Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — National Labor Relations Board v. Wichita Eagle & Beacon Publishing Co.

Supreme Court brief1974

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

otrd

*

o LIBRARY, “@ | &

SUPROME COURT, US.

73-701

No. —

seacr SARS?

WICHAEL ROGE%

t

—

Gn the Supreme Court of the United States

OcroserR TERM, 1973

Natrona Labor RELATIONS BoaRrD, PETITIONER

v.

Wicuira Eacie & Beacon Pustisutne Co., Inc., pr AL.

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED

STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

ROBERT H. BORE,

Solicitor General,

Department of Justice,

Washington, D.C. 20530.

PETER G. NASH,

General Counsel,

JOHN S. IRVING,

Deputy General Counsel,

PATRICK HARDIN,

Associate General Counsel.

NORTON J. COME,

Deputy Associate General Counsel,

LINDA SHER,

Attorney,

National Labor Relations Board,

Washington, D.C. 20570.

Gn the Supreme Court of the Anited States

OcToBER TERM, 1973

NaTIoNaL LaBor RELATIONS BoakD, PETITIONER

Vv.

Wicuita EacLe & Beacon PUBLISHING Co., INC., ET AL.

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED

STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE TENTE CIRCUIT

The Solicitor General, on behalf of the National

Labor Relations Board, petitions for a writ of cer-

tiorari to review the judgment of the United States

Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in this case.

OPINIONS BELOW

The opinion of the court of appeals (Pet. App. A,

pp. 7-15) is reported at 480 F. 2d 52. The decision and

order of the Board (Pet. App. C, pp. 17-60) are re-

ported at 199 NLRB No. 50.

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the court of appeals (Pet. App. B,

p. 16) was entered on July 2, 1973. On September 13,

1973, Mr. Justice White extended the Board’s time

for filing a petition for a writ of certiorari to and in-

cluding October 30, 1973. The jurisdiction of this

Court is invoked under 28 U.S.C. 1254(1).

(1)

524-726—73——-1

ee es

HENRI LL NG STONE EE PE Lh: OE SERENA RAT TEAL RE IT REA I GF ee |

GAGA TWN IIL MEST ET Cs

Beer egress

Bui wh SVE

2

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether a “managerial employee’’ is covered by

the National Labor Relations Act unless her duties

are such that there is likely to be a conflict of interest

between her job responsibilities and her responsibili-

ties to a labor organization.

STATUTE INVOLVED

The relevant provisions of the National Labor Re-

lations Act (29 U.S.C. See. 151, et seg.) are as fol-

lows:

Sec. 2. When used in this Act—

* * * * *

(3) The term “employee”’ shall include any

employee, and shall not be limited to the em-

ployees of a particular employer, unless the Act

explicitly states otherwise, and shall include

any individual whose work has ceased as a con-

sequence of, or in connection with, any current

labor dispute or because of any unfair labor

practice, and who has not obtained any other

regular substantially equivalent employment,

but shall not include any individual employed

as an agricultural laborer, or in the domestic

service of any family or person at his home, or

any individual employed by his parent or

spouse, or any individual having the status of

an independent contractor, or any individual

employed as a supervisor, or any individual em-

ployed by an employer subject to the Railway

Labor Act, as amended from time to time, or

by any other person who is not an employer as

herein defined.

* * * * *

3

Sec. 8. (a) It shall be an unfair labor prac-

tice for an employer—

(1) to interfere with restrain, or coerce em-

ployees in the exercise of the rights guaranteed

in section 7;

* * * * *

(3) by discrimination in regard to hire or

tenure of employment or any term or condi-

tion of employment to encourage or discourage

membership in any labor organization: * * *

; STATEMENT

The Board found that editorial writers Dorothy

Wood and Theodore Blankenship had no management

role and that thus they were properly ineluded in

the same bargaining unit with respondent Company's

news employees (Pet. App. C. p. 21).. The Board fur-

ther found, inter alia, that the Company violated See-

tion 8(a) (1) and (3) of the Act by transferring Wood,

against her will, from the editorial page department to

the Sunday magazine department, because of her union

activities (Pet. App. C, p. 55). The Board ordered the

Company, titer alia, to reinstate Wood to her former

job, with back pay (Pet. App. C, p.57).

*The Company's editorial page department consists of three

people: Pearson, the editor of the editorial] page, and writers

Wood and Blankenship. Pearson reported directly to Colburn.

the editor and publisher. and no editorial was published with-

out prior clearance by Colburn. Wood and Blankenship did not

participate in employer-employee relations. or in management

decisions involving profit and loss. capitalization. or other

entrepreneurial matters. Management policy or views that were

expressed in editorials were determined by Colburn. and ulti-

mately, by the owners of the newspaper. (Pet. App. Cy pp.

23-24.)

SA Se eee

his ihe

NUP TRE

OTE SI

+

The court of appeals held, contrary to the Board,

that Wood and Blankenship ‘*were so closely aligned

with the newspaper’s management in the formulation,

determination, and effectuation * * * of the newspaper

management's policies through its editorials as to be

properly excluded from the collective bargaining unit

of news department employees” (Pet. App. A, PD. 14). It

followed, in the court’s view, that they were not “em-

ployees” under the National Labor Relations Act, and

therefore the Company's action in transferring Wood

did not violate the Act (Pet. App. A. pp- 11, 14).

REASON FOR GRANTING THE WRIT

The issue in this case is the same as one of those

in National Labor Relations Board v. Bell Aerospace

Company Division of Textron, Tne., No. 72-1598, cer-

tiorari granted, October 9, 1973: Whether, as the

Board contends, **managerial employees’ are covered

by the Act unless their duties are such that there is

likely to be a conflict of interest between their job

responsibilities and their responsibilities to a labor

organization. The court below in this case did not

inquire whether Wood’s management functions were

likely to conflict with her union responsibilities. In-

stead, it based its conclusion that she was not an

“employee” simply upon its ruling that she was suffi-

ciently identified with management to warrant ex-

eluding her from the bargaining unit of news em-

ployees.

Accordingly, if this Court in Bell upholds the

Board’s position, this case should be remanded so that

ei NA ES IR MOIS Sot OY Se Rn Sd RP

o

Wood's status may be reconsidered under the proper

standard.

CONCLUSION

The petition for a writ of certiorari should be

granted. We suggest, however, that the Court defer act-

ing on the petition until it decides Bell, and then dispose

of it in accordance with that decision.

Respectfully submitted.

Roserr H. Bork,

Solicitor General.

PETER G. NASH,

General Counsel,

JOHN S. IRVING,

Deputy General Counsel,

Patrick Harbin,

Associate General Counsel,

Norton J. Come,

Deputy Associate General Counsel,

Linpa SHER,

Attorney,

National Labor Relations Board.

OcTOBER 1973.

APPENDIX A

United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Cireuit

No. 72-1673—May 1973 Term

Wicuita Eacte & BEACON PUBLISHING Co., INC..

PETITIONER

v.

NaTIONAL LaBoR RELATIONS BOARD, RESPONDENT

On Petition for Review of an Order of National

Labor Relations Board

Gerrit H. Wormhoudt, Wichita, Kansas (Paul R.

Kitch and J. Erie Engstrom, Wichita, Kansas, with

him on the Brief), for Petitioner.

Corinna Lothar Metealf, Attorney, National Labor

Relations Board (Peter G. Nash, General Counsel,

Patrick Hardin, Associate General Counsel, Marcel

Mallet-Prevost, Assistant General Counsel, and Leo-

nard M. Wagman, Attorney, National Labor Rela-

tions Board, with her on the Brief), for Respondent.

Before Puttuirs, SetH and Horttoway, Circuit

Judges.

Sern, Crrewt Judge.

Wichita Eagle & Beacon Publishing Co.. Inc. peti-

tions this court, pursuant to 29 U.S.C. 9 160(f), to re-

view and set aside an order of the National Labor

Relations Board (199 NLRB No. 50). The Board

cross-petitions for enforcement of its order.

The Board has found that the newspaper had en-

gaged in unfair labor prattices within the meaning of

sections 8(a) (1) and (3) of the Act, by transferring

(7)

errr er esr

8

employee Dorothy Wood, against her will, from the

editorial page department to the Sunday magazine

department because of the said Wood's union activi-

ties, and by telling employee Wood that consequences

of her union membership and activity might be severe.

The record shows that the newspaper is engaged in

the publishing, sale, and distribution of daily news-

papers in Wichita, Kansas. In August 1970, the

Wichita Newspaper Guild, affiliated with The News-

paper Guild, AFL-CIO, filed a petition with the

Board seeking certification as the collective bargain-

ing agent of the newspaper's employees. The Board

conducted a hearing on the petition and issued a De-

cision and Direction of Election. In connection there-

with. the Board found that two “editorial writers,”

Dorothy Wood and Theodore Blankenship, should be

included in the bargaining unit as they did not

“possess indicia of managerial employees.”

The newspaper filed a request for review of the De-

cision and Direction of Election with the Board, lim-

ited to the inclusion of the two editorial employees

in the bargaining unit, but the Board denied the re-

quest for review.

An election was conducted by the Board among the

unit that it had determined was appropriate and the

Union was certified as the collective bargaining agent

for the bargaining unit. Contract negotiations between

the newspaper and the Union were begun, and at the

time of the hearing of the unfair labor practice com-

plaint the parties had not reached a contract.

As to Mrs. Wood, the Union filed charges and a

hearing was held before a trial examiner. The trial

examiner found that the newspaper had violated sec-

tions 8(a) (1) and (3) of the Act by transferring

Mrs. Wood from the editorial page department to the

Sunday magazine department because of her union

SPO Es DT at ee

9

activities. He recommended that she be reinstated in

the editorial page department and that she be

awarded any back pay that she would have been en-

titled to, including increases in salary, but for her

transfer. The newspaper filed exceptions to the trial

examiner’s Decision. The Board issued its Decision

and Order, adopting the trial examiner’s Decision and

adopting his recommended Order.

