Opposition Brief — American Airlines, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board

Supreme Court brief1966

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

w

ee Opinions below- SEE VBI ON Nit ning

Jurisdiction PAS cud on > ARTE Paks

; Question, presented__.-£ Lin. 222 sel lcle

Statutes involveds----2---2 OOS

Ce | REE aceon ena :

Argument a a snedicepoe

Conclusion SRREREIMOT tar hae sete Ch, WE eam Oe ee

Cases:

F’, 2d 892, affirmed, 286 F. 2d 319, certi-

orari denied, gs § Ree

American Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics

Beard, TER F: BE Gah cccmcinciiedamactma

_ American Trucking: Associations v. United

States, 344 U B. Wb uancsimcccesacconcase

Capitol Airways Vv. Civil Aeronautics Board,

292 F. 2d 755---------=. RS SR on

Federal Power Commission v. Texaco, 377 |

UB. $B cenecccnssasccsrnvatcnnenh

National Broadcasting Co. v. U nited States,

B19 UB. TU .nccscncccnnquenesneanionn

United States v. Storer Broadcasting, 351

Statutes: ©

Administrative Procedure Act, 60 Stat. 237,

6 USA) I, 6 0Geicwnccncanamenacne

. &®

2290-857—66

Air Freight Case, 10 0. 2 5 Sean .

_ Air [ine Pilots Association v. Quesada, 276 |

a a wage

w :

Oo @ 8 © © & ow

. Statutes—Continued _

Federal Aviation Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 731,

49 U.S.C. 1301, et seq |

Section 102, 49 U.S.C. 1302-__---____ :

Section 204, 49 U.S.C. 1324.

Section. 401, 49 U.S.C. 1371

Section 403, 49 U.S.C. 1373.--_.--_--__

Section 416, 49 U.S.C. 1386

.

“es

AIA AAW

| an he i Saen Gout of the. Winited Sites

OCTOBER TERM; 1966

No. 304

AMERICAN AIRLINES, Tic, ET AL., PETITIONERS |

¥ ; v. :

_ Crvit AERONAUTICS BoaRD, ET’ AL. ~

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED,

STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR oh ca eb reshe vice OF COLUMBIA

CIRCUIT,

BRIEF 708, THE crv ABRONAUTIOS BOARD IN ecm |

OPINIONS BELOW

The opinion of the court of appeals (Pet. App. “ =e

13a-39a) is reported at 359\F, 2d 624. The order of —

the Civil Aeronautics Board (Pet. a C, 42a-44a) is

not ea reported.

JURISDICTION

The judgment of the court of appeals (Pet. App. B,

40a-41a) was entered on March 2, 1966. On May 14,

1966, ade. Chief Justice Warren extended the time for —

filing a petition for a writ of certiorari. to and iriclud- _

ing June 30, 1966. The petition was filed on that day. —

The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under 28

U.S.C. 1254(1)..

o (1): °

a

QUESTION PRESENTED Stage

Whether the Civil Aeronautics Board, in promul-

‘gating a rule authorizing all-cargo carriers aloneto of- -

fer “blocked space’’ cargo service, exceeded its - He

. thaking atithority. SAE EAS Mie i

p ; : STATUTES INVOLVED .

The pertinent provisions of the Federal Aviation

Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 731, 49 U.S.C. 1301, et seq., and

of the Administrative aiken Act, 60 Stat. 237, 5

U.S.C. 1001, et seq.; are Agia forth ‘in’ ‘Appendix’ b to

~Athe es for certiorari

STATEMENT

Following a rule-making proceeding, the Civil Aero-

_ nauties Board: adopted a regulation authorizing all-

cargo carriers, but ‘not combination (passengers plus ie

cargo) carriers, to offer‘‘blocked space” air cargo

.* sérvice. “Lhe ‘regulation’ permits ‘a shipper to con-

tract at wholesale rates for a specified amount of

cargo capacity (which must. be paid for whether or —

not actually: used) -aboard a-particular ‘carrier’s ‘all-

cargo aircraft on a regularly recurring schedule for a

period of 60 days or more. Pursuant’to this ‘regula-

* tion, the Board «rejected tariffs for “blocked space”

service filed. by petitioners—the three largest combina-

tion carriers—while permitting a similar tariff filed by

the Slick: Corpérition, an all-cargo | carrier, to go into,

* effect ‘pending’ ‘an investigation by the ‘Based of the

legality! of ‘thé: rates propbséd in Slick’s tariff. ‘The fi

backgrdurid of the tégulation is as ‘follows. Peat. |

The’ distinctioh betweer combination and all-cargo |

carriers’ has beén'’ rr for regulayeny purposes,

oe

3

ever since the Board certified a group of saheaty ;

carriers to’ bervet as specialists in this field some

_ twenty years ago. In November 1962, the Board in-:

stituted a rule-making procgeding to consider, among -

- other questions,. what volume ‘and types of charter

flights .each class of carrier should be authorized to

furnish. In, January 1964, the Board published. a.

supplemental notice of rule-making. (J.A. 115), whieh

_ proposed a regulation “to delineate the roles of the

all-cargo and supplemental carriers and to establish a

_ policy favoring the purchase from all-cargo. carriers

of blocked: space at wholesale rates by the combina-

tion carriers.”

