. Along here, there wasn’t nothing there.
Q. When you say that the ground was two feet or about two feet
below the top of the ties at that point where you were hurt, you
mean that it was filled in with cinders for about two feet? That is
what made the ties higher than the ground?
A. Yes.
Q. The ties rested on cinders?
A. Yes.
- ;
| MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 31
Q. And there was a fill there, wasn’t there, in order to get up the
hill going to the storehouse track?
A. Yes.
Mr. Simpson: I object. He cannot tell what the purpose of the
fill was. That is not proper cross-examination. He has not said any-
thing on direct as to what the purpose: of the making of the track is,
He cannot be asked what the purpose was on cross examination, and
he has not been qualified on direct examination.
The Court: Well, that may be so, Mr. Hartpence.
52 Mr. Hartpence: Well, it simply calls, it seems to me, for
a statement by this witness of what he could see with his own
eyes, that the fill was there, built up—lI did not mean to put it in the
shape to call for an expert opinion. It seems to me it is perfectly
competent to show by this witness that he understood and knew
that it was a fill and what its purpose was and what it was there for.
He testified he went up and down there to the machine shop.
The Court: Well, I will leave it stand, whatever there is in now.
I will leave it stand.
Mr. Hartpence: Yes.
Q. Now will you show, Michael, the point where you turned this
last switch when you were hurt?
A, Right here (indicating).
Q. Now you mark it with two XX’s, if you will. Mark it heavy
right where the switch is also. Now put another X alongside of it.
(Marks two XX’s.)
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That is the switch that you turned?
. Yes,
Q. After you turned the switch what did you do?
A. I walked back and T was going to get on the engine.
Q. Do you remember which way the track ran after you turned
the switch—which way the engine would have gone?
Why, it came over this way.
. Over to the left?
es.
You would have taken the track to the left?
es,
- And would have gone where?
To the storehouse,
- Where did the right hand track go?
se ry to the power house.
- “10w near to the storehouse was ¢} OW se?
A. About a hundred feet. ee ae
_Q. Well, right here at this switch, that is, to the right of it, the
cinders are filled in level there with the ties. aren’t they?
A. Yes, a little bit. ‘2
Mr. Simpson: Talk up, nobody can hear you.
Q. And the descent down to th
steep there as it was down here?
OPoPope>
© low ground was not quite so
32 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R, CO. VS.
A. No, sir.
Q. And there were two large planks right there at the switch
on those, weren’t there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That were perfectly level?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. If you, after you had turned the switch, had stood right there
at the switch or a little bit to the right of it, and had waited until
the engine passed over to that point, you could have stepped on the
engine then without any trouble or difficulty, couldn’t you?
(Objected to as calling for the conclusion of the witness. Objec-
tion overruled.)
Q. Well, if the engine was stopped I could,
Q. Now, Michael, when you went down to this po-nt which you
have marked X, and where you say you stood as you attempted
to get on the engine, you were right down in a hole there, weren't
you?
A. Yes.
Q. Two feet below the top of the ties?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And from that point you reached up and took hold of the
grab iron on the tank with your left hand; is that right’?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you reach the grab iron on the other—on the rear of the
cab—with your right hand or didn’t you?
A. Well, I was just going to get hold of it when he slapped me
over.
54 Q. Yes. Did you have either foot up on the step of the
tank or the engine?
A. Well, my left foot was pretty near all the way up, and it
threw me.
Q. Well, had your left foot actually reached the step before
you were thrown? Did you have your left foot actually on the
step of the engine or the tank belonging to the engine?
A. Yes; it was right on when they threw me.
Q. It was the moving of the engine that threw you?
A. Threw me.
Q. Do you remember how high up you had to reach in order to
take hold of that iron?
A. About four feet.
Q. Well, do you remember whether you had to put your arms
up this way in order to do it, or whether you just reached out
straight to do it?
A. No.
Q. Had to put your arms up that way to reach it?
A. Yes.
Q. Well, the engine was actually moving, wasn’t it, at the time
you did that? : j
A. No; when I was getting on the engine started off just as I
had my foot up, he starts right off.
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 33
Q. When you threw the switch how did you get back to this
point where you stood?
A. I walked back.
Q. Where did you walk?
A. Right along here.
Q. Make a straight line with the pencil right where you walked.
(Witness complies. )
Q. Well, did the engine start after you threw the switch?
A. No, it was standing there until I got back there.
Q. What is this little upright piece there, right there at the
switch?
A. This?
Q. Yes?
A. This here? I don’t know. These are signal colors or some-
thing.
Q. Signal colors?
A. Yes.
55 Q. There is a lamp in there which is lighted at night?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How far back of that signal lamp was the pilot of the engine
when you turned the twitch?
A. Right there (indicating).
Q. How many feet back?
A. About a foot.
Q. About a foot back from the signal lamp itself?
A. Yes.
Q. What is this pipe, Michael, that goes along here and then
curves out around at the point where you stood?
A. Compressed air pipe.
Q. That runs all along the tracks down there?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. I see here where this bulge comes it is supported by a plank
which is buried in the ground there, isn’t it?
A. Yes,
Q. And then it is all dug out around that pipe?
A. Yes, sir. I don’t know if it was dug out.
Q. Well, there is a hole right there?
A. Yes—it is level down here though.
Q. This part down in here is the level ground?
A. Yes.
Q. Running all up this way?
A. Yes.
Q. Now I show you, Michael, Exhibit P-2, and ask you what
this shed or house is over here on the center of the picture?
A. That is where the fire cleaners stayed.
Q. Where is the ashpit located on that picture?
A. Right over here (indicating).
Q. Off to the left of this house?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is this the same track running up along there that you
have-——
3—239
——
3 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R, CO. VS.
A. That runs to the store—or the roundhouse.
Q. That runs up to the roundhouse?
A. Yes, sir.
@. When you left the roundhouse and went down to switches
number one and number two, before you came up on the store-
house track, did you go down on that track?
A. Yes, sir.
56 Q. There by the ashpits?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Went right over the ashpits?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Then after you switched around further down you came back
up in the same direction of the storehouse?
A. Then we came up.
Q. This point on Exhibit P-2, which you have marked with X
is the place where you stood at the time you attempted to get on
the engine; is that right?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Will you show on this Exhibit P-2, the switch which you
turned just before you were hurt?
A. This one.
Q. Mark that with two XX’s.
A. (Witness complies, marking with XX.)
Q. About how far back of the signal lamp was the pilot—the
front part of the pilot of the engine when you threw the switch?
A. About one foot here.
Q. Well, will you mark that with a round ring?
(Witness Complies).
Q. When you first went to work there at Granton Mr. O’Connor
told you what to do, didn’t he?
A. Mr. O’Connor, yes, sir.
Q. He was your boss, wasn’t he?
A. Yes, sir, before Mr. Hasson.
Q. Well, what was Mr. Hasson ; what did he have to do with
rou?
: A. He was my foreman the year before Mr. O’Connor come,
Q. Well, Mr. O’Connor came there and took Mr. Hasson’s place
after you were there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you wiped the engines in the roundhouse. didn’t you?
A. Yes.
Q. When you first went there?
A, Yes.
Q. You were known as an engine wiper?
A. Yes.
Q. Whenever the engines came in the roundhouse you cleaned
them up?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Cleaned the headlights?
A. Yes, sir.
=~"
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC, 35
57 Q. The head parts of the engine?
A. Well, no—the headlight job is different; that is an-,
other man got that.
Q. You did that part of the time?
A. Oh, when I was on the extra work.
Q. When did you first go on this engine 3791 that day that you
were hurt?
A. At the tool shed.
Q. That you say was about three hundred feet away from the
roundhouse?
. Yes, sir.
When you got on you say the steam was up?
. Did not have much steam.
. How much steam did they have?
About eighty pound,
What time was that?
. About half-past twelve.
At noon—half past twelve, which is afternoon?
Well, it was twelve o’clock when I got on the engine.
It was what?
Twelve o’clock,
. When? When you did what?
A. The day I got hurt it was twelve o'clock when I went with him,
Q. What did you do at twelve o’cloek?
A. Well, I was going to go and get my ecard punched for the noon
OPOPOPrPOror
-~ r
era
.
Q. For the noon hour?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you go home for your noon meal?
A. No, sir.
Q. Where did you eat that?
A. I was working at noon hour,
Q. I know, but where did you eat your noon lunch?
A. Didn’t eat nothing at all.
Q. Where did you usually eat your noon lunch?
A. At the tool house.
Q. You took your lunch with you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Your usual noon hour was from twelve to one, wasn’t it?
A. Yes.
58 Q. What time was it when you first got on the engine
3791 there at the tool house?
A. Twelve o’clock.
Q. What time was it about, if you can tell. when you were hurt?
A. About half-past.
Q. You say you had about eighty pounds of steam up when you
got on?
A. It was eighty pounds of steam,
Q. Well, how long was it after you got on the engine before Ohr -
started the engine down the track?
A. About fifteen minutes.
36 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R, CO. vs.
Q. It stood there about fifteen minutes at the tool house before
Ohr started?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did you do in that time?”
A. I was getting ‘some steam up.
Q. What did you do to get the steam up?
A. Put some coal, hooked up the fire and put some water in
the boiler.
. Do you remember how much coal you put on?
I don’t know.
How many shovelfuls did you put on?
About thirty.
About thirty, and you put those right on the fire, did you?
Yes.
. Then the fire came up?
Yes.
As the fire came up the steam rose higher?
Kept going up.
. Do you remember how much steam was on when Ohr started
down the track?
A. Oh, it was about ninety pounds or a hundred.
Q. How much did you have just before you got to the switch
where you were hurt, Michael?
A. One hundred and eighty.
Q. One hundred and eighty. Was the engine moving when you
got off at number one switch?
