Appendix — Lakeland Grocery Corp. v. Food Fair Stores, Inc.

Supreme Court brief1962

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

15

MEMORANDUM OPINION OF

, THE COURT ic

The preseint action was instituted on January 13, 39: 56,

_ with plaintiff cotending that the defendants were engaged

in unfair competition as at common law through the con-

tinued use of the trade name FOOD FAIR. The complaint,

_ as amended, further suggests: violations of the Lanham

“Trademark Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1051-1127, and the Virginia

‘statute relating. to trademarks. These latter contentious

; were abandoned during the course ‘of trial and, for this

_ reason, this discussion will be limited to common law un-

fair competition, = ’

Plaintiff requests injunctive relief and an accounting

of profits’ made by, descendants while using the name

* FOOD FAIR It is plaintiff's theory that-the name FOOD

FAIR had acquired a secoridary meaning in the Norfolk-

' Portsmouth ‘area when defendant, Lakeland Grocery

‘Corporation, opened its place of business in Norfolk ‘on

". May 14, 1953: By way. of countetclaim, Lakeland seeks

‘injunctive relief and damages alleging that it first appro-

priated the FOOD FAIR avame%in the Norfolk- Portsmouth

area, and that plaintiff's prior activities. were not such ‘as

- were within the reasonably probable area of expansion of. |

plaintiff's business.

‘The status of Tri-C ity Foods, Inc., is of little conse-

quence. By agreement dated June 17, 1957, Lakeland

granted Tri-City a non-exclusive. license to use the name

_ FOOD FAIR in the City of Portsmouth. Tri-City opened:

its store on October 9, 1957, and was made a party to this

proceeding on June 22, 1959. Following: the. institution of

this proceeding, Lakeland ‘cancelled the licertse, and Tri-

City, claiming the right to use the name only through

Lakeland, has abandoned same. The right to an. injunction

against Tri-City would,sin any event, -be moot, and. the -

16

evidence is not sufficient to show interlocking operations

wherein, even if plaintiff should prevail, Tri-City could be

held liable for an-accounting of profits. In line with com-

anénts made ‘at the timé of argument, the complaint against

T ri- City must be dismissed. Fenty a ‘

The ultimate issue’ for determination is whether the

Norfolk-Portsmouth area was, as of May 14, 1953, within

plaintiff's reasonably probable normal area of expansion.

_ Lf so, plaintiff is entitled to an. injunction. If not, the

defendant, Lakeland, must prevail. and would be awarded

injunctive relief.

_ Plaintiffs predecessor, ‘Union Premier Food Stores,

commenced operations in and around Harrisburg, Pennsyl-

vania, during 1929. Small meat markets ‘and, grocery stores

were then in vogue. During the depression days of the

early: thirties, the officers’ of Union Premier hit upon the

idea of self-service supermarkets! and, in 1933, opened its -

- first supermarket under the name “Giant Quality Price

Cutters, Inc.” The success of this operation caused plaintiff

to open supermarkets in eight cities. throughout Pennsyl-

vinia atid southern New Jersey by the end of 1935 and, in

the interim, plaintiff closed or sold its small stores.

‘In August, 1935, plaintiff's predecessor brought about

the formation of a subsidiary corporation known as Food”

Fair ‘Stores, ‘Incorporated, under the laws of the State of

Maryland. The subsidiary opened a supermarket-in Balti-.

more, Marvland, on October 31, 1935, using the name

FOOD FAIR; it havi ing been suggested by a cotton | goods

it is said that plaintiff and its pre dicasianie were the origin itors of the

“sup ermarket” in food marketing. : ; m

’

2This was appare nntly the first use of such @ name as related: to Ae ‘ret: ail

" marketing yf food, Approximate dy 18 weeks later, a store in Washington, D.C.

= ated the same name, Food Fair Stores, Inc. v. Square. Deal Masket

/ D.C. CG. A! 206 F. (2d) 482, cert. den, 346 U.S. 937.

store in Chicago called’ THE FAIR. By 1938 all super-,

inarkels operated -by plaintiff's predecessor, or its subsidi-

ary, had adopted the name FOOD: FALR? aid, in 1942.

