Transcript of Record — Chicago & Northwestern R. Co. v. Gray

Supreme Court brief1915

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

(23,813)

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 1914.

No. 232,

CHICAGO AND NORTITWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY,

PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,

v8.

WILLIAM HI. GRAY.

IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WISCONSIN.

INDEX.

Original. Print

er OO ee eau ba staabe ede eae hehe bal yp Obse eee Sead ene 1

i rr Cr OO. essen ee abe ubewa be eeiek Seana es 3

wees Tor WEIS GF CFTOF. cc ccccccsccsves a rer nae reseseeeses 5

nO. Wee On GENE 6 adede vic che tide dees evs anbresbaeee 7

G6 5.5 5548s cae sb sesh zee eennesbah donsesroeees 9

eee MOONS ss cs srcandecker ees bebbuk sent sedseey 11

es OC DUNNE, bir cencsvtdccveesrvess bibbe wen endes wi 15

Precipe for record by plaintiff in error............:00.00. ee 17

Precipe for record by defendant in error.............4+. oenv5 19

DR civ b ver idbie sees odctbascubeseeeosaes ehnesenede ieones 21

Record from municipal court of Outagamie county......... ver 21

Notice of appeal..... Sochcpaasvagivens Ce cGp ages baa abn rhe 22

Bond on appeal....... oaeawsé evosseones iveun aces eesee vex 23

Summons ........ Pere rreerrrrrrrr yr err Fivelns cterewas ae 26

Complaint .........+.. oc cccccccccscece so deedsnbidvs bane 27

CGS SORUEE «6 ceccccvcccessccovevse bbsassesecnse tones 35

BROWSE cocccccccccccccscces oeccvceccooceses tiheewheteuns 36

Judgment ........ Saveves ous 600000000000 ccesccesc sococces 43

Clerk’s certificate ...c.ccccccccccccccce ecaveseccsoonscos 48 a |

Jupp & DeTweiLer (INc.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., AUGUST 27, 1914.

=

INDEX.

ley I Seal a ae ein eR eee

eS ck Seinen Soak ews bwliwc teks

Pho Os ned be swede cee kes vee

PN ua atch bob bso de ao5s 0 wees de

ee | ee ee ee

Frederick Kruse (recalled).............

Ee ee ree

Chas. Mohle (recalled)............. rr

Cee as SO ok 6 06'e02virevins —r

R. F. Armstrong (recalled).............

DE CP Ga iy 5 rb nd ree 6 dS een ais parce rsseee °

Ce bo oa kes Sip brs0e Dbes dc verssccebane

Testimony of W. H. Kane (recalled) Ferner nsies Sepaebe

ft oer eT parr bbe

Wee: TE; BAGO (HORE) a2 soni vacesscrs

DREGE TE vive reccdesedevscerces seve gveewt ree

Testimony of Wm. H. Gray (recalled)......... svensk

Uriginal. Vrint

49

51

52

218

230

2236

2g

TNDEX. iil

Original. Print

Pe MD ccnp ke bess bh abe Bases e pvervdeatenees 323 256

Motion for verdict for defendant.............. Ta 256

Testimony closed .......... eee ET eee Pe rey Pree re 323 256

A as no-one 55 bee 0d d0 Bb addy ES Ode hd ee 324 257

Le MON ida Cb wa unb ce Reneden ve be'ebedee 329 260

ONS S WNUEIY cncns de necsbi sano sivbcieebs 344 267

Defendant's exceptions to charge.............eee208- 345 267

Defendant's request for questions in special verdict... 347 268

pT ONIN 4556033055 b bhp rex cleo ci reendeusaeae xe 349 269

Defendant's alternative motions.................e+e. 351 271

ee ee I oa ca W io dcke bbb bs seared berne 355 273

Defendant's exception to order..............2-e0ce0- 356 274

PRE EE sche ose cr kbs ve'ed boo hewrvaeebeee 357 274

een te NO oh i bv ow cous oo 3 0d vie eee 357 74

Judge’s certificate to bill of exceptions............... 357 274

Stipulation as to bill of exceptions.................2-6.- 358 75

Se ED Le be sony bandh lence bap weos aceeesaveor ys 359 276

nee OW OP GN I civ cc bocce dndbokv ae vebcanen 360 275

OO INO naa oss ov 2b aca ne Werke xe ecuvesess 362 276

Plaintiff's Exhibit A—Notice to defendant to produce

ND. tek pve sdavensusectes ose 364 277

B—Report of W. H. Kane, engineer... 368 278

C—Statement of Wm. Rock, December

Re) ate h vu seudins soepntdeewe 370 281

Stipulation as to Defendant's Exhibits 1 and 6........... 371 281

Defendant’s Exhibit 2—Photograph................2-06-- 373 281

Dae. indcbocn sec csseeseove» 374 281

Pee RE: dno 0b edénsinecedvccve 875 281

5—Report of Wm. Grey............. 376 282

ee er — ee 284

7—Photograph of sketch............ 379 284

eI cob Onsusneds yas enesesuees 380 284

PD ico vacinesssentotuns 381 284

Clerk’s certificate to exhibits.........cc-cccccccccccccces 382 285

Argument and submission..........0-ccccccccccccersescesoss 384 285

DE ssasvusersvure A ee ee ee Peer ere ey ee 385 286

QMO os cosccce eer Terre rey LETT ee rr OU Pie 387 286

Clerk’s certificate ...ccccccocccccece Sire ane eel Mee eaKbAeoeRe>

CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY CO. VS. WILLIAM H. GRAY. 1

1 Original.

Writ of Error.

Unitep Sratres or AMERICA, 88:

The President of the United States of America to the Honorable

the Judges of the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin,

Greeting:

Because in the record and proceedings, as also in the rendition

of the judgment of a plea which is in the said Supreme Court of

the State of Wisconsin before you, or some of you, being the

highest court of law or equity of the said state in which a decision

could be had in said suit between Chicago and North Western Rail-

way Company, plaintiff in error, defendant below, and William H.

Gray, defendant in error, plaintiff below, wherein was drawn in

question the construction and application of a statute of the Con-

gress of the United States, and wherein was denied to the plaintiff

in error the right, privilege and immunity specially set up and

claimed by the plaintiff in error under a statute of the Congress

of the United States, and the decision was in all respects adverse

to the plaintiff in error; a manifest error hath happened to the

great damage of the Chicago and Northwestern Railway Company,

plaintiff in error, as by its complaint appears.

We being willing that error, if any hath been, should be duly

corrected, and full and speedy justice done to the parties aforesaid

in this behalf, do command you, if judgment be therein given, that

then under your seal, distinctly and openly, you send the

2 record and proceedings aforesaid, with all things concerning

the same, to the Supreme Court of the United States, together

with this writ, so that you may have the same at Washington, in the

said Supreme Court, on the 30th day of July, 1913, to be then and

there held that the record and proceedings aforesaid, being in-

spected, the said Supreme Court may cause further to be done therein

to correct that error, what of right, and according to the laws and

customs of the United States, should be done.

Witness the Honorable Edward Douglass White, Chief Justice

of the Supreme Court of the United States, the 30th day of June,

1913.

[Seal District Court, Western District of Wisconsin, Madison. |

F. W. OAKLEY,

Clerk of the District Court of the

Western District of Wisconsin.

By FRED W. FRENCH, Deputy.

1—232

y CHICAGO & NORTIIWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS.

3 STaTe oF WISCONSIN,

Supreme Court, 8s:

The return to the within writ appears by the schedule hereto

annexed,

The return of the Justices of the Supreme Court of the State of

Wisconsin.

CLARENCE KELLOGG, Clerk.

4 [Endorsed :]| Original. State of Wisconsin, Supreme Court.

Chicago and North Western Railway Company, Plaintiff

in Error, Defendant Below, vs. William H. Gray, Defendant in

Error, Plaintiff Below. Writ of Error. Edward M. Smart, Attor-

ney for Plaintiff in Error. Filed Jun- 30, 1913. Clarence Kel-

logg, Clerk of Supreme Court, Wis.

5 Original.

STATE OF WISCONSIN,

In Supreme Court:

January Term, 1913.

No. 122.

WituiaM H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

CuHicaco AND NortTHwestern Raitway Company, Defendant.

Petition for Writ of Error.

Assignment of Errors and Prayer.

Considering itself aggrieved by the final decision of the Supreme

Court in rendering judgment against it in the above entitled case,

the defendant hereby prays a writ of error, from the said decision

and judgment to, the United States Supreme Court, and an order

fixing the amount of a supersedeas bond.

And the said Chicago and North Western Railway Company as-

signs the following errors in the records and proceedings of the

said case:

The Supreme Court of Wisconsin erred in construing an Act of

Congress of the United States, to-wit, the Act of April 22, 1908,

35 Statutes 65, Chapter 149, and the amendment thereof under date

of April 5, 1910, 36 Statutes, 291, Chapter 143, commonly known

as the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, and in denying to said de-

fendant, Chicago and North Western Railway Company, the plain-

tiff in error herein, the right, privilege and immunity specially set

up and claimed by plaintiff in error under the said Act

6 or-said.

The said errors are more particularly set forth as follows:

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 3

The Supreme Court of Wisconsin erred in holding and deciding—

First. That the employment of an engine dispatcher in taking

care of engines immediately after their return from interstate trips

doex not constitute “employment in commerce between the several

states” under the Act of Congress aforesaid.

Second, That an engine dispatcher whose duties require him to

dispatch alternately engines engaged in intrastate and interstate

commerce, if injured while waiting for engines to be turned over to

him to be dispatched, is not then “employed in commerce between

the several states” within the meaning of the said Act of Congress

aforesaid, and such an employe is not injured “while he is employed

in commerce between the several states” within the meaning of said

Act aforesaid.

Third. That in order to constitute “employment in commerce

between the several states” an engine dispatcher must be employed

exclusively in dispatching engines in interstate commerce.

Fourth. That the employment in which the plaintiff William H.

Gray was engaged at the time of his injury, did not constitute “em-

ployment in commerce between the several states” within the mean-

ing of the Act of Congress aforesaid.

7 Fifth. That the plaintiff, William H. Gray, was not in-

jured “while employed in commerce between the several

states” within the meaning of the Act of Congress aforesaid.

Sixth. That the plaintiff, William TH. Gray, was not, as a matter

of law, guilty of contributory negligence.

Seventh. That the damages should net be diminished by the jury

in proportion to the amount of negligence attributable to the plain-

tiff, William H. Gray.

For which errors the defendant, Chicago and North Western Rail-

way Company, plaintiff in error herein, prays that said judgment

of the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin, dated May 31,

1913, be reversed and a judgment rendered in favor of the defendant

company and for costs.

EDWARD M. SMART,

Attorney for Chicago and North Western Railway Company.

SraTeE OF WISCONSIN,

Supreme Court, ss:

Let the writ of error issue upon the execution of a bond by the

Chicago and North Western Railway Company to William H. Gray,

in the Sum of Ten thousand dollars; such bond when approved

to act as a supersedeas.

Dated June 30th, 1913.

[Seal Supreme Court of Wisconsin. ]

JNO. B. WINSLOW,

Chief Justice Supreme Court of Wisconsin.

& [ Endorsed :| Original. State of Wisconsin, Supreme Court.

William H. Gray, Plaintiff, vs. Chicago and North Western

4 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

Railway Company. Petition. Assignment or Errors. Prayer. Ed-

ward M. Smart, Attorney for petitioner. Filed Jun- 30, 1913,

Clarence Kellogg, Clerk of Supreme Court, Wis.

9 Original.

Citation.

Tue Unirep States or AMERICA, 48:

The President of the United States to William H. Gray, Greeting:

You are hereby cited and admonished to be and appear at and

before the Supreme Court of the United Stats at Washington, D. C.,

within thirty days from the date hereof, pursuant to a writ of

error filed in the office of the clerk of the Supreme Court of the

State of Wisconsin, wherein the Chicago and North Western Rail-

way Company is plaintiff in error, and you are defendant in error,

to show cause, if any there be, why the judgment rendered against

the said plaintiff in error, as in said writ of error mentioned, should

not be corrected, and why speedy justice should not be done the

parties in that behalf.

Witness, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the State of

Wisconsin, this 30 day or June, 1915.

{Seal Supreme Court of Wisconsin. |

JNO. B. WINSLOW,

Chief Justice, Supreme Court of Wisconsin.

Attest:

CLARENCE KELLOGG,

Clerk Supreme Court of Wisconsin.

Mitwavckee, W1s., July Ist, 1913.

I, attorney of record for the defendant in error in the above

entitled case, hereby acknowledge service of the above citation.

STEPHEN J. McMAHON,

Attorney for William H. Gray.

10 [Endorsed :| Original. State of Wisconsin, Supreme Court.

Chicago and North Western Railway Company, Plaintiff in

Error, Defendant Below, vs. William H. Gray, Defendant in Error,

Plaintiff Below. Citation. Edward M. Smart, Attorney for Plain-

tiff in Error. Filed Jul- 2, 1915. Clarence Kellogg, Clerk of Su-

preme Court, Wis.

11 Copy.

Bond.

Know all men by these presents, that we, Chicago and North

Western Railway gs nme! as principal, and Fred Vogel, Jr., and

Wm. Bigelow, of Milwaukee, Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, as

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 5

sureties, are held and firmly bound unto William H. Gray in the

penal sum of ten thousand dollars ($10,000), good and lawful

money of the United States of America, to be paid to said William

H. Gray, his certain attorney, heir, executors, administrators, sue-

cessors and assigns pointly and severally, firmly by these presents.

Sealed with our seals and dated this 25th day of June, 1913.

Whereas, lately at a term of the Supreme Court of the State of

Wisconsin, and on the 31st day of May, 1913, in a suit depending

in said Supreme Court, between William H. Gray, plaintiff, and the

Chicago and Northwestern Railway Company, defendant, a judg-

ment was rendered against the said Chicago and North Western Rail-

way Company, and it intends to obtain a writ of error and file a

copy thereof in the office of the clerk of said court, to review and

reverse the judgment in the aforesaid suit, and a citation directed to

the said William H. Gray, citing and admonishing him to be and

appear at the Supreme Court of the United States, at Washington,

D. C., within thirty days from the date thereof;

Now, the condition of the above obligation is such, that

12 if the said Chicago and North Western Railway Company

shall prosecute said writ of error to effect, and if it fail to

make its plea good. shall answer all damages and costs, including

just damages for delay, and costs and interest on the appeal, then

the above obligation ix void, otherwise to remain in full force and

effect.

[ SEAL. | CHICAGO AND NORTIL WESTERN

RAILWAY COMPANY,

By H. R. McCULLOUGH, Vice-President.

FRED VOGEL, Jr. [SEAL.

WM. BIGELOW. [ SEAL. }

Countersigned :

CHAS. L. LOWE,

Asst See't'y.

13 Sratre or Wisconsin,

Milwaukee County, #8:

Fred Vogel, Jr.. being duly sworn says he is one of the subscribers

to the foregoing bond; that he ix a resident and freeholder within

the State of Wisconsin; and is worth the sum of five thousand dol-

lars ($5,000) over and above all his debts and liabilities, in property

within the State of Wisconsin, not by law exempt from execution.

FRED VOGEL, Jr.

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 26th day of June, 1913.

JAMES E. MOORE,

[ SEAL. | . " :

Notary Public, Wisconsin.

My commission expires Jan’y 28, 1917.

6 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

Strate oF WISCONSIN,

Milwaukee County, ss:

Wm. Bigelow being duly sworn says that he is one of the sub

scribers to the foregoing bond; that he is a resident and freeholder

within the State of Wisconsin, and is worth the sum of five thousand

dollars ($5,000) over and above all his dents and liabilities, in

property within the State of Wisconsin, not by law exempt from

execution.

WM. BIGELOW.

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 26th day of June, 1913.

[SEAL. ] JAMES E. MOORE,

Notary Public, Wisconsin.

My commission expires Jan’y 28, 1917.

Bond approved and to operate as a supersedeas.

Dated June 30th, 1913.

[Seal Supreme Court of Wisconsin. ]

JNO. B. WINSLOW,

Chief Justice, Supreme Court of Wisconsin.

14 [Endorsed:] Copy. State of Wisconsin, Supreme Court.

Chicago and North Western Railway Company, Plaintiff in

Error, Defendant Below, vs. William H. Gray, Defendant in Error,

Plaintiff Below. Bond. Edward M. Smart, Attorney for Plaintiff

in Error. Filed Jun- 30, 1913. Clarence Kellogg, Clerk of Supreme

Court, Wis.

15 Original.

Certificate of Lodgment.

SuprREME Court,

State of Wisconsin, ss:

I, Clarence Kellogg, Clerk of said court, do hereby certify, that

there was lodged with me as such clerk on June 30th, 1913, in the

matter of William H. Gray against Chicago and North Western

Railway Company:

1. The original bond of which a copy is herein set forth.

2. Two copies of the writ of error as herein set forth, one for the

defendant, William H. Gray, and one to file in my office.

In witness whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the

seal of said court at my office in Madison, Wisconsin, this 30th

day of June, 1913.

[Seal Supreme Court of Wisconsin. ]

CLARENCE KELLOGG,

Clerk Supreme Court, Wisconsin.

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 7

16 | Endorsed:] Original. State of Wisconsin, Supreme Court.

Chicago and North Western Railway Company, Plaintiff in

Error, Defendant Below, vs. William H. Gray, Defendant in Error,

Plaintiff Below. Certificate of Lodgment. Filed Jun- 30, 1913.

Clarence Kellogg, Clerk of Supreme Court, Wis.

