Appendix — United States v. Pullman Co.

Supreme Court brief1947

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

r

/ i - i ee ee

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

Octover TERM, 1946

*

„ No. 253

THE UNITED STA, ES OF AMERICA, APPELLANT

vs.

THE PULLMAN COMPANY, PULLMAN-STANDARD CAR

MANUFACTURING COMPANY, PULLMAN INCORPO-

RATED, ET AL.

No. 254

OTIS & CO., APPELLANT

vs.

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE PULLMAN

COMPANY, PULLMAN-STANDARD CAR MANUFAC-

TURING COMPANY, ET AL.

No. 255

THE CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILROAD COMPANY,

THE NEW YORK, CHICAGO AND ST. LOUIS RAILROAD

COMPANY, AND PERE MARQUETTE RAILWAY COM-

PANY, APPELLANTS ;

: vs.

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE PULLMAN

COMPANY, PULLMAN-STANDARD CAR MANUFAC-

TURING COMPANY, ET AL.

INDEX

No. 256

*

GLORE, FORGAN & CO., APPELLANT

vs. *

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE PULLMAN

COMPANY, PULLMAN- STANDARD CAR MANUFAC-

TURING COMPANY, ET AL.

,

APPEALS FROM THE DISTRICT ane THE UNITED STATES

FOR THE BASTERN DISTRICT OF PEGNSYLVANIA

INDEX

Original Print

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania 1 1

( ² * VRO ˙—:Q . — nale 1 1

— ᷣ ͤu VʒUjæ... . 17 12

— 0 ̃ AAA · ( :: 97 60

1. Appendix A—Predecessor Companies to the

11 98 60

2. Appendix B— Results of Corporate Opera-

— — . ee 119 79

3. Appendix C— Finance Docket No. 1885. 130 88

4. Appendix D— Exhibit —-- 132 89

Exhibit No.:

1— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Santa Fe R. R. Co., effective

c 132 89

2— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and B. & O., effective Jan. 1,

—2 — . 150 1%

3—- Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Bangor & Aroostook R. R.

Co., effective Dec. 1, 19399 160 116

4—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Boston & Maine R. R. Co.,

effective Jan. 1, 19399 169 124

5—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Canadian Pacific R. R. Co.,

effective June 1, 19366. 180 134

6—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and H. D. Pollard, Receiver,

Central of Ga. R. R., effective

SS ERE nee 186 140

7—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Central R. R. of N. J., effec-

.

INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania

Continued

Docket entries—Continued

Complaint—Continued

Appendices to complaint—Continued

4. Appendix D—Exhibits—Continued

Exhibit No.—fontinued

8—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and C. & O. R. R., effective July 1,

1 cauntisiiibendiinedes

9 Agreement between Pullman Co. &

C. B. & Q., Colo. & So, Ft.

Worth & Denver City, effective

e

10 Agreement between Pullman Co. &

C. & E. I. & Trustee, effective

.

11 Agreement between Pullman Co. &

Trustees Chi. Great Western

R. R. Co., effective July 1, 1939.

12 — Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Chi., Ind. & Louisville R. R.

Co., effective July 1, 1935.

13—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustees for Chi. Mil., St. P.

and Pac. R. R., effective Jan. 1,

14—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustee of C. & N. W. and

Chi., St. P., Minn. & Omaha R.

R. Co., effective July 1, 1935.

15— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustees of Chi., Rock Is.

and Pac. R. R. Co., effective

.

16— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Del. & Hudson R. R.,

effective Jan. 1, 19366.

17—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and D. I. & W. R. R. Co., effec-

. See

18 Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustees for Denver & Rio

Grande R. R. Co., effective July

— See ae

19—Copy letter by Pullman Co. to

W. R. Freeman, Receiver, Den-

ver & Salt Lake R. R., Denver,

Colo., dated June 25, 1924 (and

two other letters)

III

Original Print

205 158

215 167

231 182

239 190

248 198

256 206

267 216

277 225

293 239

303 249

314 259

322 267

Iv

Continued

Aa

INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania—

Docket entries—Continued

Complaint—Continued

Appendices to complaint—Continued

4. Appendix D—Exhibits—Continued

Exhibit No.—Continued

20—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustees for Erie R. R. Co.,

effective Nov. 1, 1939

21— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Fla. East Coast R. R. Co.,

dated Sept. 1, 1923

22— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Grand Trunk R. R. Co. of

Can., dated June 7, 1916.

23— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Gr. Northern R. R. Co.,

effective Jan. 1, 1935, and Sup-

24—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustee of N. O., Tex. &

Mex.; Beaumont, S. L. & Wn.;

St. L. Brownsville & Mex.; San

An., Uvalde & Gulf R. R. Cos.,

effective Jan. 1, 1939 ss

25—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and III. Cen. R. R. Co.; Yazoo

& Miss. Valley R. R.; Gulf &

Ship Is. R. R., effective Jan. 1,

26— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustee Intern’l. Gr. North’n.

R. R., effective Nov. 1, 1939.

27—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and K. C. So. R. R., effective

28— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Lehigh Valley R. R., effec-

tive June 1, 1939.

20— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Louisville, Henderson &

30— Copy Agreement Pullman Co. and

Louisville & Nashville R. R.,

dated May 2, 1910, and sup-

plemental agreement of July 20,

1923, including Exhibit 30A.

31 Agreement between Pullman Co. &

Maine Central R. R., effective

3

367

375

397

Print

315

INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania—

Continued

Docket entries—Continued

Complaint—Continued

Appendices to complaint—Continued

4. Appendix D—Exhibits—Continued

Exhibit No.—Oontinued

32—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustees of Minn., St. P. &

S. Ste. Marie R. R., effective

rt ll

33—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Mo.-Kans.-Tex. R. R. Co.

and Mo.-Kans.-Tex. R. R. of

Tex., effective Nov. 1, 1934.

34—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustees Mo. Pacific R. R.

Co., effective Nov. 1, 1934.

35—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Receivers for Mobile & Ohio

R. R. Co., effective Nov. 1, 1934.

36— Agreement between N. Y. Cen. R.

R. Co.; Pittsburgh & Lake Erie

R. R. Co.; Rutland R. R. Co. and

Pullman Co., effective Jan. 1,

37 Agreement between Pullman Co.

and the N. Y. Chi. & St. L. R.

R. Co., effective May 1, 1939___

38—Agreement between N. Y. N. H. &

H. R. R. Co. and Pullman Co.,

effective Jan. 1, 1935.

39—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Norfolk & Western R. R. Co.,

effective July 1, 1927.

40—Agreement between Pullman Co.

& Northern Pac. R. R. Co., effec-

tive April 1, 19877.

40A Supplement Agreement between

Pullman Co. and Nor. Pac. R. R.

11 Agreement between P. R. R., Balt.

& Eastern R. R., L. I. R. R. Co.,

Penn. & Atlantic R. R. and Pull-

man Co., effective Jan. 1, 1936.

42 — Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Pere Marquette R. R. Co.,

effective January 1, 1939.

43—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Reading Co., effective July

—

461

469

477

493

531

547

411

~

vi INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania—

Continued

Docket entries—Continued

Complaint—Continued

Appendices to complaint—Continued

4. Appendix D—Exhibits—Continued

Exhibit No.—Continued

44—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Receivers Seaboard Airline, Original Print

effective July 1, 1938. 566 493

45—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Southern R. R. Co., dated

r 577 503

46— Agreement between Pullman Co.

and So. Pacific Co., effective Jan.

nk peli Te 583 508

47—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and St. Louis-San Fran. R. R. Co.

and Trustees, effective Nov. 1,

0 éosdade 599 523

48—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and St. L. Southern R. R. Co.,

Debtor dated Jan. 29, 1936____- 608

49—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Tex. & Pacific R. R. Co.,

dated July 1, 1925 615 539

50—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Toronto Hamilton & Buf.

R. R., Co., dated January 1,

SRE A a 622 545

51—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Union Pac. R. R. Co., effec-

tive January 1, 1940 630 553

52—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Receivers of Wabash Rwy.

Co., effective May 1, 1934. 656 576

53—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Trustees, Western Pacific

R. R. Co., Effective May 1,

54—Agreement between Pullman Co.

and Yosemite Valley R. R. 674

RS IEG, ey OS oe ep eee tae 802

Opinion, Goodrich, C. J., granting judgment in favor of

plaintiff and making certain findings of fact and con-

—— — UU e :ẽ

8

123888 F

INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania—

Continued

Docket entries—Continued Original Print

Findings of fact and conclusions of la 893 744

Supplementary opinion sur form of judgment 904 759

rr e 908 761

Final judgment, May 8, 19 44a. 913 764

Opinion, per curiam, sur entry of judgment 922 774

Plan for separation of the Sleeping Car Business from

the manufacturing business submitted by Pullman

. ⁰ om⸗mů ¼ . = mmm 923 775

f Motion of the Order of Railway Conductors of America

Ga SE Rcd wnccewccsnattinectthate citees 951 806

Petition of the Order of Railway Conductors of America

ep TER I inc nwencdr seedtbedttacine sie 955 809

Order of Court granting motion to intervene (the Order

of Railway Conductors of Americau )) 967 817

j Motion of the Pullman Clerks’ Association for leave to

tl nnnctiubonbdduudutimectinidinasnmamuhenve 98 818

Petition of the Pullman Clerks’ Association for leave to

; LETTE ce 972 820

Order of Court granting leave to the Pullman Clerks’

Association to intervene... . . .. ..ccccccccccnccccceee 983 868

Motion of the Pullman Car Employes Associatior of

the Repair Shops for leave to intervene____._.-...___- 984 869

Petition of the Pullman Car Employes Association of

the Repair Shops for leave to intervene 988 871

Order of Court granting motion of the Pullman Car Em-

ployes Association of the Repair Shops for leave to

b 899

Plaintiff's response to Plan for separation of the Sleeping

Car Business from the Manufacturing Business“ sub-

mitted by defendant Pullman, Ine 1000 900

Motion of the Independent Pullman Workers Federation

0 T 1006 904

907

939

Petition of the Independent Pullman Workers Federation

% »— œũò pénaibeheewedvedess 1010

Order granting motion of the Independent Pullman Work-

ers Federation for leave to intervene 1021

Objections of the Pullman Clerks’ Association, the Pull -

man Car Employes Association of the Repair Shops and

the Independent Pullman Workers Federation to the

plan submitted by Pullman, Incorporated, and sugges-

CRS COI a ˙ AA = 1022 940

Objections of the order of Railway Conductors of America

to the plan submitted by Pullman Incorporated, and

r ELT, LR SS 1027 943

Motion of Pullman Porters Union for leave to intervene 1036 950

Petition of the Pullman Porters Union for leave to inter-

VIII INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania

Continued

Docket entries Continued

Order of Court granting motion of Pullman Porters Union Original Print

. TU Sins Foc be Fas esks dd ccidccecece 1045 956

Petition of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters for

leave to intervene and Order of Court granting same... 1046 956

Order of Court authorizing Pullman Co. to negotiate for

sale of sleeping car business and permitting Pullman In-

corporated to negotiate for sale of its shares of stock in :

958

Order of Court amending Order entered March 22, 1945. 1053 959

Motion to file petition for leave to intervene by United

Transport Service Employees of America___. _____- 1054 959

Petition of United Transport Service Employees of Amer-

core AA 2 1057 961

Order granting motion of United Transport Service Em-

ployees of American for ieave to intervene 1064 983

Motion to intervene and Petition of Otis & Co. for approval ;

of its offer to purchase the carrier facilities of Pullman

Incorporated under the terms of the decree entered May

8, 1944 and the interim order entered March 22, 1945. 1065 984

Order granting leave to Otis & Co. to intervene 1088 1003

Amendment to petition for leave to intervene of the order

of Railway Conductors of America__......_...______. 1089 1003

Supplement to the petition of Otis & Co. for approval of

its offer to purchase the carrier facilities of Pullman

Incorporated under the terms of the decree entered May

8, 1944, and the interim order entered March 22, 1945.. 1094 1047

Memorandum of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters,

intervener, in re the Petition of Otis & Company for

approval of its offer to purchase the carrier facilities of

nr.. 1096 1048

Memorandum of United Transport Service Employees of

America Intervener, in relation to the petition of Otis

and Company for approval of its offer to purchase the

carrier facilities of Pullman, Incorporated 1100 1050

Motion by Otis & Co. to set its intervening petition etc.,

Würm „ 1102 1051

Motion to intervene and Petition of Glore, Forgan & Co.

for an order authorizing and directing Pullman Incor-

porated to sell to petitioner, consistent with the decree

entered May 8, 1944, and the interim order entered

March 22, 1945, its stockholdings in the Pullman

ee 1108 1056

Order of Court granting leave to Glore, Forgan & Co. to

. K bid 1121 1063

Pullman Clerks Association. 1122 1063

INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania

Continued

Docket entries Continued

Amendment to petition for leave to intervene of the

Pullman Car Employes Association of the Repair Shops.

Amendment to petition for leave to intervene of the Inde-

pendent Pullman Workers Federation

Motion for leave to intervene and petition on behalf of the

States of California and Colorado

Motion to intervene and Petition of Standard Steel Spring

Company for approval of its offer for the purchase of all

the outstanding capital stock of the Pullman Company,

in conformity with the terms of the judgment of May 8,

1944, and the interim order of March 22, 194353.

Order of Court granting motion of Standard Steel Spring

Company for leave to intervene

Motion and petition in intervention of the Atchison,

Topeka and Santa Fe Railway Company and others

Order granting leave to Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe

Railway Company to intervene_..................._.

Supplemental Petition on behalf of the state of Colorado

Memorandum of United Transport Segvice Employees of

America, intervener, in relation to the petition of Stand-

ard Steel Spring Company for approval of its offer to

purchase the carrier facilities of Pullman, Incorporated __

Supplemental petition of the Atchison, Topeka and Santa

Fe Railway Company and others

Return of Pullman, Inc., of its selection of purchaser, etc__

Motion to intervene and petition in intervention of the

Chesapeake and Ohio Railway Company

Order of Court granting motion to intervene of the Chesa-

peake and Ohio Railway Compan

Second supplemental petition of the Atchison, Topeka

and Santa Fe Railway Company and others

Motion and petition in intervention of Alabama Great

Southern Railroad Company and others

Order of Court granting leave to Alabama Great Southern

Railroad Company and others to intervene

Memorandum of Pullman Porters Union with reference

to the application of Pullman, Inc. and certain rail-

roads for approval of executory contraet

Memorandum of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters,

intervener, in re the petition of Otis & Company for

approval of ite offer to purchase the carrier facilities of

, T cemndionsiebeenamnns

Opinion, Goodrich, J., approving sale of stock of Pullman

railroad

1146

1147

1194

1195

1237

1238

1241

1243

1250

1253

1257

1258

1266

1272

1274

1275

1100

1112

1113

1141

1141

1170

1170

1172

1173

1177

1178

1181

1181

1185

1188

x INDEX

Record from D. C. U. S., Eastern District of Pennsylvania—

Motion of the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway

Company and others for the entry of an order providing

for continued conduct of sleeping car service pending

consummation of sale of the Pullman Company stock

to buying Group of Railroads and approving sales by

the Pullman Company of sleeping cars to individual

Final decree approving contract of sale of stock of Pullman,

Inc., under certain conditions, and retaining jurisdiction

for purpose of effectuating provisions of this decree, Jan.

Order of Court modifying order of Dec. 26, 1945, and per-

mitting Pullman Co. to operate sleeping car service, eto

Petition of United States for Appeal

Petition of Otis & Co. for appeal

Order allowing appeal of Otjs

Assignment of errors and prayer for reversal

Citation [omitted in printing]

Praecipe of Otis & Co. as to transcript of record o appeal

Order allowing appeal of the Chesapeake & Ohio Railway

Praecipe of the Chesapeake and Ohio R. R. Co., et al

Petition for appeal of Glore, Forgan & Co

Order allowing appeal of Glore, Forgan & Co

Assignments of error; Glore, Forgan & Co

Citation [omitted in printing]

Praecipe as to transcript of record; Glore, Forgan & CO

Praecipe for additional portions of record; the Atchison,

Topeka and Santa Fe Railway Co. et al

Designation of additional portions of record to be included

in record on appeal; The Pullman Co. et al

Clerk’s certificate [omitted in printing]

Government’s trial exhibits:

No. 1—Stipulation of facts

Exhibit VII accompanying stipulation of facts

Index to Vol. I of Exhibit VII

Index to Vol. II of Exhibit VII

No. 106—Letter to George Whitney, Feb. 28, 1931

INDEX

Government's trial exhibits—Continued

XI

No. 110— Letter, Richard K. Mellon to D. A. Crawford, Original Print

. 2432

No. 115— Memorandum, D. A. Crawford to L. S. Hunger-

ford and L. S. Taylor, Feb. 3, 1911. 2433

No. 146—Telegram, D. A. Crawford to D. R. McLennan,

7 d sacntue cee 2434

No. 329—Notice of special and annual meetings of stock-

holders of Pullman Inc., with annexed proxy state-

, A nceccnccéunace 2435

No. 416— Telegram, Henry Sturgis to D. A. Crawford... 2455

No. 418 Memorandum for General Contract Committee

signed by D. A. Crawford, Jan. 8, 1937 2456

No. 419—Letter, Champ Carry to D. A. Crawford, March

Sd ee eee ee eee 2457

No. 422— “Letter, Hale Holden, Jr., to D. A. Crawford

r UR— „ 2458

No. 501 — Letter to H. 8. Vanderbilt, Feb. 27, 1922 2459

No. 504 — Telegram, E. F. Carry to George F. Baker, Jr.,

r — aul dibeek aha enenon 2460

No. 525—Memorandum on Pennsylvania-New York

Central contract negotiations, July 25, 1936. 2461

Transcript of hearing of March 19, 1945, on proposed plan

for separation of sleeping car business from manufactur-

/ A . 2465

Caption and appearance s. 2465

e . K 2472

Argument of Mr. Hamilton 2484

I ov cuincedcvecccncesseevesss 2527

Argument of Colonel Finla gz 2545

,, as ie haeneue 2545

— R « -!n —ůuV--—:ng·g; •Aü„ 2551

; Transcript of hearings on four offers to purchase The

Pullman Company, Nov. 5th and 6th, 1945. 2559-A

Caption and appearances. .__........... 2.2.2... 2559-A

Colloquy between Court and counsel 2563

Testimony on behalf of Otis and 2

D e 2580

e ean wane 8 2624

, i iecinnimel we 2699

Testimony on behalf of Glore, Forgan & Co.: Charles

dn . 2724

Testimony on behalf of Standard Steel Spring Com-

pany:

r ¾—ü . 2748

Robert C. Enos (recalled )) 2783

, — A ... 2834

Testimony on behalf of intervening railroads:

W. 8. Franklin

ee

1955

1956

1956

1957

1975

1976

1977

XII INDEX

Government's trial exhibits—Continued

Transcript of hearings on four offers to purchase—Con.