Mrs. Wood's position prior to her transfer to the

Sunday magazine department was that of an editorial

writer. As the trial examiner's Decision states, the edi-

torial page department of the newspaper consisted of

three people. Charles Pearson, editor of the editorial

page, was the acknowledged supervisor of the two em-

ployees in the editorial page department, Mrs. Wood

and Mr. Blankenship. He was excluded from the eol-

lective bargaining unit at the representation hearing

by the Board. In the words of the trial examiner,

John H. Colburn, editor and publisher of the news-

paper, was also part of the editorial page department

“in a real but perhaps ex officio sense.’” The trial ex-

aminer’s Decision includes this description of the rela-

tionship of the positions:

Normal day to day procedure, in the editorial

page department, was the holding of a mid-

morning conference, with Colburn, Pearson,

Wood and Blankenship participating. In turn,

at the conference, Pearson, Wood, and Blank-

enship would be asked what he or she had in

mind for an editorial. Wood, for instance, when

thus asked, might say that she had in mind

writing a piece on ecology. Colburn or Pearson

might say that we had an editorial on air and

water pollution last week so we will not go on

ecology again at this time. That would dispose

of Wood’s proposal. Or, for instance, Colburn

might have responded to Wood’s proposal in

the following vein: What particular aspect of

524-726—73——2

10

ecology do you have in mind: Wood would re-

spond, with some details and elaboration: the

matter would then be discussed by those pres-

ent: Colburn might then say to Wood, all right,

give it a try. On some other subject thus raised,

Colburn might make it clear that there were

certain specifie things that he wished to be

stated in the particular proposed editorial, e.g..

the theme of the editorial should be that, on

balance, after weighing the arguments pro and

con. the Government should proceed with the

development of te supersonic transport plane

because of the need to maintain leadership in

the field of air transportation and because of

the need to maintain a viable aerospace indus-

try and the tens of thousands of jobs involved

in that and in satellite industries. The editorial

writer would follow such a directive.

Following the foregoing type of daily con-

ference with Colburn, Pearson, Wood, and

Blankenship would return to their offices. They

would then get together in Pearson's office and

discuss at greater length topics that had re-

ceived tentative approval at the conference with

Colburn. Views and possibly conflicting conten-

tions would be exchanged and argued. In most

instances it would be at this tripartite confer-

ence that definite editorial topics would be as-

signed by Pearson, to Wood, Blankenship or

himself.

After a writer drafted or wrote an editorial.

it was then submitted to Pearson. He might

approve it, disapprove it, or prescribe changes

or revision. If the editorial cleared Pearson, it

would then go to Colburn. Again, the editorial

might be approved, rejected, or rejected subject

to some particular revision being made. Trial

Examiner's Decision, Findings and Conelu-

sions.

Whenever a particular member of the editorial de-

partment was assigned a topic which he or she felt

TE. ene et ee Te te

ll

unable to write upon, either for reasons of personal

conviction or otherwise, upon request the writer would

be excused from the assignment. However, as the trial

examiner found, **. . . every witness in this case,

including Wood, agrees that the editorials of the news-

paper function as the voice of [the newspaper's]

ownership and management. What appears in an edi-

torial is the subjective viewpoint of management.”

Trial Examiner's Decision, Findings and Conclusions.

Petitioner newspaper contends that editorial writers

have the essential characteristics of managerial and

confidential employees and therefore the two editorial

writers in question, Mrs. Wood and Mr. Blankenship,

were improperly included in the collective bargaining

unit to begin with, and the newspaper’s action in

transferring Mrs. Wood was not properly subject to

the Act’s coverage. On the particular facts of this

case, as brought out in the trial examiner’s Decision

and from an ext-nsive reading of the record, we agree.

We recognize that the task of determining the appli-

cation of the term “employee’’“. . . has been assigned

primarily to the agency created by Congress to admin-

ister the Act... NLRB v. Hearst Publications, Inc., 322

U.S. 111: Allied Chemical & Alkali Workers v. Pitts-

burgh Plate Glass Co., 404 U.S. 157. The courts, how-

ever, “. . . have never immunized Board judgments

from judicial review in this respect.”’ Allied Chemical

d& Alkali Workers v. Pittsburgh Plate Glass Co. The

court said in NERB vy. North Arkansas Electric Co-

operative, Inc., 412 F.2d 324 (8th Cir.):

The term “managerial employee’’ is not used

in the National Labor Relations Act, nor is pro-

vision made in the Act for the inclusion or ex-

clusion of such employees in bargaining units.

The Act is silent as to whether this type of

emplovee is entitled to the protection of the Act

SSID

yay eevee Tey ere

12

for union activities or membership. The Board,

however, has long followed the practice of ex-

cluding employees, desigreted as “managerial,”’

from bargaining units in representation elec-

tions. It does so on the premise that certain

non-supervisory employees are so closely allied

with management that they should be excluded

from employee bargaining units.

Althongh the Board considers editorial writers such

as Mrs. Wood to be employees within the meaning of

the Act, A. S. Abell Co., 81 NLRB 82, 83 (1949), and

there does seem to be some language in the case of

Associated Press v. NLRB, 301 U.S. 103, which could

support this position, a closer reading of the latter

ease in view of its facts leads us to another conclusion.

Associated Press dealt not with a person who was

actively engaged in the “formulating, determining and

effectuating” of the employer’s policies. Illinois State

Journal-Reaister, Ine. v. NLRB, 412 F.2d 37 (7th

Cir.) : Retai! Clerks International Ass’n, AFL-CIO V.

NLRB, 366 F. 2d 642 (D.C. Cir.). Rather, that case

dealt with a person who, although characterized as an

‘‘oditor” or “editorial employee,” was employed ™. . .

to determine the news value of items received and

speedily and accurately to rewrite the copy delivered

to [him], so that the rewritten matter [should] be

delivered to the various filing editors ... respon-

sible for its transmission, if appropriate, to the areas

reached by their circuits.”

Regardless of which appellation is given to the em-

ployee in Associated Press, whether it be ‘‘editor.”

‘editorial employee,” or a member of the “news de-

partment,” his position was much more akin to that

of the employees in the news department of the peti-

tioning Wichita Eagle & Beacon Publishing Co., Inc.,

in the instant case than to that of Mrs. Wood. The

2 PE PPE DTT AS BEE ME AEA BC IV

13

hierarchy of personnel in Associated Press was such

that the aggrieved employee was responsible, in turn,

to a filing editor, various “editorial employees,” ‘‘su-

pervising editors,’’ and an ‘“‘executive news editor” in

the “news department” of the Associated Press.

Although Mrs. Wood was responsible to the editorial

page editor, Mr. Pearson, and in turn to the editor

and publisher of the newspaper, Mr. Colburn, as con-

cerns the content and direction of the newspaper's

editorials, she nevertheless was an active participant

in “formulating, determining and effectuating” the

newspaper's journalistic policies. The daily confer-

ences between Colburn, Pearson, Wood. and

Blankenship attest to this relationship. While subject

to supervision in her writing by the editorial page

editor and the editor and publisher, Mrs. Wood could,

and did, propose topics for editorials, propound her

oWn Viewpoint in an effort to influence editorial policy

on various subjects, and was, in sum, an integral par-

ticipant in the newspaper’s subjective voice, its edi-

torials. Whether termed a managerial employee, a con-

fidential employee, or whatever, Mrs. Wood's relation-

ship to the newspaper and its staff placed her in a

position where she was intimately involved in “formu-

lating, determining and effectuating” her employer’s

policies. Illinois State Journal-Register, Ine. ¥..

NERB, 412 F.2d 37 (7th Cir.); Westinghouse Elec-

tric Corp. v. NLRB, 398 F.2d 669 (6th Cir.) : Retail

Clerks International Ass'n, AFL-CIO y. NLRB, 366

F.2d 642 (D.C. Cir.).

Mrs. Wood may not have been a “Chief”? (in the

words of the trial examiner), but she was certainly a

member of the Chief’s council in the formulation of

editorials. We recognize that she had no formal hand

in determining wages, hours, and working conditions

for employees on the newspaper, nor did she par-

14

ticipate in such matters as basie ownership and man-

agement policies in the area of profit and loss and the

like. Cf. North Arkansas Electric Cooperative, Tne.,

185 NLRB No. 88 (1970), 75 LRRM 1068-69. There

is. however, a distinction between the reporting of

news and the creation and expression of subjective

opinion on behalf of a newspaper. To hold that a per-

son who was involved in the formulation of editorial

content of a newspaper is not aligned with the news-

paper’s management would come perilously close to

infringing wpon the newspaper’s First Amendment

euarantee of freedom of the press.

The business of the newspaper is not immune from

the Act’s coverage merely because it is an agency of

the press. Associated Press V. NLRB. The newspaper

is not contesting the Board’s determination that its

news department employees are a proper collective

bargaining unit and come within the Act’s protections.

Although the Board's ruling in this case does not have

any relation to the impartial distribution of news, per

se. nor to the newspaper's ability and freedom to pub-

lish the news as it desires it published ( Associated

Press ¥. NLRB), it does infringe upon the news-

paner’s freedom to determine the content of its editor-

ial voice in an atmosphere of free discussion and ex-

change of ideas.

We therefore reject the Board’s determination that

the two editorial writers, Mrs. Wood and Mr. Bianken-

ship, were “employees” under the National Labor Re-

lations Act. Rather, we hold that they were so closely

aligned with the newspaper’s management in the form-

ulation, determination, and effectuation, not to men-

tion expression, of the newspaper management's pol-

icies through its editorials as to be properly excluded

from the collective bargaining unit of news department

employees.

A Rt ey

15

As the Supreme Court has noted:

* * * (T]n the normal course of events Board

orders in certification proceedings under § 9 (¢)

are not directly reviewable in the courts. This

Court held as long ago as American Federation

of Labor v. Labor Board, 308 U.S. 401, that the

‘*final order[s]** made reviewable by §§ 10 (e)

and (f) in the Courts of Appeals do not include

Board decisions in certification proceedings.

Such decisions, rather, are normally reviewable

only where the dispute concerning the correct-

ness of the certification eventuates in a finding

by the Board that an unfair labor practice has

been committed as, for example. where an em-

ployer refuses to bargain * * *. In such a ease,

69 (d) of the Act makes full provision for

judicial review of the underlying certification

order by providing that “such certification and

the record of such investigation shall be in-

cluded in the transcript of the entire record re-

quired to be filed”? in the Court of Appeals.

Boire v. Greyhound Corp., 376 U.S. 473. See also

Magnesium Casting Co. v. NLRB, 401 U.S. 137. This

is the situation in this case. The newspaper has duly

tiled objections to and requests for review of the col-

lective bargaining unit determination at every step

in this controversy. On the facts here present we find

that the Board’s Decision and Order are not sup-

ported by ‘substantial evidence on the record consid-

ered as a whole.”’ National Labor Relations Act, § 10

(e), 29 U.S.C. § 160(e). Accordingly, the petition for

review is granted, and the Decision and Order of the

National Labor Relations Board, filed September 29,

1972, is vacated.

APPENDIX B

May Term—July 2, 1973

Before Honorable Orte L. PHILuips, Senior Circuit

Judge, Honorable OLIveR SETH and Honorable W1IL-

tum J. Hottoway, Jr., Circuit Judges.

No. 72-1673

Wicuita Eacte & Beacon Pusiisuine Co., INc.,

PETITIONER

Vv.

NatIoNaL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD, RESPONDENT

This cause came on to be heard on the petition for

review of the decision and order of the National

Labor Relations Board, and was argued by counsel.

On consideration whereof, it is ordered that the

petition for review is granted and the decision and

order of the National Labor Relations Board, filed

September 29, 1972, is vacated.

Howarp K. PHILLIPS,

Clerk.

By: Lavon M. IRLBECK,

Deputy Clerk.

