Transcript of Record — Rail Coal Co. v. Ohio Industrial Comm.

Supreme Court brief1915

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

(24,255)

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

OCTOBER TERM, 1913.

No. 1104.

RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY, APPELLANT,

ve.

VALLACE D. YAPLE, MATHEW B. HAMMOND, AND

THOMAS J. DUFFY, AS MEMBERS OF AND CONSTITUT-

ING THE INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION OF OHIO.

PPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR

THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO.

INDEX.

Original. Print

Se TENE eR LEE TET COLETTE TCT eCLT TTT eee TT eS 1 1

ee SPO Eee EPC TET ERT TOPCO TE TTC ore her Teen 2 l

ubpeena in equity, with acceptance of service................ 19 13

i MTs Sioa vss ke new ead eae eae es eee Luawe nabs 35 21 15

rder overruling plaintiff's application for interlocutory injune-

Ditka ses Fess vRTae Ee OK DEED FRCS ST ETN d se ERROK CER ewEedeve 32 22

eee SOUUNINE COOUNED Ss 555 6cs vcs knda ke was cd0 Roe k dee oo 33 23

etition for appeal and waiver of issuance and service of

PR 055 bb ib woee dds baacey ORO OURS EASING Reb Ghedbe Ses ete 34 24

On MONE s oon cence hedth oskn bo deb bbbabeeed ee ras ees 35 25

CE MOE ceckpieosserssprersedesesnetetbevwenoesevess 38 27

SOWIE GOON cs ccncoscocacrasendersesnaedpeneesedse 40a 23

SO TOG TFBNSETIOE. 2c cvccvcccvcscvecaces evetheeawkgeres a 40 28

PE OPO cere sce de eek e dre rEDEH s pswsnedsn coer vee 41 29

Jupp & Detweiter (1Nc.), Printers, WasuiNcToN, D. C., June 11, 1914.

, sae .

DEES ETOP POLES

———

RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS. WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL.

; UNITED States OF AMERICA,

Northern District of Ohio,

Eastern Division, 8s:

Record of the proceedings of the District Court of the United

states within and for the Eastern Division of the Northern District

f Ohio, in the cause and matter hereinafter stated, the same being

inally disposed of at a regular term of said court begun and held

it the City of Cleveland, in said District, on the First Tuesday in

\pril, being the 7th day of said Month in the year of our Lord one

housand nine hundred and Fourteen, and of the Independence of

he United States of America, the one hundred and thirty-eighth,

o-wit: on Saturday, the 23rd day of May, A. D. 1914.

Present:

Hon. John W. Warrington, United States Circuit Judge.

Hon. John E. Sater, United States District Judge.

Hon. John M. Killits, United States District Judge.

In Equity. No. 233.

Ratt anp River Coat Company

vs.

VaLLAcE D. YarLe, MarHew B. HamMonp, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Constituting tie Industrial Commission

of Ohio.

Said action was commenced on 16th day of April, A. D. 1914,

nd proceeded to disposition at the term and day above written,

nd during the progress thereof, pleadings and papers were filed,

rocess was issued and returned and orders of the court were made

nd entered in the order and on the dates hereinafter stated, to-wit:

(Bill of Complaint. Filed April 16, 1914.)

n the United States District Court for the Northern District of

Ohio, Eastern Division.

No. 233. Equity.

Rai anv River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

VaLLAcCE D. YAPLE, ticumer HAMMOND, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial Commission

of Ohio, Defendants.

Bill of Complaint.

‘o the Honorable the District Judges of the Northern District of

Ohio, Eastern Division:

Rail and River Coal Company, a corporation, brings this, its bill

f complaint, against Wall-ce D. Yaple, Mathew B. Hammond and

1—1104

, —— Lepr DIET U4 PL

Byes oe. ¥ - - $

er.

2 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY V8. |

Thomas J. Duffy at East Liverpool, Ohio, in the Eastern Division

Commission of Ohio, and thereupon said plaintiff complains and

alleges:

I.

Said plaintiff is and has been for a long time past a corporation

organized and existing under the laws of the State of West Virginia,

and is a citizen of said State of West Virginia, and a resident thereof.

IL

That the said defendants, Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew B. Ham-

mond and Thomas J. Duffy are citizens and residents of the State

of Ohio, defendant Wallace D. Yaple, residing at Chillicothe, Ohio,

defendant Mathew B. Hammond at Columbus, Ohio, and defendant

Thomas J. Duffy at East Liverpool, Ohio. in the Eastern Division

of the Northern District of Ohio, and within the jurisdiction of this

court.

Said defendants are the duly appointed, qualified and act-

3 ing members of The Industrial Commission of Ohio, having

been appointed as such members under and pursuant to an

Act of the Legislature of the State of Ohio entitled “An Act Creat-

ing The Industrial Commission of Ohio,” passed March 12, 1913,

approved by the Governor of said State March 18, 1913, and duly

filed in the office of the Secretary of State on March 20, 1913. Said

defendant Wallace D. Yaple is Chairman and said Mathew B. Ham-

mond is Vice-Chairman of said Commission. Said Act is set forth

at length in the Session Laws of the State of Ohio for the year 1913,

Volume 103, pages 95 to 110, both inclusive, to which Act, for the

full text thereof, complainant begs leave to refer, as fully as though

the same were at length incorporated herein.

That under and by the terms of Section 22 of said Act it is made

the duty of said Industrial Commis-ion, and it is given the power,

jurisdiction and authority on and after the first day of September,

1913, to administer and enforce the general laws of, the State of

Ohio relating to mines, manufacturing and other establishments.

Under the provisions of Sections 18, 19, 20, 21, 22 and 35 of said

Act, said Commission is given extensive inquisitorial powers, and

it is made the duty of all employers to furnish to said Commission

information pertaining to their private business affairs, to enable

it to carry into effect the provisions of said Act and the orders of

said Commission made thereunder, and said employers are required

to make specific answers under oath to all questions submitted to

them by said Commission, and to give said Commission access tu

their establishments and places of business. Under the provisions

of Section 36 of said Act said Commission is given authority to direet

the prosecution of any action, proceeding, investigation, hearing or J

trial relating to matters within its jurisdiction, and upon the request

of said Commission it is made the duty of the attorney gen-

4 eral of Ohio or the prosecuting attorneys of the various

counties in said State to aid sail Commission and prosecute

under the supervision of said Commission all necessary actions or

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL. 3

proceedings for the enforcement of said Act, and for the punish-

ment of all violations thereof.

IIL.

Said plaintiff is now and for many years last past has been

actively engaged in the State of Ohio in the business of mining and

selling coal, and now owns and for a !ong time past has owned in

said State a large acreage of coal lands, consisting approximately of

32,000 acres, of the value of more than $1,000,000.00, upon which

said lands said plaintiff has four coal mines properly developed,

in which it employes upward of 2,000 persons, and from which

said mines said plaintiff's average daily production is about 2,800

mine cars of two tons each of coal; that among said employés of

plaintiff are about 1,700 persons who are paid on the basis of the

ton for mining or loading coal.

IV.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that the business of coal min-

ing in the State of Ohio ix very lo~ze; that there are about six hun-

dred (600) coal mines in said State, in which there are employed

upwards of 45,000 persons; that upwards of 36,000 tons of coal were

produced in the year 1913, and there was expended in wages to said

employés in said year upwards of $26,000,000,00,

V.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that Western Pennsylvania,

the States of Illinois and Indiana are likewise large producers of

coal; that the mines located in these States are in close competition

with each other and with the mines in the State of Ohio in the

sale of the coal produced by their respective properties; that a great

majority of the operatives engaged in the coal mining business

in said States are members of an organization known as The

5 United Mine Workers of America. That for many years last

past it has been the custom for said mine operatives, through

their representatives in said organization, under arrangements made

with the various coal operators in the said States, to enter into con-

tracts with said operators for the period of two years, whereby the

interests of said operatives and their employers have been subserved

by securing reasonably uniform wages for the different kinds of

labor performed in said mines; that the last agreement entered into

was for the period of two years, expiring on April 1, 1914.

That it has been for many years last past the custom and practice

of large users of coal, such as railroads and large manufacturing

concerns, to make contracts for their fuel requirements by the year,

and that many of said contracts expired about April 1, 1914, or will

expire in the immediate future, and practically all of them prior

to May 20, 1914.

Witc., eet “ ata iade : . : . aye - ’ I OF LOEB

a

4 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

VI.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that the wage agreement re-

ferred to, which expired April 1, 1914, as well as several of said

agreements theretofere made, covering the wages of such mine

operatives as are paid by the ton in the said States of Pennsylvania,

Ohio and Indiana, provided for the screening of coal and for pay-

ment of wages at a certain price per ton for lump coal, to-wit: such

coal as would pass over a bar screen of certain dimensions, wherein

the bars were 114 inches apart; of said four States, the mines in

said State of Illinois, alone, operating upon any other basis, except

that in the State of Indiana the operators, at their option, paid on a

mine run basis also, and plaintiff states (o the court that said method

of screening coal and paying the miners and loaders thereof,

upon the basis of such coal as will pass over said screen,

6 is designed and well calculated to induce carefulness in min-

ing, in that said loaders and miners exercise greater care in

the manner in which charges of powder are placed to break down

said coal, and in the manner in which said coal is loaded after the

same is broken down, and the safety of the operatives is much

enhanced because of the better condition of the roof of the mines,

growing out of the smaller charges of powder used therein.

That for the reasons aforesaid, those engaged in the mining busi-

ness operate their mines more economically and in a safer manner,

and coal of a better grade is produced when the mines and loaders

are paid upon the lump coal basis.

VII.

Plaintiff further says that by Section 970 of the General Code

of Ohio, the owners and operators of coal mined in said State are

uired to permit their mine operatives to employ, and it is the

universal custom in said State for such operatives to employ, a

representative known as check weighman, whose duty and right it

is to examine the scales and screening apparatus and machinery at

the mine, and see the coal weighed and check such weights, and

make a correct record thereof. By this law the operatives are pro-

tected and secured against any false weight or improper screening

of their coal, and from any improper deductions from the coal

mined or loaded by them.

VITl.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that on the 20th day of May,

A. D. 1914, there will become effective a certain Act of the General

Assembly of Ohio, known as Senate Bill No. 3, entitled “An Act to

Regulate the Weighing of Coal at the Mines,” which was duly

by the General Assembly of Ohio on or about February 5,

1914, approved by the Governor of the State of Ohio on

7 February 17, 1914, and filed in the office of the Secretary

of Siate on February 20, 1914, a true copy of which is hereto

attached, marked “Exhibit A” and made a part hereof.

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL.

IX.

That in and by the terms of said Act it is provided that every

miner and every loader of coal in any mine in this State, who, under

the terms of his employment, is to be paid for mining or loading

such coal on the basis of the ton, or other weight, shall be paid for

such mining or loading according to the total weight of all coal

contained within his car in which the same shall be removed from

out of the mine, unless the contents of such car when so removed

shall contain a greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or

other impurities than that ascertained and determined by the said

The Industrial Commission of Ohio.

xX.

It is further provided in said Act that said Industrial Commission

shall ascertain and determine the percentage of slate, sulphur, rock,

dirt or other impurities unavoidable in the proper mining or load-

ing of the contents of the several cars of coal in the several operating

mines in said State of Ohio, and said Commission is given power

to change, after investigation, any percentage ascertained or deter-

mined by it from time to time as it shall deem necessary.

XL

It is further provided in said Act that it shall be the duty of the

miner or loader of coal, and his employer, to agree upon and fix

for stipulated periods of time the percentage of fine coal allowable

in the output of the mine wherein such miner or loader is employed,

and if such agreement is not made, the said Industrial Gom-

8 mission is authorized to fix and determine the same. Said

Commission is also empowered to change from time to time

the percentage of fine coal which may be so lawfully loaded. Said

Industrial Commission, if it finds that for a period of one month

there shall be produced a greater percentage of fine coal than that

fixed and determined by it, is authorized to make and enforce such

orders relative thereto as will result in reducing the percentage of

such fine coal to that fixed by said Commission.

XII.

It is further provided in said Act that it shall be unlawful for the

employer of a miner or loader of the contents of any car of coal to

pass any part of the contents thereof over a screen or other device,

for the purpose of ascertaining or calculating the amount to be paid

to such miner or loader for mining or loading such contents, whereby

the total weight of such contents shall be reduced or diminished,

and it is provided that any person, firm or corporation who shall vio-

late such provision in respect thereto shall be deerned guilty of a mis-

demeanor, and upon conviction, shall be fined for each separate

offense not less than $300.00, nor more than $600.00. *" bn)

—_— ers s — . — — ee eed Be |

6 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY V8.

xu

It is further provided in said Act that any miner or loader of the

contents of the mine car who loads a greater percentage of slate,

sulphur, rock, dirt or other impurities than that ascertained and

determined by said Industrial Commission shall be guilty of a ‘mis-

demeanor, and upon conviction shall be punished for the first offense

within a period of three days by a fine of fifty cents; for a second of-

fense within such period by a fine of One Dollar; and for a third

offense with- such period by a fine of not less than Two Dollars, nor

more than Four Dollars.

9 XIV.

Plaintiff further shows to the court on information and belief

that on or about the — day of February, 1914, and pursuant to said

custom of entering into said biannual contracts, the various operators

engaged in the mining of coal in the said States of Ohio, Pennsyl-

vania, Indiana and Illinois, by their representatives, met and con-

ferred with the duly authorized representatives of their employés in

the City of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, with the view to making a

wage agreement covering the employment of said operatives in all

said four States for the period of two years, beginning with April 1,

1914; that at said meeting said operatives demanded that in the

State of Ohio, coal should be mined and produced, and the wages

of miners and loaders be determined, in all respects in conformity

with said Act of the General Assembly, and in no other manner,

that said meeting was adjourned without agreement; that later, on

or about the — day of March, 1914, a further meeting was convened

in the City of Chicago, Illinois, at which the operatives repeated the

same demand with respect to the methods of mining and paying for

the coal mined in the State of Ohio, but offered to renew, unmodified

so far as weighing and screening of coal was concerned, the contracts

expiring on April 1, 1914, in — to the business of coal mining

in the States of Pennsylvania, Illinois and Indians, but no offer or

proposition was made to make any contract with respect to the min-

ing of coal in Ohio, except upon the basis of the said Act of the Ohio

Legislature aforesaid.

XV.

Plaintiff further shows to the Court on information and belief

that the operators of coal mines in the State of Ohio (among which

is the plaintiff herein), were ready and willing to renew, to take

effect on April 1, 1914 for the period of two years, the contract

10 ~~ which expired on said date, and that the inability to reach

such an agreement with their operatives was largely, if not

wholly due to the existence of said Act aforesaid prescribing the

methods of mining and determining the basis of wages of said miners

and employés, and delegating to the said Industrial Commission the

powers therein prescribed, and fixing and prescribing the penalties

that would be incurred by said operators and said employés for any

violations thereof.

PII ATE I “= , —_ _

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL.

XVI.

Plaintiff further shows to the court on information and belief that

on April 1, 1914, the owners and operators of mines in the State of

Ohio, being unable to secure men to operate their said mines upon

the basis and terms upon which said mines had been operating for

two years theretofore, were compelled to close down said mines, to

their great detriment and damage, and that plaintiff was required

for said reasons to close down its mines, to its great loss and damage.

XVII.

Plaintiff further charges that said Act, to-wit: said Senate Bill

No, 3, is unconstitutional and void, and of no effect whatsoever, for,

among other reasons, the following, to-wit:

(1) It violates the fourteenth amendment to the Federal Consti-

tution, in that it abridges the privileges and immunities of the plain-

tiff, and deprives it and oter persons similarly situated of the lib-

erty of contract, and constitutes an unwarranted and arbitrary inter-

ference with plaintiff's right to manage its business of mining, pro-

ducing and selling coal according to its own judgment, and takes

the property of the plaintiff and others similarly situated without

due process of law.

(2) Said Act confers authority and power on said Commission

and requires it to determine for each operator and each miner and

loader in the State, who is paid by the weight, the percentage of im-

purities unavoidable in proper mining or loading of coal in cars and

the allowable percentage of slack or fine coal, thus depriving the

said operator and his employés of the right to determine, bargain

and contract for the quality of coal to be produced from said mine,

all in violation of said Fourteenth Amendment.

