Brief for the Respondents in Opposition — Ajem Laboratories, Inc. v. C. M. Ladd Co.

Supreme Court brief1970

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUPREME COURT,U-S- 0-7 0 ys

-Sayreme Court ve" United States

we 7 : “oo |

No. 413. sith Tae

ge , ’ ,

AJEM LABORATORIES, INC. AND’

CENTRI-SPRAY CORPORATION,

es Petitioners,

Mere } v. a

‘CM. LADD CO., INC, AND CHARLES M. LADD,

s

_ RESPONDENTS BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO

2” PETITION FOR/WRIT OF CERTIORARI

- iti

ae. E CASHAN P. HEAD /

Og - “\. 4118 Guardian Building

SS eee Detroit, Michigan 48226

_ BENJAMIN W..COLMAN

} : . 502 Northland Towers West _

r Interstate Beil 8 Record Co. 1036 Beaubien St.. Detroit. Michigan 48226

wo. 2-8745—WO. 2-8732 :

6 | eid

“-

.

‘

.

. .

.

as

.

. aos

.

i. *

=> ’

°

.

‘

Ss:

yey

.

3 .

.

.

‘

.-

s

.

. ~~

,

.

on)

_*

—~

.

v .

x -

eo

.

. .

we *

. . ?

. . .

The Question Presented ne hee ee RSA ieee marae

Statute Involved .....°..... POOR etree a

Statement: of the Case ........ hess vs fe Pee yee

A rgument:

There are No Special and Important Reasons

For Review of This Case as Specified in Rule

19 of This Court ie ea ooh be Ay ee Fee

The Courts 3clow ‘Considered * ‘and Treated the

Issue of Reduction to Practice as Purely

"Factyal ee ee ieee eee Meelis 6 aes

The Courts Below Found. ag a Fact That the

Patented or Claimed Construction Had Been

Placed “On Sale” In Violation“of the Statute

. The Courts Below. Held That the Combinations

Defined in Late-Filed Claims . and 16 Were

Barred Under the Rule of W/ ungte eer... ..

The Findines of Fact of ‘the “District: Court,

Fully Adopted by the Court ‘of Appeals,

‘Should Not-Be Set Aside Exce pt C nder Most .

Unusual Citeumstances ..... +. .........0..

EIEN Sy has 5 ovis n noe o> —

Appendix A oh ey eee oeere

- Appendix. B ............ eee nese See ea ks ort ein he

" WN —

by

—

ii ~

TABLE OF CASES CITED

Bassick wok, v. R. M, Hollingshead Co., 298

US. 415 (1936). ..... WEE OP ORE E |

Graham vy. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1° (1966).....

Graver Tank & Mfg. Co. v. Linde Air Products Co.,

wk Ge a ar pa ey we Pee ee ee

Kaiser Industries Corp. v. Me Louth Steel Co., (CA-

6, 1968), 400 F.2d 36, cert. denied 353 U. S.

EIA! Oh OR WOR oes cs coker sn ees seen

Leeds & Catlin Co. v. Victor Talking: Machine Co.,

213 U.S. 301,29 S.Ct. 495 (1909).,......-.0.

Lincoln Rnsiaveti ing Co. v. Stewart-Warner Corp.,

Me OB BUD I sis aon aye asan eas |

Page

10

Monroe Auto ‘Equipment Co. v. Heckethorn Manu- —

facturing Co., 332 F.2d 406 (CA-6, 1964), cert.

en See US on on oe eee

Muncie Gear Works. Inc, v. Outboard, Marine &

Mfg. Co., 315 USA 59” (1942)... ee ere 2

Permutit Co. v. Graver, Corp., 284 U.S. 52 (1931)..

S. D. Warren Co. v. Nashua Gummed Paper, 205 :

F.2d 602 (CA¢1, 1958) errr ane ay

_IN THE

- Supreme Court af the United States

OCTOBER TERM, 1970

—_—_—-——.

No. 413

—-— = ;

- AJEM. LABORATORIES, INC. AND 3

CENTRI-SPRAY CORPORATION, ° 3

Petitioners,

Vv. |

. C.M. LADD CO., INC. AND CHARLES M. LADD,

Respondents. a.

a on 2

RESPONDENTS’ BRIEF IN OPPOSITION ‘TO

_ PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI:

THE QUESTION PRESENTED

= 5 | ; |

i

4

The sole question presented by the petition, RO

standing the form of the questions presented by the peti- ©

tioners, is as follows:

Whether,‘in a patent case based” upon the sales activ-

ities of the petitioner under Title 35 United States Code

Section 102(b), which has been decided by the District

Court on its facts and affirmed in all respects by the Court

of Appeals, this Court should take jurisdiction for the

purpose of reviewing the findings of fact.

Mo

STATUTE INVOLVED

United States Code, Title 35 j |

“$102. Conditions for patentability novelty and loss of

right to patent -

A person shall be entitled to a patent unless—

* ~.* ‘ .

(b) -the invention was patented or described in a printed

; publication in this or a foreign country or_in publie use

or on sale in this country, more: than one year prior to

the date of the application for patent in the United States,

or....”? ee ° ; ; ee

<3

_ STATEMENT OF —_ CASE ‘

The “Statement of the Case’ : appearing on pages 3 and

4+ of the petition presents no facts or “eireumstanees on

which the petition should be granted.

This case is a patent case inv olving petitioner Cai.

Spray Corporation’ s sales.and offers for sale of the pat-

ented invention under 35 U.S.C. §102(b), more than one oe

‘year prior to the filing of the application for the patemtt—

_in snit and more than-one year prior to the filing of

Clainis 4 and 16 by late amendment. There is no -unusual.

issue involved warranting the exercise of this Court’s:

jurisdiction. The trial was limited to the issne,of whether .

the patent in suit was invalid under Section 102(b), plac-- -

ing the entire patent in issue and the ‘Trial, Court ruled —

upon the entire patent.

After_a trial on this issue, lasting four court days, dur- ;

‘Ing w hich the trial judge heard petitioners’ witnesses and -

Witnesses from industry representing companies that had

3

«

purchased. and utilized the machines offered for sale and

sold by -petitioner,- the District Court handed down its

decision for the 1 respondents, accompanied by its written

_, opinion filed January 17, 1969, reproduced at Appendix’ B

- of this brief, in which the trial judge clearly and specifi-

‘ally set out his findings of fact and conclusions of law.

That there were no novel issues of law presented is well

shown by the citation. of only a single case by the District

Court, Appendix B-9. This cited case bore only on the

question of petifioners’ claiming in broader terms and lan-

guage, by late amendment, the feature of construction

which petitioner had specifically limited during the prose-

cution of the application for the patent in suit to only the

" disclosed feature: This-clement in the late-filed Claims 4

and 16, as found by both Courts below, was broadened in

these Jate claims to include a construction not disclosed ji in

the applic ation as filed.