Testimony on behalf of intervening railroads—Con. Original Print

2219

Colloquy between Court and counsel

Otis and Company Exhibits:

Exhibit 1—Letter dated October 5, 1945, from

3031

Exhibit 2—Document dated May 12, 1945, en-

titled “In re: Proposal for sale of stock of the

Pullman Company under decree entered May 8,

1944, and interim order entered March 22,

1945, in the Pullman antitrust case in the

Federal District Court at Philadelphia”

Exhibit 3—Paper headed “The Chesapeake &

Ohio Railway Company—Excerpt from Min-

utes of Meeting of Board of Directors Held

October 17, 1944”

Exhibit 4—Letter dated July 25, 1945, from

D. A. Crawford, Pullman Incorporated, to

Mr. Robert R. Young, with attached letters

marked B, C, D, E, F, and G 3065-A

Exhibit 6—Copy of telegram dated August 29,

1945, from Robert R. Young, Allan P. Kirby,

Cyrus Eaton and Others to Chief Executive

Exhibit 8—Letter replies to Otis and Company,

r

Exhibit 9 — Memorandum dated 912-45 from

Exhibit 10— Memorandum entitled Memoran-

dum Regarding Sleeping Cars, dated Septem-

ber 19, 1945, from the New York Central

Exhibit 11—Telegram dated September 27, 1945,

from Edward G. Budd to Robert R. Voung

Exhibit 12—Telegram dated September 27, 1945,

from Charles J. Hardy, Chairman, American

Car and Foundry Co., to Robert R. Young_-

Exhibit 13—Telegram dated September 27, 1945,

from Pullman Standard Car Manufacturing

oung

Exhibit 14—Paper entitled Statement by Carl

E. Newton, President of Chesapeake and Ohio

Railway to AAR Board, October 26, 1945, on

behalf of smaller passenger-carrying roads”’ __-

INDEX

Government's trial exhibits—Continued

Transcript of hearings on four offers to purchase—Cen.

Otis and Company Exhibits—Continued

Exhibit 15—Letter dated October 25, 1945, from

Robert J. Bowman, President, Pere Marquette

Railway Company, to Mr. C. E. Newton,

President, the Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Original Print

3157 2309

— ͤ—ͤVyAA—. . ²—⁰—½- c

Exhibit 16— Letter dated October 25, 1945, from

J. W. Davin, President, the New York,

Chicago and St. Louis Railroad Company, to

Mr. C. E. Newton, President, the Chesapeake

and Ohio Railway Company

Glore exhibits:

Exhibit 1— Paper entitled The Pullman Com-

pany— Capital Stock,“ dated November 3,

Exhibit I- Statement showing armor plate pro-

gram, bomb production and gear and axle

program of Standard Steel Spring Company

Exhibit 2— Offer of Standard Steel Spring

Company to Pullman Incorporated, dated

October 25, 1945, with attached memorandum

Exhibit 3— Statement of Standard Steel Spring

Company Average Yearly Employment

Exhibit 6— Document entitled Thirtieth An-

nual Report to Shareholders of the Standard

Steel Spring Company

Exhibit 7—Document entitled “Standard Steel

Spring Company and Subsidiary— Consolidated

Balance Sheet as of August 31, 1945“

Exhibit 8—Document entitled “Standard Steel

Spring Company and Subsidiary—Consoli-

dated Profit and Loss Statement for the Eight

Months ended August 31, 194577 .

Exhibit 9—Paper headed “Net Sales by Years

for the 10% years ended June 30, 1945’’______

Exhibit 10—Paper, the first line of which says

“Total Number of Shareholders“

Exhibit 11—Paper headed “Shares of Common

Stock Owned and Controlled by Directors of

Standard Steel Spring Company

Exhibit 12—Paper headed List of Stockholders

Owning One Thousand Shares or More of One

Dollar Par Value Common Stock as of October

Exhibit 13—Document dated October 24, 1945.

Railroad exhibits:

Exhibit 1—Paper headed The Nation’s Stream-

3225

2344

2349

XIV INDEX

Government's trial exhibits—Continued

Transcript of hearings on four offers to purchase—Con.

Railroad Exhibits—Continued Original Print

Exhibit 2—Statement by defendant, Pullman Co. 3286 2367

Exhibit 3—Letter dated October 13, 19438. 3331 2389

Exhibit 4—Letter dated October 15, 194338. 3332 2390

Exhibit 5—Document entitled “Pullman Car

Assignment October 1, 1948 ' 3334 2391

Exhibit 6 Corresponden cee 3340 2393

Chesapeake and Ohio exhibits:

Exhibit 1— Statement of sales 3355 2402

Transcript of argument on four offers to purchase The

Pullman Company, December 10th, 11th, and 12th,

— — e RM een 3363 2404

Caption and appearances . 3363 2404

Argument of

D ̃ . 3366 2404

r rr 3376 2409

D ̃ A SE Ra agi 3422 2431

sie . a OE at Ss 3434 2437

tit Y 3454 2445

RL al ‚— ER TIE RAN 3457 2447

a ..... 3463 2449

ae oe bbe ee nun ou numhaoh oon 3490 2462

D r 3494 2464

D . ˖˙—— ... 3587 2507

r ] RO aly ib ee 3656 2539

EE ͥͤ%‚ Ri a ag IRA 3660 2541

D i i 3710 2564

D nar eene ds men antmeudins 3748 2581

Argument in rebuttal of

D set 3754 2584

, ae at nanan ueoanue 3779 2594

r r 3797 2603

r .

——ũ—C'—H PVD e

—— Uw OVnU ee eee

—U— ! UUVU MVV LUTP d 2 2

——U—U— — PU H 2

——ũ— ßVUPMwHHʒZiii

——u— U U(AQuP d

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 1

In the District Court of the United States for the Eastern

District of Pennsylvania

Civil Action No. 994

Untrep Srarxs or AMERICA

ve.

Tue Puttman Company, Puteman Sraxbanb Car Manvrac-

TURING Company, PottMan IN cORrOnATTD, Puttman Car &

Manvracrurine Corporation or ALaBamMa, Davin A. Craw-

ronb, George A. KIL, Lower, M. Greentaw, Cuaries A.

Lappe, ELLAs W. Test, WILIA J. Perers, E. Evcenr Apams,

Sewett L. Avery, James F. Bett, Artuvr O. Cuoate, J.

Frank Drake, Donatp R. McLennan, Ricuarp K. Meion, J.

Pierront Mondax, Joun R. Morrow, Avan M. Scaire, Arrep

P. Stoa x, Jr., Henri S. Srundis, HRO S. Vanversiur, Grorce

Wurrney, Louis S. Taxton, W. N. Barker, H. H. Guiserr, J.

A. KxOwWTox, H. M. Duptey, WX. Brerman. R. L. Gorvon, P.

G. Jenks, R. S. Eulxn, H. S. Mondax, C. W. Seanurc

Intervenors: The Order of Railway Conductors of America;

The Pullman Clerk’s Association; The Pullman Car Employees

Association of the Repair Shops; The Independent Pullman

Workers Federation; Pullman Porters Union; Brotherhood of

Sleeping Car Porters; Otis & Co.; United Transport Service Em-

ployees of America; Glore, Forgan & Co., Atchison, Topeka &

Santa Fe R. R., et al.; Alabama Great Southern R. R. Co., et al.;

States of California & Colorado; Chesapeake & Ohio Rwy. Co,

et al.; Standard Steel Spring Co.; United Transport Service Em-

ployees of America.

Appearances: Gerald A. Gleeson; Edward A. Kailick, for

Plaintiff Winston, Strawn & Shaw, Esqs., Ralph M. Shaw, Walter

H. Jacobs, Lowell M. Greenlaw, of Chicago, III., and Davies,

Richberg, Beebe, Busick & Richardson, Esqs., Seth W. Richard-

son, Raymond N. Beebe, Adrien F. Busick, George Wharton,

Pepper & Pepper, Bodine, Stokes & Schoch for all (original)

defendants. Leon M. Despres, 77 W. Washington St., Chicago

2, III., John Pemberton Jordan for Pullman Porters Union. Jer-

ome L. Markovitz for United Transport Service Emptoyees of

America. Lemuel B. Schofield, Esq., for Otis & Co. Evans, Bay-

ard & Frick for Glore, Forgan & Co. Robert W. Kenny, Attorney

General, State of California, San Francisco, California. II.

Lawrence Hinkley, Attorney General, State of Colorado, Denver,

Colorado. Lewis M. Stevens for Standard Steel Spring Co. John

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

Dickinson for Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe et al., and Alabama

Great Southern R. R. Co., et al.

Docket entries

1940

July 12—Complaint filed.

July 12—Expediting Certificate filed.

16—Orcer of Court (Biggs, C. J.) designating Circuit Judges Biggs,

Maris, and Goodrich to hear the cause filed. 7/17/40 noted &

notice mailed.

16—Order of Court authorizing service of summons beyond district

filed. 7/17/40 noted & notice mailed.

17—Summons exit to Dist. of Delaware.

17—Summons exit to No. Dist. of Alabama.

17—Summons exit to No. Dist. of Illinois.

17—Summons exit to Dist. of Minn.

17—Summons exit to So. Dist. of New York.

17—Summons exit to West. Dist. of Penna.

17—Summons exit to E. District of Penna.

24—Summons to Dist. of Minn. returned: “on July 22, 1940, served

James F. Bell“ and filed.

24—Summons to No. Dist. of Ala. returned: on July 22, 1940, served

Pullman Car & Mfg. Corp. of Ala.” and filed.

24—Summons to Dist. of Del. returned: “on July 22, 1940, served

Pullman Standard Car Mfg. Co. and Pullman, Inc.” and filed.

1—Summons to W. Dist. of Pa. returned: “on July 23, 1940, served

J. F. Drake, Allan M. Scaife, Wm. Bierman, and R. K. Mellon“

and filed.

5—Order of Court authorizing service of summons beyond district

filed. 8/6/40 noted & notice mailed.

5—Summons as to R. S. Euler exit to Western District of Pa.

6—Summons returned from E. D. of Pa. “Served Hale Holdon, Vice

Pres. of Pullman Co. on July 22, 1940” and filed.

&8—Summons as to R. S. Euler from Western District of Pa. returned

“Served on August 6, 1940” and filed.

. 10—Order of Court authorizing appearances of certain counsel in

Chicago, III., and Washington, D. C., and directing that all

papers be served on them filed. 8/12/40 noted & notice mailed.

10—Stipulation as to filing of Answers, and taking of Depositions

filed.

. 10—Order of Court upon stipulation extending time for filing of answers

and providing for deposition & discoveries, filed. 8/12/40 noted

& notice mailed.

Aug. 10—Notice of Appearance of Winston, Strawn & Shaw, Esqs.,

Ralph M. Shaw, Walter M. Jacobs, Esq., Lowell M.

Greenlaw, Esq., of Chicago, III., and Davies, Richberg,

Beebe, Busick & Richardson, Esq., Seth W. Richardson,

Esq., Raymond N. Beebe, Adrien F. Busick, Esa., of

Washington, D. C., filed.

Sept. 12—Summons

Oct. 15—Admission of service of answer filed.

Nov. 19—Appearance of George Wharton Pepper, Esq., and Pepper, Bodine,

Stokes and Schoch, Esqs., for all defendants filed.

Nov. 25—Deposition of Chas. O. Allen filed.

Dec. 11—Deposition of Sterling J. Joyner, volume 1, filed.

July 22—Order of Court granting leave to plaintiff to amend its complaint

filed. 7/23/41 noted and notice mailed.

July 31—Stenographer’s report of conference of July 22, 1941, filed.

Aug. 20—Amended answer, filed.

Sept. 22—Complaint, amended to conform to order of July 22, 1941, filed.

without the district, ete., filed. 10/20/41 noted and notice mailed.

22— Statement of facts which plaintiff believes defendants should

stipulate filed.

22—Defendants’ response to facts tendered by plaintiff for agreement

filed.

4 Oct. 27—Deposition of F. E. Webb filed.

Oct. 28—Further application of plaintiff for permission to subpoena

witnesses living out of the district filed.

Oct. 28— Order of Court granting permission to subpoena witnesses living

without the district filed. 10/29/41 noted and notice mailed.

Nov. 3— Trial (Biggs, Maris & Goodrich, C. JJ.).

Nov. 4—Trial resumed.

Nov. 5—Trial resumed.

Nov. 5—Testimony filed (2 vol. Nov. 3 and 5).

Nov. 6—Trial resumed.

Nov. 6—Testimony filed (1 vol. Nov. 5).

Oct.

Oct

Oct. 18—Order of Court granting permission to subpoena witnesses living

Oct

Oct.

724808—47—1

4 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

1941

Nov. 6—Further application of plaintiff for permission to subpoena wit-

nesses living out of the district filed.

Nov. 6—Order of Court granting permission to subpoena witnesses living

without the district filed. 11/7/41 noted and notice mailed.

Nov. 7—Trial resumed. K

Nov. 7— Testimony filed. (1 vol. Nov. 6).

Nov. 10— Trial resumed.

Nov. 10—Testimony filed (1 vol. Nov. 7).

Nov. 13—Trial resumed.

Nov. 14—Trial resumed. °

Nov. 14—Testimony filed (1 vol. Nov. 13).

Nov. 15—Testimony filed (1 vol. Nov. 14).

Nov. 17— Exhibit VII filed (2 printed vols.).

Nov. 18— Trial resumed (Continued to 3/2/42).

Nov. 19— Testimony filed (1 vol. Nov. 18).

Dec. 17— Application by defendants for extension of time for filing objections

and motion to strike and Order of Court (Biggs, J.) granting

motion, filed. .

Feb. 17—Motior by defendants for postponement of taking of addi-

tional evidence, filed.

17—Hearing sur motion for

19— Affidavits of C. A. Liddle, D. A. Crawford & L. M. Greenlaw filed.

|

|

|

|

|

6— Answer of defendants to plaintiff's request for admissions, filed.

9 Hearing sur motion to strike certain evidence.

10— Hearing resumed. Eo die: Motions No. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, & 9

denied. Motion No. 2 granted (Order to be submitted). Ad-

journed to June 1, 1942.

10— Answer of defendants to plaintiff's request for admissions filed.

10—Defendants’ objections to ahd motions to strike certain docu-

mentary evidence conditionally admitted, filed.

11—Stenographer’s transcript of March 10, 1942, filed (1 vol.).

9—Stenographer’s transcript of Argument on Mar. 9, 1942, filed

(I vol.).

1— Trial resumed.

2— Trial resumed.

2—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 1).

3—Trial resumed.

3—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 2).

5—Trial resumed.

5—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 8).

TE EE FRE Fees ©

ttt

8 8 8

THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

1942

June 8—Trial resumed.

June 8&—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 5).

June 0. Trial resumed.

June 9%—Testimony filed (1 vol June 8).

6 June 10— Trial resumed.

June 10— Testimony filed (1 vol. June 9).

June 11—Trial resumed.

June 11—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 10).

June 12—Trial resumed.

June 12—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 11).

June 16—Trial resumed.

June 16—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 12).

June 17— Trial resumed.

June 17—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 16).

June 18—Trial resumed.

June 18—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 17).

June 19—Trial resumed.

June 19—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 18).

June 22—Trial resumed.

June 22—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 19).

June 23—Trial resumed.

June 23—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 22).

June 24—Trial resumed.

June 24—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 23).

June 24—Plaintiff’s requests for admissions filed.

June 30—Trial resumed.

June 30—Testimony filed (1 vol, June 24).

July 1— Trial resumed. Testimony closed.

July 1—Testimony filed (1 vol. June 30).

July 2— Testimony filed (1 vol. July 1).

Oct. 2—~Brief of U. 8. and proposed findings of fact filed.

Dee. 1—Defendants’ proposed findings of fact filed.

Dec, 1—Brief and argument for defendants filed.

Dec. 31—Reply brief of U. G. filed.

1943

7 Jan. 28—Argued sur pleadings and proofs.

Jan. 29—Transeript of hearing of Jan. 28, 1943, filed.

Jan. 20— Argument resumed.

Jan. 20 Transeript of hearing of Jan. 20, 1943, filed,

Jan. 30—Argument resumed.

Feb. 1—Transeript of hearing of Jan, 30, 1943, filed,

Feb. I— Argument concluded.

Feb. 1—Agreement of plaintiff to certain of defendants’ requests for findings

of fact filed,

Feb. 2—Transeript of hearing of Feb. 1, 1943, filed.

Apr. 20—Opinion of the Court (Goodrich, C. J.) granting judgment in favor

of plaintiff, and tasking certain findings of fact and conclusions

of law, filed.

5

6 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

1044

Jan. 22—Supplementary Opinion, Maris and Goodrich, C. J., sur form of

Jan. 26—Stenographer’s transcript of proceedings on Jan. 22, 1944, filed.

Feb. 2— Opinion, Biggs, C. J., sur form of judgment, filed.

