Appendix — Ramos v. United States
Supreme Court brief1968
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Appendix 7 ae | * ‘
Filed —
Jun 22 1966.
‘Clerk, U. S. Dist. Court
an Francisco
In the United States District Court for the Northern
’‘District’6f California, Southern Division
Joe R. Ramos and ‘Mary Ramos, aap :
: Plaintiffs, oe
ilar | ge
United States of America, No. 40202
: _. Defendant. ; :
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
The instant cases were brought by the~plaintiffs,
Joe R. and Mary Ramos, under Section 1346(a)(1)
of Title 28, United States Code, to obtain refunds of —
_ federal income tax and interest which they allegedly
overpaid. In Civil Action No. 40202, the plaintiffs
‘ seek to recover tax and: interest totaling $66,797.77,
paid for the calendar year 1956, plus interest allowed
thereon by law. In Civil Action No. 40033, they seek
to recover. tax and interest totaling $55,182.04, paid
for the calendar year 1957, plus interest allowed
thereon by law. These cases were consolidated for
trial and tried to the Court sitting without a jury. |
The issues of fact/and of law as framed by. the pre-
trial order of these consolidated cases and as ap-
_ proved by plaintiffs and defendant are as follows:
A... ULTIMATE ISSUES OF FACT:
(1) Whether or not a valid family partner-
ship composed of the plaintiffs and their children, .
Dolores Donaldson and Joe S. Ramos, was in |
existence and conducted and operated during the
calendar year 1956 in connection with orchard
and farming activities on the ‘‘Ramos Home
Ranch.”
(2)' Whether or nota valid family partner-
ship composed of Joe R. Ramos and his children,
Dolores Donaldson and Joe S. Ramos, was in
existence and conducted and operated during the
calendar year 1957 in connection with orchard
and farming activities on the “Ramos: Home —
Ranch”. :
B. ISSUES OF LAW:
(1) If the Court finds that a valid family
partnership was in existence during the calendar —
year 1956, was the sum of $70,640.48 received in
that year from crops sold during the. calendar .
year 1955 (at a time when there was no partner-
ship) taxable to the members of the 1956 part-
nership or to the plaintiffs. ~ to
(2) If the Court finds that a valid family
_ partnership was in existence during the calendar
year 1957, was the sum of $157,088.71 received in
that year from crops sold during the calendar
a :
year 1956 taxable to the members of the 1957
partnership or to the members of the 1956 part-
nership (assuming that the Court finds that a
valid family partnership was in existence for
the calendar year 1956) or the plaintiffs (assum-
ing that the Court’ finds that no valid: family
partnership was in existence for the calendar
year 1956). ee :
_ Additional questions which must be resolved as they |
_ relate to the amount of refund to which plaintiffs may
be entitled are:
(1) If a partnership is found for 1956, must the
corrected income thereof be adjusted to provide for
the elimination of deductions for depreciation and
_ property taxes.
(2) Ifa partnership i is found for 1956, must the
corrected income thereof be reallocated to. credit
plaintiffs with a reasonable salary for services ren-
dered by plaintiff Joe R. Ramos.
(3) If a partnership is found for 1956, must the
corrected income thereof be reallocated to credit plain-
tiffs with the reasonable rental value of the. land, -
trees and equipment used in the production and har-
' vesting of their crops during this year.)
1The alternative to a correction of. the 1956 seats income
by a reallocation of the credit due plaintiffs for the reasonable
rental value of the land, trees and equipment would be a realloca-
tion of the credit due plaintiffs as a return on their capital. In the
circumstances of this case, since neither the land, trees or equip-
ment ever became partnership assets and all that the partnership
received was the use thereof, such use may be more appropriately
treated and described as a rental (as was the case for the calendar
year 1957) and is so ete for the purposes of these en
4
@ Did no inion of Joe S. ee in 1956 and
for nine months of 1957 due to military service’ affect
the distributive share of the partnership income to
which he wile have been entitled but eerie such ab-
sence.
' (5) Ifa partnership is found for 1957, must the
corrected income thereof be reallocated to credit
plaintiffs with a. reasonable salary for services ren-
dered by the.plaintiff Joe R. Ramos. — j
Plaintiffs ‘were credited with the reasonable rental
value of the land, trees and equipment for 1957 (25% =.
. of the crop income), hence, subject to such adjust-.
ment as must be and will be hereinafter made because
the partnership operated on a cash basis, no problem
of reallocation of this item for this year arises.
- The Court’s answers’ to the issues of fact and law
framed by the pre-trial order and the above additional
questions, for the reasons hereinafter stated, are:
qd) A valid family. partnership composed of plain-
. tiffs, Joe R. and Mary Ramos, and _ their children,
Dolores Donaldson and Joe S.° Ramos, was in exist-
ence and conducted and operated during the calendar
"year 1956 in connection with almond orchard and
farming activities on the ‘‘Ramos Home Ranch”.
(2) A valid family partnership eomposed of Joe
R. Ramos and his children, Dolores Donaldson and
2Section 704(e) (2) of the Internal ‘Revenue Code of 1954 (26
U.S.C. 1958 ed. Sec. 704(e) (2)) provides in. part: “The distribu-
tive share of a partner in the earnings of the partnership. shall not -
' be diminished because of absence due to military sérvice.” An
identical provision appeared in Section 191 of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1939 (26 US. C. 1952 ed. Sec. 191). :
ee ee eee
“ee
- Joe Si Ramos, was in existence and conducted and
operated during the calendar year 1957 in connection
_ with almond orchard and farming activities on the
‘Ramos Home Ranch”.
(3) The sum of $70,640.48 received in the year
1956 from erops sold during the calendar year 1955°
was taxable to the plaintiffs.
(4) . The sum of $157, 088.71 aad: in 1957 from’
-erops sold during the calendar year 1956 was taxable.
to each of the members of the 1956 aguas in
equal shares. —
(5) The corrected income of the partnership ee
1956 must be adjusted to provide for the elimination
of deductions for depreciation and property faxes in.
the sum of $9,623.68 (depreciation $7,596.88 and. taxes
~ $2,026. 80). .
( 6) The corrected income of the inialy for
1956 must be reallocated to credit plaintiffs with a -
reasonable salary for services rendered by plaintiff,
- Joe R. Ramos, which the Court finds to be and fixes
in the sum of $4,200.00. ($350.00 times twelve months).
(7) The corrected income of the partnership for
1956 must be reallocated to credit.plaintiffs with the _
reasonable rental value of the land, ‘trees and equip-
ment used inthe production and harvesting of their
erops during this year, which the Court finds to be
3 Although the family partnership was formed i in about June of
1955, and the son, Joe S. Ramos, worked in the preparation of the
land for 1956 and in the. harvest of the 1955 crop, the family
partnership was not to commence camesnt: until January 1,. 1956.
6
and healt in the sum of $55,160.12 (25% of the erop
| ‘income of $220,640. 48). ;
(8) The ‘absence of Joe S. Ramon 3 in 1956 and for
nine months i in 1957 due to military service did not.in -
any way affect the distributive share of the partner-
ship income to which he would have been entitled but
for such absence. —
_..(9) The corrected income of the partnership for
1957 must be reallocated to credit plaintiffs with a
reasonable salary for services rendered by the plain- .
tiff, Joe R. Ramos, which the Court finds to be and »
fixes in the sum of yscitiee ($350.00 times ‘nine
months).
A further adjustment, must: be made on the, rental
- value of: the land, trees and equipment for 1957. -
Such adjustments, based upon the fact that the
partnership operated on a cash basis and based upon
“the books of the corporation, reflects the need to
correct the partnership income for 1957 by a deduc-
tion in rental of $11,240.67. (This deducted amount
_of rental was actually paid in 1958 and not 1957.)
~The foregoing answers and the adjustment of rental
_ for 1957 are amply supported by the record.
The documentary evidence offered and received in
evidence, the testimony adduced and the stipulations ©
a entered ‘into show no substantial factual conflict. The ©
7A record in these cases presents matters of law arising
- from what is in practical effect an agreed statement
of facts. (Tr. 215). All of the evidence in the case,.
oral and documentary, ; save and except Government’s
7
_-Exhibit “A” was presented - by plaintiffs, At the
Government’s request, all witnesses were excluded
fromthe courtroom during the taking of. testimony.
