Opposition Brief — American Airlines, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board
Supreme Court brief1966
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
w
ee Opinions below- SEE VBI ON Nit ning
Jurisdiction PAS cud on > ARTE Paks
; Question, presented__.-£ Lin. 222 sel lcle
Statutes involveds----2---2 OOS
Ce | REE aceon ena :
Argument a a snedicepoe
Conclusion SRREREIMOT tar hae sete Ch, WE eam Oe ee
Cases:
F’, 2d 892, affirmed, 286 F. 2d 319, certi-
orari denied, gs § Ree
American Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics
Beard, TER F: BE Gah cccmcinciiedamactma
_ American Trucking: Associations v. United
States, 344 U B. Wb uancsimcccesacconcase
Capitol Airways Vv. Civil Aeronautics Board,
292 F. 2d 755---------=. RS SR on
Federal Power Commission v. Texaco, 377 |
UB. $B cenecccnssasccsrnvatcnnenh
National Broadcasting Co. v. U nited States,
B19 UB. TU .nccscncccnnquenesneanionn
United States v. Storer Broadcasting, 351
Statutes: ©
Administrative Procedure Act, 60 Stat. 237,
6 USA) I, 6 0Geicwnccncanamenacne
. &®
2290-857—66
Air Freight Case, 10 0. 2 5 Sean .
_ Air [ine Pilots Association v. Quesada, 276 |
a a wage
w :
Oo @ 8 © © & ow
. Statutes—Continued _
Federal Aviation Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 731,
49 U.S.C. 1301, et seq |
Section 102, 49 U.S.C. 1302-__---____ :
Section 204, 49 U.S.C. 1324.
Section. 401, 49 U.S.C. 1371
Section 403, 49 U.S.C. 1373.--_.--_--__
Section 416, 49 U.S.C. 1386
.
“es
AIA AAW
| an he i Saen Gout of the. Winited Sites
OCTOBER TERM; 1966
No. 304
AMERICAN AIRLINES, Tic, ET AL., PETITIONERS |
¥ ; v. :
_ Crvit AERONAUTICS BoaRD, ET’ AL. ~
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED,
STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR oh ca eb reshe vice OF COLUMBIA
CIRCUIT,
BRIEF 708, THE crv ABRONAUTIOS BOARD IN ecm |
OPINIONS BELOW
The opinion of the court of appeals (Pet. App. “ =e
13a-39a) is reported at 359\F, 2d 624. The order of —
the Civil Aeronautics Board (Pet. a C, 42a-44a) is
not ea reported.
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the court of appeals (Pet. App. B,
40a-41a) was entered on March 2, 1966. On May 14,
1966, ade. Chief Justice Warren extended the time for —
filing a petition for a writ of certiorari. to and iriclud- _
ing June 30, 1966. The petition was filed on that day. —
The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under 28
U.S.C. 1254(1)..
o (1): °
a
QUESTION PRESENTED Stage
Whether the Civil Aeronautics Board, in promul-
‘gating a rule authorizing all-cargo carriers aloneto of- -
fer “blocked space’’ cargo service, exceeded its - He
. thaking atithority. SAE EAS Mie i
p ; : STATUTES INVOLVED .
The pertinent provisions of the Federal Aviation
Act of 1958, 72 Stat. 731, 49 U.S.C. 1301, et seq., and
of the Administrative aiken Act, 60 Stat. 237, 5
U.S.C. 1001, et seq.; are Agia forth ‘in’ ‘Appendix’ b to
~Athe es for certiorari
STATEMENT
Following a rule-making proceeding, the Civil Aero-
_ nauties Board: adopted a regulation authorizing all-
cargo carriers, but ‘not combination (passengers plus ie
cargo) carriers, to offer‘‘blocked space” air cargo
.* sérvice. “Lhe ‘regulation’ permits ‘a shipper to con-
tract at wholesale rates for a specified amount of
cargo capacity (which must. be paid for whether or —
not actually: used) -aboard a-particular ‘carrier’s ‘all-
cargo aircraft on a regularly recurring schedule for a
period of 60 days or more. Pursuant’to this ‘regula-
* tion, the Board «rejected tariffs for “blocked space”
service filed. by petitioners—the three largest combina-
tion carriers—while permitting a similar tariff filed by
the Slick: Corpérition, an all-cargo | carrier, to go into,
* effect ‘pending’ ‘an investigation by the ‘Based of the
legality! of ‘thé: rates propbséd in Slick’s tariff. ‘The fi
backgrdurid of the tégulation is as ‘follows. Peat. |
The’ distinctioh betweer combination and all-cargo |
carriers’ has beén'’ rr for regulayeny purposes,
oe
3
ever since the Board certified a group of saheaty ;
carriers to’ bervet as specialists in this field some
_ twenty years ago. In November 1962, the Board in-:
stituted a rule-making procgeding to consider, among -
- other questions,. what volume ‘and types of charter
flights .each class of carrier should be authorized to
furnish. In, January 1964, the Board published. a.
supplemental notice of rule-making. (J.A. 115), whieh
_ proposed a regulation “to delineate the roles of the
all-cargo and supplemental carriers and to establish a
_ policy favoring the purchase from all-cargo. carriers
of blocked: space at wholesale rates by the combina-
tion carriers.”