The District Court found that ‘not only had machines

defined by the claims of the patent in suit been “On Sale’’

before the critical date of the patent application and before

the critical dates of the two late-filed Claims 4 and 16, but

these two claims had been subinitted by amendments in

the. Patent Office more than five (5) years .aftek the. appli-

cation had been filed and in view of new machines eartier

sold by petitioner Centri-Spray Corporation to the Olds-

mobile Diyision. Thesenew machines. embodied features of

construction not disclosed in the application, prompting

petitioners to then file amendments to the application

broadening the | scope of the claims in order to eCNCOMpass -

the new and different features of construction not previous-

ly disclosed: in the application.

The finding that there was sP-vidlaticn of the Statute

was etna 1 supported by the testimony and

record of the trial. The Depict Court found tliat peti-—

tioners, in their preparation and filing of the application

.

for the patent in suit and in their prosecution of that ap-

plication, well knew of the sales of the several machines

which established the presence of the statutory bar upon .

w hich the trial i issue was, based.

On appeal, the Court of Appeals for the Sixth Cireuit

affirmed in all particulars (Appendix A of this brief’) the

decision of the District Court. The opinion of the Court of

Appeals shows that the affirmance was based upon g proper

application of Rule 52(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil

Procedure.. The Court of Appeals went heyorid the. re-

quirements of the rule and held— .

“On this record we certainly cannot say that. any

of the findings of fact of the District Court on the

. Section 102(b) issue are ‘clearly erroneous” Fed.

R. Civ. P. 32(a).” ig 1 A-8.)

¥F enthes the Court of Apecale i in ils cone luding statements

respecting the District Court’s findings onthe .asserted

claims added by late-filed amendments, ‘stated: » -

‘In this record these findings also find such evi-

dentiary support that they cannot be held to be

“Clearly erroneous’.

oe:

“Our inspection of this reedrd cgnvinces us that

‘the concluding language of Muncie Gear is directly

ge” to this aspect of -appe Hants’ conten-

tions: ( Appendix A-LL.) ae

ARGUMENT _

There Are No: ‘Special and Important Reasons for Review

‘of This Case as Specified in Rule 19 of This Court «

While it is recognized that paragraph 1(b) of Rute 19

of this Court does not either control or fully measure this

Court’s déscretion, it does nevertheless set forth the gen-

eral circumstances under which ‘petitions for certiorari.

to a Federal Court of Appeals will be granted. The

“special dnd important reasons” referred to in Rulé 19

are reasons of public importance. All patent cases are

important to the litigants. But no special importance at-

taches to the patented industrial washing machines so as

to invoke the supervisory authority of this Court to pass

on mere questions—of fact. that have already been care- |

fully seratinized and decided by the District Court and

the Court of Appeals. . +

Nor do the> petitioners contend von there is a contlfet

between the decision of the Court ofS Appeals: for the

Sixth Circuit and any other court of appeals on the same

matter. .The case does. not inv Dan acortant question -

of Federal law which has no ba but should be setthg) ”

by this Court, because the Court , of Appe ‘als was con-

* cerned priinarity with the Distriet Court's findings of. faet

and conclusions of law, which it affirmed. There is no con

flict of applicable decisions of this: Court. hor have the

-courts below se far departed from the acer ptivd and usual

course of judicial proceedings as toc all lor-an exercise

of this Court’s power of supe rvision.

. 7

°

*

The Courts Below Considered and Treated the Issue of

Reduction to Practice as Purely

en

rz

_ Notwithstanding. the petitioneng? contention in ‘their

Question No. 1, both of the courts below found. that ‘the.

invention of -the patent in suit had in fact been reduced to

practice by the produetion and shop-testing of a machine

_ embodying the patented construction, its acceptance by

the customer, the receipt by petitioner Centri- Spray of

full payment. for,the machine, the use of that machine by

- petitioner in its competitive sales promotion and demen-

stration program, and the shipment of that machine to

the customer, all before-the critical date of the application

for the patent in suit. Petitioners themselves acknowledge

that the broader construction defined by the late-filed

Clains 4 and 16 was embodied in machines offered for

sale and sold before the critical dates of those Aaims

(Petition p. +). The Trial Court specifically held that ma-

chines embodyi ing the definitions of Claims 4 4 And.16 were

offered for sale and sold prigg to the critical dates of these

~ elaims (Appendix B-7, $).

= * €

Since the trial court and the Court of Appeals have both

held that the invention of the pafent in suit was. actually ”

reduced to practice before the eritical date of the apjylica-

tion, this Court has no need to review the que stion framed |

by petitioners thi it nectuc thon to prac tice” is a requirement

undet * the Statute. '

*’

The tridl Gourt found no proof of “experimental” o

dev@lopmental” activity beeause petitioneys presented

vone, though such Was their contention be ‘fore and follow.

mye the trial. ti. .- ;

Per Mie be

The “~~ Were questions ol. facet decided by haath of the Zz

eourt “7 below. ° ‘ % Z - 7 ( |

- ae ? ;

5

‘ .

.

The Courts Below Found as a Fact That.the Patented or

" Glaimed Construction Had Been Placed “On Sale” , ;

In Violation of the Statute - alata ..

“The trial Court had. the i issue of tlie ‘entire patent hefore

it (Finding 6, Appendix B-2) contrary to petitioners’ :

contentions in respect" to, their Questions 2 and 3. The in- +.

vention disclosed and defined in the patent, as the Court

found, had been embodied in machines o.ered*for sale and

sold before the critical dates of the application tg the .

late-filed Claims 4 and 16, in violation of 35 U.S CNG

|} ao : o |

This Court’s. decision in Leeds €-Catlin Co. x. Victor

Talking Machine Co., 213 U.S,.301,29'8.Ct. 495 Boo) in-®

volved an entirely different section, Section ASST of the

Revised Statutes, which established the term of a United:

_ States patent disclosing and claiming. an invention that the °

‘applicant for the United States patent brad earlis r covered

and claimed in foreign applieations and Pe nts. Legs i ia” =

clear and fo the effect that the elaims of bo patent «: fine

the invention ethibited Me them” (}. ae Wy. . Phe courts

below Sound that petitioner Centri-Spras Corporation has

placed the tnvention exhiited and detimed Jn the patent

Clatms on sale in’ violatton of Seetion Lone] ) a held the

patent in suit invalid.

Petitioners Jiave not contended. and cannot im good gon

science Contend, that. petitioner ContriSpray didi mot at:

‘fer fox sale and sell machines ‘enmibodving hts Invertion

detinydl in the patent in suit before the eritiegh date of the :

ppldaition and before the eritieal dates of the late filed

(Janes deand 16. lofted, they rely upon den alleced “ian.

provement the **shot p nN” deview, a> defined ia Chan

“Tt whaeh ayaas’ filed iineons

ae 8. 4 oy

’ the application, contending that it was disclesed in. the

_ application. But’ petitioners ignore the significant fact,

‘founded upon. petitioners’ own assertions to the Patent Of-

- fice , that, Claim 16 defiffed a construction ‘embodied in the

originally filed method Claims 6, 7 and 8, later abandoned,

_, Which defined the operation ‘and Gunction gf the earliest

.°. machines placed-‘‘on sale” and sold by petitioner Centri-

Spray before the critical date of the applic ‘ation in viola-

tion af Section 102(b), as: found by ‘the District Court in

. » inding 11 ( Appendix B-4) and its Conclusion of Law 5

i ciara ; he tate | 3 aa

In addition, the so-called **shot-pin” device is absent

from and is not ealled. for as an clement in any’ of the

patent clainis in “complete and accurate definition as re-

quired by 35°U.S.C. $112. The “omission of such “improv e-

ment’’ element from the sear claims ‘renders the claims

invalid, Bassick Mfg. Co. v. RM, Hollingshead Co., 298

US. 415, 425 (1936); L ame Engineering Co. “i, Stewart-

Warner Corp., 303, ELS. 545, 5490 195 38); Permiutit Co. -v.

ae er Corp., 284 U °S. 52, 57,60 41951); S.D. Warren Co.

