Appendix — Bellach v. New York
Supreme Court brief1963
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
2 | Al
IN THE _ hess
United States Court of Appeals
aaa wat giana Salt
~~” FOR THE Hen CIRCUIT ——->.. Or Sas ae
aye No. 19901 . .. | oe
JOHN H. JACKSON,
Appellant,
aa
vo
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
; Rew Appellees : ,
Anpes! from the United States District Court for the
Northern District of Georgia
April 4, 1962 ;
Before TI TTL Chief Judge. and POPE* and JONES,
Circuit Judes.
POPE, Circuit Judge: Appeliant, a citizen of Georgia
brought this action azainst Southerr: Railway Company. i
corporation of the State of Virginia, seeking recovery ot
-
Of the Ininia Circuit, sitting by de .gnation
: yo, 3
Yl An examination of the complaint indicates how close the
plaintiff carne to alleging lack of jurasdiction’ The complaint ai-
fegea
that said defendant 1 . a citizen of the State of Vir-
= " ginta, with headquarters in, Ri¢hmona, Virgina, and with the
principal office and plagt of doing business at 99 Spring
Z St: #4. SW. Atsanta, Fulton County. Georgia, and ha
ae tesietnated agent for service. Mr. M. W. Taylor at sa ed ad-
oe “within -the jurisdiction. of this Court. °° Jurisdi
the court -below could only be invoked under T; tle 2
S.C. ¥ 1332, the so-called “diversity” jurisdiction, which
provides that, “for the purposes, cf ths. section ‘and 1441 «of
A2
damages for personal injuries in an amount substantially in
excess of $190,000, The jury returned a verdict for plaintiff
im the sum of $2500. The principal contention upon this
appeal by the plaintiff is that the trial court eommittec
-yeversibie error in giving to the yury an instruction on_
comparative negligence and that the ‘smallness of the ver-
Ute je netprherenh! + re
i is attributable to that errer.
en eee waite
o
Fo we “ ° re reat 5
_The record shows that on December »2 1959,.plaintiff
was riding ina mail’ecar as a United States postal railway
mail clerk. The car was a part of the defendant’s passenger
train southbound. At a point near Mableton, Georgia. the
train ran through a red light stop signal set against its,
travel past that-point and head on into a freight train stand-
ing on the same track and headed in the opposite direction.
Plaintiff, who was gtanding in the mail car slightly to the
reas of the center thereof, was thrown fv ward into a
this titie, a corporation shall be deemed a estizen of any State
by which it has been incorporated and of the State where it
Has its pemeipal place pf business “* see Canton v. Angelina
Casualty Company, 5 Cir. 279 F.2d 553 Had the allegation
Gueted above been. to tne effect that -{ts principal office and
place of doing business, etc., was at 99 Spring Street, it would:
be difficult to say that the plaintitf had not pleated a lack
of diversity. However, 3n stating that “the prine.pat office
“nd place of “dome usimess”, etc., was af 99° Spring treet,
when read with the piiegation of “headauarters In Richmond,
Virgin, a’. may well mean simply that the principal office
. mn Georgia was at 49 Spring Street’ No question as 10 diver-
atv of citizenship ’was raised in the eourt belew: indeed the
wer expressiv adn tted “that this court has jurisdiction of
the cause and of the parties.” While such an admission would
be without stenificance im determining the couft’s jurisdic-
tion, we think that it must be said that the trial court deter-
ine@thatat bod turisdiction under the rule that “Ever vy court
rendering a judement. tacitiv. if not expressly, determines
it. jurisdiction over The parties and the subject. matter.”
Stoll v. Gotthich. 205 U.S. 165. 171172: cf. Yanow v. Wever- .