_At the conclusion of. plaintiffs’ case, the Government
~ rested and did not offer any evidence either by way
of oral or further documentary evidence. In this con-
nection it should be noted’ that. the farming and
business activities of the partnership,“as well as the _
acts and conduct, both business and. personal, of the -
individuals involved, had been under close scrutiny
and continuous investigation of government tax
agents and investigators since December 1958 (Pitfs:
Ex. 50). Also of significance is the government’s
frank and open concession that the testimony of the
four witnesses, Ruben Lopez (Tr. 367-373), Charles
Huff (Tr. 373-379), Frank Molina (Tr. 379-383) and |
“Sam Silva (Tr. 383-390) as to their knowledge of
the formation, conduct and existence of the 1956
family partnership ‘‘is fairly truthful” (Tr. 390a). .
The weight to be accorded such a record is well ex-
pressed in Nicholas v. Davis, 204 F'. 2d 200, 202 (a tax
refund case), wherein, in connection with | a similar
record, the Court said: _ | 3
When. controlling, positive ni uncontradicted
evidence is introduced, and when it is unim-
_ peached. by cross-examination or otherwise, is
not inherently improper, and no circumstance ~
reflected’ on the record casts doubt on its verity,
then under the principles laid down in Chesa-.
peake & Ohio Ry. Co. v, Martin, 283 U. S.. 209,
215-220,:51 S. Ct. 453, 75 L. Ed. 983, it may not
_be disregarded even though adduced from inter-
‘ested witnesses, and no question of credibility
° .
SY
—————— ere |
| a
or issue of fact is aes for determination by
the jury.
. See also: Alabama Title & Trust Co. v. “Miltsap,
71 F. 2d 518, 520; S.F. Assn. for: Blind v. Industrial ©
Aid, 152 F. 2d 532, 536. .
‘
The Partnership Background.
Joe R. isin ie Sickie ty Rnbdin tend dias Wi the
United States just before his sixteenth birthday. in
1925. He was not.a man ‘of formal education. His .
total schooling in Spain was five months and in the
United States it consisted of about one month’s study
in~ preparation of his application for citizenship,
which was granted to him in .1950 or 1951. In 1931
he married’ the plaintiff Mary Ramos at Auburn,
California. ‘Both of their children were born in
Loomis, California; their daughter, Dolores Donald-
son, on November 15, 1931, and their son, Joe S.
. Ramos, on September 17, 1934. —
_ Joe R. Ramos had farmed on his own account in <
California since 1932, and prior thereto had worked )
as a ranch hand for others, In 1943 he purchased a J
_ 219 acre almond ranch at Winters, California, where —
he established the family at what became known as ©
the “Ramos Home Ranch”. At this time Dolores was
about twelve and one-half years of age and Joe S.
‘ Ramos was about nine years of age. Throughout all
_ their school years the children worked on the. ranch.
As they progressed in years, maturity and ability,
they were responsible for and took on more and more
of an’ active participation in the various ramifica-
tions of farming crops in and about the ranch
(Tr. 10). While Dolores: was in high school she
began to learn bookkeeping in connection with the
books of account and gecords of the ranch (Tr, 11).
She was tutored in this work by Mr. Beverly
Laugenour, the certified public accountant, who for
many years was in charge of the books of account
. and responsible for the tax returns of Mr. and Mrs.
Ramos (Tr. 11), Her brother, Joe S. Ramos, was
carefully trained. by his father in preparation for his
eventual work as the “outside partner”. Young
Ramos’ many years of apprenticeship were not con-
fined to mere menial farm chores. To the contrary,
he was meticulously and patiently instructed and
trained by his father in all aspects of almond ranch-
ing, including the planting, shaping and cutting of
trees (Tr. 421), spraying and pruning of trees
(Tr. 421), contouring of land, placing of markers to
indicate direction of levees (Tr. 423), pollenization
(Tr. 423), and the hiring and recruiting of field
workers (Tr. 27), including a trip to Mexico for such
specific: purpese (Tr. 372). This latter activity, bear-
ing in mind young Ramos’ knowledge of Spanish, was
one of the most important aspects of the operation
of the ranch because it had to do with the actual |
harvest of the crops. This training and work of his
children was in preparation of and had for its definite
_ objective the fulfillment of the clear intention, under-
standing and avowed purpose of Joe R. and Mary
Ramos that when their son, Joe S. Ramos, reached
his twenty-first birthday,-a family partnership com-
posed of all members of the family, would come into
—_— ee
. * 10
‘being (Tr. 19, 145, 154, 421, 426-427), This idea and
purpose was acted upon as early as 1946, when Joo
I. Ramos sought the advice of their then attorney, —
Mr. Ford of Colusa County, as to the wisdom and
propriety of forming a family partnership with his
wife and children (Tr, 13).
It ix not open to question that on numerous ocen-
sions the subject of a family partnership was dis-
cussed by atid among members of the family, and —
that these discussions became more numerous and
pointed as Joe S, Ramos approached his twenty-_
. first birthday. Tt cannot be disputed that the finalizing
of the ‘agreement to form the partnership actually
took place about the time Joe S, Ramos graduated
from Sacramento Junior College in June 1965, and
that immediately after graduation he went to work
on a full-time basis at the home ranch in connection
with the 1955 crop, Because of his draft status, and
his status in the Naval Reserve, he entered the United
States Navy, but deferred doing so until November
1955, at-a time when the 1955 crop had heen fully
harvested (Tr. 23). . |
The plain and legitimate inferences which may
properly be indulged in-and drawn from the record
in this case are that the Ramos family is an affec-
tionate, close-knit, loyal and harmonious family, in
which the virtues of filial respect, obedience and
industry are the daily way of life; where the good
things of life are worked for, nurtured and preserved
for their enjoyment and natural passage from the
parents to the children; “‘eventually that some day
“
il J
they would take over the complete management them-
selves, the children”, (Tr. 515),
As authority for its resolution of the ultimate facts
as to ths existence and operation of valid family
partnerships for the years in question, this Court
relies upon the principles enunciated in Commissioner
v, Oulbertson, 3387 U.S, 733, 93 L. Ed. 1661, decided
in 1949. The yardstick by which the trial court is
to measure the “family” partnership is set forth-at °
page 742 of the Chief Justice’s opinion, wherein he
declared : |
~ . The question is not whether the services or
capital contributed by a partner are of sufficient
importance to meet some objective standard ©
supposedly established by the Tower case, but
whether, considering all the facts—the agreement,
* the conduct of the parties in execution of its pro-
visions, their statements, the testimony: of dis-
interested persons, the relationship of the parties,
their respective abilities atid capital contribu-
tions, the actual control of income and the pur- -
poses. for which it is used, and any other facts
throwing light on their true intent—the parties .
in good faith and acting with a business purpose
intended to join together in the present conduct
of the enterprise. (emphasis supplied)
Again, at page 744 the Chief Justice went on to
declare: |
Unquestionably a court’s determination that
the ‘services contributed by a partner are not
‘‘vital” and that he has not participated in ‘“‘man-
agement and control of the business” or con-
tributed ‘‘original capital” has the effect of plac-
' 12
ing a heavy burden on the taxpayer to show the
bona fide intent of the parties to join together
as partners, But such a determination is not con-
_ elusive, and that is the vice in the ‘‘tests” adopted
by the Tax Court. It assumes that there is no
room for an lionest difference of opinion as to —
whether the-services or capital furnished by)the
alleged partner are of sufficient importance to
justify his inclusion in-the partnership. f, upon |
a consideration of all the facts, it is found that
the partners joined together in good faith to con-
duct a business, having agreed that the services
or capital.to be contributed presently by each ts
of such value to the partnership that the con-
tributor should participate in the distribution of
profits, that is sufficient. The Tower case did not
purport to authorize the Tax Court to substitute
its judgment for that of the parties; it simply
furnished some guides to the determination of
their true intent. (emphasis supplied)
The record in the instant case amply meets the
test laid down by the Culbertson: case. In the words of
the Supreme Court, ‘“There is nothing new or par-
ticularly difficult about such a test.”
If, on the instant record, the Court were to con-
clude that there was no true partnership in existence
and operating during the years involved, it would be
substituting its judgment for that of the parties. This
record does not reflect “a misuse of the outward
form of a partnership as a device for the obtaining
of tax advantages”. This Court finds that the parties,
without. thought of tax advantage, in fulfillment of a
long-nurtured and oft expressed desire ‘‘in good faith
SPAS HEP TA ~- - hat See el ae ee
LD 0 eg LIAL ETP FPS LAKE 0A OH See ew
pe sithins Wi hoe | ee
13 :
and acting for a business purpose” and a ‘‘community
of interest in the profits and losses”, joined together
‘in the conduct of the almond orchard and farming
activities of the Ramos Home Ranch. This was their.
true intention and the history of the partners in their
actual operations during the last six months of 1955.
and throughout 1956 and 1957 bears this out.
