Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Grand River Dam Authority v. National Gypsum Co.
Supreme Court brief1966
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ae Selita Office-Supreme Court, U.S.
, ~CUPT oy @ FILED
DEC 1 7 1965 .
a ae
JOHN F. DAVIS, CLERK
SUPREME COURT OF TE : UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1965
wo. 830
GRAND RIVER DAM AUTHORITY, a Body Corporate,
Petitioner, e :
NATIONAL GYPSUM COMPANY, a Corporation,
Respondent.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
TENTH CIRCUIT
Q. B. BoyDsTun
General Counsel, Grand River
Dam Authority ma
Vinita, Oklahoma ;-
Counsel for Petitioner
Of Counsel:
Horace D. BALLAINE — 3
SawuEt Hess CrRosSLAND \ i
JAMES R. RYAN
711 First National Building
Tulsa, Oklahoma
> — —
E. L. Mansanmss, Ene., 1108 Oak Street, Kansss City, Mo. 64106, HArrison 1-3080
&
Oo ee ent ee fe aoe
' INDEX
Opinions Below
Jurisdiction
Questions Presented
SNe INI eiciscctdi cn dnssasiesicecisisasinseamennsnnncaideerniadiioinianptionmas
Statement of the Case
Reasons for Granting the Writ
Conclusion
DI crit bicecternncdseeceaeaeniieeaeeindbdnbnninlasthandictin
Citations
CasEs
Bartlesville v. Corporation Commission, 82 Okl. 160,
199 Pac. 396 (1921)
City of Pawhuska v. Pawhuska Oil & Gas Co., 64 Okl.
214, 166 Pac. 1058 (1917), error dismissed, 250 U.S.
394, 39 S. Ct. 526, 63 L. Ed. 1054
Federal Crop Insurance Corporation v. Merrill, 332 U.S.
380, 68 S. Ct. 1, 92 L. Ed. 10 (1947)
Home Telephone & Telegraph Company v. Los Angeles,
. 211 US. 265, 29 S. Ct. 50, 53 L. Ed. 176 (1908) ............
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers v.
Grand River Dam Authority, 292 P.2d 1018 (1950) ....
Midland Realty Co. v. Kansas City Power & Light Co.,
300 U.S. 109, 57 S. Ct. 345, 81 L. Ed. 540 (1937) ............
Realty Mortgage & S. Co. v. Oklahoma Emp
Sec. Com’n, 197 Okla. 308, 169 P.2d 761, 770 ................
Rock Island, Arkansas & Louisiana R. Co. v. United
States, 254 U.S. 141, 41 S. Ct. 55, 65 L. Ed. 188 (1920) _
Royal Indemnity Co. v. United States, 313 U.S. 289, 61
ee ee Ee | eeenetnen enya A
wwe.
iw)
12
12
17
17
af INDEX
Sheldon v. Grand River Dam Authority, 182 Okl. 24, 76
P.2d 355 (1938) 3
Union Dry Goods Co. v. Georgia Public Service Corp.,
— 248 US. 372, 39 S. Ct. 117, 62 L. Ed. 309 (1919) -...... 17
United States v. City and County of San Francisco, 310
U.S. 16, 60 S. Ct. 749, 84 L. Ed. 1050 (1940) 220... 17
a _ STATUTES
17 OkLSt.Ann. §151 et seq. in: ae
17 Okl.St.Ann. §152 6
Oklahoma Constitution, Article 18, §7 ....2, 3, 6, 12, 13, 16,17
Oklahoma Session Laws 1935, Ch. 70, pp. 350-358, 82
Ok1.St.Ann. §§861-880 3
Oklahoma Session Laws 1935, Ch. 70, p. 354, 82 Okla.St.
Ann. $868 2, 3, 6, 9, 10, 13
Oklahoma Session Laws, 1955, p. 562 11
: Appendix
CONTENTS
Opinion of Court of Appeals Al
Judgment of Court of Appeals Al5
Order of Court of Appeals —— Petition for Re-
hearing -....... Al5
Section 8 of Grand River Dam Authority a A16
—\
5
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1965
No.
a
GRAND RIVER DAM AUTHORITY, a Body Corporate,
Petitioner, :
vs.
NATIONAL GYPSUM COMPANY, a Corporation,
Respondent.
PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE ©
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
TENTH CIRCUIT
Grand River Dam Authority, a body corporate under
the laws of the State of Oklahoma, prays that a Writ of
Certiorari issue to review the Judgment of the United
States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit entered in
the above case on October 6, 1965.
OPINIONS BELOW
__ The opinion of the District Court for the Northern
District of Oklahoma (R. 52 and 57) has not been reported
and the opinion of the Court of Appeals for the Tenth
Circuit has not yet been reported. It is printed in the /
Appendix hereto.
—
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the Court of Appeals was made and
entered on October 6, 1965, and a copy is appended to this
Petition following the opinion of the Court of Appeals
in the Appendix. A Petition for Rehearing was denied
on November 16, 1965. The jurisdiction of this Court is
invoked under 28 U.S.C. §1254(1).
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
1. Whether it is proper for a Court of Appeals to base
its ruling upon an argument not suggested, urged, briefed
or even anticipated by the parties to the wince
before it.
2. “Whether petitioner’ is authorized, in establishing
and collecting utility rates pursuant to the Grand River
Dam Authority Act, to establish contingency and deprecia-
tion funds.
3. Whether the hetalabane of Oklahorna can impliedly
sanction actions of an agency created by it which violate
an express provision of the Oklahoma Constitution.
> 4. Whether the Court of Appeals erred in interpreting
the provisions of Article 18, §7 of the Oklahoma Constitu- .
tion.
STATUTES INVOLVED
Section 8 of the Grand River Dam Authority Act, 1933
Okl.Sess.Laws, Ch. 70, p. 354, 82 Okl.St.Ann. §868, is
the statute applicable to this case. This section of the
Grand River Dam Authority Act has not been amended
since its adoption in 1935. Pertinent portions are printed
<<
in the text of this petition. The entire section appears
in the Appendix.
Article 18, §7 of the Constitution of the State of
Oklahoma is cited in the text.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Petitioner is a conservation and reclamation “District”
eStablished by the legislature of the State of Oklahoma
in the Grand River Dam Authority Act of 1935, Okl.Sess:-
Laws 1935, Ch. 70, pp. 350-358, 82 Okl.St.Ann. .§§861-880,
primarily to build and operate a hydroelectric dam upon
the Grand River in Northeastern Oklahoma. It is Okla-
homa’s largest State-owned utility and is the principal
supplier of electric power to municipalities, industries and
electrical cooperatives in fifteen counties of Northeastern,
Oklahoma. In operating its plants and facilities it exercises
sovereign power of the State of Oklahoma and its directors,
officers and employees are the agents and employees of
the State of Oklahoma."
