Petition for a Writ of Certiorari — Anthony v. Louisiana & Arkansas Railway Co.
Supreme Court brief1963
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
1
ys
° 4 : é tas c
JOHN F. DAY
2 ‘ bo, wh j
_——— acaiion ~--- ee:
SUPREME COURT OF THE WNT STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1963.
‘No. — 31 d Bad a ices ae / Z 3
3 GLEN F. DASTUGUE, |
tw Ane lash hs od + 1: Petitioner,
versus
a AMERICAN OIL COMPANY,
~
Respondent.
\
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
_ UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE Pritt
FIFTH -CIRCUIT.
a
EDWARD C. ALKER,
Audubon Building, 3
New Orleans, Louisiana;
“MILTON W. JANSSEN,
Audubon Building, —
; 2 New Orleans, Louisiana,
-* . _Counsei for Petitioner, Glen F. Dastugue.
Montgomery & Co., “The Brief Specialists”, 430 Chartres St, N. O.. La
_ SUBJECT INDEX. -
Page:
OPINIONS BELOW . 1
JURISDICTION } ¥:
‘ Qa .
QUESTIONS PRE: SENTE D. 2
STATEME NTAOF THE- CASE ee ead
REASONS FORMGRANTING THE WRIT 29
CONCLUSION 34 |
CERTIFICATE 34
fa ;
APPENDIX | - 35
‘AUTHORITIES CITED. |
~ saron v. Martin, La. App, 1936, 167 So. 106 17, 24
: ——Bergeron-v--Greyhound-Corp.« 100 So. 4 (2d) 923 24 ‘cinaeigitiomte
a Dufrene y. Indemnity Insurance Co. al N. America, °
he 303 F. (2d) 788, 790 28
1. * Duree V. State, La. App., 96 So. (2d) 854, 865 .- 27
Emerson ¥. Hicheses, 1933, 163 A. 381 +. 27
Howley Vv. Kantor, 1933, 163A. 628 27
ie —— "| Minois Central Railay Company_s—Aaeoin-— See oa
Cir., 1952, 195 F. 12d) 983 , 18)
Jacob Schybinger v. “Interlake Stea amship Co., 273 ;
80. (2d) 307 15
>
—— ae
=
: —
- AUTHORITIES ‘CITED— (Continued!
« . or
° .
Robinson. v. “Missouri- Pacific R, R. C ompany, 165
So. 527
Robiowolski. v. Holloway Gravel Co., 173 So. 174
Ryder v: Vermont Last Black C 0.; 1917, 99 AL 773.
Simon v. Texas & New Orleans Company, 124 So:
(2d) 646
Tracy vy. Mass. Bonding’, & Insur. Co.. 1960, 159
_A. aa 86
Miscellancous: '
Article 3215 5, Leulslans Revised Code -
Jefferson Parish Building Code. Art. 1108, Sec. A ah,
/ a
17.24
Ww
eager, IN-THE i”
“OCTOBER TERM, 1963. s ,
é ry No. : “ : , ° - : ; ; oe, He
“ : e : | ; / : ee
GLEN F. DASTUGUE, "7 - :
ee ne, ——— pothioner
ouce Se perUs . se
Fr aunts Me : # o peeve ‘ vA
- + AMERICAN OIL COMPANY, |
: 6 | anne yng /. _ Respondent.
PAL . . ‘a . vs 7
: PETITION: FOR WRIT OF. CERTIORARI TO THE
oe UNITED . STATES COURT > APPEALS —. THE ..
eos , a FIFTH £1RCUIT.
a ; . ° A ° d. 5 ;
ZS hig a
Yar It Pi ease the Carit: ; Pe bag 3
¥ -
that a writ of cer sess issue to .
<*s/ Petitioney vr ays
United States Court of Appeals
review the judgment of. the
eT itty Cireuit entered dn April 29, 1963 3.
a.
for th
, : “OPINIONS BELOW. a |
ff Tee text of the opirions of the Court of Appeals
jor the Fifth Circuit Cou-t, _ however, is found in Ap-
/ pendix.
o. \ =:
pe, AE “JURISDICTION. - : ae
een: “The judgment, of the Court of Appeals was entered
~~ on the 29th day of April; 1963. This Court has jurisdic-
tion over; this case and gore specifically: under Article
- 2315 of the Louisiana Revised Code... .- * ‘4
QUESTIONS PRESENTED.
JA. The case Was presented. to the district Court in
its entirety, and after the overruling of a dirécted verdict
the jury brought in a yerdict for the plaintiff in the sum
of $50.800. Upon ‘appeal, the appellant alleged — that. the
district judge had erred in charging. the jury in regard
to the € earning Fated of the plaintiff. AE at sr
. @
z The district judge had ‘erred in allowing a par- ;
ish ordinance which regulated the height of a pilot light
in a panel ray heater to twenty-four inches from the floor.
: ‘STATEMENT OF THE CASE..
This is a civil action in which Glen F. Dustugue.
plaintiff, being a Loujstana citizen, seeks to recover a
money judgment frorp the defendant, American Oi] Com-
pany, a foreign corporation | authorized to do and doing
business in the State uisiana, thereby allowing fed-
-eral jurisdiction hased upon diversity of citizenship. :
On January 23, 1961,- - plaintiff was ee as
“a service station ‘attendant by -the lessee, Mr: Floyd J.
Gremillin’, operator ef the service stat ion on Jefferson
Highway near Harahan, Louisiana, said lessee’operating
under ‘x written lease-~from the defendant herein, the
American Oil Company,
Plaintiff -at ap)
stated date was in the |
<
Rear: , alan,
yoximately 7:15 P.M. on above:
yrocess of cleaning down the grease
E clea
-rack,, cleaning room and the offiee section, all enclosed
in one building of the service station in question.
The plaintiff, used the only cleaning product avail- ae
able during the entire time he was employed at said sta
tion, gasoline, which -was contained .in a can in the grease
‘yack. -Plaintiff swept
the gasoline cleaner to ‘clean the, grease racks, cleaning ;
out the entire ‘building and used*
*
yoom and office and, as he finis ed, he lrad to leave the -
station to service .a vehicle and. shortly after his return
te the office the office was ignited by flames when the
pilot light on a panel ray heater ignited the gasoline. The:
said panel ray heater
pilot light was approximately 14
_ inches off the floor rathér than the regulation 24 inches
: ‘off the floor and the exhaust fan. over the door to the.
entire office, installed
.
and owned by the defendant, was
_ inoperative ‘at the time. Further, another large fan at
‘the other entrance door to the office was inoperative at
the time.
- The jury trial resulted in‘a general verdict for the
_ plaintiff for $50,000.00. “Motions for judgment notwith-
standing the verdict or
for a new trial were denied. - The
‘- defendant’ has perfected this appeal and the questions in-.
volved in the appeal dr
‘Court.
e to be resolved by this Honorable
gs
Plaintiff carried: the burden of proof beyond all
preponderance of evidence that the defendant was west)
“gent in having a ventilating fan. for. the purposes of |
ventilation that was inoperative and did not work and
x 7°!