the corporate name of Union Premier Food Stores, Ine.,

was changed to Food Fair Stores, Ine., by which the corpo-

rate. identity is presently known. el,

While much of the testimony points .to the tapid

growth of plaintiff since 1953, we are not here concerned

with this factor exce pt to such exterity if any, as such sub-

sequent activities may have some bearing upon the reason-

ably probable area-of eSpansion as of May 14, 1953. The

defendant, Lakeland, opened its first store in the Norfalk

Portsmouth areaon May 14, 1953, under the name FOOD

FAIR, and it is this date—and this date only—which should

he considered in ascertaining whether the name-FOOD

FAIR had acquired .a secondary meaning inthe Norfolk-

Portsmouth area. The “secondary; meaning” is denoted as

such when the name h. is become associated in the rainds of

purchasers or.customers with the source or origin of goods

or services, rather than witli the’ goods or services them-

selves. Rosso and Miistracco v. Giant Food, 200 Va. 159,

104.8. BE. (2d) 776, 150 ALL. BR. 1079. While a number

of locak witnesses testified as to their knowledge of plain-

tiff's activities prior to 1953, the true test to apply would

be the confusion, if any, existing with respect to the over-.

all general public pure hasing % groceries, meats, ete.’ ‘That

Sa) Am insurance aejuster Atated that bq had heard of plaintiff's

th

plaintiff. The adjfister, at

the time of trial represented pl tintiff on claims arising in this area

operations through ‘relatives wi ho Ah. wl traded: as

(6) The public opinion survey was as of August, 1959, at which dime

~ceantusion admittedly existed. It) is: of. little valae in ascertaining publi

opinjon as of May 14. 1953. Z

(co) A represent: sive of “Skippy Peanut. Butter’, manufactured by Best

Foods, Inc. had sold peanut butter to’ plaiti#t stace 1945. .

18

. ‘

-FOOD FAIR was well known by persons in the grocery ’

trade, by inv estors on the stock market, and among certain

individuals peculiarly connected with plaintiff's activities,

‘cannot successfully be disputed. Indeed, Lakeland’s presi:

dent, Harold Eisenberg, testified that he was well aware

of the name FOOD FAIR and plaintiff's chain of super-

snarmets at the time Lakeland — its FOOD - F. AIR

a — ——— v - —-— --—._ —- — ee — _

(d) A representative of Valley Poultry & Produce Corp. stated that the

name FOOD FAIR did not mean much in the Nortolk-Portsinouth area ‘prior

* to 1953, although he identified the name with ‘stores in) Maryland and °

Pennsylvania. As of the date of trial he was se Mirage poultry to both the

plaintiff and Lakeland.

(e) A sugar broker re sabeiatte Amerjcan Sugar Refining Company

testified that he had heard of “Kood Fair of Philadelphia” several years’ prior

to 1953; that hg sells sugar to plaintiff; that he knows of ‘six or seven. stores

in the area of Winston-Salem, North Carolina, "operating under .the name

_ FOOD FAIR. 9

(f) A manufacturer and distributor of food specialties, who sells to beth

plaintiff and Lakeland, sajd that he knew of: “Food Fair of Philadelphia”

as one of the outstanding ghain operations, and that: he, had been in one

FOOD FAIR store in the District of Columbia’ in 1948, although he did not

know who owned. the store. This latter reference was obviously té a FOOD

FAIR store operated by Square Deal Market Co.

(4) The Director of Promotion for a local radio and television station

knew of FOOD FAIR while attentling the University of Miami, Florida.

Plaintiff now uses his services in advertising. ‘ :

(h) The president of Atlantic Pridluce “Co., selling to both. parties

identified the name FOOD FAIR, prior to 1953, as being the chain store

he liad visited in Philadelphia, and that he had read of same in trade publi-

cations. ‘

(i) A wholesale bien a wine helen selling to both parties; heard

of the name FOOD FAIR through trade magazines.

(j) The manager of Swift & Co. ice cream plant, selling to both parties,

knew that Swift & Co. sold to plaintiff since 1945, and that the name FOOD

FAIR meant one of the largest chains in the country. >

‘(k) A representative of Wholesale Food & Produce Co. selling to

plaintiff, knew of FOOD. FAIR: — to 1953 by reason of his dissociation

with the trade.

(1) A stock -broker stated that alaintiff s quotations were first’ listed as

FOOD FAIR in 1942.

_19

Store on May 14, 1953, although he insists that’ the ame

FAIR was suggested by the name FURNITURE PAIK

adopted by a store a short distance away from I ake land's

supermarket. |

The principles of law underlying these Gases: of com-

0M HA unfair competition are grounded upow the fact

that one should not profit in the goodwill of another's trade

‘or business., The extent: to which the market has been

affected by the use of the name is of paramount impor-

tance. The name may mean gne thing jn one territorial

market, and an entirely different thing in another. The

‘market is the customer or purchaser—it is from such cus-

tomer or purchaser that profits are earned and goodwill

established.

