Transcript of Record — St. Louis & San Francisco R. Co. v. Brown
Supreme Court brief1916
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(24,705)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 1915.
No. 453.
THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY,
PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,
v8.
JAMES R. GAINEY, Jr., ADMINISTRATOR DE BONIS NON
OF THE ESTATE OF RICHARD DWYER, DECEASED.
IN ERROR TO THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF
KENTUCKY.
INDEX.
Original. Print
NL iss Bi Wd 6 6p kd Cee wR KS EMTS AE AVES ROD bike ¥ Oa 6 300 84 e% bs 1 1
Transcript of record from the Boyd circuit court.............. 2 1
a SS err erty aie rere Se ee ee eee ee ee ee ee 2 l
EE SONENOUE dss by elie © creo a Sw oes bak hae Aiea aw hia mere 2 1
Answer of defendant and order noting same............... 6 3
Reply of plaintiff and order noting same.................. 10 6
Order of March 13, 1913, noting commencement of trial and
AR ee ee ek Cet ee Pen eee 12 7
Judgment of the Boyd circuit court................2.0004. 12 7
Order of March 21, 1913, noting motion and grounds for
ENON cick wicks cewieeneieebertiveskse.ctaus aval tons 13 8
Order overruling motion and grounds for new trial........ 14 8
Granting appeal to court of appeals............6.....0e eee 14 &
Extending time for filing bill of exceptions................ 14 8
Motion and grounds for new trial.........ccccccccccscene 14 8
ey ae Ele OF GECIIONG i scoot kev we ved ease esceses 15 9
Judgment of court of appeals (first appeal) ............... 15 9
Opinion of court of appeals (first appeal). ............00e 17 10
Mandate of court of appeals (first appeal)................ 28 15
Amended petition of plaintiff and order for filing of same.. 29 15
Jupp & DeTweEILer (INC.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., Fesruary 10, 1916,
" INDEX.
Order of June 24, 1914, noting filing of mandate of court of
PO eEe hry ery ae ek he Ue ERT TE eee Pee
Order of June 24, 1914, traversing the plaintiff's amended
RROD 6 ask CREO Owe Cee Sy EA Cet ok wa Ohm ea rhea Kee ts
Order of June 24, 1914, noting commencement of trial and
ANE CG FI 60556 pon ob on Nw mere aca) sime sesso Cb .
Order and judgment of June 25, 1914.................0.4.
Order of June 26, 1915, noting motion and grounds for new
trial, and said motion and grounds for new trial.........
Order of July 3, 1914, overruling motion and grounds for
new trial and granting appeal to court of appeals........
Order of July 3, 1914, extending time for filing bill of ex-
re EEE eT OAT Ce TN ee oT eT ee CTO Tee
Order of September 11, 1914, extending time for filing bill
LE CITE shoe c eRe Reba AER AS CAG FON BT RA de RR RETR
Order filing and approving bill of exceptions..............
ENUEESANEs ROI hog oa tel nian tp Wak Va olens riclh@ ween se ues
SENSI Ce ED EME NNE. oc 5c Sv nce'e oinceew eden ese ds'eie
PE SAME os cocci bec eue eneeeked
CME wicks iF cua Waleb be eB aw see
CU RMI a ecb ehh hase g nea eae
MP MNS coheed KVeKened eo kon casvenye’s
SE INN Ga tre oF Opies a ks Gadde d.0 Slane
er OIE i os p nce ese be oe eae ncee
Dy Pee eee rie Tee ee
CO TU OEEE fa slic sed eoKeNs og kbmenews
MINOR MEETING! open 6 vo 00 6d che eee e HES
Sa ee oe rr ery re
CO REE eer TE TT RTE E RYT Cee ECT
WI GN AMA CeISAR ORE TRER DEAS OURE PED ESR EDOMENS
6 ORE ENA OTe eR TEER TE CT TE TTT ETT
Motion and grounds for new trial...............6.4..
INE 55 eis es ev aiee eer eee cds ws Sek Pvernctasenssennsee nes
CMO i cacine cecee 0s che bein evesewdeer eh seea vues deed eee
PORE IRee EE PON oy wick 8% ob balenehi sss chee cree eb ern wcels
Order overruling petition for rehearing..............ee eee wees
MI one alo aita ch babetees cent had eed et edbtweeaenueene
GE COE WEG OE CO hb aN iieede ct eeeresecetovsecseies
CEE BUOWIDE WHIT OF GEEOR. 6.066 kee acss Seve ticdeviccessecse
ET ten dla ily ge wb d KN Boe Liniebe 64 CN Shi a'e sok ease’
MeaenmANE OF GEEOES : ooo ccc ke dei ese ce ce necedeceteesecense
Cam EE ON CN oid’ wg sak ewe ~ame.els wie bled pe b:08 oie ke-wikles
a gO eee eer ee ee ree eee eek ee
Preecine LOF TOCOTA.. oo st cscc ccc cnctcescceccecesecscovescs
Additional preecipe Tor TECOTA..... ccc cscs ncccccccscccvoseses
Briefe for Appellant... soc ccc ccccccccccccscesavcccccsvesocs
COM OURRIONOR tev cccacree cb cates aeetrcatedensedern rs cane
Statement of errors to be relied on and designation by plaintiff
in error of record to be printed, and proof of service of same..
Original. Print
seauonee Pea ment wee eee
saint NEE: Le EE OES MET OME Yost aesrey on CAE ACTOS NOK) Sayama ARENT
THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO, VS. JAMES R. GAINEY, JR. 1
1 COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY:
Pleas Before the Honorable the Court of Appeals of Kentucky, at the
Capitol, in the City of Frankfort, on the 29th Day of January,
A. D. 1915,
CHESAPEAKE & Onto Raitway Company, Appellant,
vs.
Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of the Estate of Richard Dwyer, De-
ceased, Appellee.
Appeal from the Boyd Circuit Court.
Be it remembered that heretofore on the 21st day of August,
1913, and on the 12th day of December, 1914, the appellant, the
Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company, by its counsel filed in the
Clerk’s office of the Court of Appeals of Kentucky transcripts of
record on appeals in the above styled case, which transcripts contain
the following Pleadings, Orders, Bill of Exceptions, ete., ordered
to be copied for the Supreme Court of the United States by the pre-
cipe filed by the appellant and plaintiff in error-in said case, to-
wit:
2 Pleas Before the Hon. W. C, Halbert, Judge of the Twentieth
Judicial District of Kentucky and Sole Judge of the Boyd
Cireuit Court, at the Court House, at Catiettsburg, on the 20th
day of March, 1913.
Be it remembered that on the 21st day of February, 1911, the
plaintiff, Sarah Dwyer, Administratrix of the estate of Richard
Dwyer, deceased, produced and filed in the Clerk’s oflice of the Boyd
Circuit Court, her original petition, against the Chesapeake & Ohio
Railway Company, Defendants, and upon the back of which petition
appears the following endorsement:
“Filed February 21st, 1911. Summons and copy issued.
PAUL POAGE, Clerk.
By S:M. WYLIE, D. €.
Said petition is in words and figures following, to-wit:
Sarau Dwyer, Administratrix of the Estate of Richard Dwyer,
Deceased, Plaintiff,
vs.
CuesareaKE & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant,
Petition.
The plaintiff, Sarah Dwyer, says that Richard Dwyer departed
this life intestate on the 12th day of May, 1910, while a resident
1—453
SEG
“——
2 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO, VS.
of and domiciled in Boyd County, Kentucky; and, that on the 8th
day of June, 1910, she was by the Boyd County Court duly appointed
administratrix of the estate of Richard Dwyer, gave bond and quali-
fied according to law, and is now acting as such, and that said
decedent left surviving him who were dependent upon him
3 for their support and maintenance a widow and children,
That the defendant, The Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Com-
pany, is a corporation created and organized under the laws of the
State of Virginia, with power to sue, be sued, contract and be con-
tracted with as a natural person, and with the power to run and
operate a line of railway from and through the States of Virginia,
West Virginia, to and through the State of Kentucky, and was and
is a common carrier of both passenger- and freight, and was at the
time of the wrongs and injuries hereinafter complained of engaged
in carrying freight and passengers into and between the different
States and was at the said time engaged in interstate commerce.
She states that on said date, to-wit: the 12th day of May, 1910,
while her said decedent, Richard Dwyer was in the employment
of the defendant and working and laboring for it as an engineer
on one of its engines pulling with said engine its train of cars loaded
with freight and being hauled and carried by it from this State to
others and while he was engaged in interstate commerce for the
defendant hauling and pulling said train of cars as aforesaid from
Pikeville, Pike County, Kentucky, to and through Boyd County,
Kentucky, to other states he was by the gross negligence and care-
lessness of the defendant, its agents and servants in charge of said
train and engines, injured and killed.
She states that on the right of way of the defendant South of the
City limits of the City of Catlettsburg, in Boyd County, Kentucky,
where its said line of road runs and over which said decedent was
operating the engine with its train of cars, aforesaid, the defendant
in building its said line of road had made a deep cut about thirty:
(30) feet in depth, and in making said excavation and cut aforesaid
to build and lay its road and tracks thereon it left upon the side
of said cut and excavation about thirty (30) feet high above
4 the said tracks and road a large rock dangerously overhang-
ing the track. .
She says that on said night of the 12th day of May, 1910, the
said rock with a large lot of graval, dirt and earth and other rock,
in and near same, fell from said side of said excavation into the
tracks of the defendant, aforesaid, and that while he was operating
said engine, train and cars in the rear of an engine in front of his
aiding and assisting in pulling said train of cars, ran into and upon
said rock, earth and stone with said engine train and cars, aforesaid,
thereby causing same to turn over and fall upon him thereby in-
juring and killing him as aforesaid.
She further says that said defendant, its agents and servants in
charge of said road bed and tracks whose duty it was to look after,
repair and keep same in a safe condition knew that said rock was
hanging upon the side of said excavation in a dangerous condition
and likely at any time to fall down upon said right of way and
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 3
“acks, thereby endangering the lives of the employees operating en-
ines and trains over and upon said track, in time to have prevented
tid injury and death of said decedent, but negligently and carelessly
iled to use care to remove same from said place, and thereby caused
he death of said decedent, or by the exercise of ordinary care on
heir part could have known of same in time to have prevented the
njuries and death of said decedent, but negligently and carelessly
riled to do so, and that by reason of same caused the death of said
ecedent, aforesaid.
She says that in front of and attached to the engine which was
eing operated by her decedent on said occasion was another engine
ssisting in pulling the train of cars aforesaid, and which was being
operated by an engineer and fireman in the employment of
) the said defendant, and that the injuries and death of her said
decedent occurred in the night time about 11 0’clock p.m. on
aid date at a time when it was dark; and that the equipment of said
ngines were defective in equipment in this; that the defendant failed
o furnish and supply them with good and suflicient headlights so
s to enable the employees ‘hereon to see obstructions on the track in
ront thereof; that the lights furnished and supplied said engines by
aid defendant were insuflicient and defective and would not and
lid not furnish suflicient light to safely operate them on said occa-
ion, and that the defendant knew that said lights were insuflicient,
lefective and not suflicient to operate said train and cars in the night
ime safely, but that her decedent did not know of same, and that
aid defective and insuflicient lights contributed to and caused the
njuries and death of decedent aforesaid,
She says that by reason of all of which she has sustained damages
n the sum of Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000.00).
Wherefore, she prays judgment against the defendant for damages
n the sum of Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000.00) for costs and
ull proper relief,
DINKLE & PRICHARD,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
The plaintiff, Sarah Dwyer, says that the statements in the fore-
voing petition are true as she verily believes.
Subscribed and sworn to before me by Sarah Dwyer, this the —
day of ——, 1911.
My conimission expires on the — day of ——, —.
Notary Public in and for
Boyd County, Kentucky.
6 At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the
Court House in Catlettsburg, on the Sth day of March, 1918,
the following order was made:
THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Order Noting Answer.
Sarau Dwyer, Adm’x, etc., Plaintiff,
vs.
CHESAPEAKE & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant.
The defendant this day produced its answer herein, which is filed.
Said answer is as follows, to-wit:
‘Answer.
Saran Dwyer, Adm’x of Estate of Richard Dwyer, Deceased, Plain-
tiff,
vs.
THe CuHesareaAke & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant,
Comes the defendant and for answer to the petition of plaintiff
herein, it denies, that he was injured or killed by the gross or any
negligence or carelessness of this defendant, or its agents or servants
in charge of said train or engine. It denies that defendant, or its
agents or servants in charge of said train or said engine, were grossly
or at all negligent or careless, It denies that defendant’s line of
railway at the point where the accident described in the petition
occurred, is located in a cut 30 feet in depth, or that said cut is of
a greater depth than 10 feet. It denies that it left en the side of
said cut a large or any rock, or that same was dangerously or
7 at all ov erhanging the track. It denies that defendant, or its
agents or servants in charge of defendant's roadbed or track
knew in time to have prevented the injury to, or death of, decedent,
or at all, that said alleged rock was hanging on the side of said exca-
vation, or that same was in a dangerous condition or likely to fall
upon said right of way or tracks, or to thereby or at all endanger
the lives of defendant’s employ ees operating engines or trains over
or upon said track, or that defendant. or its said agents or servants
negligently, or carelessly, or at all, failed to use care to remove same
from said place, or by reason of said alleged failure caused the death
of decedent. It denies that it, or its said agents or servants, by the
exercise of ordinary or any care on their part, could have known
of the alleged presence of said rock in time to have prevented the
injuries to, or death of decedent. It denies that it, or its said agents
or servants negligently, or carelessly, or at all, failed to do so, or that
thé death of said decedent resulted from any negligence or care-
lessness on the part of this defendant, or its agents or servants. It
denies that said rock was hanging on the side of said excavation, or
that same was in a dangerous condition, or that same was liable at
any time, or at all, to fall down upon said right of way or tracks,
or that same endangered the lives of defendant’s employes operating
engines or trains over or upon said track. It denies that defendant
knew of said alleged condition or could, by the exercise of ordinary
PEEP EARN YO Sr enn cream acegirerrra 5 RSPR HENOMNSRIDS She ae PIECE |
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 5
care, have known same. Defendant denies that the equipment of
said engines hauling the trains described in the petition, or either of
them, were defective in their equipment. It denies that it failed to
furnish or supply good or sufficient headlights, It denies that
8 the lights furnished or supplied said engines were insuffi-
cient or defective or that same would not, or did not, furnish
sufficient light to safely operate same on the occasion of the accident
and injury complained of in the petition, It denies that it knew
that said lights were insufficient or defective, or that decedent did
not know of same, It denies that said alleged defective or insuffi-
cient lights contributed to or caused the injuries or death of the
decedent. It denies that plaintiff has been damaged in the sum of
$40,000.00 or any other sum. Wherefore &e.
Par. 2. Defendant further answering states that at the time and
on the occasion complained of in the petition, plaintiff’s decedent
was himself guilty of negligence which contributed to said accident
and injury, and but for such contributory negligence on his part,
said accident would not have happened nor the injuries have been
received, nor his death have occurred. Wherefore, defendant pleads
and relies on the above facts in bar of plaintiff’s right to recover in
this action.
Par. 3. Defendant further answering states that the plaintiff's
intestate was an employe of this defendant, and that in entering
and remaining in the service of this defendant, he assumed certain
risks and dangers incident to said service; that by his contract of
service with this defendant he assumed all the ordinary risks and
dangers incident to his said employment, among which was the risk
of injury set up in the petition. Defendant states that the danger
of injury resulting from the falling of dirt or rock upon defendant’s
track at the time and place of the accident described in the petition,
was a risk assumed by the plaintiff in entering the employment of
defendant as incident to his service and to the operation of railroad
trains; that the falling of said dirt or rock on defendant’s
9 track, and the resuiting derailment of the train or engine
upon which decedent was working, could not have been
avoided by the exercise of ordinary care or skill on the part of
defendant, or its agents or servants; that the said derailment of said
train was a risk assumed by the decedent as a part of the terms of his
employment; that decedent was acquainted with the fact of said cut
and with the danger, if any, of dirt or rock falling therefrom, that
the danger of accident and injury therefrom was open, obvious and
known to decedent before and at the time of his injury. Defendant
further states that the headlights upon the engines described in the
petition were such as he was entirely familiar with; that the alleged
defective or insuflicient condition of said headlights, if any, and the
danger of accident or injury therefrom, were open and obvious and
known to plaintiff before and at the time of his injury. Defendant
states that as and for a part of the terms of his employment, the dec-
edent assumed the risks of injury from the foregoing dangers, and it
pleads and relies on the facts herein set up as a bar to plaintiff's
right to recover damages herein,
SAY ie
6 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. YS.
Wherefore, having fully answered, defendant prays that it may
be hence dismissed, with its costs herein expended.
WORTHINGTON, COCHRAN & BROWNING,
Counsel for Defendant.
10 At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the
Court House in Catlettsburg, on the 18th day of March, 1913,
the following order was made:
Order Noting Reply.
Saran Dwyer, Adm’x, etc., Plaintiff,
vs.
CHesaPpEAKE & Onto Rat~way Company, Defendant.
The plaintiff this day produced her reply, herein which is filed.
Said reply is as follows, to-wit:
Reply.
Saran Dwyer, Adm’x of the Estate of Richard Dwyer, Deceased,
etc., Plaintiff,
vs.
CHESAPEAKE & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant.
