Transcript of Record — United States v. Bloom

Supreme Court brief1951

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

United States Court of Appeals

EIGHTH CIRCUIT

No, 14,212

IN BANKRUPTCY.

UNITED STATES, APPELLANT,

vs.

GENERAL ENGINEERING AND MANUFACTURING

COMPANY, A CORPORATION, DEBTOR,

APPELLEE.

APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE

EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI.

INDEX.

Amended Claim of United States for Taxes.................. 2 1

Petition of Debtor for Hearing on Caims of United States of

America and State of Missouri...... ............. 06.0. c0eeee 3 3

a,

Original Print

Order of Referee in Bankruptcy setting Claims of United States

of America and State of Missouri for Hearing, etc. 7 6

Order of Referee in Bankruptcy that Amended Claim of United

States of America be allowed as a Priority Claim, etc., wed

i aus iNav eden kdedvdiatde fecrkkk Ha. ; 8 7

Memorandum Opinion.......................... 9 8

Petition of United States of America for Review of Order of

Referee in Bankruptcy... ............ 16

Certificate of Referee in Bankruptcy on Petition of United States

of America for Review of His Order of May 9, 1950... 17 15

hel tec oreaderssde dd ce devvetciecs. rota, Tne

IR aig tu tle ua ne eeade’ collec 18 = 16

Petition for Review.......... ....... 18 «16

Question for Determination Submitted to District _ for

ER ears cncviedeshsedestadews 3 is 16

Memorandum of Papers Transmitted with Certificate eae 19 #17

Stipulation that All Facts stated in Memorandum Written by

Referee in Banksuptcy and made the Basis of his Order of May

9, 1950, refusing the Claim of the United States for Interest,

etc., be considered to be True and Correct. __. 2 #17

Stipulation and Agreement as to Matters upon which Petition for

Review was submitted to Referee in Bankruptcy...._. 21 IS

Memorandum Opinion and Order of District Court Ceo ‘onfirming

Order of Referee in Bankruptcy varnishes Post Interest on

Government Claim, June 28, 1950... 23 19

NERS SRN RE ie Teena aay 8 2% 2

Proceedings in U. 8. C. A., for the Eighth Cireuit....._........_____ 23

RR cccncnccesnnwenquecsssessnsescsweiuennncsecetennwenn 2

Co EE ee ee a 24

i 25

Fe critinticcmedesnatnieeernnequies--ednenthmnentnmi 29

a A tees iccerarcsnepcneneninciatpeempneeperetaiiaetsdenipehiihimenparerammaseeniiednaanies 30

Order extending time within which to file petition for certiorari_____ 31

em NO ee ee 32

[fol.2] (Amended Claim of United States for Taxes.)

(Filed April 7, 1950.)

Amended

In the District Court of the United States for the Eastern

Division of the Eastern District of Missouri

In the Matter of —

General Engineering & Manufacturing Co.

4417 Oleatha Avenue

St. Louis, Missouri

Index or Docket No. 11319

In Arrangements*Chapter XI of the Bankruptcy Act

City of St. Louis,

State of Missouri.—ss. :

Arthur J. Brady, Deputy Collector in Chg. of Internal

Revenue for the First Collection District of Missouri, a

duly authorized agent for the United States in this behalf,

being duly sworn, deposes and says:

l. That General Engineering & Manufacturing Co.

above-named is justly and truly indebted to the United

States in the sum of $25,156.27 with interest thereon as

hereinafter stated.

2. That the nature of the said debt is internal revenue

taxes due pursuant to law as follows:

2

ature of Tax Year or Taxable

tatute involved Period ended

a,

Amount of With interest at the rate

Tax of 6% per annum until dat

eee

ica 9/30/48

Fica 10/1/48 to 11/16/48

Futa 1/1/48 to 11/16/48

Withholding 9/30/48

Withholding 10/1/48 to 11/16/48

**If claim of Division of Employment

Security, State of Missouri, is paid

in full, Collector's claim will be

reduced in accordance with Section

1601(a)(3) of the Internal Revenue

Code.

(Interest claimed herein has been

figured up to and including 11/16/48).

Tax §$ 4,492.86 Plus Stat. Int. from 11/17/48 to,

Int 8 Bi Se . ’ ™ e

Tax 1,111.67 “* .

Tax ** 6,444.80 “

Tax 5,956.22 “

o

Int 15.66

Tax 7,123.24

$25,156.27

so) - - =

a a ee

es ff

a a ae

3. That no part of said debt has been paid, but that the

same is now due and payable at the office of the Collector

of Internal Revenue at St. Louis, Missouri.

4. That there are no set-offs or counterclaims to said

debt.

5. That the United States does not hold, and has not,

nor has any person by its order, or to deponent’s knowl-

edge or belief, for its use, had or received, any security or

securities for said debt, except statutory liens.

6. That the said indebtedness is now due and payable;

that no note or other negotiable instrument has been re-

ceived for said debt or any part thereof; and that no judg-

ment has been rendered thereon.

7. That said indebtedness has priority, and must be

paid in full in advance of distribution to creditors, as and

to the extent provided in Section 64 of Public Law 171,

July 1, 1898, 55th Congress as amended and Section 659

of Public Law 696, 75th Congress; that the provisions of

Section 3466 of the Revised Statutes of the United States

must be observed where applicable; that attention is also

called to the provisions of Section 3467 of the Revised

Statutes of the United States, with respect to the personal

liability of every executor, administrator, assignee or other

3

person who fails to pay the claims of the United States in

accordance with their priority.

Dated this 7th day of April 1950

ARTHUR J. BRADY

Deputy Collector in Charge for

the First District of Missouri

Subscribed and sworn to before me this 7th day of April,

1950.

MARGARET M. BOREN

Notary Public

My Commission Expires Feb. 19th, 1951

[fol.3] Petition for Hearing on Claims of the United

States of America and the State of Missouri.Based

Upon Social Security Taxes Owed by Debtor as of

the Date of Commencement of These Proceedings

and for Determination of the Respective Amounts

Due.

(Filed Dec. 16, 1949)

In the District Court of the United States for the Eastern

Division of the Eastern Judicial District of Missouri.

In the Matter of

General Engineering and Manufacturing Company,

a corporation, Debtor.

In Proceedings for an Arrangement under Chapter XI.

Division No. 2. No. 11,319

General Engineering and Manufacturing Company,

Debtor herein, states as follows:

1. As of the date of the commencement of these pro-

ceedings, November 17, 1948, Debtor owed to the United

States of America certain sums on account of social

security taxes and withholding taxes. In this connection,

the amounts claimed by the United States of America, ex-

4

elusive of interest, are set forth below and are presently

outstanding and unpaid.

Social Security Taxes

§ AEPPOTITT TTT TTT 226.32

Federal Insurance Contribution 10-1-48 '

SP Ds vasbneseesioeesaus 1,111.67

Federal Unemployment Tax................ 6,473.45

Withholding Taxes

DT ULcsd ucUincuaiddbvenbenvecordéuuts 5,956.22

Period 10-1-48 to 11-16-48. ..............005. 7,123.24

WU chadcevas $25,417.28

{fol.4] In addition to the amounts shown above, the

United States of America is asserting a claim for interest

thereon to date of payment.

2. The claim of the United States of America for the

payment of said social security taxes and withholding

taxes has priority under Section 64(a)(4) of the Bank-

ruptey Act and is to be paid out of the funds heretofore

deposited by the Debtor for the payment of prior claims.

However, Debtor has refused to pay, or recommend pay-

ment of, the aforesaid claim for the following reasons:

(a) Said claim includes accrued interest after the date

of the commencement of these proceedings. Debtor be-

lieves this to be contrary to law. New York vs. Saper, 336

U. 8. 328; 93 L. Ed. 571; 69 S. Ct. 554.

(b) A 5% penalty, amounting to $226.32, has been as-

sessed in connection with return filed by the Debtor for

federal insurance contributions for the quarter ending

September 30, 1948. This penalty was apparently assessed

because of late filing of the return. This assessment of

$226.32 appears clearly to be a penalty or forfeiture pro-

hibited by Section 57(J) of the Bankruptey Act.

(c) The amount of $6,473.45 shown above as federal

unemployment taxes due for the period January 1, 1948 to

and including November 16, 1948, does not give effect to

Fs 5

the eredit to which Debtor will be entitled under the stat-

ute, 26 USC 1601, as and when it pays to the State of Mis-

souri the unpaid balance due the State for unemployment

taxes assessed during the period involved. In this connec-

tion said Section 1601(a)(3) provides that any employer,

upon timely payment te the state of the state’s share of

unemployment taxes, is entitled to a credit of the amount

so paid against the unemployment taxes required to be

paid by such employer to the United States of America.

[fol.5] In the event payment to the state is not made on

time, then the credit to which such employer is entitled is

reduced to 90% of the credit otherwise allowable. In the

instant case, Debtor has deposited with this Court sufficient

funds to pay the unpaid balance of the unemployment taxes

claimed by the State of Missouri ($4,043.91) and such pay-

ment will be made when ordered by this Court. However,

the representatives of the United States of America have

stated that they will nevertheless refuse to give the credit

provided by law when payment is made to the United

States. Debtor cannot safely, therefore, pay either the

United States of America or the State of Missouri until

it is determined whether or not the above mentioned credit

is allowable. In this connection, it may be stated that the

question involved is not whether the disallowance of such

credit would constitute a penalty or forfeiture prohibited

by Seetion 57(J) of the Bankruptey Act but rather wheth-

er Debtor is entitled to the eredit provided for all tax-

payers by said Section 1601(a) (3).

3. The State of Missouri has a claim against Debtor

for unpaid unemployment taxes in the amount of $4,043.91

for the quarter ending September 30, 1948. Interest on

this amount is claimed at the rate of %% per month from

dne date to the date of payment. Debtor has not paid this

claim for the following reasons:

(a) Because of the existing uncertainty as to whether

credit for such payment will be allowed in connection with

the payment of unemployment taxes required to be paid to

the United States cf America, Debtor is of the belief that

such payment should be withheld until the questions men-

tioned above have been resolved.

