Transcript of Record — Seaboard Air Line R. Co. v. Horton
Supreme Court brief1916
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(24,824)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1915.
No. 541.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,
, v8.
JAMES T. HORTON.
IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NORTH
CAROLINA.
INDEX
: Original. Print
SO GOO BO WEI OF GEOR. 26.0 ei cece es stevcenccnensccnce 1 1
3 er ND MAUL Ge MUN oss os na dindd oe cae owes vakene 3 2
P ’ Assignment of errors and prayer for reversal................. 4 2
MeWeit Of CLTOF.... 0.2... eee e cece eee e eee cere cet neeee seen eees 33 20
Mepaitation and service..............ceceeeeceeccesscee seen ceees 36 21
MEE ME GUO sic ssc ne dupe ss dnc voben shinndenscaaveces 38 22
4 Transcript of record from the superior court in and for the
ee eas Sika iibeish cde tsesinnkes seated 40 28
CUS nic leben sche Pie aA iu 06h 0.06e serge sav sang oo 40 23
Summons for relief..........0.ccsccscccseresececccecsees 40 23
ne aed Wi wb Seg fh oe Rb ENS MED 41 24
- Return on SuMMONBS....\.........- 6c eee e cece eee eee eene 41 24
nya Gh tes webnianst eee yr orersesecee unt e 42 24
NES Slr sb ara gs Wisc of sa ¢ v0.0,0 0:0 by BM Ope hw aie Sih 'e¥, O09, 6 bie 45 27
EPEC E GREE EEC CTCL ECE EO POLE 48 28
EEE OO COMDDIRINE, 6. ccc acc sev einevecswsinpecs 51 31
Answer to amendment to complaint..............+00e00ees 52 31
PE IE 55 6 civ. 40b Ex oo a wa be oo hoo bap apiesia-e's 52 31
_ Jupp & Derwetter (INc.), Printers, W..sHINGTON, D. C., OcToBER 27, 1915.
INDEX,
EE, SEAM a Ur 4 04 Rs CR OO UNE A si ebe nb 6b Rakb Fee Hele e 3
a Oe dip
CE ODES farwitl cs is FE AS SEs abn aden taeeauresaneeee
EL G6 cha og te ks Wald SO RW ROR Oe Kesd.ok 6 S00 Chae Eee
nS I I aS a sa wai deg as baldlae koe wba) Ghee ds
eh Per I a ick s £4 oon be EE ES KE ROR RE OO eS
Order overruling motions to set avide verdict and for new
UREA OA sid RUE Chas oe ae WEE NOS % 0:60.46 oom ewes ee
Defendant's statement of case on appeal..............066-
PUGS OL PMO Es BEORTOMR s ciis-tcc cc cecssees sede
James T. Horton (recalled).............
CSG es RE SP = 2 gre aera era
el TE Sie is hie Kee bak 6 dbo s odie eeinne
ee MS ne 8k ae <b 0k 6b eae eA ees
Powhatan BE. Matthews. ......ccceccccce
BOURNE VV eehie tee ieoscenseaces
TE si 5 ekki cpadwiee see's
ey IA PREP eeeinrera ett ree area
BEN Ue MEIN 7 6. 6.54 oh 0 oe orale eeiaed er 6
NN Oe wis ee orks diet nae eb abecws
i Osler ie bred bs eens neohe ‘
a ie NG ho Gl osi'a.6 &b,K's de 0S a cos.ais
w. T. DUNE B54 SRE MAA EA Ree UK Rcne Ran
rr es gas kab Ue odes es cceeeee
James T. Horton (recalled).............
RE EINES iia 8 6 oid 6:0-0'656:4.6 eo kidree cab
Dr. R. H. Lewis (recalled)..........0.0.
Exhibits C, D, E, and F—Reports by Horton as to con-
nh ee ING FR Oe os 6 6. kb Waicicauwasts ba.vcmige
Exhibit G—Certificate of J. T. Horton as to hearing,
NE Uisie yh bik rad 6a 0 eiwikiee a ebcelelas
H—Report of accident by R. H. Lewis, surgeon
I—Statement of J. T. Horton as to injury....
Defendant’s request for instructions. ...............45
i CE OY SR io Sa ius pwd ahh. newi ad dee uses seve
Motion for new trial for newly discovered evidence. .
EGNGTE OF TEMTOGS (ATMO io oii icici ccic heccsiesens ‘
Order overruling motion to set aside verdict and tor * a
PE OME Eek ve 8s hae ee KOT Rie eb ees we PO er ere
Exceptions and assignments of error............+.06.
Stipulation as to statement of the case................
ME SUNN fia cede G's Leiarele'o 0 Uaw ie e:ka ae davies k400 6b RED
Rene GUE TON, WODTOING COUEC. 6 vice cece bes cvcicccecsceseees
I SER Ordeal c's kde Och aes Ke Weds eeeeaekee wexenereas
I ing RURUNONINIDS 5 <a'c.6 <.6)0.b ewe cl s'e'e oes coacerssegas
EEG 5. io ce ankbhedbedecteveuy ceuned
CE Ace Pais oa specane kas adeantedianesev ned Aer er é
Clerk’s certificate ...........0.. RUNS hcg Ve aivawee wee hi
Original. Print
52
53
53
Sk&eesess
FSRSRSSESSREE
RRZFRSz2SSS
<<
~~
102
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 1
1 In the Supreme Court ea Carolina, Spring Term,
1915.
No. 257.
James T. Horton
vs.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY.
Petition for Writ of Error.
To the Honorable Walter Clark, Chief Justice of the Supreme
Court of North Carolina:
Your petitioner, Seaboard Air Line Railway, a corporation of the
State of Virginia, North Carolina and other states, respectfully
shows:
This was a suit brought by James T. Horton, an employee of the
Seaboard Air Line Railway, to recover damages for personal injury
under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, enacted by Congress
of the United States, April 22, 1908, and the amendments thereto.
At the trial in the Superior Court of Wake County, issues were
submitted to the jury and answered as follows:
1. Was the plaintiff injured by the negligence of the defendant,
as alleged in the complaint?
Answer. “Yes.”
2. If so, did the plaintiff assume the risk of injury?
Answer. ‘‘No.”
3. Did plaintiff, by his own negligence, contribute to his injury?
Answer. “No.”
4. What damages, if any, is the plaintiff entitled to recover?
Answer. “$4,500.” ston
From the judgment rendered upon said verdict in favor of the
plaintiff for the sum of $4,500.00 and the costs of the action de-
fendant appealed to the Supreme Court of North Carolina:
2 That the Supreme Court of North Carolina, which is the
highest Court in the State of North Carolina, in which a de-
cision in the said action could be had, at the February Term, 1914,
of said Court, to-wit, on the 12th day of May, 1915, rendered judg-
ment adverse to this petitioner, and aflirming the judgment of said
Superior Court of Wake County. ;
That in the proeeedin had and judgment rendered, certain er-
rors were committed to the prejudice of the petitioner, all of which
more fully appears in the assignment of errors filed herewith.
That the cause of action set forth in the complaint and defense
thereto set up in the answer of the plaintiff in error, arose under the
statutes of the United States, to-wit the act regulating, governing
and controlling the liability of a railroad engaged in interstate com-
merce to an employee who receives an injury or is killed while em-
1—541
2 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON,
ployed in such commerce, approved by Congress, April 22, 1908,
and usually referred to as the Federal Employers’ Liability Act.
That the errors complained of in this petition, and more fully set
forth in the assignment of errors accompanying this petition, are,
that the Supreme Court of North Carolina decided against the rights
set up and claimed by your petitioner under the Federal Employ-
ers’ Liability Act in that instructions to the jury were given which
were objected to by your petitioner, which denied your petitioner
the constructions of said act, to which it was entitled, and in that
your petitioner's motion for judgment of nonsuit was denied, and
that incompetent evidence was admitted over petitioner’s objection
and exception, and your petitioner was in other ways in the trial
of said action deprived of its rights under said Federal Employers’
Liability Act, as more fully appears in the assignment of errors filed
herewith,
Therefore, considering itself aggrieved by the final decision of the
Supreme Court of North Carolina in rendering judgment against
it in the above entitled case, your petitioner hereby prays that a
writ of error may issue from the Supreme Court of the United
3 States to the Supreme Court of North Carolina for the cor-
rection of the errors complained of; that an order may be
entered fixing the amount of the supersedeas bond herein; that a
duly authenticated transcript of the record and proceedings herein
in said Supreme Court of North Carolina may be sent to the Su-
preme Court of the United States, and that the decision and judg-
ment of the Supreme Court of North Carolina may be reversed and
annulled.
Assignment of Errors herewith filed.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY, [seau.]
By MURRAY ALLEN,
Attorney for Seaboard Air Line Railway.
Strate or Nortu CAROLINA, 88:
Let the writ of error issue upon the execution of a bond by the
Seaboard Air Line Railway in the Sum of Seven Thousand Dollars;
such bond when approved to act as a supersedeas. Dated June 23,
1915.
WALTER CLARK,
Chief Justice Supreme Court of North Carolina.
4 In the Supreme Court of North Carolina, Spring Term, 1915.
No, 257.
James T. Horton
vs.
SEABOARD Arr LINE RaAILway.
Assignment of Errors and Prayer for Reversal.
This is an action brought by James T. Horton against Seaboard
Air Line Railway to recover damages for personal injury received
ee
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 3
by the explosion of a water glass on an engine on the line of rail-
road of the Seaboard Air Line Railway, while he was employed on
one of the freight trains of said Railway as an engineer. It was
alleged in the complaint and admitted by the defendant that at the
time of said explosion of the water glass and injury to the plaintiff,
both the defendant and plaintiff were engaged in interstate com-
merce, and plaintiff brought his action specifically under the Em-
ployers’ Liability Act, passed and approved by the Congress of the
United States on the 22nd day of April, 1908, and the amendments
thereto. The evidence also established facts sufficient to bring the
action within the provisions of said Act.
Now comes the Seaboard Air Line Railway, plaintiff in error,
and files herewith its petition for writ of error and says that there
are errors in the record and proceedings in the above entitled cause,
and, for the purpose of having the same reviewed in the United
States Supreme Court, makes the following assignments of error:
1. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, a statute of
the United States, approved by Congress on the 22nd day of April,
1908, especially in the construction of Sections 1, 3, 4 and 5.
2. For that by these errors the Supreme Court of North
5 Carolina decided against the rights set up and claimed by
your petitioner under the said statute and denied to your
petitioner a correct construction, interpretation and application of
the provisions of said statute.
3 For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina committed error
in sustaining the trial court in overruling certain contentions made
by plaintiff in error asserting a construction of the Federal Em-
ployers’ Liability Act, approved by Congress, April 22nd, 1908,
which, if acceded to, would presumably have produced a verdict in
favor of plaintiff in error, and consequent immunity from the
action.
4. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina committed error
in affirming the judgment in this case, because it denied to the
plaintiff in error, Seaboard Air Line Railway, the right, privilege
or immunity of being governed in respect of the right of defendant
in error to recover in this action solely by the Constitution of the
United States, Section 8, Article 1, and the Act of Congress, ap-
roved April 22nd, 1908, known as the Federal Emplovers’ Lia-
ility Act, as properly construed and in adjudging the liability of
plaintiff in error by an erroneous construction of Section 1. of said
Act, thereby denying to Seaboard Air Line Railway the right,
privilege or immunity aforesaid, which it duly and specially set
up in this proceeding.
_ 5. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred and
its decision was against the rights set up and claimed by your
, petitioner under Section 1 of the said act of Congress, because of
the holdings of the Supreme Court of North Carolina in construing
| certain instructions given and refused upon the first issue submitted
to the jury, to-wit: Was the plaintiff injured by the negligence of
i ti as or Baton
4 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
the defendant as alleged in the complaint, which said errors are
hereinafter more particularly set forth.
6. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
6 and its decision was against the rights set up and claimed by
plaintiff in error under Section 4 of the said Federal Em-
ployers’ Liability Act, approved by Congress of the United States
on April 22nd, 1908, because of the holdings of the Supreme Court
of North Carolina, because of certain instructions given and certain
requests for instruction by plaintiff in error, which were refused,
and because of certain incompetent evidence admitted upon the
second issue submitted to the jury, to-wit: If so, did the plaintiff
assume the risk of injury? which said errors are hereinafter more
particularly set forth.
7. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred and its
decision was against the rights set up and claimed by plaintiff in
error under Section 3 of said Federal Employers’ Liability Act
approved by Congress of the United States, April 22, 1908, because
of the holdings of the Supreme Court of North Carolina in con-
struing this act and because of certain instructions given and cer-
tain requests for instruction by plaintiff in error, which were refused,
upon the third issue submitted to the jury, to-wit: Did the plaintiff
contribute to his injury by his negligence as alleged in the answer?
which said errors are hereinafter more particularly set forth.
8. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the follow-
ing testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s objection
and exception:
“T told Powie Matthews that the guard glass was gone, and asked
if he had any of them. He was the day roundhouse foreman and
he said no, hey did not have any here.”
This is defendant’s Exception No. 1.
9. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in permit-
ting plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s objection and exception
to testify that defendant’s roundhouse foreman told him, “No, they
did not have any (guard glasses) here (in Raleigh).”
7 This is defendant’s Exception No. 2.
10. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
in holding that the trial court did not commit error in admitting
the following testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s
objection and exception :
Q. What did you say to Powhatan Matthews?
Objection by defendant.
By the Court: To any statement as to the water glass, the defend-
ant objects. Objection overruled.
Defendant excepts.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 3.
11. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the fol-
lowing testimony of the plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s
objection and exception.
ete
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 5
Q. State to the jury why you ran that engine out on the second
trip without the guard glass in, Mr. Horton.
‘A. Because I was promised I would have a guard glass when
I returned, Mr. Matthews told me, and I was told to run her and I
had to do it.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 4.
12. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in referring to the
answer to the foregoing question, making the following statement
and admitting testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, as follows:
By the Court: Strike out what he was promised by Matthews, that
part of it is tricken out, as that was a conclusion. You san say I
ran it because of the conversation I had with Matthews.
A. That is right.
By the Court: All of the answer is stricken out and I will permit
him to say I ran it on account of the conversation with Matthews.
Objection by defendant. Objection overruled.
Defendant excepts.
8 This is defendant’s Exception No. 5,
13. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
in holding that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the
following testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s
objection and exception :
Q. I will ask you this question : State to the jury whether you in
your present condition in respect to the sight of your right eye are
sa * capable to operate a locomotive engine?
. No.
This is defendant’s exception No. 6.
14. For that the Suprome Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the
following testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s
objection and exception:
Q. Why?
A. On account of the condition of my right eye, impaired eye
sight.
This is defendant’s Exception No. a
15. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the
following testimony of plaintiff, J. ‘I. Horton, over defendant’s
objection and exce tion :
Q. What reply did they make to you, if any?
Objection by defendant.
By the Court: It is not a question of the reply, but whether he
could secure employment.
By Mr. Douglass: State, Mr. Horton, if you failed to get employ-
ment with the Seaboard Air Line Railway on account of the cou-
dition of your eye sight.
Objection by defendant. Objection overruled.
Exception.
A. Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 8.
6 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
9 16. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
in holding that the trial court did not commit error in ad-
mitting the following testimony of plaintiff, .. T. Horton, over de-
fendant’s objection and exception:
Q. You said something about handing in a large list of repairs
to be done to the engine on the day before this injury to your eye?
ee
Q. Did they do the work?
A. Not a bit of it. I believe they did open the sand pipes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 9.
17. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in a4mitting the follow-
ing testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s objection
and exception :
Q. Was it your duty under the rules of this company to put the
missing gauge glass on that work report?