17 (Copy.)

In Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin.

Witi1am H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & NORTHWESTERN RarLway Company, Defendant.

'

To the Clerk of the above-entitled Court:

You will please prepare transcript of the record in this cause

to be filed in the office of the Clerk of the United States Supreme

Court, under proceedings in error heretofore perfected herein, and

include in said transcript the following pleadings, proceedings and

papers on file, to-wit:

1. Summons and Complaint.

2. Answer.

3. Judgment.

4. Bill of Exceptions, excepting and excluding therefrom all

exhibits.

5. Notice of Appeal, undertaking and clerk’s return on appeal.

6. Opinion and decision of the Supreme Court of Wisconsin.

7. Record entries of the judgment of the Supreme Court of

Wisconsin.

Said transcript to be prepared as required by law and the rules

of the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin

EDWARD M. SMART,

Chicago and Northwestern Railway

Company, Plaintiff in Error Herein.

Service of a dopy of the above precipe is admitted this 1st day

of July, 1913.

STEPHEN J. McMAHON,

Attorney for Defendant in Error.

18 [Endorsed:] Copy. State of Wisconsin, Supreme Court.

William H. Gray, Plaintiff, vs. Chicago Northwestern Rail-

way Company, Defendant. Precipe. Filed Jul- 2, 1913.

Clarence Kellogg, Clerk of Supreme Court, Wis,

CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

(Copy.)

In the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin.

Wuu1aM H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & NorTHWESTERN Rar~tway Company, Defendant.

To the Clerk of the above entitled Court.

It is desired that you please incorporate in the transcript of the

record in this cause to be filed in the office of the Clerk of the United

States Supreme Court, in the proceedings in error heretofore per-

fected herein, and include in said transcript the following pleadings,

proceedings and papers on file, to-wit:

1. All exhibits, including plaintiff’s exhibits A, B, and C inclusive,

and defendant’s exhibits 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9, inclusive.

2. Certificate of the Clerk of the "Municipal Court of Outaganie

County, Wisconsin, for the transmission of said above ennumerated

exhibits attached thereto.

Said pleadings, proceedings and papers to be incorporated and

included in the transcript to be prepared as required by law and the

rules of the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin and the

Supreme Court of the United States.

STEPHEN J. McMAHON,

Attorney for Plaintiff William H. Gray,

Defendant in Error Herein.

Service of a copy of the above precipe is admitted this 10th day of

July, 1913.

EDWARD M. SMART,

Attorney for Plaintiff in Error.

20 [Endorsed:] Copy. State of Wisconsin Supreme Court.

William H. Gray, Plaintiff, vs. Chicago & North Western

Railway Company, Defendant. Precipe. Stephen J. McMahon,

Attorney for William H. Gray. Filed Jul- 11, 1913. Clarence

Kellogg, Clerk of Supreme Court, Wis.

21 Pleas Before the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin at

a Term Thereof, Begun and Held at the Capitol in Madi-

son, the Seat of Government of said State, on the First Tuesday,

To wit: the Seventh Day of January, A. D. 1913.

Present: Hon. John B. Winslow, Chief Justice; Hon. Roujet D.

Marshall, Hon. Robert G. Seibecker, Hon. James C. Kerwin, Hon.

William H. Timlin, Hon. John Barnes and Hon. Aad John Vinije,

Justices; Clarence Kellogg, Clerk.

Be it remembered that heretofore, towit; on the sixth day of

December in the year of Our Lord One Thousand Nine Hundred

and Twelve came into the office of the Clerk of the Supreme Court

WILLIAM H. GRAY. a

of the State of Wisconsin, the Chicago & Northwestern Railway

Company, by its attorney, and filed in said Court its certain Notice

of Appeal and Undertaking, according to the statute in such case

made and provided, and also the return to such appeal, of the Clerk

of the Municipal Court of Outagamie County, in said State, in

words and figures following, that is to say :—

22 STATE OF WISCONSIN:

Municipal Court, Outagamie County.

WiiuiaM H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & NoRTHWESTERN Raitway Company, Defendant.

To Mr. Stephen J. McMahon, Attorney for Plaintiff, and Mr. A. 0.

Danielson, Clerk of the Aforesaid Court:

Please take notice that the above named defendant, Chicago «

Northwestern Railway Company, hereby appeals to the Supreme

Court of the State of Wisconsin from a judgment rendered by t!

above named court in the above entitled action entered on the 4th

day of December, 1912, in favor of the plaintiff, William H. Gray,

and against the defendant, Chicago & Northwestern Railway Com-

pany, for the sum of Seven Thousand Nine Hundred thirty two and

01/100 Dollars ($7,932.51) damages and costs, and from the whole

thereof.

EDWARD M. SMART,

Attorney for Defendant.

Dated December 4, 1912.

23 STATE OF WISCONSIN:

Municipal Court, Outagamie County.

Witiram HH. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs..

Cuicaco & NorTHWESTERN RarLway Company, Defendant.

Whereas on the 4th day of December 1912, in the Municipal

Court for Outagamie County, the above named plaintiff recovered

judgment against the above named defendant for the sum of Seven

thousand nine hundred thirty-two and 51/100 dollars ($7,932.51)

damages and costs; and the defendant, Chicago & Northwestern

Railway Company, feeling aggrieved thereby intends to appeal

therefrom to the Supreme Court of the State of Wisconsin.

Now, therefore, the National Surety Company of the City of New

York and State of New York does hereby undertake that the said

appellant will pay all costs and damages which may be awarded

against it on said appeal, not exceeding two hundred and fifty dollars

($250.00) ;

10 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

And does also undertake that if such judgment, so appealed from,

or any part thereof, be affirmed, the said appellant will pay the

amount directed to be paid by the judgment, or the part of such

amount as to which the said judgment shall be affirmed, if it be

affirmed only in part; and all damages which shall be awarde|

against said appellant on the said appeal.

NATIONAL SURETY COMPANY,

By WM. F. LYNCH, [ SEAL. |

Attorney in Fact.

Dated December 4th, 1912.

24 State of Wisconsin.

Department of Insurance.

This is to certify, that the National Surety Company of New York

New York, has complied with all the provisions of law, and is author-

ized to transact the business of (7) fidelity or surety-ship insurance

in this State from the first day of March, 1912, until the twenty-

eighth day of February, 1913, inclusive, unless its authority be

sooner revoked.

Witness my hand and official seal, at Madison, Wisconsin, this

4th day of March, 1912.

[SEAL. | HERMAN L. EKERN,

Commissioner of Insurance.

No. 8.

I, Herman L. Ekern, Commissioner of Insurance of the State of

Wisconsin, hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy

with the original certificate of authority, issued to the National Surety

Company of New York, N. Y., Company and now on file and of

record in my office and in my lawful custody, and that such copy is

a true copy of said original and of the whole thereof.

Witness my hand and official seal at Madison, Wisconsin, this 31st

day of August, A. D. 1912.

[ SEAL. | ee L. EKERN,

”

Commissioner of Insurance.

(Endorsements:) Original. Municipal Court Outagamie

County. William H. Gray, Plaintiff, vs. Chicago & North-

western Railway Company, Defendant. Notice of Appeal and Un-

dertaking. Due service of a copy of the within notice and under-

taking admitted this 4th day of December, 1912. Stephen J. Me-

Mahon, Attorney for Plaintiff. A. O. Danielson, Clerk of Municipal

Court. Filed Dec. 5 1912. State of Wisconsin. In Municipal

Court for Outagamie County. A. O. Danielson, Clerk. Edward M.

Smart, Milwaukee, Wis., Attorney for C. & N. W. Ry. Co.

WILLIAM H. GRAY.

26 STATE oF WISCONSIN:

Municipal Court, Circuit Court Branch, Outagamie County.

Wituiam H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & NortruwesterN Rattway Company, a Corporation,

Defendant.

Summons.

The State of Wisconsin to the said Defendant:

You are hereby summoned to appear within twenty days after

service of this summons, exclusive of the day of service, and defend

the above entitled action in the court aforesaid; and in case of your

failure so to do judgment will be rendered against you according

to the demand of the complaint, of which a copy is herewith served

upon you.

STEPHEN J. McMAHON,

Plaintiff's Attorney.

P. H. MARTIN, of Counsel.

P. O. Address 504 Goldsmith Bldg., Milwaukee, Milwaukee

County, Wis.

STATE OF WISCONSIN:

Municipal Court, Cireuit Court Branch, Outagamie County.

Wituiam H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & Nortuwestern Rartway Company, a Corporation,

Defendant.

Complaint.

The above named plaintiff by Stephen J. McMahon, his attorney,

and P. H. Martin, of counsel, complains of the above named de-

fendant, and for cause of action alleges as follows:

1. That the defendant is and was at the various times hereinafter

stated, a railroad corporation, duly organized and existing under

and by virtue of the laws of the state of Wisconsin, and owning

and operating a commercial railroad between the city of Antigo in

Langlade County, and various cities, villages and other places in

said state, carrying passengers and freight for hire.

2. That said defendant owns and maintains in and about said

city of Antigo, where are located the headquarters of the Ashland

Division of defendant’s railroad line, yards, extending north and

south about three miles, more or less, in length and extending east

and west about one-fourth of a mile, more or less, in width at its

widest part. That in these yards are situated freight and passen-

12 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

ger depots, office buildings, railway tracks, locomotive engines and

other rolling stock, a cinder pit, a coal shed, a blow-off box for

containing steam and water discharged from engines, a cabin

28 or shanty for the use and convenience of plaintiff and other

employes during leisure moments and bunting hours, a large

stationery water tank, a large pile of fire wood, a round house or barn

for housing engines and other buildings, materials, facilities and

equipment usually used in connection with a railroad. That in

said city partly between the south line of First Avenue extended,

and the north line of Third Avenue extended, both of said avenues

running east and west, there is running north and south on the

westerly side of said yards, a surface side track, which is also known

as an ingoing track, extending from the main track of defendant’s

railway line to a point north of said round-house, which latter is

situated north of said First Avenue. On said side track approxi-

mately and about over the north and south lines of Second Avenue

extended, which likewise runs east and west, there is said cinder pit,

which is open and under ground, about eighty-one feet in length,

more or less, about thirteen feet in width, more or less, and

about two and one-half feet in depth, more or less, over and

along which said side track extends. Said cinder pit is used prin-

cipally for receiving hot ashes and burning coals dumped into it

in emptying and cleaning the fire places of defendant’s said locomo-

tive engines. About six feet, more or less, north of said cinder

pit, on the west side of said side track and parallel thereto, is said

. coal shed, which is of considerable height and width, and about

two hundred and seventy-three feet in length, more or less. Be-

tween the west rail of said side track and the east line of said coal

shed is a space of about three feet and nine inches, more or less, in

width upon and along which runs a beaten foot path or track, over

which plaintiff was required to travel and pass frequently, in the

discharge and performance of his duty as an employee of

29 said defendant, as hereinafter more particularly stated. On

the east side of said sidetrack, several feet therefrom and

parallel thereto, is situated said blow-off box, which extends in an

easterly and westerly direction, and is several feet in height and

width. About twenty-one feet, more or less, north of said blow-off

box, and about thirteen feet, more or less, east of said sidetrack and

parallel thereto, is said cabin or shanty of the width and height of

an ordinary box car. North of said cabin or shanty, on the east

side of said side track and parallel thereto, are situated said sand

house, a sand tower, said stationery water tank and said wood pile,

at short distances apart and located consecutively.

3. That the plaintiff is an inhabitant, resident and citizen of

the city of Kaukauna, in the county of Outagamie, in said state.

4. That the plaintiff on and prior to the 19th day of January,

A. D. 1911, was an employee of said defendant in the capacity of

engine dispatcher, in and about the said yards of defendant in said

city of Antigo. That plaintiff's principal and usual duties as such

dispatcher were (a) to receive defendant’s said engines, of various

sizes, with tenders attached thereto, from the engine crews in charge

13

WILLIAM H, GRAY.

thereof, when brought into said yards, in the ordinary course of

business upon their return from trips between various other places

and said city of Antigo; (b) to cause the fire and ashes to be

emptied from the fire place of such engine into said cinder pit

situated in said yards for such purpose, and assist in said empty-

ing; (c) to cause the amount of water and steam in the boiler of

each engine to be reduced by discharging the same into said blow-off

box, situated in said yards for such purpose, and assist in the same;

(d) to cause the tender of each engine to be loaded with

30 coal from said coal shed, situated in said yards for such

purpose, and assist in such loading; (¢) to cause the tender

attached to each engine to be filled with water from said stationery

tank, situated in said yards for such purpose, and assist in said

filling; (f) to cause the tender of each engine to be supplied with

kindling wood from said wood pile, situated in said yards for such

purpose, and assist in supplying the same; and (g) to run each

engine so received and dealt with into said round-house, so situated

in said yards for housing the same, That, in addition to said prin-

cipal duties, it was the duty of said plaintiff, (A) to occasionally

drive said engines and other engines in switching cars loaded with

freight, wood, cinders and other materials, and cars in bad order, in

and about said yards; (/) to guard, care for and protect the said

property of defendant, and particularly said cinder pit and its im-

mediate surroundings; (j) to prevent the damage or destruction of

said property by fire or other causes; and (£) to promote and fur-

ther the interests and welfare of said defendant in and about said

yards, generally.

5. That it was the duty of said defendant to provide said plaintiff

with reasonably safe, suitable, sufficient and proper places and facili-

ties in which and with which to perform his said duties, and for

said defendant by and through its other employees, servants, agents

and officers, in the discharge and performance of their duties, to

use due, proper and ordinary care, skill, diligence and prudence in

preventing and avoiding injury or damage to the person and

property of said plaintiff while in the discharge of his duties; and

that said duties of said defendant and its other employees, servants,

agents and officers to said plaintiff were wholly disregarded and

violated by them as hereinafter stated.

6. That on said 19th day of January, 1911, at about the

31 hour of 9:45 o’clock A. M., while walking in a northerly

direction along and upon said beaten foot path, or track,

between the westerly rail of said side track and said coal shed, at a

distance of about seventy-two feet, more or less, north of said cinder

pit, and while in the discharge and performance of his said duty,

and while assisting in and supervising the extinguishment of a fire

and threatened conflagration, which had originated in said cinder

pit, he was violently struck by one of defendant’s said locomotive

engines, running in a northerly direction on said side track, in

charge of and driven by another engineer and a fireman in de-

fendant’s employment, and in the discharge and performance of

their duties as employees of said defendant. That said plaintiff

14 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

was thereby vislently thrown against said coal shed, knocked down

and rolled and dragged upon the ground adjacent thereto, and

severely evt, bruised, athe gashed, torn, lacerated and maimed.

That plainviff’s head and face were badly cut in numerous places,

and his skuil fractured. That three of plaintiff’s ribs were broken

and fractured. That plaintiff's arms and legs, and other parts of

his body were badly bruised. That plaintiffs left arm and shoulder

were severely bruised, crushed and torn, resulting in the permanent

paralysis thereof. That because of said injury, plaintif has been

caused great bodily and mental pain and suffering which has been

continuous and is continuing. That plaintiff has been and is perma-

nently disabled and oe anges from performing his maid usual

duties or other manual labor. That because of said injury, plaintiff

has been required to incur expenses of money for surgical and

medical services, drugs and other material in the amount and up-

wards of two hundred dollars. That in all, plaintiff has been dam-

aged in the amount and sum of ten thousand dollars.

32 7. That said injury and damage to plaintiff was caused

wholly without any fault or carelessness, ‘negligence or want

of ordinary care on his part contributing to said injury.

8. That said injury was caused wholly by and through the fault,

carelessness, negligence and want of ordinary care of said defendant

and its other employees and in disregard and violation of their said

duties to the plaintiff, because, for the reason and in that (a) the

construction, arrangement and location of said side track, cinder

pit, coal shed and other buildings, facilities, materials and equip-

ment adjacent and pertaining thereto, as aforesaid, were and are

unsafe, insufficient, improper, defective, careless and negligent, all

of which was known to said defendant and its other employees; (6)

said cinder pit was carelessly and negligently permitted by defend-

ant’s other employees, in charge thereof, and responsible therefor,

to catch fire and produce a threatened conflagration and destruction

of said side track at and over said cinder pit, and of said buildings

and other property adjacent thereto and in the vicinity thereof, as

heretofore stated said fire requiring water to be used in extinguish-

ing it and resulting in the rising of large clouds of smoke and

steam to the north of said cinder pit over said side track and he-

tween said coal shed and other buildings, and thereby impairing

plaintiff’s vision; (c) defendant’s said employees in charge of and

driving said engine, carelessly and negligently failed and omitted

to sound or ring, or cause to be sound- or rung, the bell situated

upon said engine for the purpose of giving warning to plainti#® or

others against such danger, or danger of any kind; (d) without

notice to plaintiff, said engine was carelessly and negligently rin

and permitted to be run by said defendant and its said other em-

ployees upon said side track, at and to a point and place

33 thereon north of the extreme southerly end of said cinder pit,

contrary to the requirements, rules, custom and practice estab-

lished and followed by defendant and its employees in said yards,

and upon which plaintiff relied, and while said cinder pit and the

vicinity north thereof were covered with and surrounded by large,

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 14

overhanging clouds of smoke and steam, which rendered it impos-

sible for the plaintiff to see or distinguish objects; and (a) said en-

gine was carelessly and negligently run and driven and permitted to

be run and driven by said other employees of the defendant at a

careless, negligent and unlawful rate of speed of twelve miles per

hour, beyond the control of said other employees, and in violation

of the provisions of sections one and two of Chapter twelve, of the

Revised Ordinances of the City of Antigo of 1906 pertaining

thereto.

