Appendix — Sheffield v. Brooks

Supreme Court brief1965

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

=)

APPENDIX A.

Decree.

United States Court of Appeals, for the Ninth Cir-

cuit.

Pacific Power & Light Company, Petitioner, vs. Fed-

eral Power Commission, Respondent. No. 18853.

Department of Fish & Game of the State of Cali-

fornia, Petitioner, vs. Federal Power Commission, Re-

spondent. No. 18954.

Before: Pope, Merrill & Duniway, Circuit Judges

These causes came to be heard upon petition of Pa-

cific Power & Light Company filed August 22, 1963

and the petition of the Department of Fish & Game

of the State of California, filed October 16, 1963 to re-

view an order of the Federal Power Commission is-

sued by it on March 14, 1963 and as amended by a

further order issued on August 19, 1963. The Court

heard argument of respective counsel on March 9, 1964

and has considered the briefs and joint appendix filed

in this cause.

On consideration whereof, and pursuant to the opin-

ion rendered and filed, on June 8, 1964, It Is Ordered,

Adjudged and Decreed by this Court that said causes

be and hereby are remanded to the Federal Power Com-

mission for further proceedings, not inconsistent with

the opinion of this Court, relating to the cost of oper-

ating and maintaining the fish trapping and egg tak-

ing facilities, and for such clarification of Article 50 as

it may desire to make. In -!! other respects, the or-

ders of the said Federal Power Commission be, 2nd here-

by are.affirmed.

A True Copy

Attest: August 21, 1964

Frank H. Schmid, Clerk.

|

Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for

the Ninth Circuit.

United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Cir-

cuit.

Pacific Power & Light Company, Department of

Fish and Game of the State of California, Petitioners,

vs. Federal Power Commission, Respondent. Nos. 18- ©

853 and 18,954 [333 F. 2d 689].

[June 8, 1964]

On Petitions to Review an Order of the

Federal Power Commission

Before: Pope, Merrill and Duniway, Circuit Judges

Duniway, Circuit Judge:

These are petitions, consolidated for hearing and de-

termination, to review a decision of the Federal Power

Commission. The order in question relates to the Iron

Gate Dam on the Klamath River in Northern Cali-

fornia, a facility constructed by petitioner, Pacific Pow-

er & Light Company (Pacific) under a Commission li-

cense. Pacific attacks the portion of the order that

requires it to construct, at its expense, a fish hatchery,

and to reimburse the Department of Fish and Game of

the State of California (Department) for 80 percent

of the cost of operating the hatchery and of operating

fish egg taking facilities already constructed. The De-

partment also attacks the order, urging that Pacific

should be required to pay 100 percent of the cost of

the operation of these facilities, with one exception.’

'1The Department voluntarily consents to bear operation and

maintenance costs of Iron Gate Fishery facilities that may be

incurred for all king salmon egg taking at Iron Gate over

15,800,000 annually. and 19% of the quantity up to that figure.

It asserts that it has not agreed to bear any costs with respect

ame ee

The Klamath River, which rises in Southern Ore-

gon and flows into and across California to the Pacific

Ocean, has long been a famous fishing stream, sup-

porting large numbers of anadromous fish: king sal-

mon, silver salmon and steelhead trout. Pacific’s prede-

cessor, the California Oregon Power Company (Cop-

co), constructed five hydroelectric plants on the river

and its tributaries, between 1908 and 1925. None was

licensed by the Commission; three were constructed be-

tore the enactment of the Federal Water Power Act

on June 10, 1920.

Two of the plants, Copco No. 1, built in 1918, and

Copco No. 2, built in 1925, are located close together on

the river and about 100 miles from the sea. Their con-

struction cut off access to spawning areas above them,

and Copco and the State of California therefore agreed

that Copco should build a fish hatchery at Fall Creek,

just below Copco No. 2, and an egg taking station.

The hatchery was conveyed to the state, which operated

it at its own expense, until 1948, when it was aban-

doned. Thereafter, eggs taken at the station were trans-

ported by the state to its Mt. Shasta hatchery.

Cepco No. 1 and No. 2 have been operated as peak

load facilities. Water was released downstream only

when it was desired, because of demands on the Copco

system, to add their power output. This has resulted

in sudden and extreme fluctuations in the flow of the

to species other than king salmon, or 81% of the king salmon

eggs up to 15,800,000 annually.

The Department takes this distinction based upon its historical

assumption of operation and maintenance costs of the now

abandoned Fall Creek facilities and facilities substituted since its

abandonment. However, this distinction becomes irrelevant in

view of the conclusions we reach, infra.

_

river, which, in turn, has been detrimental to the fishery

and hazardous to human life. While Copco claimed

that its operation in this manner had continued so long

that it had a prescriptive right to continue it, the state

took a contrary position, and sought to prevent the

operation as a public nuisance. In 1950 it filed suit for

that purpose. (See California Oregon Power Co. v.

Superior Court, 1955, 45 Cai.2d 858, 291 P.2d 455).

In 1951, Copco applied to the Commission for a li-

cense to construct another facility, called Big Bend No.

2. The Commission then issued an order requiring it

to show cause why all of the existing facilities should

not be brought under license. (See California Oregon

Power Co., 10 F.P.C. 1561) In 1954, the Commission

held that all of the facilities were within its jurisdic-

tion. (13 F.P.C. 1; 15 F.P.C. 14; California Oregon

Power Co. v. F.P.C., D.C. Cir., 1956, 239 F.2d 426)

The 1954 order left open the question whether a license

should require the installation of re-regulating facilities

at Iron Gate.

In 1957, Copco asked for a license, Project No. 2082,

for the existing facilities, and also for an amendment

of the license to authorize the Iron Gate development,

for two stated purposes, production of power and regu-

lation of the flow of the river. Thereafter, in 1959,

Copco and the state entered into an agreement which

refers to the state’s pending lawsuit and Copco’s pend-

ing application for a license for Iron Gate. It recites

that Iron Gate will regulate the flow of the river in

the manner desired by the state, and that the desire

of the parties is to facilitate the issuance of the license.

Copco agrees to proceed with the development as soon

as licensed, and to release water from it in a manner

RO MC ne Pr om

a ee

specified. The agreement, paragraph 3, also provides:

“Copco shall construct permanent fish trapping and egg

collecting facilities at or near and downstream from the

Iron Gate development, . . . and title thereto, . . . shall,

upon completion of the facilities, be conveyed by Copco

to the State;”.

Copco received from the siate a dismissal, with preju-

dice, of its lawsuit, and a release. It agreed, pending

construction of Iron Gate, to “manually operate” Copco

No. 1 and No. 2 so as to limit downstream fluctua-

tions. The release is: “. . . from any and all claims,

demands, actions and causes of action, for any and all

legal and equitable relief arising at any time in the

past, and for such reasonable future time as may be

necessary for construction of the Iron Gate develop-

ment referred to in said agreement by reason of alleged

conduct of Copco of the kind described in the com-

plaint in an action in the Superior Court of the State

of California, in and for the County of Siskiyou, No.

13995.” The agreement states, in reference to the re-

lease and dismissal: ‘The parties hereto understand

and agree that the effect of said dismissal with preju-

dice and said release will be that no claim will ever be

made against Copco in the future for damages or any

other relief arising out of any act or omission of Copco,

up to the date of this agreement so long hereafter as

Copco shall perform its obligations under this agree-

ment, of the kind embraced within the complaint in

said state court suit; but that the prosecution of any

action hereafter brought, claiming relief by reason of

alleged wrongful conduct uf Copco occurring after the

date of this agreement, shall not be prejudiced there-

by.” It also provides: “The State, the Department and

~~

the [California Fish and Game] Commission shall forth-

with cause to be withdrawn and dismissed all protests

and interventions with respect to the pending applica-

tions of Copco before the Federal Power Commission

in Project No. 2082, and before the State Water Rights

Board in Application No. 17,527; provided, that the

right is reserved to all parties hereto to be heard in any

future proceedings in regard to fishery facilities, other

than the fish trapping, and egg collecting facilities re-

ferred to in paragraph 3 thereof.” It does not state

-t whose expense the fish trapping and egg collecting

facilities are to be operated. Pacific asserts that con-

veyance of title to the state means that the state is to

operate them at its own expense, particularly because

the reservation of the rights to be heard in future pro-

ceedings in regard to fishery facilities expressly ex-_

cepts the fish trapping and egg collecting facilities.

Pursuant to the agreement, the state, the Department

and the California Fish and Game Commission with-

drew their protests and interventions in the Commis-

sion’s Project No. 2082, and the Commission issued its

license for Iron Gate in January, 1960. (23 F.P.C.

59; 25 F.P.C. 579). The order amends the license for

Project No. 2082 to include the existing facilities, and

to authorize Iron Gate, all as part of a single project.

Article 30 contains the following reservations: “The

Commission reserves the right to determine at a later

date after notice and opportunity for hearing, the fol-

lowing matters . . . (b) Whether the Licensee for

Project No. 2082 shall construct, operate and maintain

a fish hatchery and appurtenant facilities.”

Article 42 requires construction of the agreed-upon

fish trapping and egg collecting facilities. It is silent

—

on the subject of their operation. Article 43, on the

other hand, requires Copco to construct, maintain and

operate fish ladders, fish traps, or other fish handling

facilities or fish protective devices.

An amendment of March 27, 1961 adds Articles 49

and 50:

“Article 49. The Licensee shall construct, main-

tain, and operate or shall arrange for the construc-

tion, maintenance, and operation of artificial prop-

agation facilities and such other permanent fish

facilities and protective devices including, but not

limited to, fish-hauling trucks, fish screens or lad-

ders, and comply with such reasonable modifica-

tions in project structures and operation in the ia-

terest of fish life as may be prescribed hereafter

by the Commission upon the recommendation of

the Secretary of the Interior and the California

Department of Fish and Game, after notice and

opportunity for hearing.

“Article 50. The Licensee shall construct, con-

currently with the construction of Iron Gate Dam,

and thereafter operate ard maintain permanent fish

trapping, collecting, holding, and spawn-taking fa-

cilities and appurtenances at or near and down-

stream from Iron Gate Dam as may be prescribed

hereafter by the Commission upon the recoramen-

dation of the Secretary of the Interior and the Cali-

fornia Department of Fish and Game, after notice

and opportunity for hearing.”

Articles 42 and 43 were eliminated. The license. as so

amended, was accepted by Copco.

In August, 1961, the Department petitioned, in Proj-

ect No. 2082, pursuant to Article 49, for an order re-

wells.

quiring Pacific to construct, operaic, and maintain a

hatchery adjacent to the egg collecting station. The pe-

tition does not ask that Pacific be required to pay the

cost of operating the egg collecting station. Pacific

denied that a hatchery was necessary or appropriate,

and the matter was heard on these pleadings. Pacific

and the Department stipulated as to the size and type

of hatchery that would be built, if the Commission

should so order, but reserving Pacific’s claims that a

hatchery was not required and that, if required, Pacific

should not pay for it or for its operation. The power

of the Commission to require the construction and oper-

ation of fishery facilities, including a fish hatchery, rests

on section 10(a) of the Federal Power Act, 16 U.S.C.

§803(a), which provides that all licenses issued by the

Commission shall contain conditio:us;:

“That the project * * * shall be such as in the

judgment of the Commission will be best adapted

to c comprehensive plan for improving or develop-

ing a waterway or waterwavs for the use or bene-

fit of interstate or foreign commerce, for the im-

provement and utilization of water-power develop-

ment, and for other beneficial uses, including rec-

reational purposes; * * *” (Emphasis added)

The petitioners are agreed that the Commission is

empowered by this subsection to require the construc-

tion and maintenance of a fish hatchery. The basic

questions, then, are whether this is an appropriate case

for the exercise of that power, and if so, whether the

power has been properly exercised. Pacific also con-

cedes that the question of whether a hatchery should be

built was reserved, both in its agreement with the state

and in the Commission’s prior orders, and was properly

A ee Ne AN, eae Se

a eee

before the Commission upon the Department’s August,

1961 petition. Its contention is that the evidence does

not sustain the determination that a hatchery was

needed. We do not agree.

The evidence shows that one of the reasons for con-

structing the Iron Gate Dam was to regulate the flow

of the stream, so as to eliminate the extreme fluctua-

tions caused by the method of operating Copco Nos. 1

and 2. It was Copco that chose to operate them that

way. It could have abated the fluctuations by operat-

ing them in a different manner. It preferred the Iron

Gate Dam because this would assure the continued oper-

ation of Copco Nos. 1 and 2 as peak load facilities,

would create another source of power at Iron Gate

Dam itself, and would eliminate the fluctuations as the

state was seeking to require, both in its lawsuit and

before the Commission. The fact that the state, which

had been seeking to abate what it claimed io be the

nuisance created by Pacific’s method of operating its

two facilities, decided to accept this method of abate-

ment, does not make the choice that of the state rather

than that of Pacific. At most it makes it the choice

of both. When parties settle a controversy, the settle-

ment is ordinarily not forced by one upon the other—

usually it is a result somewhere between the desires of

either.

The way in which these objectives were accomplished

was by the building of a dam at Iron Gate, some 8

miles below Copco No. 2. This created a reservoir

area some 8 miles long, into which flows the irregular

discharges from the two Copco facilities, and in which

they are held. The power plant and dam at Iron Gate

are then so operated as to maintain a reasonably conr-

—10A—

tinuous discharge of water below Iron Gate. ‘This

does eliininate the fluctuations below Iron Gate, and

does improve the fishery below Iron Gate.

There is, however, another result. The new reservoir,

above Iron Gate, submerges some 16 miles (about 8

on the Klamath; about 8 on its tributaries) of the bet-

ter fishing and spawning grounds on the river. It

covers them with comparatively still water, and 1¢nders

them unfit for spawning, and less desirable as habitat.

The evidence supports, though it may not require, a

finding that most fish headed upstream and reaching

the barrier of Iron Gate Dam will not turn back down-

stream to spawn, and that a substantial percentage (per-

haps over 50%) of the fish moving upstream will be so

affected. The fish could not testify. The commission

had to rely upon studies by, and the opinion tcstimony

of, expert biologists. In the nature of things, preci-

sion in prediction was quite impossible. But as we

read the record, we think that it fairly supports the

Commission’s conclusions that “without a hatchery there

can be no assurance that the fishery resource will be

preserved and maintained at a level approximately

equal to that which existed prior to construction of the

Iron Cate Development” and that “[s]ince Licensee has

created the situation which necessitates the fish hatch-

ery, it is no more than reasonable to require that it

pay the cost of construction thereof.”

