Transcript of Record — Diehl v. Lehigh Valley Railroad
Supreme Court brief1955
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 1954
No. 246
PAUL W. DIEHL, JR., PETITIONER,
vs.
LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD CO., ET AL.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT
INDEX
Original Print
Proceedings in the U.S.C.A. for the Third Cireuit 1 1
Appendix to brief for appellant 1 1
Docket entries . 1 1
Complaint . 3 3
Motion to dismiss 7 7
Affidavit in support of defendant’s motion to dis-
miss 3 ore 7 7
Memorandum of agreement covering senior-
ity status of employees, ete. 13 13
Memorandum of agreement relating to senior-
ity status of Carmen Helpers, ete. 16 16
Agreement between the Lehigh Valley Rail-
road Co. and System Federation No.
96, ete. . 21 21
Counter affidavit 24 24
Order for leave to intervene : 26 26
Motion of intervening defendants to dismiss com-
plaint Zal-E 27 27
Jupp & Derwerer (Inc.), Printers, Wasutnoton, D. C., Nov. 23, 1954
—8647
el 8 eer kt Ae oe ee SM eR eg og Nee
tt INDEX
Appendix to brief for appellant—Continued Original = Print
Motion for summary judgment 29 29
Affidavit in support of plaintiff's motion for sum-
mary judgment 29 29
Opinion on motion to dismiss, Kirkpatrick, J. 35 35
Judgment 39 39
Joint appendix to separate briefs of t appellees 41 41
(See Separate Index) ........... 42 42
Opinion, Biggs, C. J. 5 ick ete! “ 53 53
Judgment , nee ae ; 61 60
Clerk's certificate (omitted in printing) 62
Order exicuding time to file — for writ of certiorari 63 61
Order granting certiorari Pht Ee 67 61
—
la
APPENDIX
1. IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Civil Action No. 12996
Pau W. Drex1, JR. ) G. A. Gleeson, Esq.
v.
LeHich Vattey Ratroap | Harry E. Sprogell, Esq.
CoMPANY
System Feperation No. 96 | William M. Gerber, Esq.
of THe Ramway Em-
PLOYEES DEPARTMENT OF .
THE AMERICAN FEDERA-
TION OF LaBor, Pau C.
Yost, WarREN A. SHUupPP,
Srantey CC. BRINKMAN
| and STEPHEN J. PAVLIN-
| SKY,
Intervening Defendants )
|
Docket Entries
1951
1 Nov.28 Complaint filed.
Nov. 28 Summons exit.
2 Dec.18 Summons returned: ‘‘on Dee. 5, 1951
served and filed.”
3 Dec.26 Stipulation of counsel extending time for
filing Answer to January 21, 1952 and
Order of Court approving same filed.
Noted 12/27/51.
1952
4 Jan.21 Stipulation of counsel extending time for
filing Answer to February 4, 1952 and
i EDIE NSE 2 SY ES IAT ED ILS LE IID AGES
14
Feb. 4
Feb. 4
Apr. 7
Apr. 7
Sept. 9
Oct. 14
Oct. 14
Oct. 14
Oct. 17
Oct. 20
Nov. 12
Docket Entries
Order of Court approving same filed.
Noted 1/22/52.
Motion to dismiss and notice of motion
filed.
Affidavit in support of motion to dismiss,
filed.
Motion of System Federation No. 96 of
the Railway Employes’ Department of
the American Federation of Labor and
Paul C. Yost, Warren A. Shupp, Stanley
C. Brinkman and Stephen J. Pavlinsky
for leave to intervene, filed.
Order of Court granting leave to inter-
vene as to System Federation No. 96, etc.
et al. filed. Noted and Notice mailed
4/8/52.
Motion of Intervening defendants to dis-
miss filed.
Argued Sur Motions to Dismiss—cont’d
to 10/20/52. ;
Motion for Summary Judgment filed.
Affidavit in support of Plaintiff’s Motion
for Summary Judgment filed.
Counter Affidavit of Paul W. Diehl, Jr.
filed.
Counter Affidavit Opposing Plaintiff’s
Motion for Summary Judgment, filed.
Hearing Sur Motions to Dismiss (sub-
mitted on briefs) C.A.V.
Opinion, Kirkpatrick, J., dismissing
complaint filed.
Complaint 3a
15 Nov.12 Judgment Dismissing Action filed.
11/13/52 Noted and Notice mailed.
16 Dec.10 Notice of Appeal by Plaintiff filed.
12/11/52 Copy to Harry E. Sprogell.
17 Dec.10 Copy of Clerk’s Notice to U. S. Court of
Appeals filed.
18 Dec.29 Order Extending to 3/10/53 Time Within
Which to Perfect Record on Appeal filed.
12/30/52 Noted and Notice mailed.
2. [Caption omitted]
Complaint
1. The jurisdiction of this Court is founded, and this
cause of action arises under the provisions of the Act
of Congress known as the Selective Training and Serv-
ice Act of 1940, as amended, U.S.C.A., App. Sec. 308E.
2. Plaintiff is a citizen of the United States of
America and of the State of Pennsylvania, residing at
1045 E. Gordon Street, Allentown, Pennsylvania.
3. Defendant, the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company,
is a corporation organized and existing under and by
virtue of the laws of the State of Pennsylvania, and
doing business in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
4. The plaintiff was first employed by the defendant
company June 24, 1942, as a Car Repair Helper, and
continued in that capacity until February, 1943, when
he was promoted to the position of Set-up Car In-
spector and worked on an assigned job other than tem-
porary until April 15, 1943, when said plaintiff was
drafted into Military Service.
2 A ETO RAILS EEL LILLE DELLE LADS A
ta Complaint
5. On or about the 20th day of October, 1945, plain-
tiff was honorably discharged from the United States
Air Force and returned to work for the defendant com-
pany on or about November 11, 1945, as a Set-up Car
Inspector.
6. On November 1, 1942, a Collective Bargaining
Agreement effective November 1, 1942, between the de-
fendant and System Federation No, 96, Railway Em-
ployes’ Department, American Federation of Labor,
covered the position which plaintiff left to enter Mili-
tary Service.
7. A Collective Bargaining Agreement between the
same parties aforementioned was entered into on Au-
gust 29, 1944, covering the seniority status of em-
ployees in the mechanical crafts who have been pro-
moted to mechanies from apprentices, helpers and
coach cleaners, and on March 1, 1949, the defendant en-
tered into a Memorandum Agreement with the Broth-
erhood of Railway Carmen of America relating to the
seniority status of carmen helpers promoted into the
position of temporary Carmen Mechanic under the pro-
visions of Memorandum of Agreement with System
Federation No. 96, dated August 29, 1944, heretofore
mentioned, paragraph ‘‘Second”’ being set forth as fol-
lows:
‘A earman helper, who has qualified as ecarman
mechanic, as provided in Section First hereof, and
is presently working on position of a temporary
earman mechanic on the effective date of this
agreement. shall be given the opportunity to make
Complaint 5a
an election within fifteen days after the date of his
being notified of having worked 1160 days as a tem-
porary carman mechanic to be placed on the
permanent carman mechanics’ roster with sen-
iority date as of the effective date of this agree-
ment in the order with other men in which he com-
pleted 1160 days’ experience as provided in See-
tion First hereof, and if so electing shall forfeit
his seniority as carman helper. The election by
employee provided herein must be submitted to
local management officer in writing, bearing his
personal signature and witness therete, and copy
furnished to local committee.
8. On January 10, 1949, plaintiff completed his 1160
days, and within 15 days thereafter, in accordance with
Agreement dated March 1, 149, between defendant
and Brotherhood of Railway Carmen of America, ex-
ercised his eleetion, in writing, to be placed on the
permanent Carman Mechanies Rester.
9. In June, 1949, the Bethlehem Car Inspectors Sen-
iority Roster was posted reflecting seniority status ef-
feetive March 1, 1949. On that list, there appeared the
following names, with seniority in the order in which
they appear:
Warren Suver
STANLEY BRINKMAN
Streve PAVLINSKY
Paci W. Dent, Jr.
10, Plaintiff states that if his employment had not
been interrupted by his service in the Armed Forces,
to wit: from April 15, 1943, to November 11, 1945, he
6a Complaint
would have completed his 1160 days on June 1, 1946,
and, therefore, claims seniority over the aforesaid War-
ren Shupp, Stanley Brinkman and Steve Pavlinsky.
11. Plaintiff requested of defendant that he be as-
signed the seniority status that would have been
granted him, except for the interruption of employ-
ment caused by his service in the Armed Forces. De-
fendant refused, and still refuses to grant plaintiff the
relative seniority standing to which he would have been
entitled, if his employment had not been interrupted by
his service in the Armed Forces as heretofore set forth
in paragraph 10.
Wuererore, Plaintiff demands that defendant, the
Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, be required to ac-
cord to the plaintiff the seniority to which he would
have been entitled had his employment not been inter-
rupted with the defendant by his services in the Armed
Forces, as aforementioned, and that plaintiff be granted
such other relief as is equitable and just.
/s/ GERALD A, GLEESON
Gerald A. Gleeson
United States Attorney
/s/ Epwarp A, KALLick
Edward A. Kallick
Assistant United States Attorney
Motion to Dismiss Ja
3. [Caption omitted]
Motion to Dismiss
The defendant moves the Court as follows:
1. To dismiss the action because the Complaint fails
to state a claim against defendant upon which relief
can be granted for the reasons among others:
A. Plaintiff was restored on November 12, 1945 to
the position which he had left and remained in
that position for more than one year;
B. The position of temporary car inspector was not
one in which plaintiff was protected by the Se-
lective Service and Training Act of 1940.
29 To dismiss the action because the Court has no
jurisdiction over the subject matter of the Complaint
for the same reasons.
Signed: Harry E, SproGeLL
Harry E. Sprogell
2301 Packard Building
Philadelphia 2, Penna.
Attorney for Defendant
4, [Caption omitted]
Affidavit in Support of Defendant's Motion to Dismiss
Strate or New York
County or New York | -
-C. L. Waaner, being duly sworn according to law,
deposes and says as follows:
I am Chief of Personnel of Lehigh Valley Railroad
Company, defendant in this case, and am duly author.
8a Affidavit
ized on its behalf to make this affidavit in support of
a motion to dismiss the Complaint.