A. No, sir.
Q. Was it moving when you got on?
A. No, sir.
Q. Was it moving when you got off at No 2 switch?
OPOPOrOerere&
A. No, sir.
59 Q. Was it moving when you got on?
A. No, sir.
Q. Was it moving when you got off at No. 2 switch?
A. No, sir.
Q. Well, it was moving when you got on No. 3 switch, wasn’t it?
A. Sir?
Q. It was moving when you got on at No. 3 switch, wasn’t it?
A. No, sir; when I got on, then she started off just as I was gel-
ting on.
Q. Just as you were getting on?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you say, Michael, that the track and the conditions there
at the switch shown in these two photographs, Exhibits P-1 and P-2,
are just the same as they were the day you were hurt?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You were pretty familiar with the conditions there, weren't
you?
“A. Yes: went down there every day.
Q. Went down there every day?
A. Pretty near.
—
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 37
The Court: What was that answer?
Mr. Hartpence: He says yes, I was down there every day, pretty
near.
Q. How old were you when you first started to work there at the
roundhouse?
. Fifteen, going on sixteen. ,
Going on sixteen when you first started to work?
Yes, sir.
. How old are you ne hael?
. Nineteen.
By the Court:
When was your last birthday?
When was my last birthday?
. When were vou nineteen?
. Last November.
Last November? ,
A. I will be twenty this——
>O>Oop>
e202
60 Q. You will be twenty this coming November? What
time in November, do you know?
A. The fifth.
Q. Then you were nineteen years old November 5 of 1913?
A. Yes.
Q. Is that correct?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Hartpence:
Q. Have you done any work at all since you were hurt, Michael?
A. Not much; couldn’t get no work.
Q. Well, what work have vou tried to get?
A. Well, IT was trying to get a chauffeur’s job, and I couldn't
get it.
Q. Have vou tried to get any other kind of a job?
A. No, sir. °
Q. Have you gone to school any since you were hurt?
A. No, sir.
Q. You went to school before you were hurt, didn’t you, before
you went to work there?
. Before I went to work on the railroad?
Yes?
Yes, sir.
Do you remember what school you went to last?
Public School No. 3.
In what grade were you when vou left?
Fifth.
. How long was it after you were hurt before you were able to
leave the hospital?
A. About nine or ten weeks,
Q. About nine or ten weeks? How long after that was it before
you were able to walk around?
A. About a year.
OPO>opo>
38 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, VS.
Q. About a year?
A, About a year.
Q. During that year were you at home?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In the house?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. All the time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Since then you have been walking around, haven’t you?
61
DPOPOPOPoOPo>
A. Yes.
Q. You have been working since then over at the garage,
haven’t you, of your brother-in-law?
Wasn’t working there.
You have been over there haven’t you?
Yes.
Day after day?
Yes, sir.
How far is that from your house, Michael?
About two blocks.
. You walked down there and back, didn’t you?
Yes.
Did you say yes or no?
Yes.
And you have and you do operate an automobile, do you not,
Michael ?
A.
Q.
A.
Yes, sir.
Yes, sir?
Yes, sir.
You have a license, a chauffeur’s license, haven’t you, from
the State of New Jersey, to do that?
3 O>OPOPro>r
runni
PO>OPOPOPoPro>
Yes, sir.
Got one in 1913, didn’t you?
Yes, sir.
And also one in 1914?
Yes, sir.
Still have it, haven’t you?
Yes, sir.
Have you learned or tried to learn to do anything else besides
ng an automobile?
. Before that I was learning telegraph.
. Learning to telegraph?
Yes.
How long did you do that?
. Well, about two months.
Have you done any of that since?
No, sir.
Did you learn?
No, sir.
Where were you when you were learning to telegraph?
T was in West New York schools.
Eh?
_ A school at West New York.
——_—
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 39
Q. That is where you were?
A. That is where the school was.
Q. How much money, Michael, did you make at the time you
were hurt, Michael, a month? How much money were you making
a month at the time you were hurt?
A. When I was hurt?
62 Q. Yes.
A. I didn’t get no money from the company.
Q. Didn’t you get money while you were working for the railroad
company ?
A. Yes.
Q. How much did you get?
A, Oh, about fifty dollars a month.
Q. Fifty dollars a month?
A. Yes,
Q. Who told you to go around on the engine the day you were
hurt with Ohr?
A. Freddie Ohr told me.
Q. Anybody else?
A. No, sir,
Q. And you were on your way to the tool house to eat your dinner
when he called you, weren’t you?
A. I was going to get my card punched and then come back and
Q. And then come back and eat?
A. Yes.
Q. Who punched your card?
A. Well, the clerk.
Q. At the tool house?
A. The storehouse,
Q. At the storehouse?
A. Or the office.
Q. At the office?
A. Yes.
Q. Where had you been working before that, that morning?
A. Up on the headlight job that day.
Q. What?
A. On the headlight job.
Q. In the roundhouse?
A. No, on the headlight job outside.
Q. Outside the roundhouse?
A. Yes.
Q. You mean you were cleaning the headlights?
A. Yes, and filling them up.
Q. So you got on the engine then and went on around the store
house or towards the storehouse with Ohr; is that right, when he
called you?
A. Oh, we go around. Yes, we went around there,
Q. And you put coal on the fire and pumped water into the
boilers, is that right?
Yes, sir.
63 Q. And rode on around towards the storehouse?
A. Yes.
a
40 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
Q. That is when you were hurt?
A. Yes.
Q. You had not got to the storehouse yet, had you, when you
were hurt?
A. No, sit, until they carried me.
Redirect examination by Mr. Simpson:
Q. What is this punching your card: what do you mean by that,
you were going to get your card punched?
coe There is a clock they have got, they punch the time you go
there.
Q. That is the time you stop work?
A. Yes,
Q. To eat your dinner?
A. Yes.
Y. Then you go back and punch it after you are through eating
dinner?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you go and get vour card punched before you were hurt,
or were you called on your way?
A. Just as T was going.
Q. You did not get it punched?
A. No.
Q. You got on the engine before it was punched?
A. Yes.
Q. You stated to Mr. Hartpence you put on coal and got up the
steam, and you said to me something about hooking up; what did
you mean hy hooking up?
. Hooking the fire.
, a put this iron hook in the fire and pull it around?
es,
Ts that after you put the coal on or before?
After you put the coal on.
What does that do?
. Makes it burn up.
Ts that what brings the steam up?
. Yes, sir.
"You stated to Mr. Hartpence when you got off and threw
number one switch and got on the engine was stopped. Did Ohr
tell you to throw number one switch?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did not tell vou to throw any, did he?
A. No, sir.
64 Q. But the engine stopped at one and you got on and it
stopped at two and you got on?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And did it stop at three when you got off?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You sav you have got a chauffeur’s license: what do you mean
by that? You mean a card that the secretary of our State gives‘
A. Yes, sir.
D>O>rOroro>
_
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 41
Q. They did not examine you whether you had a wooden foot or
not, did they, when they gave you a card?
A. No, sir.
Q. You simply signed an application blank, didn’t you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And told about vour age and all that?
A. Yes.
Q. They did not ask you whether you had a wooden foot or not?
A. No, sir.
Q. You did not tell them you had a wooden foot?
A. No, sir.
Q. Simply gave the card to run an automobile?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And all they asked you to do before they gave you a card was
to sign this application, wasn’t it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now at this switch Mr. Hartpence asked you something about
a switch. Is that ground level at the switch or is it low at the
switch,
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as leading.
Q. What is the condition of the ground at the switch?
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as not proper redirect examination.
A. It is low there.
Mr. Simpson: It is entirely within your Honor’s discretion.
The Court: T do not recall any testimony on his direct examina-
tion as to the condition of the switch. \
65 Mr. Simpson: No, I did not ask him.
The Court: T think it was all directed to the point where
he was attempting to get on.
Q. At this switch was the ground—what was the condition of the
ground here with reference to the switch?
A, Well, it was lower on one side.
Q. That is between the switch and the water pipe?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was it as low as the place where you fell, or not as low?
A. Not as low.
Q. What was the condition; how much higher was it at the switch
than at the place where you fell?
A. About a foot.
And it was a foot lower here and two feet lower there?
Yes, sir.
When you walked back was the engine stationary?
. Yes, sir,
2. That is, if you had waited there—when you were there stand-
ing, and threw the switch, what part of the engine were vou opposite?
When you went up to the switch what part of the engine was oppo-
site the switch when the engine was stationary?
A. Was that the right side?
Q2Oreo>
42 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, VS.
Q. No. When you stood at the switch and threw the switch where
was the headlight of the engine?
A. The head? North.
Q. North of the switch?
A. Yes.
Q. Then the front wheels were not over the switch, were they,
when you threw it?
A. No, sir.
Q. Where was the cab with reference to the place you were hurt;
where was the cab standing, in other words, when the engine was sta-
tionary?
A. There (indicating).
Q. At the water pipe?
A. At the air pipe.
Q. When you got back to the cab was the engine in motion or
was it still standing?
A. Standing.
66 Q. Now had Ohr or anybody told you anything about the
danger of attempting to get on an engine at this point where
you tried to get on?
(Objected to. Question withdrawn. )
Q. Did Ohr instruct you in any particular as to what danger
there was, if any from attempting toe step on an engine from e
point two feet below the ties?
A. No, sir.
(Objected to. Question withdrawn.)
'Q. Did you receive any instructions about boarding the engines
at a point where the roadbed was two feet below the ties?
A. No, sir.
Q. How much money did you say you have made since you were
hurt?
A. About fifty dollars.
Q. Fifty dollars or fifteen dollars? There is the last man on that
jury that is straining his ears to hear what you are saying. You
might as well be in Weehawken if you don’t. Your roar out in
the hall and now you talk to yourself. ‘How much money have you
made?
A. About fifty dollars.
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as immaterial, how much he has
made.
Q. How much have you earned since you have been hurt?
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it. It seems to me as to how much
he has produced to his father might be relevant—the father is su-
ing—but as to how much
Mr. Simpson: We have to do one thing at a time. I should think
only his earnings would go to his father.
The Court: Is not that the presumption, that they do go to the
father?
__ ee
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 43
Mr. Hartpence: Yes.
