Transcript of Record — William Cramp & Sons Ship & Engine Building Co. v. United States
Supreme Court brief1910
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
/#
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 190€)
No. @8.99,
THE WILLIAM CRAMP AND SONS SHIP AND ENGINE
BUILDING COMPANY, APPELLANT,
us. |
THE UNITED STATES.
APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS.
FILED MARCH 3, 1908.
(21,054. )
(21.054.)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
CCTOBER TERM, 1908.
No. 306
THE WILLIAM CRAMP AND SONS SHIP AND ENGIN
BUILDING COMPANY, APPELLANT
THE UNITED STATES
APPEAL FROM TITE COURT OF CLAIMS
INDEN
Original Pris
Caption
Stiterment of fiitie petition, &e
Vinended petition
Exhibit \o Contraet for tl t ! boat Ni
Septerbn ', |
i idl cot pocur 1h pon
( Bill ot puurt i 1} 1 wh
Traverse (
{reument snd sulmiss
Order for re-argunient '
Re-wreumient aid submission
Findings of fact y
Conclusion of law is
Opinion {s
Judginen vi
Application for appert
Order allowing sppernt
Clerk's certitiont ‘
jivonp & Prerweiien Nt Prixtrens, Wasutsarosx, D.C... May 11, 1900
WM. CRAMP & SONS SITIP AND ENGINE BLDG. CO Vide (Ue Ge
| H Petition lied Aaeeniled Pet (rid
In the Court of Claims
ae Winniam Cramp & Soxs Suie vxp Exeixe 2 ILDING Com-
VARY
Vs
THe Usirep Srares
Phe claimant filed its original petition April 24. 1401. and subse
quently, to wit, on Mareh PS. 1908. by leave of Co moaned in leu of
sted ortetial petition, t filed its sare nde petition hich is as feod-
lows
THe Wintiam Cramp & Sons Site & Exaine Borppixe CoMPANY,
Chratresint.
Tue Ustrep Srares
Lanended Petition tpiad kahit fs | i. (
}Iiled Mareh PS. p9a3
To the Tlonorsibole Chief istics sid J iWdoes of the Court
of Claims of
the United States
The claimant. The Willian Cramp W Sens Ship & Engine Build-
the Company. a corporation Inearporated wider the hows of the State
of Pennsvivanias respectfully shows
1. On or about September 24. PSO. che the United
States, represent | by thr NA tine secretal it ihe N entered into
a contract, a copy of which is hereunto annexed. marked Exhibit: A.
and hiade prart hie reat. whereby HL Wats. cthnen
Hooother things, agreed
"_ pes ' .
Phat the elatiians Wotld. da aecoredsmes with ce ream taws, planes
and specilications, construct for the Unite) States i eertatn vessel
destamated as “Battleship No. S27 with her Ititigs ~pecitied and
certain af her equtpmient: saved vessel to bi constricted with her ma.
chiners enedies and boilers conmplete a their parts and
’ TUPLE abies pie! Col vered 1 thie Naw Vord Leaoue [x]-
and. Penueviversia. to sued perso Secretary of the
Navy meeht designate. within three vears trem: iy date of the con-
tract. to with on oor before Si plember 24. W899, Phat the claimant
Would. in accordance with the said spec iientions ane Prisatis, furnish
all of the material to be used in the comstruetion of the hull and
machinery of the said vessel That the clainant las rapidly
ils possible, furnish all workine drawihhe@s and: tey Plates necessary to
1—306
2 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
‘
show the dinieistens atid shape o. eawehi and every arinor plate re-
quired ior the construction of the said) vessel, Including those to be
provided for hier side and diagonal armor, turrets, barbettes, cise
lates, Coming towers. animunition tubes and. the protections for
her gaos and lomdling positions, such drawings and templates to shov
ithe Positions and sizes of the bolt holes therein. ‘That the Clatineant
would furnish all of the armor and its accessories which night bs
required for the construction of the protective deek of said yesse!
That the clatwant would care for and preserve from injury the said
vessel and all of the waterial: provided for or used in her construs
tion during the progress of the contract work, and would keep lie
and all of the said raaterials. including these to be furnished by thi
clatinant and those to be furnished by the United States, duly in
sured against fire ond marine risks. breakage of wives, and risks of
laubching, uintil her Prelipe tary or conditional UECOD LATICO? Hy thre
United States. the loss. if any, te be pavable to the Secretary of the
Navy.
Irn eonsideration the reof the United States verecd 1) to pay the
Clalit Certain sts of tenev: (2) to furnish the Clatmant all
armor pactes to be teed tn the com=trietion of certain parts of the said
vessel, rretudiig her <tde sed dingonal armor, turrets, bar
casenrifes, conmitns towers. anmmoimition tubes. and
Protections tor her guns and loading positions, and all bolt
for such armor plates: ¢3) to tring: the lates to the drawing or ten
plate “170s phaed <he pes Within resase niable rind bactiurinye litits as sy
jorth wn the speeileations and to dred) ane fii) all bolt hates therein
as shewn by the dr wines and femiplates, and by te deliver the said
arnior plates mt ihe shipvard of the claimant “within the times and
th. onde Popecguey i Orpy Whe ane nr) pra er /
2 Thereati "HN aeeordares ith the terns of the snid comirae
the elotmant procuved materials to be used in the bull and maehiners
of the said vessel and the protective deck thereof, and as rapidly
po sph ole burnin! hans, dra ines, ini templates ROCESS ‘
shew the dimen) bel shape of each and every armor plate rv
quired for tie eon-irieiion of the scid vessel. and proceeded with th
work of construction. andl at all times kept the said vessel and mate.
riils ctily 8 es 2 ae bias t }tt=s hy fire and THUD risks, breakaee ot
wavs and | i miehine. all of whieh thines were duly an
proved 1. ie Seeretary of ti \; Vy and the Clatmient, Prony tivee t
tine, did and powrlormied al other thines which. tivder the terms o
the satd coutract, it was required to do and perform, exeept in se far
te the ely Wits Chted from: so deine by the sets and failure-
of the cptied States hereinafter set forth, and the elaimant eompl
the sai | delivered her to the person thereunto desien
b : ERE
veel Hse oof the con-trnetion of the sido voesse!
nm or al February T, 1S98. sad at divers times ther ifter, th
af i Cat ui moorder to earee on the work prone
vial yy yf) i with the terrgs of the site contraet. certatn «o |
ror ylote > which the Uriited States diod Aaa a a !
< li ct thee ( THN YT thre elaine, when the He shrouded ay
required, Dirt the ( nited States COMETATS lo its suid Wereenpent,
ENGINE BUILDING CO. VS. THE UNITED STATES. 3
mt not then furnish and ch i 1 { Wier plates, although
! a ae ae ape
thereunto requested, and foiled to doe sa for lone nertods of time
hereafter, And whereas the claimant eentd have completed the said
vessel in aecordn ce with the terme of the soid contract, and delivered
by
a r to the United States On oy hve fore Sone miher ue TPNO9tp- hy reason
of the s; id failures of the United Stites to perborrs he sj i contract
on its part. the said vessel's completion and delivery to the United
States was delaved until on or about Oetober 16. L900. and the elaim-
ent was thereby erventiy Tindered in the eon truce! i of the said vessel.
1] was put to creat a lditional expense in canines i with the same
t her ear Momreservation ome thar of the 1 ih outsed or pro
el toy her corstriceti red Foor th thre a
( } ry ay! real ‘ Et thy 1 cor ; } AE oF :
count of the fathiure of the United Stites te 4 ain
a} unted to the sim: of = ! ae
hh need Ie hivefour dolls che) rt Siac |
mrope full PrPeag ys frome two dell of pa “P ' . ’
hee! Madiliit. B ond €, respee tively. ri ’ ot i
1 Phe el rant de the only pes On awryen aa Pat Le
‘ iD forty erie - eS | ti~f ( ’
iV part tere rinterest therein hiss be Y
ri-tly tt it! fir POCOTYVE rel recover tray tt) y , & for s |
WE ee a id daaisge the sen ef t t! id jive
hina Ye } ariel ( hiv ar Tove sityed ‘ ‘ | 4
The elainnant das made due ° : , ict: Mideea
h for the payment of the said sum. but the Seereiary of the
Navy. ais thre nvent of thre United State n the mre Mises. has
}
|
( to consider the said demand. and the said <a as not
been paid, nor anv part thereof. The claimant has alwave borne
true ollegianee to the Governiment of the United States. aad has not
In any wav waded, abetted. or ociven encauravement + WS Ree
loninst it
Wherefore the clotinaat pravs for ince 1 ist the United
States in the stim of seventyv-ctelt thousand five Hundred and ciehty
four dollins and fourteen cents (Sia. pe4 FA). apd fer such further
rehefas this lionorable court 1 av vrant. both at | tid try ecndity.
othe preniises
THE WILLEAM CRAMP & SONS STITP
\ND ENGINE BUILDING COMPANY
By CHARLES Ho CRAMP. President
HAYDEN,
‘
\
tttorneus for Claimant
McC AMAMON «
; P Se
Croha coppel Cetin at Pi ladel ph "1
(hark ~ 1] Coren Dp. bere cluly “Worl deposes and ~VVs thysyt hye
thie porentede f of Th \\ titan Cramp & Sons Shay ie} vpoyye
Pathdine Compr. thie eluting rire Ith anal which subseribed
lies Poors eon eo petition: that he has re; cl the
irre inial knows the eor
7
4 THE WELLEAM CRAMP &4SONS SITIP AND
tents thereof. aid that the frets therein stated are true te the best
of his knowledge anid belied,
Subscribed aud sworn to before me this 12th dav of Mareh, 1908,
ISAAC ARROTT,
Notary Public
Exuipir A,
~
Contract for the Construction ofa Seaqoog Coastline Battle Ship
of Ahout 110000 Tons Displace ment,
“Battle Ship No a
Contract, of two parts. made and concluded this twenty-fourth
day of September, AOD) TS96, by and between the William Cramp
and Sons Ship aud Prueine Building Company. a corporation created
under the laws of the State of Pennsylvania, and deine business at
Philadelphia. its said) State. represented by the president of said) cor:
poration, party of the first part. and the United States, represented
by the Secretary of the Navy. party ot the sceone part.
Whereas, The vet entitled “An net raking appropriations for the
naval service for the fiscal vear ending June thirtieth. eighteen hun
dred and ninety-secenu. and for other purposes” approved June LO,
1896, authorized the construction of three servoing coust-line batth
ships. te be constructed) in vecordanee with certain Provisions Col
tained in the oet entitled “An aet to dnerease the naval establish
ment.” approved \neust ISS6] and te he in all their parts of
domestic miantfaeture: an
Whereas, \fter din cide risenrent, the propesal of the said party
of the first part for the construction of one of said vessels. including
hull, machinery. eneines, boilers, and Uppurtenanees, equipment,
,
’
}
tl
except amehors said chaits, the Installation of the ordnance and
ordnance outfit, aod the tittine. fixing. placing and securing of all
her armor complete in all respects, Which vessel is. for the pur-
pores of this contract, designated and known as “Battle Ship
S No. 82° Tas heen dirty BECO LE « hay the Seeretary of the Navy,
and
Whereas The drawines, plans sinned ~pectiioations~ required hiv the
said aet have heen « Wi provided, adopted, and approved Th ecard
ance with the provisions of said aet of June 10. TS96-
Now. therefore. this contract witnesseth: That. in consideration. ot
the preniises. abel for aird tee consideration of the pavinvents to hi
made as hereinafter provided. the party of the first part, for itself
and its ~tecessars sited HSSTQMS, and its legal representatives, does
hereby covenant and agree te and with the United States as follows,
that is to say
First. The party of the first part wilh at its own risk and EXpenise,
construct. In aceordanece with the provisions of the nets of Coneress
relating thereto. sid in eouformitw with the aforesaid) drawings.
plans. and ~pectiieds ons. one battle ship Of slieuit eleven thortsired
tons displacement, with fittines ils ~pectfied, shied equipment, except
ENGINE BUILDING CO, VS. THE UNITED STATES h
anehors anid Chains: sich vesse] to be construeted of steel of domestic
manufacture. and to be provided and fitted with machinery, engines,
and botlers. also of domestic manufacture, complete in all their
parts, apPpurberanees, anid spare parts. and in all respects as described
In the annexed drawings. plans, and specifications. and in the acts
of Congress above referred to. and will deliver the same at the Navy
Yard, League Island. Pennevivania, to such person as the Secretary
of the Nav may desieniate: if heme, however, expressly understood
and agreed that af ana article or thing. included im. or covered
the drawings. plans. and specifications aforesaid) shall be found
during the prosecution of the work under this contract. toe be met
produced or manufactured in the United States. and i. atte:
9 reasonable effort, it shall be found impractieable to obtarn
the sare as an article of domestic mamufactire, then. and 3
sell Cue, Pravision shall he niade, hy or with the appreval of the
Secretary of the Navy. for such alteration tn the drawings. plans
and specitications. or for the adoption of seh new or different devices
or pelauts is thay be feorrriel HeCessa PN in order to Carry oll aid Corl
plete this contract, ~ubpect, as to tnerensed or dititiished compen
sation by reason oof stich change. to the conditions applicable te
chanees as expressed in the second ehuise of this contract
Secoud. The eoustruetion of said) vessel. the word vessel as used
here and hereafter througheut this contract heme titended to an
clide evervihing covered hay the drawthes, polaunis. anid ~peettientions
above referred to, lial] conform ta all respect- te cited wath sada
drawings, plans. and speetheations. whieh are hereto ammexed said
shall be deemed and taken as forming a prart of this contract with
the like operation and effect as Tf the same were tmeorperated heren
No omission tn the drawttes. plans or specifications of ain detail
object, or provi- Odi necessary to Carrs this contract inte full arid
complete effect. th accordance with the object ane intent of the aet-
of Congress above referred to, ~hall operate to the disadvantage of the
Vrited States, but the same shall be sati-factortly supplied. per
formed. ane observed liv the PRUTEN of the first part, amd all clams for
eXtra compensation by reason of. or for. or on account of. such extra
perfornnmes, are dre reby and tn consideration of the prenitses x
presslv waived. and di is hereby further provided. and this contraci
Is pon the eXpress condition that the drawihes, platin. and ~pectiion
tots aforesaid shall bool be changed Wh unas respect, When thie Cost of
such change shall, ih the execution of the work, ‘ xeood five hauindred
dollars. except pron the written order of the Se retary oo
1) \eting Secretary of the Navy: that if changes ave thie raed
the actual cost thereof. and the damage. tf anv, eansed there by
shall be aseertatnied. estiimited. and sr as nc hy oa board of rave
officers. appeotnted ie the Seeretaryv of the Nawyv. and that the in
the first part <hadl dhe heotard be the oo of said board,
Or a peetOritn ee as te the c1miount of nereased or diminished
On pen sation whieh the sate print of the first part shall be entitled
to recerve. Tf any. PD corse quence of -ueh chatige or chars
There The prrrtn of thre fir~t puart will, ths rapidly ue possthle frit
| Wt ooyorkpne drawdigs ane teniplate. necessary ote shaw the
4
5 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
"yanerisis ced shape of each and covery armor plate required for use
ty the eoostruetion of the vessel, including those to be used in the
coustuetion of the side and diagonal belts, turrets, barbettes. case-
ces connine towers. ammunition tubes, and protection for the
suns aud loading positions, and the position and sizes of the bolt
holes thorein--the spacing and dimensions of said bolt holes to Tx
in accordenee with the specifications and subject to the approval of
ihe Secretary of the Navy: it being expressly understood and agreed
that the party of the first part shall furnish all the armor, armor
bolls. aud their aecessories required in the construction of the pro-
tective deck: that the party of the second part shall furnish all other
spror. aud the armnor belts. te be used im the construction of thi
vessel including such as mreNv Ie required in the construction ef @
1 ooral belts. turrets. barbettes, casemiates, conniig to
ers, anitaiiion tubes, and protection for the guns and loadiag posi
{to fins sech ormor plates to the drawing or template =ize= and
chepos, within reasonable manufacturing limits, as set forth im the
-pecifications, and drill and tap all armor-holt holes there:
1] shown by said approved drawings and templates, and de-
liver said armor. and armor bolts. at the ship vard af the
pariv of the first part. and within the times and in the order required
to e:nrey oor the warl pre perks ond thet the party of the first part
|
shall at its own risk amd expense. furnish all rivets and other fasten-
ines. apd deill. tan. ane fit all holes for rivets and other fastenimes
used to couneel any part of the hull framing to the armor for con-
-trietive prrposes. except as hereinbefore mentioned, and properly
ft oH. mace wv J secure to the vesse] all the Arnon, including the
side and Giacenal belts. turrets. barbettes, easemates, conning towers,
aymnnition tubes, and protection for the guns and loading positions.
is required by the aforesaid drawines. plans. and speeifieations ; and
Hodes expressly niderstood. covenanted, and agreed that if, upon the
jon of the vessel. except the fitting. fixing. placing. and se-
eurine of the armor for her side and diagonal belts. turrets. bar
Wettes. eoseruates. aid conning towers, the party of the second part
sh not deve commenced the delivery of such armor to the PAUTty
fhe fie port. then and tn sueh case the vessel shall he subjected
to the teiat provided for in the tenth elause of this contract, and if
toandoeon suelo triak all the conditions and requirements relating
thereto, exeent a= to the fitting. fixing. placing, and sceuring of th
armor for the ide and Jinegonal helt<. turrets, harhettes, cnseniuites,
and cor nine fowers, Nal] ha fulfilled the vesse] shall he aeeepted Hh
pros idea! for in the eleventh eliose of this contract: and if the party
of the scecnd vert shall not have commenced the deliverv of the
apmior fer the <tde and digeonnl belts. turrets. barhettes. easemates,
or eonnine towers when the vessel is readv for her final trial ot
within five reenths after either a preliminary or a conditional ac
coptince of the vessel. said vessel shall he finally accepted, sub
}? foet to the eondittons ane requirements of this contract. a
the eost of fitting. fivine. placing. and securing the arnier
the side and dineonsl belt<. turrets, harhettes. caseriates. gay
eonnine teawers <halb be asec rintned. estimated. and determined
ENGINE BUILDING CO, VS. THE UNITED STATES. 7
i board ot haval othicer- tppel tod by thie Secretary Ol thie aN i\ .
