Appendix — Panczko v. United States

Supreme Court brief1966

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

‘APPENDIX A _

FIRST POINT |

Portions. of Decisions: Below

Re Government’

Wreck-Removal Expenses

1. OF THE TRIAL Court

a.. Memorandum Opinion, aed 28, 1963. '

os H°

Claim of the United States inieiemiais, |

“Fhe United Statés makes claim for $35,801. 38. This

consists of a number of items, some for preparing and 7

towing the disabled vessel to an anchorage in Bolivar ’

Roads November 10, 1961;~for services of a standby

’ tug while so anchored November 10-27, 1961; for

hire of a ‘ship keeper’, around the clock, November .

27, 1961 to January 12, 1962; and for overhead

charges of the Corps of Engineers. x é

" “As noted earlier, following the collision the Union

Reliance was a burning wreck swinging on her anchor -

-in the Houston Ship Channel. This navigable water-

way was effectively blocked, with a number of vessels

_ trapped up stream in the Port of Houston. Under

_ § 409 of Title 33, U.S.C.A.,-the duty was imposed

“upon Petitioner immediately to remove the wreck and

to clear the Channel. Petitioner was unable or un-;

‘ willing to do so, and her representative, (Mr. Eikel) so

advised the-Engineers. Proceeding under § 415 of Title

~ 33, U:S.C.A. on November 10, while still unable to

board the vessel the Engineers had her ‘anchor cut and

the vessel towed to safe anchorage in. Bolivar Roards. ©

The sum of $8,582.00 was expended for this operation.

-I find that this sum was. properly spent. for this pur- -

pose by the Engineers, was reasonable in amount, and -

: cme necessary to clear the Channel.

- “Proceeding under § 415 of Title 33, US.C.A., the ..

United States filed its libel in this Court November 17,

(22 ¢

1961, seeking sale of the a" and his ‘cargo, and

seeking personal recovery against Petitioner for certain

other expenses alléged to ‘constitute legitimate salvage

, items. When the limitation proceeding was filed here-

‘ in November 28, 1961, this libel by the United States,

together with others against Petitioner, was enjoined. . ..

On more careful consideration I- have concluded ‘that

Court was in error in restraining the sale of the

] and her cargo, in the event reimbursement was .-

not made within the thirty day period provided" by:

§ 415.

“Under this Section,. ‘alt tea sali interpreting ;

‘it, it seems clear that these costs of clearing the navi-'

_-gable waterway do- hot give the United States an in

personam claim against the shipowner, Loud v. United

. ‘States, 286 F. 56 (6th Cir.) ; Hagan v. Richmond, 52

' , §.E. 385; Petition of Highlands Nav. Corporation, 29

FF, (2d) 37 (2nd Cir.); 56.Am. Jur. 687, WATERS,

§ 227. They create no ‘liability of the owner of: any

vessel . . for ‘any embezzlement, loss or destruction

an any goods shipped on such vessel, or for any

‘Hoss, damage, or injury by collision,’ or otherwise,

which may be limited under the terms of § 183: of.

te

Title 46, U.S.C.A. There is no liability of the owner at «

all. Rather, these costs are.an in rem charge -against _

-the vesselzand her cargo, to recover which the United

- States may sell both vessel. and cargo. The United

States was undertaking to. follow this statutory. pro-

cedure.. She had maintained possession of the vessel,

through the presence of the ship keeper and. Deputy pi

U.S. Marshal, until this Court intervened and took. .

custody through its trustee under the limitation pro-'

ceeding..

“Hades this Court not , ineerventd, on the Govern-

ment’s claim remaining unpaid by December 10, 1961,

(being thirty days after the expense was incurred) the

Government might have sold the, vessel and her cargo.

The statute does not- make this

exist irrespective of the Petitioner’s right to. limit.

right conditional. It

ee nit

—_—— .

a= .

. ordinary rights afforded by § 415 do not

a * i ‘ =

2 ao

Petitioner may not deprive thé United States of its

right of sale by undertaking to surrender. the vessel.

The payment ofthis sum—and release of this charge

against the vessel—was necessary before she could be

__surfendered in‘ a.limitation proceeding. Hence, under

§ 185 of Title 46, U.S.C.A., I fix thissum, of $8, $82.00

as _an additional amount to be deposited with this.

Court_ by Petitioner, for the use and. benefit of the

United States, as necessary to carry out the provisions:

of, § 183 of Title 46, US.C.A. . -

The other items of expense composing the: ‘latin

of the United States were incurred after the vessel

reached anchorage in Bolivar Roads, These were not a

necessary part of clearing the Channel,

attach thereto.

While—as the United States contends—the Union Re-

liance thereafter constituted a potential hazard to navi-

gation—it does not follow that all of the expenses in-

‘curred by the Engineers in performance of their duty —

to protect commerce may be taxed here. I withhold

passing upon whether this remaining portion of the

Government’s claim constituted salvage expense until

trial on the merits: :

“Proctor for the trustee is requested to’ “prepare *.

order for the payment of the claims ‘mentioned above

from the limitation fund; and providing for. pay-

-fnent into the Registry by’ Petitioner of the amount __.

of $8,582.00, within thirty days from: this date, 4s

a condition of maintaining the limitation proceeding.”

(R. 1152-1155)

. Decision, July 17, 1963.

ee a aa ser oe \ 7 ‘a

Findings of Faet

* * &

ya’ 44, The services rendered to the UNION RELI-

- ANCE while she. was at anchor in Bolivar Roads, and

24

subsequent thereto, by ‘the United States were, in the

light of circumstances. then existing, reasonable and ©

necessary; and the charges made therefor reasonable -

in amount and consistent with charges generally made °

for similar services in that vicinity.” (R. 5137-5138)

+ * &.