6 .

(b) It is the belief of the Debtor that the assessment

of interest for the period subsequent to November 17, 1948,

{fol.6] when these proceedings were instituted, is con-

trary to law. New York vs. Saper, 336 U. 8. 328; 93 L. Ed.

571; 69 S. Ct. 554.

Wherefore, Debtor prays that the above and foregoing

claims of the United States of America and of the State of

Missouri be set down for hearing in order that the respec-

tive amounts of said claims may be determined.

Dated this 16th day of December, 1949.

JAMES 8S. McCLELLAN

Attorney for Debtor.

Of Counsel:

Willson, Cunningham & McClellan,

1930 Boatmen’s Bank Building,

St. Louis 2, Missouri.

[fol.7] (Order of Referee in Bankruptcy setting Claims

of United States of America and State of Missouri

for Hearing, ete.)

(Filed December 16, 1949.)

At St. Louis, in said District, this 16th day of Decem-

ber, 1949.

The petition of Debtor for determination of the amounts

due on the claims of the United States of America and the

State of Missouri having been filed herein and duly con-

sidered, and good cause having been shown, and it appear-

ing that no notice of the filing of said petition and the

entry of this Order has been given and that none is required,

it is therefore

Ordered, that hearing on said claims of the United States

of America and of the State of Missouri for the purpose

of determining the respective amounts thereof be set down

for hearing before the undersigned Referee in Bankruptey

on January 4, 1950, at 11:00 o’clock A. M.; and it is further

Ordered, that Debtor shall give notice of said hearing

by forthwith mailing or delivering a copy of this Order

and a copy of said petition to the United States Attorney

7

for the Eastern District of Missouri and to the Division

of Employment Security, Department of Labor and Indus-

trial Relations, Jefferson City, Missouri.

WM. O’HERIN,

Referee in Bankruptey.

[fol.8] (Order of Referee in Bankruptey that Amended

Claim of United States of America be allowed as

a Priority Claim, ete.)

(Filed May 9, 1950.)

At Saint Louis, in said Division of said District, this

9th day of May, 1950.

On December 16, 1949 General Engineering and Manuv-

facturing Company filed its petition for a hearing and

determination of the amended claim (No. 23) of the United

States of America for taxes, filed February 23, 1949, in

the amount of $30,412.23. On January 4, 1950, pursuant

to notice, hearing was had on said claim and the matter

taken as submitted. After submission of the matter, and

on April 7, 1950, by agreement of the parties, a second

amended claim was filed by the United States (No. 571) in

the amount of $25,156.27, plus interest at six per cent per

annum from November 17, 1948 to date of payment:

And the Referee having duly considered said second

amended claim, the briefs filed by the parties, and being

now fully advised in the premises, it is, in accordance with

the memorandum hereto at

Ordered that the second amended claim of the United

States of America (No, 571), be and hereby is allowed

as a priority claim for taxes under Section 64a (4) of the

Bankruptcy Act, in the amount of $25,156.27, without fur-

ther interest, and less credit due under Section 1603 (a)

(3) of the Internal Revenue Code for unemployment con-

tributions paid the Division of Employment Security, State

of Missouri.

WM. O’HERIN,

Referee in Bankruptcy.

8 "

[fol. 9] Memorandum.

Statement.

The United States, on February 23, 1949, filed an amend-

ed claim (No. 23) herein for social security and withhold-

ing taxes, allowance of which was postponed. On Decem-

ber 16, 1949, debtor filed a petition for a hearing and

determination of said claim, which in effect constituted

objections to said claim. A hearing was held January 4,

1950 and the matter submitted upon briefs to be there-

after filed by the parties. Consideration of the claim dis-

closed that it included taxes which had accrued subsequent

to the filing of debtor's petition for an arrangement, which

in the interim had been paid, and in addition a recompu-

tation of interest was necessary. By agreement of the

parties a second amended claim was filed by the govern-

ment April 7, 1950 (Claim No. 571), which is the claim

presently for determination. This claim is for social se-

curity taxes and withholding taxes which acerued prior to

November 17, 1948, the date of the filing of debtor's peti-

tion, which taxes with acerued interest te November 16,

1948, aggregate $25,156.27. In addition interest is claimed

from November 17, 1948 to date of payment. The claim

states that unemployment taxes aceruing from January 1,

1948 to November 16, 1948, aggregating $6,444.80, will be

reduced in accordance with Section 1603 (a) (3) of the

Internal Revenue Code if the claim of Division of Employ-

ment Security, State of Missouri, is paid in full.

{fol. 10] The objections of the debtor to the first amend.

ed claim (No. 23) were (1) that the government was not

entitled to interest on this tax claim after the date of com-

mencement of these proceedings; (2) that the claim in-

eluded a penalty, not allowable; and (3) that the claim did

not recognize or give effect to debtor’s right of credit

under Section 1603 (a) (2) of the Internal Revenue Code.

The filing of the second amended claim has eliminated

debtor’s objections (2) and (3), so that the sole question

for decision is whether or not the United States is entitled

to interest on this tax claim from the date of filing of the

petition herein, November 17, 1948, to date of payment of

the tax.

The debtor insists that such interest is not allowable

under New York vs. Saper, 336 U. S. 328, 69 S. Ct. 554

(Decided March 7, 1949 denying post-bankruptcy interest

on tax claims). The government insists that the Saper

case is not controlling here for the reason that it involved

straight bankruptcy under Chapters I to VII of the Act,

while the instant case is one for an arrangement under

Chapter XI of the Act.

The undisputed material facts are as follows:

Debtor’s petition for an arrangement was filed Novem-

ber 17, 1948. Debtor was originally and for many years

had been engaged in the manufacture of shapers (machine

tools), but in recent years began the manufacture of com-

mercial air conditioning equipment, which at the time of

commencement of these proceedings was its chief business,

the manufacture of shapers having been relegated to a

secondary position. The plan proposed in the original

petition was in the nature of an extension. However, the

company’s financial condition and lack of a line of products

sufficient to sustain operations in the off season made con-

tinued operation of its air conditioning business imprac-

ticable, and the proposed plan was abandoned. It was

apparent that the best interests of the creditors would

be served if the air conditioning division of the business

could be sold as a going concern rather than have an imme-

diate liquidation of the company. In order to maintain

[fol.11] the business, together with its distributorship

system, for such sales purpose, operations were continued

under Court order, during which time material inventories

were processed into finished units, those remaining unsold

being included in the subsequent sale of the business. A

purchaser was obtained after several months of negotia-

tions and the plan formulated which was subsequently ap-

proved by creditors and confirmed by the Court. Under

this plan debtors’ air conditioning division was sold to

Automatic Firing Corporation, a manufacturer of heating

equipment. This sale in addition to the air conditioning

division included all debtor’s real estate and buildings,

but excluded its machinery and equipment for manufacture

of shapers, which together with all other assets, including

the proceeds of the sale to Automatic Firing Corporation,

were transferred to a liquidating corporation, with the

10

exception of shaper inventory not te exceed in value

$135,000.00, and shaper patents, drawings, jigs, ete. which

were retained by debtor. Debtor has mo remainine facili-

ties left for manufacture of shapers, but contraets with

other tool cnanufacturing companies to so do under its

patents and in the process using up the shaper inventory

so retained, The stock of this liquidating corporation is

held by a creditors’ committee of four selected by the

creditors and the assets transferred to it, are tpon Haga

dation to be distributed upon a proportionate basis to the

general unsecured creditors. This method was adopted,

as part of the purchase price received from Automatic was

in notes payable within four vears and liqnidation of cer

tain inventories over a period of tine invelyed, fron the

proceeds of sale of the real estate there was deposited

in Court $204,000.00 for payment in full of elaine for

$100.00 each or less, as provided in the plan, and pay-

ment of priority claims. The deposit is for more than

the amount required. Any balance reimaining is to be

paid to the liquidating corporation for the benetit of gen

eral creditors. No objections to this plan were filed at an

time prior to its confirmation. Tlaving been accepted hy

the required creditors affected it was, upon due notice to

[fol. 12] all parties in interest, confirmed September 15,

1940).

Opinion.

In City of New York vs. Saper, 356 U.S. 528, 69S. Ct.

oo4, the Supreme Court affirmed decisions of the Cour!

of Appeals for the Second Court, denving interest after

the filing of a petition in bankruptey on sales tax inposcd

by the City of New York (Saper vs. City of New York,

168 BF. (2d) 268), and tax claims by the United State

and State of New York (Carter vs. United States, 168 F.

(2d) 272).

The Supreme Court there potuts out that the rule stey

ping interest at bankruptey had been established a-

fundamental principle of the Enelish bankruptes system

for almost two hundred vears and our bankraptey law wa-

copied from it. That our law contains mo provision es

pressly repudiating (hat principle or allowing any excep

tion in favor of tax claims. That the logical tiiplieatioms

from relevant provisions of the present law are te the

11

contrary, citing Section 63 of the Act, subdivisions a (1)

and a (9) (11 US.CLA. a (1), (5)) allowing interest: on

judgments and written instruments only to date of bank

rupley, and only to that rate on debts reduced to jude

went after bankruptey. That no provision of the Act

permits post-bankruptey interest on other claims in gen

eval or tax clas in particular. That Seetion 57n (11

US.CUA, See. 98u) requires governmental claims be proved

in the same manner and within the same time as other

debts and that tax claims are treated the same as other

debts exeept for the fourth priority under Section 64a,

The court notes that the practice of allowing interest

on tas claims in bankruptey to time of payment dates back

to In re Kallak, 147 F. 276 (D.C) N. Dak. 1906) and eases

followin it, and then states that it was there first decided

that Section 64 of the Act of 1808 wave taxes absolute

priority over claims of every kind as subsection (aj pro

vided that the court **shall order’? the trustee to pay taxes

in advanee of the payment of dividends to creditors. acd

vbsection (hb) following, set up the order of priorities

(1. Costs of preserving the estate; 2. filing fees: 3B. ad-

(fol. 15) ministration expenses; 4. wages): that. taxes

were not claims in baukruptey, as they need not be proved

but the trustee was obligated to seek them out and par

them in full and the court saw no reason Wliv the rule

‘topping interest on ordinary claims, which was a rule of

expediency and convenience, should apply to taxes.