Numerous comments were submitted in response ‘to

this notice (J.A. 129-35). However, before the

Board took any further action in this proceeding,

Slick * filed a tariff for blocked-space service between

' New York and Los Angeles and New York and San

. Francisco, under which substantial _rate reductions —

-would--be allowed shippers who confracted for a: speci-

fied: amount of space on specified flights.every week for

90 days or more. * Petitioners filed eomplaints chal-

_ lenginig. the legality. of Slick’s tariff on various”

grounds, and asking the Board to suspend and in-

\ Air Freight Case, 10 C.A.B. 572, affirmed sub nom. American

_ Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics Boand, 192 F. 2 417 (C.A.D.C.

1951). The history of the all-cargo industry is traced in Do-

mestic Cargo-Mail Service Case, 36 C.A.B. 344, 352-355.

*Slick suspended its scheduled ‘operations on September 1,

1965 (C.A.B. Order Nos. E-22588, August 27, 1965; E-23362,

March 14, 1966). Airlift International, Inc., has, applied for

the‘ transfer of Slick’s certificate to’ it. At ‘the present time

there is only one all-cargo carrier, The Flying Tiger Line, that

can offer blocked-space serviéé”on the New York-Los Angeles

and New York-San Francisco routes Slick formerly served.

a

——

' * gate them.

4

vestigate it. They also filed assertedly ‘‘defensive’”

blocked-space tariffs of their « own, duplicating Slick’s

in. smost’ respects. Slick, in turn, asked. the: Board ¥

either to reject tens taitts oF or to suspend and investi- — ,

| While these: tariff piacolidisign -were ‘pending, the

Board issued a further. supplemental notice of pro- |

posed rule-making (J.A. 137), inviting oral. argument

- on whether all-cargo carriers should be “permitted to

sell blocked space at wholesale rates to air freight -

forwarders and other darge volume shippers.’”’ The

all-cargo carriers proposed that they alone ‘should be.

authorized to -offer blocked-space service; petitioners,

and = other combination earriers vigorously opposed a

(J.A. 149-171).

On August 7, 1964, the Boatd issued ‘its Regilation - vo

-_No. PS-24 (J.A. 74-80; 144CFR. § 339.37), announc--

‘ing a policy of permitting all-cargo carriers, but not

combination carriers, to. _provide. blocked-space. gerv-

ice..to combination. carriers, air freight forwarders,

and large-volume individual shippers.* In an ac-

companying .statement of the basis and. purpose of

the rule, the Board observed that differences ‘in. the

service and. function of combination and. all-cargo.

carriers were inherent in the terms of their certificates

and . their operating responsibilities thereunder. A.

. Blocked-space service was defined as.

the carriage of property im all-cargo aircraft at whole: :

sale ‘rates pursuant to an effective tariff. stating a rate -.

'’ applicable only when the user reserves and agrees to pay —

for a specified amount of space or lift on a regularly

Ph cthice Wert iN aia i aaa |

Semegreayt a : ;

7 ‘68

7 logical and practical means for further dclipeating *

the role of all-cargo carriers, the Board reasoned, was

to encourage their - development ‘as. specialists for

. large-volume air freight service in all-cargo aircraft,

_ However, while blocked-space service had a substantial ,

potential for attracting to air freight substantial vol--

umes of bulk traffic now moyed by surfaee carriers,

. “its potential could be realized only if new techniques

eo

—

< e

_ were developed for handling such traffic with greater. . ;

efficiency and lower_eosts, and | this was likely only if, .

the number of carriers taking part in blocked-space

service was limited. in its experimental stage. For.

this reason, the Board found it should be restricted

to all-cargo carriers ‘‘at this time.”’ This would not

injure the combination carriers, for the diversion of.

_ existing traffic from those carriers would probably not :

be significant and they might be expected to acquire -

an ‘increasing share,of small-package shipments..