OE ay ced we eee
~,%
mo
es A
so -%
that according to ‘eipert testimony would nines pre ented.
tnis terrible tragedy. In the testimony of Mr.
rd J.:
Gremillion, the lessee of ie station in question, | was
pointed out. /. .
‘“
~ .
~e
A. .
Q..
A:
Q:
te
the loc:
12 to 14 inches from the fleor, as pointed out: in the testi-_
‘Did ‘you gry to operate the fan; the ventilating
¢an whick was located over the door way, going
frorfi the office to the grease rack?
_ No, sir. -There was no blade on that fari,
No blade: or the. fan?
- That’s right.’
So, then, even if the motor. worked, the fan it-
self would not oper ate, is. that < cor is |
- That is right.”
Plaintiff by all preponder ance of evidenge proved
of this pafiel ray heater to be’ only about
mony of | Mr. Floyd J. Gremillion:
“BY MR. ALKER:
@
A. Yes, sir’
- That heater that Was in the service station at
‘tne time that you are talking about, that you .
took oyer. -the- station, what. tyne of heater”
- ©
was ‘it?
It was a panel, ray. heater, the natural’ gas-"
type, with a pilot light.
With a Kis light?
tight. a
Do -vou know where this pilot light was lo-
‘ eated?-
~,*, +
28
¥
ww“
wae ; ‘ Sf
ae : _5> Pak oe
= 4 7 aoe 6
Q. Where? a oe, °
= _ A. oOn the hotgom. of the heater, ight, near the:
= : fae ' purner. 9: *.
es ie , Q. How ‘high: would. you say that this - pilot fight
* : -was4rom the floor? |e
; .@ ° A. Approximately one ay ea nr
Q. Approximately twelve | inches: or one foot?
Rare Right.” Pe yap ae 1 Sone:
In the testimony of Dy. ‘Raymond V. Bailey. dean
: or t chemistry . department at Tulane University, )
‘ ‘ ayas sO brought out that if the exhaust’ fan would
. : hate been oper
| -. been reduced:
= 1.1—and I believe it is just a. little higher ‘for
Doctor, let's ‘assuine that the grease rack door
and the wash shed door. were closed, that these
two doors here, that these two. deors here were
closed (indicating ° on exhibit» would this in-
crease or decrease the possibility of ignition?
THe would incr ease it because you would get
some diffusion through the doors, if the doors
were: open, some dilition was there. There is
" a minimum quantity of vapor that you mpst
‘have in the ‘air before you get an explosive
limit: For gasoline: this is about’ one per cent
by volume. For kerosene it is approximately
kerosene than it is of gasoline,
.. Now, with the door closed, the concentration
of vapor, chat can build up a little more, and _
you will ret some diffusion from the outside
_*
ative the chatices of an explosion w rould fave
4
BY MR. ALKER: *, | obi ee
Q.
wos
if the doors are epen, and_it is less likely that
yeu will build up an explusive concentration. -
Now, ‘tor, let’s assume that the front d-or
to the office and the § grease rack and the wash
rack doors are closed, would this increase. OF
* decrease the possibility of | ignition?
Titis. would increase it. : ¥
Noy, doctor, if you washed or-cleaned the floors
of the office with threessibstances, one being
gas, and. one being kerosene, and one mineral
spirits.tell” us individually; if you: will, what
the possibilities of ignition wonld be from_ this
pilotlight? . | -
Would you repeat
|
fine. quest jen, please?
lw ant to know, with «fl of the doors closet,
-. and we have everything closed exce} m this door,
| let's say, and I want ‘to know if we cleaned
this Bred ‘indicayme, on exhibit-. in the office
down with. Number 1, gas. Naa? 2. wain-
era! spirits, and Number ? kerosene, or 1 ques=—
Gt shotffd be Number 1, gas, Number 2. ket ro-
sene, and Number 3, mineral! spirits. what the
possibility of ignition would be from the pilot
fgets oe = |
I would. sas ‘chat the possibilits vould be ex-
trémely high for gasoline. . It would be much
iowert fer kerosene -and minera! spirits, te-
causes of their’ rélative volatility. ov vaporiza-
tion that we were talking about a moment avo.
which, I would say, that the possibility for
* : ‘ ¢ ‘
s : a £77
kerosene and mineral spirits would exjst, and:
specially if there were hot spots created in the
vicinity cf che heater Sy the radiant heat from
the heater so that the temper rature of the kero-"*
‘sene or mineral spitits in that viginity were
: raised to a sufficient point Lo get a little more
volatilization than might normally oceur.
.
.
q. In-other wor is, this pilot, light «ould ignite
any of pre inflammable fluids, is that vight? : ae
A. Yes. sir.
Then, as ! 1 understand your testimony, it would
decrease it, somewhat if there Were no fans
“hlowin at all under those circumstances, blow-
ing from the inside of the office into the greasé
. + rack, ic that correct? If there is no fan blow- es
ing, there is more probability of an explosion —
_ than if the fan was blowing from inside of the
” office to.the’outside, into the grease yack, pull-
ing air through the door, is that correct?
A. Co et
he]
.
| Once again expert testimony by Dr. Raymond V.
Bailey pointed out that the installation of this panel ray
seater below the statutory heizat requirement had a-great
jeal to do with this fire: ;
“Q. Do you consider ‘the placement, of this particu-
Jar panel ray hee ater in this particular. s@rvice
. station unsafe, if you feel qualified to-answer
that on ‘the basis of the inf formation “which you,
‘have?
*
%
e -
-
-A. d would say that the existencé of any flame at
a low level woud be unsate. It woul] be un- <
safe at a higher leve], but: it would be more,
unsafe at a lower level.” ;
”
_. Even in cross-examination of Dr. Bailey by counse?
for defendant it was clearly shown the danger and negli-
gence on the part of the defendant having this panel ray
heater in the service station and particularly the negli-
gence of the defendant having it below the statifory
height: ; : .
“Q. Mr. Bailey, if you assume that there is gusoline
. int the gas pumps out in- front cf the station,
some distance, and you assume that there ir. ‘i
gasoline in 6ne of those containers in the grease
racks, and assume that the floor of the office
in which the heater is’ located is litertlly soaked
‘with gasoline, and is slippery to the.feel and
. can be seen, is there any question in your mind
about the’ source of che flammable-material!? :
-A. T'am-not stire that 1 am with. you on the Gues-
‘tion that you are asking. You're telling me
that there are three somrces, one being evenis
> distributed over the floor, and en the grease
-—, rack, and: they_the ether one in the. gaseline
mt
~ - pump? And now, what is gour quéstion?. .-
j ; co
“(My question is vou “asstinie those three loca-
tions, those three Circumstances, and ‘you as.
sume this location.of the heater in tht office.
‘where the gaselire is on the floar, where. in
your opinion. did the fumes come from which
i; nited?-
5
. : 9
Ar if you're going to spec cify that case, then I
would say ‘that in all probability the fumes
came from the floor in the office:
@, Then, by all probabilitfes. you — it is more
; probable in your opinion than not’
A. In this case, that is what. I ae js more
probablo than not that those fumes, the fumes,
would be fram the floor.
