Memorandum — Francisco Enterprises, Inc. v. Kirby

Supreme Court brief1974

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

~

see

aT 0S

No. 73-1008

In the a.

Supreme Court of the United States

Octoser Term 1973

PORTLAND CEMENT ASSOCIATION,

Petitioner,

vs.

ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION

AGENCY,

Respondent,

MEDUSA CORPORATION

NORTHWESTERN STATES PORTLAND CEMENT CO.,

Intervenors.

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to The United States Court

of Appeals for The District of Columbia Circuit

PETITIONER’S REPLY MEMORANDUM

Rosert E. HayTHoRNE

130 East Randolph Drive

Chicago, Illinois 60601

Epwarp W. WarREN

1776 K. Street N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20006

Counsel for Petitioner

Of Counsel:

Krexuanp & ELLs

130 East Randolph Drive

Chicago, Illinois 60601

SORG/CHICAGO U.S.A.

SSD EAN LIRA RLY TS ROLE LAY EN AOI RIN IAN BN NH SEITE P,P ERIE sic

Iu the

Supreme Court of the United States

Octoser Term 1973

No. 73-1008

PORTLAND CEMENT ASSOCIATION,

Petitioner,

vs.

ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION

AGENCY,

Respondent,

MEDUSA CORPORATION

NORTHWESTERN STATES PORTLAND CEMENT CO.,

Intervenors.

On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to The United States Court

of Appeals for The District of Columbia Circuit

PETITIONER’S REPLY MEMORANDUM

The Agency asserts the Writ should not issue because

a requirement that EPA prepare impact statements would

be inconsistent with provisions of the Clean Air Act; that

several federal appeals courts have so held; and that, since

the record was remanded for limited supplementation, the

Standards should not be set aside.

These contentions are unsupportable.

Adequacy of the Record

The administrative record was found to be totally in-

adequate to support judicial review. (Pet. App. 53) The

remand was not solely for ‘‘clarification of certain matters

concerning methodology of tests’’ as asserted by respon-

dent. (R. Opp. Br. p. 3) The record failed to contain ade-

quate information on any of the matters necessary to sus-

tain the Standards.

The court found a ‘‘critical defect’’ in the Agency’s de-

termination that the Standards are achievable. (Pet. App.

31ff) It also found that opacity measurements may be

‘‘inherently inadequate’’ and that the Agency failed to

show that the 10% opacity measurement required by the

Standard can be made within reasonable accuracy. (Pet.

App. 51, 52) In addition the Agency was directed to

respond to questions concerning adverse environmental im-

pacts (Pet. App. 21), economic costs (Pet. App. 24), future

supply of cement (Pet. App. 24), and cost-benefit analysis

(Pet. App. 23). In fact the court did not find a single

necessary element adequately covered in the administra-

tive record.

A regulation purportedly based on such a completely in-

adequate administrative record should be set aside. Camp

v. Pitts, 411 U.S. 138 (1973).

Environmental Impact Statements

The Agency’s opposition brief argues that preparation

of environmental impact statements by EPA would be

‘‘duplicative and inconsistent with the detailed provisions

and time schedule of Section 111 of the Clean Air Act.’’

(R. Opp. Br. p. 4)

This is shocking!

3

EPA has announced to the public that it has decided

to COMPLY WITH THE SPIRIT OF NEPA AND WILL

PREPARE IMPACT STATEMENTS IN CONNECTION

WITH ITS MAJOR REGULATIONS.’ This announce-

ment reveals that the Agency has, throughout this litiga-

tion, represented to the courts (including this Court) that

compliance with NEPA is inadvisable, if not impracticable

—and at the same time its staff has concluded that a direct-

ly opposite policy can, and should be followed. The fol-

lowing chronology was revealed by EPA’s announcement

on April 26, 1974.

The cement Standards were based ‘‘almost exclusively

on technology.’? Under Agency policy the degree of re-

quired control was considered adequately demonstrated if

a single test for a short period on the most stringently

controlled facility showed compliance. No consideration

was given to whether the specified degree of control was

required to protect the public health or welfare. Cost of

the prescribed degree of control was taken into considera-

tion only to the extent that the Agency concluded that the

cost burden was ‘‘feasible.’? The cost was not balanced

against expected environmental benefits as would be re-

quired in a NEPA environmental impact statement.?

