Appendix — Tooni v. Zuckert

Supreme Court brief1969

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

«

-matics at Hope College plus additional mathematics courses -

la

AFFIDAVIT |

State of Ohio | |

County of Montgomery, SS:

JOSEPH N. TOONI, being duly cautioned and sworn,

deposes -and says that with respect to his claim of having

_ taken physical chemistry I and II and including this as

part of his physics studies and for which he claimed six

(6) college credits, he includéd the laboratory work which

he took separately from the lecture work for which credit

was given; that further the transcript of his Hope College

record shows that in the college years, 1934-1935, he took

chemistry 410-a and 410-b theoretical and physical chem-

istry which were for college credit of two (2) semesters

which total eighteen (18) college credits in physics and

physical chemistry.

That with respect to his claim of twenty-two (22)

college credits, he earned sixteen (16) credits in mathe-

at military intelligence schools-at Fort Riley Kansas and

at Baghdad Military College; that he submitted a copy of

SF-57 on approximately December 17, 1955 on which he

_ deleted twenty-two (22) college credits for physics and

mathematics combined; it is his belief in subsequent typing,

he claimed sixteen (16) credit hours for physics, explained

above, and the typist by inadvertence, simply typed mathe-

matics by itself and copied the twenty-two (22) credits

from the previous SF-57.

Affiant wishes to cite SF-57 dated December 17, 1955,

which lists the following courses as having been taken at

Oklahoma A & M: Industrial chemistry ten (10) points,

engineering four (4) points, and laboratory organic prep-

aration four (4) credits. This totals eighteen (18) credits

and not twenty-eight (28) credits that he was charged

with having claimed; that subsequent SF forms 57 show

twenty-two (22) credits for work done at’ Oklahoma A & ©

meee RRR

peng

2a

Affidavit ‘

' M;; that it should be eighteen (18) ; that the six (6) credits

he claimed for the heat transfer fuels. and lubricants

courses relates to the engineering review course which he

took at University of California Extension School and .

which course was paid for by Aerojet General Corporation

in Sacramento, California while he was. employed by Stan-

dard Oil Company of Iraq; that he was attending a night —

school arranged for by the company to train him in oil

engineering which he was not previously mentioned; that

it was a petroleum engineering series of classes; that it

was his understanding that college credit was awarded for

the engineering review course at University of California

Extension School; that he did not know that the course was

non-credit until February 10, 1964, when he received a

telegram from the University of California Extension

stating it was non-credit; that he was told by Aerojet and

the instructor the course was equivalent to the included

courses that were credit courses; that he as a student was

told that upon completion of the course, he could qualify

to take the State examination for Professional Engineer

which requires a minimum of fourteen (14) credits in

engineering courses; that he had not had these courses or

their equivalent before ; affiant states further that referring

again to his claim of twenty-two (22) graduate credits, he

* has eae this in an attachment to SF-57 dated Decem-

ber 61; that the attachment is dated January 4, 1962;

that it shows the twenty-two (22) credits to consist of

work done at Oklahoma A & M and Institute of Applied

Science; that he has earned eighteen (18) credits as

* explained above at Oklahoma A & M and twenty-six (26)

credits at Institute of Applied Science as substantiated by

records of his work done at that school; that actually this

totals forty-four (44) credits but he claimed only sped

two (22) credits.

3a

‘Affidavit

Reference to paragraph 4c(1) of Notice of Proposed

Removal. Affiant states the list of technical college courses

completed reflects where the undergraduate courses listed -

were taken, namely at Hope College, Kalamazoo State

Teachers College, and at New York Institute of Applied

Arts and Sciences. Engineering mechanics I and II and

strength of materials were taken by him at New York

Institute of Applied Arts and Science; that at Hope College,

he took physical chemistry I and II, and comprehensive

chemical engineering programs; that he took heat transfer

and fluid flow (fluid mechanics) and thermodynamics at

University of California Extension in-Sacramento; that

he studied high polymer theory and practice and chemical

engineering analysis in Iraq with Standard Oil Company of

Iraq; that when he first went back to Iraq in 1936, he

was employed as superintendent of oil affairs of Baghdad

during the day; that at night, he taught at Baghdad Higher

High School, the equivalent of a Junior College where he

taught from 1986 to 1938; that he also took courses in the

Higher High School during the same time.

Reference is made to paragraph 4c(2) Notice of Pro-

posed Removal. Concerning the graduate courses at issue, ;

affiant states that he took physical chemistry and industrial

chemistry at Oklahoma A & M; that the fuels and lubri-

cants course, structural design, engineering mechanics and ©

power equipment were taken in Iraq with Standard Oil

Company ; that the remaining courses in the list are thermo-

dynamics, strength of materials afd the engineering re-

fresher course itself which were taken at University of

California Extension.

Reference is made to paragraph 4(3) Notice of Pro-

posed Removal relating to numbers assigned to the sep-

arate courses listed under the heading “List of Technical

Courses Completed”; that he either designated the num-

pial 4a

| Affidavit

bers as semester hours or he did not assign a heading at

all to such numbers. Affiant further states that at no time

did he call such numbers credit: hours; that in his mind,

semester hours means the equivalent in time spent in such

courses; that at no time did he wish to represent. that he

had credit hours for all the courses listed in the attach-

ment; that he had intended that the list would further

clarify the nature of his professional educational training;

that actually when you total his graduate hours, they do

total forty-four (44).

Affiant states that with reference to the charge of falsi-

fying item number 33 through the omission of required

information relating to arrests, he was driving and he

stopped to ask a police officer for directions to the Racquet

Club and this was in front of the Rocket Bar to which he

had already been directed; that the officer assumed he was

drunk because he: was otherwise occupied and affiant had

to ask the officer the same question 2 or 3 times; that the

- officer may have felt affiant did not know affiant was .

already where it seemed he wanted to be. (Officer mis- .

understood “Racquet” for “Rocket’”). The officer was put-

ting youngsters who were in the Rocket Club into the police

wagon; and was probably irritated and the officer told

affiant to get in the wagon also; that at the police station, |

affiant was told to pay Ten Dollars ($10.00) and told it

would be forgotten about; affiant understood there would

be no record made of the incident; affiant then went back

to his car and drove to the Racquet Club. Affiant was not

drunk; that the entire incident took jess than two (2)

hours including a fifteen (15) minute walk back to his car. |

Affiant did mention his arrest in Upper Marlboro, Mary-

land, and he would have mentioned the Dayton, Ohio inci-

dent if he had felt it was really recorded as an arrest.