~.. . ,* ° Conclusions of Law

| + ” * ie

“9, China Union Lines, Ltd. is liable to the United

States of America for the expenses incurred in con-

nection with this incident and made the subject matter

'.of the claim of the United States.” (R. 5141) |

, Interlocutory ; Decree’ Determining Liability. :

“ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED in

Admiralty No, 2012 that the United States of America, ,

libelant, is entitled to recover its salvage charges, as

a valid claim in rem against the M/V UNION -RELI-

' ANCE, and the proceeds of the sale thereof now in

the . registry of the Court, and the amount of the’

government’s reasonable salvage charges having been

_ already determined; it is therefore, ORDERED and

DIRECTED that after payment of all unpaid Trustee’s

expenses, United States of America is éntitled to re-

cover out of the amount now in the registry of the

- Court the sum of Twenty-Seven’ Thousand Two

‘. Hundred Nineteen and 38/100 Dollars: ($27,219.38),

- with interest thereon at the rate of six per cent (6%)

from the date hereof until paid, United States of -

America having already recovered out of the funds

in the registry of the Court the sum of Eight Thousand

Five Hundred rage dtalhial Dollars ($8, §82)).”- id

a 5149)

Peg

2s

‘2. OF THE Court OF APPEALS

“ee ae : + * .

- CLAIM OF UNITED STATES ..

China Union alone ‘challenges the claim of the” United

- States. The claim consists et three separate items:

(1) expense -of reshoving and ‘re2anchoring the RELI-

. ANCE, $8,582.00, and . 3 he

(2) experise of shipkeepers. and similar enpenite to

preserve -the property, $6,031.38, and _ |

(3) ex of stand-by: tug to prevent ‘he vessel feos’ .

. Moving and re- blocking the channel, $21,188. Cee, AG

: That the RELIANCE, as a result of the. casualty, be-| -

came a flaming derelict which imperiled, the very existence

. of other -watercraft and obstructed and prevented the

navigation of the channel, is beyond argument. The owner

and underwriters were unable to control the fire. Actirig

under the emergency’ provisions of 33. U.S.C. § 415,. the»

United States District .Engineer, after a special investiga- ©

tion, made a determination that the RELIANCE was a

’ special danger to navigation and, after notice, to owner,.

directed that the vessel be towed. from. the Channel and

anchored in Bolivar Roads, adjacent to the ‘channel.

After removal of the vessel, the United States filed a

libel, asking for the sale of the vessel,” to pay the cost of

removal and incidental expenses, This proceeding: was en-

joitied, on November 29, 1961,,0n China Union’s petition

for a limitation of liability. After granting the injunction, |

the judge required China Union to pay into court the

cost of removal of the vessel-in the sum of $8,582.00. Other

' proceedings, “and allowances, are outlined in detail in .

| American Cyanamid Co. v. China Union Linés 306 F d

¥

265 Sold as scrap for $109,100:00. ~ <<

eee

135 (5th Cir. 1962), in which proceeding the circuit court

- refused. jurisdiction, but suggested that the district ae

_ might make findings on the issues presented.

On the first issue, the Government must prevail. It had

*a statutory right to hold the vessel and cargo, dispose there-

of -at public sale and deduct from the proceeds $8,582.00, —

the expenses of removal. While the Government could not

proceed’ in personam, against China Union, United States

v. Bethlehem Steel Corp., 319 F.2d 512, (9th Cir. 1963);

' cert. denied 375 U.S. 966 (1964) and United States v. Zu-

bik, 295 F.2d 53 (3rd.Cir.:1961), we must remember that _

it was China Union which was seeking the injunction and

a limitation of its liability. It was to its advantage, and

the advantage of its underwriters, to free the RELIANCE

“of the Government’s statutory lien, and secure the decree

‘of injunction, The judge, in requiring China Union’ to

make this payment, recognized that the equities ‘were with

the Government and that the Government’s*lien was first

in time and prior in right.”* The order of the court did

not amount to a judgment in personam against . the peti-

tioner,, but merely required China Union to do awhat it

should have done in the first instance.

On _December 3, 1962,. after receipt of the mandate

of the Cc Court of Appeals, the = held a supplemental

..%6 “Had this Court not intervened . . . the Government might

have sold the vessel and her cargo. The statute,does not make this

right conditional. It exists irrespective of the Petitioner’s. right to ©

limit. Petitioner may not deprive the United States of its right of

_ sale by undertaking to surrender the vessel. The payment of this

‘sum—and release of this charge against the vessel—was necessary

_before she could be surrendered in a limitation proceeding. Hence, ~

under § 185 of Title 46, US.C.A., I. fix-this. sum of $8,582.00 as an

additional amount to be deposited with this Court by Petitioner,

for the use and benefit of the United States, as necessary to carry.

out the provisions of § 183 of Title 46, U.S.C.A.” AOrder, January 28,

1963.) /

27

hearing, at’ which-time testimony. was taken and exhibits

introduced in connection with the nature and reasonable-

ness of the. Government’s and other claims. Eighteen wit-

nesses testified at this hearing and there is solid evidence to

support the finding in favor of the Government. The fact

that the judge’s finding on the subject, is included under

his conclusions of law,”" is of no significance. Compania

‘ . Transcontinental de Petroleo, S.A. .v. Mexican Gulf Oil

Co., et al, 292 Fed. 846 (2d Cir. 1923); Arkansgs Amuse-

ment Corp. v. Kempner, 57°F.2d 466 (8th Cir. 1932).

Even in the absence-of a finding of fact, this being a trial

de novo, we would be compelled to say that the record

fully supports the pertinent provisions of the interlocutory

decree. True enough, specific amounts are not mentioned

in this: finding. However, there wy hts misunderstand-

ing as to the amounts, in that the on of the Govern- —

ment’s claim, both in the exhibits and the. testimony,. was

uniform and precise. They are the figures which are set.

forth, with exactness, in the interlocutory decree. 2

Te is our view that item (3) of the Government’s claim

_ is also covered by the provisions of 33 U.S.C. § 415, and

that the lien against the RELIANCE for such item was

also first in time and prior in right. The statute contem-

plates that the Government hold said vessel for a period of

thirty days, after notice to the owner, and thereafter until

sale. It-is logical to assume that the Congress intended the

Government to take proper care of the vessel during pos-

session. The “expense of removing,” in our opinion, should

not be limited to the precise cost of removing the vessel

from tk. place of. the casualty to a place of safety, but _

should also cover any and all reasonable expense incidental -

27 “9° China Union Lines, Ltd. is.liable to the United States of

America for the expenses incurred in connection with this incident.

and made the subject matter of the claim of the United States.”

