Appendix — Murphy v. Ragsdale
Supreme Court brief1990
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
} supreme VOU, Ww -
90-714 FILED
- ’
i NUY 2 1990
3 YOSEPH F. SPANIOL, dfs
No a CLERK
In The
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1990
RITAELLEN M. MURPHY, et al.,
Petitioners,
vs.
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D.., et al.,
Respondents.
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Before Judgment
to the United States Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit
APPENDIX TO CERTIORARI PETITION
CRAIG H. GREENWOOD
Attorney at Law
4100 Lindley
LAWRENCE J. JOYCE Downers Grove, IL 60515
Attorney at Law (708) 968-4468
4100 Lindley Counsel of Record for
Downers Grove, IL 60515 Petitioners-Appellants
(708) 968-4468
Of Counsel
74
INDEX TO APPENDIX
App.Page
A-Order of the District Court for the Northern
District of Illinois Denying the Intervention
of Petitioners, Reed and Aughenbaugh,
pS Ts Shree ae. uae ee A-1
B-Memorandum Opinion of the United States
District Court for the Northern District of
Illinois Approving the Settlement Proposal
and Denying the Petition to Reconsider the
Denial of the Invention of Petitioners, Reed
and Aughenbaugh, March 22, 1990................ B-1 to B-30
C-Judgment of the District Court for the
Northern District of Illinois, March 22, 1990.............. C-1
D-Order of the District Court for the Northern
District of Illinois Granting, in Part, the
Rule 52(a) Relief Requested by Petitioners,
Murphy and Greenwood, April 19, 1990.................0.... D-1
E-Notice of Appeal of Petitioners, Reed and
Aughenbaugh, April 20, 1990.................ccccccssessssesereees E-1
F-Notice of Appeal of Petitioners, Murphy and
CO, Fe I Bi iesccerisnveticstnvessccdedevrvsvecssaetes F-1
G-Notice of Appeal of Petitioners, Reed and
Aughenbaugh, May 18, 1990........... ccc ceeceeeeeeeesseeees G-1
H-Notice of Appeal of Petitioners, Murphy and
CRITE, BG Bs Baa ok ves decca cs coseveesscssecccsceveessecs H-1
I- Order of the United States Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit Consolidating the
April 20, 1990 of Petitioners, Reed, Murphy,
Aughenbaugh and Greenwood, May 21, 1990.....I-i to I-2
J- Order of the United States Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit Consolidating both the
April 26, 1990 Appeals and the May 18, 1990
Appeals of Petitioners, Reed, Aughenbaugh,
Murphy and Greenwood, June 7, 1990............... J-1 to J-2
K-Order of the District Court for the Northern
District of Illinois Denying the Request to
Supplement the Record with the over 1200
Telegrams, Models, Letters, and Other
Papers Considered by the District Court
Prior to Entering the March 22, 1990
Memorandum Opinion, July 9, 1990................:ceeeeeee K-1
L-Order of the United States Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit Denying the Suggestion
for Hearing En Banc, August 20, 1990.............. L-1 to L-2
M-August 15, 1990 Amendments to Ambulatory
Surgical Treatment Center Licensing Require-
ments, 77 Ill.Adm.Code, Ch. 1, Sec. 205........ M-1 to M-26
“iin
= es
In The
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1990
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., etc.. et al.,
Respondents-Plaintiffs-Appellees,
and
RITAELLEN M. MURPHY, et al.,
Petitioners-Plaintiffs-Appellants,
vs.
BERNOCK J. TURNOCK, M.D., etc., et al.,
Respondents-Defendants-Appellees,
and
KENNETH M. REED, et al.,
Petitioners-Proposed Intervenors-Appellants.
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Before Judgment
to the United States Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit
APPENDIX TO CERTIORARI PETITION
APPENDIX A
(Entered March 5, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
V.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, ey al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
ORDER
Court denies Petition to Intervene and to maintain
Class Action of Baby Reed and Baby Aughenbaugh but
grants Kenneth Reed and Mark Aughenbaugh leave to
appear as Amicus Curiae and grants Craig H. Greenwood
leave to file his appearance as their counsel, nunc pro tunc
to February 22, 1990.
ENTER: /s/ John A. Nordberg
United States District Judge
Dated: March 5, 1990
A-1
APPENDIX B
(Entered March 22, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M_D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
Before the court is the parties’ joint motion under
Rule 23(e) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure for ap-
proval of a proposed settlement and consent decree. For the
reasons stated below, the court grants the motion and enters
the consent decree.
BACKGROUND
Plaintiffs brought this action on June 28, 1985, seeking
declaratory and injunctive relief from the enforcement of
portions of three Illinois statutes, the Medical Practice Act,
Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111, Sections 4433(1 a)-(e) (later recodified
as Sections 4400-22 (1) (a) - (e)), the Ambulatory Surgical
B-1
ee
Treatment Center Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111 1/2, Sections
157-8.1 et seq., and regulations promulgated thereunder,
and the Health Facilities Planning Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111
1/2, Sections 1152 et seq.
Plaintiffs challenged the constitutionality of these
statutes and regulations, contending that they form ascheme
which in effect requires all abortions to be performed in a
hospital or its functional equivalent. Plaintiffs charged that
this scheme violated the equal protection rights of Illinois
physicians who perform or desire to perform abortions, and
the privacy rights of Illinois women who desire or may desire
to obtain an abortion. This court agreed, and on November
27, 1985, granted plaintiffs’ motion for preliminary injunc-
tion.! On March 10, 1988, the United States Court of
Appeals for the Seventh Circuit upheld the injunction,
except for one portion which it vacated as moot.?
Defendants filed a Notice of Appeal, seeking review
by the United States Supreme Court. On July 3, 1989, the
Supreme Court entered an order accepting the case for oral
argument but postponing the question of jurisdiction until
the hearing on the merits. Before the date scheduled for oral
argument, the parties negotiated the proposed consent de-
cree now before this court. The decree seeks to resolve all
claims for declaratory and injunctive relief brought by plain-
tiffs and reserves their claim for attorney’s fees, costs and
expenses. On December 1, 1989, the Supreme Court granted
the parties’ joint motion to defer proceedings there pending
this court’s decision to approve or disapprove the proposed
decree.
'The court’s opinion is published at 625 F. Supp. 1212(N.D. III.
1985).
The decision of the Court of Appeals is published at §41 F.2d
1358 (7th Cir. 1988).
B-2
Following the Supreme Court’s order, the parties
gave notice of the proposed settlement to the plaintiff and
defendant classes, with this court’s approval.* The court al-
lowed any class members objecting to the proposed settle-
ment to file submissions by February 9, 1990, with responses
due the following week. During this period, the court
received 326 telephone calls, two telegrams, and 1,266
letters. The court read every single letter in its entirety.
On February 23, 1990, the court conducted a hearing
to assess the fairness of the proposed settlement. The
parties explained their reasons for negotiating the settle-
ment; afterward, the court heard objections from amici who
had filed briefs with the court.* Finally, the court permitted
>The parties gave notice by mail to all facilities which, at the time
the complaint was filed, were licensed ASTCs (Ambulatory Surgical
Treatment Centers) and offered abortions; by publication in the Chicago
Tribune and the Chicago Sun-Times to all presently licensed ASTCs
which offer abortions; and by mail to all members of the defendant class
of state’s attorneys. All methods of notice were completed by January 29,
1990.
As required, the notice also informed class members of the
fairness hearing to be conducted on February 23, 1990. For this and other
aspects of the settlement process, the court was guided by the procedures
set forth in the Manual] for Complex Litigation, Second, Sections 30.4-30.47
(1985).
‘Among the amici were certain members of the Illinois General
Assembly and an individual attorney from Chicago. There were other
objectors who filed materials with the court, but did not style themselves
“amici.” The court heard their comments as well. The court also heard
objections from some of the state’s attorneys of the defendant class, who
had submitted briefs to the court.
Two objectors, Kenneth M. Reed and Mark I. Aughenbaugh,
sought leave to intervene on behalf of “a class consisting of all Illinois
unborn babies.” Any interest in protecting the fetus is for the state to
assert, however. The objectors brought no evidence showing “gross
negligence or bad faith” committed by the state in representing the
interests implicated by this litigation. Without sucha showing, the state’s
B-3
NL PU Nee ea A a
REE
individuals attending the hearing — who filled the largest
courtroom in the courthouse — to express their views if they
wished. After reviewing the prior findings of fact and
conclusions of law issued by this court, reviewing the opinion
of the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals and the applicable
decisions of the United States Supreme Court, examining
the briefs filed by the parties and objectors, and hearing and
considering all of the written and oral presentations made in
connection with the fairness hearing®, the court makes the
following findings of fact and conclusions of law.
DISCUSSION
In deciding whether to approve a proposed consent
decree, “a district court must determine whether [it] is
lawful, fair, reasonable, and adequate.” E.E.O.C. v. Hiram
Walker & Sons. Inc., 768 F.2d 884, 889 (7th Cir. 1985). The
court does not draw on a clean slate, however. Deference
must be given to the settlement, since it embodies a negotia-
ted compromise between the parties. A district court should
representation must be presumed adequate. United So}
Communitv Schoo] Corporation. 692 F.2d 623 (7th Cir. 1982). Accord-
ingly, the court denied the objectors petition but granted leave to file
written objections and appear as agci, which they did. Their Petition to
Reconsider Petition to Intervene’and to Maintain Class Action of Baby
Reed and Baby Aughenbaugi filed March 15, 1990, is likewise denied.
See United States v. City of Chicago. 897 F.2d 243 ( 7th Cir. 1990) (“inter-
vention to take an appeal is permissible only if the original parties’
decision to discontinue the battle reflects gross negligence or bad faith’).