It is. clear that a substantial burden rests apon the

plaintiff to prove that the name FOOD FAIR had, as of

May 14, 1953, acquired a secondary meaning it the Nor-

folk-Portsmouth area among . -puichasers . or . customers

generally dealing with grocery stores and supermarkets.

Rosso end Mastracco v..Giant Food, supra.

Shortly after Lakeland opened its first store on May

14, 1953, plaintiff, having been advised of this fact by an-_

other chain store, addressed a letter! to Lakeland under

4The body of the hthed 5 re ache’ os follows:

“We have recently learned that you are now operating a supermarket

under the name ‘FOOD FAIR’.

“Since 1935, we have operated a\chain of supermarkets for the. retail

sale of groceries, meats, meat products and other related products under the

trade name ‘FOOD FAIR. . ;

“The name ‘FOOD FAIR’ is registered with the United States Patent

Office. In’ addition, we have widely advertieed and circularized the nas by

radio, newspapers, circulars and other media, as oan integral part of ou

business operations. As a result, the name has been ‘for sometime ide tified

‘in the minds of the public and the food trade with the business which we

operate and with “Food Fair stores in the entire eastern and southern areas

of the United States and throughout other parts of the Country.

“Our common stock is listed on the New York Stock Exchange and is

widely distributed throughout the country.

-

‘S| . -

a as

a

date of June 1, 1953, protesting the use of the name FOOD

FAIR. By this time Lakeland had already opened its super-

market and, in advance thereof, had advertised the name:

FOOD FAIR extensively. In October, 1957, as previously

noted, Tri-City opened a store.in Portsinouth using the

‘name FOOD FAIR under its licensing agreement’ witli

Lakeland. Following plaintiff's action in opening a super.

market in the Nowolk area on-January 15, 1958—two days

subsequent to the institution of this ‘action — Lakeland

opened another store in Portsmouth in July, 1959, using

the name FOOD FAIRS © —

Since the ifstitution of this action, plaintiff has open-

ed two’ additional supermarkets in the area. At Aragona

Village in Princess Anne County—approximately 12 —:

from the first store—plaintiff opened a store on June 15,

1958. Within weeks following the trial of this case, a hind

supermarket was opened by plaintiff on Tidewater Drive

in the City of Norfolk—a distance of approximately four

miles from the first location. As observed, the openings sub-

sequent to May 14, 1953, do not have any material bearing

on. the ‘nal decision of this case; nor are we concerned’

with plaintiff's subsequent activities in the Newport News- |

Hampton area where certain supermarkets were acquirgd,

by plaintiff, but Lakeland claims no » priority of use in that

peyticales ipcemty. °

“The use of ay name “pOOD FAIR’ he you constitutes an appropriatian

of our valuable trade name. Your continued use of that name will eaten

the public, our customers and others into the belief that vena store is past

of our chain and may cause us considerable damage

“We. teel sure that, under tliese circumstances, you will wish t to discon-

tinue use of the name.

“However, if you persist in the use of the name, we shall be constrained

to take such action. as may be necessary to protect our rights.”

5An exchange of letters in June, 1957, revealed that Lakeland was

protesting the proposed opening of . plaintiff's first store in the Norfolk-

Portsmouth area, with plaintiff again asserting its ay! right to the use of

the name. These letters are of "0 consequence as they followed unsuccesstul

negotiations on plaintiff's part to purchase. Lakeland’s store

21

‘Plaintiff. cnuliatis its failure fo take prior le ‘gab action

by-stating that Lakelaid’s one store was not considered a

matter of serious consequence and that plaintiff was not

-aware of any intention on Lakeland’s part to expand its -

operations. During the year 1956-—the exact date being un-

hnoswn—plaintitf commenced negotiations with Lakeland

to purchase its property but due to: Lakeland’s demands

which were considered exorbitant by plaintiff. these nego-

tiations failed. Subsequent-to the institution of this action.

the parties resumed negotiations which reached a point of

near agreement in the spring of 1959. Tout finally again

failed on March 31. 1959. Lhe details. of these negotiations

are not, in the opinion ob the Court, pertinent to the de-

cision here in Controversy, |

Reverting to the growth of plamtitf’s business. it can-

not be doubted that plaintitt isa well-established grocers

~ chain in certain areas, Prior to World War U plaintiff had

expanded from the Harrisburg area to localities through-

ont eastern PennsyWwania, New Jersey, Delaware and

Marvland. Excluding for the moment any discussion of its

activities in the District of Columbia and Ales: andrea, Vir-

ginia. plaintiff's closest: stores to Norfolk using the name

FOOD FAIR were in Baltimore. Marsland a distance of

approximate ‘h 25 miles.