. Nashua Gummed Paper, 205 F. 2d 602 (CA-1, 1953);

easer Industries Corp. v. McLouth Steel Co., (@CA-6,

- + 1968) 400 B. 2d 36, cert. denied 393 U.S. 1419; 89°S. Ctr:

992. Oe ry paeeee. es Sa

%

Kaiser held that, since the. invention: is measured by the

claims, the foeus for the’ proper definition of the peterited

invention is on those claims, ‘and the concept of invention

must be found in the claims: Failure to include petitioners’

“shot-pin” device. as an. esse tial component element of —

-each .patent claim renders. the elaims invalid, because !

petitioners have not distinguished their claimed invention

fram the washer combinations which they had earlier of-

__ fered for sale, sold, built and shop-tested, “be fore the-criti-

\ sal dates of the application and the late-filed Claims 4 and

ee a :

:

The Courts Below Held That the Combinations Defined

_* in Late-Filed Claims 4 and 16 Were Barred :

| ; -Under the Rule. of Muncie Gear

Petitioners’ Quéstion , direated to the application of:

Muncie Ge ar W ’orks, Tue. . Outboard, Mar: He and Manu-

poe Co., aio U.S. an (1942), to ‘the latd-filed Claims

4 and 16, completely ignores the facts, as Tound by’ the

| ‘ courts beloy, that (a) the construction de fined by the late-

filed Claims 4 and 16 was embodied i in mac ‘hines offered for-

‘sale and sold before. the’ critical ‘dates of those elaims

(I*inding °23, Appendix A-ll, 3-7), (b) thesé- late-filed -—

claims were, based—as ‘pétitidners stated to the Patent

Office, upon abandoned application -method Claims 6, 7.

and 8 that ‘defined the functional operation af, machines

offered for sale and soRl before the critical date of the

application (Finding 11, Appendix -A-2; B44). (e). the

late-filed claims were subihitted in view S£ the sale by petis

tioner Céntri-Spray of washers embodying a feature of cone

ita mar ipsa in -the application, as filed (Finding

» Appendix A-10, B-7), and (d) the, admittedly broad-

a, aa scope of these claims, enlarged to include such un-

dise losed feature, Violates the injunction of Muncie Gear,

‘The’ applic: ition of Muncie Gear by the courts below was > -

altogether correct. If the admittedly broadened Claims +

and 16 encompassed and defined a feature of construc tion

- ngt disclosed in’ the application,” partic ularly after peti-

tioners had, by prior amendments, limited such featuge

in their originally filed claims te only the lie losed_ con-

struction, Graham v. dohen. Devre Co., 3838 U.S. 1 (1966),

petitioners in these ¢ adoase had now broadened And change d

the’ original invention, Monroe oe poi Eanipment’ Co, 0,

Heck’'tharn Mayufacturing Co., 332. F. 2d 406 (CAN-6, 1964),

. cert. denied 379 US. S88. ‘

4&

10

The Findings of Fact of the District Court, t, Fully “Kioped

', by the Court of nag Should Not Be SetAside |

oe) / Except Under Most Unusual Circumstances.

,The matters presented by the petitioners are squarely

in linedvith statements made by.this C Surt. in. Grav er Tank

& Mfg. Co. . Lindé Air Products Co., 336 U.S: 271. In

particular,’we refer to page 274 where this Court, after

quoting | Rule 52(a), Feder al Rules of Civil Procedure,

Says: . ere i | be i

‘*The rule requires that an appellate court make.

allowance for the advantages possessed by the trial

court in appraising the significance of conflicting

.. _ testimony and reverse only ‘clearly erroneous’ find-

ings. These ‘are manifestly ‘supported by’ substan-

tial evidence and the Court of Appeals found them

supported by the weight of the evidence *-* * A-

court of law, such as “this Court is, rather than a

court for correction of errors in fact finding, cannot

undertake to review: concurrent findings of facet by

two courts below in the absence 0 of a very obvious

and exceptional showing of error.”

There is no showing of error in the petition.

2 : - CONCLUSION

4

- The Courts below held the patent in suit invalid upon.

the issue ander 55 U.S.C. §102()) that the patented con-

struction had been “on sale” before the critical date of the

application and before the critigl dates of the asserted

claims filed by amendment more than five years after the

filing. of the bz as iy Reh at wie te

We submit that the decisions of the Courts ‘were in all

respects carrect, the petitioners have presented noybasis

for the Court to exercise its’ jurisdiction, and the pphition

for a writ 6f certiorari should be denied...

| + Respectfully: submitted,

CASHAN ’P. HEAD :

- BENJAMIN \W. COLMAN

JELIUS DENENBERG

Attorneys for Respondents

1

a)

¢ e. x

: ag e

_ KPPENDIXA |

No. 19643 Bee byte. Se

UNTFED STATES COURT OF APPEALS .

; ‘ for the Sixth Cc ircuit me

Ajem Laboratories, Ine., and Centri-Spray’ C orporation,

* ) Plaintiffs -Appellants, +

. ee

. : - .

C. M. Ladd Co.,-Inc.,.and Charles M, Ladd,

Defendants-Appellees. © : :

ner from the United States Distr ict C ourt for the wes

Bastern District-of- Michigan, Southern Division

Deeided and filed Apr, 1970.

Before: Weick, Edwards and MecCree, Circuit Judges.

Edwards, Circuit Judge. ‘Phe question posed ebyethis=

‘ase is whether the United States District Court for the

“Epstern District of Michigan was right in holding appel- -

lants patent No. 2,979,062 invalid... The patent, issued |

sAprfl 11, 1961, covered. a ‘commercially suceesstul auto- ——— :

matie power washing machine for - cleaning automobile —

engine he ads and. similar’ large castings.’ The District

‘Court held ‘the patent invalid because the device had been

“on sale” for more than one year before the patent was

applied for. : | |

- 2 Oe A> ;

i.

