Opposition Brief — Leavitt v. Tennessee Valley Authority
Supreme Court brief2004
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 03
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
3)
62
}
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY. ef al..
V.
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY. ALABAMA POWER
COMPANY, DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION. TENNESSEE
VALLEY PUBLIC POWER ASSOCIATION. ef al..
Petitioners.
Respondents.
On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the Eleventh Circuit
BRIEF OF ALABAMA POWER COMPANY AND
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION IN OPPOSITION TO
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
GARRY STEPHEN RICE
Associate General Counsel
Duke Energy Corporation,
PBOSE
422 S. Church Street
Charlotte, NC 28202-1901
(704) 382-8111
T. THOMAS COTTINGHAM IIL.
HUNTON & WILLIAMS
Bank of America Plaza,
Suite 3500
101 S. Tryon Street
Charlotte, NC 28280
(704) 378-4700
Counsel for Duke Energy
Corporation
March 29, 2004
KARL R. MOOR
Vice President and Associate
General Counsel
Southern Company
601 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Suite 800
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 261-5000
STEVEN G. MCKINNEY
Counsel of Record
MICHAEL D. FREEMAN
P. STEPHEN GIDIERE III
BALCH & BINGHAM LLP
1710 Sixth Avenue North
Birmingham, AL 35203-2015
(205) 251-8100
Counsel for Alabama
Power Company
meses" 3 BEST AVAILABLE COPY
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING
Petitioners before this Court (respondents before the Court
of Appeals) are the United States Environmental Protection
Agency and Michael O. Leavitt. Administrator, United States
Environmental Protection Agency.
Respondents before this Court (petitioners before the Court
of Appeals) are the Tennessee Valley Authority; Alabama
Power Company; Duke Energy Corporation; Tennessee
Valley Public Power Association; Memphis Light, Gas &
Water Division; Electric Power Board of Chatta-
nooga; Middle Tennessee Electric Membership Corporation:
North Georgia Electric Membership Corporation; and
Volunteer Electric Cooperative.
il
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
Alabama Power Company (“Alabama Power”) is a wholly-
owned subsidiary of Southern Company, a_publicly-held
company which owns all of the outstandir.g common stock of
Alabama Power; no other publiciy-held company has a 10%
or greater ownership interest in Alabama Power.
Duke Energy Corporation (“Duke”) is an energy company
traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol
DUK. No publicly-held company has a 10% or greater
ownership interest in Duke.
- REN eM Te MA BR coc en
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING................0.s00000000.
EP APU: STATEMENT ...........0000.cassecscoscsocssoseess
ES PE FRR CII ED yescccesssoscesvessonscossesessoussessses
REASONS FOR DENYING THE PETITION .............
I. THE PRESENCE OF THE’ PRIVATE
PARTIES ASSURES THAT THE CON-
TROVERSY BEFORE THE COURT IS
NS Siiicci vccrwescacxyesnsesasscasacsvinenrsesadacasi
Il. THE RECORD AMPLY DEMONSTRATES
THE STANDING OF THE PRIVATE
oad es lovkssavennenandsiesinextovsinnvasencss
Pas PRPEMCEE TEL SEBIGING......4.0..00000000.0cccesneveevesesees
1. Private Parties’ injuries are legally
ea issisbie ietelchicesananesdsvimeieiesens
a. Alabama Power's and Duke's
IN Th cainatiicesaelinciudarahucsiintisaxeces
ioe yo
2. Private Parties’ injuries are fairly
traceable to the EAB decision ...............
B. Private Parties have met their burden to
GEMAORSIFMIS StANGING ..............000.0.0seeresesevees
cc deriak aaehibcanaladwnsecibicssnocninbaniin«s
(111)
Nn
9
19
hY
TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
APPENDICES Page
A. Declaration of W. Perry Stowe...............:0cceee la
B. Declaration of Dr. John H. Landon................... 10a
C. Declaration of Gary H. Little....................ccceeeee 25a
D. Declaration of William F. Reinke...................... 32a
“. Affidavit of Mike McDowell.................ccccccceeees 38a
F. Declaration of Gary P. Garrett................:cccccceee 42a
G. Declaration of Jerry L. Golden............0....cce 45a
H. Letter from Craven Crowell, Chairman, Board
of Directors, TVA, to Hon. Fred Thompson,
SI TI TOI oni iies sc benivctcnsacacecccaskecdeccceds 50a
Declaration of Thomas L. Giles ......................6. 53a
»
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
CASES Page
Arlington Heights v. Metro. Housing Dev. Corp..
SEF Ea ER COTE Maisie nintamaaeienes 6
Bennett v. Spear, 520 U.S. 154 (1997).......... 4.13.15. 16
Central Ariz. Conservation Dist. v. EPA, 990
PF 2 F5 SE COUR. FIFE secntivnicsessesceneencirarnens 14.17
Department of Commerce v. United States House
of Representatives, 525 U.S. 316 (1999).......5. 7. 8. 16
Duke Power Co. v. Carolina Envitl. Study Gr irOup,
8 GR OP Gt eee tinisciapeniausaninee 15
Fund for Animals, Inc. v. Norton, 322 F.3d 728
CERES. eee isirsssatsenteuiseaigesa ase aeenae i8
Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife. 504 U.S. 555
PP Biss iivssciinvinckeiekinsic sooo 9,17, 18
New England Public Communications Council,
Inc. v. FCC, 334 F.3d 69 (D.C. Cir. 2003)........ 17
North Shore Gas Co. v. EPA, 930 F.2d 1239 (7th
OR Bt Bicccaccasiesideseensnkuntanitincsana eaeae eee 17
Save Our Heritage. Inc. v. FAA, 269 F.3d 49 (1st
Ronen ORME BE AOL a Neruifiarnn ox 6
Sierra Club v. EPA, 292 F.3d 895 (D.C. Cir.
Po SRO OPER ERE EOI LER N FREES Ga Meier eU Drolet 17, 18
Sierra Club v. Morton, 405 U.S. 727 (1972)......... 13
Southwestern Pa. Growth Alliance v. Browner,
144 F.3d 984 (6th Cir. 1998)..........u..cccsseeeees ont 14
TVA vy. EPA, 278 F.3d 1184 (11th Cir. 2002)........ 3
TVA v. EPA, 336 F.3d 1236 (11th Cir. 2003)........ 3
STATUTES AND REGULATIONS
et es 8 Pe iidaen eae 9
Re Das OF FMI iis erennuseranceasintnresammnaiareiaieeesl 9
S20 2A... © FSCO itinwinieeniosancanamann 9
PPT Be © UOC ieissccnnionnienmees 2
vi
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES—Continued
MISCELLANEOUS Page
U.S.-Canada Power System Outage Taskforce,
Interim Report: Causes of the August 14th
Blackout in the United States and Canada
CI. RP Missicsniiocsiviccivessmearimeneeaamenma 1]
IN THE
Supreme Court of the Anited States
No. 03-1162
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY, ef al..
Petitioners,
Vs
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY, ALABAMA POWER
COMPANY, DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION, TENNESSEE
VALLEY PUBLIC POWER ASSOCIATION, ef al..
: Respondents.
On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the Eleventh Circuit
BRIEF OF ALABAMA POWER COMPANY AND
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION IN OPPOSITION TO
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED
Petitioners have included some of the relevant provisions
of the Clean Air Act (CAA) in an appendix to their petition.
Additional relevant provisions are reprinted in an appendix to
this brief in opposition. The appendix to this brief also
contains materials from the record before the Court of
Appeals which Respondents believe are essential to an
understanding of the petition and which were omitted from
Petitioners’ appendix.
j
*
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
This case involves multiple. separate petitions for review
challenging action by the United States Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) relating to certain maintenance.
repair, and replacement activities at several electric
generating units owned and operated by the Tennessee Valley
Authority (TVA). On November 3, 1999, EPA issued an
Administrative Compliance Order (ACO) which found that
TVA had been violating the CAA for nearly twenty years by
performing various activities to maintain and repair its
electric generating units. EPA amended the ACO several
times. the last time on May 2, 2000.
On May 4, 2000. the Administrator of EPA directed the
agency s Environmental Appeals Board (EAB) to conduct a
“reconsideration proceeding.” The Administrator directed
the EAB to allow only “limited” discovery and oral testi-
mony. close the administrative record by August 1, 2000, and
issue a decision by September 15, 2000. The EAB issued its
decision on September 15, 2000, as directed. The EAB
' Three petitions for review of the ACO were filed with the Court of
Appeals. TVA filed an individual petition (No. 00-12310-E); Alabama
Power and Duke filed a joint petition (No. 00-12311-E); and TVPPA filed
an individual petition (No. 00-12349-E). In addition, after EPA refused
to stay the ACO, TVA filed a petition for review of that decision (No.
00-12459-E); Alabama Power and Duke filed a separate joint petition
(No. 00-12458-E); and TVPPA filed a separate individual petition (No.
00-12457-E). Based on the issuance of the EAB decision on September
15, 2000, the Court of Appeals dismissed these six petitions as moot. See
Pet. App. 61a. EPA’s petition for a writ of certiorari does not seek review
of the dismissal of these six petitions, and no cross petition has been filed
seeking review of the dismissal of any of these six petitions.
> The EAB is a board located within the Administrator’s office whose
members are not independent Administrative Law Judges (ALJs), but are
instead appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the Administrator. See
40 C.F.R. § 1.25(e)(1).
Pn Oe en en
3
decision upheld virtually all of the findings and sanctions
contained in the ACO that EPA chose to prosecute.
Following the issuance of the EAB decision. TVA.
Alabama Power, Duke, and TVPPA? filed petitions with the
Court of Appeals for review of the EAB decision. See No.
00-15936-E (TVA): No. 00-16234-E (Alabama Power): No.
00-16235-E (TVPPA): and No. 00-16236-E (Duke). For
purposes of review, the Court of Appeals consolidated the
four petitions.
The Court of Appeals issued two opinions addressing the
petitions for review. In its first opinion, dated January 8.
2002, the Court of Appeals resolved several threshold issues.
Pet. App. 5la-99a, reported at TVA v. EPA, 278 F.3d 1184
(11th Cir. 2002). With respect to TVA, the Court of Appeals
held that TVA possessed independent litigating authority and
that its dispute with EPA presented a justiciable “case or
controversy.” Pet. App. 6la-74a. The Court of Appeals
held that the EAB decision was a final reviewable order.
Pet. App. 74a-76a. The Court of Appeals also held that
Alabama Power, Duke, and TVPPA (collectively ‘Private
Parties”) had standing to challenge the EAB decision. Pet.
App. 89a-98a.
In its second opinion, dated June 24, 2003, the Court of
Appeals held that the CAA statutory scheme under which the
ACO was issued “is unconstitutional to the extent that mere
noncompliance with the terms of an ACO can be the sole
basis for the imposition of severe civil and criminal
penalties.” Pet. App. la-50a, reported at 7VA v. EPA, 336
* Joining TVPPA in its petition were 5 of its members—Memphis
Light, Gas & Water Division, Electric Power Board of Chattanooga,
Middle Tennessee Electric Membership Corporation, North Georgia Elec-
tric Membership Corporation, and Volunteer Electric Cooperative. For
sake of convenience, all of these petitioners are referred to collectively as
“TVPPA.”
4
F.3d 1236, 1260 (11th Cir. 2003). The Court concluded that.
in light of this constitutional infirmity, the ACO lacked
finality under the test in Bennett v. Spear, 520 U.S. 154
(1997). and that therefore the Court lacked jurisdiction to
review it. Pet. App. 46a. Based on this holding, the Court of
Appeals dismissed the petitions for review. The Court of
Appeals withdrew only part D of its first opinion. which held
that the ACO was reviewable. Pet. App. 19a-20a.
EPA filed a petition for a writ of certiorari on February 13.
2004. EPA’s petition requests review of three issues: 1)
whether the Court of Appeals erred in holding that the CAA’s
sanctions for non-compliance with an EPA order violate
TVA‘s rights under the Due Process Clause and Article III of
the Constitution, thereby rendering the order issued by EPA
to TVA in this case without legal effect—and therefore non-
final and not subject to judicial review; 2) whether a dispute
between TVA and EPA, two executive-branch agencies
whose leaders serve at the pleasure of the President, presents
a justiciable case or controversy: and 3) whether TVA has
independent litigating authority to bring this case over the
objection of the Attorney General.
REASONS FOR DENYING THE PETITION
Alabama Power and Duke ask this Court to deny EPA’s
petition for a writ of certiorari. TVA’s brief in opposition
sets out many reasons for doing so, and Alabama Power and
Duke hereby adopt those reasons. Alabama Power and Duke
write separately in opposition to the petition to emphasize the
fact that the existence of Private Parties’ own petitions
for review (which the Court of Appeals held they had
standing to maintain) make this case justiciable even without
TVA‘s participation.
EPA’s petition incorrectly states that the Private Parties’
presence will not affect the outcome of this case. See Pet.
28-29. This is a misstatement of law and reflects a basic
5
misunderstanding of the facts. To the contrary. even if this
Court were to agree with EPA that TVA’s petition did not
present a justiciable controversy, there would still exist a
justiciable controversy with respect to the EAB decision
because of the Private Parties’ petitions.’ The same is true
with respect to whether TVA possesses independent litigating
authority. Therefore, even if the first issue raised by EPA in
its petition were resolved in EPA’s favor, this dispute would
be remanded to the Court of Appeals regardless of the
outcome of EPA’s issues two and three. Because resolution
of issues two and three would have no impact on the ultimate
resolution of the case, those issues do not present substantial
federal questions warranting this Court’s review.
I. THE PRESENCE OF THE PRIVATE PAR-
TIES ASSURES THAT THE CONTROVERSY
BEFORE THE COURT IS JUSTICIABLE
EPA asserts in its petition for a writ of certiorari that the
presence of the Private Parties “is unlikely to affect the
disposition of this case.’ Pet. 28. According to EPA, “[i]f
the Court determines that . . . the dispute between TVA and
EPA presents no Article III case or controversy, then this
entire case should be dismissed.” Pet. 28. This is a mis-
statement of law and fact.
It is well settled that so long as a dispute is justiciable as
between two parties, the matter is a live controversy that
satisfies Article III°s case or controversy requirement. See,
e.g., Department of Commerce v. United States House of
Representatives, 525 U.S. 316, 330 (1999) (holding that the
“presence of one party with standing assures that [the]
controversy before [the] Court is justiciable”) (citing
‘The Court of Appeals correctly held that the Private Parties had
standing to maintain their own petitions (the only justiciability issue
raised with respect to their petitions), see infra, section Il, and EPA does
not seek review of that holding.