We have no doubt that the Commission could re-

quire Pacific to construct the hatchery at its own ex-

pense. Pacific’s operations, as a unit, substantially

interfere with the ratural ecology of the river and dele-

teriously affect one of its most valuable recreational]

features. It is quite proper that, as a condjtion to its

—l1A—

having the privilege of so doing, Pacific should be re-

quired to pay for facilities that will, at least in part,

prevent the impairment of the principal recreational

feature of the stream.

The Commission’s orders do not directly require that

the hatchery be conveyed to the State, as the contract

between Pacific (Copco) and the state requires that the

egg taking facilities be conveyed. But this result is

certainly implicit in the order, else why the requirement

that Pacific reimburse the Department for 80 percent

of the cost of its operation and maintenance? At oral

argument, counsel for Pacific stated that it would prefer

to own and operate the hatchery itself. This, however,

seems to be an afterthought. We cannot find in the

record any indication that it seriously urged this con-

tention Lefore the Commission. There, its position has

been (a) that no hatchery is needed, (b) that if one

is needed, Pacific should not be required either to build

it or pay for it, and (c) that in any event it should

not be required to pay for maintenance and operation.

It does not now urge that the state is not able or wil-

ling to operate the hatchery properly.

Assuming that the contention is available to Pacific,

we cannot say that it is improper for the Commission

to require conveyance of the hatchery to the state. The

state and federal governments are not such separate

entities, either legally or in fact, that one cannot call

upon the other tc help to achieve, in the public interest,

a result that they both desire. The objective that the

Commission seeks here is one that Congress has author-

ized it to seek. The choice of means, so long as they

are reasonably adapted to achieve the authorized end,

is not for Pacific, but for the Commission. There is

—12A—

no doubt, upon this record, as to the competence of

the state to operate the hatchery, or its willingness to

do so. If there be evidence in the record that Pacific

is equally able and willing, it has not been called to

our attention.

There remain the questicns of the expense of main-

tenance and operation (1) of the hatchery and (2) of

the egg taking facilities. As to the hatchery, we think

that what we have already said disposes of the ques-

tion. If the Commission could have required Pacific

to build and itself to maintain and operate, and if, as

we have held, it could require conveyance of the hatch-

ery to the state, it can also require that the state be

reimbursed for the expense of maintenance and opera-

tion. Unless the hatchery is maintained and operated,

its construction means nothing, and the desired end,

preservation of the fishery, will not be achieved.

Pacific’s reply is, first that the Commission is med-

dling in matters that are beyond the scope of the Fed-

eral Power Act, and is acting in contravention of state

laws. It says that, if no funds were provided by it,

the Department would still be required by state law to

operate the hatchery at its expense, and that therefore

the Commission’s order improperly interferes with the

fiscal affairs of the staie, and unlawfully imposes upon

Pacific a burden that, under state law, Pacific is en-

titled to have the state bear. It says, second, that its

settlement agreement with the state gives it a contract

right to have the state maintain and operate the hatch-

ery. P

In support of its first argument, Pacific cites Sec-

tion 5938 of the California Fish and Game Code. That

section provides :

Se ee eee reo

—13A—

“Whenever in the opinion of the [California Fish

and Game] commission it is impracticable, be-

cause of the height of any dam, or other condi-

tions, to construct a fishway over or around the

dam, the [California Fish and Game] commission

may, in lieu of the fishway, order the owner of the

dam completely to equip, within a specified time,

on a site to be selected by the department, a hatch-

ery, together with dwellings for help, traps for the

taking of fish, and all other equipment. necessary

to operate a hatchery station, according to plans

and specifications furnished by the department.

After such hatchery has been constructed, the de-

partment shall operate it \‘ithout further expense

to the owner of the dam except as provided in sec-

tions 5940 and 5941.” (Emphasis and bracketed

words added.)

It was first enacted in 1917 (Cal. Stats. 1917, ch. 749,

§1), before the Federal Water Power Aci. and on its

face deals only with hatcheries ordered constructed by

the state. It does not purport to deal with federally li-

censed projects. Here, it is the Commission, not the

state, that ordered the hatchery constructed. The De-

partment’s request that the Commission do so does not

make the order the state’s order. Indeed, we think it

doubtful that the state could have ordered this federal

licensee to construct a hatchery at this federally licensed

facility. We think there is nothing in Pacific’s first

contention. Nor is there anything in Pacific’s argu-

ment that the Department has no authority to receive

or use the funds required to be paid to it. We doubt

if Pacific has any standing to raise the question. Sec-

tion 13,011 of the California Fish and Game Code does

not support Pacific’s arguments.

—14A—

The short answer to Pacific's second contention is

that there is nothing in the agreement with the De-

partment, or the release, that requires that the Depart-

ment, rather than Pacific, pay for the operation or main-

tenance of the hatchery. On the other hand, Article

49 of Pacific’s license does require Pacific to ‘‘con-

struct, maintain and operate, or . . . arrange for the

construction, maintenane and operation of artificial

propagation facilities . . . as may be prescribed here-

after by the Commission. .. .”

The egg taking facilities present a different ques-

tion. They were provided for in Pacific's agreement

with the Department, had been constructed and con-

veyed to the Department, and were being operated by

the Department, when the order under review was made.

We assume that Article *O reserves the question as to

who shall pay for operation and maintenance, as the

Department claims.” But we are of the opinion that

the contract, although it does not specifically refer to

maintenance and operation, contemplates maintenance

and operation by the Department, and that the reser-

vation in the contract relating to fishery facilities,

which specifically excepts these facilities from its terms,

does not reserve to the Department the right to de-

mand that maintenance and operation be paid for by

Pacific. The Department made a post hoc attempt to

2We are not, however, convinced that .t does. Article 50

refers to facilities of this kind that “may be prescribed here-

after . . . after notice and hearing.” Hereafter must mean

after March 27. 1961. when Article 50 was added to the li-

cense. The Commission had previously, in Articl 42, of Jan-

uary 13, 1960, ordered Pac ific to construct the agreed facili-

ties. They were completed and tendered to the state by Feb-

ruary of 1962. How, then. can Article 50 refer to them?

On its face, it appears to refer to possible on or addi-

tional facilities.

et es

—15A—

keep the question open by accepting the conveyance of

the facilities as agreed, but seeking to reserve the ques-

tion unilaterally. This, however, cannot change the ef-

fect of the agreement, although the Commission seems

to rely rather heavily upon it. We do not think that

Article 50 is a valid contrary determination by the

Commission. Nor does the original reservation in Ar-

ticle 30 of the license for Iron Gate reserve this ques-

tion. The Department’s petition did not ask for this

relief specifically.

It may well be that none of these facts, as a matter

of law, prevents the Commission from requiring Pacif-

ic to pay for the maintenance and operation of these

facilities.” But the existence of power in the Com-

mission does not dispose of the problem. The state ar-

rived at a settlement with Pacific, under which these

facilities were constructed and conveyed by Pacific to

it. The Commission, to that extent, saw to it that the

State got this benefit of its bargain. The state re-

served no right to make further demands in this con-

nection. We hold that it impliedly agreed to pay for

maintenance and operation. This, together with the

Commission’s orders relating to the hatchery, appears

to us, absent other facts, to assure the desired preser-

vation of the fishery. The Commission gives us no rea-

son in public policy why the Commission should now

transfer the burden to Pacific and relieve the -tate from

its bargain. We think that it would be justified in

so doing only if it found upon sufficient evidence that

®The Commission says that it is not bound by any agree-

ment between Pacific and the Department, citing F.P.C. v. Ore-

gon, 349 U.S. 435; First lowa Hydro-Electric Coop. v. F.P.C..

328 U.S. 152, and other cases. This, however, does not mean

that the Commission can arbitrarily disregard the contract.

—16A—

there are sound reasons to do so. It made no such find-

ing or determination. So far as its findings and opinion

reveal, it based its decision entirely upon what we hold

to be its erroneous legal conclusions, either (a) that

the state had not agreed to pay the cost of operation

and maintenance, or (b) that the state could unilateral-

ly relieve itself of its obligations, or (c) that Article

50 had the effect of relieving the state of its obligations.

The Commission now asserts in its brief that it is

not bound by the contract, assuming that it means

what Pacific says that it does and what we hold that

it does. We quite agree that this is not a private law-

suit between Pacific and the Department. We also

agree that the Commission is not “bound” by the

contract. We do not, however, think that this alone

is a reason for disregarding the contract.‘ As the

Supreme Court has said in Burlington Truck Lines,

Inc. v. United States, 1962, 371 U.S. 156, 167:

“There are no findings and no analysis here to

justify the choice made, no indication of the basis

on which the Commission exercised its expert dis-

cretion. We are not prepared to and the Adminis-

trative Procedure Act will not permit us to accept

such adjudicatory practice. See Siegel Co. v. Fed-

eral Trade Comm'n, 327 ~.s. 608, 613-614. Ex-

pert discretion is the lifeblood of the administra-

tive process, but ‘unless we make the requirements

‘The Federal Power Act. §$313(b) (16 U.S.C. §251/(b))

declares that this court, on review of an order of the Com-

mission, has jurisdiction “to affirm, modify or set aside such

order [of the Commission] in whole or in part.” The Adminis-

trative Procedure Act $10(e) (5 U.S.C. $19009(e)) directs that

this court shail “hold unlawful and set aside agency action,

findings, and conclusions found to be (1) arbitrary, capricious,

an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law.”

AL 8D ORS PTR A BAO I ALE A ACTED tts TN a

.

—17A—

for administrative action strict and demanding, ex-

pertise, the strength of modern government, can

become a monster, which rules with no practical

limits on its discretion.” New York v. United

States, 342 U.S. 882, 884 (dissenting opinion).

‘Congress did not purport to transfer its legislative

power to the unbounded discretion of the regula-

tory body.’ Federal Communications Comm’n v.

RCA Con:munications, Inc., 346 U.S. 86, 90.”

The Commission does not act in a vacuum, and we

thirk it just as much bound to take into account a

contract of this kind, which, if carried out, would as-

sist in accomplishing the result that the Commission de-

sires, as it is to take into account the topography of

the Klamath River Basin and the biological function-

ing of anadromous fish. Surely, it would be arbitrary

if the Commission had concluded, in the face of the

evidence, that the fish would spawn successfully in the

reservoir formed by the Iron Gate Dam, when al! of

the evidence is that they would not. ‘io here we think

it arbitrary for the Commission to disregard the con-

tract for no apparent reason. It has not found, and it

makes no attempt to point to any evidence that would

support a finding of reasons to disregard the contract

and thus relieve the state of its bargain.

There remains the Department’s contention that the

Commission could not require that it pay 20 percent

of the cost of maintenance and operation of the hatch-

ery. The Commission did not so order. It merely or-

dered that Pacific pay 80 percent. The Department

asserts that section 10(a) of the Act, quoted supra,

requires that the Commission impose the entire cost

upon Pacific. The section certainly does not do so ex-

—18A—

pressly. It merely requires conditions in the license

that, “in the judgment of the Commission,” will be best

adapted, inter alia, “for other beneficial uses, includ-

ing recreational purposes.” We think that this gives the

Commission wide latitude, and that its judgment should

not be disturbed unless exercised in an arbitrary manner.

Here the Commission determined that “[t}he evi-

dence in the record suggests that the regulation of the

flow of the Klamath River by the Iron Gate Dam com-

bined with the construction and operation of the hatch-

ery will result in a greater fish population than if

Iron Gate had not been built. This would stem from

the reduction or elimination of destruction of natural

fluctuation and river levels which will follow from the

construction of Iron Cte Dam and its operation in ac-

cordance with the year-round minimum releases required

by Article 52 of the license. To impose on the Licensee

the full costs of building and operating the hatchery

would not merely restore the status quo, but would

actually require Licensee to pay for enhancing the fish

production as compared with pre-Iron Gate conditions.

Apportioning 20 percent of the operating costs to the

Department will more nearly result in restoring the

status quo.” (Our emphasis)

The Department attacks this statement as inconsis-

tent with the formal finding thst the hatchery is needed

to compensate for the loss of spawning grounds above

Iron Gate, and is necessary to sustain the fishery at a

levei “approximately equal” to that which existed be-

fore the construction of Iron Gate. In this, the De-

partment is perhaps technically correct. We do not

think, however, that the matter should be treated with

such iron rigidity. As we have pointed out, the Com-

—19A—

mission was here dealing with predictions. The evidence

does indeed “suggest” what the Commission Says it

does. Even the finding on which the Department relies

deals only with conditions “approximately equal” to

pre-Iron Gate conditions. We do not think that the

Commission’s conclusion is unreasonable. We need not

consider the other bases for its order that are siated

in the Commission’s opinion. We neither approve nor

disapprove them.

We do think, however, that Article 50 of the license

is unclear in one respect. Rather than requiring Pa-

cific to pay the full cost of operating and maintaining

the hatchery at 80 percent of capacity, it requires that it

pay 80 percent of the annual cost of operation and

maintenance. Thus, if the Department chose to reject

the benefit of full capacity operation (a benefit that the

Commission does not claim that it can order the De-

pa: ment to accept) and operates at 80 percent, Pa-

cific would pay only 80 percent of 80 percent. This

appears to be inconsistent with the views expressed by

the Commission itself. We presume that the Commis-

sion intends that, so long as the Department operates

the hatchery at at least 80 percent of capacity, Pacific

should pay for the cost of operating at 80 percent of

capacity, but that in no event should Pacific be re-

quired to pay more than actual operating costs.

It may be that there is evidence now in the record,

o* that other evidence can be produced, that would jus-

tify the decision of the Commission as to the operation

and maintenance of the fish trapping and egg taking

facilities. That is a question for the Commission, not

for us. (Burlington Truck Lines v. United States,

supra; F.P.C. v. Idaho Power Co., 1952, 344 U.S. 17,

20-1)

= "ae

The matter is remanded to the Commission for fur-

ther proceedings, not inconsistent with this opinion, re-

lating to the cost uf operating and maintaining the fish

trapping and egg taking facilities, and for such clarifi-

cation of Article 50 as it may desire to make. In all

other respects, the orders of the Commission are af-

firmed.

