Appendix — Bear Sales Co. v. Federal Trade Commission
Supreme Court brief1966
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
APPENDIX A.
ee
BEForE Fevers TRADE Comasston. |
17% CCngtion:--027) Sass cage
“IN ITIAL DECISION. |
By William L. Pack, Hearing Examiner. ° :
Thomas J. Whitehead, for the Commission. is
7 Charles H. Rowan “a Willis Hagen, Milwaukee, Wis-
consin, for the Respondents.
Respondents are charged in the Coiienninaitionn' s panna ‘
with the use of lottery methods in the sale and distribution
of their merchandise, in violation of the Federal Trade. .
Commission Act. After the filing of respondents’ answer
to the complaint, a hearing was held at which evidence both
in support of and in opposition to the complaint was intro-
duced. Proposed findings and’ conclusions have been sub-
mitted by counsel for the parties, oral argument before the
hearing examiner having been waived. The case is now
before the examiner for final consideration. Any proposed,
findings or cenclusions not included herein have been re- -
jected as not material or as not warranted by the —
or the applicable law.
Respondent Bear Sales Co. is an Illinois corporation |
with its principal office and place of business at se! North -~
Wabash Avenue, Chicago, Illinois.
Respondent E. Robert Baer is an officer of the corporate |
respondent, and formulates, directs and controls its acts
and practices. His address is the same as that of the cor-
poration. |
»
4
Respondents are engaged inthe. sale and distribution,
through others, of numerous articles of merchandise to the _
public.
In the course and conduct of their business respondents
are engaged in interstate commerce within the meaning of’
the Federal Trade Commission Act. Not’only is their mer-
chandise sold and shipped. to purchasers residing in states
of the United States other than Illinois, but respondents’
advertising and sales literature, order forms, and the al-
leged lottery devices ‘are also mailed from respondents’
place of business to numerous members of the public lo-
cated in states other than Illinois (CX 1A-B; Tr. a 31;
_ 85-40).
Respondents’ method of selling and distributing their.
merchandise is to send to members of the public advertising
and sales literature, order blanks, and a device commonly
_ called a push. card. One of these-cards, which is typical “of
those used by respondents, involves the sale of an electric
-broiler-toaster. The card has forty-five partially perfo-
rated discs, each of which bears a masculine or feminine
name. Under each disc is a number which determines the
amount to be paid by persons punching the dises. For ex-
ample, the person punching the disc which has under it the
- number twelve pays twelve cents. The numbers are effec. .
tively concealed until the disc has been. punched or sep-
_ arated from the card.
* The card also contains a master seal under which is con-
_ cealed a name corresponding to one of the names on the
discs. When all of the discs-have been punched, the master.
seal is removed and the person who has punched the dise
bearing the name corresponding to that under the master
seal wins the broiler-toaster (CX 3E).
Thus the amount to be paid and whether persons ‘‘play-
ing’’ the card receive the broiler-toaster or nothing for the
<
)
* 85
_ amounts paid are determined wholly by lot or chance.
The broiler-toaster has a yalue greatly in excess of the
amount paid by any of the persons playing the card.
The operator of the card (member of the public to whom
’ respondents have sent the card) sells the chances on the
card among his friends and acquaintances. After all of the
chances have been sold and the money collected, the opera-
tor remits the total amount to respondents and respondents
ship to the operator two of the broiler-toasters, one to be
delivered by the-operator to the person punching the lucky —_—
dise and the other to be retained by the operator as com-
pensation for his services. 3
In the circular letter which respondents send to membérs
of the public along with the push card, the sales method is-
set forth as follows:° = - . Se
‘‘Show the enclosed card to all your acquaintances.
_ Explain to them that they can-win a genuine Continen-
tal Broiler-Toaster, guaranteed for 1 year, for as little
as 1¢ just by taking a punch on the card. You see,
under each of the names is a number. - No. 1 pays 1¢,
No. 6 pays 6¢, No. 12 pays 12¢, No. 14, pays 14¢, and
No. 19 pays 19¢. But regardless of how high the num-
ber goes nobody pays a single penny more than 39¢. ‘
‘*Then, when all the names are punched out you lift
the big seal and the person with the name under the
big seal—even if they paid only 1¢—wins a’ deluxe ;
Broiler-Toaster. And you’ve got yours almost as a:
gift! ; ee )
‘‘What’s more. The persons who get the numbers
3, 13 and 17 pay nothing. and even they can win the’
_ Broiler-Toaster, too.’’ (CX 3A) - cos ;
- The sales method clearly involves and contemplates a
_ lottery.” Respondents thus: supply to and place in the Hfnds ©
of members of the public lottery devices to be used in the
sale and distribution of respondents’ merchandise. ’
Respondents do not deny that their sales method involves
36
the use of a lottery. Their defense is that their ‘‘ practices
are not inconsistent with:the standards of fair dealing of
contemporary * business practices and public behavioral
norms and are therefore not in violation of Section 5 of
-* the Federal Trade Commission Act.”’ (Respondents’ An-
“swer to Complaint.) - cs ;
In support of this defense respondents point out that
* during comparatively recent years a number of the states
‘in the United States have ‘enacted laws permitting Bingo
games,-raffles, pari-mutuel betting | on horse races, etc. ; that
there is now a state-operated lottery in New Hampehire.
