Appendix — Stief v. J. A. Sexauer Manufacturing Co.
Supreme Court brief1967
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
SUPREME Cournt.u,g | FILED —
a |. AUG 4 1967
eae aS a eae “JOHN F. DAVIS, CLERK
Supreme Court of the United States
a. @
«
“ October Term, 1967.
“=
™.
No. 455.
CLAYTON H. STIEF,
Petitioner,
;
re eee
J. A. SEXAUER\ MANUFACTURING CO,, INC.
. £ # 1 and
DIAMOND ALKALI COMPANY, . |
; ree Respondents.
r
APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR A WRIT OF _
CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
“COURT OF°APPEALS FOR THE
», . SECOND CIRCUIT.
‘B. Natwantet Ricuter,
Cuaries A. Lorp,
Seymour I. Tot,
m.% _ » * Ricwrer, Lorp &Cavanaveg, .
‘ ’ ; 121 S. Broad Street,
‘Philadelphia, Pa. 19107.
Attorneys for Petitioner.
Ps
International, 711 So, 50th St., Phila., Pa. 19143—Tel. SA 7-8711 Area Code 215/
aA
gf
A
Before:
APPENDIX.
ia nies: STATES COURT. OF APPEALS
For THE Szbomp CizcuirT
Nos. ES es Term, 1966 :
- (Argued September-28, 1966 Decided April 7, 1967)
‘Docket Nos. 30312-13 _
—
a
No. 30312 : ee
pin 30 | '
i
“* Crayton H. Srier,
Rlaintif-Appelant,
v.
J. A. Sexaver Manvracrugine Oo, Inc., *
Defendant-Appellee.
<-
No. 30313 Pct a ae
‘Ciayton H. Stier,
i-—~ Plaintiff-Appellant,
v. j
e
a
_ Dano ALKALI Gouna,
5 — Pit Ares ie
Lumparp, Chief Drills, Moore and Femara,
Circuit Judges.
(1a)
» ER
2a ; Appendia
Appeal from a judgment of the District Court for the
Southern District of New York, Thomas F. Croake, Judge,
in consolidated actions for personal injuries which directed
a verdict in favor of defendant Diamond ‘Alkali Company,
Inc., at the close of plaintiff’s case and, \after a disagree-
ment by the jury, dismissed the complaint against defend-
. ant J. A. Sexauer meena ee ned Inc. Affirmed.
ait
oe . \
Seymour I. Touz, New York; N. Y. (Ch&rles A. Lord,
‘ Philadelphia, Penn., Norman J. Landau,‘ New .
York, N. Y.). (Richter, Lord & Cavanaugh, Phila-
— delphia, Penn., of counsel), for plaintiff-appeéllant.
- Bengamun H. Str, New York, N. Y. (Gair & Gair, New
_ York, N: Y.), for J; A. Seaauer er Monafactging Co.,
Ine.
J. Rocer Cussiuai, New York, N. Y. (Davis Polk Ward-
well Sunderland & .Kiendl, New York, N. Y.), for
Diamond Alkali Company.
_ Moors, Circuit Judge: ~ 7,
Plaintiff (appellaht), Clayton H. Stief (Stief er plain-
tiff), a citizen of Pennsylvania, brought two actions%jn the
District Court for the\Southern District of New York to
recover damages for personal injuries, one against defend-
fe {appellee), J. A. Sexauer Manufacturing Co., Inc. (Sex-
auer), a New York corporation, and the other against ap-
pellee Diamond Alkali Company amee): | a Delaware
corporation, lad |
In substance, i in the complaint against Sexauer, Stief
alleged that, in the course of using a product, packaged and
sold by Sexauer, known as ‘‘ Mule Kick,’’ and advertised as
opening clogged drains, he was burned and permanently
blinded by a spray containing Mule Kick which issued from
a hole in a pipe which he was attempting to clear. Breach
of warranty and negligence were charged. A second cause
Appendia 3a
_ of action was based upon breach of express warranties of .
merchantability, safety, freedom from explosion, free-
dom from dangerous adulterants and of fitness for the
particular purpose mentioned on the product ag well as
breach of implied watranties of safety. ©
In the complaint against Diamond, the manufacturer of
. the produet, Stief also alleged negligence and breach of .
warranty. .
The cases were consolidated and tried to a jury. Dur-
ing the trial, the breach of warranty issue was abandoned
anid the trial proceeded on the theory of negligence. At the
close of plaintiff’s case, defendants moved for direction of .
a verdict. The court granted the motion, dismissing the .
complaint as- to Diamond, but reserved decision as to
Sexauer. The motion for a direction was renewed at the
end of the entire case, decision was again reserved and the
case was submitted to the j jury on the morning of November
5, 1965. That eve ing the jury reported hopeless disagree-
-ment and was rged.
Some five weeks later, the court, with the benefit of the
full transcript of the record, additional memoranda, further
oral argument and consideration of cited cases, granted the
motion and dismissed the complaint against Sexauer. In
a memorandum opinion, the court said: ‘‘Suffice it to state
that, viewing the facts in a light most favorable to the
plaintiff, this court.is unable to formulate any reasonable
view of them or of the law applicable to this case under
which the defendant Sexauer might be held liable to this .
plaintiff, an experienced plumber who had used the product
of the defendant on prior occasions, for this most unusual
‘ -accident.’’ What ‘‘the facts,’’ so considered by the court in
‘ reaching this judgment, might have been are not disclosed
because the court said: ‘‘No useful purpose would, be
served by a restatement of the facts here.”’