* bacser Steamship Company. 274 F.2d 274. We think that
be the piderment here wader review, the trin} court has in’
effect adjudged, with respect to Southern, Railway Cofhpany.
that it was not true that “its principal office and place of do-
* . ina business” was 1D Georgia ‘
Ps Pa
A3
: » . |
\corner of the car near the front and received injuries from
which the jury. might have ascertained, on the basis ‘of
evidence received. that plaintiff had suffered quite substan-
tinl, damages. ‘There was evidence from which the- jury
might have found that as a result of the accident plaintiff
was disabled from working for a considerable length of
tind and lost earnings in excess of $12,000. He underwent
an operation for the relief of his injuries: he testified ‘to
severe pain and suffering: and there was evidence that
some. of his injuries were permanent. His medica! and
ills were in excess of $1300:
hospital
Appellant asserts that what he calls a “grossly inade-
quate verdict” wes due to the trial court’s error in giving
an instruction on ‘comparative negligence in which the jury
were told in substance that if the plaintiff was himself
negligent and the negligence ot plaintiff Was less than that
of the defendant, plaintiffs recovery “would be reduced
in. proportion, to the amount of defau!t attributable to.
him’? Plaintiff objected to the giving of.this instruction on
the ground that there was ho evidence to support or war-
rant it. Sein
-
° °
“» After a charge to the jury to the effect that plaintiff would
be berred from any recovery In the event of his,own contributory
negligence, the court's charge relating to comparative negligence
proceeded as fcliows: “I charge you, gentlemer ~f the Jury, ‘that
if vou beheve frem the evidence that the defendant was negligent
and if you further beheve from the evidence that a pafticala:
plainti-f could not, in the exercise of ordinary, have avoided the
consequence s of the negligence of the defendant, but if vou be-
heve that such plaintiff was himself neghigent ar d if, you furihe:
believe that such - negligence oD the pait of auch plaintiff "was
less than the neghgence of the detendan* contributing to the ale -
leged injury to such plaintiff. then, and in sucn evert, sue h plain-
tiff could recover, but bis recovery would be reduced in propor-
tion te the amount of default attributable tochin |
8
: i . Ad:
The contention of the defendant with respect ‘to the’
propriety of that instruction, a contention with which the
trial court agreed, is based upon evidence given by the sev-
‘eral railway mai! clerks who were in the mail car at the
time. This shows that one Billingsley. a mail clerk. stood
at the daor’ of the mail car, and looked ahead as the .
train was ‘approaching the point Where tne collision oc-
curred. Jackson, the plaintiff. was-then some distance away.
he said 20 feet from the doér. He was in a position where
he could neither see out the door nor. see ahead along the
‘train. Billingsley, avho had gone to the door, evidently for
the purpose of throwing out mai! as it passed the next
town, looked ahead and said that ‘the: train had run a
“red board”: that it had gone through a red stop signal,
and that the train was not stopping. According to Bil-
lingslev he said: “F don't believe ‘he could stop at ate
red light: the | lishts are red; and I don't believe he can stop.”
un Billingsley estimated that this was some 20) seconds be-
fore the: actual collision occurred. He did not yell: he
_ merelw made the statement. Jackson heard this statement
‘ and replied that it was on a double track. ‘According to
Jackson's testimony he s aid: “You crazy idiot. its double
tr ack " Bill lingslev continued ’to Batch, and he then said:
No he's on the same track, watch out, thev’re going to
hit.” Billingsley shouted this last warning. He estimated’
that the collision éccurred “five or six- or, seven seconds”
after that second alarm - , : J:
“McClure, another clerk. who was in charge of tHe car.
told about @his second als vm from Billingsley. When Bill-
ingslev _said there was going mi be a collision:. * .. one
of the bovs said ‘vou mean thi t?? And he suid. “Yes. I mean
it and brace. Well, of course, in the next four qr five
seconds. or maybe echt seconds pees would time that
ort of thing or could the impact cate”. When asked. to
-“@
Abd
estimate tne, time ‘that elapsed after that last ‘warning
until the collision, Jackson estim.ted that it was fifteen
seconds.
- When that w arnif: of a collision came, Jackson grabbed
the rack -on which the mail so ocks were hung and when the
impact éarhe he was thrown some 2() feet forward janding
in the forward corner of the mail car. ‘Billingsley, in the
meantime, had moved to the center aisle petween- ‘the racks
and grabbed the side of a distributing table. Although the
table was bolted to the floor, when the’ cotlisjo:! occurred
Billingsley pulled it loose and he was found on the floor
covered with mail sacks.’ _ ‘ ha
The basis for the defendant's claim of contributory neg-
ligence Is the ‘showing that there was in the car an emer-
gency brake ‘valve: that Jackson did not pull the cord on.