1] (3) In conferring power on said Industrial Commission

to prescribe the percentage of fine coal that may be loaded

and the percentage of slate, sulphur and other impurities that may

be loaded with the coal, and prescribing penalties for violations

thereof by the miner or loader, said Act constitutes an unwarranted

interference with the rights and liberties of said miner and loader,

and with his freedom of contract with his employer; and likewise

in requiring the operator to accept and pay for coal of a quality fixed

by said Commission, said Act interferes with the freedom of the em-

ployer to fix and determine the uality of the product of his mine

and interferes with the freedom of the employer and the employé to

contract with each other,—all in violation of said Fourteenth

Amendment.

(4) The duties devolving on said Commission under said Act, if

exercised pursuant to the powers conferred on said Commission b

the Act creating said Commission, and especially by Sections 18, 19,

20 21 and 22 thereof, authorize and require said , eerer me to in-

vestigate and inquire into the private business affairs of the operator,

all in violation of the rights secured to said operator by the Consti-

tution of the United States, and especially the Fourteenth Amend-

ment thereof.

- RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

Sk a i ah

(5) The plan provided by said Act of fixing the quality of said

coal by said Commission, that may be lawfully mined and neded. is

wholly impracticable in the daily business operations of a mine and

would result in material and arbitrary interference with the oper-

ations of the mine, in violation of said Fourteenth Amendment.

(6) Said Act is not within the police power, or any power of the

State of Ohio. It is not designed nor intended to promote nor pro-

tect, nor does it bear any relation to the health, safety nor general

welfare of the public. It is not intended nor designed to prevent

fraud upon the operatives in coal mines. Said operatives by Section

970 of the General Code of Ohio are specially empowered to and in

fact do by universal custom, supervise, check and determine the

weighing and weight of all coal produced.

(7) The penalties and fines prescribed in Section 6 of said Act,

to-wit: Senate Bill No. 3, are so extreme and cumulative as to deter

and prevent any person, firm or corporation described in said Act,

and subject to its provisions, from challenging the validity thereof,

and such persons, firms or corporations are thereby constrained to

submit to the provisions of said Act rather than take the chance of

the penalties imposed. The minimum fines prescribed in said Section

§ of said Act would amount, in plaintiff’s case, to over $800,000.00

per day for each day’s operation of plaintiff’s property.

Said Act, for the reasons herein mentioned, denies to this plaintiff

and to other persons similarly situated, the equal protection of the

law as secured and guaranteed to them by the Fourteenth Amend-

ment of the Constitution of the United States.

XVIII.

Said Act is likewise unconstitutional and void in that it violates

Section 1 of Article 1 of the Constitution of the State of Ohio, in

prohibiting the freedom of contract therein guaranteed and secured.

12 XIX.

Said Act is further in violation of the Constitution of the State

of Ohio in that it delegates legislative authority to said Industrial

Commission, in violation of Section 1 and Section 26 of Article 2 of

said Constitution.

XX.

Said Act is further in violation of Section 16, Article 2, of the

Constitution of Ohio, which provides that no law shall embrace more

than one subject, which shall be clearly expressed in its title, in that

the title to said Act relates exclusively to the weighing of coal at

the mine, while said Act purports, in the body thereof, to confer

upon said Industrial Commission wide powers of inspection and

supervision of the manner and methods of mining coal, and em-

powers said Commission to determine the quality of coal, which shall

be paid for as such, and the contents of mine cars, which shall be

binding upon employés and employers, regardless of their contracts

in reference thereto.

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL. 9

XXII.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that because of said Act, said

Senate Bill No. 3, and the uncertainty in respect to the constitution-

ality thereof, plaintiff's mines are closed down as aforesaid, and plain-

tiff is unable to make or accept contracts which are now being

offered, and particularly contracts for periods of one year or more,

which contracts are now being taken, as plaintiff is advised

and believes, by the coal operators in said States of Pennsylvania

and Indiana, competitors of the plaintiff, and plaintiff is now, and

before the effective date of said Act, suffering great immediate and

irreparable injury by reason thereof.

XXII.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that said defendants

13 acting as said Industrial Commission, as plaintiff is informed

and believes, has taken steps and measures, or is about to take

steps and measures, to put said Act in full force and effect, and to

that end has employed its agents and a special representative, whose

duties are to assist said Commission under said Act, and to make the

investigations in respect to the matters and things provided for

therein, and plaintiff is advised and believes that said Industrial Com-

mission, through said representative or deputy, and its employés

and other agents, is about to demand access to the mines and prop-

erty of plaintiff, with a view of determining and investigating, and

examining into the business of mining as heretofore conducted and

carried on by said plaintiff, and plaintiff is advised that said Indus-

trial Commission threatens to and will promptly on May 20, 1914,

put into full effect all the provisions of said Act, in the meantime

trespassing upon plaintiff’s property and and the property of other

operators of coal mines in Ohio, in the making of said preliminary

investigations, as hereinbefore outlined; that said proposed investi-

gations are for the purpose provided in’ said Act, and constitute an

unwarranted and illegal inquiry into the private business affairs of

plaintiff.

XXIII.

That to prevent the immediate and irreparable injury and the

continuing wrong which will necessarily arise by the enforcement of

said Act, and from the requirements by said defendants acting as

said Industrial Commission in the enforcement thereof, and to pre-

vent a multiplicity of suits against the plaintiff, and to prevent prose-

cutions under said Act and the imposition of the heavy penalties de-

scribed therein, and to prevent immediate and irreparable injury

which will be caused to plaintiff by reason of the fact that it

14 is prevented from operating its mines and from accepting

contracts for the sale of its coal, a writ of in juncttion is nec-

essary to restrain said defendants from interfering with plaintiff

and other persons similarly situated.

2—1104

e

ae

10 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

XXIV.

That the amount in controversy herein and the value of the mat-

ters disputed herein, and the loss which the plaintiff is sustaining

by the threatened enforcement of said Act, and the damages to plain-

tiff, as hereinbefore set forth, will greatly exceed the sum of Three

Thousand Dollars ($2,000.00), exclusive of interest and costs.

XXV.

Inasmuch, therefore, as plaintiff has no remedy in the premises,

save in a court of equity, plaintiff prays the aid of the court.

1. To the end that the said Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew B. Ham-

mond and Thomas J. Duffy, defendants herein, as members of and

constituting The Industrial Commission of Ohio, may, without oath

(answer on oath being expressly waived), full, true, direct and per-

fect answer make to all and singular the matters and things herein-

before stated and charged;

2. To the end that said Act, Senate Bill No. 3, may be decreed to

be unconstitutional and void, and of no effect whatsoever;

3. To the end that plaintiff may be decreed to have the right to

operate its mines and property, and to mine and sell its coal, without

compliance in any way with the restrictions in said Act set forth, and

si the regulations and orders of said Industrial Commission there-

under ;

4. To the end that plaintiff, its agents and employees may be se-

cured against unlawful and illegal trespassing and arrests,

15 ree and penalties, by reason of any alleged violation of said

ct;

That the said Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew B. Hammond

and Thomas J. Duffy, as members of and constituting The Indus-

trial Commission of Ohio, their agents, deputies, representatives at-

torneys and employees of every kind whatsoever, may be perpetually

— forever restrained by the order and injunction of this court

rom,

(a) Enforcing and attempting to enforce any of the provisions

of said Act, said Senate Bill No. 3;

(6) From entering upon plaintiff’s premises for the purpose of

making, with respect to said Senate Bill No. 3, any investigation pre-

tended to be authorized by said Act of the Legislature of Ohio

creating said Industrial Commission ;

(c) Making or establishing any rules or regulations in respect

to the amount of fine coal or the amount of impurities to be loaded

into cars at plaintiff’s mines, or to be taken as a basis for, or con-

sidered in connection with, the wages to be paid to and received

by said miners and loaders of coal ;

(d) Beginning any action of any nature whatsoever against plain-

tiff, its agents or employees, on account of any violation of said

Senate Bill No. 3;

(e) Arresting or causing the arrest of any agent or employee

of plaintiff.

é

Bi)

Be

lake: YR 5 ras i

—

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL. 11

And that said defendants, each and all of them, may be in the

meantime so restrained during the pendency of this suit, and plain-

tiff prays for such other relief as it may in equity be entitled to.

XXVI.

May it please your Honors to grant unto the plaintiff not only

a writ of injunction conformable to the prayer of this bill to

16 be issued to the above named defendants, but also writ of

subpeena to be issued out of and under the seal of this Honor-

able Court, to be directed to said defendants, Wallace D. Yaple,

Mathew B. Hammond and Thomas J. Duffy, as members of and

constituting The Industrial Commission of Ohio, commanding them,

at a certain time and under a certain penalty to be therein specified,

to be and appear before this Honorable Court, then and there to

answer the premises, but not under oath (answer under oath being

expressly waived), and to abide by the order and decree of the

court therein, and that said defendants may appear herein according

to law.

RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY,

Plaintiff,

By A. C. DUSTIN, Its Solicitor.

HOYT, DUSTIN, KELLEY, MCKEEHAN

& ANDREWS, Att’ ys.

A. C. DUSTIN,

Of Counsel,

Unitep States or AMERICA,

Northern District of Ohio,

Eastern Division, Cuyahoga County, ss:

W. R. Woodford, being first duly sworn, upon his oath deposes

and says that he is the President of Rail & River Coal Company,

plaintiff in the foregoing action, and duly authorized in the prem-

ises; that he has read pS statements and allegations contained in

said bill and knows the contents thereof and that the same are

true to his own knowledge, except as to the matters therein stated

to be alleged upon information and belief, and as to those matters,

he believes them to be true.

W. R. WOODFORD.

Sworn to by the said W. R. Woodford, and subscribed by him in

my presence this 16th day of April, 1914.

[SEAL. ] ADRIAN WYCHGEL,

Notary Public.

1z RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

17 Exuisit “A.”

(Senate Bill No. 3.)

An Act to Regulate the Weighing of Coal at the Mines.

Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Ohio:

Section 1. Every miner and every loader of coal in any mine in

this State who under the terms of his employment is to be paid for

mining or loading such coal on the basis of the ton or other weight

shall be paid for such mining or loading according to the total

weight of all such coal contained within the car (hereinafter referred

to as mine car) in which the same shall have been removed out of the

mine; provided, the contents of such car when so removed shall con-

tain no greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or other im-

purity than that ascertained and determined by the industrial com-

mission of Ohio as hereinafter enacted.

Section 2. Said industrial commission shall ascertain and deter-

mine the percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt. or other impurity

unavoidable in the proper mining or loading of the contents of mine

cars of coal in the several operating mines within this state.

Section 3. It shall be the duty of such miner or loader of coal

and his emplover to agree upon and fix, for stipulated periods, the

percentage of fine coal commonly known as nut, pea, dust and slack

allowable in the output of the mine wherein such miner or loader is

employed. At any time when there shall not be in effect such agreed

and fixed percentage of fine coal allowable in the output of any mine

said industrial commission shall forthwith upon request of such

miner or loader or his employer, fix such allowable percentage of

fine coal, which percentage so fixed by said industrial commission

shall continue in force until otherwise agreed and fixed by such

miner or loader and his employer. Whenever said industrial com-

mission shall find that the total output of such fine coal at any mine

for a neriod of one month during which such mine shall have been

operating while the percentage of fine coal so fixed by said industrial

commission has been in force, exceeds the percentage so fixed bury it,

said industrial commission shall at once make, enter and cause to be

enforced such order or orders relative to the production of coal at

such mine, as will result in reducing the percentage of such fine

coal, to the amount so fixed by said industrial commission.

Section 4. Said industrial Commission shall, as to all coal mines

in this state, which have not been in oneration heretofore, perform

the duties imposed upon it by the provisions hereof.

Section 5. Said industrial commission shal] have full power from

time to time, to change, upon investigation, any percentage by its

ascertained and determined, or fixed, as provided in the preceding

sections hereof.

Section 6. It shall be unlawful for the employer of a miner or

loader of the contents of any car of coal to pass any part of

18 such contents over a screen or other device, for the purpose

of ascertaining or calculating the amount to be paid such

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL. 13

miner or loader for mining or loading such contents, whereby the

total weight of such contents shall be reduced or diminished. Anv

person, firm or corporation violating the provisions of this section

shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and unon conviction. shall

be fined for each separate offense not less than three hundred dollars

nor more than six hundred dollars.

Section 7. A miner or loader of the contents of a mine car, con-

taining a greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or other

impurity, than that ascertained and determined bv said industrial

commission, as hereinabove provided, shall be guilty of a misde-

meanor and upon conviction shall be punished as follows: for the

first offense within a period of three days he shall be fined fifty

cents; for a second offense within such period of three days he shall

be fined one dollar; and for the third offense within such period

of three days he shall be fined not less than two dollars nor more

than four dollars. Provided, that nothing contained in this sec-

tion shall affect the right of a miner or loader and his employer to

agree upon deductions by the system known as docking, on account

of such slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or other impurity.

C. L. SWAIN,

Speaker of the House of Renresentatives.

W. A. GREENLUND,

President of the Senate.

Concurred February 5, 1914.

Approved February 17, 1914.

JAMES M. COX, Governor.

I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true copy of the engrossed

bill.

———

Secretary of State.

Filed in the office of the Secretary of State February 20, 1914.

19 (Subpena in Equity, Issued April 16, 1914.)

Tue UnitTep STATES OF AMERICA,

Northern District of Ohio, ss:

The President of the United States of America to the Marshal of

the Northern District of Ohio, Greeting:

You are hereby commanded to summon Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew

B. Hammond and Thomas J. Duffy, as members of and consti-

tuting The Industrial Commission of Ohio, citizens of and resident

in the State of Ohio, if they be found in your District, to be and

appear in the District Court of the United States for the Northern

District of Ohio, aforesaid, at Cleveland, on or before the twentieth

day after service, excluding the day thereof, to answer a certain

Bill in Equity, filed and exhibited in said Court, against them, by

Nan Ad acs =e

14 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

Rail and River Coal Company, citizen of and resident in the Stat

of West Virginia.

Hereof they are not to fail under the penalty of the law thenc

ensuing. And have you then and there this writ.

Witness the Honorable John M. Killits, and the Honorab

William L. Day, District Judges of the United States, this 16t

day of April, A. D. 1914, and in the 138th year of the independenc

of the United States of America.

[SEAL. } B. C. MILLER, Clerk,

By R. C. DEAN, Deputy Clerk.

Memorandum.

The said defendants are required to file their answer or othe

defense in the Clerk’s Office on or before the Twentieth day afte

service, excluding the day thereof, otherwise the bill may be take

pro confesso.

B. C. MILLER, Clerk.

20 (Endorsement on Subpena when Issued.)

No. 233. United States District Court, Northern District of Ohi

Rail and River Coal Co. vs. Wallace D. Yaple et al. Subpena i

Equity. Return day May 7, 1914. Hoyt, Dustin, Kelley, McKe

han & Andrews, Complainant’s Attorneys.

(Endorsement on Subpena when Returned.)

April 21, 1914. I hereby accept service for all defendants.

ROBERT M. MORGAN, Aft’y,

(Special Counsel for Attorney General

of Ohio) for all Defendants.

Returned and Filed April 21, 1914. B. C. Miller, Clerk, U. |

District Court, N. D. O.

| WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL.

21 (Opinion of Court, Filed May 20, 1914.)

United States District Court, Northern District of Ohio, Eastern

Division.

No. 233. Equity.

Rai anv River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

vs. -

Watiace D. Yarite, Matrnew B. HamMonp, and Tuomas J.

Durry, as Meinbers of and Constituting the Industrial Commis-

sion of Ohio, Defendants.

On Application for an Interlocutory Injunction.

Decided May 20, 1914.

Before Warrington, Circuit oe Sater and Killits, District

u

Per Curiam:

The plaintiff, a West Virginia corporation, a large producer of

coal and employer of mine laborers, of whom there are more than

45,000 in Ohio, assails the constitutionality of the Ohio law of Fep-

ruary 5, 1914, entitled “An Act to Regulate the Weighing of Coal

at the Mines,” and asks for an interlocutory injunction against the

defendants, who constitute the Industrial Commission o Ohio, tu

prevent them from enforcing and attempting to enforce any of the

provisions of such act. The act, in so far as it need be considered,

is set forth in margin.* Diversity of citizenship and the

*Section 1. Every miner and every loader of coal in any mine

in this state who under the terms of his employment is to be paid fur

mining or loading such coal on the basis of the ton or other weight

shall be paid for such mining or loading according to the total weight

of all such coal contained within the car (hereinafter referred to as

mine car) in which the same shall have been removed out of the

mine; provided, the contents of such car when so removed shall con-

tain no greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or other im-

purity than that ascertained and determined by the industrial com-

mission of Ohio as hereinafter enacted.