Wherefore, the plaintiff demands judgment against the defendant

for the sum of ten thousand dollars, together with his costs and dis-

bursements herein.

STEPHEN J. McMAHON,

Plaintiff's Attorney.

P. H. MARTIN,

Of Counsel.

34 SraTe or WISCONSIN,

Milwaukee County, 88:

William H. Gray, being first duly sworn, on oath deposes and

says, that he is the plaintiff in the above entitled action; that he

has heard read the foregoing complaint and knows the contents

thereof, and that the same is true to his own knowledge, except as

to those matters therein stated to be alleged on information and

belief, and as to those matters he believes it to be true.

WILLIAM H. GRAY,

Plaintiff.

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 19th day of February,

A. D., 1912.

M. A. MARCHANT,

Notary Public, Milwaukee County, Wisconsin.

My Commission Expires March 25, 1912.

35 (Endorsements:) Original. State of Wisconsin. Muni-

‘ cipal Court. Cireuit Court Branch. Outagamie County.

‘William H. Gray, Plaintiff, vs. Chicago & Northwestern Railway

Company, a corporation, Defendant. Summons and Complaint.

State of Wisconsin in Municipal Court for Outagamie County, Filed

Apr. 15, 1912. A. O. Danielson, Clerk. Filed Dee. 6, 1912,

Clarence Kellogg, Clerk of Supreme Court, Wis.

STATE OF WISCONSIN,

County of Outagamie, sa:

I hereby certify that on the 28th day of February 1912 in the

City of Appleton in said County of Outagamie, I personally served

the within Summons and Complaint on the above named defendant

Chicago & Northwestern Railway Company by serving on and

leaving with H. P. Martin, Agent for said Company, by then and

16 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

there delivering to and leaving with him a true and correct

of the same, and that I endorsed on said copy the date of service

and signed my name and official title thereto.

Dated Feb. 28, 1912.

M. M. LOCKNEY, Sheriff,

By MARTIN VERHAGEN, Under Sheriff.

Fee, Service

Mileage 2

Sk reer

36 STaTeE OF WISCONSIN:

In Muncipal Court, Outagamie County, Circuit Court Branch.

Witt H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & Norru Western Raitway Comrany, a Corporation,

Defendant.

And now comes the above named defendant, by Edward M.

Smart, its attorney, and for its answer herein shows to the court

and alleges:

1. It admits the allegations of paragraph One of the Complaint.

2. It admits that the general situation, location, position, and

measurements of the defendant's yards, buildings, tracks, ete., as

set forth in paragraph Two of the complaint are substantially cor-

rect, excepting as to the following particulars, to-wit, and as to t’

it alleges that the following are the true and correct measureme..

The cinder pit is thirteen (13) feet wide and eighty (80) feet

long, and two (2) feet nine (9) inches below the rail; that t!

coal shed is six (6) feet nine (9) inches north of the cinder p’

the west side of the track and parallel thereto.

It admits that west of the rail of the side track and the east line

of the coal shed there is a space three (5) feet nine (9) inches, in

width, but denies that there is within said space any beaten ,

37 foot path or track, or that the plaintiff was required to travel

or pass thereon or thereover at any time in the discharge or

performance of his duties.

3. It admits that at the time alleged the plaintiff was employed

by the defendant as an engine dexpatcher at the City of Antigo.

4. It alleges that the duties of plaintiff as engine despatcher were

as follows:

To get on the engine as it came in off the road and after it had

been deposited any where on the round house track by the engineer,

to be inspected; to stop the engine on the cinder pit and have the

fire and ashes cleaned out; move the engine to the coal shed and

have the tender filled with the proper amount of coal, and from

there take it to the water tank to be filled with water; after he had

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 17

supplied the engine with kindling wood he then took it to the round

house turn table, after which he took it to the round house.

Except as admitted in the foregoing paragraph, defendant denies

that the plaintiff owed the several duties set forth in paragraph

Four of the complaint, and especiaily denies that he owed any

particular or special duty to guard, care for or protect the cinder pit

or any particular piece of property, and alleges that the particular

duty of looking after any danger by fire in the cinder pit was in

charge of the cinder pit men;

Admits that the plaintiff owed the general duty that every em-

ploye owes to his master of rescuing and saving property from

danger by fire or otherwise when he learns of the same.

38 5. Denies that the defendant or any of its employes, serv-

ants, agents or officers disregarded or viola any duty

owed to the plaintiff.

6. Admits that on the 19th day of January, 1911, the plaintiff,

while on the said premises and near the said coal shed, was struck

and injured by one of defendant’s engines, but denies that he was

walking outside of the track or upon any beaten path, and in that

behalf alleges that he was at the said time walking along between

the rails of the said side track with his back in the direction from

which the said engine was coming, without giving any thought or

attention thereto or his own safety.

Denies that he was then in the discharge or performance of any

duty, or assisting or supervising the extinguishing of any fire or

vonflagration. .

Alleges that as to plaintiff's injuries, it has no knowledge or in-

, rmation as to the character or extent thereof, and therefore denies

fae same.

djenies that the plaintiff has been or is permanently disabled

id, gneapacitated in performing his usual duties or other manual

labor.

Alleges that it has no knowledge or information as to the ex-

penges incurred for surgical or medical services, drugs, and other

material, and therefore denies the same, and denies that plaintiff

has -been damaged in any sum whatever.

7. Denies that the plaintiff's injuries were received without fault

on his own part, and alleges that they were caused solely by his

own negligence.

5. Denies that plaintiff’s injuries were caused either wholly or in

part by or through any fault or negligence on the part of the de-

fendant or any of its employes.

39 Denies that the construction, arrangement or location of the ,

side track or the cinder pit or coal shed, or any other building,

or any facilities, material or equipment on the premises, or any of

them were unsafe, insufficient, a defective, careless or negli-

gent, or that the defendant or any of its employees had any know]l-

edge thereof.

Denies that the cinder pit was carelessly or negligently permitted

by any one to catch fire, or to produce a conflagration or destruction

2—232

18 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8.

of the side track or cinder pit, or any other property, or any buildings

in that vicinity or elsewhere.

Admits that there was some hot coals in the said cinder pit, and

that water was thrown thereon, and alleges that the same was with

the knowledge and consent and under the direction of the laintiff,

and that the clouds of steam arising therefrom were Peet | by the

plaintiff and well known to him.

Denies that the employes in charge of the said engine failed or

omitted to sound or ring the bel. thereon, and alleges that the said

bell was, at and prior to the time of the accident, being continuously

run

enles that said engine was carelessly or negligently run or per-

mitted to be run by the defendant or any of its employees upon the

said side track at any point thereon, and denies that the same was

run contrary to any requirement, rule, custom or practice established

or followed by defendant or any of its employes, and denies that the

plaintiff relied upon any requirement, rule, custom or practice;

Denies that the said engine was run at a careless, negligent or un-

lawful rate of speed, or that it was run at the rate of twelve miles per

hour, or that it was beyond the control of employes so running the

same, and denies that it was being run in violation of any ordinance

of the City of Antigo, and denies that there was any such ordinance

as set forth in the complaint.

40 9. Further answering, defendant denies each and every

allegation in said complaint not hereinbefore expressly ad-

mitted, qualified or explained.

10. Further answering defendant alleges that this action was not

commenced until February 28th, 1912, and no notice of injury was

given, made or served, as required by Section 4222 of the Wisconsin

Statutes of 1898 as amended, and defendant pleads failure to give

such notice as a defense hereto.

Wherefore defendant demands judgment that the complaint of the

laintiff be dismissed and that it have and recover its costs and dis-

ursments herein.

EDWARD M. SMART,

Attorney for Defendant.

41 Strate or WISCONSIN,

Milwaukee County, #8:

Edward M. Smart, being first duly sworn on oath, says that he is

the attorney for the defendant in the above entitled action.

. That he makes this verification for and on behalf of said defendant

and is authorized so to do.

That deponent has read the foregoing answer and knows the con-

tents thereof; that all the material allegations of the same are within

deponent’s belief, and deponent verily believes the same to be true.

That the grounds of deponent’s belief on the subject are the records

and documents of defendant relating to said matters in deponent’s

possession and conversations with the officers and agents of the de-

fedant.

That the reason why this verification is not made by the defendant

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 19

is that defendant is a corporation and none of its officers reside in the

county where deponent resides.

EDWARD M. SMART.

Subscribed to and sworn to before me this — day of —.

K. M. CROWLEY,

Notary Public for Wisconsin.

42 (Endorsements:) Original. Municipal Court. Circuit

Court Branch. Outagamie County. William H. Gray, Plain-

tiff, vs. Chicago & Northwestern Railway Company, Defendant.

Answer. Due service of a copy of the within answer is hereby ad-

mitted this 10th day of April 1912. Stephen J. McMahon, Attorney

for Plaintiff. Edward M. Smart, Milwaukee, Wis. Attorney for C.

& N. W. Ry. Co.

43 Srate or Wisconsin:

Municipal Court, Cireuit Court Branch, Outagamie County.

Witiiam H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & Nortnwestern Raitway Company, a corporation,

Defendant.

At the General Term of the Municipal Court in and for Outagamie

County, State of Wisconsin, Begun and Held at the Court-House

in the City of Appleton, in Said County, for the Year 1912, and

on the 4th Day of December, 1912, a Day of Said Term.

Present, Hon. Thomas H. Ryan, Municipal Judge, Presiding.

Judgment.

This action being at issue and having been brought on for trial

before the court and a jury, on the 15th, 16th, 17th, 18th, 19th, and

20th days of July, 1912, and the issues having been tried, and a

special verdict which is of record hating been duly rendered on the

20th day of July, 1912, in words and figures as follows:

Strate or WISCONSIN,

County of Outagamie:

In Municipal Court for Said County.

WiiuiaMm H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & Nortuwesters Raitway Company, Defendant.

Special Verdict.

1. Was the plaintiff on the 19th ne | of January, 1911, struck by

one of defendant’s engines and injured?

Answer. Yes. (By the Court.)

20 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS.

2. Did the defendant prior to the day of the plaintiff’s injury

cause an order to be issued providing in substance that engines de-

livered on the coal shed track to be despatched should stop

44 south of the cinder pit?

Answer. Yes.

3. If you answer question numbered 2 “yes,” was such order

abrogated prior to the day of the plaintiff’s injury?

Answer. No..

4, If you answer question numbered 2 “yes,” and question num-

bered 3 ‘‘no,” then was Engineer Kane guilty of negligence in run-

ning his engine north of the cinder pit in violation of such order at

the time plaintiff was injured? .

Answer. Yes.

5. If you answer question numbered 4 ‘“‘yes,” then was such negli-

gence of Engineer Kane a proximate cause of plaintiff’s injury?

Answer. Yes.

6. Was the engine bell of the engine that struck plaintiff ring-

ing at and immediately prior to the time of plaintiff’s injury?

Answer. No.

7. If you answer question numbered 6 “no,” then was Engineer

Kane guilty of negligence in failing to cause the engine bell to be

rung immediately prior to the time of plaintiff’s injury?

Answer. Yes.

8. If you answer question numbered 7 “yes” then was such

negligence a proximate cause of plaintiff’s injury?

Answer. Yes,

9. Under the circumstances existing was Engineer Kane guilty

of negligence in running the said engine north of said cinder pit

to the place where it struck plaintiff at the rate of speed at which

he was running?

45 Answer. Yes.

10. If you should answer question numbered 9 “yes”

then answer this: Was such negligence a proximate cause of plain-

tiff’s injury?

Answer. Yes,

11. Was the plaintiff guilty of any negligence which proximately

contributed to his injury?

Answer. No.

12. If you should answer the 11th question “yes,” then answer

this: Was the said negligence of Kane greater than what of the

plaintiff?

Answer. (No answer.)

13. If you should answer the 12th question “yes.” then did such

negligence contribute in a greater degree to the plaintiff’s injury

than did that of the plaintiff?

Answer. (No. answer.)

14. What sum will justly compenstate the plaintiff for the in-

juries sustained by him?

Answer. $7,815. Seven thousand eight hundred and fifteen dol-

(S’d) CHARLES FOSS, Foreman.

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 21

And an order having been made and entered by the court in this

action on the 29th day of November, 1912, ordering and directing

that judgment be entered in the above entitled action upon the said

special verdict in favor of the plaintiff and against the defendant

with costs,

46 Now on motion of Stephen J. McMahon, attorney for the

plaintiff and P. H. Martin of counsel for the plaintiff, and

after hearing them for the plaintiff, and Edward M. Smart attorney

for the defendant,

It is adjudged, that the said plaintiff William H. Gray recover of

said defendant Chicago & Northwestern Railway Company the sum

of seven thousand eight hundred and fifteen (7,815) Dollars, his

damages, as found by the jury in their said special verdict, with

his costs and disbursements of this action taxed at the sum of one

hundred and seventeen dollars and fifty-one cents ($117.51) mak-

ing together the sum of seven thousand nine hundred and thirty-

two dollars and fifty-one cents ($7,932.51.)

47 (Endorsements:) Original. State of Wisconsin: Munici-

pal Court: Circuit Court Branch: Outagamie County. Wil-

liam H. Gray Plaintiff, vs, Chicago & Northwestern Railway Co. a

corporation, Defendant. Judgment. Filed, Dec. 6, 1912. Clarence

Kellogg, Clerk of Supreme Court, Wis.

48 In Municipal Court, Outagamie County, Wisconsin.

WituiaM H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & NoRTHWESTERN Raitway Co., Defendant.

STaTE OF WISCONSIN,

County of Outagamie, ss:

I, A. O. Danielson, Clerk of the Municipal Court in and for said

county and State, do hereby certify that the papers hereto attached

are the original records necessary to this appeal pursuant to Supreme

Court rule one, filed of record in this office, in the above en-

titled action, and that the same are hereby transmitted to the Su-

preme Court of the State of Wisconsin pursuant to such appeal.

In witness wherein, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the

seal of said Court this 5th day of December, A. D. 1912.

[SEAL. ] A. O. DANIELSON, Clerk.

(Endorsements:) Filed, Dec. 6, 1912, Clarence Kellogg, Clerk

of Supreme Court, Wis,

22 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

49 Strate or WISCONSIN,

Outagamie County:

In Municipal Court for said County.

Wiiu1aM H. Gray, Plaintiff,

: vs.

Cuicaco & NoRTHWESTERN Rartway Company, Defendant.

Index to Witnesses.

Plaintiff's Witnesses.

Adverse Direct Cross-

witness. examination. examination.

Anton Beranzyk

Charles Mohle

Dr. Connell

Dr. Levings

Be SEO i sb owe hace vex

US ee ee

W. H. Gray recalled

W. H. Kane re-called

W. H. Gray re-called

Plaintiff rests

R. F. Armstrong

Claude Ashmore

Peter Vanderaa

Chas. Mohle re-called

Wm. Rock re-called

S. S. Long recalled

Wm. Kruse recalled

23

50

R. F. Armstrong

Wm. Kane re-called

857

Defendant rests.

Wm. H. Gray re-called in rebuttal 871

Testimony closed * 885

Plaintiff’s Exhibits.

Exhibit “A”—Notice to Defendant to Produce Papers.

” “B”—Report of Officer Kane

. “C”—Letter of Mr. Rock’s

Defendant’s Exhibits.

Exhibit “1.”

Exhibit “1”_Blue print

me

PT ss

“6g? “

“5”—Report of injury

“6”—_Large blue print.

“7”__Sketch of Premises

ws geome “ “cc

“9”—Photograph

51 STaTE oF WISCONSIN:

Municipal Court, Outagamie County, Circuit Court Branch.

W. H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

CuIcAGO AND NORTHWESTERN Rartway Company, Defendant.

GENTLEMEN: Please take notice that annexed is a copy of the

bill of exceptions proposed on the e of the defendant in this ac-

tion, and that the game contains all the testimony taken in this ac-

24 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

tion, set forth by question and answer and certified as such by

Margaret E. Hogan, stenographic reporter on the trial thereof.

EDWARD M. SMART,

Attorney for Defendant.

Dated March 10, 1913. °

To Mr. Stephen J. McMahon, Plaintiff's Attorney; P. H. Martin,

of Counsel,

Due service of a copy of the within proposed bill of exceptions

admitted this 10th day of March, 1913.

STEPHEN J. McMAHON,

Attorney for Plaintiff.

52 State or WIsconsIN:

Municipal Court, Outagamie County, Circuit Court Branch.

W. H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco AND NORTHWESTERN Raitway Company, Defendant.

Be it remembered that this action was brought on for trial at the

June, 1912 term of said court, at the court house in the City of

Appleton, beginning on the 16th day of July, 1912, before the

court, Hon. Thomas H. Ryan, Municipal Judge, presiding, and a

jury.

Plaintiff present in person and represented by Stephen J. Mc-

Mahon, his attorney and P. H. Martin of counsel.

Defendant appeared by Edward M. Smart, its attorney.

Whereupon the following proceedings were had:

53 Strate or WIsconsIN,

County of Outagamie:

In Municipal Court for Said County.

WirtuiaM H. Gray, Plaintiff,

vs.

Cuicaco & NorTHwesterRN Raitway Company, Defendant.

Testimony taken July 16th to July 20th, 1912.

July 15, 1912, jury drawn.

July 16, 1912, 9 A. M. case called. Plaintiff present in person

and represented by his attorneys, 8. J. McMahon, of record and P.

H. Martin of counsel.

Defendant appears by Edward M. Smart, its attorney.

Jury sworn and examined.