5One notable submission to the court is the Draft Order Approv-
ing and Entering Consent Decree, filed jointly by plaintiffs and defen-
dants on March 16, 1990. It reflects the parties’ stipulationsas to findings
of fact and conclusions of law in this case. As such it can more properly
be characterized as a Stipulation, which is how the court will hereinafter
refer to it. While declining to incorporate the entire Stipulation into this
opinion, the court enters it into the record as evidence to be weighed in
evaluating the proposed consent decree.
B-4 |
therefore “be chary of disapproving a consent decree.” Id., p.
890. Indeed, the court “may not deny approval of a consent
decree unless it is unfair, unreasonable, or inadequate.” Id.,
p. 889.
The consent decree proposed here enjoins the en-
forcement of certain statutory provisions challenged by
plaintiffs. Foremost among them are Section 157-8.3(A) of
the ASTCA, defining any facility in which a medical or
surgical procedure is utilized to terminate a pregnancy as an
“Ambulatory Surgical Treatment Center”; and a host of
regulations requiring ASTCs to comport with physical plant
specifications and other restrictions which “in effect...require
ASTCs to be the functional equivalent of small hospitals.”* It
was this statutory scheme that plaintiffs regarded as in-
fringing on the constitutional right of women to have an
abortion, a view shared by this court and the Court of
Appeals.
The consent decree introduces a new scheme which
identifies two types of surgical facilities: those that perform
abortions beyond 18 weeks gestational age, or with general,
epidural, or spinal anesthesia, or with incisions exposing the
patient to a risk of infection; and those that perform abor-
tions within 18 weeks gestational age, under local anesthesia.
The former are made subject to a panoply of licensing
provisions under the ASTCA and Health Facilities Planning
Act. The latter, while still obliged to obtain a license, are
*Ragsdale v. Turnock, 625 F. Supp. at 1216. Together with the
appellate court’s opinion, that decision contains exhaustive discussions of
the statutes in question and plaintiffs’ challenge to them. The court’s task
here is not torehash that material, but rather to ask whether the proposed
consent decree fairly addresses the concerns expressed on both sides of the
dispute. Since the findings of fact set forth in the Ragsdale decisions are
relevant to that inquiry, the court incorporates them in today’s opinion.
{
B-5
required to comply with a new set of regulations tailored to
those facilities.’
This scheme is neither unfair, unreasonable, or inad-
equate. Ascounsel for both parties noted during the fairness
hearing, the settlement addresses each side’s principal con-
cern. To plaintiffs’ satisfaction, the decree preserves their
constitutional right to have or provide abortiuns; to defen-
dants’ satisfaction, it permits the Department of Public
Health to regulate outpatient clinics devoted to abortions
and abortion-related procedures. The decree reflects “the
essence of settlement,” which is “compromise...Each side
gains the benefit of immediate resolution of the litigation
and some measure of vindication for its position while
foregoing the opportunity to achieve an unmitigated vic-
tory.” Hiram Walker, 768 F.2d at 889.
Various objectors insist that the proposed consent
decree compromises too much. Family Planning Associates
Medical Group (FPA), a major provider of abortion services
in Chicago and elsewhere, objects to the provision that
subjects an abortion-only surgical facility to full ASTC
regulatory requirements ifit uses general anesthesia. “That
provision,” says FPA, “permits the imposition ofburdensome
and medically unnecessary regulations that would imper-
missibly infringe on the rights of the physician class to
provide abortion services...” FPA brief, p. 2.
FPA’s argumentis unavailing. General anesthesiais
more hazardous than local anesthesia, a fact to which
Doctors Ragsdale and Hern, plaintiff and plaintiffs’ expert,
-'The decree does not require a separate license for physicians
whose offices are not primarily devoted to providing surgical services, and
it does not affect the provision of abortions in hospitals.
B-6
respectively, testified. State Defendants’ Response, p. 8.
Indeed, the Abortion Standards and Guidelines of Planned
Parenthood Federation of America, Inc. provide that
“(gleneral anesthesia may not be used in out-of-hospital
settings.” Id. In view of this distinction between local and
general anesthesia, the court cannot conclude that the
provision challenged by FPA renders the settlement unfair
or unreasonable.
Equally unavailing are suggestions by a number of
objectors that Webster v. Reproductive Health Services,
Inc.,__U.S.__, 109 S.Ct. 3040 (1989), requires disapproval of
the settlement. Webster concerned the use of public facili-
ties and employees to perform abortions, the use of public
funding for abortion counseling, and viability testing at 20
weeks gestation. These issues are not involved here. As the
state defendants properly observe, “(t]he Webster decision
did not provide any definitive pronouncements for purposes
of this litigation and did not overrule the previous relevant
Supreme Court decisions.” State Defendants’ Response, p. 9.
Similarly, mere speculation that the Supreme Court
might uphold the provisions challenged here in light of
Webster will not invalidate the consent decree.’ In deciding
whether to approve a settlement, “[t]he district court should
refrain from resolving the merits of the controversy or
making a precise determination of the parties’ respective
legal rights.” Hiram Walker, 768 F.2d at 889. Settlement
proceedings are not an appropriate occasion for resolving the
merits of undecided legal issues. The court declines the in-
°To say the Supreme Cour! might uphold the challenged provi-
sions is doubly speculative. Not only is the substantive law unsettled, but
the Court reserved the issue of jurisdiction and may not have reached the
merits in this case.
B-7
vitation of some objectors to do so.
Other objectors insist that the consent decree en-
dangers the health and safety of women seeking abortions.
There is no evidence to support this contention. To the
contrary, in their briefs and at the fairness hearing, counsel
for both parties made clear what their intentions were
during settlement negotiations: to assure safe and sanitary
conditions for abortion procedures while permitting women
the opportunity to exercise their constitutional rights. To-
ward that end, the parties consulted with obstetricians,
gynecologists, and other medical and public health experts
in drafting the terms of the settlement.®
Far from leaving women unprotected, the settlement
creates a network of statutes and rules regulating the
provision of abortion services. Facilities that provide abor-
tions beyond 18 weeks gestational age or use general anes-
thesia mustcomply with the Ambulatory Surgical Treatment
Center Licensing Requirements. Facilities that offer abor-
tion services within 18 weeks gestational age, using loca!
anesthesia, must abide by the requirements set forth under
subpart G of the ASTCA, “Limited Procedure Specialty
Centers.” Like any other provider of medical services, abortion
providers must comply with standards of conduct generally
applicable to the medical profession.'° Finally, the Clinical
*Among those consulted were the American College of Obstetri-
cians and Gynecologists, Planned Parenthood Federation of America, the
National Abortion Federation, and other professional societies. The
parties also reviewed Williams Obstetrics and other respected medical
texts and publications. Stipulation, p. 18.
Some objectors complain that the decree puts physicians wholly
outside the regulatory powers of the state, but that objection misses the
mark. No less than the clinics regulated by the ASTCA, physicians may
not violate accepted standards of medical practice when performing abor-
B-8
Laboratory Act — and any other present or future legislation
not contrary to the consent decree — may be applied to
providers of abortion services."
Taken together, these statutes and regulations pro-
vide the state with ample authority to safeguard the health
and safety of women seeking abortions. That is certainly the
view of the Department of Public Health, which is charged
with regulating health care in the State of Illinois: “it is the
judgment of the medical doctors with the Department of
Public Health that the remaining regulations provide a
sufficient mechanism by which the Department can regu-
late and inspect these facilities in order to minimize the risk
of harm to patients undergoing surgery at these facilities.
This judgment, as well as the goal of regaining regulatory
authority is consistent with the stated purpose of the ASTC
Act to promote safe and adequate treatment.” State Defen-
dants’ Response, p. 7 (citation omitted).
There remain two objections to the proposed consent
decree worth discussing. A handful of state’s attorneys
contend that the defendant class to which they belong was
not adequately represented during settlement negotiations.
In support of this charge, the objectors refer obliquely to
"information" culled from their review of the settlement
proceedings which they regard as evidence of inadequate re-
presentation. They consider the behavior of their class
tions.
Moreover, the decree leaves the Legislature free to amend the
Medical Practice Act or to enact legislation specifically regulating physi-
cians’ offices.
"The consent decree does not, as some objectors contend, purport
to bind future actions of the General Assembly. The decree specifically
applies only to the challenged statutes as presently enacted. If those
statutes are amended or new statutes passed, the decree does not affect
their enforcement.
B-9
representative so suspect that, even if it does not require
rejection of the proposed settlement, it warrants further
discovery.
Their charge is without merit. On November 8, 1989,
this court ordered the State’s Attorney of Cook County, or his
representative, to participate in settlement negotiations.
Assistant State’s Attorney Harold E. McKee, III, was as-
signed to the case. At the fairness hearing, plaintiffs and
defendants alike attested to the vigor and frequency of Mr.
McKee’s participation in the negotiations. He “attend[ed|
and participate[d] in all settlement negotiations...partici-
pated in drafting the proposed seitlement and consent de-
cree, represented the class interest in maintaining the
ability to prosecute future violations under the settled acts,
and also participated in the briefings held for the benefit of
the news media...” State’s Attorney Partee’s Response, p. 4.
The court finds his representation adequate and denies the
Motion for Leave to Take Discovery brought by Dennis
Schumacher, Greg McClintock, Samuel Naylor, and Stephen
L. Reed, state’s attorneys for Ogle, Warren, Hancock, and
Henderson counties, respectively.