Attached to this affidavit are true and correct copies
of the following documents pertinent to the plaintiff’s
rights:
Agreement effective November 1, 1942, between Le-
high Valley Railroad Company and System Fed-
eration No. 96, Railway Employees’ Department,
American Federation of Labor (‘‘1942 Agree-
ment’’)
Memorandum of Agreement dated August 29, 1944,
between the same parties (‘1944 Agreement’’)
Memorandum of Agreement dated March 1, 1949,
between Lehigh Valley Railroad Company and
Brotherhood Railway Carmen of America, one
of the crafts forming System Federation No. 96.
Arrer Paut W. Drex1, JR., was employed by the de-
fendant on June 24, 1942 the 1942 Agreement covered
the status and rights of a number of crafts including
that of carman. By the terms of the Agreement (Rule
27) reduction and expansion of working force in the
erafts covered by the Agreement were to be accom-
plished on the basis of seniority. Among the crafts cov-
ered by the Agreement the carmen were divided for
purposes of seniority into four subdivisions under the
provisions of Rule 31, reading as follows:
‘‘Seniority of employes in each craft covered by
this agreement shall be confined to the point em-
ployed in the Maintenance of Equipment Depart-
ee
‘fidavit 9a
ment and there shall be four subdivisions of the
Carmen as follows:
Pattern Makers
Upholsterers
Painters
Other Carmen
‘The seniority lists will be open to inspection
and copy furnished the committee.
‘**Rosters will be compiled and posted in January
of each year and will be open for correction for a
period of sixty (60) days after being posted. If
no exceptions are taken to a roster date within the
sixty day period after it is first posted, the date will
be considered as correct and not changed there-
after. Copy of the roster of each point will he
mailed to Seeretary of the Federated Shop Craft
Committee.”’
Separate rosters were maintained for each sub-divi-
sion of the carmen. Seniority on those rosters was de-
termined by date of first entry on the roster. Seniority
accumulated on one roster did not carry to another
roster if a man caused his name to be changed from
one to another. No man could maintain his name on
more than one roster.
Among the special rules of the 1942 Agreement were
certain rules for carmen of which Rule 120 ‘‘Qualifica-
tions’’ reads as follows:
_—— PE RAMA LS ARE IP RE AE ONE GARR PO TN NS RAI TS
‘*Any man who has served an apprenticeship or
who has had four (4) years practical experience at
carmen’s work and who with the aid of tools, with
10a Affidavit
or without drawings, can lay out, build or perform
the work of his craft or occupation in a mechanical
manner, shall constitute a carman.”’
In addition to the group of fully qualified carmen
there were certain subordinate classifications estab-
lished by the 1942 Agreement including the classifica-
tion of carman helper (Rule 123). In this sub-classifi-
cation also a seniority roster was maintained. Sen-
iority on this roster was governed by principles identi-
eal with those which have been stated above for the sub-
division rosters. When Diehl was employed, his name
was entered on the roster of carmen helpers and until
further assignment he performed the duties of a car-
man helper.
On February 19, 1943, Diehl was assigned tempo-
rarily to perform the duties of a carman and continued
to perform those duties until the time when he entered
the Armed Forces. The phrase ‘‘Set-up” which is used
by Diehl in paragraph 4 of the Complaint to describe
his position as car inspector in railroad terminology
has the same meaning as “‘temporarily advanced’. The
advancement or Set-up of Diehl and other carmen
helpers was made because of war-time emergencies
under agreement between the defendant and System
Federation No. 96, evidenced by the 1944 agreement.
This is the agreement referred to in paragraph 7 of
the Complaint as covering seniority status of em-
ployees in the mechanical erafts. Paragraphs 4 and
11 of that Agreement read as follows:
‘4, Helpers in any craft promoted to mechanics’
positions subsequent to January 1, 1940, will
Affidavit lla
be placed on a desk seniority roster as of the
date they were promoted ; but this will not af-
fect their helpers’ seniority date; they to be
carried on the regular helpers’ roster as of
their original date.”’
‘11. Question of disposition of helpers promoted to
mechanics in any craft, subsequent to January
1, 1940, will be disposed of between the General
Committee and the Management at the expira-
tion of the present emergency.”
During the performance of his duties as a carman
helper temporarily set-up or advanced to perform the
duties of a carman, Diehl and all other similarly Set-up
remained on the roster of carmen helpers. Their names
were not entered on the roster of carmen. They ac-
quired no seniority as carmen and they had no right to
be placed upon the carmen’s roster. Diehl and all other
earman helpers temporarily Set-up to perform the
duties of carmen retained whatever seniority they had
on the carmen helper roster.
When Diehl was re-employed on November 12, 1945,
following his return from service in the Armed Forces
he retained the precise position and seniority on the
-roster of carmen helpers which he had at the time when
he had entered the Armed Forces and he was again
temporarily advanced to perform the duties of a car-
man.
No earman helper Set-up or advanced temporarily
since 1940 to perform temporarily the duties of a car-
"= Al AAAS IRL, 2S MLE SO PEARY OS ENE FL EERE ANE, tl NR RIS Ll
12a Affidavit
man has acquired any seniority as a carman or been
permitted to be listed on the carmen roster except under
the provisions of the 1949 Agreement. The attention
of the Court is particularly called to the following
provisions of paragrapa SECOND of the 1949 Agree-
ment:
‘A earman helper, who has qualified as carman
mechanie, as provided in Section First hereof, and
is presently working on position of a temporary
earman mechanic on the effective date of this
agreement, shall be given the opportunity to make
an election within fifteen days after the date of
his being notified of having worked 1160 days as a
temporary carman mechanic to be placed on the
permanent carman mechanics’ roster with sen-
ority date as of the effective date of his agreement
in the order with other men in which he completed
1160 days’ experience as provided in Section First
hereof, and if so electing shall forfeit his seniority
as carman helper. The election by employee pro-
vided herein must be submitted to local manage-
ment officer in writing, bearing his personal signa-
ture and witness thereto, and copy furnished to
local committee.”’
Reference to 1160 days is to a definition by agree-
ment between defendant and System Federation No.
96 of the four-year requirement of Rule 120 of the 1942
Agreement.
The provisions of paragraph Srconp of the 1949
Agreement as applied to carmen helpers whose 1160
Pratt
a
Affidavit 13a
days of service as temporary carmen mechanics have
not been continuous is exactly the same whether the
interruption was because of service in the Armed
Forces or because of illness or because of leave of ab-
sence or for any other reason. Non-veteran employees
whose service was interrupted by illness or leave of
absence could not apply the time that they were absent
against the 1160-day requirement.
/3/ C. Li. WAGNER
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 18th day of
January A.D. 1952.
(SEAL ) /s/ Grorce C, HAMM
Notary Public
Notary Public, State of New York.
Qualified in Queens County.
No. 41-6749300—Cert. Filed with
N. Y. Co. Clerk and Register. Com-
mission Expires March 30, 1952.
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT COVERING SENIORITY
Sratus orf EMPLOYEES IN THE MECHANICAL CRAFTS
Wuo Have Bren Promorep TO MECHANICS FROM
ApprEeNTIcEs, HELPERS AND CoACH CLEANERS.
1, Helpers in any craft promoted to mechanic’s posi-
tion prior to January 1, 1940, will be placed on the me-
chanies’ seniority roster as of the date they were first
promoted to mechanies.
2. Apprentices who have not finished their ap-
prentices:ip and who have been advanced to perform
mechanical work will be given their seniority as me-
RPA NRIAN ANE IMA ETE RENE TI OE MECR, FN IMU. DAP TOSI 5) NE ORS CI I
l4a Affidavit
chanics from the date of advancement, upon the com-
pletion of their four (4) years’ apprenticeship.
3. Apprentices advanced to mechanics before the
completion of their training course must keep up cur-
rently the lessons required of them in accordance with
the rules governing apprentices.
4. Helpers in any craft promoted to mechanics’ posi-
tions subsequent to January 1, 1940, will be placed ona
desk seniority roster as of the date they were pro-
moted; but this will not affect their helpers’ seniority
date; they to be carried on the regular helpers’ roster
as of their original date.
5. On account of the necessity to temporarily ad-
vance apprentices and helpers to mechanics’ positions,
it is agreed that the following procedure will be fol-
lowed in making such advancements.
6. Regular apprentices, who have served three (3)
years or more of their apprenticeship, will be advanced
first.
7. Helper apprentices, who have served two (2) years
or more of their apprenticeship, will be advanced next.
8. Regular apprentices, who have served two (2)
years or more of their apprenticeship, and helper ap-
prentices, who have served one (1) year or more of
their apprenticeship, will be advanced next.
9. Qualified helpers having two (2) years or more
experience as mechanics, or as helpers, will be ad-
vanced next.
— PRRBNE EMILE EE LILLE GLE IE GLENS LP FE LORI FEM OLR PMS ELM
Affidavit 15a
10. Local Management and Local Committees will
mutually agree on the employees to be advanced and
demoted, subject to appeal to the General Chairman
and the General Management.
11. Question of disposition of helpers promoted to
mechanics in any craft, subsequent to January 1, 1940,
will be disposed of between the General Committee and
the Management at the expiration of the present emer-
gency.
12. This Memorandum of Agreement supersedes all
previous Memorandums of interpretations thereto, cov-
ering the promotion of apprentices and helpers.
For MecHANICAL Crarts System Frperation No. 96:
/s/ Joseru P. McSparron
Int. Assn. Machinists
CHARLES GRAHAM
lat. Bro. Boilermakers, ISB&H
Bruce L. JeENninas
Int. Bro. Blacksmiths, D. F. & H.
Leon E. Gorsk1
Sheet Metal Workers Int. Assn.