A true copy.

Teste:

Howarp K. PHILLIPS,

Clerk, U.S. Court of

Appeals, Tenth Circuit.

(16)

APPENDIX C

United States of America Before the National Labor

Relations Board

Case 17—CA—4800

Wicuita Eacre & Beacon PvsrisHine Co., Inc.

and

Wicuita Newsparer Guitp, AFFILIATED WITH THE

NewspaPer Guitb, AFL-CIO

DECISION AND ORDER

On May 8, 1972, Trial Examiner Ramey Denovan

issued the attached Decision in this proceeding. There-

after, Respondent filed exceptions to the Trial Ex-

aminet’s Decision and a supporting brief.

Pursuant to the provisions of Section 3(b) of the

National Labor Relations Act, as amended, the Na-

tional Labor Relations Board has delegated its author-

ity in this proceeding to a three-member panel.

The Board has considered the record and the Trial

Examiner's Decision in light of the exceptions and

brief and has decided to affirm the Trial Examiner's

rulings, findings, and conclusions and to adopt his

recommended Order.

ORDER

Pursuant to Section 10(¢) of the National Labor

Relations Act, as amended, the National Labor Rela-

tions Board adopts as its Order the recommended

Oxder of the Trial Examiner and hereby orders that

the Respondent, Wichita Eagle Eagle & Beacon Pub-

(17)

524-726—73-—-3

18

lishing Co. Ine., Wichita, Kansas, its officers, agents

successors and assigns the Trial Examiner’s recom-

mended Order.

Dated Washington, D.C.

[September 29, 1972

[SEAL ]

NaTionaL LABor RELarions Boarp,

Epwarp B. MILLER, Chairman.

Joun H. Fannine, Vember.

JoHN A. PENELLO, Member.

United States of America, Before the National Labor

Relations Board, Division of Trial Examiners,

Washington, D.C.

Wicuita Eacte & BEacon PUBLISHING Co. INC.

and

WicHITA NEWSPAPER GUILD, AFFILIATED WITH THE

NEWSPAPER GUILD, AFL-CIO

Gerald A. Wacknov, Esq., for the General Counsel.

Jim Lawing, Esq., for the Charging Party. Gerritt

H. Wormhoudt, Esq., for the Respondent.

TriaL EXxAMINER’S DECISION

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

RaMeY Donovan, 7'rial Examiner: A charge and an

amended charge were filed on August 18, 1971 and on

January 10, 1972, respectively, by Wichita Newspaper

Guild, aftilated with The Newspaper Guild, AIF L-

C1O, herein the Union, against Wichita Eagle & Bea-

con Publishing Co., Inc., herein the Respondent, the

Company, or the Employer. The complaint issued on

January 11 1972, was amended at the instant hearing

pursuant to a Notice of Intention To Amend. As

amended, the complaint alleged threats of reprisal

against employees because of Union membership and

19

activity and that Respondent had transferred employee

Dorothy Wood from its editorial department to its

Sunday magazine department because of her meinber-

ship and actiivty in the Union, all in violation of

Section 8(a)(1) and (3) of the National Labor Rela-

tions Act, herein the Act. Respondent in its answer

has denied the commission of the alleged unfair labor

practices. It has also, in its answer, invoked specified

constitutional provisions and amendments to support

its affirmative contention that Wood and other edi-

torial writers are not “employees”? within the meaning

of the Act and that the National Labor Relations

Board, herein the Board, has no jurisdiction “as to

the employment relationship of such persons.’* The

case was tried in Wichita, Kansas, on March 2-3,

1972."

FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS

I. Jurisdiction

Respondent is engaged in the publishing, sale and

distribution of daily newspapers and has its main of-

fice and principal place of business in Wichita, Kan-

sas. In the course of its newspaper operations, Re-

spondent has an annual gross volume of business in

excess of $200,000. Respondent holds membership in,

or subscribes to, interstate news services, publishes

nationally syndicated features, and advertises nation-

ally sold products.

At all times material, Respondent has been and is an

employer engaged in commerce within the meaning of

Section 2(6) and (7) of the Act.

The Union has been and is, at all times material, a

labor organization within the meaning of Section

2(5) of the Act.

*The General Counsel's motion to correct the transcript of

testimony is unopposed and is granted, including p. 259. line

22, change “have waived” to “have not waived.”

20

II. The Alleged Unfair Labor Practices

Background

Respondent employs approximately 667 full-time

and 127 part-time employees. From Monday to Fri-

day Respondent publishes the Wichita Eagle, a morn-

ing paper, and the Wichita Beacon, an evening paper.

A combined edition, the Wichita Eagle & Beacon, is

published on Saturday and on Sunday. There were

approximately 143 persons employed in the news and

editorial department. The Eagle employed 55 em-

ployees and the Beacon 36. Fifty-three employees were

employed in sections that served both papers.

In the spring of 1970, the Union commenced orga-

nizational activities among Respondent’s employees.

A petition for certification was filed with the Board

by the Union in August, 1970. Thereafter, in Sep-

tember, 1970, the Board conducted a hearing on the

petition. All parties participated in the hearing. On

November 30, 1970, the Board, through its Regional

Director, issued a Decision and Direction of Election.

The aforementioned Decision found that the follow-

ing was an appropriate bargaining unit:

All employees of the news and editorial depart-

ment of the Wichita Eagle & Beacon Publish-

ing Co., Inc., in Wichita, Hutchinson, and To-

peka, Kansas, excluding professional employees,

guards and supervisors as defined in the Act,

and excluding all other employees.

As disclosed in the Decision, the parties had stipu-

lated in accordance with the record, and it was found,

that the following positions within the news and edi-

torial department would be excluded as supervisors,

confidential secretaries, or as persons allied with man-

agement: (Eagle & Beacon) editor and publisher, ex-

ceutive editor, secretary to executive editor, state news

“

21

editor, associate editor of public affairs, editorial page

editor, head librarian, chief photographer, and Wom-

en’s editor; (Eagle) managing editor, night manag-

ing editor, city editor, executive sports editor, sports

production editor; (Beacon) managing editor, secre-

tary to managing editor, assistant managing editor,

and sports editor.

In addition to the foregoing exclusions from the

unit, the Board excluded, as supervisors, two assist-

ant city editors (Eagle) as contended for by the Com-

pany. Contrary to the Company's position, the assist-

ant chief photographer was found not to be a super-

visor and was included in the unit. Although the wom-

en’s editor was excluded as a supervisor, it was found

on the evidence in the record that the women’s news

editor was not a supervisor and she was included in

the unit. The Company had contended that two edi-

torial writers, Dorothy Wood and Theodore Blanken-

ship, were supervisors and should be excluded from

the unit. The Board found, however, that the two edi-

torial writers were not supervisors and that they did

hot possess the indicia of managerial emplovees.

Their positions, therefore, were included in the unit.

Following the aforedescribed Decision and Direction

*Jnter alia, the Board Decision, is referring to the two edi-

torial writers, stated:

“Record testimony reflects that neither Blankenship nor Wood

possess any indicia of statutory supervisory authority. All three

writers [Blankenship and Wood and Pearson, editor of the edi-

torial page; Pearson was excluded from the unit in view of his

supervisory status over Blankenship and Wood]. including the

editor, have individual offices, and are under the direct super-

vision of the editor and publisher [Colburn] and major stock-

holders of the Company, with respect to questions of editorial

policy. There is nothing in the evidence to indicate that the—

two editorial writers , in any way, possess indicia of man-

agerial employees...”

of Election, the Employer filed with the Board a re-

quest for review of the Decision and Direction of Elec-

tion.” The request for review was limited to the matter

of the inclusion in the unit of the two editorial em-

plovees. On about December 31, 1971, the Board

denied the request for review on the ground that “—

raises no substantial issues warranting review.”

An election was conducted by the Board on Janu-

ary 6, 1971, in the unit that it had determined was

appropriate. Thereafter, in January, 1971, the Union

was certified as the collective-bargaining agent. The

Company and the Union commenced contract nego-

tiations in Mareh, 1971. At the time of the instant

hearing, agreement on a contract had not yet heen

achieved.

Dorothy Wood

Wood commenced work on the copy desk of the

old” Wichita Beacon in 1957. After about a vear she

became an assistant to the editor of the editorial page

of that paper. When the Eagle purchased the Beacon

in 1960, Wood was offered a position with the Eagle,

the Beacon having heen discontinued as such. She

worked for the Eagle for several months as the educa-

tion writer. In about December, 1960, Wood left the

paper to become assistant editor of a magazine. She

returned to the newspaper in October, 1963. The news-

paper was then publishing as the Wichita Eagle &

Beacon. At the time of her return Wood had been

asked to work in the editorial page department. How-

ever, Colburn, editor and publisher, had then asked

her. when she returned, if, instead of the foregoing

editorial page work, she would be editor of the

°The Decision and Direction were by the Board's Regional

Director acting pursuant to duly delegated authority of the

Board. As provided, the Employer's request for review had

been directed to the Board itself.

oe

23

paper’s Sunday’s magazine. Wood held the latter po-

sition until about February, 1965. Apparently because

of some change in the nature of the Sunday maga-

zine, Wood decided that she did not wish to continue

working in that section of the paper. She applied for

and received a transfer to the editorial page depart-

ment in February 1965.‘ Wood continued as a writer

in the editorial page department until August 16, 1971,

when she was involuntarily transferred to the posi-

tion of editor of the Sunday magazine.

As the Board found in the representation case, pre-

viously described, and as the evidence in the instant

case shows, the editorial page department of Respon-

dent consists of three people. Pearson, editor of the

editorial page, was an acknowledged supervisor of the

two employees in the editorial page department, Wood

and Blankenship. The two latter persons were writers

in the editorial page department. In a real but per-

haps ex officio sense, Colburn, editor and publisher,

was also part of the editorial page department. Pear-

son reported directly to Colburn and no editorial,

whether written by Pearson, Wood or Blankenship,

was published without prior submission to, and clear-

anee by, Colburn. Insofar as the two writers were con-

cerned, editorials written by them were initially sub-

ject to Pearson's scrutiny, review, and clearance, and

they were subject to his direction and supervision.

The foregoing organizational structure of the edi-

torial page department discloses that the two writers,

Wood and Blankenship, are Indians rather than

Chiefs. The two management supervisors are quite

clearly Colburn and Pearson. Wood and Blankenship

* Referring to the Sunday magazine, Wood. in her testimony

stated that she thought “it was abominable and I didn't want

to edit it any longer and I asked if I could go back to the job

that I originally applied for and had been asked to apply for”

[i.e., editorial page writer].

a ee

ee et

are the editorial page people who are supervised. They

themselves possess no indicia of a supervisor as the

term is defined in the Act, broad though the defini-

tion is” The two writers supervise no one in their own

department or in any other department.