2a

Affidavit

Reference is made to Notice of Decision—-Removal dated

April 2, 1964, paragraph 3(h). Affiant does not. believe

that anything should be inferred from the mere fact that

he had amended his SF-57 to conform to the evidence made

available to the Air Foree Agency; affiant still stands fast

on his statement that no falsification was intended in the

preparation of any of his SF-57’s; that at no time has he

had any motivation to falsify his SF-57 which has remained

substantially the same from 1958 to 1964; affiant received

his GS-12 in. January, 1960, based upon experience on the’

job; affiant states that he never said that his first and

second level supervisors were “liars or dishonest”; that in

SF-971. Employees Performance Rating, in April, 1963, he

-was marked low on “Loyalty to His Employer”; and all .

he did was make a statement that this was not true or

honest, confining his remark to the low rating; that he

never did tell his supervisors that they were “liars or dis-

honest”; that he teld this to Mr. Leuben, his supervisor, at ,

that time, and who rated him in this way; that Mr. Leuben

-is in no way a part of the removal charges per se; but,

however, Mr: Leuben was instrumental in originating the

oral admonishment based upon affiant’s saying the rating

was not honest; that Major Mente was not present at this

time but has accused him of saying Mr. Leuben and Major

Mente were “liars and dishonest.”

That Mr. Leuben competed with him for the. position of

supervisor and which position Mr. Leuben secured in July,

1962; that Mr. Leuben explained to him that by rating

him low in “Loyalty to His Employer”, he had in mind-~

remarks which affiant made comparing himself to Mr.

Leuben during such competition; that such. remarks |

which affiant made then were to the effect that affiant had

more experience than Mr. Leuben did; that after Mr. ©

SS TAO RT RT ee sist ih

6a

Affidavit

Leuben became supervisor, affiant never made such re-

marks; that they never had any difference of opinion to

speak of until the performance rating in question; that

_affiant’s performance rating had —— been satisfactory

or excellent.

In conclusion, affiant states that he at no time had any

intent to defraud o¥ misrepresent anything in his SF-57;

that he has served atisfactorily sincé 1947, entering the

government service as a ‘chemist; that he at no time

received any promotions or transfers that he did not earn

through expérience; that he never intentionally misrepre-

sented any material fact: Affiant does not believe that the

discrepancies claimed by the Air Force are significantly

material in view of the lack of intent to defraud to warrant

dismissal or removal from federal service.

Under all ‘the facts and circumstances of this case,

affiant believes the removal from his job to be too severe a

penalty; that he thinks his foreign extraction must be

taken into consideration in regard to the misunderstanding

with his supervisors.

“/s/ Josurn N. Toon!

JOSEPH N. TOONI

_ in my presence this

Sworn to before me an

31st day of January, 196

/s/ WILLIAM R. CoEN

- Notary Public

7a

Letter of Proposed Reméval

LETTER.OF PROPOSED REMOVAL

SGME | ° 07 FEB 1964

Notice of Proposed Removal

SGMES-20 (Mr, Joseph H. Tooni) |

1; It is proposed to remove you from your position with

the Air Force not earlier than 30 days after receipt of

this letter. 7 |

2. This action is predicated upon your having falsified offi-

cial documents. You furnished false information on your

educational | background both at the undergraduate and

graduate levels. You listed college courses which you never

had taken and college credits which you never had received.

You further stated that youobtained graduate credits

from a university which is nonexistent. In addition, you

failed to furnish complete information on your arrest

record in that you omitted from official documents a par-

ticular occasion of having been arrested.

3. This proposetl removal is specifically based upon your

_ falsifying the following official documents contained in your

official personnel folder: |

a. Standard Forms 57, “Application for Federal Em-

ployment’, dated 18 Dee. 1961, 11 Jan 1960, 9 Sep 1959,

apd 28 July 1958, as amended by signed statements from

you dated 18 Dec 1961 and 4 Jan 1962.

b. Standard Form 61, “Appointment Affidavits”, dated

4 Jan 1962. - a ee

4. With reference to each of the above listed SF 57’s, as

amended, you are specifically charged with falsifying the

information listed under item number 18, entitled “Educa-

tion’’, as follows:

a. Under item riumber 18.D you listed the following as

your chief undergraduate college subjects with accompany-

ing semester crédit hours: :

“UR NRO sears

°

8a

a

_ Letter of Proposed Removal

Chemistry—32

Engineering—24

Mathematics—22

Physics—16

Official records of your educational background above high

school level reveal the above information to be false to the

following extent: —

(1) That you obtained only 12 semester hours of

engineering courses or subjects at the undergraduate col-

lege level as opposed to the 24 hours you elaimed. The

courses which you completed were “Metallurgy I and II”

- at New York Institute of — Science for a total of 12

semester credit hours.

. (2) That you obtained only 10 semester’ hours of

physies.courses or subjects at the undergraduate college

level .as opposed to the 16 hours you claimed.’ The courses

which you completed are as follows:

(a) Physics 801—five semester hours from Hope

College. |

(b) Physics 302—five semester hours from Hope

College.

(3) That you obtained only 16 semester hours of

mathematic courses or subjects at the undergraduate col-

lege level as opposed to the 22 hours you claimed. The

*courses. which you completed are as follows:

on (a) Math 2—three semester hours from Hope Col-

lege.

(b) Math 3—three semester hours from Hope Col-

lege.

(c) Math 204—Four semester hours from Hope

College.

9a

Letter of Proposed Removal |

(d) Math 205—Four semester hours from Hope

- College,

of

*(e) Math 101—Two semester hours from Hope

College. .

b. Under item number 18.F you listed the following as

your chief graduate college subjects with accompanying

semester credit hours: ; |

Chemical Engineering—12 .

Organic Preparation—5 5 tit

Engineering Mechanics—5

Heat Transfer, Fuels & Lubricants—6

Except for the subject listed as “Organic Preparation”,

the above information is false iti that official records reveal

that the only graduate college subject or course which you

have taken is Chemistry 570, entitled “Advanced Organic

Preparation”. This was a three semester hour couyse com-

pleted by you in J anuary 1936 at Oklatvoma Staté Univer-

sity (formerly Oklahoma A&M). It is to be noted that you

claimed, in item 1QE, a total of 28 semester credit hours of

graduate college level Subjects while in actual fact you

have obtained only three semester hours. _

c. Attached to each Sf the referenced SF 57’s are essen-

tially identical listings entitled “List of Technical College

Courses Completed”.: These attachments are a continuation

- of item number 18 of the SF 57’s. On each you have listed

courses which are not supported. by the official records of

your educational background and, therefore, are false

entries. : | |

(1) The false entries which you listed under the head-

ing of undergraduate courses are:

(a) Engineering Mechanics I and II

(b) Strength of Materials

.

.

a Ge ey

10a

Letter of Proposed Removal

(c) Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow

(d) Physical Chemistry I and II

* (e) High Polymer Theory and Practice °

(f) Thermodynamics

(g) Comprehensive Chemical Engineering Prob-

lems

(hr) Chemical Engineering Analysis

(2) The false entries which you listed under the head-

‘ing of graduate courses are: «

(a) Physical Chemistry .