_ Respondents also showed, through the testimony of.an ex-
pert’ witness, a professor of marketing at the University of
“ WiSeonsin at Milwaukee, and through documentary exhibits -
introduced through tlie | witness’ testimony, that a number
of the. country’s major and reputable business concerns
\ employ games, contests, and-various methods in which there
is an element of chance, i in advertising and marketing their
an products. ‘Such methods, according to the witness, appeal
to the publie’ s curiosity, to its needs and desires. for amuse-
ment, novelty; ete. (Tr. 54-110; RXs 1-15.)
In summary, respondents’ position appears to be that
whatever may have been the situation in the ‘past, the use
_of lotteries. and games of chance in the sale of merchandise
is not now in contravention of public policy and therefore
_ 4s not in Violation of the Federal Trade Commission Act.
The contention must be rejected. Insofar as the state
statutes aré “concerned, they merely provide exceptions to
the general. rule against gambling. As. for the games, con-
_tests and_other methods used by major business concerns,
it is obvious that most of.them do not constitute lotteries.
If any of them are in fact lotteries, their’ use is insufficient
to show a change in public policy. |
Since. the decision in Federal Trade Commission v.
37
Keppel, 291 U. S. 304*(1934) innumerable decisions have
held that the sale of merchandise by lottery means is. in
contravention of public policy and an unfair practice within
the meaning of the Federal Trade Commission Act. A
very recent case, which would. appear to be decisive of the
issue here, is Dandy Products, Inc. v. Federal Trade Com- ..
mission, 332 F'. 24-985 (1964). Referring to a contention
made there which is very similar to, if not identical with,
the contention made here, the United States Court of
Appeals for the Seventh Circuit said:
‘*Without agreejng that morals are’ relative, as peti-
tioners argue, we have considered petitioners’ argu- -
- ments that there are many contests, involving prizes,
used by major companies; that in some states gambling
_ is permitted and in others punchboards are held not to |
* be gambling equipment; that gambling is not immoral
per se, and is involved in stock brokerage and other
businesses; and that a gambling ‘instinct’ seems tobe
a weakness in human natute. All these arguments
were addressed to the Commission below, and in one
degree or another’have been addressed to this court,
without. success, in Wren Sales, Peerless and Modern-
istic Candies. We are not persuaded that this mer-
.. ¢handising practice is less an ‘unfair method of com-
petition’ today than it was in the time of K eppel.’’
It it concluded that respondents’ practice constitutes an
unfair practice in commeree in violation of the Federal
Trade Commission Act and is to the prejudice of the public.
The present proceeding is in the public interest. |
% |
-
38
‘Order. :
Ir 1s ORDERED that respondent Bear Sales Co., a corpora-
tion, and its officers, and respondent E. Robert Baer; indi-
vidually and as an officer of said, corporation, and respond-
ents’ representatives, agents and employees, directly ‘or
through any corporate or other device, in connection with
the offering for sale, sale, or distribution of any merchan-
dise in commerce, as ‘‘commerce’’ is defined in the Federal
Trade Commission Act, do forthwith cease and desist from:
1. Supplying to or placing i in the hands of others, push
cards or.any other device designed ox,intended to
be used in thé sale or distribution of Merchandise
‘to the public by means of a game of = gift
enterprise, or lottery scheme.
- 2. Selling or otherwise disposing of any merchandise
by means of a game of chance, gift enterprise, or
lottery scheme.
Win L. Pack,
Hearing Examiner.
January 25, 1965. |
a
389
APPENDIX B.
Berore Feperau Trape Commission. - ~
_ * * (Caption—8627)' * *
Commissioners:
Paul Rand Dixon, Chairman
Philip Elman ,
Everette MacIntyre |
John R. Reilly
Mary Gardiner Jones
FINAL ORDER.
Respondents and counsel in support of the complaint
having filed cross appeals from the initial decision of the
hearing examiner, and the matter having been heard on
briefs and oral argument; and the Commission having ren-
dered its decision denying respondents’ appeal and grant-—
ing the appeal of counsel ‘Supporting the complaint and
directing modification of the initial decision: .