In April 1972 an EPA task force was established to de-

termine whether EPA should prepare environmental im-

pact statements for its regulatory programs.®

1 1974 B.N.A. Env. Rptr., Curr. Devel. 2128-29 (April 26, 1974)

(Ex. A hereto).

2 Application of the National Environmental Protection Act to

EPA’s Environmental Regulatory Activities, Task Force Report,

EPA, 1973 (relevant excerpts attached as Ex. B) pp. 12, 13, 56-58.

81d, p. 2.

4

On November 30, 1972 the Agency argued to the court

below that ‘‘Requiring the Agency to follow NEPA pro-

cedures in connection with this rulemaking would, in effect,

subvert the specific requirements of the Clean Air Act.’’

(R. Br. p. 40) This contention was reiterated in oral

argument in January 1973.

In February 1973 the task force report was published in-

ternally. It concluded that the promulgated Standards

‘‘may not meet the criteria of [NEPA],’’ that compliance

with NEPA would produce benefits but might create delay

and would require additional manpower.‘

On June 29, 1973 the court below, not having been advised

of this report, and principally because of the asserted dif-

ficulties attributable to NEPA compliance, undertook

judicial legislation and ‘‘created’’ an exemption from the

unmistakably explicit provisions of NEPA for EPA de-

terminations under Section 111 of the Clean Air Act. (Pet.

App. 6-21)

Meanwhile, on June 14, the Agency announced that in

proposing regulations it would make available information

concerning ‘‘major environmental effects’’ and ‘‘a discus-

sion of pertinent non-environmental factors’’ including

‘¢social, and economic factors.’’ (38 Fed. Reg. 15653)

The petition for rehearing called this to the court’s at-

tention a month later with the observation that the sub-

stance of the contemplated information constituted an en-

vironmental impact statement. The Agency responded to

the court stating:

‘‘Suffice it to say that the information to be dis-

tributed by the Administrator to interested persons is

most certainly not ‘an environmental impact state-

4Id, pp. 56-58.

5

ment as required by NEPA.’ Nor is it intended to be.

The Administrator, as evidenced by his position in

this case, is in total agreement with the determination

set forth in the Court’s opinion that a NEPA impact

statement is not required in promulgating new source

standards under Section 111.’*

Thus reassured, the court denied the petition for re-

hearing.

Now, the Agency has concluded that preparation of im-

pact statements will not ‘‘subvert the specific requirements

of the Clean Air Act’’ and proposes to prepare such state-

ments, thus ‘‘ providing for greater public involvement, and

providing better analysis of EPA’s activities.’ But this

procedure will not apply retroactively. The result is that

the unfortunate decision will remain standing as a confus-

ing legal precedent and some stationary source standards

will have a different basis than others—the quintessence

of arbitrariness and discrimination.

Review by this Court is urgently needed to rectify the

results of the sequence described above. The decision be-

low is the basic statement of the erroneous legal principles.

It concerns the first case for direct judicial review of sta-

tionary source standards by the one court which has ex-

clusive jurisdiction under the statute.

The other decisions cited in the Agency’s opposition

brief are not pertinent. Those opinions involved collateral

attack (Getty), state implementation plans where state pro-

ceedings presumably furnish adequate safeguards (Ap-

palachian Power Co., Duquesne Light Co., Buckeye Power,

5 Resp. Reply, p. 8 (copy attached as Ex. C).

® Note 1, supra.

6

Inc.), a completely different statute concerning insecticides

(Environmental Defense Fund, Inc.), pure dictum (Ana-

conda Company), and one contains the statement ‘‘al-

though we do not reach the question whether EPA is au-

tomatically and completely exempt from NEPA ...’’ (In-

ternational Harvester Co.).

CONCLUSION

In order to correct the erroneous decision below which

was based on misapprehension, and for the other reasons

stated herein and in the Petition, the Petition for a Writ of

Certiorari should be granted.