Its the plaintiff's contention that it has the right to

object to the use of the name FOOD FAK ATK at ans place

in the United States. We-detiotaarec. Unlike the names

emploved in Stork es Vv. Sahati, 9 Cir., 166. (2d)

MMS: Sweet Sixteen Co. v.. Sweet “16” Shop.’8 Cir. 15 F.-

(2d) 920. White Tower ae my W ‘hite- Castle System,

6 Cir. 90 F. (2d). 67: and Safew ay Stores v.. Suburban’

Foods, E.D. Va., 130 F. Supp. 249, the name FOOD FAIR

is, not so fictional and fanciful as to create a grocer’s pseu-

donym entitling plaintiff to an exclusive use P of the name in

-

areas where there are no commercial transactions hd the

area is viot within the then reasonably probabie limits of

expansion. |

Obviously plaintiff, although vigorously asserting its

mtentions to expand, has never embarked upon any fixed

pattern. The executive vice-president referred to a conte

nuity of surveys in the Norfolk and, Richmond areas since

i949, when plaintiff constructed a warehouse in Baltimore -

which was designed to serve Baltimore, Washiiigton,

northern Virginia, Richmond, and the Norfolk-Portsmouth

area. The only fixed pattern of expansion is keved to’ the

construction of warehouses; it being said that approxi-

mately 15 stores are necessary to support a warchouse. .

When there are sufficient st6res to support a warehouse,

another area is then opened up and the process is repeated .

However, plaintiff waited niye years after the construction

of its Baltimore warehouse before electing to invade any

area south of the District of Columbia territory. Other than

through: trade journals, two or three articles written in

national magazines admittedly having a circulation in Vir-

ginia,.and stock-market transactions, plaintiff did io ad-

vertising by “way of newspaper, magazine, radio or tele-

vision calculated to. réach ‘the general public in the ‘Nor-

folk-Portsmouth area. True, such advertising did take

place « few weeks prior to the opening of plaintiff s first

_store in Norfolk on January 15; 1958, but, in the interim,

the name FOOD FAIR had been substantially established

hy the efforts of Lakeland. Plaintiff now wishes to capita-

lize of: Lakeland’s advertising and goodwill built up from

May 14, 1953, to January 15, 1958, a. period of nearly five

_ years. This it cannot do unless plaintiff substantially proves

that FOOD FAIR, as of May 14, 1953, had acquired a

secondary meaning in the Norfolk-Portsmouth area among

purchasers or customers generally dealing with grocery

stores and supermarkets.

‘

Lakeland relies heavily upon Food Vair Stores, Inc. v.

Square, Deal Market Co., Ine., D.C.C.A., 206 F. (2d) 482

growing ‘out of plaintiffs efforts to establish a superior

right to the use of the name FOOD FAIR i: the operation

of retail grocery stores in the District of Columbia and sur-

rounding areas, including that part of Virginia generally

denominated as the Washington Metropolitan Area.” The

litigation in Washington was instituted by the now plain-

tiffin 1948. but the court granted injunctive relief to

Square Deal Market, maiuly* upon the ground that the lat-

ter opened its first grocery store in Washington approxi-

mately 18 weeks after plaintiff adopted the name for use

in Baltimore. In other words, both parties “hit upon the

nse of the name” at approximaiely the same time. We do

notihavea similar question in this case. ,

‘= Plaintiff insists. that keod Fair Stores | v. Food Fair,

1 Cir. 177 FE. ¢2d) 177, is controlling. Disagreeing with.

plaintiff, it should be noted that the findings in the Massa-

chusetts case were to the effect that, prior to the adoption

anc use of the name FOOD FAIR by the defendant. there-

in, the plaintiff had (1). acquired a reputation in Massa-

chusetts, (2) done business with wholesalers there, (3)

