Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Carlo Bianchi & Co. v. United States

Supreme Court brief1965

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

iiRary 3 | “RSS

COURT Uf

MAY 7 1965

“JOHN F. DAVIS, CLERK

’ IN. THE

| Supreme Court of the inited States |

Ocroser TERM, i:

No. rae 1)

CarRLO BIANCHI AND Company, Inc., Petitioner

Ke |

‘Unitep Srates, Respondent

= .

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS —

Ce

Rosert F', BRADFORD

53 State Street

_ Boston, Massachusetts 02109

. Attorney for Petitioner

WiLuiAM H. MATTHEWS

821-15th St.,N. W. .

Washington, D. C. 20005

Of Counsel’

May 7, 1965."

Press or Byron S. ApaMs, WASHINGTON, D. C.:

>>

nor a eaer anneal

Opinion below .........6..sesee. nA. S eligucionae oe

Jurisdiction ° sihdncaxateneie © eeacddedacuesadeueda 1

Questions presented snaee pinnecesinntctuntaccneuats 2

Statutory and contract provisions involved cakueeuees 2

Statement ....... Kakkedbeiuaudes oun sednesaas ae

Reasons for granting the writ .......+... me Gavan: 9

CIE sca Nconvbwkendobewenbcensaess anne er ie

Appendix ........ Wkemeuneeaaner clseecbasbcacsids- 2k

. CITATIONS

CasEs:

a Traders, Ine, v. United States, 144 Ct. Cl.

ES Ee rte MO aN PE PO ey Conn oie 15.

Bell Aircraft Corp. v. United: States, 120 Ct. C1. 398,

BE ee ob nea on'ennt 0s dccnnececkinsasces 14

ae a, a geome Co. v. United States, 122 Ct.

i Kk PPT Pree res Cnr) pet rey om 14

Securities & Exchange Commission v. Chenery Corp., . _

318 U.S. 80; 382 U.S. 194 ... 0... cece cece cece 14:

United States v: Bianchi, 373 U.S. 509 ............ 3

Wunderlich et al v. United States, 117 Ct. Cl. 92, 342

US. 98 ........ hahha shear iwd oe kdaeheekeekens “14

Srarures: .

‘Act of May 11, 1954, 68 Stat. 81 cae Act)

(41 U.S.C. 521-822) soccer eect eee eceseneeeeess va

°

| Supreme Court of the United States

_Octoser TERM, 1964

No.

_ ° Canto Brancut anp Company, INc., Petitioner

a | v. :

| Untrep States, Respondent

PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE

: UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS i

‘Petitioner; Carlo Bianchi and Company, Inc, prays

that a Writ of:Certiorari issue to review the judgment

- ° of the Court of Claims entered in this case on 1 J fuly 17,

=

OPINION BELOW |

The opinion of the Court of Claims of July 17, 1964

(App., infra, p. da) is not yet reported.

" JURISDICTION ae

- The judgment of the Court of Claims was entered .

on July 17, 1964. <A timely petition for reconsidera-—

_ tion and to vacate the judgment was denied on Decem-

ber 11, 1964. ‘The = of this Court i is invoked

under 28 U.S.C. 1255(1).

IR TRR fk te

2

_ QUESTIONS PRESENTED

(1) Whether the United States Court of- Claims

'. properly exercised appellate jurisdiction in.

‘basing iis decision upon determination of an

issue of fact not presented to and not considered

_ by the contracting agency below.

(2) Whether the United States Court of Claims:

5.

' properly exercised appellate jurisdiction in

applying thé substantial evidence rule, and

thereby attaching finality, to the contracting

agency’s interpretation of government contract

specifications as applied to admitted facts, a .

question of law.”

STATUTORY AND CONTRACT PROVISIONS INVOLVED

1. The Act of May 11, 1954, 68 Stat. 81 (Wunderlich

~

ps chiiae (41 U.S.C. 321-322) provides:

. 321. Limitation on pleading contract-provisions |

aa _ Telating to finality ; standards of review.

No p vy gree of any contract, entered into by

the United:States, relating to the finality or con-

clusiveness of“tny decision of the head of any de-

partment or agency-~or his duly authorized repre-

"sentative or board in a dispute involving ‘a ques-

tion arising under ‘such donitract, shall be pleaded:

in any suit now filed or to be filed as limiting judi-

'. - @ial review of ‘any such: decision to cases where

fraud by such official or his said representative or

board is alleged: Provided, however, That any

such decision shall be final and conclusive unless

the same is fraudulent or capricious or arbitrary

or so grossly erroneous as necessarily to imply bad

faith, or’is not supported by substantial evidence.

322. Contract-provisions making decision final

: on questions of law.

'

No Government contract shall coritain a provi-

sion making final on a question of law the decision

of any administrative official, representative, or

board. al eae ;

2. The ‘Disputes’ or ‘‘Finality-Clause’’ Article of -

the contract here involved provides: 7

Article 15. Disputes.—Except as otherwise spe-

cifically provided in this contract, all disputeg con-

cerning questions of fact arising under this con-

tract shall be decided by the contracting officer sub-

ject to written. appeal by the contractor within

30 days to the head of the department concerned

or his. duly authorized representative, whose deci-

sion shall be final and conclusive upon the parties

hereto. In the meantime the contractor shall dili-

- gently proceed with the work as directed.

STATEMENT -

The present case was heard by the Court of Claims

“on remand by this Court, ‘confining its review to the

. administrative record ‘under the standards in the

- Wunderlich Act (United States v. Bianchi, 373 U.S.

‘ §09). : eo

The action arises out of petitioner’s claim for its in-

creased costs incurred: in the course of constructing a

710-foot diversion tunnel which was part of a Govern-

‘ment flood control dam project in upper New York

' State. The contract with the Army Corps of Engineers _

was entered into in 1946. | ie

The specifications provided that prior to lining the

tunnel with concrete, permanent tunnel protection in.

the form of steel supports was to be ised to support the

roof of ‘the tunnel excavation for the first fifty feet .

from each end of the tunnel. The specifications pro-—

4

vided that where the tunnel support was used, back-

_ packing consisting of selected excavation material,

with later grouting, was to be placed above the steel -

supports, and that the steel supports and the back-.

‘ packing would remain embedded in the concrete lining

. after it was installed. The specifications also stipulated

that where permanent tunnel protection in the form of

steel supports was not required, no backpacking was to

be used, but that overbreaks in these areas were to be

backfilled with conerete at the time the concrete lining

was placed.

The specifications also sili that the permanent

tunnel protection was to be installed beyond the 50

feet from the portals where ‘‘required”’ or ‘‘directed”’

by the Contracting Officer (TP4-03, TP4-08, R.,’ pp.

