Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Tseng Fu Lin v. City of Goldsboro

Supreme Court brief1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

BARES RSS ES

Supreme Court, U.8.

FILSD

(\ :

W) 952040 MAY 7 199%

OFFICE OF PHE OLERK

No. 96-

RERKRKKARARKEKKKRRRKRKREKKRRKRRARERRARAE

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

October Term, 1995

RRRRAAAKRAREKRKERERRRARERARRRRRRRRRERE

TSENG FU LIN, d/b/a

ORIENTAL JADE RESTAURANT,

Petitioner

We

CITY OF GOLDSBORO, FLOYD

MCKEEL, Agent, and CHARLES R. SOUTHERLAND,

Respondents

On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari

To The North Carolina Court of Appeals

RRAKKKERARAARRRARRARERRRARKRKREKKRRRKE

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

dbcbhehebbtd dd tt ttt iti titi tii iiiitititty

Robert E. Fuller, Jr., Esquire

Counsel of Record

109 North William Street, Suite 4

Goldsboro, North Carolina 27530

(919) 735-7496

May 6, 1996 Attorney for Petitioner

RECEIVED |

JUN 17 1996

OFFICE OF THE CLERK

SUPREME COURT, U.S.

HU \f

QUESTIONS PRESENTED

z. WERE THE PETITIONER'S CONS'I'({TUTIONAL

RIGHTS VIOLATED WHEN HIS USE OF ROPERTY WAS

DENIED, HIS WATBR CONNECTION WAS “UT OFF,

HIS WATER WOR ‘S WERE SEIZED WITHOU?’ A WARRANT,

HIS LICENSES WERE CONFISCATED WITHOUT CAUSE BY

THE CITY OF GOLDSBORO, FLOYD M. McKEEL, AGENT,

AND CHARLES R. SOUTHERLAND WITHOUT AFFORDING

THE PETITIONER A HEARING? EXCEPTION NO.1

[APP-12]

II. DID THE COURT ERR IN GRANTING THE

RESPONDENTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN

INVALIDATING THE CITIZENS 'CONSTITUTIONAL

RIGHTS, AND THE LAW OF THE UNITED STATES 33

USCS ST. 1251 AND 42 USCS 1983? [APP-12]

ii

REFERENCE OF THIS CASE

Tseng Fu Lin v. City of Goldsboro, et.al,

COA 95-657, the N.C. Court of Appeals rendered

and filed an opinion on December 19, 1995,

requiring a citizen to give up his

constitutional protection entirely for

Executive Privilege and Immunity. This

decision is clearly in contradiction with at

least three (3) prior Federal Court of Appeals

decisions regarding Executive Privileges and

Immunities under USCS Section 1983. The

following are submitted as selected cases

which are in contradiction:

1. Nelson v. Knox (1958) CA 6 Mich 256

F.2d 312.

2. Gaffiney v. Silk (1973) CA 1 Mass

488 F.2d 1248.

3. Birnbaun v. Trusell (1965) CA 2 N.Y.

347 F.2d 86.

iii

Also please see the following:

1. City of Laudue et.al. v. Margaret Pp.

Gilleo 512

US 129, 36 L. Ed 114 (92-1856).

2. Harlowe v. Fitzgerald (1982) 457 US

800.

3. Youngstown Sheetmetal and Tubing,

343 US 579.

The privileges and immunities of the

Executive Branch does not necessarily require

a citizen to give up his or her constitutional

rights. This Court in Harlow v. Fitzgerald,

457 US 800 (1982), ruled in favor of this

position.

The ruling in the case at bar by the

North Carolina Court of Appeals in upholding

the ruling of the lower court arms municiple

employees with the power to affect a citizen's

livelihood-here the cutting off of water-

iv

anytime they choose. This type of

unrestricted activity goes beyond the boundary

of the law in 33 USCS mgt Fe 1251.

In the instant case, the lower courts

invalidated the Constitution and it's Laws,

allowing the city employees' judgment to be

substituted for the proper agency or agencies

opens the door for abuse and the potential

sacrifice of the citizen's rights guaranteed

by the Equal Protection Clause of the

Constitution. This principle; the methods

used in enforcing City Ordinances which

disregard the rights, integrities,

Constitutional guarantees and abandon

safeguards for those rights of the citizens;

need to be examined and ruled upon by this

Court. If this Court does not hear this

matter, the reality is that people must live

in this great land without the rights to speak

Vv

out, to be heard concerning change, to work

out whereby they may obey the law and to

correct any violations. In his book, The

Realm of Law, Albert V. Dicey states at pages

188-195 the following:

"No man is punishable or can be lawfully

made to suffer in body or goods

except for a distinct breach of law

established in ordinary legal manner

before the ordinary Court of the

land."