Bt OD ele he OE ee eRe A ammewte S

—21A—

APPENDIX B.

[29 F.P.C. 478.]

OPINION NO. 381

PACIFIC POWER & LIGHT COMPANY,

PROJECT NO 2082

Opinion and Order on Petition to Require Licensee to

€onstruct, Operate, and Maintain a Fish Hatchery,

Amending License, and Directing Revised Filings

(Issued March 14, 1963)*

* * © * *

Commission Requires Licensee to Construct Fish Hatch-

ery at Its Iron Gate Dam to Compensate for

Spawning Areas Rendered Inaccessible by Dam’s

Construction. P. 482.

Before Commissioners: Joseph C. Swidler, Chair-

man; Howard Morgan, L. J. O’Connor, jr., Charles

R. Ross, and Harold C. Woodward.

Woodwara, Commissioner:

This proceeding arose before the Commission on <

petition filed August 21, 1961, by the State of Cali-

fornia, acting by and through its Department of Fish

and Game (Departm<nt), requesting that the Commis-

sion require Pacific Power & Light Company (Licen-

see), licensee for Project No. 2082, to erect and main-

tain a fish hatchery and appurtenant facilities. pursuant

*Initial decision appears on p. 487. Opinion 381-A, issued

August 19, 1963, 30 FPC [499].

‘By orders issued June 16, 1961, 25 FPC 1154, 1156. the

Commission approved a merger between Licensee and The Cali-

fornia Oregon Power Company (COPCO), Licensee being the

surviving corporation. Pacific Power & Light Company is sub-

ject to all conditions of the licenses previously issued to COPCO,

which includes Project No. 2082. The license for the project

expires February 28, 2006.

—22A—

to Article 49 of ihe license, to continue the normal

runs of salmon and steelhead trout which have been

displaced by Licensee's construction of its Iron Gate

Development on the Klamath River in northern Cali-

fornia. Licensee answered the petition on September

13, 1961, by denying the need for a hatchery or other

fishery facilities for the purpose stated, or that it should

be required to construct or maintain such facilities.

Pursuant to order of the Commission, a hearing was

held in San Francisco, California during June 1962.

The parties’ arguments were consistent with their plead-

ings, the Department presenting testimony of fish biolo-

gists regarding the present and anticipated deleterious

effects of the Iron Gate Development to support its

contention that the hatchery is vital to the preservation

of the fishery resource, while Licensee c!2imed that the

evidence as so presented and as contradicted by testi-

mony of its own biologist fails to establish that the

existing resource will not adequately be maintained with-

out the hatchery. The staff of the Commission adopi-

ed a position supporting the need for the hatchery and

its construction by Licensee but proposed that the De-

partment and Licensee share equally in the costs of

operation and maintenance.

On Nevember 14, 1962, the presiding examiner is-

sued his initial. or recommended, decision (infra) in

which he determined that Licensee should be required

to construct a fish hatchery facility at its expense to

replace the natural spawning grounds eliminated by

Tron Gate Dam, but that the cost of operation and

maintenance of the hatchery and of the other appur-

tenant facilities thereafter should be borne by the State

of Califoritia. Exceptions to the decision have been

Nate ihe cameron arent 5

ST Ose eI A later a ARS een thank")

—23A—

filed by each of the three parties, 1.e., Licensee, the

Department, and the Commission’s staff, and oral ar-

gument was held before the Commission on January 24,

1963, at the Department’s request Pursuant to leave

granted at the conclusion of the oral argument, Licensee

and the Department have submitted comments on state-

ments of fact made by opposing counsel, which mem-

oranda have been considered by the Commission.

In order to place the proceeding in its proper con-.

text, a brief recitation of the underlying factual back-

ground is desirable. As noted in the examiner’s de-

cision, the present controversy is the latest episode in

a protracted dispute between the Department and Li-

censee dating from 1918 and 1925 when the two hydro-

electric plants known as Copco No. 1 and Copco No. 2

were constructed on the Klamath River in California a

few miles below the Oregon border.? These dams were

too high to permit fish migrations and Licensee there-

fore constructed a hatchery a short distance below the

dams on Fall Creek, a tributary of the Klamath River,

conveying the facility to the State in 1919. In 1925

fish trapping facilities and an egg collecting station

were constructed and similarly conveyed to the State.

The Fall Creek hatchery was operated and maintained

until 1948 when it was discontinued as uneconomical.

Use of the trapping and egg collecting facilities was

continued until the construction of the Iron Gate De-

velopment, which includes new facilities for these pur-

poses.

“Representatives of the Department of the Interior and the

California Senate Fact Finding Committee on Natural Re-

sources were present a. the hearing but did not enter formal

appearances nor did they participate therein.

*The Klamath River in California and Oregon was held to be

a navigable water in the United States in The California Ore-

gon Power Company, 13 FPC 1, 12.

_")

Operation of the existing hydroelectric plants as peak-

loaded facilities with alternate storage and release of

large volumes of water produced severe changes in the

downstream river level and eventually led tu the filing

of a suit by the State of California in 1950 to enjoin

the abnormal fluctuations as a continuing public nui-

sance. Following a course of extended but inconclusive

litigation, Licensee filed an application in January 1957

for amendment of the license to authorize construction

of the Iron Gate Development, approximately eight miles

below Copco No 2, the primary purpose being to even

out the flows below the Copco plants. On July 27,

1958, Licensee and the Department entered into an

agreement under which the Department withdrew its

informal objections to the proposed Iron Gate Develop-

ment and acknowledged that the construction thereof

would serve to reregulate the flow of the Klamath River

in a manner satisfactory to the State. Licensee agreed

that it would construct the permanent fish trapping and

egg collecting facilities which are now a part of the

development. The necessity for the construction of a

fish hatchery at Iron Gate expressly was preserved for

future determination, Article 6(b) of the agreement

providing “* * * that the right is reserved to all parties

hereto to be heard in any future proceedings in regard

to fishery facilities, other than the fish trapping and

egg-collecting facilities... .’’ The agreement was made

a part of the record in the 1959 proceeding and was

relied on by the examiner in denying a finding pro-

posed py the Department implying a determination that

the hatchery was to be constructed as a condition of

the license.‘ No exceptions were filed to the exam-

423 FPC 61. 68.

Sa iets te ee ee ee ae]

Pate PUP He mt

—25A—

iner’s approval of the application for construction of

the Iron Gate Development, and on January 13, 1960,

the decision was adopted by order of the Commission®

On March 27, 1961, the Commission, pursuant to

application of Licensee, issued an order further amend-

ing the license to authorize certain requested changes in

design and in the timing of construction.® Articles

49 and 50, as presently constituted,’ were included in

the license at that time. These Articles provide as fol-

lows:

Article 49. The Licensee shall construct, maintain,

and operate or shall arrange for the construction, main-

tenance, and operation of artificial propagation facili-

ties and such other permanent fish facilities and pro-

iective devices including, but not limited to, fish hauling

trucks, fish screens or ladders, and comply with such

reasonable modifications in project structures and oper-

ation in the interest of fish life as may be prescribed

hereafter by the Commission upon the recommendation

of the Secretary of the Interior and the California

Department of Fish and Game, after notice and op-

portunity for hearing.

Article 50. The Licensee shall construct, concurrent-

ly wir'i the construction of Iron Gate Dam, and there-

after operate and maintain permanent fish trapping,

*The California Oregon Power Company, 23 FPC 59.

*/bid.. 25 FPC 579.

‘Analogous provisions were contained as Articles 42 and 43

in the 1960 license amendment, accepted by the Licensee on

January 26, 1960. Article 43. which was similar to present

Article 49, was incorporated after consultation with the U.S.

Fish and Wildlife Service and the Department, and in line with

a morlification suggested by Licensee in a letter to the Commis-

sion filed September 9. 1957. The March 1961 amendments

were accepted by the Licensee on April 10, 1961.

—26A—

collecting, holding, and spawn-taking facilities and ap-

purtenances at or near and downstream from Iron Gate

Dam as may be prescribed hereafter by the Commis-

sion upon the recommendation of the Secretary of the

Interior and the California Department of Fish and

Game, after notice and opportunity for’ hearing.

Construction of the Iron Gate Development, includ-

ing the fish trapping and egg collecting station, was

undertaken in February 1960 and completed in Jan-

uary 1962 at a claimed cost of approximately 8.4 mil-

lion dollars. In conformity with the license, an 18,000-

kilowatt generator connected to a 25,000-horsepower tur-

bine has been installed and is in operation.

One of the issues under dispute in the hearing in-

volved the size of the hatchery as proposed by the

Department. At the examiner’s request a meeting was

held between Licensee and the Department after con-

clusion of the hearing at which the parties signed a stip-

ulation agreeing to the specifications of the hatchery

facilities which would be built if required by the Com-

mission. The stipulation, filed August 17, 1962, is

without prejudice to Licensee’s position that there is

no need for a hatchery and that, if a hatchery is found

to be required, it is not liable for the costs associated

with the construction, operation, or maintenance there-

of. Construction of the fishery facilities as originally

proposed by the Department in 1961 was estimated to

cost $1,003,020. Although no computations have been

made as to the cost of the stipulated facilities, the fact

that the total weight of fish to be produced has been

lowered in the stipulation from 121,500 pounds to 50,-

000 pourds per year indicates that the cost of con-

struction will be substantially less than the million dol-

2 ne A Re Ale et eat Balt ASE le tn a ae?

—27A—

lar figure. The staff has estimated that annual op-

erating and maintenance custs will be reduced from

$95,256 which would have been needed to run the pro-

posed facility to approximately $54,278 for those stipu-

lated in the agreement,

Upon our consideration of the record and the oral

arguments presented by counsel, we are of the opinion

that the Licensee properly should be required to con-

struct a hatchery of the capacity provided in the stipu-

lation to compensate for the spawning areas which

have been rendered inaccessible by the dam’s construc-

tion. The costs of operation and maintenance of the

fish facilities, however, should not, we believe, be as-

sessed wholly against the Licensee. Instead, and assum-

ing that the Department will be the operating agency,

we shall direct Licensee to reimburse the Department

for 80 percent of the annual expenses incurred in the

operation and maintenance.

There is no question that the Commission has the

power to require construction of the requested facili-

ties by the Licensee. The question of jurisdiction over

Project No. 2082 was considered in the original Cali-

fornia Oregon Power Company case, 13 FPC 1,° and

was determined to vest in the Commission generally

under Part I of the Federal Power Act on the ground

of navigability of the Klamath River. In addition, the

Commission found that the project would utilize sur-

plus water from the Link River Dam, a “Government

dam” within the definition of Section 3(10) of the Act,

and therefore was subject to our licensing authority

“Opinion No. 266, 13 FPC 1, rehearing denied March 29,

1954, supplemental Opinion No. 266—A, 15 FPC 14, affirmed

239 F. 2d 426 (CADC, 1956).

—28A—

under Section 4(e). Inclusion of the Iron Gate De-

velopment with the previously constructed developments

was affirmed by the Commission in its January 1960

order. It is clear that the Commissiun may require the

construction, maintenance, and operation of fishways by

a licensee. Section 10(a) of the Act requires the Com-

mission, before issuing a license for hydroelectric de-

velopment, to find that the project shall be such as in

the judgment of the Commission will be best adapted

to a comprehensive plan of development of the water re-

sources for power and all other beneficial public uses.

This provision has been interpreted to embrace the con-

servation, preservation, and enhancement of anadro-

mous fish resources. and the Commission, on a num-

ber of occasions, has directed the inclusion of fish fa-

cilities in licensed projects where appropriate.’ —Li-

censee has conceded that the Commission has the power

and obligation ia the present proceeding “. . . to take

such measures as are reasonably necessary to preserve

fish and wildlife.”

The factual evidence presented by the Department is

amply covered in the examiner's decision and need not

be repeated herein. Alihough Licensee maintained

that the Department has not established the need for a

hatchery at Iron Gate. and questioned the accuracy of

the Department's estimates as to the number of fish

formerly spawning above the site of the Development, it

City of Tacoma, Washington 10 FPC 424 (1951):

Portland General Electric Company, 10 FPC 445 (1951); Idaho

Power Company. 14 FPC §5 (1955); City of Eugene, Oregon,

14 FPC 408 (1955); Pge! Sound Power and Light Company.

18 FPC 1496 (1956); Portlund General Electric Company, 17

FPC 58 (1957): Puget Sound Power and Light ‘Company, et

al., Projects Nos. 943 and 2114, Order Directing Modifications

in Rock Jsland Dam Fishways, issued October 24, 1962, 28

FPC 718.

= oo

admitted that some spawning and rearing areas have

been eliminated by the Dam’s construction. Licensee

argued, however, that normal runs will be sustained by

the spawning grounds located below Iron Gate. The ex-

aminer concluded that while the Department’s estimate

that 57.1 percent of the fish runs at Klamathon Racks

spawned above the Iron Gate site was open to question,

the estimates were the best available arid do support

the ‘ecessity for additional fishery facilities at Iron

Gate to replace the natural hatching and incubation proc-

ess that would normally have occurred in the lost spawn-

ing areas. He also found no apparent evidence in the

record to support Licensee’s assertion that the fish

would turn back on reaching the Dam and spawn down-

stream.

Licensee has continued in its exceptions to assert that

there is no evidence to support the finding that (1)

there are not sufficient spawning grounds elsewhere 11

the river tu support the runs which might have spawned

in the eliminated area, or (2) if there are such spawn-

ing grounds, they will not be used by the fish. Attack-

ing the Department’s estimates of the number of fish

formerly spawning above Iron Gate as “‘completely spec-

ulative,” it argues that without more definite evidence

the need for a hatchery has not been established with

adequate certainty. it also contends that the improve-

ment of conditicus for anadromous fish runs in the

river and of: the recreational potential’® in the upper

Klamath area resulting from the construction of Iron

Gate Dam more than satisfy the obligations of Li-

censee and its ratepayers to the public, stating :

14 reservoir of approximately 1,200 surface acres has been

created which is available to the public.

po.