6
Director, Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs. y.
Perini North River Associates, 459 U.S. 297, 303-305
(1983)). See also Arlington Heights v. Metro. Housing Dev.
Corp... 429 U.S. 252, 264 n.9 (1977) (“Because of the
presence of this plaintiff, we need not consider whether the
other individual and corporate plaintiffs have standing to
maintain the suit.”); Save Our Heritage, Inc., v. FAA, 269
F.3d 49, 55 (1st Cir. 2001) (“It is sufficient for the case to
proceed if at least one petitioner has standing.”). In the
present case, the sole justiciability challenge raised by EPA
with respect to the Private Parties was standing. The Court of
Appeals correctly held that the Private Parties had demon-
strated their Article III and prudential standing, and EPA—
while stating in its petition that it “disagrees with the court of
appeals’ resolution of that issue”—does not raise it as an
issue in its “Questions Presented.” See Pet. (1) and 27.°
Thus, the petitions of the Private Parties are viable, and it
would be error to dismiss them even if this Court were to find
that the dispute between EPA and TVA is not justiciable or
that TVA did not possess independent litigating authority to
maintain its own petition. Accordingly, the resolution of
these two issues (issues two and three in EPA’s petition)
* EPA’s stated reason for not raising the issue before this Court is that
it “presents factual and legal complexities . . . and could prove difficult of
resolution in this case.” Pet. 28. Alabama Power and Duke suspect that at
least part of EPA’s motivation in not raising the standing issue is EPA’s
expectation that this Court would affirm the Court of Appeals on the issue
based on the record and its recognition that such a ruling would render
irrelevant the justiciability and independent litigating authority issues it
wants this Court to decide. As discussed in subsequent sections of this
brief. the Court of Appeals’ holding that the Private Parties have
demonstrated their standing follows this Court’s precedent, is supported
by the record, and is therefore wholly unremarkable. See infra, section II.
C7, Sup. Ct. R. 10(c) (providing that Court’s decision whether to grant a
petition for a writ of certiorari considers whether the court of appeals “has
decided an important federal question in a way that conflicts with relevant
decisions of this Court”).
J
would have no practical effect on the outcome and are not
substantial federal questions warranting review by this Court.
See Department of Commerce, 525 U.S. at 344.
This Court’s decision in Department of Commerce, supra.
is instructive here. In that case, two separate sets of plaintiffs
filed separate suits challenging the Census Bureau's plan to
use statistical sampling in the 2000 Decennial Census to
address the problem of undercounting. See id. at 320. The
two cases involved identical substantive issues—whether the
Census Bureau's plan violated the Census Act or the United
States Constitution. See id. The first suit, Clinton v. Glavin,
was brought by four counties and residents of thirteen states
who claimed that statistical sampling would lead to the loss of
their Representatives. 19 F. Supp. 2d 543 (E.D. Va. 1998).
The second suit, United States House of Representatives v.
Department of Commerce, was brought by the United States
House of Representatives. 11 F. Supp. 2d 76 (D.D.C. 1998).
The two suits, although raising the same substantive issues.
raised unique justiciability concerns. In Clinton v. Glavin, the
Census Bureau and the other federal defendants argued that
the suit was not justiciable because the plaintiff counties and
individuals did not possess Article III standing. 19 F. Supp.
2d at 545. In United States House of Representatives vy.
Department of Commerce, multiple Article III justiciability
issues were raised including standing. ripeness. and the
separation of powers doctrine. 11 F. Supp. 2d at 82-83.
On appeal, this Court held that because the record sup-
ported the Article III standing of one of the individual
plaintiffs in Clinton v. Glavin, there existed a justiciable
controversy as to the substantive issues in the two cases. See
Department of Commerce, 525 U.S. at 330 (holding that the
“presence of one party with standing assures that [the]
controversy before [the] Court is justiciable”) (citing
Director, Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs. vy.
Perini North River Associates, 459 U.S. 297, 303-305
| 8
(1983)). Thus, this Court refused to address the justiciability
issues as between the House of Representatives and the
Department of Commerce, because resolution of those issues
was not necessary to a resolution of the merits and therefore
did not present a substantial federal question. See id. at 344
(“As this decision [in Clinton v. Glavin] also resolves the
substantive issues presented by Department of Commerce v.
United States House of Representatives, No. 98-404, that case
no longer presents a substantial federal question.”).
Likewise, the present case consists of multiple, separate
petitions to the Court of Appeals for review of the same
decision of the EAB. See No. 00-15936-E (TVA); No. 00-
16234-E (Alabama Power): No. 00-16235-E (TVPPA): and
No. 00-16236-E (Duke). The TVA petition and the Private
Parties’ petitions have drawn separate and distinct jus-
ticiability challenges from EPA. Because the record amply
demonstrates the standing of the Private Parties (the only
justiciability concern raised with respect to their petitions),
and because EPA does not even request certiorari on that
issue, there is no need for this Court to grant EPA’s request to
review the justiciability of the petition filed by TVA or
TVA‘s independent litigating authority. Department of Com-
merce, 525 U.S. at 344.
Il. THE RECORD AMPLY DEMONSTRATES THE
STANDING OF THE PRIVATE PARTIES
EPA’s petition does not seek review of the Court of
Appeals’ decision that the Private Parties have standing for
good reason—the decision is squarely in line with the law,
amply supported by the record, and presents no unique or
substantial question warranting this Court’s attention.
:
|
z
3
¥
3
9
A. Article III Standing
Article Ill standing requires that a petitioner seeking
judicial review of final agency action show: (a) injury in fact.
(b) causation, and (c) redressability. See Lujan v. Defenders
of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 560-61 (1992). Courts evaluate
these three elements based on “the manner and degree of
evidence required at the successive stages of the litigation.”
Id. at 561. As discussed below. the record in this case (which
includes testimony submitted by the Private Parties) amply
supports the Article III standing of the Private Parties to
petition for review of the EAB decision.°
1. Private Parties’ Injuries Are Legally Suf-
ficient
a. Alabama Power's and Duke's Injuries
In response to a motion by EPA to dismiss their separate
petitions in the Court of Appeals, Alabama Power and Duke
submitted sworn testimony by way of declarations that
established their injuries. These declarations demonstrate,
among other things, Alabama Power's and Duke’s injuries in
the form of disruption and interference with their own electric
transmission grids and increased energy costs as a result of
the EAB decision.
TVA’s electric generation and transmission system is
interconnected with the systems of both Alabama Power and
Duke. See Resp. App. 27a, 34a, 43a.’ These intercon-
nections allow for the frequent exchange of power between
the connected systems in order to produce economic and
° The Court of Appeals correctly held that Private Parties satisfy the
prudential “zone of interest” test. See Pet. App. 94a-96a (citing 42 U.S.C.
$§ 7401(b)(1) and 7409%(d)(2)). See also 42 U.S.C. § 7470(3). EPA’s
petition does not call that holding into question.
7 . . . . .
For example, Alabama Power has six major transmission intercon-
nections with TVA. See Resp. App. 27a.
10
reliability benefits. See Resp. App. 27a, 34a, 14a, 43a.
Specifically, the interconnections help prevent loss of
electrical service (blackouts or brownouts) by facilitating the
exchange of power during emergency conditions (see Resp.
App. 27a, 34a) and provide cost savings by allowing for
energy purchases from and through the neighboring system
(see Resp. App. 26a-28a). For example, Alabama Power has
contractual rights to a substantial amount of power generated
by TVA and frequently purchases power that must travel
across the TVA system. See Resp. App. 3la. This power is
assumed and rationalized into the planning conducted by
TVA‘s neighboring utilities to meet the demands of their cus-
tomers and their own power supply commitments. See id.®
The EAB decision orders TVA, among other things, to
undergo new source review permitting at thirteen of its
generating units and to install new pollution control equip-
ment. See Pet. App. 274a-28la and Resp. App. 34a-35a.
This requirement to retrofit its units means that TVA would
be forced to remove generating units from service for
extended periods of time. See Resp. App. 29a-30a, 34a-35a.
This loss of generating capacity is not projected in current
planning. See Resp. App. 29a-30a. In addition, there is a
strong possibility that some of TVA’s generating units would
be withdrawn from service permanently if TVA is required to
comply with the EAB decision. See Resp. App. 35a.
* Alabama Power and Duke both coordinate their operations with TVA
through interconnection agreements filed with the Federal Energy Regu-
latory Commission (FERC) and through membership in the Southeastern
Electric Reliability Council (SERC). See Resp. App. 27a, 34a. Alabama
Power and Duke follow SERC guidelines to conduct internal reliability
planning (see Resp. App. 27a-28a, 33a) that is based on expected avail-
able generation levels on the TVA system (see Resp. App. 4a-Sa, 28a).
SERC has requested review of the issue of reliability in light of EPA’s
enforcement initiative against its member utilities. See Resp. App. 44a.
:
4
4
4
|
*
|
<
4
1]
The adverse effects of decreases in available generation
resources are experienced regionally and are not limited to
the owners of the equipment disrupted. See Resp. App. 13a-
14a. Inadequate reserves at times when neighboring utilities
are operating at full capacity creates a substantial risk of
major electrical supply disturbances such as those that
plagued the Midwest and Northeast this past year. See Resp.
App. 4a-5a; see generally U.S.-Canada Power System Outage
Taskforce, /nterim Report: Causes of the August 14th Black-
out in the United States and Canada (Nov. 2003), available at
http://www. ferc.gov/cust-protect/moi/blackout-report.pdf. If
TVA units were removed from service even temporarily.
Alabama Power and Duke would have to take steps to
maintain an adequate level of system reliability. including
increasing their own generation levels and reserves and
employing costly hedging techniques. See Resp. App. Sa-6a.,
15a-16a, 28a, 35a.” In addition, when TVA units are off-line.
there is a greater need for TVA to acquire capacity on the
wholesale.energy market, and this increased demand would
drive up prices that Alabama Power and Duke must pay as
competitors for that power. See Resp. App. 15a-l6a, 28a-
29a. For example, the prolonged loss of generation from just
one of TVA’s Cumberland units would cause TVA to import
more power and frustrate Alabama Power's ability to use
TVA and northern power markets for firm contract power.
See Resp. App. 31a.
In addition to the specific units and maintenance projects
targeted by the EAB decision, the EAB decision changes
TVA maintenance practices going forward and impairs its
ability to promptly return units to service. See Resp. App.
29a-30a, 51a. TVA must perform necessary maintenance on
” At a minimum, additional reliability studies would have to be con-
ducted by TVA, Alabama Power, and Duke to ensure that an adequate and
reliable supply system is available under the changed TVA operating
conditions created by the EAB decision. See Resp. App. 4a-Sa.
12
its units to assure a reliable supply of electricity. See Resp.
App. 46a. The EAB decision and its theory of routine
maintenance would apply to maintenance activities that TVA
is planning to undertake. See id. If TVA had to obtain
permits in advance of these or other scheduled maintenance
activities, the scheduled work would have to be postponed
during the permit proceedings, and it can take a year or more
to obtain a single permit. See id. The loss of TVA generating
units due to additional equipment breakdown, deterioration,
or delay in maintenance would jeopardize TVA’s ability to
meet the demands on its system and to assist other systems in
meeting their demands, and has the potential of leading to
brownouts and rolling blackouts. See Resp. App. 44a, 46a-
48a. This change in TVA maintenance practices results in an
increased present risk that TVA would not be able to provide
the power which is currently factored into the reliability plans
of neighboring utilities. See Resp. App. 29a, 49a. This loss
of TVA generation resources would also result in higher
market prices for electricity. See Resp. App. 29a-30a.
In addition, Duke purchases electricity for its own con-
sumption directly from TVA. Specifically, a Duke subsidiary
that operates a gas pipeline purchases electricity directly from
TVA in order to run compressor stations. See Resp. App. 55a.
If electricity were unavailable from TVA, this subsidiary
would have to restrict use of the pipeline and limit the volume
of gas transported. See Resp. App. 55a. The subsidiary
presently has no other alternative source of electricity in the
Tennessee Valley. See Resp. App. 55a.
In its petition to this Court, EPA failed to mention any of
this evidence. So too, EPA failed to mention that this
evidence was specifically relied upon by the Court of Appeals
to reach its decision on the standing issue. See Pet. App. 92a-
93a. This evidence is more than adequate to support the
Private Parties’ standing. This Court has held that “[e]co-
nomic injuries have long been recognized as sufficient to lay
13
a basis for standing,” and this principle has been extended to
claims brought under the CAA. Sierra Club vy. Morton. 405
U.S. 727, 733 (1972).
EPA’s principal argument against the Private Parties’
standing was that their injuries were “highly speculative.”
Pet. App. 89a. As the Court of Appeals recognized. EPA’s
argument fails to appreciate the nature of the Private Parties”
injuries. Operation of an electric transmission grid must take
into account possible future events that would cause
disruption. The fact that the EAB decision purports to
“alter[] the legal regime” under which TVA conducts its
maintenance activities causes a present injury to inter-
connected grid operators like Alabama Power and Duke who
must take into account that new regime and the uncertainty
which it causes. See Bennett, 520 U.S. at 169.
b. TVPPA’s Injuries
TVPPA’s standing was likewise established by the
evidence before the Court of Appeals. See Pet. App. 96a-98a.
One hundred and fifty-nine (159) of TVPPA*’s member
systems have entered into long-term wholesale power and
supply contracts with TVA that require each system to
purchase all of its requirements of enérgy and capacity from
TVA. See Resp> App. 39a. In the fiscal year most recent to
the submission of TVPPA’s affidavit, TVPPA’s members
purchased one hundred percent of their electric energy
requirements from TVA, representing approximately eighty-
three percent of the electric energy produced by TVA. See
Resp. App. 39a-40a. Under these long-term, all-requirements
contracts, TVA has the right to adjust or change wholesale
and retail rates during the term of the contract in order to
assure TVA’s ability to continue to supply the power
requirements of the TVPPA member systems and TVA‘s
other customers on a financially sound basis. See Resp.
14
App. 40a. As a result, TVPPA member systems would be
ultimately responsible for paying most of the increases in
TVA‘s costs resulting from the EAB decision. See id.