: At the outset, this court must state its views as to the
applicable principles of law against which the facts dis- _
closed by the record must be reviewed. |
which was proven,” ¢
4a ae, Appendia
_ First, the question for the trial court was: were there
any facts, or facts from which inferences might be drawn,
wWfich should have been sent to the jury for its determina-
tion as to whether Sexauer had breached a duty to plaintiff.
It was not for the trial court so to decide unless there was
a failure by plaintiff to present any facts which met legal
standards. -
‘Second, plaintiff °s previous experience ‘as a plumber
and his knowledge and use of Mule Kick was a relevant fact —
but certainly not decisive on the question of Sexauer’s lia-
' bility.
Third, the fact that the accident was ‘‘most unusual’’
is not to be considered in Goniting whether the directed
verdict was justified. |
Quite apart from the reasons mentioned by the trial
court, the function of this court on appellate review is to
~ examine the entire record to determine whether there were
‘any jury questions. . Re
The Issues on Appeal.
-On appeal within the field of negligence, the issues-have
been narrowed further. Stief states ‘‘the plaintiff’s case
against Sexauer is grounded in the legally deficient charac-
teristics of its ‘Mule Kick’ label’’ (Br. p. 6), and that ‘‘the
essence of plaintiff’s case of Sexauer’s liability is directed
toward that label’s inadequacies, untruths, misstatements
and misinformation’’ (Br. p..2).
' Stief’s case, as stated in his appellate brief, ‘against
Diamond is based on Diamond’s role in checking Sexauer’s
Jabel ‘Mule Kick’ from time to time and yet making’ no
suggestion regarding the inadequate warning on that label
when Diamond knew of the dangerots properties of the
material which Sexauer was selling to an unwarned and
_ unsuspecting public’”’ (Br. p. 6).
Stief contends that ‘‘each of the following characteris-
tics of the ‘Mule Kick’ label constitutes a legal deficiency
ing that ‘‘each alone would raise
|
a
Appendi« as;
: viv,
a prima facie case of negligence against Sexauer.’’ These —
claims aré set forth verbatim (Br. pp. 6-7):
_ “a. The label describes ‘Mule Kick’ as safe. In truth
“b,
Sfa.
it is extremely dangerous.
‘The label failed to use the words Lye’ or ‘Caustic
Soda.’ This absence failed to warn the public of
the dangerous material.
The label stated that ‘Mule Kick’: ‘Contains no
disguised perfumes, no Danogrous ‘‘bubbling’’
adulterants, causing injurious spray, explosive
gases, harmful fumes.’ In this respect it was
misleading, for this product in combination with
zinc did cause explosive gases which exploded,
' and its injurious spray blinded the plaintiff.
‘+d.
—;
The label failed to warn that explosive and propul-
sive gases might be created by reason of contact
with pipe materials or foreign materials in drain
stoppages. This was a breach of defendant Sex-
auer’s obligation to warn of the hazardous pro-
pensities of its product. That breach Greely * re-
sulted in the accident in suit. -
The label failed to warn users of ‘Mule Kick’ to
employ goggles while in the presence of ‘Mule -
Kick.’ This was in violation of defendant Sex-
auer’s duty to give users reasonable warning of
reasonable precautions to be followed i in using its
_ product.’’
| Stief takes the position that the statement on the
Sexauer label, namely, ‘‘Contains no disguised perfumes,
no Daneerous ‘bubbling’ adulterants, causing injurious
spray, explosive gases, harmful fumes”’ is ‘‘the gist of the
prima facie negligence against Sexauer’’ (Br. p. 20). The
concession is-made arguendo that-S‘as the label stands it is
6a F Appendix
not inaccurate,’” but it is claimed that ‘‘however accurate
it may be, it is. grossly, dangerously incomplete.’* Stief
' further limits Sexauer’s alleged negligence to making a
‘grossly misleading’’ statement on the can ‘‘when it knew
that the product under reasonably expected conditions
would cause an ‘injurious spray’ and would cause a highly
dangerous ‘explosive gas.’’’ Stief asserts that he "proved
that defendant knew or should have known of ‘Mule Kick’s’
reasonably foreseeable hazardous propensities’’ (Br. p. 21).
The Plaintiff’s Case. Agaiist Sexauer,
‘The question of the correctness of the trial court’s dis-
‘ missal of the complaint must be tested by the proof adduced
- during plaintiff’s case unless there were evidence developed
by defendant Sexauer which might have supported plain-
tiff. For all practical purposes there were four witnesses,
Stief, his fellow employee, Nixdorf, his expert witness, Dr.
Willard, and one Springhorn, Assistant to Sexauer’s
President.
Stief.
‘Stief, a plumber, an employee of the plumbing firm of
Everts & Overdeer, Inc., in Lancaster, Pa., on January 25,
1961, was directed to proceed t6 5 Eocust Street, about a
half-block from the office, to attempt to clear a clogged
drain in a second-floor apartment occupied by tenants
named Taylor. Nixdorf accompanied him. They discov-
ered that the stoppage was in the kitchen sink. Their ef-
forts with a plunger were unsuccessful: After. draining
the sink trap, they then poured down the drain one to two
quarts of hot water which had beef mixed with a can of
, Mule Kick, a causti¢ soda substance which they carried on
their truck and had used for drain cleaning purposes on
previous occasions. They prepared the solution in a gal-
vanized pail and followed the instructions on the label
which reads in its entirety as follows:
Ci OSB IE Mit CAL ACE LEAL BEING ye ae a a em ae
a
Appendix . 7a
‘‘Mute Kick’’
Trade ‘Mark Registered
Clears ee Drains—Peps up lazy drains.