In contrast to the public benefit already con-

ferred by the company and its ratepayers, the bene-

fit which might be realized by the construction of

further fishery facilities is insignificant. We

have already shown that there is no substantial evi-

dence in the record to support a need for a hatch-

ery. If no neeci cari be shown the prospect for

benefit is obviously small. In the face of these

circumstances, it is apparent that the point of di-

minishing return for investment of Lacensee’s dol-

lars in fishery facilities in the upper Klamath has

long since been reached. The Licensee cannot in

good conscience be required to pay more.

In support of its position that further expenditures

shou.d not be required of it for the development of nat-

ural resources, Licensee has cited certain of the past

decisions of the Commission. A reading of those cases

will reveal, however, that the Commission thoroughly

considered on each occasion the effect of the proposed

development on the anadromous fish population and

found either a negligible result or made suitable provi-

sion to insure the perpetuation of the fish resource.

Thus, in the Portland case,'’ the Commission rejected

a request for fish facilities more extensive than those

proposed in the application on a finding that the Des-

chutes River above the Pelton project site “. . . is not

now a relatively large producer of anadromous fish

and the likelihood of its becoming so in the near ‘Suture

is relatively remote.” The cost of fish facilities in-

stalled at the project may amount to over five million

110 FPC 445 at 150. The decisin of the Court of Ap-

peals vacating the Commission's order, 211 F. 2d 347. was in

turn reversed in F.P.C. v. Oregon, 349 US. 435, 75 S. Ct.

832.

seus SAS SBRBNET RAG, SPT

—31A—

dollars out of a total cost of approximately $20,575,-

000. In City of Tacoma” the Commission directed the

licensee to install various fish facilities at an estimated

initial cost of $7,100,000. The ultimate cost of facili-

ties and improvements for the fishery resources pro-

gram was expected to approximate $9,465,000 with an

annual cost of operation and maintenance estimated at

$610,000. It may be noted that the licensee proposed

to construct and operate extensive fish hatchery facili-

ties as a complement to the other fish protection meas-

ures. In City of Eugene,* the provisions in a con-

servation agreement between the licensee and the State

Game Commission were deemed adequate to provide pro-

tection ‘or the tis:.erv resource in view of evidence that

an-uromous and fresh ,.ater fish did not ascend the

iver to the project area. Finally, in the Jdaho case,“

a provision was included for the licensee’s construction

of fishery facilities in recognition that the proposed Ox-

bow, low Hells Canyon and Brownlee developments on

the Snake River “. . . would adversely affect the fish

and wildlife resources of the area, and particularly

the anadromous fish.” The decision shows that an ex-

penditure of about five million dollars was anticipated

for the fishery program, exclusive of a low barrier dam

which might be needed.

The cases relied upon by Licensee not only fail to

afford support for its claim, but serve to demon-

strate the importance attributed by the Commission to

the preservation of existing fish resources in the com-

1210 FPC 424, 428-432, 436-439, affirmed 207 F. 2d 391,

cert. deniec 347 U.S. 936. \

1314 FPC 408, 413, 418.

1414 FPC 55, 63, 77, affirmed 237 F. 2d 777, cert. denied

353 U.S. 924.

AE RL QE LIRR T NE EN PRS I RANE HS AY RI AF a Se atl

—32A—

prehensive development of the nation’s waterways. We

agree with the examiner that without a hatchery there

can be no assurance that the fishery resource will be

preserved and maintained at a level approximately equal

to that which existed prior to construction of the Iron

Gate Development. As brought out in the record, Li-

censee could have applied for zuthorization to change

its method of operation of the Copco plants, thereby

obviating the necessity for the reregulating facility

and leaving the spawning areas undiminished. For pure-

ly economic reasons it chose not to do so, and has

created an impassable barrier which the evidence indi-

cates will have a deleterious effect on the pre-existing

fish population. Moreover, tne evidence clearly estab-

lishes that construction and operation of the fish

hatchery and related facilities, whether of the cxtent

specified in the Department's petition or of the more

limited capacity called for in the stipulation agreements,

will not render the Iron Gate project economically in-

feasible.*

Licensee has excepted to a statement of the exam-

iner tying the hatchery to the Articie 50 facilities built

under the terms of the July 1959 agreement and since

conveyed to the State as elements necessary to a com-

plete fishery facility. In view of the fact that these

facilities were constructed solely to replace the trapping

Although suitable regulation of che river flow could have

been achieved through operating Copco No. 1 and Copco No. 2

as steady flow plants rather than as peak-load facilities and the

Commission could have directed Licensee so to modify its opera-

tions, this would have resulted in a loss of one-half of the

56,000 kw generating capacity of those plants. + s noted earlier,

Licensee has installed 18,000 kw capacity at the Iron Gate

Development. At $210 per kw, the average cost given by Li-

censee for its hydroelectric facilities, the loss of 28,000 kw

would have cost it $5,880,000.

—33A—

and egg collecting station formerly situated at Fall

Creek, the argument of Licensee that its assumption of

the cost of their construction should not influence the

determination regarding responsibility for the hatchery

construction costs is well taken and is accepted.

Since Licensee has created the situation which neces-

sitates the fish hatchery, it is no more than reasonable

to require that it pay the cost of construction thereof.

For this same reason, it must also be required to pay

for a substantial portion of the costs involved in the

operation and maintenance.of the facility. Only in

this manner will the taxpayers of the State of Cali-

fornia be saved from the imposition of a Surden in

the form of annual operating and maintenance expenses

arising from an election of Licensee in a situation

where an alternative course of action could have been

selected by it which would not have necessitated the

hatchery facilities. Licensee’s argument that it should

not be required to pay the cost of operation and mainte-

nance on the basis of Section 5958 of the California

Fish and Game Code and of the State policy as ex-

pressed therein is unavailing, as is its contention that

the question as to who shall pay these expenses “

is a matter between the State and the Cu>mny.”

Whether the State Legislature intended that the statu-

tory provision would be applicable to federally licensed

projects or, as alleged by the Department, the section

refers only to hatcheries constructed pursuant to State

requirement, is wholly immaterial since the Federal gov-

ernment, in its enactment of the Federal Power Act,

has occupied the entire field of licensing power projects

on navigable and interstate water, to the exclusion of

—itih—~

concomitant state jurisdiction."* That no residual or

supplementary control with respect to the determina-

tion of necessary provisions for maintenance of the

fish resource has been left to the states was indicated

in the passage of the Fish and Wildlife Coordination

Act,’’ which contemplates that power companies op-

erating under a federal license would be required to

make adequaie provision for fish conservation as a con-

dition of the license.

We are not convinced, however, that Licensee should

be required to pay the full costs involved in operating

and maintaining the hatchery and related facilities.”

Some sharing in costs already is envisioned in Item

No. i(c) of the stipulation as agreed to by the parties.

Reregulation in the flow of the Klamath River by Iron

Gate Dam will not only restore the downstream reaches

to the condition which existed prior to 1918 but will

also serve to diminish or possibly even eliminate de-

structive natural fluctuations in the river level, particu-

State of Washington Dept. of Game v. F.P.C., 207 ©. 2d

391; F.P.C. v. Oregon, 349 U.S. 435.

1716 U.S.C. 661, et sea.

1’Both the Department's brief and that of the Licensee in-

clude the question of responsibility for the costs of operation

and maintenance of the fish trapping and egg collecting sta-

tion among the issues to be decided herein. Licensee's statement

tha: the Department undertcok to operate these facilities and in-

dictating that the matter is settled is contradicted in the exchange

of correspondence between Licensee and the Department where-

in the latter was permitted to operate the facilities temporarily

in full recognition by both parties that such action was not de-

terminative of the issue as to their continued operation and

maintenance. The presentations made by the parties do not dis-

tinguish between the facilities on this point nor do they in any

way indicate that the matter is now ripe for decision. Our

determination herein with respect to operation and maintenznce

of the hatchery facility, accordingly, is also dispositive of this

issue.

—35A—

larly in these reaches contiguous to the Development.

To this extent, the river and the enjoyment thereof

by the people of the State of California will be en-

hanced over its original condition. Availability of the

Iron Gate Reservoir to the public for lake fishing, boat-

ing, swimming, and other recreational activities like-

wise indicates that the advantages to be derived from

Licensee’s election to construct the Iron Gate Develop-

ment are not all one-sided. In our opinion, an equitable

division of costs will be achieved, commensurate with

the benefits attained, if Licensee is required to construct

the hatchery and, again assuming State operation, to

pay the State for 80 percent of the yearly costs of .

operation and maintenance of all fishery facilities at

the Developmen’. Although we are unable to order the

State of California to assume the remaining 20 percent

of the operation and maintenance expenses, we believe

that the apportionment of costs as herein sef out is

reasonable and will be so considered by the State agency.

Apportionment of the costs in this manner also will

provide the State with a financial incentive to assure

economy of operation of the fishery facilities. More-

over, while no major difficulties are anticipated under

the arrangement, we shall retain continuing jurisdic-

tion to settle possible disputes which may arise over

the determination of the proper annual amount to be

charged Licensee by the State.

The Commission further finds:

(1) Iron Gate Development is a unit of Project No.

2082, licensed to Pacific Power & Light Company, and

is situated on the Klamath River, a navigable water

of the United States as previously found by the Com-

mission.

—36A—

(2) Iron Gate Development has been constructed by

Pacific Power & Light Company and is now in opera-

tion.

(3) Iron Gate Development blocks and prevents the

seasonal migration of anadromous fish to approximately

16 miles of spawning gravels in the Klamath River

and its tributaries between the Iron Gate Development

and the Copco No. 1 and Copco No. 2 hydroelectric

plants.

(4) To compensate for the loss of the spawning

areas described in Finding (3) hereof, a fish hatchery

should be constructed, operated, and maintained at Iron

Gate Development of a size and capacity to annually

hatch and rear 200,000 yearling steelhead trout to a

total weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds, 75,000 year-

ling silver salmon to a total weight not to exceed 5,000

pounds, 6,000,000 fingerling king salmon to a total

weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds, and 5,500,000 king

salmon swim-up fry; provided, not more than 12,800,-

000 king salmon eggs should be required to be accom-

modated in any year at the Iron Gate hatchery facility.

(5) Licensee has constructed a fish trapping and egg

collecting station at the Iron Gate Development of suf-

ficient size and capacity to obtain the eggs for supply-

ing a hatchery of the aforesaid size and capacity.

(6) Iron Gate Development will be economically and

financially feasible if the aforesaid fish facilities are

constructed, operated, and maintained in the manner as

hereinafter provided.

(7) The construction, operation, and maintenance of

a fish hatchery. as hereinafter provided. of the afore-

said size and capacity is necessary in the public interest

—37A—

to sustain the anadromous fishery resource of the upper

‘Jamath River at a level approximately equal to that

which existed prior to the construction of the Iron

Gate Development.

The Commission orders:

(A) The license for Project No. 2082, as amended,

is further amended tu provide as follows:

Article 49. The Licensee shall construct or arrange

for the construction, at its expense, of a fish hatchery

at iron Gate Development, together with supplemental

structures and ancillary equipment as detailed in the

agreement filed with the Commission on August 17,

1962, by the State of Califorma Department of Fish

and Game and the Licensee, of 2 size and capacity to

annually hatch and rear 200,000 yearling steelhead trout

to a total weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds, 75.000

yearling silver salmon to a total weight not to exceed

5,000 pounds, 6,000,000 fingerling king salmon to a

total weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds, and 5,500,000

king salmon swim-up fry; provided not more than 12,-

800,000 king salmon eggs shall be required to be ac-

commodated in any year. Plans for the aforesaid fa-

cility shali be prepared by Licensee, in cooperation with

the State of California Department of Fish and Game

and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Department of

the Interior, and shall be submitted to the Commission

for approval within 60 days of the issuance of this

order. The. facility shall be constructed within one year

from the date of approval of the plans by the Com-

mission.

|) om

Article 50. Licensee shall reimburse the State of

California Department of Fish and Game for 80 percent

of the combined annual cost of operation and mainte-

nance of the facilities and appurtenances constructed

pursuant to Article 49 and of the permanent fish trap-

ping, collecting, holding, and spawn-taking facilities and

appurtenances constructed at Iron Gate Dam. Should

Licensee and the State of Caiifornia Department of

Fish and Game fail to agree on the amount to be paid

by the Licensee for this purpose, the Commission re-

serves the right to determine the amount of such annual

payment, after notice and opportunity for hearing.

(B) Pending completion of the aforesaid facility,

Licensee shall take all reasonable measures to provide

for maintenance of the Klamath River fishery resource.

(C) To the extent not inconsistent herewith, the de-

cision of the examiner is affirmed.

(D) All exceptions to the decision of the examiner

not herein granted are hereby denied.

(E) This order amending the license for Project No.

2082 shall become final 30 days from the date of its

issuance unless application for rehearing shall be filed

as provided in Section 313(a) of the Federal Power

Act, and failure to file such an application shali con-

stitute acceptance of this order. In acknowledgment

of the acceptance of this order. it shall be signed for

Licensee and returned to the Commission within 60

days from the date of its issuance.

—39A—

INITIAL DECISION

UPON PETITION BY THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA TO REQUIRE LICENSEE TO CONSTRUCT,

OPERATE, AND MAINTAIN A FIS6H HATCHERY

(Issued November 14, 1962)

eee SUES ‘a cee ote oe ome ete « game = 00 mero

CALIFORNIA =

N =

ous on f

a a auas 4 % wala:

; ih

aA ,

Toon Gots Proje ry °

f& Sas

v

LEGEND

LMIAP OF

L DAM :

LEPER ALAMATH RIVER

@ Power HOUSE

E FIisH CowrTis STAT?IOW

"a

Levy, Presiding Examiner: This proceeding is before

the Federal Power Commission by reason of a petition

filed by the California Department of Fish and Game

(Department) on August 21, 1961, requesting that Pa-

cific Power and Light Company (Licensee) be required

to construct, operate, and maintain a fish hatchery at

its recently completed Iron Gate Dam (Project No.

2082) pursuant to Article 49 of the license.’

The Licensee, in its Answer of September 13, 1961,

denied the necessity for any fishery facilities to main-

tain normal fish runs in the Klamath River, or that it

should be required to construct or maintain such fa-

cilities. On January 30, 1962, the Commission issued

an Order setting the matter down for hearing and pre-

scribing certain prehearing procedures, including the

filing and exchange of prepared testimony and exhibits.