Car. K. Smita
Int. Bro. Electrical Workers
Gro. EK. SELLERS
Bro, Railway Carmen of America
JoHN J. WASLOSKI
President, System Federation No. 96
For LEHIGH VALLEY RAILRoAp COMPANY:
‘s/ J. N. HAINes
Asst. to General Manager
Dated August 29, 1944
16a Affidavit
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RELATING TO SENIORITY
Srarus or CARMEN HELPERS PROMOTED TO THE Post-
TION OF TEMPORARY CARMAN MECHANIC UNDER THE
Provisions OF MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT, DaTED
Avaust 29, 1944 (GENERALLY KNOWN AS THE Ur-
GRADING AGREEMENT) BETWEEN THE LEHIGH VALLEY
RatLroap CoMPANY AND SYSTEM Feperation No. 96,
Rauway Emp.oyeres’ DEPARTMENT, AMERICAN FED-
ERATION OF LABOR,
Ir Is AGREED:
To decide the seniority status of carman helpers pro-
moted to temporary carman mechanics under Memo-
randum of Agreement dated August 29, 1944, in accord-
ance with the provisions of Item 11 thereof, reading:
“Question of disposition of helpers promoted to
mechanics in any craft, subsequent to January 1,
1940, will be disposed of between the General Com-
mittee and the Management at the expiration of the
present emergency.”’
the following will apply:
First:
A carman helper, who was upgraded under the pro-
visions of the Memorandum of Agreement dated Au-
gust 29, 1944, and who has worked a total of 1160 days
at a temporary carman mechanie’s rate of pay from
date of first upgrading to temporary carman mechanic,
which date shall be that subsequent to January 1, 1940,
shall be considered eligible to accept or reject perma-
nent carman mechanic seniority date in the following
manner:
1 POAT ay oe rs MBO b>
> a
Affidavit lia
SECOND:
A carman helper, who has qualified as carman me-
chanie, as provided in Section First hereof, and is pres-
ently working on position of a temporary carman me-
chanic on the effective date of this agreement, shall be
given the opportunity to make an election within fifteen
days after the date of his being notified of having
worked 1160 days as a temporary carman mechanic to
be placed on the permanent carman mechanics’ roster
with seniority date as of the effective date of this agree-
ment in the order with other men in which he completed
1160 days’ experience as provided in Section First
hereof, and if so electing shall forfeit his seniority as
carman helper. The election by employee provided
herein must be submitted to local management officer
in writing, bearing his personal signature and wit-
nessed thereto, and copy furnished to local committee.
THIRD:
A carman helper who becomes qualified as a carman
mechanic, as provided in Section First hereof, subse-
quent to the effective date of this agreement, shall be
entitled to elect within fifteen days after notice thereof
to be placed on the permanent carman mechanics’ ros-
ter with seniority date as of day following that on
which he completed 1160 days’ experience as provided
in Section First hereof, and if so electing shall forfeit
his seniority as carman helper. The election by em-
ployee pre ‘ided herein must be submitted to local man-
agement officer in writing, bearing his personal signa-
ture and witness thereto, and copy furnished to local
committee.
. one
a: OPES LOM Br EOIOM OE a a
18a Affidavit
Fourra:
A carman helper who, subsequent to January 1, 1940,
was promoted to temporary carman mechanic and who
presently is not working on a carman mechanic’s posi-
tion, having been demoted to carman helper position or
furloughed as such, shall be given the opportunity to
make an election within fifteen days after the effective
date of this agreement of his desire to have his days of
service rendered at a temporary carman mechanic’s
rate of pay subsequent to January 1, 1940 counted to
qualify him for a earman mechanic’s seniority date.
If he so elects and has the required number of days to
qualify as a carman mechanic as provided in Section
First hereof, he shall be placed on the permanent car-
man mechanics’ roster with seniority date as of the
effective date of this agreement in the order with other
men in which he completed 1160 days’ experience as
provided in Section First hereof, and if so electing
shall forfeit his seniority as carman helper.
If he so elects, but does not have the required number
of days to qualify as a carman mechanic, as provided in
Section First hereof, his record of qualifying carman
mechanic’s days from January 1, 1940 to date shall be
determined, and if in the future he adds to such record
sufficient qualifying days of service rendered at a tem-
porary carman mechanic’s rate of pay to reach total of
1160 such days, he shall be entitled to make further elee-
tion as to whether he desires a carman mechanic’s sen-
jority date in the same manner as provided in Section
Third hereof.
Notices of the provisions of this section of this agree-
ment shall be posted on the employees’ bulletin boards
Affidavit 19a
at all locations for period of fifteen days from the effec-
tive date of this agreement. These notices so posted
shall be deemed to be full and sufficient notice to ear-
man helpers as specified of the provisions of this agree-
ment wher by they may, if they so desire, obtain car-
man mechanie’s seniority date if they have the qualify-
ing days of service rendered at a carman mechanic’s
rate of pay, or, if not, then to have the number of such
qualifying days to be credited to them for future con-
sideration, and not otherwise.
A carman helper coming under the provisions of this
section must submit his request for consideration as
provided herein to local management in writing, bear-
ing his personal signature and witness thereto, and
copy furnished to local committee within the time limit
herein specified of fifteen days after the effective date
of this agreement.
FirrH:
A carman helper who upon qualifying as a carman
mechanie under the provisions hereof and who does
not elect to aceept a permanent carman mechanic’s sen-
iority as provided in Section Second and Section Third
hereof, shall be returned to his former position as a car-
man helper as soon as the local management and local
committee can agree upon replacement to fill position
he has been holding as a temporary carman mechanic.
SIXTH :
The provisions of this agreement shall apply to re-
turning veterans who were promoted to temporary
earman mechanics under the provisions of the agree-
ment dated August 29, 1944, prior to their enlistment
'
ie cll —
YE a es a fo eee eee ere
20a Affidavit
or induction in the armed forces of the United States,
under the Selective Training and Service Act of 1940
and the Selective Service Act of 1948, and when they
returned to service and complete the remainder of the
days’ experience as provided in Section First of this
agreement.
SEVENTH:
All of the provisions of the Memorandum of Agree-
ment dated August 29, 1944 between the Lehigh Valley
Railroad Company and System Federation No, 96,
Railway Employees’ Department, A. F. of L., to which
the Brotherhood Railway Carmen of America was a
party. Sections 1 to 12, inclusive, with the exception of
Section 11 as modified by this agreement, shall continue
in full force and effect for employees of the Carmen’s
Craft represented by Brotherhood Railway Carmen of
America, until changed in accordance with the pro-
cedure required by the Railway Labor Act.
EIGHTH:
This Memorandum of Agreement shall be effective
March 1, 1949 and shall continue in full force and ef-
fect until changed in accordance with the procedure re-
quired by the Railway Labor Act.
.
Accepted for:
BroruErHoop Rat.way CARMEN OF AMERICA:
By /s/ Grorcr E, SELLERS,
General Chairman
Accepted for:
Leniah VaLLey RarLroap COMPANY:
By /s/ C. L. WAGNER,
Chief of Personnel
att =
as = -
anes
Affidavit 21a
LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY
AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD
Co. AND System Feperation No. 96, Errective No-
VEMBER 1, 1942.
* * 7 *
Rule 27
Reduction of Forces.
When it becomes necessary to reduce expenses, the
force at any point or in any department shall be re-
duced, seniority as per Rule 31 to govern ; the employees
affected to take the rate of the job to which they are
assigned.
Four days’ notice will be given employees affected
before reduction is made and lists will be furnished the
local committee.
In the restoration of forces, employees will be re-
stored to service in accordance with their seniority if
available within a reasonable time and shall be returned
to their former positions if possible. The local com-
mittee will be furnished with a list of employees to be
restored to service.
Employees restored to service will not be laid off
again without the four days’ advance notice provided in
this rule.
In reducing the force the ratio of apprentices will be
maintained.
a LAP LEI GELLING LS PLR LE IT, SEINE LENE LIEGE LIEN: PLEO
Affidavit
Rule 31.
Seniority.
Seniority of employees in each craft covered by this
agreement shall be confined to the point employed in
the Maintenance of Equipment Department and there
shall be four subdivisions of the Carmen as follows:
Pattern Makers
Upholsterers
Painters
Other Carmen
The seniority lists will be opened to inspection and
copy furnished the committee.
Rosters will be compiled and posted in January of
each year and will be open for correction for a period of
sixty (60) days after being posted. If no exceptions
are taken to a roster date within the sixty day period
after it is first posted, the date will be considered as cor-
rect and not changed thereafter. Copy of the rosters
of each point will be mailed to Secretary of the Fed-
erated Shop Craft Committee.
* * * *
Rule 120.
Qualifications.
Any man who has served an apprenticeship or who
has had four (4) years’ practical experience at car-
men’s work and who with the aid of tools, with or with-
out drawings, can lay out, build or perform the work of
his craft or occupation in a mechanical manner, shall
constitute a carman.
Affidavit 23a
Rule 121.
Classification of Work.
Carmen’s work shall consist of building, maintaining,
dismantling (except all wood freight train cars), paint-
ing, upholstering and inspecting all passenger and
freight cars, both wood and steel, planing mill, cabinet
and bench carpenter work, pattern and flask making
and all other carpenter work in shops and yards, except
work generally recognized as bridge and building de-
partment work ; carmen’s work in building and repair-
ing motor cars, lever cars, hand cars and station trucks;
building, repairing, and removing and applying wooden
locomotive cabs, pilots, pilot beams, running boards,
foot and headlight boards; tender frames and trucks,
pipe and inspection work in connection with air brake
equipment on freight cars; applying patented metal
roofing; operating punches and shears, doing shaping
and forming; work done with hand forges and heating
torches in connection with carmen’s work; painting,
varnishing, surfacing, decorating, lettering, cutting of
stencils and removing paint (not including use of sand
blast machine or removing vats); all other work gen-
erally recognized as painters’ work under the super-
vision of the locomotive and car departments, except the
application of blacking to fire and smoke boxes of loco-
motives in engine houses; joint car inspectors, car in-
spectors, safety appliances and train ear repairers;
oxy-acetylene, thermit and electric welding on work
| generally recognized as carmen’s work; and all other
work generally recognized as carmen’s work.
* * * *
Counter-Affidavit
Rule 126.
Inspectors.
Men assigned to inspecting must be able to speak,
write and read the English language, and have a fair
knowledge of the A.A.R. (Association of American
Railroads) rules and safety appliance laws, including
the railroad company general rules.
Rule 127.
Inspectors and other carmen in train yards may be
required to take record, for conducting transportation
purposes, of seals, commodities or destination of cars in
connection with carmen’s duties.
* * * *
5. [Caption omitted]
Counter Affidavit
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA on
CouNTY OF
Pau. W. Dreat, JR., having been duly sworn accord-
ing to law, deposes and says as follows:
This affidavit is submitted in answer to affidavit of
C. L. Wagner filed on behalf of defendant.
Defendant’s affidavit alleges that separate rosters
were maintained for each subdivision of the carmen and
that no man could maintain his name on more than one
roster. This was true prior to the agreement between
defendant and System Federation No. 96, dated August
29, 1944, which provided that ‘‘Helpers in any craft
promoted to mechanics’ positions subsequent to Janu-
ary 1, 1940, will be placed on a desk seniority roster as
_ —
Counter-A ffidavit 25a
of the date they were promoted; * * *.’’ After that date
my name was carried on the ‘desk seniority roster’’ of
mechanies and the regular helpers roster.