67 The Court: So far the question may be framed, how much
you have earned or how much you have turned over to your
father. It would amount to the same thing so far in the case.
Mr. Hartpence: Yes.
The Court: I will allow that question.
Q. How much have you earned?
A. About fifty dollars.
Q. Fifty dollars or fifteen dollars?
A. Fifty.
Q. Have you attempted to get work? Have you tried to get
work? Have you tried to get a job?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. As what?
A. Chauffeur.
Q. Have you succe-ded?
A. No, sir.
Q. Why not.
A. I don’t know—because 1 got a wooden foot, I suppose.
. Not what you suppose, but what have the people told you when
you tried to get a job?
Mr. Hartpence: I object, as I do not think that is competent evi-
dence, what these people may have told him. They might have told
him enything. How could that be brought in here as evidence,
Mr. Simpson: I will withdraw the question.
Q. Why were you not able to get a position as chauffeur?
(Objected to as calling for a conclusion, and that the name of:
some person to whom he applied would have to be specified. Ob-
jection sustained. )
Q. Where did you try to get a position?
A. I don’t know; a whole lot of places.
Q. Trying to get a place as a chauffeur?
A. Yes, sir.
68 Q. This fifty dollars that you spoke of, have you earned
that driving a machine, or how have you earned that?
A. Well, driving a machine.
Q. How much would you get when you worked?
A. Get about two dollars or three dollars a day.
Recross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
Q. Who examined you, Michael, when you got your license from
the State to drive a machine?
A. An inspector.
Where?
Jersey City.
What part of Jersey City?
. Montgomery Street.
No. 1, Montgomery?
P>Oore
seen
44 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R, CO. VS.
A. No, sir; City Hall.
Q. The City Hall? Do you know his name?
A. No, sir.
Q. Well, he asked you a lot of questions, didn’t he, about your
ability to run an’ automobile?
. No, sir.
What?
. No, sir.
Didn’t he ask you if you had ever run an automobile?
_ No, sir. I had a paper that had the questions on.
>O>O >
The Court: Which are you referring to now, the 1911 license,
or 1913 license?
Mr. Hartpence: I have specified the 1913 license.
By the Court:
Q. You understand that is the 1913 license, the first license, you
understand?
A. Yes.
Q. Mr. Hartpence’s questions are all directed to the time when
your 1913 license was issued to you?
A. He tested me on the road.
By Mr. Hartpence:
Q. Tested you out on the road?
A, Yes.
Q. He took you out on the road with the machine?
A. Yes.
69 Q. And you ran the machine?
A. Yes.
Q. With the inspector riding with you?
A. Yes.
Q. And he passed you and gave you your card?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. He also gave you a paper with questions on that you had to
answer?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You wrote the answers to those questions, did you?
A. Yes.
Q. Those questions asked you what you knew about an automo-
bile, didn’t they?
Tell about the law of the road and things like that.
The rules of the road?
. oe.
. And the mechanism of the machine?
Not much about the machine.
There was something about it, wasn’t there?
_ Well, T am telling you about how—what you ought to have
on machines.
Q. Asked you if you had a puncture what you would do?
A. Puncture?
>OPOreo>r
—_—_ sania
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC, 45
Q. If you had a breakdown what you would do?
A. Yes.
Q. Those questions were all in that paper?
A. Yes. ;
Q. Then after you had answered those questions apd had gone
out on the road with the inspector he gave you the license?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, when you got your 1914 license they did not ask you
so many questions, did they?
A. Didn’t ask me none.
Q. Just filed a paper asking for the renewal of your license?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It was renewed for you?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Simpson:
Q. Do you know how high the step was that you tried to reach
from the rail, how high up on the locomotive?
A. No, sir.
Q. Have you walked with this cane ever since the time vou were
hurt?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Use that all the time?
A. Yes, sir.
70 Josern C. Manurneck, sworn.
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson:
Q. Mr. Mahlbeck, what is your occupation ?
A. Surveyor.
Q. How long have you been a surveyor?
A. Five years.
Q. Where is your place of business?
A. 927 Union Street, West Hoboken.
Q. Did you at my request go to the Granton yard of the New
York Central, and make a map of a portion of the track, and also
a map of a sectional portion of that track.
A. I did.
Q. At the switch pointed out to you by Mr. Tonsellito?
A. I did.
Q. Is that the map?
A, That is the map.
Q. Is that a correct map of the switeh and the w
the surroundings there?
A. The plan shows the situation, but it m
part where the switch crosses, |
ment,
Q. I show vou a photograph ;
thing as you made a map of?
A. Yes,
ater pipes and
ay not show the exact
ut sections of it is exact measure-
is this a photograph of the same
46 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
The Court: Designate the exhibit.
Mr. Simpson: Exhibit 2-P, K.
Q. Showing you a picture of what purports to be a railroad tra
and pipe which is looped and a switch, I ask you if that map is
correct picture of the scene shown by the photograph?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. When was it made?
A. This was made October 7.
Q. 1914?
A, 1914.
Mr. Simpson: I offer that map in evidence.
Mr. Hartpence: May I see it? (Examines.)
(Paper marked Exhibit P-3.)
71 Mr. Hartpence: May I cross examine?
The Court: Certainly.
Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
Q. When you made this sketch, Mr. Mahlbeck, what time of t
day was it?
A. About half past two.
Q. In the afternoon?
A. In the afternoon,
Q. How long a time were you there making your examination a
inspection ?
A. I was there for about a half an hour to an hour outside;
was in the place about ten minutes.
Q. In the place about ten minutes?
A. About ten minutes.
Q. Where were you outside?
A. Out in the street-—on the Bergenpike Road.
Q. And this yard is enclosed by a fence, isn’t it?
A. Yes, sir.
_ And the Bergenpike Road is quite high up above the ya
isn’t it?
A. It is, yes.
Q. And do you know how far it is from where you stood outs
over to this switch?
A. As far as I could judge it was about a hundred feet.
Q. You did not measure it?
A. I did not have time.
Q. You merely judge that that was the distance?
A. About a hundred feet in.
Q. Then you went inside alone, or was some one with you?
A. Some one with me.
Q. Who?
A. Some assistant of Mr. Simpson’s.
Mr. Simpson: Gentz.
Q. I understood you on direct examination that Mr. Tonsel!
showed you the place?
A. No,
| MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 47
Q. How did you know where to go and make this?
A. Mr. Gentz went with me.
Q. Mr. Tonsellito was not there then?
A. No, sir.
72 Q. Neither Michael nor his father?
A. I do not know them,
Q. During the ten minutes that you were actually in there what
measurements did you actually make?
A, Measured the height of the rail, the height of the tie beams at
that point.
Q. At which point?
A. Shown on the section.
Q. At the switch?
A. No; section A-B marked on the sketch,
Q. Shown at the section A-B?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. The height of the rail from what point?
A. From the top of the tie.
\
Q. To the top of the rail?
. To the top of the rail.
Q. Is that indicated on this section?
A. It is shown on the section, and then the height of the rail—
not the rail—the height of the tie.
Q. From what point?
A. From the ground, the level of the ground, at that point,
Q. You mean by the level of the ground the level of the ground
surrounding ground?
A. The surrounding ground.
Q. On this at that point A-B where you made the section, there
was a fill, was there not?
A. What do you mean fill?
Q. Well, the track was raised on cinders which were raised up
higher than the level of the surrounding ground?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you measure the height of these cinders from the general
level of the ground?
A, I did. It is marked on the plan.
Q. Is that shown on this section also?
A. It is.
Q. And that fill ran all the way along both ways, did it not, from
the place where you made your cross section ?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Did you notice where it ended, looking north, looking to the
right?
A. I measured it about from the height——
73 Q. From which pipe?
A, From the air pipe shown on the plan.
Q. You mean from the hook of the air pipe?
) A. Yes, sir.
Q. How far north did you measure?
A. I judge it to be that point, about thirteen foot and a half.
7
48 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
Q. That was about what—to what switch?
A. Well, it did not quite reach the switch.
Q. Thirteen and a half feet did not quite reach the switch?
A. Yes, |
Q. But it almost reached the switch, is that right? |
A. Yes.
. So, from the point where the air pipe crooked up to the switch,
it was about thirteen and a half feet?
‘A. It was about sixteen or seventeen feet. I did not measure to
the switch.
Q. Did you look and judge with your eyes about how far from
the switch that fill ran?
A. Well, it ran maybe a hundred feet.
Q. Up to some building up there?
A. Some building.
Q. Did you notice with your eye how far south it ran?
A. Well, it ran quite a distance south, several hundred feet.
_ Gradually tapered off, didn’t it, down to the level of the
ground?
A. Yes.
Q. Well, y-u made the actual measurements, did you, with your
instruments for the heights at the sections?
A. I made it with a standard tape line.
Q. Anybody assist you?
A. Well, not in the heights. I could do that myself.
Q. What did anyone assist you in?
A. Just showed me where the place was and measured the width
of the ties.
Q. Now just one or two more questions, will you state how far it
‘s from the crook of the air pipe in a southerly direction to
74 the point where you indicate the fill?
A. T do not know,
Q. Can you state how far it is northerly to that?
A. No.
Q. You did not actually measure those distances?
A. No: I did not have time to measure it.
Q. And the map—and the section itself on the outline is based
really upon your judgment as to distances?
A’ Not on the section. These are actual distances.
Q. Every one except at the section?
A. Yes.
Q. What does this irregular line running along the track show?
A. Shows the slope.
Q. That shows the slope?
A. The dirt runs out up to here and then she slopes down.
Q. Does this show the distances from the rail out to the point
where it does slope?
A. Does here (indicating). Pegins to slope right at the tie itself,
and shows at the section here (indicating).
Q. And further south and further north?
a | ”
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 49
A. Why, there is a distance of about a foot and a half where you
can walk,
(. Did you measure that distance along here where you have in-
dicated, or is that your judgment?
A. No, that is measured,
Q. That is actually measured?
A. Yes, measured at those points here and over here (indicating).
Y. Will you indicate the two points where you measured?
A. Right here (indicating),
Q). Mark it out here with X. You also measured there?