Additionally. one hundred and nine (109) members of
TVPPA are municipal governments in Tennessee, Kentucky,
Alabama, Mississippi, Georgia, and North Carolina that buy
energy and capacity from TVA. See Resp. App. 40a. These
municipal governments rely upon the availability of low-cost
electricity purchased at wholesale from TVA to assist them in
economic development efforts and will suffer an economic
disadvantage compared to other communities due to the
higher power costs that will result from the EAB decision.
See Resp. App. 40a, 50a-52a.
Relying on these facts, the Court of Appeals found that
TVPPA was injured by the increased cost of electricity that
its members will be forced to pay. See Pet. App. 98a.'° The
Court of Appeals concluded that “business realities make it
likely that TVPPA’s members can expect some rate increases
as a result of EPA’s order, a point that EPA apparently
concedes.” /d. (emphasis in original). As the Court of
Appeals noted, even EPA conceded that compliance with the
EAB decision would raise the rates that TVA charges its
customers like TVPPA. /d. This economic harm from
the EAB decision is more than sufficient to provide TVPPA
with standing. See, e.g., Southwestern Pa. Growth Alliance v.
Browner, 144 F.3d 984 (6th Cir. 1998) (holding that organi-
zation of manufacturers and governments in Pennsylvania
had standing to challenge EPA order based on economic
disadvantage that order would cause); Central Ariz. Con-
servation Dist. v. EPA, 990 F.2d 1531, 1538 (9th Cir. 1993)
’ Because TVPPA’s standing was demonstrated by the fact of in-
creased rates, the Court of Appeals did not need to consider TVPPA’s
standing on the basis of the economic disadvantage that would be suffered
by its members as a result of the EAB decision. See Pet. App. 98a.
KS ENS Nar IR de RABEL
15
(holding that standing was satisfied by showing that agency
action “will likely cause Petitioners some amount of
pecuniary harm”) (emphasis in original).
2. Private Parties’ Injuries are Fairly Trace-
_able to the EAB Decision
To establish that the Private Parties’ injuries are fairly
traceable to the EAB decision, the law does not require that
the Private Parties prove a cause and effect relationship with
absolute certainty. Rather, a substantial likelihood that they
will be harmed by the EAB decision is sufficient. See Duke
Power Co. v. Carolina Envtl. Study Group, 438 U.S. 59, 75 n.
20 (1978). This principle applies even in cases where the
injury is the result of agency action primarily directed at
someone else. See generally id. For example, in Bennett v.
Spear, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS)
argued that a water district's injury was not fairly traceable to
FWS's biological opinion because the proximate cause of the
harm stemmed from the Bureau of Reclamation’s allocation
of water and not from the biological opinion itself. 520 U.S.
at 168. The FWS, like EPA here, focused on the fact that the
Bureau, like TVA, “retains ultimate responsibility for deter-
mining whether and how a proposed action shall go forward.”
Id. This Court, however, rejected that line of thinking,
stating: “This wrongly equates injury ‘fairly traceable’ to the
defendant with injury as to which the defendant's actions are
the very last step in the chain of causation.” Jd. at 168-69,
The Court recognized, while injury should not be the result of
the independent action of some third party not before the
court, “that does not exclude injury produced by deter-
minative or coercive effect upon the action of someone else.”
Id at 169. In fact, Bennett involved what EPA would
describe here as a non-justiciable dispute between two federal
agencies (the Bureau of Reclamation and the FWS), but that
did not change this Court's conclusion that the water district
had standing.
16
The Court of Appeals followed Bennett's causation analy-
sis when it held that the harms to Alabama Power and Duke
were fairly traceable to EPA’s action in this case. See Pet.
App. 93a-94a. Even more so than the biological opinion in
Bennett, the EAB decision has a determinative and coercive
effect on TVA’s actions.'' EPA itself makes this point clear
by asking this Court to reverse the Court of Appeals” decision
that “IVA is free to ignore the ACO.” Pet. App. 3a. EPA
cannot have it both ways.
Department of Commerce, supra, also illustrates the prin-
ciple that petitioners need not show that the challenged action
is the last link hh the chain of causation. In that case, one of
the individual plaintiffs. a resident of Indiana, submitted an
expert affidavit that demonstrated his standing to challenge
the Census Bureau's proposed census plan. See Department
of Commerce, 525 U.S. at 330. The affidavit was based on
the expert's projection of year 2000 populations. /d The
expert used these projected populations as the basis for
further projections of how many Representatives would be
apportioned to each State under each census method. ulti-
mately reaching the conclusion that “it is a virtual certainty
that Indiana will lose a seat ... under the Department's Plan.”
ld. The tact that the plaintiff's demonstration of causation
involved multiple projected events did not prevent this Court
from holding that the plaintiff had satisfied his standing
burden. /d. at 330-332.
'' At the inception of this case. it was as true here as it was in Bennett
that the target agency (here, TVA) was “technically free to disregard” the
order issued to it, “but [did] so at its own peril (and that of its employees)”
who could have been subject to civil and criminal penalties for violation
of the CAA. Bennett, 520 U.S. at 170. EPA, like the FWS in Bennett.
is “keenly aware of the virtually determinative effect” of its orders and
should not be allowed to avoid judicial review by denying that effect. /d.
SOIL RDA I LA lit PULLS G iste Bas NN aE cette ps teh it TG ARE sey Saari <8
17
3. Private Parties’ Injuries are Redressable
The third element of constitutional standing requires that
the requested judicial relief be “likely” to redress the injury.
Lujan, 504 U.S. at 561. Redressability is not a difficult test to
meet. “[A] probabilistic benefit from winning a suit is
enough ‘injury in fact’ to confer standing in the undemanding
Article Ill sense.” North Shore Gas Co. v. EPA, 930 F.2d
1239, 1242 (7th Cir. 1991) (internal citations omitted).
Courts find redressability if the requested relief is the vacatur
of the agency action that would impose the bur-
den. See, e.g., Central Ariz. Conservation Dist., 990 F.2d at
1538 (“[E]limination of the Final Rule would necessarily
eliminate the increased financial burden the rule causes.”).
Clearly, the Court of Appeals’ vacatur of the EAB decision
redressed the Private Parties’ injuries by enabling TVA to
leave unchanged its well-established and predictable oper-
ational and maintenance practices, thereby preserving plant
availability and reliability and avoiding the increased costs
caused by the EAB decision.
B. Private Parties Met and Exceeded Their Bur-
den to Demonstrate Standing
Applying this Court's decision in Lujan, the Court of
Appeals for the D.C. Circuit recently explained that, where a
petitioner seeks direct review of agency action in the court of
appeals and “the petitioner's standing is not self-evident . . .
the petitioner must supplement the record to the extent nec-
essary” to substantiate the three elements of standing. Sierra
Club v. EPA, 292 F.3d 895, 900 (D.C. Cir. 2002),'* Although
" In most direct review cases, the petitioner’s standing is self-evident.
and no evidence outside the administrative record is necessary. Sierra
Club, 292 F.3d at 899-900. See also New England Public Commu-
nications Council, Inc. v. FCC, 334 F.3d 69, 74-75 (D.C. Cir. 2003) (“We
have no need to consider the application of Sierra Club in this case.
however, [since the challenged agency order] affects payphone line rates
18
EPA specifically declines to seek certiorari on the issue of the
Private Parties” standing. EPA nevertheless suggests that the
Court of Appeals decision is somehow inconsistent with
Sierra Club, See Pet. 27-28.
There is no inconsistency. Both the Court of Appeals here
and the D.C. Circuit in Sierra Club applied this Court’s Lujan
decision. Compare Sierra Club, 292 F.3d at 898-900, with
Pet. App. 89a-90a. Moreover, as the earlier discussion in this
brief makes obvious, the Private Parties. acting consistent
with Sierra Club, filed extensive declarations with the Court
of Appeals that support each element of standing. This is
precisely why, as EPA explains, there are “factual
complexities” presented by this issue that make certiorari
inappropriate. Pet. 28.
The Court of Appeals relied on the declarations submitted
by the Private Parties in concluding that standing had been
shown. Pet. App. 92a-93a. Inexplicably, EPA seizes on a
statement of the Court of Appeals that the Private Parties had
“adequately alleged injury™ to create the false impression that
no evidence was submitted and that standing would not exist
under Sierra Club. Pet. 28. That is simply not the case—the
Private Parties submitted sworn testimony amply supporting
their standing to challenge the EAB decision. That is all that
Sierra Club and this Court’s precedent require.
+
in every state.”); Fund for Animals, Inc. v. Norton, 322 F.3d 728, 733
(D.C. Cir. 2003) (“Sierra Club, however, does not require parties to file
evidentiary submissions in support of standing in every case.”).
GARRY STEPHEN RICE
Associate General Counsel
Duke Energy Corporation.
PBOSE
422 S. Church Street
Charlotte, NC 28202-1901
(704) 382-8111
T. THOMAS COTTINGHAM III
HUNTON & WILLIAMS
Bank of America Plaza,
Suite 3500 |
101 S. Tryon Street
Charlotte, NC 28280
(704) 378-4700
Counsel for Duke Energy
Corporation
March 29, 2004
19
CONCLUSION
The petition for a writ of certiorari should be denied.
Respectfully submitted,
KARL R. MOOR
Vice President and Associate
General Counsel
Southern Company
601 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Suite 800
Washington, D.C. 20004
(202) 261-5000
STEVEN G. MCKINNEY
Counsel of Record
MICHAEL D. FREEMAN
P. STEPHEN GIDIERE III
BALCH & BINGHAM LLP
1710 Sixth Avenue North
Birmingham, AL 35203-2015
(205) 251-8100
Counsel for Alabama
Power Company
APPENDICES
la
APPENDIX A
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket Nos. 00-12310-E. ete.
(Consolidated)
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY. ef al..
Petitioner.
we
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, and
JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator, UNITED
STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY. REGION IV.
Respondents.
DECLARATION OF W. PERRY STOWE
I, W. Perry Stowe, depose and state as follows:
Background:
[ am employed by Southern Company Services, Inc.. 600
North 18th Street, Birmingham, Alabama. as the Director of
Transmission Planning. I began working for Southern
Company thirty three years ago as a Coop Student with
Alabama Power Company and graduated in December 1971
with a Bachelor of Electrical Engineering degree from
Auburn University. After graduation, I began working for
Alabama Power in the Transmission Planning Department
and progressed through various departments and positions
within Alabama Power before transferring to Southern
Company Services, Inc. as Manager, Transmission Planning
in April, 1992. During this time, I received a Masters of Busi-
ness Administration degree from the University of Alabama
at Birmingham.
‘\
\
—
2a
My current responsibilities include planning the 115 kV
and above networked transmission systems for Alabama
Power and its affiliates. | am a registered professional
engineer in the State of Alabama.
Summary: :
The purpose of this declaration is to inform the court about
the transmission grid reliability impacts of TVA removing
significant amounts of generation from service to make
repairs as required by EPA. This declaration also explains
why EPA has harmed reliability interests by mandating such
actions without having taken sufficient time or provided for
the study and factoring of the reliability impacts of its Order
against TVA. This declaration will give a brief overview of
how the North American electric system operates, how
reliability is impacted if one entity within this system
operates in an unplanned manner, the relationship of Alabama
Power and its affiliates to TVA. and the present increased
risk of reliability problems caused by the EPA Order
against TVA.
Introduction:
The North American Electric Reliability Council (NERC)
defines reliability of the interconnected bulk electric system
in terms of two basic, functional aspects; adequacy and
security. Adequacy is defined as “the ability of the electric
system to supply aggregate electrical demand and energy
requirements of the customers at all times, taking into
account scheduled and reasonably expected unscheduled
outages of system elements.” Security is defined as “the
ability of the electric system to withstand sudden disturbances
such as electric short circuits or unanticipated loss of
system elements.” This entire process is a coordinated and
planned effort among all the electric entities within an
interconnection.
:
4
5
3
2
¢
Y
4
2
we het
Roath Ree sd lee aa ARS Tet Hees
PS a ee eee, eR ee er oe ee
3a
Each control area operator (such as TVA) in an inter-
connection owes a duty to every other operator (such as and
including Alabama Power Company) within the same
interconnection to plan for and operate its system in a safe
and reliable fashion to meet customer requirements—so that
all control area operators can keep the lights on in their areas
of responsibility. When one entity interconnected to the grid
has a situation that is unplanned and is more involved or
larger than has been planned for in the past. then all entities
within the interconnection will be adversely impacted. A
portion of transmission planning involves risk management,
identifying the risk of reliability events and managing these
risks. The EPA Order has a significant and very real impact
on the interconnected system by altering the relative risks of
various system disturbances.
Reliability Planning:
The North American electric system operates as three
distinct systems. These systems are divided geographically
into the Eastern Interconnection, Western Interconnection and
the ERCOT Interconnection. The Eastern Interconnection is
the largest interconnection. It covers an area from Nova
Scotia to Florida and from eastern New Mexico to Sas-
katchewan. The Western Interconnection is the second
largest. extending from Alberta and British Columbia on the
north to Baja California, Arizona, and New Mexico in the
south. It has several direct current ties with the Eastern
Interconnection. The ERCOT Interconnection includes most
of the electric systems located within the state of Texas. It has
two direct current connections to the Eastern Interconnection.
For each of these Interconnections to operate safely and
reliably and for them to provide dependable electric service to
its customers, it must be planned and jointly studied in a
coordinated manner.
4a
An interconnection is made up of several entities that
Operate as “control areas” that have the responsibility to
ensure that their customers have a safe reliable and adequate
supply of power. One manner in which this is accomplished
is through joint reliability planning studies. These studies are
performed between TVA, Alabama Power and its affiliates
under a reliability and coordination contract. In these studies.
the parties share transmission and generation data and then
perform studies to make sure that the joint systems have the
capabilities to handle the forecasted loads. As these studies
are conducted, the parties use the normal planning guidelines
for the impacted companies to evaluate the electric system.
For Alabama Power and its affiliates, these planning guide-
lines require that there be adequate and secure power supply
to customers despite the loss of a single major generating unit
at the same time as a single major transmission element is out
of service. When this situation changes, such as when TVA’‘s
power generation units face higher than planned forced
outage rates, will be out of service for longer periods to make
necessary repairs (and obtain necessary EPA permits), then
the reliability of the region and possibly the entire
interconnection has a higher risk factor than if only the
normal planning guidelines are evaluated. This higher risk
factor requires control area operators to make appropriate
adjustments to its reserves and operational practices.