Section 2. Said industrial commission shall ascertain and deter-

mine the percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or other impurity

unavoidable in the proper mining or loading of the contents of mine

cars of coal in the several operating mines within this state.

Section 3. It shall be the duty of such miner or loader of coal

and his employer to agree upon and fix, for stipulated periods, the

percentage of fine coal commonly known as nut, pea, dust and slack

allowable in the output of the mine wherein such miner or loader

is employed. At any time when there shall not be in effect such

—

16 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

22 paren of federal questions confer jurisdiction. Siler v.

uisville & Nashville R. R. Co., 213 U. 8., 175, 191; Mich-

igan Central R. R. Co. v. Vreeland, 227 U. S., 59, 63, 64; Louisville

& Nashville R. R. Co. v. Siler, 186 Fed. Rep., 176, 179; Ohio River &

W. Ry. Co. v. Bitty, 203 Fed. ., 537, 589; Mutual Film Co. v.

— Commission of Ohio, decided in this District April 2.

agreed and fixed percentage of fine coal allowable in the output of

any mine said industrial commission shall forthwith upon request

of such miner or loader or his employer, fix such allowable percent-

age of fine coal, which percentage so fixed by said industrial commis-

sion shal] continue in force until otherwise agreed and fixed by such

miner or loader and his employer. Whenever said industrial com-

mission shall find that the total output of such fine coal at any mine

for a period of one month during which such mine shall have been

operating while the percentage of fine coal so fixed by said indus

trial commission has been in force, exceeds the percentage so fixed by

it, said industrial commission shal! at once make, enter and cause to

be enforced such order or orders relative to the production of coal at

such mine, as will result in reducing the percentage of such fine coal,

to the amount so fixed by said industrial commission.

Sectiox 4.* * *

Section 5. Said industrial commission shall have full power from

time to time, to change, upon investigation, any percentage by it as

certained and determined, or fixed, as provided in the preceding sec-

tions hereof.

Section 6. It shall be unlawful for the employer of a miner or

loader of the contents of any car of coal to pass any part of such con-

tents over a screen or other device, for the purpose of ascertaining or

calculating the amount to be paid such miner or loader for mining

or loading such contents, whereby the total weight of such contents

shall be reduced or diminished. Any person, firm or corporation

violating the provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty of a

misdemeanor and upon conviction, shall be fined for each separate

offense not less than three hundred dollars nor more than six huv-

dred dollars.

Section 7. A miner or loader of the contents of a mine car, con-

taining a greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or other ir-

purity, than that ascertained and determined by said industrial com-

mission, as hereinabove provided, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor

and upon conviction shall be punished as follows: for the first offense

within a period of three days he shall be fined fifty cents; for a secon

offense within such period of three days he shall be fined one dollar,

and for the third offense within such period of three days he shall be

fined not less than two dollars nor more than four dollars. Provided,

that nothing contained in this section shall affect the right of a miner

or loader and his employer to agree upon deductions by the system

known as docking, on account of such slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or

other impurity.”

rtp — > ~ - i

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL. 17

The Ohio Coal Commission, appointed by virtue of a joint

23 resolution of the General Assembly (103 Ohio L., 981) “to

investigate and report an equitable method of weighing coal

at the mines, when the employees are to be paid for their labor on

the basis of weight, measure or quantity, and that will at the same

time be to the len interest of the consumers and protect the coal

measures of the state,” submitted a report in December, 1913, in

which, following a review of the evidence and arguinents of both

operators and miners, it recommended for passage a bill which finally

assumed the form of the present act. The information thus brought

to the attention of the General Assembly, and to which counsel in the

present hearing freely alluded, in so far as deemed material is surn-

marized in the next succeeding aph and is as follows:

All mine employés are required to belong to the United Mine

Workers—the strongest labor organization in the country. They

have had no difficulty in the past in securing fair wages. The sys-

tem of paying miners long in vogue in nearly all Ohio mines orig-

inated when only lump coal was marketable and is based on the

amount of coal mined and passed over a 114 inch screen, which

amount is assumed to be 28%. The insistence of the miners that

they are paid for but a part of the product of their labor began when

the finer grades of coal became salable. Their persistent grievance,

although it will not bear analysis, engendered disputes and bitter

feeling between them and their employers. A statute (Sec. 956,

General Code of Ohio) whose purpose is the avoidance of danger,

especially in gaseous mines, wisely requires the removal of fine coal

and coal dust from the mines, for the violation of which (Sec. 976,

9. C.) the offender may be punished by fine or imprisonment, or

both; but the miners, believing their grievance to be just, have not

always removed such coal and dust and thereby neither obviate such

danger nor conserve the coal supply. Generally stated, from 20%

to 50% of the coal under the heretofore prevailing systems of

24 mining has been left in pillars, ribs and stumps. The coal

so left deteriorates from exposure, becomes somewhat crushed

by the overlying strata, and yields a more than ordinary percentage

of fine coal, in consequence of which the miners either wholly refuse

to draw such supports or decline to do so unless paid a sum additional

to the regular contract price. In many instances, on account of such

unwillingness, those portions of mines which yield an unusual

amount of fine coal have been abandoned and the fuel so indis-

nsable to industrial ope is lost. On account of dissimilarities

in the character of coal, the quantity of fine coal produced varies in

different mines and even in different portions of the same mine—

the variations in some instances being quite marked. The result is

a variation in the wages of miners of equal skill and ability and

an advantage to operators obtaining an excess of fine coal as against

the miners and also as against other operators in districts in which

an effort is made to secure as large a percentage of lump coal as is

ible. The increased openings between screen bars, resultin

m the wear incident to use, diminish the quantity of lump coa

passing over such bars, to the loss of the miner. The failure to sub-

3—1104

—

18 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

stitute new screens is due in part to the negligence of the check.

weighman, authorized by statute (See. 970, G. C.) and selected and

paid by the miners to call attention to the defective character of the

screens, and in part to the carelessness of the operators in failing to

maintain screens conforming to their contract. Each, however,

charges the other with the responsibility of such failure and in-

stances have occurred in which the miners have struck and closed

down mines on account of disputes and delays regarding the furnish-

ing of new screens, Neither the charg» that the operators so dump

mine cars as to break the coal (by an excessive drop from such cars

to the screens, for instance), nor the counter charge that the miners

will not permit such dumping as will eliminate the fine from the

lump coal, is proved; but the cupidity and the carelessness

25 of each are deemed factors worthy of consideration. If coal

be shot from the solid, payment on the mine run basis will

result in an increased quantity of fine coal. Whether such increase

will occur if the coal is undercut before it is shot down, as was done

with about 95% of the coal mined at the time the report was filed is,

in view of the experience in other states having kindred statutes and

the difference in the Ohio coal from that of other fields, problem-

atical. If an increase occurs, it will operate quite prejudicially to

the sale of Ohio coal. The adoption of the mine run’ system will

also cause, to the prejudice of the operators, a considerable increase

in the amount of impurities brought to the surface, unless some way

be found to protect the operator from the carelessness and indiffer-

ence of the miner, and will require the inauguration of some method

of cleaning. It will also necessitate some increased expenditure in

the readjustment of tipples. The commission, in view of its find-

ings so summarized as above, concluded that the present system of

mining is inequitable, unjust, and productive of discontent. To ob

viate existing conditions, and to conserve the coal by supplying an

incentive to employés to remove pillars, ribs and stumps and the

portion of mines yielding more fine coal than is usual and to load

and send from the mine the fine coal which is now left underground,

the commission recommended that shooting from the solid be prohib-

ited and that the mine run system of payment be adopted, but so

safeguarded as to apply to clean coal only, i. e., coal so cleaned as to

be marketable.

The plaintiff charges that the act, in lodging in the industrial

commission the duty of determining the percentage of impurities

unavoidable in the proper mining or loading of coal, and of fixing,

in case of disagreement between the mine operator and his employés

and until they subsequently agree, the percentage of fine coal allow-

able in the output of the mine, unreasonably, unnecessarily

26 and arbitrarily deprives the operator, whose business, it is

alleged, is strictly private and unaffected by any public in-

terest, from contracting with his employés for the production of coal

containing more impurities or having a greater degree of purity

than that which the commission has fixed, and denies him the right

to reject and requires him to accept and to make payment for the

total contents of each mine car, without deduction or diminution, 9

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL, 19

long as the percentage of impurities fixed by the commission is not

exceeded, It avers that the act is not designed to protect the morals,

health, or safety of the public or of mine employés and has no real

or substantial relation as between the purposes attributed to it and

the means devised for attaining such purposes, but has for its object

the regulation of the relations between masters and such of their

servants as are paid by weight for coal mined or loaded; and that it

is therefore unconstitutional in that it deprives the plaintiff of lib-

erty and property without due process of law and of the equal protec-

tion of the law as guaranteed by the fourteenth amendment and the

Ohio bill of rights.

The act must be sustained, unless it can be clearly shown to be in

conflict with some constitutional provision. Board of Health vy. Green-

ville, 86 Ohio St., 1, 20; Schmidinger vy. Chicago, 226 U. S., 578,

587, 588; Mutual Film Co. v. Industrial Commission of Ohio, supra.

It came into existence through a claimed exercise of the police power,

a power which extends to the making of regulations “promotive of

domestic order, morals, health and safety.” Railroad Co. v. Husen,

95 U. S., 465, 471. Laws enacted in its appropriate exercise have

been sustained whose purpose has been to remove causes which give

rise to disputes and bickerings prejudicial to the good order of soci-

ety (Camfield y. U. 8., 167 U. S., 518, 524), to promote harmonious

relations between capital and labor (McLean vy. U. S., 211 U.S., 539,

549, 550), to avert strikes, violence and bloodshed (Peel Splint Coal

Co. v. West Virginia, 36 W. Va., 802; Knoxville Iron Co. v. Harbi-

_ son, 183 U. &., 13, 21), to provide for the safety and health

27 of miners (Freund, Police ny See. 115; Plymouth Coal

Co. v. Pennsylvania, 232 U. S., 531), and to regulate mines

and mining and to conserve and avoid the waste of fuel, minerals

and other natural resources. (Barrett v. Indiana, 229 U. §., 26, 29;

State v. Ohio Oil Co., 150 Ind. 21; Ohio Oil Co. v. Indiana, 177

U.S., 190; Hudson Water Co. v. McCarter, 209 U, S., 349; Wilming-

ton Star Mining Co. v. Fulton, 205 U. S., 60).

The rule announced in McLean v. Arkansas, supra, which in-

volved a statute akin to that here under consideration, has subse-

quently been so often approved by the Supreme Court as to be con-

trolling in the present instance, if the Ohio act is not materially dif-

ferent from that of Arkansas and is free from the constitutional in-

firmities which resulted in the overthrow of the earliest statute for

the weighing of coal before screening (93 Ohio L.. 33) in Re Pres-

ton, 63 Ohio St., 428. It is contended that the McLean case is not

an authority on account (among other things) of the powers con-

ferred on the industrial commission, the alleged absence of a pro-

vision granting to operators the right, under proper circumstances,

to reject coal brought to the surface, the possibly heavy penalties

that may be imposed on offending operators, and the alleged obscu-

rity and uncertainty of the penalties to which transgressing em-

ployees will be subjected and that the act must be held to be in ex-

cess of the state’s police power and contrary to its declared policy in

view of the Preston case, which pronounced invalid a law less vul-

nerable, it is claimed, to constitutional objection. None of the state

a

20 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

courts has passed upon the present statute. The courts may declare

the public policy when the law-making power is silent, but when

the people, acting within constitutional ers, have, by amendment

to their fundamental law enumera the subjects of legislative

action, such constitutional provision and statutes enacted in harmony

therewith must be enforced and not nullified by the courts.

28 Probasco v. Raine, 50 Ohio St., 378, 391. Subsequent to the

decision of the Preston case, the state constitution was

amended by adding to Article 2 the following sections:

“Section 34. Laws may be passed fixing and regulating hours

of labor, establishing a minimum wage and providing for the com-

fort, health and general welfare of all employés; and no other pro-

vision of the constitution shall impair or limit this power.

Section 36. Laws may be * * * to provide for the reg-

ulation of methods of mining, weighing, measuring and marketing

coal, oil, gas and other minerals.”

Without determining the soundness of the argument that the act

indirectly at least establishes a minimum wage, in that it insures

the miner full pay for all coal mined in accordance with the pre-

scribed regulation, it may not be said that, in supplying an in-

centive for more effectually securing the removal of fine coal and

coal dust to the surface and thereby minimizing or dissipating the

danger arising from their continued presence in the mines, the act

does not provide for the health, safety and general welfare of em-

ployés. Furthermore, section 36 was designed to limit by —

priate legislation the freedom of contract as regards the methods of

mining, weighing and measuring coal. We are not prepared to

hold that the legislature, acting within the scope of that section

may not say that the business of mining coal is so far affected with

a public interest as to justify appropriate requlation of the manner

of paying employés when they are to be paid according to the quan-

tity produced and when such regulatory statute will operate to allay

discord and strife and conserve the coal supply.

The Ohio act does not restrict the right of contracting for the

labor of miners by the day, week, month or year, or in any other

manner (except as to quantity) that the operator may deem proper.

If the miner or loader by the terms of his employment is to

29 be paid by the ton or other weight, the right of contract is

then curtailed to the extent that he shall be paid according

to the total weight of the coal contained in the mine car—such con-

tents to include, however, no greater percentage of slate, sulphur,

rock, dirt or other impurities than is unavoidable, as determined by

the industrial commission. If the employé should send to the sur-

face an excess of such impurities, or of any of them, the operator is

not required to accept the car or pay for its contents as delivered but

is at liberty to agree with him as to the deductions to be made on

account of impurities. If no agreement is made, the offending em-

ployé may be prosecuted for his violation of the commissioners’

order as for a misdemeanor. If he be unable or unwilling to pay

the fine imposed, he may be imprisoned in the county jail until his

fine and costs are paid or secured to be paid or he is otherwise legally

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL. 21

discharged, provided that he be given credit upon his fine and costs

at the rate of sixty cents per day for each day’s imprisonment.

Sec. 13,717, G. C. He is thus subjected to penalties which are

neither obscure nor uncertain, The act does not require the operator

to mingle the contents of such a car with the other coal produced

or prevent his removing, by screening or otherwise, the excess of an

impurities. It must be presumed that the industrial commission will

perform its official duty and fix a standard which will exclude all

slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or other impurities, except such as is un-

avoidable. The operator, if given the unrestricted right of contract,

could do no more. If dissatisfied with the commissioners’ order,

which by statute is made prima facie reasonable and lawful, he may

petition for and obtain a hearing before the commission as to those

features, and may thereafter have a speedy review of its action by

the Supreme Court of the state. Act February 27, 1913, 103 Ohio

L. 95, Sections 25, 27, 38-42; Art. 4, Sec. 2, Ohio Constitution. The

commission may of its own motion upon investigation modify

30 or rescind any of its prior orders. The law permits the em-

ployer and employé to stipulate as between themselves what

reentage of coal commonly known as nut, pea, dust and slack shall

™ allowable in the output of the employer’s mine. It is only in

case of their disagreement that the commission may designate such

percentage, and its orders in that behalf must ae the same char-

acteristics as those above mentioned and are likewise subject to re-

hearing and review. If at any time for a period of one month dur-

ing the operation of the mine the percentage vo fixed is exceeded, the

commission is required to enforce its order regardless of whom the

offender may be. The act prescribes no penaity for disobedience to

such an order, but if, as claimed by defendants, section 43 of the act

of February 27, 1913, applies, which we do not determine, an offend-

ing y may be fined not less than $50 nor more than $1,000 for

his first offense, and not less than $100 nor more than $5,000 for each

subsequent offense. In either event the attitude of the employer is

no worse than that of the employé. The danger of an increase in

the quantity of fine coal caused by shooting from the solid may,

under the act of February 5, 1914 (104 Ohio L., 161), be wholly

obviated, if the operator so elects, in that shooting of that character

may not be done and is made a misdemeanor, unless the operator and

4 majority of his miners obtain from the commission, upon applica-

tion, an order permitting it.