acquired oficial permission for one of its subsidiaries to do

business, (4) negotiated for the acquisiiotn of enterprises

in the Greater Boston area, (5) established its name, to a

limited extent, among average customers of fetail food

stores, (6) distributed its stock among approximately 500

stockholders in Massachusetts, particularly in Greater Bos-

ton. Moreover, Massachusetts had an express statute on

the subject which provided: “likelihood of injury to busi-

ness reputation or of dilution of the*distinctive quality of eee

trade nanie or trade-mark shall be ground for injunctive

relief in cases of trade-mark infringement or unfair com-

petition notwithstanding the absence of competition be-

tmecen the parties or of confusion as to source’ of goods or

services.” Thus it appears that the quantum and quality of

proof required under Massachusetts law is considerably

less than Virginia démands under Rosso and Mastracco v

Giant Food, supra. Of course, it goes without saying that

the Jaw of Virginia’ must be applied to the facts of the

existing controversy. .

To the exteit, however, that the First Circuit con-

cluded that the words FOOD FAIR are essentially generic.

terms but are ievertheless susceptile of appropriation, this

.

Court is in complete agreement for the reasons assigned in -

the opinion of Circuit Judge Woodbury. .

We attach little significance to the testimony of plain-

tiff's executive vice-president and general manager of oper-

ations wherein he stated that the Norfolk angl Richmond

areas were the subject -of continuous surveys beginning

with 1948 when plaintiff commenced the construction of

‘its Baltimore warehouse. The witness stated that experi-

enced reaf estate men were sent to the area as early as

1950.0r 1951 for the purpose*of making these surveys in-

volving. population, population trends, competition of.

other chains, consumer spending, atid many other factors.

These purported surveys wer not presented in evidence® -

and no individual participating in such a study was called

to testify. We think it clear that, as of May 14, 1953, plain-

tiff enjoved a mere “hope of expansion” into the Norfotk

area, consistent with its financial progress justifying same,

and that plaintiff's possibility of expansion-into the Norfolk

: | : ee

“OTe witness testified Shat the sursess were not retaine A heCause thes

became ont-ol-date within few sears Avwemingearcacnde the correctness. «

of this statement, it is nevertheless anuenal te note that ne mdisidual com

ducting any sures was called to testify The wituess abo stated that phantitt

had mans offerings frome teal estate Wrekers and landlords in the Nerfoll

area trom 199) to date, but ae cormdborating evidence was, submitted on

this point.

\

”

as ° 5)

-

_area as of that*date is too remote to sustain plaintiff's bur-

den of establishing by substantial evidence that the naine

FOOD FAIR hac then acquired a secondary meansig in

this locality. It does hot appear that plaintiff became nore

than remotedly iaiterested in Tidewater Virginia until 1955,

when an approach. was\inade to purchase Rich's Stores,

located primarily, in the Néwport News-Hainpton atea and

separated from ihe Norfolk-Portsnfouth area by the Port

of Hampton Roads.’ This was followed shortly thereafter

by plaintiff s efforts to acquire Bakeland’ $ store.

The expansion in northern Virginia has little or no -

effect upon this litigation. In 1946 plaintiff opened a store

in Alexandria using the name FOOD LANE. No other

store in Virginia operated by plaintiff under the name

FOOD FAIR was opened until January, 1958, which was;

as noted; the Norfolk store. The storé in: Alexandria was

acquired by plaintift's subsidiary, Big Bear Foud Stores of *

Virginia, Inc., when operated under the name FAIRFAX

SUPER MARKET. The name was then changed which

resulted in litigation instituted by Food Fair of Virginia,

Inc., a corporation then using the name FOOD FAIR with

the consent and permission of Square Déal Markets, Inc.,

the latter being the ultimate successful litigant in the Dis-.

trict of Columbia proceedings heretofore discussed. The \,

Alexandria case was dismissed by consent in 1948, and the

now plaintiff or its subsidiary continued to operate under

the name FOOD LANE. Beeause it. was unsuccessful iu

the District of Columbia litigation, the present plaintiff

continued to use the name FOOD LANE in northern

7Lakeland does not contend that its plans for expansion extend to the

Newport News-Hampton’ area, but confines its argument to the Norfolk-

Portanouth area which is generally described as the cities of Norfolk, Ports-—

mouth, South Norfolk and Vigginia Beach, together with the counties of -

Norfolk and Princ-ss Anne. :

- ;

* . 26

Virginia and the so-called Washington Metropolitan Area."