54 The plaintiff asks that the bulletin in question in this

cease be produced by counsel for the defendant so that it can

be here in evidence,

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 25

By Att’y Smarr:

The bulletin was not one that was recorded. The bulletins are

all numbered. Search has been made for it but it cannot be found.

It was simply in the nature of a foreman’s orders.

Freperick Kruse, called as an adverse witness, being first duly

sworn, testified as follows:

Cross-examined by Att’y P. IH. Martin:

Q. Mr. Kruse, you were on the 19th day of January, 1911, in

the employ of the defendant company as fireman?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How long had you been in its employ at that time?

A. In the company’s employ? About six years all told.

Q. You were on the engine that struck Mr. Gray, the plaintiff

in this case on that day?

A. As I understand it I was on the engine that was supposed to

have struck Mr. Gray.

Q. That engine passed over the cinder or clinker pit on toward

the round house on that day?

A. Yes si

Q. About what time of the day?

A. Between ten and eleven in the morning.

Q. Are you able to fix it any nearer?

. No sir, I don’t believe I could.

. You registered in did you not?

. Yes sir.

. Do you know what time you registered in that day?

. I don’t remember.

Q. Who was the engineer in charge of the engine as you passed in

to the clinker pit and on towards the round house?

A. William Kane.

Q. At what point beyond the clinker pit did you first stop?

A. Right opposite the water tank.

55 - Q. The track on which you came in at that point runs in

a northerly and southerly direction?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What was occupying your mind as you passed in over the

clinker pit at that time, that is, what were you thinking about?

A. Well, that would be a pretty hard matter for me to say—what

I was thinking about.

Q. You aren’t able to say are you?

A. No, I couldn’t recall what I would be thinking about about

that time.

Q. Are you able to tell what you wer’ thinking about at any time

after you passed over the clinker pit aad before your engine stopped

at the water tank?

A. T was probably thinking about——

Q. No, not probably, what were you thinking about as a matter

of fact, if you know.

A. I don’t believe I can answer that question.

CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS, ~

Q Are you able to tell us where you started from on your run

that day or the night before?

A. I think it was Fond du Lac.

You aren’t sure of that are you?

. No sir, I am not.

Q. You have been examined before?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Are you able to explain why you can’t tell the jury where you

started from on that run?

A. Well, we as a rule, don’t keep track of every day that we work,

Q. Don’t you keep track of every day that you work?

A. I couldn’t keep track of every day that I worked two years

ago and where I started from.

Q Then you have no recollection of the time and place you

started from on that particular run?

A. No sir, I haven’t.

Q. Have you made any attempt since that examination before the

commission to find out?

A. No sir, I don’t believe I did.

Q. How far is it from the place that you left your train, follow-

ing the track that your engine passed over, to the clinker pit, about—

I don’t care for exact figures?

A. Oh, about 100 rods I guess.

Q. While the road the engine took was about a mile?

A. About a mile, yes, it would be.

56 Q. But you left your train about 100 rods from that point

of the clinker pit?

A. Yes, up the track.

Q South?

A. No, northeast a little.

Q. So after pulling your train up north east of the clinker pit

you cut off your engine and backed down south? .-

A. No, we cut off and went north to the north house.

Q. The train was registered then backed down the main line then

in on the clinker pit tracks?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Then went north?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You were on the west side of the engine as you proceeded

north over the clinker pit?

A. Yes sir. |

Q. How soon after you stopped did you learn Mr. Gray had been

hurt?

A. About twenty minutes.

Q. Was it that long?

A. Yes, I think it was about that long.

Q. You understood then that it was claimed your engine struck

him?

A. I didn’t at that time, No.

Q. How soon did you learn that it was claimed your engine was

the one that struck him?

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 27

A. I believe it was along in the afternoon or evening.

Q. You don’t know what time?

A. No sir, I don’t.

Q. How long had you been in the habit of coming in there with

your engine, up to that clinker pit?

A. Up to the clinker pit and pass through there?

Q. How long had you been in the habit of doing that?

A. It was always customary to pass through there if the track

was clear.

Q. You knew Mr. Gray?

A. Yes sir.

+ ial knew a number of the men employed in and about the

ard?

‘ A. Yes sir.

Q. And cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Employees occupy that space quite generally between the

clinker pit and the round house, do they not, in passing back and

forth on the track itself?

A. Why, I believe they do.

57 Q. You have seen it done, haven’t you?

A. Yes, I have seen it.

Q. Do you know about how many employees are employed in

and about that place?

A. There are two cinder pit men, engine dispatcher and helper.

Q. Foreman there is there not?

A. Round house foreman? A. Yes sir.

Q. And other men employed in the round house?

A. Yes.

Q. So there were quite a number of men who had occasion to work

in that immediate vicinity, is that true?

A. Well, I don’t know as there would be probably anybody that

ever worked there but that probably would pass by there.

Q. You knew about the presence of that little shanty on the

right of the track?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What did you understand that was used for?

A. For a place for the engine dispatcher and helper to stay while

waiting for engines.

Q. After an engine was pulled in the yard and stopped you knew

the engineer had no further duty concerning the engine?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Then it was given to the clinker pit men and they saw to the

fire being knocked out of the engine and water put on and that

the engine was made ready for the next trip?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And the engine dispatcher and helper did that work?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Did you know about this bulletin that has been mentioned

claiming to forbid the engineers from proceeding north of the

clinker pit with their engines?

28 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY Vs,

A. I knew of a bulletin; I don’t know as it forbade them to go

north of the clinker pit.

Q. Did you read that particular bulletin?

A. Yes sir.

Q. If you did what did it provide?

A. That engines shouldn’t be stopped on a certain switch.

Q. Didn’t it particularly provide that the engines shouldn’t go

north of the clinker pit?

A. I couldn’t say.

Q. You say you remember of reading the notice?

A. Yes sir.

Q - long did that bulletin notice remain on the bulletin

A. That I couldn’t state.

Q. Was it on the bulletin board when you saw it?

A. It was,

58 Q. You have a regular bulletin board where some superin-

pam or officer notifies or gives directions to the employees?

A. -Yes,

Q. That is kept where?

A. In the round house in the enginemen’s room where they

register in.

Q. You are supposed to read and observe these directions?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Are you able to give us any idea when that bulletin disap-

?

A. No sir, I haven’t any idea.

Q. You knew it to be a fact that a great many engines did stop,

that is, that put up south of the clinker pit?

A. I couldn’t say; I suppose they did.

Q. There wasn’t any particular reason that you took your engine

north of the cinder pit except as a matter of convenience and to

save you walking? ;

A. Not as I know of.

Q Mr. Kruse, I suppose it is part of your duty to keep a pretty

close lookout ahead to see that no one is in danger and to f sie

the condition of the track as you pass along?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you recall what you were doing on this particular occasion

as you were passing over the clinker pit?

A. Yes, sitting on the seat looking out ahead.

Q. You were not shovelling coal?

A. No sir.

Q ap had nothing to do except perform that particular duty?

A. No sir.

Q. Why didn’t you see Mr. Gray? What is your explanation of

the fact that you failed to see Mr. Gray?

A. Well, there was steam rising from the cinders of the pit.

Q. Was it a cold day?

A. Yes, I believe it was.

Q. The steam rising from the cinders on the pit was sufficient to

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 29

entirely obscure Mr. Gray, even though he had been standing right

ahead—I mean in between the west rail of the track and the coal

shed?

A. I believe so.

Q. In the line of your vision had not your vision in front been

obscured by the steam you would have seen Mr. Gray?

A. Yes sir.

59 Q. If he was in there the only reason why you couldn’t

see him and didn’t see him was because of the steam or

vapor arising from the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You were looking there constantly enough to see him if it

wasn’t for the vapor and steam?

A. Yes sir.

( Were you looking through a glass in front of your seat?

Q. It wasn’t a clear open space?

A. No sir, glass.

Q. Do you know whether or not that glass had become steamed or

covered in any way so as to impede your vision?

A. No sir.

Q. In running a long distance it does become steamed and covered

with cinders and soot and smoke from the cars?

A. We usually wipe that off when it gets dirty.

Q. Did you wipe it off on this occasion?

A. I can’t recall.

Q. If Mr. Gray’s head extended above the steam and vapor you

would have seen that?

A. Yes sir.

Q. About how high in your judgment was this steam and vapor

above the ground?

A. Six or eight feet I should judge.

Q. Were you over it or did it rise still higher?

A. We were over it.

Q. Do you mean to say that it didn’t rise higher than this - ight

feet?

A. I don’t believe it did because I could see over the top of it.

Q. You sat about how high from the ground?

A. About six or eight feet.

Q. It was a large size engine?

A. One of the large sizes.

Q. Pretty near eight feet isn’t it? Do you know what the dimen-

sions of the drive wheel is on that size engine?

A. Sixty-seven inches.

Q. Your seat was considerable higher than the top of the drive

wheel?

A. Yes sir.

Q. I understand you now to claim that you saw no trace of Mr.

Gray at all on that day after you crossed the clinker pit or before

you stopped at the water tank?

A. No sir.

30 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY YS.

Q. You _— keeping a constant lookout on that side of the engine’

. Yes sir.

60 Q. And the thing which obscured your vision was the

: Boag ra of steam and vapor rising from the clinker pit?

es sir

Q. And the wind was carrying the steam and vapor in the

direction in which you were moving?

A. I couldn’t say for sure.

Q. The ——- of a large coal shed and other buildings through

there would tend to confine it in there any way?

A. Yes sir.

Q. There was both smoke and steam rising from this clinker pit?

A. Yes, I believe there was.

Q. And there was some smoke being emptied from the smoke

stack of your engine?

A. I couldn’t say — to that but I don’t believe there was any

smoke.

Q. Not any great volume?

A. No sir.

2 hg didn’t feel anything when the engine struck Mr. Gray?

- 40,

Q. I suppose in passing along there, striking a man and knocking

him down you wouldn’t feel it in any way?

A. I don’t believe we would.

Q. What rate of speed were you going that time, after ing

d bet

over the clinker pit and while passing over the clinker pit an ore

you stopped?

A. We couldn’t have been going over six miles—six to eight

miles an hour.

Q. Might it not have been ten miles an hour?

A. No sir, I don’t think so.

Q. In other words, without thinking of the speed you were moving

along there, but forming a judgment some months ‘ater, within

two, three or four months, could you give the speed with any degree

of certainty or sureness at which you were running?

A. We don’t as a rule generally go in in there over six or eight

miles an hour.

Q. You think you were going about as usual?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Haven’t you testified you were going about eight miles an

hour?

A. I think between seven and eight or six to eight.

Q. Might it have been as high as ten miles an hour?

A. I couldn’t say whether it was or not.

61 Q. Sitting in your position, in the engineman’s position

for that matter. either of you had the same opportunity

to the view ahead?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. How close in front of the engine can you see the roadbed

between the rails?

A. I don’t believe over 20 feet.

WILLIAM H. GRAY.

Q. About 20 feet ahead?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. If a man stood between the rails and you were approaching,

when the engine got within 20 feet of him, or less, he would no

longer be within the line of your vision, as you and engineman

sat in your positions in the engine, is that right?

A. I think the distance and his height would make some dif-

ference.

Q. Suppose it was a block of wood or something of that kind,

say a foot high and a foot square, resting between the rails, near

t the pilot nose or the engine, could you see that?

A. niven 15 and 20 feet I believe we could.

Q. As you looked ahead this time could you see the roadbed

and the rails while you were passing over this clinker pit and through

this thick smoke and steam and vapor?

A. Couldn’t see it on my side that is, the rail.

Q. You don’t know whether the density of this fog was the same

on that side as on the engineman’s side?

A, No, sir.

Q. You were not paying any particular attention to it?

A. No, sir.

(). Neither did you have the rate of speed in mind so as to form

any judgment of the rate of speed you passed in there? ~

A. No, I don’t think so.

Q. Suppose your engine, under the conditions existing there that

morning, and the condition of the vapor, effected the rails so they

were a little wet?

A. I couldn’t say as to that. It might be passing right over the

cinder pit on each side.

Q. With the conditions existing there that time, and the rate

of speed as you passed over clinker pit, after you begun to slow-

down, within what distance would you stop that engine,—50 or

60 feet?

A. I could stop within 20 feet.

62. Q. Are you sure about that?

A. lam pretty sure.

Q. Defendant’s Exhibit “1” shows the location of the tracks

and buildings with reference to the tracks and the objects there in-

dicated in a general way, as they were at the time of the accident,

doesn’t it?

A Yes, sir.

Q. Now, wouldn’t the discharge of steam, the exhaust stay on the

track inside always so that it would form ice?

A. Perhaps.

Defendants’ Exhibit “1” offered in evidence by the Plaintiff

in connection with the examination of the witness.

Q. And you haven’t any idea of about how many hours you had

been on duty at the time you pulled in there over the cinder pit?

A. Approximately 10 or 12 hours I guess.

Q. What have you got to base your guess on, Mr. Kruse? You

82 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY Y8,

don’t know what point you left or how far you traveled or what

hour you left. Is there any way by which you can tell how long

you had been on duty?

A. By looking up the train sheet.

Q. Have you looked up the train sheet?’

A. No sir, I haven’t.

Q. So at the present time you wouldn’t be able to tell?

A. No sir I couldn’t.

Q. You had nothing to do with the ringing of any bell as you

came in over the cinder pit to advance to the point where you

stopped your engine, had you?

A. No, sir.

Q. That wasn’t any of your business to ring the bell?

A. It was if there wasn’t an automatic bell ringer.

Q. That wasn’t your duty at that place at that time?

A. No, because the bell was ringing

By Mr. Martin: I move to have the answer struck out as not

— to the question.

Motion granted.

Exception by defendant.

Q. You didn’t have anything to do with the ringing of the bell

at that time and that place?

A. No, sir.

Q. Do you know about how far the end parts of that engine

extended over the rails?

A. About 18 inches.

63 Q. It was one of those great big heavy engines?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you know anything about the tonnage of it?

A. No sir.

Q. Do you know the number of that engine?

A. 1066 I think it was.

W. H. Kaye, called as an adverse witness, by the plaintiff, being

first duly sworn, testified as follows:

Cross-examination by Att’y Martin:

Q. Were you in the employ of the Chicago Northwestern Railway

Company on the 19th of January, 1911, at the time Mr. Gray was

hurt?

A. I was.

Q. As an engineer?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You operated the engine that is supposed to have struck him?

A. Yes sir.

Q. When did you first learn that it was your engine struck Mr.

Gray as you came in that day?

A. I learned that Mr. Gray was injured after arriving at the

round house for registering in.

Q. How soon was that after you passed over the cinder pit?

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 33

A. Probably 20 or 30 minutes.

Q. Might it have been as low as ten?

A. No sir.

Q. You operated the engine as you came in approaching the

cinder pit and passed over the cinder pit on north to the round

house where it stopped near the water tank?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Can you tell us what was occupying your mind at that time?

A. At that time I was thinking if the track was clear ahead of

us.

Q. Clear of what?

A. Cars and engines.

Q What did you go up there for?

A. I have always went up there if it is clear.

Q. What did you go up there for on this occasion?

A. 1 considered that T had a perfect right to go up there.

Q. What business had you? What reason did you have to take

your engine up there? What business had you with your engine

up there? Did you have any work for your engine up

64 there?

A. I had no work for the engine, No.

Q. You knew that if the engine was —-, north of the cinder

pit that the engine dispatcher was compelled to run it back again

south of the cinder pit to do his work on it?

A. Yes.

Q. Back it up?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How far did you run it across the cinder pit north of the

cinder pit?

A. To the water tank.

Q. How far is that?

A. I should judge about 180 feet.

Q. And you did that to avoid walking that distance did you not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. I should think a walk would have been an agreeable change

to-you at that time. Gotten lazy and wanted to ride had you?

The only reason you had was to avoid that distance?

A. It might be that I was tired when I got that far.

Q. If you were tied then you wanted to avoid walking? Were

you tired that time?

A. A man is generally tired after he gets in his run.

Q. Where were you going after your engine stopped?

A. Going to the round house.

Q. What did you have to do there?

A. Well, I had to carry what clothes I had and take them up

there, put them in a cupboard provided for that purpose and regis-

ter in and report the necessary work to be done on the engine.

Q. That was all?

A. That was all.

Q. Then go about your business whatever it might be elsewhere?

A. Yes.

3—232

34 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8.

Q. You had been examined before in this action before a com-

missioner at Antigo?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You knew about the existence of this so-called bulletin?

A. I remember such a bulletin.

Q. That bulletin provided that engines should stop south of the

cinder pit did it not?

A. That was part of the bulletin I believe.

Q. Do you know who promulgated that bulletin or caused that

to be put up there?

A. f believe it was Mr. Armstrong.

Q. He was at that time in what position?

A. Assistant-superintendent.

Q. Of that division?

A. Yessir. -

Q. How long before this accident to Mr. Gray had this bulletin

been put up there?

A. I don’t know.

Q. About?

A. Don’t remember.

Q. How long had you known of it having been put up?

A. It was sometime that same winter—I don’t remember when

it was.

Q. That would be the winter of 1910 and 1911?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How long to your knowledge was that bulletin on the bulletin

board?

“A. I don’t remember how long it was.

Q. This bulletin board as its name indicates is a board where

orders and directions to employees are posted or written on is it

not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And it becomes your duty to examine that bulletin board

every day you are on duty?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Every trip you go out?

A. Yes sir.

Q. In view of that fact can you tell us when you last saw this

bulletin concerning the stopping of engines south of the cinder

it?

r A. I cannot.