Finally, some objectors challenge the consent decree
because it would expose defendants to a claim for attorney's
fees. But the consent decree expressly reserves the issue of
attorney’s fees for resolution at a later date:
The plaintiffs’ entitlement to, and the amount
of, any counsel fees and reimbursement of
disbursements and expenses to be paid by the
defendants shall be determined by the District
Court upon proper application by the plaintiffs
after the entry of the Consent Decree and
final judgment.
B-10
Settlement Agreement, p. 5. Any objections regarding fees
made at this time are premature.
The parties’ Stipulation discusses this and nearly
every other aspect of these settlement proceedings. Al-
though far too detailed for full discussion here, some elements
of the Stipulation deserve mention. Beginning with page 7,
for instance, the Stipulation comprehensively reviews the
procedural history behind the consent decree. The court
incorporates that review in this opinion. Further, the
Stipulation identifies several factors which may be used to
decide whether a settlement is fair, including the strength of
plaintiffs’ case versus the settlement offer; the complexity
and expense of further litigation; the reaction of class mem-
bers to the settlement; the opinion of competent counsel; and
the stage of proceedings and amount of discovery completed.
Stipulation, p. 27.
Without le _nching into full analysis of these factors
here, the court notes that it considered them all in reaching
its holding today. The consent decree offers plaintiffs, by
their own admission, “permanentinjunctive relief similar...to
that which they sought in this litigation...” (Stipulation, p.
28); further litigation could prove lengthy and expensive;
few class members objected to the settlement; counsel were
clearly well-informed and represented their clients zeal-
ously; and the settlement agreement arose late in the pro-
ceedings, after thorough discovery had been completed.
These and other factors considered by the court are more
fully explained by the parties in the Stipulation.
For the foregoing reasons, the court finds the proposed
consent decree lawful, fair, reasonable, and adequate. Ac-
cordingly, the court grants the parties’ joint motion for
approval of the settlement, and enters the consent decree
herewith.
B-11
4. tec Ly
ENTER: /s/.}ohn A. Nordberg
United States District Judge
Dated: March 22, 1990
CONSENT DECREE
I. HISTORY OF THE LITIGATION
This class action litigation was commenced as a civil
rights case on June 28, 1985, by named Plaintiffs Richard M.
Ragsdale, M.D., Margaret Moe, R.N., the Northern Illinois
Women’s Center, Sarah Roe and Jane Doe, under 42 U.S.C.
sections 1983 and 1988, and 28 U.S.C. sections 2201 et seq.
Plaintiffs claimed that the challenged Illinois statutes and
regulations, which included (1) the Medical Practice Act,
("MPA”) Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111 section 4433 (a)-(e) (since
recodified at Il] Rev. Stat. ch. 111 section 4400-22(1)), (2) the
Ambulatory Surgical Treatment Center Act (“ASTC Act”),
Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111 1/2 sections 157-8.1 to 157-8.16 and
regulations promulgated thereunder, and (3) the Health
Facilities Planning Act (““HFP Act”), Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111
1/2 sections 1151 to 1168, impermissibly restricted the
performance of first and second trimester abortions and thus
allegedly violated rights secured by the First, Fourth, Fifth,
Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States
Constitution.
A. Parties
1. Plaintiffs
Plaintiff Richard M. Ragsdale, M.D., is a physician,
licensed to practice in Illinois, who is the Director of the
Northern Illinois Women’s Center. At the time the com-
plaint was filed and at the present, Dr. Ragsdale performs
abortions for his women patients who seek such medical
B-12
care. Plaintiff Margaret Moe is a registered nurse and the
sole owner and executive director of a medical facility in
Cook County, Illinois. Ms. Moe employs licensed physicians
and she sought to offer abortion services at her facility.
Plaintiffs Sarah Roe and Jane Doe are patients of Dr.
Ragsdale who had sought and received an abortion from Dr.
Ragsdale and who may need or desire another abortion in
the future.
The named plaintiffs brought this lawsuit on their
own behalf, on behalf of a class of physicians who perform or
desire to perform abortions in the State of Illinois, and on
behalf of a class of Illinois women who desire abortion
services. In orders issued on November 27, 1985 and on
December 11, 1985, this Court certified the following plain-
tiff classes pursuant to Rule 23(b) of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure:
(a) A plaintiff class consisting of all phy-
sicians and surgeons who perform or desire to
perform abortions in the State of Illinois;
[and]
(b) Aplaintiffclass consisting ofall Illinois
women of child-bearing age who desire or may
desire an abortion sometime in the future[.]
2. Defendants
Defendant Bernard J. Turnock, M.D., is the Director
of the Department of Public Health of the State of Illinois
and was suedin his official capacity. He is responsible for the
enforcement of the ASTC Act and for the promulgation and
enforcement of regulations under that Act, and has certain
administrative responsibilities under the HFP Act.
B-13
Defendant Neil F Hart‘ gan, Attorney General of the
State of Illinois, was sued in his official capacity, in which he
is charged with the defense of challenges to the MPA, the
ASTC Act and the HFP Act, and their respective regulations,
throughout the State of Illinois. In addition, as chief legal
officer of the state, the Attorney General represents the
directors of state agencies in their enforcement activities,
and upon referral by these agencies, has certain enforce-
ment responsibilities on behalf of these agencies.
Defendant Gary L. Clayton was sued in his official
capacity as the Director of the Illinois Department of Regis-
tration and Education. As such Mr. Clayton, and his succes-
sor in office at the successor agency, Robert C. Thompson,
the Acting Director of the Department of Professional Regu-
lation, is empowered to implement, administer, and enforce
the MPA.
Defendant Richard M. Daley was sued in his official
capacity as State’s Attorney of Cook County, and as the
representative of the defendant class of all state’s attorneys
of the 102 counties of the State of Illinois. Under the ASTC
Act, the Director of the Department of Public Heaith may,
through the State’s Attorney of the county in which the
violation occurs, seek injunctions to restrain violations of the
ASTC Act or its regulations, or enjoin future operation of any
ambulatory surgical treatment center (“ASTC”) violating
the ASTC Act or its regulations. Under the HFP Act, state’s
attorneys may prosecute persons in violation of the Act for
committing a business offense.
In orders issued on November 27, 1985 and on De-
cember 11, 1985, this Court certified the following defendant
class pursuant to Rule 23(b)(1) of the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure:
B-14
“A defendant class consisting of all State’s
Attorneys in the State of Illinois.”
Richard M. Daley, as the State’s Attorney of Cook County,
was named as representative of this defendant class. Rich-
ard M. Daley has been succeeded in office by Cecil A. Partee,
who pursuant to Rule 25(d), F.R.Civ.P., has been automati-
cally substituted as the named defendant state’s attorney
and as representative of the defendant class of state’s at-
torneys.
B. Jurisdiction
This Court concludes that it has jurisdiction of this
action under 28 U.S.C. section 1343. Venue is proper in the
United States District Court for the Northern District of
Illinois pursuant to 28 U.S.C. section 1391.
C. The Claims
In their Complaint, plaintiffs alleged that the chal-
lenged statutes and regulations impermissibly restricted
the ability of physicians to perform and the ability of women
to secure first and second trimester abortions. Plaintiffs
claimed that the laws singled out abortions for a discrimina-
tory level of regulation and, further, required that all
abortions performed in Illinois be performed in a hospital, or
its functional equivalent—an ASTC. Plaintiffs thus alleged
that the laws violated plaintiffs’ right of privacy as guaranteed
by the First, Fourth, Fifth, Ninth, and Fourteenth Amend-
ments to the Constitution and the penumbra of the Bill of
Rights. Plaintiffs also alleged that the challenged provisions
deprived Dr. Ragsdale and other physicians of their asserted
right to practice medicine free from vague, arbitrary, irra-
tional and burdensome regulations, in violation of the equal
protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendments to the Uni-
B-15
—— a a
ted States Constitution, and that the provisions similarly
prevented Margaret Moe from operating her facility free
from vague, arbitrary, irrational and burdensome regula-
tions, in violation of the equal protection clause of the
Fourteenth Amendinent. Plaintiffs sought declaratory and
injunctive relief from the enforcement of the challenged
provisions.
Defendants filed an Answer which denied each and
every allegation of the Complaint, except as otherwise re-
| sponded to. Defendants specifically denied each and every
allegation that the laws, as written or as enforced, violated
any of plaintiffs’ rights guaranteed by the First, Fourth,
Fifth, Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United
States Constitution. Defendants argued that the challenged
statutes and regulations reflected accepted medical, health,
safety, and construction standards for outpatient surgical
facilities. In addition, defendants contended that the chal-
lenged provisions appropriately furthered the State’s inter-
ests in protecting the health, safety and welfare of women
who choose to have abortions in such facilities
D. The Preliminary Injunction
Following an evidentiary hearing and a review of the
pleadings and other written evidence submitted by the
parties, this Court granted plaintiffs’ Motion for a Prelimi-
nary Injunction in orders issued on November 27, 1985 and
on December 11, 1985. The Court enjoined the defendant
class members and the individual defendants Bernard J.
Turnock, Neil F. Hartigan, and Gary Clayton (hereafter
collectively referred to as “defendants”), in their official
capacities, and defendants’ successors, officers, agents, ser-
vants, employees and attorneys and those persons in active
concert or participation with them, from enforcing section
4433 (1) (a)-(e) (now section 22 (1) (a)-(e)) of the MPA, the
B-16
ie —
ASTC Act and any rules and regulations promulgated there-
under, or the HFP Act, against any person or facility to the
extent such person or facility offers or performs, or desires to
offer or perform first or early second trimester abortions or
other abortion-related gynecological procedures, such as a
dilation and curettage.