Advertised in The Saturday Evening Post and a house- .
hold favorite for a generation. -
12 oz. net.
No odor—No fumes.
Waste Pipe Cleaner.
’ Directions
To: Clear Clogged Drains. 1st. Remove all water pos-
sible from drain. 2nd. Never pour cleaner in dry
form directly into drain. 3rd. Dissolve one can_in~
1 quart boiling water in 3 gallon iron or enamel pail,
Never Aluminum. Use double dose for obstinate stop-
' pages. 4th. Caution: Pour contents of can into pail .
Slowly, stirring with stick. 5th. Pour solution slowly
down drain. 6th. Give 8 hours to work. After solution
drains away, flush with plenty of hot water.
Important: Prevent Clogs, Pep Up Slow Drains—keep
clear and sanitary by using one-third can weekly. Keep
cover on tight or ‘‘kick’’ will be lost.
‘‘Mule Kick”’ is pure, powerful, safe. Contains no dis-
guised perfumes, no Dangerous ‘‘bubbling’’ adulter- -
ants, causing injurious spray, explosive gases, harmful
fumes. ‘‘Mule Kick’’ will not dissolve broken glass or
metal obstructions. It attacks the grease that catches
* coffee grounds, matches, hair, lint causing stoppages,
and releases it. Follow directions closely.. ‘‘Mule ~
Kick’’ will destroy linoleum.
For Heauta’s mae
Keep all drains clear and sanitary by using one-third
can ‘‘Mule Kick’’ weekly. They are natural breeding
_places for Typhoid, influenza and other germs when .
RET AES ta NIA PONE NS BGR ERY OE RAE PIETERS BEA oe SOE : ag Leese
8a Appendia .
slow running or clogged. A solution of one-third of
,. @can has many uses about the house: 1st. Use weekly
for ice-box, lavatory, sink, toilet, and bathtub drains
to prevent clogs. 2d. To clean and deodorize garbage
cans. Swab with rag on stick; let stand half hour, then
empty in sewers or cinders. Rinse and dry in sun.
3rd. To clean stove burners, cooking tops, burned cook-
ing utensils \eneegs aluminum) greasecaked tools and
machine parts. | .
To thaw frozen pipes, mix 2 full-can solution as di-_
rected and pour into pipe.
Keep Away From Hands, face, clothing, linoleum,
aluminum, . See antidotes for external and internal
caustic burns.
Poison
This Cleaner contains Godiem Hydroxide.
External:
Flood with water, then wash with vinegar.
Internal: |
Give vinegar, or yan of lemon, grapefruit, or orange,
copiously.
Follow with olive oil.
Kyes: |
Wash out with 5% boric acid solution.
Container Made in U. S. A.
They then left. The next. day, January 26th, Stief re-
turned alone, found-eonditions unchanged, again drained
.the trap and poured andther can of Mule Kick, prepared
as previously, down the drain. This, also proving unsuc-
cessful, Stief informed ‘his office that it wonld be necessary
to obtain permission | to remove the flooring | in order to
‘expose the pipe line.
Appendia a | ne 9a
On the third day, January 27th, Stief removed floor ©
boards in the second floor pantry, discovered a metal plug
covering a clean-out opening in the pipe, removed the plug
cautiously lest there be pressure, but found none and no
seepage, although there was liquid in the pipe at that point.
He then proceeded to the first floor and, removing the
pantry flooring, noticed that the drain pipe from the second
floot was joined to a sloping pipe under the pantry flooring
by means of a 45° galvanized pipe elbow. Just below the
elbow on the top of the sloping pipe was another plug-
‘ covered clean-out opening.’ He removed this plug, found
“nO seepage or pressure, saw some flakes of ice above the
_ hole not sufficient to cause a clogging of the drain, and
concluded that the stoppage must be between the first and
second floors. He replaced the plug, making it ‘‘finger
tight.’’ To eliminate any trouble from the ice flakes, Stief
used a blow-torch in that area to heat that section of ex-
posed ‘pipe. He then returned to’ the office to obtain a
‘‘snake’’—a device some twenty feet in length which can
be twisted through clogging material in a pipe. This he
inserted in the second floor opening. During this operation,
there was no sign of pressure, of spraying, or of escaping |
gases, but also no sign of success in clearing the pipe. Not
knowing what to do next, he returned to the first floor and
while standing i in the pantry doorway about eight feet from
the exposed pipe trying to determine his next course, he
heard a noise like a firecracker and was hit by a spray
containing a sodium hydroxide solution which issued from
the clean-out opening with sufficient force to cover the walls
and ceiling of the pantry and to cover his face, eyes and
‘upper body. Remedial measures failed and permanent
blindness resulted. )
Niadorf
Nixdorf’s participation was limited to the use of the
plunger and the pouring of the Mule Kick on the first day
and toa — of the extent of the spraying observed.