Respectfully submitted,

Rosert BE. HaytHorne

130 East Randolph Drive

Chicago, Illinois 60601

Epwarp W. WaRREN

1776 K Street N.W.

Washington, D. C. 20006

Counsel for Petitioner

Of Counsel:

Krexianp & E1uis

130 East Randolph Drive

Chicago, Illinois 60601

May 8, 1974

EXHIBIT A

(From 1974 B.N.A. Env. Rptr., Curr. Devel. 2128-29)

General Policy

EPA GUIDED BY INITIATIVE, CONCERN IN

DECISION TO DO IMPACT STATEMENTS

The Environmental Protection Agency decided on its

own initiative to begin preparing environmental impact

statements on its regulatory activities, according to Shel-

don Meyers, director of EPA’s Office of Federal Activities.

Congressional pressure was ‘‘a factor’’ in the decision

but ‘‘not a predominant factor,’? Meyers told Environ-

ment Reporter April 19.

He said EPA still believed it was not bound by the Na-

tional Environmental Policy Act to write environmental

impact statements on its regulatory activities. However,

the need to do more to explain the rationale behind its regu-

latory activities has concerned EPA for some time, he said.

Meyers made note of an EPA task force report, dated

February 1973, which studied the application of NEPA to

EPA’s regulatory activities. The report said, ‘‘Pending

final conclusion of all out-standing issues, EPA should im-

plement the spirit of NEPA to the greatest extent pos-

sible.’’

Meyers said that in June 1973 EPA issued a notice of the

procedure the agency would follow in preparing and issuing

‘‘environmental explanations’’ of certain of its own pro-

posed standards, regulations, and guidelines.

At that time, EPA said the procedures were responsive

to growing public demand that government agencies pro-

vide ‘‘full and public explanations of their actions.” The

agency said it would provide explanations of ‘‘major”

proposals.

Meyers said EPA’s recent voluntary decision to do im-

pact statements on its regulatory activities was a further

step in meeting the agency’s responsibility to the public,

providing for greater public involvement, and providing

better analysis of EPA’s activities.

He said EPA plans to publish a statement of policy in

early May and should be ready to issue final procedures

in June, Meyers noted that impact statements developed

under these procedures would apply only to prospective

regulatory activities and would not be retroactive.

EXHIBIT B

EXCERPTS FROM APPLICATION OF THE NATIONAL

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ACT TO EPA’S EN-

VIRONMENTAL REGULATORY ACTIVITIES, TASK

FORCE REPORT, EPA, 1973.

Program Examples

How these trends evidence themselves and how

the above listed factors are considered, can be best

appreciated by reviewing the substantive aspect of

EPA's decision-making process with respect to specific

regulatory programs. For purposes of comparison

and analysis, programs can be arrayed along a

spectrum, established in terms of statutory criteria,

ranging from those based entirely on consideration

of technology and cost, through programs requiring

an explicit balancing of costs and benefits, to

programs in which attainment of a certain ambient

condition is the sole statutory target.

New Stationary Source Emission Standards (Air)

A program in which standards are based almost

exclusively on technology and cost considerations is

establishment of emission standards for new stationary

sources. Decision-making here involves two stages,

the first of which takes account of ambient air

considerations. Under the program, EPA first publishes

a list of categories of stationary sources which may

contribute significantly to air pollution causing or

contributing to endangerment of public health or welfare.

Once the sources categories are listed, EPA

must propose and set regulations establishing standards

of performance for new sources within each category.

A standard of performance is defined as "a standard

for emissions of air pollutants which reflects the

degree of emission limitation achievable through

the application of the best system of emission

reduction which (taking into account the cost of

achieving such reduction) the Administrator determines

has been adequately demonstrated." In establishing

performance standards, analysis focuses almost

entirely on the questions of what is the best

system of emission reduction, what does it cost,

and has it been adequately demonstrated. Alternative

emission levels largely reflect the accomplishments

of alternative abatement technologies.

In setting new source performance standards,

explicit consideration is not given to their

predicted impact on ambient air conditions. Indeed,

the major premise underlying the program is that

standards should be uniform across the Nation, so

that polluting industries will be denied any inducement

13

to locate in clean air regions, where emission standards

might otherwise be less strict. 74 However, in

limited cases, control of one pollutant may cause

a problem with another air pollutant. When this

occurs, the benefits of the control of one pollutant

will be weighed against the problems caused with

the other pollutant involved.