Article 18, §7 of the Constitution of the State of
Oklahoma provides, inter alia,
“Nor shall the power to — the charges for public
services be surrendered. .
and Section 8 of the Grand River Dam Authority Act, 82
Okla.St.Ann. §868, requires petitioner (referred to in the
Act as the “District”), by its Board of Directors, to:
“_ . establish and collect rates and other charges
for the sale or use of water, water connections, power,
electric energy or other services sold, furnished or
supplied by the District which fees and charges shall
yt
1. International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Vv. Grand
River Dam Authority, 292 P.2d 1018 (1950); Sheldon v. Grand
River Dam Authority, 182 Okl. 24, 76 P.2d 355 (1938).
4 .
. be. reasonable and. non-discriminatory and sufficient
to produce revenue adequate:
a) To pay all expenses necessary to the operation and
maintenance of the properties and facilities of the
District;
b) To pay the interest on and ‘principal of all bonds
issued under this Act (the Grand River Dam Au-
thority Act) when and as the same shall become
due and payable; .
c) To pay all sinking fund and/or reserve > payments
agreed to be made in respect of any such bonds,
and payable out of such revenues, when and as
the same shall become due and payable;
d) To fulfill the terms of any agreements made with
the holders of such bonds and/or with any person
in their behalf. Out of the revenues which may
be received in excess of those required for the .
purposes specified in subparagraphs (a), (b), (c)
and (d), above, the Board shall establish a reason-
able depreciation and emergency fund and retire
(by purchase and cancellation or redemption)
bonds issued under this Act. It is the intention
of this Act that the rates and charges of the Dis-
trict shall not be in excess of what may be
necessary to fulfill the obligations imposed upon
it by this Act.”
_ On November 6, 1950, petitioner entered into a contract
(hereinafter referred to as the “Contract”) with respond-
ent (later. amended on April 6, 1951) under which petitioner
agreed to furnish respondent’s requirements of electric
power and energy, water, steam and compressed air“(R.
6-19, 20-21). The term of the Contract was for a period
of twenty-five years.
With respect to rates for electricity and electrical
energy, the Contract expressly provided that rates might
be from time to time changed by petitioner “only as pro-
5 ‘
vided jn the Grand Biver Dam Authority Act” but that
such rates should at all times be “reasonable and non-
discriminatory and shall be-adequate but not in excess
of what may be necessary to fulfill the obligations imposed
upon [petitioner] by said Act.” The Contract contained
no similar provisions dealing with changes in rates for
water, steam and compressed air.
On the basis of studies and reports which indicated
that the rates being received by petitioner for the sale of
electricity, water; steam and compressed air were insuf-
ficient to provide the revenues required by the Grand
River Dam Authority Act, the Directors of. petitioner
adopted Resolution No. 3890 (R. 33-40) on January 5,
1960, promulgating new and increased schedules of rates
for electricity, water, steam and compressed air. On April
20, 1964, the Directors promulgated Resolution No. 4123
(R. 41-50) further increasing the rates for all utility serv-—
ices. Respondent paid the increased rates under protest
and filed this action in the US. District Court for
the Northern District of Oklahoma seeking refunds for
the rates paid for water, steam and air and a determination
that petitioner had no authority to change the rates for
water, steam or air. No complaint was made as to the
increased rates for electricity and respondent did not
complain that the rates for water, steam or air were
discriminatory or unreasonable—only that petitioner had
no power to change such rates at all (See Complaint at
R. 1-5). Jurisdiction was based upon diversity of citizen-
ship. When it apparent that respondent’s claims
were based so on the question of petitioner’s power,
under any circumstances, to make any changes in the rates
for water, steam and air, petitioner moved for summary
Pe ah ee ee tne or Pe ee
ie iouieiads
sw.
6
The District Court (Bohannon, J.) granted respond-
ent’s Motion for Summary Judgment (R. 67) and filed
an Order (R. 52-57) indicating that his ruling was based
*upon*the premise that any attempted change in rates for
water, steam or air by petitioner would “impair the obli-
gation of [respondent’s] contract with [petitioner]” (R.
56). ‘
Petitioner appealed to the Court of Appeals for the
’ Tenth Circuit urging that the provisions of Article 18, §7
- of the Oklahoma Constitution, supra, precluded it from
making any effective contract which would bar proper
‘rate adjustments for utility services when changes should
“become necessary to maintain revenues adequate for the
purposes specified in Section 8 of the Grand River Dam
é Authority Act, 82 Okl.St.Ann. §868, supra. ?
The Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment of the
District Court holding: (%) that the Oklahoma legis-
_ lature had impliedly approved an administrative construc-
tion of the Grand River Dam Authority Act recognizing
_petitioner’s authority to execute long term contracts which
do not reserve power to make appropriate fate adjustments;
(2) that Article 18, §7 of the Oklahoma Constitution did
not apply to petitioner because municipally owned utilities
are excluded from ‘the definition of the word “utility”
in a statute (17 OklSt.Ann. §152) which established a
regulatory agency to supervise the rates “of privately
owned utility. companies; (3) that when petitioner’s Di-
rectors in 1950 approved the Contract they had “exercised”
(to the exclusion of any later power of review) the legis-
lative rate authority delegated by the Grand River Dam
Authority Act; and (4) that petitioner had improperly
accrued depreciation and contingency funds in deficit
years and had no authority to accrue such reserves except
out of excess earnings. i ses
~~
SSS
7
The latter holding is relied upon primarily as the
basis for this pie ap certiorari because neither party
to the action had even suggested any such argument or
remotely anticipated such an unsolicited ruling and because
the ruling may well jeopardize petitioner’s right to collect
rates sufficient to establish reserve funds - specifically
pfovided for in its outstanding bond indentures.
Petitioner is frank to state that although it regards the
“piuion of the Court of Appeals as manifestly erroneous in
all respects, the errors would not ordinarily give rise to
‘questions erftitled to review in this Court by certiorari
except for the drastic effects of that part of the Court’s
opinion which deals witht the reserve funds petitioner is
legally entitled to establish. That ruling was volunteered
by the Court of Appeals sua sponte and. without any thought.
as to its possible effect. Its effect is Startling and extends
far beyond the instant controversy. It casts doubt on the
validity of reserve funds, established for many years under
the specific terms of bond indentures. It will imperil
petitioner’s” rights in other rate cases now pending and
may well affect future bonds to be issued by the Au-
thority. The ruling perils the economic and industrial
futtire of all of Northeastern Oklahoma at a time when the
ture is not scheduled to meet until 1967, and
legislative relief can not be had until such time. —
«<
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT
A. The Ruling Concerning Petitioner’s Right to Estab-
lish Reserves Presents a Question of Importance
upon Which Petitioner Should Have a Fair Hear-
ing. ] ar
Petitioner has already suggested that the surprise
holding of the Court of Appeals and the far-reaching and
drastic consequences of that ruling are the principal basis
for this petition for certiorari. The holding transcends the
merits of this particular controversy. By affecting the
‘validity of the reserves which petitioner has established,
the opinion affects the entire debt structure of petitioner.