A. Right about here (indicating).
Q. At the two points you marked X are you prepared to state
those measurements?
A. Yes.
Q. I did not ask you to do it, but I ask you if you are prepared to
state that?
A. Yes, can. This is drawn to an accurate scale.
75 Mr. Hartpence: Well, if the Court please, this seems to be «
sketch and section that were made from a general observation
of the point which is indicated, from a distance of at least a hun-
dred feet away, at a point where the yard is enclosed with a fence,
and very slight measurements were actually taken, and it does not
seem to me to have been prepared with that minuteness and ac-
curacy which is necessary to render it admissible as a sketch or
section.
The Court: But he has testified, as T understand, that some parts
of it are the results of actual measurements. I think I have to
agree with you on the part which is produced merely from observa-
tion.
Mr. Simpson: That does not go to the competency.
The Court: But only to the part where the actual measurements
were taken.
Mr. Simpson: That does not go to the competency. This man
says it is an actual picture—whether he made it improperly or prop-
erly certainly goes to the weight of the evidence.
The Court: I will admit it,
(Exhibit P-8 placed on easel.)
Redirect examination by Mr. Simpson:
Q. Now will you come down here a minute, What is this marked
section A-B and scale one to one. What is that?
A, That is an imaginery cut through the line A-B.
Q. Is the line A-B the second tie from the curved water pipe?
A. Yes.
Q. What is the distance from the bottom of the imaginery cut,
being the top of the top rail? What is that distance, from this
point down to that?
A. Two feet three inches,
76 Q. Two feet three from the ground to the point——
A. To the top of the rail.
4—239
a
50 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, VS.
The Court: Suppose you mark that perpendicular distance A-B?
Mr. Simpson: A-D,
Q. Two feet three inches; is that right?
A. Yes.
Q. What is the distance from A to the top of the tie on which the
rail rests?
A. One foot ten inches,
Q. That is A-E. I show you this photograph marked Exhibit
P-2, K, and ask you to show me where on this photograph that
imaginary cross section is made?
A. Right through the center. Through the center of the first two
ties, Through the center of these ties.
Q. Through the center of the second tie from the crooked pipe?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now you say that you did not have time. What do you mean |
by that, you did not have time?
Mr, Hartpence: I object to it as immaterial,
Mr. Simpson: I want to show what preparation he gave to the
making of this map. Mr. Hartpence has brought that out and
asked him if he did not have time, and I want to show it.
The Court: What virtue is there in that? The real question is
what he did do,
Mr. Simpson: I will withdraw that question.
Q. Did the employees of the New York Central chase you off
this ground before you had a chance to finish the getting of the de
tails for this map?
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as incompetent, irrelevant and im-
material, and framed for the purpose of prejudicing the
77 jury.
The Court: I will sustain the objection. I do not see the value
of it.
Mr. Hartpence: I move for the withdrawal of a juror.
The Court: I decline to do that. I will sustain the objection.
Q. You did say to Mr. Hartpence you did not have time to
make it?
Mr. Hartpence: I object as immaterial, irrelevant and not proper
cross examination.
The Court: I will sustain the objection and it may be stricken
dut,
Q. How much time were you on the ground? How long were
you on the ground where this track was?
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as not proper redirect examination.
He was asked on cross examination and he said ten minutes.
Mr. Simpson: Mr. Hartpence brought it out.
—
MIVHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. o
The Court: That was for the purpose of informing himself as to
whether he should object to the offer of the exhibit.
Mr. Simpson: Mr. Hartpence brought out the cross examination.
The Court: I will overrule the objection.
A. About ten minutes.
Q. When did you make your observation of the place from the
highway; was it after you were at the track or before you were at
‘the track?
A. Before I was at the track.
Q. Before you were at the track?
A, And afterwards, too,
78 Q. What was it you looked at from the highway, was it
the top part, to get material for this, or for this (indicating).
A. To the top part.
Emit EILers, sworn.
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson:
Where do you live?
No. 619 Fish Street, Union Hill.
What is your business?
Machinist.
2. Did you work in the West Shore yard on the day that Ton-
sellito was hurt?
A. I did, sir.
Q. Do vou know the place of the accident?
A. I do, sir.
Q. How would you describe it? What is it known as in the yard
there?
A. That pipe is under my restriction. This air pipe is called the
expansion, and right about this locality
Crore
The Court: I cannot hear you.
A. This pipe described is the pipe under my restriction there,
called high pressure air pipe, and this bend was called an expansion
bend. and between the locality of this expansion pipe and this bend
I presume he was hurt.
Q. Between the expansion pipe curve and the switch, were you
on that day familiar with that general location there?
A. I was, yes.
Q. How long had you been working in the yard then?
A. Close on three years.
Q. What was the condition of the ground and the track and the
ties and the rail where the air pipe curved between the curve of the
air pipe and the switch; what was the condition of the ground with
reference to height?
A. A large slope.
79 Q. How much of a slope was there?
A. About two feet slope running about forty-five off the
horizontal line.
NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS. |
Q. Forty-five what?
A. Degrees. Two foot drop off the center.
Q. Did you see the accident to the boy?
A. T seen him in that falling position, yes.
Q. Just tell the jury what you saw from the beginning until the
end, will you?
A, While eating lunch between one and two on this day T was look-
ing southerly and seen an engine approaching, and my attention
was drawn to a paper, and on looking by reason of this fellow falling
off the engine or what I cannot tell, because the distance was too
ereat, but I seen him in a stumbling position falling on the ground.
Q. What was his position? Had his foot reached the engine step?
A. That was too great a distance to say. I seen him in a standing
position, seemed to make an attempt to mount the engine, and I saw
him fall.
Did you see him go under the engine?
I did not, no sir: the distance was too great to distinguish that.
How far away from the position?
T should say around five hundred feet more or less.
Where were you with reference to the storehouse?
Opposite to the storehouse.
. Did you go down to help him?
A. I did not, no, sir.
Q. Could you tell whether the engine was moving at the time
you saw him in the falling position ?
A. T could not; no, sir.
Q. Could not tell from the distance?
A. No, sir.
Q. Could not tell whether it was stationary or moving?
A. No, sir.
80 Q. What did you do after you saw him in this falling
position ?
A. I could not possibly leave my plant, because [ was in sole
operation at that time, and I stayed there until I got relief and T
went down to the machine shop and saw him on the bench,
Q. Did not see him brought from the injury?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did not see who got hold of this man?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you see the engine before you saw him in the falling
position ?
A. I saw it approaching; yes, sir.
Q. Where was it when you last saw it before you saw him in the
falling position ; how near this switeh was it?
A. Somewhere about a hundred or more feet, approaching, coming
towards that switch.
Q. Did you see it again between that point, that is, a hundred feet
away from the switch, that is at the point where you saw him in the
falling position?
A. Only while it was standing.
Q. Where was it standing?
PPOrore
re
©)
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 53
A. I presume at the mouth of the switeh.
Mr. Hartpence: I object.
Q. You say when it was standing. When you saw it standing
where was it?
A. Somewhere around the bend of the pipe, of the expansion.
Q. Where that expansion
A. Yes.
Q. How long did you see it standing there?
A. An impulse of a few minutes, probably four or five minutes.
Q. Do you mean minutes or seconds?
A. Minutes.
Q. You saw it stationary round this pipe four or five minutes?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That is before it got to the switeh—before it went over
31 the switch?
A. Before it went over the switch.
Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
Q. Where were you, Mr. Filer?
A. T was eating my lunch outside the boiler house, sort of an ex-
ension.
Q. And that boiler house is located north of the switch, isn’t it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You say about five hundred feet?
A. I believe so; yes, sir.
Q. As you were up at the boiler house you looked up in this di-
ection ?
A. Yes.
Q. Were you on the right-hand side of this track or left-hand side?
. On the right-hand side of the track.
. On the right-hand side of the track?
. On the left-hand side.
. On the left-hand side as you look south?
. Yes, sir.
TIow far to the left of the track were vou?
. Why, practically-——well, left of the track. There the track
vas—in other words, that is quite a complicated question. The track
urved there, your Honor, and I was sitting on the left of the track
nd looking at the south of the track.
Q. From where you sat were you in a line—would a straight line
lirectly south run to the left of this switch or to the right of the
witch?
A. To the left of the switch.
Q. About how much?
A. Direct line to the left of the switch five hundred feet in distance,
nd I am
>O>OPro>
Q. You were not five hundred feet to the left of the track, were
‘ou, from where you sat?
A. IT am saying that the switch took that S shape. T was sitting
54 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
on the right of the track looking at the left of the track. It is a hard
thing to distinguish, but I ean draw it for you.
82 Q. You were sitting on the right of the track, but you were
looking on the left to the track?
A. Yes, that is right.
Q. How much to the left of the track would a straight line run
right from your eye directly south?
A. I presume a foot or two. TI was sitting—probably right on the
track.
. You had worked there, you say about three years?
. Close to three years.
Had you been up and down that track?
On rare occasions, yes.
Engines come up and down there all the time?
Yes.
9 were taken up to the storehouse there?
es.
And the boiler house, and out all the time?
. Yes, coal cars.
- Workmen there working up and down that track all the time?
. All the time.
Q. That switch was thrown from time to time to send them in
the different ways?
Yes.
Regular everyday occurrence, wasn’t it?
Yes, sir.
Are you working up there now, Mr. Eiler?
. No, sir.
How long since you worked up there?
Why, over a year, I believe.
. Are you working for the New York Central Railroad at all
.
>OPOPOPOroPro
>dOPOPoro>
. No, sir.
When you left up there you left their employ, did you?
I resigned ; yes, sir.
Did you know Michael Tonsellito before he was hurt?
I did; yes, sir.
You had seen him around there?
. Yes, sir.
. How long? e
_ Ever since I had been in the employ of the company.
>O>rOrore
Mr. Simpson: Talk louder.
83 A. While in the employ of the company I seen him on
frequent occasions coming back and forth and in our power-
house and around the superintendent’s and so forth.