10a < | 7 Appendia
by him when he returned shortly: after the accident. He
also participated in the removal of sections of the pipe at
a subsequent cate a and installed a new line in the apartment.
Dr. Willard
In November 1963, sia three years after the acci-
dent, Dr. ‘Mary Willard was given for examjnation a section
of the pipe containing the clean-out opening (from which
the spray had issued) and the 45° galvanized elbow. She
found at the endvof the cut off piece of pipe at a point
below (away from the second floor) ‘the clean-out hole a
hardened mass of material, which she assumed ‘‘was at
some other point in the pipe before the accident.’’ - She
made an analysis of 4 small sample and found that it
contained 1.2% zinc. She also took scrapings from the
interior of the ‘galvanized elbow, found zinc present and
stated as a chemical fact that zinc and sodium hydroxide
will form hydrogen. Upon @ factual hypothesis, including
- assumptions which. plaintiff’s counsel asserted would be
‘*tied in,’’ Dr. Willard gave her opinion as to cause, i.e.,
' ‘metallic fragments which were in the pipe, the zinc, the
zinc coming from the elbow, the iron, the aluminum frag-
ments, reacted chemically with the sodium hydroxide to
. liberate hydrogen.’? She concluded that-there were two
causes of the accident, (1) the production of hydrogen,
- and (2) the heated solution of lye.
Dr. Willard also testified that her analysis of Mule Kick
showed that it was ‘‘well fit for the purpose it was to be
used’’ and that she found no zinc in Mule Kick.” She had
made no test as to the reaction of Mule Kick in galvanized
pipe, new or old. It: was her opinion that hydrogen would —
start evolving from zinc as soon as there was any sodijim
hydroxide present and that the gas would rise slowly. Her
explanation for the gas, if any, not rising was the column
of liquid above it, although ware was no stoppage at the
wer end of the Pipe.’ 7
”
a
| Appendix lla
| Springhorn
This Sexautr.employee ‘also testified to the fact that
zinc and Mule Kick produce hydrozen. He thought it was
so stated on the can—actually the statement was made in
the Sexauer catalog that Mule Kick was free of. adulterants
such as aluminum chips, zine borings, or ‘other agents
whieh could: cause’ harmful, obnoxious fumes, explosive
gases or injurious sprays. (The label stated no ‘‘adulter-
ants, causing injurious spray, explosive gases, harmful ©
fumes.’’) .
The Applicable Law )
Plaintiff relies upon five characteristics of the Mule
Kick label which he claims ‘‘each standing alone would
raise a prima facie case of negligence against Sexauer’’
(Br. p. 6). oa
a. ‘‘The label describes ‘Mule Kick’ as safe’’ whereas
“In truth it is extremely dangerous.’’ | |
The words on the label ‘‘pure, powerful, safe.’’ cannot
;be isolated or ‘read out of gontext. Stief had used Mule |
Kick many times before for its intended purpose—in fact, -
it was the only drain cleaner he used. He had read and
re-read the label, which contained warnings that it was
‘‘Porson’’ and that it should be kept away from hands,
face, linoleum and aluminum. ~ :
_ Since plaintiff bases his case on the alleged inadequacy
of the label, the question. immediately-arises: what should
have been put on the label which might have prevented |
this accident? No answer can be given to this question |
because the cause of the accident is completely unknown.
If there had been any testimony from which it could
be inferred that it was reasofiably foreseeable that con-
tact of Mule Kick with zine found:in galvanized pipe would
cause formation of explosive gases, plaintiff would be on
firmer ground. But filaintifi'was unable to préduce any
12a Appendia
" evidence that it would indicate that such a phenomenon as
here occurred had ever happened during the generation
Mule Kick had been on the market (some 3,800,000 cans
sold), despite the fact that galvanized pipe is ‘‘ probably
the most common of all types of pipe’’ (Pl. Reply Br. p. 2).
- Although the issues whether the likelihood of danger
' required a warning is normally\a jury question, 2 Harper
& James, Torts, p. 1546, the intiff must show some-
thing that should have led the defendant to action. The
law requires'a plaintiff, in order to establish a prima facie
case of lack of warning, to show/that the defendant knew,
_or through reasonable care should’ have known, of the
possibility of the danger. See Di and Hart, Product
Liability: Direction for Use and the Duty to Warn, 41
Va. L. Rev. 145, 156 (1955) ;-Noel, Manufacturer’s Neg-
ligence of Design or Directions for Use of a Product, 71
' Yale L. J. 816, 830 (1962).
Plaintiff, relies heavily on Maize v. Atlantic Refining
. Co., 352 Pa. 51,41.A. 2d 850 (1945); Spruill‘v. Boyle-Mid-
way, Inc., 308 F. 2d 79, 86 (4th Cir., 1962) ; Kieffer v: Blue
Seal Chemical Co., 196 F’. 2d 614 (3d Cir., 1952); and Bean
v. Ross Manufacturing Co., 344 S. W. 2d 18 (Mo. 1961).
In Matee, supra, “Sarery-Kuren”? appeared i in large |
letters on all four sides of the can.\\The only warning given ~
was ‘‘Do not inhale fumes. Use only in well-ventilated
- places.’’ The proof showed that the product contained
thirty times as much carbon tetrachloride as could safely
be inhaled in-a room of 1,000 cubic feet. Under the circum-
stances, the court properly held that the question of
whether the defendant had discharged its full duty to ‘the
purchaser was for the jury.. However, there ‘the defen-
dant knew the strength of its product, the probable area |
of its intended use (the attention or, better, lack thereof)
which ‘would be given: the label by the average housewife
in using it, and the probable consequences of misuse.