Par. 1. The plaintiff, for reply herein, denies that at the time or
on the occasion complained of in the petition, plaintiff's decedent
was himself guilty of negligence, or that such negligence contributed
to said accident or injury, or that but for such contributory negli-
gence on his part said accident would not have happened nor the
injuries have been received, nor his death have occurred.
ll Par. 2. Plaintiff denies that in entering or remaining in
the service of defendant her intestate assumed certain risks or
dangers incident to said service, or that by his contract of ser-
vice with the defendant he assumed all or any of the ordinary
risks or dangers incident to the saie employment, or among which
was the risk of injury set up in the petition. Defendant denies that
the danger of injury resulting from the falling of dirt or rock upon
defendant’s track at the time or place of the accident described in
the petition was a risk assumed by plaintiff in entering the employ-
ment of defendant, or as incident to the service or to the operation
of railroad trains.
Plaintiff denies that the falling of said dirt or rock on defendant’s
track and the resulting derailment of the train or engine upon which
decedent was working could not have been avoided by the exercise
of ordinary care or skill on the part of the defendant, or its agents
or servants, or that the said derailment of said train was a risk as-
sumed by the decedent as a part of the terms of his employment, or
that decedent was acquainted with the fact of said cut, or with the
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 7
danger of dirt or rock falling therefrom, or that the danger of acci-
dent or injury therefrom was open or obvious, or known to decedent
before or at the time of his injury.
Plaintiff denies that the headlights upon engines described in the
petition were such as decedent was entirely, or at all, familiar with,
or that the defective or insuflicient condition of said headlights or
danger of accident or injury therefrom were open, or obvious, or
known to plaintiff before or at the time of his injury: Plaintiff
denies that as or for a part of the terms of his employment the de-
cedent assumed the risks of injury from the said dangers, or any of
them.
Wherefore, plaintiff prays as in her petition.
GEO. B. MARTIN,
DINKLE & PRICHARD,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
12 At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at
the Court House in Catlettsburg. on the 19th dav of March,
1913, the following order was made:
Trial.
Saran Dwyer, Adm’x Richard Dwyer, Plaintiff,
vs.
CHESAPEAKE & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant.
The parties this day appeared by their attorneys, thereupon came
a jury, to-wit: David Rucker, G. 8. T. Griffith, James Reynolds,
James B. Dixon, Milt Rice, Samuel Cyrus, Wm. Gray, John A,
Plaffenberger, Andy Scott, I. S. Collins, John P. Creighton, John
Fowler, who were duly sworn to try the issue, and having heard the
evidence in full, and being unable to complete the trial, were ad-
monished by the Court and adjourned until 9 o’clock tomorrow
morning.
At a Cireuit Court Began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, on the 20th day of March, 1913, ‘the following
order was made:
Judgment.
Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of Richard Dwyer, Deceased, Plaintiff,
vs.
CHESAPEAKE AND Onto RatLway Company. Defendant.
13 The jury sworn herein on yesterday, the 9th day of the
present term, this day reappeared in their seats, and having
received the instructions of the Court, and having heard the argu-
ment of counsel, retired to their room to consider of a verdict, and
later returned into the Court room with the following verdict, viz:
. “ " mee Meena deat ie sas oh jnsts)
heal het aie aN (3 AS PRE . 5 on AES,
§ THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
“We, the jury, agree and find for the plaintiff the sum of Fourteen
Thousand Dollars, $14,000.00.
(Signed) JNO. P. CREIGHTON,
One of the Jury.”
It is therefore adjudged by the Court, that the plaintiff, Sarah
Dwyer, Administratrix of the estate of Richard Dwyer, deceased,
recover of the defendant, The Cherapeake and Ohio Railway Com-
pany, the sum of Fourteen Thousand Dollars ($14,000.00) with
interest thereon at the rate of 6% per annum from the 20th day of
March, 1913, until paid and her costs herein duly expended.
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, on the 21st day of March, 1913, the follow-
ing order was made:
Order Noting Motion and Grounds for New Trial.
Saran Dwyer, Adm’x., ete., Plaintiff,
v.
CHESAPEAKE & Onto Raitbway Company, Defendant.
This day came the defendant and produced and filed its motion
and grounds for a new trial herein, and the Court being sufficiently
advised, it is ordered that the same be and it is hereby over-
14 ruled, to which the defendant excepts, and prays an appeal
to the Court of Appeals, which is granted accordingly; and
upon motion of the defendant it is given until and including the
tenth (10th) day of the next April Term of this Court within which
to prepare and tender its Bill of Exceptions herein.
Said Motion of Grounds for new trial are as follows, to-wit:
Motion and Grounds for New Trial.
Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of Richard Dwyer, Deceased,
Plaintiff,
vs.
CHESAPEAKE AND Onto Raitway Company, Defendant.
The defendant, Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company, moves
the Court to set aside the verdict and judgment herein and grant it
a new trial upon the following grounds to-wit:
Ist. The verdict is contrary to law.
2nd. The verdict is not supported by the evidence.
3rd. The amount of damages is excessive and so much as to indi-
cate that it was the result of passion and prejudice.
4th. The Court erred in admitting irrelevant and incompetent
testimony offered by plaintiff, which was objected to at the time
by plaintiff.
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 9
5th. The Court erred in refusing to admit competent and relevant
testimon offered by defendant.
6th. The Court erred in refusing to grant defendant’s motion
for peremptory instruction made at the conclusion of plaintiff’s
testimony.
15 ith. The Court erred in refusing to grant defendant's mo-
tion for a peremptory instruction made at the conclusion of
all testimony.
Sth. The Court erred in giving instructions marked 1, 3, 4 and 5.
To each of the errors complained of defendant excepted at the
time each was made.
WORTHINGTON, COCHRAN & BROWNING,
Attorneys for the Defendant.
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, on the 6th day of May, 1913, the following
order was made:
Order Filing Bill of Exceptions.
Saran Dwyer, Adm’x of the Estate of Richard Dwyer, Deceased,
Plaintiff,
vs.
CHESAPEAKE & Onto Rainway Company, Defendant.
This day came the defendant and produced and tendered its
Bill of Exceptions herein, and same having been examined and found
to be correct, it is now ordered that same be filed, and signed, sealed.
approved and made a part of the record herein, without being
spread at large upon the order book, all of which is accordingly
done.
16 Afterwards at a Court of Appeals held in and for the Com-
monwealth of Kentucky on February 25, 1914, the follow-
lowing orders and judgments were entered, to-wit:
Judgment of Court of Appeals.
CHESAPEAKE & Onto Ratway Company, Appellant,
*.
Ricuarp Dwyrr’s ApMINISTRATRIX, Appellee.
Appeal from the Boyd Circuit Court.
The court being sufficiently advised it seems to them the judg-
ment herein is erroneous.
It is therefore considered that said judgment be reversed and
cause remanded for a new trial consistent with the opinion here-
with. Which is ordered to be certified to said Court.
It is further considered that appellant recover of appellee its
costs herein expended.
2—453
10 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. v8.
At the same time, to-wit, February 25, 1914, the Court of Ap-
peals of Kentucky delivered the following opinion, to-wit:
17 Court of Appeals of Kentucky, February 23, 1914.
Cuesarpeake & Onto Rattway Company, Appellant,
v.
Ricuarp Dwyer’s ApMINISTRATRIX, Appellee.
Appeal from the Boyd Circuit Court.
Opinion of the Court by Judge Settle, Reversing.
Richard Dwyer, who was a locomotive engineer in the employ of
the appellant, Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co., was killed May 12,
1910, at England Hill in Boyd County, Kentucky. by the derail-
ment of a part of a train upon which he was at the time employed
as such engineer. The train was a freight train, being operated by
two engines, the second engine being the one of which the decedent
had charge.
At the place of the accident the railroad track is located in a cut
the banks of which arise in height several feet above that of a train.
The accident was caused by a land-slide from one side of the cut,
which caused rocks and earth to be deposited upon the track in such
quantities that when struck by the moving train the two engines
and several cars thereof were derailed and the decedent, being thrown
under the engine of which he was in charge, received injuries which
shortly thereafter resulted in his death. This action was brought
by the appellee, Sarah Dwyer, the widow of the decedent and
18 administratrix of his estate, to recover of appellant damages
for his death, the recovery being sought under the act of
Congress known as the “Employers’ Liability Act,” approved April
22, 1908, as amended by the act of April 5, 1910; the petition aver-
ring the facts necessary to bring the action within the. purview
thereof. There were three grounds of negligence alleged, first, neg-
ligence of appellant’s servants, other than the decedent, in charge
of the train, in the manner operating same; second, negligence of
the appellant in failing to equip the engines with sufficient head-
lights; third, negligence of the appellant and its servants in failing
to take the proper precautions to prevent the fall of debris upon the
railroad track at the place of the accident. We gather from the
record, however, that the third ground of negligence mentioned was
the only one relied upon for the recovery; and in support thereof
evidence was introduced by appellee which strongly conduced to
prove that the side of the cut from which the land-slide came had,
for some months prior to the accident, been in a more or less dan-
gerous condition because of the presence of overhanging rocks and
loose dirt, which gave notice to appellant of the danger to be appre-
hended from a land-slide and of the necessity of taking such pre-
cautions as, by the use of ordinary care could have been employed
to prevent the same, and which, if employed, would have prevented
Me oR et ee A Oren Se 1 oP a .
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. »
the accident and consequent death of the decedent. On the other
hand, in support of the denials of negligence contained in its an-
swer, appellant introduced considerable evidence to the effect. that
the side of the cut gave no indication of danger or of the probability
of a Jand-slide; and further, that the accident could not have
19 been anticipated or prevented by it.
The trial resulted in a verdict and judgment in appellee’s
favor for $14,000 damages. Appellant was refused a new trial, hence
this appeal.
It is not contended by appellant’s counsel that the verdict was not
authorized by the evidence, but it is insisted by them that the judg-
ment should be reversed because of error committed by the trial
court in instructing the jury as to the measure of damages. The
instruction on that subject is as follows: “The jury are instructed
that if they should find for the plaintiff, then they will from the
evidence find for her such a sum of money as they may find and
believe from the evidence will fairly and reasonably compensate the
estate of the decedent, Richard Dwyer, for the destruction of his
power to earn money, caused by his death, not exceeding, however,
the sum of $40,000, the amount claimed in the petition.” Counsel
concede that the instruction correctly states the measure of dam-
ages applicable to actions for death brought under section 6, Ky.
Statutes, but contend that it is not applicable to actions brought un-
der the Federal Statute, arguing thav the damages recoverable under
the latter statute are not such as will compensate the estate of the
deceased employee for the destruction of his power to earn money,
but such as will compensate’ his surviving relatives for the actual
pecuniary loss resulting by reason of his death to the par-
20 ticular person or persons for whose benefit the statutory right
of action is given. We are constrained to sustain this con-
tention, indeed, in effect, have heretofore done so in the case of
I. C. R. R. Co. vs. Doherty’s Adm’r, 153 Ky., 863, in which a re-
covery was refused the administrator of an employee of the railroad
company alleged to have been killed, while engaged in interstate
commerce, by the negligence of its servants in operating one of its
trains, because of the failure of the petition to allege, and of the evi-
dence to show, that the deceased emplovee left surviving him a bene-
ficiary or beneficiaries in whose behalf the recovery could be had.
In the opinion we said:
“It is clear that the act does not like the Kentucky statute appli-
cable to similar cases, allow a recovery merely to compensate the
estate of the decedent for his death and the consequent destruction
of his power to earn money, but provides that only those naturally
or actually dependent upon the decedent shall take the benefit. of
the recovery. It, therefore, expressly limits the right of recovery to
eases in which only the person or persons sustaining pecuniary loss
by the decedent's death are entitled to be compensated, viz; the
beneficiaries named, in the order named. This being so, it neces-
sarily follows that in an action under the act of Congress if there
is no one for whom a recovery can be had, there can be no recovery,
i Wi ea
12 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. vs.
Proof must, therefore, be made of the existence of such sur-
21 viving beneficiary or beneficiaries; and, if necessary to be
proved as an element essential to a recovery, it is an issuable
fact that must be alleged. So, if the petition in such an action fails to
allege that the decedent is survived by a person or persons coming
within the indicated limitation, it is bad on demurrer.”
This question seems to have been authoritatively settled by several
recent decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States, declar-
atory of the liability imposed by the act in question and the meas-
ure of recovery thereunder, and we will now consider some of these
eases, In Mich. Cent. R. R. Co. vs. Vreeland, 227 U. S., 59, (de-
cided January 29, 1913), a recovery was sought under the federal
statute for the widow of an employee who was killed by the railroad
company while engaged in interstate commerce. In the opinion it
is said:
“The obvious purpose of Congress was to save a right of action
to certain relatives dependent upon an employe wrongfully injured,
for the loss and damage resulting to them fi: ancially by reason of
the wrongful death. Thus, after declaring the liabilitv of the em-
ployer to the injured servant, it adds: ‘or in case of the death of
such employe, to his or her personal representative, for the benefit
of the surviving widow or husband and children of such employe;
and, if none, then of such employe’s parents; and, if none, then
of the next of kin dependent upon such employe, for such
22 injury or death,’ ete.” * * *
“This cause of action is independent of any cause of ac-
tion which the decedent had, and includes no damages which he
might have recovered for his injury if he had survived. It is one
beyond that which the decedent had—one proceeding upon alto-
gether different principles. It is a liability for the loss and damage
sustained by relatives dependent upon the decedent. It is therefore
a liability for the pecuniary damage resulting to them, and for that
a... ilies:
“The statute, in giving an action for the benefit of certain mem-
bers of the family of the decedent, is essentially identical with the
first act which ever provided for a cause of action arising out of the
death of a human being,—that of 9 and 10 Vict. chap. 93, known
as Lord Campbell’s Act. This act has been, in its distinguishing
features, re-enacted in many of the states, and both in the courts of
the states and of England, has been construed not as operating as a
continuance of any right of action which the injured person would
have had but for his death, but as a new or independent cause of
action for the purpose of compensating certain dependertt members
of the family for the deprivation pecuniarily resulting to them from
his wrongful death.” * * * “The word ‘pecuniary’ did not ap-
pear in Lord Campbell’s act, nor does it appear in our act of 1908.
But the former act and all those which follow it have been contin-
uously interpreted as providing only for compensation for pecuni-
ary loss or damage.”
23 “A pecuniary loss or damage must be one which can be
measured by some standard. It is a term employed judi-
, .
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 13
cially, not only to express the character of that loss to the beneficial
plaintiffs, which is the foundation of their right of recovery, but
also to discriminate between a material loss which is susceptible of a
pecuniary valuation, and that inestimable loss of the society and
companionship of the deceased relative upon which, in the nature
of things, it is not possible to set a pecuniary valuation. Patterson,
Railway Acci. Law, sec, 401.”
In the yet more recent case of G. C. & S. F. Ry. Co. vs. MeGin-
nis, 228 U.S. 173, which was an action for the death of an employe
caused by the negligence of the railroad company brought under
the Federal statute in a state court of Texas by his widow, as admin-
istratrix, for her benefit and that of their four children, one of the
latter being a married daughter residing with her husband; it was
held both by the trial court and the Court of Civil Appeals, that
the statute expressly authorized the suit to be brought by the per-
sonal representative for the benefit of the surviving wife and chil-
dren of the deceased, irrespective of whether they were dependent
upon him or had the right to expect any pecuniary assistance from
him. In passing on this ruling the Supreme Court of the United
States in the opinion delivered said:
“This construction of the character of the statutory liability im-
posed by the act of Congress was erroneous. In a series of
24 cases lately decided by this court, the act in this aspect has
been construed as intended only to compensate the surviving
relatives of such a deceased employee for the actual pecuniary loss
resulting to the particular person or persons for whose benefit an
action is given. The recovery must therefore be limited to compen-
sating those relatives for whose benefit the administrator sues as are
shown to have sustained some pecuniary loss. Michigan C. R. Co.
vs. Vreeland, 227 U. S. 59; American R. Co. vs. Didricksen, 227
U.S. 145. In the last cited case, speaking of the employers’ lia-
bility act, we said:
“*The cause of action which was created in behalf of the injured
employee did not survive his death, nor pass to his representatives.
But the act, in case of the death of such an employee from his
injury, creates a new and distinct right of action for the benefit
of the dependent relatives named in the statute. The damages
recoverable are limited to such loss as results to them because they
have been deprived of a reasonable expectation of pecuniary benefits
by the wrongful death of the injured employee. The damage is
limited strictly to the financial loss thus sustained.’ ”’
“The statutory action of an administrator is not for the equal
benefit of each of the surviving relatives for whose benefit the suit
is brought. Though the judgment may be for a gross amount,
25 the interest of each beneficiary must be measured by his or
her individual pecuniary loss. That apportionment is for
the jury to return. This will, of course, exclude any recovery in
behalf of such as show no pecuniary loss.”
It is manifest from the authorities, supra, that the trial court
did not, by the instruction quoted in the opinion, correctly advise
the jury as to the measure of damages. Tle recovery should have
, MERE INE SHE AE IER ILRI Oe eRe tonne a
14 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. vs.
been confined by the instruction on the measure of damages, in the
event of a finding for the plaintiff, to such a sum in damages as
would reasonably compensate the widow and children of the decedent
for such pecuniary benefits as the evidence might show they had
a reasonable expectation of receiving from the decedent, if his death
had not been caused by the negligence of the defendant, if it was
so caused; and after thus finding for the plaintiff a sum sufficient
to compensate all the beneficiaries named, it should have been appor-
tioned by the jury among the beneficiaries, stating in their verdict
how much, if anything, they find for each of them: the damages
altogether not to exceed the amount claimed in the petition. It is
not apparent from the record before us, however, that the court
could have intelligently instructed the jury at all on the measure of
damages for the petition only alleges that “said decedent left sur-
viving him, who were dependent upon him for their support
26 and maintenace, a widow and children.” It is nowhere
stated in the petition how many children there were or the
age of any of them; and the evidence, strange to say, is wholly
silent on the subject of the children. We must take it for granted
that there were children, because the averment in the petition to
that effect is not denied by the appellant’s answer. So, in view of
the failure of the petition to state, and of the evidence to show, the
number of children and also their dependence upon the decedent,
while living, for maintenance, it would have been practically impos-
sible under the circumstances for the court to have guided the jury
by a proper instruction on the question of the damages to be
awarded.