(b) Industrial Chemistry

(c) Fuels and Lubricants

(d). Thermedynamics

(e) Engineering Mechanics

(f.) Structural Design

(g) Strength of Materials

(h) Power Equipment

(i) Engineering Refresher Course

_.: (8) While not presented as a charge of falsification,

it is believed pertinent to point out that you presented

misleading information by listing a number alongside each

graduate course contained in the above mentioned attach-

ments. “These numbers, while listed without benefit of a

heading or explanation, do convey the impression that they

represent. credit hours. When added together these num-

bers total 40, and appear to represent that you have com-

pleted or obtained that number of graduate credit hours.

As previously presented, however, you have completed only

a three semester hour graduate course.

d. Undey item number 18.C you listed, in part, that you

had attended. California State College, Sacramento, Cali-

fornia, during the year 1957 and had obtained 14 semester

hours of graduate courses. In the listings entitled “List: of

lla

t

Letter of Proposed Removal °

Technical College Courses Completed” attached to each of

the referenced SF 57’s, you further stated that “Graduate

courses were taken at Oklahoma AGM College, Stillwater,

Oklahoma; and California State College, Sacramento, Cali-

fornia”. Aside from the two statements being contradic-

tory, official records of your éducational background reveal]

that the only graduate college course which you have taken

was the three semester hour course in chemistry specifically.

mentioned in paragraph 4b. Your statements that you

obtained 14 semester hours of graduate courses from Cali-

fornia State College and that you attended such a college

are false in that there is no such institute. The official

records of your educational background do establish, how-

ever, that you did attend the University of California

Extension School in Sacramento, California, from 11 Feb

to 11 Jul 1957 in which the facilities of Sacramento State

_ College were utilized. While enrolled you did complete a

noncredit course entitled “Review of Engineering Funda-

mentals—874”,

5. With reference to the mentioned SF 57 dated 18 Dec

1961, as amended, you are specifically charged with falsi-

fying item number 33 through the omission -of required

information. You are further specifically charged with

falsifying item number 8 to the above mentioned SF 61,

dated 4 Jan 1952, through the omission of required infor-

mation. ‘These items are identical on the SF 57 and 61

and are as follows: “Have you ever been arrested, charged,

or held by Federal, State, or other law-enforcement authori-

ties for any violation of any Federal law, State law, county

or municipal law, regulation or ordinance?’ Do not include

anything that happened. before your 16th birthday. Do

not include traffic violations for which a fine of $25 or less

was imposed. All other charges must be included even if

vai | |

t

TOT er tage

arg?

Re

12a |

Letter of Proposeg Removal |

they were dismissed. If your answer is: “yes” give in

Item 34 for each case: (1) approximate date, (2) charge,

(3) place, (4) action taken.” On each of these forms you

answered yes to this question and listed occasions of having

been arrested consistent with the dates of the Standard

Forms. You failed, however, to list on each of the forms |

that you had been arrested on.10 Sep 1960 at 238 South

Ludlow Street in Dayton, Ohio, on the charge of “drunk”

and that as a result you forfeited a $10.00 bond.

6. You are reminded that you received an oral admonish;:

ment on 24 Apr 1963 for various infractions, among which

was your calling your first and second level supervisors

“liars and dishonest”. In addition you received an official

reprimand dated 9 May 1962 for conduct which gave the

impression that you were asleep on duty. Your further

-received an official reprimand dated 29 Aug 1963 for your

_insolence and disrespectful behavior towards your imme- .

diate supervisor. These previous offenses were considered

in addition to the present offense in arriving at the decision

to propose your removal.

7. The evidence used to support the charges of falsifica-

tion contained in paragraphs 4 and 5 aboye was furnished

as a result of an official investigation requested by the

Deputy Cgmmander ofthe former Dayton Air Force Depot.

_ The investigation was requested on 15 Feb 1962, while you

were employed at the Depot, based upon receipt of infor-

mation from another Federal agency. The investigation

was completed on 22 Oct 1963.

8. You may answer these charges in person, in writing, or

both to the undersigned. You may also submit affidavits

in support. of your answer. You wili be allowed 10 days

from the date of receipt-of this letter to submit your

134 |

Letter of Proposed Removal

answer. In preparation of your reply you are encouraged

to review your official personnel folder and the documents

with which you are charged as having falsified. This right

to reply is a significant right granted to you. If you

believe the proposed action is unwarranted, it is important

that you reply stating completely all the facts why you

. \believe the proposed action should not be taken. If you care

to read the applicable regulations pertinent to this action

or obtain information about how you make a reply, you may

_ contact Mr. Jack Rottman of the Civilian Personnel Divi-

sion, Building ‘70, telephone extension 76126. This action

is being taken in accordance with the procedures set forth —

in Chapter 752 of the Federal Personnel Manual.

9. No decision to remove you has been made or will be

made until after the time allowed you for reply. Any

reply you make will be given careful consideration before

a final decision is made. Whether or not you reply, a

written notice of final decision will be given you. If you

do not understand the above reasons for the propesed

action, contact the undersigned for further explanation. |

10. No action based on the charges set forth above will be

taken to remove you from duty status in your present

position during this 30 day advance notice period.

/8/ LOREN D. CARLSON

.LOREN D. CARLSON, Captain USAF

Acting Chief. a

Engineering and Technical Division

Directorate of AF Support

im ..%,

M emorandum Decision and Order

UNITED STATES DISTRICT, COURT

‘SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO

WESTERN DIVISION

CASE NO. 3117

JOSEPH E. TOONI, ok

Plaintif,

v.

EUGENE ZUCKERT, Secretary of the Air Force,

Defendant.

a

MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER

(Filed July 3, 1967)

This matter is before the Court upon cross motions for

summary judgment. The Court has withheld decision of

this action pending a decision by the Court of Appeals in

another employee dismissal case which was decided by this

Court. On June 22, 1967, the Court of Appeals released

its decision in that case, Fass v. Ruegg, No. 17,031. In that

case the Court of Appeais noted the limited role the courts

are to play in cases where individuals are dismissed from

federal employment and then seek review of their severance.

The Court quoted with approval from a decision, Baum v.

Zuckert, 342 F.2d 145, 147 (6 Cir. 1965) wherein Judge

Phillips, speaking for the Court, said:

“The function of a reviewing court in cases involv-

ing the discharge of civil service employees is a lim-

ited one. ... The judicial function is to determine ©

whether there has béen substantial compliance with

the applicable procedures and statutes, and not to

review the administrative determination as to the wis-

dom or good judgment of the agency in exercising

@

l5a, .

M emorandum Decision and Order

its discretion . . . the courts will not examine into the.

merits of the dismissal. . . Sh

In the instant action plaintiff was removed from federal

service; he appealed his removal tothe Chicago Region

of the United States Civil Service Commission which found

in his favor and reversed the removal. The United States

Department of Air Force appealed that decision to the

Board of Appeals and Review, United States Civil Service

Commission, Washington, D. C. That. Board concluded

that plaintiff’s misrepresentations with respect to his

undergraduate and graduate studies were intentional and -

material, being designed to mislead the Air Force into

believing he had ‘a strong educational background in engi-

neering studies, whereas, in. fact, his professional educa-

tion preparation was mainly and primarily in Chemistry.

