Brief for the Respondent in Opposition — Federal Power Commission v. Greene County Planning Board
Supreme Court brief1972
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
f certiorari 7 FEDERAL POWER COMMISSION,
below re.
ted | GREENE COUNTY PLANNING BOARD, TOWN OF DURHAM,
NEW YORK, ASSOCIATION FOR THE PRESERVATION
OF DURHAM VALLEY, POWER AUTHORITY OF THE
STATE OF NEW YORK and THE SIERRA CLUB,
Respondents.
BRIEF OF RESPONDENT POWER AUTHORITY OF THE
STATE OF NEW YORK IN OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR A
WRIT OF CERTIORARI
THOMAS F. MOORE, JR.
10 Columbus Circle
Suite 1800
New York, New York 10019
Attorney for Respondent
Power AUTHORITY OF THE
State or New Yorx
Scorr B. Litty
New York, N. Y.
i
of Counsel.
Angust 8, 1972
Sy eS
;
2 aie
iets ki
Le
INDEX
PAGE
rents in the proceeding .........sseeccvcccescons 3
Jurisdiction of the Commission ...............0005 11
Status of Commission proceeding .............005. 12
Status of project construction ............ee eee eee 15
Other pending cases involving interpretation of
Sa Aas ah eae cau ASERRERER ERA SRI EA 15
The urgent need for the line ..............eceeeee 19
The Authority’s position with respect to the opinion
IIE ep SA IOAN APR EE RS Segre rene a ae ee er 21
AEE IEE STOEL ETT SUT OEE TTE PTO 22
APPENDIX:
OPC order of Marek (, 1072 2... ccecesceccccncees la
og Be Be oy ae 6a
re SE EE Oy BO na ys Snes eravecececes ens 9a
Bru eter OF AUSUSE 4, TOTS occ i ercdecscccss 12a
Presiding Examiner’s notice of certification, Project
eb en ae eran eee l5a
Court of Appeals order modifying opinion ......... 18a
ii
CITATIONS
CAsEs: PAGE
Calvert Cliffs’ Coordinating Committee, Inc. y.
Atomic Energy Commission, 449 F.2d 1109... 17
Citizens for Cleon Air v. Froehlke No. 72 Civ. 2259,
Ge IG Ay Oe ML EE bn ve wc ancnawisacecancus 17
Kalur v. Resor, 335 F. Supp. 1 .................... 16-17
Scenic Hudson Preservation Conference v. Federal
Power Commission, 354 F. 2d 608, cert. denied sub
nom., Consolidated Edison Co. of New York vy.
Scenic Hudson Preservation Conference, 384 U. §.
Se anes ceksdeccuneebkeskk 4k ie dee ceenuan 13
Scenic Hudson Preservation Conference v. Federal
Power Commission, 453 F. 2d 463, cert. denied 32 L.
Rs EE sh ndu dada Wanddeonce bens eusauwss . BB
Sierra Club v. Hardin, 325 F. Supp. 99 ............ 7
Sierra Club v. Sargent, Civil No. 249-71C2, (W. D.
WU: OA SU EEE od icaNasmadeues vacen cove se 17
Students Challenging Regulatory Agency Procedures
v. United States, No. 971-72, (D. D. C. Jul. 10,1972) 17
Upper Pecos Association vy. Stans, 328 F. Supp. 332,
aff’d 452 F. 2d 1233, cert. granted, 40 L. W. 3556 .. 15,16
FepErRAL Power CoMMISSION PROCEEDINGS:
Arkansas Louisiana Gas Co., Docket No. CP70-267 .. 6
Columbia LNG Corp., et. al., Docket No. CP71-289,
OU sccndessncdudanetescseesouciistssesae .6, 17-19
Distrigas Corporation, Docket Nos. CP70-196, et.al. . 6
El Paso Natural Gas Company, Docket No. RP72-6 .. ; 6
Florida Gas Transmission Company, Docket No. |
gS eee seeVeteneessvaeedenunsranuens 6
Tecon Gasification Co., et. al., Docket Nos. CP72-100, ;
Cy sbcckawsaconecsessineseseseeuses
United Gas Pipeline Co., Docket Nos. RP71-29, et. al.
Utah Power & Light Co., Project No. 1744 ......... 6
iil
SraTUTES:
Federal Power Act PAGE
6012), 36-G. &. C. § FORCED) 2. ec cnccccccccs 11
Cite), BS WU. B.C. § TOT Ce) ... 5 cccccccncesscs 11
§10(a), 16 U.S. C. § 803(a) ....... 2.0... 13
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42
U.S. C. § 4321 et seq.) ...... 2, 3, 5, 6, 13, 15-17, 19, 21, 22
Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899
Se Gee We BOOED enn vdeecéccewecwceacece 16
New York Public Authorities Law § 1005 .......... 12
REGULATIONS:
Federal Power Commission Rules of Practice and
Procedure, 18 C.F.R. § 2.81(b) (Order No. 415 as
SEE Keehn s LeU ae ewe nbadeved cone cawrecks 4,5,7,8
\[ISCELLANEOUS:
Guidelines of the Council on Environmental Quality 5)
Federal Power Commission Orders, Project No. 2685
Order of March 7, 1972 ....................... 8-10
Ce Ss ee 10, 12, 15
Order of July 5, 1972 . 0... ccc ccc ccc cc cccccce 11
Order of August 1, 1972 ..................... 11
Presiding Examiner’s Notice of Certification, Project
2685, dated February 9, 1972 ................... 8
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1971
No. 71-1597
FepERAL Powrer CoMMISSION,
Petitioner,
vs.
Greexe County PLannine Boarp, Town or Durnam, New
York, AssoclATION FOR THE PREsERVATION oF DuRHAM
Vattey, Power AUTHORITY OF THE StaTe oF NEw York
and THE Sierka CLus,
Respondents.
BRIEF OF RESPONDENT POWER AUTHORITY OF THE
STATE OF NEW YORK IN OPPOSITION TO PETITION FOR
FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
This case involves a strictly procedural dispute between
the Federal Power Commission (Commission) and some
intervenors in a Commission proceeding who oppose con-
structon of a transmission line. Respondent, Power Au-
thority of the State of New York (Authority) and con-
sumers in New York State are unfortunately caught in
the cross fire.
The Authority opposes the granting of the petition for
a writ of certioravi on the grounds that:
1. A resolution of the issue which the petition asks
this Court to resolve under ‘‘QuEsTIon PRESENTED’’ was
not included in the judgment of the court below. By way
of dictum the court expressed the opinion that prior to
the start of hearings, which were in progress at the time
of the court decision, on a transmission line with respect
to which there is a contest, the Commission should have
2
circulated a draft environmental statement Prepared by
its staff with respect to the line.* However the court
allowed the proceeding for approval of the line ty continue,
directing that a draft environmental statement be pre-
pared and circulated and that intervenors be given ap
opportunity to cross-examine with respect to it prior ty
the Examiner's initial decision. Thus the dictum which
is the subject of the “QUESTION PRESENTED’? does not re-
flect the holding which was the foundation of the judgment,
(Pet. App. pp. 10a, 18a.) **
2. The case should be considered moot because the
Commission largely complied with the judgment of the
court below before countermanding an order it had given
its staff to comply. (The recission order Was made after
the Solicitor General agreed to petition for a writ of cor.
tiorari.)
3. This ease is not a proper vehicle for this Court’s
resolution of the several complicated questions which are
currently being considered throughout the United States
with respect to interpretation of the National Environ.
menta! Policy Act (NEPA) (42 U. S. C. $4321 ef seq.)
since: (a) this case at most involves only one of such ques-
tions and a narrow one at that; (b) other pending cases
involve additional questions as well; (c¢) the Commission’s
compliance with the order of the court below would require
virtually no additional functions to be performed by its
staff except circulation of a draft statement which has
already been prepared or virtually prepared and thus
*The Court also expressed the opinion that # draft environ-
mental statement should have been prepared and circulated by the
Commission prior to its making a determination With respect to two
transmission lines concerning which there Was no contest and no
hearing. It denied the relief sought with respect to those lines,
** References to the Solicitor General’s Appendix are to ‘Pet.
App.”’ References to the Authority’s Appendix annexed hereto
are to ‘‘A. App.”’
3
would impose no burden on the Commission; (d) granting
ihe petition would inevitably result in extremely serious
delay in the availability of transmission facilities urgently
needed to carry electric power, particularly to the New
York City area, and hence would be very much against the
public interest whereas review will undoubtedly be sought
in other cases where similar consequences would not result;
and (e) the merits of the case before the Commission are
not involved.