A. All that is necessary is to get a requisition and put it in.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 10.
18. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in
holding that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the
following testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s
objection and exception:
Q. Was that repair within the rule requiring it to be in writing?
A. No, it is a supply.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 11.
19. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the
following testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant's
objection and exception :
10 Q. Is there any rule requiring a written report for a
supply?
No
This is defendant’s Exception No. 12.
20. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the fol-
lowing testimony of plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s objection
and exception, and making the following statement:
Q. I ask you if it was a proper thing for an engineer to do?
Objection by the defendant.
Q. Compare to the jury, if you can, the danger or safety of run-
ning an engine with the water glass closed and with the gauge cocks,
depending upon the gauge cocks, and running without a shield on
the water glass?
Objection by the defendant. Objection sustained for the reason
that this has been — over on both the direct and cross examinations.
By Mr. Simms: Does your Honor understand that it is in the
record that it is more dangerous to attempt to run it with the gauge
cocks than with the water glass?
By the Court: Yes, he said that, because they would stop up.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 13.
21. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
—
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY vs. JAMES T. HORTON. 7
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting and
refusing to strike out the following testimony of plaintiff, J. T.
Horton, over defendant’s objection and exception:
Q. The Court says you may explain why you told Mr. Burrus you
did not report that guard glass for reasons best known to yourself.
A. He asked me why I did not put it on my work report
11 and the reason was because I had been to some one higher
than him and he said he did not have any. Mr. Matthews
was higher than—over Mr. Burrus.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 14.
29. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in up-
holding the trial court in the refusal to strike out the foregoing
testimony upon defendant’s motion.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 15.
23 For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in permitting the plain-
tiff, James T. Horton, to be recalled and testify as follows:
Q. State to the jury what you meant in your cross examination
by saying that you could run an engine as good as you ever could?
A. I meant T knew as much about an engine mechanically as
I ever did, but I could not see to run it.
This is defendant’s Exception No, 16.
24. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the fol-
lowing testimony by plaintiff's witness, Dr. W. C. Horton, over
defendant’s objection and exception:
Q. When he went up there for examination, he told you how
his eye got hurt?
A. I think he did. I don’t remember what he said, but it seems
to me it was an explosion of some kind—I am not sure about that.
This is defendant’s Exception No, 17.
25. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the fol-
lowing testimony by J. A. Massey, a witness for the plaintiff, over
defendant’s objection and exception :
12 I think I know what the custom and practice was when sup-
plies were needed by engineers on their engines.
Q. What was it?
A. The man in the store room furnished the supplies upon
requisition. The requisition was brought to him, and it had either
to be signed by the Master Mechanic, General Foreman, or the
Foreman.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 18.
26. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of Sections 1, 3 and 4 of the Federal
Employer’s Liability Act, and in holding that the trial court did
not commit error in overruling defendant’s motion for judgment of
nonsuit at the conclusion of plaintiff's evidence.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 19.
27. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not coramit error in excluding, over
|
8 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
defendant’s objection and exception, the followin i
a — Powhatan Matthews: ee
ow wou t have been supplied if there w guard
glass in stock? ess pes
This is defendant’s Exception No. 20.
_ 28. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over
defendant's objection and exception, the following quer ‘on asked
defendant's witness, Powhatan Matthews:
What could have been done?
This is defendant’s Exception No. 21.
29. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over
defendant’s objection and exception, the following question asked
defendant’s witness, Powhatan Matthews:
Q. Are the water gauge and water cocks part of the engine that
should be inspected by the engineer?
13 This is defendant’s Exception No. 22.
30. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in
holding that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over
defendant’s objection and exception, the following question- asked
defendant’s witness, Powhatan Matthews:
Q. Did you ever tell Mr. Horton to run his engine like she was
and you would send to Portsmouth and get a guard glass for the
Buckner gauge.
A. I don’t remember telling him that.
Q. Would you not know whether you told him that or not?
This is defendant's Exception No, 23.
31. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over
defendant’s objection and exception, the following question asked
defendant’s witness, D. K. Wright:
Q. Did you ever operate an engine that had no gauge glass on it?
This is defendant’s Exception No. 24.
32. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over de-
fendant’s objection and exception, the following question asked
defendant’s witness, D. K. Wnght:
Q. If anything should happen to the gauge glass, what is the
duty of the engineer?
This is defendant’s Exception No. 25.
23. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over
defendant’s objection and exception, the following question asked
defendant’s witness, W. 8S. Burrus:
Q. If an engineer is employed or discharged by the Seaboard,
what officer has control of it?
his is defendant’s Exception No. 26.
a 34. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
14 in holding that the trial court did not commit error in ex-
cluding, over defendant’s objection and exception, the follow-
ing question asked defendant’s witness, W. S. Burrus:
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 9
Q. Would the notice of the dismissal of an engineer come through
your office?
This is defendant’s Exception No. 27.
35. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over de-
fendant’s objection and exception, the following question asked
defendant’s witness, W. S. Burrus:
Q. Had Mr Horton’s employment as an engineer ceased?
This is defencant’s Exception No, 28.
36. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in holding
that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over de-
fendant’s objection and exception, the following question asked de-
fendant’s witness, W. S. Burrus:
Q. When did you request Mr. Horton to return his pass and other
property of the Seaboard Air Line Railway, if you did?
By the Court: You want to show a certain date?
By Mr. Allen The defendant proposed to prove by this witness
that he did not take up the plaintiff's annual pass, issued to him as
an engineer, and the other property belonging to the railroad com-
pany, until after suit was brought by the plaintiff against the Sea-
board Air Line Railway.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 29.
37. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding, over
defendant’s objection and exception, the following question asked
defendant’s witness, W. S. Burrus:
Q. When an engineer ceased to be connected with the Seaboard
Air Line Railway, is he required to turn over his pass and other
property of the railroad to the railroad?
15 This is defendant’s Exception No. 30.
38. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in
holding that the trial court did not commit error in admitting the
following testimony of plaintiff’s witness, Dr. A. W. Goodwin:
Q. If the jury should find from the evidence that Mr. Horton
has only 20-70 sight in one eye and normal in the other, would he
in your opinion be suitable for a railroad engineer’s duties?
By the Court: In the first place, the question is whether — has
any opinion. Have you an opinion satisfactory to yourself about
it?
A. Well, I would think in a deformity in the eye—I would imag-
ine that was a deformity more than a disease, that is simply an
opinion—I would think in a deformity in the eye would (any de-
formity) unfit him for the engineer’s service and in testing I did
not find any. TI would not like to express an opinion, but from a
general medical standpoint, T am not an eye specialist, I would
xo he was — 2 ton No. $1
his is defendant’s Exception No. 51.
39. For that the * dre Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in exculding the follow-
ing question asked the plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s ob-
jection and exception:
2—541
—
10 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
Q. I understand from you whatever Mr. Benton or Mr. Burrus
or Mr. Hopkins or Mr. Matthews testified to differently from your
recollection is not true?
This is defendant’s Exception No, 32.
40. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding the follow-
ing question asked the plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant’s ob-
jection and exception:
Q. You say that what Mr. Hopkins said contrary to what
16 you said is not true?
This is defendant’s Exception No. 33.
41. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in excluding the fol-
lowing question asked the plaintiff, J. T. Horton, over defendant's
objection and exception:
Q. Didn’t I understand you to say what Mr. Hopkins said was
not true?
By the Court: I do not think that is the way to examine a witness.
I think you may direct his attention to any particular thing and
ask if that happened.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 34.
42. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in refusing upon
motion of the defendant, to strike out the following evidence of
plaintiff’s witness, Ernest Horton, overruled defendant’s objection
and exception :
Q. What would be the proper thing to do, or would it be the
proper thing in the event there was no guard glass on the water
gauge to shut off the water glass and run the engine with the gauge
cocks?
A. T ran an engine over there for four years and I never shut
the glass off.
This is defendant’s Exception No, 35.
43. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in overruling defend-
ant’s motion for judgment of nonsuit at the conclusion of all the
evidence.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 26. oN
44. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of Section 1 of the Act of Congress,
known as the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, and in hold-
17 ing that the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over
defendant’s objection and exception, to instruct the jury as
follows, as requested by the defendant:
1. The Court charges you that if you believe the evidence, the
plaintiff was not injured by any negligence on the part of the de
fendant, and you will answer the first issue, No.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 37. “age
45, For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of Section 4 of said act of Congress in
holding that the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over
-
defendant’s objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows,
as requested by the defendant: ;
2. The Court charges you that if you believe the evidence, the
plaintiff assumed the risk of injury from the explosion of the water
glass, and you will answer the second issue, Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 38.
46. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant’s ob-
jection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant:
3. If you do not answer the second issue, Yes, then the Court
charges you that if vou believe the evidence, the plaintiff by his own
negligence contributed to his injury, and you will answer the third
issue, Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 39.
47, For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant’s
objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant:
5. The Court instructs you that upon all the evidence in this case
the absence of the guard glass and the risk incident to the use
18 of the water gauge in that condition were so obvious that an
ordinarily prudent person under the circumstances would
have observed and appreciated them, and if plaintiff reported the
absence of the guard glass to defendant’s foreman and the foreman
gave him a promise to repair, a reasonable time for the performance
of such promise had expires, and plaintiff assumed the risk of in-
jury and you will answer the second issue, Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception 40.
48, For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant’s
objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant:
6. The Court instructs you that upon all the evidence in this case,
if plaintiff reported the absence of the guard glass to defendant’s
foreman and was given a promise of repair, the danger was so im-
minent that no ordinarily prudent man, woder the circumstances
would have relied upon such promise, and pleintiff assumed the iisk
of injury, and you will answer the second issue, Yes.
This is defendant’ Exception No. 41. ; se Sis
49. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant’s
objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant: } ; ;
7. The Court instructs you that upon all the evidence in this
ease, if plaintiff reported the absence of the guard glass to defend-
ant’s foreman and was given a promise of repair, there is no evi-
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON. 11
12 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
dence that he was induced by such promise to continue to use the
engine with the water gauge in a defective condition, and you will
answer the second issue, Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 42.
50. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in
19 its construction and application of said act of Congress in
j holding that the trial court did not commit error in refusing,
over defendant’s objection and exception, to instruct the jury as fol-
lows, as requested by the defendant:
8. The Court instructs you that the absence of the guard glass and
the risk incident thereto were so obvious that an ordinarily prudent
person would have observed and appreciated them, and you will
answer the second issue, Yes, unless plaintiff has satisfied you by a
preponderance of the evidence that he reported the absence of the
guard glass and was given a promise of repair.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 43.
51. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant's
objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant:
9. If you find that the plaintiff reported the absence of the guard
glass and was given a promise of repair, if you also find by the
preponderance of the evidence that no ordinarily prudent man under
the circumstances would rely upon such promise, the Court instructs
you to answer the second issue as to assumption of risk, Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 44.
52. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in modifying, over defendant's
objection and exception, defendant’s request for instruction No. 11,
by adding at the end thereof, “That is, relying on that promise, he
continued to use the engine,”’ as follows: oF
11. If you find by a preponderance of the evidence that plaintiff
appreciated the risk incident to the use of the gauge glass without
guard glass, the Court instructs you that under the Federal
20 Employers’ Liability Act, he assumed the risk and you will
answer the second issue, Yes, unless the plaintiff has satis-
fied you by a preponderance of the evidence that he reported the
absence of the guard glass and was given a promise of repair, and
that he was induced by such promise to continue in the employment.
The Court modified the instruction by adding at the end thereof :
“That is, relying on that promise, he continued to use the engine.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 45. ee
53. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant's
objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as reques
by the defendant:
13. If you answer the first issue Yes, then the Court charges you
that under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, if you find that the
or
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 13
plaintiff appreciated the risk incident to the use of the water gauge
without the guard glass, and you should further find that the plaintiff
told the defendant’s roundhouse foreman that the guard glass was
gone and was given a promise of repair, the time reasonably required
for the performance had expired at the time of the explosion of the
water glass and you will answer the second issue, Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 46.
54. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant’s
objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant:
18. If you answer the first issue Yes, and if you find by the
greater weight of the evidence that the plaintiff appreciated the
danger incident to the use of the water glass without the
21 guard glass and that he could have shut off the glass, and
operated his engine with safety by using the gauge cocks
on his engine and that the plaintiff with such knowledge failed to
shut off the glass and use the gauge cocks, then the Court charges
you that the plaintiff assumed the risk of injury, and you will an-
swer the second issue, Yes.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 47.
55. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its con-
struction and application of said act of Congress in holding that the
trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant’s ob-
jection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant:
20. The burden of proof is upon the plaintiff, J. T. Horton, to
show that the water glass was defective and that the defendant knew
of the defect, and unless you so find by the greater weight of the evi-
dence, you will answer the first issue, No.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 48.
56. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said Act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defendant’s
objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows, as requested
by the defendant:
21. If you find from the evidence that the engine could have been
operated in safety by cutting off the water glass and using the
gauge cocks, and that the plaintiff continued to use the water glass
when he knew there was no guard glass on it and that it was dan-
gerous to use the water glass in that condition, you will answer the
first issue, No.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 49.
57. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in its
construction and application of said act of Congress in holding that
the trial court did not commit error in refusing, over defend-
22 ant’s objection and exception, to instruct the jury as follows,
as requested by the defendant:
22. If you find from the evidence that ee could have
performed his duties in operating the engine by using the gauge
14 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
cocks for the purpose of telling how much water was in the boiler,
and he continued to use the water glass without the guard glass, you
wil] answer the first issue, No.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 50.
_ 58. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructiong the
Jury, over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
_ They, as I understand the decision, and as I charge you the de
cision 1s, hold it is not the duty of the railroad company, not an ab-
solute duty that the railroad company owes to a servant to furnish
an absolutely safe place, or absolutely safe and secure tools and ap-
pliances and equipment with which to do his work, but that the
rule is that the railroad company shall exercise ordinary care and
prudence to the end that—I want to use the exact language—to the
end that the tools and the appliances of the work may be safe for
the workmen. The Supreme Court of the United States says that
the common law rule is that an employer is not a guarantor of the
safety of the place of work or of the machinery and appliances of
the work. The extent of its duty to its employees is to see that ordi-
nary care and prudence are exercised, to the end that the place in
which the work is to be performed and the tools and appliances of
the work may be safe for the workman.
It is the duty of the employer to exercise due care in respect to
providing a safe place of work, and suitable and safe appliances for
the work.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 51.
59. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
23 in holding that the trial court did not commit error in in-
structing the jury, over defendant’s objection and exception,
as follows:
Negligence is the omission to do what a reasonable and prudent
person would ordinarily have done under the circumstances of the
situation; or doing what a reasonable and prudent man under the
existing circumstances would not have done. That is negligence.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 52.
60. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury,
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
And it becomes actionable when it is the proximate cause of the
injury, either when it is the direct cause thereof, or when the injury
is the natural and probable consequence of the act, and when in the
exertion of ordinary care, an ordinarily prudent person would have
for-seen that such consequences would likely be produced thereby.