170, 171). Petitioner bid the job on the basis that

additional tunnel protection would be directed if .

needed in order to successfully accomplish the place-

ment of the concrete lining of the tunnel, and that

_ petitioner would be compensated for such additional

protection (R., p. 91). On account of the condition of

‘the tunnel and the extensive rockfalls after it was

holed through, petitioner installed the additional tun-

nel protection for the entire length of the tunnel. This

suit is for the récovery of the extra expense incurred

by petitioner by. reason of the failure and refusal of the

Contracting Officer to direct: such installation.

‘The tunnel was holed through by March 12, 1947.

Only a nominal amount of temporary tunnel protection —

had to be provided for the- protection of the workmen

during the course of the excavating. The tunnel was

1 Reference is made to the portions of the administrative record

before the Court of Claims set forth in the prior record in Docket

No. 529, October Term 1962. ;

driven in cold weather and there. were no rockfalls

during the driving. The.roof of the tunnel started to

fall in during the clean-up work. Rockfalls were so

bad that it was too dangerous for the clean-up crew

to go back into the tunnel to remove rock which had

fallen after they had performed the clean-up opera-

tions. Rock continued to fall from the tunnel roof.

until the time the steel supports were installed. The

rockfall, totaling 203 cu. yds., was distributed in vary-

ing degrees throughout the tunnel (R., pp. 97, 105).

There was an exchange of correspondence. between

petitioner and the Resident Engineer in April of 1947.

‘The petitioner pointed out the hazardous conditions

existing in the tunnel as the result of the rockfall, and

requested authcrization to extend the permanent tun-

nel protection throughout the tunnel.

The ‘position of the Resident Engineer and that of

the Contracting Officer was that while some additional

steel supports, with backpacking above, were necessary

before the concrete lining could: be accomplished, to

provide protection against damage to completed work

as well as to protect the workmen, it was’ “‘temporary

protection’? under ‘the specifications and therefore

would not be paid for (R., pp. 157-159, 245-249). They

' relied on.the following provision of the specifications: '

TP4-02. TUNNEL EXCAVATION. a. Sco :

The tunnel] bore may be driven from either or both |

ends by any of the usual methods of tunneling, -

providing the driving is continuous and progress .

is consistent with that indicated on the progress

schedule. Temporary tunnel protection shall be

provided where required for safety of the work-

men and shall be placed progressively after each

heading blast and prior to resumption of excava-.

tion and.drilling operations.. ... (R:, pp. 169, 170)

F

J

. ‘

ca 6

-

Petitioner appealed the decision of the Contracting

Officer, rendered May 5, 1947, to the Board of Claims

- and Appeals of the Corps of Engineers. On August

11, 1947, the Contracting Officer authorized the instal-

_ lation of the steel supports as ‘‘temporary’’ tunnel pro-

tection under the specifications, the cost to be borne by

petitioner. (R., pp. 253, 254) The petitioner pro-

ceeded promptly to make the installation.

At the hearing before the Board, in June 1948, the -

_Government’s expert witness Mr. McGavock, on whose

testimony the Board’s findings were based, ‘took the.

same position as that of the Resident Engineer and

Contracting Officer. This witness inspected the tunnel

in June 1947 and rendered his report the month fol-

lowing. According to his report, he observed orily 300°

feet‘of the tunnel interior. This was because df the

. depth of the water in the remainder of the tunnel. He

observed three areas of major rockfalls extending a

cumulative distance of about 00 feet, which he ad-

mitted required tunnel supports in the form of steel

- ribs with wooden lagging and metal plates, and back-

packing above the lagging, before concreting could be

accomplished (R., pp. 135, 136, 138, 141, 142). He

agreed that the purpose of the steel supports, which

he limited to 100 feet of protection, was to prevent

rock movement that would damage the concrete before

it had a chance to harden (R., 142, 148). He admitted

that the steel supports, with lagging and backpacking

above them, had to remain embedded in the concrete

because it was too dangerous to the work as well as to

the workmen to remove them (R.,; 142, 149). Never-

- theless, like the Resident Engineer and the Contract-

ing Officer, he took the position that the provision in.

the contract for temporary tunnel protection, which

7

was required only for the safety of the workmen and

only during the operation of tunnel excavation, im-

~ posed an obligation on the part of the contractor -to

provide protection against damage to completed work

as well. .

. One of the main issues before the Board and the

Court of Claims was whether the type of tunnel sup-

ports which the Government’s expert witness admitted

- was required in‘a limited area of the tunnel, similar

| to what was installed eventually by the petitioner,

should be construed as temporary tunnel protection

under Section TP4-02 of the specifications or perma-

nent tunnel protection as provided in Section TP4-03.

Engineering measurements of the rockfalls from the

roof. of the tunnel taken in each 30-foot Monolith sec-

- tion, substantiated by photographs of: the rockfalls,

established that there’were ten areas of rockfalls char-

acterized by the Government expert witness as major

rockfalls and many lesser rockfalls.

On remand, the Court of Claims referred the present

case t2 a Commissioner for his determination. ‘ The

_ Commissioner found that the Findings of Fact and -

Decision of the Board were unsupported by substan-

tial evidence. The primary basis for the Commis-

sioner’s determination was that the steel supports with

backpacking above, which the Government’s expert.

witness indicated had to be installed in a limited area —

of the tunnel prior to the placement of the concrete

lining, were for the protection of the work as well as

for the protection of the workmen, and that they could

not possibly be construed under the specifications as

temporary protection, but that, once installed, they be-

came and forever remained permanent protection.

In this connection, according to the Commissioner’s

interpretation of. the contract ‘specifications, (1)

the temporary protection provision of the contract

only required the petitioner to install temporary

support of ‘whatever kind it felt necessary in or-

der to excavate the rock in the tunnel; (2) the

use of the word ‘‘temporary”’ as defined in "Webster's

Dictionary is not meant to apply to any form of perma-

nent protection; (3) the contract drawings - show

that where steel supports were to be used they were

to be embedded within the concrete lining; as to the

balance of the tunnel, where permanent tunnel protec- |

tion was not provided, the contract drawings show that

the concrete lining extended up to every irregular face

of the tunnel rock; in other words, that all overbreak .

was to be backfilled with concrete making the back-

filling a part.of the tunnel lining operation; (4) there

is no requirement in the contract specifications that

petitioner take any measures after the holing through |

of the tunnel to keep the roof from falling in within

the tunnel, except to place the tunnel lining as promptly,

as possible; (5) the implication in the specifications is .

that if the condition of the tunnel interior was such - -

that support would be needed, it would be authorized

as a pay item. The Commissioner also found that the

engineering computations of the rockfall in the tunnel -

and the photographic exhibits before the Board showed>

that extensive rockfalls occurred throughout the length

of the tunnel, which necesssitated the installation of

_ the permanent tunnel protection before concreting be-

cause of the threat of rock — into wet or uncured

concrete.