Feb. 18—Order of Court granting leave to file certain briefs of record filed.

2/19/44 noted and notice mailed.

Feb. 18—Order of Court ruling on motions to strike from the record certain

documentary evidence filed. 2/19/44 noted and notice mailed.

Mar. 16—Defendants’ trial briefs (3) (Points 1, 2, and 3) filed.

Mar. 17—Reply brief of defendants in support of objections to proposed final

judgment, filed.

Mar. 17—Order of Court, Maris, C. J., granting leave to defendants to refile

amended answer with certain corrections filed.

Mar. 17—Amended answer with corrections, filed.

Apr. 3—Piaintiff’s trial brief filed (Parts I and II, 1 vol.).

May 8—Per curiam opinion sur entry of judgment filed.

May 8 Judgment in favor of plaintiff and requiring separation of business

of manufacturing and operating by certain defendants filed.

5/9/44 noted and notice mailed.

June 27—Suggestion of death of William J. Peters, J. Pierpont Morgan and

P. G. Jenks filed.

July 27— Motion by plaintiff for allowance of stenographer’s fees as taxable

costs filed.

s Aug. 7—Report of Pullman Company showing list of railroads to

which copies of the final judgment were sent, filed.

Aug. 7—Report of Pullman-Standard Car Mfg. Co. showing list of railroads

to which copies of the final judgment were sent, filed.

Sept. 8—Hearing sur motion to tax stenographer’s fees as costs.

Sept. 20—Order of Court requiring Pullman Co. to pay certain stenographer’s

fees and costs, filed. 9/21/44 noted and notice mailed.

Oct. 2—Election of defendant Pullman Incorporated to dispose of its

interest in sleeping car business, filed.

Oct. 2—Pian for separation — car business frosh manufacturing

business submitted by Pullman Incorporated, filed. |

Oct. 6—Plaintiff’s bill of costa, filed.

1945

Jan. 12—Clerk's taxation of costs, filed.

Jan. 18—Motion by The Order of Railway Conductors of America for leave

to intervene, filed.

Jan. 18— Petition by The Order of Railway Conductors of America for leave

to intervene, filed.

Jan. 18 Order of Court (Biggs, J.) granting motion of The Order of Rail-

way Conductors of America for leave to intervene, filed.

. 26—Motion by The Pullman Clerks’ Association for leave to intervene,

filed.

. 26—Petition by The Pullman Clerks’ Association for leave to intervene,

filed.

26—Order of Court (Biggs, J.) granting motion of The Pullman Clerks’

Ass n for leave to intervene, filed.

THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 7

26—Motion by The Pullman Car Employes Ass'n of the Repair Shops

for leave to intervene, filed.

26—Petition by The Pullman Car Employes Ass’n of the Repair Shops

for leave to intervene, filed.

26—Order of Court (Biggs, J.) granting motion of The Pullman Car

Employes Ass'n of the Repair Shops for leave to intervene, filed.

Plan for Separation”, ete., submitted by

S- Motion by The Independent Pullman Workers Federation for

leave to intervene, filed.

. 5—Petition by the Independent Pullman Workers Federation for leave

to filed.

» 5—Order of Court (Biggs,

Pullman Wor

. 9—-Objections of The Pullman Clerks’ Ascociation, et al., to plan filed.

. 19—Appearance of John Pemberton Jordan, Esq., for Pullman Porters

Union filed.

10 — Hearing on plan for separation of the sleeping car b isiness from

the manufacturing business, submitted by Pullman Co., Ine.

10 — Motion by Pullman Porters Union for leave to intervene filed.

. 19—Notice of motion by Pullman Porters Union for leave to intervene

filed.

. 19—Petition of Pullman Porters Union for leave to intervene filed.

. 19—Order of Court (Biggs, J.) granting motion of Pullman Porters

Union for leave to intervene filed.

. 21—Stenographer’s transcript of hearing on Mar. 19, 1045, filed.

. 22—Appearance of Goldstein & Woolston, Ege. for Brotherhood of

Sleeping Car Porters filed.

- 22—-Petition of Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters for leave to inter-

one and Order ot Court grancing leave filed. .

22 Order of Court authorizing Pullman Co. to negotiate for sale of

sleeping car business and permitting Pullman Incorporated to

negotiate for sale of its shares of stock in P

2— Petition of United Transport Service Employees of America for

leave to intervene filed.

2 Order of Court granting the above petition filed.

Aug. 27— Motion to Intervene and Petition of

8

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

1945

Sept. 27—Supplement to petition of Otis & Co., for approval of its offer to

purchase

certain facilities of Pullman, Inc., filed.

Sept. 27—Memorandum of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters, etc.,

EFR ES F REESE SVB

—

—

Oct.

Oct

Nov.

Nov.

in support of Petition of Otis & Co. for approval of its offer to

purchase certain facilities of Pullman, Inc., filed.

5—Affidavit of service of Supplement to Petition of Otis & Co., etc.,

filed.

5—Motion by Otis & Co., to set its intervening petition, etc., down

for hearing filed.

5—Order of Court fixing Nov. 5, 1945, for hearing of petition of

Otis & Co., for approval of its offer to purchase, ete., filed.

9—Memorandum of United Transport Service Employees of America

in relation to petition of Otis & Co., for approval of its offer to

purchase, etc., filed.

13—Affidavit of service of Motion, Order, etc., of Otis & Co., filed.

13—Petition of Glore, Forgan & Co., for leave to intervene and for

Order directing Pullman, Inc., to sell to petitioner, etc., filed.

19—Affidavits of service of notice of motion of Glore, Forgan & Co.,

for leave to intervene filed.

19—Order of Court granting leave to Glore, Forgan & Co., to intervene,

filed. ’

19—Order of Court fixing Nov. 5, 1945, for hearing on petition of

Glore, Forgan & Co. for order authorizing The Pullman Co. to -

sell its stock, filed. 10/20/45 noted and notice mailed.

23—Amendment to petition of Pullman Car Employees Association

of the Repair Shops for leave to intervene, and Order of Court

allowing same, filed.

23—Amendment to petition of Independent Pullman Workers Federa-

tion for leave to intervene, and Order of Court allowing same,

filed.

23—Amendment to petition of Pullman Clerks Association for leave to

intervene, and Order of Court allowing same, filed.

26—Motion by States of California and Colorado to intervene and

petition to intervene filed.

26—Appearance of H. Eastman Hackney, Esq., and Lewis M. Stevens,

Esq., for Standard Spring Steel Co , filed.

Oct. 26—Motion of Standard Steel Spring Co. to intervene and

petition for approval of its offer for purchase of capital stock of

Pullman Co., filed.

26—Order of Court fixing Nov. 1, 1945, for hearing on motion of

Standard Steel Spring Co. to intervene, filed 10/27/45 noted.

. 29—Motion of Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railway Co., et al., to

intervene and Petition for approval of their offer for purchase of

capital stock of Pullman Co., etc., filed.

1—Affidavit of service of motion of Standard Steel Spring Co. filed.

1—Hearing sur motions of Standard Steel Spring Co.; Atchison,

Topeka & Santa Fe Rwy. Co., et al; and States of California

and Colorado; for leave to intervene. ,

1—Order of Court granting leave to Standard Steel Spring Co. to

intervene filed. 11/2/45 noted.

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 9

1945

Nov. 1—Order of Court granting leave to Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe

Rwy. Co., et al, to intervene filed. 11/2/45 noted.

Nov. 1—Order of Court granting leave to Attorneys General of States of

Nov. 1—Order of Court fixing Nov. 5, 1945, for hearing petition of Standard

„ filed.

Nov. 1—Order of Court fixing Nov. 5, 1945, for hearing petition of Atchison,

. ' Topeka & Santa Fe Rwy. Co., et al, filed.

: Nov. 1—Order of Court fixing Nov. 5, 1945, for hearing petition of States

Colorado, filed.

of California and ‘

Nov. 1—Stenographer’s transcript of hearing on Nov. 1, 1945, filed.

Nov. 5—Supplementa! petition on behalf of the State of Colorado filed.

Nov. 5— Hearing sur petitions of certain Intervenors for approval of plans

for purchase of the Pullman Co.

Nov. 6—Hearing resumed. Ordered that Pullman Co. file report of its

selection of purchaser of its stock by Dec. 3, 1945. Further

hearing fixed for Dec. 10, 1945. -

Nov. 6—Testimony filed (1 vol. 11/5/45).

Nov. 6—Telegram from Ellia Arnall, Governor of Georgia, filed.

Nov. 6—Memorandum of United Transport Service Employees of America

in re petition of Standard Steel Spring Co., for approval of its

offer to purchase, etc., filed.

12 Nov. 13—Report by Pullman, Inc., of its selection of purchaser, ete.,

filed.

Nov. 13—Supplemental Petition of Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Rwy.,

et al., for approval of sale, etc., filed.

Nov. 15—Testimony filed (2 vol.—11/5 & 11/6 & exhibits).

Nov. 17—Petition and Motion of Chesapeake & Ohio Rwy. Co., et al., for

leave to intervene, filed.

Nov. 19—Order of Court granting motion of Chesapeake & Ohio Rwy. Co.

for leave to intervene, filed.

Nov. 30—Brief of Glore, Forgan & Co., sur offers for the acquisition of the

Capital Stock of the Pullman Co., filed.

8—Brief of Chesapeake & Ohio Rwy. Co., et al., filed.

8—Reply brief for Standard Steel Spring Co., filed.

Dec. 1—Second Supplemental petition of the Atchison, Topeka & Santa

Fe Railway Co., et al., filed.

Dec. 1—Brief of Buying Group of Railroads in support of Pullman’s

application for approval of contract of sale, filed.

Dec. 1 Brief of Standard Steel Spring Co., filed.

Dec. 5—Memorandum of United Transport Service Employees of America

with reference to the application of Pullman, Inc. and certain

railroads for approval of executory contract, filed.

Dec. 5— Motion and Petition in Intervention of Alabama Great Southern

Railroad Co., and others, filed.

Dec. 6—Order of Court granting leave to Alabama Great Southern Rail-

road Co., et al., to intervene, filed. 12/7/45 noted.

Dec. 7—Brief of U. 8. on various proposals to purehase sleeping car business,

filed.

Dee. 8— Reply brief of Otis & Co. in further support of its offer to purchase,

etc., filed.

Dec.

Dec.

10 ‘TH® UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

1945

Dec. 8— Reply brief of Buying Group of Railroads, filed.

Dec. 8—Statement of position of Pullman Clerks’ Ass’n, et al., filed.

Dec. 8—Statement of position of Order of Rwy. Conductors of America,

Dee.

Dec.

Dec

filed.

10—Motion of Standard Steel Spring Co., Intervenor, to admit certain

documents in evidence, filed.

10— Hearing re approval of sale of stock of The Pullman Co.

. 10—Memorandum of Pullman Porters Union with reference to applica-

tion of Pullman, Inc., and certain railroads for approval of

executory contract, filed.

13 Dee. 10—Stenographer’s transcript of hearing on Dec. 10, 1945, filed.

Dec. 11—Memorandum of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters,

Intervenor, in re application of P. man, Inc., and certain

railroads for approval of sale, filed.

Dec. 11—Hearing resumed.

Dec. 12—Argument concluded.

Dec. 14—Stenographic transcript of hearing on Dec. 11, 1945, filed.

Dec

Deo.

Dec.

. 18—Opinion, Goodrich, J., approving sale of stock of Pullman Co., to

the railroads, filed.

18—Stenographic transcript of hearing on Dec. 12, 19465, filed.

21—Motion by Buying Group of Railroads for order providing for

continued conduct of sleeping-car service pending consummation

of sale of Pullman Company stock, and order of Court fixing

Dec. 26, 1945, for hearing, filed.

car business until Mar. 31, 1946, etc., filed.

1946 ,

Jan. %—Stenographer’s transcript of hearing on Dec. 26, 1945, filed.

Jan. 4—Final Decree approving contract of sale of stock of Pullman, Inc.,

under certain conditions, and retaining jurisdiction for purpose

of effectuating provisions of this decree, filed. 1/4/46 noted and

notice mailed.

Jan. 4—Hearing re settlement of decrze.

Jan. 8 Stenographer's transcript of hearing on Jan. 4, 1946, filed.

Mar. 4—Petition of United States for Appeal filed.

Mar. 4—Assignments of Error, etc., filed.

Mar. 4—Statement as to jurisdiction filed.

Mar. 4—Statement by United States, appellant, required by Rule 12 (2),

Mar

Mar

Mar

Mar

filed.

. 4~—Hearing sur motions for allowance of appeals.

. 4~—Order of Court allowing appeal of U. 8. filed.

. 4—Citation allowed and issued.

. 4—Order of Court modifying order of Dec. 26, 1945, and permitting

Pullman Co. to operate sleeping-cer service until further order

of the Court, filed.

14 Mar. 4—Petition of Otis & Co. for appeal filed.

Mar. 4—Assignments of error, etc., filed.

. 4—Statement as to jurisdiction filed.

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 11

FFF kkkkkfk F kek

4—Order of Court allowing appeal of Otis & Co. filed.

4 Petition of Chesapeake & Ohio Rwy. Co., et al., for appeal filed.

et al., filed.

4—Statement by appellants, Chesapeake & Ohio Rwy. Co., et al.,

calling attention to Supreme Court rule 12 (3), filed.

5—Stenographer’s Transcript of hearing on Mar. 4, 1946, filed.

. filed

allowed re appeal of Glore, Forgan & Co., and .

6—Statement by Appellant Glore, Forgan & Co., required by rule

12 (2), filed.

6—Bond for costs in $250 re appeal of Glore, Forgan & Co., with

Travelers Indemnity Co., surety, and order of Court approving

bond filed.

“ 7—Bond for costs in $250 re appeal of Otis & Co., with Indemnity

Ins. Co., of N. A., surety, and order of Court approving bond

filed

Mar. 7—Bond for costs in $260 te appeal of Chesapeake & Ohio R. R. Co,

FF

et al., with Indemnity Ins. Co. of N. A., surety and order of

Court approving bond filed.

&—Proof of service of petition for appeal, order allowing appeal, eto,

by United States, filed. .

%—Proot of service of petition for appeal, order allowing appeal,

ete., by Glore, Forgan & Co., filed.

Mar. 14—Affidavit of serviee of papers re appeal of Otis & Co. filed.

Mar. 14—Acknowledgement of service re appeal of Otis & Co., filed,

- 26—Praecipe re record on appeal of United States, filed.

15

Mar. 28—Praccipe re record on appeal of Glore, Forgan & Co,, filed.

Apr.

- 28—Praecipe re record on appeal of Otis & Co., filed.

2—Praecipe re record on appeal of Chesapeake & Ohio Rwy. Co. et al.,

filed

4—Designation of Pullman Co. et al., of additional portions of record

on appeal, filed.

4—Praecipe of Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Rwy. Co. et al., for

additional portions of record on appeal, filed.

12—Order of Court extending time for filing transcript of record on

appeal to and-including June 14, 1946, filed.

June 7—Order of Court with consent of counsel, extending time for filing

record on appeal to and including Aug. 15, 1946, filed. 6/10/46

Noted,

June 10—Statement on behalf of Otis & Co. calling attention to the pro-

visions of Supreme Court Rule 12 (3), filed.

12 THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

17 In the District Court of the United States for the Eastern

District of Pennsylvania

June Term 1940

Civil Action No. 994

Unrrep Srates or AMERICA, PLAINTIFF

v.

Tue Portman Company, Puttman-Sranparp Car Maxvraorun-

— 1 Poutiman Incorvoratep, Puttman Car & Max-

ACTURING CORPORATION or Auasama, Davm A. Crawrorp,

Geman A. — Lowem M. Greentaw, Cuartes A. Lx,

Exzas W. Tesr, Wa1am J. Perers, E. Eveens Avams, Seweii

L. Avery, Janus F. Be, Axrnun O. Cnoarx, J. Franx Drake,

Donato R. McLznwan, Ricnarp K. ML Ox, J. Pro r Mon-

Gan, Jonx R. Morron, Auan M. Scairn, Aurrep P. Stoax, In.,

Henry S. Srundis, Harotww S. Vanvexsmr, Gronan Wrrxxx,

Louts S. Taxon, W. N. Banxer, H. H. Grazer, J. A. Kxo .-. ¹ .

ton, H. M. Duptzy, WX. Brerman, R. L. Gorvon, P. G. Juxxs,

R. 8. Era, H. S. Mandam, C. W. Snanbnxr, buruxbawrs

, Complaint

Filed July 12, 1940

To the honorable the Judges of the District Court of the United

States for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania:

The United States of America, by its attorneys acting under the

direction of the Attorney General of the United States,

18 brings this civil action against The Pullman Company,

Pullman-Standard Car Manufacturing Company, Pullman

Incorporated, Pullman Car & Man ing Corporation of Ala-

bama, defendant corporations, David A. wford, George A.

Kelly, Lowell M. Greenlaw, Charles A. Liddle, Ellis W. Test, Wil-

liam J. Peters, E. een Cored Say any. Sel

=

JURISDICTION AND VENUE

1. This complaint is filed and the jurisdiction of this court is

invoked to obtain civil relief against said defendants because of

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 13

many of the unlawful

by defendants and

Company is in the Pullman

pres-

rd has its principal offices at 110 West

Street, Wilmington, Delaware. It is a wholly owned sub-

Pullman Incorporated.

14 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

5. Defendant Pullman Incorporated, hereinafter called Pull-

man, is a corporation organized in 1927 under the laws of the State

of Delaware to acquire control of The Pullman Company and of

the Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corporation, whose name was

changed to Pullman-Standard Car Manufacturing Company in

1934 as described in paragraph 4. The principal office of Pull-

man is located at 100 West Tenth Street, Wilmington, Delaware.

Pullman is a holding yo which owns all of the stock of

defendant corporations, with the exception of The Pullman Com-

pany of whose stock Pullman owns 99.99 percent.