",..No man is above the law. Every man

is subject to the

ordinary law of the realm."

vi

TABLE OF CASES

Birnbaum v. Trusell, (1965), CA 2 N.¥., 347 F

2nd 86 Coe eee eee eee eee eee eeeeeeeseseseeeps iii

Blanchard v. Baker, 8 ME 253 eeoeeeeeeeee eps 18

City of Laudue et al _v. Margaret P. Gilleo,

512 US - 129 LED 2nd 36, 114 sct .. pp. iv, 27

Dohany v. Rogers, 281 US 362 74 LED 904 (1930)

eee eee eee eee eee ee ee 8 or 18

Dolan _v. City of Tigard, 129 LED 2nd 304

(1994) coer eee eee eeesesseseeeeseses pps 19, 26

Gaffiney v. Silk, (1973), CA 1 Mass., 488 F

BAG T24E co cccsviccdcccdvevcveccecssvecdsecespe. S44

Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 US 800 (1982)

Coe eee eee eereeererssessssesssesses PPs iv, 26

Lucas _v. South Carolina Coastal Council, 505

US 120 LED 2nd ee e#oeee#ee#e#eee#e#e#e#e¢ e*eeeeee#seeee#e#e¢ Pp. 19

Marbury v. Madison, 1 Granch 137 (1803)

CeCe ee ee eee reser eeeeseeeseesesesesepps 24, 27

’

628 F SUPP 1018 eeenreeeet#ePeneeeeee#n#s#eenenseseeeneeee Pp. 15

New York Times Co. v. United States, 1971,

403, US 713 ee ee ee es ©) or 1S, 29

Nelson v. Knox, (1958), CA 6 Mich., 256 F 2nd

31S ccocccveevvcccteccceseeceseeeceseeseets Bas

New Orleans Waterworks v. Rivers, 29 LED 525.6

St. 273 (1885) e*eeseeeeoesee@ee#eee#eee#ee#ee#ee#e#e#«¢ Ppp. 16, 25

vii

Ogden v. Sounders, 12 Wheat 213 ........ p. 28

Oyama v. California, 332 US 633 (1948) . p. 22

Roberts v. New York, 295 US 264 79 LED 1429,

Supreme Court, 689 eeeeseeoaeeeeeeeeeeneeeoeeeee p. 20

Turpin v. Lemon, 187 US 51 47 LED 70.23

Supreme Court 20 (1902) ....eseeeceeeeee Pe 18

United States v. Carolene Product Co., 304 US

144 (1938) CoCr eee eres eseseeeeseseesesesesps 27

United

EL, 126 LED 2nd 490-491 e*ee4e#e#se2s+ee*ee#ee#ee#*ee#*ee#ee#ee#ee#e¢ p. 19

Wong Sun v. United States, 371 US 471 (1963)

Coe eee eee eereeeeeeseseeeeeeeseeseesesesesssseps 20

Youngstown Sheetmetal and Tubing Co. v.

Sawyer, 343 US 579 (1952) ......... pp. iv, 25

—

TABLE OF AUTdORITIES

, Volume 26, Eminent

Dorman, Section 98 eeeeoeeee#neeeeneeeneeeeeeee#e p- 19

American Jurisprudence, Volume 78, Water,

Chapter VIII, Section 232, Definition of Water

Rights and Privileges .......eeeeeeeeeeepe 16

American Jurisprudence, Volume 78, Waterworks

and Water Company, Chapter IX, Rules and

Regulations of Municipality Supply Water

eee errors eesereeeseeeeeeeseeseeseseseseseseepes 16

United States Constitution

RECSOLSG 1, BOGCIOR © ccccvccssvcevsteesese

ccccovceceecddctssccesecdcca BOe 44, V7: 40. 26

aetiolia IV, .BOSCies 3 cc20000008024b46000%

ccccevesoeneeseesoceecectaeceeete: Me S55 Ve 20

Article VI, second sentence .......seeee0.