Fromm this we note that plaintiff had not invaded Virginia

~under the name POOD FAIR, but,-even had it done so

prior to 1953, we would not consider it df importance as

the Washington Metropolitan Area is located approxi-

mately 200 miles from the Norfolk-Portsmouth area. The.

litigation does- suggest, however, that plaintiff's plans; if,

any, for expansion into Virginia under the name FOOD .

FAIR were; effectively blocked.

Nor is it of importance that plaintiff cctalmensod ex-

pansion into Florida during 1942 or thereabouts. Plaintiff

had an opportunity to acquire a chain of established stores

——— and now urges that this marked the entire area between

Maryland and Florida as the reasonably -probable area of

expansion. To carry this theory to the extreme, if plaintiff

- opened a store in California—as it at one time contem- -

_plated—all states between the east and west coasts would

fall within the reasonably probable area of expansion.

_ As of April 25, 1953—the closest date availgble to, the

ope.ing of Lakeland’s supermarket in Norfolk—plaintiff -

stores were distributed in the following states as indicated:

Seca |

Maryland 2...” 19°

New Jersey...

New York .. Decciccea case Saas ae

Natstens Se tec eesti ae

. ments to use the ndme FOOD FAIR ih the Washington Area effective

a

27

The foregoing does not include the. stores operated ‘as .

FOOD LANE. By May 1, 1954, the only marked increase

~ was in Florida where plaintiff had acquired another chain

of stores. Connecticut was invaded during the fiscal year.

ending April 30, 1955, by the establishment of four stores.

In the fiscal year ending April 27, 1957, two stores were

opened in Virginia (presumably in the Newport News-

* ° Hampton area); two were established in Tenhessee; and

one in Georgia. With the exception of Florida, this marked

the first attempt to expand operations below the Mason-

Dixon Line. As of September 2, 1959, plaintiff was oper-

ating, 399 stores,’as contrasted with 162 when Lakeland

opened its supermarket but again, with the exception of »

Morida, the expansion has been essentially limited to the

. states of Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, and ‘New

York, plus a few stores in Connecticut and Delaware. The

area concentration of these stores strongly suggests that,

_ excepting Florida, the expansion plans have been sharply

limited, Furthermore, plaintiff has continued its practice of

operating under names other than FOOD FAIR:

Merely because plaintiff is a prior user of the name —

FOOD FAIR in. other areas does not project the right of .

protection of said name in advance of the extension of the

trade; nor does it operate as a claim of territorial rights

over areas into which it thereafter may be. deemed desir:

able to extend the trade. United Drug’ Company v. Theo-

dore Rectanus Company, 248 US. 90.

Not overlooked is the fact that Lakeland has adopted

a style and size of lettering on its signs which is substanti-

‘ally identical to plaintiff's signs as they existed in 1953. Or ,

the other hand it should be observed that the lettering is

of standard block design. If this design or size of the signs

had any meaning in this area in 1953, it could, of course,

Ti

. ‘ . 28 3 -

be construed as an effort to do some act inimical to plain-

tiff’s interest for the purpose of obtaining the benefit of the.

réputation of plaintiff's goods, or to forestall the extension

of plaintiff's rade, but such does not exist in the present

controversy. a

° .

There is little peel’ to conside Lakeland’s contention

that pl: aintiff is estopped by the doctrine of laches. The

doctrine of estoppel would only preclude plaintiff's rights

to'an accounting if it prevailed. While it is.clear that plaipy:

tiff would be ‘estopped to demand an accounting, -it is

equally apparent that plaintiff is not, and Lakeland is. en-

titled to injunctive relief with respect to the age of the

name FOOD FAIR. |, ; 3

»

This: is not a case meriting punitive damages in hehalt

*.° of Lakeland. Whether it has sustained compensatory dam;

ages is reserved for further consideration:

.In-the final analysis these cases wedi ing unfair coms\ -

petition at common law are dependent upon the. individual ‘

facts‘of each controversy. The equities’ of this case aye +

manifestly with Lake land. It should prevail.