Q. You did not see him get off the engine, did you, at this switch?
A. No, sir.
Q. You did not see him until he was just about to—
A. About ascending the engine.
Q. About ascending the engine?
A. Yes.
_ ——————
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 55
Q. What became of the engine after he, Michael, fell—after you
saw Michael fall?
. That I don’t know, sir.
Where did you go?
Back in the powerhouse.
You did not wait to see which way the engine went?
I did not; no, sir.
Did you see the engine at all after that?
T did not; no, sir.
POPOro>r
Redirect examinauon by Mr. Simpson:
. Mr. Eiler, you told Mr. Hartpence you had seen him about
three vears around. What did vou see him doing in the three years?
A. Why, practically everything in the line of labor, work
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as not proper redirect examination.
Mr. Simpson: He brought it out. I want to find out what he saw
him doing.
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as not proper redirect.
Mr. Simpson: He says “How long have you known him. You
have known him three years. Where have you seen him? I have
seen him around, in and out and all around,” and IT want to see what
he saw him doing.
Mr. Hartpence: My examination was to test this man’s power of
identifying Michael, just as to whether he had seen him and knew
him, and T asked him nothing about
84 TheCourt: If von will say that that was vour intention——
Mr. Hartpence: That was my only intention.
The Court: And then you limit your testimony on that point to
that purpose. Then I will sustain the objection.
Mr. Hartpence: That was my object and purpose.
The Court: Then vou declare that all that this witness testified to
as to this seeing of the plaintiff in and about the place there wae
only for the purpose of testing the reliability of the recollection of
this witness?
Mr. Simpson: I ask to have an objection to your Honor’s ruling
on the ground that it is not proper. It is not possible to rule out
a redirect question simply on the ground that the counsel will say
that is all he wants the testimony to prove, because the jury may say
it proves a great deal more, and merely by him stating a purpose
is not sufficient to shear the evidence of such qualities as would allow
me to examine on it.
The Court: Oh, I think so.
Mr. Simpson: I ask an exception to your Honor’s overruling the
question.
The Court: My statement and his answer were made in the hearing
of the jury, and they are certainly capable of understanding it.
You may have your objection.
Mr. Simpson: I ask to be allowed that question as though he was
my witness on direct and as though there had not been any question.
ARs
a
56 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, VS.
Q. What did you see him doing in those three years around the
place there?
85 Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as not proper redirect ex-
amination.
Mr. Simpson: It is not proper redirect and it is within your
Honor’s discretion to allow me to ask the questions omitted on di-
rect examination. It is entirely in your discretion.
The Court: All right. I will permit it.
Q. What did you see him doing around in these three years?
A. Everything in general. Laboring work.
Q. What about engines? What did you see him doing about en-
gines?
A. Cleaning and shining lights and filling them and so forth,
and firing engines back and forth in and around the roundhouse,
pumping them up.
Q. Can you tell us generally how many times you have seen him
firing engines before the day of the accident?
A. Probably hundreds.
Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
Q. What did you see him doing on the engines, firing them?
A. T seen him on the steps of the engine, throwing coal in the
boiler, and working the injectors and so forth.
Where were the engines?
Stored in the roundhouse.
In the roundhouse, weren’t they?
Yes, sir.
. On these other occasions that you have seen him around there,
these numerous occasions, had you ever seen him go up and down
this storehouse track to the machine shop?
A. T cannot say I did; no sir.
Q. You saw him chiefly in and around the neighborhood of the
roundhouse? s
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And on the tracks, the spurs that run out from the
86 roundhouse?
A. From the roundhouse; yes, sir.
Q. On which the engines stand, isn’t that right?
A. Yes, sir.
Redirect examination by Mr. Simpson:
Q. These spurs are spurs that engines are brought out from the
roundhouse outside on?
A. On to the turntables.
Q. And they are brought out under their own steam?
A. The majority of them, yes.
OPOPo
By Mr. Hartpence:
Q. Do they come to a dead end at the turntable or just beyond?
A. They go to the turntable; yes, sir.
— z
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 57
FREDERICK WENDT, sworn.
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson:
Q. Mr. Wendt, where do you live?
A. 521 Blum Street, Town of Union.
Q. How long have you lived in this country?
A. Last forty-five years. a
Q. Did you work for the New York Central in June, 19127
A. I did. ;
Q. Were you working for them on the 23rd of June, 1912?
| A. Yes, sir. é
| Q. What were you doing on that day?
A, Airbrake inspector. ;
Q. Had you seen this boy Tonsellito around the roundhouse at
Granton or on the outside of the roundhouse while vou had been
employed there before the 23rd of June?
A. I did.
Q. Well, say, take a year before that time, what had you
87 seen him doing, if anything in and around the roundhouse.
and out of the roundhouse?
A. Rubbing machines and laboring around and cleaning up and
wiping engines.
Q. Anything else?
A. Pumping engines; took care of them.
Q. What do you mean by taking care of them; what would he
do?
A. Keep water in the boilers and keep fire in the engines.
Q. How would he keep fire in the engines?
A. By putting coal on.
| Q. Putting coal on?
A. Yes.
Q. How many times have you seen him do that?
A. Yes; all of a hundred times,
Q. Who was with him when he would do that—anybody on the
mene, any man that was known.as a hostler or anything of that
xind ?
A, Not around the shop.
Q. But on the outside, when the engines were taken out of the
roundhouse to the turntable, who would do that? Would he do
that or someone else?
A. No, the hostler.
Q. Well then, who would be firing the engines and kee
\ ping up
fire and steam while the hostler took it outside
to put it on the turn-
table?
A. If she had steam enough in her and fire enough in her to
ast.
Q. If he did. You saw Tonsellito on the machine?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Tell us what you would see him do if
ler would take them outside?
anything, when the host-
aR SBI AN Tn > NSIS ROMEO SESE SSPE EEDA SEATBELT Mh
58 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
A. Well, he would be getting on there and shoveling coal or som
thing like that, on to the fire, that is all I seen.
Q. That is while the hostler was taking it out?
A. While the hostler was taking it out.
Q. Where would the hostler bring them out when he would tal
them out?
A. Right out to the tool room.
88 Q. Tool room; where was that?
A. About a hundred feet or more outside of the tur
table. ‘
Q. Who was the foreman around the yard during the time th
you were there and Saw Tonsellito doing these different things th
you have stated?
A. Mr. O’Connor.
Q. Have you ever seen Mr. O’Connor around near enough
Tonsellito to see him when he was doing these different things th
you have stated?
Mr. Hartpence: I object.
A. Yes.
(Objected to as calling for a conclusion. Question withdrawn.
Q. How near was O’Connor to Tonsellito when you saw Tons
lito doing these different things, firing engines, wiping engin
keeping up steam—how near did you see O’Connor to him on th
occasions?
A. Some days seen him right close by and sometimes further aw:
just where he happened to meet him around the place.
Q. Where was O’Connor’s general position during these times?
Where would he be doing his day’s work around the works?
A. Yes, all around the roundhouse.
Q. Where was O’Connor’s office?
A. Why, this end of the—west of the roundhouse.
Q. Where did you work generally?
. I worked
Near his office?
. Ashpit inspection.
Q. That is around where the inspection was?
Yes.
' These engines that you have described being brought out
the roundhouse by the hostler, how near would they pass to O’C
nor’s office?
A. Why, right past the door.
Q. Right past the door?
A. Yes.
89 Q. Who gave the orders around the shop?
A. Why, Mr. O’Connor.
Q. He was the man in charge, was he?
A. General foreman.
Q. a you know a man named Ohr when you worked there?
A. Yes.
>O >
or
s-
Pabiaal eeu de
-«~,
—
A.
Q).
NNR Aw So taal Loess
MICHAEL TONSELLIiO, ETC. 59
What did Ohr do; what was he?
. Hostler.
What was the hostler; what did he do?
. Supposed to bring engines in the house and take them out
they are ordered.
). Take them in and take them out? On the 23rd of June,
_ who was the hostler there then, Ohr?
Yes, sir.
Did you see any of this accident yourself?
. No, sir; I did not.
Where were you?
. I was on the inspection trip.
. How near was it to this switch?
. About two hundred feet.
. Were you there at the pit at the time of the accident?
Yes.
. That is you were only two hundred feet away?
. Yes, sir.
. You saw this engine then, didn’t vou?
Yes.
Well now, what did you see, if vou did not see the accident?
Will you tell the jury just what you saw prior to the accident and
subsequent to the accident?
A. Well, the engine stopped there right across two hundred feet
from
Q.
A,
my distance—I was eating my dinner at the time.
T could not hear that. Will you tell us that over again?
T say I was two hundred feet away from the engine at the
time she stood there when the accident happened. I was eating my
dinner at the time.
Q.
a0
You were eating your dinner?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. When she stopped what did you see, if anvthing?
A. T seen lots of them running over there, and T was just
looking over there and I didn’t see anything else.
Q.
A
side.
POFOPO
Q.
Could not see anything else?
A. No, sir; because I was on the left side and she was on the right
. Did you see her as she approached the switch?
Yes,
. Did you see how near she got to the switch before she stopped?
. She stopped this side of the switch.
. That is before she reached the switch?
. Yes.
How far before she reached the switch? How far away from
the switch was she when she stopped?
About two or three feet.
Did you see the boy Tonsellito at all?
No, [ could not see him.
Could not see him?
No,
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A,
A
60 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
Q. Where was the engine when you first saw it or you saw it
proaching that switch?
A. I see it standing there then.
Q. You saw her when she was standing. You did not see her
she came up to the switch?
A. I saw her come up, but I did not see her stop there at
time.
Q. Were you watching her all the time?
A. Well, I did not just put my eye on her, but I seen her wl
she stopped dead and go on.
Q. When she stopped dead?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was that the time that the people all ran?
A. Yes; that is the time of the accident.
Q. You don’t know whether when she came up and she stop
before she made the dead stop or not?
A. She made a dead stop.
Q. I know she did, but was that the time when the people
ran?