After the close of the hearing, held June 4th and 5th

in San Francisco, Licensee and the Department stipu-

lated, at the request of the Presiding Examiner, to the

details of fish hatchery facilities which would be built

if required by the Commission. The stipulation filed

August 17, 1962 (Appendix A), is without prejudice

to the Licensee’s position that there is no need for a

fish hatchery and that, in any event, it is not liable

for construction, operation, or inaintenance.

1Article 49 reads as follows:

Article 49. The Licensee shall construct, maintain, and oper-

ate or shall arrange for the construction, maintenance, and opera-

tion of artificial propagation facilities and such other perma-

nent fish facilities and protective devices including, but not lim-

ited to, fish-hauling trucks, fish screens or ladders, and comply

with such reasonable modifications in project structures and oper-

ation in the interest of fish life as may be prescribed here-

after by the Commission upon the recommendation of the Secre-

tary of the Interior and the California Department of Fish and

Game, after notice and opportunity for hearing.

soll pane

Background of the Proceeding

The instant proceeding is the latest episode in an

extended fishery controversy between the Department

and the Licensee? that goes back to the construction

in 1918 and 1925, of two hydroelectric plants known

as Copco No. 1 and Copco No. 2 on the Klamath

River in California just below the Oregon border (see

Map.) In lieu of a fish ladder the Licensee constructed

a fish hatchery at Fall Creek, a short distance do-yn

river and, under an agreement with the Department,

conveycd the facility to the State of California in March

1919. In 1925, the Licensee constructed and conveyed

to the State an egg collecting station at Klamathon some

15 miles downstream.

The Fall Creek hatchery was operated and maintained

by the Department until 1948 when “operations were

discontinued due to the high cost of maintaining the

installation and high operational cost of raising fish”.

(23 FPC 66) The egg collecting station was continued

in operation by the Department until the construction

by the Licensee of new egg collecting facilities in

March 1962, pursuant to Article 50 of the Iron Gate

license.*

“Licensee” also includes. where applicable, Pacific Power and

Light Company’s predecessor, California Oregon Power Com-

pany (Copco).

3Article 50 (25 FPC 579, 581) reads as follows:

The Licensee shall construct, concurrently with the construc-

tion of Iron Gate Dam, and thereafter operate and maintain

permanent, fish trapping, coijiecting, holding, and spawn-taking

facilities and appurtenances at or near downstream from Iron

Gate Dam as may be prescribed hereafter by the Commis-

sion upon the recommendation of the Secretary of the Interior

and the California Department of Fish and Game, after notice

and opportunity for hearing.

9?

ar~——-—

The hydroelectric plants were operated to meet peak

load requirements by alternately storing and releasing

water with increasingly severe downstream fiuctuations.

The Department maintained, and the Presiding Exami-

ner in the license proceeding found, that the fluctuat-

ing water levels “. . . have a decidedly detrimental effect

on fish and aquatic life.” (23 FPC 66)

In 1950 the Devartment filed suit to compel the Li-

censee to construct a regulating dam at Iron Gate. After

protracted negotiations and the commencement of li-

cense* proceedings to authorize the construction and op-

eration of a regulating dam, the Department and the

Licensee entered into an agreement on July 27, 1959,

Exhibit 62 in the license procéeding, under which the

Department withdrew its objections to the Iron Gate

development as proposed by the Applicant. The agree-

ment provided that the Licensee would construct a dam

at Iron Gate for the principal purpose of regulating

the flow of water in the Klamath River, and would

build fish trapping and egg collecting facilities in ac-

cordance with plans and specifications to be furnished

by the Department. The necessity for the construction

of a fish hatchery at Iron Gate was expressly reserved

tor future determination.° Paragraph 6(b) of the

*The full history of the proceedings in Project No. 2082 is

stated in 23 FPC 59, 62 (199). The license was iurther

amended at 25 FPC 579 (1961) so as to authorize changes in

the design from a concrete arch dam to an earth-filled dam,

the erection initially to its ultimate height. and reduction in the

size of the generator from 25,000 to 18,000 kilowatts.

5The Presiding Examiner denied a request by the department

for the inclusior in the findings of language which could be con-

strued as implying a determination that fish hatchery facilities

ought to be constructed as a condition of the license. (23

FPC 68, 71)

ee ee ee

Li I ete i te RNR the ae

A a

~=ARA—o

Agreement provides as follows:

The State, the Department and the Commission

shall forthwith cause to be withdrawn and dis-

missed all protests and interventions with respect

to the pending applications of Copco before the

Federal Power Commission in Project No. 2082,

and before the State Water Rights Board in Ap-

plication No. 17527; provided, that the right is re-

served to all parties hereto to be heard in any

future proceedings in regard to fishery facilities,

other than the fish trapping and egg collecting

facili‘ies referred to in paragraph 3 thereof. [Em-

phasis supplied. ]

Construction of the Iron Gate facility, in a single

Stage rather than the two stage construction originally

contemplated, was completed in January 1962 at a cost

in excess of $8,000,000. Of this amount more than

$700,000 was represented by the cost of building the

fish trapping and egg collecting facilities. The Iron

Gate Development as completed consists of an earthfill

dam about 173 feet high with crest elevation of 2,338

feet, a concrete side channel spillway of the overflow

type in the right abutment, a reservoir with normal

water surface at elevation 2,328 feet and a capacity of

about 58,000 acre-feet, a tunnel through the right abut-

ment which will serve as a sluice and diversion during

construction, an intake structure, a power conduit

through the left abutment, a penstock, a powerhouse

with one 25,000-horsepower turbine connected to an

18,000-kilowatt generator, a substation adjacent to the

powerhouse, a 66 k. transmission line extending to

COPCO No. 2 Switchyard, a fish ladder and fish trap-

ping facilities complete with appurtenant facilities, and

a

other electrical and mechanical facilities. The existing

fish facilities are being operated by the Department

temporarily, with the consent of the Licensee, pending

determination of responsibility for operation and

maintenance (See Exh. B attached to California’s Reply

Brief).

The Issues

The stipulation of August 17, 1962, covering the de-

tails of fish hatchery facilities, if required, leaves the

following issues for determination:

1. Are additional fish rearing facilities required at

Iron Gate to preserve aiid maintain the fishery resource

at a level approximately equal to that which existed

before the construction of the Iron Gate Development?

2. If so, who is responsible for construction, opera-

tion and maintenance of the fishery facilities?

The Evidence

The Department’s experts, fishery biologists Skiriner,

Croker, Bailey, Hill, and Fraser testified in substance

that the Iron Gate Development prevents access by sal-

mon and steelhead to about 16 miles of spawning gravel

between Copco Dam and Iron Gate which historically

has been utilized by anadromous fish to spawn and re-

produce, and that a hatchery is needed to replace these

spawning areas which have been eliminated by the con-

struction of the Iron Gate Development. Croker testi-

fied that the general trend of salmon runs above

Klamathon is downward (Exh. 11-A) and that, based

on live fish counts, aerial surveys, carcass and redd

counts, 57.1 percent of the fish passing Klamathon

spawned above Iron Gate.

Robert Macklin, the Department’s Supervisor of Fish

Hatcheries, proposed the construction of a fish hatchery

—45A—

at Iron Gate, based on runs of 15,000 king salmon at

Klamathon, designed to incubate, hatch, and rear an-

nually 200,000 yearling steelhead trout, 75,000 yearling

silver salmon, and 6,000,000 fingerling king salmon, to

a total weight of 121,500 pounds, at an estimated con-

struction cost of $1,003,020, and an annual operating

and maintenance cost of approximately $95,256. (Exh.

Nos. 6, 7, 8, 9)

Jj. C. Boyle, Licensee’s Vice President, testified in

support of the Company’s position. Licensee’s fishery

biologist, Dr. Hamilton, conceded the loss of spawning

and rearing areas eliminated by the construction of

Iron Gate Dam. His proposed hatchery facilities were

smaller and less costly than those proposed by the De-

partment. (Exh. Nos. 15-18, inclusive) The facilities

detailed in the stipulation (Appendix A) are also less

costly than the Department’s original proposals. The

total weight of all fish produced is reduced from 121,-

500 pounds to 50,000 pounds. The holdover of one

million fingerlings for fall release is eliminated. Reduc-

tions in construction costs are effected by the substitu-

tion of rearing ponds for nursery ponds, reduction in

the area required to accommodate the hatchery troughs,

the number of incubation trays, and the elimination of

all of the 14 nursery ponds originally proposed. The

Staff estimates that annual operating and maintenance

costs will be reduced from $95,256 to $54,278. (Staff

br. p. 11)

Discussion

1. Licensee maintains that the Department has not

established the need for a fish hatchery at Iron Gate,

and questions the accuracy of its estimates as to the

number of fish spawning above the Iron Gate Develop-

a)

ment. It argues that normal runs will be sustained by

spawning grounds below Iron Gate Dam. The testimony

indicates, however, that Iron Gate Dam, completed in

1961, prevents access by salmon and steelhead trout to

about 16 miles of spawning gravel, thereby eliminating

one of the most popular stream fishing areas in the

upper Klamath River. (23 FPC, 66, 67) Licensee’s fish-

_ eries biologist, Dr. Hamilton, conceded that “. . . the

Iron Gate reservoir has eliminated whatever salmon and

steelhead spawning areas existing between Iron Gate

and COPCO Dam...” (Tr. 246) and chat “. . . about

970 steelhead were trapped at the site this spring after

the Iron Gate egg-taking station was put into operation

on February 27, 1962.” (Tr. 278, 286)

The historic decline of Klamath River king salmon is

documented in Exhibit 11-A, the most detailed data of

record. While the accuracy of the Department's esti-

mate that 57.1 percent of the fish runs at Klamathon

spawned above Iron Gate may be questioned, these esti-

mates are the best available and do support the necessity

for additional facilities to replace the lost spawning

areas above Iron Gate Dam. I conclude that facilities

for the artificial propagation and the perpetuation of

the anadromous fish are required at Iron Gate to pre-

serve and maintain the fishery resource at a level ap-

proximately equal to that which existed before the con-

struction of the Development. The question remains as

to whether a hatchery is required at Iron Gate.

Pursuant to the agreement of July 27, 1959, and Ar-

ticle 50 of the Iron Gate license, (Project No. 2082).

Licensee has constructed fish trapping and. egg collect-

ing facilities which went into operation on February 27.

1962. The Denartment argues that withoui the fur-

Pe eee

—47 A—

ther construction of a hatchery, the egg collecting sta-

tion is incomplete since “the eggs cannot be simply re-

leased back into the river. It is needed as a substitute

for [the] natural hatching and incubation process that

would normally occur above the Iron Gate Dam had the

dam not been constructed” (Tr. 18) The Licensee

suggests that any fish which wou!4 penetrate the river

as far as the Iron Gate Dam will turn back to find suit-

able spawning grounds down river, and, if this does

not maintain the runs, the fish can be transported

downstream to other suitable spawning grounds. There

is no assurance, however, or evidence that a sufficient

number of anadromous fish reaching Iron Gate Dam

will turn back and spawn downstream; or that they

can be made to do so even if they are trapped and physi-

cally transported to downstream areas. In short, I am

unable to conclude from the evidence of record that the

upper Kiamath fish runs can be maintained at an

equivalent level without the construction of additional

fish rearing facilities. A hatchery® is the established

method of insuring that the eggs taken from the fish

at the trapping facility are properly incubated, hatched,

and reared. Licensee’s predecessor had constructed a

fish hatchery at Fall Creek in 1919, which was op-

erated and maintained by the Department until 1948.

I concluded, therefore, that fish hatchery facilities are

required to replace natural spawning eliminated by the

dam and to complete the fish trapping and egg collect-

ing station heretofore constructed at Iron Gate. Fortu-

nately, the parties have stipulated to the nature of the

*The Departn:ent’s witness, Macklin, testified that 15 hatch-

eries are being operated by the California Department of Fish

and Game. (Tr. 145.)

—, |:

hatchery facilities to be built if required. These faciii-

ties are described in Appendix A, attached hereto and

made a part of this decision.

2. The construction costs of the hatchery, as detailed

in the stipulation, should be paid for by the Licensee.

This is consistent with the agreement between the Li-

censee and the Department of July 27, 1959 (Exh.

62) pursuant to which the Licensee built the fish trap-

ping and egg collecting facilities. The hatchery will

expand the egg collection station into a complete facility

for the maintenance of the fishery resource of the upper

Klamath River. The agreement provides (para. 3) for

the conveyance of the “permanent fish trapping and

egg collecting facilities’ to be built by the Licensee,

“ . . and title thereto, together with the land upon

which they are situate . . .” to the State. Similarly,

the complementary hatchery should be conveyed to the

State tu be owned, operated, and maintained by the

Department as an integrated fishery facility. The cost

of maintenance and operation, however, should be

borne by the Department and the State which will

now own, control, and operate the entire facility.

The Department argues chat the 1959 agreement is

not conclusive since it did not expressly agree therein

to opera'e and maintain the fish facilities. The agree-

ment did leave open the issue of hatchery construction

and overall cperz ion and maintenance costs. These

are the issues to be resolved in this proceeding. -

Operation and maintenance by the State is suggested,

however, by the following considerations. Historically,

the State operated and maintained the Fall Creek fish

hatchery constructed by COPCO and conveyed to the

. TREE

—iA—

State in 1919, and the fish trapping facilities at Klam-

athon built by COPCO and conveyed to the State in

1925. The Fall Creek hatchery was abandoned’ by

the Department in 1948 as too costly. The Iron Gate

hatchery, which Licensee is now required to build under

this order, will substantially replace the Fall Creek

hatchery previously operated and maintained by the

State.

The Fall Creek hatchery was operated and maintained

by the State, as are all 15 State hatcheries, under the

California Fish and Game Code. Section 5938 thereof

provides in pertinent part:

Whenever in the opinion of the commission it

is impracticable, because of the height of any dam,

or other conditions, to construct a fishway over

or around the dam, the commission may, (n lieu

of the fishway, order the owner of the dam com-

pletely to equip, within a specified time, on a site

to be selected by the department, a hatchery,

together with dwellings for help, traps for the

taking of fish, and all other equipment necessary

to operate a hatchery station, according to plans

and specifications furnished by the department.