(). Well, can we put the question this way: : If you
rule out the possibility oy the existence, if you
rule ‘out. the existence of the gasoline pumps in”
the front. and you rule out the existence of any
_eans of gasoline, mineral spirits ¢ or Key rosene in
_ the” grease rack— oe
* Yes co ee ane :
Q. -.-- you assume the existence of tire gas neater
in the office. then i suppose you Wo! ld not say
‘hat the heater is unsafe because there is gaso-
line on the floor, but*rather that the: gasoline
on the floor is unsafé because there ts a heater
there, would you not?
ome Well, there js the prob jem, of semantics —an,
unsafe condition exists due to the corbin: ition -
of the heater and the gasoline.’ %
The chief ‘building jnspector for “thie Parisiv of Jef-
_terson, Denis De Vun, Sr.. closely read-out the require-
ments under Article 1108, Section » A’, of the Building
Cade and Ke lated Regulations of the Parish of Jefferson.
the re gulations for installation 6f the panel ray heater in
a building such as the service station mayen:
0
a SAS <-
“BY MR. ALKER: 2
Q. Mr. De Vun, I direct your attention to Article
, 1108, and what is the caption of that Article?
“oA. Artide 1108, ‘Special. ‘Hazards Sed
4j. Would you, read, please, Section 1A’ of, Article
_ 1108 of the Building Code ‘and Rel lated Regu- .
lation of. the Parish of Jefferson”
eg: ‘In any room in which volatile, flammable’ jja-
uids are used or ¢tored, no device cenerating .
a glow or flame capable of igniting gasoline
vapors shall be installed or used w ithin tw enty-
four inches of the f loor.” '
’
At was clearly éstablished that the sales representa-
_tive and inspector for the, defendant knew. of the failure.
of the exhaust fan. but both of them yeti ised or failed to
correct the condition of said ventilating fan. This was
brought out in the. testimony of Mr. Hirman B. Barver.
the _fermer lessee, of said station:
“Q. Tid you ever ask Mr Red a Oe repair
o
that fan?
A. No, sir I never asked Mr. Red Probst.
Q: Who did you ask?
A. Henry Jackson.
9. -Who is that? . ca
ee an rere. -_ ° : :
AD He was our sales, representative out there at
.the time.
: , ° . . ° . °
q. ‘And who is this ‘our sules representative’?
A. American Oil Company.
es
° “ 2
Q. What did he tell you” ey SS
A. ‘He told me that: it wasn't part of the “station
. equipment. | . ne TAD 4. ;
Q. So then he re fused to: repair i ;
A. -Well, they never did repair it.”
< It was clearly iat shed through é&xpert testimony
even by experts called by the defe mdant, a regional engi-
neer, James E. St. Ge rmain, for the defendant stated
the statutory requirements of a panel-ray heater he twenty-
four 124) inc ‘hes from the floor, “and not 12 or 14 ine hes
from the floor such » as the case of this panel ray heater:
“0, {-hand you this Building Code. and: Related
"Regulations of Jefferson Parish, and direct
your attention to Article 1108, which is ‘Spe-
‘bial Hazards,’ and ask if you afe familiar with.
Section ‘A — 2? Would you read Section A,
please” '
A. . ‘General. ‘Chimneys. heating apparatus and
gas-fired furnaces shall conform to the require-
mon teof-C hapter STi2 and 93" Tn any room
which volatile, flammable liquids are used
or ae no-device generating a glow or flame
.-° capable.of igniting gasoline vapors shall be irt-
"stalled or used “within: twenty- -four inches of
_ the floor.’ ;
Q. Where is this.service station located?
In’ Jefferson Parish.” SD °
The fact that the ventilat ing fan Was a property
of the dete ndant was clearly established arid was inopera-
tive was Gearly shown and was. Clearly pointed ‘out by
2
12
the testimony of a Mr. Felicien Perrin, a mechanical en-
gineer for the defendant: vas
_ “Q. When’ you offered your’ “building plans to the,
id | Regulatory Inspection. Board of Jefferson Par-
ish. did--these plans provide for three doors
within the office? In other words, the front
door, the side door going to the grease rac k, and
the door going out to the street hy Rural
Street?
A. Yes, they did.
‘Q. Did your cuimpany, at any time ask for. re-
quest and secure; a permit from the Je fferson
Parish Building Regulations, Department, a
permit to board up ‘and close this door?
A. Not to my. knowledge, ‘
_Who_has the fan to the ventilati ng—the ven- -
-tilating fan, who has that now, Mr. Perrin?
A. E don’t know. It-was a property of the opera-
tor, and I presume that he removed it.
Q. I'm talking about the ventilating fan? °
A” The ventilating: fan? It is in the hands of an
electrician. 5 “epttth ; y
ne, Still in the hands of an’electrician?” *
A. Yes, sit |
Q,. A year and six months: later?
has Yes, sir
/-Q.. Sipce the time it has been removed”
A. . Right.
~0
13
Q.. Is it a company electrician? -
A. No, sir, it is an outside contractor.”
Testimony of ‘snid expert witness, under fe-cross-~
examination brought out the plaintiff's position that it is.
4 common practice ind practice of the trade that. neces-
"sarily: open “inflamriables and fluids are. neal in service
stations: | o ;
“BY MR. ALKER: °”
Q. Did you or did you hot testify that it was com: .
" mon practice of, the trade to*heep _ recep
tactes of inflammable fluids in the
ind
A. 1 would. like. to-qualify” that----¢
Q..- Just answer me yes or no, esi ---
A. Yes.” ioe
They establishéd that it w as a clear violation of
_ the Jefferson Pari ich Building Code if the required 34
inches is not ‘from the fleor in the installation of any’
open flame heater. The said, expert testimony under
redirect éxamination is as follows:
“DB Y MR. MOSS:
Q. Mr. Perrin, this Section 110% of the Building
C ode of Jefferson Parish which Counsel showed -
to you and which ‘you read, did it contain any-"
thing which suggested to you that the jnstalla-
tion on Jeffer: son Highway is improper or in
violation of the Code? E
A. No, it confirms that it is not in violation ‘be-
- cayse the Sectfen clearly states that flame or a
glow would not be. allowed in any room where
aM
products are used or stored, and there is no
common practice to store open containers of
- flammable liquids in a sales office.” L
4
. It is ‘dearly established iy defendant’s own wit-
_ ness nerein that ‘although he answered it was not a vio-
Jation because flames or glow \ would not be allowed im any
oom where products were used, or Stored, it was clearly
* brought out by une same testimony of this’ same witness,
"in answer to the practice of the trade that a service station
being a building of one section divided only . by passage-
ways between sectioris with no doors between grease racks,
cleaning recm, and office section, esti ahlished along*with °
all the other: testimony that the installation of this open
flame ! heater -only @® inches off ‘the flecr was a clear
_ vio ation of the Building Code of the “Parish. of Jefter "son -
on the part = the defendant.