. In Spruill, supra, a baby had swallowed some of the de-
fendant’s product. The aula died-of chemical pneumonia. —
Cc
Oo
'
et
Appendiz - . Ia
*
The ‘legend ‘‘Porson’? was in very small type but par-
ticularly determinative was the fact that the defendant,
had notice of 32 cases of chemical pneumonia (seven in-
fants, four of whonf died) during six preceding years. f
‘Even ‘there, the court said that it was necessary for the.
plaintiff to show that ‘‘defendants knew, or should have
known, that the product was being used, or might be used,
in a dangerous manner * * *”’ (308 F.. 2d at 88).
In Kieffer, supra, an action against a drain cleaner
-. manufacturer, the sodium hydroxide cleaner contained pow-:
dered metal aluminum, (pene in Mule Kick): The batch,”
contained more aluminum than the formula called for which
increased the vigor of its reaction. Furthermore, letters of
complaint had been received by the defendant’s President
so that the defendant was on notice of the danger.
In Bean, supra, adulterants, aluminum and zinc chips
- (absent in Mule Kiek), had been added to the powder with-
out any warning of their reaction in water.
The law as to alleged failure to warn cannot be better
summarized than in the statement in the opinion in Jamie-
son v. Woodward & Lothrap, 247-F. 2d 23,°25-26 D. C.
Cir.), cert. denied 355 U. S. 855 (1957): so,
‘‘The cause of action in the case at bar-does not arise
from any of these. It arises, as we have said, from
alleged negligence in failing to warn or otherwise pro-
tect the user in the use of the article.
‘‘There: are on the market vast numbers of. products
¢as to which the law holds the manufacturer to a duty
to-warn of foreseeable dangers or to provide safe-
guards against such dangers. But. there are also on
the market vast numbers of potentially dangerous
? products as to which the-manufacturer owes no duty
of warning or other protection. The law does not re-
quire that an article be accident-proof or incapable .
of doing harm. It would be totally unreasonable to.
require that a manufacturer warn or protect against
a
LR eka OP REE EM YER ENE TORS, Le POE LOPE MA ETRE NE AP NEGO TIT p ree ee
-* inoe oe + : ain thee 4 “ >
14a
Appendiz
every injury which may ensue from mishap in the use
of his product. Almost every physical object can be
inherently dangerous or’ potentially dangerous in a
sense. A lead pencil can stab a man to the heart or
puncture his jugular vein, and due to that potentiality
it is an ‘inherently dangerous’ object; but, if a person
‘accidentally slips and falls on a pencilpoint in his
pocket, the manufacturer of the pencil is not liable for
_ the injury. He has no obligation to put a safety guard
on a lead pencil or to issue a warning with its sale. A
tack, a hammer, a pane of glass, a chair, a rug, a
rubber band, and myriads of other objects are truly
‘inherently dangerous’, because they might slip. They
cause accidents and injury even more often, we expect,
than do rubber exercisers. But the doctrines fashioned
by the law for inherently dangerous objects do not
encompass these things. A. hammer is not of defective
design because it may hurt the user if it slips. A
manufacturer cannot manufacture a knife that will not
cut or a hammer that will not mash a thumb or a
stove that will not burn a finger. The law does not
require him to warn of such common dangers. Qn the
other end of the spectrum of praticalities, a manufac-
turer should not be permitted to market without pro-
” tection to the user-a spray which would kill trees if
_ used at the wrong time, as in McClanahan, or a skirt
which would otherwise ignite if brushed by a lighted
cigarette, as in Noone? A manufacturer might be
liable for failure to provide a shield or an emphatic
warning to users of an electric power saw, but he
Court’s footnote renumbered}
. McClanahan v. Colifornia Spray-Chemical Corp., 194 Va. 842,
75 S. E.. 2d 712 (1953).
2. Noone v. Fred Perlberg, Inc., 268 App. Div. 149, 49 N. Y. S.
2d 460 (1944), aff'd’ 294 N. . 680, 60 'N. E. 24839 (1945). Cf.
Frank R. Jelleff, Inc. v- Braden, 98.U. S. App. D. C. 180, 233 F. 2d
671 (D. C. Cir. 1956).
° ~
. removed and that a sample should be
Appendix | iba
would not be liable if he failed so to provide i in respest
to a kitchen knife.’’ 3
b. The Failure to Use the Words **Lye’’ or ‘‘Caustic
Soda’’ instead of ‘‘ Sodium Hydroxide.”’
Stief knew that Mule Kick had to be handled with care. ~
The‘ label advised him of the precautions which he should .
take. His testimony disclosed that he took them. The use
of the word ‘‘lye’’ would not have added to his saat tal
of its characteristics. ———__
ce. The Label’s Statements as to no Adulterante.
The testimony of: plaintiff’s expert established this to
be a, true statement. It contained no zinc or the listed
adulterants. | |
d. The path of the Label to Warn ‘that Explosive
and Propulsive Gases might be created by.reason of con-
tact with pipe materials or foreign materials in ain stop-
pages or by the use of heat.