To ensure efficiency “and reliability of power supply.
therefore, it is imperative that sufficient time be permitted to
perform detailed evaluations and simulations of any proposed
unit outages that exceed the normal planning guidelines prior
to EPA’s imposition of mandatory shut down schedules on
TVA. The EPA Order, however, does not appear to con-
template or authorize this sort of evaluation and parts of it are
now already affecting transmission risks. When significant
amounts of generation are not available to supply loads and
the actual loads are greater than the capability to supply the
generation, and TVA is not able to bring “forced outaged”
ai ticaee Nausea
Tia ie RIES Ut SENN IOS Te THN Gig AE OC
FESS A TR FA NEE,
Sa
units back to service as quickly as possible after necessary
repairs or replacements, major problems are highly likely to
develop such that significant portions of an interconnection
could be without power. In the case of cascading outages. all
loads could be impacted including traffic controls. hospitals
and other critical infrastructure loads. For all of these reasons
and out of a due abundance of caution, before these problems
manifest, studies must be performed jointly among all inter-
connected and affected control areas to ensure that an
adequate and reliable supply system is available to meet the
loads of all customers within the interconnection. The EPA
Order, again, fails to allow such collaboration and limits
all compliance schedule to TVA and EPA alone. without
any assurance that impacts on others will be considered
or addressed.
Single Network Comprised of Inter-Working Components:
The monitoring and control function of an interconnection
is distributed among the control areas that make up the
interconnection. A control area is an electrical system
bounded by metered tie lines. The control area operates its
generation in a manner to maintain its interchange schedules
with other control areas within the interconnection and
contribute to frequency regulation of the interconnection.
What this means is that the load and generation within a
control area must be balanced on a moment-to-moment basis
since electricity cannot be stored in these magnitudes. In
simple terms, when I-turn a light on in my home in
Birmingham, Alabama, a generator(s) within the Eastern In-
terconnection increases its output to supply my instantaneous
load and loss requirements. If this reaction to my action does
not happen, then the system frequency will begin to decrease.
Likewise, when a TVA plant goes down due to a component
failure, other generators in the interconnection must increase
output immediately to make up the TVA’s short fall. The
longer TVA must keep units down, the more other utilities
6a
may have to make up the differences. The electric systems
within each interconnection are responsible for planning to
ensure that sufficient generating and transmission facilities
are in place to meet their customers’ demand reliably.
The EPA Order Will Contribute To New Stresses on The Bulk
Power System:
The bulk power electric grid was constructed over time to
facilitate the electric entity supplying the needs of its cus-
tomers under a prescribed set of planning assumptions re-
garding load growth, generator construction and the operating
characteristics of the existing generation fleet: These
assumptions generally provide for the supply of generation to
match the load requirements within a control area with a
minimum amount of interchange between control areas.
Today, the electric industry finds itself in a transition
position where a particular electric entity does not have the
responsibility for serving all the load within its control area
and new environmental regulations. In addition to this new
contingency. new interpretations of old regulations are being
imposed on the existing facilities. These changes have caused
additional stress to be placed on the bulk power electric
transmission system. These strains are concentrated in, two
primary areas. One is the uncertainty about who is building
generating capacity to serve a particular load in question.
Based on the latest NERC Reliability Assessment 1999-2008
Report published in May 2000 the summer generating
capacity margins for 1999 through 2003 are at the lowest
reported levels in many years. This report also states that the
Eastern Interconnection is particularly low compared to
earlier years. It is currently in the 12-14% range, while it is
typically in the 14-16% range. In the 2008 time frame this
value is reported as 8-10%. These numbers must be viewed
with caution since they are being influenced by the
construction of merchant generation capacity that may or may
Ta
not be included accurately in these reported values. Again,
this is an unknown factor that makes the planning for a
reliable bulk electric transmission system even more
challenging. The second factor that is impacting the
transmission grid is the impact of additional transactions on
the bulk power grid. These transactions are the result of
merchant generators locating generation close to fuel
pipelines and water sources then moving power across the
grid to their load centers. This power movement creates flow
patterns and reactive power requirements that may not have
been planned for or experienced in the past. These flow
patterns use transmission capability that was previously
constructed to facilitate reliable network load servicing.
These factors in conjunction with the possibility of higher
loads than projected due either to unseasonably hot weather
or load growth being higher than forecast and extended
outages to make enhancements to generators related to
environmental regulations, increase the stress levels being
placed on the bulk power transmission system.
Relationship of Alabama Power and the other operating
affiliates of Southern Company with TVA:
Alabama Power is an operating company affiliate of the
Southern Company. Alabama Power and Georgia Power
Company, another of the Operating company affiliates of
Southern Company, have interconnections with TVA that
provide for the exchange of power between these entities and
the other operating affiliates of the Southern Company. The
Southern Company is a holding company located in the
southeastern portion of the Eastern Interconnection that
covers approximately 122,600 square miles of territory. The
2000 summer expected instantaneous control area load is
projected to be in excess of 40,000 MW. The company has a
fleet of generators, a demand side program and intercom-
nections with its neighbors to provide supply assets to meet
this projected demand. The Southern Company is a net
8a
purchaser of energy on its interfaces during the projected
2000 summer season. With the summer weather projected to
be hotter than normal by 2-4 degrees and the projected
rainfall to be 75% of normal, Southern Company will be
relying on the interconnections to provide a portion of its
supply requirements. The reliability of the interconnected
grid would be impacted if for any reason the projected supply
quantities were not available during these peak times due to
unplanned or extended outages of generating units.
TVA is one of the four major interfaces that the Southern
Company will be relying on to supply a portion of its
resources during the summer of 2000. The TVA interface is
made up of 500 kV, 230 kV, 161 kV and 115 kV lines.
Forcing TVA to have unplanned units off line for envir-
onmental repairs and mandating permitting for each and
every instance of replacement of any of thousands of different
power plant components, even before necessary repairs could
be performed to bring a “forced down” unit back into service,
has a significant reliability impact on Alabama Power Com-
pany and the entire Eastern Interconnection. The follow-
ing negative impacts occur on the Eastern Interconnection as
a result of the EPA Order and its requirements that TVA
repair units under a prescribed timeline without sufficient
prior studies of reliability impacts:
e maintenance outages already scheduled would be
extended to facilitate the required enhancements,
e normally scheduled work will not be performed be-
cause of the environmental equipment work and this
will result in increased equivalent forced outage rates,
e new extended maintenance outages would be required
to repair impacted units,
e the units not impacted by this Order would be oper-
ated more to make up for the outage of the other
units and thus may experience an increased forced
outage rate,
WAN Gt ated Pa aaa A
SEE PRENATAL NER EES,
9a
e the inability of TVA to place units back in service
promptly after a forced outage when the “fix” required
to do so would trigger a new source review would
limit the available generating capacity for TVA and
others within the interconnection during a time when
generating capacity is critical , and
e the bulk power pricing and stability impacts, as well
as transmission system strains from modified flow
patterns, will follow from TVA converting from a
Status as a net seller (generating what it needs and
selling surplus) to a net buyer (not having enough
generation to meet its needs, making up the deficiency
with purchases from other utilities. and ceasing to
have any surplus to sell to other utilities)
The resulting effect of any or all of these impacts would be
a less reliable grid within the Eastern Interconnection and an
increased probability there will be major system disturbances
that will cause interruptions or curtailments of electric service
within the interconnection.
Because of the increased probability of system interrup-
tions caused by the EPA Order, prudent system Operation
requires that the impacts must be identified that would
negatively impact the reliability of the Eastern Intercon-
nection, and a plan must be developed to mitigate these
impacts such that the grid remains reliable while the
enhancements are being completed.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true
and correct. Executed by me on the 24th day of July, 2000.
/s/ W. Perry Stowe
W. PERRY STOWE
10a
APPENDIX B
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket Nos. 00-12310-E
and
00-12459-E
(Consolidated under |
Docket No. 12310-E)
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY.
Petitioner.
V.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, and
JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator, UNITED
STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, REGION IV,
Respondents.
DECLARATION OF DR. JOHN H. LANDON
1. | am a Principal and Director of the Energy and
Telecommunications practice of Analysis Group/Economics,
an economic consulting firm. I joined Analysis Group/
Economics in March of 1997. Prior to joining Analysis
Group/Economics, | was employed by National Economic
Research Associates (NERA) from 1977 to 1997 as a Senior
Consultant. Vice President. Senior Vice President, and
member of the Board of Directors. Much of my work over the
last twenty-three years has been on issues relating to the
application of economic principles to the electric utility
industry. I have participated in numerous projects addressing
electric industry economics and related antitrust issues. I have
provided expert testimony related to the electric industry
§ ee det ans
> te Sa welsh
A Pe ae TY OE Ee
Set sha cd et rasta Sis
lla
before the Federal Energy Regulation Commission (FERC).
the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), state
regulatory commissions, and federal and state district courts.
| received a B.A. degree with highest honors from Michigan
State University with a major in economics in 1964. |
subsequently attended graduate school at Cornell University.
where I was awarded an M.A. in economics in 1967 and a
Ph.D. in the same field in 1969. I served on the faculty of
Case Western Reserve University from 1968 to 1973, rising
from the rank of assistant professor to associate professor.
and on the faculty of the University of Delaware from 1973 to
June 1977 as an associate professor. I studied regulatory
economics both as an undergraduate (Michigan State with
Professor Joel Dirlam) and as a graduate student (Cornell
University with Alfred Kahn). I was one of the graduate
assistants who provided research assistance for Professor
Kahn as he wrote his Economics of Regulation. As a faculty
member at Case Western Reserve University and the Uni-
versity of Delaware, | taught regulatory economics and
authored or co-authored several articles and book chapters
focused on economic aspects of the electric utility industry.
2. In my opinion, Alabama Power Company, its affiliates.
and their customers are highly likely to suffer significant
harm and injury upon Tennessee Valley Authority's (TVA)
compliance with the Order issued to TVA by the Envir-
onmental Protection Agency (EPA). Indeed, Alabama Power
Company and its customers are already suffering some harm
caused by the uncertainty created by the EPA Order. In
reaching my opinion I have relied upon the following:
Compliance Order /n the Matter of Tennessee Valley
Authority, United States Environmental Protection
Agency, Region 4, Docket No. CAA-2000-04-0008.
Order [42 U.S.C. §§ 7413 and 7477].
Motion of Petitioner Tennessee Valley Authority for
Stay of Agency Order, Tennessee Valley Authority vy.
12a
United States Environmental Protection Agency. and
John H. Hankinson, Jr., Regional Administrator, United
States Environmental Protection Agency, Region IV, In
the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh
Circuit. Docket Nos. 00-12310-E and 00-12459-E.
Letter to Mr. Joseph R. Bynam, Tennessee Valley
Authority from John H. Hankinson, Jr.. Regional
Administrator. Environmental Protection Agency
regarding In the Matter Of Tennessee Valley Authority,
Docket No. CAA-2000-04-0008, Order Under Sections
113 and 167 of the Clean Air Act.
Declarations of Gary P. Garrett, Jerry L. Golden,
Gregory R. Singer, and Steven C. Struck, Tennessee
Valley Authority v. United States Environmental Pro-
tection Agency, and John H. Hankinson, Jr.. Regional
Administrator, United States Environmental Protection
Agency, Region IV, In_ the United States Court of
Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, Docket Nos. 00-
12310-E and 00-12459-E.
WSCC Preliminary System Disturbance Report Draft,
August 10, 1996, 1548 PAST. Prepared by a WSCC
Investigative Task Force for submittal to the Department
of Energy.
Testimony of Marcie L. Edwards, director of Bulk
Power on behalf of the Los Angeles Department of
Water and Power before the Water Power Resources
Oversight Field Hearing on Issues and ‘Recommenda-
tions concerning the August 10, 1996 Bonneville/
Western U.S. Power Outage. The Honorable John T.
Doolittle, Chairman, November 7, 1996.
Report of the U.S. Department of Energy's Power
Outage Study Team, Findings and Recommendations to
Enhance Reliability from the Summer of 1999, January
2000, Interim Report. (Provided details of individual
outages.)
13a
Report of the U.S. Department of Energy's Power
Outage Study Team. Findings and Recommendations to
Enhance Reliability from the Summer of 1999, March
2000. Final Report.
Results of HEAT WAVE 1999: July 1999 Low
Voltage Condition; Root Cause Analysis, March 21,
2000. Prepared by Root Cause Analysis Review Team,
accepted by PJM Operating Committee.
Staff Report to the Federal Energy Regulatory Com-
mission on the Causes of Wholesale Electric Pricing
Abnormalities in the Midwest during June 1998.
Electricity Prices in a Competitive Environment: Mar-
ginal Cost Pricing of Generation Services and Financial
Status of Electric Utilities. A Preliminary Analysis
Through 2015, August 1997, prepared by the Energy
Information Administration.
Customer Value of Service Reliability Study, March
1, 1999. Submitted by Southern California Edison to
California Public Utilities Commission as required by
Decision (D.) 97-09-092.
A Stochastic Model for the Measurement of Elec-
tricity Outage Costs. by Abraham Grosfeld-Nir and
Asher Thisler, Energy Journal, April 1993, vol. 14,
No. 3.
Various news reports on outages and reliability prob-
lems around the country.
3. It is reasonably certain that the unanticipated, prolonged
withdrawal of TVA generating plants from service to comply
with the order will lead to significant adverse consequences
to Alabama Power Company, its affiliates and their cus-
tomers. Alabama Power Company operates in a geographic
region that is contiguous to TVA. Both entities are members
of the Southeastern Electric Reliability Council (SERC).
l4a
Alabama Power Company is directly interconnected with
TVA: these direct interconnections facilitate direct bulk
power transactions between TVA and Alabama Power
Company and its affiliates. Such bulk power transactions are
vital to the reliability and efficiency of the power grid and
routine in the course of these businesses. In general, the
adverse effects of disruptions to electrical service, includ-
ing decreases in availability of generation resources, are
experienced regionally and are not limited to the owners of
the equipment disrupted. This phenomenon is characteristic
of “networked” systems. One way to understand this is to
look at examples from analogous networked industries with
which people are generally more familiar. The airline
industry offers an example of how unanticipated disruptions
at one location can drastically affect service quality and
reliability elsewhere in the network.