The phrase ‘‘set-up’’ used in the Complaint denotes
that I was advanced to a higher position, namely, that
of carman mechanic, without having completed the re-
quirements necessary to acquire seniority in that posi-
tion. The position was the regular established posi-
tion in the employ of the defendant and was not a tem-
porary position. When advanced I began to acquire
time towards the ultimate aim of acquiring seniority in
the position. Rule 120 of the 1942 Agreement between
defendant and System Federation No. 96 provided that
‘‘Any man who has served an apprenticeship or who
has had four (4) years practical experience at carmen ’s
work and who with the aid of tools, with or without
drawings, can lay out, build or perform the work of
his craft or occupation in a mechanical manner, shall
constitute a carman.’’? When ‘‘set-up”’ I began to ac-
quire time towards the four years necessary under this
rule.
When re-employed on November 12, 1945, I was re-
employed in the position which I left to enter the armed
forces, namely, that of ‘‘set-up Car Inspector.”’ I was
still in the position of acquiring time towards obtaining
seniority as a carman mechanic.
Defendant has alleged that the provisions of para-
graph Second of the 1949 Agreement are the same re-
gardless of whether service was interrupted by service
in the armed forces or by illness or leave of absence or
any other reason. It is my contention that the pro-
visions speak for themselves and are not ambiguous, I
— ETE PETIA DEP TA, 6 GAO NS FREE PIED bay 59) AS EET OL ASI EE,
' oe PI
a eS!
26a Order for Leave to Intervene
have no information as to the treatment of non-veteran
employees whose service was interrupted by conditions
other than service in the armed forces, but the treat-
ment afforded them is immaterial because ther seniority
was not protected by the provisions of the Selective
Service and Training Act while my seniority is so pro-
tected.
/s/ Pau. W. Dies, Jr.
Paul W. Diehl, Jr.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this
14th day of October, 1952.
Notary Public.
6. [Caption omitted]
Order for Leave to Intervene
Anp Now, to wit, this 7th day of April A.D., 1952,
upon motion of William M. Gerber, Esq., of Philadel-
phia, Pennsylvania, and Richard R. Lyman, Esq., of
Toledo, Ohio, its attorneys, leave is hereby granted to
System Federation No. 96 of the Railway Employees’
Department of the American Federation of Labor, et
al., to intervene in the above entitled case, to file for its
pleading to the Complaint of the plaintiff, a motion to
dismiss said Complaint, and to participate fully in all
further proceedings herein as a party defendant.
/s/ Guy K. Barp
-—
Motion to Dismiss Complaint 27a
7. [Caption omitted]
Motion of Intervening Defendants to Dismiss Complaint
Now come the intervening defendants System Fed-
eration No. 96 of the Railway Employees’ Department
of the American Federation of Labor, and Paul C. Yost,
Warren A. Shupp, Stanley C. Brinkman, and Stephen
J. Pavlinsky, and respectfully move the Court to dis-
miss the complaint of the plaintiff herein on the
grounds of lack of jurisdiction of this Court over the
subject matter and failure of said complaint to state a
claim upon which relief can be granted, and in support
of said motion state as follows:
1. It appears on the face of the complaint that upon
his return from the armed forces plaintiff was restored
to the position in the employ of defendant Railroad
Company which he left to enter the armed forces, was
retained in such position for more than one year fol-
lowing such restoration, and was not subsequently dis-
charged therefrom.
2, Whatever reemployment rights plaintiff possessed
by virtue of the Selective Training and Service Act of
1940, as amended, necessarily accrued upon his dis-
charge from the armed forces and application to de-
fendant Railroad Company for reemployment; and
this action, brought more than six (6) years subsequent
to plaintff’s reemployment on November 11, 1945, is
barred, insofar as it purports to assert such rights, by
the applicable statute of limitations of the State of
Pennsylvania.
28a Motion to Dismiss Complaint
3. It appears that prior to March 1, 1949, plaintiff
possessed no right to demand and receive either a
permanent position or any seniority status as carman
(mechanic) ; that whatever rights he now possesses to
such position and status necessarily spring from the
agreement effective March 1, 1949, between the System
Federation and defendant Railroad Company ; and that
this Court lacks jurisdiction of the subject matter over
the claim asserted by plaintiff for the reason that ex-
clusive jurisdiction of such claims is vested in the Na-
tional Railroad Adjustment Board.
4. That the Selective Training and Service Act of
1940, as amended, did not entitle plaintiff, under the
circumstances related in the complaint, to the position
and seniority status of carmen (mechanic) which he
claims.
/s/ Wit1iaM M. GerBer
William M. Gerber
1203 Morris Bldg.
1421 Cliestnut St.
Philadelphia, Penn.
/s/ Ricuarp R. LyMan
Richard R. Lyman
741 Nicholas Building
Toledo 4, Ohio
Of Counsel:
MvuLHOLLAND, Rosie & Hickey
741 Nicholas Building
Toledo 4, Ohio
" res’ = ee ai Saal
Motion for Summary Judgment 29a
8. [Caption omitted]
Motion for Summary Judgment
The plaintiff, Paul W. Diehl, Jr., by his attorneys,
Geratp A. GLEESON, United States Attorney in and for
the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, and Edward A.
Kallick, Assistant United States Attorney in and for
the said District, hereby moves the Court to enter sum-
mary judgment for the plaintiff, in accordance with the
provisions of Rule 56(a) of the Rules of Civil Proee-
dure, on the ground that the pleadings in this case and
the affidavits filed by the parties hereto show that the
plaintiff is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
/s/ Geratp A, GLEESON
Gerald A. Gleeson
I'nited States Attorney
s/ Epwarp A. KALLick
Edward A. Kallick
Assistant United States Attorney,
Attorneys for Plaintiff
9. [Caption omitted]
Affidavit in Support of Plaintiff's Motion for Summary
Judgment
CoMMON WEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
CouNTY OF } =
Paut W. Diext, Jr., being first duly sworn, deposes
and says:
I am the plaintiff in the above captioned case, and
have personal knowledge of the facts herein set forth.
This affidavit is submitted in support of plaintiff’s
' motion for summary judgment herein, for the purpose
ty
og
Pa,
= laser al laa BE ILI LISLE TUT IONE GE AOE. A So VE IONE NY «EMPLOI LSE SEND
30a Affidavit
of showing that there is in this action no genuine issue
as to any material fact, and that the plaintiff is en-
titled to judgment as a matter of law.
I, Paul W. Diehl, Jr., was employed by the defend-
ant, Lehigh Valley Railroad Company, on June 24,
1942, as a Car Repair Helper and acquired seniority as
such under the rules, practices and customs of the com-
pany as of that date. In February 1943, I was pro-
moted to the position of ‘‘Set-Up Car Inspector’’. In
that position I performed all of the duties of a Car In-
spector. This position was not a temporary position
but a permanent position in the employ of the defend-
ant company. The defendant company had entered
into a collective bargaining agreement with System
Federation No, 96, Railroad Employees’ Department,
American Federation of Labor, on November 1, 1942,
which agreement covered the position of Car Inspector.
Copy of said agreement is attached to affidavit of C. L.
Wagner filed on behalf of the defendant company.
On April 15, 1943, while employed as Car Inspector
by defendant railroad company, I was drafted into the
military service of the United States.
While I was serving in the armed forces of the
United States, defendant railroad entered into a col-
lective bargaining agreement with System Federation
No. 96, mentioned above, on August 29, 1944, which pro-
vided in part:
‘*4. Helpers in any craft promoted to mechanics’
positions subsequent to January 1, 1940, will be
placed on a desk seniority roster as of the date
they were promoted; but this will not affect
pony
PELOTON, EH pe
Affidavit dla
their helper’s seniority date; they to be carried
on the regular helpers’ roster as of their orig-
inal date.
‘**11. Question of disposition of helpers promoted to
mechanics in any craft, subsequent to January
1, 1940, will be disposed of between the General
Committee and the Management at the expira-
tion of the present emergency.”’
The reference to mechanics’ positions in paragraph
4 above included the position of Car Inspector, which
I occupied when drafted into the military service of the
United States. I was placed on the ‘desk seniority
roster’’ referred to above as of February 1943, the date
I was promotedto Car Inspector. The names of War-
ren Shupp, Stanley Brinkman, and Steve Pavlinsky
were placed on said ‘‘desk seniority roster’’ subsequent
to the date assigned to me.
On October 20, 1945, I was honorably discharged
from the United States Air Force and returned to
work for defendant railroad as a ‘“‘Set-Up Car In-
spector’’. Had it not been for my service in the armed
forces, I would have completed 1160 days of service
as a ‘Set-Up Car Inspector”’ on June 1, 1946. Warren
Shupp, Stanley Brinkman and Steve Pavlinsky all
completed 1160 days in such position after June 1, 1946.
I completed 1160 days of actual service on the job as a
‘Set-Up Car Inspector’”’ on January 10, 1949, the delay
being caused solely by my absence in the military serv-
ice of the United States. At that time no ‘‘Set-Up Car
Inspector’’ had been placed on the carmen’s seniority
— ab PTET RARE TL) TYE T TM PRT HT YP OY a ei i 6g oe a SOT Pee de
32a Affidavit
roster but seniority was still retained on the helpers’
seniority roster and the ‘desk seniority roster’’, on
both of which rosters I was senior to the said Warren
Shupp, Stanley Brinkman and Steve Pavlinsky.
On March 1, 1949, defendant railroad and System
Federation No. 96, Railway Employees’ Department,
American Federation of Labor, entered into a collective
bargaining agreement in pursuance of Section 11 of
the 1944 agreement quoted above, which provided as to
helpers who had been upgraded to the position of Car-
man Mechanic, which position is the same as that of
‘‘Set-Up Car Inspector’’, as follows:
‘*Pirst
A carman helper, who was upgraded under the
provisions of the Memorandum of Agreement
dated August 29, 1944 and who has worked a total
of 1160 days at a temporary carman mechanic’s
rate of pay from date of first upgrading to tem-
porary carman mechanic, which date shall be that
subsequent to January 1, 1940, shall be considered
eligible to accept or reject permanent carman me-
chanic seniority date in the following manner:
** SECOND
A earman helper, who has qualified as carman
mechanic, as provided in Section First hereof. and
is presently working on position of a temporary
carman mechanic on the effective date of this
agreement, shall be given the opportunity to make
an election within fifteen days after the date of his
being notified of having worked 1160 days as a
cc eal
Affidavit 33a
temporary carman mechanic to be placed on the
permanent carman mechanies’ roster with sen-
iority date as of the effective date of this agreement
in the order with other men in which he completed
1160 days’ experience as provided in Section First
hereof, and if so electing shall forfeit his seniority
as carman helper. The election by employee pro-
vided herein must be submitted to local manage-
ment officer in writing, bearing his personal sig-
nature and witness thereof, and copy furnished to
local committee.’’