After thus reviewing the Kallak case, the Supreme Court

slates that Section G4a has since been amended. first. in

126 and dater by the Chandler Act, so as te deprive taxes

of their preferred status. The 1926 amendment (See. 15

of the Act of May 27, 1926, ¢. 406, 44 Stat. H6H2, HOH6) ex

pressly provided that taxes vield priority to administration

expenses and wages, neither of which bear interest. That

the Chandler Act amendments “finalized the subordina-

tion of taxes to other priority items" and also wrote inte

Section O7n the requirement of proof, formerly unnieces

“ary oon tax claims under Section 64a. The ultimate con-

chision is stated as follows, 69.8, Ct. Le 559:

“The Court of Appeals concluded that by the 1926

amendment and the Chandler Act. Coneress assimilated

12

taxes to other debts for all purposes, including denial of

post-hankruptey interest. We think this is a sound and

logical interpretation of the Act after those amendments

to See, 64, sub. a, and 7, sub, un. Considered in conjune-

tion with the eeneral rules against post-bankruptey inter-

est as Well as Sec. 63's limitations of interest on other

Claims to date of bankruptey, they compel our concitsion,

already stated, that the statute as amended did not con-

template any exception in favor of tax claims.”

As hereinbefore noted the government contends that this

decision of the Supreme Court is not controlling, its ap-

plication being limited to straight bankruptey. This con-

tention cannot be sustained,

An arrangement may be by way of settlement or satis-

faction or by extension. It is to be noted at the outset

that the arrangement in this case is not by way of exten-

sion. Payment is to be made te ceneral unsecured creditors

pot a proportionate basis, out of the proceeds derived

from liquidation of the assets which under the plan go

to creditors,

Section 202 of the Aet provides that the provisions of

lol. 14) Chapters LT to VIP shall apply te proceedings

under Chapter NT except where inconsistent or in conthiet

with the provisions of the latter Chapter.

In a case such as this, filed under Section 322 (an orig-

inal petition where no bankruptey is pending), Section 352

tnakes the rights, duties and Habilities of erediters and

others, with respect to debtor's property, the same during

the Chapter XT administration as they would have been if

the debtor had filed a voluntary petition in straight bank-

ruptey and an order of adjudication entered when the peti-

tion was filed. In re Morgan, 1 FL Sup. 52 (DCL NLY.);

Collier (14th Bad.) Vol. Sp. 941,

The only definition of ‘tereditors’’, *tdebts** or **claims”’

in Chapter XT are those contained in Section 307, which is

defining them states in each instance **whether or not prov-

able as debts under Section 63 of this Act.’ That seetion by

its eXpress terms is limited to ‘tan arrangement providing

for an extension of time for payment of debts in full’? It

is not applicable in this case, which as above noted is not an

extension arrangement,

13

There is no comprehensive definition of ‘‘ereditor”’

Where the arrangement is by way of settlement or satis-

faction. Collier (14th Ed.) Vol. 8, p. 946 states:

“Tlence, under the applicability provisions of Sections 302

und so2 of Chapter XI, the definition of ‘ereditor’ and the

correlated definition of ‘debt? in Sec. 1 (11), (74) of Chap-

ter Tapply for all purposes, Section 1 (11) states that

‘creditor shall include anyone who owns a debt, demand, or

clain provable in bankruptey, and may include his duly au-

thorized agent, attorney, or proxy,’ while See. 1 (14) de-

fines ‘debt’ to ‘inelnde any debt, demand, or claim provable

in bankruptey.” Debts provable in bankruptey are enumer-

ated in Sec. 63. A person who owns a debt provable under

See. 65 is therefore a ‘ereditor’ in an ordinary bankruptey

proceeding under Chapters | to VIL of the Act. By virtue

of Sections 302 and 352, a person who owns a debt provable

under See, 63 is likewise a creditor in an arrangement pro

ceeding under Chapter Xt, where the arrangement is by

Way of settlement or satisfaction.”

See also In re Strotz, 50 F, Sup. 622, 324 (D.C. Cal).

The provisions of Section 68a, referred to in the Saper

case, limiting interest to date of bankruptey, are applicable

to the present proceeding (a Section 322 case by way of set-

Hlement or satisfaction). Collier (14th Kd.) par. 7.05, yop.

S47, 948,

[fol 15) The government in its brief correctly states that

Section 64 of the Act establishing priorities is applicable

here to determine which are priority claims under Section

bo0 (2) (deposit for payment of priority debts). It is by

reason of the statutory command of Section 64a (4) that

this tax claim of the United States (for taxes and interest

acerned to bankruptey) is a priority claim. And it was hy

Virtue of Section 64a (5) (debts owing the United States)

that the vovernment’s claim for refund of exeess profits

Was heretofore allowed priority in this case and not hy

reason of reocgnition or approval of “the absolute Priority

rule’’ as stated in the government's brief. Such rule

(Whether or not requiring payment of post-bankruptey in

terest) lias no place here and will not apply. Of course,

that not being a tax claim, the government did not claim

post-banukruptey interest.

l4

The argument is made by the government that the Inter-

nal Revenue Code compels allowance of this interest irre-

spective of the Bankrnptey Act. This same argument was

rejected by the court in the Saper decision,

To the extent that priority claims and interest on this

tax claim (if such were allowable) are paid then to that ex-

tent is the fund distributable to general creditors depleted,

Under the long established general rule against post-bank-

ruptey interest (G0 8.0. 555 note 7) and the provisions of

Section 65 of the Net applicable here, these creditors may

not inelude post-bankruptey interest in computing — the

amount of their claim, pon whieh proportionate distribu.

tion is based nor is such payable on priority claims other

than taxes,

The conelusion of the Supreme Court in the Saper case

that taxes are assimilated to other debts for all purposes,

including denial of post-bankruptey interest, is applicable

under the facets here. This tax claim of the United States

will be allowed for tases and accrued interest to and in-

chiding November 16, 1948. Tnterest thereon from and af-

ter November 17, 148, the date of filing of debtor's orig-

inal petition herein will be denied. An order will enter ae-

cordingly.

WAM. OCHERIN,

Referee in Bankruptey,

mt. Louls, Missourt,

May 9, 1950,

fol, 16] (Petition of United States of America for Review

of Order of Referee in Bankruptey.)

(Filed May 19, 150.)

The United States of America, claimant herein, by Drake

Watson, United States Attorney for the Eastern District

of Missouri. and Wie. Ve O'Donnell, Assistant United

States Attorney for said) Distriet, respectfully states as

follows:

1. Claimant, United States of America, is aggrieved by

the Order herein of Honorable Win. O'flerin, Referee in

Bankruptey, dated May 9, 1950, a copy of which order is

15

annexed hereto, marked ‘exhibit A’) and made a part

hereof,

2. The Referee erred with respect to said Order in dis

allowing interest on 825,156.27 earned subsequent to No

vember 16, 1948, the date when petition was filed herein,

Wherefore Gaimant prays that said order be reviewed

by the United States District Court in accordance with the

provision of the Act of Congress relating to bankruptey,

that the said order he reversed, and that this elain of the

United States for interest hsequent to the commence-

ment of these proceedings be allowed,

DRAKE WATSON,

United States Attorney,

WM. V. OODONNELL,

Aasiatnns United States Attorney,

Dated this Sth clean of May, 1950.

lfol. 17] Certificate OF Referee On Petition Or United

States OF Aimerica For Review OF Referee’s Order

Of May 9) 150 Denving Post-Bankruntey Interest

On Tax Claim Of United States (No. 571).

(Filed May 25, 1950.)

To the Honorable JIndees of said Covrt:

1, Win. O'Herin, Referee of said Court in Bankruptey, do

hereby certify that in the course of the proceedings m the

above cause before me, the following question arose pert

nent thereto;

(in November 17, 14s, (Genera | Mneineerine and Manu-

facturing Company filed a petition for an arrangement un

der Chapter NE of the Bankruntey Net,

On February 25, 1949 the United States of Amerien filed

its amended claim Jor social security, withholding and un

employment taxes (No. 25) in the amount of S30 412.22

Qn December 16, 1045 3 the cle htor filed aopetiti n for hear

ing and determination of said claim. The elain: was set for

16

hearing on January 4, 1950, pursuant to notices, and the

matter was heard and submitted on that date.

Alter submission of the matter, and on April 7, 1950, hy

asreement of the parties, a second amended claim was filed

by the United States (No. 571) for social security, with-

holding and unemployment taxes acerued prior to Novem:

ber 17, 1948, the date of the filing of the Chapter XI pro-

ceeding, which taxes, with acerued interest to November

Tol IS| 16, 1948, aggregate $25,156.27. In addition inter

est is claimed from November 17, 1948 to date of payment.

(Claim No, 571 and the debtor’s petition for hearing and

determination of said elaim are transmitted herewith),

Evidence,

No evidence was offered. The findines made are based

on the record in the case and stipulated by the parties to he

trne and correct. (The stipulation filed is transmitted

herewith),

Order of Referee.

On May 9, 1950, the Referee entered an order allowing

Claims No. 571 of the United States for taxes and interest

accrued prior to November 16, 1948, in the amount of #2H,-

1o.27, less credit due under Section 1605(a) (5) of the

liternal Revenue Code for unemployment contributions

paid the Division of Employment Security, State of Mis

souri, Interest subsequent to November 17, 1948 was de-

nied. (The Referee’s order and the memorandum filed

therewith are transmitted with this certifieate).

Petition for Review.

On May 19, 1950, and in due time, the United States of

America filed a petition for review of the Referee’s orde:

of May 9, 1950, and the said petition is transmitted bere

with.

Question for Determination.