Similarly, in determining what abatement technology

is “best,” consideration is given to the pollution

effects of such technologies on media other than air.

Such consideration, though, generally is limited

to reviewing whether such problems are of sufficient

magnitude to compromise the air pollution abatement

benefits of a technology being considered, as opposed

to making a detailed evaluation of what all such

non-air pollution problems are. In like fashion,

consideration is given to other environmental

problems, insofar as they have a reasonably direct

relationship on the cost or feasibility of a proposed

standard. Thus, in establishing performance standards

for fossil-fueled steam generators, much analysis was

devoted to the availability of low vs. high sulfur

coals, and the consequences of their supply, while

less consideration was given to the probable effect on

energy supply and the environmental consequences

thereof. 3/

2/ Concurrently, however, State implementation plans

must provide for location of new stationary

sources in a manner that does not cause violation

of national primary or secondary ambient air

quality standards.

3/ e.g., whether pollution abatement costs would result

in increased reliance on nuclear energy.

C. ESTABLISHMENT OF STANDARDS OF PERFORMANCE FOR

NEW STATIONARY SOURCES (AIR)

The program involves (1) designation of the source

category and (2) setting performance standards. The

Clean Air Act requires that the selection of emission

standards reflect both adequately demonstrated technology

and consideration of cost of control. The source categories

considered are those which may contribute significantly

to air pollution causing or contributing to endangerment

of public health or welfare.

I. Full Compliance

1. Substantive Effects: Full compliance with NEPA will

result in better documentation of the secondary impact

of the standards and of the criteria for selection of

the source categories to be regulated. The alterna-

tives explored, both in regard to standards and

technology, would be disclosed to the public. Any

adverse effects would also be made public with the

rationale for the standard set and the balances of

benefit versus adverse effects. Currently the

development of new source performance standards

takes into account the cost of control and the economic

impact of the standard. If compliance with NEPA

requires a balancing of cost and environmental effects

or benefits, significant changes in the standards

might occur so that best control technology might

not be prescribed. The performance standards, therefore,

may not meet the criteria of the Act.

2. Procedural Effects: It is assumed the draft impact

Statement will be published simultaneously with the

proposed standards (120 days after categories published)

and the final statement will be published prior to

promulgation of the standards (90 days after standards

are proposed).60/ Because standards for several cate-

gories are proposed at the same time and the time

schedule is severe, a great amount of additional effort

will be required. More detailed disclosure of an

increased variety of factors will substantially

increase the range of public comments. Because per-

formance standards are established for individual

source categories, cost/benefit analysis considering

the total environment will open many debates on the

e@ legal problems w S program are discuss

supra p. 36-37,

FY 73

FY 74

4.

57

level of the standards. Therefore, significant

delays due to increased litigation may result.

Incremental Banpoyer Requirements: An estimated

new source performance s rds will be formu-

lated in FY 73 and an estimated 10 will be established

in FY 74. At least one and a half additional

man-years per standard are estimated to be needed

for full compliance with NEPA: 1 man-year to

complete additional documentation, cost/benefit

analysis and draft impact statements; 1/2 man-year

to complete final impact statements and follow through.

appropriate channels. This represents approximately a

100% increase in technical staff presently responsible

for actual preparation of the standards and 50% increase

in staff responsibility for briefing materials and

standards review. If manpower were not increased, the

rate of standards being promulgated would be decreased.

Actions/Year Man-Years/Action Total Man-Years

a . Max >. Min .

19 2.0 1.5 38 28.5

10 20 15

Benefit: Full compliance with NEPA would result in

providing more information to the public, industry,

and other government agencies in regard to the source

categories selected, standards proposed, and conse-

quences and benefits of these actions. Full compliance

might necessitate a balancing of costs and benefits

of the standards being considered; the benefits to the

public health and welfare would be stressed. The basis

and rationale for setting standards would be docu-

mented for internal and public use.

II. Intermediate Compliance

1.