The Board concluded that the plaintiff's falsification of his

educational record in his application for Air’ Force em-

ployment, when considered in conjunction with his prior

record of one oral admonishment and two official, repri-

mands for other established breaches of discipline, war-

ranted his retnoval from federal service. Under the facts

in this case, the‘foregoing determination cannot be said to

-be arbitrary or capricious, as urged by plaintiff. ,

It may be true, as argued by plaintiff's counsel, that the

government has lost the services of a skilled and valuable

employee; but this Court cannot consider the merits of

plaintiff’s dismissal. The required procedural steps were

followed in plaintiff’s dismissal and the review of that

dismissal. Accordingly, plaintiff’s motion for summary

judgment is DENIED; defendant’s motion for summary

judgment is SUSTAINED. ,

/s/ CARL A. WEINMAN

Chief Judge U.S. District Cowzt

o

Bi erat

SPECS INS me:

ce are eae ot “Semen PE SLEK TLR OEEOY FR, SO iene

ae

TIS FETC RIN PN TEE TENS

be a a a ain Soa a

. léa

Judgment

JUDGMENT

y / _ (Filed July 3, 1967)

“~— This action came on for (hearing) before the Court,

q Honorable Carl A. Weinman, United States District Judge,

. presiding, and the issues having been duly (heard) and a

decision having been duly rendered, ae

It is Ordereu and Adjudged that upon the cross-motion§

for summary judgment filed by the respective parties and

the court being fully advised in the premises that defend-

ants motion for summary judgment be and it is hereby .

_ sustained and Plaintiffs motion for summary. judgment is

denied and plaintiffs complaint is hereby dismissed.

Dated at Dayton, Ohio, this third day of July, 1967.

/s/ R. L..SNELL

JOHN D. LYTER

Clerk of Court .

By: R. L. SNELL, Deputy

17a

Grievance Hearing

GRIEVANCE HEARING 7

SUBJECT: Grievance Hearing ‘2° November 1961

x : Commander p ;

Dayton AF Depct *

. Thru: Chief, Civilian Personnel.

Request grievance hearing as prescribed in AF Manual

A0-1 on matters already in hands of authority and com-

mand.

-_ #1-INSTRUCTIONS TO DELIVERING EMPLOYEE

[_] Peliver ONLY to

Show address where

dressee P delivered

(Additional charges required

for these Services}

RETURN RECEIPT

numbered article described on other side,

SIGNA ANAME OF ADDRESSEE (must olways be filled in)

habe Gch, FFD _

Received the

DATE DELIVcRED ADDRESE WHERE —e if requested in item #)

AeA

Daniel L. Edwards, Jr. ae ee

MDHQAI

ce: Commander

| Dayton AF Derot

RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL—206 |

SE]

a ~

/ / O8 DATE

-F} i i . WZ a AM,

ROMA

1105 ab Swe sone ae] 8

Lira where delivered + +

. 50¢ fee eer

FEES ADDITIONAL TO 204 FER

Ape teen a0 SEE OTHER SIDE

PI Ce sana a et ae tt a tet te

DIRS

: 18a

* AFM 40-1, AF A-12.5

AFM 40-1, AF A-12.5

TS 186 . AFM 40-1

31 DEC 61 AF. A-12.5

. In view of decisions of the United States Supreme

Court which have emphasized the importance of adhererrce

to procedural requirements when taking adverse personnel

actions, the commander will assure, when making his deci-

sion, ‘that there has been compliance with applicable

procedures whether externally imposed or established by

the Air Force at any level. If unusual circumstances cause

a delay, the hecsats will be notified of the reasons in.

writing.”.

=

toy DAAFDM 40-1 ee?

1 ck 1961 — | . DAAFDM 40-1

“ : Chapter 9

* * * *

. .

e. If the grievance cannot be resolved informally, the

supervisor to whom the grievance is presented in writing,

will initiate action withia 10 working days to obtain per-

tinent facts; afford opportunity to persons complained

against to make a written reply; render a decision, and.

notify the employee in writing of nis decision and reasons.

If the decision is not acceptable to the employee, he will be

informed that he may present his grievance in writing,

through the remaining supervisory levels, to the Com-

mander. If the employee requests a hearing, the statement

of grievance will be sent to the Civilian Personnel Officer

who will insure that an impartial grievance committee is

convened within 10 working days of the date of receipt

of the request to hear the grievance. If the statement does

not ‘contain a specific request for a grievance hearing the

employee. will be contacted orally to determine whether he

- 19a

AMCM 40-2

desires a hearing. This information will be recorded with

‘the statement of grievance and forwarded to the Installa-’

tion Commander, 2 aay Ns |

f. If a committee is not convened, thé CPO will ascertain

the facts and submit’ a summary to the Commander, to-

gether with findings and recommendations. Both the super-

visor and the employee -will be permitted to comment on

the statements made. by the other during the course of the

CIE Ee OE te cE rt

inquiry. *;

g. Within 10 working days after completion of the hear-

_ Ing, the committee or the CPO,. if no hearing was held

(paragraph 6f) wilt prepare a complete record of the griev-

ance to the Commander. The Commander will consider the

findings and recommendations of the committee or CPO;

make a decision, and give written notice of the decision to

the employee within 1 working days of the date on which

the recommendations; were received.

baat ein

Pee

x * x * *%

AMCM 40-2

HEADQUARTERS, AIR MATERIAL COMMAND °

AMC MANUAL ‘Wright-Patterson Air’Force Base, Ohio

No. 40-2 ) 29 July,. 1959

| - FOREWORD | | |

1. PURPOSE AND SCOPE. This manual establishes -

Command policy, applicable both in the continental] United ss

States and overséas with regard to disciplinary-and. other“

adverse personnel action procedures not specifically defined \ e

in Chapters C2 and S1 of Air Force Manual 40-1. .This )

. manual is designed to establish a uniform concept of dis-

cipline and disciplinary action and to assure that whenever

necessary, prompt and effective corrective action will be

‘taken in the interests of maintaining. an efficient work

force. This manual does not cover any action regarding

a . —_ POLE OLSON PORE PIES, ied toe

ELEN ET LOIN I TET LNT SL ISTO COG PS

7 MI RO Re RE anys ° '

POLS PIT Cre . ‘

: ,

. . é

7, 20a

| ~ AMCM 40-2 aes a

retirement, reduction-in-force, actions ordered by the Civil

Service Commission, action taken.on grounds of political

activity or subversive activity, or security (Air Force

Regulation 40-12), or actions taken in connection with the

| performance rating program. In no way does this manual

imply an infringement of the employee’s rights to use the

grievance procedure if he feels he has been disciplined un-

justly. (Italics ours.) eae

2. POLICY. Employees will be fully informed concern-

ing the conditions of their employment, their .duties and

responsibilities as well as their rights and privileges. The

Air Material Command recognizes its obligations to em- .

ployees 4nd in return expects each employee:

a. To be honest, reliable, trustworthy, and of good char-

acter, reputation, and unquestioned loyalty to the Govern- ©

ment and the Command. =

- ». To support and defend the Constitution of the United

States of America.

c. To give a full day’s work for a full day’s pay.

d. To conduct himself on and off the job in a manner that

will reflect upon himself and the Air Materiel Com-

mand. ;

- e. To respect the administrative authority of those who

direct his work. , ;

.f. To observe the spirit as well as the letter of the rules

and regulations governing his conduct. Emphasis will be

placed on the prevention of situations requiring disci-

plinary actions through the exercise of. gpod. manage-

ment practices. When, however, need for \disciplinary

action arises, the action which is justified and warranted

will be taken promptly, impartially, and constructively.