the party of the first part shall be bound by the detertuination ot
suid board, and such cost: shall be deducted fromr th price oO} this
vessel in the final settlement under this contract: but if cl
the second part shall commence aud eoutinue with reason
vence the delivery of the armor fer the side or diagonal Petts, tu
rets, barbettes, casemites, or comming towers of the vessel prior to der
final trial or within five months after either 2 pre Inyo}
conditional accep hance of the vessel, the party of the firsi part <h
fit. fix, place, and secure all the armor toe the vessel in aceardanes
with the requirements of this contract and the drawings,
specications hereto annexed,
Fourth. The materials and workiiishin used cid police
the construction of the vessel herein contracted. fer
finish, shall he first-class anid of the very bent CUUbi dy :
from the beginnine to the end of the work. be sul
tion of the Secretary of the Navy: it being hereby uid
enanted. and aereed that the sid Secretary
ch
Inspectors, to whem the party of the first part ~hiel riint
is
suuples of said materials, and such informiition as to
thereof. and the hianner of using the same. as 1 iN ber ye
also any assistance such inspectors may require in di li
weight and quality of steel and other metals. said of 4 dott
materials, either used or intended for use In the eensteruy of thr
vessel, and that the inspectors may. with the appre
Secretary. peremptorily rejeet any unfit rote) orl
1s the use thereof. The Inspectors shall. at all trv hie
progress of the work. have full aeeess therete.
of the first part shall furnish them with full facilities for
ton and superintendence of the sane
hifth. The steel to be used in the construction of thre
contracted for shail conform to the “Speciications for
steel for use in the construction of the hulls and miachirn '
ships Nos. 7, 8, and 9, for the United States Na as
the Secretary of the Navy under date of Jaty Bo S06
cations are annexed to and fornia pruart of this contrnes
Sith. The party of the first part will, at its own ex:
such plans or drawings as mav be necessary duri
the work, and will submit the sme to the Nowy Derr
proval | etore the toatertal is order door the work ea ‘
Nevepth, The paren of the first preart, db conpsre ' i}
pretmises, hereby covenants and agrees to held
States harmless from and against all and every deneand. os !
anv nature or kine for. or on mecount of. thy
in. model, design, or sueeestion. or for or
fany patented invention, article. or anplianes which |
he adopted or nsed in or ahont the const)
iV port thereof. under thi- CoOmtraek, ane te per ‘
Government from all habilitw on aeeount thes
the nse thereof. by proper releases fron) 4 iMenters. oO 1}
to the sati-t chron of thre Secretary of the N
4
ro) Pik WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
Lighth. Vhe vessel herein coutracted for, and all materials
appliances provided for and used, or to be used. in the constructs:
thereof, shall be kept duly insured against fire and marin
14 risks, breakage of ways and risks of launching, which insu
ance shall be renewed and inereased, from time to time, by
and at the expense of the party of the first part, until the prelinal
nary or the conditional acceptance of the vessel. the loss, if any, to
be stated in the polieles as pavable to the Secretary of the Navy: thi
insurance to be effected in such manner and in sueh COULPAUNTOS as
shall be approved by him. and in an amount to be fixed. fron: tiny
to time. by him, not exceeding the amount of the pavinents tide
under this coutract
Vinth. The vessel herein contracted for shall be completed i
aecordanes with the drawittes, platis, and speetfications alibbeNed
hereto and resid for delivers to the party of the second pert. On oy
before the eXpiration of three Vvears from the date hereof: buat th
len of the Party of the -econd pRUrPh Upon idl vessel, and the materials
on hand for use in the construction thereof, respective] ned cotter
lively, for all TOTES, pute on account thereof, shall conmnenee with
the first payment. and shall thereupon attach to the work done and
Inaterials furnished. and shall, in like manner. attach from tiniest
titne, as the work progresses, and as further pavinents are mide. and
shall continue until it shall have been properly discharged. Tn ease
the completion of the vessel as aforesaid: shall be delaved bewond the
said period of three vears, deductions shall be made fron the pricy
sUpulated in this contract for each and every day (excepting Sry
days) during the continuance of sueh delay. and Until the vesse
shall be completed as atoresard and ready for delivery tor othe
party of the second party, as follows, viz) During the three month
nent sueceeding the eOXpIration of sia perro, seventy-tive dol]
(870.00) a day. during the fortieth, forty-first and forty-seea
tnonths from the date of this contract, one hundred and tite
1 dollars (8150.00) a dav: and for each and ever daw Cex
cepling Suridiaves ) during Which stich cCormiplet ion shill |
delaved beyond the period of three vears and “IN months from: the
date of this contract three hmdred dollars (8200000) Sond all sueh
deductions fron the price of the Vessel to be nade. fron titiie
tine. fron UV pPavinent or pavimients fallin dive Hinder this cay
TNC: provided, however, thisit such delay <hall niet have been crnpsy
In the aet of the PRUTEN of the ~ecornad part.oor by fire on Waiter, op tiny
anv strike or stand-out of workmen emploved in the consteaeri
of the vessel, or by other CIPCT Ts tatiees, bevornd the control of t}
party of the first part: lat such cirenmistanees shall not de deen
to Ineluide delays My obtamine tatertals When sueh delay. iVtse fro
causes other than those herern =peettiod sand provided. further Wh
Incase of any such alleged delav. the party oof the first mart «hall
Hitnedtate notice thereof iw riting to the Seeoretary of the News
In Cise Guy questions shall arise, under this CODEPANOCH. Compe
deductions from the price of the vessel hereny contracted fey
question. with all the facts relatinve therete shill die Sub itted
ENGINE BUILDING Co. V8, THE UNITED STATES. 9
Secretary of the Navy for consideration. and his decision thereon
shall be conelusive and binditig (ipront the puttiies to this contract,
All delavs whieh the S ereiiy of the Navy shall find to be properly
attributable to the party of the second part, or to its authorized offi-
cers, or agents, or any or either of then. and to have been delays
operiting upon the completion of the vessel within the tive ~pecrtied
therefor in this contract. <lhall entithe tbe party al the first part toa
corresponding extension of the period preseribed for the conmpletion
of the Vessel : provided, howerer, that te delay nor the alleged Callse
or catises thereof attributed by the party of the first Paart. to
lth the party of the second part. its officers or agents. shall be eon-
stdered by thie Secretary of the Nay tithes thy party of the
fitst part shall. aut the tie of Lhe oeerrrernies of suehe delsay notify
idm an Writhig of the faet< armed ere Mtrtitihiees ti enehy couse, and of
the extent to whieh the said purty cot the first part elatus that the
completion od the vessel ds thereto deliaved
Fenth, The party of the tivst part hereby further covenants and
agrees that the vessel to be eomstrueted ay der this contraet shall be
sullieneriths strony te earrmy bier ar Pe to this Mbriitient, equip
ment, coal, stores, and raeditrpers prescribed by the Seeretarv. of
the Navy uted Prretterttoen| ty thie ititie Neal dren tis relsites, and spect
eobiatis threat thie beotsr! Woes hi | sitet ft why w! eluding engines,
hotlers. sted HPP eras i TINTHAMO™ OPEP bperene itied fire TOOTS,
soke Pipes clistilltrye sippy ts, stores “pare parts heating itp)
parattls, tools ty Workshop, mud water tn beaplers condensers, PUTS,
pipes, itiel stegry turbves but tet ineludtne Parrer misehine My eapstan,
Hot eXceed eleven han
dred and thirty tons (LEO tons) Hits wetahit ter be detertitned from
the certified records of the itetital werodit oof thy parts of the ma
chinery v= they are sent om board the vo-se!
withdliss steering gear. oor Witieties } hall
tor doe cothected Hp aN
cept the wetelt of the contained Water, whiredy <dradl dn caletlated
from the actual volumes tn steaming condita hown oon the
certified drawings of the completed iieliners the veocht to be
caloribited for <alf water exeepy fat thine poaet v bier fresh) Witter
only is used: that if said tote werobit bn Seoedted. a dednetion of
five hindred dollars (S500) a tor <b heeotrdte from the eontraet
price af thr Vossel for ouve hi hot af Nees.
mel that if satel total Werohit ba
rothat <thpulated,
execodled ty epereent.a further
dednetion of ten thousand dollar oSPoae, dath hy toade from the
contract pries of the vos« Why deduetrons te be made
li Prot ANN Paver on Davent. eoutdey this eon
tract: ane that wher the vesse Plefted. os required) by
the drawings. plow. Po specrientians Had ete for delivery te
the party ff thee eco rt his { he Hateetend) tog trial trip,
the Aeon a nulor 4 ried or approved by the See
retary of the Navy. te tet tl | chinery, inelud
Ing engives. batters, and appurtenanees, the canipmernt, the installa
ten wt the cbdianie or fit dothe <poed of the yvesse]
inne threat ~bie ~h 1} bie ceverpileay ¢ J moy mtoaf rey ibeet i
’
10 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SIIIP AND
(1.) Thot the working of the nh cehinery in all it< parts shal! be
to the satisfaction of the Se relay ob the Navy
2.) The party of the first part hereby guarantees that the <pe
deve lope Hrs the vessel, Upon sid trial meder coredition Preseritved
Or approved bry the Secret iy of the Navy, shall be tet lees than
average of sixteen (16) knots an hour, maittained successfully for
four (4) consecutive hours, during which period the air pressure in
the fire room: shall not exceed an average of one ineh of water, ¢]
vessel to be weighted te a tea draft of twenty-three feet six inch
(26 feet 6 tnehes)
(3.) That stick vew-e hill be found to be <tronge and well built
and iu sire Colby % th the contract drawtnes, plans, ied
specications, ittiet «4 he ip vovedd Tvs the Secretary of the Navy
provided, That if, at and ipeerny scered 00 Hh. there <hall be any farlure
ii the vessel to meet fully the rr puirenient- of this eontraet, ile
party of the first port stall be entitled to make further trial, sutli-
cient in mituber to reasonably demonstrate her capabilities; a
provided ulso, Viiat the toner of trials -hall be determined and
Litttedd | thie Scere { the Navy. and that all the ex
1s penises of ll trials prior to the preliminary or the conditional
’
aceeplance of the vessel shall be borne by the party of the
first part
Kleventh, We at anne tpn the trial before mentioned. the fore
VOINe reqiireniené | conditions relating to the vessel herein eon-
tracted for =teal firititled. and af the “peed C16) krots) cuarantecs
as aboresiid si hn developed nid maintained as aforesatd. thet
ateel dan <thelp eu bie Vesserd <br dl be predinuit ily accepted, and pay.
ment of the | throe tuetallaent: of the priee stipnlated tn this eer
tract. ard el a: te ! tertis, <brall be rade. <tbteet. however, to
special reserve of lye piel chodiags (SOLOW) Pree ard out ¢
the reservations. Ju tter provided for: Dnt if the <peed develop
and miotitauine --<el on der trial <hell fall below the spe
(dts teiyet ~aforesetd, but mot below 14 knete an beur
she shall be « coepted, sabypeet te de ctiretion from the
price Of tlie verse] woot of ber fathire te reaeb the <peed 16
knots) etiarartecd aforesaid. at the rate of twenty-five thom-nnd
dollars (325.000) a quarter knot for speed between 16) knots
lots, and (itive thermeaned dobhare C850 O00) ) a oegiiart r knot for sy
between o's us Sheets. proached however, that all the other re
querer ed ( if of this contract shall lave heen fu
ariel, 1h ‘ ar S75 tical ecerhiniee threat the levst) thryyres
stallmrette of th wool the ve nd the reservatterns on pers
The lis wit ‘ reserve Fuel whepedy <Peall be
plicable tae he satisfaction of <ueh deductions. and <!
be reteti 1] ‘ ‘% 1) “14 rerrt fer th Tae
provide! fy tf thie vessel ~ teoonhithit an avers
of at lena Vo bape ty brane tt <beadl dee optional with the Sere
of the Nave to f her ot weept ber at reelueed prnee aimed
conditions te be aereed unen between the <atd Seeretare and the
party of the first part
EXGINE BUILDING CO, V8, THE UNITED STATES. 11
" In cose of a prelionin a#eceptance of said vessel. the said
special reserve of sixty theasand dollars (860,000), or. in
ise of a conditional aceeptianece of the vessel, the said reserve fund,
or so ttieh there tay. ite the fndement of the Secretary of the
Navy. be noeessare. «ball be held anti! the vessel has been finally
trie! after bad f en et eet ee ried, i werohted correspond-
ingly. and in all respects conmplete and ready for sen. under conde
fiom preserthed or approved by the Secretary of the Navy: provided,
that «teh fins! trial <hall take pleee within five months from and
fter the date of the peelingivesy the conditional aceontanee of the
es<el ct othrat thes retises thereef <hall he borne lw the party of
Vf. cat sanyo tee seby Cty tr eratanv troe within five months
ifter ¢] relty ry oor th " fromal aceentanee of sat vessel,
ts fisivitee Pe plrce. anv weal - or defeet in
4 ‘ 4 ' Paeechiee mn oop detepioy i a her than
thet eltpe ts ‘ It, ' partor parts of ite po Winery
f pepe nte ] ) F Vyeal] dig
: Rasaas a fn Ae ry of the
y ; | 4 ‘ 4 } ‘ ‘ ‘ i hyysf Posye ! } rity at
, a | 3 1 1iare t why <cocloee.
‘ings trenannd in 41 rn i i ovessel ot anv fi or times
durine suri! fice wbeec fl I fell onnartiny v to al rve end
nerert ti evkine of the wnehinery in oll ites Withont,
me Urectine or controlling power over the <ame in ease such
neer «hall | liege, fy ensation shall he paid by the
rtwoof the fips f
Tf ssid veces ty Pereties. for sneh final trial within five
rrverethin fs the date of her preliminary or eandit nal ae-
Pa eeptaner. threnugh ne fault or delav on the port of the party
f the first pert. ond if there hall her red po wenk-
Ver fave rt, ‘ ! eroaney failure. hreakine down or de-
fier ther ql thet af fe four wear snd tear. of any part
nart< of tf chinery, enets botlers or appurtenances, then
he vessel eferl] bee firesl tte mil the said <) reserve, or
hie « | 7 of tlye ! rye fumed yy red, <apboye however, to
loduetiopy et perorunt pret mew peelepettens thet nav | } de oan the
fice of the vessel under the procteios of thie cnntpact
In ease of the reieetion of the vessel for ane of tl eontises provided
win this contract. the party of the first part hell refund to the
party of the ~ecotned prert «or letratid. op witht ity sve thre reatter,
IE posnwernveeret theretefeere ¢ lee tos thy id party of the first par for
ri ent of the construetion of <id rosce
Porelith Pe tive fel ecome! part hovine approved. as foun-
Theore four 9] tf Plans. and specifications of a ves
v! rt fore 'Ehaf properly carried out. result
by rewlrietin woul orf fT lees then SIxfeen le nyot- ae) h war,
12 rik WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHEP AND
changes, so loug as the size, strength. and character of the vessel shall
remain substantially the same: changes in plans or speeitieations i
volving Ihereased or deeroased eNpeiise to be dealt with as provided
for in the second clause of this contraet
Thirteenth, Wois further mstitiialls uiiderstood, covenanted ana
avreed that. tn ease of the failure or onisston of the party of the
{inst partoat anv staye of the work prior to its completion,
21 from GY Calise OP Cates other than those speciiiod ity the
ninth clause of this contract, to eo forward with the work and
make satisfactory progress towards it+ completion within the pry
seribed period, it maar] Tee optional with the Secretary of the Navy te
declare this contract forferted, The purty of the first part shall
thereupon. and oon notice thereof. ta writing, be. and the sat parts
of the first pearl does hereby. ti consideration of the prenibses, bet
itself ane its seeessors aud assigns. and its legal representatives, ca
knowledge tteelf te be justly tidebted to the party of the sec
part, as for liquidated and aseertamed damages. tna stm equal to
the ageregale amount of al! Paavinenits there tofore minde to at for. or
on aecount of work doue under this contract, and does further cove
nant and agree, as aforesaid, to refund the same on demand, or within
sINtY days thervedatt route that the pears of ihe ~ecored pret shiall sini
mav hold. as collateral security. for sueh refined. said) vessel. or se
much thereof as shall them diave been constructed. ane all qratertal
furnished or on hand for the purposes of construction. "Phe Seer
tary of the Navy shall thereupon eanse te be taken and filed a full
and complete efatement and iaventory of all work done Or con
meneed He Upon. or sbeouit “atd vesse, anid of all hoetertals ont hand
applicable thereto. the property of the party of the first part. and
shall catise the <anie to be duly valaed bw oa board. conu-t-tine of yet
less than five persons. qualitio
discharge of their duties. to be appotnted by the Seeretary of the
Navy, which board shall proceed without unnecessary delay to ex
amine such work and qeatertals and aseertatn amd deehiure the fair
market value thereof. tneludine a reasonable and eustommary mare
of profit litbotiosn motel of the work is “hall have bee moot the tune
such forfeiture t. declured. satisfactorily performed: and ape
22 seh exsiiuation the party of the first puerl daVv athenad
hy its represcntative or. if it <0 desires, by cotnsel aed sul
mit such evidence is thie board tar deen proper
Fourteenth Upon receipt of the report and finding of said) board
and upon his approval thereof, the Seeretary of the Nawy mary
his discretion rroceced a COniy lets wife Ves ol, an Hecoredanee with
the contract. drawines. pl
pose all siritabl nootertals ony brand and ire lipeded Nh thre ryyveryytay
aforesaid: and the tithe to said vessel. or so much thereof as shal
have been completed, ined ter sd] ~uely omiaiterials shall forthwit}
vest in the party of the second part: sited thee party of the first part
does hereby, for iteclf ined tts sees seers. and Hss}Ons med tts lew
representatives, covert and aeree to and with the party of th
econd part that. on receiving moties of the tntention af the Seen
tary of the Navy to proceed to thre competitor of the work t wil
11 loniow ledoe and experienee Cor thi
|
itis aid species tion Wisin for threvt pry
—-
ENGINE BUILDING CO. Vs. THE UNITED STATES. 13
surrender said vessel and all nictertals on hand, together with the
use of the vard or plant. and all machinery. tools. and appliances
appertaining thereto and theretofore used or tecessartiv to be used
inoand about the completion of che work,
Kiftecnth, Un ease the Secretary of the Navy shall proceed. under
ihe foregotne chinse. to complete the work. such procedure <hall be
without trmecessary delay. and shall be at the risk and expense of
the party of the first part. which party shall be chargeable with any
roerense dh the cost of matertals or labor incurred by reason of its
fathure te performs this contract, Upon the final settlement of the
ability of the party of the first part an account shall be stated stub
stantially as follows
The party of the first part shall be charged
1 With all pavinent. made
2. With the extra cost. if anv. of matertals and labor ane
oe all other extra eCNpenses, if anv. tnenmrred in the cormpletion
of the work.