Ir 1s orpErED that the following order be, and it hereby
is, substituted for the order contained in the initial decision:
Ir 1s orperep that respondent Bear Sales Co., a cor- -
poration, and its officers, and respondent E. Robert
‘Baer, individually and as an officer of said corporation,
and respondents’ representatives, agents and employ-
ees, directly or through any corporate or other device,
in connection with the offering for sale, sale, or distri-
bution of any merchandise in commerce, as ‘‘com-
merce’’ is defined in the Federal Trade Commission.
Act, do forthwith cease and desist from:
¢ 40
.. Supplying to or placing in the hands of others, push
_ eards or any other device designed or intended to
be used in the sale or distribution of merchandise
to the public by means of a game of chance, gift
enterprise, lottery scheme, chance, or gaming device.
‘2. Selling or otherwise dipsosing of any merchandise
by means of a game of chance,” gift enterprie, lot- _
tery scheme, chance, or gaming device.
Ir 1s FURTHER ORDERED that the initial decision of the
hearing examiner, as modified, be, and it hereby i is, aii
as‘ the decision of the Commission.
Ir 1s FURTHER oRDERED that respondents shall, within
sixty (60) days after service upon them of this order, file
‘with the Commission a report, in writing, setting forth in
detail the manner and form in which they have complied’
with the order to cease and desist contained herein. :
By tHe Commission. Commissioner Elman dissents on
the ground that there is no ‘‘established public policy of
the United States’’ that requires the Commission to expend '
its limited resources on this kind of case.
JoserH W. Sue,
Secretary.
Issued: July 8, 1965. —
Berore Feperat, Trape Commission.
e * * (Caption—8627) * tu
. Commissioners : 7S
Paul Rand Dixon, Chairman
Philip Elman
_ Everette MacIntyre,
John R. Reilly
Mary Gardiner Jones
OPINION OF THE ‘COMMISSION.
Respondents have been charged with selling merchandise,
through others, by means of a lottery scheme, game of
_ chance or gift enterprise. The hearing examiner found
that the allegations of the complaint had been sustained
by the evidence and entered an order to cease and desist.
The matter is before the Commission on cross appeals.
Respondents contend that complaint counsel failed to
prove that the practice of selling merchandise by chance
is an unfair act or practice under Section 5 of the Federal
Trade Commission Act and further contend that this prac-
tice is not contrary to the established public policy of the
United States. Both of these arguments are rejected. Re-
spondents failed to demonstrate that the public’s -concern
with lotteries as evidénce by the various state and federal
laws dealing with lottery and related practices had changed
significantly to enable the Commission to conclude that
lotteries were no longer against public policy. . Similar at-
tempts to show a change in public policy have been rejected
by the Commission and the Courts. Dandy Products, Inc.
v. Federal Trade Commission, 332 F. 2d 985 (7th Cir. 1964),
Wren Sales Co. v. Federal Trade Commission, 296 F.2d 456 *
| 42
(7th Cir. 1961), Goldberg v. Federal Trade Commission,
283 F’. 2d 299 (7th Cir..1960) and Surf Sales Co. v. Federal
Trade Commission, 259 F. 2d 744 (7th Cir. 1958).
Counsel supporting the complaint appeals from the scope
of the examiner’s order, arguing that the order may not
apply to the practice of selling’merchandise by means of:
devices designed to appeal to the public gambling instinct
but which are not technically lotteries, i.e., do not include
all three elements of consideration, chance and prize. We
agree that this possibility exists. See J. C. Martin .Corpo-
ration v. Federal Trade Commission, 242° F. 2d 530 (7th
Cir. 1957) and J. C. Martin Corporation, et al., Docket No.
8520 (1964), aff’d ....... : F, 2d ....... (7th Cir. 1965). “The »
complaint specifically alleges that the sale of merchandise
in accordance with ‘respondents’ sales plans ‘‘also con-
stitutes the sale of merchandise by means of a chance or
' gaming device’’ and ‘the findings, of course, support this
_ allegation. Consequently, the order will be modified to
prohibit*respondents froni selling merchandise by means of
a chance or gaming device or placing in the hands of others
devices for this purpose.
- Respondents’ appeal is denied. The appeal of eine
supporting the complaint is —— Ar iat order
will be entered.
Commissioner Elman dissents on the ground that there
is no ‘‘established public policy of the United States”’ that
requires the Commission to expend its limited resources
~ on this kind of case.
July 8, 1965.
' APPENDIX C.
IN' THE
Unirep States Court or ApPEALs
For the Seventh Circuit.
September Session, 1965 — April Session, 1966.