: ‘3 p
that yalve, and, that had 11 been pulled, the train's emer-
gency, brake system would have been pat in actioh. The
only evidence as to where this valve was lecateéd, comes
from the tes stimony of Billingsley that as he observed the
red lights from his position 1n/ ‘the door the emergency
cord was six to-eight feet from him. It does, not appear 1,
which direction that was. Fhe record contains an exhibit
No. 14, which is a diagram of the car in question. This does
not show w here the emergency valve‘was located. Its loca-
tion may well have been ‘at the rear wall of the car which
was some eight feet from the door, or it may have been on
a -
3. Jnere was a fourth mail clerk in the car, one Gardner,
who-hedrd Billingsley call out ‘but did not hear what he said-
Gardner “was near the table to which Billingsles@clung and to .
which Billingsley was.“moving in a hurry”. In gome inexplicable
manner, p»fter the ace ident .Gardner found himself “hanging out
of the door. andthe maii was all over him.” “As the door was to @#
the reg? of the table it is difficult to understand how Gardner got
there, unless.the car rebounded ‘after the collision. .
”
\
* : * ¥
the locker against the rear w all. which would be some seven.
or eight feet from the door. Apparently that would be a
likelv location for the vaive, though there is no ev idence
to that effect. Jackson was. farther aw ay from that location
than Billingsley at, that time.. :
The defendant’ s contention was that Jackson, who had
. previous experience as a railréad fireman, was negligent in
not goite to that. emergency valve and: puiiing the cord
‘after he had been warned: by Billingsley that a ‘colhsion
“was about to-cccur. The contention - ‘was and is that Jack-
~ son had fifteen seconds in which to do that because aecor d-
ing to the latter's testimony ‘fifteen seconds. elapsed be-
tween the time when Billingsley shouted. his warning and
the time w hen the collision <sagiiatvm Nf
. . °
oW e chink that this contention 1s . manifest! v fallacious.
showing of negligence cn the part of Jackson cannot be:
based upon the time which actually elapsed between Bill-
ingsley" Ss warning ‘and the collision. That has no: bearing
upon the questi n of Jackson’s neglicenc ©. The question is
what did Jackson then Know, ‘as 10 the imminence of the
collision or as to a possible timé. lapse. So far as the recortl .
is concerned, it shows nothing. Jackson could not see out
of the car: -he had no woty to estimate w hether’ the colli:
_sion would happen in one second. two seconds, _or half a
-second, He did the oniv thine which he could possibly do
to protect himself from an accident—he grabbed the racks ~
7 and, hur 1. on with beth hands. i‘ :
It-wou!ld he fantastic to assume that Fick yn shoul
have measured the distance to the valve, w herever it was
an ad calculated that he trad time to run’ to the valve at 1
then run back to grab the racks.. Furthermore there |
nothing. to, show where tlre valve was ‘aside from its Ati
tame from Billingsies” For aught ‘that appears here Jack-
.
° i ; - ,
e ‘ :
as | aa |
son | might have to. pass over or around mail pouch racks to
, . get there, A person confronted with a sudden .peril not
arising from any fault of his own, “will not be held neg-
- ligent when he exercises the right. to take care of himself
in order to avoid injury, provided he acts “with such: care |
as avr ordinarily prudent person would exercise. " Everett
2 Clegg, 213 Ga. 168, 170,.97 S.E.2d 689, 691.
. . The court correctly charged the jury that in this case:
“The det fendan t+ owed to [the pldintiff| the duty of extra-
ordinary. care, the same duty it would have owed to any
passenger, on the defendant's train.” We do not have any
\ reason to question this portion of the charge given by the
\ , learned trial 4Yudge w ho, was familiar with Georgia law,’
‘ That a railway miil clerk is as a matter of law a passenger
‘s” of the carrier is supported, hy a preat weight of authority.‘
~ "We have no reason to believe that Georgia would follow.