Once again in the testimony of another expert bY —
the defendant, a mechanical enzineer, James M. Todd,
“Stated that the defendant victated the requireme hts and
regulations of the Jefferson Parish. Building Code.
“oO. I hand you “the Building Code and Related
Regulations of Jefferson Parish, sir, and ask
you if you are familiar with. Afticle 110s,
Sect ion A. and would you piease read the title
- jax Settion A fef us? PF) Nea j
ft As 08T. ee ae
cE are Sa Zo e rf
A. What is “Special ‘Hazards, ‘Ay General, Chim-
“neys, heating appar atus-and gas-fired furnaces
“shall conform to the requirements of. Chapter
4
‘
"th Cir., Dec? 29, 1959, 273 So, (2d) 207:
15.
3752 and 53. ‘In any room¢in which volatile
Zammable liguids “are used or stored, no de-
vice ‘generating a glow: or flame. capable. of
igniting gasoline: vapors ghall be installed or
used within twenty-four inches of the floor.”’
ate -* . fas , .
Q. Are you familiar with that regulation? -
A. Yes, sir.” moe
é : > : at . .
Plaintiff submits that there is no: dispute avith the
_ case relied upon by defendant in: its argument for a judg-
ment fora matter of law, for in that case cited by Judge
Hutcheson this.Court ruled:
wee * As decided by this Court in Brinson V. Illi-
nois Central Ry. Co. 0 Cir., 241 F. (2d) d94, while *
negligence ‘and contributory negligence are ordi-
narily issues for the jury, where there is no sub-
‘stantial conflict in the evidence and when. from un-
‘disputed and indisputable facts, feasonable men in
the ,exercise of right reason and fair judgment
. could draw only one .conclusion, the court may
- properly withdraw them from the NG
Ve : *. e c 1
Tlie plaintiff agrees with this rule, but frem all the
testimonies through the tre nscript of this prial the prez
ponderance of testimony substantiates the negligence on -
the part of the defendant and certainly does negate con-
-tributory negligence on the part of the plaintiff. Plain-
tiff could cite innumerable cases to substantiate plaintiff's
position hut feels it suffices to rely upon Jacab-Sef whinger
«py terlake Steamship Company, U.S: Court of Appeals,
ve
= 16 nay a
phe district court did | not err in denying the de-
fendant’ s motion for directed verdict’ and for judg-
ment notwithstanding the verdict because the ver-_
dict was based upon false’testimony. A mere scin-
tilla of evidence is not sufficient to submit ‘a case
to the jury, but here there was sufficient evidence -
to sustain the verdict and the. issue depended upon
the credibility and weight of Up evidence. Thus,
the trial court was justified in submitting the case
to the-jury, Gunriing:v. Cooley, * 231 U. S.
90, 94, 50 S. Ct. 231, 74 L. Ed, 72 Neither the
trial court nor the reviewing court can reweigh
the evidence because the jury could have come toa
different conclusion, or because the vourt belie ‘el
-
“a contrary verdict would be more ‘reasonable. Teén-.
nant Vv. Peoria & P. U. R! Co., 1944. 321 VU. S. 29,
64 S. Ct. 409, 83.L. Ed. 520. ‘Only when there is
a complete. absence of probative facts to support ie
conclusion reached does a reversible error appear.’
Lavender v. Kurn, 1946, 327 U.S. 645, at page653,,
66S. Cte 740, at page 744, 90 L. Ed. 916. While’
these two cases were décided under Federal Em- ’
ployers’ Liability Act 45 U_ S.C. A. £51 et seq.
the. same ‘rules. of law are’ aicBenble under ‘the:
Jones Act. Ferguson. v. Moore-Meé ‘ormack Lines.
1957, 352 U.S. 521, 523, 77 S. Ct. 459, 1 L. ee .
s2d 515 ». The plaintiff's testimony was sufficient
proof to take “the case to the jury. There was
CO nflicting ev idence. but it. was a questi on forthe
jury to determine whether the accident occurred
as plai intiff contended.”
, een, 17 *
’ Plaintiff feels that there: is hardly. any eonfliet in
this cave, and it’s a decision for the jury to decide. Plain-
tiff again relies tor his position. on the case of Simon v.
Texas & New Orle ans Company, Court of Appeal of .Lou-
- isiana. 3rd Gir. Nov. 17, 1960, 124 So. (2d+ 646. In Simon .
. Texas and New Orleans Railroad Company, sup, a, the
Court states as follows:
“The ‘jury’s function is to find facts relating to
negligence, . contributory negligence, ‘dast.- clear
chance’ anc damages, In the case of Ross v. Sib-
ley, 116 La. 789, 41 So..93, 95, the Supreme Court
stated: . :
“The question of negligence was one of fact,
‘and. we are not prepared to say “that. a verdict
of the jury was erroneous.’
“See also Henweod v. Wallace, 5 Cir., 159 F. 2d)
263 ; Foreman v. Texas & N. O. Ri Company, D.-C.,
La., 195i, 37 F. Supp. '878- Missouri Pacific Rail-
road Company v. Saileau, 5, Cir., 195%, 265 F.
(2d) 90.” eee 7
’ That the jury’s s findings ¢ on contributery negligence
should “be undisturbed unless they have no basis in evi-
dence has been recognized in Aaron v. Martin, La. App.
1936, 167 So. 106; [Minois Central Railway Company v.
Aucoin, 5 Cir, sone, 1950F. (2d) 983.
*
"Plaintiff scatod: any contr ibutory negligence or as-
sumption of risk on his part in ‘préponderance of evidence
when the witness. Fi wd J. Gremillion testified that Mr.
. Dastugue was never ‘told’ not to use any “gasoline or petro- ~~
leum produc ts to tlean down. 008 station:
3
Qe “Did you ever sastiet Mr. ‘Dastugue to use,
gasoline or os sincane products | ‘to Clean the sta-
2+ *. ° Sent
A. No, sir.
Q- Did you ever instruct. him or tell him not to
doso? $
A. That, sir, I will be axtietl fran!:—-I don't
" remember telling him specifically ‘Do not use-
-gas-to mop the floor.” -No,- sir, I don ‘t remem-
: ber. |
(). ow: let’ me‘ask you about occasions during
your tenure as lessee of the station: w hen ‘Mr.
Probst Was visiting the station. Do you re--—
-member any such oceasion on W hich Mr. Probst
discussed. with you. the use of, petroleum oh
: ucts for cleaning pumps? 3 : .
A. No, sit, I sdon't remember.” * r
~ Further, it was clearly established that said lessee.
knew that the plaintiff used gasotine as it was a com- .
_ mon practice of the srade as done in the case at hand:
—*Q. Now, I ‘don’t want you to repeat vour testi-
* -, mony, but theré are two things “that [want to -
‘ get very clear to the jury, and; Number 1 is.
I understood your testimony to be that you did .
not tell Mr. Dastugue not fo clean down any
part of the service station with inflammafle
| fluids, ° and is that correct?.