Numerous comments were submitted in response ‘to
this notice (J.A. 129-35). However, before the
Board took any further action in this proceeding,
Slick * filed a tariff for blocked-space service between
' New York and Los Angeles and New York and San
. Francisco, under which substantial _rate reductions —
-would--be allowed shippers who confracted for a: speci-
fied: amount of space on specified flights.every week for
90 days or more. * Petitioners filed eomplaints chal-
_ lenginig. the legality. of Slick’s tariff on various”
grounds, and asking the Board to suspend and in-
\ Air Freight Case, 10 C.A.B. 572, affirmed sub nom. American
_ Airlines v. Civil Aeronautics Boand, 192 F. 2 417 (C.A.D.C.
1951). The history of the all-cargo industry is traced in Do-
mestic Cargo-Mail Service Case, 36 C.A.B. 344, 352-355.
*Slick suspended its scheduled ‘operations on September 1,
1965 (C.A.B. Order Nos. E-22588, August 27, 1965; E-23362,
March 14, 1966). Airlift International, Inc., has, applied for
the‘ transfer of Slick’s certificate to’ it. At ‘the present time
there is only one all-cargo carrier, The Flying Tiger Line, that
can offer blocked-space serviéé”on the New York-Los Angeles
and New York-San Francisco routes Slick formerly served.
a
——
' * gate them.
4
vestigate it. They also filed assertedly ‘‘defensive’”
blocked-space tariffs of their « own, duplicating Slick’s
in. smost’ respects. Slick, in turn, asked. the: Board ¥
either to reject tens taitts oF or to suspend and investi- — ,
| While these: tariff piacolidisign -were ‘pending, the
Board issued a further. supplemental notice of pro- |
posed rule-making (J.A. 137), inviting oral. argument
- on whether all-cargo carriers should be “permitted to
sell blocked space at wholesale rates to air freight -
forwarders and other darge volume shippers.’”’ The
all-cargo carriers proposed that they alone ‘should be.
authorized to -offer blocked-space service; petitioners,
and = other combination earriers vigorously opposed a
(J.A. 149-171).
On August 7, 1964, the Boatd issued ‘its Regilation - vo
-_No. PS-24 (J.A. 74-80; 144CFR. § 339.37), announc--
‘ing a policy of permitting all-cargo carriers, but not
combination carriers, to. _provide. blocked-space. gerv-
ice..to combination. carriers, air freight forwarders,
and large-volume individual shippers.* In an ac-
companying .statement of the basis and. purpose of
the rule, the Board observed that differences ‘in. the
service and. function of combination and. all-cargo.
carriers were inherent in the terms of their certificates
and . their operating responsibilities thereunder. A.
. Blocked-space service was defined as.
the carriage of property im all-cargo aircraft at whole: :
sale ‘rates pursuant to an effective tariff. stating a rate -.
'’ applicable only when the user reserves and agrees to pay —
for a specified amount of space or lift on a regularly
Ph cthice Wert iN aia i aaa |
Semegreayt a : ;
7 ‘68
7 logical and practical means for further dclipeating *
the role of all-cargo carriers, the Board reasoned, was
to encourage their - development ‘as. specialists for
. large-volume air freight service in all-cargo aircraft,
_ However, while blocked-space service had a substantial ,
potential for attracting to air freight substantial vol--
umes of bulk traffic now moyed by surfaee carriers,
. “its potential could be realized only if new techniques
eo
—
< e
_ were developed for handling such traffic with greater. . ;
efficiency and lower_eosts, and | this was likely only if, .
the number of carriers taking part in blocked-space
service was limited. in its experimental stage. For.
this reason, the Board found it should be restricted
to all-cargo carriers ‘‘at this time.”’ This would not
injure the combination carriers, for the diversion of.
_ existing traffic from those carriers would probably not :
be significant and they might be expected to acquire -
an ‘increasing share,of small-package shipments..