On March 10, 1988, the United States Court of
Appeals for the Seventh Circuit upheld the Preliminary
Injunction, except insofar as the challenge to one provision
was determined to be moot. The Court of Appeals subse-
quently denied defendants’ petition for rehearing and sug-
gestion for rehearing en banc on August 12, 1988.
Thereafter, defendants Turnock, Hartigan, and
Stephen Selcke, then-director of the Department of Profes-
sional Regulation and successor to defendant Clayton, filed
a Notice of Appeal, seeking review by the Supreme Court of
the United States.
II. RESOLUTION OF DISPUTED ISSUES
This Consent Decree is the result of negotiation and
-ettlement. Defendants deny the allegations in the Com-
plaint and specifically deny that the challenged provisions
a > heir enforcement of them violates the constitutional or
other legal rights of the plaintiff classes. Nothing herein
shall be considered an admission of fault of any kind by the
defendants, nor shall anything herein be considered a reflec-
tion of any weakness of proof by the plaintiffs.
The parties are desirous of avoiding further protracted
and costly litigation and therefore have agreed that this
controversy should by resolved by settlement and without
further evidentiary hearings. In addition, the defendants
cesire to expeditiously regain the State’s authority to license
B-17
intense,
and regulate outpatient surgical facilities in which abor-
tions are performed and to implement and enforce regula-
tions as to such facilities. Accordingly, as indicated by the
signatures below, the parties have agreed to the entry of this
Consent Decree.
This Consent Decree and judgment shall constitute a
final resolution of all of the claims for declaratory and
injunctive’ relief asserted in the complaint, with the reser-
vation of plaintiffs’ claims for attorney's fees, costs, and
expenses, and shall be binding upon the parties to the action,
their officers, agents, servants, employees, and attorneys,
and upon those persons in active concert or participation
with them, including: the defendants, their agents and
employees, and their successors in office, the defendant class
of state’s attorneys, and upon the named plaintiffs and all
persons in the classes they represent. The plaintiffs’ en-
titlement to, and the amount of, any counsel fees and
reimbursement of costs and expenses shall be determined by
the Court upon proper application by the plaintiffs after
entry of this Decree. Defendants retain their right to object
to such application submitted by plaintiffs. The parties also
may resolve the plaintiffs’ claim to fees, costs and expenses
by agreement.
Plaintiffs and defendants agree to the dissolution of
the Preliminary Injunction and to the entry of this Consent
Decree as a Permanent Injunction.
Ill. FINDING OF FAIRNESS AND ADEQUACY
The Court, having held a hearing pursuant to court-
ordered notice to the plaintiff and defendant classes in
accordance with Rule 23(e) of the Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure, hereby finds that the terms of this Consent
Decree provide for a fair, adequate, and reasonable settle-
B-18
|
ment of the claims for declaratory and injunctive relief
asserted in the complaint, with the exception of plaintiffs’
claims for attorney’s fees, costs and expenses. The Court
thereby dissolves the Preliminary Injunction and enters this
Consent Decree as a Permanent Injunction, the injunctive
terms of which are set forth in section IV.
IV. JUDGMENT AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION
NOW, THEREFORE, upon the consent of the parties
and approval of this Court, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED,
ADJUDGED AND DECREED:
[SEE ATTACHMENT A FOR THE INJUNCTIVE
PORTION OF THIS CONSENT DECREE]
V. COMPLIANCE
Class members shall be given at least 6 months from
the date of approval of this Consent Decree to bring their
facility into compliance with the terms of the Consent Decree
or any new regulations promulgated by the Department of
Health, pursuant to this decree, governing the provision of
abortion services.
ORDERED THIS 22 day of March, 1990.
ENTER;/s/ John A. Nordberg
United States District Judge
Approved:
One of the Attorneys for
the Plaintiff Class:
/s/ Colleen K. Connell
Bernard J. Turnock, M.D.,
Director, Illinois
Department of Public Health
Defendant Neil F. Hartigan
Attorney General of Illinois
One of the Attorneys for
Cecil A. Partee State’s Attorney
of Cook County and the defendant
class of State’s Attorneys
Kevin K. Wright,
Director, Illinois
Department of Professional
Regulation
ATTACHMENT A
INJUNCTION PORTION OF
CONSENT DECREE
1. Defendants, in their official capacities, their suc-
cessors in office, their officers, agents, servants, contractors,
employees and attorneys, and those people in active concert
and participation with them, are hereby enjoined from
initiating any prosecution, including but not limited to
criminal, civil and administrative proceedings, or imposing
any sanction for violation of, or enforcing in any way, any of
the statutes set forth in subparagraphs (A) and (B) below
against any person or facility offering or performing abortions:
B-20
A. Section 157-8.3(A) (section 3) of the Ambulatory
Surgical Treatment Center Act ("ASTC Act”), Ill. Rev. Stat.
ch. 111-1/2, pars. 157-8.3(A), to the extent that Ambulatory
Surgical Treatment Center is defined as any facility in
which a medical or surgical procedure is utilized to termin-
ate a pregnancy.
B. Section 22(1)(a)-(e) of the Medical Practice Act.
Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111.
2. Defendants, in their official capacities, their suc-
cessors in office, their officers, agents, servants, contractors,
emp!oyees and attorneys. and those people in active
concert and participation with them, are hereby enjoined
from initiating any prosecution, including but not limited
to criminal, civil and administrative proceedings, or im-
posing any sanction for violation of, or enforcing in any way,
against any licensed Ambulatory Surgical Treatment
Center (“ASTC"), the following provisions of the Ambulatory
Surgical Treatment Center Licensing Requirements, 77 Ill.
Admin. Code, Section 205, subchap. b: (1) 205.710, (2)
205.720, (3)205.730(aX3) and (b), (4) 205.740, and(5) 205.760, -
and, if such facility provides only abortions and related
gynecological procedures, (6) 205.120(b)(5)-(7), and (7)
205.125(b)(5)-(7), to the extent that, provided that all infor-
mation required under said sections is maintained at the
ASTC, the application required by said sections need only
include the name, address or telephone number of the
owner(s), administrator(s) and medical director(s) of the
ASTC.
3. Defendants, in their official capacities, their suc-
cessors in office, their officers, agents, servants, contractors,
employees and attorneys, and those people in active concert
and participation with them, are hereby enjoined from
initiating any prosecution, including but not limited to cri-
B-21
minal, civil and administrative proceedings, or imposing
any sanction for violation of, or enforcing in any way, any
of the statutes or regulations set forthin subparagraphs (A)
and (B) below against any person or facility offering or
performing abortions within 18 weeks assessed gestational
age, with only local, and not general, epidural, or spinal
anesthesia, without incisions or other techniques which
expose a person to risk of infection from airborne bacteria,
and gynecological procedures related to such abortions, in
an ASTC whose surgical procedures are limited to the
performance of such abortions and gynecological procedures
related to such abortions:
A. Sections 1152-1168 of the Health Facilities Plan-
ning Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111-1/2, pars. 1152-1168.
B. The following provisions of the Ambulatory Sur-
gical Treatment Center Licensing Requirements, 77 III.
Admin. Code, Section 205, subchap. b:
(1) 205.120(bX5)-(7) - Licensure, enjoined to the ex-
tent that, provided that all information required under said
section is maintained at the ASTC; the application need only
include the name, address or telephone number of the
owner(s), administrator(s) and medical director(s) of the
ASTC.
(2) 205.125(bX5)-(7) - Application for License Re-
newal, enjoined to the extent that, provided that all informa-
tion required under said section is maintained at the ASTC,
the application need only include the name, address or
telephone number of the owner(s), administrator(s) and
medical director(s) of the ASTC.
(3) 205.520(c) - Preoperative Care, enjoined to the
extent said section requires tests to be performed by a quali-
B-22
fied laboratory technician. (Relevant legal requirements
regarding laboratory tests are found in the Clinical Labora-
tory Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111-1/2, Sections 621-103 et seq.)
(4) 205.330 - Nursing Personnel, enjoined to the ex-
tent that “surgical experience” as used in said section may be
interpreted to exclude experience gained in a clinical facility
providing abortion procedures.
(5) 205.410(c) - Equipment, enjoined to the extent
that said section requires an ASTC that does not use inha-
lation anesthetic or medical gas to have written procedures
to insure the safety in use or storage of such substances,
provided that if intravenous sedation is used in accordance
with the ASTC’s program narrative, mechanical ventilation
devices and intubation equipment must be available on site.
(6) 205.540(cX1)-(3) - Post Operative Care, enjoined
to the extent the requirements of said section would apply in
circumstances where (1) no licensed hossital within 15
minutes from the ASTC (“nearby hospital”) will allow
admitting or practice privileges to abortion providers and (2)
either the ASTC has a transfer agreement with a nearby
hospital, or a physician practicing at the ASTC or the
medical director of the ASTC has a professional working
relationship or agreement, maintained in writing at the
ASTC and verifiable by IDPH, with a physician who does
have admitting or practice privileges at a nearby hospital, so
as to assure availability of patient care in the event of
medical complications ensuing from an abortion or a gyne-
cological procedure related to an abortion.
(7) 205.710 - Abortions, enjoined.
(8) 205.720 - Personnel, enjoined.
B-23
(9) 205.730 - General Patient Care, 730(aX(1), en-
joined to the extent that said section requires any examina-
tion beyond a determination of the patient’s blood Rh factor;
730 aX3), enjoined; and 730(b), enjoined.
(10) 205.740 - Pre-operativ irements, en-
joined.
(11}-205.760 - Reports, enjoined.
(12) 205.1310(a) - Plant and Service Requirements,
enjoined to the extent that said section requires that a
proposed ASTC meet any requirements enjoined or not
permitted pursuant to the provisions of this decree.