A. Thatis tight. |
ae
Q.- And, s sbeondly, you knew that he cleaned down
' ¢ the s irvice station pr the grease. rack with
gasoline, is that cor rect?
g That is right. _
= * ~
Once é agai in, be testimony by Mr. Wayne Dahlman,
a - former employee of tlie lessee at said station, at was
cle arly established that the cleaning fluid, gasoline, was
‘used te clean down the office, grease. racks. and’ ‘cleaning
room jof the station. in question : 8 co ae
“BY MR. AL KER:
PI]
Q. Will you state ‘your name for the Jury and the
Judge, please? ; e P
A. Way ne Joseph; Dahlman. uy re
Q. Mr, Dahlman, by ‘whom ard you, employed”
A. +By Trahan’s Texaco. i, 1s
/
*
Q. . ‘And how ae have you been in the service sta-
tion business? ‘
ah. ae ay as
_ aA. Since: I Ww as about 11 vears old.
Q. ° For whom did you work during the month of |
January, 1961?
A. <—e Gremillion. °
.
Q. Did you ever have dan ieoruntiy to clean his ’
service station duying that month? :
. A. Yes, I did. ;
~ Q.. Did you have an gppor tunity to clean ‘this serv-
ice station prior to January 23, 1964?
*
-
I probably did, yes..
: 2 ; ‘ 2 . ie
Q. - What cleaning fluid did you usé to clean that
service station?
oO 32 ” a eae ws oe
A. © Gasoune, | 4
a a,
Once again, in. redirected ¢xamination of the. wit--°\ .
ness that the former lessee, Mr, Probst, used gasoline and \
knew of ‘the gasoline being used and accepted this as the \
only thorough way to clean grease spots on the floor: -
- “BY MR. ALKER: : | ay ao
o. Mr. Dah!man, I ask you once again prior to
January 23rd, 1961, did you clean down the
_ service station, the Amoco. Service - Station,
which was owfied or jJeased by Mr. Gremillion
in the 8900. block of Jefferson Highway?
. 2 “ = / .
y es, sir. ‘ ~ f “ : ;
Q. Did M- Gremillion rane inet 3 you cleaned down
the service station? \
“A. Yes, sir.
Q. sHad Mr. Red’ Probst seen you clean down this
' servive station? =~ : 0
A. Yes, sir.
_Q. What ‘eclvent ‘did 3 ‘you use to clean dowr the
service stziion during the month of January,
but -prior to January 23rd, 1961?
_ A. Gasoline, mineral spirits.” eee
‘. ee rs eee e.
Further testimony clearly established -this practice:
“BY MR. ALKER. ue
Q. Wi 30, if bea ae told } you to mop dewn the serve. 7°
ice station With gas? i Rhos Saat
as
‘
.4
ap : » See | eps
‘ iy o*
% : len ae ee ‘3 a
4. it is done everywhere. It is the practice: of!
the trade - - -” ie ere
ee eae
, was clearly established acoaeh plaintiff's testi-, j
mony that he had only worked for Mr. Gremillion a yery’ |
short fime in the service station and..was not familiar
with the use of cleaning fluids: ee
oe to eae?
“QO. In other words, prior to the ace ‘ident, your total
experience in a service station’ was roughly 4
couple or threé months: is that correct?
A. About ae
It was Farther b ought out by the: plaintiff that the
former lessee at the i tag of the tragedy was told to use
gasoline for cleaning purposes: ims
oe) Mr. Dastugue, will. you please tel] us what type
* of-solvent you used to clean down the’service — <
station When you worked for Mr. Barber?
A. Gasoline and miineral spirits.
@- Who told you to use these solvents”
- A. -Mr. Barber. Se tS
BY MR. ALKER:
e
Q: Whom, if anyone, told. you to use | these solvents”
A. Mr, Barber. ro z
Q. Was there anyone else? : _
A. Well---— an
ae Was there anyone elec, and if there was, name ~ ~
who ,else’ was working with you for Mr. Bar-
her? . ;
: A. It was John Simmor::”.
‘It was further brought out by plaintiff's testimony
that the Yepresentative saw him use gasoline as cleaning
flu ids in-the station:
"2: W ho saw you W ashing down the serv ice station ~~. *
'. with these flarnmable fluids? .
A. Red and Dick. . eae ;
°Q. Dick-who? =~ . oe . ;
A. Dick Gremillion and Red: Probst. | :
Q. And Dick Gremillion is Mr. Floyd Gremillion, |
is that correct?
A. That és right.”
It was fur the or established i in, the testimony of ZI Ger -
ald G. “Migand, a ‘former employee of said servicé station,,
that gasoline was used as well as mineral spirits for clean-
ing purposes: Bical Ak :
“Q. What sulvents did you use to clean up with? e
-A. Well, most of the time, if they had mineral
spirits, we used mineral! spirits or coal oil, and
if they didn’t. have that, we used sometimes
gasoline.
Q. Anything else?
A. Well. usually, if we used minera! spjrits-or gas,
or whatever we used to clean the floor, after
we finished. well, we usually hesed it down.’
Dr. Bailey in his testimony clearly showed the un-
safe hazardous condition having an “pen flame burning
in a service station: ‘ ts. Mh so ‘
* iain
=
A.
Well, I will say in the general use, there are
cans. of inflammables as a rule in the serv ice
ce" gaso- -
ae or Ge ‘oséne oF sisted: spiyits in opet\ con-
tainers for the purpose of ¢
tive parts, ceaning hands, or Maybe cledAning
grease racks and other things, ant Gd like
to know what the possibilities would be or the
probabilities would be of having an ignition
with a permane nt light. such as the pilot light
in this heater, 24 hours a day, with these @x-
Mosives in open containers around the service
station? : i |
An ing auipnio-
@
*] would certainly be forced to say that 3: would
be a hazardous condition. uns safe condition, to
have a flame going at all times. As far “as
the particul: iw probability, | think in order to
answer that, | would have fo have a more <} e-
cific case, and would have to know a little more
?
precisely how these things were being da nidled
Well, let's assume the gasoline, was kept where
you see these circles right outside | indicating
on exhibit:, right outside the door, and let's
assume that on a cold night they close these
doors, what is the ‘possibility or probability of
ignition? _ ; ’
i would say there is a vetly mae probability of
ignition frem a situation of that sort. In a
closed room with a door ie here for oppor-
tunity for fusion. where \ the re js aglight. a
flame.” * Pica 4 oo
Plaintiff relies on the rule set up in Simon v.~
‘Te vas & New Orleans Railroad Company, Court of ‘Appeal!
of Louisiana, 3rd Cir. Nov. 17,/1960, 124 So, (2d) 646;
supra, when the Court cites as follows :
“The Jury's function is te find facts relating to neg-
ligence contributory nefligence, last clear chance
and damages. in the cate of. Ross v. Sibley. 116 La.