‘The Board had previously suspended, and ordered. :
an investigation of, the blocked-space tariffs filed by —
- Slick and petitioners. Following the issuance of its |
eel tegulation, it ‘lifted its suspension | of ’
Slick’s tariff, although continuing the investigatiou.‘
_ Shortly Aiheewaseds, the Board issued the order under — 2
review rejecting the blocked-space tariffs of peti-..—
tioners on the ground that under the new regulation -
they were not authorized % Provide this service isa ha
94-7). a = af :
* The Flying ‘Tiger Line sono, filed 2 pees
tariff; and the Board siniilarly ordered an investigation , (which
is still: pending) while. allowing it to be put into Tet :
+ eh
’
| ae se
The Board denied petitions for reconsideration ie
petitioners and. others (Order E-21447, October 26,
1964, p. 4), stating that, on balance, the air transporta-
3 tion systém as a whole would be benefited by giving all-
cargo carriers the exclusive right to provide blocked .
space service at-the present time. ‘However, re ‘stated,
- “we must stress - * *.* that our policy on ‘plocked-
space service is not an immutable one, We have acted
in the light of the present and reasonably foreseeable
circumstances. The policy’ is thus subject to amend-.
| ment as the blocked-space experiment develops, and
| we, of course, retain our power to issue waivers under —
‘appropriate circumstances.” * : .
On petitioners’ suit for review, a panel of the court
of ‘appeals reversed the Board’s order rejecting peti- -
- tioners’ ‘tariffs, holding, with one judge dissenting,
that it amounted to a modification of their certificates.
without compliance with the hearing requirements of
3 Section ‘401(g) of the Act, 49 U.S.C. 1371 (Pet. App:
D, 50a, Pet. App: A, la-12a), ; On rehearing « en bane, ,
the’ court, divided’ 5-3, sustained the ‘Board, ‘Tt: "held,
| that the Board’s action did not amount to a iaiiflas
>
tion of thie combination carriers’ certificates ; that the .
4/2 Board ’s distinction between combination and all-cargo...
carriers hada rational basis; and that the Board’s
action’ was a valid exercise of its power t to make rea- a
sonable classifications of. carriers ‘and rules regulating
them under Sections 204 and 416 of the Act, 49 U.S.C.
1324, 1386 (Pet. “App. D, 55a, Pet. App.. Ay 13a-3la).-
“Two members.of the Board: dissented, ad: thos hed, from, jadch,
of the ptidr, orders.in: the ' case, questioning both ‘the: hegality.
and the wisdom of the Board’s pays
TF
’
7
Bointing,out,thad-the considerations that had moved:the
_ Board,to\ adopt iits :poli¢y were: broadly legislative in’
nature, and, did not: rest’ on: any: evaluation of ‘the:
3
"use, of, rule-making’ procedures was: entirely appto-
priate. Finally, it: noted ‘that the:petitioners would.
merits or demerits of individual carriers, it ‘ruled that
have an adequate remedy in the courts if the assump-
tions on which: the Board’s policy was based changa”
and the, Board refused to, take: einen action’ to
a modify (Pet App. Ay 30a-B1a). sian
ARGUMENT
The action’ of. the Board in promulgating a rule -
'. that permits only ‘all-cargo carriers to offer blocked-
- space service was reasonably found by the court be-
low to be within the Board’s broad rule-making
power. Further review, we submit, is not warranted.
2
1, The Board has statutory responsibility for the .
promotion, development, and regulation of. civil avia-
cise broad. rule-making powers: (49 ‘U:S.C. 1373) and,
specifically, it may classify air, carriers according to
the, service they perform. and:,.define distinctions
- among’ classes (49:U.8.0, 1386(a)). . This is what the
- Board did here. To encourage adoption of efficient. .
methods. of . freight trafisportation, and. thereby ‘in-
crease. competition in this field by air carriers, the
tion (49 U.S.C. 1302), and, to this end, it may.-exer-.-
Commission has authorized the blocked-space experi-
ment,, initially. limiting .it to, the: all-cargo. carriers 80:
ee wna Swill: have an. indueement to exploit the serv-
subi: wit ) i 1 the normal scope of agency y-sule:naking r
8
«dts =n and general i in ‘its application, legislative.
. and preseriptive father than judicial ‘in its character.
. -Itis mnie many rules that have been uphetd-by
| the ecourts®. 2g
7 Petitionera argue that” the blocked-space rule dt .
fects a modification: of the rights granted in tlie cer- |
- tificates under which they operate, -and that therefore
. adjudicatory procedures—prescribed in the Act for -
modification proceedings—were necessary. The argu- °
ment is without merit. Their certificates do not au-
thorize—or even mention—blocked-space service, nor *,'
did‘ combination carriers. attempt to provide it until
a blocked-space tariff was: proposed. by an alrenp -
earrier. '
To be sure, edeabination carriers are authorized to Z
carry freight bétween the points specified in. their_.
certificates; but they retain this authority under the:
rule. Nor is there the slightest indication that any .
of their freight operations will be impaired’ because. -
- 6 See, ey., Federal Power Commission -v.. Tewaco, 877 US...