(13) 205.1320 (a Xl) - ions, en-
joined to the extent that said section requires any physical
marking that denotes the facility as an ASTC.
(14) 205.1350 - Admission Department and Public
Areas, enjoined, provided that the ASTC complies with all
applicable federal and state handicap access laws, includ-
ing, without limitation, the Illinois Environmental Barriers
Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111-1/2, Section 3711.
(15) 205.1360 - Clinical Facilities, 1360(aX1) [ex-
amination room], enjoined to the extent said section would
require that the examination room (which need not be
separate from the procedure room) be larger than minimally
adequate to accommodate the equipment required for the
examination, to facilitate the examination safely, and to
allow unobstructed ingress and egress to and from the room
through the door that, if locked, can be opened from within
the room;
.1360(b)(1) [procedure room], enjoined to the extent said sec-
B-24
tion would require a room larger than 120 square feet with
a minimum dimension of at least 10 feet unless the ASTC
demonstrates that a smaller room size is minimally ad-
equate to accommodate all equipment required for the pro-
cedures, to perform the procedures safely, and to protect
patients and staff in the event of fire or other emergency;
.1360(b)(2) [communication system], enjoined;
.1360(cX2) [recovery room], enjoined to the extent said
section would require a room larger than is necessary to
- accommodate the recovery beds or lounge chairs in the room,
with a minimum of three feet between each bed or chair and
an unobstructed passageway of a minimum of four feet
clearance at one end each bed or chair;
.1360(c3) [drug distribution station, hand washing facility,
charting facility, nurses’ station and storage space for sup-
plies and equipment], enjoined except that the ASTC must
provide for direct visual supervision of the patients’ recovery
area;
.1360(c\ 4) [toilet specifications], enjoined to the extent said
section would require the inclusion of a toilet, a gray
diverter valve or a fluid waste disposal in the recovery room
ifa toilet is reserved for only patient use and does not require
recovery room patients to enter public areas or other patient
care areas to access the toilet; and
.1360(c)(7) [minimum of four recovery beds or lounge chairs],
enjoined to the extent said section would require the
inclusion of more than three recovery beds or lounge chairs
for each procedure room unless the ASTC’s narrative program
provides that no more than two Procedures per hour will be
performed per procedure room, in which case a minimum
of two recovery beds or lounge chairs for each procedure
B-25
room is required.
(16) 205.1370 - Support Services,
.1370(a) [control station], enjoined;
.1370(d) [scrub stations], enjoined to the extent said section
requires a separate scrub station outside of the procedure
room, provided that the procedure room contains a sink with
handwashing capabilities;
.1370(e) [soiled workroom], enjoined to the extent that the
section requires more than closed clean storage which pre-
vents contamination by soiled materials and for separate
storage and handling of soiled materials;
.1370(f) [fluid waste disposal}, enjoined to the extent said
section requires more than a toilet with a gray diverter
valve, a sink exclusively used for fluid waste disposal, or a
separate fluid waste disposal unit;
.1370(g) [workroom or supply room], enjoined to the extent
said section requires more than facilities for closed clean
storage;
.1370(h) [anesthesia storage], enjoined;
.1370(i) [medical gas storage], enjoined;
.1370(k) [changing areas -- staff], enjoined to the extent that
the section requires more than minimally adequate space for
any changing or gowning required by the specific procedures
that are being performed in accordance with the ASTC’s
narrative program;
.1370(1) [changing areas -- patients], enjoined; and
B-26
.1370(n) [janitor’s closet], enjoined to the extent that the
section requires more than mi~‘mally adequate space for
storage of cleaning supplies.
(17) 205.1380(b\3) and (4) - Diagnostic Facilities,
enjoined.
(18) 205.1400 - Details and Finishes,
.1400(a)(1) [minimum corridor width], enjoined to the ex-
tent said section would require that the width of corridors
in an ASTC exceed five feet;
.1400{b){3} [minimum door width], enjoined to the extent
said section would require that the width of any doors in an
ASTC exceed three feet;
.1400(d) [thresholds flush], enjoined, provided that the ASTC
complies with all applicable federal and state handicap
access laws, including, without limitation, the Illinois Envi-
ronmental Barriers Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111-1/2 Section
3711;
.1400(n) [ceiling .finish], enjoined to the extent said section
requires ceilings to be readily washable and without crev-
ices, if ceilings are otherwise cleanable;
(19) 205.1410(dX1) - Construction, Including Fire-
Resistive Requirements, enjoined, provided that the ASTC
complies with all applicable federal and state handicap
access laws, including, without limitation, the [Illinois
Environmental Barriers Act, Ill. Rev. Stat. ch. 111-1/2 Sec-
tion 3711.
(20) 205.1540(a)-(q) and Table A = Air conditioning,
Heating and Ventilating Systems, enjoined to the extent
B-27
ii ome: * lia a ill
that said section requires more than that temperature be
maintained between 68° and 80° Fahrenheit.
(21) 205.1750(b) - Receptacles, enjoined.
4. Following the entry of the Consent Decree, (1)
defendants may enforce those specific portions of the Medi-
cal Practice Act (“MPA”), the Health Facilities Planning Act
(“HFPA”), and the Ambulatory Surgical Treatment Center
Act (“ASTCA”) not enjoined herein; (2) defendants shall not
enforce Section 22(1)a)-(e) of the MPA as presently codified;
(3) defendants’ enforcement and non-enfercement of Sec-
tions 1152-1168 of the HF vA as presently codified shall be
consistent with the injunctions set forth in paragraphs 1
through 3 above; and (4) defendants’ future regulation under
and enforcement and non-enforcement of the present provi-
sions of the ASTCA shall be consistent with the injunctions
and specifications in paragraphs 1 through 3 above, and
further shall be limited as follows:
(A) With respect to any person or facility that offers
or performs abortions in any ASTC described in paragraphs
2 and 3 above, defendants may promulgate and enforce
regulations implementing the requirements of paragraphs 2
and 3 above (“implementing regulations”);
(B) With respect to any person or facility that offers
or performs abortions in any ASTC described in paragraph
3 above, defendants may promulgate, implement and en-
force future regulations under the ASTCA, which are differ-
ent from and additional to the requirements in paragraph 3
and the implementing regulations (“paragraph 3 future
regulations”) only when a change in medical or scientific
knowledge requires paragraph 3 future regulations in order
to insure against a significant health or safety risk to the
welfare of a woman undergoing an abortion as permitted in.
B-28
such ASTC, and further provided that no paragraph 3 future
regulations shall (i) restrict access to the procedure, either
by materially increasing the cost of the procedure or mate-
rially reducing the number of facilities without resulting in
more than a marginal increase in safety; (ii) interfere with
the safety of the procedure as determined by accepted
medical practice; or (iii) prevent a physician from exercising
medical discretion, within accepted medical practice and
within the scope of the facility, to provide a patient with
appropriate care given the unique circumstances presented
by her health situation; and
(C) With respect to any person or facility performing
an abortion in any ASTC described in paragraph 2 above,
defendants may promulgate, implement and enforce future
regulations which govern all such ASTCs (“paragraph 2
future regulations”), however, if any paragraph 2 future
regulations are specifically directed at the abortion proce-
dure, as opposed to all procedures done in such facility,
defendants may promulgate, implement and enforce such
paragraph 2 regulations only when a change in medical or
scientific knowledge requires paragraph 2 future regula-
tions in order to insure against a significant health or safety
risk to the welfare of a woman undergoing an abortion as
permitted in such ASTC, and further provided that no
paragraph 2 future regulations shall (i) restrict access to the
procedure, either by materially increasing the cost of the
procedure or materially reducing the number of facilities
without resulting in more than a marginal increase in
safety; (ii) interfere with the safety of the procedure as
determined by accepted medical practice; or (iii) prevent a
physician from exercising medical discretion, within ac-
cepted medical practice and within the scope of the facility
to provide a patient with appropriate care given the unique
circumstances presented by her health situation.
B-29
5. With respect to the number of weeks assessed
gestational age set forth in paragraph 3 and 4 above, the
parties stipulate that said figure has been determined by the
Illinois Department of Public Health and is based on an
assessment of risk to the health and safety of women as
evidenced by available published data, present surgical and
medical procedures commonly used and constituting accept-
able medical practice, and the standards and guidelines of
professional medical and health organizations. Following
the entry of this Consent Decree, the plaintiffs and the ©
Director of the IDPH expressly reserve the right to seek
modification by the Court of said figure upon a showing that
the further development of medical or scientific knowledge,
including the basis of assessment set forth above, evidences
that abortions and related gynecological procedures may be
or should be performed within a different number of weeks
in the facilities definedin paragraph 3, on the basis that such
a change would not pose or will eliminate a significant risk
to the health or safety of women obtaining such services.
6. The Court retains jurisdiction to enforce compli-
ance with the provisions of this Consent Decree.
B-30
APPENDIX C
(Entered March 22, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
V.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al., —
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
JUDGMENT
Judgment is entered as follows: Enter memorandum
opinion and order finding the proposed consent decree lawful,
fair, reasonable and adequate. Accordingly, the court grants
the parties’ joint motion for approval ot the settlement, and
enters the consent decree herewith. (For further detail see
order attached to the original minute order form).
ENTER: /s/ John A. Nordberg
United States District Judge
Dated: March 22, 1990
C-1
a
APPENDIX D
(Entered April 19, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
ORDER
Hearing held on Craig H. Greenwood, attorney for
Ritaellen M. Murphy and Penny R. Greenwood's petition to
clarify. Per oral ruling court denies Craig H. Greenwood's
petition to file his appearance. Court supplements the
memorandum opiniw” and order stating that additional
time to February 13, 1990 was given to file objections.