' 3 APPLICABILITY. The. policy and procedures set

forth in this mamial will be applied in order to maintain |

ie , ff

2la |

AMCM 40-2

acceptable standards of employee conduct, production, and |

efficiency and to insure.the exercise of sound management-

employee relations practices (AMC Regulation 40-14).

This manual will be made. available to all levels of super-

vision responsible for civilian personnel management; as

indicated in paragraph 6, AMC repens 40-7. , (Italics

ours. )

4. RESPONSIBILITY. The Civilian Personnel Division,

‘Directorate of Personnel and Support Operations, Hq

AMC, prepared this manual and will be responsible for the

preparation of future revisions or editions. |

«6. COPYRIGHT. This manual contains no eopyright

material.

FOR THE COMMANDER:

. (SEAL).

ERNEST L. WALTERS

Colonel, USAF

_ Chief, Administrative Services

* This manual supersedes AMCM 40-2; 5 = 56, and -2A,

14 Jun 56.

OPI: MCAC .

DISTRIBUTION : See page (ii)

AMCM 40-2, P. 14 (4-7; 4-8) ”

29 July. 1959 vo | AMCM 40-2

. 4:

re

\

* *+ &£ 8 &

16. NOTICE. PERIODS:

a. Notice periods will vary in length with various types

of actions and employees ae 2 and 3, — AF

>

SPO See 2

YR DE lia ihemins aa ea tiie Bieta TORRE ONG BEN ONTE

. . ~ a . e , ‘

\

CPOE RON EERE BLL EME OME BGs

lp.

22a

AMCM 40-2

$1.5, AFM 40-1 and the table in ania ine aad 20, this

manual). 54 °

(1) The determination as to what is a reasonable time |

will depend on all the facts and circumstances of the case.

(2) Sufficient time will be allowed to. give the employee

ample opportunity to prepare his answer and secure affi-

davits. | |

(3). Unless unusual circumstances exist which justify

immediate action, the following notice periods for proposed

suspension, removal, and separation actions are sufficient:

(a) In cases of suspensions of 30 days or more, a 30

. days’ notice period will be given preference eligibles. When

practicable all other employees will also be given a 30 days’

notice period. In no case will the notice period be Jess than

_/2 weeks (14 calendar days) for nonpreference eligible

employees.

(b)- In effecting suspensions due to emergency the length

of the notice period.may vary depending upon the proce-

_ dural requirements applicable in individual cases and the -

urgency of circumstances. It will be necessary to consult

the civilian personnel office before processing the emer-

gency. suspension. ees

(c) In Separation (Disqualification), that is, action

taken during the probationary or trial period, a notice

period of 2 weeks (14 calendar days) will be given.

(d) In Removal actions, it is mandatory that a 30 days’

notice period will be given preference eligibles. A 30 days’

notice period may be given all other employees; however,

a 2 weeks’ advance notice (14 calendar days) normally is

considered a reasonable notice period for a

eligible employees.

b. The notice period will begin the day often the em-

ployee receives the advance notice of proposed action, and

23a

AMCM 40-2

will terminate at the close of the last day of the notice

"period. Only full calendar days will be counted. For ex-

- ample, a 30 days’ notice period is given the employee. The

advance notice of proposed rémoval is received by the em-

ployee on 1 April. The notice period is computed as having

started the next day, 2 April, and will be terminated at the

close of the 30th day thereafter. The action will be effected

not earlier than the close of the employee’s regular hours

of duty on the day on which the full notice period is com-

pleted. ge :

¢. The civilian personnel office may be consulted in these

matters for further information as to regulatory require-

ments for determining notice periods.

17. STATUS OF . EMPLOYEE DURING NOTICE -

PERIOD:

a. Normally, the employee will be retained in his position

in a work status during the notice period of a pending sus-

pension, removal, or Separation action. .

b. The immediate Supervisor, through the appropriate —

operating official, may request that the employee be with- -

drawn from his position and/or the work area for the

period if there is valid reason to believe his presence:

May result in damage to Government property.

- May be detrimental to the interests of the Government.

- May be injurious to the employee, his fellow workers, or

the general public. | |

c. When it is necessary to place the employee in another

position during the notice period, an appropriate written

. Yequest, stating why the action is necessary, will be for-

warded to the civilian personnel office for consideration.

On the basis of reasons given and applicable procedural

requirements, a determination will be made as to the exact

status of the employee during the notice period.

SETH ero oe

’ .

e ad

24a

AMCM 40-2

d. In the advance notice of propased action, the em-

ployee will be advised of his Guty status ssc the notice

‘ period.

18. "NECESSITY OF NEW ADVANCE NOTICE:

a. When the action decided upon is the same as or less

severe than, the action stated in the advance notice, and

is based on the reasons or charges specified in the advance

notice,-‘no néw notice of proposed action is necessary.

(1) Regardless of its significance any error in the notice

should be corrected. Minor typographical errors may be

corrected by pen and ink change on al] copies of the notice

if the correction is not significant to the reasons or charges

in the proposed action, and if the correction in no way

violates the employee’s rights. 7

‘(2) When the error is considerable, but does not involve

any change in the reasons, charges, or the proposed action,

a corrected notice may be issued. For example, a corrected

notice should be issued if there is an omission of required

information, such as, failure to cite the regulatory author-

ity, to give the location and telephone number of the place-

ment and employee relations adviser named, or to give

all information about the importance of the employee’s

reply. When necessary, the notice period may be extended

with the issuance of a corrected notice so that the employee

- will have full opportunity to consider the additional infor-

mation and make.a reply, if he so desires. |

(3) In the event a lesser penalty than that originally

proposed is determined appropriate after reviewing the

employee’s reply and/or reconsideration of the offense, the

employee will be so advised in the letter of final‘decision.

_ b. A new advance notice will be issued if the following

conditions apply:

(1) ‘A more severe penalty is decided upon.

25a

Letter—Col. Lawton

(2) When the action set forth is based, either in whole

or in part, on reasons or charges not. specified ‘in the ad-

vance notice, ‘

c. When a new advance notice js given, all procedural

requirements, including the notice period, will be complied

with anew.

* * * * *

LETTER—COL. LAWTON

HEADQUARTERS

MIDDLETOWN AIR MATERIEL AREA

UNITED STATES ATR, FORCE.