9

_ REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT

(1) The decision below is based upon the Court of

Claims determination of a factual issue not presented

_to and not.considered by the Claims and Appeals

Board. The Court properly states that. the eritical

_ issue is whether it was necessary for petitioner to in-

- stall steel supports throughout the length of the tunnel.

However, in resolving that issue, the Court states in

substance that no recovery is proper unless the steel

supports were required for the permanent support and

' maintenance of the tunnel. (App., p. lla, 3rd par.).

- This issue was never before the Board. There the .

issue was whether or not it was necessary to install the

permanent steel ‘supports before the concrete lining of.

the tunnel could be accomplished, as indicated by peti-

tioner’s counsel in his opening: statement before the —

Board:

. Mr. Fox (the Government attorney) has clearly

stated the position of the appellant to this extent

that the appellant has lined this entire tunnel with

steel liner plates and appears before this Board

asking in-equity and good conscience that it be

reimbursed by the Government for the installation

of these are liner plates which the contractor

felt were absolutely necessary in order to line this

tunnel and complete the tunnel job because of the

character of the rock that was encountered... We

ask, that we be paid for the work which we say was

absolutely necessary and without: which this tun-’

nel could not have been«lined with concrete as

required. (R., pp. 79, 83).

According to the siecle own ind witness,

_ if. steel supports were not installed before concreting

in the area of major rockfalls, the tunnel could not have —

been successfully lined with concrete ‘‘without danger

ae

to personnel or structure’? (emphasis supplied) (R.,

p. 142). The testimony of this witness establishes that

the steel supports he deemed necessary for a limited

area were for the purpose of preventing rock move-

‘ment that would damage the concrete before it had a

chance to harden (R., p. 148). Testimony of the gov-

- .ernment’s design engineer clearly indicates that once

the concrete was installed and hardened, that alone |

would adequately support any load that eould possibly

come on it from the roof of the tunnel (R., p. 134).

No witness before the Board indicated that the steel

supports were necessary for the permanent support

of.thé tunnel. Nor did the Board decision. As a mat-

ter of fact, the Government design engineer testified in

a positive manner that at the end sections of the tunnel,

- where the plans ealled for the installation of permanent

tunnel protection, the 1. foot-3 inch thickness of rein-

forced concrete tunnel lining was sufficiently strong to

' take care of any load which would occur on these ends

’ without using in any way the protection work in the

’ form of steel ribs and plates. The Government design

engineer further testified that, within the mid-section

_ of the tunnel, the concrete tunnel lining was designed

for sufficient strength to make the rock above the tun-

nel completely stable, and that the roof would be sup-

ported by the concrete without the necessity for any

type of tunnel protection. (R., p. 129.) |

The Court below seems’to rely in part on the testi-

mony of Mr. Mather, the Resident Engineer, in sup-

port of its assertion that, in order to recover, petitioner

must establish that the steel supports were required

' for the permanent support of the tunnel. The Court

decision states, referring to ‘his testimony: ‘He testi-

fied that the contract required steel lining only where

4

11 | “ é

necessary for the support of the tunnel on a permanent

basis.”” “{App., p. 9a). This was not Mr. Mather’s

testimony. Had he expressed that opinion it would _

have been. entitled to no credence, because no ‘such pro-

vision is contained in the contract, and also because of

his very limited experience in tunnel roof construction,

and the fact-that he did not profess to be a design

engineer. (R., pp. 150, 151). This witness stated that:

he refused to authorize permanent tunnel protection

because his interpretation of the specifications was that

the protection required was ‘‘temporary protection’’, .

and that it was the responsibility of the contractor to

place it for the protection of his workmen. Another

statement attributed to Mr. Mather was one which he

made to the sub-contractor’s engineer in direct charge

of the tunnel excavation work that the only time tun-

- nel protection would be used would be to prevent the

failure of the tunnel itself. (R., p. 113). This ob-

viously refers to the failure of the “tanned during the °

course of construction, and not to the maintenance or

permanent support of ‘the tunnel, .

“The Court of Claims bases its declaration that the

central issue was whether the steel supports were neces-

sary for the maintenance or permanent support of the

tunnel, and its disposition of this issue in favor of the

respondent, primarily on its reference to the ‘‘perma-

nent tunnel protection” and “temporary protection’?

provisions (TP403, TP4-02) of the specifications.

(App., p. 1la). . The Court concludes:

. Had the contract contemplated payment for

sup rts designed only to protect. the workmen

e the job was being completed, it seems reason-

xble $6 suppose that T’P4-08, or some comparable

paragraph, would have made this —_— Cop.

pp. said 7 2 | ‘

12

_ The above statement indicates that the Court mis-

takenly believed that the steel supports were installed

by petitioner in-the mid-section of the tunnel only to

protect the workmen while the job was in progress.

This is not so: As indicated by the testimony of re-

spondent’s expert witness, Mr. McGavock, supra p.

6, the purpose of the steel supports was to make it

possible to install the concrete lining without danger

to the structure, in order to protect it from rupture by —

falling rock during its installation and during the sub- |

sequent period of hardening, as well as without danger

to the workmen. ' Nor is there any concéivable conflict .

on this basic issue between the testimony of Mr. Me-

- Gavock. and that\of petitioner’s expert witness, Mr.

- Following the Contracting Officer’s interpretation of

_ the specifications that the ‘temporary protection’’ pro-

vision of the contract, imposed on petitioner the obli- ©

gation to provide ‘protection against damage to the

tunnel structure as well-as for the safety of the work- ©

_ men, respondent’s expert witness took the position that

the steel supports he recommended were temporary

protection even though the steel supports, with back- '

packing above, had to forever remain embedded in the

concrete, supra, pp. 5, 6. Completely ignored was the ©

fact that under paragraph TP4-02 temporary protet-

tion was, required by the contract solely for thé protec-

_ tion of the workmen, and ony. during the process of

tunnel excavation.

_ The contract specifications provided that the perma-

nent tunnel protection be installed beyond the 50 feet

from the portals where ‘‘required’’ or ‘‘directed’’ by

the Contracting Officer, supra, p. 4. It was conceded

by respondent’s design engineer that the words ‘‘re-

quired’’ or-‘‘directed’’ were inserted in the specifica-

mG

13 .

tions to cover the possibility that conditions would be

encountered at the tunnel site differing from those rea-

sonably to be expected, and which would require the

installation of the steel supports beyond the 50 feet

from the tunnel portals (R., p. 133). This testimony.

confirms the reasonableness of the basis on which the

contract was bid, that additional tunnel protection

- would be directed before concreting if needed, supra,

~p. 4.