A violation of the provisions of section 6 is made a misdemeanor

punishable by fine for each distinct offense in a sum not less than

$300 nor more than $600. If the penalties are a separate part of the

act, which we need not now determine, the objection to it on account

of them is premature. Flint v. Stone Tracy Co., 220 U.S..177. {ff

they are not thus separate, they are not so excessive as to preclude a

resort to the courts for the purpose of testing its validity. It is not

to be presumed that a prudent employer wishing to test the law wiil

risk the possibilities of repeated violations of the commission-

31 ers’ orders.

Every argument advanced to sustain the contention that

22 | RAIL AND BIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

the act delegates legislative power to the industrial commission in

violation of Sec. 1, Art. 2, of the state constitution was urged against

the act providing a board of censor motion picture films, approved

May 13, 1913, in the case brought by the Mutual Film Co. v. The

Industrial Commission of Ohio, supra. To state our reasons for

holding the present contention unsound as we do, would be to repeat

in substance what was said to the same point in that case. We are

content to abide by the conclusion there reached.

The claim that the act is in violation of section 16 of article 2 of

the Ohio constitution which provides that “no bill shall contain

more than one subject, which shall be clearly expressed in the title,”

is unavailing. But one subject is embraced in the act. Were it

otherwise, we should follow the decisions of the state court and hold

that the provisions of the constitution above quoted is directory and

not mandatory. Ohio ex rel. v. Covington, 29 Ohio St., 102, 116.

In view of the above quoted amendments to the Ohio constitution,

the present act’s want of similarity to that considered in the Preston

case and its general resemblance in its principal features to that of

Arkansas, the instant case is ruled by McLean v. Arkansas and is well

within German Alliance Insurance Co. v. Lewis, decided April 20,

1914, Sup. Ct. U.S. It is not repugnant to any constitutional pro-

vision, state or federal. The prayer for an interlocutory injunction

is therefore denied. In order, however, to enable complainant to

take an appeal in each of the suits directly to the Supreme Court of

the United States, pursuant to Section 266 of the Judicial Code, and

to apply to that court for orders of suspension or supersedeas, if it so

desire, we have concluded to suspend the operation of the orders of

denial herein for a period of fifteen days from the date of their entry.

J. W. WARRINGTON,

Circuit Judge.

J. E. SATER, District Judge.

JOHN M. KILLITS,

District Judge.

32 (Order Overruling Plaintiff's Application for Interlocutory

Injunction Entered May 23, 1914, Entered for the Court

by Judge Killits, One of the Judges Sitting Therein.)

No. 233. Equity.

Rait & River Coat Company

vs.

Watiace D. Yarre, Matuew B. Hammonp, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial Commis

sion of Ohio.

This cause having hitherto been argued before the court and sub-

mitted, and an opinion having been filed herein, signed by the judges

of said court, which was constituted pursuant to Section 266, Judicial

Code, in accordance with such opinion, it is ordered, adjudged and

pee

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL. 23

decreed that the motion of the plaintiff for an interlocutory injune-

tion suspending and restraining the enforcement,, operation and exe-

cution of the Act of the legislature of Ohio, entitled “An act to regu-

late the weighing of coal at the mines,” approved February 17, 1914,

be, and the same is hereby denied; to all of which the plaintiff ex-

cepts.

Tt is ordered that the operation of this order denying said appli-

cation for an interlocutory injunction be, and the same hereby is,

suspended for a period of fifteen days from this date, to enable the

plaintiff to take an appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States,

if it should so desire.

33 (Preliminary Restraining Order, Entered May 23, 1914, by

Honorable John W. Warrington, U.S. Cireuit Judge; Hon-

orable J. EB. Sater, U. S. District Judge, and Honorable John M.

Killits, U. S. District Judge.)

No. 233. Equity.

Ratt AND River Coat Company

vs.

Wattace D. Yaprte, MatHew B. Hammonp, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial Commission

of Ohio.

This cause having been argued before and submitted to the court,

consisting of Honorable John W. Warrington, Circuit Judge. Hon-

orable John E. Sater, District Judge, and Honorable John M. Killits,

District Judge,—such court having been constituted pursuant to Sec-

tion 266 of the Judicial Code—upon motion for an interlocuto

injunction as prayed in the Bill; and such motion, after due consid-

eration by such court, having been denied as appears by its per

curiam opinion and order heretofore filed and entered in the cause;

and such court having inadvertently and erroneously assumed that

preliminary restraining order had been previously granted pursuant

to Section 256 of the Judicial Code, and so provided for suspension

of its order of denial herein for a period of fifteen days to enable

complainant to take an appeal to the Supreme Court of the United

States if it should so desire; now it is hereby ordered that a temporary

restraining order be, and such order hereby is, granted as prayed in

the bill of complaint herein until the 4th day of June, 1914 (on

which day said order shall expire), for the purpose of enabling com-

plainant, if it shall so desire, to appeal the cause to the Supreme

Court of the United States and there apply for an order of suspension

or supersedeas in the cause.

HE PTET AS i MiB

24 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY V8.

34 (Petition for Appeal. Filed May 28th, 1914.)

In the District Court of the United States for the Northern District

of Ohio, Eastern Division.

No. 233. Equity.

Rar anp River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

vs.

Watiace D. Yarpte, Matuew B. HammMonp, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial Commission

of Ohio, Defendants.

Petition for Appeal.

The above named plaintiff, feeling itself aggrieved by the order

made and entered in this cause on the 23rd day of May, A. D. 1914,

does hereby appeal from said order to the Supreme Court of the

United States, in accordance with the provisions of Section 266 of

the Judicial Code, for the reasons specified in the assignment of

errors which is filed herewith, and it prays that said appeal be al-

lowed, and that a transcript of the record, proceedings and papers

upon which the said order was made, duly authenticated, may be |

sent to the Supreme Court of the United States, and your petitioner _

further prays that the proper order, touching the security to be re-

quired of it to perfect its appeal, be made.

HOYT, DUSTIN, KELLEY, MCKEEHAN

& ANDREWS,

Attorneys for Plaintiff.

A. C. DUSTIN,

Of Counsel.

The foregoing petition is hereby granted and the appeal allowed

upon giving bond, conditioned as required by law in the sum of

$250.00.

JOHN M. KILLITS, Judge.

The issuance and service of a citation herein is hereby waived, this

28th day of May, 1914.

35 TIMOTHY L. HOGAN,

Attorney General of Ohio,

Attorney for Defendants.

CLARENCE D. LAYLIN,

ROBERT M. MORGAN,

Of Counsel.

Bat

- ie

i i

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL.

(Assignment of Errors. Filed May 28, 1914.)

In the District Court of the United States, Northern District of Ohio,

Eastern Division.

No. 233. Equity.

Rart anD River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

vs.

Wattace D. YapLte, MatHew B. HammMonp, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial Commission

of Ohio, Defendants.

Assignment of Errors.

And now comes the plaintiff, Rail and River Coal Company, and

says that the order entered in the above cause on the 23rd day of

May, A. D. 1914, is erroneous and unjust to the plaintiff because the

court, composed of Judges Warrington, Killits and Sater, which in

accordance with the provisions of Section 266 of the Judicial Code,

heard the plaintiff’s application for an interlocutory injunction

herein, erred for the following reasons:

1. The District Court erred in denying the application of

36 __— the plaintiff made after due notice and hearing for an inter-

locutory injunction.

2. The District Court erred in holding that the act of the Generai

Assembly of the State of Ohio, entitled “An act to regulate the

weighing of coal at the mines,” passed by the General Assembly on

February 5, 1914, approved by the Governor of the State of Ohio on

February 17, 1914, and filed in the Oftice of the Secretary of State on

February 20, 1914, does not violate Section 1, of the Fourteenth

Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, prohibiting

any state from denying any person of liberty or property without due

process of law.

3. The District Court erred in refusing to hold that the said act

constitutes an unwarranted and arbitrary interference with the right

of the plaintiff and of others similarly situated to contract with their

employees, and to manage their business of mining, producing and

selling coal, according to their own judgment; and in refusing to

hold that the said act thereby deprives the plaintiff, and others simi-

larly situated, of liberty and property without due proess of law, in

violation of the said Fourteenth Amendment.

4, The District Court erred in refusing to hold that the said act in

conferring authority and power on the Industrial Commission of

Ohio, and in requiring it to determine for each operator and each

miner and loader in the state, who is paid by weight, the percentage

of impurities unavoidable in the proper mining or loading of coal

in cars, and the allowable percentage of slack and fine coal, thereby

deprives the said operator and its employees of the right to deter-

mine, bargain and contract for the quality of coal to be produced

4—1104

ie

from said mines, and thereby deprives the plaintiff and others simi-

larly situated of uberty and properry without due process of

37 law, in vioiauuon of the said f ourveenth Amendment.

5. ‘Phe Vistrict Court erred in refusing to hoid that the said

act in requiring the operator to accept and pay for the mining ci

coal of a quality fixed by tne Indusirai Comnussion of Oto, inter-

feres with the freeuom of the employer to fix and determine the

product of his mine, and interferes with the freedom and the right

of the employer and the empioyee to contract with each other, and

thereby deprives the piainutt and others similarity situated of liberty

and property without due process of law, in violation of the suid

Fourveenth Amendment.

6. The District Court erred in failing to hold that the said act

denies to the piaintitf and others similarly situated the equal protec-

tion of the iaws as guaranteed by Secuon 1 of the fourteenth Amend-

ment to the Constitution of the United States, and by Articie 1 of the

Constitution of the State of Ohio.

7. The District Court erred in holding that the General Assembly

of the State of Ohio had authority to pass the said act under the po

lice power of the said state.

8. The District Court erred in failing to hold that Sections 34 and

36 of Article 2 of the Constitution of the State of Ohio did not au-

thorize the General Assembly to pass said act.

9. The District Court erred in that it failed and refused to follow

the decisions of the Supreme Court of the State of Ohio, with respect

to the extent and exercise of the police power of the said State, and

the interpretation and construction of the Constitution of the said

State.

10. The District Court erred in holding that the said act does not

delegate legislative power to the State Industrial Commission in vio-

iation of Sections 1 and 26 of Article 2 of the Constitution of the

State of Ohio.

11. The District Court erred in holding that the said act

38 does not violate Section 1, or any other section, of Article 1

of the Constitution of the State of Ohio.

12. The District Court erred in holding that the said act with re-

spect to the penalties therein prescribed for violation thereof, does

not violate Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitu-

tion of the United States, and Sections 1 and 16 of Article 1 of the

Constitution of the State of Ohio.

13. The District Court erred in failing to find that the plaintiff,

nding the final hearing in said court, would suffer irreparable in-

jury and damage, if the enforcement of said act were not enjoined.

HOYT, DUSTIN, KELLEY, McKEEHAN &

ANDREWS,

Attorneys for Plaintiff, Cleveland, Ohio.

26 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL.

(Bond on Appeal. Filed May 28, 1914.)

In the District Court of the United States for the Northern District

of Ohio, Eastern Division.

No. 233. Equity.

Rar anv River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

vs.

Watiace D. Yapite, Matuew B. HamMmonp, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial Commission

of Ohio, Defendant-.

Bond on Appeal.

39 Know all men by these presents that we, Rail and River

Coal Company, a corporation of West Virginia, as principal

and the American Surety Company of New York, a corporation of

New York as surety, acknowledge ourselves to be jointly indebted to

Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew B. Hammond, and Thomas J. Duffy, as

Members of and Constituting The Industrial Commission of Ohio,

appellees in the above cause, in the sum of $250.00 conditioned

that—

Whereas, on the 23rd day of May, A. D. 1914, in the District Court

of the United States, for the Northern District of Ohio, Eastern

Division, in suit pending in that court, wherein the Rail and River

Coal Company was plaintiff, and the appellees above named were de-

fendants, appearing on the Equity Docket as No. 233, an order or

decree was rendered against said Rail and River — Company, and

said Rail and River Coal Company having obtained an appeal to the

Supreme Court of the United States and filed a copy thereof in the

Office of the Clerk of this Court, to reverse the said order or decree,

and jssue of a citation thereon having been duly waived by the de-

fendants.

Now, if the said Rail and River Coal Company should prosecute

its appeal to the effect and answer all costs, if it fail to make its plea

good, then the above obligation to be void; otherwise, to remain in —

ull force and eftect.

RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY,

By W. R. WOODFORD, President.

AMERICAN SURETY COMPANY OF

NEW YORK,

[SEAL. ] By C. I. ZIMMERMAN, Res. Vice-Pres.

Attest: ?

H. LABET,

Res. Ass’t Sec’y.

The Foregoing Bond on appeal is hereby approved.

JOHN M. KILLITS,

Judge of the U. 8. District Court, Northern

District of Ohio, Eastern Division. -

—— : : 2 ; PO

98 RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY VS.

40a (Order Allowing Appeal;, Entered May 28th, 1914, by Judge

Killits.)

No. 23:3. Equity.

Rat anp River Coat Company

vs.

Wattace ID. Yap te et al.

On motion of A. C. Dustin, Esq., solicitor and of Counsel for the

complainant, it is ordered that ain appeal to the Supreme Court of the

United States, from the decree meretofore filed and entered herein on

the 23rd day of May, 1914, be and the same is hereby allowed; and

that a certified transcript of the record in accordance with the rules

of practice of the Courts of Equity of the United States, November

4th, 1912, be forthwith transrmitted to said Supreme Court of the

United States.

It is further ordered that the bond on appeal be fixed in the sum

of Two Hundred and Fifty Dollars ($250.00).

40 (Precipe. Filed May 28, 1914.)

In the District Court of the Uniited States for the Northern District

of Ohio, Eastern Division.

No. 233. Fquity.

Rait anp River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

vs.

Wautace D. Yarre, Matnew B. Hammonp, and Tuomas J.

Duffy, as Members of and Comstituting the Industrial Commission

of Ohio, Defendant-.

Precipe.

To the Clerk:

Please prepare transcript for appealing to the Supreme Court of

the United States, under Section 266 of the Judicial Code, from the

order made in the above entitled cause on May 23, 1914, by this

court, denying the plaintiff's application for an interlocutory injune-

tion, including in said transcript a copy of each of the following

pleadings and documents.

1. Bill of Complaint.

2. Subpeena in equity bearing: acceptance of service on behalf of

defendants thereon.

3. Memorandum of opinion filled by Judges Warrington, Killits,

and Sater on May 20, 1914.

4, Order overruling plaintiff’s application for interlocutory injune-

tion entered May 23, 1914.

WALLACE D. YAPLE ET AL.

5. Temporary restraining order granted May 23, 1914.

6. Petition for appeal and allowance.

7. Assignment of errors.

8. Appeal bond.

9. Precipe.

HOYT, DUSTIN, KELLEY, McKEEHAN &

ANDREWS,

Attorneys for Plaintiff.

41 (Certificate of Clerk.)

In the District Court of the United States, Northern District of Ohio,

Eastern Division.

No. 233. Equity.

Rai & River Coat Company

vs.

| Watiace D. Yapte et al.

NorTHERN District or OnI0, 8:

I, B. C. Miller, Clerk of the District Court of the United States

within and for said District,do hereby certify that the foregoing pages

contain a full, true and complete copy of the record in the above en-

titled cause, in accordance with the precipe for transcript filed by the

Appellant, Rail and River Coal Company, including the petition for

eppeal, assignments of error and the memorandum opinion of the

urt.

In testimony whereof, I have hereunto signed my name and affixed

the seal of said Court, at Cleveland, Ohio, this 29th day of May, A. D.

1914, and in the 138th vear of the Independence of the United States

of America.

[Seal of the District Court, Northern Dist. of Ohio. ]

B. C. MILLER, Clerk,

By R. C. DEAN,

Deputy Clerk.

Endorsed on cover: File No. 24,255. N. Ohio D.C.U.S. Term

No. 1104. Rail and River Coal Company, appellant, vs. Wallace D.

Yaple, Mathew B. Hammond, and Thomas J. Duffy, as members of

and constituting the Industrial Commission of Ohio. Filed June

4th, 1914. File No. 24,255.

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

Octozner Term, 1913,

No.

RAIL AND RIVER COAL COMPANY, Praryrtipp-

APPELLANT,

v8,

VYALLACE D. YAPLE, MATHEW B. HAMMOND, anp

THOMAS J, DUFFY, as Mempers oy AND Constirut-

ING THE INDUSTRIAL Commission or On10, Devenvanrs-

APPELLEES,

__

MOTION FOR TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER.