iw) Ate endehnndes 4h thn 2 a, See

Amendment V .ccccccccce Bp 11,'V, 11, 26

AmenGpent 1% cccccccivesS@ 44,: 9; 1234: :49

Amendment XIV ......... pp. ii, v, 12, 25

Martin Luther King, Jr., August 28, 1963,

Washington speech, "I Have a Dream" .... p. 23

33 USCS St. 1251 (a) ..pp. v, 2, 9, 13, 27, 29

33 USCS St. 1251 (b) ..pp. v, 2, 9, 13, 27, 29

33 USCS Bt. 19913. (4) ..mp. ¥,. 3,. 9.33, 27.29

$3 USCS St. 1251 (¢): + pe. ¥,°25 9, 23627429

The Realm of Law, Albert V. Dicey, ist Ed.,

pp. 168 - 195, end p.: 1868S: sccecccivsctis Pe Vi

ix

—_

1994 Clean Water Act .......pp. v, 2, 8, 9, 20

42 USCS, Section 1983 ......pp. iii, 9, 13, 27

STATEMENT OF FACT

Petitioner, Tseng Fu Lin, has owned and

operated a restaurant in Goldsboro, North

Carolina, since 1976. The restaurant is

located on 5.43 acres, and is bordered by U.S.

Highway 117 Bypass, 117 Business, along with

others and surrounded by other city

properties. The building size is 22,400

square feet, one part for the Oriental Jade

Restaurant; the other part leased for

operation of a grocery store known as the A&P

Building.

Sometime in 1990, the City authorized a

jail facility to be installed on nearby

property. Because some problems developed in

association with the City approval of this

site, there were many protests from citizens.

On March 11, 1991, the sewer line backed up

and grievances were aired in public hearings.

The City authority blamed the Petitioner as

the cause of the contaminates which affected

users further down stream. Since this cause

arose under US 33 USCS Section 1251, the Clean

Water Protection Law, Pet tioner requested

Federal and State Environmental Administrators

tc investigate what the core of the problem

was with an eye to try to improve the

situation. After investigation, federal

authorities declined to take any action

against the Petitioner because the State

environmental agency already determined that

the Petitioner had complied with the Law by

having a Grade A Report [APP-15].

On March 24, 1993, the city plumbing

inspector, Mr. John Hales, certified a letter

to Petitioner and ordered him to install a

grease trap. At that time, the Petitioner was

equipped with many devices approved on the

record and the certified letter did not state

2

Clearly which building code section the

Petitioner had violated. The Petitioner

rushed to North Carolina Building Code

Enforcement Agency for help. The agency

informed the Petitioner of their decisions not

to prosecute the violation under state

authority [APP-16].

On July 15, 1993, the restaurant

~ experienced an arson fire which the local fire

department put out in time. The Petitioner's

property sustained limited damage. After the

investigation, the Court convicted offender

and the City Building Inspection Department

issued a permit to repair. There was no

structural construction involved, thus

limiting the repairs. All of the operations

licenses were to remain in effect, and the

Petitioner maintained his good standing with

all utility services. By November, 1993, all

2

the repair work had been completed. After

inspections, the property was permitted to be

used for the same past use. Several days

later, Mr. John Hales came over and started

taking action to shut off Petitioner's

operations at the restaurant and the vacant

grocery store, stating that the Petitioner did

not comply with his order in the March 1993

letter. Within a week and more specifically

on December 1, 1993, the Petitioner filed a

petition for variance with the city manager

and the city attorney [APP-18].

On December 7, the Petitioner received

from the Respondent, Chief Building Inspector

Floyd M. McKeel, a certified letter ordering

water and electricity to be cut off.

On December 15, the Petitioner's

waterworks, lines, gauge valves and meter

regulators were confiscated by Respondent,

4

City Utilities Director Charles R. Southerland

and the City of Goldsboro Police Department.

Thus, the property's exclusive rights to use

had been taken and the privileges and

immunities and other constitutional protection

were gone like the dust with the wind. After

an injunction against the actions of the

Respondents was denied by the Wayne County

Superior Court, the Petitioner installed the

grease trap as specified. The restaurant's

water was back on. The grocery store's water

was still off. The Petitioner experienced the

loss of water works and the property is under

a foreclosure sale which Petitioner contends

is the result of the Respondent's actions in

not allowing him to operate his business.

[APP-23].