This argument. defies and rejects the ie fore-
seeable principle of law. Were plaintiff’s contention to be
adopted, the seller of every drain cleaner would have to.
advise the purchaser that, before using, he should cléan out
the clogged drain, that the sdiecing: material must first be
to ascertain
whether it would be safe to use the drain cleaning sub-
stance. Or the clogged pipe would have to be removed and
sections or scrapings thereof be tested: for possible explo-
sive reactions to Mule Kick. But according to Stief and
_ his fellow employee, Mixdorf, in all their years of experi-
ence with Mule Kick in all kinds of pipes they had not ex-
perienced any explosive or propulsive ewe of the liquid
— any pipe.
Nor is there any basis for otitis that plaintiff’s
use of the wane to melt the observed ice oryetals pro-
16a ee | Appendia
duced 4 : hydrogen a If heat had. any eicterning
- effect, the explosion, if such it were, should have occurred
- when the heat was applied. The proof is uncontradicted
’ that it did not. To the contrary, an appreciable amount of
time elapsed thereafter while Stief went to his office to
obtain the. plumber’s snake, returned to the second floor
Taylor apartment, used the snake unsuccessfully, and then
proceeded to the first floor to consider his next move. |
Furthermore, there is no claim made by Stief in his env- ©
meration of ‘‘legal deficiency’’ in the label (a-e, supra).
that a warning as to heat had been negligently omitted or: ..
was even required.
} As to the timing of the formation of hydrogen gas, it
-was the opinion of plaintiff’s expert that contact between
‘Mule Kick and zinc would create hydrogen immediately,
whereas the proof was that the Mule Kick was poured in
_ first on the 25th, again on the 26th with no tangible signs
of pressure or gas formation, and that the propelled spray
accident did not‘occur until the,27th. Furthermore, gas if
forméd by the liquid Mule Kick according to the testimony
of Dr. Willard, would rise, being fourteen times lighter.
than air. Thus, as to the adequacy of the Sexauer label,
_ there was no proof from which the jury could have con-
- eluded that Sexauer had notice of any chemical fact or of
any experience involving the use of Mule Kick which should
have caused:it to warn against its use if galvanized pipes
might be encountered or against the use of external heat
.on pipes containing Mule Kick.
e. The Failure of the Label to Warn ‘that iit
should be worn.
At the time of the accident, ‘Stief was. actually not work-
_ ing with Mule Kick and had no need to wear goggles. He
had just returned from the second floor and was standing
at the pantry door on the first floor wondering what to do
next, Any warning on the label about wearing goggles
when using Mule Kick would not have been applicable a Ca
the time. ee
ee A GIO lt 20 I I Fe
ce ane i areata: 8 actin west lle a om Amel
Appendis a 17a
Plaintiff here utilis the'same argument as was ihe
in the Jamieson case, supra, ‘namely, that the case should
have been submitted to the jury. Again turning to Jamieson
for a clear analysis of this argument, we agree with the
answer thereto, in the court’s statement (247 F. 2d at 33):
‘‘Tt is urged that a contest of the sort here involved can
just as well be submitted to a jury, without a prior de-
termination of possible liability on the part of the de- —
fendant. There is in some sociological circles a philos-
ophy that the burden of damges suffered in accidents:
with manufactured articles ought to be widely spread,
by way of the manufacturer and his available i insurance,
such as is the plan widely adopted in respect to injuries
suffered in employment But such a plan ought to be
adopted, if it is to be adopted, by the voice of the people
generally, expressed by the législative branch of the
government. It ought not be imposed by the judicial
branch. To be sure, there are many respects in which
-the development of the‘common law calls for re-exami-
nation and change by the courts. The advances made
by the courts in this very field by cases such as Huset *
and MacPherson, supra, are illustrations. But so
sweeping a change in commercial liability as the change
. Just mentioned is not within that area. We must, when
appropriate procedural demands have been made, de-.
termine at the outset of an action whether a possible —
liability in law of the defendant has been indicated by
the plaintiff. This is a concept basic in our jurispru-
' dence. It is established, firmly and correctly, that if a
defendant has violated no legal obligation, his liability
for pecuniary damages must not be submitted to the
Court’s footnote renumbered]
The tabject 1s discussed iu an articls by Dein Pousid,: New
Theories of Liability, 8 N. Y. Co. L. A. B. Bull. 32 35 (1950)..
‘ See also James, Functions of udge and Jury in Negligeace
Cases, 58 Yale L. J: 667, 689 (1949).
4. Huset v. J. Y. Case Threshing Mach. Co., 120 F. ye (8th
Cir. 1903).
18a | : Appendiz:
possible prejuidices, sympathies or whims of a lay jury.
. His basic liability is first to be tested as-a matter of
law by the judge.”” 7 PS
And, as recently stated in Borowicz v. Chicago Mastic
Company, 367 F. 2d 751, 760 (7 Cir., 1966) : “‘the premise
of pecuniary liability for tort is not the mere fact ‘of: in-
jury, but ‘i injury plus fault. It would be totally. unreason-
able to require that a manufacturer warn or protect against
every. injury waieh may ensue ‘from’ a mishap i in oe use of
his produ . .