Now comes Rail and River Coal Company, appellant, by

attorneys, representing to the court that it has appealed

the Supreme Court of the United States from an order

retofore entered herein by the ] istrict Court of the U nited

tes for the Northern District of Ohio, Eastern Division,

lying appellant’s application for an interlocutory injune-

1, Which appeal has been allowed by said district court, re-

lo

2

spectfully moves the court to grant a temporary restraining

order herein, pending the hearing and decision of such ap-

peal by this court.

RAIL AND RIVER COAL COM-

PANY,

By HOYT, DUSTIN, KELLEY, Mc-

KEEHAN & ANDREWS,

Ite Attorneys.

(Norice.—Acknowledgment omitted. )

Copy.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

Raw ano River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

vB.

Waace D. Yarie er Av., Defendants.

Affidavit in Support of Application for Restraining Order.

Tue Strate or Onto,

Cuyahoga County, 88:

Charles E. Maurer, being first duly sworn, deposes and says

that he is forty-nine years of age; that he is president of the

Glens Run Coal Company and the St. Clair Coal Company,

which operate in the State of Ohio, and is also president of

the Standard Pocahontas‘Coal Company, which operates in

West Virginia; that said companies produce approximately

nine hundred thousand tons of coal per year; and that affiant

has been familiar with the coal business in Ohio, Pennsyl-

vania, West Virginia, and Indiana for the period of fifteen

years last past.

Affiant further says that he has read the bill filed in this

case; that there is invested in the coal mining industry in the

“i

3

State of Ohio fully one hundred million dollars; that such

business gives employment directly to upwards of 45,000

persons to whom wages were paid in the year 1913 in excess

of twenty-eight million dollars, and indirectly gives em-

ployment to many thousands of other persons; that there was

produced from the mines in Ohio during said year upwards

of thirty-six million tons of bituminous coal.

Affiant further says that all the coal in Ohio and Indiana

was produced by employees who are members of an organiza-

tion known as the United Mine Workers of America, and

that of the eighty-two million tons of bituminous coal pro-

duced in 1913 in the western part of the State of Penn-

sylvania approximately forty million tons were produced by

members of said organization, and that of the coal mined in

West Virginia approximately ten million tons were produced

by mines employing union labor.

Affiant further says that for upwards of twenty years to

affiant’s knowledge, and to affiant’s best belief from practi-

cally the beginning of the business of coal mining in the State

of Ohio, the coal mines in Ohio have been operated on what

is known as the screen-coal basis.

Affiant further says that for many years it has been the

practice at stated intervals, either once a year or once every

two years, for the coal operators who employ union miners to

meet in convention with officers and representatives of said

miners’ union and fix a scale of wages to be paid at mines em-

ploying union labor for certain definite periods; and that the

contract entered into a little over two years ago was for a

period of two years, expiring on April 1, 1914. Said con-

tract, as well as several of the contracts theretofore made, pro-

vided for the payment of miners and loaders of coal upon the

sereen-coal basis in the State of Ohio, and, generally speak

ing, in Pennsylvania and Indiana. Where miners and

loaders are being paid on the screen-coal basis the weight of

the coal is ascertained by passing the same over a screen, the

bars of which are, as applied to Ohio, Pennsylvania, and

Indiana, one and one-fourth inches apart.

ee re ee

re att

ve

eek ces tte dei

CREATAS

ES Ft,

4

Affiant further says that the bituminous coal produced in

Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana, is sold under keenly com-

petitive conditions, and that such coal and coal produced in

West Virginia reaches approximately the same markets; that

in the year 1913 twenty-three million tons of bituminous

coal produced in Ohio, Western Pennsylvania, and West

Virginia, were shipped via vessel up the Great Lakes, all of

which were sold on the same market and under competitive

conditions.

Affiant further says that the margin of profit in the coal

business for many years has been very small; that according

to statistics prepared by Dr. FE. W. Parker, of the United

States Geological Survey, the profits in coal mining in the

year 1909 were 2.5 per cent of the capital actually invested.

or, as stated by Dr. Parker—

“The average value per ton of all the bituminous

coal produced in the United States (1909) was $1.07,

the costs averaged a fraction of a cent over $1.00, so

that the margin of profit to cover interest, deprecia-

tion, and amortization was a little less than 7 cents a

m, 7 = -*

“Pennsylvania, by long odds the most important

producer, with an output of 137,300,000 tons, showed

a total of expenses of $117,440,000 and of value of

$129,.550,000, a balance on the profit side of a little

over $12,000,000, or about 34 per cent on the capital

invested, * * *

“The four competitive States, West Virginia, Illi-

nois, Ohio, and Indiana, which rank second, third,

fourth, and fifth, respectively, in producing impor-

tance, all show such narrow margins between income

and outlay that profits are visible only with a micro-

scope. The figures follow:

Value of product. Expenses, Difference.

West Virginia... $44.344,067 $43,024,716 = $1,319,351

HINO ss >>> 53,030,545 51,697 504 1,833,041

i eee * 27,353,663 27,153,497 200,166

Indiana ...... 15,018,123 14,906,831 111,292”

5

and since said date there has been little or no change in the

situation.

Affiant further says that in mining coal the efforts of the

operator are directed to produce as large a per cent of lump

coal as possible; that there is of necessity in the production

of coal some slack coal produced, which is generally marketed

under cost; that slack coal sells on an average of 45 cents per

ton less than coal screened over a 114-inch sereen, 35 cents

per ton less than coal screened over a *4-inch screen, and 25

cents per ton less than the ordinary run-of-mine coal as pro-

duced without a screen,

Affiant further says that the experience of operators in

States where methods of mining have been changed from a

screen-coal basis to run-of-mine basis shows that the amount

of slack coal produced has very materially inereased,—in

some cases the amount of slack coal has practically doubled.

so that the market value of the product is very materially re-

duced by such change in the methods of mining.

Affiant further says that just prior to the expiration of

the last agreement with the United Mine Workers various

meetings were held by the operators and the representatives

of said union in an effort to reach an agreement relative to

the mining of coal for two years following April 1, 1914;

that after many negotiations an ugreement was entered into

between said union and the operators in respect to mining

coal in Western Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Illinois, but no

agreement was made with respect to mining coal in Ohio,

and the mines in the State of Ohio are and have been closed

since April Ist; that the wage agreement so entered into was

substantially a renewal for a period of two years of the old

agreement expiring on April 1, 1914, in said States.

Affiant further says that the operators of Ohio were ready

and willing to continue their old agreement for the further

period of two years, and such an agreement would have been

entered into but for the statutes of the State of Ohio chang-

ing the method of mining and weighing coal referred to in

the bill in this case.

—9

6

Affiant further says that while theoretically it may be

possible to mine coal at so much per day, or so much per

week, it is the universal practice wherever the United Mine

Workers are employed to exact payment by weight for all

miners and loaders of coal, and the members of such union

refuse to work in any other way.

Affiant further says that as a matter of fact payment by

the day or week is not practicable in a business such as coal

mining, where the working places are widely separated and

incapable of proper supervision.

Affiant further says that the markets for Ohio coal require

the production of large amounts of lump coal, and that the

cost of changing the tipples and loading devices in use in

the mines of the State of Ohio, so as to weigh the coal before

the same is screened, would entail a large expense upon the

plaintiff to readjust its tipples and mining devices, and would

entail an expense to the operators of Ohio for that pur-

pose of upwards of one million dollars.

Affiant further says that while theoretically it may be pos-

sible to change the methods of weighing coal from the

screen-coal basis to a run-of-mine basis, and change the

method of paying employees from one basis to the other, as a

practical proposition such changes cannot be made without

great loss and injury; that the present law in Ohio was en-

acted by the legislature of said State upon the demand of the

United Mine Workers, and that if adopted by the operators

in Ohio as a method of weighing coal and paying employees

it will be impossible to restore the former method of weigh-

ing and paying for coal except after strikes, lockouts, and

labor troubles involving great loss and expense to both the

operators and their employees, which is to be deprecated, and

which should be avoided until the ultimate constitutionality

of this law is determined.

Affiant further says that the contracts heretofore made

prior to April 1, 1914, between said United Mine Workers

and operators in the States of Pennsylvania, Ohio, and In-

7

diana, were in each case the result of long and protracted

efforts to adjust the varying conditions to a proper competi-

tive basis, and that any attempt to establish a proper competi-

tive run-of-mine basis for the mines in Ohio when coal is

being produced and paid for in Western Pennsylvania and

Indiana on a screen-coal basis is a matter of the greatest diffi-

culty. All attempts that have been made to that end since

the passage of the law complained of in this bill have failed,

and as the result of such failure all the mines in Ohio are

now closed down, as aforesaid, and all said employees are

idle.

Affiant further says that the law of Ohio places upon the

coal operators of Ohio a great disadvantage, in that the In-

dustrial Commission of Ohio is authorized to fix and make

public the per cent of slate, rock, dirt, and other impurities

which may be loaded with the coal, and that such determina-

tions, being matters of public notoriety, will be used against

the coal operators of Ohio in all markets where the coal of

Ohio comes into competition with the coal produced in other

States, which will force the Ohio coal to be sold at a very

much less price than if mined in the ordinary way and

under rules and regulations prescribed by the operators them-

selves,

Affiant further says that in many of the coal mines in

Ohio the coal seam contains one or more dirt or slate bands,

and that it is only by the most constant and unremitting

vigilance on the part of the operators that coal can be pro-

duced in a marketable condition, and that the fixing by the

Industrial Commission of Ohio of certain percentages of dirt

and other impurities which may be properly mined with the

coal, and the taking from the operator the right to determine

how his coal shall be mined, will necessarily lead to great

carelessness and indifference on the part of the miners, and

that the method of control prescribed by said law is wholly

impractical and will not protect the operator against a prod-

uct being produced from his property which he cannot

8

market in competition with coal produced in the other States

mentioned.

Affiant further says that coal has been produced and paid

for in Ohio for more than thirty years upon the lump-coal

basis, and that no injury can result to the miners in the State

of Ohio, or to the State of Ohio itself, by continuing such

condition until a full hearing can be had and the validity of

the legislation attacked in this bill finally determined.

Aftiant further says that experience has shown that when

miners and loaders are paid on the screen-coal basis they will

exercise great care in the method and manner of shooting

coal, but that when they are paid on the mine-run basis

there is no such incentive to mine good coal, the consequence

being that much larger charges of powder are used and less

care exercised, and that as a result thereof the dangers of

mining have been very much increased.

Further deponent saith not.

CHAS. E. MAURER.

Sworn to before me and subscribed in my presence, this

29th day of May, 1914.

[SEAL. ] P. L. KLEIN,

Notary Public.

Copy.

(Caption omitted. )

Tue State oF OuIO,

Cuyahoga County, 88:

W. R. Woodford, being first duly sworn, deposes and says

that he is president of the Rail & River Coal Company, plain-

tiff herein; that he has read the affidavit of Charles E.

Maurer, and that the facts therein as stated are true.

Affiant further says that to rebuild and rearrange the

tipples at plaintiff's mines so as to handle the coal there-

9

from in a practicable manner and comply with the law of

Ohio would cost the plaintiff not less than ten thousand

dollars, and a similar amount to change back in event said

law of Ohio is ultimately held unconstitutional.

Further deponent saith not,

W. R. WOODFORD.

Sworn to before me and subscribed in my presence this

29th day of May, 1914.

[ SEAL. } P. E. KLEIN,

Notary Public.

STATE OF OHIO,

Cuyahoga County, ss:

D. J. Jordan, being first duly sworn, deposes and says that

he is forty-three years of age and is a resident of Cleveland,

Ohio, and has been engaged in the coal business practically

all his lifetime; that after the appointment of the Ohio Coal

Mining Commission by the Governor of Ohio, under the

joint resolution referred to in this case to investigate and

report an equitable method of weighing coal, etc., affiant

was employed by the coal operators of Ohio to go with said

commission, and accompanying said commission and affiant

was one Percy Tetlow, who, at that time, was a member of

the Ohio Legislature ; that after the testimony was taken and

the matter was being considered by the commission affiant

and said Tetlow both made arguments before said commis-

sion as to the proper report for them to make to the Ohio

Legislature ; that in the argument made by said Tetlow he, in

afliant’s hearing, said in substance:

If this commission will recommend a mine-run law for

Ohio we guarantee you that there will never be another

screen-coal contract entered into by the miners in the com-

petitive fields, meaning thereby that if the commission

would recommend to the legislature and the legislature

should adopt a screen-coal law for Ohio that Ohio would not

20

10

be allowed by the United Mine Workers to be put at a dis-

advantage in competition with the competitive States.

At the time said Tetlow was engaged in said work, and at

the time he made said statements, he was not only a member

of the legislature, but was an official of the United Mine

Workers.

Further affiant saith not.

D. J. JORDAN.

Sworn to and subscribed in my presence by said D. J.

Jordan the 1st day of June, 1914.

P. E. KLEIN. [seat.]

Notary Public.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.

Raw & River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

v8.

Waxiace D. Yarie er A., Defendants.

Affidavit in Opposition to Application for Restraining Order.

Tue State or Onto,

Franklin County, #8:

John M. Roan, being first duly sworn, deposes and says

that he is the duly appointed, qualified, and acting chief

deputy and safety commissioner of the Division of Mines of

the Industrial Commission of Ohio; that he is 55 years of

age; that at the age of nine and one-half years he commenced

to work in and about a coal mine; that he has served in

practically every employment or position in and about coai

mines in the State of Ohio from that time until he became

a coal operator and superintendent as hereinafter stated, such

positions being those of trapper, track layer, practical miner,

engine runner, and, in fact, all related positions; that he

mY

ii,

_

11

was a practical miner in Ohio coal mines for a period of ap-

proximately sixteen years; that in addition to serving in the

aforementioned employments and positions he has been an

operator of coal mines in the States of Ohio and West Vir-

ginia, holding the following managerial positions :

Between the years 1884 and 1901 affiant, together with

others associated with him, owned and operated a mine in

Perry County, Ohio, known as the Martin and Roan mine;

at the date last mentioned affiant and his associates sold said

mine to The Sunday Creek Coal Company, a large corpora-

| tion operating more than sixty mines located in the States of

Ohio and West Virginia.

In the year 1900 affiant was employed by the said The

Sunday Creek Coal Company «as general superintendent of

its properties in the Hocking and Sunday Creek fields in the

State of Ohio, located in Hocking, Perry, and Athens coun-

ties in said State; that in such capacity affiant was in charge

of 34 mines owned and operated by said The Sunday Creek

Coal Company; in 1901 the said The Sunday Creek Coal

Company purchased a number of mines in the State of West

Virginia and at the same time purchased the Martin and

Roan mine, of which affiant was part owner as aforesaid ; at

that time affiant was employed by The Sunday Creek Coal

Company as manager of its practical operations, both in Ohio

and West Virginia, and as such gave all his time to The

Sunday Creek Coal Company and had charge of all of its

mining operations of whatsoever character and wherever

located ; in the year 1907 affiant was employed by the Clinch-

field Coal Corporation in a capacity which required him to

develop mining properties located in the State of Virginia

upon 316,000 acres of coal land located in said State; that

he remained in the employ of said Clinchfield Coal Corpora-

tion for a period of four years, during which he opened up

on the property of said corporation ten bituminous coal

mines,

In the year 1911 affiant resigned the position last described

a

12

and organized a corporation under the name of the Log

Mountain Coal Company, which said company acquired the

ownership of five bituminous coal mines located in Belle

County, Ky.; the said company operated and is still operating

all of said mines, and affiant at that time became general

manager of said company ; affiant continued in the position

last described for a period of about one year, when he was

forced to abandon the same because of failing health. Affiant

returned to Ohio for the purpose of regaining his health, and

in the year 1913 was appointed by the Hon. James M.

Cox, governor of said State, as a member of the Ohio Coal

Mining Commission, being a commission appointed under

authority of an act of the General Assembly of the State

of Ohio for the purpose of investigating and reporting upon

the conditions of coal mining in the State of Ohio and the

method of compensating the miners for their services. A

copy of the report of said commission is attached hereto and

made a part hereof, marked “Exhibit A.”

Since December 26, 1913, affiant has been connected with

the Industrial Commission of Ohio and is now serving in

the capacity first above stated.

Affiant said that he has read the affidavit of Charles FE.

Maurer filed in support of the application for a restraining

order in the case of the Rail & River Coal Company vs.

Wallace D. Yaple et al.