Our attention has been called by the brief of appellee’s counsel
to the case of L. & N. R. R. Co. vs. Stewart’s Adm’x, 156 Ky, 550,
brought under the Federal statute, an expression in the opinion of
which apparently approves such an instruction on the measure of
damages as that complained of in the instant case. It is only
necessary to say that the inadvertent statement referred to, has been
corrected in response to a petition for a rehearing filed in the case,
and, that as modified by the response, the opinion does not conflict
with the conclusion expressed in this case. :
It is insisted for appellee that, as appellant did not on the
27 trial offer a correct instruction on the measure of damages,
it is estopped to ask a reversal of the judgment appealed
from because of the giving of the incorrect instruction by the trial
court on that subject. This contention must be overruled. It is
true that an instruction on the measure of damages was not offered
by appellant, but such failure did not relieve the trial court of the
duty of correctly instructing the jury on that subject. Having at-
tempted to give an instruction on that feature of the case, it was
the duty of the court to state it in correct form. Its failure to do so
was prejudicial to the rights of appellant, and, as it objected to the
instruction as given, it is not estopped to insist upon a reversal
of the judgment because of the error committed by the trial court in
iving the instruction. I. & E. Ry. Co. vs. Crawford, 155 Ky., 728;
South Cov. & C. St. Ry. Co. v. Core, 29 R. 836.
TF homed eh nas eee re Pe TT Te -
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 15
Because of the error of the trial court in failing to properly instruct
the jury on the measure of damages, the judgment is reversed and
cause remanded for a new trial consistent with the opinion.
Worthington, Cochran & Browning, Maysville, Ky., for Appellant.
Dinkle & Prichard, George B. Martin, Catlettsburg, Ky., for Ap-
pellee.
(Endorsed:) Feb. 25, 14. C. & O. vs. Dwyer’s Adm’r’x.
28 Afterwards on the 2nd day of April, 1914, the mandate
of the Court of Appeals of Kentucky issued on the foregoing
judgment in words and figures following, to-wit:
Tur CoMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY:
The Court of Appeals, February 25, 1914.
CuesapEAKE & Onto Raitway Company, Appellant,
against
Ricwarp Dwyer’s ADMINISTRATRIX, Appellee.
Appeal from a Judgment of the Boyd Cireuit Court.
The Court being sufficiently advised is seems to them the judg-
ment herein is erroneous.
It is therefore considered that said judgment be reversed and cause
remanded for a new trial consistent with the opinion herein.
Which is ordered to be certified to said Court,
ROBT. L. “GREEN, C. C. A.,
By A. ADDAMS, D.C.
29 Sarau Dwyer, Adm’x, &c., Plaintiff,
vs.
Tue CursapeaKe & Onto Raitway Company, Defendant,
The plaintiff this day produced her amended petition herein
which is filed.
Said amended petition is as follows:
Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of the Estate of Richard Dwyer, De-
ceased, Plaintiff,
vs.
Tue CuesarrAKke & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant,
Plaintiff, for amendment to her petition herein says that the aver-
ment in her original petition that decedent, Richard Dwyer, left
surviving him children dependent upon him for support and main-
tenance was a mistake and is hereby withdrawn.
Plaintiff says that the only child left surviving said decedent was
16 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
married at the time of his death and was not dependent upon him
for her maintenance and support. Plaintiff says that she, this plain-
tiff, is and was the sole dependent surviving beneficiary of the cause
of action herein set forth under the Federal Employers’ Lia-
30 bility act; that at and before the time of the decease of Rich-
ard Dwyer, she was his wife; was — years of age at the date
of his death, and was at said time and theretofore solely and en-
tirely dependent upon said decedent for her maintenance, livelihood
and support; that by reason of his death, she, as beneficiary, was
and is damaged and has suffered pecuniary loss in the sum of forty
thousand Dollars.
Wherefore, plaintiff prays for judgment as in her original pe-
tition.
DINKLE & PRICHARD anp
GEORGE B. MARTIN,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
At a Cireuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky, on the 24th. day of June, 1914,
the following order was made.
31 Saran Dwyer, Adm’r’x of Richard Dwyer, Deceased,
Plaintiff,
vs.
Tue CHESAPEAKE & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant.
The plaintiff this day produced in open Court the Mandate of
the Court of Appeals herein, which is filed and ordered to be rec-
orded, and is as follows:
Copied on page 28 of this record.
32 Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of Richard Dwyer, De-
ceased, Plaintiff,
vs.
Tue Cuesareake & Onto Rai~tway Company, Defendant,
By agreement of the parties hereto, it is ordered that the affirm-
ative allegations of plaintiff’s amended petition filed herein, be now
traversed of record,
At a Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky, on the 24th. day of June, 1914,
the following order was made.
SaraH Dwyer, Adm’r’x of Richard Dwyer, Deceased, Plaintiff,
vs.
Tue CuesapeaAke & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant.
The parties this day appeared by their attorneys, thereupon came
a jury to wit: Stephen Bryant, Lewis Rowe, William Caveron,
Joseph Stewart, Hugh Faulkner, A. T. Gilley, William Williams,
JAMES K. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 17
Almon Darby, J. L. Rucker, T. R. McGlothlin, E. V. White, J. M.
Standley, who were duly sworn to try the issue, and having
33 heard the testimony on behalf of the plaintiff, and being un-
able to complete the trial, were admonished by the Court and
adjourned until 9 o’clock tomorrow morning.
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky, on the 25th. day of June, 1914,
the following order was made.
Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of Richard Dwyer, Deceased,
Plaintiff,
vs.
CuesareAKe & Onto Raitway Company, Defendant.
The jury sworn herein on yesterday, the 15th. day of the present
term, this day reappeared in their seats in the jury tee and having
heard the testimony in full, and received the instructions of the
Court, and having heard the argument of counsel retired to their
room to consider of a verdict, and later returned into the Court room
with the following verdict, to-wit:
34 “We, the undersigned jurors agree and find for the plain-
tiff, in the sum of $16,000 sixteen thousand dollars.”
JOE STEWART,
S. H. BRYANT.
ALMON DARBY.
HUGH FAULKNER,
LOUIS ROWE,
J. L. RUCKER.
T. R. MeGLOTHLIN,
WILLIAM CAVERON,
A. T. GILLEY.
It is therefore adjudged by the Court that the plaintiff Sarah
Dwyer, Administratrix of Richard Dwyer, Deceased, recover of the
defendant, Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company, the sum of six-
teen thousand ($16,000.00) Dollars, with interest thereon, at the
rate of six per cent per annum, from the 25th day of June, 1914,
until paid, and her costs herein duly expended.
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky, on the 26th day of June, 1914,
the following order was made:
Saran Dwyer, Adm’r’x, &e., Plaintiff,
vs.
CrrsaPpeake & Onto Rainway Co., Defendant.
The defendant this day produced its motion and Grounds for a
new trial herein, which are filed and thereupon moved the Court
8—453
18 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
for a new trial of this cause, and this cause is submitted on said
motion,
35 Said motions & Grounds for a new trial herein are as
follows:
Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of the Estate of Richard Dwyer,
Deceased, Plaintiff,
vs.
Tue CHESAPEAKE & Onto Raitway Company, Defendant.
Comes the defendant, Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company and
moves the Court to set aside the verdict of the jury, in this case and
the judgment of the Court entered therein and to grant it a new trial
thereof, and assigns these its grounds in support of said motion:
First. Because the verdict is contrary to law.
Second. Because the verdict is opposed to the overwhelming
weight of evidence.
Third. Because the amount of the verdict is excessive and so ex-
cessive that same appears to have been given under the influence of
passion and prejudice.
Fourth. Because of error of the Court in excluding certain compe-
tent, relevant and material testimony offered by defendant, to which
action of the Court the defendant at the time and in each instance
objected and excepted.
Fifth. Because of error of the Court in admitting certain incom-
petent and irrelevant testimony offered by plaintiff, to which action
of the Court defendant at the time and in each instance objected and
excepted.
Sixth. Because of error of the Court in giving to the jury in-
structions numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6, and each of them,
36 and to the giving of each of said instructions the defendant
at the time and in each instance objected and excepted.
WORTHINGTON, COCHRAN & BROWNING,
Attorneys for Defendant.
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky, on the 3rd day of July, 1914, the
following order was made:
Saran Dwyer, Adm’r’x, Plaintiff,
vs.
CuESAPEAKE & Onto Raitway Co., Defendant.
The defendant this day called up their motion for a new trial
herein and the Court having considered of same and being sufli-
ciently advised adjudges that said motion be overruled to which the
defendants excepted and prayed an appeal to the Court of Appeals
which is granted.
spat SPE Be pep Rt ean pee i uy
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 19
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky, on the 3rd day of July 1914, the
following order was made:
37 Saran Dwyer, Adm’r’x, &e., Plaintiff,
vs.
CuesapeaKe & Onto Ry. Co., Defendant.
Upon motion of the defendants time is given it to and including
the 6th day of the next September term of this Court to tender and
file its bill of exceptions herein.
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky on the 11th day of September,
1914, the following order was made:
Saran Dwyer, Adm’r’x, &c., Plaintiff,
vs.
CHEesaAPEAKE & Onto Rattway Co., Defendant.
On motion of defendant it is ordered that time be extended and
that defendant be and is given until and including the 11th day of
the present term of this Court to file its bill of exceptions herein.
At a Circuit Court began and held for Boyd County, at the Court
House in Catlettsburg, Kentucky, on the 17th day of September,
1914, the following order was made:
38 Saran Dwyer, Adm’r’x, &e., Plaintiff,
vs.
Cnesapeake & Onto Ry. Co., Defendant.
The Defendant this day produced and tendered its bill of excep-
tions herein, duly signed, sealed, and approved by the court, which
is filed, and same is ordered to be and is hereby made a part of the
record of this cause without being spread at length upon the order
book.
Boyd Circuit Court.
Saran Dwyer, Administratrix of the Estate of Richard Dwyer,
Deceased, Plaintiff,
vs.
CresareaAkE & Onto Rattway Company, Defendant.
Be it remembered that on the 24th day of June, 1914, upon the
ealling of this cause for trial the same was submitted and trial thereof
had and upon the trial the following evidence, steps and proceed-
ings and objections thereto were taken and had as follows:
20 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
First the plaintiff, Saran Dwyrr—introduced as a witness in her
behalf, herself, who being first duly sworn, testified as follows,
to-wit:
Direct examination :
39 Q. 1. Your name is Sarah Dwyer?
A. Yes, sir.
2. Where do you live?
T live on Greenup, between 20th and 21st.
3. In Ashland, Kentucky?
Yes, sir.
4. How long have you lived there?
About seven or eight years.
5. Are you the Widow of Richard Dwyer?
Yes, sir.
6. When did he die?
Died May, 10th, 1912.
. 1912, was it?
Well, it has been four years——
8. 1910?
Yes, sir.
9. May 10th, 1910, is that the correct date?
Yes, sir.
10. Where was he killed?
At the place called England Hill.
11. Was his body brought to Ashland?
Yes, sir.
12. At what time of the day or night?
It was brought about 4 o’clock in the morning, the next morn-
13. Was he dead at the time he was brought to Ashland?
. Yes, sir.
14. At the time of his death, what was his occupation?
. He was an engineer.
. 15. For what company? -
A. Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company.
40 Q. 16. And where was his run-
A. Well, it was up Big Sandy, but I don’t know, from
Russell, I don’t think he had a steady run
Q. 17. His run was from Russell up the Big Sandy Division of
the Chesapeake & Ohio Railway?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 18. How long had he been running an engine at the time he
was killed?
A. Two years, about.
Q. 19. Prior to that what was his occupation?
A. He was a fireman.
Q. 20. In whose employment?
A. The same road.
Q. 21. At the time of his death what was he earning as an
engineer?
OPOPOP POP OPOPOPOPNEOPOPOPOPO
| aa
A. He made from $150.00 to $160.00 and $165.00 when he got
in extra time.
Q. 22. You mean he was earning that running as an engineer,
$150.00 for how much time? He made that much or more, how
about that?
A. He made $160.00 and $165.00 and he had made $170.00-
Q. 23. As much as $170.00 per month?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 24. At the time of his death did he own any property?
A.
Q.
JAMES R, GAINEY, JR., ETC. 21
Yes, sir, we was paying for a home.
25. Where?
A. Where TI am living now, between 20th and 21st. on
41 Greenup.
Q. 26. How much had you paid on it?
A, About six or seven hundred dollars, between six and seven
hundred dollars.
Q. 27. Did he own any other real estate at the time of his death?
A. No, sir.
Q. 28. Have any personal property other than his personal
effects?
A. No, sir.
Q. 29. Wearing apparel, and so forth?
A. No, sir.
Q. 30. Did you at the time of his death have any property in
your own right?
A. No, sir.
Q. 31. To what extent, if any, were you dependent upon him
and his earnings for your livelihood at the time he was killed?
A. Well, I depended on him all together. I didn’t have any thing
except what he made by his work, his wages.
Q. 32. What did he do with his wages?
A. He brought them to me.
Q. 33. Who kept up the expenses of the house-hold?
A. He always brought his money to me and T paid my bills.
Q. 34. Did he have any personal habits, by which he used any
part of his eagnings other than ordinary expenses?
A. No, sir.
Q. 35. What was his habits as to sobriety?
A. It was all right, he was a sober, good worker, and always pro-
vided well for me.
42 Q. 386. How many children did you have?
A. Two.
Q. 37. Had they been raised by Mr. Dwyer up to manhood and
womanhood ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 38. Were they schooled by Mr. Dwyer?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. 389. Were they married at the time of his death?
A. My daughter was.
Q. 40. Where was your son at the time of his death?
A. He was at home at the time his father was killed.
22
THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
41. Was he able to take care of himself?
Yes, sir.
He was not dependent upon your husband for his living?
0, sir.
= How old was Mr. Dwyer at the time of his death?
5.
44. What was the condition of his health?
Good,
45, Was he able to work regularly and steady?
Yes, sir.
46. About what was his weight?
About 148.
47. And what was your age at the time of his death?
I was 48,
48. Had you any means, or source of income or revenue, from
any source at the time of his death, other than his earnings?
43 A. No, sir.
Q. 49. Any one contribute to your support in any way
except your husband?
No, sir.
PPOPOPOPOrPOorere
Cross-examination :
Q. 1. You mean that your husband would turn all his wages
over to you?
A. Yes, sir, he generally had board to pay up Big Sandy and he
paid that and brought the rest to me.
Q. 2. Paid his board up — Big Sandy?
A. Yes, sir, he had to get meals when he was out.
Q. 3, He paid those expenses out of his salary?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 4. And he turned all the money he received over to you except
what he paid for board up — Big Sandy?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. Who constituted your family—how many in your family?
A. Three of us.
Q. 6. He turned over to you sufficient money to take care of the
expenses of the household?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. He did that up until the time of his death?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 8. Had he ever been sick?
A. No, sir, he never was sick that | can remember of. He was
hurt once in a wreck, never was sick.
Q. 9. When was that?
A. I don’t know how long ago it was.
Q. 10. Tell the circumstances?
A. I don’t know, the engine turned over and he was hurt,
Q. 11. That — after you were married?
A. Yes, sir.
44 Q. 12. Can you tell just what injuries he received?
A. Well, he was scalded—he was burned about as bad as he
could be.
: PELE NET OEE IG RETA Te POET LII MEL ROI POON OLE ELT NEI TOA LIEN EEL MOGI EOD) WE LIT ET: Pr,
3
| a!
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 93
Q. 13. Was he laid up for any considerable period of time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 14. Hew long?
A. Seven or eight months, maybe a little longer.
Q, 15. Do you remember—give us as near as you can when that
was?
A. No, sir, I don’t.
Q. 16. How long was he with the road?
A. I guess about seven years.
Q. 17. These injuries were received during that time while he
was on the road?
Yes, sir.
18. How long was he fireman?
He was fireman for about four years.
19. And he was engineer for about three years.
Yes, sir.
POPrOor
Redirect examination:
Q. 1. Had he recovered entirely from these injuries?
A. Yes, sir. Yes, he had been working a long time.
Q. 2. Any effect from these injuries after he went back to work?
A. No, sir.
The witness, Emma Compton, being first duly sworn, testified as
follows, to-wit:
Direct examination:
Q. 1. What is your name?
A. Emma Compton.
45 Q. 2. Where do you live?
A. Live at England Hill.
Q. 3. How long have you lived at England Hill?
A. About 11 years.
Q. 4. About how near to what is known as the England Hill
cut?
A. I live right there in the cut, 30 or 40 feet out from the cut from
the track. .
Q. 5. Which side of the track do you live on?
A. Left hand side, going up.
Q. 6. Between the railroad track and the river?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. At the time of the derailment of the train there, did you
see it?
A No, sir, we was all in bed when it happened.
Q. 8. About what time was it?
A. It was about half past one by our time.
Q. 9. What did they do with the man that was hurt there, Mr.
Dwyer?
A. They brought him in our house. ;
Q. 10. Did you go over and see where the train was derailed?
Bp ane ae, EY . , ' , . —— :
Bieperase ag ey ae <0 PORE RS
,
94 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
A. Never until the next-mornin’, could see the fire, but I never
went out on the track.