Events in the Proceeding
On August 15, 1968 the Authority applied to the Commis-
sion for a license to build a one million kilowatt pumped
storage hydroelectric project in the Catskill Mountains
southwest of Albany. (The project is known as the Blen-
heim-Gilboa Project.)
On June 6, 1969 the Commission issued a license for the
plant and three transmission lines connected with the proj-
ect switchyard but required that construction of the lines
be deferred until the Commission specifically approved
plans for design and location including ‘‘plans for pres-
ervation and enhancement of the environment as it may
be affected by the transmission lines[’] design and loca-
tion’.
Un June 16, 1969 the Authority accepted the license, im-
mediately started construction and proceeded to borrow in
stages approximately $200,000,000 to pay the cost.
On November 24, 1969 the Authority filed for approval
plans for the three transmission lines together with an
Appendix describing environmental considerations,
On January 1, 1970 the President signed NEPA and it
became effective on that date. (It had been passed by both
Houses of Congress in December, 1969.)
On April 10, 1970 the Commission after study by its
staff approved plans for two of the lines, there being no
opposition to them.
AAD RRD Sipe
4
There being opposition to the third line, largely by resi.
dents of Durham, one of the towns in Greene County through
which it would pass on its way to Leeds near the Hudson
River south of Albany, the Commission deferred action with
respect to it and granted petitions for intervention by re.
spondents herein (other than the Authority) and several
landowners in the Durham area.
On December 4, 1970 the Authority filed an amended
application for approval of the Leeds line containing a modi.
fication of the route first proposed and also an alternate
route avoiding most of Durham but traversing a good part
of the Town of Greenville in Greene County.
Also on December 4, 1970 the Commission issued its
Order No. 415 for the first time establishing regulations
implementing NEPA. (36 F. R. 18958, 18 (. F. R. §§ 2.80-
2.82.)
On March 15, 1971 the Town of Greenville which ob-
jected to removal of the proposed line location from Dur-.
ham into its territory filed objections to the alternate route
and moved to intervene. (Intervention was granted on May
4, 1971.)
On March 26, 1971 the Authority filed its Environmental
Statement with respect to the Leeds line in compliance
with the Commission’s Order No. 415. The Authority
circulated the Statement as required by Commission
regulations and gave it additional circulation and pub-
licity beyond that required by the regulations. In the
Environmental Statement the Authority described three
additional alternate routes for the line which were ad-
vanced by people objecting to the two alternates set forth
in the Authority’s amended application for approval. The
Statement made clear that the Authority did not consider
any of the three added alternates feasible.
The Commission staff reviewed the Authority’s En-
vironmental Statement as to form, found it not to be
deficient, circulated it among federal and state agencies,
5)
sought their advice with respect to it and made it public
as required by Commission regulations. (The court below
held the consultation requirements of NEPA were thereby
net. Pet. App. pp. 17a-18a.)
On June 22, 1971, following a Commission order direct-
ing that hearings be held, a Commission Examiner con-
ducted a pre-hearing conference and set up a procedural
schedule for filing and serving prepared written testimony
by the Authority, the staff and the intervenors and for
the actual holding of hearings.
In November and December, 1971 and January, 1972
hearings were held but not completed.
In the meantime on October 22, 1971 some of the inter-
yenors petitioned the United States Court of Appeals for
the Second Cireuit for review of the Commission’s as-
sumed denial by silence of many motions made by the
intervenors including motions to stop construction of the
project proper and the two transmission lines, construction
of all of which was then about 80% complete, and a motion
to stay the proceeding on the Leeds line pending the Com-
mission’s distributing a draft environmental statement
which intervenors contended should have been done before
the hearings started.* The court denied a motion to siay
the proceeding and on January 17, 1972 entered the
* On November 19, 1971 while the court proceeding was pending
ike Commission issued its Order No. 415-B amending Regulation
§281(b) to provide that the applicant’s draft statement after
being approved as to form by the staff and after being modified if
found to be deficient in form ‘‘shall be deemed to be information
comparable to an agency draft statement pursuant to Section 7
of the Guidelines of the Council on Environmental Quality’’.
(Pet. App. pp. 33a, 44a.)
Before argument in the court below Authority Counsel pointed
out to Commission Counsel the urgent need for the Leeds line
and the importance of keeping the proceeding before the Examiner
going. Authority Counsel requested that the Commission file and
distribute a draft environmental statement and thus avoid a
court decision.
(Footnote continued on next page)
seietiellcigindl eiayacin ty
6
judgment here sought to be reviewed. The Only relief
granted by the judgment was a direction to the Commis.
sion to have its staff, prior to the Examiner’s initial
decision, prepare and circulate a draft environmental
statement and obtain comments on it and that the Fx.
aminer allow the intervenors to examine Authority and
staff witnesses with respect to it before the hearings are
closed. (Pet. App. p. 18a.) (The court expressed the
opinion that NEPA requires that a draft Statement he
circulated before hearings in all eases except where there
are two hearing the first “‘solely to gather information to
aid the Commission in formulating its Statements, the
(Footnote continued from preceding page)
After the Court of Appeals’ decision Commission Counsel made
it clear to Authority Counsel that in eases other than the instant
case the Commission would go ahead with administrative proceed.
ings upon applications under the Federal Power Act and the Natn.
ral Gas Act where significant environmental considerations are
involved without complying with what the opinion of the court
below said the law to be. The fact that it is doing so is illustrated
by a gas certificate case involving a $139 million gasification plant
and related pipeline facilities for which application to the Commis.
sion was filed in October 1971 and in which hearings were ordered
by the Commission on February 24, 1972 five weeks after the Court
of Appeals’ decision in the instant ease without requiring staff to
file a draft environmental Statement. The hearing was completed
May 24, 1972. The staff did not file a draft statement before, dur.
ing or after the hearing. Tecon Gasification Co. et al., FPC Docket
Nos. CP72-100, et al. (See also Utah Power and Light Co., Project
No. 1744; Arkansas Louisiana Gas Co., Doeket No. CP70-267, Opin-
ion No. 612, issued February 18, 1972; Distrigas Corporation,
Docket Nos. CP70-196, e¢ al. Opinion No. 613, issued Mareh 9,
1972; El Paso Natural Gas Company, Docket No. RP72-6. Order
issued March 6, 1972; United Gas Pipeline Co., Docket Nos,
RP71-29, et al., Opinion No. 606, issued December 3, 1971, Presid-
ing Examiner’s Order issued February 17, 1972, and Order issued
March 31, 1972, staying Presiding Examiner’s ruling; and Florida
Gas Transmission Company, Docket No. CP70-104, Order issued
February 17, 1972.) See, however Columbia LNG Corporation,
et al. (infra pp. 17-19) where the Commission staff circulated its
own draft statement in a brief to the Examiner at the close of hear-
ings and asked for reopening of hearings to consider matters re-
flected in it.
7
second to consider the merits of the license application’’
‘Pet, App. p- 16a, emphasis added). This statement of
the court was not necessary to the judgment.)
The court again refused to stop the proceeding before
the Examiner pending circulation of, and receiving com-
ments on, a draft environmental statement and left it to the
Commission to determine the most efficient procedure for
meeting the court’s mandate, (Pet. App. p. 18a.)
Basically what the court did in its judgment was to
hold that before the close of hearings on an application
to a federal agency for a license or other approval in a
situation significantly affecting the environment, the agency
through its staff must prepare, circulate and receive com-
ments on an agency draft environmental statement and
the Examiner must g've intervenors an opportunity to
utilize that statement in the course of hearings. In doing
so the court held invalid tne provision in Section 2.81(b)
of the Commission’s regulations that an applicant’s draft
environmental statement as modified by applicant if re-
quired by initial review by the staff as to form is ‘‘informa-
tion comparable to an agency draft statement’’. The court
held that an agency’s circulation of an applicant’s state-
ment after any required modification as to form does not
satisfy the requirement that the agency’s staff circulate
and receive comments on a draft statement of its own com-
position. (Pet. App. pp. 9a-18a.)