Affiant says that the statement on page 2 of said affidavit

to the effect that “from practically the beginning of coal

mining in the State of Ohio the coal mines in Ohio have

been operated on what is known as the screen-coal basis” is

not strictly correct; that as a matter of fact and to affiant’s

personal knowledge there was no single and uniform basis

of compensating coal miners and loaders in use in the State

of Ohio prior to the year 1883, but that prior to said date

the several coal mines then operated in the State of Ohio

made use of different bases, such as the car measure, the bank

measure, the run of the mine, weight measure, and the

-_

13

sereen basis, with the use of screens of various lengths and

differing meshes; in the year 1883, under an act of the

Legislature of the State of Ohio, a commission was appointed

to investigate the subject of the compensation of miners.

The said commission and its report are referred to at page

33 of the attached report of the Ohio Coal Mining Commis-

sion. The said commission of 1883 recommended in ita

report the use of the screen system and the prescribing of a

standard screen. Since that time the recommendations of

said commission have been, by agreement, followed through-

out the State of Ohio, with very few exceptions, and the

statement of Mr. Maurer would hold good from the date

mentioned to the present time. Affiant says, however, that

the present-day conditions in the bituminous coal-mining

industry in the State of Ohio are fundamentally different

from those which existed when the commission of 1883 made

its report, and when what is known as the sereen-coal basis

of compensation was adopted uniformly in the State, in this

to wit:

In 1883, and for some years thereafter, there was no

market for Ohio bituminous coal which would pass through

a three-eighths-inch screen. In the opinion of the commis-

sion of 1883 this fact constituted a sufficient reason for the

adoption of the screen-coal basis of compensation and the

rejection of what is known as the mine-run basis of such

compensation. At the present time and for several years

last past there has been a market for all coal of standard

purity which can be brought out of an Ohio coal mine, and

coal which goes through the sereen is now sold as well as

that which passes over the screen; therefore the condition

which led to the adoption of the screen-coal basis no longer

exists; while the condition, the absence of which precluded

the adoption of the mine-run system in 1883, has now arisen.

viz., the marketability of all coal regardless of its ability to

pass over the screen.

Affiant further says that the statement of Mr. Maurer

14

at page 2 of his affidavit relative to the nature of the con-

tracts made between the coal operators and the miners’ union

is somewhat misleading; that as a matter of fact the territory

of the State of Ohio and the extreme western portion of the

State of Pennsylvania constitutes the only part of the entire

bituminous coal fields of the United States in which a strict

and exclusive screen-coal basis has been agreed upon as a

method of compensation. In the State of Indiana, referred

to by Mr. Maurer, the agreement between the operators and

the miners’ union provides for a double standard, both screen

and mine run and both standards are in actual use in that

State. The same, or the exclusive use of the mine-run sys-

tem, is true of all other bituminous coal fields wherein the

miners are organized and affiliated with the United Mine

Workers of America, including all fields which are in direct

competition with the Ohio fields.

Affiant further says that Mr. Maurer’s further statement

on page 2 of his affidavit relative to the competition of Ohio

bituminous coal with that produced in Pennsylvania, In-

diana and West Virginia is somewhat misleading. Affiant

says that it is true that Ohio, and particularly Eastern Ohio,

in which the operations of the companies with which Mr.

Maurer is connected are conducted, is in competition with

Pennsylvania, Indiana and West Virginia; also with Illi-

nois, which Mr. Maurer does not mention (and in which

field the mine-run basis of compensation is exclusively used) ;

affiant says that to his personal knowledge the different

operators in the Eastern Ohio field are in competition pri-

marily with each other rather than with the operators in

outlying fields or States; that coal from this district does not

compete with coal from other States until it reaches Cleve-

land. At this point Ohio coal is offered for sale at 15 cents

a ton less than Pennsylvania coal, and on the Great Lakes,

including the upper lake ports, as affiant is informed and

believes, Eastern Ohio coal is offered at 15 cents a ton lower

than Pennsylvania coal and at 5 cents a ton lower than coal

15

produced in the Hocking Valley field, which is in the

State of Ohio. Afliant has no knowledge of any West Vir-

ginia coal known as splint coal, being offered in any market

at a price lower than 5 cents a ton less than Hocking Valley

coal, which would be the same price as Eastern Ohio coal.

With respect to the statement of Mr. Maurer in his affi-

davit at page 3 to the effect that slack coal is “generally mar-

keted under cost,” this affiant says that from his knowledge

of the coal-mining business, the truth of this statement can-

not be established or overthrown by any absolute proof, be-

cause all depends upon the method of book-keeping and cal-

culating cost of production; however, to the best of his

knowledge the cost of production is and only can be figured

on the basis of the total product, that is, on a mine-run

basis, because it is impossible separately to compute and

ascertain, except by some arbitrary method, the respective

cost of production of lump coal, slack coal, and the various

intermediate grades. When coal is separated into the vari-

ous grades and sold otherwise than asx run of mine, i. e.,

as lump, nut, pea, slack, etc., the question as to whether

or not each grade is sold at a “profit” can be figured only

on what might be termed the average cost of production, i. ¢..

the cost of producing the whole product on the mine-run

basis. As a matter of course, the higher-priced grades will

appear on such a basis of computation to be sold at a higher

profit, while the slack will appear, on such a basis, to be sold

below cost of production; but the average of the coal sold

at various grades and otherwise than on the mine-run basis

will always be, affiant believes, in excess of the actual cost

of production.

Respecting Mr. Maurer’s statement on pages 3 and 4 of

his affidavit, to the effect or carrying the inference that under

a run-of-mine basis the amount of slack coal produced

will be practically doubled, based upon the experience of

ther States, this affiant says that to the best of his knowl-

edge and belief there is no basis whatever for any such

16

statement. It is true that the relative amount of fine coal

will undoubtedly be slightly increased on the run-of-mine

basis, but this increase, in affiant’s opinion, would come

from the fine coal that is now being left in the mine and

thrown back into the refuse pile. Afliant states positively, as

a result of his personal experience and the investigations

made by him as a member of the Ohio Coal Mining Com-

mission, that the leaving of fine coal in the mine is a great

economic waste of fuel and, furthermore, adds to the danger

of operating the mine.

Afliant further says that under the present screen basis

the manner in which the coal is passed over the screen is a

matter of continuous controversy between miners and opera-

tors, as a result of which miners have successfully insisted

that the coal be allowed to pass over the screen in a con-

tinuous, uninterrupted stream, so that much fine coal, adher-

ing to or carried by the lump coal, has been passing over

the screen. Such fine coal so passing over the screen with

the lump coal has the effect of deteriorating the quality of

the lump coal as such and at the same time reducing the

apparent proportion of the fine coal in the whole carload.

Affiant is of the opinion that under a run-of-mine basis

the miners would have no reason to object to such methods

of screening as will effectively separate the fine coal from

the higher grades. The result of this would naturally be to

increase the apparent proportion of fine coal produced by

the mine, at the same time enhancing the quality of the

higher grades, but in reality very little more fine coal would

be produced.

Affiant says that, aside from the two aforementioned rea-

sons for the production of more fine coal under a run-of-

mine basis than has been produced under the screen basis, he

knows of no practical reason tending to a production of an

undue amount or proportion of fine coal. So far as Mr.

Maurer’s statement to the effect that the amount of slack

would be “practically doubled” or “very materially in-

dekh

17

creased” is concerned, affiant has to say that he heard the

said Charles E. Maurer on June 2, 1914, at a convention of

miners and operators held in the city of Columbus, Ohio,

say publicly that in his opinion under a mine-run basis the

increase in the relative amount of fine coal would be not less

than 6 nor more than 12 per cent of the total output,

stating positively that he believed that 12 per cent would

be the largest possible increase.

Respecting Mr. Maurer’s statement at page 4 of his affi-

davit, in reference to the efforts which have been made to

renew the wage scale agreement from April 1, 1914, applica-

ble to the Ohio field, this affiant says that he has talked to

numerous miners, members and officials of the United Mine

Workers of America, and has heard them repeatedly express

themselves in the most positive terms, both publicly and

privately, to the effect that the Ohio miners would not renew

the agreement of 1912-14, providing for the screen basis of

compensation, under any circumstances, whether the recent

act of the Ohio Legislature be held constitutional or not;

that, other means of securing the run-of-mine basis fail-

ing, they would wage industrial warfare in order to secure

what they believed to be their rights. So that affiant be-

lieves that Mr, Maurer’s statement to the effect that the old

agreement would have been continued for a further period

of two years but for the statutes of the State of Ohio chang-

ing the method of mining and weighing coal referred to in

the bill in this case, has no foundation whatever in fact.

Affiant further says that Mr. Maurer’s estimate of the

cost of changing the tipples and loading devices at present

in use in the mines in the State of Ohio is evidently based

upon a misconception as to the meaning and effect of the

law set forth in the bill in this case. Mr. Maurer’s state-

ment is that the change to which he refers is such as to

make possible the weighing of the coal “before the same is

screened.” Affiant says that there is nothing in the new

law, which was prepared by the commission of which he

30

er eee a |

I ee ee ee ee ne ee

se

i 3

A hit DRESS ARE ES AE etal AER

NR Pe na ASE SS Fed Se

wa

| Vara eRe:

18

was a member, requiring the coal to be weighed before it is

screened. ‘The operator is permitted to screen his coal and

remove the impurities, providing he pays for all the per-

missible coal contained in the mine car. The screens may

be used as they are at the present time and the lump coal

and fine coal weighed separately. No change whatever in

the tipple is necessary to be made excepting the installation

of hopper scales to weigh the fine coal. The cost of such

installation would be betweeen one hundred and twenty-five

dollars and one hundred and fifty dollars for each tipple,

which would be from twelve thousand to twenty-one thou-

sand dollars for the State of Ohio.

Affiant says that the changes which he speaks of are the

only ones absolutely necessary, and that if Mr. Maurer has

in mind other changes for the purpose of producing higher

grades of coal, his figures do not relate to such changes.

Referring to Mr. Maurer’s statement on page 6 of his

atlidavit relative to the attempts that have been made to

establish a proper competitive run-of-mine basis for all mines

in Ohio, this affiant refers again to the statement hereinbe-

fore made relative to the attitude of the miners toward the

renewal of the screen basis.

Afliant says that he has noted Mr. Maurer’s objection to

the determination by the Industrial Commission of Ohio

of the allowable percentage of impurities which may be

loaded with coal on the ground that the publication of such

a percentage will work a detriment to Ohio coal wherever

it comes into competition with coal produced in other

States. Afliant, from his knowledge of the coal-mining

industry in this and other States, and the investigations

made by him as a member of the Coal Mining Commission

of Ohio, states that there is a well-known practice on the part

of miners and operators alike, existing throughout the

bituminous coal fields of the United States, to market im-

pure coal during times of great demand; that the impuri-

ties which occur in coal seams throughout the bituminous

19

coal fields are similar, so that Ohio coal is no more likely

to have such impurities in it than is the coal produced in

any other State; that so far from the standardization of the

quality of Ohio coal constituting a detriment to the Ohio

operators in the markets where that coal competes with the

coal of other States, affiant is of the opinion that it will

prove a positive advantage to them, in that Ohio coal will

virtually be sold under the law and the regulations of the

Industrial Commission upon a guaranteed standard of

purity, whereas coal from other States will not be marketed

under such conditions unless the legislation of other States

is conformed to that of. Ohio.

Relative to Mr. Maurer’s statement that no injury could

result to the miners in the State of Ohio or to the State’ of

Ohio itself by continuing existing conditions until a full

hearing can be had and the validity of the legislation at-

tacked in the bill filed in this case finally determined, affiant

says that he is convinced that there is not the remotest pos-

sibility of coal ever being produced again in the State of

Ohio upon the coal-screen basis. The granting of a tem-

porary restraining order in this case will not have the effect

of reopening the coal mines; on the contrary, it will serve

only to encourage a small number of operators in the State

of Ohio in an attitude which they have assumed (and which

is not followed by the majority of the operators in said

State), viz: the attitude of insisting upon the screen basis

and resisting the adoption of the run-of-mine basis, whether

by agreement or under the sanction of legislation. So long

as such operators continue in this attitude and the miners

continue in the attitude which they have assumed, as affiant

has hereinbefore stated, the mines will not be operated and

the miners in the State of Ohio and the public generally

will suffer very serious hardships,

Affiant further says that a convention of miners and

operators in Ohio and other fields was held in the cities of

Philadelphia and Chicago in the month of April, 1914, and

20

at such conventions the efforts referred to in Mr. Maurer’s

affidavit, looking toward wage scale agreements for the two

years beginning in 1914, were made. Affiant has talked

with Mr. Maurer and with other operators and with officials

of the United Mine Workers of America respecting the pro-

ceedings of said conventions, and upon information and be-

lief says that the mine operators in the Ohio field offered to

the miners at such conventions a wage scale based upon the

separate weighing of lump and fine coal, but providing com-

pensation for all the coal brought out of the mine, which is

all that the legislation complained of in this action requires.

Affiant believes that said offer so made by the operators was

entirely voluntary on their part and was made without ref-

erence to the legislation involved in this case. Affiant is

informed that said offer was rejected by the miners because

of the scale of compensation provided for therein.

Affiant further says that there is at the present time a

convention of miners and operators in the Ohio field being

held in the city of Columbus; that Mr. Maurer, who makes

affidavit in this case, attended said convention and acted as

spokesman and representative of the operators; that affiant

attended said convention and heard the said Mr. Maurer on

June 2, 1914, offer on behalf of the operators to the miners

a certain wage scale based on the run-of-mine basis, condi-

tioned upon the privilege of going back to the screen-coal

basis if the present litigation should terminate favorably to

the operators; but said proposal was rejected by the miners,

whether because of the annexation of the condition or be-

cause of the amount of compensation affiant is unable to

state.

Affiant refers the court generally to the contents of the

report of the Ohio Coal Mining Commission attached hereto,

in which many of the matters to which Mr. Maurer and

affiant refer, are quite fully discussed. Further deponent

saith not.

21

Sworn to before me and signed in my presence this 3rd

day of June, A. D. 1914,

’

Notary Public in and for Pranklin County, Ohio.

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO, EASTERN

DIVISION.

In Equity.

Rat anp River Coat Company, Plaintiff,

v8.

Watiace D. Yarte, Marnew B. HamMonp, anp Tuomas

J. Durry, as Members of and Constituting The Industrial

Commission of Ohio, Defendants.

Bill.

To the Honorable the District Judges of the Northern Dis-

trict of Ohio, Eastern Division:

Rail and River Coal Company, a corporation, brings this,

its bill of complaint, against Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew B.

Hammond and Thomas J. Duffy, as members of and con-

stituting The Industrial Commission of Ohio, and there-

upon said plaintiff complains and alleges:

L

Said plaintiff is and has been for a long time past a cor-

poration organized and existing under the laws of the State

of West Virginia, and is a citizen of said State of West Vir-

ginia, and a resident thereof.

IL

That the said defendants, Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew B.

Hammond, and Thomas J. Duffy, are citizens and residents

22

of the State of Ohio, defendant Wallace D. Yaple, residing

at Chillicothe, Ohio, defendant Mathew B. Hammond, at

Columbus, Ohio, and defendant Thomas J. Duffy, at East

Liverpool, Ohio, in the Eastern Division of the Northern

District of Ohio, and within the jurisdiction of this court.

Said defendants are the duly appointed, qualified and

acting members of The Industrial Commission of Ohio, hav-

ing been appointed as such members under and pursuant

to an act of the Legislature of the State of Ohio, entitled

“An act creating The Industrial Commission of Ohio,”

passed March 12, 1913, approved by the Governor of said

State March 18, 1913, and duly filed in the office of the

Secretary of State on March 20, 1913. Said defendant.

Wallace D. Yaple, is chairman, and said Mathew B, Ham-

mond is vice-chairman of said commission. Said act is set

forth at length in the Session Laws of the State of Ohio for

the year 1913, volume 103, pages 95 to 110, both inclusive,

to which act, for the full text thereof, complainant beg:

leave to refer as fully as though the same were at length

incorporated herein.