A. Yes, sir.
91 Q. Before she made her dead stop, as she came up to
switch, do you know whether she stopped before she made
dead stop, or weren’t you watching her at all?
A. I seen her coming, but I didn’t watch the stop.
Q. Did you see her stop to throw the switch before she made
dead stop?
A. Yes, I saw her stop.
Q. I know, but what kind of a stop was it? Was it the fir
when everybody ran, when the boy was hurt, or was it before
was hurt that you saw the stop?
A. He stopped to throw the switch.
Q. You saw him stop to throw the switch? Well then, how |
after that did you see the people run?
A. Well. then I did not look right away and after awhile I
her standing there yet and I seen them all running.
Q. What interval of time was there between the time she sto]
to throw the switch and you looked upon and saw her still stoy
and saw the people running? What time occurred?
A. Four or five minutes there.
Then what did you do, if anything?
I walked over there after a while.
You did not go over right away?
No.
. When you got there where was this boy?
They was taking him over to the machine shop.
He was in the machine shop?
Taking him over.
You did not help to carry him?
. I did not. T did not help to carry him.
When you got there afterwards you found him in the
POPOPO
FO>O>o
a
1a-
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 61
Q. You did not find him lying alongside of the engine?
A. No.
(). Where was that machine shop?
\. That is five hundred feet from there or more.
92 Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
(. You were over to the ashpit, Mr. Wendt, you say?
A. Yes.
(). That is over near by this engine 858, isn’t it?
A. Yes, and I was here.
Q. In Exhibit P-1; that is where you were, over near that en-
vine?
A. No.
Q. That is the ashpit, isn’t it?
A. Yes, but I was over from the ashpit, on this end of it,
Q. On the right of it?
A. Yes. That building was not there at that time of the acci-
dent.
Q. You mean this building on Exhibit P-2 with the white shirt
tacked on it; is that the building?
A. Yes; that is the bench there 1 was sitting on at the time of
the accident.
Q. That bench is located right in to the left of that building,
isn’t it?
A. Yes, facing south.
’. Which way were you looking?
A. Over towards this way.
Q. Over towards the storehouse track?
A. Yes.
Q. You were seated there eating your dinner?
A
Q
A
Q
-~
. Yes.
. What time of day was it?
. About half-past twelve.
. What is the dinner hour?
A. Between twelve and one.
Q. Therefore | suppose everybody eats their dinner between twelve
and one?
A. Well, if we haven’t any work in the pit. We work twelve
hours.
Q. Where is the tool house; does that show on Exhibit P-2?
A. No, don’t show there.
Q. As you sat there, eating your dinner, looking over towards
this storehouse track, you saw this engine 3791 coming up
A. Yes, sir.
Q. —the storehouse track; is that right?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was she running fast or slow?
A. Slow gait.
93 Q. Making any noise?
A. Yes. Oh, yes.
62 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, VS.
Q. Ringing the bell?
A. Yes.
Q. Blowing the whistle?
A. No; I did not hear the blowing of the whistle.
Q. The bell was ringing?
A. No: the bell was not ringing. No bell ringing.
Q. You took particular notice of that; the bell was not ringing?
A. Yes, no bell was ringing.
_ You say as the engine was headed up the track you saw the
left-hand side of the engine; that is the fireman’s side?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You could not see the engineman’s side of the engine, could
you, from where you sat?
A. No, sir.
Q. You could not see this switch on the storehouse could you?
A. No, not while the engine stood there.
Q. You could not see this curve in the air pipe, could you, from
where you sat?
A. No, not while the engine stood there.
Q. What was your business there?
A. Air-brake inspector.
Q. How long had you held that position at the time Tonsellito
was hurt?
I held it there about a year then.
Are you still in the same position?
Yes, sir.
Where?
Pennsylvania road.
Not working for the New York Central now, are you?
No, sir.
_ How long have you been working for the Pennsylvania?
OPoOrerer
(Objected to as not proper cross examination. Question permit-
Q. As you tested the airbrakes what part of the Granton yard
would your duties require you to go?
. A. In the ashpit.
94 Q. At the ashpit; is that where the test was made always?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where is the roundhouse located with relation to the ashpit’
A. About four hundred or five hundred feet or more.
Q. North?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. When you saw O’Connor up by his office would you be down
here at the ashpit?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. When you saw Tonsellity on the engine with Ohr up there
where O’Connor was located, you would see him from the ashpit:
is that right? |
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You were too far away to hear what they said?
_ ——
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, PTC. 63
A. Yes, too far away. :
Q. And you usually saw them when they were right up there by
the office, up to the roundhouse, didn’t you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. This engine came up the storehouse track and you saw it stop
and then you saw the people running; is that correct.
A. Well, she might have started, but I did not just see her when
she started; I see after it stopped again, and I was sitting—TI could
not see whether she started or didn’t.
Q. You saw her come up and stop?
A. She stopped there.
Q. And you looked at her?
A. I started to eat my dinner; I did not look over there right
away, for five or six minutes.
Q. Then you saw people running?
A. She was still standing there.
Q. Did you see who was there?
A. I don’t remember who was there.
Q. Did you see anybody on the engine when she first came up
and stopped?
A. Mr. Ohr.
Q. You saw Ohr, did you?
A. I saw Ohr, and saw Tonsellito.
95 Q. Where was Tonsellito when you first saw him?
A. He was on the deck.
Q. What do you mean by the deck?
A. That is on the deck floor of the tank.
Q. On the floor of the tank right directly back of the fire box?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. About midway between the fireman's seat and the engineer’s
seat?
A. Yes, in the gangway.
- Q. Did you see what he did after he came up and the engine
- stopped?
No, I did not see him.
He was still on the engine when you saw him?
Still on the engine, yes.
When did you next see him?
I didn’t see him until after he got hurt.
Where was Ohr when it came up to a stop?
. On the right-hand side.
Right side of the engine?
Right side of the cab.
Could you see him from where you were?
Yes, sir.
a you see anybody else on the engine?
0.
When did you next see Ohr?
I saw him right-hand of the engine.
. All the time it stood there?
Yes,
PO>OPOPOPOPOroro>
64 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO, VS. |
Q. Saw him all the time that it stood there?
A. It stood there quite a while after the accident.
Q. When you said she came up and stopped and that you saw
the people running, did you see him on the engine all that time?
A. I don’t remember where he was.
Q. Of course you did not see Michael attempt to get on the engine,
did you?
A. I did not.
Q. The engine was between you and him. That’s all.
96 Redirect examinataion by Mr. Simpson:
Q. From the first time you saw the engine come to a stop, which
you have called the stop to throw the switch, until the time you
jooked up a second time and saw the people running, how much
time elapsed?
A. About five or six minutes or more.
Recess.
Mr. Simpson: I want to read the testimony of the witness Albert
W. Gayman, who was the engineer of the Continental Limited.
The last time it was put off I said I should not, and I do not want
to bring him back, and Mr. Hartpence agreed to put in the testi-
mony.
The Court: There is no question but that comes in the stipula-
tion?
Mr. Hartpence: Yes.
The Court: It may be entered on the record that the defendant
consents to the reading of the testimony.
(Mr. Simpson read the testimony of Albert W. Gayman as fol-
lows: )
“Appert W. GAYMAN, recalled:
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson:
Q. Is that in your handwriting?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Will you tell me where you took your engine and at what
time you took it on the 23rd of June, 1912?
Mr. Hartpence: I object, unless the particular trip upon which
he took it is specified.
“Q. I am referring to the testimony already given by the
97 witness that he was engineer of the Continental Limited that
left at 2:35 in the afternoon at Weehawken.”
Mr. Simpson: Do you want all these objections read—the ob-
jections that you made?
Mr. Hartpence: I do not think so, Mr. Simpson—all right; I
will admit it.
“A. Where I got on the engine?
a ERASER EERE
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 6h
Q. Where you took it from by that slip?
A. 1 took it from Granton back to Weehawken.
Q. The Granton roundhouse?
A. Yes.
Q. When?
A. Out at 1:45.
Q. What was the number of the engine?
A. 3791.
Q. 3791. Where did you take it from the Granton roundhouse?
\. 1 suppose
Q. Look at that slip; is that in your handwriting?
A. Yes.
Q
). You said, “Time of leaving yard 2:58;” is that correct?
A. 2.38.
Q. Is that correct?
A. That means Weehawken.
Q. Is that correct?
\. I should think it would be.
Q. It is in your handwriting. You wrote it down. Do you write
hings down?
A. 2:38, that is what I said. Correct.
Q. Where did you go with that when you left the yard? Where
lid you go with it? Where did you go with this engine?
A. Answer it?
Q. Yes.
A. Where did I go? I go to Ravina, New York.
Q. What did you pull that day, what kind of a train? Passenger
rain or freight train?
A. Passenger train.
Q. Have you any doubt about it?
A. No, sir. All right.
98 Q. When you got this engine out of the roundhouse at
1:45 steam was up in her, wasn’t it?
A. Certainly was.
Q. Certainly was. Do you know how much steam was in her;
what pressure?
A. No, sir.
Q. Who got on the engine with you?
A. Charlie Brown, the fireman.
Q. Is he your fireman?
A. Yes.
Q. What did you do with that engine when you got to Ravina?
(Question withdrawn.) )
Q. What does that mean, “Time wanted?”
A. It was supposed the scheduled leaving time of the train at
Weehawken.
Q. 2:38?
A. 2:30.
Q. And you left at 2:38?
A. Yes, that is as I understand it.
5—239
66 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
Q. Isn’t this the same figure there? Isn’t that 8? Isn’t that
the same figure as that?
A. No, I think that is 8 there. It has been rubbed here so you
can’t tell: It is there 2:30, but we probably left a few minutes late,
We run number one. 2:30 was the scheduled time for leaving
of that train.”
Epwarp J, CLIFFORD, sworn.
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson:
What is your business?
IT am a brakeman.
How long have you been a brakeman?
About three years.
Where have you worked as brakeman?
On the Pennsylvania Railroad and the Central Railroad of
New Jersey.