With major expansion projects well launched, petitioner is
now faced with a challenge going to the very heart of its
allowable revenues.
In most cases, this court is right to insist that it not
‘be burdened with cases which merely call upon it to make
another judgment:as to the correctness or error in non-
federal rulings already thoroughly argued and briefed by
‘two lower tribunals. The parties have had their day in
‘court—usually twice. In the instant case, however, peti-
tioner’s only day in court on the ruling which most vitally
affects its future (and the economic future of a major area
of the State of Oklahoma) consisted of a chance to call the
attention of the Court of Appeals to its error on a Petition
for Rehearing (cursory review at best).?
2. ‘Review on a Petition for Rehearing in situations where
the Court has offéred several grounds to support an opinion is
most unsatisfactory. Even if the Court of Appeals has become
convinced that it erred in one or more respects, it will tend to deny
the Petition for Rehearing without comment on the basis that the
judgment is supported by other grounds. Such action may leave
in force an opinion announcing an erroneous rule of law which has
far reaching and tragic consequences. Petitioner suggests that
this is what has occurred in the instant case.
~~ »
9
Petitioner feels that if it can demonstrate clear and
manifest error in the Ruling of the Court of Appeals in its _
“volunteered” ruling concerning the establishment of
proper reserves, the writ of certiorari should be granted
in this case even if the Court of Appeals be correct in its
other rulings, none of which are nearly so grave or sig-
nificant to petitioner or the citizens it serves. Petitioner
would like to show-why te Court of Appeals could not, on
the record in this case, »=ve decided the question of what
reserves petitioner may establish.
All of petitioner’s rate making authority is derived
from the above quoted provisions in Section 8 of the Grand
River Dam Authority Act. This section requires petitioner
not only to establish, but to collect, rates which “shall be
. reasonable and nondiscriminatory and sufficient to produce
revenue adequate:
“a) To pay all expenses necessary to the operation
, and maintenance of the properties and facilities of
the District;
b) To pay the interest on and pfincipal of all bonds
ee er ee ne teal
become due and payable;
c) To pay all sinking fund and/q@ reserve fund pay-
ments agreed to be made in respect of any .
bonds, and payable out of such revenues, when
and as the same shall become due and payable;
and :
d) To fulfill the terms of afiy agreements made with
the holders of such bonds and/or with any person
in their behalf.” (Emphasis added)
’
Thus, under the plain and unambiguous language of the
Statute, petitioner is not only authorized, but commanded,
to establish and collect rates sufficient for such reserve fund
payments which may be required in respect to its Sutstand-
’
-
4
ll
10
ing bonds. Petitioner is a party to an elaborate bond In-
denture which requires mandatory payments to the chal-
lenged depreciation and contingency funds but the In-
* denture was not before the District Court or the Court of
Appeals. If petitioner could have introduced the Indenture
into the record on its Petition for Rehearing in the Court
of Appeals, it would, of course, have done so. Since no one
but the panel of the Court of Appeals which heard the
case even remotely suspected (or could have suspected)
that this issue would arise, the Indenture had not been
made a part of the record—nor did the issues framed by
the pleadings suggest that it might become relevant.
The Court of Appeals ignored completely the statutory
provisions quoted above and commenced its analysis with
the statutory words following the really relevant ones. It
is true that the sentence following the quoted portion of
82 OklSt.Ann. §868(d) refers to reserves which are to be
established. . . “Out of the revenues which may be received
in excess of those required for the purposes specified in
subparagraphs (a), (b), (c) and (d).” The latter sentence
_is, however, operative only after. petitioner’s rates have
brought it sufficient revenues to establish those funds
which the Grand River Dam Authority Act absolutely re-
quires it to establish (furfds required by its indentures
and agreements with bondholders). -
The irresponsible action of the Court of Appeals in
interjecting this issue into the controversy without any
proper foundation or hearing makes. this a proper case in
- which this Court should exercise its general supervisory
authority over the administration of justice in the Federal
Courts.
11
B. The Court of Appeals Erred in Ruling That the
Oklahoma Legislature Had Impliedly Ratified the
Contract.
The opinion of the Court of Appeals held that since
the Oklahoma Legislature had amended the Grand River
Dam Authority Act in 1955 (Oklahoma Session Laws, 1955,
p. 562) without taking any action concerning petitioner’s
contracts, it had impliedly ratified an administrative con-
struction of the Grand River Dam Authority Act under
which petitioner did have the authority, by contract, to put
rates for water, steam and air beyond review for long pe-
riods of time.
This holding is incorrect because there is no evidence
that any of petitioner’s’ contracts ever came to the atten-
tion of the Legislature. Petitioner does not publish “re-
ports” concerning its contracts or report them to Legisla-
ture periodically nor have there been any prior contro-
versies concerning the instant aspect of any of petitioner’s |
contracts which might have focused legislative attention
upon the subject. In the absence of some indication that
the question could have come to the attention of the Legis-
lature, or even one of its minor committees, it is absurd
to presume any legislative ratification, implied or other-
wise, of petitioner’s contra¢ts.*
3. The Oklahoma Supreme Court is familiar with the fact
that few of the State’s administrative agencies publish reports
or otherwise communicate regularly with the Legislature and has
not recognized the doctrine of implied legislative ratification of
administrative action. This explains why the only authority
the Court of Appeals was able to muster to support its holding
of implied legislative ratification was a reference to*a dissenting
opinion by a Justice of the Supreme Court of Oklahoma. (The
citation to Realty Mortgage & S.-Co. v. Oklahoma Employment
Sec. Com’n, 197 Okl. 308, 169 P.2d 761, 770, in Footnote 3 of the
opinion of the Court of Appeals is a reference to the dissenting
opinion of Vice Chief Justice Hurst.) Petitioner does publish
financial reports which show its reserves and the annual alloca-
tions thereto. Thus, if the legislature has impliedly ratified or
’ sanctioned any administrative practice, it has ratified petitioner’s
practices of allocating funds to depreciation and contingency re-
serves.
|
Tete, eee wun a ene wo OW Senet Sonne | Een mere SRL ant or Cin One ee ane 8 en
rf
s
12 a
Certainly neither the 1955 or 1957 amendments to the
Grand River Dam Authority Act dealt with the subject of
contracts or rates. These amendments changed the
‘ composition of petitioner’s Board of Directors, their terms
of office and compensation, the location of the principal
office and increased the amount of bonds petitioner might
issue, but did not in any manner involve petitioner’s rate
- structure or its contract authority. ,
In event, however, the Oklahoma Constitution
prohibits ahy one on behalf of the State from contracting
away the State’s sovereign power to regulate the charges
for public services. Article 18, §7 provides:
“Nor shall the power to regulate the charges for public
services be surrendered; .. .”