- The 1956 Partnership.
‘The expressed intention of the parties to form a
family partnership, although not to be operative un-
til January 1, 1956, came into existence, as the par- .
ties intended for years, on September 17, 1955, which
was the twenty-first birthday of the son, Joe S.
Ramos. It was given meaning and’ expression as-.early
as June of 1955 when young Ramos graduated from
Sacramento Junior College. From the day of his .
graduation and until November of that year, when
he enlisted in the Navy, young Ramos, with knowl-
edge of the family partnership to be formed and
formed on his twenty-first birthday and in prepara-
tion and anticipation of its operative effect on Jan-
uary 1, 1956, worked continuously on the ranch to
complete the, harvest and prepare for 1956. by ferti-
lizing. an ‘spraying. His sister, Dolores, contributed
her services as bookkeeper throughout 1955 and con-
tinuously thereafter in 1956 and 1957. The fact that —
she was also employed by the Pacific Gas and Elec-
tric Company did not detract in any way from her
capacity to properly keep the books and records of
the ranch, nor did it prevent her from enjoying the
14
_ status of a partner. It is a fair statement from the
record that no partner worked “full time”. This was
“necessarily so because the busifiess was a seasonal
business in many respects. Joe R-Ramos, the father,
did not devote his entire time and attention to the
ranch, but was engaged in-.other pursuits, business
ventures other than the partnership.
The basic concept, of a partnership | is a group of
persons having a common business interest, working
together in their respective spheres toward the suc-
cessful operation and conduct of that business in-
terest. It does not connote the idea that each and
every working partner must punch a clock at eight
‘O’clock in the morning and work continuously through
the day until five o’clock. Dolores devoted her en-
ergies, skill and ability toward the paper work of the
partnership in all that was*required of her and
thereby fully’ performed -her responsibility to the
partnership. Young Ramos, after doing all lie could —
to complete the 1955 harvest and to prepare for 1956,-
went into the Navy and thereafter continued to do
everything he could within the limits of military serv-
ice by keeping abreast of ranch affairs, giving advice
on farming matters, expressing his concern over ranch
_ operations and by working on the ranch during some
of the days of his Christmas furlough. In 1957 he
worked. continuously on the ranch from the date of
his discharge from the | Navy on October 4, 1957 to
the end of the year. In speaking of the arrangement —
with his father at the time of his enlistment, he said:
“It was an understanding we had, that I had with
my father, that he would take care of things while
<3 | 5 |
I was gone and when | I came back, I would make it
up, and then he could take it easy. ” (Tr. 464-465).
Under the circumstances of this case wherein the
_ partnership, pursuant to an oft expressed intention
over the years, was created on September 17, 1955,
even though not operative until January 1, 1956, the
military service of young Ramos did not foreclose,
was not intended to foreclose, and statutorily (26
U.S.C., 1958 ed., Section 704(a)(2)) could not fore-
close his right to a distributive share of the partner-
ship earnings. See: Culbertson v. C.I.E., 168 F. 2d.
979; Seabrook v. C.I.R., 196 F. 2d. 322; Crossley v.
Cumabel 87 F. Supp. 862; Anderson v. Robinson,
115 F. Supp. 776; Skarsky v. United States, 153 F.
Supp. 796, cases whisk are in accord with the con-
clusion reached by this. Court, though the specific _
principle relating to absence because of military serv-
' ice was not discussed. _
In reaching its conclusion this Court is not un-
mindful of the Government’s reliance on the case uf
Cain v. United States, 135 F. Supp. 516. However,
there are three significant facts in the Cain case
which. distinguish it from Ramos:
(1) That at the time of the ‘Cain partnership
young Cain had already received. a, commission .as
a probationary naval ensign while still in dentistry
- school, and. prior to the signing ‘of the agreement;
(2) That the partnership agreement took the pre-
- caution to provide that should the son die during
his period of service all the property of the partner-
ship would immediately revert to the father. This in
- ee
. 16
the face of the fact that at the time of the agreement
young .Cain was married. This indicates a.lack of
control of the son over his interest in the partner-
ship because the fact of death would completely cut
out his wife and all peopel? would revert to the
father; .
(3) That the Cain case involved a partnership of
a strietly personal service character. .
Contrary to Cain, we have Culbertson, and the a“
uation respecting the four Culbertson sons, whose —
' partnership status was contested. The oldest. son was
twenty-four years of age; married, and living on the
ranch, of which he had for two years been foreman
: under the Coon and Culbertson partnership. He was
a college graduate and received $100.00 a month plus ~
board and lodging for himself and his wife, both be-
fore and after the formation of Culbertson & Sons
and until entering the Army. Thé second son was
twenty-two years of age, was married ‘and finished —
‘college in 1940, the first year during which the new
~ partnership operated. He went directly into the Army
- following graduation and rendered no services to the
partnership. The younger sons who were eighteen
and sixteen years of age, respectively, in 1040, went
‘to school during the winter and worked on @he ranch
-. during the summer. In a concurring opinion in Cul-
bertson, Mr. Justice Burton at page 749 states:
. The physical absence of some of the Cul- -
hertson boys from the ranch does not necessarily
preclude them or others from the obligations or
the benefits of the ‘eal for tax purposes.
.
deme pc chainiseiciaitnatiecen rie Mitre brats tend iels
ee eo
. he on in nicl
Their sisal: of capital, their stlininge:
tion in the income and their commitments to re-
turn to the ranch or otherwise to render service —
to the partnership are among the material fac-
tors to be considered. A present commitment to .
render future services to a partnership is in it-
self ‘a material consideration to be weighed with
— all other material considerations ‘for the purpose
' of taxation as well as for other partnership pur-
poses. (emphasis supplied) : :
The fact that the negotiations leading up to the 1956
partnership, and ‘the partnership agreement itself,
‘were oral, did not militate against the exis+ nce of the
partnership, for as Joe R. Ramos expressed it, “.
we understand we don’t have to have papers between
the family.”. (Tr. 69) During this particular year the
partners had not received any advice as to the forma-
tion of their business partnership and did not for a
moment believe that there _was-any impropriety in
continuing the business in the name of the father
alone. As Mr. Laugenour, their then accountant, put.
it, ‘‘Although aware that a family partnership would
be formed when the son, Joe S. Ramos, and the daugh-
‘ter, Dolores, were both of. age, I took no technical
interest in their discussions because there: was in my
opinion no action necessary to accomplish this. rela-.
tionship for the purpose of preparing income tax
returns. 9 (Pitts. Ex. 89)
It is true that in 1956 no change had beer made in
_ the bookkeeping practices of the family, that, other
than the use of the land, trees and equipment in what
18
‘the Court deems to have been a rental, there was no
actual capital contribution, and separate partnership
accounts were not maintained, yet there was no ques-
~ tion as to the partnership and the nature thereof. This _
_ was expressed in the testimony. of Dolores Donaldson,
when she testified on cross-examination: | ww
Q.. Well, what was your twenty-five pe cent
interest in 19569 2 s
A. In the partnership agreement. When we ~
formed it we were going. to be partners, were —
going to be a family partnership, all together, and
. whatever income we made we would share.
If we had losses, we would share them and: we
' would pay your expenses, and whatever’ was left
we would share twenty-five percent, my father,
my mother, my brother and I. I don’t think you
have to own land to have a share in anything.
Q.- In other words, you feel you can partici-
pate in the profits from the land. without owning
any portion of the land? Roel
A. Yes. oe oe
- Q. And this is the type of partnership interest
you had, just in ‘the profits generated by assets?
‘A. Profits or losses that would be produced by
the almond trees on the lari@. (Tr. 301-302)
Even though there was no bookkeeping separation
of the partnership business from the rest of the fam-—
ily business, the books were adequate and clearly
- reflected what were to be considered as partnership
’ items and what were to be gonsidered as items per-
sonal to Joe R. and Mary,S. Ramos. The business
operations on the home ranch in. connection with the
6g
_ almond crop were not of particular magnitude and —
- did not involve:the intricacies and complexities inher-
ent in a big business. On the subject of bookkeeping
records. in connection with farming activities, it has
“been stated in Britt’s Estate v. C.I.R., 190 F 2d. 946:
- As to the bookkeeping records, farming is not a
type of business in which elaborate records are
usually kept.. Nor are the members of a family, -
when dealing inter se, as likely to observe formal-
ities ‘as strictly as when dealing with others.