Q. In yards located in Jersey City?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That is in the County of Hudson?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have you become familiar with the condition of the roadbeds
within those yards?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. As a brakeman has it been necessary in following your oceu-
pation to get on and off trains near switches?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And to throw switches?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now have you become familiar with the general custom of the
railroads that you have named in keeping the condition of their
roadbeds up?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. At places near switches?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, I show you a picture marked Exhibit P-1-K, and ask you
to look at the portion supposedly the portion of the roadbed between
the curved water pipe and the switch? You see that?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Assuming that there was a distance of two feet between the
top of the rail and the bottom of the ground as shown in this pie-
ture—and I also invite your inspection of a picture marked Ex-
hibit P-2-K, which seems to be lighter in tone, and ask you to look
at the portion, seemingly a portion of roadbed between a curved
water pipe and the switch, and also telling you in addition that, as
suming it to be a fact, that is two feet between the top of the rail
and the foot of the roadbed there—-the ground—what would vou say
as to that roadbed two feet below the ground being in good or bad
— with reference to persons getting on and off trains at that
point
Mr. Hartpence: I object on the ground that it is incompetent,
>OPOPrO
co
To)
———
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 67
irrelevant and immaterial, and this witness has not been
1) qualified to express an expert opinion on that plan, and that
there has been no basis for the relative comparison as fixed
stween this and the conditions this witness has become familiar with
n other roads.
Mr. Simpson: I invite your Honor’s attention to the case of Buck-
ut, in 31 Vroom, which lays down the rule for qualification of an
xpert. I have shown that this man is familiar with conditions of
yadbed, and he has worked as a brakeman for three years and he
nows what those conditions were, and certainly then he is qualified
) state whether this is a good or bad roadbed.
The Court: By comparison with other standards?
Mr. Hartpence: Yes.
The Court: I understood from Mr. Hartpence’s objection that that
‘as one of the objections that he was urging.
Mr. Simpson: I have not asked him about standards, I asked
im for an opinion as a man familiar with general roadbeds, as a
rakeman for three years, whether this is a good or bad roadbed.
The Court: What is the measure, Mr. Simpson? Isn't it by that
‘hich is a.standard?
Mr. Simpson: What he knows in his experience. If your Honor
hinks I should prove the roadbeds w-ere he has worked, | will with-
raw that question and ask him this one.
The Court: You should do that, aside from the question of the
bjection as to whether or not he has been properly qualified. I will
ot pass on that for the present. I think the objection is good, in
hat it ought to be shown what the standard conditions are in those
yards where he has had experience.
01 Q. In these yards where you have had your experience
what is the condition as to whether the roadbed is level with
he ties or not at points near switches and at points where it is cus-
omary to get on and off trains?
Mr. Hartpence: I object on the ground that it is incompetent, ir-
elevant and immaterial, unless it is shown that those conditions are
imilar to the conditions in the Granton yard, which would require
ills and embankments—otherwise the yards that this man has been
n may be strictly simply level yards.
Mr, Simpson: I do not think so, because there is no proof that
here is any fills or anything else required. There is no proof in
his case of anything except that this was a railroad track and a
witching yard. There is no proof that fills were required. I can-
1ot show by this man’s experience in the Granton yard.
The Court: True, but there is proof, as T would call it, that this
rack was upon a fill.
(Question repeated.)
The Court: I will overrule the objection to that.
Q. What is vour answer?
A. Every yard I have worked in—I have worked in a filled yard
n Greenville—that is a fill in the yard at the Greenville work,
68 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R, CO. VS.
and I have worked in the Cove and I have worked in the Communi-
paw, and I have always found you always get on and off trains,
going at an average of ten and twelve miles an hour, and when you
get on again without the trouble——
The Court: That does not answer the question. Strike it out.
102 (Question repeated, )
Q. What is the condition of the yards where you have worked—
you say filled in, and yards that were not filled in—with reference
to the dirt being level with the ties?
A. Always found them pretty near the same.
Q. Pretty near level?
A. Pretty near level.
Q. Have you ever found any of these yards where you have
worked, filled in or otherwise, the ground two feet, from measure-
ment, from the top of the rail down to the ground?
A. No, sir,
Mr. Hartpence: I object to it as incompetent and immaterial,
The Court: What is the specific reason?
Mr, Hartpence: It is merely calling on this witness to state
whether or not he has found certain conditions in certain yards, As
to whether these certain yards required the condition that may have
been required in the Granton yard, does not yet appear.
Mr. Simpson: That is for cross examination. It seems to me T am
éntitled to prove the general custom.
The Court: I will overrule the objection,
(Answer repeated. )
Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
What has been your particular business, Mr. Clifford?
Brakeman.
Did you ever build a railroad track?
No, sir; I never did.
Ever construct a right of way of a railroad?
No, sir.
Repair one?
No, but IT have——
Have you ever repaired one?
No, sir.
_ Never had anything to do at all with the constructing or
building of a road?
A. No, sir; T was a brakeman.
Q. In what yards did you work?
A. Greenville, on the Pennsylvania—worked in the Cove
103 in the Pennsylvania Railroad, and worked in Communipaw
here for the Central Railroad,
Q. Ts it a fact that in none of these yards you find a track that
1s elevated more than two feet above the level of the ground?
A. No, sir: I never have. All vards are the same.
Q. All yards are the same?
O>OPOrOrore
— Er nee
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 69
A. Yes, but I don’t know about the road work, I have never
done any road work.
Q. The tracks are all level in those yards?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. There is no necessity for the tracks to be elevated above the
ground?
A. No, sir.
Grorcke F, Hrx.arp, sworn.
Direct-examination by Mr, Simpson:
Q. Mr. Hilliard, what is your business?
A. Brakeman.
Q. How long have vou been a brakeman”
A. Three years, and two years throwing switches.
Q. Where have you worked as a brakeman”
A. Pennsylvania Railroad.
Q. Any other vard here beside the Pennsylvania?
A. Meadow yard.
Q. What is the Meadow, Pennsylvania?
A. That is the Pennsylvania.
Q. Any other vard?
A. And the Cove and in the Jersey City vard.
Q. In those yards what did you do, what was your work in those
vards?
A. Worked around the cars, braking and switching.
Q. Were those vards used for switching and braking?
A. For switehing and braking.
104 Q. In that work was it necessary for you to get on cars
in motion and get off cars in motion?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In those vards at the time that vou worked there what was
the condition of the roadbed in the vards with reference to the rail?
Was it even with the ties or was it down two feet lower than the
ties?
A. Even with the ties——
Mr. Hartpence: IT object to it as incompetent and irrelevant.
The Court: IT will overrule the objection.
A. About even with the ties.
Q. Have you ever found in any of those yards where they used
the yards for switching cars and braking work, that the ground
was two feet lower alongside the ties than the rail?
A. No, sir.
Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
Q. Where did you work, Mr, Hilliard?
A. Pennsylvania Meadow yard, and Cove and Jersey City freight
vards,
Q. Those vards are all level yards?
A. All level vards.
70
Zorererere
NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
No necessity to have fills?
. No; well, _ meadows yard is filled.
What say?
The meadows is filled in.
But where the tracks are it is all level?
. All level with the ties,
Many tracks there?
No,
How many tracks do you suppose there are across the Meadows
yard?
A.
A.
How many tracks in the yard?
. Yes,
Why, there is twenty-four in one yard—there is two or three
sections of the yard.
4
Side by side?
. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Simpson:
. That is a filled in vard?
Yes, sir.
By Mr. Hartpence:
The whole yard is filled in?
. Yes, sir.
From side to side?
. Yes, sir,
FREDERICK OR, sworn.
pororo>forororororere
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson:
What is your business, Mr. Ohr?
Hostler.
Where are you employed?
New York Central at Granton,
Were you a hostler on the 28rd of June, 1912?
Yes, sir.
How long have you been a hostler?
A. From eight to ten years.
. What was your duty as a hostler; what did you do?
Handle engines.
Took them out of the roundhouse?
Yes, sir.
- Took them out to wait in the yard for the regular engineer t
‘them?
Yes, sir.
Now, on the day of the accident did you have this engine 3791'
Yes, sir.
Where were you going with it?
To the storehouse after a barrel of oil.
Did you get the barrel of oil?
Yes, sir.
—V7"—~“”" pu Faw
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC.
Where was that barrel of oil to go?
. Ravina,
New York?
New York.
What kind of oil was it?
I don’t know.
Did you see it at all?
What the barrel?
Yes, the oil.
I saw the barrel.
. Not the oil?
No.
Was there any mark on the barrel as to what kind of oil there
DPOPOrOPOorere
A. I presume there was. I did not see it.
Q. You did not look at it? Now what did you do with the
106 engine after you got the oil on it up at the storehouse ?
A. Took it back to the roundhouse.
Q. And left it in the yard?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you see it taken away by Mr. Gayman ?
A. I did not see it go away; no, sir,
Q. But you left it for him to take away, didn’t you?
A. Yes.
Q. Was there steam up when vou left it?
A. Yes.
Q. How much steam was up on it?
A. About 180.
. 180 pounds? Well, assuming that that engine was a dead
engine, the fire was out when you got hold of it, how long would it
take to get steam up?
Mr. Hartpence: I object on the ground that it calls for an expert
opinion of this witness.
Q. You have worked upon engines, haven’t you, a long time as a
hostler ?
A. Yes.
Q. You have seen them fired, haven’t you?
A. Yes.
Q. And seen a man start fires and seen the steam get up?
A. Yes,
Q. How long would it take to produce steam in an engine, assum-
ing that the engine was a dead engine when you got hold of it?
Mr. Hartpence: Obiected to unless it is further shown that the
engine- this man has had experience with are engines of a similar
type of construction.
Q. Have you had experience with engines of a similar type to
3791?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How much experience?
72 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R, CO. VS.
A. Oh, from eight to ten years.
107 Q. How long would it take to get up steam if the engine
was dead cold when you got hold of it, no fire in it?