On January 28, 1972, the Commission Examiner held a
formal conference to discuss the judgment of the court
and to establish procedures for going ahead. Intervenors
refused to attend but sent the Examiner a letter stating
their position. At the conference Commission Staff Coun-
sel stated that the staff would prepare and file a draft
environmental statement and asked a specific time in which
to do so. Staff Counsel also asked that the Authority
furnish the staff with a great deal of information which they
listed on the record including prognoses as to the need for
Sie LEE sic BGS pik RT ~
8
power in New York State in the 1970’s and 1980’s and plans
of the Authority and other power entities for Providing
generating and transmission facilities to supply such needs
Covered by the request was the report of the results of g
feasibility study of proposed additional generation facilities
on the Schoharie Creek which the Authority had announced
was being made at the prehearing conference tho preceding
June and which it then had agreed to make available to all
parties and the public during the hearings as soon as com-
pleted. (The report was nearly complete at the time of the
January 28 request and was filed shortly thereafter.) [py
addition Staff Counsel asked that the intervenors be re.
quired to file prepared testimony which they had been qj.
rected to file and had agreed to file by January 18, and had
prepared but had not filed. Staff Counsel stated that all
this material was needed for the preparation of the draft
statement.
The Examiner made an order setting a time for circula.
tion of a draft statement and refused to delay the resump.
tion of hearings as requested by intervenors in their letter
until the draft statement had been circulated for 45 days."
The Examiner stated however that intervenors could move
to fix time and place of hearings to conform with their con-
venience.
After the Examiner at the intervenors’ request certified
procedural questions to the Commission, the Commission on
March 7, 1972 issued an order affirming the Examiner's
direction that the staff file and circulate a draft environ-
mental statement by the time prescribed but modified his
procedural schedule by providing that hearings resume
after the statement had been distributed for 45 days and
comments received from interested agencies rather than
while it was being prepared and distributed. (A, App.
pp. la, 15a.)
* Section 2.81(b) of the Commission’s regulations provides that
agencies to which an environmental statement is circulated shall be
afforded 45 days in which to respond,
9
In its March 7 order the Commission directed:
‘‘(C) The Examiner shall reopen the record to
receive, as soon as practicable after the completion of
such circulation period, additional direct testimony
from PASNY and the Commission staff, and to allow
additional cross-examination promptly thereafter;
and he shall open the record to receive, as soon as
practicable after the completion of such cross-exami-
nation, direct testimony from Intervenors, and to
allow cross-examination promptly thereafter.’’? (A.
App. p. 5a.)*
In its March 7 order the Commission said that it was
secking a rehearing of the Court of Appeals’ judgment but
that
“* * * the public interest requires that this pro-
cecding progress rather than remain dormant pend-
ing judicial review * * *.’? (A. App. p. 4a.)
The Court of Appeals denied the Commission’s petition
for rehearing on March 10, 1972. (Pet. App. pp. 31a-32a.)
The Commission asked the court to stay its mandate but
the court refused on April 5, 1972.
On February 28, 1972 the Court of Appeals granted a
motion by the Authority to clarify its opinion by correcting
minor errors and by amending a statement in the opinion
about the Authority whieh had been taken from the brief
of petitioner Greene County Planning Board. (The cor-
rections and amendment are not reflected in the opinion
as printed in Appendix A to the petition for a writ of cer-
tiorari. The court’s order is printed in the annexed ap-
pendix at p. 18a.)
The intervenors filed and served some written testimony,
they had already prepared, as directed by the Examiner and
the Authority filed and served a great mass of material re-
quested by the Commission’s staff, The last day upon which
the staff could possibly have filed a draft environmental
*The record was never closed.
ae
ase
Cit dace Ean BE. re Sg
tans RS
10
statement in timely compliance with the March 7, 1972 order
of the Commission was May 15, 1972.*
On June 1, 1972 the Commission unilaterally and without
notice to any of the parties other than its Staff issued an
order countermanding its March 7 direction to the staff to
prepare and circulate an environmental statement. The
order also stayed the administrative proceeding before the
Examiner. The stated reason for the order was that the
Solicitor General had agreed to apply for a writ of certiorar
and there was concern that if the staff were not forhidden to
circulate the draft statement the case might become moot
and further concern that continuance of the proceeding ab-
sent obedience to the Court of Appeals’ judgment directing
circulation of the draft statement might conflict with that
court’s mandate. (A. App. pp. 6a-8a.)
In efforts to persuade the Commission to rescind or mod-
ify its June 1 order so that the proceedings could continue
the Authority took many steps including: a telegraphed re.
quest by the then Acting Chairman of the Authority for
rescission which the Commission treated as a motion for
reconsideration; a motion to the Court of Appeals for clari-
fication of its judgment to make clear whether or not it
would consider continuance of the proceedings absent the
Commission’s compliance with the court’s direction with re-
spect to the draft environmental statement a violation of the
mandate; an application to this Court which was referred
first to Mr. Justice Marshall and later to Mr. Justice Rehn-
quist for a full or partial stay of the Court of Appeals’ judg-
ment to the end that proceedings continue pending decision
on the petition for a writ of certiorari; and a formal appli-
cation for rehearing by the Commission of its June 1 order,
*The draft statement was required to be filed within 45 days
after receipt by the Commission staff of material requested on the
record at the January 28 conference from Authority and inter-
venors. The staff requested further material informally from the
Authority, the last of which the Authority submitted on Mareh 29,
1972, 45 days before May 15.
11
The telegraphed request which was treated by the Commis-
sion as a motion for reconsideration was denied July 5, 1972.
(A. App. p. 9a.) The motion to the Court of Appeals for
clarification was denied June 14, 1972. The application to
this Court for a full or partial stay was denied by Mr. Jus-
tice Rehnquist on July 27, 1972. The application to the Com-
mission for rehearing was denied on August 1, 1972. (A.
App. p. 12a.)
Jurisdiction of the Commission
Section 4(e) of the Federal Power Act (16 U. S. C.
(797(e)) authorizes the Commission to issue licenses for
project works ‘‘necessary or convenient’’ for power devel-
opments on waterways over which Congress has jurisdic-
tion, Section 3(11) in defining ‘‘project’’ includes ‘‘pri-
mary line or lines transmitting power therefrom [the
project] to the point of junction with the distribution sys-
tem or with the interconnected primary transmission sys-
tem’. (16 U.S.C. § 796(11)). The Leeds line does not con-
nect with a distribution system. Neither does either of the
other two lines included in the project. The other two lines
are already part of the State’s interconnected primary
transmission system. If the Leeds line is compieted it will be
also. It will be a very important part of it.
The Commission licensed the three lines as primary
lines hut in the Leeds proceeding the matter with respect
to that line has been reopened.
Some intervenors took the position that the Leeds line
if constructed will not be a primary line but will be part
of the interconnected grid. At the initial hearing in
Albany the Examiner refused to require the intervenors
unequivocally to state on the record at that time whether
or not such was their position.* In contesting the need for
*The discussion before the Examiner appears at pp. 178-181
of the transcript of the hearing in the proceeding held on November
9, 1971 at Albany, N. Y.
12
the line at the hearings intervenors restricted their Cross.
examination to the need for the line to carry project power
and to insure stability of the power plant. Thus they con.
fined their treatment of need to need as a primary line,
If the line were held not to be a primary line the Com.
mission would not have jurisdiction and the line could
legally be built by the Authority under state law (New York
Public Authorities Law, § 1005). Thus, whether or not jt
is a primary line is a threshold issue in the Comission
proceeding. A resolution of the issue has been put off by
the Commission's June 1, 1972 order staying the proceeding
**pending final review by the United States Supreme Court
of the Court of Appeals decision * * *.”’ (A, App. p. 8a.)
Status of Commission Proceeding
Many issues have been raised in the Leeds line pro-
ceeding, some by the intervenors’ cross-examination of
witnesses presented by the Authority and the Commission
staff, some in direct testimony of Commission staff wit.
nesses, some in New York State Public Service Commission
comments on the Authority’s Environmental Statement
and some as a result of events which have occurred since
the amended application for approval of the line was filed
in December, 1970. Included among the latter are changes
in route which the Authority has suggested aad which re-
sulted from recent developments in the area involved such
as subdividing and the building of structures.
While the original application sought approval of a
single circuit 345 kv line, the Commission because of the
prospect of additional generating facilities being con-
structed in the area and elsewhere must consider whether
the towers should be capable of carrying two 345 kv cir-
cuits as suggested by the State Public Service Commission
and whether they should be capable of being converted to
765 kv as suggested by a Federal Power Commission
13
expert witness. Both suggestions were made in anticipa-
tion of further transmission capacity being needed in the
future because of construction of additional generating
facilities by the Authority and other power en.ities. Testi-
mony showed that additional facilities will be necessary as
part of the interconnected grid whether more generating
facilities are constructed on the Schoharie or not.