Q. Did it in fact disappear sometime before the happening of this

accident?

A. T don’t know.

Q. So that your state of mind concerning that bulletin is that

sou don’t know whether it was in fact on the board at the time

this accident happened or not?

A. I don’t.

Q. You never saw any bulletin revoking that one?

A. No sir.

Q. Why was it you took nd engine north of that cinder pit in

violation of that bulletin? Was it to save you walking?

65

WILLIAM H. GRAY.

A. Well there could be no other reason.

Q. In other words, you did it several times?

A. I have always done that if there were no engines in there?

Q. This accident happened in January, 1911, with reference to

that what time in the winter did that bulletin first appear?

66 A. I don’t know. I don’t remember.

Q. Was it before the holidays?

A. I couldn’t say whether it was before Christmas or around

Thanksgiving.

Q. It was before freezing weather?

A. I believe so.

Q. Sh of the bulletin related to ice forming on the switch?

A. Yes.

Q. Now, will you tell us why you went north of the cinder pit

in violation of the bulletin with your engine on this and other oc-

casions?

A, That bulletin as I remember it read like this “Engines coming

into Antigo will stop south of the cinder pit on account of stopping

the switch leading to the wrecking track.

That is the track on which the wrecking cars are situated?

Yes.

Go ahead and give us the further reading of the bulletin?

. That is the bulletin as I remember it.

Is that all of it?

. That is all that 1 remember—that is as I remember the bulle-

Q.

A.

Q.

A

Q.

A

tin.

Q.

A.

Q

A

Q)

It was dated?

I suppose it was, yes.

. You don’t remember the date?

. No sir.

. Isn’t it a fact that the instructions or provisions were in

different bulletins, that the provision for stopping south of the

cinder pit simply provided that you should stop south of the cinder

it.

A. No, sir, not to my knowledge.

Q. So you concluded that regardless of the fact that all engines

coming from the south should stop south of the cinder pit you would

go through to the north, provided you could go north and did not

stop your engine in such a way as to stop where it formed ‘ice?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You can give no reason why you couldn’t stop south of the

cinder pit?

A. No.

Q. So you took it in your own hands to go north?

A. As long as I didn’t stop on this switch I considered it all right.

Q. That is, if I interpret your testimony right, you on all occas-

ions when you pulled in you run your engine across north of the

cinder pit before you stopped?

A. If the track was clear, yes.

67 Q. It never occurred to you that that stopping south of

the cinder pit might be intended to protect the lives of the

86 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

men working around there as well, in a place where fog and smoke

and vapor would obscure a person?

A. That was the furthest from my mind.

Q. You knew men did work up in there?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And quite a number of them?

A. Yes sir, =, a half dozen men.

Q. And in doing their work they would move up and around the

track and between the rails?

A. Not necessarily.

Q. They didn’t go through the air did they?

, A. I suppose not.

Q. I am asking what you saw as you came in, di-n’t you see men

go down the track and between the rails of the track and some at

the side of the track?

A. Yes.

Q. You knew where this little shanty was?

See tay they tek thant Os urpose of th

Q. You say they that for the p of the engine dis

patcher and the helper I believe. e

A. Yes, when they had nothing to do but wait for an engine to

come in they staid there.

Q. naa would stay in there out of the severe weather?

A. Yes.

Q. It stood right close to the east rail of the track? -

A. Yes.

Q. What is it? A box car cut in two?

A. I believe that is what it is.

Q. Isn’t it a fact that there is frequently rising from this cinder

pit vapor, smoke and steam?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Engines are cleaned and the fire knocked out on the pit every

day, are they not? .

A. Yes sir.

Q. And a good many of them?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And these coals among them have live coals which hold fire

for a considerable length of time?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do they also exhaust the engine which is hostled, exhaust the

steam from the engine while standing there on the cinder pit track,

blow off the steam?

A. That is optional with him, I think.

Q. Does he do it sometimes?

A. Sometimes they do I suppose.

Q. They have a hose there for the purpose of throwing water on

these live coals?

A. They have a hose there, yes.

68 Q. I show you photograph, defendant’s Exhibit “2,” and

call your attention to the cinder pit, hose attachment fastened

to the pipe immediately west of the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir..

Q. Know what it is used for?

A. Yes sir.

Q. It is used to throw water upon the live cinders that are

— from the engines that are cleaned on the cinder pit is it

not

A. Yes sir.

Defendant’s Exhibit “2” offered in evidence in connection with

the cross-examination of the witness.

Q. It is in daily use is it not?

A. I couldn’t say.

Q. Well, at least it is commonly used is it not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Whenever it is used to throw water on the live coals it is

likely to cause vapor and steam to arise?

A. It is.

Q. And obscure the vision at that time?

A. Yes.

Q. The work of these men who have occasion to work around

there is principally between the cinder pit and the round house

north of there, is it not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. That is, they have no particular work south of the cinder

pit—around the cinder pit they get the engines and bring them to

the cinder pit and go on north?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And then come back and get another engine?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Then the space or area is from just south of the cinder pit to

the round house north?

A. Yes.

Q. You never talked with any superior officer with reference to

what the construction was or what was intended to be meant by

that bulletin?

A. No sir.

Q. As you approached the cinder pit on this time in question you

of course observed a cloud of smoke and steam or whatever it was

or might have been, hovering over the cinder pit and over the

track?

A. Yes sir.

Q. About how large a volume did you observe and in what direc-

tion was it passing? : ;

A. It varied from three to eight feet high I should judge ap-

prox-mately. -

69 Q. A thick up and down mass, some places higher and

some places lower?

A. Yes sir. ;

Q. Some places dense and some places light?

A. Yes sir. Peta bs

Q. And the wind was carrying it in what direction?

38 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

A. I couldn’t say.

Q. Did it cover the track in front of you?

A. It covered the track at the cinder pit.

Q. And beyond the cinder pit did it cover the track also?

A. I don’t think so.

Q. Do you mean to say it arose straight over the cinder pit and

didn’t extend north of it at all?

A. I wasn’t in a position to see; I saw the steam coming from the

cinder pit.

Q. You were in a position to see after you crossed the cinder pit

whether or not you were still in fog and vapor and smoke?

A. There wasn’t any fog at any time.

Q. What I mean by fog is the vapor and steam and smoke rising

there?

A. I couldn’t say.

Q. You testified at Antigo that there was some six or eight feet

or cloud of this stuff before you?

A. I was over that—I was higher.

Q. You were higher?

A. Certainly.

Q. This was along the ground and extended about six or eight

feet?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Did it settle down nearer to the ground than you were, so

you could look over it?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Did you see Mr. Gray as you advanced in there?

A. No sir.

Q. Were you looking or on the look-out for any person that

time, any person or persons between the rails or near the track?

. Yes.

Q. Were you keeping a lookout for that particular purpose?

A. Yes.

Q. And you saw no one on that side?

A. There was no one on my side any place.

Q. How fast were you going as you crossed the cinder pit track

before you slowed down for the stop? .

A. I don’t remember how fast I was going—possibly be-

70 tween six and ten miles an hour.

Q. Did you make a report of this accident to the company

afterwards?

A. Yes sir.

Q. In which report you did state the rate of speed did you?

A. T believe so, that is generally made in those reports.

Q. And in that report you stated it at what?

Objected to as immaterial. Objection over ruled.

Exception by defendant.

Q. Are you able to state at what rate of speed you reported it?

A. In my answer from six to ten miles I mean approximately. I

may have been going slower than six but no faster than ten; what-

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 89

ever rt I did make I was going that fast because I remembered

better than that I can today.

Q. Didn’t you report you were going eight miles an hour?

A. If I did I was going at that.

The plaintiff asks the defendant to produce the report.

By Att’y Smarr: I believe we are not required to produce any re-

rt of witness to explain that explained anything as to this particu-

a accident.

Epwarp M. Smart, being first duly sworn testified for and on

behalf of the plaintiff as follows:

Direct examination by Att’y Martin:

Q. Mr. Smart, you are the attorney for defendant in this case

A. Yes sir.

Q. Rather with the preparation of the defense in this action?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Were you served by the plaintiff with a notice to produce

papers, documents, etc. that had any bearing upon this case?

A. I received such notice.

Q. Look at this instrument which is entitled, “Notice to

71 Defendant to produce papers, etc. a copy of this Exhibit “A”

was served upon you was it not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You heard me ask the last witness, Mr. Kane, whether he

sent a report of this accident to the defendant company after the

accident happened di- you not?

A. Yes sir.

Q And he said he did?

A. I so understood

Q. Have you that report in your possession among your papers

here now?

A. I object to that question and claim that the furnishing of any

papers in relation to the testimony of the witness by my client and

mryself is confidential ; that the matter related simply to the prepara-

tion of our defense and they have no right to ask me what I pro-

cured in that matter any more than they have to ask me for my

brief or my private letters or to come on the stand and tell what

my witnesses are going to swear.

Q. The plaintiff objects to your stating anything unless you are

going to produce it. You can produce it if you want to unless you

have something to conceal. ‘ :

A. I object to your making a statement that there is anything to

conceal in it and at the same time I refuse to produce it.

By the Courr:

Q. To whom was that report made? —

A. It was apparently to the company in general, not to any par-

ticular officer.

Objection over ruled. Exception.

40 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

Q. You have that report in your possession have you, Mr. Smart?

A. I have a — here that purports to be signed by Mr. Kane

and I am advised by him it is his signature.

Q. We ask now that you produce it for the use of counsel of the

plaintiff in connection with the cross examination of Witness Kane

who was just dismissed from the stand temporarily?

A. I object to the request and will produce the report only on the

order of the Court.

By the Court:

The objection is over ruled and the witness ordered to produce

the report.

The defendant excepts to the ruling of the Court.

72 Pu’ xr F's Ex. “B.”

Mr. Kane recalled by the plaintiff.

By Att’y Smarr: Counsel for the defendant produces the report

in question which has been marked Plaintiff's Exhibit “B” under

protest, and in fear of commitment for contempt.

By Att’y Martin:

Q. Mr. Kane I show you this instrument marked Plaintiff’s

Exhibit “B” and ask you if that is the report you made of the acci-

dent?

By Mr. Smarr: It is understood that to all of the questions con-

cerning this report we enter the same objection.

A. Yes sir.

Q. After having examined that report Mr. Kune tell us whether

you reported the rate of speed at which you were moving at about

eight miles an hour?

A. I did.

Q. You stated a little while ago that if you reported it in your

statement that was more likely to be correct than any estimate you

could make now?

A. Yes sir.

Q. That report was ne on the day it is dated?

A. Yes sir. P

Q. What was the date?

A. 26th of January, 1911.

Q. Going at about eight miles an hour on the track as it was at

the time in question, operating this engine and tender, within what

distance could you stop the engine?

A. About twenty feet.

Q. When you were examined at Antigo didn’t you give the dis-

tance at 40 feet?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. Has your attention been called to the subject as to how soon

you could stop it?

A. No sir.

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 4l

Q. If you gave it at 40 feet when examined at Antigo and at 20

feet now how do you account for the difference?

A. May be 20 feet and may be 40 feet, according to the rails.

Q. According to what?

A. To the condition of the rail.

73 Q. When you testified in Antigo you had better in mind

the condition of the rails as they were at the time of the

accident?

A. No sir.

Q. Did you think that counsel was asking about rails covered

with snow, stopping in the snow or with a train attached?

. No sir.

At this time in question how were the rails?

I don’t remember how they were at the time.

You don’t know whether they were dry or damp?

No sir.

If they were damp it would take a greater difficulty to stop?

. It would be more likely to slip on the damp rails than on the

Were you going down or up grade in crossing the cinder pit

5s &

RO? pOPoPeP

~

A. Level grade.

Q. Don’t you think that 20 feet was a pretty short distance in

which to stop an engine running eight miles an hour?

A. When I gave the answer 40 miles an hour I might have had in

mind making an ordinary stop on surface blocks. Now I am not

positive; but at the rate of speed I was going I know I could stop

that engine within 20 feet with the emergency brakes.

Q. Why didn’t you make that answer before the commissioner?

A. I probably didn’t think of that.

Q. For how great a distance along in front of that engine and

near the ground was this:bank of vapor, steam and smoke after

you passed through the cinder pit going north? You said as you

sat there you were over this bank of vapor and smoke, that is you

were higher up and could look it over, that it was down near the

ground—now, what I want to know is how far it extended north after

you crossed the cinder pit track?

A. I don’t think it extended north at all.

Q. Do you mean to say that after your engine crossed the cinder

pit track there was no smoke at all?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. Will you swear there wasn’t.

A. I don’t know I said.

Q. You heard the testimony of your fireman?

A. Yes sir.

74 Q. Did you look on his side of the track to see?

A. From where?

Q. From where you were in your engine?

A. I couldn’t say.

Q. You could see some distance ahead from his side of the track?

A. Yes sir.

42 CHICAGO & NOKTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

Q. I am trying at the presence of fog and vapor and smoke

that might be ae on over up the cinder pit track. Will you

swear that there wasn’t any ahead of your engine after you passed

the cinder pit track? After you passed over the cinder pit track

is what I mean?

A. How far do you mean over the cinder pit track? (There

might have been some extended out one or two feet.

Suppose you got 50 or 60 feet beyond?

A. I will swear that there was none 50 or 60 feet beyond.

Q You think you can swear to that?

A. I know it.

Q. Where did that stuff stay?

A. I don’t know.

Q. It didn’t rise to the moon?

A. Might have went around the other side of the coal shed. It

was just as likely to.

Q. Go east and west?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. How was the wind blowing?

. I don’t remember.

Don’t know whether it was north or south?

I don’t.

Might have been directly from the south for all you know?

I don’t think there was very much wind blowing at all.

Do you know?

I don’t remember.

. Where did you start from on your trip that day?

. Green Bay, I believe.

Are you sure?

. I am positive.

. Didn’t you say on your examination that you didn’t know

whether you started from Green Bay, Kaukauna or Fond du Lac?

A. I don’t remember what I said.

Q Don’t you remember being asked and you said you didn’t

know whether Green Bay, Fond du Lac or Kaukauna?

, A. Well, I don’t know and I am not positive now where I started

rom.

Q. Why did you say “Green Bay I believe’?

A, Because I was on the run that time between Antigo aml

Green Bay.

75 Q. Didn’t the fact that you learned about this accident

30 minutes after impress this trip on your mind particularly?

A. No sir.

Q. How many hours had you been on duty continually at the

time of this accident?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. You don’t know the time of day or the time of night you

started from whatever point you did start?

A. No sir, could have found out very easily.

Q But you haven’t found out?

A. No air.

A

Q.

A,

Q.

A.

Q.

A.

Q

A

Q.

A

Q

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 43

Q. As a matter of fact you do keep a record of the — you

make on every trip and report it and get paid for it?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And you are not able to tell this court and jury whether you

left Green Bay or Fond du Lac on this trip?

A. No sir.

Q. Spend any ~—e since that time working on a run between

Kaukauna, Green Bay and Ashland and over that division?

A. I don’t keep any track on my mind at all. I don’t know

where I run two tone ago. Since that time I worked on runs all

over that division.

Q. How many times have you encountered smoke, steam vapor

or such stuff?

A. Several times.

4 How are you able to tell us that the vapor didn’t extend 50 feet

north?

A. Because I know it didn’t.

Q. How is it your memory is able to remember that?

A. Because I remember that—I know it.

Q. ag you can’t say where you left on that trip?

A. No.

Q. Do you mean to say you left Green Bay, Kaukauna or Fond

du Lac?

A. I can’t say what point I started from.

Q can’t say that now but you remember about the vapor?

A. Yes.

Q. On your examination at Antigo wasn’t this question put to

you:

“Q. How far were you south of the south end of the cinder pit?

A. Probably 60 or 80 feet may be 100 feet I can only guess it.”

A. Yes sir.

Q. That was your figures approximately.

A. Yes sir.

“Q Then you first saw the steam 60 or 80 feet south of the

south end of the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.”

Q. Do you remember those questions?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And did you give those answers?

A. Yes, sir.

76 “Q. How fast were you going at that time?

A. Approximately between six and ten miles an hour. I

couldn’t say exactly how fast I was going; wasn’t going over ten

miles an hour.”

—. Did you give that answer?

A. Yes sir.

Q Wasn’t going over ten miles an hour?

A. I could stop at the rate I was going within a car length.

Q. What is a car length?

A. About 40 feet.

44 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

Q. Going at such a rate of speed you can bring an engine to a

stop within 40 feet distance?

A. I could, yes.

Q. Do you remember those questions and did you give those

answers?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Was this question —toy

“Q. When you got to the male ‘oi of the cinder pit going north

where did you first strike the steam. You couldn’t see the track

pene on account of the steam for at least a distance of 40 feet

north?

A. I couldn’t see the rail.”

Q. If that is true, then the steam extended at least 40 feet north

and obscured that rail didn’t it?

A. The cinder pit is probably that long.

2 How long is the cinder pit?

I don’t know; may be 100 feet long.

Q As you were looking over this bank of vapor and smoke you

could not tell how far it extended north could you?

A. I could by looking over it.

Q. Did you have it in mind at that time? Were you consciencely

thinking of just how far this bank of vapor and smoke extended

for the purpose of remembering it?

A. I had it in mind on account of seeing the steam there.

Q Did you have it in mind for the purpose of remember- it?

Did you try to charge your mind with how far that bank of vapor

and smoke extended north of the cinder pit?

A. Not to remember it, no.

Q. How frequently do you meet with vapor and smoke at this

place?

A. Quite often.

Q. About how often? How often during a week would you get

in there?