‘The Board had previously suspended, and ordered. :

an investigation of, the blocked-space tariffs filed by —

- Slick and petitioners. Following the issuance of its |

eel tegulation, it ‘lifted its suspension | of ’

Slick’s tariff, although continuing the investigatiou.‘

_ Shortly Aiheewaseds, the Board issued the order under — 2

review rejecting the blocked-space tariffs of peti-..—

tioners on the ground that under the new regulation -

they were not authorized % Provide this service isa ha

94-7). a = af :

* The Flying ‘Tiger Line sono, filed 2 pees

tariff; and the Board siniilarly ordered an investigation , (which

is still: pending) while. allowing it to be put into Tet :

+ eh

’

| ae se

The Board denied petitions for reconsideration ie

petitioners and. others (Order E-21447, October 26,

1964, p. 4), stating that, on balance, the air transporta-

3 tion systém as a whole would be benefited by giving all-

cargo carriers the exclusive right to provide blocked .

space service at-the present time. ‘However, re ‘stated,

- “we must stress - * *.* that our policy on ‘plocked-

space service is not an immutable one, We have acted

in the light of the present and reasonably foreseeable

circumstances. The policy’ is thus subject to amend-.

| ment as the blocked-space experiment develops, and

| we, of course, retain our power to issue waivers under —

‘appropriate circumstances.” * : .

On petitioners’ suit for review, a panel of the court

of ‘appeals reversed the Board’s order rejecting peti- -

- tioners’ ‘tariffs, holding, with one judge dissenting,

that it amounted to a modification of their certificates.

without compliance with the hearing requirements of

3 Section ‘401(g) of the Act, 49 U.S.C. 1371 (Pet. App:

D, 50a, Pet. App: A, la-12a), ; On rehearing « en bane, ,

the’ court, divided’ 5-3, sustained the ‘Board, ‘Tt: "held,

| that the Board’s action did not amount to a iaiiflas

>

tion of thie combination carriers’ certificates ; that the .

4/2 Board ’s distinction between combination and all-cargo...

carriers hada rational basis; and that the Board’s

action’ was a valid exercise of its power t to make rea- a

sonable classifications of. carriers ‘and rules regulating

them under Sections 204 and 416 of the Act, 49 U.S.C.

1324, 1386 (Pet. “App. D, 55a, Pet. App.. Ay 13a-3la).-

“Two members.of the Board: dissented, ad: thos hed, from, jadch,

of the ptidr, orders.in: the ' case, questioning both ‘the: hegality.

and the wisdom of the Board’s pays

TF

’

7

Bointing,out,thad-the considerations that had moved:the

_ Board,to\ adopt iits :poli¢y were: broadly legislative in’

nature, and, did not: rest’ on: any: evaluation of ‘the:

3

"use, of, rule-making’ procedures was: entirely appto-

priate. Finally, it: noted ‘that the:petitioners would.

merits or demerits of individual carriers, it ‘ruled that

have an adequate remedy in the courts if the assump-

tions on which: the Board’s policy was based changa”

and the, Board refused to, take: einen action’ to

a modify (Pet App. Ay 30a-B1a). sian

ARGUMENT

The action’ of. the Board in promulgating a rule -

'. that permits only ‘all-cargo carriers to offer blocked-

- space service was reasonably found by the court be-

low to be within the Board’s broad rule-making

power. Further review, we submit, is not warranted.

2

1, The Board has statutory responsibility for the .

promotion, development, and regulation of. civil avia-

cise broad. rule-making powers: (49 ‘U:S.C. 1373) and,

specifically, it may classify air, carriers according to

the, service they perform. and:,.define distinctions

- among’ classes (49:U.8.0, 1386(a)). . This is what the

- Board did here. To encourage adoption of efficient. .

methods. of . freight trafisportation, and. thereby ‘in-

crease. competition in this field by air carriers, the

tion (49 U.S.C. 1302), and, to this end, it may.-exer-.-

Commission has authorized the blocked-space experi-

ment,, initially. limiting .it to, the: all-cargo. carriers 80:

ee wna Swill: have an. indueement to exploit the serv-

subi: wit ) i 1 the normal scope of agency y-sule:naking r

8

«dts =n and general i in ‘its application, legislative.

. and preseriptive father than judicial ‘in its character.

. -Itis mnie many rules that have been uphetd-by

| the ecourts®. 2g

7 Petitionera argue that” the blocked-space rule dt .

fects a modification: of the rights granted in tlie cer- |

- tificates under which they operate, -and that therefore

. adjudicatory procedures—prescribed in the Act for -

modification proceedings—were necessary. The argu- °

ment is without merit. Their certificates do not au-

thorize—or even mention—blocked-space service, nor *,'

did‘ combination carriers. attempt to provide it until

a blocked-space tariff was: proposed. by an alrenp -

earrier. '

To be sure, edeabination carriers are authorized to Z

carry freight bétween the points specified in. their_.

certificates; but they retain this authority under the:

rule. Nor is there the slightest indication that any .

of their freight operations will be impaired’ because. -

- 6 See, ey., Federal Power Commission -v.. Tewaco, 877 US...