Appellants Ajeni. Laboratories. Ini, (owner of the pat-

ent in -Stit) and Centri-Spray Corporation (exclusive, li-

‘eensee) brought this action claiming infringement hy ap:

pellees of claims 4.and 16 of their patent. af Ay * oe

- Epon appe lees’ motion, a.separate trial was heid on the

bd

“on ‘sale’ issue. Appellees contended hefore the District -

- Judge, and new‘eontend before us, th: it ‘the facts developed

in. testimony on ther motion to dismiss. clearly showed

the invalidity of the‘ patent under section 102(b) of the

Patent Act, 35 U B.C. § 102(b) ¢1964). This section reads

as follows: ae

e > ] °

“A person: Shall he etititled toa ‘patent unless—

* ** * f se :

2? é 4 “ei

7)

(b) ‘the invention was patented or described in this

or a f6reign country er in public use or ort ‘sale in this

country, ere -than one year prior to. the date of the —

applicationVYor’ patent a the United States . 2.2”

The District Judge, after t whines extensive evidence gn

the motion, made the following findings sof {det : : ‘

.

ee Qh Ditonddnt Best ablished ~ salletastied evi-

dence, Which Plaintiffs did not ‘nepal or overcome,

that Plaintiff Centri-Spray, prior ‘to the criticn! date,

November 9, 1953, issued six (6) offers for sale or pro-

-posais for machines which embodied the invent! on de-

finet in the Arnold Disclosure (x. P), in Cl aim 1

of the applic atipn as ‘filed, j in Claim 1 of thé patent as

‘ issued, and in the originally filed Method Claims 6, 7

and &, upon which Plaintiffs later, in 1960, purport-

edly ase d their amendmént claims as. issued as

patent Claims 4+ and 16. :

: (12) The Ford of Canada eichins offered for

‘* sale in August 1952, more. thant two years prior | to the

‘ ~

2

af

- filing ‘date of the application for the. patent in suit,

G

and represented by Plaintiff at the trial to be substan-

“tially according to the demonstration model, JExhibit

7, was ordered by Ford of Canada, constructgf by

. Plaintiff Centri- Spray, shop-tested, Appreved “by the

customer, invoiced: by Centri-Spray, paid for in. full,

and shipped to the customer before the critical date.

The machines sold to Pontiac Motor Division and Me-

Kinnon Industries, Ltd. ere proposed by Plaintiff

Centri-Spray and orde a these eustonjers well be-

fore the critical date., In accordance with such; con-

tracts of sale. Plaintiff Centri-Spray | proceeded to

fabricate these machines and to embody therein the

invention defined in ‘the disclosure, the application

and the claims of the is ssued patent. a eaees

. — -

“(13) Each of the offers and propos sals for the sale

of turret-type Wishing machines embodying the in-

vention fogord Motor Company-Highland Park, Ford

Motor’ Gpmpany-Cleveland, and Chevrolet Manufac-

turing ‘Division: were made prior to the critica ] dat. /

even though the purchise orders for the last two pro- ”

posals were issued after the critical date and the.ma-

chines were fabricated and shipped in -due course.

“(14) Plaintitt Centri-Spray offered | these ma-

chines for sal in accordance with their’ regular pro- Y

motional and competitive business practices and in’

the ordinary course of-their business. - At Teast phe

first of these washers, to. Ford of € anada,. was used. i in

Plaintiff's promotional sales efforts and shown“to its

prospective customers.” The é company’s officers’ and °

sales representatives, in sales promotional. discussions

With their ¢1 ustomers, mnposed nv, obligation _of seereey*

or confidence nor any re striction upon their disclo-

‘sures regarding the nature of the’washer cons struction

a ate S .

lo - . =e i

¢

derock “Phe _ proe cured, them tor ee USE, as

= . ’ . es

~ ac

at) . -

that Centri-spray was offering for sale andl late " built

for-them, “These offers pnd sales were made antl ene

tered inte solely for Vlaindiffs” profit, to provide their: :

customers with required, wasting equipmert. The

sitles Were undertaken. suid made in anvatmosphere of”

competitive aetivitye 2 es

CLD) Substential evidence Was presented and the \

Court dinds that none ef the machines charged by De-

fendants to violate Seetion AO Is) were offered, for

sale sas) ‘experimental’ inachines by -Plaintif! Centri-

Spray..No requirement, Was imposed by Plaintiff that

the purchased machines he kept seeret or in) confi-

dence, néro was any. requirement made upen the cus-

» tomers that they submit fo Plaintiffs regular or ‘any

test reports tipen the runctional operation, oflicieney

‘or inefticiency of the machines procured front Centri-

Po yee Te * : : Pen nate

Spray. , oe a _*

"C16) The customers of Pp lain tir Coatri- res ww did |

not underst ind nor-consider these ngi¢ shines to bevtexs

“pe rink ntal machines in any sense’ @hen theyorere*or-

resul ir “produc tion’ equipment.”

gl 1S The . facts: jextabliish that “Plaintitt* Centri-

_ Spray a did nat consider nor treat the machines

‘as either @xperiinent: ih or “developmental? Plaintiffs

did not request nor minke any record of festing, and

neither, its own empletees nor its customers’ em-

plovees, or for that matter anyone glse. kept or main-

tional effecdive-

trined any contrel record of the oper

ness of any of these washingymachines Offered for sale-

and sed hefore the eritical da +

ev(1S)) Plaintiff Centri- s fray ay offered each of these

Ne as a completely designed and operable ,piece

ee v 7 x s°

af production’ equipment, ready when, dativered to be:

‘installed and operated for production use at the plants

of its customers. It appes urs from the evidence that,at

least two of these very earliest: (195 3) machines are .

still in operation today, : . period of more than 15

-.% years.” eye, hes

.

“(19) It el early appears that. any “problems asso-

ci lated with thefstart- up and initial operation of these

*. 8 machines were merely matters of adjustment after in-

stallation, rather than, material changes in the nature

or construction of the wa isher eaten

. “ ° » ao

- Appellants concede, as inieed the facts require #that the

first a application for the pate nt in suit was nade November

9, 1954, and, hence, that the critical date i in re ‘lation to the

“on sale” provision of. Section 102(h) is ‘November 9, 1953.

Appellant Centri-Spray also Lonec ‘des that before Novem-

“ber 9, 1953, the critical dateé, it ‘had issued six’ proposals

for sale of the Washing machine, ‘which the District Court

held was’ covered by the patent in suit. But appellants

claim that in faet the invention had never been redyced to

“. practice in this country before the critical date, and, hence,

could not have been. “on saie” within the meaning of See-

tion. 102€b). Involved. in their’ ¢ontentions. i is ‘the ar eument

_ that. the first’ of. hese machines, which was fabricated to.

the order of and sold to Ford Motor Company of Canada, —

itd., was not attually’ in production use: prior to the

“critical date, “and in.any event, if it were found to hafe

been, that such use was in a foreign country and did ot

represent reduction to practice for purposes of the “on

sale” prov isions of Section 102(b).