“28.

to the removal:and enforcement process, such as the ex-.

pense of safe-guarding. This expense is contemplated by

the statute, Petitioner’s arguments that ‘the tug hire of

_- $21,188.00 was not a legitimate expense, is illusory in the

"extreme. The record discloses many considerations which

weighed in favor of having the tug stand by, rather than:

_ using two anchors. The District Engineer, after consulta-

tion with Coast Guard officers, decided to use only one

anchor and have the tug stand -by, so as to be assured of

its immediate availability in case the anchor did not hold.

Those making the decision were of the opinion that (1)

. two anchors might foul the vessel, (2) the anchor wind-

~. Jass and the deck supporting it had been subjected to severe

_ fire, (3) the “upper shots” of the anchor chain had been

subjected to severe heat, (4) the Galveston area was sub-

ject to severe changes in weather conditions, (5). the tide

was exceptionally swift. where the vessel was anchored,

and (6) the vessel, even with dual anchors, might: well

slip back into the channel. True enough, the court even-

tually found that the tug was not necessary to keep the.

RELIANCE at its’ anchorage, and this is the. point on

which China Union principally relies. Here, the mischievous

a of validity which lurks behind the veil of hindsight is. .

again presented. The original action of the District En-

gineer in ordering the tug to stand by, when viewed in -

light of his obligation to protect the traffic in the channel

without unduly jeopardizing the vessel and ‘its cargo, is

quite understandable. The judge’s action, in subsequently -

ordering the tug dismissed, was taken after more than. two

weeks of actual experience in holding the vessel at anchor.

It does not imply disapproval of its. previous use; indeed,

_ doubtless because of his own wise reluctance to be governed

by hindsight, the judge expressly refused to pass on that

question at that time. The record reveals no subsequent

= oe

developments weighing against his ultimate. approval of

the charge.

. On November: 27; 1961, the judge dismissed the tug

from standing by the RELIANCE and, on that day, placed

shipkeepers aboard pending ‘the further order of the court. |

At the same’time, custody of the vessel was taken by the

United States Marshal and the court was thereafter in

possession. Earlier, on. November 24th, the District En- |

gineer, acting on order from the Unitéd States Attorney’s

office, caused shipkeepers to be placed aboard and the cost

of employing those shipkeepers, round the clock, both

before and after the court order is, in major part, the

basis for the Government’s claim of $6,031.38. China Union

charges that the Government was no longer in possession ©

of the vessel and is not entitled to this allowance. This claim

is without validity, whether we view the service performed :

as under the. statute, or as an allowance by the court to

the Government for expense incurred in connection with

protecting the vessel, after the seizure by the Marshal.

Our only area of doubt is whether any allowance should

be made for the three day period November 24-27, when

the tug was also standing by. It does not appear that this

“over-lapping” was called to the attention of the judge and

he may want'to take another look at this feature in the .

other. proceedings which must be hereafter conducted by |

him. We believe that the employment of the shipkeepers _

on and after November. 27th 1, Should be treated as an -

“expense of justice” and entitled to .perferential treatment. —

New York Dock Co, v. SS. POZNAN, 274 US. 117

(1927); THE ST: PAUL, 271 Fed. 265 (2d Cir., 1921). .

Since these expenses were necessary they should be allowed.

Yokahama Bank v. Wong, 113 F.2d 329 (9th Cir. 1940);

‘THE TRANSFER NO. 7, 176 F.2d 950 (2d Cir. er

~

| 30

= ' APPENDIX B

SECOND POINT

- Portions of Decisions of the Courts Below

‘Re the BEREAN’S Acrylonitrile Cargo

1. OF THE TRIAL Court

a. Trial vite dismissing Libels “me American Cya- .

namid Company.

ee * + Ey

“endl

“As to the motion of American Cyanamid Com-

pany for judgment at the conclusion of the pétitioner’s

case, I think the motion is well taken and will be

_ granted. As the manufacturer and shipper of an in-

herently dangerous commodity, I understand the law

to impose oh them the duty to warn and advise others |

who may come in contact with it of its dangerous

propensities. I think the evidence shows clearly here

that that was done, that the carrier was. fully advised

of the dangerous "characteristics of the cargo,-and .

without deciding the question, but if there be any

fault in the way the BEREAN was loaded, as to which

tanks the cargo was carried, and: so forth, I consider

' that to be a fault of the vessel and of Andersen, and

- not of the shipper.” (R. 3454-3455)

ee ‘* * #

b. Decision, July 47, 1963. * :

- ss“ Findings of Fact

+ +

_- “10. On November 6, 1961, the BEREAN loaded

14 tons of acrylonitrile at Good Hope, Louisiana, Upon

the direction of the officers of the vessel, this shipment

was placed in the forwardmost cargo tanks of’ the

. BEREAN, — No. 1 _ No. 1 center, and: -™ 1

starboard. ~

\

sy

by)? Acrylonitrile is similar to gasoline in its burh-.

ing’ and explosive characteristics. However, it is highh

toxic, and gives off poisonous and dangerous fumes.

_ These fumes will cause illness to a person exposed

thereto in relatively weak concentrations over a pro-

longed. period of time; and may cause illness or death

from a single exposure if in a sufficiently high concen-

tration. The symptoms of acrylonitrile poisoning are °

somewhat similar to those of cyanide poisoning. Acry-

lonitrile is and was at the time of the casualty classified ©

under pertinent Coast Guard regulations as a Grade C

flammable liquid (46 -C.F.R. 146.21-100), as is gas-

oline, benzine, naphtha, etc. It is not classified as an

‘extremely dangerous poison’, nor as a ‘less dangerous

poison’ (46 C.F.R. 146.25-5; 146.25-10).”-(R. 5124)

+ + *

' “26... . The impact was not severe, and injured

no one. It was hardly felt in some portions of the two

vessels. However, the bow of UNION RELIANCE

. breached the No. 1 port tank of BEREAN, causing

its acrylonitrile-cargo-to. become ignited and to ex-

plode. Quantities of the burning: liquid were thrown

upon the foredeck of UNION RELIANCE which

in turn was ignited. The vessel continued to burn for

several days, as noted above, and she: became a con-

‘structive total: loss, iene

“27. As a result of the fire caused by the collision,

Houston Ship Channel Pilot Duncan and the following

crew-members of UNION RELIANCE were killed:

Lan Jing-chau, Chen Teh-Yao, Wu Hsing-Rei, Wu

Shih-Ming, Pao Fuh-Gen, Huang. Ah-Tong, Hu Ah-

Wang, Ting Chea-Fah,- Yuan Sing-Wang, Hsia Lian-.