The Commission must consider the additional issues,
not only because of NEPA but also because of the require-
ments of Section 10(a) of the Federal Power Act which
provides :
(a) That the project adopted, including the
mays, plans, and specifications, shall be such as in
the judgment of the Commission will be best adapted
to a comprehensive plan for improving or develop-
ing a Waterway or waterways for the use or benefit
of interestate or foreign commerce, for the improve-
ment and utilization of waterpower development,
and for other beneficial public uses, ineluding ree-
reational purposes * * *.’* (16 U.S. C. © 803(a); see
Scenic Hudson Preservation Conference v. Federal
Power Commission, 354 F. 2d 608 (2d Cir. 1965),
cert. denied sub nom., Consolidated Edison Co. of
New York v. Scenic Hudson Preservation Conference,
384 U. S. 941 (1966); Scenic Hudson Preservation
Conference Vv. Federal Power Commission, 453 F.
2d 463 (2d Cir. 1971), cert. denied, 32 L. Ed. 2d 813
(1972).)
Long before the hearings commenced, the locations of
the alternate routes of the line for which approval had been
sought as well as information with respect to voltage and
design of structures shown in the application for approval
were advertised in newspapers and given wide circulation.
Notice was given as to where and when the application,
plans and drawings including sketches of alternate types
of structures could be examined.
Some of the additional issues, further consideration of
which must be given in the proceedings, are so substantial
Ane
Mele
—s
hee
eh eel th Atti om ae
14
that additional advertising and other forms of notice must
be carried out in order to comply with the Federal] Power
Act, the Commission's regulations thereunder and related
statutes.
A great amount of prepared testimony and exhibts must
be submitted by the Authority and by others who Wish to
do so.
For example, intervenors cross-examined Authority and
staff witnesses at length on the issue of undergrounding
but have submitted no affirmative testimony on the issue
and no exhibits. Likewise they cross-examined at length
on the need for the line as a primary line and did some
cross-examination on route selection but have submitted no
testimony of their own on either and no exhibits except an
essay on the history of the Susquehanna Turnpike concern.
ing which some of the prepared testimony they submitted
relates.
The Authority, as required by the Commission, sub-
mitted exhibits showing precise locations and elevations
of tower sites on the two alternate line routes one or the
other of which the Commission has been asked to approve.
It must submit similar exhibits with respect to suggested
revised route locations not only for single cireuit 345 ky
towers but for higher towers capable of carrying two 345
kv cireuits and for still higher towers capable of carrying
two 345 kv cirenits and being converted to a single 765 ky
circuit. It also must present exhibits showing locations of
the higher towers on the routes already subject to the hear-
ings. The Authority will of course also have to submit
direct testimony explaining the exhibits. Higher towers
require a wider right-of-way and the effect of widening
must be shown.
The Authority intends to produce additional evidence
on the need of the Leeds line to carry power to the New
York City area and on the need of the line to insure stability
of the power plant and of power systems to which the power
will he delivered when one of the other lines from the plant
15
is out of service because of faults or maintenance require-
ments.
The Authority will be prepared to supply the additional
material soon after an order is given for the proceeding
to be resumed. However, everything has been stayed by
the Commission’s June 1 order. (A. App. p. 6a.)
Siatus of Project Construction
The project proper consisting of a lower reservoir in
Schoharie Creek with a dam designed to handle 155,000
cubic feet of water per second, an upper reservior 1,000
feet higher, a powerhouse, penstocks, motor generators,
pump turbines, dikes, roads, and other features is 92%
complete. The transmission lines to Fraser (Delhi) and
to New Seotland (Albany) are complete. They were en-
ergized on July 27, 1972 and are being used to bring power
from the west, largely Pennsylvania, to the Albany area.
Other Pending Cases Involving Interpretation of NEPA
(m May 22, 1972 this Court granted a writ of certiorari
to the Court of Appeals for the Tenth Cirenit in Upper
Pecos Association v. Stans, 452 F. 2d 1233 (1971 ), 40 L. W.
3356. The ease involves a two to one decision affirming a
jndgment of the District Court for the District of New
Mexico on a challenge to the legality of a grant made by
‘he Economie Development Administration of the Depart-
ment of Commerce (EDA) to a county in New Mexico of
% of the cost of building a road in the Elk Mountain
area. A declaratory judgment was sougitt to the effect that
the grant was invalid because of violation of NEPA (328
PF. Supp. 332). EDA issued no environmental statement
before or after making a decision to make the grant of
money but the Forest Service which was charged with
approving the location of the road and which the court
found to be the ‘‘lead ageney”’ did cireulate an environ-
mental impact statement after the decision on the grant had
Dt inet RAT wheelie see A
aE deci
ents AR
16 ei
been made by EDA. The opinion of the majority of the
Court of Appeals said that there was presented a question
of the point in time at which an environmental statement
must be available. The majority of the court held that
the circulation of the environmental statement after the
EDA decision on the grant was timely. The dissenting
judge took the position that NEPA required that EDA
consider the environmental consequences of making the
grant and that it had failed to comply with NEPA. (452 F,
2d at 1234-37.)
In the instant case this Court is asked for an advisory
opinion. The subject of the requested opinion is actually
in issue in the Upper Pecos ease. This Court can, therefore,
answer the ‘‘Question Presentep’’ in the instant case in
the Upper Pecos case which is already before the Court.
It can do so without the unfortunate delay to an important
public project which will come about if a writ is granted
in the instant case.
Kalur v. Resor, 335 F. Supp. 1 (D. D. ¢. 1971), is an
action for a declaratory judgment and injunction. The
court set aside regulations promulgated by the Secretary
of the Army under NEPA and Section 13 of the Rivers
and Harbors Act of 1899 (33 U.S. ¢. §407). The regula-
tions were concerned with applications for permits to make
discharges into navigable streams or non-navigable tribu-
taries. The court held, contrary to the contentions of the
Government, that NEPA applies to all applications for per-
mits to discharge material into navigable streams including
those where water quality is involved and held invalid
Corps’ regulations exempting the Corps from issuing en-
vironmental statements in permit eases where water quality
is solely involved.* The case is on review before the Court of
* It also held that Section 13 of the Rivers and Harbors Act
forbids discharges into non-navigable tributaries of navigable
Streams and that the Corps of Engineers does not have authority
to permit such discharges although it does have such power as to
navigable streams.
2 17
Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit and is expected
to be argued early in the fall. It involves issues in addition
to the narrow issue sought to be presented in the instant
case and is deemed to be of great importance by the Depart-
ment of the Army. A writ of certiorari will almost in-
evitably be requested. The proceeding is a_ general
attack on regulations under which no action was ever taken.
No specifie project is involved so the question here sought
to be resolved along with other NEPA questions could be
resolved by this Court in that case without delaying a
vital public project.
For other cases involving preparation and circulation
of agency environmental impact statements, the scope of
review under NEPA and the question of what constitutes
major federal actions subject to NEPA see Sierra Club v.
Sargent, Civil No. 249-71C2, (W. D. Wash. March 16, 1972) ;
Students Challenging Regulatory Agency Procedures v.
United States, No. 971-72, (D. D. C. July 10, 1972) involv-
ing an Interstate Commerce Commission freight rate de-
cision; Citizens for Clean Air v. Froehlke, No. 72 Civ. 2259,
(S. D. N. Y. August 1, 1972). See also Sierra Club v.
Hardin, 325 F. Supp. 99 (D. Alaska, 1971). That case which
involves the need, adequacy and timeliness of an environ-
mental statement is scheduled to be argued in the Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on September 7, 1972.
The Commission staff did largely what the court below
directed be done in the instant case, in Columbia LNG Cor-
poration, et al. (F.P.C. Docket No. CP71-289 et al.) The case
involves an application for approval of a liquid natural gas
facility on Chesapeake Bay in the area of Calvert Cliffs
Park which was described in Calvert Cliff’s Coordinating
Committee, Inc. v. Atomic Energy Commission, 449 F. 2d
1109 (D. C. Cir. 1971). Approval was sought for various
project features including a pier extending 6,000 feet from
the shore of Cove Point to accommodate tremendous
tankers. The application was filed on June 4, 1971. Hear-
rere .
eo ha a LOMA Racal s Decal debe Ralaelatinneds
Pe Sib thelltang dia eral) Madiae A
kicokyeleng oad’.
18
ings before an Examiner were completed on J uly 8, 197],
The Commission staff filed a brief with the Examiner on
August 16,1971. Attached was an appendix labeled “Draft
Environmental Statement’. The statement Was cirep.
lated for 45 days. On August 18, 1971 the staff made a
motion requesting that state and federal agencies be
allowed until September 30, 1971 to file comments in con.
nection with the staff draft environmental statement.