6. Defendant Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corporation of

_ Alabama, hereinafter called Pullman of Alabama, is a corpora-

tion organized in 1929 under the laws of the State of Alabama,

where it owns certain manufacturing plants which are leased to

Standard for the manufacture of rolling stock. Pullman of Ala-

bama is a wholly owned subsidiary of Pullman.

7. The individual defendants David A. Crawford, E. Eugene

Adams, Sewell L. Avery, James F. Bell, Arthur O. Choate,

21 J. Frank Drake, Donald R. McLennan, Richard K. Mellon,

J. Pierpont Morgan, John R. Morron, Alan M. Scaife,

Alfred P. Sloan, Jr., Henry S. Sturgis, Harold S. Vanderbilt, and

George Whitney have been and are officers or directors of and

have participated in and participate in the direction and manage-

ment of defendant Pullman Incorporated and defendant The

Pullmen Company and may be found in said Pullman Building,

i Illinois, with the exception of the following individual

def ts who are to be found at the addresses set opposite their

names:

Sewell L. Avery, 300 W. Adams Street, Chicago, III.

James F. Bell, 200 Chamber of Commerce BIidg., Minneapolis,

Arthur O. Choate, 61 Wall Street, New York, N. V.

J. Frank 3132 Gulf Bidg., Pittsburgh, Pa.

Donald R. , 164 W. Jackson Bivd., Chicago, III.

Richard K. Mellon, The Mellon Natl. Bank, Pittsburgh, Pa.

J. Pierpont Morgan, J. P. Morgan, Inc., 23 Wall Street, New

York, N. Y.

John R. Morron, 25 n New ER N. V.

Alan M. Scaife, Oliver Bldg.,

Alfred P. Sloan, 421 Terz, x. le

Harold S. Vanderbilt, 230 Park Avenue, New York, N. Y.

1 Een Whitney, J. P. Morgan, Inc., 23 Wall Street, New Tork,

8. The individual defendants Louis S. Taylor, George A. Kelly,

and Lowell M. Greenlaw have been and are officers or di-

THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 15

22 reetors of, and have participated in and participate in, the

direction "and management of defendant The Pullman

Company and may be found in the said Pullman Building,

Chicago, Illinois. ‘

9. The individual defendants Charles A. Liddle, Ellis W. Test,

W. N. Barker, H. H. Gilbert, J. A. Knowlton, H. M. Dudley,

Wm. Bierman, R. IL. Gordon, P. G. Jenks, R. 8. Euler, H. 8.

Morgan, C. W. Seabury, and William J. Peters have been and

are officers or directors of, and have participated in, and partic-

ipate in the direction and management of defendant Pullman-

Standard Car Manufacturing Company and may be found in

the said Pullman Building, Chicago, IIlinois, with the exception

of the following individual defendants who are to be found at

the addresses set opposite their names: .

Wm. Bierman, 1402 Gulf Building Pittsburgh, Pa.

R. I. Gordon, 52 Vanderbilt Ave., New York, N. T.

P. G. Jenks, 52 Vanderbilt Ave., New York, N. V.

R. S. Euler, Union Trust Bldg., Pittsburgh, Pa.

H. S. Morgan, 2 Wall Street, New Tork, N. T.

C. W. Seabury, 164 W. Jackson Blvd., Chicago, III.

III

Description or THe Nature or TRADE AND Commerce Invonvep

10. The principal business of Pullman is direction of the affairs

of The Pullman Company, Standard,.and Pullman of Alabama.

Standard is engaged in the business of manufacturing all kinds

of rolling stock. The principal business of Pullman of Alabama

is the ownership of certain manufacturing plants leased to

23 Standard for operation. Through stock ownership Pull-

man controls The Pullman Company, Standard, and Pull-

man of Alabama.

11. Since 1867 The Pullman Company has been engaged in the

business of operating sleeping, parlor, private, and miscellaneous

cars for railroads. In 1881 it commenced the business of manu-

facturing cars of this kind for its own use and other types of

rolling stock for railroads, Prior thereto all of its sleeping cars

had been constructed from existing passenger coaches or had been

built by independent manufacturers. For a considerable time

thereafter the manufacturing and operating businesses of The

Pullman Company were commingled, but some time prior to 1924

these two activities were segregated and conducted as separate

divisions of The Pullman Company. In 1924, the manufacturing

division was incorporated under the laws of the State of Delaware

under the name The Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corporation.

16 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

12. During the first thirty-three years of its existence The

Pullman Company met active competition both in respect to its

enon and in respect to its operating business. By 1900

The Pullman pany had acquired virtually all of its operating

sleeping car services operated by i i railroads. Because

acquisition of its operating competitors in many cases

to The Pullman Com r

cause The Pullman y after 1900 1 to pursue in

2 — field

the manufacturing business of Standard at the present

time is the largest of its kind in the United States. Its annual

aggregate manufacturing capacity has during recent years been

all the railroads in the United States. This capacity

amounts to approximately 113,000 freight cars and to approxi-

mately 3,000 passenger cars. During recent and in fact ever

25 in terms from time to time and from railroad to railroad.

In general, these contracts have provided that the railroad

14. The Pullman Company sells its tickets either through

agencies of its own or by the medium of railroad ticket-selling

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 17

Pullman Company. Under either of the above

of seats, berths, and other and at periodic inter-

vals such financial adjustments as are necessary under the con-

Ratio

a Palen

Pullman Pas- im ag we

2⁰ Year senger-M iles — 1

* (000 omitted) (exclusive of

commutation)

nnr . 14, 006. 8 27, 147.9 61.9

rr 13, 7. 8 25, 001.8 55.5

Fran eee 14.088. 6 24. 206.3 57.9

777 ⁰ AAA Ft A SANA Es 12, 515.4 20, 206.5 61.9

FDD 9, 301.9 14, 915. 4 62.2

. ͤͤ AAA 6, 757.8 12.011.7 6.3

DD 6, 142.0 12, 050. 8 0.9

1 6,891.0 13, 906.6 40. 8

Daerr 7, 146.3 4,301.1 9.7

1 PTS SA ER St OS 8, 354.8 18, 272.1 46.7

cr 9,170.4 20, 578.8 “46

c A 8. 200.9 17, 64.8 4.9

The relations between the gross passenger revenues of The Pull-

man Company and the gross passenger revenues of all railroads in

pee sag State (excluding commutation) in 1938 and 1939 were

as Ws:

Class I railroads: Distribution of raihoay passenger revenue, exclusive of

Commutation, between Coach Traffic and Parlor and Sleeping Car Trafic’

1938

Revenues Percent

ccc $189, 760, 255 45.6

In parlor and cars:

Es a Ä 1 11

— — ae N

226, 651, 504 4. 4

— AAA ———— ˙+—r— ER Tae eT, 416, 411, 750 100.0

18 Tn UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

27 Mass I railroads; Distribution of railway passenger revenue, e-

clusive of Commutation, between

ing Oar Traffic.

1090

Revenues | Percent

SGS²2 ’ $200, 464, 636 46.

In +

M a cl. —

vn 328, 101 wa.

Total. 8 430, 0 737 100. ¢

eg i ne y required railroads to

enter poodle pir yr agreements which ran either for various

stated 0 eis — twenty years to longer or in ty

„ pany and the dependens —

2 nial S wand be omens though at the present

cab Tie eee eee

ined the prod of notice oel by tiv rao the

E bahay: of adhere the railroad that

to operate its own sleeping car service

within the IIe

cellation privilege. No railroad in recent years has ever can -

8 There is another insuperable prac-

tical difficulty which precludes any important railroad from

i apt ed vc aye ban ol anger gab eeds a pt ater r

imposed by the Pullman organization. A substantial part of

sleeping car travel involves the use of connecting carriers. Even

if a railroad could prepare to operate its own sleeping car

28 service, it would be unable to send its sleeping cars over

the lines of connecting carriers with which The Pullman

Company has contracts, or if these Pullman contracts were

abrogated, without then entering into numerous complicated con-

tracts for exchange of cars.

17. All railroads which derive substantial revenues from pas-

senger traffic are now and have been for many years completely

dependent on The Pullman Company for the successful operation

of their passenger business. The Pullman Company has plenary

power to deprive railroads of sleeping car service and to force

undesirable rolling stock and onerous terms on recalcitrant rail-

roads. No railroad of any size can afford to be deprived of Pull-

man service or to be discriminated against by The Pullman Com-

pany in respect to the sleeping car service performed for it. This

THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 19

Iman organizati

red

consequence, the

an organization very sleeping car manu-

factured in the United States since 1900, except the afore-

29 mentioned fifteen. There are a number of manu factur-

ing companies in the United States equipped to manufacture

there is

19. By virtue o the fact that it operates all sleepi cars i

the United States and by virtue of the fact that the railroads

the United States are dependent on Pullman

t of the railroads, the car

general public. By virtue of the facts

ve, The Pullman Company has the power unlawfully

to restrain the character and type Jeeping car service offered

lly exercised such power to

the

724808—47—2

20 THE UNITED STATES V6. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

30 United States car production

Yeu | Pes Sie

—

i

Perr reir

1 SSESESIETE

5 | es- 88 88188813

ts the profitable that becomes. There

F

which have increased the appeal to the public, and safety

of modern passenger rolling stock.

Orrenses CHAN

22. Beginning some time prior to 1900 and continuing from

day to day up to the date of the filing of this complaint, the de-

some time prior to 1900 and continuing from

day to day up to the ing of this complaint, the

conspired with each other to

polized, trade and com-

22 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

chaser of such goods, wares, — — ta 8 —

r iateaean Sadie tin

merchandise, machinery, supplies, and other —

— Sf Lode 9 9 9 tonates of onl inthe

lease, and contract for sale, and each such condition, agreement,

and understanding has been in each instance substantially to

has tended to create a monopoly in the manufacture, sale, and

operation of sleeping cars, parlor cars, other types of rolling

stock and railroad supplies, all in violation of Section 3 of the

Act of October 15, 1914, as amended, commonly known as the

Clayton Act.

V

Tue History or ru Coum NATION

A. CREATION OF THE OPERATING MONOPOLY

27. In 1826 the first regular railroad passenger service was de-

veloped on the Stockton and Darlington Railroad in England.

The first regular railroad service in 0 ion in the

United States was on the Charleston and burg Rail-

34 road in 1830. At first these early railroad cars offered no

sleeping-car service. In 1836 the first sleeping-car service

was offered to the traveling public by the Cumberland Valley

Railroad of Pennsylvania, on its line between Harrisburg and

Chambersburg, Pennsylvania. These early sleeping cars were di-

vided into four compartments. In each compartment there were

three bunks built against one side. In the rear of the car a towel,

basin, and water were provided. During the next ten years, simi-

lar “bunk” cars were built and operated by other railroads.

28. In 1858 Mr, George M. Pullman, a contractor and house-

mover of Chicago, Illinois, arranged with the Chi and Alton

Railroad to remodel two of their day coaches into first Pull-

man sleepers at a cost of from $1,000 to $2,000 per car. In these

first cars Mr. Pullman introduced as an innovation the upper

berth. These first Pullman cars were described by Mr. J. L.

Barnes, the first Pullman conductor, as follows:

“* © * The first Pullman car was a primitive thing. Besides

being lighted with candles it was heated by a stove at each end of

the car. There were no carpets on the floor, and the interior of

the car was arranged in this way: There were four upper and four

lower berths. The backs of the seats were hinged, and to make

up the lower berth the porter merely dropped the back of the

seat until it was level with the seat itself. Upon this he placed a

mattress and blanket. There was no sheets. The upper berth was

suspended from the ceiling of the car by ropes and pulleys

up until it hugged the ceiling, there being

ld it up. At night it was suspended about halfway between

the ceiling of the car and the floor. * * *”

Subsequently a vestibule was added at either end of the Pull-

man car. In all other respects development of the Pullman car

has followed the development of other types of rolling stock.

29. These first two Pullman cars were snecessful and Mr. Pull.

——— ——— i

and Northwestern railroads. In 1867 Mr. Pullman incorporated

his business under the laws of the State of Illinois under the

name of Pullman’s Palace Car Company.

ing

operating their own sleeping car facilities. It early adopted the

policy of stifling competition by acquiring its competitors. Pur-

suant to this

result, by 1900 it had attained a monopoly.

quisitions are shown in the following table: *

z

°

B of New Y:

— et ew York,

S&S SBS 8 S © @ swe @

Pullman Company is set out in Appendix & attached bereto and made T

170

24 THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

31. Although the dates of acquisition of some of the competitor

ies mentioned above are set at subsequent to

sleeping-car companies ) "

1900, actually the controlling stock interest had been acquired

long prior to that date; and in fact the acquisition of the Wagner

Palace Car Company on December 30, 1899, marked the elimination

of the last competitor of The Pullman Company.*

32. With the intent and effect of achieving a in the

operation of sleeping cars on the railroads of the United States,

The Pullman Company the contracts and assets of other

— 5 — facilities of the rail.

roads operating i service. In the acquisition of

37 eee eee Th Pullman Company also ac-

ired the manufacturing facilities which many of its com-

petitor sleeping-car companies possessed, so that prior to 1900

The Pullman e

cars in the United States. In acquiring its competitors The Pull-

man Company paid many millions of dollars more than the value of

the tangible property which it secured. It made these huge addi-

tional itures for the sole purpose of securing the monopo-

listic position which the acquisitions conferred through eliminat-

ing the sellers from the field of manufacturing and operating

sleeping cars. In this way The Pullman Company paid more

than $36,000,000 for the sole purpose of stifling competition. The

exact payments made in the case of fifteen principal acquisitions

are shown in the following table :**

Apportionment of consider-

aM Name of company 1 7 r —

quired cash

Physical | Nonphysical

1. Pacific Car Co 1884 | $1,085,000.00 | $434,020.64 | $000, 979. 96

x Mann’ 8 —— lift ng } 1880 . 788, 0 : 2,670, 914. 66

7 . — 1800 | 36, 667, 401, 96 2 28, 643, 980, 35

. Ohio R R CO 1 Ms | 220, 213. 42

7. e 1 100 754, 787.81 | "674, 787. 81 80, 000. 00

8. 4 N. 31, 056. 48

9 ew 4 R. K. 1902 1111 10, 000. 00

10. — hiccecchovececarasavce 1906 | 1, 558, 225. 00 947, 08 67 710, 388. 33

11. D 1907 | 1,028,000.00| 576, 302. 451, 607. 58

12. Wisconsin D 1. % % 10, 700.00 5, 300. 00

12 ims n e e

16. Southern 2 1882 91, 080. 00 0568.20} ° 81,521.80

al ae TR A RS A LM Sas 50, 548, 142. 21 |14, 430, 147.08 | 96, 117, 905. 13

aaa DIL

> Interstate Commission.

r

Tore 1

1079 reported in 26 Interstate Commerce

THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 25

83. The necessity for expending these millions of dollars in

order to secure monopolistic power was explained by H. J. Eng-

land, an accountant - and executive of The Pullman Company,

when he testified as follows“ with reference to the above-men-

tioned table:

I have included in the exhibit only those companies for which

the accounting records show that the total amount paid at the

time of purchase exceeded the recorded value of the physical prop-

erty acquired. The accounting report of the Commission shows a

list of 49 acquisitions of sleeping-car property. * * * For

this property considerations were paid in cash or in stock amount-

ing to approximately $60,000,000. In the case of the 15 companies

shown in the exhibit * * * the records show that

39 the amounts paid included large sums for this type of in-

tangible or nonphysical property. In those 15 instances

the negotiations between the officers of the purchasing and selling

companies resulted in an agreement to pay more than the bare

value of the property * * * because the selling companies

the contracts to operate cars or were themselves operat-

such cars. * * * The total cost of such intangible prop-

erty so purchased, paid for in cash or in stock, amounted to

$36,117,995.13 as shown in the schedule.”

34. Pursuant to its plan to monopolize the operation of rail-

road sleeping cars its attempt to exact monopolistic, non-

competitive, and unreasonable rates for the carriage of passengers

in sleeping cars, The Pullman Company attempted to have these

thirty-six millions of dollars which it had paid for its monopolistic

position included in the value of its property for ra‘e-making pur-

poses. Accordingly, The Pullman Company introduced the

above-mentioned table into evidence at the hearing before the

Interstate Commerce Commission and endeavored to secure the

consent of the Commission to this inflated value. The Commis-

sion refused to permit The Pullman Company to include this sum

in its valuation for rate-making purposes because it found that

this money had been unlawfully expended by The Pullman Com-

pany to acquire a monopoly of the business of supplying sleeping

cars. In re this contention of The Pullman Company, the

Commission as follows:

In support of its contention for the inclusion of the

40 636,117,995. 13, the carrier introduced an exhibit with sup-

porting testimony showing the costs incurred by it in ac-

quiring the sleeping-car properties and business of 5 predecessor

and 10 railroad companies, for which the accounting records show

“Testifying in 1928 on behalf of The Pullman Company before the Interstate Com-

\

26 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

that the total consideration paid exceeded the recorded appraised

value of the physical property purchased. The exhibit contains

the names of these predecessors and railroad companies, the dates

the properties were purchased, the total consideration in cash or

stock paid for each, and an apportionment of the consideration as

to physical and nonphysical properties. A total consideration

of $50,548,142.21 in cash and securities was paid for the cars and

other properties of these companies, and at the time

of purchase eee

the carrier at 814,430, 147.08. That amount was recorded in

investment accounts as cost; thereof. The remaining costs,

gregating $36,117,995.13, the arrier charged to its income or

and loss accounts.

The carrier’s witness stated that the building of a unified or-

ganization and service nation-wide in extent involved the acquisi-

tion by the carrier of the property and business of predecessor

companies, of sleeping-car property from railroads and others,

and the steady and persistent establishment of the company on

new lines of railroads; that in doing that it was necessary, in a

large number of cases, to pa amounts in excess of the value of

the physical properties involved; and that these amounts con-

stitute the original cost of the intangible values and ele-

ments of value purchased from predecessors and others.