It is not every negligence that is actionable, but I repeat, it becomes
actionable when it is the proximate cause of the injury, either when
it is the direct cause thereof, or when the injury is the natural and
probable consequence of the act, and when in the exercise of ordi-
nary care, an ordinarily prudent person would have foreseen that
such consequence would likely be produced thereby.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 53. :
61. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 15
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury,
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
The law is, that if the act is one which the party ought in the
exercise of ordinary care to have anticipated was liable to result
in injury to others, then he is liable for any injury proximately re-
sulting from it, although he could not anticipate the particular in-
jury that did happen. Consequences which flow in unbroken se-
uence, without an intervening cause from the original neg-
24 ligent act are natural and proximate, and for such conse-
quences the original wrongdoer is responsible, even though
he could not have foreseen the particular result which did folles .
This is defendant’s Exception No. 54.
62. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in ho 1
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury,
over defendant's objection and exception, as follows:
The first requisite of proximate cause is the doing or omitting to
do an act which a person of ordinary prudence could foresee might
naturally or probably produce the injury, and second that it did
actually produce it.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 55,
63. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury,
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
If you find from the evid: ace that the guard glass was in its
proper place on the engine when the plaintiff started on his run on
the morning of July 27, 1910, and that the defendant had no knowl-
edge of the absence of such a glass, and it was the plaintiff's duty to
make a note of the absence of the glass in writing on his work report,
and he failed to do so, and you further find that the defendant’s
failure to have knowledge of the absence of the guard glass was due
solely to the plaintiff's failure to make the report in writing of the
absence of the guard glass, the Court instructs you that there has
been no negligence on the part of the defendant, and you will an-
swer the first issue, No.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 56.
64. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury,
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
Contributory negligence is a want of ordinary care upon
25 the part of a person injured by the actionable negligence of
another, combining and coneurring with that negligence and
contributing to the injury as a proximate cause thereof, without
which the injury would not have occurred.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 57.
65. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury,
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
Contributory negligence arises when the plaintiff as well as de-
fendant has done some act negligently or has omitted through negli-
gence to do some act, which it was their respective duty to do, and
this combined negligence produces the injury.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 58.
~
16 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
_ 66. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold.
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
The Supreme Court in passing upon this particular case says, that
it is the law so far as this case is concerned:
The distinction between contributory negligence and assumption
of risk is simple. Contributory negligence involves the notion of
some fault or breach of duty on the part of some employee, and
since it is ordinarily his duty to take some precaution for his own
safety when engaged in a hazardous occupation, contributory neg-
ligence is sometimes defined as failure to use such care for his safety
as an ordinarily prudent employee under similar circumstances
would use.
On the other hand, assumption of risk, even though the risk be
obvious, may be free from any suggestion of fault or negligence on
the part of the employee. The risk may be present notwithstand-
ing the exercise of all reasonable care on the part of the employee.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 59.
67. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
}
i
29 SE Ie SATE pees:
— onesie
SE EE
ET Sere rss
H 26 in holding that the trial court did not commit error in in-
structing the jury over defendant’s objection and exception,
as follows:
Some employments are necessarily fraught with danger to the
workman, danger that must be and is confronted in the line of his
duty. Such dangers as are normally and necessarily incident to
the occupation are presumably taken into account in fixing the rate
# of wages, and a workman of mature years is taken to assume risks
i o/ this sort, whether he is actually aware of them or not.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 60.
68. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
But risks of another sort not naturally incident to the occupation,
t may arise out of the failure of the employer, the defendant in this
:} case, to exercise due care with respect to providing a safe place of
f work and suitable and safe appliances for the work.
These risks, the latter risks, the employee is not treated as assuming
until he becomes aware of the defect or disrepair, and of the risk
arising from it, unless defect and risk alike are so obvious that an
ordinarily prudent person under the circumstances would have ob-
} served and appreciated them.
| This is defendant’s Exception No. 61.
69. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
When an employee does know of the defect, and appreciates the
risk that is attributable to it, then if he continues in the employment
without objection, or without obtaining from his employer or his
representative an assurance that the defect will be remedied, the
employee assumes the risk, even though it arises out of the master’s
breach of duty.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 62.
accuser
ss
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 17
27 70. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
in holding that the trial court did not commit error in in-
— the jury over defendant’s objection and exception, as fol-
ows:
If, however, there be a promise of reparation, even during such
time as may be reasonably required for its performance, or until
the particular time specified for its performance, the employee re-
lying upon the promise does not assume the risk unless at least the
danger be so imminent that no ordinarily prudent man under the
circumstances would rely upon such promise.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 68.
71. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
The burden of the second issue is upon the defendant, and_the
burden of the third issue is upon the defendant, and the defendant
should offer you evidence to sustain the plea of contributory neg-
ligence and assumption of risk.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 64.
7 +. that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in modifying, over de-
fendant’s objection and exception, the following request of defend-
ant for special instruction, by adding at the end thereof, the follow-
ing words, “that is, relying on that promise he continued to use that
engine.”
If you find by a preponderance of the evidence that the plaintiff
appreciated the risk incident to the use of the gauge glass without
the guard glass, the Court instructs you that under the Federal Em-
ployers’ Liability Act, he assumed the risk and you will answer the
second issue Yes, unless the plaintiff has satisfied you by a pre-
ponderance of the evidence that he reported the absence of the
guard glass and was given a promise of repair and that he was
induced by such promise to continue in the employment.
28 That is, relying on that promise he continued to use that
engine.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 65.
721%. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in
holding that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the
jury over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
“Tf you answer the first issue ‘Yes,’ then the Court charges you
that under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, if you find that
the plaintiff appreciated the risk incident to the use of the water
gauge without the guard glass, and you should further find that the
plaintiff told the defendant’s round house foreman that the guard
glass was gone and was given a promise of repair, yet, you should
find that the time reasonably required for the performance of this
promise had expired at the time of the explosion of the water glass,
you will answer the second issue ‘Yes.’ ”
This is defendant’s Exception. No. 6544.
73. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
3—541
1s SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON,
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
If you answer the second issue Yes, that he assumed the risk
incident to his injury, the burden being upon the defendant to
satisfy you of that by the greater weight of the evidence, you need
not answer the third and fourth issues.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 66.
74. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the jury
over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
The burden is upon the defendant to satisfy you that the plaintiff
assumed the risk which resulted in his injury.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 67.
75. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the
jury over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
The burden is upon the defendant to satisfy you by the
29 greater weight of the evidence on the second issue that the
plaintiff did assume the risk of his injury. If it has so satis-
fied you by the preponderance of the evidence, you will answer the
issue Yes, and unless they have so satisfied you, you will answer it
No.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 68.
76. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in
holding that the trial court did not commit error in instructing the
jury over defendant’s objection and exception, as follows:
The rule is that where the plaintiff has been injured by the negli-
gent conduct of the defendant, he is entitled to recover damages for
past and prospective loss resulting from defendant’s negligent act,
and this may embrace indemnity for actual expense incurred, in
nursing, medical attention, loss of time, loss of ability to perform
mental or physical labor, or capacity to earn money, and actual
suffering of body or mind which are the immediate and necessary
consequences of his injury. You will consider bodily pain and
suffering occasioned by the injury, if any resulted from said injury,
and in case you fina that the plaintiff has not yet recovered from
said injury, or that he has been permanently disabled, then you
will take such facts and circumstances into consideration in esti-
mating the damages, to which you may add such amount in your
sound discretion that you may think from the evidence will be com-
pensation for the injuries that are purely and plainly the con-
sequences of the injury complained of. That is the rule.
This is defendant’s Exception No, 69.
77. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in refusing defendant’s
motion for judgment non obstante veredicto.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 70.
78. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in refusing defendant’s
motion to set the verdict aside because the amount awarded is
excessive.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 71.
—
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 19
30 79. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
in holding that the trial court did not commit error in Te-
fusing defendant’s motion to set the verdict aside as against the
weight of the evidence,
This is defendant’s Exception No. 72.
80. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in refusing defendant’s
motion for a new trial for errors occurring during the trial and errors
in the admission and exclusion of evidence, in overruling defend-
ant’s motion for nonsuit and in the Court’s charge to the jury and
in the Court’s refusal to give defendarit’s requests for instruction.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 73.
81. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in signing judgment
in this case as appears in the record.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 74.
82. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred in hold-
ing that the trial court did not commit error in denying the de-
fendant’s motion for a new trial for the newly discovered evidence
of C. E. Barrow, who would testify that he, the said Barrow, married
the sister of James T. Horton’s mother, and lived within about
three miles of the Horton’s home, near Youngsville, N. C., twenty-
five or thirty years ago; that he remembers distinctly that the said
Horton’s eye was injured when he was a boy; that the said eye has
been injured ever since the said time; that he saw the injured eye
at the time and it is the same eye he now claims to have been
injured by the railroad; that he was told by Horton at the time
that his eye was hurt by a knife striking it; that the knife was in
the hands of one of his brothers and struck him in the eye while
they were tusseling.
This is defendant’s Exception No. 75.
83. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina erred
31 in holding that:
“There was evidence from which the jury could find that
while the absence of the guard glass was a defect causing the injury
to plaintiff, and which amount- of negligence on the part of de-
fendant, yet it was not such an imminent danger which would
justify excusing the plaintiff, if the plaintiff remained on service
after reporting the defect and receiving assurance that it would be
repaired.
84. For that the Supreme Court of North Carolina committed
error in confirming the judgment rendered in this action, because
the said judgment denied to the plaintiff in error, Seaboard Air Line
Railway, a construction of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act,
to which it was entitled and which, if granted would have defeated
the right of defendant in error to recover in this action.
85. The Supreme Court of North Carolina for the various reasons
set forth, committed error in rendering the final judgment that it
did render against the plaintiff in error in this action.
Wherefore, for these and other manifest errors appearing in the
record, the Seaboard Air Line Railway prays that the said judgment
20 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON.
of the Supreme Court of North Carolina, dated the 12th of May,
1915, be reversed and the judgment rendered in favor of plaintiff
in error, and for costs.
June 23rd, 1915.
MURRAY ALLEN,
Attorney for Seaboard Air Line Railway.
32 [Endorsed:] Seaboard Air Line Railway, Plaintiff in
Error, vs. James T. Horton, Defendant in Error. Petition
for Writ of Error, Assignment of Errors and Prayer for Reversal.
Filed and copies lodged for defendant in error this June 24, 1915.
J. L. Seawell, Clerk Supreme Court of North Carolina.
Sethe AT GEA TGESS EA O
33 Unirep STaTes OF AMERICA, 88:
The President of the United States of America, to the Honorable
the Judges of the Supreme Court of the State of North Carolina,
Greeting:
Because in the record and proceedings, as also in the rendition
of the judgment of a plea which is in the said Supreme Court be
fore you, or some of you, being the highest court of law or equity
of the said Siate in which a decision could be had ir the said suit
between James T. Horton, plaintiff, and Seaboard Air Line Rail-
way, defendant, wherein was drawn in question the validity of
a treaty or statute of or an authority exercised under, the United
States, and the decision was against their validity; or wherein
was drawn in question the validity of a statute of, or an authority
exercised, under said State, on the ground of their being repugnant
to the Constitution, treaties, or laws of the United States, and the
decision was in favor of such their validity; or wherein was drawn
in question the construction of a clause of the Constitution, or of
a treaty, or statute of, or commission held under the United States,
and the decision was against the title, right, privilege, or exemption
specially set up or claimed under such clause of the said Constitu-
tion, treaty, statute, or commission; a manifest error hath happened
to the great damage of the said defendant, Seaboard Air Line Rail-
way, as by its complaint appears. We being willing that error, if
any hath been, should be duly corrected, and full and speedy justice
done to the parties aforesaid in this behalf, do command you, if
judgment be therein given, that then under your seal, distinctly
and openly, you send the record and proceedings aforesaid, with
all things concerning the same, to the Supreme Court of the United
States, together with this writ, so that you have the same in the said
Supreme Court at Washington, D. C., within thirty days from the
date hereof, that the record and proceedings aforesaid being in-
spected, the said Supreme Court may cause further to be done
therein to correct that error, what of right, and according
34 to the laws and customs of the United States, should be done.
Witness the Honorable Edward D. White. Chief Justice of
Seay ons Sta tS i are ieee”
”
gape
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 21
the United States, the 23 day of June. in the year of our Lord one
thousand nine hundred and fifteen.
[Seal United States District Court, Eastern District of N. C.
at Raleigh. ]
ALEX. L. BLOW,
Clerk District Court, United States,
Eastern District of North Carolina.
Allowed by
WALTER CLARK,
Chief Justice Supreme Court of North Carolina.
This 23 day of June, 1915.
35 [Endorsed:] Seaboard Air_ «ine Railway, Plaintiff in
Error, vs, James T. Horton, Defendant in Error. Writ of
Error. Filed and copy lodged for defendant in error this 24 da
of June, 1915. J. L. Seawell, Clerk Supreme Court of North
Carolina.
86 Unrrep States or AMERICA, 88:
To James T. Horton, Greeting:
You are hereby cited and admonished to be and appear at a Su-
preme Court of the United States, at Washington, D. C., within
thirty days from the date hereof, pursuant to a writ of error, filed
in the Office of the Clerk of the Supreme Court of North Carolina,
wherein Seaboard Air Line Railway is plaintiff in error and you
are defendant in error, to show cause if any there be, why the judg-
ment rendered against the said plaintiff in error as in the said
writ of error mentioned, should not be corrected, and why speedy
justice should not be done to the parties in that behalf.
Witness, the Honorable Walter Clark, Chief Justice of the Su-
preme Court of North Carolina, this 23 day of June, in the year of
our Lord one thousand nine hundred and fifteen.
WALTER CLARK,
Chief Justice Supreme Court of North Carolina.
Attest:
[Seal of the Supreme Court of the State of North Carolina. |
J. L. SEAWELL,
Clerk Supreme Court of North Carolina.
I. William C. Douglass, attorney of record for the defendant in
error in the above entitled case, hereby acknowledge due service of the
above citation and acknowledge receipt of a true copy of same,
together with copy of petition for writ of error, assignment of errors,
prayer for reversal, bond and writ of error. This 26 day of June,
1915, at Raleigh, N. C.
WILLIAM C. DOUGLASS,
Attoney for James T. Horton,
Defendant in Error.
22 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
37 [Endorsed:] Seaboard Air Line Railway, Plaintiff in
Error, vs. James T. Horton, Defendant in Error. Citation.
Filed and copy lodged for defendant in error this 24 day of June,
1915. J. L. Seawell, Clerk Supreme Court of North Carolina.
38 The Supreme Court of North Carolina, Spring Term, 1915.
No. 255.
Seasoarp Arr Line Raitway, Plaintiff in Error,
vs.
JaMEs T. Horton, Defendant in Error.
Bond.
Know all men by these presents, that we, Seaboard Air Line Rail-
way, a corporation of the State of Virginia and other States, the
principal office of which is in the City of Portsmouth, State of
Virginia, as principal, and Fidelity and Deposit Company of
Marvland, as sureties, are held and firmly bound unto James
T. Horton in the full and just sum of Seven Thousand Dollars
($7,000.) to be paid to the said James T. Porton, his certain at-
torney, executers, administrators, or assigns; for the payment of
which sum, well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves, and
each of our successors and assigns, jointly and severally, firmly
by these presents. Sealed with our seals and dated this 23 day of
a in the year of our Lord one thousand nine hundred and
teen.
Whereas, lately at a hearing had before the Supreme Court of
North Carolina in a suit depending in said Court, between the said
James T. Horton, as plaintiff, and Seaboard Air Line Railway, as
defendant, a final judgment was rendered against the said Seaboard
Air Line Railway and the said Seaboard Air Line Railway; seeks
to prosecute its writ of error to the Supreme Court of the United
States to reverse the said final judgment in the aforesaid suit, and
a citation having been directed to the said James T. Horton citing
and admonishing him to be and appear at a Supreme Court of the
a States, at Washington, within thirty days from the date
thereof.