Thereafter and before the Examiner handed down a
decision the Commission staff joined in a successful appli-
cation to reopen the hearings and urged that witnesses on
environment previously examined be subject to cross-ex.
amination. Additional hearings were held and environ-
mental testimony received. The hearings were concluded
on January 24, 1972, seven days after the decision of the
court below in the instant case. On February 29, 1972,
the staff filed a brief attached to which was an appendix
modifying and updating its draft environmental statement
based upon evidence at the second hearing . This was one
month and 12 days after the decision of the Court of Ap-
peals in the instant case. On May 15, 1972 the Commission
issued an order expediting proceedings and cutting down
on the time prescribed in the regulations for the parties to
file exceptions to the Examiner’s decision. His decision
was filed on May 22 and included a draft ‘‘Environmental
Statement’’. On June 28, 1972, thirty-seven days after the
Examiner’s decision the Commission adopted his decision
with some modifications. The Commission decision con-
tained a final environmental statement.
The action of the Commission Staff in the Columbia
ease did not conform to the judgment of the court below
in that its draft statement was not filed prior to the close
of the hearings before the Examiner. However, it cured
the lack of conformance by circulating the statement and
joining in the successful application to the Examiner to
reopen the hearings in which environmental evidence was
received.
19
On motion of parties including the Sierra Club and the
Maryland Conservation Council, the Commission issued
an order granting rehearing. The grounds upon which
rehearing was sought included allegations of violation
of the Commission’s own environmental regulations with
respect to notice and violation of NEPA including alleged
violations of requirements with respect to the draft environ-
mental statement.
Court review will undoubtedly be sought in the case which
involves many issues and a writ of certiorari will almost
certainly be asked.
Many other cases involving NEPA are pending through-
out the country.
The Urgent Need for the Line
The line as planned is only about 33 miles long and if
built without further extensive delay will replace only
four or five houses. It is of vital importance to carry
power to the New York City area and to insure the stability
of the project power plant and of at least one power sys-
tem to which power will be directly delivered. It is needed
both as a project primary line and as a necessary link in
the interconnected grid. It is by far the most important
of the three project lines. Although need for the line is
one of the issues raised by intervenors all evidence pre-
sented has shown the need and none has shown a lack of
need. More evidence based on additional recently com-
pleted computer tests will be presented when the hearing
resumes,
Leeds is on the way to New York City from the Blen-
heim-Gilboa Project. To increase substantially the amount
of power which can be carried from the project and the
west to New York the Leeds line must be completed and
the capacity of some connections between Leeds and New
York increased. This inerease in capacity is being delayed
pending decision on whether or not the Leeds line in fact
20
will be built because the power entities involved need to
have assurance that it will be built before commiting the
necessary funds.
When the Leeds line is built and the capacity of those
connections increased and a 345 kv interconnection from
Fraser south (the missing links in which have recently
been approved by the State Public Service Commission) jg
built the amount of power which can be carried from upstate
New York to New York City will be increased by an amount
almost equal to the amount which can be carried to New
York now over existing facilities.* The Leeds line is essen.
tial to this result.
While the City’s peak loads are in the summer, upstate’s
peak loads are in the winter. Thus, the Blenheim-Gilboa
plant will be of the most value upstate in the winter and
in the City in the summer.
The power situation in New York City and Westchester
County in the summer is desperate and getting worse. The
1,000,000 kilowatt Blenheim-Gilboa plant represents almost
one-eighth of the peak power load which New York City ex.
periences in the hot summer months. The Leeds line js
essential for carrying power to the New York City area.**
Because of delay already experienced it is not now
possible to have the Leeds line and the improved intercon-
nections on the east side of the Hudson ready for service to
*There.are two 345 kv lines between Albany and Leeds,
When the Authority’s Leeds line is complete it together with its
New Scotland line will constitute a third 345 kv line to Leeds.
** Leeds is a key point. A very important new switchyard is
located there. Two 345 kv lines and some lower voltage lines from it
go across the Hudson and down the east side to New York City.
Additional 345 kv lines will be substituted for the lower voltage
lines. It is this work which is being impeded by delay in the Leeds
line. Recently a 345 kv line was completed from Leeds on the
west side of the river south to Roseton about half way to New York
City. A 345 kv interconnection is planned from Roseton south for
future construction.
21
Yew York for the summer of 1973. It is important that
further delay be avoided in order to have them ready for the
summer of 1974.
The Authority’s Position With Respect to the
Opinion Below
The Authority sympathizes with the problems of the
Commission and other agencies in carrying out traditional
duties and in addition the many added duties imposed by
NEPA. The Authority is in the position of other public
and private organizations which have an obligation to
supply goods or services vitally needed by the public. It
believes that there must be an accommodation between en-
vironmental considerations which are of course extremely
important and the needs of human beings for the essentials
of life such as electricity. It recognizes that ultimately
this Court must resolve differences between extreme posi-
tions taken by some as to interpretation of statutes designed
to safeguard the environment and the positions of entities
charged with the responsibility to construct needed facili-
ties which have an effect on the environment.
We believe that the opinion of the court below to the
effect that agency draft environmental statements must be
submitted prior to the start of administrative hearings in all
eases except where an administrative hearing is conducted
“solely”’ for the purpose of obtaining information on which
to hase the statement is unsound. There is no statutory or
practical basis for it. An agency stati can formulate a much
more useful and adequate statement after a hearing is
commenced and issues joined than before.
However we believe that the actual judgment of the
court below requiring a staff draft statement prior to the
close of the hearing is reasonable and legally justifiable.
It is consistent with the position the Authority took in the
court below. (Pet. App. p. 10a.)
22
Conclusion
It was not necessary for the court below to answer the
‘‘Question PreseNTED”? in order to reach its judgment, The
opinion expressed by the court that an agency draft ep.
vironmental statement must be circulated prior to con.
mencement of administrative hearings is dictum. The judg.
ment of the court was that such an impact statement must
be circulated before hearings are closed and must be made
a subject of the hearings if requested by intervenors, Henee,
there is not presented to this Court a controverted issye
necessarily passed upon and since the judgment does not
match the ‘‘Question PresenteD’’ it is not properly
reviewable.
The Commission substantially complied with the man-
date of the court below by having its staff either complete
or almost complete a draft environmental statement after
receiving from the Authority a mass of technica] informa-
tion and computations which it prepared at great expense
and in good faith on the basis of the staff’s formal state-
ment in the course of Commission proceedings that it was
necessary for the preparation of a draft statement which
the staff stated it would circulate and which the Commis-
sion later formally ordered it to prepare and circulate,
Under these circumstances the Commission’s abrupt change
of course did not keep the case from being moot.
Other cases now in litigation, one of which is already
before this Court and several of which will almost surely
be brought to the door of this Court, involve the question
here sought to be resolved as well as other questions
with respect to interpretation of NEPA. The ease in whicha
writ of certiorari has already been granted or one of the
others now in litigation would form a much better vehicle
for this Court’s interpretation of NEPA than the instant
case.
Requiring the Commission to comply with the judgment
of the court below by denying the petition would require
no substantial work on the part of its staff or place any
23
burden on the Commission because of the extent to which
the judgment has already been obeyed. On the other hand
the Authority would be put to great hardship and expense
by the granting of the petition and power consumers would
be put at a great disadvantage because of the delay in the~.
construction of essential power facilities. :
For these reasons the petition for a writ of certiorari
should be denied.
However, it is respectfully requested that in the event
the petition is granted the Court direct that the proceedings
before the Commission be resumed and carried forward
during pendency of the case in this Court. This would
be highly proper because (i) the court below held that the
Commission had carried on adequate consultation with other
agencies by circulation of the Authority’s Environmental
Statement, (ii) all issues which could conceivably be raised
in the proceeding before the Commission have already
been raised so the availability of a staff environmental
statement is not essential for notice purposes, (iii) the
merits of the case before the Commission are in no way
involved, and (iv) regardless of what decision this Court
might finally make on the merits a Commission environ-
mental statement could be circulated before the hearings are
fnally closed and made available as provided in the order
of the court below.
Respectfully submitted,
Tuomas F, Moorg, Jr.
10 Columbus Circle
Scort B, Litiy oe
ee ee a ia New York, New York 10019
New York, N. Y. Attorney for Respondent
Jouxn C, Mason Power AUTHORITY OF THE
Washington, D. C. StaTe or New York
of Counsel.