41 It appears, therefore, that these excess expenditures were

not for the creation of common carrier property or for the

installation of new property in transportation service, but for

the purpose of eliminating competition and building up an or-

ganization having virtually a monopoly of the sleeping-car busi-

ness. This item was properly omitted from the statement of

original cost to date,

35. The intent of The Pullman Company to secure a monopoly

in the business of operating sleeping cars on the railroads of the

United States and its success in doing so were described by the

said H. J. England as follows:

“In the early history of the company, competition was very

keen. The New York Central Sleeping Car Company was incor-

porated in 1865, prior to the incorporation of Pullman’s Palace

Car Company. The Gates Sleeping Car Company was merged

with the New York Central Sleeping Car Company in 1869. These

companies were the predecessors of the Wagner Palace Car Com-

pany, incorporated in 1886, as shown in the chapter on corporate

in the tentative report.

*Testimony of H. J. an accountant and executive of The Pullman Com-

before the Intersta’ Copatestgn ta Vat tion Docket No. 1079

Reported in 86 Interstate aluation B45 et seq.

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 27

“There were a number of other sleeping-car companies in the

early years of the history of the business, many of which had been

acquired by Pullman’s Palace Car Company prior to the

acquisition of the Wagner Company. These included the

Central Transportation y, bringing contracts with

18 roads to the Pullman System; s Boudoir Car Company,

Woodruff Sleeping & Parlor Coach Company, and Union Palace

Car Company, these three companies operating over 14 railroads;

Pullman Southern Car Company, for which there had been several

predecessor companies covering sleeping-car operations in the

south; Pullman Pacific Car Company; Erie & Atlantic Sleeping

Coach Company ; and others, as shown in the chapter on corporate

history in the tentative valuation.

“The largest acquisition of sleeping-car properties purchased

from other companies by The Pullman Company, was Wagner

Palace Car Company which operated over 30 different railroads.

When the Wagner Company was purchased in 1899, the name of

Pullman’s Palace Car Company was changed to The Pullman

Company.

* 0 * * * *

“In the early days of the sleeping-car business, a number of

railroads owned and operated their own sleeping cars. Sleeping

cars were also operated jointly with the railroads, that is, an

association was formed, The Pullman Company and a railroad

company each owning an interest in the equipment, the earnings

of an association being divided between the Pullman Company

and the railroad company on the basis of their relative invest-

ments. Among the roads having association interests with The

Pullman Company for the operation of sleeping cars, were

43 the Baltimore & Ohio, Santa Fe, Union Pacific, Southern

Pacific, Missouri Pacific, Illinois Central, Atlantic Coast

Line, and others.

“On valuation date, practically all of the sleeping car business

had been taken over by The Pullman Company. At that time the

only large roads owning and conducting their own sleeping car

service were the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul, the Great North-

ern, and in Canada, the Canadian Pacific and part of the Grand

Trunk System.

“In the 52 years from its incorporation to date of valuation,

the Company had grown from a small corporation with only the

operating contracts with three or four railroads taken over from

Mr. Pullman, to a nation-wide system on all the principal roads

in the United States. It had developed a system for handling

more than 7,000 cars over more than 1,400 sleeping-car lines, fur-

28 run UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

contrnets by direct negotiation vith eee it had soquired

sleeping parlor car properties from 49 other companies, prin-

cipally to obtain the contracts for operation over the roads con-

trolled by such other companies so as to furnish to the

44 public uninterrupted through service, and thus to advance

to the position of unified control which it possessed at June

30, 1919.

*

* * 7 *

„ The nature of the costs I have reference to, are the

considerations, over and above the recorded value of the physical

property, given by The Pullman Company, consisting of cash,

cash and securities, bonds and capital stock, at the time the various

properties were acquired. In the various purchases of these prop-

erties, the company paid out large sums, not alone to obtain physi-

cal property, but for Nee — property, to acquire the organiza-

tion, system and trained of the other companies, and the

opportunities to operate its sleeping and parlor cars over the vari-

ous lines of railroads. Through making these expenditures the

company was able to establish a unified organization which enabled

it to utilize the cars purchased and those constructed for its use,

and to make those contract arrangements through which the sleep-

ing and parlor car facilities over each road became an integral

part of the entire system. Such expenditures reflect amounts actu-

ally paid to secure the opportunities to get railroad contracts, and

to furnish sleeping car service to the public over the railroads in-

volved in from other companies, They were essential

to the t of the Company’s ability, which it had on

valuation date, to obtain and renew contracts.

“It is important, in endeavoring to measure the intangible value

of properties, to consider the amount expended by the Company

for those elements of value.

45 5 Pullman Company's ability, which it possessed at

valuation date, to obtain, hold, and renew contract arrange-

ments with the railroads, was very largely facilitated by the fact

that it had a unified organization and service, ‘nation-wide in

extent. This system had been built up through the efforts of the

company over a period of 50 years. At date of valuation, a

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 29

railroad company not using Pullman service was the exception ;

it stood apart from the one large organization which could fur-

nish such service for the railroads and for the public more com-

pletely and effectively than could be done under separate railroad

“It will, therefore, be seen that the buildi

reer Sng am it was necessary, in a

large number of cases, in acquiring the property of predecessor

companies and others, to pay an amount in excess of the value of

the physical properties involved, and this excess, that is the differ-

ence between the value of the physical properties and the total

payments made, constitute the original cost of the values and

elements of value purchased from predecessor or other com-

panies.

* * 0 P —

The map, Exhibit No. 26, shows the trackage covered by sleep-

ing-car lines of the Wagner Company which were acquired

46 by The Pullman Company as of Jan 1, 1900. This

map shows the important position which the Wagner Com-

pany had right in the heart of the Pullman territory. It reached

from the northeast section of the country, covering the New York

Central Lines, to Chicago all over the north central States, reach-

ing as far in the northwest as South Dakota, and covering the

southwest over the Missouri, Kansas & Texas down to the Gulf

of Mexico. This map gives a vivid illustration of the competition

between the two companies and the importance to The Pullman

Company of the acquisition of the Wagner Company with its

contracts with 30 railroads which it held at the time of the pur-

chase, December 30, 1899.

“The Wagner Company at that time had the equivalent of about

one: third of the volume of business of The Pullman Compo ny, and

situated as it was, it is easy to see that without that purchase, it

would have taken The Pullman Company a great deal longer to

have acquired the contracts and to have assembled its business

as it existed at valuation date, and would also have required

greater expenditures on the part of The Pullman Company.

Without that acquisition, The Pullman Company never would

have had the business structure which it did have at date of valu-

ation. Its purchase was the most constructive step in the develop-

ment of the unified system in the entire history of the sleeping-

car business.”

37. In accordance with the intent of its creators, the plan

to monopolize the operation of sleeping cars over the railroads

of the United States when effected proved highly profitable.

During the period from 1868 to 1919 The Compan

to 8% and deposit the remainder of its earnings in a surplus

account until aggregate earnings become sufficient to pay an an-

nual dividend of 8% upon both capital and surplus. There-

upon stock dividends are issued to the extent of the

48 surplus, which is transferred to the capital account. As

a consequence, the earnings of The Pullman Company

during this period were much larger than the consistent pay-

ment of an annual dividend of 8% would indicate.*

B. THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE UNLAWFUL MANUFACTURING COM-

BINATION AND THE ATTEMPT TO CREATE A MANUFACTURING

MONOPOLY

38. The Pullman organization really started when Mr. George

„57 ˙ lan ate

aacTs high profits which The Pullman

2

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 31

The emphasis was soon shifted from the reconstruction of coaches

into sleeping cars to the operation of the latter. In the be-

ee oe cecal n

sleeping cars. In 1881 Mr. George

ta tract of land on the prairie near Lake

Fitna bg arg age built a large car-manufacturing

plant. r plete later terme the tows of Pollina: Tiiineis

At the same time r shops previously located in St. Louis,

Detroit, Elmira, and Wilmington were consolidated, and the car-

building business became important. Then it was »

49 common practice of railroads to produce most of their

own rolling stock, either directly or subsidiary or

affiliated corporations. During this period the organ-

ization used most of the cars which it built, and it was not until

the introduction of steel cars early in the present century that The

Pullman Company commenced to uce substantial quantities

of rolling stock for sale to rai As early as 1894 Andrew

Carnegie had constructed steel freight cars for use in his manu-

facturing plants and about 1900 the manufacture of freight cars

with all-steel under frames and underbodies was commenced on

a large scale. Impetus was given to the use of steel passenger

cars in 1908 when the tunnel under the Hudson River was com-

pleted, because the Pennsylvania Railroad Company, which con-

trolled the Hudson Tunnel, refused to permit wooden cars to

use the tunnel on account of the fire hazard. In the same year

The Pullman Company made its first all-steel sleeper and thence-

forth concentrated on steel construction, retaining, however, wood

interiors. By 1914 transformation to all-steel construction was

complete. Thereafter the defendants with the intent to mono-

polize and in an attempt to monopolize the business of manu-

facturing rolling stock embarked upon a program of iri

manufacturing competitors. Pursuant to this policy The Pull-

man Company, through unlawful exercise of its monopolistic

power, has systematically acquired competing car-building com-

panies and closed up these facilities insofar as they competed with

the car-building facilities of The Pullman Company.

50 (1) Acquisition of Haskell and Barker

39. In 1921 The Pullman Company entered into an

agreement consummated in 1922, whereby it ired the phy-

sical property and all corporate assets of & Barker Car

rr

manufacturers then in existence. The manufacturing plant of

Sedat & Basher —— — Gan tha eae

32 rut UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

(2) Miscellaneous Acquisitions of Manufacturing Competitors

40. In 1927 Pullman ired the Dickson Car Wheel Company

of Houston, Texas. Du the same year

poration, the New Orleans

The intent and effect of the

and the formation of the new subsidiary, New Orleans

Car Company, Inc., was the acquisition of a monopoly of

car building facilities in the Houston and New Orleans dis-

51 41. Since long prior to 1929, Pullman has had a sub-

r

common stock of the General Steel Castings Corporation,

Pullman exercises control of that organization.** The General

Steel Castings Corporation occupies a commanding strategic

Alabama,

laid plans for the completion of a modern car-building plant to

monopolize the car-building industry in the Birmingham, Ala-

bama, district.

(3) Acquisition of Osgood Bradley Car Company and Standard

Steel Car Company and Subsidiaries

TH 0 UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 33

of the Osgood Bradley Car Company and the Standard Steel Car

Company and its subsidiaries. Acquisition of the assets of

52 these corporations was completed on March 1, 1930. This

was the last in a series which gave defendants

the dominant position in the manufacture of rolling stock in the

United States. In 1930 Pullman exercised its power through con-

trol of corporations having the following total productive

capacity :

44. At the present time the total productive capacity of Pull-

man is substantially the same as set forth in paragraph 43 above,

with the exception of certain manufacturing plants which have

been abandoned by the Pullman organization.

C. MONOPOLISTIC POWER OF THE DEFENDANTS

53 45. In attaining the monopoly of the operating business

through acquiring competitors and in other ways, it was the

purpose of defendants and their predecessors to use the monopolis-

tic power thus unlawfully attained to achieve monopolistic profits

by ing railroads to agree to noncompetitive

terms in their operating contracts and by exacting from the travel-

ing public noncompetitive and unreasonably high prices for the

34 THE UNITED STATES V8. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

services performed by The Pullman Company and the merchandise

in f sleeping cars, parlor cars, dining

cars, and similar types of rolling stock and dominate the business

of manufacturing all types of rolling stock. For many

54 pears defendants have used and now continue to use their

monopolistic power unreasonably to restain the trade of all

the principal railroads of the United Sates, of manufacturers of

rolling stock in the United States, and of the many millions of

people who annually purchase transportation service from defend-

ants.

D. CORPORATE HISTORY OF THE COMBINATION AND MONOPOLY

46. Prior to 1924 the corporat® structure of the Pullman organi-

zation was a simple one consisting of a single corporate entity

first incorporated in 1867 under the laws of the State of Illinois

as Pullman’s Palace Car Company, which name was changed to

The Pullman Company in 1899, all as related in paragraph 3. All

acquisitions of property and assets prior to 1924, i ing the

acquisition of the various operating competitors of The

Company prior to 1900 as described in paragraph 30 and the ac-

quisition of Haskell and Barker Car Company, Inc., in 1922 as

described in paragraph 39, were made in the name of The Pullman

Company.

47. In 1924 The Pullman Company was as to the operation of

sleeping-car and similar services a common carrier by virtue of

express provisions of statutes of the United States. The Pullman

Company also had a manufacturing division, called by it the

manufacturing department, whose business among other items

consisted in supplying all sleeping cars to The Pullman Company

which were owned and used by it. In its operating business The

Pullman Company took such equipment as it required from

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 35

55 its department into its y accounts at

the billed, including therein costs as materials,

labor, and overhead, plus 10% profit on the foregoing ag-

costs in addition to such return as the item

micht include. Upon the San Chacon ter

— connor

ceeding to determine the valuation of the operating assets of

Pullman Com for rate-making purposes known as Valuation

Docket 1079, finally submitted after hearings in 1928, and finally

determined in 1931, and reported in 36 Interstate Commerce Com-

mission Valuation Reports, 845 et seg., The Pullman Company

endeavored to establish a valuation from which the fares

the traveling public would be figured which would reflect

figure of cost plus 10% profit on the basis described above. The

Interstate Commerce Commission refused to allow the 10% adui-

tional profit claimed by The Pullman Company as a part of the

valuation of its operating assets for the period during which The

Pullman Company was a single corporate entity.

48. In 1924, anticipating an unfavorable decision from the In-

terstate Commerce Commission on its claim of the additional 10%

profit above described, The Pullman Company’ with unlawful de-

sign to secure further monopolistic profits, determined to create

& separate corporate entity to take over the manufacturing de-

partment and the noncarrier assets of The Pullman

56 = pany. In 1924, The Pullman Company caused to be incor-

porated under the laws of the State of Illinois, a corporation

known as Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corporation, whose capi-

tal stock was entirely owned by The Pullman Company. To this

newly created corporation The Pullman Company then trans-

ferred the manufacturing department and all the noncarrier assets

of The Pullman Company. This plan was brought to the atten-

tion of the Illinois Commerce Commission in a proceeding in 1924,

although the jurisdiction of that commission was not properly

invoked, and it was not necessary to any such proceeding

before the commission. Thereafter The Company in-

cluded in its investment account in carrier property the additional

10% profits by virtue of a contract to that effect between The

Pullman Company and Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corpora-

tion. Between 1924 and 1927 The Pullman Company operated

in this manner, owning all the capital stock of this newly created

corperation as heretofore set forth. These various corporate

changes were undertaken by defendants and their predecessors

724808—47-—-8

36 $$ THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

to avoid regulation by any State or Federal authority having con-

trol of the common carrier activities of The Pullman Company.

49. Further pursuant to the aforesaid unlawful plan, in 1927

The Pullman Company caused to be incorporated a new corpora-

din Guide the later dl the Bate 48 Delovare tnawe a9 Pullman

Incorporated as related in Paragraph 5. The accompanying cor-

porate transactions are concisely described in the following

excerpts submitted by Pullman to the Securities and Ex-

57 change Commission in Pullman’s anual report filed for the

year ended December 31, 1935, in which it is stated

“Pullman Incorporated, the registrant, was organized under the

laws of the State of Delaware on June 21, 1927, with authorized

capital stock of 3,375,000 shares, without nominal or value,

pursuant to a plan of reorganization offered to ders of

The Pullman Company by its directors, and accepted by the stock-

holders at a meeting held July 12, 1927. Prior to such reorganiza-

tion, The Pullman Company, an Illinois corporation, engaged in

the sleeping-car business, was the owner of all the capital stock

of Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corporation, an Illinois cor-

poration, and of other miscellaneous assets not requisite or used

in the carrier business of The Pullman Company. The plan of

reorganization contemplated (1) the formation of a new company

(the registrant), which should own directly the capital stock of

The Pullman Company and of Pullman Car & Manufacturing

Corporation ; (2) that each stockholder of The Pullman Company,

upon consummation of the plan, should receive two and one-half

shares in the new company in place of each share formerly owned

by him in The Pullman Company; (3) that the existing pro rata

interest of each stockholder in all assets of The Pullman Com-

pany would be preserved; and (4) that, upon completion of the

plan, The Pullman Company would be divested of the property

and assets not requisite to or used by it in its sleeping-car business.”

“Pursuant to the plan and for the purpose of determining

58 the pro rata interests of stockholders in assets of The Pull-

man Company, an appraisal was made of all the property

and assets owned by The Pullman Company at the time of the pro-

posed reorganization. On the basis of such appraisals, and as the

next step in the plan, The Pullman Company transferred to regis-

trant all of the capital stock of Pullman Car & Manufacturing Cor-

poration in exchange for 675,000 shares (being one-fifth) of the

authorized capital stoock of registrant, the shares of registrant so

received being distributed by The Pullman Company to its stock-

— *

t’s stock to the holder of each share of stock of The Pullman

poet ey Thereupon, as the next step in the plan, the capital

THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 37

stock of The Pullman Company was surrendered by its stock-

holders through depositaries to registrant in exchange for shares

of capital stock of registrant on the basis of two for one. Thereby,

upon completion of these steps, each participating stockholder

received the contemplated two and one-half shares of Pullman

Incorporated stock in place of each share of stock of The Pullman

Company theretofore held by him, and the other purposes of the

as above enumerated, were accomplished.

certificate of incorporation of the company (the registrant)

provides that shares of its capital stock may be issued by the

company from time to time for such consideration and upon such

terms as may be fixed from time to time by the Board of Directors.