ENTER: /s/ John A. Nordberg
United States District Judge
Dated: April 19, 1990
D-]
APPENDIX E
(Filed April 20, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
a V.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
NOTICE OF APPEAL
\
Notice is hereby given that KENNETH M. REED, as
Expectant Father and Next Friend of BABY REED, and
MARK I. AUGHENBAUGH, as Expectant Father and Next
Friend of BABY AUGHENBAUGH, proposed Intervenors
as of right, hereby appeal to the United States Court of
Appeals for the Seventh Circuit from the MINUTE ORDER
dated and entered in this action on the 5th day of March,
1990, and MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER dated
and entered in this action on the 22nd day of March, 1990.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Kenneth M. Reed
/s/ Mark I. Aughenbaugh
E-]
APPENDIX F
(Filed April 20, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
V.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice is hereby given that RITAELLEN M. MURPHY
and PENNY R. GREENWOOD, members of the Plaintiff
class consisting of all Illinois women of child-bearing age
who desire or may desire an abortion sumetime in the future,
hereby appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit from the MEMORANDUM OPINION AND
ORDER dated and entered in this action on the 22nd day of
March, 1990.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Ritaellen M. Murphy
/s/ Penny R. Greenwood
F-]
APPENDIX G
(Filed May 18, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
V.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice is hereby given that KENNETH M. REED, as
Expectant Father and Next Friend of BABY REED, and
MARK I. AUGHENBAUGH, as Expectant Father and Next
Friend of BABY AUGHENBAUGH, proposed Intervenors
as of right, hereby appeal to the United States Court of
Appeals for tne Seventh Circuit from the MINUTE ORDER
dated and entered in this action on the 5th day of March,
1990, MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER dated and
entered in this action on the 22nd day of March, 1990, and
the minute order entered on the 19th day of April, 1990.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Kenneth M. Reed
/s/ Mark I. Aughenbaugh
G-1]
APPENDIX H
(Filed May 18, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice is hereby given that RITAELLEN M. MURPHY
and PENNY R. GREENWOOD, members of the Plaintiff
class consisting of all Illinois women of child-bearing age
who desire or may desire an abortion sumetime in the future,
hereby appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit from the MEMORANDUM OPINION AND
ORDER dated and entered in this action on the 22nd day of
March, 1990, and the minute order entered on the 19th day
of April, 1990.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Ritaellen M. Murphy
/s/ Penny R. Greenwood
H-1
APPENDIX I
(Entered May 21, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPPEALS
FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
Nos. 90-1907 and 90-1908
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M_D., et al..
Plaintiffs,
Vv.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK , et al., ;
Defendants.
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Northern District of Illinois
No. 85 C 6011 - John A. Nordberg, Judge
ORDER
The court, on its own motion, orders that these
appeals are CONSOLIDATED for purposes of briefing and
disposition.
Counsel for all parties are ordered to meet with the
court's Senior Staff Attorney, Donald J. Wall, in the court's
Auxiliary Courtroom at 9:00 a.m. on May 31, 1990 to discuss
coordinating the briefing in order to avoid burdening the
court with duplicative briefs.
I-1
LY
Briefing:on the merits shall be HELD IN ABEY-
ANCE pending further court order of this court.
APPENDIX J
(Entered June 7, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPPEALS
FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
Nos. 90-1907, 90-1908, 90-2122 and 90-2123
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
a Vv.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
e
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Northern District of Illinois
No. 85 C 6011 - John A. Nordberg, Judge
ORDER
The court, on its own motion, orders that these
uppeals are CONSOLIDATED for purposes of briefing and
disposition.
On May 31, 1990, the parties to these appeals had a
conference with DonaldJ. Wall, Semor Staff Attorney forthe
Court; a telephone conference call with the same parties was
heldonJune 4, 1990. As aresult, the following matters were
agreed to, and IT IS SO ORDERED
®
The briefing schedule is as follows:
1. The appellants shall file their joint consolidated
brief and required short appendix on or before July 9, 1990.
2. The appellees shall filed their respective consoli-
dated briefs on or before August 15, 1990.
3. The appellants shall file their joint consolidated
reply brief, if any, on or before September 5, 1990.
Counsel for appellees are encouraged to avoid un-
necessary duplication by filing a joint brief or a joint appen-
dix or by adopting parts of a co-appellee's brief. Duplicative
briefing will be striken and may result in disciplinary
sanctions against counsel.
NOTE: The parties are advised that Federal Rule of Appel-
late Procedure 26(c), which allows for three addi-
tional days after service by mail, does not apply
when the due dates of briefs are set by order of this
court. All briefs are due by the dates ordered.
J-2
APPENDIX K
(Entered July 9, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS
EASTERN DIVISION
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M.D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
V.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
No. 85 C 6011 - Judge Nordberg
ORDER
Hearing held on Craig Greenwood's motion for leave
to supplement the record on appeal. Per oral ruling, court
denies motion to supplement the record.
K-1
APPENDIX L
(Entered August 20, 1990)
(Corrected August 22, 1990)
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPPEALS
FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
Nos. 90-1907, 90-1908, 90-2122 and 90-2123
RICHARD M. RAGSDALE, M_D., et al.,
Plaintiffs,
V.
BERNARD J. TURNOCK, et al.,
Defendants.
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Northern District of Illinois
No. 85 C 6011 - John A. Nordberg, Judge
ORDER
Before Hon. WILLIAM J. BAUER, ChiefJudge, Hon.
WALTER J. CUMMINGS, Circuit Judge, Hon.
HARLINGTON WOOD, JR., Circuit Judge, Hon. RICHARD
D. CUDAHY, Circuit Judge, Hon. RICHARD A. POSNER,
Circuit Judge, Hon. JOHN L. COFFEY, Circuit Judge, Hon.
JOEL M. FLAUM, Circuit Judge, Hon. FRANK H.
EASTERBROOK, Circuit Judge, Hon. DANIELA. MANION,
Circuit Judge, Hon. MICHAEL S. KANNE, Circuit Judge.
L-1
This matter comes before the court for its consider-
ation of the "SUGGESTION FOR HEARING EN BANC"
filed herein on August 1, 1990, by counsel for the appellants.
Upon consideration by the active members of this court.*
ITIS ORDERED that the Suggestion for Hearing En
Banc is DENIED.
*Judge Ripple took no part in this matter.
L-2
APPENDIX M
August 15, 1990 Amendments to
Ambulatory Surgical Treatment Center
Licensing Requirements,
77 Ill.Adm.Code, Ch. 1, Sec. 205
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH
NOTICE OF ADOPTED AMENDMENTS
TITLE 77: PUBLIC HEALTH
CHAPTER I: DEPARTMENT OF. PUBLIC HEALTH
SUBCHAPTER b: HOSPITAL AND AMBULATORY
CARE FACILITIES
PART 205
AMBULATORY SURGICAL TREATMENT CENTER
Section
205.110
205.115
205.118
205.120
205.125
205.130
LICENSING REQUIREMENTS
SUBPART A: GENERAL
Definitions
Incorporated and Referenced Materiais
Conditions of Licensure
Application for Initial Licensure
Application for License Renewa!
Approval of Surgical Procedures
SIJBPART B: OWNERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT
Section
205.210
j
4
Ownership, Control and Management
M-1
205.220
205.230
205.240
L
Section
205.310
205.320
205.330
205.340
205.350
Section
205.410
205.420
Organizational Plan
Standards of Professional Work
Policies and Procedures Manual
SUBPART C: PERSONNEL
Personnei Policies
Presence of Qualified Physician
Nursing Personnel
Basic Life Support
Laboratory Services Ambulatory-Surgicat
TreatmentCenter
SUBPART D: EQUIPMENT, SUPPLIES, 2
AND FACILITY MAINTENANCE
Equipment
Sanitary Facility
SUBPART E: GENERAL PATIENT CARE
Section
205.510
205.520
205.530
205.540
Section
Emergency Care
Preoperative Care
Operative Care
Postoperative Care
SUBPART F: RECORDS AND REPORTS
205.610 Clinical Records
205.620 Statistical Data
iit
SPECIALTY CENTERS
}N-WHHGH-OBSFEFPRICAH/GYNECOLOGICAB
Section
205.710
205.720
205.730
205.740
205.750
205.760
Section
205.810
205.820
205.830
205.840
205.850
205.860
Section
205.1310
205.1320
205.1330
205.1840
PROCEDURES ARE PERFORMED
Pregnancy Termination Specialty Centers
SUBPART G: LIMITED PROCEDURE
Abortions
Personnel (Repealed)
General Patient Care (Repealed)
Preoperative Requirements (Repealed)
Postoperative Requirements (Repeaicd)
Reports (Reoealed)
SUBPART H: PROCEDURES FOR
Complaints
Acknowledgement of Compliant
Investigation
Prompt Investigation
Methods
Notification of Results
INVESTIGATION OF COMPLAINTS
SUBPART I: BUILDING DESIGN,
CONSTRUCTION STANDARDS,
AND PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS
Plant and Service Requirements
General Considerations
New Construction, Additions and Major
Alterations
‘
Minor Alterations and Remodeling Changes
M-.