The party of the first part shall then be eredited with the value
of the work done yp) le the time of SHSPeriston, ana of the rater!
on hand. as ascertained Dw the board. under the provisions of the
thirteenth elanse of this contract and approved by the Sceretary ot
the Navws and with sueh pavinents, tf anv. as tay have been re
funded. Tfoa balance shall thereupon appear in faver of the ports
of the first part. the same shall be paid te and accepted by the said
party oof the first part in full discharge of all claims under this
contraet: but oa balanee shall appear in faver of the party of the
second pret, thr PRUrty of the first poart hereby coveratts sid recs,
vs aforesatd. to pay and discharge the sare on demand
Nirtoonth It js rititually tnderstood, eovernmnted, ated avrecd hy
Hid between the respective parties hereto that it shall mot. under ars
eretmistinces, be obligatory upon the party of the second part to
weeptoor pay fer the vessel. or anv part thereof. to be constructed
Hider this contract, unless she shall have been completed: in. strict
conformity with this contract, and in accordance with the provision-
of the aete of Coneress. relating thereto. and that this qualifieatton
Shall he deemed and teken as applicable and applying te each and
every cliatise, covenant, and condition, express or tripelted, it) thits
contract contamed
Nerentecnth Wo ts rvtitunadds nnderstood, covenunted md serreed
byoand between the respective parties hereto that this contre shall
net, nor shall any titerest herein. be transferred by the party of the
fir-t part tonne other Persan Or persons
Riahteonth Wis hereby mutially and expressly covensnted and
agreed, and this contraet 1 Wiper the express condition that
a | no omeniber of or delegate to Coneopress. offices roof the Navy
HO GEE preter holdine any offiee or oppor tree nt under the
Navy Department. t< or shall be admitted: te anv share or part of
this eontraet., or to pny ha Ne fit fe arise therefrarnn leit t} I~ «1 poke
Hon. se farias it reliates tes mienibers of or delegates tr Congress, <hall
the eonstried to extend to this eontract. of hein trode with an
Heorporited Company
14 PHE WILLIAM CRAMP « SONS SHIP AND
Ninclecvth. The party of the sec ned part. in constderation of the
pretiises, lees hereby contract, promise and engage to and wiih
the party of the first part, as follows
1. The price to be paid for the vessel to be constructed and fur-
nished. in accordance with this contract. shall be two million <i
bundred aye fifty theusend dollar ¢82.650,000 )
2. Payments shall be made by the party of the second part in
thirty equal inetallnents, as the work progresses, with a reservation
of ten per cent. from each installment
3. No payment shall be made except upon bills in quadruplicate,
certified by the spectors of dial) and machinery of the vessel. in
such tianner a shall be directed bes the Sccretary of the Navy, Whose
firiat] approval of all lil. thu certified shall be Mecessary before pray-
ment thereof,
4. MI warrants for payioents ander this contract shall be iiide
payable to the party of the first part or its order
®. Payment of the last three tn-tallments shall not be made ex-
cept as provided for in the eleventh clause hereof,
6. When a payment i te be made under this contract, A a con-
dition preeedont thereto. the Seeretury of the Navy may, in his dis.
cretion require, for the protection of the party of the second peart,
evicle nee ~atisfactory ter Daten ior be furnished hy the prarty of
2 the first prart. that ne liens or rights jn rem of any kind
against said vessel. or her machinery, fittings, or equipment,
or the taaterial on hand for tise tn the COnSEPUCtIOn thereof, have
heen or Cal be cequirred, for eren account of any work done Or any
machinery, fitting, equilprent, or toatertal already Incorporated “ls
a part of said vessel, or on Picannel fer that purpose. or that such liens
or rielit~ hiaive either bree ti releus¢ | absolutely ors subordinated le
the rights of the Government as te make its lien for all paviments
Parent, <0 as not to eneumber or hinder in anv wav the rights
of the Government to accept or reject said vessel. and so as to become
ib-olutely extinguished in case of the acceptance of the vessel,
7. When all the Con tions. cone tants. and provisions of this con-
tract =hall have been performed and fulfilled by and on the part of
the party of the first port. said party of the first part shall be entitled.
within ten davs after the filine and aeeeptance of tts claim, to. pe-
Cove the mite ~pectal reserve, or the surplus, if anv, of sud TESeryvc
frre. Or <0 4 neh of either as the mitted party of the first part may ha
entitled to. on the execution of a final release to the party of the
second peuirt it “neh lorry iis shall! bn approved by the Seeretary of thre
Nay ve of all clatty- Of gen kind or deseription under or hy virtue
of this coutraet
Te whith, Ty ony doubt~ or disputes ATISe as to the meanlhig of
anvihing in the drawines, ‘
’ °n é ae
pricttin, or -peetieations, or rt any diserey
anev appear between satd driawines. plans or <pecifications. and th:
ey traet. the misnttes Pid] Vee at enee referred to the Secretary of the
Navy. for determination. and the party of the first part hereby binds
ht ,
If ated its steecessors and assicns. amd its legal representatives to
\s t.: oh. -
‘ by f by fils eet feoda vty the prre tey}=ar-
ENGINE BUILDING Co. VS. THE UNITED STATES. 15
. Tn Withies Whereni th res pechive parties hereto tive hore
unto set their hands and seals the day and vear first above
written,
THE WILLEAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP \ND
ENGINE BUILDING COMPANY
Lskan.] By CHAS. WH. CRAMP. President
Signed and sealed in the presence of
Attest:
JNO. DOUGHERTY. Seercta
THE UNITED STATES,
[SEAL.| By W. McADOO.
jx cle tiny Nee re tary oft the Vann
SAM. C. LEMLY.
Audie ld rocat, freneveal
\s te \W Ne \doo.
\eting Secretary of thre Navy
Exuinir B
PHiLaDeELpHta, December 6. LaO0
United States Government, Departinent of the Navy. Bureau ot
Construction and Repair,
lo
The William Cramp & Sons Ship and Engine Building Company,
Ir
lor charges for care ana Preservaliolh of the US B.S Aluhanin
exciusive of tiachinery) in con-equenice of delay in completion of
the vessel, cattsed hy the fatlure of the CGovernnie
a her armor at the tities arch in the
the work properly, from: September 24 T8900 doa, of oxnir
Hon of Contract, lo October EG. Ta
it to deliver
’ ?
oraer required to !
rey on
M”). both dates inclusive,
as follows
Whartave. OAS days ub ome cent per ton
per dav on 6,802.12 eross tons (tonnage
bared on Report of Bureau of Constrie
lion aire Repair, ISU pp. 7]
Watchine
man for the above period, at SH for 24
One niolit and one dav wate)
hours a : Pog oo
Electric Lielting. Pilatistisitine vessel 248
dave during the shove period, at S46. .2 16.049. 76
Paintine.— Touching pound repatting
waiter bottoms, trraninie tunk, coffer
dams, boiler-roonys Avinrwne-rooms. er
fine-roomis, woodwork. oniilitary mast
ontarede Of - Hutt. tel cork pruntiy u
throuehout shin. and turpentine deeks
0 hours painting. at Le
ey Ih
S200 00
red-lead oil, at 1 889 AQ
'y PHE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SIIIP AND
1.200 The, eolor, at We... .. 2... e, 21000
6 gals. hard oil, $4.50... . 27.00
10 eals, varnish, at 83.75... .. a7 Ov
1.120 [bs. turpentine, at 66.00.0000... 247.20
1 bags sawdust, at 25e. 0000, 1.00)
—— 2,908 . 25
Keeping ship clean from snow and ice, re
moving debris, and general attendance
and sealing
25.8295) hrs. laborers, at 22'oe.. DST] 64
25 Covers. —Canvas over hateles, ven-
Ulators, and turrets
1.250 Ibs... at 15e SITS4 30
Running heaters to heat ship
5420 hrs. machinists, at 350... 1.89700
Turning over dynamio, steering, boat erane,
ice tiachine, and windlass engines, gal-
ley, ranges and bottom and other rma-
chinery in hull specifications
9800 hours machinists, at 35 .. $2,049.25
9850 hours helpers, at 226. ius end <oo
eicrncectinonnetant 53.366 63
Running air machines at night in order to
obtain pressure to cut armor bolt holes:
extra time which would not have been
necessary had the armor arrived in time
to carry on the work properly
S20) hours machinists, at 35e S287 00
2100 hours helpers, at 22!s¢ a4 O00
aoe 311.00
Tearing out scupper pipes and putting in
place again to allow armor to goon. Tad
the seuppers not been in place the ship
would have been damaged by water: it
Was necessary, therefore, to install the
~cuppers before the armor arrived. . .
1000 hours machinists, at 356... S1.400.00
STO hours helpers, at 22toe.. 198.75
oY WHO hours pattern-makers, at
ot Ye, ... “en ra S560 .00
SOO ft Inmber at 106.0... S000
ans 6. GOR or
Turning ship to avert magnetic polariza
ton
Tow-boat service oo... . $7500
ISO hours riggers, at 80e.. 000... 54.00
6 hours locomotive eranes, at 82.00 IS 00
ENGINE BUILDING CO, VS, THE UNITED STATES. 17
174 men were working on the ship
whose time was lost, but who were
paid, through vir and electric light
connections bemg disconnected for
two hours, each averaging 20c, per
SL . OP le eae epee Orn ee a eae ee 6960
- _ 216.60
Tow-boats breaking ice around ship... ... 15.00
Insurance. —Cancellation value of policies
tts Temes. OOK, FG, FOU «oo as sie lee eo BATH T6
lusuranee whieh would not have been re-
quired had the ship been delivered
Date of begumiag. Cost.
B24.75
September 29 1S99
‘ a IS7 250
30,
October | | Deen as Pea aati tartare Ue ort i a Ti
DOCHINDOT Os dh cs one ; LTO LAT
» Be es See was B20 086
re Rat soak Hig a aie 16.5]
January § 11,1900....... ; O27 2S
¢ ta ig 177 6S
30
February 20, 1900.........4.4.. 8323.00
ae ong eRe SAE Mery oP IST. 26
March Re een tt ae on 202.07
April ee Net Rt IF are ah care St 202.91
de Bee ee ae hanes ered B2O 8D
os at ii ot Pee eel Saar an ... 699.78
A RS ie in 629 36
July Ree es ee ee aie Sot. 23
i SAS ary ne eae eT en 143.75
August ES ee SEGA RPA Cee 1LAOT 90
si re rete i ees, BLA 090
y+ | Nae big tepanseth ae sae 1.20617
«ena Rene SE LN ALN Ee 715.08
eons S1TPSS52 034
Return preniiuins allowed on) cancellation
October 16, 1900, Maoh tts 2,027.04
KO SOS 30
POuil pore. : 2... $70,996.66
J3—5Ub
18 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
Exuipir ©
PrinapeLVHla, December 6, 1900
United States Gov rhinent, Wepartraent of the Navy. Bureau
Stem Miigineering,
to)
The William Cramip & Sons Ship and Engine Build
iene Comm
Dy
Por charges - POy aesrye rheg pore rvertiorm « thie propeddine@ tre
APi\
of the tS bb. Ss Lethe Mh Conmseaqienee ob dela 1) ¢
oO] pletion of {! Vaessett, Lint L din itn fst] } t the fravep
to deliver ber armor at the times and in the order required
to carry on the work property, ft Sent ber 24, TS99, date
expiration of contract, to Noweryhber 16 }ove j ile rredusive
as follows
September, LStith Overhaun Hre-roory blowers, ele
ine boilers, PUne ten porary steam nines, cleanis
feed-tanks and rin ee optiTpede =e An S256 O65
October, IS9% Examining and dabrieatine evlinder-
and piston, runnine tenmorary bilo heLLONE | peypoe
lubricating ane greasing cirendating pumps, overhaul
Ing fire-room, blowers, and tlehtenine up fire main
cc on ia ee aaa ey ar Fe Caer Poe Age Pe ale toa gs
Novennrby Pr. Psa (le; ryt ! coneenss r’ tube overhaul
Ing engine-roon: lower, rejoimting fire ranin pipe.
adjusting main beariies. clenning beilers. running
water boat suction. overhouling drains from fire-roe
blowers, ranuing punaps. and esunining water service
pipe and valy
December, 1889. Overhauling eross head brasses. fit
ting up temporary boilers for heating, raving suetion
pipe from temporary tank. running temporary heater
pipe, overhouting piston rod paeking. runnin
oe tet
porary steam: pipe. lubriesting alr and. feed pumps.
and cleaning hotles 2G
January, [9000 Connecting temporary steam pipe te
stern tubes. getline hellers rendy for stean arensines
pups. exami 1) nisfton prods and valve sten
82 packing, bracketing extension levers on te
porary y ret ' dlonkevinen oy} PEM orary
boiler, hleedin mNtlisy eed orp red ruattl
eovers on temporary bearer ; OT
February, 1200 Willing for amd running water beat
; : ‘
suetioan. «te my ' } wap?
’
.
pu ApS, €K ! i~t} > hb ?
ie :
and stacks. fish i ( ' }
any ’ . ; s : ! igi
Jott and cleanniie | Cx COonneetiopm gn boplers 1o7
ENGINE BUILDING CO. VS. TILE UNITED STATES,
March, 1900.—Overhanling ere-< head ouides and slip-
temipornry steain pre. putting fish oil in
pers, running
boiler tubes. ramming purips, everhan
: ) am
line CraNN shaft,
donkeyman, watchman, overhauling crank pins,
running water boat snetion. firing temporary boiler,
Cleanine ane reodslhiye ! 1] | l re} ‘ ! \ ea
hre-room. assembling and adjusting euid 625.68
April, 1900.—Overhauline ms ne oT psto
DONS, GIscon ect Tevrppocteyy Peoria] rm ng
pumps. overhauls ited Onne temnorart
tend pipes. cle: ! { ! oOve;l
hauhine blower are SHonsiol
links. overh ' ‘ DbO..2e
May. 1900 i
bhatt re}
boilers. dis ecting and
pipe, eXmmining feed a
tharv feed pumps. overbeidine
6 putinps overhauling 4 ut ’ |
Inine MeCorib steaine Nuts
Pulp, Cleenineg and ore rristed
bilge suction plage. overbear|i thir
service, rejoiit! hotter dy HIDE. OVE
hrieator Verbatiling safety y \ ! YH1 66
June, 900 \djustine tin rrryit
purups, donkevian. overhiaantine @ enya
cocks, rejointing auxiliary feed drains verhaniing
drains fron dyn mno-rootus. over] ' iy eoid
fo crane reqorntiine suundiiage stent ind exhaust
Pipes 184 3]
fuly. 1900 Donkeviian. rpuonnine 2 , averhanlin
ane reqotntiiya <4 larg] ge} . H
chinery 200 58
\ueust, 1900 Ponmkewrnear ‘ o}} at Tei tan litho iN
} a t nn? ly , a! , }
Piveal steatn cibaittis, @lenminp tUTheh OPPO sist ! bie?
NOT tenatm ame avxtiiary st it ]
,
blowers ane pruldaipos vern rie tery %
i
. 1 5 ’
reroprnty " ary. 9 ‘
ee, rehtent ' qetred t) ‘ ? boesttevny i = my ry
pistons, tichtenine hole covers. tightening jeints
ys: ‘ ’ 3 :
On CVIINGePS, ENG Piste eit MB CN
° . 1 ’
NTTRELEE ool { ) ' THE TET rf] 39
Sprites } Perey { ; asf
bheee'y ( '
i985
| ‘ (y ) { 1
yore Ors
| , H40 14
ony } ~ ~ 1 an) wi
} ty Teiey xe)
20 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
156 gals. lubricating oil, at 60e.. 20... 93.60
. fs oo. eh ee eee 12.00
—$ 1.3546 40
BOE or 8 eee aN IE. oa a a ae ee $7,587 . 48
35 I1.——Traverse. Filed December 12, 1905.
In the Court of Claims of the United States, December Tern,
i ee,
No. 22,535.
THE WILLIAM Cramer & Sons Suite & Exatxe Buinpinc Compasy
vs,
Tne Unirep Srares.
And now comes the Attorney General, on behalf of the United
States, and answering the petition of the claimant herein, demic
each and every allegation therein contained: and asks judement that
the petition be dismissed.
L. A. PRADT.
Assistant Attorney General
36 Il1.—A rgument and Submission.
On the 12th and 13th days of December, 1905, this cause wos
argued by Mr. James TH. Hayden, for the claimant, and by Mr. fF. W
Collins, for the defendants, and submitted.
Subsequently, to wit, on December 28, 1907, the case was on
manded to the Trial Calendar for oral argument by the following
order :
It is ordered that this case be remanded to the Trial Calendar for
the reasons stated in memorandum,
Memorandum.
Argument is desired solely upon the question of the effeet of. the
final receipt and wherein the execution thereof takes it out of th:
recent decision of the Supreme Court in the ease of The Willian
Cramp and Sons Ship and Engine Building Company respecting thy
battle ship Indiana.
By roe COURT
Accordingly on December 4. 1907, Mr. James Th Hayden was
heard for the claimant and Mr. F. W. Collins for the defendants and
the case was resubmitted.
ENGINE BELLDING CO. VS. THE UNITED STATES, 21
OF LV Findings of Fact and Conclusion of Law and Opinion
of the Court. Filed February 4. T9OS.
Tue Wintiam Cramp & Sons Sup axp Exaixe Bt thpine
Company
v.
Tur Uxrrep Srares
This case having been heard by the Court of Claims. the court,
upon the evidence, makes the following
Findings of Fact
I.
The claimant is a corporation Incorporated and existing under the
laws of the State of Pennsylvania
1]
On September 24. 1S96. the Claimant and the Uriited States en
tered tite the contract, annexed to the petition herein, providing for
the construction and delivery of a battle ship designated as “Battle
ship No. 8,” abil row known as ine. & = * \labaria.” sud con
tract being designated as “Exhibit A.”