In acquiring the capital stock of Pullman Car & Manufacturing

Corporation by issuing in exchange 675,000 shares of its

59 capital stock, the directors set a value thereon, being the

net worth of the Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corpora-

tion after adjusting the book value of its assets to an appraisal

thereof made as of April 30, 1927. In acquiring the capital stock

of The Pullman Company by issuing in exchange therefor its

shares on the basis of two shares of stock of the company for each

share of stock of The Pullman Company, the Board of Directors

set a value on the capital stock of The Pullman Company, pred-

icated on an appraisal of the assets of The Pullman Company as

at April 30, 1927, which represented a valuation in excess of its

book value or net worth of $56,117 ,366.56. This appraisal and the

write-up of its assets are not given effect to or recorded on the

books of The Pullman Company as its books are kept in accord-

ance with accounting requirements of the Interstate Commerce

Commission which do not permit a carrier to give effect on its

books to a write-up of its assets.”

50. Thereupon and in 1927 as described in the preceding para-

graphs, Pullman became the holding company and Pullman Car

& Manufacturing Corporation became a wholly owned subsidiary

of Pullman. Pursuant to the exchange plans set forth Above,

The Pullman Company became a subsidiary of Pullman, the stock

of which was turned in from time to time in exchange for stock

of Pullman as described above, so that at the present time the

capital stock of The Pullman Company is more than 99.99% owned

by Pullman.

51. After 1927 Pullman acquired the assets of the Osgood Brad-

ley Car Company and The Standard Steel Car Company

60 and its subsidiaries as described in paragraph 43, which,

pursuant to the unlawful design of the defendants, were

transferred to a newly created corporation organized under the

laws of the State of Pennsylvania and known as The Standard

38 j#$ THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

Steel Car Corporation of Pennsylvania. In 1930 the Standard

Steel Car Corporation of Pennsylvania was incorporated under the

laws of Pennsylvania to acquire all of the physical plants and prop-

erties of the Osgood Bradley Car Company and of Standard Steel

Car Com and certain of its subsidiaries and the capital stock

of the wn Car Company, together with the receivables

and inventories of the above companies. The Standard Steel Car

Corporation of Delaware was incorporated in 1931, under the

rE eee eee

man Incorporated to acquire Pullman Incorporated the capi-

tal stock of the Standard Steel Car Corporation of Pennsylvania

in exchange for the Standard of Delaware stock and to acquire

also the stock of the subsidiary companies and certain of the

manufacturing properties of Standard of Pennsylvania. Sub-

sequently, Standard of Delaware acquired certain assets of the

Steel Car Forge Corporation which, in turn, after transferring

the balance of its assets to the Standard Steel Car Corporation

of Pennsylvania, was dissolved. As of the end of 1934, all of

the stock in the following companies was directly owned by the

Standard Steel Car Corporation of Delaware:

“Standard Steel Car Corporation, Pennsylvania, with plants

at Butler and Elwood City, Pennsylvania, having an annual capac-

ity of 22,500 freight cars and 30,000 tons of forgings.

61 “Richmond Car Corporation of Richmond, Virginia,

having a plant with an annual capacity of 3,600 freight

cars.

“Pullman-Bradley Car Corporation, formerly the Osgood Brad-

ley Car Corporation, of Worcester, Massachusetts, with plants at

Worcester and Sagamore, Massachusetts, having an annual ca-

pacity of 6,000 freight cars and 300 passenger cars.

“Lyndora Land and Improvement Company of Butler, Penn-

sylvania, which owns apartment and tenement houses, miscel-

laneous buildings, and real estate in Hammond, Indiana, and

Butlef, Pennsylvania.”

The transactions by which the domestic properties carried by The

Pullman Car & ufacturing Corporation and The Standard

Steel Car Corporation of Pennsylvania were transferred to the

ownership of a new corporation, defendant Pullman- Standard Car

Manufacturing Company, organized in 1934 under the laws of

the State of Delaware, a wholly owned subsidiary of Pullman,

were in fact as they were described by Pullman in its annual re-

port for the year ended December 31, 1935, to the Securities and

Exchange Commission as follows:

“On February 18, 1930, Pullman Incorporated entered into

agreements with Standard Steel Car Company and Osgood Brad-

eee

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 39

ley Car Company, whereby it acquired substantially all of the

fixed properties and net current assets of these companies in ex-

change for shares of stock of Pullman Incorporated and cash.

The value of the property so acquired, for which shares,

62 in part, were issued therefor at a value per share predicated

on an appraisal made of these properties at the time. By

authority of the Board of Directors February 19, 1930, a new

corporation was formed for the purpose of acquiring and operat-

ing said properties. The Standard Steel Car Corporation of

Pennsylvania was then organized, with an authorized capital stock

of $1,000,000 (par value), which was issued to Pullman Incor-

porated in exchange for the properties, The books of this com-

pany then reflected the value of its assets based on the said ap-

praisal, with a net worth of $57,332,338.88. Subsequently various

moves were made in segregating and/or merging the properties

carried by the Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corporation and

Standard Steel Car Corporation of Pennsylvania without any

change in property values. This group now consists of the fol-

lowing companies :

“Pullman-Standard Car Manufacturing Company.

“Pullman Standard Car Export Corporation.

“Pullman Car & Manufacturing Corporation of Alabama.”

52. Pursuant to their unlawful design, defendants by the vari-

ous corporate moves and transfers described above consolidated all

the assets of the combination and monopoly into a unified corpo-

rate structure headed by Pullman as the holding and management

company, and consisting primarily of The Pullman Company as

operating subsidiary and Pullman-Standard Car Manufacturing

Company as the manufacturing subsidiary.

63 VI

Means aNp Mernops

53. In addition to the various means and methods for consum-

mating the offenses charged which have been referred to above in

describing the growth of the monopolistic power of this combina-

tion, various other methods and means for consummating the of-

fenses charged have been resorted to by the defendants from time

to time. The defendants have consummated the offenses charged

by the following means and methods among others:

(1) Creating and maintaining by unlawful combination and

conspiracy a monopoly in the operation of sleeping-car facilities

over the railroads of the United States.

(2) Stifling competition in the operation of sleeping-car equip-

ment by (a) driving competitors out of business, (b) acquiring

40 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

competitors, (c) coercing railroads into signing operating con

tracts and (% foreing railroads to deal exclusively with de

(3) 0 Fising and exacting arbitrary, noncompetitive, unreason-

able, and unlewiul prices end terms for the operation of sleeping-

car services.

(4) Fixing and maintaining among themselves and with others

artificial, arbitrary, noncompetitive, and unreasonable prices and

terms to be exacted for rolling stock, and allocating the customers

to whom it would be sold.

(5) Arbitrarily and unlawfully limiting and restricting the

production of sleeping, parlor, and dining-car equipment, and

other types of rolling

64 (6) Unlawfully suppressing the development of more

efficient, safer, and more comfortable sleeping-car equip-

ment than that owned and operated by The Pullman Company by

coercing railroads into refusing to deal with any operator or manu-

facturer of sleeping-car equipment except the defendants.

(7) Unlawfully bringing pressure to bear upon railroads and

manufacturers of rolling stock and railroad ‘supplies through

interlocking directorates and financial control, and in other ways.

(8) Discriminating between railroads in the terms for operat-

ing sleeping cars and other types of rolling stock.

(9) Exacting unreasonably high and monopolistic profits.

A. THE CONTRACT STRUCTURE

54. Prior to the attainment by defendants of the combined

monopolistic control above described and while competition still

existed between defendants and others in furnishing and operat-

ing sleeping-car service on railroads, competitive rates to the

public and competitive prices to the railroads for the furnish-

ing of such service were in effect and the terms and conditions

of the Pullman contracts as a result of such competition were far

more favorable to the railroads than at the present time. The fares

charged the general public for sleeping-car service while these

competitive conditions prevailed were lower both absolutely and

relatively than Pullman fares have been since the attainment of

the complete Pullman operating monopoly. Since the at-

66 tainment of this monopolistic control, defendants have dic-

tated the contractional terms and conditions upon which

they furnish reserved cars and reserved-car service to the railroads.

55. In the exercise of this monopolistic power, defendants have

through the years negotiated individual contracts with all those

railroads in the United States engaged to any substantial degree

in the transportation of passengers in interstate commerce. While

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 41

the negotiating of such contracts has been on an individual basis,

defendants have carefully and dictated the pattern,

principles, and relationship of such individual contracts so as

to develop and maintain a unified contract structure constantly

subject to their control and effectively adapted to the mainte-

nance of the monopolies and to the perpetuation of the restraints

and other violations of law herein complained of.

56. Defendants have dictated the terms and conditions of the

contracts making up this unified contract structure by bringing

the full force of their bargaining power to bear upon the rail-

roads, by discriminating between railroads, by threatening the

cancellation of such contracts pursuant to cancellation clauses con-

tained therein, by threatening the withdrawal of sleeping-car

service from the railroads, and by actually cancelling such con-

tracts and thus forcing railroads to agree to the terms and con-

ditions of new contracts to avoid complete elimination of first-

class passenger transportation over their lines. As a practical

matter the carriers’ ability to cancel under the provisions of any

contract providing for cancellation is nonexistent because in

order to maintain its properties, good will, and freight

66 traffic, a railroad must have sleeping-car service and only the

Pullman operating monopoly offers such service at the

present time. No important carrier or carrier system has ever

cancelled a Pullman contract and, on many occasions, The Pullman

Company by threats of cancellation, by cancellation, and by other

devices, has forced the carriers to accept contracts containing

onerous and restrictive provisions harmful to the railroads and

the public, but beneficial to defendants.

57. At the present time, defendants, through their instrumen-

tality, The Pullman Company, have in effect contractual operating

agreements with the particular railroads listed below:

Railways and mileage over which The Pullman Company operated on

June 1, 1940

Name of railway Name of railway

rr

int | i

— Topeka & Santa Fe

Pe —p

—

3

ow

py

Pr

42 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

Rathoays and mileage over which The Pullman Oompany operated on

June 1, 1940—Continued.

Mileage Mileage

Name of railroad — Name of railroad operated

4 Southern, Inc., FT. W. 4 67 National of Mexico... 2,000

. 02 24. —. ortheastern . . 22

n a New York Central Lines 5, 693

114 New York, C & St. Louis... 42

— 14 — 8 974 || New York, New Haven & Hartford 630

ver & Salt wae 232 || Norfolk & Western 1, Bo

3 —~"\e ae 18 Northern Paci et

7 2 i

iat tn... | ‘i Richmond, Fredericksburg & Po-

Grand 9 12 tomac...... ven T 117

Guat Const a, N. o., Tex. & Mex. 766 Saat inn „ . 2, 256

Illinois — on 3,200 || Southern Rů rr 3, 308

North nn 965 || Southern Pacific Gystan 8, 911

1—— $00 || Spokane, Portland & Seattle.........

A eee Francisoo. 2 6

Louisville, Henderson & St. Louis 137 St. Louis, Southwestern System...... 812

Sey tetas Wien 2. 446 || Tennessee Centraal 166

33 IS 649 || Texas & Pacific. e 1, 138

~~ eo St. Pan & Saule Ste 1% || Toronto, Hamilton & Bun 38

Missouri-Kansas-Texas............ 1,740 ba Pacific Gem 4, 660

——— 4 1% Webs 1, 408

obe & Olo n Western Pacific............-.-.------ 92¹

Nashville, Chatanooga & St. Louis 525 || Yosemite Valleyhyh‚‚h 78

58. With practically all of the foregoing railroads The Pull-

man Company has in effect written principal operating agree-

ments and with practically all of them hes in effect written

supplemental agreements, hereinafter described, covering air con-

ditioning of reserved cars and other particular phases of the

contractual relationships. In a few instances, the contractual

relationships covering particular phases are contained in oral

contracts.

59. Although the operating agreements vary considerably in

detail they have certain general characteristics in common. These

contracts usually provide that The Pullman Company will furnish

sleeping cars and parlor cars for operation on lines of the rail-

road, that the railroad will receive all of the revenues from

passenger fares and that The Pullman Company will receive its

revenues from the sale of seats, berths, and other accommodations.

The number of sleeping cars and parlor cars to be furnished by

The Pullman Company is in some instances determined by mutual

agreement between The Pullman Company and the rail-

68 road, while in other instances The Pullman Company re-

serves to itself the right to determine the number of cars

to be furnished to the railroad. The Pullman Company assumes

the expense of shop and running repairs to the cars, and the cost

of supplies, and furnishes attendants to wait on the passengers,

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 43

while the railroad furnishes the same facilities it would for its

own first-class coaches for which Pullman cars are substituted,

such as water and ice, heating and lighting the cars, and cleaning

the outside of the cars. If the Pullman service on a particular

railroad does not earn a stipulated minimum amount, the railroad

must pay The Pullman Company the deficiency. If the Pullman

service earns an amount sufficient to reimburse The Pullman Com-

pany for all expenses and to insure it a profit, then The Pullman

Company will give the railroad a portion of the earnings over

that amount.

60. Section 6 (5) of the Interstate Commerce Act, Part I (Act

of February 4, 1887, c. 104, 24 Stat. 379, as amended, 49 U. S. C.

§6 (5)), provides that every common carrier shall file with the

Commission copies of all contracts, agreements, or arrangements

with other common carriers in relation to any traffic affected by

the provisions of the Act to which it may be a party, and Section

16 (13) of the said Act provides that copies of all such contracts,

agreements, and arrangements between common carriers filed

with the Commission, as provided in Section 6 (5), shall be pre-

served as public records in the custody of the we a of the

Commission, and shall be received as prima facie evidence of

what they purport to be in all judicial proceedings,

69 and copies or excerpts from any of said contracts, agree-

ments, or arrangements certified by the Secretary under

the Commission’s seal shall be received in evidence with like effect

as the originals.

61. Pursuant to the provisions of Section 6 (5) of the said Act,

defendants, through their instrumentality, The Pullman Com-

pany, have filed with the said Commission copies of the written

principal operating agreements in effect with the railroads above

listed, with the exception of the principal operating agreements

with the following railroads:

Alabama Great Southern.

Atlanta and West Point and Western Railway of Alabama.

Atlanta, Birmingham and Coast.

Atlantic Coast Line.

Cincinnati, New Orleans and Texas Pacific,

Detroit and Mackinac.

Georgia, Southern and Florida.

Louisiana and Arkansas.

Nashville, Chattanooga and St. Louis.

National Railways of Mexico.

New Orleans and Northeastern.

Richmond, Fredericksburg and Potomac.

Tennessee Central.

44 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

Photostatic copies of such principal operating agreements certi-

fied by the Secretary of the Commission under the Commission’s

seal (attached hereto as Appendix D, exhibits 1 to 54, inclusive)

are attached hereto and made a part hereof with the same force

and effect as though set out and alleged herein. The supple-

70 mentary air-conditioning agreements have also been filed

with the said Commission by the Pullman Company in

accordance with Section 6 (5) of said Act.

62. Defendants, in violation of Section 6 (5) of said Act, with

the express intent and purpose of perpetuating their monopolies

and restraints, as aforesaid, and for the express purpose of per-

unjust and unreasonable discriminations between rail-

roads, have failed to file with the said Commission copies of many

supplemental agreements, some written and some oral, which

have been, or are at the present time, in effect between The Pull-

man Company and said railroads.

63. The defendants, by placing restrictions upon the use of

coach sleepers in order to maintain unreasonable prices and exact

unreasonable profits, have impeded railroads in their attempts

to restore earning power to light earning lines.

B. PRICE CONTROL

64. Since the acquisition, extension, and maintenance of the

monopolistic power as described above, defendants have possessed

and exercised and continue to possess and exercise the power to

fix and adopt arbitrary, discriminatory, noncompetitive, oppres-

sive, and unreasonable prices for the furnishing to railroads of

sleeping cars, parlor cars, and other reserved cars, and for the

operation of such transportation services for railroads.

65. Defendants and the railroads with whom they negotiate

contracts are engaged in furnishing a joint transportation service

to the public, and therefore if the business relationships between

them were affected by normal competitive conditions de-

71 fendants would share with the railroads the risks of profit

and loss normally y incident to quch a joint enterprise. In

fact, defendants have held themselves out to the contracting rail-

roads as being engaged with such railroads in a “partnership

enterprise.” Nevertheless, defendants, since attaining the con-

solidated monopolistic position above described, have, in their

dealings and negotiations with the contracting railroads, pursued

a calculated and deliberate policy designed and intended by the

defendants to develop and continue a contract structure which

the defendants from all risk of financial loss from the

joint enterprise and casts the total risk thereof upon the con-

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 45

tracting railroads. In this way defendants have secured monop-

olist ie profits.

66. The contractua: provisions, devices, and formulae by which

defendants have effectuated such purpose and design have varied

with different contracting railroads, and from year to year, as the

exigencies of the operation of the policy above described have

demanded, but whether it has been the car-mileage-payment plan,

the flat deficiency guarantee plan, the guaranty of net operating

expenses plus an initial return, or other plan, heretofore or now

employed by the defendants, the purpose and result has been the

same, and the policy above described has thereby been successfully

effectuated. ‘This contractual policy, persistently pursued, has

been an important factor in enabling defendants to develop an

insignificant initial investment into an enterprise now capitalized

ut approximately $225,000,000 and to pay over one-half billion

dollars in dividends.

72 67. The defendants, through their instrumentality, The

Pullman Company, are at the present time engaged in

negotiating contracts with various railroads whose contracts have

expired, and are demanding and ‘insisting upon terms and con-

ditions in such contracts which in purpose and effect continue such

policy. Although these negotiating railroads would like to oppose

such demands, they are without power to resist them for the

reasons aforesaid.

68. The contracts which defendants have in recent years forced

upon many railroads, and the contracts which defendants are at

present seeking to force upon negotiating railroads, employ, for

the effectuation of the policy above described, a formula which,

while varying with some railroads, ordinarily provides that The

Pullman Company shall first retain from the gross earnings from

the sale of seats, berths, and other accommodations in the reserved

cars operated under the terms of the agreement, an amount equal

to the total of The Pullman Company’s “Expenses of Operation”

of such cars, plus “an initial return of $1,000.00 per annum per car

furnished and operated.” Not only do these contracts successfully

effectuate and perpetuate the results above described, but they

also embody additional oppressive and unreasonable terms where-

by defendants are enabled to exact exorbitant profits. Thus, while

it is ordinarily agreed that the term “Expenses of Operation” shall

include all of The Pullman Company’s expenses of conducting

its sleeping-car and parlor-car business in present-type standard

cars, including depreciation and all taxes, the railroads are

73 given no control over the expenses incurred by The Pull-

man Company nor over The Pullman Company’s account-

ing practices, it being stipulated that the exepnses shall be ascer-

46 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

tained “in accordance with the practice of The Pullman Company

in compiling such expenses at the time the agreement is made.”