=

were required for the permanent support of the tunnel

is in direct violation of the engineéring design of this -

tunnel, and it imposes on petitioner a burden of proof

- for which there is no warrant an the.record, or in the

' decision of the Board. The Court states:

We find it impossible to say that the Board could —

-not properly conclude that the steel ribbing and,

; plates were not required for the continued support

of the tunnel (emphasis supplied) (App., p. 12a,

line 5)

Nowhere does the Board decision indicate any con-

clusion on its part that the tunnel supports which peti-

tioner installed lost their essentially permanent -char-

- acter merely because they did not fulfill the function. .

of providing continuing support of the tunnel struc-

ture, which means support after the completion of the

work:. Nor was this function contemplated or required |

under the contract..: - Sa

Petitioner submits that the decision of the Court

below is fundamentally erroneous because it is based

upon a determination of ‘the issue whether the steel:

supports were necessary for the permanent support of

the tunnel, an issue not presented to and not considered ~

_ The holding of. the Court of Claims that no recovery

is proper unless it can be said that the steel supports

o>:

#4

i the Board. J udicial review is limited to the i issues

presented to the administrative agency. In Securities ©

& Exchange Commission v. Chenery Corp., 318 U.S. 80, |

87 (1943), the first Chenery case, this Court states. _

\. The .grounds upon which:an administrative order

must be judged are those upon which the record dis-

closes that its action was based’’. In the second Chenery '

- ease, 332 U.S. 194, 196 ca08t), ' this Court amplified its —

previous statement:

When the case: was first ue we ; letead a

simple but’ fundamental rule of administrative law.

* » hat rule is to the effect that a reviewing court,

-- in dealing with a determination or judgment which

- an administrative agency alone is,authorized to

‘make, must judge the propriety of such - action

. gsolely:by the grounds invoked by the agency. If

‘”.. those grounds are inadequate or improper, the

Court is powerless to affirm. the administrative

action by substituting what it considers to be a

more adequate or proper basis. |

es (2) The decision below applied the substantial ‘evi-

| dente rule, and thereby attached finality, tothe con-

tracting agency’s interpretation of the. specifications

as applied to admitted facts, a question of law.

"The Wunderlich Act permits finality for adminis-

trative decisions only on questions of fact, -as distin-

- .guished.from questions of law, supra, pp. 2,3. Gen--

- erally, questions of igterpretation of. contracts are not —

‘questions of fact’’ within the meaning of that expres-

sion as it is written into disputes articles of govern-.

- ment contracts, but are questions of law to be decided

- by the Court. Wunderlich et al v. Umted States, 117

Ot: Cl.,92, 212-214, reversed on other grounds 342 U.S..

98, and cases there cited; Bell Aircraft Corp. v. United

States, 120 Ct. CL. 398, affirmed 344 U.S. 860; ——

15

: Shipbuilding Co. v. United States, 122 Ct. Cl. 72, 97;

Associated Traders, Inc. v. United States, 144 Ct. Cl.”

744, 750-751. |

The Claims and Appeals Board interpreted the

“Temporary Tunnel Protection’ provision (Par.

T'P4-02) of the specifications as\ embracing any steel

supports with backpacking above, which are needed to

' protect the structure of the tunnel in the course of the

‘ Installation of thé concrete lining, even though both

the’ steel supports and backpacking had to remain em- ___

bedded in the concrete forever. This interpretation is

Implicit in the Board’s finding that: © .

. . . Vertical joints encountered at three central

locations representing less than 100 feet of tunnel ©

length could have been supported with relatively |

little temporary protection. (R., p. 176),

when considered with the admission of respondent’s

- expert witness that the steel supports he deemed neces-

‘ sary, similar: to what ‘were installed by petitioner,?: .

_ were for this purpose and met these tests. 3

* The Contracting Officer by letter of 13 June 1947 (Exhibit N -

before the Board, R., p. 248) recommended that adequate protection

_ would be obtained by using throughout the length of the tunnel

- Steel T beam ribs of about 3 inches and 6 lb. weight; spaced 4 to 8

* feet apart, with two-inch timber lagging. This was in lieu of the

contractor’s recommendation that the same size steel ribs and liner

plates as were prescribed and used at the portals be used throughout

the central portion of the tunnel. The Contracting Officer took the

position that this type of installation was considered an overdesign

for the purpose required, and therefore would be more costly than

» he considered necessary. He recognized and admitted the necessity .

for support throughout the entire length of the tunnel. The type

of tunnel protection recommended by the Contracting Officer is in

its very make-up identical with that contemplated under paragraph

TP4-03 ‘‘Tunnel Protection’’ in the contract specifications’ Never-

theless, he interpreted the specifications by characterizing it as

**temporary’’. | ’

soe

16

.The Board preceded the above finding by quoting the

contract provisions for Temporary Tunnel Protec-

tion dnd for Permanent Tunnel Protection, com-

menting on these provisions. (R., pp. 169-173). The

Board’s conclusion that only ‘‘temporary tunnel pro-

tection’’ was required necessarily involved an inter-

pretation of these provisions of the specifications, ‘as

applied to admitted facts. Petitioner submits that this

was a question of law.

The Court of Claims applied the substantial evidence

rule to the Board’s interpretation of the specifications

im the following language:

. the critical issue remains the necessity for

steel supports throughout the length. On that

question the Board’s conclusion that ‘vertical

joints encoun at three central locations repre-:

mesg Bye 100 feet of tunnel length could

have beén supported with relatively little tempo-

rary protection’’, seems buttressed by substantial

evidence. _(App., p. 12a, 1st full par., line 8)

_ The decision below upholds the Board on the ground

. that there was a conflict in the testimony of petitioner’s

and respondent’s expert witnésses which the Board had

a right to resolve in favor of respondent. (App., p..

lla). The decision properly states that the critical

issue is the necessity for steel supports throughout the

length of the tunnel. However, confining this critical .

factual issue to the 100 feet of tunnel protection, apart

from the question of interpreting the specifications,

there is no conflict whatsoever between the testimony of

‘any of petitioner’s and respondent’s witnesses. In

limiting the tunnel. protection installed to Mr. Me-

Gavock’s 100 feet no question of fact is involved, but

17

only a question of law which can be resolved within the |

four corners of the specifications.