The Case denied Diomond ,
The gist of Stief’s argument is that, assuming that Dia-
a mond knew the nature of Sexauer’s Mule Kick label, Dia-
mond should have insisted-upon, or exerted some power or
pressure upon Sexauer to provide, a label which would have
- avoided this accident. However, as in the case of the Sex-
auer label, since the cause of the accident is unknown, what
could Diamond have suggested be added to the label even
assuming sucha policing power? —.
Since on the facts here presented, there would have
been no rational basis for a jury’s conclusion that the acci-
dent was caused by an inadequate label, the trial court cor-
rectly dismissed the case against Diamond.
; Judgment dismissing the complaint against Sexauer
- and Diamond affirmed.. No costs.
FRIENDLY, Circuit Judge (dissenting as to Sexauer and con-
curring as to Diamond) : :
I believe the majority’s affirmance of the dismissal of
the complaint with respect to defendant Séxauer unwar-
rantably deprives the plaintiff of his right to a jury trial.
To have his case against Sexauer submitted to a jury,
Stief was merely required to present evidence sufficient to
to warrant a finding that his serious injury was caused by a
aed a a : " NPP aR rey) ep ne netoer tag te Ore
ie ; . Appendia ee 19a
property of Mule Kick of which Sexauer knew or ought to |
_ have known and against which it should have warned, The
majority opinion, as I understand it, résts on the basis that
he did not. present sufficient evidence to- show. what the
cause of the accident was and that it would therefore have
been impossible for Sexauer to have prepared a warning
that would'have prevented the catastrophe. This view rests
on too formalistic an approach to the evidence, particularly
. in. the light of the established ‘rule that in determining —
whether evidence is sufficient to.take a case to a jury, all
reasonable inferences must be drawn in plaintiff’s favor.
On the issue of causation we start with three undis-
. puted facts: At temperatures of 125° Fahrenheit and above
a combination of sodium hydroxide and zine will generate ———_.
hydrogen gas; there was Zinc in the galvanized elbow of the
pipe as well as in'the clogged material; and, when the liquid
escaped from the pipe, there was an explosion. the propul-
sive force of which carried the liquid to the ceiling of the
pantry and to a wall eight feet away. These facts alone
- might suffice to warrant a finding that the generation of
hydrogen gas from the reaction of sodium hydroxide with
zine at a high temperature caused the accident. Since the
only alternative explanation. offered by Sexauer, of a free
fall of liquid caused by the melting of the ice, failed to
account for the wide spread of the liquid through the pan-
try, the jury would have been justified in accepting plain-
tiff’s. theory.. As Judge Medina has recently said, ‘‘But
there are cases where common sense is more reliable than
any amount of expert witnesses, and this is one of those
cases.’’ Achilles v. New England Tree Expert Co., 369 F.
2d 72, 73 (2 Cir. 1966): fee oa
. However, the proof went considerably beyond this.
Dr. Mary Willard, Professor Emeritus of Chemistry at’
Pennsylvania State Universi , testified that in. her opinion -
the accident was caused by the production of hydrogen from
the combination of zine with the heated solution of sodium
hydroxide. She thought that the production of hydrogen
cane ae Appendic
above the stoppage forced the senneds eet through the
_ pipe past the clean-out hole and that this pressure expelled
the plug and the caustic solution through the hole. Another -
theory, consistent with a statement by Stief in applying for
workmen’s compensation benefits although in conflict’ with
his trial testimony, is that there were two stoppages, one
of ice above the plug and another of grease and debris
below; that the melting of the ice by the torch caused some
’ of the Mule Kick solution to fall through the pipe past the
clean-out hole where it was stopped by the second blockage ;
and that the reaction of the Mule Kick with zine in the
~ pipe at’ the high temperature created ed by the torch. produced
__'_____ hydrogen, -which expelled the plug and-caused the mixture
to spurt through the hole. When Sexauer challenged these
theories by asserting that if hydrogen had been formed,
_ it would/have bubbled up and been seen by Stief when he
ascended to the second floor and put the snake down the
‘pipe, Dr..Willard responded that the gas would have been
_ held down by the long column of liquid in the pipe. Whether —
| this was implausible, as Sexauer claims, is precisely the :
|. ______kin@-ef question that ought to be left for decision by a jury
unless the implausibility is such that no rational ‘mind
could think otherwise. That was not the situation either as
to the matter of bubbling or as to the other element stressed
by the majority, the time between Stief’s application of
the torch to the pipe and the explosion. I see no reason
why, in the absence of contrary scientific evidence, the jury
_ could not conclude that the application of the torch might
have begun the hydrogen-forming- reaction, and that this
would have had to continue for five or ten minutes—the .
time it took Stief to get the snake, place it in the pipe on >
the second floor, and walk downstairs to the pantry—before
enough hydrogen to cause the explosion could have been
‘formed. Not only was there no such evidence, but defend- .
ant’s expert testified that at 125° F. zinc would react with
sodium hydroxide only ‘‘very slowly.’’ If twelve practical
"people can be persuaded that Stief’s — of the accident
°
Appendia oS 21a
was more plausible than Sexauer ’s, I fail to understand
how a judge could say they had gone beyond the bounds .
of reason. : ° ;
Once. this is admitted, the plaintiff was entitled toa \
jury’s consideration whether the label was adequate in view
_ ofthe hazard of the formation of hydrogen as a result of
' contact with zine at a high temperature. Sexauer knew tliat
. Sodium hydroxide involved this hazard, and it is common
_knowledge both that household plumbing’ frequently con-
tains galvanized pipe and that galvanized
with zine. Under these circumstances a jury could ration-
ally find that failure to warn of the hazard of utilizing
Mule Kick in conjunction with galvanized pipe at a high
temperature was negligent; indeed, defendant’s witness
‘Springhorn, formerly sales manager and’ at the time of
trial assistant to the president of Sexauer, thought. the—
label in fact contained a warning with respect to zinc, as
it did with respect to aluminum. Moreover, the label ‘was.