ITT.
Upon the execution of the said) contract the clarmant made all
preparations necessary for the commencement of work upon the
construction of the said battle ship. December 2. 1896. her keel
Was laid. and thereafter the work progressed with due dispatch, and
the battle ship would have been completed) and ready for delivery
within the contract period if the Government had delivered to the
Catmant the arnuor and armor bolts within the times and in the
order required to carry on the work properly. as obligated <o ta do
by Clause 3 of the contraet
Vv.
Ih due course the chiammant furnished to the Uriited States working
drawings and tommplates, showing the dimensions and shape of enely
ind everv armor plate required for use in the construction of thre
satd battle ship
38 V
On or about February 15, TSO. work tipon the vessel tard pre
eressedl tan port where the delivers of her Internal arhner heeamie
necessary, dn order that her comstruetion nitohit proceed within the
Contract period The first tristalliavent of plates for tie ro interna!
rer was not received by claimant until December 22. TSO. and
the last istallments Were tet delivered hy le ferdants unite Moreh
I. 1899. and notwithstanding these hindrances the chumeant prose
Cited the work Wyn the vessel, in “Oy fur and im Tinpor In its it could ay
done.
22 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
VI
On May TS. PS9S, the said battle ship was launehed. She had
then progressed toward completion to the extent of about oo per
cent.
Vil.
On or about June 350, ESOS, the supermtending constructor, aetin.
as the representative of the United States at the claimant's shipyard
made a report to the Chief of the Bureau of Construction and Repen
no which he stated
“Tt is estimated that on June 30. 1S98. the vessel (“A /labaimna’
Was 60 per cent completed. The contractor's trial, tinal couipletio
and delivery of the vessel to the government will depend entire!
Wpron the delivery of the armor and armament, and the shin -houwld
he ready for final delivery to the government within two months
after the receipt of the armor and armiunent at the shipbuilding
vard.’
at “tated further threat the probable date of the vesse]'s final Coty
pletion was September 28 T8900) that estimate being based upon th
SMP positron threat all rmrbror worttle hy delivered without undue dle fits,
Vill
On dre & TSOS. the United States entered inte a contraet with
the Bethleli Nia [ron CCoriipeans which provided for the PEVPPDUD Pree eye
and delivers by the latter of the armor required for thr said: batt!
ship.
IN
\fter the liunehing of the sad battle ship.oain order that wor!
prot her mieht proceed in proper rder to complet her within the
contract period. the claimant required for use certain parts of her
external armen namely, the plates for her side arnror or rain be!
~1de casemiates, Upper and lower: ban the United States did) not
Mav TS. SOS. deliver the same Plates for the external armor of th:
satd battle <hin were delivered to the elatmant from time te
between May 27. TS99. and June 7, 1900. as follows
Armor, Date of delivers
Side or main belt Mav 27 to Nov 10, }soo
Lower side casenates Noy 28, 1899, to Jan. 3, 1900
Upper stde Casenuites Jan. 3 to Feb PTB. 1000
uy Upper side casemate
wings Jan. 12 to Feb, 12, 1900
Signal tower June 15. PS99
Turret——aft Vor Ste Apr 2b psoe
Turret. forward Mav 9 to June 7. 1900
Hineh Qua protections Sept, 28 to Oet. 1. 1S99
\
On oor choot Tine DO) TOO) the <apertntending eonmstruetor, aett
as the POP POSO HE ALEV of the United States at the clitmant’s shiny vard
ENGINE BUILDING CO, VS. THE UNITED STATES Z
Hade a report to the Chiei of the Bureau of Constructi
which he stated
"The vesse] is at present estimated to he 7 per cent. comy leted,
L estimate that the date of the offical trial earn de bout Nugust 15,
100. and that the ship will be ready for commuissioni by the 50th
of September, 1900"
\1
Onoor about July DPS. TS99. a strike cecurred none the workme
Cr
n the Claimant’. vir, which involved tran id 4 SOOO rien I
ditlerernt tines between sted dent tid the oarts mriy ‘ 1enyey It i.
how) threat sid strike isatevialts bitriede oy i rk
} the laheoiwa Vhe ond workine ) hie | | it
the strike were about 160 riveters. but the reuse
lle tine thier Hter installed a ey { of oyaebpinne t | hii ~
Which the elutmant was enabled te iy re she ‘ ;
work, and by std tears expedited the work bevornd wheat would
nave dor basic “ited riveters pot porred ty thre <tr)
NII
rom June 7, 100, wher thr
last shipment of rior piste for the
— beat lt stipe Wiis deliv read to the
Claimant the wor chine
Sb tiioan, loin elvis order aid with al
J tr- bile oe ] ted
Hew otlieral tris ct ~peed test Wie hie 7 on AW st (702) 1H)
October r 16, P00, she was delivered to the United s "
ent inte: Commndisstem as Vessel af thie United sstiite Navy
XII
Ihy Pocsony cof the fehure of thr ly tee Steite te fare by thy } yt
m thy rad bottle ~hip is oat Was required tooenrry oo | ‘ of dies
iietion properly, her completion was delayed for period of
“ days
NI\
Ny orenson oof delavs on the part oof the armor contraetors. the
Or Wits lief delivered it) thie char thite caupyyT is get {
Houlel drave been. ane the vesse Wits not fe ered to the endant
| Odetortney lt. }Ona
Upon thr request of thie elityrisitt Cony Coty } ‘ !
eat Hearth uate eptember 28. TSO the Sacer, the
() Navy. on October 9, IS9O by letter. not ed the ¢
pany that the “prow of the ninth ise the eorntract
he Constrnetion Posand vessel, pelatiy for «le 1 the
CL price for ad will be suspended for a4 ree
! thy | ite ‘ ' ’ ' thre eNXtoOn
wel Cde-tarbiet ] wy P erpedat he BR w
Steamy Enis ern | ¢ rine nd WR bie
e for the completion of the Alabama was duls | Si
} i] ! ! cone ‘ () ay) , Pa
| nseauence af tis exis ;
2+ THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
Was nade from the contract price of the vessel, which wae pated (i
the claimant company in full,
XV.
On February 9, 1901, the claimant directed a letter to the Seere-
tary of the Navy in which it made claim for the damage which it
had sustained in consequence of the said failures and delays of th
United States.
On February 13, 1901, the Secretary of the Naws directed the fel-
lowing letter to the claimant:
Navy DePaki MENT,
Wiasnminaron, Fe hruary 13. 1907
GENTLEMEN Referring lo vour letter of the Oth instant, enelosing
statement of geeount and claiming retriburserent. in the sam of
SG6.973.28. of expenses incurred in caring for the A/abaned ane her
machinery during the delay in her completion, for whieh it is alleged
the Government d+ responsible. TP have te state that while. from
casual consideration of the matter. it might seem: proper that the
papers should be referred to the bureans concerned for eX bat ion
and report. it appears. after a careful consideration of the subject,
that the claim. being for unliquidated damages. is of a kind the
Department has ne authority under the baw te entertann
Very respectfully,
JOIN PD LONG Neeretary
The Willian Cramp & Sons. Ship and Engine Building Conpany
Philadelphia. Penna
On April 15, 1901, the claimant, by it< counsel, directed the fo!
lowing letter to the Seeretary of the Navy
WasHiIneton, DOC). Apr bo, 190}
In the Matter of the Final Release on the U.S. 8. blrhame
Sin in behalf of the William Cramp & Sens Ship and Engine
Building Company we beg to say
The company is in receipt of these papers whieh von sent te rt for
execution: (1) A form for the final release to be given on deen
of the construction of the UL S28. Aahwme. and (LTD) a ter
4] of the contract whereby the company will agree toe imderunf
the United States against all miatner of deriands rade foro:
on aecount of the use of the patented inventions employed in thy
construction of the vessel.
We enclose to vou herewith the contract of tdemmnity: duly es
ecuted by the company,
We also enclose a final release duly exeeuted. We invite vou
attention to a proviso, inserted by the company. which does tet o
pear in the forms of release presented by vou. This proevice i
follows (p>. se
ENGINE BUILDING CO. V8. THE UNITED STATES, 25
Provided That nothing hereon <bal] Operate as a waiver of this
COMMPRINY s riehit tr athe for sped recover Judoinert Hh the Court of
Clatt~ for daniages ineurred or losses sustained by the company In
the prosecution of the contract werk which were occasioned by de-
lave or defaults on the peat of the | tiited States.”
On February 9. 1901, the conpany presented to vou a claim for
lamiices to the amount of se 7i vs. Which it had sustained by
resmson ane as a result of the fathure ef the United Stites to furnish
immer, te be tised in the construction of the vessel, at the times and
ti the Peesstiteet prescribed bay thre contraet for the construetion of the
vesse]
In vour letter directed te the eompary on Bi bruary 13, 1901, you
=! ited that thi elaine, he eeey fe whignidated nage x, US of a hind
the Depart cent teas we athe “i sree the law to entertain.”
It hiss freepentiy beer beld byw the Supreme Court of the United
States and by the Court of Clater that the head of an Executive
Department is net vested with juri<dietion te hear and determine
ati for unliquidated dames, even though they may grow out of
contract. tiade ly bits depeurtierndt
Ly the net of Maireh 7, ISN? kevewn as thre ‘Tucker Act,” the
Court of Claims ix vested with turtedietion to hear and determine
stich elaits
The release subnoitted by vou. witheut qualification, such as the
TOV ise inserted hy thie compan werraled undoubtedly be held to
nelude net onty all claims whieh vou have passed upon and over
hich veu might have jurisdietion. but also claims which vou had
of entertamed and over whieh won pessess no jurisdiction. By ex-
enting the release without the qualification the company would be
leprivecl of the rohit te seek and obtain its remedy in the only forum
pessessitise purtselietions in the prPetritses Tha provisn inserted does
ot affect the etlietenes or comtietetress of thre relense so far as it
deals with mittters coming within wour jurisdiction We diet that
OU WHT] approve the release as arene, appreeniting that it merely
preserves the corey, ! ulit ter thie die Wing anid adpidieation of its
eatin. as preserthed by the ° Tue tp”
Wi re ~peetfully Peaqtiest Vang te oreder Peavenert to thre COMMpPany for
the stan of S10.000. the amgunt of the consideration named in the
release
Very respectfulls MeCA\MMON & HAYDEN,
The Hheory Jobin |) Loony Seeretiat if thre Nav
WN Oh April 17. 1900. the Seeretary of the Navy directed to
the elatmant’. counsel the following letter
Navy DervrrM en,
Wiastincros, Lpril 17, 1904
spas hatersachad efor Hige ts eur letter of the loth instant. imelos
ng 2 final release exeenterd by the W Wn Cramp & Sons Ship and
Engine Building Conmmany. under the contract for th Re SL Ny
Dread I have te state that the proviso inserted in the last
+ —— 30M
26 THE WILLLAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
=
paragraph of sata reine, (oot vac thereta contaiied shall oper.
ale us a Watver or the cotapany’s right to sue in the Court of Claims
for alleged damiaeos arising from delays and defaults on the part of
the Government curing the con-truction of said vessel, t= mot Huecepl
able to the Dey ritnenk.
After cons iderniion oo the matters set forth in vour letter, and the
discussion of the sclicet between Mr. Phavden. of your firma, and the
Judee-Ndveocate-Cienersl the Denartment will aecept a release tr
seid COMPLE awn in secordanee with the form forwarded to the
contractors tn its hi ON Yoon. of the 9th Instant, with the follow-
Ing provicion. whitely excepting the substitution of “elaims’ for
rpohe” is sui tintds hint was suecested by Mr. Tlavden
namie] Provided. That this release shall not be taken to inelids
Claims avisti: a tba i contract other than those whieh the
Seer LAT O1 the Nav listed Hiriselietion fooentiort Wn fs
Upon receipt of release property executed tn form as mdieated
herein, vouchers in favor of the Willjam Cramp Sons Ship ani
Engine Buildine Company wilh be approved for payment of the
balances due under the eontract less the 820.069 contemplated In
said relen-e
The veleas ‘ favith vour letter i herewith returned
Very respectfully,
. JOUN DD. LONG. Seeretary
eal eB
Messrs, MeCammon & THavden, No. 1420 F Street No W., Wash-
ington, D.C.
XV1
On April PY 1901. the chiiniant. by it. counsel, directed the fol-
lowing letter to the Sceretary of the Naw
Wastinetox, DOC April 20, 190)
Sir We ~enal vou herewith a finial relosuse execuled hy the W il-
liam Cramp & Sone ship and Eneine Building Company, aoder the
contract for the con-trnetion of the A/lebawe. This eontains a
¢lanse which excepts Tro the operation of the release claims arising
under the contraet why ‘yh vou. as Seeret iTV of the Navy, had not
jurisdiction to entertain, the chunse being the one set out im vou
letter of the U7th instant
Verv respectfilly, WeCAMMON & TEAYDEN
To the Honorable the Secretary of thre Navy
13 The tollowing release was transmitted with the foregone
letter:
ENGINE BUILDING CO, VS. THE UNITED STATES, 27
RELEASE.
Unde r Contract Dated Nepile mboy 2A, IS. noth the W iam Cramp
and Sons Nh ip cated Menge Baal Ming hh, Oi Py for the ¢ ‘onstrue-
hion of Batth Nh p Va oF, thy fi {li hary tye Gols
Whereas by the cleventh clause of the contract dated September
24. T8986. Dy and between the William Cr amp and Sons Ship and
Engine Building Cotman, parts af ihe first part, and the United
States, party of the seeond pert. for the CODSEMTETION of battle ship
No. 8, the b/odiia, it is; roreed: that a spectl reserve of s “INV thou-
sand (SG0.0000) dollars shall be held until the vessel -hall have been
finally tied, provided threat stich lintel trial shall take place within
five mouths fromr and after the tlate of the prelitninary aeceptance
of the vessel: anid
Whereas by the seventh paragraph of the ninerconth clause of
«tid contract it is further provided that when all the eonditions.
coveriants, ane provistoms of <aid ontract <liall have been ! vlormied
and fultilled by andoon the part of the party of the fet part said
party of the first paat shall be entitled. within ten day after the
filinver steed aecephinee of its elit. bo receive the snid “pred ial reserve,
or the Surry tus, if wy, of the ssid reserve fund, Or so ried) of ¢ tther
as the sata prarty of the (rst pecurt ryraa be entitled ta, on the execu-
tion of a final release to the party of the second part, m auch form
us shall hn opproved lw the Secretary of the Navy. of all « aims of
any kind or deseription under or by virthe of said contraet: ‘and
Sebi “tide vosse] Wil preltsinaurdds aeceptod on the 22nd day
of October, 1900, gid her tinal trial conmplered March 11, 1901: and
Whi revs al] the conditions, COVeT EES. and prov hans at eatd con-
tract have been performed and fabltitled bye sad the mart of the
party of the fir-t part. excepting certal i! vote. Tedieieneies,
and items of Hiiconipletod work, to cover wht i noob iwenty
thousand dollars is, according to oan undorstuidine between the re-
“pective parties to sate contract, and as stated in the letter dated
April 9 1901 (No. YOTO-OT). of the Secretary of the Navy to the
parties of the fir-t part. to be withheld by dhe party of the second
part mati the completion of the vessel im said ress na
Whereas owing to the ti ypedtenesy at this thine of Loeping the
Alahejue ata Wavy vile leony ’ enonoh for thie loine of the work in
question, the party of the second prart has consented ta rav fo the
parties of the first part all balinees due aiider HH eontroct, except.
Ine th Hel special reservation of twonty the lolly
Now, therefore. tn onsideration of the prey Hy my of forty
thousand dallars (8 10.000 1] srriemanit oof thy Overssi peetal
erve Joes. thy above-nremd oned reservatian of : thousand dol-
rs (ZOO). heqiic to me dn dand nad ly a | the Sisntes,
represen tod Try thre Secretary oof the Nay the receipt 4 hereof is
hereby selknowledged. the Willian: Cran Hd Say Shin and
Kicvine Buildine Company. represented by te. Chas th Crarmn
reste nif ssrd commaay, dees he reby, form pfx offs Steees-ors
2S THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIIIP AND
and assign- and it- legal representatives, remise. release, and for-
ever discharge the United States of and from all and all manner of
debts, dues. st and stuns of money, accounts. reckonings. clatnis,
and demands whatsoever in law and in equity, for or by rea-
44 son of or on account of the construction of said) vessel under
the contract aforesated, excepting the sum of twenty thousand
dollars. withheld by the Seeretary of the Navy as above set forth
Provided, Vlhiat this release shall net be taken to include claims
arising under the <aid contract other than those which the Secretary
of the Navy had jurisdiction to entertain,
In witness whereof the Willtan Cramp and Sons Ship and Eneime
Building Company has caused its corporate mame to be hereunte
subseribed aid it- corporate seal te be affixed this nineteenth day
of April, 1901, by Charles Th. Cranup. its president.
[Seal of the Willian: Cramp and Sons Ship and Engine
Durtleding Co. |
THE WILLEAM CRAMP AND SONS SHTP
AND ENGINE BUILDING COMPANY,
By CHAS. TE CRAMP. President,
Attest:
CILAS. T. TAYLOR, Seeretary
On April 20. 1901. the Judge-Ndvecate-CGeneral. by direction of
the Secretary of the Navy. directed the following letter to claimant's
counsel
Navy DEPARTMENT,
Orrick of THE Jt par ADVOCATE-GENERAL,
WiastixGron, Apri] 20, 190]
GENTLEMEN The final release by Messrs. Cramp & Sons under
the contract for the A/eheme, received with vour letter of this date,
and the patent guaranty by the sate company previously received,
have been approved lw the Department,
By direction of the Secretary
Very respectfully. SAM. C. LEMLY
Judge -ldrocate-General
Messrs. MeCanition & Haveen, Nev, 1420 F Street N. W... Wash
meton, DO.