STATEMENT OF CASE

The Petitioner filed a Complaint on April

20, 1994, asking for damages, both actual and

punitive, from the Respondents under the

Constitutional protection and for his

utilities to be turned back on under the State

licensing authority. A preliminary injunction

was denied on May 26, 1994 ... [APP-34]. The

Respondents filed a counterclaim on June 27,

1994. The Petitioner filed his reply on July

8, 1994. On November 29, 1994,the Respondents

filed a Motion for Summary Judgment and was

granted such on January 30, 1995, on the basis

of governmental immunities [APP-36].

This cause came before the North Carolina

Court of Appeals on December 18, 1995. Its

opinion was filed on December 19, 1995,

affirming the lower court. In affirming the

6

trial court, the Court finds that the

Petitioner is not entitled to the property

interest which has constitutional protection.

The Petitioner filed for discretionary

review on January 5, 1996, [APP-36]. LA

certified copy of the record was filed with

the North Carolina Supreme Court [APP-54].

After consideration, the discretionary

review was denied on February 8, 1996, and an

Order was entered in the North Carolina Court

of Appeals on February 22, 1996.

GROUND OF PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

On January 30, 1995, the Superior Court

of Wayne County, North Carolina, in granting

the Respondent's Summary Judgment finds:

A. Under the doctrine of governmental

immunities, the Respondents are entitled to

ee ee ee ee Tee

summary judgment. Thereby, the citizen's

Claim under the Fifth and Fourteenth

Amendments for due process and just

compensation protection were denied [APP-1];

and

B. The Court expressed concern for due

process of law under the procedures used in

this case [APP-1}.

In affirming the Trial Court, the North

Carolina Court of Appeals’ opinion filed on

December 19, 1995 finds:

A. A municipal corporation is the owner

and title holder of clean water. The

corporation shall be able to do what ever it

sees fit and is not under any scrutiny under

the law and constitution [APP-61];

B. The action in removing the

Petitioner's rights to water is within a

city's official capacity. To bar the

Petitioner's claim is justified since the

North Carolina Supreme Court decides who is to

be under the jurisdiction of constitutional

protection [APP-61]}.

On February 8, 1996, after consideration,

the North Carolina Supreme Court voted to deny

discretionary review in Chambers. The

Petitioner had submitted a brief within the

time, but said brief was not considered. No

voting records and opinions were given. The

denial of the Petition was entered in the

Court of Appeals on February 22, 1996. Thus,

the Petitioner exhausted all his remedies in

the State Court system [APP-56].

This Petitioner submits to this Court

that:

A. Under color of North Carolina Law,

North Carolina is requiring citizens to give

up rights to clean water under 33 USCS 1251;

protection and rights under 42 USCS, Section

1983, and other constitutionally guaranteed

rights under the guise of executive privileges

and immunities.

B. The decision of the North Carolina

Court of Appeals in COA 95-657 is in conflict

with the decisions of three United States

Courts of Appeals dealing with municipal

9

officer's immunities under 42 USCS, Section

1983, and this Court's decisions of many cases

which will be examined in Arguments I and II.

VERBATIM QUOTATION OF UNITED STATES

CONSTITUTION

ARTICLE I SECTION 8 The Congress

shall have power: To regulate commerce with

foreign nations and around the several

states, and with the Indian tribes;

ARTICLE IV SECTION 2 The citizens of

each state shall be entitled to all privileges

and immunities of citizens in several states;

ARTICLE VI SECOND SENTENCE This

Constitution, and laws of the United States

which shall be made in pursuance thereof and

all treaties made or which shall be made,

10

under the authority of the United States,

shall be the supreme law of land; and

the judges in every state shall be

bound thereby, and things in constitution or

laws of and state to the contrary not

withstanding;

AMENDMENT V No person shall

be held to answer for a capital, or other

infamous crime, unless on a presentment or

indictment of a Grand Jury except in cases

arising in the land or naval forces or with

militia when in actual service in time of war

or public danger; nor shall any person be

subject for same offence to be twice put in

jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be

compelled in any criminal case to be a witness

against himself; nor be deprived of life,

liberty or property without the due process of

11

law; nor shall private property be taken for

public use without just compensation;

AMENDMENT IX The enumeration

in the constitution, of certain rights, shall

not be construed to deny or disparage other

retain by the people;

AMENDMENT XIV SECTION 1 All persons born

or naturalized in the United States, and

subject to the jurisdiction, thereof, are

citizen of United State and of the state

wherein they reside. No state shall make or

enforce any law which shall abridge the

privileges or immunities of citizens of United

States. Nor shall any state deprive any

person of life, liberty, or property without

due process of law; nor deny to any person

within its jurisdiction the equal protection

12

of the law.