In the relationship of the Employer (manage-

ment) to its employees regarding wages, hours, and

working conditions, the two writers have no manage-

ment role nor any other role distinguishing them from

other employees. The area of an employer's relation-

ship to its employees regarding the latter’s wages,

hours. and working conditions is the crux and the am-

bit of the Act. Congress has recognized that those

who represent and act for management in the em-

ployer-employee arena are management's agents and

are not employees. They are excluded from alignment

or inclusion with employees when the latter deal with

management through a labor organization.

In addition to having no management role or par-

ticipation in employer-employee relaticns, there Is no

evidence or contention that Wood or Blankenship were

participants in or privy to basie ownership and man-

agement policies in the area of profit and loss, eapitali-

zation, stock issuance, stock distribution or owner-

ship, acquisition or disposition of real or other prop-

erty or expansion or contention of the enterprise, or

related management policy. Management policy or

views that were expressed in editorials were deter-

mined by Colburn, the editor and publisher, or per-

haps, ultimately, by the owners of the newspapers.

We now examine the normal day to day operations

and activities of the editorial page department and of

its personnel, including certain of their outside activi-

ties and Respondent's rules relating thereto.

5 See. 2(11).

Ne

25

Although almost all descriptive terms are relative,

Wwe can appropriately describe the editorial page

people as creative writers. They are craftsmen (and

women) of the written word and they are professional

writers. They deal with events and ideas in an inter-

meshed context. As individuals, they are aware of and

participate as members of the community in world, na-

tional, and local affairs; they read and they ruminate;

they discuss and confer, and they write.

Every witness in this case, including Wood, agrees

that the editorials of the newspaper function as the

voice of Respondent's ownership and management.

What appears in an editorial ix the subjective view-

point of management. An editeria! prepared by Wood

cr Blankenship must have the appreval of Pearson

and Colburn before it is published, with Colburn hav-

ing the ultimate determination. Whether the personal

views of an editorial writer coincide or differ, in

whole or in part, from what management wishes to say

in an editorial, the editorial is written to reflect man-

agement’s views. Neither Wood nor anyone else has

disputed the foregoing standard either in theory or in

practice. In any event, as aforementioned, no editorial

is approved or published without Colburn’s and Pear-

son’s clearance and approval.

Normal day to day procedure, in the editorial page

department, was the holding of a mid-morning con-

ference, with Colburn, Pearson, Wood and Blanken-

ship participating. In turn, at the conference, Pear-

son. Woed, and Blankenship would be asked what he

or she had in mind for an editorial. Wood, for in-

stance, when thus asked, might say that she had in

mind writing a piece on ecology. Colburn or Pearson

might say that we had an editorial on air and water

pollution last week so we will not go on ecology again

at this time. That would dispose of Wood’s proposal.

524-726—7,-—__4

BB Te ER —

26

Or, for instance, Colburn might have responded to

Wood’s proposal in the following vein: what par-

ticular aspect of ecology do you have in mind; Wood

would respond, with some details and elaboration ; the

matter would then be discussed by those present; Col-

burn might then say to Wood, all right, give it a try.

On some other subject thus raised, Colburn might

make it clear that there were certain specific things

that he wished to be stated in the particular proposed

editorial, e.g., the theme of the editorial should be that,

on balance, after weighing the arguments pro and con,

the Government should proceed with the development

of the supersonic transport plane because of the need

to maintain leadership in the field of air transporta-

tion and hecause of the need to maintain a viable aero-

space industry and the tens of thousand of jobs in-

volved in that and in satellite industries.’ The editorial

writer would follow such a directive.

Following the foregoing type of daily conference

with Colburn, Pearson, Wood, and Blankenship would

return to their offices.’ They would then get together in

Pearson’s office and discuss at greater length topics

that had received tentative approval at the conference

with Colburn. Views and possibly conflicting conten-

tions would be exchanged and argued. In most in-

6 The Trial Examiner is. of course. stating a supposititious

case in order to flesh out the clear import of testimony in the

record describing the nature of the editorial page conferences

with Colburn.

-'The offices are on the third floor rear. The president or

owner of the Company occupies an office in the extreme south-

east corner. Pearson's office is north of the president's. separated

by a reception room and the office of the president’s secretary.

The offices of the two editorial writers are next to Pearson’s.

From this area. and on the same floor, there are, in turn geo-

graphically. the library, the women’s section, the sports depart-

ment and then the newsroom.

i apes

27

stances it would be at this tripartite conference that

definitive editorial topics would be assigned by Pear-

son, to Wood, Blankenship or himself.

After a writer drafted or wrote an editorial, it was

then submitted to Pearson. He might approve it, dis-

approve it, or prescribe changes or revision. If the

editorial cleared Pearson, it would then go to Colburn.

Again, the editorial might be approved, rejected, or

rejected subject to some particular revision being

made.

Weod testified that in her more than 6 vears as an

editorial writer for Respondent there had been ocea-

sicns when she or another writer, at one of the afore-

described editorial conferences, might be assigned to

a topic that was distinctly unpalatable to that particu-

lar writer or concerning which she believed she could

not write with reasonably good conviction. In such

situations, Wood or whoever else might find himself

in a similar position, would ask to be excused from

the assignment. Management would customarily honor

such a request and would assign the topic to someone

else. However, there is no contention or instance in

this record where management, Colburn, or Pearson,

told Wood that, despite your feelings. we want you to

write this editorial and she refused to do so or, where,

under such circumstances, she failed to perform with

professional competence. As Wood credibly testified :

if her request to be excused from a particular topic

was not honored, she, “‘like any other employee

fwonld have obeyed management’s order]. I would

have put it [the topic] into writing for them because,

as he had said, that is our job to write out what man-

agement’s view is.”’ Confirmation that Wood per-

formed her job as a professional writer in the man-

ner that Respondent prescribed is admitted by both

Colburn and Pearson. Colburn, for instance, was

28

asked if it was not a fact that Wood had *‘received

her salary increases and you found no fault and al-

ways thought she was a good employee?’ He replied:

‘Obviously, or we wouldn’t have kept her on.”’ This

was true despite the fact that at times Colburn and

Pearson state that, in their view, Wood became **emo-

tional’? about certain contentions or points of view.

At various times Colburn had complimented Wood on

a particular editorial that she had written.

In addition to writing editorials, the editorial page

people each had a column that appeared on the edi-

torial page. Unlike the editorials, the writers of the

respective columns were identified. Thus, Wood had

x column called, ‘Ladies Day’’ that appeared with

her name and picture in the Wednesday night Beacon.

The column was a personal opinion type of thing

where Wood could write about subjects that interested

her, e.g., a snow storm, a sermon she had heard,

women’s rights and so forth. Generally, as contrasted

with the editorials, the writers did not discuss their

column ideas with Colburn or Pearson beforehand.

However, carbon copies of the proposed column were

submitted to Pearson prior to publication and he, in

turn, would submit the carbon to Colburn. The column

was not. published without the approval of Pearson

and Colburn.

To complete the foregoing picture of Wood as an

editorial page employee of Respondent since Febru-

ary 1965, the type of subjects on which she custom-

arily drafted editorials and her outside activities are

relevant. She focused on urban topics and frequently

wrote about schools and their problems.’ Welfare and

women’s rights were also within her ken. Labor-Man-

*Pearson’s column was entitled “Vagaries” and Blanken-

ship's was called, “It’s Not Serious.”

° At one time Wood had taught school.

ee

a eee

29

agement matters were not her topic. Indeed, accord-

ing to Wood’s uncontroverted testimony, labor-man-

agement was an infrequent topic on Respondent's

editorial page.

Wood was, at all times during her employment,

active in various groups and organizations. She was

active in the National Conference of Christians and

Jews; she was on the board of KPTS, a public tele-

vision station; she was a member of Presswomen of

the National Organization for Women: she had ap-

peared publicly on television with the aforementioned

Presswomen; she was a member of Fair (Forum to

Assure Individual Rights), an organization concerned

with the problems of welfare recipients; she was a

church member; a member of the board of the Heart

Association. Wood had made no secret of her many

outside activities and frequently discussed matters

with Pearson that had arisen at meetings of these

organizations. She had neither sought nor received

clearance from Respondent before joining or becoming

active in these various outside organizations and had

never been admonished regarding such activities.

Other persons working for Respondent also en-

gaged in outside activities. A city editor and a re-

porter serve as precinct committeemen for political

parties.” Colburn testified that Respondent had

granted permission for the foregoing activity. In the

last city election, both Pearson and Wood were active

in the selection and support of some candidates for

the city commission.” Colburn testified that during

The record is not clear whether they are both precinct

committeemen for the same political party (Democrat or Re-

publican) or whether each is a committeeman for a ditferent

party.

*t Wood and Pearson, as appears from the record. were good

friends and apparently shared a number of common view-

points.

LS Pe OS CELE ALI Tcl ON AA wn ? = eh RES SAE TE PS 8

30

some campaign Pearson had erected a sign in his yard

for a named congressman. Colburn states that he

had ordered Pearson to take down the sign but “it was

not removed as far as I [Colburn] know.”

There were also other outside activities of persons

employed by Respondent that had been discontinued

at Respondent’s request. Colburn, apparently came

with the paper in 1962 or 1963. At that time, Perry

was editor of the editorial page. He was on the board

of the Urban League. According to Pearson, Colburn

gave Perry the choice the resigning from the board

of the League or of severing his employment with Re-

spondent. Perry resigned from the League’s board.

Colburn testified that when he joined Respondent’s

staff, Mac Martin was writing pieces “for politicians

and specials and so on... he did it rather notoriously

and he worked both sides of the fence politically.”

Also, Colburn states that he found that some sports

writers “were writing for certain promoters.” The

foregoing activities ceased with Colburn’s advent and

the issuance of a handbook on Respondent’s policies

and rules.”

In April 1971, a publication or paper called the

Central Standard Times appeared with a fairly long

article headed: *

“Newsmen Make Payola Pay—Subtle PBla-

tant Bribes Exist On Every Paper in Country”

After a few introductory comments, e.g., “Newsmen

are nothing without their scruples, their ethics and

their independence. Based on that statement, many

newsmen are nothing. ‘Prostitution’ it’s called on a

more base level: payola is the legal term... .”’ and a

2 The relevant portions of the hendbook are described. intra.

From limited evidence in the instant record, the Central

Standard Times was evidently an “underground press” type

of publication.

+. co ethses

ee

31

quotation from a university professor, the balance of

the article castigates, by name, Respondent’s paper

and various editors, writers, and departments thereof.

Disproportionaate coverage by the paper of the local

professional baseball team is ascribed to the execu-

tive editor’s personal financial investment in the team

and his baseball role in the Chamber of Commerce.

Next, the executive sports editor is alleged to have

received and to be receiving money from teams and

sports organizations. The article then asserts that “a

situation unique to Wichita is the relationship be-

tween the aerospace writer and the city’s aircraft

company managers.’’ This theme is developed by

mentioning perquisites allegedly received by the aero-

space editor; it is stated that recently it was virtually

impossible to have the newspaper’s aerospace writer

“gather facts for a story unpalatable”’ to the aireraft

company management. Other departments and writers

on the paper are similarly accused of venality or cor-

ruption, including “incredibly biased editorial ac-

counts’’ regarding aspects of the prisoner of war

issue in Vietnam.