Q. 11. Did you see-Mr. Dwyer that night?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 12. ‘Where was he?
A. He was at my house.
Q. 13. How did he come?
A. They carried him.
Q. 14. You know who picked him up and carried him over
there?
A. Mr. Schump and Mr. Diamond and some railroad men, I
don’t know just who they were.
Q. 15. And he stayed there until he was taken away on
46 the train?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 16. Did you see the rock and dirt on the track?
A. Yes.
Q. 17. You were not out there at the wreck that night?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 18. What was the matter with him as he appeared, when
brought to your home?
A. Well, I don’t know exactly, how he was injured, had a
skinned place on his head and he had hemmorrphages from his
lungs, they laid him on the floor on a quilt and he just laid
there——
Q. 19. Did you pass up and down the railroad track through that
cut before this derailment occurred?
. Yes, sir.
. 20. Did the derailment occur above or below your house?
. It was just a little above.
21. A little above?
Yes, sir.
. 22. Did you notice the nature of the material in that cut?
Yes, sir.
23. What kind of a cut was it, a slippery cut or not?
A slippery cut, I always call them.
24. What did it have in it?
Small rocks and dirt, and it would be slipping in
25, Every know of the track along there being cleaned up——
. Yes, sir, often—the work hands would come along and dig
ut of the ditch
26. You had seen them dig out the ditch there?
Yes, sir.
17. Who was it did that?
. The section foreman and his hands.
18. Did you see that big rock before it fell?
All along, I can’t say just now when I saw these rocks in
the ditch, there was a few small ones——
rererekrersrercrerer
47 Q. 19. And the section men would remove it, the dirt and
rocks that fell?
A. Yes, sir
NR PON Ga BA OE EE EVI enc 9 se pe -
SILI ie sala PAP Fh nS rR, SAPS INS NPIS RRTEP A . = rage
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 25
Q. 20. Do you remember any thing about a rock and some dirt
slipping in there and on the track? Some time before this de-
railment?
A. Not to amount to any thing, only on Mr. George Arthur's
Section when he was section foreman, a rock fell on the railroad
track then.
21. Who removed that rock?
. Mr. Blankenship and my husband.
22. Who was Mr. Arthur working for at that time?
. He was the section foreman.
23. Where was it?
It was just below where this big one came in,
24. Where was it, on the railroad track?
Yes.
25. What did they do with it? Tiow did they remove it?
They broke it with a pick and took it off.
26. About how long before this derailment did that happen
. Compton?
A. Yes, this was in August, some time before, this, about a year
and six months before this.
Q. 27. Now what was it that caused that derailment there?
A. Why, there was a big rock sticking out that come down and
dirt and other rocks, they came out and that caused it.
Q. 28. Did you see the big rock on the track?
A. No, sir, I didn’t. Saw the man there next morning working.
I didn’t see it until after they had rolled it out on the bank.
Q. 29. Where did they leave it?
A. Left it right opposite to our house.
48 ~ Q. 30. Between the river and the railroad track?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 31. On the left hand side going up?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 32. And who was it that did that?
A. It was the wreck train of the railroad Company.
. 33. Now before you saw the rock and material being removed
that morning had you ever seen the track itself being cleaned of
dirt and rocks off of it, before this?
A. A good deal, yes.
Q. 34. Now you had seen where this rock hung in the cut before
this, hadn’t you?
A. Of course—I didn’t examine that rock—I could see it in
among the dirt and other stulf there ;
Q. 35. After the derailment did you notice the side of the cut
where the rock had been?
A. Yes, sir. ;
Q. 36. How long had it been there—is the rock in the cut there,
that you noticed that fell?
A. Yes, sir. ‘
Q. 37. How much had it changed, or moved since you had been
there?
4-453
OPOPOoPOoPOore
=
z
26 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
A. Of course,—I didn’t inspect that rock. I could see it there
in the cut as I would pass by.
Q. 38. How did it look, was it solid all through?
A. Why on the upper side of the rock there was a place broke
and open and dirt behind the rock
39. On which side?
. On the upper side.
40. About what size was the rock?
. About ten feet long and six feet wide.
41. What position was it laying in the cut? ’
It was laying so that it partly showed, say here was the rock
and part of it showed, I can’t tell exactly, it was laying in the
49 slope of the eut——
Q. 42. Could you tell that the rock was changing its posi-
tion any?
A. Yes, these rocks and dirt kept coming down.
Q. 43. Saw whether or not this rock looked like it was changing
its position, was moving—or sliding away from the cut?
A. It looked like it was gradually coming down, giving away—
could see it and it looked like it was.
Q. 44. How much of the length of the rock could you see before
it fell?
A. About five feet.
Q. 45. Then you saw about half way of the rock?
A. Yes, sir.
Cross-examination :
POreore
Q. 1. As I understand it you live between the track of the Chesa-
peake & Ohio Railway Company, and the Big Sandy Kiver?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 2. How far from the track?
A. About 30 feet.
Q. 3. Just across the England Cut?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 4. That is where the wreck occurred, wasn’t it, in that Eng-
land Hill cut?
. Yes, sir.
. 5. That is a rocky hill side?
. Yes, sir.
. 6. Rocky bluff?
. Yes, sir.
7. These rocks that are in that bluff, do they extend back
into the side of the hill—back into the hill?
A. Well, you can see them, you can’t tell just how far they
extend back inte the hill
8. How long do you think this rock was?
10 feet, that you could see.
9. Where did you see the rock?
I seen it right there by our house.
10. What size in your judgment was it?
Ten feet.
bret ERE Re o a Nest 052 , owe “ — - ee ony
O>PoOPop>
on
)
POPOPo
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 27
11. Ten feet long?
Yes, sir.
12. How wide?
About six feet.
13. How thick?
About two feet.
14. About two feet thick?
Yes, sir.
. 15. Now how much of that rock did you see, that was on the
side next to the rail?
. You could only see about that much of it,—(indicating)
. 16. Could you see the thickness of it?
A. Yes, sir.
17. Thickness on the side of the bluff?
. Yes, sir.
. 18. Did you see the thickness of the rock, length wise 10 feet,
or the short wise, 6 feet?
A. Why, you could only see a little bit of it until it came
down.
Q. 19. How much could you see?
A. I could see the depth of it, couldn't see it in length-——
Q. 20. As I understand it you saw the thickness of the rock
where it projected out of the side of the bluff and you say that
rock was two feet thick?
51 A. Of course I didn’t measure it then, I don’t know how
much it was.
Q. 21. Whether you measured it or not it was the face of the
thickness that you saw?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 22. And it extended back into the bluff how far?
A. I don’t know how far it extended—how far it went.
Q. 23. Did it go back into the bluff any?
A. Yes, sir. :
Q. 24. You could see the face of that rock—two feet of it, thick,
but you don’t know how far it extended back into the bluff?
I don’t know how thick it was before——
25. Underneath that rock was ledges of slate rock?
Yes, sir.
26. Solid almost from the ground?
They worked out gradually
. 27. Solid slate foundation from the bottom of the cut up
to where this rock laid?
A. I don’t know slate or not. Small rocks in the side of the
hill and they kept falling down in the ditch
Q. 28. And when they would fall down in the ditch the section
men would come along and clean the rocks and dirt out of the
ditch?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 29. You have seen them working there?
A. Sure, when I passed them.
bh
OPOPOrero
OPoOrop>
ep
.
.
A
Ore
28 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Q. 30. It is frequently the case in a cut of the character that
you — of this one being that rocks are known to fall?
es, Sir,
Q. 31. You say that some time before this rock fell another rock
had fallen there in that cut, when was that?
52 A. Yes, sir, it was in—I judge—It was when Mr. George
Arthur had charge of the section.
Q. 32. What time was that?
A. I don’t know only it was during the time when George Ar-
thur had charge of the section there.
se tt George Arthur preceded Barney Wells as section foreman
there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 34. Did you know that the rock extended back into the bluff
except that you know that it extended back to the bluff?
A. No, sir, I can’t say that it extended back into the cliff, it was
covered.
Q. 35. It was covered with dirt, and didn’t you notice it to be
that way?
A. I guess it was.
Q. 36. It looked like it was—back in the rocks—in the bluff, like
any other rock there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 37. Did you see the entire length of that large rock, or just
the width of it?
A. Yes, sir, saw the width of it, and of course you could see a
small portion of it.
Q. 38. Didn’t vou saw this rock was 10 feet long and six feet
wide, didn’t the rock extend this way (indicating) ten feet?
A. I don’t know.
Q. 39. Which way was it turned?
A. I don’t know, looked like it was kinda out at the other corner,
of course I couldn’t tell how far it went back into the hill.
Q. 40. You never noticed the crack that you have mentioned
until after the rock had fallen out?
A. Yes, sir. Why, yes, sir. The crack was there some time
53 before the rock fell, on the upper side.
Q. 41. You testified in this case before, didn’t you?
A. Yes.
Q. 42. At that time wasn’t you asked on eross-examination about
that crack in the hill, this question: 55. Now that crack was in
bluff, the side of the bluff there?” and did you not make this an-
swer: “A. Yes, sir.” “Q. 56. And up at the place where this big
rock and dirt fell? A. Yes, sir.”
A. You mean after the rock fell?
Q. 43. Yes.
A. Well, there was a crack there, of course. Take a rock that
big out of there——
Q. 44. A crack where?
A. Where the rock fell. ;
Q. 45. Is that the crack you testified about on the other trial?
gee tetas eas PART EN ethics ms — :
MT as ees iat een tt aie ari cea aerate gt te eat ESSAI AS RLS OLINGER fe aR Rs
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 20
A. No, sir. The other crack
Q. 46. And was not these questions asked you and did you not
make these answers on the other trial? “Q. 56. And you noticed
this crack after this happened? <A. Yes, sir. Q. 58. Was that the
first time you had noticed that crack there—— A. Yes, sir.”
Didn’t you testify that way on the other trial?
A. That is all you asked me about——
Q. 47. Do you now recall of having testified that way before and
is it correct?
A. No, sir. You asked me to described about how the rock laid
and of course I deseribed it as best I could
Q. 48. I am not asking you about your direct-examination—I
asked you if you didn’t mention before that the crack was in the
side of the bluff? Did the crack extend into the side of it or
not?
54 A. I seen the rock there after the regular force and the
extra force had took it out of the way
Q. 49. You recollect now of seeing two cracks, one before and
one after?
A. Well, I don’t suppose he was asking about the other.
Q. 50. You crack that you could see before the rock fell, was
up and down?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 51. And parallel between this large rock and other rocks?
A. Well, I don’t know about the other rocks.
Q. 52. And one that was back in the side of the hill?
A. Yes, sir.
Redirect examination:
Q. 1. About what was the character of that crack, four or five
or six inches long?
A. No, sir.
Q. 2. Could you see it from the railroad track?
A. No, sir, you can’t see it all coming down, can’t see all of it.
Recross-examination :
Q. 1. Now to stand and look at the hill side these rocks and
the general appearance of the cliff is all about the same, the rocks
just extend back horizontally invo the hill?
A. I can’t tell you just how it was, | know the general appearance
of the side of the hill all about the same—there was a large rock
and it came out of there-—
Q. 2. You don’t know what proportion of the rock you saw,
either of its width or length?
55 A. Of course, I saw the width, but I wouldn’t say that I
suw it all, it was covered with dirt on one side of the eut——
Q. 3. How far did that rock project—out from the hill side?
A. Came out that way, kinda out in a point, where the big rock
Wwas-———
Q. 4. You know how many feet or inches of it, you could see?
Mee eos
30 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. YS.
, -y The place, where the end part of it was, could see about two
ee
The witness, Joz Compton, being first duly sworn, testified as
follows, to-wit:
Redirect examination:
Q. 1. Where do you live.
A. I live up Sandy here, at England Hill.
Q. 2. England Hill cut?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. And you are the husband of Mrs. Emma Compton, whe
just testified?
A. Yes, sir. .
Q. 4. And you have lived at the place she spoke of, how long?
A. Well, I don’t remember just how long.
Q. 5. You remember the occasion when a freight train of the
Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company was derailed up there?
A. Well, I wasn’t at home at night, just that night.
Q. 6. You remember the fact that it occurred?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. Up to that time how long had you been living there?
A. Well, I can’t say just how long.
56 Q. 8. About, your best judgment?
A. I had lived there, I except ten or twelve years, some where
like that.
Q. 9. You say you wasn’t at home the night the derailment oc-
curred?
A. No, sir, I wasn’t there.
Q. 10. How long after the accident before you got up there?
A. Well, it was a week or so, I guess.
Q. 11. A week or more?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 12. Were you familiar with the place where the derailment
happened?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 13. What kind of material was in that cut?
A. Well, sir, it looks like a slaty kind of rock, loose layers and
some hard rock mixed, through—some of the rocks stick out of
the hill, and are liable to fall
Q. 14. Before this had any rocks fallen down out of the cut
there
. Yes, sir.
15. How long before?
Something like a month before.
16. What became of the rocks on the track at that time?
I went out myself and rolled them off of the track.
17. Where did you roll them to?
Rolled them off to the side of the track.
18. You removed several of them?
OP>OPere>r
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. F $1
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 19. Any body ever help you move any rocks off of the track
there in the cut?
A. They did, once.
57 Q. 20. Who helped you?
A. Pete Blankenship. I went and told George Arthur
about it and he sent one of his men with me to help get it off.
Q. 21. Blankenship assisted you to remove the rock?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 22. The other you got off by yourself?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 23. Why did you do that?
A. I just didn’t want to see a train wrecked or some thing like
that, so I rolled the rock off of the track
Q. 24. Did the section foreman and the section men know of
the falling of the dirt and rocks in there in that cut, from that
slope?
A. Indeed, I don’t know if he did or not.
Q. 25. Ever say anything to the section foreman at that time
about it?
A. No, sir, only George Arthur, he was section foreman, when I
rolled the stone off and the one I told about it.
Q. 26. George Arthur was the section foreman at that time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 27. Did the railroad Company ever pay you for removing
rocks and dirt from the cut?
A. One time, when Mr. Blankenship helped me, broke the rock
up and rolled it off, they paid me for that.
Q. 28. How high is the cut?
A. 15 or 20 feet in the highest places.
Q. 29. Had your attention ever been drawn before this derail-
ment to that cut and the rocks that were in that cut?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 30. What drew your attention—You saw the rock that fell
before it fell?
A. Yes, sir, the rock came loose from the rock bank, the dirt and
stuff kept pushing behind it and it gradually washed down behind it
and kept pushing it down all the time.
58 Q. 31. Any thing indicate to you that it was loose?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 32. What indicated to you it was loose?
By the Court: Just describe it. The Condition there.
A. It was a hard flat rock, two feet thick, and about four or five
feet wide and about ten feet long, wider on the bottom, and every
time there was a bad wash it would wash stuff down in behind there
and keep it pushed out—— :
Q. 33. Did it slip on more any from the time you first noticed
it until the derailment?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 34. About how much had it moved during the time you had
lived there and had observed it?
39 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
A. I don’t know how much it did move——
Q. 35. For how long had you noticed, if you had of the rock
not being in the hill?
A. Some three or four weeks.
Q. 36. And may be longer?
A. Yes, sir, I couldn’t tell you exactly what time.
Q. 37. That one of a chain of rocks, on still above the railroad
track?
A. I don’t know, there was some three or four slabs left—didn’t
clear the track, from which it could have split——
Q. 38. When you first noticed it after it fell it was moved, I
suppose?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 39. How far from the railroad ties, did they have this slope?
A. Well, there was four or five feet may be. Just giving it as a
guess, never measured it.
59 Cross-examination :
Q. 1. When was it that you first noticed the rock was Icose or
insecure?
A. Some three or four weeks before the accident
Q. 2. It had been that long a time before the accident that you
first noticed the rock was loose?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. Had you ever noticed the rock before that, and if so for
how long? ,
A. Noticed it, prior to that time. Yes, for six months or a right
smart while.
Q. 4. How much do you think it had come down, moved, during
that time.
A. Well, I don’t know exactly how far. Just the wash, con ing
in behind it.
Q. 5. How much did you notice it slipping?
A. I expect 2 or 3 feet.
Q. 6. You noticed it moving that far?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. You testified before in this case?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 8. Didn’t you testify before as follows: “Q. 34. How was
it down next to the bottom, solid, wasn’t it? A. When it would
be wet, it would be slipping, vou could tell you that?” Was that
question asked you and did you make that answer?
A. I suppose it was.
Q. 9. And was this question asked you, “Q. 35. You think this
rock had come out four or five inches? A. Yes, sir.’ And this
question, “Q. 38. This rock had slipped out toward the track,
four or five inches, that it? A. Yes, sir.’ Did you say
60 __ that? ; :
A. I suppose so.
Q. 10. Why do you say now that it moved two or three feet?
A. I guess, I said after it come out of the hill,
ee “
Ru ages 3 PRE ips ss ei heaens BOPP ARNE iat Pe FOYE Le ARIES penemnmes aso ee
%
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 33
Q. 11. What did you mean by saying before that it had moved
four or five inches?
A. Four or five inches down the slope—four or five inches down
the rocky hillside——
Q. 12. And rolled down the slope, two or three feet from where
it came out of the main bank?—did it roll out of the track three
or four feet?
A. Didn’t get quite to the track at that time.
Q. 13. Will you explain why you said before that the rock slipped
four or five inches from the time you first noticed it, and now you
say it slipped two or three feet?
A. Where it came out at the main bank—TI had noticed it, five
or six feet pushed out——
Q. 14. What did you mean on the last trial when you said four
or five inches?