Detachment 14, Heath Annex

Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio

Reply to

(SEAL) -

Attn. of: MAHQI | 20 Apr. 62

SUBJECT: Notice of Proposed Remova] and-Decision to

Remove—Inefficiency

TO: MAHQI (Mr. Daniel L. Edwards, Jr.)

1. This letter corrects ‘an error appearing in Paragraph

8 of MDHQA letter of ‘15- February 1962 by deleting sec-

tion 9.102 (a) (1) and inserting Part 22 of the Civil Service

Regulations.

2. You have received job protection rights under Part 22

of the Civil: Service Regulations and Sectiqn 14 of the

Veteran’s Preference Act, as shown by the 30 day notice

decision.

/S/ THOMAS O. LAWTON, Jr.

THOMAS 0, LAWTON, JR.

Colonel, USAF

Director of Heath Operations

a ee

SORYSTEA TOMES Pemen yyeee npeten may > SRR oy eae re OOH er parte te:

STONE PR Nee aeesRe Bip NBA cK Et sate

a

26a

AFM 40-1

ahi 40-1, CHAPTER AF, A-1, SEC. 5

TS 186 | AFM 40-1

31 DEC 61 AF A-12.5

| Section 5

THE HEARING PROCESS

1. GENERAL. The hearing process provides a com-

plainant the opportunity to present his dissatisfaction to

an ad hoc committee. This process is used to consider such

matters as dissatisfactions with working conditions or *

work relationships, personal bias or prejudice, performance

| ratings, and adverse personnel actions.

2. AD HOC GRIE SVANCE COMMITTEE. |

a. When it is determined that the hearing process is the

appropriate means for consideratior. of a grievance the’

- commander will appoint a committee on an ad hoc basis.

_ Every effort will be made to select members who will be

impartial in weighing the facts and will use sound judg-

ment in arriving at recommendations. The membership of

this committee will be compdésed of Air Force personnel

and will consist of three voting members and a non-voting

chairman. At least two of the three voting.members will

- be civilian employees of the installation. Members will be

selected from outside the immediate organizational unit

to which the aggrieved employee is assigned or from which

he was separated. The appellant will be permitted to select

one voting member. The selection will be made from the

roster established ui.der the provisions of paragraph 3c,

Chapter AF P-4.5. A non-voting chairman generally will.

be selected from among the best qualified members of the

servicing civilian personnel office. In the event a key mem-

ber of the civilian personnel office staff ix’ directly involved

a

27a.

AFM 40-1

in the grievance, e.g., he is the person against whom the

complaint is lodged, or will appear as a witness, the chair-

man may be selected from outside of the installation

civilian personnel office. }

* _b. The committee is a fact-finding and advisory body.

Its purpose is to assist the commander in arriving at a

prompt and fair decision when reviewing an action taken

by an operating Official. This is accomplished by making a

full and complete evaluation of the evidence in the matter

and by furnishing the commander the grievance record

(paragraph 12, Section 2) upon which the committee’s

recommendations are based.

c. The Secretary of the Air Staff will appoint a griey-

ance committee on an ad hoc basis for hearing grievances

emanating from employees in Headquarters USAF and the

Office of the Secretary of the Air Force. The composition

and functions of this committee will be the same as those

provided for the grievance committee at installations, 5a

3. PREPARATION FOR THE HEARING.

a. The chairman of the committee, upon receipt of a

request for a hearing, will give all persons immediately

concerned written notification of the hearing. These notices

will be given sufficiently in advance to permit adequate

preparation for the hearing and will: °

(1) Indicate the date, time, and place of the hearing, and

| the nature of the grievance to be considered.

' (2) Inform the complainant and the persons(s) com-

plained against of their right to request witnesses to

' Appear in their behalf or to present signed state-

_ ments from witnesses if witnesses are not available.

‘ This notification will state that persons desiring to

bring witnesses will furnish the committee chair.

man with their names ‘together with an indication

OME Re ete sak | See melne, age 5

28a

Oe

AFM 40-1

of how the testimony of each would be reievant.

Both the appellant and the person complained.

against will be supplied with a list of the witnesses

of the other party. The notification also will include

, the following information:

(a) The chairman will request, in writing, the attend-

- ance of all witnesses whose testimony has been de-

termined to be relevant and who are Air Force per-

sonnel. .

(6) Witnesses are expected to — facts freely and“

honestly as a basis to a fair and equitable decision.

(c) Only witnesses will be heard who, in the opinion of

«the committee, are in a position to offer testimony

relevant to the grievance; whose presence is con-

sidered necessary to a fair consideration of the

grievance; and whose presence at the heaniig is

practical. : ,

(3) Advise all persons concerned of their right to:

(a) Obtain and submit documentary evidence.

(6) Obtain advice from the civilian personnel office rela-

tive to regulatory and sees aspects of pre-

_ paring the case.

(c) Have, or examine, a copy of the grievance procedure.

(d) Attend a pre-hearing interview.

(4) Advise the complainant:

(a) That he must’ appear ‘idenoealiy before the com-

mittee and of his right to arrange for representation

at the hearing.

(b) Of his right to select one member of the ad hoe

grievance committee from the roster furnished

with the notice. °

b. “When the committee chairman regulate an Air Force

employee to appear as a witness at the hearing, the request

will be in writing and sent direct to the employee with a

29a

AFM 40-1

copy to the employee’s supervisor. The employee will be

advised that it is his duty to testify, that the testimony of

witnesses given freely and honestly is basic to a fair and

equitable decision and that his appearance as a witness will

be free from any form of interference, criticism, or reprisai

on the part of management. __

- ¢. In no instance will any person exercise persuasion

or coercion in an attempt to influence an employee appear-

_ Ing as a witness at a grievance hearing. |

d. If necessary to assure attendance of witnesses, the

committee will requést appropriate administrative author-

ity t6 require their presence. The committee, at its decre-

_ tion; may call witnesses in addition to those originally

requested by either party to the matter.

e. The procedures established by Executive Order 10925

and Section .7 of this Chapter will be explained to each

employee requesting a grievance hearing before the hear-

ing is granted. The employee will be requested to sign a

statement indicating that the above mentioned procedures

have been explained and that his grievance is not related

to discrimination because of race, color, religion or national

origin. If the individual indicates that the matter under

consideration is due to discrimination, he will be referred

to the deputy employment policy officer.

‘f. The. civilian personne} officer will furnish advisory

service to all persons concerned in preparing for a hearing.

He will designate the member(s) of his staff, other than

the chairman of the committee, to conduct prehearing inter-

views with the aggrieved employee or his representative

and the operating official or his representative.:

(1) The Aggrieved Employee. 7 cares

(a) In order for the civilian personnel office to exercise

its function of advising an employee regarding

any question connected with the written statement

ian {RL TR 5 |

30a

Standard Form 50

of grievance it. is essential that the employee state

his complaint fully and in detail-about time, place,

dates, events, and all other information pertinent to

the grievance; and to state clearly the remedy he

is seeking.