That under and by the terms of section 22 of said act

it is made the duty of said Industrial Commission, and it

is given the power, jurisdiction and authority on and after

the first day of September, 1913, to administer and enforce

the general laws of the State of Ohio relating to mines.

manufacturing and other establishments. Under the pro-

visions of sections 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, and 35 of said act, said

Commission is given extensive inquisitorial powers, and it

is made the duty of all employers to furnish to said Com-

mission information pertaining to their private business

affairs, to enable it to carry into effect the provisions of said

act and the orders of.said Commission made thereunder,

and said employers are required to make specific answers

under oath to all questions submitted to them by said Com-

mission, and to give said Commission access to their estab-

lishments and places of business. Under the provisions of

arte

23

section 36 of said act said Commission is given authority to

direct the prosecution of any action, proceeding, investiga-

tion, hearing or trial relating to matters within its jurisdic-

tion, and upon the request of said Commission it is made

the duty of the attorney general of Ohio or the prosecuting

attorneys of the various counties in said State to aid said

Commission and prosecute under the supervision of said

Commission all necessary actions or proceedings for. the

enforcement of said act and for the punishment of all

violations thereof.

III.

Said plaintiff is now and for many years last past has

heen actively engaged in the State of Ohio in the business

of mining and selling coal, and now owns and for a long

time past has owned in said State a large acreage of coal

lands, consisting approximately of 32,000 acres, of the value

of more than $1,000,000, upon which said lands said plain-

tiff has four coal mines properly developed, in which it em-

ploys upward of 2,000 persons, and from which said mines

said plaintiff’s average daily production is about 2,800 mine

cars of two tons each of coal; that among said employees

of plaintiff are about 1,700 persons who are paid on the

basis of the ton for mining or loading coal.

av.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that the business of

coal mining in the State of Ohio is very large; that there

are about six hundred (600) coal mines in said State, in

which there are employed upwards of 45,000 persons; that

upwards of 36,000,000 tons of coal were produced in the

year 1913, and there was expended in wages to said em-

ployees in said year upwards of $26,000,000.

24

¥;

Plaintiff further shows to the court that Western Pennsy!-

vania, the States of Ilinvis and Indiana are likewise large

producers of coal; that the mines located in these States are

in close competition with each other and with the mines in

the State of Ohio in the sale of the coal produced by their

respective properties; that a great majority of the operatives

engaged in the coal-mining business in said States are mem-

bers of an organization known as The United Mine Workers

of America. That for many years last past it has been the

custom for said mine operatives, through their representa-

tives in said organization, under arrangements made with

the various coal operators in the said States, to enter into

contracts with said operators for the period of two years,

whereby the interests of said operatives and their employers

have been subserved by curing reasonably uniform wages

for the different kinds of labor performed in said mines;

that the last agreement entered into was for the period of

two years, expiring on April 1, 1914.

That it has been for many years last past the custom and

practice of large users of coal, such as railroads and large

manufacturing concerns, to make contracts for their fuel

requirements by the year, and that many of said contracts

expired about April 1, 1914, or will expire in the immediate

future, and practically all of them prior to May 20, 1914.

VI.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that the wage agree-

ment referred to, which expired April 1, 1914, as well as

several of said agreements theretofore made, covering the

wages of such mine operatives as are paid by the ton in the

said States of Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Indiana, provided

for the screening of coal and for payment of wages at a cer-

25

tain price per ton for lump coal, to wit: such coal as would

pass over a bar screen of certain dimensions, wherein the

bars were 144 inches apart; of said four States, the mines

in said State of Illinois alone operating upon any other

basis, except that in the State of Indiana the operators, at

their option, paid on a mine-run basis also, and plaintiff

states to the court that said method of screening coal and

paying the miners and loaders thereof upon the basis of

such coal as will pass over said screen is designed and well

calculated to induce carefulness in mining, in that said

loaders and miners exercise greater care in the manner in

which charges of powder are placed to break down said coal,

and in the manner in which said coal is loaded after the

same is broken down, and the safety of the operatives is

much enhanced because of the better condition of the roof

of the mines, growing out of the smaller charges of powder

used therein.

That for the reasons aforesaid, those engaged in the min-

ing business operate their mines more economically and

in a safer manner, and coal of a better grade is produced

when the miners and loaders are paid upon the lump-coal

basis.

VIL.

Plaintiff further says that by section 970 of the General

Code of Ohio the owners and operators of coal mined in

said State are required to permit their mine operatives to em-

ploy, and it is the universal custom in said State for such

operatives tu employ, a representative known as check weigh-

man, Whose duty and right it is to examine the scales and

screening apparatus and machinery at the mine, and see

the coal weighed and check such weights, and make a cor-

rect record thereof. By this law the operatives are protected

and secured against any false weight or improper screening

of their coal, and from any improper deductions from the

coal mined or loaded by them.

4o

26

VIII.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that on the 20th day

of May, A. D. 1914, there will become effective a certain

act of the General Assembly of Ohio, known as Senate Bill

No. 3, entitled “An Act to Regulate the Weighing of Coal

at the Mines,’ which was duly passed by the General As-

sembly of Ohio on or about February 5, 1914, approved by

the Governor of the State of Ohio on February 17, 1914,

and filed in the office of the Secretary of State on February

20, 1914, “a true copy of which is hereto attached, marked

Exhibit A” and made a part hereof.

13.¢

That in and by the terms of said act it is provided that

every miner and every loader of coal in any mine in this

State who, under the terms of his employment, is to be paid

for mining or loading such coal on the basis of the ton

or other weight, shall be paid for such mining or loading

according to the total weight of all coal contained within his

car in which the same shall be removed from out of the

mine, unless the contents of such car when so removed shall

contain a greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or

other impurities than that ascertained and determined by

the said The Industrial Commission of Ohio.

X.

It is further provided in said act that said Industrial

Commission shall ascertain and determine the percentage

of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or other impurities unavoidable

in the proper mining or loading of the contents of the several

cars of coal in the several operating mines in said State of

Ohio, and said Commission is given power to change, after

investigation, any percentages ascertained or determined by

it from time to time as it shall deem necessary.

27

XI.

It is further provided in said act that it shall be the duty

of the miner or loader of coal, and his employer, to agree

upon and fix for stipulated periods of time the percentage

of fine coal allowable in the output of the mine wherein such

miner or loader is employed, and if such agreement is not

made the said Industrial Commission is authorized to fix

and determine the same. Said Commission is also empowered

to change from time to time the percentage of fine coal

which may be so lawfully loaded. Said Industrial Commis-

sion, if it finds that for a period of one month there shall

he produced a greater percentage of fine coal than that

fixed and determined by it, is authorized to make and en-

force such orders relative thereto as will result in reducing

the percentage of such fine coal to that fixed by said Com-

mission.

XII.

It is further provided in said act that it shall be unlaw-

ful for the employer of a miner or loader of the contents

of any car of coal to pass any part of the contents thereof

over a screen or other device for the purpose of ascertaining

or calculating the amount to be paid to such miner or loader

for mining or loading such contents, whereby the total

weight of such contents shall be reduced or diminished, and

it is provided that any person, firm or corporation who shall

violate such provision in respect thereto shall be deemed

guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon conviction shall be fined

for each separate offense not less than $300 nor more than

$600.

XIII.

It is further provided in said act that any miner or loader

of the contents of the mine ear who loads a greater percent-

aA

Bares. WA a2 ee

28

age of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt or other impurities than that

ascertained and determined by said Industrial Commission

shall be guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon conviction shall

be punished for the first offense within a period of three days

by a fine of fifty cents; for a second offense within such

period by a fine of one dollar; and for a third offense within

such period by a fine of not less than two dollars nor more

than four dollars.

XIV.

Plaintiff further shows to the court on information and

belief that on or about the — day of February, 1914, and

pursuant to said custom of entering into said biannual con-

tracts, the various operators engaged in the mining of coal

in the said States of Ohio, Pennsylvania, Indiana, and IIli-

nois, by their representatives, met and conferred with the

duly authorized representatives of their employees in the

city of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, with the view to mak-

ing a wage agreement covering the employment of said

operatives in all said four States for the period of two years,

beginning with April 1, 1914; that at said meeting said

operatives demanded that in the State of Ohio coal should

be mined and produced, and the wages of miners and loaders

be determined, in all respects in conformity with said act

of the General Assembly, and in no other manner; that

said meeting was adjourned without agreement; that later,

on or about the — day of March, 1914, a further meeting

was convened in the city of Chicago, Illinois, at which the

operatives repeated the same demand with respect to the

methods of mining and paying for the coal mined in the

State of Ohio, but offered to renew, unmodified so far as

weighing and screening of coal was concerned, the contracts

expiring on April 1, 1914, in respect to the business of coal

mining in the States of Pennsylvania, Illinois, and Indiana,

but no offer or proposition was made to make any contract

with respect to the mining of coal in Ohio, except upon the

basis of the said act of the Ohio Legislature aforesaid.

XV.

Plaintiff further shows to the court on information and

lelief that the operators of coal mines in the State of Ohio

(among which is the plaintiff herein) were ready and will.

ing to renew, to take effect on April 1, 1914, for the period

of two years, the contract which expired on said date, and

that the inability to reach such an agreement with their

operatives was largely, if not wholly, due to the existence of

said act aforesaid prescribing the methods of mining and

determining the basis of wages of said miners and em-

ployees, and delegating to the said Industrial Commission

the powers therein prescribed, and fixing and prescribing

the penalties that would be incurred by said operators and

said employees for any violations thereof.

XVI.

Plaintiff further shows to the court on information and

belief that on April 1, 1914, the owners and operators of

mines in the State of Ohio, being unable to secure men to

operate their said mines upon the basis and terms upon

which said mines had been operating for two years thereto-

fore, were compelled to close down said mines, to their great

detriment and damages, and that plaintiff was required for

stid reasons to close down its mines, to its great loss and

damage.

XVII.

Plaintiff further charges that said act, to wit: said Senate

Bill No. 3 is unconstitutional and void, and of no effect

whatsoever, for, among other reasons, the following, to wit:

(1) It violates the Fourteenth Amendment to the Fed-

30

eral Constitution, in that it abridges the privileges and im-

munities of the plaintiff, and deprives it and other persons

similarly situated of the liberty of contract, and constitutes

an unwarranted and arbitrary interference with plaintiff’

right to manage its business of mining, producing and sell-

ing coal according to its own judgment, and takes the prop-

erty of the plaintiff and others similarly situated without

due process of law.

(2) Said act confers authority and power on said Com-

mission and requires it to determine for each operator and

each miner and loader in the State, who is paid by the

weight, the percentage of impurities unavoidable in proper

mining or loading of coal in ears and the allowable per-

centage of slack or fine coal, thus depriving the said operator

and his employees of the right to determine, bargain, and

contract for the quality of coal to be produced from said

mine, ‘all in violation of said Fourteenth Amendment.

(3) In conferring power on said Industrial Commission

to prescribe the percentage of fine coal that may be loaded

and the percentage of slate, sulphur, and other impurities

that may be loaded with the coal, and prescribing penalties

for violations thereof by the miner or loader, said act con-

stitutes an unwarranted interference with the rights and lib-

erties of said miner and loader, and with his freedom of

contract with his employer; and likewise, in requiring the

operator to accept and pay for coal of a quality fixed by said

Commission, said act interferes with the freedom of the

employer to fix and determine the quality of the product

of his mine and interferes with the freedom of the employer

and the employee to contract with each other,—all in vio-

lation of said Fourteenth Amendment.

(4) The duties devolving on said Commission under said

act, if exercised pursuant to the powers conferred on said

Commission by the act creating said Commission, and

especially by Sections 18, 19, 20, 21, and 22 thereof, au-

thorize and require said Commission to investigate and in-

31

quire into the private business affairs of the operator, all in

violation of the rights secured to said operator by the Con-

stitution of the United States, and especially the Four-

teenth Amendment thereof.

(5) The plan provided by said act of fixing the quality

of said coal by said Commission, that may be lawfully mined

and loaded, ix wholly impracticable in the daily business

operations of a mine and would result in material and arbi-

trary interference with the operations of the mine, in viola-

tion of said Fourteenth Amendment,

(6) Said act is not within the police power or any power

of the State of Ohio. Is is not designed nor intended to pro-

mote hor protect, nor does it bear any relation to the health,

safety, nor general welfare of the public. It is not intended

nor designed to prevent fraud upon the operatives in coal

mines. Said operatives, by section 970 of the General Code

of Ohio, are specially empowered to and in fact do, by uni-

versal custom, supervise, check, and determine the weighing

and weight of all coal produced,

(7) The penalties and fines prescribed in section 6 of said

act, to-wit: Senate Bill No. 3, are so extreme and cumulative

as to deter and prevent ay person, firm, or corporation de-

scribed in said act, and subject to its provisions, from chal-

lenging the validity thereof, and such persons, firms, or cor-

porations are thereby constrained to submit to the provisions

of said act rather than take the chance of the penalties im-

posed, The minimum fines prescribed in said section 6 of

said act would amount, in plaintiff's case, to over $800,000.00

per day for each day's operation of plaintiff's property.

Said act, for the reasons herein mentioned, denies to this

plaintiff and to other persons similarly situated, the equal

protection of the law as secured and guaranteed to them by

the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution of the

United States,

SDE elt BEA HA RE RTT tie HS DOMES PG GAG SER NRE Bi 5b RRR BERR SNe OR deal]

TROL, AeA

Mb NT RR ak SRL A

ceil MMe leE SRR tS tilt

oP Rh asdateaee.

SEs Macey

*

ee

| whee,

32

XVIII.

Said act is likewise unconstitutional and void in that it

violates section | of article 1 of the constitution of the State

of Ohio, in prohibiting the freedom of contract therein guar-

anteed and secured.

XIX.

Said act is further in violation of the constitution of the

State of Ohio in that it delegates legislative authority to said

Industrial Commission, in violation of section 1 and <ection

26 of article 2 of said constitution.

XX.

Said act is further in violation of section 16, article 2, of

the constitution of Ohio, which provides that no law shall

embrace more than one subject, which shall be clearly ex-

pressed in its title, in that the title to said act relates exeiu-

sively to the weighing of coal at the mine, while said aet pur-

ports, in the body thereof, to confer upon said Industrial

Commission wide powers of inspection and supervision of

the manner and methods of mining coal, and empowers said

Commission to determine the quality of coal, which shall be

paid for as such, and the contents of mine cars, which shall

be binding upon employees and employers, regardless of

their contracts in reference thereto.

XXI.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that because of said

act, said Senate Bill No. 3, and the uncertainty in respect to

the constitutionality thereof, plaintiff's mines are closed

down as aforesaid, and plaintiff is unable to make or accept

contracts which are now being offered, and particularly con-

tracts for periods of one year or more, which contracts are

33

now being taken, as plaintiff is advised and believes, by the

coal operators in said States of Pennsylvania and Indiana,

competitors of the plaintiff, and plainuff is now, and before

the effective date of said act, suffering great and immediate

and irreparable injury by reason thereof.

XXII.

Plaintiff further shows to the court that said defendants

acting as said Industrial Commission, as plaintiff is informed

and believes, has taken steps and measures, or is about to take

steps and measures, to put said act in full force and effect,

and to that end has employed its agents and a special repre-

sentative, whose duties are to assist said Commission under

said act, and to make the investigations in respect to the mat-

ters and things provided for therein, and plaintiff is advised

and believes that said Industrial Commission, through said

representative or deputy, and its employees and other agents,

is about to demand access to the mines and property of plain-

uff, with a view of determining and investigating, and ex-

umining inio the business of mining as heretofore conducted

and carried on by said plaintiff, and plaintiff is advised that

said Industrial Commission threatens to and will promptly,

on May 20, 1914, put into full effect all the provisions of said

act, in the meantime trespassing upon plaintiff's property

and the property of other operators of coal mines in Ohio,

in the making of said preliminary investigations, as herein-

before outlined ; that said proposed investigations are for the

purpose provided in said act, and constitute an unwarranted

and illegal inquiry into the private business affairs of plain-

tiff.

XXIII.

That to prevent the immediate and irreparable injury and

the continuing wrong which will necessarily arise by the en-

forcement of said act, and from the requirements by said

defendants acting as said Industrial Commission in the en-

forcement thereof, and to prevent a multiplicity of suits

5o

|

34

against the plaintiff, and to prevent prosecutions under said

act and the imposition of the heavy penalties described

therein, and to prevent immediate and irreparable injury

which will be caused to plaintiff by reason of the fact that it

is prevented from operating its mines and from accepting

contracts for the sale of its coal, a writ of injunction is neces-

sary to restrain said defendants from interfering with plain;

tiff and other persons similarly situated.

XXIV.