Yen, and Koo Kuang-Yan; and the following were

injured: Hau Wen-Tsai and Mang Han,Ying. In ad- |

dition, much of the cargo of the UNION RELIANCE

(principally that in the forward holds of the vessel)

was lost, as well as the personal effects of the crew.”

~ (R. 5130) . a

——

“s - 2 »®#

ee eee oe - pthnen mot Se et man ee tn a oe a eaialieg “ sth BS Se pe ade. PO OR cE OE BRO Aas

32

“40, BEREAN was not at fault in carrying acry-

lonitrile cargo in her forward tanks. She violated no

_ . Coast Guard regulation by doing so, and I find this

995

was not a negligent. or careless manner of loading.”

| * *

Conclusions of Law

+ + :

7 “4. The only Sule of the BEREAN having been

one which did not and, under the circumstances, could

not have contributed to the collision, A/S Andersen

& Co., and the BEREAN in rem are not liable to any as

of the libelants who have made claims against them,

and are exonerated and freed of liability in these ac-

tioris.” (R. 5140) -

. c. Interlocutory Decree Determining oe

ee a + -

“ORDERED; “ADJUDGED and DECREED, in

Admireky No. 2006, libelant, China Union, Lines,

Ltd. recover nothing against’ respondent, A/S A. O.

Andersen & Co. and: the M/V BEREAN, and the

libel is dismissed with costs, and that A/S A. O. An- --

dersen. & Co., as cross-libelant therein, recover of and

from the M/V ‘UNION RELIANCE and cross-re-

spondent, China Union Lines, Ltd., the damages sus-

tained by it in consequence “of the matters referred

to in the cross-libel, and costs: It is, further,

+ + +

_ & “While petitioner offered evidence tending to show that a

greater safety factor would result if thére were inner lining

of the tank so that an air space was maintained between the

skin of the ship and the outer wall of the wing tanks, these

experts conceded that it was the custom and practice to carry

. gasoline and other inflammable and explosive liquids in tanks

immediately adjacent to the skin of the ship.” (R. 5136-5137)

% ‘ %

». 33

: “ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED that |

in Admiralty No. 2007; libelant, American Cyanamid

Company, shall recover of ‘and from . the M/V

UNION RELIANCE and her owner, China Union

Lines, Ltd., the damages sustained by libelant in con-

sequence of the matters referred to in. said libel,

gether with costs; and .the cross-libel filed: in a

miralty No. 2007, by China-Union Lines, Ltd. a

American Cyanamid Company i is dismissed with costs,

'_, and -any intervening libels or cross-libels against Ameri- |

can Cyanamid Company in any of the actions con-

solidated in Admirality No. 2018 are hereby- dismissed

with costs;” (R. 5149- -5150) |

2. Or THE Court OF ‘APPEALS

a. Opinion of the Court

Ly Ly +

CLAIM AGAINST CYANAMID

China Union and the Consul General complain of the

action of the judge in dismissing the libel against Cyanamid.

Aside from the subject discussed. under Assignment V,

the appellants pose two additional assignments against _

. Gyanamid: (1) the procedure on the dismissal, and , (2)

that Cyanamid had actual knowledge, or by the exercise

of reasonable diligence should have known, of the danger-

” ous, poisonous and lethal characteristics of acrylonitrile, of

which the Coast Guard and BEREAN had no: knowledge.

At the outeit, we must stress the grave doubts we-enter- -

tain on whether China Union has, standing to press these

assignments. The damage*to RELIANCE and its cargo was

caused by fire, not bythe poisonous or toxic qualities of

the chemical. Since , gasoline and other such products are

as flammable and explosive as acrylonitrile and since such

other — may be — carried in forward tanks,

: e

34

next to the skin of the ship, it would em that no causal.

‘relationship exists between the toxicity of that chemical

andthe fire damage to ‘China Union’s property, or its

Cargo.

(1) The first eolae is one‘ of prdcedure, iat iis

substance: The record shows that during the course of the

trial, the judge asked all parties.if all evidence, except as’

to damages, had. been presented against Cyanamid. After

- counsel for the respective parties indicated that they had

no additional evidence to offer against that company, its

_ proctor moved for a dismissal.’* Forty pages of the record

are devoted to a transcription of the arguments of the proc-

tors 0 in/ this motion. No claim was made that there was

additi Jaa evidence to offer on the subject, For that matter,

the. ‘precise issues raised on. this appeal were fully argued

to the judge. At the conclusion ‘of . the arguments, the

motion was taken under advisement and was not decided *

until the following morning, at which time the judge found

in favor of Cyanamid.” Obviously, the judge made*find-

"ings on the issues then before him. In the formal findings,

ee

19 “Mr. ‘Waesche: If Your Honor ones in that event we would

like to move to dismiss the action against American Cyanamid, on

the grounds that the libelants have failed, to establish a cause ae

action against them.” (R. haeaasad

20 “As to the motion of ‘American Cyanamid Company for judg-

ment at the conclusion of the petitioner’s case, I think the motion ©

is well taken and will be granted. As the manufacturer and shipper

of an. inherently dangerous commodity, I understand the law to

impose on them the duty to warn and advise others who may come’

in. contact with it of its dangerous propensities. I think the evi-

dence shows clearly here that that was done, that the carrier was

fully advised of the dangerous characteristics of the cargo, and

without deciding the question, but if there be any fault’in the way

- BEREAN was loaded, as to which tanks the cargo wads carried,

* and so forth, I consider that to be a“fault of the vessel and of.