Spurious agreements, designed to evade taxes, are
_ frequently in better form than genuine ones. The
records here kept were adequate and appropri-
ate for the purpose, and present no evidence of
distortion or concealment of: facts.
This almond crop business,’ which was well suited
.. to the Ramos family, was operated and carried out in
- the utmost good faith, in accordance with their ‘part-
_ nership agreement, with each of the partners exer-
cising dominion over the business in their respective
spheres and participating in the earnings thereof in
- accordance with their respective interests. The part-
nership distributive shares were received and uséd
and controlled by the partners with complete inde-
pendence and have continued ever since to be so
received, used and controlled. ‘The 1956 partnership —
returns for both the federal and state governments
were made in accordance with the agreement, and. sub-
‘ ject to adjustments hereinabove and hereinafter set
_ forth, strictly and accurately reflected the distributive
share of each partner. /
| ye
7
The 1957 Partnership. 3 ; |
Without going into any. greater. detail than neces-
| sary, the record clearly: reflects a valid formalizéd
family partnership agreement between Joe R. Ramos, -
Dolores Donaldson and Joe S. Ramos for the year
1957. Except for the formalization of the agreement
and the fact that it was limited to Joe R. Ramos,
“Doléres Donaldson and Joe S. Ramos, the: 1957 agree-
ment was essentially the same agreement that existed
in 1956. The man instrumental in the formalization a
of the family agreement was Mr. Ffanzman, a cerfi-
Laugenour as the family accountant. After reviewing
. with the family the entire family operation in 1956,
he testified further at page 486 as follows:
Q. Yes, and do you know who was instru- ,
mental in having the change made? :
A. Well; I guessI was; .. : ;
Q. . All right, tell us about that. —
A. Well, one of the first questions I° asked all. -
the members of the family, whether there was a
' written partnership. agreement on this, and I
- found out there was none, so I said ‘“Well, in my
opinion, we-should firm up this a little more. Ii’s
-fme what’s in your hearts, yes, it’s a partnership
within your heart or the heart of each of you, but’. ,
- for legal purposes we probably should firm it up
a little. Something might happen to you, might .
happen to Joey, Dolores—You don’t know, you
don’t know what you might ‘get. involved in.” So
I suggested-some type of a —e agreement
be drawn up.
>
SN DEAE TES a
' -fied* public accountant, who in 1956 succeeded Mr. ny
21 %
ad
| " Thoreation a partnership eagtensiink: was drawn up
_ with each of the partners making an initial capital
contribution, of $15. 000,00, for a total of $45,000.00.
As"the exhibits refiéet, the partnership agreement was. -
followed by such documents as Memorandum of Rent
Agreement, Certificate of Transacting Business Under.
. Fictitious Name of “Joe R. Ramos & Co.”, Affidavit .
of Publication, together with the opening of partner-
commercial and savings accounts and 6riginal
_ books of account and bookkeeping records of Joe R.
Ramos & Co. Without going into further detail, it can
be said that the proof of the 1957 partnership is re-
plete with indicia pointing to the fact that the pro-
ducing, harvesting and sale of the 1957 almond crop
“ , was conducted as a family partnership enterprise.
It i is clear:
(1) That the partnership épétations were wnulinatis
in accordance with recogni#éd business practices and
pursuant to the intent of the parties;
_ (2) That each of. the partners made capital con-
tributions of $15,000.00, and that these respective
capital contributions were necessary to and were
utilized by the partnership in connection with the
1957 operations; ;
(3) That the partners Joe R. ro and Dolores
Donaldson each rendered services to the partnership
in accordance with their previous understandings and
agreements and did the work allocated to them; and
(4) That. the partner Joe S. Ramos, by reason of
his: military service, was not able to be physically .
&
present. in connection with the 1967 farming opera-
tion until his discharge on October 4, 1957, and that
he then immediately went to the ranch, without any.
time off or vacation, and worked straight through to
the end‘of the year. As heretofore stated, Joe S.
,Ramos was a partner, and. his ‘military servicé in no
- way served to diminish and was never intended to
have the effect of diminishing his distributive: ‘share
in the partnership earnings. ‘
. Having found a valid family partnership for 1956
ana a valid fafnily partnership for 1957;*the Court,
in determining the amount of overpayment, must now . ~
give consideration to the adjustments to be made to -
establish the corrected partnership income ‘for each of
these years and the manner in which the income
should be allocated arhong the partners. The Realloca-
tion of Receipts from Crops Sold in .Prior Years.
: Depreciation and Property Hanes, Rental and Serv-
tees of Joe R. Ramos.
In 1956 the Ramos family partnership reported <as
’ part of its gross income the sum of $70,640.48 received
for almonds raised on plaintiffs’ ranch and sold in .
1955 before the partnership was to become operative.
Similarly, the partnership for 1957 reported as part
_of its gross income the sum of $157, 088.71 received for
almonds, and peaches (the receipts for peaches
amounted to only $152. 60) raised by the 1956 partner-
. ship in its operation and sold and delivered to the.
buyer in 19956. Although the plaintiffs and the part-.
nerships for 1956 and 1957 were on a cash basis, the
fact‘remains that the receipts in 1956 for crops raised
. * .
— 2 S *
- een Seen er. oe as
in 1955 represented earnings of the plaintiffs, and the
receipts in 1957 for crops.raised in 1956 ae '
earnings of the 1956 partnership.
‘It is basic that income from serves is taxable to
- the person who* renders, the services, and that income
‘from property is taxed to the person. yho owns or
controls the property. Moreover, this basic cgncept, ©
. which has been applied to Section 61 ofthe Internal :
Revenue Code of 1954 and similar provisions of prior |
revenue acts, cannot be defeated by a: transfer a
assignment before the income is realized. The $70, ~ |
_ 640.48 received i in 1956 for*crops sold in 1955 ‘repre- |
sented: income earned exclusively by the plaintiffs and
generated by their services and by property owned
and controlled by them, ‘The 1956 partnership con-—
tributed nothing to the earning or creation. of this
income. Similarly,.the $157,088.71 received in 1957 for
.. erops sold in 1956 represented income earned exclu-
sively by the 1956 partnership and generated by
services of and property controlled by the 1956 part-—-——
nership. The 1957 partnership contributed ee: to .
~ the earning or creation of this income.
_ The plaintiffs, having earned $70,640.48 for crops.
' sold in 1955, cannot defeat or avoid their tax liability _
by assignment to the 1956 partnership, and the 1956.
partners, having earned $157,088.71 for crops sold. in
1956, cannot defeat or avoid: their tax liability therefor
by assignment to the 1957 partnership. For cases in
accord, see: Lucas v. Earl, 28% U.S. 111 (1980) ; Hel- el
vering v. Horst, 311 U.S. 112 (1940); Helvering v.
Eubank, 311 U.S. 122: (1940); Anthony’s Estate. v-
a — :
+
a if a . oe .
)”
eri
“7 Commissioner, 155 F. 2d 980 (10th Cir. 1946) ; Austin
v. Commissioner, 161'F. 2d 666 (6th Cir. 1947), cert.
- denied 332 U.S. 767; Palmer v. Commissioner, 267 F. .
<< .° * Od 434 (9th Cir. 1959), cert: denied. 361 U.S: 821;
* Williamson v. United. sais 292 F. 2d a 528 (Ot
Cl. 1961); :
‘It is evident that per 1956 ae never .-
\. owned the actual property upon which dépreciation. ~
and property taxes deductions were claimed by the ~
partnership ih its 1956 returns. These deductions, i
~A amounting to $7 596. 88 and $2,026.80, respectively, .
a _ must be and are ‘eliminated as dedictions of-the part-.
nership and ie ere personal expenses of the plain-
tiffs..
Belaty * allowances — been tiie to inves
: Donaldson for her actual services in 1956 and 1957
and to J oe 8. ‘Ramos for his actual services in the last. -
__ three months of 1957, and the nature and quality of |
the services rendered by Joe R, Ramos in 1956 and
for nine months’ of 1957 being at least comparable to ,
those rendered by his son, the Court finds and directs.
that such reasonable salary allowances must be and — .
are credited to Joe R. Ramos in the sum of $4,200.00
.- for’ 1956, and i in the sum. of — for nine > months a
——— ~of 1957.