XVII
The leust pauvinenyt om seeount of battle ship Las a * Plahaa
was made on or about \ueust 26. 1902) as set forth in the follow
ing voucher
ENGINE BULLDING CO, VS. THE UNITED STATES au
Quadruplicate. Noo 895s Bo 6
The (oS Navy Department to Win. Crampoand Sons Ship and
Mngine Building Company, Dr
Appropriation, Terease of the Navy, “Construction and Machinery
Battleship: Now S.** Alabama.’ Date of contract
September 24. 2806
Ane Se. Pel } Por amount withheld on vouchers of April 20. boa]
the vessel lia lige been finally aecepted STO OOO OO)
Loess
Destactions faa uncompleted work on huidlanad mevetin
| ery (as per statement of items attached) as follows
|
{
On tial S832 55
| Onomachimers 70S
| 1. IT Sthol
Viniount paver IS,S}0050
1 Navy DerarTMEN’T.
WASHINGTON, [). CUA ugust POH. TOO]
We hereby certify that this bill is correct,
DARIUS GREEN,
Lehing Chief of Bureau of Construction and Repar,
4: B.S.
GEO. W. MELVILLE
Linger m Chie. USN
Chief of Bureau of Nteam Linge rong
Navy DrepartMent, Wasningrox, D.C
\pproved for the sti of eighteen thousand eight hundred and
en and 39° 100 dollars. pavable by purchasing pay officer at Phila
delphia. Pa
rE. W: RACK ETT.
Aeting Neeretary of the Navy
Jat ‘ dollars in full of
Recerved, a
the above bill
Nt the vine yl tit ED Es Chargeable tis Countracto ‘SN Onn Aer stigil / lH ”) Do it
and Materials Furnished at the Navy Yard. Neu York. to he Deducted
m Vouchers for Final Parijanent
On Plu]
Lissboon Miter: Por
Replace Cust t t? trap H i Viilte
eneines With ¢ ry t i ostrapos ~ SOF + . St
Ke en POPtv secs bolts for side lights and
pina ! Zen ents ’ #4) i }
helitting and stitl ~pons shutters of forward
t ch guns ridin deek S440) ; | {
350 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
On Machinery
i ining up starboard Hl. P. engine S47.80 31 G7 S40 47
Repairing auxiliary starboard dise har: ue pipe i in eae h
ene PAO Wy a or kel sds ate a eee ad BL i! 15.4%
Placing stop vale in dee machine system, : LUS.o4 YON le
Making stop valve at upper end of steam: pipe ‘to
auxiliary feed puinps accessible from fireroom
TOOE ne act eis Die Chines cae ase P66 11.60 38
Fitting salin meter pots for ey pore itors nou 4? Ny Jn.
Covering steate pipes 24.52 1.20 ws
PAS, 2 Os Tt Ti]
Hull BSS. 20}
Machinery... D7 0S
Total Lise
46 XVI.
By rearoti of the idl -everal failures and delays of the Unite
of the armor for the said batt
ship, ania the de af t\ Wn hier « and dithe ities CNT rreneed ]
her cons: truetion cot equent thereon, the clatraant wae put to ext’
exXpehee in the perforniinice of the contract iu suit. anvdd stistanine
damage to the amount of S40. 792.66. ‘The items of the said exti
expense and damage were is follows
Wharfage: September 24. 1899. to October LO. [900
BS7 dave at S500 per month, including watehing. 0. See t0.0
Electric Hghting—Hluminating SAS days during
the above pertod, at #46.12..
furnishing
comapletions
States with Reapers to the
vesse|
16,049 .7
Painting-——Touching up and repamting
water bottoms, trimming tank. coffer-
dams. boiler rooms, dynamo rooms, en-
gine rooms, woodwork, military masts,
outside oof hull. and cork painting
throughout ship. and turpentining decks
5.000 hours painting, at ssf e. S1.520 00
8.825 lbs. red-lead oil, at 10.6. 382 50
1.750 Ibs. color, at 12 « 10.00
6 e@als. hard oil, at 88.75. 29 50
10 @als. varnish, at $3.02. . BO PO
4.120 Ibe. turpentine, at 6¢ 247 .20
16 bags sawdust, at 256. 4.00
j cleat from ~The and Ce,
attendance and sealing
Keepme -hy
and Col ral
PU S298) hrs. laborers. at | ad i ee ae
Covers —Canvas over hatches, ventilators. and turre
£2306 ths... ab tore. Wie
(Pp. 92 -93. )
Teron ine debris,
i
POOR COPY
ENGINE BUILDING CO. VS. THE UNITED STATES.
Hhunning heaters to heat ship
o. 420 brs.. machinists. at 2S e@..
Turning over dynamo, steering, boat crane. iee machine
}
ryal
and windlass engines, galley. ranges, and blower. a
ether machinery in hull ~pecifications
O50 hrs. machinists, at 2S e.. S1.639 40
5.599 lirs., helpers, at 16.16 D412 66
Running air machines at night in order to Obstertny pore
ure to cut armor bolt holes: extra time whieh wonld
not have been necessary had the artior arrived im tines
to carry on the work properly
S20 hre.. machinists. at 2S ¢ SPIO BL
240 hrs. helpers, at 16.1 ¢ IS 64
Tearing out scupper pipes and putting mm place again te
low armor to goon. Tad the <Cuppers not heen tr
place thi hip would have been damaged Tw water
Was necessary, therefore, to install the scuppers before
the armor arrived
1,000 hrs. machinists, at 2S ¢ S1.P20 000
STO hirs.. helpers, at 16.1 ¢ 110 07
960 hrs. pattern makers, at 80.6 ¢ 2G 16
SOO ft. lumber, at 106 S000)
Turning ship to avert magnetic polarization
Towhoat service eters S75 00
ISO his., riggers, at 18.5 33.30
6 hrs.. locomotive eranes. at S32. IS 00
Ivf men were working on the ships
Whore time was lost. but who were
pad. through air and electrice-lght
connections being disconnected — for
two hours, each averaging 20 ¢ per
hour. or HO 60
Towboats’ service. breaking ice around ~hip
17
Insurance
Cancellation value of polreres hh force
Septeniber 25, PSa9 S5.7H4 16
Renewals Of Tusuranee evidenced hy
sid policies puld between Septernber
24. 1S99) and October 16. 1900 H.058 20
YSLe 26
Deduet cancellation Value of said pot
CIES 1 turned to Claimant October 14)
1g00 2,027.04
17 F
> 580
ESN
1.633
195
1
32 YHE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
Maintenance and upekeep of propelling machinery :
Septeniber, Iso Overhauling fire-reom blowers.
cleanite boilers, running temporary steane pipes.
cleaning feed-tanks and running pumps subse-
quent to 24th... 6. eect eee ences L11..
October, ISO9—-Examining and lubricating cylin-
ders and pistons, rHnniig temporary bilge suction
pipe. lubricating and greasing circulating puraps,
overhauling fire-room blowers, and tightening up
Cee COAG SOT os is ses hae eee 6s ee LUSZ
November, IS99— Cleaning condenser tubes, over:
hauling engine-room blower, rejointing fire-main
pipe. adjusting main bearings, cleaning boilers.
raining water-hoat suetion, overhauling drains
from fire-room: blowers. running pumps and ex
amining water service pipe and valves... 0...
December, 1890 Overhauling eress-head bras-e-.
fitting up temporary boilers for heating, running
suction pipe from temporary tank, running tem:
porary heater pipe, overhauling piston red pack
ine. running temporary steam: pipe. lubricating
air and feed pumps. and cleaning boilers... ... 2A7
January, 19000 Condueting temporary -team pipe
to stern tubes, getting boilers ready for steam,
ereasing pumps, examining piston reds and valve
stem packing, bracketing extension levers on tem
porary suction, donkey-mnan on temporary boiler,
bleeding auxiliary feed pipes, and putting covers
on temporary LO EN ae oO eer gene os
February, 1900-—Drilling for and running water
hont suetion, donkey-man on temporary boiler,
running pumps. cleaning feed tanks, putting fish
oil in boilers and stacks, fish oiling tubes, renew
ine auxiliary steam joints, and cleaning back
connection in boilers... 0.000.000... tM Sere a
March, 1900— Overhauling eross-head) guides and
slippers. runing temporary steam pipe, putting
fish oil in boiler tubes. running pumps, overhaul:
ing erank shaft. donkey-man. watchman, over:
hauling erank pins. running water boat suction,
firing temporary boiler, cleaning and greasing
machinery, repacking valves in fire-room, assem
bline and adjusting enides.. 00.0.2... a
April, 1990 Overhanling packing in piston stuffing
hoxes, disconnecting temporary boiler, running
pumps, overhauling guides, connecting temporary
steam) pipes. cleaning and greasing machinery,
overhauling blowers, examining and adjusting
suspension links, overhauling stop valve gear,
donkev-man 348
BO]
ENGINE BUILDING CO, VS. THE UNITED STATES,
May, 1900—-Running purnps, pumping bilge, don-
kev-man, rejoining auxiliary steam valves, clean-
ing boilers, disconmectiirg and removing Ler po-
rary steani pipe, examiing feed putuip pistons,
overhauling auxiliary feed puraps. overhauling
fire and bilge putops. overhauling main feed
pumps, examining MeConib strainers, examining
sanitary: opurmps. cleaning and greasing mia-
chinery, examining bilge suction plugs, overhaul
Ine thrust bear Walter ser 1ee, rerori tie howler
drain pipe. overhaul
safety valve gear ;
June, 1900-— Adjusting turning engine. running
Pultips. donkev-miat, overhauling biloe suetion
© lnbricators. overhauling
plug COM ke. it Jointing TLUEEN TEDL feed drains, over-
hauling drains from dyname-roome. overhauling
joints, steam) to crane. rejornting auxiliary steam
and exhaust pipes. : a
July. 1900—Donkev-rian. rutting putaps. over
hauling and rejotnting stecm to deek machiners
getting boilers ready for steam. overhauling
boilers, turning miachiners
4s
August. 19000—Donkev-man. enuimeer. rejornting
wuNiliary steam drains. cleaning and greasing
machinery, examining math and auxthiary steam
joints. running blowers and purips. overhauling
=
steam Gari S¥St@M). rejqornting heoiler nanhole
plates. overhauling off serviee. tightening joints
}
in Water bottom. orf stowine pistons. tightening
manhole covers. theahtemmmye joints on evlinders
eXumiining pistons. cleaning berlers. examining
valve chests. exatiiniing putups
rt
plenrber, 100 Cleaning botlers. donkev-man,
enorme er, ele | hie mn | ore mane rope bina ry; tioht
ening main auxiliary stesa and exhaust joint
October, LQOQ 2 Clenrntne
meer, VUE putipyes. clennine tiny! GTCUSING Mr,
chinery te Oet. 16. L900) ine a
B50 tons biturineus conl. at S3 S1.050 00
424 eals. fish oil at Dre 140 SO
:
, $
horlers donkey Prieith, EMO
56 gals. lubricating otf at GO. q
200 Tbs. waste. at He 1? 00
Total
Less overcharges On) bar Ol miaehinists inh miaintersanes
and upkeep of propelling machinery, 13.575 hours,
tl 7 cents per how
Making i tots! aut
h—300
—"
—
33
248 .98
V4 ool
200.48
A41 40
Qs Sf
329 S4
46 40
N90 25
799 66
34 THE WILLIAM CRAMP & SONS SHIP AND
Conclusion of Law.
Upon the foregotng findings of facet the court decides as a con
clusion of law that the petition be distuissed and judgrient ordered
for the defendants under the authority of the case of United Stat,
vy. Woe. Cramp & Sons, ete. (206 UL S.. 118).
Opinion.
Per Curiam:
The contract tn this case. respecting the language of the tinal re
lease upon the completion of the vessel and the payient of the ve
serve therein mentioned, is the same as in the ease of Cited States v.
Cramp and Sous (206 US. LIS). wherein the court said
“The sixth Clause of this paragraph Hiatkes ~pectal provision fo
the last payment. to be tiade ‘when all the conditions, covenants, and
provisions of said contract shall have been performed and fultilled
by and on the part of the party of the first parts and ton the execu
tion of a final release to the United States im such forme as shall be
approved by the Secretary of the Navy, of all claims of any kind or
description under or by virtue of said contract. Evidently the
parties contemplated and specially provided by this stipulation that
the whole matter of the contract should be ended at the time of thi
final release and the last payinent. That which was to be releawesd
was ‘all clattas of any kind or description under or by virtue of said
contract. Manifestly. ineluded within this was every claim: arising
not merely from a change in the specifications, but alse @rowing ov
of delay caused by the Government. The language is not alon
‘claims under’ but ‘clatmie by virtue’ of the contract — chains of
any kind or description. ATL the claims for whieh allowances wer
made in the judginent of the Court of Claims come within one or thi
other of these causes. Tt imay be that, strictly speaking. they were
not claims under the contract, but they were clearly claims by virtua
of the contract. Without it ne sueh elatuis could diave arisen
49 Now, it having heen providod in oaedveunee thie the contrac
should he closed by the execution of a release of this scope |
can not be that the company, when it signed the release. underston
that some other or lesser release was conteniplited. Tt riust hav
understood that it was the release required by the contraet—a re
lease intended to be of all elaims of any kind or deseription under or
by virtue of the contract. and that the form of words which thi
Secretary had approved was used to express that purpose. * * *
It is only by reason of the performance of the contract in the ear
struction of the vessel that these elaine arise. Bit for the contract
and the construction of the vessel ander it, there would be ne sted
claims. * * * Tf parties intend to leave some things open and
unsettled their intent so to do should be rinde minifest”
That language evidently has reference to the contract and its nm
quirements and therefore when the contract tn ternis mroavides that
the reserve or final payment will be made “when all the condition.
1
i
1
{
ENGINE BULLDING CO. VS. THE UNITED STATES oO
covenmts, and provisions of said contract shall have been performed
and fulfilled by and on the partof the party of the fist part,” the
clan wats, pon such pravrnent, obligated to sten the release pro-
vided by the terms of the contract releasing the Government from
“all claims of any kind or deseription under or by virtue of said
contract And. strive eel Court dy the cast cited holds that the re
ease of all clans growing out of the construction of the vessel
without whieh such elaine would wot have
of the contract and settled. as the court save. all
the partios iis : melding unliquidated
clatms——the Seeretury of the Nave in respect thereto mot only had
thre rioht fo weeept stich release in the Interest of the Crovernmient,
brit ttieler thi contract it was bias duty toda so
Therefore it rrntast bo hele threat. when the vessel was complet d
he reserve patd. the rights of the parties were determined by the
contract self and) ried thre lerroviaee of the releuse It follows th
arisen Was a recognition
disputes hetween
to chums sted Upon
ind
oni the auithrorit of ths, or! cited the petition Tritist ay dismissed,
whieh fs necorea nol lorie thiel bdorient i~ ordered to by entered for
the defendant
mo) y Judame ntoof the Court
No Aopen)
Mik Wittiam Crawe anp Soxs Sup asp Exaise Borpixe
COMPANY
Pie UNirep Srares
Ata Court of Clatms held tr the (atv of Washington on the 8d
lav of February, T9OS. judgment was ordered to be entered as fol
premises tire
ty fi] Onistele Viatteo aot the {
do order, adjudee and deeree that the petition thi
fendanits, and
latmcant. Phe Wallin tu & Sons Ship and Eneoine Iuildine
Conmipeaniy bi supvel thie cltpie ~ hereby Manni
By rie COUR’
tilrance of. Appeal
Poe Wiettaw Crawe wwe Sox, Sump any Exarse Br ILDING
(iu ~~ S } 1 phil
Tite ( BD: STATES
Ire hie rie rit 1! ley 114 thre tu ‘ } eel ‘ ol thie
he fol ) 1 4aays " { on oe .¢0 lef’ ‘ this elay
t. bn t Thorens ) Ieediy hil | Po) | poly {
ob WM. CRAMIE & SONS SHIIIP AND ENGINE BLDG. CO. VS, U. 8.
wid gives notice of an appeal to the Supreme Court of the United
States,
MeCAMMON & HAYDEN,
Attorneys for Claimant
Filed February 4, 1908
FEBRUARY 5, 1908
Ordered that the above application for appeal be allowed as
praved for
By rue COURT
_te
VII Certificate,
In the Court of Claims
No. 22535
Tue Witniam Cramer axp Sons Suip anxp ExGixne Burtping
COMPANY
vs,
The Unitvep States
I, John Randolph, Assistant Clerk Court of Claims, hereby certify
that the foregoing are true transeripts of the pleadings in the above-
entitled cause: of the findings of fuet and conelusion of law: of the
Opinton of the Court: of the Hhiedorrenst of the Court distiissing the
petition: of the application for, and allowanee of, appeal to the
Supreme Court of the United States
Thy testin Oni\ whereof | have hereunto set mis hand and affixed
the seal of said Court of Claims this 2ilat dav of Mebruary, 1908
[Seal Court of Claims. |
JOIN RANDOLPH,
Asst Clerk, Court of Claims
Mridorsed on cover) File No 2b.054. Court of Claims. Term No
8060 The William Cramp & Sons Ship and Engine Building Com-
pany. appellant, ox. The United States. Filed March 3d, 1908, File
No. 21.054.
1)
Ty Me iy :
Jak,
ek ihrdge toon te §
4 ‘ \. ¥
oe hoo
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
Ocrorer Team, 1909.
No. 92.
THE WILLIAM CRAMP AND SONS SHTIP AND
ENGINE BUILDING COMPANY. Apperrtanr.
THE UNITED STATES.
BRIEF FOR THE APPELLANT.
STATEMENT OF TITE CASE.
This ts an appeal by the Cramp Company, claimant below,
from the judgment of the Court of Claims, dismissing its
petition (pp. 33-36). The claim in suit is for breach of
contract. The contract was entere] into by the claimant
and the United States, represented by the Secretary of the
Navy, on September 24. 1896. It related to the construe-
tion of a battleship, now known as the U.S. S. “Alabama.”