Andersen, and not of the shipper.” (R.3454.) :

>

the judge made it clear that io was passing on the issue

. of the liability." We must view this record as the findings

of the judge on the issues then presented. Those findings,

unless clearly erroneous, even though informal, are bind-.

ing on, us.. Myles v. Quinn Menhadden Fisheries, 302 F. 2d °

146 (5th Cir. 1962). The fact that the findings were made

On a motion for dismissal, or for a directed verdict, as

argued by one of appellants, is of no significance.

(2) On the motion for dismissal, the proctor for Cyana-

mid argued that the evidence almost. conclusively demon- . .

strated that the Chinese crew men died or were injured

as a result of the raging fire, on the water and on the

RELIANCE. Proctor for the dead and injured seamen,

on the other hand, argued that the men died from, or —

_ were injured -by, the toxic and poisonous effects of the

chemical. Cyanamid. pointed to the evidence of a young

lieutenant of the Coast Guard who testified that he and

his men worked right at the hatch where the particular

cargo’ was loaded, and from ‘there fought the fire with

no ill effects. A number of the members of the crew of

‘the BEREAN testified that they went forward and fought

the fire with no ill effects. The master of the tug boat said

that he was in there fighting the fire. Members of the

crew of RELIANCE were on the foredeck fighting the

fire. Most of the ‘photographs of decedents, with one ex-

ception, disclose faces and bodies that were “badly charred.”

21 . At the close of petitioner’s case, the Court afforded all

‘uidiion an opportunity to introduce evidence bearing on the issue

_. Of the Hability of Ame rican \Cyanamid Company; and was advised —

by all. counsel that the claim against American Cyanamid rested

solely on the evidence produced by: petitioner. The Court was of .

the view that petitioner had failed to show a cause of action

against American Cyanamid on behalf of UNION RELIANCE, cher

cargo interests, or others, and dismissed the libels against the

atl ” (Emphasis supplied.) (R. —

36

The one major exception was the picture of a| Chinese.

second mate, who evidently died in the cabin deck wash- ,

room. He was not burned, nor was there anything else

observed. which pointed to the cause of his death. The

photograph in eVidence, and the testimony shows, that the

pilot Duncan was burned beyond recognition.

‘In support of his, position, proctor for the injured and

decedents, called attention to th¢ unburned body of the

‘second mate that was found in the washroom, the body of ~

the oiler-wiper who was found above the main deck and .

who was not “burned too seriously,” and tq the testimony

of the funeral director that he examined five bodies which

" were recovered in Galveston Bay, over one week after the

casualty. He testified that he did not find burns “to. any

noticeable degree.” These bodies were puffed and swollen +

‘to stich an extent that examination was difficult. The un-

dertaker. thought that the death of each of these men was .

caused by drowning. care

Even the death eae ae do not support the. ‘theory:

_ that death could have been caused by the toxic or poisonous °

effects of the chemical under observation. Five of the

certificates gave the cause of death as: “drowning, due to

jumping overboard”; five of the certificates gave the cause.

_ of death as “suffocation, 2nd &. 3rd degree burns,” and

one certificate gave the cause of death as “septisemia, due

_ to major thermal body burns.” Even as to the decedents —

whose deaths were attributed to drowning, the funeral

at director conceded that there were burns on the bodies. ae

‘In any “event, both in the testimony and on the argu-

ment, the theory of the Consul General was fully presented

to, and explored by, the able trial judge. After analyzing

all of the evidence, he found that the deaths and personal .

«™

fo 37 - : .

injuries were cused s fire.”? While this specific finding -

was not made at the»time of ruling on: Cyanamid’s motion

for dismissal, no additiorial evidence was produced on the

subject, For that matter, ‘the final dismissal as to Cyana-

mid is 2 part of the main interlocutory. decree, from which —

this a is prosecuted. This dismissal, of. course, . was

entered. yee the entry of the findings and conclusions.

Therefore, Cyanamid i is entitled to the benefit of each find- —

ing on which. the decree is based. ra

If... in fact, it could be said that ‘hi judge failed to

make a finding on the issue of the cause of death or in-

juries, nevertheless, the burden of ‘proof on that issue was

on the Consul .General. Consequently, all facts not. em-—

- braced in the specific findings should be regarded as not

proved by the party having the burden of proof. Shapiro -

v. Rubens, 166 F.2d 659 (7th Cir. 1948) ; Container Patents

Corp. v. Stant, 143 F.2d 170 (7th Cir. 1944), cert. denied

323 U.S. 734, Appellant had a right to seck a nce find-

ing if -he so desired. |

Any other. finding by the iudge, on’ the record before

him, would be based on pure speculation’ and guess work.

- This is conceded by Dr. Brieger, the principal witness

for China Union and its dead and injured crew members,

who testified that an autopsy would be required before even

an expert could express an ation on whether any: one of

¥

22. “Asa renuit of the fire caused by the collision, Houstdn Ship

Channel Pilot Duncan and the following crew members of UNION

RELIANCE were killed: Lan Jing-Chau, Chen Teh-Yao, Wu Hsing: °

Rei, Wu Shih-Ming, Pao Fuh-Gen, Huang Ah-Tong, Hu Ah-Wang _

Ting Chea-Fah, Yuan Sirig-Wang, Hsia Lian-Ken, and Koo Kuang-

Yan; and the following were injured: Hau Wen-Tsai and Mang

Han-Ying. In addition, much of the, cargo of the UNION RELI-

ANCE (principally that in the forward holds of the vessel) was

lost, as_ well as the segeriaree effects af the crew.” (R. 5130.)

>.

Cyeese p

cae Seedy,

38 ot

these men died from exposure to acrylonitrile.2*> With the

opinion in the record, a trial judge could/arrive at no con-

clusion other than that the Consul Ge eral had failed in

his burden of showing that death or injury was caused |

from. the toxic effects of the acrylonitrile.

Completely disregarding the effect Vf.the controlling

finding that fire was the cause. of the deaths and personal

_ injuries, both China Union andthe Consul General again

point to testimony indicating a practice in the chemical

industry to construct cofferdam space around t4nks in. which

dangerous chemicals are to be transported and that, one of

the purposes of such construction was to prevent the escape

of such chemicals in the event of a collision. Other testi-

\\ moriy indicates that it was a common practice in the in-

~\ aon to carry dangerous chemicals away from the skin

of the ship. Doctor Brieger testified ‘that sufficient bodily

contact with acrylonitrile would, in his opinion, cause .