We finde neéd to dea) | with the problems posed by the

arguinents Which pertain to the use of the machine by Ford

of (@anada on foreign soil. It scems clear to us that the

: evidende Supports thn ‘District F udee’s finding’ that the

- sple tod in the U mited States at the Livonia Ph mnt of appel-

lant, was tried out the re, atid Was used as it sales inodel™

* during the stummer af 155. -“Ehese facts, pkus the five other

“proposals tor sale of suche aie ee prior to the critica |

date, and payment for the Bord of Can da machine prior”

-to that same date ‘ppear to-us to proy ide anple, support

for the tinding-ot the District! Aude thi 4 tlhe dnve ntion had >!

heen on sate for more, than one vear prior fy the date ” Sees

2

the applic ation for they veent. —

“For purposes ot tifis e ‘ines we will assupre without, les

ee ciding, that. redueétion to, Prictican: of the invention is an

‘ exspiitial of the progts. ‘required | fer: an “he Sa e holding

a ae under Scetion Lb). : ..

Cc.

?

de This court has. pre \ fously che ld ¢ (in ease dealing with!

Section 18(e)) that for nate nt purposes an invention nay Re

he pethiced « to practice by iuil ling a working medelaand.

operating it undef simulated fe Id conditions without. the

necessity of showing sacees tu commercial uses: :, <4.

“Satisfactory reduction to practice ofh invention...

does not, hAvever, demand proof ef sucéessful -com-

. me reial use. ‘ora « ord Tire Co. vy. Dovan, ‘Chemical

Corp. 276 US Bas aS S.CL 380, 4, Ad. 610. (1928):

Minnesota- Mining & Mie. Co. ¥. Vat Cleef, 139 F.2d

aes | : a ae Sag 14), At Mes demand tests Which: sue- :

ae ae cessfully prove practic ‘al utility for its intended’ use:

The Court of Customs and Patent. Appedls has out-

» lined these pr ine iples thus: :

Ne

©

os tae 6 'To constitute an actual reduction to practice of

ge a ne hine, the device must be complet ted in an: op-

i erative form: capable of successfully demonstrating

~ 8.

. “nutoniatie wi isher ordered hy Mord of Canada: Wis COM. °° —<

Se af

“its ] practic: " u Vity in its acted ‘he kl cf use.

Oespuipanat v.

Vv Cummings

4250. ~Untlesh

_+its very simplicity its practical operativeness is

“manifest, Mason v. He phuta, 13 App. D.C. 86, 89,

49 J. 2d 490, 18° .C.P.A., Patents,

the device is, of: ‘suc hoi nature’ that by.

’

¢ the machine must. be tested under wie working «

/ conditions, Smith-v. Nevin, 723 F. 2d 940, 22 C.C.P.A.

Patents, 748, in such a way-as to demonst ate its

: sietth il. utility. fox -tts | sara purpose, Sydeman

i ‘Thoma, 32. App. D.C. 362. 373; Meldmeier ét al...

=a ¥ Mojonnicr, 97 F.2d 1 a 25 C.C.P.A,, Patents,

1. , AR, event probability of failure, T ayvlor v. Swine

gle, 13 zd vt, 30 CLC.PIA., Batents, 1219. Actual

eee eis re equired, of the function for which ,,

the machine is intended with. a qui lity, ‘oxtent, and .

character of operation sufficient to adits its utili-,

‘ty in the'environment-in which it’ is contemplated to

- be USC ful. Lavin’ v. Pierotti, supra, ‘| 129 F.2d 883

29 (' C. PAs, Patents, 1255}: Steenstrup v.’ Heath,

OF F.2d 514, 517, 25 C.C.P.A., Patents, OSI, OSG: Van

' Auken vy. Cranmings, supra. Fipld-v. Knowles, 183

‘F.2d 598 G01, 37 C.CPLA. (Patents) 1211 (1950).

#3 See aie: Visas Gord Tire Co: v. Dovan Chemical

Corpy Supra; Elmore v, Schmitt. 278 F.2d 510, 47

G.C.PLA. ( Patents)" 958 (1960). Toledo Scale Coxpo-

ration v. We stinghouse Electric Corpariition; Dal P.: ad

173, 182 (6th Cir. 156s g

The°faets in this case eee sntity the District Judge's

finding that the Ford of Canada Jniachine Was reduced to

practice’ by the. sliop tests-at the Contri- Spray plant? They

also fully justify his’ rejection ‘of appellants’ arguments:

a .

Norton, 25 ~ p. 1).C. 90; Van Auken’

*

|

a

)

+)

A-8 ; fy

‘ . ‘ -

“et

fo

Austin Machinery Co.-v: Buckeye Traction Ditcher Co.,:'

‘13. F.2d 697. (pth Cir.), a: denied, 273 U.S. 747 (1926).

e

On this record we cortainly ‘annot say that any of the

findings of fact of the District Court on the Section 102(b)

isstreeare “¢ learly erroneous.” Fed. R. Civ. P. p2(a).

9 ‘ ?

: .

.

: Much of appellants’:argument, however, appears ‘s cen-

ter Apon-a partictlar-locking device (the shot pin arrange-

ment) enrployed to lock the turrets of the washei-in place.

This device ww ay described. in patent claims 4+ and 16—par-

tieularty claim 16, Appellants ‘appear to assert 1) that -

* elaim 16 alone -represents an invention and 2). that this in-

‘vention was not a part of the Ford of Canada washer

and was not “on sale” prior to, the critic: al date. As to

this issue, appellants brief-states :

©

¢* “The Shot Pin Arrangement |

“As, stated prev iously, Claim 16 contains a material.

~ limitationg which is directed .to the, indexing drive

-means. This is s6-called shot pin arrangement. In

the words of’ the ¢laim it-is deseribed as follovs: |

a igs said indexing means for* said turrets in-

‘eyluding a drive shaft for turning each of said turrets,

a drive wheel connected to said shaft and having a

plurality of openings arranged in a cireular pattern

concentric with said shaft, a drive arm swingably

mounted for swinging movement along an are concen-

trig with said shaft and adjacent to said drive wheel,

a: drive. eylinder having a piston connected to Said

arm for swinging ‘the arm, a drive member carried |

by-said arm intermittently engaging said openings in

sequence. to turn sa uid. shaft, a locking evlinder mount-

edon the frame having a — intermittently en-

. -

ae, this machine Was .“e experimental” w ithin the rule of 4

Ty

AY Ah cet :

raginty said: wheel ‘for locking said turrets in align-

ment with said path :

“As. ste ited, SUpPA, this shit pin arrangement was

not. -eyven conceived of and released for production

until November 14, 1905 ~ ea. Binee this ‘is clearly

after the critical daté of thes application, November 9

1953, and it is to, a material part of Ch iL 16, Chain

16 cannot said to have Leen-on sale within the prohibi-

tion of 35 U.S.C. § 102()) more. than one year before |

the application was made.” (Mimphasis in original.)

vg ag | . os " yee |

- Appellants are, however, in’ our view faced by hard

vhoices.. | ay

If the invention claimed bysappellants to have been in-

fringed was disclosed in their application of November 9,

1954, in such bread claims as to include both the bord of

Canada mechanism and the. “shot pin arrangement,” then

the patent is barred because the ‘device was “on sale” for

more than one vear “prior to that date ror the reasons set”

outabove. - Se

: . eel 2 ws, Me ° . .