' not merely deficient in warning against the application of
heat, but worse than that; it instructed the user to dissolve -
Mule Kick in ‘‘boiling water’’ and to ‘‘flush with plenty of-
hot water,’’ and urged that it be used to thaw frozen
pipes. Thus, there was not mérely a lack of warning with
7 respect to the dangers of contact between, a heated solution —
containing Mule Kick and zinc but a positive indication of
‘incident had ever occurred. In any event the jury could’
find that sineéthe hazard was known, Sexauer was under
\
—
—
228 reaae Append
siti to refer to our own decision in Butler v. L. Duinghee
_- Bons, Inc., 296 F.. 2d 623, 626 (2 Cir. 1961), which is ‘about
as close in point as’ one tort case can be to another. There
- also a manufacturer contended that a long record of acci-
- dent-free experience justified failure to give a re
We rejected that contention, saying:
“But, especially when injury is likely to be serious
if trouble occurs, even slight foreseeability may war-
rant, and.a long history of good fortune will not neces-
sarily exclude,:a conclusion by ‘the trier of the facts
that prudence requires the manufacturer to take on
so small an added burden.’’
Depriving Stief of jury y d termination of ‘the common
sense questions on which case against Sexauer depends
- runs wholly counter to the trend of Supreme Court deci-
. Sions over the past decades.
I concur in the affirmance as to Diamond although not —
on the ground relied on by the majority.: The 400 pound
drum in which Diamond sold caustic soda to commercial
‘and industrial buyers for a variety of uses bore a label’
reprinted in the margin.° Stief’s contention is not that this.
label was inadeqnate in the sense that it did not inform
sexauer of the danger that contact with zinc might result
in the formation of hydrogen; since Sexauer knew all
about this, any such deficiency in the label’ would have
* lacked sufficient causal relation to the accident. The claim
is rather that Diamond was bound to see to it that Sexauer’s
label was adequate. Plaintiff relies heavily on Restatement
(Second), Torts § 388 (1965) and particularly on the dis-
~ eussion of ‘«Warnings given to third person”’ at pp. 307-10.
; * “WARNING: CONTAINS CAUSTIC SODA. Burns skin
and eyes. ee eee, oe Do not take inter-
nally: When handling wear goggles or face-shield and avoid all skin
contact.. While making solutions, add Caustic Soda slowly to surface
be Poms Patra pectin In.case of accidental skin contact, flush
affected ‘parts wi
oe Soe See oy ee ee - Obtain medical attention.
water and wash with vinegar.’ For eyes, flush.
_ ‘stances could never arisé in which a
| Appendia . a ee 23a | fs
' Most of the discussion, however, does not read directly .
on the instant. situation where a manufacturer sells ‘a raw
material in large containers to many purchasers for a wide
variety of uses and the particular purchaser has repacked
it under his own name and label. Perhaps the only obser- _.
vations direttly applicable are the searcely decisive ones.
that ‘‘it is obviously impossible to state in advance any set
of rules which will automatically determine in all cases.
whether one supplying a chattel for the use of others
-throngh.a third person ha8 satisfied his duty to those who |
are to use the chattel by informing the third person of the
dangerous character of the chattel, or of the precautions
which must be exercised in using it in. order to make its
use safe,’’ and *that ‘modern. life would be intoJerable
unless one were permitted to rely to a certain extent on
_ others doing what they normally do, particularly if. it: is |
Diamond might be subjected to liability
labelling by an intermediary like Sexauer, ak, for example,
if it knew a packager who had purchased significant quan-
tities of its caustic ‘soda was putting this into the market
with no warning whatever, or if the packager had submitted
and obtained approval for a label that was highly mislead-
ing. But the facts here are at the opposite end of the spec-
| trum from these hypotheticals,
Sexauer had been selling Mule Kick for thirty years
under the same label but began purchasing caustic soda
from Diamond only a little while before the injury to Stief.
The record. reveals nothing as to how important an outlet.
Sexauer then became, and there is no eviderice that Dia- .
mond had seen its catalog .or periodical advertising. Al-
though plaintiff claims there is evidence that Diamond had
seen the label on the can, the testimony was highly equivocal
and surely does not show that Diamond had seen the label
before it sold the caustic soda that was repackaged into
4a : Appendia
the cans used by Stief in January, 1961, or that if it had
protested upon seeing the label,.the agcident would have >
been avoided. Moreover, although a jury could find the
Sexauer label inadequate to discharge the duty of care of |
a distributor to the plumbing trade, it was not blatantly .
offensive or insufficient; the degree of foreseeability of
danger and hence the amount of care required with respect
to warniig may vary somewhat inversely with a_seller’s
distance’ from the ‘specific use and with the number of in-
termediariés. On. the facts here presented, there would
have been no rational ‘basis for a jury’s concluding that
Diamond had ‘failed to exercise reasonable care with re-
opest to the plaintiff.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.