Pursuant to this agreement I was given the option of
electing to become a Carman Mechanic and exercised
this option within fifteen days after being notified of
the election.
In June of 1949 the ‘‘ Bethlehem Car Inspectors’ Sen-
iority Roster’? was posted showing seniority status as
of March 1, 1949. Said list showed seniority as follows:
Warren Shupp
Stanley Brinkman
Steve Pavlinsky
Paul W. Diehl
Warren Shupp was employed as a helper on Septem-
her 5, 1942, and, without interruption by reason of mili-
tary service, completed 1160 days as a Car Inspector on
October 25, 1946. Stanley Brinkman was employed as
a helper on April 19, 1943, and, without interruption
by reason of military service, completed 1160 days as a
Car Inspector on December 22, 1947. Steve Pavlinsky
Pitre ¥ mg EP (7 POM LMA ED LEI ENN ION AT OE ET HLS NIN ET He
— ens
34a Affidavit
was transferred from Easton as a “Set-Up Car In-
spector” and, without interruption by reason of mili-
tary service, completed 1160 days as a Car Inspector
on July 18, 1948.
I requested the defendant railroad company to ad-
vance my name on the seniority list above that of War-
ren Shupp, the first man junior to me who completed
his. 1160 days of service as an upgraded Carman Me-
chanie subsequent to June 1, 1946. After considerable
negotiation my req fist was refused. I then consulted
the representative of the United States Department of
Labor on July 5, 1949. Said representative communi-
cated with the defendant railroad on July 13, 1949.
Negotiations regarding my rights as a veteran under
the Selective Service and Training Act continued be-
tween the representative of the United States Depart-
ment of Labor and defendant railroad until the rail-
road finally denied my claim on January 2, 1951. In
the meantime I had applied to System Federation No.
96, Railway Employees’ Department, American Fed-
eration of Labor, the collective bargaining representa-
tive of the employees of defendant railroad, to file a
grievance on my behalf, but the Union refused to do
so on December 30, 1950. On February 26, 1951, my
case was referred to the United States Attorney for the
Eastern District of Pennsylvania by the representative
of the United States Department of Labor, together
with a letter from me requesting that legal proceedings
Opinion 35a
be instituted in my behalf. On November 28, 1951, this
suit was brought.
/3/ Pau. W. Dieu, JR.
Paul W. Diehl, Jr.
Subseribed and sworn to before me
this — day of , 1952.
Notary Public
10. [Caption omitted]
Opinion
Sur Motions to Dismiss
Before Kirkpatrick, Ch. J.
This case is before the Court on motions by the de-
fendant and the intervening defendants to dismiss the
complaint. Both sides have filed affidavits, but no sub-
stantial issue of fact is raised by them and they are in
the main merely explanatory.
The question involved is whether the plaintiff, Diehl,
a veteran, is entitled to seniority rights ahead of Yost,
Shupp, Brinkman and Pavlinsky, the four intervening
individual defendants, non-veterans.
At the time the controversy arose the seniority status
of all five men was governed by a Union Agreement
dated March 1, 1949, the pertinent sections of which
provided in substance that carmen helpers, temporarily
upgraded to carmen mechanics’ positions (in which
category all five of the men then were), could at their
election become permanent carmen mechanics, pro-
vided they had worked a total of 1160 days at a tem-
porary carman mechanic’s rate of pay from the date of
4 READ DEI O IEE AEE TR TC EF NASA NE AD 2
36a Opinion
first upgrading ‘‘with seniority date as of the effective
date of this agreement in the order with other men in
which (they) completed 1160 days’ experience.”’
Taking the word ‘‘experience’’ in its ordinary mean-
ing, the plaintiff completed his 1160 days of experience
on January 10, 1949. If he had not been drafted and
had been able to work continuously in his position of
temporary carman mechanic, he would have completed
the 1160 days on June 1, 1946. The other four men, the
continuity of whose work was not interrupted by mili-
tary service, all completed their 1160 days after June 1,
1946, but before January 10, 1949.
It is plain that the agreement did not intend that
military service was to be counted as “‘experience”’ in
determining seniority and, therefore, unless the agree-
ment is in contravention of some provision of the Se-
lective Training and Service Act of 1940, the employ-
er’s award of seniority to the intervening defendants
was proper and the plaintiff's claim must fail.
The Act provides that a returing, veteran who has
left a position ‘‘other than a temporary position” shall
be restored “‘to such position or to a position of like
seniority, status and pay” and that he shall then ‘be
considered as having been on furlough or leave of ab-
sence during his period of training and service’’ and
shall be restored ‘without loss of seniority.’’
The first question is whether the plaintiff, when he
returned to his employment, was restored without loss
of seniority to the position which he had left. If he
was, then unless the Union Agreement in some way op-
erated to impair the seniority status, to which he was
entitled when he returned, it cannot be held invalid,
a
_—
Opinion 37a
there being nothing else in the Act which would up-
set it.
When the plaintiff left his employment to go into
military service he was a carman helper temporarily
upgraded to the position of carman mechanic. He had
been first employed June 24, 1942, as a carman helper,
was advanced to the position of ‘‘set-up car inspector,”
which is the same thing as a temporary carman me-
chaniec, and while in that position was drafted on April
15, 1943. On that date he had seniority as a carman
helper, running from the date of his first employment,
but none at all* as a carman mechanic. Under the
Union Agreements and rules, then and since in force,
the two positions were entirely separate and distinct,
so far as seniority was concerned. When a man moved
from one such position to another, he lost all seniority
acquired in the old job and had to begin at the bottom
in the new one. Thus a man with twenty years con-
tinuous employment behind him might, if he accepted
promotion to a new job, find himself in seniority behind
men with ten years or even less. The retention of sen-
iority rights is often considered preferable to promo-
tion—a fact which accounts for the option to elect not
to take the new job which was accorded to the men by
the 1949 agreement.
When the plaintiff returned to work on November
11, 1945, he was restored to exactly the position which
he had left, namely, ‘‘set-up car inspector’’, or tempo-
* When the plaintiff was advanced to his temporary position as
earman inspector, his name was placed on a ‘‘desk seniority
roster’’, but all parties agree that this had no effect upon the
seniority which he claims in this action.
— 2 ye TORS a RL PNR PEIN SH A EWI eet RRR 2 ee a
38a Opinion
rary carman mechanic. He lost no seniority which he
had when he left, for he retained seniority as a carman
helper dating from his first employment, June 24, 1942,
being given seniority credit on that for the time he was
in service. This was in exact compliance with the pro-
vision of the Act requiring that he be considered as hav-
ing been on furlough or leave of absence.
When the plaintiff was drafted, the only right he had
was that given by Rule 120 under the Union Agreement
of 1942, namely, to be promoted to carman mechanic
after four years (the equivalent of the 1160 days of the
1944 Agreement) of ‘‘practical experience at carmen’s
work’’, with seniority as of the day he became a carman
mechanic. A temporary assignment as carman me-
chanie did not affect that right in any way. Nor did
the Agreement of 1944, which merely provided that the
question of seniority of such temporary employees
should be postponed until a later agreement could be
effected, as it was, in 1949. There was, of course, the
possibility, maybe probability, that he would be able
to work continuously and acquire the necessary experi-
ence ahead of men who began to get theirs later, but the
protection of the Act extends only to emplovees’ rights
and was not intended to cover their expectations. To
restore the veteran to the rights which he had when he
entered military service and which would be lost unless
protected is something that the law ean do and does, but
to restore or compensate or give the equivalent of lost
opportunities is something which the law wisely does
not attempt.
_
Judgment 39a
When the plaintiff was drafted, he had at most a rea-
sonable expectation that he would get on the permanent
seniority roster of carman mechanic ahead of the men
who are now intervening defendants—an expectation
which might have been realized if he had not been in
military service. But the Court can give him the ad-
vanced seniority which he claims in this action only by
a ruling which would mean that no Union Agreement
regulating seniority, no matter how long after the vet-
eran’s return it is made, is valid unless it provides that
military service shall be taken as the equivalent of ex-
perience in the craft. The great weight of authority
is to the contrary. See Fries v. Pennsylvania Railroad
Co., 195 F. 2d 445; Zaversnik v. Union Pacific Railroad
Co., 95 F. Supp. 209; Seattle Star, Inc. v. Randolph
— —- 168 F. 2d 274.
The complaint may be dismissed.
,
11. [Caption omitted]
Judgment
Berore KIRKPATRICK, J.
AnD Now, to wit: November 12th, 1952, in accord-
ance with Opinion of the Court, it is OrpERED that the
above action be and the same is hereby Dismissed.
By THE Court:
ATTEST :
/3/ J. A. CoMEY
Deputy Clerk
WU. S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1953—251896/P.0.1534
_ n°
No. 11022
In the
United States Court of Appeals
For the Third Circuit
Paun W. Dient, Jr., Appellant
v.
Leuien VaLury Rat_Lroap Company, BT AL.
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern
District of Pennsylvania
JOINT APPENDIX TO SEPARATE BRIEFS OF APPELLE
LEHIGH VALLEY RAILROAD COMPANY AND OF
APPELLES SYSTEM FEDERATION NO. 96 OF THE RAIL-
WAY EMPLOYES’ DEPARTMENT, A. F. OF L., AND PAUL
C. YOST, WARREN A. SHUPP, STANLEY C. BRINKMAN
AND STEPHEN J. PAVLINSKY
Harry E. SPROGELL
2301 Packard Building
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Of Counsel: Attorney for Appellee Lebigh
SAUL, Ewine, Remick & SAUL Valley Railroad Company
2301 Packard Building
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania WILLiAM M. GERBER
1203 Morris Building
1421 Chestnut St.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
MULHOLLAND, Ropir & HICKEY RicHarpD R. LYMAN
741 Nicholas Building 741 Nicholas Building
Toledo 4, Ohio Toledo 4, Ohio
Attorneys for Fs garuer System
Federation No. of the Railway
— yes Department, A. F. of L.,
and Paul C. Yost, Warren A.
shapp, Stanley C. Brinkman and
Stanley ]. Pavliasky
—————HFCEIVED& FILED —“‘C;:#
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
1. Rules 32; 40, 41, 42, 43; 123; 134, 135, 136, 137, 138,
139; 142 of agreement between the Lehigh Valley
Railroad Company and System Federation No. 96
effective November 1, 1942, attached to affidavit of
C. L. Wagner (which affidavit together with cer-
tain other rules of said agreement appear at pages
7a-24a of Appendix to brief for the appellant
erein) nn cccccccccccccccccevecececccsccoscees la
Counter affidavit opposing plaintiff's motion for
summary judgment ............0eeeeeeeeeeeees 9a
ANNE LT NP MINN NT SF AR MUIR FA 0G ARITA GANT
|
e
43
Rules Attached to Affidavit la
1. Rules 32; 40, 41, 42, 43; 123; 134, 135, 136, 137, 138,
139; 142 of agreement between the Lehigh Valley Railroad
Company and System Federation No. 96 effective Novem-
ber 1, 1942, attached to affidavit of C. L. Wagner (which
affidavit together with certain other rules of said agreement
appear at pages 7a-24a of Appendix to brief for the ap-
pellant herein ).