Now. therefore, the condition of this obligation is such, that if
the said Seaboard Air Line Railway shall prosecute -its said writ of
error to effect, and answer all damages and costs which may be ad-
judged against it, if it fail to make its plea good, then this
39 obligation is to be void; else to remain in full force and
effect.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY, [srat.]
(S.) By MURRAY ALLEN. Attorney.
FIDELITY & DEPOSIT COMPANY
OF MARYLAND. [SEAL. |
) By JOSEPH B. CHESHIRE, Attorney in Fact.
) RALEIGH INSURANCE AND REALTY
CO., Agents,
By JAS. McKIMMON, Agent.
(S.
(S.
gees
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
Bond approved and to act as supersedeas, this 23 day of June,
1915
(S.) WALTER CLARK,
Chief Justice, Supreme Court of North Carolina.
40 Seventh District.
No. —.
James T. Horton
against
SeaBoaRD Air Line RAILway.
(From Wake.)
Before H. W. Whedbee, J.
Defendant appealed.
Caption.
Be it remembered, that at a Sunerior Court beeun, continued and
held in and for the County of Wake, State of North Carolina, at
the court house in the citv of Raleigh, on the first Monday after
the first Monday of September, 1914, it being the 14th day of Sep-
tember. 1914, before Honorable H. W. Whedbee, Judge presiding,
the following proceedings were had, to-wit:
Summons for Relief.
Wake County:
In the Superior Court.
James T. Horton
‘ against
Srapoapp Arr Ling Ratiway.
The State of North Carolina to the Sheriff of Wake County, Greet-
ing:
You are hereby commanded to summon Seaboard Air Line Rail-
way, the defendant above-named, if it be found within your county,
to be and appear before the Judge of our Superior Court at
41 a court to be held for the County of Wake, at the court
house in Raleigh, N. C., on the seventh Monday after the
first Monday of September, it being the 24th dav of October, 1910,
and answer the complaint, which will be deposited in the office of
the Clerk of the Superior Court of said county within the first
three days of said term; and let the said defendant take notice, that
if it fail to answer the complaint within the time required by law,
the plaintiff will apply to the Court *»r the relief demanded in the
complaint.
=
2 ae
er
eet
Ease reat Sen Soe Pr Ey
Fae
24 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES '’. HORTON.
Hereof fail not, and of this summons make due return.
Given under my hand and seal of said court, this 5th day of
October, 1910.
W. M. RUSS,
Clerk Superior Court.
Prosecution Bond.
We acknowledge ourselves bound unto the defendant in this
action in the sum of $200; to be void, however, if the plaintiff shall
pay to the defendant all such costs as the defendant may recover
of the plaintiff in this action.
Witness our hands and seals, this 5th day of October, 1910.
J. T. HORTON. [seat.]
J. S. HORTON. [skat.]
Return on Summons.
Received October 6, 1910; served October 10, 1910, by reading
the within summons and delivering a copy of the same to W. T.
Huntley, agent at Raleigh, N. C., for Seaboard Air Line Railway,
the defendant therein named.
J. H. SEARS,
Sheriff of Wake County,
By H. H. CROCKER, D. 8.
And on the 9th day of November, 1910, the plaintiff, James T.
Horton, by his attorneys, Messrs. Douglass, & Lyon and Holding,
Snow & Bunn, comes and complains as follows:
42 Complaint.
Nortu CAROLINA,
Wake County:
Superior Court, January Term, 1910.
(Title of Cause.)
The plaintiff, ag” age of the defendant, alleges:
1. That on the 4th day of August, 1910, and some time prior
thereto, and ever since that time, the defendant was and now is
a corporation duly chartered and organized and engaged in the
Cs gpgerg of a line of railway from Hamlet, N. C., to Portsmouth,
a., via Raleigh, N. C., and other points north and south thereof,
outside of the State of North Carolina.
2. That on the said 4th day of August, 1910, the plaintiff, who
was then and now is a resident of the County of Wake, State of North
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 25
Carolina, was a young man thirty-one years of age, with perfect
eyes and eyesight and otherwise physically and mentally sound,
was in the employ of the defendant as a locomotive engineer, and
on said day and date was engaged in running and operating a loco-
motive engine of defendant, and in the discharge of his duties as
locomotive engineer aforesaid, drawing a train of loaded freight cars,
a part of which said cars were loaded with goods, wares and mer-
chandise which the defendant had received for transportation and
was transporting from points inside the State of North Carolina, to
Portsmouth, Va., and other points outside of North Carolina, over
its said line of railroad.
3. That it was the duty of the defendant to furnish to the plaintiff
a locomotive engine for the use of the plaintiff in the discharge of
his duties as locomotive engineer aforesaid that was properly
equipped with modern safety appliances that were in general use,
especially with a modern and sate water glass, such as was at that
time in general use upon railroad steam locomotives, for the purpose
of gauging the water in the steam boiler of the said loco-
43 motive, and such as would protect the plaintiff from injury
to his person while in the discharge of his duties as loco-
motive engineer aforesaid, and that would afford him a safe place
where he might discharge his said duties.
4, That in disregard of its aforesaid duty to the plaintiff on the
day and date aforesaid, the defendant negligently furnished to the
ag a locomotive engine with which to draw the aforesaid cars
oaded with goods, wares and merchandise as aforesaid, negligently
and carelessly equipped with a water glass that was not modern
in its make and that was unsafe for use, and that was of an inferior
grade and quality, and which water glass was known to the defend-
ant to he not modern in its make and unsafe for use and of an in-
ferior grade and quality and liable to burst and seriously and
permanently injure the plaintiff while in the discharge of his duty
as locomotive engineer aforesaid.
5. That while in the discharge of his duty as locomotive en-
gineer as aforesaid, and while running and operating the locomo-
tive engine which the defendant negligently furnished as aforesaid
to the plaintiff on the day and date aforesaid, negligently and care-
lessly equipped with said defective glass not modern in its make
and unsafe for use as aforesaid and which was of an inferior grade
and quality as aforesaid, at a point on the line of the defendant's
said railroad in the county of Wake, State of North Carolina, known
as the town of Apex, the plaintiff, as it was his duty frequently to
do, looked at the aforesaid water glass with which said engine was
equipped as aforesaid, for the purpose of ascertaining the amount of
water that was in the boiler of said locomotive, and while he was
so looking, said water glass, on account of its being defective as
aforesaid, and of inferior grade and quality as aforesaid, and not
modern in its make as aforesaid, was exploded and burst by the
steam pressure from said boiler, and pieces of flying glass there-
from were violently thrown thereby into the face and right eye of the
4—641
26 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON.
plaintiff, seriously, painfully and permanently wounding,
44 cutting and bruising his face and eyeball of the plaintiff's
right eye and almost totally destroying the vision of the
plaintiff's right eye, so that his trade, business and calling as a loco-
motive engineer has been destroyed by reason of said injuries and
so that the plaintiff has been rendered totally unht and unable to
perform the duties of his said trade, business and calling, and has
lost his employment with the defendant on account thereof, and is
unable to obtain employment as a locomotive engizeer with the de-
fendant or any one else.
6. That on account of the aforesaid negligence of the defendant
as hereinbefore set out, the plaintiff has been seriously, permanently
and painfully injured and rendered totally and permanently un-
fit to perform the duties of his trade, business and calling, has
suffered great physical pain and mental anguish; has lost’ much
time from his business; has been sorely inconvenienced; has spent
large sums of money for medical attention and medicines, and has
been injured and damaged in the sum of fifty thousand dollars.
7. That at the time that plaintiff was injured as alleged in this
complaint, the defendant was engaged in interstate cominerce, and
the plaintiff was employed and engaged in interstate commerce, and
brings this action under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act passed
by the United States Congress and approved on the 22nd day of
April, 1908, and the amendments thereto.
Wherefore, the plaintiff prays judgment that he recover of the
defendant fifty thousand dollars damages, together with the costs
of this action, and for such other and further relief as he may be
entitled to in the premises.
DOUGLASS «& LYON,
HOLDING, SNOW &
BUNN,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
45 Verification.
Nortu CAROLINA,
Wake County:
James T. Horton, the plaintiff above-named, being duly sworn,
deposes and says that the foregoing complaint is true to his own
knowledge, except as to matters stated on information and belief,
and that as to those matters he believes it to be true.
JAMES T. HORTON.
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this the 9th day of November,
1910.
W. M. RUSS,
Clerk Superior Court.
And thereafter, to-wit, on the 6th day of December, 1910, the
defendant, by its attorney, Murray Allen, Esq., comes and answers
as follows, to-wit:
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON, 27
Answer.
NortH CAROLINA,
Wake County:
Superior Court, October Term, 1910.
(Title of Cause.)
The defendant, answering the complaint herein, says:
1, That the allegations of section 1 are admitted.
2. The defendant denies, upon information and belief, that on
August 4, 1910, the plaintiff was a young man with perfect eyes
and eyesight and otherwise physically and mentally strong, as al-
leged in section 2 of the complaint.
3. The defendant is informed, advised and believes, that the
allegations of section 3 of the complaint state matter of law, and
the defendant is not called upon to make answer thereto; but the
defendant says, in regard to the matters set forth in said
46 section, that it has performed its duty to plaintiff in every
respect as required by law.
4. The allegations of section 4 are not true, and are denied.
5. The allegations of section 5 are not true, and are denied.
6. The allegations of sections 6 are not true, and are denied,
And for further defense, the defendant says:
1. That if the plaintiff was injured as alleged in the complaint,
which the defendant expressly denies, the said injury was caused
by the negligence of the plaintiff in the manner in which he used
the water glass, which he alleges was in a defective condition, and
the manner in which he operated the engine on which he was
employed, and his contributory negligence is pleaded by the defend-
ant in bar of plaintiff’s right to recover in this action.
9. That if the engine on which plaintiff was employed was de-
fective in any respect on August 4, 1910, as alleced in the com-
plaint, which the defendant again denies, such condition was known
to the plaintiff, and he carelessly and negligently failed to report
said condition to defendant’s foreman as it was his duty to do, and
his contributory negligence in that respect is pleaded by the defend-
ant in bar of plaintiff's right to recover in this action. _
8 That if the defendant was negligent as alleged in the com-
plaint, which is again expressly denied, the plaintiff by his own
negligence, contributed to his injury, if any he has sustained, in -
that, having knowledge of the character and condition of the water
glass on the engine upon which he was employed, and knowing the
risk incident to its use in that condition, he negligently and care-
lessly continued to use said water glass, and the defendant pleads
plaintiff's contributory negligence in bar of his right to recover in
this action. see :
4. The defendant again denying that the plaintiff sustained the
injuries as alleged in the complaint, savs that if the water glass
on the engine on which he was employed was not modern in its
make and was defective in any respect, both of which are de-
28 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
nied, the character and condition of said water glass were
47 open and obvious and were fully known to the plaintiff and
he continued to use said water glass with such knowledge and
without objection, and he knew and voluntarily assumed the risk
incident thereto, and the defendant pleads such voluntary assump-
tion of risk in bar of plaintiff’s right to recover in this action.
Wherefore, the defendant demands judgment that it go with-
out day and recover the costs of this action, to be taxed by the Clerk.
MURRAY ALLEN,
Defendant's Attorney.
Verification.
J. F. Mitchell, being duly sworn, says that he is agent for the
defendant company at Raleigh, N. C.; that the foregoing answer is
true to his own knowledge, except as to matters therein stated on
information and belief, and that as to those matters he believes
it to be true.
J. F. MITCHELL.
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this 6th day of December,
1910.
[N. P. SEAL. | CARY K. DURFEY,
Notary Public.
Commission expires September 19, 1912.
And thereafter, to-wit, on the 20th day of April, 1911, the de-
fendant, by its attorneys, Messrs. Armistead Jones & Son, and
Murray Allen, comes and files an amended answer, as follows:
48 Amended Answer.
Nortu CARouina,
Wake County:
Superior Court, October Term, 1910.
The defendant answering the complaint herein, says:
1. That the allegations of section 1 are admitted.
2. The defendant denies, upon information and belief, that on
August 4, 1910, the plaintiff was a young man with perfect eyes
and eyesight, as alleged in section 2 of the complaint. At the time
alleged in the complaint the plaintiff was engaged as engineer in
the operation of an engine drawing a train between Aberdeen, N. C.,
and Raleigh, N. C., and his duties were performed entirely in the
State of North Carolina.
3. The defendant is informed, advised, and believes, that the alle-
gations of section 3 of the complaint state matter of law and the
defendant is not called upon to make answer thereto ; but the defend-
ant says, in regard to the matters set forth in said section, that it
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 29
has performed its duty to plaintiff in every respect as required by
4, The allegations of section 4 are not true, and ave denied.
5. The allegations of section 5 are not true, and are denied.
6. The allegations of section 6 are not true, and are denied.
7. The defendant has no knowledge or information sufficient to
form a belief as to the truth of the allegations of section 7 of the
complaint, and therefore demands strict proof thereof.
And for further defense, defendant says:
1. That if the plaintiff was injured as alleged in the complaint,
which the defendant expressly denies, the said injury was caused by
the negligence of the plaintiff in the manner in which he used the
water glass, which he alleges was in a defective condition, and in the
manner in which he operated the engine on which he was employed,
and his contributory negligence is pleaded by the defendant in bar
of plaintiff’s right to recover in this action.
49 2. That if the engine on which plaintiff was employed was
defective in any respect on August 4, 1910, as alleged in the
complaint, which the defendant again denies, such condition was
known to the plaintiff, and he carelessly and negligently failed
to report said condition to defendant’s foreman, as it was his duty
to do, and his contributory negligence in that respect is pleaded
by the defendant in bar of plaintiff’s right to recover in this action.
3. That if plaintiff was injured as alleged in the complaint, which
the defendant again expressly denies, the plaintiff by his own
negligence contributed to his injury, if any he has sustained, in
that, having knowledge of the character and condition of the water
glass on the engine upon which he was employed, and knowing
the risk incident to its use in that condition, he negligently and
carelessly continued to use said water glass, and the defendant pleads
plaintiff's contributory negligence in bar of his right to recover in
this action.
4. The defendant, again denying that the plaintiff sustained the
injuries as alleged in the complaint, says that if the plaintiff was
injured by the explosion of the water gauge on the engine on which
he was employed, which is denied, the said injury was caused by his
own negligence in using the said water gauge when he could have
operated said engine by using the gauge coks thereon, and his con-
tributory negligence is pleaded by the defendant in bar of plaintiff's
right to recover in this action.
5. The defendant again denying that the plaintiff sustained the
injuries as alleged in the complaint, says that if the water glass
on the engine on which he was employed was not modern in its
make and was defective in any respect (both of which are denied),
the character and condition of the said water glass were open and
obvious and were fully known to the plaintiff, and he continued
to use said water glass with such knowledge and without objection,
and he knew and voluntarily assumed the risk incident thereto,
and the defendant pleads such voluntary assumption of risk
50 in bar of plaintiff’s right to recover in this action.
6. The defendant, again denying that the plaintiff sustained
ROE PO Pe ae a ~ ea Oates rs eg
ore eengamem
——
—
30 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
the injuries as alleged in the complaint, says that if the water glass
on the engine on which plaintiff was employed was not modern
in its make and was defective in any respect (both of which are
denied), it was the plaintiff’s duty, and he had every opportunity,
to know the condition thereof, and the risk incident thereto, if any,
was assumed by the plaintiff, and his said assumption of risk is
pleaded by the defendant in bar of the plaintiff’s right to recover
in this action.