After such hatchery has been constructed, the

depariment shall operate it without further expense

to the owner of the dam except as provided in

Sections 5940 and 5941. [Emphasis supplied. ]

The Department argues that the Fish and Game Code

of California is inapplicable to a federally licensed

power project. The Federal Power Cummission has the

7After its abandonment, eggs taken at Klamathon were reared

at the Department’s Mount Shasta hatchery.

—S0A—

vuthority under the Federal Power Act, which it has

exercised in appropriate circumstances, to require the

construction, operation, and maintenance of fish facili-

tits by the Licensee as a condition of the license.

State law, policy, and history are, however, relevant

considerations in the exercise of such power. The

policy of the State of California, as set forth in its

Fish and Game Code, is to share in the expense of

maintaining fish runs, disrupted by the construction

of hydroelectric projects, by operating and maintaining

fish hatcher:2s constructed by the owner of the project

at his cwn expense. This policy is not in conflict with

the Federal Power Act or Coinmission policy. I see

no good reason why it should not be followed in this

proceeding.

Here the Department by agreement has obligated the

Licensee to convey to the State the fish trapping and

egg collecting station which it built and the Department

is now opetating. The fish hatchery when completed

should also be conveyed to the State so that its operation

can be integrated with the related fishery facilities.

State ownership and control of the Iron Gate fish

facilities should carry with it responsibility for the cost

of operai:on and maintenance. This is consistent with

California law, with sound fiscal policy, and with the

prior pattern on the Upper K!amath.

The Department argues that it is unfair and inequit-

able to burden California taxpayers with part of the

costs of generating power which is distributed and sold

interstate. It is not unfair, however, to require tax-

payers to participate in the maintenance of a natural

resource from which all benefit. The California legis-

te

—51A—

lature long ago decided to share in the expense of pre-

serving fish by operating and maintaining hatcheries

constructed by the owners of California dams. More-

over, the taxpayers of California also benefit from the

construction of license. )ower projects. The rate-

payers of California and Oregon may well ask why

they should be saddled in perpetuity with the unknown

and escalating costs of hatcheries operated by the

Department, without cost limitations, for the benefit of

all citizens and taxpayers. The objective of the Federal

Power Act is the maximum development of the entire

water resource including power and recreation® as well

as fish. ] am therefore compelled to reject the position

of the Department that the Licensee should, in addition

to constructing the hatchery, defray all operations and

maintenance expense The history of this project

and the facts in this proceeding suggest otherwise.

The Staff brief is silent in respect of who is to

bear the cost of operating and maintaining the egg

collecting facility at Iron Gate. The Staff proposes,

however, that Licensee and the State share equally in

the costs of operating and maintaining the fish hatchery

to be constructed at Licensee’s expense. The State

would continue to pay for the annual operating and

maintenance expense attributable to an annual average

of 3,000,000 Klamath River king salmon eggs presently

hatched and reared at its Mount Shasta hatchery for

release into the upper Klamath River.

Licensee and the Department oppose the Staff sug-

gestion; Licensee on the ground that it has no obliga-

*The Iron Gate Development has improved the recreational

facilities of the upper Klamath by creating a 1,200 acre reser-

voir available to the public. (Tr. 181-183.)

—52A—

tion to pay for half the operation and that the Staff

proposal is a compromise® “unsupported by law or

reason”. The Department argues that hatchery con-

struction should not be conditioned on their acceptance

of the obligation to operate and maintain the facility.

I have concluded for all the reasons previously discussed

that the Department should pay for the entire cost

of mainta‘ning facilities it will own, control, and operate

in conjunction with numercus other hatcheries through-

out the State.

ADDITIONAL FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS

Upon consideration of the entire record in this pro-

ceeding, including the pleadings, the evidence adduced,

and the briefs filed, it is found and concluded in addi-

tion to the findings and conclusions heretofore stated

that:

(1) The erection of the Iron Gate development

eliminated approximately 16 miles of natural spawning

grounds previously used by king salmon, silver salmon,

and steelhead trout.

(2) A fish hatchery, the details of which are de-

scribed in a stipulation filed with the Commission on

August 17, 1962, (Appendix A), is required to sustain

the anadromous fishery resources of the upper Klamath

River at a level approximately equal to that which

existed before the construction of the Jron Gate +)s-

velopment.

(3) The public interest in the conservation and the

development of the fishery resourcés affected by the

®The Licensee points out (Reply br. p. 3) that sharing costs

will create serious allocation problems with respect to adminis-

trative overhead and other costs associated with running the

Department and its facilities throughout the State of California.

saints Cites mii _—_

Pe ee ee ee el

—53A—

Iron Gate Development requires the construction of the

fish hatchery by the Licensee, and its ownership, oper-

ation, and maintenance by the Department as herein-

after provided.

ORDER

WHEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED, pursuant to

Articles 49 and 50, Project No. 2082, as amended,

subject to review by the Commission that:

(A) T'e Licensee shall provide for a site and

arrange for, and pay for, the construction of a fish

hatchery as described in the stipulation filed herein on

August 17, 1962, (Appendix A).

(B) Plans for the aforesaid facilities shall be pre-

pared by the Licensee, in cooperation with the State

of California Department of Fish and Game, shall be

submitted to the Commission for approval within 60

days of the issuance of this Order, and shall be con-

structed within one year from the date of approval by

the Commission. Upon completion of the aforesaid

facilities, all the fish facilities shall be conveyed by

Licensee to the State; provided that the Licensee shall

not be required to reimburse the State of California

for the cost of operation and maintenance.

William C. Levy,

Presiding Examiner.

[Appendix “A” to the Presiding Examiner’s decision

(Stipulation re size of hatchery) omitted. ]

re

=)

APPENDIX C.

[30 F.P.C. 499.]

OPINION NO. 381-A

PACIFIC POWER & LIGHT COMPANY,

PROJECT NO. 2082

Opinion and Order on Rehearing and Denial of

Motion for Stay

(Issued August 19, 1963)

* * * * *

Before Commissioners: Joseph C. Swidler, Chair-

man; Howard Morgan, L. J. O’Connor, Jr., Charles

R. Ross, and Harold C. Woodward.

On April 10, 1963, Pacific Power & Light Com-

pany, licensee for Project No. 2082, applied for rehear-

ing of the Commission’s Opinion No. 381 and Order is-

sued on March 14, 1963, 29 FPC 478, in the above-en-

titled proceeding. A second application for rehearing

was filed April 12, 1963, by the Department of Fish

and Game of the State of California. By order issued

May 3, 1963, rehearing was granted for the limited pur-

pose of affording opportunity for additional considera-

tion. On examination of the rehearing applications

we find that while the majority of points raised by Li-

censee and the Department are merely restatements of

arguments raised in their exceptions which have been

covered in our Opinion and Order and do not warrant

further discussion here, certain aspects of our opinion

require clarification.

Licensee urges that amended Article 49 of the li-

cense for Project No. 2082, as provided in ordering

paragraph (A) of the order accompanying Opinion No.

—55A—

381, is not in complete conformity with the July 20,

1962 stipulation and distorts the agreed upon provi-

sion limiting the number of king salmon eggs required

to be accommodated at the Iron Gate hatchery in any

one year. Item No. 1 of the stipulation provides in per-

tinent part:

1. If the Commission determines that fish

hatchery facilities are required at Iron Gate, said

facilities shali be sufficient to accommodate the in-

cubation, hatching, and rearing of the following

kinds and numbers of fish each year:

(a)* * * #

(b)* * * *#

(c) King salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)

Rear up to 6,000,000 fingerlings to a total weight

not to exceed 20,000 Ibs., and release an additional

5,500,000 swim-up fry. Not more than 12,800,-

000 king salmon eggs are required to be accom-

modated in any one year by the Iron Gate hatchery

facility; provided, nowever, if the total number of

king salmon eggs taken at the Iron Gate egg collec-

tion facility in any one year is equal to or less than

15,800,000, the fish hatchery facilities described

herein shall not be required to accommodate more

than 81% of the total king salmon eggs taken dur-

ing the year.

The clause omiticd from Article 49 is the portion of

Item No. 1(c) which provides that “if the total num-

ber of king salmon eggs taken at the Iron Gate egg col-

lection facility in any one year is equal to or iess

than 15,800,000 the fish hatchery facilities described

herein shall not be required to accommodate more than

a)

81% of the total king salmon eggs taken during the

year.” The Department, in its application for rehear-

ing, specifically acknowledged its responsibility for the

hatching and rearing of 19 percent of the king salmon

eggs taken at the egg collection station up to 15,800,-

000 per year’ as representing the number of eggs for-

merly reared by the Department in connection with

the abandened Fall Creek hatchery. It was not our

intention, in determining the capacity of the hatchery

to be constructed at Iron Gate and the number of king

salmon eggs to be accommodate therein, to change or

modify any of the provisions of the stipulation or to

release the Department from a recognized responsibility.

No finding was made that deletion of the proviso is

required to effectuate the purposes of the Federal

Power Act and no such finding could have been made

on the record presented in this case. Accordingly, we

chall amend our findings and Article 49 of the license

to include all provisions contained in Item No. 1(c)

of the stipulation.

The Depariment’s exceptions raise objections to cer-

tain language in the Commission’s opinion which we

take this occasion to clarify. In our discussion of the

reasons for assigning 20 percent of the operating and

maintenance costs of the hatchery to the State, we com-

mented as follows as to the impact of the construction

of the Iron Gate Dam:

* * * To this extent, the river and the en-

joyment thereof by the people of the State of Cali-

fornia will be enhanced over its origina! conci-

1The Department states that it will defray 100 percent of

the cost of rearing any king salmon eggs-in excess of 15,000,-

000 taken in any year.

Allis ithe etna Nts di

—57A—

tion. Availability of the Iron Gate Reservoir to

the public for lake fishing, boating, swimming, and

other recreational activities likewise indicates that

the advantages to be derived from Licensee’s elec-

tion to construct the Iron Gate Development are not

all one-sided. [P. 485.]

The Department’s exceptions suggest that the lan-

guage carries implications which are far reaching and

which go beyond our intentions. We therefore wish

to restate the Commission’s position un the questions

raised in the above-quoted sentences to avoid any such

misinterpretation.

We do not believe that recreational advantages such

as lake fishing, boating and swimming, which are by-

products of Licensee’s hydroelectric project of general

public benefit, should constitute an off-set to the Li-

censee’s responsibility to provide reasonable facilities to

maintain the fishery resource of the river, in the ab-

sence of prior agreement to that effect by all interested

parties or special circumstances not present here. There

is much to be said for cooperation by local, state and

Federal agencies to provide non-power benefits from

multi-purpose projects beyond those which could feasi-

bly be imposed upon an applicant for a license, but this

does not apply to the provision of facilities intended to

correct for damage to existing resources created by the

construction of a project.

As a general rule, a licensee is required to make full

recompense for the diminution of a natural resource

resulting from a power development on a navigable

stream. The evidence presented by the parties estab-

lished that the construction of Iron Gate Dam will re-

—58A—

sult in a lessening of the anadromous fish resource in

the upper Klamath River and that a hatchery is neces-

sary to counter this eftect. A licensee in such circum-

stances would normally be required to pay all costs in-

volved in restoration of the fish resource, both as in-

curred in construction of the hatchery and in the yearly

costs of operation and maintenance. In this case we

shall require the licensee to construct the hatchery en-

tirely at its cost, but there are special circumstances

which persuade us that the State should assume 20 per-

cent of the yearly cost of operation and maintenance of

all fishery facilities at the development:

(1) The history of this controversy cannot be ig-

nored. The proper apportionment of the cost of oper-

ating and maintaining the hatchery should be considered

in light of the prior relationship between the State

and the licensee with respect to the operation of the

Fall Creek Hatchery, in which the State assumed all the

expenses of operation. In 1919 after construction was

begun on COPCO 1 and COPCO 2, the Fal! Creek

Hatchery was conveyed to the State, and in 1925 the

licensee added fish trapping and egg collecting facilities

to the Fall Creek Station. The State operated the

Hatchery at State expense until 1948 and the egg col-

lection facility until 1961. Thus, to eliminate any

State participation in the operating cost of the Iron

Gate Hatchery would be inconsistent with this pre-

existing pattern.

(2) To impose the full cost of building and operating

the hatchery on the Licensee would be to assess costs

that wouid overcompensate for the damage by Licensee’s

project to the fish population. The evidence in the

record suggests that the reregulation of the flow of

—59A—

Klamath River by the Iron Gate Dam combined with

the construction and operation of the hatchery will re-

sult in a greater fish population than if Iron Gate

had not been built. This would stem from the reduction

or elimination of destruction of natural fluctuations

and river levels which will follow from the construction

of Iron Gate Dam and its operation ir. accordance

with the year-round minimum releases required by

Article 52 of the license. To impose on the Licensee

the full costs of building and operating the hatchery

would not merely restore the status quo but would

actually require Licensee to pay for enhancing the fish

production as compared with pre-Iron Gate conditions.

Apportioning 20 percent of the operating costs to the

State will more nearly result in restoring the status

quo.

(3) Apportioning this small share of operating costs

tu the State will provide it with a financial incentive

to irsure economy of operation of the fish facilities.

The remaining assignments of error contained in the

applications now before us do not convince us that

we are incorrect in our determinations or, except for

amending finding No. 4 and Article 49 to conform

to the stipulation, that any further action is necessary

on the rehearing other than to affirm sur original de-

cision and order.

Licensee had requested separately that it not be re-

quired to comply with the provision in the second sen-

tence of Article 49 >f the license for Project No. 2082

pending possible judicial review of the Commission’s

opinion and order. The sentence now provides: “Plans

for the aforesaid facility shall be prepared by Licensee,

in cooperation with the State of California Department

—(QA—

of Fish and Game and the U.S. Fish ana Wildlife

Service, Department of the Interior, and shall be sub-

mitted to the Commission for approval within 60 days

of the issuance of this order.” in the alternative,

Licensee requested that the time be extended for a

short period, designating June 30, 1963. The 60-day

period would have expired May 13, 1963, had the

running thereof not been tolled by our decision to grant

rehearing sojiely in order to afford additional time to

consider the matters set forth in the applications. It

does not appear that a brief stay will materially affect

the time required for construction of the hatchery.