Rule 32
Assignment of Work
None but mechanics or apprentices regularly employ-
ed as such shall do mechanics’ work as per special rules of
each craft, except foremen at points where no mechanics
are employed.
This rule does not prohibit foremen in the exercise of
their duties to perform work.
At points where there is not sufficient work to justify
employing a mechanic of each craft, the mechanic or mech-
anies employed at such points will, so far as capable, per-
form the work of any craft that may be necessary.
This agreement will not be construed to prevent engi-
neers, firemen, cranemen and operators of steam shovels,
ditchers, clam shells, wreck outfits, pile drivers and other
similar equipment from making any repairs to such equip-
ment they are qualified to perform when required on line
of road.
Rule 40
Apprentices
All apprentices must be able to speak, read and write
the English language and understand at least the first four
ules of arithmetic. Applicants for regular apprenticeship
‘a od SVR P LETT IIOL PL me Co RRR S49) ee A TREO CRE
2a Rules Attached to Affidavit
shall be between 18 and 23 years of age, and, if accepted,
shall serve four (4) years of 290 days each calendar year.
If retained in the service at the expiration of their appren-
ticeship, they shall be paid not less than the minimum rate
established for journeymen mechanics of their respective
erafts. Apprentices shall not work on oxy-acetylene, ther-
mit, electric or other welding processes until they are in the
last year of their apprenticeship.. In selecting helper ap-
prentices, ability and seniority will govern and selections
will be made in conjunction with the respective shop craft
committee.
Rule 41
All apprentices must be indentured and shall be fur-
nished with a duplicate indenture by the company, who will
also furnish every opportunity possible for the appren-
tice to secure a complete knowledge of the trade. No ap-
prentice will be started at points where there are not ade-
quate facilities for learning the trade.
FORM OF INDENTURE
Tile will covtify that ...ccccccccccccccccvesccccvees
was employed a8........-ecscccceseces apprentice by the
bd adasen@hecauushankhaaeaweuéuss -..se+-Railroad at
pudeedeveccdeecdeséueevesed GD vccvevccacsveccedececy OD
ee
(Title of officer in charge)
SERVICE PERFORMED DURING
APPRENTICESHIP:
eeeeeeeeeoeoeeeoeeeeeeeeeeeeeeseeeeeeeeeeeseeeeeeeeveeesee
eoeoeeeeeoeeeooeeeeoeoeeeoeoseeeeoeeeeesesveoseweeeesenveeeseeonaer eee
eee eee eoeoe ee eeeeeeeoeeeeoeeeeseeveeevsFesbeCoeeseeeeoeeeeeesves?
pbducondse Gs dace eben ue desvowiends completed the course
of apprenticeship specified above and is entitled, if em-
ployed by the ........-eceeceeeceeeeeereeees Railroad to
45
Rules Attached to Affidavit 3a
(Title of officer in charge)
NOTE :—The above form is to be used both for regu-
lar and helper apprentices. (Helper apprentices to serve
three (3) years).
The ratio of apprentices in their respective crafts shall
not be more than one to every seven mechanics. This not to
apply to Pattern and Upholstery Shops.
Two apprentices shall not be worked together as part-
ners.
The distribution of apprentices among shops where
general repairs are made on the division shall be as nearly
as possible in proportion to the mechanics in the respec-
tive trades employed therein.
In computing the number of apprentices that may be
employed in a trade on a division the total number of me-
chanics of that craft employed on the division will be con-
sidered.
If within six months a regular apprentice and within
three months a helper apprentice shows no aptitude to
learn the trade he will not be retained as an apprentice.
An apprentice shall not be dismissed except for just
and sufficient cause, before completing his apprenticeship.
Regular apprentices shall not be assigned to work on
night shifts, and shall not be allowed to work overtime dur-
ing the first three (3) years of his apprenticeship.
If an apprentice is retained in service upon complet-
ing the apprenticeship, his seniority rights as a mechanic
will date from the time of completion of apprenticeship.
Preference will be given to sons of employes in the
selection of apprentices up to 80 percent of the number em-
ployed.
46°"
4a Rules Attached to Affidavit
The number of special apprentices permitted shall not
exceed eight (8) at any time; they shall be selected from
men between the ages of 18 and 30 years who have had edu-
cation of such character as to provide them with exceptional
qualifications for this nature of service. They shall serve
three (3) years of 290 days each calendar year or its equiv-
alent.
They shall receive training in the various departments
and in the different classes of work of the crafts in the
Maintenance of Equipment Department and may be moved
at the discretion of the Management.
If retained in service at the completion of the three (3)
year course, the apprentice may choose the craft he desires
employment in and shall receive a special rate for a period
of one (1) year, at the expiration of which he shall be classi-
fied and receive the minimum rate of the craft employed in.
Special apprentices shall receive not less than the
rate paid helper apprentices during their first three years;
this to apply to such apprentices employed after the effee-
tive date of this agreement.
Except as provided for in this rule, special apprentices
shall be governed by the rules of this agreement.
Rule 43
(a) An apprentice who fails ‘9 maintain the study
schedule requirements of two nes examinations each
month, becomes delinquent in any month in which he is
either one or two examinations behind schedule, and he no
longer has a perfect record. However such apprentice is
still considered in good standing and can clear his delin-
quency by submitting the required number of new exam-
inations to put himself on schedule again.
(b) An apprentice who accumulates two uncleared de-
linquencies (two separate months) is still considered in
good standing and can clear his delinquencies by submit-
ting the required number of new examinations to put him-
self on schedule again.
Rules Attached to Affidavit da
(c) An apprentice who accumulates three uncleared
delinquencies (three separate months), is subject to re-
moval from the service after proper investigation is held,
as provided for by Rule 37.
(d) An apprentice who removed himself from the
service for cause as provided in paragraph (c) after proper
investigation is held, as provided for by Rule 37, is given
one more opportunity to clear his record under the follow-
ing conditions :
(1) Within fifteen (15) days after removal from the serv-
ice such apprentice must personally bring to the of-
ficer in charge of the shop point where such appren-
tice is working a sufficient number of new examina-
tions to put himself on schedule again and in addition,
reworked examinations on all lessons on which such
apprentice has previously failed to attain a passing
grade. These examinations must be in an unsealed
and properly stamped envelope or container, so that
the officer in charge may inspect the examinations.
(2) After complying with the requirements of item (1)
such apprentices will then be reinstated.
(e) If an apprentice accumulates three uncleared de-
linquencies a second time, he will be given an investigation
as provided for by Rule 37, and if it is proven that such ap-
prentice was three months delinquent a second time, he will
be dismissed as an apprentice.
(f) In connection with the application of paragraphs
(ec), (d) and (e), it is »nderstood that an apprentice may
be excused for failure to live up to the study schedule re-
quirements of his technical training on account of sickness
or any other legitimate cause beyond his control. The Ap-
prentice Instructor, in conjunction with the Local Commit-
tee, will investigate such cases and will make their recom-
mendations to the supervisory officer as to whether an ap-
prentice should be excused.
RETAIL OL TIO GE FOLGE NA PLE CLO LEI KE MORAG IR
AE IE OO GOEDEL ALLEL LOE IES
48
6a Rules Attached to Affidavit
(g) An apprentice who is delinquent in his studies
when completing his apprenticeship, will not receive his di-
ploma until after he has cleared his record.
(h) Apprentices leaving the service before complet-
ing their apprenticeship will be required to return the com-
plete drawing outfit furnished by the Company, to the of-
ficer in charge at his station before receiving the final pay
due him.
Rule 123
Carmen Helpers
Employes regularly assigned to help carmen and ap-
prentices, employes engaged in washing and scrubbing the
inside and outside of passenger coaches preparatory to
painting, cleaning and dyeing cushions; seat backs, cur-
tains, ete.; washing and scrubbing freight cars; cleaning
car carpets, draperies, curtains, etc., removing of paint and
varnish on other than passenger cars preparatory to paint-
ing, ear oilers and packers, operators of bolt threaders, nut
tappers, drill presses and punch and shear operators (cut-
ting only bar stock and scrap) heating and holding on rivets,
striking chisel bars, side sets, and baeking out punches,
using backing hammer and sledges in assisting carmen in
straightening metal parts of cars, rebrassing of cars in con-
nection with oilers’ duties, coating and cleaning journals,
repairing and fitting up steam and air hose, assisting car-
men in erecting scaffolds, assisting dismantling ears, at-
tending tool room; sand blasting; grinding drills and edge
tools; and all other work generally recognized as carmen’s
helpers’ work shall be classed as helpers.
Rule 134
Apprentices
Regular apprenticeships will be established in all
branches of the trade. Apprentices shall be governed by
49
Rules Attached to Affidavit 7a
the general rules governing apprentices, They will be giv-
en an opportunity to learn the trade.
Rule 135
Helper Apprentices
Fifty percent of the apprentices shall be selected from
carmen’s helpers who have had not less than two (2) years
experience at the point employed at the time application
for apprenticeship is made. Helper apprentices shall not
be over 35 years of age and vill serve three (3) years, a
minimum of 290 days each service year. Helper appren-
tices shall be governed by the same rules as regular appren-
tices. If after the first three (3) months they do not show
an aptitude to learn the trade they will not be retained as
helper apprentices.
Rule 136
Painter Apprentice
Regular apprentices—Division of time for painter ap-
prentices :
The following schedule for regular apprentices, paint-
er, showing the division of time on the various classes of
work, is designed as a guide and will be followed as closely
as the conditions will permit :
6 months—Freight car painting.