anv different rue and this rifle is certainly consistent with
‘the definition of a passenger under the Georgia Code,
The. mail clerk's. fare is-of course a part of the’ com-
‘ pensation Which the Post Otti e@ pays the rauroad tor haul-
ing the mail car, The pro position that ,any perse mn in the
oo) 2 Bouter ) Co. v. Harrington, 166 Ala. 630, 52 So. 57:
Malott v. Central Trugt Co., 168 Ind. 428, 79 N.E 369. Loutsville
~& ON. K. Co. v. Dougherty, 170 Ky. 10, 185 S.W. 14; Libby v.
s Maine Cent. R.-Co. 85 Me. 34, 26 Atl. 943; "Baltimore & O. R. Co
vi Davis, lo2 Md. 427, 137 Atl. 30; Decker ¥. Chicago, M. & St. P.
_ R¥. Co., 102 Minn. 99, 112 N.W. 901! Nix v. Gulf, Mobile & Ohio
ae _ R.Co., 36% Mo. 187, 240 §.W.2d 709; Hoskins v. Northern Pac. Ry
_Co., 39 Mont. 394, 102 Pac. 988; Seybolt v.-New Yorks-ete., R. Co
‘93, NY 562: Miller v. P pennies R. Co.. 368 Pa. 507, 84 A.2d
200; Tiknois Cent. R. Co. v. Porter, 117 Tenn. 13, 94 S.W. 666
ae Carter v. Washington & O. D. Ry,, 122 Va. 458, 95 S.E. 464.
9
* 5. Ga. Code Ann., 3 18-201: a." passenger is one who trave,
ime sor me oe ublir conveyanc ce by virtue of a co mtrac ti-express or
plicci,.with the carrier as to the payment of the fare or that which
is accepted as an equ valent therefor :
“6 ; ; « ¢ *
2
.4
postion of a pasreneer, whether: na passenger car or ina
nualcar owes avduty to sf6p a ruti- -Awavy train by throwing
go the emergence y ber: ake system is semething that we carn-
net acca Byoen le there ‘ever were such u duty. certainly
thi as net suc hha Case: The complete absence of evidence to
show ary lack of care on Jac kson’ s part wade ‘the CAVING, |
et the Anstrue tion here’ involved completely Gul -of order
- t' is the settled Jaw ot Georgia that it 15. error fo: a
trial court to imstruct a jury on contributory” negiugence
when there is no evidence of such. negiigence. The rule
can ber no different with respect te an instruction based
seus the Geor gla statute relating to com parative negligence
which provides that if the complainant and the agents of
the. compat “ire both at fault. the former may recover
dur the damages shall be dimimshed. by the jury in pre:
Dortiort to tre amount cof the fautt at tributable to -him.
\ oe pene age
Ga, Code Ann.‘ 94-FUI -
: Z om ie
Tf we assume that sin ce this was a d Hives “ case. tried
a. . 4 -
in a federal @ourt, the “question of what matters are to be
a
Barn + The Athers Foundry and Machine Werks. 75 Ga
on tloulam. + “Powe l!, 90 Ga App 787,733, 87 S-E.2d 332.
Jan, Hare 4 Southern Rygtlwav. Company, 61 Ga App.' 139. 161
~~ 9.3 7 a S-4 © os . O°.» “4 » | q cee | “ ee “ae ‘ P y
he i te? ou Andrews Tax: &-U-Drive-it Company -% McEve
> . . ° °
+.
S upet $6, 114 S-Bd 145, 14s
, tt »
Ving tf * Ttaa ed 7 * £i0 ,~ N\ Tre" ={ :
i ‘ 1
+ ? ‘ . i 4 ei 2 ‘ C i” if 13 + ~t
ae 2 “
‘ . ° —- .
i ragwont where tMe saz ss done ¢ h 3 $
. ’ “” .
. . ~ «
rer figs dus ow he egy ‘the egmiplainart and %t ages
. - “ a
5 4) peikiel +f M% f “j J 0
* .
tie, iaite eat | be rews i! ‘ rm O07 t tk
5 5
;
util. fat Hutab to oh
por ' : .
S - Lie follinn the plas i 2%
” *
s? i ‘ hl seg} . +4 i .