_ death by ingestion or by inhalation of its fumes. He, like~

wise, opined -that acrylonitrile was much more poisonous

than a five percent dilution of hydrocyanic acid: which, by

Coast Guard Regulations, was classified, for transportation

purposes, as a Class B poison. He thought that the state-

‘ment in Cyanamid’s literature. that acrylonitrile produces

symptoms “‘similar to those produced - hydrogen cyanide”

23 “An autopsy would show whether re man, in addition to the

effect of the fire, has’ absorbed large quantities of acrylonitrile,

~ which, as [ have told, will be converted into cyanide, a very easy

affair; it can be shown with a spectrophotometer and otherwise; °

and if such an autopsy is made, ° one can state whether this indi- -

vidual had absorbed such quantities of acrylonitrile that they in

themselves would have killed this man. But this can only be

“ done—such a statement can only be made if a proper autopsy has

been made, or if the blood is bright red; that’s a much simpler

. method. It would indicate. that the man has indeed absorbed very

large quantities or large quantitie#,of acrylonitrile;- with the con-

secutive deve}épment of cyanide.” (Emphasis supplied.) (R:2129.)

: . ‘ 4 * :

‘ ; *%

?

39

was incorrect._His thought was that the symptoms were

- precisely the same, but this is a mere play in words, and

not of substance. He also believed that if rat tests had

been made by the Coast Guard with the chemical, it prob- -

ably would have been classified in a Class B category as

toxic or poisonous in nature, The judge was not bound to

accept and apply these opinions, He was only bound. to

give to them such weight as. he thought they deserved and

he was at liberty to entirely reject them if he felt that

the reasons given in support thereof were unsound. This

rule is applicable to a trial judge, as well as a trial jury.

Sartor. v. Arkansas Gas Corp., 321 U.S: 620, 627-628

(1944). Also, the judge had the opportunity to see and

hear the witness and pass on his credibility. |

Beyond that, the printed record of this witness’ testi-

mony presents a portrait of considerable doubt on his part

as to whether the Coast Guard, in fact, wrongfully. classified

the chemical.- In its final analysis, this witness’ testimony

does not require a finding that Cyanamid knew, or by the

exercise of reasonable diligence should have known, that

the Coast Guard classification of the chemical was’ in error.

Of significance, though not controlling, is. the fact that

the casualty occurred in November, 1961. There was an

immediate Coast Guard investigation. The classification of

acrylonitrile has been reviewed by the Coast Guard on. at

least three occasions™ since the casualty and remains in

the. same. classification. The legal principles applied in

Whorton v. T. A. Loving & Co.,, 344 F.2d 739 (4th: Cir.

1965); are sound, but the faétual background there dis-

cussed. is so far removed from ours that such principles

almensieee § « . Ae ,

24 (1) 46 C.F.R. § 146.21-100, p. 172, § 146.25-200, p. 495:694; (2) ‘46

_C.F.R. § 146.10-100, p. 20, § 146.25-200,° p. 220-256; (3) Federal Regis- °

ter, December 24, 1964, Vol. 29, No. 248, pp. 18163-18168. '

40

cannot ‘be here applied. For the purpose of this opinion,

we have assumed that liability would attach to Cyanamid

if the evidence disclosed a breach of Guty, tortious or con-

_ traétual,

Aside from everything else, it would :appear that the

proximate cause of death of and injuries to the seamen,

and for that matter all other damages, was not the inherent

nature of acrylonitrile, nor any lack of care in its manufac-

ture, nor in giving notice of its toxic or poisonous qualities, °

nor its stowage location on the ship, but was the unanti-

cipated wrongful action of the RELIANCE in crossing to

the wrong side of the channel and propelling its ax like ©

_ bow. against, and substantially through the tank in which |

| the chemical was stowed. The remarkably clear * pictures

in evidence demonstrate that the RELIANCE ruptured the

skin of the BEREAN and advanced irito. the hull to a depth

of approximately 14 feet. Obviously, the inside skin of a~

cofferdam would have been ruptured and such a dam: would »

not have prevented’ the escape’ of the chemical. Under the

weight. of this assault, a cofferdam would have p ovided

no more protection that would a sheet of tissue paper.

b. . _ Dissenting Opinion of Judge Brown.

; BROWN, Circuit Judge, concurring in part and dissenting

in part:

I concur fully in all of. the very excdilent opinion pre-"

pared for the Court by Judge Kilkenny except as to. some

portions in the section entitled “Assignment V” as-to which .

I have some reservations and that ‘part entitled ‘Claim

Against Cyanamid” which I believe to be erroneous. As to

the latter I dissent. My. difference would not charige the:

result as between BEREAN and RELIANCE, between RE-

At

41

LIANCE’S Cargo and RELIANCE, between -the injured/

decedents and RELIANCE and her owners, or. the denial of

relief as to injufed/decedents against BEREAN, It would

afford RELIANCE and the injured/deceased victims: the

. right to show that damages and injuries were caused or ag-

gravated by Cyanamid’s neglect of its duties, To this extent

and for this purpose, I believe the case should be reversed

and remanded.

* + As to “Assignment V.,” I accept the: proposition that a

shipowner is entitled to’ rely on the classification of the ma-

terial and the stowage ee gre prescribed by the regu-

latory agency, here the Coast Guard. There may, however,

come a time when a carrier acquires so much knowledge |

about the peculiar characteristics of a. particular cargo,

which are not generally known, that it can no longer rely

solely on the insulation afforded by reading and applying

Coast Guard regulations which it knows in fact are either

_ wrong or incomplete. The aim of the regulations, the aim

of the law, is to promote safety, especially to the innocent

‘third parties—crew members, longshoremen, persons on

_ other vessels, members of the public, and others—who are

likely to be exposed to the hazards of the product in its

normal course of distribution, transportation, and handling.