720. £1 So. 93, 95, the Supreme Court stated:
4;
“?*The question of negligence was one ‘of fact. and
we are not prepared to sy that a verdict of the
jury was erroneous.’ |
“See alvo Henwood 'v. Wallace, 5 Cir. 159 F. (2d!
263: Foreman V. Texas & N. OLR. Company. D. C.,
La., 1951, 97 F. Supp. 378; Missouri-Pacifie Rai
road Company v. Soileau; 5 Cir., 1959, 265° F.
(2d mp ° i
That the jury's findings on contributery negligence
should: be undisturbed unless they have xo “basis In evi-
dence has been recognized: in Aaron x. Martin, La. App:
1926. 167 Se. 106. Flinors Central Ratlroad Company v.
Aucinit, 5 Cir.. 1952. 195 F.: (2d! 983: Robinson », Mis-
Souri-Paci ties 2° R. Company, 165 my. 527: Be ye Yon
reg yphound Corp., 100 So, (2d) 928 ; Robiowolsh i. v..Holio-
way Gravel Co, .173-So. 474. :
Py we ‘
. Plaintiff, proved by submitting medical bill=. ap-
proximately S4544.75 past medical bills already incurred
and approximately $2,245.50 clinical “bills. and further it.
was brought out by the deposition of Dr. Dunean M. Me-
_ Kee that future, medicai bills would. ‘run approximatels
$10,000.00 over a period of four years:
1
* -*
“Q. ”. Doctor,,could you give us an appr oxiMATION, of
about how long it would take in months or
years to return Mr. Dastugue togis close to nor-
mal as could possibly be ‘done—ayait. let me fin-
ish that_question— jet me add this: Assfiming .
that he has the ope: ration= as you would sched-.
ule them, if you would se heduie one this month
and another: one in three months, and another
one in six months, assuming that on ‘your
echeilule he had received this work, and you
were completed what you had es stimated, wend)
‘ » iis: maximum recovery, 4row long do you
ace it would take veu to de so?
A. To bring him to the ultimate of, what ‘could
be accomplished would, take about’ three te
four veary.
@. And roughly, what do you think the cost of tha!
_ weuld be? |
A. That's very difficult to. say.
a
-(y Well, just approximately”
» A. Ob, J would think $10,000.00 should cover it
’
und again, that’s @ gross estimate.”
The ‘above figures ‘amoun! tO $16,605.25 .1n medical
hills alone. Plaintiff further showed through its medical
j x wosition along with the testimony by Mr. and Mrs. Glen
» Dastugue and testimeny of = several witnesses that vVis-
‘ca piaint iff, the tremendous amount ot ‘pain and sufter-
ing indulged by Mr. Dastucue and further trom the testi-
‘mony of said Dr. Duncan Mckee the amount ‘of pain and
suffering stil! indulged and to be indulged by plaintif?
over a period of four more long years.
S ‘
‘The defendant contended: that the jury may “have
* had pity by the’ appearance of Mr. ‘Dastugue, but'¢er-
tainly this could net be the case as evidence is the award
of $50,000.00 in consideration of the medical bills in the
.
amount of $33.396.75,, taken also in consideration the -
amount of pain and suffering indulged in any burn case
The trial Court esd the plaintiff's petition and
the defendant cites only part of the claim as peinted out,
in plaintiff's petition: :
“The plainuff, Glen F. Dastugue, makes a claim
against the American Oil Company in the amount
of $525,000.00, which incite Sere ee claims for:
. loss of income, $250, 000. 00 ..%
When in fact plaintiff's petiticn, that part spelling
out. plaintiff” s alleged claims, was readdin total by the
trial judgé as follows in allegation number 4.’
wae
SS As a result of the hereinabove described accident,
‘complainant suffered the following injuries, to-wit:
(1) Third-degree burns over 68°. of
body a 50, 00.00
‘2) Total disability us result of burns - |
omnis. on Dony 100,000.00
> ae ee ain? ; xp ;
}'- Disfigurement to lace - 56,000.00
“> (4: Disfigurement to bedy «| 10,000.00
. (5) Pajn and suffering . : 56,000.00
ry (6) Specials :. mags ;
: fa’ Loss-of ir sme — 250 000.00
‘bi Medical costs 15.000,00
‘
!.
TOTAL | ° =" $595,000.00,
ssuca as this, 2°. saan eM tere as Zari iemanepmeniniair ati
%»o
~)
~l
It’s plaintiff's position that through medical testi-
mony and through the-photographs it was clearly shown
that plaintiff suffered Aisfigurem ment to the face. bedy
and hands, and through medical testimony It is iufficic nt
that not only did but still is suffering & great deal. all
‘of which certainly ‘wouldentitle ‘plaintiff to the -am’ of
$23,300.00. in question... .
eB 2 Rie
OOD string we
ate. Osa. ta Mg -
Further, it is obvious “Tone tite jndgment of only
$50,000.06 that’ no loss of earnings Was consis dered w ut
soeyer -in ‘the jury findings. The trial judge read the
allegations hereinabove quoted, and further plaintiff asks
to call the Court’s attentién to the followtre decision,
which clearly states that future pain and suffering and
future disability and future loss of waves or future im-
pairment of. capacity te work cnt ie supported by expert
at medics proof, Peg F.2d) O1L: Trae eon, Maas. Ronding’
—& lisurance Com pind, 160, 159 A, Pdi SO: Kinerson v.
Hiv hoses, 1983, 163 A. 3812 Howley o. Kanter, 1933, 163
- OZ: Ruder e. Ve rnin Last. Black ik A up are foc A. tia.
likewise of the case of Jtvrce 7. State, Las App.. $6 So
ids S54, 863, in discussie darnages, the following lan- -
guage Was employed: ‘ s ioe
“The award of damages for persia injury
death is of: necessity somewhat arbitrary; loss of
love, companionship, support (both spiritual and
financial’, undersianding, and guidance, of a good
. father and husband has, no, monetary equivalent
While the damages show! he compensatory’ of tiv
- loss sustained? Article 2315. LSA-C) C.. in’ Cases,
cuch as the present, where the damage ‘7s certain
» wut of uncertain pecuniary value, much discretion
o-
er
28
- must he left. to the trier ‘of fact, Article 1954,
Subd. 3, LS A-Civil Code, . . . Although awards so
made muy vary greatly with rh facts of each case,
‘likewise they should be made with some degrée of
‘miformity with these made for similar losses . . ".
The defendant contends that che trial Caurt should
not have read plaintiff's claims, and, therefore, it should
be pointed out to the jury that this should not be decided
by, the jury, but obv iously the jury did not consider any
loss of earnings in this matter: further, defendant admits |
Ride St, which clearly states:
“No party may assign was error the giving er fail-
ure to vive an instruc tion unless he objects thereto
hefore the Jury retires to consider its verdict, stat-
ing Mstinetiy the matter to which he objects and
the rounds for his objection. Opportunity shall be
given to make the objection out of the hearing of
the Jury.” |
ss
Defendant failed to make a’timely objection, and.
it should further be pointed out that it was brought t ouf in
the examifation that plaintiff had been working only for
a short period of time since hé had been honorably. fiss-
charged from the armed. service only « short time before
the accident.