August 5, 1972.
ee
APPENDIX.
FPC Order of March 7, 1972
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FEDERAL Power CoMMISSION
Before Commissioners: John N. Nassikas, Chairman;
John A. Carver, Jr., Albert B. Brooke, Jr.,
Pinkney Walker, and Rush Moody, Jr.
owER AUTHORITY OF THE : eres
hae . ee Project No, 2685
Srate oF NEW YorK j
ORDER ADOPTING PROCEDURE FOR HEARING
(Issued March 7, 1972)
On June 6, 1969, the Commission granted a license to
the Power Authority of the State of New York (PASNY)
to construct and operate the Blenheim-Gilboa Pumped Stor-
age Project No, 2685 including, as part of the project works,
three 845 Kv transmission lines (41 FPC 712). The princi-
pal project works and two of the lines are currently nearing
completion, This proceeding involves PASNY’s application
to construct the third line, which it proposes to route from
the Town of Gilboa, in Schoharie County, New York, to the
Leeds substation in the Town of Athens, in Greene County,
New York,
As of the conelusion of the cross-examination of
PASNY’s and the Commission staff’s direct witnesses on
January 7, 1972, the schedule for the hearing provided that
Intervenors would file the prepared testimony of their direct
witnesses on or before January 18, 1972, and that cross-
examination of such witnesses would commence on Febru-
ary lo, 1972. On January 17, 1972, however, the United
States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit issued an
opinion' holding that the Commission staff is required by
'Greene County Planning Board v. Federal Power Commission,
Docket Nos. 71-1991 and 71-1996.
2a
the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) to
prepare and circulate a draft environmental impact stat.
ment and should have done so prior to the hearing.
Intervenors did not file the prepared testimony of their
direct witnesses when due and, by Notice issued January 21,
1972, Presiding Examiner William C. Levy called a gop.
ference for January 28, 1972, ‘‘for the purpose of consider.
ing the impact of the Court of Appeal’s [sic.] opinion op
the future course of this proceeding and adopting such pro-
cedures and schedules as may be required by the courts
[sic.] opinion and remand.”’
The Commission staff indicated at the conference that it
would prepare and circulate an environmental impact state.
ment solely for the purpose of expediting the proceeding
and not as an interpretation of the Court of Appeals’ opin.
ion. The staff requested that the environmental information
accumulated by both PASNY and Intervenors be made
available for the preparation of such statement, and it asked
specifically that PASNY furnish certain data and that
Intervenors furnish the prepared testimony which should
have been filed on or before January 18, 1972. The Exam.
iner directed that PASNY furnish the requested material as
soon as possible and that ‘‘the staff will have 45 days from
the receipt of that material to file the detailed environmental
statement required by the court’s mandate.”’
Intervenors did not appear at the conference. Instead,
they expressed their positions in a letter dated January 25,
1972, in which they challenged the Examiner’s continuing
jurisdiction in the proceeding through the Court of Appeals’
statement,
‘*We leave to the Commission to determine the most
efficient procedure for meeting this mandate [Em-
phasis added].”’
They also indicated that the character and scope of their
witnesses’ testimony would be substantially affected by the
Commission staff’s environmental impact statement, and
3a
that it would be financially burdensome and wasteful of time
to file what they had prepared and submit their witnesses
to cross-examination prior to their receipt of such impact
statement. Nonetheless, the Examiner ruled that he had
continuing jurisdiction and directed ‘‘them to file this over-
due direct testimony forthwith’’, granting leave for Inter-
yenors to move that ‘‘such witnesses be cross-examined at
atime and place convenient’’,
By letter dated February 4, 1972, Intervenors asked the
Examiner to reconsider such rulings and, in any event, to
reduce all of his conference rulings to writing and refer
them to the Commission pursuant to § 1.28 of the Commis-
sion’s Rules of Practice and Procedure. As a result, the
Examiner issued a Notice dated February 9, 1972, in which
he set forth, reconsidered and reaffirmed his conference rul-
ings* and certified them to the Commission.
Intervenors state in their request that ‘‘we had testi-
mony in a prepared form on January 17, 1972 and obviously
it would be a small burden, financially speaking, for us to
hile this material at this time.’’ They assert, however, that
they should not have to file the testimony because to do so
would further violate NEPA by continuing the hearing
prior to the preparation by the Commission staff of a draft
environmental impact statement, and they state that such
‘*... testimony contains statements of position, rec-
ommended compromises and admissions which we
may not wish to make after we have had the oppor-
tunity to review both the staff impact statement and
any comments thereon which are submitted within
the 45 day circulation period. We cannot say, due
to the changed cireumstai.ces, whether any, all or a
part of this testimony will be part of our direct ease.’?
Nonetheless, Intervenors offered to make available ‘all
backup material used by our witnesses in preparing the tes-
* Although the Notice states that the Examiner denied Inter-
venors’ request for reconsideration, its context indicates that he
reconsidered but declined to change his rulings.
4a
timony which was ready on January 17, 1972, the files of
the Greene County Planning Board, and the employees of
the Planning Board for consultation’,
On February 14, 1972, we petitioned the Court of Appeals
for a rehearing of its opinion issued January 17, 1972, and,
consequently, we do not consider it appropriate to
to interpret it at this time. On the other hand, the public
interest requires that this proceeding progress rather than
remain dormant pending judicial review; and for this rea-
son the Commission staff offered to prepare a draft envi-
ronmental impact statement and requested that the envirop.
mental information accumulated by all participants be made
available for such purpose. Accordingly, any environmen-
tal information which is in the form of prepared testimony
of Intervenors’ direct witnesses should be made available
to the Commission staff and other participants together
with the other environmental material to be furnished by
the participants.
The Commission finds:
In the present posture of this proceeding, the best adopt-
ed procedure for assuring compliance with the Federal
Power Act and the National Environmental Poliey Act of
1969 is set forth in principle below, subject to the continu.
ing authority of the Presiding Examiner to issue further
rulings to implement this Order.
The Commission orders:
(A) As soon as practicable, all participants to this pro-
ceeding shal! make available to the Commission staff and
other participants all environmental information requested
from them during the course of the conference on January
28, 1972, including any environmental information which is
in the form of prepared testimony of Intervenors’ direct
witnesses which was due for filing on January 18, 1972; bat
“‘statements of position, recommended compromises and
admissions’? may be deleted.
da “
(B) The Commission staff shall prepare a draft envi-
ronmental impact statement, and shall file it and commence
greulation within 45 days after receipt by it of the fore-
ing environmental information. Participants and agen-
cies shall have 45 days from the date of such filing in which
to comment on such statement.
(C) The Examiner shall reopen the record to receive,
as soon as practicable after the completion of such circula-
tion period, additional direct testimony from PASNY and
the Commission staff, and to allow additional cross-exami-
nation promptly thereafter; and he shall open the record
to receive, aS soon as practicable after the completion of
such cross-examination, direct testimony from Intervenors,
and to allow cross-examination promptly thereafter.
(D) The Examiner’s conference rulings set forth in his
Notice dated February 9, 1972, are affirmed to the extent
that they are consistent with this Order and reversed to the
extent that they are inconsistent herewith.
By the Commission,
(SEAL)
Kenwnetu F. Pius,
Secretary.
1 td ALA AA ORAS eae A
6a
FPC Order of June 1, 1972
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FEepERAL Power CoMMISSION
Before Commissioners: John N. Nassikas, Chairman;
Albert B. Brooke, Jr., Pinkney Walker, and
Rush Moody, Jr.
Power AuTHorRIty oF THE) ,,_. —
Stare or New York Project No. 2685
ORDER PARTIALLY RESCINDING ORDER OF
MARCH 7, 1972 AND STAYING
FURTHER PROCEEDINGS
(Issued June 1, 1972)
On June 6, 1969, the Commission granted a license to
the Power Authority of the State of New York (PASNY)
to construct and operate the Blenheim-Gilboa Pumped
Storage Project No. 2685 including, as part of the project
works, three 345 Kv transmission lines (41 FPC 712). The
principal project works and two of the lines are currently
nearing completion. This proceeding involves PASNY’s
application to construct the third line, which it proposes to
route from the Town of Gilboa, in Schoharie County, New
York, to the Leeds substation in the Town of Athens, in
Greene County, New York.
On January 17, 1972, the United States Court of Appeals
for the Second Circuit issued an opinion holding that the
Commission staff is required by the National Environmental
Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) to prepare and circulate a draft
environmental statement and should have done so prior to
hearing.' We filed a petition for rehearing which was denied
on March 10, 1972.