If, on the other hand, claimy 16.represents a separate in-

vention of which “the shot pin arr&igement™ was an es-

sentigh feature, such mvention clearly was not, disclosed.

by the patent. application of November 9, 1954. As to such

“ae claim, the Muncie Gear doc#ine of the Supreme Court

‘requires adoption of a critical date one .vear before: the

first disclosure. Muncie Gear Works, Inc. r Outboard.

Varime and Manufacturing Co., dio US. iw? (i$42).

Claims + and 16 were added by amendnents on’ February -

23 and April 25; 1960, and, hence, the critical dates appli-

cable to this argument would be February 3, 1959 and

April 25, 1959, respectively. |

ff

—-

A-10

As to this’-feafure-of appellant’s claims, the District

Court found: | ;

“(20) -Plaintif{s assertey’ Claims 4 and 16 of the

patent in suit “against Defendants. These claims were

“filed as new apparatus claims by amendments more

than five vears after the filing date of the application,

on February 3 and April 25, 196Q. These new ap-

paratus claims contained a definition of the he rizontal

transfer mechanism which read simply ‘transfer

means.’ * "This definition was eoneeded by Plaintiffs’

counsel at the trial to be an enlargement over the

definition for such. ¢ element ine the apparatus claims

previously limited by Plaintiffs to a ‘shuttle-bar’

transfer device, in their earlier prosceution Sf the ‘ap-

plication.

“(21}) ‘This attempt to ‘enlargé the claim coverage

followed the. Acquisition by Plaintiff Centri-Spray of

m order from the Oldsmobile Division for two turiet-

‘type washers requiring a ‘walking beam’ transfer

mech unis This order was acquired in Noyember

1959 upon offers for sale submitted by Plaintiff Cen-

tri-Spray: in Gedober, ‘The washers were. in fabriea-

tion at the time the first amendment was filed on Feb-

ruary 3, 1960, The sceond amendment was filed short- °

ly after shipment: and delivery of the washers to: Olds-*

mobile.

“(22). Plaintiffs obtained the entry of the amend-

ments, whereby Claims 4+ and 16 were issued in the

. patent, only after interviews by associate counsel with |

the Examiner in the Patent Office. These interviews

were held following the fermination of prosecution of

the originally-filed claims, and following Plaintiffs -re-

ceipt of. Oldsmobile’s order ior the two ‘walking beam’

washers.

“err All

“(23) The eritical dates of patent Claims + and 16

: ae . 7 %

asserted against Defendants are February 3, and

April 25; 1959.. Prior to these critical dates, .Plain-

tiff Centri-Spray, admittedly sold) machines edining’

within the de eimai of invention defined in these as-

= serted claims.” . i

In this record these findings also find such -evidentiary

support that they cannot be he Md ae Ie “fice rly erroncous.”

Our inspection of this record cont inces us, that the con-

cluding language of Mancie Gear is directly applicable to |

this aspect of appellants’ contentions:

P 7

-“Tt is clear to us, however, ‘that’ the amendments of

December 8, 1928, like the original appheation, wholly

failed to disclose the invention now asserted,

“The claims in eee ‘are invalid if there owas

public use, or sale, of the device which they are

claimed to cover, more than’ t&% -vears* before the

first disclosure thereof, to the Patent Office, Cf Rail.

way Co. v. Sayles, 97 US. 554, 557, 559, 563-64 ;

Schriber-Schroth Co. v..Cleveland Trust Co., supra,

at 57. Section 4886 of the Revised Statutes would fn

fered by application rather than by amendment; and

whatever may be the efficacy of an amendment as a

substitute for an application, it surely can effect no-

more than the application itself.

o

was public use, or sale, of devices embedying the as-

serted invention, more than two vears before it was

(1964).

_

. ‘

terms provide for their invalidity had-they been of-.

“We think the ¢onelusion,is inescapable that there’

* The applicable period is now one‘year. See 35 U.S.C. §102(b)

| et Bee

first presented, ‘to. the Patent Office.” Mautcie “Gear

Works, Tne. . Outboard, Marine ‘and Manufacturing .

Co, 3loU.s : 759, 1605 (1942).

Anto Equipment Company v. Heckethorn

Manufacturing and Supply Company, 332. F. 2d 406 (6th

Cir.) cert. denied, 9 U.S.888 (1964).

See also Monroe

The judgment of te District Court is affrmed.:

B-1

APPENDIX B

UNITE ST ATES DIST RICT COU RT

Haster n District of Michigan,

d_- Southern Division

~~

Civil pital! dass 7

Ajem Laboratories, Ine., a Michigan. corporation, and

* Centri- -Spray Corporation, a Michigan corporation,

Plaintiffs, *

--

¢ fe

:

C. M. Pre Co.,-dne., a” Michigan ‘corporation, and

— ~~... * Charles i Ladd,

Defendants and Third Party Plaintiffs, .

| Tyg, |

WwW ilson_ yer ee -Company, a Michigan corporation,

- Third Party Defendant. |

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

(1) This.is an action for patent infringement filed by

Plaintiff corporations, Ajem Laboratories, Inc. (Ajem)

- and Centri-Spray Corperation (Centri- Spray), organized

and existing under the laws of the State of Michigan, and

_ having their principal offices and place of business in Li:

vonia, .Michigan, within the _jurisdiction of this Court.

(2) . Defendants are a corporation, C. M. Ladd Co.,

Ine., organized and existing under the laws of the State

- ° ° c

~~ ©€

—

+

of Michivan and having its principal office ‘e- and. ‘place of

_ diction of this © ourt. ee

business in Trov, Michigan, and the individual Charles M.

Ladd, residing in Redfotd Township, within the juris-

e

(3) For the purposes of this litigation, Plaintitt Aseay

js the recorded owner of: Umbricht et al United States .~

Letter Patent. No. 2,979,082, and Plaintiff Contri-Spray is

the exclusive licensee of Ajem under this patent.

cen >

(4) ; Tith-<35 U hited States Code Section 102(b) sat

_? vids’ that a patent shall not issue if the “invention: was” «

“on ‘snle in. this country” before the ertiical date of the |

dade The idSntifieation off the “invention” is found,

upon reference to 35 U.S.C. $412, in the specification and

claims of both the application for and the patent in suit.

which were placed -in evidence. In addition, the Court had

available to it the original disclosure of the applicants

upon which Plaintiffs counsel based the application for.

_ Letters Patent.

(5) The application for the patent in suit was filed on

November 9, 1954, and the eritiéal date ‘therefor is No-

vember 9, 1953. _

?

(6) Upon motion’ of Defendants, a separate trial of

‘the ‘‘on sale” issue*undér 35 U:S.C. §102(b) was held on.

July 16-19, 1968 and primarily dealt with defendant’s con-

tention that the patent in suit was invalid ‘becatise the in- .-

-yention of each claim was aflegedly “on sale” more than one

year befcre the application, which resulted in this patent,

was filed in the Patent Office.’

. ‘=.