Finally, adjustments must be made in the rental of
the land, trees and equipment’ used in the production |
and harvesting of the almond crops. As observed in
Note 1 of this opinion, since al] that the partnership.
received in 1956 from the plaintiffs was the use of the |
land, trees and equipment needed for the almond
ae
*.
i tee ee eee
Loess ie : oe 25
orchard ‘oii such use should be’ and. is spendin =
as a rental rather than a capital contribution, and the —
reasonable value thereof, as expressed in the 1957
agreement, is twenty-five percent of the ‘crop income. |
. This Court now, therefore, finds and fixes such rental
for the year. 1956. in the sum of $55,160. 17 (twenty-
five percent of’ the crop income for 1956 in the sum
4 of $220,640.48). ‘For the ° year 1957, as. previously
stated in this opinion, the corrected partnership
income should show a deduction | in rental for that
year in the sum of $11, 240.67. . :
Consonanf’ with its rulings and findings, the the Court |
now sets forth what it deems to be appropriate sched- _- |
‘ules reflecting the corrected . ancome of me Laue 7
chips for 1956 and 1957, . oe 7 eee
1956 FB
> The corrected partnership income for \1956 is .
$161,787.12. This amount has been determined _ as
— follows:
"Receipts : ns | ane
_ From 1955 crops : $70,640.48
From 1956 érops - * 150,000.00
ae | Receipts per 1956 tax return - ee $220,640.48
Expenses: * | rs
Expenses per | i
1956 tax return - =———Ss«$ 68,477.04
Deduet depreciation | (7, 596. 88) |
Deduet property taxes (2,026,80). 58 ssh 36
“Corrected income for 1986 .. » ‘$161,787.12
‘ 8 * : :
° . ; ‘ ie ge
Fit: %6 <
sed . : 2 : : rrr.
-@ ° . ae
- — es ‘
/
.: Se accord with the. views seins siadainia i.
-, ~~ the Court, this correcteil income should be allocated
to Joe R. and:Mary’ “Ramos and their children as
follows in computing the jndgnient, herein : |
~ Joe R. and Mary Ramos:
Receipts from 1955 crops 70,640.48 i)
~ Rent ; ae 38 “ie : iy ;
(25% of 1956 receipts) 55,160.12 |
12 months’ salary | .
($350.00 per month) ; 4, 200.00
50% of unallocated balance | 14,993.26 $144, 993.86
Forward oe - $144,993.86
, Joe 8. Ramos: ad Sie | San
25% of unallocated balance | 7,496:63
- Dolores Donaldson : : as }
25% of unallocated balance - $ 7,496.63.
12months’salary “ef
- ($150.00 per month) = ~ 1,800.00 = 9,296.63
* ‘Total . < * $161,787. 3:
A In computing the judgment, J oe R. and Mary
- Ramos would also: be entitled, to a deduction from
' their distributive share of 1956 income for deprecia-
tion .and property taxes of $9,623.68, which were
- eliminated in correcting the partnership income for
< that year. These were personal expenses of the plain-
tiffs, since the assets remained their property.
ae 1957
Sie The corrected partnership income for 1957 is
. $114,972.46. This amount has been determined as
follows:
schiisias "hahaa casas hice Aisa kata lant tii tai hice agate
5) ; ‘ VAG : ; ; A e ° : ¢ ee
Receipt: rae ce : eS ae :
From 1956 crops pair
‘(almonds andpeaches)- = = sss $157,088.71,
From ‘1957 érops and | SRC ik tke
- other sources — ar +. 2. TESTIS
". Receipts per 1957 tax return —. $194,206.45
Expenses: ; ye Bee.
? Expenses per Race mee,
.1957 tax return * $ 91,524.66
* Deduet rent paid in 1958. ; (11,240.67) .
a Deduct Joe S. Ramos pa eck 36“ Seen eae
drawing for 3 months ¢ 1,050.00) | 79,233.99
Corrected i income for 1957 $114, 972. 46
* with 1956, this corrected income ‘should be.
allocated to Joe R. and-Mary Ramos and their chil- ©
dren as follows in computing the eet:
_ Joe R. and Mary Ramos:
50% of 1956 erop receipts
(almonds only, with ad- 7
justment of $152.00 for . -
peach crop) eR . $ 78,468.35 -.
9 months’ salary 3
. - ($350.00 per month) - * 3,150.00 . :
3314% of default balance z (15, 988.09) $ 65,630. 26
JoeS.Ramos:. @ ae
25% of _I56crop ~" | *'
receipts (almonds) ° $ 39,234.18
3 months’ salary © ee bee
e ($350.00 per month) — -1,050:00.
83149" of deficit balance’ —S»=—(15,988.08) 24,296.10
Dolores Donaldson : | :
| . 25% of 1956 crop | mer
| _ Teceipts (almonds) - $ 39,234.18 ~
| °12 months’ salary Preece eee
| ($150.00 per month) 1,800.00
Ly + 3814% of deficit balance (15,988.08) 25,046.10
fas a $114,972.46
- 28 &
. > me. computing the ‘judgment Si: plaintiffs :
. should also adjust their rental income. from Joe-R.
Ramos & Co. to eliminate the rent: paid in 1958.
“'This ‘opinion shall constitute the ‘findings: of fact ia)
and conclusions of law of the Court. Based thereon *
‘and: the schedules above’ set forth, the parties are
directed to compute the refunds due plaintiffs for the
_ Year 1956. and, 1957 and submit ‘an apEtepriate judg-~
~ ment to the Court. Peri |
Dated: June . ies , 1966. ae rn Wes 5
\- Alfonso“T. Zirpoli :
United States District Judge :
,!
hy”
e.
ine ee ee Vac
; In the United States District Court: for the — / : Bes
. Northern District of California -,
’
Fook R. Ramos and 7 Ramos, snap wie ie
oa a os Piniaits, > No 0008 my
United States of America, ° FRG 0
pais * Defendant. | No. re pe!
2
+ is ‘ . . ea
AMENDMENT TO ) MEMORANDUM OPINION. ae
-° AND ORDER . f eae
oe The Court, at the request of counsel, has reviewed -
_. the allocation of ineome for: the ‘1956 partnership |
‘ involved. in. the above actions. It appears that: the
‘Court used’ as the measure of rent for 1956 gross
: receipts of $220,640, 48, whereas the correct partner-
ship gross receipts for that year were only $150,000.
-, ° The Court therefore modifies and amends its June 22, —
1966 Memoranduin Opinion and Order to find and fix * .
- as rental allocable. to plaintiffs for 1956 the sum of |
$37,500 i in lieu of the amount previously“set forth. ©
| In accordance with this amendment, the income ea
the 1956 partnership should be alloeated as follows in -
computing the amount of the ee to be entered-
| herein :
K .
:
. t - .
.
° ey
od . .
.
‘ ’
~
a < .
’
* eee e *
.
30
Joe R. and Mary Ramos:
Receipts from 1955 crops
Rent (25% of receipts from
1956 crops)
12 months’ salary
($350.00 per month).
| 50% of unallocated balance
Joe 8. Ramos: |
25% of unallocated balance
Dolores Donaldson : js
' 12 months’ salary
* ($150.00 per month)
25% of unallocated balance
Total Le
$ 70,640.48
37,500.00
4,200.00 |
23,823.32 $136,163.80
11,911.66 —
$1,800.00
11,911.66 13,711.66
$161,787.12
In computing the judgment, Joe R. and Mary
Ramos would also be entitled to a deduction of
$9,623.68 from. their distributive share of 1956 part--
nership incorke for depreciation and property taxes
which were eliminated in correcting that partnership
income.
In all other respects, ‘the Memorandum ‘Opinion
and Order entered herein on June 22, 1966 shall
remain unchanged.
Dated : September ia 1966.
Alfonso J. Zirpoli ”
United States District Judge
\ C
- United States of en ;
{2
Appendix “‘B” | ,
_ United States Court of ees e
for the Ninth Circuit fisirg
5
. Appellant and Cross-Appellee |
v8, = | : No. 21,824
Joe R. Ramos and Mary Ramos, we Sane A
Appellees and Cross-Appellants.
[April 10, 1968] .
On Appeal from the United States District Court
-. for the Northern District of California
. Before: CHAMBERS, J ERTBERG and ELY,
Circuit Judges. : Cj
JERTBERG, Cireuit Judge: |:
Before us are two family partnership cases: Both
involve federal income tax claims,—one for the year
1956, and the other for the year 1957. The two cases
were consolidated for trial in the district court, and
are before this court on a consolidated record. |
In the first case, the Commissioner of Internal
Revenue determined that the entire income from a
. partnership allegedly entered into and existing dur-
ing the year 1956, by and between Joe R. Ramos and
Mary Ramos, his wife, appellees, (Joe FZ Ramos
being hereinafter sometimes called “‘taxpayer”), and
1957 from crops sold in 1956.