CONGRESSIONAL DECLARATION OF GOALS AND POLICY

33 USCS, 1251 (a) Restoration

and maintenance of chemical, physical and

biological integrity of nations water;

national goals for archivement of objective;

(b)

Congressional recognition, preservation and

protection of primary responsibilities and

rights of state;

(da)

Administration of environmental protection

agency to administer 33 USCS, 1251;

(g) Authority of

state over water.

42 USCS, 1983 Civil action for

deprivation of rights every person who, under

13

iain

color of any statute, ordinance, regulation,

custom oc usage of any state or territory

subjects or cause to be subjected, any citizen

of United States or other person within the

jurisdiction thereof to the deprivation of any

rights, privileges or immunities secured by

the Constitution and Laws shall be liable to

the party injured in an action at law, suit in

equity, or other proceedings for redress.

ARGUMENTS

I. THE ‘PETITIONER'S CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS

WERE VIOLATED WHEN HIS USE OF PROPERTY WAS

DENIED WHEN HIS WATER CONNECTION WAS CUT OFF,

HIS WATERWORKS WERE SEIZED WITHOUT A WARRANT,

HIS PRIVILEGES AND IMMUNITIES WERE

CONFISCATED WITHOUT CAUSE BY THE CITY OF

GOLDSBORO, FLOYD M. MCKEEL, AGENT, AND CHARLES

SOUTHERLAND, AGENT, WITHOUT AFFORDING THE

PETITIONER A HEARING PRIOR TO SUCH ACTION

BEING TAKEN [APP-12].

The water supply is essential for life

and property. Therefore, it is a property

14

right protected in the Ninth Amendment of the

United States Constitution. The states hold

the ownership and title, although it has

granted the right of use to its' citizen on

prescribed conditions. In accordance with

American Jurisprudence, Volume 78 entitled

"Water" in Chapter VIII Section 232, a water

right is regarded as property and a vested

water right or privilege constitutes property

within the meaning and operation of the

constitutional guarantees. The position that

water rights are under Constitutional

Protection is supported in Metropolitan Water

District v. United States, 628 F. SUPP 1018

(1985). In the present case, the Petitioner

had obtained a grant of water for a commercial

venture in February, 1976, under the

regulations of the Environmental Health

Commission. This category of water for a

15

commercial venture was without a municiple

corporation holding a franchised right. This

relationship established a contract which

would fall under the commerce clause of the

United States Constitution, Article I, Section

8. In New Orleans v. Rivers, 129 L.Ed 525,

the Supreme Court has declared monopolies are

unconstitutional. Petitioner has paid the

water assessment in full when the water

problem subject was raised. State and federal

agencies were called upon to deal with the

cause of the sewer problem and to make a

determination of its cause. Even after the

investigations, the Petitioner was given a

grade "A" sanitation report. The Petitioner

was permitted to use the water and sewer

systen. Therefore, there exists reasons

sufficient for the Petitioner to be protected.

American jurisprudence Volume 78, Chapter

16

IX, Section 69, entitled "Waterworks", states

that a municipality in the business of

furnishing water to its inhabitants as a

private corporation and an ordinance

prescribing such regulations has the same

force and effect as a by-law of a private

corporation whose powers are of like character

and conferred for the same purpose. This

position has been taken by the high courts of

Illinois, Kentucky, New Mexico, Ohio and

Virginia. The only restriction upon the power

to pass such an ordinance is that it conforms

to the laws of the state and are reasonable.