A. I meant to sav where it fell out of the bank, where it be-
came loose and fell out, I noticed where it had moved out four
or five inches.
Q. 15. How long before this train was derailed had you noticed
that?
A. A great while.
Q. 16. Just give us your best independent recollection?
A A month or two.
Q. 17. A month or two?
A. Yes; four or five inches, it was about a month.
Q. 18. And later on you say it was two feet?
A. Yes, at the time the rock fell out of the bank, it was.
Q. 19. These rocks all extended horizontally back into that bluff,
didn’t they?
61 A. No sir, the- laid flatways in the side of the hill.
Q. 20. Did this one that fell lay and extend clear back into
the hill?
26. It is almost perpendicular, straight up and down?
No, not perpendicular.
By the Court: What first attracted your attention to this rock?
A. Well, I saw it was coming out, sliding down from the side
of the hill, and I just kept noticing it then to see how much it had
slipped down.
Q. 27. That is what first attracted your attention?
A. Yes, sir.
5—453
A. No, this one didn’t.
Q. 21. This was laid out?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 22. Wasn’t the whole rock exposed?
A. No, not all.
Q. 23. How much of it was exposed?
A. Five or six feet.
Q. 24. Five or six feet of it exposed?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 25. That is a pretty steep bluff, ain’t it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q.
A.
THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Q. 28. How long was that before it fell?
A. Two or three months or maybe longer.
Q. 29. Two or three months?
A. Yes, sir.
Redirect examination :
1. This rock was loose from the rest of the bank?
. Yes, sir.
>e
Recross-examination :
62 Q. 1. Did vou ever testify before that you saw that that
rock had slipped two or three feet at any time? I will ask
you if on the first trial of this case, you did not testify, about that
rock slipping two or three feet?
A. Not that 1 recollect of.
Re-redirect examination:
Q. 1. Were you not also asked on the other trial as to how far
the rock stood out from the rest of the bank there and you said
five or six inches?
Yes, sir.
2. And was that true?
Yes, sir. :
3. And you answered all that you were asked about?
. Yes, sir.
POPO>
Re-recross-examination :
Q. 1. You said it had slipped four or five inches, on one side?
Ris I said it had slipped out some four or five inches, giving down
then.
Q. 2. You never have testified about it giving down or slipping
to the extent of two or three feet, this is the first time you have
ever testified to that?
A. I don’t recollect.
Q. 3. You don’t recollect of ever having testified to anything
of that kind before?
A. No, sir.
63 The witness, GeorcEe STaNLey, being first duly sworn testi-
fied as follows, to-wit:
Direct examination:
Q. 1. How old are you?
A. I am about 60, I guess, 60 or 65, I don’t know hardly which.
Q. 2. Where do you live?
o Live on Chadwicks Creek.
A
. 3. How long have you lived on Chadwicks Creek?
. Near about three years,
PALI REET IE SRE REE LSS BAF HES MOLE ND SIE CLONE RRC a
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 35
Q. 4. At the time the train was wrecked up here on the Big
Sandy Division at the England Hill cut, where did you live?
A. Well, just about that time I lived about two or three hundred
yards down below where the wreck was, but I didn’t never measure
it.
Q. 5. Two or three hundred yards below where the wreck was?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 6. Did you live along the railroad track?
A. IT lived on the left hand side as you go up.
Q. 7. Left hand side going up?
A. Yes.
Q. 8. Did you have any occasion to pass through that cut be-
fore that wreck?
A. Well, I kept my cow in Shock Richardson’s pasture and me
and my wife would go backwards and forwards to milk and we
would kinda notice that rock.
Q. 9. How often would you go through there?
A. Yes, sir, twice a day——
Q. 10. To milk?
64 A. Yes, sir, go to milk the cow and come back
Q. 11. You kept the cow in Shock Richardson’s pasture?
Kept her in Shock’s pasture.
12. And you all would go up there to milk her?
Yes, sir.
13. And you would pass through there twice a day, every day?
Yes, sir.
. 14. How long had you been going through there when that
accident happened ?
A. Well, we had been going through there a couple of years, two
pastures,
Q. 15. During that time and before this derailment did you no-
tice any loose rock, that might fall out?
A. TI would notice it every time T passed.
Q. 16. You noticed that every time you passed?
PrOorer
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 17. What did you notice about this rock that fell, if any
thing?
A. Tt was dropping all the time, the dirt washed down and my
wife would run a past that rock.
Q. 18. Why?
A. She was afraid of it.
Q. 19. What was there about it, if any thing that made it look
dangerous?
A. Well, the rock sit up in that position and loose underneath,
looked like you could take a hand spike and push it off.
Q. 20. Was it attached to, or loose from the rest of the hill there?
a Well, it looked to me like it was pushed loose from the main
cliff.
Q. 21. Pushed loose from the main cliff?
A. Yes, sir, kinda shrunk down from the main cliff.
65 Q. 22. What became of that rock?
A. I don’t know, I never measured it, or nothing of the
sort.
' es ’ i TEN 5 neg sap
36 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Q. 23. What became of it?
A. It is laying over on the left of the railroad.
Q. 24. As you go up?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 25. ‘Between the railroad and the river?
A. Yes, sir, right before Joe Compton’s door.
Q. 26. ‘Who put it there?
A. These here railroad men, I reckon—can’t tell who put it
there—they lifted it with the wrecker
Q. 27. The wreck train lifted it off?
Yes, sir.
28. Where did they lift it from?
Lifted it off of the railroad.
29. When was it?
I couldn’t tell you right exactly when it was.
30. How long after the accident was it that they lifted this
rock off of the track?
A. Oh, they lifted it off, I think, that evening, T ain’t right cer-
tain that they lifted it off that same evening, but I know it was
right at once.
Q. 31. Do you know what time the train was wrecked?
A. No, I don’t know exactly what time it wrecked, I went up
there just a short while after ‘it wrecked and they had taken the
man over to Joe Compton’s.
Q. 32. And that before the wreck train came?
A. I can’t tell you exactly when the wreck train came, but it
come.
Q. 33. Did you see the rock there
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 34. Where was it then?
A. Well, it had kinda slid over, up on the saileead
66 Q. 35. On the track?
A. On the track.
sr theca
Q. 36. And where did you next see it?
A. I stood right there, sir, until they lifted it off with the wrecker.
Q. 37. And.they laid it on the left hand side?
A. Laid it on the left hand side as you come up.
Q. 38. Did you see the engine there that was wrecked?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 39. What wrecked it?
A. Well, I couldn’t tell you, if that rock didn’t wreck it I couldn’t
tell you what wrecked it.
Q. 40. Had it hit the rock?
A. I —— it had.
Q. 41. Knock the engine over against the rock, or on it?
A. No, it was kinda leant over.
Q. 42. Laid over against the rock?
_ A. Yes, I couldn’t tell if the train was wrecked on the rock or
not, I gO it was through.
Q. 48. Was that the same rock that you had seen in the cut
there, that you speak of?
A. Yes, sir, same rock.
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC.
44. How long did you n tice that rock there loose?
About a couple of years.
45. As much as two years
. Yes, sir.
. 46. Had it changed any in position during that time?
Well. I don’t know as it had, but it looked to me like a big
crack all the time, the dirt had washed in and it was pressed out,
and in a very wet time it would be filled with dirt there and stuff
from the rock, and it looked dangerous.
> OPOPO
67 Q. 47. Some times the dirt would wash over it and some
times it would be washed off of it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 48. Was there space between it and the main body of the
hill.
A. Well, if there was T couldn’t see it.
Q. 49. You spoke about it being prized loose?
A. Tt was prized loose, T could get a hand spike behind it——
Q. 50. You mean a crack was in it?
A. Yes, sir, a crack.
Cross-examination :
Q. 1. You spoke about during wet spells dirt falling down, that
was all along the side if the bluff, wasn’t it?
A. Certainly, I have seen rocks slide off in the cut
Q. 2. They would fall in the ditch there, and you have seen
the ditch cleaned out?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. That was an often occurrence all along the whole side of
the bluff?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 4. It will come in, in bunches?
A. Yes, sir, more so when you tend up above the cut, it will be
washed more.
Q. 5. Now you say there was a place there that it looked like
you could put a hand spike in?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 6. That was in between this rock and another rock next to it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. A crack up and down on the side of the cliff?
A. It was up this way, here stood the main cliff and here stood a
rock (Indicating) and it looked to me like you could put a hand
spike in there and prize that rock off.
68 Q. 8. Take this side of the table as the side of the Cliff,
the rock laid in this way? (Indicating.)
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 9. Crack between this rock and the one next to it?
A. No, sir, crack run lengthwise.
Q. 10. On top of the rock?
A. No, right in the middle of it, when that rock fell it left the
face of the cliff here—another rock
ELMER LATE OL PMS LES POP IA SAE EM TD PIE ERC ARE
38 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Q. 11. The crack that you are talking about was in the middle
of the big rock—the erack?
Ps This rock that fell off, connected by the crack—after it fell
)
Q. 12. The crack that you speak of, you told me extended up and
down the side of the cliff, didn’t you?
A. No, sir, I never did.
Q. 13. Which was did it extend?
A. Lengthwise, up and down this way (indicating) here is the
cliff and here stands the rock, this end, the upper end was sprung
_ about far enough it looked like to me to get a hand spike in
ere,
Q. 14. The way you placed your hands, here was the side the
erack was on and here was the rock here?
A. No, sir.
Q. 15. That is the way you have got your hands?
A. No, sir. My hands are correct—this hand is where the upper
end of the rock, and it was about four or five inches, looked to me
like far enough ‘to get a hand spike in there and prize it down.
Q. 16. You remember about it being out four or five inches?
A. Yes, the part next to the railroad.
Q. 17. The whole rock was out that way?
A. The bottom of it was on slate, but I suppose it kept on
69 cutting, and the stuff coming down here, kept on pushing
the rock out
. 18. What kind of material did it rest on?
. On slate, or some kind of a soap stone.
19. And extended back into the side of the cliff?
It run down, you couldn’t see the end of it.
20. Where?
The lower end.
. 21. Where was it?
. It was “agin” the hill.
. 22. If it was against the hill you could see it, couldn’t you?
. I don’t suppose you could.
. 23. What Hy you know about it?
. I suppose, there was a little dirt on the lower end of it.
24. Could you tell how large the rock was when it extended
back into the hill?
A. Well, I know from what TI could see of it, I could see it on
the outside, up and down, I could see about five or six feet as near
as I can get at it.
Q. 25. You could see five or six feet of that rock?
A. Yes, sir, but I couldn’t see underneath, or IT couldn’t see
through the crack.
‘. a 26. How far did that rock project out from the side of the
ill
A. Well, it slanted out about three or four inches——
Q. 27. Three or four inches, out of the side of the hill.
A. One end of it——
Q. 28. One end was out three or four inches?
A. Yes, sir.
OP OPOrOPrOrore
REI IE TON OL OLLI APARNA SEMIN Fit
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 39
Q. 29. What about the balance of it?
A. The balance was sitting on soap stone and a little
70 dirt down at the lower end of it was exposed.
Q. 30. What was on top of the balance?
A. Dirt and stuff that had washed down.
Q. 31. How far up from the lé¢vel of the track was that rock in
the hill?
A. It was five or six feet, I] reckon, I never measured it.
Q. 32. Four or five feet?
A. Five or six feet, 1 never measured it, only just guessing.
Q. 33. How long was that rock?
A. Well, sir, I never measured it, never went around it.
. 34. You saw it?
. | never measured it, I seen it.
35. What is your judgment about it?
I suppose the rock was close to ten feet long.
. 36. How wide was it?
About five or six feet wide, or seven.
37. How thick? :
. Well, IT don’t know really, I never measured the rock.
. 38. Give me your judgment about the thickness of the rock?
I guess about two feet thick, or a little over.
. 39. Now that was the thickness of the rock that projected out,
wasn’t it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 40. The thick part of it?
A. Yes, sir, it stood upon its edge.
Q. 41. What do you mean by sitting up on its edge?
A. Well, you have seen a sliver of rock, split off of a rock, and
the jury can get an idea how that is.
Q. 42. I want you to give us an idea how that is
A. I don’t know, there was some there that didn’t fall.
Q. 48. What kept them from falling?
A. I couldn’t tell you, only it was a soap stone cut—it kept it
from falling
71 Q. 44. How far from the outside edge of the soap stone
out to the projection of the rock?
A. I never paid enough attention to that.
Q. 45. Four or five inches?
A. I told the old woman if I had a hand spike T could stick in
there and prize it out, and prize it down—lIf I had one, I would
prize it down, and she says if you do some one will get killed
Q. 46. You and your wife walked by it all the time?
A. No, sir, she run by it.
Q. 47. How would she go?
A. She would get on the fur side of the track and would run by it.
Q. 48. Now in order to get the thing in my mind, get your tes-
timony correct about it,—I just want to repeat the question again—-I
want to know just as near as you can give it, how much of the
rock—the actual rock you could see?
A. Underneath?
O>OrOPoOrore
40 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Q. 49. The whole rock? How much of the whole rock?
A. Well, sir, | don’t know exactly,—if 1 should die, I couldn’t
tell you.
Q. 50. In other words, you wouldn’t say how much you could
see?
A. I don’t know as I could. 4 could make a blunder at it, it is
not my desire to tell a lie, I want to tell the truth.
Q. 51. You had noticed the rock for some time prior to the night
the train was derailed?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 52. Ever notice any change in the position of the rock dur-
ing that time?
A. Never paid much attention only as we would pass there and
me and my wife would notice the rock of course, If I had known I
would have been on the witness stand I would have paid a
72 little better attention to it.
Q. 53. As a matter of fact you didn’t pay much attention
to it?
A. Of course, I was watching “atter’”” my own family.
Q. 54. You testified before in this case didn’t you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 55. Didn’t you testify then that the crack extended up and
down the hill?
A. Up and down, lengthwise, up and down,
Q. 56. Up and down and lengthwise are entirely different’
A. I didn’t state the crack was up at the top, I said the crack
was up here and the rock was “kind a swagged out.
Q. 57. I will ask you if this question wasn’t asked you on your
Cross Examination: “Q. 18. Where.was that crack did it extend up
and down in the cliff’ or lengthwise in the cliff and did you not
answer: “A. Up and down?”
A. I might have done it, but I have showed the jury and you to-,
like this is the cliff and it was up and down here (indicating) at the
end, the rock had come out and I could have taken a hand spike
and prized it out——
Q. 58. This crack was just an ordinary crack like you see in
rocks on the side of the hill, wasn’t it?
A. Certainly.
Q. 58. Run up and down?
A. No, sir, it run lengthwise.
Q. 59. Why did you tell me that then?
A. You folks just misunderstood me.
Q. 60. 1 didn’t——
A. Of course they may have misunderstood the way I have given
it, but it was lengthwise.
73 Redirect examination:
Q. 1. Lengthwise, you mean up and down the river?
A, Yes, sir.
Q. 2. And the space between the rock and the slope was at the
upper end of the rock?
SEF 1»
ao ~—
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 41
A. At the upper end, yes, sir.
By the Court: Going up the river?
A. Yes, sir.
The witness, Joun Boyp, being first duly sworn, testified as fol-
lows, to-wit:
Direct examination:
Q. 1. Where do you live?
A. Live in the 4th. ward now.
Q. 2. Catlettsburg?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. In May, 1910, where did vou live?
A. I lived in Ewing District—England Hill District, you might
Q. 4. England Hill District?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. Were you farming then?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 6. Where if that with reference to the England Hill cut, on
the C. & O.? Did you live above that cut?
A. I lived above it, yes, sir.
Q. 7. How far?
A. About a mile.
74 Q. 8. In going to and from Catlettsburg to your farm up
there, did you pass through this cut up there—the England
Hill cut?
A. In coming to town, I passed it, of course.
Q. 9. Walking the railroad. Would you walk the railroad, or
how?
A. Walked the railroad.
Q. 10. When you would not be hauling some thing?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 11. You remember the time the train was wrecked up there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 12. You remember when that was?
A. In May, I think.
Q. 18. How long ago?
A. 1910, I think it was.
Q. 14. 1910?
A. Yes sir.
Q. 15. How long before that had you been in the habit of going
up and down through that eut?
A. I don’t know how long I had been in the habit of walking
there, up and down the railroad, been traveling it ever since the
railroad had been built, been a good while since I first traveled jit.
Q. 16. Did you ever notice the nature of the material in that cut?
A. Kind of a loose crumbly rock, looked like.
Q. 17. During that time had you noticed any rock in that cliff
that looked different from the others in any way?
A. I noticed a rock in the cliff that looked like it was going to
6—453
42 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
come down, that was extending out—looked like it had slipped loose
from the originai rock, some distance, I can’t say just how far it
had slipped, slipped five or six inches, made a crack there.
Q. 18. Five or six inches from what?
A. That far from the other rocks.
75 Q. 19. It separated and was loose from the other rocks?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 20. How long had you noticed that rock being there that way
before the wreck?
A. I had noticed it several times in passing.
Q. 21. How long had it been since you first noticed it?
A. It wasn’t very long before the wreck.
By the Court: About how long?
A. It might have been a week, or more than a week, I can’t say
for sure, I know I passed the rock all the time.
Q. 22. How did it compare in size with the other rocks in the
slope there?
A. Well, I don’t know, some rocks smaller—of course some larger
than it was,
Q. 23. About what size rock was this that you noticed had become
loose and separated from the rest of the slope?
A. Well, the rock that extended out was four or five feet—the
side of it that was naked and the end of it stood out from the cut,
the nearest end towards town.