)
4
205.1350
205.1360
205.1370
205.1380
205.1390
205.1400
205.1410
Section
205.1510
205.1520
205.1530
205.1540
Section
205.1610
205.1620
205.1630
205.1640
205.1650
Section
205.1710
205.1720
205.1730
205.1740
205.1750
Administration Department and Public Areas
Clinical Facilities
Support Service Areas
Diagnostic Facilities
Other Building Services
Details and Finishes
Construction, Including Fire Resistive
Requirements
SUBPART J: MECHANICAL
General
Thermal and Acoustical Insulation
Steam and Hot Water Systems
Air Conditioning, Heating and Ventilating
Systems :
SUBPART K: PLUMBING AND
OTHER PIPING SYSTEMS
General
Plumbing Fixtures
Water System
Drainage Systems
Identification
SUBPART L: ELECTRICAL
General
Switchboards and Power Panels
Panelboards
Lighting
Receptacles (Convenience Outlets)
M-4
|
205.1760 Grounding
205.1770 Equipment Installation in Special Areas
205.1780 Emergency Electric Service
205.1790 Fire Alarm System
205.TABLE A
AUTHORITY:
SOURCE:
General Pressure Relationships and
Ventilation Rates of Ambulatory Surgery
Area
Implementing and authorized by the
Ambulatory Surgical Treatment Center
Act (Ill. Rev. Stat. 1987, ch. 111 1/2, par.
157-8.1 et seq.)
Amended July 18, 1974; emergency
amendment at 3 Ill. Reg. 10. p. 43. effec-
tive February 23, 1979, for a maximum of
150 days; amended at 3 III. Reg. 30, p.
371, effective July 23, 1979; amended at
5 Ill. Reg. 12756, effective November 4,
1981; amended at 6 Ill. Reg. 6220, 6225,
and 6226, effective May 17, 1982;
amended at 6 Ill. Reg. 10974, effective
August 30, 1982; amended at 6 Ill. Reg.
13337, effective October 20. 1982;
amended at 7 Ill. Reg. 7640, effective
June 14, 1983; codified at 8 Ill. Reg.
9367; amended at 9 Ill. Reg. 12014,
effective July 23. 1985; amended at 10 Ill.
Reg. 8806, effective June 1, 1986;
amended at 10 Ill. Reg. 21906, effective
January 15, 1987; amended at 11 Ill. Reg.
14786, effective October 1, 1987;
amended at 12 Ill. Reg. 3743. effective
February 15, 1988; amended at 12 III.
Reg. 15573, effective October 1, 1988;
M-5
amended at 13 Ill. Reg. 16025. effective
November 1, 1989; emergency amended
at 14 Ill. Reg. 5596, effective March 26,
1990, for a maximum of 150 days;
amended at 14 Ill. Reg. ___, effective
August 15, 1990.
NOTE: Capitalization denotes statutory lan-
guage.
SUBPART A: GENERAL
Section 205.120 Application for Initial Licensure
a) AN APPLICATION FOR LICENSE SHALL BE MADE
TO THE DEPARTMENT ON FORMS PROVIDED BY THE
DEPARTMENT (Section 5 of the Act). The application shall
be submitted not less than sixty days prior to the date of
intended operation and shall contain the information re-
quired under the Act and this Part.
b) The initial application shall include the following infor-~
mation:
1) The names and addresses of all persons who own
the facility, any names under which any of these
persons do business. and the type of ownership of the
facility (for example, individual, partnership, corpo-
ration, or association). In addition, a corporation
shall submit:
A) A copy of its certificate of incorporation.
B) Alist ofthe title, name and address of each
of its corporate officers.
M-6
C) Alistofthe name and address of each of its
shareholders holding more than five percent
of the shares.
2) The names and addresses of all persons under
contract to manage or operate the facility.
3) The location of the facility.
4) Information regarding any conviction of the appli-
cant, or if the applicant is a firm, partnership or
association, of any of its members, or if the applicant
is a corporation, of any of its officers or directors, or
of the person designated to manage or supervise the
facility, of a felony, or of two or more misdemeanors
involving moral turpitude in the last five years.
5) The name, address, telephone number, education,
experience, credentials and any professional licensure
or certification of the following persons:
A) Administrator.
B) Medical Director.
C) Supervising Nurse.
6) Alistofthe medical staffincluding name, address;
telephone number; specialty and license number.
7) A list of all staff personnel including name,
address-tetephone-number; position, education. ex-
perience, and any professional licensure or certifi-
cation.
8) A narrative description of the facility including
but not limited to interviewing, examination. surgi-
M-7
cal and recovery room facilities.
9) A description of services to be provided by the
facility including a list of surgical procedures to be
performed subject to approval in accordance with the
requirements of Section 205.130.
10) Documentation of compliance with Section
205.350 of this Part. Frenanre-address-edueation,;
Whe abe — T°
ee ~at ea iene va
taboratery;treensed bythe Department;te-perform
sere tal :
11) Acopy of the transfer agreement with a !icensed
hospital within approximately 15 minutes travel
time of the facility or other documentation demon-
strating compliance with Section 205.540(d) tes of this
Part.
12) A copy of the organizational plan of the facility
(see Section 205.220).
13) Schematic architectural plans.
14) Documentation of a permit as required by the
Illinois Health Facilities Planning Act (Ill. Rev. Stat.
1987, ch. 111 1/2, par. 1151 et seq.)
15) Documentation of compliance with all applicable
local building, utility, and safety codes.
c) THE APPLICATION SHALL BE SIGNED BY THE
APPLICANT AND SHALL INCLUDE A VERIFICATION
form acknowledging the application to be true and complete
M-8
and certifying that the applicant has knowledge of and
understands the action required to comply with the Act and
licensing requirements. THE FORM SHALL BE VERI-
FIED by a notary public. (Section 5 of the Act)
d) THE LICENSE APPLICATION SHALL BE ACCOMPA-
NIED BY A LICENSE FEE OF $500. (Section 5 of the Act)
(Source: Amended at 14 II]. Reg. , effective August 15,
1990)
Section 205.125 Application for License Renewal
a) Application for license renewal shall be submitted on
forms provided by the Department. Application for license
renewal shall be submitted to the Department not less than
30 days prior to the expiration date.
b) An application for license renewal shall include the
following information:
1) The names and addresses of all persons who own
the facility, any names under which any of these
persons do business, and the type of ownership of the
facility (for example, individual, partnership, corpo-
ration, or association). In addition, a corporation
shall submit:
A) Alist of the title, name and address of each
of its corporate officers.
B) A list of the name and address of each ofits
shareholders holding more than five percent
of tha shares.
2) The names and addresses of all persons under
M-9
contract to manage or operate the facility.
3) The location of the facility.
4) Information regarding any conviction of the appli-
cant, or if the applicant is a firm, partnership or
association, of any ofits members, or if the applicant
is a corporation, of any of its officers or directors, or
of the person designated to manage or supervise the
facility, of a felony, or of two or more misdemeanors
involving moral turpitude during the previous year.
5) The name, address, and telephone number of the
administrator, medical director, and supervising
nurse. In addition. the education, experience, cre-
dentials and any professional licensure or certifica-
tion of these individuals must also be submitted if
this information was not submitted with the initial
application or a prior renewal application or if this
information has changed since the prior submission.
6) Alistofthe medical staffincluding name, address;
telephone -nimber; specialty and license number.
7) A list of all staff personnel including name,
atdress-tetephone number, position, education, ex-
perience, and any professional licensure or certifica-
tion.
8) A list of surgical procedures being performed at
the facility. Any new procedures which are included
in this list must be identified and are subject to
approval in accordance with the requirements of
Section 205.130.
c) THE APPLICATION SHALL BE SIGNED BY THE
&
M-10
APPLICANT AND SHALL INCLUDE A VERIFICATION
form acknowledging the application to be true and complete
and certifying that the applicant has knowledge of and
understands the action required to comply with the Act and
licensing requirements. THE FORMSHALLBE VERIFIED
by a notary public. (Section 5 of the Act)
d) The license renewal applic. ction shall be accompanied by
A LICENSE RENEWALFEE OF $300. (Section 6ofthe Act)
(Source: Amended at 14 IIL. Reg. , effective August 15
1990)
SUBPART C: PERSONNEL
Section 205.350 Laboratory Services. Atrbttatorypsurprest
Hach ambulatory surgical treatment center shali meet each
harve-one of the following requirements:
b) Have a” written agreement with a laboratory, teensed
by-theDepartment under the Department's rules Illinois
Clihical Laboratories Code {77 lll, Adm, Code 4150), tc
perform any required laboratory procedures which are not
performed in the center.
M-11
(Source: Amended at 14 Ill. Reg. : effective August 15,
1990)
SUBPART E: GENERAL PATIENT CARE
Section 205.520 Preoperative Care
a) Where medical evaluation, examination, and referral are
made from a private physician’s office, hospital, or clinic,
pertinent records thereof shall be available and made part of
the patient’s clinical record at the time the patient is regis-
tered and admitted to the ambulatory surgical treatment
center.
b) A complete medical history shall be obtained and the
physical examination shall be complete. A preanesthetic
evaluation shall be completed specifically identifying any
patient sensitivity or contraindications to anesthesia.
c) Ahemoglobin or hematocrit and examination of the urine
for sugar, protein, and acetone shall be performed by-a
quatfredtaberateryteehmieran prior to the following proce-
dures:
1) those performed with general anesthesia,
2) those performed with intravenous sedation,
3) those performed with spinal or epidural anesthe-
sia,
4) those performed with any other specific anesthe-
sia technique designated by the consulting commit-
tee, and
5) those performed to terminate pregnancy.