The Oklahoma Supreme Court has applied this constitu-
tional provision to bar attempts by municipalities to con-
tract with private utilities and place rates for utility
‘services beyond the reach of the State’s continuing, sover-
eign power of regulation. Bartlesville v. Corporation Com-
emission, 82 Okl. 160, 199 Pac. 396 (1921); City of Pawhuska__
v. Pawhuska Oil & Gas Co., 64 Okl..214, 166 Pac. 1058
(1917), error dismissed, 250 U.S. 394, 39 S. Ct. 526, 63 L. Ed.
1054. The Court of Appeals ignored the Constitutional pro-
vision by finding that petitioner was not a “utility” as de-
fined in the Statute which created a Corporation Commis-
sion and delegated to it the power to regulate utility
charges of privately owned utilities. 17 Okl.St.Ann. $151
et seq. :
This merely misconceives the regulatory scheme
adopted in Oklahoma. The Corporation Commission of
Oklahoma exercises rate-regulatory authority over pri-
vately owned utilities. The Legislature has not seen fit to
commit the regulation of rates by municipally owned and
13
publicly owned utilities to the same body which regulates
private utilities. This scheme does not represent a legis-
lative determination that petitioner’s charges for its serv-
ices are not “charges for public services” under the Consti-
tutional provision.
When petitioner was established as a body satis and
as an agency of the State in the Grand River Dam Au-
thority Act, the Oklahoma Legislature plainly recognized
that its charges were subject to Article 18, §7 of the Consti-
tution. The last paragraph of Section 8 of the Grand River
Dam Authority Act, 82 OkLSt.Ann. §868, immediately fol-
lows the paragraphs and subparagraphs which prescribe
the rates petitioner must charge. It reads:
“Nothing herein shall be construed as depriving the
State of Oklahoma of its power to regulate and.control
fees and/or charges to be collected for the use of water,
water connections, power, electric energy, or other
services, provided, that the’State of Oklahoma does
hereby pledge to and agree with the purchasers and
successive holders of the bonds issued hereunder that
the State will not limit or alter the power hereby vested
in the District to establish and collect such fees and
charges as will produce revenues sufficient to pay the-
items specified in sub-paragraphs (a), (b), (c) and
(d) of this Section 8, or in any way to impair the rights
or remedies of the holders of the bonds, or of any
person in their behalf, until the bonds, together with
, the interest *thereon, with interest on unpaid install-
ments of interest and all costs and expenses in connec-
tion with any action or proceedings by or on behalf
of the bondholders and all other obligations of the Dis-
trict in connection with such bonds are fully met and
discharged.” Laws 1935, p. 354, §8.
This paragraph is a clear reference, to Article 18. §7. .
of the Oklahoma Constitution and ‘is a recognition by the
Legislature that it was as powerless to surrender the State’s
“
ON AOE ho ply Ped Wr
14
rate making ennanrned as petitioner or any other party
would be.
‘Finally, the parties themselves’ sitiaiiiaes that by
virtue of the Oklahoma Constitution and the Grand River
Dam Authority Act, petitioner had a continuing duty to
change its rates from time to time to keep them in com-
pliance with the legislative mandate. Respondent has paid
the increased electric rates without question* and has chal-
- ]Jenged only the increased rates for water, steam and air.
Yet the provision of the Contract (paragraph No: 16, R. 9)
which authorizes changes in electric rates recognizes that
petitioner has an obligation to make changes. It provides:
“Rates Subject to Change
ad
| 16. The schedule of electric rates and charges as
herein set forth may be changed by the Authority from
time to time only as provided by the Grand River Dam
Authority Act (Title 82, Sec. 861 et seq., O. S. 1941,
as amended and supplemented as of the date on which
this agreement is executed by the Authority), which
rates and charges shall at all times be reasonable and
nondiscriminatory and shall be adequate ‘but not in
excess of what may be necessary to fulfill the obliga-
tions imposed upon the Authority by said Act. Any
change in the Authority’s schedules of rates shall be
applied to all customers of the Authority in a reason-
able and nondiscriminatory manner. The Authority’s
costs of redeeming bonds prior to maturity will not be
considered as a part of operating costs and electric rates
“explains why petitioner could not reasonably have anticipated a
by the Court of Appeals which finds, in effect, that peti-
tioner’s revenues were adequate without any raise in rates.
15 :
hereunder will not be increased for this purpose.”
(Emphasis added)
The error of the Court of Appeals in the above respect,
together with its much graver error in ruling upon the re-
serves petitioner is legally entitled to establish justifies an
exercise of this Court’s reviewing authority.
| C. The Court of Appeals Erred in Deciding That the
| Twenty-Five Year Contract Was an Exercise of
. the State’s Rate-Making Authority Which Was
| Binding for Such Term.
The Court of Appeals decided that petitiontr was obli-
gated “at the time the contract was entered into to deter-
© mine what rates in its [petitioner’s] considered judgment
would be adequate to meet, the requirements of §868 during
the term of the contract and fix the applicable rates ac-
cordingly.” The Court stated that the fact, if it be a fact,
that actual experience showed the initial judgment to have
been faulty over the life of the Contract “does not retro-
actively maké the initial determination improper or unlaw-
Bee and does not, render void the contract rates.”
Petitioner does not contend that the contract is mean-
ingless or “retroactively void.” It contends that the con-
tract rates remained valid at all times until that time
when such rates were no longer adequate to meet the
statutory requirements of the Act. Precisely at that time _
petitioner had a duty under the statute to make appro-
priate changes to bring the rates into line with ‘the
| statutory mandate which required petitioner,- not only to’
establish, but to collect, rates and other charges sufficient:
to produce revenue adequate for the purposes set forth
in the Grand River Dam Authority Act. Petitioner was
: prepared to meet the burden of showing that the contract
rates were no longer adequate for such purposes and that
~
‘
16
the rates for water, steam and air had become discrimina-
tory in that such rates were not bearing their fair propor-
tion of petitioner’s costs. When respondent took~ the
position in the District Court that the only question in-
volved was the legal right of petitioner to change rates
for water, steam and air for any reason at all, both parties
moved for summary vere and such proof became
unnecessary. =
The result of the opinion of the Court of Appeals is
to force petitioner to maintain until 1975 discriminatory
rate schedules under which all users of electricity must
unfairly bear the burden of its losses in furnishing water,
steam and air to respondent. Since the opinion of the
Court of Appeals was announced, the City of Pawnee,
Oklahoma, has amended its pleadings in a suit between
it and petitioner in the District Court of Pawnee County,
Oklahoma, to allege that it is being required to bear an
unfair portion of petitioner’s costs of service by reason of
the unreasonably low rates charged to respondent for
water, steam and air. “Other users have threatened
similar action so‘that the opinion of the Court of Appeals
‘has jeopardized petitioner’s entire rate structure as well
as its debt structure. The matter thus affects the entire
population and economy of Northeastern Oklahoma, which
is wholly dependent upon petitioner for mania utility serv-
ices. ;
The purpose of Afticle 18, §7 of the Oklahoma Con-
stitution was to. prevent officers and agents of the State
from binding the State and its agencies to contracts which
put ‘review of utility-rates beyond review. The effect of
the opinion of the Court of Appeals is to do just that—
to put the rates charged to respondent completely beyond
review until 1975.