32
their son and daughter, Joe S. Ramos and Dolores
Donaldson, respectively, must be taxed to the appel-
lees, In the second case the Commissioner of Internal
Revenue determined that the entire income from a
partnership allegedly entered into and existing during
the year 1957, & and between Joe R. Ramos and his
son and daughter, must be taxed to the appellees.
The deficiencies. assessed in each case were paid,
~ and claim for refunds were filed and rejected. Within
the time provided in § 6532 of the Internal Revenue
Code of 1954, appellees instituted actions in the dis-
trict court for the recovery of taxes paid for the years
1956 and 1957. |
The cases were tried to the court sitting without a
jury. Following trial the district court held that a
valid. family partnership existed during 1956, com-
posed of appellees and their two children, and that a .
valid family partnership existed during’ 1957 com-
posed of taxpayer, Joe R. Ramos, and the two chil-
dren. The district court also determined the “cor-
rected” partnership income and the distributive -
shares of the partners on the basis of various adjust-
ments, including the allowance of twenty-five percent
of the crop receipts as rent owing to appellees by
the partnership for the two taxable years, and the
allocations in equal amounts among members of the
1956 partnership of the sum of $157,088 received in
Ttie Government appeals from the judgment ente
by the district court, and the appellees cross-appeal
from certain portions of said judgment. |
33
The district iit a the parties to this appeal are
-in agreement that the basic facts disclosed by the rec-
ord are. virtually undisputed. Our review of the
record. and examination of the briefs cause us to
adopt, as the basic and relevant facts, the statement
of facts which appear in thébrief filed by the Gov-
ernment, as appellant. We-find nothing in the briefs
filed by the appellees which takes serious issue with
such statement. Ate we i
k J
The statement, with slight editing 0 on our part, is
as follows:
Taxpayers, Joe R. and Mary Ramos, are husband
and wife and reside on a 219-acre ranch near Winters,
California. They purchased this ranch in the latter
‘part of 1943 and have lived on and farmed it con-
tinuously from that time. Approximately 175 acres of
the ranch are planted in mature almond trees with
the balance being planted in peaches and olives. The _
land, trees and other improvements which comprised
' the taxpayers’ ranch and the equipment necessary for’
its operation had a value of $200, 000 to $230, 000 dur-.
_ ing 1956 and 1957, the years in suit.
Taxpayers’ daughter, Dolores er was 24
. years old in 1956 and by that year had graduated
from Sacramento Junior College and was married. °
From the time she was in high school, Dolores had
dere the bookkeeping for the ranch as well as for
her parents’ other business ventures. She ‘was paid
for these services and in 1955 received $75 for this
work. ;
\ | . 34 ° .
\ oe | | |
Taxpayers’ son, Joe S. Ramos, had worked on tax-
payers’ ranch on weekends and during vacations from
school.” From the time he graduated from high school,
he was paid for his work. After he graduated from
Sacramento Junior College in June 1955, he worked
on the ranch and was paid aecordingly. On November
22, 1955, Joe S’ Ramos went’on active duty with the
United States Navy and was shortly thereafter trans-
ferred to Hawaii. At the beginning of the period in
suit, Joe S. Ramos was 21. years old. 2
- Paxpayer’s brother, Frank D. Ramos, was foreman
of the ranch prior to the years in suit and throughout
the period Joe 8. Ramos-was in the Navy. |
-commence..'This, partnership was “to operate tax-
payers’ ranch for the year 1956, with each of the four
partners having a 25 percent interest in the business.
The partnership acquired no interest in the land, -
trees and other improvements which made up the tax-
payers’ ranch or in the equipment necessary for its
operation, as these assets were retained by taxpayers.
The partnership did not pay any rent in 1956 for
these assets. Neither Dolores Donaldson nor Joe S.
Ramos-contributed any capital to the partnership for
196. | :
--During 1956, the ranch continued to operate under
the name of “Joe R. Ramos.” The expenses for op-
erating the ranch for that year were paid from tax-,
‘
e
ae
payers’ joint checking account with the Bank of °
America at Winters, with the receipts ‘from the opera-
tion of the. ranch being deposited to that account.
This account included funds other than partnership —
- funds. The accounting records for the 1956, ranch
operations Were kept on the cash basis and were —
merely a continuation of the individual records main-
tained for taxpayers in previous years. © Pap Gy
. The 1956 federal employer’s withholding tax return
for the ranch employees was filed in the name of “Joe
R. Ramos, owner” and under. the account number
assigned to him. On January 28, 1958, Dolores
~ Donaldson advised the District Director that the
“» employer’s return for 1956 should have been filed’
‘under the name and _account~ number for “Joe R.
Ramos & Co.” However, that account number was
not applied for until November of 1957 and was ob-
tained for a partnership that did not include Mary
Ramos as a partner. The workmen’s compensation
report for that year was also. filed under al ath S
name. ° °
Because of his: experience, taxpayer was senior
partner and ‘‘boss” of the partnérship. He made the
decisions concerning the sale of crops grown on the
ranch and generally supervised the ranch operations,
_ However, he received no- eplazy or. ailowanee for- his
work.
Taxpayers’ daughter, Dolores, Hived j in Winters with
her husband and ‘worked. full time throughout 1956
as a clerk for Pacific Gas m Electric Company. As
gs. "¢
‘compensation. for doing the bookkeeping for the part-
_ nership on a part-time basis, she received $150. She. :
was | also paid $35 for two days’ field work.
Taxpayers’ son, J 08, was on military duty in’
Hawaii during 1956 with the exception of the last
~ week in December. During that brief stay at honie,
he did ‘not do any wo work on the ranch.
The 1956 er crop was sold on June , 26, 1951,
by Joe R. Ramos as the seller.
For 1956, the partnership filed a federal partner-
ship information return in the name of ‘“‘Joe R.
Ramos Co.” This return was filed on the cash basis -
and reflected total receipts of $220,640.68, of which
$70,640.48 represented proceeds from the almond crop
grown on taxpayers’ ranch and sold in 1955. ‘The re- .
turn further reflected expenses of $68,477.04, includ-
ing depreciation and real. property taxes on assets be-
7 longing to taxpayer. The net income of $152,163.44, _
as shown on the return, was divided into four equal
shares of $38,040.86, which shares were reported by
- the purported partners on their individual returns. for
1956. _
| Dolores Donaldson’s distributive iis of the part-
nership’s profit for 1956 was paid to her on February
14, 1957. She then paid $16,028.68 to the Internal
"-- Revenue Service in payment of -her federal income
taxes for 1956: In addition, she paid $1,160.34 to the
Franchise Tax Board of the State of California in —
payment of her 1956’ state income tax.
Payment of the distributive shares of J oe S. Ramos,
who was then in Hawaii, was handled as follows:
$17,472.56 was. paid to the Internal Revenue Service -
. from taxpayers’ joint. checking account for their son’s « -
1956 federal income taxes and $19,173. 85 was de-
‘posited to a savings account maintained in the names
of ‘‘Ramos, Joe 8S. or Joe R.” in the form of a chéek
drawn on taxpayers’ joint account. Taxpayer then
withdrew $2,217.75 from the account he had with his
son to pay state and accetzonal federal income taxte
- for Joe S. Ramos for 1956.
For 1957, a different partnership was purportedly
@organized 3 operate taxpayers’ rarich. A written
agreement was entered into by taxpayer and his son |
and daughter which provided that they would engage |
in the farming business underithe name of “Joe R.
Ramos & Co. ¥ until January 1, 1962, and that each -
would receive 331%, -percent of thee profits. Mary
Ramos was not a party to this agreement and was not -
to be a partner in 1957. -The partnership agreement)
in pertinent part, further provided: —
3. . Capital. The capital of the partnership shall
. be contributed by the partners, in cash as follows: -
Joe R. Ramos . $15,000.00
Dolores Donaldson - —_$15,000.00__-
Joe S. Ramos ‘$15,000.00 .
The foregoing capital consists entirely of cash
and represents the entire assets:of the partner-
- Ship at the commencement of the calendar year
1957. eee. ace 8
* * © © '
5. om aes of Working Partners. Joe R. Ramos
shall.devote full time and attention to the part-
nership business, and upon his release from mili-
. /
/
/
38
tary service, Joe S. Ramos will devote such time
and attention to the partnership business as he is
able. Dolores Donaldson shall render bookkeep-
ing services for the benefit of the partnership.