Colburn, upon learning of the foregoing article in

the Central Standard Times, wrote to each of the

7 Wichita Eagle and Beacon reporters because of

their “connection with some of the material that ap-

peared in the April edition of Central Standard

Times. ... [the] article infers through deceptive re-

porting and writing that corruption prevails in the

newsroom ... other inferences were made .. . that

reflect a lack of professionalism and a disrespect for

your employer [the Eagle and Beacon].”’ The letter

cited provisions in Respondent’s “Employee Hand-

bocl:,** regarding employee conduct. Colburn in the

letter, then informed the 7 recipients that they had

the choice to either disassociate themselves from the

<2 OMAR ee ett TRO! AE

Central Standard Times or to resign as employees of

Respondent.

The “Employee Handbook,” that employees of Re-

spondent received, described the paper’s history and

the rules, benefits, and related matters that applied

to employees. With respect to editorial policy, the

handbook stated, inter alia,

Label as editorial its [the paper’s] own views

or expressions of opinion . . . Stimulate and

vigorously support public officials, private

groups and individuals to increase the good

works and eliminate the bad in the community.

Serve as a constructive critic of government

at all levels, providing leadership for necessary

reforms or innovations .. .

Under ‘Publication Relations’? the handbook de-

clared,

You, as an employee, represent the Company

in your contacts with the public. Your conduct

will have some effect on the image others have

of the newspapers. For those who deal directly

with the public in the course of their work .. .

courtesy is required at all times... .

Telephone requests for information should be

handled politely ...

The next heading in the handbook is ‘Outside

Jobs.’’ It is there stated:

Under certain circumstances, a company em-

ployee may do limited outside work for pay if

it does not interfere with his duties to the com-

pany or impair his efficiency. Such outside jobs

must be approved by the department head in

advance.

Editorial and News Department employees

are forbidden to serve as public relations writ-

ers for political candidates or parties, or any

group seeking to influence news or editorial

policy.

at Abe

33

In the Examiner’s opinion the above ‘‘ Public Rela-

tions” rules deal with employee ‘‘conduct” vis-a-vis

the public. That is, the employee should be polite,

courteous and so forth since ‘“‘your conduct will have

some effect on the image other have of the newspa-

pers” and, in that sense, the employee” “represent[s]

the Company in [his or her] contacts with the pub-

lic.’? The section does not purport to deal with what

kind of outside job, work, affiliations or associations

are permitted or proscribed. By the same token, the

section on ‘‘Outside Jobs’’ is the guideline and the ex-

tent of the guideline on outside activities or affilia-

tions by employees. The import of the caption, ‘Out-

side Jobs,’’ is borne out by the text which speaks of

‘outside work for pay”; and the concern about such

‘‘outside work for pay’’ is in terms of impairment of

efficiency or interference with the employee’s perform-

ance of his duties with the papers. As to editorial and

news department employees, who are subject to the

general rules of the sections dealing with ‘‘Public Re-

lations’? and ‘‘Outside Jobs,”’ there is an additional

specific prohibition. They are not to serve ‘‘as public

relations writer for political candidates or parties”

nor are they to serve as public relations writers for

“any group seeking to influence news or editorial

policy.”’

Having seen the manner in which the editorial page

department and its editors and writers operated, as

well as their outside activities, and the rules of Re-

spondent’s Employee Handbook, we come to Wood’s

activities which are the crux of the instant ease.

When the Union began organization activities

among Respondent’s employees in the spring of 1970,

Wood signed a union card. She states that thereafter

there was considerable talk or “whispering” going

Naas ear EIA A Ee eee em ORT ER RRR TS OE SY

34

around about which employees had signed cards and

which had not.”

Wood and Pearson were good friends. Soon after

Wood joined the Union she told Pearson of this fact

at his home. Pearson *‘became very grave” at this in-

telligence but said it was Wood’s choice and that he

would do nothing to interfere with her choice. How-

ever, he said that he wanted to warn Wood as a friend

“that consequences were likely to be real severe.”

Without describing the consequences, Pearson told

Wood that the Company “would not like” the fact

that she had signed a card and that she “should be

prepared for any consequences.”

As previously mentioned, the Union filed a petition

for certification with the Board in August 1970. A

hearing on the petition was held in September 1970, at

which the Company, inter alia, opposed the inclusion

of editorial writers in the unit. In November 1970, but

evidently prior to the Decision and Direction of Elee-

tion. dated November 30, 1971, Wood told Pearson

that she had been invited to attend a meeting in Chi-

cage of women members of the Union. The meeting

was to be held on Saturday and Sunday. Wood pro-

posed to leave on Friday and work Monday of the fol-

lowing week instead of the Saturday of the meeting.

In short, she proposed a “swap” or trade of days off."

%* The other editorial writer, Blankenship, did not join the

Union. Since Wood was aware of this fact, it is quite possible

that others were aware, at least to some degree, of the union

supporters and opponents. Blankenship testified that, per-

sonally, he was opposed to the Union and felt that as an edi-

torial writer he “had the confidence of management” and that

it was not proper for him to join the Union.

‘8 Tt is probable that the parties did not receive the Decision

and Direction until December 1, 1970.

6 The Chicago meeting was evidently one called by the Union

at the request of its female members who wished to discuss the

problems of their sex as employees in the newspaper field.

35

Pearson said that he would ask Colburn. Pearson re-

turned and said that, although Colburn was not at all

pleased, Wood would be allowed to trade her day off.

This was done and Wood attended the meeting.

The Board election was held on January 6, 1971.

Wood was the union observer at the election.’ There-

after, in the same month, the Union was certified as

the bargaining agent for the unit. The local union has

a president, vice president, secretary and treasurer.

They and 3 other union members comprise the execu-

tive committee or board. On January 23, 1971, Wood

was elected as one of the non-officer members of the

executive committee.

In January 1971, after the Union was certified, the

four party (Colburn, Pearson, Wood, and Blanken-

ship) editorial conferences were discontinued. There

Was no announcement or proclamation but the confer-

ences were no longer held. The tri-party conferences of

Pearson, Wood, and Blankenship continued to be held

as before and Parson's daily contacts with Colburn

continued. For a brief period Colburn and one or two

other executives did not speak directly to Wood but

this situation did not continue. Colburn did resume

calling and speaking to Wood about this or that aspect

of the work as had been the case previously. However,

the four party conferences were never resumed while

Wood continued as a writer in the editorial page

department.

In the period after the editorial conferences with

Colburn had been discontinued, Wood discussed the

fact with Pearson on several occasions in January

i971. Pearson told her, ‘It is quite obvious that it

7 At Board elections. in addition to the Board agent, each

party, the emplover and the Union. has an observer that each

selects. The observer monitors the eligibility of voters and the

conduct of the election.

30

is beeause the Company did not want you to be in

the Guild [the Union] and Mr. Colburn does not

want to have editorial conferences with us any longer.

They made it a point that you are affiliated with the

Guild.” *

Preparatory to beginning contract negotiations with

Respondent, the Union, in February 1971, elected

members to its negotiating committee. Wood was one

of those elected to serve on the committee.” She par-

ticipated in negotiations thereafter.”

Colburn testified that in “late January or early

February, [1971]"° and ‘after the Guild won the

[Board] bargaining election and Mrs. Wood became

an officer of the Guild, I advised Mr. Pearson that

Mes. Wood should not be permitted to write any

editorials regarding labor affairs.”** Pearson sub-

stantially confirms Colburn on this aspect. Pearson

informed Woed that Colburn had decided she was not

to write any more editorials on labor matters. Wood

asked Pearson the reason for this decision. Pearson

replied that Colburn considered that, as a member

of the Union and as a wnion negotiator, she was

biased on labor matters and therefore should not

write editorials on that subject. Wood protested that

Wood was the enly person in the editorial page depart-

ment who was a member of the Union.

%* Negotiations began in March 1971.

2° Although Colburn was not one of the Company repre-

sentatives in negotiations, he was in close contact with the

Company representatives regarding various management pro-

posals and bargaining positions.

21. As we have seen. Wood became a member of the execu-

tive committee of the local union (the Guild) after the Union

was certified. She then was also elected to be a member of

the local union’s negotiating committee. As the term is cus-

tomarily used, she was not an officer of the Union although,

in our view, this is not a determining factor one way or the

other.

37

as a professional writer she could be fair and unbiased

no matter what her aftiliations. Pearson said he agreed

with that and had so informed Colburn but the latter

had adhered to his decision.”

Although Wood testified that she believed the above

edict regarding her not writing on labor subjects oc-

eurred in May, 1971, the evidence persuades us that

this occurred in late January or early February.

However, there was an incident around May, 1971 that

merits description. ,

From April into May 1971 the local public school

teachers, represented by the NEA, and the Wichita

board of education had been in negotiations regarding

pay increases for teachers. The evidence reveals no

strike or threat of strike. Apparently and predictably,

the community would be and was concerned about the

failure of the parties to resolve their differences in

this important public sector.

In one of the intramural editorial conferences of the

type previously described, Wood proposed writing an

editorial on the above dispute.” She outlined the sub-

stance of the editorial she had in mind. Pearson told

her to go ahead and prepare the editorial as outlined.

Wood did so and submitted the editorial to Pearson.

This was around the middle of May. Pearson read it

and said that it looked all right to him. Pearson took

the proposed editorial to Colburn. The next occur-

2? Pearson testified that Wood was a geod employee and a

good editorial writer. He said that as far as he knew she had

never written anything exploiting any prior activity that she

was engaged in. Pearson also testified:

“I believe I expressed to Mr. Colburn that T hod confidence

in her competence and that I thought that she was a pro-

fessional writer and that she could write on these snubjeets.”

*° Wood testified that she regarded the dispute as primarily a

public school problem involving the whole community rather

than as a labor-management confrontation.

ee

te eee eee

AN ee OO Ee RTA a tO

38

rence was a call from Colburn to Wood. Colburn made

it clear that he was not satisfied with the proposed edi-

torial. Colburn said to Wood that she had not been

thorough enough and that she should have talked to

Darrell Kellogg.* While Wood testified that she per-

sonally did not think that contracting Kellogg was

necessary, she did call him as suggested by Colburn.”

Using some material furnished to her by Kellogg, she

drafted a second editorial. The record does not show

whether she had turned in this latter editorial or was

still working on it when Respondent did publish an

editorial on the school dispute.

The published editorial was written by Pearson. It

was quite apparently written at Colburn’s direction

after his disapproval of Wood’s proposed editorial.

Since Pearson had approved Wood's editorial, it is

fairly evident that, in addition to heing directed to

write a substitute editorial, Pearson had reeecived

some kind of instruction from Colburn as to the tenor

or direction of the desired editorial.