7. That if the plaintiff was injured as alleged in the complaint,
which is denied, there was open to him two ways of operating the
engine on which he was employed: by using the water glass and by
using the gauge cocks, which was a safe way to operate said engine;
and in voluntarily operating the said engine with the water glass
as alleged in the complaint, the plaintiff assumed the risk of injury
therefrom, and his assumption of risk is pleaded by the defendant
in bar of plaintiff’s right to recover in this action.
Wherefore, the defendant demands judgment that it go without
day, and recover the costs of this action, to be taxed by the Clerk.
ARMISTEAD JONES & SON,
MURRAY ALLEN,
Defendant's Attorneys.
Verification.
J. F. Mitchell, being duly sworn, says that he is agent for the de
fendant company at Raleigh, N. C.: that the foregoing answer is
true of his own knowledge, except as to matters therein stated on
information and belief, and as to those matters he believes it to be
true.
J. F. MITCHELL.
51 a to and subscribed before me, this 15th day of April,
C. T. McDONALD,
Notary Public.
My commission expires Ist day of February, 1912.
This cause came on for trial at \pril Term, 1911, of the Superior
Court of Wake County, and at the conclusion of the plaintiff’s
evidence, his Honor, Judge H. W. Whedbee sustained defendant’s
motion for judgment of nonsuit and dismissed the action. Plaintiff -
appealed to Supreme Court, and at Fall Term, 1911, of the Supreme
Court of North Carolina the judgment of the Superior Court was
reversed, and a new trial ordered.
This cause being called for trial at October Term, 1912, of Wake
County Superior Court, plaintiff moved to amend his complaint
as a which motion was allowed and the complaint so
amended :
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8, JAMES T. HORTON, 31
Amendment to Complaint.
Nortu CAROLINA,
Wake County:
Superior Court, October Term, 1912.
(Title of Cause.)
The plaintiff amends his complaint filed herein, as follows, by
inserting in paragraph four thereof, the following:
That the said water glass was imperfect, defective, dangerous
and unsafe in the following varticulars, which were also known
to the defendant, and by it negligently allowed to continue and
exist, to-wit: in that the same had no guard glass or shield in front
thereof and in connection therewith.
DOUGLASS, LYON & DOUGLASS,
W. B. SNOW,
J. W. BUNN,
R. N. SIMMS,
Plaintiff's Attorneys.
52 Verification.
Norru CaROoLina,
Wake County:
James T. Horton, the plaintiff, being duly sworn, deposes and says
that he has read the foregoing amendment; that the same is true of
his own knowledge, except as to matters therein stated on informa-
tion and belief, and as to those he believes it to be true.
JAMES T. HORTON.
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this 21st day of October,
1912,
VITRUVIUS ROYSTER,
Deputy Clerk.
Answer to Amendment to Complaint.
The defendant filed the following answer to the amendment to
plaintiff’s complaint:
“Answering said amendment to the complaint, defendant says:
“The allegations of said amendment are not true, and are denied.”
Verification of this answer is waived by plaintiff.
Trial, Jury, ete.
Therefore let a jury come by whom, ete.
And thereupon, after the introduction of evidence on behalf of
’
32 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
the plaintiff and defendant, and after the charge of the Court, said
jurors heretofore empaneled in this case, for their verdict found the
issues submitted to them as follows:
Issues, Verdict.
1. Was the plaintiff injured by the negligence of the defendant, as
alleged in the complaint?
Answer. ‘‘Yes.”
53 2. If so, did the plaintiff assume the risk of injury?
Answer. “No.”
3. Did plaintiff, by his own negligence, contribute to his injury?
Answer. “No.”
4. What damages, if any, is the plaintiff entitled to recover?
Answer. “$4,500.”
Motion to Set Verdict Aside, ete.
Upon the coming in of the verdict, defendant moved for judg-
ment non obstante veredicto. Motion overruled. Defendant ex-
cepts.
Defendant moves to set the verdict aside, because the amount of
damages awarded is excessive. Motion overruled. Defendant ex-
cepts.
Defendant moves to set the verdict aside as against the weight
of evidence. Motion overruled. Defendant excepts.
Defendant moves for a new trial for errors occurring during the
trial and errors in the admission and exclusion of evidence, in over-
a
cabeesree 3
4
i ruling defendant’s motion for’ judgment of nonsuit, and in the
FE Court’s charge to the jury, and in the Court’s refusal to give defend-
E | ant’s requests for instruction. Motion overruled. Defendant ex-
ah cepts. ;
ied And thereupon judgment is rendered and filed, as follows:
teed
id . |
Judgment.
ot
a —
Nortu CaRoLina,
Wake County:
Superior Court, September Term, 1914.
(Title of Cause. )
ale
This cause coming on to be tried before his Honor, H. W. Whed-
bee, Judge, and a jury, and being tried, the following issues were
, submitted to the jury:
‘ 54 1. Was the plaintiff injured by the negligence of the de
Z fendant, as alleged in the complaint? ie
HW 2. If so, did the plaintiff assume the risk of injury, as alleged
in the answer?
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 33
3. Did the plaintiff, by his own negligence, contribute to his in-
jury, as alleged in the answer?
4. What damages, if any, is the plaintiff entitled to recover?
And the jury having answered the first issue “Yes”; the second
issue “No’’; the third issue “No”, and the fourth issue ‘Four thou-
sand, five hundred dollars”; it is—
Ordered, adjudged and decreed that the plaintiff, James T. Hor-
ton, recover of the defendant, Seaboard Air Line Railway, the sum
of four thousand, five hundred ($4,500) dollars and the costs of
this action, to be taxed by the Clerk.
H. W. WHEDBEE,
Judge Presiding.
To the judgment signed by the Court defendant excepts, and in
open court appeals to the Supreme Court. Notice of appeal given
in open court, and further notice waived. Undertaking on appeal
fixed in the sum of $50.00.
By consent, defendant is allowed 66 days to file and serve state-
ment of case on appeal, and the plaintiff is allowed 60 days there-
after to serve counter statement or exceptions.
Defendant thereupon filed the following appeal bond and bond to
stay execution :
Appeal Bond.
Nortu CAROLINA,
Wake County:
In the Superior Court, September Term, 1914.
(Title of Cause.)
Whereas at September Term, 1914, of the Superior Court of
Wake County judgment was rendered against defendant in
55 the above-entitled action in the sum of $4,500 and costs; and,
whereas, the defendant intends to appeal to the Supreme
Court: .
Now, therefore we, Seaboard Air Line Railway and Fidelity —- De-
posit Company, of Maryland, undertake pursuant to the statute, that
the defendant shall pay all costs which may be awarded against de-
fendant on such appeal bond, and not exceeding, however, the 3um
of $50.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY, [SEAL. ]
By MURRAY ALLEN, Attorney.
FIDELITY AND DEPOSIT COMPANY OF
MARYLAND, ‘ [seat]
By JOSEPH B. CHESHIRE, Jr., Attorney in Fact,
By J. L. SKINNER, Agent.
5—541
:
3
4
aa
|
ot SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON.
Bond to Stay Execution.
Nortu Carona,
Wake County:
In the Superior Court, September Term, 1914.
(Title of Cause.)
Know all men by these present: that the Seaboard Air Line Rail-
way, as principal, and the Fidelity and Deposit Company, of Mary-
land, as surety, are held and firmly bound unto James T. Horton
in the just and full sum of $6,000, the payment whereof, well and
truly to be made, we bind ourselves and our successors and assigns
jointly and severally, firmly by these presents.
Sealed by our seals, and dated this 7th day of October, 1914.
The condition of the above obligation is such that whereas in a
certain action pending in the Superior Court of Wake County, North
Carolina, between James T. Horton and the Seaboard Air Line
Railway, on the 25th day of September, 1914, the said James T.
Horton recovered judgment against the said Seaboard Air
56 Line Railway in the sum of $4,500; and, whereas, the said
Court did make an order suspending execution upon the de-
fendant’s giving bond in the sum of $6,000, with condition accord-
ing to law; and, whereas, it is the intention of the Seaboard Air Line
Railway to appeal the judgment aforesaid:
Now, therefore, if the said judgment appealed from or in any
part thereof be affirmed, or the appeal dismissed, and if the Sea-
board Air Line Railway will pay the amount directed to be paid
by the judgment, or the part of such amount as to which the judg-
ment shall be affirmed, if it be affirmed only in part, and all damages
that shall be awarded against the said Seaboard Air Line Railway
upon said appeal, then the above obligation is to be void, otherwise
to remain in full force and virtue.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY, | [seat.|
By MURRAY ALLEN, Attorney.
FIDELITY AND DEPOSIT COMPANY
OF MARYLAND, [ SEAL. |
By JOSEPH B. CHESHIRE, Jr., Attorney in Fact,
By J. L. SKINNER, Agent.
Thereafter, and before the expiration of the term of court at which
said suit was tried and judgment rendered, defendant filed the
following motion for a new trial for newly-discovered evidence:
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 35
Motion for New Trial for Newly-Discovered Evidence.
NortH CAROLINA,
Wake County:
In the Superior Court, September Term, 1914.
(Title of Cause.)
To the Honorable H. W. Whedbee, Judge Superior Court:
The petition and motion of the defendant in the above entitled
cause respectfully shows:
57 1. That the plaintiff in this action brought suit for the
recovery of damages for injury to his right eye, alleged to
have been caused by the explosion of water glass, while employed
on defendant’s railroad as engineer.
2. That defendant denied that the injury complained of was
due to the explosion of said water glass, and set up as a defense
that plaintiff's eye was injured prior to the time alleged in the
complaint, and that the defective vision of plaintiff is due to the
sear left there by an old injury.
3. That defendant offered evidence of Dr. Battle, who testified
that he examined plaintiff’s eves in 1905, nearly five years before
the alleged injury, and found the vision in plaintiff's right eye,
which he alleges was injured, to be 20/70, which is the condition
of vision in said eve found to exist by Dr. Horton, who examined
plaintiff’s eyes in 1912. after the date of the alleged injury.
4. That the plaintiff testified and offered evidence of Dr. Goodwin
to prove that his eye-sight in his right eye was normal prior to date
of the alleged injury, and that he had never received an injury to
the said eve prior to that time, and the plaintiff vigorously denied
that the said eye had ever been injured, except at the time alleged.
5. That the iurv found the issues in favor of plaintiff, and
awarded him $4.500.
6. That the defendant had no evidence that the plaintiff’s eye
had been injured by being struck with a knife in the hands of one
of his brothers when he was a boy, and had been unable after having
exercised due diligence to secure such evidence.
7. That after the trial of the action, and during this term of
Court. the defendant was apprised for the first time of the fact that
the plaintiff’s eve had been iniured when he was a boy by a knife
striking him in the eve, and the defendant received information
through its counsel that C. E. Barrow had stated that he remem-
bered the time the plaintiff received the said injury to his eve;
that he knew the said eye had been in a damaged condition
58 since that time. and that the said iniury was due to plaintiff's
eye being struck by a knife in the hands of one of his
brothers.
8. That thereupon one of defendant’s counsel consulted said
C. E. Barrow about the matter, and he stated to defendant’s counsel
36 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
» facts in this connection, which appear in an affidavit attached
ereto.
9. That the said C. E. Barrow, if sworn to testify in this case,
as he will be subpeenaed to do so, he will testify to the facts as set
forth in said affidavit of defendant’s counsel, Murray Allen.
10. That the said evidence is probably true.
11. That the said evidence is competent, material and relevant.
12. That the defendant had no knowledge of the existence of
this testimony prior to the trial or during the trial of this action,
and did not secure such information until after judgment had
been rendered.
13. That the said evidence is not merely cumulative.
14. That the said evidence does not tend only to contradict a
former witness or to impeach or discredit him.
15. That it is of such a nature as to show that on another trial
a different result will probably be reached, and that the right will
probably prevail.
16. That after making the statements as set forth in the affidavit
of Murray Allen, the said C. E. Barrow stated that the facts were
true, and that he would make an affidavit setting forth said facts,
although he would not like to do so on account of his relations with
James T. Horton, but subsequently and on the same day the said
C. E. Barrow said he would not make an affidavit, but he did not
deny the truth of the statement.
Wherefore, your petitioner prays that the verdict and judgment
in this case be set aside and a new trial awarded in order that the
defendant may have an opportunity to present the said newly-
discovered evidence to the jury, and the defendant prays
59 that the Court may have the said C. E. Barrow brought be-
fore the Court and examined upon oath as to the facts set
forth in the affidavit of Murray Allen.
WINSTON & BIGGS,
MURRAY ALLEN,
Attorneys for S. A. L. Railway.
L. M. Calvert, being duly sworn, says that he is agent for the
defendant Seaboard Air Line Railway at Raleigh, N. C.; that he
has read the foregoing petition, and that the facts set forth in
said petition are true of his own knowledge, except as to those matters
stated upon information and belief, and as to those matters he
believes it to be true,
L. M. CALVERT.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 8th day of October, 1914.
C. A. GOSNEY,
Notary Public.
My commission expires 29th day of January, 1916.
" sees
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 37
Affidavit.
NortH CAROLINA,
Wake County:
In the Superior Court.
(Title of Cause.)
Murray Allen, being duly sworn, says that he is attorney for the
defendant Seaboard Air Line Railway in above action, which was
tried at September Term, 1914, of Wake Superior Court; that after
judgment was rendered against the defendant in said action, affiant
was informed that C. E. Barrow had stated that he remembered
that James T. Horton received an injury to his eye when he was a
boy, and that the said injury was caused by a knife in the hands
of one of his brothers, striking the said Horton in the eye
60 while they were playing; that this was the first information
that had reached affiant as to the existence of this witness
or as to the facts which he had stated, and affiant had never received -
information that the said Horton had received an injury to his eye
in the manner stated; that affiant talked with said C. E. Barrow,
after receiving this information, and that the said Barrow made a
statement to affiant as follows:
That he, the said Barrow, married the sister of James T. Horton’s
mother, and lived within about three miles of the Horton’s home,
near Youngsville, N. C., 25 or 30 years ago; that he remembers
distinctly that the said Horton’s eye was injured when he was a
boy; that the said eye has been injured ever since said time; that
he saw his injured eye at the time and that it is the same eye he
now claims to have been injured by the railroad; that he was told
by Horton at the time, that his eye was hurt by a knife striking it;
that the knife was in the hands of one of his brothers, and struck
him in the eye while they were tusseling; that he would not like
to have anything to do with Horton’s suit because they did not
speak to each other, and because of his connection with the family,
but that the statement he had made was true, and he could so testify,
2A called upon to do so, and that he would make an affidavit to that
effect.
That subsequently the said Barrow called affiant on the telephone,
and said he would not make the affidavit: that he preferred not to
have anything to do with the case. Affiant further says that the
said C. FE. Barrow will, if subpcenaed as a witness, give the evidence
as contained in his statement to affiant: that it is probably true;
that it is competent, material and relevant: that there has been no
laches, and that the defendant used due diligence to procure this
testimony prior to the trial of this action; that the evidence is not
merely cumulative; that it does not tend only to contradict a former
witness, or to impeach or discredit him; and that this evidence
61 is of such a nature that on another trial a different result
will probably be reached, and that the right will prevail.
MURRAY ALLEN.
38 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this 8th day of October,
1914,
(SEAL. ] C. A. GOSNEY,
Notary Public.