The question for determination is the correctness of

Referee’s order of May 9, 1950, denying post-hankruyt

17

interest on the tay claim of the United States: and the mat-

ter is submitted to the JIndee for his opinion,

Respectfully submitted,

WM. OL THEREIN,

Referee in Bankrnptey,

St. Louis, Mo.

May 26, 1950,

[fol. 19] The following papers are transmitted with this

Certificate:

1. Claim No. 571 of the United States of Amerien.

2. Petition of Debtor for hearing and determination of

said claim.

Original order of Referee of Mav 8) 1050, and mem-

orandum filed therewith.

4. Stipulation between Debtor and United States that

facts stated in Referee’s memorandum are correct,

» Petition of United States for review of Order of Ret.

eree of Mav 9, 1950,

[fol. 20] (Stipmlation that AIL Facts Stated in Memoran-

dum Written by Referee in Banlawotey and made

the Basis of his Order of May 0) 1850, refnsine the

Claim of the Uited States at Interest, ete, be con.

sidered to be Trne and Correct.

(Filed Mav 19, 1950.)

It ix hereby stipulated and agreed by and between Gen-

eral Engineering and Manufacturing Company. debtor

hereim, and the United States of Amerien, by Drake Wat

son, United States Attorney for the Mastern Jadicial Dis

triet of Missouri, and Wire. Vo O'Donnell, Assistant United

States Attorney for said District, acting for and on belialf

of the Pnited States of America, that all of the facts stated

the memorandum written by the Honerable Wr,

Miter. Referee in Bankruptey, and made the basis of his

Pirder entered May 9, 1950, refusing the claim ef the United

“ates for interest on claim for taxes earned subsequent to

meneement of these proceedings, a COPY of which

EERE RII LNT

18

said Order is attached to claimant’s Petition for Review, he

considered to be true and correct. Copy of said) memor

andum and copy of the claim of the United States of Amer

iea are attached hereto and made a part of this Stipula

tion,

GENERAL ENGINEERING AND

MANUFACTURING CO.,

By James S. MeClellan, Attorney,

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

By Drake Watson,

United States Attorney,

WA. V. OCDONNELL,

Assistant United States Attorney.

Datod this IS day of May, 1950. WVOQ) ceh

ffol. 21] (Stipulation and Agreement as to Matters

Upon which Petition for Review was submitted to

Referee in Bankruptey.)

(Filed June 19, 1950)

General Engineering and Manufacturing Company. a

corporation, debtor in the above-entitled matter, and the

United States of America, by their respective attorneys,

hereby agree and stipulate that the Petition for Review

dated May 18, 1950, may be submitted to the Honorable

Rubeyv M. Hulen, Jndge of the District Court of the Eastern

District of Missouri, upon the filing of briefs by the vr

spective counsels of General Engineering and Manutaec

turing Company and the United States of America, th

latter to file brief within ten days after this date and the

former within ten days thereafter, and the latter to he

permitted to file reply brief in five days npon receipt of the

answering brief of General Engineering and Mannutactur

ing Company.

The Petition for Review is submitted not only on said

briefs, but also on the following records, to-wit:

1. Petition for Review dated May IS, 1950, stating that

the Referee erred with respect to an order marked Exhibit

A and made a part of said Petition for Review, in disallow

ing interest on $25,156.77 earned subsequent to Noven

ber 16, 1948, the date when petition was filed herein.

19

[fol.22] 2. The Order of Honorable Wr, O'Herin, Ref

eree in’ Bankruptey, dated May 9, 1950, marked Exhibit

“Ey,

3. Stipulation in connection with Claimant’s Petition

for Review.

# Memorandum of Referee O'Herin dated May 9, 1950,

2% Amended Ciaim filed by collector,

6. Acknowledgment of service of copy of Petition for

Review,

All of the foregoing papers have been filed and attached

to the Petition for Review.

GieNERAL ENGINEERING & MFG.

CO),

By James S. McClellan,

Attorney for Debtor.

UNITED STATES OF \ MERI "A,

3y Drake Watson,

United States Attornes

Wim. V. O'Donnell,

Assistant United States Attorney,

ffol. 23] (Memorandum Opinion and Order of District

Court Confirming Order of Referee in Bankruptes

Disallowing Post) Interest on Government Claim,

June 28, 1950.)

(Filed June 28, 1950.)

In The United States Distriet Court. Eastern Distriet of

Missouri, Eastern Division,

In the Matter of

General Engineering And Manufacturing Company, a

Corporation, Debtor.

Hulen, Judge.

In Proceedings for an Arrangement under Chapter NI,

No. 11,319,

The question presented on this appeal is the correctness

of the Referce's order denying post bankruptey interest on

20

the claim of the United States for Social Security, with

holding and unemployment taxes. The debtor tiled) peti

tion for an arrangement under Chapter NE of the Bank

ruptey Act. The claim of the United States with titerest

to date of filing of the petition was allowed. The Referee

disallowed interest on the tax subsequent to the filing of

the petition and it is from this ruling that the appeal is

taken. We cenelude the ruling ef the Supreme Court in

New York vs. Saper, 356 U.S. 528, is decisive on the ques

tion presented and binding on this Court. Tn the Sapes

case the Supreme Court denied post interest on tax elains,

observing:

“Every logiea! implication from relevant provisions i

to the contrary, Section G3(a)(1), UL S.C. Ta cayed)

allows interest on judements and written instruments onl

to date of bankruptey, Seetion 6hGaj(o), TU. se.

1O3(a) (5) allows interest only to that date on debts re

dvced to judgement after bankruptey. No provision per

nits post-bankruptey interest on other claims in general on

tax claims in partienlar. Section 57 Gj). TE USS. eC. 99800),

forbidding allowance of governmental penalties or tor

feitures, permits allowance of losses sustained by the aets

penalized, with actual costs and ‘such interest as may have

acerned thereon according to law.’ Tlowever, on its face

this appears to delimit even such allowable debts as of the

fol. 24] date of bankruptey and to allow no more inter

est than does © 63 with respect to the elaiis there specitied,

Moreover, there is no interest exeept that wliels acerucs

according to law -it is exactly such interest) that) the

‘fundamental principle’ fenust | off as of bunkruptey. Seetion

d7(n). 1. USS. CL 9800) requires governmental clatins to

he proved in the same manner and within the same time as

other debts and only for canse shown may a reasonaldle

extension be granted. "Tas clatnis are treated the sane as

other debts exeept for the fourth priority of payment,

64a), 11 UL S.C. 6 104(a). and the provision makine

taxes nondisehargeable, © 17, UL S.C. 85.) But each of

these seetions is silent as to interest,

“The long-standing rule against post bankruptey titer

est this appears implicit in err current Bankruptey Net”

We are urged to disregard the Saper case on the eronnd

it ‘tis limited to a straight bankruptey proceeding”, that

Order.

Findings of fact and conelusions of law of the Honorable

Win, O'Terin, Referee in Bankruptey, are adopted as the

findings of fact and conelusions of law of this Court. and

the order of the Referee disallowing post interest on the

Government claim is confirmed,

RUBEY M. HULEN,

Judew,

iTol. 26] Notice of Appeal to the United States Court of

Appeals.

(Filed July 27, 1950)

In The United States Distriet Court. Eastern Distriet of

Missouri, Kastern Division.

In the Matter of

General Engineering and Manufacturing Company, a

Corporation, Debtor.

In Proceedings for an Arrangement under Chapter NI.

No. V1,319.

Notice is hereby given that the United States herely

appeals to the United States Court of Appeals for the

Kighth Cirenit, from the final order of the United States

Distriet Court affirming the order of the Referee in- Bank

ruptey disallowing the interest on the elaims of the United

States, entered in this action on June 2s, 1950,

DRAKE WATSON,

United States Attorney.

And thereafter the followine proceedings were had in said cause in the United

States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, vic:

(Appezrance of Mr. Dralre Watson and Mr. Wm. V.

O'Donnell as Counsel for Appellar *.)

United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Cireuit

No. 14212.

UNirep Srvres, elLppellant,

Fe

GENERAL ENGINERRING «asp Mancracrronine (‘OMPANY,

al Corporation, Dettor,

The Clerk will enter my appearanee as Counsel for thie Appellant.

Drake Wartsox,

v8; Aflorney.

Wa. V. O'Doxnenn,

étast. i. N. eifforney.,

Attorneys for Appellant,

(Endorsed): Filed in U.S, Court of Appeals, sep. 8, 1950,

(Appearance of Mr. Theron Lamar Caudle and Mr. Ellis

N. Slack as Counsel for Appellant.)

The Clerk will enter our appearance as Counsel for the United

States.

Tieroxn Lamar Cycpir,

elssistant Allorney General.

Fuus N. Stack,

Special elssivtant to the

eWiorne y General,

(Endorsed): Filed in U.S. Court of Appeals, Sep 9, 1950,

—_—_——

(Appearance of Mr. Homer R. Miller as Counsel for

Appellant.)

The Clerk will enter my appearance as Counsel for the Appellant.

Tlomer Ro Miniurr,

(Endorsed): Filed in U.S. Court of Appeals, Mar. 12. 1951.

~

M4

(Appearance of Counsel for Appellee.)

The Clerk will enter oar appearance as Counsel for the Appellee,

James S. MeCien an,

Cirorce (. Winuson, TEE,

1930 Boatmen’s Bank Blde..

St. Louis > Missouri.

(Endorsed) ; Filed in U.S. Court of Appeals, Oct. 17, 1950,

(Order of Submission.)

Monday, Mareh 12, 1951.

This cause having been ealled for hearing in its regular order.

argument was commenced by Mr. Tomer R. Miller, Special As.

sistant to the Attorney General, for appellant, continued by Mr.

Gieorge (. Willson, TIL, for appellee, and eoneluded by Mr. Homer

R. Miller, Special Assistant to the Attorney General, for appellant,

Thereupon, this cause was submitted to the Court on the printed

record and briefs of counsel filed herein,

see ee

DARK PAGE BLEED THRU

See iterates ~~

25

(Opinion. )

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

POR THE Eraurrit Crrevrr,

No, 14,212.