If petitioner’ s contention thatthe steel supports

which. respondent’s expert deemed necessary consti-

tuted permanent tunnel protection rather than tempo-

rary protection, under the specifications, be sustained,

the only remaining real issue is how much additional

tunnel protection, other than the respondent’s expert’s |

100 feet, was required before the concrete lining of the —

tunnel could be accomplished. Although the words:

* “permanent tunnel protection’? do not appear in the

contract or the specifications, the issue before the Con-

tracting Officer and before the Board was ‘whether

“‘permanent tunnel protection’’ under paragraph TP4- |

03, or ‘‘temporary tunnel protection’’ under paragraph

TP4-02 of the contract specifications, was required

throughout the length of the tunnel b re it would

be possible to line it with concrete. That this was the ©

issue. is apparent from the opening statements of .

counsel for both parties, from the testimony and ex-

hibits of.record, and from the decision of the Board.

(R., pp. 77-81, 153-161, 171-176).

The Court of Claims disposes of the issue: of jie :

‘much additional tunnel protection was needed, over and

above Mr. McGavock’s 100 feet, by. eoneluding that

_ rockfall in the downstream half, uninspected by Mr.

McGavock, could have been averted by scaling. (App.,

p. 12a) This conclusion is based on the Court’s com-

‘parison of total rockfall in five 30-foot Monoliths with

three such Monoliths in the upstream half of the tun-

nel, which is in.effect the expression of an expert opin-

ion for which there is no warrant in the record. Had re-

spondent’s expert witness expressed this opinion, and

had petitioner ‘been deprived of the right of cross

‘examination or siesta this would — been a serious

error.

18

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully sub-

mitted that the petition for a Writ of Certiorari be

granted.

ROBERT F. BRADFORD

53 State Street -

Boston, Massachusetts 02109 .

aa Attorney for Petitioner

Wuuiam H. MarrHews |

821-15th St, N. W..

Washington, D. C. 20005

| Of Counsel

May 7,196. ©

Si Sie 3

oe ‘

Fae 8

la

APPENDIX

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF CLAIMS

a ie

(Decided July 17, 1964)

Carto BiancHi ann. Company, Inc. v. THE Unrrep States

William H. Matthews for plaintiff. Robert F, Bradford

on the briefs. —

_ Gerson B. Kramer, with whom was Assistant Alterna

General John W. Douglas, for defendant.

Before Jones, Senior Judge, Rezp, Justice (Ret.), sit-

ing by designation, LarAMOrE- and DuRFEE, ani

“Opinion | eo

Reep, Justice (Ret.), sitting by designation, delivered the

- opinion of the court:

_ In 1946 the plaintiff contracted with the ieotencanbsiah to

. construct a flood control dam in upstaté New York: Inci- |

dent to the project was the construction of a tunnel 710 |

_ feet long with a diameter of 13 feet after concreting. The

contract called for steel ribs and liner plates to be installed

as tunnel support in the 50 feet at each end of the tunnel.

_ .No other protection than the concreting was provided for

the central 610 feet. Plaintiff deemed it necessary to pro-

vide steel support for the entire length. This suit is for the

large additional expense allegedly involved. in installing

ribs and liner plates beyond the 50 feet at each mouth.

The plaintiff’s request for authority to use permanent

_ steel supports throughout was first presented by-letter to

2a |

the contracting officer in April 1947, before the supports had |

been installed. The officer refused to authorize the addi-

tional expense on the grounds that the contractor had Been ..

furnished full information as to rock conditions at the

tunnel site, that the contract limited steel support to one

hundred feet, and that the contract placed the cost of pro-

_ tection of the safety of workmen during construction on the

contractor. An appeal was taken to the Board of Claims

and Appeals of the Corps of Engineers, While that appeal

was pending ‘the plaintiff installed the supports for which

compensation was claimed.

In June .1948 the Board held a — and in December

of that year it rendéred its decision denying plaintiff’s

claim.’ In 1954 plaintiff timely instituted this action in

this court. In this suit, varying the claim presented to

the Board for estimated costs of installing the support,

plaintiff requested a. total of $233,425.25 costs allegedly in-

curred as a consequence of the government’s refusal to au-

thorize support throughout the tunnel. The primary issue

here, too, is the necessity for the additional support. Plain- ~

- tiff does not contend that this issue is not one of ‘‘fact’’

under the standard ‘*Disputes Clause” in plaintiff ’s con-

tract:

“Except as dhiiotin rere provided in this con-

tract, all disputes concerning questions of fact arising.

under this contract shall be decided by the contracting

officer subject to written appeal by the contractor within .

30 days to the head of the department concerned or

’ his duly authorized representative, whose decision shall

be final and conclusive upon the parties thereto. In

the meantime the contractor shall agus proceed

with the work as directed.”?

1The Board’ s decisions are not officially aieiiiil The opinion ©

is to be found in the printed record, in the Supreme Court, Carlo

“Bianchi v. United States, 373 U.S. 709, Record p. 166.

P of

.

. 3a

As the claim was presented under this clause, the suit is gov- .

erned by the ‘‘Wunderlich Act,’’? 41 U.S.C. §§ 321-322

(1958), which provides that the Board’s decision on mat-

ters covered by the Disputes Clauses ‘‘shall be final and

' conclusive unless the same is fraudulent or capricious or

arbitrary or so grossly erroneous as necessarily to imply

bad faith, or is not supported by substantial evidence.’

The ‘case was sent to a Commissioner who conducted a

-second hearing admitting. evidence not presented to ‘the

Board. The Commissioner recommended that plaintiff re-

‘cover. This court accepted the Commissioner’s findings

and conclusions, 144 Ct. Cls. 500, and, after receiving addi-

tional evidence on the question of damages, entered judg-

ment for plaintiff. 157 Ct. Cls. 432 (May 9, ee oN

The Supreme Court reversed, 373 U.S. 709 (1963), hold-

ing that the Wunderlich Act prevents de novo consideration

by a court where an administrative determination has been

made. Rather the Supreme Court held the reviewing court

-is limited to a determination whether there is substantial

evidence, based on the record’ develéped before the. Board,

to support the administrative conclusions.

The case was again sent to the Commissioner after re-

-mand from the Supreme Court decision. The Commis-

sioner, after examining the record of the Board hearing,

concluded that the Board’s finding for the government was

not based on substantial evidence.? The parties are agreed

that under the Wunderlich Act our scope of Peview i is the

same as that exercised by the federal cour® of appeals

under the Standards of Universal Camera Corp. v. Labor

Board, 340 US: 474, and its progeny.” .

2 Commissioner’s Determination Pursuant to Court’ s Order of

July 12, 1963, upon Remand from the Supreme Court of the United

States, filed November 4, 1963. “*. :

.**P1. Br. 40-45; Def. Br. 7-10. .

| 4a . |

The task -before this court under the Supreme Court

decision is to review the determination of the Board of

Claims and Appeals of the Corps of Engineers and decide

whether there was substantial evidence in the regord as a

whole before that Board to justify its conclusion. . In reach- .

ing our conclusion, we cannot disregard plaintiff’s evidence.