The claimant undertook : to provide all material, to be used
in the construction of the vessel, except certain armor plate ;
to construct her in conformity with certain laws, specifica-
tions and plans: that she should meet certain re-
quirements: and to deliver her to the United States. com-
plete in all respects, within three vears from the date of the
contract; also to keep the vessel and all materials provided
for use in her construction, insured for the benefit of the
Secretary of the Navy, against loss or damage by fire and
other risks. up to the time of her delivery to the United
2
States. In consideration of this the United States assumed
two independent obligations: (1) To furnish part of the
armor to be used in the construction of the vessel, more
particularly described as all “such as may be required in the
construction of the side and diagonal belts, turrets, barbettes,
casemates, conning towers, ammunition tubes, and protec-
tion for the guns and loading positions.” and to “deliver
said armor and armor bolts at the ship vard of the party of
the first part (Cramp Company ) within the times and in the
order required to carry on the work properly.” (2)
To pay the Cramp Company the sum of $2,650,000;
this being made pavable in’ thirty instalinents, some
of which were to be paid as the work progressed, some upon
the delivery and preliminary acceptance of the vessel, and
the balance. including a special reserve of $60,000,
upon the vessel's final acceptance and the execution
by the builders of a release to the United States “in such
form as shall be approved by the Secretary of the Navy, of
all claims of any kind or description under or by virtue of
this contract” (p. 14). Final acceptance was not to occur
until the vessel should have been in the actual service of
the Government not exceeding five months. It was stipu-
lated: (1) Tf the delivery of the vessel should be delayed.
bevond the expiration of the building period of three years,
the builder would become liable for liquidated damages to
be deducted from its compensation, unless such delay were
caused by act of the United States, or by certain other cir-
cumstances beyond the builder's control. (2) The builder
was required to submit all questions with regard to delays
to the Secretary of the Navy and his decision as to their
cause and extent was made binding upon both parties; (3)
In case the Secretary should find that. the builder's work
was being delayed by acts of the United States or its offi-
cers or agents, the builder was to be allowed “‘a correspond.
ing extension of the building period” (pp. 4-15. 21, Find
ing IT).
7”
aa
3
Upon the execution of the contract thy claimant made
all preparations necessary for the commencement of the
work, undertaken. On December 2, 1896, the vessel's keel
was laid and thereafter her construction progressed with
due dispatch, and she would have been completed and ready
for delivery within the contract period if the United States
had delivered her armor as and in the manner undertaken Ds
it (p. 21). By the middle of February, 1898, the construe
tion of the vessel had progressed to a point where it became
necessary for the builders to have her internal armor, in or-
der that work upon her might proceed properly. ‘This
was a portion of the armor that the Government had agreed
to furnish. It was to constitute part of her strueture in
the same sense as her keel and frames. The first instalment
of it was not delivered to the builders until December 22,
1898, and the last instalment was rot delivered unti! Mareh
11, 1899, Notwithstanding the hindranee and combat
rassment caused by the lack of the internal armor. the
builders proceeded with their work as rapidly as possible
in so far as it could be done at all (p. 21). On May 18,
1898, the vessel was launched. \ccording to the official
estimate, the contractor's work was then about Hiftv-live per
centum completed (p. 22). On June 9, 1898, over ty enty
months after the execution of the contract in suit and nearly
four months after the lack of internal armor began to de-
lay the builder’s work on the vessel, the United States en
tered into a contract with the Bethlehem [ron Company by
which the latter agreed to manufacture and deliver certain
armor, including that which the Government had under
taken to provide for the “Alabama,” deliveries of. the
armor to begin in December, 1908. The Cramp Company
had nothing to do with that contract. nor was it apprised by
the contract in suit of the manner in which the Government
would procure the armor which it undertook to contribute
The Government had given no order for that armor, nor
Daehn oral eh ao el
4
taken steps to procure it, before June 9, 1898. In his re-
port, dated June 30, 1898, the Navy Department's represen-
tative at the Cramp Company's ship-yard, said:
“It is estimated that on June 30, 1898, the vessel
(Alabama) was 6O per cent completed. The con-
tractor’s trial, final completion and delivery of the ves-
sel to the Government will depend entirely upon the
delivery of the armor and armament, and the ship
should be ready for final delivery to the Government
within two months after the receipt of the armor and
armament at the shipbuilding yard.”
He stated further that the probable date of the vessel's
completion was September 24, 1899, provided that all of
her armor were delivered cithout undue delay (p. 22)
After launching. in order that work upon the vessel
might procecd in due course, it became necessary for the
contractor to have certain parts of her external armor.
This was not delivered until much later, nor were
the deliveries of armor of the several classes made
in the order necessary to carry on the work properly. The
first instalment of external armor was delivered on April 5,
1899, and the last of them, as late as June 7, 1900—<ight
and a half months after the date fixed by the contract for the
completion of the vessel and her delivery to the Government.
Armor for the turret, aft, was delivered in April, 1899,
while that for the forward turret was not delivered until
over a year later. Again the last of the armor for the side
or main belts was not delivered until November 10, 1899,
or six weeks after the expiration of the building period.
This latter delay had the most detrimental effect upon the
progress of the work, for the armor being heavy and de-
signed to be submerged in part, a great amount of material
intended for the internal fittings of the vessel could not be
installed at all, since its weight would have sunk her too deep
vt
to admit of the subsequent installation of the main belts (p.
22). Inhis report of June 30, 1900, the Navy Department's
representative at the Cramp’s shipyard said of the ‘Ala-
bama”’:
“The vessel is at present estimated to be 97 per cent
completed. | estimate that the date of the official trial
ean be about August 15, 1900, and that the ship will
be ready for commissioning by the 30th of September.
1900.”
From June 7, 1900, when the last instalment of armor
plate was delivered, the work of fintshing and testing the
vessel was prosecuted with all possible dispatch. Her off-
cial trial was held on August 20, 1900, and she was deliv
ered to the Government and placed in commission on Octo-
ber 16, 1900. On October 31. the Secretary of the Navy
issued an order to the effect that the vessel's preliminary ac-
ceptance should date from October 22, and that the build-
ing period should be extended until that date (p. 23, Finding
NIV). In July of 1899 @ strike occurred among the work-
men of the Cramp Company's yard, but it had no effect upon
the progress of work upon the “Alabama” (p. 23, Finding
XT). The whole delay of more than a year (387 days) was
attributable to the United States, and the inevitable con-
sequence of its failure to) provide armor plate for the
vessel, as agreed. Such was the finding of the Sccre-
tarv of the Navy, by whom the cause and extent of the
delay was inquired into and determined in the manner pro-
vided by the contract (Paragraph 9th) which made his
decision of such matters conclusive upon the parties
(pp. 23-24. Vinding NIV). While this finding of the
Secretary is not now open to dispute it is noteworthy
that the Government's delay of over twenty months in
placing an order for the armor accounts for the
delay, in the deliveries of the armor, and the hindrance
8
of work and damage of which the ship-builder complains.
By reason of the Government's breach of contract in failing
to provide armor plate for the vessel in due season, the
Cramp Company was put to extra expense in the perform-
ance of the contract on its part, and suffered damage, which
the Court of Claims has assessed at $49,792.66. This was
made up of items covering (1) the wharfage, maintenance
and upkeep of the vessel, and insurance carried upon her as
required, during the delay period; (2) the cost of extra
work made necessary by the delay: and (3) the increased
cost of doing certain of the work specified by the contract
because of the lack of armor, when needed (pp. 30-33).
On February 9, 1901, after the delivery of the vessel to
the United States and her preliminary acceptance, but be-
fore final acceptance, the Cramp Company wrote to the Sec-
retary of the Navy, presenting its claim for the damage suf-
fered by it, in consequence of the Government's default,
estimating this at $66,973.23. On February 13, 1901, the
Secretary replied :
“ek * * while from a casual consideration of the
matter it might seem proper that the papers (particu-
lars of demand) should be referred to the bureaus con-
cerned for examination and report, if appears after
careful consideration of the subject, that the cLaim, be-
ing for UNLIQUIDATED DAMAGES, JIS OF A KIND THAT
THE DEPARTMENT HAS NO AUTITORITY IN LAW TO EN-
TERTAIN.”
On March 11, 1901, the Department, having completed
the final trial of the vessel, the Secretary notified the Cramp
Company of her final acceptance. Along with this notice he
sent the company a form of final release and said that a
part of the special reserve. amounting to $40,000, would be
rs
paid to the company upon the return of that release duly
executed. This draft release read:
“Whereas, by the eleventh clause of the contract,
dated September 24, 1896, by and between the William
Cramp and Sons Ship and Engine Building Company.
party of the first part,and the United States. party of the
second part, for the construction of battleship No. &, the
“Adlabama,” it is agreed that a special reserve of sixty
thousand (60,000) dollars shall be held until the ves-
sel shall have been finally tried, provided that such final
trial shall take place within five months from and after
the date of the preliminary acceptance of the vessel:
and
“Whereas, by the seventh paragraph of the nineteenth
clause of said contract it is further provided that when
all of the conditions, covenants, and provisions of said
contract shall have been performed and fulfilled by and
on the part of the party of the first part said party of
the first part shall be entitled, within ten days after the
fling and acceptance of its claim, to receive the said
special reserve, or the surplus, if any, of the said re-
serve fund, or so much of either as the said party of
the first part may be entitled to, on the execution of a
final release to the party of the second part, in such form
as shall be approved by the Seeretary of the Navy, of
all claims of any kind or deseription under or by virtue
of said contract: and
“Whereas, the said vessel was preliminarily accepted
on the 22d of October, 1900, and her final trial com-
pleted March 11, 1901: and
“Whereas all the conditions, covenants. and provi-
sions of said contract have been performed and fulfilled
by and on the part of the party of the first part, except-
ing certain minor defects, deficiencies and items of un-
completed work, to cover which the sum of twenty
thousand dollars js according to an understanding of
the parties to said contract, and as stated in the letter
dated April 9, 1901 (No. 2919-01) of the Secretary
of the Navy to the parties of the first part, to be with-
held by the party of the second part until the completion
of the vessel in said respects; and
Whereas, owing to the inexpediency at this time of
keeping the “.\labama”™ at a navy vard long enough for
the doing of the work in question, the party of the sec-
ond part has consented to pay to the parties of the first
part all balances due under said contract, excepting the
suid special reservation of twenty thousand dollars;
“Now, therefore, in consideration of the premises, the
sum of forty-thousand dollars (S40,000), the amount
of the aforesaid special reserve, less the above-men-
tioned reservation of twenty thousand dollars (S20,-
COO) being to me in hand paid by the United States,
represented by the Secretary of the Navy, the receipt
whereof is hereby acknowledged, the William Cramp
and Sons Ship and Engine Building Company repre-
sented by me. Charles HI. Cramp, president of said com-
pany, does hereby for itself and its successors and as-
signs, and its legal representatives, remise, release, and
forever discharge the United States of and from all and
all manner of debts, dues, sum and sums of money, ac-
counts, reckonings, claim and demands whatsoever in
law and in equity for or by reason of or on account of
the construction of said vessel under the contract afere-
said, excepting the sum of twenty thousand dollars,
withheld by the Secretary of the Navy as above set
forth.”
The Cramp Company being advised that such an instru-
ment would bar its right to assert and collect its claim for
damages. declined to execute a release in that form, but, on
April 15, 1901, tendered to the Secretary one in all respects
like his draft, except that it contained this additional pro-
viso, designed to save the company’s right of action on the
claim in suit (p. 25):
“Provided, that nothing herem shall operate as a
waiver of the company’s right to sue for and recover
judgment in the Court of Clotms for damages incurred
or losses sustained by the company in the prosecution of
the contract work, which were occasioned by delays
or defaults on the part of the United States.”
9
This was tendered by counsel for the Cramp Company
along with a letter in which they showed that the company
wished to preserve its right to collect. the claim) in
suit, and was not willing to relinquish it in’ the man-
ner contemplated by the Secretary's draft of the release.
They suggested further that inasmuch as the Sceretary had
declined to entertain the claim on the ground that he lacked
authority to do so, and was sustained in that position by
numerous decisions of the Court of Claims, holding that
the head of an executive department is not vested with
jurisdiction to hear and determine claims for unliquidated
damages, the company was constrained to seek — its
remedy by suit in the Court of Claims, as provided by the
act of Congress, approved March 3, 1887, and known as
the “Tucker Act.” On April 17, 1901, the release thus ten-
dered was returned to counsel by the Secretary with a letter
in which he said that the proviso, added by the company. was
not acceptable to the Department. but that the Department
would accept a release containing a proviso, “which, er-
cepting the substitution ef “crars:s’ for ‘rieuts,’ is substan-
tially what was suggested by Mr. Hayden, namely + Pro-
vided, that this release shall xov be talen to include CLAIMS
arising under the said contract, OTOFR THAN THOSE WHICH
THE SECRETARY OF THE NAVY HAD TURISDICTION TO EN-
TERTAIN. *
On that representation, the Cramp Company executed a
release containing this proviso, sugeested by the Secretary,
and it was tendered to the Department by counsel, on April
20, 1901, with a letter in which they said:
“This (release) contains a clause which excepts from
the operation of the release claims arising under the
contract, which you, as Sceretary of the Navy, had not
jurisdiction to entertain.”
x
¢
Sep ver 4
10
In that form the release was accepted (p. 28) and the sum
of $40,000 was thereupon paid to the Cramp Company.
Phis suit was brought on April 29, 1901 (p. 1). On August
26, 1901, the Department accounted to the company for the
sum of $20,000, withheld, pending the completion by the
Goverument of a few minor items of work. The cost of
these came to S1189.61,, and the balance of the contract
price-—S18,810.39-—was paid toe the company and receipted
for as follows:
“lor amount withheld on voucher April 20, 1901,
the vessel having been finally accepted, less deductions
for uncompleted work on hull and machinery (as per
statement attached) as follows :”
No further release or voucher was called for by the De-
partment or given by the Company (pp. 28-30). After
hearing. the Court of Claims dismissed the petition and en
tered judgment for the defendant (p. 34), holding: (1) that
under the contract the Government became entitled to a
release of all claims that might have accrued to the Cramp
Company for the Government's breach of contract on pay-
ment of the special reserve, and that the contract itself had
the effect of a release: (2) that the acceptance of the special
reserve barred the company’s right of action, although it
vas paid with the understanding. expressed in the release.
that it should not operate agaimst claims that the Seeretary
had not authority to entertain. The court said that this
decision was “under the authority of the case of Umited
States us. Wim. Cramp & Sons, etc. (206 U. S.. 118)"
SPECIFICATION OF F-RRORS.
The errors of the Court of Claims, relied upon and in-
tended to be urged are these:
1. The said court erred in dismissing the petition and in
‘ntering judgment for the defendant.
11
2. The said court erred in holding that the claimant was
debarred, by the contract in suit, or by the release from
asserting and collecting the claim in suit.
3. The said court erred in holding that by acceptance of
the last payment made on account of the contract price of
ihe vessel the claimant became debarred from asserting and
collecting the claim im suit.
4. ‘Vhe said court erred in failing and refusing to hold
that under the terms of the contract the claimant had a right
of action for the damages suffered by it in consequence of
the defendant’s failure to deliver armor for the vessel as
covenanted, and that the claim in suit remained open and
unsettled, the claimant saving its right) of action upon
the same.
5. The said court erred in failing and refusine to vive
judgment for claimant in a sum equal to the damage suf
fered by it, caused by the defendant's failure to deliver the
vessel's armor. as covenanted.
ARGUMENT.
In the court below the defendant raised several issues of
law, denying the Government's liability. ‘These were
founded upon the terms of the contract and those of the
release, and upon the acceptance by the claimant of the
payments made after final acceptancs \s stated above,
the court confined its consideration of the case to the sup-
posed bar, created by the contract itself, and the acceptance
of the last payment. That question will be taken up first
Afterwards, the other questions, ratsed below, but not men-
tioned in the opinion of the court, will be considered
12
I.
The contract did not obligate the claimant to re-
linguish the claim in suit, or any other claims that
might accrue to it for breach of the contract by the
United States. The contract itself was not a release
of such claims. The acceptance by the claimant of the
last payment did not create a bar to the claimant's
right of action for the breach comimitted by the United
States.
The interpretation of the contract by the court below
comes down to this: (1) While the United States, as a
consideration on its part to be performed, covenanted to
deliver armor plate to the builder for use in the construc-
tion of the vessel. when and as the builder should need it,
and, independent of and in addition to that, covenanted to
pay the builder a certain sim of money; there was another
provision of the contract (Paragraph 19, Sec. 7), which
made the Government's covenant to furnish armor nugatory,
by requiring the builder to relinquish any and all claims that
might accrue to it for breach of contract by the Govern-
ment on receipt of the sum stipulated to be paid. In short.
it was held that the Government was relieved of both of its
obligations by performing one, and, from the moment when
the contract was signed. the chumant was powerless to
compel the Government to perform both obligations, al-
though the two were independent, and together made up
the consideration to the builder for the construction of
the vessel. (2) Thoueh the Government broke its cove-
nant to deliver armor, it) did perform its other and in
dependent covenant to pay a certain sum of money, and
the condition as to payment was such that acceptance of
the money had the same effect as an unconditional release
and precluded the builders from claiming damages for breach
of the first covenant, although they gave notice of their claim
18
before payment of the money, and by the release which was
given before payment, the parties left the claim in suit open
and unsettled.
Let us see whether there is any justification for placing
such an interpretation upon the contract or the conduct of the
parties.
The contract, drawn by the Navy Department, was of
great length and divided into nineteen paragraphs. Sixteen
of these related exclusively to obligations assumed by the
builders, including: (1) the provision of materials: (2) the
prosecution of work upon the vessel: (3) the time of her
completion and delivery: (4) the tests to which she should
be subjected and requirements that she would have to meet :
and (3) numerous penalties and forfeitures to he posed
upon the builder in the event of failure on its part
Three of the paragraphs—the third, eleventh, and nine-
teenth—relate, among other things, to th considerations
moving from the Government.
Paragraph “Third” deals with the furnishing of the
vessel's armor. Certain contingeneics provided against in
the latter part of this paragraph, and whieh, had they arisen,
might have modified the obligations of both parties, did aot
arise, so we can ignore them and contine our attention. to
the following: The builder undertook to prepare plans and
templates for all of the armor, to supply the plates required
for the protective deck, and to install all of the armor Upon
the vessel. The Government on its part undertook to pro-
vide all armor plate other than that requived for the protec-
tive deck, and to deliver it to the builder “at the times and wt
the order required to caryy on the work properly.” These
undertakings. were not subject to any condition as to the
manner in which either party should produce or procure the
part of the armor to be contributed by it. The Govern-
ment’s obligation was not made dependent upon or an alter-
native for any other consideration to be performed by it.