UNirep Srates, Appellant,

*.

GENERAL ENGINEERING AND MaNnvrscruring Company,

a Corporation, Debtor, Appellee.

Appeal from the United States District Court for the

Eastern District of Missouri.

[April 11, 1951]

Mr. Homer R. Miller, Special Assistant to the Attorney General

(Mr, Theron Lamar Caudle, Assistant Attorney General, Mr. Ellis

N. Slack and Mr. A. FL Preseott, Speeial Assistants to the Attor-

ney General, Mr. Drake Watson, United States Attorney, and Mr,

William V. O°Donnell, Assistant United States Attornes, were

with him on the brief) for Appellant.

Mr. George C. Willson, TIE, (Messrs. Willson. Cunningham & Me-

Clellan and Mr. James 8S. MeClellan were with him on the brief)

for Appellee.

Before Sanborn, Wooprover, and JouNsen, Cireuit Judges.

SaNvorn, Cireuit Judge.

This is an arrangement proceeding initiated by the dehter cap-

pellee) on November 17, 1948, under Chapter XT of the Bankruptey

Act as amended (30 Stat. 544 as amended by 52 Stat. S40, 11 UL Ss.

(. A. SLet seq.). The United States filed a elaim for Social Se-

curity and withholding taxes with interest to November 17, 1948.

It also claimed interest from that date until payment of the tax

claim. The Referee in Bankruptey, to whom the proceeding was

referred, allowed the claim exeept as to interest after November

17, 1948. The United States, in the belief that its claim bore inter-

est until paid, sought a review and reversal of the Referee's order.

The Distriet Court confirmed the order of the Referee, and this

appeal followed.

The question for decision is whether, in an arrangement proceed.

ing under Chapter XI, a tax claim bears interest after the date

of the filing of the debtor's petition,

26

The faets are stipulated. They are stated in the opinion of the

Referee as follows:

“Debtor's petition for an arrangement was filed November 17,

WHS, Debtor was originally and for many Vears had been engaged

in the manufacture of shapers (machine tools), but in reeent vears

began the manufacture of commercial air conditioning equipment,

Whieh at the time of commencement of these proceedings was its

chief business, the manufacture of shapers having been relewated

toa secondary position. The plan proposed in the origina! petition

was In the nature of an extension. However, the company's finan-

cial condition and Tack of a line of products sufficient to sustain

operations in the off season made eontinued operition of its air

conditioning business inpracticable, and. the proposed plan was

abandoned. Uo was apparent that the best Interests of the ereditors

would be served if the air conditioning division of the business

could be sold as a going coneern rather than have am immediate

liqnidation of the company, Tn order to maintain the business, te-

gether with its distributorship system, for such sales PUrposes,

operations were continued under Court order, during which time

material inventories were processed inte finished units, these re-

maining unseld heine included in the subsequent sale af the Tnisi-

hess, A purchaser was obtained after several months of hevotin-

tions and the plan formulated whieh was subsequently approved

by creditors and confirmed be the Court. Under this plen debtor's

air conditioning division was seld te Aut wiatie Firing Corporation,

a manufacturer of heating ejuipment. This sale in addition te the

vir conditioning division included all debtor's peal estate and bnild-

ines, but exchided its machinery and equipment for manufaeture

of shapers, whieh together with all other assets. ineluding the pro-

coods of the sale of Automatic Firing ¢ ‘orporation. were transferred

toa liquidating corporation. with the exeention af shaper inventery

not to exeeed in value S195. 000.00, and shaper patents, drawings.

jigs, ete, which were retained by debtor. Dehior has ne remaining

facilities left for manufacture of shapers, but eontraets with other

fool mannfaeturing companies to so de under its patents and in

the process using up the shaner inventory so retained. The stock

of this liqnidating corporation is held by a creditors’ committee of

four selected by the ereditors and the assets transferred to it, are

upon liqnidation to he distributed upon. a proportionate basis te

the eeneral unseerred eveditors, This method was adopted, as part

of the purchase price reeeived from Automatie was in notes payable

Within four vears and liqnidation of certain inventories over a

period of time involved. From the proceeds of sale of the real estate

there was deposited in Court $204,000.00. for pasment in full of

claitos for $100.00 each or less. as provided in the plan, and pay-

De

-/

ment of priority elaims. The deposit is for more than the amount

required. Any balance remaining is to be paid te the liqnidatine

corporation for the benefit: of general creditors. No objections to

this plan were filed at any time prior to its confirmation, Havine

heen accepted by the required creditors affected it was, upon due

notice to all parties in interest, confirmed September 13, 1949.7*

In denying the United States interest upon its tax claim from the

date of the filine of the petition to the time of payment, the Re-

feree and the District Court relied mainly upon the deeision of the

Supreme Court in City of New York y. Saper, 336 US. 325. In

that ease it was held that tax elains against a bankrupt bear inter-

est only to the date of hankruptey and not until pavment. The

fiovernment argues that the rule of the Saper ease is limited ta

tax claims in what are ealled ordinary or straieht bankruptey pro-

ecedings, namely, those in which there is an adjudication in hank-

ruptey and the assets of the bankrupt are liquidated by a trustee tor

distribution to creditors, The Government contends that the rule

may not be extended to tax claims against a debtor in a proceeding

under Chanter XT.

We think that no implieation reasonably ean be drawn from

the Saper case that tax elaims have any different status in an ar-

rangement proceeding under Chapter XT than they have in ordi-

nary bankrupteies, The Supreme Court said in the Saper ease

(pages 357-338 of 336 U.S):

“The Court of Appeals eoneluded that by the 1926 amendment

and the Chandler Aet, Congress assimilated taxes to other debts for

all purposes. ineludine denial of post-hankruptey interest. We

think this is a sound and logical interpretation of the Act after these

amendments to §$64(a) and 57(n). Considered in coninnetion with

the general rule against post-hankruptey interest as well as S62".

limitations of interest on other claims toe date of bankruptey, ther

compel our conclusion, already stated, that the statute as amended

did not contemplate any exception in faver of tax claims.”

It seems apparent that if the amended sections referred to by

the Supreme Court, namely 64(a), 57(n) and 63. are applicable

fo arrangement proceedings under Chapter XT. there ean be neo

logical basis for a ruling that in sueh a proceeding 2 tax elaim

hears interest bevend the date when the debtor's petition is filed.

Section 64(a), I UL S.C) AL S104¢a). specifies the debts whieh

have priority in hankruptey and makes tax elaims fourth in priority

of payment. Seetion 570m). WW UL S.C) AL $99 y . provides that

Exeept as otherwise provided in this Act. all claims provable under

this Net, ineluding all claims of the United States and of any State

or subdivision thereof, shall be proved and filed in the manner

provided in this seetion.”’ Seetion 63(a) GNA CA

28

S1OS(a) (1), allows interest on judements and written instruments

only to date of bankruptey. Seetion 68(a) (4), TP UL Ss. OLA,

S108(a) (5), allows interest only to that date on debts reduced to

judement after bankruptey.

What the Bankruptey Aet gives to the United States in bank-

ruptey proceedings is a provable elaim for its taxes and interest

to the date of bankruptey, together with a limited priority.

Section 302 of Chapter NPT CM UL S.C.) AL $702) provides:

The provisions of chapters LT to VIL, inelusive, of this Aet shall,

insofar as they are not inconsistent with or in econfliet with the pro-

visions of this ehapter, apply in) proceedings under this chapter.

For the purposes of sueh application, provisions relating to ‘hank-

rupts’ shall he deemed to relate also to ‘debtors’, and ‘bankruptey

proceedings’ or ‘proceedings in bankruptey’ shall be deemed to

inelude proceedings under this chapter. For the purposes of sueh

application the date of the filing of the petition in bankruptey shall

he taken to be the date of the filing of an original petition under

section 822 of this Aet, and the date of adjudieation shall be taken

to he the date of the filing of the petition under section 3821 or S22

of this Aet except where an adjudication had previously been

entered.’

In an arrangement proeceding under Chapter XT the ‘‘debtor’’ is

virtually a bankrupt except in name, Section 80603), 11 USS. CLA.

ST06(3). Where not inconsistent with the provisions of the chapter,

the jurisdietion of the bankruptey court over the debtor and his

property is the same ‘tas if a voluntary petition for adjudication

in bankruptey had heen filed and a deeree of adjudication had been

entered at the time the petition under this chapter [Chapter XT|

was filed.” Section 312(2), TUL S.C. A. $712(2), and the powers

and duties of the officers of the court and the rights, privileges and

duties of the debtor are alse the same as though sueh an edindiention

had heen had, Section 341, 11 U.S. CL AL $741.0 So also are the

rights, duties and liabilities of ereditors, $952, TUL S. CL AL $752,

The debtor, within a time fixed by the court after the acceptance

of an arrangement, is required to deposit the consideration to be

distributed to eveditors and ‘the money necessary to pay all debts

whieh have priority."" Seetion 837(2), 11D UL S.C. AL $787(2).) To

determine what debts have priority, recourse coneededly must be

had to Seetion 64a), ID UL S. CL AL S1040a),

In ease of the abandonment or rejection of an arrangement pro-

ceeding, the court may adjudieate the debtor a bankrupt or dismiss

the proceeding, Seetion 876, 1D UL S. CL AL $776. Tf the eourt

directs that bankruptey be proceeded with, ‘the proceeding shall be

conducted, so far as possible. in the same manner and with like

eifeet as if a voluntary petition for adjudication in bankruptey had

29

been filed and a deeree of adjudication had been entered on the

day when the petition under this chapter [Chapter XP] was filed.”

Mection 378(2), 19 U8. €. A. $778(2). Confirmation ef an ar-

rangement effects a discharge of the debtor from all his unsecured

debts and liabilities provided for by the arrangement and the order

confirming it. Seetion S71, TUL S.C) A. S771. See, also, Seetion

3/2, 11 U.S. C. A. §772.