A. Might get in there every day and then again might not get

in there for a month.

Q. Every time they put an engine in there to knock coals

77 out of they knock down some live coals don’t they?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And they have a hose there to turn water on those live coals

to quench them?

A. Yes sir.

Q And whenever they do that there is some vapor and steam

arises from the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And it is carried according to the wind?

A. Yes sir.

Q. So you might come in on the track and not see any and you

might come in every day and see it every time?

A. Yes sir.

Q. So this is not an unusual thing there?

A. No.

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 45

-Q You cannot tell this court and jury when you saw vapor

and steam there Jast before the accident?

A. No sir.

Q. Are you quite sure there was any smoke and vapor there

on the day of the accident?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How do you come to remember that, on this particular day?

A. I probably wouldn’t remember it only on account of the acci-

dent.

Q. Did you have any talk with Mr. Gray after the accident?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How soon after the accident did you talk with Mr. Gray?

A. I believe it was that evening or the next day, I don’t remember

which.

Q. Where?

A. At his house.

Q. Was it that evening or the next day?

A. Possibly that afternoon or evening of that day I think.

Wi1u1aM Rock, called as an adverse witness, being first duly

sworn, testified for and on behalf of the Plaintiff.

Cross-examination by Att’y P. H. Martin:

Q. Are you in the employ of the defendant company at this time

Mr. Rock?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You were at the time Mr. Gray was hurt on the 19th of

January, 1911?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What position did you hold at that time?

A. Hostler helper.

Q. That is you helped Mr. Gray?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What did you have to do as helper?

; A. Knock the fires, take water and wood, and throw

78° switches when necessary.

Q. Where did your work take you?

A. Between the cinder pit and the round house.

Q And you were passing up and down the track there?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Or on either side of the track?

Either side sometimes.

. The help all do that?

Yes sir.

That is those who had occasion to pass back and forth there?

We did.

Every day?

. Every day.

When you take an engine what do you first do with it?

. Put it on the pit.

Q. Then what?

ePpeorore>

>

46 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V5,

A. Have the pan cleaned and knock the fire.

Q In knocking the fire out would you knock all of the live coals

out of the pan?

A. All of them.

Q. After an engine comes in from its run there wouldn’t be much

live coals in it?

A. Sometimes and sometimes hardly any.

Q. How mary engines a day would you handle on the cinder

pit—on an average?

A. On an average about fifteen.

Q. There was a crew that did that work was there not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. When you say you did you mean during your shift?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What method did you have of putting out those coals or

quenching them?

A. The pit men would throw water on them.

Q. How many men did you have employed in the pit?

A. It might be lots of engines would come in—there would be

four; two daytimes and two nights.

Q. What do the pit men do there?

A. Wet down the cinders, clean out the pan and clean the cinders

out of the pit.

Q. And whenever an engine is discharged from the cinder pit

wouldn’t the pit men wet down the cinders?

A. Sometimes wet them down right away and sometimes they

wouldn’t.

Q. Sometimes waited until the pile accumulated did they?

A. Sometimes they were busy at something else.

Q. When they did wet it down they would throw the

water upon these live coals and cinders?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. That would cause a lot of steam to rise and blow over in

there with the wind?

A. Yes,

Q. Didn’t it make a noise also?

A. Sometimes, yes .

Q. And that steam would be carried in which ever direction the

wind was?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And it would rise a large volume or small volume according

to the area of cinders that were wet down?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Was it a usual thing to find a volume of steam hanging over

that cinder pit and being blown by that wind?

A. There would be some blowing around.

Q. Some blow away and some stay there for a while according

to the wind?

A. Yes sir.

Q. i that as a common thing there was the presence of some

3 WILLIAM H. GRAY. 47

A. Yes for awhile when the cinders were taken out.

Q. State to what extent you had occasion to pass up and down

that track between the cinder pit and the round house and switches”

A. Walked up and down several times a day whenever the wotk

would call us to go up and down there.

Q Mr. Gray the same way?

A. Yes sir. A

Q. Did you know about the existence of this little shanty on the

road or the track?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What was that used for?

A. It was used for the dispatchers and helpers to go in and eat

their lunch and sit down in there out of the weather when there

wasn’t any work.

Q. Were you in there at the time this engine was brought in by

Mr. Kane soon after the accident?

A. Yes, I was in that shanty.

Q While in that shanty was it part of your duty to listen for

incoming engines?

A. Why, yes, but being there as long as 1 was something would

call my attention; being at the work as long as I was there were

times when my mind wouldn’t be on what was around there.

Q. You became conscious of the fact that this engine had passed

up north?

A. When brought into the yard, yes.

80 Q. Did Mr. Gray come into the shanty after he was struck

or injured?

A. Yes, he came in afterward.

Q. How long before that had you heard this engine pass by?

A. Do you mean pass the shanty? I didn’t hear the engine go

=. the shanty; I heard her come in the yard but not past the

ty.

Q. Did you hear any bell rung as this engine went by your

shanty?

A. 1 didn’t hear the bell on that engine.

“@ If the bell on that engine was ringing as it passed the shanty

you would have heard it?

A. Not always.

Q. On this particular occasion do you know whether or not you

would have heard it as it went past the shanty if it was ringing?

A. Not necessarily—Il could have my mind on something else

and the bell ringing.

Q. And at the same time you might have heard it?

A. Yes.

Q. But you didn’t hear it?

A. No.

Q. It might ring and you not hear it?

A. Yes sir.

& As a matter of fact it was your duty to listen for the bell ring-

ing

A. Yes sir.

48 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS.

Q. Were you listening for a bell that might go north of the

cinder pit?

A. In a way I was listening but it just slipped my mind.

‘Q. It was your duty to listen?

A. It was my duty, yes.

Q. That was one way in which the presence of an engine was

indicated to you?

A. Yes sir.*

Q. On hearing a bell it was your duty to come out and take care

of the engine?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How far is this shanty, about, from the east rail?

A. I judge about 14 feet.

Q. Is it that far?

A. Yes, I judge it to be.

Q. When Mr. Gray came in there he was all covered with blood,

wasn’t he?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. He told you he was struck by an engine?

A. Yes sir. 3

Q. You were a little surprised because you had heard no

81 engine go by and heard no bell?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Other times you did hear the bell ringing on engines as they

went by and also had heard the engines?

A. Not always.

Q. You had heard them on other occasions?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Isn’t it a fact, Mr. Rock, that you had nothing to do on this

particular occasion but to listen for the approach of an engine, and

isn’t it true also that you were listening for the bell on any engine

that might come in on your track?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Under those circumstances isn’t it true you would have heard

the bell if one were ringing?

A. No.

Q. I show you plaintiff's Exhibit “C’ and ask you ‘o look at it

and state whether or not that is all in your own handwriting?

A. It is in my handwriting, yes.

Q. Do you know about when you wrote that—how long ago?

A. I don’t know whether it is dated or not; I didn’t notice that.

Q. It is dated Antigo, 5th of December, 1911 that date is evi-

dently correct is it?

A. I don’t remember if it was that date or not.

Q. You said in that, did you not, that if the bell had been ring-

ing you surely would have heard it?

A. That is what is down there.

Q. Was that your opinion at that time?

A. I didn’t base it on anything at that time.

Q. You did state in that didn’t you or intended to that every-

thing you set forth was the truth in reference to whether or not the

49

WILLIAM H. GRAY.

ling ga ringing and if it had been ringing you would have

h it

A. I intended to put down what was the truth.

Q. And that time you said if the bell had been ringing you

surely would have heard it. Was that your judgment then?

A. Yes, in a way.

Q. I don’t understand what you mean by “in a way.” What do

you mean to modify by “in a way?”

A. I was in the shanty there and didn’t hear it go by.

Q. Is it your judgment now that if the bell had been ringing as it

went by that you would have heard it?

A. No, the bell could have been ringing and I not hear il.

82 Q. I grant you that; but the question is—Is it your judg-

ment that if it had been ringing going by you would have

heard it?

A. It could have been ringing and I might not hear it.

Q. You told me that a dozen times. What did you mean when

you state in that writing “If the bell had been ringing I surely

would have heard it?”

A. I had my mind based on the fact that the bell wasn’t ringing.

Q. You had it in your mind when you made that written state-

ment that the bell wasn’t ringing?

A. Yes, that is why I made that statement.

Q. You had that in mind because you were in the shanty at the

time listening for incoming engines?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And it was your duty to listen for incoming engines?

A. It was.

Q. And you can hear the bell of incoming engines when they are

‘passing that shanty?

A. You can if you are listening.

Q. You can hear them further away than that?

A. Yes.

Q. If an engine went by two blocks away and they were ringing

a bell you could hear it?

“A. If you were good of hearing.

Q. Are you good of hearing?

A. Pretty fair.

Q. You don’t claim your hearing is at all defective?

A. I haven’t had it tested.

Q. How soon after this accident did you talk with counsel for the

defendant about the bell ringing?

A. Do you mean with Mr. Gray?

Q. With Mr. Smart or Mr. Gorman?

A. I can’t remember just how long it was; might have been a

week or somewheres along that.

Q. How did you come to see them so soon after the accident?

A. One of the company men called me in the office I think a week

after, may be longer. I can’t say that for sure; I don’t remember

when.

Q. Who was it?

4—232

50 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

‘A. A claim agent, I forget his name.

Q. Mr. Pearsall—this man sitting over towards Mr. Smart—

looks like a clergyman?

A. I think he is the gentleman.

Q. How soon did you talk with Mr. Smart or Mr, Gorman here

about the ringing of the bell?

A 2 don’t remember of talking with any of them any

83 shee unless today.

Q. Did they ni you whether or not you heard the bell

we ve

forget now.

Q. Do you mean to say you forget the talk you had with them

today?

A. I forget other things.

Q. You hadn’t talked with any of them at the time you made

this written statement?

A. No.

Q. Do you know what you were doing before Mr. Gray came into

the shanty?

A. Sitting in the shanty resting.

. What, if anything, occupied your hands?

. Nothing.

Just sitting still?

Yes.

Was the door open?

The door was closed.

Any windows in?

Yes, three windows.

Any window in the west end?

Yes, there is a window in the door.

Any window in the west end?

No, Just in the door.

Q. How long had you been in the shanty before Mr. Gray came

in at the time you saw Mr. Gray when he was injured?

A. May be about two hours.

Q. Continuously for two hours?

A. About two hours. —

Q. What time of day did Mr. Gray come in there injured?

A. After being injured?

A. I think about ten minutes.

Q. Did you make any note of it?

A. No.

Q Had you been in the shanty doing nothing for those two hours

75 © that time?

>OPOPOPOrPePe

. Yes.

Q. Continually? Hadn’t come out at all?

A. Hadn’t come out at all.

Q. Was there a window in the south side of that shanty?

A. Yes air.

Q. A couple?

WILLIAM H. GRAY.

A. One.

Q. That was towards the cinder pit track?

A. Yes. ;

Q. You were looking out of that to see if an engine was coming

dow?

A. No sir, the windows are up a little high.

84 Q Any windows in the north side?

A. No sir.

Q. They weren’t smeared over?

A. No sir.

Q. Only one in the south end and one in the east end?

A. Yes.

Q. Did ycu notice how much vapor and steam and smoke there

was Say from the cinder pit track at this time when Gray was

hurt?

A. I noticed that there was quite a bit.

Q. Did you notice it before he was hurt?

A. I noticed it that morning; couldn’t help but see it.

Q. Why do you say you couldn’t help noticing it?

A. Knocking out the fire it was close to the cab.

Q. There had been a good deal of cinders knocked out and left

undisturbed on the cinder pit that morning and the day before?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Did you hear Mr. Gray give directions to the pit men to turn

water on the cinders that were hot and likely to burn somewhat?

A. He told me several times at different times.

Q. On this particular morning?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. Did you see the man turn water on the cinders and coals on

this particular morning?

A. When they were knocking fire out and I came to the gangway

then they were putting water on.

Q. So you did, in fact, see them putting water on?

A. Yes sir. :

Q. Didn’t the steam and vapor and gas rising there make it dif-

ficult somewhat to do your work?

A. Sometimes.

Q. Didn’t it that morning if there was quite a bit there?

A. Sometimes a person can stand more gas than others.

Q. Do you know whether the wind was blowing the steam north

toward the coal shed and shanty?

A. It was blowing north [ think. I don’t know just which way

the wind was blowing; the wind was blowing the steam and gas more

north I think.

Q. Was the wind blowing quite a gale?

A. No, [I don’t think it was.

Q. Was it a brisk wind.

A. I couldn’t say how fast it was blowing.

52 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS.

Q. Did that steam and vapor rise high from the pit so as to bother

you when up on the seat of the engine.

A. Some times.

Q. How was it on this morning. How high did it rig

85 above the the cinder pit?

A. When the water was thrown on it would sometimes rise

to the top of the cab.

Q. That would depend on the force of the water?

A. Yes sir.

Q. After you went into the shanty did you observe the condition

of the vapor and smoke any further?

A. I didn’t look out the window to see.

Q. ga look out to know anything about it?

A. No.

Q. Immediately after Mr. Gray came in hyrt what did you do?

A. He asked me to get him a pail of water and I went and got it.

Q. When you got this pail of water there was still steam and

smoke from the cinder pit and blowing north of it?

A. Yes, there was some blowing.

Q. And the wind was blowing north?

A. Yes.

Q. How far north did it extend?

A. I should judge about a car length, or a car and a half at

times.

Q. I suppose you didn’t measure it in any way?

. No.

Q. Didn’t pay any attention much?

A. No, not exactly.

Q. Was it pretty dense?

A. Some times.

Q. When you went out after this pail of water was it thick and

A. Yes sir.

Q. As a matter of fact that vapor and steam and smoke was blown

further on north of the shanty than it was when you went out?

. No, that time it was blown a car or a car and a half.

. It had blown further north than the shanty when you went

Not shat I know of.

Will you swear that it hadn’t.

I know it hadn’t.

Had it rose up above the ground a little ways?

es.

Ii hadn’t stopped at a certain point had it?

No.

It kept on going until it was evaporated?

Yes sir.

What did you do after you got the water?

Brought it to the shanty.

°

POPOPOPOPOFPrRO>

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 53

Q. What of the engine?

A. When I got back with the water I noticed the engine up at the

wood pile north of the shanty.

Q. And that was Mr. Kane’s engine?

A. Yes,

Q. Did you see Mr. Kane?

. No sir.

. Did you see his fireman?

. No sir.

. They had departed?

A. They had gone.

. About how far north of the shanty had the engine stopped?

. I think it was around in here some place.

Blue Print, Defendant’s Exhibit “One” indicates the point by an

“z” at which the engine had sto ,

(Witness indicates by pointing finger towards a place marked

“wood bin.”)

Q. I notice along here on the east side of this track north of the

cinder pit there is an obstruction is there not?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How high up is that box in which they discharge steam?

A. I should judge about four feet high.

Q. Comes closer to the east rail than what your shanty did?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Did you see within an hour or two, either Mr. Kane or Mr.

Kruse, after the accident?

A. No sir.

Q. How soon did you get back to your shanty again after having

gone up to where the engine was?

A. Why, it must have been an hour afterwards; after I had the

engine taken care of I went back to the shanty.

Q. You didn’t go back to where Mr. Gray was or take any care

of him.

A. No, I couldn’t stand to be around where there was any blood,

that is the reason I didn’t go back to help him.

Q. Was he bleeding profuselv?

A. He was.

Q. Where was he bleeding from?

A. He was covered with blood all over his face. I just took a

glance at him, that is all.

Q. When you came back Mr. Gray was gone?

A. When I came back from the engine.

87 Q. When you came back from tending the engine?

A. He was in the shanty then.

Q. When you remember him bleeding?

54 CHICAGO &£ NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

A. Why, I went and got the engine and put it back on the pit

and after I got back to the shanty he was readv to go home.

Q. He was still in the shanty after you had done all that?

A. No. After I gave him the pail of water I went and run the

engine down to the pit and opened the pan and while I opened the

pan and was getting the cinders out of it he was on his way home

then.

Q. Then I am right in saying when you came back after doing

this — Gray was no longer in the shanty?

A. No.

Q. How long had you worked there in this capacity, with Mr,

Gray?

A. Between six and seven years.

Q. Did you know about this bulletin which had been put u

there that winter which gave instructions for engines to stop sou

of the cinder pit?

A. I didn’t know of no bulletin.

Q. You knew that the engines did frequently stop south of the

cinder pit?

A. Some times.

Q. Some stop south and sometimes some go north?

A. Yes.

Q. The greater number of them that winter and a short time

before Mr. Gray was hurt stopped south of the cinder pit?

A. No, they were running along most any place.

Q. Was there a place for damaged engines north of the cinder

it ?

- ? A. I don’t know of any.

Q. Wasn’t it part of your duty to look after the bulletins that

are stuck up there and see what they provided?

A. I suppose in a way.

: gaa you make it a habit daily to read bulletins?

. No.

Q. How frequently did you read bulletins?

A. Couldn’t say about that. I couldn’t say how often it would be.

Q. Can you tell us when was the last time you looked at the

bulletin board just before Mr. Gray was hurt?

A. I looked at the bulletin board most every day. I went into

the round house to see what was the number; but I didn’t

88 look at the bulletins that was posted up there in writing

or paper.

Q. You looked at the bulletin board every time you went in the

round house?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Was that every day?

A. Yes.

Q. Then you would read the bulletins there daily?

A. No. I wouldn’t read the bulletins. The bulletin was on ons

side; there is part of one side that has the bulletin on written on

paper or printed, and the bulletin board is on the other for the

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 55

purpose of marking the train and engine and name- of the engi-

neer and fireman and what time they are going to leave.