14
Paragraph “Nineteenth” (p. 14) relates to the money
consideration: “The price to be paid for the vessel to be
constructed and furnished in accordance with this contract.”
was fixed at $2,650,000—to be paid by the Government to
the builder in thirty equal instalments with a reservation of
ten per centum from each instalment. Twenty-seven in-
stalments were to be paid as the work progressed. The last
three were to be paid as provided by Paragraph Eleventh.
and not otherwise (pp. 10-11), that is to say: they were to
be retained by the Government until preliminary acceptance
of the vessel, when they were to be paid over to the con-
tractor, subject, however, to a special reserve of $60,000.
as to which it was provided :
“In case of a preliminary acceptance of said vessel,
the said special reserve of $60,000 * * * shall be
held until the vessel has been finally tried, after being
fully equipped, armored, or weighted correspondingly,
and in all respects complete and ready for sea, under
conditions prescribed or approved by the Secretary of
the Navy; provided, that such final trial shall take place
-cithin five months from and after the date of the pre-
liminary «acceptance of the vesse 7
Paragraph “Nineteenth” also contained this :
“7 When all the conditions, covenants and provr
sions of this contract shall have been pe rformed and
fulfilled, by and on the part of the party of the first
part (Cramp Company ). said party of the first part shall
be entitled within ten days after the filing and accept-
ance of its claim, to receive the said special reserve or
the surplus if any of said reserve fund or so much of
either as the party of the second part may be entitled
to, on the execution of a release Ih sit ir form as shall
be approved by the Secretary of the Navy, of all claims
of any kind or description under or by virtie of this
contract.” ;
15
These surely do not justify the interpretation that. the
court below placed upon the contract.
(1) The price stipulated to be paid was “for the vessel,
to be constructed and furnished in accordance zith this con-
tract.” i. ¢., the Government supplying all armor other than
that for the protective deck and delivering it to the builders
“at the times and in the order required to carry on the work
properly.”
(2) The contract (Par. 11th, p. 11: Par. 19th, See. 5,
p. 14) did not sanction the withholding of the special re-
serve by the Secretary after final acceptance of the vessel,
or more than five months after her preliminary acceptance.
(3) Section 7 of paragraph nineteenth (spray) was not a
present release, but, at the utmost, an agreement to release,
conditioned upon the performance by the Government of
the considerations specified. Verformance by the Govern-
ment of its covenant to supply armor failing, the builder's
agreement to release went with it. “Jf part of the consid-
cvation agreed on be not performed, the whole accord fails.”
(City of Memphis vs. Brozar, 20° Wall. 289: Bank vs.
Leech, 94 Fed. R., 3102.1 Smith's Leading Cases, 3th Am.
d., 445-H6.) In the case of Bank vs. Leech (supra),
Caldwell, J... said:
“It is a well settled rule of law that accord with-
out satisfaction is net a good answer. An agree-
ment or accord which is to operate as a. satisfaction
of an existing liability must. before it can have that
effect, be fully executed. It is not enough that there
be a clear agreement or aceord and a sufficient consid-
eration: but the agreement or accord must be executed
before it can he pleaded as an accord and satisfaction.
If part of the consideration agreed on be not performed,
the whole accord fails.”
(4) Section 7 of paragraph nineteenth (supra) contem-
plated the presentation of a claim by the Cramp Company for
16
the part of the money remaining unpaid at the time of the
final acceptance of the vessel, an adjustment of the matter
with the Secretary, and thereafter a release and pay-
ment. based on such adjustment. — These things did
not occur for obvious reasons. The Cramp Com-
pany had presented — the claim in suit, over two
months before final acceptance of the vessel. The Secre-
tary, without disputing the amount of the claim or the right
of the company to recover It, advised the company that “fe
claim being for unliquidated damages, is of a kind the De-
partment has no authority in law to entertain” (p. 24). It
was the Secretary who, two months Tater, after final accept-
ance of the vessel, and without a request from the Cramp
Company, tendered to it a part of the special reserve, saying
that it would be paid on the execution of a release which
svould have discharged the United States from all “debts,
dues, sum and sums of money, accounts, reckonings, claims
and demands whatsoever in law or in equity for or by rea-
son of or on account of the construction of said vessel under
the contract aforesaid, excepting the sum of $20,000, with-
held by the Secretary of the Navy" subject to a further ad-
justment. The company declined to execute that release, be-
cause it wished to preserve its right of action on the claim in
suit. and so advised the Secretary. It agreed with him
in his conclusion that “the claim, being one for unliquidated
damages, was of a kind that he had no authority in law to
entertain.” Tt told him that it proposed to submit the claim
to the Court of Claims, which had authority in law to enter-
tain it. It tendered to the Secretary, in lieu of the release
proposed by him, one by which its “right” of action on the
claim in suit was excepted and left open, as well as its claim
for a further adjustment of the $20.000 matter. The Sec-
retary objected to the use of the word “right” as applied to
the claim in suit. Doubtless he considered that the accept-
ance of such a release might be taken as his assent to the
17
proposition that the company had a right of action. Tle
had no authority to concede even that much, and to do so
would have been an encroachment upon the jurisdiction,
committed by Congress, to the Court of ( ‘laims. So he of-
fered to approve a release, which in speaking of the matter
anal ee from its operation, should deseribe the compariy’s
bill of damages as a “elaine” rather than a “right.” We said
in effect that such a change of terms would not impair the
efficiency of the proviso as a saving clause (p. 20). The
company acceded to this proposition and the release executed
by it and delivered to the Sc retary before payment of any
part of the special reserve, in terms, ¢ Seepted from its opera
tion “claiinis arising wader the said contract other | an those
which the Secretary of the Na: V had jurisdiction to ente
‘aiw’—the very words that had been cmploved by the Rates
tary to describe the claim in suit,
The elaborate and tautologiea! expressions contained in
the fifth paragraph of the release (pp. 27-28) do not over-
come the particular sents of limitation, contained in the
proviso (p. 28), which limited the operation of the release
to claims which the Secretary of the Navy had jurisdiction
to entertain,
Texas, efc.. R. Co. vs. Dashiell (48 U. 3. Osh, Fes
case turned upon a release which read:
“Ww hereas, on and prior to the 24th day of December,
19C0, 1, G. HL. Dashiell, was employed by the ‘Texas &
Pacific R: ahead Co. as brakeman and extra freight con-
— at or near Eastland, Texas, on the said 24th day
t December, 1900, about 3.15 o'clock ALM. 1 sus-
a certain personal injuries in the manner and of
the character described, to the best of my knowledge
and ability, to-wit: Extra east eng. 189 struck caboose
of extra east eng. 255, 2'4 miles cast of Fastlan}
carte my body, right lee, right arm, and giving me
t scalp wound. And whereas, it s by said railway
company and myself mutually Pui wre to maintain
18
amicable pleasant relations and avoid all controversy in
respect to said matter: Now, therefore, to that end, and
in consideration of thirty and no/100 dollars, to me
now here paid in cash by said Texas & Pacific Railway
Company, | hereby release and acquit, and by these
presents bind myself to indemnify and forever hold
harmless, said Texas & Pacific Railway Company from
and against all claims, demands, damages, and _liabili-
ties, Of any and every kind or character whatsoever,
for or account of the injuries and damages sustained
by me in the manner or upon the occasion aforesaid.
and arising or accruing, or hereafter arising or accru-
ing, in any way therefrom. * * * And it is also
expressly understood, that all premises and agreements
respecting or in any wise relating to the subject hereof
are fully expressed herein and no others are made to
exist.”
\fter executing this Dashiell brought an action against
ithe railroad for his personal injuries, enumerating injuries
to his head, eves, back, sides, arms, shoulders, and in the
organs and functions of his brain and his mental and nerv-
ous systems. The railroad set up the release contending
that it was intended “to be a final settlement of all claims
erowing out of the aceident.” The defendant contended
that it was a settlement only for the particular injuries
there enumerated. The court adopted the plaintiff's view
of the instrument and gave judgment in his favor. This
was afiirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals and thereafter
by this court, where Mr. Justice McKenna. delivering the
opinion, said :
“The words ‘in the manner and upon the occasion
are a mere tautological identification of the collision
and cause of the injuries. They add nothing else
whatever to the meaning of the release. This construc-
tion gives purpose to the enumeration of the injuries
and to all of the provisions of the release. Ind the
rule of construction should not be overlooked that*ijen
eral words in.a release are to be limited and restrained
to the particular words tn the recital.”
EAPC DRA CRIA LAB ESL AS HARE DEED
19
(3) The Seeretary of the Navy and the Cramp Com-
pany were © rreet in the opinion expressed by the former and
acquiesced in by the latter that ‘the clatu being one for
unliquidated damages is of a kind the Department has no
audiority under the law to entertain” (p. 24). By the
saving clause which was finally included in the release «
“Provided, That this release shail not be taken io
include claims arising under the said contract other thai
those which the Secretary of ihe Navy had jurisdiction
fo entertam.”
they adopted apt words to carry out their purpose to leave
the claim in suit open and unsettled. It is and always has
heen the law that executive officers of the Government
cannot entertain such claims, and it has been held over anil
over again that the head of an executive department is not
authorized to entertain and settle claims for unliquidate.
damages, even when they grow out of contracts made by
him. Such has been and is the rule followed by all execu-
tive departments. In an opinion given in 1832 (Opinions,
ed. 1841, p. 882). Mr. Attorney-General Tawney said:
“If the Navy Commissioners have refused to take
the bread from Mr. Stiles. according to contract, when
he had prepared it of the quality called for by the
agreement, if is not in the power of the executive branch
of the Government to liquidate and pay the damages he
may have sustained. Vf he has been damnified by the
oficers of the Government, Congress* alone can re
dress the injury.”
*Since that opinion was written Congress by the act of March 3.
1887, known as the “Tucker Act,” has conferred upon the Court of
Claims jurisdiction “to hear and determine * * * all claims * *
for damages liquidated or unliquidated. in cases not sounding in tort
e
x
we
* ‘
&
a
Pd
ix
McKee vs. U. S., 12 C. Cls., 5
Power vs. U. S., 18 Id., 263, 2
McClure vs. U. S., 19 Id., 18, 28-29;
Brannen vs. U. S., 20 1d., 219, 223-224:
Pneumatic Gun Carriage e o. vs. U. S., 36 1d., 71:
J Opin. Attys.-Genl., 327-328 ; Id., 627, 630.
14, 555-558:
7
bs Tes
In Power vs. U.S. (supra), Davis, J.. delivering the
opinion, said (p. 275):
“Claims for unliquidated damages require for their
settlement the application of the qualities of judgment
and discretion. “They are frequently, perhaps generally,
sustained by extraneous proof, having no relation to
the subjects of the contract, which are common to both
parties: as, for instance, proof concerning the number
of horses and the number of wagons, and the length
of time that would have been required in performing a
given amount of transportation. The results to be
reached in such cases can in no just sense be called an
account, and are not committed by law to the control
and decision of Treasury accounting officers.”
(6) Apart from the plain and explicit language of the
release, it was clearly nnderstood by the parties that the
claim in suit was left open and unscttled, to be adjudicated
by the tribunal having exclusive jurisdiction of claims for
unliquidated damages. That was the situation of affairs,
when the first payment of S10.COO0 was made from the spe-
cial reserve. When the 820,000 matter was adjusted, some
months later, this suit had been brourht and no release
whatever, bevond a voucher for the payment, was asked for
or given. To give the release or the claimant's acceptance of
the last payments the effect claimed for them by the Gov-
ernment and given them by the court below, would be to
use them in a way not justified by the terms of the release,
a
21
or intended by the parties, and would allow the Government
to commit a fraud. (Parmelee vs. Lawrence. 44 Ill... 405-
409; Fire Ins. Assn. vs. Wickham, 141 U. S., 564, 576-
S82). If the terms of the release were obscure, which they
are nol, it would have to be interpreted in such a Way as to
carry out the intent of the parties, to be ascertained from
the correspondence which passed between them. (Fire Jus.
Assn. vs. Wickham, 141 U.S., 564, 576-582. CS. 7s. Peck.
102 U. S., 64: Merriam vs. U. §..107 U. S.. $37, 441-442:
U.S. vs. Gibbons, 109 U.S... 200, 3-204: Chicago, ete.
R. Co. vs. Denver, ctc., R. Co.. 143 U. S.. 596, 609-610:
Nash vs. Towne, 5 Wall. 689, 699.) No one can read that
correspondence and] say that either party intended the release
to bar the claimant's remedy on the claim in suit. but on
the contrary that both parties intended that it should be pre-
served.
(7) The Seer tary was not precluded from paving the
spectal reserve without requiring the claimant to exeeute an
unconditional release. ‘Take Section 7. Paragraph Nine-
teenth (supra) literally and by itself, without: regard to
the rest of the contract. or the situation of the parties: or
the fact that the Secretary, whe made the contract. had au-
thority to modify it, and it would have precluded him: from
ordering final acceptance of the vessel or from) paying any
part of the special reserve until “all the conditions, cove-
nants, and provisions of this contract. shall have been
performed and fulfilled by the perty of the first part
(Cramp Company). This the company had not done,
here remained. as shown by the release itself, “certain
defects, deficiencies and items of mncompleted work.” to
cover the cost of which the Secretary withheld $20,000
pending the completion of these things by the Govern
ment at the builder's cost (p. 27). Tf he had authority to
make that exception of a matter which he was authorized to
settle, he had, also. authority to make the other exception
Hy
19)
with respect to claims that he could not entertain and was
obliged by law to leave unsettled, if the contractor refused to
relinquish them. The Secretary had legislative authority to
make a contract for the construction of the vessel in ques-
tion, and while this was limited in some particulars it was
broad. There was no limitation with respect to the manner
of paying the money consideration, or the taking of a
release. These things were left to his discretion. Tle was
as free to exercise his judgment in the modification of the
contract ‘in these particulars as he was to make the contract
in the beginning. (U.S. vs. Barlow, 184 U.S. 123:
Salomon vs. U.S. 19 Wall, 17:0. S.. ex rel. Redteld, vs.
Windom, 137 U. S.. 636.) Mr. Justice MeKenna, deliv-
ering the opinion of this court, in (urifec States vs. Barlow,
said (p. 135):
“It is contended by the United States that the direc-
tion of the Secretary of the Navy was a change or
modification of the contract within the meaning of the
7th subdivision of the contract, and that the Secretary
had no power to direct or consent to such change more
than the ‘humblest laborer employed upon the work.
and besides, that no such change could be made except
by an agreement in writing.
“We have no doubt of the power of the Secretary of
the Navy. His power is manifest from the contract,
and is given by law.”
The acceptance by the claimant of the payments made
after final acceptance of the vessel with the understanding
acquiesced in by the Secretary, that the payments should not
bar the claim in suit, certainly did not create such a_ bar.
Weeks vs. Rector et al of Trinity Church (56 Appellate
Division, N. Y., 195). The contract drawn in question in
that case provided for the construction of masonry work in
a building to be erected by Trinity Church. It was stipu-
23
lated that this work should be completed by a certain date,
or in default of that, penalty should be imposed upon the
contractor. While not expressly provided in the instru-
ment, the implication was that the church would secure the
necessary building permit and file the necessary plans, with-
ina reasonable time and so enable the contractor to proceed
with his work. ‘Vhis the church negleetcd to deo promptly,
and in consequence of the delay the contractor was obliged
to suspend on two occasions. Tle finished the work, how-
ever, and was paid the sum named in the contract. Later
he brought his action for damages caused by the delay. The
lower court dismissed the complaint and gave judgment for
the defendant. On appeal that was reversed. the court in
general term saying:
“But it is said that the plaintiff having gone on and
finished the work after he had been permitted to do so
on the 18th of September, and having received his com-
pensation therefor, waived his right to bring any action
for damages because of the failure of the defendant
to perform the contract on his part. It appears in
the case that it was agreed between the parties that
the payment of the contract price should not prejudice
the right of the plaintiff to bring this action, but even
if that agreement had not been made, the receipt by
the plaintiff of the stipulated contract price for the per-
formance of the contract would not operate as a waiver
of Ins right to proceed against the defendant for a
violation of its agreement. When the plaintiff was
compelled by the act of the defendant to cease work
on this building he was not called upon to rescind the
contract or to refuse to proceed further with it at the
pert] of waiving any damages which he might have suf-
fered, but he was at liberty to go on with the work,
considering the contract still in force, and when he had
finished maintain his action to compel the defendant
to pay the increased expense to which he had been put
by its act.”
24
(8) The court below erred ta saving that this case is gov-
erned by the decision of this court in Uatled States vs. 1 nt,
Cramp & Sons, cic. (206 U.LS.. 118), which will be referred
to as the “Indiana” case. The two are not comparable
for several reasons. (a) In the “Jiadiana™’ case the builder
dil not give notice of its claim for damages until long after
an unconditional release had been given and the special re-
serve paid. In the preset cause such notice was duly given
before release and payment. €b) In the “/ndtana™ case the
release was vucondiiional and given cuhout protest. Tn the
present case the relcase was unon the condition therem ex
pressed, that i should wof extinguish elaims of the class te
which the one in suit belongs. nor wes the conditional release
given, nor was pavment of the special reserve made, until
the parties had reached an understanding that the claimant
should be left free to pursue its remedy on the claim in suit.
(c) Inthe “/ndiana’ case suit was not brought until fiftcen
months after the release was given and the contract closed.
In the present case suit was brought on the ninth day after
the execution of the conditional release and payment of part
of the special reserve and four months before payment of
the balance (pp. 1. 28). (d@) The points on which the de-
cision of the “/adiana” case turned are clearly set out in the
opinion of this court:
“This case turns on the re/case executed by the build-
ing company. * * * No payment of moneys not due
is necessary to sustain this release. It is under seal and
the contract is itself full consideration. * * * In-
deed, the general language of the release itself and the
number of words of description in it show that it was
the intent of the Secretary of the Navy to have a final
closing of all matters arising under or by virtue of the
contract. * * * Jf partics intend to leave some
things open and unsetiled their intent to do so sho vdd
be made nianifest. Here was a contract, involving thre
25
millions of dollars, and after the cork scas d me, the
vessel delivered and accepted, and this release entered.
claims are presented amounting to over $500,000. Sure-
ly the parties never intended to leave such a bull: of
unsettled matters.”
In the present case none of these things occurred. The
release was limtied to claims that the Secretary was au-
thorized to pass upon. He said that the claim in suit Was
not one of that class and the claimant agreed with him in
that conclusion. He was advised of the nature and amount
of the builders claim and knew just what he was obliged to
leave unsettled. It is certain that he paid over the special
reserve with his eves open and without any expectation that
the conditional release and payment of the special reserve
would close the transaction, but on the contr: ary, with the
claimant's assurance that it would bri Ing suit upon the claim.