My commission expires 29th day of January, 1916.
Order.
Nortu CAROLINA,
Wake County:
Superior Court, September Term, 1914.
(Title of Cause.)
This cause coming on to be heard at this term, upon motion,
supported by affidavit, to set aside the verdict and judgment entered
at this term, on the ground of newly discovered evidence, and the
same being considered and the Court being of opinion that the pro-
posed newly discovered evidence, if true, is merely cumulative, it
is now ordered and adjudged by the Court that said motion be and
it is hereby denied.
H. W. WHEDBEE,
Judge Presiding.
To this order defendant excepts.
H. W. WHEDBEE,
Judge Presiding.
Defendant's Statement of Case on Appeal.
Nortu CAROLINA,
Wake County:
Superior Court, September Term, 1914.
(Title of Cause.)
This was a civil action for damages brought by the plaintiff
under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act. to recover for
62 personal injuries alleged to have been sustained by plaintiff
while employed by the defendant. The action was tried at
September Term, 1914, of the Superior Court of Wake County,
before his Honor, H. W. Whedbee, Judge, and a jury. The plead-
ings which appear in the record show the contentions of the parties.
The issues with the answers made thereto by the jury and the
judement rendered upon the verdict appear in the record.
Plaintiff offered the following evidence:
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 89
Plaintiff's Testimony.
NortH CAROLINA,
Wake County:
Superior Court, September Term, 1914.
(Title of Cause.)
James T. Horton, the plaintiff in this action, having been duly
sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination.
Examination by Mr. Douglass:
1 am the plaintiff in this case, and live in Raleigh. Have lived
in Wake County about 20 years, and am now 34, and will be 35
years old my next birthday. My occupation prior to the alleged
injury was engineer on the second division of the Seaboard. ‘lhe
second division is between Hamlet and Columbia and Wilmington
and Kutherfordton and up to here. Up to August 10, 1910, 1 had
been in the employ of the Seaboard about eight years and a half,
five years and a half as engineer, and three years as fireman. Along
at the time I was hurt the character of the trains I was running
consisted of every train they had, but my regular train was local
freight between Raleigh and Aberdeen. I had done extra passenger
work. I received wages from $165 to $-90 per month, ac-
63 cording to how many trips I worked; I mean by that $165
to $190 a month. Prior to the time of this injury the condi-
tion of my health was good. Condition of my eyes as to sight was
good. I will show you what a water glass in a locomotive is. (Wit-
hess unwraps a parcel and holds up an article.) That is a water
glass, a hollow glass tube, which is fixed in a locomotive engine on
the left side of the boiler head, to the left of the engineer, next to
the fireman’s side. I will explain its office on a locomotive engine:
what it is used for. It is connected at the top and bottom with a
valve, and you turn your water and steam pressure into this tube,
and it enables you to see how much water you are carrying in your
boiler at all times; it is the only way you can tell exactly how
much water is in your boiler; is to see it in the glass. I will show
you what a Buckner water gauge is. (Holds up an article.) This
(pointing) is the tube connection, and this (pointing) is the steam
connection. Inside of the brass tube is a glass tube like the one
I had, and it will—both will—come out. I will explain what a
Buckner water glass is. It is a brass tube or gauge, with the water
valve at the bottom and steam valve at the top, with this (pointing)
thick piece of glass on the top makes the Buckner water glass com-
plete. I will explain how it works. You drop this piece of glass
in the tube and it protects anyone from flying glass in case the tube
bursts. You can see through the thick glass in through the other
and tell how your water stands in your boiler. The piece of thick
40 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
glass is to prevent flying glass from hitting you in case this inner
tube should burst. The amount of pressure on the inner tube is
the same pressure that you carry on your boiler; 200 pounds is
about what we carry on standard engines, some 150; the one I
had carried 200; all new engines carry 200. I was in the em-
ploy of the S. A. L. Ry. on the 4th of August, 1910. On that morn-
ing I had engine 752, Richmond engine, 10-wheel engine, and I
left Aberdeen on August 4th at 6:35 A. M., on train No. 2,
64 a local freight, and arrived at Apex right around 1.00 o’clock,
between 1:00 and 1:30. The conductor tola me that he had
to go to the house track with three cars, three head cars, and he
would leave two of them at the house and come out with the head
ear, and when he was there doing that work I pulled up to the street
crossing at Apex and cut off the three head cars with the engine and
went up to the cross-over, and there is a locking plant where we
cross the Norfolk Southern, and backed down to the depot with
these three cars, and the head brakeman uncoupled my engine, and
I went out to the main line, up to the pass track, and went up to
get water while they were unloading the cars. and 1 got the water
and backed up, and as I crossed the crossing, it may have been just
before I crossed the crossing or as I crossed the crossing, 1 don’t
know which; anyway, I told the fireman or he might have sug-
gested. to go to the store and get something to eat, and then I pulled
up there. The second brakeman, Willis Crumpler, he was on the
back of the tender, and we passed over the interlocking plant, and I
backed down to the platform, about ten feet of the cars, and just
as 1 stopped the engine—you see they were unloading on the left
hand side, my fireman’s ble and my fireman was not on the engine,
and I pronto about eight or ten feet from the car, and as I stopped
the engine I was sitting in this position (illustrates), facing across:
eross-ways the engine, to the fireman’s side, looking back, with the
reverse lever between my legs, just like this, with my hand on the
brake, and the engine stopped and the water glass burst, and some
of the flying glass hit me in the face and eyes, and the cab was full
of steam and hot water, and I climbed over to the fireman’s side
and shut off the top and bottom valves as best I could, and went
around to the spicket on the tender. where you draw water and
sloshed water into my eye and wet my handkerchief, and I was
about a car length from the depot platform, and went to the plat-
form and called the conductor, and he came and asked what was
the trouble, and I told him the glass had burst and hit me in
65 the eye and get me to a doctor, and he told me all right,
and said to close the car doors, and we went out to the main
line and backed down to the train, and we coupled up to the train,
and Fireman Benton came with something to eat, and as soon as
we pumped the brakes off we started, and Benton ran the engine
to Raleigh, and Conductor Orrell was with us, and about ten minutes
after we left there we arrived at Cary, and there was a red board
there, and we stopped while the conductor went in to see what orders
they had for him, and I went to the drug store to see if I could not
get the druggist to put something in my eye. I was suffering every-
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 41
thing I could suffer with my eye. i do not know who the druggist
was. He was a new man, not a licensed druggist, and he was afraid
to tamper with it, and there was no doctor available, and I would
have to tough it out until I got to Raleigh, and I went back to the
engine, and the conductor, Orrell, had the clearance card, and we
left for Raleigh, and I asked them to wire to Raleigh to have a
doctor and carriage meet me at Johnson Street. No ductor, but a
carriage met me, and I got in the carriage and went to Dr. Lewis’
oflice. I did not find Dr. Lewis there. Dr. Rogers said he was
honing for him, and Dr. Lewis came in about five minutes after
Cock there. There was 200 pounds pressure in the boiler at the
time the glass burst. When Dr. Lewis came 1 was sitting in the
chair holding my head, and he came in and took an eye-dropper
and gave me attention, dropped something in my eye and told me
to shut it, and then waited about three or four minutes and put
some kind of liquid in my eye again, and it kind of eased it; Dr.
Lewis treated me 30 to 40 days. The condition of my eye all along
from the time Dr. Lewis first treated me, I suffered some, but, of
course, the older the wound got the less and less I suffered, but the
first three or four nights or the first week I just walked the floor
all night; I could not sleep, and kept hot towels on my face. Dr,
Lewis told me to keep them on. It was about 60 or 90 days before
I opened up my eye to the light; then with respect to my
66 ability to see, I could not see one-third out of that eye as well
as I could before I got hit. Before I was hit I couid see all
tight. The condition of failure to see out of that right eye con-
tinues now. ‘There is no improvement since I first took ‘off the
bandage. I have recently been examined by an oculist, on last
Tuesday by Dr. M. C. Horton, who is no relation of mine. He lives
in Raleigh, and has examined me before that time, May, 1912, the
best I remember. The engine I was operating the day I was in-
jured was equipped with a Buckner water auge. It had this
(points) on there, the frame and the gauge, but this guard glass
was gone. The guard glass is made of glass about ¥% inch thick,
about 1% or %4 wide, and 8 or 10 inches long. The whole equip-
ment is a patented appliance. The guard glass was gone. (Holds
up water gauge.) There is a glass tube in there now. I will hold it
up and show the jury where my face was when I was looking across,
It was this way (illustrates). I was sitting on the left hana side,
and I was sitting crossed over here, facing the glass with the reverse
lever between my legs, backing the engine up and looking back
and across too for signals from anybody, and just as I stopped I
partially raised up; I was going to cross over on the fireman’s side
to see the conductor, whether he was ready to couple up, and that
put me directly facing the glass, with my right eye directly opposite
that slit. I took charge of engine 752 on July 27th or 28th, one
of those dates, I do not remember which. | had the engine two
tound trips, I know; that would be two days to a trip; a round trip
is two days. My schedule time to leave Raleigh was 7:30 in the
morning, and I reached Aberdeen at 4:45, but we seldom got there
on time. I would leave Aberdeen at 6:30 the next morning. The
6—541
——,
42 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES Tt. HORTON.
merning I took this engine, 752, it was at Johnson Street, standing
on the water tank track when | arrived there. It was my regular
engine. I had been in passenger service, and when I came back
they had taken my engine and given it to somebody else. I was
called to take out the local freight with 752. I had been in
67 passenger work about two weeks, between Raleigh and Colum-
bia. We have to report about 30 minutes before leaving
time, and I arrived there at 7:00 o’clock, and I went to filling up
the rod cups and doing various things, tightening up nuts or bolts;
it looked like it was in pretty bad shape, and about 7:20 we ran
out on the main line and backed down on the scales track where the
local freight was made up. It took me 20 minutes to do the work
I had to do on the engine, and you had to hustle to do what you
had to do, to fill eight rod cups and tighten up the set screws.
When I got up in the engine it was time to move it down to where
I had to go, and J hit out and backed down on the seale track and
coupled up to the local freight. I was leaving Johnson Street when
I discovered that there was no guard glass in the Buckner water
gauge. I was around by the Standard Oil Mill, between Johnson
Street and the Union Station, pulling my train out. I discovered
that the glass was gone, and kept running the engine, and went on
to Aberdeen, and the next day I came back to Raleigh. I was run-
ning without a guard glass, Nothing hapnened to the water gauge;
I used and operated it. 1 got back to Raleigh the next evening at
3.00 o’clock; came in on time the best I remember; around 3:00
o'clock. I got off the engine; brought the engine to the round
house, and put it on the coal chute track, and as I stepped down
off the engine Mr. Powie Matthews, who was the day foreman, came
up and asked me how she was, and I told him she was a hospital,
she was shaking and rocking and pounding the blocks, and the
wedges needed setting up.
The plaintiff was permitted to testify over defendant’s objection
and exception:
I told Powie Matthews that the guard glass was gone and asked
if he had any of them. He was the day round house foreman, and
he said no, they did not have any here.
68 To this evidence defendant in apt time objected. Objee-
tion overruled and defendant excepts.
Exception No. 1.
Q. What position did he occupy? ‘
A. Day round house foreman, and he said no, they did not have
any here.
To the statement that “he said no, they did not have any here,”
defendant in apt time objected. Objection overruled, and defend-
ant excepts. Exception No. 2.
Exception No, 2.
The duties of the round house foreman were to see that the
proper work was done and to see that engines were properly equipp
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON. 43
to make successful trips. My duty with respect to the water gauge
and absence of it, was to go to the foreman, and if the guard glass
was gone to see him and ask if he had any, and to get a requisition
and go to the store-room and get one: to get one and put in this slot.
That was all I had to do when I got it. The guard glass was known
as a shield. Yes, it was known as a supply. It was a supply. I
obtained supplies of that character by going to the foreman or gen-
eral foreman and getting a requisition signed by them and going
to the store-room keeper and getting such water glass or lantern
globes, torches, torpedoes, fuses or such as that.
Q. What did you say to Powhatan Matthews?
Objection by the defendant.
By the Court: To any statement as to the water glass the defend-
“nt objects; objection overruled; defendant excepts.
Exception No. 3.
A. I told him the guard glass to the water glass was gone, and
he said they did not have any and did not keep them in stock,
and they were in Portsmouth, but he would send to Ports.
69 mouth and get one. He said: “You will have to run her
like she is,”
I went to the wash-room and washed up and made out my report
and time slips, and went home, and took her out the next morning.
With respect to making out my report, the report was made after
I notified Matthews that the glass was gone, and he told me to run
it. I went out the next morning; that was on August 3rd, the next
morning when I went out. I went to Aberdeen that day, and it was
the next trip I made that I was injured, the best I remember. I
did not go every day, Sunday came in between July 28 and August
- Local freight does not run on Sunday. J did not say that I
had made two round trips and part of another when I was injured,
I was making the second. I was making my second round trip
when I was hurt, I had made one round trip and was on the next
one, and it was on the second trip that the occurrence at Apex was
brought about. I took it out first on the 27th, and if on the 27th I
went to Aberdeen on that date and came back on the 28th. and the
29th was Sunday, and on the 30th I went out again and came back
on the 31st, but during that time I might have been called for a
passenger run to Monroe. I don’t know about that. I know I made
two round trips, possibly three. I know that the pressure of 200
pounds was the proper pressure for that engine. As to whether or
not this Buckner water glass with the protection of that thick piece
of glass was in general use on railroads at that time, I only know
that they were used on the Seaboard. I know that protecting glasses
of similar character were in general use on railroads. 1 have never
measured the dimensions of the tube, I will give an estimate. I
would say it was 12 or 14 inches long and about three-eight-s of an
inch thick and one-half inch in diameter.
Q. State to the jurv why you ran that engine out on the second
trip without the guard glass in, Mr. Horton?
44 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON.
70 Objection by defendant. Objection overruled. Defend-
ants excepts. Exception No. 4.
Exception No. 4.
A. Because I was promised I would have a guard giass when I
returned; Mr. Matthews told me, and I was told to run her and I
had to do it.
By the Court: Strike out what he was promised by Matthews,
that part of it is stricken out, as that was a conclusion. You can
say I ran it because of the conversation I had with Matthews.
A. That is right.
By the Court: All of the answer is stricken out and I will permit
him to say I ran it on account of the conversation with Matthews,
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant
excepts. Exception No. 5.
Exception No. 5.
T at times still suffer with this right eve when I take cold and it
settles in it at times.
Q. Do vou know what the standard ruies are on railroads in re
spect to the vision of engineers?
Objection by the defendant.
Q. Do you know what the requirements are on railroads under
the standard rules of operation in respect to the vision of engineers-—
the eye-sight of engineers?
Objection by the defendant.
Q. I will ask vou this question: State to the jury whether you in
your present condition in respect to the sight of vour right eye you
are able or capable to operate a locomotive engine?
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant
excepts. ..xception No. 6.
Exception No. 6.
71 A. No.
By the Court: Q. You san ask him why, if you want to.
By Mr. Douglass:
Q. Why?
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant
excepts. Exception No. 7.
Exception No. 7.
- On account of the condition of my right eye, impaired eye
sight.
I can state what that is due to. It is due to being hit in it by
flying glass from the water tube, on the occasion stated by me.