33, 39-44 (regulations prohibiting specified types of pricing |

clatises widely ysed in natural gas-contracts); American Truck-

ing. Associations v. United States, 344 U.S.°298 (“trip-leasing”

regulations applied to some classes of carriers but not others) ;

_National Broadcasting Co, v. United States, 319 U.S. 190 (reg- |

ulations ‘requiring extensive: modification in existing radio net-

- works’ contracts); United States v. Storer Broadoasting, 351°.

U.S. 192 (multiple ownership of radio ‘stations restricted by —

regulation) ; Air. Line Pilots Association v. Quesada, 276 F.2d. |

892 (C.A. 2), affirmed, 286 F. 2d 319 (C.A. 2), certiorari denied, -

366 U.S. 962 (licensed pilots over 60 barred by regulation from |

piloting’ transport’ aircraft) ; Capitol Airways v. eVwil Aero-

nautics Board, 292 F.2d 755 .(C.A:D.C.) | (supplemental carriers :

handling military charters required to obtain individual exenip- ai

tions fror ‘restriction on: operating — ‘in lieu ‘Of: prior ‘is

“blanket or : °

| ‘competing air carriers will be offering blocked,space;

~ gerviée.” Since October 20, 1964, when Dplocked-space.

‘regulation becarhe effective (Pet. App. A, 14a, n..3),;°

there has been little blocked-space traffic and.no. signifi- y

“eant diversion of cargo business from petitioners (Pet:

App. A, 31a), whose ability to compete for air-freight |

_* traffic has.nof been discernibly affected.” . The court, be-

low has expressly preserved petitioners’ right to reopen

the issue of their exclusion from blocked-space_ Service «

' if petitioners’ cargo service is impaired (Pet. App.. A,

30-31a).° In addition, petitioners. have. intervened in

the still-pending investigation of the Flying Tiger and: %

Slick blocked-space tariffs. There they will have full ..

opportunity to object that the rate levels of those tariffs

prevent them from providing thoir certificated service.

-2. Petitioners also contend. that the. Board com- -

mitted procedural errors. in ‘promulgating its rule...

The ‘court below, however, observed that: “the proce- i

dure followed by the Board admittedly complies fully ©

a } with the requirements for rule making established in

Section 4.of the Administrative, Procedure Act” (Pet.

App. A, 15a; emphasis added). Petitioners’ btief. - - ©

_ below made no argument that the Board’s procedure ae

was deficient. Their attempt to raise this issue now:

7On the basis of official reports: filed with the Civil” Aero:

nautics Board ‘by the carriers,’ it appears that in the year end-

dng in. May 1964 petitioners carried 57.9 percent of the nation’s

air freight, while the principal all-cargo operators. (Slick and

.. Flying. Tiger) carried 16.8 percent. In the -year ending in

. May 1966, nineteen months after implementation of the blocked-.

space. regulation, petitioners’ share ‘of the air-freight market}

- had increased to 62.9 percent, while the ger oe: share mee

~ had omen to 13. 3 aun

4%,

10

' is; we’ believe, belated: In any event, the record

shows. clearly: that petitioners in fact had ‘adequate

notice—ard | actual knowledge—that one of the issues

before. the Board in the rule-making”proceéding was.

whether the all-cargo carriers should, be given ex- ”

. ghaatge blocked-space rights,* and petitioners had a

reasonable opportunity to comment on this issue

‘No more was required.

& By supplemental notices of J: anuary 93, 1964, ad June

' 22, 1964, the Board clearly made an issue of blocked- -space

agreements (J.A. 115, 187). Petitiongrs’ written, and oral com--

ments to the Board demonstrated their awareness that the all-

cargo carriers were proposing, and the Board considering, exclu-

sive blocked space rights for the all-cargo carriers (J.A. 130-140, |

. 167, 169, 171). They also had ample oppottunity to commandant

on the final regulation and its policy justification in their peti-

rere for reconsideration which, with petitions by other inter-

ested persons, were carefully considered’ by the Board | in de-

termining whether to .set the regulation aside, :

, Om: 3

' CONCLUSION

For ee. reasons stated, the — i certiorari

should be denied.

ere submitted.

. THURGOOD ‘Masewatz,

: Solicitor General.

oF | _ ‘Donatp F. Turyer,

Assistant Attorney General. .

Howarp E. SHaPiro,

LAWRENCE G. MEYER, -

} _ Attorneys.

JOsEPH B. GOLDMAN,

General Counsel,

0. D. OzMunr,

Deputy | General Counsel,

Warren L. ‘SHARFMAN,

Associate General Counsel,

FRrepERIC D. HOUGHTELING,

‘ Attorney,

Civil Aeronautics Board,

Aveust 1966. - . A

:

0.8, GOVERNMERT PRINTING OFFICE: 1966

A

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.