For example. adverse weather conditions in Chicago may
delay or even ground planes at O'Hare airport. The effects of
this service disruption typically will radiate well beyond
service into and out of Chicago. For example. Atlanta-bound
flights from Chicago will be disrupted, which, in turn, affects
outbound service from Atlanta. Flights out of Atlanta may
require equipment that is either grounded in Chicago or is
rerouted to other cities to cover for equipment grounded in
Chicago. Thus, airlines flying through Chicago may cancel or
delay flights originating in Atlanta due to the unavailability of
equipment. Outbound Atlanta passengers must rebook their
air travel, abandon their travel plans or adopt a different mode
of transportation. Frequently, passengers choose to rebook
travel onto other airlines. The rebooking process leads to
delays on alternative airlines’ flights as ground crews
scramble to accommodate as many passengers as possible,
board them, recover and load their baggage, etc. These
disruptions continue to radiate through the airline network as
arrivals at outward bound (from Atlanta) destinations are
cancelled or delayed. Similarly, Atlanta-bound flights from
|
lSa
cities other than Chicago also will be disrupted as a result of
equipment stranded in Chicago, creating another round of
disruptions. Furthermore, Chicago-bound flights that are in
the air at the time of the service disruption will need to land at
alternative airports such as Atlanta, resulting in further delays
and disruptions at the airports receiving the diverted flights.
In a similar way, major disruption on the interconnected
generation and transmission system cause a reaction that
often reverberates hundreds if not thousands of miles away to
affect neighboring utility systems. In contrast to the example
of the airline industry, however, these negative effects are
virtually instantaneous with the original disruption. There is
no time to evade or to mitigate their negative impacts. In
addition to direct costs that may be incurred by Alabama
Power Company, its affiliates, and their customers, increased
reliability risk to them is an inevitable cost that will arise
should TVA’s generating units be withdrawn to comply with
the EPA’s order. TVA’s actions in closing certain of its
generating stations create an increased risk of repercussions
beyond its immediate service area in much the same way that
closure of the Chicago airport creates an increased risk of
delay to Atlanta outbound passengers. The development of
this increased risk is similar to the way that traffic delays at
one location cascade throughout the airline system creating
expense and delay at distant locations. This cost is manifest in
a higher expected value of energy production or of energy
that will not reach customers due to system outages.
4. The regional character of electricity markets and tech-
nologies means that withdrawal of TVA’s generating plants
in order to comply with EPA’s order will have a significant
and immediate adverse effect on Alabama Power Company.
its affiliates, and customers. At a minimum, this effect will
take the form. of increased risk of price spikes and trans-
mission system outages. This risk is costly and harmful. The
cost of the risk can be measured as the cost of hedging it with
l6a
market instruments, of insuring against its effects, or of
keeping generation units operating that would otherwise be
off-line. However, some of the risks cannot be hedged and
others may be uneconomic to hedge. Hedging risk by pur-
chasing options or keeping costly plants online is expensive.
If the risks are not completely hedged, the higher risk is itself
a direct cost to Alabama Power and its customers. Electrical
supply systems are typically designed so that the probability
of customers’ losing electric service does not exceed one day
in ten years. In 1999, Alabama Power sold 67,627,000 MWh
of electricity to native load and other customers. or about
7.720 MW per hour on average. This level of sales equates to
a ten-year system design loss of electric service 185,279
MWh or to a 92,640 MWh toss over the likely five-year
retrofit period. If this exposure increases by only a tenth as a
consequence of the plant outages resulting from TVA’s
compliance with the Order, that is 9.264 MWh. Valued at
$6.00 per kilowatt-hour, this gives an increased cost of $55.6
million for the five years.’ This is the amount that Alabama
Power Company and/or its customers would be willing to pay
to others to avoid the increase in risk. Such hedging mi,ht
include paying to bring back in service mothballed units or
paying other utilities to postpone maintenance. If hedging or
insurance instruments are too expensive, or if there is no
suitable hedging or insurance instrument available. Alabama
Power Company, its affiliates, and their customers will bear
directly the higher expected level of outage costs.
5. At a minimum, withdrawing plants from service has
three regional impacts: 1) prices for power are increased,
2) regional system reliability is decreased, and 3) other
' Six dollars per kilowatt-hour is the midpoint of the range of estimates
of the cost to customers of unserved electricity. See: Southern California
Edison. “Customer Value of Service Reliability Study,” March |, 1999.
Submitted to California Public Utilities Commission as required by
Decision (D.) 97-09-092.
a heleabiine ARR AV IRC Sai eich st aes aa Sic A daa BSR Ne RES:
ptandinaaean fe
SLT Lae retest en te
17a
regional generators are operated and maintained in a less
efficient mannet.
e Spot prices for power usually reflect the costs of the
marginal (most expensive) plant. Prices for power are
increased when efficient, low-cost generating units are
withdrawn because this leads-to utilization of less effic-
ient and more expensive plants to meet regional loads.
In addition, TVA may need to shop for replacement
power in the spot market to meet its obligations. The
resulting increase in demand for power will lead to
further price increases. These price increases will be
driven by the mismatch between resources and demand.
and prices will be determined in a market which will
have decreased supply to meet the same level of
demand. That means higher prices for utilities in the
region and higher rates for their customers.
e System reliability is determined in part by reserve
margins, the amount of “resource cushion” available
under peak conditions. This measure of system reliabil-
ity reflects the vulnerability of the regional system to
disturbances at the time when it is most exposed to risk.
When plants are withdrawn from service for an extended
period of time. system reliability throughout the region
is reduced. This is because regional reserve margins are
reduced. As a result. there is less head-room for dealing
with potential problems because system operators have
less margin for error, leading to an increased likelihood
that demand will exceed generation capacity. Parties
tend to limit their activities to reduce their exposure to
the increase in risk. Commercial transactions that would
otherwise take place are likely to be curtailed or to have
higher costs as sellers charge a risk premium.
In addition to the reserve margin issues, the regional
transmission system requires generation plant support in
Pi
Csi
18a
order to maintain stability. Under peak conditions, when
the transmission system is stressed, generation support
may become critical to ensuring regional system
reliability. Under these conditions, withdrawal of gen-
erating plants from service increases the likelihood of
transmission system operational instability. This effect 1s
exacerbated for summer-peaking utilities since plant
generating capability and transmission capability decline
in hot weather. All of the instances of transmission
system failure in Summer 1999 investigated by the
Department of Energy took place during unusually hot
weather conditions. Several of them were caused by
insufficient generation capacity to support transmission
system operation.”
e Power plant operation and maintenance are planned to
promote the efficiency and reliability of the plants and
the system. Generators have different characteristics.
Some are more efficient when operated at high levels of
output for long periods of time. Others are designed to
be started and stopped frequently but are high-cost to
operate. All units have planned maintenance cycles to
optimize their contributions to the system and reduce the
likelihood of forced outages. Units in the region were
designed and sized in recognition of the other generating
resources in the region. When substantial changes are
made in the down time of several large generators in
a region, all utilities in the region will have to
accommodate the changes. As a result, units will be
operated and maintained in less efficient ways, which
will increase generation and maintenance costs and
degrade generation unit reliability. ~
> Report of the U.S. Department of Energy’s Power Outage Study
Team, Findings and Recommendations to Enhance Reliability from the
Summer of 1999, March 2000.
— ee
19a
6. The impact of price increases arising from the with-
drawal of TVA’s inframarginal units will adversely affect
Alabama Power Company, its affiliates, and their customers
since they will be forced to absorb the effects of any
increased prices for purchased power. This. effect is rea-
sonably certain and substantial since Alabama Power is a net
purchaser of power during the peak period which is when the
price effect will be greatest. Spot prices for electricity are not
set in isolation. The market responds to many pressures.
However, generation plant outages contribute to price move-
ments, and that contribution is amplified by other market
conditions. These are not merely hypothetical constructs.
A number of recent examples illustrate the effect on
spot markets and regional utilities of withdrawal of plants
from service.
e In Aprii 1999, the Number 6 unit at Tampa Electric’s
Gannon Plant exploded, knecking out the entire plant
which supplied about 35 percent of the company’s
generation. Coincident with this event, a number of
generating units in peninsular Florida were out for
planned maintenance, and an early heat wave hit the
state. The combined effect of these events was to drive
up prices; for example, the price for power purchased
from out of state sources by Florida Power and Light
between March and April nearly doubled, from $23.80
to $42.70." ,
e Salem Units | and 2 were withdrawn from service in
the Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland Power Pool”
* “Explosion cuts 35% of Tampa Electric’s output” Megawatt Daily,
April 9, 1999, Vol.4, No. 67.
* Early Heat, Maintenance Outages Drive up Power Prices in Florida
in April,” Southeast Power Report, June 25, 1999, p.9.
* PJM Interconnection, LLC is responsible for the day-to-day operation
of the largest centrally-dispatched electric system in North America. Its
foremost responsibility is the safe and reliable operation of the
20a
(PJM) on May 15 and June 8, 1995, respectively. This
removed about 2.200 megawatts (MW) of capacity from
service for a period of several months. Plant owners
primarily purchased replacement power, which led
observers to comment that “the loss of Salem for several
months will be ‘hurtful’ to the pool.”® However, the
regional effects of the extended outage were most
pronounced during a subsequent heat wave in which
insufficient generating capacity led to pressure on
electricity prices. PJM utilities ran thermal units at
maximum generation levels as well as peaking units at a
cost of $60 per megawatt-hour’ for gas-fired and
$90/MWh for oil-fired plants.” This compares with a
variable cost of generation of $15-$20/MWh for coal
plants in PJM.’ According to press reports: “For two
days. some PJM _ utilities were close to maximum
emergency generation levels and ‘prices didn’t matter’
as long as the power could be secured, a source said.”"'°
PJM system lambda in the peak hours during June
transmission system and ensuring the reliable supply of energy from
generating resources to wholesale customers. In addition. PJM operates
the competitive wholesale energy market for the region and facilitates
open access to transmission. (Source: www.pjm.com).
© “Midwest. PJM Prices Ride Heat Wave; PSE&G’s Units Down for
Months.” Power Markets Week, June 26, 1995.
” One megawatt-hour is equal to one million watts drawn for a period
of one hour. It is equivalent to the amount of energy required to light
10.000 light bulbs of 100 kilowatts for an hour.
8 “«Mfidwest. PJM Prices Ride Heat Wave; PSE&G’s Units Down for
Months.” Power Markets Week, June 26, 1995.
” Based on 1995 variable costs of generation for Homer City Units 1, 2.
and 3, Seward and Warren plants.
'0 “Midwest. PJM Prices Ride Heat Wave; PSE&G’s Units Down for
Months.” Power Markers Week, June 26, 1995.
2la
through August 1995, increased by 7.4 percent com-
pared with peak system lambda for the same period in
1994,"
e Regional exposure to risk of high prices due to gen-
eration outages is further demonstrated by the unpre-
cedented price spikes experienced in the Midwest in
Summer 1998. The Federal Energy Regulatory Com-
mission Staff that studied the underlying eauses of these
extraordinary price levels found that they were due to a
combination of factors. The first of these was that “An
above average amount of generating capacity was not
available in the midwestem United States due to planned
and unplanned outages. '° (emphasis added)
e Elsewhere, withdrawal of generating plants from
service has led to reactivation of expensive, mothballed
plants in order to ensure sufficient generating capacity.
This will lead to higher prices for electricity. For
example, in 1997 the Philadelphia Inquirer reported on
reactivation of four 50-year-old mothballed plants in
order to supply power as needed in the wake of the
shutdown of four out of the nine nuclear facilities in the
region.
7. Increased vulnerability of the transmission system also
results when generation plant is removed from service. This
can lead to disruptions and outages that impose significant
'' System lambda is the variable cost of the last unit from the dispatch
order that is in service. Analysis is based on comparison of system lambda
as reported on FERC Form 714 in the most expensive 390 hours in June
through August of each year.
'? Staff Report to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on the
Causes of Wholesale Electric Pricing Abnormalities in the Midwest dur-
ing June 1998. Executive Summary, page v.
'’ McNeill Rates Nuclear Power a Top Competitive Asset, Peco Takes
Contrarian Energy View, Philadelphia Inquirer. July 20, 1997.
2a
costs and hardship. Because the transmission system is so
complex and interconnected, transmission outages which are
triggered by localized problems can have very expensive, far-
reaching effects. A number of recent examples illustrate the
far-reaching effects of transmission failures due in part to
inadequate generation support.
e On August 10, 1996, an event triggered by contact
between a tree and a Bonneville Power Administration
transmission line near Portland, Oregon cascaded
throughout the Pacific Intertie and tripped off generators
as far away as Arizona. The resulting power outages
interrupted “. . . service to 7.5 million customers for
periods ranging from several minutes to nearly six
hours.”'* Hearings were held in the House of Repre-
sentatives, and the Western Systems Coordinating
Council (WSCC) conducted an in-depth investigation of
the disturbance. While there are several, inter-related
reasons for the extent of the damage. one of the
contributing factors was that generating plant in the
Northwest was out of service for environmental reasons
and unavailable to supply voltage support when required
to stabilize the transmission system.
e The Secretary of Energy appointed a panel of experts,
the Power Outage Study Team (POST), to investigate
some of the widespread power outages of the summer of
1999. The POST thoroughly studied eight major outages
and disturbances. In the majority of cases, generation
deficiencies played a role in the outages, either because
there was simply insufficient capacity to meet load or
because there was insufficiént generation support for
transmission service.
'' WSCC Preliminary System Disturbance Report, August 10, 1996.
Page 2.
ah hm Goleta nt i Nit Delta tetas parks Qiariek
S CAO LN Rete eA, tet bea BLS Rt Rr a aa
23a
e One finding of the POST was that some members of
SERC rely on the economy energy market to supply
reliability to more than the usual degree. This
circumstance led to rolling power outages in Entergy’s
service territory during 1999, resulting in over 550,000
of Entergy customers’ losing power. Withdrawal of
generating plant within the reliability region over
extended periods likely will exacerbate this situation
with adverse implications for Alabama Power Company
and other utilities in the region.