That the amount in controversy herein and the value of

the matters disputed herein, and the loss which the plaintiff

is sustaining by the threatened enforcement of said act, and

the damages to plaintiff, as hereinbefore set forth, will greatly

exceed the sum of three thousand dollars ($3,000.00), ex-

clusive of interest and costs.

XXV.

Inasmuch, therefore, as plaintiff has no remedy in the

premises, save in a court of equity, plaintiff prays the aid of

the court;

1. To the end that the said Wallace D. Yaple, Mathew B.

Hammond and Thomas J. Duffy, defendants herein, as

members of and constituting The Industrial Commission of

Ohio, may, without oath (answer on oath being expressly

waived), full, true, direct, and perfect answer make to all

and singular the matters and things hereinbefore stated and

charged. /

2. To the end that said act, Senate Bill No. 3, may be

decreed to be unconstitutional and void and of no effect

whatsoever.

3. To the end that plaintiff may be decreed to have the

right to operate its mines and property, and to mine and sell

its coal, without compliance in any way with the restrictions

in said act set forth and with the regulations and orders of

said Industrial Commission thereunder.

35

4. To the end that plaintiff, its agents and employees may

be secured against unlawful and illegal trespassing and ar-

rests, fines, and penalties by reason of any alleged violation

of said act.

That the said Wallace D, Yaple, Mathew Hammond, and

Thomas J. Duffy, as members of and constituting The In-

dustrial Commission of Ohio, their agents, deputies, repre-

sentatives, attorneys and employees of every kind whatso-

ever, may be perpetually and forever restrained by the order

and injunction of this court from—

(4) Enforcing and attempting to enforce any of the pro-

visions of said act, said Senate Bill No. 3.

(4) From entering upon plaintiff's premises for the pur-

pose of making, with respect to said Senate Bill No. 3, any

investigation pretended to be authorized by said act of the

legislature of Ohio creating said Industrial Commission.

(ec) Making or establishing any rules or regulations in

respect to the amount of fine coal or the amount of impu-

rities to be loaded into cars at plaintiff's mines, or to be taken

as a basis for, or considered in connection with, the wages to

be paid to and received by said miners and loaders of coal.

(d) Beginning any action of any nature whatsoever

against plaintiff, its agents or employees, on account of any

violation of said Senate Bill No. 3.

(e) Arresting or causing the arrest of any agent or em-

ployee of plaintiff.

And that said defendants, each and all of them, may be

in the meantime so restrained during the pendency of this

suit, and plaintiff prays for such other relief as it may in

equity be entitled to.

XXVI.

May it please your honors to grant unto the plaintiff not

only a writ of injunction conformable to the prayer of this

bill to be issued to the above-named defendants, but also

writ of subpena to be issued out of and under the seal of this

a

36

honorable court, to be directed to said defendants, Wallace

D. Yaple, Mathew B. Hammond, and Thomas J. Duffy, as

- members of and constituting The Industrial Commission of

Ohio, commanding them, at a certain time and under a cer-

tain penalty to be therein specified, to be and appear before

this honorable court, then and there to answer the premises,

but not under oath (answer under oath being expressly

waived) and to abide by the order and decree of the court

therein, and that said defendants may appear herein accord-

ing to law.

RAIL AND RIVER COAL CO.,

Plaintiff,

By A. C. DUSTIN, Its Solicitor.

HOYT, DUSTIN, KELLEY,

McKEEHAN & ANDREWS,

Attorneys.

A. C. DUSTIN,

Of Counsel.

Unitep States oF AMERICA,

Northern District of Ohio,

Eastern Division, Cuyahoga County, ss:

W. R. Woodford, being first duly sworn, upon his oath de-

poses and says that he is the president of the Rail and River

Coal Company, plaintiff in the foregoing action, and duly

authorized in the premises; that he has read the statements

and allegations contained in said bill and knows the con-

tents thereof and that the same are true to his own knowl-

edge, except as to the matters therein stated to be alleged

upon information and belief, and as to those matters he be-

lieves them to be true.

W. R. WOODFORD.

Sworn to by the said W. R. Woodford and subscribed by

him in my presence this 16th day of April, 1914.

[SEAL. ] ADRIAN A. WYCHGEL,

Notary Public.

37

Exhibit ‘‘A.”’

(SENATE Brix No. 3.)

An Act to Regulate the Weighing of Coal at the Mines.

Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of

Ohio:

Section 1. Every miner and every loader of coal in any

mine in this State who under the terms of his employment

is to be paid for mining or loading such coal on the basis

of the ton or other weight shall be paid for such mining or

loading according to the total weight of all such coal con-

tained within the car (hereinafter referred to as mine car)

in which the same shall have been removed out of the mine:

Provided, the contents of such car when so removed shall

contain no greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or

other impurity than that ascertained and determined by the

Industrial Commission of Ohio as hereinafter enacted.

SEcTIoN 2. Said industrial commission shall ascertain and

determine the percentage of siate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or

other impurity unavoidable in the proper mining or loading

of the contents of mine cars of coal in the several operating

mines within this State,

Section 3. It shall be the duty of such miner or loader

of coal and his employer to agree upon and fix, for stipulated

periods, the percentage of fine coal commonly known as

nut, pea, dust, and slack allowable in the output of the mine

wherein such miner or loader is employed. At any time

when there shall not be in effect such agreed and fixed per-

centage of fine coal allowable in the output of any mine said

industrial commission shall forthwith upon request of such

miner or loader or his employer fix such allowable percentage

of fine coal, which percentage so fixed by said industrial

commission shall continue in force until otherwise agreed

—

38

and fixed by such miner or loader and his employer. When-

ever said industrial commission shall find that the total out-

put of such fine coal at any mine for a period of one month

during which such mine shall have been operating while

the percentage of fine coal so fixed by said industrial com-

mission has been in force exceeds the percentage so fixed by

it said industrial commission shall at once make, enter, and

cause to be enforced such order or orders relative to the pro-

duction of coal at such mine as will result in reducing the

percentage of such fine coal to the amount so fixed by said

industrial commission.

Section 4. Said industrial commission shall, as to all

coal mines in this State which have not been in operation

heretofore, perform the duties imposed upon it by the pro-

visions hereof.

Section 5. Said industrial commission shall have full

power from time to time to change, upon investigation, any

percentage by it ascertained and determined, or fixed, as pro-

vided in the preceding sections hereof.

Section 6. It shall be unlawful for the employer of a

miner or loader of the contents of any car of coal to pass

any part of such contents over a screen or other device for

the purpose of ascertaining or calculating the amount to

be paid such miner or loader for mining or loading such

contents whereby the total weight of such contents shall be

reduced or diminished. Any person, firm, or corporation

violating the provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty

of a misdemeanor and upon conviction shall be fined for

each separate offense not less than three hundred dollars nor

more than six hundred dollars.

Section 7. A miner or loader of the contents of a mine

car containing a greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, |

dirt, or other impurity than that ascertained and determined

by said industrial commission, as hereinabove provided, shall

be guilty of a misdemeanor and upon conviction shall be

punished as follows: For the first offense within a period of

=

39

three days he shall be fined fifty cents; for a second offense

within such period of three days he shall be fined one dollar,

and for the third offense within such period of three days

he shall be fined not less than two dollars nor more than

four dollars: Provided, That nothing contained in this sec-

tion shall affect the right of a miner or loader and his em-

ployer to agree ypon deductions by the system known as

docking, on account of such slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or

other impurity.

C. L. SWAIN,

Speaker of the House of Representatives.

W. A. GREENLUND,

President of the Senate.

Coneurred February 5, 1914.

Approved February 17, 1914.

JAMES M. COX, Governor.

I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true copy of the

engrossed bill.

’

Secretary of State.

Filed in the office of the Secretary of State February 20,

1914.

|

et. Pie m4 ee

as ”

40

(Preliminary Restraining Order. Entered May 23, 1914, by

Hon. John W. Warrington, U. 8S. Circuit Judge; Hon.

J. E. Sater, U. 8. District Judge, and Hon. John M.

Killits, U. 8. District Judge.)

No. 233. Equity.

Rait anp River Coat Company

v8.

Wauiace D, Yarie, Matuew B. Hammonp, and THomas

J. Durry, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial

Commission of Ohio.

This cause having been argued before and submitted to the

court, consisting of Hon. John W. Warrington, Circuit

Judge; Hon. John E. Sater, District Judge, and Hon. John

M. Killits, District Judge—such court having been consti-

tuted pursuant to section 266 of the Judicial Code—upon

motion for an interlocutory injunction as prayed in the bill,

and such motion, after due consideration by such court,

having been denied, as appears by its per curiam opinion

and order heretofore filed and entered in the cause, and

such court having inadvertently and erroneously assumed

that preliminary restraining order had been previously

granted pursuant to section 266 of the Judicial Code, and

so provided for suspension of its order of denial herein for a

period of fifteen days to enable complainant to take an ap-

peal to the Supreme Court of the United States if it should

so desire; now it is hereby ordered that a temporary re-

straining order be, and such order hereby is, granted as

prayed in the bill of complaint herein until the 4th day

of June, 1914 (on which day said order shall expire), for

the purpose of enabling complainant, if it shall so desire,

to appeal the cause to the Supreme Court of the United States

and there apply for an order of suspension or supersedeas in

dl

41

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, NORTHERN

DISTRICT OF OHIO, EASTERN DIVISION.

No. 233, Equity.

Raw axp River Coat Compaxy, Plaintiff,

v8.

WaALLace PD, YarLe, Marugew B. HamMMonp, and THomass

J. Durvy, as Members of and Constituting the Industrial

Commission of Ohio, Defendants,

On Application for an Interlocutory Injunction.

Decided May 20, 1914,

Before Warrington, Circuit Judge, and Sater and Killits,

District Judges,

Per Curiam:

The plaintiff, a West Virginia corporation, a large pro-

ducer of coal and employer of mine laborers, of whom there

are more than 45,000 in Ohio, assails the constitutionality

of the Ohio law of February 5, 1914, entitled “An Act to

Regulate the Weighing of Coal at the Mines,” and asks for

an interlocutory injunction against the defendants, who con-

stitute the Industrial Commission of Ohio, to prevent them

from enforcing and attempting to enforce any of the pro-

visions of such act. The act, in so far as it need be con-

sidered, is set forth in the margin. Diversity of citizenship

Section 1. Every miner and every loader of coal in any

mine in this State who under the terms of his employment

is to be paid for mining or loading such coal on the basis

of the ton or other weight shall be paid for such mining or

loading according to the total weight of all such coal con-

tained within the car (hereinafter referred to as mine car)

in which the same shall have been removed out of the mine:

Provided, the contents of such car when so removed shal]

60

42

and the presence of Federal questions confer jurisdiction.

Silver vs. Louisville & Nashville R. R. Co., 213 U. S., 175,

191; Michigan Central R. R. Co. vs. Vreeland, 227 U. S.,

59, 63, 64; Louisville & Nashville R. R. Co. vs. Siler, 186 Fed.

Rep., 176, 179; Ohio River & W. Ry. Co. vs. Bitty, 203 Fed.

Rep., 537, 589; Mutual Film Co. vs. Industrial Commission

of Ohio, decided in this distriet April 2, 1914.

The Ohio Coal Commission, appointed by virtue of a joint

resolution of the General Assembly (103 Ohio L., 981) “to

investigate and report an equitable method of weighing coal

contain no greater percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt,

or other impurity than that ascertained and determined by

the Industrial Commission of Ohio as hereinafter enacted.

Section 2, Said industrial commission shall ascertain and

determine the percentage of slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or

other impurity unavoidable in the proper mining or loading

of the contents of mine cars of coal in the several operating

mines within this State.

Section 3. It shall be the duty of such miner or loader

of coal and his employer to agree upon and fix, for stipulated

periods, the percentage of fine coal, commonly known as nut,

pea, dust, and slack, allowable in the output of the mine

wherein such miner or loader is Pron: At any time

when there shall not be in effect such agreed and fixed per-

centage of fine coal allowable in the output of any mine said

industrial commission shall forthwith, upon request of such

miner or loader or his employer, fix such allowable per-

centage of fine coal, which percentage so fixed by said in-

dustrial commission shall continue in force until otherwise

agreed and fixed by such miner or loader and his employer.

Whenever said industrial commission shall find that the total

output of such fine coal at any mine for a period of one

month, during which such mine shall have been operating

while the percentage of fine coal so fixed by said industrial

commission has been in force, exceeds the percentage so

fixed by it, said industrial commission shall at once make,

enter, and cause to be enforced such order or orders relative

to the production of coal at such mine as will result in redu-

cing the percentage of such fine coal to the amount so fixed

by said industrial commission,

43

at the mines, when the employees are to be paid for their

labor on the basis of weight, measure, or quantity, and that

will at the same time be to the best interest of the consumers

and protect the coal measures of the State,” submitted a re-

port in December, 1913. in which, following a review of the

evidence and arguments of both operators and miners, it

recommended for passage a bill which finally assumed the

form of the present act, The information thus brought to

the attention of the General Assembly and to which counsel

Section 4, * * +

Secerion 5. Said industrial commission shall have full

power from time to time to change, upon investigation, any

percentage by it ascertained and determined, or fixed, as

provided in the preceding sections hereof,

Section 6. It shall be unlawful for the employer of a

miner or loader of the contents of any car of coal to Pass

any part of such contents over a screen or other device for

the purpose of ascertaining or calculating the amount to be

paid such miner or loader for mining or loading such con-

tents whereby the total weight of such contents shall be re-

duced or diminished. Any person, firm, or corporation vio-

lating the provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty

SecTION 7. A miner or loader of the contents of a mine

car containing a greater percentage of slate. sulphur, rock,

dirt, or other impurity than that ascertained and determined

by said industria] commission, as hereinabove provided, shall

be guilty of a misdemeanor and upon conviction shall be

punished as follows: For the first offense within a period of

three days he shall be fined fifty cents; for the second offense

within such period of three days he shall be fined one dollar,

and for the third offense within such period of three days he

shall be fined not less than two dollars nor more than four

dollars: Provided, That nothing contained in this section

shall affect the right of a miner or loader and his employer

to agree upon deductions by the system known as docking,

on account of such slate, sulphur, rock, dirt, or other im.

purity.”

44

in the present hearing freely alluded, in so far as deemed

material, is summarized in the next succeeding paragraph

and is as follows:

All mine employees are required to belong to the United

Mine Workers—the strongest labor organization in the

country. They have had no difficulty in the past in secur-

ing fair wages. The system of paying miners long in vogue

in nearly all Ohio mines originated when only lump coal

was marketable and is based on the amount of coal mined

and passed over a 14-inch screen, which amount is assumed

to be 28 per cent. The insistence of the miners that they

are paid for but a part of the product of their labor began

when the finer grades of coal became salable. Their per-

sistent grievance, although it will not bear analysis, en-

gendered disputes and bitter feeling between them and their

employers. A statute (section 956. General Code of Ohio)

whose purpose is the avoidance of danger, especially in

gaseous mines, wisely requires the removal of fine coal

and coal dust from the mines, for the violation of which

(sec, 976, G. C.) the offender may be punished by fine or

imprisonment, or both; but the miners, believing their griev-

ance to be just, have not always removed such coal and

dust and thereby neither obviate such danger nor conserve

the coal supply. Generally stated, from 29 per cent to 50

per cent of the coal under the heretofore prevailing systems

of mining has been left in pillars, ribs, and stumps. The

coal so left deteriorates from exposure, becomes somewhat

crushed by the overlying strata, and yields a more than

ordinary percentage of fine coal, in consequence of which the

miners either wholly refuse to draw such supports or decline

to do so unless paid a sum additional to the regular contract

price. In many instances, on account of such unwillingness,

those portions of mines which yield an unusual amount of

fine coal have been abandoned and the fuel so indispensable

to industrial progress is lost. On account of dissimilarities

in the character of coal the quantity of fine coal produced

45

varies in different mines and even in different portions of

the same mine—the variations in some instances being quite

marked. The result is a variation in the wiges of miners

of equal skill and ability and an advantage to operators ob-

taining an excess of fine coal as against the miners, and also

as against other operators in districts in which an effort is

made to secure as large a percentage of lump coal as is

possible. The increased openings between screen bars. re-

sulting from the wear incident to use, diminish the qJantity

of lump coal passing over such bars to the loss of the miner.

The failure to substitute new screens ix due in part to the

negligence of the check weighman, authorized by statute

(see, 970, G. C.) and selected and paid by the miners to call

attention to the defective character of the screens, and in part

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.