The defendant urges the case of Dufrene v. Indem-
nity Inswrance Ca, of North America, 303 F. ¢2di-788
{ A .
790 ‘sth Cir. 1962), as a basis that the trial Court erred
in allowing hypothetical questions to be asked by experts
wssured facts of evidence. Ih view of ‘the fact that the
penne
- ¢ounsel for plaintiff tried this case and that the counsel
for defendant represented. the defendant in the said case,
it seems almost impossible that the defendant would rely
upon this case for its position, in view of the fact this
_Honorable Court affirmed judgment of the.lower Court
. not be: able to determine what lees of earnings were.
Fifth Cireuit‘is cont
and that the U. S. Supreme Court refused writs. There
is no doubt in the minds of the counsel for pl laintiff that
after the Dufrene case that hypot hetical - “questions may
he used as long as they do not effect. the utcome of this
case.
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE WRIT.
First, Ure opinion of. the Court of Appeals for the.
rary to the facts
this matter for the following: ren-ons:
and t
:
The Court-of Appeals for the Fitth Circuit
that the district judge should not have charged the jury
in regard to the. earnings of the plaintiff because. there
awas no evidence of loss of earnings se that the Jury w ould
is completely incorrect hecause the deposition taken by the
defendant. which was offered and inireduced into evidence
clearly set forth the earning power of .the plaint iff. In
Doctor McKee’s deposition talen by the plaintiff,
clearly set forth and determined that the plainti
it’ Was
have to undergo operations for a period of four years,
subsequent to the date of the trial in thé district. Court.
The time lost was set out read
and it was quite. clear to the
‘clearly in said de position,
and explained to the jury
jury the loss of time and the amount of expenses which
the plaintiff would have as avesultznf this accident. The
7 ale
to. the law in
“held |
This” ,
ff wwould-
¢
30 } ane o
. charge by.the district judge is clearly stated on pages 473 .
and 474 of the transcript, .the first. paragraph after dis-
cussing with the jury the extent Of-lost and future earn-
ings injected the. two words “if any,” and this would be
very clear to the jury that-if there waS an absence of
proof as to any of the above-stated loss of, earning power
that they were not to decide upon it, and the charge fur-
ther clearly states that they are to determine the amount
of damages only in accordance with the evidence. It he--
* « * . .
comes quite apparent that the jury did not even consider
loss of earnings in computing the damages because -the,
terrific suffering this man sustained as the result .of. this
injury would he in excess of $50,000.09, not even consider- °
P id ° . .
ine the fact that It was clearly poirited -out to the jury’.
that he would have. medical expenses in excess of $16,-
00,00, “as a bare .minimum. This would leave only
$34,000.00 for pain and suffering. ei
Assuming that the charge Was erroneous whieh is
argued above (we are positive that it is not), the defense
counse! failed to object to the charge in accordance with
Federal’Rule No. 51. Theresore, whether the charge was
erroneous or not is irrelevant’ because the charge. was not
objected: to at-the proper time. Had the charge ‘been ob-
jected fo at. the proper time, the disttiet judge, who inci-
“dentally was Judge, Frank Ellis, who was trying his first
jury cate, and had nothing to use as a yardstick’ but the
Federal Rules. would have had an opportiinity to recall
the jury: and reinstruct the jury if the charge had’ been
improper. This is the purpese of Rule 51, and, if this rule
is going to be disregarded, then all other Federal Rules
should bé disregarded and the courtreom should then be-
come a “free for all.”
sg
31
*. *
I would like to point out. to this Honorable Court
that this was a serviceman who had only been. te work’
a few months after having server his country in. the armed
Service, and it would"have been very dif fieu)t te present
a pattern of income by this man to the jury. and verte vinly
reasonable earnings were made: by this man which 1 do?
net believe thatthe Court of Appeals has the right to
break open the skulls of the jury and look into the jury’s
minds and determine how they arrived at their judgment
figure unless this judgment was a specific judgment, sspeci-
fying so muck for mental iv hy 30 miich for pain and
suffering. so much for lone of earnings, ete?
The second reason: for grant ing writs invelves the
Je flerson Parish ‘Building Codé . Article 1108, Nee. A.
which reads as follows: |
“Special Hazards. In any room in which vol: atile
- flammable liquids are “used ‘or stored. no device ”
generating a gow “or flare capable of igniting
gasoline vapors shall be installed ¢ oy jised within. 24
inches of the floor.” .
‘It is apparent that the Court of Appeals did not pay
any attention whatsoever to the tremendous amount of. tes-
timony by. engineers | and people who were ip the servic
station ‘business, fow years, Wiich is clearly pointed out in
the transe rit on many pages, but | wil] point out, certain
specific pages for this Sots able Court. Mr. Alhert. E.
Probst testified on pages 353, 356, 357, 398 ta-the follow-
. ing facts: that while he was ‘the supervisor for the Ame ri-
can Oil © ‘ompany and their rerrese ng ve. he diel not at
any time sell to ov even have. available ta sella detergent
A
, °
“
I
a
_- “ » . : =
to clean up the service station - or any: of its parts, other :
. than gas, mineral spirits or kerosene. He further testi-
fied quite clearly that cpen recentacles for volatile fluids
were kept in the lubritorium which it was only a. matter
of three or four: feet ‘from:the open fiame, and also admit-
_ted-that he nee that the service station, inside and out,, Se.
was ¢leane 1 down with volgiile fluids because there W ere’
no other substances pe llable to do otherwise. The three
engineers W ho tefified for the defendant, who, of course,
were ical engingers, testified that it was a com-.
‘ mon practice to keep flamifable liquids in the lubritorium,
six or eicht feet from the heater, and that volatile fluids —
such as antifreeze were kept inside the service statien
n the office where the flame w2s burn ing, and ‘generally -
Bar all three. that this was t the custem of the trade,
; and that ‘it was extremely, Arazardous to nave a glowing
ay flame in the cervice statjén under these conditions. The
most = ‘alent. testimony of Mr. St. Germain is found on
page 38%, Mr Perrif’s testimony is most prevalent on /
pages. 402,. 413 through 418. Mr. ‘Todd's testimony on
“pages 420, 443 and 451 is very important ‘to substantiate
the fact that volatile fluids were in the area’ where this
‘flame glowed, and was ¢ apable of: igniting gasoline yapors
_in accordance with: Article 108, Section A, of the Jeffer-.
son Parish Buildine Code. It is undisnuted that the flame |
in-this heater was from eight to possibly 12 inches high
and no more, and everyone has admitted that this is a
>. hazard. Wai ; ae am Ny Psat
-
-
“~s
: Dr. Bailey: the dean of the 4 Chemic ‘al. School of Fin-
gineering at Tulane University, W ho was the only * chemi-
cal engineer who testified at this trial, cledrly stated that
$8
’
. . °
_#
the receptacles in the’ lubritorium could have easily been
ignited by the vapor flowing into the office by the incor-. }
rect height ok the pilot light-in the panel ray heater in. |
-the office. Dr.\Bailey ¢ learly stated the location of the.