‘

(7) The disclosuré, prepared. -by .an:. officer of the

Plaintiff. Ajem experie néed for 22 years in patent mat-

ters before his employment by the Plaintiffs, described

and defined the invention as follows: | io oe

$

: - eve ®

-

Bee oe

* : . ; i

“The heart of. these new ‘improved w ashing devices

for engine heads and similar fabricated. castings or.

steel parts is found in Qe central units composed of

the. turrets,?the indexing devi ices and-the accompany-

ing arrangement of nozzles,” (Emphasis added. )

(Arnold Disclosure, ok. p. £1)

t

“In this newly designed washer: the primary inven-

tion is concerned with the indexing and transjer of

’ the part to position” the castings for separate wash,

rinse and drying operations, * * * It will be. noted

that there are two main motions to actuate and con-

trol.“One is the transfer of the head along the track

and the other is the indexivg of the rotating mechan-

ism.’ "(E mphasis added, )

(Arnold Disclosure, Ix. P. os 47)

“

This definition of applicants in their disclosure was used

and followed by counsel in the prepawation of the applica-

tionefor the patent in suit.

o(8) The invention described in the patent specifica-

tion involves a horizontal shuttle-bar transfer mechanism

having an intersected sectional track for sliding moving”

aparts to be cleaned horizontally through the washer, and —

rotary turrets disposed transversely of the track and in

the gpen spaces between the track sections for receiving

thé’ parts from the track, carrying them through a full

360°: revolution of the turrets, while spray. noezzels direct

jets of washing liquid or drying air to the parts, and dis- ~

charging the parts back onto the: track.

ole

(9) During ‘the initial prosecution -of the ‘application, ,-

Claim. as filed, together with other apparatus claims, were

materially limited in amendments filed by the Plaintiffs,:

- m é azo e

to avoid prior art patent-references cited hy the Examiner

and to ‘obtain the allowance of claims. These amendments

applied limitations’ to, the definition of the horizental.trans-

fer mechanism so that-the apparatus claims were directes

and, read specifically to a horizontal ‘shuttle-bar” trans-

fer device having an intersected sectignal track.

e

.

(10)° The file wrapper of fhe patent in suit reveal® that

early - in the proseeution of the applieation, Plaintiffs

wre required to elect between their apparatus claims aff

thre e method claims, as filed, before the Patent Office would

aet upon the merits of the applicatioi. To meet this “re-

quirement, Plaintiffs elected. the apparatus claims, . and

the non-eleeted inethod claim@ were thereupon restricted

from prosecution: (Method Claims’ 6, 7 and 8 were later’

meyperg upon the submisgion of new apparatus Claims

24 and 2 Fb oincigen Claims + and 16] ‘by amendments filed

February 3 and April 25, 1960.) ; = eds

(11) Defendants. established by substantial evidence,

which Plaintiffs did. not negate or-overcome, that Plaintiff’

Centri- “Spray. priar.to the critical date, November. 9, 1953,

issued six (6) offers for sale or proposals for machines

which embodied the inventien defined in’ the Arnold Dis-_

closure (Ex.P), in Claim 1 of the application as filed, in

‘Claini 1-of the patent. as issued,:and in the originally-filed~

Method Claims 6, 7 ad, 8, upon which Piaintiffs later, in

1960, purportedly based their amendinent élaiins. whiche

issued as patent Claims 4 and 6.

- 9

(12) The Ford of Canada Se ae offered fer en

in August, 1952, more than two years prior to the filing

date of the appligation for the patent in suit, and repre- .

‘ ‘sented b\ Plaintiff at the trial to be spbstantially according

to. the demonstration model, Exhibit 7, was ordered by Ford — *

of Canada, constructed, by Plaintiff Centri-Spray, shop-.

c J : *, F ‘ ae, “

” ee ae

, . /

tested, approved by the customer, bewuled by: Centri-Spray, |

paid for inegull, and shipped to the customer ‘before the

critical date, The inachines sold to Pontiae Motor Divi sion.

~and -McKinnon Industries, ‘Ltd. ‘were proposed by Plain--

tiff Centri-Spray y and ordered by these customers well be-

"fore the’ critical date, In accordance with such contracts of

sale, Plaintiff Centri-Spray proceeded to fabricate. these

‘machanes: cand to embody therein the: invention defined in—

the: disclosure, the application and the claims of the issued

patent. ; ee |

*

(13) Each of the offers and proposals for the sale of |

turret-type washing machines embodying thé-inventibn to

Ford: Motor Company—Highland Park, Ford Motor Com-.

pany—Cleveland, and’ Chevrolet Manufacturing Diyision

were made ‘prior to the critical date, even though the pur-

chase orders for the last two" proposals were issued after

the critical date and the machines: were fabricated and.

shipped in due course.

(14) Plaintift Centri-Spray offered tiene machines for

- sale in accordance .with their regular* promotional and

competitive business practices and in the ordinary course

of their business. At ‘least. the first of these washers, to

Ford of Canada, was used in Plaintiff's promotional sales

‘efforts and shown to. its prospective customers. The ‘cour

pany’s officers and ; sales ‘representatives, in sales promo.

tional discussions with their customers, imposed: no obti-

gation of secrecy or confidence, nor any restriction upon

their disclosures regarding the nati ite of the washer con-

struction that Centri-Spray was offe ‘rine for sale and later

built for them. These offers and sales were made and en-

tered into solely for Plaintifis? profit, to provide their

customers with. required washing equipment. The sales:

were un?ertaken and made in An atmosphere’ of. competi-

tive eetavity.

©

finds that mone of ‘the machines charged-by D

(15) + Sabstantiat evidence was presented and the Court

‘oud

to violate Section 102(b) were offered for sale as **experi-

mental” machines by Plaintiff! Centri-Spray. No require

be kept. seeret or in confidence, hor Was any niet

made tipon ‘the customers that they submit to. Plaintiffs

regular @ any tes® reports upon. the base co opera-

tion,. eftici ieney er ineflicieney of the inachines procured

from Centri-Spray. . kc =

(15): The customers of Plaintitt Centri-Spray drd -not

unde stand: ner consider these wuachines to be ‘texperi-

mental” machines in “any xe nse whe “Lh, they were ordet ‘od,

They procured them lor production Use, as regular produg-

tien equipment.

(17) “The facts establisli that Plaintit Centri-Spray

itself did not consider no? treat the machines’ as either

‘experimental” or rn “deve opmental” P laintiffs did not re-

quest nor make Anns, record of oes. and? neither its own

employees nor its. customprs’ employees, or for that matter

ment was imposed by Plaintiff that the purchased mae ‘hines:

anyone else, kept or maintained oo adeal record of the -

operational effectiveness of any of these’ washing ma-

chines offered for sale and ‘sold before the eritical di: tie,

a -

(18) .Plaintiff Contri-Spray offered“each of these ma-

chines as a completely désigned and oper rable piece. of

produetion equipment, ready ‘when delivered to be in-

stalled and opel rated for production ase at the plants of

its customers, It appears from the evidence that at least.

‘

‘

(19) It*cle arly appears that any proble nis assoein ed

‘

with the start-up and initial ope1 ration of these machines

were merely matters of adjustment after installation, ra-*

Qi?

Co

e

_.. two of these very earliest (1995) machines are. still in.