Q. 24. There was four or five feet of it exposed?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 25. And one part of it stood out four or five inches, that right?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 26. What about the other part of it?
A. The other part was covered up with dirt.
Q. 27. Covered with dirt?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 28. Which end was covered by dirt?
A. The lower end of it.
Q. 29. The lower end?
A. Yes, sir.
76 Q. 30. Was there any thing about the condition of the
rock that indicated to you that it was dangerous, or might
fall, other than the distance between it and the rest of the slope?
A. I spoke to some other people that was with me, I don’t know
just who it was——
By the Court: Don’t tell what you told.
Q. 31. Just tell what there was that indicated to you that it was
dangerous or liable to fall?
A. I thought the rock might fall is all.
Q. 32. Why did you think so?
A. Because it was loose and slippery, had a foundation of soap
stone and stuff on there, several ingredients—and it was over the
railroad track, away up there——
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 43
Q. 33. The material under it was a slippery sand stone material?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 34. What became of the rock?
A. I saw that rock later on, on the left hand side of the railroad
next to Mr. Compton’s house,
Q. 35. Left hand side of the railroad?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 36. When did you first see it there?
A. I saw it there just a day or so after the wreck.
Q. 37. And did you notice that it had disappeared from the hill
top slope?
A. Yes, sir.
:; > How high above the railroad track was this rock in the
slope?
A. It might have been five or six feet.
Q. 39. About what size was the rock?
A. I never measured the rock—the rock looked like it might
have “— _ or ten feet long, and probably a couple of feet
thick.
77 By the Court: And how wide?
A. Five or six feet wide.
Cross-examination :
Q. 1. The formation of the side of this cliff where the rock came
from was a slatey formation, wasn’t it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 2. This rock laid on the slate?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. It projected right out from the side of the cliff?
A. Yes, sir. :
Q. 4. Laid in the cliff flat ways?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. Which edge of this projected out from the cliff and the
other rocks?
A. The upper end of it going down towards Catlettsburg, stood
out, the other end was back quartering in the hill.
Q. 6. That was all covered by the portion of the cliff that was
on top?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. How far did you say the rock projected out from the side
of the cliff?
A. I said it wasn’t—along the side of the track you could see
four or five feet.
Q. 8. You mean you could see the width of the rock for four or
five feet?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 9. And that projected out from the side of the cliff for four
or five inches?
A. I mean the length of it, was down that far—the width of it
extended up like this, probably four or five feet——
he
44 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. Vs.
78 Q. 10. Take the top of this box—this was the length of the
rock and this part towards Mr. Malin to be the width and
here is a flat surface, here is the cliff, and extending down that way
was the slaty formation?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 11. Above that was rocks and dirt and material of that char-
acter?
A. Yes, sir. It extended out four or five inches from the main
rocks—the cliff—up and down the hill, another rock behind it, it
had slipped away from another rock, and out from it——
Q. 12. And the hill was back of the rock?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 13. You couldn’t see it all?
A. Only a portion of it, a little portion of it.
Q. 14. The way it had separated from the other rocks you didn’t
think it was safe?
A. A portion of it.
Q. 15. If it had slipped away from another rock, it was the rock
thai was exposed to view in the side of the cliff, wasn’t it?
A. Yes, sir, I suppose so.
Q. 18. The rock was laying along the side of it?
A. Along the side of the hill, didn’t lay diagonally in the hill,
laid along the side of the hill, in the cut, the rock did.
Q. 17. Which rock was it that laid that way?
A. The one that fell out.
Q. 18. The one that fell out?
A. Laid on the side of the hill. Laying down in the side of the
hill, wasn’t diagonally in the hill—the end of it.
Q. 19. Which end, the upper end?
79 A. The lower end of it was covered with earth, coming to
town.
Q. 20. How much of the rock was exposed?
A. I said four or five feet of the side of it, the edge, I mean.
Q. 21. How far did that stick out from the side of the hill?
A. You mean the whole rock—say here was the rock here, it ex-
tended out four or five inches—slipped over towards the railroad, is
what I mean—at the end
Q. 22. You say vou could see four or five feet of the thickness of
the rock, or the width?
A. The length.
Q. 23. Of the length, how much of the top of the rock could you
see, the flat surface?
A. Couldn’t see so much of the top, covered with earth.
Q. 24. Give an idea about how much of the top of the rock was
exposed ?
A. T can’t say, never measured it, the upper corner was naked-———
Q. 25. Your best judgment?
A. T can’t say how much there was.
Q. 26. The top of that rock was 6 feet by ten feet, T believe is the
dimensions given by the witnesses, that would be 60 square feet,
now how much of that surface could you see?
|
|.
JAMES K. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 45
A. I could see four or five fect of the length of ti running down
the river.
Q. 27. How much of the top—square feet? ,
A. The top wasn’t naked at all, except a small portion of the
upper end.
Q. 28. - small portion at the upper end exposed to the naked
eye?
80 A. Yes, sir.
Redirect examination:
Q. 1. Standing down on the railroad track the top of the rock
could be above your head, wouldn’t it?
A. O, yes, yes, sir.
Q. 2. And you could see four or five feet of it extending along on
the side of the slope?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. The lower four or five feet was covered with dirt?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 4. And where the rock had broken loose from the ledge, be-
tween the ledge and the rock was a space of four of five inches?
A. Yes, sir.
Recross-examination :
Q. 1. The elevation of the rock from the railroad track was about
four or five feet?
A. Yes, it would have been that far “up.
The witness, Joun Fortune, being first duly sworn, testified as
follows, to-wit:
Direct examination :
Your name is John Fortune?
Q. 1
A. Yes, sir.
Q 2. Where do you live?
A. Live in Oakland Addition to Catlettsburg.
81 Q. 3. How long have you lived there?
A. About 20 vears.
Q. 4. How near do you live to what is known as England Hill Cut,
on the railroad?
A. About a quarter of a mile, T reckon, from my house.
Q. 5. You remember of a freight train that was derailed up there
several vears ago?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 6. Before that accident—that wreck—had vou ever had ocea-
sion to pass along the railroad and through that cut there?
A. Once in awhile T would pass up and down, yes.
Q. 7. Had you—how long before that wreck had you passed
through it?
A. Well, I can’t say exactly how long.
Q. 8. Well, was it a short while or a long while?
46 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
A. Yes, it was a short while.
Q. 9. About what was the height of that cut?
A. Well, I suppose it was something like 15 or 20 feet, might be
twenty some thing.
Q. 10. What kind of material was in the cut?
A. Mixed up with all kinds of rocks.
Q. 11. All kinds of rocks and dirt?
A. Yes, slate and some hard rock and dirt.
Q. 12. Was it sand stone or lime stone?
A. Yes, sand stone.
Q. 13. Was there any soap stone in it?
A. Yes, there was soap stone in it.
Q. 14. Had you ever noticed any of the soap stone material or
dirt slipping out of that slope?
. Why, yes, now and then I had noticed it.
Q. 15. You had noticed it?
A. Yes.
82 Q. 16. Was there any rocks in the slope?
A. Yes, some. There was rock in there.
Q. 17. What size rocks?
A. Different sizes.
Q. 18. Before this wreck, did you notice any rock that differed
from the other rocks, in any way, and if so tell the jury, if your
attention was attracted to it?
A. Well, I noticed a right smart sized rock that laid in the bluff
ike.
Q. 19. What attracted your attention to it?
A. I don’t know, I just happened to be passing and happened
to notice it.
Q. 20. What caused you to notice it?
A. I just thought it had slipped out of the bluff, you know.
Q. 21. It had slipped out of the bluff and that was what attracted
your attention to it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 22. How far had it slipped out?
A. I can’t say exactly, “shoved” out a right smart, kinda lean-
ing against the bluff like.
Q. 23. Loose from the rest of the bluff?
A. Looked like it to me.
Q. 24. What space, if any, was there between it and the rest of
the bluff there?
A. T couldn’t tell exactly how much.
Q. 25. Was there any space?
A. It seemed to be laying out from the dirt and slate like.
Q. 26. baa position did it occupy in the cut, this large
roc
83 A. Well, this rock you speak about, it lay in a kind of an
angling shape against the hill like.
Q. 27. Was there dirt over any part of it?
A. I can’t say might have been some dirt at the lower edge of it.
Q. 28. About how much of the rock was exposed there?
’ WS AUB Tmt ee. eae The teiees tae — . — : . . «aif
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 47
A. Well, there was, I suppose, four or five feet wide, and | reckon
eight or ten feet long, probably.
Q. 29. You could see that much of it?
A. Yes.
Q. 30. Four or five feet of the width?
A. Yes,
Q. 31. And eight feet of the length?
A. Six to eight feet of the length.
Q. 32. Had that rock changed any in position during the time
you noticed it there?
A. No, I don’t remember noticing it only the one time in pass-
ing it.
Q 33. You noticed that it had slipped from the rest of the bluff?
A. Yes. Had come out from the rest of the bluff there, had
slipped down.
Q. 34. About how long before the accident was it that you noticed
it in that condition?
A. Well, I can’t say exactly.
Q. 35. About how long?
A. The accident happened in May, about the first of May
Q. 36. May, 12th?
A. Probably, it might have been April when I was along there,
but I generally go around up there a good deal in the Spring of
the year looking after business.
84 Q. 37. Was there any thing about the base that it was
laying on that indicated to you that the rock might fall?
A. Well, it was laying kinda with a foot hold in the bank, like
soap stone you might call it—it didn’t seem to be laying right.
. 38. A slaty loose material under it?
A. Yes, sir, there was a kind of soap stone under it, there was a
little “grain” of coal under there. Of course always slate and soap
stone about a coal bank.
Q. 39. Did you ever see that rock after the wreck?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 40. Where was it?
A. It was on the lower side of the road.
Q. 41. You saw them when they were taking it off the track?
A. No, sir, I didn’t see it, I was on top of the hill. Wasn’t down
at the railroad at all. I saw the wreck laying there.
Q. 42. When was that, the next morning?
A. Next morning, yes, sir.
Q. 43. Could you see that rock?
A. I didn’t notice the rock at all.
Q. 44. You were up on the hill?
A. Yes, saw some people around down there, I didn’t go down
among them.
Cross-examination :
Q. 1. How far above the track was this rock that you speak of?
A. Above the level of the track?
Q. 2. Yes?
48 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. V8.
A. I suppose two feet, or more,
Q. 3. The bluff at that point was almost straight up and down
was it not?
A. Well, it leant back a little bit, sloped back some.
85 Q. 4. It sloped back some, but not very much was it?
A. No, pretty near a square cut of course it sloped some.
Q. 5. Describe the position of this rock to me again, will you?
A. The size of the rock?
Q. 6. The rock itself, the way it was in the hill?
A. It was about four or five feet wide, and eight or ten feet long.
Q. 7. How much of the rock could you see?
A. That is all I could tell about, what I could see couldn’t tell
any thing about what I couldn’t see, only guess work.
Q. 8. Just consider for a moment the top of this table, this is
the length of the rock and this is width?
A. I understand.
Q. 9. And this is the thickness and then the top surface, of course,
was about as long as ths is wide?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 10. Just show t. = how the rock extended into the hill, to
the jury?
A. Well, it dicn’t—It laid up, against the hill like.
Q. 11. Laid up against the hill on its end?
86 A. “Kinda” leant up like.
Q. 12. The if I take the top of this table and lean up up
like that against the side of the room would that be the position
it was in? (Indicating.)
A. Well, “kinda” sloped like, leaned back against the bill.
Q. 13. Then what you mean to say to the jury is, that if I take
this top of this table and lean it up against the side of the house
there, what would be the position the rock was in that what you
want the jury to understand as being the position of the rock’
A. It wasn’t perpendicular, the side of the house is perpedic-
ular, and the bluff up there is sloped.
Q. 14. The- it laid on the slope there, whatever slope there was?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 15. How much of the top surface of that rock was exposed to
view?
A. I think four or five feet wide and about eight or ten feet long.
Q. 16. Then you could see sixty square feet of the surface of the
rock on top, that what you mean?
A. Standing on the track, could see up on the bank.
Q. 17. Standing on the track looking at the rock cliff you could
see about 60 square feet of its top surface?
A. I suppose so, | made no estimate of it.
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 49
The witness, Jor LikeNs, being first duly sworn, testified as
follows, to-wit:
87 Direct examination:
Q. 1. Where do you live?
A. I live up on the Sandy road here.
Q. 2. About how far from the England Hill cut?
A. O! About a mile, may be a little more—about a mile.
Q. 3. A mile above it or below it?
A. Above it.
Q. 4. You live along the line of the Chesapeake & Ohio Rail-
way?
A. My land goes to the road.
Q. 5. Your land goes to the railroad?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 6. Is that cut between your home and Catlettsburg?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. In going to and from Catlettsburg, do you pass along the
railroad and through that cut?
A. Which?
©. 8. When you would go to Catlettsburg, from your home would
you go through the cut?
A. Yes, sir, I could go around.
Q. 9. You walk the railroad, and go through the cut?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 10. And how long have you been accustomed to passing
through that cut?
A. Ever since it was made, I hauled feed and stuff to the rail-
road when they was making it.
Q. 11. You remember the time when the freight train was de
railed and Mr. Dwyer was killed?
A. I just didn’t keep any account of it, 1910, I think it
was.
88 Q. 12. You remember that it happened?
A. O, yes, 1 was dewn there next day and saw the wreck,
1 see it about two times a week, going to town and some times six.
Q. 13. Now just describe to the jury, Mr. Likens, that cut, as
best you can—the material in it?
A. How long and how high or what?
A 14. How long and how high and what material it was made
of?
A. Well, the cut would be right some thing near 20 feet———
Q. 15. 20 feet high?
A. Would be that high, the best of my judgment.
By the Court: How long wes it?
A. Well, it will average about, from thirty to thirty-five T. rails
in length.
Q. 16. What kind of material in that slope?
A. You mean in the cliff?
Q. 17. Yes.
A. Soft places and hard places, and like that?
7—453
50 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. vs.
Q. 18. What kind of rock, if any?
A. Well, there is hard rock and soft rock.
Q. 19. Lime stone or sand stone or shale?
A. Kind of a slately rock, and ore beds and such as that, mixed
with hard rock.
Q. 20. How far back from the railroad track does this slope be-
gin—the lower part of the slope, how far is it from the rail-road?
A. You mean sloped back that way? (Indicating. )
Q. 21. From the railroad track?
A. I know, it is pretty near straight up and down until you get
to the top of it.
Q. gy wide is the ditch between the railroad and the
89 A. It is very narrow.
Q. 23. About how much?
A. I suppose, would be five or six feet on a side, not over that.
Q. 24. Before this wreck occurred had your attention been drawn
to any rock in that cut that laid different from the others in the
cut?
A. Yes, sir—This here one that fell in, I have noticed that rock.
Q. 25. How came you to notice it?
A. O! I would be passing there, may be I would stop there and
just look around and just notice it like anybody would.
Q. 26. What attracted your attention about it, that it was dif-
ferent?
A. Well, it just looked like a rock that was dangerous, might fall
down there and cause a wreck.
Q. 27. What made it look dangerous?
A. Just because it was up there against the side of the cliff.
Q. 28. Did it look like it was attached to the cliff so that it would
not fall?
A. No, sir, it wasn’t attached to the cliff, because it was loose from
the cliff.
Q. 29. And how far from it?
A. You could see it had dropped down and hung out away from
it, about five or six inches, the other end that laid against the cliff,
not loose.
Q. 30. The upper end was five or six inches from the cliff?
A. Yes, “Sorter” dropped down that way from the cliff up the
river
90 Q. 31. Was it a part of a ledge of rocks or loose there in
the dirt, the rock that fell, this big rock?
A. It was different, laid up against the side of the cliff there and
the other end it run in there enough to keep it from slipping out it
looked like that end that hung against the cliff.
Q. 32. That was the lower end?
A. Lower end, this way..
Q. 33. How much of the rock could you see—I understand you
to say that there was a space of between five or six inches, between
the cliff and the rock at the upper end?
A. Five or six, between five and six inches wide.
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC.
Q. 34. How much of the rock could you see?
A. About half of the length, could see the full width——
Q. 35. What about the width of it?
A. I would say it would be about the same width clear through.
Q. 36. Could you see the whole width of it?
A. Yes, the upper end was naked, see the whole width of it, run
the same width all the way
Q. 37. About what size was the rock?
A. You mean how wide?
Q. 38. And how long and how wide?
A. Well, it would average right about ten feet long, now, looks
like, been broke when they got it off the track, out of the cut.
Q. 39. That long where it is laying now?
A. Yes, sir, some thing near ten feet now.
Q. 40. Where is it laying now?
A. Right there on the side of the track, on the side of the
91 dump.
Q. 41. Was it larger when it was in the slope?
A. Yes, been a whole lot of it broke off.
Q. 42. You know who broke that?
A. IT guess the oad company broke it when they lifted it out
with the derrick, I don’t suppose anybody else would.
Q. 48. You don’t know who did that?
A. No, I don’t know who broke it, don’t know it was broke, of
course,
Q. 44. Now how long before this wreck had you noticed this
rock in that condition?
A. I noticed it every time I passed, just be walking along there.
Q. 45. How long a period of time before the wreck had you
noticed the rock in there in that position?
A. I don’t hardly know, been a right smart bit, for a year or
more kept springing out there a little all the time.
2 46. Show any change in position during the time you noticed
it?
A. Yes, sir, kept springing out, a man could tell that if he no
ticed it—I noticed it.
Q. 47. About how far above the level of the track was this rock
in the slope?