M-12
d) Prior to pr rocedures performed to terminate a pregn ae cy,
he ph 1 ian shall lish i i
r linical luati ing. In gp
ient’s bl h f; r shal rmin
e) dA written statement indicating informed consent and a
signed authorization by th« patient for the performance of
the specific surgical procedure shall be procured and made
part of the patient’s clinical record.
f) e) Surgical procedures shall not be performed on patient’s
having medical, surgical, or psychiatric conditions or com-
plications as specified by the consulting committee in the
facility's written policies.
g)# Prior to admission to the facility for a surgical procedure
the patient shall be informed of the following:
1) Patients who receive general anesthesia, intrave-
nous sedation, spina! or epidural anesthesia, or any
other specific anesthesia technique designated by
the consulting committee, must not attempt to drive
a motor vehicle immediately upon discharge from the
facility.
2) Patients must make arrangements prior to admis-
sion for safe transportation from the facility upon
discharge to return to home or to a similar environ-
ment.
(Source: Amended at 14 111. Reg. __, effective August 15.
1990)
Section 205.540 Postoperative Care
) Patients shall be observed in the facility for a period of
M-13
time sufficient to ensure that the patient is awake, physi-
ologically stable, manifests no immediate postoperative
complications, and is ready to return to home or to a similar
environment. No patient shall be required to leave the
center in less than one (1) hour following the procedures.
b) Rh factor sensitization prophylaxis shall be provided to
ll Rh n iV i wi r
terminate pregnancy, in accordan 1 idard medical
procedure.
¢) & Patients in v-hom a complication is known or suspected
to have eeenred occurred during or after the performance of
a surgical procedure, shall be informed of such condition and
arrangements made for treatment of the complication. In
the event of admission to an inpatient facility a summary of
care given in the ambulatory surgical treatment center
concerning the suspected complication shall accompany the
patient.
d) e To insure availability of follow-up care at a licensed
hospital, the ambulatory surgical treatment center shall
provide written documentation of one of the following:
1) A transfer agreement with a licensed hospital
within approximately fifteen (15) minutes travel
time of the facility.
2) A statement that the medical director of the
facility has full admitting privileges at a licensed
hospital within approximately fifteen (15) minutes
travel time and that he/she will assume responsibil-
ity for all facility patients requiring such follow-up
care.
3) Astatement that each staff physician, dentist, or
M-14
———————
podiatrist has admitting privileges in a licensed
hospital within fifteen (15) minutes travel time of the
facility.
e) # Written instructions shal! be issued to all patients in
accordance with the standards approve -d by the consulting
committee of the ambulatory surgical treatment center and
shall include the following:
1) Symptoms of complications associated with pro-
cedures performed.
2) Limitations and/or restrictions of activities of the
patient.
3) Specific telephone number to be used by the
patient at anytime should any complication or ques-
tion arise.
4) A date for follow-up or return visit after the
performance of the surgical procedure which shall be
scheduled within six weeks.
f) & Patients shall be discharged only on the written signed
order of a physician. The name, or relationship to the
patient, of the person accompanying the patient upon dis-
charge from the facility shall be noted in the patient's
medical record.
Infe ‘
shall | patier
undergoing a pregnancy ter sn ion pr racedure. When, in in
the physician's opinion, it js 1 in sts of the
ai - nd with the augers con a family planning
‘eS the discharge of the
aA
(Source: Amended at 14 IIl.Reg. , effective August
15,
1990)
SUBPART G: LIMITED
PROCEDURE SPECIALTY CENTERS
ADDHEHYTONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR FACHIFEES
EA-WHHGTL-OBSFEFRICAH/GYNEECOLOGICAL
PROCEDURES ARE PERFORMED
Section 205.710 Pregnancy Termination Specialty Centers
Abertrons |
a) A facility will be considered a pregnancy termination
specialty center if it meets each of the following conditions:
1) Procedures performed at the facility are limited to
procedures to terminate pregnancy performed within
18 weeks assessed gestational age (beginning on the
first day of the last menstrual period), and other
gynecoligic procedures related to the termination of
pregnancy. Assessed gestational age may be deter-
mined by patient history or by clinical assessment.
2) The center does not use general, epitural, or spinal
anesthesia for any of the procedures performed. If
intravenous sedation is used, mechanical ventilation
devices and intubation equipment must be available
on site.
3) The program narrative and policies of the facility
are limited to the performance of procedures to ter-
M-16
minate pregnancy and other procedures related to
the termination of pregnancy.
b) The following exceptions and modification of the require-
ments of this Part apply to pregnancy termination specialty
centers.
Pregnancy termination specialty centers shal! comply with
each of the requirements of this Part, unless specifically
excepted or modified by the provisions of this subsection.
1) The initial and renewal application need only
include the name, address, and telephone number of
all owners, administrators, and medical directors of
the center [in lieu of compliance with Section
205.120(b)(5) through (7) and Section 205.125(bX5)
through (7)]. However, the other information re-
quired in these provisions shall be maintained at the
center and be available for inspection by the Depart-
ment. The information shall include the original! or
notarized copies of credentials of all licensed or cer-
tified personnel.
2) Compliance with Section 205.540(d) is not re-
quired, if the medical director or a physician practic-
ing at the facility has a professional! working relation-
ship or agreement, maintained in writing at the
facility and verifiable by the Department, with a
physician who does have admitting or practice privi-
leges at a licensed hospital within 15 minutes from
the facility and who will assume responsibility for all
facility patients requiring such follow-up care.
3) The administrative and public areas of the facility
are not required to comply with Section 205.1350.
M-17
ata caiaieeeinai
4) A separate examination room is not required;
however, adequate space shall be provided to accom-
_ modate any equipment necessary for examination, to
perform examinations safely, and to allow
unobstructed ingress and egress to and from the
examination area {in lieu of compliance with Section
205.1360(aX1)].
5) Each room in which procedures to terminate
pregnancy are performed shall be at least 120 square
feet in size with a minimum dimension of at least 10
least. Exceptions will be made when the center
demonstrates that the room size is adequate to ac-
commodate the equipment required for the proce-
dures, to facilitate the performance of the procedures
safely, and to protect the patients and staff in the
event of fire or other emergency {in lieu of compliance
with Section 205.1360(b1)].
6) A communications system between the control
station and each procedure room is not required |in
lieu of compliance with Section 205.1360(b\2)).
7) Not less than three recovery beds or lounge chairs
shall be required for each procedure room. However,
if the facility's narrative program provides that no
more than two procedures per hour will be performed
per procedure room, then only two recovery beds or
lounger chairs will be required for each procedure
room. A minmum of three feet shall be provided
between each recovery bed or lounge chair and an
unobstructed passageway of a minimum of four feet
shall be provided at one end of each bed or chair |in
lieu of compliance with Section 205.1360(c)(2) and
(cX7)).
8) The recovery area is not required to include a
M-18
tion, or storage space for supplies and equipment | in
li fcompliance with tion 205.1 3)1. How-
ver, the facility shall provide for dir isual super-
vision of the recovery area for all patients.
9) A toilet for patient use must be in the recovery
r rinal ion which not requir ients
o enter public areas of other patient care areas in
rder in from th Vv rea. A gray
iverter valve is not requir n - ilet in th
recov f m i isposal i
provided at another location within thecenter{in lieu
f compliance with ions 205 O(c)i4) and
205.1370(f) |.
10) A control station for the operating suite is not
r ir in li f compliance with ion
205.1370(a)|.
11) A ser ion is not required outside th
r r if the pr room contains
ink with washin ilities [in lieu of com-
pliance with Section 205.1370(d)|.
12 iled wor m_is not requi
howev ilities sh los lean
r i reven n inati ’ soil
ial r stor h i soiled linen
her soi rials. Ss res shall
ribed in the center's narrative program |inli
of compliance with Section 2 70(e) an L
Anesthesia and medical gas stor facilities ar
not requir in li f compliance with ion
205.1370(h) and ()].
M-19
‘nts fo
205. 1410(dX 1) do not apply,
21) Ventilation, air change, and air filter reguire-
M-20
(Source: Section repealed, new Section adopted at 14 Il. Reg.
___, effective August 15, 1990)
Section 205.720 Personnel (Repealed)
(Source: Repealed at 14 Il. Reg. , effective August 15,
1990)
Section 205.730 General Patient Care (Repealed)
. .
’ ot a .
. c <
M-22
(Source: Repealed at 14 IIl.Reg. , effective August 15,
1990)
Section 205.740 Preoperative Requirements (Repealed)
(Source: Repealed at 14 IIl.Reg. , effective August 15,
1990)
Section 205.750 Postoperative Requirements (Repealed)
(Source: Repealed at 14 IIll.Reg.
1990)
, effective August 15,
Section 205.760 Reports (Repealed)
: ne de ; * soli cs pines a amare ie . :
report shal be -submittedtotheDepartmrent-
(Source: Repealed at 14 IIl.Reg. , effective August 15,
1990)
Section 205.1380 Diagnostic Facilities
wee me oe oa — oT — : cocaine
a) Radiographic suite, if radiography is provided in the
center, shall contain the following:
1) film processing area
2) viewing and administration area
3) film storage facilities
4) toilet room with handwashing facilities, directly
accessible from each fluoroscopy room without en-
tering the general corrider area.
5) dressing area with convenient access to toilets.
b) If laboratory testing is performed in the center which
required a permit or license under the Departments rules
Illinois Clini ratori 77 Ill Adm.Code 4
he labor f the center baberatery-sutte shall
contain the following minimum facilities:
1) Laboratory work counter with sink and vacuum,
and electric services.
M-25
2) Lavatory or counter sink equipped for handwash-
ing.
3) Storage cabinet or closet for any necessary labora-
tory supplies and equipment. This storage area may
be combined with other storage areas in the center.
b-Seee; Heetienfaeiits ; 1 wit]
tortetandtiavatery-
4) 5 Blood collection facilities shall have space fora
chair and work counter.
(Source: Amended at 14 Ill. Reg. , effective August 15,
1990)
M-26
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.