Accordingly, we shall extend the time for Licensee’s

compliance with the requirements of the quoted pro-

vision to October 15, 1963, in line with the request

made in the second part of the motion filed April 10,

1963. In all other respects, the motion will be denied.

The Commission further finds:

(1) The assignments of error set forth in the appli-

cations for rehearing present no new facts or principles

of law which were not fully considered by the Com-

mission when it issued its Opinion No. 381 and Order,

or which having now been considered, warrant any

change in, modification, or rehearing of such Opinion

and Order, except as stated above and specified below.

(2) There is no justification for, and the public

interest would not be served by, granting a stay of

the order accompanying Opinion No. 381, as herein

amended, pending judicial review.

(3) Good cause exists for extending the time for

compliance with the second sentence of Article 49, as

amended, of the license for Project No. 2082 to October

15, 1963.

ee ae ne ae os ie

—61A—

The Commission orders:

(A) The assignments of error Set forth in the appli-

cations for rehearing in the above-entitied proceeding

are hereby denied, except to the extent specified below.

(4) To comperisate for the loss of the spawning areas

described in Find'ng (3) hereof, a fish hatchery should

be constructed, operated, and maintained at Iron Gate

Development of a size and capacity to annually hatch

and rear 200,000 yearling steelhead trout to a total

weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds, 75,000 yearling

silver salmon to a total weight not to exceed 5,000

pounds, 6,000,000 fingerling king salmon to a. total

weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds, and 5,500,000 king

salmon swim-up fry; provided, not more than 12,800,-

000 king salmon eggs should be required to be accom-

modated in any one year at the Iron Gate hatchery

facility; and provided further that if tke total number

of king salmon eggs taken at the Irun Gate egg col-

lection facility in any one year is equal to or less than

15,800,000, the fish hatchery facilities described herein

shall not be required to accommodate more than 8]

percent of the total king salmon eggs taken during

the year.

(C) Article 49 of the license for Project No. 2082,

as amended by our opinion and order issued March

14, 1963, is further amended to provide as follows:

Article 49. The Licensee shall construct or arrange

for the construction, at its expense, of @- fish hatchery

at Iron Gate Development, together with supplemental

Structures and ancillary equipment as detailed in the

agreement filed with the Commission on August 17,

1962. by the State of California Department of Fish

and Game and the Licensee, of a size and capacity

oy oe

to annually hatch and rear 200,000 yearling steelhead

trout to a total weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds,

75,000 yearling silver salmon to a total weight not to

exceed 5,000 pounds, 6,000,000 fingerling king saimon

to a total weight not to exceed 20,000 pounds, and

5,500,000 king salmon swim-up fry; provided not more

than 12,800,000 king salmon eggs shall be required to

be accommodated in any one year at the Iron Gate

hatchery facility; and provided further that if the total

number of king salmon eggs taken at the Iron Gate

egg collection facility in any one year is equal to or

less than 15,800,000, the fish hatchery facilities de-

scribed herein shall not be required to accommodate

more than 81 percent of the totai king salmon eggs

taken during the year. Plans for the aforesaid facility

shall be prepared by Licensee, in cooperation with the

State of California Department of Fish and Game and

the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Department of the

Interior, and shall be submitted to the Commission for

approval no later than October 15, 1963. The facility

shall be constructed within one year from the date

of approval of the plans by the Commission.

(D) The motion--filed by Pacific Power & Light

Company on April 10, 1963, is denied to the extent

that stay is requested pending judicial review.

(E) In all other respects, the original cpinion and

order issued in these preceedings is affirmed.

Commissioner O’Connor concurring in resuit.

Commissioner Ross concurring i part and dissenting

in part, filed a separate statement appended hereto.

Commissioner Morgan dissenting in part filed a sep-

arate statement appended hereto.

PPP ARE Basi Ge me

iiSionn

Ross, Commissioner, concurring in part and dissenting

in part:

I concur generally with the statement of Commis-

sioner Morgan, and contend that California should

defray only those costs to which it has agreed in the

stipulation in this case. In view of the fundamental

shift in the majority’s approach to a licensee’s obli-

gation regarding comprehensive development, a _ ad-

ditional comments are required.

The majority is holding that construction and oper-

ation of the fish hatchery, which it alleges overcom-

pensates for the damage inflicted by Licensee’s project

to the fish population, constitutes a basis for this

Commission’s imposition of user charges. This holding

assumes that the Commission has the authority to al-

locate, and should allocate, a portion of the costs of

these supposed benefits to the people of the State of

California.

Such a position opens a Pandora’s Box. It means

that licensees hereafter have a legal basis for contend-

ing that the citizens of any state wherein a hydro-

electric power project is constructed which produces

nonpower benefits (e.g., flood control, recreation, irri-

gation, fish and wildlife) should bear some part of the

costs of the project which are attributable to the asso-

ciated nonpower benefits regardless of whether the

Citizens of a state desire or request such benefits.

With the instant opinion as precedent, it is difficult

to see how this contention could be rejected.

Adoption of this concept might well be required in

the years ahead when relatively less economical hydro

sites, from a power aspect, may be developed. However,

aT

in my opinion, this is an extremely important step and

Congress must first act and provide a legislative basis

for our imposing of part of the costs of such devel-

opment upon anyone other than the licensee. Once

Congress determines that comprehensive development of

our water resources requires contributions from the

users of nonpower benefits, then the Commission should

make the required allocation.’

But in the absence of such legislation, we should

continue io implement the policy, established by Con-

gress, of requiring licensees to bear all the costs as-

sociated with the development of a navigable waterway.

The Federal Power Act reflects the philosophy that

any development must be consistent with a compre-

hensive plan of development, i.e., that which provides

the greatest benefits—power and nonpower alike. The

framers of the Act wisely insisted on comprehensive

development as the quid pro quo of granting the right

to private parties to use our nation’s water resources

for commercial purposes. This Commission should not

waive this hard fought concession to the public interest.

For these additional reasons, I respectfully dissent

to the majority's decision to the extent that it allocates

20 percent of the operating costs of the Iron Gate

fish facilities to the State of California.

Morgan, Commissioner, dissenting in part:

I dissent from my colleagues’ denial of the remedial

relief requested by the petition of the Department of

Fish and Game of the State of California for rehearing

1In this connection, I believe that any user charges should

be imposed upon a statewide or national basis, depending upon

whether the benefits are limited to the residents of a particular

state or are available to all citizens.

online

and, upon reconsideration, I must dissent from that

portion of Opinion No. 381 which requires the Depart-

ment to pay 20% of the total cost of Operating and

maintaining the Iron Gate fish facilities.

By its petition for rehearing the Department has

made it clear that it only offered, in its stipulation

with the Licensee, to bear the cost of rearing 19%

of the king salmon eggs taken at the Iron Gate fish

facilities; and not an additional 199 or 20% of the

entire cost of operating and maintaining hatchery fa-

cilities for the rearing of the remaining 81% of the

king salmon eggs plus the eggs of additional species.

Yet this is what the majority has attempted to force

the State of California to do.

I cannot say whether my colleagues’ decision to order

the Department to assume 19% (in round numbers,

20%) of the full cost of operating those facilities

was based on the mistaken belief that the Department

had volunteered to do so. But I must say that mine

was. Nor can I say whether my failure to recognize

the Department’s specific limitation on that 19% was

due to the truncated record in this case, or to failure

by the Department to make its limitation clear, or to

inadequate analysis of the Department’s proposal and

the record herein.!

—_ ——

"However self-evident the facts and the law on this point

may have been to the Department, it is now clear that to ob-

viate confusion in minds more hurried and less familiar with

the background facts than their own, the Department should

have continued the methed of making the governing distinction

that it used in its Reply Brief before the examiner. It there

treated the matter as follows (at p. 23):

Whenever maintenance and operation costs and hatchery

costs have been mentioned in this brief. such expense ex-

cludes 19% of the king salmon eggs taken at Iron Gate.

This was done for the sake of brevity, so that continual

reference would not have to be made throughout this brief

to the exception of 19%.

—66A—

I have never knowingly departed, as some of my

colleagues here depart, from that principle of resource

development (explicitly set forth as Section 18 of the

Federal Power Act) which requires licensees to conserve

or to compensate for all resource values impaired, dam-

aged or diminished by their use of the Nation’s streams

for generating electric power. My apparent willingness

to do so in Opinion No. 381 was based solely upon

the belief that the State of California—by way of

settlement and for reasons best known to itself and not

shown upon the record—had agreed to pay 19% of

the cost of offsetting the damage that Licensee’s Iron

Gate Dam caused to the fis resources of the Klamath

River.

I considered and believed that the 20% figure se-

lected by my colleagues and here reiterated by the ma-

jority was a departure of only a single percentile from

an agreement entered into by the State of California

with ihe Licensee and that the difference, while sup-

ported by no rational explanation whatsoever, was

de minimis. Accordingly, and solely in order to reach

a decision I believed to represent no significant depar-

ture from principle, I concurred in their arbitrary se-

lection of that figure.

But, as the supplementary pleading filed by Cali-

fornia now makes abundantly clear, my belief was mis-

taken. That pleading now leaves us with no alternative

During its oral presentation before the full Commission, the

Department did not similarly limit or qualify its response when

asked if it maintained that Licensee should be required “. . . to

pay the whole cost of this hatchery?” Although the limitation

or qualification is implicit in the remainder ‘of the Department's

response, its reply nevertheless was specific: “We are only ask-

ing them to pry for 81 percent of it.” (Tr., page 339.)

It is now clear that this was mere ellipsis.

—~67A—

but to remedy our error by requiring the Licensee

to compensate the public in full for the damage in-

flicted; and the majority’s obdurate refusal to do so

here requires my most respectful but total dissent.

Although the amount of money involved is negligible,

the majority’s refusal to vindicate the principle involved

is a policy aberration of alarming precedential signif-

icance.

By themselves, the incidental flood control and recrea-

tion “benefits” that allegedly result from the existence

of the Iron Gate Dam, although sharply disputed by

the Department, essentially are nothing more than the

inevitable results of the performance of licensee’s duty

to re-regulate stream flow fluctuations caused by its

COPCO omlant. As long as it was mistakenly assumed

that the State had undertaken to defray a portion of

the particular costs in question, the recital of those

“benefits” in Opinion No. 38] (although objectionable

to me) was in the nature of dicta and did not call for

my dissent. However, those alleged, unsolicited “bene-

fits’ —“‘benefits” unwanted and unneeded prior to the

building of Licensee’s projects—are plainly no substi-

tute for Licensee’s duty to compensate for its impair-

ment of Klamath fish resources; and I here dissent

from any attempt to make them serve as such in jaw.?

—68A—

The operative facts of this specific matter, the emer-

gent issue, and the applicable law now are unmistak-

ably clear. Since 1919 the existence of the barriers

caused by Licensee’s COPCO projects, together with

Licensee’s failure to shoulder its proper respunsibility

under Federal law, required the Department to main-

tain and pay the operating costs of an artificial hatch-

ery facility to accommodate some 3 million king salmon

eggs produced by Klamath River fish whose upstream

passage had been blocked by those dams for more than

40 years. From 1919 until it was abandoned as uneco-

nomical in 1948, the Department conducted this service

at the Fall Creek hatchery. Since then, and by eimploy-

ing tank truck transport, the Department has utilized

its hatchery at Mount Shasta to accommodate the eggs

formerly propagated at Fall Creek, and it has volun-

tarily agreed to go on doing so. These eggs comprise

an annual average of 19% of the king salmon eggs

which will be taken below Iron Gate. However, the

existence of the Iron Gate Dam (completed in 1962)

now constitutes a barrier to the migration not only of

the 3,00¢ king salmon which produce those eggs but, in

addition, some 12,800 additional king salmon as well

as several other species!

A new hatchery is needed to accommodate the eggs

produced by these additional fish if the annual runs are

to be, preserved, and the State of California has no

obligation whatever to pay any of the costs thereof.

I think they can be explained, but it would be difficult to do

so in a manner which lends stature to the majority’s candor or

objectivity. #

The majority feels entirely free to abandon its original ar-

guments. It does not feel at all free to abandon its original

conclusion, even in the face of obvious difficulty in making

that old couclusion square with the new or remaining arguments.

We may be pardoned, I think, for asking what is going on here.

—69A—

The obligation to defray these costs rests exclusively

on the Licensee. ;

The record shows all this'clearly, and because it does,

we found and ordered that the Licensee must construct

a hatchery to accommodate all fish runs impaired or

blocked by Iron Gate, except those 3 million Fall Creek

king salmon eggs that the Department historically has

provided for and has voluntarily agreed to continue

providing for. Responsibility for operation of this new

Iron Gate fish hatchery follows a fertiori from the

same reason and rule that compels us to require Li-

censee to construct that hatchery.

However, and intentionally or unintentionally, by dis-

torting the Department's willingness to continue to pro-

vide for the 3 million Fall Creek king salmon eggs it

has provided for historically—which comprise 19% of

the total king salmon run impaired by Iron Gate—the

majority rules that the State of California must pay

20% of the entire cost of operating the hatchery we

have decided Licensee must build to accommodate the

fish runs blocked by erection of Iron Gate. This, it is

now clear, is over and above the outlay the State has

voluntarily agreed to continue making in order to pro-

vide for the 3 million king salmon eggs discussed above.

No valid reason is given for this decision. The record

before us cannot provide a reason for this decision—

with the exception of the reason clearly illuminated by

the briefs, arguments and petition of the State of Cali-

fornia: that the terms, effect and purpose of th. agree-

ment entered into by the State of California and the

Licensee were misunderstood.

To misunderstand may be embarrassing, though it

need not be so in this case: counsel for the State of

Z 7 = Stews ie

> 92-0.) Site. 3 da A ee

aad

ee ae

—70A—

California must bear some responsibility for the mis-

understanding here. But to attempt to rationalize, de-

fend and perpetuate a misunderstanding is inexcusable.

And to do so in circumstances which produce a danger-

ous precedent adverse to a valuable principle is out-

rageous.

The majority now rests the conclusions it previously

set forth in Opinion No. 381 on the followings bases:

1. The history of this controversy cannot be

ignored. The proper apportionment of the cost of

operating and maintaining the hatchery should be

considered in ‘ight of the prior relationship be-

tween the State and the licensee with respect to

the operation of the Fall Creek Hatchery, in which

the State assumed all the expenses of operation.