- And each of the. partners. shall receiye such
monthly salaries as may from time to time be
fixed by mutual agreemen ‘between them, such
salaries to be an allowance of reasonable corffpen-:
sation for services actually rendered to thé part-
nership. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the —
>
amount. of such salaries shall be subject. to~ the
provisions of paragraph... hereof. eA
* * * *# *
7. Drawing Accounts. * * * Except as otherwise
specifically provided herein, no part of the
~ eapital contribution of the partners shall be with-
drawn without the unanimous consent of the»
‘g. Management. The ° ership business shall
be managed by the working partners, but in the
event of any disagreement between them, the de--
cision of Joe R. Ram shall be controlling.
- 9, Restrictions on Partners.. * * * No partner
ee tieceaceta
As in 1956, the land, trees and improvements which —
made up taxpayers’ ranch and the equipment neces-
sary for its operations were not transferred to the -
- partnership. However, about. the. same time the 1957
partnership agreement was signed, a Memorandum of
~ Rental. Agreement was entered into. by all partners
- with the Bank of America at Winters. ‘At that time, .
on behalf of “‘Joe R. Ramos & Co.” and by the tax- .
payers individually. This agreement provided: __.
Toe R. Ramos & Company, a partnership will .
rent from Joe R. Ramos and Mary S. Ramos, |
for a two-year period commencing November 1,
1956 and terminating November 1, 1958, approxi- —
mately 175 acres located near Winters and’ be- .
longing to the owners. The‘ rent to be paid to
owners shall be 25% of the gross sale price of the
crops: raised . thereon during the term and the
_- partnership shall pay all expenses except real
. property taxes .and machinery costs, | said
machinery to be supplied by owner, except that -_
minor repairs to machinery for maintenance and
less than $100.00 shall be paid by the partnership.
"Until the end of March, 1957, banking for the part- .
nership was handled through taxpayers’ joint account
taxpayer and his son and daughter each contributed
' $15,000 to the partnership.. The © contributions of
Dolores and Joe S. in 1957 were derived from the
' profits of the.1956 partnership. The actual mechanics —
- the Bank of America at Winters, the depositing of ;
of making these contributions involved the issuance of
checks to the children from taxpayers’ account with
these’ checks to accounts maintained by the children,
3 ae al ni -
and the purchasing’ of cashier’s checks for the funds
w
- .actually deposited to the account opened in the name
.. of “Joe R. Ramos & Co.” with the First National _
Bank of Dixon. These contributions were deposited
to the account of ‘‘Joe R. Ramos & Co.” which was .°
- opened at the First National Bank of Dixon. This
account and a savings account subsequently opened
in the same name ‘could be drawn upon only by
- oe R. Ramos or Mary Ramos. )
The partnership books ‘for. 1957 were Lent 0 on the :
cash basis and in substantially the same form as the _
books kept for taxpayers in previous years. A similar
. set of books.was also kept. for taxpayers in 1957.
For 1957, business was done mainly in the name 5 of
“Joe R. Ramos &.Co.” A fictitious name certificate
listing the purported partners was executed in J uly
‘of that year’ and filed with the County Clerk of
Solano County in Fairfield, California, but was not
published until September in a local newspaper. The
1957 almond crop was sold under a contract made by -
. “Joe R. Ramos & Co.” as seller and payments were |
‘made in that name by the purchaser. The - federal
employer’s withholding tax return was filed under the
account number obtained for the 1957 partners and .
the workmen’s compensation report for 1957 was 3 also
filed in the partnership. name. |
-Dolores Donaldson, in acting as NERS for the
1957 partnership, ¢ did esseritially the same work which .
' she -had done in prior years for taxpayers. Taxpayers’
son was not separated from the Navy until October
of 1957 and. worked on’ the ranch for only the last.
three months of the year. He received a salary. of
net — ial month sia die this secu
41
For 1957, a federal partnership information ‘return
was filed on thé cash basis in the name of “Joe R.
- Ramos & Co.” This return reflected total receipts in
the amount. of $194,206.45, including $157,088. 71 from
almonds and other crops which were raised, sold and
delivered in 1956. Rent to Joe’ R. Ramos in the
amount of $48,480. 08, and other expenses of: $43,044.58
were deducted from the total receipts to arrive at a
net income of $102,681.79 for the year. The sum of
| $48,480.08 was paid by partnership receipts of
- $30,000 and $7 ,239.41 which taxpayer. withheld as
advance rent, and a check for $11,240.67: which was
drawn by the partnership in 1958. The sum of
$48,480.08 was approximately 25 percent: of the gross
crop receipts received in 1957 and was determined a
- without regard to the period in which the crops were
grown, whereas the rental agreement purportedly in.
effect for 1957 provided for only 25 percent ofthe |
- gross receipts for crops. grown on the premises after —
_ November 1, 1956.
Dolores Donaldson.and Joe.S: ‘amos each enn
$34,227.20, or one-third of. the partnership net in-
come, on their individual federal income tax returns
for 1957. ‘Taxpayers reported the remaining one-
third of the net income,and rent in the amount of
$48,480.08 on their 1957 federal income tax return.
On February 6, 1958, Dolores Donaldson and Jge
- §. Ramos each received $15,000 as a partial distri
tion of the profit reported by th i
for. the remainder of their 7 distributive shares, |
| ete
- On February 10, 1958, Dolores Donaldson and her
husband paid a total of $14,622.98 for 1957 federal
and state income taxes due in addition to the taxes
withheld from -their salaries. On the same day, Joe —
S. Ramos and his wife paid 1957 federal and state
income taxes. ‘totaling $12, 343. 30.
We first consider the validity of e oral ‘hie
partnership” claimed to be in e ce for the year
1956. Preliminarily, we récognize/ that for several
- years prior to’ 1956, the members of the, Ramos fam-
ily had discussed, and intended to enter into, a family
ranching partnership when the son became twenty-one
years of age. -We do not doubt that they i intended to
enter into a family ranching partnership for the year
* °1956. More than intention, sachiiliee is required to
_ effectuate such purpose. ;
It is evident that neither the son nor daughter con-
tributed any capital to the claimed partnership. The
" gon contributed no significant services during the year
1956. He went on active duty- with the Navy in the
fall of 1955, and shortly thereafter was transferred
to Hawaii where he remained throughout 1956, with
the exception of the last week in December when he
was home on a short leave, at which time he did not
work on the ranch. The daughter, who throughout the
year was a full-time employee of Pacific .Gas_and
Electric Company, did the ykkeeping for the
claimed | partnership, and was $150.00 for such
services. She rendered the same service to her parents -
for the year 1955 and received payment for such serv-
ices in the sum of $75.00. No rent was paid by the
43
partnership to the parents for the land and equip-
ment. The father supervised the farming~ operations
for which no compensation ‘was paid to him. by the
partnership for such services.
Hence, we have before us a claimed family part-
nership in which the parents retained ownership and
control of the income producing properties, and to
which the children contributed neither property or
services except the bookkeeping services of the :
daughter, for which services she was compensated.
- In order to sustain their position, the taxpayers
seek the benefits provided by §§ 191 and 3797(a)\(2)
of the Internal Revenue Code of 1939, as added and
amended, respectively, in 1951 (Rev. Act.1951 § 340,
65 Stat. 452, 511), now embodied in Section 704(e) - .
of the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. § 704(e)).
Section 704(e) provides:
—“(e) Family partnerships.—
(1) Recognition of interest created by. put-
chase or gift—A person shall be recognized’ as a
partner for purposes of this subtitle if he owns a
capital interest in a partnership in which capital
is a material income-producing factor, whether or
not such interest was derived by siaipcsid or gift.
from any other person.
(2) Distributive share of ‘donee includible in
gross income.—In the case of any partnership
interest created by gift, the distributive share of
the donee under the partnership agreement shall.
be includible in his gross income, except to the
extent that such share is determined without
allowance of reasonable -compensation for serv-
| . Ad ae |
ices rendered to the partnership by the donor,
and except to the extent that the portion of such
share attributable to donated capital is propor-
tionately greater than the share of the donor at-
tributable to the donor’s capital. The distributive
shart of a partner in the earnings of the part-
nership shall not be diminished becausé of ab-
sence due to military service.
(3) * * #»
These sections were dealt with by this court in
Kuney v. Frank, 308 F.2d 719 ~ Cir. 1962), at p.
721, where it is stated:
ine “These provisions recognize the principle that
‘earnings are taxed to him who earns them, and
* the principle that income from capital, however
- aequired, is attributable to’ its owner. They
eliminate, as a factor to be considered in deter-
mining the bona fides of a family. partnership,
the fact that the new partner acquired his interest
by gift, and that ” may be an inactive partner.”