It is no concern of the Trial Examiner what Re-

spondent says or dees not say in its editorial ahout

the school dispute. Our involvement in the matter of

these particular editorials is necessitated by Respond-

ent’s contention in its brief that Wood's inability to

write without bias on labor-management is demon-

strated by the episode of the school dispute. Thus,

Respondent asserts that ‘the salient facts favorable to

the school board” were not present in Wood's pro-

posed editorial as contrasted to the published edi-

torial.

“Kellogg is not identified in the record but Respondent's

brief indicates that Kellogg was a representative of the board

of education. also referred to as the “school board.”

2: There is no claim or evidence that originally or later Wood

had contacted a representative of the NEA before writing her

propo-ed editorial.

§os

39

Although Wood admits her sympathies lay with

the teachers, her editorial was brief and said nothing

about the merits of the issue in dispute or indicated

a position on the merits.” The sole theme and inyport

of the editorial was that “in the interest of the schools,

the teachers and the public, it looks like the time has

come to ask for mediation in the teacher contract nego-

tiations.””* Elsewhere, the editorial stated:

Apparently the main difficulties came in inter-

pretation of facts, partienlarly whether there

is money available for salary increases on the

scale asked by the teachers. NEA-Wichita has

ficures showing the board has money on hand;

the board contends that it doesn’t. Obviously,

some outside person or persons is needed to

ASSUSS ‘he facts.

The editorial published by Respondent also en-

dorsed and had the theme of mediation. In fact. as

published. the caption was **Why Not Mediation.”

The editorial stated:

The big dispute at the moment is over how

much money is really available for teacher sal-

ary increases. The hoard uses one set of figures,

the teachers another.

The editorial said that the board had done a better

jeb in explaining its figures than the NEA. It was

then stated that the board had a budget of a named

fizure: the board had allocated increases it deemed

Necessary to transportation, food service, equipment,

administrators, etc. and, if the raises asked by the

teachers were given, this would be a named figure

over the budget total: budget increases of more than

2 percent over the existing budget figure weuld re-

** General Counsel Exh. 7.

* A mediator’s role is to attempt to help and persuade the

partics to reach agreement. Unlike an arbitrator or a court

he cannot decide the issue or impose a settlement or a decision.

a

40

quire a vote of the people. The editorial, however.

again endorsed mediation as a possibility offering

hope of a “compromise or a reordering of priorities.”

that would resolve the dispute.

We do not purport to know all the salient facts in

the school dispute and we would not express an opin-

ion on them in any event. The position of the Re-

spondent, whether pro school board, or pro teachers

or pro public or whatever, does not concern us. Re-

spondent, at no time prior to her writing the proposed

editorial. indicated to Wood that its position was that

the school heard’s position was more tenable than that

of the teachers and that this should he indieated or

stated in the editorial. Indeed, Wood’s imme iate

supervisor, Pearson, had approved her editorial. Tt is

a dubious proposition that Wood should have known

that Respondent desired a tilt in the direction of the

school board’s position. There was probably a great

deal to be said on each side of the contending parties.

Wood's editorial did not assay the merits of the dis-

pute since she was sponsoring the theme of mediation.

Generally, if, for instance, the Government, or a cit-

izens’ group, or a newspaper, is eoing to urge media-

tion of a dispute, say, between the Longshoremen 's

Union and the Shipowners, it as the sponsor, does not

in the same breath indicate that it believes that ene

party to the dispute has the more tenable position.

Even a party disposed toward mediation may have

some second thoughts if, in sponsoring the mediation.

the sponsor has expressed an opinion on the merits

unfavorable to the aforesaid party. Moreover, even

after Colburn rejected Wood's editorial, he gave no

clear indication of what he wanted in the editorial or

whether he wanted the editorial to be down the mid-

dle or in one rather than in another direction. Such

directive as he gave, i.e., to talk to Darrell Kellogg

=>?

41

was carried through by Wood. In any event, we do not

perceive in this episode of the school editorial, evi-

dence of Wood's bias on labor matters or evidence of

incompetence as a professional writer. More impor-

tantly, we have difficulty in believing that a person

of Colburn’s intelligence and experience in the news-

paper field believed that, despite his failure to approve

Wood's editorial, the proposed school editorial showed

that Wood was incapable of writing professionally

and without bias on labor matters.

Around August 5, 1971, Wood and some other

women in the community met together on two occa-

sions. Their purpose was to form a women’s political

cancus, They invited women in the community to join

the movement or organization. On August 10 or 11,

the Political Caucus of Wichita Women was orga-

nized and temporary officers were elected. Wood was

elected coordinator, equivalent to chairwoman. An

executive committee was also selected. On the com-

mittee were women who were, respectively, teachers,

Writers, computer programmers, production manager

fer a printing and advertising company, a former

chairman (woman) of the Governor’s Commission on

the Status of Women, and a member of the Wichita

board of edueation.

A story describing the formation of the Women’s

Cauens appeared in the Respondent's Eagle on Au-

wast Il, 1971. It was written under the byline of

Respondent’s Women’s News Editor, Diane Lewis.

-\s described, the organization sought to have women

elected to public office and have them involved “in

the mainstream of Wichita and Kansas polities” and

to bring women’s interests to the attention of present

clected officials. Represented were women from the

Democratic and Republican parties as well as Inde-

pendents. “Dorothy Wood, editorial writer for the

SRE, OR RO : —

42

Wichita Eagle and the Beacon was named coordinator

of the group.”” Wood was quoted as stating:

We have become very concerned that although

Kansas women have been franchised for more

than 50 years, very few women have been

elected to responsible offices or hold high posts

within the political organizations. This hampers

all of society because 53 percent of the popula-

tion—women—is not adequately represented.

Also, on August 10 or 11, Wood was interviewed

briefly for one or two minutes on a 6 o'clock news

type of television show. Wood explained what the

Women’s Caucus was and what its goals were. She

had been introduced as the coordinator of the Caucus

and, apparently, as is customary on such programs.

she was asked what her occupation was. The answer

of course was that she was an editorial writer with

the Eagle and Beacon.*

Neither with respect to the newspaper story about

the Caucus nor in the brief television news interview.

had Wood written any press release or script. No

2° About a month before the actual formation of the Caucus.

Respondent’s Beacon had published an editorial entitled,

“Women’s Caucus.” The editorial was written by Wood. The

editorial described a meeting of the National Women’s Politi-

cal Caucus and its goals, as well as a suggestion from that

organization that local women in Wichita and elsewhere form

their own caucuses. The editorial then spoke of the desirability

of Kansas women becoming interested in assuming a more

active and prominent role in politics and thus correct the im-

balance in their political status. The editorial was completely

supportive of the idea of a Women’s Political Caucus and with

particular focus on the participation of Kansas women in ae-

tive and responsible political roles. Colburn testified that he

does not take issue with what the Women’s Political Caucus

stands for and that he subscribes to many of its ideals and

policies. In fact, there is no claim or evidence that Colburn or

Respondent was opposed to any of the goals or methods of

the Caucus.

43

effort was made to convey and no impression was con-

veyed, in our opinion, that Wood, and the other

women officers and committeewomen were participat-

ig in the Caucus as official representatives of their

employers. They were participating as individual

women and came from all political parties and a

Variety of occupations. The teachers’ participation,

for instance, did not indicate that the city of Wichita

Was sponsoring or was officially identified with the

Caucus. Wood and the other women officials were

ali identified by name and occupation since such

information is part of normal identification and

description in a newspaper or television presentation.

1f Wood had been held up and robbed in downtown:

Wichita, the news story, in print and on the air,

would no doubt state that last night, at the corner of

X and Y streets, Dorothy Wood, an editorial writer

of the Eagle and Beacon, was held up and robbed.

At no time after the August 11 newspaper report

or story about the Women’s Political Caucus or after

the television news interview thereon, did Respondent

receive mail or oral expression from its readers indi-

cating disapproval of the fact that one of its editorial

employees, Wood, was coordinator of the Wichita

Women’s Political Caucus.”

*° In the Examiner's opinion. if the average citizen and news-

paper reader and television viewer learned or was told that this

or that woman writer. reporter. photographer. doctor, lawyer,

saleswoman, secretary. was active and prominent in a movement

for women’s rights and equality in the political field. he or she

would be neither surprised nor concerned. By the same token,

there would be an equal lack of surprise and concern if it was

learned that this or that woman writer. saleswoman. or what-

ever, was not a member of or not active and prominent in a

woman's rights organization.

NOS A ADEN OLE LE 8 ELLIO IDLE OM LILY LDA AN «0 -

“ So ara a ET

44

On August 16, 1971, Wood was summoned to Col-

burn’s office.’ When she presented herself, Colburn

said that he had something that was going to upset

her and he preferred that she simply read it and

then they would discuss it later. He handed her a

letter or memorandum addressed to Wood from Col-

burn. She read this memorandum :

As you are aware, the Company has had a

long-standing practice that employees consider-

ing any type of outside work must consult their

department head to make sure there is no pos-

sible conflict of interest or that their position

with the paper is not exploited by other groups.

On August 11, we carried a news story report-

ing that you had become coordinator of A

Political Caucus of Wichita Women. Similar

reports were carried on radio and television

and you made at least one television appear-

ance.

‘harles Pearson advises me that he was not

consulted as to your accepting such a position

nor was I consulted in his absence. This is a

violation of company policy. Further, your

leadership in such a movement diminishes fu?-

ther your value and performance as a member

of the Eagle-Beacon editorial staff. Your pres-

ent involvement with the Wiehita Newspaper

Guild has made it necessary to prohibit your

writing editorial commentary on labor matters.

(underscoring supplied).

Your leadership role in the Political Caucus

is a conflict of interest because you have been

publicly identified as an editorial writer and

the public can question the credibility of the

newspapers as to any comment we may make,

regardless of the merits of the program out-

lined by the caucus or any future caucus proj-

ects that cannot be forseen at this time. This is

30 Pearson was on vacation in Minnesota during the entire

month of August.

a

DNR SS et I UPR EI eS Fe ath

45

possible, even though you have no hand in the

commentary.

Therefore, because of the restrictions we must

impose on the subjects you can handle for edi-

torial comment and because of the limitations

of the size of the editorial page staff, effective

August 23 you are being transferred tem-

porarily to the Sunday department with no

change in salary and with comparable work-

ing hours until the executive editor works out

a regular assignment for you.

After making reference to the newspaper and tele-

vision publicity on the Women’s Caucus and her role

therein, Wood asked Colburn why he had not said

anything to her before about the matter. He said that

he first had wanted to check with Pearson as to

whether Wood had discussed the subject with him.”

Wood than asked why Colburn had not told her that

he objected to her being coordinator of the Caucus.