A. You mean from the “T” rail?
Q. 48. Yes.
A. Where it lay up in the cliff?
Q. 49. Yes.
A. Between eight and nine feet.
Q. 50. Above it?
A. Up on the cliff.
92 Q. 51. Was that on the right of way of the railroad com-
pany there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 52. Did you ever hear the railroad section foreman up there
say anything about the condition of that rock?
| A. Me and George Arthur when he was section foreman up there,
52 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. YS.
was talking a little about it, and he said he always kept somebody
to notice it of a bad night.
Q. 53. He said he always kept somebody to notice it of a bad
night and he was section foreman?
A. He was section foreman at that time, but he wasn’t section fore-
man there at the time it slipped in.
Cross-examination :
. 1. Where is George Arthur?
Well, sir, I guess he is under the ground?
2. Dead?
. Yes, sir.
3. You think that rock is close to ten feet long now, you say
Yes, sir.
. 4. And that it must have been longer when it was in the hill?
. Yes, sir, it was longer.
5. Because a portion of it has been broken off?
. Yes, sir,
. 6. And that it is about six feet wide?
Yes, sir, if laid in straight, right close to six feet.
7. And about two feet in thickness all the way through?
‘bout two feet thick from the looks of the rock, any way.
8. You could not tell how thick it was before it came out of
the cliff, could you?
93 A. No, sir, I could not tell how thick it was before it came
out, only at the upper end, don’t know how far it was back
in the cliff.
Q. 9. Laid back in the cliff, wasn’t it?
A. Back against the side of the cliff, right that way. It didn’t
lay in the cliff, laid right against the side of it.
Q. 10. Why couldn't vou tell how big it was?
A, If it had been out from under the dirt you could have told.
Q. 11. Then it was back in the cliff, wasn’t it?
A. Until it slipped out, it was.
Q. 12. How far did you say it was from the T trail as you call
it up to where this rock was?
A. Well, between eight and nine feet, laid right up against the
side of the cliff, didn’t lay up and down the cliff, laid right against
the side of the cliff.
Q. 13. Didn’t stand up on its end?
A. No sir.
Q. 14. Laid lengthwise.
A. Yes, sir, lengthwise. Laid back against the cliff—laid rather
right up on its long end, long side of it that way—(indicating) and
was covered by dirt and dropped down
Q. 15. Down this way?
A. No, sir.
Q. 16, And it had not fallen from the cliff?
A. No, just stood out there——
Q. 17. And that was a point eight or nine feet from the rail-
road track, up above?
D>OrOPOporoprore
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 538
>
: I suppose—my estimate, it would be eight or nine feet in the
cliff—straight up and down.
Q. 18. Which part of it could you see there in the cliff?
A. Which part of what?
19. Of this rock, could you see the end of it, couldn’t you?
. Yes, sir.
20. Where was the other end?
Back against the sliff, as I told you?
21. Under the ground?
. Back against the side of the cliff?
22. Back in the cliff?
No, it wasn’t in the cliff—if it had been in the cliff, it wouldn’t
fallen
25. Didn’t you say before that it was in the cliff?
A. No, sir, I didn’t.
Q. 24. I am reading the transcript from the notes of the stenog-
rapher taken on the other trial. [I will ask you if this question
wasn't asked you and if you didn’t make this answer ;—TI am going
to read the official stenographer’s report of vour testimony on the
former trial. Wasn't this question asked you, and didn’t you make
this answer: “Q. 27. Which part of it could vou see? A. One end.
Q. 28. It had two ends? A. Yes, sir. Q. 29. Where was the other
end? A. Under the ground. Q. 30. Back in the cliff? A. —. Q.
81. That rock was part of the formation of the cliff, wasn’t it? A.
Of course. It gave away from that cliff as a matter of course.”
Wasn't those questions asked vou before and didn’t you make those
answers just as | have read them to vou?
A. How is that?
Q. 25. So T have to read them again to you, do I? T will read
them again and I want you to pay close attention. Ws gt you asked
this question and didn’t you make this answer “Q. 27. Which part
of it could you see? (Meaning the rock) A. One Sis
A. Yes, sir
95 Q. 26. And then wasn't this question asked you, “Q. 28.
It had two ends?” and didn’t you make this answer, “Yes,
sir,”? “Q. 29. Where was the other end? A. Under the ground?
Q. 30. Back in the cliff? A. Yes, back there, of course. Q. 31
That rock was part of the formation of the cliff, wasn’t it? —. Of
course, it give away from that cliff as a matter of course.” Were
those questions asked you and didn’t you make the answers that I
have just read to you? That is on the other trial of this case?
A. Back against the cliff-———
Q. 27. You can answer what T want to know by yes or no. On
the last trial, whether or not you made those answers, to those ques-
tions?
A. It was back against the cliff.
Q. 28 Then you don’t want to say whether you testified that
way at the other trial of this case or not, what I have read?
A. 1 told you it was right back against the side of the cliff, that
is the way it stood all the time, under the dirt—It didn’t stick in
the hard dirt.
SS
ipePperere ~
©
a=
oO
ond
54 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Q. 29. And wasn’t this question asked you before and didn’t
you make this answer;—“Q. 31. That rock was part of the forma-
tion of that cliff wasn’t it? A, Of course. . It give away from that.
cliff as a matter of course.” Wasn't that question asked you and
didn’t you make that answ a Were you not asked what I have read
to you ‘and did you not make those answers?
A. I have told you what I knew about the rock.
By the Court: Answer it yes or no?
A. Of course, I made some of them, I guess.
96 Q. 30. The end of it was under the ground any how,
wasn’t it? :
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 31. And to get under the ground didn’t it have to go back on
the cliff?
A. Back against the side of the cliff.
Q. 32. If it was back against the side of the cliff, wasn’t under
the ground was it?
A. Yes, one end of it. There is where it held.
Q. 33. One end of it was back under the cliff?
A. Against the cliff—of course there could be loose dirt on that
end—could be up against the cliff.
The witness FLoyp Scuump, being first duly sworn, testified as
follows to-wit:
Direct examination:
Q. 1. Where do you live?
A. Ashland.
Q. 2. What is your occupation?
A, Engineer.
Q. 3. For whom?
A. C. & O.
Q. 4. Were you on the train that was wrecked up here at England
hill cut in May 1910?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. What were you doing?
A. Fireing.
97 Q. 6. What kind a train was it?
A. Freight.
Q. 7. Double header, was it?
A. Double header.
Q. 8. You mean by that that there was two engines pulling the
train.
A. Two engines.
Q. 9. Which engine were you fireing?
A. Fireing the head engine.
Q. 10. Who was your engineer?
A. Diamond.
Q. 11. Who was engineer on the second engine?
A. Dwyer.
Q. 12. Richard Dwyer?
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 55
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 13. Who was his fireman?
A. Gayhart.
Q. 14. You were working for the Chesapeake & Ohio Railway
Company at that time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 15. Were these engines derailed there at England Hill cut
there, at that time?
A. Yes, sir.
2. 16. What caused that wreck?
A. A rock and slide on the track,
. 17. From the cut?
. From the cut.
18. What time of night was it?
About 1:25,
. 19. Was the train going down?
. Going west.
20. Where had it started from?
A. Shelby.
98 Q. 21. On its way to Ashland and Russell.
A. Russell.
Q. 22. When the train—the front engine, the one that you were
on, did it hit that rock?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 23. What did you do?
A. Jumped off.
Q. 24. What became of the second engine?
The second engine went towards the cut, towards the bank.
25. Which way did the front engine go?
. Went to the road
26. Which way did the front engine turn?
Towards the river.
27. Which was did the second engine turn?
A. Towards the hill, the second one didn’t turn over, left the
track that way.
Q. 28. It left the track, but wasn’t turned over?
A. No.
Q. 29. What became of Mr. Dwyer?
A. Why he got down by the side of the fire box and was killed.
Q. 30. And he was by the side of the fire box of the second en-
gine and was carried to Mr. Compton’s house and died there?
A. Yes, sir.
OPOPoOro
OPore>
Plaintiff at this point introduced in evidence Dr. Wigglesworth’s
mortality tables, showing the expectancy of life at 45 years of age
to be 23.92, and 48 years of age the expectancy of life is 24.77
years.
99 By the Court: The statement as to what the life tables
show as to the expectancy of life of the deceased, Richard
Dwyer, and his wife, is to be considered by you in connection with
the state of health and habits of the deceased and the plaintiff as to
hb. ss aa - " PAM EEE aE SRS
56 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
the probable duration of their lives and is to be considered for that
purpose only.
The foregoing was all the evidence offered or introduced by the
plaintiff in chief, and thereupon the defendant moved the Court to
peremptorily instruct the jury to find for it, to which motion the
plaintiff objected, and the Court upon consideration of said motion
and objection overruled said motion and sustained said objection,
to which ruling of the Court, the defendant excepted.
Thereupon the defendant introduced the following evidence to -
sustain the issue in its behalf. Tirst the witness, BARNEY WELLS, be-
ing first duly sworn testified as follows, to-wit:
Direct examination:
Q. 1. How old are you?
A. 44.
Q. 2. Where do you live now?
A. I live in South Catlettsburg, Hampton City, rather.
Q. 3. What is your occupation?
A. Section foreman.
Q. 4. For the Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Company?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. What comprises your section, what proportion of the road?
A. Six miles—for six miles of track.
100 Q. 6. From where?
A. From Big Sandy Junction, to mile post 6.
Q. 7. Does that Section include what is called the England Hill
cut?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 8. Were you in charge of that section in the year 1910, the
month of May, 1910?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 9. You remember the time of the derailment of a freight train
going towards Catlettsburg, from which Dwyer received injuries
which resulted in his death?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 10. In the England Hill Cut, now describe to the jury as near
as you can the formation of the England Hill cut.
A. Well, England Hill cut is about 300 feet long—that is the
cut is, and the cut on the left hand side is about—well, it runs all
the way from 5 to 15 feet high, and on the right hand it runs from
five to six feet, or may be seven feet high.
Q. 11. The right hand side, you are speaking of the right hand
side coming this way?
A. Yes, sir, river side.
Q. 12. The left hand side you speak of, that is the hill side?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 13. The height of the cut on the hill side runs from five to
fifteen feet?
A, Yes, sir, may be some places more, never measured it, fifteen
feet in heighth
nail 4 ™
Fe . . wed
4 yi |
ate eR spews & . <—
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 57
Q. 14. What is the character of the rock in that cut, in the hill
side?
A. Rock mostly all the way through there, it lays in seams, the
rock does—part slate/y rock and part hard rock, I don’t
101 know whether to call it lime stone, or lime sand stone, but it
is a pretty hard rock through, it lays in seams.
Q. 15. You say it lays in seams, how does the hard rock lay in
the hill, also the slately formation?
A. Well, it lays in the hill that way—(indicating)—with the
edge out that was.
Q. 16. The edge projecting out?
A. Yes.
Q. 17. You remember the rock that was taken away from the
track the morning after the derailment?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 18. That rock form a part of the cliff formation there in that
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 19. Whereabouts was that rock?
A. It was in the West end of the cut, towards Catlettsburg.
Q. 20. That is the end towards Catlettsburg?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 21. About how high up was it?
A. It was about seven feet from the top of the rail.
Q. 22. Describe to the jury just how that rock laid in the cliff.
A. Well, the rock laid in the cliff this way, (Indicating) with
its upper corner showing out, the dirt and slate rock on top this way
and under here was an air slack of material and it just crumbled from
that air slack
Q. 23. What were the dimensions of the rock?
A. I believe the rock would be about eight feet long, about four
feet wide and—about 18 inches thick, may be two feet.
102 Q. 24. You say I believe, that one corner of it projected
out?
A. Yes, one corner projected out.
Q. 25. That is, of the side of the cliff?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 26. That cliff is of a rocky formation, slately?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 27. Corner sticking out, that would be the way of it?
A. Yes sir,
Q. 28. Which corner projected out, the West corner or the east
corner?
A. East corner.
Q. 29. That the part that was coming out?
A. The east corner—that is the lower corner—that was the one
that showed.
Q 30. The East end is the end up the river?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 31. Underneath that, it projected back in the bill?
8—453
58 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
A. Yes, you couldn’t tell how far the rock laid back in the hill
until after it fell out.
Q. 32. This large rock, and if it was flat, it extended back into
the hill just as that shows it, this piece here shows it exactly? (In-
dicating. )
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 33. Now how often did you go through that cut?
A. Probably I went through twice a day. My work was all on
the East end nearly, but a short distance this way, wasn’t very much
work to do on the west end of the section, always worked East,—
Just East of the tool house I suppose, 500 feet may be, 1500 feet
West of the tool house.
103 Q. 34. What was the last trip you made through there
before the derailment?
A. The last time, I suppose I was through there, was about 5:15
in the evening.
Q. 35. I forgot to ask you, when you took charge of that sec-
tion?
A. I taken charge Septenabine 5th, or 6th, before this accident
happened in May.
Q. 36. You say you took charge September 5th, 1909?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 37. And this derailment occurred May 12th, 1910?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 38. You had been working there six or eight months at the
time of the derailment?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 39. And it was a part of your duties to look after the cuts?
A. Yes, sir.
4 40. And the condition of the rocks in them?
. Yes, sir.
41. ‘During that six or eight months had there been any fall-
ing of the rock on the track there?
A. No, sir, no rock hadn’t fallen, had I never seen it.
Q. 42. W hile section foreman, prior to the time of the derailment
were you ever on top of the cliff?
A. Yes, I was on the cliff, I couldn’t tell you just how many
times, had been there more than once all along on top of the cliff.
Q. 48. Any thing there to indicate to you that this rock in ques-
tion was not safe?
A. Not a thing.
104 Q. 44. What caused the rock to fall?
A. Well, sir, I took it the dirt on top of the rock being so
heavy, the air slack came in it about where this seam was, it got top
heavy and it dropped off.
Q. 45. Could you see that seam?
A. No, sir, you could tell there was a seam of rock, but there
wasn’t any openings in it.
Q. 46. You say the dirt on top kept coming down on the rock?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 47. Had it been raining any just before that?
, bine
we
‘
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 59
A. Yes, sir, had been raining some that night, a kind of drizzling
rain. .
Q. 48. You were there after the accident?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 49. Say whether or not there was any dirt on the track?
- A. Yes, sir, there was some dirt and small rock on the track.
Q. 50. Where did the dirt come from?
ie Some above the rock, and some below, right smart little pile
of it.
Q. 51. This heavy rock, was it struck by the train?
A. It was struck by the rear engine, I don’t think that the front
engine ever struck the big rock.
Q. 52. Was there another rock that fell out?
A. Yes, sir, but the small rock laid under the big one.
Q. 53. Both came out of the cliff?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 53. Did the small roek lav over the track?
A. Yes, sir, it was more of a slate rock than the other.
105 Cross-examination:
Q. 1. It was your business to look after the safety on the track on
the right of way for this space of six miles?
Yes, sir.
Q. 2. How many men help you in that work?
A. I believe I had five men at the time.
Q. 3. Five men?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 4. Did you notice this big rock in the side of the cut there as
you would pass through it?
A. Yes, sir, I noticed it, the part of the rock that was showing.
Q. 5. How many times did you notice it in passing through the
cut?
A. Well, practically every time I went through the cut, I would
notice it, noticed the rock in the cut every time I went through
there.
Q. 6. You looked at this rock every time you went through the
cut?
A. I don’t know that I looked at that one any more than the rest
of them, just noticed how the rocks were there ail the way through.
Q. 7. How are you enabled to remember about the position of this
rock in the fall?
A. Well, I know it fell, and naturally one would remember it,
have an accident like that he would remember it.
Q. 8. You went there after the accident?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 9. You say the end up the river was exposed ?
A. Yes, sir, it was showing, couldn’t see it all, could see the end
of it, East end, couldn't see the west end but the rock was show-
in
106 a 10. The rock was practically all back in the hill, hori-
zontally?
60 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. V8.
A. Yes, sir, back in the hill.
Q. 11. And considered a part of the ledge, or cliff there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 12. It was covered with dirt?
A. Yes, sir, and slate rock.
Q. 13. I understood you to say that dirt falling down on it, broke
it loose?
A. It was the dirt on top—I think the weight of the dirt on top
caused it to break loose,
Q. 14. Also dirt under the rock?
A. No, sir, no dirt under the rock.
Q. 15. The side of the rock was exposed?
A. Yes, a part of it.
Q. 16. How far was that rock projected over?
A. About a foot.
Q. 17. In going along the rail-road you could see this long rock
in the hill, projecting out about a foot, and this pretty heavy weight
on top of it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 18. What caused it to project out the way you say it did?
A. I couldn’t say unless it was that the slate and coal material
under it had air slacked and fell out.
Q. 19. Slate and coal under it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 20. What is the effect of the elements on slate and coal?
A. T couldn’t hardly say.
Q. 21. Air slack, or whatever you call it?
A, Air slacked slate will crumbly.
Q. 22. Cause it to crumble and wash out?
107 A. Yes, sir.
Q. 23. How long had vou noticed that this slate and coal
under this rock had been air slacking and crumbling?
A. Well, there wasn’t enough to notice it—wasn’t enough to notice
that it was falling at any time.
Q. 24. But it had fallen out from there, hadn’t it?
A. It had fell some, yes.
Q. 25. You say it was air slacked and kept crumbling out—it was
your judgment as you went along that it was air slacking and crumb-
ling a little?
A. I couldn’t see anything fall in the ditch to fill up the ditch,
wasn’t anything fell to amount to anything.
Q. 26. It kept crumbling all the time vou passed there?
A. T suppose it did. Wasn’t enough to fall in the diteh to amount
to anything.