Q. Was that marked in chalk on a blackboard?

A. Yes,

Q. And also the bulletins written on paper posted on one side of

the board?

A. Yes.

Q. Did you examine those?

A. No. : :

- Q. Did you never examine those?

A. Once in a while, not often.

Q. Wasn’t it part of your duty to examine those to see what your

duties were and get directions for duties on the tracks?

A. It might have been but I didn’t.

Q. Will you tell us whether or not there was a bulletin directing

that engines will stop south of the cinder pit?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. But engines were stopped south of the cinder pit?

A. There was some did.

Q. That was before Mr. Gray got hurt?

A. Yes.

Q. The fact is that many of the engines did stop south of the

cinder pit that winter?

A. Oh, yes, there were some.

Q. You passed up and down that space frequently between the

west rail and the coal shed?

A. Not very often.

Q. Where did you generally pass up and down between the two

rails?

A. Sometimes; sometimes outside of the east rail.

Q. There was a space there of three feet between the rail and the

north?

A. Not so close to the track.

89 Q. Are there more obstructions on the east side than on

the west side?

A. Yes sir. :

Q. Any obstructions on the west side?

A. Yes, the coal shed.

Q. There was a space there of three feet between the rail and the

coal shed?

A. I don’t know; I never measured it at all.

Q. Have you been asked by counsel in the case where you usually

walked when you passed up and down there?

A. I don’t know what you mean.

Q. Have you been posted by Mr. Smart or Mr. Gorman today or

any other time where to say you walked when you passed up and

down the track?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. Can you remember anything they asked you?

A. Well, may be, a few things.

Q. Did they ask you about ni you walked?

56 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

A. I said I don’t remember.

Q. Didn’t they suggest to you the idea that you always walked

on the right side?

A. No, they never told me I always did.

Q. aad didn’t tell you that?

A. No

Q. Can you tell us whether they asked you about where you

walked or not?

A. I don’t remember.

Q. You can tell us whether they asked you whether the bell was

ringing or not?

A. I think they asked me about that.

Q. But when I asked you that question some 15 or 20 minutes

ago you said you didn’t know about it. Do you now remember that

they did ask you about the ringing of the bell?

A. I don’t think you asked me that. If you did I think it is

queer I didn’t answer it. I don’t think you asked me at all.

Q. Do you know now as to whether or not Mr. Smart or Mr.

Gorman asked you about the ringing of the bell on that engine?

A. They never asked any other time.

Q. My question is did they today, or any other time, ask you

about the ringing of the bell?

A. I think they asked me today.

Q. You know they did, don’t you?

A. I’m pretty sure they did.

90 Q. And that is where you got the idea that you are not

sure that you heard the bell ringing, if it did ring in fact?

A. Oh, no, I had it before.

Q. Discussed that question with them? Doesn’t that account

with your testimony not jibing with your written statement?

A. No sir.

Q. There was nothing along in this place between the west rail

and coal shed to prevent your walking along there if you saw fit

so to do?

A. In the winter time there would be snow in there.

Q. But beaten down just the same as between the rails?

A. That is on the inside. -

Q. I want to know was it beaten down the same as between the

rails?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And to and from work to your coal shed?

A. I say that the sheeting is on the inside of the studding.,

Q. I call your attention to photograph marked “Defendant’s Ex-

hibit 3” which purports to show the coal shed?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you see the construction of that coal shed?

A. Yes sir.

Q. There is a wide space here I judge a foot wide?

A. I think so.

Q. And the sheeting is on the inside of the studding?

A. Yes sir,

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 57

Q. There is plenty of space in there for a man to walk even

when an engine is i

A. I wouldn’t care to be walking in there.

Q. You had rather be walking between the rails?

A. No, on the other side.

Q. And you got that idea from Mr. Smart and Mr. Gorman?

A. No sir.

_ Q. Would you prefer being in between the end of this steam box

and the east rail when an engine was passing? The blow-out box?

A. There is space there——

Q. Answer my question? Would you prefer to be in there then

in between the north rail and coal shed?

A. Yes.

Q. Why?

A. More space.

Q. Which is closer to the rail—the east end of the blow off box

of the sheeting or the coal shed?

A. I don’t know; I never measured; there can’t be much differ-

ence.

91 Q. Why do you say more space if you never measured it?

A. Because I have been there.

Q. Will you admit the truth that you are now trying to help the

defendant in your testimony. You are now trying to testify as Mr.

Smart would like you to as near as you know how?

A. I am trying to tell the truth.

The defendant objects to the attorney asking such questions and

making such remarks to the witness, and takes exception at this time

to counsel stating that the witness is trying to testify as Mr. Smart

wishes.

Q. Why do you say that you had rather be in between the west

end of the blow off box and the east rail rather than up between the

coal shed and the west rail if you didn’t know whether the blow off

box is closer to the east rail than the coal shed is to the west rail?

A. I don’t know how to answer that.

Q. And that means you don’t know which is closer to the shed?

A. I never measured.

Q. But from your observations is the blow off box closer to the

east rail than the coal shed is to the west rail?

A. I judge it to be a little closer.

Q. Some excavation between the shanty and the cinder pit on the

east side of the track up close to the rail?

A. I don’t know what you mean. i

Q. I mean a dig out between the shanty and the cinder pit on the

right hand side of the track?

A. Yes, there is.

Q. How close is that to the end of the ties?

A. I don’t know what you mean.

Q. Isn’t there a dug out there further on the north end of that as

shown by this blue print (blue print shown witness) Plaintiff's

58 CHICAGO 4 NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY YS,

Exhibit “1” right near the cinder pit where that track is depressed,

that track and the east rail? r

A. There is a foundation.

Q. How much of a dug out is there there?

A. About 24 inches.

Q. Down below the surface of the main track?

A. Yes.

Q. How near does that dug out come to the east rail of

92 the main track, suppose I say the dug out is down here, How

close does this wall of the dug out come to,the main track—

the east rail of it.

A. I should judge about three feet any way.

Q. — you ever measured it?

0.

Q. At most it is not more than three feet?

A. Well, it is close one way or the other.

Q. How far out does that dug out extend from the north side

of the cinder pit? How far north does it go towards the shanty?

A. About six or eight feet.

Q. It projects up towards the shanty six or eight feet?

A. Yes.

Q. And

the blow o

A. Yes.

Q. Who were the men that you saw at work that morning there

throwing water on the cinders on the pit?

A. There was only one man, Tony Kriuscki.

Q What time did you see him throwing water on the cinders?

A. We were taking care of the engine, cleaning the fire and

knocking it out.

Q. That doesn’t tell me what time it was?

A. Between six o’clock and eight o’clock in the morning.

Q. Did he continue from six until eight o’clock?

A. No sir.

Q. Can you fix it any more definitely—whether he would be put-

ting water on five minutes on ten minutes?

A. Five or ten minutes at a time; it all depends on how long it

would take to get the fire out.

Q. You mean to say that between the hours of six to eight, from

time to time you saw this man put water on?

A. Well, we had engines all the time. I didn’t notice it any other

time.

Q. You say you were in the shanty two hours before the accident

happened so you went to the shanty shortly before the eight o'clock?

A. Yes sir. : .

Q. So after that you didn’t see what this man did?

A. No sir.

Q. When you went back to get the water did you help

93 yourself to the water?

A. Yes sir.

Q Did you see this man?

just beyond that is the end of the blow off box, that is,

f box is right north of the dug out?

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 58

A. No sir.

Q And you got the water from this hose that was used to throw

the water on the cinders, did you?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How many engines did you handle on the cinder pit track

that morning before the accident?

A. Four I think is all that I can remember.

Q. That doesn’t include Kane’s engine of course?

A. No sir.

Q. Do you know where these engines came from and who the

crews were?

A. I know where the engines came from; I don’t know the name

of the crew though.

Q. Where did the fourth engine come from?

A. Rhinelander.

What was the number of that engine?

. I don’t remember.

. Where did the third engine come from?

. That was one of the switch engines.

. And the second?

. That was one of the switch engines.

. And the first?

. That was an engine come from Ashland.

. Did you work on those four?

. Yes sir.

And Mr. Gray also on all four?

. Yes sir.

Q. About how long does it take to handle an engine from the

you take it and put it on the cinder pit until you let go of it

with your work completed?

A. ‘Some engines take ten minutes, some 15, 20, 25, all depends

on the fire.

Q. What was that fourth engine’s train number?

. 114.

.Q. Train No. 114 was the Rhinelander train?

. Yes sir.

. Was that a passenger?

. Yes sir.

Q Did you see any railroad men about when you first went down

to the shanty immediately after Gray came in bleeding and hurt,

after you came out of the shanty?

A. ‘After I came out of the shanty? No, I didn’t see any railroad

men then.

Q. You talked with none?

A. No sir.

Q. Where was the foreman of the roundhouse?

A. I suppose he was at the round house soine place.

Q. You didn’t go and notify him of the fact that Gray was

hurt?

94 A. I did not. I didn’t know how bad he was hurt.

Q. The fact is you didn’t talk to any railroad man about

his being hurt?

Ct) CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY YS.

A. No sir.

Q. You didn’t see any railroad man about him at any time while

he was in the shanty after being hurt?

A. No.

Q. Did you see anybody with him after he left the shanty?

A. Yes

: Tony Be anzyk

. Tony Beranzyk.

Is that a pit man?

No fireman.

Where did you see he and Gray —— At what point?

. Just a little ways north of the cinder pit.

. Going with Gray to Gray’s home was he?

They were both standing still when I saw them.

>POrore>

Antuony J. BeranzyKk, called as an adverse witness, being first

duly sworn, testified for and on behalf of the plaintiff, as follows:

Cross-examined by Att’y P. H. Martin:

Q. Where do you live?

A. Antigo.

Q. Were you in the employ of the defendant company on the

19th day of January, 1911, when Mr. Gray was hurt?

A. Yes sir.

Q. In what capacity?

A. Fireman.

Q. Did you see Mr. Gray before he was taken home after being

hurt?

A. I saw him by the coal shed standing there.

Q. Was he hurt at the time you saw him?

A. Yes.

Q. About what time of the day was it?

' A. Along ten o’clock in the morning.

Q. Do you know how long before that he was hurt?

A. No sir.

Q. Did you see this engine 1066 that Mr. Kane was engineer on

that morning? :

A. Seen her standing on the cinder pit.

Q. Was it standing on the cinder pit when you saw Mr. Gray?

A. Yes.

95 Q. Was it being cleaned at that time?

A. I don’t know.

Q. What was Mr. Gray doing when you first saw him?

A. Standing wiping blood off his face.

Q. Did you go up to see how bad he was hurt?

A. He was bad.

Q. Had he been to the shanty after being hurt?

A. I don’t know.

Q. Did you go to him?

A. I walked to him; I was about ten feet; I asked him what was

the matter; he said an engine hit him.

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 61

2 Did you go home with him?

A. No sir, I took him by the arm and I said go to the doctor and °

he said, “No, I want to go home, I want my own doctor.” I said

“Can you make it home yourself?” He said “Yes.” I said “I am

going up and notify the foreman to telephone Dr. Donohue to go

up to your house.”

Q. And you did, did you?

A. Yes.

Q. Where did you come from?

A. From the round house.

. You didn’t see Kane’s engine coming in?

. No sir.

. Didn’t know it was in?

. No sir.

2. Didn’t notice the condition back there of this vapor ant smoke

at the time it came in?

A. No sir.

Q. Did you observe whether or not there was still some vapor and

smoke rising from the cinder pit at the time you saw Mr. Gray?

A. No sir.

Q. Do you know whether there was any?

A. I couldn’t say.

Q. Did you notice the wounds that Mr. Gray had on his head

and face—the injuries?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What did you notice with reference to any injuries he had?

A. Well, he had on the forehead and his face.

Q. How about the wound on his forehead; what did you notice

— reference to that?

. The skin was hanging over on his eyes.

. How large a flap?

. I couldn’t say.

. Did you see him at his house after that?

. About two or three days after.

ry Did you go down the track from the round house on the

lead track—on the out-going track?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You know about men working in there between the

96 cinder pit, on the cinder pit between there and the round

house, do you?

A. No sir, I don’t.

Q. You know Mr. Gray worked there and had a helper a couple

of men—one at least?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You don’t know anything about how this accident happened?

A. No.

62 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

Cuartes Mouze, called as an adverse witness, being first duly

sworn, testified for and on behalf of the plaintiff, as follows:

Examined by Att’y P. H. Martin:

Q. You live at Antigo?

A. Yes sir.

Q. On the 19th of January, 1911, were you in the employ of the

defendant company as foreman of the round house at Antigo?

A. Yes sir.

. Did you see any of this accident to Mr. Gray?

. No sir.

. How long after it happened before you learned of it?

. Why, it must have been 20 or 25 minutes I think.

: a have no personal knowledge of how it happened, then?

. No.

Did you see Kane’s engine come in?

. No sir.

. When did you first know it was in?

A. When I saw the engineer and fireman in the roundhouse

registering.

Q. Your work kept you that morning in the round house?

A. Yes sir.

Q. So you know nothing about the conditions outside so far as

they relate to this accident?

A. No, nothing I am occasionally called out doors at times.

Q. This morning of the accident I mean?

A. No sir.

Q. Do you know anything of this bulletin that has been men-

tioned?

A. No, I can’t recollect it.

Q. Did you have any duty or was it your duty to know what was

contained in that bulletin?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Now, I do not refer to what was written in chalk on the black-

board but what was posted up in pen or pencil.

A. Yes.

Q. The engineer testified to having knowledge of a certain

bulletin that was put up ther ‘hat winter, do you know any-

thing about that?

A. The only recollection I have of the bulletin was a matter of

icing up of the wrecker track switch.

Q. You refer to a bulletin that you saw that meant that?

A. Yes, that was the meaning of it; I can’t remember it exactly.

Q. In that same bulletin did it not say that engines should stop

south of the cinder pit? °

A. I can’t remember.

Q. It might have contained it?

A. It might have, yes. '

Q. Do you know what happened to that bulletin?

A. No, I can’t say.

Q. Don’t you preserve those bulletins?

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 68

A. We do, yes.

Q. What, in the ordinary course of business, would become of that

bulletin?

A.

It would be preserved on file.

. And you are pretty careful to preserve all these?

. Yes, we try to.

. Whose duty is it to put it on file?

. The clerk would file it.

In the usual course of your business would it remain on the

bulletin board a definite length of time?

A. Yes.

Q. Then put it on file? A. Is that the way you do?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Take this particular one: How long would it remain on the

bulletin board before it would be placed on file?

A. Sometimes they remain longer than others. Long enough

for the men to become acquainted with them. .

Q. You would leave it long enough for all the men to have knowl-

edge of its contents?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And when all the men were supposed to know the require-

ments of the bulletin you would take it and file it away?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you know by whom this bulletin was signed?

A. I cannot recollect but I suppose by Mr. Armstrong.

Q. He had authority to issue such a bulletin?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Have you made any examination of the files to ascertain

whether or not this bulletin was among them?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And you didn’t find it?

A. I didn’t.

98 Q. When did you make the first examination for that

urpose?

Looked in the files at the time Mr. Gray was hurt.

At the time?

. Shortly after. —

About how soon?

I can’t remember.

How did you happen to do that?

To see if there was anything specifying that.

What?

. The movements of engines over the cinder pit.

Q. Mr. Smart suggests that you thought he had written in refer-

ence to the examination of the files, and that he did, at that time,

send up for information to draw his answer?

A. We looked then, yes.

Q. But you did look before?

A. Yes, we did look before, that is, I did in the files in the

office.

Q. And the bulletin isn’t to be found?

POPOPOPOD

64 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

A. No sir.

Q. Did you, under the instruction of some one, look for that

bulletin in the first instance?

. No sir.

. Was it at your own volition you made the search?

. Yes, I think it was.

. No one suggested it to you?

. No, I just casually looked it over.

Q. You had something in your mind that it did state something

about where the engines were to stop?

A. That is the only recollection I had.

Q. Wasn’t it your recollection that that bulletin said the engines

should stop south of the cinder pit?

A. No sir.

Q. You cannot deny whether it did or not?

A. I don’t think it did; the only recollection I have I remember

that the matter was brought up about standing on the wrecking

train switch relative to ice at that point. é

Q. The wrecking track switch wasn’t very far north of the cinder

pit was it?

A. Might have been three or four car lengths, probably five.

Q. Comparatively a short distance. About how many feet—100?

A. 100 to 150 feet; I couldn’t say exactly.

Q. Approximately that?

A. Yes sir.

99 WeEpDNEsDAY Mornina.

Wirtuiam H. Gray, being first duly sworn, testified for an- on

behalf of the plaintiff, as follows:

Direct examination of Mr. Gray by Att’y P. H. Martin:

. Mr. Gray you are the plaintiff in this case?

Yes sir.

How old are you?

51 years old.

Where do you live? -

Kaukauna, Wisconsin.

Where did you spend your earlier days?

Manitowoc county.

Where?

Meeme.

On a farm?

Yes sir.

Were you in the employ of the defendant company on the

of January, 1911?

Yes sir.

In what capacity?

Engine dispatcher. Fae :

How long had you been in its employ in any capacity?

. 29 years.

_

POPOPEOPO>OrOrororo

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 65

Q. In what different capacities had you worked for the defendant

company for those 29 years?

A. Dispatching, wiping, firing, running an engine.

Had you been an engineer pulling engines on the road?

Yes sir.

For how many years?