It seems obvious to us that all of the seetions of the Bankruptey

Act upon which the Supreme Court relied in. the Saper case in

demonstrating that tax claims in bankruptey proceedings are debts

and that interest upon them is allowable only to the date of bank-

ruptey are equally applicable to proceedings for an arrangement

under Chapter XI. We agree with the Referee in Bankruptey and

the Distriet Court that the Government in the instant proceeding

was no more entitled to the allowance of interest on its tax e¢laim

after November 17, 1948, than it would have been had the debtor

on that day been adjudieated a bankrupt.

The order appealed from is affirmed.

A true copy.

Attest: KE. EF. Koen,

Clerk, U.S. Court of Appe als, KRigqhth Circuit,

(Judgment. )

United States Court of Appeals for the Eiehth Cireuit

No. 14212.

UNITED Staves, Appellant,

v.

GENERAL ENGINEERING AND Mancracturtne Company,

a Corporation, Debtor,

Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Eastern District of Missouri.

This Cause came on to be heard on the record from the United

States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. and was

argued by counsel.

On Consideration Whereot, It is now here Ordered and Ad-

Judged by this Court that the Order of the said District Court ap-

pealed from in this case be, and the same is hereby, affirmed,

April 11, 1951,

30

(Clerk’s Certificate.)

United States Court of Appeals for the Eiehth Cireuit

I, BE. E. Koeh, Clerk of the United States Court of Appeals fo

the Eighth Cireuit, do hereby certify that the foregoing contain

the printed record on which the appeal from the United Stat:

Distriet Court for the Eastern Distriet of Missouri was heard it

said Court of Appeals, and full, true and complete copies of th

pleadings, reeord entries and proceedings, ineludine the opinion

had and filed in the United States Court of Appeals for the Bight!

Cireuit, exeept the full captions, titles and endorsements onvittes

in pursuance of the rules of the Supreme Court of the Unite

States, in a ecrtain cause in said Court of Appeals wherein the

United States was appellant and General Engineering and Manu

facturing Company, a Corporation, Debtor, was Appellee, No

14212.

I do further certify that on the 27th day of April, A.D. 1951, a

mandate was issued out of said Court of Appeals in said cause.

directed to the Judges of the United States District Court for the

Eastern District of Missouri.

In Testimony Whereof, | hereunto subseribe my nate and atiix

the seal of the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Cir-

euit, at office in the City of St. Louis, Missouri, on the Oth day of

August, A. D. 1951.

(SEAL) (Signed) FE. EB. Koen,

Clerk of the United States Court of Appeals for the

Bighth Circuit,

Rei PAGE BLEED THRU :

Inthe Supreme Court of the United States

No. . Octoner Term, 1951

Unirep Srares, pevirvioneR., ¢. Generan Enxoinrerine AND

MaANuracturtne Company

ORDER

Upon consideration of the application of counsel for the

petitioner,

It i- ordered that the time for tiling petition for writ of certio

rariin the above-entitled cause be. and the sare is hereby, extended

toand including September sth, 1951,

(Syed.) Fren M. Vinsox,

Chief dustice of the lnited Ntate ®.

Dated this 5rd clay of July, Jy],

ATT ihe paeed ") S$ GOVEONMENT PE NTING “866 108

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

Ocroben Tram, 1951

No. 300

Order allowing certiorari

(Filed November 5. 1951)

The petition herein for a writ of certiorari to the United States

Court of Appeals for the Eighth Cireuit is granted. The case is

transferred to the summary docket,

And it is further ordered that the duly certified copy of the

transcript of the proceedings below which accompanied the peti-

tion shall be treated as though filed in response to such writ,

V7S446—51

Gare

INDEX

Opinions below

Jurisdictio:

Question presented

Statutes involved

Statement

Reasons for granting the writ

Conelusion

Appendix

American Iron Co. v. Seaboard Air Line, 233 U.S. 261

Consolidated Rock Co. v. DuBois, 312 U.S. 510

Cumberland Glass Co. v. De Witl, 237 U.S. 447

WV whusetts, Commonwealth v. Ti m, 190 F.2d 10

Ve Temple, et \ Dd , i2 I 2d SOO, ¢ rari

ke 1, 323 U. S. 784

\ bie s / gt if yd | i Ss. Vie

} \ 44 ~ wa

Ne d | tinge Com } ' gf. 3 Co

1

Bankruptey Act, ¢. 541, 30 Stat. 544, See. 12

|

I

Bankrupteyv Act, e. 541, 30 Stat. 544, as amended byw t

he

Act of June 22, 1938, ¢. 555, 52 Stat. 840, Chapter XT,

en WE Clit. S. ¢ Lu dty« n. Tul

see Oo? «11 1 = 146 ~ 72

sen Mectt UL. ¢ } ‘ Ti

See. 307

See. 323 (11 U.S. C. 194 s 25

™ ian (12 U.S, 4 | 737

- wo (lit. Ss. ¢ ’ ‘ see, TO

Sec. 357 11 | Ss pode j ~ rary)

mene CELT a bhp ¢ Paris

SHOSIS v1 1

DARK PAGE BLEEP THRY

Il

Statutes—Continued

Bankruptey Act, c. 541, 30 Stat. 544, as amended

Sec. 367 (11 U.S. C. 1946 ed, See. 767)

See. 304 (JT UL S.C. 1946 ed., See. 794) -

See. 397 (11 U.S. C. 1946 ed., “ee. 797) - ----

Internal Revenue Code:

See. 1420 (26 UL 8. ¢

Sec. 1605 (26 U.S. C. 1946 ed., See. 1605)

Sec. 1627 (26 U. 8. C. 1946 ed., See. 1627)

Miscellaneous:

8 Collier on Bankruptey (1sth ed., 19411)-_------.

Con,

*, 1946 ed., See. 1420). __-

H. Rep. No. 1400, 75th Cong., let Bess. ...-.....-.-.--.-

Letter from Charles Oliphant, Chief Counsel, Bureau of

Internal Revenue to Assistant Atty. Gen. Caudle, dated

Aug. 20, 105)....-- An ee ee

Page

8, 18

19

20

Inthe Supreme Court of theAnited States

OcTober ‘TERM, 1951

——_— - ——

No. 300

Unrrep STATES OF AMERICA, PETITIONER

Vv.

GENERAL IENGINEERING AND MANUFACTURING

COMPANY, A CORPORATION, DEBTOR

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED

STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT

The Solicitor General, on behalf of the United

States, prays that a writ of certiorari issue to

review the judgment of the United States Court

of Appeals for the Fighth Circuit. entered in this

case on April 11, 1951.

OPINIONS BELOW

The memorandum opinions of the referee in

bankruptey (CR. 8-14) and of the District Court

(R. 19-22) are unreported. The opinion of the

Court of Appeals (R. 25-29) is reported in 188 F.

2d 80.

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the Court of Appeals was

entered on April 11, 1951. (R. 29.) By order

(1)

2

of Chief Justice Vinson, dated July 3, 1951, the

time within which a petition for a writ of cer-

tiorari might be filed was extended to and in-

cluding September 8, 1951.) The jurisdiction of

this Court is invoked under the provisions of 28

U.S. €., Section 1254.

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether, in an arrangement proceeding under

Chapter NI of the Bankruptey Act, the United

States is entitled to interest on unpaid taxes for

the period following the date of the filing of the

petition for arrangement.

STATUTES INVOLVED

The pertinent statutory provisions are printed

in the Appendix, “vfra, pp. 11-20.

STATEMENT

There is no dispute as to the faets (R. 17-18)

which may be summarized as follows:

The debtor’s petition for an arrangement was

filed November 17, 1948. The debtor is a cor-

poration which for many years has been en-

gaged in the manufacture of shapers (machine

tools) and more recently commercial air con-

ditioning equipment. The plan proposed in the

original petition was in the nature of an exten-

sion, but this was abandoned. It was apparent

that the best interests of the creditors would be

served if the air conditioning division of the

business could be sold as a going concern rather

3

than have an immediate liquidation of the com-

pany. In order to maintain the business, to-

gether with its distributorship system, for such

sales purpose, operations were continued under

court order, A purchaser for the air condition-

ing division was obtained after several months of

negotiations and a plan formulated which was

subsequently approved by creditors and confirmed

by the court. Under this plan, the debtor’s air

conditioning division was sold to a manufacturer

of heating equipment, the sale including all of the

debtor's real estate and buildings. From the pro-

ceeds of sale of the real estate, there was de-

posited in court $204,000 for the payment in full

of claims of $100 or less, and the payment of

priority claims. The deposit was more than the

amount required, and the balance is to be paid

to a liquidating corporation for the benefit of

general creditors.

The remaining proceeds of the sale. together

with the debtor’s machinery and equipment for

manufacture of shapers and certain other assets,

were transferred to the liquidating corporation,

the stock of which is held by a creditors’ com-

mittee. Its assets are, upon liquidation, to be dis-

tributed upon a proportionate basis to the general

unsecured creditors. This method was adopted

since part of the purchase price was in notes pay-

able over four years and because liquidation of

certain inventories would require a period of time.

Certain shaper inventory, not to exceed in value

4

$135,000, and shaper patents, drawings, jigs, ete.,

were retained by the debtor.

No objections to this plan were filed at any time

prior to its confirmation. Having been accepted

by the required creditors affected, it was confirmed

on September 13, 1949.

The United States, on February 23, 1949, filed

an amended claim for social security and with-

holding taxes. (R. 8.) By agreement of the

parties, to eliminate certain objections made by

the debtor, a second amended claim for these

taxes was filed on April 7, 1950 (R. 8). The

taxes, with acerued interest to November 17,

1948, the filing date of the arrangement petition,

aggregated $25,156.27 (R. 4). In addition, thie

claim asserted interest from the date of the

petition to the date of payment. (R. 4.) After

hearing, the referee allowed the claim for taxes

and accrued interest through November 16,

1948, but sustained the debtor’s objections to

interest for the period beginning November 17,

1948. (R. 7.) The District Court confirmed the

order of the referee (R. 22), and, on appeal by

the United States, the court below affirmed

(R. 25-29).