After the injury to my eye I suffered; it looked like as bad as a man
could. The first 15 days was the worst suffering. Then as time
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY Vs. JAMES T. HORTON. 45
went by it lessened more and more as the wound healed, and after
about 40 days it was just at times I would have to drop cocaine in
it or have Dr. Lewis give me prescription for about 60 days, and
then I wore smoked glasses for about probably 30 or 60 days. At
night I had to keep hot towels on it if I got any rest at all the first 3
or 4 nights, and then after that I would put 2 or 3 applications on
my eye and that would ease me. As to going to bed the first 3 or 4
nights I would lie down but would have to get up. I was so nervous
and it hurt so bad. I wore a shield over my eye for about 60 or
70 days, the shield and smoked glasses. I was without employ-
ment 9 or 10 months after my injury. I got employment after that,
making inspection for the Wake Water Company, inspecting the
town, at a salary. I started at $15 a week. That lasted a year and
3 or 4 months, the best I can remember, and then I got a raise to
$17.50 a week, about the last 8 months that the Water Company
existed before the city took it over. About a month and a half after
the city got it, they got it last May, the commissioners were
72 elected along the first of July or middle of July, and they
raised me to $25 a week, the commissioners did. The city
paid me the same salary for the 30 days, the first 30 days. They
did not pay me $100 a month, but $25 a week. I am gecting the
$25 a week now, but I do not know how long it will continue.
Objection by Mr. Allen for the defendant as not responsive.
Objection withdrawn.
I am employed until next May under these present commission-
ers. I made an effort to get employment after this injury. I ap-
plied to Mr. C. H. Hix, general manager of the S. A. L. Ry., for
employment and Mr. Stanley, who is the claim agent of the com-
pany.
Q. What reply did they make to you, if any?
Objection by the defendant.
By the Court: It is not a question of the reply, but whether he
could secure employment.
By Mr. Douglass:
Q. State, Mr. Horton, if you failed to get employment with the
Seaboard Air Line Railway on account of the condition of your
eye-sight.
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant
excepts. Exception No. 8.
Exception No. 8.
A. Yes.
After this injury I was not able to see the wound in my eye, I
could see an inflamed streak in there with a mirror. I could pull
it open and see a red streak across my eve by looking in a mirror.
It was a red streak right across right under the bottom of my sight.
You see my other eye was in sympathy with this, and I could not
look at anything-long at the time. At the time of the injury to
46 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
my eye my brother Ernest he ran with me and he waited on
73 me at night and got me hot towels, and my mother and
sister. Ile examined my eye, first and last. The insertion
of the piece of glass in the slots described by me will prevent flying
glass from striking the engineer or other persons in the cab if the
tube explodes.
Cross-examination.
Examination by Mr. Allen:
That is what the glass is for, for the protection of the engineer
or anybody, this guard glass. I have the glass tube here that has
been exhibited, and in this brass cage there is a glass tube like that
one. This part of the water gauge (points) connects with the boiler,
and all of the steam in the boiler of the pressure in the boiler comes
down in that glass tube, and this end (points) is the water connee-
tion and the steam up here, so that the steam that comes from the
boiler down in this tube, which is in the center of that gauge, is
the same pressure as in the boiler. On this occasion it was at least
200 pounds of pressure that came from the boiler down in that tube,
and at that time this guard glass was out. That glass by the move
ment of the water would indicate to me how much water was in
the boiler. That was on the left hand side of the engine, of the
cab, on the fireman’s side. The engineer’s side is the right hand
side. On that side of the boiler were 3 gauges or gauge cocks, one
situated above the other. They were right close at hand, about 2%
inches apart, and they were right close at hand to the engineer,
and he could sit in his seat and reach and turn them. He could
turn those gauge cocks and it would indicate where the water was in
the boiler if they were in working order, but if he had muddy
water, or if the water is muddy or bad, they will stop up. It is the
duty of the engineer to see that they are in working order. Sup-
pose they stop up on the road, you don’t expect a man to s
on the road, do you, and try to blow them out? He can't
74 do that. With reference to the water, my engine was oper-
-ted from Apex by Mr. Benton with the gauge cocks. Mr.
Benton, the fireman, brought the engine in from Apex to Raleigh
using the gauge cocks to tell how much water he had in the boiler.
I took this engine out on the morning of the 27th of July the first.
That is what I remember, it has been so long ago. When I re
turned on the 28th I made out a work report. That work report
is made out by all engineers when they reach a terminal if they
want any work done on the engine. It shows on that work report
the defects on his engine that he wants repaired. The work re
port is placed on a file or in a box in the round house desk
for that purpose, then the foreman or the general foreman takes
that and reads it over, and distributes them to the different ma-
chinists and the different class of mechanics showing the different
work he wants to give to them. Going back to the water gauge, I
did not say with pressure on that tube in the glass cage that that
glass is liable to explode at any time. No, that is not so, I have
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON, 47
run those a year without them exploding. Yes, it is dangerous to
run it without a guard glass. You see the tube might explode. The
guard glass is put there to prevent the explosion of the inner tube
injuring the engineer. The purpose of the guard glass is to make
it safe for the engineer to operate his engine with that Buckner
water gauge. (Witness is shown a paper.) That is my signature,
and that, and that. That is my signature.
Counsel hands witness paper and witness testifies:
It is a form for work report blank for engineers to make out at the
end of the trip.
It is the report they make out when they want repairs made to their
engine. The foreman takes that and distributes it out and the ma-
chinists make the repairs. (Witness is handed a paper.) The date
of that is 7/28/10. That is the date I returned from my first trip.
I made out that work report and put it in the proper place.
75 The date of that is July 28. I made them both out when I
returned from my first trip and put them in the proper place,
and noted on there the work or repairs | wanted done on the engine.
(Witness is handed another paper.) The date of that one is 7/30.
That shows that I took the engine out on a trip on the 29th and
came back on the 30th.
The date of that is 7/30. I made out a work report on the engine
on 7/28 and 7/30. I did not say that I made only two round trips,
Isaid I know I made two and possibly three. I made out this work
report on the second trip, and when the water glass exploded it must
have exploded on the third trip. The report of 7/30 that shows the
repairs | wanted made when I returned from the second trip, it shows
the work I wanted done but it was not done. I did not make a re-
port upon my return from the third trip. These two reports were
_ upon other trips than the time of the explosion of the water
glass,
Q. Under the rules of the company at that time, I was required to
report in writing the repairs I wanted done to my engine.
A. Of course, machinists’ work but supplies you don’t put that
on work reports,
Repairs such as machinists do are put on the work report in
Writing as required by the rules.
I do not know whether the rules of the company say that verbal
reports would not be noticed.
I do not know, but I know they are noticed. I have found many
a defect about an engine and called a machinist’s attention or fore-
man out there and fixed them. I have called them out there when
was standing on the main line and had them repaired. The de-
I wanted repaired I put in writing, the biggest ones. Yes, I
talked with Mr. Matthews and told him that this engine wes a
wreck, I called his attention to most of the items on there. You
could hear the engine pound two blocks, ( Witness is handed
a paper.) I have inspected this and there is no reference on
there to the absence of the guard class, and the reason I did
hot put it on there was I found out from Mr. Matthews that they did
a
48 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
not have any, and it wasn’t any use to put them on there. (Witness
is handed a paper.) I have looked on here and there is no report of
the guard giass being gone. This was the return from the second
trip. Yes, I was examined in the office of the master mechanic. No,
I did not tell him that the reason | did not put it on there was be-
cause I had reported it to Mr. Matthews, I said for reasons best. known
to myself. When that question was asked me in the master me
chanic’s office that is what I replied. As to whether I was asked the
question, according to your statement, this fixture was not equipped
with the guard glass when you made the first trip on the engine,
July 28, had you made any report as to this fixture not being
equipped with the guard glass, you were asked that question, weren't
you? I do not remember. And as to whether I answered No, I do
not remember about that. As to being asked the question Why? I
was asked the question why I had not reported it in writing, and
that was Burrus, the chief clerk, and I said for reasons best known to
myself. (Witness is shown a paper, Exhibit “I”—That is my sig-
nature, I signed that paper.
Exhibits “C,” “D,” “E,” and “F” are identified by witness and are
marked by the Court.
At the time I was examined about this matter I was in Mr. Bissett’s
oftice, the master mechanic. He had the callboy beating on my door
before day it seemed to me, and he was there 5 or 6 mornings before
I could make a statement. I think I went down in a week or 10
days. I was not examined before the master mechanic, it was the
chief clerk, Mr. Burrus. I did not put it down in writing, the sten-
ographer did, typewrote it and I signed it. I signed the typewritten
statement that was made at that time. When I ran on the local
freight I would spend a night in Aberdeen and a night in Raleigh.
Well, yes, I had my expenses to pay in Aberdeen for my
77 room, but we boarded on the cab, and we figured out what
the groceries were we bought at Sanford and we figured up
what it was at the end of the month.
Me and the fireman roomed together in Aberdeen. I think we
paid $6.00 between us. You see, we were only in Aberdeen every
other night. There are two local freight crews and the room rented
for $10 or $12 a month, and me and my fireman slept in it one
night and the other crew slept in it the next night. I think it cost
us $2.50 or $3.00 each a month.
My board would average from $3.00 to $4.50 a month. It varied,
of course, at different times. We did not get but one meal a day on
the cab, that’s going and coming.
I had a room here in Raleigh, and when I left here going south
we got supper at Aberdeen. For dinner, we usually carried lunch.
Coming back, we did not get any dinner unless we bought a little
knick-knack. We did not buy it if we were on time unless we were
awfully hungry. The run was best coming back, and we made it
fast, as we were anxious to get home. Sometimes, not often, probably
once a month, I would be late in the evening. It would have to be
a derailment or wreck or engine failure or something or extra move
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON. 49
ment of freight. We usually came in here on time. We were due
here at 3:30, and we did not miss it but one time in two months. I
was not paid by the runs I made, but was paid by the trips, miles
and hours. As to extra pay connected with the job, there was plenty
of over-time, make all of the overtime you wanted, more than you
wanted, I was not paid monthly, I was paid by the mile and hour.
They paid me every 16th of the month. Phat would give me a check
for whatever was due. I would go to the agent’s office and sign for
the check and carry it to the bank. That would show the previous
month’s work. That would usually show the amount due, but I have
had checks short. At the last of the month if you put in a trip
late, that might be too late and so then they would put that
78 in the next month’s check. They would figure all that was
due in one month and put it in one check unless the check
amounted to over $200 and then they would give you two checks. I
have drawn two checks several times. I averaged from $165 to $190
a month. I made that for the year prior to August, 1910, I made
more than that sometimes ; that was just an average. So far as laying
off, this was my run and I could work every day if I wanted to.
Answering your question, “taking the 12 months previous, would
you average $165,” I will say I was not on that run all of the time.
I ran from here to Monroe part of the time on Red Ball freight.
That paid more. I took that run some months before, 4 or 5, and
that run would average $165; I would make $140, $160 and $199,
and some months I would lay off part of the month. My average
would run from $155 to $190 if I ran all of the time. I testified that
I would average $165 to $190 a month. That was what I was making
so far as I know, but some months I would lay off during that time.
I do not know exactly what I made. I know Mr. Douglass asked me
what I made, not what I could have made. I have made as high as
$20-. I averaged from $165 to $190. I do not remember whether
I swore on the last trial that I averaged $165,
I do not remember whether I testified to that at the last trial.
(Witness is shown several, 12, pay checks.) I identify my signature
on those checks. They are the pay checks for the period shown.
I will look through them and see if there were not times within
the year prior to August, 1910, in which I only made $90 a month,
between $90 and $100?
I have looked at that and refreshed my memory, that is only
$91.68. I may have dropped out a few trips that month. I could
have made more than that if I worked. That shows that I made
$91.68 that month, here is one $139.43 and here is $140.15 and here
is one $91.05 for the month of March, 1910. Here is one $147.01
and $172.15. I cannot tell if that is the highest, I have not
seen them all. $132.76 and $132.50. This must have been
the one I only worked the 4 days, $27.67. $174.16 is the
highest one in there. The lowest is about $90. The period that
covers is that last 12 months that I worked for the Seaboard. These
checks will show what I averaged during the last 12 months.
By the Court: The witness in this case having testified that these
7—541
50 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
particular checks which were handed to him were the actual amounts
that he received from the Seaboard Air Line for the months therein
stated for his services as locomotive engineer, counsel for the de-
fendant having asked him to sum up the 11 months prior to his
injury and state what the general average was, the plaintiff objects.
Objection overruled. Exception.
$138.10 not counting the part of the month for August.
I am now working for the city as meter inspector. I do not read
meters, I overhaul them. I am a mechanic, and work on the water
meters that are placed around in the town. I do that work at the
water tower in the workshop. i repair all defects in the meters.
They are brought for me to put in proper repair and see whether
they are working properly. I test them. When I first went to work
for the water company I read meters, up until the city took the plant,
and they began to buy a lot of meters and the work got so heavy in
rebuilding the meters I was needed for other service. A boy can
read a meter, and they relieved me. Before being employed by the
Wake Water Company I was employed by the Democratic Head-
quarters. I had charge of the Straight Democratic Headquarters,
there were two factions. I made $25, I could have made more if 1
had double-crossed. I mean by that a certain faction offered me a
certain sum of money to give them some information. ‘They offered
me to sell out, and offcered me a pretty flattering piece of money,
$250.
Objection by Mr. Douglass for plaintiff.
By the Court: I do not think it is competent.
I do not recall making other money during the 8 or 9
80 months spoken of. I am now making $25 a week. No, not
$1,250 but $1,300 a year, 52 weeks. I make $1,300 a year.
The Seaboard Air Line Railway did have a store house down here at
Johnson Street when I worked there, I suppose so now, I say they
did at the time I was working there. The general storekeeper was in
Portsmouth.
At that time the Seaboard haa two passenger trains each way be-
tween Raleigh and Portsmouth.
It had two each way, 32 and 33 and 38 and 41. They were the
regular trains from Portsmouth here.
32 was going towards Portsmouth and left here about 2:20 at
night or 1:40 and got into Portsmouth about 8:00 or 8:30 in the
morning. 33 left Portsmouth about 8:00 or 9:00 o’clock and got
in here next morning about 2:00 or 3:00. The Seaboard passenger
train made a round trip each day.
The trains of the Seaboard at that time I was employed with them
were operated under rules. (Witness is handed a book of rules.)
am looking to see if it has a date on it. Yes, that is the book of rules
in force at the time. Rule 668 was in force at that time.
Q. And wasn’t there a rule in force at that time requiring that an
engineman must report to——
Objection by Mr. Douglass for the plaintiff.
--
By the Court: That puts it so you can introduce anything in that
book. He states that these rules were in effect at that -ime. I will
identify the whole book, and counsel can offer such rules as they de-
sire.
By Witness Horton: I went to Dr. Whitaker about 30 or 40 days
after I was hurt, He is an eye specialist here. I paid him $5 to
examine my eyes and tell me their condition. I have never been
back? Yes, I have talked to him. I have been back for treatment.
This spring I went back for a prescription, but I wasn’t there 10
minutes. At the time I filed my complaint, I suppose I had paid
$5 or $10 for medicine and doctors. I do not know whether I had
spent $6.55 or not, $5 for medicine [?] and 65 cents for
81 medicine. I do not know exactly, Mr. Allen, or I would tell
you, but I can not remember exactly. Yes, I was asked the
question and answered it that I paid Dr. Whitaker and Dr. Horton
$5 each for examining my eyes and 65 or 70 cents for medicine, and
paid Dr. Horton $5 after the suit was brought. Dr. Horton examined
me just prior to the other trial in 1912. I paid him $5 for that ex-
amination. I did not go back for treatment. I said I ought to
wear lens glasses. I swore to that complaint. Yes, I swore in that
complaint that I had spent large sums for medical attention and
medicine. I did belong to the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers
and do now and am in good standing. At that time I did belong to
it. The Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers had a working agree-
ment with the railroad. (Witness is handed a paper.) I have
looked at that paper. It is a copy of our agreement or contract with
the company. I had a copy of that. That was the contract with the
company that was in force at the time of the injury.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON, 51
By Mr. Douglass: We object to that. You must identify your
paper.