69. In the year 1939 a joint committee composed of representa-

tives of the Accounting officers of the Atchison, Topeka & Santa

Fe Railway Company; Chicago & Northwestern Railway Com-

pany; Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad Company; The

Chicago, Minneapolis, St. Paul & Pacific Railroad Company;

Great Northern Railroad Company; Illinois Central System;

Seaboard Air Line Railway; Southern Pacific Company; and

Union Pacific Railroad Company (all of which railroads were

then bound by Pullman contracts containing the provisions de-

scribed in paragraph 68 above, guaranteeing the defendants “Fx-

penses of Operation”) made an examination of The Pullman

Company accounts to determine the fairness and validity of the

Pullman Company’s accounting practices with respect to assign-

ing expenses common to all cars, and to establish to what extent

the carriers’ contract settlements were affected.

70. As a result of this examination, this Committee submitted

a report finding that the Pullman accounting practices were un-

fair and unreasonable and resulted in total overcharge to ex-

penses common to all cars of $596,049.08, or an average per car per

annum based upon the number of cars operated by Pullman in the

year 1938 (5,046.7) of $118.11.

74 71. The exceptions taken by this Committee to the ac-

counting practices of Pullman are listed below :

1. Taxes:

Descrip

(a) Undistributed Profits, 244% of net taxable income $113, 911. 76

(b) Income tax on air conditioning and Mexican opera-

tion Amount

(cy Social Security and Railroad Retirement taxes on car

cleaning and other car supplies and expenses_

(d) U. S. Capital Stock Tax chargeable to other than con-

tract operations

2. 9 insurance applicable to other than contract opera-

ons

3. General shop overhead applicable to air conditioning 41, 113. 37

4. Depreciation on building housing battery charging plant—

Calumet shops 1, 461. 05

5. Air conditioning Accounting Bureau 33, 239. 00

6. General Expenses Applicable to Operations in which Rail-

roads do not participate. — 64,266.72

Total overcharge to Expenses common to all cars — 586, 049. 08

Average per car per annum based upon number of cars operated

year 1938 (5,046.7)

72. The aforesaid carriers submitted this report to The Pull-

man Company with the request that it correct these accounting

practices and eliminate overcharges that had been found to exist.

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 47

But to this date defendants have refused to do so, and defendants’

monopolistic position enables them arbitrarily to maintain such

refusal

73. As a further means of effectuating the — — — —

perpetuating their arbitrary control over prices and of stifling t

—.—. of any competition, the defendants have forced upon

the railroads a contractual provision which gives to The Pullman

Company the right to terminate the agreement on six months’

notice “if by reason of competition, legislation, or other causes,

beyond the contro} of the Pullman Company” the guaranty

75 rovision of such contracts, as above described, should not

be effectuated. Defendants have limited the period of

notice prior to cancellation to six months, well knowing that such

a period is totally inadequate to permit a railroad to provide its

own operating services or to secure operating services from other

sources.

74. Pursuant to uniform provisions in all of the Pullman con-

tracts, The Pullman Company is privileged to charge and collect

fares from the traveling public for the use of seats, berths, and the

other accommodations provided under such contracts. Although

the railroads have a vital interest in having such rates and charges,

and the differentials between them, maintained on a basis which

will reflect the reasonable value of the service and will produce the

highest level of operating income commensurate with the economi-

cal use of cars, these contracts uniformly exclude the railroads from

‘any control whatsoever over such fares and charges and the differ-

entials between them.

75. Only defendant The Pullman Company is subject to the

regulatory jurisdiction of the Interstate Commerce Commission,

and it does not have the statutory duties of a public utility with

respect to its dealings with the railroads and is subject to the

regulatory jurisdiction of the Interstate Commerce Commission

only to the limited extent herein set forth. As a sleeping-car

company, within the definition of Section 1 (3) of the Interstate

Commerce Act, The Pullman Company is subject, with certain

exceptions, to the provisions of that Act applicable generally to

common carriers and as such files with the Commission,

76 pursuant to Section 6 of said Act, schedules showing the

rates, fares, and charges for its services. The Interstate

Commerce Commission is empowered to exercise the same regula-

tory power over the fares and charges of The Pullman Company

as it has over the fares and charges of other common carriers. But

the said Commission has never fixed either maximum or minimum

fares and charges for The Pullman Company, and the Pullman

rates and fares now in effect are not rates and fares fixed by the

48 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

Commission, but are those initiated by The Pullman Company

pursuant to its own monopolistic price policies. Since the acquisi-

tion, extension, and maintenance of monoplistic control over the

the power —

— 2 — — 2

arbitrary, discriminatory, oppressive, and unreasonable prices for

the same and to maintain arbitrary and unreasonable di tials

bet ween the price of upper and lower berths.

C. PERPETUATION AND PROTECTION OF OBSOLETE EQUIPMENT

above described. The Pullman Company has always re-

served to itself complete control over the quality and im-

provement of this equipment = denied to the railroads any right

to control the design and quality of such equipment or the accom-

modations afforded therein. ving achieved this control, The

—— for many years pursued, and does now pur-

sue, a policy o —— improve this equipment and to keep i it up

to the standards of safety, speed, comfort, and convenience made

possible by advancements in rolling stock construction. Although

many improvements in quality, design, materials, and safety have

been made available to The Pullman Company which, if adopted,

would have made these pool cars incomparably better in safety,

earning power, and riding comfort, The Pullman Company has

consistently refused to adopt such improvements.

D. DEVELOPMENT OF STREAMLINE LIGHTWEIGHT HIGH-SPEED PASSENGER

TRAINS STIFLED BY PULLMAN

77. In the past twenty years travel habits of the people of the

United States and national needs in transportation have changed

22 enormously. The remarkable growth in private

ile ownership has been largely responsible for this greatly

— urge to travel. This new vehicle and, to a much lesser

degree, the common carrier bus, have now created an immense

stream of highway passenger traffic which, in the course of its

expansion, has absorbed a large portion of the movement that

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 49

formerly was attached to the railroads. In this reservoir of high-

way travel, vast and continuing to expand, and susceptible

78 a ae blag —— —u— — manage

ments ha ve seen the opportunity for regaining the patronage

the roads once had and for restoring to the railroads profitable

passenger revenues. For many years railroad officials have inten-

sively studied means for covering passenger traffic and have con-

cluded that, to the extent this purpose could be accomplished

through improvement of the equipment, a railroad vehicle must

be offered to the public that would possess qualities of safety, speed,

comfort, and economy superior to those of highway vehicles. A

solution to the was found by railroad managements in the

streamline, lightweight, high-speed passenger trains. Within the

past seven years, there has been devised and adopted a Diesel two-

eycle engine, practicable for high-speed train service. Materials

suitable for lightweight train construction have become available

at prices which make their use in large structures practicable and

these new materials have radically changed car designing and

construction. Designs along entirely new lines have been per-

fected to withstand the rigorous stresses to which new trains are

subjected so that safety factors are not sacrificed to light weight.

In 1934 and 1935 the Union Pacific, the Chicago and Northwestern,

the Southern Pacific, the Chicago, Burlington and Quincy, the

Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe, and the Chicago, Rock Island and

Pacific railroads established the first streamline train service on

their respective lines. Subsequently, high-speed service was in-

augurated by the “Hiawathas” of the Chicago, Milwaukee, St.

Paul & Pacific, the “Flying Yankee” of the Boston &

79 Maine-Maine Central, the “Comet” of the New York, New

Haven & Hartford, the “Royal Blue,” “Columbia,” “Ann

” and “Abraham Lincoln” of the Baltimore & Ohio-Alton,

the “Green Diamond” of the Illinois Central, the “Mercury” of the

New York Central, the “Rebels” of the Gulf, Mobile & Northern,

the “Eagles” of the Missouri Pacific, and the “Crusaders” of the

Reading, and high-speed streamline trains became popular. The

Seaboard Air Line’s “Silver Meteors” and the Atlantic Coast

Line’s “Champions” are high-speed streamline trains which were

placed in operation along the Atlantic Coast. New high-speed

ightweight streamline trains are important from the standpoint

the national defense because they constitute a new technique for

the high-speed transportation of large groups of men and materials.

78. Since the inauguration of the first three-car Zephyrs on the

Chicago, Burlington and Quincy on November 13, 1934, and the

three-car “City of Salina” on Union Pacific on January 31,

1935, approximately one hundred high-speed trains, with modern

50 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

luxurious appointments, have been introduced on different rail-

roads, a large number of which are streamline, lightweight con-

struction.

79. These trains, however, have replaced or extended but a small

fraction of the high-class passenger train service of the country

and this advance in modern passenger transportation is sli

when compared with the potential use of such trains, for which

there is opportunity and need from the three standpoints of

national defense, the domestic economy, and the require-

80 ments of the traveling public. Although the service now in-

augurated has commanded wide public approbation and has

proved itself to be financially profitable to the railroads, the entire

program of modernizing passenger transportation by this means

has been thwarted, restrained, and stified by defendants, as here-

inafter alleged. Few of these high-speed trains above referred

to operate or can operate sleeping-car service because of the ac-

tion and policies of defendants, hereinafter described.

80. The new lightweight, high-speed, streamline sleeping cars

developed in the manner above described are approximately one-

half the weight of standard Pullman sleepers, are more economical

in operation, permit greater train speeds, and the greatly superior

in earning power, riding comfort, and safety to 95% of the sleep-

ing cars making up the Pullman pool, which defendants choose

to characterize as “standard.” Even the few sleeping cars which

defendants, through their manufacturing agent, -Stand-

ard Car Manufacturing Company, have reluctantly built since

1933, have been of the new type described.

81. Nevertheless, defendants ha ve feared that the development

of this new type of equipment will impair their monopolistic

profits from obsolete sleeping cars and will thwart their carefully

pursued policy of compelling the railroads to use the present tool

equipment of The Pullman Company far beyond its normal period

of serviceable use. Defendants, in the development of the Pull-

man contract structure as above described, have always been

81 careful to preserve complete control over the type, design,

and quality of the equipment furnished the railroads. Mak-

ing use of this power, defendants, since the advent of the new

type of equipment above described, have consistently refused

to recognize such new type equipment as standard, or even to fur-

nish such equipment to the railroads on the same contractual prin-

ciples as the old equipment was furnished or on reasonable terms

in the amounts needed by the railroads.

82. Instead, and with the intent, purpose and effect of stifling

the development and use of such lightweight, high-speed, stream-

line equipment, defendants have furnished such equipment to the

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 51

railroads only upon onerous special contractual terms and condi-

tions. Such special contracts, sometimes embodied in the princi-

pal operating agreements, but more often in special supplementary

agreements, have required the participating railroads to pay a

large share of the added cost of building such cars, even though

cars remain the property of defendants. Other unreasonable,

onerous and unjust provisions as to the cost and operation of such

equipment, have been exacted by defendants as conditions prece-

dent to furnishing such equipment. In the case of many railroads,

the exaction of such conditions by defendant has, according to

the monopolistic plan and deliberate purpose of defendants,

created an insuperable barrier to the use of such lightweight, high-

speed, streamline equipment, and in the case of other railroads

has discouraged and limited the use of such equipment to a few

special trains nnd has prevented the full advantage and superiority

of such equipment from being realized by any railroad.

82. E. ELIMINATION OF ALL OUTSIDE COMPETITION IN THE

BUILDING AND FURNISHING OF HIGH-SPEED, LIGHT-

WEIGHT, STREAMLINE EQUIPMENT

83. So powerful has been the demand and need for the high-

speed, lightweight, streamline trains, that the harsh and dicta-

torial policies and repressive methods adopted by defendants, as

above described, to suppress their development and prevent their

introduction into the Pullman pool have not been completely suc-

cessful in preventing the railroads and other manufacturers from

attempting to meet this demand. Less than 5 percent of the total

cars of the Pullman pool are of the new high-speed streamline

lightweight type.

84. About 1933, the Edward G. Budd Manufacturing Company

of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, evolved a novel method for weld-

ing stainless steel and thus made the structural use of that material

practicable in railroad car building. This method was patented

and trademarked “shot-weld process.” The Budd Company be-

came interested in using this material to construct lightweight,

high-speed, streamline rolling stock, including both sleeping car

and other equipment. Constant improvement and development

of this stainless-steel passenger equipment by The Budd Company

has resulted in a product which would successfully compete in ex-

cellence of design, quality, safety, speed, economy, earning power

and riding comfort, with the best lightweight equipment manu-

factured by defendants. Although the license to use the patented

process and design necessary for the construction of the stain-

less steel and other sleeping cars has been offered to defendants,

724808 47——-4

52 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

they have, with the unlawful purposes and unlawful intent

83 aforesaid, consistently refused to accept it, choosing instead

to use the full force of their monopolistic power and control

to crush the potential competition created by the development of

this new equipment and to prevent the use of such equipment on

the railroads.

85. In order to stifle and crush the potential competition of shot-

weld stainless steel, defendants brought to bear one of the power-

ful weapons which had been carefully placed in the contract struc-

ture developed as described above. This weapon consisted of a

uniform provision unlawfully inserted for many years by The

Pullman Company in all of its operating contracts, in violation of

Section 3 of the Clayton Act and of Section 1 of the Sherman Act

as charged above, which uniform provision declares in express

terms that “The Pullman Company shall, except as provided for,

and contemplated, in Section 1, Article III hereof,* have the ex-

clusive right, so far as the same may be legally granted, to furnish

under this agreement all standard sleeping cars and parlor cars

to meet the requirements of travel over the lines oper-

ated by the railroad company.” The phrase inserted by Pullman

in this uniform exclusive dealing clause, “so far as the same may be

legally granted,” was employed merely to give color of legality

to the provision but has not in any way limited the complete control

exercised by The Pullman Company and the other defendants.

86. Whenever a railroad has sought to purchase, acquire,

84 or otherwise obtain the use of the stainless steel equipment

produced by the Budd Manufacturing Company, as above

described, defendants have brought to bear upon such railroad the

full force of their monopolistic control, bargaining power, and

have coupled the use of the exclusive dealing provision, above de-

scribed, with threats of cancellation of contract, discrimination,

and withdrawal of service if the railroad secured sleeping cars

from any other manufacturer than Standard.

87. On December 16, 1935, The Chicago, Burlington & Quincy

Railroad ordered from The Edward G. Budd Manufacturing

Company two ten-car trains, containing a total of eight sleeping

cars, for service between Chicago and Denver. At that time,

the Burlington and its allied lines, The Great Northern and North-

ern Pacific, were negotiating a new contract with The Pullman

Company. Defendants brought all their power to bear upon the

Burlington to prevent it from consummating this order. After

a long controversy, defendants finally consented to write a

new contract permitting The Burlington to order a total of ten

.

„n

. THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 53

from The Budd Company. Neither the Great Northern

nor the Northern Pacific was permitted to purchase sleepers, and

there was specific prohibition against the Burlington purchasing

more than ten cars, although these railroads desired to make such

purchases from the Budd Company.

88. On April 7, 1936, the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railroad

ordered from the Budd Manufacturing Company six eight-car

trains to run between Chicago and Los Angeles. These six trains

were to be identical and were to consist of sleeping cars,

85 diners, and club cars. The manufacturer agreed to build

one complete train in advance of the other five so that it

might be determined whether or not any changes were desirable

in the other five trains. At this time, the Santa Fe was operating

under a. Pullman contract, which had about one year to run.

Defendants learned of the placing of this order and immediately

brought the full force of their power to bear upon the Santa Fe.

A new contract to replace the then existing one to run for a period

of five years, was submitted to Santa Fe. Defendants after long

controversy were persuaded to provide in this new contract for

the operation of the five stainless-steel Budd sleeping cars which

had already been delivered to the railroad, pursuant to the order,

above described, on April 16, 1937, but beyond this defendants were

adamant and forced upon the railroad a provision in the new con-

tract prohibiting the purchase of any additional sleepers from the

Budd Company. As a result of this pressure, the Santa Fe was

forced to notify the Budd Manufacturing Company that it could

not accept any more sleeping cars and that the remaining cars

making up the order should consist of dining cars, club cars, chair

cars, and passenger equipment other than sleeping cars. While

defendants were forcing these conditions upon the Santa Fe that

railroad gave serious consideration to the question of giving up

its arrangement with The Pullman Company entirely and ordering

sufficient sleeping cars from other sources to service their entire

line. Because of the tremendous investment necessary for such

a step and because defendants could and would have fore-

86 _— stalled working arrangements with other railroads for

through service, combined with the tremendous pressure

brought to bear upon the railroads by defendants to prevent this

step, this plan was not consummated and the Santa Fe was forced

to succumb to defendants’ pressure.

89. In like manner, and with like purpose and effect, defendants

have prevented the consummation of other purchases by numerous

railroads of stainless-steel, high-speed, lightweight sleeping cars

from the Budd Manufacturing Company. Notwithstanding the

fact that defendants have permitted the use of a total of 15 such

52 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

they have, with the unlawful purposes and unlawful intent

83 aforesaid, consistently refused to accept it, choosing instead

to use the full force of their monopolistic power and control

to crush the potential competition created by the development of

this new equipment and to prevent the use of such equipment on

the railroads.