The costs of widespread outages are very high. The cost of
a particular outage will vary with many factors such as timing
(day of week, time of day, etc.), weather conditions and so
on. Because the cost of outages is an important factor in
system planning, estimates are used to evaluate system outage
costs. As previously noted, the midpoint of these estimates is
about $6.00 per kilowatt-hour. The outage costs in many
instances are much greater. Electronics firms, for example,
can have outage costs at least as high as $20 per kilowatt-
hour.'* An example illustrates potential outage cost exposure
to Alabama Power, its affiliates, and customers. Alabama
Power's summer peak in 1998 was 10,329 megawatts (MW):
in 1999 the peak was 10,739 MW. Based upon the $6.00
estimate of outage costs, a system wide outage of 10 per-
cent of demand during peak hours'® would cost around
$18,000,000.'’ In fact. the cost of such an outage would
likely be much higher since the cost per kilowatt-hour of
'° 4 Stochastic Model for the Measurement of Electricity Outage Costs
by Abraham Grosfeld-Nir and Asher Tishler, Energy Journal, April 1993,
Vol. 14, No 2, page 157.
'° System peak is the time period most likely to experience outages that
are due to insufficient generation capacity. For example, all of the outages
studied in the POST report occurred under peak load conditions.
I
” Based on average hourly peak demand of 10,000 MW for three
hours.
_——
24a
outages during peak is higher than $6.00. Should TVA
withdraw plants from service to comply with EPA’s order,
the risk of outages will rise.
| declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true
and correct. Executed by me on this 12th day of July 2000.
/s/ John H. Landon, Ph.D.
JOHN H. LANDON
Principal
July 12, 2000
Ad ten WTP a 5 1
25a
APPENDIX C
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket No. 00-12310-E, and
Docket No. 00-12459-E
(Consolidated under lead
Docket No. 00-12310-E)
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY,
Petitioner,
Ne
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,
and JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator,
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
REGION IV,
Respondents.
DECLARATION OF GARY H. LITTLE
1. My name is Gary H. Little and I have been employed by
the Southern Company Services, Inc. since 1974. I have a
broad professional background with regard to electric system
transmission, generation and markets. Included in this experi-
ence is 15 years in high voltage transmission planning,
including managing the group responsible for assessing the
adequacy of transmission interconnections with neighboring
utilities. | have served as chairman of multiple joint utility
transmission reliability and interconnections study groups,
with representatives from most of the electric utilities in the
Southeast United States. I also have 11 years of experience in
generation and system reliability planning where I was re-
sponsible for determining the appropriate generation reserve
levels and forecasting the required generation expansion to
26a
meet future customer needs. | am currently employed as
Manager. Market Planning at Southern Company Services.
The Market Planning organization serves as a consultant to
Alabama Power Company (“APC”), as well as the other
operating companies of the Southern Company, on matters
concerning wholesale market conditions. I received a
Bachelor of Science in Engineering from the University of
Alabama Birmingham in 1979. I have read the EPA Order
against TVA as well as the declarations filed by TVA
in this matter. | have personal knowledge of the facts
stated herein.
2. APC and its affiliates each own and operate their own
fleet of electric generation power plants to serve the electric
needs of their customers reliably and at the least cost
possible. These plants generate electricity with a diverse
number of fuels and have differing cost structures and
operating characteristics. Some of these plants are nuclear
plants, that run around the clock, while some are fueled by
more expensive fuels. such as oil, and are only run for short
periods during peak demand. Other plants in APC’s fleet
are fueled by coal or natural gas and therefore run after
the nuclear plants but before the oil units. Hydro plants have
no traditional fuel cost, but have limited generation availabil-
ity due to water limitations and are thus run mostly during
peak times.
3. Asa general rule, electricity can not be easily or cost
effectively stored. It must be generated at the instant that
customers demand it, otherwise customers will be discon-
nected. The demand for electricity varies greatly from one
season to the next as well as between different days and
hours. These patterns are based on numerous factors such as
temperature and business needs. Therefore, to minimize cost
and maximize efficiency. utilities (including APC) use their
ieast expensive generation first and then use additional power
plants in order of increasing cost, until the current demand is
hk er ee
27a
met. When power is available from neighboring utilities at a
cost less than the cost of the next unit to be started, a
purchase will be made that will lower the average cost to
customers. (This kind of transaction is often referred to in the
electricity industry as “economy” or “opportunity” transac-
tion.) When a utility runs out of generation due to extreme
weather or significant planned or forced outages, purchases
can and will be made from neighboring utilities, if available.
rather than disconnecting customers. (These purchases are
often referred to as “emergency” or “reliability” transactions.)
For APC to realize these efficiency and reliability benefits,
interconnected power systems, including TVA, must have
generation in excess of its load available for supply to other
power systems.
4. The electric power systems of TVA and APC have been
interconnected for decades. These transmission interconnec-
tions have allowed for the routine exchange of power
between the companies for economic and reliability benefits.
There are currently a total of six major interconnections
between TVA and APC, consisting of: two interconnections
operated at 500,000 volts; three interconnections operated at
161,000 volts; and one interconnection operated at 115,000
volts. There also are three additional interconnections be-
tween TVA and Georgia Power Company. All of these
interconnections collectively are referred to as the “TVA
Interface.” The available emergency power that it delivers is
critical to the operations and reliability of APC. The
interconnected operations between TVA and APC (and it and
its affiliates) are governed by the terms of an Interconnection
Agreement, which is on file with the Federal Energy Regula-
tory Commission.
5. Due to the highly interconnected and integrated nature
of the power system network within the Southeastern United
States, coordination between APC and TVA is essential to
ensure reliable operations. To facilitate coordinated opera-
28a
tions, planning and reliability activities TVA and APC are
both members of the Southeastern Electric Reliability Coun-
cil ("SERC”). The stated purpose of SERC is to augment the
reliability of the bulk power supply in the areas served by its
member systems. This is best accomplished by promoting
maximum coordination of planning, construction and utili-
zation of generation and transmission facilities involved in
the interconnected operations..The general guidelines imple-
mented by SERC call for assessments of future. resource
adequacy which include: (i) availability and performance of
all resources (including generation); and (ii) any environ-
mental or regulatory limitations. SERC engages in these
resource assessments due to the acknowledged reliability
relationship between neighboring utilities.
6. APC (together with its affiliates) has retained Southern
Company Services to advise and consult in the development
of joint resource plans and reliability guidelines. APC
and its affiliates’ internal generation reliability planning is
based, among other things, on expected economy and emer-
gency power purchases from TVA. These purchases are
counted on to avoid potential outages and available due to the
fact that there are differences in the timing of peak conditions
and unit failures among neighboring utilities. If TVA’s
planned available generation levels were decreased, APC
would be required to have a higher level of generation
reserves (additional power plants) to maintain an adequate
level of system reliability. APC’s expected ability to purchase
power from and through TVA will be impacted adversely in
two ways when TVA is unable to operate (or operate on a
lower producing basis) some of its power plants due to EPA s
order. First, TVA will be unable to provide APC and its
affiliates with the emergency purchases they have planned on
from TVA. Second, there will be a greater need for TVA to
acquire capacity for its own needs with short notice in the
regional market. This will cause a shortage of capacity in the
region, impacting the availability and pricing of APC pur-
i
j
4
29a
chases from other power generating organizations. This
impacts both the economics and reliability of APC’s
power operation.
7. As a result of APC’s reliability planning and depend-
ence on the emergency purchases, a required transmission
reservation called the “Capacity Benefit Margin” (“CBM”)
for each transmission interface with neighboring utilities has
been determined. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commis-
sion has defined CBM as follows:
That amount of transmission transfer capability reserved
by load serving entities to ensure access to generation
from interconnected systems to meet generation reliabil-
ity requirements. Reservation of CBM by a load serving
entity allows that entity to reduce its installed generating
capacity below that which may otherwise have been
necessary without interconnections to meet its genera-
tion reliability requirements. Capacity Benefit Margin in
Computing Available Transmission Capacity, 88 FERC
{ 61,099 (1999).
The CBM for the TVA Interface is 450 MW. This amount of
interface capability has been reserved on an ongoing basis to
ensure that emergency purchases can be delivered to APC
and its affiliates from TVA when required to maintain system
reliability. Since EPA’s order causes TVA to change its
operational and maintenance practices and discourages or
prohibits the real time repla:ement of failed major compo-
nents, there is a material incre» 2 in the present risk that TVA
will not be able to provide the power contemplated in and
planned for in the CBM.
8. In today’s de-regulated wholesale electricity market the
level of available generation in the region has a significant
influence on the price of power in the daily market. This
influence has become greater in recent years due to
significant load growth in the Southeast while new generation
additions have been less that this load growth. This reduction
30a
in generation reserves has led to progressively higher market
prices over the last three years. The EPA order requires TVA
to remove much more generation for maintenance associated
with retrofits than has been projected, and imposes regulatory
requirements that will apair TVA’s ability to return units to
service that have been forced down due to capital component
failure. The critical supply/demand balance upon which
current pricing and resource assumptions are based will be
upset. The loss of TVA generation resources from the market
will result in higher market prices for electricity. Even more
significant will be the high prices associated with major
generation failures during peak load periods when the neces-
sary repairs cannot be performed due to permitting concerns
and restrictions. These losses of TVA resources from the
market will cause higher wholesale power prices which will
inevitably result in higher retail prices and the cost the public
pays for power.
9. To illustrate the historical utilization of TVA generation
for energy savings and reliability, the following table shows
the growing annual purchases from TVA by APC and its
affiliates for over the last three years. The KHW column
shows the actual kilowatt-hours purchases from TVA for
each year. The actual hourly purchases vary greatly, but to
illustrate the magnitude and importance of these purchases
the “equivalent homes served” column shows the number of
APC customer homes whose needs could be served for an
entire year by this energy:
Year | kWh Purchased Equivalent
homes served
1997 302,534,000 27,012
1998 493,796,000 44.089
1999 774,938,000 69,191
3la
10. In addition to APC’s dependence on TVA for spot
generation purchases, APC and its affiliates have made long
term purchases from TVA and its northern neighbors as a part
of their generation resource planning. APC (jointly with its
affiliates) are currently purchasing about 700 MW of firm
contract power across the TVA interface for the summer of
2000. This accounts for about half of the planned imports
during this time period. Of the 700 MW, 200 MW is directly
from the TVA system. Reduced reliability and availability of
TVA’s plants would have significant reliability implications
for APC since this purchase is a part of its planned internal
generation reserves. For the summer of 2001, APC and its
affiliates will be purchasing about 800-1000 MW of firm
contract power to meet their internal reserve margin guide-
lines, of which about 400-500 MW is expected to flow
across the TVA interface. Any significant reduction in TVA
system availability (such as the prolonged loss of just one of
its Cumberland units) will cause TVA to import more power
and frustrate APC’s ability to utilize TVA and the northern
power markets for firm contract power. By potentially
eliminating or reducing the northern power market, APC
will incur economic harm with fewer suppliers to buy from in
the marketplace.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true
and correct. Executed by me on the 14th day of July. 2000.
/s/ Gary H. Little
GARY H. LITTLE
32a
APPENDIX D
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket No. 00-12310-E and
Docket No. 00-12459-E
(Consolidated under lead
Docket No. 00-12310-E)
ALABAMA POWER COMPANY, and
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION,
Petitioners,
Vv.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, and
JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator, UNITED
STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, REGION IV
Respondents.
DECLARATION OF WILLIAM F. REINKE
I. William F. Reinke, having been duly sworn, depose and
— say as follows:
1. For the past 10 years, I have resided in Denver, North
Carolina which is in Lincoln County. I am over 18 years of
age, and give this affidavit based on my personal knowledge.
2. I have a Bachelor of Science degree and a Master of
Science degree in Electrical Engineering from the University
of Wisconsin. I also received a Master of Management degree
from the University of North Carolina at Charlotte. | am also
a registered Professional Engineer in both North Carolina and
South Carolina.
3. I have worked for Duke Energy Corporation (“Duke
Energy”). the Petitioner in the above-captioned case, for
33a
approximately thirty-six (36) years. | joined Duke Power in
1964 as an Assistant Engineer in System Planning Depart-
ment. I progressed through a number of assignments in
System Planning and was named Manager of Production and
Transmission Planning in 1977. I was named as the Manager
of System Planning in 1984; Vice President of System
Planning in 1990; and Vice President of System Planning and
Operating in 1991. In 1997, I was appointed Vice President,
System Marketing, Planning and Operating.
4. | am the past chairman of the Virginia-Carolinas Reli-
ability Agreement Executive Committee and the North
American Electric Reliability Council (NERC) Reliability
Assessment Subcommittee. I served on the NERC Board of
Trustees and am a past chairman of the Southeastern Electric
Reliability Council (SERC) Board of Directors and the SERC
Engineering Committee. | am a member of the Institute of
Electrical and Electronic Engineers and a U. S. Represen-
tative on the International Conference on Large High Voltage
Electric Systems Study Committee 37-Power System Plan-
ning and Development.
5. In November 1999 I was named Vice President of Grid
Operations. In this position I am responsible for overseeing
the operation of the Duke bulk power system which includes
more than 12,000 miles of transmission lines and more than
19,000 MW of generating capacity consisting of three nuclear
stations, nine coal and gas fired stations and 30 hydro electric
and pumped storage facilities.
6. Reliability organizations such as NERC and SERC were
formed to promote the adequacy and reliability of the North
American bulk power grid. Although membership in these
organizations is voluntary, all systems in North America
follow the Policies, Procedures, and Guides established by
NERC and the Regional Councils.
34a
7. Duke Power operates in a geographic region in the
Southeast that is contiguous to TVA. Both entities are
members of SERC and are interconnected with high voltage
transmission facilities. Systems developed high voltage
interconnections primarily to enhance overall network reli-
ability. These interconnections facilitate the exchange of
power during emergency conditions.
8. Electricity flows across this interconnected grid without
respect to assigned geographic service areas. A consequence
of such interconnections is that service disruptions in one area
can have a profound impact on other systems in the region. In
some cases these impacts could extend well beyond regional
boundaries. These effects would be not unlike an interruption
in other critical infrastructure facilities such as pipelines,
railroads, or interstate highways.
9. Licensing, permitting, and construction times for bulk
power facilities will vary but typically are about three years
for gas fired combustion turbines and up to ten years or more
for major transmission facilities. Unexpected and unantic-
ipated unavailability of generating facilities immediately
affects supply adequacy and is likely to affect the reliability
of the interconnected grid. Because of lead-times associated
with replacement facilities and network enhancements these
effects cannot be immediately resolved.