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT

1. The Internal Revenue Code provides that

if taxes are not paid when due, there shall be

added as part of the tax interest at the rate of

six percent until the tax is paid. Internal Rev-

5

enue Code, Section 1420, 1605 and 1627, set forth

in Appendix, vfra, pp. 11-12. In this case, the

court below refused to permit payment of any

part of the statutory interest which accrued sub-

sequent to the date of the filing of a petition for

arrangement under Chapter NDT of the Bank-

ruptey Act (e. 541, 30 Stat. 544, as amended

by the Act of June 22, 1958 (Chandler Act),

«975, 52 Stat. S40, Section 1). The court’s

decision was squarely based on this Court’s opin-

ion in New York vy. Saper, 336 U.S. 328, which

denied the Government the right to interest aceru-

ing during the course of a straight bankruptey

proceeding. The question here is whether this

same limitation should apply im a Chapter XI

proceeding.

As is pointed out in the petition for a writ of

certiorarl In United States ve Edens, which is

being filed concurrently with this petition, these

two cases, and United States v. Bloom, No. 100,

this Term, present different facets of the same

general problem, the Edens ease involving Chap-

ter NX and the Bloom case state assignment pro-

ceedings for the benefit of creditors. Issuance of

Writs of certiorari in all three cases is sought for

the reasons stated more at length in the petition

in the Edeus ease,

2. The issue with respect to Chapter XT alone

is an important one both in its application to the

tax Jaws and to the adjustment proceedings of the

Bankruptey Act. Based upon a survey, made in

6

August, 1951, of the records in his. office, the

Chief Counsel of the Bureau of Internal Revenue

has stated that there are currently pending ap-

proximately 771 arrangement proceedings involy-

ing federal tax claims under Chapter NI, and that

the post-petition interest to August 51, 1991, ex-

ceeds $1,000,000." Since not only the Government

and the debtors, but also all other creditors, are

directly concerned with the ultimate solution of

the issue involved, this case has real importance

to many persons,

3. It is the Government’s view that the reliance

of the court below on the decision of this Court

in New York vy. Saper, is misplaced for substan-

tially the same reasons set forth in our petition in

United States v. Edens, filed concurrently here-

with.

Like Chapter X, Chapter XI is not an instru-

ment for liquidating insolvent debtors and dis-

tributing their assets.” The primary purpose of

the arrangement proceeding is rehabilitation, ap-

' Letter from Charles Oliphant. Chief Counsel, Bureau of

Internal Revenue, to Assistant Attorney General Caudle,

dated August 20, 1951. It is also stated in this letter that

both the number of proceedings and the amounts of interest

involved appear to be increasing from year to year.

“Chapter XI is derived from Section 12 of the old Bank-

ruptey Act. enlarged by Section 74 added in 1995, 47 Stat.

1467. Old Section 12 was always considered as something

apart from bankruptey since its object was to revert his prop-

erty to the debtor free from creditors’ claims. Cumberland

Glass Co.v. DeWitt, 237 UL. 447, 453-44: Nassau Works v.

Brightiwood Co.. 265 U.S. 269.

7

plicable especially to ‘small individual or corpo-

rate business where there are no public or private

interests invelved requiring protection by the pro-

cedure and remedies afforded by Chapter X.”

Securities and ERachange Commission vy. U.S.

Realty Co., 310 U.S. 434, 448, 454. An arrange-

ment proceeding is essentially a reorganization

proceeding tailored to meet the needs of small

business.”

As with Chapter \ reorganizations, the condi-

tion for confirmation of an arrangement under

In recommending Chapter XI, the House Committee said

CH. Rep. No. 1400, Toth Cong., Ist Sess. pp. ole:

_ ‘The scope of the proposal has been expanded so Chat it nay

include any terms aud be rade upon any consideration, sub-

ject to approval by the court as fairy equitable. and in the

_ interests of creditors. The wisecured creditors ay le «li-

vided into classes, and the proposal may deal with all or any

of these classes in different ways: and in such event each class

votes separately. Provision is made for the rejection of con-

tracts, executory in whole or in part. including unexpired

leases of real or personal property. Debts which are incurred

during the pendency of the arrangement may be given prior-

ity of pavinent over debts atfected bys the arrangement, The

debtor may be continued i possession of his property during

the pendeney of the proceeding and also during the period

of the arrangement, A general provision is inserted whieh

permits aiy other appropriate terms Hot inconsistent with

the section. In several respects the proceeding has been

speeded up.

We believe that the section as rewritten has been made suf-

ficiently flexible to permit the offer of a settlement ina vari-

ety of situations not new covered either by section 12 or by

section 74. The inclusion of corporations will permit.a large

number of the smaller companies such as are now seeking

HVHOS28 Of 4

8

Chapter Nbois that the plan be ‘fair and equi-

table.’ Seetion 366° (05), ( Appendix, infra, |).

7). ‘Vhis test, as in other reorganization stat-

lites, requibes absolute priority. Mecca Temple,

Ele. v. Darvock, 142 FY, 2d 869, 872 (CL AL 2),

certiorart denied, G25 U.S. 784. And, in as re-

organization procedure, a creditors claim to

interest up to the date of payinent is considered

one of the rights to which le has priority. Con-

solidauled Rock Co. y. Du Bois, p12 US. DO,

OT OOO Tits allot the essential elements whieh

Wwe contend take the rile in the Saper ease in

ippleable toa Chapter \ proceeding, are equally

compelling with respect to Chapter NE proeeedines,

There are additional recsens Why interest

shotld not be ent off in thi Ivpeool preceeding.

Htiust be remembered that, under Chapter NO,

ho alteration may be made in the rights of the

secured creditors, NSecurvitie sand Barchangye C'oni-

mission Ve. U, S. Realty Co, 310 VU. 8S. 494.

12. Although we are not here dealing with

secured tax claims, we are dealing with a claim,

Which under Chapter Ni. is given priority and

safeguarded by the requirement that ao special

deposit: be set up ote insure its payment (Sec

tions 337 (2), 367 (2); Appendix, fafra, pp.

relief under section T7B but do not require the complex

machinery of that section. to resort to the simpler and

less expensive, though fully adequate. relief afforded by

section IZ,

> Sa

9

16,18). Pt world indeed be anomalous if interest

were permitted to run on all debts not covered by

the arrangement (7. ¢. secured debts), but eut

off at the date of the petition with respect. te

federal tax claims, the payment of whieh is eon-

sidered se important that it must be guaranteed

by the establishment of a special deposit,

The adjustment whieh has been approved by

the erediters and confirmed by the court in this

very case Ulustrates the unreasonableness of dis-

allowing the government's elim for interest.

The poleuty provides, after setting pea deposit for

stall claims and these having priority. and after

surrendering certain assets tea lhawidating Corp

Withon ter the benefit of erediters., that inventory

hot to exeeed S155.000 as well as certain puitenits

and other assets shell be retained by the debter,

Sieh oa plan is quite within the purposes of

Chapter NI, whieh. os is pointed out above, is

Mitended as a means of rehabilitating the debtor.

Dut itis notin accord with the accepted rule even

in striicht benkruptey that priority. creditors

should be required te surrender part of their

claims while the debtor is invested with a portion

of his estate. Cf. American Tron Co. v. Seaboard

* Section 302 incorporates by reference the priorities estab-

lished in Section 64a (Appendix, afro. p. LE) whieh ineludes

haves owing It the United States. See S Collin on Bank-

upted (i Mthed. MAL) S51 504.

10

Air Line, 233 U.S. 261, 266-267. As Judge

Woodbury stated in lis dissent in Commonwealth

of Massachusetts v. Thompson, 190 F. 2d 10, 12

(C. A. 1):

. * * in view of the fact that interest

is entitled to the same priority as princi

pal, © “© © te deny interest on the

Commonwealth's tax claim while per-

mitting the debtor te continue in” the

ownership ool iis property and the control

of its business would be te subordinate the

right ef a priority creditor to the interest

of the owners of the business. in this case

stockholders. and thus run directly counter

to the “absolute priority” rile,

CONCLUSION

For the foregoiig reasons this petition for a

writ of certiovari should be ranted.

Respectfully submitted.

Pritie B. PerumMan,

Solicitor General,

SEPTEMBER 1951,

<< me et ee “ Bg os. Sees.

DARK PAGE BLEED THRU

ee ee ao

APPENDIN

INrernan Revencve Cope;

Sec. H20, Cone rerion AND PAYMENT OF

TAXES,

» * * * ’

(hb) Addition to Tor im Case of Delin

quency. Tf the tax is net patd when due,

there shall be added as part of the tax

interest Cexcept im the case of adjustments

made in aeeorcanee with the provisions af

seetions TOL Co) and 1411) at the rate of 6

per centum por annum from the date the

tax became de util paid,

* ¥ ¥ ¥ *

(P6 UL S.C. 1046 ed... See. THO)

Sree. 1605. yy MeN’ oF TANS,

¥ * ¥ ¥ ,

th) Addition to Tar in Case of Delin-

queney.—Tf the tax is net paid when due,

there shall be added as part oof the tax

interest at the rate of 6 per centim per

annum from the date the tax beename dite

until paid.

* * * * *

(26 U.S. €. 1946 ed., See, 1605.)

Sec, 1627 fas added by the Current Tax

Payment Act of 1943, ¢. 120, 57 Stat. 126,

See. 2]. OTHER LAWS APPLICABLE.

All provisions of law, including penalties,

applicable with respect to the tax imposed

(11)

12

by section HOO shall, insefar as applicable

and not meonsistent with the provisions of

this subehapter, be applteable with respect

to the tax under this subehapter.

(26 UL S.C. 146 ed., See. 1627.)

Bangrervey Aer, «. S41, 30 Stat. 544 [as

amended by the Act of June 22, 1988, «. 575, 52

Stat. S10, See. 1]:

Sec. G4 | As further amended by the Aet

of June 28. 1946, «& 512, 60 Stat. 323, See.