The law allows municipalities to furnish water

and to make sure that the water is available

to its citizens within its boundary. The law

even grants municipalities the capacity to

invalidate state grant water rights or

privileges. However, when a municipality

17

attempts to invalidate a state license for the

use of water before the license expires by use

of the violation of another law, such as

occupancy, it has been held that that action

is not reasonable. Blanchard v. Baker, 8 ME

253. To invalidate the public grant without

due process of law is not reasonable and is

not legally enforceable. This Court held in

Dohang v. Rogers, 281 US 362, 74 L.Ed 904, 50

(1930) 12 and Turpin v. Lemon, 187 US 51 47

L.Ed 70.23, Supreme Court 20 (1902), that when

water is cut off and there is a refusal to

turn it back on while the Petitioner's license

is still in force and no exigencies such as

fire or shortage exist, but is used merely to

abate an ordinance violation without the

limits of constitutional guarantees, then

there has been a_ violation of the

Constitution, in particular Article VI, second

18

sentence. This Court also expressed this

view in Dolan v. City of Tigard, 129 L.Ed 2nd

304. With no water or no electricity,

Petitioner cannot operate his restaurant. The

lease to the grocery store expired, and the

property is now in foreclosure. Thus,

according to American Jurisprudence, Volume

26, entitled "Eminent Domain", Section 98, the

Petitioner was entitled to a due process

hearing. Eminent domain is only allows a

taking within the guarantees» of the

Constitution. This Court unanimously ruled so

in Lucas _v. South Carolina Coastal Council,

505 US 120. Government must afford a due

process hearing in eminent domain cases

according to United States _v. James Daniel

Good, el Property, 126 L.Ed 2nd 490-491.

A clean water supply is essential and is

protected in the Ninth Amendment of the

19

Constitution. With the Clean Water Act,

authorities must be required to protect it's

source and prohibit tampering. A cut-off

taken with force, is arbitrary as viewed by

this Court in Roberts v. New York, 295 US 264

79 LED 1429, Supreme Court, 689.

The core of the Petitioner's argument is

to show to this Court that it is not necessary

to require citizens to give up the right to

have water upon the discretionary whim of the

local authorities of administration upon the

pretext of enforcing the law. The right to be

heard, to have a lawyer present to present the

Petitioner's side and to appeal cannot be

circumvented under the Constitutional

guarantees. To seize the property, without

cause or warrant, is Poison Fruit Tree, as

seen in Wong Sun v. United States, 371 US 471

(1963).

20

II. THE COURT ERRED IN GRANTING THE

RESPONDENTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN

TAKING THE PETITIONER'S PROPERTY RIGHTS,

PRIVILEGES AND IMMUNITIES AND OTHER

CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS WITHOUT THE FOURTEENTH

AMENDMENT DUE PROCESS OF LAW, EQUAL PROTECTION

UNDER THE LAW AND THE FIFTH AMENDMENT DUE

PROCESS OF LAW AND JUST COMPENSATION [APP-12]}.

This case came before the Wayne County,

North Carolina Superior Court on January 30,

1995. In granting the Respondents Motion for

Summary Judgment, the Court found:

a. The actions of the building

inspectors issuing a violation .order and

summarily enforcing the same by cutting off

the water supply and refusing to turn back on

thus causing losses was not tantamount to a

taking which required due process.

b. City government and agents under the

doctrine of governmental immunities does not

have to afford due process protection to

Petitioner.

c. Court had a concern of the right to

be heard, but in most cases solved by

political process - not by law.

This case went on before North Carolina

Court of Appeals on December 18, 1995, without

21

oral argument. The Court affirmed the trial

court's opinion on December 19, 1995. The

Court found:

a. The judgment proper in the absence of

law and constitution requiring liability.

b. The state holds the water property;

the water supply, by the City. Petitioner has

no property interest. No due process is

required.

And this case went on before the Supreme

Court of North Carolina. In conference, after

consideration, they denied the Petitioner's

Discretionary Review on February 23, 1996. In

affirming the trial court, the Court of

Appeals made a ruling holding that the

Petitioner does not have any property interest

and cannot claim due process protection. This

ruling is clearly in contradiction with this

Court's decision in Oyama v. California, 332

US 633 (1948). This Court declared that every

American is entitled to pursue life, liberty,

22

property and the pursuit of happiness. Dr.

Martin Luther King, Jr. once stated "I Have a

Dream". So too, Petitioner has a dream to

keep the property he had already obtained, to

receive and retain the grant from the

government, and to be under the protection of

the United States Constitution and the law.

Petitioner further contends that he is a

United States citizen who has paid all his

dues. Therefore, he is entitled to have an

American Dream.