6 months—Color room, mixing paint.
6 months—General locomotive painting.
12 months—Brush work, passenger equipment.
18 months—Lettering, striping, varnishing, and such
laying out and designing as the shop affords.
Rule 137
Schedule of Work Painter Helper Apprentice
Helper apprentices—Division of time for painter ap-
prentices :
ba atte maths wat ae SE CLEP ee oe COLL HAE: 4
8a Rules Attached to Affidavit
The following schedule for helper apprentices, painter,
showing the division of time on the various classes of work,
is designed as a guide, and will be followed as closely as
the conditions will permit:
4 months—F reight car painting.
4 months—Color room, mixing paint.
4 months—General locomotive painting.
10 months—Brush work, passenger equipment.
14 months—Lettering, striping, varnishing and such
laying out and designing as the shop affords.
Rule 138
Regular Apprentices, Carmen
The following schedule for regular apprentices, show-
ing the division of time on the various classes of work, is
designed as a guide and will be followed as closely as the
conditions will permit. Where sufficient passenger car
department work is not available without exceeding the reg-
ular ratio of apprentices in the passenger car department,
apprentices will complete their apprenticeship in the freight
car department.
18 months—General freight work, wood and steel.
6 months—Air brake work.
6 months—Mill machine work.
18 months—General coach work, wood and steel.
Rule 139
Helper Apprentice, Carmen
The following schedule for helper apprentices, show-
ing the division of time on the various classes of work, is
designed as a guide and will be followed as closely as the
conditions will permit. Where sufficient passenger car
department work is not available, without exceeding the
regular ratio of apprentices in the passenger car depart-
ment, apprentices will complete their apprenticeship in the
freight car department.
St
Counter Affidavit 9a
12 months—General freight work, wood and steel.
6 months—Air brake work.
6 months—Mill machine work.
12 months—General coach work, wood and steel.
Rule 142
Miscellaneous
Except as provided for under the special rules of each
craft, the General Rules shall govern in all cases.
2. [Caption Omitted]
Counter Affidavit Opposing Plaintiff’s Motion for
Summary Judgment
Strate or New York
ss.
County or New York
C. L. Waeyer, being duly sworn according to law de-
poses and says as follows:
I am Chief of Personnel of Lehigh Valley Railroad
Company, defendant in this case, and am duly authorized
on its behalf to make this affidavit in opposition to the
plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment. I have personal
knowledge of the facts set out below.
It is not accurate to say that the ‘‘desk seniority rost-
er’’ on which plaintiff’s name was entered pursuant to the
agreement dated August 29, 1944 also carried the names of
qualified mechanics. It did not. Mechanies, i.e. carmen
were carried on their own roster—the earmen’s roster.
The only persons placed upon the ‘‘desk roster’’ were un-
qualified persons like the plaintiff who by reason of the
emergency performed a carman’s work.
Lam advised by counsel that I cannot express an opin-
ion whether the plaintiff’s position as a set-up car inspec-
tor was temporary or permanent because to do so would be
Pape senicecee ye MN
oe SPEER MELEE IS EE LGR IS GE LOIN
52 -
10a Counter Affidavit
to express a conclusion and not a fact. The following facts
concerning the plaintiff’s position as a set-up car inspec-
tor were true, however: his name was not entered on any
roster with the name of a qualified earman mechanic. He
had no seniority and was not in position to acquire any
seniority as a carman mechanic prior to the 1949 agree-
ment. He had no right to become a carman mechanic prior
to the 1949 agreement. He performed the work of a car-
man mechanic and was entered upon the ‘‘desk seniority
roster’’ only because of emergencies; had the emergency
not prevailed neither of these events would have occurred,
The phrase describing his ‘‘set-up’’ in railroad terminology
means ‘‘ temporarily advanced.’’
It is not accurate to say that the plaintiff was ‘‘senior”’
to Shupp and others on the ‘‘desk seniority roster’. His
name was entered there earlier than the names of Shupp
and others but seniority has no meaning except as may be
supplied by a labor agreement and the agreements referred
to in my original affidavit were the only agreements under
which the plaintiff ever could have acquired any seniority
whatever.
/8/ C. 1. Waaner
Sworn to and subseribed before me this 16th day of
October, A.D. 1952.
(SEAL) /s/ Grorce C. Hamm
Notary Public
Notary Public, State of New York.
Qualified in Queens County.
No. 41-6749300—Certs. Filed, ete.
we
53
{fol. 53] In Unrrep States Court or APPEALS FOR THE
Tuirp Circuit
No. 11,022
Pauv W. Drea, Jr., Appellant,
Vv.
Lenicn Vatiey Rattroap Company (Derr.), System Fep-
eration No. 96 or THE RatLway EMpLoyees DEPARTMENT
or Lasor, and Paul C. Yost, Warren A. Shupp, Stanley
(. Brinkman and Stephen J. Pavlinsky (Intervening
Defts.)
Appeal from the United States District Court for the
Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Argued September 15, 1953
Before Biggs, Chief Judge, and Goodrich and Hastie,
Cireuit Judges
Opinion or THE Court—Filed March 3, 1954
By Bices, Chief Judge:
This appeal requires a construction of Section 8 of the
Selective Training and Service Act of 1940, as amended."
1 See 54 Stat. 990, 56 Stat. 724, 58 Stat. 798, 60 Stat. 341.
See 50 U.S.C.A. App. § 308. The basic statute will be found
at 54 Stat. 885. As amended the Selective Training and
Service Act expired in its major part on March 31, 1947.
Section 8, however, is saved indefinitely. See Act of June
29, 1946, 60 Stat. 341, § 7. Section 8(c) provides: ‘* Any
person who is restored to a position in accordance with the
provisions of paragraph (A) or (B) of subsection (b) shall
be considered as having been on furlough or leave of ab-
sence during his period of training and service in the land
or naval forces, shall be so restored without loss of seniority,
shall be entitled to participate in insurance or other bene-
fits offered by the employer pursuant to established rules
and practices relating to employees on furlough or leave
IE AM AMIEL OATES, y — 7 - —
ayer Sets a, Aa Ip Sabena Ae ORR AO RASA
een
54
[fol. 54] On June 24, 1942, Diehl was employed as a ‘‘car-
man helper’’ by the Lehigh Valley Railroad Company. A
carman helper’s job fell into a sub-class of a division of
the craft of ‘‘car-men”’ under a collective bargaining agree-
ment executed by Diehl’s union and the railroad. On Feb-
ruary 19, 1943, Diehl was promoted to a job of ‘‘set-up
car-man inspector,’’ the equivalent for our purposes of a
‘*temporary car-man mechanic.”’
On April 15, 1943, Diehl entered the armed forces. On
August 29, 1944, Diehl’s union and the railroad entered into
an agreement which provided that the seniority status of
car-man helpers promoted to temporary car-man mechanics
would be determined by the union and the railroad at the
expiration of the war emergency. On October 20, 1945,
Diehl received an honorable discharge and on November
11, 1945, he re-entered the railroad’s employment as a
temporary car-man mechanic.
On March 1, 1949, a supplemental contract was entered
into between the union and the railroad. The pertinent pro-
vision of this contract provided that ‘‘A car man helper,
who has qualified as a car man mechanic . . . and is pres-
ently working on position of a temporary car man mechanic
of absence in effect with the employer at the time such per-
son was inducted into such forces, and shall not be dis-
charged from such position without cause within one year
after such restoration.’’
The provisions of Section 9(c)(1) of the Selective Serv-
ice Act of 1948, Act of June 24, 1948, 62 Stat. 615, amended
and renamed the ‘‘Universal Military Training and Service
Act’? by the Act of June 19, 1951, 65 Stat. 75, 50 U.S.C.A.
App. § 459, are identical with those of Section 8(c) of the
Selective Training and Service Act but Section 9(c)(2) of
the Selective Service Act of 1948 provides: ‘‘It is hereby
declared to be the sense of the Congress that any person
who is restored to a position in accordance with the pro-
visions of paragraph (A) or (B) of subsection (b) shal!
be so restored in such manner as to give him such status in
his employment as he would have enjoyed if he had con-
tinued in such employment continuously from the time of
his entering the armed forces until the time of his restora-
tion to such employment.”’
ee
—_
5)
on the effective date of this agreement [March 1, 1949],
shall be given the opportunity to make an election within
15 days after the date of his being notified of having worked
1160 days as a temporary can man mechanie to be placed
{fol. 55] on the permanent car man mechanics’ roster with
seniority date as of the effective date of this agreement im
the order with other men in which he completed 1160 days’
experience .. . and if so electing shall forfeit his seniority
as a car man helper.’’ (Emphasis added.)
Diehl would have completed 1160 days’ experience on
June 1, 1946, if his employment by the railroad had not
been interrupted by his war service. He actually completed
1160 days’ experience on January 10, 1949. The four indi-
vidual appellees completed their 1160 days’ experience after
June 1, 1946, but before January 10, 1949. The four indi-
vidual appellees were put on the seniority roster ahead of
Diehl purportedly in accord with the quoted provisions of
the supplemental contract of Mareh 1, 1949. On November
28, 1951, Diehl filed the suit at bar to have himself placed
ahead of the four individual appellees on the seniority
roster. The court below dismissed the complaint’? and
the appeal at bar followed.
We need not concern ourselves with the so-called one year
limitation proviso in the last sentence of Section 8(c), for
the contract of August 29, 1944 provided, as has been said,
that the seniority status of car-man helpers promoted to
temporary car-man mechanics should be determined by the
union and the railroad at the expiration of the war emer-
gency. Diehl was in the armed forces at the time the agree-
ment referred to was made and he was reemployed by the
railroad before the supplemental agreement of March 1,
1949 had been executed. He contends that he is entitled to
the seniority status as a car-man mechanic that he would
have achieved except for the interruption of his employ-
ment by his military service. He cites Section 8(¢), in
particular the phrases which state that the returning vet-
eran must be restored to his employment ‘‘without loss
of seniority’? and gain the ‘‘benefits . . . offered by the
employer pursuant to established rules and practices re-
2 No opinion reported for publication.
— ie she GMT EID ALE ERA OTE” TY NAL NG AS AR
56
[fol. 56] lating to employees on furlough or leave of ab-
sence....’’ Diehl relies on the ‘‘esealator’’ rule cited in
such decisions as Fishgold yv. Sullivan Drydock and Repair
Corp., 328 U.S. 275 (1946) ; Trailmobile Company v. Whirls,
331 U. S. 40 (1947); Aeronautical Lodge v. Campbell, 337
U. S. 521 (1949); and Oakley v. Louisville & N. R. Co., 338
U. S. 278 (1949)." The appellees in support of their posi-
tion cite other language of Section 8(c), viz, that the re-
turning veteran ‘‘shall be considered as having been on
furlough or leave of absence’’ and put a quite different
emphasis than does Diehl upon the decisions of the Supreme
Court of the United States, of this and of other courts. Both
Dich] and the appellees cite legislative history in support
of their positions but that history does not illuminate the
problem confronting us.