STANDARD FORM 50

NOTIFICATION OF PERSONNEL ACTION

(EMPLOYEE—See General Information on Reverse)

ndard Form 50—Rev. Dec. 1961

S. Civil Service Commission :

FPM R-1 50-110-08

1. Name (Caps) Last-First-Middle Mr. — -Mrs. :

EDWARDS, JR., DANIEL L., MR.

Birth Date (Mo., Day, Year): 05-11-23

Social Security No.: 403-26-6602 -

Veteran Preference: 2 (2—A5pt.)

Tenure Group: 1

Service Comp. Date: 09-13-42 —

9, FEGLI: 1 (1—Covered)

10. Retirement:.1 (1—CS)

12. Nature of Action: 345 (Code) Removal—Inefficiency

13. Effective Date: (Mo., Day, Year): 04-23-62

* * * * *

AID OP oo

15. From: Position-Title and Number: Missile Inspec-

tion Specialist (Guidance) HQA-1476

16. Pay Plan and Occupation Code: GS-1950

17. Grade or Level: 12 : :

18. Salary: pa 10,255

een Bile

Standard Form 50

19. Name and Location of Employing Office: AFLG, .

MAAMA, Detachment #14 (Heath Annex), Dir of Heath

Operations Quality Control Div, Quality Assurance Br,

Olmsted AFB, Pennsylvania

* * * * *

25. Duty Station (City-County-State) : Wright-Patter-

son AFB, Ohio pal

27. Appropriation: 431

28. Position Occupied: 1 (1—Competitive Service)

_ 30. Remarks: * * *

Functional Code: 4421,10-23

AFSC: 03054 |

Action taken for unsatisfactory performance of duties

as outlined by your ‘supervisor and contained in your offi-

cial position description. .

Notice of proposed action dated 02-15-62, received 02-19-

. 62. Reply dated 04-03-62 and. replied orally 04-11-62.

Notice of final:decision dated 04-16-62.

SF 55 issued 04-20-62. Maili g Address: 8828 Fairfield -

Avenue, Dayton 31, Ohio :

* * * & *

82. Office Maintaining Personnel Folder (If different .

from employing office): DESC (DESC-AR) Dayton, Ohio

33. Code Employing Department or Agency: AF 05

Department of the Air Force

_ 34. Signature (Or other authorization) and Title for the

Appointing Officer: /s/ BRap RoBBINS—Director, Indus-

trial Relations Office |

35. Date: 04-19-62

(1. Employee Copy)

. >

32a - 4

Special Order Appointing Committee -

‘nanhemenmnes ORDER APPOINTING COMMITTES

HEADQUARTERS .

WRIGHT-PATTERSON AIR FORCE BASE (AFLC)

United States Air Force

Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohic

(Letterhead )

SPECIAL ORDER 14 May 1962

M-104 ,

Under the provisions of Ciaiion AF A-12, Section

5, AFM-40-1, the following named Air Force Personnel

is appointed an AD HOC Grievance Hearing Committee

to meet at the call of the Chairman for the purpose of

hearing the grievance of Mr Daniel L Edwards, Jr, Missile

Inspection Specialist (Guidance), GS-12, Directorate of

Heath Operations, and to make recommendations to the

Comdr, Middletown Air Materiel Area, for his decision.

Charles A Bradshaw, Placement & Em-

ployee Relations Advisor, GS-7 (Chairman

without vote) MAHRA

Francis R Bush, Logistics Specialist, GS-13 :

(Voting Member) SANBS

Mrs Henrietta R Oliver, Supv Accountant, _

GS-11 (Voting Member) MCCOEC

Mr Lawrence E Toedte, Logistics Officer, GS-14

(Voting Member) MCFW

Mary L Williams, Shorthand Reporter, GS-9, .

Recorder (Without vote) EWJ

FOR THE COMMANDER:

[OFFICIAL SEAL]

Glen E Martin

Administrative Officer

Administrative . Services

DISTRIBUTION:

L

rr”

S8a-. ..

Letter, Col. Lawton, MAHQI

| LETTER, COL. LAWTON, MAHQI .

HEADQUARTERS *

MIDDLETOWN AIR MATERIEL AREA

United States Air Force

Detachment 14, Heath Annex

Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio

( Letterhead) |

‘ply to Attn af: MAHQI = . 20 Apr 1962

Subject: Decision to Remove—Inefficiency

| To: MAHQI (Mr. Daniel L. Edwards, Jr.)

i ‘My letter of 16 April 1962 notified you of my jane

‘to remove you on 20 April 1962, 7

2. You are now advised that the removal iets. will be

23 April 1962.

3. Other provisions of fy 16 April 1962 p letter remain

unchanged. 4

/s/ THomas O. WTON, JR.

THOMAS O. LAWTON, JR.

Colonel, USAF -

Director of Heath Operations

i

.

34a

Memorandum Decision and Order

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO

WESTERN DIVISION

CASE NO. 3059

re .

DANIEL L. EDWARDS, JR.,

Plaintiff,

Ve

EUGENE ZUCKERT, Secretary of the Air Force,

: Defendant.

Sn

~

MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER

(Filed July 3, 1967)

This matter is before the Court upon plaintiff’s amended

motion for summary judgment and defendant’s amended.

motion for summary judgment.

The law with respect to the removal of a federal em-

ployee such as: plaintiff has been stated in a very recent

case decided by the Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, .

Fass v. Ruegg, decided June 22, 1967 (17, 031).

- “In the government’s brief in support~of its amended.

motion for summary judgment, the government sets forth

in detail the reasons for plaintiff’s dismissal and the chron- |

ology of events. Those facts are not denied by plaintiff. :

The Court finds that the required procedural steps were

| _. followed in the removal of plaintiff from his position and

no précedural rights were denied plaintiff in the subsequent

reviews. Accordingly, plaintiff’s motion for summary judg-

ment should be and hereby is DENIED;.defendant’s mo-

tion for summary judgment should be ‘ond it atried is

sindadians Siea : é;

/s/ CARL A. WEINMAN

‘Chief Judge U. S. District Court

ss Tete

35a

Judgment

JUDGMENT

(Filed July 3, 1967) sates

This action came on for trial (hearing) before the Court,

Honorable Carl A. Weinman, United States District Judge,

presiding, and the issues having been duly tried (heard)

and a decision having been duly rendered, cae ;

It is Ordered and Adjudged that upon the cross-motions ~~ « ©

for summary judgment filed by the respective parties and:

the court being fully advised in the:-premises that the

defendants motion for Summary judgment be and it is

hereby sustained and Plaintiffs motion for summary judg-

ment is denied and plaintiffs complaint is hereby dismissed.

Dated at Dayton, Ohio, this third day of July, 1967.