10. I have reviewed the Administrated Compliance Order
(“Order”) that the United States Environmental Protection
Agency (“EPA”) issued to. TVA. The Order establishes a
process whereby EPA will set a schedule for the temporary or
permanent shut down of most of TVA’s coal-fired power
plants. EPA has identified specifically 14 TVA units at which
allegedly illegal modifications triggering New Source Review
(NSR) controls occurred. In addition, TVA is required under
the Order to audit all its units to determine if projects similar
to the allegedly illegal projects identified in the Order
occurred at the rest-of TVA’s units. Thus, at least 14, and
35a
possibly all of TVA’s units face either temporary or
permanent shutdown. Where TVA chooses to install pollution
control equipment the shutdown would be temporary. In
some instances TVA may choose to retire a unit rather than to
install expensive control equipment. But even a temporary
shutdown can extend for twelve weeks or more, and the type
of equipment needed to achieve the stringent Best Available
Control Technology/Lowest Achievable Emission Rate
(BACT/LAER) requirements that EPA requires are likely to
require lengthy outages or shutdowns.
11. Based on my past experience in this industry, I believe
that there is a strong possibility that if Tennessee Valley
Authority (“TVA”) is forced to comply with the Order issued
to TVA by the Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”), it
is likely that some TVA generating plants may be withdrawn
from service.
12. If. in the course of complying with the Order, TVA
generating plants are withdrawn from service for a prolonged
period and without sufficient lead-time it is reasonably
certain that adequacy and reliability of power supply in the
Southeast will be adversely affected. This is because there
will be insufficient time to plan, permit, and construct
replacement facilities. These adequacy and reliability issues
directly and negatively affect Duke Energy, its affiliates, and
its customers.
13. EPA’s Order does not set a specific deadline for TVA
to complete controlling its units to (BACT/LAER) levels.
Rather the Order requires TVA to propose a schedule to EPA
for approval. The length of the schedule is critical to
mitigating the adverse impacts discussed above, however. an
unrealistically short schedule would present significant risks
and consequences. Thus, the Order's impact on Duke's
system reliability is directly related to the schedule that EPA
ultimately approves.
36a
14. System adequacy is determined in part by capacity
"margins. Capacity margins are maintained to accommodate
unexpected events such as prolonged hot or cold spells
(forecast uncertainty) as well as lower than average avail-
ability of generating facilities. When plants are withdrawn
from service for an extended period of time supply adequacy
in the region is affected because regional capacity margins
are reduced. This. in turn, will affect traditional flow patterns
on the transmission systems. As a result operating margins
are reduced leaving operators with fewer options as they
manage the day-to-day operation of the grid. Operation of
generating and transmission facilities are interdependent.
Generating facilities provide voltage support for the grid
which is critical for system reliability. Absence of this
voltage support will result in lower overall system voltage
negatively affecting customer service. Low voltage con-
ditions are commonly referred to as brownouts. Such
conditions are more common during hot weather periods.
15. In addition to the risk posed by TVA outages arising
from efforts to comply with EPA*s Order and whatever
schedule is imposed, power plants all across the SERC region
are expected to undertake numerous outages of long duration
from 2000 to 2003 to comply with EPA’s NOx SIP Call Rule,
which requires significant reductions of NOx emissions by
May 1. 2003. TVA is the largest utility in the nation, and
adding numerous TVA units to the list of those that will have
to undergo outages during this same time frame can only
exacerbate reliability risks. This can lead to disruptions and
outages that impose significant costs and hardship. Because
the transmission system is so complex and interconnected,
transmission outages which are triggered by localized prob-
lems can have far-reaching effects.
16. Withdrawal of generation plants within the region over
extended periods likely will have adverse implications for
Duke Power Company. other utilities in the region and their
37a
customers. Should systems be required to ration energy as a
result of plant unavailability the effect is expected to ripple
throughout the regional economy.
17. Any adverse ruling against TVA and any requirement
to comply with the existing EPA Order will affect the
reliability of the SERC Region due to the possible permanent
shutdown of capacity and/or unanticipated maintenance
outages needed to install additional environmental controls on
TVA units. In addition, for the reasons discussed above, an
unreasonably short shut down schedule imposed by EPA will
have substantial and direct impacts on power flows adversely
affecting Duke’s generation and transmission system.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NOT.
/s/ William F. Reinke
WILLIAM F. REINKE
Sworn to and subscribed before me,
this 21st day of July, 2000.
/s/ Nancy H. Taylor
NANCY H. TAYLOR
Notary Public
My commission expires: January 26, 2002 [seal]
38a
APPENDIX E
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket No. 00-12349-E
TENNESSEE VALLEY PUBLIC
POWER ASSOCIATION,
Petitioner,
¥.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, and
JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator, UNITED
STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, REGION IV,
Respondents.
AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL MCDOWELL
STATE OF TENNESSEE:
COUNTY OF HAMILTON:
Comes the Affiant. being duly sworn, deposes as says as
follows:
1. My name is Mike McDowell. I am over 18 years of age
and have personal knowledge of all matters set forth herein.
2. I am the Executive Director and Chief Custodian of
Records of the Tennessee Valley Public Power Association
(“TVPPA”). TVPPA, a Tennessee non-profit corporation,
represents the interests of the 110 municipal and 50 rural
electric cooperative distributors of electrical power listed on
Attachment 1. All but one of these municipal and cooperative
electrical systems distribute and sell power purchased from
TVA to the residents and businesses of the TVA area. This
area includes almost all of Tennessee and parts of Alabama,
39a
Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, and Vir-
ginia, and contains a population of nearly 8,000,000.
3. TVPPA represents the interests of its members in a
wide range of activities relating to TVA. For example, several
TVPPA Committees (comprised of TVPPA member system
representatives) operate under the direction of the TVPPA
Board of Directors, including (a) TVPPA’s Rates and
Contracts Committee. which handles matters relating to the
terms, conditions and rates of the power supply contracts
between TVPPA member systems and TVA: (b) TVPPA’s
Power Supply Planning Committee, which handles matters
relating to short term and long term power supply issues with
TVA; and (3) TVPPA’s Governmental Relations Committee,
which handles matters relating to state and federal legislation
impacting TVA and TVPPA member systems. TVPPA is
actively involved in other matters relating to TVA as well.
These Petitions for Review are germane to and consistent
with the long-standing involvement of TVPPA in repre-
senting its members in matters relating to TVA.
4. One hundred fifty-nine (159) TVPPA member systems
have entered into long term wholesale power supply contracts
with TVA that require each system to purchase all of its
requirements of energy and capacity from TVA, with the
remaining one member being eligible to purchase wholesale
power from TVA but not doing so presently. Copies of the
wholesale power contract entered into by TVA with TVPPA
members Memphis Light, Gas & Water. Joe Wheeler Electric
Membership Corporation, and the Metropolitan Government
of Nashville and Davidson County are attached as Attachment
2 to my Affidavit. The wholesale power contracts of
other TVPPA are substantially similar to those included in
Exhibit 2. While TVA has recently given TVPPA member
systems a limited opportunity to arrange for the purchase of
small blocks of power from sources other than TVA for
transmission into the TVA system, to date no purchases have
40a
been made under that program. During the latest TVA fiscal
year, TVPPA members purchased one hundred percent
(100%) of their electric energy requirements from TVA,
representing approximately eighty-three percent (83%) of the
electric energy produced by TVA. TVA’s remaining output
of electric energy is purchased by very large industrial
customers directly served by TVA, by federal agencies, and
by others located in the same service area as TVPPA mem-
bers and which have a major impact upon the economy and
welfare of the region served by TVA and TVPPA members.
5. Under these long-term all-requirements contracts, TVA
has the right to adjust or change wholesale and retail rates
during the term of the contract in order to assure TVA’s
ability to-continue to supply the power requirements of the
TVPPA member systems and TVA’s other customers on a
financially sound basis, including the objective that power
shall be sold at rates as low as feasible. As a result, TVPPA
member systems and the customers that they serve are
ultimately responsible for paying for most of the increases
in TVA’s costs resulting from TVA’s compliance with the
EPA Order.
6. One Hundred Nine (109) members of TVPPA are
municipal governments in Tennessee, Kentucky, Alabama,
Mississippi, Georgia, and North Carolina that buy energy and
capacity from TVA. These municipal governments rely upon
the availability of low-cost electricity purchased at wholesale
from TVA to assist them in economic development efforts
and will suffer an economic disadvantage compared to other
communities if TVA complies with the EPA Order and
TVA’s power costs are increased. Businesses, particularly
small businesses, farmers, residential ratepayers, and munic-
ipalities that receive their electric service from TVPPA
member systems organized and operating as rural electric
cooperatives also will be substantially and adversely affected
by compliance with the EPA Order.
4la
7. TVPPA requested information from TVA relating to the
financial impact of compliance with the EPA Order and was
furnished a copy of the report submitted by TVA to various
members of Congress which is attached as Attachment 3 to
my Affidavit.
/s/ Michael McDowell
MICHAEL MCDOWELL
STATE OF TENNESSEE:
COUNTY OF HAMILTON:
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 24th day July.
2000.
WITNESS my hand and notarial seal at my office in
Chattanooga, Tennessee, this day of July, 2000.
/s/ [Illegible]
Notary Public
My commission expires: 3/7/01
42a
APPENDIX F
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket No. 00-12310-E
and
Docket No. 00-12459-E
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY.
Petitioner,
Vv.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY. and
JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator, UNITED
STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, REGION IV,
Respondents.
DECLARATION OF GARY P. GARRETT
1. | have been employed by the Tennessee Valley
Authority (TVA) since 1974. I currently hold the position of
Project Manager, Transmission Resources, in TVA’s Power
Resources & Operations Planning organization, which is the
TVA organization responsible for identifying current and
future demand for electricity on the TVA power system and
planning how to meet that demand. I received a Bachelor of
Science degree and a Master of Science degree in Electrical
Engineering from the University of Texas at Arlington in
1972 and 1974, respectively. I have personal knowledge of
the matters stated herein.
2. TVA operates the Nation's largest integrated electric
power system, serving approximately eight million people in
parts of seven southeastern states. TVA’s integrated power
system consists of 5 nuclear generating units, 11 coal-fired
power plants with 59 units, 29 hydroelectric dams, 48
43a
combustion turbines. and 1 pumped storage facility. The
dependable capacity of all of these generating units is 28,502
megawatts. The system is linked by more than 16.000 miles
of high-voltage transmission lines.
3. The TVA system is interconnected to 12 neighboring
power systems, including Alabama Power. Georgia Power.
and Duke Power. These interconnections allow TVA to send
and receive electricity to and from the neighboring systems.
The neighboring systems are. in turn, connected to other
power systems. Collectively, all of the Nation's power
systems constitute the national electrical grid. The inter-
connected power systems east of the Rocky Mountains,
exclusive of systems in Texas, are referred to as the “Eastern
Interconnect.”
4. For many years, TVA’s interconnections with other
power systems and the routine exchange of electricity among
power systems have enhanced the ability of all systems to
meet the public’s demand for electricity in a reliable manner.
Because neighboring systems frequently have peak demands
at differing times. electric energy generated on one system
can be transmitted to another system to help that system meet
its demands.
5. On the TVA system and in the Eastern Interconnect.
demand has caught up with the generating capabilities of the
systems. On some systems, demand has exceeded the
systems’ generating capacity. While the Eastern Interconnect
is roughly in a state of balance, demand during critical
periods has exceeded the available capacity of individual
systems, especially during the summers of 1998 and 1999.
6. Because of excessive demand, some systems had to
curtail service at various times during the last two summers.
TVA-generated power helped to limit the extent of some
curtailments and service disruptions.
44a
7. Because of such excessive demand, it is extremely
important that TVA‘s generating units be able to perform
reliably. The loss of generating units due to additional
equipment breakdown or deterioration would jeopardize
» TVA’s ability to meet the demands on its system and to assist
other systems in meeting their demands, and has the potential
of leading to brownouts and rolling blackouts, especially
during the summer months.
8. In light of the potential impacts of the Environmental
Protection Agency's enforcement initiative on the reliability
of generating resources in its member utilities, including
TVA, Alabama Power, and Georgia Power, the Southeastern
Electric Reliability Council (SERC) has requested review of
this issue through its Reliability Review Subcommittee.
SERC is a part of the North American Reliability Courcil
(NERC). NERC and SERC are not-for-profit organizations
that are responsible for promoting the reliability of the
electric supply in North America or their sub-regions.
9. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746 (1994), I declare under
penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this 15th day of May, 2000.
/s/ Gary P. Garett
GARY P. GARRETT
45a
APPENDIX G
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket No. 00-12310-E
and
Docket No. 00-12459-F
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY,
Petitioner,
v4
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
and JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
REGION IV,
Respondents.
DECLARATION OF JERRY L. GOLEIN
1. I have been employed by the Tennessee Valley Author-
ity (TVA) for 27 years. I currently hold the position of
Manager, Production Technology, in TVA’s Fossil Power
Group. My current and past duties and responsibilities in-
clude, among other things, evaluation and recommendation of
strategies and technologies for emissions reductions and new
generation projects and maintenance-project related work. At
various times I have served as TVA’s Head Mechanical
Engineer, Fossil Steam Generation and Equipment; Manager,
Advanced Production and Environmental Technology:
Manager, Clean Air Program and Generation Technology:
and Manager, Fossil Engineering. I have served on the Acid
Rain Advisory Committee of the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA), and I have chaired the Base Programs
Analysis and Policies Work Group of EPA’s Clean Air Act
46a
Advisory Committee. | have read EPA*s Compliance Order
(order), as amended, which is the subject of this proceeding.
and | have personal knowledge of the matters stated herein.
2. TVA operates the Nation’s largest integrated electric
power system, serving approximately eight million people in
parts of seven southeastern states. TVA’s integrated power
system includes 11 coal-fired power plants with 59 units.
TVA must perform necessary maintenance on these units to
assure a reliable supply of electricity.
3. Between February | and June 1, 2000, TVA scheduled
23 of its 59 coal-fired units for maintenance so that needed
electric power will be available during the upcoming high-
demand summer season. The maintenance activities sched-
uled for 7 of these 23 units include projects similar to projects
that have been included in either the EPA order or the EPA
complaints against other electricity generating units (e.g..
superheater elements, reheater). An additional 4 of these 23
units have maintenance activities scheduled that could be
included in future EPA enforcement actions based on EPA’s
theory of routine maintenance, although EPA has not yet
specifically identified them in the order or other complaints.