He replied that she should have known how he felt

about it. Wood said that if she had known how he felt

and that he objected so strongly she might have con-

sidered resigning as coordinator. Colburn repeated

that she should have known how he felt. He did not

then give her the option of resignation and, as we

shall see from his testimony, he at no time entertained

the idea of affording Wood the option of resignation

of her position in the Caucus.

Wood was transferred to the Sunday department

where she served as editor of the Sunday Magazine

and a Sunday TV supplement. Sparks, who had held

the Sunday Magazine editorship until Wood's trans-

fer, took her place in the editorial department.

Wood states that, when she was still in the edi-

torial department, the fact that Sparks was not a

** Colburn had telephoned Pearson in Minnesota and. as was

the fact, Pearson said that Wood had not consulted him.

ecrrasine- converses mAE

46

member of the Union was made known to Pearson

in the course of office conversation. Although Pearson

denies knowledge of Sparks’ status vis-a-vis the

Union, Colburn did not testify on this aspect. In our

opinion, it is highly improbable that Colburn trans-

ferred Sparks to the editorial department without be-

ing aware of and considering his union status. Re-

spondent and Colburn have consistently held the view

that editorial writers were part of management and

should not be in the Union. As the evidence shows,

and as confirmed by Colburn’s letter to Wood on

August 16, 1971, her “involvement with the Wichita

Newspaper Guild’? was considered a major disability

in her employment as an editorial writer and was at

least one of two major factors in her removal from

that position. Under such circumstances, it strains

credulity to believe that Sparks’ membership or non-

membership in the Union was not known, or ascer-

tained and considered before he was appointed as an

editorial writer in place of Wood.

Wood's duties as editor in the Sunday department

were more or less mechanical and involved little, if

any. creative writing. She handled copy, wrote head-

ings, saw to the page layout and makeup, and assigned

some articles. At some later point the Sunday Maga-

zine was discontinued and combined with a section

enlled **Modern Living.” Wood wrote half of Modern

Living. She no longer edits TV week but, since Febru-

ary 1972, she writes a television column. She also edits

the entertainment section for the Friday edition of the

Beacon. Wood testified that she considered her trans-

fer to be a demotion despite the fact that her salary

remained the same. The principal reason why she felt

this way was her interest in creative writing. Al-

though management scrutinized and cleared the work

of the editorial writers, Wood regarded the work as

47

basically creative and certainly more so than in the

position to which she was transferred.

Colburn testified that Wood’s transfer “was based

on the diminution of her talents as an editorial writer

beeause of her involvement in outside activities.”

Q. And what was the outside activity ?

A. One was the outside activity dealing as a

labor negotiator; two, coordinator of the Wom-

en’s Caucus.

The Act which governs this proceeding does not as

such protect activities other than employees’ union

and concerted activities for the purpose of collective

bargaining or other mutual aid or protection. Con-

sequently, if the only facts in this case were that an

employee named Wood was transferred from her job

because of activities or role in the Women’s Political

Caucus, the matter would not be cognizable under the

Act. But such is not the instant case. If we accept the

above-quoted explanation for Wood's transfer as tes-

tified to by Colburn, one of the two reasons for Re-

spondent’s action was Wood’s union activities. Dis-

crimination against an emplovee for such a reason is

egal and a violation of Section 8(a)(3) and (1) of

the Act. This is true, if, in addition to the illegal rea-

son, the discrimination is also due to another reason

or two reasons, only one of which is proscribed by the

Act.**

But, Respondent apparently argues, Wood's union

activity is not protected by the Act because she was

** Section 7 of the Act.

“Even though part of the motivation for Weber's discharge

night. have been a needed cutting of expenses. such circumstances

could not be legally used to effectuate a companion motive to

rid the company of a union protagonist.” (citations omitted)

V.L.R.B. v. West Side Carpet Cleaning Co., 329 F.2d 758. 761

(C.A. 6).

“We have repeatedly held ‘that if the discharge is because of

union activity it is a violation of the Act even though a valid

ia PEL Ey PPE ME TT

prac et are es = ot INE Sa wr = . RN PR aA Be WS

48

not simply a member of the Union but was also on the

Union's negotiating committee and on its executive

board. The Act, however, does not make the distinction

that Respondent seeks to make. In our opinion, the

Act protects the right of an employee not only to join

a union but to assume an active role therein. This in-

cludes the protected right to serve on union commit-

tees whether the committees are contract negotiating

committees, grievance committees of whatever: al-

though Wood was not a union officer, an employee has

the protected right to be an officer in the Union. -\t

such time as an employee becomes a paid employee of

a union, (or any other employer) e.g., if Wood had

become a full (or part) time paid representative or

business agent of the Union, she would be an employee

of the Union. Her original employer would no longer

be obliged to retain her as an employee and her em-

ployee rights under the Act wouid relate to her union

employer.”

ground for dismissal might exist’ (citations omitted). V.Z.2.B.

v. Longhorn Transfer Nervice, 346 F.2d 1003, 1006 (C.A. 5).

See also V.Z.R.B. v. Nachman Corp. 337 F.2d 421, 423-4

Cee oes

°* There are a number of cases where unions. as employers.

have been involved in NLRB cases where their employees

charged them with unfair labor practices In Retail Clerks [nter-

national Association, AFL-CIO v. N.L.R.B.. 360 F.2d 642

(C.A.D.C.) Cert. denied 386 U.S. 1017, the full time paid In-

ternational Representatives of the Union had joined another

union in their status of employees of the International Union.

Among other grounds, their employer (the Union) vigorously

contended that the representatives were managerial people and

not employees. In support of this position it was pointed out

that the International Representatives were the agents of their

employer, the Union, and that the relationship was not only

confidential but possessed certain internal political aspects in

addition to the managerial role of International Representatives

in dealing with the local unions and in dealing with employers.

The Board and the Court rejected these contentions and held

that the representatives were employees under the Act.

a RR 6ce

49

Respondent then contends that while one of the two

reasons for Wood’s transfer was her union activity,

Respondent’s action was due to the fact that such

union activity impaired and undermined both her

status and her usefulness as an editorial writer. The

record reveals the factors used by Respondent in pro-

ducing this proposition.

In the representation case and in the instant case,

Resnondent’s consistently held proposition and prem-

ine is that editorial page writers such as Wood are

part of management and are not employees. From such

a premise it follows, as Respondent saw it and does

now contend, that editorial writers, since they are

management people, cannot and should not engage in

union activities or be in a union, because they cannot

perform their management role since their ability,

effectiveness and integrity as management people

Writers is destroved by their union association and

activity.”

The difficulty with the foregoing is that the all im-

portant premise is without support. The Board has

found, after litigation of the issue, that editorial writ-

ers are employees and Wood, as :n editorial writer. is

an employee in the bargaining unit and is protected

by the Act’s provisions. Further, the evidence in the

instant case, in our opinion, fully confirms that the

editorial writers are employees.

While some employers have believed and others

have asserted the belief that an employee's affiliation

with or activity in a union impairs his loyalty, effec-

tiveness, productivity, integrity and so forth, such

** Wood was not an employee of the Union. In important

respects, the Union is the agent of the employees. It becomes

the collective-bargaining agent of the latter by the choice or

vote of the latter. By a similar process a union can be de-

certified by the employees and thus lose its status as bargaining

agent.

-~----

50

belie’s cannot negate the policies and provisions of

the Act. An emplover’s fiat of belief cannot change

an employee into a part of management or remove

the employee from the Act's protection.

On the sole basis of the legally untenable premise

and the syllogistie type reasoning flowing therefrom

and described in the second paragraph above, Respen-

dent decided that, because Wood was a union member

and a union committeewoman, her effectiveness and

integrity as an editorial writer was impaired. Without

any evidence that Wood, as an admittedly competent

professional editorial writer, had not, or would ‘not,

or could not, write, as directed, editorials expressing

management's views. Respondent, after discontinuing

all full seale editorial conferences for the quite ap-

parent reason that it was displeased that Wood was a

union member and activist, then barred Wood from

writing any editorials on labor subjects. Respondent

now asserts that since Wood's effectiveness and in-

tegrity as an editorial writer was thus impaired by

Respondent's fiat, this impairment was one of the

reasons for her transfer.

In important respects Respondent's position and

contentions in this case have been dealt with before.

Thus, in A. S. Abe?! Co., 81 NLRB 82, the Board

stated:

The Emplever states that it has carefully

selected and instructed its editerial writers, and

that it insists that they keep themselves free

from outside commitments which might inpatr

their judgment or divide their lovalties, Tt con-

tends that to ask such men te participate Ina

nnien election is te ask then te ceonmreimise

themselves, to Vield part of their loyalty te an

outside organization. The Board rejects thie.

contention. We cannot subscribe to the sug-

524-726—73——_7

dl

gestion that participation in a union election

or membership in a labor organization **eom-

romises”’ integrity or freedom of thought. The

Rapreme Court dismissed a similar argument,

saving :

“The order of the Board in nonwise cirewn-

scribes the full freedoin and liberty of the Peti-

tioner to publish the news as it desires it pub-

lished or to enforce policies of its own ¢hoos-

ing...and... to discharge .. . any editorial

employee who fails te comply with the policies

it may adopt.” (Associated Press vy. N.L.R.B.,

301 U.S. 103)

The above cited Associated Press case covers many

matters raised by Respondent in the instant case.

In the preceding paragraphs, we have accepted,

arguendo, Respondent’s contention that Wood's ac-

tivities in the Union and her activities in the Wom-

en’s Caucus were the two reasons why her ability

and effectiveness as an editorial writer were im-

paired and thus led to her transfer. In that context,

we have concluded that Respondent's position is

legally untenable for the reasons cited above. We find

that Respondent has violated Section 8/2) (1) and

(3) of the Act by its transfer of Wood from the edi-

torial department.

An additional approach to the issues in this case

is afforded by the fact that the evidence casts doubt

on the authenticity of Respondent's contention that

Wood's activities in the Women's Caucus was one of

the two causes of her transfer. There is substantial

indication that Wood’s union activities were the basic

reason for the transfer and that her Caucus activities

were pretextually added as a reason so that the trans-

fer might not appear to be based solely on her union

activities.

ouur—-——-- ——

52

After Wood joined the Union and informed her

supervisor, Pearson, of the fact. he warned her as a

friend that Respondent’s reaction might be severe.

When, thereafter, Wood became active in the Union.

Respondent discontinued its customary full editorial

conferences. Pearson, at that juncture, told Wood

that the situation was due to Respondent’s ancer at

her union activity. Next. Respondent horred Woed

from writing on labor subjects.”

Although Respondent had published an editorial

favorable to the idea and objective of the Women’s

Cancus, it later cited failure to secure prior clearance

from Respondent before becoming active in that orga-

nization as a reason for her transfer. Respondent in

its letter notifying Wood of her transfer stated that

on the Women’s Caucus matter she had violated Com-

pany rules and policy. But a reading of Comnany

rules as to outside activities, as set forth earlier in

our Decision, persuades the Examiner that Wood vio-

lated no company rule on the subject of employee

conduct generally or on employee engagement in ont-

side activity. As to policy and practice, we have earlier

described the variety and types of outside activities in

which Wood and others had eneaged in previously.