It is to be presumed that the Secretary acted in good faith,
Probably the court below in m: king its decision seized upon
an expression contained in the opinion of this court in the
“Indiana” case, i. e.:
“No payment of moneys not due is necessary fo sis-
tain this release. Vt is under seal and the contract itself
is full consideration.”
That does not mean that the contract which necessarily
was made in advance of its breach by the Government and
of course before the claim in suit could have accrued, was
equivalent to a release of that claim. Tf an unconditional
release had been given in the pre sent case, the contract itself
ie, reid hase heen se aye ” copoderrady We a ’ ft: Iyoey } oH,
release was qiven and ne is nothing to sustain, but the
tnstrument which left the claim in suit “open and unsettled
26
Il.
The Government broke the contract, and in conse-
quence of that the clamant suffered damage, and ts
entitled to recover an amount equal to that damage.
Phe Government's failure to deliver armor plate as agreed
was but a partial failure of the consideration moving from
it. When the breach occurred the builder had no means of
knowing how long it would continue. When the delay be
gan the vessel was abont half completed, and over $1,
YOO,000 must have been paid by the Government on account
of the contract price of the vessel. The unfinished vessel
was lable to rapid) deterioration. It was the builder's
right, and obviously 1 was for the best interest of the United
States, as well as its own, to proceed with the work as best
wt could, complete it, and sue for damages caused by the
breach. (2 Parsons on Contracts, 679; Clark vs. UL S.,
() \\ oe 343 : ( eee ey A Speed, S Wall : “rie Pie YP vat Behan,
110 U. S., 338, 344; Figh vs, UL S28 C. Cls., 319; Myeric
eo U: SL SEC Ce 8.)
In Cornwall vs. Henson (2 Ch 298—1900), Collins, L.
J.. said (p. 303):
oP)
“The law is clear that the breach ot one stipulation
does not necessarily carry with it even an inplication
of an intention to repudiate the whole contract. * *
lhe farther the parties have proceeded with the per-
formance of the contract, the less likely is it that, by
breach of one stipulation by one party, he should im
tend to declare his incapacity to perform the contract
or his intention not to carry it out.”
Hudson on Bialding Contracts (1, p. 303—1907 ) :
“[f the prevention does not go to the root of the
whole contract, but merely delays the performance, the
contractor does not waive his right to recover damage
merely by proceeding with the work.”
MLR oe OOS Do Diidth PO tal ore Cr ote Wwe
pees te OEM, LI RM a ES "ete
27
A.
In the court below the Government contended that,
when the Secretary determined that the delay in the comple-
tion of the vessel was due to the failure of the Government
to furnish armor plate as agreed, and extended the building
period, named in the contract, by an interval equal to the de-
lay enforced by the Government, he modified the contract so
that it called for the completion of the vessol in something
over four vears, instead of three vears. From: that, they
argued that the vessel being completed within the time set by
the contract, and the armor plate having been delivered to
the ship builders soon enough to enable them to complete the
vessel within the time required, there was, in contemplation
of law, no delay in the delivery of armor, no breach of con
tract, and, of course, no injury to the builder. That is pure
sophistry. On that theory, the Government might have de-
ferred ordering the armor for vears, or forever, and if the
Secretary kept on extending the Cr unp Company's building
period, the Government could have left the — vessel
on claimant's hands indefinitely and still remained
blameless. = The effort to evade the indisputable fact
that the Government failed to perform its undertaking
is lke the reasoning of the divine who sought — to
soothe his congregation by saving that. when properh
interpreted, the parable of the rich man does not
mean necessarily that Dives was confined ina place designed
for torment, but might, equally well, be taken to mean that
he was ma celestial sanitarium, whither he had been taken
to be cured of an attack of gout, and being in pain, he spoke
of that as a place of torment. The Secretary found that
the delay in the completion of the “d/abama” was attributa-
ble to the Government, and catsed Dw its failure to furnish
armor plate as agreed. Accordingly acting under the con-
ract (Par. 9th) he ordered preliminary acceptance of the
vessel, after the expiration of the building period. and
extended the building period up to the time of deliv-
ery. No amount of juggling with terms and phrases can
convert this simple admission of responsibility for the delay
and recognition of the builder's right to deliver the vessel
into a modification of the contract itself. The fact
being undisputed that the Government did not de-
liver armor plate “at the times and in the order
required to carry on the work properly” it is no defense to
sav that the contract was not broken because the armor was
delivered in time to enable the builder to complete the vessel
within the building period, as extended by the Secretary.
That is a non sequitur. The contract allowed the builder to
constime the period of three vears in constructing the ves-
sel but did not require the builder to do so. If she had
been finished in a shorter time the Government would
have been obliged to accept her. It would have had no
right to require the builder to maintain her after comple-
tion, simply because the full building period had not elapsed.
The Government's obligation to deliver armor would not
have been fulfilled ipso facto if the deliveries had been made
early enough to enable the builder to complete the vessel in
three years. If her construction had progressed without tn-
usual dispatch, but more rapidly than the contract required,
and the builder, in order “to carry on the work properly”
had needed the armor plate sooner than he got it. the
Government would have been guilty of a breach of its
covenant.
B.
The Government further contended that by forbearing
to take advantage of its own wrong, that is to say, by the
omission to impose penalty for its own delay and the exten-
sion of the building period, it rendered full satisfaction to
the builder for the damage suffered on account of the
Government's failure to deliver armor plate as stipulated
in paragraph “Third.” Counsel for the Government
based this upon paragraph “Ninth” of the contract
and invoked the maxim: “[.rpressio unius est exclusio alte-
rius.” The argument was that, inasmuch as the contract pro-
vided for the deduction of liquidated damages from the build-
ers compensation in the event of delay caused by the build-
er, but, said that if delay were caused by the United States.
no such deductions should be made. and that the builder
would be entitled to an extension of the building period, it
must be presumed that the builder was to have no remedy
for breach by the Government except immunity from pen-
alty and continuance of the Government's obligation to re-
ceive and pay for the vessel. If such were the law or such
the meaning of paragraph ninth, of what use was it to put
in the contract, as part of the consideration moving from the
Government, the covenant that it should) furnish armor
when needed by the builder? What value has an obligation,
if the obligor can tenere it without hability ?
There is nothing in paragraph “Ninth” which deprives
the claimant of its right to pecuntary damages. This whole
subject is well treated of im a recent work (/ludson on
Building Contracts, YO07) where it is said (Vol. 1. pp.
524-525) :
“Building and engineering contracts, as has already
been stated, usually contain provisions for the payment
by the builder to the owner of liquidated damages in
case of the work's not bemg completed by a stipulated
time. Liquidated damages, stipulated for at a rate for
each day or week of delay in completing the works,
must begin to run from some definite date. It follows.
therefore, that if there ts no date in the contract, or if
the date in the contract has for some reason ceased to
be the proper date for the completion of the works,
there is no date from which hqudated damages can
run. and, therefore, all right to recover liquidated dam-
30
ages has gone. In order to meet this contingency, a
provision is generally inserted that the architect may
erant an extension of time for the completion of the
works in case of delay from various causes, such as
strikes, lockouts, alterations and additions, ete., and
that in case of such extension of time being granted,
the builder shall complete within the extended time.
This clause, if duly acted upon, fixes another date for
completion and the obligation of the builder may then
be to complete by that other date: but that other date
may for some reason not be the proper date, or, being
a proper date, may have ceased to be so, in which case
again there is no date from which liquidated damages
can run, and, therefore, the right to recover liquidated
damages may have gone. For example, the architect
may only have power to extend the time for (1)
strikes, (2) lockouts, or (3) alterations. If delays take
place, for example from the failure of the building
owner to give the builder possession of the site on
which he has to build, then, in that case, the time for
completion in the contract having ceased to be ap-
plicable, and there being no power in anvone to fix an-
other date. there is no date from which liquidated dam-
ages can run and then again no liquidated damages are
recoverable.”
,p. S31:
“Where there is power to extend time for delays
which in fact have taken place, but the power has not
been exercised, either within the time expressly or im-
nliedly limited by the contract, or not at all, it follows
that the building owner has lost. the benefit of the
clause. and, if the contract time has ceased to be ap
plicable owing to delays caused by the building own
there is no date from which penalties can run, and
therefore, it would seem, no penalties can he recoy
ered.”
oe se SL OTM Oe Bh A LP ELI OR RGAE PG
31
Id., pp. 542-543:
“In the event of the employer having hindered the
performance of the contract so as to prevent the agreed
liquidated damage clause applying, it is doubtful
whether he can recover unliquidated damages against
the builder. It is concluded by authority that when
the parties have agreed upon a Heuidated sum as dam-
ages the amount of the damages cannot be left to the
jury, but the question appears to be undecided whether
if the emplover cannot recover Hanidated damages
from any default of his own, he can recover unliqui
dated damages, and if so how such damaves may be
assessed. [Tf the employer, in such a case, were per
mitted to recover unliquidated damaves, without ans
limit to the amount. it might be said that he would be
able by his own act to defeat and take advantage of
the breach, which he himself had conmiitted. if the un
liquidated damages were greater than the liquidated
damages. It 1s submitted that the agreement as to
liquidated damages is as much a part of the bareain as
any other part of the contract, and that it does not rest
with the building owner to change the contract which
he has entered into by substituting another term, viz:
that if the clause as te liquidated damages should by
his own act or default cease to be applicable, then he
should be permitted to recover whatever unliquidated
damages he could prove. Of course, if the contract has
heen entirely put an-end to by the default of the
employer, then the builder can recover on a quantum
meruit for work done at reasonable prices and ina rea-
sonable time and the emmplover can claim damages rf the
work ts not done ina reasonable time.”
Id... p. 546:
“Fextension of tinte does not release the employer
from damaaces for delay unless the bilder covenants
to accept the extension in satisfaction of his claim for
damades.-
aad
32
In the present case the parties by their contract liquidated
the damage recoverable by the Government for delay at-
tributable to the builder. There was no attempt to lqui-
date the builder’s damage for the Government's failure to
supply armor as agreed. The contract made the Secretary
the final arbiter to determine two facts: the cause and the
extent of delay. Those facts being determined the con-
tract provided under what circumstances the builder
should or should not pay liquidated damages and
whether the building period should or should — not
he extended. It was competent to provide, as the contract
did, that no damages should be imposed for delay, oc-
casioned without fault of the builder and beyond its control,
whether the Government or some other agency were respon-
sible. It was reasonable to discriminate, as the contract did,
between delays due to the Government's default and delays
arising without fault of the Government or builder. That
is: in case delay were caused by the Government. it
should not benefit by its own wrong. and its obligation to
take and pay for the vessel should be continued by a suitable
extension of the building period: but if delay were caused
without fault of the Government by other agencies beyond
the builder's control, such a continuance of the Govern-
ment’s undertaking should not be obligatory—for both par-
ties being innocent of causing the delay it might well be as
great a hardship to compel the Government to accept an
obsolete type of vessel as to leave her upon the build-
er’s hands. But here we have the cause and extent of
the delay determined by the Secretary and aside from
that, they are admitted by other agents of the Gov-
ernment and established by uncontrovertible proof. The
default was the Government's own and no one else was
to blame for it. The builder's immunity from liquidated
damages followed as a matter of law, as well as by virtue of
the contract. The obligations of both the Government and
33
the builder were continued by the extension of the build-
ing period. The Government argued in the court below that
in the absence of a covenant giving the builder a right to
recover damages, it did not possess that right. That is pre-
posterous. The right existed not because the contract said
. but because the Government failed to perform the con-
tract on its part and because the contract did not say that
the builder should not have damages for the Government's
breach if an extension were granted,
Stubbings Co. vs. Exposition Co. (110 TM. App.. 210).
This action grew out of a contract for glazing and other
work upon buildings to be erected for the World's Pair at
Chicago. Tt was stipulated that the contractor would com-
plete it by a certain date. It contained this clanse:
“The sum of $50 per day shall be deducted from
the contract price for each day the work is delayed in
completion after the specified date. If, however . prog-
ress of the work shall be del: wed by any cause beyond
the control of the contractor, an extension of time m: Ly
be made by the Chief, but claims for such extension
must be made in writing at the time of such delay,
and the decision of the Chief thereon shall be final and
binding upon both parties.”
Three of the items in plaintiff's bill of particulars were
for “damages for extra time on account of advance in
wages, caused hy work not being ready for us to complete
as per terms of our contract.” The court said:
‘The propriety of an allowance of claims for dam-
ages for such delay, when supported by the evidence,
has been recognized. Tobev vs. Price, 75 Tl. 645:
Church vs. Hearson, 41 Ill. App., 89. And the con-
tractor was not obliged to abandon the work and sue
for damages, but had the right to proceed to complete
it and then claim damages. * * * Tt is contended.
however, by appellee, that the stipulation in the con-
tracts that if delays are occasioned by other contrac:
34
iors additional time will be allowed within which to
complete the work, by implication means that there is
to be no pecuniary compensation on account of dam-
ages suffered by such delays. It is conceded that there
was delay, and it does not seem to be denied that wages
rose in the meantime and that it cost the appellant con-
siderably more on that account to perform its contracts.
The provisions of the contract referred to do not pur-
port to authorize the chief to determine what, if any,
damages the contractor might suffer from such de-
lav. The question is not as to the amount of extra
time to be allowed the contractor. There might be no
contention as to such allowance, and yet the contractor
might be seriously damaged by a rise in the cost of
material and labor, possibly to such an exter t as to
cause him absolute loss. We are of opinion that the
language used in the contract did not submit this ques-
tion of damages to the decision of the architect or
chief.”
In the present case we ha. > seen that the law precluded
the Secretary of the Navy from entertaining the question of
the claimant's damage, and that he refused to entertain the
claim in suit on the ground that he had no authority in law
ty do so.
Velson vs. Pickwick Co. (30 Il. Apps., 333). This was
an action for breach of a contract by which Nelson, the
appellant. had undertaken to do certain painting and glaz-
ing on a building which was being erected by the Pickwick
Company, appellee. The specifications provided that the
work should be completed by a certain date, and that if
Nelson failed to do so, penalty at the rate of $25.00 per
iy should he deducted from his compensation; also, that
Nelson should co-operate with the other contractors
and arrange to avoid delay. The specifications were in
print and the court assumed that all the contractors were
bound by like provisions. The contract required the work
to be done under the supervision of architects. It reiter-
Bd
ated the provision for the deduction of $25.00 per day for
each day’s delay, but provided:
“Should delay be caused by other contractors, to
the positive hindrance of the contractor hereto, a just
and proper amount of extra time shall be allowed by
the architects, * * * and in case the said parties
shall fail to agree as to the * = * amount of
extra time, the decision of the architects shall be final
and binding.”
Judge Gary delivering the opinion of the court said (pp
335 et seqg.):
“The principal question in the case is. whether this
provision for the allowance of extra time by the ar:
chitects is the only remedy of the appellant when de-
laved by other contractors. He was so delaved until.
by the rise in wages, it cost him $473.20 more than it
otherwise would have done to perform his contract.
The matter in controversy is, whether he shall recove!
that sum. There is parol testimony of a promise by
the general agent of the appellees, having authoriiy.
made to appellant when but a small part of the work
was done, and he claimed extra pay as condition of
going on with it, that the company would pay the ad-
ditional cost caused by such delay. But if the rights
of appellant were fixed by the contract. any promise
to pay him extra for doing what the contract bound
him to do would lack a consideration, unless special
circumstances would take the case out of the general
rule, as in Bishop vs. Busse, 69 IW, 403. and Cooke
ws. Murphy, 70 Ill, 96. There is a preponderance
of the testimony that such a promise was made.
and the probability that there was, as well as
the justice of the claim, are strongly supported
by the concurrent circumstances. Without — re.
citing that testimony and those circumsiances, hov- 3
ever, the case may safely be put upon the ground thai
‘the contract necessarily presupposes and implies, on
the part of the appellees, an obligation to supply’ that
36
upon which the appellant was to do his work. Broom's
Legal Maxims, 667. It was the legal duty of the ap-
pellecs to keep the work in such a state of forwardness
as to enable the appellant to perform his contract with-
in the limited time. See vs. Partridge, 2 Duer., 403.
The provision for the extra time was for the avoid-
ance of the penalty the appellant would incur tf he did
not complete his contract on time. In its language it
purports to be a benefit to him; an allowance, not a
deprivation, of his right to require the work to be in
readiness for him. Under a provision in the spectfica-
tions with other contractors, whose work preceded that
of the appellant, like that in the specifications for his
work, the appellees had in their hands indemnity for
the increase to the price of the appellant's work. If
they did not have such a provision it was their own
omission, the consequence of which is not chargeable
to appellant. If the appellees desired exemption from
their obligations under the contract, they should have
put such exemptions in clear language that would
have put appellant on his guard, and left no doubt as
to what was intended. * * * Itis only by the ap-
plication of the maxim, “EXPRESSIO UNIUS EST EXCLUSIO
\LTERIUS,’ that the claim of the appellant can be cut off;
that, as there is one consequence of delay caused by
other contractors declared, all others are, by that dec-
laration, exclided. But this maxim ‘is not of uni-
versal application, but depends on the intention of the
parties as discoverable upon the face of the instrument,
or of the transaction.” Broont’s Legal Maxims, 633.
The claim made by the appellant is not within the
clause quoted from the contract as to questions the ar-
chitects should decide. There is no question of the value
of extra work, nor is there any disagreement between
the parties relating to performance of the contract.
The amount which the appellant should recover 1f he ts
entitled to recover at all, being undisputed, the decree
is reversed and the cause remanded with directions to
allow to appellant $478.20 for his damages for delay.
as well as the amount due him upon the contract.”
See also: Frost vs. Rand, McNally & Co. (51 Ul.
App., 276).
ee
Del Genovese vs. Third Ave. R. Co. (13. N. Y. App. 412,
1897). The contract drawn in question related to an exca-
vation for the foundation of a power house. The com-
plaint set out two causes of action: one for an unpaid
balance of the contract price; the other for damages sus-
tained by plaintiff in consequence of numerous hindrances
and delays caused by agents of the defendant company.
The case went to a referee who found for the plaintiff, re-
porting that, in consequence of directions given by the ar-
chitect, defendant's agent, which the plaintiff was required
to obey, he had on certain occasions been obliged to suspend
work altogether and at other times had been greatly ob-
structed in his operations by the presence of material and
apparatus of other contractors engaged in doing
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.