A. Well, it takes different times.
Q. Well, this engine 3791, suppose that the water was cold and
the fire was out and you had to light the fire and make steam, how
long would it take—180 pounds?
Mr. Hartpence: Objected to as incompetent, irrelevant and im
material, and that there is no proof in this case to show this en
gine was dead cold at the time the steam was gotten up.
The Court: I sustain the objection.
Q. When you left the engine she was up to one hundred anc
eighty pounds, was she?
A. Yes.
Q. Was there a fire under her when you left her?
A. Yes.
Q. What is it necessary to do to raise the steam from eighty t
one hundred and eighty pounds? What was necessary to be done
A. Why, blower and hook—hook the fire up a little bit, shovel |
little bit of coal in and keep the doors shut.
Q. If that was not done it would stay at eighty pounds or g
lower, would it?
A. Well, it might and it might not.
Q. Well, when you say getting up steam, what do you have to d
to increase the steam? Just what you have described, hook th
fire, put the blower on and shut the door, is that what you have t
do?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Up to what point could vou get steam on that engine?
A. Why, you get up to two hundred pounds.
Q. Would one hundred and eighty pounds be sufficient for he
pulling out this Continental Limited?
A. Why, yes.
Q. What amount would be sufficient—up to what amount
108 A. From about one hundred and fifty to two hundred.
Q. She could not run under that?
A. She might.
Q. Could she run with one hundred and twenty pounds?
A. Yes, after they get going.
Q. If she did not get going, I mean to go down and get her trait
is it necessary to have one hundred and fifty pounds?
A. T don’t know.
Q. You don’t know?
A. No; T have not had the experience.
Q. What?
A. T never had the experience.
Q. But you know she had to have steam up, don’t you?
A. Why, yes.
Q. And if the fire was not hooked up and new coal put on ar
blower, and the fire went out, the steam would go down, would i
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 73
A. It would if the fire burned out, yes.
Q. If the fire did not get new coal it would burn out, wouldn’t it?
A. It would, yes.
Q. And the place that you left her was the regular place for the
engineer to take her, wasn’t it?
A. Yes.
Q. Where was this barrel of oil put on your engine?
A. On the back of the tank.
(No cross-examination. )
JamMEs TONSELLITO, sworn.
Direct examination by Mr. Simpson:
Q. You are the father of Michael Tonsellito?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How old are you?
A. Fifty-three.
Q. How old is the boy?
A. Nineteen.
Q. When was he nineteen?
A. Will be this month.
109 Q. What?
A. He will be this month.
Q. He will be this month nineteen ?
A. Yes.
Q. Then he is not nineteen years?
A. No, sir.
Q. He is not nineteen yet?
A. Well, he will be on the 17th of this month.
Q. Of October?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Nineteen years old?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Since he has been hurt has he been living with you?
A. Yes.
Q. Has he been working since he was hurt?
A. Why, didn’t do work—he can’t do nothing, except the au-
tomobile—once in a while he get a dollar or maybe two dollars—
very little he gets—the rest I have to support himself,
Mr. Hartpence: I object.
The Court: I don’t hear what he says.
(Answer repeated. )
A. I have to support himself; he can’t do nothing.
The Court: That part, I suppose, is not strictly responsive.
Mr. Hartpence: No, sir.
Mr. Simpson: That is my objection.
Mr. Hartpence: It is his objection, but at the same time it strikes
me 2g hardly testimony that could be allowed to remain on the
reco:
74 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R, co. VS.
The Court: It is not of enough importance.
Mr. Simpson: No, it is not of enough importance.
Q. What did he earn at the time he was hurt? How muich did
he earn when he was hurt?
A. How imuch he was get-?
Q. Yes?
A. Why, they get—first start he got
By the Court: No; at the time he was hurt how much
,
110 was he earning—at the time he was hurt?
A. At the time he was hurt about fifty-five—fifty and fifty
and fifty-five because he has a gang and he
The Court: I cannot understand that. The first answer seems to
be fifty to fifty-five a month.
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Simpson :
You say he earned fifty-five dollars a month or forty-five?
The first time he brought forty-five.
No, but when he was hurt?
_ At the time he got hurt fifty and fifty-five he drawed.
You know this Granton yard?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know this switch where you say he was hurt which is
on the track to the storehouse? You know that switch don’t you?
A. Yes.
Q. You know the ground around that switch, in back of that
switch, don’t you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Are there any other switches in this yard besides this switch?
A. Why, ves, you got a lot of switch- in the yard. i
Q. That is all I asked you. Are there any other switches in the
yard?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have you seen these other switches?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Before the day he was hurt?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were you working there on the day he was hurt in the yard?
A. Well, T was working in the-morning: the time he got hurt I
was not there.
Q. What was the condition of these other switches, compared with
this switch near which he was hurt, with reference to the ground?
Were all the other switches above the ground or was the
111 ground level with the switches, or what was the condition?
erere
(Objected to as incompetent, irrelevant and immaterial, unless
it is shown that conditions were similar where the other switche
were as existed at the place of this switch.
The court sustained the objection. )
es FC Sa ETA RE cht RAO
MICHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 75
Q. You knew the other switches in the yard, didn’t you, the
vitches on other tracks?
A. I know the switch in that yard.
Q. How many switches are there in the Granton yard?
A. On that track there is—
Q. Not on this track. I mean the whole yard?
A. Well, I cannot count so many switch-; T could only count
here it goes to the storehouse track for the shop—go to the store-
ouse track—that is all I can count.
There are more switches on this track?
Yes, sir.
Two other switches on this same track, aren’t there?
There was more switch- for the shop, go to the storehouse.
Take the switches on this track, there were four switches?
. Four switches.
. Take the other three, not this one where he was hurt, but
he other three, how were they with reference to the ground along-
ide of the track? Was the ground level or was it not level on the
ther three switches on the same track?
A, Two switch- by the shop, one the same as the shop, and the
ther by the shop is level and to where they got hurt is a Jittle dif-
rent. little ways from the other, that is way down—it is two feet
eep there.
Q. That is the only switch on this track where there is a fill of
vo feet?
A. There is two switch- there.
12 Q. Is this the only switch on this track where he was hurt
where there is a fill of two feet?
A. Why, the one above and one above—two switch- there. Come
ere. (Indicates photograph.) Here is switch over here and here.
mean as between here, this all low.
You say this switch here, this water pipe?
. That is water pipe.
Where is the switch?
. Air pipe.
. Well, is there a switch here?
. Why there is—no, the switches is over here—see—it goes over
All this line in there——
. I understand it is all slag. What T understand is, this, there
re other switches on this track?
A. Yes.
Q. How many more besides this one?
A. Well, there is four altogether.
Q. Well, where are the four, down this way?
A, Well, they started at the shop. Where they start, the shop
lace, T can’t say—that is the shop—that goes to the storehouse.
Q. Yes; that goes to the storehouse?
_A. Now, there should be another switch here, and that is air
ipe, and here is very deep, two feet deep between here, is about
wo feet deep, and betweeen here that slag, come this switch and
PEOrore
23 >Qroro
76 NEW YORK CENTRAL & HUDSON RIVER R. R. CO. VS.
then comes level to go to the power house, another track goes to the
storehouse.
Q. Is it level up there?
A. This one going to the power house is high, because they have
got slag
Q. Is it level?
A. Oh, they ‘are level.
Q. How about this here, is it level down here?
A. Yes, below there, be level there.
Q. Then this is the only place here where there is two feet of
hole?
A. That two feet hole there.
113 Cross-examination by Mr. Hartpence:
Q. Right there where that two feet hole is, Mr. Tonsellito, is
where the air pipe curves around, isn’t it?
A. Yes.
Q. And then there is a big stick under the air pipe, isn’t there,
down in the ground, to hold it up, right there?
A. I don’t take notice of the stick. I know the pipe because I was
there at the time they put it up.
Q. On Exhibit P-1, this is the air pipe curving around there?
A. Yes.
Q. That rests on that stick down there in the ground?
A. I never took notice about the stick, whether it is a stick or on
top of the tie, [ would not say.
Q. And along on this storehouse track where you say it is two
feet down to the ground?
A. Right here.
Q. Right at that point?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. There by the air crook?
A. By the air pipe, yes, and then comes deep and then come
level up here, and this goes to the power house and this goes to the
storehouse—this level with the storehouse, right level, and this i
the power house that goes.
Q. And then level there, too?
A, Level both sides, only the track goes slanting to go to the power
house.
Q. And it is filled in there?
A. Yes.
Q. In order to get up to the power house?
A. Yes.
Q. And it slants or slopes down gradually, down to the machin
shop; is that right?
A. No; the machine shop it goes as far as here, and then thi
hole between here and here.
Q. When it goes beyond that aad on down to the machine shop
A. Below here it gets level again.
114 —. It gets less and less?
A. Level and level, to go to the machine shop.
——
MIVHAEL TONSELLITO, ETC. 77
Q. Right up here by this switch marked two X’s on exhibit P-1,
there it is level again?
A. Well, it start- getting level from here and then level and
level as far as here and then goes to the machine shop.
Q. Where were you, Mr. Tonsellito, when Michael was injured?
A. Well, i was at home. I left at twelve o’clock. I was working
half a day on Sunday. I went over to work four o’clock in the
morning and do my work—lI was cleaning office there, and after
I done my work, why, then I go home the rest of the day, after-
noon.
Q. Twelve o’clock was the end of the day?
A. Twelve o’clock I left.
Q. How many hours did you work a day there?
A. Well, I was work four o'clock in the morning until twelve,
Q. Michael went to work at what time?
A. Why, forir o’clock he come down with me.
Q. And he was through at twelve?
A. No, he was not through. He got to work all day himself, be-
cause he was working on two jobs?
Q. How late did he work that day?
Mr. Simpson: TI object to it as not cross examination. and in-
competent, because this witness had no knowledge of how long his
son had worked, and I object on the ground it is not proper cross ex-
amination, and second, there is nothing in this witness’s testimony
that indicates he knows anything about it.
The Court: I do n
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.