© 2 ©
‘3 sisrit rt g : ‘ titied 3 } t
: : ;
° : Mt M% . ; ’ th , id
AY
: ©
submitted to a jury 1s governed. by federa} law. Simler v.
Conner, — US. —. (Feb. 18, 1963 | we still feach the same
result as to the impropriety of, the instruction here ive. ques-
uon. . ; “i
‘Jn holding that a tr idl by jury in a federal court is to be
governed by federal law. the Supreme Court Spoxe itt
Herron v. . olithern Pacific, 283 U.S. 91, 95. as follows: “In
‘a- trial ths jury in a federal court. the judge is not a mere
moderator, but is the governor of the trial for the purpose
Of assufing its proper conduct and of determining que-
sylvania R. Co., 7 Cir., 156
es
tions of law. This dise harge of the: judicial function as ‘at
common law Is an essengii] factor in the process for which
the Fedefa! Constitution provides. As was said by ‘Mr.
Justice’ Story. ain United States \ Battiste, 2 Sumner. 246
243: ‘It is the duty of the Court to ‘instruct the jury as to
- the lave; and it is the “duty ot the jury to follow. the nee
as it is laid down, by the Court.’
The C oun t also quoted trom ‘the Mt-cited case of ( ‘apital
Traction Compan v Hof, 174 US. 1. 13-14: Such ‘is stil’
1
the law. New York, N. H. & H.R. Co. v. Henagun, 364 U.S
441. . She Ve ens
It is impropér for a court to instruct on a romana
of law about whieh there is no evidence. McCarthy v. Penn-*
F. 2d 277: Jones \ . Weaver, 9
cir, 123 F. 2d 403, 407 Such an instrucuor should be re-
fused. Willitt v: Purvis, 5 eir., 276 F. 2d 129. 132. Here
under the cre umstances present. where the giving of this
instruction improperly perniitted the jum : to find the plain
tiff gun ity .of comparative négligence. the giving of the in-
rey} : 494.5 eF
struction | WAS. prejutlicia! error FE iliipon ,. Albion Vetn
Slate Co., 950 US 76. 2? Mec ‘andless . \ Unitea. Seate.,
er ¢ i € ePoOtuts o. eer * 423] eet eo soiling oe a Ee.
, i a ‘ course i mii rid roneou re bb 35 ay ai pie
“
aunyptivels impurious, especially those emiiydred in mstrachior
Alb
998 U.S. 342. 347-548; Farris v. Interstate Circutt, 5 crr.. 116
FE 9d 409. 442. Standard Accident. Insurance Co: v. .Terreli,
5 ciy.. 180 F. :
Accordingly, the jidgment Is xeversed and the cause
4 .
‘
is remanded for a new trial.
A true copy - ee
Test: Edward W. Wadsworth
Cierk. U.S. Court of Appeals F
if
oe *
-
-
~~
.
=
a
— ee
o..
~
’
* By 5. Clara R. James
Deputy
19. 19635.
New Orleans. Louisiana. June
(Seal). : ‘
.
.
°
-
'
“
. os
°
°
-
-
« ’
‘
a
.
-
° .
*« P
.
‘United States Court of Appeals
: ahs FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT ae
z .
. No. 19901
- JOHN H. JACKSON,
Apnellant. ;
versus
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
re
Appellee. |
Appéa] from the United States District. Court for the
Northern District’ ‘of Georgia *
(June 7, 1963)
Before TU "TTLE. Chief Fudge. and POPE” and JONES
Cireult dudges.
PER CURIAM: Upon petition for a yehearing appel-
lee asserts that the court has misread the recora, which, 1
asserts, showed Jackson's ability and duty. to protect mim-
self by appivirg emergency brukes as the train apy yroached
the collision point. The following assertions are mace
that photographs in evidence showed that the emergencs
cord extended the entire iength of the car. that Jackson
could see the red lights ahead through ine car windows;
and that he could have run to the car door to look for him
self. We find no such evidence in the record. The signifi-
rey eee “Si can near te ps Pay ae madi
Can rac noted im ou? op lrn1i08n Is that JaCKSON atte: warn
Al2
ing, “had no way to estimate phither thie collision woud
Lappen in one second, twi seconds. or half a second.” It
is for this reason that the unsupported assertions now made
would be irreievant if true. "
It is elem entary that the burder of vroof of compara-
tive neglivenc e,on the part of a plaintiff is on the defend-
ant. Western & Atlantic RR. v. Mathis, 63.Ga. App. 172.