_ However, even though we might have decided as an original -

meter with plaintiff on balfnce, the decision of the Su-

preme Court requires us to go further and uphold the

Board’s decision if there was substantial evidence to sup-

port the Board’s decision on the record as a whole.

Plaintiff and defendant are agreed that the original con-

tract called for steel ribbing only in the 50 feet of the'tunnel -

nearest to each end. Plaintiff contends, however, that the

‘ condition of the rock was such that steel ribs and liner plates

were required throughout the tunnel. Accordingly, plaintiff -

contends that recovery should be granted under paragraph

TP4-08 of the specifications, which provides that ‘‘ Payment

for all costs of furnishing and placing liner plates, and tun-

~ nel supports, * * * specified herein or directed by the Con-

tracting Officer, will be made at the applicable unit price

**¢ > Plaintiff contends that the evidence establishes

| that ‘the officer should have directed the installation of .

the liner plates and ribs involved, and- therefore that the

. government should pay for the support.— Plaintiff also

pra to TP4-03, which. provides:

- TP4.03. Tunnel Protection.—a. Bikee= _The tunnel

' protection shall be furnished and placed as required for

. distances of approximately the first 50 feet at each end.

of the tunnel which includes the underground portion

of the outlet transition. Such tunnel protection con- -

forming to‘the cross-sectional shape of the tunnel and

transition, shall consist of steel arch ribs and corru-

.

gated steel liner plates a® indicated on the drawings -

or required, including tie rods and spreaders. eer

. [Italics © supplied]

5a

_ As an alternative theory, plaintiff ‘argues that the condi-

tion of the rock was sufficiently different from that revealed

by test borings to show the supports became necessary by

virtue of changed conditions within the meaning of Article 4

of the contract:- ‘ Ny:

“Article 4. Changed Conditions—Should the ¢on-

tractor encounter, or the Government discover, during.

the progress of the work subsurface and/or latent con- ~°

ditions at the site materially differing-from those

shown on the drawings or indicated in the specifications,

or unknown conditions of an unusual nature differing ©

materially ‘from those ordinarily encountered. and ae

generally recognized as inhering in work of the .char- *

acter provided for in the plans and specifications, the

attention of. the contracting officer shall be éalled im-

mediately to such conditions before they are disturbed.

The Contracting Officer shall thereupon promptly in-

vestigate the conditions, and if he finds that they do so

materially differ the contract shall with the written

approval of the Secretary of War or his duly author-

ized representative, be modified to provide for any in-

_ erease or decrease of cost and/or difference in time

resulting from such conditions.” ars His

The Board rejected plaintiff’s d@ntention that it had en-

countered changed conditions. The Board held that the

testimony indicated that the job could have been completed

with the aid of temporary supports at vertical joints in the

rock. Under the contract ‘‘temporary”’ supports are not to ;

be computed as -pay items. It was further thought that

plaintiff’s delay from the holing out in March until De-

cember 1947 when the concreting was started: had contrib- —

uted to the rockfall that had dpcurred in the turinel, and

that. the rockfall after the ho ing out was not excessive.

The. Board also found that the failure to undertake con-’

ereting promptly and air slaking due to the failure to séal

. up the tunnel were the cause of what it, termed ‘‘gradual

deterioration’’ of the rock. a:

6a °

The Commissioner found these conclusions unwarranted.

First, the conclusion that ‘‘temporary’’ supports would be:

~~ adequate for the protection of the workmen was rejected.

~™Phe ommissioner apparently took the position that. be-

‘ eause backpacking would be used even with wooden lagging,

‘ o + ‘and the backpacking would ultimately be encased in con-

crete when the tunnel was grouted, such support. could —

not be deemed ‘‘temporary’’ under the specifications. Fur- ~

ther, the photographs introduced by plaintiff showed sub- —

' stantial amounts of rockfall in the period shortly after the

tunnel holed ut. * The Commissioner.agreed_, with the) —

plainti that this demonstrated the threat of tockfall into |

% -. .wet or uncured conerete.if the gh had been under-

taken’ immediately. And last, the Co oner disagreed

that the plaintiff had contributed to tiecttan by failing

properly to seal up the tunnel while awaiting the grouting

process. The Commissioner held that the provision of the

contract that the tunnel shall be ‘‘adequately lighted and

wentilated’”’ prevented any sealing to prevent temperature |

- and humidity changes from causing rockfall. Farther, he _

thought the all was to a large extent in pieces |

- too large to have: n caused by air slaking. if

-.- We are unable with the Commissioner that the

' Board’s conclusions..were unsupported by substantial evi-

dence. The plaintiff, in order to recover, must establish

either that changed conditions were encountered within the

meaning of Article 4 quoted above, or that the permanent ~

steel ribs and liner plates were necessary to the completion |

' of the tunnel and therefore should have been directed by the

cont, ‘officer under paragraph TP4-08. We do not

consider the view ‘of the Commissioner that the failure to

: ‘ seal! up the tunnel is an inadequate basis for denying

recovery on the evidence adduced before the Board. We -

hold that the Board was warranted in finding that no chang-

ed conditions were encountered necessitating the support

and that the contracting officer was not required under the’

circumstances to direct the installation of steel ribs and liner

_— throughout the tunnel.

.

EA Oh AO eh Ne APRIL Des hg tM ae TL hima te ate i tie

i Ta can . |

The testimony before the Board consisted of the views

of four witnesses for ” plaintiff and three soi the

: government. ’

' ‘Thomas A. hiv, the plaintift *s onan superintendent,

testified that the nature-of the rock did not change as the

tunnel was dug deeper. Vertical joints in the rock appeared

every 3 to 5 feet. Earlier test borings had not revealed .

_- these joints because no borings had been made at an- angle.

| Because of winter weather, the grouting was not started has

- as soon as the tunnel was holed out. By April the roof of

the tunnel had started to fall,and ‘by August the volume of

fallen’ rock had reached 203 cubic yards. | Temporary sup-

ports’ would riot have been feasible because: it would not.

have been practicable to remove the backpacking that would

have been necessary. The contractor ..would have beén.

required to encase the backpacking in-concrete during the

grouting process. Mr. Coyne had had no prior experience _

- in tunnels of this length.

_ Elford H. Richardson, plaintiff 5 chief engineer, testified

‘that there was no data as to the dates on which the rock

fell, but that over the entire March to August period some

203 cubic‘yards fell, including some that had to be servary 2

for the installation of liner plates.