12]. Derers wien ave priority, a. The

debts to have priority, in advance of the

payinent of dividends to creditors, and te

he paid in fallout of bankrupt estates, and

the order of payment shall be (1) the ae-

tual and necessary costs and expenses of

preserving the estate subsequent te filing

the petition; the fees for the referees’

salary fund and for the referees’ ex-

pense fund; the filtne fees paid by ereditors

in Invelunitary cases: where property of the

bankrupt, transferred or concealed by him

either before or after the filing of the

petition, shall have heen recovered for the

henetit of the estate of the bankrupt by the

efforts and at the east and expense of one

or more ereditors, the reasonable costs and

expenses of stich recovery: the costs and

expenses of administration, ineluding the

trustee's expenses in opposing the bank-

rupt's discharge, the fees and mileage pay-

able to Withesses as new or hereafter pro-

DARW PAGE

hc csheneen

oe.

13

vided by the laws of the United States, ana

one reasonable attorney “s fee, for the profes-

sional services aetually rendered, irrespee-

tive of the number of attorneys cniploved, te

the petitioning erediters in involuntary

eases and to the bankrupt i voluntary and

Involuntary cases, as the court may allow:

(2) wages, net to exceed S600 to each elain-

ant, Which have been carned within three

months before the date of the commence-

ment of the proceeding, due to workmen,

servants, clerks, or traveling or eity sales-

rer) oth salary OF COripssion basis, Whole

or part time, whether or net selling exeln

sively for the bankrupt: (3) where the eon

firmation of an arrmngement or wage-

earner plan oor the bankrupi’s discharge

has been refused, revoked, or set aside upon

the objection and through the efforts and

at the cost and expense of one or more

creditors, or, Where through the efforts and

at the cost and eXpense of ene or more

creditors, evidence shall have been adducod

resulting in the couvietion of HV persen

of an offense wider this Act, the reasonable

cost and expetses of suelt erediters in ob-

taining such refusal revocation, or setting

aside, or int adducthe such evidenees (4)

taxes legally due and owing by the oank-

rupt te the United States or any State or

any subdiviston thereof; * * *

(11 U.S. CL. 1946, ed. See. LOE)

LEED THRU

Sere - — - -

14

CHAPTER NI—ARRANGEMENTS

* * * * *

Sree, 301, The provisions of this chapter

shall apply exclusively to proceedings un- |

der this chapter.

(11 UL S.C. 1946 ed., See. 701.) |

Ske, 302. The provisions of chapters |

to VIL, inclusive, of this Act shall, insefan

as they are not inconsistent with or in con-

ict with the provisions of this chapter,

apply in proceedings under this chapter.

For the purposes of such application, pro

Visions relating to ‘bankrupts’? shall be

deemed to relate also to ‘debtors’, and

“hankruptey proceedings’ or * proceedings

in bankruptey” shall be deemed to include

proceedings under this chapter. For the

purposes of such application the date of

the filing of the petition in bankruptey

shall be taken to be the date of the filing |

of an original petition under section 322 of

this Act, and the date of adjudication shall

he taken to be the date of the filing of the

petition under section B22 or S22 of this

“Act except where an adjudication bad pre

Vieusly been entered,

(11 UL S.C. 1946 ed, See. 702.)

Sree. 306. Bor the purposes of this chap- |

ter, Unless inconsistent with the context |

(1) “arrangement” shall mean any plan

of a debtor for the settlement, satisfaction,

or extension of the time of payment of

his unsecured debts, upon any tertis;

* & . * *

DARK PAGE BLE

ee ee ee

15

(3) ‘debtor’ shall mean a person who

could become a bankrupt under section 4

of this Act and who files a petition under

this chapter;

* » * * *

(5) “petition”? shall mean a petition filed

under this chapter by a debtor proposing

an arrangement,

(11 U. S. C. 1946 ed... Sec. 706.)

Sree. 307. Unless inconsistent with the

context and for the purposes of an arrange-

ment providing for an extension of time

for payment of debts in full and applicable

exclusively to the debts to be extended—

(1) ‘fereditors”’ shall inelude the holders

of all unsecured debts, demands, or claims

of whatever character again t a debtor,

whether or not provable as debts under

section 63 of this Act and whether liqui-

dated or unliquidated, fixed or contingent ;

and

2) “debts” or “elaims’’ shall include

all unsecured debts, demands, or claims of

whatever character against a debtor,

whether or not provable as debts under

section 63 of this Act and whether liqui-

dated or unliquidated, fixed or contingent.

(11 U.S. ©. 1946 ed., See, 707.)

* * * * .

Sere, 823, A petition filed under this chap-

ter shall state that the debtor is insolvent

or unable to pay his debts as they mature,

16

and shall set forth the provisions of the

arrangement proposed by him.

(11 U.S. C. 1946 ed., See. 723.)

*

* * * *

Sec. 337. At such meeting, or at any

adjournment thereof, the judge or ref-

eree shall, after the acceptance of the

arrangement—

* x * * *

(2) fix a time within which the debtor

shall deposit, in such place as shall be desig-

nated by and subject to the order of the

court, the consideration, if any, to be dis-

tributed to the creditors, the money neces-

sary to pay all debts which have priority,

unless such priority creditors shall have

waived their claims or such deposit, or

consented in writing to any provision of

the arrangement for otherwise dealing with

such claims, and the money necessary to

pay the costs and expenses of the proceed-

ings and the actual and necessary expenses

incurred in connection with the proceed-

ings and the arrangement by the committee

of creditors and the attorneys or agents

of such committee, in such amount as the

court may allow; * * *

(11 U.S. C. 1946 ed., See. 737.)

* * * * * |

Sec, 356. An arrangement within the

meaning of this chapter shall include pro-

Visions modifying or altering the rights

of unsecured creditors generaliy or of some

DARK PAGE BL.

—— fee —

ED THRU

17

class of them, upon any terms or for any

consideration.

(11 U.S. C. 1946 ed., See. 756.)

Sec. 357. An arrangement within the

meaning of this chapter may include—

(1) provisions for treatment of unse-

cured debts on a parity one with the other,

or for the division of such debts into classes

and the treatment thereof in different ways

or upon different terms;

(2) provisions for the rejection of any

executory contract ;

(3) provisions for specifie undertakings

ef the debtor during any period of exten-

sion provided for by the arrangement,

including provisions for payments on

account ;

(4) provisions for the termination, un-

der specified conditions, of any period of

extension provided by the arrangement ;

oa * * * +

(11 U.S. C, 1946 ed., See. 757.)

Src. 366. The court shall confirm an

arrangement if satisfied that—

(1) the provisions of this chapter have

heen complied with;

(2) it is for the best interests of the

creditors ;

(3) it is fair and equitable and feasible;

(4) the debtor has not been guilty of

any of the acts or failed to perform any of

the duties which would be a bar to the dis-

charge of a bankrupt; and

18

(5) the proposal and its acceptance are

in good faith and have not been made or

procured by any means, promises, or acts

forbidden by this Aet.

(11) U.S. C. 1946 ed., See. 766.)

Sec, 367. Upon confirmation of an ar-

rangement—

(1) the arrangement and its provisions

shall be binding upon the debtor, upon any

person issuing securities or aequiring prop-

erty under the arrangement and upon all

ereditors of the debtor, whether or not they

are affected by the arrangement or have

accepted it or have filed their claims, and

Whether or not their claims have been sched-

uled or allowed and are allowable ;

(2) the money deposited for priority

debts and for the costs and expenses shall

be disbursed to the persons entitled thereto;

(3) the consideration deposited, if any,

shall be distributed and the rights pro-

vided by the arrangement shall inure to the

creditors affected by the arrangement whose

claims are not barred by the provisions of

section 354 of this Act, and (a) have been

proved prior to the date of confirmation

and are allowed, or (b) whether or not

proved, have been scheduled by the debtor

as fixed liabilities, liquidated in amount,

and are not disputed ; and

(4) exeept as otherwise provided in see-

tions 369 and 370 of this Act, the ease shall

be dismissed.

(11 U.S. C. 1946 ed., See, 767.)

19

¥ * * +

Sec. 394. The clerk and, in the case of a

reference, the referee after such reference,

shall forthwith transmit to the Seeretary

of the Treasury copies of —

(1) all petitions filed under sections 321

and 322 of this Act;

(2) all notices given in a_ proceeding

under this chapter;

(3) all orders dismissing proceedings or

directing that bankruptey he proceeded

with, discharging debtors, closing estates,

and setting aside confirmations ;

(4) all orders appointing receivers or

continuing debtors in possession ;

(5) all orders confirming arrangements,

together with copies of such arrangements;

(6) all orders approving alterations or

modifications in arrangements, together

with copies of such alterations or modifica-

tions;

(7) all applications for allowances for

compensation and expenses, and the orders

making or refusing to make such allow-

ances; and

(8) such other papers filed in the pro-

ceedings as the Seeretary of the Treasury

may request or which the court may direct

to be transmitted to him.

Any order fixing the time for confirming

an arrangement which affects claims of the

United States shall include a notice to the

Secretary of the Treasury of not less than

fifteen days,

(11 U.S. C. 1946 ed., See. 794.)

—_

20

* * * a *

Sec. 397. Any provision in this chapter

to the contrary notwithstanding, all taxes

which may be found to be owing to the

United States or any State from a debtor

within one year from the date of the filing

of a petition under this chapter, and have

not been assessed prior to the date of the

confirmation of an arrangement under this

chapter, and all taxes which may become

owing to the United States or any State

from a receiver or trustee of a debtor or

from a debtor in possession, shall be as-

sessed against, may be collected from, and

shall be paid by the debtor or the corpora-

tion organized or made use of for effectuat-

ing an arrangement under this chapter:

Provided, however, That the United States

or any State may in writing accept the pro-

visions of any arrangement dealing with

the assumption, settlment, or payment of

any such tax,

(11 U. S. C. 1946 ed., See. 797.)

U. G. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE, 1981

ow dl,

DARK PAGE BLEED THRU

ee peter - — --

= —— ye

Wap

a oe ee ae

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.