On March 7, 1972, prior to the Court of Appeals’ denial
of rehearing, we issued an order setting forth the procedure
to be followed in this proceeding pending judicial review
* Greene County Planning Board vy. Federal Power Commission,
455 F. 2d 412 (CA 2, 1972).
7a
of the Greene County decision. Among other things, we
soneluded that this proceeding should progress rather than
remain dormant pending review, and that Commission staff,
in compliance with the mandate of the Second Circuit,
should proceed with the preparation of a draft environ-
mental statement to be filed within 45 days following the
receipt of certain environmental information from the
participants.
Since the issuance of our order of March 7, 1972, and
the denial of rehearing by the Court of Appeals, the Solici-
tor General of the United States has agreed to file, on behalf
of the Federal Power Commission, a petition with the
United States Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari to
review the judgment of the Court of Appeals. In view of
this fact, and pursuant to our authority under Section 309
of the Federal Power Act, we have decided to rescind our
order of March 7, 1972, to the extent that it: (1) requires
the Commission staff to prepare and circulate a draft envir-
onmental impact statement, (2) direets the Examiner to
reopen the record for the receipt and cross-examination of
additional evidence, and (3) affirms certain rulings of the
Examiner, as set forth in his notice dated February 9, 1972,
which are inconsistent with our action today. Such action,
we believe, is required in order to preclude the possibility
that the issue for which review is sought might become moot.
An early resolution of this issue by the Supreme Court will
serve to eliminate uncertainty in this proceeding as well as
inmany other cases before the Commission in which NEPA
issues have been raised.
In order to avoid a conflict with the mandate of the
Second Cireuit, we deem it appropriate to stay these pro-
ceedings pending final review by the United States Supreme
Court of the validity of the judgment of the Court of
Appeals.
The Commission finds:
The proper disposition of the present proceeding will be
best served through the partial rescission, as set forth be-
ith Metab Pr SEERA hes.
8a
low, of our order of March 7, 1972, and the cessation by
Commission staff of any further action toward the prepa.
ration of a draft environmental statement pending further
order of this Commission. Moreover, these proceedings
should be stayed pending final review by the United State;
Supreme Court of the validity of the judgment of the Court
of Appeals in Greene County Planning Board vy. Federq|
Power Commission, 455 F.2d 415 (CA2, 1972).
The Commission orders:
(A) Pursuant to our authority under Section 309 of the
- Federal Power Act, ordering paragraphs (B), (C), and
(D), of our order of March 7, 1972, in this proceeding are
rescinded and the Commission staff is directed to take no
further action toward the preparation of a draft environ-
mental impact statement, pending further order of this
Commission.
(B) The proceedings in this matter are stayed pending
final review by the United States Supreme Court of the
Court of Appeals decision in Greene County Planning Board
v. Federal Power Commission, 455 F.2d 415 (CA2, 1972),
(C) The Examiner’s conference rulings set forth in his
Notice dated February 9, 1972, are affirmed to the extent
that they are consistent with this order and reversed to the
extent they are inconsistent herewith.
bv the Commission.
(SEAL)
Kenneth F, Pins,
Secretary.
9a
FPC Order of July 5, 1972
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FrepErRAL Power Commission
Before Commissioners: John N. Nassikas, Chairman;
Albert B. Brooke, Jr., and Rush Moody, Jr.
y 'THORITY OF THE , :
— a cies Project No. 2685
Srate oF New York j
ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR
RECONSIDERATION
(Issued July 5, 1972)
On June 6, 1969, the Commission granted a license to
the Power Authority of the State of New York (PASNY)
to construct and operate the Blenheim-Gilboa Pumped
Storage Project No. 2685 including, as part of the project
works, three 345 Kv transmission lines (41 FPC 712). The
principal project works and two of the lines are currently
nearing completion. This proceeding involves PASNY’s
application to construct the third i‘ne, which it proposes to
route from the project switchyard in the Town of Gilboa,
Schoharie County, New York, to the Leeds substation in
the Town of Athens, Greene County, New York.
On January 17, 1972, the United States Court of Ap-
peals for the Second Circuit held in Greene County Plan-
ung Board v. Federal Power Commission, 455 F. 2d 412,
that the Commission staff is required by the National En-
vironmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) to prepare and
circulate a draft environmental impact statement and
should have done so prior to the hearing. On February
14,1972, we petitioned the Court of Appeals for a rehearing.
On March 7, 1972, considering at that time that ‘the
public interest requires that this proceeding progress
< San ad: bbe vents ct Ano
wee
a.
10a
rather than remain dormant pending judicial review”, we
issued an order adopting a procedure for assuring compli.
ance with the Federal Power Act and the Nationa] Environ.
mental Policy Act of 1969 pursuant to the Second Cireuit’s
mandate that the ‘‘staff should prepare a detailed State.
ment before the Presiding Examiner issues his initial do.
cision.’?” On March 10, 1972, the Second Circuit denied
our petition for rehearing, and subsequently the Solicitor
General of the United States agreed to file in the Supreme
Court of the United States a petition for a writ of certioray;
to review the judgment of the Second Circuit. In order
to preclude the possibility that the issue for review might
become moot, we issued an order on June 1, 1972, partially
rescinding our order issued March 7, 1972, and staying
further proceedings.
On June 6, 1972, we received from PASNY a telegram,
which we are treating as a motion for reconsideration, pro-
testing our Order issued June 1, 1972, and asking that it be
rescinded. Asserting that the Gilboa-Leeds line is the most
important of the three transmission lines to serve the pro}-
ect and is the key to reliable delivery of power to the New
York area, PASNY urged that this proceeding should not
be stayed to test a legal issue in the Supreme Court while
other licensing proceedings are allowed to continue without
the staff having prepared environmental impact statements
prior to hearing. PASNY also asserted that the delay
is very much against the public intergst and that the longer
it continues, the greater the transmission line changes,
additional costs and environmental problems to be en-
countered.
Although PASNY also asked that we withdraw our re-
quest to the Solicitor General, the petition for a writ of
certiorari was filed in the Supreme Court of the United
States on June 8, 1972; and, among other matters, it ad-
vised the Court of our Orders issued March 7 and June 1,
lla
1972. While we regret the consequences of the delay re-
sulting from our stay, we consider our action to have been
necessary and appropriate to carry out the provisions of
the Federal Power Act and the policies and goals of the
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.
On June 21, 1972, two days after the last date for filing
answers, we received for filing an unsigned original and
two copies of the answer and cross-motion of Intervenor
Greene County Planning Board, which we are also con-
sidering. While the answer generally supports our Order
issued June 1, 1972, and questions PASNY’s assertions
with respect to the importance of the Gilboa-Leeds line,
the eross-motion (1) asserts that PASNY’s telegram was
considered to be a valid filing of a motion although it did
not comply with our Rules of Practice and Procedure and
(2) requests ‘‘that all future filings in this proceeding be
deemed proper if an original and two copies are sent to
the Commission, and each party of record served with one
copy.’’ We believe, however, that in acting upon PASNY’s
telegram the Secretary of the Commission properly dis-
charged his duties by construing it as a motion for recon-
sideration, serving it upon the other participants, and
thereby affording them an opportunity to respond.
The Commission orders:
PASNY’s motion for reconsideration of our Order
issued in this proceeding on June 1, 1972, and Greene
County’s cross-motion for relaxed filing procedures, are
denied.
By the Commission.
(SEAL)
Kennetu F. Pius,
Secretary.
Lg Pt ante Kaa Scie ae ee oe Oe
ot
12a
FPC Order of August 1, 1972
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FreperaL Power ComMISssION
Before Commissioners: John N. Nassikas, Chairman;
Albert B. Brooke, Jr., Pinkney Walker,
and Rush Moody, Jr.
Power AUTHORITY OF THE
STATE oF New York Project No. 2685
ORDER DENYING APPLICATION
(Issued August 1, 1972)
Power Authority of the State of New York ( (PASNY)
filed a telegram June 6, 1972, which the Commission by
letter of June 8, 1972, advised all parties would be treated
as a motion for reconsideration of its Order of June 1, 1972,
which stayed the proceeding on PASNY’s application for
authorization to construct a third transmission line for the
Blenheim-Gilboa Pumped Storage-Project No. 2685.