Description and Benefit: The option for intermediate

Sangtionss selected for new source performance

standards is to comply with NEPA analysis requirements

without filing an environmental impact statement. In

this way, EPA would more thoroughly analyze the

consequences of its standards and control technology

58

and the rationale for setting the standards at

certain levels and examine in detail the alterna-

tives and secondary impacts. If there are portions

of NEPA which conflict with legislative mandates

of this program, these need not be addressed under

this option. Following this option would provide a

more accurate estimate of the manpower required to

complete the additional analysis required and an

indication of whether statutory time constraints

would have to be changed were NEPA to be legally

applied.

Incremental Man r Requirements: The additional

manpower eaateed under this option would be

approximately one man-year per standard to complete

development of the required additional data and

information. This estimate may need to be greater

due to the setting of standards for various categories

simultaneously.

Actions/Year Man-Years/Action Total Man-Years

Xe Min. Max. Min.

19 1.5 1.0 28.5 19

EXHIBIT © |

EXCERPTS FROM RESPONDENT'S REPLY BRIEF

a

The standards should not be set aside without the

petitioner or intervenors' overcoming the presumption that she

standards are proper and in accordance with the law, See

Delaware Citizens for Clean Air v. Ruckelshaus, F.2d

(C.A. 3, No. 72-1548, June 21, 1973) slip opinion, p>. 9

and 11. In view of the foregoing and taking into account chat

the Administrator is currently preparing to publish inforreation

3/

in compliance with this Court's remand directives, the

standards should remain in effect.

II

THE ADMINISTRATOR IS NOT REQUIRED TO PREPARE

AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT, PURSUANT

TO THE NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT, IN

ORDER TO PROMULGATE NEW SOURCE STANDARDS

This Court thoroughly discussed, in its opinion, she

issue of whether or not the Administrator must prepare an

environmental impact statement in order to promulgate new

source standards pursuant to Section 111 of the Clean Air <ct,

42 U.S.C. sec. 1857c-6. The Court reached the conclusion <hat

since EPA's proposed standards are "inevitably an alert to

environmental issues" and an alert "to the public and the Congress

3/ The Administrator intends to publish this material within

the next two to four weeks.

Je

who will have an opportunity to comment as to possible adverse

environmental effects," a NEPA impact statement was not necessary

for the promulgation of Section 111 new source standards.

Petitioner, however, continues to take the position

that an impact statement is required. In addition to arguments

previously made to the Court, Portland points out that Congress

is considering an appropriation bill for $5,000,000 for EPA to

prepare impact statements. Portland apparently fails to realize

that EPA does in fact prepare impact statements with regard to

functions directed by statutes other than Section 1l1l. See 33

U.S.C. sec. 1371. The fact that EPA receives appropriations

for the preparation of impact statements does not indicate any

Congressional intent whatsoever that Section 111 requires the

preparation of such statements. The appropriations bill has no

relevance to whether or not Section 111 of the Clean Air Act

requires the preparation of impact statements,

Portland also asserts, incorrectly, that EPA now

takes the position that it should prepare NEPA statements

before setting its standards. This is based on the Administrator's

4nnouncement on June 14, 1973, of the policy that EPA will make

4vailable to interested persons a statement of the basis and

oe §-

purpose of any proposed action, and an explanation of its

environmental effects. Petitioner quotes the information

which the Administrator will provide to interested persons

and states, "This information constitutes an environmental

impact statement as required by NEPA."" Portland petition,

p. 6. Suffice it to say that the information to be distributed

by the Administrator to interested persons is most certainly

not “an environmental impact statement as required by NEPA,"

Nor is it intended to be. ad The Administrator, as evidenced

by his position in this case, is in total agreement with the

determination set forth in the Court's opinion 2/ that a NEPA

impact statement is not required in promulgating new source

standards under Section 111.

4/ The contents of a NEPA impact statement are specifically

described in the CEQ guidelines for the preparation of

environmental impact statements, 38 Fed. Reg. 20550-20562,

August 1, 1973.

5/ Cf. Duquesne Light and Power Company v. Ruckelshaus,

F.2d (C.A. 3, 1973), No. 72-1542, decided June 5,

1973, and Appalachian Power Company v. Ruckelshaus, F.2d

(C.A. 4, 1973), No. 72-1517,. decided April 11, 1973.

ener

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.