/8/ R. L. SNELL F

JOHN D. Lytrr, Clerk of Court

BY: R. L. SNELL, Deputy:

LETTER, AFLC, W-P AFB, OHIO, DATED 13 DEC. 1962

Headquarters ie

AIR FORCE LOGISTICS COMMAND

United States Air Force

Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio -

Reply to Attn of: MCACA 18 Dee-1962

To: Mr. Daniel L. Edwards, Jr. a

8828 Fairfield Ave. ~. | [

_ Dayton 31, Ohio : , |

Dear Mr. Edwards

1. Reference is made to your claim submitted to the

Comptroller General which was forwarded to this Head-

quarters through Air Force Accounting and Finance Cen-

@ TOE SE A By Per RN CIRCE OREN we te 4 STR RU NSE

is

e : 36a

en |

y ‘ Letter, AFLC W-P AFB, Ohio, Dated 13 Dec. 1962

é ter for local settlement. Considerable difficulty was en-

countered in locating all of your pay and personnel records

necessary to adjudicate your claim. It is regretted these

difficulties have caused delays in settlement.

2. Listed below are the three separate accounts for which

you: claim payment for compensation: |

a. 2%4 hours compensation 20 October 1961 ~

‘ b. 8 hours compensation 30 November 1961

ce. The reduction of 16 hours from your annual leave

balance of 222 as shown on AF Form 530-1.

3. Under Public Law 623 you are entitled to pay for the

8 hours (LWOP) suspension on 30 November 1961. You

. are also entitled to 2%4 hours of pay for the LWOP charge

which was made on 20 October 1961, since your absence was

approved and was considered official business.

4. The reduction. of 16 hours from your annual leave

balance of 222 as shown on AF Form 530-1 is explained

below. It is to be noted the annual leave balance of 222

hours was lined out and changed to 206.

a. Eight hours was deducted for the 8 hours (LWOP)

suspension 30 November 1961. In other words the LWOP

on 30 November 1961 was changed to annual leave and

deducted from your leave balance. Reimbursement was

made for this day on the pay period ending 28 April 1962.

_b. The annual leave balance shown on AF Form 530-1

is a machine printed amount based on 8 hours of annual

leave accrual through pay period ending 28 April 1962.

Since your separation was effective on 24 April 1962 you

were not entitled to any leave accrual during this period.

These 8 hours of annual leave were deducted from the

machine printed amount of 222. _

- 5. Your final salary payments included the following:

48 hours compensation sor 16 ‘April 1962 ahs 23

Cn hoa ae

37a

_ Letter, Col. North

Official time wi attendance records lee this periéd indi-

cate you were in a duty status on 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, and

23 April 1962.

_ 8 hours compensation for 30 November 1961 for ‘which

your annual leave balance was reduced: _

* Regular earnings—above 56 hours—$276, 64

206 hours lump sum leave for os 24 April through 6

hours on 29 May 1962.

Lump sum leave 206—$1, 017.64 ,

6. Payment of 10%4 hours of compensation for which you

are entitled will be made by the Finance Officer, Newark

Air Force Station, Newark, Ohio in the near sien

Sincerely

/8/-E. A. ELY

EK. A. ELY

- Chief, Personnel Standards. Branch

Civilian Personnel Division

LETTER, COL. NORTH

Office of the Commander —

‘Headquarters

* 2907th AIR BASE GROUP (DAAFD) |

United States Air Force

\\ Gentile Air Force Station

Dayton 20, Ohio

23 Jan 1962

(Letterhead) .

Subject: Grievance—Daniel L. Edwards

To: Mr. Daniel L. Edwards

8828 Fairfield Avenue

Dayton 31, Ohio

PRR ILI *

38a

Letter, Col. North

Dear Mr. Edwards

i. I have reviewed the record of your grievance and the

report of the Grievance Committee which convened on 18

January 1962, to hear your grievance in accordance with

_ your request and applicable Air Force regulations.

2. The prime issues given consideration in arriving at

my decision were:

a. All government employees have the right of. direct

recourse to the Inspector General at all times without

hindrance or censure. : ,

b. There was no clearly defined evidence presented to

substantiate the charge that you went outside proper chan-

nels and obtained signature permission on the pass through

misrepresentation or fesepiciin ae

3. In uteiien of all the witness in the grievance

record and in the interest of maintaining an effective and

efficient work force, it is my decision that the aetion taken

to. suspend you from duty for charges as stated is unwar-

_ ranted, not justified and will be rescinded. .

Sincerely

/s/ C. L. NORTH

-C. L. NORTH

Colonel, USAF

» Commander

39a

Order

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

Nos. 18,288-18,229

(Filed 16 Oct. 1968) -

18,228 JOSEPH N. TOONI, tate

| Plaintiff-A ppellant, |

V.

EUGENE ZUCKERT, ETC.,

3 Defendant-A ppellee.

13,229 DANIEL L. EDWARDS, JR.,.

te Plaintiff-A ppellant, -

Ae V. Ai

EUGENE ZUCKERT, ETC., |

cs ie Defendant-A ppellee.

ORDER

Before:. WEICK, Chief Judge, CELEBREZZE and PECK,

Circuit Judges.

In these consolidated cases Appellants appeal from an

order of the District Court for the Southern District of

Ohio, Western Division at Dayton, sustaining the action

' of the Secretary of the Air Force in removing the Appel-

lants from ‘civil service employment by the United States

Department of Air Force. ne |

Upon consideration of the record, briefs and arguments

of counsel, we find no procedural rights were denied the

Appellants; and, considering the record as a whole find

there was substantial evidence to sustain the removals.

It is ORDERED that the jydgment of the District Court

be, and it is, hereby affirmed.

ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE COURT

’ /s/ CARL W. REUuss

.

‘

SORES NOR RPM TRO RELY MINE aR HIG ae Thane en

OTN HE de OLE Pe ee ME

a t

RRR MEROM Tete:

ph eee

“9

a mle er

DLA GBP ABBE 0 hoes Rica

Order =

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT |

No. 18,228

(Filed Dec. 10, 1968)

. JOSEPH N. TOONI,- .

| Appellant,

_ Vs. |

EUGENE ZUCKERT, Se@retary of the Air Force,

Appellee.

ORDER

Before: WEICK, Chief Judge, CELEBREZZE and PECK, Cir-

. cuit Judges.

Upon consideration, it is ORDERED that the petition

for rehearing be, and hereby is, denied.

ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE COURT

/s/ CARL W. REUSS

Clerk

4la

Order

UNITED, STATES COURT OF APPEALS

‘ ‘FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

No. 18,229

(Filed Dec. 10, 1968)

DANIEL L. EDWARDS, JR..,

Appellant,

Vs. ;

EUGENE ZUCKERT, Secretary of the -Air Force,

Appellee.

ORDER ©

Before: WEIcK, Chief Judge, CELEBREZZE and PECK, Cir-

cuit Judges.

Upon consideration, it is ORDERED that the petition

for rehearing be, and hereby is, denied.

ENTERED BY ORDER OF THE COURT

-/s/ CARL W. Riuss

Clerk

[

Yo Bene ome VSPA SAR NORE MENS MRI © rege

EOCENE Ip PERI 8 OPEB Rm 4 wT

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.