17)
Thsep ani: ta ne libs tok Sak anes
fully charged with notice of all limitations upon the au-
thority of petitioner.and its officers, as agents and em-
ployees of the sovereign, Rock Island, Arkansas & Louisi-
ana R. Co. v. United States, 254 US. 141, 41 S. Ct. 55, 65
L. Ed. 188 (1920);. United States v. City and County of —
San Francisco, 310 U.S. 16, 60 S. Ct. 749, 84°L. Ed. 1050
(1940); Royal Indemnity Co. v. United States, 313 US.
‘289, 61 S. Ct. 995, 85 L. Ed. 1361 (1941), and that the
. sovereign is not bound by rules of estoppel or apparent
agency when its officers exceed limitations upon their
authority. See Federal Crop Insurance Corporation v.
Merrill, 332 U.S. 380, 68 S. Ct. 1, 92 L. Ed. 10 (1947). The
provisions of Article 18, §7 of the Oklahoma Constitution
and the rate standards of the Grand River Dam Authority
Act are clear and unambiguous limitations upon peti-
tioner’s authority to make contracts establishing rates
which, either initially or subsequently, fail to meet the
legislatively established standards. |
It is equally clear that contracts establishing utility
rates do not put the rates so established beyond the
sovereign power of the State to abrogate them, Union Dry
Goods Co. v. Georgia Public Service: Corp., 248 U.S. 372,
39 S. Ct. 117, 62 L. Ed. 309 (1919); Midland Realty Co. v.
Kansas City Power & Light Co., 300 U.S. 109, 57 S. Ct. 345, -
81 L. Ed. 540 (1937), and this Court has recognized the
well established rule that the surrender, “by contract, of
a power of. government, is a very grave act requiring
specific authority which must “cleagly and unmistakably
appear”. Home Telephone & Telegraph Company v. Los
Angeles, 211 U.S. 265, 29 S..Ct. 50, 53 L. Ed. 176 (1908).
-The opinion of the Court of Appeals ignores, even
violates, these settled principles of law which protect the
State against the acts of its agents who exceed the “au-
thority committed to them.
x.
ee en
“~ ;
18
CONCLUSION
The ruling of the Court of Appeals far transcends this
particular case. The most serious, and demonstrably er- .
roneous, portion of its ruling may well prove chaotic in
its effect upon the economy of a large portion of ‘a
sovereign State. Rulings which have such effect should,
be accorded at lea8t one review even though the substan-
tive question may be one of State law. This court has a
continuing concern for the manner in which justice is dis-
pensed in the Federal appellate Courts. The case, there-
fore, is one of those cases where,the Court of Appeals
has so departed from settled rules of State law as to justify
a hearing on certiorari and the writ should be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
Q. B. BoyDsTun
General Counsel, Grand River
Dam Authority
_ Vinita, Oklahoma
y
JAMEs R. RYAN
SAMUEL HEss CROSSLAND ~
711 First National Building
Tulsa, Oklahoma -°
Counsel for Petitioner
a
o>
Al
United States Court of Appeals
TENTH CIRCUIT
No. 8063
GRAND RIVER DAM AUTHORITY,
a body corporate,
Appellant,
Vv.
NATIONAL GYPSUM COMPANY,
a corporation,
Appellee.
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Northern District of Oklahoma
(Filed United States Court of Appeals, T. Circuit,
October 6, 1965, /s/ Robert O. t,
- Clerk.)
James R. Ryan (Q. B. Boydstun, Horace D. Ballaine,
Hess Crossland, and Conner, Winters, Randolph & Ballaine
were with him on the brief) for Appellant.
Remington Rogers (Rogers, Donovan & Rogers were
with him on the brief) for Appellee.
Before PHILLIPS, LEWIS and BREITENSTEIN, Circuit
Judges.
PHILLIPS, Circuit Judge. :
p ‘National Gypsum Company’ brought this action
against Grand River Dam Authority* to recover excess
1. Hereinafter called National.
2. Hereinafter called the Authority.
A2
charges alleged to have been paid under duress by
National to the Authority for water and steam furnished
National by the Authority under the written contract re-
ferred to hereinafter. Both parties moved for a summary
judgment.. From a summary judgment in favor of Na-
tional, the Authority has appealed.
The Authority is a conservation and reclamation dis-
trict created by the Oklahoma Legislature in 1935 to pro-
vide flood control and to store, preserve and distribute
“the waters of the Grand River and its tributaries for
’ irrigation, power and other useful purposes, the reclama-
tion and irrigation of arid, semi-arid, and other lands need-
ing irrigation, and the conservation and development of
the forests, water and hydro-electric power of the State
of Oklahoma.” (Session Laws of 1935, Chapter 70, Article
4,§1)
The contract above referred to was entered into be-
tween the Authority and National on November 6, 1950,
and in part here material provides:
“Whereas, the Consumer [National] plans to lo-
cate, construct, maintain, and operate an industrial
plant or plants upon and/or adjacent to the Authority’s
Chouteau Steam Plant property at the Oklahoma Or-
dinance Works near Pryor in Mayes County, Okla-
homa; and —
“Whereas, the Consumer will require for use in
operating and maintaining said plant or plants electric
power and energy, processed steam, raw and treated
water, compressed air, and certain sanitation sacilitign;
and
“Whereas, the Authority is able and can furnish to
the Consumer its requirements of electric power and
energy, processed steam,- raw and treated water,
compressed air and certain sanitation facilities;
* * * ® %
a
A3
“Article I
Electric Power and Energy
“Service |
1. The Authority shall sell and deliver to the
Consumer, and the Consumer shall purchase and re-
ceive from the Authority electric power * * * all in
accordance with thé terms and conditions of this
Contract.