“ope ration today, a period of more than 1 years

~~

B-7

ther than mater jal changes i in the nature or construc ‘tion of

the washers; | mo hey te,

(20) Piaintiffs Asse rted Claims 4 | “and 16 of, thie pate nt

in suit agi uinst Dere ndgants. These clatms were filed as new

; apparatus claims by wnendinents nore ‘than five years

alter pes filing date of the application, on February 3 and

April 2 D, 196). These dew apparafus claims contained a

defhiition of the horizontal trans! mechanism which read

simply “transfer mgans’*, "This definttionaas cone eded “by

“Plaintiffs” counsel at the trial to be an chlargement over

the definition for such element. in’. ‘the apparatuS claims

pre vioushUimited by P iaintift’s ty a “shuttle bar” triffisfer,

device, in their cartier prosecution of the gpplic ition.

(21) ‘Bhis attewpt to enlarge the ‘claim coverage fol-

‘lowed the acquisition. hy Plaintiff Centri-Spray of an ‘order

>from the. Oldsmobile» Division for twof turret-type washers

requiring a “walking be aun’? transfer _Inechanisin, This

order was acquired in November 1959 pan offers for’ sale

Submitted by ‘Plaintiff Contri-Spyay in October. he wash--

ers: were in ‘fabrication at the-time: the first amendment

was filed on F ebruary 3 3, 1960. The second amendment was

filed shortly after ‘shipmen nt and delivery of the washe rs to

Oldsmobile. ;

(22) Plaintiffs obtained the entry of the pstndéveitas

whereby Claims 4 and ‘16 were issued in the patent, only

after interviews by associate counsel with the Examiner

2

«

.

in the Patent Office. 'T hest-interviews were held following

the termination of prosecution of tlie originally- filed

“claims, and. following Plaintiff’s receipt of Oldsmobile’s

order for the two ‘“walking beam” washers. .

(23) The eriticat dates of -patent Claims 4 and 16 as-

serted: against Defendanfs are February 3 and April 25,

1959. Prior to thése critieal dates, Plaintiff Centri-Spray

¢

-

f

.

an , B-S

adinittedly sold machines coming within the definition of

invention defined in these asserted claims.

(24). Plaintiffs were well aware of. and fully informed .

concerning their proposals for and sales of these washing

machines ‘to ‘the Ford Motor Company of Canada, Ltd.,

Pontiac Moton Division, McKinnon Industries, Ltd., Ford

Motor Compaiiy---Nighland Park, F ‘ord Motor—Cleveland

Engine Plant; and the Chevrolet Manufae turing, Division,

before the disclosure of the invention was made to, counsel

for the preparation of the application that resulted in the

patent. in suit. Photographs Gf significant and vital por-

tions of “ne first machine to Ford of Canada, illustrating

the invention, were included: With ‘the disclosure of appli-

‘ants to cotinsel. The ‘disclosure appears to have been

drawn, so far as the significant elenients of the invention

are concerned, as if no distinction was made by Plaintiffs

between the Ford of Canada maéhine and any of the other’

machines, including the Chevrolet machine, later *fabri-..

cated and shipped. and upon which Plaintiffs claim to have

based their application for the patent in suit. ee

.(25) . The Court finds that Plaintiffs did aut fulfil ¢ their

obligatiqn ofa full, frank and truthful diselostire of the

facts relating to the. washing machines offered for sale

and sold before the critical date of the application and of

the washers sold in. 1999, upon which they attempted to

obtain enlarged claiin’ covérage by theix filing of new ap-

paratus Claims + tand 16,

(26) The P Isintiffs, by failing to meet this obligation

in their prosecution of the application for patent, did not.

exercise that candor and good faith required of appli:

eants standing before the Patent Office.

(27) Defendants met and maintained their burden of

proof by showing that machines embodying the invention

hen

ma

owner me,

BS

were sold before ‘the critical dates in violation of 35 U.S.C.

§102(b), but Plaintiffs failed to meet or support their

burden of proof that the eon charged by Defendants.

_to violate the statute were ‘“expérimental” within the —

meaning and intent of Section 102(b).—

~ CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. This Court has, jurisdiction of the subject matter and

the parties in this action under Title 28 United States Cod

Sections 1338 and Title 35 United States Code See. 281.

_ Venue is properly laid in this District, Title 28 United

States Code Sec. 1400. \

2. For.the purposes of this litigation, Plaintiff Ajem>

is the owner, and. Plaintiff Centri-Spray is the exclusive

"licensee of the patent in suit, U mbricht et al United States

Letters Patent No. 2, 979; 062.

3. The application for the patent in suit wis filed No--

‘vember 9, 1954, and the‘critical date therefor was Novem- >

ber 9, 1953.

4. The machines charged. by Defendants to violate 35

United States Code Section 102(b) embodied the invention |

and were “on sale in this country” before the critical daté

of the application and before tlie critical dates-of asserted

Claims 4 and 16, in violation of the statute.

5: Claims 4 and 16. asserted against the Defendants.

and based by the Plaintiffs upon their originally: filed

- Method Claims 6, 7nd 8, later abandoned, are infalid: ‘in’

view of the sales, iy Plaintiff Centri-Spray of machines

embodying the. invention defined in these’ claims prior to _

their critical dates. *

6, Apparatus Claims 4 and 16 are- invalid under the

- Muncie Gear rule. ‘(Muneie’ . Gear Works wv Outboard, -

a

/

*c¢

tT,

B-10

Marine and Mfg. Co., 315 US. 759, 53 ULS.P.Q, 549) for

Clainning in broader terms and language, by late-amendment,

the horizdntal transfer means that Plaintiffs had specifi-

cally limited during their carlier prosecution of the origin-

~- ally-filed’ apparatus claims to a “shuttle-bar’’ transfer de-

vice, with an intersected sectional track.

5]

7. “Reduction. to pidictice’ is not essentially a neces-

sary element involved in a violation of 35. U.S.C. See. 102

(b) after proof of the sale without reservation for actual

use more than thé statutory period of one year before the

-application for patent ‘therefor. In these proceedifigs the

issue of reduction to practice is relevant only to show the

purpose of a particular use or sale.

< Even if “reduction to practice” were a prerequisite

fo a Section 102(b) violation, Defendants. have established |

the burden that the patent was reduced to practice for pro-

duction se bt, establishing that the Ford of Canada wash-

-er was shop-tested under conditions which satisfied both the

‘ this 17th day of January, 1969

"plaintiff and its customer; before shipment from laintiff’s

plant before the critical date as found’ by this Court in

paragraph (12) of Findings of -Fact (supra).

9. “Defendants are entitled to judgment declaring that—

U nited States Letters Patent No. 2,979,062 is invalid and

void, and not infringed by Defendants. |

10. * Defendants are entitled to thei ir casts and disburse-

anents, W rth costs against Plaintiffs. af ares 2 ee

11. Defendants are entitled to recover from Plaintiffs

s

thei? reasonable attorneys’ fees incurred in the defense of

this action and the prosecution of their counter-claim.

poco — /s/Thaddens M. Machrowicz,

a U.S. District Judge

Dated at Detroit, Michigan Meas es

r

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.