In 1919 after construction was begun on COPCO

1 and COPCO 2, the Fall Creek Hatchery was

conveyed to the State, and in 1925 the licensee

added fish trapping and egg collecting facilities to

the Fall Creek Station. The State operated the

Hatchery at State expense until 1948 and the egg

collection facility until 1961. Thus, to eliminate any

State participation in the operating cost of the

Iron Gate Hatchery would be inconsistent with: this

pre-existing pattern. [P. 502.]

Indecd we should not lose sight of the history of

this controversy! But the use the majority opinion

makes of that history in an attempt to justify its mis-

taken conclusions is little short of incredible.

“This controversy,” Opinion Na. 381 explains at

page 479, involves the question of whether Licensee

should be required “to erect and maintain a fish

—71A—

hatchery . . . to continue the runs of salmon and steel-

head trout which have been displaced by Licensee’s con-

struction of its Iron Gate Development on the Klamath

River” seven miles below COPCO No. 2 {emphasis

added].

Iron Gate was licensed in 1957 ; its construction was

completed in January 1962; and in Opinion No. 381

we found that it constitutes an impassable barrier to

all fish that: formerly spawned in the eight miles be-

tween Iron Gate and COPCO No. 2. There is no con-

troversy here. Opinion No. 381 settled the matter.

Nor is there any controversy here over who will pay

to hatch the eggs of the fish whose upstream passage

was blocked by COPCO No. 2 in the past and which

is now blocked eight miles downstream (along with the

upstream passage of many other fish) by the new Iron

Gate barrier. The State always paid to hatch the eggs

of the fish formerly blocked by COPCO No. 2 and the

State proposes to continue to do so. The eggs of the fish

formerly blocked by COPCO No. 2 and now blocked by

Iron Gate comprise 19% of the 15.8 million eggs of

king salmon blocked by Iron Gate: so the State has

volunteered to bear the expense of hatching 19% (or

3 million) of the 15.8 million eggs of king salmon

blocked by Iron Gate. Plainly, the Federal Power Act

never requested the State to defray the cost of hatch-

ing those 3 million eggs in the past: and plainly that

Act does not require the State to do so now that the

COPCO plants have been put under license and made

subject to the comprehensive development requirements

of Section 10(a) and Section 18 of the Act. Neverthe-

less, ithe State has volunteered to pay the cost of hatch-

ing those 3 million eggs, and there is no question or

controversy over that matter here.

—72A—

This controversy only relates to who should bear the

cost of operating and maintaining a hatchery big

enough to hatch the eggs of only those fish that for-

merly spawned in the eight-mile stretch between Iron

Gate and COPCO No. 2. There is not even any dispute

as to the number and weight of fish that the hatchery

must hatch: the parties have stipulated the size of a

hatchery sufficient to hold the eggs of only those fish

that previously spawned in “the lost spawning areas

above Iron Gate” and below the COPCO No. 2 facilities

(Examiner at pp. 490-491, Opinion No. 381 at pp.

482-483). We found that “since Licensee has created

the situation which necessitates [a] fish hatchery” ade-

quate to hold the eggs of (only) the stipulated number

of fish that previously spawned in the gravels above

Iron Gate, “it is no more than reasonable to require

it to pay the cost of consiruction thereof.” Thus there

is no controversy with respect to construction of the

hatchery.

Licensee argued that we should not require it to pay

the cost of operating and maintaining the (stipulated)

hatchery. because state law says the state will do so

and because the state paid the cost of operating the old

(3 million egg) COPCO hatchery at another reach of

the River. In Opinion No. 381 we said those historic

matters are “wholly immaterial,” because (a) “the Fed-

eral government, in its enactment of the Federal Power

Act has occupied the entire field”; and (b) because “the

Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act . . . contemplates

that power companies operating under a federal license

would be required to make adequate’ provision for fish

conservation as a condition of the license.” We did not

feel ‘t was necessary to explain that the comprehensive

—73A—

development standard of Section 10(a) of the Act

means that if Licensee’s use of the waters to develop

electricity results in damage to fish or other resources,

Licensee must pay for facilities to preserve them; and

we did not feel it was necessary to point out that Sec-

tion 18 of the Act says that “the Commission shall

require the construction, maintenance and operation by

a licensee at its own expense of . . . such fishways as

may be prescribed . . .”

Now the majority contradicts itself. Contrary to its

own exposition of the requirements of the Act, the

majority now says that the State must help pay to pre-

serve a resource damaged by a re-regulating hydroelec-

tric plant licensed by us in 1957, because in the past

and under a discredited, inapplicable state law, the State

had to pay to preserve a different and separate. fish

resource impaired by an unlicensed plant, built before

enactment of the Federal Power Act, in a different reach

of the River.

I heartily dissent from this contradiction; and totally

disassociate myself from the majority’s attempt to ob-

fuscate and conceal the operative facts of this contro-

versy. The majority need iiot stoop to conquer.

The majority then proceeds to its next major point:

2. To impose the full cost of building and op-

erating the hatchery on the Licensee would be to

assess costs that would overcompensate for the

damage of Licensee’s project to the fish population.

The evidence in the record suggests that the re-

regulation of the flow of Klamath River by the

Iron Gate Dam combined with the construction

and operation of the hatchery will result in a

greater tish population than if Iron Gate had not

Man

been built. This would stem from the reduction or

elimination of destruction of natural fluctuations

and river levels which will follow from the con-

struction of Iron Gate Dam and its operation in

accordance with the year-round minimum releases

required by Article 52 of the license. To impose on

the Licensee the full costs of building and operat-

ing the hatchery would not merely restore the

status quo but would actually require Licensee to

pay for enhancing the fish production as compared

with pre-Iron Gate conditions. Apportioning 20

percent of the operating costs to the State will

more nearly result in restoring the status quo. [P.

502. |

The stipulation entered into by the parties to this

proceeding provides that: ‘‘(1) if tie Commission de-

termines that fish hatchery facilities are required at

Iron Gate, said facilities shall be sufficient to accom-

modate . . .” the stated number of fish whose

spawning grounds were blocked by Iron Gate.

The Commission, in Opinion No. 381, found that

a fish hatchery was required at Iron Gate; and that a

hatchery oi the stipulated size will “preserve and

maintain [the fish resources] at a level approximately

equal to that which existed prior to the coustruction

of the Iron Gate Development” [emphasis added}.

The Commission failed to find that re-regulation of

the River will improve the fish resource over its condi-

tion prior to Iron Gate, because the record contained

no evidence whatsoever to support such a finding. It

does not contain any now. Further, contrary to the

majority's empty assertion here, the record does not

even “suggest” that re-regulation and the hatchery com-

a

—75A-—

bined “will result in a greater fish population than if

Iron Gate had not been built.”

Obviously, if the majority’s present “reasoning” is

to hold water, it must rest on findings of fact, and

those findings in turn must be based on a preponderance

of solid evidence in the record before us. Neither the

findings nor the evidence upon which to base them can

be pointed out.

Here again, therefore, the majority fails in its

attempt to manufacture now a reason why—contrary

to the record evidence, its own findings, and the re-

quirements of the Federal Power Act—it ordered Cal-

ifornia to pay 20% of the cost of operating and main-

taining the project facilities that the comprehensive

development standards of the Federal Power Act re-

quire Licensee to maintain.

Finally the majority rests its order on the following:

3. Apportioning this small share of operating

costs to the State will provide it with a financial

incentive to insure economy of operation of the

fish facilities. [P. 502.]

Here the majority discloses what it now insists was _

a central purpose underlying its impcsition of 19%

(rounded to 20%) of the O & M costs of the fish

hatchery on the State of California. That purpose was

to protect the Licensee from assumed extravagance on

the part of the State. The question of the ethics of

the State of California was not made an issue in the

proceeding but apart from this the requirement that

the State must pay 20% would very likely achieve the

desired result. We may likewise assume that if the

Commission were to require the State to pay 100%

—76A—

of the O & M costs it would almost certainly achieve

the desired result. Better still, if the Commission were

to require the State to pay the Licensee 200% of the

O & M costs it would certainly achieve the desired

result.

But this exhilarating vista of expanding Commission

jurisdiction over the sovereign states (in order to protect

Licensees from conjectural expense) evaporates when

a simple question is asked: What is ‘the statutory au-

thority for the Commission to impose such a charge on

the State? The answer is: No such authority exists

in law.

I agree that the Licensee is entitled to protection

against State extravagance, whether real or fancied.

Such protection is afforded by the arrangement, which

has been operating successfully for years, between the

Department of the Interior and California as well as

a number of other States. Under this arrangement

the Department builds hatcheries to correct damage to

State fishery resources caused by its dams, turns those

hatcheries over to the State and reimburses the State

for operation and maintenance. Prior to the beginning

of each fiscal year a budget conference between the

State and the Department is held for the purpose of

reaching agreement on operation of each hatchery

during the coming year, and the hatchery is operated

in accordance with that annual budgetary agreement.

Such an arrangement could properly be required

as a license condition here, and the Commission could

reserve the right to settle any dispute which prevents

agreement in the unlikely event such a dispute were

to occur. This is the pattern suggested by California

during oral argument. It is the pattern we should

—77A—

have adopted here. It is equitable; it provides ali the

protection needed by the Licensee; and it does not

require the Commission to exceed its statutory powers.

i, 2a oe oe

In sum, the majority defends its ruling that Cali-

fornia should bear 19% (rounded to 20%) of the

hatchery O & M costs by citing: (1) a history of the

controversy which the majority clearly misunderstood

and misapplied, (2) an hallucinatory claim that such

costs would exactly balance an unproved “over-compen-

sation” of the State by the Licensee, and-(3) a claim

that imposition of such costs is necessary to preserve

California’s virtue.

Let us examine item (2) at greater length, though

the temptation is great to discourse further on all

three.

If my reading of the majority’s reason No. 2 is

correct, it is as follows: The parties in this controversy

have agreed upon the size of the hatchery to be built,

but their agreement was in error. Further, the majority

knows the nature and direction of the error: the hatch-

ery agreed upon is not too small; it is too large. It

is too large because that hatchery, in combination with

future improved conditions in the spawning beds below

Iron Gate will, in the course of time, result in the

propagation of more fish in the future than before

Iron Gate was built. Further, the majority knows

exactly how many more fish will be propagated in the

future than before Iron Gate was built, as well as the

value of those additional fish. Therefore the majority

feels able to correct, with precision, the error made

by the parties to the agreement. It finds, on the basis

of no evidence beyond the foregoing assertions, that

—78A—

experience in future years will demonstrate that Iron

Gate re-regulation, plus a too-large fish hatchery, will

overcompensate California by exactly the amount equal

19% (rounded to 20%) of the cost of operating and

maintaining the stipulated fish hatchery!

I freely confess that I lack both the evidence and

the expertise necessary to make such daring yet metic-

ulous calculations involving the life and behavior of

generations of fish yet unborn, and the operation of

facilities yet unbuilt. If I possessed such expertise

and evidence I might have been tempted to correct the

(assumed) error of the parties by the simpler method

of adjusting the size of the hatchery those parties had

already agreed to.

¢ Jf the majority really possessed this dazzlingly in-

tuitive expertise I am confident they too would have

made such a correction. But they did not. It matters

little whether we conclude they failed to do so because

they had neither the expertise nor the evidence on which

to act, or because they are here merely attempting to

rationalize a misunderstanding.

What js important is that they lacked the authority

to do what they decided to do.

A. Rs ee

A clear understanding of and correct ruling on this

matter can be achieved by the reading of a simple and

undisputed statement of fact, plus the answers to two

simple questions. The simple statement of fact is as

follows: The fishery facility we have prescribed and

have ordered Licensee to build is required in order to

correct and repair damage inflicted on the fishery re-

source of the Klamath River in California by the Jron

Gate Dam constructed by Licensee.

—79A—

Question number one: How much of this damage

resulted from activities of the people of the State of

California? Answer: None.

Question number two: What proportion of the cost

OI repairing this damage should be borne by the people

of the State of California? Answer: None.

The majority, by an indirect, oblique approach,

attempts to lend the authority of this Commission to

a new and alarming theory—that a Licensee, without

the agreement or consent of a sovereign State, may

impose charges on the State for asserted but disputed

and unwanted “benefits” arising indirectly from Licen-

see’s use of the Nation’s rivers for the generation of

electric power; and that this Commission, under the

Federal Power Act, has the authority to force the State

to bear those charges against its will.

If the majority seriously believes it lawfully has this

power—which I maintain it does not—it should

(attempt to) assert that power openly, citing statutory

authority, rather than attempt to establish such power

obliquely, as it does here, by entangling its new theory

with a legitimate dispute over the Proper responsibility

5f a Licensee to repair and correct damages it has

inflicted upon a natural resource of the State of

California.

I believe the majority’s attempt to establish such a

theory will fail, regardless of whether it is made openly

or as in this proceeding, and I concur in the dissenting

remarks of Commissioner Ross on this subject.

The one question Properly before us is the respon-

sibility of Licensee to protect and conserve the fishery

resource of the Klamath River in California.

a

This Commission has committed a serious error, and

in doing so has set a precedent dangerous to the rights

of the several States and their citizens, by attempting

to force the people of California to pay cosis not rightly

theirs, for damages not inflicted by them, upon a re-

source they have every right to enjoy unimpaired.

There is an obligation to pay for correcting the damage

inflicted on that resource by Licensee’s project. But

that obligation rests squarely on the Licensee. Not one

iota of that responsibility rests upon the public.

If Licensee and the State of California had entered

into an agreement to share the costs of meeting that

responsibility in the manner mistakenly understood to

be the case on first presentation of this matter before

us, this Commission would have had adequate statutory

authority to examine such an agreement and decide

whether its impact on Licensee’s customers did or did

not serve the public interest. But, as is now clear,

there was "o such agreement, and we have not the

slightest shred of statutory authority to concoct a sub-

stitute therefor and then proceed to force the State

of California, against its determination of the public

interest and against its will, to accept it and require

its taxpayers to pay for tt.

The majority’s attempt to force the people of Cali-

fornia to do more than they voluntarily agreed to do is

wrong and cannot be supported by facts, by logic or

by law. I am confident that on review their attempt

will be struck down by the courts, as it should be.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.