Similarly, the maintenance activities at 5 of the 17 units
scheduled for maintenance between September 1. 2000, and
January 1, 2001. include projects that are similar to the
projects identified in EPA’s order or its complaints against
others. Four more units in this time period are potentially
subject to future EPA enforcement actions based on EPA’s
theory, but have not yet been specifically identified by EPA.
The units referred to above are:
FEBRUARY | to JUNE 1, 2000
TVA Unit Unit Size
John Sevier 3 200 MW
Johnsonville 3 125 MW
Kingston 3 175 MW
Kingston 5 200 MW
Kingston 6 200 MW
Paradise 3 1.150 MW
Shawnee | 175 MW
Gallatin | 300 MW
Kingston 4 175 MW
Shawnee 2 175 MW
Widows Creek | 140 MW
SEPTEMBER | to JANUARY 1, 2000
TVA Unit Unit Size
Allen 3 330 MW
Colbert 2 200 MW
Gallatin 3 327 MW
Paradise | 704 MW
Widows Creek 4 140 MW
Johnsonville 9 172 MW
Kingston | 175 MW
Kingston 2 175 MW
Shawnee 6
175 MW
48a
These projects are typical of the kind of projects that TVA
routinely undertakes during its spring and fall outage seasons.
If TVA had to obtain permits in advance of these or other
scheduled maintenance activities, the scheduled work might
have to be postponed since it can take a year or more to
obtain a single permit. This kind of delay in carrying out
needed maintenance projects would jeopardize the reliability
of the TVA system and its service to the public.
4. In addition to scheduled maintenance outages, there can
be “forced” outages when an element of a component or
entire component suddenly fails. forcing TVA to shut down
the entire generating unit. Based on TVA’s historical experi-
ence, such forced outages can include elements or compo-
nents that are similar to the elements or components EPA has
identified in its order to TVA or in the complaints filed
against other utilities. In such outage situations, TVA‘s
routine practice has been to repair or replace the failed
element or component as quickly as possible taking into
account the availability of other generation and the demand
on the TVA system for electricity. However, EPA’s current
position, as the order shows, is that permits must be obtained
before conducting many types of maintenance activities. If
TVA were required to obtain permits before conducting
maintenance activities during forced outages and before
returning these units to service, needed generating capability
would be unavailable for an extended period, since, as noted
above, it can take a year or more to obtain a single permit.
5. As an alternative to applying for permits, TVA could
seek a formal determination from EPA as to whether a
specific maintenance project requires a new source permit
before proceeding with the project (an “applicability deter-
mination” under EPA’s regulations). However, such determi-
nations can take months or longer to obtain. For example.
Detroit Edison sought an applicability determination from
EPA in June 1999 for a proposed project to replace deterio-
49a
rated turbine blades and has yet to receive it. The needed
maintenance could not be performed during this period
of delay. Moreover, if EPA determined that a permit were
necessary, the time required to obtain such a permit would
further delay the performance of such maintenance activities.
6. Loss of generating capacity would seriously impact
TVA’s ability to fulfill its obligations to provide electrical
service to the citizens of the Tennessee Valley and could
jeopardize the stability of the national electrical grid during
periods of peak demand. Postponement of the scheduled
maintenance work on other TVA coal-fired units would
exacerbate the problems by creating the substantial risk that
equipment in need of maintenance will break down or
deteriorate, leading to an even greater loss of reliable
generating capability. Sudden breakdown of equipment also
can result in injuries to employees and loss of life.
7. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746 (1994), I declare under
penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this 15 day of May. 2000.
's/ Jerry L. Golden
JERRY L. GOLDEN
50a
APPENDIX H
[Logo]
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY
400 West Summit Hill Drive
Knoxville. Tennessee 37902-1499
Craven Crowell
Chairman. Board of Directors
November 4, 1999
The Honorable Fred Thompson
United States Senate
523 Dirksen Senate Office Building
Washington, DC 20510-4204
Dear Fred:
Yesterday, the Environmental Protection Agency an-
nounced that it was taking action to require the installation of
new pollution control equipment on coal fired power plants
operated by seven private utilities and TVA. We wanted to
share with you TVA’s views on this action.
TVA agrees with EPA that pollution from coal-fired power
plants must be reduced further if the Tennessee Valley region
and the rest of the nation are to continue to improve air
quality. In fact, last summer TVA became the nation’s first
utility to implement an aggressive NOx reduction strategy
which includes installing state-of-the-art pollution controls on
TVA’s largest coal plants. This enormous investment will
help reduce ozone problems in the Smokies, allow continued
purchases of Kentucky coal, and help Valley states meet their
ozone reduction strategies while allowing continued industrial
and economic development.
Sla
So while we support EPA’s goal. we disagree with their
means of achieving it.
All utilities, including TVA, routinely repair and replace
broken equipment at their plants. It is through such activities
that we are able to maintain reliable electric service to the
public and why, last summer, TVA was able to meet record
demands for electricity in the Valley without interrupting
service. EPA is now saying that such maintenance practices
trigger the requirement to install controls designed for new
power plants. This is a dramatic change in how EPA has
applied these requirements in the past. Under this new
interpretation, EPA says that 80 to 90 percent of the utility
industry is in violation of its new source control regulations
because of maintenance projects over the last 20 years.
At TVA, the total cost of complying with this regulation
could exceed $1 billion. Indeed, the combination of capital
costs, interest expense, and ongoing operating expenses
would require a 14-percent rate increase. The increased costs
for every business and residence in the region could limit
economic growth.
Not only does this new interpretation threaten our ability to
continue to maintain reliable operation of our units, but it
potentially limits our ability to put controls where they will
do the most good. In the pollution reduction plan we
announced last summer, we put control equipment on plants
that would most help meet the needs of the region, such as the
efforts by Memphis, Tennessee, and Louisville, Kentucky. to
meet EPA’s air quality health standards, and to address the
problems in the Smokies. Under EPA’s approach, controls
would be installed on plants where EPA thinks it can make its
best legal case—without regard to the region’s air quality
problems.
We hope to be able to work with EPA on a resolution that
will allow us to continue to reduce TVA’s emissions where
§2a
hn
and how it makes the most sense. We also want to reach a
resolution that will allow us to maintain unit reliability and to
continue to fully meet the public’s need for electricity. It is
also important that any resolution treats TVA and our rate-
payers no differently than other utilities and their ratepayers.
I appreciate this opportunity to share our views with you
and will keep you informed of further developments.
Sincerely,
/s/ Craven Crowell
CRAVEN CROWELL
53a
APPENDIX I
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR
THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT
Docket No. 00-12310-E and
Docket No. 00-12459-E
(Consolidated under lead
Docket No. 00-12310-E)
ALABAMA POWER COMPANY. and
DUKE ENERGY CORPORATION.
Petitioners.
V.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY. and
JOHN H. HANKINSON, JR., Regional Administrator,
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
REGION IV,
Respondents.
DECLARATION OF THOMAS L. GILES
I, Thomas L. Giles, having been duly sworn, depose and
say as follows:
1. For the past 22 years, I have resided in Houston.
Texas, which is located in Harris County. | am over 18 years
of age, and give this affidavit based on my _ personal
knowledge.
2. I have a Bachelor of Science Degree in Mechanical
Engineering from the University of Tennessee in Knoxville.
Tennessee, and a Master of Business Administration Degree
from the Houston Baptist University in Houston, Texas. I
have also attended South Texas College ef Law in Houston.
S4a
Texas. Lastly, | am a Registered Professional Engineer in
both Louisiana and Texas.
3. I have worked for Duke Energy Corporation, the
Petitioner in the above-captioned case, for approximately
twenty-nine (29) years. For the vast majority of this period
(i.e. 28.5 years), I have worked for Duke Energy Gas
Transmission. During my years in gas transmission, I have
held positions of increasing responsibility relating to the
application of hydraulic engineering principles to manage
pipeline capacity and energy consumption.
4. For the past 3.5 years, | have worked as the Duke
Energy Gas Transmission Energy Manager for Texas Eastern
Transmission Corporation (“TETCO”). TETCO is a wholly-
owned subsidiary of Duke Energy Corporation. In this
position, my responsibilities include developing and
implementing TETCO’s pipeline operation energy manage-
ment plan. This plan helps TETCO achieve quantifiable
operating efficiencies and to improve the overall management
of the system. My responsibilities also include developing the
necessary tools to manage TETCO’s energy resources;
developing consistent performance measures; and developing
capital/O&M budget recommendations. In conjunction with
the Manager of Gas Control and the Manager of Gas
Planning, I am also responsible for the daily management of
the pipeline system's energy consumption.
5. The TETCO pipeline system consists of approximately
10,000 miles of pipeline and 74 compressor stations with
1,500,000 installed horsepower (HP). The pipeline system
transports natural gas from the Texas-Louisiana Gulf Coast to
shippers located in the northeast United States (including
Public Service Electric and Gas in New Jersey; Keyspan in
New York: and Boston Gas Company in Massachusetts). The
majority of the system facilities were built during the 1950’s
and early 1960’s.
55a
6. TETCO uses compressor stations for the compression
and transmission of natural gas. Gas is transmitted by com-
pressing it and allowing it to flow naturally through the pipe
in the desired direction, which is lower in pressure. In most
pipeline systems, these compressor stations are typically gas-
fired, operating by combusting natural gas taken from the
pipeline. However, at the time the TETCO pipeline system
was constructed, electric power was an economic alternative
to natural gas as a source of energy in the Tennessee Valley.
As a result, TETCO is atypical in that some of its compressor
stations use electricity, rather than natural gas to compress
the gas.
7. TETCO buys electric power from TVA for five of its
electric drive compressor stations. More specifically, TETCO
uses 180.000 HP in the form of electric motors to power
compressors at five locations in TVA’s territory. These plants
are located near Egypt, MS (45.000 electric HP), Barton, AL
(30,000 electric HP), Mt. Pleasant, TN (45.000 electric HP),
Gladeville, TN (30,000 electric HP) and Tompkinsville, KY
(30,000 electric HP).
8. In contrast to the other intervenors or petitioners,
TETCO is a direct served customer of TVA’s at two
compressor stations, and is a TVA _ distributor served
customer at three compressor stations. The unavailability of
power for these compressor drives would result ‘in a loss on
capacity of approximately 15% - 20%. Currently, TETCO
does not have any other alternative source of electricity in the
Tennessee Valley. Accordingly. in these circumstances, under
peak day winter conditions when the pipeline is operating at
full capacity, TETCO would be forced to restrict the use of
the pipeline and limit the transportation volume. This would
require the shippers to seek alternative transportation paths
and/or reduce gas consumption.
S6a
Sworn to and subscribed before me.
This 21 day of July, 2000.
/s/ Kathy Cash
KATHY CASH
Notary Public
My commission expires: 10-15-2002
[Seal]
57a
APPENDIX J
|. Section 7401 of Title 42 of the United States Code
provides, in relevant part:
§ 7401. Congressional findings and declaration of purpose
* * * *
(b) Declaration of Purpose
The purposes of this subchapter are—
(1) to protect and enhance the quality of the Nation's air
resources so as to promote the public health and welfare
and the productive capacity of its population;
(2) to initiate and accelerate a national research and
development program to achieve the prevention and
control of air pollution;
(3) to provide technical and financial assistance to State
and local governments in connection with the
development and execution of their air pollution
prevention and control programs; and
(4) to encourage and assist the development and
operation of regional air pollution prevention and control
programs.
* * * *
2. Section 7409 of Title 42 of the United States Code
provides, in relevant part:
§ 7409. National primary and secondary ambient air quality
standards
* * *
(d) Review and revision of criteria and standards; independ-
ent scientific review committee; appointment; advisory
functions
(1) Not later than December 31, 1980. and at five-year
intervals thereafter, the Administrator shall complete a
58a
thorough review of the criteria published under section
7408 of this title and the national ambient air quality
standards promulgated under this section and shall make
such revisions in such criteria and standards and
promulgate such new standards as may be appropriate in
accordance with section 7408 of this title and subsection
(b) of this section. The Administrator may review and
revise criteria or promulgate new standards earlier or
more frequently than required under this paragraph.
(2)(A) The Administrator shall appoint an independent
scientific review committee composed of seven mem-
bers including at least one member of the National
Academy of Sciences, one physician, and one person
representing State air pollution control agencies.
(B) Not later than January 1, 1980, and at five-year
intervals thereafter, the committee referred to in sub-
paragraph (A) shall complete a review of the criteria
published under section 7408 of this title and the
national primary and secondary ambient air quality
standards promulgated under this section and_ shall
recommend to the Administrator any new national
ambient air quality standards and revisions of exist
ing criteria and standards as may be appropriate under
section 7408 of this title and subsection (b) of
this section.
(C) Such committee shall also (i) advise the Adminis-
trator of areas in which additional knowledge is required
to appraise the adequacy and basis of existing, new,
or revised national ambient air quality standards,
(ii) describe the research efforts necessary to provide the
required information, (iii) advise the Administrator on
the relative contribution to air pollution concentra
tions of natural as well as anthropogenic activity, and
(iv) advise the Administrator of any adverse public
health, welfare, social, economic, or energy effects
which may result from various strategies for attain
ment and maintenance of such national ambient air
quality standards.
59a
3. Section 7470 of Title 42 of the United States Code
provides:
§ 7470. Congressional declaration of purpose
The purposes of this part are as follows:
(1) to protect public health and welfare from any actual
or potential adverse effect which in the Administrator's
judgment may reasonably be anticipate’ to occur from
air pollution or ‘rom exposures to pollutants in other
media, which pol'utants originate as emissions to the
ambient air). notwithstanding attainment and mainte-
nance of all national ambient air quality standards;
(2) to preserve, protect, and enhance the air quality in
national parks, national wilderness areas, national
monuments, national seashores, and other areas of
special national or regional natural, recreational, scenic.
or historic value:
(3) to insure that economic growth will occur in a
manner consistent with the preservation of existing clean
air resources:
(4) to assure that emissions from any source in any State
will not interfere with any portion of the applicable
implementation plan to prevent significant deterioration
of air quality for any other State: and
(5) to assure that any decision to permit increased air
pollution in any area to which this section applies is
made only after careful evaluation of all the conse-
quences of such a decision and after adequate procedural
opportunities for informed public participation in the
decisionmaking process.
' So in original. Probably should read “anticipated.”
~ So in original. No opening Parenthesis.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.