. Between ten and eleven.

How long had you been dispatching.

About 14 or 15 years.

What had been the condition of your health at all times?

Fairly well.

Able to do all kinds of hard work?

Yes sir.

. How long had you stayed on a farm?

Until about 17.

Until you were about 17 years of age?

Yes sir.

Were you able to do different kinds of farm work that a boy of

that age would be?

A. Yes sir.

Q. On the 19th of January, 1911, were you on duty?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What time in the morning did you go to work?

A. Six o’clock.

Q. How many engines did you take care of prior to the time you

met with your accident?

A. I took care of three engines to my knowledge.

100 Q. What did you do with them?

A. Run them on the pit, knocked the fire out, took them

to the coal shed and had coal put on, and to the water tank to get

water and to the wood pile for wood, and from there to the turn

table and to the house.

Q. Did you sand them also?

A. No, sir.

Q: Did you have a helper in doing this work?

A. Yes sir.

OPOPOPOrerororer

Q. Who was it?

A. William Rock.

. How many men worked around the cinder pit and up the

space between the cinder pit and the round house and yard in

the city of Antigo?

A. Two clinker pit men and | think three coal shed men and

myself and helper. ey

Q. Was there a number of men working in the round house

as well?

A. Yes sir.

Q. State how generally the men used the track and premises be-

tween the cinder pit and the round house in passing to and from

their work and in doing their work?

A. Well, myself and helper used that track almost continually

while we were working; the coal shed men could use it walking

5—232

66 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS,

back and forth, they | arte in the coal shed from that side, and the

ee pit men woul it from the pit to the sand house very

often

©F

How about the engineers and fireman in coming in and going

out?

I have seen them walk up and down there.

So it was used daily?

Sometimes it was.

I mean used by yourself, the clinker pit men and the coal

men?

Yes sir.

Are these premises wholly within the city limits of Antigo?

Yes sir.

. About what time of the day did you sustain your injury?

. I should judge it was a little before ten when the engine struck

. Where had you been just before?

. Just before that I had been to the engine house.

Do you mean the round house when you say the engine

house?

A. Yes.

Q. —— was the condition of things at the cinderpit that morn-

ing

101 A. The cinder pit was full of cinders almost; at places it

was filled, at other places a little lower, and so on through

the pit.

Q. What was the condition with reference to whether or not

there were live cinders in it?

A. Yes, there was fire in them.

Q. Go right on and tell the condition of the fire and all about it.

A. It threw up smoke and gas and steam, a certain amount of

steam, made it very disagreeable to work there.

Q. That was true on that morning?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Did you give any directions with reference to quenching the

cinders?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What did you say?

A. Told the cinder pit man to put the hose on there and put the

fire out, that the stringers would get hot and some big engine would

be liable to come along and get into that pit.

Q. Did he do so?

. Yes sir.

. What did you have this hose there for?

. To wet the cinders down.

. Was that a condition that prevailed frequently?

.. Yes sir.

. Live cinders on the pit that you had to wet down?

Yes, that is generally there i is live coals in the engine in the

fire box, and you will get an engine once in a while that the fire will

be practically out in the fire box.

POPOPRO>OP>

B

Opo®

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 67

Q. In other words, whatever fire is in an engine at the end of a’

trip is knocked out on the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. You said you had been at the round house and came down

to this cinder pit. What did you go there for?

A. 1 went to the sand house and I went down to see if those

men were putting the fire out properly.

Q. How did you go down? On what side of the track?

A. I went down what is known as the coming in track to us; I

started to take that track between the rails up to the north end of

the sane house.

Q. What track?

A. The track next to the coal shed.

Q. Is that the track on which the engine came that hit you?

A. Yes.

Q. Go on?

A. And I took between the track and the sandhouse to the shanty

and from the shanty I crossed over from about the blow-out box and

the corner of the shed.

102 Q. That is, you crossed the west side of the track?

A. I crossed to the west side of the track.

Q. How close did you come to the cinder pi-?

A. When I ear over I was probably three or four feet from

the end of the cinder pit; When I was crossing over between the

shed and the cinder pit.

Q. What did you find the condition to be there then?

A. I found the man standing there with his back towards the

shed or a little towards the south with the hose in his hands putting

the fire out. I looked at him for a short while and started back to

the shanty.

Q. As you were going back to the shanty tell us about the volume

of steam and smoke and vapor if there was any rising from the

cinder pit at that time?

A. There was quite a lot.

Q: Give us some better description of the volume. How extensive

was it? How much did it obscure the view, etc.?

A. It obscured the view; the steam was about as high, in my

judgment, as the lower part of the shed; very thick and drifting

north.

Q. What was the occasion for its drifting north?

A. The wind.

Q. Which side of the building was it being carried to? I speak of

the coal shed?

A. It was passing me along the east side of the coal shed.

Q. Before you started back did you see or hear any engine ap-

proaching?

A. No sir.

Q. Did you listen?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Then when you started back what route did you take?

A. I took the route between the coal shed and the west rail.

”

68 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY VS.

Q. Was that the usual way?

A. Yes, I have walked there thousands of times.

Q. As you walked back state whether or not you were enveloped

in this vapor and steam and smoke?

A. I was completely enveloped.

Couldn’t see your way?

No sir. .

Where were you going?

I was going to the shanty.

. What for?

To stay there until there was work for me.

. That would be until an engine came in?

A. Yes sir.

103 Q. How did you guage your way?

A. I gauged my way along the coal shed. Along the

stringers of the coal shed—I guided my way with those.

Q. How did you know where the shanty was?

A. I had to guess at it.

Q. Go on and tell what happened and how it happened and what

ou did.

. A. I got down about, in my judgment, in front of the shanty,

and the steam was so thick that I couldn’t see my hand in front of

me, and I stopped and listened for an engine and I couldn’t hear

any. I could hear a noise that water would make on hot cinders by

pouring water on.

Q. What sort of a noise did it make?

A. My explanation of that would be, I guess everybody most has

done it, it would be similar something to throwing a can of water or

a pail of water on a pile of hot fire. It would make about that noise,

Q. Go ahead and tell us what you did?

A. I listened and couldn’t hear nothing and I made up my mind

that everything was clear and I raised my leg to make a step across

the track and I got hit.

Q. Got hit by what?

A. That engine.

Q. Kane’s engine?

A. Yes sir, well, that is, I didn’t know at the time whose engine

it was or who was running it.

Q. What happened to you?

A. I got hit in the face and I fell against the shed with my shoul-

der and the back of my head and I fell to the ground.

Q. Was it the first stroke of the engine that threw you against the

shed?

A. Yes sir.

Q. And when you fell to the ground what happened?

A. I rolled over this way (indicating how) back towards the shed

to get my legs and arms out of the way of the wheels and something,

I should judge that it was one of the big oil hose of the tank that

caught me in the back about a little above my ribs and about my

hips and it rolled me.

Q. How far?

OPOPope

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 69

A. That I couldn’t tell it was done so quick.

Q. What have you to say about the violence of the blow—the first

blow you got which threw you against the coal house?

A. It was very hard.

104 Q. The coal house seems to be constructed by sheeting and

studding on the inside. What was the object you struck—

was at the edge of one of these studdings or were you thrown towards

them

. I think it was the edge of the studding.

What part of your body was struck?

My head and shoulder.

Did your head also strike the studding?

Yes sir.

What part of your head and shoulder was struck?

The back of my head across the scalp.

There was a scalp wound?

Yes sir.

Which shoulder?

. This one (left).

. Where on the shoulder?

A. The left shoulder was black and blue here just between the

elbow and up to the shoulder to the top of the shoulder also.

Q. Was that bruised?

A. Yes sir.

Q. After the engine passed what did you do?

A. I got up. I lost my hat; I crept around and I happened to

find my hat and I felt my way around through the steam and went

to the shanty.

Q. If you will, at this point, go on and tell us what wounds and

bruises you had on your head and body and where they were. Take

first the head—to what extent was that cut or wounded?

A. My temple was cut here. (You draw your finger on a line di-

rectly over the left eye.)

Q. Is that what you call your forehead?

A. My forehead, yes.

Q. To what ask was that cut?

A. It was cut so this flesh hung down and my skull was exposed.

Q. There is a black mark now leading from your ear down to the

front of the forehead to your right eyebrow. Is that a mark you re-

ceived that time?

A. Yes sir.

Q. There were also other slight marks or injuries that you received

that time?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How much of the skin on the forehead flapped down?

A. It must be over two inches I guess. The marks are there I

LPOPOrOPorer

Q. How wide was the piece?

A. It is probably two inches or more.

105 Q. Just step down into the light so the jurors can see these

marks that are on your forehead and I will describe them so

we can have them in the records,

70 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY Ys,

Q. And the flesh and skin on the forehead between those marks

is the flap that hung down?

Q. On the left cheek leading from the edge of the lip and out

about to the middle of the cheek and under the left cheek bone is a

black and blue mark. State whether or not that was received at that

time.

A. Yes, it was.

Q. Was there any other mark on your face?

A. Yes, under my chin and the top of my nose was split.

Q. How about this black mark on the top of your nose is that

where the spectacles cross?

es sir.

Q. Point out where on the back of your head was ‘this scalp

wound?

A. Just about at the crown.

Q. How far did it extend?

A. Across here,

—. The distance that you draw your finger across the crown of

your head is a distance of about three inches?

A. Something like that.

Q. What bruises were on your body?

A, Well, there was quite a few bruises on my body.

Q. You have already mentioned bruises on your left shoulder and

arm. To what extent were there bruises on the top of the left shoul-

der? .

A. The bone of the shoulder was black and blue.

106 Q. How much of the surface did that cover?

A. Two or three inches. F

Q. Take it up and down from the point of the shoulder towards

the neck, how long that way?

A. About three inches,

Q. How wide was it across? ITow wide across the shoulder and

how far back would it go down the shoulder, if at all?

A. It was probably two inches or two and a half inches wide.

Q. To what extent did that bother you?

A. It was sore,

Q. Was the skin broken?

A. No.

Q. How about your arm?

WILLIAM H. GRAY.

A. The arm was black and blue up near the shoulder joint.

Q. On the outside?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How far down from the shoulder joint was it?

A. It started about an inch from the shoulder joint and went down

about three inches.

Q. How much of the arm did it cover in circumference?

A. May be two inches.

Q. What was the nature of the wound? Was the skin bruised or

broken?

A. No sir, it was black and blue but not broken.

. Where else on your body did you have bruises?

. I had a bruise on my left thigh.

On the inside?

On the outside.

From beginning where? Point out on your thigh.

. Right about here. A. Just below the hip.

And following down to what point?

. A little above the knee.

That would be about how many inches long there?

. About six inches.

How wide was that across?

. It was about three to three and a half inches.

Was the skin broken there?

It was kind of scraped.

That is, rough?

. Yes sir.

Was it so rough as to bring the blood to the surface?

. Yes, slightly.

Where else did you have bruises?

. I had bruises on my back.

. Did you see those?

. No sir.

Learned that from the doctor?

A. Yes, and my wife.

107 Q. Any place else?

A. There were slight bruises on my body that I couldn’t

describe just where they were.

Q. There were quite a few bruises which you sustained in this

injury when you got hurt?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How soon did you go home? ;

A. I went to the shanty and tried to wash my face. I didn’t

realize at the time that I was injured that I was so bad. I asked Mr.

Rock to get me a pail of water and I started to wash and in washing

I felt this flap hanging down here.

Q. Felt like a veil hanging over your eyes?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Go on.

A. I went to the glass and I looked in the glass and I could see

the skull so that scared me and I started for home.

Q.

A.

Q.

A

Q.

A

Q.

A

Q.

A

Q.

A.

Q.

A

Q.

A

Q.

A

Q

A

Q.

72 CHICAGO & NORTILWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

Q. What happened when you got home?

A. I lay down on the lounge.

Q. Did you faint?

A. I think I got weak; I think there was for a little while I was

pretty faint.

Q. How soon did the doctor come?

A. Just a short while after I got on the lounge.

Q. Who came?

A. Dr. E. J. Donohue.

Q. Who treated you during your illness?

A. Doctors E. J. and M. J. Donohue.

Q. Before. you go into the question of your doctoring and how

long, I wll ask you about this so-called bulletin that has been re-

ferred to, what do you know about that?

A. I know it was in existence.

Q. Did you read it?

A. Yes sir. '

Q. What did it provide for in reference to engines stopping and

where they were to stop?

A. It provided for stopping south of the pit.

Q. Of the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What was the fact as to whether or not, after this bulletin was

put up engines did stop south of the cinder pit?

A. Yes, they did.

Q. Did all of them stop south of the pit?

A. No.

Q. Can you give us the bulletin wording of it. Are you able to

give us in substance the way that bulletin read?

A. It read to my knowledge for engineers to stop south of

108 the cinder pit.

Q. Did you see anything else? Did it have any reference

to ice on the switch connecting this wrecking track with the track

that the engines were moved on to the round house?

A. Not to my knowledge.

Q. Who signed that bulletin?

A. Mr. Armstrong, if I remember right.

Q. He is the division superintendent or assistant superintendent?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Was there any occasion whatsoever for running engines north

of the cinder pit?

A. Not to my knowledge.

Q. In caring for this engine state whether or not you would have

to back it up on to the cinder pit?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Was that bulletin which you speak of put on the regular bul-

letin board for the purpose of inspection by the employees?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you know how Jong it remained there?

A, No, sir, I don’t,

WILLIAM H. GRAY. 72

Q. Was it part of your duty to inspect that bulletin and know

what the bulletins contained?

A. It was for my own benefit; that was my practice; I was in rail-

road service; of course the road men are supposed to—everybody is

supposed to look at the bulletins.

Q. a are supposed to know what is on that bulletin board?

A. Yes.

» - you have any ribs broken at the time you were struck?

. Yes.

Q. What ribs did you have broken—on which side?

A. I don’t know.

Q. Did you have ribs broken on both sides?

A. I don’t know as to that.

Q. Why don’t you know?

A. I had two broken in the back and I think I had one broken in

front.

Q. Your doctor will know about that I suppose?

A. Yes, I suppose.

Q. As that engine which struck you approached over the cinder

pit and beyond to the point where it struck you, state whether or not

any bell was ringing on the engine?

A. No sir.

Q. Would it be possible for a bell to be ringing and you not

hear it?

A. No sir, not under those circumstances.

Q. Did you look and listen for a warning before crossing

109 sor attempting to cross?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How is your hearing?

A. All right.

Q. Were you able to form, or did you form an opinion or judg-

ment as to the rate of speed that engine was going when it struck

you?

A. Yes,

Q. What, in your judgment was the rate of speed of that engine

at the time it struck you?

Objected to as incompetent as it was impossible for the witness

to tell.

Objection overruled. Exception.

A. Between 10 and 12 miles an hour I should judge.

Q. What did you judge that from?

A. At the rate it struck me.

Q. You mean the violence of the blow?

A. Yes sir, and the time it took to go by me.

Q. You were quite familiar with the length of an engine of that

kind and the tender, I suppose?

A. Yes sir.

. Q. How long were you confined to the house with these injuries

after the accident?

A. I think about two weeks.

74 CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY V8,

Q. Did you have or suffer any pain?

A. Yes sir.

Q. How long, if at all, did Pay continue to be disabled from the

performance o manual labor?

A. Ever since I got hurt.

Q. You may state whether or not you continue to suffer from in-

juries at the present time?

A. I do and my shoulder aches continually.

Q. You mean your left shoulder?

A. Yes sir, I cannot lie on it in bed. If I happen to roll on it

when I am asleep in a short while it will wake me up with pain.

It pains if I lie on it any length of time.

Q. Where is the pain?

A. From the bone of my shoulder down about four or five inches

towards my elbow.

Q. Go ahead and tell us what further ills you suffer?

A. These muscles here pain me.

Q. The muscles just in front on the extension of the arm—the left

arm?

A. Yes sir.

Q. What else?

A. And my fingers on the left hand at times get numb,

110 especially if 1 get a little bit cold.

Q. How about the movement of the left arm?

A. I can’t move it certain ways.

Q. Can you throw up your left arm at right angles with your

body this way (indicating) ?

A. No sir.

Q. Move your arm in that motion as high as you can out directly

and up.

(Witness moves arm as directed. )

Q. Can you lift it any higher than that?

A. No sir.

Q. You practically can do nothing more than lift it about five

inches up from your side?

A. No sir.

Q. Can you swing it out—ewing the whole arm around?

A. No sir.

Q. How about this rotary motion. Can you turn it so the palm

of your hand will turn clear out?

A. No sir.

Q. Is that all the motion you’ve got in your left arm?

A. No sir.

Q. Was that the fact with reference to its condition before the

accident?

A. No sir.

Q. Was'‘the rotary motion of the arm limited in any way before

the accident?

A. No sir.

Q. Has it been restricted or limited in motion ever since the in-

jury?

WILLIAM H, GRAY.

A. Yes sir.

Q. It has been no better at any time since the injury?

A. No sir.

Q. Your left arm and hand?

A. Yes sir.

Q. Do you feel that you have strength so you are able to lift and

handle it as formerly?

A. No sir.

Q. I mean even with the limitation it has now?

A. No sir.

Q. What weight can you carry with your left arm as compared

with what you might carry or lift before you were hurt?

A. I cannot carry only very little weight with it; can’t carry a

light satchel for any length of time.

Q. Suppose you had a weight as heavy as a Revised Statute like

this how long could you hold that and carry it?

A. J couldn’t carry that long.

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — Chicago & Northwestern R. Co. v. Gray · 237 U.S. 399 | Frix