No.15350 re
- Brar Sates Company, a corpora- an
tion and E. Roserr Barr, indi- | On. Petition to Re-
vidually and as an officer of said view and Set Aside
corporation,. > an Order of the
| | Petitioners, Federal Trade.
vs. Commission. _
Feperat Trape Commission,
Respondent. )
June 1, 1966.
Before Hastines, Chief Judge, and CastLE and Kiey,
Circuit Judges.
Per Curiam. This matter is before the Court upon the
petition of Bear Sales ‘Company, a corporation, and E.
Robert Baer, individually, to review an order issued by
the Federal Trade Commission. The order requires the
‘petitioners to cease and desist from selling or disposing
of merchandise by means of a game of chance, gift enter-
prise, lottery scheme, chance, or gaming device, and from
_ supplying to others devices designed to be so used. ~
44
The record establishes that petitioners are engaged in
a typical ‘‘push card’’ merchandising operation such as that
recently considered by this Court in Dandy Products, Inc.
v. Federal Trade Commission, 7 Cir., 332 F. 2d 985, and
found to:constitute an unfair method of competition which
violated the Federal Trade Commission Act. In Dandy
Products we rejected as unpersuasive the contention that
Federal, Trade Commission v. R. F. Keppel & Bro., Inc.,
291 U.S. 304, 54 S. Ct. 423, 78 L. Ed. 814; should no longer
be considered an authoritative precedent because of what
was represented to be ‘‘a change in the ‘moral’ climate of
the business community’’. We find equally unconvincing
petitioners’ attempt to now distinguish Dandy Products on ,
the basis that the prize contests ete. there alluded to as
furnishing the predicate for a change in the standards by
which to measure the fairness of merchandising methods
were not, as here, the subject matter of yom contained in
the record.
We adhere to our reliance upon K eppel and we regard
‘Dandy Products as dispositive of the refurbished | and
embellished contentions made by the petitioners.
The petition to set. aside, revise or remand the order of
‘the Commisison is denied ; the — is affirmed, and will
be enforced. -
| Orper AFFIRMED. ©
APPENDIX D.
Unirep Srates Courr or APPEALS ©
For the Seventh Circuit.
Chicago, Illinois 60604.
Thursday, June = 1966.
Before .
Hon. John S. iets Chief Indes
Hon. Latham Castle, Circuit Judge ae
Hon. Roger J. Kiley, Circuit. Judge
Bear Sates Company, et al., etc., ) ;
Petitioners, | Petition—forTéview
No. 15350 vs. ea 3 of an order of the
FrperaL Trape CommMiIssion, - Federal Trade
Respondent. } Commission.
Ir 1s orDERED by the Court that the petition for a re- —
hearing of this cause, filed by the petitioners herein, be
and the same is mane, DENIED.
APPENDIX E.
- Unrrep Srares Courr or APPEALS
For the Seventh Circuit.
Bear Saues: Company, a corpora->
.tion, and E. Robert Baer, indi-
vidually- and as an officer of said
corporation, Petition for review
‘of an order of the
Petitioners >
i ; ? Federal Trade
ace a Commission.
. FEDERAL TrapE ComMISSION, -
: 3 Respondent. ,
FINAL DECREE ENFORCING ORDER °
TO CEASE AND DESIST.
June 29, 1966.
The Federal-Trade Commission, heving issued an order
to cease and desist on July 8, 1965, against Bear Sales’
Company, a corporation, and HE. Robert Baer, individua
- and as an officer of said corporation, in a proceeding before
it entitled ‘‘In the Matter of Bear Sales Company, a corpo-
ration, and E. Robert Baer, individually and as an officer
of said corporation, Docket Number 8627,’’ and a petition
to set aside, revise or remand said order to cease and desist
having -been filed 1 in-this Court on September 8, 1965, and
the transcript of the entire record in the proceeding which
resulted i in the said order to cease and desist having een
certified and filed in this Corrt; and the matter having been -
heard by this Court on briefs and oral argument on May
18, 1966; and this Court having rendered its decision on °
Ps
“A true copy:
' (Seal)
47
June 1, 1966; and having, on the same date, entered its
order denying the said petition to set aside, revise or re-
mand, and affirming the said order of the Federal Trade
Commission :
Now THEREFORE, IT Is HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DE-
oREED that Bear Sales Company and KE. Robert. Baer be,
sand they hereby are, commanded forthwith to obey said .
“order of the Federal Trade Commission and to comply
therewith.
/s/ LatTHAaM Custiz,
United States Circuit Judge.
| '/8/ Rocrr J. Kitey,
- United States Circuit Sudge.
Teste: ’
Kenneta J. Carrick,
Clerk of the United States
Court of Appeals for the.
Seventh Circuit.
By H. K. McCormaon,
Deputy Clerk.’
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.