piigt light was so azardous’ that had the ‘wind been blow-
ing in the direction of the office, the fumes could have,
very easily been ignited by the pilot light whi¢h was only
a few feet from the front, door, and could have created
-a tremendous hazard, Fur ther, it is clearly ‘establish hed
by two experienced service station people, one Mr. Wayne
Dahlman. whose testimony on. page 128 through page 131
clearly states that while he Worked in this perticular serv-
ice station that all they used ‘9 clean the service station
was volatile flammable fluids, and no detergents were
ever provided or used, and that it» was the custom Of the»
trade to clean service stations, including the office, with
euch fluids. Mr. Gerald G.* Mierastd testifie: Pon page 292
of the transcript that it was the custom 0 the ‘trade to, aff
lean the office and the :est of the setvice ation WwW "
either, gasoline, mineral spirits or kerogen e, and 2 aire
‘ million on page 87 stated that these fluide w¢ reser rivht
outside of thé door going to the lubri icorium., Which 1s only
a matter of three or four feet from such flame, and the’
rest of Mr. Gremillion’ s testimony also pointed out that
these fluids were used in cleaning. up the = vice station
. : a hed cur
oe, oe inconceivable. that, after this tremendous,
amount of testimony where it was clearly shown that Wola-
tile. flammatle liquids were used and store sd wit hin’ the
‘office of the service ste ition where the nilot light was lit.
which 1 is absolutely in’ contravention-to the Code, “which
stated that these liquids were not to _< used or stored and. ’
that-no device gener: ating a glow or flame capable ‘of ignit-
ing gasoline vapors: shall be installed -or used within 24
inches of the. floor of which it is clear that this device
was quite capable of niting gasoline vapors. As pointed
out by Dr. Bailey's Diu that the mere vapor from
the gasoline pumps could be ignited by this device, and
further, that under certain conditions it was pointed out
in the transcript’ that the’. doors on the washroom and ©
grease rack were’ often closed and the gas fumes from
the volatile, flammable f luids could have easily been jionited
by this improperly placed pilot light. *"
. CONCLUSION.
For the foregoing reasons, this ‘petition for ‘writ
of.certiorari should be granted,.
| respectfully submitted, |
¢.
EDWARD C.-ALRER, .
MILTON W. JANSSEN,
627 Audubon Building,
New Orleans, Louisiana,
Counsel for Petitioner, Glen F. Dastugue.
————— :
*.
3 - CERTIFICATE. = -
I hereby. certify that a copy of the foregoing brief
has been sent to Mr. Murphy Moss at Lemle & Kelleher
in the National Bank of Commerce Building, New Orleans,
Mea “ “
Loutsians- | _ fm
7 “EDWARD C: ALKER,
. ‘2 Attorney for Appeliant.
"|
“
35
". APPENDIX.
INTHE 3
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
“FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT
No. 20087
AMERICAN OIL COMPANY. |
As Appellant,
versus’
GLEN F. DASTUGUF.
" Appellee.
Appeal from the lsnited Stotes District Court, for the
‘ Eastern District of Louisiana.
,
.
‘April 20, 1963) ae
> Before PHILLIPS’. CAMER IN and WISDOM, Circuit |
Judges.
CAMERON, Circuit Judes: This is an appeal from
a jury verdict and judgment against the lessor of a.service
station and in favor of an ‘omiployee of the jessee-operator
‘ ‘of the station. Appellee was burned in a fire allegedly
a as —_——— - ee ee at
’
36 ah, 3
Tce
;
caused “by the negligent acts’ of appellant in its ‘role of
ewner of the vealty: upon which the fire occurred.
When the aecident occurred, app Hee Dastugue had
heen employed for about four weeks by one Gremillion, the
lessee-cperator of the station. He had previously worked -
for Gre million’s predecessor le=see for about a week, and
continued working at the station when Gfremillion took
over its operation, Aypellee’s claim against appellant
American Oil Company is not based, upon any sort of
agency thecery; American's alleged liability is based uy n
the charge that it was netlivent in that an unsafe heater
and a defective ventilating fan were provided in tne officé *
of the station.
al
Appellant wa- washing down the floor of the station
office with gasoline when the fumes. were ignited by the
pilot Hight of a panel ray heater, the light being situated -
_ approximately twelve to fourteen inches from the floor.
He was severely burned and the jury returned a verdict
for $50,000.
. Appellant moved for a divected vefdict and judg-
ment n.c.v. on the yround that, as a matter of law, no neg-
ligence on its .part Was shown: and, ‘alternatively, that
- appellee was. guilty of contributory negligence. also as a.
matter of law. Appellant argues that the court below was
in error in refusing to grant the motions. In addition,
appellant urges error inter alia in the court's instructing
the jury that it micht consider lost earnings as an elemén’
of damage, contending that no evidence of lo-s of earnings
was introduced at the trial.- -
97 e
Appellee’s theory of liability rests upon his charge |
that appellant negligently furnished a heater with the pilot
© . x * . a, ”
light so near the floor as to be dangerous ; and that it neg-
.
ligently failed to repair a vertilating fan which, if in
- good condition, would, under the circumstances relied on,
have cleared-the room of fumes to the extent that the fume.
yolume would have remained below the danger point. It
js undisputed that gasoline fumes settle, .being heavier’
than air’
_ We cannot say, after a careful review of the record,
that the court velow was in error in refusing to grant a
directed verdict ‘or judgment nov. on the proof before it:
and it is not necessary, therefore, to detail thie conflicting
evidence from which the jury reached its decision. We do,
however, reverse and remard for a-new trial because of
two errors committed by the court below: (1) its error in -
instructing the jury on the appellee's claim to loss of earn-
ings when there was no proof of loss of earnings in the
record, e.g.,-Greyhound Corporation xy. Ault, 1956. 5 Cr
veg F, 12d: 198; and 12) it manifest acceptance, as the
chief basis of liability. of a Parish ordinance’. which we
think inapplicable to the.case, developed in the trial as-
revealed to us by the record. It is cur opinion that this
ordinance is not applicable under the facts of this case, “
since ft is ‘lear from the record thet ne “volatile, flam-
mable liquids” were “used or stored” in the office of phix
lection A of Art! le "10s bh “4 Cog ate Peiasted Rewilatror
Jefferson Varivh: ¥ ‘ 7
1 Hazarec- In any roan mn which volatile “flan mable
sigis ate uset oy ores MO lik genoréting a gow ot
, flame capable of igniting gssoune vapor- shall be .on-talled o7
ed within twenty -fo if! he- of the floor.”
s
2
.
Sh oR oe:
cept the gasoline brought in by appellee.
We think that, on another trial, this ordinance should not
be before the court,or jury, and that the question of neg-
« ligence ve! non should be tried under the genéral law of
negligence in force in Louisiana. - °
service station ex
* REVERSED AND REMANDED forea new trial.
ey
an
s
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.