Counsel will prepare an appropriate decree carrying

into: effect this memorandum which is adopted by the

Court in lieu of specific’findings of fact and conclusions of

law. Counsel may likewise submit specific findings not

‘ sufficiently covered herein. If a hearing is requested, the

same shall be granted. er

eee - (s) Walter E.-Hoffman '

.' United States District Judge

Norfolk, Virginia “

January 3, 1961

29 i

ORDER

It appearme, to the Court that) the follownig ad:

- ditional findings gf fact should be made a part of the

record. itis se ORDERED:

The name “Kood Pair was. pridrsto-the use ther eel

by Liatkeland. used byw retail grocers net owned by Phaivtitt

in Polashi, Virginia’ Tazewell Virviniad Martinssille. Vir-

‘wnias and Richmond \ irecinda.

fie Rehmond Virginia, a groeery stare not-owied. by

Phatetdll Graded as Food Pair team E957 to 197.

fn Statesvalle, North Carolina. a retail @rocers store

not owned by Plaintitl trades as “Pood Fair since 195]

In WinstoneSalém. Noth Carolina a retail UPON

chain not-owned by Phaintitf las traded as “Pood Fan

simce Nucoustoof T9487. now operating six stores. |

* . e .

fy Atlanta, Macon and Savannah, Georgia. ‘retail

grocery miatkets not owned- bs Plaintiff operate on have.

operated under the trade namie ~Kood Fair,

The same sittiation is tite 4s to Montwomers. Abe

bania, where two stares have Teen operating sinee [952

unde vy ownersbip other than Plaintiffs.

«

In Tennessee, four stores operating under thet treacle

name of “Food Fair’ were not-owned by the Planstitt jut

avere/ purchased by the Plaintiff from the owners as ol

July SE 1956. ¢ ioc 5tee |

E i +s) Walter Eo Hoffman

United States District Judge

Norfolk. 4 iveinia ;

\pril 25. 1961

. . *

m_,

ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES

__-Pfaintiff, Food Fair Stores, Inc., by Myer B. Marcus,

‘ Executive Vice President, its agent, having been duly

sworn, makes the following ‘responses to the interroga-

‘tories served upon it by defendants September 10, 1959:

1. Plaintiff adopted the tradename “Food Fair”

August 14, 1935, when it obtained a charter for The Food

’ Fair, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary, from the State of

~ Maryland. The name “Food Fair” was obtained from no -

source but was originated by officers of plaintiff's prede-.

cessor corporation. It was ‘suggested by the name “The

Fair’ on a Chicago department store. —

2. At the time of the adoption of the - Food Fair —

tradename plaintiff's predecessor corporation owned and

operatec twenty to twenty-five conventional service type.

grocery stores in eastern Pennsylvania under the name .

Union Premier Food Stores. All these storef had been

disposed of by 1937. In addition plaintiff operated. the

following supermarkets at the following locations at the

. time of the adoption of the Food Fair tradename, August

14, 1935:

Giant Quz lity Food Price Cutters, Inc., Harrisburg.

Pennsylvania. ‘

Union Premier Food Store, Philadelphia, Pennsyl-

+ vania.

Giant Quality Food Price Cutters, hic., ending.

Pennsylvania. — a A

Giant Quality Food Price Cutters, ‘Ine., York. Penn-.

= sylvania.

Giant Quality Food Price Cc utters, Inc., Columbia,

Pennsylvania. F

Giant Quality Food Price, Cutters, Inc., Allentown,

Pennsyjvania.

31 oe

Airport Market, Perinsauken, New Jersey 7

Giant Quality Food Price Cutters, Inc., Coatsville,

Pennsylvania.

The Airport . Market oe October 31, 1935. The -

names on the other’ stores were changed to Food Fair

by 1935 °

3. To plaintiff's knowledge there were no other retail

grocery stores trading under the name of “Food Fair” or

under a name Of which “Food Fair” was a part at the

time plaintiff adopted the tradename “Food Fair.”

4. See attached Appendix A. |

5. Following termination of the litigation in the Dis-

_ trict of Columbia in which plaintiff in this case was plain-

tiff and Square Deal Market, Company, Inc., was de-

fendant. The Grand Union Company, purchased” Square

Deal Markets, Inc. The Grand Union Company, by con-

tract dated October 9, 1958, conveyed to the plaintiff the

right to use the’ name “Food Fair” in the Washington,

D.C. area. Plaintiff at present operates four supermarkets

under the name “Food Lane” in the Washington, D.C.

area but will convert such markets -to: the name “Food

Fair’ by October 9, 1960.

‘6. See attached Appendix A+ Substance of letters ‘in-

dicated in Appendix A is. the same as Exhibit A attached’

to the complaint.

. See attached’ Appendix B.

3 In May, 1953, when defendant Lakeland Grocery /

Corp. opened its business in Princess-Anne County, Vir-

ginia, the nearest grocery store operated by plaintiff under

the tradename “Food Fair” was in Baltimore, Maryland.

Myer B. Marcus |

Executive Vice President

Food Fair Stores, Inc.