Q. 27. What do you mean by not to amount to anything?
A. To fill the ditch so we would have to clean it out.
Q. 28. But there was some fell, enough for vou to notice it?
A. A small bit, didn’t enough fall to have to clean it out.
Q. 29. But any how it kept falling?
A. Yes, siz.
Q. 30. A little bit of stuff would fall?
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 61
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 31. ‘And you saw that it came from under this big rock?
A. I couldn’t tell the rock was giving away
Q. 32. Didn’t you say you noticed the crumbling under this big
rock, that it was coming from there?
A: Well, a small bit I said, not enough to have to clean the ditch
out.
Q. 33. How many times did that happen? How many times did
you notice that it had air slacked and that stuff had fallen down in
the ditch?
108 A. I couldn’t say.
Q. 24. Didn't you notice it off and on during all the time
you were passing through that cut?
A. I noticed, the rock, ves, sir.
Q. 35. Didn’t you notice the air slacking of this stuff under it?
A. Not enough to amount to anvthing, to have to clean the ditch
out during that time, under this rock, didn’t have to clean the ditch
out.
Q. 36. You testified in this case once before, didn’t you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 37. I will read—to vou from the official stenographer’s report
of that trial and ask vou if you wasn’t asked these questions on—the
other trial—and didn’t vou make these answers: “Q. 5. Would you
notice the rock when you passed there? A. Yes, sir. Q. 6. Ever
notice this rock when you passed there? A. I wouldn’t look at it
any more than the rest. Q. 7. You noticed the rock when you
passed? A. Yes, sir. Q. 8. You noticed the dirt coming from up
there? A. I noticed the air slack, some little bit, ves. Q. 9. It kept
crumbling all the time you passed there? A. Yes. Q. 10. Under
this rock? A. All along under this heavy rock, it would crumble.
Q. 11. That continued from the time you commenced up there until
it fell. A. O, no, IT couldn’t say it continued all the time.” Did you
answer those questions that way?
A. T suppose I did.
109 Q. 38. And that is a fact?
A. Yes, sir, that is a fact.
Q. 39. Now this air slacking process continues along in wet
weather as well as dry weather?
A. Yes, sir, if continues in dry weather as well as wet weather,
a continuous process,
Q. 40. Did you go up and sound this rock?
A. Yes, sir, I] was on this rock—more than once——
Q. 41. You was on this rock?
A. I was on this one and the rest of them, not all, of them, more
than once.
2. 42. When was that?
. T can’t say, some time before this accident happened.
Q 43. Considerable time before, wasn’t it?
A. 1 couldn’t say, just how long before.
Q. 44. How came you to go on this rock?
h.
62 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
A. I went up there to see if there was anything giving away on
top of the cut, from one end to the other.
Q. 45. Did you go on this particular rock? Why did you yo
on it?
A. I didn’t go on this particular rock any more than the rest.
Q. 46. You don’t remember whether you went on it or not?
A. Yes, sir, I was on it.
Q. 47. You was on this rock?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 48. How far were you from the track when you were up there?
A. I was just as close to the edge of it as I could get without going
over, on the steep part——
110 Q. 49. You were on the hill side, beyond the top of the
cut?
A. I was on the top of the cut.
Q. 50. You couldn’t see under the rock from there?
A. Not from the top, T couldn’t.
Q. 51. Could you see the rock at all from there?
A. From the top. .
Q. 52. Yes.
A. I could see the upper corner, sticking out, so that I could see
a small bit——
Q. 53. You noticed the upper corner of this rock, which was stick-
ing out? it was part of your business to take down rocks and other
material in cuts that might endanger the safety of the railroad?
A. Yes, sir, anything I thought was dangerous, my duty to take
it down.
Q. 54. But vou didn’t try to take this rock down?
A. No, sir, I thought this rock was safe.
Q. 55. I didn’t ask you that, I asked you if you tried to take it
down?
A. No, sir, I did not.
Q. 56. This England Hill cut was known as a dangerous cut wasn’t
it?
A. Well, there hadn’t been anything at all fallen since I had
taken charge, used to be dangerous——
Q. 57. Didn’t they keep a watchman for the cut?
A. Never kept any watchman
Q. 58, It was dangerous in May, 1910, wasn’t it?
A. It.was dangerous on that night, I don’t know
111 Q. 59. But it was known as a dangerous cut, wasn’t it?
A. Hadn't been any watchman there, wasn’t considered
dangerous.
Q. 60. Say whether or not it was known among the section hands
and the employes of the Company as being a dangerous cut?
A. Well, I couldn’t say.
Q. 61. You knew that stone and dirt had fallen out of this cut
before, didn’t you?
A. I knew it had fallen out before, yes, sir.
Q. 62. Several times before this accident.
A. Yes, sir.
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 63
Q. 63. What would have been the method, according to your in-
structions of getting that rock out of that slope?
A. We could have took a drill and went in and drilled a hole and
shot the rock out.
Q. 64. With dynamite?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 65. Wouldn’t have taken but a few minutes?
A. No, sir, wouldn’t have taken but a few minutes.
Q. 66. I believe you say there was a small rock that fell at the
same time that the large one did?
A. Small rock came out, laving there, don’t know that it fell just
at the same time, might have dropped before or later, it was there
with the large rock.
Q. 67. Both came down together?
A. Yes, sir, they were both together.
Q. 68. Just before vou took charge there as section foreman there
had been a bad slip in that cut, hadn’t there?
A. On the East end, I heard the men that worked for-me say,
sometime before I came, there had been a rock fall out on the East
end.
112. ~— Redirect examination:
Q. 1. The projection of the rock, where you speak of, you could
see, and had seen the corner of the rock there?
A. Just the corner projected out, yes, sir.
Q. 2. You went over all the cliff, you went over the top of
it from one end to the other?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. And over all the rocks, in connection with your examina-
tion of the cut, the hill side?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 4. This crumbling you speak of in the side of the cut, was
a gradual crumbling away?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. That was true. through the whoie cliff?
A. Yes. sir, no more on this one than the rest of them.
Q. 6. That happens in any cliff with a formation of that kind?
| i | aa
Q. 7. And this crumbling had not been sufficient to fill up the
ditch before this accident, was it?
A. No, sir.
Q. 8. Or the ditch had not heen opened, cleaned out?
A. No, sir.
The witness, James McGuire, being first duly sworn, testified
as follows, to-wit:
Direct examination:
Q. 1. What is your age?
A. 43,
Q. 2. Where do you live?
Se
64 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
A. Ashland, Kentucky.
113 Q. 3. What is your present occupation?
A. Section foreman, Ashland Yards.
Q. 4. Section foreman in the Ashland Yards?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 5. In May, 1910, what were you doing?
A. Supervisor of Track, Big Sandy Division.
Q. 6. That embraces what is known as the England Hill cut?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. The cut in which the derai!ment occurred which resulted
in the death of Mr. Dwyer?.-
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 8. How long had you been Supervisor of Track of the Big
Sandy Division.
A. About two years.
Q. 9. In the performance of your duties as Supervisor did you
or not pass up and down the river on the track of the Chesapeake
& Ohio Railway Company?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 10. And through this cut, how often?
A. Why, three or four times a week.
Q. 11. Did you notice the England Ui'l evt on those trips that
you made?
A. Yes, sir, I looked at it as I went through there.
Q. 12. You know the character and formation of the rocks in
that cliff?
A. A little bit, yes, sir.
Q. 13. How were they—how did they rocks lay in the hill?
A. The rocks laid on a level, horizontally in the nill.
Q. 14. Flat ways?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 15. Ledges of rock?
A. Yes, sir.
114 Q. 16. Did you ever walk along through the cut, or did
you ride through on a train?
A. Rode through on a train, and walked through the cut too.
Q. 17. Did you notice that cliff and the sides of it—the rocks
in the hill—that is ne .» the hill—notice this rock?
A. Yes, sir, I have 1 © ced it.
Q. 18. Was there anything to indicate to you that this rock in
question that fell down was dangerous?
A. No, sir.
Q. 19. Did you see that rock after it fell?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 20. What was the size of it?
A. Why, it was about 8 feet long and 4 feet wide, and about
20 inches thick, along near about that.
Q. 21. How soon did you get there after the accident?
A. I got there about six o’clock the next morning.
Q. 22. What was on the track the next morning, I mean (hat
came out of the hill side?
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 65
A. Rock and dirt.
Q. 23. Have you a judgment as to how that rock came to fall
out of the hill—what caused it, to fall out of the hill?
A, It slipped from the top of the bank, pulled the rock ut.
Q. 24. The dirt pulled it out?
A. Yes, sir, the dirt back of the rock pushed it out.
Q. 25. How much dirt was there on that track at that time?
A. There was about two feet.
115 Cross-examination :
Q. 1. You were Supervisor of Track from Ashland to Elkhorn
City?
A. No, sir, from Hampton Junction.
Q. 2. About 118 miles?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. You didn’t give any particular attention to these different
euts?
A. I noticed them very closely to see if there was any danger,
yes, sir.
Q. 4. Hundreds of cuts in that distance?
A. Yes, sir, quite a lot of them.
Q. 5. You never made any particular examination of this eut?
A. I didn’t particularly examine it. No, sir, I didn’t.
Q. 6. But you seen this rock in there that fell?
A. I don’t know as I noticed this particular rock that fell, I no-
ticed the rocks in there.
Q. 7. I believe this cut had a number of rocks in it, a ledge of
rocks through it?
A. The rocks laid in there flat ways. Yes, sir, a ledge of rocks.
Q. 8. You are just speaking of the rocks generally that laid in
there, you don’t know if this rock was loose or not?
A. No, sir, I don’t.
Q. 9. How was it laid in the hill?
A. It laid flat ways in the hill.
Q. 10. How do you know?
A. All of them did.
Q. 11. Was there a rock over this one?
A. I can’t say if there was a rock over this particular rock or
not.
116 Q. 12. You say it was a part of a ledge of rocks? ‘oO
A. Yes, sir, it was on top—in this ledye—— :
Q. 13. This was on top, of the ledge—this rock?
A. Near the top of the cut, yes, sir.
Q. 14. Any rock over it?
A. 1 can’t say positively there was or not.
Q. 15. Well, how do you know it was a part of a ledge unless
you know that there was rock under it and another rock over it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 16. Wasn't there slate and coal under it?
A. There was some kind of a formation under there, I don’t
know what it is.
9—453
66 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Q. 17. Was it a slatey substance—or a slate rock?
A. Slatey substance next to the bottom of the cut.
Q. 18. And next to this rock that fell out?
A. I couldn’t say.
Q. 19. And you don’t know if there was rock under it or not?
A. Rock under it, I can’t say right exactly under the rock, dirt
or rock, might be a few inches of dirt between that rock and an-
other rock.
. 20. What was on top of this rock, dirt or other stuff?
Up the bank was dirt. Yes, sir.
21. Right next to it?
. I can’t say.
22. You don’t know what was by the side of it?
. No.
23. You don’t remember if it was a part of a ledge, or a loose
rock lying in that slope, you just gave your judgment generally—
and you don’t know how this particular rock was loose or not?
A. [I couldn’t say it was loose. No, sir.
Q. 24. You don’t remember ever seeing this particular rock?
A. No. IT don’t know as I did.
ROPePrOrEe
117 Q. 25. Never saw it at all except as you passed through
in the train, from the rear end of the train?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 26. Going 25 or 30 miles an hour?
A. I don’t know if it was going that fast or not.
Q. 27. That is the only inspection you gave it as you went
through on the rear end of the train?
A. Yes, sir.
Redirect examination:
Q. 1. You saw it after it had slipped from the hill side?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 2. Slides there where the rock came down?
A. Yes, sir, back of the rock,
Q. 3. You saw that cut the next morning and the slip in the
hillside?
A. Yes, sir.
The witness, L. B. ALLEN, being first duly sworn, testified as
follows, to-wit:
Direct examination :
Q. 1. Where about are you located at present?
A, At Huntington, West Virginia. F
Q. 2. Where were you located in 1910? .
A. I was in Ashland—I was Division Engineer of the Ashland
and Big Sandy Division, and was also Engineer of Maintenance of
the Western Division.
Q. 3. Did you have charge of the track as Civil Engineer from
Ashland up the Big Sandy?
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 67
118 A. Yes, sir.
Q. 4. What time did you leave that portion of the road?
A. May Ist, 1910.
Q. 5. That was just twelve days previous to the time of this acci-
dent?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 6. How long had you had charge of that Division?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. What is your profession?
A. Civil Engineer.
Q. 8. Are you acquainted with the cuts on the Big Sandy Divis-
ion?
A. Yes, sir, I have a general knowledge of the Big Sandy Division
from one to the other.
Q. 9. That knowledge includes what is known as England Hill
Cut?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 10. Describe to the jury the character of that cut?
A. Well, it is a rocky cut about 15 feet deep on the upper side,
and 4 or 5 feet on the lower side and is a cut some six or seven hun-
dred feet long.
Q. 11. Now what about the cliff on the hill side, that is with ref-
erence to the slope?
A. Well, it is an ordinary rock cut with a slope of—Well, between
one foot and four, and two feet and four, just an ordinary rock slope
cliff-——
Q. 12. Was or not the slope the usual slope given for a slope of
that kind, where the formation is such as that is, a rock cliff?
A. Yes, sir.
119 Q. 13. These kinds of cuts necessarily have rocks pro-
jecting out from the sides of them at times?
A. Yes, more or less rocks projecting out
Q. 14. Impossible to make them out without having them that
way is it not?
A. Yes, sir.
~ Q. 15. For how long and how often had you seen England Hill
eut prior to the time vou left that Division?
A. T went up that Division on an average once a week, passing
back and forth through that cut. |
Q. 16. In passing through it would you notice it and look at it?
A. Yes, sir. I always observed the cuts and the general character
of the road all the way along. That was a part of my duties.
Q. 17. On the sides of the cliff next to the hill—anything there
that indicated that there was any danger there of any rock falling
out?
A. I never noticed any particular danger, or any special feature
that that would call any particular attention to it.
Q. 18. As a matter of fact any thing in the hill side that would
indicate any danger, in connection with any rock?
A. No more than the usual cuts, rock cuts.
68 THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY CO. VS.
Cross-examination :
Q. 1. What did you say your official title was?
A. Division Engineer—Engineer of Maintenance of Way, at the
time the accident occurred, Just previous to that I had been Division
Engineer, had charge of all the track men and track forces and the
road bed in general.
120 Q. 2. In the performance of your duties you rode up and
down the Big Sandy river on the railroad trains?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 3. You,never stopped at England Hill cut?
A. I have walked through England Hill cut a number of times-
Don’t remember of any special time though.
Q. 4..That was several years before this accident, wasn’t it?
A. No. No, sir. Might have been a month before. I couldn’t
tell.
Q. 5. In fact wasn’t it a year or so before this accident since you
had been in this cut, walking?
A. My best judgment is I had been through that cut within two
months previous to this accident, couldn’t give the time exactly.
Q. 6. Walking?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. 7. And other times, most of the time you rode through on a
train?
A. Various times T would get off the train and examine the tracks.
Get off and walk between stations.
Q. 8. When was that?
A. I say; I can’t tell, don’t remember—don’t recall now, don’t
remember any one particularly.
Q. 9. You don’t know that you ever did—Don’t you know that
it is a fact that you did not?
A. No. I know I walked—I am confident I did.
Q. 10. The next station above that cut is Lockwood, ain’t it?
A. There is Savage Branch in there.
Q. 11. That is about four or five miles above this cut?
A. Yes, sir.
121 Q. 12. And the next one this way to the cut would be
Hampton City?
A. Yes.
Q. 13. And then you would have to walk seven or eight miles?
A. That is not far I walk that very often.
Q. 14. Is it customary for those who are designated as Engineer
of Maintenance of Way to make walks to seven or eight miles be-
tween stations?
A. Yes, sir, that is part of his business.
Q. 15. And more often don’t they ride in the parlor car or the
Pullman car?
A. No, sir.
Q. 16. Did you notice this rock that fell that the witnesses say
was loose in the side of the slope?
A. I didn’t notice that particular rock, no, sir.
PIOMEREL LLL EGIL OE PERE NT ee Tae steey Sate ge cence a
JAMES R. GAINEY, JR., ETC. 69
Q. 17. If the rock was sticking out from the slope—the side of
the cliff—six or eight inches, from the main body of the cliff, and
there had been an erosion by air slacking, and sufficient material
had come out from under it until it was projecting over the slope a
foot or more, would that indicate to you that there was any danger
of it falling?
A. No, sir.
Q. 18. Would not?
A. No.
Q. 19. Is there any condition of a rock in a slope that would indi-
cate to you that it was dangerous?
A. Why, yes, of course there is.
Q. 20. What would that be?
A. If the rock was entirely loose and attached to the slope
and was showing signs of settling under the foundation and if. the
rock had moved and was off of the foundation and was liable to fall
from any pressure, put on it—that would indicate the rock
122. ~—s was _ dangerous.
Q. 21. The fact that it projected out over a piece and was
loose from the main part of the slope, wouldn’t indicate any danger
to your main at all?
A. No, if the rock was sticking out, it would not be any more
likely to fall than a cope stone—W ouldn’t fall simply because it pro-
jected out a little.
Q. 22. If there was the weight of other rock and stone and stuff
on the rock in question and there was gradual erosion under it, say
the rock was out—from. the cliff six or eight inches, as much as 12
inches, as stated by Mr. Wells would that indicate to you that there
was any danger at all? _
A. If it was known that dirt and stuff above the rock was loose,
and there was any signs of that moving, generally it might be well
to look after it.
Q. 23. Suppose that there wasn’t none, but a gradual crumbling
of the material under
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.