We decide first that the provisions of Section 8 of the
Selective Training and Service Act govern. These were
preserved when the rest of the Act was repealed. The pro-
visions of Section 8(c) of the Selective Training and Serv-
ice Act and those of Seetion 9(c) (1) of the Selective Service
Act of 1948 (now known as the Universal Military Training
and Service Act) are identical. The statements in Section
9(c)(2) of the latter Act, beginning, ‘*Tt is hereby declared
to be the sense of the Congress ... [that the returning
veteran] shall be so restored in such manner as to give him
such status in his employment as he would have enjoyed if
he had continued in such employment continuously. . . .’”*
constituted a declaration by Congress as to the meaning
*In Fishgold v. Sullivan Drydock & Repair Corp., 328
U.S. at pp. 284-285, it was said:
“Thus he [the returning veteran] does not step back on
the seniority escalator at the point he stepped off. He steps
back on at the precise point he would have occupied had he
kept his position continuously during the war...
‘¢ He acquires not only the same seniority he had; his
service in the armed services is counted as service in the
plant so that he does not lose ground by reason of his ab-
sence,”’
*The language of Section 9(¢)(2) is quoted in note 1
SULTG,
_—
57
of the provisions of Section 8(¢) of the Selective Training
[fol. 57] and Service Act and of Section 9(c)(1) of the
Universal Military Training and Service Act. Section 9
(c)(2) is a restatement of the escalator doctrine of Fish-
gold and similar decisions. The provisions of Section
9(c)(1) of the Universal Military Training and Service
Act and, therefore, those of Section 8(c) of the Selective
Training and Service Act, seem to be at variance with the
terms of Section 9(¢)(2). It is our duty to reconcile these
apparently conflicting pronouncements if we can. In so
stating we are not unmindful of the fact that Diehl’s rights
are to be tested under Section 8 of the Selective Training
and Service Act of 1940 rather than under Section 9 of the
Universal Military Training and Service Act. But we
cannot believe that Congress, having employed words iden-
tical in Section 9(c) of the Universal Military Training and
Service Act with those of Section 8(c) of the Selective
Training and Service Act of 1940, intended any substan-
tial change.
We think, therefore, that we cannot fairly avoid consider-
ation of the provisions of Section 9(e)(2) of the Universal
Military Training and Service Act. The latest decisions
of the Supreme Court respecting the rights of the returning
veteran are embodied in the Aeronautical Lodge and the
Oakley decisions, supra. In Aeronautical Lodge the Sn-
preme Court resolved a conflict between this court and the
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cireuit, referring partieu-
larly to our decision in Gauweiler v. Elastic Stop Nut Corp.,
162 F. 2d 448 (1947). In that case we held that by reason
of a collective bargaining agreement employees, who had
been elected union officers, were entitled to a seniority
status higher than that of a returning veteran, the collec-
tive bargaining agreement having been executed during the
veteran’s service in the armed forces. This was the problem
which was before the Supreme Court and the Court of Ap-
peals for the Ninth Cireuit in Aeronautical Industrial Dist.
Lodge 727 v. Campbell, 169 F. 2d 252 (1948). In reversing
the ruling of the Ninth Cireuit in Aeronautical Lodge Mr.
[fol. 58] Justice Frankfurter made it clear that in enacting
Section 8 of the Selective Training and Service Act Con-
eress was not creating a seniority system for veterans but
was recognizing seniority systems created by collective
See ae ie ee al ILO A > PT ITE, ML PLE LR OLIN GNI <a ENR 2a
58
bargaining agreements, save where their previsions were
discriminatory in respect to a returning veteran. See 337
U.S. at pp. 526-527. In the Oakley case, supra, Mr. Justice
Burton stated that the position to which the returning
veteran must be restored was one which ‘‘on the moving
escalator of terms and conditions . . . would be compar-
able to the position which he would have held if he had
remained continuously in his civilian employment.”’, citing
Fishgold, Aeronautical Lodge and Trailmobile. See 338
US. at 283. The Oakley case was decided in 1949 after the
enactment of the Selective Service Act of 1948. The lan-
guage employed by the Supreme Court is substantially simi-
lar to that used in Section 9(c)(2) of that Act. See note
1, supra.
By the decision in Aeronautical Lodge, as in our Gau-
weiler case, a special class was carved out for employees
who beeame union officials and these were given seniority
over returning veterans who were not designated to official
union posts. This was done because of the terms of col-
lective bargaining agreements and existing seniority sys-
tems. But if we upply literally the test supplied by Oakley
we must advance Diehl above the four individual appellees
for only so will his position become comparable to that
‘‘which he would have held if he had remained continuously
in his civilian employment’’. If we adopt this course we
must disregard the provisions of Section 8(c) of the Se-
lective Training and Service Act and of the Selective Serv-
ice Act of 1948 (the Universal Military Training and Serv-
ice Act) which provide that the returning veteran ‘‘shall be
considered as having been on f urlough or leave of absence’’
and shall be ‘‘so restored”’ to his position without loss of
seniority. There is a very palpable difference between
‘‘furlough’’ and ‘‘leave of absence’’ and ‘‘continuous em-
[fol. 59] ployment’’.® If we are to follow the ‘‘sense of the
5 In Fishgold v. Sullivan Drydock and Repair Corpora-
tion, 154 F. 2d 785, 788 (2d Cir.), affirmed 328 U.S. 275
(1946). Judge Learned Hand put this issue succinctly as
follows:
‘‘Subdivision (¢) confirms the intention so disclosed. As
subsection B reads, it would probably be understood to
‘ill
Congress”’ as stated by it in Section 9(c) (2) of the Selective
Service Act of 1948 (the Universal Military Training and
Service Act) and apply literally the interpretation of See-
tion 8(c) of the Selective Training and Service Act in the
Oakley case, we must treat ‘‘on furlough’’ and ‘‘leave of ab-
sence’’ as the equivalent of ‘continuous employment”’.
We cannot reconcile the irreconcilable. Congressional
intent as expressed in the actual words of a statute must,
we think, be held paramount to an express Congressional
interpretation of that statute even in an immediately fol-
lowing clause. It must also be borne in mind that in the
Oakley case the Supreme Court was concerned primarily
with the application of the so-called one year limitation for
the protection of the veteran embodied in the last sentence
of Section 8(c). This was the substantial issue before that
tribunal for decision. There is no Supreme Court decision
which rules the precise question before us. But see the
decision of the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Cireuit in
Fries v. Pennsylvania R. Co., 195 F. 2d 445 (1952). In the
instant case the supplemental agreement of Mareh 1, 1949
creates the escalator upon which Diehl must rise to senior-
ity. Non constat but that terms of that agreement which
are discriminatory to the veteran must be disregarded.
But the requirement of 1166 days’ experience to be ap-
plied in the order in which Diehl completed them ‘‘with
other men’’, ineluding the four individual appellees, are
[fol. 60] not discriminatory for Diehl is treated precisely
as are other workmen in his class or working group. The
decision of the court below fitted Diehl precisely into the
59
restore the veteran only to that same position which he
held when he was inducted. That was, however, thought
to be unfair; for while he was in the service, there was likely
to be such changes in the personnel that when he came back,
he might find himself junior to those over whom he had had
priority when he left. To remedy this, by an amendment
made while the bill was in Congress, he was given the same
status that he would have had, if he had been ‘on furlough
or leave of absence’ while he was in the service. How far
that differed from his position, had he remained actively
at work, does not appear; but clearly the amendment pre-
supposed that a difference there might be.’’
3 as RETIREE RR IPCC NTE SIRE TR
—— a
seniority system created by the March 1, 1949 agreement.
He ix dealt with on a parity with other employees who are
non-veterans. To put him above the four individual appel-
lees would seem to award him a kind of superseniority not
contemplated by any statute.
Accordingly, the judgment of the court below will be
affirmed.
| fol. 61] Ixy Usrvev States Court or Appears ror THe Turmp
Crecvit
No. 11,022
Pav W. Dien, Jr., Appellant,
Vs.
Lenin Varcey Rattroap Company, System Feperation No.
Peer tue Ratmoway Emrtovers Department oF THE
Amentcas Feperation or Lanor, and Paul C. Yost, War-
ren A. Shupp, Stanley C. Brinkman and Stephen J.
Pavlinsky
On Appeal from the United States District Court for the
Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Present: Biggs, Chief Judge, and Goodrich and Hastie,
Circuit Judges.
Jvuvogment—Filed Mareh 3, 1954
This cause came on to be heard on the record from the
United States Distriet Court for the Eastern District of
Pennsylvania and was argued by counsel.
On consideration whereof, it is now here ordered and
adjudged by this Court that the judgment of the said Dis-
trict Court in this ease be, and the same is hereby affirmed.
Mareh 3, 1954.
| File endorsement omitted. |
[fol. 62} Clerk's Certificate to foregoing transcript omit-
ted in printing.
wa
61
| Fol. 63-65] Supreme Court or tHe Unirep States
Orver Extrexpixc Time to Fite Petition ror Writ or CEr-
Tioraki—Filed May 20, 1954
Upon consideration of the application of counsel for peti-
tioner,
It is ordered that the time for filing petition for writ of
certiorari in the above-entitled cause be, and the same is
hereby, extended to and including July 31, 14.
Harold A. Burton, Associate Justice of the Supreme
Court of the United States.
Dated this 22nd day of May, 1954.
fol. 66] [File endorsement omitted. ]
[fol. 67] Supreme Court or THe Unirep States, OcToBer
Term, 1954
No. 246
[Title omitted ]
Orper ALtowixe Cerriorani—Filed October 25, 1954
The petition herein for a writ of certiorari to the United
States Court of Appeals for the Third Cireuit is granted,
and the case is transferred to the summary calendar.
And it is further ordered that the duly certified copy of
the transcript of the proceedings below which accompanied
the petition shall be treated as though filed in response to
such writ.
(8647 )
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.