* * oe x
“Rates
8. The Consumer agrees to pay the Authority
monthly, each month during the period of this Con-
tract for power and electric energy, in accordance
with the following schedule of rates:
* ¢ &¢ *®
“Article IT
Water —
“Service
1. The Authority shall sell and deliver to the
Consumer the Consumer’s requirements of (1) treated
water * * * and (2) raw water * * *.
mene * & & *
“Rates BEES
3. Consumer agrees to pay the Authority * * *
for water in accordance with the ow schedules
of rates:
e * *« @# * te
“Article IT }
Steam
: “Service
1. The Authority shall sell end: deliver to the
Consumer and the Consumer shallpurchase and re-
A4
ceive from the Authority the Consumer’s requirements
of dry saturated steam * * *.
v a * * *
“Rates bike 4
3. The Consumer agrees to pay: the Authority
monthly each month during the period of this Con-
tract for said dry saturated steam at the rate of 20¢
per thousand pounds of steam delivered in accordance
with Consumer’s requirements provided no monthly
bill for dry saturated steam shall be less than
$2,500.00.
“Article IV
Compressed Air
- “Service
1. The Authority shall sell and deliver to the
Consumer, and the Consumer shall purchase and re-
ceive from the Authority the Consumer’s require-
ments of compresseg air***.
° * 8 @ *
“Rates : ‘
3. The Consumer agrees to pay the Authority
monthly each month during the period of this Contract
for said compressed air at the rate of 3¢ per thousand
_ cubic feet of free air.
“Article VI
General
e¢* 2:06:86
“Term of Agreement
9. This. contract shall become effective on the
complete execution of the same and shall continue
a Se Rahat aed ON NN Babs
(he
from this effective date for a period of twenty-five
(25) years. It will thereafter remain in effect until
cancelled by two (2) years’ written notice by either
party. * * * Nothing herein contained shall be con-
strued as limiting the rights of modification or ter-
mination at any time as specified in the contract. It
is further understood that each of the services under
this contract shall be contingent upon the erection by
consumer of the industrial plant hereinbefore de-
scribed and shall begin on the dates required by the
Consumer for its production operations.
* ss * - Fs
. “Most Favored Consumer Clause
. 14. The Authority shall give the Consumer
notice of, and shall give the Consumer the benefit
of, any lower rate schedules and/or more favorable
terms and/or more favorable conditions of purchase
made available to any of its other industrial customers
of the same class at any time during the terms of this
agreement.”
The contract provides that the. schedule of electric
rates and charges set forth in the contract may be
changed by the Authority from time to time but that such
fates .and charges shall at all times be reasonable and
nondiscriminatory and shall be adequate but not in excess
of what might be necessary to fulfill the obligations im-
posed upon the Authority by the Act under which it was
created. The contract contains no provision for changing
the rates for water, steam and compressed air and under
the provisions of the contract the charges therefor were to
remain unchanged during the life of the contract. .
By resolution adopted January 5, 1960, the Authority
-increased its rates for electric power, steam and water to
be effective ‘April 1, 1960: Such resolution in eS pro-
vided:
: A6 -
“Whereas, Section 7.10 of the Indenturé’ entered
“Gnto between the Authority and the Marine Midlafid
Trust Company of New York, as Trustee, dated as
of October 1, 1948, as follows:
“‘The Authority covenants that it will, * * *
prepare, adopt and file with the Trustee * * * a schedule
of rates, tolls, rents and other charges for electrical
energy and for any and all other commodities, services
and facilities to be furnished or supplied by the Au-
thority from the System, which are fair, reasonable
and nondiscriminatory, and which are calculated» on
the basis of all available estimates (and with due
allowance for contingencies) to yield funds at least
sufficient: :
“‘(a) To meet the requirements of Article IV
with respect to the amount from time to time to be
set aside in each of the special funds provided for in
Article IV; and
- “(b) To meet all other obligations of the Au-
thority hereunder or otherwise,’ ”
National was advised by the” Authority of such rate
changes applicable to it and National thereafter paid such
increased rates on water and steam under protest.
By resolution adopted April 20, 1964, the Authority
again increased its rates for electric power, water and
steam to be effective July 1, 1964. That resolution in
part provided:
“Whereas, Section 8.1 C of the-Grand River Dam
Authority’s Bond Resolution No. 4010 creating and es-
tablishing an issue of $50,000,000 in Revenue Bonds,
adopted December 5, 1961, is as follows:
“‘The Authority shall fix, establish, maintain
and collect rates and charges for electric power and
energy and other services, facilities and commodities
. sold, furnished or supplied through the facilities of
4
ee eee wen .
. AT
the system, which shal] be fair and nondiscriminatory |
and adequate to provide the Authority with revenues
sufficient to pay the costs of the proper operation,
maintenance and repair of the System, and also for
the payment of all costs, expenses and charges speci-
fied in paragraph B above, and any and“all other
amounts which the Authority may now or hereafter
become obligated to pay or set aside from said rev-
enues by law or contract.’ ” :
- The Authority advised National of the last-mentioned
change in rates applicable to it and National thereafter
paid the increased rates for water and steam under pro-
On September 17, 1964, National filed its complaint
in this action in which it alleged that the increase in
rates of water and steam by the Authority was a breach
of the contract and that it paid such rates for water and
steam furnished it under protest. It further alleged that
prior to March, 1950, it was operating numerous plants
economically located for sources of raw material. and for
economical transportation of its finished products to vari-
ous markets throughout the United States, and that to
meet the growing needs of its business National, prior to
March, 1950, decided to locate a new paper plant at some
convenient point in northeastern Oklahoma; that as a
result of negotiations between the Authority and National,
the Authority agreed to sell to Nationa} a certain indus-
trial site for the construction of such paper plant, and ad
a part and parcel of such transaction, to induce National
to purchase such industrial site and construct its plant
thereon and to become a customer of the Authority, the
Authority agreed to furnish National with its requirements
of electrical energy and agreed to sell to National its re-
quirements of water, steam and air under the specific
. A8
,terms and conditions set forth in the contract referred to
above.
_ National further alleged that in reliance upon such
contract and the “performance thereof by the Authority,
National purchased the industrial site from the Authority
and. at great expense constructed a substantial plant
thereon and from the date of its completion has continued
to operate such industrial plant; that in the operation
thereof, National continuously requires not only a depend-
able source of electric power but also steam, water and
air in substantial quantities; and that it is necessary for
National to operate such plant continuously to enable it
to perform its contract with its various customers.
The trial court held that the Authority had plenary
power to operate, manage and conduct its business includ-
ing the power to establish rates and charges for water
and steam to be furnished by it for a definite term, and
that it had the power to enter into a contract to furnish
water and steam at such rates throughout such term. It
. concluded that the rate changes which the Authority un-
dertook to make in 1960 and 1964 violated the contract re-
ferred to above.