10 S.E.2d°457. 460. The failure of the. record to show cir- -
cumstances requiring . Jackson to act in ‘the manner appellcé
asserts he ‘Should have done amount 's toa situple tailure 6!
proof. -
The petition for rehearing is denied.
o-*
*.
A true‘copy — ;
Test: E DW AI BD W. W ADSWORTH
-Clerk. U.S. Court of Appeals Fifth Circuit
.
‘By s Clara RK. James ie
. Deput: v
New: Orieans. Louisiana, June 19, 1963.
Seal)
o-
Ai3.
’ Order Denying Rehearing
° 3 2
‘Extract from the Minutes of June 7, 1963.
No. 19901,
oo”
JOHN H. JACKSON,
; james .
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY.
Ii is or derea by the Court that the petition for rehea
ing” filed in this cause be. and the same is her eby. denied
a » *
@
Ald ae
United States Court of Appeals
FOR THE: FIFTH CIRCUIT ao -
" October Term; 1962
No. bic a i
D.C Docket No. 7516 Civil A, D.
JOHN H. JACKSON,
Appellant,
vs. Pes
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY.
Appellee. ,
“Appeal,from the United St ates District Court for the .
Northern District of Georgia.
Before Tuttle. Chief Judge. and Pope* and Jones.
Circuit Judges.
Judgment.
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of
the record from the United States District Court for thé
Northern District of Georgia. and was argued by counse!
ON CONSIDERATION W HEREOF. It is now here
ordered and adjudged” bv this Court that the judgment
of the said Thstrict Ceur + in this cause be. and the same 1s
hereby. revers oe and that this cause be, and it is hereby.
remanded to the said District Court for a new trial:
(. 6 Tf is further ordered and adjudged that the appellee.
Southern Railway @ompany. be condemned to pay the
costs of this cause in this Court for w hich execution mav
be issiied out oft the said eae i Court.
°Of the Ninth Circuit, sitting bv desfgnation. -
Issued as Mandate
"Ae. 2 :
United States Court of Appeals
“FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT. Rey,
. No. 19901
- &
pe ac JOHN H. JACKSON,
Appellant.
VA.
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
- Appellee. -
| ON CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICATION of
the. Appellee in the above numbered and eritétled cause
for a stuv of the mandate of this court therein. to enable
Appellee’ to apply for and to obtain a writ of certiorari
from the Supreme Court of the
ORDERED that the issue of the mandate of this court In
said cause be and the same ts staved tor a period of thirty
tav to continue in
tion of the case by the Supreme , C uct’. provided that
thirty davs from the date of this order there shal!
be filed with the clerk of this court the certificate of the
hat certiorari petition and
crerk of the Supreme Court th:
days: the s force antil the final disposi-
-y*
withit
is further ordered that the
and record have’ been filed It.
clerk sh. l] issue the mandate upon the filing of a copy of
denving the ‘writ. or? upot
an order-of the Suprerhe Court
‘4 | >!
the expiratl from the date of this order
hovementionec
unless the at
the Clerk of this court within that time ee
“7° , , 7 4 “es . . j eh rhesx f
DONE AT NFW ORLEANS. LA. this 17th dav, ©
five 196
“*c Walter L.:Pope.”. °
> United States Circuit
dd June 19. 1965
‘nited States. IT IS.
fy
a”
Al6-
IN THE
United States Court of Appeals
* FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT.
No. 19,901
«
_JOHN H. JACKSON,
Appellant.
2 : VS ae
SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY,
Appellee.
: Order |
.
- IT IS ORDERED that the Stay of the Mandate here-
_ tofore entered on the 17th dav of June, 1963, is hereby
extended to and including the 5th day of August, 1963. /
s Elbert P. Tuttle,
Chief Judge. United States |
Court of Appeals
Dated.- (Qriginal Filed July 16. 1963 )
at
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.