In some instance prior clearance had been secured

from Respondent and, in other instances, not.

** Respondent cites the fact that in the period after Wood

became a union member she received a pay raise and had

also been allowed to attend a union conference in Chicago.

Both of these events occurred in 1970 before the Union was

certified and before Respondent was faced with the actuality

of having to recognize the Union. This was also before Wood

was elected 2 committeewoman in the Tnion. The pay raise

of 325. raising her salary to $225, was in Aneust 1970. pursu-

ant to a regular periodic review of performance of Wood in

Angust. Since Respondent had no fault to find with her work,

it presumably had no reason to deny her a periodic raise at

that time.

53

Regarding those outside activities of which Re-

spondent had disapproved, the maximum action taken

by Respondent was to afford the employee or individ-

ual the option of resigning from the outside activity

if he wished to remain in Respondent’s employ. Thus,

a former editor of the editorial page who was a mem-

ber of the board of the Urban League was told to re-

sign from the League or cease to be in Respondent’s

employ.” Seven of Respondent’s reporters were in-

volved in writing an extremely strong and bare

knuckle attack upon newspapers in general and upon

Respondent, its departments, and its editors. specifi-

cally. The article, described above in some detail. ap-

peared in the Central Standard Times and its sub-

stance was that newspapers generally and Respondent,

as a fairly typical example. were flagrantly venal and

corrupt. If venality and corruption are not the worst

accusations that can be made against a free press ina

democratic country, the Examiner must plead igno-

rance of greater sins. But even in this instance, and in

every other instance where Respondent disapproved of

outside activities, it took no greater action than to re-

quire the 7 reporters to resign either from the outside

Standard Times or from Respondent. Wood was the

only employee who was not afforded the option of re-

signing from the disapproved outside activity (in this

case, coordinator of the Women’s Caucus) as the price

of continuing in the job of editorial writer that she

then oceupied with Respondent. Nor had Colburn

* Although it is of minor importance. Wood te-titied credibly

and without contravention that she was unaware that the

former editor was a member of the Urban League or that Re-

spondent had told him to resign therefrom if he wished to re-

main with Respondent.

Be

ever entertained the idea of offering Wood the option

of resigning as coordinator of the Caucus.*

The most reasonable, if not the only apparent,

explanation, in Respondent's failure to tell Wood that

she had the option of resigning as coordinator if she

wished to continue as an editorial writer, was that

Respondent was so intent on removing Wood from the

editorial department because of her union status that

it did not wish to give her an option or an “out”

regarding the Caucus. In short, if Respondent had

given Wood the option of resigning as coordinator of

the Caucus and she did resign, she would still be in the

editorial department. And, as contrasted with Wood’s

role in the caueus, Respondent could not legally give

Wood the option of resigning her union role or of

forfeiting her job. Her union role, being protected

under the Act, was not one that she need forsake as

the price of continued employment by Respondent. In

this situation, therefore, in order to use Wood’s role

in the Caueus as an ostensibly legitimate reason, un-

cennected with union activities, for transferring her,

Respondent avoided affording Wood the opportunity

to resign as coordinator of the Caucus. Resignation

would have left Respondent with only one arrow in its

how and that arrow was union activities, a risky

course because of the protection of the Act.

It is the Examiner’s opinion, therefore, that the

evidence supports either of the following conclusions

and in either case Respondent’s action violated Section

8(a)(1) and (3) of the Act: Respondent transferred

“4. [Colburn] . .. It came to me later that she could have

resiened if I had brought that question up.

Q. Well. if she had said it [I will resign as coordinator]

right then. what effect would that have been /

A. None.

Q. You had already made up your mind?

A. Yes: there was nothing else I could do.

ame a ORE er ee

00

Wood because of her union activities and her Caucus

activities; Respondent transferred Wood because of

her union activities; and the Caucus activities, from

which she could have been asked to resign but on which

she was not given the opportunity to do so, were used

to color and diffuse the basic motivation against her

union activities.

Statements of Pearson to Wood to the effect that

consequences to her were likely to be severe because

she had become a union member and that she should

he prepared for any consequences since management

Was angry about her union activities are found to be

Vioiative of Section 8(a)(1) of the Act. [While] it is

trie that Pearson spoke as a friend and wished to

hel Wood by speaking to ler along the above lines,

the statements conveyed a threat and thus constituted

interference, restraint, and coercion of an employee

in the exercise of her statutory rights to joi a union

and to engage in union activity. The impact of the

statements, coming as they did from a friend who was

part of management, was probably greater in view of

tre suthenticity and credibility of the source.

Conelusions of Law

Respondent has violated Section 8(a)(3) and (1)

i the Act by transferring employee Dorothy Wood,

against her will, from the editorial page department

to the Sunday Magazine department because of the

said Wood's union activities.

Respondent has violated Section 8(a)(1) of the Act

by telling employee Wood that consequences of her

union membership and activity might be severe be-

cruise management was angry about her aforesaid

inembership and activity.

The Remedy

Having found that Respondent has violated the Act.

it will be recommended that Respondent cease and de-

sist therefrom and take appropriate remedial action

to remedy its unfair labor practices.

Accordingly, Wood should be offered her former job

as a writer in the editorial page department, displac-

ing, if necessary, any present incumbent in her former

job. She should receive, upon restoration to her former

job, her former salary at the time of her transfer on

August 16, 1971, plus any increase she would have re-

ceived, absent her transfer, since her last pay increase

in August, 1970, to the time of the offer of reinstate

ment.”

Upon reinstatement to her former job Wood will

enjoy the status of any other writer in the editorial.

page department without discrimination because of

her union membership or activity. By the same token,

Wood will he subject to the same lawful standards

and requirements that Respondent, as an employer,

applies or may apply to its emplovees. Inability or un-

willingness of any employee to perform as lawfully

required by his or her employer subjects the employee

to the employer’s full power as an emplover.

Recommended Order *°

Wichita Eagle & Beacon Publishing Co.. Inc.. its of-

ficers, agents, snecessors, and assigns, shall:

*° August 1971 was the periodic time for Respondent's review

of Wood's salary. Before leaving on vacation for the month of

August 1971, Pearson, Wood's immediate supervisor. ha-) writ-

ten a memorandum to Colburn. Therein he reminded Colburn

that it was time for review of Wood's salary and that Pearson

recommended an increase for Wood.

In the event no exceptions are filed as provided by See-

tion 1/246 of the Rules and Regulations of the Netional Labor

Relations Board, the findings. conclusions. and recommended

ees Stat at to tea See

—<—“ss

57

1. Cease and desist from:

(a) Discouraging membership and activity in the

Wichita Newspaper Guild, affiliated with the News-

paper Guild, AFL-CIO, or in any other labor organi-

zation, by transferring employee Dorothy Wood from

her position as a writer in the editorial page depart-

ment because of her union membership and activities.

(b) Interfering with, restraining, or coercing

Dorothy Wood or any other employee by statements

that consequences to Wood could be severe because of

her union membership and activities in view of man-

agement’s anger because of such membership and ac-

tivities.

(ec) In any like or related manner interfering with,

restraining, or coercing employees in the exercise of

rights guaranteed by Section 7 of the Act.

2. Take the following affirmative action to effectu-

ate the policies of the Act:

(a) Offer to Dorothy Wood immediate and full re-

instatement to her former job, without prejudice to

her seniority and other rights and privileges and make

her whole, with interest at 6 percent, for any loss of

pay increases that she would have received absent her

discriminatory transfer on or about August 16, 1971,

as more fully described in the Remedy section of this

Decision.

(b) Post at the office or offices of its newspapers in

Wichita, Kansas, copies of the attached notice marked

“Appendix.” Copies of said notice, on forms pro-

Order herein shall, as provided in Section 102.48 of the Rules

and Regulations. be adopted by the Board and become its find-

ings, conclusions, and Order, and all objections thereto shall be

deemed waived for all purposes.

** In the event that the Board’s Order is enforced by a Judg-

ment of a United States Court of Appeals, the words in the

notice reading “POSTED BY ORDER OF THE NATIONAL

LABOR RELATIONS BOARD” shall be changed to read

ce er i eS Dee a Pa a a fea LAT Dat

58

vided by the Regional Director, Region 17 of the

Board, after being duly signed by Respondent’s rep-

resentatives, shall be posted by Respondent immedi-

ately upon receipt thereof and be maintained by it for

60 consecutive days thereafter, in conspicuous places,

including all places where notices to employees are

customarily posted. Reasonable steps shall be taken to

ensure that such notices are not altered, defaced or

covered by other material.

(c) Preserve and, upon request, make available to

the Board or its agents, for examination and copying,

all records necessary to analyze the amount of back-

pay raises, if any, that Wood would have received ab-

sent her discriminatory transfer in August, 1971, in-

cluding payroll records and personnel memoranda and

records.

(d) Notify the Regional Director, Region 17, in

writing, within 20 days from receipt of this Decision,

what steps have been taken to comply herewith.”

Dated at Washington, D.C.

RaMeEyY Donovan,

Trial Examiner.

“POSTED PURSUANT TO A JUDGEMENT OF THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS ENFORCING

AN ORDER OF THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS

BOARD.”

2—In the event that this recommended Order is adopted by

the Board after exceptions have been filed, this provision shal!

be modified to read: “Notify the Regional Director for Re-

gion 17, in writing. within 20 days from the date of this Order,

what steps the Respondent has taken to comply herewith.”

eee aS ee ee

APPENDIX

NOTICE TO EMPLOYEES

POSTED BY ORDER OF THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS

BOARD—AN AGENCY OF THE UNITED STATES GOVERN MENT

After a trial in which all parties participated and

were represented by attorneys, it has been found that

we have violated the National Labor Relations Act in

certain respects. To remedy these violations, we advise

vou that:

WE WILL NOT discourage membership and ac-

tivity in the Wichita Newspaper Guild, afiiliated with

the Newspaper Guild, AFL-CIO, or in any other

labor organization by transferring employee Dorothy

Wood from her position as a writer in the editorial

page department because of her union membership

and activity.

WE WILL offer Dorothy Wood immediate rein-

statement to her former position as a writer in the

editorial page department and WE WILE pay her

any wage increases that she would have received in

that position if she had not been transferred in Au-

gust 1971.

WE WILL NOT interfere with, restrain, or coerce

Dorothy Wood or any other emplovee by statements

to Wood that consequences could be severe because

of her union membership and activity.

WE WILL NOT in any like or related manner in-

terfere with, restrain, or coerce employees in the exer-

(59)

West 2 OD te ert ee er

cise of rights guaranteed by Section 7 of the National

Labor Relations Act.

WIcHITA EaGLE & BEACON

PUBLISHING Co., INc.,

(Employer)

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.