In support of their carpus taxpayers state 1 in their
brief: is =
“The Government’s statement that neither the |
daughter nor the son contributed any capital to
the partnership in 1956 is again unwarranted.
The daughter and son having each acquired a
25% interest in and to the ‘crops business’ con- _
tributed that 25% interest to the partnership;
the ‘crops business’ consisting of the right of use
and control of the trees, lands and equipment, ,.
together with all accounts receivable of the said j
business and each of the children then con-
tributed their said 25% interest in and to the
right of use, control, possession and enjoyment
P late eal Bg a ee
45
of the said i lands, trees and equipment and the
257% interest each in and to the accounts receiv-
able of the business during the-1956 partnership.
We respectfully submit that the documents rep-
resenting ownership of the lands, trees, equip-
ment and accounts receivable could of themselves
produce nothing. It is the use and control of the
lands,. trees and equipment and the accounts re-
ceivable of the business which produce either
‘profit or loss. These are rights of substantial —
economic value. The accounts receivable of the
business at the time of the creation of the part-_.
nership on September 17, 1955 were in the sum
of $70,640.48. It is thus apparent that each child
in contributing his interest in the account re-
Celv, ee in effect made a capital contribution to
th rship of $17,460.12 each, and. that this
$17, aa 12 contributed by the son and the
daughter was commingled with and was -actually
used in the operation of the ranch. Their contri-
butions, therefore, were of a definite economic |
value to the partnership.” ) j
The record furnishes no support for such conten-’ :
tions. In this wes deat we again — from the tax-
payers’ brief :
‘*Perhaps the rnost expressive statement’of the —
existence and operation of the 1956 partnership is
to be found in ‘the testimony of Mrs. Dolores |
Donaldson as elicited on cross-examination :
‘Q. That is essentially all he gave you on
the ranch in ’56, wasn’t it, just an \ “interest in
the profits?
A. No. |
_ Q. What was your ‘interest? _ didn’t
-own land, did you Mrs. Donaldson, or r any in-
terest in the and?
46
| 0, we don’t own the land. :
. Q. You don’t own any interest in the
| machinery ? , '
A. No.
Q. There was no cash capital put into’ die:
partnership in 56%
A. No. |
Q. Well, what was your ania per ‘eent
interest in 1956? |
A. In the partnership agreement. When we .
formed it we were going to be partners, were
going to be a. family partnership, all together,
and whatever income we made we would share.
If we had losses, we would share them and
we would pay our expenses, and whatever was
left we could share twenty-five per cent, my
father, my mother, my brother and I. I don’t
think You have to own land to have a share 1 in
anything.
Q. In other words, you feel you can par-
ticipate in the profits from the land without a
owning any portion of the land ?
A. ° Yes.
- @& And this is the type Of partnership in-
terest that you had, just\in the — gen-
erated by. the assets?
_ A. ‘Profits or losses that would be produced
by the ‘almond trees on the land.’” (Emphasis
omitted.)
Thus, the daughter’ s statement reveals ‘that the -
children received no interest whatever in the assets
of the farming operation. Therefore, they were thus
unable to contribute to the partnership that which.
they, themselves, did not have. The parents retained
complete interest, in the operating assets of the ranch.
)
47
Now we consider the validity of the written “family ie
partnership” agreement claimed to be in existence for
the year 1957. The 1957 agreement was in writing,
instead of oral as in 1956. The pertinent: provisions
of this agreement are set forth earlier in this opinion. :
Under this agreement each partiier was required to .
contribute $15,000.00, and the aggregate amourit of
Such contributions was to represent the entire. assets:
of the partnership at its commencement. Taxpayer,
Joe R.-Ramos, was required to devote full time and.
attention to the business. His son, Joe S. Ramos, was
still in the military service and upon his release
therefrom was to devote such time and attention to
the partnership business as he is able.’ Taxpayer’s
daughter, Dolores Donaldson, was to render book-
. keeping services to the partnership. ‘In tlie event of
any dispute or-disagreement between the partners, the .
- .decision of taxpayer was to be controlling, and all”
disbursements from_the. partnership bank account.
were to be withdrawn only updn checks sign y the
taxpayer. |
A “two-year - rental agreement was: wien ‘inl,
. under which the partnership would lease from the
_ taxpayers the ranching property and farming equip-
ment belonging to the taxpayers,—the rental for the
two-year term to be in the amount of twenty-five per
- eent (25%) of. the gross sales price of the crops
raised. .The partnership would pay all expenses ex-
— cept real property: taxes and machinery costs, except
for minor maintenance repairs to machinery.
48
The cash contribution of the children, to the capital
of* the, partnership, was made at the end of March
; 1957, and such contributions were derived by them
from the profits of the 1956 partnership income.
-Funds of the partnership. were in the name of the
partnership in a eommercial and a savings account.
Checks on such accounts could be drawn only by
either the father or mother.
‘Taxpayers’ son was not separated from hi Navy
until October of 1957, and rendered no significant
service to the partnership except for the last three
months of the year, for which he was compensated at
the rate of $350.00 per month. _
As in 1956, the taxpayers retained ownership and
control of the income producing properties during
1957. The father again supervised the farming opera-
- tions for which no compensation was _ to him by
the partnership for such services.
_. The economic relationships of the parties, remained
the same as in the claimed: family partnership for
- 1956, unless it can be said that the contribution of
each child of $15,000 to the capital of the partnership,
in March 1957, was significant. The capital contribu-
‘tions of the children were derived from .the profits
of the 1956 partnership and were originally paid out
‘of taxpayers’ joint account and finally deposited in
‘another bank account which taxpayers alone could
draw upon. The procedure followed with respect to
such withdrawal. and deposit appears earlier in this —
opinion. The checking account which was opened with
the capital contributions by the children and a #5, 000.
contribution by the taxpayer never fell below $40,000.
‘and approximately $70,000 in partnership receipts _
were placed in a savings account and left untouched
for the remainder of the year. Less than a month’
before, the taxpayer withdrew $30,000.00 as “advance
rent.” It is clear that the capital contributions, of the
children were not needed or utilizedthat year. In
these circumstances we see. no other purpose for the
capital contributions of the children except to create -
the appearance of a change i in the economic relation-
ships of the parties. Rae
The district court found that a valid partnership
existed between the father, the mother and the two
children for the year 1956, and that a valid partner-
ship existed between the father and the two —
for the year 1997. 7
The government on that each of wail findings :
is ‘‘clearly erroneous.” 7
"- finding is ‘clearly erroneous’ when although
there is evidence to support it, the reviewing
eourt on the entire evidence is left with the defi-
nite and firm conviction that'a mistake has been
made.” Untted States v. ise Co., 333 U.S.
364, at 395 (1947).
We are mindful that o ily the cheldlles as to
whether a family partnership) is valid is one of-fact, .-
not of law. Commissioner v. Culbertson, 337 U.S. 733 |
(1949). _However, as is true of any other question
of fact, where all the relevant and material evidence
dir us to but one conclusion, such conclusion must
folfow as a matter of law. See Kuney v. Frank, supra.
— 50
Here the evidence compels the conclusion thatthe
family arrangements, in each year, created only an
_ anticipatory assignment to the children of future
income from property owned and controlled by the |
. | : parents, and the services of taxpayer.
As stated in Commissioner v. Culbertson, s supra, at
” pp.'739-40:
“To hold that Individuals « carrying on business
- im partnership’ includes persons who contribute |
‘ nothing. during the tax period would violate the.
first. principle of income taxation:. that income
must be taxed to him who earns it. Lucas v. Earl,
281 U.S. 111 (1930); Helvering v. Clifford, 309 -
U.S. 331 (1940) ; National Carbide Corp. v. Com-
missioner, 336 U. S. 422 (1949).”
In our view the findings. of the district court aie
stated are ‘‘clearly erroneous.” Our review of the
: entire record in this case leaves us with the definite
and firm conviction that the. district: court was mis-
taken in each of said .findings.
Our holding that each of the partnérships is invalid
makes it unnecessary for us to review those portions
of the judgment entered by the district court relating
to the determination of the ‘‘corrected” partnership
income and the distributive shares of the partners on
. the basis of various adjustments appearing in the
judgment, and renders moot the cross-appeal of
' appellees as to certain portions of such judgment, and
- requires a dismissal of the cross-appeal for, mootness.
The judgment ‘of the district court is reversed and
the cross-appeal is igeatenes 4 as moot. |
M7
PAE OA 20 WE PRET HOLT BET! sesias
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.