33, 39-44 (regulations prohibiting specified types of pricing |
clatises widely ysed in natural gas-contracts); American Truck-
ing. Associations v. United States, 344 U.S.°298 (“trip-leasing”
regulations applied to some classes of carriers but not others) ;
_National Broadcasting Co, v. United States, 319 U.S. 190 (reg- |
ulations ‘requiring extensive: modification in existing radio net-
- works’ contracts); United States v. Storer Broadoasting, 351°.
U.S. 192 (multiple ownership of radio ‘stations restricted by —
regulation) ; Air. Line Pilots Association v. Quesada, 276 F.2d. |
892 (C.A. 2), affirmed, 286 F. 2d 319 (C.A. 2), certiorari denied, -
366 U.S. 962 (licensed pilots over 60 barred by regulation from |
piloting’ transport’ aircraft) ; Capitol Airways v. eVwil Aero-
nautics Board, 292 F.2d 755 .(C.A:D.C.) | (supplemental carriers :
handling military charters required to obtain individual exenip- ai
tions fror ‘restriction on: operating — ‘in lieu ‘Of: prior ‘is
“blanket or : °
| ‘competing air carriers will be offering blocked,space;
~ gerviée.” Since October 20, 1964, when Dplocked-space.
‘regulation becarhe effective (Pet. App. A, 14a, n..3),;°
there has been little blocked-space traffic and.no. signifi- y
“eant diversion of cargo business from petitioners (Pet:
App. A, 31a), whose ability to compete for air-freight |
_* traffic has.nof been discernibly affected.” . The court, be-
low has expressly preserved petitioners’ right to reopen
the issue of their exclusion from blocked-space_ Service «
' if petitioners’ cargo service is impaired (Pet. App.. A,
30-31a).° In addition, petitioners. have. intervened in
the still-pending investigation of the Flying Tiger and: %
Slick blocked-space tariffs. There they will have full ..
opportunity to object that the rate levels of those tariffs
prevent them from providing thoir certificated service.
-2. Petitioners also contend. that the. Board com- -
mitted procedural errors. in ‘promulgating its rule...
The ‘court below, however, observed that: “the proce- i
dure followed by the Board admittedly complies fully ©
a } with the requirements for rule making established in
Section 4.of the Administrative, Procedure Act” (Pet.
App. A, 15a; emphasis added). Petitioners’ btief. - - ©
_ below made no argument that the Board’s procedure ae
was deficient. Their attempt to raise this issue now:
7On the basis of official reports: filed with the Civil” Aero:
nautics Board ‘by the carriers,’ it appears that in the year end-
dng in. May 1964 petitioners carried 57.9 percent of the nation’s
air freight, while the principal all-cargo operators. (Slick and
.. Flying. Tiger) carried 16.8 percent. In the -year ending in
. May 1966, nineteen months after implementation of the blocked-.
space. regulation, petitioners’ share ‘of the air-freight market}
- had increased to 62.9 percent, while the ger oe: share mee
~ had omen to 13. 3 aun
4%,
10
' is; we’ believe, belated: In any event, the record
shows. clearly: that petitioners in fact had ‘adequate
notice—ard | actual knowledge—that one of the issues
before. the Board in the rule-making”proceéding was.
whether the all-cargo carriers should, be given ex- ”
. ghaatge blocked-space rights,* and petitioners had a
reasonable opportunity to comment on this issue
‘No more was required.
& By supplemental notices of J: anuary 93, 1964, ad June
' 22, 1964, the Board clearly made an issue of blocked- -space
agreements (J.A. 115, 187). Petitiongrs’ written, and oral com--
ments to the Board demonstrated their awareness that the all-
cargo carriers were proposing, and the Board considering, exclu-
sive blocked space rights for the all-cargo carriers (J.A. 130-140, |
. 167, 169, 171). They also had ample oppottunity to commandant
on the final regulation and its policy justification in their peti-
rere for reconsideration which, with petitions by other inter-
ested persons, were carefully considered’ by the Board | in de-
termining whether to .set the regulation aside, :
, Om: 3
' CONCLUSION
For ee. reasons stated, the — i certiorari
should be denied.
ere submitted.
. THURGOOD ‘Masewatz,
: Solicitor General.
oF | _ ‘Donatp F. Turyer,
Assistant Attorney General. .
Howarp E. SHaPiro,
LAWRENCE G. MEYER, -
} _ Attorneys.
JOsEPH B. GOLDMAN,
General Counsel,
0. D. OzMunr,
Deputy | General Counsel,
Warren L. ‘SHARFMAN,
Associate General Counsel,
FRrepERIC D. HOUGHTELING,
‘ Attorney,
Civil Aeronautics Board,
Aveust 1966. - . A
:
0.8, GOVERNMERT PRINTING OFFICE: 1966
A
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.