The paper in question is identified by the witness,
When I came back to Raleigh from the last trip on August 4th,
I went right to the washroom, took off my overalls and washed my
face and changed my clothes before coming up town, and put my
overalls in my grip and I had a cupboard in the washroom and put
my grip in there. I do not remember whether I came up town that
night, I suppose so. I did not testify before that I went to the ball
game the next day, I did not say the next day, but if I was able to get
there, I was there. I don’t know whether I went to the ball game
the first or second day. I do not remember the day, but if I could get
there, I was there. Raleigh had a ball club at season. When that
inner tube exploded in this water glass hot water and small pieces
of glass and steam filled the cab until it was closed off.
82 The Buckner glass is a safe water gauge, with the guard
glass in place.
hat is an important part of the Buckner water glass. That, so
far as the protection of the engineer is concerned, is the most im-
- portant part. That is valuable, when it is in the proper place, sim-
ply because that glass affords protection to the engineer. When it is
52 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS, JAMES T. HORTON.
out of the proper place, the water glass does not afford proper protec-
tion, this Buckner glass does not. The connection was so arranged
with the boiler that you could cut off the steam entirely by that valve,
It was so arranged that you could cut off the water entirely by that
valve. That would cut the glass out,
Of course, there would be no danger. I could have cut off the
water and steam by simply turning these two valves,
I don’t know that engines have been run with the gauge cocks
a long time before the water gauge was ever put on them,
Objection by the plaintiff. Objection overruled. Exception,
I don’t know that. Every one I was on had a water glass.
Yes, you can operate an engine without a water gauge, but with
the water cocks, but not as well. You can not keep these cocks open.
They are liable to stop up, but a water glass has got so much bigger
opening here than the gauge cock. They are the safest things at all,
as they do not stop up like the gauge cocks, like all of the gauge cocks
I have seen. I have run an engine many a time with the gauge
cocks stopped up. Yes, you can run an engine without the water
glass and with the gauge cocks if they stay open. I could have run
this engine without the water glass and with the gauge cocks if they
were in working order. Were they in working order or not? My
opinion one of them possibly was working all right. I think possibly
a little steam would come out of them. I don’t think I made any
report at that time of the gauge cocks, I went by the water glass.
Yes, it was my duty to report on that engine, but the water was
83 muddy. We just got the drainings from Johnson Street. It
was my duty to report the gauge cocks if they were not in
working order. I do not know whether I saw each morning that the
auge cocks were in working order. Whether it was my duty to do
it, depends upon whether I had time or not.
In that 30 minutes I filled up 8 rod cups with grease, and took and
oiled the engine around and looked at the valve stems and eccentric.
You got about 20 or 30 minutes’ work before you can get up in the
engine. The first thing an engineer does is to set his rip up there
0, t
and tell the fireman to hand him a wrench and oil can. e first
thing I see to it not the gauge cocks, but the first thing I do is to
open the fire door and look at the crown sheet. No, the next thing
is not to look at the gauge cocks, I look at the water glass. Was it
my duty to see that the gauge cocks were working? It was the round
house duty to see that they were working. Was it my duty to see
that they were working before I went out? If they were not work-
ing they would tell you to go on. They would not take an engine
back in the round house and blow it out. It was not my duty to try
the gauge cocks, I used to look at the water glass. I noticed that the
guard glass was gone when I was out of Johnson Street, around by
the Standard Oil Company. We were going this way (pointing) and
the sun was plainer around there in the morning. I noticed there
that the guard glass was gone. I knew it was dangerous to an engi-
neer’s eyes. I did not cut out the glass. I guess I tried the water
cocks, I must have. I think I did. I went to Aberdeen, made the
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY V8. JAMES T. HORTON. 53
round trip and returned on the 30th with the guard glass in that
condition. On none of these trips did I cut out the water glass and
used the gauge cocks. The opening of the gauge cock is not the same
as the opening of the water glass. It is a small copper pipe, a size
smaller than this (indicates) and is easily stopped up. You can not
turn the steam on them and blow them out, not if they are
84 packed up with mud. You can clean them out and do clean
them out by running a piece of wire in there. I did not cut
the water glass out during the time the guard glass was gone and I
was running this engine. I did not attempt to cut it off, I needed it,
I did not attempt to run my engine without it. Yes, I had a water
= to explode with me once before, or rather the man TI was firing
or did. I don’t remember whether it was in 1902 or 1903. It was
in Anson County, near Russelville, a pass track, where it exploded.
No, the glass did not hit my eye, the hot water and steam did. I lost
two round trips. I think it paid $2.40. When that glass exploded
it blew glass all over the cab.
(The witness upon request exhibits his eye to the jury.)
Q. Without that guard glass in there, did I know that inner tube
would be liable to explode and hurt somebody?
Objection by the plaintiff and objection is sustained as the ques-
tion as been asked and answered a number of times,
By the Court: I will let him answer it one more time.
I knew that with that guard glass out that the tube was liable to
explode with the 200 pounds pressure on it. I knew that it was liable
to explode, but I could not tell when.
It was lable to explode at any time. No, I did not know if it did
explode without the guard glass that it would be liable to hurt the
engineer, as I have seen lots of them explode without hurting the
engineer. Yes, the guard glass is there to protect the engineer, I
have told you that.
After this accident I thought I was able to run an engine,
Yes, and I am now, and I can run an engine with any man in the
world, if I can get a job. I don’t stand aside for anybody, and my
record on the Seaboard will show it.
And right now I can run an engine with anybody. Yes, if I can
get a job, but I can not get the job.
85 Redirect examination.
Examination by Mr. Douglass:
Q. You said something about handing in a large list of repairs to
be a to the engine on the day before this injury to your eye?
es.
Q. Did they do that work?
A. Not a bit of it. I believe they did open the sand pipes.
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant ex-
ts.
Exception No. 9,
54 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
I was asked awhile ago about going to a ball game. I went to the
ball game. I could see well enough to see that Mr. Allen was there,
I think he was there. I think I spoke to him and he asked me how
I was. I had a bandage on my eye. I used cocaine and salve in it,
which eased it temporarily. I carried my eye dropper and cocaine
in my pocket.
Q. Was it your duty under the rules of this company to put the
missing gauge glass on that work report?
Objection by the defendant on the ground that the rules them-
selves require that they be in writing. Objection overruled. De
fendant excepts.
Exception No. 10.
A. All that is necessary is to go get a requisition.
Q. Was that repair within the rule requiring it to be in writing?
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant ex-
cepts.
Exception No. 11.
A. No, it is a supply.
Q. Is there any rule requiring a written report for a supply?
A. No.
86 Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. De
fendant excepts.
Exception No. 12,
Q. I ask you if it was a proper thing for an engineer to do?
Objection by the defendant.
Q. Compare to the jury, if you can, the danger or safety of run-
ning an engine with the water glass closed and with the gauge cocks,
depending upon the gauge cocks, and running without a shield on
the water glass?
Objection by the defendant. Objection sustained for the reason
that this has been over on both the direct and cross examination,
By Mr. Simms: Does your Honor understand that it is in the record
that it was more dangerous to attempt to run it with the gauge cocks
than with the water glass?
By the Court: Yes, he said that, because they would stop up.
To the foregoing statement defendant in apt time objects. Objec-
tion overruled. Defendant excepts.
Exception No. 13.
Q. Who was it you say examined you about this matter?
A. Chief Clerk Burrus.
Q. Did he have any right to examine you about it?
Objection by the defendant.
Q. The Court says you may explain why you told Mr. Burrus
you did not report that guard glass for reasons best known to your
self.
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 55
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant
excepts.
Exception No, 14,
87 A. He asked me why I did not put it on my work report
and the reason was because I had been to some one higher
than him and he said he did not have any. Mr. Matthews was higher
than—over Mr, Burrus,
By Mr. Allen: I will ask your Honor to strike that out.
By the Court:
Q. Didn’t you say you told him that right there?
A. No, I did not tell him that.
By Judge Biggs: We ask your Honor to strike that out.
By the Court: I will leave that in and give you an exception,
To the refusal to strike out this evidence, defendant objects. Ob-
jection overruled. Defendant excepts.
Exception No. 15.
a
did not accept the $250 offered me, as that would have been selling
my principle. I will state that the cost of living has increased since
I boarded as I testified to at Aberdeen,
By Witness Horton: Mr, Allen asked me about my earnings, I
Recross-examination :
Yes, I was examined in April, 1911, at the first trial. Replying
to your question if I said anything at that time about Mr. Matthews
telling me to run that engine that way, I told you at the last trial if
I'did not say it I intended to say it. I cannot’ remember everything
Isaid. It was 4 years ago. I cannot remember whether 1 testified
that I ran the first time to Aberdeen and upon my return to Raleigh
I asked Mr. Matthews, the foreman, if he had any glass and he suid
no, that they were put in in Portsmouth and he had none; that he
was the foreman at Johnson Street. I do not remember saying on
the first trial, in answer to question, “When did you, say anything to
Mr. Matthews about the guard glass being out of the gauge?”
88 that it was after the first trip or second trip I ran the engine..
I do not remember saying that I asked him if he had any
Buckner shields, and he sai no, that the glasses were put in at
Portsmouth. If I did not say in my first examination in this case
that Mr, Matthews told me to run the engine like she was, I intended
fo, I do not know whether I said it or not. I did not say at that
time upon my return on August 4th, that on that afternoon I went
over to Mr. Charley Murray at the Baker Thompson Lumber Com-
ny and asked him to cut me a glass. I did not testify that at the
st trial. Yes, I asked him, but I did not do it on August 4th.
That was after I came back from the first trip, that I asked Charley
Murray to cut the glass and after I talked with Mr. Matthews.
Charley Murray was glass-cutter at the Baker Thompson Lumber
mpany. It was not my business to ask Mr, Matthews to cut me a
56 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON.
glass. No, I did not ask Mr. Matthews to cut me a glass, but I did
ask Mr. Murray. I swore the last time that a piece of glass could be
cut, a ea piece of glass and fitted down in there. That’s how they
are made,
James T, Horton, the plaintiff in this case, having been recalled,
testifies as follows:
Redirect examination:
Objection by defendant to the recall of this witness.
(By Mr. Douglass: )
Q. State to the jury what you meant in your cross examination by
saying that you could run an engine as good as you ever could?
Objection by the defendant. Objection overruled. Defendant
excepts.
Exception No. 16.
89 A. I meant I knew as much about an engine mechanically
as I ever did, but I could not see to run it.
Objection by Judge Biggs for the defendant to this answer. Ex-
ception. |
Recross-examination.
By Mr. Allen:
I said I could run an engine as good as any man mechanically.
I did not say mechanical!,”, but I do say it. I said I could run an
engine as good as any man.
Dr. M. C. Horton, e witness for the plaintiff, having been duly
sworn, testifies as follows:
Direct examination.
Examination conducted by Mr. Douglass:
I am not related in any way that I know of to Mr. J. T. Horton.
I am a graduate of the medical college and practice on the eye, ear,
nose and throat.
It is admitted that Dr. Horton is an expert.
I have been practicing on the eye, ear, nose and throat for 7 years
in Norfolk, New York and Raleigh. I was raised out here in Wake
County, Wakefield. . Have had occasion to examine J. T. Horton's
right eye. Do not exactly remember the date, it was in 1912. ound
a scar running across the cornea, that is the part of the eye that shows
dark across in front there, diagonally across, at about an angle
120 degrees. Shall I make myself more explicis, Witness makes
drawing on paper. I will make myself as explicit as I can. You have
a circle and the vertical line is 90, up and down this way, and this#
100, and so on, down here, and that was 120 here. There was a lineat
SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON. 67
sear. This is 180 and this is 90 and this 90 is supposed to be vertical,
and this 180 horizontal. This line runs across the cornea at
90 axis about 120, and extends almost across the entire cornea.
The cornea is the transparent portion of the eye concerned in
refraction, the anterior portion of the eye consisting of no blood
vessels, It is the transparent portion of the eye. In respect to the
sight, the cornea refracts the light. The effect of such a scar upon
one’s sight, a sear upon the eye there, passing as it docs across the
central portion, so there is ibly a smoky effect, it is translucent,
this scar is, and naturally Page rays of light do not pass through that
sear as readily, and even if they do pass through they are not ac-
cepted or interpreted as light, ia other words, you can not see through
a translucent body. It is as if you breathed ‘on a window pane. It
not only has the effect of not being able to see through that trans-
lucent part, but there is a ce:tain amount of contraction in the line
of this linear scar. There is always contraction where there is scar
tissue. That is brought about in the healing process. ‘The cornea
has no blood vessels and therefore it has not healing properties. It
has not the capacity to heal like your hand or anywhere else which is
external. There are no blood vessels in there. as it would be impossi-
ble to see through them. I am speaking of the first time I examined
him. In this axis there is a contraction. It is rather hard for me to
say what I think and make myself plain. A contraction in the axis
of 120 shortens the meridian in the opposite direction, doesn’t it, but
it does not shorten it in the axis 120. If I take that handkerchief.
up this way at 120 it does not shorten at 120 but it shortens it up this
way. It makes the line of shortening in an almost exactly opposite
divection from the line of the scar. It naturally does that, because
it simply pulls across this way. The effect that has upon the sight
or vision, that has the effect of shortening here, and has the effect of
producing an astigmatism where the rays of light do not focus in the
same point on the retina. You ask me, Is that in addition to this
smoky appearance that the scar causes? That is purely a re-
91 sult of the contraction in that meridian, makes one meridian
of the eye shorter than the other. The scar tissue makes that
shorter, and it naturally makes that smoky as the rays of light do
hot pass through there. The condition of that eye has the same effect
upon the distance or nearness of vision. At this examination I meas-
ured the amount of the astigmatism incident to this contraction
across here. We oculists have some fractional estimates by which we
express the condition of the sight. The normal vision is 20-20, that
means by actual measurement of the eye, putting a patient at 20
feet distant, the letters are measured by the angle of the vision, so
to speak.. We use a unit of measure. It is a unit of measure and
means nothing as accepted by the profession all over the world meas-
uring by this angle of vision, and we say a person who sees a line
there, a certain size, at 20 feet, represents normal vision, that is 20-20.
In my examination of Mr. Horton, the figures I used to express the
vision in his right eye, if I recall correctly, was 20-70. That means,
20-70 means, we have 20-20, 20-40, 20-50, 20-70, 20-100, 20-200,
and all of these letters are graded in proportion. 20-20 is normal,
8—541
58 SEABOARD AIR LINE RAILWAY VS. JAMES T. HORTON,
20-40 is one angle larger, and 20-50 is another, and 20-70 is the third.
20-70 simply represents that the man sees the lines that are measured
and have been accepted as standard vision, being measured 20-70 at
20 feet and graded from 20-20 on down, 20-40, 20-50 and 20-70, He
would have to stand within 7 feet of the object to sce the 20-20
line. I had occasion on the 22nd of this month to examine Mr.
Horton, at which time I examined the sca
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.