Everett Diehl, the chief engineer of the subcontractor that ;

excavated the tunnel, testified that weakness in the roof had —

been noted from the outiet. Steps were taken in blasting

to avoid éausing rockfall, and the tunnel was holed out -

without incident. The rockfall between March 12 and the

end of the clean-up on March 25 was approximately 60 cubic

yards in Mr. Diehl’s estimation. The total -volume of the

- excavation was 6,000 cubic yards. Mr. Diehl could not esti-

mate whether 3% (203/6000) was. an excessive fall because

he had had no prior experience in unsupperted tunnels of

this length. Mr. Diehl also testified that. the resident engi-

'.neer told him at the time of the excavation that the only

circumstance under which permanent support would be

authorized would be if it became necessary to. prevent the

4%

| ie

collapse of pet tunnel ii i.e., to prevent the failure of the -

tunnel itself. _

Irving | . Crosby, plaintiff *g siiittiais quent’ testified

¢

‘that he Visited the dam in April 1948, At that'time the

tunnel was largely lined with concrete, but some 140 feet -

were unlined. The steel ribs and liner plates were installed —

- throughout. The liner plates were so installed that. Mr.

Crosby could see “‘almost to the crown of the roof.’’ Mr.

“Crosby expressed the view that the rockfall was chiefly due

to the fracturing of the rock: The rock contained parallel

systems of fractures intersecting at.more or less right.

angles. .These fractures were not indicated on the contract

drawings and there was no way of knowing that the roof .

conditions would be so bad. If no support was provided, it

would have been likely that rock would have fallen through _

the wet concrete.

‘The first PORE 2 witness was David 0. Congteton,

chief of the Dam Design Section of Baltimore District.

He had had some 15 years experience in tunnel construction.

He testified that no likelihood of rockslide was seen except

_ at the ends of the tunnel where the 50 feet of ‘permanent

steel supports were provided. It was assumed that the roof

would stand without further scat once ths: concrete lin-

. ing was installed.

-C. B. McGavock, J r., & wetligiet with the Baltimore Dis-

© trist, testified that he examined the tunnel in June 1947,

before the support was installed. He estimated at the time

that he examined ‘‘the upstream half’’ of the tunnel, but

- did not see the remainder of the tunnel because of water.

He later testified before the Board that he examined all

but about 200 feet. He stated that the rockfall was largely

in three.areas comprising about 100 feet in total. These

areas were where intersecting joints occurred at particu-

| ~~ larly acute angles. Soms form of “temporary”? “support. —

would be necessary in these places, but as to the remainder

of the tunnel there was ‘no reason why it could not safely be |

grouted without support. Scaling with the jumbo would

| \

a weisits

be necessary.” Mr. McGavock also expressed the view that :

if the tunnel had been sealed up to prevent outside air from °

_ entering during the period after the cleaning up, much of

' cfhhe expansion causing the rockfall that did occur would not

‘have taken place.

- The last witness was Donald. Mather, the government's

resident engineer on the project. He testified that the con-.

tract required steel lining only where necessary for the —

support of the tunnel on a permanent basis. Support: neces-

‘sary for/the workmen’ while concreting was the regponsi- —

! bility of the plaintiff under TP4-02.* - also expressed

<TP4.02, Tuiinel Mentvetlen a. seals The tunnel. ‘hare

may be driven from either or both ends by any of the usual methods

of tunneling, provided the driving is continuous and progress is

consistent with that indicated on'the progress schedule. Temporary

tunnel protection shall be provided where required for safety of

the workmen and shall be placed ‘progressively after e eading

-. blast and prior to resumption of excavation and p tions.

The tunnel shall be maintained free of water by 1 sf

and sump pumps. Tunnel dust shall be kept under-proper con- -

trol by wet-drilling and sprinkling. The tunnel shall be adequately

lighted and ventilated. Only electric or air motorized equipment -

shall be used in the tunnel, An adequate power supply shall be’

available at all times. All rock projections ‘inside the tunnel neat

~ line shall be removed and-overbreak_beyond-the-tunnel-pay- line

' shall be backfilled with approved material, compacted to the re-

quired density without cost to the Government. Where and as the

arch ribs and liner plates are placed to the designated grade and

alignment, the overbreak ‘Voids at the. crown and haunches shall -

be progressively backpacked‘ with selected tunnel excavation in a

‘way that will hold the completed tunnel protection on line and

grade. Where such tunnel protection is not required all overbreak -

beyond the tunnel pay line shall be backfilled with concrete. Such —

work shall be done together with placing of the concrete tunnel

_. lining. After the conerete tunnel lining is in place and prior to

* tunnel and collar grouting the entire length of the tunnel shall be

grouted at a pressure not to exceed five pounds to complete filling

remaining overbreak voids. Such grouting including furnishing

and placing of grout pipes wil], not be paid for as a unit and all

costs shall be included in the contract unit price for tunnel con-

erete lining. Disposal of tunnel excavation shall be in accordance

_ with subparagraph TP3-Old.”’ |

_

10a | |

: the view that there was no eid for any permanent protec

_¢ion. Temporary protection was probably necessary in

. some parts of the tunnel where the roof was weak. He

testified that the rockfall:that occurred was not unusual.; If

he had found unstable rock in the middle of the tunnel _

similar to that at the portals he would. have authorized

steel ribs and liner plates. ,

It.appears to us that it cannot m= said that the Board’s

“decision was without substantial support in the record.

Whether the steel ribs and plates were necessary for the

maintenance of the tunnel was the Central issue. On that

‘question Mr*Crosby testified for the plaintiff and Mr. Mc- ’

-Gavock for the government. Both men wére. qualified

geologists. “They disagreed on the cause of the rockfall—

Crosby attributing it largely to ground water and Mc-

Gavock to expansion from contact with the air. ' But:

<=, MeGavock’s unequivocally expressed judgment was that

Bad only temporary support was necessary at three areas of

major rockfall. Crosby does not directly controvert this

judgment. The strongest statement that he made was in

the following excerpt : Bh oe,

____MoCannow- {plaintiff's counsel]? Will you tell us

whether or not, in your opinion, the contractor could

have lined this tunnel without the use of some form

- .of permanent tunnel support, having in mind the char-

acter of the rock, without siamese or damage ” the

concrete lining? . | ;

Crossy: You mean, could oe lined it ‘eithinal

leaving some support in there? site

McCarron: Assuming-no “support was ‘provided at

all, would it have been possible for him to line it with —

concrete without having falling rock? |

Crossy:- I think in some cases they might have gone ©

through the concrete and crashed to the. floor which

~—,would-have left voids in the concrete which would have

been exceedingly detrimental to the permanent safety

of the tunnel.’”’ — | |

| lla .