That aim’ is hardly achieved by an absolute which declares

that a shipowner may: ignore hazards not disclosed by the —

Regulations, but of which it knows and knows how to

minimize by prudence. This is a long way from making

every shipowner his own chemist, physicist, physical chem-

ist, or. the like in this day of scientific marvels and new

esoteric products. 3

But Cyanamid is in no such favored position. -It is the

manufacturer and supplier of a chemical that it knows can

OE OET STR i a ake i =

No LAS IT RTE EL SH ai il hs tag nae era wad

be

&

and does kill. Cyanamid’s awesome obligations in this day

of products ljability when Acrylonitrile goes to sea is no

less than on land. It cannot’ rely on—and the proof does

not even bégin remotely to suggest that it ever did, or

would, rely on—the Coast Guard. Cyariamid knows that if

it—a huge industrial enterprise which proudly claims:a pre-

eminence in this chemical field—relied on the Coast Guard:

with its limited laboratory facilities for its research and

development, it would go bankrupt. The Coast Guard

might comeé to it, but it would never, simply never, go to

‘the Coast Guard to ascertairi what the characteristics and

hazards of its own product are.

So while the law affords to BEREAN the right to accept

a faulty Coast Guard classification, Cyanamid can claim

“no such privilege. Its own published pamphlet entitléd

“Handling-Storage-Analysis of Acrylonitrile,” introduced as

an exhibit and to which the Court’s opinion: refers, makes

it clear that it was, as Dr. Brieger testified, no less toxic

than a Class B poison since it was more toxic than the test

7

standard 5% dilution of hydrocyanic acid: Dr. Brieger had _

preeminent qualifications . which Cyanamid never chal- |

lenged—indeed could not challenge.” If, as the Court sug-

gests, his testimony was guarded, occesiclfally hesitant, it

was, as the quoted reference to autopsies (see note 23) re-

veals, just another clear proof of his scientific competence.

Time and time again, he made plain, based upon a lifetime

. study and industrial experience with this very compound,.

at for seamen to be afloat in water having a film of

Acrylonitrile on the surface would mean almost certain

- Dr. Brieger had made tests and reports on it sane

aa were submitted to Cyanamid.

82 In the collision, No. 1 port wing tank was ruptured. All

of the 226 tons of Acrylonitrile spilled out into the channel.

43:

-

-o. death:** ‘And dies is what Cyanamid’ s Own pamphlet. re-

flected i a vivid terms." 7

83 Ironically the soldi reveals that about a year after ‘this

collision, the Master of BEREAN was killed by Acrylonitrile

fumes resulting from a very small leak in. the pump room. —

No one, certainly not Cyanamid, suggests that this post-

collision event was‘an untoward surpriséto those ina

able about Acrylonitrile.

84 As to handling the chemical, Cyanamid explains:

“The precautions set forth in this bulletin are the

results of the “experience gained in handling and

Storing Acrylonitrile during ‘this period. It should

be emphasized at the outset, that -because of the

toxic and flammable nature of: Acrylonitrile, handling.

operations should be performed in areas which are

properly ventilated and free from sources of igni-

tion.”

As to cleaning tanks in which Acrylonitrile has been

stored, Cyanamid warns:

“Protective equipment should be made available to

¢ -. those entering) [storage] tanks. This equipment should

include cover-alls, eye goggles, and gas masks. * * *

The person working in the tank slould- be provided

with a body harness with life line attached. Station a

man on the outside end of the life line to do nothing

but watch the worker within.” |

And the type of gas-mask required differs with the concentra-

tion of the chemical’s vapors: —

- “Use this type of canister (organic vapor) only in

' locations where Acrylonitrile vapor content is -less

than 2% and the oxygen concentration is above 16%.

Otherwise a mask with self contained oxygen or air

supply .must be employed.” [Emphasis in original]

Cyanamid is the last to minimize the effects ‘ol the chemical

.on the human body:

. “Acrylonitrile is toxic by inhalation, ‘tw. absorption

*. -through the skin, and by oral ‘ingestion.

ie e *

“Poisoning by Acrylonitrile produces iaeniain which

. are similar to those produced by hydrogen cyanide. Exces-

sive vapor inhalation causes weakness, headache, sneezing,

abdominal pain, and vomiting. Absorption of large amounts

of the liquid through the skin produces similar a.

ee”

DW deg? Se AR ES I Pah gx

Nr Lea RIA A Og ALAN hall ait: Ake SE RNR acerea aps MoS

ale academe

Jed Da.

44..

The question is not whether BEREAN was at fault in

1

nal knowing also that the cargo was going into skin tanks.

In this respect,;Cyanamid had duties that transcended those

it owed to Andersen or- BEREAN and which, the Court

supposes, it perhaps satisfied by showing the Master the blue

pamphlet. It owed a duty literally to the world—at least

And in describing the proper methods of waste disposal, the

manufacturer warns of the danger to fish:

“Acrylonitrile stream effluents should be treated to such an

extent that they pose no danger to downstream public

water supplies or to aquatic life. *°* * Although it has

. been demonstrated that fresh-water fish can tolerate an

_ Acrylonitrile level of 10 p.p.m., the actual tolerable limit

will depend on local conditions and use of streams.”

And if that “aquatic life” happens to be seamen afloat, who

will both absorb and breath vapors, “the currently accepted

threshold limit for * * * an eight-hour exposure is 20 parts of —

vapor per million parts of air,” which makes. it more toxic

than carbon tetra ,chloride (25 p.p.m.) but:only slightly less

toxic than hydrogen cyanide (10 p.p.m.) Nevertheless, the

chemical is toxic enough so that “the regimen of treatment

. [by.a physician]; recommended for Acrylonitrile jeans is

that for cyanide poisoning. re

In several places and ways the pamphlet equates Acryloni-

trile with Hydrogen Cyanide (Hydrocyanic Acid). is is a

Class A poison, § 146.25-5, defined as “poisonous gases of liquids .

of ‘such nature that a very small amount of gas, or liquid,

mixed with air is dangerous to life.” As such it is listed with

only 13 other poisons, three of which are military poisonous

gases. And footnote 1 to Hydrocyanic Acid ‘permits dilute.

solutions not exceeding 5% strength to be classed as Class B

poisons. Class B covers “Poisonous liquids or solids * * * other

/. than Class A, C or D poisons, which are known to be so toxic

k to man as to afford a hazard to health durifig transportation.”