85. In order to stifle and crush the potential competition of shot-

weld stainless steel, defendants brought to bear one of the power-

ful weapons which had been carefully placed in the contract struc-

ture developed as described above. This weapon consisted of a

uniform provision unlawfully inserted for many years by The

Pullman Company in all of its operating contracts, in violation of

Section 3 of the Clayton Act and of Section 1 of the Sherman Act

as charged above, which uniform provision declares in express

terms that “The Pullman Company shall, except as provided for,

and contemplated, in Section 1, Article III hereof,* have the ex-

clusive right, so far as the same may be legally granted, to furnish

under this agreement all standard sleeping cars and parlor cars

necessary to meet the requirements of travel over the lines oper-

ated by the railroad company.” The phrase inserted by Pullman

in this uniform exclusive dealing clause, “so far as the same may be

legally granted,” was employed merely to give color of legality

to the provision but has not in any way limited the complete control

exercised by The Pullman Company and the other defendants.

86. Whenever a railroad has sought to purchase, acquire,

84 or otherwise obtain the use of the stainless steel equipment

produced by the Budd Manufacturing Company, as above

described, defendants have brought to bear upon such railroad the

full force of their monopolistic control, bargaining power, and

have coupled the use of the exclusive dealing provision, above de-

scribed, with threats of cancellation of contract, discrimination,

and withdrawal of service if the railroad secured sleeping cars

from any other manufacturer than Standard.

87. On December 16, 1935, The Chicago, Burlington & Quincy

Railroad ordered from The Edward G. Budd Manufacturing

Company two ten-car trains, containing a total of eight sleeping

cars, for service between Chicago and Denver. At that time,

the Burlington and its allied lines, The Great Northern and North-

ern Pacific, were negotiating a new contract with The Pullman

Company. Defendants brought all their power to bear upon the

Burlington to prevent it from consummating this order. After

a long controversy, defendants finally consented to write a

new contract permitting The Burlington to order a total of ten

* tion and

ont a — to sleeping-car equipment refers only to the

. THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 53

sleepers from The Budd Company. Neither the Great Northern

nor the Northern Pacific was permitted to purchase sleepers, and

there was specific prohibition against the Burlington purchasing

more than ten cars, although these railroads desired to make such

from the Budd v.

88. On April 7, 1936, the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railroad

ordered from the Budd Manufacturing Company six eight-car

trains to run between Chicago and Los Angeles. These six trains

were to be identical and were to consist of sleeping cars,

85 diners, and club cars. The manufacturer agreed to build

one complete train in advance of the other five so that it

might be determined whether or not any changes were desirable

in the other five trains. At this time, the Santa Fe was operating

under a. Pullman contract, which had about one year to run.

Defendants learned of the placing of this order and immediately

brought the full force of their power to bear upon the Santa Fe.

A new contract to replace the then existing one to run for a period

of five years, was submitted to Santa Fe. Defendants after long

controversy were persuaded to provide in this new contract for

the operation of the five stainless-steel Budd sleeping cars which

had already been delivered to the railroad, pursuant to the order,

above described, on April 16, 1937, but beyond this defendants were

adamant and forced upon the railroad a provision in the new con-

tract prohibiting the purchase of any additional sleepers from the

Budd Company. As a result of this pressure, the Santa Fe was

forced to notify the Budd Manufacturing Company that it could

not accept any more sleeping cars and that the remaining cars

making up the order should consist of dining cars, club cars, chair

cars, and passenger equipment other than sleeping cars. While

defendants were forcing these conditions upon the Santa Fe that

railroad gave serious consideration to the question of giving up

its arrangement with The Pullman Company entirely and ordering

sufficient sleeping cars from other sources to service their entire

line. Because of the tremendous investment necessary for such

a step and because defendants could and would have fore-

86 stalled working arrangements with other railroads for

through service, combined with the tremendous pressure

brought to bear upon the railroads by defendants to prevent this

step, this plan was not consummated and the Santa Fe was forced

to succumb to defendants’ pressure.

89. In like manner, and with like purpose and effect, defendants

have prevented the consummation of other purchases by numerous

railroads of stainless-steel, high-speed, lightweight sleeping cars

from the Budd Manufacturing Company. Notwithstanding the

fact that defendants have permitted the use of a total of 15 such

54 ‘THE UNITED STATES vs. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

non-Pullman-built sleeping cars on the Santa Fe and Burlington

railroads, defendants have arbitrarily imposed as a condition upon

the use of these 15 cars the unreasonable, unlawful, and oppres-

sive requirement that these cars be used only on two trains; in

the case of the Chicago, Burlington and Quincy on the “Denver

Zephyr,” a train plying only between Chicago and Denever, and

in the case of the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe on the “Super-

Chief,” a train plying mainly between Los Angeles and Chicago.

Because of seasonal variations in the amount of travel over these

two runs the railroads which own these cars are required by de-

fendants to keep some of them idle, although in the absence of

such requirement the railroad could profitably operate such cars

over othér runs.

90. Shortly after defendants had been successful in restricting

the purchases by the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy and Atchison,

Topeka & Santa Fe to a total of fifteen Budd-built sleeping cars,

The Pullman Company, through its President, David A.

87 Crawford, and other defendants, announced to these rail-

roads, and on various occasions since that time, has an-

nounced to other railroads that The Pullman Company would,

from that time on, refuse to operate or make contractual pro-

visions regarding the operation of sleeping cars built by the Budd

Manufacturing pany or by any other manufacturer than de-

fendants’ manufacturing agency, The Pullman Standard Car

Manufacturing Company. With the intent and purpose to stifle

all competition from outside manufacturers, defendants gave

widespread publicity in the railroad industry to the adoption of

this policy, with the result that many railroads which otherwise

would have been interested in negotiating with competing manu-

facturers for the building of sleeping cars have been discouraged

and prevented from doing so, and competition in the manufac-

turing of such sleeping cars has been unlawfully suppressed.

91. Since the consummation of the contractual provisions with

the Santa Fe and the Burlington permitting the operation of «

total of fifteen Budd-built sleepers on these railroads, defendants

have consistently refused to consider the operation of any sleeping

cars built by manufacturers other than their manufacturing

agency, the Pullman-Standard Car Manufacturing Company,

and have consistently refused to permit any railroad to purchase,

acquire, or otherwise provide for the use on such railroad of such

sleeping-car equipment. Thus defendants have completely elim-

inated all possible competition from outside manufacturers in the

manufacture or furnishing of lightweight, high-speed.

88 streamline sleeping cars. Many of the so-called high-

speed streamline trains put out by Standard and known as

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 55

Pullman-built merely involve certain so-called “high-speed better-

ment,” which is to say that these trains consist of old standard

Pullman cars whose contour is changed to give these cars the

appearance of streamlining and whose interiors are rebuilt, and

which cars have certain improvements in the trucks and couplers.

F. POLICY OF REQUIRING RAILROADS TO PAY FOR ALL IMPROVEMENTS

92. Although The Pullman Company holds itself out as en-

gaged in a partnership enterprise with the contracting railroads,

and although, under the terms of its contracts with railroads, The

Pullman Company is the owner of the reserved cars furnished

thereunder, together with all improvements and fixtures on said

cars, The Pullman Company has uniformly pursued a policy of

requiring the contracting railroads to pay for all improvements on

such equipment. This The Pullman Company has done under the

pretext that reserved cars which are built upon a model more than

twenty years old are “standard” cars and that any changes and im-

provements in such cars are extraordinary and for the sole bene-

fit of the railroad and that the railroads must therefore stand the

cost of such improvements, even though such improvements be-

come the property of The Pullman Company and materially and

substantially increase the value of its property and do not miti-

gate against The Pullman Company using said cars in fulfilling its

contract with any other railroad.

89 93. Air-conditioning systems for reserved cars are, and

for the past several years have been, an essential and neces-

sary feature of sleeping and parlor cars on the railroads. Never-

theless, The Pullman Company, pursuant to the policy above de-

scribed, has forced upon the railroads contractual provisions,

sometimes embodied in the principal operating agreement but

more often embodied in elaborate supplemental agreements, the

effect of which is to require the railroads to pay in some instances

75 percent and in others more than 100 percent of the total cost

of air-conditioning sleeping cars. This air-conditioning equip-

ment becomes a fixture of the Pullman car and becomes the pro-

perty of The Pullman Company. Such air-conditioning con-

tracts ordinarily run for a term of five years at the end of which

the railroads will have paid 75% of the installation cost of such

equipment in addition to payments covering the railroads’ por-

tion of the operating expense. However, at the end of the five-

year period there is no contractual obligation for Pullman to

furnish air-conditioning equipment and in many cases The Pull-

man Company has required the railroads, as a condition precedent

to the continued furnishing of such air-conditioned equipment,

56 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

to extend the five-year period for a further period so that the

carrier is committed to a schedule of payments which will force

it to meet all the original cost of the air-conditioning equipment

e

94. Likewise The Pullman Company has

90 does require, the contracting railroads to pay the —

cost of all other improvements on such equipment under the

. onan. SRY eee

standard-type cars. In fact, however, such improvements have

become necessary and essential features of such cars operated on

the modern passenger train. Thus the con railroads have

been required by The Pullman Company to pay for the installa-

tion costs of those improvements which have resulted from the

normal developments of the trade for the purpose of improving

AFP Ex-

amples of such improvements, for which the railroads have been

required to pay are: outside vestibule enclosures, “special” ex-

terior paintings, full rounded roofs with built-up ends for stream-

line appearance, “special” weather stripping, tight-lock couplings,

rubber draft gears, “new” diaphragm suspensions, “special”

truck springs, “special” truck bearings, journal-box lids, dust

— gm “special” buffer foot plates, vestibule folding steps, and

side skirting, curved type for streamline appearance.

G. USE OF COMBINED SLEEPING-CAR MONOPOLY TO PROMOTE MONOPOLY

OF FREIGHT-CAR AND PASSENGER-CAR TRANSPORTATION

95. The defendants, making use of their monopolistic position

in the manufacture and operation of sleeping cars, have practiced

oppressive sales methods and have used coercion, with the unlaw-

ful purpose and effect of forcing the railroads to purchase their

— equipment and freight cars from defendants’ manu-

acturing agency, the Pullman-Standard Car Manufactur-

91 ing Company, and have thus attem to monopolize and

have monopolized a large part of the manufacture of such

passenger and freight car equipment.

96. The new lightweight high speed streamline rolling stock

described above is purchased by railroads in unit trains which

are complete except for the power unit. Defendants refuse to per-

mit railroads to such trains containing sleeping cars from

any one except man-Standard Car Manufacturing Company.

As a consequence railroads are unable to purchase the passenger

coaches, dining coaches, parlor coaches, and other types of rolling

stock that go into such trains from any manufacturer except the

Pullman-Standard Car Manufacturing Company.

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 57

EFFECTS OF THE UNLAWFUL COMBINATIONS, CONTRACTS, MONOPOLIES,

AND ATTEMPTS TO MONOPOLIZE

97. The unlawful combination in restraint of trade, combina-

tion to monopolize, monopolies, attempts to monopolize, and un-

lawful contracts described above have, as intended by the defend-

ants, produced the following unlawful consequences :

(1) Defendants have secured a complete unlawful monopoly

of the business of operating sleeping-car services in interstate

commerce over the railroads of the United States.

(2) Prices and terms charged by the defendants to railroads

for sleeping-car services have been artificial, noncompetitive, and

unreasonably high.

(3) Prices and terms charged by the defendants to the

92 traveling public for services operated by the defendants

have been artificial, noncompetitive, and unreasonably high.

(4) The defendants have secured an absolute monopoly over

the business of manufacturing sleeping cars.

(5) Defendants have unreasonably and unlawfully restrained

—— in the manufacture, sale, lease, and distribution of

1 15 rs and other types of rolling stock.

(6) Defendants have forced railroads to pay artificial, noncom-

petitive, and unreasonably high prices for rolling stock.

(7) Defendants have unreasonably coerced and restrained rail-

roads in the operation of their businesses and have unlewfully

forced railroads to refrain from responding to the forces of com-

ition.

(8) Defendants have stifled competition in the manufacture,

sale, lease, and operation of modern, lightweight, streamlined,

high-speed trains and rolling stock, and defendants have unrea-

sonably retarded the growth and development of a supply of

modern passenger coach and sleeping cars in the United States.

VIII

PRraYer

Wuenrerore, plaintiff prays:

(1) That the aforesaid monopolies, attempts to monopolize,

combinations and conspiracies to monopolize, and contracts, com-

binations, and conspiracies in restraint of trade be adjudged and

decreed to be unlawful, and that the agreements, under-

93 standings, acquisitions, purchases, and practices alleged in

this complaint be adjudged and decreed to be in violation of

the Sherman Act and of the Clayton Act.

(2) That the Court adjudge and decree that the defendants

have monopolized, attempted to monopolize, combined and con-

58 THE UNITED STATES V8. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

spired to monopolize, combined and conspired to restrain trade, in

violation of Sections 1, 2, and 3 of the Sherman Act.

(3) That the “tying clauses” contained in the various contracts

between The Pullman Company and the railroads of the United

States be adjudged and decreed to violate Section 3 of the Clayton

2

such “tying clauses,” or similar clauses, be 1 enjo

(4) That defendants, and each of them, and their die

tors, agents, representatives, and all persons and co

—— — apa td gy ually ——

from monopolizing, attempting to monopo combining and

congpiring to monopolize, or agreeing, combining, or conspiring

to restrain trade, or from leasing or making a sale or contract for

sale of goods, wares, merchandise, machinery, supplies, or other

commodities for use, consum , or resale within the United

States upon the unlawful conditions hereinbefore outlined, and be

perpetually enjoined from engaging in or participating in prac-

tices, contracts, relationships, or unde ings, or claiming any

rights thereunder, having a tendency to continue or revive any of

the ay violations of the Sherman Act and of the Clayton

94 (5) That the Court adjudge and decree that the various

unlawful provisions in each of the several contracts bet ween

The Pullman Company and the railtoads of the United States

are null and void, and that The Pullman Company be perpetually

enjoined from hereafter inserting any such unlawful contractual

provision in any contract which may hereafter be entered into

between The Pullman Company and any railroad of the United

States, and from claiming any rights under any such unlawful

contractual provision which may be contained in any presently

existing contract between The Pullman Company and any railroad

of the United States.

(6) That the manufacturing and operating businesses of Pull-

man Incorporated be effectively divorced and separated in such

manner and to such extent that the efficiency of a single operating

pool of sleeping car equipment under responsible and unified man-

agement may be preserved and maintained and that effective com-

petition may be created and maintained in the future in the manu-

facture and sale of sleeping car equipment; and that Pullman In-

corporated and its —— be required to make such divesti-

tures and conveyances of their stock holdings and properties as

shall be necessary to accomplish such effective divorcement, and

complete separation of the management of the said manufacturing

and operating

(7) That in order to preserve and protect —— in the

manufacture of sleeping cars and in the car- building industry

THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY 59

— each individual defendant herein be perpetually

9 enjoi from simultaneously holding or controlling, di-

rectly or indirectly, or through subsidiary corporations,

agents, representatives, or assignees, any of the capital stock of

more than one of the corporate defendants herein, and that each

defendant herein engaged in the manufacturing busi-

ness be perpetually enjoined from holding, directly or indirectly,

any of the capital stock of any other corporate defendant herein

engaged in the operating business, or of any successor or successors

of such corporate defendant, and further, that each corporate

defendant herein, engaged in the operating business, be perpetu-

ally enjoined from holding, directly or indirectly, any of the capi-

tal stock of any other corporate defendant herein, or of any com-

petitor or of any successor or successors of such corporate defend-

ant, or of such competitor, engaged in any way in the manufac-

taring of railroad rolling stock.

(8) That The Pullman Company or its successor or successors

be perpetually enjoined from refusing to operate any sleepi

cars purchased, leased, or otherwise control any railroed

having contractual relations with The Pullman pany or its

successor or successors, provided that these sleeping cars meet

reasonable standard specifications and provided that The Pull-

man Company or its successor or successors shall receive a just and

reasonable compensation for such operation.

(9) That plaintiff have such other and further and different

relief as the nature of the case may require and the Court may

deem just and proper.

(10) That plaintiff recover the costs of this suit.

06 (11) That pursuant to Section 5 of the Sherman Act

and Section 15 of the Clayton Act, an order be made and

entered herein requiring such of the defendants as are not resident

within this District to be brought before this Court in this pro-

ceeding as parties defendant and directing the marshals of the

Districts in which they severally reside to serve summons upon

Wenvewt Berar,

Fowian Hamicron,

Frank Coteman,

Wiser StaMMier,

; Special Assistants to the Attorney General.

Bonert H. Jackson,

Attorney General of the United States.

Tuourman Arnot.

United States Attorney.

60 THE UNITED STATES VS. THE PULLMAN COMPANY

97 In the District Court of the United States for the Eastern

District of Pennsylvania

[Title omitted.

Appendices to Complaint

98 APPENDIX A

Parr 1

[This material taken verbatim from 36 I. C. C. Val. Rep. 845,

927-036 }

PREDECESSOR COMPANIES

een Cae St a eee, Uaanes

Palace Car Company (The Company) formerly

— 4 3 —

The Pullman Southern Car Company was incorporated March

16, 1870, by ial act of the State of , under the name

of Crescent City Sleeping Car Company. The name was changed

February 13, 1871, by amendment to the act of March 16, 1870.

The date of organization was March 11, 1871. No accounting

records of the company were obtained. no informa-

tion can be given from its accounts regarding its ial deal-

ee ee ane eee However, certain data

indi below were obtained from other sources.

The company was controlled on October 1, 1894, the date of sale,

by The Pullman Company, through ownership of its capital stock.

On the other hand, the records reviewed do not indicate that this

company then controlled any common-carrier corporation. The

property of this company was operated by its own organization

from the date of acquirement to the date of sale.

The property owned by the company consisted of 72 cars and

equipments. manner in which this property was acquired is

not ascertainable from the records reviewed. minutes indi-

cate that 11 cars and equipments had been purchased from the

Pullman Kimball end Ramsey Sleeping Car Company and 18 cars

and equipments from the Paine Lines (so-called) in October 1872

in exchange for capital stock ; also that 6 cars had been

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Appendix — United States v. Pullman Co. · 331 U.S. 865 | Frix