82 Okl. St. Ann. § 868 provides as follows:
“The Board [of the Dam Authority] shall estab-
lish and collect rates and other charges for the sale
or use of water, water connections, power, electric
energy or other services sold, furnished, or supplied
by the District which fees and charges shall be reason-
able and nondiscriminatory and sufficient to produce
revenue adequate:
“(a) To pay all expenses necessary to the opera-
tion and maintenance of the properties and facilities
of the District;
*
‘ AS
“(b) To pay the interest on and principal of all
bonds issued under this Act when and as the same shall
become due and payable;
“(c) ‘To pay all sinking fund and/or reserve fund
payments agreed to be made in respect of any such
bonds, and payable out of such revenues, when and as
the same shall become due and payable; and
“(d) to fulfill the terms of any agreements made
with the holders of such bonds and/or with any person
in their behalf. Out of the revenues which may be re-
ceived in excess of those required for the purposes
specified in sub-paragraphs (a), (b), (c) and (d)
above, the Board shall establish a reasonable depreci-
‘ation and emergency fund, and retire * * * bonds is-
sued under this Act, or apply the same to any corporate
purpose. It is the intention of this Act that the rates
and charges of the District shall not be in excess of
what may be necessary to fulfill the obligations im-
posed upon it by this Act.
| “Nothing herein shall be construed as depriving
the State of Oklahoma of its power to regulate and con-
prtekaygehncsste Sec <aprtioncge ache fhm dy
water, water connections, power, electric enefgy, or
other services, provided, that the State of Oklahoma
does hereby pledge to and agree with the purchasers
and successive holders of the bonds issued hereunder
that the State will not limit or alter the power hereby
vested in the District to establish and collect such fees
and charges as will produce revenues sufficient to pay
the items specified in sub-paragraphs (a), (b), (c) and
(d) of this Section * * *, or in any way to impair
the rights or remedies of the holders of the bonds, or
of any person in their behalf, until the bonds, to-
gether with the_interest thereon, with interest on un-
paid installments of interest and all costs and expenses
in connéction with any action or proceedings by or on
behalf of the bondholders and all other obligations of
the District in connection with such bonds are fully
met and discharged”.
?
A10
82 Okl. St. Ann. § 862(n) grants to the Authority the
power “to make contracts and to execute instruments nec-
essary or. convenient to the exercises. of the powers, rights,
privileges and functions conferred upon. it. %
On December 18, 1950, the Authority entered into a
contract with the City of Pryor, Oklahoma, for the sale of
water at specified rates for a definite term. That contract
made no provision for changing such rates during the term.
On January 9, 1951, it entered into a contract. with the
Coronado Manufacturing Company for the sale of electric
energy, steam and water for specified rates set forth in the
contract. That contract provided for the changing of the
rates for electric energy by the Authority but made no pro-
-vision for changing the rates for water and steam which
were fixed for a definite term under the contract. And
on October 3, 1952, the Authority contracted with the 2 City
of Chouteau, Oklahoma, for the sale of water for a d sfini
term, at rates specified in the contract. ‘That contra@t.con- -
tains no provision for the changing of the rates by the Au-
thority and such rates were. fixed for a definite term by
the contract. .
While the Authority also entered ‘into other contracts
in whith it reserved the power to change rates, it is clear
that the Authority in 1950, 1951 and 1952, construed Section
868, supra, as giving it the power to establish rates and
charges for water and steam for a fixed period and Section
.862(n), supra, as giving it the power to contract to furnish
water and steam for such fixed period at such unchangeable
rates. |The Act creating the Authority and defining its
powers was amended in 1955 (Oklahoma Session Laws,
1955, p. 474) and again in 1957 (Oklahoma Session Laws,
1957, p. 562). In neither of such amendatory acts did the
Legislature amend or change Section 862(n), supra, or limit
or take away the power of the Authority to establish and
All
‘
contract for fixed rates for a definite period which the Au- .
thority had theretofore exercised and which constituted an
administrative construction of the Act. The Legislature
therefore impliedly approved such administrative eam
tion of the Act made by the Authority.’
The Authority contends that Article 18, Section 7 of
the Oklahoma Constitution‘ prohibits it from entering into
a_contract“which establishes fixed rates, relying upon
City of Bartlesville v. Corporation Commission, 82 Okl.
160, 199 P. 396; City of Pawhuska v. Pawhuska Oil and
Gas Co., 64 Okl. 214, 166 P. 1058, writ of error dismissed;
250 U.S. 394; and American Indian Oil & Gas Co. v. George
F. Collins & Co., 157 Okl. 49, 2 P.2d 438, as supporting
their contention. We think those cases are not controlling
in the instant case. In City of Bartlesville v. Corporation
Commission, supra, the Oklahoma Supreme Court held
that the Corporation Commission had the power to change
the rates charged by a non-municipal gas company in
Bartlesville notwithstanding a home rule city charter pro-
vision authorizing the city to fix and regulate such rates.
In City of Pawhuska v. Pawhuska Oil & Gas Co., supra,
the Oklahoma Supreme Court held that the rate for gas
supplied to the inhabitants of Pawhuska by a non-municipal
gas company could be changed by the Corporation Commis-
sion notwithstanding a provision in the franchise granted
by the City to the gas company prior to the time the Corpo-
ration Commission was granted power by the Legislature
to regulate the rates,of public utilities, establishing a maxi-
mum rate for gas. And in American Indian Oil and Gas
3. Realty Mortgage & S. Co. v. (Oklahoma Emp. Sec. Com’n.,
197 Okl. 308, 169 P.2d 761, 770.
4. Article 18, — 7 -of- the Oklahoma Constitution pro-
vides in part .as foll
“Nor shall x power ‘to regulate the charges for public
services be surrendered; * * *.”
Ai2 ‘ 2
Co. v. George F. Collins & Co., supra, the Oklahoma Su- ~~
preme Court held that a ten-year contract between a non-
municipal gas company and a private consumer which es-
tablished a fixed rate for gas was binding upon the parties
so long as no rate had been established by the Corporation
Commission, but céased to be effective as_to rates when
the Corporation Commission had established rates.
Those cases all involved rate changes made by the
Corporation Commission. The rates charged by public
utilities in Oklahoma are controlled and regulated by the
Corporation Commission. But the Authority is a “body
politic’® and as such it is expressly excluded from the
statutory definition of a public utility’ and its rates and
_charges are not subject to control or regulation by the Cor-
poration Commission. The only limitations upon the rate
making powers of the Authority are those imposed by the
Legislature which appear in 82 Okl. St. Ann. § 868, supra.
e
.. Furthermore, each of the cases relied upon by the Au-
thority involve an attempt by the user to fix rates so as
to prevent the duly constituted rate making agency desig-
nated by the Legislature from performing its rate making
‘duties. In the instant case the Legislature designated the
Authority as the agency to fix its own rates, and any rates,
set by it, whether by contract or otherwise, if set according *- ,
to law are subject to change only by the Legislature. -
Hence there was no surrender of the-power to regulate as
there was in the cases cited by. the Authority. Rather there
was an exercise of such power.
~—
.
5. 17 Okl. St. Ann. § 152.
6. 82 Okl St. Ann. § 861; Intefnational Brotherhood v.
Grand River Dam Auth., on , 292 P.2d 1018, 1019.