On January 30, 1995, the Superior Court,

in granting the Respondents' Motion for

Summary Judgment, made findings in cutting off

the Petitioner's water that it was not

tantamount to a taking. The Petitioner's

contention is that a municipality is required

to furnish water, not shut it off. Taking

away the Petitioner's water privilege is a

23

taking. Therefore, the taking should be done

under Constitutional mandates. In the

Conclusion of Law, under (c), the Honorable

Court stated that it had a concern for due

process and then stated that most cases are

solved by political process, not by law. The

Petitioner protests and feels the Honorable

Judge of the Superior Court is not expressing

a wise view. The United States Constitution

is the foundation of the law. The supreme law

of the Sent, in Article VI, second sentence,

granting judicial review is a check and

balance. The correct view has been already

expressed in Marbury v. Madison, 1 Granch 137

(1803) by this Court. Even the Court of

Appeals and the Superior Court correctly

declared the Constitution protection is

absent. The Petitioner is still insisting

judicial review is important to insure

24

domestic tranquility, to secure blessings of

liberty to ourselves and our posterity as

stated in the Preamble. In this instance

case, the Superior Court of Wayne County,

North Carolina, finds the actions of the

‘building inspector is a governmental function.

A governmental function must be delegated by

Legislation. The Fourteenth Amendment,

Section One , prohibited legislation to cut

off water without due process of law. The

Supreme Court of the United States, in 1885,

dealt with monopolies under the Constitution.

It invalidated the city charter in New Orleans

v. Rivers, 29 L.Ed 525, 6 S.Ct 273 (1885).

Ordinance law is comparable to a by-law. The

use by a private corporation law for a broad

Claim of immunity shall not be allowed which

was enunciated by this Court in Youngstown

Sheetmetal and Tubing Co., el v. Sawyer, 343

25

US 579 (1952). This Court also stated that a

violation of law or due process will subject

the offending party to a civil action in

Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 US 800 (1982).

The relation established in the supplying

of water service is wholesaler and retailer.

The Petitioner paid the assessment in full and

all the additional charges associated

therewith. The waterline on the Petitioner's

property is absolutely at Petitioner's own

cost; therefore, the Petitioner shall have the

right to exclude the Respondents from cutting

off at the Petitioner's property. Thus, the

right to exclude from taking shall be retained

and protected under the Fifth Amendment (Dolan

v. City of Tigard, supra.).

Since the Respondents are a municipal

corporation maintaining water for sale, it is

liable to the Petitioner for damages and thus

26

the Motion for Summary Judgment should not

have been granted.

Thus, the Respondents are liable under 42

uscs, 1983, City of Laudue et al_v. Margaret

P. Gilleo, 512 US - 129 LED 2nd 36, 114 sct.

When Chief Justice Stone, in United

States _v. Carolene Product Co., 304 US 144

(1938), insisted that requiring citizens to

give up their constitutional protection is not

reasonable, the Court shall be "concerned with

power and not the merits of its exercise".

Therefore, the lower courts in invalidating

the United States Constitution and it's Laws

(33 UCSC St. 1251 and 42 USCS 1983), was in

error.

SUMMARY

Chief Justice Marshall, in Marbury v._

27

Madison, 1 Granch 137 (1803), expressed the

view of judicial review. He argued that

without judicial review, a written

constitution would be quite futile as a means

of limiting the abuse of government power.

For that reason the government power need not

deny the Petitioner equal protection under the

law and the Constitution.

Under the doctrine of presumption of

constitutionality of any written law, Justice

Washington outlined in 1827 in Ogden v._

Sounders, 12 Wheat 213, requiring Courts and

other authorities to presume the legality of

legislative principles. Respondent's actions

violated the Petitioner's constitutional

protection and its guarantees. The officials’

conduct and actions are questioned in this

controversy. The Petitioner presented this

question to the Superior Court.

28

Unfortunately, the Court mistook this issue by

insisting the city ordinance is constitutional

and rejecting the Petitioner's clain.

There is no clean water protection law

with requirements adopted and imposed in the

Respondent's ordinance. Yet, even with 33

USCS 1251, the Petitioner received the above

stated results. The Petitioner faced many

unusual disappointments. The original

questions presented never were heard properly

per curiam as expressed in the view of New

York Times Co. v. United States, 1971, 403, US

713. Therefore, the Petitioner requests this

Honorable Court to invalidate the Respondents’

conduct and _ actions, disregarding the

Petitioner's Constitutional protection

guaranteed to the people, for the right to

pursue a daily livelihood, liberty and the

security of property.

29

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, the Petition

for a Writ of Certiorari should be granted.

Respectfully submitted this, the 6th day

of May, 1996.

Qala &. AN. (\,

Robert E. Fuller) Jr.

Counsel of Record

109 North William Street, Suite 4

Goldsboro, North Carolina 27530

(919) 735-7496

Attorney for Petitioner,

Tseng Fu Lin, d/b/a Oriental Jade

Restaurant

30

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.