Mass.

~ Holvoke | }

N.S.

City

Montgomery

. Bridgeport |

St. Augustine

Tampa

.* Atlanta

Atlanta

Macon

Savannah

Baltimore

Baltimore

25 & Charles. ) |

(Eutaw St.) -

Brookline

Shrewsbury

‘Camden

Cranford

Name.

Used .

Lazenby s Food Fair

-Ike Fitzgerald's

Food Fair Market

Nat's Food Fair ©

Fla. Food Fair

‘Food Eair Ine.

Clark's Food Fair

Food Fair Supermarket

Food Fair Supermarket

“Henry's Quality Food

at Fair Prices”

“We Sell Food at

Fair Prices”

Food Fair

Agawan Food Fair

“Food Fair

Fred's Food Fair

Santones Food Fair

No. at

m © Stores.

Protest

‘Date of

/ First’ . Letter

‘Knowledge Sent

4/52 4/18/52 :

7/16/54 .8/16/54

4/22/49 3/26/49

7/50 10/15/51

4/29/52 6/2/52

3/18/53 - 3/25/53

" 12/52 1/28/53

8/51 8/9/51

4/30/49 3/3/ 49

5/48 7/49

12/47 .- 12/26/47

11/26/52 1/8/53.

3/49 prior to

5/18/49

- 4/28/48 4/29/48

Unknown | Unknown -

_ Duration

- of Use as

cot 1 13 58

Uncertain ;

Name Changed

U ncertain.

Favorable

‘Decree (11/21/55)

_ Discontinued

Continued

_ Continued

Continued.

Discontinued -

Discontinued

_ Favorable

Decree (10/1/48)

Name Changed .

‘Name Changed .

Name Changed

Ceased Optn.

4/1/47

a

Va.

Hammonton.

Vineland

Bronx

_ Monticello &

_ So. Fallsburg

Manhattan |

-Manhattan

Queens

Staten Island

. Statesville —

Winston-Salem

Moosic —

Newport

. Chattanooga (2)

also Marietta (1)

& Dalton, Ga. (1)

Pulaski

Richmond

Washington, D.C.

Mid-Way Food Fair — 1

Handy Food Fair 1

Food Fair 1

Famous Food Fair 2

-China Food Fair Inc. I

Marotta’s Italian |

- American Food Fair l

Queen’s Food Fair |

Food Fair . 1

Fraley’s Food Fair 1

Food Fair ate Cl

Rocky Glen Food Fair l

Food Fair Supermarket 1

Food Fair £

Food Fair ]

Food Fair l

Food Fair l

‘ ° ; - af

APPEXDIX A

12/4/51

9/18/47

2/7/50 -

1/13/50

8/9/49

1/7/55

8/1/52

- 5/3/48

1/19/51

2/51-

8/47

9/18/53

5/49

9/1/52

‘Unk.

4/56

4/7/36

1/29/52

Unknown

8/16/49

1/12/55

4 -«

9/18/52

5/3/48

2/2/d1

8/7/51

8/12/47

7/10/51

10/1/53 ©

_ 5/26/49

9/18/52

9/18/52

none

4/7/36

Suit 2/15/32:

use discont’d.

' 8/19/52

Favorable

Decrée (7/13/48)

Name Changed

~ Continued

F avorable |

Decree (1/15/57)

Name Changed

Name Changed

~ Name Changed 3

Continued —

Continued

Name Chusesd

Modified

Purchased by. a

Plairitiff *.

7/31/56 -

Continued

Discontinued

Unfavorable .

. Decree (9/20/52) :

Date, of Purchase 7

July 6, 1948 *

en 3, 1956

June 14, 1956 .

July 31, 1956

October 9, 1958

Vendor

Queens Food Fair |

New York City

‘Ike Fitzgerald’s

Food Fair’ Market

Bridgeport, Conn. ©

* Food Fair, Inc. |

Atlanta, Georgia

Tennessee Food Fair, Inic.

‘Chattanooga, Tennessee,

Marietta and Dalton, Ga.

Grand Union Company

Fairlawn, New Jersey

APPENDIX B

Cirgumstances - “a

‘ t

Plaintiff paid for sign “vs

change and change ins.

corporate charter.

Plaintiff paid for sign

change.

Plaintiff purchased store

ifi move to extend operations

of Southern division.

Plaintiff purchased stores

' in move to extend operations

of Southern division.

See answer to: Interrogatory

3. ‘7.2

+

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.