_ It appears that Crosby did not express his views on the

necessity of the type of support, temporary or permanent,

steel or some less expensive substitute, but rather that he at

best. expressed the view that some-sort of support was neces-

sary. It is not clear’ whether that support was thought

_ necessary while the concrete was hardening or whether it

was deemed necessary for the Renee support of the

tunnel,”

We hive here a catyfitet 3 in 1 testimony by witnesses shown

to have had enough knowledge of tunnel construction to

- Imake them ‘competent to express ° conclusions | to the

necessity for extension of: the steel supports. the

distances called for by the contract. ° It is situations such as

this that call forthe application of the rule that where there

is substantial: evidence to support varying decisions, the

conclusion of the Board’ of Claims and agpeeet of es Corps

of Engineers must stand: .

That the backpacking iit be bial} in uebilie after

the grouting does not, in our View, render the support ‘‘per-

‘55. Mmanent?’ rather than “‘temporary. *? The specifications con-

_ templated that the contractor bear the burden of ‘‘tempd-

rary’’ support ‘‘for the safety of workmen.’’ The inference

seems plain that the contractor was left to its own devices to

_ protect its men in the course of the construction. . The sup-

port for which the government agreed to pay was that which

was necessary to the maintenance of the tunnel. Unless it

can be said that tue steel ribs and plates were required for:

____the permanent support of the tunnel, no recovery is proper:

_ This interpretation seems inescapable to us when the ‘pro-

vision of TP4-03, referring to ‘‘tunnel ‘protection’? and

specifying steel ribs and plates in the 50 feet at each end,

is compared with TP4-02, dealing with the excavation pro-_

cedure and calling for ‘‘temporary tunnel protection * * * .-

where required for the safety of workmen.”? _

The latter form of support is not compensable, while the

' former is, under iain Had. the contract mene

: payment ferrwupbetts designed only ¢ to ‘ici the ee Ney

while the job was being ‘completed, it seems reasonable:td. es

suppose that TP4-08, or some ee one would jee

_have made this express. .— Ne

‘We find it impossible to say that the Board could not

properly conclude that the steel ribbing and plates were not bh vagy.

required for the continied support of the tunnel.. The. ——

Board’s views or ithe cause of the rockfall that oceurred

from March to August do not constitute the basis of our

affirmance. Whether the: fall was due to the contact with

the open air or not, and whether or not plaintiff should have |

sealed the tunnel while.no work was underway, the critical

~~jssue remains the necessity for steel supports throughout

the length. On that question the Board’s conclusion that

‘vertical joints encointered at three central locations rep- .

resenting. less than 100 feet of tunnel length could have

‘. , been supported with relatively little temporary protection,’’ -

seems buttressed by substantial evidence.

Plaintiff urges that the testimony of their Mr. Richard.

son, as well as photographic evidence, shows that there were

9 or 10 areas of major rockfall. Accordingly, plaintiff con-. —

tends that the view of Mr. McGavock, the government’s ~~

\ geologist, that there were three areas covéring less than 100

‘feet requiring temporary support i is untenable. But as Mc- .

~Gavock testified, he-entered only one-half of the tunnel. ‘As

such, his testimony would be expected to relate only to one-

half. An examination of the rockfall by area in the tunnel

. shows that plaintiff ’s own data shows thrée monoliths in the

upstream half of the tunnel, each 30 feet of tunnel length, .

‘at stations 25+-74, 26-+04, and 26+-34, with rockfall above 5

- . “eubie yards. There are 5 such monoliths in the downstream

half, uninspected ‘Dy McGavock, but these. show | a total rock-

ex fall about equal to that in the three upstream monoliths.

It does not appear to us to be demonstrated that the lesser

rockfall in the other areas could not have been averted by

sealing, or was.even dangerous. Again we must. conclude

that the question presented to the Board was one calling

a

; 13a Ss

for the exercise of judgment-and one on which-we may not

_ Substitute our guess for the conclusion of the administrative

bey. eS, a Gen a sng MpstekG wel)

| _ Plaintiff also suggests that the Board could not/accord - —

~ greater credence to McGavock’s testimony than to Crosby’s. |

~ McGavock entered only one-half‘thedunnel. Further, in a

- contemporaneous report he stated that the bedrock was -

’, ‘thin bedded, hard gray sandstone * * * with interspaced

‘partings and zones of black, fissile shale.’ Before the

Board McGavock described the rock as ‘“‘siale of the me-

chanical sedimentary type.’’ - Plaintiff suggests that be.

cause of this discrepancy, McGavock’s testimony must be

discredited. We do.not agree. N. thing was made of this

point on cross examination. As hi are ‘not geologists, the

extent or import of the asserted discrepancy is at. best

'/ ° obscure. We cannot say that the Board was compelled to

' disregard McGavock’s opinion on this basis. -

It is'pertinent that Crosby’s testimony is also subject to

' some skepticism in ‘that he entered the tunnel for the first

_ time in 1948 when all but 140 feet had been lined. with con-

_ ¢rete and steel ribs,and liner plates had been installed

throughout the tunnel.® | ® Ea g °

; wi: 3 fete a aa

‘The last.issue.in the case, whether the Board was war-"

ranted in concluding that:there were no changed conditions, ©

seems to us. to fall equally into the area reserved to. the

administrative agency. The government produced testi-

mony by McGavock that anyone familiar with the area and

the type of rock should know that-there wauld be joints

throughout the rock. Crosby testified that the fracturing

system could not be anticipated to be so bad. ‘The borings

did not reveal the joints for the obvious reason that they

__were taken only vertically, i.e., parallel to the joints them-

selves. Again this‘seems to be an issue on which there was '

. conflicting expert opinion. Plaintiff does. not raise any

: ° See note 1 above and page 120 of the printed record referred

- “to therein. a ‘& i. 2 : .

yw

l4a

_-we cannot say that the Board was without support in adopt-

ing McGavock ’s view over Orosky’ 8.

_ specific refutation of McGavock %s testimony and therefore - ©

Farthermore, the issue, even if the rock tractuftig were 7

> unable to be anticipated, remains whether the changed con-‘

” dition required the installation of the steel supports. On.

that issue, as we have stated, we find the Board’s oo.

clusions adequately supported.

- The purpose of the adoption of the rule of the Wunderlich

fre. submitting determinations of technical disagreements

~ betwéen parties to government contracts to boards familiar -

with the subjects of such:contracts, was to have determina-

tions by experts. No charge of fraud arisés in this case.

The conclusion of the Board has substantial support in

the record as a whole and must be upheld. * Judgment is”! :

entered for the ‘defendant and ac ogat pear es is dis-”

4 \ CONCLUSION OF LAW

Upon the foregoing opinion which incindée therein the

findings of fact made-by the court as a part of its judgment

| _ herein, the court concludes as a matter of law. that plaintiff -

is not entitled to recover, and its’ petition is therefore

dismissed.

Davis, Judge, took’ no part in the consideration and -

decision of this ¢ case.

a]

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.