7. 17 OkL St. Ann. § 151.
«
pmo eanl Armee ar Senda ne we
)
Al3
©
The Authority further contends that its revenues are
inadequate to meet the requirements of § 868, supra, and
that therefore the contract is void. We do not agree.
The only evidence in the record as to the insufficiency |
of the fees and charges made by the Authority was an
exhibit which tabulated revenue and expenses for a 5-1/2
year period. That exhibit shows in part the following:
Operation & Debt Service
Outstanding Total
Bonds: Revenues Maintenance
20,767,000.00 4,459,498.46 3,100,320.39 952,446.27
20,951,000.00 4,912,646.18 3,399,790.52 978,016.21
50,000,000.00 4,964,426.27 3,034,510.26 1,056,738.19
50,000,000.00 5,390,983.20 3,870,211.48 643,100.00
50,000,000.00 5,963,719.16 5,628,525.84 — 643,100.00
50,000,000.00 3,910,661.09 2,825,829.69 1,336,255.36
29,601,934.36 21,859,188.18 5,609,656.03
Debt. Ser. Contingency Depreciation Gain or
Res. Fund Fund : Deficit*
35,790.30 50,000.00 607,035.80 286,094.30*
63,695.72 50,000.00 593,070.42 171,926.69*
_ 48,036.95 50,000.00 585,674.55 139,466.32
283,680.63 250,000.00 614,651.16 270,660.07*
283,680.63 250,000.00 617,660.68 1,459,247.99*
141,840.32 125,000.00 "328,803.86 847,068.14*
906,724.55 775,000.00 3,346,896.47 2,895,530.87*
It should be noted that § 868, supra, permits the es-
tablishment of depreciation and emergency funds only
“out of the revenues which may be received in excess
of those required for the purposes specified in sub-para-
graphs (a), (b), (c) and (d)” of § 868, yet in each of the
years:in which the above tabulation shows a deficit, there
. _ were set up as expense items depreciation and contingency
reserve. We think that a contingency fund and an emer-
gency furd are the same.
Al4
Revenues in excess of those required for the purposes
specified in sub-paragraphs (a), (b), (c) and (d) of § 868,
supra, were not available in the amounts charged as ex-
- penses for depreciation and emergency in 4-1/2 years.
Had such expenses not been so charged, there would have
been no deficit in 1950, 1960 and 1962. .
Since the Authority decided to set rates for water
and steam sold to National by contract for a 25-year period,
the Authority was obligated by § 868, supra, when the
contract was negotiated to establish rates which would be
reasonable and nondiscriminatory and which it then de-
termined Would be sufficient to produce revenue adequate
to pay operation and maintenance expenses, to pay in-
terest and principal on bonds, to pay sinking and reserve
fund payments, and to fulfill the terms of any agreements
with bondholders. In other.words the Authority was
obligated at the time the contract was entered into to
determine what rates in its considered judgment would
be adequate to meet the requirements of § 868 during the
term of the contract and fix the applicable rates accord-
ingly. Presumably it performed that duty and made such
‘determination, and the fact, if it be a fact, that actuel
experience has shown the prospective determination of the
rates, although fully adequate at the*beginning of the con-
tract term, later turned out to be inadequate, does not
retroactively make the initial determination improper or
unlawful and does not render void the contract rates.
National contends the action’ of the Authority was
an impairment of its contract. We do not think the ques-
tion “f impairment of contract is involved. In its usual
connotation, impairment of contract means impairment
‘by legislative action. No such action has occurred. The
issue rather is one p simple breach of contract.
>
*+
Al5
We conclude the Authority had the power to fix rates
for water and steam for a definite term and to contract
to furnish water and steam for such period at such fixed
rates.
Affirmed.
| Judgment
Sixteenth Day, September Term, Wednesday,
October 6th, 1965
Before Honorable Orie L. Phillips, Honorable David T.
Lewis and Honorable Jean S. Breitenstein, Circuit Judges.
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of
the record from the United States District Court for the
Northern District of Oklahoma and was argued by counsel.
On consideration whereof, it is ordered and adjudged
by this court that the judgment of the said district court
in this cause be and the same is hereby affirmed.
Order Denying Petition for Rehearing |
Second Day, November Term, Tuesday,
November 16th, 1965.
Before Honorable,Orie L. Phillips, Honorable David T.
Lewis and Honorable Jean S. Breitenstein, Circuit Judges.
This cause came on to be heard on the petition of
appellant for a rehearing herein and was submitted to the
court.
~ © on consideration whereof, it is ordered by the court
that the said petition be and the same is hereby denied.
Al6
Section 8 of the Grand River Dam Authority Act,
Okl. Session Laws 1935, Ch. 70, P. 354,
82 OklL.St.Ann. §868
Section 8. Rates and Charges—Fees.
The Board shall establish and collect rates and other
charges for the sale or use of water, water connections,
power, electric energy or other services sold, furnished, or
supplied by the District which fees and charges shall be
reasonable and nondiscriminatory and sufficient to produce
revenue adequate:
(a) ‘To pay all expenses necessary to the operation
_and maintenance of the properties and facilities of the Dis-
trict;
~~ (b) To pay the interest on and principal of all bonds
issued under this Act when and as the same shall become
due and payable; |
(c) . To pay all sinking fund and/or reserve fund
payments agreed to be made in respect of any such bonds,
and payable out of such revenues, when and as the same
shall become due and payable; and v
(d) To fulfill the terms of any agreements niade with
the holders of such bonds and/or with any person in their
behalf. Out of the revenues which may be received in ex- :
cess of those required for the purposes specified in sub-
paragraphs (a), (b), (c), and (d) above, the Board shall
establish a reasonable depreciation and emergency fund,
and retire (by purchase and cancellation or redemption)
° bonds issued under this Act, or apply the same to any
corporate purpose. It is the intention of this Act that the
rates and charges of the District shall not be in excess of
what may be necessary to fulfill the obligations imposed
upon it by this Act.
we
Al7
Nothing herein shall be construed as depriving the
State of Oklahoma of its power to regulate and control fees
and/or charges to be collected for the use of water, water
connections, power, electric energy, or other services, pro-
vided, that the State of Oklahoma does hereby pledge to
and agree with the purchasers and successive holders of the
bonds issued hereunder that the State will not limit or alter
the power hereby vested in the District to establish and
collect such fees and charges as will produce revenues suf-
ficient to pay the items specified in sub-paragraphs (a),
(b), (c), and (d) of this Section 8, or in any way to im-
pair the rights or remedies of the holders of the bonds, or
of any person in their behalf, until the bonds, together with
the interest thereon, with interest on unpaid installments
of interest and all costs and expenses in connection with
any action or proceedings by or on behalf of the bondholders
and all other obligations of the District in connection with
such bonds are fully met and discharged.
Ca
i '
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.