§ 146.25-10. Rat and rabbit ingestion, absorption and inhalation

_ test standards are thereafter prescribed. There is no evidence

to refute -Dr. Brieger’s testimony that Acrylonitrile would fail |

aaa tests.

,

loading Acrylonitrile in skin tanks unprotected” by coffer=- ~— ee

dams. The question is whether Cyanamid knowing what . a

: does, could’ knowingly load BEREAN at Cyanamid’s termi-

me)

OOP Tt mes

45 . le :

that world -within the reach and protection of American

jurisprudence, land-based, salt water and amphibious, It had

to have in mind port workers at the place of loading, crew

_ «Members on the carrying vessel, crew menabers on acces-.

- sorial tugs, owners and crew’members of vessels with which

the carrying yessel might come in contact by collision or

otherwise, port’ officials, customs inspectors, immigration

officers, maritime service personel, aid members of the pub-

lic, The duties owed to this limitless group of protectees

“require as a minimum that it not knowingly participate in

_a method of handling or transport which would imprudent-

ly imperil the lives.of these people. I do not suggest here

that Cyanamid, the manufacturer-supplier-shipper, has the

liability of an insurer, but it certainly has the far-reaching

awesome liabilities now associated with products liability.

Putman, v. Erie City ‘Mfg. Co., 5 Cir., 1964, 338 F.2d 911,

Restatement, Torts §388, When the material is fraught with

so much danger, the liabilities may be almost absolute either

because the so-called ordinary care of the prudent person

itself calls for care which is extraordinary or because of

principles of strict liability. Indeed, this teaching of Texas

City was not lost to the industrial or judicial world because

- the Government as the manufacturer of FGAN escaped

liability from the ‘peculiar governmental “discretionary —

function” exemption, Dalehite v. United States, 1953, 346

U.S. 15, 73 S.Ct. 956, 97 L.Ed. 1427,.... AMC...., or

the stringent limitation. of the scope of the FTCA to ex-

clude “novel and unprecedented” cases, a reading which ~

was shortly to be ‘Pepudiated. Rayonier v. United States,

—- : 1957, 352 U.S. 315, 319, 77 S.Ct. 374, 1 L.Ed.2d 354.

But the trial Judge never really faced up ‘to: this issue.

Nor does this Court, Rather, each equates Cyanamid’s ob-

ligations with those the carrying yessel BEREAN owed to

gobi ds icecih SS LAI

as: a

others. As to the BEREAN, the Coast Guard regulations, so

long as BEREAN did.not know they were faulty, were an

adequate insulation. But-in relation to members of the pub-

lic and others, Cyanamid could not fall back on the Coast

Guard. The problem was really not whether the Coast

. Guard classification was in error, as. Dr. Brieger tried to

demonstrate. Rather, it was what Cyanamid actually knew

and ought to have known about its own: product and know-

ing that, what in prudence considering these extremely °°

high hazards could and ought to be done to minimize,” if

net eliminate, the devastating consequences of. a foreseeable

This was a basic error in approach by the District Judge.

nd our efforts to overcome the deficiency by questioning. -

\ th ding of China Union to assert the claim and to hold

- \as a matter of law that there could be no proof of causation

as to the claims of the injured/deceased will not suffice. We

must. recall that this ‘case, as are all extensive maritime ca-

tastrophes, was being tried in two stages—liability and

damages. This is the first time, to my knowledge, for ex-

ample, in which death certificates, issued generally in Texas

by people whose only competence is the lowest. office in the

judicial hierarchy—prove the cause of death..I agree the

issue has not been proved. No more so was the damages

sustained by BEREAN or its cargo. That is to come later.

As to China Unions’ standing, at the liability phase only, -

who is to say that had the fumes from this lethal cargo not |

have been: freed by rupture of the hull forming: the tank |

sides, the action on RELIANCE might not have oe differ-

ent?

35 BEREAN had. main tones 1 through 8 divided by longi-

tudinal bulkheads affording a series: of 16 inboard tanks fully

separated from the ship’s hull by wing tanks on each, port . .

and starboard, side. . ,

Oo eee 47 |

_ On this record, the Judge should have held that as against

Cyanamid a prima facie case had been made out. Cyanamid

should have been put to its proof to refute, if it could, the

_ hazardous characteristics, and on what prudénce would re-

quire of the manufacturer-supplier-shipper of a product of

such deadly potential. 8° The Judge would then have decided

_ whgther Cyanamid had the usual land-based products li-

ability of a chemical manufacturer. If he declared in the —

affirmative, proof of damages, if any—and I do not mini- ‘

mize the if’ any—would be opened for a second stage on

damages.

The admiralty has led, not fallowed. But here salt water

dilutes.the responsibility now so plainly resting on the

manufacturer-supplier-shipper of a commercially useful, in-

deed valuable, chemical compound which carries death with

‘its utility. . | ;

I would hasten reverse for forties liehting 4 as appropri-

ate on the claims of RELIANCE and her owners, and the

injured /decedents against Cyanamid.

86 §=Indeed at this point the’ Coast Guard regulations might

turn on Cyanamid to prescribe an absolute standard. Cf. Lael

shall v. Isthmian Lines, Inc., 5 Cir., 1964, 344 F.2d 131, :

AMC . .. If, as Dr. Brieger so stoutly maintained, the ‘rat

* tests prescribed by § 146.25-10(1)(2) (see note 34, supra) would

bring Acrylonitrile within Class B poisons, then it is undis-

puted that for a combustible liquid having lethal character-

‘istics and defined as a Class B or Class C poison, such cargo’

must be carried in tanks whjch are independent of the ship’s

hull, separated by cofferdams, etc. 46 C.F.R. § 39.01-1, .05-1. The

significance of such tests would not-be to establish that classi-

fying Acrylonitrile as inflammable by the Coast Guard -was

erroneous as such. Rather, since a manufactufér knows what .

accepted tests would. reveal, the significance would be to for-

bid the manufacturer as shipper to tender it for shipment.

without disclosing all ‘these characteristics and to knowingly

participate in a loading or shipment which, with such knowl .

edge, it knows to be dangerous. Cf. 46 USCA § 170(10).

oo"

Es,

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.