In our order of July 5, 1972 we denied the motion for
reconsideration after considering PASNY’s assertions that
staying the proceedings was against the public interest and
stated:
Although PASNY also asked that we withdraw
our request to the Solicitor General, the petition for
a writ of certiorari was filed in the Supreme Court of
the United States on June 8, 1972; and, among other
matters, it advised the Court of our Orders issued
March 7 and June 1, 1972. While we regret the con-
sequences of the delay resulting from our stay, we
consider our action to have been necessary and ap-
propriate to carry out the provisions of the Federal
13a
Power Act and the policies and goals of the National
Environmental Policy Act of 1969.
On July 3, 1972, PASNY filed an application pursuant
to Section 313 of the Federal Power Act and Section 1.34 of
the Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure for re-
joaring of the Commission’s order of June 1, 1972, by which
tie proceedings were stayed.
In addition elaborating on its reasons why it believed
the stay of proceedings to be against public interest,
PASNY also asserted without elaboration that ‘‘. .. The
June 1 Order, having been issued without notice in violation
of relevant statutes and the Commission’s own regulations,
was void.’” PASNY does not refer to any particular statu-
jory or regulatory provisions, and we are not aware of any
requiring Notice before the Commission could temporarily
stay its own proceedings. On the contrary, in view of the
breadth of our discretion under Section 309 of the Federal
Power Act (16 U.S.C. Section 825(h)), established in Niag-
ara Mohawk Power Corporation v. Federal Power Commis-
sion, 879 F.2d 153 (1967), we are confident as to the validity
of our Order issued June 1, 1972.
Inasmuch as the June 1 Order complained of is proce-
dural in nature, the Commission may modify it at any time
and continue the proceedings, when to do so will not conflict
with the mandate of the Second Circuit in Green County
Planning Board v. Federal Power Commission, 455 F.2d 415
(A2, (1972), and will not render moot a serious legal ques-
tion now pending for review by the Supreme Court of the
United States in this same ease.
Since PASNY’s application of July 3, 1972, reiterates
with elaboration contentions similar to those set forth in
the telegram of June 6, 1972, and which were considered
inour denial of July 5, 1972, the application should likewise
be denied.
l4a
The Commission orders:
The Application of the Power Authority of the Stats
of New York filed July 3, 1972 asking for further recon.
sideration of our order of June 1, 1972 is denied.
By the Commission.
(SEAL)
Mary B. Kipp,
Acting Secretary.
lida
Presiding Examiner’s Notice of Certification
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FEDERAL Power ComMMISSION
’ Z » Stave )
Power AUTHORITY OF THE § Project No. 268%
or New York (PASNY) — 57 Todeet No. 2685
PRESIDING EXAMINER’S DENIAL OF REQUEST
TO RECONSIDER RULING MADE AT CONFERENCE
ON JANUARY 28, 1972 AND
NOTICE OF CERTIFICATION
To THE COMMISSION :
Cross-examination of applicants and staff’s direct case
was concluded on January 7, 1972, and the hearing was
recessed to resume February 15, 1972, for the cross-exami-
nation of Intervenors prepared testimony due on or before
January 18, 1972. On January 17, 1972, the Court of
Appeals issued an opinion in Greene County Planning
Board v. Federal Power Commission et al. Docket Nos.
71-1991, 1996 holding inter alia that the Commission failed
to comply with the National Environment Policy Act and
remanding for further proceedings in accordance with its
opinion. Accordingly, a conference was called for Friday,
January 28, 1972 at 10 A.M., at the Office of the Commission
for the purpose of considering the impact of the Court of
Appeal’s opinion on the future course of the proceeding
aid adopting such proceedures and schedules as may be
required by the courts opinion and remand.
By letter dated January 18, 1972, the Presiding Exam-
ner was advised that Intervenors, in view of ‘‘yesterdays
opinion of the United States Court of Appeals ... are not
submitting any direct testimony at this time.’? ... and
“await guidance from the Commission concerning the most
dicient procedure for meeting the mandate of the Court.’
l6a
On January 25, 1972, Intervenors wrote ady sing tha:
they would not be at the conference, that the conference ya;
not properly called, and requesting that the letter be Copied
into the transcript of the conference as a statement of their
position (See TR. 1864-1867).
The conference was held on Friday, January 28, 1972
(See attached transcript Vol. No. 12) at which time the
Presiding Examiner considered the position and requests
of all the parties, including Intervenors, and made the fol.
lowing rulings:
1. The Presiding Examiner’s continuing juris.
diction to proceed with the hearing, and to determine
the most efficient procedure for meeting the court's
opinion, has not been terminated or revoked by the
Commission or by the Courts.
2. The Staff was directed to file a detailed .
vironmental statement within 45 days from the
receipt of certain requested data from Applicants
and to serve copies of such statement on all the par.
ties and Agencies to whom the Applicants Environ.
mental Statement was distributed.
3. All parties and agencies will have 45 days
thereafter to file their comments along with any an-
swering testimony or requests for a further oppor-
tunity to examine PASNY and Staff witnesses in the
light of Staff environmental statement.
4. Intervenors were directed to file forthwith
their direct testimony, due January 18, 1972, and to
make any motions they deemed necessary concerning
a convenient time and place for cross-examination of
their witnesses.
x
5. The February 15th hearing date was recessed
pending the filing of Intervenors direct testimony. A
new hearing date will be fixed when such testimony is
filed.
17a
On February 4, 1972, Intervenors wrote requesting, inter
glia, that 1 reconsider the above rulings, correct the record,
and in any event, refer them to the Commission. (A copy
of their letter is attached.)
The Presiding Examiner has carefully reconsidered his
rulings in the light of Intervenors letter of February 4, 1972,
and sees no good reason for Intervenors continuing default
in the filing and cross-examination of its prepared direct
testimony concedely available for filing when due on Janu-
ary 18,1972. The cross-examination of PASNY and Staff’s
direct case was concluded on January 7, 1972. Progress in
completing the direct phase of this proceeding is the most
dicient procedure for mecting the Court’s mandate pending
the filing of the Staff’s detailed environmental statement
now in preparation. Intervenors will, of course, have full
opportunity to respond to such statement, to file answering
testimony, and to cross-examine PASNY and Staff wit-
nesses in the light of the statement. Not to proceed with
Intervenors prepared direct testimony is conducive to the
very delay which Intervenors take such pains to discuss in
the Appendix to their letter of February 4, 1972.
Accordingly, their request for reconsideration is denied
and the conference rulings reaffirmed. However, in view of
the status of this proceeding in the Court of Appeals, the
Presiding Examiner’s Rulings are certified to the Commis-
sion for its consideration, as requested, under § 1.28 of the
Commissions Rules of Practice and Procedure.
Respectfully submitted this 9th day of February, 1972.
/sf/ Wrasam C. Levy
William C. Levy
Presiding Examiner
Attachments
Cory To aLL Parties
en eee re ee ae |
~ oe
18a
Court of Appeals Order Modifying Opinion
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
Seconp Circurr
At a Stated Term of the United States Court of Appeals,
in and for the Second Cireuit, held at the United State
Court House, in the City of New York, on the 28th day of
February, one thousand nine hundred and seventy-two,
Greene County PLansineo Boar,
Petitioner,
v.
Fevers, Power Commission,
Respondent.
Town or Dvurnam, New York and Assoctatioy ror tar
Preservation or Dunnam Vatiey, Power Avruoriy OF
THE State or New York, Tue Sierra Civs,
Intervenors.
Upon the motion made herein by intervenor, Power
Authority of the State of New York, by notice dated Feb-
ruary 14, 1972, to modify and clarify portions of this
Court’s opinion dated January 17, 1972, it is hereby ordered
that the sentence ‘‘PASNY has admitted that the Gilboa-
Leeds line is part of a plan which may include three mas-
sive pumped storage hydroelectric projects, six 345 kilo-
volt transmission lines and three 765 kilovolt transmission
lines*’, beginning on page 13, line 18 of the opinion, be de-
leted and the following sentence substituted: ‘“PASNY
has indicated that this line is part of a plan which may
include an additional massive pumped storage hydroelee-
tric project with attendant transmission lines.”’
It is further ordered that the date March 21, 1971, on
page 5, line 15, of the opinion be deleted and the following
date substituted: ‘‘ March 26, 1971’’.
19a
It is further ordered that the appearances for the Power
suthority of the State of New York be changed to read:
“Seott B. Lilly, New York, N. Y. (Thomas F. Moore,
Jr., New York, N. Y., John R. Davison, New York,
N. Y., John C. Mason, Washington, D. C., of counsel),
for Intervenor Power Authority of the State of New
York.’”’
J. Josern Smiru
Irvine R. Kavrman
WriuiuM H. Meiuiean
Circuit Judges
Dated: February 28, 1972
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.